CorpusRecord 64324

SSCSD BOE Meet the Candidates 5/4/2022

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SSCSD YouTube
Date
2022-05-05
Location
Saratoga County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,528 words · about 76 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay i'm going to have each one of  you try your mics before we start   john you want to try your mic hello everybody billy hello martha welcome dean hello try that again dean i want  to make sure we hear you hello oh that's we hear   you loud oh pretty loud yeah how about that is  that better you want mine again yeah good good   too yep natalia hello can you hear me yeah just  a little bit louder maybe a little bit louder   yeah is that better yeah  is that good okay all right good evening everyone and welcome to the meet the  candidates event for the city of saratoga spring   school board election all candidates on the ballot  were invited this event was organized by the lee   the saratoga springs school district and moderated  by the league

002of women voters of saratoga county   it will be recorded and posted on the school  district website league rules require that   if a meet the candidates event is recorded it  must be broadcast or rebroadcast in its entirety   my name is kathy kobrik i am a member of the  league of women voters of saratoga county   i live in the town of malta and  i will be your moderator tonight   the league of women voters of saratoga county is  a non-partisan volunteer political organization   dedicated to the informed and responsible  participation of citizens in government the league never supports or opposes any  political party or candidate that has been   league policy since 1920. membership is open  to anyone who is eligible to register and vote   so please consider joining your local league we  have received questions from the public in

003advance   these were reviewed by league members and  questions were selected to be representative   and to avoid redundancy questions of  a personal nature are never included   candidates this is your opportunity to let voters  know your stance on these topics and how you will   address the issues facing the saratoga spring  schools please do not waste time valuable time   tearing down or labeling your opponent deal with  the facts and in your closing statement don't put   anybody on the spot by saying something that other  people won't have an opportunity to respond to   we have timers for this evening's event cards will  be held up for the candidates to glance at green   means one minute left they're going to show you  right there yellow means 30 seconds left and red   means your time is up a bell will also ring

004when  time is up and it turns out that i have a handy   little mute button too so instead of um banging on  the gavel i might just mute you so please respect   the time we have a lot of questions to get to  and we want everybody to have a fair chance   um for those of you in the audience we have pretty  strict rules about recording this event it can   only be recorded by the school district and like  we said it can only be shown in its entirety so if   i see anybody recording i will stop and we'll  wait for you to put your camera or whatever   recording equipment you have away okay so  i'm counting on you all to follow our rules   we've had a problem in the past where  candidates or some of their

005followers have used   snippets against each other and that makes  it it's not fair because then people don't   want to participate in our debates so  thank you for your help with that okay the six candidates for three open school board  seats in alphabetical order are john breugerman   martha devaney you can raise your hand if you  like dean colligan natalia loctakia billy mccann   and edwin spickler now it's time to hear their two  minute opening statements they have drawn lots to   determine the order and i want you all to remember  you've got to push your button before you start   talking and then when you're done push it again  so the first to speak is going to be john breugman   okay john you're on hi everyone i'm really glad  to be here to join in a productive conversation   with

006my fellow candidates i want to thank  you all for being here i want to thank the   league of women voters i like how you all  do things and i'm thank my neighbors who   came here tonight and everybody who's watching at  home i've been a teacher for 30 years my wife's   a pediatrician we have three kids who have  been in saratoga schools since kindergarten   and they've had a really good experience we think  there are a lot of ways that our schools can be   improved and i'm mindful that not every family has  had the same positive experiences that we've had   the most important challenge in our district in  in my opinion is socio-emotional well-being our   schools should always be ambitious about  reading writing arithmetic challenging   students to learn as much as they possibly  can but it's hard

007for students to learn   when they're struggling with mental health issues  anxiety isolation addiction or special needs   the various issues related to social emotional  well-being were challenging before the pandemic   and have only gotten worse the key to it is good  governance that requires board members who know   what the job of the board is and what it is not it  also means studying best practices and making sure   we have good processes in place when you have good  processes you're gathering input from everyone who   cares getting the best evidence possible listening  to experts and following sound procedures if we do   well on any given topic with good process we've  got the best chance of taking productive action   during my first term i have worked with a bunch of  school board members from across the pool spectrum   who cared

008about governance and sound  procedures and were there for the right reason   it has been an honor and a privilege to know  them and to work with them and i would love   the chance to serve again okay thank you  very much john uh billy it's your turn okay   thank you to the league for hosting this  forum tonight i appreciate the opportunity   my name is billy mccann my husband and i have twin  sons that attend caroline street elementary school   next year they will be at meeple ave i'm actively  involved in the school community as part of the   pta i have served as classroom parent for years  as well as on the building leadership committee   i've been a pediatric ot for over 20 years and  a certified life coach for the last four years   i have a passion

009for supporting children to learn  and to prosper to the best of their ability i have   experience working in public and private schools  i've also held a contract with saratoga county   early intervention for years i most recently  owned and operated a small private practice called   healing in motion where i provided life coaching  and reiki healing to parents and children with and   without disabilities i'm motivated to serve our  community in the school district to the best of my   ability student safety mental health and quality  education will be my priority you can trust that   if i'm elected i will work diligently to bring  curriculum and policy transparency forward   to foster communication channels between  the school district and stakeholders   i feel that my professional experience paired  with my compassion communication skills ability   to think independently be open-minded and  work

010collaboratively would serve me well   as a board member thank you okay thank you  billy next to speak will be martha devaney thank you do you remember your first day of  kindergarten i do and i do because that day   was so much fun and as i run for school board i  recognize my belief and in the ideal that school   should be fun and it should be welcoming for every  student i am running for school board because   schools are the cornerstone of our community  having spent my adult life building this community   i'm investing and serving our schools and our  students for them to be the best that they can be   i began my career in community mental  health where i developed the gestalt   outlook which is the ability to look at the big  picture in finding solutions

011i live in wilton   and both my children graduated from the saratoga  schools i have worked in education for 20 years   10 years in administration and 10 years in the  classroom teaching business and marketing i now   work as a director of finance for a not-for-profit  healthcare organization that serves people with   disabilities as a finance director i manage  budgets i do grant writing i was also a small   business owner that managed budgets and finances  and organizations hired me to solve their problems   i've served in volunteer boards including  saratoga arts fest and wilton wildlife preserve   i stand for building strong  holistic and welcoming schools   which in turn builds the same in our students i'm  running for school board to add my voice and yours   i stand for focus putting students first my  priority safety and wellness i support

012diversity   equity and inclusion and i'm here interested  as a candidate to build community as a builder   i promise to listen to your input and serve as  a team builder as a trustee on the school board   thank you thank you martha next  is dean colligan good evening   as kathy mentioned my name is dean colligan my  wife aaron and i are the proud parents of four   children madison who's 20 peyton who's  17. catherine is 14 and carson is 11.   our oldest is a graduate of saratoga springs high  school and a sophomore currently at siena college   the other three attend the high school the middle  school and dorothy nolan i'm currently the vice   president at the at one of the vice presidents at  the adirondack trust company in charge of security   and facility operations of that organization  my

013primary responsibilities on a daily basis   include facility management and the oversight  of 14 branch locations and 20 total buildings   on a day-to-day basis i'm tasked with the physical  security of each of these locations which includes   hundreds of employees and thousands of customers  that enter these facilities on any given day   additionally i'm responsible for our emergency  action plan and our crisis management plan   aaron and i are also partners in a  family business in the town of wilton   we own and operate a commercial office park that  houses 14 different tenants in nine buildings   we manage approximately a hundred thousand  square feet of professional office space some   of which is utilized by educational businesses  i'd like to take this opportunity this evening   to talk with you all about why i'm running for  re-election and a seat at the

014board of education   as i discussed three years ago for the  first time i'm looking to make a difference   as i previously mentioned i'm the father of four  amazing children three of which attend three   different schools here and in the district my wife  erin has been a coach here for nearly 15 years   with the girls varsity lacrosse program  she's also a third generation alum   our family has a lot invested in the educational  system and i would be proud to continue to be   a small part of the group tasked with overseeing  this process i'd like to continue to utilize this   form this evening as an opportunity to discuss all  of the concerns that i along with many others may   have when it comes to share to share when it comes  to the educational system of the saratoga

015spring   city school district those are educational quality  health safety and security including mental health   and long range facility planning and  infrastructure monitoring i would also   like to take the opportunity to continue to  work with teachers oh thank you thank you next ed spickler thank you to the league  of women voters for this opportunity   and thank you all out there who are listening my  name is ed spickler and some of you have come to   know me as coach ed a native of mechanicville  i moved to saratoga springs with my wife karen   and our newborn son because we thought it  would be a great place to raise our family   for the next fall our boys will enter sixth and  ninth grade in the district for the past eight   years i've coached three different youth sports  leagues and

016i'm also a co-founder of the saratoga   nfl flag football league i'm running for the  board of education as i've come to know many   of the students in our community and i want them  to receive the best education we can give them   i've i i'm running prior to excuse me it's my  first time doing this so i'm a little frazzled   but anyway prior to becoming coach ed i worked at  various large financial service firms state street   corporation prudential financial to name a couple  i served in the treasury department of those firms   and i oversaw very diverse groups of clients and  worked with and managed very diverse individuals   currently in service with treasurer  of my hoa for the past 12 years   providing treasury financial oversight is my  strong point also working with various clients   in servicing their

017needs and acting as a liaison i truly learned the value of collaborating in a  team in resolving complex issues and communicating   effectively with various stakeholders i'm  much better in a one-on-one or fewer person   situation than sitting up here on a panel  for the first time in a long time i will not i'm running on a platform that's very simple  i think that we need to continue to have   programs for special needs and i think we also  need to continue to focus on public safety   as well as complete financial transparency  one thing i will not do is i will not call   for the banning of books as i believe in free  speech but i also support a parent's right   to choose what books in media are appropriate  for their child if you hear a negative opinion  

018of me thank you please ask yourself okay  thank you okay um natalia it's your turn   hi i am natalia latakia i have lived in saratoga  springs with my husband and now kindergartner   since 2016. as a special educator i have  dedicated my career to working with students of   um with students of all ages in the public  education system i am passionate about my   job and work hard to meet the needs of each of  my students making sure that they have a safe   loving and healthy educational environment i want  that for every student in every district and i   bring that commitment to my service on the board  especially in my role as policy committee chair   in my family education is everything it is what  led my parents to come to the united states   after i completed my

019master's in speech-language  pathology i followed their lead into the role   of educator i am a community builder i cook and  serve food through saratoga stronger and code blue   i volunteered at almost every covet  19 vaccination clinic in our district   and many test kit distribution events in our city  i am a helper and i love saying yes to as many   volunteer opportunities as i can i teach my son  and my students to always be kind and respectful   and i work to embody these principles myself i  have spent my time on the school board conducting   myself collegially respectfully collaboratively  and with integrity i am a firm believer that   the only way forward is together i am a friend  of organized labor and a champion for justice   education has been a lifelong passion for me i  work hard

020on my professional development classes   the many courses i have taken on effective  board leadership and policy making   my weekly voice lessons and educating  myself about the world around me   i am a person who asks questions and seeks truths  thank you to the league of women voters for having   this forum for those joining tonight i hope  to earn your vote thank you okay thank you all   now it's going to be time for questions  candidates will have up to one and a half   minutes to respond to a question you are not  required to respond you may pass if you wish   each candidate will be afforded two opportunities  to request an additional minute during the   question session for a rebuttal or to expand  an answer and someone has already asked if   they could hold up their card right

021away so you  know they're going to add a minute please hold   up your red card and wait to be acknowledged by me  before you begin your extra minute we want to make   sure you get all the time you can this may only  be done during the question session and it may   not be used for closing statements questions  will be directed to candidates in rotation   so that everyone gets a chance to respond  first so we're going to start with john again   then next time billy you'll be first okay  what is your vision for the school district   in 10 years are there any issues  that should be dealt with proactively thank you i think it's a great question i think the uh right now we have some pretty  serious problems brewing and i hope that within 10  

022years we can um resolve those problems and move on  to some improvements i think we are facing a um a   very grave situation relative to the shortage  of certain positions especially teachers   also this is true for nursing it's true for for  bus drivers and there's some other positions the   um the solutions at that level need to be systemic  they need to involve probably the state and other   districts but we also have to do everything  in our district to try to help with that and i   the in terms of moving forward i hope we can  really get a handle on the socio-emotional stuff   that's part of a national pattern and it's it's  difficult here and i think our district devotes   more resources to that cluster of issues than most  and we're still not where we need

023to be so we need   to add resources there and we need to continue to  try to add value for every single student bring   the best out of every single student in in the  district okay thank you john billy it's your turn   i sure can any you can all ask any time for me  to repeat the question what is your vision for   the school district in 10 years are there any  issues that should be dealt with proactively   um the school district mission is to empower  learners in engaging collaborative environments   to find their personal pathway in the future  rooted in equity opportunity collaboration   community and personalization i feel like our  vision is impeded by some of the more concerning   issues pressing issues that are facing our school  district today and at the forefront of that for me  

024is safety and mental health the  pandemic left our our world in fact   and left a lasting impact on student mental  and emotional and social well-being and we're   seeing the adverse impact of that in the  form of increased violence vaping and abuse   if elected i would advocate for a multi-tiered  approach to supporting this concern in the school   i would promote the use of assemblies to teaching  anti-bullying empathy and conflict resolution   to promote our safer school helpline rely  on school counselors ask stakeholders for   informed input and ideas increase the number and  diversity of our floor monitors and in consider   the impact of student schedules and downtime at  home i would encourage that we work with parents   not only to make them aware of problem behaviors  but of solutions and resources available   that would support them i would

025reach out to our  community and rely on the vast community resources   that are available to our school district  to create relationships and programs that   would foster support of our students and i would  encourage the review of the effectiveness of our   restorative justice practice when persons violate  code of conduct they need to be held accountable   accountability may come in the shape or form of  community service detention letters of apology   attendance or conflict resolution classes etc so  my vision for the school district would focus on   the pertinent issues that are at hand today namely  health and safety transparency of curriculum and   policy as well as improving communication channels  between stakeholders and our administrative   staff 10 years is a long time i think that it's  important that we refocus our efforts on academics   and excellence in academics and

026merocracy thank  you okay thank you very much if you notice she   held up her red card and she got a minute extra  so thank you okay martha it's your turn thank you   and looking forward ten years i can um as i  sit here i think back who would have thought   10 years ago what the past two years would have  been like so with that perspective um what and   knowing what we know now i um would like to see a  fully implemented policy for the diversity equity   and inclusion i would like to see the mindful  attention continued to be paid on the pathways and   the pillars of the mission of the school district  so that essentially is to do an assessment of   the things that we're planning today to implement  and to see that they are

027successfully implemented along with the implementation of the diversity  equity inclusion i'd like to see a mentoring   program that would engage students and to have  some peer-to-peer activity and the school level   i'd like to look at ways we could recruit  staff to address some of the retirement issues   and i'd like to see investment in social workers  and psychologists so that we can support our   every student and continue the upward positive  data and outcomes that we see here currently in   the school thank you okay thank you very much  dean it's your turn thank you um vision for our   district in 10 years from now needs to you know  continue to focus on quality education that should   be first and foremost this happens by having a  firm understanding of what are the current areas   of need this happens

028by obtaining information  through conversations with our current teachers   and our current students our vision today may not  be the same as it is in five or ten years from now   as martha just mentioned covid certainly threw  us all for a loop over the last few years   who would have thought three years ago that  mental health and safety of our students   would be a primary focus of just about  everybody today mental health is important   but i think it has risen  to the surface to make sure   that we truly have a firm understanding of exactly  what mental health means to each and every student you know our focus needs to be on adaptability and  flexibility as well as we navigate over the course   of the next few years as i just mentioned with  kovid we all had

029to take a step back and reassess   what the needs of the students were at that point  in time quality education mental health and safety   should always be at the forefront of what our  vision is but we also need to maintain our   adaptability and our flexibility  moving forward okay thank you dean ed   in 10 years i would like to see saratoga springs  in the school be a place where we have to actually   turn teachers away because our positions are all  filled and we have excellent teachers i would   like to see that we have to have an overflow  of students because the students want to come   here and they want to come here to learn that's my  vision for the school how do we get there i think   i would like to see for safety purposes to

030have  intervention and prevention programs and to help   those youths that are at risk have counseling  and treatment programs also for special needs   learners i would like to see them have a mentor  or a dean someone that they could go to for their   entire duration that they're here k through  12 5th through 12 so that they have one person   who is their mentor and is advocating for them  thank you okay thank you very much ed uh natalia um i think that my goal or my vision for 10 years  from now is for us to be truly preparing students   for life i think that students should be coming  to our schools to learn the necessary and complex   knowledge that they need to engage with those  around them with their communities and in society   students should be learning

031about  themselves their strengths and how to use   those to work collaboratively with others  their weaknesses and how to learn from others   and their responsibilities and how those  intersect with the responsibilities of others   students should be coming to our schools  to learn how to think critically about   the world and how to engage within it to work  towards a more equitable society for everyone   and schools as the foundation for democracy  should be preparing our students to   participate effectively within an informed  and involved way and finally i think that um   we should move a little bit away from such  a focus so young on sitting at a table and   learning and instead be working more on fostering  creativity in our youngest learners i think that   this isn't particularly a saratoga springs thing  rather a nationwide thing that we're

032seeing where   we're really asking our students to sit at their  tables and do academics from such a young age when   what we need for what we need to do is to really  foster the innate sense of secure of excuse me of   curiosity we're moving on to the second question  and billy you're going to get to answer it first   what do you see as the goals of public education  and how do you understand the role of the board   of education in that and its limits okay i  think that the goal of public education is to teach core academics to empower our students  to learn in a collaborative and equitable   environment to teach them functional  life skills that will serve them well   in their future and i think that um what  was the second half of that

033question how do   you understand the role of the board  of education in that and its limits   um this has been a hot topic of conversation at  board meetings um recently and to be honest before   i decided to run firstly on the board i researched  what my role and responsibility would be   i understand it that a board provides oversight  and not and is not administrative in nature   it provides oversight of budget policy and  curriculum while adhering to state ed guidelines   we hire and evaluate the superintendent and adopt  collective bargaining agreements that work in   favor for teachers and cse unions and finally we  serve as a communication channel for stakeholders   while balancing the school needs with what the  community wants for the best outcome of everyone   if i'm lucky enough to be elected i  will bring forward

034my experience of 20   years working with children parents school  districts and my understanding of development   childhood development and life coaching  skills okay thank you billy next martha   could you repeat the question sure what do you  see as the goals of public education and how   do you understand the role of the board of  education in that and its limits thank you i see the goal of public education to be  a resource for every student and to be   as i've described that cornerstone  of our community for to reflect   the values of our community i see the goal of  public education is being very student centered   to recognize the unique capabilities of every  student and provide a very inclusive environment   where students are empowered and that they have  the opportunity to develop and grow holistically   i think the

035overall goal like billy i also  read the parameters on that i believe it's to   be an integral part in moving forward  the mission of the district to function   collectively and to implement the policies that  are approved by the board um i think also the uh   role of the board is to be in compliance with  new york state education department of education   while representing the interest of the district  community thank you okay thank you martha dean   thank you so uh as the goal of public  education and then the role of the board   education is the focus of public education  not only for today but for life as well   i think one of the focuses that we need to  have is to dig deep right dig deep and learn   as much as we can about each and

036every student  that we have that walks through our buildings   let's focus on strengths and weaknesses let's  provide those students with the tools that they   need to be successful in life not every student's  going to go to college not every student's going   to go right into the workplace we have students  that will sit back and try to find where their   path is going to be we have students that will go  and they'll sign up for the military at the age of   18 which is a phenomenal decision that people make  it enables us to have you know the ability to sit   here today in front of you all and and discuss  exactly what education in a public setting is   supporting those life skills and those tools  that students can utilize for the rest of their   lives will

037be the most important thing i think  that we should focus on in public education and   simply as a role of the board i think we're here  to support those folks support the teachers to   make sure that they have the tools to teach those  students the ability for the rest of their lives okay thank you dean ed it's your turn the goals  of public education the way that i see it is to   make sure that every child is striving or can meet  or exceed the state's standard curriculum with a   focus on reading comprehension writing in stem  also to encourage and develop critical thinking   skills also to teach individual responsibility  accountability and how to be good citizens and   community members lastly it should prepare the  student with life skills for post graduation   either college skill or trade

038schools or directly  into the workforce but they should be prepared to   walk out these doors the role of the board of  education should be to communicate those goals   to the public effectively we should provide  policies and curriculum to achieve those goals   and we should create a budget that provides  for those goals okay thank you ed natalia i think that the goal of public  education is to prepare students for life   the board of education sets the direction of  the district through a shared vision for future   of for the future of education and the students we  provide accountability and oversight we adopt and   maintain policies oversee the budget and evaluate  the superintendent each year in the case that the   superintendent leaves the district we are also  responsible for hiring a new superintendent we are   not at involved

039at all in day-to-day operations  of the district nor are we responsible for the   translation of policy into action even though we  are responsible for the policies themselves we are   not district employees we are a governance board  and i think that it is our role to support the   district in preparing students for life all right  thank you very much john i like what i'm hearing   i think uh a lot of smart words have been  said um i agree with the points have been   made about what public education is this is  about helping young people develop life skills   academic achievement find their way in the world  become more self-realized develop psychologically   and appropriate ways we owe this to every uh  young person in our district that's and and our   institution as a district should be a partner

040with  other institutions to help uh the community um   help move these help children move forward  the board we've also heard a good definition   of what the board is i just want to emphasize  that the board has to be a functioning team   and that's something i've always been committed to  good governance good processes i've helped people   with whom i disagree craft motions so that they  could have their voices heard and i think that   the board always has to be collaborative when  we're not working together as nine people we are   not fulfilling the mission of the district and we  can disagree on this or that issue and we should   we should have lots of different voices but we  have to be able to work collaboratively i also   think that the board does have to be a conduit

041for  communication i have pushed the administration to   keep enhancing our communication systems i don't  think they're as strong as they should be one of   the things where the district is working on now is  to um review and redo the website which i think is   long overdue and that's going to help a lot but  i think the board has to play an integral role to   working on those communication systems as well  okay thank you john okay the third question   martha you're going to be the first to answer this  one in your opinion what does diversity equity   and inclusion mean and look like to you  in a public school setting how do you   see yourself contributing to the district's  commitment to equity inclusivity and diversity thank you that's a topic that i've mentioned  twice already um and

042i'm um thrilled to be   aware that uh the diversity equity and inclusion  policy has been approved at the board level and   that will be undergoing implementation i'll skip a  little bit ahead to say where and how i see myself   involved in that is if i'm fortunate enough to be  elected i would like to participate in one of the   subcommittees to oversee its implementation in my  current position i do lots of program development   and i've done a lot of strategic planning in my  career and looking at implementation measuring   progress measuring results is a critical aspect  of what i believe we need to do to measure its   effectiveness what diversity equity and inclusion  means to me is an opportunity for everyone to feel   that they are part of this community as people  that currently live in our

043community and people   that hopefully will join our community on the  equity is that they get the resources that are   particularly student-centered and tailored to  what is available for them and the inclusion is   is that they have that environment where they feel  that they are an integral part of this entity and   that ultimately uh that this is a community that  embraces everyone and everyone succeeds thank you dean thank you i'd like to start off with respect  to what does diversity equity and inclusion look   like in a school district and what what does it  mean to me i think the focus for all of us it's   a very hot topic within the community it's a  hot topic across the country i think that each   one of us benefits from the opportunity to take  a step back and

044learn as much as we can about   exactly what diversity equity and inclusion  mean i can speak about it on behalf of of   different boards that i've been a part of or  experiences that i've had and i think as john   mentioned earlier when it comes to sitting at  a board table with 800 other individuals these   are one of those topics that we can learn the  most from diversity is important to allow us to   have differing opinions from individuals that  sit at that table not having nine like-minded   individuals is something that's beneficial right  the same in a student setting all students within   a classroom if they have a diverse mindset if they  come from diverse backgrounds they'll provide that   teacher and the other students in the classroom  the ability to learn from their diverse thoughts   the equity

045component of this means that we try to  have the we give the ability for all students to   have their voices heard in those classrooms when  we're talking about diversity making sure that   everybody understands the thought process that  people have when they're discussing a topic of   conversation whether it's in a history classroom  an english classroom or an elective classroom   inclusion is very important this is something  that's been done for a long time within our   district when we talk about students with sp thank  you team you want to use your red card that's okay   okay thank you okay ed it's your turn you want  me to repeat the question yeah in your opinion   what does diversity equity and inclusion mean  and look like to you in a public school setting   how do you see yourself contributing to

046the  district's commitment to equity inclusivity   and diversity well the way that i see it is the  way that i kind of grew up uh homogeneous town   in mechanicville went to northeastern university  and met kids from all over the world and we all   came together working together for a common goal  that was our education and we worked in different   groups and then i went off to big companies and  the same thing we put aside our differences and   we got to work and then we learned about each  other everyone brought the best from their world   into the work setting and gave their best and  that's how i see it in the school system i think   that's what we need to do we need to come together  in a common goal and work towards that common goal   and

047bring the best of our world and meld them  together okay thank you ed natalia i was proud   to be part of the committee that crafted  our district's dei policy and regulation i   want each and every one of the 6 300 students in  our district to be welcomed and affirmed in our   schools to have their needs met to support them  and growing their strengths and learning from   others i want us to celebrate our differences for  me equity is when each and every student is served   i've spent my career working in special education  and i think of educational equity in terms of   special education special education isn't about  what students benefit from dei isn't about what   students benefit from it's about meeting their  needs so they can meet their full potential   it is why when a student

048can't see we  get them a pair of glasses we don't get   every single student in the class a pair of  glasses it's when a student can't hear they   get a hearing aid it's when students  need speech they get to come see me   even though every single student in my school  would benefit from leaving their classroom to   be in a small group setting for a short amount  of time thank you okay thank you very much john i think this is such an important  topic and i i want to just   offer my full throated support for our district's  efforts in terms of diversity equity inclusion   i think the the topic that has been most  difficult in our discourse is equity   and i think you know the standards don't change  but the idea of equity is that different

049kids have   different needs it's in our mission statement and  every child needs the support and opportunities   to get what they need to fulfill their to grow to  add value let me say something about what equity   is not nobody thinks white babies are born racist  nobody here thinks that there is no critical race   theory here that's not part of district goals it  never has been and there's been a lot of chatter   about that but it's just not on topic there are  racial disparities there are class disparities   and i'm really proud that our board unanimously  supported a new policy that highlights diversity   equity inclusion i helped co-author a resolution  a couple years ago that also supported dei work   a couple of things that we do that are  important we look at every student's exact   data related to

050the every student succeeds  act every year and what we see is there are   different populations that have larger gaps and  every year we're thinking about what are the   actions we can take to close those gaps we also  we also have um lots of different programs um   that are part of equity in a more expansive  sense it's part of the socio-emotional work   it's part of making sure that people have the  the the wi-fi or devices they need at home to   participate in their education it's part of  making sure all students have healthy access   to healthy food you can't learn if you're hungry  it's trying to reduce all the fees that we have   across the district the psat is now free for all  students that's a huge jump forward for equity   you can sign up for ap

051classes if you  have if you have the motivation no matter   where you were before it started it's part of  our um our partnership with best buddies our   award-winning unifi unified sports program snack  pack toga toiletries project lift it's reducing   the fees for arts theater and sports and all those  things equity has to be a part of what we're doing   every single day and not just the stuff we're  talking about when we're having these volatile   conversations that's important and i fully  supported but if we think about equity more   broadly it should be woven into everything  we do in the district thank you okay um wait sorry billy it's your turn thank you  got lost over here with the red cards   i'm a proponent of diverse equitable and  inclusive cultures i think in order for our   school

052district's dei efforts to be successful  dei needs to begin at the top with our very own   dei committee which is not diverse equitable  or inclusive i have concerns regarding the lack   of information on policy and regulation and  implementation strategies of our dei policy   it's my understanding that other school districts  in the capital region are doing a much better job   of providing this transparency using an app called  parent square additionally i would like to see dei   initiatives focused on providing more resources to  the economically disadvantaged students that make   up the largest marginalized group at 25 percent  of our student population as well as the second   largest marginalized group of disabled students i  also want to comment that our dei policy supports   culturally responsive sustaining education which  emerged from the works of gloria ladson billings   who is

053a critical race theorist who  introduced critical race theory to education   culturally responsive sustaining  education and critical race theory   goals are the same i want all children to  succeed regardless of race ability gender   and or socioeconomic status i believe that dei can  be a successful tool tool to support this endeavor   i also feel that the current modalities in media  being used under the current dei umbrella requires   analysis and feedback from our stakeholders okay  thank you billy uh dean you're going to answer   this question first the fourth one has there been  a change in the level of violence in the schools   what is the board's role in ensuring  the safety of students at school thanks kathy i'm sorry i was  just writing a couple notes down   so do i feel like there's been a change in  the

054level of violence within our schools the answer is yes and no the answer is  yes because social media unfortunately   you know magnifies any type of violence whether  it occurs within a school or whether it occurs   in society i think the types of violence that  are occurring within the schools probably have   changed over the years 30 years ago when i was in  school i think we talked about going outside by   the monument if somebody wanted to fight with  somebody today it happens much differently it   happens all based on social media there's no uh  there's no build up to whatever may occur out   by the monument 30 years ago that violence occurs  directly within the hallways with everybody's cell   phone out looking to capture whatever they can  capture and immediately it's put on social media   i think

055the board's role in the violence within  the school system is to make sure that we're   supporting our teachers and administrators is  really what it comes down to making sure that they   have the tools in place to um i'll go ahead and  use this now even though i have 30 seconds left   to make sure that this the teachers and the  administrators have the tools that they need   to make sure that the disciplinary actions that  should be taken upon students who commit violent   acts of behavior within the schools are taken care  of violence along with violence i think um is you   know we're finding more and more students that  are just they're misbehaving they're mistreating   other people they're not respecting the adults  within the school district whether it's teachers   staff members hall monitors uh janitors whatever  it

056may be uh the level of disrespect that we're   seeing in schools in the community it's growing  day by day and again i think a lot of this is   fueled by social media for those of you that  know me know that i have nothing to do with   social media and that's probably why i harp  a lot a lot on this going back to the roles   and responsibilities from a board member you know  one of our biggest responsibilities is the budget   and when this disrespectful behavior or  potentially violent acts of behavior occur within   the school that may damage property or require  additional resources if it impacts the budget   then it does impact what what the responsibilities  of the board members are i think it's our goal   to continue to serve as board members to act as  partners

057with our administrators and our teachers   within the school district to make sure that  we're providing the support that our students   need so that these violent and disrespectful  behaviors start to discontinue okay thank you ed i would agree with a lot of what dean had  to say but also i'd go a little bit further to   say that i mean we kids came back and they came  back to a world that's not entirely what they   left and i think it put a lot of stress on them  and then some of the policies and some of the   other things within the school have changed  and that's put another level of stress on them   i don't know if anyone took the time or has talked  to the kids and have found out if how they're   feeling i would like

058to hear from the kids i think  that's one thing that we don't do enough of is we   listen to the kids why can't we have some focus  groups why can't we get conversations with the   kids and find out what they're stressed about and  what we need to address as adults to help them out   thank you okay thank you natalia um we heard about  this topic in depth at the last board meeting from   our superintendent i think that our students are  seeing division and discord when they see adults   interacting as well on social media and in real  life our students are speaking loudly at committee   meetings as well as at board meetings about racism  homophobia other sorts of things that are really   impacting their day-to-day lives as in addition to  the pandemic we know our students

059are struggling   and we know adults are as well to me the only  path forward is together we need to work together   collaboratively and collegially to support  the administration the teachers and the staff   the people who are working day to day with our  students who are here in the schools with them   every day and like we heard from our  superintendent at the last meeting   we need our parents to be joining in in that work  with the administration the teachers and the staff   we need to be working together as a community  because a community that works well together   will do well by its students thank  you okay thank you natalia john i think uh any single act of violence in our  schools is is too many and um that's that's always   true and anybody who's involved in

060violence needs  to be held accountable in appropriate ways but   i also want to cite the superintendent's comments  and presentation at the last meeting which was   very instructive and what it showed is that there  has been no pattern of increasing violence in our   schools we see presentations each year we've  been watching it year to year and this has been   the case we are seeing as many districts  are an increase in disrespectful behavior   lots of frustration lots of anxiety this was true  the before the pandemic and it's gotten worse with   the pandemic i think the the board's role is to  partner with everybody in the district who has   a role in this certainly the sros the grounds  monitors health services psychologists social   workers and our other community partners this is  this is a a multi-dimensional set of

061issues it's   not one problem and i want to also echo the  point that social media is mostly a disaster   there is just so much misunderstanding  and misinformation sewn on social media   that is almost never helpful or and barely  related to what's going on in the district and   it would be great when we're when we're talking  about bullying among our students to try to get   parents to to work in a different direction  than bullying or trying to call people out or   or posting things anonymously which which  to me is really a telling kind of situation   that shows you're not interested what's going  on in the district thank you john okay billy   sure could you please repeat the question thanks  has there been a change in the level of violence   in the schools what is the board's

062role in  ensuring the safety of students at school   so um i think i jumped the gun and answered this  question preemptively but it's very important   to me to get my platform out there i do feel that  there is increased violence in our school despite   what the vadar report or any other report  has shown maybe not violence in the form of   physical altercations but just violence in the  general sense of what violence means disrespect   destruction of school property bullying that's  all violence in my opinion so i think that it   has increased and i think that it's a big problem  i think that it is a multi-tier approach i think   we there's lots that we can do in school we've  been hearing from our students about the need   for more assemblies and anti-bullying and empathy  and conflict

063resolution classes um i think we need   to improve the communication between the district  and our parents the lack of communication instills   doubt in us it makes us suspicious that we're  not in the loop that things are happening in   the school that aren't being communicated to  us so i think we have to increase and improve   communication i think we have to reach out  to our stakeholders we need to speak to the   sros the floor monitors and the ground monitors  they're the ones that deal with it every single   day they have the most inside information  and can offer lots of informed opinions and   and supports on how we can best remedy this along  with our students okay thank you billy martha   thank you i think we can all agree that  any level of violence is too much

064violence   and also that believing in data i from  what i understand there has not been an   increase in school violence there may be an  increased awareness due to such variables as   social media social media will get the word out  instantly and it can also serve to fuel any of   any of the things that are going on um that  way um i am a finance person as you know   i'm also very data driven and i think the data  does suggest that violence is not increasing   and i'm also very solutions oriented the u.s  department of education suggests that the solution   to this is that we invest more in  counseling and mental health services   that will address the violence in our school  it will provide a supportive environment   and be a solution to this topic okay  we're moving

065on to our fifth question   ed you're going to get to answer first what are  your spending priorities in the district budget   do you think the proposed 2.7 percent  tax living increase is warranted that's a very good question and i wish the budget  was a little more detailed so we could see where   certain things are being spent when you talk in  terms of budget codes and things rolling up into   big old budget codes and into curriculum it's very  hard to look through and find the detail as to   what curriculum and program we're talking about  i think that there should be more spending and   not cuts to programs for the arts for instance  music where kids who are most at risk can find   their level of self-confidence i also think that  you know addressing the special needs

066learners   that we need to keep them in classes with their  peers and be able to give them the services   to bring them to a level playing field  so they can learn along with their peers   instead of on their own are being sent to  services outside the district thank you okay   natalia would you repeat please sure what are  your spending priorities in the district budget   do you think the proposed 2.7 percent  tax levy increase is warranted um so every year what we see is that we are   forced to make cuts because the cost of  increasing our programs or the cost that our   programs just automatically increase each year  is more than our tax levy it's more than the   amount of money that we bring in um and so i do  think that the tax levy is

067appropriate that said   my priorities are really increasing programs  that are focused on our students this year i   strongly supported um moving from having  co-teaching just at kindergarten in first   grade to also having a second and third grade to  me co-teaching is better for our students it's   better for our teachers as well i also have been a  strong advocate for preserving our music programs   and that would extend to art and movement as well  i think that those things are not just essential   to our students they're also essential to our  culture when we have a strong music program when   we have a strong arts program and when we have  strong movement or pe and our athletics programs   i think that that makes school into more than  just being about sitting at a desk and learning   it really

068becomes more focused on preparing our  students for life and to be human beings in a   culture in a society and those are two things that  are essential to me making our school environment   better for our students better for our workers  and then really preparing our students for um the   richness of life not just focusing solely on a few  areas of academics thank you okay thank you john   um this this is complicated you know the budget is  super complicated and uh i feel humble about it i   i joined the uh the finance committee to try to  help but also so i could learn i've participated   in 14 training events as a board member to try to  learn about a range of things including the budget   a lot of it is guided by state parameters the tax 

069levy that we are able to implement is is shaped by   a very complicated equation guided by state law  i think it's appropriate what we've been doing   the vast majority of our budget's money is  in people which is where it should be i think   the most important thing that happens in our  district is the learning relationship between   teachers and students and we should always be  protecting that and we have enough we have to   have enough people to make sure we're delivering  uh our curriculum and trying to get everybody   moving forward one of the things i've tried to  do on the board is to get the administration to   present budget information to the board earlier so  could we we could understand difficult trade-offs   so that we could see the trade-offs and  consider alternatives for getting to our

070goals   there natalya outlined why there are difficult  decisions to make and they are every single year   and i i think we do want to try to do a better  job of communicating with different stakeholders   including parents families and others in the  community and the board needs to have a chance to   work through the diff difficult decisions before  time runs out and we got to pull the trigger   okay thank you billy i think it would be  helpful for the district to utilize an academic   return on investment data informed decision  making progress process in order to be   reflective of effective and ineffective district  practices so that we're better aware as to which   programs have the greatest impact on our students  success it will also be important for us going   forward to review any programs that have been 

071created using federal funding that will expire   i as if i'm lucky enough to be elected  as a board trustee i will rely heavily   on the expertise of tim timothy hilker and joe  greco for guidance in keeping a balanced budget   and helping us to determine what is an  appropriate tax levy to place on our taxpayers   i think that staff positions  safety resources special ed   arts and education and music would be areas  that i would prioritize okay thank you martha   thank you i seem to invert the questions in my  responses so first i'll address the tax levy um   without knowing every um detail of the budget  i have a high degree of confidence and trust   in the construction of the budget and that the  experts compose something that they felt would   be meaningful and effective and do

072well by our  students in our school communities i think that one of the ways that we can determine that is  also to get information from our stakeholders   in the communities to see how people perceive how  the budget is being spent and also perhaps greater   dialogue on communication to explain the benefits  of why the spending is the way that it is some of   my priorities would be to support social workers  and psychologists and mental health professionals   i think it's critical also to invest in staff  retention and recruiting because as we know   there'll be um many retirements that are coming  up and we're also faced with the work shortage   um and and i think um another area would be to  uh for the schools to engage in outreach uh to   engage communities and have  dialogue with our

073constituents   okay thank you right moving on to the sixth  question natalia you're gonna get to go first oh dean i'm so sorry please forgive me i'm easily  forgettable it's okay kathy sorry no worries thank   you so i'll be brief how about that uh student  priorities um from my perspective flow back to my   objectives right and those are quality education  student health and safety most importantly their   mental health and lastly facility infrastructure  and uh long-term planning when it comes to   our facilities we need to have a safe and  secure and well-kept facility infrastructure   system in place to provide the most comfortable  learning environment for our students to flourish   i agree that we should be talking about budgets  throughout the course of the year not just during   budget season tim and joe as well as mike and

074dave  and all of the other individuals that are at our   our monthly meetings will let you know that as  soon as this community approves the budget they   start working on next year's it's not too soon  for us to start talking about that the sooner we   learn about potential budget cuts the sooner we  can engage the potentially impacted stakeholders   with respect to the 2.7 percent tax  levy i believe it is appropriate   we consistently stay under that tax cap which  not only benefits today but one of the things   that i've learned over the course of the last  few years it can impact potentially the next 10   or so years within our community and the tax base  that is impacted all right thank you now it's   question six and natalya you're going to get to  go first how

075can saratoga springs school district   encourage and enforce civil discourse on the b  board of education and with members of the public um sorry could you repeat yeah that was hmm how can the saratoga springs school district  encourage and enforce civil discourse on the board   of education and with members of the public all  right um so in terms of the board of education we   do have a series of agreements that we um create  at the beginning of the year where we have our   essentially a code of conduct for us to follow  however it should be noted that the district code   of conduct and all of the policies also apply to  board members as well so i think that when we are   following our agreements which involve things like  coming to meetings prepared engaging with each   other

076in good faith leaving our politics at the  door et cetera i think that when we do that we are   able to engage with each other in a an appropriate  manner that is civil in terms of the public um   i'll be honest i'm not quite sure how to answer  that question i do believe that it is important   for the public to be able to come and share their  thoughts with us that's why we have two public   comment periods um and so i i think that the  enforcement that we have on that is the time limit   and i think that it is good that our public is  engaged and coming to share their ideas with   us i always take notes i always learn from the  public and i want for more people to have their   voices heard

077not just at the school district but  also at other levels it's important to be engaging   with the different governance bodies in um  in your community in your state nationally   i think that i'm just going to use my card um i  think like i said earlier that a strong education   really is the foundation for democracy and i think  that we want people to be thinking critically   and engaging so that they can learn so they  can share their ideas and so that we can grow   together i think that um it's you know like um  some of my fellow candidates were saying earlier   it is important for every voice to be heard  it is important for us to talk about our ideas   when we talk about what we think and when we learn  from each other we can

078work towards a better world   and that's what i want that's what i want our  schools to be working on so in terms of engaging   productively i think that that's on each of us  to think about how we want to be treated and to   treat others that way that's what i encourage  in my family that's what i encourage at work   that's what i encourage in those around me  and um yes thank you all right thank you john   what she said um i i think we've had kind of  a perfect storm there's so many challenges   in our district and then we've had covid  and so we've we've sort of buttoned down   uh our organizations and and closed the doors and  had things remote and been distanced from each   other and all the time we're getting more and

079more  frustrated uncertainty has been sort of the mantra   of our time and so it's been frustrating for  everybody we're all frustrated with this situation   and so as we emerge out of kovid we need to  open things back up we need more open houses   i think we need more committees and task  forces that are more inclusive we need   to invite our neighbors into the schools  we need to have more input more discourse   i also think we need better communication systems  i've said that before i think an overhaul website   will help a lot and i and i think communication  needs to always be a priority for the district   the third thing i'll say is get off social  media it's almost never helpful if someone   posts something anonymously ignore it if someone  attacks somebody else's motives and character  

080ignore it the final thing i'll say is let's  extend each other a little bit of grace   you know every single board member i've  worked with has been here because they   care about children every single one of them  let's assume that's true of everybody that   serves here and let's assume it's true that  everybody comes to our meetings let's listen   more carefully and let's build on our common  ground i am so heartened by this conversation   we don't agree on everything but look at all the  stuff we agree about let's build on that thank you billy i agree with john i think that the pandemic  you know literally closed our school district   doors and it kept parents on the outside and  because i think that there's a breakdown in   our school district's communication to our  community and parents

081and all stakeholders   i think that it created a divide and  so parents are left wondering what is   you know being implemented in the schools i've  stated before that part of my platform would be   to increase transparency in the curriculum and the  policies that are being implemented in our school   in particular to dei it was a new curriculum  or a new policy that was implemented when we   came back from the pandemic and a lot of parents  including myself have lots of questions about that   i think that the the other thing that could happen   to improve the civil discourse between members of  our community and the board is for voters to elect   board members that will bring a balance to this  board by offering differing ideas and diversity   so that stakeholders feel that when they're  attending a

082board meeting that their views   beliefs and ethics are being represented by  the the diverse board members that are sitting   okay thank you martha thank you i was a little  thrown by the question um because i didn't   i wasn't sure that i heard it correctly in terms  of um the question about increasing how can we   increase civil discourse so in processing that i  think that we're in agreement that civil discourse   can be productive um but i think a  lot of that has to do with process   and that the term of civility um  is maintained in the in the process and that people's inputs and people's opinions  are valued and processed because when people's   opinions and information are valued and processed  they can be churned and then come out with a   better result so i think that's

083the goal and why  it would be appealing to increase civil discourse   certainly i support the public comment area  and i like the idea of having a task force to   look at this in ways that we can expand civil  discourse and engage community members and   perhaps students as well that classes could  study this and the value of civil discourse   at the board level and then how that is of  value and how we can improve that for everyone's   learning and increase productivity okay thank you  martha dean thank you so i believe part of the   question was how can certain spring city school  district encourage and enforce yep but part of   it was encouraged right yes and correct correct so  i believe that we already do right we do encourage   civil discourse we do that in a multitude

084of  different ways primarily as some other folks   have mentioned that's done through public comment  which happens two times during every meeting   over the course of the last few years we've had  many people who've gotten up to speak about very   various things that they're passionate about we  don't always have to agree with them there may be   individuals at the board table that do and there  may be individuals at the board table that do not   the key to those individuals that are listening  to what the public is telling us is that we are   acting with respect and professionalism at  all times there's an individual here who was   a coach for a very long time named coach johns  and you may have seen his slogan on on lawn signs   you may have even seen it all the way

085down  to duke university and the students that he   impacted down there and it's a simple message  act with respect always if we're doing that   then no matter what the discussion is we  have an opportunity to learn from each   other i take that opportunity each and every time  that i come to the board meetings the bottom line   is we should treat others the way we would like  to be treated always okay thank you dean ed   well with within the board i think you got to be  willing to come and look at things objectively be   willing to look at the good the bad and the ugly  and you got to be able to discuss them and you got   to be able to come to agreements and have hard  conversations but civilly now when dealing with   the public

086i think that yeah the board has to have  a continuous open dialogue with the public there   should be some mechanism even outside of the open  minute meetings and things like that the public   should be able to speak to the board and the  board has to communicate openly with the public   also with the committees get parents involved in  these committees the board should approve who are   on these committees and make sure that they are  inclusive and diverse and have diversity because   you can't have a committee that is just full of  just one stakeholder or one group or segment of   the community it has to be representative of  everyone thank you okay um it's about 8 13.   i think we're going to make this question the last  one and then we'll move on to closing statements i

087guess it'll be this one should and it's  going to go to john first we're all the way   back to the beginning should the district  evaluate purchasing electric only vehicles   are there other efficiency options  you would consider yes and yes this this is something we've been talking about  the board members led this conversation last year   and the transportation department was it wasn't  really on their radar i mean they were thinking   about it they were aware of it but they sort of  turned their attention more fully to it and now   we're hearing from other players in the state that  this there's a lot of districts that are starting   to think about this and it would be great you know  it's a difficult thing you don't want to get too   far out in front of it when it's

088really expensive  and and not yet all the kinks are worked out but   that's i think that's coming in our future i think  our district is paying attention and we're i think   we're in a good place there and i think that the  state is going to help uh make that easier for   for districts i think becoming more green  has to be a goal and i wish it was more   of a priority for us we're trying to do so many  things and we can't do everything but i hope we   will increasingly become green and that certainly  should be part of it okay thank you john billy um   i agree with john that becoming more green  is important i think as a school district   it's imperative that we work collectively and  collaboratively together that we reach out to  

089the people who are in the know of knowing whether  or not our budget can afford and be looking at   allocating funding that would be appropriated to  buying electric only vehicles i think that as an   individual i don't think that it's ever wise  to do only one thing so i think that it would   be important for me if i were to be elected to  work collaboratively with informed individuals   to help shape and um mentor my decision making  along this process okay thank you martha   thank you i would love that for the school to have  electric only i have an electric car and i love it   however i don't think it's quite as simple  although it would be lovely if it was yes and yes   as an answer i think it's definitely a goal and  the direction

090that the school district should head   incrementally and that that would be a cost  savings and just a greener solution i think there   are some complications in some considerations  such as charging mechanisms heated garages   distance that the buses need to go etc i think so  that there are some infrastructure considerations   that need to be looked at um in the big picture  so i while i support heading in that direction   i think it would be prudent to study some other  districts that have also gone this way and make a   decision a commitment to move incrementally toward  having that thank you okay very good i want to   emphasize that it said should the district  evaluate purchasing electric only vehicles okay all right um dean colligan sure thank you  uh so the question of should the district   evaluate purchasing

091electric only vehicles the  answer is simply yes we should always evaluate   every opportunity that we have to be better  stewards of our community and our environment   we should always strive to completely understand  all the pros and cons that are associated with all   decisions of magnitude this being one of them we  took an opportunity a couple of years ago dave and   his team through the transportation department uh  of communicating with a school district downstate   that had started to migrate their their bus fleet  over to electric that's really where the focus   is i think today not necessarily from the the  vehicles or the cars that that administrators or   teachers may use within the community but more so  on the on the school buses right that's how we get   our kids to school every day safely and just

092like  martha mentioned there's so much more one of my   focuses has the word infrastructure in it and the  amount of infrastructure that goes together with   electric charging vehicles is monumental  however as i mentioned yes we should evaluate   this opportunity and again find a way to be better  stewards of our community and our environment okay   thank you dean um ed yes i'm all for exploring  the possibility of purchasing an electric vehicle   i know it's promoted as the green solution right  now but a very big problem facing this industry   is that the batteries are literally  hundreds of pounds of toxic chemicals   and they have no way to dispose  of those batteries the only   current proposal of disposing of those  batteries is dumping them into the oceans   so this would come at a great concern so and how 

093green is that i'm a lover of seafood i don't know   that i want to have a seafood that's full of  these toxic chemicals thank you okay natalya um as has been said before the  board did ask for electric bus   information and i personally was very  happy to listen to the information that   we got from people who have expertise  in this field it's very very complicated   that said we have no choice but to continue  to evaluate this because it's my understanding   that the governor has set a date by which we  must have electric buses in our school districts   and so i hear all of the concerns and i hope that  we can continue to explore that i also hope that   electric buses continue to improve because as  they are right now it's my understanding from   the

094presentation that we got and i think that's  the understanding of others too that we're not   quite there yet with the technology to be  able to serve our district properly with them   but again there is a date set so i don't think  that we have any opportunity or any option but   to continue to explore um that said we must be  taking every effort to do this um i'm sorry we   teach our students to take care of our planet  that's something that i learned in kindergarten   and have carried with me um we as adults must be  taking every effort to do this at the district   level in our neighborhoods and our community  for me it's not just about the electric buses   it is truly about taking care of the planet thank  you okay thank you very much

095well it's time for   closing statements and um each person will have  one minute each candidate will have one minute   for your closing statement and we're going to go  back to our original running down the panel so   john you're going to go first okay during my time  on the board i have met so many amazing people   who genuinely care about the well-being and growth  of our students this includes talented devoted   employees inside and outside the classroom  in visible positions and behind the scenes   it also includes neighbors who give their time  freely including parents and others who volunteer   for different kinds of service and i'm inspired  by all of them i think they all know that it takes   a village to educate a child they also know that  the best decisions in the district will always put  

096students first the way to make our schools even  better is to collaborate around that singular goal   no group agrees on everything  but if we keep that goal up front   i am confident we can together bring  the best out of every single student   in the district i love serving on the school  board and i'd like to do it for another term   okay thank you john billy being a member of the  school board is a time-consuming rigorous and   important responsibility it is not a position  that i ever intended to seek however i feel a   civic responsibility to serve if i'm elected  you can trust that i will work effortlessly to   improve communication channels between the school  district and our stakeholders to identify and   share with the community the who the what the why  of all policy and

097curriculum and budgetary items   i believe that stakeholders the parents community  students teachers and school personnel are an   integral part of our educational system and that  as a board member it would be my responsibility   to represent those views and not my personal  views if elected i will not push the political   or personal ideologies of any one group or  party i will give 100 to ensuring adherence   to our school district mission implementation of  developmentally appropriate policy and curriculum   which align with state ed guidelines  while providing excellence in education   and a safe and welcoming environment  for all okay thank you billy martha   thank you for hosting thank you for being here  and to the fellow candidates for being here   and supporting this process what i'd like  you to know about me and remember about me   is that in

098in addition to experience in  education and supporting community resources   i am a builder i'm a proven professional  that solves problems and delivers solutions   i'm skilled in board practices and i  will add to the productivity of the board   by not having children in the school i offer the  unique perspective that qualifies me as a trustee   you can have confidence in my objectivity and  my qualifications to put every student first   to focus on students well-being and to represent  our community's values i respectfully ask for your   vote on may 17th okay thank you martha dean thank  you i believe that the saratoga spring city school   district as a whole is great and i completely  value the public educational school system   certain springs is one of the best in the  capital district that supports student academic   athletic and extracurricular

099aspirations and has  very strong graduation rates we could certainly   work on a few things we continue to monitor our  such things as class sizes challenging educational   opportunities within some of our programs  and most importantly the health safety and   welfare of our student population through mental  health support channels i hope that you have all   learned a little bit more about me and the other  candidates this evening i want to thank the league   of women voters the saratoga spring city school  district all of you and those listening at home   i also uh i'm happy that you were here to listen  to all of our concerns as well as as well as   my concerns and the concerns of other candidates  you can make a difference by voting on may 17th   and letting all of your eligible family  and

100friends know that they should vote too   and the last thing that i would like to  say is happy national teachers appreciation   week to all of our teachers thank you  for all that you do for our students okay ed i chose run for school board because  i know many of the students in our community   from coaching them over the last eight  years and i want to see them all succeed   i view the school district much like a sports team  educators parents and students coming together   for a common goal a winning education for all i  will bring my deep financial services background   open communication skills and  collaboration skills to the board   i want to work with all stakeholders in the  district to provide an inclusive education   transparent financial reporting as well  as school safety for all on

101our campuses we need all stakeholders to work together to give  our kids an excellent education they deserve it   because they're our future and i want to thank all  the teachers out there teacher appreciation week   i put a post up today honoring one of my favorite  teachers a long time and great saratogian   miss remyjifoy she was fantastic and she  taught me a lot about the world and a lot   about diversity so i want to thank  her okay thank you very much natalia   school is the foundation for a lifetime of  positive relationships love of learning and   connections with the world i am committed  to supporting our district and preparing   our students for the future through academic  achievement and character development as well   as providing adequate resources to our teachers  and staff i am a special educator at

102a public   elementary school as well as a community builder  my personal and professional knowledge perspective   and problem-solving skills combined to make me a  highly effective trustee i will continue making   decisions collaboratively while talking connecting  and listening to the ideas of my community   since 2019 i have worked collegially with my  fellow trustees to support decisions based   on research and best practices with every single  member of the school community in mind but while   there are many stakeholders what matters most  is that our schools serve each and every student   i will always put students first thank you okay  well thank you everyone uh please vote on may 17th   ballots can be cast between 7 a.m and 9 p.m at  caroline street division street lake avenue geyser   road dorothy nolan and greenfield elementary  schools applications for absentee ballots can  

103be found at the school district website i want  to thank the candidates for being so respectful   and really doing a great job i think you taught  us a lot about civil discourse and i want to   thank the audience for being respectful and  being here and taking time out of your busy   lives to come and find out about who's running for  your school board remember if you want to join the   league of women voters we've got some flyers  right here so good night everybody thank you you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.