CorpusRecord 64355

Saugerties Board of Education Meeting 1/14/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Saugerties Central School District
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Ulster County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,770 words · about 105 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right good evening everybody we'll call to order this meeting uh regular meeting of the Sor School Board of January 14th um designation of emergency exits we have two this way and there's one back over here um I heard there's one over there but was told not to send people that way so we have two here and one over here um Virginia would you roll a call what you call herea hereon H here here here micher [Music] here all right for pledge ofast all right Dr ERS our mission and vision statements please uh we in s Central School District provide Equitable engaging inspiring and holistic experiences that support success and empowerment for students families and community in a diverse and changing world it's our vision to become a beacon of educational Excellence

002where every individual is inspired to be able to achieve their fullest potential all right thank thank you um we have first item up is approval of minutes from our December uh 10th meeting do I have a motion to accept Carol second Rosa discussion not all those in favor all right Miss Mills our student report please thank you hello um region week is coming up next week please refer to the reg letter that miss m shared recently or the week at glance for more specific information feel free to call our offices with any or with any questions Savannah tle back took third in the eastern states tournament this past weekend for female wrestling by February Science Olympiad will have competed in two invitations and regionals we are looking forward to hearing if they will qualify States

003first States best of luck to everybody in all e Club has been working with our custodial staff and director of facilities to improve recycling efforts in the secondary campus we would like to thank everyone for their effort in seeing this through anyone interested in building leadership team anyone interested in serving as a member in the senior high building leadership team please reach out to miss moo and the second semester begins January 27th that's all I have thank you all right thank you all right uh next up is our ricardi elementary school update by principal TR good evening everyone my name is Paul Tri the principal of ricardi Elementary thank you for this opportunity uh we are very very excited to have our Student Government officers here tonight we're very eager to share with you all

004about ricardi happenings and so they're going to kick it off tonight uh so first of all big thank you to Mrs petett our third grade teacher here at ricardi and also the advisor to our student government uh Mrs P does a phenomenal job uh empowering our students to you know see initiatives through and truly enact the change that we want to see at ricardi so each officer you're going to hear from tonight was elected democratically um they gave speeches to the student body right here in this room uh on the Beautiful on the left see if I canate this on the left we have Miss scotus grenell uh right after she won right after she was elected look that smile and on the right we have Maline pet uh and uh you know she was

005passionately sharing her campaign promises uh with our student body so this evening our ricardi student leaders are going to start by sharing uh a moment that has challenged them and how they navigated that challenge um as well as a moment that Pro and so without further Ado please give a warm welcome to miss Addison [Applause] Taylor I'm Taylor and I'm the student government President we have learned from our teachers that it is very important to have a growth mindset we will try to model that now by sharing some things that we are proud of about our own gr and one challenge we had to work to overcome I am proud that I can help my school Community by being a part of student government even though I had to overcome finding from Spirit ideas that

006would appeal to students I didn't give up and found ideas that appeal to most I'm p and I'm the student government treas one memorable thing I always enjoy a Feld day even though even though we do it every year they are one of the most fun things we do at school and I look forward to them every year field that also helps us work together as a team and build friendship One Challenge I used to face was struggling with math but I got better over time by practicing more often and Mrs mags my fifth grade teacher last year helped me during the summer which helped me improve I am Matthew I'm the student government co-s social director I am proud to have worked with the student government last year to get volleyball nets and soccer

007nets at recess this was something that the students asked for one obstacle that I have fac is not being good at speaking in front of a large group of people I practiced my student government speech in front of my family countless times and took their feedback I was proud after I delivered my speech [Applause] I am Emma grer and I am the student government co- social director I'm proud of getting straight A's on most of my report cards a challenge I faced in school was when I had to write my essay and my speech for Student Government so my parents helped me it was a challenge because I had to write a 500w essay and a one minute speech [Applause] my name is Alice fitgerald and I'm the student government secretary I was proud of

008getting voted into student government by the school I faced a lot of Social Challenges with my friends and the students in marari I overcame them by making some good friends [Applause] here I Vice presid one thing I'm proud of was getting 3 in my that was very exciting because it l my gr One Challenge I faed was when I changed scho from M Mar to ricardi the the things that made me feel welcome were all the kids being super nice to me and the teachers being welcoming and making out sh all the work all right one more round of applause for C government [Music] officers everybody so they're going to stick around and help me with uh the student experience portion of this presentation but before we get there I just want to share a

009couple very brief uh data slides with you so this is data that I realized you've seen before at the other uh schools and so we we'll keep it tight we keep the brief uh you're looking at the 2023 2024 I ready reading data um and the two things I'd like to highlight from this slide uh is at the beginning of the year 21% of our students were considered at risk um and that decreased to 10% by the end of the year so we had an improvement of 11 percentage points over the course of the year um that's for reading and 33% of our students if you look all the way on the left were considered high performing right or at or above grade level and that increases 63% by the the year um and Improvement

010of 30% points so we have similar data in in math so same slicing of the data most at risk students went from 19% of the student body at the beginning of the year down to 4% at the end of the year um so that's an improvement of 15 percentage points and our highest performing kids uh went from 21% at the beginning of year to 64 % at the end of the year um an improvement of 43 percentage points right so that's one way to slice the data um we expect students to grow right over the course of a school year so the other thing we look at is from September to September right so September 23 to September 24 um are we improving or not right and so generally what we're seeing is that students

011are oops uh we're seeing similar levels of proficiency from year to year and we saw the same thing when we compar last year when we compared 22 to 23 and so we can expect similar growth that we've seen in the past this year um one quick piece of data that I want to uh to highlight that is encouraging to me is the percentage of atrisk students in September decreased by 4 percentage points so from 19% down to uh 15% which shows that our most struggling kids right our most at risk kids are are making more than one year's worth of growth in one academic school year right so they're making one more than one year's worth of growth in one academic school year which shows that we're catching some of those students up right it's

012not all it's it's a small number but we're making momentum um there is a lot of work to be done some of which we'll talk about tonight um but that is encouraging to me right so that even our most struggling kids who are multiple years below grade level are making progress so congratulations to our teachers who are really driving that work so on to our first priority area in our blueprint for excellence is um academic Excellence so you've all seen the engagement Continuum it's really exciting uh work if you walk walk into any classroom you see uh the Continuum on the walls uh students are using the language and I just I want to share one one anecdote about uh the engagement Continuum I was I was working out in a local gym here in

013Glasgow u a couple weeks ago and we have some some high school students uh working out nearby and the the funniest thing happened I was not expecting to hear anything about you know School uh certainly not about the engagement continu but two teenage boys talking to each other um away from adults right away from parents away from anyone that they might try to be you know impressing one teenage boy said to the other well you know man I was disruptive for a while but now I'm back to participating crazy right so if teenage students are using this language that we're teaching them in school at the gym away from school um that's a win right it's a very big win for SES so congratulations to the high school teachers who over there of those students

014um and of course we're seeing at the elementary level too so the picture up there on the right is one of our fourth grade students who uh set her goal her goal for that particular lesson when I was in that room was to be investing and she put the star underneath uh her goal and then beyond that she actually wrote down her specific goal she knows that when she gets bored she goes into her desk and uh avoids uh you know and doesn't participate so her goal was I want to not go in my desk if I get board okay so that's obviously that's that's the first step identifying our bad habits The Next Step there would be for her to identify a replacement Behavior right what am I going to do instead of um

015going into my desk um to make sure I don't get board right whether it's getting up stretching our legs taking notes Etc so that's going really well this year it's a huge priority area uh when it comes to academic Excellence next up uh I'd like to highlight three areas prior areas that I have here at Ricard um so this is not necessarily District um you know initiatives these are things that I've noticed walking around um that I think that we if we can hit these hard we can really Drive um uh you know move the needle so first is uh playing volleyball instead of ping pong right so as a teacher ping pong right you ask a question and the student responds to you right um and then you evaluate the correctness of of the

016students response and you know certainly sometimes we want to do that it is absolutely necessary to do that but generally we want students to be uh more engaged right we want students to be thinking and listening about what all the other kids are saying in the room when you ask that question you want to play volleyball right so you as a teacher you serve the ball you ask the question the students uh respond and then you have another student evaluate you know uh that student's response or add on or rephrase or revise whatever it is and then you go to another student before you bring it back to you as a teacher and so many teachers here are are on it uh we're moving in that direction um but you know the more that we

017can do that uh we'll see engagement levels go through the roof um and we'll see um students really be able to to use the language that we want them to use around um evaluating one another in a constructive way second is uh instruction that is laser focused on the objective right so um it's very easy to tell life lessons and you know go off go on tangents uh but we really want to stick to whatever the objective is in that lesson have it posted on the board and we're not deviating from that the third is that assessments are actionable and connected concretely to that objective we need to know if we effective as the teacher as the adult in the room we need to know if we're doing you know a good job or not

018and and you know anywhere in between and using that data to inform our instructional next steps uh two pictures I'd like to share with you on the left we have a kindergarten classroom U Mrs Porter's classroom and the student is running the morning activity um so he uh is he's looking at the letter M and his job is to uh you know tell the class what sound M makes and he forgot what sound M makes and he's also you know a kid that gets nervous a little you know a little easily and so Mrs Porter did the the brilliant move of bringing up a friend uh who told him what the sound M makes and she was up there for the entire morning uh exercise and so you know it's it's great we have something

019similar on the right um actually mot grenell is leading the the charge in fifth grade um also phonic space right foundations and um so I put these side side by side I didn't even realize as I was as I was taking the pictures but right it's we have kindergarten and we have fifth grade and we have students leading the activity right so this all comes back to Shifting the majority of thinking that kids are doing um from adults to students right so you don't want to have a mental workout as the adult you want the students to be having that mental workout so great job godess it was very impressive so onto our next priority area the student experience I'm going to bring up our students again to kick it off you guys ready all

020right so uh our Student Government really has done a wonderful job soliciting feedback from uh students to inform their initiatives so uh our students here our officers are going to talk about all the ways that they are improving the student experience atardi so please give a warm welcome to Addison t [Applause] theard Student Government officers have been busy improving the student experience here's a breakdown of our initiative and the positive impact they can have for all of our students last school year the student government worked hard to cre a smaller version of the high school score store our store opened up in SE in September and has provided students with needed school supplies donated by our community it has a positive impact on our students because they are now able to get the items they

021need for school at no cost it has also taught the officers responsibility since we are in charge of running the store we have also been in charge of organizing spirit days which help Foster community and pride through the theme dress up days or events spirit days have positive impact by promoting fun engagement and unity within the [Applause] school this past holiday season we voted on having Lobby decorations to represent all holidays by doing this we created a welcoming and inclusive school by recognizing diverse holidays and coaches it was impactful because it helped students feel valued and represented supporting a scene of the only [Applause] we hope to send out a survey to our cardi Community soon to gather input from families to ensure a comprehensive and inclusive representation of holidays we think it will have

022a positive impact on families and encourage family involvement promote diversity and strengthen School family [Applause] connections these initiative demonstrate creativity inclusivity and Leadership they are all things that make ricardi [Applause] special wonderful job everyone thank you so much erence if you want to leave you know great job guys I'll see you tomorrow [Applause] so in the spirit of inclusivity we want students to have a a window and a mirror experience right we want kids to always see themselves in the mirror uh in our curriculum regular their daily experience and we want them to be also be able to see other perspectives and other lives that they um points of view that they may not uh you know have experience with and so if our vision truly is to uh for our students to become Global

023Citizens we need to continue to look at everything through that lens right everything we do has to be through that lens and so with that I'm really excited to I was really excited to see um what's pictured there it's simple right it's three Clues is a six straight classroom uh Mrs Rio's classroom and students while independently working were encouraged instead of raising their hand and waiting for the teacher to come over and answer the question they were encouraged to go up right uncover one of those Clues and then come back with that clue uh to independently solve the problem right so would Empower students instead of relying on um someone else right to to solve it themselves using those Clues and um so again ideally we are fostering independ um up next we've got professional

024culture uh so Jim Collins talks about a big carry audacious goal and when I think about uh what that means I think about our blueprint for excellence and I think about our portrait of a graduate uh right how are we actually going to achieve those things are we actually going to uh develop the skills the soft skills and hard skills in our students um once they graduate graduate to do that uh we need need to continually and intentionally cultivate um a culture of professional um Excellence right and so last year at ricardi something that we were very focused on in this room with all of our teachers was Carol D's work right developing a growth mindset what that actually means for adults um because it takes a lot of humility to look at a set

025of data and um even you know talk about it uh you know you have to set your ego aside uh because it's truly not representative of who you are as a person but instead we have to take that data and we have to act on it and it's very difficult to do uh you know if if you're not used to doing that and so we we spent a lot of time just talking about growth mindset through the lens of students of course but also through adults um so what does our data tell us our data tells us that vocabulary and comprehension need continued focus and this is nothing you know that's isolated to ricardi right this is something it's a crisis uh that we're focused on and so uh one of the things I'm very

026excited about is Dr Jen's work one of our instructional coaches uh this year I have seen an increase in the number of teachers uh voluntarily opting into working with her uh working with coaches period um you know outside of their assign times and that shows me that you know people are are generally you know open to this you know obviously everyone's open to growth right but the idea of working next to somebody who who who um might have some you know different perspective it's really great to see uh people taking advantage of um of her uh so we are gaining momentum you know not because of a district mandate right but because I think teachers are seeing the impact on learning um and they're actually willing to you know to try these initiatives which is

027wonderful to see uh I'll talk briefly about the BLT so you know what a reality is Right building leadership team meets once a month made up of key stakeholders uh couple highlights from last year at ricardi we saw chronic absenteeism decrease from 20% to 18% it's only 2% points but we're moving in the right direction uh academics we saw grades 1 2 3 and five all saw year-over-year increases in ela and we saw grades 1 2 3 and four uh see year-over-year increases in math uh Proficiency in Geometry which has been a focus area increased across the grades by 3 percentage points also small for gaining momentum uh and I'm very proud of our fourth grade team and their students as they saw a 24% Point increase on the New York state math assessment uh

028this year I won't read you the goals you have them uh but we have a goal in attendance in academics and in student culture uh as we all know we just visited the classrooms right where we had the uh the first uh heating pipe and the the flood I just want to uh take a moment to thank everyone who helped with that so thank you Dr ERS and your family uh his family came in and help the teachers post flood Dr Roach Jen fellows uh for inventory our curriculum um rich prince and his team Pur um thank you uh especially Jeremy uh who as we know you know identified that there was something wrong uh with the temperature Spike um immediately uh I think on December 22nd so that people could take action on on

029the 23rd um and my team here uh the custodial team Ruben Keith and phip uh just you know spent a lot of time here when they weren't planning on it over the break pictured here uh every single staff member here at rard stayed after school to help teachers rebuild their classroom uh they beyond the faculty meeting time uh to put it all back together you all just walked into the rooms right it's it's hard to tell that a flood occurred in there and those rooms were absolutely stripped and bare just a few weeks ago um so I'm very very proud of the team here um you know truly demonstrating of whatever it takes attitud um so onto our last uh PRI area family and Community engagement like to thank the ricardi PTA who has been

030incredibly supportive and involved particularly this year in funding one field trip a year um for each grade level I'd also like to highlight our community service club uh their name is ricardi Lions Ro for the community they're picture here their advisor is dapne Chelly dapne has spent countless hours with this team of students going to the I Lodge Al's children host children Hospital over the break uh so's food pantry and the animal shelter um they truly have gone above and beyond to give back to the community and finally uh some next steps and priority areas for family and Community engagement here at ricardi um actually this is across across the district we're doing a career fair as I'm sure you've heard about to expose students to various career options uh we'd like to develop parent

031workshops um so you know to invite parents in uh on a variety of topics we're going to survey them to see what they'd like to like to see um but ideas are you know how do I help my third grader with new you know math standards that you know a new approach to math that maybe I didn't have when I was in school uh how do I manage Tantrums in the grocery store for my 5-year-old you know uh when they they want that piece of chocolate or whatever it is all right so I'd like to thank our Student Government officers for being such good leaders um and you know that concludes our presentation this evening thank you for your time uh your continued support uh are there any questions I can answer the same anybody

032have any spe I have a lot of questions far too many for probably the minute we have here to go through but if anybody has any specific questions for Mr TR I just have uh two comments one I think one of the nice things about teachers more teachers opting into coaching is that it's also a sign of trust that that system is going to work and serve them and I think that's a great great um I've done a lot of work with that idea of Windows and mirrors and um we've also now added sliding doors so that idea that what I'm looking at through that window or what I see reflected is that I can actually make that leap and go and explore that culture or explore perspective so I just add sliding doors anybody

033else anybody else so I just have one comment uh on the the flood that you had um I know everybody has and well well deserved have thanked Mr or thank all the teachers and and Mr Prince's team and Jeremy and Dr ERS for helping um but I always go back to I think people handle that based on the leadership that they follow so since you're the building leader thank you for you know over the holiday getting us through that and you're right you walk into those two rooms and that you would not know so thank you for leading them anyone else all right thank you thank you thank you getting up with this or not okay yeah yes all right next up is our long range financial analysis um the process um we have Dr

034Rick Tims uh presenting to us yeah I've got some handoffs for you we're in the middle of the process of your long range plan we got a lot of work done but a lot of work to do because there's a a lot to finance I think everybody thinks they an expert on finance but it's very complicated um see are we going to get the slides up on that Big Board too or no there they are look at that perfect okay all I ask you to do is if we could just stay in the same page oneline because we've got a lot here lot to go over can I just take this and walk over I think I can handle the microphone I played the rock band for 20 years so I think I have okay

035here we go so thank you first for inviting me uh many districts in New York state are out on the precipice to start struggling mightly and that's because the state aid that we're used to getting over the last few years will not be as robust as it has been into the future and I think a major part of your Revenue picture will be State a so what I'm going to do is take you through some slides and tell you what we're going to be looking at in your District all right we good thank you so the first thing we're going to look at is submissions from SE or st3s now these are the official forms of the school district they're submitted to the State education department so this tells where the money came from and

036where it went to because budgets really money in money out and you have many sources of revenue and extremely large number of sources of expenses so we're going to check that out we're going to look back five years because we wanted us to compare your District preco to postco because there were huge federal grants in the meantime second thing we're going to look at the financial calculations on the SCB website now your district has access to these I do not and we're not supposed to only the district does and what happens is as kids are we'll say registered with this theate education department things like this for students with special needs it triggers certain Aid categories so we're working with the school district to keep up on that we've taken a look our RIT your

037auditor reports so we look at those all the time now the auditor reports have certain value uh we make sure nobody ran away with the money and we make sure that everything's in the right code so to speak but really the auditor is looking backwards it's nice to look backwards we're going to look backwards too but the whole purpose of this is to look forward in the end to use we can learn from that we're going to take a look at your Capital expenses and your debt these are two huge parts of any School District budget and debt is very important many times debt uh occurs when you do capital projects as you all know and of course it's related to building AIDS we call expense driven AIDS because you're spending money to get State

038support and then we're also going to look at bands and bonds so these are debt instruments where you borrow money we're going to take a look at the use of the Capital reserves any the capital reserve that you have we're going to take a look at your debt service schedules how much debt you have for the next 20 years and what potential debt you could get we're going to look at all expense driven AIDS now this would be for instance uh students with special need type AIDS this would be Transportation Aid building Aid those types of things we're going to try and take a look at those revenues we're going to take a look at the tax Gap implications in the most recent years your district is basic they Stu to the cap which is

039very good but I must tell you in the early years of the tax cap that wasn't the case with your district and it was that really is caused some significant problems going forward because what happened there is when those tax caps weren't collected it depressed your Levy I'd say forever and you can't go back and get it you could go back and get it with huge tax increases but no one desires that obviously we're going to take a look at your de service fund Andor reserves we going to actually look at both of them I hope you're familiar that you know you have a general fund that actually operates the district day in day out and part of that general fund section is called restricted reserves we're going to go over those actually tonight and

040we also have something known as The Debt Service fund where you have some money set aside to help absolve yourself of debt you have a school lunch fund for instance you have a capital fund to help pay for your your capital projects we're looking at all those items we're also looking at the reports of the controller of New York State uh I dare say the controller wants to make sure all the t's are crossed and all the dies are dotted and that's fine but unfortunately the rules of the controller is using as nice as they are they're ancient and they're not necessarily keeping us up the date L we really need so when I do my final report I'll be pointing out places where May the controller may be critical and I think visiting their

041school districts will brace yourself uh but the other thing is is that I may find as a financial advisor that perhaps they may not see the use for them but looking into the future I do the controller looks backwards we're going to look backwards and then look forward I think they do a nice job in the reports but again it doesn't help us going forward uh we're going to take a look at your funds and I mean funds called appropriated and unappropriated fund balances so there's always a difference in school districts between your budgeted revenues and your budgeted expenses they try to mask it sometimes but there's always a real real difference okay and we're going to take a look at that we're also going to look at how much cash you have on hand

042because cash flow is the life blood of the district matter fact your bond rating is going to be determined by how much fund balance and cash flow you have so when you go borrow money for this Capital project you're going to be looking at how much money you have the less you have the higher your rates are going to be we're going to take a look at a pro a projected teachers retirement employees retirement system rates now we're not trying to pick on anybody here but the key thing is they are a big ticket item in your in your budget and those rates are going up ERS the employees retirement system rates going up 16% this year and keep in mind that those are rates are leveraged against salaries so when salaries go up and

043the rates go up simultaneously you get a compounding effect so we're going to take a look at that we're going to take a look at the implications of loss of federal grants the corona uh virus Relief act and also the arpa the American Rescue plan uh we're going to take a look at the loss of those federal grants every school district in state of New York lost those grants as of September 24th 2024 there was a big Chance by school districts to build fund balances and buy things they normally could not afford and that includes people uh professionals to help out with kids to relieve them from some of the their learning loss uh you could help with capital projects you could do a lot of things for those the problem is all that money

044is now gone and literally you are on a own um the next thing is determination of future expends escalations uh I'm doing a number of these I'm working all over the state doing these I've done these for a really long long time and I must tell you that we're starting to see some huge escalators here one is like health insurance is a big escalator huge escalator your District in particular it's going to be a big issue I think coming up so I think we're going to have to take a look at that and come up with some ideas for you but we're going to try and project where that appears to be going into the next five years I'm going to try and do a projection to the year 2930 for you after we get

045past there it's really kind of uh dicing and then uh we're going to also look at I did interviews with your intern business profal Michelle and Dan have been very gracious with their time and I've driven them absolutely crazy digging things up uh but they've always come through for me because we are trying to really get to the bottom of some big ticket items we will not count paper clips how much paper you use and things like this we're after the big ticket items okay because those are the ones that escalate more other words if paper goes up at 5% you're spending 100,000 on paper that's different than certain other items say health insurance going up at say 10% when you're spending millions of dollars on it so we have to use our energy where

046it pays off the most all right so let's just take a look at this uh left hand side of the slide so I'm going to take you through this I'm going to walk you through it so that you don't get lost in the data but there's a lot of data here this is State a as you know it as your District should know it and if you notice on the left hand side are all the categories for state aid so the first one I want to bring up here is foundation Aid so let's just see here I I don't think sounds like parts of this aren't working there it is foundation and the top now take a look at your foundation you'll see between the 22 23 23 24 year it went up a pretty

047sizable amount of money looks like maybe $56 76,000 or so I must tell you for a district your size that was chunk change compared to other people got and part of it's because of of enrollment issues okay many districts are losing enrollment over time now enrollments not measured in this formula just on which enrollment was last year to this year they really look back to 20 to 2007 they're looking back to see what's happened between those years from now if you'll notice going into the 23 24 years so let me see if I can pull this over here you'll notice now the difference is zero and the difference between 25 and 26 is zero the state actually believes they have given you more than enough money in Foundation Aid please when you look at the

048page look at the size of the number for foundation Aid and compared to the sizes of the numbers of all the other eight categories you will see it is the largest by far matter of fact it makes up more than half of your agid so think of it this way districts have two huge sources of revenue there's a bunch of little ones but there's two huge ones state aid and tax so think of it as you have two jobs to keep your household going and one of the jobs they're telling you and a big part of it they're not going to give you a raise ever again this is going to put pressure on your budget because it's decreasing the rate of increase of your revenues matter of fact that big category that 179 as

049far as the state's concerned might be Frozen like forever now there have been initiatives by certain legislators to actually decrease your rate but so far the governor hasn't done that last year during her presentation in January her proposal was to decrease your Aid the legislature nicked that and got you back to zero now that is better than losing the money if you understand what I'm getting at but it still leaves you pretty vulnerable now if we keep going down the page you see it says High tax Aid now do you have high tax because you have high taxes there's no evidence that is true I'll tell you why because when high taxing was started over a decade ago there was such an uproar over the formula and how it was inequitable and improperly done the

050legislature rather than take money away from people simply kept giving everybody who got it the same amount of money and they have not run the formula since so there's really no evidence you would still be eligible for it if they were to do that by the way that's just a little under uh 400,000 then we have summer school we have summer Transportation a transportation Aid these two Aid categories go up and they go down they go up and they go down they're based on cost with your transportation system some of which are allowable and some not and it's also how many buses you buy and actually how you finance them the cost of the buses and so on so those go up and down all the time depends upon each year okay so that's it

051but there spend to get programs in other words when you buy a bus someone can say well you're getting State eight on the bus yeah but they're not paying for the whole bus they're only paying for a portion of the bus you pay for the rest of it then we've got down here building Aid and building Aid fluctuates as well so when you do a building project and let's just make up a number let's just say you have 85% building a on your building project and you have to amortize the debt for 15 years would you get 85% a year not exactly because your building Aid ratio actually changes every year by a couple say t of a point most cases so it does tend to vacillate so we see vacillations in it also we

052take we're going to look at your debt service schedule trying to find out how even it is you want to keep your tax cap flat one of the things you have to do is keep your debt service flat and your Aid flat and when we do our final report we'll talk more about that b CA B CA so b c a the vas late too because sometimes school districts buy a lot of technology in one year and not so much the next or they send more kids to career in technical education one year and not the next now you may be saying well it depends on how many students with special needs to be send to both these each year the answer is no that's in Foundation Aid students for special needs to go to

053bothies do not receive both's Aid all special ed Aid is either the foundation Aid or it's in the next couple AIDS going down the excess cost AE the public and private so public excess cost a would be kids who are going to high cost programs who say bothies uh you pay a certain amount to begin with you hit a threshold and they give State gives you a percentage pass there now here's the thing it's interesting about that number if you'll notice you're in public exess cost Aid you're getting $582,000 an A or there F depending on what you're you're looking at but you're probably spending 750 at least to get it so it's only a partial reimbursement your private excess cost Aid you're getting a million dollar in eight but you're spending a lot more

054than a million dollar to get the a so what happens is you are always fronting the money the next thing I think we got to look at is software Library textbook and hardware and you see some red numbers there differences and you'll see some black numbers and differences the differences are very small because your enrollment isn't moving much this at least is an enrollment projection annually so this can go up and this can go down based on how many kids you have it's a per student amount then we have the universal prek and you'll notice it's an orange it's an orange for a reason and the reason is that it does not that money does not get deposited into your general fund it's put in a special fund called the special Aid fund for this

055purpose now keep in mind that even though the aid is available you don't necessarily always get it so you'll notice that in the blue lines you're eligible 2324 for $469,000 upk a but in 2425 it's got 762 so it looks like look at all the a we're going to get but you notice have put down the difference is zero and that's because you have to have room you have to be able to fill the slots you have to have demand in most communities they require you to they won't send the kids to the program unless you transport the kids by the way there's no Transportation need for upk kids so you're on your own and in many cases upk programs cost more than the aid because the aid was designed to be seed money for

056the program but I must tell you as an educator because I was also an educator for many years it's a great program for kids it's really what you want in your school district it's excellent to have but you have to be able to fund it as well and then you have supplemental public excess cost Aid a whopping $617 uh and that's frozen because there was a big to-do about that formula as well so they just kept in practice so if you look at the bottom line and I mean the total overall eight increase without upk you'll see it's really not moving much and if it is it's moving down so this is one of your major sources of revenue so we got to dig into this now the interesting thing about today's date is today

057was the State of the Union by the governor the governor then today at 1:00 told everybody all the things want to put in a budget but she has not disclosed the budget she won't do that any sooner than January 21st in January 21st 22nd or 23rd we should be able to get at least what they call the state aid runs some updates to your state a those will not be etched in stone until no later than or no earlier than excuse me April 1st when the legislature acts and of course then you'll have two weeks to solidify your budget don't you know your real State eight numbers so the problem is we will have a report obviously before that but the key thing is is that I mean to give an accurate report we'd have

058to give it about when you're doing at the end of your budget because that's when we know the real numbers because that's how the state operates now there's some other things I think we've got to point out here one is the safe harmless business is really important I can't overemphasize it you were $317,000 into safe Harless which means according to the state's calculations you are now receiving $317,000 you're not eligible for and Foundation there was a Rockefeller report I don't know if youve heard about the Rockefeller report uh I'm also the executive director of the Statewide School Finance Consortium so I made a bunch of recommendations to increase Aid to school districts the Rockefeller report embraced almost every single one of them so we're really proud of her walking around at PX but the key

059thing is is we don't know Governor or the legislature will embrace them because that we believe they will cost more money and I think the state's going to start getting pretty much cash draft here but the thing is is even if they were to embrace some of the changes you'd actually have to embrace $37,000 in changes for you to get you to stay at zero just said so there there's the piece that's really important to know let's just take a look at those result reses for a second here so we've got a reserve tab here we stopping it right now at June 24th because that's that's the official data that we have in the school district and you have a number of reserves you've got the workers compensation and unemployment Reserve now to tell you

060the truth you just started your workers compensation Reserve just recently which is nice and it's nice to have that because all you need is a couple people tripping and falling in the work Zone claiming and suing you and then having major C and you've got a real expense I've already been through this a couple times even professionally during my career it's no joke uh law lawyer the people lawyer up it's amazing uh unemployment of course is 127 which seems appropriate right now the controller might like to see that at 25,000 because maybe you haven't unemployed a bunch of people in the past but we're starting to see a lot of districts with retirements or over you know right sizing and things like this so we'll take a look that going for the future you've got

061a reserve for the ERS and TRS and you'll see you've got a good chunk of change in there but as I mentioned to you before we're going to study this those are hugely expensive pension plans so we're going to have to take a look at that uh based on the districts I'm working with I work with between three and 400 districts um that's not an inordinate amount so that's actually pretty good property loss you don't have any money in there but I don't think you need any except for this FL this keeps happening I put some money into property loss to be honest with you CU you can't keep taking ahead even if you get deductibles it's not the same okay so it's really not the same okay and reserve for liability you had $200,000

062to settle the case there for liability so that Reserve has been eliminated which is a good practice excellent by the board Insurance Reserve now if you had a child's victim act Claim by an ex-employee or but not by an ex employee by an ex or someone who worked here uh for some type of sexual harassment or or something like that uh some of your neighbors by the way have these claims and they're millions of dollars so let me give you an example of this claim uh I could say you know I went to socer te back in 1972 and Mr Jones sexually assaulted me and now I want $2 million because he ruined my life and I sue you the problem you have is the insurance company probably had 19 72 doesn't exist so now

063you're on the hook now if you had that claim I would say put some money in there but I would go to your attorney they would evaluate the claim and then they would advise you on how much should be in there but you don't have that claim that does not mean you won't get a claim it's still good to the end of the year and I think the legislature wants to renew it for another year so people can so many times all right let's just take a look at what else we got here taxor uh some of your neighbors we've just paid out millions of dollars in Tex jeary claims these things are killers now the Tex jeary claim is supposed to work like this when you get a claim and I mean a legal

064claim I don't mean like some you think you're going to get sued for a tax CLA you have to have a claim uh you get it from your your assessor and you hear about it that way you turn it over to your attorney you're trying to figure out what your liability is if the claim is settled sometimes these claims take five six years sometimes they take uh 2 years they could take forever many of them take 3 to five over that period of time the amount of the claim actually escalates so let's just say I'm a business and I think I was over assessed therefore I paid to you $50,000 more taxes than I thought I should have I file a claim next year if it's not adjudicated I can use the 50 plus the

065increase in taxes so now I'm at like 70 so 70 and 50 is 120 does everybody see how this is working I keep the claim keeps growing until it's adjudicated because I have to still be required to pay the amount districts that do not save the money are faced with a couple decisions one is they depending upon the size of the CLA obviously they can take it out of the fund balance they can fire people to save money or they can go borrow the money and when you borrow the money you pay interest on the money and there's no State support for it and it will be simply added to your budget and if your budget then you're going to have to find a levy to support your budget you understand what I'm talking about

066now so in other words it's like your cost just went up a lot you got to find a new job somewhere so that's part of the problem you do have neighbors that work with me that we went and borrowed money we're paying interest on depending upon the size of the claim compared to the size of your budget and your attorney figures this out to make it take care of your legal liability you may only have 5 years to pay the money back it's not like you have 152 depends some are five are 10 but many of them are five and they're big amounts so you could inherit debt a couple million dollars over a couple years quickly so this one here is great dicey so to me we always advise to be cautious because we're

067supposed to be fiduciaries we're supposed to protect you and you want to I'm sure help protect the taxpayers the idea is when you get the claim find out what your liability is put the money in the reserve and don't screw around the next thing we've got down here is the ACR uh reserve for benefits and recruit liabilities this is used when people sear their relationship from the district it's used to pay for unused sick person on vacation days and that's all it can be used for General Municipal off 6p misuse of the fund is subject to a misdemeanor all parties that would be like all you because you are the CFOs so we got to do this right so the key thing here is if you have a retirement center for instance for staff or

068something and it's based on unused sick person or vacation days you you can take the money out of here this is so it does not hit your budget in case you have to do something like that the next one are the capital reserves now these Capital reserves I've got four of them in here you don't have four of them but the reason I have four of them in here because I think we got to think about how Capital reserves work and what they're used for Capital reserves are very special reserves they're educational our reserves uh 3651 so what happens here a capital reserve cannot be created by School District without voter approval so in other words the community must say to you yes we want you to save money for that purpose I love it

069because it's full transparency you're showing people what you're saving for the resolution to create the capital reserve has four parts and must say what's the purpose of the reserve so if you notice I've got different purposes I've got equipment and vehicle I got technology Capital Construction vehicle equipment so you can have multiple Capital Reser simultaneous even for the same things you must also say what I don't know what it's for you must say how long it will last 5 years 10 years 15 years it's got to be in the resolution that's approved by voters other words full transparency the next thing you must have in it is what is the maximum amount of deposits that can be put into the reserve over the life of the reserve 10 million 5 million 500,000 whatever it is

070okay now you cannot exceed that amount during the life of the reserve you can acrew interest past that amount but you cannot exceed the deposits mathematical example here we go you've got a $5 million capital reserve but you only have 4 million in it because you don't deposit all once you can deposited as you see fit over time so you have a $5 million permissible capital reserve you have 4 million million in it now you take one out to do a capital project 3 million in it the question that me comes could you put two in it to finally get to the five the answer is no because then all the deposits would added to six so you have to be you got to have a plan so I think one of the things we'll

071be talking to you about is capital plan and timing uh also you can have one for equipment and vehicles for instance uh sometimes we buy vehicles I bought for instance a giant uh vehicle dump truck for a district this year for $180,000 that's what it's going for by the way pick up trucks a couple years ago 30 40,000 now 7580 okay so get ready you got to scrap on of the prices here so the thing is what I think we got to look at here is we got to come up with a vehicle replacement schedule for this District it's not like you got a tiny little District so how much are these things going to cost for the next 5 years is we want to plan for the worst and hope for the best because

072hope alone isn't the plan so the ideas got to figure what's going on same thing with equipment maybe a major equipment purchases I've got a number of districts who are actually refitting all their trucks with plows in the front that's a piece of equipment that you know remove snow where I left I just left 2 ft of snow I'm be heading back into another foot on the way home but you know it depends on what you got what your equipment needs are but you can also have it for technology for instance for instance in 20 2021 you send everybody home laptop including staff everybody and you've got infrastructure needs in here in your buildings all of them they have to be updated firmware software upgrades and all the rest of this you got to replace

073all those laptops so my question is what's the plan I don't care what the plan is I just care what it's going to cost to find out your budet can take care of it if not we want to do something with the reserve perh I've also got in here um if you had buses for instance and I know you have contract trans but if you had a bus maybe you want a bu we want a bus replacement schedule also we've got down here um uh in those Capital reserves got the one in blue that's yours the one you have now and looks like you're getting Pro prepped up for a capital project and that's good planning that is excellent planning by the way but you have nothing for Equipment Technology or vehicles or Vehicles equipment

074or things like that I don't know if you know this but during a capital project say for instance this is a cafeteria you want to replace the furniture in here you could in a c project you would advertise that furniture for 15 years and pay interest on it and get no building Aid on it because Furniture is not building it eligible you can start a reserve buy the furniture out of the reserve still won't be aable but it won't you won't advertise it for 15 years think about it for a second okay I mean would you go buy a couch and advertise it for 15 years no you save up by so that's something to consider also on Capital reserves it takes approval to expend the money again perfect transparency now you're saying to people

075look you've allowed us to save the money for this purpose the time has come to spend this money we want to spend it now here's why you explain it and ask for a voter approval I think it's a great way to keep Faith with the community reserve for repair not a favorite fan of mine even though he had a repair recently to me if you wanted to put 10 20 40,000 in or something like that to cover maybe a couple things fine but most repairs are not State a eligible okay so that's the problem you want it in the capital project in a capital project you don't repair a boiler you replace it you understand what I'm meing so that's what you you don't repair the floor you replace the floor you don't repair a

076wire you replace a wire you don't fix a sidewalk you install a sidewalk that's what makes the state eligible now reserve for debt you are not eligible for that because if you had sold one of your buildings you still owe debt on it you have to put the proceeds from the sale in that Reserve to absolve you of the debt that's not your situation and other restricted reserves you're not eligible mainly because you don't have a nuclear power plant here I have a couple PX have nuclear power plants or coal fired power plants and they're closing and they're allowed to save money to offset the huge negative tax impact when that thing closes okay Save By the way they won't have enough money it's going to be huge but'll it'll take the edge on now

077part of the thing we're starting to realize about this thing is currently that capital reserve of yours is actually worth 37% of all your reserves so when you do that next Capital project if you use that money over a third of everything you've saved is now gone so people who look at this normally I got a lot of boards would say look we got 12.6 million in there yeah but that 4.7 of it is for all the needs you have in every single building you have and I think you have a building condition survey probably longer in my arm if you think about it that you has to be fixed and things have to be done and I got news for you stuff is not getting any cheaper everybody thinks well inflation's going to go

078away that's not how inflation works for schools it's not how inflation Works in construction so if I could if I C if I charge you $1,000 for a steel piece of beam because of inflation it used to be 500 don't expect that price to go down it's not going down because once you paid 1,000 or somebody does it's always going to be a th okay so that's what I'm trying to point out the next thing I think you got to realize is that your employer retirement system you be PRS you are already going to use some of these reserves in your budget hypothetically I don't know if by the end of the year you're going to need to but you've already declared that you are willing to use those amounts of reserves right there out

079of out of the out of the ERS $852,000 and out of the the TRS 764 I'm not so sure it's something I want to do because what it's going to do is take a look at it look at the ERS 8 8 goes into 31 how many times not many so you're going to De depress that that Reserve amount rapidly if you do it and the same thing for TRS so to me it looks like you're already counting on depleting the reserves I don't know we'll see so if I was to project those reserves going forward this is what I would get what I would get is I would depress the ERS Reserve if you do it once you're going to completely you're going to have to keep doing it because you won't be able

080to raise money any other way so I think TRS if you ERS if you keep using the 852 by 2728 it'll be 3,000 and a h if you do it with the TRS you'll be out of money by 27 28 if we take the tax suror claim and it's paid in the next 3 years that money's gone and then to make it worse if you use the capital project which is going to help you probably in 2 uh 28 29 that money will be gone so the 12 million 6 turns into 1 mil7 pretty fast see what I'm talking about this is why I worry this is what keeps me up even though I'm no longer a superintendent or a business official or a district superintendent so there's more that loss of reserves plan right

081now is about 1.66 million it's another 133% and of course we still haven't taken a look at what you need in a capital project the timing of it we still don't know the vehicle purchases you need and we don't know the Tech equipment purchases you need that's what we're all working on now so already I can see we got this could to be tough it's going to be pretty St uh and none of our course is getting less expensive you do have a Debt Service fund now the Ted service fund is a special fund the money's placed into and it usually gets in there three different ways one is let's just say you did a million doll Capital project and you spent $900,000 doing it other words you stopped after spending 900 and said let's

082not do the last 100 but you would already borrow it you would take that 100,000 difference and has to go in this fund okay that's how it work now the other way is if you borrow money and you get they call a premium which basically means four people say four Banks say all right well get a money at 4% but one of the banks says well I'm not only loan to you at 4% like the other three but what we're going to do is we're going to hand you a check for $50,000 to help you with your first interest payment sweet the pop that's called a premium that means they would to the bed you must take that when you put it in there and that money over time is supposed to be used to

083decrease your debt now to me that money is untapped and if you're going to come up with a capital project plan I am not your financial adviser I'm only doing this project I mean I have my own clients that I am a financial adviser one of the things I've suggested to the district is that anything you do that money be included in the plan that money cannot be used to decrease it cannot be used against new debt it can only be used against existing debt but the way you would do it is in the same years you acire the new debt you would use it against the existing debt to make room for the new debt think oh give me an example uh uh my my mortgage PS $1,000 my truck payment is$ 250 and

084it comes time for get a new truck I'm keeping my mortgage payment going and I say to Uncle Louie I said Uncle Lou you know I'd like to get this new truck but now they want the payments at 300 and I can't afford it and he says well tell you what we'll do what's the difference 50 bucks why I just give you 50 bucks until the till the truck's paid off then the hit to me is still the 250 does it understand this going you do or you don't sounds like we have to do a class on it we'll get it okay we can do that okay and the next one is school lunch fund and you're doing really well with your school lunch fund so that is excellent news so that that's real good

085and I think a lot of it's attribut to your SE that plant your you know everybody bre lunch okay so what's the future hold well first of all here's what we're going to do we're going to try and figure out during the month of February how much money you're going to end up with in the month in June 30th that is not easy okay we have an inter business official is working very very well and I got to tell you Michelle's been a lifesaver for us but I think the key thing is is you know she doesn't hasn't run your budget every year but we're going to have to try and figure out how much money you're going to spend and how much money you're going to get in June 30th somewhere in February so

086that's going to be the tough part so we figure out how much money to carry over because we need to either build reserves or use balance next year's budget keep in mind when you're budgeting that the budget is like half heart half calculations this makes any sense for instance does anybody here know I mean anybody in the room know exactly how many kids with special needs we will have next year in fourth grade anybody no bu he probably knows exactly because some I know we got special ed right I'm not worried you know why cuz here's what's happened to me four kids moved in in a single year there were option four kids that were 200,000 a pop at a special school and my district inherited $800,000 in about 2 hours and 15 minutes now

087luckily for me they were trying to get away from civil or uh Social Services they were running across the state and 2 months later they left but I felt bad because those kids we need a lot of help boy we inherited a lot of cost and no stack form no form for special ed was enough to cover that so nice try though good thought you had me right okay so the thing is is it's really hard okay so I think we're going to try our best it's also your historical data one of the things I got to tell you this I'm going to say this right now out loud and I think I'm just going to be honest you got to get stability in a business office you got have someone going to stay here

088and be here and get this thing done because we got this this up this down this over that which we're finding out so trying to get an historical context here has been very very difficult now mich's L pile through everything but remember every business official has a way to do this or a way to do that and when they keep changing chairs it's not helpful okay in terms of trying to get a a hand on it re-evaluate purchases and staff need I've already said to your superintendent probably much do a your gr because I speak plainly but that is I would I would on a not telling everybody don't buy anything else we're not buying anything else that's because I don't know what the future holds I'm a little concerned about it if you didn't

089need it by now I used to say you didn't need it now there are exceptions of course kids need maybe you get two more kids in physics and you need some more books or something like that happens there's exceptions obviously but I call it Mission critical we got to start counting the money so Michelle and I and Dan are going to count the money as best we can by the end of the year before the end of the year and we and we haven't been here that makes any sense that all try to do so but what you got to do is you're also got to take a look at Staffing now your principal did an excellent job do telling about all things a great staff is doing but at the same time what I

090the question I'm going to have is how much of the staff came on board that we didn't have before in numbers FTE for federal funds that we would like to have but can we afford to have any longer so that's something going to have to take a look at that's terrible to say but and my daughter is a teacher so she tell me but the truth of it is we got to do it um we also want to know that you start looking for attrition to breakage so if Rick was working for you and then Rick leaves you know he retires uh he gets another job he gets hit by a fast moving truck whatever happens to Rick the old way looking at things was who are we going to get to replace Rick I

091think the new way of doing it is we're going to have to say do we need to replace Rick perhaps you don't need to replace Rick but you need something that Rick wasn't doing done so there is what they call attrition and breakage and then monitor scarce resources scarcity first I got to tell you something District Sur State can't find bus drivers they can't find maintenance mechanics they can't find business officials uh the superintendent's uh handout just came out last Friday there a page of superintendent openings you can't find school psychologist you can't find French teachers you can't find uh maintenance mechanics you can't find social workers a special ed teacher can't find duol certified foreign language teachers list goes on you're just not entering the field right now I think there's five people graduating

092from Brockport in the business head program that 20 years ago I taught in when we were graduating 30 at so keep in mind there's two messages there one is these are going to be hard to fill number two is you're going to be you have to be competitive to get them okay um cost escalations I already talked about uh escalations of long-term expenditures you have limitations on revenues I mentioned already and then we need to look at long range plan because I don't think the calary from the state is going to arrive anymore we might get a little help maybe this year in a couple things if they update the formula maybe some places might get help but the truth of it is uh stak's having an opral moment I call it you know you

093get a car you get a car you get a grant you get a grant money for this money for that not that that is bad I'm not criticizing it but what happens is their pie is only so big right like more pieces trying to help help more people I think good motive but I think it's going to be a problem we got a take your reserves your fund balances by the end of the year and into the future the loss of the co money is catastrophic I don't know if you noticed you've got millions of dollars in coy so it's it's going to be a problem uh State a you are State har as I pointed out when in on of the state a and I'm still wored about the zero Mission bus mandate which

094has not gone away uh I was hoping something would happen to alter that now many districts that have contract busing say has nothing to do with us we have contract busing uh uh that is not true at all I'm your contractor for busing let's pretend I I buy about three uh zero Mission buses and I don't use any of them in your school district I'm going to charge you for them anyway that's what's going to happen just keep that in mind oh and I got to have the charges and I got to have the infrastructure so I'm going to have to build that now if this does if this gets altered and go away a little bit or push down the line we might get some repri it's not that zero emissions is a bad

095idea it's just I don't know if anybody's got enough money I don't even think the state has enough money to pay the a uh we got to visit revisit Cal construction give replacement equipment and Technology we talked about and we're going to monitor the tax Gap and your appropriate fund balance so we've got a full plate to do we're hot on it right now we're digging through things we're trying to figure out how everything works in your District uh but I wanted you to know that um we're going to be as comprehensive as we can but we're not counting paper clips okay are there any questions I can answer for the board I don't have any any questions it's a lot to digest it is I do the report so so normally you cut off

096uh you know you cut off any purchase orders around April sometime no I I off DE yeah we doing that right now right yeah well I think you sure it's up to them what they do but okay if you really need it Mission critical got to have it for the kids got to have it in the program you buy it but the idea is see to me here's how it works a business off July one 60 million purchase work go out already then everything comes in over the summer mostly couple things Trail into the fall then we should be ready but if we don't want is people running around going jeez looks like I got 20 to this budget what could we buy that's what we want over not anybody would do that just say

097got to get a handle on the M make sense any other questions yeah just for the capital reserve for the technology does that include like data security or is that just hard wir in the resolution your bond Council would write the resolution okay we would work with the B counsel and we would be interviewing the district to find out what exactly you consider to be technology right now on the tab I have in our spreadsheet we're working on it includes all those things safety security it would be cameras security you know the blue lights whatever you want to call it it could be um motion detectors more sort of data security yes it can also be data security it could be programs it could be systems it can be wired drops it can be firmware

098Hardware software upgrades all that stuff and what would happen there just to answer your question is they would say we want create technology uh Reserve that would include such items as and we would list out a bunch of them to make sure you're covered okay in the resolution so the voters know what they're voting for okay anything thank you app okay um public recognition there's anybody in the audience that would like to address the board um now is the time um come up to the if you're allocating time to Dr Tims you have 37 seconds to do your BL analysis came on uh before we do though this is not my time limit I just want to recognize Mr Wickham This will be his last board meeting with him retiring at the end of the

099month uh first hire in 1993 I'm told a business teacher chaired the business department for number of years coach multiple sports sports teams throughout the years he's been behind the scenes with us I think since Co and does anything that is asked [Applause] all right update on blueprint jump to uh the update so Priority One U so if you recall Priority One has to do with providing students with individually academic challenging experience emphasize development of skills acquisition knowledge andin with the for graduate and New York standards so I did Identify some things I want to highlight tonight I will send the uh full summary to the board uh with other information as well so first and foremost Port graduate we spent time at our December uh DLT meeting District leadership team meeting uh to brainstorm

100this we'll continue to refine this and work with this uh to get this approved by the board over by the end of the year on what our Pro graduate will look like uh Partnerships so we've spent a lot of time working with Partnerships um this year uh one thing we are going to do have a one document with all our Community Partners what they've done for us whether be donation or resource uh other things I do want to highlight publicly is El the magnetics the Council of Industries um as well as Viking uh corated cardboard um we've had several meetings with them they uh we are actually El pitch to our uh our students at the high school to make a video for them for their website our students actually just kind of pitch back

101their proposal Miss Hayes this morning um and I guess the feedback was very very positive about that so that's us kind of branching out and using our Community Partners uh to enhance our experiences for our students uh also in the realm of of prity area one um is uh review current progress monitoring procedures provide professional development on best practices and create common guidelines so mtss has been receiving professional development on progress monitoring um I already consultant has been providing two rounds of of instructional coaching as well uh Dr Jen principal Trion have been meeting with our kindergarten teachers across the district to solicit feedback on current assessments progress monitoring systems so getting their input as to how to we move forward for the best for our students um and then in terms of our goal

102for Project based learning phenomenon based learning uh we've had three high schools uh science teachers and 10 professional rning on the new investigations uh for Science and then six of our high school teachers actually went to Regional training at Kingston High School for um for sign for the new investigations as well and our plan pilot is ongoing uh researching R revamping report cards grades 345 we're looking to have a a committee to begin looking at standards based report cards to extend for three grade 3 through five um and also greeing for Equity book study Mr L A book study last which was a big success and is doing Dr you want to hold questions or do it Bas on I was just curious through this why is it and why is it only great three

103through five so we've already done it K through two so it's so on the report just to be clear right it doesn't say reading viers have literacy standards and then if just child is progressing meeting or exceeding okay all right thank you um and then in terms of Vel in common language behavior management language between resorted practices we've had several uh resorted practice uh sessions in our conference days goal two was to increase family community engagement um one big thing that I heard from several community members was having parents be more aware at the secondary level of what their students are taking uh so we're going to have a meeting actually next week about uh reviewing how we can get parents to sign off on either courses that students identify that they want to take

104or their action schedules so we'll see how we can Implement that uh parent workshops kill had a survey go out you heard Mr TR explaining how he was going to have a survey go out his parents get feedback for that and then grade book uh what what will a grade book uh look like a common great book um so we do have a grade book committee that has met three times so far this year um the re researching the capacities of Campus um but just to kind of summarize that briefly right now and our student R can can tell you some teachers classroom some teachers share grades on campus some teachers use schoy right so how can we get everything in one spot so that parents kids can all know how they're doing at any

105moment in time within reason right it's not going to be instantaneous but within reason and just like our discussion the target for that is September 25 correct so online for next year yes so I'm hoping to get the report from the committee and ultimately be my decision to in September and then is the infinite C space where that will happen well that's part of the part of of the decision so infinite canas is our student management system right so that's where all theud information is contained whether your demographic stuff or schedule stuff and so forth um there are some benefits in and cons to using that versus Google Classroom um but from what I'm hearing from parents is they're really concerned about right how is my child doing not necessarily what does the assignment look

106like um so kind of two different things about the educational platform versus the rep so just so for clarity so everybody so as a district we already own in in the campus we use components of it we're not using the grade book today and that's one of the things they're evaluating we're not wiely use grade it's not our standard correct yes but all teachers have to put their grade in the quarterly grades because that's like our official documents so some teachers do not put every individual assignment into C they might just put at the end of the quarter A5 whereas other teachers my son has one teacher who puts all his assignments in there so I can see all the assignments um professional culture right so create Foster nursury superior quality professional learning T to

107all staff needed for Student Success uh research ways to implement instructional rounds learning walk Japanese learning studies this has been a big success so far this year um so we have done learning walks at the junior high level for engagement we've also done it for uh math in terms of um math practices sorry um we've also done at the elementary level for fourth grade and then just the other day uh director of special ed took around a state representative and went to C Cod talk classrooms um to there as well so this is a big shift ultimately if we break if one day we have teachers on those walks and have conversations afterwards and improve instruction all the way around research and develop a plan to incorporate more student voices to provide feedback in developing

108positive School culture uh students are we've got student councils in each one of our our buildings uh they're involved students are involved in the BLTs um we're also tasking uh students with certain things especially at the the junior high and senior high levels uh one of the big things has come up is uh using bathrooms for the bathroom purpose not for Vaping other things trying to start a campaign there get the message out right having students um be their best advocates for those stes of things uh lastly priority four is a stud studing experience we will create an environment where all students want to come to school and they feel welcome successful in the work recognize for their efforts and support all areas um so ensure all students are aware of opportunities available to them

109based in their interest so this has to do with our counselors pushing into grade levels for overviews giving them the highlights of where their choices lie and what what what is going on uh promote advertise courses offered are uh M Veil is is kind ofing the charge to updating our course catalog and making it more user friendly as to you know if I'm in nth grade what courses am I really can I take what are my options um we talked about developing with plan increase alumni presenters the current students um once again M Bale is going to be having a Q&A with with uh junior high students with our sixth grade students as they go to the junior high utilize faculty meetings for diversity Equity inclusion topics um we've had this throughout as you've heard

110about our engagement Continuum um and this rubbing off into the community it is nice one when my own children yell each other for for avoiding um research methods to measure student engagement obviously our Continuum and then create OPP for students to learn and teach from each other this could really be transformational and once again missale at the junior Senor high school with misso uh they have teachers in grades eight and grade seven who are planning on having their students present culminating presentations at the end of the year so uh they last year we had genius day at the at the end of the year led by Mr Pho same idea students presented their work to a group this is going to be a bigger uh spinoff of that I know that I spoke very fast

111is the is the course Cal is that something when we talk about parent signing off which I know came up this last one the last leadership um is that something that's going to be available to parents that they can look at the course catalog and sit with their their kids so the course catalog is available online so it's also a matter of us getting information out there as well kind of going through but then having it be in usable format it wasn't 47 seconds but okay board member remarks I'm not to M speak out um I think that um um we just spoke about Community engagement and we had community members who were here to speak tonight um I I think it's uh it's a consideration if community members want to speak with us want

112to speak want to address the board and we know that we have uh a lot of presentations set before them that I I I don't know whether we can take a vote whether we speak on it about moving the public comments up rather than make them sit to wait an hour and a half hour and 45 minutes only to leave and not engage with us I don't think that's a good way it's it's our agenda so we can we can talk about the agenda and move things around and okay and and we can change it every every month but the order is we decide we we come in and we can say wow I know there are 10 people here ra our hand say we have to make if we do it at a meeting

113we have to make a motion and move it around but I'm saying beforehand this structure proced for me this is procedural for me to know um because I did speak to that with public comment section before the elementary you know um presentation and I think it's a matter of if we want to do it every time or if we have honest I didn't think Mr Tim's thing I saw six pages I didn't think it was going to go that long he went into a level of detail um so but if it's something ongoing it's like I said it's our agenda we can move it around uh yes I just like to thank Mr Trant and uh Miss petet and all the students and thank you for hosting us and and certainly thank you everybody that

114sets up any of these rooms whether it's rard or or any of our other buildings that we go on tour uh it's a lot of of work right when you when you look at the number of people that are actually actually involved in the the time that we spend here so thank you for that um and just looking forward I you know we we talk about a lot of things you know all the time we talk about and Mr Tim even pointed out you know some of the uh uh the types of vacancies that you see in school system that uh that we're having trouble filling so when I look at our agenda um I I I really truly uh want to congratulate and thank all of those people that are are going to be

115approved to either work here for soy School District volunteer to help in our district in our district um and and certainly those retirees uh commend them for the time that they've spent with us um it's it's uh it's a nice feeling to know that uh that we still are you know a district that people want to to stay and work in and it's it's something worth noting uh when we look at uh all these these appointments um you know I was going to talk a little bit about some of the Rockefeller Institute recommendations and Mr Tim's kind of alluded to that I think think you know when we look at the The District budget calendar is going to begin uh technically has begun right with these conversations but I know next next February you know

116there's going to be an initial budget uh presented to the board and things like that um I just encourage everybody to try and work and develop as as much fluency as they can and pick up and follow along a lot of these topics because um uh we are in we are in the budget cycle at this point we are in the budget development season so uh while thinking about that I won't go on too much more about that uh good luck to all of our students that uh that will be taking region exams this January thank you hello okay uh I and I don't want to go on uh long either I just want to thank Mr Tron and uh his students uh for coming and doing such a wonderful presentation it's really nice to

117see um some of those students students who were just kindergarteners at Mount Maran uh that I worked with and now they are fifth and sixth graders um it's nice to see that they've grown and come uh become a part of this community um I also just want to thank um those uh people who are retiring and like Bill said coming on board um especially Miss Kendall who's in the audience who I've worked directly with and Mr Wickam who is always at everything thing and um does such a tremendous job so I just want to thank them and wish them uh all the happiness and healthiness that retirement brings um yeah I I want to thank the ricardi students that are not here but just for being brave and vulnerable and the 500 word essay reminded

118me of 500 word essay I had to write on why I should beet class started as 300 minute go 500 somehow um I also want to just sort of acknowledge the um teachers students and parents that the kids referenced as helping them when they talked about their challenges right so I think it's you know that it's Brave to stand up there and it's Brave to stand up there and say this is a challenge I had and I think that that's um that's great and that it's other people that help it um so I just wanted to of I think the daily interactions that we have with everybody those are the things that make the difference in children's learning and our own development and sort of to that end um this is an amazing group of

119people that we have up here and um I feel like partly because of the way our tables are sometimes set up um there's a sort of performative aspect to our board meetings but you know we are all volunteers here and this monthly board meeting is our opportunity to talk to one another So to that end I've talked to several board members about it and with Dan Jeffrey and so I invite everybody to come to our board meeting in February at the library where we may have a little bit of a different seating set up that I think will help us really feel like we're having a conversation together and that this is our meeting in public that it's not a public meeting and those are really two very different things and I think that we

120have gotten the board to a place where we can have these diffult and deep conversations and now we need to actually sort of manifest that physically so um I just invite everybody sort of the superpower I have is arranging Furniture um also to the end of um uh sort of increasing communication and conversation all the board members reive two invites today one is for office hours one are Virtual Office hours which will be on Thursday Tuesdays online from 7 to 8 um and will I will use Google meets for that you like very much um and then the other will be at Wednesdays for now um from 8:30 to 10 o' in the morning atos on partition Street if you want me to meet me anywhere else please let me know but sort of as

121the vice president my job is to help take the temperature of the board and to sort of stay connected so I want to take that seriously I started that in November but it was right for a lot of travel and a lot of other things so um I just want you available and happy to talk and about board stuff or just you know have a walk somewhere we don't have to sit and coffee pastri so we can take a walk um and then I am gonna take just this moment of time to close with Jimmy Carter's grandson Jason Carter's part of his eulogy um because I it made me Jimmy Carter was my first president and his commitment to service is what brings me here and most of what I do and clearly me cry

122um but he highlighted his grandfather's work been bringing cases of guinea worm disease from 3.5 million cases every year to only 14 um and what he noted is the disease is not eliminated with medicine it's not eliminated with technology it's eliminated by neighbors talking to Neighbors about how to collect water in the poorest and most marginalized V the world and those neighbors truly were my grandfather's partners for the past 40 years and demonstrated their own power to change their world he saw a small village as a place to find partnership and power and a place to carry out that commandment to love your neighbor as yourself essentially he eradicated a disease with love and respect Dr Tim's talked about a really challenging budget landscape that we have in front of us but we also have

123an amazing of people in this town and I just he waged peace with love and respect he led this nation with love and respect and I just wanted to offer those words to all of us to reflect on as we will to lead this district and then the Whitney modern museum is free for all people under 25 thanks to a gift from some know billionaire um and I really recommend that you go there's an amazing show for of Al Al's work until uh February um but there's also it's also free on second Sundays which is not a small thing because it cost $28 as an adult to go in there so if you want to go for free um amazing resources something for everyone outes beautiful Vision all right um I I I just have

124a couple of things and I I'll I'll be quick um one thank you to to Mr Tron um for for putting this on but in in relation to that and and also into relation to something that Dr hos was talking about about making it better uh you know just communication along the board um we we've had we've had a couple discussions and we realized that putting this on um for us is a lot of work it takes time out of your day it takes time your students are here late I know in granty Mor we had a an executive session beforehand and the the kids were there 8:30 n um and it's not very interactive it's it's kind of presentation wide so we're going to look at and and on how we um we have

125a we have a commitment of the board to visit each of the elementary schools there's nothing that says we have to have a meeting a board meeting um and so we're going to look at um some things where um we go and visit the schools um when the students are in session um and we can get to see a broader scope of kids it's more interactive we can see all the teachers um and there's some stuff we have to work through but we have an entire year to do that um but I think the idea of having forcing a meeting onto our elementary schools and having you guys have to PR prepare all this stuff is something we're going to look to move away from a little bit so that's number one number two I'm

126going to Echo something that um Mr uh Dr H talked about um and that is um Mr Wickham um congratulations uh 31 plus years with the district um there are too many stories of students um who have positive things to say to go over with them here um I I still talk to students that I coached 10 12 years ago that still mentioned things that Mr Wickham and his classes that he had um and I'm fortunate enough that my son Damian only got a few months of you but is in one of your last classes and there is probably not a you know two days in the week that go by where he doesn't come home and talk about something that happened in Mr Wickham's class um and for dny and to talk about all

127about anything a 15-year-old about what happened in school is a big deal so um and you know your impact not only in your teaching but you know your your support of our athletic programs uh you made wrestling a mustsee event here um if anybody has ever been to one of Mr willam's presentations of introducing his wrestlers is quite special um and you always stepped up on needed when the varsity when the school needed a varsity baseball coach um you were first in line to take that um and you just went and won a sectional title for us so um so thank you and and congratulations and uh you know on 31 years and and congratulations and enjoy your retirement um the last thing is uh different topic um and it's something that I was asked

128to address um so I will um we um based on an email uh that the Dr IG and the board got this week uh regarding uh immigrants and um undocumented um students um so this is we are um so we are not a political board um nor will we ever engage on either side of a political debate um so what does that mean what that means is if we have a student that is in our district and they meet the age and residency require um residency requirements as defined by law they are welcome in our schools and our and they will be taught by our district and our district will provide a safe learning environment for all students um in addition our Administration will follow the New York State Family Court act um fura and

129Dasa which deal with student information dissemination of student information and Pi um and that is that that's how we are going to approach that um and you know obviously as this um environment either moves or changes Dr ERS and Dr warbach will will follow guidance from the state education commission um but I know and I think I I I do know that um somebody who was here was speaking public and I apologize um for them not um for not being able to speak to us this was one of the topics um so I just felt um and was asked to address it um and give a uh a a couple of comments on so okay all right next Dr Roat the science of reading seven slides last one was only six there are probably 20

130hyperlinks to documents of Plus St Mr Wickham thank you so much comparatively to everybody else that worked with you the least amount of time but I have so enjoyed the way that we have collaborated particularly with Project based learning you were part of the first cohort here at in sties with Miss Hayes Mr Cooper m and Mr feto and every time I left our planning meetings I thought wow this is going to be incredible and you brought so much to the table with your enthusiasm creativity and really wanting to move the needle so that our students were really driving their learning so thank you so much I really appreciate you the S Central School District believes that literacy is a human right our students engage in multiple literacies to explore the world and themselves and

131connect with others to solve problems within and beyond our community literacy instruction in sties Embraces research and standards based instruction we are committed to providing diverse Innovative and joyful literacy experiences that prepare each student to be globally literate and reach 21st century success that is phos literacy that was created in 2021 22 Academic School year um by our teachers here in sties so this is a huge topic I've been given five minutes and we're going to begin the conversation so I invite you to think about this I invite you to ask me questions uh our principles are very well vered in this Dr Jen is uh Miss Churchill and I spent a lot of time up late talking about this as well so again this is the beginning what you have in front of you

132was uh I provided you hard copies of three literacy briefs the first one is what is the science of reading the second one is the myths because there are many myths so part of tonight is dispelling some of the MTH and how it relates to writing so those are yours the briefs are exactly what they say they're brief and they're concise so you could read them probably within 10 minutes all three so New York state has literacy initiatives right now and we know that literacy is the Cornerstone of academic and personal success so ni it has several literacy initiatives that align sence of reading so while is not telling us the very specific curricula that we need to use unlike other states in America uh they are providing us a lot of guidance um so

133Mr Tron Dr Jen and myself have attended some of the trainings at osis of unpacking the science of reading and then recently was new guidance actually it's not really that new it's from 2020 and they resurfaced it and it's the P3 instructional best practices here's what you need to know by September 1st in 2025 not that far away soty Central School District needs to attest to the commissioner of Education in New York state that we are adhering to the P3 instructional best practices so we have some work to do we are on our way but there are many things we need to continue to work to make sure that we are aligned with the science reading so I take it by you saying that if we had to do that today we could well I'm

134going to go through I'm going to answer that we can just pause because ways in which we have aligned ourselves in the past four years but we have a lot of work to do and it needs to be a priority this is our business teaching and learning and reading is our fundamental thing that we need to teach needs to be our top priority so what exactly is the science of reading it is a 50 plus years of meta studies it is a body of research of how children develop reading and writing and competences it reflects research in multiple Fields such as education psychology Linguistics Neuroscience sociology speech and language pathology implementation science and other fields and it integrates discoveries from across disciplines and creates a comprehensive understanding of the reading and writing process it is

135not a single approach and it's not a curriculum it can't teaching reading is probably one of the most complex things that we do in education and if our teachers are about my age when we were attending college and being trained to be a teacher we were not taught the science reading it wasn't taught to us so we're in a very vulnerable state here in America This research has surfaced we now know what is right and good practice and we need to change and change we know you keep coming back to that uh theory of Change by cter and how that can be vulnerable and scary particularly for our adults the students don't care the students are like yeah teach me they're but working with adults and changing practices is difficult this in which we need

136immense support it is a structured approach which I'm going to Define and it's a structured approach for all students all meaning all English language Learners all special education students all students who have dyslexia all means all and it's grounded by big six and we will Define that in a second it emphasizes culturally responsive environment that is Equitable for all and the science of reading should be used to inform what we teach and how we teach it all right so what exactly do they mean by structured reading and every single slide that is being used today is taken from and the documents they have provided and um everything that I've hyperlink for you reading is systematic and cumulative meaning that it's presented in terms of the skills that need to be taught and are introduced systematically

137in a logical sequence keep building and building and building it's explicit and direct the instruction is clear meaning we're not going to have the students make assumptions um in the past put a learning reader before a six-year-old there would be pictures and we would do queuing and what does the pictur say well we take away the pictures and we want the students to read now through explicit and direct teaching of bonic awareness and phics the science of reading is not just phonics it includes many other components but that is just an example it's also responsive and authentic and I this because there are multiple Pathways for our students we need to differentiate some of our students come to school already knowing how to read we need to meet them where they are and continue to

138challenge them then we have students uh who really struggle one of the best examples sometimes is by showing a non example right so with the science of reading particularly this is not the time that we want to do inquiry and phenomenon Bas learning this isn't the time where we want to say what do you notice what do you wonder that's perhaps we would ask that about a book for comprehension at the end but when we are teaching letter sounds lending that needs to be explicitly taught okay so the big and competencies that s has adopted um are all in the science of reading and it's oral language phological awareness which is how many sounds in a word so for example the word chop CH chop there's four letters but three sounds so if you have

139your students at home and you see them tapping that's we we want for them to beinging out those sounds and phonic is the matching of the sound to the letter so there's a difference there and then we have comprehension fluency and vocabulary so this is this gets to the point and it answers Mr Ria's question about if we had to answer this today where would we be so we've been on a journey so I want to take a few minutes just to explain this journey four years ago we had four different literacy programs two needed to immediately be implemented in the fall of 2021 I immediately was very distressed because there was not of commonality between these four programs so after researching and speaking to multiple experts in the field who have far more knowledge

140in literacy than I do it became apparent that you always come back to the New York State Ela standards and what we did the instructional coaches and I was we came up with some articulation and pieces that create connective tissue of these four different programs and they were the following in every agenda everything we did with the principles that year was we told the teachers we want small group differentiated instruction whole group instruction like read aloud with accountable talk not just let's feel cozy on the rug and read a nice little book but we're going to read I'm going to ask question we're going to engage with the text explicit and direct Bic awareness and phonics instruction independent reading with conferring because the research has stated that drop everything and read does not work particularly

141if you had me as a child um so conferring with the teacher conferring peerto peer and writing as a process not an assignment writing requires revision feedback from the teacher Rion again feedback from your peers revision again until you finally get your final revision so in 2021-22 those articulation of those lit literacy goals were so important for us um we created the philosophy of literacy we implemented inter reading inter reading is considered a science of reading program by the way the implemented literacy footprint that's where some of the questioning happens it is not considered a science of reading program we supplement it with the foundations program to teach ex indir phics andic awareness um we trained and launched an instructional coaching program um and also systematized how do we assess our kids in literacy and

142to uh we also launched the salty Central School District uh first PD catalog at this particular time we did not have any specialized reading teachers in the elementary school which assist this is our business uh we had no pacing guys and we had no curriculum maths so if somebody went out on medical there was no direction for them of what to do 20 22 to 23 uh we moved in the direction of hiring two specialized reading teachers uh train them in Wilson which is an incredible Dynamic program uh specifically addresses needs with students with dyslexia um we also at that time offered this training to any special ed teacher and any mtss teacher who would like training to be clear this training is very robust the teachers have to videotape themselves and they receive immediate

143feedback from a coach who is very direct with them so at this point in sties we have six teachers who have gone through the training uh We've trained all of our reading Specialists who we hire in this program and we are seeing a huge difference uh as you can see in the slide we've offered a plethora of all different types of Science of reading and structured literacy workshops in our superintendent conference stas in after school and we began creating p and guides again peace and guides is just calendaring this is what you need to do this month and this month curriculum mths are the skills the assessments and what you're doing 23 we got tighter with a vision um I just want to swing back that in 2022 that Dei belief statement just like our

144philosophy of literacy that really is another North Star for us just like our mission and vision and it influences our work in literacy so last year we did a lot of phenomenal work of moving towards the science of reading one of the biggest things that happened was we implemented in third grade not only did we do that but here at ricardi under principal Trion ricardi was a pilot school receiving um intense feedback and coaching from an expert in foundations while simultaneously training our instructional coach Anna Zan and then Anna trained everybody else all the other third grade teachers but here in rard uh Stephanie received intensive coing we also began looking at a structured literacy approach for writing and with the ELA and Humanities lead teachers we really began looking at writing what is our

145data we didn't have much for writing that tells us we need to do something and thinking about so what do we want to do which leads into this work we began doing Shifting the balance book studies um then with a community partner at the Orum there was this incredible documentary called the right to read so anyone who wanted to go see that for superintendent conference day we met at the Orum we watch the documentary which is about the science of reading and gu all the controversies may or may not have read in the newspaper um and also how going back to our philosophy of literacy literacy is a human right andent upon your ZIP code you need to still be receiving an equitable education in literacy and that documentary did address that we provided a

146panel discussion and we provided some roundt discussions the documentary because it it's very upsetting when you first watch it particularly if you're a teacher you want to do the right thing you think you've been doing the right thing and then all of a sudden you find out what guided reading is not what I'm supposed to be doing so for many Educators here in America this is a moment in time where people are pausing reflecting on their practice and this is a time where they need immense support with professional learning with coaching with financial supports as well last year I did mention this previously but The Curriculum maps that the kindergarten through third grade teachers did over the summer were incredible it's probably the best Curriculum maps I've seen they also began to Implement social studies

147and science into the maps which is critical because we want depth and Bre of academic vocabulary so which brings us to today today we have three reading specialist which is plus one in the secondary which is great we have launched the writing Revolution which while it's not the science of reading structured literacy practice because it is an explicit and direct way of teaching writing through strategies again we C bu the writing Revolution program curricula their strategies and our teachers are have really takeen to this um K through 12 we have done our learning walks and I'm so pleased to see all different types of strategies uh in our to date we have offered internally 59 structured literacy workshops so the people who have been facilitating that would be folks like everyone from Principal Tri myself

148and the four instructional coaches um we have 31 teachers who have officially finished the micr credential in the science of reading and Sunni new now these are thees are officially Anders that I mentioned and right now we have a book study happening in the writing Revolution Elementary and secondary and we have 39 teachers in r so that's on their own time they're very much invested and right now our peace and guides are up to date and we're moving along with curriculum so where do we go next last slide everyone's doing great everybody awake all right good okay so coming back to by September 1st 2025 we need to attest to the fact that we are aligned with uh the P3 instructional guide uh we're on our way what do we need to work on we

149need to work on that K kindergarten through second grade component we need to work on uh assessment structured assessment strategies for the teachers and principal Tron who has a lot of expertise in this and Dr Jen as well um are beginning to look at kindergarten you know there are other ways we can think about assessing kindergarteners um and we need to do that and we need for these literacy assessments to align with the set so you know as we're wrapping up we need to be vigilant about structured literacy practices and teachers receiving feedback from principls from coaches from and most importantly from each other Contin the writing Revolution work and you know we are at the beginning of budget season I understand the situation I think everybody in the room understands the situation after Dr

150Tim's report but this is our work if we're not doing the literacy work then why are we here and the budget is the statement of value so literacy has to be our top priority and what we value stud can be Aon of our thank you so this is just the beginning I just think it's also worth sh for that um we we interview candidates we are still getting candidates who graduate relatively recently we have no idea what the science of reading is so this is more than just uh public school it's also at the second higher education as well thank you Dr any questions thank you okay thank you moving on uh to our agenda portion um um is uh K which covers resignation leaves of absence and appointments second by Mr Mrs caler any

151discussion all those in favor so with this there are I would like to to make a note that there are two people in the audience who stuck it out with us um uh congratulations to Mr dear welcome aboard and Mr Cooper thank you for taking on uh M W's department chair [Applause] thank K here justed I AP congratulations on your retirement thank you thank you okay moving on to uh L the business office recommendations um we have the treasures report revenue and Appropriations internal claims audit tax refunds uh non-resident tuition rates um estimated and final um and then the Health and Welfare Services billing rates I have a motion so by Dr hos seconded by Miss Bosa any discussion I just um just wanted to just point out on the internal claim audit report um

152I mentioned a couple meetings ago that oural claims aors you know being more diligent um on her report to the board where a claim may have failed um her review and it's typically just um you know signatures not being on purchase orders or receiving reports and things of that nature um that she she flags as not being complete um and in her report she typically identifies the number of claims that have um failed her review but I've asked her in the future additional information to include the value of those claims that are failing as well it just gives us a little bit more context um of what she's revie so I just want to point that out to the board to the rest of the thank you okay any discussion else any other else all

153those in favor all right moving on to M which are board action items um we have some resolutions up front um and then some agreements with the Anderson Center for Autism that South School um new teacher position M with the STA and then um several policy um second readings yes okay so y so um we're going to pull number nine policy uh 5840 um out um for a discussion and then a roll call vote um so I'm going to table that one and I look for a motion [Music] on items the other items which are 1 through eight and 10 11 12 and 13 I have a motion for those Miss Bosa second by Mr Meyer any discussion on those all right all in favor okay number nine which is our um I just had

154a question our um on the safety plan it just references Anonymous reporting mechanism for school violence what is that so we have Anonymous alerts we people go online okay on the website yes okay and it goes to the building administrator sorry all right so um number nine is uh policy 5840 which is our artificial intelligence our second reading um so that's the one we're going to pull out um so um I'd like to hit every board member and get their thoughts and opinions and concerns so Mr Meer will'll start down with you um thank you um I appreciate the conversations that we had the policy meeting about this as well um and I guess based on the conversations had policy it seems like most on board with a lot of the AI um used by

155teachers faculty administrators um I don't think there's a concern about uh exposing some kids to AI in certain contexts but I do think AI is going to be a huge step I don't think anyone disagrees it's going to be revolutionary um and based on uh you know some review I did I saw she Research Center did a survey of 12 faculty members and public school teachers and in that survey 6% of the teachers thought that would be more benefit than a cost more than a harm and so I guess in that kind of context gave giv me pause to um to go forward with AI and I guess um you know I think looking at doing and hearing from faculty about what their needs are for having students use AI um I guess I'd be

156more comfortable if we had a little bit more time to uh to maybe put some some additional guidance or guard rails in it I guess my concern is that um the proposed policy sort of opens it up to um almost any type of use of AI in School situation and I guess my concern is that rather than opening the door fully and then trying to close it later on um that we maybe consider a little bit more of a narrower start to using AI in in the classroom and then grow the use of AI as as information and resources available rather than opening it and then trying to close that Barn in the year when we're having concerns about a thank you Ro sure um I guess just I'll be brief my perspective is that

157you know artificial intelligence has been around for a long time um you know from the earliest gr you know internet searches and such and it's been growing and growing and this generative AI you know is definitely taking us to another level um you know is only going to continue to grow um and you know my concerns you know are some would address within this policy and that you know we want to make sure that it's communicated that generative Ai and have biases and things of that nature but um I also then have to look you know my second perspective is that you I look at the company that I work for um it's a very very small company the own the 70 years old um and he's starting to embrace AI in you know you

158know D daing in chat gbt and on one of our last um te meetings um we were talking specifically about using AI to help capture um meeting notes you know being a participant in our meetings that and it's not and it summarizes everything and we produced Weekly News uh week the newsletter and using AI to um help generate those newsletters and you know he's taing our 26y old um assistant to research those AI abilities and components and you know then I kind of think about okay you know I have you two ends of the spectrum kind of embracing Ai and really the 26y old you know I look at what our business education and it's to prepare our students for higher education and the workplace and if this is going to be expectations in the

159workplace you know I do think that it's important that we probably do have some sort of um introduction to AI in the classroom and um amongst the facy of Staff um you to the other point being made a lot of policies that we do have kind of are made and then and addressed for 10 15 years you through our policy manual the last time they were updated is quite a long time so I hope that this policy is not stag and that we are constantly looking at it and especially as this technology um is very fluid and moving and that we do continue to revisit it and um making sure that we do have bar drills in place um because there are a lot of good about but there can be a lot of negative

160and I think that we need to be openminded about that and and really move with you know what's going on my perspective so my concern is who you know this is going to fall the responsibility for all of this is going to fall on our Educators um I feel like I'd like to see them give them more time more training before we implement the policy where we open this St specifically to students um and we also become responsible as a district to how that data is used um I think that in this policy we mention a lot of our concerns and they're made mention of but they're not addressed they um and again this is going to fall on teachers who are overwhelmed with all of their responsib existing responsibilities and for them to would

161like to see them have the time to learn these AI systems themselves and before they're going to be expected to guide students through appropriate usage and through the biases that the systems that are built into these systems we again we make mention of them but we don't have we don't have a plan for them again this will all fall on Educators to manage I also have concerns about the technical staff um that we would have to manage implementation help select platforms um you know and and we've handed every student a computer essentially um we become responsible for how they use those tools um we say we don't want them in the policy we say we don't want them to we don't want information to be shared personal information but students working on assignments only have

162their own home experien their own experiences in their own lives to draw from so AI systems thrive on data and I was looking for the the statistic but um data breaches hackers T are targeting to um targeting institutions to uh to pull data from education Falls thir health information and I think financial services are the top two but student data is what um hackers are looking to break into break into and obtain um and AI systems are going to be fed with student data um um and I think also if we don't have the technical staff or expertise you know I was discussing um with tech in my life about how do you limit these large language models you have to have a small language model that's taken outside and holds student data completely separately

163from from the rest of the um uh of the AI system and do we have the ability that up and we were just talking about money do we have the money to finance um a truly secure system for our students and their and their data so because of data concerns and because of the additional um burden I see this being on Educators um not in with this policy Dr hos yeah um I U concur with a lot of what has been said I've recently actually used CH GPT um to do you know some very very tiresome work that we've taken in many hours to do otherwise and it was amazing um and so I think AI is here it's I think it you know whether or not it's here to stay is one thing um

164I think generative AI I me when you do a Google search of using AI um I want to apologize really to the policy committee uh chair and committee and the board really for not paying closer attention to this policy over the past few months in the policy committee meetings several of which I missed um reading the policy and I actually met today with the nisba representive and I really encourage everybody to take them up I think you probably got pained or maybe I just because I'm technically a new board member um but you can reach out to nisba and they will talk to you about any of the resources they had I asked I said you know what's the deal with the AI policy and so we can actually request I mean we pay for

165eie one boes but we can each as individuals request one to two policies from Misa a month and they'll give us a sample policy and um so anyway so I um I think we could have a better policy I think we need to have a policy and I think we need to say okay when when are we going to have some policy I agree with Mike I think it could be more limited and include some more language around you know these are our concerns and these are our values um I listen to Dr Warra talking about literacy as our priority in the policy it says you know the district permits teachers to determine whether students in their class may use gen AI for assignments I think it's important to give teachers that autonomy but I

166think all teachers need to have notify students of how that is going to work for them whether or not they're permitting them to use AI um and then it says that the district Personnel no the district will provide training awareness and support to teachers in navigating the evolving use of generative AI in the classroom and I do think that needs to happen but we have limited resources and I would hate to have our resour spent in that kind of training when we need to invest in those interactions that really help kids navigate ideas and making things and doing things and interacting with others so I um yeah I mean I think we need to have a policy I think we could have a policy in place I'm not sure I want to um support this

167policy tonight and I apologize for it getting to a second read without more this conversation Mr W um yeah so I I don't think we're not bringing and and again I'm just trying to you know collect and and listen to some of my colleagues and some of their concerns we're not bringing AI to s's School District I think a couple people pointed out that that artificial intelligence has been here um for a pretty pretty long time um and and what this policy does is this policy acknowledges that first and foremost that artificial intelligence is here and we acknowledge that artificial intelligence is here and when we look at the the actual policy and we look in detail at what's included there's no question there's there are there are areas where some people might say well

168that's there that's a vaguery right that's too vague for me I don't understand we need to develop that out how's that going to be fleshed out what's that going to look like how is the teacher going to tell the kids how they're going to do that um you know these types of things but in essence that's essentially what policy is creating the opportunity for right so any time we do anything in the school system you you ultimately say at some point we have procedures for what we're going to do and when we're creating uh the the and getting together with our colleagues to develop those procedures we usually do so based upon a plan and you don't have procedures and you don't have a plan unless you have a policy that articulates the need for

169the plan it acknowledges the circumstance that exists it acknowledges that there's room for you know the growth the training and and the opportunity um but what it what it doesn't do is it doesn't Kick the Can down the road um and you know I'm not you know attempting to diminish anyone's opinion on this policy in particular um because the policy itself States really clearly that it sets guidelines for the fact that these things are going to be Revisited the risks and limitations are going to be Revisited um the how how the biases and how teachers teach the biases and all these different types of things so um you know I'm I'm not uh I'm not someone that thinks that you can policy and plan and procedure everything out of existence by any stretch of uh

170of the imagination uh but I do think for us to not acknowledge that AI is here and to not create some structure surrounding how we're going to proceed as a district moving forward um is providing no gu guidance and providing no guard else um and to a certain degree is is a little der in our responsibility um without this policy it is the wild west you don't have the opportunity to to create plans you don't have the opportunity to create procedures because people are doing this anyway students are doing this anyway and it's similar to you know one of the earlier conversations it's happening if we've got 200 different teachers using AI it's happening 200 different ways right so you have to have a starting point thousand M Journey starts with one step um so

171my feeling is that this is a needed policy it's like any other policy it's going to evolve as our information grows it's going to evolve as we engage with our instructors right that was mentioned quite a few times there's no question how the responsibility this is going to be on the teachers it's part of their work right we don't operate in isolation and teachers don't operate in isolation from from policy or or administrators so when we do have policy and we do have to develop plans and procedures absolutely it's going to involve work on the part of the teachers right and that's where this evolution is going to come from when we grow and learn together really as we're moving towards some really Uncharted Territory uh more important than ever that we at least begin

172to structure what this is going to look like so I think this is an important policy I don't think uh it's any more sacr San than any other policy in what I mean by that is this it can change and they can all change but to not have a policy on AI in 2024 or 2025 I think we are in right um yeah I I think that would be a derion of the board's responsibility disc okay um I have a lot of mixed feelings about this um I I feel like we definitely need to have a policy and like um Bill said you know we have to start somewhere um but I also feel as though I don't want to have a policy just to say we have a policy if we're going to have

173a policy that has to be the beginning of the work and we have to come up with a plan um of how we are going to support teachers in being able to communicate to our students exactly what the expectations are um and how we the board or or um you you know higher Administration is going to support our teachers so they can support their students it is going to be a lot of work but with anything and we are like like um Christine said you know we are AI is is the future you're going to find it in um uh employment when you leave um even before you leave High School I mean you go to McDonald's and they're you know using different things there um um so I do believe we need to have

174this policy but I would like to see what the plan is I or should I say I'm very interested and and um excited to see what the plan is going to be um so that we can support our teachers and our students moving forward all right I think we have everybody um so my my thought is I really quick I I think there's um there are some differences of what goes in a policy and then what is the responsibility of the administration which is the teacher roll out and how those are going to be communicated that stuff is not going to be in a policy ever um those are day-to-day operational things um that our Administration has to determine um I do I do understand the data components of it um and uh and where

175the security lies and what is needed from from a data perspective um I also think I you know I get the sense that there is a thought that this policy if we approve it okays AI or allows AI into the school um I can tell you AI is here there are students using it today um so if we think that there is you know because there's not a policy or if we don't we don't move forward with something or we raise some different concerns that there are no students using it um it is it is being used um and I think you know Dr warbach and I it's going probably on a year ago now we always said that you're you can't put a um a a policy around AI with walls in it that

176has everything defined in it um the technology is changing too fast the usage of it is changing too fast you have to create a policy that is going to have some some in it um and then you going to go and um you know as things evolve and the plan as as Mrs kelder said as the plan comes out you may have to change some of that so I I understand the concerns I do think I think one one thing that's not mentioning mentioned is I definitely think there's a different perspective and plan on AI in our elementary schools for elementary AG kids as there are for our secondary kids um I think I think you know when you get to 10th 11th and 12th to what M Miss belosa and and and Miss ker

177said about preparing our students that's a different perspective than allowing a third grader to go use AI on their own and write something so I think that's something that we really haven't discussed um you know I am if people need to you know feel like it needs to be discussed um I just think you know this is not a matter of determining whether AI is going to be allowed or not so all right um we I'm sorry we are going to take a roll call so just want to go by table just oh yeah absolutely that's okay uh just a couple things I want to maybe highlight or address uh one being the actual plan right it's going to depend on what the policy says so you know we can we have an idea of

178what we want to do but depending on what's actually approved we determine EXA the details of the for that in uh last year our Focus really has been on secondary for this so there has been professional development during conference days uh three say Elementary right what AI can do um and then we actually did have uh time for our secretary staff to go into the computer lab and experiment with AI particularly to help with lesson plan development so they were putting stuff we we we shared various ones from poster po that we got so they were using it uh themselves to see how that they could use it incorporate in their classrooms right with with the caveat that right just because it spits it out doesn't true right just it's on Facebook doesn't true so

179they're all responsible for um for verifying the information so uh for that um and just to kind of you know unfortunately this is going to fall on our Educators you know I think it is going to be a question of right when is AI useful right so is uh if one of my children is is researching something has to put the other representation is the research component of it more more import than using AI to put the information on the slides right so I would much rather have my child kind of spend that time in the research the ideas and then if you know the presentation part is secondary to me at that point right so it's also going back to the New York state standard saying what do our kids need to learn and

180then how do we get them there as it should be at at all times um and one thing I just want to go back and clarify too is so voting yes or no moves this if we vote no we're simply moving it back to first read um which means it's still going to sit within the policy committee and it get reviewed so I would ask that everyone including the public um we listening is that they come to the February policy committee meeting everyone is welcome um and come with ideas of what the policy should say things that you want in the policy right whether you're the public whether you're on this board whether you're a teacher um and not simply come with well we can either turn AI on turn AI off and that's our

181discussion but come with what we think the policy should say so it it can it can be discussed and we can move around okay it is now in Virginia's yes I yes no no yes Timothy well Michael Meer no yes oh I apologize okay moving on to our committee reports AUD committee your report so fa ities about the FL last week talked about the flood uh the application for the next Capital alley project atardi which will be on the exterior of the building uh for the ada8 comp ramps at the state level it got approv at the engineering department I believe is going through um the financial department next so hopefully we'll get that back soon so we go out to bit for that uh Capital project is overall uh wrapping up uh we are

182going to have a meeting to see um what addition work we are going to perform at Morris elementary school policy committee wall yeah we uh obviously talking about policy a little bit here today I think you you've got some updates as the types of things we've been talking about our next meeting is scheduled for February 4th at 5:30 all right public recognition is anybody still here no okay all right um do this um so initially the agenda had a um an executive session having to do with um hiring appointments and uh collective bargaining uh at this particular time I don't have any updates um so unless there is something else that the board would like to to bring up could be a motion to am okay so um anybody a motion to uh eliminate the

183executive session second any discussion all those in favor all right motion to adjourn wow Dr Austin congratulations you [Music] have e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.