001e e okay yeah we just got get we get four you ready okay uh welcome back everyone uh sorry for the change of venue but um uh the Acoustics in the uh old junior high are difficult for us to hear the community and also BR of talk and it was also freezing up front of that thing so that's all we moved over here so I appreciate you coming over um the first item I have on the agenda is correspondence uh we received an email regarding uh the railway fencing and also we received one email uh in favor of armu guards and one against as well okay and then I turn it over to the superintendent schools Dr Paris good evening everyone and thank you for joining us here in part two of the meeting this
002is our business portion of the meeting I just want to take one more moment to congratulate all of our athletes and our students who uh were just recognized and to Dr Cox and his team for uh and to miss mackus for helping get the certificates out in an orderly fashion so we could uh have the kids celebrate in a timely manner so thank you to the kids their parents and all their students um thank you for coming tonight and for joining us online uh so we're going to do a little around the district just kind of celebrate a couple of items that happened throughout the district and then we're going to have two reports uh one is going to be a report on the findings and the data that was presented to the board ofed
003from the security Forum night many of you who are in the audience um did participate and we want to show you that data that data in addition to this presentation will be available on our website in full form so you can read all the feedback directly yourself uh but we've kind of summarized uh for the board and the board also had the entire data sheet as well and then we're going to hear from covert security I sent an email out earlier in the week announcing that we will be contracting with covert security to um administer the uh head of security and to help be a team with us to um to ensure that our security programs are up to to to Snuff and and adjusting with the times that we're in I want to make
004a comment though that's really important I'm really glad we have a lot of our guards here tonight and that is that the feedback from the parents from our teachers was exactly what we expected in terms of our guards which is that they are fantastic they care about our kids they know our families and they do their jobs really well and so I just want to thank those [Applause] guards further um no matter what information I put out I've also learned that it can become anything and something else other than what I put out uh you know after I put it out so if I say we're Contracting with cover security to uh take on the head of security position and manage our security program uh that could turn into a whole bunch of things online
005and in rumor Mills so I want to make it abundantly clear that this board of education and myself and our entire Administration fully support our current guards that they are our guards they are part of our family and they are not going anywhere cover is simply taking on the management of our program so I want to make that abundantly [Applause] clear okay so um moving along just a couple of items and of course my glasses last week they broke this week they missing all right um so this is just some pictures from uh Cherry Avenue School students in Mrs Gallow Miss constant constantatos and Miss Rita's classes took part in an inqu injury prevention program organized by Sony Brooks pediatric Trauma Center during this interactive session important topics such as car safety passenger safety and
006the proper use of helmets were taught through roleplay and demonstrations the presentation culminated with a crowd favorite the teddy clinic in this Hands-On activity children were brought their beloved stuff animals from home and took on the role of doctors and nurses to treat their injured companions with care and affection they treated their stuffed friends using Band-Aids splints gauze and of course an abundance of hugs so here we have even at the very earliest level of Education talking about important life skills for our students so congratulations to our Cherry Avenue kindergarten [Applause] group at the high school students part participated in the New York State regional trade show on Wednesday January 8th virtual Enterprises International students that's a class we have at the high school that simulates like running your own business um participated in the
007New York State regional trade show at Long Island University post both firms set up trade show booths to display and sell their products to customers from across New York State students took part in various competitions including a business plan competition website competition Booth design competition newsletter competition and a sales pitch competition one of sail's firms that short toore earned a silver award in the newsletter competition both students from both teams had a fantastic time gaining valuable experience while presenting their business plans to judges and again I just want to say this is an amazing course taught by a wonderful business teacher uh that really prepares kids for what life would be like if you were working in the business world and I just want to compliment this program and the work that these students do
008at the high school uh Mrs long gabo and Mrs Barrack's classes work together at least once a month to study learn about many of the upcoming holidays and events that are important to our country and the world uh they have studied the election Hanukkah and recently created a mural of Martin Luther King Jr after spending time exploring the values of equity kindness Justice and Justice classes were guided to complete a mural that is displayed in the hallway between the rooms so not only integrating art we're also integrating social studies and learning about important events in our in our culture and in our Liv so congratulations to our chair Avenue students and and um all County selections SCA congratulations to the pictur nth grade and 10th grade students who are selected for the suffi county music
009educators Awards All County ensembles we have a number of students every year who are uh selected for this uh we continue to have great outcomes not only Athletics as you saw tonight across the street but also in the Arts and in the music and we want to continue to support those great Endeavors as we move forward in our school year so congratulations to our music program as well I want to congratulate our Middle School uh in the last week they had several concerts there were three different concerts at the middle school all just absolutely awesome to see the growth from elementary school to Middle School progressing towards high school so I want to compliment the teachers and staff of the middle school as well as the students in the orchestra the chorus and the band
010at the saille middle school so let's give them a round of [Applause] applause and finally I had the real pleasure of attending on Saturday The Outsiders at the high school uh the the students in this group did an absolutely phenomenal job last time I went to the play there it was a comedy and I was laughing the whole time this time and I know the story so I like I expected I know the story of The Outsiders I read it when I was in ninth grade just like all of us did I you know saw the movie In 1980 something and I just know the story but when these kids performed it they did such an amazing job I was actually like tearing up you know because it's a sad story obviously at the end
011but uh they they were unbelievable and I just want to compliment the the the entire cast The Ensemble they share roles and they and they do a great job and also uh Doug the director uh and the kids who did lighting and sound like they all have a great learning experience and and it was really just a phenomenal play so I just want to congratulate the high school as well okay so um now we're gonna move on to the security Forum data review and we're going to have miss deola our assistant superintendent for instruction uh who was very helpful with her team of just taking the data and analyzing it and kind of putting it into a um digestible bites so she's going to share with you the um basic um I have this the
012thing I'll pass it to you the basic findings then you can talk about the findings as a board discuss that as as you would like then we're going to have covert security do a presentation on what does it mean if there our management company that's going to be working with us for management and then you can ask questions about that and then we have to have a discussion about how we want to proceed with additional security measures as a board of education and as a school community and um so that's kind of where we're at and I'm going to turn it over to miss could you de could you pass that down okay okay I don't think it's maybe it's not on hold on a second it has a grand symbol if it's on thanks
013thats okay thanks um so um on January 7th the community came together to um listen to a presentation about the current format of our security program um and then they had the opportunity to break into focus groups to discuss um the same set of questions across every group and give their feedback their thoughts their insights their concerns their questions um and the there were 18 groups uh and we collected largely qualitative data uh and so as a result the facilitators of every group diligently uh wrote down everything that they were hearing and what we did um we have a shared data expert from Bose's uh and I um coded all of the feedback uh so that we could try to quantify it and and look for Trends and patterns and be able to present it
014back to everyone so that's that's what I'll be sharing back tonight is just the uh results of the conversations that we had um so overall 144 people registered ahead of time and um it was a freezing night uh so uh in the end we had 100 people in the audience and uh 96 of those people stayed for focus groups and I thought it'd be very interesting to represent uh in that sort of donut graph is um the different school buildings and they're I mean virtually evenly distributed across the five school buildings in our district uh so across the district people are interested concerned and wish to participate um and that's what we were trying to illustrate there uh so I'm going to go through there were five questions that the focus group facilitators asked at
015their tables and word for word these were the questions um and so I just tried to highlight the main idea of the question the question number one was really focused on what is the district doing well um so I know this is very hard to see there's a lot uh here we go okay so um what we tried to do was take the conversations and break it into themes so the major themes we found that people wanted to discuss that we were doing well were buildings and grounds and there some uh subcategories there uh multiple mentions for man traps and swipe cards um people overwhelmingly wanted to and just to Echo what Dr Ferris was saying wanted to discuss the guards our guard staff is wonderful um they have a rapport with the community um
016our security is well organized and adequate people were saying um and that their retired law enforcement meant a lot to a lot of people um our protocols people were complimenting that there are trainings and drills and there uh there are guards that uh walk the perimeter and they do appreciate some of our arrival and dismissal protocols um there were some uh complements on the technology such as the use of the Rave app um and we have also just the Staffing and the training the number of security guards that was mentioned as well I just want to reh highlight if you go back to that graph I know it's hard to see but the purple lines in that middle section are the number of comments positive about the guards so again I want to reemphasize the
017happiness that our community has with the quality and the people who are our guards and it's important to just make sure that that line is the largest line in the entire graph yeah and um and what you'll see next uh the the pattern that we tried to follow was to try to Quant to try to capture and quantify it but then extract um specific comments that may be represented um a poignant uh um comment or something that kept on coming up over and over again so just some of the comments that we pulled um I believe the buildings are secure and I really appreciate that I'm impressed with how seriously the district is taking this issue security guards in my building are very strict and they follow protocols gates are locked guards walk the perimeter
018they take it seriously uh classroom number signage sticks out from the doors um and they're easy to see and that's a comment on Lincoln Avenue they have actual signs that um protrude from the side from the walls for each classroom um like a street sign sort of uh prevented if we're look working with the community in the fifth Precinct um question number two areas of improvement um so there was a a a really robust conversation around that um again it's it's hard to read uh we tried our best to capture everything so I'll I'll just um uh specify uh security within the building is this top area uh here the the blue Shades and overwhelmingly uh window security was something that uh people wanted to talk about um and uh right behind that is building
019entry and exit procedures and that could be anything from during the day um students uh parents coming in uh just the general procedures to enter and exit buildings people wanted to discuss um doors doors in classrooms doors to the outside of the buildings um a number of comments on after hour security so when our programs continue um or scope programs uh which reside in the buildings there were some well articulated concerns about after hour security um uh the next category we um really wanted to highlight that we were hearing about was security outside of the building um so that's just general outdoor security per monitoring came up um and then there were um multiple comments about entry and exit off the school grounds itself um there were comments um ideas for how to make that
020an even safer process arrival and dismissal um looking for improvements in areas of technology and communication regarding enhancement of our Equipment Technology improved Communications um and just Mak making sure practices are consistent across the district um areas of improvement included um multiple um recommendations for staff training uh an increase in staff with some requests um and then there were some discussion around uh preventative measures that links back to mental health which was a question onto itself and we'll get to that in a few minutes um so some comments uh for areas Improvement so a lot of discussion on air conditions um and then some some ideas that were raise shatterproof window film um and clearer room number displays for emergency um responders um improve protocols for visitor check-in especially at large events um all of
021our schools welcome families in for special events and that's something we celebrate and is there a way to make those events even more tight um single point of entry to buildings this was a suggestion uh tighten protocol for parent identification especially when they're picking up a student procedures for office pickup um exploring consequences for repeatedly propping open doors if that's ever an issue in a building um how how are we addressing that there's um there are specific systems uh it was the door a jar system came up more than once um and then the procedures like I said before about scope are they following the same protocols that we expect during the day um and if not then can we ensure that they do security outside of the buildings um a comment came up multiple
022times is due to the timing of the day that recesses in session uh at the same time upk pickup happens uh and people were noticing opportunities to breach um you know parents can access the recess field where our kids are uh playing um anyone can come to outdoor events such as field day that's something we want to take a closer look at um people were suggesting a single point of entry to campus um including privacy fencing guard booths um um discussions about Gates um you know maintaining the vigilance about locking the gates perimeter monitoring and there uh were some comments about the oversight of arrival and dismissal um details about uh doors being left a jar um and you know just a tight practice is about releasing to students um many of which we know
023uh are our buildings are already very uh cautious and Vigilant about and it's always good to um have discussions to be reminded um other areas of improvement technology and communication cameras um can our cameras have Cent sensors are we ensuring complete coverage uh can we look into better cell service will the Rave app work even if there's poor Wi-Fi can we enhance commun communication about um security protocols just in general with the public uh can we continue increase or you know if in the event that we're not doing enough of active shooter or stop the bleed training um buildings need better cell service this came up and um there were some uh comments to even more widely equipped buildings uh with supplies in different various locations uh aeds Outdoors um if if they don't already
024exist question number three uh was a specific question about um arm perimeter guards which was the question that Drew people uh together for this event in the first place and and it was really focused on the concept of armed perimeter guards um and so with that in mind people were first asked um or at the end of the event actually to ask um whether they were for or against are you know just straight up and there was a tally that was taken at each table um and uh I just want to note that the unsure there there were some people who um arrived wondering if there is another option Beyond uh armed perimeter guards um and they were curious to discuss that so they weren't sure whether they how they felt about perimeter guards specifically
025but maybe some other version of security uh so that's what the unsure um uh most likely represented um with regards to Perimeter guards um uh we have um um some comments in favor some comments and gets in some general um in some general comments and I'll just make it um a little more clear um why would people be in favor of armed perimeter guards uh overwhelmingly this bar on the top is faster response time right after that it's it's an added layer of protection and comfort um people were just in favor in general this is a necessary solution um often times people were mentioning that it's a deterrent um there were some comments that it would be helpful um for students to be aware of it and protecting students is worth the cost um people
026who were not for armed perimeter guards the top bar questions their effectiveness they brought up the costs to the community um they brought up that uh the risks that um it may create and their concerns that guns um may bring violence to buildings um people asked to consider other measures instead um uh what some Viewpoint that was shared um uh multiple times was that armed guards they were concerned would increase student anxiety or change uh the culture um then some comments and questions were regarding uh they would just like more detail more research um research grounding our decision um they have questions um some people wanted to discuss arming and empowering in the existing guards or the inside guards um they wanted to add that to the discussion they knew the discussion was about perimeter
027guards but they wanted to uh expand the discussion to um uh inside um some people almost the same amount of people were saying they are are okay with perimeter guards but opposed to Armed inside guards so that conversation I think is worth uh more of an exploration based on this data um and then um just just General improve interest in improving other measures of security comments and support armed guards perimeter inside they'll know the building they could respond quickly um schools without guards are a Target uh I am very comfortable with armed perimeter but not armed inside these are comments from the community uh some this came up multiple times I felt the need to specify that it was five times five different people said I'm working in a district with armed guards and I
028feel safe there um a practice that is employed else where um that some districts rotate who is armed and nobody knows who it is um and someone asked if is there research to not support this uh comments and opposition uh this provides a false sense of security the threat can come from inside or outside data shows High number of school shootings that had armed guards present um uh community members saying money should be spent on other ways to improve security that they don't feel the advantages outweigh the costs concerned about human error guns getting into the wrong hands um the role of guns should remain with the police uh it would disrupt our culture and the schools should not need this level of protection these are comments that came up um so other comments would
029a perimeter guard be effective for a student who has brought the gun into the school um what would be a better deterrent the question came up marked or unmarked they wanted to discuss um what would the expectations be of perimeter guards that came up as a question uh another question what kind of qualifications training type of firearm communication between the perimeter guards and the building people were really looking to deeply explore the details of this and have the methodical conversation that it deserves um will there be further discussion if a different version of this plan um is considered such as armed guards uh being inside um and should uh this should be a research-based decision and a detailed plan uh question number for regarded mental health um and the it's a two-part question on suggestions
030uh on Mental Health initiatives and additional questions and um Miss mackas had given um a a really well-rounded presentation on everything that we have available to us in our district So based on that uh people were able to reflect and comment further um so I think it Bears mentioning that the first and most overwhelming um response to suggestions to our mental health program were simply compliments to the program um and and I think that it speaks to the um the the richness and the variety of ways that we work with our students um other questions and suggestions that came up revolved around um wanting to clarify the role of PPS emphasis on Staffing stigma um trust confidential it um you know parents rais questions about cyber builing and social media um student interactions and inclusivity
031promoting connection um and communication so you know there were fewer and fewer comments about different categories but they in included instruction curriculum uh transitions to buildings uh as well was an interesting one um comments a lot is being done my child uses the strategies she learns so it's a valuable um asset to our our programming strides connected community events Color Run Carnival and specifically uh mentioned multiple times it was a great idea to bring on PM Pediatrics um good communication well staffed a commendation to miss Maas um Frost Valley uh is essential for seal uh a comment to please continue providing parent education and continue to normalize the conversations that surround mental health and that can help reduce stigma uh some students worry about confidentiality when it's time to speak to an adult um and
032the question comes up how are we being more inclusive especially for students at risk um peer-to-peer restorative justice and mediation were important topics to people uh students should be reminded that their confidentiality will be protected this came up as something that was important what is the counselor role in Seal learning and the suggestion came up to bring on a K5 counselor it's important to focus on the negative effects of social media um phone other Tech that's harming this generation um and that's a really important topic right now uh cyber bullying we do a good job teaching about it h but when an issue arises um a comment was we want some better follow through um make and share plan to better identify atrisk students uh and uh and speak with our students more even more
033than we already do about following um their instincts if there's a threat um comments about the transition between Elementary and Middle School it's traditionally a really hard time for kids uh and there was a call for even more help to navigate those years and um how do we support mental students mental health after they leave are we following them or there programs that you can access even after you graduate questions that came up if kids are bullied how are they being supported um should mental health be a part of this forum um is it what are we overstepping is this what parents should be teaching at home um do we know if Mental Health Services result in fewer fights issues in school refusal so looking for data um do students know where they can go
034in a crisis and is the anonymity upheld and do students know it finally anything else that you want to share so mostly that revolved around people wanted more clarity on current protocols um a a desire to strengthen our current protocols and then there was a large discussion about what's going to be the methodology for decision- making on this topic and um considerations that people wanted to keep us in mind um for proposing a plan there were some compliments there were some concerns so around policy do teachers and guards have a say um can they comment uh anonymously if they wish uh the armed guard petition was brought to light but it seems like other avenues weren't explored uh someone commented that they would like to see this um uh done as a community decision uh
035potentially a vote um we someone wanted to clarify um whether when the perimeter guard would enter um and would that individual intervene if the threat was from inside um other avenues that came up dedicated SRO other tools such as a taser V they wanted to know if the vestibules were bulletproof um of policy should the policy be um it should be focused on how can we delay danger by time improving current protocols can we invite um the law enforcement for drills and familiarize them even more with our locations um reinforcing with students to not let people in uh they just want more detail on current uh procedures unless it's confidential uh people are very interested in what our guards are doing um and how do we monitor um one question that came up was the
036monitoring of students who have returned from suspension uh if the suspension was for making threats um pre-screening list for opener special events that came up um they would like to hear from families who have been affected by school shootings um and a discussion about um you know how parents can join the Safety Committee and finally uh General comments small groups were a really good format for this conversation um despite that uh the comment there came up that some people even still didn't feel comfortable sharing because they were um uh they felt that they were at risk of being ostracized by louder voices um that comments that it would is good to be proactive uh more communication is good in general but can we streamline it find a way to prioritize notices um overc communicate don't
037keep us wandering uh try to avoid the chatter and um essentially in this comment I think just summed up the whole reason that everyone came together which is we're just concerned for everyone in the buildings staff and students alike and I believe that is the end this yeah I just want to take a moment um you know a lot of people asked us you know what was the purpose of the Forum are we really caring about what people have to say what are we going to do with the information and I hope this illustrates that we are taking this very seriously we care very much how our community feels the board cares very much about what the community thinks and I want to compliment Amy who is our assistant superintendent for curriculum she's not security
038expert but she is an expert in analyzing data so usually just so you should feel better about this she works with teachers on Ela data math data and designing curriculum In This Very methodical manner we apply the same concept to analyzing this data so I want to thank you for presenting and then open it up to questions from the board of education but this basically summarizes the larger packet you were given you have all the raw data and again for the community this is all going to be posted on our website with the raw data so that people can see it is exactly what it is I'd be happy to begin yeah um so first of all that's great data I just want to sorry just one General comment uh because we said it uh
039at our last meeting uh just to repeat it for all the board members the experience was was really positive for us to be able to have direct communication with individuals from the community and uh everybody was uh polite and and it was a very productive evening so um we really appreciate that and thanks again um yeah so it's great data for how those who came out feel so we thank those of you who did come out and share that I'd like to speak from firsthand experience um having walked the halls of the high school for over 30 years I've worked with many of our security guards and I can attest to the two which were the most positive responses of security as well organized and adequate and the guard student report they have a beautiful
040respectful Report with our students for those of you who don't know I can attest to that um and also kudos to Mrs Maas as I can attest to all of her initiatives and how beneficial it is for our students thanks thank you any other questions or comments I just want to make my only comment is our security guards to get into our buildings is not easy our will say for myself which most people know me they ask for my ID they won't let me through the doors unless I give them my ID and I think that's commendable so I want to thank our security guards for even people you know you never know what's going to happen show your IDE thank you um I'd like to make a comment first of all Amy thank you
041so much that was a huge undertaking um it was very well organized and I think it um gave everyone here and everyone at home a really good uh feeling of how the night uh unfolded so thank you for that um I'm I'm very proud of our community um these comments and and this data really spanned a huge um it was it was a large span of of information uh from all areas um the questions are amazing um the comments are insightful I I don't really have a question because I did I was able to go over it and I and I attended I was in one of the groups but I would just like to I really just want to say thank you to the parents for being so insightful um and really like I
042had a small group I know we talked about this last week but um I just just keep up the good work I I I can't believe like how great everyone was uh had such great comments and really specific like the things about um coming at the same uh recess at the same time as prek and uh the doors being propped and just like such specific information inside the building doors being propped inside the building things like that uh it's just very helpful especially for us we're not in the buildings as much I have older children I'm not in the elementaries anymore but I I really just wanted to say thank you to the community because this is very insightful for us so thank you I just um Echo the sentiments about the night I do
043think though um one of the things that we can can do is uh and we always tell our kids and we always you know try to preach this lesson like you control the things that you can control and so right now while we discuss this and and this is in limbo and we're figuring out what's the best thing to do for the for the district let's try to get better at the things that we know that we can get better at um and the one thing that I saw up there um is consistency and continuity across buildings um I think that you know all three of the elementary schools need to be on the same page so I I know I referenced this at the last meeting for example um one of the ladies at
044my table had an issue with scope uh early morning program whereas at and whereas at Sunrise uh they're very strict and and so I think you know some people had issues with chalk doors some schools were like wow I never even thought about that so I think consistency across the buildings is one thing that we can control that's within our control now I think communication has to be better um us as a district our communication has to be clear and concise I actually loved um I missed it the first time I that when Amy sent this but the color-coded priority notices I think is a great idea uh because it will immediately let the parent know when they see that notice that okay this is this level of seriousness um and so I I think
045one of the things that came out of this was um you know we're we're not all knowing and we're not all encompassing as a board we're just seven community members who are just trying to do the best that we can and and when we take uh comments from the rest of the the community uh it really is eye openening when you see different perspectives and and different ideas that that people come up with so um for example I know I brought it up last time too but the I believe it was Miss Corwin uh brought up hey we're gon to be saving money uh with solar panels we could maybe take some of that money and that could defer some of the costs like those are things that I had never thought of we had
046never brought up in here so I think things like that are important and I also love the comment where someone thought that it would be a good idea to do these types of things more often because we get to hear like these other ideas and you know like Sab is a great place and the town is filled with highly intelligent motivated people who care about the town and care about the kids and um you know it doesn't always have to be on our shoulders we can take the these ideas from from the community and and we can do great things with them I think it makes the Community member feel like they're listened to and that they're a part of the process it helps us get a broader perspective um and I I just think
047you know I think that's something that we can do better just for clarity it's not the first time that we've done this type of thing we've done it with uh Bond projects as well you know that we uh create committees and and groups and have committee involvement is a best practice though Amy I want to thank you as well this was obviously a huge undertaking and really really helpful um I I know we all had Separate Tables but I feel like this reflected my table like I'm like I feel like you only looked at my data all your TBL only 12 um but I I really feel like it totally was encompassed the conversation and kind of some of the things that people have already said but I I think what it highlights is some
048people walked in with an all or nothing it's this or nothing and it think that this really highlights that security is a much bigger conversation and that there's many aspects to look at and um that I think it led to more questions I think there's a lot of questions that still are not answered that we need to really focus on answering can I just add something you're making me think of a comment that I saw and that um I can't believe didn't make it to the um slide someone said um as a result of this conversation I came in thinking one way but as a result of this conversation I feel like I might be changing my mind and they didn't say from what to what but I thought wow the power of having a
049a conversation at a table um hi one thing I think it's important to point out was um our children go to schools like these are our kids too I have a daughter in the high school so this isn't just a topic you know what I mean um I think from my part um I'm a lifelong School administrator um when I was in Connect quat schools we actually had it plann threat they were in step three of a six-step process to commit an act of mass harm the student uh was then psychiatrically evaluated did not return to the school but then had another plan and end up serving eight years in prison of which they're still serving this is not just a topic um I I'm very grateful to the community for having this kind of
050thoughtful discussion about it um this is the stuff that keeps me up at night working in schools and having kids um but I also think that I'm really proud of the community uh because of the way we're discussing it the kind of conversations that we all saw in our groups you know I have an A nasso County cop who's dir decorated for Valor uh and you know he's really honest talking about how brutal that experience was and you know but when we talked about mental health um which is really the cause of it said look I don't have any answers I don't know kids weren't like this I don't really know how this fits into it um yeah I think for me what I do think about is that I've made this part of my
051life's work um I teach a threat assessment course because I think the way to deal with this is to have the kind of relationships you have with your kids and teachers have with their kids because kids ultimately if they trust us we'll tell us what's going on I'm just incredibly impressed and I'm just very grateful that this is such a priority in the school um because I think in Sable sometimes we are very proud of and we have more parades than anybody in America but sometimes it makes it hard for us to look critically and thoughtfully uh at ways that we can improve and make our schools safe so I'm just really grateful uh for the communities handled this this has been our chapter but a really instructive one for all of us thank you
052yeah I just want to that was well said I almost didn't want to say this but I I just um one of the things that I thought was very interesting up there that I would love to explore as a board in a district would be like helping of the alumni so be being like maybe the district you know we talk about you know we heard we just heard it all now how like we're family and the football team and the girls volleyball team and we told talk about all that that that family stuff and it's you know the friendliest town in America and then and we talk about all these positives that we are and maybe we should like look into further like how can we help these kids that maybe go to school and
053are struggling in their first year of college or that didn't go to college and and now are in the workplace and you know that's a huge transition from when you're an 18year old high school student to now you're a 19yearold you know in in the workforce and you know have different sort of priorities like that was a comment from the community but that's something that I think we we might be willing we we should be willing to look into um to be a place like a central place where these these kids because let's face it they're they're still kids um can come back and and have like a safe place to you know talk or somebody to talk to it knows uh I think a perfect person to talk to somebody about that is also
054the one that was just at our at the awards Andrew cendo right because it's a townwide topic yeah you might be right yeah yeah I think it's I think it's worth a like bringing to her absolutely okay um so NE uh next steps then right so what what I'd like to kind of transition to because uh you spoke to this study and then I want to talk about covert and I want to let them present and then I want to talk about next steps but I think it's important to note uh the question may be like why did we go to covert um and why did we do it immediately um one it was not a smokes screen or a bait and switch to try to get out of a conversation about the armed perimeter
055guards when you look at this data there are things you cannot look away from which are well beyond perimeter guards but inclusive of that conversation um in schools and for 30 years you know we school systems have people who are experts in fields Amy deola is our instructional expert she works with curriculum and she's Dynamite with it uh jayen mackus is our PPS director and she works withal and she works with uh PPS support for students and she's excellent at it and she's our expert in house we have a director of special education who's an expert in special education we have a budget person who's an expert in finance and as I'm looking at these issues I recognize that there is no one here including myself who is an expert in security for law enforcement
056or ensuring that we have a balance of security for kids um in a school setting we're the expert for kids but we need somebody who can help guide us through all of this and uh when talking to covert um investigations and they're going to present to us now and this is the transition to that presentation it was abundantly clear to me and to the Board of Education when we discussed it that we need that arm as part of our leadership team making decisions and supporting us in analyzing uh analytics uh looking at data looking at this and saying what kind of systems do we need in place and working with our very very talented guard staff uh to help support them in having what they need and asking them they need to be the most
057effective guard staff that they can be so um that's the reason for it and nothing else additionally um you know they're going to help manage our security as a firm and give us advice and also uh structure our leadership for the guards but um they're not replacing any of our guards our guards are awesome and they're not going anywhere and when we hire new guards they're going to be IR guards so um they're going to help with the hiring process but they're not taking over any jobs from art team and I want to make that abundantly clear I think I did earlier but I think I could say it 25 times and people might say hey what are we doing to the guards so I just want to make sure it's very clear we love
058our guards uh there's nothing changing in our guard structure um we're just looking for a leadership uh group to help us with these analyzing this data and making good decisions on all aspects whether it's organizing scope in the elementary schools who don't like they're not our employees but they use our spaces so how do we we do that and what it should it look like to organizing the drop offs and the pickups and making sure those are what they should be and talking to our guards about that and getting feedback to make it I've talked to the guards at the middle school about um where the screens are and we got to like move those things to so that it makes it better for them so there are a whole bunch of things we need
059management to to kind of um structure and decide and then support and having happen and that is the reason why we're going with covert because they can do that with us and collaborate with us and our guards so with that I want to introduce Don FL the owner and director of the covert investigations and they're going to do a presentation for us thank you good evening I don't usually get a round of applause but um we'll see what happens at the end um we need to um just switch the port while they're while they're doing that um I need it on the screen it's a different input five thank you um good evening uh to uh Dr feris and the board and the community and definitely the uh the guards that are here tonight I
060want to Echo um his sentiment but I want to start out by talking about something and I was going to talk about this in a different way but um uh Dr Burch brought up a uh you know an incident which has resonated I think with both of us for a very long period of time and so my opening comment was going to be um in watching the presentation about the data in that there are a lot of uh very interesting um and Ono topics that were in there whenever we do public presentations we try to be acutely aware of that we're doing public presentations and still being transparent so um those in the educational World know that we we uh operate by two sets of plans um district-wide plan that is on the on the
061website and the building principal spend a whole lot of time um with the uh with their building level which is in-depth so districtwide plan public building level plan so a lot of the topics that I was seeing that were being talked about up there um excuse me if during the uh the presentation we may not delve down into them because of and this relates back to those who are prone to cause harm usually spend the better part of six to 18 months studying their target and um you know we are it was that going back a long time ago and company was founded um basically on behavioral threat assessment process which uh Dr Frank who works for us uh will go into uh a little bit more but I just wanted to preface those two
062pieces um from the onset so again I said I'm the uh I'm the owner and founder of the company um where does the name covert come from um the company's been in business over uh over 20 years uh cobbert goes back to my uh my former uh life in uh I was a detective Sergeant NYPD but at the bulk of my career I spent in covert doing covert operations I was blessed to be surrounded with and you know there is that word you know you're only as successful as the people you uh surround yourself with and I was blessed to be surrounded by an unbelievable group of detectives um and so I I took that piece with me and the other piece which the company's founded on is training uh training and learning and and
063that'll become evident throughout the presentation um because um my my being able to travel nationally and meet law enforcement from around the country working in the Caribbean with counterparts down in Caribbean Central America and also the Israeli Intel opens your eyes and so we still operate in that capacity um so it again is a foundation of how we've uh you know going back 22 years ago and up until uh 6: am this morning that we'll speak about um we'll speak about later on um I do want to be cognizant of the time there is a whole lot of information that we're going to pack try to pack into a short period of time so i' uh I've asked my staff to go extremely quick I am usually the worst Defender so with that I'm going
064to jump right in I'm not going to go bullet point by bullet point but it's up there um in the 20 years um I don't put a number on the amount of districts that we uh that we work with um the numbers up there probably not uh accurate it's it surpasses where we are but we are a company that is uh K12 probably 99% of what we do so I say all time we don't do bars we don't do nightclubs we don't do any other type of security 365 days a year and literally 365 days a year we're operating in the K12 environment um founded as a security management company and again I appreciate the superintendent bringing that home for the men and women who are in this room right here who come from the
065same background that many of those who are going to present uh tonight do um if you call around and you'll see um every District where we have Security Management in is it is as the superintendent says uh we don't have our unarmed uh we don't have unarmed security staff so when a number is up there of 600 active and retired that we train yeah we trained them um they belong to the uh they belong to the districts um the caveat underneath there which uh may talk about later um those are uh armed Personnel they they are ours um but we'll delve into that probably later so we have primary objectives is is Management training as I uh as I spoke about and most importantly um we all you know those of us who have children
066raise children is finding the balance nobody wants to send their child to a to a school or to an environment where they feel like they're going to an encampment and um so any of the recommendations that we do make regarding that um we certainly take that into uh into account wanting to keep that warm and welcome environment so with that um I have uh some members of my staff who are with me today they'll give a brief introduction and as they get to the top topics that they particularly specialize you know again affirm executed your level of expertise um most of the people in the company have a specific area of expertise and we work in a team atmosphere good evening everybody my name is Bob Brown you can see from the slide up there
067my position with covert is executive director that's about a year old spot that I have my primary job is liaison to law enforcement I uh I spent a lot of time speaking to both Police Department both County police departments uh in you know related to subjects that come up in the districts where we work uh in addition to that um my background is up there uh you can read it it's nearly 40 years now that I've been in this business in either the police department or uh security firms I did 30 almost 36 years with the selfic PD in every job that they have pretty much uh I was never a detective I got promoted to Sergeant uh very quickly and I I missed Detective but other than that I finished up with five years
068as chief of Patrol uh and I worked as you can see pretty much everywhere in the department I did by the way spend some time in the fifth as an quick aside and I saw myself on the photo outside from the uh dedication of the football field to Sergeant Timmy Hank who lost his life tragically in the line of duty uh many years ago um Tom you could flip that the rest of it is uh no good evening and I know it's getting late so I'll try to be quick uh my name is Brian Frank uh professionally I started out uh in the NYPD uh in the 103 uh I transitioned over to the education field uh I've been a curriculum director K12 in several districts uh fairly close to here um besides that I've
069also um been a school principal um Elementary um I story about that is my wife who elementary teacher told me not to do it because I was a secondary person and I did it anyway and it was an interesting experience um so I come I come to this with a bit of a different perspective being a school administrator but also being in the police department and knowing what the focus is when you're out- on patrol and Safety and Security I was also a principal in a building that actually had armed guards outside so I'm familiar with that too um I'm one of the primary Trainers for the company and when we talk about the 6 people um you know a lot of times I'll see myself Danny or somebody else we'll go there and we
070have a very specific K12 program that we teach to the security Personnel that's dedicated to what we do every day in these districts Mike good evening I'm Mike elom I'm the security consultant with covert um I have 32 years law enforcement experience 25 as a supervisor I retired as a detective sergeant from the intelligence Bureau I'm looking forward to working with the board and the members of the security team to ensure a safe environment for all of our students I just want to point out that Mike is going to be taking on the role of head of security here in [Applause] Saville uh hello everybody my name's Tom I'm flipping your slides here tonight but my background is Emergency Management um worked at the local state and federal levels um both public and private sector
071uh currently I'm an analyst trainer for covert investigations my day today is to support the covert supervisors as well as the Tactical Team on the ground um I assist with assessments I perform analysis of events that take place at school districts all over the country and I provide training when I'm asked to do so um I hold instructor asserts from The Crisis Prevention Institute as well as the American Red Cross I'm certified to teach nonviolent Crisis Intervention and verbal deescalation I teach almost everything that the righted cross has to offer uh my favorite thing that I get to do is going out to the school districts and getting to work with staff and students providing that awareness training you'll see a slide in just a little bit that's going to go through exactly what encompasses
072that I'm also a certified FAA drone pilot and I like to dabble around with artificial intelligence uh staying on top of the latest trends products if there's any anything I think could uh help keep a school district safer I'll bring it back to the team thank you okay I'm back this is uh uh the 600 that keeps getting spoken about these are district security Personnel that covert trains that is a big Focus for the company that's one of the things that we'll be doing going forward with saille um this is a little bit of uh you know minutia but it is important uh just to point out that New York State's requirements for security training are the same if you're going to be a bouncer in a in a bar at four o'clock in the
073morning as it is if you're detecting children at of school every day um so you need eight hours of training every year to be an a security guard retired law enforcement in fact the first 10 years of their retirement are exempt they don't get even the eight hours um and there are no requirements right now uh for K12 topics to be included in that uh eight hours we strongly jump in I'm sorry to interrupt We There is actually a bill in Senate to require a supplement and that bill came from saal and Saum specifically to make sure that we differentiate and had enhancement um just wanted to point that out we have a slide on that uh up there about that that's coming listen now it's your thunder uh and uh we're happy we're very
074happy about that could you go back to Tom so where I was before uh talking about what cover really uh stresses that that eight hour training should be used to the best at best Advantage so whether the New York state requirements offer security guard training these are other topics that we cover on a rotating basis if you take a look at this and you can see that uh it speaks to a lot of the things that were in under that mental health uh the concerns that were expressed during the survey um we have uh one more time these instructors all work for covert these are not outside companies that we bring in to do the training every one of those numbers up there and obviously some of them are you know one person is both
075but eight security guard instructors certified Red Cross stop the bleed there's several of those five Firearms instructors for you know you can read the numbers there's a lot of people with a lot of certificates to do the training inhouse we don't have to go out and look for that or get another company to come in and do it that's very rare in the business uh even with my short experience it's more like the police department where the instructors work for the agency next one uh we talked about this yep and here you go I think I'm done um I just want to um you know delve in a little bit more as to what Bob was talking about because I think for as long as I've been doing this I've you know scratched my head
076when I when I realized that I was going to be primarily or totally being involved in in k12 and as Bob um made mention um there is nothing you know New York State education department says oh everybody must be trained in the district's Emergency Management plan there's no delineation of whether it's five minutes an hour or five hours it just doesn't exist so the challenge for us has been primarily uh working um with security personnel and many of them being active and retired you know unbelievable backgrounds resumés that are really um through the roof and so you take that retired lieutenant who solved countless number of major cases and homicides and you say listen we're going to do a lockdown tomorrow I like wait a minute so um it's important to us and the other
077thing that compounds it is that as as Bob said for the first 10 years of being retired you're exempt from the eight hour training um we have you know our our philosophy and and and it's continue training as I said earlier um even those who aren't mandated to take the eight hour um we we always strongly recommend getting together for the eight hours work as a team train as a team and uh syllabus that's not just K12 but uh Germain to the districts that we working so we found it to be extremely helpful as Dr Burch mentioned those are the two U bills that that are up there I had the privilege going back probably a year or so ago of uh of testifying at one of the Committees in relation um to this uh
078um to these initiatives right here and a strong supporter of it right when we talk about Security in school and we we talk about the Outer Perimeter the inner perimeter one of the most important parts I think we have to discuss behavioral threat assessment um and and night tonight's not tonight to go a deep deep dive because there's a lot to it Dr B you know that um but it's really where we're trying to identify issues threats or possible threats before they get to that next level so when we look at the behavior threat assess some model districts are bringing that in districts are asking for training in it and also trying to get help because ultimately what are we in we're in a school district and we're here to help the students so if
079we can prevent things from happening and provide services and support to the students that's where we want to be yeah um just on a behavioral threat assessment we uh we you know continue training members of our staff travel around the country uh to interact with both FBI Secret Service uh seminars we'll talk about that in a little bit um you can go so the the K12 security assessments again another Foundation um of what we we believe in um you know we're looking forward um to starting with uh with saal but one of the primary U responsibilities we'll have is really get the field and we'll need to sit down with um every um every aspect of the uh of the district U from really um top to bottom you know emergency management everybody's on the
080same playing field whether you're superintendent your security guard or custodian or grounds um in the moment um it's all Hands-On so goes back to um enhancing training for everybody but this the assessments that we do usually take the better part of a minimum of a month to two um and it's a day by day not just during school day we'll look at after after hours which is important um weekends night events and uh we look for again we're working for the district so um we don't believe in any aha I got you but we do look um to implement best practices and that's uh evident in in the assessments that we do right one of the programs that we have been doing and districts have been requesting this is when we talk about trauma informed
081training for students so in some districts we've gone in from for grade six through 12 and we've done a uh We've R through some courses just awareness courses in CPR AED stop the bleed um choking things like that um for a couple of reasons one we want them to know what this is and and if they if it happens and and know at least if they're not fully trained at least they can help somebody who's responding to this emergency um and and take that that shock out of it if an event does happen in school where're working school we you know as a school principal one of my biggest concerns has always been choking choking in the cafeteria and the concern and it seems like every other week there's something on channel 12 news about
082a child choking or something like that so we run these awareness programs Danny doeses it uh Tom does it and uh we found that the feedback has been fantastic and uh we continue to have more districts asking for us to do it now just one more point on that it's great to live in suffa County where you get a great response time from your First Responders like Danny and he'll talk about that in a few minutes um but it's even better to be in a school building where you have hundreds of people who know how to make an effective 911 phone call they know how to intervene within seconds instead of having to wait minutes for someone to help uh so the students love it I believe one of the districts we were in we
083did a choking course not two weeks after we had left we had an eighth grader save a sixth grader in the cafeteria so that's a good feeling going out to get to do that just some of the toys we have go ahead some of the agencies um that and this is just a small portion of uh who we work with um again reiterates not just on a local level with the local police departments which we have work hand inand in into the you know NYPD FBI Secret Service you um tis is based out of uh we do National tabletop exercises with them they're based out of Texas um tiny G is located over in London we coordinate with them um and you know a recent training that we we just were at was uh again
084it was uh instructors from all over the world we'll talk about that in a little bit but these are some of the partners that we work with um so that's all thank you I I I appreciate it we went very quickly there is you know um depending upon where you want to go at this stage uh this stage of the game but I'll leave it at this at this point yeah I I want to thank you guys and I we might go have to go there but let's hold off on that for now but what I wanted to say was I hope you can see in the array of support um why this would be a good choice for saille schools just to have they're not going to be all here present all the time
085but if there's a crisis this is the team that we have that we can call upon to ask for advice to give us support uh if we if we want to schedu superintended conference days for our teachers to get training or for our staff to get training they would be able to provide a variety of trainings for us if they doing a threat assessment going through the schools identifying and then matching that up with the data that you guys provided us as parents who have eyes and can see it yourselves uh really will Elevate the level of support we can give to Security in our schools I mean there's just no comparison to what they can do for us compared to what we can do for us without something like this it's not a knock
086on any of the people we have it's just the added layer of support that I think all of us will appreciate including our guard teams who will get support that they may not have been able to have in our current system and as an added bonus uh because we can go through bosis for this particular service our current uh cost of a head of security was about with health insurance $100,000 this would be about $120,000 but it's 50% aable so we're going to be saving about 30 to $40,000 a year as a district going with this model so it's a cost savings and look at what we get for that price so I I do think I hope you can see why this is going to be significantly helpful to our school district further as
087you're about to you know you're going to have we're going to have to have the discussion about where we're going and what we steps we need to take should the district decide to do armed perimeter guards they are fully trained to train and help hire and support the uh in that situation if that is the direction we tend to go in but I just wanted to open to the board any questions for covert at this time go um thank you so much for your presentation uh one thing that I like uh when we discussed this last week um was that you offer the audit after seeing Amy's information data analysis um I feel like the audit is is great um and it will really address many of those questions and and comments that the fames
088made can you speak to that a little bit more please uh yes uh you know philosophically as I said with the the assessment piece for us um starting to work in a district without having that background and there's 124 126 school districts on on Long Island so you have to take into account yet his best practices but also each district has a different culture so we you know we weigh in on that it's not one siiz uh one siiz fits all um your community Forum that you held obviously not because um accolades that is a tremendous amount of help for us in starting the assessment process we already have a good feel um that we take that that information sit down and speak to every you know the staff levels that I spoke about but
089that's an absolute great starting point and I think that's a model for a lot of other districts to follow um you know getting you know getting the input um and so we we relish that information can can I jump in there one of the things that I think impressed us when in talking with cover was precisely the put it you know because one of the things that it was just part of an organic conversation one of the things that they're doing is they're having a drone up right away and they're looking at visuals from the standpoint of building security like and and that's just another like it's great that law enforcement will come in and and there's now a Homeland unit which is more specialized in the training they can do an audit covert knows
090more than they do like and it's because they've been molded all of their training and years of experience and focused it specifically on school I mean there isn't in my eyes a better school security firm on Long Island um and and I think the model is so much to do with it but that audit I think that's huge because you're getting honest feedback and we're getting honest feedback about where are our vulnerabilities what do we need to better how can we grow and that's the mindset it takes to be safe so I just appreciate how important that is to you no thank you and and um you know the we look at you know I don't like to get onedimensional in the approach Ro to everybody you know the you know the active shooter piece
091because on the dayto day um we put the drones up uh two of them at FAA uh drone commercial certified Pilots but they had parents in in one particular this they were infuriated by traffic in the morning right and whatever you know move the cones here move the cones back and just you know a couple of Mornings in a row put the Drone up and you really got a completely different perspective as to where the bottlenecks was starting they're actually you know three blocks away and it it gave um a whole different feel for the assessment that was done on a track traffic flow and it it was it was helpful we could put 10 guys out there 10 different ways but you know the eye and the sky so the technology as Tom said
092earlier whether it's you know AI or drones or whatever um roll with it um okay all right so at this point um you know I need some direction from the Board of Education in terms of like how do we want to proceed forward um clearly we have a budget coming up which has to be presented to you and adopted in April um and if Rhonda and I are going to you know plan that budget we have to know what we're planning for so I I just wanted to kind of put that out there that and I'm not trying to pressure it's just that if we're going to go in One Direction or another I I need to know what I'm you know what we're planning for so that we could um I mean start to
093talk about this I think uh my suggestion would be that um I guess to have two parallel tracks and maybe you know for budgetary purposes to uh come up with a realistic you know cost you know of perimeter guard um and then at the same time we still collect more information and the effectiveness and you know but along with the budget then we'll make a decision whether to uh move forward anyone else have any thoughts on uh go ahead James I I think I like the approach because I think what a board is is a deliberative body like we're supposed to weigh all the information we have to make good decisions um that's rational to me I I think for me is I want to know what what covert's seeing after they do an audit
094to me that's what I want to know you know um but I think that's prudent I just want to say I think we're hiring experts and we should let the experts do their job and come back and I think that audit and that assessment and the data that they're going to provide along with what we've already heard from our community will help us make those decisions but I don't think we're at the point where we have enough information or explored enough about our own security system to be able to make those intelligent conversations or have them or make those decisions so I do agree I think at this point Sorry Rhonda but um having um both taken into consideration because we don't have to adopt this budget until April and there's a lot of information
095we can gather to make a good decision between now and then uh I agree with you Christine but and there is one other question if the decision going forward if it was coste effective and whatever uh is there a contract that we have to sign for a number of years or is it like month to month year to year how does that work if we were going to go with so just to clarify for perimeter guards we would have to put out an RFP and then firms it's different than what we've done with cobt as a management firm so then firms like covert or other firms can put in a proposal and then we have to look at those proposals and there's a process for accepting bids for that so my point is Ronda you
096know would so so in that parallel concept that Tom's talking about we would in order to plan for this we would have to put out an RFP collect uh bids from companies for armed perimeter guards and then build it into a budget and then and then give it to you as a budget presentation and then you would have to decide if you want it in or out no no no I think you miss yeah I just want to just clarify I think us working with cover is is a no-brainer we should move forward with that that should be a done deal the other piece is letting them do the work that they need to do to assess to tell us what would be our most effective moves going forward and that may or may not
097include armed guards at that point but we don't have that information yet so we have to have a budget that allows for both yeah um at this point what I would just say is that we have we're going to plan and we have to buildar all right yeah I say we I I say we 100% send out the rfps I say we get all of uh the bids that we can get for armed perimeter guards I think armed perimeter guards uh teamed with what I've seen with cover which to me is amazing because in most things in education you get a mile wide and an inch deep I feel like covert offers us a mile wide and a mile deep um I love what they do in the schools I think this is something that
098can make sville ahead of the game instead of constantly being followers I think we can be leaders in this situation um so I think 100% we put the RFP out we see what we get and then we build it into the budget and and if it's not cost- effective and it doesn't work then then we look at other options but I think it's something that after watching I mean we had 70 70.1% of the people that came out I know that's only of the people that came out but those are the people that care enough to come out so I think that um literally said that for was the answer I I think hold on hold on hold on hold on so I think we put out the RFP I I think we get the
099bids and then we we make the best decision after that but I say we 100% go go well well we'll we'll clarify explain the bu I think cover did very good presentation and I think assessing our security uh giving a good audit I think that's a great idea right so we're we're not having we're not having let's just let's let's just um Let me let me clarify no let Meer we need we need you to wait wait hold on a let the superintendent speak we are the voices that speak we are the voices but you're not listening you're not are thees that you guys work for us love thank you you're the one who spoke reasonable the other two who weren't paying attention Okay it's sir sir sir stop just listen for a minute please
100it's hard when you put so much time into we've put all the time into we're putting all the time into too and I want to there's no runaround here's what the plan is that I'm trying to establish and I want the board to tell me if that's okay we are going to plan our budget we're going to get rfps for actual prices for perimeter guards and we're going to build that into a budget to present to the Board of Education which is the process for the budget uh then the board can decide at that point what they want to do with that that's the okay so there's no there's no you'll get a chance to just right so um what I'd like to do is can we have Co may I may I for yeah
101please um I don't have children in the school district any longer I know EXC may I speak I don't have children in the school district anymore I have a niece in the school district I have other families in the school district but let me explain the the horses in the race that I'm concerned with are all saval kids and even if I did have children here it wouldn't just be my my children I do care about your children I wouldn't be here if I didn't I agree here that I'd like to put it out I'd like to put it out I'd like to see the prices and I would like to see okay but I I I I I would like to I would not part of the process hold on hold we have let
102me just explain something let us get through with the meeting we have a comment period and we can we could take your comments During the commment period okay it's okay there was just something else I would like to see if we can survey the whole Community because there are people out there who don't have children who but wait who don't they don't know about the meetings okay okay okay ex listen hold on there's a can we just agree that when we're doing public comments please off for comments then otherwise we're not really listening to each other so I recognize people are frustrated there's going to be an opportunity for people to make comments and ask questions can we do that because I think it would be productive so the process I want to say one
103more thing before we wrap this up here I I would like people to understand that just because um just because we want to be thorough does not mean we do not agree with excuse me this is how it works in the board meeting we're going to let anybody who wants to talk they can talk and go right up there and talk we like to be respectful we like to have a certain air of decorum in here we don't like to scream and yell at each other because nothing gets accomplished that way it's right we can't hear what you're saying some people are saying a few things I can't hear you other people are screaming over them it's not productive okay but please understand Kathy made a point she doesn't have kids in school some of
104us do it correct but I'm just repeating what she just said she didn't have she doesn't okay please let me finish she doesn't have kids in the school some of us have kids in the school still we're here with you for a reason we're not here to put anyone in danger but it's a process we have to make sure we do everything right so that we have everything right for the kids there's nothing there's no one here that is arguing that the Safety and Security of our kids and teachers and staff is anything but our top priority please let's follow the rules here finish up and then we'll have our comment section and I ask during that section if we could remain civil so that we again can get things accomplished thank you okay so
105I would just like to reiterate what some people said this conversation as people are having it does not mean that certain board members are for or against the perimeter guards this is the process for getting perimeter guards if that is in fact what we choose to do so the next step is that Rhonda has to go out Miss Moll has to go out and get rfps which are what does that stand for EXA request for propos thank you and then companies will propose to US based on what our request is uh their bid so to speak for the job then that number will be built into a budget that's the process of getting it to happen it can't happen without being funded and they can't just say we're spending money without a proper budget presentation
106a proposal and then the board has to accept the proposal so I'm going to build a budget with that in the budget and then the board will get to comment on and give me feedback on that and either reject or accept that proposal that's the process it doesn't mean that right now no one's accepting it or not accepting it it's just the process that has to be gone through to get a budget passed it can't go to the voters until the board adopts the budget in April and then you get to vote on the budget in May so the next the directive that I feel like we have at this point is to collect rfps get a price get a company build it into the budget and then talk further simultaneously we've hired covert they
107are fully trained and certified to do all the things we want them to be able to do they're going to do an audit of our security all things Windows Doors security op uh man traps everything looking at the feedback and then they will present findings which will include all things and then the board will be able to at the April adoption either adopt or not adopt a budget with armed guards in it but right now I'm planning on putting this together and and in in the meantime we have we have Community meetings where the community members can come to those budget in those budget meetings where they can come and they can give their input as to where um you know where they think you know because inevitably when you give to something you have
108to take from something else so that's where the community input would be important that they come to those meetings as well um just to clarify when you hire a company don't you have to put out an RFP you have to that's required by the state that's required by the state that's done explain why we're able the reason that we didn't have to do it for the security management is because the security manage is through Eastern suff boses and we already have a contract with ethern suff Eastern suff bis so that we could go through that contract without an RFP process so uh no other armed security companies go through suff bosis uh they don't and even covert does not go through bosis for armed security guards correct yeah all right so again I'm going to
109reiterate step one we're going to put the RFP together and we're going to get prices step two we're going to build our budget which by the way will also include things that we want for children related to instruction to World Language to science to math to AIS support for English and Ela and all the things that we want as our fiveyear plan includes for students and we will present that budget to you in stages stage one will be in February where we'll present the tax cap and the um what are the other components of the first stage um the first presentation which is February 13th is tax cap and we incorporate like the fiscal stress score in there and then um I believe it's in March Mar that we have uh revenues um the first
110one in March for revenues and expenditures and then we do the three-part budget and then we present the actual budget in April and then the board will adopt or not adopt okay so that's the process I'd like cover to maybe just briefly talk about if we were to have perimeter guards what would your approach to management be and all that thank you right thank you I I realized this I've been down this road many many times before um that it is assess the topic um I will say this and I know there was a comment that I respect both both sides of it but uh because we do have a large number of armed uh security Personnel in K2 we have never made the recommendation to a district to either go or not go in
111that direction we follow the same philosophy of nass suff police departments however we do say we're not being arogant about it and um we give you some information to I think it would be very helpful for for a lot of people is that I was doing K12 security long before armed security came into play and I call it now I call then it was a game changer never in a million years that I think the conversation would be had that being said um after February 14th of 2018 which is mar stman Douglas one of our districts which we have working with for a very long period of time we started receiving a number of phone calls give me some arm guards give me some arm guards we told every one of them the same thing
112no said we' like to start with an assessment take a look at an assessment one District which I don't name districts um I give them a lot of credit um I said we'd like to take a look at it and uh and examine it go back um they I said earlier executed your level of expertise we've heard the name Danny baned around here a little bit Danny is standing next to me and we'll go down that Road uh go down that road in a little bit him and I know each other um a long time our boys wrestled together um still remain extremely extremely close but I know what I did my job was to analyze uh school Mass Cas with the shoot shootings not a very nice topic to do so but when it
113came down to the Tactical piece I knew his background um we we got together and the better part of a number of months came up with a program so we'll go through that so I guess it's food the thought um I'm hoping hoping that both both sides you know again I'm certainly appreciative and I think what sa has done between the Forum um you know and and the process it is um you know again the RFP process has to happen um and then you know you see where you go from there let me just run through a few some information so on that on that note I mention uh Danny I always get the Hot Topic uh my name is Dany Colona I've been a South County police officer for 25 years the last 18
114years I've been in the emergency service so what is the emergency service unit it's a pretty unique uh unit within the country because we're squat team Rescue Unit Hazmat unit and we're the bomb squad like we're bomb squad is a a special Squad most unit don't have that I am a certified graduated FBI SWAT School New York State SWAT School FBI sniper School uh there's two schools of thought as far as active fter response NYPD and n county do alert some of you guys might have through that alert training sou County adopted the laser princip sou County very smart and the chief was in charge over here handsome gu on my left um the reason why is as everybody knows especially the board everything always comes down as doll and S we adopted the principles
115here because it was funded by Department home security sou count Police Department is probably one of Premier police departments in the country spots because we get a lot of fun do drill we actually have drill Saturday one of uh areas of responsibility the emergency service unit is R Train control so we usually do approximately one active drill a month we control in We R through these through these scenarios stress based scenarios um the principles that we do here at covert um is very similar to the principles that we bring to the sou count right so we want our guards when they ENT a building if that chance does alive that they can operate in the same environment that Poli they can if they do enter a building with a police officer they can basically be
116off each other um the training that we do is very intense it's very stress St I want my guards when they go into building to be comfortable being comfortable um we exceed New York state standards as far as our shooting and our tactics we go for the amount of hours um that's required by the state um and our guys just train train train just another one of our instructors he's not here tonight um one of Danny's former partners um I will say this all right um I believe uh in the late approach to security so when you get districts in this way it just hammers the point home and I know sa will probably has a lot of these things in in play but it's important that when districts I say to call us say
117give us some armed guards we want to look at what else you have because it's not a Panacea so um for the sake of uh you know saving time um you know if the district decides to go it shouldn't be in replace of or you still best practices still Prevail one of the positive things if anything it's come out of you know the armed guard program is that I think many districts are always concerned about the perimeter our philosophy is that they should only be on the perimeter we don't um we're not we're not a fan of the Firearms being in the building except under one scenario and one scenario only so what that forces us to do is constantly have a set of eyes trained eyes on the perimeter at at all times so
118that has benefit that has come out of it so um let me just go through this you know some of it Danny go through the um the rest of it the uh photo on the side is just that that's not in act that's what that's us actually training it's two of our instructors actually training so um they're all our Personnel active and retired police officers but by me merely being that that really means nothing um being know our our uh our failure rate is probably somewhere in the 60 65% of individual who do not make it through the uh make it through the program um we look for when we look at their you know look at the resumés we talk about this all the time whether you were a no matter what what you
119did in your job there are people who just went to job you know went to work did their eight hours and went home and there were really people who put their heart and soul so when we look for people we look for people who those were individuals because we use you know use the term finding the warrior mindset and a lot of good questions are asked by G you know people in the public that you know are hesitant about going down this road and it's up to us to answer these questions um internal and I know this has been a question Dr Farah said should a district decide to go and there's preface in many of the districts that we have on Personnel we always we always look to go in house first okay um
120nobody gets any special benefits there not a you know we have rubrics that we use so you don't get a certain amount of points but the fact of the matter is it behooves us to hire or bring on board those who are actually security Personnel in the district they know the district they know the buildings they know the floor plans so it's actually a win-win situation that being said they still have to go through what the process looks like and and Danny described a little bit about what that look what does look like this is not bring a gun to work day it's uh right we're looking we're looking for that mindset so just to piggyback on what Don had said prior um about bring your gun to workday uh there are some districts in
121the in the county that they just say well you're an law enforcement bring your gun to work right shooting is a perishable skill I know the the ladies and gentlemen that work your security Now can tell you that you don't go to rain for a while right it's it's a perishable skill when we're putting a guard in a building with our most per uh you know our most precious assets we need the best Shooters available we're need the best tactics available um and that's where we come in um and we do our stress Based training all our scenarios that we do myself and carine you saw the picture of the gentleman before all our scenarios are based off real live events that Happ to through the country we go on the internet we look at
122different active shooter situations or different hostage situations that happened in schools and then we base our scenarios all of that and then we want to see how W guards are going to react to that and I I always give the example of of a scenario that we had in another state where they had a a retired police officer who actually worked Security in a building he winded up going into the building and the skirty guard let him in because he sees him every day he goes in the building winds up find out that his wife was a teacher there was having an affair with another teacher and he held hostage right those are the scenarios that we do in in our company because that's something that could legitimately happen when that arises we want our
123guys to be able to operate in that environment um like I said just reiterate what I said before the training that we do way exceeds what New York State expects for us DCJS asset us yeah so uh DCJS they we talk about training even with the unarmed 8 Hour you have a be a licensed pistol holder or have an an armed license in a state of New York you must go to the range once a year shoot 50 rounds um we shoot at least three to four times three to four times a year you shoot at a paper Target for State qualification paper Target doesn't shoot backage yet so we use real life based scenario Sim weapons um that can hurt when you get hit but it then we also trained within the buildings that
124we operate in schools that we're in um off hours we're very um in tune with trauma base we make sure the buildings are empty whether it be on holidays January 29th Luna New Year we'll be doing some active shooter in one of the districts that we work with so you know there is and I totally respect as I said as I said earlier um both sides of the equation as to how they feel I know there's all these studies that are out there the harbard the Yale all these other pieces for us it just came down to one piece and it was just about response time suff for count is unbelievable Nas County unbelievable these men and women will come 150 miles an hour that being said at any particular point in time so we
125never delve down into the debate as as far as but just for us it's merely about if the district has decided to go this it's one reason one reason only and that's just about response time so Danny uh Danny spoke to the Tactical training this is just how you know how we how we operate I won't delve down to things that are here because there's reasons behind them go ahead um this is what we were talking about Danny just spoke about the um the model of um you know B buses um and and a whole host of scenario based uh training um I'm not going to go not going to go through it it's you know the decision to provide on Personnel is is is basically is basically up there maintaining the balance as I
126said earlier um you know where where fir I believe there was an article in the one of the local papers that somebody sent we a lot of that was in there and I was very you know very hesitant about what what gets put out there we I I want to say we wrote Danny and I wrote the first um specs that went out um on Long Island many you know many years ago and it was based upon as I said earlier real study of you know 476 page marer stowman Douglas and on and on so um we continue to look into what works better as he said it's a fluid uh fluid training so again um you know it's communication is key I know the district is very familiar heard in accolades to you know
127as far as implementing with the you know the Rave app you save hotlines all of these pieces um any tools that staff members are using in-house you know the guards on the outside should also not just be familiar with um are are mandated to have uh have these pieces um with them at all period of time to enhance communication and also Communication in 911 if necessary I just put this up there and I said I continued training and and and this was only put in within the last couple of hours um we train literally um around the world as I said earlier um we flew in about 6: am this morning uh several several of us were out on the west coast um to do a um to do a training tactical active uh active
128shooter but more importantly as Thomas said earlier to bring back the latest and greatest so um out on the west coast with people from all around the world um you know and we're a big fan of our military um the youngsters on the right left left guy on the left the uh Army uh veteran of the army the guy on the right is also an active suff suff cop um Danny and I is a great experience to have and it's just you know you never done so I think it drives home to point when he said it's a perishable skill technology be you know continues to change scenario based continues to change so it's not a decision to be taken lightly um and so as if the district decides to go forward the board decides
129to go forward there are a lot of hard questions to ask you know during an RFP process because um sometimes a lot of times it's not all what it cut you know it's cut out to be so um that being said you know if there doc if there's anything else I I can do but I appreciate it I think it's important to put it out there the district and um the administration has been very from the U when we first started talking and and and the board um very very inquisitive asking a whole lot of questions and doing a due diligence and that's a whole lot better than like when I get a phone call on a Sunday night after a mass casualty incident can you give me 10 people tomorrow that's a knee-jerk reaction
130so I I I do um even though they are our people we would certainly like to work with work with the district but I appreciate the due diligence and the assessment and taking a look at because uh I think it's important to do and find the right people if you decide to go forward thank you yeah um i' just like yeah oh okay um I'd like to summarize a few things that we heard here because I think some of the things that were said here are worth repeating um first of all I'd like to thank Don and Ronda and Dr Ferris for reiterating that the RFP is something that we are obligated to do and it's obviously part of the process of this um I think sometimes people don't and and and before I got
131on the board this was my thought process too there are many many steps that we're obligated to take okay we can't just make as Don said a knee-jerk reaction because then we run the risk of not doing the right thing I don't think anybody in this room or anybody in the district would want a knee-jerk reaction uh decision for security for their kids um if we want this Dr ferrah said this before if we want this we have to pay for it right so we need to make a budget that pays for it it has to be done you have you want to pay for it right we got we have to figure out how to pay for it that's another part of the process um James said this keeps him up at night this
132keeps all of us up at night you see us here twice a month meeting for many hours but you don't see all the other stuff that we have to do I'm not sure um if you guys realize this but almost daily we have obligations and responsibilities for the board of education so please do not think that this is something that we haven't thought of for a long time and very thoroughly the comment about the Forum being the answer the Forum Ryan I heard you okay well that's okay I didn't I I didn't say you could speak you can talk yes but you can talk when we have it I want hear what you have to say but my point right now is to think that the Forum alone please to think the Forum alone was
133the only way we were going to make this decision I I've been racking my brain trying to get something that I can uh um compare this to I really can't because this is such a big decision but so don't don't give me any grief when I make this this analogy here it's it's not the best I can do but you're one toy a house you just walk down the street and buy the house no you have to do your due diligence you have to make sure that people you're working with are going to do the best job you have to make sure not only excuse let me finish please you have to make sure the people that you're working with are doing the right job and making sure they maintain their responsibilities you don't want
134to have um let's just let's take a scenario you want to make sure all these things we talked about earlier in the evening are taken care of in addition to exploring we're not just with this is a whole big picture I I really want to drill this down for everyone this is a huge decision and it's and please don't mistake us doing our due diligence for uh giving the runaround or a smoke show this has to be something that is done 100% correctly these are our children okay so please just understand that this is a difficult thing for everybody everybody has a different opinion here I'll tell you that and I just want to add the Forum is absolutely directly influencing this whole conversation right now the reason that I'm putting a budget together with
135this involved the reason we're going out for rfps is a direct result of the Forum and other things that we've heard uh any other questions from the board no thank you we're gonna get we're not there yet okay um do you have any other topics or any other questions on this any other on this topic there was one other topic that you just asked me to talk about which was the um at the high school level um the ninth and 10th grade Global Studies program and the English program was transitioning to be in line with other programs at the high school such as the nth 10th and 11th grade program where we have an honors level program for ninth and 10th which was a preap and then a regions and then that third middle component
136was going to be either you go one way or the other um so if you had questions about that I could answer that and or Amy could talk about that as well so Amy could you just speak a little bit to to that please because I know there were some community members that had questions about that specifically sure thank you um so what the uh High School is looking to do what we're looking to do as a district is um streamline our honors and our Regents um tracks for a lack of a better word um and the um the it's it's about a commitment to not overtrack our students philosophically uh and it's also about designing a really well articulated program so that um our courses that end uh that culminate in AP courses so
137the the series of classes that lead up to that um are designed um with the like a an like the national and a a state-based framework in mind uh right now we have a 9h and a 10h and these are locally designed classes that uh end in the same assessment that the regions classes end in and so over the years it's they've sort of morphed there it's very hard to contain what what they act the the level of rigor that they actually are um but um and and it it splits our kids into three different groupings and after 10th grade there's like really no endgame for the honors uh it really is a sort of a region pathway or an AP pathway so um if we design backwards from the outcomes um they just step
138into them with a lot of intentionality um students are really well prepared uh because those courses have been designed to lead to an outcome so they're more confident they're less stressed um so after 10th grade they're not forced one way or the other without having that yeah sequences from nth grade and the ninth grade honors program which is the preap prepares them with skills in a safer environment right less high stakes environment to go into an AP course in 10 and then also in 11 if you're in honors of 10 right now you have to make a choice AP or regions and you haven't been in a program that's preparing you for that AP level kind of coursework I think also just to add we currently do this in our other subject areas science as
139an example and in 11th and 12th grade social studies so we're trying to streamline and have a consistent system that matches in all of our disciplines and I think no this was really well informed by the expertise of our teachers who are know our kids they know the courses they know what um what a great design would be and had a lot of thoughtful conversation um that that resulted in this being like a really optimal outcome um and I think having two major groups instead of three um creates an inclusive environment it creates um an environment that um just Embraces a wider range of student profiles in each course um and the teachers who were designing they know this going into next year they will be given the support the curriculum time um the the
140um the knowledge that their course needs to be designed to accommodate a a wider range of Learners than maybe they have right now and um that's something that will be done with intentionality okay thank you I know you have such a wide of information on this and expertise could we ask the um community members who have further questions more specifically for their child or for a subject to be able to reach out to either uh guidance or to you or something yeah absolutely um I miss Bricker and I have spoken about this extensively uh all the teachers are really well equipped to speak about it so your child current teacher building principle guidance everybody's very well informed and articulate about this obviously me is uh I'm very happy to discuss as well um but I
141think straight from the the the people who are delivering the instruction all the way through the faculty and and administration uh anyone would be willing and very happy to discuss it thank you thanks so much thanks Mr Bier I just have one quick question in so what what percentage of kids would you say are falling in that middle bracket that that H bracket as opposed to the AP and the region is it 33 33 33 no not exactly um if you look at the numbers now correct me if I'm wrong but like you'll have like 28 in a class two 28s of like a preap class then you have like a 20 or an 18 in like a couple sections of honors and then you have a couple sections of regions that may have 25
142or 24 so it really depends but it's not 30 303 it's is it like 20 20 I'm pretty close right yeah because I'm just thinking about like those those I guess would you call the middle of the road kids are are now being forced to make a decision to push themselves into uh difficult and challenging AP classes or to the the lower regions and so those are those are just the kids that I'm thinking about this I think yeah but you sound like well way more well versed of this time no I think that's the question that I keep hearing I think it would be the the main question that I I would expect people to have I think first all changes causes a lot of discomfort for things like this and and concern we've
143done it for science we did it it was a while ago I think it was over a decade ago that we made this change in in science and um um I think it it signifies like we we believe in our kids and the teachers are are will able to you bring bring on the students who if had honors been an option in science um students who would have taken them but instead didn't and are in an AP class and they are being successful and thriving there it's a testimony to you know um helping students students um raise their raise their B also what we've seen in the 11th grade is an example so for a 11th grade American history and and the American AP American history uh many kids more started taking the AP and
144finding success and the quality of our regions program got better too because the the quality of the curriculum so now you have a rigorous regions program and and a and a really nicely successful AP program which kids were not taking advantage of because they were having that middle choice right more choices is always better um Desmond and everyone so having taught a true Regents Class A true heterogeneous class um it is very strong because your strong students will always Thrive and rise and your uh more reluctant or challenged students will have better role models for Behavior motivation effort and you'll have Exemplar I could speak for English papers to share with them and discussions right right and also there's differentiated instruction to be done to reach everyone yeah just the thought that in this area
145it's probably 25 years ago some of the more Forward Thinking schools said like let's get rid of honors because what happens is and I think that was the key piece of Kathy's describing is is that students are making an associ if they're afraid of the riger so they kind of do that but they can do it I want to rephrase it though we're not no one's getting rid of honors we had two honors we had like level one honors and level two honors we're just saying we only need one honors and one Regents and and you can provide for multiple tude of students earlier Desmond a previous meeting mentioned we want to provide opportunities for all kids right and we want to make sure that we have a region track that's strong and we want
146to have a honors track that's strong not no honors track and honors is preap basically or AP oh so you're wherever there's a course that has an AP we have that as an offering if there's no AP there's an honors course right so we're not ating honors that's a like kind of not a great way to say it's the AP or the preap is the honors court and then the regions court is a strong region but you're not running a region and honors and an AP correct because the AP in effect is the honors right okay so back but getting rid of that middle of the road Choice you're asking kids to make a choice if they're ready for AP right and I think the biggest benefit that I experienced in a school that got
147rid of that middle track was we sort in the region classes but I also think the other benefit is in ninth grade there's no AP right so there's no AP so it's a preap honors class really so really it's an honors class and they teach the skills and then with no AP at the end of it so if you're doing well in that you can say oh I have confidence I've built these skills and now I can go into an AP class in 10th grade in confidence if you're in that honors class in ninth grade and it's not going well and you feel like it's too much you now are informed and you can say okay next year I'm going to go into the region because I so I think it creates a nice pathway
148for kids to try things and then make decisions as they progress through through high school and to Desmond's point from last meeting we want to have multiple opportunities for kids whether they're doing it a pre-ol track or a career field or any other field to have opportunities okay okay right so that's the end of um your my report okay so now we have a board discussion um upcoming uh training opportunities we have at Longwood Regional leg legislative breakfast on February 1st at 9:00 amm uh the nisba virtual Capital conference on February 7th the nisba lobby day on February 12th that's in Albany and the Eastern suff Bose executive uh briefing that's on February 12th at 6:30 pm uh in Riverhead Riverhead sorry and then we have the refit legislative breakfast for March 7th at 8:30
149a.m. at Bose and weatley Heights Kathy you have a a update on the railway fencing uh so for some of you you know you saw the um slideshow that Christine and I prepared for the railway um situation that we are working on for those of you who don't know we went and took photographs of bay ports fencing along the railway and then we showed you what it looked like at saille which you know so uh Christine reached out to some people I reached out to someone and finally I received a response because I sent the email again and I'm really excited to share this with you so this is from uh Miss Anna Garcia she's the assistant director of government and community relations with the MTA uh she said safety is our number one priority
150and we take your request very seriously we will certainly look into the areas you've highlighted to assess what is feasible in terms of fencing in the meantime we would be happy to arrange a virtual meeting with the relevant terms to our ends to discuss the situation further we truly appreciate the work you are doing the to discuss the meaningful initiatives we commend your dedication um so we will whether we want to do a Christine just you and I or anyone else wants to join the committee uh we will set up a time to meet with them and hopefully move forward to getting fencing there thank you very much and thank you for taking that up okay um the next uh item on the agenda is the claims order report um any uh comment on that
151[Applause] no okay I do I have a question oh you do sorry the claims report yeah okay so there was um something stated by John Macwan and Suns so who is that and what do they do um do you have to answer to that I believe it's buildings and grounds and I believe it's asphalt and I believe that the claims auditor did not um move forward with it because it was missing some backup documentation with regard to a breakout of labor materials that kind of thing and once that was supplied he then released okay great because it did say that six items were missing backup support P vendor right and it's $888,000 so I was interested in knowing what was going on but that's also a clear example how the claims order works yeah it's
152wonderful basically you know they check to make sure everything is in line and nothing gets approved until they reaches it's just right you should know to provide that yeah yeah okay thank you I I just wanted to give everybody just like a little bit of heads up um of what our next conversations will probably look like so the governor's been busy right know this is not talking about budget yet but she's put out her preliminary numbers but three things that she's just put out publicly in the last week or so our first Universal free lunch which she is trying to include as part of the state budget um and if she does if she succeeds um then that means that all schools would be providing breakfast and lunch um I don't know what the funding
153part of that looks like yet obviously none of us do uh but um but that's certainly something that's um on the horizon um something I fully support I think it's great I think working families are going to benefit from that the most right free and reduced lunch has always existed but the families who are above that level who are writing that $200 a month check if you have a couple of kids in school um it definitely can help um the other piece is she just um presented the no cell phones in school from B the Bell um and we're going to have to discuss how that would be implemented and last is the um School temperature regulations too hot too cold um and um how that needs to be uh dealt with so there's a
154lot of pieces to this and whether they're going to be funded or unfunded mandates will have a huge impact on our budget discussion so um just something I think you guys should kind of keep aware of I'm glad you said that and I'd just like to biggy pack uh piggyback because I had made note regarding uh the bill on school temperature so I guess we need to put in place some type of inventory on our classrooms because I can tell you the classes along that Southside in the high school are like a greenhouse onid yeah the one side of the building is much more hot than the other the there's a lot of discussion among all the superintendents in the county and probably the state regarding how are we gonna possibly measure all this because
155it says it's 88 degrees but it has to be measured from the center of the room at 3 feet high so like are we going to get devices and go into every room and it's 88 in this room and 87 in that room and then take reason able action what is the reasonable action 82 is like lower the shades turn off the lights 88 might be an evacuation to a cool space so we are looking for more guidance from the state because it's very unclear but also 30 students in there yes yeah that was a topic that Rhonda brought up at our health and safety so we discussed that yeah and it's effective September 2nd so we have to be ready for that Sorry's telling me she didn't mentioned no cell phone in schools that
156was the last one yeah that'll be interesting okay okay any other uh board discussion no no okay so um we're gonna have our first comment period the first comment uh section is on agenda items only uh this way we can uh take care of our business and then we can vote on our business and then the second common period will be for General topics okay so yeah okay so before we start I'll want ask first if anyone wants to comment on the agenda well does anybody want to comment on the agenda that's the items that the board okay so how many people would like to make a comment about security just show a hand okay okay good so let me just read this uh statement before we start um the Board of Education appreciates feedback
157from the community and we recognize Free Speech as one of our uh our fundamental freedoms these freedoms are not without restrictions we follow regulations specified by law and board policy and we encourage community members to offer public comment according to Sable School Board policy 12:30 we request the following participants in public session must demonstrate civility as they address the board and Community there 30 minutes have been set aside for comments by the public the board reserves the right to limit or extend public participation if they deem uh necessary comments and questions from the board are limited to three minutes per person and should be Rel related to school matters speakers are requested to identify themsel or the group they represent and direct their comments to the board the board will not permit discussion involving students
158District Personnel or community members the full policy is available on the district website and we appreciate your support to have a productive meeting thank you okay so who would like to go first yeah can you just come to the microphone yeah thanks because the people online can hear you there okay good evening and thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak tonight first I'd like to thank the board for doing their homework on this you know sadly it's a it's a different world than when we grew up in and we have to make necessary steps and changes to adapt with those changes right the times are crazy now so I do believe in the armed security I'm not going to sit here and and preach first I'd like to address every person in these
159Blue Jackets thank you for everything you've done for the school I have two boys in in the district and I've dropped them off picked them up Security's always out doing their job squared away great guys great and and women so thank you for all of that just one question are we in agreement tonight that we're proceeding forward with armed guards now I know Dr Ferris has to get a budget and I know we have to go through all of that but is the board in agreement that we're we are stepping forward with this so you can get these rfps and kind of expedite this thing and get this going or is that another vote for a future meeting where you're going to agree on the arm guards and then Dr Ferris can do the budget
160so let's it's clarifying it's perimeter guards right and we I'm sorry it's perimeter it's perimeter guards on the outside yeah I just I'm sorry I should I should have said that I I just want to be fair here and not biased I work for cover so just so I'm not going to sit here and preach and say who's better than that they are very good I get more training with them than I do with the police department I'm an active duty police officer 28 years I've trained three or four times active shooter training with covert shot once or twice we do simunitions they do everything if you're going again I can't push anything on you that would be a company that you should be looking at before anybody but again that's for you to decide
161all I want to know is that if we tonight when we leave do we know that okay the board is in agreement with looking into the perimeter guards we're gonna get the rfps so then Dr Ferris can get his budget in order and then hopefully by April we have this ready to roll out is there a vote happening tonight is what I'm saying there isn't a vote happening here tonight I mean I think we were pretty clear we're we're getting the RFP so we then can make a decision and we're also waiting for feedback from the co uh so how does that work you have different companies give you their rfps and then you're going to decide hey we want right so when we put out an RFP any company that wants to can submit
162a proposal proposal then we have to look at the proposals and you want to explain the process um when we do a request for proposal we have to put together exactly specifically what we are asking of the companies uh we know are familiar with a number of companies that provide the perimeter armed guards covert would definitely be mailed in RFP we would then also need to put this in the paper it is a legal ad uh and giving all the pr we are going to receive um sealed rfps by such and such a date they will be all opened at the same time and then we make our analysis because it is um personal services unlike a product um there is uh you know lowest reasonable so you know you don't always go with the
163lowest cost um it's a an in-depth analysis that we make of those received so that's happening that's what I want that's that's so let me explain my board has directed me in this meeting to get an RFP put out an RFP collect that information and build into the budget proposal that cost then the process is that on April I forget the exact date the B the board must vote to adopt or not adopt our budget which then gets passed to the taxpayers to vote on in the May election okay that was my question are we proceeding forward with this we currently proceeding forward with that okay that's it that's it for me thanks and can I just say I just want to be clear but I also want to clear we've also asked covert to
164do an assessment of our security program right I heard that at the same time yeah I heard that earlier we're proceeding forward to get a cost estimate on the topic okay right I understand that you're not proceeding forward to have armed guards outside the school you're proceeding forward to get the numbers okay that's all I want to know as long as we're not having another vote a month from now to do the rfps okay that's happening now okay that's that's my question thank that's it that's all I got and correct me if I'm wrong Tom that that the first time we see those numbers is not going to be in April no no right so this is going to be a process that everyone can be a part of like you come you see you
165look at the the budget proposals you go you be part of the budget meetings and then you see what's you know what's taking and and then we and then we weigh everything out so it's not just okay we show up in April and we're like all right well you know now we have to make we give a budget presentation starting in February with a basic overview of the tax cap and other factors then we do another presentation in March you guys ask lots of questions you can direct me to put things in take things out then we give you a proposal in April and then you vote yeah I mean I know that just and some way along that we should have our Co assessment and by the time we're doing that we'll also have
166an assessment done by covert which will tell us additional things which you know the covert has said that many of the things they suggest are not cost inhibitive they're just structural things or or procedural things so there's going to be a lot of things that we glean from an assessment to better that we could probably put in place immediately for kids that we would want to do like door systems or or something of that nature right I also just want to clarify when Moren wanted to clarify about armed guards versus armed perimeter guards we have as a board received several emails from people that do not understand the difference so we do want to make sure that everyone understands that there is a difference okay thank you right thank you thank you thanks George I
167think one of the most important things that you said Rhonda is that th this type of bid is not lowest bidder wins no and yes um a public bid is normally for a project or um an a particular item when you're dealing with personal services such as our external auditing firms our internal auditing firms our bond counsil we've done a number of rfps um it is not the lowest there's a whole bunch how many years have they been they come in with more a little more money but they're offering the district more um so you know there's um a very thoughtful analysis that's done once we receive all those I think that's important okay any other questions yeah just come on up hi regarding the rfps I know it obviously isn't going to come down
168to money is there someone on the board or in the district who once you get those rfps they'll be able to assess in a knowledgeable way which one is the best one to get not based on cost like what they like who does level of service quity who who examines that level of service who's got that we don't have do based on course well there's an interesting thing here because um that would be Ronda myself and my cabinet team then making recommendation to the Board of Ed and usually we would include our head of security however our head of security now works for covert so we have to consider that as a um conflict of interest so we would have to think about that process but it's not just a um a number thing like
169that's the cheapest number we take that one right we want I just didn't know who would make that who would be able to assess which one would be the best for saille without admittedly not having a head of security the other thing I would do in that case is also call superintendents who have those companies working for them and get feedback about how has it gone what have they done for you has it been smooth has it not been smooth so we have a lot of superintendent colleagues in the community in other communities that would share that information with us so we could help the board make a good de or us make a good decision and recommendation to the board I think it's really I I work with the district I work for works
170we work with Don and covid and the team and we've as a teacher got a tremendous this amount of training as a teacher things you never thought you'd have to know as a teacher but um they're they're super thorough so I think for the record they're they're a fantastic organization and I'm glad that they're on board for and that's why we grabbed them to get us up to speed and we knew we had to do something immediately and I think that's a really good solution to a current you know our first step also if we're gonna go with arm guards I want a company and a and a group who's going to be able to help us manage and support that with good training so you don't just go get armed guards and put them
171you have to have a management firm that kind of trains supports and provides okay thank you yeah outside of the schools right come on Amanda I like your hat thanks the same thing you don't want to know what the hair looks like underneath it um I would like to mirror what this gentleman said and thank our current security guards I've said from the beginning of all of this I've been at this Podium for two years now um fighting for the exact same thing I want armed perimeter guards I've made it clear why I've provided statistics I've done the research you all know how annoying I am with all of this um our team is excellent I've never wanted that to change not once but our previous head of security didn't have a handle on things
172the way company yeah okay great the way that a company like covert can make changes within and outside of our school is what I've been begging for for two years I've presented up here for two years asking for the same thing so while I appreciate the passion of some of my friends and comrades here who support the same thing I predicted the way that this night would go to a tea I said to them I said it to some of you we would not have an answer tonight I am very used to coming up to this Podium and there being an additional delay needing more research wanting more data I've been more than patient and I don't envy any of you for the job that you have to do I don't yeah Moren you you're
173making the big bucks with this job what I have a very hard time of understanding is why it seems that we every time we reach a certain point we stall out and the numbers are just continuing to get worse so I am a numbers person I've always been I quoted numbers last week incorrectly and some of my friends put me right on track um so I'll start with the statistics for this year 2025 there's been 12 shootings to date we're not even out of January 12 school shootings to date in January last year 330 school shootings none of you in this room are equipped to handle that and the security teams that I love are not equipped to stop a shooter with a warm hug I'm Sorry Miss macis they're not it is a collaborative
174effort of what we need to to make the improvements that have to get done so again I stand up here and I implore you as you've been taking this seriously to really think about your voice and your opinion being in the background because at the end of the day it doesn't matter our voices matter what we want is why you are in these seats and you've given the community an opportunity to come out and if they didn't come out sorry not sorry we did and we got almost a thousand signatures standing behind us and last year's budget vote was 2555 people 828 said no guess how many there will be that say no this year if this doesn't go the right way it's not a threat it's a fact the the community has spoken we've
175told you what we want we're asking you to take it seriously thank you all for your [Applause] time good evening everyone uh my name is Cara Corwin and I represent the group of tireless hardworking parents that have been going at bat for this for years and most recently the last few months I know I've said this a million times but I love this town and I love this school I went to this school I was an active member of Athletics in this school I was Captain of teens at this school and I had my Blood Sweat and Tears go into making sure that my children attended saille and everything that they had to offer so when I say I love this town I really do love this town and I love this school um I
176was talking with another parent earlier today and we said we've moved to different places but we always come back home because nothing feels like home like saille does that being said I really wanted to get up here today and thank all of you like I have all of the other board meetings before however there are 70% of the community wants this 29% don't and 1% is unsure I went door too to gather these signatures in the cold I work 40 plus hours a week my children have school activities and sports every single day of the week and my husband works Night hours which is why he's not here today I don't care that it was cold on the night that you had the Forum I don't we were there we showed up our voices were
177heard I'm confused on when the weather determined the Safety and Security of your children if it's important to you you show up the community the comment about being nervous because other people are speaking louder you speak loud for your children that's a mandate of a parent and your job to advocate for your children if you are scared to do that take a seat because this is not the place for you I want to say that this fight was never against our security guards they are amazing our children love them we respect them and we really love everything that they do but that doesn't change the fact that they're unarmed and the response time from local law enfor enforcement is absolutely unacceptable I said this time and time again I work in banking I've had to
178pull that hold up button I don't want my kids to wait that long since our last meeting there have been two school shootings that have occurred the most frequent one was just yesterday with two casualties this shooting was instigated through online messages as we've seen here in our community the shooters said that they were inspired by the shooting that occurred just a week prior to that and it took the police because there were no armed guards at that school 10 minutes to get there so I urge you all to go home tonight and sit in your room for 10 minutes and tell me when that 10 minutes feels like 10 hours and then tell me that you want your children to sit in a room for 10 minutes and wait for somebody to come help
179them I also want to reiterate again like I've said before at The Forum and at other meetings that this entire cost could almost be offset as desmin said before by the savings that we have for the paneling I urge you as a board to listen to your community we have been at this for some of us for years some of us last for months and there's no more data that needs to be collected from the community that you work for we are here our voices have been heard if you haven't come out if you haven't made your voice heard you don't care enough we're here we care we need this to be done thank [Applause] you anybody else I can't take credit for that by the way that was your idea yeah how you doing
180guys happy to be here again again let's make that clear I love the security in our school I think they're awesome I think they would agree that it would be nice to have an outside security staff or somebody outside the building armed perimeter guards outside the building just in case there was an emergency all right now I'm going to get back to before when I was yelling and and upset because you know what we were all under the impression that the the the community was going to have a chance to come out and speak at a forum The Forum happened whether you had 180 people sign up and only 100 showed up the hundred who showed up cared the other 80 didn't really care that much we were told that what was found in the
181per uh in the Forum was going to be what we base things off of but now a few minutes ago I was told well we want to extend it it's got to be broader we've got to look further into it what are we looking further into you told us the Forum was going to be the leadup to to this that's that's just one of my points Kelly before you said it's your job to be prepared for everything and you're working constantly but at the regionalization two weeks ago when Dr Ferris said all right we're gonna have to vote there were quite a few I gotta look more into it when Dr Ferris replied well let's due Tuesday and we didn't have nobody looked into it but we had to put a vote out there why
182would I trust you we'll pull up the I'll pull up the video in a few minutes but why would I trust you guys why should we trust you guys 70% of the community who cared came out and said what we wanted but you're not listening I know you're going to do an RFP but your faces the actions the way you're responding they tell the story no you guys don't want it you don't want it I think it's unfair of you to say that yeah I you know what that's fine you you can have that opinion too the problem is is you're the voice of us and the 71% of those people who voted for you to be the voice of us are now left waiting for you to be the voice of us and I'm
183just not saying it why would I trust you we're going to talk about budgets Dr Ferris let's let's call it spade a spade we now have a PR team with you we now have a private or a third party investigator looking into you none of us voted for that that where did that money come from that's not accurate okay well whatever it is but our budget did not specify we were going to do that it didn't where is it coming from and I'm not against you I'm starting to turn against you guys because I don't trust you I don't and I think a lot of people here don't trust you and there's a couple seats that are coming up and you know things are going to change the people are going to change the budget's
184going to get shot down if it's not in there it's gonna get shot down now why wasn't why didn't we look at three security firms get prices and have that answered why do we not have that the RFB it's been months now man it's been months we did if I if I didn't do my job I wouldn't have a job and I own my own company I would still quit and go to work for some we got basic estimates now we have to go out an official we did talk to three security firms we did meet with security firms we hired a security firm no and I love These Guys these guysen being a little bit unfair to say that no one's doing anything we're giving you the runaround we're taking every step we possibly
185can take to ensure that we go forward all right so I understand your upsetment I know you want it to happen today I just want to have faith in you guys that something's gonna happen but I have I also want to say we never said that we would make a decision and the next day we would have oned guards we said this is going to be a process you guys called covert in here this week to throw the smoke screen up and calm us all down we all know that that's not true or fair to say and we explained we explained before the reason that we're we're allowed to go into a contract with covid is because we already have a contract with bosies if we go with armed guards there has to be an
186RFP because it's it's not covered by boses that's why we can't move forward further if we're going to go with armed guard we have to have something like cover in place so how is it not part of the process to get to where we're going I understand that part I do understand that part of it but what I'm not understanding is why did we not have these things set already why are you guys not figuring that out why it's still gonna be wrapped into the budget no matter what it's we know we know that it's GNA get wrapped into the budget but at some point we want to know for sure it's going is it for sure going just told me to get rfps and put it into the budget presentation that's pretty much the
187process they they have to do anything do the budget now they have to vote on the budget in April it's the law you trust them to vote but I I think I I think the one the one thing that is in if if it had come back 7030 the other way we wouldn't be having this disc no no we would we would doing I think the fact actually I'm not giving up I will keep coming for years my child is in first grade I'll be here for 11 more years and if I'm anything like Dolan I'll be here forever I ain't leaving I'm I'm GNA sit down I I said my piece no no I just want I just want to I just want to um just like I just want to address it like
188so I I think like I said if it was 7030 the other way would be no conversation right but the fact that it was 7030 in in favor of the fact that everybody on the board agreed whether whether we all agree or not about it the fact that everybody agreed to go get the rfps and to go and to take that next step is is a step in the right direction regardless of what I can't I can't speak for anybody I add we were further January 7th was the event yeah we spent three days in a row of Amy did and her team crunching it so it could be readable right because you have all these notes right gave it to the board on a Thursday reviewed it put the presentation together the very next
189meeting we present and we go out and we've been directed by the board to go out for an RFP and put it put it into a budget presentation that is as fast as the governmental process of a board of education in any situation could ever run there's there's no other way to move it forward I just feel like you know we could have can I I just want to say something since I've been here forever yes you told me that last time you said it I use your words no no and I enjoy you what I what I do know is the process in education takes longer than in business unfortunately because the state requires certain things in place so this is a process and we just didn't call them up say find their name
190in the phone book and call them we looked at other people too so we know that they're a good firm that's what I have to say and I can't you can't I don't know anyone who would be able to argue that having this in place cover right now is a step in the right direction for the Saville schools in terms of the management of our security and that everything is the stage being set for the next step in the conversation I don't think anybody would disagree with that we all agree with that but we don't want to stop that's what scares that was not as a bait and switch that was done because it was necessary for the schools and the feedback from the for was directly yeah we need to put lots of things
191in place to make sure that we are 100% safer than we currently are and i' just like to add one more thing as far as the rfps whether we have them ready to go today or we asked them to get into place now first of all they still be going into the budget in the same time timeline but a more important thing is that we're always asked to be very public about things we had to have this discussion we had to look at the data with all of you so that you understand why we're putting the rfps in place uh we had a meeting last week let's say we oh let's just put the rfps in place and then someone comes and says why did you do that you didn't even have the data yet
192you didn't even present it to the public yet so it I hope you understand that this this is the process no one it's a thankless job I totally understand I also want to say nobody said the data wasn't accurate because the weather was cold and 40 people in trouble it was just a factual statement that it was cold and we' lost 40 people that we would have liked to have had that doesn't mean that the data isn't accurate in fact in fact statistically speaking the data reflects the community I think actually during that presentation someone said it's cold thank you for coming for the people who were there because it was so cold it was the opposite so I still like the Forum I mean I think was a good and it was purposeful and
193we're using the data to make the decisions I want to trust you guys well not quite right can I say I I I I enjoy you I get a kick out of you but can I can I just just for the community in general but but only because of some of the things you said I understand that people are passionate about this and that you want it done yesterday and and that you're frustrated by the process and I apologize for that because I think we all explained that it's it's it's frustrating to work to the process yeah well you guys don't want to keep that it sucks ter I want you to be conscious though and I want you to be mind of that when you come up and you're upset or you're you're um
194you're animated and then you start to throw things out that aren't necessarily factual that lead to more chatter and more distrust it it it's not helping the situation it's not allowing us to be able to speak freely and and and and have a conversation you you just like lobbed a bunch of things that we then have to clarify and say well those things are't true and they feel like attacks and I don't know that's what you meant but it it's it's hard you know when when you make comments that you're not 100% sure correct so let me let me clarify a couple of those because I really think it's important um we have always had a PR person in the district for as long as I I think the district you there's and that is
195a salary line in the in the budget that was about $63,000 plus health benefits is about $85,000 the district similarly to um covert which a team can do more than any one person a PR firm which has a website specialist which has a newsletter specialist which has photographers which has a video filmographer which has crisis management response can provide and we've been talking about this since the summer actually um can provide a greater service to the district than one person so our person on staff costs us $80,000 we have a contract through bosis which costs us $80,000 it's aable so we'll get $40,000 back so we get a team of PR people doing all of those things to promote really soccer games football games um play is all the things that we want to put
196out in the world that are good about our schools and make SAA look great for our community uh for half the cost it's something the district should be doing uh that has nothing to do with specific incidents that you're trying to tie it to or that people will tie it to but I just wanted to clarify that fair okay fair thank you I listen to you guys I I take it all in right thank you I do and we listen to you goe short people um I just think some of the frustration that I'm observing tonight is more or less that the community was expecting something that didn't come forward I myself did as well I was coming in to hear a presentation from covert with the expectation that an assessment had already been done
197and they were coming to tell us what would be placed what the job and expectation would be of the Armed perimeter guard because you can't put an RFP out without having that expectation and I think that's what people wanted to hear what's going to be be expected of these guards what will their job be you know they they describe their company wonderfully I know of them I work in the education field um I love our guards that we have I know many of them as well from their previous jobs but that's not what people heard tonight and I think the time laps I understand how it all works in the process of the board and getting all bids and all of that but what I didn't hear was what is our expectations of these guards
198what are we looking for them to do for our children and then what is that RFP plan because when you get your multiple bids you have to make sure that those bids are going to be providing the same quality of service when you put out the RFP you have to be very specific about what you're asking for and I would like covert security who we now are employing to help us design the system that we would so I think people thought that already taken place if you notice the last my email to the community was we are hiring C commun cover Securities to um you hired them for one job and now you're well their management but the management included if you looked at the bulleted list in my email included an assessment of the
199district and and direct feedback to the district about how to move forward with security right so when you said assessment of the district I think people under thought that that assessment already happened we just hired them last week okay like I said a communication piece so I think that's part of email been a long time that this discussion has had and I do think you hear but I I wrote what everyone said the in my email to the community which had words in it that basically said we're hiring CO security to manage our security to take on the leadership it's going to do these things there's a bulleted list of the things they're doing including an audit including uh suggesting to us what we should be doing and effective February 1 so they were just
200coming here to show they're showing us what they do so then the next would be you'll have a second meeting with what their findings were and what we're expecting perimeter guards to do eventually there'll be a budget presid but that's different budget presentation is a monetary piece prior to that because when you have your budget pres budget presentation you've already put out your bids right so our question is is what's going to be the job of the perimeter armed guards prior to the we have to Define that right with our Security Experts giving us back and then show the board what we're doing so the question was though there'll be a sec a meeting we're going to have me every weeks you put the bids out you would have to with the community so that
201everybody feels that they've been heard and they well I would not want to I'm not going to do that what I would propose is that so you're just going to make up the assessment not tell the community and put you're putting words in my mouth that make it sound like we're responding to our comments right you want us to go fast but you also want us to uh you know have a meeting to discuss what we're going to do and be transparent we're trying to be transparent and also move fast so cob security would help us put together a job responsibility then Ronda would put it out as an RFP and then at the very next board meeting we report out on what we put out I don't think we would have time to wait
202for a community meeting to get feedback on what we should be putting in the job description I think we're going to trust cover Community to do the job we hired them to do to help us with that description I believe goes out yes it's a public RFP it does it's transparent I mean I have you're not I'm just saying I think the lack the frustration that was being felt was that some of that would have already been done that was going to be presented that's all and I can update the community about what we're putting out and the you I hear Sor I could update the community when it the time comes the RFP was put out this is what the description was thanks yeah thank you any others okay okay so I'm just trying
203to understand this whole process so you're saying you're going to get the rfps it would potentially go in the budget and then you all are going to vote if that budget is going to go forward is that right yeah that's the budget we present to the public okay but from the looks on some people's faces um it seems like there are people that would not want it in the budget so then what happens then there's a vote just amongst you I know majority vote amongst the board and then and then and then what and then and then the Thousand Community signatures that we have the 70% that we have from the forums that just goes out the window no they use that to inform their vote you have to vote on it no no I
204know what a vote is I got it but I but I'm saying if you all don't if you all don't decide if you if you decide that armed guards are you do not want that then then it's just a dead we're done that's very that's very upsetting you're not done you're not done we live in a community what we live in a community just like somebody indicated there's elections you know there there's there's there's other possibilities we need to get other people in the seats to make it happen I think you're putting the car on I think you're putting the car before the horse because you need to let us you know uh have the vote first and then you'll see I know but I'm just saying City back here and watching the faing faces
205coming this way and we're talking about wanting more research and then not even making eye contact with the people that are up here giving the research is very telling it's very telling well I just want to say if four people vote for it and three vote against it it goes right and you know but you know what's sad about that is I just looked at a pie chart with 70% of the community it's not 70% they had they had ample opportunity to come out ample opportunity they they did we've done all the research we know what the response time is and you heard the co the cover man stands up here and he said that's number one and you're not even looking at me now what I'm talking and it's like so upsetting though it's
206so upsetting itward okay I don't know what else no just a minute just a minute the fact of the matter is that the from Culvert stood up here and he said the number one issue was response time that's it the the mic drops that's it okay that's it and who brought the man from the from the cobt here these guys yeah no we love it we're happy we want that we want that but it's still that man is standing up here he still is not able to put people with armed guns in the hands of the people to protect our children okay we understand it we cannot move it any faster than we're already moving it that's that's the okay uh do have someone else would like to speak okay just just a minute you
207can come up and speak just come up just come up go ahead no please just come up and speak so we can you people at home can hear you because you speak into a microphone and it goes directly to the online viewers so if you want to speak please do just come up also we can't always hear you from back there please just come up I just have one loud can you could just come up to the mic only because the online people can't hear you more effort for me to walk up I think that a a lot of the frustration myself included and I respect everybody on this board and I hope you know that the frustration comes from us not knowing your personal opinions yeah and every time we ask it's sort of
208a blanket response which I understand that you you kind of feel like you have to do but we're begging you not to we're begging you to kind of give us some insight as to where you stand so that way we know coming into April what to expect and then maybe we can sit down much like a security Forum okay and have a conversation and say you know hi Desmond I'm Amanda let's get to know why you feel the way that you do and let's share some ideas because I think us as a community with every topic that comes into this room we don't know what any of you are thinking about it discussions are had behind closed doors things are talked about quietly and privately and I get that I respect the process I really
209do but with something as sensitive as protecting our children we have a right to know where the people that we elect into the these seats feel where they stand um I you will know the board's decision before April I mean because the budget is going to be developed you know before then so I think you have to respect the process because once we get the the pieces of information then we'll have we'll we'll make a decision whether to put it in the budget or or not put it in the budget no I get that I think it's the it's the the process leading up too also keep in mind one of the comments that was um reported on by Amy's data collection was that one person came in with an opinion and when they left
210they had another opinion so that's important to remember because that could be happening right here right now all of this information when everybody gets up to speak and tells us how they feel that's all important information that we take in influen to help us make our decision and influence and I I I agree with that and I I respect that you guys are hearing us um you know I think a b piece of this too and that what I've spoke about I spoke about it at our forum is the side where there has to be trust right like that's something that our district really pushes as part of the strides is the trust and I think that there's a huge wall between this side of the room and this side of the room and I
211don't want that anymore I don't want it for you I don't want it for us I don't want it for the staff I have a really great relationship with every single person in my building um and I work really hard at that I want them to be able to come to me and have conversations and be candid and trust me and I want the same for me to them I think that as a board and as a community we need to fight to bridge this Gap because it is really difficult to come to these meetings month after month year after year and feel the Divide I I want to respond right to that cuz that's a very good point I know you're other than PTA yes and you have that ability as a single person
212to talk to anybody in your building and they to you y on the board it is different we are a collective unit of seven people so we are required to respond as a unit we do all have different opinions that's true of course uh we you know take into consideration what the community says and and that influences us but we just like we can't um respond specifically to emails right this is a good this is a good example someone sent us an email we cannot respond back to that person what our opinion is because we are a board I wouldn't want uh Tom to respond to an email with an opinion he has that I don't share Ag and vice vers we do the same for the PTA it we we vote as a board
213we take stance as a board I understand that process I just wanted to make mention of that because sometimes that gets lost uh on some people right I want to add two things if you don't mind um one the board is not allowed to discuss these kind of things in private quarters they have to discuss it in public session so even if like a topic comes up in exec the only things we discuss in exec or fall under six categories which would be like you know private uh staffing issues legal issues contracted negotiations things of that nature which have to be confidential sure a student issue that's confidential things of that nature uh any discussion like this has to be done in a public form so even when we're doing reminders in our text app
214like reminder the meetings at 6:30 tonight be sure to be on time and someone says oh are we talking about X we say oh can't talk about that it's not it's got to be done in a public session so this I I just want to kind of debunk the idea or try to debunk the idea that uh these discussions are happening behind closed doors that these guys have all decided something and that they just haven't shared it with you they're only allowed to discuss this topic in public in this meeting when they're in a room of seven if there are three of them in another space they actually can't talk about it together uh it's not it's not legal they have to do it in this setting with a quorum which would be a minimum
215of four right so but we have seven so um there is no discussion other than the the board discussion and I don't know you know there's no there's been no meetings where they've decided something and then said let's just say this at the board meeting no and I I I understand that our bylaws are pretty much the exact same thing the other thing I wanted to just uh add is you and I have had this discussion for two years and something I said that was important to me when this came up this last time was I don't want to be in the same situation like the wash cycle where we go around in a circle we end up in the same place and then we haven't gotten anywhere and you have said to me that
216you have felt some sense of hope because we have done things differently this year and you're sitting in a room where the two years ago this would have been a non-starter conversation because of the world we lived in has changed the world has changed right now we're sitting in a room where the board has said to the superintendent get an RFP put it in your budget presentation that's so different than anything you've experienced in the last two years I agree and and and that's the relationship that I think that we all want is for us to be able to come into a room and feel that you are on our side and that we're not asking you for a vote I'm not saying Christine please vote right now in front of me but I can
217and I should be able to say what is your opinion can I can I just like honestly disagree with that yeah because what I'm hearing you say is you got the data and 70% of us are in favor of that and you meaning me have to follow that so you're not really interested in my personal opinion you want my personal opinion to be your opinion reflect your op yeah no I don't want I have to be blatantly honest with you I'm not I haven't formulated my full opinion yet I I see that and and it's the honest truth and I appreciate the honesty and I think that that's a lot of us here there's a lot to take in there's a lot of obviously pressure and I said this at the meeting two meetings ago
218no matter what decision we make is a group we're have a lot of unhappy people yeah right so yes there are people in this room are are showing up consist ly and in voicing their opinion and the people who did show up may be a good reflection of the community but it's still a very small number and that doesn't mean it's not an important number it doesn't mean you are correct you showed up you you and you continue to do so they could also have emailed over the last three months but but but there have been but there the poent all of that is really important yes so and I and and there are people who have that this is very black and white and then there's a whole lot of things in the middle
219so I I understand that you're frustrated I understand you want an answer right now and I don't actually I don't want an answer right now I want the care that you are all promising to put into it the trust comes with patience I'm sorry like it does we only get to talk about this every two weeks we don't we're not friends we don't hang out with each other we don't see each other we barely even text each other we're not allowed to have conversations as a group it's the most frustrating thing on earth I've worked in organizations and in in elected positions my entire career and this is fascinating I just have to say so a little Grace a little grace that we are trying to do the due diligence and and and move a
220process forward and find a way that we can put our heads to sleep at night and that we've done what we need to do right and and and I I'm sorry that doesn't give you the answer that you want right now I can we just take a deep breath and give us a little patience and I I think that we have I I understand the frustrations that are coming out from members of the community I have been patient I've been patient for two years I've stood up at this Podium every single time with respect and and and I think that that the attitudes and things may have changed in those two years so I'm not sure that you didn't get anything you're just not getting it fast enough and I understand that right I get
221it I but I but it's not going to happen tomorrow and I think that's got to be what and I don't think that the expectation is that it will happen tomorrow I'm just trying to advocate for having an open dialogue with you the community being able to come up here and openly speak about how they feel and having some type of relationship where we work together I hate coming to every single meeting and somebody's screaming at you guys and you're defending yourselves and you're living by the letter of the law I get it Jackie and I deal with it on a regular basis I understand a very small snippet of that I had a conversation with Dr Ferris not that long ago we only have 440 students parents that we have to mediate conversations with
222you have an entire District as I said I don't envy the positions you're in right you know and and I appreciate what you're saying and I think that's why we're taking this topic so seriously right and we're we're trying to get as much information as we can from the community as well well so um in the essence of time because it's getting late for everybody um if anybody else wants to speak uh I I would I'd like to take one more comment and can I just before you speak do you mind I didn't know it's GNA be the closer so right um So Christine was I don't know if the word's brave enough but she gave her opinion which is which is her honest opinion and I don't want her to be the only one
223to feel like she's by herself um but I will say I I I said I don't know if it was two or three meetings ago but I believe it was the meeting I was in the the middle school I said that I did not feel strongly either way and I wasn't sure how I felt that I wanted to hear from you and those were my exact words and then I did and I sat down with an amazing group of people um I met a whole bunch of different people that were in the group and I I felt like between petitions talking to people in town people that I that whose opinions I value and people that I trust and the people at my table who um were a perfect like microcosm I felt like of
224the district that I I I felt that this was the way to go and that this was you know something that we should seriously look into what I will also say is that to Echo kind of what Christine said and what Tom has said and what Mark has said um everybody in here has been extremely open-minded um there's there's nobody in here um that had is completely shutting doors on things and um you know it it it every everyone has been open-minded and listening and I think what Christine was trying to say is so much has happened in two years and you know opinions that may have been held two years ago may be shifted and like Kelly said even somebody was shifted within the Forum so I I do think that's important I think
225maybe we can clean up communication um I I did think that Mark's email was you know fairly clear but if we can clean up communication and then people have um you know a different understanding of what they're walking into then maybe we can kind of you know that that can kind of calm some of the the emotions because this is an emotional topic but I just felt that um that's that's my opinion on on the on the topic um I I do think that Mark has done things that I've never seen done in a district uh so I I think you know on this topic I think that he should be commended because I I think he has been like pretty Forward Thinking when it comes to some of these things and extremely uh listening
226to community members and taking in all sides and to be honest he has he has been very um I don't know what the word is but has listened to us yes when it when it comes to you know what we bring to him so um I just wanted to share that thank you now it's close the show all right no no pressure at all uh okay um bear with me I'm not used to reading off of my phone so my name is Caitlyn Foy I'm a parent of two uh that sunrise drive thank you for all the time and work you've put in to the conversation of armed guards I've spoken once before in November and was very satisfied to learn that we would have a community Forum where many would be speaking and they
227would be breaking up into groups uh I was impressed with this school with what they do now regarding security with what they had and um I'm home now but my experience and my degree is in school counseling so I really appreciated all that the school and the school district does with the mental health aspects but in the end and it all comes down to exactly what covert said a response time situations when seconds count so during our focus group we heard from a seoc police Lieutenant who explained to us the various training exercises and activities that they do for shooter situations and to my dismay I was shocked to hear that he was inable unable to provide response times and he gave the rationale that giving response times would somehow embolden what he called the
228bad guys I was further dist stretched to hear that their best response on any given day would be two police officers maybe a third responding from areas of not just saille but possibly responding from Pat hog and bport again in a time when seconds matter I also learned that school resource officers are spread out through multiple schools and the most dismaying thing was the closing statement from the lieutenant uh who essentially said that he received the actor active shooter training and he found it difficult to complete and he would just figure it out in a real situation uh we have no control now that me we realize over what officers show up to our school we don't know they're training we don't know how good they shoot we don't know their target we don't know
229how in shape they are something we have no control over and I think it further proves our point that we should rely on our own private armed security for our first line of defense while we aate further resources because again seconds matter we have about 1.5 million people living in Sea County and only 2 200 are police officers and of course they all don't work at once and some of them are supervisors and they're in the station so to rely on a department with such limited Personnel when we could have our own private armed security to me makes no sense with such a limited amount of officers on the road it was eye openening to hear and then to realize that if they were involved in another series call like let's say a child is
230choking or in some sort of grave danger they're they're not going to leave that child which means our children will remain in danger for longer until the next closest officer can come so while I immensely appreciate the dedication of our police forces the unique demands of school safety require a solution that is more immediate and personalized private armed security offer these advantages and will allow our teachers and our school staff to never feel that they are waiting long for help to arrive thank you thank [Applause] you thank you and I just want to say you you all had valid points and it will make an impact on our decision okay thank you we have to vote on the yeah I know I have to the agenda no that's where got okay so um moving on
231to our agenda I need a motion for items uh recommending actions item 601 to 807 uh sorry 701 to 807 motion second discussion discussion okay all those in favor against motion passes and I need a motion for recommend uh for new business 90 uh item 90 to uh 102 discussion that was Kelly and Christine got that okay no discussion all those in favor against motion passes and then I have um upcoming dates this meeting went on so long my laptop laptop hold I got it I got it I got it right here January 29th is yeah it's gone my my Lunar New Year schools will be closed January 30th Is All District Strings night at 7:30 p.m. in the Middle School February 4th all district chorus concert at 7:30 in the high school February 12th
232the middle school high school PTA talent show 6 p.m. to 9:00 P p.m. in the middle school and February 13th is our Board of Education workshop at 7:30 p.m. be there or be square thank you okay um that concludes our public I want to make one comment really super quick sure um when we talk about the calendar for when do we talk about the calendar for next year the next meeting okay perfect thank you okay see that okay I need a motion to go into exec session to discuss particular Personnel all those in favor against okay good night everybody