001evening everyone and welcome to the 2025 Equity committee meeting um The Time Is Now 543 and I am summer Hall your chair and Dr Renee Muller um the co-chair so we will begin today with um Keith licky Clifford thank you Wonder all right well s all right how about that all right well thank you madam uh summer hall for letting uh us be here today my name is Keith lick I'm the director of school Improvement I brought Chrissy Sims with me uh as well she's a coordinator in the school Improvement office and we wanted to talk to you today about our local Equity action plan um something that we uh support in the office of school Improvement uh under Carla's leadership now I have clicked my click share button um but I don't see the
002presentation switching up top so maybe Tech could help us uh get that up there I think there's a hardwire thing maybe they did back there there we go all right um so we wanted to start off off with maybe a little bit of our technical language and I think you have a copy of the presentation let's see what's happening here so my computer just decided to load in all my add-ins so uh let's give that a second to close those out first time signing into this device here we go all right um so you know what's uh so the every student succeeds act outlines uh a lot of the rules and regulations that we have to do in the office of school Improvement uh is the Avenue in which we receive our tital one in
003federal funds and and part of meeting the compliance and the every student succeeds Act is we have to have a school Improvement plan and that school Improvement plan has to address uh equity and explicitly Equity gaps in equity in the state of Ohio does grade us on a rubric on our action step and and how well we're looking at the data and analyzing the data and so I know we had another group just looking at the blueprint for excellence and one of the things just for some background information one of the things that our office does is we make sure our district uh documents are aligned with what we file with the state of Ohio or the Department of Education and Workforce so we have a we have a three-year plan in their language that
004you'll often hear us Us in the district talk about our one plan and we update that every 3 years and it is also aligned to the blueprint for excellence and so I say all of that because um why do I say all of that because a big part of that plan and meeting the Essa guidelines is making sure that our equ that we're talking about equity and we're closing gaps ensuring that every child has Equitable access to high quality education I know everybody in this room uh believes than that and so what uh Dew has given to us is this leap planning process and we're going to go through here kind of a high level today uh but then have an opportunity to ask questions or give you more information if you like but leap
005stands for local Equity access plan uh and so what you have represented on the screen is a is an improvement process so uh we have one called OIP Ohio improvement process that we follow like a fstep guide uh you've probably heard the superintendent talk about datawise which is Harvard's uh scientific improvement process but very simply it is we look at data we interpret the data we create a plan and then you know we work that plan and we look at the data and measure it and so we're going to walk you through a little bit about what our team will be doing this year as we dive into our uh equity data so first of all the who um so this work as I dive in and start sharing with you some of the data
006that we do collect uh in akine you're going to notice it touches every facet of the organization so uh all of the cornerstones that you're talking about in The Blueprint are also represented in stakeholders here um so for example when we think about the district and School administration um you know where tapping into uh we're tapping into talent and organizational development with Mr Larry Johnson we're tapping into uh human capital with Todd wamas because we're talking about how we staff and recruit we tap into obviously our Equity office we tap into teaching and learning because how do we support teachers and principles so that that right there is a big group already uh Federal programs as a stakeholder as I mentioned we're sort of the um uh we're the compliance uh police making sure that
007we're compliant um so that we continue to receive those dollars our our parents and our students are stakeholders in this because uh all of this all of our programming our teachers um you know what we're offering across the district is important that it's meeting their needs our community organizations now I do you know I haven't been on this Committee in a couple years um but I think this is those two areas are probably areas that we could grow and and as our teams are exploring uh find more ways to get feedback around these areas because you know I think of uh you know we have a lot of surveys in place now about your educational experience but maybe not so much in this Equity lens so that's an area we might want to explore uh
008I already mentioned HR staff and then of course teacher and teacher leaders are a big part of the stakeholders in this work uh so as I mentioned the first step is to analyze the data and that's what we're going to show you a little bit about um and what OD has done uh you know we have I I know you know drct or Zack hanshaw who leads our technology services department and he has a fabulous team who takes our whole student information system uh where you guys are getting all of your data about our teachers and our substitutes and cour and grades uh all of that gets Fe fed into emis and reported to the state and so what the state has done is they have grabbed uh information from emis that we're reporting and
009put it in a tool for us to help us analyze the data so that's this leap tool and this is our second year for this tool so we're kind of new at this tool as well it used to come to us in a giant spreadsheet and then you had to sort of make sense of what all this information was in the in the spreadsheet uh another thing I wanted to mention is this data is always a year in the rear so we talk about this a lot in graduation I know I was listening to a board meeting they were talking about the report card and we're saying you know when we celebrate that graduation rate it's really those kids from a year ago because we want to make sure we get all those summer graduates
010we roll that in so as we talk about this data same thing uh because we're look looking at courses uh and course offerings and Staffing uh you you have to get that data at the end of the year crunch the numbers so that we're you know uh we're able to make some sense of that and so uh you can see that Dew had partners and worked uh with stakeholders in Ohio again to develop this tool and chrisy and I just really got some more training around it this October I think we went to our federal uh administrators conference in Columbus where we got a little bit more training and then uh we had a meeting with Carla and some team members from Zach's Department with a little bit more one-on-one support as well um so
011we're anyway we're excited to be able to use this new Tool uh and essentially uh if I didn't mention it already all of this leads to helping us identify the gaps so what are the gaps that we have across our district in certain areas and I'll get to those areas in just a minute uh so here they are so the big measures that OD is looking at um are up here on the screen so the first is out of field teachers and so that measure means you know are you qualified do hold the right credentials to teach the course you're teaching um so that's a big measure uh inexperienced teachers that just means how many years do you have of on the job experience and so obviously uh the the threshold is 2 years and
012so we can't really do much about that we're going to get new teachers people are going to retire they're going to come in but uh as we talk about the so what of this data it's so then what do we do with our new teachers how do we support them right and how do we make sure they're uh prepared for the classroom uh not yet effective teachers so this relates to otz so that's the evaluation system here in Ohio so teachers who are in the bottom two categories are labeled not yet effective uh then they're also looking this is a new one for us frequently absent teachers uh so they're uh sharing with us now data that they pull out of our own system uh and any teacher who misses more than 10 days of
013school is considered a frequently absent teacher uh and then another new one for us this year is no enrollment in advanced courses um so they're looking at the amount of courses that we offer to our students and then what's that comparison uh into the high level so AP uh IB CCP uh college credit plus courses and then lastly inexperienced principles so just like teachers how many of our principles have less than two years experience so those are the categories that we're measuring uh and then that is compared against different groups of students and so these are four ferally uh these are four ferally designated groups um that we must measure uh so we have students of color uh students and so this this group is just measuring black students versus white students uh that's the
014comparison and then students who are economically disadvantaged so uh this measure is looking at students identified economic versus not same with students with disabilities they either have a disability or they don't in this calculation and then students learning English compared to students who are proficient in English uh so those are the four groups um I think Miss Carla wanted to jump in on your okay yes thank you uh Madam chair so I want to just clarify that while this tool measures the six educator measures the inexperienced out of fi absent um enrollment and inexperienced principles against the four uh categories that you see uh here it does not represent a complete and total big picture analysis that I would call an equity data dashboard it is a portion of the type of data that an
015equity data dashboard would also give us so we would be looking for uh academic achievement AC across these measures and categories suspension data across those measures and categories student absence uh English learning students I would even want zip code data exposure to violence and so just want to reiterate that this is uh a more detailed version of a snapshot of data not the overarching Equity data dashboard that we've discussed the need for in previous meetings thank you that's a great point I think another way to put that like this is the floor this is the federal requirement of some things that we must do um but we know we can do better um so with that uh so again just in recap this tool that I'm going to show you a screenshot of the main
016page it is uh looking at the six areas above um and then comparing them with those uh with those four student groups and so our team uh will be looking at this tool and really um looking at it to identify the gaps so which group of students are most disadvantaged uh what's our biggest concern what's our biggest priority you know we're not going to be able to tackle everything at once but when our team uh gets together uh I don't think I mentioned it yet the data just dropped 48 hours ago um so we had been talking to Carla about the importance of getting these teams and meetings started again um and it and we know that every January to look for the data and and as I mentioned it just it just dropped so
017when the team gets together uh we're going to take them through the dashboards and look at the data and try to focus on what are the big buckets what are the big rocks that we need to talk about um first and um just again to add more to how we identify the gaps it is a root cause analysis so it is not us sitting and coming up with our own uh theories and ideas about why these things are occurring it is looking at data going deep asking five wi's really talking through uh why are we here at this particular data point so really drilling down and asking critical questions having deliberative dialogue making each other uncomfortable sometimes about what we're learning that is a great point and I think that's going to come up more
018in in maybe step two I like the data part I like to get messy and dirty and unpack the data Christy and I have been having fun we've been even some things that surprised us today even just looking more closely at the data and I think um that's my favorite part and then yeah getting into the root cause and and um and then when you're doing the root cause it's like what is it you know if we fix this problem if we fix this symptom you know will will that fix the problem uh so I want to show you this is kind of what the main dashboard looks like and we we did make the decision not to go live today because a wrong click or two could take us into some personal data with
019uh principal and teacher names um so this this tool is provided in a reports portal that's accessible to administrators uh and central office staff through our safe account with DW uh I am sorry I do not uh Carla asked me to bring those to and in my preparation it did slip my mind so they don't have this I do apologize I will get that to you post post meeting it's very similar so I mentioned the data dropped 48 hours ago we turned this slide deck in last week so we wanted to be able to show you the most up to-date data so in your slide deck you'll notice at the top so I guess this is a great talking point group on your upper right hand corner corner of your slide how many gaps do
020you have 70 what and how many gaps do we have this year so we're not moving in the right direction so see I did this on purpose so now you can compare you can compare two years worth of data um so so let's take a look at uh if you if you see uh as I mentioned we're looking at different groups so on the left hand side of your screen um you'll see we have out of field teacher we have the not yet Effective Teacher the inexperienced teacher the frequently absence teacher and the no enrollment Advanced courses so there are those big categories and then across the top you'll see those first set of red bars that's the comparison uh in students of color so last year how many of our schools had gaps in
021out of field students of color what is on your paper six six how many gaps do we have now out of field teachers students of color we have 10 so uh they are not the same buildings but we have we have uh 10 buildings instead of six uh and so that that number is going in the wrong direction uh so if we go down the list there in students of color um well let me just go back to the 10 so that means 10 schools and we'd have to drill down deeper to see how many teachers it is but that's what's nice with this Tool uh our team will be able to rightclick on that number they'll see which schools those are and then they'll even see which teachers those are and sometimes and this
022is going to be part of the cleanup and part of the conversations we have with carlot and her team one of the things that we have to do is make sure we're really clean with our data because bad data sent to OD will uh trigger a gap that's not real and I'll give you an a real life example from your set of data we haven't gotten deep enough into the new data yet but we had a principle who accidentally scheduled themselves probably not they probably did it for a reason they put a placeholder in the system and put themselves as a second grade math teacher well they're not licensed to teach second grade they weren't really teaching second grade um but it accidentally made its way down to Dew so then you know that was
023a bad day to point back so one of the things that we'll do is make sure our data is clean our systems are clean and we're providing support and so probably getting ahead of myself but that could be a potential action step in the future that you know we have processes and syst in place to make sure things are clean and airfree let me stop there for a moment it looks like we have a question thank you yes so for clarity I know you said the data is a year back and the data just dropped so the one that's up here this is is this one 2223 or is this one 23 24 go ahead oh gosh 23 24 okay so this is 23 24 and this one's 22 23 I'm going to label that
024for myself thank you thank you and I think I don't know if we had that on on camera so on the screen right now is 23 24 you have 22 23 uh and so just I guess a little bit if you know I feel like Dr mullar you're a numbers person uh so the way they this is uh based on a ratio so the gaps are determined by taking the um like they would take the students of color uh how many students of color have an inexperienced teacher how many white students have an inexperienced teacher they would calculate that ratio anything greater than a 1.5 represents a gap um and so uh 10 of our schools have a ratio greater than 1.5 all right I have a quick question yes ma'am um I'm sorry will
025you finish with that I am do I have to well no cuz you're you're doing the most talking so no quick question um um Miss Carla um when we had talked a while ago about how students with like disabilities sometimes it was also like our International Community too did we talk about that before I can't remember or I may have been talking about it with someone instru it was an instructional policy okay now I see because like the numbers right when they say students with disabilities but then you also include our students that have language barrier as a disability too which is not really a disability but we say it is because they're not speaking English but with this breakdown I see students with disabilities and students learning English so are we now like have
026we noticed that and now we're separating those two instead of being one uh it's always been a federal subgroup for us so we talk about it all the time in our world of school Improvement and uh it's the Chrissy you might have to help me out if uh I can't remember a time where we weren't looking at limited English profession or El students it's it's been a subgroup for us from Dew for a long time but I like I think you were touching on I like to call it like multiple Footprints so uh an inexperience so in this case an inexperienced teacher could be serving a student who's African-American who's economically disadvantaged and has an IEP so they footprint is in all of those categories and so sometimes you know having one inexperienced teacher can
027trigger three or four of these categories to produce those gaps because because those kids have multiple labels if that makes sense Footprints I call them um so Christy any other things we wanted to call out uh I don't want to go over each one of those numbers but where where you see the numbers in the red bars represent present the number of schools who have that Gap okay thank you um member Jackson did you have something to say um yes Madam chair thank you the what summer was referencing and now I'm seeing how instructional policy and this committee overlap with is still an issue of concern because what she was referencing and what we discussed is that those students who have English or English language learners or Eng English as a second language when they
028are getting State tests or assessments how they are not permitted then to they perform lower because they don't understand the language but they are not permitted to get it read to them in certain and so the data is skewed it's not really because it could be a high- performing student had it been interpreted into their language so then they end up with um IEP or um labeled with a certain learning disability when in fact they're just being underserved because of the language disconnecting barrier and there is no um there is no no uh resource that is afforded to them to really help them in that matter they have to take the test because they need to be English proficient and so that's one of those things that I do believe is an equity piece as
029well as far as providing the students with what they need in order to Excel and so that's the overlapping and so I just wanted to highlight that uh M here cuz I got excited when I saw this and I'm like oh we finally got it but we did and it's not us per se it's just our regulations but what I appreciate about Dr Chapman is she's getting the right people in the room so if I may because this is overlapping because this is multiple departments this is hitting every Cornerstone this work so uh Christy and I are just two members of the team but we have uh Dr Chapman we also have Chuck and Sam from the tech department who are two Tech guys i' always want on my team they understand the data they
030understand how information is processed from the schools to OD we have uh Larry Johnson representing talent and organizational development because when we would do something about this right we need those people in the room we have Michelle Marcus Kars representing the principal supervisors because we need to make sure we're supporting our teachers and our principles in a way that um especially if they're brand new or if if they're struggling uh in the uh area of uh uh Improvement for teachers you know we we want that group uh we have Dr Cav and a member of her team represented on this and then also uh Mr Todd wamas from human capital again representing um that recruitment the retention all of things things come into play when we start to talk about the root cause that we
031were saying so uh another data that I promise to one moment just I think Mr licky thank you uh Madam chair I think he answered the question um and I also um just want to reiterate that this particular measurement is around the educator MH out of fi teachers inexperience not yet effective their absence and our course en enrollment not academic achievement so academic achievement would be another Factor we lay on top of these measures but this particular tool is not referencing academic achievement I think this this first came to my attention around the same time that the Gates Foundation uh released their study about what matters most in terms of student outcomes teachers so this is the focus of this is looking at what you know what are our teachers doing how are we supporting
032our teachers and what are the systems in place to make sure that everybody has a high quality access to high quality I'm sorry if I cut you off Miss Jackson president Jackson it's never a problem when you saying something you saying something so that's all right with me to cut me off um my question kind of peeky backs on I think all that you said because and maybe Dr Chapman or yourself can help me with some clarity because Dr Chapman you just said um that then you got after you get this information then on you would top that and run an analysis in in um connection with students in some capacity I want to be clear before I ask my question that that's what would be needed yeah yes so uh we want to be
033sure that we have the capacity to develop and pull the kind of data that helps us make good decisions and right now I don't believe we have that capacity okay thank you that answer that's what I was asking if that existed because then my next question to do a deep dive to really get to root causes because you can have a quality teacher and that that still does not disseminate into the child learning right and the reason why because I was looking at uh some of the factors fre frequently absent teachers right and so we if we get that data what sub what subjects do they teach right right and then what's the classroom demographic and then student performance in this teacher class by the subject matter because then that's some data we can use
034to inform when we get to the point of this is an ineffective teach for this reason or this teacher these certain students are not performing well in this teacher's class she seems very they she appears to be an ineffective teacher with this group but she's highly effective with this group right yeah so that's so I like the the convers the things that you guys are saying is making me think like well we need what what Dr Chapman is talking about what is the system if we going to really you know extrapolate and get to the root causes and then start to be able to say this needs to be removed or individual so that's it thank you so much uh so I have to get you this slide as well so this is this is
035another screenshot you have it we updated it with the data that dropped 48 hours ago so this is the 202 uh 3 24 data on the screen um but it's a highlevel breakdown of some of that data that you were looking at by school so uh based on the emis data that we submitted you can see uh last year we had 1,567 teachers so 14% of them were inexperienced teachers meaning they have less than two years it doesn't mean they're a bad teacher it just means they're new and so I think that's kind of a sign of where we are I know I'm getting towards the end of my career and you know back in the 2000 we were hiring like two 300 teachers at a time so now you know those big groups are
036starting to retire so we're going to see bigger hiring needs um what I think surprised Chrissy and I today when we were unpacking this um I hadn't seen this number before um 41% of our teachers are frequently absent that was last year data so um 41% of our teachers are missing 10 or more days of school and so you know that'll be something for the team to talk about are there you know I think we tried to have a strategy in place and the last time we negotiated we upped those incentives for attendance so it's you know the team should be reflecting on those are those things working what else can we do you know um this is the data the important stuff is what what do we do next um as we get to
037those root cause like Carla said um so principles 25% of our principles have two uh two years or less experience and just kind of keep going down there um 3% not yet effective so that's a great very low number that means they're in the bottom two levels of otes um it's kind of cool to see our courses listed out we have a lot of offerings for our kids so 13,000 of our uh courses we have over 13,000 courses just under 10% of them offer Advanced curriculum so that's that's something I need to unpack a little bit more as I'm working with the teaching and learning department and the tech department to get a better understanding of that that's a brand new measure coming out this year so thank you for that real quick so I
038know I had made a comment last year about one of my schools had 18 teachers missing in one day yeah 18 call offs thank you for the data because it shows frequently absent I can't I'm bar I can barely see but I think it was 41 yes per 41% that's tough 22 to 23 school year yeah that's a problem so our kids aren't really getting that full package when they go to school right and because now you're pulling in substitutes or other teachers that don't even can can't even do that math you know or don't really know the teacher may not have left a lesson plan for that substitute teacher so they go there and they're just like right what were you doing yesterday right you know so and I know that you had some
039parents address you I'm sorry sorry yes I just want to clarify this this is 23 23 2324 on the screen and the reason you have 22 23 is because this just came out I got the call today so and and knowing what we know I mean you you have the anecdotal information right now you're hearing stories from the buildings that we're having trouble with Subs we we had Parents uh of students with disabilities who have come to talk to the board concerned about substitutes in their classroom so you know my hunch is the numbers are not improving so we'll you know we'll have to see the data um but those are big concern I know when Christy and I were digging a little bit today we noticed like one of those ineffective or one of
040those out of field teachers at one of our buildings was a long-term sub um so you know we we had the classroom covered but they didn't have teaching credentials and so they took a hit by having um a non-certified teacher in for a long period of time and and so that would be that's why we have human capital talent and organizational development as part of this team so we can think about uh when we get to those root causes cuz the third step that we haven't really talked about yet is the plan so when we get to step three like what is it that we really want to focus on and put our attention to try to move these numbers real quick when you give us these slides could you put the Year yes ma'am
041on the slides so when you give it to all of us we'll know thank you mhm uh so that uh brings us really to back to the process right so step two is uh looking at the gaps diving into that data with the teams identifying what that root cause is um and so Carla did a great job explaining it so won't uh I'll just quickly highlight it but basically we're looking at what are the symptoms and trying to figure out what is the underlying problem and then if we resolve that problem we're going to see a movement in our numbers so for example you know inexperienced teachers is tough right you're always going to hire new teachers but what is it that we're doing to support and Mentor them so that we keep them right
042so we don't have a cycle of hire and lose and so that might be you know uh uh uh something that we we root cause and dive deeper into and and begin to build strategies around so uh we have to make sure as we're identifying our root cause that they're adult centered like what are the things that are in our control uh as I just mentioned for example we're always going to be hiring new teachers but what is it that we can be doing as an organization to support them to Mentor them to make sure that they're successful and they want to stay with us in akan public schools uh and then I I think it's high it's important to note there's usually not one there's not one Silver Bullet if there was we would
043all take that on the road show and make lots of money so it's complex it's messy and it takes time uh and and then step three that's where we get to the plan and that's also where I was saying Chrissy and I that's where I think we shine and making sure that our one plan that our Blue Print for excellence is all aligned that the work is focused and we reporting that work to OD in our plan um I know you guys have been talking kpis key performance indicators and that's the big thing that's so once we develop our plan uh what is it that we're monitoring what data are we collecting to make sure that we're moving in the right direction and I'll just give you I know things that we've talked about in
044the past for example you know when a teacher does resign or leave are we uh following up with them are we doing exit surveys are we trying to figure out you know why are you you know you know what is taking you away from akan so that we can uh solve any issues or concerns for the future or to help us be better in retaining our talent uh so our next steps uh so we uh have to work on our plan Chrissy do you have the timelines uh I know we just de oh go ahead uh so we uh we already we submit our plan in January of every year we did get feedback this year that we needed um to update our plan so Chrissy uh has made sure we're compliant yeah so we
045sent everything to OD and they're still waiting to look at that we had three areas of our plan that we had to update and two are compliant and this one hasn't been done uh reviewed yet since Christmas so we're waiting uh so it'll be the goal for the team though so so we we will be compliant we just need OD to review it but now that we have new data we need to adjust the plan so that's that whole cycle So the plan that we're compliant in is last year's plan and there were strategies around recruitment retention uh professional development for our teachers so now this team will look at the data identify the hot spots and then rep prioritize you know where is it that we want to go and I think as Carla
046keeps mentioning I'm I'm glad you did this is one small piece of equity right so uh as your team represents uh a larger picture of what we need to do in the district this is one small piece thank you for that this presentation M Dr CH you have something to say yes so uh that would be all we have today uh Madam chair unless you all have questions for myself or Mr licky or Miss Sim thank you madam chair thank you for the presentation so I hear that you're looking at the plan on how to retain teachers and that's that's great but I didn't hear hear anything about how are we keeping our teachers uh consistently coming to work when we talk about 41% of our teachers are absent what what what what are we
047finding out why are they absent what what is happening that's an excellent question and I think that's what that's what I like about this Loc Equity access plan so I had never seen that number before and so what's going to be great is now we have the data so uh in the next week we'll we'll get that meeting on the books before the end of the week we'll get this meeting on the books but that's that's the first line of work to make sure everyone in the organization has that number so that we can begin to talk and you know um I don't know where that will lead us but that's why we need all those excellent thought Partners in the room may I follow up Madam chair and and will your data show you
048where they most likely are not are they in in elementary middle school high school yes it is a fabulous tool and and I will lean on Carla if there's a better more appropriate place to ever dig into that tool um but it is very robust I mean I I gave you one small screenshot I just did a mini session today uh with Mrs Alexander everyone needs to be using this tool in the district and so one of our strategies should be to expose our leaders to this um and not just as viewers as users so really want to do that and then that teacher that educator absence measure being new um the 41% we really have to dig into that so we hear things like uh from learning Specialists and principles inexperienced teachers get overwhelmed
049uh they struggle with classroom management they're not coached and supported enough um and uh mental health issues around that I mean just a number we really have to know more about why mad I'm sorry I think one of the biggest things is teacher burnout you said teacher teacher burnout okay yeah Madam chair I was going to ask may I was going to to ask if um if it shows uh not only what levels are they absent but uh I'm thinking that in order for a person to be absent frequently they have to accumulate it quite a bit of time so it may not be our inexperience or our new teachers it may be those teachers who have all this time that they can afford to take it off that is a great point that is
050a great point so uh we'll jot that down actually something to think not say how inexperienced new teachers could it's not all all inexperience cuz they won't have the time they have tool lets us see who yes so we'll be able to do that now we have some new data that can be very help we know who and in which buildings and so I I shared today that having such detailed information really tells us as a a District how are we supporting our principal leaders in the way that they're coaching and supporting their staff because now there's no question we we know we know but if if I may be so transparent you know many of these things cost money and I know we're in a hard place in acam public schools and one of
051the biggest programs that we had for new and inexperienced teachers was the par program um I'm sorry the par program the peer assistance Review Committee um and they serve first year teachers in the district and so um you know with budget cuts unfortunately we weren't able to uh afford that but we we have other tools and resources we have instructional coaches and we have learning Specialists and we have folks supporting those teachers but those are the things that we have to take a hard look at as we're also talking about money and uh we got to look at the data and make sure that it's going to the places that are going to impact our student outcomes that par program was that only like a two-year program for new teachers they were in it for
052one to I don't want to I'm not the expert may I they move from par into resident educator status and continue to get that support but that no longer exists it it was cut uh significantly uh in its former State it's smaller less available now to those who probably would need it Li St that we can find for that but even so just where's just someone just taking someone along pulling them up and showing them the ropes like you know I understand we have programs but we don't have the funny for the programs why can't if I'm a new teacher and you're an experienced teacher you guide me just out of wanting to see me succeed also we do do a lot of that and I don't want you guys to walk away here thinking
053we're not working on some of these issues now our office is working very closely with Larry Johnson uh and so we have uh just recently made sure so you guys just approve some new staff members at the board meeting on Monday and so Tuesday our instructional coaches uh were here uh they were training them they were giving them some guidance they were giving them the the 411 and here's everything you need to know before you walk into the door and then once they get in the door we have instructional coaches housed in our buildings and they're there to welcome them and support them but you know we have to make sure we put the systems back together wrong or not wrong we have to make sure we put the systems back together correctly when we
054have to you know we have to make Cuts we have to we have to change programs and we just have to make sure we're Nimble and we catch up and we close those gaps as we discover them Dr mull thank you madam chair um I appreciate the presentation love data it's always good for us to have a good background of understanding of the types of things that Administration is working on the implementation that is occurring um on your end um my question is um what type of action you did mention action that we've already taken that's kind of related to this what type of action do you anticipate coming to the board related to this what what can we do with this that's a thoughtful question I I got to look around the room thank
055you this chair um I I I would first like to get through the process and to do that deep dive those root cause analysis pull this cross functional team of folks together and determine what we can do with the resources we have and what additional resources would be required and at that point it would be uh more itable and more prepared for something that the board could do yeah any more questions yes is it possible I know you you all talked about getting uh individuals trained on this uh this dashboard but is it possible without the names because I understand Dr Chapman you explain like we oh we know if we can just have the year of service and buildings concerning the absenteeism like if we can see that data like from building cluster to
056the number of absence and the ten the years of experience I'm nodding my head and I see Chrissy taking notes so we will see what we can put together and the system does have a place where you can take the names off so that is something yeah cuz I think the more important than the names for us will be the numbers in that visual because then that also may be able to inform some other behaviors in certain buildings and clusters okay so you said school yeah the school years of service years of service okay perfect okay well if there's no more questions thank oh yes Dr M were you were you concluding no you go ahead well I I have something on section three okay now go ahead okay so I guess kind of related
057to my question on this and then moving on um as co-chair Now new co-chair of the equity uh committee um first of all I have attended many Equity committees I'm glad to actually be an official Committee Member um let alone a co-chair um but Equity obviously is foundational not just in our district but literally to our strategic plan it is connected Ed to every single Cornerstone within our strategic plan and everything that we're doing and so for that reason um what I would like to see when we talk about you know moving forward this year is um a clearer link to what we're doing in committee and the action that we're taking in our full board member board meetings and you know the decisions that we are making and the the things that that we
058are doing and what um what you need from us really um what we're here to support I I love hearing about the implementation and the the data drives because that connects everything for us um and so I kind of I wrote down in my my notes here um a lot of these meetings we have our like equity and action that's happening um but um like as far as progress and preparation like what do you what do we need to do would be really helpful to me as part of agendas um moving forward and then also if there are any Equity priorities um coming up in the background that we notice federal state local those types of things I understand that we do have a policy committee but there are some things that might not need
059to go through policy committee but we need to talk as far as Equity goes especially you know there will be a new federal Administration change and things like that people are talking about you know their families concerned about Deport ations and status and things like that and while we might not have anything that we can or would do it might be worth uh a discussion but it also maybe there is something that we could do we could talk about you know um student records and status and what what admin would or would not divulge about status um under different scenarios or or something like that that um real things that families are are are really concerned about um and maybe it would would eventually go through a policy committee um from here or or not
060but just to have a section on um Equity priorities that we're really looking out for uh for our families and our communities um and then also a public comment section um in the policy Committee in the last year um we approved public comments for the committee meetings and so having a section to remind community members and family members if there is something that they want to talk about that they're concerned about from an equity lens that we would hear them so those are my I guess four recommendations um if anyone has any feelings Madam chair may I just add that reminded me of the the the the young woman that spoke last evening about her daughter that wanted to be a cheerleader and that she had some disabilities and so perhaps that would would roll
061right into into this discussion on what happened there and why she feels so child is not being treated fairly mhm no that's awesome and awesome um you spoke about look Dr mullar is on fire today yes remember you have more no that's okay just saying that's how yeah from the comments from the public comments okay so maybe we need to do some things a little different when we have our like board meetings tell people to come to committees for certain you know complaints or issues or things like that you can go to this committee so I don't think we really talk about what the Committees which each committee is for for a public comment so maybe if we say you know if you have issues with like the mother you know come to our Equity
062committee and maybe we can deep dive into it a little bit more yes Dr Chapman yes I I I think uh that's a really good example because in my mind uh I'm thinking that we could bring then the district's work and process in including students with with disabilities on extracurricular programs and activities so that would be a way to tie in a public comment for a regular board meeting back here with information that could be discussed in equity committee but I think Dr monar Al monar I also heard you say you would like a public comment agenda items so that folks would know when the agenda is Public public they can come and make comment as well yes I just want yes a public comment section because I know um I'm hearing from a lot
063of people that I that I know with the example of um the status and deportation I know a lot of people that are really concerned about that but if I weren't here we might not know about that and it would be great if we had public comments so someone could tell us about that because I'm sure that there are a lot of things we don't know right right yes Dr Chapman yes in in fact there's a plan underway as we speak uh finalized yesterday a safety plan to support our students and our families so yes deportation yes yes uh deportation safety plan wonder I was just going to ask that question but good thing I picked you to answer that so that's wonderful yeah and part of what I I I like to bring to
064the table is just a way of looking at our processes and practices so that no matter the emergency there's a standard operating procedure in this case the emergency is the deportation uh issue but it it could be any emergency that would happen in the community where our students could be walking home and there's a safety risk or uh uh students who you know may be experiencing violence during uh walks to or from school where an emergency situation would be required so we the standard operating procedures is is the way I like to approach it so that we are not so reactive to things that happen that we have a way of doing business no matter the emergency but this case is special do you plan on putting out that um Deport deportation plan or the
065emergency plan our lead in that work is yvon cver okay and so if you're interested I can have uh Miss Culver come to talk more about that um there was a request I'll pass this out um for topics that could potentially be presented to the equity committee um and so I'll pass those around to you um for your uh approval suggestions um we had a request for February for a presenter on uh that particular topic but I'd be happy to have Mrs Culver come as we are just finalizing the plan related to safety and deportation it's very relevant thank you cuz I know our next me it's not until it is February February 3rd and although it's coming up you know people will be taking place very soon and this deportation will be taking place
066very soon so our plan is in place our our plan is in place okay and it will be going out to principles on Friday so while you all may not be aware of what we're doing the plan is in place and so we're ready to roll it out wonderful and we'd like to share that with you thank you yes Dr M you have a question to M okay thank you so much for sharing this and I um it it is so um it is so good to be reminded of how much work is being done in this District all of the time the the care and the planning and the preparation that's happening um there are great things happening in this district for our students and um being able to highlight that especially proactively not
067reactively and that's another reason why I I really would be um I I hope that having this section in the agenda would be a reminder even sometimes briefly to say we've got a plan for this it's on our radar we know about it and now even more taken care of thank you so much thank you yes thank you that's I get excited about our meetings all the time with Equity because there's always something new something Enlighten and just you learn more about what's going on here and with our students so thank you for your leadership Dr Chapman um is there any more questions no okay well we will be ending at 6:41 1 um our Equity committee thank you everyone for attending um our next meeting will be February 3rd at 5:30 thank you [Music]