CorpusRecord 64698

Legal, Contracts & Policy Committee Meeting Livestream - January 9, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Akron Schools
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Summit County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,121 words · about 23 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you good evening and Welcome to our January 9th legal policy and contracts committee meeting um it is 5:30 p.m. and in attendance tonight I am chair molar co-chair Sykes we also have a member of the board Harrison attorney capar and um Miss Carter here from the administration and jumping straight into our agenda today is uh item number one previous meeting summary the approval of the minutes so for those of us with packets the meeting minutes is the second section of the packets it is the minutes of our December 19th meeting so does anyone see any adjustments or recommendations to the previous meeting minutes U Madam chair I moves uh approval of the uh minutes wonderful uh and with that we would move on to section two public participation there is no one signed up

002to speak section three policy readings this uh we do not have any policy readings for this meeting so we're heading straight to section four our Roundtable discussion um and our Roundtable discussion is starting with item 4.01 SRO contract we asked the administration to give us an update on what is happening with the SRO contract I'm have legal cont yes uh haly cap weton Andress um we are um still in the process but close to having a uh final agreement and we'll update the board accordingly there's been um an ongoing back and forth with the city um and there was a meeting yesterday and um we anticipate that there will be a update shortly with a final version any questions or comments Madam chair just just a couple questions so uh in the meantime the officers

003are still in the in the schools that's right okay and so uh they are working as if the O kind contract is still in place that is my understanding I'm not 100% certain on um how they're operating but I know that the superintendent did um elect to have as a policy decision the um not I mean not like a board policy decision but to have uh uh the SRO officers stay on campus at the buildings okay so so Madam chair one more thing so you anticipate by Monday meeting that the we may be able I can't say for certain I I think that we're hopeful it will just depend on how um negotiations continue with the contract with the city but discussions are continuing that's correct okay good thank you for this information so um

004as far as the update to the board if if there is not an update by Monday's meeting should we expect to hear another update before the following meeting is is when you say it's closing um I feel like this is something that um has been happening for a while so what so there's there are um a remaining few issues that we're hoping to resolve um and those issues we anticipate will be resolved shortly I think that um it would be that we would be able to provide um some update as to where we are at by then but I can't speak as to timeline specifically um for exactly when we would come to a resolution on these things and sorry I guess my my question is is an update would an update be emailed to

005the board or presented to the board at a meeting so it would be likely that that would be privileged communication so in um that respect it would be an for any client privileged to email um with any other details I'm not sure um what details they would be at that point um but that would be my understanding of how any update would would would be to the board any other questions regarding item 401 no no Madam chair all right thank you so now we're going to move on and actually I'm going to do these in the opposite order uh 403 and then 402 if that is um okay with the committee uh starting with policy 7544 use of social media um and the reason I want to do that is I want to do a

006bit of review of our year uh we started this policy committee this year um with a new agenda and that agenda was following um the concept of the policy process and so I am very proud of our committee this year we have been a very productive committee I think we had uh reached the annual um Norm of policies that have gone through the committee by April of this year so we've done about twice we've been about twice as productive and I really attribute that to um this committee really uh doing the work um but as I reflected uh over uh the new year as uh people often do I thought about what have we done and what still needs to be done I thought about our board trainings with Miss Deborah Key's right um and

007talking talking about the policy process and one of the um really most critical parts of the policy cycle is the evaluation and support maintenance to fill that whole Loop of the policy evaluation process or policy cycle so in the packets and thank you Heidi for um printing these and I'm sorry we couldn't um get them up for you um I just made a visual first of the policy process um generally there's you know different versions of this all around but generally it starts with you know agenda setting formulation adoption implementation evaluation and support and maintenance and so the second item our second visual is how we have aligned our legal contracts and board policy agenda to the full policy process so starting with agenda setting that's our new business section that's how we were we

008are bringing items to committee and having a fully functional committee so then we had the formulation this is our Roundtable discussion where we're building our policies um some that come from Administration some come from Neola some come from the board and then we do our policy readings that's how we do the adoption and then once the board passes these policies it goes into um the administrative guidelines the administration implements it and the last two sections the evaluation and support and maintenance this is something that as a committee we haven't modeled much of this year and so I'd really like to close out our 2024 season I know uh next Monday we have um a new president and possibly new committee assignments and things like that so closing out our year with examples within this agenda

009within this uh format this formula to continue looking at our policies and so policy status review so far this year we've been using that for first read second read third read but we would add to that the section of policies within evaluation the policies that we're evaluating that's where that would fall in um and then we would bring those policies to Round Table to discuss the evaluation of them so that is in effect what we're doing in this meeting now is kind of modeling that and what that might look like and how we can participate in that process to make sure all of the good work of our district is moving forward and we are serving our community so uh we're starting with policy uh 7544 the reason why we're starting with that is because

010this was introduced in committee April 15th at our April 15th meeting and it was passed by the board June 24th so it was in committee for a long time so following the process of this um policy um I thought it was going to be a very good example so now it's been in effect for 6 months and so now in the evaluation of this um we can look at questions like um and this is where we're going to um go to the administration and um ask you know do you feel now that we've had this policy for 6 months that this policy still aligns with the organization's current mission and vision and strategic priorities and kind of give us an update how has this policy been working um now that you have implemented it um

011so so I believe that the policy is still in alignment um as relates to how it's been working um I have not seen any violations as it relates to um the social media policy we did share this districtwide I think that what we need to improve on is making sure that we have a um an ongoing process of getting policies in front of our staff and our administrators so that we can keep it in the Forefront some of our policies I think it's important that we're doing constant reminders in professional development just so that our employees are aware and then making sure that we're incorporating these things in our new hire orientation as well so that our staff is aware of um these policies especially big ones that we've seen Trends in as it relates

012to any discipline issues or anything like that um this is something that I would definitely um Reach Out to our Labor Department and ask what are the trends as it relates to any violations with the social media policy have we had anything come up is this you know looking to see where does the PD need to happen and so I think that that's something that we can especially when we're when you look look at this cycle part of the cycle would include monitoring and looking at what professional development or what extra support do we need for staff so that we can make sure that we're abiding by our policies that we have in place and we want to make sure that people are aware of the policies thank you for that update are there questions

013or comments from the committee or from the board thank you madam chair and and I appreciate this end of the year Circle process that you've done for us colorful but yeah I think that that yeah this this is one that was in the committee for quite a while and we had quite a bit of discussion on it and so I think now the whole idea is just my question would be just so when an employee is hired I'm I'm assuming these policies are part of their packet of information or doing their on boarding or doing their orientation of some sort that they are receiving this information so I know right now during the new hire process some policies are highlighted during that orientation um one that is highlighted is the um threatening behavior we go

014over Title 9 harassment things like that um I think that the social media policy because how big social media is is something that I think I will bring to the human capital Department to make sure that we're introducing producing this within our new hire orientation especially when you look at our students coming out of college now how big social media is across all age groups yeah and so just making sure that this is a highlight within that new higher orientation we will incorporate this thank you madam chair Madam chair uh Madam director so uh do you know if this is being highlighted now as new employees I mean we we we I was looking at our agenda on Monday so we continue to bring new folks in so is this a part of the packet

015or not are you not sure as of right now the social media policy is not a part of the packet okay the last time I looked at our new higher orientation it has not been a part of the packet and I'm going to uh say that it's not but this is something I think that we need to incorporate knowing how big social media is with our students and Families in and our staff Madam chair um Madam director I would agree I think that this definitely should be part of the packet of orientation that we do with with all employees all levels that they receive this disinformation thank you I I agree that this is um of especially because it's a new policy um for the new hires but since it is a new policy what

016is being done to communicate this also to the the current staff right and so um first when we first adopted the policy we did um communicate this out districtwide um but again I think that this is one policy that we need to have constant reminders on as relates to What's um appropriate and what's not appropriate as it relates to social media whether it's school account that you're running or even you personally using the account what are what's permissible and what's violations as relates to if you're naming yourself as an APS employee on social media so I think that um these are things that you would constantly revisit on an ongoing basis with staff in different settings so that they can hear it multiple times and that we can set our our staff up for success

017MH Madam chair yes I would agree with that uh uh as well as uh making emphasis placing emphasis rather on the consequences of the policy violation I think we want to in particular make emphasis show uh make sure that we point that out uh so that all employees are aware of the consequences of the violation of this policy okay thank you and I I will add to that also um the reporting aspect what should an employee do if they feel like something um you know might be appropri or might might affect them or or something like that you know what what happens with that information what should the process be uh internally externally um for that that's part of the training it's it's new we don't know what to do with it yet and then

018um my next question is is there different training for different levels of Staff because um we have I many of our new hires you know work um you know directly with students and buildings um but we also have you know administrators and we have um you know we have drivers and and all kinds of things so are there different levels of training and is this Incorporated in all of the levels of training um yes so there's different um levels and types of training based on the division or departments that people are being hired for but again I think that this is something that we would bring to the director's attention as it relates to when they're on boarding within their particular divisions and departments that they're including this as well within their within their training

019so making it a highlight of part of the onboarding process and onboarding actually is more than just your new higher orientation it really is like a year-long process so it's something that needs to like I said I think it's something that we need to constantly revisit especially as we look at developing our staff and making sure they're equipped to be successful uh and uh Madam chair Madam director so so who is responsible for making sure that the employees that we're all doing everything that we need to do with throughout the district I see quite a number of times it makes reference to the communication director is the communication director the person that's responsible for making sure that all of us are are doing what we're supposed to do um I think that the communication director

020would help with um providing that Avenue of how it's going to definitely be communicated and I think um now that I'm working within the human capital Department I would collaborate with our development our um talent and organizational development director because he oversees all of our professional development throughout the district and then we would look at putting a plan together to make sure that our social media policy and other policies that we need to make sure are kept at the Forefront of our employees is embedded throughout the year as we have our instructional um Improvement days because on those days we ALS also are training all staff throughout the district so that's our safety team members that's our custodians they're all receiving PD so we need to make sure that this is embedded within our our

021learning okay so are you saying this would be in the next all staff day when is that um January 17th January 17 oh so that is coming up mhm um I have one more question about the um compliance monitoring and the mechanisms in place um to address on how the policy is working how how the policy is functioning so does the administration or have a plan on that or would that be also part of the discussion in preparation for the January 17th I think that um part of the monitoring I think would be based on how many violations may have occurred um how many complaints have we received you know regarding social media so this is something that I would sit down with our team and look at what's our data collection process with this

022to see how well the policy is happening so the less violations we have the the more we know that the better we know the policy is is working so and US educating staff so the less violations we have then or the less complaints and problems we have then we know we're doing well with the implementation of the policy thank you madam chair is there any way to quantify the number of complaints the number of complaints that we receive regard regarding the policy the um I think there would be um a way to quantify that um and if if if it if they're not tracking the type of complaint that it is we can ask them to start um desegregating the types of complaints that are being received so right now we do track all of

023our discipline and things like that but we can start categorizing the type of discipline or incident that are happening like kind of like we do with our students if it's a a fight or verbal inappropriate you know um language we can start making sure that we're tracking the types of disciplines that are happening because then that provides us with information on the work we need to do as it relates to educating and making sure our staff has the knowledge around repetitive type of things that we're seeing so that we can start minimizing those okay follow M and I guess I'm going back too we we know policies are working when we don't have issues and so um I'm thinking about the discipline is is a way to certainly track it but that's too late um

024well not too late but you know that's corrective from a discipline point but if there was and there may not be um but if I can quantify the number of complaints I'm getting then I can look at the training okay so we need to do more training in this area we need to do more training in this area because this is where we're we're finding issues at and I guess that's you know not every complaint is going to rise to the level uh but it may be on the line correct and but when the line is crossed the line is crossed mhm so um that's just something that was just a question I I don't know that we need to go as far as the discipline but is there a way to say hey we're

025seeing a spike in this um and and social media is international at this point so absolutely so I'll definitely take this back to the team and um brainstorm how can we start quantifying the number of complaints that we may receive as it relates to social media I I appreciate that and I think on a on a general level as as we um begin to consider evaluating more policies I think uh a question that we can ask of of of really any policy is uh what data collection methods are we using to evaluate the policy impact and so that might be a specific opportunity for this policy there might be other opportunities for this policy but for any policy uh what data collection methods are we using and what evidence has been gathered so far towards

026that end because then what we can do as a committee when when that information is brought to the committee then our question will be based on that um should the policy be maintained as is revised expanded discontinued um you know if it's if it's a training situation then we don't need to change the policy but maybe during training there's a need to adjust the policy um or or something like that just based of based on our conversation um so um that that's my I think most of my questions on this policy in particular any other uh comments or discussion uh thank you madam chair just want to point just want to read this line just to make sure that it's clear that when we talk about this policy in particular uh this policy applies to

027all District employees use of social media whether the whether for personal or professional use regardless of using District or personal technology and to to any person using District equipment so of course nothing in this policy should be construed as denying employees their civil or political Liberties under the US and the state state of Ohio Constitution but I just think that as we go through training with employees we want to highlight that quite often a person may feel that as long as they're using their personal their personal um equipment and it's on their personal time that they're fine and I just think that we wanted to highlight that this also deals with on your personal time with your personal equipment if you are violating any of these items then you are subject to the consequences of

028the policy violation that's listed in this in this in this policy just just want to note that want to put that on record so that uh employees are aware that this is personal as well as professional equipment and time great okay I appreciate that and I also um in within the scope we have social media and the social media presently is defined as website websites and applications that enable users to create or share content or participate in social networking so a lot of times when people say social media um personally I think oh people are talking about Facebook and Instagram but it is actually beyond that um to any or presently as we have defined in this policy um so any website or application to create and share content for social uh networking is what

029it says here so um I think that is also an important distinction that employees might not understand they might think oh if I'm doing this in I don't know I don't social network very much but this other application then it's fine um and so that would be an important part of the training absolutely thank you um so with that we have started this discussion of the uh policy status review the evaluation we are having a round T discussion um however I don't think we have all of the information for the support and maintenance I think there's a lot of information that Administration can still bring back to us after the January 17th training after um coming up with um I don't know I made a whole list here I'm sure you have a list here

030too everything that needs to be discussed with the data collection process um so with that it is my recommendation to place this policy as the first policy that we would be adding in policy status review um we'd have a new subject it'd be 705 which which is the uh policies in evaluation so we have usually have uh policies heading to the board for a second reading policies heading to the committee for a first reading um and so this would be policies that would be in evaluation if that is all right with the committee just clarification uh Madam chair so uh so you're saying that you want this particular piece use of social media in 705 or generally speaking what what what are we talking so both generally speaking we would always have an item in

031policy status review section 7 always have an item for evaluation okay and then we would list which items are currently in evaluation okay or undergoing EV the evaluation process or um looking at evaluation oh is that going to be a different is that going to be a different section or that would live under seven as well it would live under seven okay okay okay so I was want to make sure for hiding yes yeah and so this use of social media is the first one that you place it yes under 705 okay okay any other comments or discussion on 7544 no all right thank you so now we are moving on to our last agenda item for today which is policy 43621 threatening behavior this policy was chosen um today for us to go through

032a very similar exercise to go through the policy evaluation cycle this one was chosen because this policy is actually from uh April 27th 1998 eight so um my first question is after 26 years um has this policy been reviewed or updated to address any changes in societal Norms workplace Dynamics legal standards um that would be one of the first things I would want to know about this policy um so I will ask Administration first if there are any updates on this policy and then I will move discussion to the committee and then to the board no there are no updates um to this policy right now it lives in 4362 and 33 62 so 4362 is for um classified staff and then professional staff is under 3362 but it's the same exact um verbage and

033so if this needs to be beefed up I think that this is where we would have that discussion here you know we could put it under discussion and then we can make sure that we're bringing this to the attention of um you know internally to see if there's anything that needs to be updated but this is one of the things though that we do cover well harassment we cover harassment and um sexual harassment bullying intimidating we cover that in our new hire orientation like very thoroughly and we ident identify our Title 9 UM compliance officers for people to contact if they do have issues um so any comments or discussion from the committee yeah just just uh as with polic as with the policy that we just just discussed use of social media uh consequences

034of policy violation is not on this but I'm assuming may not be a good thing do that this is under the heading that you mentioned so that we would find the consequences of the policy violation in that section that goes along with harassment bullying and intimidation I'd have to go and look at that but I do know that um all of it is included in every code of conduct for every job code okay and it talks about the different consequences that comes with the different violation ations in the code of conduct for our staff okay but I will go and look I will go and pull every policy that deals with um threatening be because some of them overlap and so I'm I'll pull those so that we can look at we can look at

035those all together okay thank you madam chair uh Chief Harper yes sir is is that that the right chief chief Harper I haven't heard that yet so that doesn't oh I used to be Harper I forget sometimes myself Char okay yeah I was like it does sound right but something sound wrong about it yeah some part sounded right I was like okay I didn't get Harper Carter Chief Carter so looking at this policy um and and I guess this would be for the attorney as well a lot of things have happened since 98 uh 1998 a lot of issues in schools a lot of different scenarios come up and so when we're looking at a policy threatening behavior um and we have a bullying policy we have a harassment policy and we have a sexual

036harassment policy even if they overlapped should should they not be succinct in language if we're going to have different policies then each policy even though the language anguage May overlap but we need to have all of those elements within the policy um if I'm understanding your um your point correctly um to an extent I guess it would depend because obviously something like sexual harassment would have different elements than threatening behavior so there are probably reasons um in most instances that the policies are separate but we can take a look at that and see if they need to allow in a way that they don't presently if that's if that is the case and I guess just on this one um uh as we reviewed this one I would like to see all of those elements

037okay this is what this is what it is okay this is what we we want to happen um to report this this is the um discipline measures for this particular policy um but I just think 1998 you know a lot of things have happened in the school and uh we certainly can be a little more um detailed within this policy thank you thank you madam chair and I would just add that uh just uh the processes that one would go to through uh in reporting this uh say when would an employee feel that they have exhausted all of the internal processes and feel the need to go outside of the district in order to uh report a a harassment bul bullying intimidation do we have those processes set up someplace so that the employee is

038clear on how they are to uh report this type of activity um I do know we do um know that the labor department has had conversations with individuals as relates to if they feel as though they need to go outside of the district um like an eeo complaint or OCRC complaint um so they're made aware of that and but that is something I can look into as it relates to do we put that in the policy like steps that you take yes yes yes the reporting process is internal M and that would be for Union and non-un employees what are the processes that one should uh expect the employee to go through before they go through an outside agency in reporting uh any of these these uh behaviors okay and I will include my default

039question for this one at all which is what data collection methods are we using to evaluate the policy's impact and what evidence are we Gathering towards that end um and then in addition to that I am curious um the types of support systems that we are offering and the support systems while that might or might not be outlined in policy um if we are um offering you know protection or support for victims um counseling other resources things like that might not be you know guaranteed in policy but it could also be part of our data collection or the evidence of uh the policy Effectiveness too yes Madam chair thank you um one one one last question um is there um well not even a question just a statement I think that there needs to we

040need to look at some mandatory reporting um and especially when we're looking at threatening behavior bullying I think we um as a district U need to be hypervigilant and for whatever reason if a person does not feel um comfortable in reporting and but someone else is witnessing that there there needs to be some type of um prompt that will allow um third party reporting or mandate third party reporting when we're talking about conduct uh that that's threatening I'm also a little um confused I I have in my notes that in the new hire orientation process they are thoroughly um learning about you know harassment bullying intimidation um and it's in the job codes um but I'm wondering if that is in policy somewhere the definition of that is in policy somewhere and if it isn't

041um perhaps there's a a reason for that um but also it might just be because it was 199 I was barely born I'm just kidding I wish um so uh lots of information uh on this any other comments or discussion no I just be interested in where you're placing this on the U the committee is this 70 7.05 also okay I I haven't I haven't done that yet you're ahead of me okay I'm just but yes I'm that tells me it felt logical yes it does it does it does so yes it would be my recommendation then that we we would receive the updates in this in 7:05 also uh wonderful so thank you everyone happy New Year welcome back thank you for uh meeting with us tonight while we got to finish the policy

042review cycle with a brand new and a not even close to brand new policy and this is what we would do for any policies that people would like to bring to the board as new business and with that I believe we are including at 612 great thank you e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.