001e e e [Music] [Applause] [Music] good evening and welcome to this December 9th 2024 meeting of the Aram public school board roll call please Dr Thompson Mr Alexander present Miss ayy present Reverend Harrison present Miss Jackson present Dr Molar present Mrs Sykes present six present one absent thank you um if you're able to stand please do so for the Pledge of Allegiance vice president Jackson would you please lead used aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all again welcome this evening um I just wanted to share a few comments before we jump into our agenda um this is going to be our first Committee of the whole meeting for the Board of Education um
002and it starts uh an important change on how we conduct our work as a board um the committee of the whole or cow is a meeting format designed to help us be more effective and efficient in serving our community this structure gives us the opportunity to focus on in-depth is discussions asking clarifying questions and deliberate thoughtfully on key issues before taking formal votes the proc process will work in this way the first board meeting of each month like tonight will be reserved as the committee of the whole and during this meeting we will review and discuss agenda items in detail and we may or may not take action the second board meeting of each month will be a regular board meeting where we will vote on items that were reviewed and moved forward from the
003cow this process helps ensure we have ample time to understand complex issues collaborate as a team and make informed decisions it also strengthens our financial oversight and promotes greater transparency and accountability in our work so let's begin tonight's discussions and as always I feel free to reach out to myself or superintendent Robinson with any questions about this process moving forward and so as I mentioned um most items we will go through the meeting as we normally do um but our main topics will be the items that will be for deliberation and discussion um and potentially moving forward to the next board's agenda and so the next item are recognitions and it will be the superintendent book of the month club winners Dr Robinson thank you president ay I want to say congratulations to our top
004readers in November in Elementary uh we celebrate first graders Briana r from Betty Jane uh who read 38 books yes I will ask you to come up shortly for Middle School Ariana Stevens a sixth grader from bookal CLC who led the way with 17 books read and at the high school level Emily Bell a ninth grader from eclc stood out by reading 32 books let's give them a round of applause in total our Scholars received the following Milestones K to 5 so far we've read 914 books middle schoolers have read 141 books and high schoolers have read 43 books and a special congratulations to the schools with the highest number of books read Betty Jane uh Elementary 250 books inis uh Middle School 63 books and East CLC with 43 books that have been read
005so if we can have the parents and principles our Scholars to come up um so we can take a picture and thank them for their unwavering support um in this initiative which plays an essential role in nurturing the LIF love of reading among our Scholars and thank you again to Acme uh who supports this initiative and partners with APS for the and generous generously donating gift cards to these Scholars so if we can uh Briana is from Betty Jane and Ariana Stevens oh wendir I'm sorry okay she's cute as a button is she got her little dress on and her blackes NOP y AR bet J you guys come over good job I assumed a lady in the red sure either she's from windamir thank you great [Applause] job congratulations keep up the good work
006thank you to our families for supporting the students and for our Educators and staff as well thank you have a great have a good Christmas thank you so much the next item on our agenda our board member Reflections there any board member Reflections at this time vice president Jackson you've been recognized thank you madam president um very quickly before I get my um my Reflections I would just like to ask um for a moment of reflection silence and prayers for our eight we had a eight-year-old student um from Cross um Elementary that's been taken to emergency as a result of a as I understand a self-inflicted uh gunshot wound and so it could have been accidental we don't have all the details but I just would like to say this in this form because I
007believe in the collective power of prayer and so those who um are prayer people that pray I just ask that you would pray for this um 8-year-old child um and the family as well as their classmates and the school in general and just pray that you know that this child will have a recovery we'll pray for the family at superintendent just let me know that the student has passed um 8 years old so please please remember as you pray or you reflect on this family and the school community Community my god um and so I just was that was just brought to my attention as we sat here and so I wanted to mention that and just ask that I'm I don't know the family but EV hopefully we'll get information um so that we
008can uh send our condolences and prayers with that family um additionally I wanted to highlight uh some great things that I found about found out about while I was out the country and I was so excited because we know that I love that fourth e of Entrepreneurship and that I am a I believe in capitalism and free enterprise and I'm proud to be an American citizen where we can do these things and so I was so excited to hear about our Garfield graduate alumni trade Gordon and his work with the Garfield basketball team with their uniforms and doing custom designs for those basketball players at Garfield and it's positive press and things that we can highlight about what our graduates are doing and how they're giving back if you recall a few months ago Trey
009Gordon is the same young man who I talked about who is over vontes that's his uh clothing brand he donated uh prom suits to the students at booked of the basketball team and he also brought the fashion show to the art museum and this is one of our own homegrown graduates that was stationed in Georgia and then came back to uh support our economy and also our community so I just want to say Kudos and thank you Trey for remembering your roots and giving back to your community and also Josh Meir Muhammad um also known as Bari is a graduate from eclc and he too gave back to the East football team with customade made jerseys um that was donated um from him he's also a designer so again I just want to salute these
010two young men and let them know we recognize your efforts we are grateful to you for not only um giving back to the schools that you graduated from but giving back to the akan economy and to your community and that concludes my Reflections Madam president thank you vice president Jackson are there any other Reflections Dr Molar you've been recognized thank you Madame President um I have a few Reflections I'll try to get them all in uh first uh to jump on the entrepreneurship or follow the entrepreneurship thread um I um was lucky to attend a a Junior Achievement meeting I know that we have Junior Achievement and especially a lot of our middle schools where there uh the students have the entrepreneurship seminars and events like that um but I also learned about something um
011that apparently is new to Junior Achievement and it's the 3de um and it's um incorporating the Project based into the core classes and it's something that we aren't doing yet to my knowledge um I know at Firestone we have an IB program but the 3de can incorporate as it was explained to me can incorporate into to um and and complement the Ford NGL things that we're doing in a lot of the other high schools so I was curious um if we thought that something like this could work or help in somewhere since we have I be at Firestone maybe bookle or north or east or or another school to um enhance our programming for our students in that way um another thing oops I have notes here sorry um I want to say I got
012to see the Firestone and bookle girls basketball game it was a very exciting game especially the last two minutes that lasted about as long as the whole first quarter I won't say who won it doesn't really matter who won because it was so exciting everyone was standing um and it was very very very exciting Up Until the End um for both teams and the girls I want to talk about the girls basketball team the girls sports right now um because I know so often uh we don't think about all the girls games so great job to both teams there um I also um want to talk about um an email that uh I received I don't know if the whole board received it from an ellot student and we speak so often and at our
013recent board retreat we speak about um you know hearing from the students and what they want and what they need and amplifying the student's voice and this uh Ellet student I want to say thank you for your email I read your email and they were talking about um something related to the Ohio Means job certificate and how we're handling the Ohio Means Jobs I know that's something that we've discussed a lot in the instruction policy committee so I don't know if there's a way that we can learn I I will say in the microphone I did hear you but I do not know about that form so I am saying I will learn about the form um and try to see if this is something that is uh on the systemic level that would be
014appropriate for the board um and then the last thing I have 23 seconds left I want to say um that on our website there has been an update the the 2425 org chart is now on the website I know that there are people reaching out to me before because the orc chart we had was from the 2223 so now there's a 2425 it says draft but um even though it says draft I've been informed that this is currently what is happening in our district presently so maybe it might be changing or something in future but we do have what is presently uh in our district represented on the website thank you thank you Dr Molar are there any other Reflections Reverend Harrison you've been recognize thank you madam president um members of the board um
015want to just take a time take some time right now to mention to vocalize the name jasmir Tucker we want to acknowledge to our students to the community to everyone that our student students are important to us often times we can conduct business and we we have disagreements we have as adults we deal with dayto day functions of whatever but I want to use my time today right now to just stop and reflect on his family his school his classmates his teachers his counselors his coaches nothing that we do is as important as the life of our children the life of our children is the most important when we make decisions the most important decision that we should be thinking about is our kids I just want to use the rest of my time for
016us to reflect on what has happened to acknowledge what has happened to acknowledge the life has been lost and our community has been hurt I'll sit Madame President but I want to use the rest of my time for jasmir Tucker for e thank you Reverend Harrison are there any other Reflections at this time I will just share as well condolences to both of the families of the young people that have been mentioned already sending our condolences and prayers healing and resolution for our city and so since we last met I would just like to share that I had the opportunity um to attend a Showcase of learning of our earliest Learners um prek program and we have a partnership with art Sparks and the g Foundation who helps provide a 15-week program uh that focuses
017on kindergarten Readiness um and so I had the opportunity to see uh our youngest Learners from Essex and Helen Arnold perform on the stage um and that's just always amazing to see because it just reminds you of what's important and why we're here and again it's for children and so I appreciate and thank uh art Sparks and the g foundation for the opportunity uh for our young people to have those experiences also since we last met um had the opportunity to attend a roundt discussion and was able to meet some Scholars from akan early college and although we didn't get to sit at the table together we were able to talk briefly um afterwards but the presentation was around uh Akon's Bicentennial that we are currently in the midst of and so uh thank the
018district for the opportunity to be able to uh be around the children that we serve and and hear from them and support them and so that concludes my community uh reflection the next item um on the agenda are requests to address the board and we do have a few here and as I call up the first person I will read our Preamble um Kayla Lutz if you want to approach the podium participants will not be permitted to speak on matters related to vendors business matters formal complaints grievances specific student or Student Records Personnel matters and potential or pending legal matters participants must speak on matters related to the business of the board please keep your comments to 3 minutes or less the board will not respond but will assign through the super intended the appropriate
019person for followup thank you Mrs Lut you may proceed um what I came here today was to um ask the board to consider uh renovating North High School instead of tearing down the beautiful historic building it is on a historic list with the state of Ohio uh 20 some years ago when this first started a structural engineer did deem that the building was structurally in too good of shape to tear down and at that time it was uh stated that 18 million would restore and update the facility since that time the city and I don't know if it's the board I don't know who's involved but they withheld the money purposely for the repairs and updates to North High School and here we are with the problems being greater because of not being done right
020now a new school will cost $85 million restoration and upgrades to North High School is $32 million which is a savings of 53 Mill million do that the board could put into a fund to um maintain the schools in the system from what I understand at least seven of the schools uh that were rebuilt have some of the same problems that North High School has right now um and I there was an agenda with the city and the board from 20 years ago I was told that then um Mayor Don pellic um was in contact with Suma and Suma wanted the site that North High sits on and they made a sweet deal that Suma was going to get the site that North High sits on then in 2016 um then the board president tried
021to shut down North High School and move all the kids all 900 and some kids to East High School and it didn't have happen then uh Dr James uh the Su superintendent he told me I've got something up my sleeve Kayla it's not going to happen well here we are and they're pushing to tear down North High School again and our present mayor stated at a community M meeting that he thought that where St Thomas is presently being torn down another beautiful building that is lost um would be a good place for North High School um that's all I have to say I I I just have more questions than I have time thank you Mrs Lutz you're welcome next we have Ashley Conklin hello I'm Ashley Conlin I've I'm just a little concerned about
022some of the public policies uh coming from Columbus that would affect our city the children of our city and they will be seen as like ostracizing uh some of the children uh there there are demands for example to or some girls from playing girl Sports and Etc and I think that will be seen by the children and it will be seen by the children who wish to bully other children as a free pass and so I think uh proactive responses proactive action in order to curb those sorts of things would be helpful it it helps from the board it helps from the principles it helps from the teachers all the way down just unified message of we care about these students regardless uh they it makes a big difference it makes a big difference for
023one teacher from my experience and that teacher is helped by a principal who is supportive by a board that is supportive etc etc that's all I basically have to say I'm just concerned about the kids in my neighborhood and the bullying policies seem reactive rather than proactive thank you thank you Mr Concklin it's Miss Conlin but miss I'm sorry the next item on our agenda is superintendent report Dr Robinson thank you president archery we have some national days that we want to recognize uh National Rosa Parks day which is December the 1st uh National special education day which is December the 2nd and we certainly want to thank our parents and our teachers and Par professionals our school leaders for working with us um as we work to ensure that we educate our special education
024Scholars internal day of persons with disabilities day is December the 3D International I'm sorry International Volunteer day for economic and social development December 5th and school winter break we want to remind all of our families will be December the 3 23rd through January 3rd so again that's December 23rd through January 3rd we want to thank akan Council of Engineers and scientific uh societies which we call acess a grant for $4,000 for teachers at Piper ellot East cybering and niem high school at Robinson clcc the G foundation for the grants that they provided 87,000 for project rise Martha Holden Jennings grants to Educators for a teacher at EC LC in the amount of 3,000 Dick Sporting Goods foundation and local initiative support Corporation grant for $100,000 for the eclc running track I want to also let
025the board know that there is a match to that particular Grant so it would be a match of the $100,000 and then we would over time like to um bring to you about putting the um the rubberized um piece that goes on top of the regular um asphalt that would make it a competition uh track for the students and so over time we could really evolve that property um and maybe in time have a uh stadium and other things that go with it to make it a full football stadium over over time also the G foundation for the for the third phase of the essential experiences initiative and for those of us that are uh not used to that term um that term is is uh indicative of what we might know it as field
026trips um but it's much more than just a field trip they actually it is actually an essential experience and so they get an opportunity to really learn engage um and really experience the the rich history and culture that we have here in Akron and in Summit County and so again thank you to G um attended the lighting of the tree at um King CLC on December the 3rd it was very nice they had hot chocolate and S carols and um it was really really awesome Community came out and it was really a nice event um met with the superintendent business and Community advisory committee on December the 5th um attended the akine round table luncheon uh where our akan early college students participated with Mr Dave lieberth uh who spoke on December the 5th the
027inclement weather uh just to remind our families that we will do um websites we will do text Robo calls uh we will notify the news media um as well and uh so that they are aware of any procedures that have to be done with closures and we will now do our be kind 3:30 as a school counselor here at Helen Arnold I meet with fourth and fifth grade student ambassadors and I talk about the issue that they feel like need addressed at our school and they started bringing up the fact that they want to be leaders they want to be the voice of the school and um they know that I assist with making music I assist all of our kids with making social emotional songs so they were like we want to make an
028ambassador song that all our kids can can uh listen to and Vibe out to and it's actually been great um we premiered it last week and our kids have absolutely loved it they loved it on the announcements it was such a fun time and now they're like the celebrities of to school so it's it's really cool it got change and they made a plan more importantly they just made up a creative dance sh bright the together CL our andage we always St true us sometimes it get tough and they never back and down Mr Bryce uh Harris who's one of the counselors there and also um today this Anthem is a part of Helen Arnold School culture it's performed as at assemblies and events and it becomes a source of Pride for everyone teachers have
029noticed an increase in school spirit and parents have shared how it's had a positive impact on their children um Mr Harris put it best The Anthem represents more than just words and moves it's a powerful reminder that these students know their voice uh that their voice matters and so we want to thank them again and let's give them a round of [Music] applause Mr Harris is in the audience if you could stand and be recognized thank you so much thank you Mr Harris and we also want to recognize Dr Stacy Hodo who is our new director director for strategic Communications and Outreach and everything else that goes into the title that I can't remember but thank you uh Dr Hodo thank you Dr Robinson are any questions uh for Dr Robinson Dr monar been recognized
030thank you madam president um and first of all loved the video did not know it was coming and that is so a great example of the heartwarming things um that are happening in our buildings um but the question I actually have um in the superintendent report um superintendent you said our winter break is December 23rd to January 3rd and as we all know we do so much more than teach our students um and so my question is um I know over summer break and sometimes like that we have um opportunities for students to come in and get meals and things like that are there is there anything set up over a winter break for some of the buildings no there there is not um I'm not sure that they have ever had that here um
031certainly would be something that we could look into for next year that would but staff is usually all not here during that time so I'm not sure how that would actually work it's a very good idea and it's something we can definitely look into for next school year um and we'll we'll get get on looking at looking at it and investigating what we could do but to your point no ma'am any other questions vice president Jackson you've been recognized yes uh thank you me member monar for the question and also superintendent for the response and as we're processing this also because you know I always talk about collaboration Partnerships that may be a good um area for us to link with the akan food bank akan Kon Food Bank who does a lot uh for
032the community and um see what areas um organizations around may be providing those things and then we could possibly connect students based off clusters with certain churches and other uh Community organizations that are giving away baskets and meals and um you know how with the schools we have Community uh clc's what are there's something that organizations uh created like a community certain certain churches have that arm of their churches I can't think what it's not a it's like a community uh like a nonprofit of these organizations that also gets foods from the food bank in any event there is a lot of area for growth that wouldn't have to necessarily tax um our resources but we can just simply partner because I know during covid one of the things that we came into when we
033were doing things of that nature was the transportation of those things or the delivery right and I think Deb folk was a perfect person I remember she presented and talked about the whole processes because it was a great a beautiful oil machine that she and her team had going on during Co but I know now we're at the point where exra funds are limited but just to put that out there superintendent um the Aron kanton food bank is a wonderful resource to our community and also they can probably link us with other community part possible Community Partners around the area we know of enough of e and also um I know that Mason Park Angela what was the Mason Park was it a church or something that adopted Mason Park that was given away yes
034they backal schols churches yeah so just I just wanted to highlight that because we do have things that like you're saying and if yeah but if we could just leverage to like Leverage those type of relationships and then just have something that's ongoing I think it's a great idea to see where who who already has a a um a footprint in our schools because again we want to be specific to clusters because now we're talking about transportation and access to the resource so if they have to travel but they don't have the means to travel then they won't have access to the resource whereas if the resource could be in their cluster at their school um like the blessings in the backpack or whatever um then that would be even more convenient and again it
035doesn't have to be so much um for us so thank you um both thank you thank you any other questions for Dr Robinson seeing none we will move on to the next item on our agenda uh which is the treasurer's report um and this section will include two items that we would need to vote on this evening so I'll turn the floor over to you Dr Thompson well I don't really think we have anything to cover it was a joke sorry geez tough crowd um we have the resolution 6.1 is the bond issue and just so a reminder of the advantage of issuing $15 million in bonds early in this and before this uh fiscal before this calendar year expires allows that $15 million to collect invest or interest from our investments and Investments have
036still doing very well so and without Arbitrage and remember the term Arbitrage is the limit the state puts on how much borrowed money can earn public entity however that doesn't apply to that $15 million because there is it has to be a threshold over that so that's why that particular number it will also afford um the administration the funds they need to get moving as quickly as possible on the project and then we'll put that $15 million to the spend it last so that we can earn as much interest as possible from those dollars so that reminder of what uh the bond issue is and then the fiveyear forecast my understanding is the uh superintendent's office is giving you some information uh that um should um answer the questions hopefully and um pass this resolution
037on the 5year forecast it remains uh I can show it to you it's on the screen if you'd like to look at it one more time want to see it again the actual number Madam chair so are we are we going to uh skip over the five skip over the bond issue and go into the fiveyear forecast or should we deal with the F Bond you want to vote first so to open up the discussion we can entertain a motion um to approve the bond issuance is there a motion to approve the bond issuance so move it's been moved by member Sykes is there a second second second by member molar is there a discussion about the bond issuance questions I do have a question um about the bond issuance so this is based on
038the monies we received from the the the levy Bond so the funds that are generated that we're saving or getting earned interest on will be for North the north project it can't go towards anything other than the North project okay I just want to be clear on that right so you know unfortunately construction costs are still rising at about 16% a year so that you to having there is a contingency fund built into the bond issue for those kind of things or change orders it's a word you'll hear a lot as a board I'm sure you've already done it since you've had so many building projects projects here but um that's just part and parcel to construction so the additional funds if they're still there at the end uh then they'll allow the superintendent the
039administration uh the board the ability to make an addition additional change orders to to enhance the building that maybe otherwise wouldn't have been on the table so it's really advantageous for us to have that those extra dollars and and it'll be millions of dollars it'll be a few million dollars are there any other questions on the bond [Music] issuance seeing none roll call please Dr Thompson Miss Excuse Me Miss ay yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes motion carries 60 thank you and now we will have the 5year forecast so the fiveyear forecast looks the same as it did um previously there's the 10 million in Cuts 10, 205,000 in reductions over uh that would be enacted next year remember these are reductions their one-time reductions
040they're compounding reductions and they go over the life of the five-year forecast and what that allowed us to do was to move across the bottom again to for your for your reminder we will have one year fiscal year 26 which will not be in deficit spending we'll move back into deficit spending the year after but our cash reserves hold at 86 6,887 million and then 72 53 and 16 million through the life of this 5year forecast um I think that if you take a look around across the state many failed levies there weren't a whole lot that pass uh thank goodness ours passed and you also will not find very many fiveyear forecasts that are in the black meaning we have cash reserves on hand uh through the 5year forecast and there remember that the
041there's there's deficit spending doesn't mean you're in a deficit and you can see here we are not in a deficit for 5 years uh with those 10 million in Cuts any questions for me thank you we can entertain a motion to accept this to open up the discussion is there a motion to accept the 5year forecast so move it's been moved by member Alexander is there a second second it's been seconded by vice president jackon is there a discussion or questions on the fiveyear forecast seeing none roll call please Dr Thompson Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss Autry yes uh motion carries 60 and it will be submitted tomorrow morning first thing thank you [Music] next on the agenda is approval of the previous meeting
042minutes um 9.1 is approval of the meeting minutes from Monday November the 4th are there any uh additions or corrections to the meeting minutes from Monday November the 4th seeing none we'll have them as presented to us is there a motion to approve those minutes so move it's been moved by Mr Alexander is there a second second it's been seconded by member Harrison is there any discussion Dr Molar you've been recognized thank you madam president I was under the impression that this was going to be a planning meeting not a voting meeting I I understand that we were going to be voting on The but we we re received an email we'd be voting on the treasures items that we just voted on however and the discussion that we had on Friday was that all
043other voting items would be moved to our actual voting Mee meeting on Wednesday and so with that I make a motion to move this and any other votes to the voting meeting on Wednesday can you restate your motion I make a motion to move this vote and all other I make a motion to move this vote and the items that I spoke to you about on Friday if you would like me to go through here the items listed on the agenda here if you want I can I can go through each individual one to save time or I can do it each time it comes what just State your motion I make a motion to move this vote to Wednesday's voting meeting because I believe this is how we are hand I I'm still unclear
044how we're handling these cows so if what I need to do I make a motion to move the vote to the voting meeting the vote of the M of the minutes the vote of votes because this is not a voting meeting this is a cow meeting this is the board's meeting so the board can conduct the meeting as it chooses we can vote or not so so it can be both and so I'm making a motion to do what we said we would do so which item the minutes cuz that's what we're on that's what's on the floor right now starting with the minutes is there a second I just have a point of clarity yes because I thought that I heard member monar say all voting items all items that will come up from
045a vote so I'm just I just want Clarity on the motion is it just one motion M Mard that any voting items just be moved to Wednesday I just wanted that Clarity because you said one thing originally and I just want to see what we're doing cuz just for the minutes I don't I I appreciate the clarity and I'm sorry I am also very confused because we've never had one of these cows before I think it will be apparently easier to do it section by section because since we were told this would not be a voting meeting um so for this motion I make a motion to move uh it would be 91 and 92 which are the voting on the minutes the vote of them to the is that I have a question afterwards
046the voting of 91 and 92 to Wednesday's meeting and then my followup question is is that what we're supposed to be doing right now is there a [Music] second a point of clarity yes and the reason I keep saying point in Clarity because remember monar is asking a question and then you're it's getting called for the vote and I would like Clarity to the question uh because as she stated like this is our first KY and I and I thought I heard you say something Madam president so I just want can I just get clarity before I do any Vote or SE my colleagues vote because what she's u i felt as what Carla Jackson heard is that she acts is this what we're supposed to be doing and I just wonder is anyone around
047this that is anyone can answer that like is this in order is it both just so I you know what I'm saying again it's the board's meeting and it's the board's will the intention of the cow was to have the opportunity to discuss in detail uh in particular the items under Personnel business Affairs and consent agenda which is our main items um but we're able to vote on what needs to be voted on and so if it's the will to move this the minutes we can again it it's the board's meeting and how the board conducts the meeting is up to the board so it's here for our consideration and I don't know if I answered the question or not but we can vote or not vote on any particular item and so right now
048on the floor is Dr molnar's motion to not vote on the meeting minutes tonight and to move that to Wednesday's meeting so am I clear on your motion yes so because we planned for this to be a non- voting meeting and that this is the meeting that we are building an agenda and moving items to our vote voting meeting agenda then because this is a voting item I am making a motion to move the voting item to the voting day so 91 and 92 move to Wednesday so that what is what's on the floor is there a second because there needs to be a second and and and it's not meant to be so restrictive and we're trying to I guess build the meetings how the Board needs to have them and so I appreciate
049uh flexibility in the matter as we try to find what works best for this board so is there a clarifying question I'm I'm going to second I'm going to second the motion for the purpose of discussion uh it's been seconded is there a discussion it's been seconded by Mr Harrison and now we can have discussion question um I'm kind of unclear and so I want to understand the uh member molar is saying that because we have said this was going to be a committee of the whole and not voting that we should not be voting on items so I'm unclear because the standard items that do not materially Chang the course of business the um the minutes the um I just need some clarification on that because the the things that do not change the
050material functions of a meeting um we're not employment matters or um is that to be included or not so I second that for the point of clarification and discussion yes Mr Alexander you've been recognized yes you know I know we're talking about a working session and a voting session I don't think they should be just one and the other there going to be some times we need and right now where we have employees that need to get get uh okay tonight so they can begin the process of whatever it is to to move into their positions so we just wait now they miss they got to wait for another two weeks or whatever and we well maybe wday or or to if we're doing this later on a month and now how do we get
051them employ employed if we say we can only work and then we got to vote I think some we should when we talk about this and we discuss it that we discuss it if we think we need to vote on at that point in time let's vote on so we can get it out of the way if we don't then we can put it to the the the next uh voting session I I don't know how we want to do it but that's my thought and uh I'm I'm giving right now thank you there any other questions or discussions so again I I just want to say that I'm not trying to make this harder than what it needs to be um I've listened to this board uh in general State they need more time
052to consider uh items before voting at the same meeting um and is also trying to keep in mind that the business of the board or the district has to move as well and so because it is the board's agenda you can Vote or not vote on items um it's it's not some law that says we can only do one or the other because it's our meeting and so we get to decide and it's okay if we want to wait and vote on the minutes for the next meeting and I think that's the motion that's on the floor that's like not a deal breaker for me that's what's on the floor so it's been moved it's been seconded is there any other discussion yes I know we're trying something new and it's not always easy or
053perfect the first time anybody tries anything and so I'm happy that we are having discussion we're figuring this out but whatever it is we end up doing I think it is important to be able to have some sort of clarity or expectation or routine because the public should know if we're voting on things when we're voting on things what we're going to vote on and so even if there are what feels routine items we vote on them every time because it's important every time and so whatever it is that we end up doing I would like some sort of uh I'd like to be able to have confidence in the consistency of it once it's established thank you is there any other discussion questions vice president Jackson uh yes thank you madam president and member
054molar um for the statements I I think for my piece uh we know that uh the minutes are a standard operating thing and originally I wanted to make an amendment to the motion to include all voting items because for the purpose of if we said that we were going to wait on voting until Wednesday and we're talking about like additional preparation on some items and also um transparency of the things that's getting voted on the minutes like you said for me are is not a deal breaker but some of the other items that maybe people did not read into in depth um understanding that Wednesday would be a voting meeting that's the only reason why I bring up the the CAU and concern if we say we we're doing just a a working session in
055in a sense and I understand as um member U Alexander has stated as far as matters of employment we're in to meet Wednesday to vote and typic I I unless I miss something they it once it goes through and they go through it's been improved they go through HR maybe they can start a Monday but it wouldn't be in the middle of this week and I I could be wrong with that but because we've stated that the voting for certain matters would be on Wednesday and not in this specific meeting we would discuss some things and hash out certain things I think it's uh it's appropriate um the request to move them and like I said maybe not so much as minutes I'm not married to them but I the other items when we get
056to voting if we voting on minutes then what's the stop to vote on this and I know we can call it for a vote I'm just saying what we've communicated and I do know this is new and I'm a processor out loud so I'm processing as I'm speaking to you all I understand it's our meeting and um as you stated that it's the will of the board but then I understood the will of the board was to have this cow and not vote so now we're convened and now we talking about voting so that's the that's my uh just trepidation with that for us to consider that if we're not then we're not if it's pressing items and we know there's pressing items the superintendent makes us aware of something like hey this needs to
057be and we know it's pressing then we'll made aware of that that okay this is something we have to move like when we're short subs or we need to open a bill you know things like that just for consideration Madam president absolutely is there any other discussion or questions about it the question is there any objection to that so the motion on the FL did you make an amendment to the motion okay so the motion on the floor is to remove uh the items the meeting minutes 9.1 and 9.2 um to the regular meeting agenda roll call please Reverend Harrison no Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes no Mr Alexander no Miss ay no so the motion fails uh five excuse me 4 to2 and meaning we need to move to item 99.1
058for approval and 9.2 is there a motion for approval of 9.1 regular meeting minutes for Monday November 4th so move it's been moved by member sites is there a second yes it's been seconded by member Harrison is there any discussion seeing none roll call please Dr Thompson Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson abang was not present Dr Molar no Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss ay yes uh motion carries 41 thank you 9.2 will entertain a motion to accept the meeting minutes from Monday November 25th it's been moved by member Harrison is there a second second second by member Sykes is there any discussion oh I'm sorry I am sorry so it it is for one with one abstention sorry thank you thank you and did you get Harrison and okay any discussion seeing none
059roll call please Dr Thompson Miss Jackson abstain was not present Dr Molar no Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss Autry yes Reverend Harrison yes motion carries 41 with one abstention thank you and I do apologize I think I skipped over a whole section um I skipped uh president's report and so um I'm just going to circle back because it's just really something quick um I just wanted to bring to this board's attention um an opportunity for a workshop on negotiations as we're coming to that time and so um I did ask that it be put on everybody calendar uh Pebble and Wagner is providing some of those workshops so if anyone is interested in that um it is there for us to take advantage of um and also I just wanted to acknowledge it
060was mentioned earlier about the retreat um I want to thank Deborah keys for uh her time and and assisting this board um and trying to help us um learn how to work and govern together effectively and so hopefully that is something that this board is willing to continue moving forward um and so um that's actually all that I had and I apologize that I skipped over that um I don't believe there's been any uh committee meeting since we last met but if each chair could please State their uh next meeting um 8.1 legal contracts board policy that next meeting is Dr Molar yes thank you Madame President so uh legal committee we have three items that we are adding to next Wednesday's agenda there are copies of the three policies in your packets today we
061have 8510 Wellness 5200 attendance and 51 36 personal communication devices um personal communication devices is a Neola update I did ask for it to be added to our um Friday notes the actual Neola policy because um it it is um a bit different than what is here um unfortunately if we click on that we don't have access to it so I have requested access and so just to let me colleagues know if you'd like to uh review that item you might also have to request access and then be granted access um so hopefully we'll have all that Monday so these would be um a second read however I don't know if today's meeting would count as a second read and then it would be a third read on Wednesday um or what the intention is
062because this is our first cow so I will leave that up to the rest of the board if today is the second read or if Wednesday is the second read but those are the three polic IES being uh brought from policy committee to the whole board thank you and so I will have to get clarification on that so that's one of those Kinks You have to work out when you're trying something new so I will find out if this would count as a second read today for the cow thank you and did you say your next meeting our next meeting is next Monday at 5:30 uh that would be December 16 at 5:30 thank you Dr monar finance and Capital Management thank you madam chair the uh next committee was meeting was actually scheduled for
063uh December 16th at 4:30 however we have canceled the finance committee meeting I think given the various meetings that we have had that uh we will have covered those items that we would have normally plan to discuss on on the fourth on the uh December 16th therefore I think that we can cancel the next meeting I am incredibly disappointed thank you um instructional policy student achievement vice president Jackson thank you the Fantastic phenomenal instructional policy committee will be meeting in the 202 5 new year on January 6th here in our boardroom um at our regular schedule at the time thank you thank you and Equity committee Mr Alexander yes we have no report but we will be meeting tomorrow briefly uh at 5:30 Equity committee will meet tomorrow afternoon evening at 530 for a brief
064meeting thank you thank you very much and so um next on the agenda we already dealt with the minutes um so we start with the first section of personnel recommendations uh Dr Robinson thank you president arrey I wish to recommend approval of the Personnel recommendations presented in categories 10 through 20 to be moved upon the board's approval process to to the special board meeting on December 11th 2024 and so this is just to move the items uh to the agenda and then also open up the discussion so is there a motion uh to move the Personnel items um to our next meeting agenda so move it's been moved by vice president Jackson there a [Music] second second it's been seconded by Mr Alexander and so now would be the time um if you want to
065go Section by section for your questions around Personnel I'm starting with the first section section 10 which are professional staff and administrators are there any questions have comment yes uh I I I know we're talking about discussing these things now and then moving them to the next meeting but if they're ready to be voted on I don't see a reason to hold them basically hostage and until the next meeting if we don't need to I know it's it'll be Wednesday but if we were in a regular a regular uh cycle of our board meetings we might have to wait a little longer so I I I wouldn't want us to get put in a rabbit hole uh for for this type of stuff I think if they're ready to be voted on move them vote
066for them and move on and we can go from there that's just my thought Reverend Harrison been recognized Madam chair uh um I'm a little confused confused about the process and I know we are um working on the process but um my initial uh reservation about voting on something was because we didn't have information and so if we move if we discuss them today okay so my initial reservation was treating Personnel like a consent agenda saying 10 through 20 appr approve yes or or no but if we go 101 and we discuss that then I'm ready to vote on it if we go 10 two and we discuss that then I'm ready to vote on it if we go 10 three and I have a question on it then I say I'll ask that we
067take time on it or we move it but there's a process for this uh so I'm kind of with board member Alexander I'm kind of confused if if we talk about it today if we come to an understanding today then we can vote on it if there's an item that we don't have an understanding then we would ask to move it so I'm not talking about today I'm just talking about the process more so than voting today but if we're going to discuss the item the issue we're going to get clarification if the issue has or the item has been through a committee meeting and we have had opportunity to get the information I think U again we are chewing the cud twice and again if if it's our will to vote on it I
068mean we can do that if that's what we decide how we want to run the cows we can but again the the purpose was to have the opportunity to discuss items uh and have time to not feel pressured to have to vote at the same meeting because that's kind of what I was SC but it's up to the board if they want to vote at the same meeting this is just an attempt to get on the cycle so Madam chair yes member sites Madam chair thank you and members of the uh board I think that uh what's happening is that we just kind of putting things uh before uh so what we should do actually is we should uh right bring up each issue 10 .1 discuss that issue if we find that there is
069a need to refer this issue to the voting uh to the next section session where we're going to be voting and that's what we should do I think that when when the superintendent uh requested that all items go immediately to the next meeting then that kind of prevents us from discussing each item before we actually refer that item to the next meeting where we we may vote because we as as as the Pastor said we cannot determine whether or not we have any questions if we don't discuss it first before we refer it so we should discuss before we refer so again this is all new and so would so it's it's just understanding the process I appreciate Madame President you're willing to do this to take the time to do this uh but I
070just think it's just a matter of us just just taking the time to go as we should and just just uh so I would ask the superintendent if you would just not just report out that you are just reporting these items and not necessarily referring it right now and then if there are some additional questions that we may have that uh we can determine whether or not we want to refer it then and to have it for a vote if we decide if with like with member Alexander if he's finding that after the discussion there's no other new information that's going to come before the board then perhaps we may find that we want to vote on this tonight but we really have to discuss it uh and ask questions before we can refer it
071to vote at the next meeting so it's it's it's just a matter of finding out and the thing the unique let me just say Madam Madame President the uniqueness about this is that normally with the body we can do these things outside of the eye of the public but because when four or more of us get together we can't have a caucus we can't meet behind the scenes and determine how to proceed with this agenda so we're kind of learning this as we go in real time in real time in front of the public so thank you and forgive us as we go through this process but we will get there yes I I just appreciate you being willing to have a working session so that we can have the time to talk about these
072issues so I would just ask Madam chair if you if you would allow the president the superintendent to just if you could could just kind of kind of uh resend your recommendation and and allow our board members to just kind of go through each one of these and then we can decide which one we want to refer and which one we want to vote on tonight that's okay I think moving forward um M SES the way we wrote it um I we probably need to be a little bit more definitive in in saying CU When I said the board's process which was to allow you to go through each one right um so we just need to re write it so that it says says that so I can resend that right that we want
073to go through each one and then after each one we can decide whether or not we want to refer and you can or vote yeah you can vote on it tonight if you so choose to yes and so there was a motion then that we should probably move um at this time so yes Mr Alexander yeah so that we can be expeditiously and move uh in a in a timely manner could we look at let's say like 10.1 through 10.4 if anybody has questions on 10.1 through 4 ask their question and we can discuss it versus going by each one of these things so we're going to be here all night going through each line by line but if we go through Section by section and there's a question on that specific item then we
074can say yay or nay and we can move on I think we make it too difficult and it's really not difficult right so if we're in agreement the motion is removed from the floor uh to move it forth because we'll have the discussion now so we can just as I was going to State section 10 unanimous consent to remove it if there's no objections so section 10 is professional staff and administrators and so there's four items in section 10 I don't know if there's any questions around that Reverend Harrison I have a question thank you madam chair um item 103 assignment of Title One um just for for my clarification what what determines when we have a a current job and we switch it from let's say a general fund to a title fund what
075determines why we're switching that um Pastor Harrison so there there are certain guidelines that we have to follow for Title One title two title three title four and so forth um and so when you're talking about certain positions that are going to be directly in front of children or that really like tutors those types of those positions are just an example is a position that could be used I mean could be placed on title on um federal dollars um which it does save us on the general side um but we're paying for it out of title um funds so it's it's just the criteria that we have to follow and they tell us what that is and and as long as we meet that that criteria then we could use that position or pay for
076that particular program out of the title funds did that answer your question rever Harrison yes do you have further clarification no I just wanted to we're here uh for personnel I wanted to introduce Judy ner and Patty Russell who are from the HC department and myself of course yine Atkins and we're here to answer any questions you have thank you are there any other questions in section 10 Dr Molar thank you and this is a general question also as we continue to uh work on the C process um are there any items in section 10 or other sections that could have been brought through some sort of or or listed uh in in a committee first so we would have seen the positions were coming in advance versus the first time that we see um
077not the names of the people but the number of positions that are coming to the board's voting agenda so in we were actually going to do that this month but we will start that in January um where we bring the Personnel matters to the finance committee and then those questions would be asked then which may even save time when you have the next cow that you're not I mean people may still have questions but it will have already gone through the finance committee thank you any other questions in that section section 11.1 retirements resignations I'll just State um I want to thank Mr linger who looks like he is after 40 years going to be uh resigning or leaving us and so I know he was a coach for a while he's been our assistant
078athletic director for the district just want to thank him for all of his service um Madam president I want to thank you for saying that because he has been around a long time and done a lot of work with a lot of students and a lot of his students still come back and see him and talk to him about what he has done for them and help them throughout their uh school and their athletic careers thank you thank you the next section is supplemental contracts and so questions Reverend Harrison Reverend Harr uh thank you madam chair item 121 um we list a um we we have supplemental contracts listed throughout here and there different C certain things we approved I think last meeting we approved maybe 60 supplemental contracts and you uh superintendent stated that
079we will um look at this in the finance committee um but I just have some questions I talked to the treasur I have some questions on the number of people that we uh approve at one time through supplemental contracts and sometimes it's hard to pick a name out because we are in an open meeting um but with the um superintendent stating um that we will look at this in the finance committee um I will ask my questions there um because there's a lot of questions thank you thank you are there any other uh questions around supplemental contracts in section 12 vice president Jackson um I have a question in regards to if um because for some of these if it's a designation for like wrestling coaches one is a male for male one is for
080female and it's two different um stiens or the contracts is being paid how does that work in the sense that they're not getting paid the same time like two different payments for um one job while they're on the clock for another job do does it do you understand where so why does one person have the boy's contract and the girls cont yeah like are they are they practicing at different times or on different dates or is it just one should it just be one contract for the co being the coach wrestling they are two separate sports that have two distinct um uh schedules the game schedules and different things like that so you know there could be different PR practice nights boys are Monday Wednesday and Friday girls are Tuesday Thursday it depends on the
081school but the you will see that um typically with the smaller and roll sports like bowling Golf and uh wrestling yeah because if there's just one girl that's wrestling and I'm just I'm saying this um because I feel like I heard someone say like at a specific school it wasn't a full girls team um and I can get I'll get those facts by the next time we meet cuz I like to just dealing real facts um but so if that's the case and it's one girl who she's who is she practicing with that's a good question so if uh and that's why I'm asking this question because if in fact it's one girl on a wrestling team and there's a full boy wrestling team and she's going through drills or something with the boys then
082that's what I'm saying about my question should it be not to say that a person shouldn't get pay but shouldn't it be one like why are they they're getting two supplemental um contracts and they're doing the same thing with at the same time do you understand right absolutely um and I think that you know there are uh again the the Ohio High School Athletic Association does have two very distinct you know girls and boys and we do have the two supplemental contracts that are outlined in our colletive bargaining AG okay but I can get further information if you want to oh yeah I'm going to get further information too for clarity because I actually had someone ask me this question that's why I'm asking you all um with my exact example that I gave you
083but like I said I'm I'm going to make sure whenever and it'll be offline like that I come to you with the facts because then you know so that it's clear right and we can you know I can yes yes thank you Reverend Harrison you been nice thank you madam chair my question would be simultaneous contracts okay so we got the girls we got the boys we got one coach getting paid two two individual contracts at the same time um and I think that would for me that succinct what what my question supplemental contracts are we paying two contracts at one time and if if we are with that not be better to pay one contract boys and girls wrestling boys and girls bat Mitten well we do have some schools that do have two
084different individuals that one does the boys golf team when does the girls golf team um you know again something that we can consider and do a 50/50 spit or however we want to look at that just also we have to just keep in mind lot all these are listed these these different contracts with in the uh collective bargaining agreement so they're separated out and in that manner but not to say that that uh looking at some of the um situations may occur why is there only one person on this team you know those type of situations how do we take a look at that so that's something that we certainly can discuss but they they are listed separately a separate agreement and and just for clarity that I understand I don't have any problem with
085anyone having a like SE that's qualified to get a supplemental contract to individuals that is not my thing at all I I I'm saying when one person yeah like two separate yeah that's the that's the only thing that you know that I I just wanted Clarity on so thank you are there any other questions in that section for supplementals okay seeing none the next section 13 is for substitutes any questions or comments around the substitutes okay we'll move on to section 14 which are tutors there five items under our tutors are there any questions under our tutors okay there's no items on under 15 for support staff the next section is 16 par professionals I'm sorry I has a question about the tutors I'm back to the tutors yes you've been recognized it is a
086HR it is a HR question if a teacher who a contractual teacher um I understand doing her or his or her contractual hours right they're serving in the role you know of their classroom teacher if if for out of school time or after hours could a teacher then also you know how some teachers serve as coaches and they get a supplemental contract could then a teacher also receive a contract to be a tutor like uh we do have that situation with the akran after school programs where certified teachers are providing tutoring services and it's funded through the Acron okay and so with like for instance you know teacher they may be a math teacher they're working with their kids and like some teachers are may stay after hours they're not getting paid necessarily like they're
087just great teachers and um so they're like trying to do extra how would they go about like is there a certain process that they should go about to seek compensation I'm just curious for my own this is not like no teachers are baned on my door there are Provisions for teachers uh in their contract that we'd have to follow for for instance if there's extended time or some kind of provision that may apply in any given circumstance that we'd have to look at if there is something going on an ongoing basis or if we have them assigned to something after the regular work okay I was just curious cuz I saw like $338 and I just like hey if I'm a teacher and I'm already helping six kids after school then how can I just
088say add me to the list I'm already certified and I'm here Monday and Wednesday doing extra tutoring for my kids cuz I'm passionate and so I just wanted to it was just my own curiosity thank you you thank you anything else around tutors okay section 16 is the pair professionals Reverend Harrison you've been recognized thank you madam chair item 163 164 community resource Specialists are are they teachers um when when we're looking at is this something different than supplemental contracts are are they teachers they they're answer it they're not te I'll let them answer but they're not teachers they are um I guess you would consider them like a guest lecturer they really are the ones that are helping the kids prep them and get them ready for these plays and the musicals that they
089have to engage in they're really the ones that help them with their lines and the at the part the acting parts that they have to do within these plays that's that's the work that they they do but I can let Patty add more to it if you yeah so community resource Specialists it's a position that sort of um just encompasses a variety of different professionals that we bring into schools to support different programs so you do tend to see them a lot at Firestone and Miller South as um they're coming in to assist students learning how to do like technical sets lights sound for theater Productions uh learning how to build sets um and then you see them as well at Miller South and Firestone in um Performing Arts you see um it might be
090sometimes the community resource specialist might be like a um a really talented like strings player that's coming in to do private strings lessons for a small group of students so their functionality depends on what program they're serving but they are Community professionals that have a really specific skill set that they're bringing to benefit our students thank you thank you there any other questions under section 16 Dr Molar you've been recogniz thank you Madame President um for a lot of the items it will say like name position effective and then another column that says like new replacement Etc so I was wondering in 161 is this new is this replacement and then what kind of do we use to determine when we list that information well okay so 16.1 is that's a resignation so that wouldn't
091we wouldn't list a newer replacement but for 163 and 164 it hasn't traditionally been our practice to list newer replacement for as needed positions um as needed positions come about based on like the needs of the program so in a sense they're always Replacements but they're also always new because each time you bring in a community resource specialist they are doing a specific work unique to that individual but the concurrent of of using those um is cyclical and you know Firestone um Miller South and different buildings do use those annually so it's it it really it could go either way you could say that it's a new position you could say that it's a replacement the nature of the work is new the existence of the position is not um so in that note with
092as needed positions it hasn't really been our practice to State um newer replacement thank you followup um can I make a request to maybe come up with something to identify that I don't know if the term as needed would be sufficient but just something to let us know absolutely this is exactly what you said I think as needed in that last little box there might be helpful I appreciate that thank you thank you any other questions under section 16 section 17 is Child Nutrition are there any questions Child Nutrition I don't see any section 18 is maintenance operations Transportation there's four items are there any questions around those four items seeing none section 19 is security Personnel any questions I don't see any SEC vice president Jackson you've been recognized yes so with the um
093resignation of safety team members what is our process like how quickly do we feel these resignations and um how are we determining like the necessity of the the the role for the safety team member CU I see just as we go through just like it's a lot of resignations going on and so I'm just curious as far as um you have safety team members resigning what is our what's the turnaround process for something like that yeah a lot of them I mean on occasions you have some who resign and then we have on occasion where we're replacing those those positions we try we sort of I met with Mr Jones and um Miss Patty and um no U Miss Judy I'm sorry and we got it down to pretty much a science where we balanced
094it out for all the schools um Jennings which is the school that this particular person will go um they were short um a a a a uh safety team member but sometimes we don't even have people that apply for these jobs and sometimes it could take longer than we would want we advert and sometimes we don't get it and then sometimes we advertise and I guess it just depends on depends cuz I have people in the community always asking me about this specific love for them so it's just to look and and and the reason why I want to ask because as I understood it I know it's with the metal detectors how they were talking about the timing like it's good to have the safety team members there because of the Sweat Equity it
095takes when their kids are bringing the bags through to help those um building administrators get through that that's why I wanted to kind of like that so thank you for the information I just want to add one point um one you asked the question what is the process and um we have we we talked about this earlier in the year if you recall but we do have a internal process it's called the position budget Control process the PBR process and we are requiring um departments that when there's a vacancy for whatever reason that if there's a need to fill the position they put in that position a requisition for that it comes to the HC Department uh we review that um and um Finance also um sees that and is notified about that and ultimately
096determination is made based on the assessment um of whether or not you know budgetarily and the operational need for the position okay because how like on the mic we're talking about this position is resignation because I literally of all the positions I can be in a grocery store I can be at a baby shower I can be at a game walking through people are asking about I put in something for safety team and um they still haven't got like what is you know y'all say y'all need people you know I'm a retired security guard you know different things like that so I just wanted to kind of have a other than cuz I tell them go on the website and so then people are inboxing me you know Facebook ask determination is made that we
097are going to post for the position that's what occurs after we make an assessment so if we determine we're posting this job that's when people you know then it people apply and then you know they'll know it's there and available okay thank you and Miss Jack and just for additional Clarity this specific position has already been replaced we uh we hired three two full-time one part-time safety team members at the previous board meeting and one of those was to replace this vacancy so it's already uh we're already on the overs side of that process thank you Dr Molar thank you I kind of want to follow up on this discussion because this was really informative um about I guess I I have I don't know how many questions but I was wondering about how long
098does that process usually take to determine and I know it can vary from position to position but to decide whether or not we will replace because whenever I see the resignations in the agenda I always feel like well of course we'll let them go you know if somebody is is is going to leave we but it might the information that might be really helpful is if we have like uh a a term that was used a lot earlier this year was uh a pass through right this person is leaving but we're going to replace something else with something else and it's it's a pass through position or pass through money and so if maybe we could have something on here like intend to replace and so that way when we see The Replacements we see
099where that replacement came from if we see new we see the connection to where that new was related to before but some way to know just a list of like what we intend to replace if if that determination is if we know at the time again we meet weekly here in our office uh to review the all the requisitions and um you know so it's it's based on if we have that information available but I have no problem sharing um and then to to answer your question about the timeline it really depends on the position some of them are are pretty like clearcut right you see this and you're like okay well we have to replace this teacher um some of them require a little bit more discussion and consideration so the turnaround time it
100really does vary position to position but usually um it's uh minimum probably one week maximum maybe 3 weeks at this point just depending on the on the role this is my I promise this will be my last thing and I want to thank you so much you guys are doing a great job answering the question and I appreciate the energy um so this is just what I to clarify from my own mind because I'm looking at this here agenda for this here meeting and I see a resignation and so for me I'm thinking in when we're approving these that this is right now this resignation but you made a statement that these have already been filled because it's a old no that's what she said Y no no yeah no and so I just want
101to be clear how does that is this like a retro thing because if I'm just seeing the resignation now but it's been filled I don't understand how that works that you fill a position that I'm not understanding being resigned from yet and I'm approving yeah absolutely so that those kind of things happen kind of just with um General bureaucratic breakdown uh sometimes resignation letters get turned into a supervisor um and so a vacancy gets going but it takes a some time for that resignation letter to get all the way to human capital and until we have certain documents in place we don't put things on the board for you guys um to consider so there every now and then you are going to see some some resignations from a few weeks ago um we we
102try our best to stay timely and to just stay on top of things but it will happen every now thank you for that honest response I appreciate and respect it thank you thank you any other questions under safety team section uh 21 or section 20 is for uh students student worker any questions so that actually concludes the Personnel recommendation section so if you look on 21 it states approval of personnel recommendations to move to the next board agenda if that's our will or we can entertain a motion to actually vote on these items now with your Amendment and it sounds like you know the questions were answered in this section and I know things are forthcoming to finance yes vice president Jackson okay the student worker for like $111 and some change what is the
103Stu what is the job what does the student worker do okay so um so student it's a student custodial worker um buildings can hire them based on their custodial um Staffing allotment so if they have a vacancy instead of using a temporary custodian they can um if they have an interested student um or or if our job trainers have an interested student they can assist them in applying into one of those uh but what they do is custodial work excellent thank you for that and see this is my problem is because when those stone masonry when I asked about those kids who have an excellent teacher at bookto and they they're in a masonry program and I said why can't they get hired I I heard a lot of reasons is why they could not
104but they can be hired to be custodians so I'm going to leave that there and I want someone to follow up with me because I know those students do quality work they have an excellent teacher I have work done at my house by Stone work done and they do a great job so again if we can pay the kids to clean up it's a budget for custodial work and I'm talking about a skill trade almost to the level of Journeymen these some of these kids are doing so much so that the instructor will pay them I need for everyone to have some reconsiderations when we're doing tuck point work on our buildings that these masonry students could do why we need to pay these kids and so I need somebody give me a clear good
105answer for all the HR people and everyone who had a reason why they couldn't get paid I need somebody to to uh get at me about that I'll follow up on that clean the building I'll follow up on that thank you vice president Jackson so again we're at the end of our Personnel recommendations um did you have an additional question Dr Bonar I do and I'm sorry that if this might not be the time but um if we do I guess I'm jumping back to what you said before if we do vote on everything today does that negate the need to meet on Wednesday it depends on what's left if there's anything left okay but if there's nothing left if there's nothing left it's good to know thank you oh motivation huh yeah motivation okay
106so our person person recommendations we've gone through um and so we can entertain a motion at this time as to how we would like to proceed either way Madam chair I make a motion we forgo what was established and we vote on these Personnel recommendations today second it's been moved by Mr Harrison and seconded by Mr Alexander is there any further discussion and this is to approve the Personnel recommendation this evening is there any further discussion seeing none so Dr Robinson you can make the recommendation that makes sense that makes sense yeah um president archery I wish to recommend approval of the Personnel recommendations presented in categories 10 through 20 for approval um this evening thank you it's been moved by Mr Harrison and seconded by Mr Alexander is there any further discussion seeing none
107roll call please Dr Thompson Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss ay yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes motion Carri 60 thank you and and so the next item I um 22.1 and Dr Molar actually already referenced this so we should probably just decide right now um when it comes to the cows and any potential policy readings um I mean the cow is considered a board meeting and so do we want to consider this to be uh part of the readings for the policies because it is a board meeting and Madam chair I would make a motion that we would um consider this the necessary reading um we've had the policy the policies have been through committee they have been vetted through committee so I would make that motion it's been
108moved to consider this the policy uh number two for 8510 8 5136 and 5200 0 second so this is just to decide that C meetings will include the count as a reading towards our policy second second second is there any discussion Madam president just so for for clarity here as I note this are are we specifically just talking about um that particular one are we are we saying we're going to is it part of 26.1 approval under the consent agenda are we taking this piece out and voting on it individually right now I just I'm not clear so this is 221 for the policies legal okay legal the legal committee yeah legal contracts and board polic and for clarification we aren't voting to approve the policies we are just recognizing them as a second read
109the second read okay so I don't know I no no that helps I understand now okay okay that that makes sense got it so it's been moved it's been seconded and is there any further discussion seeing none roll call please Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss ay yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson oh I'm sorry okay Dr Molar yes motion carries okay and so next is our consent agenda which does include the items in 23 and 24 and so are there questions about the donations Reverend Harrison you've been recognized Madam chair I would ask that we would remove item 236 and 241 from the consent agenda so there is a motion to remove 236 235 235 236 236 241 and 241 from the consent agenda is there a second discussion uh thank you madam
110president since we are on the uh we're going through the process of a committee as a whole so because it's on the consent agenda then we actually can uh as opposed to removing it from the consent agenda we can discuss it on the consent agenda before we determine whether or not we wanted to stay on the consent agenda for the next meeting so so uh did you madam president may I asked so did you want to discuss these items now yes to determine whether or not we want to move these over to the consent agenda for the next next board meeting yes is that what you ask okay okay so you want to discuss those items I withdraw my motion okay motion has been withdrawn and 23.4 for G Foundation Grant award Reverend Harrison Madam
111chair um I I I want to make sure that we are discussing the Partnerships that we have with the community and want to um publicly acknowledge uh the G foundation for their steadfast support of akan public schools um we have a couple of uh items that they fund and it's when we say a couple of items that they fund um I've totaled in this agenda $887,000 covering um a variety of things so G is funding for our students who do not have beds they are purchasing beds and for our students and not only are they purchasing beds but they're purchasing bed linen and not only bed linen but they're purchasing the services to deliver those beds Linens um so we want to certainly acknowledge G as a community partner um for the social needs of
112our kids the material needs but they also are partnering with us in essential experiences that allows some kids to go to the zoo and it may not seem to be um a big thing for a person to go to the zoo but when you live in a neighborhood that the zoo is located in and you never go to the zoo because you can't afford it it's a big thing we want to thank G for not only supporting the emotional needs of our kids but supporting the physical needs of our kids and being a great partner with the Aron Public Schools thank you madam chair thank you and so item uh Madam Madam chair yes uh thank you Madame President I would just add to that that so we're talking about these are our homeless children
113that particip that attend acan public schools that these beds are for and so I would just rise in support of what uh member Harrison has just said is that uh these are the type of Partnerships that we need in order to take care of our children we quite often don't think about homelessness and children but it is significant in our community and I think the number probably is somewhere close to 1,800 on a daily basis the staff can correct me on that so that's significant and so to have a partner that's willing to pay for the beds because if you're hungry uh if you're homeless where are you going to sleep where are we going to set you up how are we going to take care of you but it also points to the work
114that our staff here in the AC public school system are constantly doing you know before we can teach our children we have to make sure that they're safe and safety is having a place to go and so that's what this represent and so I too join you and saying to the uh gar Foundation that we appreciate your partnership and you're helping us to take care of our children to prepare them to be able to learn thank you and so 25.5 do you have a additional questions Reverend Harrison I think it's 23.4 256 23.5 23 I want to take the time to uh also thank the Martha Holden Jenny's Grant $33,000 at East High School um and we have a school budget of $573 million and we need every penny of that but we also need
115additional resources so the efforts and the not just the time but the talent and the treasure that we receive from um these individual Community Partners Martha Holden Jenny's um grants to help our most challenged kids at East want to um just publicly thank them um and if I could just slide to the next one I'll sit down Dick Sporting Goods uh the foundation that has provided $100,000 grant that we will match for students at East High School as the superintendent mentioned um this is the beginning of a sports complex and the beginning of anything takes Partnerships so we want to thank Dick Sporting Goods for their $100,000 uh investment in our students um and we want to encourage anyone else who have few dollars large or small uh to invest in acon public schools uh
116because we certainly appreciate it and we just always want to acknowledge U the contributions large and small thank you madam chair thank you yes vice president Jackson yes I just have a question so um and I I concur with everything that my colleagues have said about gr is phenomenal things um I believe strongly in Community Partnerships and I it's that's yes um but I have a question like or there are people like when I mentioned these young people who are graduates from our schools that give things to our school and even when um I don't recall Trey Gordon being on the agenda or acknowledge when it was thousands upon thousands of dollars worth of Taylor Made suits that he gave um and the I'm going to tell you why I'm saying this because this is
117a record and so then anyone can access this record in these agendas years down the line and so that's Legacy and I they're doing it from their heart and they are our graduate so I just want to say this in this type of forum because there may be a process there's people who give in various amounts and so even with uh joshm with Bari and the the jerseys that they donated I'm sure that there is a um a actual Financial amount that can be assigned to that how do they go about being documented and recognized in this type of format more than just on my reflection so let Miss Deborah um but a lot of times it never gets to my office so if it's something that they're just doing a partnership with a particular
118school and it happens frequently um no no ill will intended it's just that they're partnering with that school um but we do ask for the principles to let us know uh and sometimes they do and sometimes they don't so we can that's something that we had talked about earlier this year going through Communications now that we have someone um Dr hod will be able to work with Miss Deborah so that we can be a little bit more conscious of even what's going to schools um so that we can recognize those people I just if it was a process I needed to help because a young lady even asked me about doing um hair a owner of a salon asked how would she go about if she wanted to offer free hair styling um for students
119and okay so there are two forms that come within the district one is a non-cash donation so I want you to think of to your point about the suits and then there is a cash donation form the cash donation forms if somebody is donating to say a specific School through acum Public Schools an actual amount of money that goes directly on the form to the superintendent's office and it's added to the agenda the non-cash donation form comes through the principal or Department it could be like project rise and then it is completed and signed by the department head the person getting the inventory which could be the building principal or the department and then it it comes to the business Affairs office both are added together to present to your agenda following the agenda approval
120then the treasurer's office goes ahead and gives an acknowledgement thank you letter for for each individual donation or organization however it comes in and it also not only thanks them for the support of the schools or individual school it goes ahead and also allows for the uh reporting for tax purposes so that is an acknowledgement that goes through Dr Thompson's office thank you no thank you so much Miss V for that appreciate you thank you superintendent I think about all the PTA stuff that I did and I never did a form like like there's gold post and everything that we purchase so whatever it was for the kids any other uh questions yes Dr Molar sorry thank you and thanks to everyone who is answering all of our questions today this has been I feel
121an incredibly productive experiment today um but to follow up on the Don donations um if a Community member reached out to us and they wanted to set up a donation who do we refer them to who do we forward that on to to get that process started if they want to do a large scale donation or if they're watching who do they reach out to directly it depends on the type of donation so if it is a large donation of items they are more than welcome to contact the business Affairs office and we will then direct it to the correct form if it is a cash donation um we usually refer them to the treasurer's office because there are ways that we would take the money in that is very specific some of which you
122approve to be put into specific funds other ones sometimes it's important to understand that we also have a part in the akan Community Foundation and somebody can go ahead and donate to the akan Community Foundation on behalf of us and designated that way so many times it's the treasures office that handles those large types of donations you're welcome thank you are any other questions around the consent agenda and so now as we've reached the end of the consent agenda this is the time to move to approve it now or move it to our next board agenda and so we'll entertain a motion Madam president I make a motion that we uh vote on these items that that we've talked about and discussed and move uh vote on them tonight and get them off the the
123uh agenda thank you it's been moved by Mr Alexander to vote on the consent agenda um this evening is there a second I'll second it's been seconded by Dr Molar I am sorry we have to have the superintendent make the recommendations and then that's thank you president archery I wish to recommend approval of the resolutions and motions presented in category 25 they're in proper format and I move for their approval please thank you it's been moved by Mr Alexander and M Dr Molar is there any further discussion seea roll call please Dr Thompson um Madam president so just for clarification we are voting to approve this tonight right now that that's what we're doing yes correct okay understood Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss Autry yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar
124yes motion carry 60 thank you and next is business Affairs recommendations there are five items under business affairs recommendations and so are there any questions around business Affairs recommendations listed in 27 Dr Molar thank you once again Madame President um my question for uh not necessarily any item specifically but these items in general um I heard that or remember that for the uh Personnel um maybe bringing those through finance committee for business Affairs are those also potentially going through finance committee in the future or is there a place for them to come to the board before the main agenda we we would bring it to finance um unless the board wants it brought somewhere else y'all told me to bring it to finance our agendas are getting long you wanted to go somewhere on S
125Finance not [Music] Finance Harrison Madam president and uh superintendent Mr superintendent I I believe that um Finance is an appropriate place for a lot of things but I also um going to push back on member Mard because uh she do have legal contracts amen okay so so we we not going to let member Mard get a pass on here um so we certainly want things to go through committee um equitably legally amen and instructionally and financially amen so if it's a um contract you wanted to go through legal contract but if it's regular things bring it through Finance if it is the will of the board I can make room on the legal policy and contracts committee for contracts I think member SES yeah so uh Madam president don't for tonight uh and this uh
126working committee that we have going here uh I think that if if there are no questions then uh I see no reason to not support these items unless the committee chair would like something in particular to come before the committee I see nothing in particular that I would want to come to our finance and that uh as far as I'm concerned and my co-chair uh I am fine with the items that's here that we can vote on tonight Dr monar sorry well for clarification I didn't mean necessarily tonight but for in the future for the business Affairs section okay [Music] so I wish to recommend uh thank you president I wish to recommend the approval of business business Affairs recommendations presented in category 27 thank you is there a motion to approve business Affairs so
127move it's been moved by member Harrison is there a second second second by member Alexander is there any further discussions around business Affairs yes vice president Jackson you've been recognized thank you madam president I just have a general question so cuz we're akan and I am so backing 330 ranking all the way through Garfield um I'm just curious how do we come up with the contracts for like the Landscaping the snow removal it like do is there a bidding process on that and I just want to ask that because it's a large amount like it seems like the larger amount are companies that are not within the city of acine and I just wonder does the city of akan not have enough or what was the bidding process that we have all these WDS worth
128outside areas that's getting the larger amount for us so um before Miss Deborah answers the question um at the last meeting I uh stated to uh Pastor Harrison that we'll start this process in like in the Summer where we can put this on the district website for people to actually um apply moving forward um and it'll go through the because these are the kind of the vendors that we've been using over years but that would afford these vendors as well as anybody else that qualifies for the the um the expectations rules that they have to follow they will have a chance and then we will be able to do this early enough um before December and bring this October November to the board points I'll let her actually these were approved at the meeting of
129the 25th the only reason this has coming back tonight is to change the date because the original approval was for these contracts to start tomorrow and then we had an issue with snow last week so we needed to bring it back just to change the date so if we needed to use and pay for those services and we had another question that time night do we pay for the services beforehand we do not we pay for the services once rendered but we wanted to make sure that we met the unexpected snow that came in last Thursday and Friday so we brought it back to change the effective date that was the reason why it was coming I see it in a small writing at the bottom my question was Wadsworth sto talet and those were
130as we explained pre approved and that's what yes so and I understand the meeting of the 25th I was I was not at but my question is how do we determine who I understand that and you answer my question actually superintendent because you said they've already were selected so it's just common practice who we've been using and the reason I'm asking this question Equity uh chair is because we live in akan we need people that vote in akan pass our Levy for our school and so if there's business in aine tax dollars in our city for businesses in our city then I just think I don't know like the rule or how that works that if you have a business and you're in the city a that do this that you get I don't know
131the legalities of it so don't start throwing stuff at me no I won't but that they can bid F if we're in akan cuz I want people that vote in Aran that pay taxes for the city of akan and who live in akan and have business in akan I think should serve our district uh we did explain at the last one to your point uh as we put this process out earlier there are some criteria that the vendors need to be qualified for we do not ask vendors to come on um without about S 2 Ines of snow is when you start but they need to start plowing at 1:30 in the morning to be done by 4:30 to 5:00 because we go behind them with our trucks to Salt so that's one of the
132criterias that has been in place for a long time because we have 55 locations that we need to clean and get ready if the determin is the school will be open and that's conversation that the staff has with uh our buildings and grounds team our travel Transportation team information we get from snow and ice at the city and then we are talking with the superintendent beginning at 4: to 4:30 because we must make a call by 5:00 in order to decide if school is going to be in session which is what happened last Thursday and Friday or are we going to need to close school which happened to the county the schools in the northern part of the county slightly later than they would have normally done last week so if that helps you yes
133there are criteria to meet our needs yeah 13 yeah I just thank you that that that gives me Insight because if I'm a business person 130 like I said I'm a capitalist so I'm up at 130 to get the money and it's a lot of people in the city that I think would too so that's not a real thing for me but thank you superintend I think I'm clear that you're going to open it up and then it'll be posted and people can bid on it that's all that I'm ask and I'm sure if we're on here we'll be aware so that's morning and fine thank you Miss F thank you any other discussion around business Affairs I just also wanted to acknowledge um under business Affairs uh the resigning uh with Suma Health Academy
134of leadership and Innovation our agreement um and partnership uh with btal CLC we're talking about partners and again uh I think they're one of our earlier Partners they've been around with us um since I think 2018 so thanks to Suma and their support uh of bookal clc's pathway that being said roll call please Dr Thompson Mr Alexander uh abstain from 271 uh yes on arrest Miss ay yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes uh motion with the exception of 27.1 carries 60 27.1 carries 5 with one exstension thank you as we move on um there is no unfinished business um is there any new business Reverend Harrison you've been acknowledged thank you madam chair madam M chair for the purpose of um forward meetings Committee of the whole meetings
135I would um ask that we can clarify now that the committee of the whole be considered a reading for the purpose of passing um policies yes did we vote on that we we voted specific to second reading the second reading on those policies that's correct I'm asking that we just consider the committee as a whole a for the purpose of passing the any policy a reading and I think we can agree to that unanimous consent can we as we're structuring this cow there's no objection okay got it okay thank you um so there is there any other new business seeing none there is a need to recess two executive session pursuant to Ohio revised code 121.2 2g1 to consider the employment of public employees or officials of the school district and pursuant to Revise Code
13612122 G3 to conference with an attorney for the public body concerning disputes involving the public body that that are the subject of or pending or imminent Court action is there a motion to go into executive session so move it's been moved by Mr Alexander is there a second second seconded by vice president Jackson is there any discussion Dr Molar thank you Madame President for clarification for everyone else that gets to go home right now um are there any items left from our committee of the whole to vote on for Wednesday what items are remaining there aren't any we voted on minutes nope it looks like we cleared it all up so don't we have to like make sure we make sure yeah so we'll put that notice out yes okay um we're voting on the
137recess and session did you I have uh motion Mr by Mr Alexander second by Miss Jackson yes any other discussion seeing and hearing none roll call please Dr Thompson Miss ay yes Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes yes M Mr Alexander yes motion carries six so thank you we stand in adjournment recess to Executive session at [Music] 7:46 e [Music] e e e e e e e e e e e e okay we are back in session at 10:26 p.m. and we do have uh items for Action um first we will entertain a motion on um item point1 retirement agreement is there a motion so so move second it's been moved by member Harrison seconded by member Alexander is there any discussion seeing none roll call please Dr Thompson
138Reverend Harrison yes Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mr Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss autrey yes motion carries 60 thank you um the next item is resolution 24- 172 resolution to approve settlement agreement release and waiver is there a motion so Mo it's been moved by vice president Jackson is there a second second second by member sites is there any discussion seeing none roll call please Dr Thompson Miss ay yes Mr Alexander yes Mr Sykes yes Dr Molar yes Miss Jackson yes and Reverend Harrison yes motion carries 60 thank you our next board meeting will be this Wednesday December the 11th at 5:30 right here so we'll see you back then we'll entertain a motion to adjourn so moved moved by Dr monar there a second second second by Reverend Harrison any discussion seeing
139none roll call please Dr Thompson Miss jackon Miss Jackson yes Dr Molar yes Mrs Sykes yes Mr Alexander yes Miss Autry yes and Reverend Harrison yes motion carries 60 thank you we stand adjourn at 10:29 [Music] e