CorpusRecord 651

School Board Action Meeting: January 7, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Lee County School Board
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Lee County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,067 words · about 34 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone we're ready to begin this evening's board meeting Sergeant arms has a Lobby been attended to yes thank you Chief request that all electronic devices be turned off or put in silent mode also please refrain from using flash photography except during the special presentations portion of the meeting I'm pleased to welcome you the January 7th 2025 school board meeting the time is 6 p.m. and this meeting is hereby called to order we'd like to take this opportunity to remind the members of the public of the district's Mission which is ensure that each student achieves his or high his or her highest personal potential and the district Vision which is to be a worldclass school system this evening's agenda includes moment of silence Pledge of Allegiance acknowledgements recognitions public comment consent action items which

002include four items under Board office one item under executive Services one item under academic Services four items under Business Services four items under Human Resources 20 items under operations and four items under good of the order other business board members is there motion to approve tonight's agenda I'll make a motion to approve the agenda I'll second okay moved by Mr Ribble second by Miss juvenile so please please record your vote motion carries 70 as is the custom of the board I will lead us in a moment of silence after which Mrs chaviano will lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance everyone please stand ask everyone to Bow their heads in a moment of silence thank you whenever you're ready Mr Chavana board members please join me in the reciting of the Pledge of Allegiance pledge

003allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all be seated next up on the agenda is acknowledgements the character word for January is commitment commitment is what transforms a promise into reality Abraham Lincoln the design displayed in the screen was created by Mariana Maldonado the 12th grade student at Estero high school so next up on the agenda is recognition so board members and Madam superintendent please join me in the pit for recognition is she here good evening the school district of Lee County is proud to announce that our chief human resource officer Angelo Monte Monaro has been named the winner of the prestigious HR excellent award in education for the North American region at the

0042024 hro today Association conference and awards program this remarkable recognition highlights the exceptional leadership and dedication of our chief human resource officer and the outstanding contributions of the human resources team we take pride great pride in honoring her as a leader of Distinction the HR today Association awards is an annual recognition program that exemplifies the essential work that HR professionals do every day and provides people teams partners and companies an opportunity to share the best practices and successes so colleagues in the industry can benefit from their experience winning the 2024 HR Excellence award in education for the North American region is a proud moment for Chief monz manaro and her HR team and the school district of Lee County Florida this achievement is a milestone in our ongoing journey to improve employee well-being and drive

005HR Innovation the school board and superintendent proudly congratulates Miss montanero and all the other winners and nominees who continue to inspire Excellence we extend our helpful gratitude to the H hro today Association for this recognition and their support and professional development within the HR Community we are excited to see what the future holds congratulations pictur yes know thank you so much than you moving on the next item on the agenda is public comment attorney debr Bruno please address the item of public comment thank you Mr chairman and good evening School Board policy provides the opportunity at this point in the meeting to address the board concerning any matter on this meeting's agenda or any other matter relevant to the operation of the school district please complete a public comment card and put it in the

006basket provided if you need a public comment card they are provided by our staff the rules concerning public comment are posted in the back and will be made from the podium in the front center aisle please be advised that the board will not respond during public comment to remarks made by speakers the purpose of public comment is to provide feedback on District issues such as duties responsibilities decisions and the general operation of the district the school board is Viewpoint neutral during public comment we ask that decorn be kept and respect be shown which is what is expected when a government agency conducts official business therefore abusive language defined as swearing use of profanity or name calling is prohibited in addition clapping hissing booing or display of temper during public comment is prohibited speakers who fail

007to follow proper Decor in the chambers will be ruled out of order by the board chair or the board attorney any speaker continuing with such remarks will be required to relinquish the microphone per board policy 01691 and may be removed from the chambers by the Sergeant at Arms per board policy 016 9.1 the time per speaker is 3 minutes if there are 20 2 minutes if there are 30 and 1 minute if there are 31 speakers or more the maximum time time allotted for public comment is 1 hour 60 speakers you will find a countdown on the big screens in the front of the room once your time has elapsed the microphone will automatically shut off please state your name when you approach the microphone I will call you five speakers at a time and

008please follow staff's Direction when lining up Mr chairman there are four individuals that would like to address the board this evening 3 minutes per speaker thank you madam attorney please ensure you have completed a public comment card to provide public comment the card is a public record identifying those who speak providing contact information to staff for followup the cards are located with staff in the hallway is there anyone in the audience who wishes to make public comment that has not filled out a public comment card yet okay seeing none please proceed with public comment attorney debr Bruno thank you Mr chairman will the following individuals please line up Robert Rio Anthony K Michael Andia Serio Sergio Cruz I don't want see your clock so good evening everybody I was here at last meeting and I

009kind of got derailed because one of the bus drivers spoke and I completely lost what I was going to talk about as a maintenance man I mentioned a few things briefly I did mement and I do like my job but when I mentioned that our pays went down they did we used to get 2204 to start now they brought us down to $21.99 that's a cut in pay and when the union was going into all the arbitration stuff they're talking about it we're supposed to go up and then if you're between a step you end up you got a better raise than you got by cutting the 5 cents off probably a good portion of people only got their five six% Raise not the extra that they were talking about during all the meetings the

010last meeting was done in the secret place so we don't know what happened with that so I feel it's kind of I don't know whose fault the board or the Union's fault whatever but in that lines I noticed State of Florida says you need 60% to be recognized at Union and I think they're down to 20% or 25% and we struck a deal with you guys with only 20 smart percent of the people that are in the unions I think the union has to go it's time for us Lee County Employees to put our big pants on and we can deal with the board ourselves we don't need a union for what we're getting they're bragging about this big raise we got what we get 8% one year but it went up 18% so we

011got 10% less than what the inflation went up then it went up some more now this time I got 6% well I'm still not at the 18% from a couple years ago so we haven't caught up you know when hurricane Ian hit people from other districts are making in maintenance for making 30 some OD dollars an hour they had nice new trucks for driving around with 2002's antique plates on them but we still don't make the same amount of money they make what's the problem are we not good enough the ball's in your court you know we're hiring people that can't even speak English they talk in their phone and they translate it doesn't make sense we gave one guy said do this he made this thing was what is that we gave him the

012measurements that's what we're dealing with we have people that's been in maintenance for 13 14 years that we were working over here he says that guy over here I'm leaving I will not work with them give us a break like thank you for your comments your time is up sir good evening my name is Anthony call I want to say first M belly thank you for what you said at last meeting you are right God is not making any more property we should hold on to what we got because people are buying property at low rates and buildings big apartment buildings that none of us can afford especially us as bus drivers my second thing is thank you all very much because the last couple meetings I've been to Things Are whe are starting to

013turn things are starting to turn around I appreciate that but we still do have a lot more way to go to get Transportation back where it needs to go I understand everybody has their job when you put main people in charge that's never done this type of work they do good but they don't understand if you're not driving a bus none of you can tell me what the quickest way is around to get through town the computer system that these poor routing people have is garbage they're at they're telling me to take a route takes an hour and 125 minutes to do I'm telling you as a truck driver as a tow truck driver in this town during traffic this time of season that's not happening when we go in and try to explain that

014this isn't safe they can't do nothing cuz it's system won't let it when they add a stop to us you would think that it would give us more time no it drops us time when they take a stop off it drops us time when you go in and explain this there's nothing the router can do there's nothing our dispatchers can do nothing our supervisor can do but tell us to spend extra time and go in and put extra time in a computer there's also a little bitty paragraph in the thing that says every day I should look to see what I get paid I clock in three times a day on three different pieces of equipment I clock in when I clock in for my RTM which is our route management time which is always

015wrong because it doesn't calculate our drive time and traffic then you have a clock into the million-- dooll tablets that are garbage because they don't show us around we actually have to figure it out from point to point to point then you have GPS on our buses that's all fine and dandy but when those systems don't integrate to our payroll so that they can look and check our payroll and I have to fight for my payroll that's not right that's not right to any of us drivers all we ask is that we get paid for what we do it was a nice system you clock in you clock out at the end of the day you clock out after your runs over you clocked in four or five times you could still tell if somebody

016was lying to you because their buses are GPS and the tablets why why why are we doing this and causing so much heartache if you look into that you'll see that's the main complaint of every bus driver and our dispatchers and everybody thank you for your comments sir your time is up Mike andos Fort Meers former teacher I want to give a real brief history of education when we first start you know through most of human history education took place in the family and was dedicated to whatever the needs of the family were numeracy were and literacy were rare and this worked out pretty well for most people because most people's experiences with the world were usually within a few miles of the place that they were born but as we started to progress as

017we started to as the world became more complicated and more inte graded people's experiences with the world expanded and people needed to have greater access to education we invested in public schools common schools as they were called and even still the curriculum was fairly narrow literac basic literacy and primac and numeracy was the was the call for the day and that sufficed but the world became more complicated the world expanded and people's experiences with the world expanded with it and with it the need for greater education as we moved on through the 19th century and into the 20th century we got to the point where our fourth grade education a sixth grade education and eighth grade education these weren't good enough basic literacy and numeracy was not good enough people needed to have a background

018in advanced literacy and more advanced literacy and numeracy history science as we become more integrated and we are interacting with different cultures and people's all over the world and globalized trade we need to invest in foreign languages Multicultural experiences Humanities the Arts The Sciences in the 20th century education W in the mid 20th century education was looked at as a national interest and the curriculum continued to expand the C curriculum continued to get more broad now we find ourselves in a position where we are not just using computers we are interacting with computers our communication networks are such that we can communicate with people all over the world at the speed of light our communication and travel networks expand into outer space and yet here in Florida and in Lee County we find ourselves Under

019Pressure to what narrow the curriculum to restrict the things that teachers can bring into the classroom the things that they can say under penalty and we are doing exactly the opposite of what the history suggests we need to do if we want to have a world class education system we need to find ways of expanding the curriculum into fields that our students need to thrive not just in Lee County but all over the world thank you very much good good evening I'm here tonight as both a familiar face to a few and maybe a new face to to some I wanted to congratulate our new board members and superintendent and just introduce myself my name is Sergio Cruz I'm a dad and just a parent advocate I Champion for individuals with disabilities and their peers

020usually when I come to these things I try to bring not only a critique but a positive note or or a praise so I'm going to try to do just that tonight so there's two two key key things that I wanted to bring up the first is I've noticed as I came that I do get some some results when I'm you know make a comment or or criticism critique if you would but it's not usually the best place for the for the type of Engagement that some of these conversations would need and so typically those would be in things that would be customarily like a advisory committee so I thought that would be what you know what our District's ESC advisory committee would kind of be a platform for unfortunately it's not kind of ran

021in that direction it's not as Equitable and equal to some of the other advisory boards that have like a board liaison or a public comment section or or really any kind of consistent discourse you know they meet quarterly it's more of like a teach and take kind of a scenario versus you know actual engagement with the genuine stakeholders it's you know usually some vendor or whatnot and I'll digress on that but I just would really like that now that we have a you know a couple new faces that you know maybe somebody could maybe find it upon themselves that want a champion and kind of move that committee to be you know more engaging and Equitable to some of the other committees that are in the district because I do think and I'm not trying

022to scare anybody off as of yet but I do think that there are some major issues within the district specifically ESC that I could easily point out and I do think that even some of the quote unquote data that is out there that speaks for the positives of the district is a little misleading when you actually thoroughly investigate that but I digress the second thing I would say would be about a positive note when I approached the district a couple months ago about an Initiative for autism drowning and an En lopment because it's an epidemic in Florida and I had gotten some voice and some support from some of the members and also had one of the leaders in the District reach out to me so I just wanted to kind of share an update

023and hope to kind of elicit some more support from any maybe of the new members that might want to jump on this but we are doing we have been able to secure with the fort Meers fire department and we're working with other departments throughout the district and County to secure free CPR and first a training for for families of children with autism as well as we've partnered up with a swim instructor who is specialized with this population to try to do that I would really love if anybody sees this to kind of pull on their heartstrings to reach out to me collaborate and we can try to make this happen thank you thank you for your comments sir chairman that concludes public comment thank you attorne debr Bruno thank you everyone we truly truly appreciate

024your public comment your feedback next up on the agenda we'll be moving to approval of consent action items the documentation for Action items listed under consent is made available to board members seven business days prior to the board meeting we're expected to review all the material and we have an opportunity to speak with the superintendent with any questions we may have regarding the recommendations some of these items have also been briefed or workshopped with the board in advance of appearing on the action agenda board members are any agenda items that you wish to pull for further discussion Miss juven Elli I have none thank you Mr Ribble I have none thank you Miss Jordan I have none thank you Mr persons I have none M lenford Fleming I have none M chaviano I have none

025and I have none at this point is there a motion to approve tonight's agenda consent action items motion okay move by Mr Shavano is there a second I'll second okay please record your vote consent action items agenda is approved 70 consent action items excuse me so at this point Dr Carlin introd please introduce any administrators or attendant with a new assignment thank you chair Fisher it's my pleasure to introduce our new assistant principal at Bonita Springs High School yamara Leonard Alo congratulations thank you Mr chair and we know that you're going to do a great job at the school I know Mr Estus is thrilled to have you on board and we are delighted to welcome you to our Lee County leadership team so congratulations thank you so congratulations and best of luck okay next

026up on the agenda is good of the order other business so we will start with Miss juvell well I'll start out by saying Happy New Year and I hope that staff has had time to regroup and get ready for 2026 because there's a lot we're we're expecting to do a lot of good things this year and hopefully transportation's one of them and it's a it's a work in progress as you said and the same with with maintenance so we're hearing you and I know the superintendent's going to be really working hard to hone in on different departments and look at everything it's going to take a little time so please be patient Rome wasn't built in a year so I just want to wish everybody Happy New Year I do want to talk a really

027quick for good of the order the advisory committees we talked about that today but we really didn't delve into it I still don't know that I understand exactly what how we're going to get volunteers from Dak because there's only two people to each school that's comes like that attends that so I don't really know how that's going to work and I want to wanted to bring that to the attention to the board tonight that I think we need to have conversations with the superintendent on because Sergio brought up you know something regarding edak and I think that we really need to make sure that we're addressing and giving opportunity for the public to have opportunity to interject rather than just 3 minutes at the DI that we really don't get to interject back with them

028and that's our opportunity I know we can do it in the community but when people have concerns these advisory groups really help to understand and have ideas and they share and they collaborate and I think we're going to miss that collaboration piece with our community and the public and I just wanted to bring that up and I think we can work through this I think we can we can we can work it out but I still think it's a work in progress I don't know that just Dak is going to take care of the needs that we have and I know they want to have like little subcommittees from Dak but I just don't know if you don't have the volunteers at the bigger level I don't know how you're going to get the volunteers

029from Dak that's where I'm concerned is the is the actual volunteers so I don't know how we engage that better but anyways I just want to bring that up and show that I am concerned over that and mention that and that's it thank you thank you Mr ju vanelli Mr Ribble yeah I just want to say every wish everybody a Happy New Year we got off to a great start this year I'm very pleased to see how things are working out with our new superintendent as many of you folks know I was one of the candidates that campaigned for superintendent Carlin and everything that she said she was going to do she has put in place her especially her quote which I heard every time sometimes three four times a week One Vision one team

030Envision safe secure schools increase student achievement expand technical education opportunities increase teacher retention and recruitment Envision physical responsibility and that includes the must does and the nice does okay Empower parents as partners in education so I'm really glad to see that we got things off to a good role particularly with our 101s and the all the department heads they seem to be lock step with us to get this mission accomplished and I did want to give some credit to Marshall B the president of Lee County School foundation for hosting us on the 19th of December us new folks we had a great evening for about an hour and a half to get meet all the key people that run the business Community here in Lee County and really do a lot for our school district

031so that's all I have Mr chair thank you Mr Ribble Miss Jordan I as well well would like to wish everybody a Happy New Year and I'm just looking forward to the New Year's congratulations to Bonita also I am looking forward to coming out and visiting schools which I hope to start within the next week and even Transportation so I'll be out there so thank you so much and have a great evening thank you Miss Jordan Mr persons Happy New Year I would just want to make mentioned give a shout out to maalla Williams who sang the national anthem at the pression luncheon that girl was fantastic one of the best student Renditions of that I think I've ever heard and I believe she goes to North for Myers so congratulations to mall a great

032job that's all thank you Mr person Miss lford Fleming thank you yes I just wanted to mention going into this next year I'm incredibly excited about it we definitely keep students safety and staff safety and the Forefront of our mind but I would be remissed if I didn't mention this evening how my heartstrings have been pulled on with the two students in Lee County who were affected because those students were former or former athletes in Lee County and while yes they attended a private school they many public school friends colleagues and I just want to send my condolences to those families and thankfully it sounds like those two young women are going to pull out of that Ellen steel thank you for the members of the community that come and speak when you come up

033to the microphone they're not your words aren't falling on deaf ears and I would encourage anyone to come and use this time I appreciate the fact that you leave your families in the evening to come share your thoughts with us so thank you they're always welcome Mr Cruz I was very interested the last time you came and spoke about the autism drowning and just the the educational piece that we need to delve into as a district so those conversations will continue even if there are behind the scenes I'm incredibly excited about the second semester after seeing all of the workshops today and all the things that are going to be happening because I think what as as you said better than I have Mr Ribble that our superintendent is putting student achievement and school safety

034and student Safety First in four and I and that's how we're going to win that's how we're going to get across the finish line so I hope that the staff and teachers are well rested and spent lots of time with family and I look forward to the spring as it approaches it'll be here before we know it and we'll all be off to graduation so thank you thank you Miss L Miss jav yeah one happy New Year and two apologies for having to cut out but I'm I'm waiting for a toe so I'm trying to get my car towed out of here so that's it so my apologies but two things I wanted to touch on outside of what everyone else did I was able to attend the Nutcracker during so that was my kind

035of first attendance for the Nutcracker by the north for Myers Academy of the Arts which was incredible I took my family there and even my youngest who is 9 years old and even my middle schooler who thinks everything is uncool at this point thought it was great and my youngest was like I want to go to this school so they did an incredible job and just kudos to to that school and to that program and then I also was able to attend the inaugural adult education Honor Society induction ceremony at the Dumar Community School 16 students were recognized for their outstanding achievement dedication and leadership and their Pursuit Of Education those 16 students were selected from over 2,000 adult students across the district so that was really neat to watch and see those adults made

036the choice to pursue additional learning to to to advance their careers and move things forward and that's just tremendous and a big Kudos to them so just very happy to participate in that and m ing what Jada said for those of you that come and take the time to to speak I am always taking notes and taking those back when we have our one-on ones and we have those discussions and I will be getting out and visiting schools and transportation is actually on my list as well so thank you for for taking the time to come out and thank you for the Emos we do read them and we do process them so thank you so much and just again hope you guys rested up and are just eager to start this New Year and

037that's it thank you thank you Miss chaviano I have a few things many of us attended the teacher of the year at harns Marsh Middle and I'm going to butcher this name so my apologies Miss reor okay okay so that was amazing I know she will be recognized I know one of the upcoming meetings I also attended at Mariner High School the kiss the pig event so that was that was great it was put on by the students and the Future Farmers of America to sport the veterinary program there and whatever administrators ended up raising the most money kissed the pig so it ended up being Dr Michael and his team of APs kiss the pig so I did not kiss the pig but I did get to see the pig so that was great

038and it was awesome to see especially you know the Future Farmers and Agriculture and see some of their things brought in these schools so that was really neat I want to give a shout out to Mr psons on this we have a community block grant through the fed but through the county I know he was instrumental in helping to get some resiliency for us as he attended and was on those committees so I appreciate that sir next up as I'm on the drug- free Coalition there is a run for prevention 5K I mention this every year so and that is on January 25th 2025 out of bcop ranch I would encourage everyone to to please sign up you can go to drugfree.org to get more information so and the last thing I have is we

039have talked about getting out in the community more as a board there will be the first town hall will be on January 23rd and that will be in District One the district I'm at and that'll be with Dr Carlin at Cape Coral High School it will be sometime in the evening and we'll be releasing information on that shortly so that's all I have at the moment and thank you we're now going to move on to ATT turn to pre Bruno just wishing everybody a Happy New Year thank you Mr chairman yes sir thank you very much I have just a few comments this evening as was mentioned previously we do appreciate when speakers come out we also receive feedback in a wide variety of ways when we're out in the community via email phone calls

040and all of that I do want to let you know that our team is working extraordinarily hard I push them each and every day certainly through 101s and our cabinet meetings and all of that really to take a look to be as I said this afternoon to be bold to be courageous to go to hard charge our issues we have so many strengths in this school district we do but we have definitely some issues we need to go to work on and we are committed to doing that and I want to tell you that our team is very serious about the work Mr Ribble you were very kind in your comments I will take every opportunity to remind you all that our number one priorities school safety student achievement making sure we're working very hard

041on Recruitment and Retention being fiscally responsible treating those tax dollars that you and trust to us as the precious dollars that they are and then making sure that we are empowering our parents as very important Partners in education so I will probably talk about that at most every meeting because I want you to know that we are just that committed to the work we also as chair fiser mentioned earlier today we attended the foundation for Lee County Schools they had a board meeting right before the break they are doing a great job working on strategic planning they are working harder than ever to align their work with our priorities and again just want to give a shout out to Mike wiic and as the as the chair of the of the board and Marshall Bower

042as their president CEO and all of those board members that work so hard on behalf of our schools and our staff and our students they're doing a great job and just again my appreciation they did honor Mr Ribble Mr chavano myself at a reception just prior to the break so just a big shout out to the foundation for all of their support board members next week we're going to be in Tallahassee as we talked about earlier today you took a look at the 2025 legislative priorities and just for our public to know that we will be up in Tallahassee for a couple days next week working very hard with our legislators to make good things happen for our children we're going to be advocating for policy changes Law changes and yes funding so please know

043that at our next meeting we'll give you an update on how that went just really looking forward to joining you up in Tallahassee for the very first time as superintendent and I know we'll do great things up there and then finally just a very happy new year as been stated previously I hope that staff and students and families and community members had an opportunity to enjoy their families get a little rest jump off the marry around turn those phones off and just enjoy that family time 2025 is going to be a very busy year it's going to be a fantastic here and I look forward to Leading and having the privilege to lead the school district as your superintendent so thank you thank you madam Superintendent at next scheduled meetings on Tuesday February 4th there'll

044be a Schoolboard workshop at 1M followed by Schoolboard Action meeting at 6:00 at this point having no other business to come before this body and seeing no objection this meeting is hereby adjourned the time is 6:39 p.m. happy New Year and have a great evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.