CorpusRecord 6523

AB School Committee Budget Workshop - February 8th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / ActonTV
Date
2025-02-08
Location
Middlesex County, MA
Material
Transcript
Extent
32,906 words · about 183 min
Collected
2026-05-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right it is 8:30 now so noting the hour in the presence of a quorum I'll call the act in boxboro Regional school committee to order good morning everybody and welcome to our budget Saturday presentations um we have a fairly packed agenda we've got a nicely laid out um list of things we're going to do in certain amount of time um there will be opportunities for both public comment and questions and comments from the other boards and committees who are here with us to any of those um act on our box for boards you don't have quorums you don't need to call to order do you no excellent all right um I will just uh highlight that we have one of the school committee members who needs to leave early so we're going to take

002some items out of order in the agenda towards the end of the day um so we're going to swap items nine and 10 um so that we can have our uh preliminary budget vote before one of our members needs to leave for a personal event so um by noon are going to have a preliminary budget vote that's that's the Target and then uh by 12:35 we're going to be out of here so that everyone can enjoy the rest of their day and go to the store and shop for their emergency milk and bread for the whopping six inches that we're going to get while we're all watching the Super Bowl tomorrow all right with that Peter I'll hand it over to you good morning everyone um so first just thank you for being here I

003know it takes a lot to take a whole you know two-thirds of a day on a Saturday uh to join the school district to to listen to our budget uh in more detail for the coming year and I just want to recognize all of the different members in our community who are here um I want to thank our leadership team for being here I want to thank any staff that have joined us uh for the presentation as well um and hopefully you find it to be a productive time I think that you know when we we talk about our vision for the school I think we've really wanted to create a school district that is a healthy place for our children um and that inspires them to be better Learners and that means that it's

004really a holistic approach to what we want in education and you know as we think about how we budget and the priorities that we set in a budget we want to really keep that Forefront in our minds that our overarching goal is that we want healthy and um engaging schools um and that doesn't mean for some students it means for all of the students that we serve and recognizing that students have different needs um and that as a student needs expand or contract we need to be responsive to that I'm sorry Peter I just need to highlight that this meeting is being recorded in broadcast on act and TV so that people in the room understand that you are being recorded thank you Beth um you know we're going to do a few different things

005today and I apologize um you know if your eyes are as bad as mine probably some of the small texts is a little bit hard to see on this um but we want to talk a little bit about a budget overview and I'll talk about that for about 15 20 minutes um chance to answer maybe any early questions you have but also um Financial overview of the district and going deep into some of the finances um as we think about budgeting there were really three priorities the school committee set um and around thinking about our programs for you know tiered systems of support as well as multilingual and special education and so we want to talk in more depth about those programs and make sure we have um a reasonable level of shared understanding of

006what those are um and some budget implications for what we're doing within those and then we will get into a staffing overview and go deep into Staffing and then um you know we'll have an opportunity from some questions and answers but also I know we're going to take our preliminary budget vote at that point but then the last topic is really looking Beyond FY 26 um and talking about what's next for the schools over the next few years um and thinking about some Trends patterns that I'll talk to early but what are the implications of those for our future so we presented our overview of our preliminary budget there's really two versions of the School District budget um before the school committee votes on it there's a preliminary budget that we present so we did

007that on January 30th and now we're back to actually go deep into that preliminary budget we will um take any feedback that we receive along the way we will come back to you on um March 13th and present you with a recommended budget um over the course of a couple meetings and then the school committee ultimately votes to adopt a budget on March 20th um some key dates you're really doing two things today this is both a preliminary budget workshop and we do seek your vote to set a preliminary budget um there's no actual legal requirements about what a preliminary budget means but in our community that historically meant that the budget that you set um you typically don't go up from that after you you set that preliminary budget so what we're looking for

008you to do today at the end of this meeting is set the upper threshold of what the budget's going to be for the two communities knowing that we're going to continue to have adjustments for State revenues um different expenses that come in over the course of the next month that have to be reflected before your final budget vote I'm going to go through some of this quickly and I might talk to a little others but I just wanted to come back to this idea of strategy um and what we're trying to accomplish in our schools and I talked about the vision of creating healthy and engaging schools for our students um so that we can maximize student potential while they're with us and so at the core of that has been belonging relationships climate and

009culture uh because that is what drives student engagement in schools um and if that's absent students can't engage academically um so that was the focus of our strategy and then we had um a series of different initiatives this really goes back now about six years um in the making and we've actually done quite a few things that we set out to do and so I'm just going to talk about that briefly from a social emotional learning standpoint um we have implemented um this year a social emot K12 curriculum the first ever K12 curriculum in our district that I know of um for social emotional learning and bullying prevention um which was a real gap for us we have implemented a process of Elementary screening to understand when students have gaps and we can more rapidly

010address uh student needs we have implemented a grade 7 through 12 advisory program we've expanded Services um and access to mental health care for our students through cartwheel and we have um implemented specialized programming at the elementary level to address students needs um with kind of more acute um social emotional SL mental health behavioral health needs in terms of Equitable opportunities and outcomes that mtss has been probably the singular focus of our school district making sure that we are addressing all of our students needs um both academically and emotionally um we have implemented um k6 literacy programming um consistent with kind of the science of reading um and understanding a structured literacy approach uh that's been years in the making for us we um have implemented new ka8 mathematics program based on highquality instructional evidencebased

011materials we have um actually increased participation in our uh Advanced coursework at our high school and we have recently completed a multi- learner program review to better understand what we're going to need to do over the next few years to address our students needs we've really focused um Mo several years ago on Universal Design for Learning and ensuring that all of our Educators in the district had access and participated in professional learning for Universal Design um to create more inclusive classrooms we have expanded classroom libraries to make sure that they reflect the diversity of our community we uh worked with a coalition of community members students staff administrators um to really look at um how we could eliminate hate and hate speech in our community we um created a series of protocols on responding to

012hate and bias um that are now being used in multiple places around the state um and quite honestly we're proud because they've been set as an Exemplar for what schools could have in place across the state um we have worked with groups of teachers across the district to examine culturally responsive practices and making sure that our instructional practices reflect the student population that we have we created the ab Resource Center we've talked extensively about the positive impacts of that um and we have started working closely with uh suffk University to increase our use of restorative practices across the district in terms of engaged learning uh many of you know we're currently working on a vision of a graduate um which I think actually times nicely uh with the elimination of mcast as a high High

013School graduation requirement that we have an opportunity to look at what is valuable for us as a community and what we want our students to accomplish over their time here we have adopted high quality instructional materials and that is um educational um lingo so you can check off the first box on your bingo card that you should have received at your table um but that is some lingo and education it really means that the instructional materials um we have in our classrooms have a strong evidence base to increase student engagement and produce better outcomes for kids um we have looked at high school course leveling um and we have re-examined some of our prerequisits that students needed in order to get into our advanced coursework in the high school terms of the impact that we're

014having um we shared some of this previously some of the data so I'm not going to give you the data points you can go back and read some you know previous school committee presentations if you want more um but we have have a statistically significant reported increase in students having a trusted adult at school a statistically significant increase in students feeling safe and supported at school and their reports of that um increases in not experiencing difficulty handling stressful situations and events it's the way it was worded in our data so I left it the same way um it's yes it's a double negative I want to you know uh recognize that but our students are doing better uh handling stressful events and we've had a statistically significant decrease in uh student reports of depression self

015harm and suicide consideration and and in terms of academic impact um 8th grade math has actually improved from prepandemic levels um we talk a lot about this idea of pandemic recovery our eighth grade math program has actually broken through prepandemic levels so congratulations there um we are overall across the district performance and science Technology and Engineering um mcast data has actually improved from pre-pandemic levels not recovery but actual Improvement um we have more students at the high school who are now taking advanced courses than ever before and our high school um AP participation has increased actually nearly 50% since 2020 um and quite honestly that actually was still high from pre-pandemic levels and we've seen no decline in performance um as we've actually increased access to this course work so just want to give a

016kudos to a lot of the work that's happening across the district and we think about the impact of what we've done it doesn't mean that we are finished and we still have work to do um we want to complete our long-term work on uh defining a vision of a graduate for our community and making sure that we can clearly articulate what we want our students to experience while they're in our schools um we have more work to do around expanding inclusive instructional practices um in our classrooms to make sure that we're actually really supporting the diverse Learners that we have every day we need to think about literacy outcomes across grade levels that has been a lagging um element for us in our data um as we've thought about post-pandemic work um I think in

017large part what we're seeing is that it really focuses on comprehension skills in students it's not um kind of phonics and pheic awareness those Baseline elements it's really the comprehension side but this is also the first year of implementation of our new core literacy program which is focused on comprehension and some of the other standards that that we have lagged a little bit so we're excited to see what that data looks like over a couple of years we have um performance gaps that have either persisted or actually increasing among some of our subgroups um that need to be addressed we um can do a better job identifying and remediating um some of oural skill gaps for students um as he experience them and we have to really think about the level of access some of

018our marginalized populations have to Mental Health Care uh because that is something that we actually saw in our student data coming up that that needs some additional work school committee gave us a set of budget guidelines um kind of school this probably isn't new to a lot of the school committee some of the data that I just shared and so I think the budget guidelines were responsive um from school committee to understanding what the needs were that we had in our schools and so probably the most uh important overarching goal school committee had for us was prioritizing a robust tiered system of supports um for social emotional mental health and Behavioral Health needs academic needs multilingual Services um and special education services and supports because that's where we're seeing our gaps in student performance and

019that goes to this idea of discrepant um student subgroup data that that we see they also implemented a series of uh revenue and cost control measures um the overall budget increase was capped at no greater than 3% in boxboro they requested an assessment no greater than 6% um in no use of excess and deficiency um so you will see that reflected in this budget we have long-term capital needs that need to be addressed um that are getting increasingly expensive and so we need to make sure that continue to fund our Capital program um or else we actually run the risk of falling behind and increasing the long-term liability to our community uh we need to plan for obligations including our cost of contracts steps Lanes cost of living adjustments um retirement contributions health insurance premiums

020um and run out claims from the act in health insurance trust those are all the really exciting elements of the budget for everyone I'm sure um programmatically the school committee asked us to look hard at class size um and ensure that we were programming all of our class sizes across the district within the school committee guidelines so we've done that um we have Incorporated some of our prioritized recommendations from our elementary budget task force and we've tried as much as possible to look at staff attrition um when making this change um we understand the cultural impact when we have to change Staffing levels um and you know cultural impact I I say that um with a lot of seriousness because I started off our presentation by saying that you know relationships climate and culture were

021the center of our strategy because if those aren't strong students don't learn um and that is research and evidence backed and so when we think about the impact on culture we have to take that seriously um and then the last one was reducing kindergarten tuition for families and I'm going to be honest in this climate we don't have a mechanism to do that and that is not included anywhere in this budget presentation um simply because the budget Gap was too large to to be able to incorporate anything um these are now some slides I'll go quickly through but we have had a decline in distri District enrollment since regionalization of about 600 students that's projected to continue um by about another 335 students over the next eight years 300 students sounds like a lot um

022and when you understand it's over eight years that actually means it's a relatively gradual decline broken um up by student populations though you can actually see there's a real shift in the students that we're serving this actually mirrors National Trends uh in composition of students in public schools um where we've seen rapid increases um in many of our um selected populations terms of projected enrollment I wanted to break that out by level um for people to see and again I'm going to suggest looking at this is this is an eight-year or excuse me this is about a fiveyear look ahead um I would also point out you know you need to consider the total population when understanding how this is is going so 76 students at an elementary level that's out of 2500 students that's

023a very different change than looking at a 91 student um decline in a high school population or a 53 student decline out of you know 700 students at a junior high so um just understanding scale uh matters when looking at some of those numbers and then just you know I think one of the things we heard last year and I don't think we did a great job addressing quite honestly was what's happened to our staffing levels as um our student population has declined we have more staff than we've ever had before in our schools um outside of the last few years um and so what we did is we actually looked at staff who were teaching in classroom facing positions versus support staff um that were you know are employed in terms of meeting needs

024of specialized student populations and when you look over time there actually has been a pretty much proportionate decline in our class facing positions from our overall enrollment um and so you know the hard part with this is Desi only publishes numbers going back about two years and then they missed the last two years of data we worked really hard to do a Reconciliation of not only staff that were uh left the district but also any positions that we've added to make sure that the data reflected on this slide are accurate and true to the best of our knowledge looking at selected populations um you know we saw a sh increase in Rise of selected populations of students in our schools and that is where we've increased our staff over time um so just want to

025recognize um also on this slide with special Educators um there's an anomaly in the state reported data and we try to use that whenever possible because when the Desi actually pulls data from our system it's not something that we send to them they pull it um and when they pull our educator data from the system if we have special Educators who are teaching in a general education classroom they're coding the most as general education teachers not special Educators and so it looks like it there's a decline but what that actually means is we're actually providing more services in the inclusive settings um during that period of time so there is an odd anomaly in that data where it looks like we're declining in special education teachers that has not happened um so just to to

026be clear so some just key takeaways um one our student enrollment has declined and it's expected to decline more over the next eight years um number of classroom teachers has declined in proportion to enrollment number of support teachers has increased in proportion to increases in our high needs populations in our schools and funding for special education programs and we've talked a lot over the last couple years about all the programs that we've developed in our district um most importantly this has given students the opportunity to stay in their home District um whenever possible and we've also shown that it actually has um avoided cost for the community um because it would cost us more to try and serve students out of District than when we develop IND District programs because we have an appropriate cohort

027of students that we can serve in our schools just want to talk about how we developed our budget now uh because I think this is important um the base that we used for a 3% budget increase was 112 7502 505 our town meeting budget last year was 114 308 105 um I believe and is that yep okay thank you um so obviously they're not the same thing so and I want to talk about how that happened and then after town meeting if you recall the school committee actually voted a higher budget by using almost $1.7 million in excess and deficiency which was um largely to pay run out claims from health insurance trust so we ended up with a budget north of 116 million we actually backed ourselves out out all the way back down

028to 112 to start building this budget and the reason we did that were um a couple reasons one when we increased the use of end late in the year we um had made a pledge to the community that we would not use that to increase the base budget for the schools um so we eliminated that $1 1.7 million of end uh before we built our budget for this year we also took off um excluded debt from the Junior and senior high schools which is about 1.6 million in change um because when we have excluded debt even though the district is paying that money and it's including in our budget once that debt is paid off um which is this year um the revenue to the towns also stopped so we didn't think it was fair

029to try and build a school budget based on excluded debt um so we we backed ourselves out of that as well um we looked at what it would cost to maintain the same Services um and I'm not talking about level Services uh because level Services respond to changing student populations but what if we just tried to maintain the same Services next year that had this year that would be about 1188 million um as a budget um and the 3% budget that was our guideline gave us 13580 um so we had about a $1.9 million gap um and that was how we've been working through um the current budget cycle so the total budget for the communities is that $116 million budget um that's a 3% budget it actually is a 1.69% total assessment increase that's

030largely due to excluded debt um I just want to you know make sure we're clear about that um in Acton it's about almost an $80 million um assessment increase and a 0.9% 0.97% assessment increase and in boxboro it's a $16 million almost $17 million budget um and that's a 5.25% assessment increase the assessment variances between acon and boxboro just as a reminder are based on enrollment shifts across um because that's the model that we have in our regional agreement so so couple of things um when we have limited resources um there's really two things that we can do to approach this one is to prioritize the critical Services um and maximize efficiency within our existing structures um I said that it's at the first school committee budget presentation efficiency and Effectiveness are not synonymous with

031each other um our goal in any budget is to have the right balance between those but when you have fewer and fewer resources you have to become more and more efficient and that uh starts to tip the scale um where you don't have a good balance between efficiency and Effectiveness and you have to start to prioritize what you're doing and I think this budget shows that that we've reached imbalance in those two areas um you know the other alternative is to really um reimagine and restructure how we're using our resources um our goal to date has been to think about um how we address structural um work within the existing School structures but then another approach and we'll talk about this more later today of actually looking at what those structures are and having to

032determine whether or not we can afford or whether or not they're even most relevant to us in the future so we'll talk about both of these as we go through the day so things we've done one is carefully managing class size um and across all levels the proposed budget is within the school committee guidelines for class sizes um some of them get to the upper end of school committee class sizes others are not um um budget recommendations from the elementary task force we've done a few of those you'll hear about those as we go through the day um closely examining scheduling practices is something we're going to have to do because we are not adding the multilingual supports that we need to add um in this budget and so we're going to have to look

033at scheduling practices in order to meet kind of some of our student needs not only in the tiered system of support but also for multilingual services and then really thinking about tier two and three group intervention sizes and the potential of increasing those group sizes um and I've talked about some of the challenges of of what we're up against with with doing that Governor released her budget proposal on January 22nd and includes some additional Revenue um particularly around Regional Transportation in chapter 78 those will come back into play um in the recommended budget and we'll talk about that um health insurance we were carrying 12% which we thought was a conservative estimate um it's actually now 14.84% um increase and that's Statewide average of Maya's rate increase for the year um and Statewide unemployment liability

034we don't yet know what's going on with this but if you've been following news out of the State House the uh state has to give back about 2.1 billion um in federal money to the government um to because it was miscategorized um as pandemic relief money and so our current understanding is that make that cost might get uh pushed down to employers so that's something we have to track as well um overall numbers for those those two things you can see here um we don't know on some of this uh we also know that we may have some additional special education needs that come up between now and March that we'll have to reconcile um and that's just some of the internal work that we'll be doing um health insurance um in terms of structural

035changes um dissolve the act and health insurance trust uh entered Mya a one of the bright spots that unfortunately is covered up by the health insurance ratings increase is that we implemented a health insurance opt out in the district and that is saving us about six actually it's over $600,000 um on the FY 26 budget so we've been able to reduce our base budget by about $600,000 through that health insurance opt out um we restricted the use of end and then unfortunately after the use the passing of the budget last year had to increase it again um to pay runout claims um but this budget uses no excess and deficiency um and reduces Elementary classroom assistance by about 25% um and that is one of the recommendations of the budget task force um and it

036begins to have to reconsider some of our elementary schedules um either across schools or even internally within schools to make sure that we're meeting the needs of our students um that we're serving I'm going to pass it over to Sher now um talk about Finance I think we our goal was to do some question and answer after the finance section correct yep and hopefully Sher will'll get through Finance in about 30 minutes minutes as opposed to the 45 minutes you had originally it's less yeah perfect I can talk fast if I need to um so this first slide just kind of gives you a history of the last six years of where we've been with the assessments as Peter said for FY 26 we are looking at 116 mil 13580 as our preliminary which is

037a 1.53 based on bringing it back to 112 and that's a 097 for actin and a 5.25 which stays within the guidelines that they've asked us to do this is just talks a little bit about our reserves so just looking preliminarily we just had the quarter two report I do apologize for not being there last week um looking at our revenues we are going to have some extra Revenue in our um investment income so we're estimating approximately 526,000 on the revenue side so if you look the Department of Labor had certified us at 2.1 million for our end balance as of July 1st right now again just looking at the revenue side if we have the additional 526 at the end of the year plus we had carry over purchase orders that we can release

038141,000 that we know of right now then we're estimating uh 2.77 six um balance for our end and again that's only the revenue side we really won't know what we're going to release in expenses till probably June but as per the school committee policy um DK it's recommended that we keep our end fund level between four and four and a half% so just to kind of give you a little bit of information that's between 4.6 and 5.2 million is really the target goal for D and we're going to try to work that number back up that's why we're trying not to use the end to offset this budget this just gives you a little bit of history on the end and what we have used and where the blue shows where we've been certified each

039year and the red shows what we have offset the budget while our certified number has gone down the use of the money has gone up but again we're not using any for FY 26 so we're going to try to build that budget right back up this gives you a little bit of history of our circuit breaker so the green line represents the fy2 anticipated reimbursement coming in from the state the red line represents the funding we needed to offset the fy2 budget and the purple line represents where our projected fund balance will be as of June 30th we allocated 3 million for FY 26 to offset the out of District tuition costs the financial rule with circuit breaker funding is that you can only carry over into the next fiscal year what you've taken as

040a reimbursement for that year and the goal for all districts is to try to leave the entire balance on the bottom line and offset the next year with those funds but I've yet to find a district in the last couple of years that's been able to do that um the OSD which is the operational services division they're the ones that set the tuition rates for the private tuitions so in FY 24 they had an historic 14% increase and for this year it was 4.69 and the increase for FY 26 is projected to be 3.67 this is just kind of a different view at our preliminary budget the top section shows you the difference of increases between the salary and the non-salary accounts and in the middle the 1.4 seven is the salary increases and um

041contractual obligations that we have we have a reduction in the fringe benefits as Peter stated we were able to save a little over 600,000 from implementing the opt out program the reduction of 921,000 is the retirement of the 1.6 million debt between the junior high school and high school and the 778 th000 is increases for tuition and transportation in the bottom section the 400,000 is what we offset between Community Ed in food services for the utilities and the 3 million is what we had stated that we were going to use for circuit breaker which is 652 th000 less than this year this just is the total budget broken down by admin code it just kind of shows you where where the biggest increases are which is personnel which is all of our salaries um special

042education which is the tuition and the transportation and then um facilities which is all of our utilities which are drastically going up and then the needs of the buildings that are getting older and the increases that we needed for them Peter kind of touched a little bit on the governor's initial budget so the top part comes from the website directly and it's what the governor had proposed in the end of January for where our Chapter 70 is going to be as a rule historically it's usually been $30 per student but the governor has put in for $75 per student so on the bottom you can see the First Column of red is where we estimated our revenues to be for the preliminary budget the second column is the governor 's budget and then those differences

043match what Peter had showed on the previous slide this is a little bit of our enrollment Trends kind of showing the difference between Acton and boxboro and what the percentages have been between the two the last two rows are NASDAQ numbers so those are what NASDAQ is um estimating our enrollments are going to be for fy2 in FY 27 and can you just make the note of why that is this is for assessment that's different from what they're going to see on the website oh true yes this is for our assessment purposes it is different than what you see on the website because I to it might not match our total enrollment because these are the actual students that live in Acton in boxboro we do have um some employee have students that here and

044we have some school choice that are going to be aging out soon some significant financial changes that we've had the first one is the retirement of the 1.6 million of debt between the junior high school and high school um as Peter said the health insurance we did budget for 12% but we have found out it is 12.84 or I mean um 14.84% or 14.9% um we did reduce we had had a larger number of the runout claims we reduced that by 450,000 for the FY 26 budget and we saved 63,000 by implementing the opt out we also were able to save approximately 450,000 through attrition um being able to bring those salaries um either the positions were eliminated or bringing those salaries down to a master six from where the uh retiree was and then

045the vacancy Factor um there's been a line item in the budget called vacancy factor for some years this line it's listed as a negative expenditure and it was capturing the leaves absences and the retirements we're trying to bring it more to actual so through attrition we've already done a lot of that process so we're trying to reduce the vacancy Factor so that adds in 75,000 for FY 26 in the last two slides I just wanted to show some other funding sources besides what's voted through the town we have federal and state grants so in FY 26 we're going to get about 1.8 million in federal and state grants and I kind of listed some of the grants so we have the federal Title One 2 3 and four we have the special education 9442 allocation

046in Early Child childhood Grant um supporting mental health McKinny vento homeless um oh I wrote supporting mental health twice sorry and then ml newcomer and homeless we have our Community Education Program which is a self-funded program taking in over 2 million per year and the expend funding is used for the community ed program and the Extend A Day program use of facilities the driver's education and some field rentals we have full day kindergarten in our preschool program those are partially funded programs taking in approximately 500,000 and 300,000 respectively the funding is used for salaries for teachers and assistance um supplies equipment and employer health insurance then we have our food service program which is another self funder program taking in over 3 million per year and expense funding is used for the salaries all the

047food at the L es um supplies equipment employer health insurance and equipment maintenance and then finally we have our Athletics program which is partially funded taking in approximately 400,000 each year and it's used for salaries for coaches salaries for the bus drivers that are driving um the officials Transportation supplies and equipment thanks Sher thanks Peter all right all right so what we're going to do is um pause for some questions now on the sort of laying the groundwork types of presentations that we've got you can see what's going to come up next is some detailed presentations on program considerations those top priorities on our budget guidelines um what I'd like to do first is go through the school committee see if you guys have any input any questions and then we'll go back a table

048to the the towns and Boards um John Connor if you want to squeeze your way up to the front there's should be a spot there so that you can speak at that time all right anyone on the committee have any questions comments Andrew thank you uh thanks for the incredible presentation from both of you Peter you mentioned earlier there savings based on keeping students in District some of our I wonder if you could just speak for a brief moment about the value of having uh services offered inside District rather than and trying to keep our students here rather than going out to outside districts for help you know I think um overwhelmingly I I think there's a benefit to students first um and being able to remain in schools uh that they've grown up in

049even if their educational programming needs change um there are times when we have a large enough cohort of students within our district where we can think about developing specialized programs um that can meet the needs there are also times where a student's need might be acute enough that they require an out of District placement or we actually don't have a large enough cohort to be able to do it effectively um and so they wouldn't be Ed educated in a peer group um and that would be a reason to place a student out of District as well um but there this is something we delved into last year so we didn't do it again this year but there's also a cost savings often um that goes along with being able to educate students in District as

050opposed to outof district and so um we've actually shown you know when we we did some comparable um outof District programming comparisons to IND District we're typically saving you know between 10 and you know sometimes even $60,000 per student based on the type of programming that they might need um if we develop cohorts in the in the district I I would like to just um go back to the um the kindergarten and preschool page slide so I just want to make sure that it's clear what partially funded programs taken in approximately 500 ,000 half a million dollars that's for full day kindergarten yeah so those are parents in our community paying to send their uh school children to public school and I just want to highlight that since at least since I've been on the

051school committee at 201 17 we have been requesting State assistance because we're one of only about a dozen school districts across a commonwealth that doesn't have Universal all day kindergarten um so we have been asking for a state assistance grant or some kind of assistance uh that would help us transition to Universal all day kindergarten because for at least 20 years it's been recognized how important early childhood education is and while we do offer some financial assistance for families who are needy we also know that there that it's still a financial barrier for many families in our district so I just want to highlight when I started on the committee our um State delegation was still Jamie alridge uh Tammy Goa and Jennifer Benson um and um Jamie's still here we have new state reps

052Dan SAA and Simon Cataldo so this is an issue that as my last budget Saturday ever I just want to highlight is something that um you know I hope at some point the state will assist us with this um as as you know across the Commonwealth there is discussion about transitioning to Universal preschool um and and we still are lacking uh Universal kindergarten Here in act in boxboro um so that's my comment I just want to ask a question Peter concerning the uh keeping kids in District and how it may or may not relate to challenges that our educators are having if that is mainly children with more substantial needs and um how the schools are you know it's great that there are cost savings and it's great that they're uh you know I'm totally

053for keeping them here where possible but how we see and this may not be a question for you and maybe it's something we'll talk about later but how we see that impacting our Educators and our classrooms uh by by keeping those students in District thank you yeah I mean I think the short answer is um what you're seeing is also a large driver of the growing increases in Staffing in those areas um because there are some really specific needs that we have to address that are a lot higher than what we have had in our Public Schools before um I know Mary's going to talk about that when we get into the special education piece so if it's okay to just put a pin in that for now and then come back to it that

054would be great other school Committee Member comments questions observations um I have two um if we could go to the end slide first um I do want to point out that um we said last year we're not going to use any end and then last year we used the most end in the past probably forever um but the use of that end was for the intended purpose of end one-time expenses that were on plan this was run out claims from act and health insurance trust um and it speaks to the importance of having a healthy eend balance it's why we're not using any more of it um but I just want to highlight that it is a very large amount that we used it was for the purposes that we really set aside end for

055which are those onetime emergency needs um and I point this out for two reasons one so that everybody understands why we used it but secondly why um it's important that we rebuild that fund and that you know as we've heard I will I will say as we've heard from Finance committees over the years we can't use this money for reoccurring expenses we need to keep this in there and for the community members as we get into tight budget Seasons again and again and again we have to hold a substantial amount of money and what would be considered free cash so that we can weather these emergencies so as we come to you and say we have no more money we have no more money and you look at an end balance of 2 million $3

056million the reason is that we could have a $2 million expense that comes that we need to have that that um availability to move on um and then the second thing I wanted to just highlight um can we go forward to the governor's initial budget um so the preliminary budget uh this this is an important not that one the one that one um this is something that I want the committee to keep in mind as we're about to vote our preliminary budget historically a preliminary budget is a not to exceed number um and what we're hearing already is that we're seeing close to $500,000 in additional funds coming from um some areas in the Commonwealth there are also expenses that are backing up along that um so as we talk about what our preliminary budget

057is and for our town leaders in in the room as well we're already forecasting additional money coming in from the state for the the past few years we've seen additional funding come in from the state after we voted all our budget and we want to have a conversation about how do we maybe more effectively planned for that now and have some contingencies so something that I want the committee and the community to think about as we're going to be deliberating what our preliminary budget number will be as we voted at the end of this meeting all right I'm going to move back a table uh any of the boards and committees have questions or comments Greg um first question um Greg jarbo Acton finance committee a first question is for Sherry you mentioned that $1.8

058million uh came in in federal and state grants do you have a rough breakdown on what was Federal what was State I do if you can just give me a second Federal is about 278,000 and this 9442 is not federal right oh then I lied hold please it is just for the record she didn't lie she misspoke oh I'm sorry I misspoke 1.7 not Congress all right 1.7 million is federal so sorry that that's okay I missp all the time um and then the second one is probably for Peter um you mentioned long-term capital needs do you have a a rough estimate as to how soon you will have a number that finance committee people could use for planning purposes I'm going to actually let Sherry speak to Capital sure so you want to know

059say it again how soon will we know what your long-term capital needs are likely to be so that if we are budgeting Beyond one year and we're often asked to try to look down the road as far as we can H how soon would we have a ballpark number so in December we had our Capital um presentation and we're working on the website right now to do out a 10-year plan we have it for FY 26 right now but we've been working with capital subcommittee to try to push that out and we're hoping to have that this spring and actually um both Finance committees have Sitting members on our Capital sub they actually have the numbers already I believe so yeah J Jason Jason has the number we shared that plan in I believe the

060their meeting we we did we put it kind of up on the meeting we know where he lives we can find the numbers thanks for the presentation Dave wellinghoff AC and finance committee you know the district district enrollment um projections I was curious if you could just explain the methodology used I think in the past it's been like housing turnover kindergarten enrollment Etc if if you could maybe explain that and then two is um the past projections um how accurate have they been so if you you know go back two years are we kind of close to where those projections were so a couple things um we use nesdec which is um a local organization that works with most municipalities around uh enrollment I will admit I don't know the the ins and outs in

061the Contours of of how they calculate it um but I'm happy to to ask them for a little bit of detail around things you know I would Hazard a guess that certainly they they access things like birth records as well as uh housing permits building permits things like that um in terms of accuracy in actually the past few years they have um they've been fairly accurate in terms of overall aggregate number um that being said there there has been a shift each year where so for example their projection um two Octobers ago was that uh the enrollment would sort of a flatline over the next two years or three years and then start to slowly creep up moderately and then this past October we got a adjusted uh projections where as as Peter pointed out

062we're still projected to moderately continue to decrease for the next eight years so um so I would say in terms of like the most immediate enrollment projections they've been fairly accurate and that being said they also you know reserve the right to make adjustments so each year when when new data comes in like they did this past year they adjusted from saying yep after the next couple years it's going to go up they're saying nope based on new data uh we're still going to decline um a bit over the next eight years but you know for for kindergarten just as a as a one data point the kindergarten projection was I think within two or three students um this year so and that's actually the the hardest Target to hit for us because that's section

063planning so um it's been helpful for for us in terms of the accuracy that they've had do you know using kindergarten as an example is is that do you know the accuracy of that over time I'd have to look but over the past two or three years it's been it's been Fair fairly accurate within a within a couple I I do remember I think 3 years ago we definitely had um a higher enrollment where we had to add a section um that wasn't anticipated but for the past two or three years it's been fairly accurate and is that data is it like act and box BR specific or is it just aggregated for the for the district it's actually they they do um enrollment for Acton enrollment for boxboro and then combined and actually um

064I think in the budget binder the um the NASDAQ report is actually uh addendum so uh if you want to go look at that specifically or I'm happy to just email it to you directly okay thank you hi I'm Karen hog Seth I'm on the ACT and finance committee I have a couple questions really for my education the circuit breaker graph you had up is there anything that you folks have control over that sounds like it is what it is and like is it something that's has any inputs that you can control just so so circuit breaker you know it's a it's a reserve fund and where it's different from all of the other Reserve funds It's actually an inside the operating budget Reserve fund so like excess and deficiency is applied after the budget

065circuit breaker is applied within the budget as an offset to essentially out of district tuitions and transportation costs um you know we have control over how much we use in a given year um and how much we receive is you know there's some control that we have in terms of making sure we submit accurate claims for circuit breaker costs but then in the end it's really a state reimbursement program so you know for example um the legislature set um circuit breaker reimbursement to districts as approximately 75% um of you know uh tuition costs and of Transportation costs um subject to appropriation the legislature appropriated money last year and then when districts across the state submitted higher circuit breaker claims than anticipated they didn't change the appropriation they lowered the reimbursement rate and so one of

066the challenges we saw is even though we received approximately 75% of our submitted claims on tuitions Transportation claims only returned at about 44% and so that left a real Gap in expenses where you're you're seeing like the purple line is not heading in the right direction So when you say you can control how much you use does that mean that if you choose to use less you just absorb whatever else you need in the rest of the budget that's correct okay thanks um the insurance opt out what's that so we provide an opportunity we we did not do this when we were self-insured because we felt there was uh it essentially allows people to not take our health insurance because we know that for a family plan it cost abouta $26,000 a year um to

067fund a family plan so instead it's an opportunity if someone has been on our health insurance for two years or more um if they choose not to take our health insurance and instead go on someone else's plan in their family or household um we would give them a reimbursement of I believe it's about $5,000 a year yeah okay for a family plan or it's less for an individual do you all right that's good um I'm I'm kind of shocked that that wasn't there before that anybody wouldn't be allowed to not take their employers Insurance you know that we didn't off off offer that we we didn't um historically when we were in the act in health insurance trust because we were we were the majority the vast majority of the health insurance trust was the

068district and when you make your pool of um insured individuals smaller you actually can increase the size of the risk within that pool and so you know it had been talked about over years going back but not pursued just because we were really worried about like a smaller pool that had higher risk leads to more volatile rates and so where we're now fully insured um through the state oh not the state but through Maya which is the largest insurer for the state um we feel like this is an opportunity to take advantage of that can I can I just ask a follow-up question so it was always allowed for people not to choose to ensure their families through the district it's just that now an opt out so that we would pay them for a

069family plan $5,000 to opt out as opposed to paying $26,000 correct so it's always been something where if you are a benefits eligible employee you could take our health insurance or not and for those who have been taking our health insurance and who have other options we wanted to provide a potential incentive to say if you have another option that perhaps wasn't as attractive before but with you know this financial incentive it may suit your needs um we then save about 21 22,000 for every family plan that opts out so if there if there were people that opted out under the act in health insurance trust this is a weird question would any of them have opted in when you changed to Maya that that's um that would offset the savings of opting out of

070paying people to opt out now there's I mean there's as long as you are a benefits eligible employee you could always come into our health insurance you know but you don't know that because I I said that would offset savings correct I think the the I guess the the bigger question is for them it's less about sort of the opt out and more whatever plan they're on now does it suit their I know is it sheap or fear family yeah does it suit their their their sort of medical uh medical needs as well as their financial planning for whatever reason um we've been able to have more go out than come in which is the reason why we have the S and I I have one last question has kindergarten enrollment started already registration registration

071has started but it's still in its uh still in the beginning stages I believe it you can register until sometime time in um late March because the we have like the the kindergarten open houses over the next several weeks so you don't have do you have an idea yet of what the total is going to be for this for next fall no the projection is about 25 students higher than last year I think it's in the low to 200s okay thank you boxboro table any questions from boxboro members uh no we're here to learn and listen and thank you very much at least for me anyway I have a question can we go back to the slide with the governor's uh budget one so I want to make sure I know Adam you kind of

072insinuated towards that um the governor's budget now says oh I'm sorry if I didn't mention my name I'm PRI box BR select board um it's 30 to70 you said the difference now it's up to 75% up to 75 so um that's more than double are we sure it's going to pass through the legislature and are you basing your preliminary budget with that 75 in mind or are you basing it on 30 and if so can we the difference if it does pass through are you going to use that as a savings for the subsequent year or how are you planning on doing that thank you yeah so um in terms of the likelihood that it will pass through um the last couple of years the legislature historically the legislature doesn't decrease chapter 78 from the

073governor's proposal um and in the last few years the legislature has actually increased um chapter 78 from the governor's proposal so the governor has proposed $30 a year over the last few years the legislature over the last two is increased it to 104 per pupil um I think it's more likely chapter 78 will be increased over the governor's proposal rather than decreased um the what's that yeah we don't know the answer to that um it's always something that you have to kind of watch um there is a bill that um Senator Lewis filed who's probably one of the more influential Senators um with regard to education because he chairs that committee um to actually increase Aid to $150 per pupil um which would obviously be a significant change to us so um we're tracking that

074we've sent that along to our delegation um in the hopes that they sign on to that and support it um and we'll see and and I can speak a little bit to sort of what the process would look like so um what I would say is first of all our the budget Saturday we're having today is much earlier than traditional budget Saturdays and we struggle every year with trying to form a budget before we know what we're going to get from the state and so in the past we formed a budget on the basis of $30 additional Revenue per student about $150,000 increase in Revenue we know already that there's probably an increase coming and there's the potential of more in the past what happens is that money flows straight to and we can't actually

075take advantage of it um and then because it goes into end it's harder to plan for it in future years as well so one of the areas that the committee will discuss today as we vote our preliminary budget is whether or not we want to take the one uh 16 million um number that you see no that's not right the the 116 that we've got in our preliminary and potentially increase it knowing that there is revenue coming some already and then maybe even some more and then how might we apply that Revenue that comes additionally from the state so today we don't have that guarantee it would go on to your assessment tomorrow once we know from the from the state what we get we very much have the ability to come back and revote

076our budget but not change the Topline number just change the assessment so we recognize additional revenue and then go be able to go back and say and that additional Revenue will go against the assessments of the town so that's the conversation that I want to facilitate with our committee later this afternoon okay so when you say um the Top Line wouldn't change the assess would change you me you telling me the assessments will go down that's a possibility okay all right thank you I mean if we see new Revenue then we get to choose where we apply it right John hi uh John Conor boxboro fincom uh question for Sher Sher can you just bring up the charts with the funding sources I think there's two slides yeah it was near the end which one

077are you looking for the funding source ones it has funding sources AC oh other funding sources other funding sources last there you go okay is that the only slide no there's another one with um Food Services and Athletics okay so across these categories have we you you're listening as a funding source have we tied the expenses to these Source excuse me the expenses to these sources to in that we have I mean Athletics for the last couple of years I don't know if you know that we have increased the athletic fees last year so this year is the first year because we have been upside down in the Athletics revolving for the last couple of years and the general fund has had to supplement um we're hoping not to be upside down this year um

078Food Services usually maintains by rules they maintain at least a 3month balance is what they're allowed to maintain in their revolving account 3 months worth of expenses is what they can keep as a bottom line balance okay so are we cash positive on these items we're cash positive currently we're cash positive on all of them okay all right thanks act and select board any questions from that table my co cord is a little short um Alyssa niichel I'm a member of the Acton select board I'm also a part-time um employee at an elementary school at least for a few more months um but I am not speaking as a Public Employee I just have a a couple of comments maybe a question I'm I'm on board with being hopeful for hoping for additional revenue and

079and I appreciate the school committee you know factoring that into the discussions over the next few weeks um I also am a little pessimistic about whether or not we would be at risk for losing any federal funding um so I just want to you know keep that in mind I know that the free lunch program might not be popular with the current Administration in DC um so I don't know do you have any preliminary does the district have any preliminary um cautions from any of your connections that any of those federal grants would be at risk um you know I think Alyssa that's a it's a good question um I also think you know I could say that we've received no guidance at this point about what to anticip um you know I know it's

080certainly something we're following um but it's it's so early I mean we're really only you know three weeks into an Administration so it's it it's awfully hard to tell what what will actually play out over the long term um so you know I hear the question I wish I had a better answer for you but I think we're all just kind of in waiy mode okay so I guess I would just suggest you know keeping that in mind but you probably already were um the other thing that I wanted to comment on one of the um school committee members um loaned me Nate levenson's book which I got to read over the winter break and something really stood out at me uh and I just want to read a couple of quotes I know that

081probably all of you have read it uh the teacher matters more than how many desks are in the room research is unambiguously clear small class sizes don't improve outcomes and if they crowd out Staffing for intervention instructional coaching or more generous starting salaries they can reduce achievement um class size is the single largest lever of spending in a typical District of 5,000 which is our district changing the average class size by one student adds or saves about 1 million a year so I was really surprised when we were facing a $2 million budget Gap that we weren't talking about increasing class sizes by two might get some side eyes at school on Monday for having said that but um I I heard a little bit about we'd have to add five more students in order

082to see the savings and I don't really understand that so if somebody could maybe explain that better um I would appreciate it um because it seems like we need to be really bold structurally in order we're not just talking about you know this upcoming fiscal year as as Greg mentioned we need and we need to plan for for the additional for the for the future for um upcoming fiscal years as well I can talk to that Alysa um so yeah I think what Nate was referring to um I'll I'll try and address a lot of these one um the notion of looking hard at class size is actually something we did so at Junior High and high school where students are all within an existing building um we looked really hard at class size and

083so we actually had a reduction of eight general education positions classroom teaching positions um and increase the class sizes by three students probably um on average um in many of the Departments to make sure they were really within those school committee guidelines um and at the junior high at really the upper end of those school committee guidelines at the elementary school um I think what you're referring to with you'd need to add five um what Nate was referring to is what he found through his study was we actually um control remarkably our class sizes across the district um so that almost all of our class sizes are right at school committee guidelines um and if they're not it's because maybe we had a late move in or something like that um so when you have

084an elementary school of three sections um at a grade level and our our elementary schools generally have either two sections at a grade level so two first grade classes or three first grade classes if you have 22 students in a class in a first grade classroom and you have three classes you have 66 students if you want to increase like if you want to try and reduce an elementary section in first grade the only option you have unless you're willing to start moving students across the district is you're going to have you know 11 students more per class and so you actually have a lot a really inflexible system once students have been placed into schools um outside of moving kids and we you know when you start we actually had explored this in our

085B budget last year um and obviously you know if you have a devastating situation I think moving kids is your last resort but in general you don't want to move students partway through their educational career we don't think that's to their benefit um so that kind of is the inflexibility so what we did instead when we looked at our elementary enrollment is you know Andrew referred that we're going to go up probably about 25 kindergarten students we actually looked at our kindergarten class sizes where we were at the lower end of school committee guidelines and we're actually growing those to the upper end of school committee guidelines um by not adding a kindergarten section so that is the way we can control our elementary enrollment within the current structures of the district um is by

086thinking about kind of how students enter the district and then allowing class sizes to grow gradually over the six-year time span that they have um so that was kind of we we definitely did use that as the tool um and that probably saved us between the eight High School positions and not and the avoided cost of adding a kindergarten position I would say that's probably like 1.2 million is somewhere in that range and I'll just add it it was an area that the school committee focused on because it was in our budget guidelines to to it wasn't to increase the the um classroom sizes but to plan more closely to that and I think we dove into that a little bit when we were looking at some of the enrollment reports and the and the

087high school and Junior High in particular so it's it's something we've considered and I think there are levels of it too right so you could say let's get closer to what we have in the guidelines today and then there's the next step which is do we actually go back to our policy which did dictates those class sizes and that's a maybe a a larger and more considered process that we would have to go through can I just speak to I and I know where almost out of time on this section but um we're going to speak to that a little bit later because I think one of the other things in and the elementary principles and central office have actually looked at this together but where we're at you know I I think everyone 's

088ideal is to have a three-section elementary school because you have a lot more flexibility in how you can place students across a grade level as if we increase our Elementary class sizes which is one thing that we could do as a district that means we're going to have fewer classroom sections across the district ultimately and as we do that we actually start to make it a lot harder to try and run the current elementary school model that we have because we're really going to restrict student placement and so you know even this year as we thought about like where how many kindergartens we're going to have in each school we had some schools actually starting to get to a place where they were so small that even though you know choice might drive in a

089different direction we had to add a section at that school because it wasn't really going to be educationally viable for a school if we didn't have kind of a third section of kindergarten in the school long term so that we're really on that teetering point and that's something we're going to talk to probably in the last section of what we do today all right uh any questions from members of the public who are in the room in The Way Way Back hi John there's a mic over there thank you John Peterson sit Jackson Drive um I wanted to Second Adam's comment with respect to the importance of rebuilding end um and I want to remind the school committee that from time to time the reserves have been looked at as Consolidated reserves so it's not

090simply a statement about end it's a statement about circuit breaker it's a statement about revolving funds like Community Ed and I think at this level of budget Saturday that's the level in which reserves should be discussed similarly um I'm sure people were struck by the fact that the assessment in for Acton is going up you know a ripping Point 8% while the assessment for boxboro is going up north of 5% that as Peter noted is an artifact of our enrollment based Regional formula I strongly urge the committee to revisit that formula and build it on eqv as is common uh throughout the Commonwealth and then although I know Sher will look at me and say I'm never doing that um I want to note that the budget lacks the significant the Precision and accuracy to

091talk about single dollar amounts so every slide that takes this down to the dollar and even the circuit breaker slide for careful viewers that went down to the penny is not not adding valuable information to anybody so get rid of all those extraneous numbers thank you thanks John hi Amanda toi I'm a parent um just a a clarification is this a question or comment right now it's kind of either oh great I was hoping you would say that okay um so Peter when you said um you made a reference to scheduling in the elementary schools and just for clarification are you talking about the distribution of reading and mass Specialists by need versus by building um I I think it actually encompasses a number of things I think um schedules are are really really intricate

092processes um and it's kind of like the string where you can't find the the end of the knot um but there's some conflicts in our schedules that make it really hard for students who might have you know be identified as either students with a disability or multilingual Learners or students who might be have dual identification um with needs to receive all of the services that they need to have um and so and then you start to throw in that some of those students might also still need a tier 2 service um or tier three intervention um and it becomes more and more complicated to think about how students are going to receive everything and as our our support systems get tighter we are kind of at a place where we have to examine maybe some

093of the like maybe the priorities we had in scheduling a number of years ago can't work anymore because we have to think about how students are going to get their services met um that they need and that's that's the level of I think detail that we're talking about when we say we have to re-examine some of our elementary schedules um because we just we're not getting to all of the students right now in a way that we think we need to um I I don't know how to say it I just wasn't sure I I recall that as a part of the recomend Commendation from the the budget task force and I just wasn't sure is that still on the table or not so I was trying to read read the you know read through

094the lines if when you said scheduling if you if you were referring to that component but it sounds like not um no that is something that we're actually actively talking about I think what we're trying to figure out right now is it something that you know to cut right to the chase is it something that we need to try and hone schedules within schools right now or do we need to better coordinate our schedules across the schools right now now what we're trying to understand is how do we maximize the the return we get on our effort because I think and we'll hear later if we end up going in favor of a much broader restructuring plan at the elementary level we don't want to spend a lot of time and money right now trying

095to restructure all of our schedules across schools and then say okay now that that means nothing because now we've done something drastically different anyway and so we need to kind of play out the next few years before we make a decision about what we're trying to do now so right now I'm thinking our effort is within the schools trying to maximize our scheduling opportunities but that thinking could shift okay okay thank you all right thank you everybody we are at our first break uh which was supposed to be 15 minutes we're going to make it 5 so stretch run use the restrooms uh we're going to come back at 10 to 10 um and start on program considerations e e e Okay one minute warning you want all right if we can find our way

096back to the seats please if you can find your way back to your seats we're going to get started oh okay perfect Al tile my coordinator I'm going allow it okay we are going to get started we're going to talk about um program considerations uh you can see that on the screen I don't want to uh just give a little process update here so we've got um three presentations one on mtss one on multilingual and one on special education after each of those um brief presentations I'll open up to questions or comments from just the school committee and then once we get through all three I'll open up to comments from the board's committees and then the public so we'll just do school committee after the three quick presentations and then everybody else after that

097all right Gabby yeah good morning everyone uh for those of you who I haven't met I'm Gabby Abrams I'm the assistant superintendent for teaching and learning I started July 1 joyfully and enthusiastically and I'm just really grateful to be here to kick off this portion of the program which really centers our kiddos so we've talked a lot about the conditions needed for Student Success and this portion of the program will really highlight the programs and the work and the um Educational Systems that we have in place to to do what we love which is to support children as we talked about earlier uh the school committee gave us provided some FY 26 budget guidelines and the first one that they highlighted was the emphasis on prioritizing funding to ensure students have access to robust tiered

098systems of support in all of these areas that are bulleted here my work with you today is to provide um additional insight into the philosophical Foundation that serves as a beacon for our teaching and learning work while the term mtss or multi-tiered system of supports is something that's used primarily at the K to 6 that term is used there are really emphasis and efforts underway really K through 12 that high that are highlighted um in the slides that follow and the information that I'm going to be providing with you uh for you today the reason why mtss or multi-tiered systems of support was chosen as an effort in the act in boxboro public schools long before I arrived is because it's an everyone effort every individual in the act and boxboro public school district is

099responsible for lifting up engaging and raising children to be highly successful both as academ MC Learners and as social emotional um in their social emotional learning development um this slide highlights several of the key roles in the leadership positions that are responsible for supporting Educators and support staff in the schools and in the classrooms both in the areas of academic and social emotional learning one of my first um collaborations with our kada 6 teaching and learning team at the beginning of the year was for us to cohere around around a bit of an elevator pitch around how we talk about mtss as a foundational framework and that surfaced as a statement the multi-tiered system of supports begins with a strong foundation in tier one you'll hear me talk about the tiers a little bit as

100we progress through this tier one provides all students with highquality evidence-based instruction in an inclusive and positive School environment Universal supports address the needs of most students a data informed process identifies students who need additional specific small group support in a tier 2 setting which could be the classroom or outside of the classroom or more intensive targeted instruction in tier three the systemic mtss approach ensures every student thrives academically behaviorally and socially represented visually our field of Education highlights that an expected distribution of success in student outcomes includes 80 to 90% of students meeting with success with core Tier 1 curriculum and differentiated instructional practices 10 to 15% of students requiring core plus more time a time for students to receive more support to access tier one instruction and one to five% of students can

101be expected to require even more additional intensive inter interventions if they continue to struggle despite tier one and tier 2 efforts we think about this work both in the area of academics as you see on the leftand side and in the area of social emotional domains and note that this framework is intended to serve all students regardless of their academic or social and emotional profile and while we recognize there'll always be a population of Learners who require even more support than tier tier three due to their exceptional needs as you will hear from my colleagues in leadership within multilingual and special education programming a large percentage of all students learn within inclusive settings and ensuring their success in these settings is a point of Pride and commitment as I was thinking about how to um

102use an analogy for uh this educational framework in our real world I was thinking about um all of the work that's been done by the CDC and other organizations around Fitness and healthy choices to raise us all to be more healthy in our lifestyles and I was thinking about the fact that we are so disproportionately um unhealthy as a nation certainly more than um we're not fitting within Health within that 80 to 90% tier you've seen so many changes that have happened in this industry that you know we're we're told on our phones to stand up when we've been sitting too long when we take Health inventories at our doctor's office were re-educated about things that we should be doing those core practices that we should be doing around the caloric intake that we have

103and the exercise that we should be getting to prevent us from having to receive you know one-on-one training with a medical professional or one-on-one Fitness training or even having to go to Other Extreme Measures in tier two and tier three so I was really wanted to conceptualize this for you to understand that this is how we think about educating kiddos is that we really want that core experience to be incredibly incredibly rich and robust and successful for kiddos which really I have to just say shows how Artful our educators are and how Artful they have to be because most students are served by these Educators in these classrooms I thought it would be helpful for you to see um the Personnel associated with each tier within a multi-tiered system of support recognizing that the goal

104is to maximize the number of students succeeding in tier one significant and energy and enthusiasm and talent is dedicated here this is where most SP students spend most of their day within their classrooms with their peers learning and growing as thinkers creators and humans when fewer than expected percentage of students are succeeded within tier one the work must include strengthening what is happening in tier one with the support of instructional coaches coordinators department leaders assistant principls and principles something that we often say in education is that you can't fix a tier one problem with a tier 2 solution we need to look at our tier one practices always which makes this work incredibly complex and as I mentioned very very Artful as students needs continue to change and our communities involved which has as you've

105seen in this beautiful Community the evolution of the demographics in this community that has enriched our community the work within mtss is always a work in progress included here are various areas of focus within mtss that all represent significant investments in time and resources you've already highlighted some conversations about scheduling and how that really is the backbone of what happens in schools it is something that needs to be clearly and um articulated what the values are it's a really it's a it's a significant um skeleton of what happens during the school day developing a data-driven decision-making culture um identifying access to high quality instructional materials ensuring integrated academic behavioral and social emotional support so that seal development is not something that is an isolated event during the day but a part of the whole experience

106that our students engage in throughout um developing professional learning and capacity building opportunities for our faculty and staff and ensuring incredibly meaningful partnership and family and Community engagement Within each of the schools in act in boxboro there should be points of Pride around progress within each of these various areas and also a recognition that this work continues to require continuous Improvement I wanted to celebrate um coming in here as someone new on July 1 it's really a wonderful opportunity for me to come in with a fresh set of eyes and really celebrate and amplify that there are so many efforts underway and that this like other efforts um around a a Continuum of we're not yet there and we never will be there'll always be work to do but this really highlights the um information

107about some of the progress or efforts underway in each of our grade spans K to six at our Junior High and our high school and while the last slide highlighted the who of this work this really talks about the what is taking place similarly I've highlighted some of the work that are under the work that is underway to support tier 2 and tier three Three Needs of our students in both both social and academic educational domains in order to give you a little bit of a sense as to what this looks like from the balcony um I wanted to look at three and share with you three data points so we know that there's one um major summative assessment that happens every year in the spring the Massachusetts comprehensive assessment system and we have an

108ability I have an ability to look at how is our doing in English and math and science if we look at it in in the aggregate across all grades it's a it's an unusual look we don't actually often look at it this way but I thought this would be really helpful to see and to give you a visual so if you take all of our students across grades three through eight and grade 10 because those are the grades that participate in mcass English language arts and you look at the percentage of students who are currently meeting or exceeding expectations you'll see that outer um that outer bar is 68% our Target should be reaching as close to 80 to 90% as possible but as a point of comparison we also then looked at our subgroup

109performance in four subgroups and we can look at this with lots of different subgroups but we chose to look at low income High needs special education and multilingual Learners and you'll see there's a significant discrepancy between all students 68% of students who are are meeting or exceeding expectations again just in this one data point one point in time 2024 English language arts you can see a significant discrepancy in that area there is a little bit of a duplication of data here um the the term High needs may or may not be familiar to you but the term High needs means that if you are a student who's identified as being lowincome or as a multilingual learner or as a student with disabilities you are considered to be high need you could also be two or

110three of those you could you could qualify in two or three of those areas but if you are considered to have one of those identities then you are considered to be a student in high needs based on historical performance the last um Circle which is in the middle or the last segment is how the state performed in the aggregate so this same data point and you'll see we are significantly performing higher than the state and our work continues to be to look at that um discrepancy and also continue to work towards strengthening um our work so that those Stu all students but certainly those students in those um marginalized um populations see more success this same data can be seen for mathematics where 72% of our students across all of those grade spans who participated

111in assessment reached a level of um success on this particular assessment knowing that it's one data point it's just to really wanted to just be UST of like how are we thinking about this those same subgroups and you'll see that the state aggregate was at 42% and then lastly science um science we do not assess as frequently in Massachusetts we assess in fifth eth and ninth grade and you'll see that um 77% um of students were able to meet or exceed expectations you can see this data in lots of other ways as well again we just wanted to give you a very high level balcony view of um and it's and it's it's a little bit of mirror right where is our work need to be done globally and then we can look at it

112by grade level and by sub subgroup and by school um to give us even more information you want to take some questions Point great so any questions from the committee on what we've seen so far on mtss and some of those mcast outcomes laki this is this is more a request on the how I want to see the data uh maybe you don't have it but I was wondering you showed the triangle right where 90 80 to 90% I was wondering um if we have enough data to say okay we have made the investments in mtss and two years time frame these kids have moved on and at two years ago this was the Triangle and this is now it shrunk it it became more flattered right so I was wondering if there is a

113possibility that we see can we can see that data to justify the Investments we make in mtss as positive yeah I think it's a great request Le me thank you so much for the ask I was doing some midyear data look um I haven't I haven't looked at the math data yet but I was doing just as an example I was looking at midyear data k to6 for literacy and um I was building my triangle uh to see where we were at the midyear point and there were so many points I was I was smiling as I was doing it because the um the success rate based on our measures our internal measures um that we've set some initial criteria for showed that 80% of students across K to6 in literacy based on our internal

114efforts were strong in the core and we had about 10% and 10% in tier two and tier three so that was a really in incredible piece of information for us we knew it it tells us that we had some work to do to move some students from that that tier three support um into tier two or tier one even so strengthening the core for some of those students in tier two to help but it was a really good exercise to to build the triangle we um engaged in that activity with our elementary principles earlier this year I think that's really a healthy exercise for us to continue to do throughout the year um we are also doing a little bit more work internally this year again just understanding where we are in our um development

115of an mtss system one of the areas is that we um that we needed to do was identify what is the consistent criteria or what are the guard rails that we're going to use to make determinations of where students um need a tier 2 support or a tier three support and we're nearly finalizing that work it's been an incredible amount of heartfelt work on the part of the leadership team k to6 um but those both of those pieces have really assisted in that process that your requesting I think we're very close to being able to do that okay I have one more question uh actually two more I can can we make it one we're behind so pick the most important question we're we're behind schedule oh okay uh I thought we were talking about

116somebody behind asking question okay um the state one that you showed this the circular the circular graph sorry and E and sorry Ela and math grades yeah I was wondering wondering if you can overlay the others the percentages on how big a portion of the all students those are because if the numbers are small that is pretty skewed so one student not kind of moving up basically is going to skew the whole thing so I was wondering if you have that yeah absolutely I can get that to you the end is different right obviously the N is significantly higher for all students than it would be for our smallest population of multilingual Learners the state does require that you have a minimum n of 20 students for reportable data and because this is three through

11710 sometimes even just looking at grade three wouldn't give me any information for small subgroups of kiddos um so that's why we we chose to give you this very high level data from three through 10 um but I can absolutely get that data to you as well thank you you're welcome thank you other questions from the committee we're going to go down this way so we'll go vicam Tori and then along the line go ahead viam thank you Adam uh wonderful presentation I was just curious we're looking at sort of like glass half full um we're seeing those who are meeting and exceeding do we have the data on those who are not meeting and not exceeding uh and I'm curious to know what those numbers look like thank you yes yeah I can absolutely

118get those too thanks for this um I attended a mask learning luncheon and it was interesting to me that although it was not in the title The Message driven home was how critical a strong mtss system is to serving all of our students and making sure that they get what they need um so it's good to me being a two-year now almost school committee member that this seems normal to me my question is um as we talk about what do we do next so a lot of the key people involved in mtss are those are positions we're looking at really hard can you talk a little bit to the tension between be do the the face-to-face delivery time versus the planning that is necessary in order to do this well yes I think in a

119in a challenging fiscal situation you're faced with a lot of bad choices and a lot of options that you don't want to want to navigate so I think what we're doing and you'll hear a little bit more from from maryan about this regarding the multilingual uh learner programming is we're trying to focus on what we can control right now which is how tightly are we scheduling what are the clear guard rails that we're using to make decisions about mtss um tier 2 and tier three supports and and the classroom educators are incredibly incredibly instrumental in a tier 2 support for kiddos and we want to we want to optimize our use of um our Specialists really for tier Three Needs um much more than tier two needs because our classroom educators are are incredibly Adept

120at that work the school leaders have all established a system in their schedule that allows for space and time in terms of a flex block that allows for some additional tier 2 work we know we um we have we have solid core programs high quality instructional materials in literacy and math but they're new too so continuing to strengthen our use of those materials um anything new takes time and so we have um it's there was a lot of incredibly hard work and research that went into selecting those materials so I would say that continuing to intensify those efforts to ensure cluster teachers have what they need to differentiate within those to work on inclusive practices within their tier one um support it is a continuous learning effort uh to Mo educate the most students in

121those core spaces and so I think those systems um are what we can control right now the other thing that we can control and I think you saw this out of the elementary budget task force findings is that ensuring that this the schools where there are the greatest needs receive the greatest services and so not to have a onetoone model but really ensuring that with the reduction of Staffing as proposed in the FY 26 uh the Staffing model does allow for additional supports and additional Personnel to be allocated to the students with the greater needs um and all of this will be in service to each other so the criteria for entry into those supports the the Personnel allocation the focus on tier one I think it's it's all they all go hand in hand

122I don't know if that answers your question but thanks tor any other questions from the committee all right thank you Gabby thanks it's my honor to welcome Maryann young coordinator of multilingual programming to share additional insights into this work hello everyone nice to see you all today um this is a very exciting time to be coordinator of multilingual education here because we are experiencing such growth and diversity so um to share some information with you about the enrollment Trends since 2015 our uh population of MLS has nearly doubled with 8.2% of our students currently identified as multilingual Learners our kindergarten multilingual learner enrollment has doubled since 2015 and 80% of our multilingual Learners are in elementary school um another change in the past couple of years is that half of our multi lingual Learners are

123at the lowest English language proficiency level of 1 to 1.5 which means they are just beginning their Journey with language acquisition and just as a comparison um students exit our program and become former English Learners when their proficiency level in English is 4.2 um another data point is to look at uh the percentage of English Learners in all of our different schools as you can see um we have 3% at the high school up to 15% at Conant and 20% um of the population at the preschool or English Learners um this slide was as of November which says our total population is 424 we are now at 436 for mult multilingual Learners um this slide celebrates our diversity so our five majority languages are Spanish Portuguese Russian Chinese and um Creole but we have many

124other languages that are spoken throughout the district and this is a slide which um shows the distribution of our English language development teachers so right now we have 16 point six full-time um staff and our case loads range from 21 to 27 with 24 being um the most average Cas um and this is another significant slide to show our growth over time so according to this slide in the past nine years we have doubled we've gone from 4.3 to 8.9 8.9 my glasses I can't really see but I think that's what the number is um and we're mirroring the trends that the state is seeing overall um as a result of our growth we do have some unmet needs um we just did go through our program evaluation some of the recommendations that were given

125were to increase Staffing so we can meet the recommended service minutes that the state sets out which is 90 minutes for students at the lowest levels of proficiency and 45 minutes for students at the mediate intermediate levels um and also to think about creating a position where someone could work with registration staff um to get uh demographic information to help with data entry um for Sims collection and also to be a family liaison another area that we're looking at is curriculum there is really no state approved curriculum for multilingual education so we're looking at um building our own and looking at highquality research and evidence-based materials that are aligned with weda 20120 which is the newest standards for multilingual education and aligned with core um curriculum practices um as Gabby and Peter mentioned we're also

126looking at scheduling we uh want to be as efficient as we can be and we would love to be able to um work with Educators to get closer to the blocks of minutes that we need um which we can only do with flexibility in in the scheduling at the elementary level um and then we also want to create spaces for enhanced collaboration because as Gabby mentioned the tier one instructional practices in the classroom are really what's most important for all of our students and our multilingual Learners are only with us for a very small percentage of the day um and we really want to grow time and capacity within the Capac uh within the um General Educators and that goes um into our next point which is professional learning and capacity building so um we're

127also looking at increasing professional development opportunities for um ELD Educators and general Educators on waa 2020 and the Next Generation ESL best practices thanks Maran okay questions from the committee viam not really a question but a commment I'm sure most of us in this room already know this but on the pie chart it says it lists Indian as a language there is no language Indian just want to be very clear on that sure and I can speak to that that is a fault in the software that we use um it has that as an option so when data transfers over it transfers over as it was entered by parents at registration and maybe Maryann you can speak quickly to why English is on that chart as well because I know we discussed that at our

128our last review but there's a bigger audience here yes sorry um so we can go back to that slide um so English is listed as 17.9% of our multilingual Learners um this is generally because we have a registration system where parents enter their own information electronically and often we have students that are born in the United States who are multilingual who speak English and another language but have not mastered English yet um so often when they fill out the forms they list English as their native language but because there are other languages listed on their home language survey we screen and then um find students eligible so that is why English is listed there thank you questions from the committee AI so it's more a curiosity question how does the tiered system of support affect

129the teaching staff and their kind of U um professional learning in terms of providing these extra Services I mean they have been introduced to the system which is new what does that mean and how does it look uh do they feel the pressure to constantly keep changing um I think one of the great changes that we've made is that um multilingual teachers are now actively involved in the um mtss process so they assist the general Educators um in working through scaffolds and supports for multilingual Learners um in whatever area is needed so it's a collaborative approach um and I think it's important to realize that the practices for scaffolding instruction for English Learners are really best practices for all students so um through the course of going through the MTS Pro mtss process and meeting

130and collaborating um teachers are growing capacity but it's beneficial to their students and um the El students at the same time um and I think because of the increased collaboration it's a shared responsibility so I'm hoping that one group of teachers doesn't feel um overburdened I think that um that that's not the case I think because of the collaborative structures they're working well together L May I can add to that um so one of the changes in kind of the complexity of teaching over time um which does you know make it more challenging to be a teacher I think now than years ago um is this notion of sheltered English immersion um requirements and this is a state requirement that Educators go through and it's essentially a requirement that all educators are English language development

131educator right like we we are all here to teach English language acquisition um and that's an actually an expectation of Educators that in the general education classroom they are English language acquisition Educators and they are there to help students learn how to acquire English language um and then we have you know multilingual Educators who are there to kind of focus in and hone on that but they are not the only providers of this support so you know ELD or English language development is actually a tier one expectation in that mtss model not a tier two or three support any other questions from committee Leela thank you so much um I this is making me this I think around this piece around not meeting minutes um makes me think about when I was supporting one of

132the math class class at AB and there was a brilliant student who did not speak English fluently um and using my kind of broken Spanish in that time um things clicked and I saw how the pieces were connecting and I'm not suggesting that was best practice in that moment um but for folks who don't spend all of their time in schools can you talk a little bit about what not meeting minutes means for students kind of tangibly on the ground for their educational experience sure so um English as a second language is a separate um content area that um you know works with the other content um areas in school but it's separate and it focuses intensely on um conversational skills but also writing reading speaking and listening those are the four um domains and

133not meeting the minutes means that there's less direct instructional time on English as a second language as a subject than um what the state is recommending all right any last questions from the committee thank you Maryann and we're going to go over now to special education with Mary and not Sherry Dan but there you go hi um I'm Mary Emmons I'm the interim director for special education um and I want to introduce Dan merer who's our assistant director of special education it's wonderful to be back in the district this is um you know familiar budget budget Saturday for me um I was here 20 years as a special educator and administrator um about nine years ago so it's wonderful to be back what I you can't hear me that might be okay um um so

134what I'd like to say is first of all what I've noted is the number of specialized programs that we have here in our district and the needs of our students and the opportunity to be in our district um and benefit from their school community community I know that we build programs to meet the needs of cohorts of students and it's the right thing to do um it really is the heart of the idea the individuals with disabilities Education Act that says that we need to provide students with an education a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment so it is the right thing to do for our students to have them in our community to the extent possible that we can um today I'm going to talk with you about programming the

135trends in special education and the budget recommendations we do know that special ed is a financial budget driver but I always tell people to remember behind every dollar are the needs of students and so what I'm going to talk about a lot of things today and hopefully I answer some of your questions I might have you do this for me if you don't mind do you mind okay okay can you hear me all right much better okay it's kind of awkward let me move my soda that's with me all the time okay people can attest to that anyways uh special education provides services and supports to students through special Educators assistants related service providers bcbas and contracted Services we we have a Contin of services within our district and when we can't meet the needs

136of students we look to out of District um to meet the students needs so we have specialized programming um I chose to put up the specialized programming so you could see it across the district this slide represents specialized programming at all levels of the district it's important to note that there's a blank box under the the high school piece this is a blank box that's representing our Pathways program we need to build the pathways program into the high school for next year we have a cohort of students that are coming from the junior high school um up to the high school the plan is to reate reallocate the resources that we currently have at the junior high school because we do not have students coming into the pathways program so what's exciting about that is

137we will have the pathways teacher that's currently at the junior high school and two of the assist assistants start that program I think it's really great for the kids she follow those students there very important that we talk about FY 27 because we'll have to build that back in the budget um for the students that will be coming from Blancher to the junior high school so this is an opportunity for reallocation programming in our school provides inclusive opportunities for all students the majority of our students are included within the general education setting to the extent possible students access general education curriculum through supports accommodations and modification the services we provide are individualized and based on student needs it is important that our provision of services and supports continue to maintain high expectations for our students

138with disabilities and collaborate and partner with our general education teachers to ensure access within the classroom so I'm going to show you some Trends around inclusion uh Dan and I uh pulled up all the Sims data that's the student informational management system to really look at a three-year trend of inclusion inclusion within the classroom so this is data that's based on October 1st Sims for the last three years um these Trends have remained pretty consistent over the last threeyear time period over 84% of our special education students are fully included in general education and what that means is they are out of the classroom less than 21% of the of the day 10% or less of students are partic are partially included in the in the general education classroom and that means between 21 and

13960% of the time and 5% of our students require subpar classroom in outside of the general education setting this again again is uh based on our Sims data um on October 1st for our students prek through 12 and Beyond the percentage of students on IEPs in our district has increased slightly over the last three years and in currently with that Sims data is 16.9% that may change they capture data again in June to look at that this the state is consistently gone up as well um we are lower than the state average of 6% again this is data that's based on the Sims reports from October 1st over three years consistently as we look to review and build programs for cohorts of students in our district it's really important to look at the high incident

140areas of disability so there are other disabilities but these are the high incident disabilities the data only captures or reflects a student's primary disability and that's really important to stress that um so when we run this on the Sims reports these are primary areas of disability many of our students have multiple disabilities or secondary or tertiary disabilities that are not reflected here um you know we may have a student with autism spectrum disorder who also has communication disorder um so that is not reflected you can see from this graph over the last three years that students with autism Health disabilities specific learning disabilities and developmental delays have remained consistent or increased slightly there's been a decline in our students with primary disability of communication and emotional disability again there may be some other comorbid things

141that are going on I will also say that one of the things I've observed is difficulty with regulation across the district with our littlest people um I think it's very hard to identify an emotional disability for a child that's dealing with trauma for a child that still is developing and we're looking at those developmental markers so um that may explain some of it because we're very hesitant to put emotional disability on a child that's in kindergarten okay so I really wanted to talk also and and highlight um the the the preschool program I want to make sure you look at the enrollment over the last three years it's remained consistent even when our um overall enrollment has declined our students with IEPs and those receiving itinerate Services which may be speech and language otpt have

142remained consistent over a three-year period I also want to talk about out of District again this is based on October 1 data when we look at the primary disability of our students who are placed out of District um again stressing this is only primary our students out of District have complex needs um and multiple multiple issues that they may be need support with um you can see that a autism and emotional impairment are the highest areas of disability for out of District students again I can't stress enough that these are students who have typically have multiple um and complex profiles when our students require out of District programming we look to put them in the least restrictive place just like in District we have a Continuum of services for our students um from least restrictive

143to more restrictive we look at collaboratives we often think of those as our um least restrictive outof District programs because many are built in public school settings and so students have an opportunity for inclusion inclusion within that whether it's the case program we are members of the case collaborative um and we use case collaborative as our collaborative we also use other collaboratives if Case doesn't have the program that's the best fit for the student um you can see that most of our students are in uh private day schools these are desie approved private day schools um they have you know when I first moved to Massachusetts years ago and I was the OT district coordinator there were over 200 out of district schools our our collaboratives are not listed as um as I think uh

144Sherry talked about operational services division they don't approve the tuition for collaboratives they do for private day schools and residential schools want to talk a little bit about our coordinators and their priorities across the district we have six coordinators for eight schools the main role of the coordinator main roles and this does not Encompass everything they do um is to support our staff uh our students and their families our coordinators are a resource within our school communities the coordinator role is also an administrative role that has supervision and promatic programmatic responsibilities as well as to ensure that the legal mandates for special education are adhered to within the school and within the program so I have Dan sitting I'm going to speak for him I guess um I didn't know we were shifting around so

145this is great to have you here in addition to the coordinators um at the administrative level we also have an assistant director for special education for a district our size it is very common to have an assistant director of special education and you can see some of the tasks especially for me this year that Dan has been so helpful you know the IEP came out that was a huge lift um sorry that was a huge lift to push that out and get that out on time I think I was surprised when I went to um a state level uh meeting and they were talking about it in October and people still had not there was a lot of work that was done over the summer with Dan and a lot of the um special Educators

146and coordinators to make sure that we were up and running there was a big piece of power school that went into that um and also there is the capacity to get out in the schools and to be visible um I've enjoyed getting out into the schools and see meeting new people and seeing people that I knew from years ago I know that there's some concerns around um the level of you know de of of reg regulation issues for our kiddos and so I want to talk a little bit about safety care safety care is really a Crisis Prevention training um and it's our response to a crisis and we hope to prevent it because it's really about deescalation uh of students and strategies that we use only those staff members that are fully trained can

147restraint a student and again restraint is absolutely the last thing that we want to do it is you know it is the it is when someone is at risk of hurting themselves or hurting others so it is only done in those times of extreme concern around safety we currently have six trainers in the district with 79 staff members fully trained um Dan has been intrical in making sure that there's a new program that came out safety care Basics to make sure those are just those deescalation strategies that all of us Us in schools teachers everyone assistance really need so that we can support students so I want to talk about um the budget changes um my priority in this budget has been to ensure that we are not touching student facing supports those supports that

148are directly working with students um our special Educators OT PT psychologist counselor all of those people that support our students we are proposing an increase in an assistant at the elementary to address student needs and A3 bcba addition to the high school it was really important for me H you know and working with the junior high to maintain a 0.5 bcba there even though we're shifting and reallocating resources I think it's really important that they continue to have those supports there of the bcba um because you know we still have programs there we had still have students that need those supports as I shared earlier we are reallocating resources from the junior high school high school to build the pathways program at the high school with a plan in the FY 27 budget to back

149to build back this program at the junior high we are proposing a reduction of 1.0 coordinator at the elementary level this was a very difficult decision um I believe that the needs of our students and staff can be met through this model um I know I met with Folks at McCarthy Town who who are very concerned about the reduction of a 1.0 um uh coordinator um it is important that we look at what supports our students do require um within especially within our specialized programs but not just that we have students and Learning Centers across the district that are not in specialized programs that are dealing with regulation issues emotional issues so we want to make sure everyone has the right supports um in addition to the coordinators our assistant director will provide a additional

150support for our students with autism and K through K through six and our coordinator for social emotional learning will provide additional supports to our Compass program as well as consultants that we have so um we took some data from November of 24 um and this looks at ipps by coordinator and you see I've just have the coordinators numbered with the different schools that they support um it's important to note that this number of students this is case load this number of students does not speak to workload it does not speak to the um services that students need every individual student has different number of service minutes this does not speak to that this is numbers of IEPs um the DAT as I said it was collected uh in November right now I know when I

151speak to coordinators there is testing that is happening across the district as we speak these numbers May shift we also know that some students are dismissed from special ed so you know at the end of the year those numbers become clearer to us but this is just a snapshot in time um again as I said in addition to our students who are in specialized programs we have students who are not in specialized programs that require higher levels of support um you can see from the chart that a recommendation of a reduction of 1.0 coordinator at the elementary level I believe is a reasonable request and will allow us to continue to provide the support to our schools um it would mean for the elementary school two schools uh per coordinator it's going to be important

152as I said to look at the cohort of our students you know when we talk about program review I think people think about that as being a one-time thing we do every year I think we need to look at our students and their needs ongoing what to hearts of students require that could shift within a school year so program review to me needs to be constant data needs to be constant you need to be looking at that I wanted to also show you and give you a little information again this is um this slide shows us the the what under each coordinator the number of Learning Centers that they have and specialized programs so we have specialized programs across the district and we have Learning Centers and there's some variation in Learning Centers across the

153district I think it's always important to look at equity and again look at the needs of students We Are One District we need to look at the needs of all of our students across the district to ensure that we have Equity of service um I didn't put a slide up here but um we Dan did pull up the data on Learning Centers our Learning Centers at the elementary average anywhere from 10 to 12 students per special educator or liaison um at the high school it's around 15 and at the I mean at the junior high it's around 15 and at the high school it's around 22 so this is the leadership structure and as I end my presentation I wanted to share our special ed leadership structure um in addition to our assistant director of

154special education and coordinators who are administrators within the district we have chairpersons in speech and language otpt 504s psyching counseling these chairperson roles are partial FTE and part of their their their full job so they are a portion of what they are doing as either a psychologist um an occupational therapist um so those are a little different than the coordinators who have administrative roles um and the position of special ed director and assistant director um I don't don't know if you can I do a look ahead I put a look ahead there's going to be lots of things that will happen in the district next year um but I did want to highlight something we started working on this year and that is um I did a reach out to Fitchburg State we currently have

15516 um special Educators who are Wilson certified we have some folks that are Orton Gillingham certified we have people that have been to just wordss training which is a Wilson product um for a small group typically older students um and we have 19 special education teachers who've had the the three-day Wilson I think it's very important that we have consistency across the district that we have at least three special Educators in each building all the way through high school that are fully Wilson certified so Fitchburg State actually will give us a reduced rate for 10 folks to go across the district to make and we've looked at where do we need that in each building um and have kind of planned because some people who have not had the 3-day overview have to go in

156March so even if they are will you know they they had that before they have to go again so we I wanted to bring it up because it's happening this year and the plan is to to start in August with that cohort of 10 special Educators with Fitchburg State to to provide that thanks Mary all right uh questions from the committee on special education Jenny thank you um I I wanted to to Circle back to your um comment about the reduction in a special ed coordinator for McCarthy Town um well it's not it's not it's it's not for just McCarthy town so it's a 1.0 reduction it's for the coordinators So currently we have four at the elementary will be reducing to one Blanchard has a 1.0 coordinator as well so it would mean there

157would be one coordinator for every two schools okay but with with regard to the compass program in particular which is housed in McCarthy town there would still be a 1.0 coordinator that would go across the buildings there right I understand that okay yeah so but but what I'm my question is with regard to the compass program um and the increase in the substantial increase in restraints that have been performed uh in McCarthy town uh it it seems like a a bad time to reduce anything in that school if the needs have uh increased that much and particularly with the compass program and and maybe you want to just talk a little bit about the kiddos who are in that program I find it I find it a little bit alarming um and you know we

158certainly have heard a lot from the the Educators who will be imp imped by that on you know behalf of themselves and their students so you know I'm I'm personally concerned about that reduction I will say that the coordinator role is really valuable it is also an administrative role and we want to make sure that we have the right supports in place for all of our specialized programs any number of restraints for us is too great right um they are not higher than they were last year at this time uh they're actually lower than they were but we need to make sure that we have that all of the people that are working with our students in all of our programs have the right the right training that they have additional PD that they have

159additional supports and we certainly have um we have a a elely wolf working with us from MGH Aspire who's just a wonderful resource she provides support and so we will increase that support for her to have her be there as well um and we have we are all vested in the success of our programs and looking at what else do we need to do to make sure that we are that we are supporting those programs so what I'm saying to you is the coordinator role to me it's the people that are working directly with students that we need to support and make sure they have the right supports in place so this is not about one school or one coordinat this is about a cut to we have four so it's a cut to one

160coordinator for the district so that they would each have two schools so they would still be available I know in sitting in my role as a special ed director and I'm the furthest away from the classroom when things come up for me around if people need support I go to those schools and I have been involved at the meeting level to support staff as well and as has Dan okay thank thank you I just want to um Follow by saying I'd be interested to hear about what seems to be a discrepancy on the resence issue U if Amanda could speak to that later on and also just want to highlight that special education is another uh State mandate that requires all school districts to provide the least restrictive environment um you know in in the

161absolutely and and that's that's another area that's woefully underfunded by the state in my opinion it's it's an area that's underfunded by the federal government as well uh when Ida came out it it has consistently and has always been underfunded and I agree with you completely I want kids you know cohorts our students to be in the least restrictive environment to the extent possible and we buil I you know My Philosophy is we build programs so that students can be included right and I I just want to point out that this is just one of those areas where it's very very difficult to make these decisions with our limited resources where we have these mandates that are not in my opinion sufficiently funded by the state or federal government but this is of concern to

162me and I think Gabby said it best I want to move us on I'm sorry we're behind already I think the the point is is very clear other questions from the committee Leela mine's connected but slightly different and I don't know that if it is for Mary or someone else um but just contextually what Jenny was talking about was restraints close to 30 um and our general numbers are around like under 10 um and that's just from last year but my question is around how that connects to our classroom assistance like I think it also connects tocl programming and a bunch of other pieces um but just wondering how you might imagine I don't know who this is directed at um the impact of reducing classroom assistance might impact the ability for adults to be

163in the classroom to um engage in deescalation or other things to prevent it from getting to the point of uh restraints or other I I what I will say is from a special education standpoint we have um special ed assistance with students who require support in the classrooms um so those special ed assistance uh you're talking about classroom assistance um special education assistance are with our students who need that support in the classroom I can't answer the classroom assistant piece any last questions Tori not a question just a comment Mary I appreciate your your thoughtful analysis of a really difficult situation and I think my comment is actually probably for the people sitting in the tier behind me um you see the difficult discussions we are having about resources and supporting kids and this is

164an area to me that I'm very concerned about accepting risk um and so as we go forth as as a as municipal whole bodies and have these conversations we all need to be asking our directors these hard questions because this is where we are at with education right now and it's not okay thanks Tory any other questions from the committee no all right so um we've heard about our multi-tiered systems of supports we've heard about uh multilingual education and special education I'm going to take it back a row to the um Town boards and committees um give them an opportunity um what I'd like you to is keep yourself to one question each um and if the question's already been asked then please let's move on because we are falling a bit behind like I

165said we have to get to a preliminary budget vote before some of our school members turn back into pumpkins um so we got to keep things moving forward I'm going to start on this side this time so anything from the act and select board questions on any of the three presentations we've had none thank you boxboro finance and select board right um my question is about um students that we are probably currently sending out of our district for special ed needs um have we thought long term about like how we can meet their needs I know you talked about like meeting their needs within our uh system but also looking into for long term is there a way or is there some benefit if we try to collaborate like within our district and also bringing

166students from other districts will that help in terms of increasing our collaboration and in having some cost or savings there um so you know a couple quick points on that um one there are times where if we have space within an existing District program we might actually allow another District to tuition a student in to a program that has in our district most typically happened like at our high school um in our ODP or PACE program so we do a little bit of that in house but you know Mary talked a little bit about the idea of collaboratives collaboratives are actually a group of school districts who have banded together forly in an entity um to provide special education services who could to students who could not otherwise be serviced in the school day so

167when you see um a percentage of our students being educated in collaboratives that actually is us working with a variety of other school districts to create these educational opportunities but are we sending them out or are students are coming to us it's both um there are times you know we have um two programs within our district over at our Boardwalk campus um where we have students not only from our school district but from other districts who come here um but the program is administered by the case collaborative and then case also runs programs in all of our neighboring communities uh where we might send our students with other school districts and I'd kind of like to add on when annual reviews we look at students and what they need and if they are able to

168come back to our district we certainly want to propose that if that's what's appropriate um but that's a team meeting decision I also want to say that when we see that's what I mean about program review if we see a cohort of students that we can build a program for then we're going to be talking about that um at some of the schools we you know we we might discuss um you know this is this is this cohort what could we build with the also with the resources that we have how do we reallocate those resources to meet the needs of a cohort of students and do we also collaborate I'll be short do we also collaborate with um the schools and universities with some of these things can we like come up with better

169ways of addressing different needs at at the same time I mean I'm trying to think long term in terms of like how we can kind of condense things together but at the same time give a good program I'm I'm going to answer this one all options are on the table but not for next year that's the challenge we're in a very acute problem right now so let's move on anything from rest of boxboro act in finance um short comment um Tori we hear you and I think one of the things that while we are normally the board that says no or the committee that says no one of the things that we are trying to recognize is uh when we can help so our colleagues over on the select board uh are having a challenge

170hiring police officers it turns out one of the Hidden problems is they have to live within 15 miles of town There's legislation to um change that if there are similar situations for the school committee please consider the finance an ally who is going to try to fight with you not against you to try to reconcile some of the crazy things that they require you to do that they don't fund if you get F Federal funding cut and by the way 1.7 million out of the 1.8 million comes from the feds if you need someone to attend a protest let us know we'll we'll show show up with our own signs because we're cheap thank you all right uh from the public hi Amanda two quick points that haven't been made Mr chair um Mary I

171don't know if you can go back and look at the um coordinator case load by IEPs really quick and if we can just combine some of those numbers and see where they end up um 65 + 73 puts us pretty high and I know that that's not necessarily the school that the two that are going to be split into part-time um but that does bump that number up pretty high you can look at that average it would Pro will be a little bit over 100 yep um the other thing that I just want to make is a point and downstream effect of cutting tier two and tier three supports there's a line in Peter's preliminary budget memo about how we're having a hard time making groupings especially in tier three because students needs are highly

172individualized um and we're also proposing cutting at the junior high so we looking at a potential Snowball Effect of kids not necessarily getting all of the Intensive intervention they need in a timely fashion given the cycles and mtss in order to get what they need before they hit the junior high and they have to catch all those different needs from the six elementary schools so I recognize there's no more money coming um but I really want to flag that for this discussion and future discussions thank you thanks Amanda all right I'm going to ask Andrew Shen to come up because you're you're next I'm yeah Andrew come on up to get ready to present and if we still have some questions from the public we'll take a couple more thank you anyone from the public

173hello um I come to you today in my pajamas to remind you that it is not my job to be here um my name is tippet I'm a fifth grade classroom teacher at McCarthy Town um and I am here to express serious concerns around the ad production of the coordinator role at MC as it is going to impact every single student and every single teacher who works in both actually in the Parker Damon building um I urge the school committee to urgently push back on this proposal as Mary mentioned the McCarthy Town staff General Educators and special Educators both met to express significant concerns around this proposal yesterday we were presented with the same information and our question questions were answered uh in the form of well the data says X the data says y

174this is a coordinator position this is an administrator as I said Mary has continued to speak about how this role is Administrative and it is um but this role to speak of it simply as an administrative role is false this is absolutely a student facing position and to apply that to imply that it is not is actually incredibly harmful and misinforms the community about what we need in our schools our special educators are already at or above capacity as are our classroom teachers and I do not mean that we need to be trained or taught on how to better support our students please do not send us to PL please do not hire people and spend money on training Us in something this is the most skilled and collaborative community of Educators I have ever

175worked with and I couldn't imagine going anywhere else what I mean is that we need to maintain the incredible leadership that we have in that position I also want to speak to the fact that you mentioned that the data does not represent what the needs are in our schools this data tells us the number of IEPs but does not tell us the level of need or the number of minutes or the amount of time that different Educators and Service delivery providers are spending with students per day when we look at this it looks like schools with specialized programs McCarthy toown and Blanchard need less support I understand why this data makes it sound like we need or could handle less support but that does not put into perspective what students get or need that they

176are not getting on a daily basis so I believe that before this committee can make a determination as you have said this data needs to reflect case load this data needs to reflect how many minutes of services are special Educators actually delivering every single day in these buildings and what is the coordinator doing during the day that is student facing because I haven't seen Christy barriers for the vast majority of this year because she is actively working with students and she is everywhere around the building and not in my room because I don't have a student this year who is actively in crisis last year I did last year I saw her every single day of the school year and that's because she is actively working with students every single day Miriam has a part-time

177coordinator there have been situations at Miriam this school year where the Miriam staff have not been able to meet the needs of those students thank you tippet we'd like to move on please hi my name is Kristen O'Neal I'm a boxb resident um I come here just to make a comment um as a parent and also with a Wonder um as we talk about this administrative role for special education I've learned so much about special education in the last year um and I appreciate that some of the people in this room might not understand the Team Dynamics um that Mary mentioned coming together as a team and making decisions as to how to best support our students and understanding that the coordinator sits in a lot of meetings and those meetings are really important when

178we're discussing the needs of our students and as a parent I've been really appreciative not to be rushed out of the room when talking about my students needs and finally after a year of meetings coming to a place where my student is really supported and reaching their potential in school is a really special place to be um and I wonder if we're expanding the case loads of these administrators and taking away their ability to be in building to um provide some of the services that were just talked about I wonder the impacts of that thank you all right we are going to move on thank you for all the questions and comments uh on to our staffing discussion Andrew okay hi everyone uh Andrew Shen Deputy superintendent uh thank you for the time to provide

179a little bit of an overview from a staffing perspective as people have shared already uh within our budget Staffing accounts just even from a salary perspective uh almost two-thirds of uh the overall budget so I think what we'd like to do now is just provide you some similar information that you may have already heard but through the lens of of um Staffing and at a certain point this is also the point uh this is also the section where we are going to talk a little bit more about proposed uh reductions and when we get to that I'll provide sort of the very mechanical information and then uh I've asked Jim marot at the junior high school Joanie Dean at the high school and Trisha O'Reilly on behalf of the elementary schools just to be prepared

180to offer a little bit of contour and texture to some of the the proposed reductions and and to answer some of the questions that I think you inevitably might have before we get into some of the details just a friendly reminder about uh some terminology and some information first and foremost just the the idea of FTE full-time equivalent that's just a concept that we use to identify sort of Staffing numbers which is different from headcount headcount is the actual number of individuals who might be uh part of our staff uh but if they are part-time you may have uh a 1.0 FTE that's comprised of two or three uh individuals FTE is really used for hourly employees and is based on a 40h hour work week so just to give you an example a special

181education assistant may be uh their full-time position may be 31.25 hours a week but in terms of our calculations uh it would count as0 875 a couple of years a I think last year we started to convert all of them just so we would have an Apples to Apples comparison so for those of you who are looking at year-over-year changes uh starting last year they are uh able to be Apples to Apples comparisons uh the other piece that I think is important to mention is over in the next few slides we are talking about um the FTE that either exist or that are proposing being reduced uh it does not talk about uh the the growing needs and the Staffing that weren't proposed uh to address trust needs so the unmet needs that I think

182you heard about from Maryann young and from others regarding tier 2 Services uh those are positions that are not being proposed um and so I just want to make sure that we we hold a space for for that reality as well and then finally just Staffing categories I know that when we talk about some specific uh roles and responsibilities just to be sure that um there's distinctions made when we're talking about certified staff positions versus par of professional positions so on and so forth you know for example I do know that at times there's um wonderings about the difference for example between reading Specialists and reading assistants um they obviously all contribute uh to some shared uh goals and yet they uh they do fall under different categories so I just want to make sure

183that we're we're mindful of that the next few slides uh provide you just simply a snapshot based on this past December of our of our current Staffing for this fiscal year uh for those who might be interested or who follow our monthly school committee reports this is just simply the Personnel report that you get on a monthly basis um and this is for December typically every month if you do look at our school committee reports you will find um just any updates not only about budgeted FTE versus current FTE then as well as budgeted headcount versus current headcount so this is really about this current year and comparison month over month uh a few slides towards the end we're going to actually compare not only our budgeted FTE for this year versus our proposed FTE

184for next year and we divide it into categories such as Administration certified staff and then subcategories then we have salaried support staff uh our office support staff our Osa uh Union our asme which is our facilities our custodians uh and buildings and grounds and then our hourly support staff our hourly support staff as I mentioned in our last school committee meeting that's tends to be uh have the most sort of churn uh in terms of month over month or seasonally in terms of uh positions where individuals who hold them may uh may choose to pursue other opportunities May resign uh they may have open positions over the course of a stretch of an entire um semester or school year and so that tends to have the most volatility um within within a given school year

185and then you'll see the the subtotals for both certified positions and total staff support position um for this year terms of personnel budgeting for this year uh in terms of certified positions the average uh salary for new hires for this current year was uh a little over 77,000 which is just a little bit over what we had budgeted um for new hires which is at an M6 rate that Sher had mentioned which is about 74,000 um and this is just the the chart shows just the breakdown in terms of the 42 new highers what were the salary ranges that we um eventually had our 42 new hires in just to connect to what uh Sherry shared before part of the savings that we're anticipating next year is with the the departures that we already know

186about through retirements and other uh resignations that we anticipate for next year we take those current salaries that we have and then re-budget it at an M6 which next year at their contract will probably still be in the the mid-70s probably 76 77,000 um as we budget more tightly and with less flexibility um I think what you see here in terms of the range of new higher salaries is going to be a little bit more it's going to be tighter you know we're going to have less flexibility I've already given a preview to our our principles that um if and when they need to fill positions we probably are going to be less flexible in terms of them calling and saying hey Andrew you know we've I know that we have this budget and yet

187we have this candidate who we think is really best for the position and and good for the role good for students um we may not have that flexibility just given sort of how tightly we are budgeting things and how we really haven't um provided as much buffer as we were able to in previous years we may need to say you know as you think about candidates to bring in um it's not just about looking at their qualifications and sort of what you think is their fit but also quite frankly the cost that they might bring um to to to the budget so uh that's not something that we have had to do as much before I think we might be entering a time period we might have to um have to be considering that as

188a a variable so I bring this slide up just as a point of um reference for next year terms of budgeting considerations uh many of these you've already heard but I'll just remind you retirements uh provided us some savings because we obviously take a higher salary of somebody who is currently with us they're retiring and we recalibrate the budget to around $77,000 um we also however do need to rightsize our substitute budget we continue to have um higher substitute costs than we did two three years ago not only in terms of actual sub needs but also sub costs one of the things that we are discovering that's that's um industrywide is that there are some roles where uh our ability to find um certified and qualified substitutes is becoming a challenge especially in areas um

189where we have certain services such as psychologists such as otpt um those are areas where there's less availability and so what we found ourselves Mary Dan and I are are uh needing to because we have to fulfill those Services going to um outside contracted service providers and they uh they they charge a healthy fee um and those are costs that we don't necessarily budget in terms of our typical substitute rates um but we have to pay Market rates and and in those Industries uh we have to compete with um other sort of other other vendors and other private um providers where they can charge um charge competitive rates that that then tax our our Personnel budget uh we have proposed additions for FY 26 as you know it's very modest it's the the special ed

190assistant and the bcba the vacancy Factor reduction that Sher mentioned uh and then the proposed reductions will which we will go over um briefly and just as a reminder as people mentioned the class siiz guidelines of um obviously provided some guidance in terms of some of the proposals that were made at the junior high and high school okay so these next few slides are actually uh providing a reminder of the proposed Staffing reductions again the the Staffing reductions probably account for a vast majority of the the closing the budget deficit um but not entirely there are other um reductions that were made that Peter had mentioned that aren't Staffing related but the majority are Staffing related um the next slides will go by District level positions then elementary junior high and then high school so

191at the district level as Mary pointed out um there is a proposal for an elementary special education coordinator reduction um and then there is also a proposed reduction in central office administrative support that is actually in my office office um I'm going to eliminate my uh administrative assistance support position um we are leaving some funding there in that line so I can probably distribute some additional hours to other part-time positions to provide some additional support but my office will U be reducing the administrative support position in in our office um there are certain sended roles and programs that uh we will be uh eliminating as it points out in that the blue square that really speaking to the seeds crtl in a world of differ ipens really in our Equity work um and so if

192you have questions around the impact around that Jen Faber can obviously speak a little bit more knowledge beond that and then in the Athletics we actually are proposing about a $30,000 reduction in um the support that Athletics gets from our general fund that's something that Jim scanland our athletic director took a review and um identified some coaching positions that are actually currently unfilled um and that he feels that moving forward in terms of contributing to bridging that that deficit um that we can move forward and eliminate those unfilled positions at the elementary level as already highlighted um there is a proposal to reduce approximately 25% of general education assistant hours that does not include kindergarten assistant positions but really at the grade 1 through six level uh there is a full-time math specialist that is

193a certified position as a reduction uh there is a proposal to to reduce a certified librarian position that's actually the result of a retirement and then replacing it with a library media assistant position so you're going from a certified position to a a PA professional position for the library media assistant so you realize some savings through that Fort part-time reading assistant positions uh that's the equivalent as we get to that ft thing again FTE thing you have U four people uh in part-time positions that's the equivalent of 1.9 FTE and then we are reducing one kindergarten section that actually was already reduced in the base budget um and so it does it's not reflected in the 1.8 million that we had to um realize in Savings in terms of the kindergarten section that does take

194us from about 18.6 uh average of class size currently in kindergarten to around 20 students for next year if you know if the enrollment plays out the way that we are projecting at the Junior High there are there's the proposal for three certified classroom teaching positions a science teacher a math teacher and a social studies teacher uh last year uh the junior high school reduced a uh English teacher and so along with some reductions that were made previously in World Language this basically takes the Junior High from eight full teams to seven teams um what happens there is you have three teams that are fully dedicated to seventh grade three teams that are fully dedicated to eighth grade and then one team the seventh team um will be divide will include students a cohort of

195seventh grade students and a cohort of eighth grade students and as you can see in the the um the yellow Square um you will take team sizes from an average of 104 students to approximately 120 students per team and then at the high school there's a proposal for five classroom teaching positions two social studies teachers one math teacher two English teachers uh the asterisk you'll note there one of those English teacher reductions has already been um reduced at the start of the school year in terms of there is currently no U individual teacher who's actually filling that position this year we uh that position became open and so we decided not to fill it in anticipation of having to make reductions at the point that we're at now in addition we are proposing the reduction

196of um two campus monitor positions for a total of 1.875 FTE uh and then a 18 hour star program assistant which is about a halftime FTE and then you can see the impact of class sizes for those three content areas um to your left what I want to do now um we did get a bit of a request at different points in time I think most recently at our last school committee meeting I think Rebecca had also shared you know as we as we talk about hard decisions and and and Staffing decisions in terms of reductions and how we're really at this place where there really aren't any good it's choosing between bad and bad um there's clearly an understandable question mark around when you think about positions especially ones that are farther away from

197the classroom from the center of of instruction and so there were um certainly questions that people had asked around positions that are much farther away from the classroom on a day-to-day basis and what we really often people will say is for example central office and so this next portion is really to offer individuals just a bit more information about central office positions um before I get into describing some of these central office positions I want to acknowledge kind of put out there the inherent excuse me what I'll say sort of awkwardness because I think in some ways it could be viewed as um spending the next few minutes trying to defend and justify the positions of which we all hold um and and quite frankly it's not really the goal of these next few slides

198to to say why uh we are um uh indispensable or or how we were or more important or how we can't be reduced obviously we have not made proposals to reduce any of the positions that I'm about to um describe but instead just provide information because people have said could you better explain the form and function of central office so we can make informed decisions about whether uh the decision not to um make proposals in those areas for reduction as as reasonable so I will just simply share that information with you as opposed to to um framing it in terms of saying why it's um why the budget decisions that we' made around that uh make sense or don't make sense that's really up for I would say the the the board to to to

199think about Andrew just before you go on make clear the light blue areas are not people the light blue areas are areas of responsibility for the people yep uh I'm about to go into some slides where yeah these are not I think what Peter's trying to say is the boxes do not represent a very large army of people um instead they are areas of responsibility instead I think the the teal blue and the dark blue uh positions are the or boxes are the ones where they're actual individual staff people involved which I will get to in a moment but this just provides sort of an organizational chart for your reference the the first slide you know includes uh my position Deputy superintendent and Gabby's position the assistant superintendent um the the quotation marks really just

200represent not official titles thank you um but really about how we've sort of organized just internally kind of the buckets in which we put sort of roles and responsibilities my side of the house if you will is really around operational elements Gabby's side of the house is really around sort of the academic the teaching and learning the instructional pieces um so whoops you can see in my my area really has to do with human resources uh student enrollment and registration policy procedures um legal and compliance responding to things like whoops subpoenas things like that records Community ad and nursing as uh I highlighted we are proposing a reduction of our admin support uh within that office on Gabby side as you can see everything teaching and learning I do think it's important to note especially

201the the the dramatic change I think over the past few years uh in Gabby's uh world where uh prior to her arrival we had um six more curriculum office staff members involved in terms of curriculum coordinators coaches um that were reduced over the past uh previous two fiscal years and so we have one Elementary curriculum position remaining in Gabby's office you now have uh director of operations and finance which actually used to be two positions was merg into one that's uh sher's World um and and a reduction also of a payroll or accounts payable position you have Mary's position director of special ed which they've described in great detail so I won't get into that um and there's the proposed for reduction for the special ed coordinator position uh Jennifer Faber to my right director

202of diversity Equity inclusion she is a department of of one a mighty Department of one um and as we pointed out how we've done that is because um she's a department of one we've distributed sort of the work and the leadership through um school-based stiens through seed crtl world of difference uh and now that we are proposing a reduction in those uh roles stipended roles for staff I think they're going to have to reimagine how we continue our commitment to to the work that exists because just because the stiens aren't there doesn't mean that the work and the commitment isn't still there def educal oh educational stability will also be uh around students who are identified as homeless or foster foster child uh foster care excuse me um and so that is an area of

203responsibility that will be part of of J along with the resource center school safety uh and compliance I think one of the interesting uh elements that U is part of Jen's portfolio that often elicits sort of responses from from families who saying why are we talking um is that she also is involved in um compliance oriented situations regarding um our compliance with bullying and harassment laws regulations and the investigation obligations that we have Title 9 complaints um there is an elaborate process that exists regardless of which Administration sort of implements Title 9 they all have these very elaborate guidelines that we have to follow and that it falls under Jen's areas of responsibility Maryann young is coordinator of M multilingual learning as you um all saw sort of her presentation the fastest growing student demographic

204in our district Heather Stout our coordinator for mental and Behavioral Health and seal um along with those district-wide responsibilities Heather is also our k6 psychology school chair so we've merged those responsibilities together uh and then many of you know Amy bizwiz our director of educational technology so along with sort of supporting all of our staff with how to best utilize technology to to support the student experience there's also just the actual kind of operational piece the broken Chromebook uh quite frankly and uh the reduction of building based tech support positions last year I think has certainly taxed her remaining staff in regards to the actual just day-to-day um needs of schools and then finally uh as uh Sherry pointed out we have Community Education and Food Services which are all self-funded I still wanted to

205include those roles and responsibilities but they um they are not charged to the general fund and they are self-funded and we also have a director of nursing position which um speaks to just the the health related needs uh within all of our schools in our our district okay so as you recall the uh the monthly Personnel report that I shared with you at the beginning of the presentation we are now using that format but also showing you the difference between what we budgeted this year and our proposed budget for next year within each of these categories as you can see we have a proposed reduction of one FTE in administration that's the special ed coordinator within our certified staff we're proposing a net reduction of a little under 10 that's 10 general education positions but

206then increasing .3 bcba within our salari support staff there's the admin support reduction that I'd mentioned and then in our hourly support staff a net reduction of approximately eight FTE that has to do with the instructional support staff those are the reading um assistance and the classroom assistance the addition of the library media assistant and then Operational Support staff that's the reduction of the campus monitor positions do for those who are very granular in terms of adding numbers I do want to point out that the sort of the net reduction is slightly different by like three or four than the numbers we've presented to you just very briefly just getting into inside baseball when you take the pathways assistance from the junior high to the high school because the the hours of the school day

207are slightly different even though they are still you know two assistants from the junior high going to the high school their FTE slightly changes and so I think they go up like 0.15 FTE or something like that so that's why there is this if if someone saying Andrew it's not 19.6 it's 19.3 or whatever that is um it's just simply it's still the same situation it's just because they're going from one building to another there's some slight um modifications in their FTE for those who are really that grandular not John Peterson not John P not down to the dollar with John with that um entertain I think are we entertaining questions within this realm and then as I said you know Trisha Jim and Joanie they uh they know that I think um if there

208are questions to be to be asked uh in terms of impact they clearly are better positioned um to offer a little bit of of the day-to-day um Insight that that might benefit all of you that I'll hand it over thanks Andrew questions from the committee comments none all right I I'll make one observation which is there's a significant reduction in student facing roles and that's because there's nowhere else to cut we are down to the bone everywhere else um and so when those questions keep coming what about Administration what about central office you've seen Cuts everywhere over the past four years there and we're at a very dire dire dire position now where we are cutting student facing roles and not just general education that core part of mtss where at our Specialists were at

209those people who are delivering tier 2 and tier three special education services in many cases so uh it's it's frightening I would say that's my commentary act and finance committee any questions from your table Yeah you you just teed us up um so what is the total number over the last four years because that is the context for this year's cut what is the total what number of FTE cut over the last sever years let's see this year the proposed reduction is around 19 I think last year was it 20 Sher or where Sher 24 last year and then the previous year was a net reduction of that I don't remember so I think we were at a total of about 60 as of last year so it's 60 on top of the 19 or

210so for this year yeah I can if if you go on I can actually I want to give a really accurate accounting to this because spret we we actually um when we did our elementary budget task force did a very very thorough accounting of not only what we've reduced but where we've also had to bring things in um for whatever reason so um I want to make sure we're we're fair with those numbers so I'll work on that all right Greg we'll come back to you as Peter pulls that information up Karine do you have question I do um one thing I want to point out though for Greg or anybody else is that when they talk about the reductions that have been made in the last several years I feel like they're going to

211the fy21 when like 22 at least 22 FTE were added for the zoom school and that was a one-year thing and they should have all been gone the next year um but that so I always I'm concerned about that time being used as a base Point um I do want to ask about the the admin positions and one figure it's it's I've tried it's impossible to find is how many admins did we have how many people did we have central office whatever when we had three school districts it's impossible to find I don't know if there's any way to pull it together because one of the things we were promised with regionalization was that we would have great efficiencies by going from three school districts to one and I would be shocked if we don't

212have a bigger administrative staff today than we had 15 years ago thanks um I don't have exact numbers for you um I I can tell you I know boxboro had its own superintendent um they had a finance director they also had um edtech staff um special and special ed so those were merged I think one of the things you know when we talk about like special education um in smaller districts I.E under 4,000 students um often times what you see is someone called a director of student services that will have um responsibilities offer all of special education and all of kind of the student conduct and counseling and other related areas like that um when you get over 4,000 students a state law kicks in that says you have to have a dedicated special education

213director only for the purposes of special ed which means that you have to take out those other functions and move them somewhere else um so that's why you actually see those two roles separate in our district um I think you know as well going back what we've tried to do um just in terms of like central office over time uh when we had a resignation in the area of an operations director we actually combined that with um finance and so we actually were able to eliminate a role um at the central office level there that would have been another efficiency an ed Tech director you you really have to have an ed Tech director I I think one of the challenges for us um around educational technology is we had an ed Tech director who

214lived on both the education side of edtech and the operational side of edtech we also had digital literacy coaches who were able to help us and one of my worries right now is we're in this Advent of AI and all of the impacts whether they're positive or negative and they're both um we've eliminated all of the infrastructure under our Ed Tech director on the educational side of Technology um because we have to have the networking infrastructure and you know all those other the pieces um in fin you know we've really tried to look at Finance um and we've actually reduced positions within the finance department um we had a retirement of a part-time Treasurer um this past year and rather than you know replacing that we actually just had the assistant treasur become the treasure

215um and now we're really just on a pum basis with people if we have to you know if the treasure is out we have um we reduced An accounts payable person um in that office as well you can hear what we've done there in the superintendent's office you know we um had a separate um superintendent um admin assistant and a school committee admin assistant um we actually eliminated one of those two positions and so now you know the individual there is you know one person doing both functions but we have we have six we have we have Vice principles at every Elementary School we not have I understand the the line of question we're going in here but I'm just really concerned about time I think I'm sorry one more thing all right because it's

216it's a different subject deleveling um so you had a November meeting where you guys chatted and said that um you basically kept the you intentially kept class sizes small to com you know to try to see deling work the deling require smaller class sizes um so it it does come with an expense um and I'm wondering you know like I personally have not heard I've heard pretty universally negative feedback the people I talk to and maybe that's because I'm picking my own audience I try not to but that it's that the class sizes just are not the deleveling in the class sizes we're never going to get there we're never going to have class sizes of 15 to make deling work so at what point do we just kind of give up on that and

217get the class sizes you know have them go up a couple and you know so have some of the the class size at the high school get larger reduce some staff there so I'll let Joanie come to the microphone um and while she's going up I will say um we looked hard and you will actually see that we've actually reduced a number of general education teachers at the high school um where we looked at what are the school committee guidelines for class size and quite honestly in any place that it was under that we reduced staff and brought it to within the guidelines um so just to to speak to that I'll let Joanie speak to nuances of what's going on with that though yeah I think that's a really good um question I know

218that there has been a lot of talk recently about course leveling I think when you heard teachers ask for smaller class for course leveling that was in particular in the first few years to get used to the new curriculum and supporting students for next year we've programmed all of our class sizes between 22 and 24 and that has always been the CL plan with course leveling um so that teachers and all of our Support Services um academic support centers could get um acclimated to our new curriculum it it's going to take 5 to six years for the for everything to um be in a place where everyone feels comfortable with exactly what they're doing and so that was part of the evolution of of the process to keep class sizes smaller where we could um

219throughout the last 3 to four years but every year for the last three to four years that I've been here we have significantly cut teachers in the high school and um you know we've tried our best to support students especially in the more heterogeneously grouped classes and then you'll find that our honors classes because we still have quite a few levels um you know every class has at least two levels when you start to get up into Math and Science and then all of our 11th and 12th grade courses you'll find three levels um and and we think that that best meets the needs of students and I think that um over time we're going to be able to support the students in the best way and again it can take 5 to six years

220for all of that to work out I think what you will see is um a much less tracked system um so just the preliminary data in the first couple of years we've increased the number of students whove taken AP classes by 50% and our average is still in the fours you know the the scores are between one and five um you'll find from students that they really enjoy having you know more diverse sets of students in their class and opportunities and that's really the goal of course leveling is to provide more opportunities for students our students and our staff really do have the interest um ability and um we want to provide the resources and support for them you know the students to achieve as much as they can um I do want to acknowledge

221though that there's been a lot of talk recently about course leveling and I think we need to kind of dive into all the work that we've done at a very granular level at the high school and um we've done a lot of data collection and share that with public school committee students and families just to show where we are and then also figure out what we can do better and and to best support students but I do think that you'll find that we're trying to be as Ally responsible while supporting students and moving through this curriculum change thank you questions from boxboro yeah Andrew U thank you for the state it's really really good um just a quick question is there any way you could provide the an additional column for 2024 uh I don't

222know if you have to integrate it into this presentation but just so we can compare it yeah happy to um and maybe not to make work but 23 I think there was an FTE shift during that period so I don't know yeah I don't know if you've done if you recalculated 23 or not if you have that'd be great um but if we could have 23 24 and 25 that would be very helpful okay so definitely do 24 and let me look at sort of how we can try and convert some of the stuff for 20 to and to this level of detail this is really really helpful great appreciate it anything else from boxboro no acon select board hi Lissa hi um back to Nate levenson's smarter budget smarter schools book just want to

223preface this by saying I'm not operating under delusion that I'm an expert because I read one book um but I just wanted to make a couple of comments of elements that he had recommended there um so I'm not happy to see the elimination of stiens um for those programs um obviously Andrew I heard you say that we're still committed to those programs but without funding how are we going to um follow through um so lenson recommended increasing stiens as a way to save money because you're you're offering staff the opportunity to take on extra work for extra pay without having to create a position pay benefits for that position Etc um you know it wasn't just about special programs but it was about um you know offering stiens for staff to take on more challenging

224students or teach intervention sections or teach larger classes um I understand that that's going to involve uh collective bargaining but just I hope that that stays on the table for the future um also the increase to the sub budget I was surprised to hear that um there's a need for some certified folks and even psychologists so I'm wondering about levenson's um suggestion to bring in community Partners to provide services during the school day um you know in his list was nonprofit counseling centers Private Practice psychologists social workers colleges and universities that train those professionals substance abuse and addiction centers so you know getting creative about ways that the district can bring in services at a lower cost um and also there was a a suggestion to rethink contracts with collaboratives and so I'm hoping that

225we can find some savings in um that I know that's a little bit from the previous section of presentations thanks Greg did thank you um so Greg you had asked originally and I apologize because then someone asked a central office related question that I answered so it took me a minute um so the net reduction in staff coming into this year was 33.1 14 um that included though the addition of 27 or just about 27 positions in special education alone over a three-year period um and so you know the actual reductions from that period were 60.9 60.9 FTE um when you look at it including this year the total net ins and outs will be down 51.4 thanks Peter and how many of those are teachers versus assistants I know I don't have a quick

226way to pull that up for you I I knew you had this in your hip pocket all right thank you so I will go to question and comments from the public it's 11:43 I'm going to give us 10 minutes on this um I'm going to ask you all to sort of self police yourself in terms of how long you speak knowing that there may be other people behind you hi Mike hi I'll be quick um Mike balesu I'm I work at RJ gray I'm the president of the teachers union um I I just had a comment to make about elementary Vice principles because a member of the act and finance committee um raised that concern that we have in the past 10 to 15 years increased um Elementary School Vice principles and I hear that

227in my position too and I wanted to offer two thoughts about the value of having an assistant principle at each Elementary School number one um we added those positions more than 10 years ago partly to help with evaluations because the state changed the teacher evaluation system and um there was a significant amount of time um that was required to do that I think we'd all agree that making sure that evaluations are done in a way that's fair and thorough and constructive is good for students and for kids um the other important role I I think that has changed that Elementary Vice principles serve is is helping when we have incidents of disregulation um that or or incidents that require restraint now these are very polite terms that Mary used previously and for those who don't

228work in schools what we mean when we talk about restraints or we talk about disregulation is incidents where teachers are getting beat up um and and I want to be very blunt about that we're talking about situations where teachers are are having things thrown at them being bitten kicked punched um often that require medical treatment and so I think we'd all agree that it's really important when a teacher or other students are in physical danger um that when someone puts out a Mayday and they're walkie-talkie there is somebody um to receive that call on the other end and that's why I'm grateful that we have a vice principal at every elementary school thank you thank you hi John John Peterson 6 Jackson Drive there have been a number of questions you know that relate to

229longitudinal understanding uh of data so I would encourage you know future presentations where possible on each slide not to be restricted to a couple of years but to try and reach three or four years not back to covid that was you know a world of hurt all by itself um but to take the Long View of what's going on in the district with the budget um the K to2 regionalization was a wonderful thing for the school district in that anybody who goes back to end understands that that K2 regionalization allowed the district to build end um now I think that might have allowed budgeting to get a little bit soft and so there were things that you know in the end Were A Bridge Too Far which for example the uh professionalism of Library support

230um which everybody would argue is a great thing to do simply was no longer valuable enough to retain in the budget and I think Andrew's comment about targeted hiring everybody who's been through that hiring process has always struggled with you know should I spend more money to get a stronger candidate or should I bring in a weaker candidate uh and make the budget a little bit easier um we'll never in this room understand that value determination that needs to be made by the administration but it's critical to the long-term success of the district thank you thank you any other public comments I tip it hello I'll promise I promise I'll be briefer this time um I wanted to speak to um just the question about the stipend for different positions in the district I have

231been um in uh one of the culturally responsive teacher leader positions since that um position was created and so I have been one of the people who has received a stipend for that work for the past is it 3 or four years now yeah um and I want to speak to the fact that I well I do in the grand scheme of um the budget concerns I do see this as an area that it it could save some money for the district but I also do have concerns about how the district is going to continue to prioritize this work even with the stipends this year we've really struggled to maintain people in that position with as a culturally responsive teacher leader um there are I believe at every Elementary School we have at least one

232now even though we are hope to have two um we've struggled um at the junior high but especially at the high school um in retaining people in those positions um and the people who are in those positions who come to our monthly meetings have also expressed that it has struggled to be a priority within their buildings um and that different buildings are in very different places in what they're comfortable even talking about as a staff when it comes to culturally responsive teaching and learning um and what they're comfortable talking about with students and so while I don't disagree um with the proposal to eliminate those stipends for the budget I do think it's something the district needs to keep in mind about how are we actually going to continue this work and make it a

233priority for all staff and uh students in our classrooms thank you thank you okay um so we were supposed to have a break and I'm going to encourage anybody who needs to please stand up we've got committee members who do that all the time um go grab a break but we're going to continue um and we're going to sort of move forward into our deliberation of a preliminary budget um do we have a slide with yeah like do we have that ending do you have an ending slide so I I want to put up the the current preliminary budget number and then I also want to take a look at where we think we might be with additional Revenue that one doesn't help because it doesn't give us a number so on Spaces uh go

234can you go to budget uh slide 30 so we had a preliminary budget that was presented um at the last meeting by Peter and the beginning of this meeting of 116 m135 uh80 um my question for the committee knowing that we've got um a Governor's budget that's showing an additional amount of Revenue of about a half a million um from where that preliminary budget was where do we want to set our preliminary budget and I kind of talked about this before where that additional money is not a sure thing um and at some point we're going to have to um look at a number create assessments on it but we could very much well come back with additional Revenue that comes from the state and reduce our assessments keep our budget the same thoughts of

235the committee Tori so recognizing that um the governor's budget is we have recognizing that the governor's budget if it comes back with additional money for education is coming back because we know Chapter 70 and the way that we fund education is broken um I also think we have presented very very fair assessments to both of our towns I am 100% in favor of any additional Revenue that we have being dedicated towards education in this next year um I I would agree with that Adam I think that um it's important to keep in mind what Peter said in terms of community expectations that um what makes this a difficult decision is that that you know historically once we come up with a a number it doesn't increase so um you know it's it's very very difficult

236and challenging year in light of um you know quite frankly the um arson that's taken place potentially at the Federal Department of Education to go out on a little bit of a limb but at the same time um you know given the projections of increases at the state level for Chapter 70 and potentially um you know more money based upon the the estimates of the millionaires tax I I feel like I would rather make increases now and cuts later as opposed to you know just knowing that the percentage of people who are able to pay attention at this time um I I think it just it is just much more difficult to move in the other direction down the road sorry to be longwinded no worries viam uh I agree uh I agree with what's

237been said so far um I think I think we are looking at significant budget increases to some degree and I I'd rather raise raise things rather than cut and have it roll back to you know to the towns um I think I think it should go up a little bit if anything and I think we can certainly sustain that with what we see coming down the pipe other Lea I agree that I think it should be going towards education um I we are actively cutting the very priorities that we have set for our district um by engaging in some of these reductions um my other commentary is like I'll be working my ass off to get Chapter 70 increased But like everyone in this room very well could Advocate to their representatives and Senators um

238to also increase Chapter 70 and actually fund public education um we just passed the fair share Amendment which is constitutionally guaranteed towards public ad and transportation um and the governor has chosen to make Cuts in other places so um we could be doing more with the billions in Revenue that we have increased at the state level so I have this slide up here because it sort of shows where we're directionally looking at from the state of about 500,000 in extra revenues um but the flip side of that is the additional expenses that we're seeing so there's an increase in health insurance what we estimating right now the flexibility so that number 100 20,000 is kind of the difference between the additional revenues and the expenses that we're seeing in the budget yeah so we could

239we could vote to increase well we could vote to set our preliminary budget at a half a million dollars greater than the 16135 8 um and I guess my question is twofold one do we feel like that 120k is enough or do we want to go more and then secondly um what direction do we want to give the administration in terms of allocating the additional funds and I will share my opinion first and foremost which is I want to give them the most leeway to pick the things that are going to be most um influential in returning some of the losses that we've seen thoughts on that vicam I think uh any any money that's going back should be earmarked to in classroom student facing uh staff okay [Music] Tori question on the um potential

240Delta there is that looking at Senator Lewis's version or is that the governor's and so if it were 150 per student then what are we looking at it's just Governor's at 75 per student as I understood it so to your point and I is 120 the right number is 120 the right number because if we went up another 20 per student that's roughly 150,000 additional Above This 500k because we know at every $30 per student 150k additional in our budget so if it comes up from 75 to say 105 like it was last year there's another 150,000 that's going to come remind everybody particularly the finance committee members typically that money when we get it goes straight to R&D and R and and we can't use it and so part of The Proposal that I'm

241making is we are going to in advance assume that that we're going to get that money if we do I think we would write it in our verbiage that we would lower the assessments based on that but there's a potential that it wouldn't come in and so it would essentially raise the assessments to the towns um but I think we also need to figure out how we're going to form our vote now because our vote typically includes a breakdown of Assessments this 500k may not be part of what we've baked into our assessments to date so I think we we need to massage that a bit um but where I'm proposing is to say let's take the 500k let's assume an additional amount of Revenue beyond that assuming that the Chapter 70 funding goes up

242more we may have to put that on the backs of the Town assessments now but we codify in a vote that says any additional Revenue that comes in from the state beyond what we already know about goes to reduce assessments to the communities committee members thoughts on that thought on what number we want to increase by Adam if I may so the 500k the assessment does not change right now because the revenue goes up so the assessment is staying the exact same so it's the question of if you decide to go higher than that then that's when the assessment will be adjusted thank you Committee Member thoughts questions I see a question from a table behind you guys so e e e as to to the town of boxboro um that that those assessments would

243go up and and I know that we will have to go through town meeting and get that support through time meeting as well because we won't have that information by then either yeah I'm sorry I wouldn't follow up question when you say the I I get just about everything you're saying uh when you say the um if the um funding doesn't come through you'll have you'll reduce the assessments again that would be done in the Motions at each town meeting right it can't be done later than that right no if so what I'm proposing is that we set our budget today and that is always a not to exceed number yes and that that the budget that we set today and the assessments that we vote will be the high point and that any additional

244funding that comes in from the state even after town meeting goes to reduce assessments so we will have to revote our budget and like we've done in the past those budget rotes then also go to the two select boards to decide if you want to take action on that in call Town meetings um but there is no guarantee that that uh that the additional re comes in from the state and so there's no guarantee that that money gets taken off the assessments to the towns I I understand now so you you would reduce your budget after the start of fiscal 26 we'd keep our budget the same we would reduce our assessments because we would see additional revenue from State I got it yes thank you and I I'll look around to sort of other

245folks does that does that make sense are you following where we're at on that Kristen um I didn't identify myself before sorry Kristen hillberg chair the select board in boxboro so hi everybody um I just I just want to point out that box Pro is already a little surprised to find out that our assessment was going up to 5.25% we understand it we don't love it um I think just definitely be aware that we already have a concern about our budget number so anything you can do to keep us appr pris as quickly as possible we understand you're dependent on outside forces but but we're really keeping an eye on all this and I'm not sure how supportive we'll be of anything more than 5.25 I'm I'm concerned because we went to the finance committee

246we expressed to them where we were our situation and the guidance we got from finance committee was no greater than 6% so I I'm kind of confused where the surprise is coming from because I'm also sitting in your meetings and where we've been forecasting this even as early as last year enrollment changes are are are driving the increase in the boxboro assessment and so you know I think where we're at is we got direction of 6% we came in at 5.25 I'm I'm well aware of sort of the the tight spot that boxboro is in right now and all of the priorities that are there but you know I guess part of what gave me confidence and bringing this to the board was that there was some you know potential room between what we were

247asked to deliver and what we ended up delivering I I think it's um as we've had our budget Saturday our Capital Saturday we're looking at our numbers and fine tuning and we've made significant cuts to be able to you know we were thrilled when you came in five and a quarter please know that um it's just that we were further down our budget and are looking at what's coming to town meeting so again just very concerned understanding finance committee gave you a a limit I'm telling where the select board is and I don't know if prya wanted to that no um just like you you guys are also looking at like what how things are changing things have changed in our end too so we really hope that it doesn't escalate up too much because

248we are concerned about how it'll go in the town meeting that's all thank you thank you John's turn just going to pass the mic over here so um we don't know how this money would be used correct not yet no okay well I I would say John that the direction is that the money be used for student serves in the that we signicant Cuts in and have been for the P few years so I mean in the spirit of where we are from a affordability perspective does it make sense to spend this money when we just don't have it yet I mean it's just doesn't isn't this communicating uh yeah I mean I think that is the friction between the town boards and the school committee and I think I speak for the school committee

249and they they can chime in we've made significant Cuts over the past four years and I think what we've been presented with this year is a budget that's untenable and so we have we we are charged with balancing the ability of the towns to pay and the requirement to educate our students and I feel like both personally and probably from the perspective of the board we have we have bent too far in that direction and at some point through no fault of our own and no fault of the towns right I think that's the overarching message as well is that these funding systems are broken but at some point we've gone too far and so I think what you're seeing is us saying this budget I agree with everything you're saying but so there is

250this half a million dollar sitting out there it's just your treatment of it is is my concern right it's it's not here yet so yeah I and and I think though the data has shown that every year that money it comes does come in there's a and we can't do anything with it and where it ends up going is the end which is an important fund to rebuild but it doesn't provide student sa facing Services committee members vicam yeah as a representative of box bro I mean we've seen Draconian Cuts year upon year upon year on the school district and that directly affects property values right in in and around boxboro right I know we need new fire station all this kind of stuff but we're not talking like a lot we did say 6%

251you know I realize numbers change on your side as well but 6% was a thing we're not talking a lot more here at this point right and we do see that the data does show that generally you do get slightly more and we don't know we' had like Draconian Cuts year upon year upon year so we can like mitigate that a little bit it' be nice if we all work together in that direction all right I want to just a couple more Committee Member comments um I do want to keep this moving forward so I was just gonna ask to look at um real numbers do we know what the assessments would increase if we did add in the um I think we're talking about 620,000 total right because we're talking about the 500 plus

252yes so I'm I'm going to have Peter sort of walk us through for those who've not seen this before this is the infamous table six this is the crazy calculation that we use to get both our budgets and then the assessments to the towns um so Peter can you walk us through what you've got uh so far in here all right so just because I think sometimes without anchoring in in seeing the numbers it's it's hard to understand what we're talking about um so the number here the the total District budget in this version which is line 25 that you can see it's in yellow um totally absd appropriation this is now 116 6411 164 Sherry in preparation for the meeting because at the last school committee meeting we had a preliminary conversation about this

253and how you wanted to treat the additional potential state revenue um so she planned this in and said all right at if I increase by the projected revenues in the governor's budget what does that do to the budget it does not change the assessments it changes the District budget upward by that projected Revenue she also had to account for some increased expenses um some of which we know she also built in some initial placeholders and unemployment insurance she increased uh because we believe that's going to be a potential liability I think potentially health insurance um she had to account for the additional Gap in health insurance between what we projected and what Maya was telling us was the reality so that budget got increased to 116 6411 164 the state revenues were accounted for that

254has no change on the two assessments which are down here all right um ultimately you know I think what's important for the two communities to understand is from a a budgetary perspective once school committee votes your assessments if there's a shortfall on the state revenue that becomes the school committee's problem to solve it doesn't become the town's problem uh because the school committee can't increase its appropriated budget it can decrease its appropriated budget um and it can adjust for things inside the budget um but it's not that at that point it's not putting an additional liability on the towns to incorporate the additional Revenue um from the governor's budget proposal um I think that you know once you add in additions and EXP expenses um from a revenue perspective it probably gives the school committee

255about $120,000 total of flexibility um for the 500 and something additional Revenue we're seeing so that's a pretty modest amount of flexibility it does not restore much in in what we're talking about but it's certainly you know I think 120 is better than zero I think would be my perspective um but just to to make sure we're seeing the actual numbers up and and what the impact is I think is important thanks Peter Jenny I just want to clarify um you know based on the input that we've we've received if the coordinator is considered because I think we've heard that it is a student facing position um that that's something that is still you know within the flexibility that would be um gaining with $120,000 I mean I think the the point would be that

256we find the additional funding for the district and we tell them to come back to us with what they believe is the most um influential use of that funding yeah I I think from a process perspective you know um I'm not prepared today to give you recommendations about what I do think should come back you know I I wanted to outline we have a preliminary and then we'll come back with a recommended ultimately the school committee can adjust that but between today and what we come back with for our recommendation um I would like to be able to meet with the administrative team we obviously hear your feedback we hear Community feedback um but we've heard you know concern conerns not only about the special ed coordinator but we've heard concerns about the reduction in

257Reading assistance um and we heard significant concern there we've heard concerns about the reduction on general education classroom assistants we've heard concerns expressed about specialist reduction um you know we're we're hearing concerns just about everything and so I I want to make sure that I don't get caught with whatever I hear Last becomes what I would want to commit to so um I just want to be thoughtful about that process but we certainly would bring something back in the next iteration yeah my question was just around like when we say they'll come back to us who is the they um because I what I think even just today hearing a disconnect maybe between like folks who are in the classroom and folks who are in administration and not that both perspectives aren't important um but

258when we say they like are the are the um like educator round tables that were happening still happening like are there opportunities to hear what uh the folks who are closest to our students are also saying about some of these positions and I understand that people are going to advocate for all of them because at this point we're cutting into really important things um but is that going to be part of the process to bring a another iteration back you know I I think one of the challenging pieces um I think that we certainly can I think what we're hearing from community and educators is that when something becomes closest to them that tends to be a priority and I'm not discounting that any of them are important right like I I actually think that

259everything you've heard no one takes time out of their Saturday or at 7 o'clock on a Saturday night to come and talk to something because it's not actually important um right like it has to rise to a level of value that it's serious and so we're hearing that the challenge is going to be any group that we hear from we're going to hear a subset of of someone and so that has to be taken into account we have to to think about what the overall impact of that is um because even if I bring it to an educator Round Table that's still only going to be 20 Educators across a district that will see that um so I I we we can think about that I'm going to be honest that I'm a little hesitant

260to do that because I think no matter what we do with that it's going to have some skew to it and I think that you know I also want to make sure that what we can really talk to principles about this because they're the ones that have to make sure all of this works in the end and you know I I have to trust that perspective on it me my question is based on an answer to this so if we didn't do anything it would go into end is what what you're saying right if we don't do anything and the money comes in it goes to e and D okay so here is my my thought but last year we asked for an override this year we are asking for something that really does not

261solve any problem it's just doesn't even scratch the surface of the problems we're facing so let's go through the pain and then come back for kind of solving the problem of this year after year H being in this mod in a bigger way rather than everybody every year we feel like the town boards are feeling the pressure from school school committee this this is 120,000 doesn't take us anywhere here yeah I I mean I I hear what you're saying and and that's part of our our the rest of our conversation this afternoon is what do we do in the long term but I also feel like what we're seeing today is detrimental enough that you know it's it's much harder to bring somebody back in after a year they've left we've got excellent Educators and

262Specialists throughout our district and we're talking about letting them go and the cost of acquiring that skill and that level of of knowledge on our district is very expensive so if we can save two positions that are um you know extremely impactful that you know that's something that we should consider and yes we need to do the bigger thing too I just want to make sure clarify one yeah please um from the the perspective of whether or not to incorporate the governor's Revenue it's not just what do we gain out of it but we also we have to incorporate another $400,000 of expenses um and so if we don't use any of that PO potential Governor's Revenue what we would want to do between now and the recommended budget is make another $400,000 in reductions

263to Staffing um to compensate so you know it's yeah there's the prospect that maybe it could benefit us by 120 but we're trying to actually avoid having to reduce another you almost half a million dollars so I'll ground Us in the numbers just one more time the the 116 614 4164 you see on the on the screen there that incorporates the additional revenue from the governor's budget um it also incorporates what we see is the roughly 400,000 in costs that have come up since the preliminary budget was presented there is that about 120 in excess um that may or may not remain once we get more expenses lined up and what I'm asking for proposing is an additional 150,000 on top of that um that would account for potential additional Revenue when the St comes

264in with their final number and that's the 150,000 that is the risk if we get it we take it off the assessments if we don't it does have to go to the towns and it has to go through honestly it will go through town meeting assessed to the towns because we won't know by that point and so I you know I've heard the concern of the of the um Town boards and committees I really want to get a number proposed from the school committee um and get a preliminary budget voted um like I said we have a member who needs to leave we just barely have the quorum to make that vote right now um so I'm looking for a feedback from the committee and B um if we're happy with that we've got uh

265do you all have motion language on the table in front of you we can put the information up to fill in the blank so thoughts from the committee Tori and then Liz from the perspective of just thinking big picture B budget model um didn't come up as we were talking about the excluded debt coming off but as I understand it this is a 3% increase in operating budget so when you think about us being responsible in terms of prop two and a half two and a half% plus New Growth that's that's kind of what we think about right so if there's additional funding coming in from the governor it's because they recognize they are not giving us enough in what towns are able to pay they recognize that the cost of education is going up

266higher than what we're getting from the state to support it and that's why I think it's important for it to be in the operating budget and not in end because we're talking about end as onetime use so 100% agree with it what do you need me to say here to put this motion on the table Let's uh let's hear from Liz and then we'll uh uh I'm also in agreement with this I think we're at the point where we absolutely need to be hedging right now and um what I did want to highlight if you can just scroll down a little bit I while I don't love it I am comfortable particularly as a box ball resident with the 5.25 going up to 5.41 we're still more than 50 basis points underneath the requirements that

267we were provided we're still under 2% for act and I like these numbers to be honest I don't like them but I am comfortable with these bonus for bringing basis points to the conversation thank you all right so um what I'm what I'm presenting in front of you is 1167 91164 would be our preliminary budget at an increase of 2.11% % and then uh an actin number would actin assessment would be 79959 269 an increase of 1.12% and a box Bor assessment of 16824 370 at an increase of 5.41% did I get that right yes yes so and and for more clarity what that is asking of the two communities is roughly and I'm going on an 8020 rough split it it's asking about $120,000 more from the town of Acton right now on the

268assessment and 30,000 more from the town of boxboro on that assessment and I think though what I heard you also say is that if we get additional state revenue the school committee would then vote to amend the assessments back down to the previous level that had been proposed is that am I understanding what it said okay trying to track it you're making things complicated Sher because you're the numbers person if you're going over right now you're going over 150,000 yes so the revenue from the governor's budget would have to be over the 150 in order for the assessment any additional Revenue over the governor's preliminary budget would go to reduce the assessment well up to to get the assessments back to where they were I well so what I think I think the intention of

269what you said was what we want to do is try if there's additional revenue from the state it would first get applied to reduce the town assessments back to the levels that originally proposed with a 3% budget increase I I was under the assumption that if after that there were additional state revenue that would then be able to flow to end so if they went beyond 105 per student that would that would flow to and D correct that that's what I thought you meant but I that's why I want to clarify for this group that's yeah that's my feeling I I have a committee in front of me what do you guys think nod heads does that make sense okay vicam um is it possible to go up from like 150 say 160 170 or

270180 because I mean 30,000 for box BR how much is a new police cruiser in box row on the order of what half a million something like that I I'll answer that I mean my my concern knowing where boxboro is at is that they're very very close to the understand in we need to be highly respectful of where we get to that I in box I I know so I I think that say 30 to 35,000 I think if we can go marginally that you know I'm just asking whether that's a possibility we can do whatever we want personally I wouldn't support it any other committee members feelings on that none all right I'm GNA do this I am uh I would like to if give me a sec is there a motion that the

271total budget of acting boxb Regional School District for fiscal year July 1 2025 through June 30th 2026 be preliminarily set at6 m791 1064 an increase of 2.11% and that the budget be funded by member towns to be preliminar preliminarily assessed in accordance with the education reform law and the terms of the regional agreement and amendments theto as follows Acton 79 million 95926 an increase of 1.12% and boxboro 16 Milli 824375 an increase of 5.41% offset by end Reserve use of zero um with the remainder accounted for by other sources of revenue Vues and reserves to be detailed in the final budget additionally any any additional Revenue o uh from the state up to the $150,000 we've just added to our budget be applied to reduce the Two Towns assessments second Leela made the mo Leela

272made the motion she moved my motion and Tori seconded it um we have a different way of voting this budget number so it's a majority of the members from each Town um so all those in favor please say I I I is there any opposed are there any abstentions it is unanimous and we do have a majority of members from both towns so thank you we've set the number um Beth may need to go back to the video to actually capture all the language of the motion um thank you for that we are not done um so I would like to take a f minute break which will inevitably turn into 10 um and we need to come back to talk about what lakmi was talking about which is what the heck do we do

273next because this is not going to work year after year after year and we've got a little bit of discussion on that now so let's take 5 minutes and then we'll come back thank you e e e okay I'd like everybody to come back to the tables we've got a really important discussion next around how do we do this in the future years okay uh we've got all our committee members back at the table um you know we did take some stuff out of order um and what we did take out of order was sort of an open questions um an answer period and then deliberation um we get we did get some feedback from the the towns as we were doing our deliberation um the next and last part of our day uh is

274to look at Beyond FY 26 so um for those of you who are here in the back um my intention is not to sort of open this up to public conversation just yet this is really sort of a pre-workshop for the committee to talk about how do we how do we move Beyond FY 26 um because the com the presentations and the conversations we just had um feel like we've had them for the past four years and we need to make um for lack of overusing the term even more structural changes um so that we can be um we can we can last so Peter I'm GNA hand it over to you to sort of start this conversation so this probably a good number of people in the room who have heard the the this

275idea of vuka um and it's an acronym that was developed in the 1980s by a couple of economists that have has actually been applied in numerous settings um and including widely adopted by the military to understand um kind of situations on the ground and what's happening um and it talks about this concept of volatility uncertainty complexity and ambiguity and as far as education goes we are living right in squarely in the middle of all of this right now where we don't know what's happening um changes are rapid unpredictable um and I think we're seeing that in the educational landscape right now there's uncertainty we don't have all of the information available to us um there's complexity where everything we're talking about here is interconnected somehow um and it's I've made that analogy earlier in the

276day about you know pulling on the string and seeing how the ball unravels um and then ambiguity we we there's a lot of different ways of looking at the same set of data and interpreting it differently um to come to different understandings and it's making how we make decisions increasingly complex but I think one thing we have seen over the last few years is we're really in a new pattern of Education spending where there are fewer and fewer resources there's declining enrollment there's increasing student need and this is not just act and box bro this is happening across the entire United States right now um in every school district in the country um where we're actually seeing fewer students and there's higher student needs um and so the students that remain have much more critical

277needs than what we had seen 10 15 and even 20 years ago and so you know I think what we're hearing in this budget and I I remember hearing this from the educator Roundtable we've talked about this with our principles is we're getting to a place where there's just fewer and fewer places left to uce um and I think that's you know becoming increasingly frustrating so just to this is going to be much more of a discussion with the group than it is a presentation I only have a couple of slides but enrollment over the next three years alone is at the elementary level I call down 14 students pretty stable because we're talking of a cohort of 2500 students um we do intend to see decline at the junior high school by about 75

278students over the same three-year period and at the high school it's only about five students down so this is not the eight-year Outlook I previously showed you this is just the next few years um student needs there's some uncertainty around this um will our multilingual population continue to grow at the rapid rate that it's grown over the last four years or do we expect a shift around that but regardless we're not meeting the needs of our students now um and we need to figure out a way to better meet student needs um our low-income student population um has rapidly increased over the last 5 to 10 years um will that change probably not um I feel a little more certain that that's going to continue to grow um our students with disabilities we've seen a

279slight increase but quite honestly historically we're pretty stable and at the same time as having an overall stable number of students with disabilities in the district um the needs have become significantly more intensive um and require a different thinking about services so that's another element of the landscape um is what do our students need in terms of expenses um you know wages um you know if you look at historic inflation and what's happened with teacher salaries teacher salaries adjusted for inflation have actually been largely flat from about 20 years ago um and they have not seen a significant increase in wages and I'm going to you know and I say this knowing we're headed into negotiations in a year um and and having to be realistic about what the market landscape looks like in terms

280of salaries um you know we you know a few years ago um settled contracts we don't know what the future contracts will look like but if I project the current cost of living that we've had for the last two years out into the future our Personnel costs are going to continue to increase just over 5% it's about five and a quarter percent a year that we're increasing Personnel costs um if we're not making reductions um so that's a reality of it and that 5 and a quar per is you know an $80 million base of our budget um that is the largest single budget driver that we have that's increasing at a 5% rate right now the other significant driver that's almost a$2 million driver for us is health insurance and I am not a

281health insurance expert I don't know what the long-term outlook for the health insurance industry is but I do know um that our team connected with Maya um early when we learned about the 14 almost 15% um rate increase and they said next year plan for the same thing or potentially slightly more um and we are not going to be able to realize another $600,000 of savings from run out claim either run out claims or opt outs because that's that's now taken credit for and that's gone so what's the impact of that um utilities costs have been escalating at a rate that we can't keep up with over the last few years um and then we have Capital needs and the cost of doing business in capital is just significantly higher now than it was 5

282years ago um it really makes it look like when we did that original $75 million Bond at a 1% interest rate there's huge avoided money um that that we were able to realize um by by bonding that Capital up front um so you know realistically and I plugged this in we developed a multi-year model with uh participation with both Finance committees last year so I plugged a lot of these costs into the multi-year model um and I increased basically everything else in the budget at 2% um and that comes out to between five and a quarter and five and a half percent a year of a budget increase annually in order to just maintain the services that we're proposing out into the future um that is not a sustainable model I recognize that's not sustainable

283in the midst of Community Resources it's not sustainable um anywhere else State funding you know we have to just keep on the state to try and try and help out with this but there's limited resources everywhere and costs are going up um I don't know what's going to happen in terms of federal funding um in the future I it's just it's really unclear right now and I don't think there's anyone who could predict exactly what's going to happen with that um State funding um you know we can hope um and I think there's more traction now than I've seen over the last few years to to take another look at what Chapter 70 funding looks like um but that's uncertain as well so given all of that I think you know and I had this

284at the footer of a slide earlier I actually think maybe some of us in the community we've been talking past each other a little bit on this idea of structural change because there's two levels of structures that we can talk about I think one level of structures is what are the structures inside the system we have now that we can look at and shift we've done health insurance we've done you know we've really looked hard at class sizes we've looked hard at how we fund different elements of our staffing and Personnel budget including assistance mtss we're talking about school schedules at the elementary level um and how do we make all of those adjustments there's another type of structural change though that we also we started to talk about last year because I think there

285were some calls in the community of saying close coning and you know I want to name that that was there I did not come back and recommend it one we were looking at increasing enrollment um in last year's nesda projection so we could probably add that to the list of uncertainty too um but I think you know the more I think about it I actually have to really wonder if we're going to be able to sustain the current overall system of organization of our schools that we've had uh because if we tried to run everything the way we're doing it now with six elementary schools a junior high and a high school um quite honestly we're not going to get 5 a half% budget over the next few years it's just not going to happen

286um and so at what is the Tipping Point where we no longer have the resources to spread out in as many places and we actually have to think about becoming a smaller district and you know I don't take that lightly um I still don't believe there should be any dialogue in saying we're closing the Conant Elementary School that that's not a useful and productive dialogue for a couple of reasons and the first reason that I think it's unproductive is I actually think it's a limiting option because it actually just inherently in saying we're closing one school actually discounts a complete broader perspective on reorganization and what that could look like we organize the schools today the way we do them because the community 50 and 30 years ago made decisions about how they wanted their

287schools organized um and moving forward based on the res resources of the community and the interests of the community at the time that's good that should happen we now have a different set of student needs we have a different Community than we had 30 and 50 years ago um and if we think we need to get smaller we should not start with pick one school and close it we actually should start with who is our community what are the needs of our students what are the resources of the community and what are the systems of organization that we might explore that are as responsive as possible to all three know knowing that no matter what we do there's some inherent trade-off and I can also tell you the second reason is it's just a divisive

288way of approaching how we would do things in our community if I pulled any one of our six elementary schools and said right now based on last year's discussion of closing coent would you close an elementary school to have greater resources than all the other schools five communities would say absolutely do it and one would say don't do it if I changed the wording and inserted a different school name five communities would say yes do it and one would not um and it's a really predictable outcome that we're going to end up in and it's going to end up dividing the community in ways that I actually just don't think are productive so I think that you know what I would suggest is if we're actually going to be talking about do we need to

289get smaller or more efficient somehow or think differently we actually need to be thinking about a reorganization as opposed to just picking something we're going to shut down um I think it's a a healthier topic there are actually a whole variety of ways that communities choose to organize schools um Nate levenson looked at this a lot um in his work here particularly around school choice and what he ended up saying is because of the way we control class size across the district we are one of the most efficient models of doing business he didn't say you are the most efficient model of doing business he said you are one of the most efficient models of of of doing business there are other ways than communities do it including other communities that are high performing care

290deeply about their kids want what's best um and have limited resources right um we're not the only ones in the world experiencing this problem and so I think the the I'm talking a lot but the question I actually am posing to to the committee and really it's a community question is do we want to have to continue to try and run the current organization on fewer and fewer resources that become thinner and thinner where we get more and more frustrated with each other because we're not meeting the needs of our kids and families um and making our Educators work harder or do we have to really take some time do some inflection and talk about is it time to think about organizing ourselves differently and if so what's the best way to organize our schools

291for the next 30 Years not the last 30 years um so that's kind of where I would end um I don't think that any of this is realistic for next year I'm not proposing that this is an FY 26 change I think they you know our additional um there's two paths one I think the earliest you would make any change like this is FY 27 so fall of 2026 would be the earliest you could do something because you would have to you know launch something pretty much now be planning for an entire year and coming back probably like next December January and making some recommendations that then you plan for during the second semester to implement um you have kindergarten registration you have all those other things that get impacted the latest I mean we

292could go we could take six years and study it if we want but in those six years we're going to just keep budgeting two $2 million less um and so you could go maybe out to FY 28 and have an another additional planning year just knowing that in the interim there's going to be fewer resources at our disposal to to bridge that Gap so um you know I I I'm not sure that we're going to get significant Revenue not to make up the Gap that we have I know that this idea of efficiency has not been well received in our community and I get it I really do but I I and I feel badly being the superintendent right now but quite honestly if we're not more efficient we're not trying to tighten things up

293we're just giving up that we're going to have whole swas of kids that aren't going to get any Services as opposed to serving students the best that we have the resources for so the question really is is it time to think about reorganization what what would that look like and how would we consider all of that thanks Peter um you know we we went earlier this week to a really interesting Workshop um and and learned from other school leaders from around the nation uh and we we went through some case studies and talked about things and I want to do just a bit of an experiment um think back 10 years ago can I see a show of hands 10 years ago how many people subscribed to a New York Times product either the newspaper

294or any of their other items all right now can I see a show of hands how many people subscribe today to a New York Times product Wordle wire cutter so slightly more if you think about 10 years ago New York Times was a print product they were making newspapers and they were sending them out to people's houses and they came through a time of volatility where print was dying and things were becoming digital um and they made a very significant shift to move from a print first supporting a digital product to a digital first product that supports their their print um a a really big change and I'm sure if you were a New York Times subscriber or you were in The Newsroom at New York Times and your print job went away um it

295was really really hard for you but they are a stronger company now they increased their revenue by I think 500 million um because of the pivot that they made at that time um and so when I think about where we are we're we're at a point where we need to make a pretty strong change um we're going to need to upset a lot of people probably um and I speak as a Committee Member who gets lots of emails from unhappy individual constituents the process that we're looking at is is not going to be an easy one um and I know that it's hard to receive those emails so you know I I know that we have a um we scheduled a budget or sorry we've scheduled a workshop a visioning workshop um for the the

296school committee in April so we're going to get through the budget and then we're going to talk about this a little bit more in depth in a workshop um but what I'd love to hear from the committee in particular is what are your thoughts what's your appetite for doing something that's significant Jenny has no appetite which is fine because she's done at the end of this year um but you know what what are what are your thoughts in terms of what you've heard from Peter and and what you've heard earlier today lakmi I think given that we're boxed in um at with the prop two two two and a half and the town budgets and the fact that people support the community support schools majorly I think we have to do we have no other

297choice and I think Peter summarized it very well uh we have to realize that education is model has changed for people who are comparing like oh 20 years ago we spent this much per student now we are we're spending a lot more in even counting for inflation I think it's the model that has changed so with the model should come the adjustments to the model you can't have both ways have the old way of organization and incorporating new because who's going to pick up the cost and I think that's the page and I I like the I think I'm fully supportive of uh anything that doesn't hurt the kids but pain is okay otherwise thanks lien that vam um I agree I have an appetite for this as well especially since this is what we're

298kind of hearing from our communities is that this is is the type of action that they're looking for I would say that I tend to desire sort of quicker like planning so that we can verbalize you know by 2027 you know and at least have a preliminary plan to be able to deliver to our communities and I would not recommend like wait drawing it out too long if that makes sense y VI um so I I have some concerns there if just a few things so one is um like the way that people were learning say in the 70s right there were no computers right we got pencils and paper right what kids actually have to learn about just to make it in today's world is just exponentially more than what it was in say

299the 1970s right and we're not really keeping Pace we're seeing that on par salaries for teachers are the same now as they were back in the 70s essentially right um so that's a big thing and I think there has to be like a Great Awakening of the fact that the education that students have to receive today is is much much much greater than it what has been in the past right um the other thing is this prop two and a half I think people have to realize that just the cost of living and inflation increase has been greater than two and a half since prop two and a half was implemented right I think the towns need to sort of realize the importance of Education in our community and the fact that 2 and a

300half just simply does not cut it and has not cut it since that's been put in place now as far as efficiency my concern is this restructuring I'm all forward if it's sort of a long-term solution but I'm not convinced that this this restructuring of things is actually going to address this fundamental lack of Revenue that seems to be consistently hitting us right I think the state is also realizing this we're seeing on the front page uh right of the Boston Globe that you know now the State House is actually saying okay well we have to reevaluate this but you know we don't know how far that's going to go and then lastly there's sort of a domino effect right of this new Administration right like healthcare now is predicted to go up 14% this

301year and probably the same next year we're also seeing that this new Administration is very open to allowing wealthy corporations buy things and so I think we can expect Healthcare to go up significantly more we can also see they're trying to deconstruct the Department of Education so Federal funding is also going to come into play and how that's affecting us so there are all these moving factors and I'm all for restructuring if if we are going to see substantial long-term change that will benefit and I'm not entirely convinced that these you know efficiency changes and mind you I was on this on this committee that was that was looking at this and reassessing everything I'm not entirely convinced that that those changes are going to provide the long-term changes and and address our budget in

302the long term that we actually need them to but but other than that I'm all for it yeah and I I think that um you know what we're saying is the efficiency is not going to work and it requires the greater reorganization um so yeah I mean I I agree with you the efficiency we've been through efficiency for the past four years now and it's done nothing but so Division and and reduce outcomes um so that's you know why we're proposing something bigger um which is a reorganization Leila yeah I think it's responsible of us to consider this I'm also just calling us into consider like what capacity building needs to happen for the committee in order for us to make an informed decision about some of these impacts um because in this moment yeah

303I just I think there's some capacity building that could happen in it's a great point and and I would say it's not just on the committee but it's on the community as a whole um and I think that we as a a school committee and the administration support in us um have learned a lot over the past I would say five years about how to run a process like that if you think about some of the processes of change that we've gone through um since the pandemic through to our last one in terms of Elementary budget you know we've we've improved that process there's always room for more Improvement um but it does require capacity building not just at the committee level it requires consideration of what the process is and who are the stakeholders

304and how do you bring them along on this journey because I will tell you right now looking at all the people people in the room we don't have a lot of Elementary parents in the room and there's probably a lot of people who might be affected by a reorganization in that constituency um so I yeah I would agree with you Tori I would I'm in that's probably a great surprise um I think probably one of the most satisfying things I've done thus far school committee wise is is participating in the elementary budget task force and as hard as the first 40 minutes of that meeting presenting it was I still walked out of there believing that we as a community did something important and we did it together and we did it in a way

305that was constructive and people listened to each other and hearing everybody responding to the survey and saying somebody in that room made me change my mind about something I think it is really important to continue to build on those strengths if we look at doing a process like that um I have two two things that worry me one is you we can't we can't turn this thing on a dime as much as I would like to turn everything on a dime I acknowledge that doesn't happen um so looking at what's we know we're going to run into the same situation next year so what is what's the the stop Gap measure on the way and then two the risk of putting all our eggs in one basket um I think we all expected something different

306to come out of the Open Enrollment conversation um for the elementary budget task force and when it didn't pan out that way um that became really difficult and so as we're all looking at this and having expectations I think we need to we need to temper those expectations with things may not work out the way we expect them to if this is the route we take um but yeah I'm in I I want to challenge you on the turn on a dime why why can't we I mean what's the what's the alternative I guess would be my question okay so I'm just going to acknowledge that given my background I am used to having to make decisions very very fast in a way that I have been reminded by many people in this room education

307does not move at that pace yeah I I just you know I think we have to we have to recognize that and and government doesn't move at that pace or we're on a two-year legislative cycle but the alternative and this is kind of the challenge that I want to put to both the committee but then also the community as they feel like we may be rushing this what is the alternative what's at stake if we don't act quickly um so you know I heard from Liz Liz is like yeah let's let's do this tor's game I'm curious from other committee members talked about capacity building you know it might be good to start talking now but what what do we think's our timeline when do we want to be able to implement a reorganization can

308I just say that you know just building on Leela's Point um and and what you said is parents of elementary school students are home with their young kids who can't be left alone so you know in terms of capacity building or you know getting the input we need from the people who are going to be most directly impacted perhaps um as well as as Educators with young children who also are very big stakeholders in this process I think we need to think about some structures for allowing participation um of of the broadest segment of the community as we possibly can if especially if we're going to move fast or you are yes uh no I agree and and I think the other constituency are those people who don't have kids in school who are facing

309budget constraints I think that oftentimes we're talking past each other right my kids need this my budget can't support this and there those are two separate groups so I recognize that please jeny just to that um you know two things um one I have your last meeting circled on the calendar and we're scheduling the vote for that night um just to make sure you have an opportunity to weigh in uh but no in all seriousness um I think you know we've tried to look at two things this year in our planning processes um one and we talked about this with the elementary budget task was looking at the composition of a group and the other thing we looked at was the Cadence of the work that has to take place this it might actually be

310something like on the elementary budget task force we didn't take you know a whole year to study this we actually did it in five meetings um with support obviously but it was a five meeting process to get to something but those were two-hour meetings there's also opportunities to say look we need a group of people's time for two solid days right and and you plan it up but you know there's a finite commitment and you actually condense a planning process you need to then send that out for feedback and proc proc and everything else but there are different cadences I think that could be played with in addition to making sure that we have the mix of people in a process um I think you know I think the elementary budget task force process from

311a committee level perspective was one thing that could be looked at and and tweaked based on what we've learned and the other part of the process that I think we could to to go back to is thinking about like uh the visioning for the boardwalk campus and the level of community engagement around that and the support that it garnered I think there's opportunities to merge those two ideas Leela um as we think about like infrastructure for capacity building for engagement for communication um I'm also just wanting us to keep in mind like what funding might be necessary to do the thing and if it's like a one-time thing is an earmark and opportunity um as we're already engaging the state house around Chapter 70 we should start talking to them now about it but yeah

312yeah um I I want to kind of name one thing as we talk about capacity building and bringing community in um we we no longer have a quorum of our own school committee um and it it worries me and we've had several conversations about the committee and you know I I I see both sides of this right we all have very busy lives we have you know activities that go on we have illnesses that come up that we can't attend um but at the same time something like this is not going to be successful unless we have the engagement of a full committee um and so I think one of the things that the committee we need to look hard at particularly in a workshop is how do we bring everybody who's at our table

313make sure that they're engaged and make sure that because this is not going to be like a budget uh an elementary budget task force where we have a couple people they do the work they come back they report and we do something we're going to have constituencies left and right day and night coming to us um and so I think that we have to have a plan and recognize that um if we're going to move forward with it as well because I I just worry that um you know if there's a core group of people who are working on this that's important but everybody needs to be engaged and we definitely have differing levels of Engagement for all sorts of reasons on our committee I see some comments behind us any other feedback from the

314committee Greg I totally agree with what you're doing and I compliment you for tackling the hard problem early one of the things that I guess I can recommend or suggest or offer is if you see this as a school committee challenge you will always have a trouble communicating it to the broader Community if we all see this as a community challenge then guess what there are board members here from other committees who also understand that we're all in this boat together so one of the things as you start thinking about structural changes is one of the classic structural changes that we've been trapped in or the silos of oh there's the school side there's the town side um and there are situations where boy it would be interesting to see if I'm going to just

315share one meeting I went to last week that the library Board of Trustees was holding trying to Envision their future and one of the things that they see again and again and again are teenage te coming to the library to study wow well pardon me at what point is that part of your educational solution they also see a lot of preschoolers coming to the library for activities they're looking at creating a messy room where that might be uh a more engaging thing wow you know how does that intersect with what the schools are also interested in encourag you know in in accomplishing so we may find that you're not alone in that other groups in town are trying to solve similar problems thanks um you know I I would agree well first of all I

316would disagree I think we're coming late to the game this is probably something we should have um brought forward sooner um and I recognize that but there is this sort of entrenchment of how you've been operating it's hard to break out that um but I would agree that this is not going to be just a school committee problem or challenge or you know Workshop or or activity to to work on it does need to include both towns and I will say it right here and now this may be also a great opportunity to relook at the regional agreement to look at the composition of how we assess Towns at how we create our Comm our committee makeup maybe there are other communities nearby that are interested in solving some of their budget challenges by joining

317a region all of those things need to be on the table and need to be considered um and so I think that there's there's in doing this we kick off a lot of opportunity um but we also kick off a lot of possibility for feedback good bad and indifferent on that so um like I said this was just the beginning um I wanted to take this opportunity to sort of take off where Peter left on the previous preliminary budget discussion um to bring it to the committee but also take advantage of having some other community leaders in the room to have it broadcast C on AC and TV so everyone can go back and play back to me the fact that I said I wanted to open the regional agreement because I'm sure I've got

318some neighbors who are going to be unhappy with that um we are going to have a workshop on April 3D the school committee about this um and for those of you who have been coming to me on the school committee about hey we need to really talk about the calendar we need to talk about this that or the other thing you can see why we've sort of been collecting those because there may be something bigger that we need to to deal with um I do want to just take a moment to thank all of our administrators who came today spent the Saturday morning with us to those who prepared and revised and revised and revised their presentations based on feedback and questions thank you to the town leaders who joined us today thank you to

319the committee members I really appreciate everyone's commitment to this we are a bit overtime but I think the discussion that we had here was was really informative um do you have any other remarks to make no no so thank you with that I'll entertain a motion to adjourn so moved second so that was Tory making the motion and vicam seconding all those in favor I any opposed exstension unanimous thank you all enjoy the rest of your day hunker down for the 6 Ines of snow

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.