001e e e Kendra is not GNA be here she had a death in the family okay all right I have no idea good evening seeing a quorum of voting members I call the February 19th student achievement and District instructional performance Committee of the whole meeting to order treasure Wagner please call the attendance roll whenever you're ready sorry about that sorry I was so busy socializing I couldn't find my phone form okay Mr Craig uh Mr Crossett here Mr Lindy miss map Mrs Weinberg here vice president Bolton president president mofin here thank you superintendent Murphy please introduce our first presentation thank you so kindly up first today we have our chief operations officer Mr Chris burkard who is going to provide us with a facilities update welcome good afternoon for you as we move forward to
002the next slide so happy to announce that we are launching fmx and fmx is our facil uh rental software that will be uh kicking off next month and that will allow a One-Stop shop to to be able to rent rent um any space within the district whether it be a cafeteria whether it's a gymnasium whether it's a classroom um as well as all the inary services that go along with that will all be done in um a website versus what we are doing now is everything is on paper we are sending emails we're trying to find out if SPAC is available emailing back and forth between principles and then um having that be a manual process now this will be a One-Stop shop in which a user will go and enter their request automatically be
003routed to the person who oversees that space to be able to uh approve or deny it as well as any uh ancillary services that are needed second I'm really really happy to talk about the Roberts dental clinic and welcome center so we are well underway with the construction this uh photo was taken last week and this week we are uh putting up drywall so the space will be uh able to be uh inhabited sometime at the end of March so we're really looking forward to getting that space usable for the Roberts uh dental clinic and welcome center big thanks to clickie for really uh and Darlene for really um stepping up and helping us through this this process as we uh move forward to the montory lab school at the Bramble nature campus we held
004a meeting last week phenomenal meeting we had over 85 um families that were there that expressed interest in utilizing that space and so as we are moving forward with facilities and looking at the um putting the the monory lab school in the Bramble building we are continuously uh updating that space and making sure that we will have a win-win situation for all those involved as we move to the uh next uh great slide Community makeover was announced the Reds every year do a community makeover this year projects will be at Frederick Douglas and Dr Odell Owens we don't know exactly what those projects will entail right now as we are just starting that process but it looks like Frederick Douglas will be at least getting a new playground area and really looking at that space
005behind their building um from the old um basketball courts and parking to make it more usable green friendly space for for the community to use so we're really excited about what that's going to look like uh over the summer I believe it's July 24th is the date in which all of our supporters from around the city of Cincinnati will will come to those two schools and within 24 hours work some magic and really transform those two schools into some magical spots so as we move to the next uh Kudos so our facilities team has really been working diligently on testing new chemicals we wanted to make sure that we were looking at the board policy that was passed last year into in relation to sustainable um environments and so we have ordered new products that
006are green seal certified Green Seal certified are those products with non-carcinogenic ingredients non-combustible have low skin and eye irritation and respiratory irritation less respiratory respiratory irritation potential um and so we're really really excited about um when we tested those products making sure that they met our standards making sure that they were green for the environment we have ordered those as we go over the next couple months we're transitioning our old products out and utilizing our new products so we will be 100% green with our uh products for facilities starting in July so that's a really uh big lift for for the facilities team and um glad that we're making a a positive impact on the environment in the process so as we talk about building cleanliness and those those cleaning products um one of the
007questions that was asked at a previous board meeting was in relation to the custodial square footage coverage and what that might look like if we were to increase that so currently what I have on the screen is the apaa standard space schedule and the app is Association of physical plan administrators what this tells us is um per um person per manh hour or woman hour uh how many uh how much space could one person clean in relation to schools and and school related facilities so if you look at the level it goes from one to five one being pretty much spotless um with 8500 Square ft all the way up to level five being unkempt and neglect at ,600 as we look at CPS last year we were at about 28,700 uh per square foot
008so that puts us on the on the tail end of level three this year because we added more school space so we had some um Renovations at Hyde Park Pleasant Ridge and walnut so our square footage became greater but we also decreased the number of custodians over the summer uh we downsized by 15 custodians over the summer which caused that number to go up from 287 to 293 so that's our current space Rob if you click on the custodians per square footage so in this we have the um table that shows you um each school as well as how many positions and how many square foot how many square feet that is per employee if you scroll all the way down to the bottom it will give you the um purse square footage if we
009were wanting to go to the next level so we are on the tail end of level three in order to get to a a solid level three it would be about $1.3 million if we were to go to which is 23 additional employees if we were go to level two it would be 162 employees at about $9 million and if we wanted to get to level one it would be 524 employees at $29 million so I just put this up here to um give you some um to level set what that would look like if we were to go from a level three to a level two or a level one I also want to take into consideration as we're talking about level three and where we're at with the 29,000 300 that does not
010include facility rental or some of those ancillary things that happen at our campuses so the APPA standards are based on an 8 hour day but we know that not all of our schools have 8 hour days we have dances after school we have Athletics we have Community organizations coming use our buildings so that 29,300 is really a soft number it's probably a lot more however because we have been um tracking our facility usage on paper we don't have the data so that's one thing that fmx as we're coming around full circle to the first slide that is something that we're really really um excited about is being able to track all of our expenses and actually what it cost to operate one of our buildings for all the cost including facility rental and usage um
011amongst the school staff and the building uh as we go to the next slide and this is the final slide um this would not be complete with a 5-year plan estimated costs that I like to share every time I get the chance Rob if you click on the slide you'll see that our cost oh um that happens so in a minute you'll see the cost um that we're we're at 171 million and I know that the board has seen this many many times before um but we're at 171 million as of today um that number keeps Rising as we are looking at um our facilities for example um as we move forward we know that we've had a lot of inclement weather we will have some uh potholes in some areas of our um pavement
012that need to be replaced and or fixed and or repaired we also have situations in which we will have Roofing repairs that need to happen based on the weather as well as tuck pointing of joints and some of those other things so as we are looking forward this 171 is today we also know that if we um are looking at levies for the future we know that every year we're looking at about somewhere around 8% increase so by 2027 um we're looking at that being around 215 million just for inflation the economies of scale as we also look at some of the changes the administration is making um I.E some tariffs and things that are going on cost of Steel is going to increase significantly as well as a lot of other building supplies so
013um again this number soft we don't know what it would look like in 3 years but we're trying to to extrapolate we're also going into into this spreadsheet on a uh monthly basis and trying to update as much as we can in relation to not only the projects but the cost of the projects as we have more updated information thank you any questions from board members I think some some board members need access to the file yes did anyone have any questions Mr P need some um Jeopardy music I said Jeopardy music and kids were like what we're good no maybe well I'm sure you'll get some questions later no worries I do have a couple questions okay um board members you'll get access I'm C ious um as as board members I know I've
014got one or two I need to return emails to uh neighbors and alumni of some of our buildings that have said hey this the the yard looks horrible we need some help with regard to facilities our alumni take great pride in their facilities and so can you share with me and I have a few questions which schools have the greatest facility need and are those schools fully staffed or are they half staffed I think it's interesting that we are having um we're able to kind of quantify cleanliness of the buildings and that was kind of interesting to me but I'm also very curious around Recruitment and um Staffing levels because particularly because the community is very interested in that and I think I have one email around litter and um wondering you know it's it
015said what has our what has our historical number been so we're at 28 8,000 now what has it been over time and and is there a trend like I don't remember this being a thing 5 years well pre pandemic seven years ago or so I don't remember there being a way to quantify Staffing levels regarding the building facilities cleanliness so just wondering how did we Faire in the past versus um how we are now and is that a direct in relationship to buildings being understaffed um buildings size capacity like a with ro campus is much larger than an Oiler so that's what I'm my question is yeah lot lots of questions to unpack there first um I think we have nine open custodial positions so we're almost completely staffed um and that is typical um
016at this time of the year we have some folks who retire um and so just getting that uh um having those those positions back filled um in relation to which schools need the most help so two things there one is our oldest schools really have a lot of needs right now to make sure that we are taking care of that infrastructure but I would say a lot of the newest schools that we've built um are also coming around to that cycle so when you build a house you know that you know for the first 10 years or so you don't have a lot of Maintenance but once you get to year 15 and 20 then that's when the maintenance really starts deteriorate because you're replacing roofs you're replacing boilers you're replacing heaters you're replacing hot
017water tanks and that's the same with the schools so we're at the point right now that both of those are converging together at the same time so our older schools um we've deferred some maintenance on and that's coming due as well as those schools that we built we like to say they're new but they're you know coming up on on you know between 20 and 30 years old now and we're having to start replacing those normal things that you would normally have to replace um as we look at all of those um from um you know athletic fields to boilers to camera upgrades uh if you ask every principal in any District across the US there's probably not enough cameras in their schools so that continuously is a situation that we continuously are just um
018adding cameras and upgrading cameras as possible knowing that will never be a finished line there there's in until we have you know the entire campus taken care of um for a lot of those other other items for example carpet and painting we're putting those on a seven-year plan um or an 8-year plan or a nine-year plan to be able to every eight or nine years put those into the budget so that we're swapping those out to make sure that we're very very diligent about you know not waiting until 5 or 10 years after the life and making sure ahead of time that we know what we want to do and what that cost is um as with everything else we can push some of those um but at least gives us a a starting point
019uh I'm glad you brought up litter because I've seen that a lot lately too is a lot of litter the one thing that we have to remember is around all of our school grounds we have fencing and most of that's the Chain Lake Fence that loves to trap all that litter from around the neighborhood so for example I was at Frederick Douglas the other day and the fence in front of the building had trapped all of the trash from trash day that had blown either out of the trash cans or down the street and ended up in front of the school so it's a constant um issue that we ask our custodians and building Engineers to go out twice a day and make sure at the beginning of the day that they're walking and getting
020all that trash but also at the end of the day making sure that that's done as well sometimes that is easier said than done though as we go around to our to our schools but that is our standard and when we don't see it happening we make sure we address it thank you War member wi not on okay yes there's my voice uh had a quick question you mentioned fencing and I actually was going to bring that up in terms of fencing so over at Westwood they have the different type Elementary they have the um I don't even know what fencing you call that but it's black and it has the long you know columns um um how do you all determine or when do we replace the fencing and which fencing do they choose
021is it based on Elementary versus high school and I was just kind of curious about that yeah so looking at fencing we have to look at why the fencing is there in the first place so sometimes it's decorative and sometimes it is um because we want to create a barrier between the two we're really looking right now at if the barrier is there for more Aesthetics than it is for anything else we're look really looking at Green fencing and what that means is things like arbori and planting those or Shrubbery planting those in the space that provides more green space makes it look nicer and then you don't have the as much upkeep on some of that fencing um to your point some of that is um the most economical fencing is the chain link
022obviously which is what we see in a lot of our athletic fields and around the backs of our buildings in the front of our building we'd go with more of a rot iron look because we want it to be aesthetically pleasing which isn't always the case when you're dealing with chain link fencing um at the end of the day it's both an Aesthetics and a cost as well as maintenance and is there any particular code that we have to meet in terms of again does an elementary school have to have a specific type of fencing in the front versus the back versus high school there's no okay thank you thank you very much thank you superintendent Murphy please introduce our next presentation absolutely I'm happy to introduce our Chief Information officer Mr Jeremy gallu with
023an update on our technology good afternoon everyone um so thank you I'm not going to spend a lot of time reading to you the the departmental Strategic Mission or that um you want go to the next one we talking necessarily about the organizational um breakdown of the department but I did want to include them uh I'd be remiss not to because of course year-over-year one of our biggest questions we get not just within the department as a district is who do I contact about what so of course for it and Technology needs our answer almost always is call the help desk but secondarily if there's an escalation need I always want to take every opportunity to put this information out as to what we do what our verticals look like like so that everybody has
024that information of who do you escalate to next good couple of quick highlights of information that the board has seen updates on previously this year we wanted to bring back some updates now um of course the biggest um fantastic work fairly overwhelming this year has been the implementation of our first year of focus as well as canvas uh recall that these are the systems that replaced a number of systems across the district including our student information system our learning learning management system uh our case management for IEPs uh as well as a number of reporting and Data Systems so as we've went through the implementation you can see you know we we've had a lot of training opportunities we provided to our staff um across the board 275 plus since August so if you laid
025those out end to end uh most of them were front loaded In fairness but if you looked at it end to end you know that that's basically like 10 training opportunity sessions per week that we've been offering uh to staff so we're very happy with that but we're not done yet you know that train has to keep going uh in addition also of course we've had guides videos office hours and trying to cover every base we can in November we we performed our first staff certis staff satisfaction survey uh we did do a random sample of 999 staff there's a couple of reason we chose to do a random sample one with respect to survey um fatigue we you know we we do have several surveys we wanted to hesitate on asking all of our
026staff to do one but we also wanted to be able to focus on a number that we could look at the responses for one of the most important questions we asked and that was why did you rate it the way you rated it you know it's nice to know that who likes who doesn't but we really wanted to hear on an individual basis if you rated it less than satisfactory especially what was missing what is the feature that's not working the way you want so as a followup up we were able to create essentially a punch list from all of that feedback and work our way through one by one to make sure that we were trying to address every um feedback that we were getting the things that were either not likeed and things
027you would just see in a normal new system uh overall so over you can see we had about a 31% response rate it was across all of our various uh stakeholder representative staff groups uh and when we do our next survey that actually launched this week we'll be selecting a new sample um you can see the overall satisfaction rating for Focus currently was 53% rated as satisfied or better for canvas that's the LMS side was 56% or better now we're obviously happy that more than half of our staff are on board with us and they're satisfied as a product and better but of course that means just under 50% we're less than satisfied and that's not a happy place that we want to be in so like I said we took that opportunity to approach
028each of those feedback items but then we looked at okay take all the individual Parts out and just at the categories what were the top three things that we were getting as a reason why they would rate it less than satisfactory those kind of came into the three categories of too many clicks too much change at once and too complicated so really if you start root causing all three of those it comes back to point the first point that more time with the system to get comfortable and more training those are really the only ways to overcome that especially as we work into it and you learn that well I thought there was too many clicks for that not really because there were but because I didn't know the way to do it in the
029short way I was doing a long way that may not have been necessary so that's where we want to continue focusing on our training efforts throughout the year uh to bring everybody on board and we'll see what our next uh survey looks like that's going out right now next SL the second large project um and the board will recall you've played a big hand in it already this year on September 23rd is when the board passed our first Cincinnati public schools AI policy and at that time if you recall I think I can't remember exactly who asked the question but I responded essentially that we were ready to take those next steps as soon as this policy was was approved um so kind of to live into some of that of what we've done what
030we kicked off immediately thereafter was our AI intro 4 Series so we started with our early adopter the tech coordinators and we did an AI introduction for Tech coordinators you can see the series running across the slide there that we went from Tech coordinators to teachers to principles to assistant principles and beginning next month we'll be launching the artificial intelligence and education introduction for families that'll be where we start providing resources and education to families at various touch points uh and events that the districts has starting next month you can see some of the uh information that's contained within that introduction of course we cover like what is generative AI what does the educational use of AI look like for staff members it's a real big part of how do you change the way you
031work utilizing AI for efficiency and of course for our teachers one of the biggest question always is what is cheating with AI what does that mean how do they do it what are we watching for that that kind of topics uh in addition to the introduction for series we've also started a number of committees to help assist in directing the future of that work for a staff usage subcommittee the instructional usage subcommittee the family engagement and usage subcommittee and lsdmc engagement sessions are being held uh all under the GU under the master Committee of the implementation committee for AI one last thing I wanted to call out real quick was that we will also be holding as you can see on the right side on March 3rd our first ever clerical Tech conference so some
032things that we've heard for a number of years while our clerical staff always get um monthly training for registrations of enrollment and things like that they're often not included in in the tech part of just generally getting information and updates on what's available to them from our systems so we wanted to respect that feedback and request and and and we have launched now this will be our first annual clerical Tech conference which will focus on a number of things including AI specific work for them or AI specific use for their work uh to assist in better efficiency so I will apologize in advance um since we posted this originally there were some questions that came up that led me to believe we might want to have a little bit more of a budget oriented conversation
033around this I do have another slide but it was not included in what the board has or what was posted so if we'd like to talk about that I'm happy to go into it or if we'd like I would be more than willing to come back and do it another time I think that was probably my question I'd send it to superintendent Murphy I wanted some information around technology and the budget um it's up to the board members that was just my I wanted to get some information around technology and the budget but I'm open to board members if you want to ask questions about what we've seen that's fine um we can save the budget technology in the budget is it a lot of pres is it is it a lot of slides Jeremy
034it's only one slide but it's pretty dense material I just have a couple questions well present your slide and then we'll okay before does I can ask my questions about okay so uh starting with a little bit of a oh I'm sorry can I ask my questions first can we go back to slide number four um so I just was curious I know that you um stated that you all were able to ask the different categories of Staff but is there going to be an opportunity where you're actually asking the parents and families regarding how they are liking Focus the ability to maneuver it Etc absolutely U I'm great question I appreciate you asking so I did forget to mention we are looking looking at that in terms of whether we want to do it
035at the end of this year following our second survey to staff or if we want to launch it at the beginning of next school year to follow little announcement um over the summer we will be launching the mobile partner app for Focus so CPS Focus will be a the mobile app version that essentially will give parents uh much more access what we see traditionally right now without you know an app is there is limited parent use for the purposes and tasks they need but not necessarily for the One-Stop shop we'd like it to be um so we are very excited that we're planning our launch of that app during the summer for next school year so we've kind of been looking back and forth whether we want to go ahead and start that survey with
036families this year or wait until after so we have a little more engagement both from them as well as we have more feedback from the staff in terms of what we um can address because obviously the staff are really the front line that works with our families that are going to have a big influence on what their opinion or their feedback is for the system is there a way to possibly do the engagement um at the end and before and the only reason why I'm saying that is because I've heard from several parents including myself it is very hard to maneuver those two sites and I think getting that feedback will definitely help you know as you're releasing out this mobile and then also for the next year of how to get parents aligned with
037the new focus in the canvas so is there any way to not wait until the beginning of next year but actually getting that information collecting it utilizing it and preparing and prepping so that when you do make the launch that it's a little bit easier as well yeah absolutely I also have another question regarding um the next slide slide five um will this particular conference will there be a cost for the employees and will they get uh professional development credit there will not be a cost I will have to check with the team to verify if they can get the professional development credit for it or not yes all right team on hand you what what more can you ask for okay so yes they will then all right thank you so much so continue
038with your your okay so uh a quick recap in terms of where we are from our technology standpoint and our really this focuses on the biggest part of our cost around our lease obligations uh you've heard that mentioned by the treasur in terms of our fiveyear forecast and and some so what I wanted to recapture was if you recall last year um during our budget reduction discussions and votes and variety of things we looked at reducing our overall techn ology lease um obligations for devices by around $3.2 million um so what that practically meant was we went to a one: one model for 3 to six grade in carts in the school they no longer took them home but they were still one to one we are take-home one: one for 7 through 12 and
039then kindergarten through second grade are still sorry second grade is still one to one in carts in the Schools kindergarten through first is no longer one to one they're using iPads in a disperse for the class typically like a four per classroom so through that model we reduce a number of costs that got us down that $3.2 million which leaves our current lease obligation at the 13.37 million per year that's an annualized lease obligation we currently have one important thing to note about that is that lease has primarily been funded uh over the past several years through our Esser dollars now that those dollars are gone that will be hitting the general fund again this year for the first time in a number of years so that represents by itself with changing nothing an increase
040that we would experience expect to see kind of extrapolating out from that um I'm not sure if we if everyone remembers but when we talked about this this was kind of a stop Gap measure in terms of those budget savings so a device has an a finite life lifetime so by reducing our lease obligation we returned some devices we had to buy out some devices we kept devices that we are forcing to have a longer lifespan than we would normally want to have so there is a there's a time limit on that reduced spending so this year we're we're fairly steady we're good with the devices we have we're making it work next year we're going to need a little duct tape and a lot of Goodwill that we can make it one more year
041with as we are but following that year we are going to be in a situation where we will not be able to maintain even the model we have today going one to one from 3 to six and the take-home 7 to 12 as the number of devices that are going to be unsupported can't function or do not function broken that we can't replace is going to exceed the number of students we would have to give them to so that's where we're kind of our Prospect for the ne for FY 27 so just to maintain the current model we will need to reinvest into our technology and our devices so the chart you see here collects not just the device lease but across all of our leases um that we also used through multiple other reductions
042in the past several years our infrastructure labeled here switches our audio video we stopped doing any refreshes of the audio and visual classroom technology um this year last year and this year outside of what we could fund through title one so that was very limited in terms of the carryover and at this point same scenario we're going to start running into failures and and Equipment that's hitting end of life and you know we were still in the process of upgrading a lot of the technology from say um projectors to the display screens that that we were still working on currently our storage U represents just the file storage that we have for the district and the firewall which manages our security systems those are our total lease uh Fleet and obligations so you can see
043I said we can maintain this year and next year essentially as is for FY 27 we will need to restore at least the 3.2 million roughly to be able to maintain what we're doing today today so you can see that raises our um cost to 17.8 in 27 and 28 and then we have additional at that point equipment that's going to be end of life from the other categories our switches our audio visual kicks back in at that point is our first year where everything is hitting that point where we have to issue either new leases or purchases so then our total obligation would go up to 9.3 million for FY 29 and fy3 so as you can see as a total there uh over the this year plus the next five an investment of
044approximately $101 million needed to maintain the technology as in the model we have right now I know at the end of our conversations last year when we went to this model there were definitely conversations around what if we wanted to step back a little bit and put takehome back in place for grades three through six so in the second area here you can you can see where there's a a pretty good breakdown here the two options we would have if we wanted to pursue that one option is a one-time purchase although that's kind of misleading technology does have a finite lifespan so that one-time purchase buys you devices and equipment that lasts four years at the end of that four years you got to buy another set of devices to replace them so it's a
045one-time spend for a period of time but then repeats right as opposed to every year the lease option allows us to annualize that cost out over a longer period of time over the years that the lifespan of the device itself so you'll see what we've broke down here with essentially both options looking at if we were to go back to a take-home model for the four grades in question so it's not exactly a scale this is pretty close um there are some intangibles that kind of move around so that's why it's not basically just 25% 25% but you can see if we were to do just sixth grade um and I would focus on the leas payments just says honestly that would probably be my recommendation as to how we would want to proceed that's
046what we've done has been very successful for us and going back to that model I think makes the most budgetary sense for us so you're looking at around 680,000 if we were to do fifth and sixth 668 683 together you can see the breakdown per grade so the total if we were to do all four grades would be an additional $2.7 million in leasing on top of the chart above that shows the maintaining so on any given year if we were to say an FY 27 we wanted to rep we wanted to reinstate our take-home for 3 through six it would be the 17.8 million plus $2.7 additional million one side note those figures do not include the additional Tech cost so when we reduced our total Fleet number of devices the brake fix has
047been a huge gain we expected it's about where we thought the money would be I don't know if the schools necessarily would have appreciated as much as they have expressed now how much better it is with the cart model in terms of that um but we were able to reduce the number of filled Texs and and uh resources we have to support those devices um because they're not going home there's a lot less turnaround issues if we were to reinstate that you're talking about close to 10,000 devices we would be adding back into our um Fleet and pull of devices which of course would require us to reinstate some level of support not the whole amount that we reduce which was we really cut it in half but probably about 25 % of that we
048would need to come back also which is around an additional 250,000 got you thank you board members have any questions vice president Bolton thank you um thanks for the presentation and I do distinctly remember you saying that you were going to it was a little bit of a sleeper thing for a couple of years at and kind of uh not at risk but you know you were giving up some things U but sooner or later uh uh we're going to have to pay the piper uh so I appreciate that and I appreciate the long-term look at this um I have gotten a few worries about uh the take-home and the availability of take-home for our high school students can you help me out with that is that a problem of maintenance is that a pro
049uh or are you aware of it I tell me which which you know mine is strictly anecdotal I mean I would I would definitely confirm that we get feedback on occasion of some issues um it's not where we had it previously all of our service levels had to suffer somewhat again with the reduction in resources especially around the support um the number of devices we have in the pool means that we had to change the way we do business so before when we had the devices available a student basically would walk in my device is broke great thanks here's you another one go about your business we'll take the time to fix this one now um because of the limited number of devices we have we have maintained that as much as possible but we
050do occasionally run into issues where we simply don't have devices to do the hot swapping that we would like to do so it delay some of that coming back there is there has been a little bit of a service impact there that we expected you that that that probably is part of it or that probably explains it the reason I think that they're heavily emphasizing this even if it is anecdotal and it may not be widespread or may it may be widespread is just because we' depend so much more on uh a curricula now that is not hard copy books and what have you so it's hard for students to do what they need to be able to do or teachers to assign what they've got to assign so but uh that's a good explanation
051and I hope there's a solution somehow in this coming budget or in how you're organized thank you any other board member comments questions concerns thanks thank you absolutely um vice president Bolton please introduce our last presentation I think that the treasurer has a a a sharing and you have in front of you the final uh draft of what she's going to be talking about uh as a poll that is now ready to be distributed tonight at The District white lsdmc uh and we'll start with the treasurer's uh presentation good afternoon good afternoon everyone um just a really quick update so just to remind you of our timeline Thank you new driver takes a second sorry that's right um so we're about halfway through our process in terms of the traditional process where we start with
052student projections in November and then finalize a budget in June um three things to consider um the growth plan was a change to this year two um we still solidifying what the budget priorities are going to be and three the governor um just dropped their budget bill um and we're in the process of analyzing I we'll give you an update on Monday night on the concerns from the urban Treasures but that may or may not have impact as we move forward we won't know what the final bill is going to be probably till the middle of late June once it gets through all the Committees and gets voted on um so we central office has not started yet we're waiting for more Direction on what to tell them about where to invest the money um
053before we let them begin um next slide but this is where we are as of February 18th so our budget Target is still based off the November forecast we we will be updating um in May so that Target may change some um but and I just combine some lines for the Simplicity of this slide you haven't this is nothing you haven't seen already what I did update was the school budget we updated this average salaries for fiscal year 26 to use in the budgets remember all the schools are built off of average salaries we had a higher than normal um retirement list and so um the average salaries weren't as much as we expected so that school budgets went down just a tiny bit um but right now as of today we're sitting at 146
054million left to allocate and that's based on the direction that we move forward I think that was it oh the survey so um I didn't right I don't want to claim the survey as mine I did not I gave feedback onto it but I did not write it go ahead and switch to the next slide um if you click on the click on the link this survey is outdated because it was revised and what you have in front of you printed I think is the most recent version and so I didn't uh know from there I turn it back to miss Bolton about board's feedback and next steps great thank you um appreciate the presentation and yeah the the uh timeline for the budget uh is fast approaching and I know everybody's made a commitment
055that we will pass a budget by June 30th uh as we are required the uh poll if you will or survey that is before you has been modified from the original one and the original and largely because uh well the original fortunately the treasurer added some language that cleared up some of the things that I had written and I appreciated that and then in order to actually distribute or get it ready for you all to look at and react to uh we got rid of at least one of the category types or whatever you uh so that we would only have five options in in each so that was one of the big changes you will you may notice that all of these possibilities actually are a growth from the initiatives chart that we talked
056about that started all the way back in October 23 uh and we talked about it February 1st at our meeting and uh this is the continuation of what we would might call board initiatives over the last couple of budgets and also uh superintendent initiatives so right now just as a um maiden voyage so to speak tonight uh as part or the end of this treasurer's pres presentation on the budget to the districtwide lsdmc um the people that are attending that meeting tonight will have an opportunity to look at this react to it and do some polling and it's and we'd like to get your input uh as to uh things to add things to take away uh and also on Monday night we can talk together more about what kind of Engagement Beyond this polling
057uh we might want to do with our families and our students and our staff so this is right now everybody would be ranking um at the lsdmc they will rank within each category one to five and then they will rank the five categories as to which is most important and least important but these are all things that we have continued and carried through since all the way back to October 23 and up through the new Administration as well thank you for member Lindy um thank you so much I would like to just suggest an alternative approach sure which was that we ask the administration for their recommendation on all of these and then respond to what they recommend is the best way to lead us towards the goals that we've set based on their visibility
058into the system and what the needs are uh to me this this feels like us getting very granular in a way that's outside the scope of where the board's energies are best directed and so my alternative is i' really before I'm happy to share feedback or reactions but I'm very interested in what the administration thinks first thank you your respond sure I think that makes perfect sense I do want to emphasize though that whatever is listed here is not strictly board driven these were taken from two different superintendence uh over the last few years so I think there's some interest of the board in particular areas here but uh this is Administrative driven it'd be great to see how they might rank it because we can't we can't have so many uh uh things that
059we have to focus on necessarily but these were all things coming from two different administrations but I think it'd be great to get their recommendations and how they're approaching I think that's that's good yeah I I wanted uh thank you again for U the presentations today were great and and for the comments um I wanted to um maybe emphasize I really liked What U board member Lindy suggested but I I wonder if when you if the administration can do that when they come back I think it would be interesting to see how those uh recommendations you know sort of are justified in terms of how they might impact student outcomes or how they might impact uh cost efficiency some rationale behind you know what why why they would be uh prioritized or ranked or whatever
060some ification I think is would be really important thank you thank you treas Wagner just a point of clarity I'm sorry are are we asking for the administrator's feedback on the just the survey or are you asking for the administration to produce a budget for you to react to is that to me treasure Wagner to the whole board what what is the direction to the administration so I think I'm going to kind of Chunk that question Ben can you clarify what you're asking because that's different for every board member I I don't have the same request so I mean my answer is the same to both you know I think it's the uh job of the administration to figure out how to get us from where we are to the vision that we've set in
061the best way possible with the resources we have um and so I'm I'm whether it's these particular budget decisions or the budget as a whole I my preference would be that there always be a recommendation from the administration about what the what the the right thing to do is and what the and to Mr crit's Point what the rationale is um and what what the what are the trade-offs you see the other options you thought about and why you prefer one over another um and and my rationale for that is just you all are so much closer to all of these details than we are we come here for a couple hours a week and do the best we can and you all do this every minute of every day and you have teams of
062people who work work for you on this um and you have access to so much more data and information than we have um and I think that you know we hire a superintendent we hire a Treasurer to have to think through these really really hard decisions and then make recommendations to the board so my answer would really be the same on on both of those I think the more conflicting signals we send you the harder we make your jobs and the harder we make it is to actually move the district forward thank you I I want to give my my opinion um regarding my feedback regarding the engagement survey I'm not certain that we're at the stage that board member Lindy is requesting which I agree with I think the administration should drive that but
063I don't see under the categories things like preschool promise which is important to me so I'm wondering how did we get to these categories um I think they're super important but I think that they they have been honed down to five and I'm not certain that those five that these five should be the final priority I remember in the original poll the question asked what do you think are your priorities I specifically put early childhood education in preschool um so I don't see that here so I think that before we get to where board member Lindy has shared um that he feels like where we are uh where we are is to um the the administration's responsibility is to enact the vision set by the board I don't know if we've set the priorities collectively
064first and then I think it is exactly appropriate for the administration team to say hey this is the budget for the things that you all have have shared are important so I don't know what happened to the feedback from the board members that listed their priorities is that how we got to the five so that two separate that was feedback for us this came from the vice president Bolton um but there is preschool expansion in here on on the second page under property tax requests so I okay still is there okay I got you so what is the ask of the board you want us to just take this paper survey not the online one or is it online I I'm sorry I don't want to speak for Miss but I think this was for
065the community's engagement this is for the lsdmc tonight to fly this and see how it works uh uh and whether or not it would ever be expanded would have to be Administration and board deciding it what we were trying to do with this is do what we said on February 1st which is revisit all the previous uh and new uh superintendent administrative initiatives and again this was all taken from those charts that we shared before that we've all seen and um we did eliminate the references regarding NE negotiations because last year I think when we did some polling on negotiations I think we got in a little bit of trouble uh with the unions because they felt it was a kind of uh roaching uh negotiations itself so those things that were on that chart
066uh that dealt with negotiations uh were not um uh included and we didn't include the growth plan because we've all kind of been there already and obviously that's not going to be stopped at this point in time so besides that all of these other ones uh have been a part of the district's initiatives and that's what we were trying to capture on this and I think what we're looking for is reactions to it uh we can we can burn it up we can uh see what happens tonight for is a matter of discussion among the districtwide lsdmc folks uh but these are things on which we have been have had the administration present to us over the last couple of years as well as things that we have uh periodically endorsed um as well so
067these are things that have come before the board before over the last couple of years so we're looking for any ideas people have and this is good so I just again I I would like to clarify before we end our meeting this budget engagement survey is being sent to the lsdmc current lsdmc members tonight who are attending tonight to see what it looks like and this has no future if we don't want it to have a future and this is being collected by whom the administration at the end of the at the end of the treasurer's annual uh budget presentation to the districtwide lsdmc and we will have the results of this when it's set up as a Google survey so I imagine tomorrow we could probably share those results okay any other board members
068have board member CrossFit yeah I I um I kind of want to reiterate what board member member Lindy was saying about we probably have to do both and you know look at the whole budget and then also the survey I I think it's great that we're going to reach out to the ls BMC folks to get their input and probably we'll have to take their input my my view would be we would have to take their input and respond to what they uh provide in terms of what we come up with with the budget I I think that we're going to ask for a survey we definitely need to respond to their input and thank them for their input and see how it how we could best use it and so that they get some
069feedback as well it's that's just not a black hole of them offering us information so i' probably have to do a little bit of both I think what Mr Lindy was saying thank you thank thank you um so we have concluded our um our agenda and I was trying to verify with um our general Council of how we're going to proceed further and I'll finish that thought right after board member Lindy Shar say ju just before before we close I was um this is I I guess technically the student achievement Committee of the whole and I was confused when I saw the agenda and didn't see any student achievement topic on it uh I recognize I've missed a couple meetings recently and I may have missed an update on that so I just wanted to
070ask what the story was with the focus of the agenda yes so we are conducting the treasurer search unfortunately I in planning the agenda our committee of the whole meeting was taken for part of the the treasur search so that begins at 5:00 p.m. I didn't have much planning in that so we cut our meeting short much of the things that were going to be discussed in an effort to accommodate um Ohio School Board Association who is planning that in addition with board member Craig and so we've tried to move those academic topics to the February 10th meeting we had some there and then the February 24th meeting we will have some academics there but the but the reason why a lot of the academics has been taken is because from our Saturday work session
071which we really needed to get some business done we conducted much of the treasur search there and then the cow was already agreed upon when we hired Ohio Schoolboard Association this particular month was already taken for the February 1st work session and the Cal to conduct treasure search uh activities and so again I apologize to board members I did not have much control over that that was an agenda that was given to me and so we are going to go into a fact finding to accommodate some of that time and then recess into executive session for the board Bo session of the agenda for the treasurer search and that's really very helpful I think what I'm taking away is unusual circumstances not part of the plan for the future for how we use this time
072and we should participate in future student achievement committee the whole meetings a heavy focus on student achievement that is exactly correct apparently the board agreed on we agreed on this back last year that February's cow would include this and so that is something that we all agreed on that we but this is unusual times so hopefully we will get back to the business of academics and we all just as a reminder did agree to extend our student our Cals our student achievement Committee of the holes by 30 minutes to include more topics around academics so we can get a full scope so normally it will be from 4 to 6 and in that was to eliminate health and safety committee so everyone remember are we all in agreement does anyone have any other questions so
073the board is going to adjourn now for a fact finding and then we will recess into executive session I need a motion so moved second second thank you have a good night oh I'm I'm sorry