CorpusRecord 65348

CPS Board Business Meeting February 10, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,169 words · about 129 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all righty seeing a quarum of voting members I call the February 10th Cincinnati school board meeting to order Treasurer Wagner would you please call the attendance R Mr Craig here Mr Crossett here Mr Lindy here miss map here Mrs Weinberg here vice president Bolton presid president Moffett here sorry here superintendent Murphy please introduce our wonderful students that will be leading Us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening absolutely tonight we'll be led by the students from Coale where Mr Michael McGowan is our principal class please join me for the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation God indivisible and justice for all outstanding a highlight of every I agree with vice president Bolton that is the highlight of

002the day vice president Bolton please explain the virtual hearing the public process thank you very much members of the public who are online and wish to speak during our hearing of the public this evening may do so by clicking the chat button now the chat feature will be open for your requests for five minutes if you would like a direct response to your questions please make sure to share your name your affiliation to the district your school Community your topic and your contact information thank you the chair will now entertain a motion and a second to approve the February 10th business meeting agenda is there a motion removed thank you board member cross it second second thank you VP Bolton treasure Wagner please call the voting roll Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy

003yes M map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president Moffett yes tonight agenda is approved as posted superintendent Murphy please update us about your goals and the evaluation review all right happy to do so uh the last time I think we talked there were uh five goals in what I would consider the instructional Realm of the state superintendent standards in Ohio uh I was asked to place additional goals in the other four four categories Vision continuous Improvement communication and collaboration third policies and governance and then five resources and so those are posted for your pleasure and your feedback at this time in addition to that uh Mr Crossett is going to help me out because he has created a scoring guide uh around those goals considering the waiting that the policy committee has

004uh asked us to have in order to move forward board members do you have any questions feedback need for clarification yeah I if it's all right I would like to walk through this spreadsheet that I created it's really sort of an extension of what um board member Lindy had sort of suggested and talked about a little bit um so if you if you actually go to um this first page uh you know I had it graded 1 through five which is kind of in sync with our state report card kind of grading and uh you can see this this identifies the um 60% part of the scoring related to the outcome goals and then 30 10% related to the check-in and 30% related to the five uh St state standards and this is sort of

005a hypothetical example of how the scoring would work and how it could roll up but if you go to page two if you can scroll if you flip it over to I guess you got to flip it over to page two yeah um so this this is um looking at the uh 60% scoring for the um um student uh the uh annual report card and so if you look at the here's the five goals and I've got highlighted if you're at 100% of the goal and then the base of the goal and so the growth goal which is a minus B which is in that column pretty far to the right that's kind of what we I would think we would be measuring on and I think Ben was kind of suggesting if we could

006get you know some percentage of the way towards that uh reaching that goal that that would qualify for some sort of a a score four uh one through five so um I kind of put together this chart so in other words if you if the goal is our current our original goal was 61% the superintendent stretched the goal to 63% I I kind of felt like those stretch goals should be worth a little bit extra since they were I felt it was like moving the goal post after the the middle of the game but we all might have a different opinion about that but that's just a suggestion of how it might look and so as you're as the uh as we get going towards that goal if you get 85% of the way in

007the growth and that might be worth a four if you get 75% of the way that might be worth a three and and this is just a suggestion and it's just a way to calculate these uh numerically to kind of put put something to um to for the superintendent to be evaluated on so um any questions about this part of this and then I'll go to the first page the front page of yeah so let me start the board members have questions around the goals that the intendent has updated at the request of the board and then we're going to go to your addition Mr Crossett what lendy yeah I think I can do them both together because I think a lot of the questions I had about how the goals were written would be

008answered if this is the approach that we adopt I was initially really worried that we're listing the instructional goals forth uh as if they're the fourth most important thing we're doing around here um when I think improving academic opportun for children is the most important thing um after keeping Kids Safe um and so in reading this proposed scoring guide what's really nice about this and I I do really appreciate this and I like this um it's super clear that the academic progress of the district makes up the Lion Share of the evaluation I think that's entirely appropriate and great and I want to say thank you um I think I I I I do um want want to raise again my concern that the targets on the academic Improvement are too low um I want

009to say just a bit about this um I know I shared an email with Phyllis who passed it on to the rest of the board this was a week or two ago and everybody's a chance to see it now but um I wanted to have some context for how high we should be aiming with the academic goals for the superintendent and I want I really want them to have meaning and so to have an a better informed opinion about that I went back and looked at the data from the Ohio Department of Education and the workforce and looked at all schools in Ohio uh or at least the districts that serve uh almost let's say uh the Lion Share of students are economically disadvantaged like CBS and look to see over the last three years

010so not any one year but really a three-year average how much improvement year-over-year are those districts seeing and and so in this goal for example if we were to go from 61% passing third grade reading to 63% passing that's a 2 percentage Point increase I wanted to know is that big is that small is that kind of average uh as you look at districts across Ohio and what the data helped me see was that if we're making two percentage points of progress that's actually in the bottom half of districts serving almost entirely low-income students in the state of Ohio I think we should be much higher than that uh I think we should set our sites to be in the top 25th percentile for improvement across the state of Ohio um and so I I

011I want to just sum up by saying sum saying two things again I I really appreciate the scoring guide I fully support every piece of this and think it is great uh and the the push I would offer is I think we need to be setting higher targets because if our goal is to be in the bottom half I don't think that goal is high enough so thank you b lendy b across it yeah I I don't disagree with you I I think that um I think the timing timing is important and I think the timing of when we look at that and reset the goals should be would best be right after the report card comes out and we're we're many months into the school year now and I I I I don't disagree

012that we should aim high I just um so that's just my opinion so board member ly uh I thank you and I'll stop talking after this um I I think you know to Mr cross's point there there is an aspect of that that is deeply reasonable that you come in in the middle of the year you have more modest Target I think the challenge I'm having with that is that many of my colleagues made the case that the reason why we didn't need a search process and the reason why we could hire a new superintendent from the floor in what was a great surprise to me was the incredible job the superintendent had been doing in the first half of the year if that is true I think there's even less of a reason for

013us to set a Target that is to be in the bottom half of schools for for academic Improvement I think that's an even stronger reason to say this bar needs to be high and so that's the point that I want to emphasize thanks for member correct um let me start by saying thank you for taking the feedback that we gave to you at the retreat and implementing it into your goals um I think again I I sent you a message directly saying thank you for that and I I think I want to say it on the floor here so that folks can hear it um because I do think this is ultimately how we are going to build a collaborative set of goals for which we would hold you accountable and for which you would

014hold yourself accountable um so I appreciate that I think I think ultimately this year is going to be a difficult year anyway just because of the nature of when we're starting the process to do the evaluation and also just in general the the uh us figuring out what this looks like you know we're not starting this at the beginning of the school year we're starting this kind of past the halfway point of a school year um so I do think that's that's an opportunity and then you gave some definitive things within each of the markers to be things for us to look at and see whether or not those things were successful those things um ultimately LED towards to the district being in a better spot and so I just wanted to say uh thank

015you for doing that and you know again what the exact way we score it I'm not as hard passed on on how we come up with that scoring mechanism I think as long as we have one that makes sense and it's reasonable this first year this is kind of a we're figuring it out on the Run um I think in future years this this would be an opportunity for us to come up with a more concrete methodology for future years so that we are able to kind of have something consistent each year so that you're not being judged in a different way every year right you may have different goals you may have different things that we need to work on as a district you may have different Focus but we don't necessarily need to

016have different ways of figuring out what your uh how we measure your success so I appreciate you doing the work there and uh just kind of look forward to us getting this solidified so that we can actually give you the expectations and you can have an opportunity to you know perform for member Matt yes so um thank you uh superintendent Murphy for providing um more context to the state standard uh goals that you are expected to be evaluated on um I do have just a little bit of a a critique with um some of the goals I know that it was our recommendation for them to be smart goals and I know that there's a pre a presentation of some elements of the smart goal there um for me I would like to see more

017concretely what those um specific um outcomes you're anticipating from these said inputs would be so if we're talking about communication what would that what would be the measurable there what would we as a uh District expect um to see in terms of the growth with communication from these different interventions put in place um so I would like to see that type of uh smart goal approach woven throughout the rest of the um um the goals that you have so I see some elements there but I think it can be strengthened but I do appreciate that you've provided some type of context so that we know um what areas you're trying to focus on to obtain those goals and then to board member Crosset thank you for helping to move this work forward to provide uh

018some solution right to um help us uh do the work of effectively evaluating the superintendent so I appreciate this I didn't know if you wanted me to go over the front page would that be helpful for everybody you can get that back on the screen there sure the scoring rubric the spreadsheet the front page so if you uh at the very beginning of this you'll see uh there in that column under uh the 60% those scores come from uh the previous page so they just carry forward and then we've got 10% of of the scoring related to checkin so I don't know if we'll check in in Q2 or Q3 it was a suggestion um and what I thought we could do there is we could have a discussion and kind of as a group

019come up with what we think would be a a score as a group but if we can't we can also each vote individually and just take our average score and that just it facilitates an average score on each of those moments um and then for the standards I think um going back to um Kendra's Point those smart goals that get developed for those standards I think would be part of a discussion and and again uh superintendent Murphy asked it we get one score from the whole board so a way to facilitate that if we can't come to an agreement and discussion is just just for each of us to make our own score and have it be an average and so that's just and then uh you know it's just a matter of calculating that

020out on the spread sheet to come up with the total score so I I hope that seems reasonable at least initially a reasonable methodology of how to how to do this so vice president B thank you very much and thank you to the superintendent and thank you to Mr Lindy and pre previous conversations and pushing the evaluation piece uh for these number of of months and and years appreciate it I have just a several questions on on on this on measuring how well we're doing or the young people are doing or not doing is is uh the test that we're using is this the state report card test yes ma'am okay um we all know I think how I feel about their assessment um but it's at least it's something we it's happening Statewide so

021it it makes sense to use it um for this what what's the why is a particular number of stretch goal I that's what the superintendent raised the I just didn't know exactly how to deal with it it doesn't have to be the way to deal with it but the superintendent actually created goals for herself that were beyond the goals that were set that were existing uh back in September October when the report card came out so the stretch is what's been raised and that means what was there was the base expectations we had of the superintendent so initially the direction to me from the board was to utilize our strategic plan and our goals and guard rails I wrote I pull these goals directly from the board approved goals and guard rails I didn't change

022anything I didn't think I had the Liberty to do that or so I didn't but then the feedback I received the last time was that uh this was after the meeting in an email that just to Mr Lindy's point they were not rigorous enough in comparison to other students who are economically disadvantaged in our state so in a good faith effort to consider the email he shared I made an adjustment I thought following what his suggestion was the concern for me around this is it's outside of what I was originally asked to do two it really gives me less than 30 school days to accomplish three uh everyone else who is working on these kind of goals they have agreements that don't allow me to change what we have agreed to as their goal so

023I'm doing this in isolation with 30 school days left when you consider the state test is the week after spring break so the beginning of April so you think about where we are right now with the number of school days available so uh as I talked through this with Mr Crossett trying to understand the scoring system we thought if we kept the base from the Strategic plan from the goals and guard rails that could be one measure but to satisfy the thought that this is looking at us being in the bottom 25% of the state which is not what I created um the um we named them stretch goals so it it considers um where we are with the goals and guard rails and where we've been over the last couple of years but it

024also takes into account this 60% measure to follow the current board policy so that's where those numbers are coming from so the base from third grade reading essentially was 47.5 according to our goals and guardate s my goal was 61 which is in parentheses which is based on what the gos and guard rails call for the stretch is in this blue 63% which takes in account um I wasn't we weren't growing fast enough but this has changed on me after nine months of work so that's where we are so the base numbers is what we had expected before this is where we started two years ago I would say when the goals and guard worlds were written so we were lower our expectations were lower yes ma'am last year year before oh yeah MH yes

025on at least some of these are all of the okay I just was unclear about the stretch goals uh and and the base piece for the evaluation I don't know if this is part of the the what the policy will there be uh opportunity for any commentary uh in the evaluation document I know we've lived through that issue uh before I didn't know have we made arrangements that the evaluation would include any commentary from uh uh board members or not uh just so will be strictly a scoring survey piece so I think that question should go to someone in the policy if I'm not mistaken um and um previous committee members correct me if I'm wrong but I believe that that additional feedback or commentary would be encompassing the 10% um as we are expecting

026to do like regular check-ins as well as the 30% where we're able to um continue to have that dialogue with the uh superintendent along the way so the 60% is mostly those measurables um whereas the other aspects of the percentages and it does include that that commentary that you're speaking about and the surveys not only from um you know us but from uh other constituents within the district thank you that's uh thank you for the clarification were were you done no I mean just the but the verbal is is will be verbal and it will not be necessarily publicly shared Bo member Lindy yeah I I appreciate it thank you I know I've talked before and I think I think I may have genuinely misread some of this having heard the superintendent's most recent comments

027and I would just like to check because if I did misread it I can walk back some of what I said earlier and if I did read it correctly um then I can just you know stay where I was but I think um superintendent I think I misinterpreted what those numbers were in parenthesis yes sir I think you missed the last conversation but this is in direct resp response to the email you sent right after yeah I don't want to mess up the dates or I was trying to respond to your suggestion I I appreciate it part of what gets so confusing about this is that um the from numbers I think date back to when the board approved the original goals and guard rails so they were they were spaced out over periods of

028years right I think that's correct so on time for this year would have been the 61% but what I heard heard you m please what I heard you say I don't know if it was the last board meeting or not what I heard you say previously no not heard you say but in an email was you were questioning the rigor so I looked at the calculation that you shared in that email and I tried to align that calculation so that it would better meet your expectation and I I want to say thank you I I really appreciate this I think part of what gets so confusing about the way these and this is not something that you did just an artifact of these having been around now for a couple of years but if we

029just take the first bullet where it says the percentage of third grade readers or sorry third graders proficient in Reading will increase from 47.5% I get confused because that's where we started a couple years ago if we look at last year's report card we were at 57% and so I was misreading the number you had in parenthesis but if if you're saying here that gosh we finished on last year's report card at 57% and you'd like us to move from 57% to 63% this year I think that feels quite ambitious I'd even be willing to entertain a lower number well let's do a lower number um no like I think and I think still not good it's still but but but I think this is why I think I think the data can be so

030helpful uh truly because I think to to say that we're going to do something that has never been done before sounds great but it's really hard to hold something somebody accountable for doing something that's never been done before and so one the reason I shared those numbers was that we could see what would it mean to be in the top cortile it would mean about four percentage points of improvement and so what you've proposed here uh is I think even more than that it's certainly fine with me I think if I just zoom out for a second I know I was I was coming across uh very directly before it's because I was very worried that we were modeling a lowering of expectations for children I don't want us to do that uh I'm very

031very grateful that there's been an effort to raise the bar since the first conversation we've had and and really I just want to say thank you for that and I want to say thank you to Mr Crossett for the the model scoring guide which I think is quite clear and quite helpful I'm I'm happy to be wrong on any of those things and take feedback from others but I wanted to walk back and say I can move that down to 62% it's going to be what we vote on but I think I think anything that would put us in that top core tile is something I think we should be proud of I did read your email I did respond so happy to respond vice president Bolton yeah I just uh I'm glad we getting

032some of this cleared up and I I think it's great to be moving forward on all of this um but I appreciated Mr Lindy's uh selection of the cohort of comparison based I think it was about economically challenged or what have you as a cohort um I tried to look at some of those districts and and the only thing I would say is that it's so crazy when the state tries to figure out who our peers are I never quite understand the lists that they create but but the the poverty piece to me is not the tell all regarding a cohort uh in many of those districts um you you may have significant poverty you may have significant uh economic disadvantage but the one of the problems that I think the challenges that we face

033is the diversity within uh our population and the uh if you talk in terms of second language or you talk in terms of students with disabilities those are the kinds of things when it comes to testing that actually start to drive your numbers um um uh over a pretty Rocky Road U so I think that it would be great if somebody statistically could actually come up with some truer cohorts that we could measure ourselves against because I really don't like the ones the state's choosing and I know that the poverty piece is not enough of a of a comparison because poverty is not necessarily the issue it's the it's the challenges that certain kids have um regarding uh actually taking tests and and and and and scholarship and and achievement initially um on a standardized

034test so uh it'd be great to find May making an assignment let's try to find some cohorts that actually uh are kind of replicate our situation and our student population M so I'm going to just comment my my comment first and then um we can go back around again I think that um I want to say thank you to superintendent Murphy for trying to take into account all seven people's uh varying opinions one thing that I think we can agree on although we may come at it a different way is that even 40 whether it's 47.5% or 63% or 61% we have significant work to do for our students within this District to move it um I appreciate the aggressive um intention and I think that that is one of the reasons why I believed

035that we could make you the permanent superintendent because I think that that is what is needed is to be aggressive I have said before when we talked about GS and guard roles last year and the year before we're talking about low numbers and that should not be acceptable by any to to anyone within this District I do have concerns that your we're changing your goals Midstream and the entire other administrative team has different numbers so to my colleagues I think we need to give that some consideration perhaps we need to be consistent for the remainder of this year and then have ambitious goals like maybe we can have the the target be in parentheses and the original goal that is consistent with the remainder of the district be what the target is and then um

036leave the the higher numbers for um ambitious intent to be to be for next year upon review of where we where we end up Landing and maybe they can change but they could be a baseline for the future but I think that to consistency across the district would be would be my suggestion I also would like to ask my colleagues a little bit I'm I'm I'm going to say this and this is not in defense of the superintendent but as a board member I'm a little confused about the scoring rubric and how we got here with regard to the numbers because when I look at the superintendent evaluation from 2022 2 and 2023 we had student achievement be 10% communication was 10% we had percentages and we're now switching to a 60% for the standards

037and while I agree that that should be a lot I think we're not consistent amongst ourselves which I think again leads the superintendent to be kind of all over around being providing for us what we want um I'm not clear on where surveys come into place or board member comments come into place I think that should be waited and I don't quite understand where that falls so that's also to my colleagues on the policy I just I am a little confused with how this um all weighs out with regard to in totality how we are evaluating the superintendent um in part to my new colleagues because I'm a little confused because we've been we've we've had changes for so many years and it was a percentage and I I just am confused so I I

038think that we need to get a little bit more clarity amongst ourselves before we impart that on you you've definitely tried to raise the bar and I'm appreciative I think 63% but I would like for it to be achievable and realistic but most importantly I want it to be consistent with what the remainder of the leadership team is having to do so I'm going to suggest that maybe we put this put the the the original targets as the goal and then put the higher numbers as a parenthese to reach if so but I don't know if that I don't know how my colleagues feel about that what if you look at what I've proposed here um the original targets are worth a a score of five if the stretch goals are achieved it's a six

039worth more it's a there's a bonus in there so I feel like I've kind of accommodated your concern already a little bit it may not be what the rest of the board agrees to but that's something that I just suggested and your suggestion was for this year to do it that way yeah and I think the other thing to keep in mind is the policy is also supposed to be looking at a three-year Trend it's not just every year individually and so um obviously looking back three years is different superintendence but uh that is also something to be incorporated as we go into the future and set goals it's it's not just Make It or Break It in one year it's supposed to look over a over a period of years to look for a

040trend that's another component of of this uh review that should be you know if we have another covid or if we have an economic crisis those things could affect the student outcome that beyond the control of the school district thank you for member Craig so can I just maybe make a suggestion because I think we've been on this for somewhere close to 40 minutes now and I don't think we're going to get any closer to getting to a final this way um that I think the superintendent received some feedback on the actual goals themselves that certainly can be uh modified or adjusted and that there's a formula that's been proposed and again maybe that's something that could be modified adjusted but that that could be something we task someone with and as an assignment to

041bring back to the board for our next meeting rather than spending more time tonight going back and forth on different parts of it because I just you know quite honestly there's a lot of stuff that we have to do on the agenda and there's a lot of stuff that we are trying to get to and I think if we spend 50 minutes every time talking about the superintendent goals while that may be great and helpful we're not getting her a goal that we're going to judge her on and it may not be something that's perfect it may not be something all of us necessarily always agree on but I think it we owe it to her because we are more than two months late for what we said we would do and so I I

042just maybe propose that we assign that to someone or assign that to Collective of a couple board members to work on whatever the formula might be and allow superintendent to work on um to modify that last modification there and be presented at the last next board meeting for us to kind of uh then at that point vote on because I just think we're going to we can keep doing this every meeting but it's not necessarily the most productive way to do it thank you um I'm going to let the chair or is it are you the chair of policy okay uh I think we should have tked tasked this to your committee but let you have the last word on this and and I'm I'm if we need to move to closure you know I

043understand I'm not going to win every vote you know we can call a vote we can get it done we're going to revisit this again in the fall like in in in six months so I I think if in terms of moving forward I want to support what Mr Craig was saying I just I wanted to go back for a second to what Miss Bolton was saying I just wanted to hear more about what you meant when you said it's not so much the poverty level as it is the diversity of the students quickly very quickly when you look at the the testing piece poverty obviously is a general condition General uh uh part of the cohort that that has been used but but when you're looking at whether or not young people can take

044particular tests or whether or not they get special dispensation or in state of Ohio don't get special dispensation because of their particular learning disabilities which is the case with our state tests on the state report card or whether or not they are English language Learners those things tend to drive down you their ability to achieve on a particular test more so than necessarily the condition of poverty thank you I appreciate that I think the thing I wanted to say and I want us to be really careful of is I think it can uh and I'm not saying this is what you were saying Miss Bolton but when sometimes when I hear people say it's not so much about the economic it's about the diversity of student students um can feel super racist and that we

045have different expectations for white low-income students than low-income students of color and again I'm not saying that's what you are saying I just want to be really clear that as a board I hope this is true um we think we can do important in powerful things with all of our students um and I wanted to make sure I said that out loud thank you and and as we say at least twice a year between the two of us in this conversation you're right that's not the issue the issue is taking tests if you have particular learning disabilities or if your language is not first English on the Ohio tests that's going to have more of an impact on the achievement of the total than necessarily whether or not young people are in poverty okay I'm

046going to stop this discussion I think the superintendent has more than enough information and conver and uh thoughts from the board members we will probably have to pick this up again I'm going to move down board members Craig and Crossett please update us about the treasurer search so uh board members met with and interviewed three candidates um and after thorough interview with each of the three we have narrowed it down to two so um and so those two will be interviewed um on the 19th and the goal with the goal of uh selecting a person to um to become our new treasure and so the hopes is that we would have someone selected that will give us enough of a runtime to uh allow them to work with our current treasur um and be able

047to on board get them up to speed that we would be uh having them here in a time frame that also allow them to start working so it'll be able to fast move through future uh um work on future budgets so uh right now it's just we got two folks that we're going to meet with on the 19th do born MERS have any questions B vice president B could could we share with the public their opportunity to participate or when does that play into the selection um so what we did decide to do is to since Treasures role is such a unique role in that uh it's so heavily connected to how School financing and school funding works we did establish two groups to kind of be participatory to give us feedback who would have

048a kind of a more connected relationship to our budget in the and how a District budget works so we had uh members of our audit committee as well as members of the staff for the treasures office as one group and then also uh an invitation if it hasn't hasn't already gone out would be going out out to our labor leaders um to invite them to also participate in the process to be able to give feedback to both candidates and then the board would have additional time to ask any other follow-up feedback uh to those followup questions we might have with regard to the uh candidates and um you know again I think our Our Hope and our dream is that we will have you know great opportunity to hear from the feedback from our uh

049audit committee folks and our labor union folks as to their uh thoughts and ideas with around each candidate and that would help fuel our uh understanding and help us make a clear decision great thank you thank you any other board members have questions all right moving on do board members have any acknowledgements or announcements board member Weinberg yes so if we could all look at the screen d I'll wait till the picture is up before I get started okay so I would like to take a quick moment to give a early Kudos um and a congratulations to president Moffett for being named the recipient of the 2025 osba training award and this training award is part of the star awards in which it represents service training aptitud ude and recognition and this is given by

050the Ohio School Board Association hold on I'm not done I'm not done let me get it all out first let me get it all out it's given by the Ohio School Board Association the award um it reflects one's true commitment to public education their role as a school board member and only 41 out of 3400 board members will receive the recognition and she will be receiving it on March the 6 so let's give her a big round of applause so early congratulations and that's all that I have for today and I did not send my picture in but I wanted to say thank you so much to Mr Beck and the north Avendale AI Club cuz they taught me about AI there were some I think a former board member Melanie bat's grandson was in

051there and they were super excited to teach me about Ai and what I needed to know so I'm on going back again but we had a great time so thank you and I think there are multiple AI clubs within our district but that one invited me out and so I want to make sure I say thank you vice president Bolton yes thank you very much one of the pleasures that I have uh being on the board is being appointed to the Recreation Commission as a representative of the district and uh just wanted to announce this is a pretty big deal within the state of Ohio and nationally as well uh the governor's management uh Innovation award for 2024 went to the Cincinnati Recreation uh department and commission uh for their uh wreck at night program

052which occurred on uh Saturday nights throughout the summer for our young people in many of our recreation centers uh it was every Saturday night throughout the entire summer providing safe inclusive spaces plenty of activities and indeed the best press that I think teenagers have gotten in a long time throughout the summer uh it was a great opportunity for the kids and for the grown-ups that gave their their Saturday nights uh part of the recreation uh team that uh does a great job but this award is very important and indeed's being recognized now nationally as something wonderful for our young people especially our kids um who often get such a bad rap in the press and such worry about Gathering they had great times and uh congratulations to the wreck people Bo yes I want to

053uh extend the kudos to uh Dr Manisha house um who's the director of positive School culture for really um taking the lead to just make sure that the social and emotional Wellness is woven throughout our district and that this is becoming a part of our culture I was so excited to attend the uh graduation for the juvenile uh Detention Center because that was the first graduation that was hosted and to see the the students the graduates feeling really proud and accomplished um and also for the staff to be excited to have a different framework and model to follow which is the PBIS framework and so it has really reframed their way of thinking about restorative practices and working with our students and so I was just so grateful to see that and then also I

054had the uh opportunity to just see an action after leaving our policy committee last uh meeting last week to see uh our custodians to see our security um to see uh those that are working in Food Services to be informed about trauma informed care to be informed about how to um support our students because they interface with our students on a regular basis and to see the energy and the excitement about having the tools uh to support our students and provide that safe and healthy culture so I just want to give a huge shout out to uh Dr minisha House in addition to her team and and lastly I'll just say just seeing the facilitators our counselors our social workers leading the charge it was an amazing thing to see and I did forget to

055say that our department of student services had a Workforce open house that was awesome so thank you for all the work that they're doing too super sorry superintendent Murphy do you have any announcements and retirements yes one retirement today from a teacher from Mount Washington School Miss Patricia m Aus is retiring congratulations ation to her and then I have I believe three Kudos I do want to share so the first goes to uh student Sonia mumal she's a ninth grade shist who plays second at the Sphinx organization music competition this is a national competition that brings together the top students from across the country congratulations to her [Applause] and the Rothenberg spelling be oh my goodness it was so much fun it was a packed house lots of parents lots of community members on January

056the 29th they had their Annual Spelling be and we want to offer a congratulations to student Le Danel blaton he won first place and then this last one I want to give a deep appreci appreciation to everyone who is a part of the office of school and Community Partnerships uh last week we hosted a partner refresh meeting at the 1819 building it was it that it was a packed house extremely well attended thank you to the board members who were able to come out I was really really refreshing to see them and to be able to host them for that morning thank [Applause] you vice president Bolton the chair is yours to please conduct our hearing of the public thank you very much we are now at the item of our agenda for hearing the

057public each speaker will have two minutes and we'll address all comments to the presiding officer if you're online once a request to speak has been granted you'll be invited to enter you should click on the camera icon to go interactive provide your name your affiliation to the district your school Community your topic and your contact information if you'd like a response to any questions you might have this request is consistent with board protocol and we'll and we appreciate your help in the unusual event that someone is not willing to follow this protocol we reserve the right to end the person's Time online again each person will have two minutes to speak when the timer goes off your time is up please refrain from discussing any Personnel matters after speaking if you're online you'll briefly see

058the welcome screen again as you transition back to the live stream meeting finally we ask that your public commentary be respectful of all listeners thank you very much and I have no cards in front of me do we have anyone online chair Bolton we have two online speakers today and do we have any iners we have no inperson speakers today wow great okay want me to read it again again I'll try to all right our first speaker is going to be hersel Daniels herel J hersel you can unmute your camera and microphone and we will start your time I'm trying to unmute my well I'm unmuted there I you're ready to go I'm ready to go all right I want to thank the board for this time and the presiding officer uh on December 17th

059as I wrote the board and uh told you I was going to re-engage into the Cincinnati public schools uh after being absent uh for over a decade I was a lsdmc member uh when you uh were doing the billion dollar build and so I'm coming back as part owner of uh company Hershel Daniels Jr LLC under board policy uh where you invited Business Partnership and so when I wrote to you on December 17th and the followup in uh in January through the superintendent who convened a starting an investigation of what we proposed uh let me say that I'm part of an 800 member Coalition that has created an88 billion do agreement with PNC Bank I sent you the information in the background and that uh we're going to be meeting on March 25th in Washington

060DC over 12200 of us uh Cincinnati public schools in my mind's eye because I'm a grandfather and uh my family has a vested interest with over 30 40 kids and CPS uh to make it the best so we've got a Wall Street broker going to issue the letter of commitment we're looking to follow up with you and the superintend investigative team uh as an ex lsdmc member I'm sorry to have missed uh the event but uh my wife's brother just died and so we've been consumed uh by uh dealing with that uh we look forward to coming uh to you uh the World Conference of Mayors uh has supported this National policy Alliance uh the national Black Chamber of Commerce Ohio that is time thank you you our next speaker is Jennifer myy of the

061NAACP Jennifer go ahead your m is mute your mic is muted I'm sorry I'll start again good evening CPS Schoolboard president Moffett members of the board and CPS leadership my name is Jennifer Mye and I am the education committee chair for the Cincinnati NAACP David Whitehead is our president happy Black History Month the NAACP scholarship is now open this scholarship I'm sorry 2025 this scholarship is only available for Cincinnati public schools we are seeking students who have at least a 2.5 GPA and complete the application by March 30th the scholarships are named after Cincinnati activists like Wendell P Dabney Wanita Adams Carla s Irvine and Charles Rock the axo competition is also accepting applications axo was founded by founded in 1978 by author and journalist Vernon Jared axo inspires black students to expand their Horizons

062and sharpen their skills from performing to culinary arts to science and technology engineering and math and stem students can demonstrate their talents in up to three competitions information about the scholarship and AO can be found at NAACP I'm sorry Cincinnati ncp.com I've named individuals who supported the black community and left a legacy of their commitment I urge you to continue two-way conversation with the black community to leave a legacy that the district is truly here for kids thank you okay superintendent Murphy please present the 2025 26 school calendar yes ma'am thank you I think General council hoing is going to join me in this uh conversation we are bringing this calendar back to you you had previously approved it however current Administration and others sought some clarification around language that was used in the calendar

063that had been just slightly different from what we had used in the past and so we wanted to be able to speak clearly about the calendar to all constituent groups and so we're asking you uh for your review and approval of this updated calendar would you be able to describe what has changed like to summarize what the difference is between year to year that you're submitting for absolutely so initially for one area is during the summer we did not have summer school um considered and then there were a few other areas around whether something was a professional day and I don't know Dan if you can help me with the specifics on that part previously previously was based on um days it's now it's now an hour's requirement for the full year that's right the

064only thing I'd add is that under 33134 a the board has to approve calendars which is why we're bringing it to you uh it's uh to be shared with the board at least 30 days in a public hearing at least 30 days before the vote on the approval of the calendar it also has to be shared with our um private roal non-pb schools in the district which uh we also will be sharing it with with them and one other thing Madam president I think it's accurate we move back the start of school by a week a week yes moved it up moved it later in the later in August okay do board members have any questions member weberg yes for my particular question if you you can go up to January um or go down

065um to yes right there I just wanted to make sure so for the 5th it's a district PD Day meaning are we starting on the 6th yes we would be starting on Tuesday the 6th the rationale behind that is we had that date this year later in the month but we thought it would be less disruptive to families if we just kept those dates from The Break um together as opposed to then they have to find another right no absolutely yes thank you any other War member mat um yes I don't I think this was uh included on the previous uh calendars but I think it would be helpful if possible if we were able to include like the testing window uh the State Testing window to the calendar just for um our edification as

066well as for families yes and then there's one more thing on here uh for the board to just make sure we're highlighting the change and pushing us uh having a later start in August means that we'll be coming back to school after Memorial Day and we have not had that in a few years you said that so Memorial day is May the 25th and we would be coming back that's Tuesday Wednesday and then the kids would be out on the 28th uh the quarter would end on the 28th so we would have children and then we would not on the 29th that would be a teacher workday so it still be the month of May but board member W so I did not realize excuse me that that fell on that day what was the

067rationale for putting um School a week later versus what it was last year's calendar and the year before that we felt that uh coming back in on the six or I guess it would have been the fifth this year didn't give us enough time to prepare to have the professional development to allow teachers time to set up their classrooms um and this is a return to what we have most recently had in the last several years this this year was an exception I don't know the rationale for that um but it this will give us more time to prepare to open school so even with this the late um the earlier start time does it still mean that could we still push up the end of the school uh week before versus the week later

068it's a later start in August than what we we're moving down to the okay I'm yes ma'am so because of the later start could we still somehow move it back to the um Before Memorial Day so that is three school days I'm just curious if if students are going to still come to school after that date of having the holiday that's just my concern I'm going to we have done that before we have had that before it's been a moment do you remember what year that was I'm just curious do I I don't remember the year I'm thinking it was even while I was a high school principal so uh it's been a while but you know the principles don't come back until like the first of August so it just makes things a little

069more challenging if we left it earlier in the month of August thank you remember Craig um just wanted to uh stress the fact that I think when we had this discussion last time there was the conversation between trade-offs so the trade-offs were you start the year earlier and you may not have people at the first days of class and it also puts us in positions where things like bus transportation and these other things you're giving a lesser time to to resolve some of those issues that may be coming up in those first weeks of school or we go we get out earlier which we recognize and appreciate the fact that some students families may make trips and plans around Memorial Day I distinctly know that I was in school past Memorial Day because that's my

070my my diploma has a June date on it yeah so it is not like we've never done um school day goes into it and it's not like we're the only School District that will go past Memorial Day in fact several school districts even locally go well into June so I don't think that's as big a concern for me I just I wanted to make sure that we had and I think it was a lot of hard work to to do this originally and a lot of good work being done to update some things but just making sure that we gave consideration to a lot of the factors I know last time one of the things that was discussed was trying to ensure that we didn't hit on holidays we didn't hit on these type of

071things so that important days or days that were valuable to uh folks because of their needs may not be uh may not conflict so I just wanted to kind of give you an opportunity to speak to a little bit to that yes we took all of those things into consideration the the committee took all of those things um into consideration uh I think this still leaves us uh two weeks at the winter break for families who do things together at that time it still leads a full spring break just about at the end of March for families um and it also still honors the week at Thanksgiving uh I remember when we used to be in school till Wednesday and it got and people would disappear on Tuesdays so it still Honors that whole uh

072that entire week around the holiday seasons we M Matt uh yes can you just speak to how the additional hours are built in since it's not focused on the number of days but it's you know recommended by hour so can you speak to how we've included that in there yes so um this is basically a um translation a calculation of the days that we would have and we've been well over the minimums that we've needed to have and so we've had to then change it to the hourly calculation so the same number of days um each school year so you'll see at the top well about Midway down um the student days in the fall 171 the teacher days uh 191 which meets the standard and then we just translate it into the number of

073hours okay I didn't know if it had anything to do with like how much you know by extending it out another week if that impacted the we're in great we're in really really great shape one Lindy um thank you I uh I appreciate all the work that's gone into this I would just like to see approve it as soon as we possibly can um so that families can plan for next year uh am I right in hearing we can't we can't do that tonight it's got to be out for 30 more days so we'll submit it for your approval on the 17th but we talked about post unless there's objection from the board posting it on our website as a propos so so families can see what the calendar looks like now or after this

074meeting that's great my my my my motivation is try to get info to parents as soon as we can that's thank you we talked about having it be like a draft and until it's voted on and then it'll it'll St final to be approved on March 6 17th yes and I'm going to just add that I might be old but I remember June dates where we were in school in June some of us have forgotten conveniently but we went to like June 10th June 9th I mean it's okay for kids to be in school in June so yes I think this is great any other questions from board members okay you thank you so um who is presenting the resolution we don't have a date down here um someone from policy the resolution for the

075filing of the um 21 original Board of revision complaints is authorized by the Hamilton count I'm happy to provide a very brief summary though I think our general council is also very well positioned to share a short update on that Dan we'll have you come back up and some explanation um is this the the uh the properties filing resolution thank you so the policy committee has been uh as as we consider policies the committee's been asked whether or not to include items in the consent agenda or whether to separate uh policies out just so that the board has an opportunity to consider it maybe discuss it and um vote on it so I think there's two before you this evening the first is um a new Step uh based on coun I think we're even

076one item prior to this this is just about the property values oh I'm sorry yes this is eight sorry that's okay I was I was trying to roll with you D don't know where you were thank you very much so tonight we're submitting for your uh consideration 211 properties for that the district would like to file complaints against the valuation with the board of revision this is based on property sales uh there's got to be a a materiality element of at least $500,000 Plus at least a 10% increase uh in the sale price compared to the value that those properties are listed on the auditor site uh we'll file those complaints uh with your permission there's a new statute that requires the board to pass a resolution for each and every one of those complaints

077that are filed so this is something we've done every year brought to you properties that we're proposing to file new complaints on and this is just noticed do we need to vote or anything on this one those are resolutions there's a master resolution so you can vote one time for all all the properties listed that so moved second any discussion further what member Matt yes uh so General Council Dan could you please uh just share briefly about the financial impact of um these set properties and also is it possible that these set properties are parel of land could be subjected to tax abatements like would they be able to be approved for tax abatements so on the first question it it certainly is related to um their the property evaluation in the city is directly

078related to the amount of tax revenue that the district receives in local funds so the the district is keeping track of and watching property values and and in these cases there were sales that significantly exceed what the board of revision value is so that's why we're filing a complaint in order to try to bring those those uh the value of those complaints up to the sale price in terms of abatements that's that's a separate process there are there is an opportunity for uh new development uh to seek abatement that's through the that's through a city process um would not would not impact these these resolutions okay all right thank you y treas Wagner I just wanted to make a comment that um on the revenue side it only impacts our fixed rate levies our fix

079some levies don't change no matter what happens to property values I just don't want anybody think we're going to get with this big rush money uh vice president Bolton good she she took care of it oh okay board member Lindy no I was I was jumping to the next one oh okay this one needs to be does anybody have anything else about this one all right let's go to the next one board M Lindy oh wait I'm so sorry I'm just I thought we were going to do one vote for all of them one vote for so we didn't vote but I thought we were we going to put okay let's take a vote you're voting for each different resolution but there's 21 properties in this resolution give you one vote that's right it's a

080master resolution that gives the board's approval to file complaints on each of those 21 cases that's right okay treasure wag Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president mofet yes now board member please update us about the resolution adopting new board policy sure so um this General Council was referencing this a moment ago uh and just as a as a process Point um as we're doing more with a consent agenda than we used to I think there's more even more that we could do but one of the things we're trying to do is proactively pull out recommendations from policy that might warrant some discussion or questions uh and more routine um cleanup items putting in the consent agenda at least is a default

081for this one um there this is a function of a new state law that requires school districts to adopt um what we've called here a Prohibition of affirmations of specific beliefs um which the statute language that you can see on board docs basically says the district shall not require any employee to believe certain things we shall not require any student to believe certain things parents to believe certain things um it's it's it's open-ended it doesn't Define what the specific things are um but we are we are following the um new state laws requirements to ensure that our district doesn't impose belief restrictions on um those different stakeholder groups so if you if you if you're interested the language in the statute parrots exactly what's in the statute so thank you um is there a motion

082to and I move to um adopt the resolution is there a second second second somebody somebody any further discussion uh vice president Bolton um it seems somewhat twisted uh from a standpoint of I think think it makes good sense about the preventing anybody from it's some sort of affirmation of particular beliefs at a time when indeed the same organization that is presenting this to us indeed is exercising apparently its com uh its um plenary rights uh and ability to to tell a lot of people what they're supposed to be or not be and how they're supposed to be treated or not treated but knowing that this is the law and knowing that uh this is what is required of us I just continue to find that not I'm not the hypocrisy but the the Twisted

083nature of of uh what is is coming to us uh from Columbus but certainly we have to have this as our policy or member Lindy uh I I will affirm that it is dark out there uh I will just add that the original language on this was titled affirmations of specific beliefs and we changed it to Prohibition on affirmation of specific beliefs was a team effort you got to love our you got to love our policy committee we are working together I love it and and you know it's to your point it's really it's it's good for people to know that there are things we have to do because we have to do them and it doesn't mean that we like them but we can manipulate and strategize where we can so thank you any

084other further discussion all right let's take a vote Jia Wagner Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes M map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president M yes board member Matt please update us about the resolution amending board policy 3440 okay yes so this actually came out of the budget and finance committee um but essentially the policy is to switch from complete reimbursement to uh perdum uh reimbursement for uh travel uh as well as Mill expenses um and so my understanding and Mr Gustin could correct me as well um Mr to really help us to become more uh fiscally sound and more um uh just Financial stewards of our dollars and so this has been the recommendation from uh the budget and finance uh committee and these expenses also have to

085be pre-approved by the treasurer and I invite anyone from the budget and finance committee to um add some additional information if necessary so is there a motion that so I moved to adopt uh the uh resolution about Job expenses second second thank you any further discussion for member Craig I just wanted to add on part of the discussion around this also comes from the work that the audit team is done and recognizing that having to gather receipts for each of these transactions for meals has become somewhat problematic and overly complicated because for instance if you you know had a flight that got delayed laid and you decide to buy lunch at the airport not permitted but you fly 4 hours and you buy lunch on the plane potentially or you land somewhere and you buy

086lunch it is so like things like that were very complicated and did not always make for easy um understanding and so now using the PDM it will just also make the work more efficient and also it takes a little bit of the stress off of the one person whose task was to make sure all of those receipts were correct um and so I think that is again shows you how much we're working with so little staff doing such large amounts of work and why things like this are a great way to prove that efficiency and manage the workload in a more effective manner so give a little credit to some recommendations from the audit team um it's been a discussion point that we've made at the a committee meeting a couple times now any further

087comments or questions so treasure Wagner take a vote Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes M map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president M yes um we've had one additional topic um vice president Bolton would you describe the next topic regarding the Xavier monor lab school yes I have a u possible uh floor motion uh for consideration uh some background uh some weeks ago we heard uh information from the administration that uh about the closing of the Xavier University Monas lab school and that that closure might uh provide or present an opportunity for the district our district to begin a monory lab school in Cincinnati public schools the Administration has asked for direction from the board as to whether or not to move forward much work has already been done

088but this is a motion uh to direct the administration to move forward with the proposal to open a monory lab school at Bramble nature campus I so move and hope for a second and discussion and ultimate passage thank you for hearing the motion from the floor is there a second second any further discussion board member Craig so I think again I think this is uh something we've talked about in the past about the work we're going to be doing with this I think it would be helpful to um reassure both the public and I guess also the board that what we will do also in in approving this is that it also the expectation is that there would be updates on a regular basis as to the progress and as to potential uh additional costs

089associated with the move so that it is something part of our regular budget uh discussion because we recognize if there are additional costs that'll result in us having to make other decisions and so as long as you know as we think about this making sure and then the other part that I want to also kind of make sure we're thinking about as we do this as well is just at some point having the longer term future discussion as to what would this school develop into I think we're having the short-term discussion as to bring the school in um but I think we also need to have the longer term discussion as to the opportunity for what the school will look like and what the expectations are um and then the third thing I would say

090is that I think we also want want to look into the potentials for and I think it's something you already doing but the potentials for how do we educate our current teachers in our monory schools on the monory standards using the resources that we would be getting from the uh bringing in this lab school because I think that's the other that was part of the goal of doing this was that it would be it would allow us to free up costs that we're spending paying someone else to do this process for our for our teachers to be able to do it ourselves and potentially do more Stu more teachers each year than uh we normally would any other discussion do you have your thing I'm particularly excited about the ability for our us to train

091our own teachers around the monory program and not have it be an additional cost to them so so I really do hope we get that up and running and that's one big reason why I want to support this is because it will allow our staff to be trained in something that there's clearly a need for and a desire for but it has been cross cost prohibitive and then also we can be continue to be our Trend Setters and train other people around the city and maybe around the region that want to get monory train and can pay us to do that and then maybe stay so I would hope that we can also consider some I don't know what it's called where uh exchange for training like you know you do so many years for

092us and then we train you maybe we can be creative with our training so that we could not only generate some Revenue but also increase our staff um of trained professionals so any other discussion vice president Bolton yes I want to second with but you said president and also what uh member Craigs mentioned uh I think two that I I I'm a very big believer uh in uh our heritage as the national leader in monu public education I'm also a big believer that you invest in your assets you don't always dwell on your deficits uh and this is a great opportunity because one of the things that has held us back on many occasions is the ability for us to get our many many wonderful monory teachers properly licensed properly recogn ized with the proper

093credentials and now this will allow us to do that in a way that is is is very exciting and to your point uh president I think um this continues then our our leadership nationally and as we heard in one of the meetings long a little while ago internationally as well regarding monor education so this is a great opportunity any other discussion so let's vote on the motion on the floor Treasurer Wagner so I have a question uh Mr hoing do I need a 48 hour waiver because this no just a motion thank you just double checking okay Mr Craig yes Mr cron yes Mr Lindy yes M map abstain Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president mofin yes superintendent Murphy please introduce our next topic all right gladly uh Mr burkart is going to

094join me today uh we are very excited to share with you our project management plan and some other details just to give you update on where we are with the district performance redesign sustainability and growth plan phase two and so uh just a real quick snippet of Mr Burkhart uh bringing together members of all of the schools involved and departments that are needed to make this uh plan work in time for the start of the school year Mr brart thank you good evening I'm very excited to uh give you an update to the growth plan phase two implementation I'm even more excited to let you know that there is only one slide in this slide de for tonight Rob can you click on so the one the the one slide Al uh shows our um

095work that we are doing in relation to the growth plan so as we are moving forward we started these meetings on January 8th and they happen every two weeks that those meetings happen here at the Ed Center and in room 110 and we consider it the room where it happens if you know the Hamilton reference is the room in which we make sure that all phases of the growth plan are being addressed and that we're answering questions as I move left to right on the spreadsheet that you will see uh in front of you the first uh tab has the overview of uh what is happening within the district in relation to each School the current grades as well as the grades for next year as well as a description of any changes that are

096happening if we move over to the right we have Global questions and those questions come from uh principles and school leadership teams about the actual process in relation to the growth Phase 2 we also color code those so once they are actually answered they're either they color coded as green meaning they are done yellow is we still have some answers but we need to finalize it and if it's color-coded red it means that we need an answer as quick as possible because it's a very important topic as we mooved right across the spreadsheet we have a pathway Matrix which shows everyone the pathways within each Corridor and the grade bands within each one of those corridors as students progress um for example through the East Corridor the Central Corridor or the West Corridor uh the

097next tab has all of our school name names along with uh we have not filled in all the irns yet but if we happen to need a new irn and or a new name um this is where we would capture that information on either of those two as we move to the right we have projections um from uh 13125 and those are the projection the updated projections u based on our greatest information uh for each school and so that any point in time anyone can go look for the latest greatest information we're considering this spreadsheet a One-Stop shop for any questions in relation to the growth plan as we move forward we are looking at the master Move schedule and this is a a uh work in progress so as we have dates in relation

098to moving one school to another or moving teachers or moving U materials we are going through each one of those in a systematic method so everyone can look and see what we are moving when where and how um additionally we have key dates so those key dates are each one of the growth meetings as well as each one of the um uh special tasks that are associated within um these are working documents so right now we have everything updated through uh March and April and as those new dates come on we will make sure that those go on this as well as we move forward to the right we have all of our schools listed each school has the possibility of um asking questions within each Corridor um as well as in each functional area

099so we have teacher Staffing and building Staffing which is um uh answered by the HRT staff Transportation student dining purchasing itm phones Communications facility needs student needs new office needs within enrollment budget curriculum master schedule Partners community and parents Athletics and other so in each one of these tabs each one of those are spelled out again we are also using the green yellow and red method to make sure that we are highlighting each of one of those areas um as as we're moving along so every school is represented here uh we are asking the team and the team is mighty to go in every week and provide answers and making sure that their information is updated um we also with within the room have all of the principles and school leadership teams as well as

100all the department directors that we uh will go through every school one by one to be able to have some Standalone time to be able to make sure every question is answered so obviously this is a work in progress every other week we get together we solve any outstanding issues and look to the Future on how we're going to make sure that all of the phases of the implementation plan are operational by August 1st that's my one slide thank you for the brevity board members do you have any questions board member Weinberg I do apologize I may have missed this already but what do the colors mean the green the yellow and the red yeah so uh if you look at the global questions or any of the um others if it's onv I'm on

101the overview page oh on the overview so they overview the colors are either merger reconsolidation consolidation or restructure so we have those and you can see on the notes on the right hand side it says what is actually happening to each one of those sites that's important because in the uh uh CBA language um it talks about what happens to staff in a restructure versus a consolidation so we wanted to make sure that we called those out so at each school we know exactly what's happening to um each building so that staff knows what type of CBA language they're governed under as they make transitions from one building to another thank you m well remember Craig um so I'm going to reiterate a thought and this is more of a rhetorical point that I still

102continue to uh raise concerns for which is I I think there are a couple schools where we are projecting numbers of students who would enroll and I don't know that that always matches up to what parents decision- making process will look like I'll give an example I think Evanson is projected as the basic on the um based on the pathway Matrix I believe it is um to to be filled by certain schools that I just don't historically believe will has shown a demonstration that that's the school they would choose for their kids um at that at that age grade so I I still have concerns with whether or not we will not this year Meet the seventh grade numbers but future Years meet the seventh grade numbers um especially since Douglas is not a natural

103progression anymore um and and that's for a lot of students that's they actually their n school to Evon is Douglas for your prek through five so I think uh I just think there may need to be some discussion as we go forward if we're not seeing the numbers in future years revisiting that potential or even adding that sixth grade in to give at least another option for students there um within that Community again I know the community is not exactly blossoming with tons and tons of new kids bre down because of the lovely housing costs and all the other factors that might be affecting how our neighborhoods are set up um that we don't control but um but I do think that's something we we really do need to be looking at I I I

104understand and I recognize that we have some needs for and some changes that we're doing but I do think we're projecting what what the numbers look like and what the seats are we can't project what parents decision- making will be and that's just the difficulty of our district um I do have a question in in regards to potential Transportation differences in schools right so we have some schools that are 678 some schools that are 78 some schools that are five six S8 I think um and just thinking about from a lowering the cost aspect of it how are we thinking or how are we working through Transportation um aspects reach those different types of middle schools Andor Junior highs U because I can imagine a 78 might still be on Metro but a 678 would

105be weird to put right now board member Craig our thought is that uh we would have one system for every school so for example if it's a middle school grades 5 6 78 we would have yellow bus service if it's a junior high grades 78 we would have Metro service that's our thought right now okay um and I think appreciate the thought too and and again I think that's one of those things as we go through just for us to kind of also explore because I think one of the reasons we moved 7th and eighth grades back onto the Metro was just in general the cost was so much cheaper on Metro than it is on yellow bus um now if that cost can be over it can be offset by not having to travel

106as far um that that's another Factor um involv for me um so I mean I think that's something for an updated projection of Transportation cost would be a great one because I do recognize and we got a little bit of the transportation cost before that some schools Transportation numbers are in large part because we're transporting students based on prior magnet status prior other enrollment reasons um that is that does not uh necessarily exist under what we're currently projected to go into um the third uh kind of thought and question I had is I know there was some documentation provided for on board dos that was centered around the cost per school or cost per people of each school and I wanted to not necessarily ask you all because I don't think it's a document you

107all provided but wanted to kind of get a better understanding of is the expectation that under these new years we will be able to kind of see a more accurate or more realistic cost per student or these type of breakdowns because I think one of my struggles also when we talk about price you know the cost of a building per student or these type of things is that those really the costs that are associated to the school not necessarily always all the costs that go into the school right like so there there's something things that we just can't never not you know you never not pay for utilities right so like in some ways saying utilities per Stu per students is is not as accurate of method link about it as for instance resources or

108Staffing and that type of deal so I mean I don't know if that's something we can in the future get an update on based on these new numbers new projections is what is that dollar per school and I'm picking more from Staffing and resources as opposed to some of the other fixed cost lens um because I do think that again I I use example of the fixed cost like if you have one building that house 2,000 students you have another building that house thousand students the fixed cost are the fixed cost and no matter many more students you add to it it still stays the same whereas the Staffing and some of the other resources we put into the school do vary based on that um so I just think that would be helpful to

109get that number at some point so we could have a little bit more accurate upto-date number uh because I have concerns that we are also okay last one of concerns we also are doing some of the projections with um Riverview based on them having the same size building as uh they had before and I know like when we got the updated uh capacity uh for the building it was based on a larger student capacity than I believe they could have in one floor of the building or in the portion of the building that which they have access to versus Spencers having you know theirs also like the prend to the building they actually have versus what is the total size of the building so I just if we get little updated numbers with those things

110as well be helpful for us to see as we continue going on this path yeah those numbers for Spencer and Riverview might be a little off because there's a lot of shared use space in that building so you can't just divide the cafeteria half and divide the gym in half and divide some of those other areas in half so some of those might be more um in that example that's a little bit more fluid because we can't split those those um specific areas in half Media Center for example thank you well member Weinberg yeah so I just had a question in regards to busing and this is uh talking about yellow buses have you all thought of or have you looked at for example the particular schools that will be taking in other students for

111example if we have ethyl Taylor students going to roow Hill have we looked at the consideration for the mileage for the school for the yellow bus and for any other particular school that that might fall into a category making sure that those particular families do not have to worry about their students walking and will probably fall in the guideline of qualifying but if they don't qualify um what are the steps that we need to take to ensure that they have a safe way to get to school so we have been saying publicly that we'll continue to follow the board policy around providing Transportation um to students I um will remind some of the communities the Avendale Community they're having conversations around that very topic just to help to make sure the kids get to and

112from school safe through through the neighborhood and I suggested the work that they're doing there could be a model for some of the other communities to consider as well are you done yes thanks board member map so yes so my question is very similar and it pertains specifically to Woodford uh or the schools that have lost their magnet status but I know that Woodford while they um are no longer being provided for with Transportation they also don't have boundary lines and so as it pertains to our board policy I believe or maybe even the state um we're required I'll say board policy 1.5 miles we have decided we will provide transportation for students that live within that 1.5 M distance so how are we I guess supporting the students and families uh at wer who

113no longer has transportation and no longer have it because they were there under the magnet status correct but what if they live within that 1.5 M distance but because they don't have we don't have said boundary lines for Woodford how do we approach that situation I believe the right answer is based on board policy we have to provide that Transportation if they live within that that neighborhood I believe now I don't maybe there's something I'm not understanding about the question but they no longer have transportation because of the loss of the magnet status so um and you're right they don't have a boundry either so theirs is really really tricky I know that they did some work around actually reaching out to their families to see if they would continue with the school and I

114I believe they got positive feedback and results with that so I don't think there's an obligation for us to provide transportation but somebody will definitely correct me I'm sure I well I think I just have a different approach um so yes that may be feasible for some families but I do think it is it would be incumbent upon us if we have say policy in place that if they live within a certain radius uh that we would make sure because they're in that actual community of the school they're not traveling from another neighborhood we if I could be wrong but I would assume that we're expected to provide them with Transportation so the hard part is I think what you said before they don't have a boundary so Mr Bart I will talk about this

115a little bit more and bring something back to the board if that's okay um but just based on off top of my head not having the magnet status not having boundary I'm not certain about our requirement around Transportation but I'm certainly open to hearing from the board okay um and then my other question is around um just the engagement process I know that there's uh the partnership with coh here um and so I think the partnership with coh here is supporting the efforts of um the engagement process with certain communities but not all communities correct yes ma'am so they uh they're doing this for us pro bono and asked me for one project and I did ask them if in that one project could it include two schools so right now that is that's the

116only thing we're doing with coher is the conversation around Uh current families and Families that could be going to the school but choose to go other places we have not been able to expand that work to other neighborhoods okay cuz that that is what I'm curious about how do we ensure that collectively as a district our our students our families our educators are informed about the upcoming changes and and receiving that same type of attention so I know that um uh Miss Russo sh shared kind of that that plan but making sure that it is really um being implemented again so that all of our our families are receiving that same level of support vice president yes thank you I appreciate the reference to boundary lines and attendance lines um especially where there may be

117none and then also we heard from folks from kind of one parcel the leap and and and roll Hill and Ethel Taylor folks talking in terms if I recall you know just what end of the street they may live on May prevent them from being able to go to LEAP let's say I think it might not be a bad idea um to have a little bit of a a review which apparently you are looking at these attendance uh boundaries um I had a a number of requests from uh the folks in uh um Mount Washington where they like the resource coordinators there because that's a a clicky school um Community Learning Center Institute uh folks um they would love to be able to have a sense of what boundaries that might be because they the

118Mount Washington boundaries but now do we also have the Riverview boundaries and do they go all the way up to Mount Adams their interest was we want to recruit so they wanted to see if those boundary lines or attendance lines so I think that would be great to I I know all this work that you all are doing I do think some um attendance lines might be of of Interest without necessarily disrupting anybody yeah it it's so I hate to it's sort of a a wink of a blink about it uh trying to still be true to policy but also find a way to make this transition work uh for families so I'd appreciate that effort uh if the administration can look at that and maybe get back to us about it we can we

119can share and remind of what we currently have and then we can discuss what we need to consider moving forward thank you I'm just going to add um I think just a couple of points to me the way that we get through projection of enrollment is engagement I I love the fact that data is being used and we're we're looking at all the numbers but you there's nothing wrong with asking Families how many would come back how many would like to stay where would you like to go and that's something we don't need coh here for we need to use our own resources and engage the families that currently exist at these schools and ask them what their plans are so that we know data and we're not just looking at numbers it it kind

120of pains me that um we don't definitively know how many students are going to utilize Transportation or be impacted by the transportation removal from Woodford Andor Taft Elementary like we should know and ask them if we do not provide you Transportation are you planning on coming back that's not a projection we can find out how many of those students would be impacted that's engagement and that's not I don't hear enough of that also with regard to um transportation I had asked before at the work session can we look at grandfathering um to have Elementary particularly for their transportation because they Pro have shared Transportation with the charter school that is 100 fet away so to to remove their transportation for that particular school but we're providing Transportation the same bus is going right there doesn't

121seem Equitable to me and I have a I have a problem with that and we should know how many students are impacted by that number with regard to Transportation because we've asked them we know that and that's not a projection that's not saying hey this many students and I understand 60 students can go to Rockdale but how many students would stay you you find that data by asking and engaging so that should be done to me um grandfathering has been done in our district in the past I'd like to know what the cost of that would be if we did that for a TA Elementary and or uh Woodford I'm not exactly sure about the Woodford piece because they may have that figured out but grandfathering has been utilized when we have removed magnet status

122and we removed their magnet status years ago um but not the transportation piece so I would like a cost of that um one thing that still kind of concerns me because I keep hearing it from the community is regarding the Evanston Junior High and that we uh one person told me and I couldn't refute them because I didn't quite know that um South Avendale is in a different Corridor than uh Evon and that we're busting kids across the corridor well I thought I definitively defended it but but I need to know if I did or not and so are we moving students who live right next door sixth graders Rising sixth graders they live right next door to Douglas they can walk to Douglas but now we're adding a cost by transporting them to South

123Avendale which is more than the mile and a half so now we have to pay for transportation of them and my question was can we just have the Douglas students go through the sixth grade like what does that look like the rising sixth graders go to Evon as um as because transportation is an added cost so again how many we find that that data out by asking them how many would you how many would would stay how many would go do you need transportation and I do know many families have shared that they're looking at unfortunately other options because of that so we need to do some better marketing of our own um middle schools I think we've got excellent programming much better than what they're being offered and they're choosing not our option so

124um the other thing that I'm kind of curious about is the Riverview piece we didn't decide as a board around I don't think we got the cost of those um freshman or sophomores and juniors that we wanted that wanted to graduate from Riverview we we talked about the current seniors and the Juniors but what is the cost um regarding those students that are wanting to finish uh we we didn't finish that conversation so I'm interested in what does that look like for the Riverview students where the numbers are significantly low and they wouldn't have a full complement of um coursework what are their options um I'd rather talk about that sooner than later so um grandfathering transportation specifically for Taft and Woodford um again projection of enrollment is great I think that's one data set

125but you collect data by asking people and that can very easily be done through the resource coordinators asking sending out a survey asking families we need to know definitive data on if they are planning on staying and what their needs are and I don't think we've done enough of that I'd also like to know what is the engagement calendar of these schools that are being restructured and having programming changes we need to we need to um definitively engage those families to get them to understand that maybe they don't have to move if like College Hill I was at College Hill and some of those parents were misinformed that they were going to have to choose a school and they didn't know that they automatically get a middle school option so again engagement is just key

126and I and I really would like to see more of that data collected in first person through surveys of the people that are impacted thank you any other board member Craig I just wanted to just revisit it maybe a topic for us to to talk about or think about as we go forward um and I know it was brought up with the by uh board member Mt uh raising the Woodford boundary line conversation I think this may be an opportunity for us to create a boundary line that is somewhat overlapping been diagram is um and part because I do know that there I mean we did have few folks come in here and say like they live in Pleasant Ridge but they decided to send their kid to Kennedy Heights or send kids to Woodford

127because of particular reasons but also because I know that folks who live right around Woodford actually has their neighborhood School listed as johnp Parker which would mean we would be busing a kid who lives within walking distance of one school to another school where they do not live within walking distance and so it's not that we have to move the parent there but if they have the option of picking or like you could be within a couple of schools in that same same thought process we had with regards to like how some students would be able to go from Silverton and Pleasant Ridge and somewhat of an overlap might be a way to also for us to evision um again giving options to students and I was just curious I know previously uh president MF

128had brought up whether or not folks were able to select um like Silverton or Pleasant Ridge as options when you were selecting schools and I just wanted to know of Woodford was another option was listed in those potential for a parent because if again if a parent can't select Woodford you're not g to have any people in in that in that same vein so I I think that would be kind of helpful to understand on that lens vice president Bolton yes uh what what member Craig brings up it's interesting this was talked about uh seven years ago the idea that we had a cluster of schools uh that first of all we had to get rid of the Fida because that was not attracting anybody and then also these that cluster of schools on the

129east side basically of Silverton John P Parker uh Woodford and and Pleasant Ridge we made the determination absolutely positively don't change the boundaries at Pleasant Ridge because somehow that's working and instead we build an an addition uh and so I do think there's there's something to be be said within a quarter especially of actually a cluster of schools uh if if that makes sense now I do recall in an LS uh districtwide lsdmc meeting being confronted by some members of One School saying don't change our boundaries uh because we don't want you to so it's a it's it's uh kind of dealing very diplomatically and politically in frankly the idea that um you know we suspending the bus piece of magnet schools a number of our schools have lost their bus uh Service uh and

130that's a hard decision but I will say too that for many many many years and I was glad that President mfet brought this up at least three years ago for many many years the children in winon Terrace have walked right past their neighborhood school to be bust up the hill into College Hill uh or the College Hill kids are being bust over to maybe a handful and over to mount Ary so all that kind of social engineering we were all doing this is long before I was even on the board that is has been disruptive but it became embedded and institutionalized and perpetuated so this is a great opportunity to see what we can do to have a littleit sponginess if you will or reconsideration of of uh some of these lines but I I

131can't think of a better group of folks to uh worry about that and better you than necessarily us but please do do at the attendance boundary I'm so glad you mentioned uh that that's great and I just have one more question can you confirm that the drop down for PRM or the ask has been for many years to bour Craigs Point has been allow students who do not who live in the golf manner uh address and that address who don't want monu they've been forced to go to PRM and we've been asking hey can they choose JN Parker can they choose Woodford can they choose Silverton and I don't know why that has been a not done but can has that been done for this year they can choose Silverton they can choose John P

132Parker can they choose Woodford they cannot they can Jeremy and John said they can they can choose Woodford okay have we seen an the bridge oh the back to the bridge have we seen an increase in those numbers at all since that drop down has happened maybe so maybe I hate to put Jeremy on the spot like this I'm just I'm very curious because it has been a significant number that have requested that and so I'm wondering does that matter has that mattered we haven't in terms of the monitoring of that to look and specifically see a student that is picking that option now that it's available as opposed to something else is not something that we can necessarily distinguish because it's an option that's available for a future state if that makes sense so

133it's not like they can change it in the middle of the year so that we could see they were changing it so we don't know what they would have picked if it hadn't been there so we can't really monitor it on a strictly count basis on the overall population of what we expect for next year we're not seeing any impact so far thank you any other board member comments superintendent Murphy do you want the last word on that yeah we look forward to continuing to do the work I think we are off to an amazing start and um thank you for giving us this assignment absolutely we are chugging along board members we are chugging along we are we are cooking with grease as the old folks said superintendent Murphy and Treasurer Wagner please update

134us about the budget the budget money so good evening we're hoping to have a robust conversation around the student budget and the progress that we are making and we need some guidance from the board on some next steps so um if you'll flip to the next slide please so I was asked to do this is what we're going to try to cover tonight you know I talk fast but it depends on how many questions in conversations you have so I I was asked to do a little bit deeper dive into student-based budgeting that wasn't clearly understood um a review of the Staffing formulas um and I just recently like an hour ago sent them to our CFT president for review for accuracy but um I wanted to go over the survey results unfortunately I only

135got three responses so we're probably not going to we'll have conversations about it because we do need to have decisions based on what are we going to do with the cash Reserve what are we going to do about preschool expansion um and then a conversation about the class sizes but um and then we'll go into where we stand today with fiscal year 26 update little challenge for fiscal year 25 and then go into the long range planning I.E Levy conversations and what deadlines you're facing on those so student based budgeting I try to boil this down as to as simple as possible um we go through a process where we project the number of students and this Revenue um there's a base rate for every student that's in a school so we'll just make up

136a mount Ary 600 kids so look at a base rate times their 600 kids and then some grades get weighted because they're like third grade might be a little bit um more costly because you're focusing on reading n nth grade got an extra waiting because of the transition in the high school um and then we actually added weights based on students with disabilities and each disability get a different waiting factor and we use State guidelines for that um gifted students English language Learners um depending on which category they fell into um so category a I don't remember all the letters but category a is if you were English language learner and you were in this District or the State education public education for 180 days or less then the next category was you've been in

137for more than 180 days but you're not yet proficient on English the third category is you're proficient on English or you've been in for more than two years um but you're not quite proficient I think and I I'll go back through the those rules but anyway there's three different categories of English language Learners there two different categories on gifted waiting K8 and 912 um and then in Career Tech each of the cluster groups have different weightings um and then there's the poverty factor that they actually use in the state funding formula so all those things get added to the conditions and the size of the building of those students generates a big Revenue so the school takes that Revenue we'll just make up a number $14 million and they go through the Staffing formulas to

138come up their with their Staffing decisions they're reviewed for compliance this is one of the weaknesses in student based budgeting is that we had challenges with some of the special needs compliances um but the schools go through they calculate how many classroom teachers they need based on formulas um the pr art music intervention Specialists based on all this stuff are based on formulas that are dict ated either by state federal or Collective barging agreement um so then they come with their Staffing budget and then they add to that a non-personnel uh expenditure budget to develop their school budget so I've been playing with some modeling on in here and there's some challenges the other Challen so the two major challenges student based budgeting was student Mobility because you staff at the beginning of the year

139and students move around so some schools gain kids all year long and so the Staffing formulas requires you to hire more people but they didn't have necessarily the revenue to cover that and then schools that lost students throughout the year would have staff um but they would lose revenues throughout the year and so they ended up in a deficit situation so if we could figure out the mobility piece it would be great and then um like I said the compliance um which just needs a little bit more education and um monitoring I think so um Rob if you'll jump to if you don't mind that spreadsheet I just sent you that shows the Staffing formulas I don't have these posted on board dos yet because I forgot in in this earlier today but I will

140post it on board dos it's all the Staffing formulas as we know them and whether they're driven by state federal um law or the collective baring agreement um and I'm having extra eyes on it to make sure that we didn't make any mistakes um but you can go through it goes through all the certificated staff um all the classroom staff monitory programming because they have different formulas in the Collective aring Agreement um how it calculates your Peart music allocation um and then other certificated staff like counselors and Librarians and um you're going so fast I can't read it your that's okay but anyway we won't go through all this stuff but this is how we build the school budgets now and if we were going to do student based budgeting we might consider changing some

141of them I don't know um but I was asked to show you how many of them are not just CPS practice but they're actually dictated by uh something that would have to be either renegotiated or a law changed okay let's say if you flip back please you're so good at that thank you okay so this is a a graphic I'm trying to show how title funds because the general fund pays for Base education and it's based on our requirements and our needs um title funds are supposed to supplement on top of what the general fund pays for so if it's something that's like we'll use the math curriculum that what Mike likes to use as an example if it's used by every third grader across the district then you can't use title funds because not

142all schools are title so um what you could do is if the title schools wanted to buy an extra supplemental workbook to work on third grade math then they could use title funds but the titled n non-title schools can't so it becomes very limiting when you're trying to do things districtwide and standardize services to students um but so these are the major ones so you have the general fund and then each title gets layered on based on the purpose of that Grant so title 1A is to proove basic programs and it focuses on disadvantaged economic students um and that gets allocated on a prop puple basis to the schools that the schools leadership team decide how they're going to use those funds you remember the title one tree I showed you before idea B focuses

143on students with special needs and that's usually dictated by the i title three um supports language instruction for English language Learners and title for uh which used to be drug-free schools is now called student support and academic enrichment um and so like I said they there's a bunch of tests you have to follow to make sure that you're not supplanting with the general fund in other replacing what the general fund would do versus what's supplemental to a student does that make sense okay just a reminder we went through this on last Saturday I just left it in here as a reminder that we've committed to um creating a operating budget general fund Opera budget does not exceed our forecast of revenues next slide so where are we so if you click on the target link

144please I just updated a little bit ago because I added the lab the monitory lab school in um so the forecast just start off with the uh and I know you guys saw this on Saturday um but some data has been updated and just for the Public's p uh understanding we'll go through it so the forecast for next year in the general fund right now is 64.7 million and we'll be doing a new forecast on May based on updated data um we talked to finance committee about starting to build up our cash reserves because they're they're getting concerningly low and uh we talked about doing a fiveyear for um phase in it's one of the things we need some guidance on tonight if possible so if we were going to do a five-year phase in

145we'd set $12 million of extra cash aside put it into our savings account so to speak and then that only leaves us with $612 million to spend for next year so off the top are all of our fixed costs so things we can't cut you can't cut debt you can't cut the fund 34 transfer into the facility master fund um you can't cut your auditor fees or your liability insurance and by state law you can't cut the superintendent or the treasure so our just our salaries alone not our departments are in there so that's total of $51 million off the top and then we have some um collective bargaining agreement negotiated costs that include you know Lead Teacher team leader stiens determinated benefits and um a bunch of professional development dollars that are allocated to

146the unions um we early on in the process we calculated what step increases would cost us for next year to the general fund and that includes fringes um we have a crossing guard increase of about a million dollars so I'm trying to keep track of increased expenses over what we're doing now and then um the Suzuki contract um well we use Grant monies this year we we think it was going to come back to the general fund we might have an alternate funding resource for that for one more year but um we don't have any negotiated cost of living increases that's Cola sorry we speaking acronyms around here um but just in general a 1% Cola would cost the general fund 4 million dollar the other funds would have to absorb their portion of it

147um and because they're Limited in size that means they would probably be able to fund less things if it included staff the first round is of student budgets based on the Staffing formulas at the time on January 9th was $397 Million um at we have not had not updated the next year's salary we were waiting for the retirement announcements we noticed the retirement numbers have gone up because of this stir the stirs onee early retirement so I think we have about 75 teachers that have already announced retirements for next year and so that'll have an impact on average salary so recalculating average salary and we'll update these numbers um when we can but um so the base one was 397 million and then we went through um an a process where we reduced class sizes

148instead of max amount at the at the maximum went down to 20 at K3 and 28 at 48 um so that cost five about five million then U they went through a process of Staffing appeals that se five and a half or I'm sorry 5.7 FTE were approved for another $600,000 um $6.5 million are put in the non-personnel school budget so they have to go out and allocate those out to the field trips and instructional supplies um textbook whatever whatever they need in their buildings um I did just tonight I added the monor lab school it so right now we think it's going to be a $1.8 million based on the Staffing that was shared with me last week we do have a meeting next week U to go over the details I don't have

149any estimates on the monor training program but I do know that we're spending $100,000 a year to train five teachers in monu and so we need to work through what this Revenue Source would look like and what the expenses would look like so that's just a placeholder um and then the last line there is the board discretionary so it's the board office budget and the internal auditor budget so if you'll scroll up just a little bit you can see that we've no the other way there you go right there so you can see we've spent 484 we've committed $484 million to next year's budget out of the 600 24 or 12 depending what we do with the cash Reserve so we've either spent about 78% of the budget for next year or 79% so that

150leaves 128 million if we use the cash Reserve set aside or 140 million um without it to do everything in central office okay questions about that should I pause keep going okay back to the slides thank you um oh before we go on to this slide so the fiscal year 25 challenge is that we've had some unintended cost items to The Bu The to the district that was not budgeted represents about $2.2 million um the crossing guards is one of them um and U Transportation fine was another one and then we had some um Staffing unusual staffing needs out in the schools so we're going to be going through a process where we're going to be pulling back budgeted money that's this year it hasn't been allocated or encumbered yet I mean it's allocated but

151it hasn't been spent or encumbered yet so we can cover this expense so we're not chewing into that cash balance any further okay so uh we shared this or superintendent shared this with you last Saturday um I just left them here for your reference I don't know if you want to talk about them on the spot happy to uh all of these fit into the three categories we have already um discussed improving our operational efficiencies incl increasing student outcomes due to a whole child perspective and then preparing our young people for beyond the tassel thank you okay um moving on so this was a slide that uh board member Bolton was looking for I went I had to go back to the workshop from February 2024 um took me a while to find the slide

152but um these were things that um the board had committed to as initiatives that needed to be funded so the ad hoc recommendations turned into the growth plan um that was last year's Cola conf conv ation um convers we were at the at the time negotiating the preschool promise Master agreement um we were going to go into negotiations we ended up delaying them for a year um talked about the public service Academy the facility repair plan we've been talking that for a while and then um Career Tech expansion and some other new initiatives but I can't remember what those were from last year this is the new slide that that President Bolton sent me that she shared with you on Saturday so I asked me to include it for your consideration um Contin with the

153growth plan um Department of student services restructuring crossing guards centralized enrollment um having a little bit of conversation about recentralize some of the financial tasks to for efficiencies and better service better compliance um we need to talk about the CPP um portion of the 48 million do Levy that's coming up uh and other RS that are in in consideration of other RS that are coming up and I have that Slinky slide for you um once again we're heading into negotiations we have step increases and benefits to uh to cost out the facility repair plan that was also on the other slide um the Woodward is the expansion of the career tech programs that are in the growth plan and so is the public service AC and the growth plan and so is the rap and

154welcome center it's so and you're very intimately familiar with those so next slide I ask this question because as we go through because do you hear me say we've already spent allocated 78% of our budget the money that's left over for central office is a lot smaller than it is today and so we're going to have to go through a reduction conversation so before we start making those conversations and putting things up on the screen we need to know like what's the board not interested in removing and cutting so that we're not putting up recommendations that you're just going to vote down because it's what I call a sacred cow I just like this picture um so we want to have a conversation about that and that was part of that survey was asking some

155feedback on where those interests lie we go to next slide so for the cash Reserve discussion so we need to know what is our budget Target for real next year are we going to try to start preserving cash set as side or not so if you go to the next slide and I'll tell you why it's important so this is a history of our cash balances in the general fund um over the last several years and you can see that we've strategically invested and been and our expenses are going up while inflation is going up at a higher rate than our revenues and so we're having to Reser rely on the cash um balances but you can see it's getting low um and we're projecting this year to end the year with 41.4 41.4 million

156in cash so why is this important because 41 million is a lot of money but what so why is this important to us so go to the next slide so if you recall our we get our revenues from the state by twice a month so it comes in very evenly and for the most part doesn't fluctuate too much but our property taxes come in twice a year those are the Peaks you're seeing so we get big big payments in July August time frame and another in in February and March but look at the valleys so that's where our cash is and so we have dry periods where we're not collecting a whole lot in December and in June and July it's a little bit harsher in December as you remember last year we had to

157do a tax anti tax anticipation note um make I just want to make sure that we had enough brother I I got caught with too much money a longterm uh investment so it was cheaper for me to borrow the money temporarily for 30 days to make sure that we got through our payroll cycle in December than it was to liquidate those long-term Investments and so I took that money I threw it in a star account earned interest on it so it was basically a net effect I think it it was like a $50,000 cost um but anyway so if you start the year with a low balance that December is going to get even harder to deal with and so what we're trying to do is build up and give ourselves a little bit more

158cushion so you have a little bit more freedom we did uh next slide went to and and talked to our district friends um most people are trying to get to a 60-day cash balance um Toledo is trying to get to a 90-day cash balance so 60 days for US represents about $104 million so we're not going to go from 44 million and4 overnight I mean that would be devastating in our to our budget so what we thought well maybe if you phase it in over a period of time and we just suggested 5 years if you take the $104 million 60-day cash subtracted what we already have 41 million that means we need to capture 603 million almost over a 5year period so it's about 12 and a half million a year year so we

159just want need some feedback is if that's a direction that we want to go in do we want um to make it longer so it's a smaller value or not or put it in a levy um and hope that that passes for to but we're getting dangerously low on our cash reserves so I'd pause there for some feedback please okay I'm going to go to board member Craig first and then I just wanted to uh reiterate and we've had this discussion in budget and finance for uh I think the actually last two budget and finance committee meetings I think the the reality is that the reason why this is really important is because our our cash on hand um is idea because we are able to sustain while we do not have uh new Revenue

160coming in at that very second right so like if you get to a point where you only have uh I think we talked about like 30 million was like or whatever whatever we were last time was like 40 or 35 days or something like that that we had cash on hand at the start of the year and so something majorly gets delayed something doesn't come through I don't know President says fund federal funds will be Frozen um stuff like like that we would be in a in a hard place if we only had 21 million or lower uh you know these lower amounts and it puts us in a position where we're having to do these tax anticipatory notes um so I think that's one of part of the reason we had that discussion recognizing

161that by doing it though you are having to make a decision not to spend that funds this year in the next five years as we go forward Lindy um thank you uh I was able to see this or parts of the presentation on the Reserve at the last finance committee of last calendar year um and I I just wanted to say here some of what I was sharing there I think this is a really good important and healthy thing for us to do uh I was surprised only in that 60 days feels kind of short uh relative to other context where I've worked but um I also think in some ways like our our revenues are a little bit I don't want to say this in jinx anything but they're they're reliable in a way

162that in other contexts they might be less reliable anyway so I'm just saying 60 days is good I think we should do this thank you so the other thing to consider I'm sorry I me to say this earlier is that because our state and federal grants are reimbursements um last year we were waiting on $40 million of reimbursement on Esser we don't have estra anymore so we're not laying out those big dollars but that has an impact on cash flow as well so if they get behind on their payments um and also last year the county auditor wouldn't commit to us when they were going to issue tax bills because remember they were going through those revisions um and so we were afraid if they delayed then we'd be in serious trouble so thank you

163vice president why at least it's not Melanie bat I mean that's um I I think we do have to do this I think that uh 12 million in one budget year that's already a stretch is too much to ask uh of of everyone so I can see over a twoyear or three-year process um if the 12 million and make that be what it is each of those years after we achieve the 12 million the 12 million is chosen because it represents what it's when we need 63 million more so I divided it to 5 years to get 12 million a year for 5 years okay so the 12 million for 5 years would get us to the 60 million and once is that correct that would get us to 104 million because we already we're

164projecting to already have 41 yes well that's what I need to know because when you start talking about those sorts of dollars rather than just thinking in terms of 12 the reality is that has to then be part of whatever the tax request is too I don't know that we could budget those many millions uh conscientiously for that many years but I think building it into what the a one of the many asks of the public it's going to be uh I think is is also a way to to do that okay thank you any other comments okay oh I'm sorry board member Matt yes uh thank you just a thought one I do think that this is um definitely something that's necessary to do um making sure that we have the cash reserves available

165so really trying to allocate money to uh have set aside I think is important the other thing that I think is important as you um definitively stated that you are not going into our cash Reserve um I think it is um incumbent upon us to be intentional about how we are spending our our dollars and so what I would like to see is making sure that we are aligning our priorities to the goals that we have established I don't necessarily see that well I won't say necessarily I don't see it I see that we see great ideas and we say let's do that versus connecting it to the actual goals that we've committed to so that would be something that I would like to see member Lindy um I wanted to just clarify that you

166all that what's helpful here is any comments on any part of the presentation or just limited to the cash reserves right now just cash reserves I'm just trying to take notes and I'm going to remind the board members to fill out the survey that we um I know there was some access issues but I think that's been fixed now so that will help uh Treasurer Wagner and her team with the priorities for the board members too so fill that out Mr Crosset uh yes I I support putting the 12 million into the um Reserve I think it's uh it's it's fiscally responsible for us to have a 60-day reserve and obviously we didn't get to this point in one year and it's going to take us a few years to get out of this but

167I I support doing it and getting to the point where we have a 60-day reserve I think it's important to protect the district with that thank you so I support us doing it I I just don't want us to stifle our growth in order to get there so I'm happy to support saving I just do want us to consider other options and I don't know if over five years is it but I I don't think that we need to stifle growth I think we can do two things at one time save and St um grow and be fiscally responsible but um I I would love to explore other options too CU $12 million seems like a small number when you look in when you're looking at 640 but it's it's it's a reduction of something

168so um I'd like to see us be a little bit more creative if we can if that's possible but i' do recognize that we need to save and be fiscally responsible with our money anybody else Bard member Craig I just wanted to reiterate I think there is support for one that vice president Bolton talked about with us consider it as part of our um determining what the levy should look like um and recognizing that we have you know again the revenue doesn't seem to be increasing from the state and recognizing that the state expects us to be able to generate our own revenue from from Stone I guess or from you know trees or something I'm not really sure where they think these things are going to come from but uh but I do think

169if we're doing that and we're thinking about that as part of what we're planning that makes sense um as we talk about now maybe not the entirety of the full 12 million as being part of what we would solely do for that purpose but recognizing that our budgetary needs might say this is something we have to be asking and planning for um and then I want also reiterate like part of the reason we're doing this is because while we get Revenue in the um I think the forgetting the two months there um in um June and July and we get Revenue again in February we don't have this whole bucket of money just sitting around all year round like it gets spent down and I think that's the other thing that we have to be

170recognizing and appreciating about why this cash on hand this cash balance is is important the cash Reserve is important because again like you mentioned the $40 million that we were waiting on Esser refunds for the projects that we're doing left and right throughout the district that need funds today that will get refunded some year someday some sometime later in the future that if we can't do and other districts fell through this problem where they had spent too much on things that weren't absolutely necessary and just didn't have the cash on hand when a federal payment didn't come through right away or we saw this a lot especially with Esser where districts rent themselves into the hole because they could not afford the work they were getting refunded back from eser for so to also to

171keep put this in perspective that each payroll we're paying out about $14 million and that's in net pay and the related withholdings um and taxes that we have to pay out so just to give you a little bit of size for each payroll I have a question Jen have we been in this or similar situation historically before um I don't know not in the last 10 years I'm kind of wondering like how did we get out of it before what were some of the options that even I hate to always compare us to other districts in Ohio because that's not fair but what have we done when we've gotten low before not necessarily Esser but how do we get have I'm looking to wh so it's hard to answer that question because the state funding

172has changed so dramatically over my tenor even before that when we used to be on the guarantee so our revenues St revenues stayed pretty consistent well now they're not so if if our enrollment drops then our revenues drop immediately that year and so also the first round of the Governor's budget that came out for the next banian budget they've he's recommending to fully phase in the state funding formula but only at 22 costs fiscal year 22 costs so if if our costs go up with a cola or something then we're getting losing that much more money to support what we need and so uh on Thursday I'm meeting Mike and I are driving up to Columbus to meet with the other Urban Treasures to strategize of how we're going to have a loud strong voice

173of supporting Urban education financially got so U I'll keep you updated on that thank you vice president B um I think just and I think we've mentioned this before I think it's remarkable that we wait at least eight years thank you that was going to say that earlier and I didn't want to interrupt that that the eight years between major Levy requests is simply unheard of uh under these circumstances so we we we do stretch this to the end and we're we're in that cycle we've been here before but but the other piece is that when I first got on the board uh President Obama had just been elected and there was a tremendous influx millions of dollars into urban schools and then Esser comes along uh some 15 student wellness came along we got

17412 million of that you have this influx of dollars that I think covers how desperate we actually are uh so I think those two things because I know I mean I have been here where a superintendent will say I have no idea how much money we really have that's the very beginning of been this is my 8 what was 17th 18th year whatever it is somebody actually saying that but but then there's that influx and now we're just faced with the opposite which is maybe there's going to be a withdrawal of money especially or we have a we have the state government also spending out of our line item monies for Universal vouchers so we are in a just a tremendously difficult place right now and and uh I think this presentation frankly this whole

175topic probably should be about six hours U but that's what it's going to take and the kinds of decisions but we've been here before but I don't know that we've been this um quite this lean if memory serves me when I first came to the district 30 some years ago we may have been in the state Loan Fund um as I'm thinking back but um and I I imagine at the end of each of those Levy Cycles our cash got pretty small and so I think that's you know uh it's just inflation is just grown so much faster than we expected plus the levies years ago were failing right consistently failing so we at least have a we've had the 20 years of consistent passage for all intents and purposes that's remarkable too and as

176the as the city has gotten wealthier according to the wealth index in the state funding formula our state share has dropped dramatically um since when I took over as a treasur it was almost 50% and now we're down to 36% we can't get a break so for every dollar our child creates in the formula we get 36 Cents on the dollar to fund our kids and property taxes don't grow with enrollment so those dollars just get spread thinner and thinner and thinner I I would just add to what member map said about focusing on what it is that we should be doing and rather than add and add um that's that's probably true that that slide with the boxes it's actually I think it I think the first one may even go back to October

177of 23 free but um those are initiatives that the board has and the Administration has come up with and and that's that's part of the attraction of them and you can see that we've added to them and of what we want to be spending money on for good reason but again these are initiatives this isn't even necessarily just looking at the goals and guard reels that you're mentioning or the kind of limiting ourselves so it it's balancing all this that we keep trying to do more than we probably are able to do okay ready for the next topic yes I I I I hear V people and say we need six hours but we don't have six hours so right well we already just did it so so what I received your feedback thank you

178very much we'll come back to you with some alternatives to consider before we um sorry just before we go on to the next section of presentation I did have some feedback on the first part that wasn't about cash reserves is now it won't be 6 hours but it's now an appropriate time to do that sure that's great I just I wanted to make the case for Focus uh and I think the more things we try to do the less we will do any of them well I wanted to just Echo what my colleague Kendra was saying about focusing on the goals that we have set and I think particularly if we're in a shortfall situation there needs to be a really strong argument that every investment is critical to advancing those goals that we've set

179as a district uh and everything all a sudden falls in the second category otherwise we need to vote to change the goals um or or something but I think I think I think we owe it to the district to provide some strategic Clarity and some consistency um I think second like is as we're thinking through your your um what's sacred and what isn't sacred question um I I would my um strong preference would be to receive a proposal from the administration for what they think is going to best Advance the goals that we've set as a district and why and then work from there rather than trying to work backwards from seven different preferences from the the group of us that was as fast as I could say that thank you thank you well I

180do think I agree with you on some things but the the intention around the survey that Jen and her team created was to shorten the time that we discussed priorities and we kind they gathered some information so it's not just about priorities on that survey but I do encourage everyone to fill that out because that helps to shorten the time period around the discussion and it helps them in addition to the administration figure out alignment of the district the administration's priorities budget priorities and board priorities so please fill that out and I do think that there is alignment with the initiatives and our goals and guard rails so they're not separate at all um we're going to increase scores if we do some of these things on here too so keep going Jen okay so

181preschool expansion um couple slides for context so we first passed this Levy as a new money Levy uh $48 million in 2016 with immediate collection um with a $15 million set aside for the expansion of preschool that $15 million was to be shared by Sensei preschool promise and CPS and we have um now outgrown that budget so this year's combined budget was about $20 million we were using um prior years unspent cash because during the first year to they ramping up did there was a lot of unspent funds um but that money is going to run out in 26 so this is part of the levy that's coming up in November of 25 and so we have a decision to make about what to do about that $15 million do we leave it at $15

182million and scale back our efforts do we grow it and if so by how much um and then that will dictate what Lev you're going to go put on the ballot uh discussion discussion one Mo across it yeah I think you probably have presented it but maybe I could use a refresher it would be interesting to know the impact of the difference between 15 and $20 million and and the whole impact of the whole program in terms of what value it's creating in the education process for future years I think if we're going to go to the public to ask for five more million dollar and not scale it back we have to have a pretty good argument for why it's worth it that would be my view thank you Bard member Craig um so

183I was going to say I'm we'll do it as a an assignment at the end too but I just think we have to get on the ball of uh the conversation that we committed to doing as part of the mass agreement with CPP to uh um both talk about results but then I think that also is part of the conversation we would have about um a campaign around specifically how much benefit that's been gained in the communities um and largely because as I kept saying during conversations we were having with them I think the idea of expansion is not the necessary direction we should be going in the conversation I think we should focus more on the quality part as opposed to the expansion part um because I think we have expanded probably beyond our

184means anyway but uh We've expanded tremendously uh beyond what we expected to be able to do and now we are talking about how we control the quality that's provided for those students to be able to come and go to become uh kindergarten ready and then be ahead of the game as they go through so I think there's a great story to be had there to board member cross's Point uh but I will offer that as an assignment at the end of the end of our meeting today thank you vice president Bolton yes I would agree with what my colleagues to the left have said um I honestly believe we've reached the saturation Point regarding preschool in this relatively conservative uh Community um districtwide um I think we should focus on on uh quality piece I

185also don't think we should be necessarily thinking in terms of expansion because I think we've reached it and looking at the numbers even out of Denver from where this came uh this has really been a remarkable achievement to have the kids that we have and I think it's not that we need more um numbers but the quality piece as well as being able to focus most particularly on the children that need it the most continues to be my concern so uh that's sort of where we are that's where I am right now about the preschool I do think the levy should be a 10-year Levy the length of it uh should be longer uh but it is I I'm I'm concerned about asking for very much more money for expansion thank you any other comments

186board members I will just share my thoughts um I I was actually I put on my survey that I felt like presol school was was an area that I wanted to support more and I really did I do think we should invest dollars there I was for expansion but I but I do hear the um the argument around quality versus quantity I just question I I'd like to hear from since preschool promise CPP on their thoughts as well around what they're seeing from their side because we're seeing it from our side but I also would like like to see I think there's value in their voice around it too and what they're seeing from their vantage point and I also think that is it about time I'm I'm looking to my my colleagues is it

187about time for us to have another joint meeting where we would um I know I am meeting with um this week with their board president but I do think there's value in getting us all together to talk about what they're seeing what we're seeing what their desires are what our desires are I know that they're using the reserves but they also have an opinion around what their projections are too and I think that they had some data when they came to just ASG a few months ago um they had some projected data too so I think before we make a big decision expansion quality we need to kind of have a joint meeting that that would be my preference board member Lindy yeah I I I definitely agree was there an effort to consult with

188them before this I think this was just the board this was just our side well they were at finance committee um a couple times in November yeah yeah uh most recently and and um so we haven't had a formal conversation about the levy with them no yeah I I just want would would just coign the The Joint decision-making process on [Music] this I just yes I just shared the same sentiment I think having everyone collectively at the table to identify what those needs are um would be helpful okay thank you okay moving on just a couple more slides left um thank you okay now we're going to talk Levy so um next slide so these are deadlines that you're working up against um you need two board resolutions passed the first one being the stating

189the need for the levy has to be at least 100 days before the election so your deadline is the board meeting on July 14th or before we typically do that in the March April time frame the Hamilton County aor has 10 days to turn around millage calculation and ballot language and then you have to um approve your second resolution with your intent to proceed to the levy to put a um levy on the ballot and that's due to the hel County Board of election no later than 400 p.m. 90 days prior to the election Dan and I usually take a trip and deliver it ourselves um so the board meeting that would meet that window uh is August 4th so now you got to decide what to do next slide um so you remember seeing

190this I've sh shared with you before Continue to update it with information as it's known but um you know here way I assumed to the cash Reserve so we'll change that depending on feedback um and then with the growth plan moving forward and those are simply the CPP Personnel that are added to the new programs not CPP CTE sorry the crew Tech um you know the crossing guards uh preschool expansion I just put in an estimate to see what it would look like if you wanted to move forward with increasing it by 5 million at some point somebody started talking about a custo expanding the custodial formula and I didn't know if that got dropped so I just left it there with a question mark we have some technology um incremental lease increases as things

191are refreshed and then um with the first one the $6.5 million is what's coming back from the Esser um and then in 27 we'll have all that and another 4.3 million so I'm just showing you new money and then um in meeting with curriculum department they have some adoptions that are coming up so this is incremental money as well so you can see kind of what your new future needs s are um this once again does not include any negotiated items right so already we're looking at Ms okay and so um three Mills would represent about 20 well one M right now is about $8.8 million excuse me okay next slide so then the second part of the need is the finance the facility repair plan that um was estimated to be about 170 million

192so we just um Chris gave me the schedule and I just keep bumping it backward a year um but so that'll be another four Ms um and so combined you're looking at an 8 mil Levy for new needs and that once again does not include hen colas the third long-term need is the seven construction projects that cost approximately Le $200 million and so if you do a bond Levy then you're not financing you're financing $200 million so the revenue that you cre bring in on annual basis only has to make principal and interest payments so I we calculate to be about a 2 M Levy Bond Levy the current the bond Levy that we have now that funded the master plan was 4.8 I believe when we first and um issued it and now it's

193um so it would be about half of what you did before um so that Bond the old Bond Levy expires December 1st of 31 so you could go onto the ballot on 30 and and explain to the taxpayers that you're kind of it's not a renewal you can't renew Bond levies but it would be like a replacement at a smaller rate so their tax rates would go down um and you can do um the life of a project or and 27 or 30 years I think or 35 years with the bond Levy because those assets are much longer they have to be related to buildings um a permanent Improvement Levy you could use to fund your facility repair plan for anything that has a asset life of over five years and you can make that

194a fixed um some Levy you could do 510 or continuing or you could do the permanent Improvement Levy for specific project and say well that projects done the levy goes away um so you have options next slide we just kind of have to figure out what agree to what our future Financial the real financial needs are so you can figure out how to size Levy that you need and then when do you do it in November 25 is the $48 million Levy you can renew it as is you can renew it with an increase switch it to a 10 year you can but only you can only go to 10 years on a fix some Levy or you can let it expire and replace it with something new and bigger um in 26 there's um

195nothing on the ballot yet or on the schedule yet so you have 26 and 27 7 in 28 you have another Levy that renewal to come up um but so these are this is just a different way of showing your different options on the current renewal Levy what your new needs are what your facility repair needs are and that's probably going to continue to grow bigger because construction costs aren't going down um and then the long-term um need so the next slide I think is the slinky slide there you go so the one that's coming up in 25 the blue line is a $48 million Levy so if you go to 10 year it would renew in 35 the $65 million fix sum Levy comes up in 28 so you have 26 and 27 you

196can play with because I highly recommend against putting two um issues on the same ballot this one of them always fails um then the red line is the 52 million Levy that you went 10 years so that'll come up in 32 so you have 30 and another window of time to do a bond Lobby next slide this different timeline actually I put on this one like who which board members are up for election and which year and when City council's up because that might factor into how many people you're going to draw to the B to the um election on Election Day for votes next slide this is just a you've seen this before this is the schedule of our debt um at one so some board member asked me to share that last Saturday

197so I just left it up there um we will actually pay off two debt issuances we did one December 21 sorry December 1st of 2024 we made our last payment on one of the city county um Stadium cops and then we'll be in June we'll be paying off the qcb 2010 Q cubies so we we paying down our debt good news I'm tired okay um so I don't know I heard um questions earlier about whether they wanted to have like a levy subcommittee to talk about next steps and details or did you want to have the conversation now or how would the board like to proceed board members wake up and share your thoughts board member Craig um so two well so we've talked about the levies for last several like five six months actually

198um in board in budget and finance and we'll continue to keep talking in budget and finance so I think there's there an aspect of those discussions that we have I think there is a need to have a at least a conversation with our folks that are outside of the district who are assisting us Levy um but I do think it's crucial that we have the conversation with CPP um first for this current Levy so that we can better also prepare each other for Life post whatever you're currently doing because right now what we're doing is using unspent funds from previous years to cover the additional costs and I know the framing that we did with them is recognizing that that's not something that's longterm longterm sustainable I do think the conversation with them is helpful

199to then build a conversation for the larger Levy conversation also recognizing we should do that in accordance with budget plans so for recognizing the need to address our future budget Cost needs for the 27 school year which I think would be when we would see the renewal funds hit um that we have to be prepared to start incorporating that into the bud the levy talks um because if we do a levy based on what our budget look likees this year in theory the future years may look a lot different and in some ways a lot worse um so I think that's I think it is a good idea to have some discussion going I just think we need some steps first before we start that kind of separate conversation with our um with our our

200outside folks who are there to assist in that process um the the second thing and I do think this is maybe the crucial part I do think we need to really have the conversation if not in this budget discussion in right after this budget discussion around a lby for next year or 27 again because I'm you know I just have very I see a potential disaster situation where we would have a school building where something would fall apart break whatever and we would not have the ability or or the funds to um do that without giving up something really big to do it and because we've been talking about facilities needs for several years now and it just reality is we have to at some point make that commitment to do it um and so

201I think that if we're not having that discussion right now in this budget cycle we should at least soon as we finish the budget cycle start the conversation to plan ahead um I think 26 is a great year because again uh we have a lot of folks who are fairly important in DC who will need some support as they go through and potentially some some races that might influence folks to come out and vote um and that would may be again an opportunity for us to utilize some of those resources as well to send a message um but I do think for the opportunities for us to do it I do think it's just we we need to take some first steps for the uh renewal of the levy just so we're all in one

202Accord and again if you did not get a chance to see the video that preschool promise produced it is a tremendous video about the great work that's happening and I think we have some of the same stories in our schools and when I go out people don't ask us are the kids getting are are the kids getting a benefit from those preschool promis dollars they don't understand the difference like everybody recognizes kids are learning and they're doing better they just don't understand how those fun funds are used and the fact that those are the last in funds or last out funds um and so like having that conversation about how much we're working how much we are doing with State funds with other resources as well to ensure that the dollars that are being spent

203by our district under this Levy for preschool for Quality at preschool that we're tapping out a bunch of our other resources first and it's a great message to say that we're being really really efficient and Thrift Central Thrift thinking um about how those funds get used and so I I think that's a great point that we can use with preschool promise because there's a good story that they have as well um with with where those resources are going um but I do think I think to your point maybe let's have a and again just one thought on this is that maybe we have the conversation with preschool promise first then from that build our conversation up so that we get it done um before before June vice president Bolton yes um real quick when is

204the big FMP off the books December 1st of 2031 so I'm going put that right there and remember that because that's a tremendous thing to celebrate uh and indeed is more a bookend to like this year is how do we get to that how do we get to 30 how do we get to 31 uh where we have uh you know a renewal in I guess 32 but also this 25 and 28 I would be very supportive of a of uh recognition that we have to have new money and I think they I think what has been said to me is that the 26 is the better time because I don't know if it's true property valuations are occurring in 27 right January 27 will be the next tringle update so you probably don't want

205to have a levy right after that yeah uh and so I think whatever we're going to decide about preschool the excuse me Jen gets mad when I call it that the $48 million uh renewal thank you uh whatever we decide there is going to impact what we're going to be doing in 26 because you can't you have to be really careful back to back two two years so I I'm very very supportive of a major uh effort uh both in facilities and also uh operations uh maybe building in that cash Reserve but a big ask in 26 we will have gone through much of the growth piece and and gone through a number of other changes so I I think 26 influences how I feel about 25 and uh I do think that the big

206big issue is the is the story of the big FMP coming off in 31 and we have to figure out a financial way to get there because that's hundreds of millions more than we would perhaps even ask correct and and we do have a need for some of these additions if we're serious about the growth piece having these additions early in the ask as well as the actual maintenance of one of our great assets which is our is our facilities they're our biggest Billboards any other board member questions comment so I may have misunderstood you so correct I want to make sure I didn't leave the wrong impression you can't combine the cash Reserve with the pi Levy right okay just so you know understand okay and we don't want to levies or two whatever

207you do a combination Lindy um thank you I I wanted will not spend long on this I just wanted to say two things one is I really uh appreciate treasure Wagner and the presentation is very helpful is very clear um second is I I don't feel ready tonight to share necessarily where I am on any of these questions and so that's not a comment on the presentation I think it was a great presentation I just wanted to register I'm not endorsing or saying I agree with any idea that's come out yet I'm saying that I'm still thinking about this and I'm grateful for the chance to do so thanks that's fair thank you any other board member any other board member thoughts comments board member cross it I I agree with board member Lindy I'm

208just not ready to make a recommendation or have a strong opinion about much of this I need more time to process it and think about it but I do appreciate Jen Wagner amazing thank you thank you very much you're welcome thank you for your attention on this late evening well we are going to spend some time talking about the budget so you'll hear this again maybe not as lengthy but we will spend some more time talking about this now talking about this uh in the next few months to board member C's point we need to be talking about the budget early to vice president Bolton's point we need to be talking about the budget often we're going to do those things moving on um vice president Bolton update us about the 110 day action plan

209that we started in our work session and I think the ask was for you to give us a plan of action so yes and I'm and I appreciate the opportunity and I'll I'll Direct people to look at the material that is posted um one of which is the necessary tasks that are bar charted by calendar month and year and the things that have to get done those are on uh board docs that chart is and then also the other thing that I might direct your attention to is the fact that we have basically made about a 100 commitments over the last couple of years of topics and issues and initiatives and votes uh and so as we try to prioritize uh what we are looking at is that in the next 100 or so days

210we have huge decisions to make we have to vote we're not going to we're not going to be late on the budget this year we're going to be able to get through uh and be ready to vote that in June uh when we're supposed to we we have a treasure uh hiring that has to be there we have at least six or so collective bargaining agreements that need to be uh hopefully done before the end of the year so that people are able to to ratify if if it's a successful uh successful uh negotiation sessions and so what I did is just look at the calendar and it was thankful that the president mfet looked and said see what you can do but before you at your seat you have we have in that 10

211and some days we have 10 business meetings we have 10 executive sessions we have five finance committee meetings and four policy meetings um in all of that uh we have to be able to get things all of these things done and whether it's the treasur search round of interviews a number of budget Community engagement meetings that have to take place meetings to finalize the development of the New Foundation for CPS we have another fact finding suggested for SCPA or even about the foundation uh possibly a special board committee able to convene regarding negotiations not to participate but to be at the ready for any kind of guidance possibly a special combined committee for Levy renewal and planning which is a normal thing that we do in Levy times so meet with those as was mentioned

212our outside folks that help guide us um if we look at this um we we really need to think in terms of maybe much of the finance committee meetings could be spent on budget to give us that time rather than necessarily the rudimentary and routine things that we would do in budget a committee all the executive sessions are going to have to have at least some portion uh about negotiation ations because that's where we can discuss uh negotiations not out in the public as such uh we also have to kind of remember that uh the using inquiries updates and board matters probably need to be focused in the next 100 days on things that pertain to getting the job done rather than some of the kind of one out oneoff kind of things that come

213to us uh because people might be particularly interested and we can't limit the hearing of the public although tonight was great uh we we somehow limited that but um probably we can use some of that time uh focused around the budget so I think what we want to be looking at is as the uh president does the agenda and as the chairs of the Committees and those people that want to spend more time on some of this or have more time everybody on this uh board has a tight tight schedule and scheduling anything beyond what is already scheduled is also a difficulty for the administration as well as the members on the board so what we've got to use is the time that we already have scheduled in a way that is the most effective

214plus we have to and maybe I can skip to the second part of this to get us through this we have to develop an engagement plan and I'm not I'm suggesting that the engagement plan that was used uh uh year before last where Administration spent a significant amount of time in small group I don't know that they have the time to do that at this point in time or if those multiple small groups was necessarily where we want to be uh I think um the what we might want to be looking at and see if people on the board are willing to spend a little time uh talking in terms of what does the budget engagement look like uh trying to get schools or particularly community members somehow participating we've done big ones before uh

215we've done surveys before but I think the smaller group ones are incredibly time consuming for administration that has this tremendous list of work to do so my uh issue is the using our business meetings using our exact using our uh Finance meetings policy if need be uh and then also some extra sorts of things that we might do to get us through negotiations being done in early May at the latest budget being able to be voted on at the end of June Treasurer search and all this work that the administration's doing regarding the growth phases so this is um this is what's ahead of us and it's I think visually on that chart as well as listed out as to what we might do and I think um I'm open for any suggestions or questions

216that uh might be that might quickly take care of those two items I apologize for being slightly distracted board members it's under a growth plan I I just emailed it to you and to the public too we were trying to find your files so that's what that is where they are on bardocks and there are under the growth plan so all of these are are listed that board member vice president Bolton was was talking about any thoughts around um yeah I would say in that file you'll you'll see like what we saw earlier from the treasure regarding the initiatives over the last few years you'll see everything that we voted on for phase two uh which we've made some commitments to spend money there or do something there you'll also see a number of other

217items that might be of interest to you but I think this is the one that's shows you the density if you will uh of just a couple of months when all this has to be and it can't be just us talking about we have to actually decide things that's that hard part so I will say that um I am a visual learner I like to see it this way um so the visual is is good for me I also offered in expressing my um engagement I ideas to the superintendent that well while she is engaging the communities that are impacted with regard to uh the corridors and the schools that she also add information about the budget not necessarily to have an additional time scheduled but to add budget conversations to the the engagement that

218should already be planned for the communities um I think that is our responsibility to educate around the budget so it doesn't have to be an additional date but it can definitely be an addon to this and I do think we are going to make some time for Budget member for board members to get conversations around the budget and questions answered as well does anyone have any other questions thank you for putting this together I know it's late so we're going to have vice president Bolton give us a little update on not now but for the next meetings and so and then have Jen give us some additional information and context again send your questions early so that we can get them answered and speed this process up and fill out the survey anything else I'm

219good and the documents are on bardocks undergrowth plan they were all there so just we we did confirm that but all right um and I thank board staff for putting them up there and helping to produce them as well we are cooking with grease all right a proposed con agenda has been distributed Treasurer Wagner please maintain the list of any exceptions and the exception makers do do board members the superintendent or the treasurer have any exception items to the consent agenda board member m uh yes it's I would like to abstain from um the treasurers report page 7 line item one so yes for the treasurers Report with that exception also please note that the treasures report was revised so there's a revised page in the back to show you all the revisions will member

220Weinberg I'm going to give first from the super then I'll um go to the treasures for the super page 19 Section C athletic and co-curricular activities line one and two then for the treasurers page 8 Line 1 page 12 amendments line two page 8 line one page 12 line two um amendments line two amendments thank you is that all okay I need a motion and a second to approve the items of the cons agenda so moveed second thank you treasure Wagner call the vote thank you call the voting roll for the passage of the consent a agenda and revisions Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes President Office yes Administration and board members are there any inquiries and updates that's what we save

221it for the end or just too tired we're all too tired are there any assignments I know I heard a couple on the floor War member Craig um so one assignment uh relating back to preschool promise um is I just uh putting together a coalition with regards to uh for the superintendent and her team to work with uh the director of CPP to uh put together materials and information uh with regards to the positive things that are going on in CPP the gains educational gains um additionally uh not for today or not for tomorrow but like a a putting together a conversation or a coalition of folks to have the conversation around our potential Levy discussions uh with our outside partners and so whatever group that is that would be assigned to that identifying it

222I think I would put that to uh our lovely board president to work with the superintendent and the treasur to identify folks to have the conversation around our Levy U once we've established plan of action um I think that is oh and then it just again uh assignment to the superintendent and her team to bring back information on an updated um updated classroom or updated capacity I think we had some of that information but just making sure we have that but then also maybe to the treasur and superintendent together an updated cost per student breakdown of our schools um since I don't think we've had one since we've just made the determination to go to phase two so so I'm I'm already actually working on that from a request from board member AC cross who

223wanted to see the cost by Stu schools having the self-contained student units pulled out so you can see the difference and so I started working that already and we'll give it to you want to get it done perfect for member Lindy I just wanted to make sure I was clear on what was getting uh assigned to policy committee uh particularly with respect to the evaluation conversation at the beginning I'd like to Advocate pretty strongly that that not get formed out to a committee uh whether it's policy or any committee because I think what we hold the superintendent accountable for really is a full Board responsibility if there's some work that needs to happen with a smaller number of board members between now and a next meeting to facilitate getting to closure I'm very happy to

224play a role on that I'm happy to do that with anybody who's on policy or not on policy but I just it used to be the case that the eval was done by a student achievement committee that was I think it's bad I think it's like should be our job together but I'm happy to volunteer to play role between now and the next meeting if that's helpful I also don't need to if somebody else wants to carry this forward I can just vote um but but I I wanted Clarity on what the request was going to be and who is going to do what that sounds fair what across it I'm happy to help Ben since I created that spreadsheet so happy to help you so member Crossett and I will have something to share

225with the board for the next board meeting that we have that sounds good and you two just happen to on policy right we don't he does not oh you're not on policy okay well that's good yeah oh this is the policy side okay I got you all right we do that in collaboration with the superintendent as the policy stat that sounds good all right and vice president Bolton yeah I a followup of uh doesn't need to be uh written in stone but a follow up on uh reviewing this this issue of uh attendance boundary lines uh and some some of the adjustments that could be made along the way uh as this transition continues to happen see where you all are I'm thinking about that for member Matt that was it that's yes and so

226specifically as it pertained to Woodford as well as Taff Elementary about the boundaries and transportation could you say that a little bit louder I couldn't hear you so yes needing or wanting information yes about boundaries but specifically as it pertains to Woodford as well as to Elementary and how that connects to their transportation that it that was going to be part of mine um I would like some research on and data around the grandfathering of Transportation I know that we we talked about that I've made that um request as well specifically around um ta Elementary but that was going to be one of mine and I I would also like the engagement schedule for those particular um schools that are the middle schools that we've now approved principles for there's only two so um what

227is their engagement schedule that's looking looking like I'd like to to know that any other questions comments concerns oh board member Weber I just wanted to make sure um if we could get an update regarding my busing question for the um schools to see uh if the mileage or whatever would work or how many students are affected by that as we're making the changes for the uh different schools for the upcoming school year and so just so that board members are aware there is an assignment log when we and and the administration is putting the assignments on the log and the person who asks it I'm going to suggest that the person who ask the question is the one who decides whether or not the assignment is complete not the administration because there's been a

228couple of concerns around what the clarifying the question and the administration thinks that the question is complete but the but the board member hasn't seen that so board members I'm going to ask you to look at the assignment sheet get make sure that your questions are answered if you put an assignment out there and then ask that all of the respon are sent to all of the board members so that they can get an idea of when that's um completed and then I don't have to be the mediator in between that are there any other questions the chair will entertain a motion for adjournment

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.