CorpusRecord 65349

CPS Board Work Session February 1, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2025-02-02
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,097 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay seeing a quorum of voting members I call the February 1st Cincinnati school board meeting to order Treasurer Wagner please call the attendance V Mr Craig here Mr crossant here Mr Lindy m map Mrs Weinberg here vice president Bolton pres president mof here okay we have um come out of exec session and now are at the point of our agenda for superintendent Murphy please present your topic I believe I'm on the agenda for my goals yes ma'am everything off so after our last conversation I did make a couple of adjustments um just based on some feedback so the sheet coming around will look a little different um from last week I had uh two separate sheets but I decided to combine the sheet uh sheets into one uh following the Ohio standards

002for superintendence so you'll see goal one or the area One Vision continuous Improvement and focus on District work area two communication and collaboration area three policies and governance then instruction is where I slid the five goals from the goals and guard rails in our strategic plan uh there was some suggestion after the meeting uh maybe about the rigor of the goal understanding the goal I shared with you again was uh as it was suggested to me and so uh goal one around third grade reading you'll see I hope you can see that's blue is a shift based on some feedback go three Algebra 1 in the blue there's a shift so this is a um change from Monday and then goal uh the next goal is the same around college credit plus the next is

003around uh Workforce credentials and then the final one around graduation you'll see a shift uh there I didn't have the x value um I think board member map asked me about the last time is this on board UPS no no not yet no I apologize uh because I think I I just worked on these again that's okay so this was actually at the request of one of the board members to do this in public so thank thank you for providing this information um the board still has to finalize it for the public to know that's why it's not there because we're still this is still a work in progress and so board members do you have any questions board member CL I don't really have any questions I just want to say thank you for

004uh taking the time to make the adjustments and based on the feedback I think it is a very creative way to add the uh what we have all talked about is being instructional goals for the district but to putting them into the instruction portion of the standard kind of also is in a lot of ways aligning what the state has offered out as ways to think about it as to also what we're tasked to do on a on a more uh dedicated level so it's like a specific goal around instruction that is a much easier way to measure than some of the other state standard stuff so I appreciate you taking the time to do so thank you any other board members questions or comments cross it um I I wanted to talk just briefly

005about possibly adding a goal for for next year not for now but to tee up the topic um we have a nice we had a nice presentation from Dr Smith on instructional rounds which is this giant document that uh talks about um how well the curriculum is being used and the and that utilization of the that report and it it is a report that's pretty measurable and I thought we've got this uh in the policy we've got this 10% where we're supposed to be checking in I thought this might be a good tool to think about being able to measure how well we're checking in with how it goes so just throwing that out there as an idea for next year um the other uh topic that I thought I would like to introduce is

006know I appreciate that you put in these blue numbers to move the goals up based on our the progress that we've made already but I think part of our annual calendar should be when we get to September or October when the report comes out that would be the right timing to reassess where are where these goals should be in terms of the um percentages for third grade reading or percentages for Algebra 1 that sort of thing and reassess it at that time and not necessarily reassess it now I don't want to feel like we're putting a superintendent in a position where we're moving the goalpost in the middle of the game so just from an annual calendar standpoint that might be a good timing to re assess those goals rather than I realize it's our

007first year and we're just doing this and it's a three-year rolling average so it's not just all based on the numbers from one year but still uh that's a couple suggestions across it are you wanting to change the policy around that because I think does the policy say October um I'm looking at the policy committee so are you are you suggesting that we move that date from October to September and the policy no no I the policy doesn't need to change I just think we might need to add something maybe it's a policy addition that we REI revisit the goals uh right after the report card comes out like the timing of that could all coincide pretty close don't you think yeah so yeah from my understanding in terms of the policy that is actually

008kind of why we decided upon October is because we'll actually have all the state data to be able to assess how to actually evaluate the superintendent goals overall so I guess what is your suggestion around September could be October okay so yeah so I think the initial um once we really begin to implement the policy overall the expectation is for it to align with that October date okay any other questions comments yes ma'am B weberg vice president B yeah thank you thank you for uh this uh document uh I I'm I'm good with the number four and how you've inserted the particular goals that are the ones that have been established and we've been living with um the change in numbers were the previous numbers what had been on the uh our targets yes yes

009yes ma'am the numbers in the parentheses were the actual targets from the Strategic plan okay okay thank you for that clarification and then we've you've ued them in a couple just like you did in number four is it possible not tonight or today but is it possible then for the board to have you do some inserts in one two and three and five the same way you've done sort of with the goals uh in four me meaning what would be those items in those like okay for your continuous Improvement and focus District work what would be the three or four it doesn't have to be four or five but uh to give us an idea of specifically so it's not so much we're trying to grade you if you will or evaluate you on this

010broad scope but that there are some uh specifics within each of these other standards that you would like us to to to think about or hold you accountable would you yes I definitely can do that would you be expecting them to be written as a smart goal with an X to Y value as the instructional goals are and my rationale for that is in my first few months I would not necessarily have a baseline but I definitely know that I can uh provide you with uh items for one two three and five I think when it's when would be applicable being a smart go that would be great when it's not because of the nature of it it wouldn't be but I think that you should make an effort to make it a smart goal

011if if the particular topic that you're choosing would work my my two cents would be that it'd be a smart goal just make sure that that's consistent across the board I think on some level all of them can be smart goals it's just if they be worded differently but I think that with regard to Smart that was good to say that just to be consistent whatever map you have a question or comment uh so yes I agree with the uh smart go approach just to ensure that we are able to measure um what we're actually working on in terms of or you're able to measure what we're working on in terms of the goals um and I do also like the feedback that uh uh vice president Bolton gave around giving more context to those

012other areas I do appreciate how um the goals have been um integrated into the instructional um aspect um my question is and I I know this is something I guess for us still as a board as we determine what it looks like under the scoring measures um are you and but just to ask you are you um anticipating to score all of these as one Collective or we would you still like well as the policy is written the measurables will be separated out as one particular scoring method so I'm just looking for your kind of rationale with the integration here if I had my dream uh and when I when I think about how we score our principles when I think about how we uh score our administrators here at central office if I had

013my dream I I am saying all five of these in the eyes of the state are important to for a superintendent I believe the same which is why I asked if those could be considered I would love it if they could be considered or weighted evenly uh in the overall evaluation of my work as a b as a complete body of work okay and then my last question is uh around go five um for the credits for graduation will increase I know the Baseline was 80.8% to uh this by this year 85% um correct me if I'm wrong if the LA if last year's state report card graduation rate was a 83.3% so do you I'm wondering are you possibly able to anticipate more growth then so since we cuz that would be like 1.7

014percentage Point difference so just a reminder on graduation rate too the reason I would advocate for keeping it there it truly will not be a reflection of my work because graduation rate is the one thing on the report card that lags um so I and I only used the 80.8 because the last meeting Monday I was missing that x value so I am not sure that it would be higher than the 85% okay okay uh and just one final question to that um and maybe this is something that you can speak to at a later time since there's that uncertainty there is there a way well I know there's a way but do you feel comfortable with providing us with the update on where we are maybe presently tracking in terms of reaching this said

015goal or maybe surpassing it yes conations M ju and just to be clear the goal for 5A is the credit folks who are in 10th Grade who are on on track track to crit and I know that that's wanted for historically we've been below where the actual graduation rate ends up being because we have a number of students who do not get on point until like last semester a senior year um so I do appreciate you kind of looking at that specific part because truly is is the graduation rate is generally not as reflective of where we currently are on the report card and the numbers we have as where we are looking at students who are currently on track so I appreciate you kind of differentiating even though that is the goal on our

016goal thing and that still is a goal graduation rate is still a goal um so I but I'm pleased and happy to work on whatever Direction pleas is the board one move across I think there's a I could be wrong but I feel like there's a next level of scoring that needs to be addressed in other words I mean I'd like to see like uh these goals have some scoring of like a 5 Four 3 2 one or something like that and and if so if you get to as Ben suggested at the last meeting like if you get to 80% maybe that's a four 70% is a three you know something along those lines I think in trying to calculate this numerically we need something some method to address that in some path maybe

017we don't decide that today I just didn't want it to not be noticed um and I and uh same with the the standards they could be graded in and it's sort of like report card five 54321 or something like that yeah anything that keeps us from doing satisfactory and unsatisfactory because I'm not living through that again um that that was that was just unacceptable um so I like the idea of having different places to go with that but I don't want to use a state as any standard regarding 80% because if you get an 80% or so graduation rate in the state of Ohio as a school district you get an F but I just I'm just making that point sure because I always make that point about the how we are you can achieve

018this graduation rate of 80 some per with a highly mobile very diverse very Urban uh School uh district and still that 80% which I think is a phenomenal achievement frankly under all circumstances is for the state they see it because they're measuring it against 570 suburban and Rural districts uh and so an 80 some percent graduation rate for US is is literally an F so that's something just to keep in mind so I I I'm thrilled that we have some high school goals on here too so so we've got the superintendent goals are there any other questions around that comments that's oh yes ma'am just um one thing for me just as a request for your consideration and whatever the scoring method is is um a request that it just be um something holistic that

019the board does as one um and not seven individual assessments if that's possible to consider comments questions the only way the only Authority we have is together all right okay so I'm sure we will have this topic on some level but today we're moving on so um superintendent Murphy and Treasurer Wagner it is time now you V to present your growth and sustainability topics I believe these presentations are on boards right for the public to look all right take it over so I I think the first topic phase one actuals was a document Miss Bolton wanted to go over that one yes this is just a reminder there's there's a couple of documents here uh treasur has worked out the the money part of uh uh phase one but I just wanted to remind the

020board and the public of what it was included in phase one which was pretty remarkable uh and that was the repurposing of Riverview the expansion of Mount Washington to a pk8 moved uh to in order to grow Spencer we moved him to Riverview combined the Owens and promise Center into one building uh moved Schroeder 7th and eth to former Lighthouse uh building uh thus creating the first of our new Junior highs Schroeder Junior High and in the some near future I think it would be great for the board to hear a report as to how that move to a junior high at Scher would be good but we can save that for assignments Schroeder became a 9912 uh and then we started to make the zoo Academy districtwide as part of the whole career piece

021and then gave uh Choice cluster options uh urging of President Moffett over a number of years to the PRM families being able to do go to some of the other schools that are close in that same cluster and then we uh created uh Bramble and uh and we said in the midst of uh phase one that uh its position and status and use would be to be determined so they just wanted to remind us of all that was done and the treasure has money uh toh talk about or at least a document that has demonstrated the cost of that tear back to the treasurer so before we switch to the slide deck do you want to go over I know there was concerns about the votes um document before we do that yes there was

022a a question by I'm Sor for Weinberg so I don't really have a question um just kind of a statement and a request but um vice president Bolton you stated that you wanted to have a update provided about Schroeder and just the high school I personally think that we should have an update on every single thing on this particular sheet because it gives us an idea of where we're going um and just to give us uh some data pieces as well great idea is that going to be an assignment to for the assignment piece put that in as an assignment how do you repeat that when we get cor I just want to uh again we'll bring it up part of this assignment also but just want to give a preview that I do think

023it'll be also important for us to look at what uh the attendance and enrollment numbers look like both the start and then where we currently are um and because I think that goes a little bit also to whether or not some of the projects that we're looking at in phase two that we've already as a board approved how we would adjust or have to make uh uh we have to make changes to or have to think about um because we do end up with places where we may have different and where the enrollment ends up at or lands at that may affect how we project what other schools would be looking at going forward so I will certainly make that as part of an assignment later but um and then also wanted to reiterate appreciation

024for sharing the information on where our current facilities look like because I think that also incorporates some of the the changes that we've made in that phase one so thank you board members I I would like is it possible that we could get it on one here I come with like one sheet or one rolling sheet where we can kind of see um to to their questions enrollment beginning phase prior to phase one phase one implementation what the enrollment numbers are whatever the data is that we're looking for can we get that just maybe on one sheet or just one way to to see the information so that it's I think preferably a spreadsheet but when we're looking at where we were to where we are it's easier for me to see it in that

025measurement I don't know if you all are looking would like that but that's that's what is helpful for me so that I can actually see the growth and I I can actually see the expenses I can actually see okay well it did cost us 5 million but we're going to save 10 or something like that whatever the numbers are that's just a preference and how I look at it yes ma'am just to follow up on that is the list that is before us which is really not anything more than notes uh not in great form is there anything else to add to f one off of that list um that is before us that I missed I don't know if Administration or Union folks or anybody picked up anything I think we captured most of

026it and I know some of this is still I won't say process but still evolving does that look like what we this is Phase One okay and we want the data about each of those uh and preferably on one sheet okay let's I love it I'm just this this is just how I look at it when I look at excuse me repurposing riverv view I'm not going to go down each one but like there was a cost of what Riverview was prior to the capacity of that building and then I'm looking at with Spencer adding to Riverview that capacity is increased the cost may be similar but is you know where's the savings at so that's that's how I'm envisioning looking at that when you combine one and three move to grow Spencer so now

027Spencer's building or their their expenses were this now they're they're currently this they have a capacity of X that's how that's what I'm thinking and again that is just um I think some of those up there combin Owens and promise Center promise Center was at the Jacob Center um Owens was the lighthouse so again those were two separate buildings coming to one now that money and that capacity those numbers look different so that's what I'm interested in seeing EXC of course board members can add whatever they're interested in but that's I'm looking at I'm interested ining at for the zoo Academy specifically how many were we able to service now we can accommodate more students so I'm looking at that type of data to be a to sh any other questions com it's great yes

028ma'am go ahead so the other document that Miss Bolton published was the votes on each of the bundles and earlier you had com commented that you thought there was a change to the document um I don't Rob if you can pull that up the vote the the votes document so for for me there was just and I know I heard from at least one other who expressed wanting to go back and expand on at least one of our areas we didn't decide on what would happen with regard to Taff Elementary um it was in a bundle so the you going have to make that just a little bit bigger eyes are not that not that uh pen so I did go back and verify that that is the document I sent out on December 16th

029yes it with the with the orange text on it because you were concerned about no what I was saying is that there in the document from December the December 9th meeting there was orange text added that was not in that original document and so and and I went back and looked at it and some of it was crossed out and I appreciate that but some of it gave an inference that may or may not been consistent with what was discussed at that meeting so that's what I wanted to finalize so the corrected version was sent out on December 16th with that text in it that that is so the orange like stay right there R the orange number 14 the board supports additional conversations around additional early college program and or other useful programs with

030local universities so you're saying that was in the original one or that was in the amended one I'm sorry it was in the corrected version right so the first one I sent I had to sent out a correction I sent the correction out on December 16th and that's what I highlighted were my changes okay go down I'm specifically interested in the Taff Elementary discussion okay so I may have captured it wrong but I just wanted to confirm that that was the same language okay okay so when we say um or the I know I did not as a board member know that we finalized ta mon Taft Elementary becoming a monory if I could stand corrected on that because we had board members go back and listen to it okay so it's bundle 24 Rob

031so um I wrote that what I wrote what it says there is um Rising Stars ADV Vine is prek only Taft receives the W has no magnet status no transport ation tff pk6 will Poss possible startup of an elementary monory neighborhood school okay so for me personally I don't remember removing K through six students from ta Elementary you didn't people they you I think what you said is they could stay if they wanted to stay right right and feel welcome they just wouldn't get Transportation okay I also said where are the other because what was said was 60 of those students were qualify to go to rockd and I asked where would the other students go because there's approximately 200 and some odd students at that school and the answer was wherever they wanted to

032go it's not an answer to me so where are those students going to go we never really finished that conversation definitively that I heard and I could very well be mistaken but I did not hear that T students were to go wherever they wanted to go I heard that they we needed to I thought we needed to make a definitive decisions and I could stand correct about that but I did not hear I heard that the lsdmc for t recommended a monory and I think that's great but we did not decide that there would be a monory there nor did we decide to displace those students to go wherever they wanted to go so that's what I would pass may I or is it me or no no I just gonna say I believe what

033we actually then voted on though was that they would start the process of tap monor uh starting with the kindergarten group coming through or first grade whoever starts at but that the students who were there presently would be able to stay as they were I think where now with regard to what monor will end up looking like or how it'll develop whatever was a little bit different and then at that time we also decided that the rap would stay at tapped Elementary as the original proposal was so while there was discussion about where students could or might go or whether we wanted to think about potentially I think one of the things we did talk about was potentially grandfathering in some Transportation needs um for at least a year to give at least a transition

034period of time but that those things would be more of discussion after the fact but that the least thing that we passed was uh adding the r moving uh removing the magnet status for the stem program and then putting potentially the start of a new uh monory because in part the original conversation was around the students would leave so they would start a whole new school at the beginning of the process and so we said those students should be able to stay was the discussion and then it ended on allow them to stay transition some new folks in through the lower level so we wouldn't bring new grades in behind them and that's what we voted on it was my understanding what we voted on but the the specifics and details of some of the

035transition and the that part of it will all be things that definitely still needs to come to the board and have discussion around and give direction about what what's going to happen but that was my recollection at least I know superintendent Murphy wanted to say you wanted to CL okay I I still have concerns and that's why I'm still a little confused because I don't think we decided on where those students go I asked a question around from from from ad hoc years ago a lot of those students were going to tap Elementary from the west side so if we are going to be allowing students to go back and only 60 of them will be going to Rockdale that means that we're pushing more students back on the West Side increasing those numbers which

036have to be redrawn anyway which are not in the plans to be redrawn so I asked where were they going specifically because that means some schools on the west side where they're coming from are going to now potentially be overcrowded and I don't think it's a sufficient enough answer to just say wherever they want to go without us knowing where they have the ability to go to and so that's why I asked the question I don't I don't think that we discussed it further I also know that there's a charter school that shares Transportation with Taff Elementary when I looked at their trans Transportation cost so they could potentially I didn't understand how their school is right literally 100 feet from them so they're already getting Transportation there so it's not really an additional cost

037that that building has a a large cost but it's also the charter sharing School uh Transportation the charter so I'm a little confus I just needed a little bit more information and I don't think we got that information so for me but vice president V yeah it doesn't seem to be any confusion necessarily about a startup of monu I think that even reviewing the the meeting itself that some kind of startup of monu that that's not the is your the issue is about the kids being able to remain and I think on three different occasions in the conversation in that meeting a board member ask can the kid stay and I think three times the superintendent I believe said yes and particularly if they're interested in monor but I think the the question for you

038that you're asking is the kids that don't want to stay and continue to be a part of it even without that Transportation but I think you're right the transportation's taken care of with the other charter school possibly that you're your your concern if I'm understanding is about the kids that are remaining or not remaining you're you're just worried right now about the kids that are currently at little Taft and what's happening to them and you need the superintendent to answer that so let me I I think I said this back in December my concern is not just that thank you for bringing that up my concern also stemmed from the engagement of those kids and those families around the change of their school so it's not enough in my mind to say where they want

039to go we should know where they qualify to go if they choose to and what their options are if they choose to stay and it felt to me like we were worried about a monory but not worried about the kids that were remaining and the engagement of the families that were there and so also I didn't feel like or understand if we had with Fidelity inquired between the transportation we're removing their transportation but we're going there anyway because the bus is dropping the other kids off right there 100t from them so I I I just don't we don't even know where those kids are coming from it wasn't definitively stated where those kids are coming from what schools they're going to we've talked to 10 kids and they qualify here like what are we doing

040we're worried about the monory piece we got that down pth but what about the the 200 or almost 200 kids that remain there that's what I that's what I was asking about and the engagement with those particular families and we we skirted along and we decided on one piece of it but I don't I didn't feel like we definitively answered any of the existing questions so that's that's my um I'm I put it on the record and at least one other board member asked me about ta Elementary so it wasn't just me that was confused um but you know the board said that we're fine with that then I you guys know my position so off for something all of the students who are at Taft right now prek through five will be able to

041remain at TA prek to five if I'm I'll back up because it was a lot of business that December meeting the original plan was that their uh magnet status would be removed therefore there would be no transportation that was the only original thing stated and then we wanted to move the preschoolers from Vine to Taft so that the school would remain and have the WAP at Vine that was the original uh piece that was shared with the board however there was no monaster anything in the original plan for Vine and for Taft but during that meeting there was a a request that they would be able to stay along the way Rothenberg declined uh the conversation around monory not a problem the V the half uh lcmc wrote a letter saying we would like it

042that's how that began but as a board what I recall is we did not want to force those kids who are currently there to leave understand so what we said was they can stay be grandfathered but they would matriculate through so there's probably about six years that those students don't have to worry or be concerned about going to another school there are current three-year-old preschoolers who will be able to remain as a four-year-old preschooler so the monor startup next year will only be preschool making it a little bit more expensive in my mind just as a startup so there's about six years of six seven years of transition for that school community at this point yes ma'am I'm we're align okay my my question slash concern is that when we say the students can stay

043we are taking away their transportation so can stay sounds like a maybe if transportation is your issue you can't stay because we're busing them from the West Side primarily that that population had a huge Westside um uh participation and we we had known that from the data in ad hoc so if they if they don't want to stay or if they want to stay but they but transportation is their issue would they go that's why I asked the other question like okay they qualify to go to Westwood well what we can do from a neighborhood standpoint only is we can get that information to you so that you would know where their neighborhood school would be um but past that what their interest is I don't know I have not checked on that at all

044but we do we can by address say to you this is what the neighborhood assignment would be I got you and that's what led to my question around engagement have we talked to those families to find out what is this is the plan I know I know that our plan has evolved as a board yeah but since December have we engaged them to find out this is what's going on this is this is how many would stay this how many wouldn't stay that's why I asked those questions back in December around hey do we know if the lsdmc is interested in this I think that's wonderful but have they done their due diligence around asking their population of of families how many would stay how many wouldn't how many would would need transportation and it

045didn't sound like there was a joint meeting of both schools to discuss this I can't remember the date um I can pull the date but there was a joint meeting for both schools both schools Vine and Taft Elementary okay no I mean it's okay I'm just saying those were the questions that I asked because I wanted to understand about the population of students that were there I can great again I've expressed my concerns if the board is fine with not getting that additional information you know that that it is what it is but I've um I just felt like we were very concerned with a monory which I think is great but we were just not as concerned around the students that were remaining only to the point where we said 60 of them can

046qualify to go to Rocka we we were leaving out a significant number of kids that we had no interest we had no no what they wanted or how many would remain and and that just troubled me but I'm I'm fine with that I think we didn't spend more time on it because I thought we decided that they would stay in December so but we just don't know how many are going to or how many need transportation that I just felt like there were still unnown yes and the transportation piece again was only because the directive was to remove the magnet status that's what and so superintendent to add to that are we aware do we know how many students it would affect how many or can we figure out and find out how many it

047could possibly affect in terms of deciding if they would like to choose to stay or go to a different school I think that it's important to have that information to be able to even know anything moving forward there's it's not a hell un willing to die on I just wanted to bring it bring it to our attention we never visited Revisited it because we spending a significant amount of time talking about mon so I just wanted to bring that up but he continues all right so Rob if we can slip to the slide deck and you can flip to the I just wanted to point out that we got posted or sent out on Thursday and then updated two things on slide 16 and slide 19 so if you had the older version this is

048the newest version excuse me um so if you'll flip to um the next slide so you wanted the cost of phase one so um the list that Miss Bolton read the final cost of all that was 1.3 million the large largest part being staff because um we committed to keeping the staff in place and um so I had a an extra little bit of cost there but so that was a cost of phase one and what I'll do is whenever they do the other document from the assignment we'll drop the cost in by bullet point this is just Collective cost um next slide is phase two um if you recall on December 2nd presentation I presented um that phase two would have a net Savings of $1.4 million if you adopted growth plan in whole

049then we had our board vote and so that dropped the savings to about $350,000 and that does include SCPA going to one start time still that's about a million dollars in transportation savings okay so um and that was from the original Staffing that went out on January 9th um and so if there was any appeals dur in those areas that might that 353 might change a little bit um I don't have the all the appeals costed that or yeah questions on that phase one or two miss m my apologies Miss M for M um yes just my quick question is so I recognize that we have identified the net savings um but have uh the team been able to identify I guess what the actual cost is for phase two yes it's in the document

050um I don't think I have it attached um I can send it out again but it's in the document that was presented on December 2nd um it shows you all the costs and then all the different savings and but that's just the net value I didn't know that you wanted to go through all those details this morning so I can um write myself a note so I won't forget I'll resend it out okay thank you that I think at least for me keep it at the top of my mind to know what the actual cost is and to be able to identify this is how much we're saving sure um to the point that you made all in kind of one place so thank you yeah so it's a grid that shows you like so

051and so is point a go going to point B and then if they have equipment costs if they have moving costs if they have Staffing costs and then it's just spread out and so yeah absolutely um okay so next slide phase three yes ma' I'm sorry thanks um when you go back here to the phase uh one the staff costs you mentioned that's because we maintained staff yeah particularly when they combined Riverview and in Mount Washington the formulas would have driven a surplus but we as a commitment to the staff and to the change and to the parents we committed to keeping the staff in in those are areas so it was in the implementation and doing it in a greater Humanity if you will uh timing since we were doing all that very quickly

052it was that we were in that transition we kept staff it isn't that we added staff it's that we kept staff perhaps where they were or were not needed in order to maintain some aspect of programming at Riverview or we may have added um AP or a security or something in the but it wasn't something significant I don't remember exactly okay so it wasn't ad it was just a n move but um I mean when I send out those documents I can send out the details of that too don't I don't mean to be labored I just wanted to make sure yeah thank you on okay phase three so um I just added if you at your leisure if you want to go look I added the presentations I did on December 9th and um

053this the 18th when I was explaining the cops presentation um the um so this is going to drive into the whole Levy planning conversation um you have if you hit the next slide for me I think it's um you have four big needs one you have the $48 million enal that's coming up in November of 2025 and so there's some decisions to be made about that whether you want to continue as a five-year cycle go to a 10-year cycle go to continuing or do a substitute and if you want to make keep it the same size because this is the one that supports the $15 million set aside for preschool expansion so there's a decision to be made there and then you have operational needs so it recall um the growth plan had Savings in

054the first year but then there were some Career Tech ads that were going to be added to the budget in the following years you also have entering negotiations so if there's any negotiated increases that come through that um that all has to be sized but you do have a need for more new money just to operate then you have the facility repair plan that I think that at last costing was 170 million over a fiveyear period And I costed that if we did a pi Levy um it would be approximately four Mills um and you can do that in 26 or 27 because you have one on 25 already you could do two in one year but then you risk having one go up and one go down and so it's a risk to take

055um and then the other fourth need is to support the growth plan on phase three which is the seven projects that cost about 200 million on construction there's no programming in there just the construction costs and you could do a bond Levy close to when the current Bond Levy expires and so we're having in some strategic talks that we have some creative things to do you can go a little bit early or you could actually borrow against future Reven tax revenues so um I'm setting up a meeting with um our financial adviser David Conley Kent Cashel and Brenda weamer we're all going to get in the room together and work through the details because they're very complicated and then we'll come to the board and talk about that one so one mill right now is

056generating about $8.8 million in property Revenue you want to go with a fix some Levy because if you go back to a fixed rate Levy because we're under the 20 mil floor it'll pop you back over the 20 mil floor so you end up like if you had a levy that was generating $10 million and they go you pop back over the 20 mil floor you're going to lose what you were gaining under the 20 mil floor so you only get like 5 million a year instead of 10 million does that make sense I'm just I'm making up numbers just to so um the renewal Levy should or the new operating Levy should stay at fixed s because it'll have a negative impact on the 20 M floor questions m Bolton president Bolton this is

057my favorite part of all of this um and it's also with the president Moffett said we should spend some time on particularly of all the financial listing here help me out um we we have our $48 million when coming up and can you flip the the next slide it shows this and it's this our our Slinky diagram yeah we got that and we have issues about the length of it and possibly adding to it uh in money as well yes if we don't add to it it money um I mean uh we really are looking at uh 26 because you're suggesting we will need new money as early as 26 is that your need new money now um because you always new money for two to balance to next year's Revenue you're gonna have to

058have a budget reduction we talked about that so so help me out that we're going to need new money we need it now and we could add to the uh 48 million uh which is the you don't let me ever call it preschool uh but the 48 million or we could have our own new Levy in 26 but regardless of needing that new money and doing something either in one of those two blocks you could let the $48 million one expire and create a new Levy that's larger that's what I wanted to add so that's yes yes you could do that and when it if you let it expire when does it expire and what happens what's that bridge time between so because uh taxes this one is it would expire you quit collecting in

059your last payment would be like the August of 26 would be the last T property tax collection because it would expire that calendar year okay because on this particular Levy we had immediate typically when you do a levy in November you don't actually start collecting until January of the F year plus so in in this Levy we did it in November of 16 we started collecting in January 17 because we put in the ballot language for immediate collection right typically a normal Levy you do it in November of 16 you don't actually start collecting until January of 18 because property taxes are year and AAR so that's why this Levy when it expires in 25 you'll quit collecting on it in 26 so in this Levy we could as a messaging thing or as an

060optional thing you could let this expire and you would create a new Levy not an an old renewal correct but a new Levy and that would that new Levy be this would we enccompass and take care of our preschool situation and our other operational money of 33 and add what we need for the facilities or is that are you is that what you're talking about a new no I wasn't no because it would be the millage would be huge if you add the facility repair plan into that so we have we would have to cost out what the new Need is and there's too many unknowns right now for me to come out with a dollar okay okay so um my recommendation would be to stick to a an operational Levy and a pi Levy

061in the following year but don't do them in the same year but I wouldn't do them together because it would be the millage would be so high that I don't think it would pass right so that's where I have where I need more clarity is right there at the front end of this I don't have a problem with the back end of this to finish phase three or whatever which all those additions and I see that as the big additions but I know Mr Mr Craig is very has been pretty adamant about first things first regarding the facilities piece so uh probably this is an introduction or a third or fourth introduction to this topic we can move on today but that's where I would need some more understanding as to the the sequence the

062chain of events for this new money because you're right we need new money now we've gone even past our eight-year uh efforts uh the last couple of I don't know 16 or 20 some years of doing this every eight years but that's if we can come back maybe that happens in finance or whatever and we get even down and dirty on that a little bit more would be helpful to me I don't know if other members have question questions I think to ask as a matter of fact it looks like board member Craig does so I'll try and be quick because I want to get through as much of this as we can get through today um I I do think so the one I think we're actually task with two questions that we need

063to immediately think about as a board one is the operational Levy what is both the dollar amount length of time that we want to request I think it's a pretty simple for that part if we choose not to do it then we have to make decisions based on the hope that we would sometime you know someone would pass a new Levy if we don't choose to this one I don't think that's necessarily the wisest course of action to do I think the second thing that we have to decide at the at a near future so not as immediate but pretty soon after is that we two years ago I think almost or a year and a half ago were given um a fact finding on what are the facility repair needs those have not gotten

064cheaper they will only get more expensive the more we go the more we wait and the reality though is that we're at a point where we're not going to be we would not be successful putting two levies on the ballot at the same time even saying to folks don't you don't want your building to fall apart in the middle of a snowstorm right like as as dire as that may sound to folks they're gonna look at two levies and say well but which one you need most and make us pick so I think it makes more sense to do 25 we do the operational Levy 26 is when we come back to do a pi Levy to to draw revenue and now the question becomes how do we want to phase in those facility needs

065in accordance with also what are the district needs for for those facilities because I think there's a reality there's some repairs that may definitely need to get done that the real is we're just not gonna get them done in the same time frame right like you're not gonna do every roof in the district at one time and I think that's where we had the fact finding before they gave us a plan of things and I think that's where we can get that plan and as over the year goes make a decision to really put that as a Forefront um I think the reality of that also means that we can do a lot of the work with trying to make sure all our buildings are updated and ready for every student who walks in the

066door that's the other part to the struggles we're going to see from the state is they don't seem to share love interest for giving more fun funding to districts to do uh facility work in a way that once was done um so I think that's for us at least right now the the immediate question the immedate thing I appreciate Jen for bringing back to our Forefront is what is that a dollar amount in large part because it also will drive some of our discussion as to what ultimately is our budget for the next school year because if we are prioritizing certain things that will mean that we may not have the same amount of Revenue to drive to other stuff or we may be looking at other needs that we have that we have to

067figure out a way to compensate or pay for whether it's the next fiscal year or the fiscal year after through these levies just shared with you um Google sheet that's called forecast long term so one thing I forgot to mention on this slide here is you have 25 November 25 is renewal you'll have another renewal of 28 which is a $65 million Levy then your next renewal after that 32 so you have 25 26 27 26 is when we're doing the trianal update so 28 would be a bad time to have something a new money on the levy um so this is where I'm tracking cash forecasts and trying to maintain a compositive cash balance with what we know to be new upcoming in in cyclical needs so if you scroll down a little bit

068where it says operational cash right there so what I'm trying to do is look at what's what is the size Levy going to look like so I know what the growth plan or we thought what the growth plan was going to cost um go forward we know what the facility repair plan based on Chris's excellent planning work um we have I just threw 200 million in as a growth plan for three in 28 because I didn't know when it was going to happen and then technology um they're on a fiveyear cycle so they're going to have needs going forward but we know that right now that $6.5 Million worth of leases we paid for Esra this year coming back to the general fund in 26 so that's going to be an increase to the budget

069then we also I got a five-year curriculum cycle adoption from the curriculum department and I dropped those in because that's above and beyond our current operational spending so I'm I'm trying to do those unknowns and then once we start looking at um um cost incre know colas any kind of negotiated changes that might cost money in in the collab in the cbas um and any other things that might come up as part of New Growth plan stuff or new strategic plan stuff so I'm trying to keep track of this on a document so that when I once I get the dollar amount I can calculate the millage to figure out and help decide where what direction to go but you have when you have you have Windows of time in order to do this new

070stuff you I have a question for you before we get off that side oh all right stay there sorry when it says millage calculation under 28 your 28 that's not Mill and only because the $200 million is in it so if you you pull that up because it's not going to be part of the new money Levy that'll be a bond issue okay um 200 million I thought that it just was kind like that excuse a lot two 200 million would be um it's not it's not a 22 mil you don't take 200 million divided by 8.8 M um for Mills because what you're paying annually is the principal and interest on the borrowing right so if you borrow 200 million it you'd only have I think I calculated it to be about three Mills

071um to do a $200 million Bond Levy okay thank you any other vice president Bolton oh go ahead just uh thank you uh just a quick question I want to make sure I'm tracking with you uh treasur Wagner so with the 48 mil uh renewal we know that that that money was already voted upon by the taxpayers and this is something that we're possibly considering to renew for this upcoming Levy cycle um but if as you talked about if we decided to allow those funds or um that uh renewal opportunity to expire you talked about the opportunity to create new money what would that particular Levy be considered with the the new money being generated after you identify what all the needs are well we haven't finished identifying all the needs yet that's the conversation

072here but yeah once that's done you can cost it out and figure out what the new Levy would be that would replace the old Levy okay so it's pretty much at our discretion as to whether we decide for it to be a pi Levy or what's the other operational level it's called an emergency Levy I don't know why they call it an emergency but it's that's what it's called fix some Levy a permanent Improvement Levy you can only do permanent Improvement projects on it to have it fiveyear life fiveyear Le life or older you can't use a pi Levy for operations okay okay you can use an operational Levy for improvements but you can't go the other way okay and the same thing with bonds bonds can only be on construction okay but again is

073at our determination as to what Levy we decide we would want to put on back right okay so we did this exercise one time when I was the baby treasure I I think I don't know if this Bolton was there or not but we put all the wishes up on the list and we costed it out and it ended up being like 30 Mills and I just it was dead silence everybody walked out depressed I'm like well that's you know that's your wish list now let's figure out what reality is and reality is really about the millage number about what we think we can pass rather than what the dollar value is okay eight has a magic number I'm told in the election world so um does so yep no yeah they try to standard

074double digit so stay make it a 9.98 levy so vice president B yeah real very quickly so we have a renewal that we have to make some decisions about in 25 we do we have what's the next renewal that we have 28 eight and that's the $65 million that's the 65 one and then the next renewal that we would or could have would be based upon how long we make the 48 one or it's the 32 it's $52 million Levy it comes up in 32 would be the next in 32 so we know we have 25 28 and 32 right we also know that our giant facilities master plan it will be paid off and that I know that's not the right term in 30 something December 1st of 31 so the huge thing that

075the I'm just talking about messaging and monies and whatever there's a we have almost a greater opportunity for money a little bit later but our problem right now is that we need money now correct okay thank you and if you in the $48 million Levy I can't express this enough the $15 million set aside for preschool we both entities have outgrown that right today this year's budget is about $20 million we're using prior year unspent cash to fund that but that unspent cash is going to run out next year so with next year's budget we either going to have to take money away from K12 to help fund the growth in preschool or scale back what we're doing in preschool right for both entities so or you increase the revenue right so decisions decisions any

076questions okay okay the next slide is just another look at the Timeline I won't through it but it just um there you go it just kind of shows you like I put on there like what H what other things are happening like next summer next November we have four members are coming up for election and then we put the city council election up there and so um you could just look at that at your leisure okay next slide in the interest of time so somebody asked to have the debt summary to review the debt summary schedule this is what it looks like we actually paid off um one um borrowing in December 1th of 24 we made our last payment you can see that is the second Gray Line the one up above it will

077make our last payment in June coming up and so we'll have paid off those two debts the front the top line is the only voted Levy that we have that's the bond Levy we as of July 1 of 25 we'll have $173 million balance and then the other ones were used to help fund the rest of the facility master plan so we just keep plugging away the two 2011 2012 Q Scoobies um we actually making principal and interest payments into what they call it a syncing fund it's really kind of like a a set aside so all our principal and interest payments are going into that so that when the loan comes due that money is already there to pay it off that's what that is so you can see that on the 2011 we

078owe $3 million but we have 2.7 sit aside in a syncing fund so we only have $220,000 left on July okay any questions on debt and before you ask me we only have about $9 million of debt capacity which isn't going to help us much in our in our future planning so the answer is not to get more debt okay um next slide oh my gosh okay so these are the topics that we wanted to discuss during this section um just go ahead and flip to the next slide zero base budgeting versus incremental is as to explain that incremental budgeting you just take what you have and you keep adding to it as you do strategic new things that you want to buy zerob based budgeting you start off at zero and then you evaluate

079everything you spend your money on for the effectiveness of that spend so what happens is in incremental budgeting it the budget grows so fast because you never stop doing anything you did right and so we really want like to go back to zerob based budgeting it's really hard it's hard work because nobody ever wants to stop doing things um but we don't we just don't have the cash reserves to continue with incremental budgeting I just want to point out we are currently at incremental we tried over the years to go back to zero base but we weren't not everybody cooperated let's put it that way Goa vice president Bolton so I heard you say we want to go back to zero base treasure Wagner wants to go back to zero base honor way out but

080yes I think I think we all are interested in zase so our re we all know and we presented this before our revenues are not keeping track with inflationary rates so our budgets keep getting squeezed down further and further and because and this is not a crism Miss sellers but because we do school budgets first whenever there's a reduction it hits in central office that's cool we call that residual budgeting we'll go over that in just a second um okay next slide fingers crossed I was asked to explain student based versus staff based we used to do student based budgeting um I don't know early 2000s mid 2000s um and there was some inherent weaknesses in that model one was dealing with student Mobility because what they do is the Money Follows the students and

081we did enrollment three times at capture enrollment three times in a year and the schools that start high and lose kids would lose Revenue but they kept the staff and so at the end of the year they would be owing the district back money and that just kept building and so we kind of abandoned that the other concern is with student based budgeting we would take all the students and do their waiting and then we would give the school I would just say Wagner Elementary here's your $15 million go build a budget well they didn't they weren't always compliant with the things they really needed they kind of funded what they wanted like for example we had one school who saved a teaching team great academic construction what but they didn't budget for any security

082so when it came to baseball season they calling me asking for more money for security I'm like well that's the decision you should have made when you built your budget right so and then we there wasn't always the tracking on the compliance especially these compliance stuff and now because we have restricted funding in the state formula so our our all weighted our gifted elll Career Tech and poverty are all restricted funds you have to show that you're spending that money on those things to get that down to the school level granularly is going to be is a little bit difficult it can be done we have the systems to do it we take a lot of teaching and guidance um but so that's student based so the money is actually allocated to the schools based

083on the needs of the students and those are the consider the needs of the students staff base is kind of the way we're doing it now because we take we do the student projections but we calculate the staff and then everything gets driven off of not everything a lot of those things get driven off and then the school gets a per pupil allocation for non-personnel and they decide how to spend that money um any questions I don't have a question I have a comment excuse me ni president help me and and everybody because we some people actually think because we do our budgeting by enrollment we do our staffing by enrollment that there's some element that there that that's student based in in reality it's it's not to explain a little just quickly a little

084bit more that you would the there's money that exists there's Revenue that exists restricted Revenue based upon what kinds and types of kids or cohorts we have help me out real quick so it is student Bas so it's all based on the students in the district so student based but it's not really student based budgeting right not so it's student based Staffing so you take the projected number of students you and you roll through the formulas and then you decide how many kindergarten teachers how many first grade and then on the conditions of the kids there's a team of each department determines what Staffing is needed for like the special needs kids based on their IEPs um and then there's other formulas that grow like regardless of what the needs of the or the population

085of a school is you're going to get an assistant principal for every 100 or 450 kids it takes 450 kids to get an assistant principal but it could be if you looked at you know the discipline of the building you might decide well we need a little bit more of something rather than just equally using the same formula across the board so it's the it's the way you cond you measure and track and wait the conditions of the students or the needs of the students versus a flat formula at sequel across the board that answer your question I think so it's just the student the the students do determine what kinds of money is's in that each school's budget correct it's not just the overall number of enrolled but it's what sorts of kids you

086have because some kids are producing more Revenue if you restricted Revenue than maybe General Ed kids would produce I mean this is coming from the state the feds where so it it depends sometimes it's our policy sometimes it's collective bargaining agreements sometimes it's a state or federal rule law so we have to follow all of them um but so right now when you're going to staff in elementary school we go through our formulas they're mostly collective bargaining agreement designed um and then the different teams DSS will go and say okay with this population kids you need this many intervention Specialists or this many classroom unit specialized units or this many one-on-one pasas based on I APS and then the gifted team will say okay this based on these kids you need this many gifted teachers

087elll will say you need this many elll teachers instead of on this side it's all driven by the waiting and the funding of the students for them to come to look at the school's needs to come up with a plan based on the type of kids you have needs of kids so it depends I mean we talked at one point of using the size of the building or students experiencing homelessness um discipline we looked at reading scores and we we played with a lot of data to determine like how best to fund the needs of each individual school so that it was more Equitable rather than equal thank you questions I I do want you to I want you to I want you to go through this but I do feel like there's there's some

088um benefit to having the uniqueness of each building have what they need and there should be a way to drive the formula down to say hey these are the things you have to fund you have to fund security you have to fund you know so but after all of those needs are met right then you get to be as creative as you want to and I think that that I don't know if we've it was a decade ago and maybe times are Chang and we can do things differently but I like yeah it's a I'm I'm I'm doing some modeling with different types of schools just to see like if I could come up with some one model that all schools can fit into but their each of their needs get taken care of so

089at the be I only done one spool it was an interesting exercise but um so we'll come back when we have more data and we can talk about F you all right next slide residual budgeting I think I talked about this but I just did a little graphic so um residual budgeting is you take a budget Target so we have $624 million to play with again we do the school budgets and then central office gets what's left over and then they if they have his money left over they get to do some new strategic initiatives right so it's kind of like what's left over on the other side you set your budget Target you fund your strategic inititive first because that's what's going to take the district forward and then you go zero based on

090the rest to and figure out what's the most effective spend to get to where you want to go because you we can't cut any more central office we're cutting to the level of incompetence and or not incompetent in the ability to serve the schools the way they need to be served so we it just can't they just can't keep taking it on the channel I knew they grew for a while and we we we got rid of some of that growth but it's hurting us real real quick on that I I don't I know this will sound terrible but I don't know that funding the schools or budgeting the schools first is necessary the wisest thing but I think we do it first in part because of transfer rounds transfer rounds I mean it's a

091tail waging the dog and we then we have to make adjustments I mean obviously our schools and our kids are primary our number one priority but but uh having to do having to have the school budgets done as early as they have to be done because of the Staffing I think I think rushes us into some decisions that maybe we wouldn't necessarily make so I think I may have misspoken it wasn't necessarily the transfer rounds that caused us to go earlier we went earlier because we were trying to compete with other districts for the best teachers recruitment right so that's why I moved it up was because of the ability to recruit and um I'm not sure how to make both of those things happen but we'll work on it thank you okay next slide

092Mr Craig oh I'm sorry sorry go ahead I I was just gonna say one of the things though and and looking at the two different strategies I think actually what makes the priority that we tried to set last year and that we still didn't really get to but if you don't establish your priorities well before you start to go into your budget talks which we didn't do again this year you can't have the second model where you're talking about your strategic initiatives and your Investments that are necessary because you're still doing the conversation around we don't even know what we want yet and I think that's why in large part why still some of the budgeting stuff we're doing when we go to the school budget and Cent operation all that yes part of the

093part of it is yes trying to deal with getting Recruitment and everything else but if you look at a lot of organizations when they have budgets that start when ours technically start they do their disc conversations in the spring of that fiscal year before so like not the spring like we're not talking about fiscal year this year talking about school year in the fall we're talking about spring this year to talk about the school year for next fall and when you do that that gives you so much more time to have the true conversation around what your PRI budget priorities are to then also evaluate what happened throughout the year to see whether or not those priorities still last so like I think one of the things that might be helpful for us to do

094as we if we are able to power through a lot of what we're doing now is to not end the conversation around the budget to really just try and get us to get in this point of doing okay so for next year what are our budget priorities that we want to establish upfront and especially when we're having a new treasure come in because Jen refuses to stay with us for forever and with us having certain things we've already established our changes to the district if we set some of those priorities early and UPF front as we keep trying to drive to do then when we get to this point next year it's not about building these things it's about okay we now know we have we've seen what worked we've seen what our budget looks

095like and we're able to give a clear picture to the teachers we never get a clear picture to the other staff in our schools but to parents into students and to ourselves because I think that's what our struggle has been is that we wait to do our priority until the fall and now we're also doing all this other stuff also and so it hasn't really given us an opportunity to true to do true budgeting the way organizations who live in the level of organization and fourthought fourthought uh have good thank you okay next slide so um I was asked to share our current Staffing model formulas that we've been talking about so for example a K3 classroom right now we we load to 25 with a pair of um you know and I talked about

096the assistant principal formula that's not in the CBA it's just our common practice so that's an example of formula that's not dictated by state law um but it would be insane not to have APS in our buildings um counselors and social workers were trying to get to National averages and in fact last year when we added the counselors for graduation are actually better than the national average um social work I've been doing some investigating on that I think the recommendation is one for 120 and I'm like there's no way right now we have one per building um which is something to think about because you have one building with 700 kids in it one building with 300 kids in it do they both need one full-time social worker but it could be because of the

097conditions of the kids and what their needs are I don't know so it's just things to look at and then Mike linked Mike actually did this slide deck for us or this slide I and actually link the full Staffing formulas if you want to get into the granularity but um that's what is was currently fund well that's what funded the January 9th Staffing there's a new model that we're looking at right now that has smaller class sizes in K3 and 46 and 78 right all three of those grade bands yeah okay next slide I have a question Jen yes you said that previously a lot of what we do is driven by the contracts the the that so these numbers are for the uh clroom based formulas those are driven by the contract yeah so

098that all that's except for so there's different contracts right so in the CFT contract the class sizes are in there um the ELO for Staffing formulas are in there and special needs and psychology some of the other stuff's in there too right jul um okay okay then in the cast contract I don't think we have any staffing requirements in there so but the state says you have to have a principal in every building so that's the state rule the assistant principal is our rule um and then um the secretarial ones are some are some of it's defined in the in their CBA um you have to have a building engineer by state law in every building so it's a collective sources of them okay thank you you're welcome next slide there we go so I

099was asked to talk about Tac and overload So currently the student projections by school by grade and conditions Drive class siiz formulas that drives into school Staffing then that drives into transfer round so you have people that positions that move around okay then in September after Labor Day there was always this thought that some kids didn't show up until after Labor Day so they gave time to get all the kids in the buildings before we would look we would rightsize the Staffing to actual students because it's all projected and projections are projections um and so that's always done in September but there's an interest in moving that forward so it's less disruptive to the academic instruction right so I but I I still even if we move it up in August I still think there's

100going to have to be a September adjustment it might be smaller but if there's a group of kids that don't show up then you got to have staff in places that you don't need them and you'll be overstaffed sorry I keep hitting this um but then I also put the fiscal year 25 overload budgets up there so currently we have in the current year budget $4.7 million funded for overload Paras and Emily would tell us that we don't have overload pairs they're just pairs but in order for us to do Staffing the way we do Staffing we have to label them as the role that they're playing in the school and then um in addition to overload Pera we have overload pay budget that's another $2.1 million so some of the formulas say when you

101get into an overload situation you get overload pay and then when you get to the next level you get a Pera and then you get to the next level you take that stuff away and put a new teacher in so you split the class into any questions on that not operational yes thank you um okay next slide so I think Miss Bolton asked me this question are formulas a help or a burden and we try to go through kind of pros and cons formulas gives you a mean to allocate money right and um it can be student based and hopefully it will be it it provides a level of equality you know I keep saying everybody wants Equity until it's not equal then they want equal I get phone calls all the time um it

102can be very trans arent if you publish all your formulas then and your data um and then it formulas also you have to have formulas in order to allocate your title one monies so it has to be based on something the burden side is currently right now it's kind of Staff based it makes a little bit harder it's a little bit little bit inflexible sometimes like the social worker you know formula um the potential for inequities because when you're doing things equally they become sometimes inequitable um and then it's slower to adapt the student changes so if there's a shift in enrollment or a shift in um the decline in enrollment stuff like that so formulas are both a help and a burden not an or okay questions next slide I'm sorry some formulas we

103could uh change and would not require contractual language changing well yeah like we changed the system principal formula exct it changed every year for for the last three or four years so would be really you know it's good we don't need to know it but you all know which ones they're written in stone and which ones aren't and which ones if you're in the midst of negotiations or something or you get some kind of change okay yep yep okay so next slide this could segue to the next slide um so under the traditional formulas that I showed earlier we had a general fund budget of 397 million on January 9th for just Staffing School Staffing then we went we ran it with smaller class sizes at the requests of the superintendent so K3 went to

10420 to1 46 went to 28 and 712 1 to 30 um without peras and it it showed that that would increase our staffing by close to $5 million smaller class sizes means more people and you need more people than your had Paras that are going away so um any questions on that K I'm sorry I kind of want yes to your questioning but I but I but I also want to ask the board members because it is 156 please and I would ask if can we get just a little bit extra time I know some people had had a hard stop but can we get just a little bit of extra time from everybody okay um we can add the rest of it to the next board meeting yeah okay so just to get through

105this through Jen's part I think the budgeting piece at least yeah there's there's there's a there's a couple good stopping places real quick okay um vice president there so this you're saying that with running at the lower uh number of students lower class size that you just that you did it it it's a $5 million difference is that Tak to place not needing part uh Paris are are not needing overload so this this means overload you'd still have the same amount of overload or you're still help me out no the overload goes away because you're making small that's what I'm asking so this five million you already took away any savings because we wouldn't have overload right that's a net change okay but overload and Paras are gone are part of the are are this

106and it's still five million yes more yes but with smaller classes and it's smaller classes K12 that's a $5 million to me in smaller classes K12 is looking pretty good but you got to figure out what you're going to cut to pay for finite budget listen I have a red pen um so just ask me so operationally less pairs in the building means less help with lunch duty bus Duty got it um and so that will be a concern then the schools are going to say I need my Paris back then that budget goes up because we're not goingon to trade in a teacher to do that right soank I just want to reiterate a point that we made last year when we had this discussion have we ever been fully staffed for the level

107of teachers that we have needed now so the thought that we would get to a point where we would be able to staff all of these folks is also somewhat not realistic unless we've made that of an effort to get even to the level we need now so I do think like while I'm all four if we want to make this decision we can make the decision whatever but also with the reality that we're still going to have classes that are bigger than that because or spaces where we're going to need Pairs and other things to fill those spaces because we don't have that now so I mean we budget for not filling positions each year so like I want us to be kind of more honest about that conversation we're going to talk about

108smaller class sizes also budgeting for overload too we're budgeting to be at Max and I my my concern is I'm not sure in the marketplace how having smaller classes would that attract more people would that retain more people would that save more mental health let alone uh the other kinds of things the stresses for teach just there's like big things to talk about which is all fine again we don't feel the positions we have and it's not just us it's every school district across the country is struggling to find teachers now there's a varying reason why because we put a lot of burden on teachers we do not necessarily always support the teachers in the way they need to be supported but that until I like I would find it very hard to say simply

109making small class I is gonna mean we're gonna suddenly get a bunch of teachers so that's all that's all I'm saying I totally agree with that and and and same as just making different wages doesn't necessarily do it either people really stay in a building because they like the principle or they don't like the principal very frankly so I mean there's a there's a there's a half dozen things that could make us be able to build more positions with the highest quality folks but remember map something to think about um yes so I just have a question as we're talking about the pairs how often do the I guess pars maybe uh substitute for maybe the actual gened teacher or are we only focusing on like substitute teachers coming in because if we're talking about

110maybe reducing the amount of pairs I wonder what that impact would be I think I'm if I to answer that question I don't know superintendent that not having the pears in the buildings will definitely have an impact to the overall operations of the building including uh they do have an opportunity to earn a few more dollars on the hour when they cover classes if they're willing to do that so there could be an impact in the classroom as well okay so how many exactly that is right yeah right okay but I guess obviously just looking at it it could be an impact either way right if we're looking at the smaller class sizes that might be a a benefit in terms of the learning but on the other side of things it could be a

111huge impact in terms of the operations of supporting our teachers and our students so it's definitely worth considering when we're having the conversation about uh changing um the the Staffing formula okay board member Weinberg add we could sorry about that could go back and forth regarding class sizes I mean there's pros and cons um there's data to show different things um it's obviously uh worth the discussion but I think in terms of moving on is just realizing that this is the data that it's showing then we can have a discussion about it I guess later I I am all for the the proposal and the information I do think that there are many other things that go into this that I'm interested in knowing about um as far as like what's the percent the vacancy

112percent of our parents currently we are we are to board member Craig's point we're we're at a deficit of teachers and parents and so I would like to look at I think it makes sense to I think it's a great savings and $5 million is for lower class sizes on the surface sounds great but there is also a lot to that number and I'm I'm not it's not missed on me that um that there are other factors you're we're already underpaying our pars we're already not paying them when they're uh not in the building and um I think that when there's a push there's an opposite pull we don't see it right here because it looks great but there's there's going to be some negative uh impact I know for instance monory um classrooms have

113a pair a requirement to them that we're not discussing here so again I think it sounds great on the surface I do want us to kind of get through the slid so that we get the picture in totality and then we can maybe at a board meeting to segregate some of this information sure okay so if you'll skip ahead to slide 18 next there this is just a reminder of the res the language and the resolution that you adopted that you would not ex create a budget that exceeds our revenues all of our revenues right all the revenues but particularly the general funds is the largest share I understand but we did get it to say all of our revenues the last time we passed it yes okay so if you on the target um

114word it'll take you to so this is a work in progress it changes constantly and I can't read that so I'm have to go to my lip but it um it starts off with um the for November forecast for so in November of 24 we do it a fiveyear forecast the revenue for fiscal year 26 forecasted was 625 million okay in finance committee we're talking about creating a cash res U balance policy to build up our cash reserves because they we've we've chunked into them pretty low to get to 60-day cash balance balance over a fiveyear phas in period you'd have to set aside $12 million every year to start building that cash back up so there's no decisions been made but this is what if we did that the available money that we have

115to build a budget on would drop to 612 you follow me okay so from the 612 you take off all the fixed costs so the fixed costs are defined by our debt payment schedule the fund 34 transfer that were're required to do facility facility maintenance all the auditor and state fees Bank fees liability insurance and the superintendent salary and the treasur salary because we're both dictated by state you have to have one of each so those don't change the next line should represents um what's in the Collective bargan Agreement requirements so like teacher stip and Lead Teacher stiens the SI Leaf conversion professional development um long-term subs for maternity and and and long-term illnesses then the step increases um and then crossing guards we've been we've been saying that if we bring them in house

116it's going to cost us a million more in our current budget um the Suzuki return so last year we we did this um $100,000 Suzuki contract from a different source and that source is gone so bringing that back up um the te I already talked about the technology return so one of the least payments the $65 million we used in s for this year is coming back to the journal fund we last year if you recall we delayed uh the rosson repair project because we knew we were going to get it done this year so we moved it into 26 the school Staffing on January 9th was 397 million you saw that on the other slide and then with the smaller class sizes I added that green spot of 4.9 the non-personnel that's being added

117to the school budgets on a per pupil basis is $6.5 million and then I have the board discretionary so it's the board office budget and the internal office budget internal auditor office budget together so that spend is $481 million already so that leaves you with1 130 million to allocate if you do the $12 million set aside if you don't do the $12 million set aside you have $ 142 million comparatively speaking in the current year budget that 142 million was about 21 million so those that haven't been left budgeted are going to have have to take sacrifice that cut that make sense had some hard decisions to make um you go back to slides you have any questions about this and I just keep updating as I get new information so that's why it says

118it's a work in progress don't get any number in your head because in may we we may have to revise the fiveyear forecast based on the current year enrollment Trends um and if we lose enrollment then next year's revenues will decline by the state funding formula because remember ta don't change en but State funding does that that's why we have a growth plan okay so yeah you can go back to the slide deck thank you I'll keep talking real fast we're almost done um this I was asked to show these are our state and federal grants and so they're listed there um it shows you the fiscal year estimated allocation and then what our estimated carryover is from last year so how much we have available to spend so for example title one are and

119this does not include we took the non-public status so these are CPS dollars Title One have 24 million to spend we're going to have about $3 and half million in carryover so our budget will be 27 million for title one okay next slide shows the rest of them because we split it onto two slides um and we shared this at finance committee last month I think so we have total of $50 million in allocation in state and federal grants some are much more restrictive than others we have about $5.5 million of carryover for a total of 56.3 million to spend and um the grants team has been meeting with superintendent I'm hearing the the plans are looking really good so feeling optimistic about how well we're going to spend that money okay next slide um

120these are just right off the website board goal your goals reading math and college in career Readiness next slide shows the guard rails over two slides you can skip over those because they're already public and I'm sure you've read them a 100 times um these I'm going to turn this over to superintendent Murphy because these are her her identified budget priorities for fiscal year 26 thank you Jen so in our district performance sustainability redesign and growth plan I have started to uh categorize everything that we're doing under growth into either operational efficiencies which you can see listed number one number two increased student nowc comes where we value the whole child and then on the next slide number three preparing our students for beyond the tassel those are how I'm categorizing the things that you

121have voted uh affirmatively for uh yep as we move forward Department of student services I'm sorry that's my fault no no no we speak in acronyms I we have a whole lot list of dictionary and acronyms for um and as if you flip to the next slide Rob you'll see the third category you can see what's under that was there another question over here Matt uh thank you so um as it pertains to uh your budget priorities uh superintendent Murphy uh you and treasur ragner and the team have been working to identify how each of these priorities work or would fall within our 5year forecast yes absolutely and I think that for most of one two and three Jen shared that out the cost for the automotive and the Cosmetology buildout in terms of um

122location would have to be in phase three because it'll require a pretty substantial amount of money we of course believe we can get entrepreneurship done at a very small cost okay thank you yes ma'am oh and then my final question to this based off of those discussions um and setting apart phase three um Treasurer Wagner are there any areas that I think I know your answer to this but are there any areas that may not look possibly feasible um based off of where we are in our financial reporting at the moment I'm not sure I clearly understand your question but um what I can say is we have $625 million and we have a lot of decisions on how we spend that money that's what I figured your response is going to be do you

123would it be helpful for me to go through each of those in terms of in my mind where I see it falling if do you all want that at the later times I know we are kind of considering I can do it really quickly the corridor model um was no cost centralized enrollment is repurposing staff there was there's a cost to everything I understand but in terms of additional cost nothing the redesign of our schools there will be some furniture moves some uh toilet moves um overtime a reduction in transportation cost as we move along um exploring recentralizing Financial operations is something the treasur and Wagner and I are talking about right now uh the junior high schools I think Jen gave you the cost out um in terms of Staffing based on what we

124know right now the monory lab school will be a cost in terms of startup but um there is a possible funding source that I'm looking into to help us with that uh additional expense the crossing guards $1 million the wp we do have a couple of Grants pending for some very exciting um work that we want to do there the DSs rest structure is looking at how we're doing business now and making that more efficient not asking for an additional cost hopefully looking for a reduced cost this Spanish is new to your eyes um as you visit our schools we have a need to address our not only our um multilanguage Learners in particular Spanish but even our um English children so that they can begin to even have conversations and um create friendships and

125um work with their their classmates it's an Ever growing population and so looking at that um moving forward the public service Academy we uh will do that through our Perkins dollars that we already have the junior rlt expansion in the Coast Guard there may be absolutely no cost to the district I will tell you that the Army Junior rltc that we have at aen cost the district $50,000 and that not only includes the instructor instructor all of the uniforms the children have to wear and the equipment uh that we use there will be a cost to redo the automotive to create an automotive Lab at Woodward to create a cosmetology Lab at Woodward entrepreneurship is the cost of a teacher some uh books materials curricular supplies the college Innovation pathway we're working with a couple

126of colleg local colleges and universities to expand on what we already have I do not see with phase two a lot of expense what remember Craig I was I was gonna say two things one is I appreciate you bringing the priorities as you see them to us um because I think that's helpful and I think we owe it to you to give you kind of what our priorities are as well um I think two things on there at least on the priorities that youve given us that I would want to make sure that we're thinking about from both this year and longer years the monory lab is one that for me the the potential of the cost Savings of having to train and educate our monory teachers May outweigh the cost of bringing it in

127and I think that's a serving thing for us to talk about because that gets into one of the things that we're known for being Innovative about um but I want to make sure that we kind of solidify that also in that conversation because if it doesn't end up being very longterm or something that can BR Revenue in it may dictate how we look at it and how we utilize it going forward um the other one is one it really still just a bothersome thing for me which is our crossing guards and in part it's a bothersome thing for me because I think it just more exemplifies why we are having cost to get added to our budget that have nothing to do with what happens inside the school and it is not fair to us

128and it's not fair to call the city our partner if they're not even willing to train or do anything for these crossing guards that are supposed to be providing safety on the streets for our students to get in and out and I will keep raising it as an issue because I think it is very frustrating that we added a million dollars to our budget to cover something that quite honestly the safety of the streets is the city's responsibility it's just like clearing the the snow off the ground is the city's responsibility and I think that's more exemplifies why to treasure Wagner's point we have to think about our budget because we keep having to do those types of things we're going to only squeeze out central office staff if we're having to add everything else

129in if we're having to do everything else first and central office kind of comes in at the last end of it we're going to end up doing more and more and more stuff with fewer and fewer people to support that work that's being done um the third thing I want to say is I do love the idea of bringing um some centralization to the financials and I know we've talked about this a lot in both budget and finance but also in the audit committee about how that can also get us to being more efficient with how we deal with some of the building financials and the way things are paid for looked at and how dollars were spent U that was a large part of the reason we did the review of all the contracts

130to see who was doing what right and how many buildings had their own separate agreements and that type of things but I think getting that more consistent will also allow us there's a couple policies that we're talking about with regards to age student fees and stuff like that that will'll get more consistency on how that stuff is done if we have a little bit more centralized unit to that and I think that will also maybe save us a few dollars in some ways to how we operate those things so I appreciate you bringing these priorities to us thank you okay super um yeah I think next slide it's your discussion this is just a question that that is just a question for the board uh mam president to think about not tonight but uh also

131to think about how we want to engage the community in the budget uh process uh the earlier part of it but also kind of assessing some of our priorities so I know that the administration spent a tremendous amount of time last budget in multiple presentations to groups and maybe we ought to look at how they did it then see if we can do more plenary kind of things but that's something for the board to figure out as to how to best engage so if you can put that on our priority list to talk about down the road I think that would be important um I I would also encourage as we get ready for these last slides uh one we have to have up there big and proud of the uh the slide that the

132cow the sacred cow yeah keep going keep going there you go keep going there you are uh so yeah if we're going I'm sorry to interrupt you but if we're going to go back to zerob based budgeting and we have to go back to a b a balanced budget there's some things that we're gonna have to stop doing that's right so once we go through the list of the stop doings what is it that we're not allowed to stop doing from the board's perspective and and the the reverse not the reverse side but another way of saying that is just as we mentioned before we were talking about negotiations or whatever uh as we look at the budget what are our specific priorities as individual board members so that we can all talk and see

133if there are there's consensus about uh board priorities uh as well as the superintendants priorities and I would just appreciate that we got through as much as we did today I think it's great all of this is an not an introduction but a reminder and much there's some other stuff that is on board docs particularly about student based budgeting and zero based budgeting and whatever if we can take the time on your own time to to look at that I think would be helpful and it'll be up to the the board to also keep in mind the history of what we're doing for example on the on board dos you'll find two slides and and one of them is dated October 14 2023 and it's a list of nine initiatives from the previous uh superintendent

134and previous board and board staff was good enough to reproduce it this at least the graphic and what we've done is just updated as we understand it on February 1st 2025 that's what these particular initiative from 23 have evolved into so there's plenty of information on the board docks for people to look and study because we Administration is deep in the throws of budget already but uh the board involvement uh is uh you know kind of kicking off do board members have any questions I think um just was that the last slide you all have was yes okay Save The Best For Last so I think that board members have a lot to do we will continue to add budget discussions on our agenda for the upcoming board meetings but I do think there is

135validity in US understanding where we stand and where we want to go so that we can explain that to the community with Fidelity additionally I think when we talk about maybe going back to re redoing the budget maybe we need to also do some inter internal work ourselves on what our PRI ities are aside from that just kind of reimagine education so invite you to do that as well does anyone have any other questions superintendent did with regard to community engagement um my only view around Community engagement that was where I was going going to speak and I want to be very brief um I think that we need to engage the community around our changes phase two I've said that a billion times you already know that probably say that from memory but I

136think in those discussions we don't need to necessarily add any additional engagement sessions but maybe we could add topics to talk about the budget and where we are in addition to what the changes are so I think is the more we understand that as board members uh the more we can join you in uh engaging the community around with Fidelity around what's coming in their Corridor what schools are needing to be changed what that looks like and then the budget the budgetary impacts of that as well so if there's no other questions or comments I think we're done um our next meeting is February the 10th oh it's right do we have any assignments apparently yes yes we do board member Weinberg um before I go into my assment I just wanted to kind of

137piggyback off of what you said regarding phase two I think it's very important as we include the community so my three things will be Clarity um making sure that we're just being transparent and then we're providing the updates on all of the changes and so as I talk about the assignment I would like to request getting updates and data regarding the CPS growth plan phase one accomplishment sheet that includes um cost per bullet point capacity service numbers and any successor challenges do you want to enrollment to that too say again did you want I thought you wanted to add enrollment to that yeah that would be the service numbers but we can call that enrollment yes enrollment as well and any additional want me to say it again no I'm that oh yes sorry that

138was anyone else I thought one remember Craig was that it hearing none I will gladly entertain oh it had to do with the super superintendent evaluation of those putting of subsets in the uh standard superintendent standards what were yours mine is mine is uh uh detailing uh numbers I think one two three five of the Statewide superintendent standards uh as to what we should be concentrating on within those more General topics any others I'm supposed to send the growth two cost plans out too yes is that it I will now a good day gladly entertain a motion for adjournment so moved second have a wonderful weekend thanks to the staff

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.