001e e e good afternoon the board is an executive session and will return shortly they apologize for any delay and they will be back soon thank you will entertain us we can we can serate you are CPS e e e of voting members I'm sorry Rob are you ready seeing a quum of voting members I call the January 27th Cincinnati school board meeting to order Jen can we do a roll call vote Mr Craig here Mr crosson here Mr Lindy here miss map here Mrs Weinberg here vice president Bolton president president M here I see superintendent Murphy Oh wait hold on I guess this okay superintendent Murphy please call please introduce our wonderful students from The Academy of world languages that will be virtually leading Us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening we going
002do the pl of [Applause] the to the flag of the United of America and to the Republic for IT stand one nation under God indivisible with liberty and J pleas to tell us what school superintendent Murphy who was where was that lovely performance from good I'm sorry I took your thunder I took your thunder where were those students from is your mic on yeah those students were from The Academy of world languages where Jackie rower is the principal thank you tell thank you treasur Wagner I think I'm might little out of order do we need to call roll again we called roll we now we need a motion to approve the agenda okay is there a motion to approve the agenda moved a second second second the vote Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr
003Lindy yes Miss map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president mofin yes president president Bolton would you explain the virtual the hearing of the public I feel so bad so sorry everybody voice thank you very much yes uh members of the public who are online and wish to speak during our hearing of the public this evening may do so by clicking the chat button now the chat feature will be open for your requests for five minutes if you would like a direct response to your questions please make sure to share your name your affiliation the district and uh affiliation to the district your school Community your topic and your contact information get on the second page so I will begin over business by talking about our health and safety committee we talked board
004members we talked at a meeting around the elimination of the health and safety Committee in front of you you should have the work plan for what the health and safety Committee involved and we talked about elimination of that committee and including that those work plan items in with the student achievement Committee of the whole so let's just have a little bit of discussion around that we didn't make a decision I'm open for any thoughts does everyone have their health and safety committee work plan looks like this what are your thoughts uh mam president reflecting on the discussion that we did have and I it was a big deal about eliminating that policy I mean that committee uh I think there were a couple of things uh that were said one is uh periodically have an
005ad hoc committee that might have uh an opportunity to talk about particular items that were in the jurisdiction of health and safety and I think another option that was discussed was to have uh perhaps extend our committee of the whole meetings from 90 by an extra 30 minutes and try to incorporate more regularly uh the issues in health and safety uh into those efforts that are really f focused on uh not only academic achievement but also whole child and uh best interest of our our students so of those two I I kind of like the personally I like the extending uh the committee of the whole largely because I think all of these topics maybe now more than ever uh seem to be particularly relevant for M Weinberg yes I would just like to add
006as well I think every single topic that we have here um listed for health and safety they are all big topics key topics and I think it would be wise to definitely keep them into consideration especially if we're going to extend out our meeting um the cow meeting um since we brought up the discussion of ending the committee I still think that those topics should definitely go over onto that side so I would be in agreeance with uh vice president Bolton any other War member discussion just for the public I'm going to give you a list of some of the topics that are on health and safety so that you'll have an idea of what we're talking about so for February's discussion this is around Mental Health Resource coordination school resource officers student code of
007conduct discipline and bullying data April the Hamilton County addiction response committee mental health physical health and nutrition June student code of conduct again pedestrian safety mental health and gun safety August Health vision and dental um safety Athletics extracurriculars and menstrual Health October Community Learning Centers sexual abuse discrimination and harassment in December um student discipline data again pedestrian safety and in school safety lockdown information so what I'm hearing is that there is agreement to extend the student achievement Committee of the whole which meets once a month by 30 minutes to incorporate the monthly or the quarterly topic for health and safety M Mr Lindy thank you um pres mfet my my for my part I would be fine um sunsetting the committee and then leaving open whether content warranted extending a given Cow by 30 minutes
008my reasoning is that and I to Shar this at our organizational meeting the um committee came from an old strategic plan where one where there was a match between committees and parts of the Strategic plan and this was a part of this strategic plan that's no longer in effect so it's like a carryover um that has assumed you know new functions but has has outlived the original Genesis um and I think that you know were there I'm I'm all for us spending less time in meetings particularly for our staff and so I think that if if if we need the time we would do it but I would I would caution against creating a default expectation that we're always going to have 30 minutes uh on additional topics any other conversation around that discussion remember
009correct um so I think I think extending as necessary I think is valid to to remember Lindy's point of that there may be time where just while we may have had it scheduled under the old health and safety plan it may not necessarily be something we wouldd have an update on at this point I think this may be a topic though for me in a lot of ways it may just require us to have someone for our Cal meetings really dedicated to looking at and working with the superintendent to kind of decide what those agenda might look like um because I do think part of the difference is how you treated as a separate committee where you would say we have to have something for each meeting or else we don't have a point of
010meeting is very different from whether it's a necessity to talk about at that time and because we're already putting so much into our Cal meetings and we're already overusing the space within our Cal meetings for other things it may become necessary to have someone just kind of coordinate with the superintendent an agenda I think this was originally the point of that merging those and having uh board member at the time board member Jones were to do that um this may be more more PR that we do that given that we're going to try and add new topics into the Cal meeting so I mean I just I think that's makes more sense so I'm fine with us doing it that way I think it just makes more sense to have someone at least trying to
011coordinate or or come up with what that looks like for meetings because I do think there would be times where we just may not need to talk about the same things on the same schedule as it always was done in in health and safety and again I think that and sometimes we may need to talk about more of it any other discussion and I will remind you these meetings had gotten decreased quarterly so it wouldn't be a monthly topic for health and sa to have a health and safety topic and I completely agree that there may not necessarily need to be discussion around some of these topics and they could easily be incorporated so does this need to go to policy committee to adjust the bylaws I wouldn't think that it has to since the
012board decided to eliminate the committee in our organizational meeting I don't think it has to go back to policy I think maybe policy has to rewrite some parts of the bylaws uh to uh facilitate the increase for the committee the whole and the elimination of health and safety but not for any major deliberation but maybe a rewrite okay so I know policy is meeting next week can we give this to the polic Friday excuse me policy is meeting on Friday so can we give this to you all to maybe adjust the bylaws as needed yes okay great great so we're going to move down to under old business superintendent evaluation policy and I'm going to adjust that a little bit because from our understanding I thought that we needed to still work on the policy
013policy we don't need to work on it but we do need to discuss the goals of the superintendent so we're going to modify that just a little bit you do have the policy in front of you board members but we're going to look at the goals of the superintendent that have been submitted by superintendent Murphy superintendent Murphy do you mind expanding just a little bit publicly around what you've submitted for your goals and your evaluation yes ma'am uh I think what I submitted with respect to my goals are really uh pieces done in two parts the first part are five critical goals taken from our current strategic plan our current goals and guard rails all of them have to do with academic outcomes uh for our students starting with third grade reading looking at Algebra
0141 looking at our students who are earning college credit plus considering our students who are earning Workforce credentials and improving our graduation rate the second aspect of that has to do with the standards for all superintendents across Ohio and there are five broad categories there for your consideration and they include Vision continuous Improvement and having a focus on the district's work a second is communication and collaboration third is policies and governance and making sure that I am following following those policies and that governance that is set by the board instruction I believe we're hitting that in the goals and guard rails in our strategic plan and then the fifth and final one is resources thank you board members do you have any questions or comments where board member Craig um so let me start by
015saying I appreciate you bringing this to us and um and trying to to get this done in accordance to the direction that we kind of agreed to as part of uh it's part of the work we're doing to to uh with you to to evaluate and assess your um work in the district I think the two thoughts that I have is just one um and I think it's something we it's not a mystery is the first one of the goals that were set just for us to define something that would be what we would say is your measurable growth towards that longer term goal um for the first year um and and I say that in also recognizing that there's some things that you maybe have had a little bit more influence on and other
016things has been a little bit different and so I think that's for you to kind of maybe give us if that's if there's a certain number that you think there's a each year if you think there's one year that'll be you know first year might be more growth or less growth whatever the case may be I think that's the only thing I would add um to that and then I also want to uh appreciate the fact that you went went to a somewhat similar or consistent method that the board has used to evaluate the superintendent over the last couple years and allows us to be more consistent in how we do the performance I think one of the things we took pride in is adding in performance and student outcomes into the process it's one
017of the things that we were advised on by the Council of great City Schools is one of the things we worked really hard on to determine what those things look like and it's a good way to measure the true success of the district is how our students do so I think I appreciate you for taking that time to add those in and use a somewhat more consist method to what we were already doing with our process any other War member Bo member Weinberg yes I'll be quick um thank you superintendent for providing these the only thing that I would maybe suggest is for goal one I notice that you have June of 2027 and then all the others are 2025 maybe if there's a possibility of giving us a percentage for that and maybe seeing
018if that could fit in so that it matches the rest of the others thank you vice president B I appreciate the uh use uh and the selection of the uh state standards for superintendents because there's also comparative work done throughout the state uh if you use those standards to kind of measure where we are versus where other superintendant might be or how people in different districts uh um uh prioritize those standards so I think that's useful for for us as well so I appreciate you adding that and also as U member Craig said keeping some degree of U standardization over time any other board member questions concerns or need for clarification board member Lindy thanks um president mfet I have a couple um and um if possible would love just a minute or two to
019look a few things up also um I really appreciate receiving these and I want to give this little thought so I'm happy to share a couple questions now I'm happy to let somebody else go I could just use a few minutes to look up a couple what I'm trying to do is see um how we did this past year on some of these things because some of the numbers tracked what I remember but some I wanted to double check so is it better for me to go now and part or better to have somebody else go and I can come back well perhaps start and then start ask a question great um so I think that this I I I think this really matters and I'm so happy to see these and I think this
020is a great step in a good direction um I think that the most important job we have is making sure that good student learning is happening uh and that we are creating more opportunities for kids in the long run because of what they learn at school in CBS I I think the best lever we have to do that as a school board is who we hire as superintendent and how we hold that person accountable so I think this is a great use of time um and I'm delighted that we have five goals when I joined the board um there was a page that had I believe more than 25 different goals on it um some of which were themselves Composites of multiple submeasures um and I've never met a human who can focus on 37
021or 38 different things at once um so I think this is great that there only five on it and it's great that we're talking about it I think it's great that they're tied to the goals and guard rails um I think the um the areas where I have some questions are um uh in two or three categories I think the first one is about scoring one of the things that is different about the evaluation policy that we passed at the very end of 24 that makes it different from past versions is that it requires the superintendent and the board to collaborate on what the scoring system should be for the evaluation so just to make this concrete let's say that the superintendent um hits 60% 61% on goal one hits the target on the second
022goal and the third goal but misses the Target on the next to is that a great evaluation is that a terrible evaluation is that somewhere in the middle um I think the idea with with the new evaluation policy is to decide in advance how we're going to score the results when they come back so that there are no surprises for the superintendent for the board for the public and we're all really clear on what good meaningful progress will be and so I I would like us to have something that we passed tonight that specifies um say that the superintendent gets 80% of the way they are on these goals that's a satisfactory evaluation the superintendent gets less than 80% of the way they are it is an unsatisfactory evaluation like I think that should and
023if if if if that sounds like that's not ambitious enough let's ratchet it up to 90 if that sounds like that's too ambitious let's ratchet it down but I think that we we owe it I think to the superintendent to provide Clarity for her on what our expectations are and I think we owe it to the public to provide transparency to them on what our expectations are going to be too and so I'm I'm what I feel quite strongly about is that we we do this and we do it in public and we do it before we get underway what I don't feel strongly about is how we set that scoring system I think there are a lot of good ways to do it and I'm I'm genuinely open to lots of different ideas um
024but I think we need to do that part of the system and I don't um I don't hold this against the superintendent this is brand new we have never done this before um but it is important uh and so I'd like that to be a part of the conversation um the other thing I'll mention too is that um part of the evaluation policy that we passed says and I'll read this um I'm in part two uh goals will include a focus on improving opportunities for African-American students latinx students students of color and low-income students um and so I think the goals that oh nope just kidding goals four so this is just another way of saying superintendent did a nice job because goals the goals that are on here the third and the fourth one
025clearly do what I was referencing um so that's great uh I need to do a little research but that that's the scoring system I think is my big one okay so um one you know give me a qu was there a question in there for you said that you wanted to find out some measurement goals you were looking up some historical data did you want to ask the superintendent no I think um on on the on the public voting of the scoring system I I don't need the recommendation to be mine you know I think it could come from the superintendent and we could start with that I mean that we we we wrote this on purpose to encourage collaboration um there may be another board member who has an idea but but as when
026we approve this I think we should we need to approve how we're going to score it at the end of the year well I think that we start by somebody just throwing something out superintendent Murphy do you happen to have since it is around your evaluation and this is brand new something that we have not done before do you happen to have a baseline of where you would like us to measure you may I ask how the 80% say that's the number plays out or if it's even being considered around the goals goals and guard rail strategic plan and the superintendent standards from the state or no you can definitely ask that question I'm looking to other board members for but yes remember correct I can say what was done before was that we had
027certain markers and so if you hit those markers from the uh student student achievement numbers whatever were part of the first the part that was for the state evaluation was just a like one through five like scale so you know at that point it's not really like a you know you just get a score on that scale um we then did some kind of percentages to reach but at the the end goal was satisfactory unsatisfactory rating I don't know if that's what we want to do again or if we want to give some type of pure score is maybe more to board member Lindy's question as to what the end thing looks like if we're measuring success of the uh in the role of superintendent but that was what we historically did is we took
028these different parts gave a percentage that was dedicated to that the uh scores that came from the uh State Standards gave a percentage to that is to reach the final score that would determine your uh at that time it was it was I think it was successful or unsuccessful were the two um things we two options we had that's helpful to that I would say and I referen a couple of things one how our principles are evaluated partially on uh state test scores but also on performance the same would be true with central office directors managers Etc there is a goal portion where they write three goals of course that's pertinent and specific to the work that they do may or may not be instructionally related but then there is a competency part that I
029align to uh these standards and so I don't know if there's any consideration for 50% and 50% because while I appreciate the comment about focusing on these five the job is really much much much bigger than that so it's not possible for me to just concentrate on these five my example of that which I've shared before is transportation is not a goal an instructional goal however if we don't get the children to school then we can't get them in the classroom so that would be my most immediate feedback for member Matt yes thank you so I'll be uh brief thank you for providing us um with the presentation of your goals for um the evaluation process I am um appreciative of the balance we talked about working collaboratively so you're you've identified a way right
030for it to um have those measurables as well as have kind of um an evaluation based off the state standard so I appreciate that and I hope that you feel confident about this as well my question is as it pertains to um the indicators or the benchmarks um relative to the goal that you've established can you explain to us how you identified where those um I guess final benchmarks would be um to help us with the evaluation process like what was the rationale around that and then also is it in any way comparable to what you've noticed in terms of other districts um for their performance measures I've not compared this to any other District at all uh where I got this from is what the board has already approved and set to be the
031measure in this given period of time so these are not X toy values that I created myself uh I pulled them based on what the guidance was from the school board okay and so so I just wanted to make sure because I know that we discuss with the interim goals right these would be considered your interim goals correct or you've establish a completely I'm just trying to make sure I have clear so with the goals and guard rails if you look at the Strategic plan kind of like uh the goal one with third grade reading some of those go out through June 2027 you'll see some for example uh Wednesday we did a presentation um on attendance well I didn't include that here but on the goals and guard rails with the Strategic plan that's
032scheduled to end May 2025 so I just pull these from the Strategic plan the goals and guard roads as written I didn't create these so to speak I just selected okay okay thank you that's really helpful um so what I'm hearing you say this is an opportunity to maintain some consistency in terms of the measurable goals that we've already established as a district absolutely okay um and then just lastly could you provide some um Clarity I think you may have explained it before um but just discussing the graduation rate with an increase of 85% and maybe where we are right now and if that's something that could possibly be included in the goal so that we are aware of yes okay definitely I do have that I will edit this so that it's spelled out
033what the X to Y is okay thank you board member lendy thank you for the time to go look a couple of things up um and um I promise we'll come back to I'll share that in just a second but I was trying to think of a really simple way to make sure that we're announcing in advance and by public vote how we're going to score the results when they come back there are very complicated ways that we could do this I think I'm guilty of trying to make this very complicated trying to make it simple but making it complicated in the past here's what I'm wondering and again the thing I want to Advocate as strongly as I can for is that we make something clear in public here is a place to start
034I'm very willing to think about different offers but the superintendent's evaluation for school year 2425 um will be a satisfactory one if two things are true um the first is that when we look at all these measurable goals on average the superintendent gets 80% of the way there these are beautifully written because they have a from and a to so you can imagine that as a distance on line get 80% of the way there you can imagine doing that across all of them on average 80% of the way there so superintendent evaluation is satisfactory if two things are true first 80% of the way they're on the goals and then second if we do for the superintendent standards what we've done in the past what this looks like is every every board member taking a
035survey where for each of the different competencies this is what Mr Craig was referencing I think board members are giving a rating from like a one low to five high we could say that the second thing has to be true is that on average the superintendent has to average blank I don't know what the number is you you all tell me but but we're saying it's a satisfactory year if you get 8 % of the way there on the five goals and the average on the competencies across all the board members is some number between you know it's got to be between one and five um but that would keep it really simple it would be really clear um there would be no surprises uh and then whatever the evaluation is it's based on what
036the results are um and I think that's that models I think good leadership and accountability uh across the board but again I'm open to feedback well M cross it yeah I I think that's a fairly good proposal and fairly simple enough I um I think we do have in our policy that 60% of the um evaluation would be on whether or not the average of 80% would count for 60% and then we we have to have some check-ins this spring for that 10% I think it's important to understand that that 10% is not based on on the results it's based on whether we're checking in to see how how it's going and then that would leave 30% for um the state standards and I think to do a simple uh one through five evaluation I'm
037assuming five would be good and one would be bad and you know maybe maybe the average score of that needs to be around 3.5 or something uh and it's the first year this is our first year in attempt at that uh we've got uh two more years of contract after that we're basing the um uh academic outcome goals on a you know where possible we're going to look at a three-year average so it it really doesn't have to be perfect this first year I think the idea that we have something and we start with it and it's a it's a um starting point and then we we can always change the scoring for future years based on how well we think this does in terms of giving a true uh representation and performance so I'm
038I would be okay with with something fairly simple like that that not only could we uh you know I think one thing about performance evaluations if if they're too complicated and the superintendent can't really think about them when she's driving in her car then it's too complicated so the simpler the better for what that's for vice president B yes thank you I appreciate this discussion and fairness to the public that's sitting through this um the superintendent has shared her proposed goals and I think we have to figure out if we are accepting those goals I have a question are we not going to accept them until we figured out the scoring is that is that the member Lindy's position so the the policy says we have to vote on the scoring the same time that
039we vote on the goals okay so it's that policy that I think was going to go back to policy but okay I think that's different from my understanding of the meeting I understand my issue is I'm having lived through the last evaluation almost anybody could have gotten a satisfactory score because of the math and I don't want to right now on the um on the Fly buy into any mathematical equation because the reality is we because of so many other things came up we were unable to do what this in executive session tonight which is where this kind of work needs to be happening um but uh I I have great reservations about I'm not confident yet about who's doing which math for what because we live through the last time and math can can
040really undo a great evaluation ation or prevent a good evaluation uh so I'm just conf I'm just concerned about that so I'm going to just offer my my reflection around what you shared um I I'm a little uncomfortable with regard to the 80% um as a numerical value similar to what you've shared but I also I think I'm getting a little VI because previously we had the superintendent do a self- evaluation in our previous evaluations and then that I don't want to say it impacted but it could influence some of how we're defining the success of the goals so I don't see that part in here under the selfassessment piece that we have had previously also believe that it's I think it's a little tough to go between quantitative and qualitative and it feels like
041the estate standards are more satisfactory unsatisfactory you know more just hey this is what it is with no numerical assessment versus the goals that have that so I guess I'm looking at are you saying 80% of each goal or are you suggesting 80% of all the goals in totality so all five goals need to be averaged to 80% completion or if there is one two three goals that are at 78% that's deemed as failure so I'm going to just summarize I'm I have I'm having some problems with the the 80% um as a number as a baseline number I'm also having some difficulty on how are we saying all of these goals numerically in totality or are we saying individual and then how are we evaluating something that is numerical in this side with regard
042to the goals and the completion there and the simple satisfactory unsatisfactory with regard to the state standards I think we need to be a little bit more consistent so I also think that there should be space for and I think that I looked here there's a little bit of space for board member evaluation but I don't see under the policy it says should the board choose to include other components in the annual evaluation which is inclusive of board member um surveys and surveys completed by other stakeholders I don't see a weight there so that sounds to to me like there should be some quantitative measurement in the evaluation that has weight and significance to the superintendent evaluation yet it doesn't reflect in the evaluation p uh percentages so I I'm a little conflicted because I
043I see some inconsistencies with regard to part two of the content that we're using to measure um that I think needs to be ironed out a little bit more succinctly um myself so I also am concerned that we're talking about accepting the goals at the same time as evaluating when we were supposed to have completed this part um by January 31st so are we offering an exception for this particular year in part because this has been a very different year I think that I would like to see weight given for closing a $90 million gap he more heavily than I would see getting to completion of all these goals um they're very important but I think that maybe for this first year there are some things that are not Incorporated that are unusual circumstances to
044the superintendent's point of being able to impact things that impact education and getting to the goals um successfully we're not incorporating those things and I I hate to just see it be a past fail simply when it's really so much more to improve improving the student outcomes so that's just where I'll leave that a little bit there yes sir or mem no I I actually think I agree with almost everything you said uh I I think the um I'm going to go in reverse order just the piece about um the budget Gap um we wrote this on purpose to be flexible enough for future iterations of the board to align it to what matters most to the district so if the board and they supposed to be collaborative so like ideally the superintendent would agree
045but like if we if we can agree that one of the things that matters most in this year and I think this makes a lot of sense uh is around uh navigating a budget process Clos like great let's put it on there you know I think that that it's designed to be flexible enough to do that I think it's a great ad um it could be that could be a great thing dad um I think that uh other other things just to mention quickly um you asked about what happens if one goal is 78 another goal is 78 one goal is 81 like how do I don't I'm open really like I think I think my preference would be let's do the one that is easiest to administer and let's the superintendent put her best
046foot forward you know like but but I think um it's whatever we agree on I think the thing that's important is just that it be clear and it be clear in advance rather than when the year is over and people have different understandings of what good means um and then the last thing about the the survey you know my my experience in the last five years is that that's we make these surveys quite quantitative in the way that we have everybody take the survey what we aggregate the results we've often used them um this not with this superintend necessarily but when we're trying to decide what percent of a performance increase should someone get we'll use like what percent of perfect score that they get on the survey and map that directly onto what percent
047of the possible increase do they get you know so I I think I'm I'm less worried about that part just because I think we've got some good muscle built around how to do that in a thoughtful way um but I think I you know I those are the other thoughts that I have I'll just we don't we can talk about this or not talk about this but but the other thing I've not brought up is just whether these are the right targets or not and I want to just mention that briefly because the the 61% thirdd grade reading um our score last year was 57% and so to get from 57 to 61 in three years feels like a goal that's not high enough like I would want to raise that um similarly on Algebra
0481 our result last year was 38% and this is aiming to improve that by 40% that's that's a little over a point and a half I think we should be setting a higher bar than that for this year um and so I think there there are um mold and and and to your point uh president Moffet um I think there are real tradeoffs in extending this goal setting process and I think it might be worth it um because it it's I think it's the trade-off is just you know we're halfway through we're more than halfway through the school year and the longer we take to get it the harder we make it on the superintendent you know and so uh I'm open but I just see pros and cons thank you any other board M
049Craig um so I think I have three thoughts real quick and I I'll do them real quick because I think we've been on this topic for a very long time and I I think we probably need to move on to a lot of the folks who' have come here to talk to speak but um one is I think we could do something simplistic as in each of the goals we would do the same type of evaluation as to whether or not we think they've met it or not very simplistic you know superintendent gets to present whether or not she believes she's met those achievement those student outcome goals to us and for at least this first year it's kind of that 60% is just did she meet yes or no like do you feel she's
050met these things I whether or not that those are the right numbers and nothing think I think we can probably still save off till the next board meeting to to fully dive that part in I don't need he need to have as complicated of a system on this first year given also that we um are really evaluating a different thing than we'd be evaluating in a normal year because we didn't give her her goals we didn't go over these goals in October we didn't really set these presidents in October as we expected to do in the normal courts of order right um so from that part I think we can still stick with the same formula that's in the policy at a next a next board meeting and and give a more base level version
051of doing the evaluation um where I would also say is is True to this is that whatever we decide to do in this and whatever we work with you to put together as a plan for this at the end of the day student achievement has to be a part of it it has to be why we're here and I think that's part of why the superintendent relied upon the things we had already set as goals so and I and I recognize been to your point or Lindy to your point maybe we've progressed past what we thought we would be able to do when we initially set these goals um but I don't necessarily want to hold her to a new set of goals just because of that um and I think that but that to
052me means that needs to maybe be fleshed out in our conversation at at a next at the next board meeting so that we really find out what those things mean because I do think we need to hold a high standard I just don't know if holding the high standard mid year has the same bringing effect as holding a high standard from the beginning of the year um my last thought to all of this is to say part of this is really about what do we set as expectations for where our students and how the district operates and to your point you know something like Transportation may be a thing that we sit down and look at those state standards and say have you managed Transportation well have you communicated with our partners well to your
053point uh president Mofford about uh handling the budget that might be something we look at in those state standards and say this is an example of how you've lived up to the expectations of the state or exceeded the expectations of what the state standard would be on how to deal with something like the budget or working with Partners on the budget I am very much opposed to kind of putting individualized things like that though as a marker because each year we'll have something that we would say is a marker that we want to give extra credit for and let's just do it through our normal process in the same way we would say to a student who performed and did a excellent job and managed to grab that actual B information we we unless we
054give it UPF front so that everybody can achieve it so we know what that is we're always going to find ways and reasons to give extra credit and I think if the superintendent is doing a great job and things are working in the district r guess what everybody's going to give her extra credit for it we don't need to necessar but what we evaluate is different so I would love to make sure that we just keep a standard so that it's very clear to superintendent upfront what she's doing that it's a standard that is based upon the goals that we is set which I appreciate taking the time to do and that if we then need to go beyond that for future years that we start to do that as a thing that we begin
055that conversation earlier because again we're we're doing the same thing that we raise concerns about when we brought in the previous superintendent which is that we didn't really create a measurable way to determine her growth until we were Midway into a school year and that meant that it was hard for us to sit down and say this is what your your plan is so appreciate again for you bringing the effort to us and I think if we can do it at the next board meeting to to kind of finalize it I think that's a fair place to do it as well any other board discussion around this I'm not advocating or pushing I just want to be clear on what what what's being decided tonight and what's next all right so we've had the discussion
056I do agree that um we need to do this sooner than later however to board member Craig's point we could finish this discussion at the next board meeting which actually is our work session if you'd like to discuss it on Saturday you can carve out a little bit of time then but I do think that we need to are we going to accept the goal goals that the superintendent has suggested for us that's the first step to me are you offered that maybe those aren't the right goals do you want her to go back and provide us with more updated goals relevant or are you fine with these goals that she submit I mean I I would vote no on the idea that our third grade reading only needs to go up four points in
057three years like I I think I think we can go faster than that I'm one person I make it out voted on that uh I do not want to create a ton of extra time and extra work I would rather get clarity on the goals tonight uh and then leave for a future what's the scoring method um but I'm just one person so let's do this is there any opposition to going through the goals so that she can leave with something definitive is there any opposition to the goals we've heard presid uh former for member Lindy talk about his opposition to goal one are you proposing another number is there any other opposition to goal one would you like to go through the goals or would you like to just have her go back president
058B the superintendent has submitted uh these goals uh and I would rather we accept them as a package or not and but not try to do anything tonight about the scoring but I do think we have to have some sort of consensus or agreement as to whether these are the goals if they aren't then we do need to send her back to the drawing board uh but so if that requires I I hate this single voting thing why I would motion that we would vote on these with the caveat that there is some concern about and then leave it at that and if somebody has concern about something that gives her guidance to go back and fix a particular thing but I think that this is a package not an individual thing so there's a
059motion well there's a motion on the floor you're submitting a motion to accept the goals as written as written uh with any uh uh concerns about any particular part of the goals being communicated to the superintendent right now is there a second for I I just wanted to add some commentary um before we um second it on the motion but um just being presented with this today I do I do want us to have some type of idea about where we are with the goals I'm okay with us tabling the scoring process but I would like to um really second and enforce wanting to see more of an exponential growth as it pertains to our student data and so that's why I posed the question around just the rationale um how do we determine this
060and maybe I don't know if there's even discussion on how like what's the expectation in terms of reaching certain benchmarks or targets um if we go back and discuss the goals because I do think that as a district unfortunately um and it's not anything I think um I I don't think this is something that you could be accountable for but I do want us to make sure that we are really enforcing and holding ourselves accountable as a district to ensure greater success for our students academically and so just looking at the data it just it's moving at a very slow pace and so that's why I also ask about the trend that you notice and if there is anything that we could do to maybe change the target of the overall uh expectation of the
061goal but I also to want to be reasonable right with what that measure could be so I think that's part of what I'm saying is that to accept the package of these items maybe that's the better way to say it because once you say Goals then the scoring kind of inherently goes part of the items she has suggested these items as goals but the scoring we should collaboratively with the superintendent work on the scoring at a little bit later date and then pass that but I I'm more than willing in that motion to accept this package as the items that she's proposing and then we can collaboratively uh work on the scoring and the goal setting which I think could be higher on some of these so is there a second for the motion to
062accept the package and make adjustments at the next meeting second okay need to vote discuss discussion Mr Crosset I I uh I appreciate what Ben is saying that maybe the goals need to be looked at but I think that that's a much bigger project that takes a lot of more time in thinking and I I I like the idea that we've got you know if we achieve our 2027 goals early or 2025 goals we exceed them good for us but then let's set some new goals for next year but I don't think I think it's this is what our targets were set a while back let's see if we can get there and then do a reboot on that for next year that would be that's why I like this motion I think that's that's
063a good way to go and it's you know we got a half a year not a full year and uh and then we can get some you know stretch those goals out in the future so can we take a vote on the motion excuse me that's on the floor Mr Craig yes Mr crosson this is the vote Yes Mr Lindy NOP M map just making sure that I'm clear we are accepting the goals but not the target measures we are accepting the package and we can adjust make adjust the items and we can make no she said that her motion you want to explain it one more time I U the word goal indicated that we were accepting the scoring necess not the scoring but the uh targets I'm saying is I'm accepting the items
064as a package and that collaboratively we will work on the scoring and possibly reset the goals the targets said that last piece one more time about the targets I'm sorry that we are accepting the items that she has pointed to which I think are good uh and that uh we do that tonight and then we at a later date collaboratively work on both the uh targets and then the scoring okay I can accept that yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes president mfin yes okay so we will look at the timeline for Saturday and maybe we can devote a little bit of time with that we got Aur over folks it seems because I do agree with member Lindy that we do need to address this sooner than later and we will have it
065for the public to be able to see these as well and superintendent Murphy perhaps you can provide us with some of what the numbers are now that board member Lindy looked up what the numbers are currently then we can have that data moving forward okay I do have one other question yes ma'am um I would like for uh board member Lindy to maybe expound on this does this change anything as it pertains to the current standing superintendent evaluation policy that we have what we just agreed upon or that's a good question I think we're in an unusual year because we have somebody starting in the middle of the year um and I do really agree with what board member Craig said earlier which is um none of we should I I believe in not letting
066the perfect be the enemy of the good and figuring out these things as quickly as we can figure them out well feels good and appropriate and a step in the right direction so I I think you know let's do it quickly you know but I think we're moving in a good direction perfect thank you and I'm going to keep advocating that we raise the bar higher and that end I do think that the evaluation policy needs a little bit of tweaking in that there is there is no quantitative measurement for the other things that come into place for the superintendent part surveys completed by other stakeholders surveys completed by board members there is no measurement there so maybe we need to look at adding that and I don't know if that was purposeful or not
067it was it was on purpose and it was it was left open so that boards could do what they want to do so if there's something that people when we do this in in the process in the fall if there's something people want to put on there there's there's room for that it was it was left open on purpose but how is that measured the board decides in in collaboration with the superintendent each year the board has a chance to figure that out together so one more question if the total is 60% for the first part 30% for state standers and 10% for the check-ins where is the measurement how would yeah I would I would think about a little bit differently so so 60% is measurable performance objectives the board decides what those measurable
068performance objectives are so every year the board could include something in there that they want to be a part of the superintendent's evaluation they just have to be clear on what how they're going to measure what success looks like there's also uh there's only it doesn't say 30% for survey it says 60% and 10% and then it leaves 30 the rest open we I can talk about this forever I'm I can tell from looks that I'm running through any Goodwill that I had left with anybody on the stage um and so I'm happy to talk about this but only if it's something people want to talk about well we definitely will come back and visit it but we have a place for you to start superintendent Murphy um right now so moving on through the
069agenda I believe next up under old business superintendent Murphy you're going to provide us an update to the Xavier monor lab I am very happy to provide a uh an update on the monor lab Lab School uh so we do have a meeting scheduled with uh the group on Friday this coming Friday afternoon in addition to that in the morning uh we are doing another visit uh Mr Burkhart uh assistant superintendent Klein and I are going to their site to see how they operate uh we also have HR director and delacio looking at their current Staffing we have shared uh their budget or at least as much of the budget as we could get with uh the treasurer just for her review and her awareness at this point things are moving forward board members do
070you have any questions concerns or need for clarification board member Craig I will try again to be quick because I know folks are still waiting to come and talk um so my two concerns and one lies around you know potential costs I actually think it's a great thing that we would be bringing something in like this but I would like to have an idea of also what potential Revenue stream looks like and and because for me if we're talking about doing it and then we're talking about a future revenue of a sizable amount that's great if we're talking about a future revenue of a couple thousand dollars cost benefit analysis might say that it may not be as worth it to us um but if it's something that we can train our own staff on
071which has a certain amount of benefit I think that would be it would be better served to kind of be able to do that comparison um the second point is still my general concern is is that we are building a lot of monasi seats in elementary schools that we do not have high school seats for and we're actually expanding the number on the side of the city that we do not have an expansion of speeds for and while I'm not here today to say we should go buy a building and and put anything tomorrow I do think we need to be cognizant of the fact that that is a valid concern and as we think about future years with things like the lottery and other things or as we're calling it now enrollment um we
072really do need to be just cognizant that some of that is not going to look and feel the exact same way if we're just constantly expanding an area which we know that there's not seats in high school for them to go to so those are my two thoughts quick thank you any other vice president B uh I appreciate the update um I am particularly thrilled that a another entity wants to perhaps join our network uh of uh of our monitory system and join CPS and that you're making the arrangements that uh that could facilitate that I I think uh member Craig is right that we um don't currently have the high school seats to accommodate the growth that we are trying to achieve in elementary but we do have a a plan that has been
073presented uh uh for a number of years which is to have a third uh high school monor high school preferably in the central quor we do have a facility available that would perhaps part of that phasee three when we're talking about an addition at Walnut as well as a Westside High School um so I'm I'm thrilled with this but the biggest thing for me on this is that I've sat here so many years and what we've uh only occasionally been able to do is get the training and the certification and licensing for our many monor teachers uh or want to be monor teachers that this opportunity having this lab school allows us inhouse literally to um get that kind of accreditation uh and for our for our professionals and uh and and also to continue
074to be seen nationally as the leader in monu Public School Monas so I'm excited but to to member Craig's point we we need to be anticipating that we're we're making seats and these kids get taller and we have to have seats a little bit later in their life for them but thank you for the update any other board member questions okay War member Craig would you provide us an update around the treasure search so um the treasur search closed as of Friday I believe it was um so if you still want to apply it's kind of a little late but you know um we have have uh applicant at the next stage for what we'll be doing is to to do our firstr interviews of the applicants um and so that's something that the board
075will take a look at um I will say we received um I can say we actually received uh results or applications from across the country um because you know again the treasur position is such a highly highly uh desired position um but what our goal is going to be is to have a selection made in a process that establishes a transition time going forward to ensure that we have enough of a uh onboarding time for whoever is selected to truly learn the work and be able to work with her current treasure as she uh makes a faithful journey to her uh Farm in Indiana to relax and have fun while the rest of us continue to keep toiling away here well learned this time I should say but um that is kind of where we
076are now as we have um our next stage in the process is do our first round of interviews do board members have any questions moving along uh our final old business topic is around the healthy neighborhoods joint meeting with the city of Cincinnati we do have that meeting coming up it will be either February 18th or February 25th any board members to check your calendars the city has given us two dates and I know I've heard from at least one board member that normally comes that they're not able to come so if you could confirm with um our board staff the either the 18th or the 25th are the dates that we need and to the public that it will be here at the board of ed we're hosting it this time and it is
077typically the health and safety committee for the healthy neighborhoods committee for the city and we will have uh city council members here in addition to board members so submit your topics and submit your calendar availability any questions all right we are moving along do board members have any acknowledgements or announcements for remember correct uh I'll throw a uh acknowledgement out there even though I was unfortunately not able to attend this weekend um but I heard that there were uh a wonderful showing from our CPS students at the uh High School ethics um competition um I High School ethics bull competition um and so one of the things that I will say is I talk to a number of folks who were judges and were moderators and stuff for the event yes over the weekend it
078was a two-day event um and several of our schools were the schools that they highlighted as the ones that they sat through and watched and were really impressed by and listening to the topics and seeing how how challenging some of these topics were for our students to be able to discuss these topics with Clarity and with a a level of understanding about the subject matter was what impressed them the most and a couple of folks felt like they didn't they weren't prepared to have the discussions themselves so it was really cool to see um so just just want to congratulate all the um the teams but also all of the teachers and staff who worked with them as coaches and I really want to highlight this because they PA made a dedication to doing that
079so those are folks who actually went outside of their normal schedule of time to get trained on how to work on these high school ethics issues and really put the time and effort in to um coach with these students and work with these students to to do a great job so very proud of the students but also very proud of their coaches because that was the other thing I heard is that all of the coaches seemed really impressed Ive and really on top of it and worked really [Applause] hard board members any other board member Weinberg yes so I wanted to give a little update the last meeting but I will share I got the opportunity to go to the Martin Luther King Coalition 50th anniversary and we had our lovely School of Hayes Porter
080Elementary they participated with some additional choir and they did a great job they were on stage and they were singing and I took a picture and I wasn't aable to give it to Mr Wilson but maybe I'll share it out next week but I just want to give them a round of applause for doing such a great job representing CPS any other board announcements or acknowledgements I will say that I had an opportunity to attend this SCPA Arts Gayla it's always a beautiful event this particular year they had students who designed costumes and they were some of the most beautiful costumes ever and so if you are looking for designers we've got some um inhouse cuz they were awesome they were awesome so thank you for the invite superintendent Murphy please present any announcements and
081retirements that you may have absolutely I there are a few retirees uh certificated Personnel Lily Cohen who is a teacher at the promise Center and then we congratulate Julie Jinx who is a teacher at Woodward Career Technical High School and then we have one non certific oh Sue Montgomery a teacher with auxiliary Services congratulations and then Civil Service employees vica Bell is a PA professional at Mount Ary school and Jacqueline Cunningham is a PA professional at Robert AA information technology high school there's one more Mr Ralph Jones the security assistant to at Robert aaft information technology high school congratulations and we do have a a couple of Kudos well one uh the president has already shared but another I want to talk to you about is uh our crossing guards I do want to give
082kudos to shaa McDow who is in our transportation department and is our crossing guard Le days on she did host a crossing guard orientation and we have more and more and more crossing guards coming on board with CCNA public schools and looking forward to even more for the upcoming school year congratulations to her for doing that and then as the president mentioned uh SCPA and their Arts Gaya thank you before I turn it over to vice president Bolton for the hearing of the public we do have one board member that had an acknowledgement or an announcement board member Matt uh yes thank you uh I just wanted to congratulate uh Tav high school for their amazing and historic uh football season and we had the opportunity um to go down to City Hall where they
083were recognized um and so I just wanted to make sure that we congratulate them not only for being athletes but student athletes with exceptional GPA with a total was it 3.1 3.1 and so uh uh president mfet was there um superintendent Murphy uh Deputy superintendent Smith and a whole host of supporters so I just wanted to acknowledge them and [Applause] congratulates one more okay sorry treasure Wagner that's okay just taking my um waiting for my turn I just wanted to celebrate um the release of the audit that you heard about tonight and congratulate the treasures department and particularly Kevin Ashley and his hard work and um being the lays on but we did get another uh clean audit um for our financial reporting um with no comments or recommendations so thank you thank [Applause] you
084madam Vice thank you all Madam vice president the chair is yours please conduct the hearing in the public thank you Madame President uh first of all rob do we have anyone online to testify tonight yes we have one online speaker and we'll need Jillian would take her to accept that invite or she will miss her opportunity please accept that invite okay as she accepts that we're going to start with the folks that are here and have been so patient and waiting uh uh Melanie whizzle if you'll come down uh and sit in these chairs that are here on the lower level and we'll call a few more names Kelly Roberts Kirsten Meadows Taylor Brown perhaps with an E uh Adelaide uh K if you all will come down and take a place and U get
085in that order and as soon as we hear from the online person then we'll start with you all Rob put her on oh I have to read this don't I see hey I got the script and I still didn't do it right we are now at the item of our agenda for hearing the public each speaker will have two minutes and we'll address all comments to the presiding officer if you're online once a request to speak has been granted you'll be invited to enter you should click on the camera icon to go to interactive provide your name your affiliation to the district your school Community your topic and your uh contact information if you'd like a response uh to of the questions you may have this request is consistent with board protocol and we appreciate
086your help in the usual uh the unusual event that someone is not willing to follow this protocol we reserve the right to end that person's time again each person will have two minutes to speak when the timer goes off your time is up please refrain from discussing any Personnel matters and after speaking if you're online you'll briefly see a welcome screen again as you transition back back to live streaming the meeting finally we ask that your public commentary be respectful of all listeners thank you very much and we look forward to hearing from all of the folks that are here tonight and our guest online thank you Julian would terer you can go ahead you have two minutes hi um thanks for letting me speak tonight I actually I had a whole document written out
087that I was going to read um regarding the current policies we have in place for our undocumented students and um we received some feedback from the district today that kind of outlines um District policy and procedures to undertake in the event that um immigration officials visit our school and so I think a lot of us were uh looking for some guidance and so my plan was to come on here and plead with you to um make that clear to us and so I just really now at this point wanted to say thank you for meeting and discussing with each other and providing some guidance to the schools and I hope that the guidelines also go out to community members and the parents in some shape or form um but that's all I have thank you
088thank you Melanie good evening good evening I am here because I am concerned about the plans to combin several schools throughout the district some of these schools have autism units and other disability classrooms I want to share my family's experience when it comes to relocating autism units in particular my son had spent the five previous school years at Riverview East Academy in an Autism unit unfortunately we are still feeling the Fallout from abruptly moving these autism units and I don't want any other families to have the same experience that we have my son did very well when he was at Riverview East and the school itself had a wonderful layout for these units they had sensory spaces restrooms actually in the classrooms and a fence playground that had pictures that the non-verbal children could use
089to communicate not all of the schools that currently have autism units have these features and the all the autism units were a community and they didn't have an opportunities to say goodbye to each other there's so much more to moving these classrooms and students than just finding available space both the staff and students need adequate time to prepare the students in these classes are there for extra support and they thrive on routine and consistency abruptly moving the autism units meant that there wasn't time to work on making these Transitions and unfortunately my son is in his third school for 2024 and they are looking at yet another placement for him this has caused his anxiety to rise and has been very stressful for the entire family as well he deserves better it's been an awful
090situation for him thank you very much for sharing Kelly Roberts good evening good evening my name is Kelly Roberts my children they go to Parker Woods monu I have a sixth grade daughter and I was just U told that I have just one choice of the monory high schools I am concerned I have anxiety I am a family of a homeless family it is very hard my son he had recently graduated from Clark monaster that was a very good school for him my daughter I'm told she has to go to gamble monory I'm told there's two uh monory high schools and I don't think there should be a choice I mean I don't think it should be just one choice I feel that we don't have a stable home we have been going through challenges
091for two years homeless this is very hard I am try my best with the two minutes but I do ask that if my daughter can please go go to Clark Monas is because I have a lot of safety concerns with gamble monu it is a lowbudget school Clark Monas is a totally different School much safer one of the staff members in Parker Woods monory um nephews just been hit by a car in gamble monory High School there's a lot of traffic accidents in that area there's a lot of safe concerns with that school one of my other children went to that school all my kids went to modur schools so I do not feel comfortable with putting my child in a school that is not a monory I would like my child to go to
092Clark monory and once again there that's what I have to say thank you very much for sharing appreciate it Kirsten Meadows and as Kirsten's so getting ready to speak if uh Rachel van uh Holly would come down and also uh Aaron M I don't think intended to sign up to speak I think they just wanted to ask their question on theer okay both of those or just Aaron just kirst just Kirsten okay great all right then we'll go to Taylor and Adelaide hi um thank you for giving people an opportunity to speak at these um we were just talking about how we want to continue to show up so that we're a little bit more a part of this so hopefully you'll see our faces a little bit more um I too am here to
093address the the topic of immigration and the possibility of immigration officers and Ice enforcement coming into our schools they're already setting a precedent across the country um and I think it's really necessary for the administration um down to have um very set policies and not have um have it be up to whoever is opening the door to these people in the individual schools and individual programs um some of the precedents that are being set are one Elementary School in Chicago ice Enforcement Officers attempted to remove children from their school and the princip um was informed by their district and was very luckily able to shut that down um another precedent being said is very different in Texas teachers actually called ice enforcement and said I have many students who don't even speak English I want
094you to raid my school um so there are two ways that we could go and I would love to be able to look at CPS and see that we are on the right side of ensuring our student safety and as a parent my child attends sailor Park element school he's in kindergarten um he loves School more than anything and I imagine how that would go if he saw one of his students one of his friends being pulled out of a classroom by armed officers um and put in a detention center and that's the reality of what this is and I know that it's easy to say that this is something political that we don't really want to tip our dip our toes in because it seems political but it's not it's the safety of our
095students as a mother when I drop my child off the obligation of their health and safety is now rest on that principal on that teacher on you know I'm going to take a minute longer because there was a lot of extra time taken before um no I don't think you can do that so we appreciate your I'll finish my sentence though because when I drop my child off his his life and safety is in the hands of those teachers and those those principles and that administration at that school and they should not be stripped away just on the whim of somebody not wanting to say no because they're fearful so I'm just asking the board to make it very clear what the rule is across across Cincinnati public school thank you so much Adelaide hello
096um I'm Adelaide Cruz I am a science teacher at Aken new Tech High School and I teach the most determined the most resilient the most good spirited and dedicated students are multilingual Learners and these students have fought through tremendous evil for the privilege to study here at Cincinnati public schools I've had students share with me that they remember playing in the backyard in the Democratic Republic of the Congo while Rebel militia bullets were flying over their heads I've had students share with me that they were separated from their family in the desert of Syria I've had students share with me that they walked all the way from Venezuela to the US border because they trusted us here in Cincinnati that we could teach them how to have a better life and so on behalf of
097the students I have homework for the board and for the administration one we need very clear policies and it's sounds like they've been shared with principles and I hope soon that they will be shared with us the teachers with the um office staff with the substitutes with the community of what happens when not if when enforcement comes to our doors Two I need us to have a plan with our school Partners when our kids come home to an empty house because their parents' job or store or even the bus stop was rated and three I need to know what is going to happen to the students who do not feel safe to come to school to learn anymore how can we serve them remotely how can we make up for those learning losses because right
098now I have 50% attendance in my classrooms and the students who are there are honestly too scared to learn thank you thank [Applause] you Rachel good evening my name is Rachel Von Holly and I am an English teacher to English Learners also known as mlls or multilangual language Learners I'm here to speak on behalf of these students families and teachers first I'd like to say how lucky Cincinnati public schools is to have such a unique diverse beautiful population of students um specifically our talking about our multilingua learners my students are the best part of my day however I have serious concerns worries and fears since the current president was inaugurated about 50% of my students have stopped attending on a daily basis families and parents are writing me saying they don't want to send their
099children to school this is my ninth year in the district teaching in the district and for the first time I feel I have no tools families are scared and I feel helpless they look to us not you for guidance they look to us not you for help and we cannot do our job if you don't do yours I am disappointed that our district has made an official state has not made an official statement on this matter there are no policies in place despite the negative and dangerous rhetoric spread about immigrants for the last two years by the current Administration we saw this coming there is no excuse for silence but we're here now and we have to face reality we are going to lose our multilanguage Learners we are going to lose their trust in
100everything they add to our community and schools we need leadership from the district and board not just the Osa office so asking for three things public support and acknowledgement board policies and training on said policies and a plan to address the uh the learning loss faced by our students who fear attending school at this time thank you thank you we have Aaron and then we'll have Sarah madal and Kendra Adamson welcome go ahead you can start cool 18 seconds it took few to get discomfortable with the feeling of me standing here in silence I'd like you to imagine the discomfort that immigrant families have felt as they endure continued Silence by CPS in regards to the dignity as students and members of this community the best time to make a statement an official position has
101long passed the second best time is now thank you Sarah hello um I'm going to start by saying that I am really disappointed I'm disappointed in this board the last time I stood in front of you I was looked at and I was told that I was seen and I don't know what being seen means to all of you but your silence doesn't feel like being seen when I talk to my students they're not feeling seen and I don't just mean seen in terms of how CPS is going to respond to the potential ice raids I mean seen like when I said that we need interpreters to be present so that our families have a voice here I mean seen like that because I said it and you guys were like oh that's a really
102great idea we do want their voices have there been interpreters at these meetings I don't think any Arrangements have been made so their voices are heard so I'm done talking for them I want to talk with them and more than that I talk with them every day I I want y'all to talk with them because we talk about them all the time and we talk around them and we talk about things that affect their lives and we never actually ask them have any of us asked them what they're feeling how many of y'all have actually asked the single immigrant how they're feeling in our schools right now and and gotten a response from any of them because what I'm telling you as I speak to them on a daily basis is they feel invisible and
103that's what our government's asking of them and that's what they're being forced to do and I was hope that CPS could be a little bit different and providing a place where they could feel seen and supported So when you say that you see me as a representation of our Latin American community and our immigrant Community I want for you to recognize what that means as it stands currently I would love for there to be action and I when President Trump says immigrants are poisoning the blood of this community Silence from the board when when he was currently in and when he said he immigrants are criminals silence he he took his time over the course of two years to misalign the Immigrant community and no one from the board ever thought to themselves let's make
104a statement of support recognizing their contributions recognizing their value recognizing the fact that we want them here because they don't feel wanted and that is from somebody who speaks to them every day thank you thank you very [Applause] much Kendra hi my name is Kendra Adamson and I also teach at Aken new Tech High School school I have the P privilege of teaching 7th 8th and 9th grade English language Learners in my language arts classroom uh and working with English language Learners at CPS is my dream job I love it I love my students I love their families and I'm here today to voice my concern because those kids that I love our kids their families and their communities they are struggling this past week with a rise in harmful anti-immigrant policies and rhetoric from
105president Trump as well as frightening headlines about ice raids and the potential of those raids happening at schools churches and hospitals I have seen a sharp decline in the attendance from my students who are usually so eager to learn in multiple classes I am missing half of my students many of whom who have said specifically that they're scared to come to school because of the potential of those raids our current our students are currently living in fear that they will be deported undocumented students or students with undocumented loved ones yes but now our students who are here with proper documentation or the path to having proper documentation are worried that a sudden change in laws that are possible with this change in leadership they might lose their home they might be separated from the people
106that they love the Silence from the school board and the lack of an official statement from CPS addressing the pain and that fear that our immigrant students face right now tells them very clearly that they are alone cps's motto this year is here for kids so my question to the board is here for which kids what guidance and communication is the board providing to its teachers to let them know how to support our immigrant students right now what leadership are you demonstrating to make it undeniably clear that immigrant students are wanted here are welcome here are safe and valued and protected here without a clear statement of solidarity from the board for our immigrant students we Face the potential reality of losing their trust in us as educators their attendance in our school and ultimately
107their presence in our communities thank you thank you very much I believe that that concludes all those that signed up thank you all very much Madam president back to you okay um render Murphy please present your policy for discussion yes ma'am uh about our severe weather procedure so what we are showing on the next slide Rob is uh the statement that we have made publicly about what we do when we have a weather emergency and of course recently we have had a few of those either because of the snow or because of the very cold extremely cold temperatures and then we place a link uh here that takes this person directly to our website it to get more detailed information about those procedures and we just remind uh the public that there are a lot
108of things that go into making a decision a good decision the best decision about whether we are going to be open or closed due to inclement weather happening uh we did just recently convene all of the union leaders to have a conversation around what our practices mean for them because there was a little bit of um a lack of clarity in some areas that we've been dealing with over the years and so in a good faith effort to bring Clarity we were trying to do that some of the things will have to wait until we are into our negotiations because we have contractual obligations around them that we must meet and so I believe they're all willing and understanding of the need to do to do that as well so in addition to considering all
10966 67 68 properties and our ability to have them ready for our staff and our students uh there are a lot of things as listed on the statement that go into the decision board members do you have any questions or concerns member weberg yes so I have a couple of questions um I guess my first question would be is this our statement or is this our procedure so this is a statement and then procedures are when you click on it's showing like a bluish purple takes you to the procedures okay so then my second question um as a parent and I'm just going to say I just want us to just make sure that we're being very transparent and as I'm looking at this severe weather procedure yes it lists a couple of different things
110or reasons of why the school would close but is there any way possible and I can shoot this over to you in in an email that we can just have a very transparent message such as the cincai public school district will close school when the National Weather Service forecast has sustained a windchill of -20 degrees Fahrenheit or lower or there is significant snowfall impacting Road Safety or other severe weather conditions that pose a risk to students and staff well-being the superintendent will make the final decision to close school after Consulting with local authorities and will notify because I don't see anything on here where it says that parents will be notified but notify parents and staff via the district website email text messaging and or local media Outlets is there any way to kind of
111just make it something that's very simple very just to the point so that no one's wondering or we're getting several emails that parents are confused they don't understand when is school closed or when is it open so I will shoot this over to you in your Emil email and I just wanted to share it with the rest of the board as well is there a way that we can get better messaging in terms of this particular piece better messaging in terms of um making sure and writing how we're informing our parents absolutely uh because we do all of the things that you mentioned email Robo call text messaging when that is available and of course using uh media the one part that you mentioned early on in your statement I get a little cautious about
112a particular number or temperature yes and I totally understand that I just think that certain families or different situations that we've encountered one day we're closed when this is a certain degree but then it's another day and it's really really really cold and we're open and it's just it's not being consistent so if there's a way to put that into the message into that statement I'm not asking for you to just specifically say A B C or D but to give those options so that parents are understanding or when we are closed they they understand why and a lot of our parents they may not know that the majority of our students are either unhoused or they don't have they may not have heat at home or they're not able to get a you know
113a meal and so that is one of the reasons why we do have to have our schools open I just want to make sure that all parents all staff members all children everyone we on the same page and I know it's a very difficult situation and very difficult choice for you to make so thank you thank you B member Craig um so I want to say I guess three thoughts really quickly U First is that I think the message as to whether or not we're open or not um pretty straightforward I mean I got the message everyone else gets the message and the robo calls uh it is lovely to to get rubel calls when I don't have to be uh or when we still have a board meeting but that's that's neither here nor
114there kind of fun stuff but I do think bringing some more clarity to what it means when we say like it's a you know a a cold weather day or whatever that type of deal it's just for those folks who are staff I think it's just a little bit more helpful to understand whose roles command whose roles don't I think to your point there's some discussion around it with regard to their particular role whether or not they're represented and in particular which which group was represented um I do want to say second thought is just I think we noted on here but it's it's the real is that some of this is dictated by folks who are not us and the reality is if we do a terrible job of cleaning the roads in all
115of our neighborhoods that are especially our most vulnerable neighborhoods they're not going to get to school even if we open a building and especially in our high schools where a large percentage of our high school students depend upon either family Transportation or public transportation to get there and we don't have a you know we have high schools where there's very few students who can literally walk to school to their High School um and so I think that's just a reality of some of the things we were dealing with I know some of the complaints that came in about like you know side sidewalks and other stuff not being cleared in areas where they were catching a bus that's not us and so I think to a certain point I appreciate that we limit our message
116to what we control and what we do I.E if there's some issue at a particular school and that we faced other issues with regards to equipment or or particular thing you know things with any school that might have been a problem the third thought I had on all of this though is the reality is that unfortunately weather patterns are becoming more and more unpredictable and that has a large reason why something like our facilities master plan not to keep throwing out random things to that attach onto the stuff but that's why stuff like this is important because if a building is damaged by severe snow or this type of thing it these costs are so super high and the one thing I worried about when I heard we got 14 inches of snow was was
117there going to be a school that Clos for longer than a day or two was there going to be a school that closed for months because the roof collapsed because pipes burst and we could not get you know I distinctly remember a school uh I remember it was last year the year before where pipe burst and it was not this type of thing the amount of time it took to get uh I believe it was Rothenberg if I'm not mistaken um but to to get that Rec that building back to place was not a one or two day thing and those students were displaced and had to then be brought back and and we commend everyone who facilities who did that work but the immediate thought to me was when we have such low weather
118we have so such low temperatures that that could have been something that happened again and so I just really want us as a board to really make an effort to get through some of the discussion around the facilities master plan to address these needs that are really existing because even if we open a building if there's no warm air circulating through a building if half the building is shut down because you can't because the snow is collapsed part of the roof things like that have severe worries for me that we're far beyond whether or not our you know kids miss three days in a week or four days in a week um which I still think is important but I I again I think there's some bigger conversation points that we have to have around
119some of this extra stuff so I appreciate the message that was being sent out and just hope that we as board can talk more about that I appreciate your feedback too you know uh I I I told the staff I deviated from what's necessarily on a piece of paper because for me that process that week Monday the first day that we had to deal with the storm I think everyone understood we had to deal with the storm on Tuesday I I instead of going my regular route to work I went a Street Route because I wanted to experience what the streets were like for people what the sidewalks were like I saw that but in addition to that I did think about the 10% of our kids who are experiencing homelessness who who are unhoused
120and what this means to them after 3 days so even the ones who are in the shelters sometimes the shelters kick them out during the day I don't know if that happened or not but sometimes that happens you've heard me say and Rebecca Beach say many times we used to worry about kids sleeping in cars we have many kids sleeping under bridges and even if we're talking about one for that particular night there's kids sleeping under bridges I worried about that I worried about our employees I worried about our families because some of our employees are hourly some of our parents are hourly they have to go to work and if there's no school they don't they're not able to go to work as easily our employees if we don't open school if you miss
121a day pay that might be one thing people can live with two days but by the time you get to that third day it can really be painful in addition to that I think about the equipment you heard on the city on the news the city said after the first snowstorm they had X the number of their plows there are a lot of things that go into this tough decision I don't take it lightly I take it very seriously and I deal with those who ex expect us to be in school and the same number that expect us to not be in school so I have grandchildren in this District I work in this District I am genuinely making what I think is the best decision not necessarily based on a temperature all the time
122but on holistically what is happening across our city what I can control what I can't control as well as specifically to the school district so the decisions were not made to irritate frustrate upset anyone that were the best decisions that I could make at that time thank you board member Lindy thanks president maffet um I just wanted to say two things one was um I don't envy you these decisions whatsoever on the list of things that I think would be extraordinarily Difficult about being a superintendent this is this is uh I want to say the top of the list because there's some other really hard stuff but it's it's on the list um and they they they feel like just you know there's going to be some group that's very upset matter what um I
123also wanted to just to thank you um other thing I want to say is how much I agree with what Mrs Weinberg was saying a second ago um that I I I don't second guess your judgment on any of these things whatsoever I do think sometimes there's an opportunity for the communication to help us out in the long run um I think the I think you even shared this example um but the the the the cold day language when there are days that are later colder than that which just confuses people you know like and I'm I'm wondering is is there some broader language we could use that gives you the room you need to weigh all of these things with every decision um but doesn't invite unnecessary frustration from parents thank you any other
124board member can I will just say and I know the superintendent has heard me say this because we've talked about it um I don't envy you at all we we um have had many conversations around this I think that what people are looking for is consistency Clarity if it's 20° one day but it's 10° the next day they want to understand why what that is I've invited the superintendent to make a little video each time to say hey this is what went into this decision on this day I don't know if that's feasible but I think that that may provide the the community with some clarity and some understanding I don't know if we should put numbers to those uh to this polic but this this the way that this is written um doesn't offer
125Clarity and it doesn't Define consistently what it will be so I just want to invite the administration to um to think about that when they are giving something to the public around days on and days off and I don't envy you this is a very tough decision and I and I know for a fact that you put a lot of heart into making that decision and have gotten a lot of backlash as well but I think that we can be a little bit more consistent for our staff and a little bit more consistent for our community as well and maybe there's something separate that goes to our staff than what goes to the public I I don't exactly know but I do know that those are two areas that we've heard a lot of discussion
126around do any other board members have any other concerns vice president Bol um I would just add and I think it's been touched on by the superintendent part of this is the differing is the internal communication because of our different employee groups uh and unions have different responsibilities on such a day and so our vocabulary I keep saying this our vocabulary has to kind of catch up with what we're doing uh because we're still using old vocabulary uh and that's part of the confusion and I'm glad you've convened a group to try to figure this out also um we don't have in this big place we don't have the same options that any of the other 21 school public school districts in Hamilton County uh have um uh because of our dependence upon Metro uh
127we don't have the delay opportunity that you know I experienced at Wyoming uh actually where superintendent get out and if that superintendent could climb up their driveway in their car that the uh the schools remained open you have to have all kinds of things to to do there uh but uh I do think we need some vocabulary that could help the clarity that uh member Weinberg is talking about because we're still using old vocabulary any other comments okay superintendent Murphy please introduce your next presentation happy to do so all right we're oh we're go from inclement weather to summer summer school uh our curriculum director miss Emily Campbell and our director of Human Resources Miss Julia andela thank you good evening what a great segue from winter to summer um thank you for uh our
128giving us time to share our proposal for our summer school um optioning this June 2nd through June 27th next slide please uh so we convened a team of principles counselors teachers a variety of stakeholders uh several weeks ago to talk through what um what we need to offer in addition to the school year and what we want to do is increase Equitable access for our K8 students our incoming K8 students and our high school um 9 through 12 students who are in need of recovering Core Credit for graduation so we um we believe these extra 19 days can be measured by um a attendance in the K8 space um as well as increased student Readiness as measured by our fall toall Ela and math benchmarks and then in high school we want to increase credits
129for graduation as well as um programs like work volunteer and clubs and then we would also like to have a climate survey for families students and uh staff SL please so in terms of logistics um it makes sense to um start the start the day early with teacher prep um our teachers we've got feedback from them that said that they would rather start early than to stay later to do the prep and so the school day across the district would be 8:00 a.m. um and then end at 1:15 allowing them to spread their prep out between the beginning and the end um and in that time for elementary they would have a math block an Ela block and an in an in and an enrichment block um this is different than in the past in
130the past they had three blocks and they had some and teachers had some choices about when they're going to teach and we really after a lot of discussion with um all the interested parties it made sense to have a a pretty static schedule across the district um at high school they would have credit recovery blocks aligned to that which they're missing so those credits that they're missing they would have a block for that um and then also at high school some opportunities to earn some credentials or seals do some continuous work on that as well as um as Emily talked about volunteer work perhaps even um work opportunities um we're hoping to um get with our partners um and our local communities to maybe help with that um in terms of helping our kids to
131have something to do all day we know that um um filling their time with productive work is a is a good thing um especially if it's leading towards some income for them or um some volunteer hours and so there's the schedule um for that for the for the day Rob and our timeline so um we are working now in the winter part so we've begun our recurring work team that meets um every other week and that team team is so we Emily talked about our stakeholder group that started early and now we're a team that is across the district in terms of all the Departments so transportation and facilities and um student dining services curriculum Human Resources all the Departments are getting together that touch summer school which is literally all the Departments right in
132central office including the treasur office Etc so at this point um we are at a point where we are ready to start recruiting students um which will happen around mid-February um and that will be based on looking have having counselors look at um what do the matriculation towards graduation look like um as well as what did the winter benchmarks look like for our students in elementary school so really looking at that data to see who in priority um needs to be included in the summer school this spring then we provide PD for um for the staff and reg registration will happen at the sites finalize the rosters of course course schedules Etc and then in June we'll Implement high quality instruction make sure that we give progress updates and take advantage of every last minute
133that we have those students in school um just to make sure that this time is effective um and engaging so that is our timeline and that's where we are now is wanted to bring that update to you so that you had a chance to um look at what where we're heading for summer school in see if you had any feedback for us or questions thank you board members do you have any questions board member Weinberg hi I'll be quick with my questions so based off of the information that you all provided I am curious of a couple things so we've done uh summer school in the past and as we're looking forward to redoing it and hopefully doing it with some Innovation and something different I did not see a cost at all listed here
134so my question would be the cost for transportation the cost for materials the cost for staff Etc and then I know there was a huge concern with attendance so if you're trying to have summer school for 19 days I know in the past there was I guess provided feedback from teachers or just staff members that stated that the children weren't showing up how are we going to really get the kids to show up and then two I three excuse me I know that your goal is to really get the kids in need how many children so far based of based off of our data that we know of could you maybe give a roundabout of a number of what we're thinking we would like to see for the numbers to make um summer school successful
135so sorry if that was a lot but when I saw this I thought about so budget attendance how do we get attendance and then what are the approximate number of students that we're addressing um in terms of budget um we've been we've worked to the treasures office and we have um $2.5 million um that is some carryover title money that can be used for um the staff materials and uh Transportation um there is also a small bucket of money in a title 11 that is uh formerly um is summer school money that was carried over from back in the days when we used to charge tuition for summer school and so those are allocated by building so you can only use those for the building that they came from and so we're looking at that
136especially for our non-title schools and think thinking about how we could fund non- tial um and so that's that's where our budget is right now that's that's what we're looking at what that we sorry to interrupt so you're saying that we're going to get the budget from Title One and Title 11 what were the two yes title title one and fund 11 fund 11 fund 11 um that will yield us um the way we think about that breakdown in terms of staff is that will get us about 260 teachers roughly about eight teachers per building um for a cost of about 101.5 million at 15 elementary sites and 16 High School sites so every High School would have its own site and we found that works best and elementaries would pair up with neighbors and
137we've also tried to be careful about choosing sites because we have the growth plan happening and so we don't want to go to sites where there's going to be a lot of construction or there's going to be a lot of movement and so we've um we've worked on that um we also would allow for one pair per site that way we can get some help with in terms of lunch and making sure that um folks are on site for that um and so that would that would also cost a little bit about $100,000 for that and then we have allocated right now about half a million dollar for um transportation so that's where we are I'll have Emily pick up on attendance and just a um say something else about with the budget when you
138come back or I'm assuming you'll be bringing back more information regarding this can we actually see that budget put in on absolutely yes and it'll get more detailed obviously as we dig in yes in regards to attendance this was a conversation that we um had with our original visioning um committee with teachers and principles and their comments where we have to offer something exciting during the day that makes students want to come and do that additional hard work with math and Ela which is why we wanted to keep that enrichment block um in the elementary school and also provide work based opportunities volunteer opportunities things that students can do to um get their seals um as well as um jobs because that was a big reason why our High School principles were saying high school
139students weren't showing up um that uh is our goal for attendance and then the third question you had was related to data and I don't have the number of um students right now in need of credits for 912 but approximately 18% of our students for the 3 through 8th grade reading benchmark um were three plus grade levels below and those are so we want to start with our students with the most need we want to invite them Market Market Market um make it seem as exciting as possible um and make sure that um our students with the most intense need thank you vice president B yes I'm uh happy to see the multiple um sites especially for the high school folks because I think that was pretty rough to to to not have them at
140the various high schools uh also it'd be great I I I I know we've done it in the past and maybe we did it recently but I can't recall it'd be great to actually see at the end of this how many kids picked up how many credits it'd be great to see if anybody that attended summer school actually have reading Improvement or math Improvement do they they do better or they are less likely to drop out or what it' be really kind of great to use some of these uh this Cadre of of kids or cohorts of kids to really see if there is this value to summer school that we uh we hope it exists so thank you for your presentation for member m yes thank you uh for the presentation um as it
141pertains to the high school must have um you have listed that there's uh offsite opportunities such as volunteer and work opportunities I'm interested in knowing if we have established a connection with the city I know that at our at our neighborhood meeting there was a conversation and a presentation around possible jobs uh available different maybe internships and so I'm wondering have we solidified that um connection so that our students do have access to uh different work and volunteer uh opportunities so we have um Mr badget on our design team and I wouldn't say that we've solidified our partnership with the city but we are actively working um with our city to offer things like um lifeguarding um classes so that students can again get jobs and so um we also have our College and Career
142Team on the design committee um to just increase our Partnerships and things like that and then board member map I want to add uh we were on a call today with the city in particular about the public uh service Academy and and we're going to do a very specific push around the fire and police cadets for cincin public schools we also talked with them about the idea we have around a city career um Cafe where City of Cincinnati employees will come and kind of um Mentor for a day uh different groups of kids talking about their particular career in the city how they got started started uh what they do on a day-to-day basis we talked about moving forward uh around our partnership with the public service Academy um continuing this career Cafe concept but
143in addition to that with the city in particular having job uh Shadow opportunities and group tours uh of kids from a variety of schools so I believe everybody is on board with working through what that looks like uh the city manager mentioned having Mr Johnson uh Jud Johnson come and speak with us a little more intently about the summer employment that is available also coming up you'll see in the weekly update this week um the deputy and Casey fiser are working on a grow your own so employment here in Cincinnati public schools in particular I think this is targeting our seniors though so not really about summer school but how our seniors who might be interested in immediate employment can get started right here in our school district so you hear more about that soon
144thank you for that feedback and then the last part of the question is um talking about the credentials and the seals where the will will there be aligned conversation around what these possible job opportunities um will do in terms of earning those SEALS or would this be a separate discussion we intend to have that all inclusive so the College and Career Team are on our design team for summer school so that it is um embedded within okay thank you for member c um so again thank you for uh putting together the presentation again superintendent I know we shared our feedback and so I appreciate you providing responses to it um so I won't go through all the parts of that but and part of it has also been already uh answered um I think one
145of the things that I do want to make sure and it's going back a little bit to board member weinberg's point with regards to consistency of attendance you know one of the issues with Summer Scholars and I get it because to a certain extent the enrichment idea parents commit to it initially and then kind of but our summer trip is planned right or you know our family reunion is that weekend or those types of things and it puts us on the line of having folks who are employed who don't have work to do and that is my one worry even in doing it in that sense because what we did notice is we had a high number of folks at the beginning of the summer who attended and a very low number in comparison in
146some spaces or even even that finishing that first week right like that that tended to be some of the issues and so I was I guess my first question in that line though is is there an expectation that for the k through eight especially that they would show some measure or have to prove some measure achievement from going through the summer school because I I do think from for me if it still remains you know trying to keep people on track or trying to keep people growing you're going to still end up with the same result which is a number of folks who who they're all G ho about it the first week by week four it's well but we plann this family trip or you know you'll miss two days this week because we
147got this thing or your cousins are in town so go play with them this week kind of deal which we know fames do dur the summer right because that's that's not unusual so I guess is there an expectation of some type of completing or meeting some level of demonstrating you've learned or demonstrating you've uh met the the necessary results as part of that talk about yeah okay so our um our goal is to look at the students who do attend and their um and look at their fall Benchmark data so we're trying to reduce the number of Summers reduce the summer Slide by increasing the 19 instructional days um the the principles on our design team were elevated those same concerns especially when we were putting seven to eight elementary schools within a building um
148which required a lot like getting your child to this building that would may have been much further away um from what they were used to going to so we were much more intentional about grouping clusters of three um I think we have one situation where we have four schools going there and making them GE graphically um make Mak sense geographically um so you would notice that sailor Park is a standalone because sailor Park students did not come to their their site that was near anything else that was identified last year so those are those are two attempts uh in addition to the enrichment making it fun um although we know that this is really important for kids to learn to read and be able to do mathematics um kids want to enjoy their time and
149they want them they want it to feel a bit different than the um typical year absolutely talk about I can understand that yeah and and one of the things that we um have done too is in thinking about the Staffing um we also know that um especially at the high school um and one of the reasons we chose to have um each of the high schools be their site is because the kids will be familiar with those folks and these are kids who are in danger of not matriculating through for high school and so having a relationship with someone from the building or someone who's familiar with the building and going to that building makes a lot of sense in terms of helping um push that piece exactly um a board member cry around um
150making sure people come to summer school that's really important but you going to say something else about that no okay and and again I think my concern Still Remains with the K through 8 more so than the high school the purpose of the high school is credit recovery getting the uh credentials and seals and these type of things which are all things that I think are essential the k through eight is the one where for me a lot more of the reason folks did not continue or did not make it all the way through has nothing to do with whether or not the building was close enough to them right there are these other factors that are part of that k through eight process of if one kid is in or one kid is not
151like those type of things um so just that's something for us to look at and and monitor as whether or not that makes the same sense in the same way um for the high school uh and to you superintendent to you a little bit of the credit to your way I know we connect you up with some folks within the uh aflci who had mentioned opportunities through number of the different trade unions I think this is another expectation that we could or another opportunity to partner with them with regards to um Career Tech in the summer opportunities because again it's a little bit more difficult in this the school year when we're trying to do some of this stuff in the middle of the school day and trying to figure out their schedules in that
152way if the whole point of it is to provide them opportunities to learn to do specific skills or trades and especially ones that might uh to I think you point you were making at the end there of opportunities to grow within you know if you have a student who's learning plumbing and a as a summer credential who then maybe they do that their junior year or their sophomore year they're more prepared to be an apprentice to become a plumber in the district right or an electric rtion in the district or outside the district to be quite honest and last time I check based on what they are charging me to to do these work in my own place uh plumbers and electricians make a good amount of money so um but that's a skill set
153that I think to be quite honest we may not have the same time and effort and ability to do all the same things in the school year that we could during a summer program there might be a mentorship or or a a uh inter like an internship or that type of deal the other thought I wanted to just kind of throw out there with regards to all of this is I know we are trying to identify those students who may be and this is to a pointed the old student achievement committee we first discussed um how do we do this how do we do work with our students is to is to look at where they're not meeting or where they're falling behind and try and get them up to speed early um one thing
154though I do think maybe is worth discussing and looking at that is are there opportunities to some schools have a different issue like at each school as to what might be drawing some of the students behind right so some schools have great Career Tech numbers right they they're on top of it but maybe math is an area that that school that they're they're they're struggle with and that type of deal and I don't know if there's at this point there may not be that level of identification that we can do with individualized schools but if we're going to be doing that within the high school trying to keep them separate it may need us to do some more targeted in the future um so just to think about something like that because I think that
155may be also a better draw to a parent to say my ski my kid at this school who they're really struggling at algebra to get through that versus at another school where maybe it is a CCH credential they need or it is something else it might be more a beneficial but it's not what's being offered and so um if you're going to have individual high schools I think it may also make sense to do a little bit more of the tailoring to get your better bang for your bug from that so before I go around a second time I'm going to just offer my S my questions and comments and I'm sorry I'm withering here on my voice um I have about four questions for you um the first is the the host schools are
156going to be the high schools correct all of the high schools did you give us which 15 elementary sites are going to be hosting summer school we did not give it to you in this presentation um but we can get you that Google doc of it's a draft right now but okay so it's just kind of in you're still thinking thinking that part through um I would love to see we we've had this discussion around summer school this now this is my fourth time being on the board and the overarching opinion is not that it works so it seems to be a lot of money a lot of resources for the the return on investment to not be as successful as we anticipate one of the things I'd like to see that I didn't hear
157that I'm sure maybe it isn't there is that can we incorporate maybe a summerbridge program for the junior high students that are going to Jun to these Junior highs that we know and maybe make it a little bit more interesting and Lively for them to attend but it also serves a purpose so that they're getting to know their new school they're getting to know their new route they may or may not be able to meet teachers they may or may not be able to see some people that they are going to see in the fall but I think that we need to start we we think of it in in terms of Education because that we're Educators and we have the best Educators if you ask me my opinion and staff as well so this
158is no knock to what you all are doing but I think we also need to make it a little bit interesting for them where they are and if we could utilize the the 19 days to expose them to what maybe are going to get maybe level set expectations for junior high is what I'm speaking of make it a true summerbridge program I would feel better about that spend of $2.5 million and transportation cost because it would feel like I would feel as if it were feeling a need that um they're going to get and they might see a value in that as well and then perhaps we can have a parent component where parents can come and get their questions answered um they can also see some of where their students are going to be
159going and what that looks like so that it's not just a we're telling you in the fall you're actually becoming immersed and perhaps we could bring some um hey join the PTA lsdmc what I am what I'm actually asking for is more continuation of and inclusion of all of our services so that it's not just disjointed the actual return on investment may not be seen academically only but it could be seen in other way ways as well we could also measure that with data around how many parents come come versus you know those that feel prepared in the summer that come in the summer or do they feel prepared in the fall we can tie that to data but I think I'm really more interested in um being more well-rounded with the money spend specifically
160for summerbridge because this is an opportunity for us to do that with regard to um seals and credit are we talking about credit recover Y which is an online program are we talking about teachers in the building and seals seals and credentials to me I I I'd like to see something a little bit more like credentialing to earn a certificate so that they are leaving that building with something it is not impressive to me that we just simply offer seals what is impressive is that we are employing these students to either be credential to get employment or they're right there at that step for employment that's what needs to happen I also think that that's going to help the students attend because right now what if we're just offering the same thing the return on
161investment to me is not worth the $2.5 million investment with regard to um paying the students there if we were to partner with the with the county the county has offered us the ab ility in return for helping students get their work permits the opportunity they pay the salary of students they pay for that so perhaps we could tie in their uh youth employment department to have them come to school during the day and then stay at school and do some sort of work again that would not be a cost to us that's a partnership we need to explore more so that I don't know if we can decrease that 2 and a half million but we can definitely be a little bit more uh efficient with that and my last Point um is around
162uh what is the capacity we talk about where the schools where the students are coming from but what would the capacity at your current Staffing that you're proposing around uh 260 teachers 31 pairs at a cost of around 1 and A5 million what's the capacity of students that you can serve at that I can answer your question about recovering credits um we do have uity that students can do on their own but we um our intent for summer school is that it is teacher um driven instruction using uity as a resource um and then miss indel capacity uh I just very quick numbers um not I'm trying to pay attention to the contract a little bit but I say somewhere between six and 7,000 students could be served depends on how we do that though
163right um so I love the idea of thinking about like the AFL cioo and working with the county and my son's a graduate of CPS he's an electrician he decided to do that after he started college and now he's making above our teacher salary um and he's 28 and so I think what you know if you could introduce those those skills to the kids in the summer and have them do hey this week we're going to have and I and we've had those folks here at board meetings before the the um apprenticeships who are saying we'd love to have some of those kids well would you be willing to come for a week in the summer and do a workshop for them and and you know the plumbers you know to your point would you
164be willing to come and and do this for a week and introduce them to different areas so that because a lot of times kids don't know how to access the trades and blue collar is not a four-letter word right this is like an important um piece that could be a a great future for for um some some students so I just think about how we use like we can talk about capacity depending on how we use those teachers and how we allocate whether it's more to high school and fewer to K8 or or that we we sort of did a rough estimate where we said if we had 260 teachers that'd be about eight per building how would you use that and it doesn't necessarily mean that's APR building right that means that's an average
165of a building but there might be some cases where it might make sense to have more at high school where there's more credit recovery that needs to happen and more of these experiences in in planning and preparation for next steps um and towards that um towards credentialing towards seals towards volunteer work and toward towards um paid paid employment and so I think we have an opportunity to kind of um with your feedback this has been really helpful tonight to think through next steps for how to really make all of this come to fruition thank you I I think I said it rather raspy but I just really want us to reimagine summer school because um we can do different for our kids for member Matthew you had a question so I just want to thank
166you for your commentary because you touched upon a lot of the things that I was going to speak about because what I do think as you talked about it being disjointed I don't necessarily know that our students as well as our parents have an um have a connection to what we're striving to accomplish and so creating conversations early as well as consistently so that we're all on one Accord and you know this is really to you all as well as superintendent I know that we have the um the um focus of here for kids but if there could be some type of campaign about what does that actually mean right so when we're thinking about trying to put in different interventions how do we connect that to our goals that we're trying to accomplish with
167the OST how do we connect that to our uh credentialing and our seals how do we connect that to what they're doing in everyday practice so that as a whole not just the teachers not just the um the board or the superintendent understand what we're trying to have the students accomplish but they have a clear understanding as well as the parents have a clear understanding of what the actual goal is and so when we hear that Focus consist throughout the district that's something that they can recognize as a whole we all can recognize this is what we're working on and so if that's something that we can do um I would definitely encourage it because I think it will help to create that excitement I think it would help to create that reimagination I like
168to speak about when I was in the classroom we had after school um opportunities so maybe if summer school isn't necessarily working are we looking at what the after school process could be like like how many students would attend how many parents would be interested in their students attending because you don't necessarily have to think about Transportation they are already there right so that's an opportunity opportunity we can capitalize on possibly if you all look into just information and research around that and then also really celebrating the students getting them excited we would have pep rallies right to say this is what our focus is and as a district everyone was speaking the same consistent language and I think that will help to have more alignment and more connection as to what we're trying to
169accomplish because just looking at we want them to earn seals we want them to uh you know we want to Target the students that need that additional support I think there needs to be more Connection in how we do that um so thank you for your point and hopefully that's something that we could possibly explore remember cross just very quickly um I like I really like the idea of the high school and the jobs connection and uh are I'm just assuming but maybe not are you working with cps's business advisory committee Council I'm sorry business advisory Council it's all about getting high school kids jobs so I'm happy to connect you I'm the board leaon to that but it's it's uh that's what they do and I think they'd be really happy to plug into
170uh your program thank you for vice president Bon I I appreciate everybody's ideas and stuff but I I also want to make sure we don't try to do so everything and not really accomplish what we absolutely have to accomplish in summer school which is the kids have to be able to progress I mean it it if it if it gets to be too many things I don't know that we're ready to be too many things yet uh and I'm very excited about the career piece and the work part part and the I think the uh enrichment that's critical that but I'm just let's not lose sight of what what we're really going to be at the end of this going to be demanding of y'all as to what was accomplished and and because we obviously
171have some issues I think it's it's important thank you uh to that point I think it is imposs important to recognize how we're paying for this so I mean there are limitations to the stuff we can do with the funds that we're paying for this with um and so I think that's important for us to recognize as a board as you all are thinking about what to do with this and how to figure out the best ways to do it because we can come up with a bunch of ways that are TR truly just purely enrichment that we can't do and like that's just the reality of how title funds are are meant right that they're not meant to create these whole wonderful things that actually are probably necessary for students who need Title One
172funds but there are to do this specific type of work and so that would be the only caveat I would I would add also to board member Bolton's or to vice president Bolton's point is that as we as a board think about all these things recognize we have a we're paying for this a certain kind of way so unless we're going to find other resources and other means to do that we do have limitations on how we can do that okay I think you are have gotten quite a bit of information I'm going to still invite you to reimagine this you know what the limitations are we don't we've given some very great feedback I think it's some rich feedback so for sure thank you for all your time and your efforts I appreciate you
173thank you uh superintendent Murphy please introduce your final presentation so we have Kathy Spelman coming along with M Amanda Vargo uh from our performance team and they're going to talk to us about third grade reading in particular our fall scores absolutely thank you so much for having us tonight thank you president Moffett vice president Bolton superintendent Murphy treasur Wagner and board members I am um Kathy Spelman director of performance and accountability and testing as you remember when I was um reported out on the report card the data lady so I'm also um pleased to introduce to you Amanda Vargo one of our testing managers and she's going to present tonight the third grade reading data the fall data for you all right good evening everybody um so we are going to take a look at
174our fall third grade results go ahead um so just a couple notes about the test I won't read the slide to you but this is the only test we give in the fall it is the same um test design same rigor and same scoring system as the test that we give in the spring even though we give this test in the fall um the results we look at are also every kid that tested not necessarily kids who will end up being like our full year accountable kids that end up populating our report card so the way this data is kind of most valuable because it is a summative end ofe assessment that we give in the fall is really comparing kind of the Fall toall data so that we can look at Trends um so
175that is provided here for you and um kind of called out in Red so there is four years of data Trend data on this sheet um from fall to fall for uh fall 21 through fall of 23 we had increases every year which followed um the state Trends as well um we did see a little bit of a difference from this fall as compared to last fall we actually remained stagnant um this fall compared to last fall at the exact same percent proficient however I do want to point out that the state uh this is the first time they had a decrease of 5 percentage points across the state and we did not follow that Trend as a district we maintain uh there were some highlights that I want to call out so 50% of
176our elementary schools did show an increase in percent proficient on the fall test uh this fall as compared to last fall we had eight schools show proficiency and at least 10 percentage points from this fall compared to last fall and those schools um are Bond Hill GDA uh Frederick Douglas John P Parker Kilgore Pleasant Ridge manasu Rose Lawn and Winton Hills and then we had four schools that actually have a higher efficiency this fall than they did compared to their overall accountable student population last year on their report card and those are bondil GDA uh hay Porter and Kilgore so did want to just shout out those highlights and then finally there is a uh comprehensive list of um percent proficient uh for all schools and showing that same fouryear Trend um the full list
177is linked there for your consideration oh sorry that's all I had I'm sorry I was I was expecting I was expecting you to continue questions board member Craig um so let me start by again thanking the superintendent for providing a response to my email when um again trying to follow president maf's uh guide for us to uh give feedback and information in early so we can have it fully understood um my question I I have two two questions at least for now um two questions first is really around the comparatives um from last year to this year and I think one of the things that is uh striking to me is we in the full chart when we look at the full summary the amount of students who go from in the fall where their
178scores are to where the percentages are in the spring or in the final report um there's a lot of growth in most of our schools there's a substantial amount of growth and that reads either one of two ways right one is that that fall is that what some people think of is that summer slide where folks have you know kind of enjoyed their summer a little bit too much right or um it could be that maybe at that level before because my understanding is we don't really have the same testing for the second grade as we do for the third grade that there may not be that achievement quite yet as they enter third grade that they'll have at the end of third grade and I guess maybe if you could speak a little bit
179to that part of it for me because I think it is important to compare the fall to fall but it maybe more important to compare the final to final given that they've now had the opportunity to learn the materials even if they hadn't been introduced to it before 100% so I think what you're calling out is really important so this is a summative end ofe third grade test that we are giving in October so there's not really like a a standard that we would look at to say we expect x amount of kids to be proficient that's really why the kind of the trend and the comparison is is where we can get value in the data the rigor of the Fall test is the same as the rigor of the spring test so if
180we didn't see those large jumps after a full year of instruction I think we would have a lot of different questions right um we don't have second grade um State Testing we have benchmark assessments that we look at that show other metrics that we measure success by um that we could do comparatively not provided here tonight and and I appreciate that because again I think that's part of where for me it's a hard part to read what the fall numbers actually are telling me because you look at some of these you have some some schools where yeah they've grown but you know your growth is you know three four people this way at least a substantial growth um in that fall number but if you look at where they are at the end of the
181Fall you have some places that are you know almost doubling and tripling what they where they started at the beginning the year um so that's that's helpful to understand I think the second question I have is as we look at these numbers as we look at the schools that have had growth if we look at the schools that are seeing growth there is also the kind of question of what happens next year in the comparative because we don't have the same schools next year for third grade and we can't it's not necessarily an accurate comparison even to the schools that we still do because they'll have a different group of students that will be their third grade and so I just wondering how we will how we're thinking about this as we go forward into
182next year because of the changes that have been uh made for the 202 25 26 school year that's great question for us to consider member ly thank you for the great report are there ways we can be helpful for you um I don't think so I think that the it's important for me for you all and for the public to understand that the point that this is a summit of end of the year test and so that's the value in compar comparing the fall to fall um but I think we we made that clear here tonight and so um I think that you know whatever we can do to help uh you know kind of community contextualize this information I think is really important we ac cross it just kind of curious why did the
183state of Ohio drop so much you know that's a great question I I don't know I mean these third graders were in prek when the pandemic hit we could perhaps to still but I I mean I don't have any sort of insights and they haven't really anything to my knowledge to explain that so I don't know vice president Weber it's been late yo call me president finally uh did they change the test I mean in that third grade I mean since the state went down so far uh the blueprints are the same the specifications are the same the scoring is the same so no thanks what are you going to call me I just wanted to say thank you so much for the presentation again I always like looking at the numbers I like seeing
184how either we're improving or what are some ways that we can get better and I also liked how you also showcased um the uh male versus female and then the different um also whether it was Hispanic versus black versus white so thank you for that as well remember correct just one other thought um came to my mind as well as I was looking at this um in some of the parts of our our district where we have a larger population of students taking the test um are there resources that are being allocated diff like in a in you know sometimes it's easier when you have like a group of 40 kids or 50 kids versus is 150 but in some ways sometimes 150 is easier to manage what we're adding out or what we're planning
185for that year what are we able to do as they grow into the processes and I think we're going to see more students per grade in some of these schools now than we had before so I'm just also trying to think of are there things that are being done in that first and second grade level that we can kind of champion out as ways that some of those schools have seen substantial growth uh I mean it's not just our monory schools it's not just one type of school it's they're wide variety and so I don't know if they're things that they're doing that you've seen or we've seen in some of the testing that's had positive results towards these uh increases in numbers I think our team has really done a lot of conversations even
186uh last week the deputy superintendent assistant superintendent and I talked about uh where we are school by school it took us a lot of time and in some places where we're observing we're still seeing um a lack of access to the curriculum at the level and degree that we are expecting it and so we are going back after instructional rounds the deputy has added around to some of the schools some schools are not where they are Benchmark to Benchmark for where we want them to be and so we're taking extra measures in that way I appreciate that because again I think that goes a little bit to what uh board member Lindy was asking in some ways is there stuff like are we having the right resources or is it just you know making sure
187the right resources get used that we can always be effective in thinking about or helping out with in any way so I just want to say thank you for the presentation I do want to go to slide five uh Rob if you could go there um we are talking about Improvement in these schools and that needs to be highlighted to me because I'm I'm really I'm it breaks my heart that we're talking talking about such low proficiency numbers quite frankly I mean we're celebrating numbers that are less than 50% proficient if we really are honest with what we're looking at but these schools did demonstrate some success and I think that that Wars us to be um highlighting that as well so kudos to those um students staff and administrators thank you and there any
188other questions all righty do board members have any topics or board matters okay a proposed consent agenda has been distributed Treasurer Wagner please maintain the list of any exceptions and the exception makers do board members the superintendent or the treasurer have any exception items to the consent agenda board member Matt uh yes I do have uh some exceptions to the uh treasurer's report just give me one second to it's okay you want me to have Miss Weber go first that's fine Mrs weberg yes so I do have some exceptions um we're going to go with page nine line 4 6 7 8 9 10 and 12 page 10 line 14 page 11 line three and page 12 line six thank you for member Matt yes thank you so uh page eight line items 11 and
18912 page 10 line item 9 page 11 line item 133 thank you any others okay so I need a motion excuse me and a second to approve the items of the consent agenda second excuse me Treasurer Wagner can you call the voting role for the passage of the consent agenda and revisions Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy I'm going to abstain on the treasures report page 14 under general counsel for the superintendent's contract yes on the rest please thank you Miss map yes Mrs weberg yes vice president Bolton yes president mofin yes we have three topics for inquiries and updates we president board vice president Bolton pleas us please lead us off with your first two topics thank you very much yes um priority one for me uh as we are developing this
190budget for this coming year but also on any given day uh is whether or not uh our kids are are safe we heard a lot today about the safety regarding our our many of our students um regarding uh State and and federal policy but uh as everyone will recall uh in the midst of uh this past year um the city of Cincinnati uh divested themselves of the responsibility of having uh to either hire train or pay for uh crossing guards on public streets where we don't even have jurisdiction um and so I'm I'm very anxious to uh hear from the superintendent um how we are um meeting this Challenge and this burden and and uh where are we um regarding uh filling all the appropriate uh spots do we still do we believe that the
191spots that the city had were the ones that needed to be did they have enough did uh just if you can give us a a sense of our crossing guards that should be paid for by the city and trained by the city and hired by the city uh that we're now hiring and training and paying for absolutely when we took on the responsibility of crossing guard uh and the conversations this summer I believe we had um several spots that had not been filled by the city at that time we agreed to do somewhat of a transition through the month of December such that by January 2025 we would have full responsibility for hiring the crossing guards we did ask the city to continue to support us in the training of those crossing guards um and
192so I mentioned earlier Shauna McDow in terms of offering sessions so that the um orientation could be provided for people who are interested in being coming crossing guards from for us and that is happening do we have all the positions filled no uh but we definitely have interests you may remember several weeks ago we started a campaign uh around uh the hiring of crossing guards from our HR department and we continue to work on that so how many crossing guards uh did the city uh suggests needed to be uh I'm going to ask Mr burkard to assist absolutely thank goodness oh well good evening um there were approximately 160 positions for crossing guards um we are actually to the point of we're trying to onboard um for a total of 150 I believe I think
193we'll have about 10 positions that we currently need to fill we have had a lot a lot of folks who have applied or expressed interest um if you remember we had the yard signs that were putting out at the intersections where we need crossing guards we've actually done interviews on um two of the television stations too to talk about why crossing guards are so important to our district and uh why safety is so important to the students of our district and that's really garnered a lot of uh um folks to really um dig in deep and and say yeah this job is for me so we're hoping that in the next two weeks or so we can have all the crossing guards actually F all the positions actually filled and they will be all of
194our employees I think that's a great accomplishment frankly um did the city uh continue the training or did they drop it um they are no longer working with us on training we did ask them if they could help us in deescalation of drivers and they would consider putting together a video training to help us do that um that is not our expertise is is uh how to handle drivers who may be combative or not want to stop for those crossing guards or how to deescalate those situations we're asking the city because they have that expertise with the police department to help us with that uh training I'll Reserve comment about the training or reference to the city council who actually seemed interested in it but then rightfully spoke up and said you know we really
195can't tell the city manager or the chief of police what to do and um so I thought that was interesting um keep up the great work I mean if I've had several people that I know that uh like a shivia placement uh crossing guard people I think this is a great opportunity for us to reach out to the community um yeah and this and this is a work of Love um with with the Communications Department obviously HR Talent uh shaa McDow with with overseeing u um the crossing guard locations and making sure they're on boarded uh so it is a a a village coming together to solve the problem I I personally don't think anything is more important than that thank you thank you thank you I will say to too we have our joint
196meeting coming up perhaps we can bring this up and board members can attend and ask questions I'm calling a member Craig to take care of the city on this matter there we go and others I was going to say I don't I don't reserve the the pleasure of not making the comment I think this is exactly why I have struggles with our relationship with our city right now because these are the types of things that normal mediumsized to Big City size city school school districts don't have to worry about and the fact that we are continuing to see the less of a investment in our school district from the city and not a reverse makes it more difficult it makes things that we have to make decisions on that we have to put funds towards
197that we have to now use our time and effort towards with HR more difficult for the district to do the work that we're actually T to do and that's I you know I think we have wonderful friendships in in relationships with the city council and with folks in the city I know several people who work in the city who are people who I I regularly interact with and connect with and whatnot but I think it is very difficult to say that these are creating opportunities for us to do something in a more effective and efficient manner um I also want to say I appreciate the fact that we have been able to get 150 when I know a year and a half ago we were still at 110 or something like that or 12 so
198it it goes to show the effort to recruit and to bring people in just wasn't happening from the city so again Partnerships matter and relationships matter but I I will probably uh say again I think it's just very troubling that we this is not a single thing this is a pattern of stuff that would probably be the next one that I believe is actually on Bolton's list of of uh inquiries but I I just I think this is something for us to acknowledge and maybe again when we have the conversation at the uh joint meeting that it becomes a reality of not just talking about things but actually some material result come from it um because it is time that the superintendent is spending it is time that her staff is spending it is time
199that everyone in the district is spending on doing things that really should be something that are the safety of our kids is something that is a priority to both of us and we had the the the uh police chief here demanding us to be stepping up and I and again I just I have a heart hard issue with you come here do that and then we can't get you to even train the folks who are being tasked to slow down traffic so that they're safe because we've had uh crossing guards hit by Vehicles so it is not like a mystery thing it's something that's actually happened and we can't get the police to even be invested in that that little bit of effort this just a sad state for that and since we're giving a
200slight bit of commentary I also want to direct the board members to an email that I sent you saying that the cost of details is rising for the district as the public knows we utilize details at our games we utilize details for board meetings but the cost is going up and um you know we're being asked to uh to assume that cost as well so just a lot to discuss at this joint meeting does anyone have any questions for board member or vice president Bolton's topic around Crossing okay next topic the next one uh this one too is about uh the safety procedures I believe um District Security review as second semester begins right as we started our second semester our new calendar year uh wanted to see if uh there's a an opportunity for
201the administration to update us uh bring us um some information or at least start to prepare some sort of overall safety piece uh on this when I put this on uh the agenda some a couple weeks ago there we had another spat of shootings uh around the country that I think for some reason really gripped people um in part I think one of them was in a private school and and another was by a girl was involved with one of those shootings and I got awful lot of uh uh concerns from of uh people that I would see or hear from uh again about do we have the metal detectors are we doing what we need to be doing how secure are our children and our teenagers and our staff is there any kind of
202a report that could be filed or a sense of reassurance yes we definitely are utilizing the metal detectors book bag searches every single day security members walking the hall security at each of our buildings I am happy to prepare and bring you a detailed report around Security in our school district if you give me a moment uh if I could when we get to assignments I'd like to make that assignment and I think it can fall within executive uh uh session uh to a certain extent because of safety but then a lot of it we would want to say share with our public too so it's a matter of what do we share with the public and what do we know and uh which lends to the discussion earlier tonight about internally what are we
203doing about the safety of many of our students that have been referenced tonight some of that has to be very very uh um obvious and and clear internally but again and careful uh in an external uh sort of sharing so that I'd appreciate it and I'll save that for assignment okay board member Weinberg has withdrawn her um did you want to she's got to do it it's a great idea okay I don't even know where that topic came from so it's not that I withdrew the item I've I never submitted that so while ago make that clear I know exactly what it is what is it when we had so many people coming and and spreading the love uh and their concerns and issues uh regarding uh the consolidation and what have you when we
204had so many people here you had mentioned to me uh that indeed wouldn't it be great if there's a way that we could start to you know we always take a list of those people that are going to speak but it'd be great to have sort of a list if people were willing to sign up uh a list of people that attend in our audience and maybe which school it's from or what their interest were because it was a really good idea I thought to kind of start that um uh engagement and and start to have a whole wonderful Cadre of of parents and families and supporters it was a great idea well I'm so happy that you remember so thank you because I but it was a great idea if we could get people
205we we have so many wonderful people come and uh and we always need them and we benefit from their presence thank you thank you you're right so does it does any board members have any questions of board member weinberg's forgetful memory and vice president Bolton for her crossing guards Etc all right are there any assignments board members I'd like that safety report from our superintendent uh and uh appreciate the earlier one we received earlier this evening remember remember c um so one is just uh I know we put together some the assignment like sheet that had all the assignments on it or something like that but I think maybe not the next board meeting but maybe or not February but like maybe mid-February the first mov of March we could just um as kind of
206an assignment to us or assignment to president just get an updated on kind of the status of those things and updated list of what's actually out there I think it's also helpful for us to remember what we've actually asked to be done um and then a second one um really focus on um thinking about the upcoming uh Levy conversation we have to have to just make some time um in the next few months for as a board to also talk about that I think we're also going to do it we're doing it in budget and finance but I think as a board we can make an assignment to just Place time on our our agenda at some point to really go through what our decisions going to be and what our needs are for our
207upcoming Lev gotcha so that was going to be my assignment is that we um have the our board admin receive a copy if your staff does keep a copy of assignments that we also keep a copy of that who it's been assigned to and then completion so that the board members are aware that they will have asked previous questions and when it got answered if at all and we can keep a record of that we started that a couple years ago but it's time to revisit that um sometimes you get the feeling like I know I asked for that and I never got it I can ask the deputy to send it to the board tonight we do we do keep track that sounds good we're going to probably have uh I call them affectionately
208P2 which is Phyllis and Pat we're going to probably have them compile that list and send it out so yes you can send it to us but we're going to probably just have them send it out too okay so the chair will gladly entertain a motion for adjournment is there a second let me get it out my gosh I heard it unanimous consent