CorpusRecord 65353

Budget, Finance and Growth Committee Meeting January 17, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2025-01-18
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,440 words · about 75 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all righty uh call order the January 17 20125 meeting of the budget financing growth committee um we are short one board member today he's on a little vacation still probably somewhere warmer than we or um so uh board member Crossett will be in our next meeting so we'll hold off on doing um or selection of a chair to I'll serve as Pro for today's meeting um but in uh the tradition of all of our other Budget Finance and growth committee meetings we'll go around and introduce who all is in the room um let's start with uh stus and then when we get back around to Rob if you want to tell folks online how to partip the hearing of the public when get this back to you good morning Phyllis Davis the

002board's Administrative Assistant good morning Lauren Roberts Chief audit executive good morning Jen Wagner treasure and Chief Financial Officer morning Michael Gustin assistant Treasurer Kevin Ashley director of financial reporting and transparency Brandon Craig board member Eve Bolton board member good day shaa Murph superintendent good morning Nan he good state and federal programs manager morning ask local morning Michelle Federation teacher 152 and Robert Wilson technician if you'd like to speak during the speaking of the public session of the meeting today please click the hand icon we will ask you for your name and Association to the district and we'll invite you to speak at the end of the meeting thank you right um the other part we have two things um still left in our old business one is just the treasure search updates we are still

003in the process of the uh treasure search and folks if you have not applied and are Desiring to apply please do if you have about a week left um and what we have it open for um and once we have received all the folks we going to receive we will at that point then the board gets a chance to sit down look at the applications and uh deter who we're going to move on to the next stage which would be the interview process and depending if we have millions of people apply or if we have you know seven or eight um May determine how big a process we have um you know I hate to say we'd have a million people apply but um but we are still working with the uh osba to or

004yes uh to to gather to gather folks in um as candidates um the other part of old business here is we had a couple policies from last year one was a cash balance policy and the other was the fixed asset policy that we were going to move um to uh policy committee and so Char if you want to give us a little bit on sure so um the cash policy is actually a new policy that we're requesting um for the board to um commit to re a cash Reserve amount um and we calculated an amount to match 60 days of operations um and but it's we're suggesting to phase it in a five-year period so what that means is every year we'd have to set $12 million aside of the available revenues in order to

005start building that cash Revenue the cash balance up to 60-day balance and so that's a pretty heavy lift of $12 million the impact to next year's budget would be take your forecast of revenues take off $12 million and then you have $12 million left to spend on your budget so I don't know if the if the board had an opportunity to think about whether five years is appropriate or you want to do it faster or slower um so that's the conversation and a little bit uh to Bolton a little bit the background of this is that what our concern was is the declining amount of our cash balance meant each year we were you know getting lower and lower and while in theory yes you'll get a higher amount when we pass Levy that as

006a good practice we felt it was a uh C having a Flor amount that we would want to stay above from a cash balance standpoint there were other as they did a kind of review of what other places did other districts did there are some levels that are probably higher and there's some practices that say that should be even higher than the 60-day Mark I think uh what was I know it was a much higher number at one point that we had looked at um one was like 120 days 45 to 120 and so what we kind of talked about at the last meeting of the budget finance committee last year as well is that we didn't want to do this all in one year right so doing it over a phase in approach yeah

007really uh Rob has slide up there for it but um and the the goal would be that at the end of that five year that we would have this Mark of what we were going to do was a 60-day cash balance that we would be able to then uh maintain as we go forward so that we would also not be able to tap in other resources where we were having to pull funds which we had to do before to ensure that we would have uh funds on hand to to do things like payroll and other stuff that we have to do and a policy would help um because at the end of every budget cycle there's always pressure to go and balance the budget using cash the leftover cash from the prior years and so

008um while we've done that to help invest in Strate strategic Investments we don't have the cushion to do that anymore because our our revenues that come in twice a year there's dry months where we're not getting a whole lot of money and our we're getting dangerously low in our cash balance in those months so this will help protect that pressure going forward to dip into that cash savings account so to speak to help balance a budget if is part of that the fact that we wait so long to go to the voters I mean if we're at an eight-year I mean yes I mean we our um revenues are not keeping track of the inflationary costs so we're spending faster than a typical Levy cycle would be but the board has been very proudly and

009should be very proud of um the fact that we've stretched a five-year Levy into eight years and so we've been very frugal with that money um but uh we just can't inflation is too to is increasing too too fast for us to continue to do that should um looking at and I think the chairman is spoken well about this in board meetings that we're looking at the the levies and the renewals that we have in the next uh half dozen years uh should this inform also our Levy requests um rather than just operational or whatever that were uh I'd be comfortable if if indeed that becomes part of the ask sure to make that to the public because I I really don't want to not have $12 million every single year not to spend on

010the children and the teenagers and the district um but if if we can build it into our planning I I could perhaps support um this policy I think one other aspect of thinking about this the cash balance policy is it is a it is also about timing of when we spend um and and thinking about that from a budgetary standpoint right so we don't want to because what to the Treasure's point there are times where our Revenue just does not come in right and so if the like any family if our expenses at that time are are so high as do we would have to be tapping into the cash balance I think that's it's a mindset change as well so it's not just the additional money to keep reserves it's also a change in

011mindset about making sure we're paying attention to the timing because to that point things are not getting cheaper they're only getting more expensive and so um and we can see that in how we how our budget has been for the last couple years where things that we've budgeted for and said this would be the amount but by the time we're able to actually do it it has a different cost to it right and that's been another part of those factors that have been tearing away at the dollars we have on hand um but I think your point I mean again about us looking at that from uh what do we ask for these next few levies coming up I think we uh were talking a little bit about it last time and I think we're

012going to score next meeting but um what what is the dollar amount that we need to ask for for this at least for this operational L that we have coming up that um includes the preschool promise but also includes some that part of cps's budget great thank you um other thoughts on just uh ask for consideration around those things that come up that are unexpected um throughout the school year so for example right now we are dealing with the surprise of the cost of a detail officer and their hourly rate increasing dramatically and the question is well how are we going to do this because we have to have that support at our various events but we didn't account for that so that's was one lovely example yeah and so in past practice we we've

013had a we build a contingency line into the budget um the last few years we haven't been able to do that because of budgetary challenge balancing challenges but you're right we that we've always had um a sizable contingency to deal with you know um sudden shifts in enrollment where we have to hire more teachers or um Paras surprises like that you know the state coming down and saying you now have to do a third grade guarantee and you're held accountable yesterday and so um those we always had a contingency b line in the budget to accommodate those things so that would be great to build in so and what I'm hearing is that we should go back and kind of think about how to work it into a levy then we'll bring it back here

014before sing it into policy I'd be more comfortable and I because I know our our our inclination is to ask for the least amount of the best amount eight is the magic number yes and I and I think maybe have we have to leave that that thinking uh be because it just is too restrictive for us to to do it I think it's helped us with our credibility with the community and we have a great passage rate for any school district let alone an urban one but uh yeah maybe as we to the chair's point we uh contemplate some of this maybe we ought to be building the fiscally responsible things as well as our operational needs as well and I and again I think from what we would put together from a policy end

015of it I think the hope is that whatever that phase in cycle looks like would be we'd leave ourselves enough leeway in the policy to adjust for things like the levy concerns that we might have or other things that might be other factors that require us to deviate from and I don't know I know at least in the draft that was there I don't know we have anything that would be the deviations or the exceptions or that type of category but I think that might be something that would be helpful yeah we can write a language in there that says you know deviation from this policy must take a majority vote of the board or something like that I don't know yeah because I do think there are situations where and again unfortunately we have

016a wonderful State who loves all public schools uh but there are things that make some C is really winning me over um but that they may put things out there at times where we may not be at cashr stage of which we would then have to be covering or paying for unexpected changes to um things that might happen so think that's another thing that the board would then should make a decision as to whether or not how we would handle that so what guidance do you have um to set the budget Target for fiscal year 26 because right now I'm using a $12 million set aside and we need to get moving I think um because you going to do basically it's an increase each year of it's just 12 million set aside for each

017year based off of the forecast revenues I think you have to wait till the policy passes and it'll pass probably before the budget is done um done but we I had to set a Target in order to start giving guidance on building okay you can set your target but the support of the that policy whether it starts this year versus next year know and I think it probably would be helpful to determine that um if it's also shared then what does that mean um financially in terms of what level of cuts will need to be made and which is better the better decision 12 million and also considering then what that or whatever the target is whatever the target is 12 million or not and then what level of cuts we would then have to

018work through in order to meet that Target yeah so I think and I think for right now if we if we keep the 12 and then we have a bu we have a a board retreat or yes board Workshop that we can finalize that number yes prior to us getting too far into the budget cycle right um so I think that might be helpful and I think we also have at least one board meeting before that um so that may be something we just add to the we can put in to add to the board agenda board meeting agenda to bring the topic up for us to then discuss at The Retreat um because I do think even if we did something where we phased it in different amounts than like even amounts based on

019kind of what we do from a levy ask and that kind stuff um we still need to make some sort of commitment to it this year and so what that commitment looks like maybe we as a board need to make a decision on sooner give you all sure space to make those adjustments yep while we're on that topic I do think it and I don't know what the superintendent has in mind but or any of us do but I I do hope that our uh work session uh on February 1st the vast majority of the time be spent on issues of finance and budget to get us kind of back on track ly yeah um I think we've got Levy decisions that have to be made and long range planning but also a budget and

020budget priority I I honestly I know that we've spent a tremendous amount of time on the growth plan of public time and also administrative time but uh I think if we can really get into the finances and spend that and suggest that to to president mafit I think that would be useful coming from the finance committee and from the treasur and from the superintendent if superintendent feels that that's needed too um the other policy that we had looked at last time was around fixed assets um again I think this was more of a modification or it's just updating some federal to some federal standards and so I think there wasn't any concerns last time I don't believe and so I think that one's one uh starting get copy of it gold but I think that

021might be one just changing amounts and then changing a few words here or there um to reflect what we have to actually keep fix assets um but getting into our I'm sorry so you're okay with the fixed asset goes forward to policy cash balance comes back here yes just making sure and then just make sure we get a copy of the policy to Forman Bolton and Forman cross it's just so they're aware of it as well um I know we presented it at the last yeah I think they're on board dogs but we could double make sure they're emailed yep thank you um and some of like just to be very clear some of this was stuff like the amount that we were supposed to be um you know responsible for as a threshold those

022are things that had we try to match up to the federal standard what language is considered uh like when you get rid of an asset all these type of things that we just being very clear to make sure that they match up to what it's supposed to be done um cool going a new business back to you TR wagy and your team yes so um we're here to present the D what's today February today's January December results sorry you know I'm working in three years at the same time so it's hard to remember what year I'm in um and so I will turn it over to Mr Ashley who gives us start off with our financial reports good morning good morning um so I'll skip past like I usually mention this is kind of a

023summary we include so if someone looks at the report doesn't hear the the presentation they can kind of have an idea of some of those key things but we'll just go through the graphs um this slide shows all funds um where our cash is is sitting at the end of December so you'll see the talk about low point in the year um we're we're waiting very much so for um our County tax advances we did get a small one this week uh but with bills just being mailed this week and do in a couple weeks hopefully in about two weeks we'll see U we'll see a big influx at that point but at this point in December the blue is our operating cash the US Bank general account primarily um that we had at that

024point 44 million uh star Ohio is a little bit less because we've been uh utilizing those funds to meet our obligations uh so it's about 15 million at the end of the year long-term Investments has been pretty consistent about 77 million that redtree manages for us and then debt related that redtree also manages um the I believe that's 39 million for um SN debt syncing funds uh next slide sry does everybody know what debt syncing fund is it's a it's like a saving it acts like a savings account where we make our principal and interest payments into that account so when they principal becomes due the money's already set aside to make that payment does that make sense okay yeah and two of those will mature here soon and then the other one I think

025goes out about six years but um so the next slide is this is US Bank General operating account only so we were just kind of um continuing to show how the Peaks and valleys of that eneral operating account and as you can see we were at about 21 million uh at the end of the year additionally we have access to the SAR Ohio dollars as well uh next slide is uh kind of broken down by fund type uh again you'll see the general funds at 76 million um once we get those tax advances it will Spike up here um in the next month or so um the only one that's negative is the state and federal grants that um basically we're waiting on reimbursements from this Department of Education and Workforce but that's fairly minimal

026at that point again the total is 176.832 million was a general fund cash balance at the end of December uh you'll notice it was higher last year and we footnoted there that's because we did the $75 million in tax anticipation notes that we received in December which uh kind of changed the timing of instead of getting tax revenue in February we got the um we issued those proceeds in December uh next slide this is a three-year history of the cash balance of the general fund again the Peaks and valleys you can see um but where we were at the end of December uh again 76 million just you for a second this is another part of the discussion that we were having with cash Balan is related to the pattern we've seen with these year-to-year

027cash balances how they go down each year with the exception of last year where we had the uh tax anticipation notes which is the reason we had to do the tax an anticipation notes exactly so it's just recognizing that was part of the background the policy uh also note the peaks in July and February is typically when we get our property tax revenues so you have to manage your investments in your cash balance to ensure that June and December don't drop too low [Music] schoolat amounts everything but I think it has been a good planning tool for us um definitely a better communication tool you yeah because we've I think we we've tried to have a better handle on it um especially as those balances do go down for us so um next slide is

028general fund comparing revenues um the third column is the current year the fourth column is the budget uh so we're about 50% to be expected uh our spring settlement's usually a little higher than fall settlement I don't know if it's that people pay a full year and so that all gets distributed in the first half but um we'll see that go up a little bit more too I think once we get that um the other Nuance obviously the pink column as the tax anticipation of last year but when we take that out it seems like every year we have something you know and so we'll continue to have that for forever and ever get rid of school wi pool yeah got go White Pool the pass through funding all that stuff you're smiling so just

029when we think we're past something it's there's always something else but uh next slide again this is three years of history for Revenue just month by month um kind of to give some perspective on that next slide is now moving to expenditures again the third column is the current year 304 versus the budget of 664 um here I'm just breaking down salaries and benefits so salaries and benefits are up about $ 11.5 million um at this point January is a three pay month this year um I'm not sure off top of my head which what it was last year so there could be some timing with that would you mind going back a slide for a second say slide 11 sure yeah I just want to point something out so you see in February and

030March you have a peak one year in February and a peak in March in the another year so we're really at the mercy of the Hamington County auditor as to when they pay us when they collect when they because if they delay bills they delay payment we get our funds late so it becomes even trickier if there's a delay we have to guard against that delay to make sure that we have enough cash to cover oral expenses so I just wanted to point that out that it's not always under our control thank you Kevin sure um so we'll go on to the next slide um again this is expenditures by month um the Peaks and valleys a lot of times are the three pay months um the next slide is the unallocated or unencumbered um

031and just pointing out um about 5.9% of the budget is is technically not encumbered it's appropriated but either is not in a PO form or may never become a PO form if it's a direct payment um but that's fairly consistent with last year um percentage wise and then the next slide is cash yeah guess next slide is mine so as Mr Craig knows we always talk about positive positive cash flow months versus negative um December's a particularly bad one so I will say that but hopefully the idea is January would be a positive cash flow month once we start getting tax advances um only things kind of in here that are out of that are look a little interesting other revenues versus estate share property taxes that looks a little interesting we just had to

032do a correcting journal entry there so deposit the money incorrectly the first time caught it corrected it but it had flipped the month so sometimes when you do these reports every month you have to have to report the the interesting looking things as well um and then on expenses purchase Services were up um over last month and a lot of that was just Transportation invoice was being paid so before we kind of keep moving forward to the next section uh need from this part I just want to see if there any questions keep us going in sure um so the next area is preschool um one of the new slides we've put in the last couple months is just taking the data from preschool to show the buckets for students um and how they allocate

033the funding um the preschool expansion is the levy dollars which are last how we say this Chen I'm sorry last dollar in last dollar in um so you can see these are the different categories that they break them down but any of them that say expansion includes those dollars um at the end of December the total en enrollment in preschool at this a snapshot at this point was 1,940 uh and then the next slide shows traditionally how we've calculated tuition assistance um which will have some changes next year that we'll have to work through um but currently you can see uh 74 741 of those 1900 students receive some level of tuition assistance uh during the month um and one of the things we've highlighted the last couple months is um the EC Grant funded

034seats were increased from 550 to 600 with 120 seats being part of the state full day P pilot so since the levy dollars are last in that's kind of affected these number of students um receiving that benefit and then the next slide is um kind of a a an income statement for the preschool expansion um the middle column 7.4 million in Revenue again we'll see the other tax settlement being posted soon um United Way 4.8 or 4.5 about half of the budget has already been remitted to United Way um and you know continue to overspend that allocation a little bit as we've highlighted each month next slide um again is just kind of visual representation of the number of students that receive some level of tuition assistance um and again it's a little lower this

035year because of those things we mentioned the pilots um and the EC Grant seat changes and that's it for pre there question you do it now you want talk thank you yeah I have a question about preschool um looking at the the uh private providers um last report I mean there's still seems on their view to be preschool and probably we can't answer this in here but uh preschool deserts and I don't know that they identified them geographically but they can can you continue to say that there are some and I don't know if there's a way that we can see what those are we know that there's going to be this renewal uh and I think that the whether or not there remain preschool deserts is part of whether or not the renewal gets

036expanded or Remains the Same uh and and then also again the emphasis that we are not credited for these 1900 kids in our state funding if I'm uh in in the way the other K12 is how does the state help us with preschool funding so the N 1900 um that we get funding for preschool disabilities so there's probably 250 almost 300 students in that 1900 that are funded by the state great um there are um state grants the EC Grant and then there's federal grants Head Start and title one that help with um preschool there's probably six different sources that and and last time I think it we spent about $13 million a year I mean don't quote me on that but um we can do go back and do a holistic analysis again um

037but I have a question about how how do you define a desert exactly and and and I they've used uh a person uh and a group that does their research uh and it might be great to see what that criteria would be the idea is that not not accessible geographically or there's not enough services or enough seats for I mean those are some of the things that's come up but I think it' be great if we all had the same definition where we all did agree or didn't agree that there are uh deserts uh there were when this started there were major deserts throughout uh the district and and I I'm I'm hardpressed to think especially how we have have spread our uh units literally throughout the district uh that why that it would still

038be some deserts and I and I like I think the Public's going to need to know those other sources that you just mentioned the state and the federal uh for the disabilities and what have you so that we are really presenting a fair picture of what the cost of preschool is because I'm starting to hear some Rumblings from other sources that there might not be as much support uh in the in the groups that uh helped uh create this incredible partnership um so uh I just think we need to be really on top of whatever the information is okay I know we had um preschool promised their presentation at our I think it's November meeting or October one of the two um and I do think the issues that we saw a couple years ago

039with regards to uh preschool deserts which were majority of which were where we had more students than we had seats then there necess were there work places that were offering preschool I think that to a certain extent there are still places where and we see it because we have weight lists right we know that we have places in our city where um that's still true um I think superintendent mentioned that we were going to we we be getting a presentation um around some of the work that's being done right now some of the preschool programming I do think it's worth noting our are definitely higher than they were when we first started the effort through the preschool expansion um there are other opportunities being offered like some of the ECE and some that stuff that

040has fluctuated a little bit I think the think we do have to figure out is is there a kind of balance point at which we can support students within the classrooms within the resources we have to put towards them given that we got limited funds on these different pockets and especially given what we would have to make a request for with regards to the levy um because I do think that's the other part of the discussion point is what we budgeted for well exceeds what the levy has allocated for preschool each year and we've been able to do that because we we underspent those first few years well now we're kind of ending the underspent dollars uh but I know superintendent had talked at last meeting about uh them the doing presentation on we do

041have a presentation scheduled for Wednesday the 22nd we are focusing this presentation on CPS preschool classrooms so yes verab will be there to talk about how we're utili using our resources well the only other thought that I just wanted to add on to what you mentioned earlier is I do think the other part that we have been discussing and I think maybe this is Kevin you can give a little bit more of an explanation on this but I think with the change and how some of these dollars are being calculated and figured out and where students fall within and that kind of deal it has presented the challenge of okay so how do you do a comparison of year to year when like we look at what we're funding for this part this year we

042may be only funding this amount but we may be funding more of this part of it well and that's why we started adding the one slide where it has the students and all their different funding sources coures because only isolating on the preschool expansion students it had showed a negative story which wasn't accurate we're still we're still serving 1900 preschoolers right um and so we will um you know plan to do we'll we'll watch Vera's presentation and then um we can follow up in February with a larger Financial picture if needed that'd be great I I do know dating back uh all the way to the very very beginning of the negotiations for this partnership and the first the first request from the public they're always and even coming out of Denver where they're the

043ones that kind of started this whole thing uh there was always a question as to what is the saturation market for preschool because throughout forget our private providers that are part of the network there are many many other private providers through churches and and other organizations and this a fairly conservative place in the country and whether or not there is even an interest in having that 100% of the kids that are preschool age would actually be going to preschool not necessarily in Southwest Ohio or Hamilton County so it it might not be a bad idea to look at some of the demographics too because we may be we may have hit uh where we are uh and and especially I know our big concern has always been to hit the right WR kids meaning the

044kids that would perhaps most benefit from the preschool experience more than perhaps others but um uh it might be interesting to look at some of those demographics of what percentage of that age population is actually partaking and what families are choosing to do this because we're not really aware of all the other uh private opportunities people have uh not just homeschooling but also a a good example is in my neighborhood the Presbyterian Church uh and people want their kids to go to the the the Church Preschool or child care for for some obvious and good reasons I think the other thing uh superintended is that we can do much later because I don't think we would do it right now is one of the things we talked about in the agreements reached with uh CPP

045was to look at the number of students who come from the private cppp uh writers into the district um because we did you know part of the story that I think CVP made and there wonderful video like the video was amazing it was definitely moving that they provided in October but one of the stories they talk about is the kindergart Readiness of students who go through and have preschool education and like how how much they're able to move faster and be more prepared and I think that's a story to also if they're coming to our schools our students are also in that same belt that's that beautiful story that we able to tell for the Levy right that's a beautiful thing that we're able to put out there uh I Know Myself uh Lindy and

046and Dr M were all very like touched by the fact that the you know the kid in the story talks about how great an experience they had um and how so much that built up their next experiences and prepared them for school and like how they look down at their younger siblings and that type of thing is a great story that we have and I think sometimes what we need for these Levy conversations is the story um so it' be great to kind of get a chance to expand that conversation Point all righty well let's keep uh keep it moving now to uh state and federal grants all right the next slide thank you this is our showing our Trend slide um of our spending as you can see we're continuing to trend upwards um

047on our spending we're significantly ahead of Prior years you know because we've just really been spending a lot of time with budget managers and principles and really focusing on trying to get that spending done in the year of the award um that number does represent the initial allocation about of the 55 million it does not include the carryover yet because those funds really just came in November December so really the managers didn't get access to them until you know mid December and not a lot of spending happens then so next slide so this just showed you the breakdown the 58% doeses now include the carryover funds so even with carryover added in um 58% of our of our grants are at or above the 34% Target um again without that it's at 47% I mean

04837% all right the next slide so I went ahead and just brought the carryover numbers I thought that you would be interested in seeing uh the amount of carryover by most of our esca entitlement grants these are our you know majority of of high dollar grants that impact the students so we had about 40% you know increase in our total allocation based on the carryover coming in which brings us up to our 52 million of that I went ahead and broke it down between the nonpublic in the public so you can see about 12% of that goes to our non-public um private schools Catholic schools and so on and so um that's where we're at there might be some slight changes as the state does some reallocations of swept funds but that should be pretty

049close to where we stand for the rest of the year on these major grants all right the next slide so this breaks down our spending um in our major entitlement grants and you know again as reflected in the first slide you can see that we are continuing to spend at a pretty healthy rate um we really jumped in early this year on some of our major grants especially Title One title four and you know we're really just taking this seriously to apply These funds you know to the students that they're awarded to I did include um our 50 our fiscal year 24 carryover amounts in the right and as you remember during some of our previous discussions those are the funds that expire at the end of this year so I like to just keep

050that as a reminder of this is the minimum amount that we would always need to spend in these grants to make sure we don't get swept and um we we really had an amazing year I felt like this year we only had one Grant which was the neglected funds that um were affected by the sweeps this year everything else we spent out timely enough that we kept our money so that's that's always our number one goal and then the next slide um Esser you know pretty much was wrapped up in December we did our final you know rebalancing and spending during December all of our final reports were doing in December it's going to go on I'm sure for a few more years for followup and and audit and things like that but I thought

051it would be useful just to you know take a minute to reflect on the next slide you know what what did we do with all that money we had about $325 million that came into the district and so this is just kind of a really highlevel look at what we accomplished and and how we focus those funds and so you can see the number one um category that we we spent those funds on is facilities so that included several very large additions as well as a lot of Renovations with HVAC and Roofing and things that would impact you know the safety and the health of the students so that was our our largest area following that was technology at 19% and obviously you know as as it first hit us and we moved to remote

052learning we had a lot of Technology needs to get devices in the hands of students and so that kind of makes sense and then the third area which was one of of the board's goals was to protect Staffing not to lose Staffing you know over um the situation that we were in so the third category was Staffing and then on the next slide um I felt like it would just kind of be interesting to see by the three primary um grants so these are just the actual Esser um large things to see kind of how our shifting shifted our spending shifted over the year so the first you know Esser funds which came in at 20 million during that time we were just in response mode of you know how to how to really deal

053with the crisis and so it makes sense that a lot more of that money was spent on health and safety because we were just trying to get our you know our facilities in a in a safe place then as we shifted into sr2 you know that one kind of covered both periods where the students were doing remote learning and then starting to come back to school and so the focus there really was on Staffing and on the technology of making sure the kids had what they needed to be able to complete their lessons at home and then really as we kind of moved into Esser 3 which you know all of these grants kind of overlap a little bit but really s or three a lot more um the kids and the students were coming

054back to school and so those funds are targeted a little bit more towards learning loss and you know just catching up from the the impact of of covid and so it's um you can kind of see where the money went that it was kind of Shifting as our goals and our intents shifted over that time and so that's that's pretty much it I just thought Esser deserved a kind of a send off yeah on the district these will be the last s was f um I particularly like the rest in peace uh I would say these three or four charts that you just shared with us it might be the last presentation in in finance but these are going to have to be be core parts of any renewal request we're making about anything because

055the public that's the first or third question is what did you do with the Esser funds and the way you've laid it out the percentage is interesting but the timing shows actual accountability it shows that there was planning it wasn't just you know having the fan on and throw the money in the air these are this is this is bedrock for the public to understand what it is and I don't know I'm going to believe that you're saying all this is true but I'm telling you showing it in that time as to the the function and the timing of the function makes complete sense and it will help and that the spending rules changed as time went on and and I think you say something like they constantly r that there were these criteria I

056I really think that you're going to one of the n one of the one of the Bedrock one of the planks of passing all these levies and renewals that are coming up is going to be to prove how we did how we spent the Esser so keep this in mind when we get to the just ask genen schedule because your way to work that in I I I wrote just ask genen on the thing when this is this is it'll be just sjan and an absolutely great job that's very important stuff because people still are want it's like 25 years of lisening well what did you do with the with the uh uh gambling money what did you do with the lottery money yeah that7 all switch soal bait and switch but I but it's

057it's part of the legend just like this Esser money now is going to be used to tear us down we can't let it so um as Nan talked about carryover money is in the grant it's time for us to do an Appropriations resolution revision to allow us to spend the money that's coming in um we will also be um so Kevin's handing out a draft we'll also be asking for an increase in the general fund by a half a million dollars because we need to pre start ordering stuff for the growth plan furniture and lockers and stuff like that and um we just don't have space in the current budget to do next year's buying so it'll be a small increase to the general fund to help kick off the growth plan so that we're

058ready when school opens questions um no I mean I think you know again understanding that it's always nice carry over money and get it out get it out the door um so and again I think I maybe want to highlight one little thing that we also were a little bit because we talked about it month after month but the percentage of funds that we are now spending on time or before schedule is huge and I think this growth and I know Dr moff she was here with you know with tell the question she asked here but I I honestly do believe it's really because there is a change in mentality about how we spend dollars that had really taken grip in a lot of the schools and a lot of the different folks who have

059budgets because there was that mentality of we wait till the end of the year so that we could spend all the dollars you know make sure we have enough money at the end of the year to make it through and it was like well then you get to the end of the year and you can't spend it all because you waited so long to do so right so we've transitioned into that and then at the end of the year we're saying no you can't do spend the money no you can't do that no you can't reject reject reject so we're taking that conversation to the beginning to say let's plan alongside of you so we can figure out how best to use this fund and when but I think it touches into how the carryover

060dollars though I mean to your point about we've only had one fund that's been touched or been swept away is because of the fact that we are making an active effort to spend better throughout the year so that we get to this end while we may have some carryover funds that exist for other reasons right we're not having you know if we had a $5 million Grant we're not having three million of it still sitting there at the end of the year we're having some of that spent and so and the only reason that got swept was because we had what four budget managers in three years over that Grant and they just couldn't get educated fast enough to spend the money um but any any other part uh with regards to us taking the

061steps to um add in the funds to cover the necessary things I I you know again we we as a board voted to do it so we have to make sure we're able to support it and funded um so I think you know again this be brought to the board next next meeting board meeting or 27 this the 27th okay yes all right thank you so we're moving on to in the slides to return on investment and so this is being this is the first meeting of the year um we wanted to have a discussion about what topics we wanted to see and get them scheduled and so Cody went and did um a request from colleagues and leadership team members to say what are you interested in seeing us analyze for return on investment

062and you take it from there Cody yeah absolutely next slide Mr Rob so like like Jen said we we did it like the you see in the column uh request origin the Google form is what I use to send out get some response and get some feedback on different topics what we didn't want the ROI efforts to be was a financially dictated decision but more of a collaborative effort across the Departments and across the district to educate the public and educate ourselves on the different topics of return on investment as this process grows um really looking at Roi as a whole it's not just the opportunity to make educated budget decisions that is a huge part of it but also a lot of these and what I'm trying to work with budget managers on is

063establishing that process of Roi what does that look like in your program do we have the tools now do we need tools do we need data what do we have how can we collaborate and build that relationship together that further makes these budgeting decisions easier in the future um I think some people hear the word Roi and they immediately like well if my Roi is not good they're getting rid of my program that's not necessarily the case um that can be a decision made by leadership and the board in future decisions but right now it's building that process building that relationship getting that understanding and seeing where we're at with the data and and using those decisions to make or using that data to make um smart budgetary decisions so I was very impressed by

064some of the different topics that came out some things I never even thought of like the international balette program that was a topic that got brought up or um the internal versus external tutoring so just looking at different things and the opportunities that are there um I also wanted to say that um Emily and Michelle if um if your union leadership have ideas you're welcome to add topics as well absolutely yeah um the that's why I went ahead on the first slide put tentative in case anybody had different ideas or we had ongoing input um some of these depending on the meeting schedule we can double up topics as we as we grow in our process and really just get that feedback from the public and from the board UNS the first two topics actually

065came out of finance committee at the last one so um we'll put those first Y and the next slide Mr Rob I think Miss Bolton has a question oh I'm sorry just I think it's right to ask the union leadership uh for their participation and if I think it wouldn't be a bad idea also to ask board members yes uh to from a standpoint to submit I I see things here the board members would say for sure but there might be some other things that might be of uh interest so and I think that'd be a great you know interchange an exchange so but thanks for doing this think to maybe if we send out something to the board just also list the ones we've already exactly um because I will say this has been

066a both a labor of probably of love and frustration at times over this past year because I plead the fist uh and and a lot of learning though because we we did a few of these where what we recognized and appreciated the thought beforehand was oh we can do this because we can figure out what this value is and then as you go to look at the comparison especially things where we looked at per School spend on stuff you started to recognize that okay well certain school do things so differently that it's not a fair comparison say this is the dollar per school for this or maybe high school was different from elementary school SP and I know that was one of the things we looked at on a few of these especially social workers

067some these others where we have a do we have a number we're going to do in the unit but that fluctuates so hard by how many uh right kids are in the school and what the school needs so right these efforts aren't about gotas and and like Cody said it's more of a collaboration because it could be an opportunity well we didn't get enough funding to finish the stuff right or um something happened to prevent us from getting things done so it's more about problem solving and continuous Improvement but there's also a huge component on educating the public on why we spend money on the things that we spend money on and how impactful it is so it's very positive experience I will also say and I know we have one more that I think

068we're still gonna hit on which is the uh under uh 200,000 vendor but I will say having the different departments come in and talk about how they've making decisions with regards to how they're picking vendors what the vendor value has been what are the kpis that they indicated that have been successful things to do I mean I think we had a wonderful discussion when we talked about some of the facility spending correct that really was fuing board members into why okay so we trying to be both Green in how we do things but also not have 12 vendors right providing a product that one could provide or having you know Chang the model of which we order stuff in advance so that you have it on stock and not ordering it the order uh it's

069a wonderful conversation that I think uh my friends at UC should be having but but those are things that I think we greened a lot of value out of hearing the explanation even you know having um I think the conversation we had with that was like an amazing conversation around how are they using our dollars in here how are they trying to do better to be a more green more energy conscious absolutely um because that was a commitment of the of the board in the district but also recognizing we don't want to do like we have to use a certain vendor because trying to do these three others where none of them could provide this this particular tool didn't make sense so absolutely giving some of those that you've already Ed yes sir as you

070kind of get some of the also the ones that we may have new ideas for for I do think that's the big one of the big themes is what to decentralize and what to centralize we if we could come to grips with what we think needs to be decentralized and what needs to be decentralized I think there's savings and productivity in the millions if we would come to grips with that and and I don't know when that happens or how that but you all have laid a good ground to have that make some sort of fun and outsourc versus insource but absolutely um so be it's a really it's a organizational philosophical decision about sight based management versus site based decision- making um I don't think our schools are equipped to do SC based management

071for every operational topic that there's there um and hence centralized enrollment right um and so those are conversations that we look forward to having well and that's again we're looking at the work Saturday that's the kind of conversation the board could convene around and have some discussion about The Out Source and in source and we've talked about it for a long time and been a target for a couple of years a matter of fact the you brought it as part of the the budget Target I think two fiscal years ago particularly and then the other centralized and decentralized that's I think that would be a great discussion and it should inform this coming budget yes we do have a process in place that evaluates insource versus outsources as the opportunities arise and um and then

072but I I look forward to the centralization versus decentralization conversation think the one of area that I think Cody and you probably hit some of the ones that we're going to talk talk through uh future topics of discussion but I we had a kind of I guess a longstanding thought process around per students versus per school um looking at costs and and expenses that way and I do think part of the thing we've learned in some ways on this R and looking at these rois is some things we do because we have to do it right so like we can sit there and say utilities per building and like look at the cost of utilties for building we ain't got an option unless we're don't really go green and have no electricity in the building

073right we don't have an option on that end but there were other things that we looked at like assistant principles like um some of those areas we were looking at whether or not what we've added has been of value and and and how we're using it is it's the best value students out um and so I imagine some things like some of the transportation costs we we've looked at that from a bigger picture but never looked at it from an Roi picture which will be an interesting one that um but I specifically the Yonder pouches discussion is um y discussion per School may be another one of those things where we may see that it's been really effective and some schools have they give one pouch and every student keeps over their pouch you that

074kind of deal another schools where we have these different things that might be happening with whether not students keep them or whether not students you know machines or that type de all those are things we can have that I think would be interesting to see I just don't know what the discussion looks like until we have it and so it' be great to have stuff like that so the per student U cost is a a philosophical disagreement with me and Edom Ed genomics wants to do everything by student but I think it's misleading to the public when if you look at um technology leases for example they don't all go to students there's adults that are involved so I think that we need to stop and think about which is the what's the right denominator

075to use in order to evaluate because um if you do everything by student I understand why they're saying they're coming from they want to do it comparatively I still think it's misleading and it may it may lead you to a different conclusion we like schedule dollar where you know if you did schedule Dollar by by per student you end up with some schools actually getting less dollars than they you're getting now and then some schools who don't have the programming getting more dollars rather than kind of looking at what you're doing in the program and saying this is the allocation so it is sometimes helpful to see pursuing but also maybe important to look at whether or not that's the right measure for that particular item I think we did something important when we dealt

076with the aps at smaller schools that was a bigger decision than I think we fully realize the cost of small schools is UNS stainable and we have had that for 15 years in part in part because of the magnet system and I think that per school and that per student while it can't be the Panacea it really it it is a it is a um it's as close as you're going to get to some sort of rudimentary Equity effort um and even these schools that have are in the process of changing now have been among our most expensive schools and very frankly we don't like to talk about it but also from a performance standpoint you it's it's obvious that this there's a there's not necessarily a uh a connection between the amount of money

077you're spending and the results that you're getting why is that that shouldn't be the case but it is and so I this whole capacity thing the whole enrollment piece all of this has really I think uh kind of been the nut of the whole uh as we prepare for the future it's it's been interesting oh if you think about it the whole capacity conversation is a return on investment absolutely right no question absolutely okay so Cody has up there a a list for future topics he can include that in the thing to the board so everybody knows what where the things are coming from um and you know we're happy for that conversation to go forward and again we always also appreciate for you Cody uh giving you the time to actually be able to

078get these get this information because I do know that's the other challenge is we're sending Cody out to like 85 different areas expertise and so oh well he's getting a good education somebody's got to do it right educated while working two birds one stone it's good for my future and good for our future so I think the next one uh is the community reinvestment act agreements uh we have three three this month yeah and again LLC names continue to get more and more creative as we go but so much better LMC right so much better um but pretty St pretty standard things here um you know commercial space a hotel commercial and office space rental residential the usual don't really have a lot to say adding to our enrollment cor yeah pretty much Z pretty

079much zero chance any of these Adar enrollment so um so then the next on there is the new policies that we kind of started to talk about uh last month um we talked a little bit about cash balances so but um we want to walk through the other new policies that we have been that kind of came up at the last meeting and we said we keep talking about them walk through some ideas skip to yeah Rob would you skip the slide 40 please thank you sir so we'll start I think with age student fees um so this is the second time this has come up we have revised data um revised as of last night data so I will say this is this has been quite the data project for for our financial technology

080team to pull from so so kind of just to set the stage so for years I mean before I got here years um we used a system called pay schools or pay for it to to assess and collect student fees and it was linked to our power school student information system when we um switch to focus to start this school year Focus also has a student fee module which is which is really I think a nice thing for the parents because it gives them a One-Stop shop you know one One log in to get in to see your students you know information as well as to pay any fees so so I think that's going forward is very nice but the issue we have is bringing over the old and age fees from from pay

081schools into Focus um and obviously it's timely right now because there's a lot of 2025 seniors who who are thinking about graduation and their parents are calling the schools and saying Hey I want to make sure we're paid up you know I want to make sure we're paid up before my kid graduates which we appreciate so in Pay schools there's about $5.5 million dollar worth of un unpaid fees and part of this part of this is the conversation about the write-off policy which we don't have at this point so so we've never written anything off there are ways to weigh fees um so usually students get fees weighed um for economic hardship um also you know schools from time to time away phase um what we what we kind of looked at we looked through

082the data was okay we pulled this data out of P schools dug through it there's a like $1.8 million of these fees are things that are obsolete like obsolete fee types Clos schools like there are things that you know there're schools that we don't that we haven't had open in 10 years right give the Burton examp yeah like like hphy for Burton like like okay so so trying to find the person that was associated with who's probably you know in their mid-30s now and try to get them back to pay a fee for a closed School could be quite difficult um there are inactive students as well so a lot of students who' left the district it's actually the mass majority and this is where this is where kind of the data update happened that

083we worked on is initially we looked at it um we looked at students it was all students and then we came back and looked at just active students so the vast majority is fees assessed to inactive students who are no longer CPS and then there's about $4 million of fees out there that are for current students attending attending one of our schools and we'll stop there for questions so um just a comment so we're recommending that we wave the obsolete fees because the likelihood of us collecting that is probably next to nil the the question on the inactive fees which is what 9.6 million is that what that says up there um does the board want us to spend efforts trying to collect those fees before we write them off or are we um good

084at writing them off because they're inactive students and we would spend a lot of money chasing these people down just looking for some feedback I think the other kind of point of clarity and I don't know if it's in I know we did we talked about it last time around but like some of these fees date back like to 2006 pre 2002 where they were just fees that would never collected at any point in time um so I mean I think to your point there may be some folks in that inactive student list to may have been gone for several years now in the efforts to try and go get that fund from family and they could have been collected and somebody just didn't Market in the student file we don't know but it would

085take a horrendous amount of effort to investigate all that so I think there's I think there's two points here so one is the actual that we need a policy to deal with that's something we have to pour on but I think the more pressing question of the current situation is uh for the inactive students is that something we would recommend waving at this point um I Rec I recollect from uh policy committee two years ago that the the real discussion was whether or not to have fees at all correct and so we waved the district white fees and then this year we did not charge any right but the schools still charge their own fees and I think that that's part of the conundrum we have a slide on that yeah yeah if you it's

086ahead it just it um whatever we're whatever we're spending or whatever we're I should say charging for what uh and and I I just think that in a district like ours there's some there's some justification for a feess district so if you look at this Slide the top two lines up there are related to tuition so people are not they're paying tuition because they're required to either they live State and if they're not paying tuition that we should not be have them enrolled because we're paying for their education without getting a revenue and so I don't see tuition as a fee okay okay so we will chase those down um the miscellaneous fees I don't I what to say about that loss and damage items intercessions there's $870,000 due for intercession fees the of course

087I don't necessarily believe in intercession either so there you go that's kind of the corner the mon I totally understand I know that even better than you do the grade level fees are the the district level fees right yes level fees are your District fees that's the biggest bucket yeah obviously like you said we stopped collecting new fees but we didn't do anything at the prior fees and and to be for the folks in this room who know how this works generally when it comes time to graduate you know that's when it happens you know the conversation happens and a lot of times the conversation is oh my kids have free and reduced lunch for the entire 13 years this parent fills out a form and then we end up waving you know 13 years

088worth of or 12 to 13 years worth of those and four days of bad publicity yes and four days of bad publicity so we're gonna we're working on a proposal to recentralize the student fees superintendent Murphy and I talked about this about a week or so ago um because clearly the schools are don't have the ability ility to necessarily collect them on a timely basis um and um uh Dr Moffett ask us well are you sending out statements and communicating with the parents well the school fees are based the schools collect the fees we weren't involved right so if we recentralize it then we can start doing using the system to establish you know invoices and statements and reminders and that kind of stuff moving forward so we but we do need to figure out

089what fees does does the board want us to charge um so um what we're trying to do is just clean up the data wave the stuff that hasn't been collected and then move forward with the fresh I think the other thing we talked about last time kind of opening the discussion out was there were you know again it's a small portion of things that are like lost damage items there small portion of things that are you know to Like Preschool tuition or out District tuition or things like that um and that part yes like those are things that in some ways we may have a hard time collecting from folks who have been away from the district for five 10 years to be like hey you remember that book you lost that was $12 or

090whatever that you're now charging the speed for um but I do think as we go forward and this is maybe to where the policy end of it needs to be we do have folks who you know routinely we don't want people to sit and wait till their senior year to start talking about those costs because they'll stay on our books to to look at and have to deal with every year rather than trying to encourage folks to make those you know affirmative statements or those things earlier in that process so that your kid is not getting X Y and Z or that we're not looking at it and saying how come you haven't paid for X Y and Z or done X Y and Z also when when the school's collected in the senior year

091are they taking an elementary value give back to elementary school right yeah so yeah there's a lot of complex it's just an impossible thing that that's important why I think the policy end of it which is May yes we focus on age student fees but also maybe thinking about um when do we consider something to be aged right so is it a year or two no as opposed to 12 years as opposed to 15 20 years because I mean again the stuff in the list went back to like before I worked at the district after law school so I was like good gosh who never collected debt or but but they may have and that's another part of the conversation we' having about this is not working centralizing certain aspects and certain tools that gets

092a lot into that discussion as to what the policy needs to kind of encapsulate right because policy may be specifically for if the policy focus on folks who are no longer in the district than HBS or folks who have left or graduated I don't know we're going to get any different Behavior no but if we maybe look at that two to five year whatever that window is how many years is considered to be aged we may get people who are still in the district who are still current students who we can start to really change the behavior this communication with the parent to say hey you're on year four of not paying for your student when they damag the chemistry lab equipment well we need to then you have the challenge of you know child

093is with us preol through sixth grade they leave the district go inactive they owe fees we write them off they come back in ninth grade and graduate with exactly so um there's a whole lot of complexity work p in a school district like Wyoming you can collect fees because those kids are there and you'll see them next year or you'll teach their parents and they wa to fee you ow a fee and you got a kid in the school now so this is just an impossibility I think but going to a completely Fess Society is going to hurt some of our schools because they collect a signif some our schools collect a significant amount of money to use towards their expens they need to be funded better I guess I don't know this is I

094think that's the reality that that's a board decision we have to decide whether or not we want to get rid of all fees as we sit we have fees and we need to decide what we want to do with those fees for things U because I also think there's some ways that some of these things with fees also create people's good behavior so if you think I don't have to do anything because nothing will ever happen absolutely I'm G just keep doing what I'm doing um and I know that that's like for a good portion of uh some of our non school grade level fees there is this pattern of trying to create responsibility with you keep up with something give you a device and one of the conversations we had about the the oneone

095devices was that how many of these one1 devices are people using but then how many that was a telling yes keep up with or they coming back to us and saying so my laptop doesn't work anymore a new one um and that's I mean again I think that's a certainly a conversation point to have as to what we charge fees for us and what we look at it and once we kind of that's a separate conversation from what we do with if we still have fees what are those fees when they're aged but um I think it also you have a slide on here also with regard to grade level I think it's very interesting um while a good portion of them hey sorry sorry to interrupt uh Dr Moffett sent a message the entire

096Board needs to have this discussion should this be referred to on the January 27 meeting for discussion thank you okay what J what well so seven no the policy needs to go to policy whether not we do a waving of the fees we can totally maybe have that discussion um so I'll send her something after the meeting you let her know but uh yeah the waving of fees the board can make a decision about but the policy policy after it's been defined yeah um but if you go to the next slide Rob I just want to highlight just the real quick where those are updated data there yeah so presents a very different picture when the act the active data is updated yeah um but the I think it's one more maybe the pie chart

097yeah yeah next slide I think the pie charts to what Char wag was actually just talking about also which is are these fees technically high school fees or they just high school students have fees based on these things that have accumulated exactly um because then you know you could see 9 to 12 you get certain fees because of things you're doing yes but also could you have fees because you just stop paying on things they keep moving up the ladder with you right so the $6.2 million that are grade signed to 12 how much of it was prior to n ninth grade yeah yeah there's an updated version of this one too Rob if you'll go one slide wow oh my Lord right there that's my that's the answer there's the pie that that that

098it's impossible oh yeah that's Beau if a pie chart has more than six sections or pieces just forget it but that's again like that that's part of the struggle that we we would have things a stained glass window so I do think we can add the the waving of the inactive fees and then the um the obsolete fees to the board agenda I will do that as a in the treasures report as a line item for you to vote on perfect awesome um and then the other fees we'll have to kind of the other fees of current students which is now four million I believe it said um I think that's just something for we to talk about as a board as to what we want to do with fees but then also from a

099policy end what is our uh age student fees policy going to look like um we had the right off ofs yes next [Music] slide I think this is second time around um this obviously this bolon first time you've seen it so we've had this is this is bigger than just a bigger it's different it's bigger but also different than student Fe so we have other fees we charge folks okay um you know just for different things whether it's you know people take Cobra benefits or you know trying to get money back from employees with their payment issues um we do not have a way to write these off currently even if legally we can't collect so we have a few people who file bankruptcy we can't collect but we can't write it off so we're

100stuck with this money on our books and so this policy would just allow us to move forward and so um I know there a proposed text I know we um certainly rob you want to click on the link to the proposed text I know part of what we and we talked about this last time part of what we really stressed in this is there were examples of this where it was like very low dollar amount that it would have been so much more for us to go in even if we could collect it good money after bad you know we're spending more money to collect the dollars we're actually getting didn't make a whole lot of sense um so policy there again I don't want to speak since we don't have Jim here I think

101we can wait till the next meeting till Jim to get a chance to it over also um but it's not I don't think there was anything in here that was significantly alarming about what we would do um biggest probably question marks were about what's the dollar amount that is the amount we say you can write off you know the authorities off but next policy next policy is reimbursements employee reimbursements in per Dam so again it's kind of kind of second time through so so CPS we we do kind of the worst of Both Worlds so so we reimburse people we reimburse people up to the GSA amount plus we require receipts so GSA amount is an amount general service Administration sets pretty much across and most companies use it to say it basically says okay

102how much does it cost for someone to have meals in Cincinnati right it's like $68 is their GSA limit most companies a lot of government use that for traveling because it's simple and it's across across the country um and then obviously different cities like L LA is higher you know New York would be higher based on based on the cost of living there um but yeah we we go up to that limit but then we also make you ride your seats so so we hit you both ways most a lot of our peers um just do a straight per dmgs El so so we're not as Carol Smith says we're not the food police so we're not looking at your Olive Garden receipt to see you know see if you see what meals you had

103to make sure you didn't spend enough we're not checking to see how much you tipped that was not an endorsement of olive Gard we're not checking to see how much you tipped your server you get a flat amount for your meals for the for those days that you're traveling that's what you're reimbursed you know no receipts no back and forth no I mean if you want to if you want to go have you know a very extravagant dinner that's great this is the amount you get reimbursed rest the rest of it would be on you um and it's just a lot cleaner it saves an incredible amount of time not only um Treasures office staff but also everyone who travels who has to keep all those receipts and make sure they're legible and not spill

104water on them and turn them in and they have to be reviewed and reconciled all that so our our ask would be that um policy 3440 is coming up um for normal regular review as part of policy is to add a sentence in that allows us to switch from complete reimbursement to perdm and this is a topic that actually was raised during audit committee meeting as well and that it just is a very labor intensive sure task for I believe it's just one person right that does a review of all two actually and expenses and it takes a lot I mean the accountants are involved and and Carol and and other people in the AR are involved and it's just it's a lot it's just a lot of like it's like unfortunately it's a lot

105of petty fights like one thing we don't currently reimburse for is meals within the greater same metro area so if you're if you're at CVG get ready to fly out that meal is not reimbursable so then someone calls and says okay I understand that but what if when I'm on the plane can I order can I order food on the plane while I'm flying well we all know how Airline meals are you know which one's better for the person you know we all know which one's cheaper yeah you know I mean so it's stuff like that just a lot of extra work I think the other thought with this is you know again both getting more efficient with how we do these things and getting more consistent um but I think one thing I would

106make sure that we have is whatever system we were using to do to to do the designation up prum that we're so like for instance at UC if I go somewhere and I get a PDM I have to mark off what meals I'm getting funded for right like not just a straight daily prum because I do think that also gets a little bit into if I leave at noon do I get breakfast yeah and like that stuff I mean that whatever process we're using to allow folks to make those decisions and determinations to get um is done in a way so that it's simply done and easy to understand all right so we'll see if go ahead how this is how does it pertain to Transportation meaning uh cab rides shuttle rides this is for

107meals this is strictly for meals meals and incidentals okay and incidentals okay and then how does this how do we know that the public dollars are not being used by the person to buy alcohol you don't no okay it's a I I got you but is there some law about alcohol and the expenditure of of so the one public dollars the one difference also with doing per Dum is that you would not be putting it onto your PE card yes so like this would be an amount that you would get given as opposed to you taking your peard using it and then having to bring the receipt back and show that this is what I use my peard on right um and just note that this is the same policy that odw uses well of

108course they are never my Champions I understand or my role models but yeah I'm just I'm just saying from the alcohol piece I didn't know if that's law about public dollars I didn't and I didn't know about the transportation this is strictly for meal for DM yeah this is meals incidentals and it is yeah it is p and incidental is a pop a snack because that's another thing they tend to be more expensive in the hotels anyway the meal thing we don't pay for if you if you're thirsty and you want to good the pot machine well it's on you so yeah and so because because the employees paying the employee it's not yeah public dollar public dollar being paid to the employee and then they have kind of the flexibility it'll save board staff

109their ethical Behavior so Lauren I just gonna add I may have said this at the last meeting when this was discussed but I do believe it will uh lessen our audit risk as well because we have fewer transactions going through PE card less uh material that we as a district need to process and less transactions our external audits we'll have to choose from Rob if you'll go two more slides please so just we don't have to spend a lot of time this this just oh next one please that's kind of the flowchart of how it would work just like that the pie chart if you if you if pie chart if there's more than six and this for a flowchart if there's more than eight get rid of it that's three separate processes we went

110from five boxes to four I think that's a win congratulations I do think and again I think this is another one like the policy itself will be something that is very efficient to bring us less it brings us more consistent with how we do stuff around around the district but I think the other part for me is the back and forth of disputes is also what is part of that timec consuming part and I know that was when we looked at it from an a committee standpoint yeah like the person bringing you the wrong rece that's not itemized on there so you don't know what is on so now you got to go find out what you did or I remember my own example getting a parking receipt and like having to figure out okay

111did they give me the right receipt when the machine didn't work with the receipt who do I call like these type of things when you're doing food gets really complicated especially for folks who are going for multiple days of a travel so there's an education component here because it's the employees going to be using their own credit card or the cash you know but but and then get reimbursed and so they um that's going to be a culture change for people for for some folks roll out too of just we have new policy once the policy is in you know informed when it starts doing some stuff beforehand to get sure everybody's own taxs and understanding um that's not different than any we change other policies so are we okay with moving this toward to

112policy I don't yeah I could almost Go the whole board probably we pretty sure the board would love um I believe that is the last of our uh policies yeah um a party going on outside u fun to work as CPS so the other topic should just be real quick but um the first on the budget timeline is that we did send the initial Staffing out graph Staffing out on January 10th it went through a a pretty quick preliminary view because of the compressed timeline to get to the deadline and so they right now the Staffing appeals process is underway for people to say this is an error I don't you know we disagree with this we need something else so that ends on the 23rd um and then the appeals team will review and

113finalize items and then transfer rounds begin after that so um any questions on timeline what what formula are we using to determine the Staffing the same formulas we've been using for the last 20 years and that one is um I mean that's 25 to 1 at K to3 32 to 4 to 6 and 78 and 912 is done by a team of people that know High School scheduling that's good I the reason I say that if you'll recall one of the very earliest of our super long meetings I think when superintendent Wright was here and we had to go through that awful line item by line item night and voting and it was like 1:00 in the morning if I recall and that was just leaving the building that wasn't even getting home I know

114that we had a long discussion about budgeting and Staffing at the top of the range for class size and I know that there was discussion now we have a different Administration but the there was there was discussion that indeed there was going to be an effort to move toward the lower numbers of the range because it's it seems really weird to me that actually and I can't say anything about any contract because we're in negotiations but my point is it's almost as though we we have bigger class sizes because of the actual possible con contractual language and ranges that it provides us as we staff I do think the discussion though started from we don't have full Staffing even at the high number so we need more Staffing for the low num so like the

115idea was that to F it what we know from this year is we still didn't fill all the spots we had opened right so I mean I think there is a reality to say we can make efforts to get towards those worlds we' have to hire people and have budget to hire people for those roles um I do think one factor though that will probably affect what next year's numbers actually end up looking like not basically what we've budgeted for is what we end up negotiating as far as contractual language so while we are put budgeting and put putting together ideas and that kind of deal I think we are longterm going to have to think about um you know in each of the schools what it looks like what what are these things going

116to look like from a past this year's budget or next year's budget I should say discussion um because in theory we are not getting new Revenue in fact some ways we're probably getting less less um per student and so um that is something that certainly the class size is is a topic I think maybe more nuanced from that sense of what does each level of schooling need what does each School need right based on resour stud um but it's something we definitely as a board can have that discussion around um as we look at budget discussions at our at our Workshop but I think for right now we have to kind of work with what we have is the standard that we until we change the standard until we get any formulas right um I'm

117all in favor of those new formulas and those are not necessarily the district invented formulas those are contractual formulas those are contractual form that's correct ranges I should say and so if I remember correctly when we looked at last year of changing the minimums it was 13 million doll increase there's 112 more teachers or something like that um and so what that which is great that if that's a priority of the district that's priority of the district but that $13 million is going to come out of central office or or operations somewhere or other choices to be made I mean so but we're not being afforded that choice and and rightfully and I won't say rightfully so but I'm just I'm just saying that might be a choice people want to make uh and indeed

118it might be that uh across the board and this is the point is that the class size at a at one of our high schools may not be the right class size at another one of our high schools or elementaries for the very reason that you know it uh I I do though I do think though having that discussion as to class size also must start with did we employ the folks to be in a r because we end up with a class of 62 because we had to put a bunch of people in the room we don't have teachers for that class we're not actually doing class out in either right so I think there is a conversation point to have around what is our goal from a negotiation conversation and then there's also

119the point of we need to find people we need to hire people we need to put people in somebody's roles because certainly elevates for equipment and in some ways this past Year's budget or this current Year's budget we formulated with the understanding that we weren't going to be able to fill certain roles and I think reality is if we did fill them and had full Staffing we wouldn't have had the space in some ways to do certain things we did so it is a conversation point of where do we pull dollars from where do we move dollars here where do we make our priorities which is leading into the last part of with our budget Workshop planning that's stuff that I do the Board needs to be upfront with the superintendent and the treasur about

120because if we come in and say this is our priority and then we later come back and say hey superintendent now we really want you to have this part is our priority so get rid of something else as not fair to superintendent or the treasure and how they're trying to put together our long-term budgets and which is kind of I think what we've unfortunately been stuck with doing at times is because we haven't made the hard decision of I really emphasize that we should really spend the vast majority of Saturday talking about some of these big issues philosophical as well as implementation and budget priorities we we've gone through almost three months or three years of the the budget part gets kicked to the bottom uh or not done uh and um I mean we

121tried to re recoup a little bit but I I just think it wouldn't be a bad idea to get our brains around that and and make that suggestion If U to the president so so the notes I took for the workshop work session agenda or Workshop whatever we're calling it is budget Levy Central centralized versus decentralized insource versus Outsource class size cash set aside and then I know the superintendent has a list of budgetary priorities um for next year fantastic and I think this speaks a little bit to we talked about it the December meeting but I think it's good to refresh we are taking the approach this year of looking at everything from a like going back to zero and saying build your budget based on okay first start with what are your mandatories

122like your things you have to spend money on and then now we look at priorities of what's the next levels of spending and so that's helpful when us having that discussion at the workshop we'll be able to kind of give let do that you uh because I think that was the other part of us trying to do it without having that starting point is that everybody just took their previous year budget and said well I'm doing exact same things I did last year plus there's no we can't we can't we can't afford it you know and and then the political scene is they want to take more money away from public education so um we can't you've heard me say this before we can't continue to business the way we're doing it and stay out

123of cash trouble hallelujah amen using the same formulas will get us into trouble seriously we cut so much out of central office this year that we are struggling to serve our customers you can't continue to squeeze down central office you will become non-compliant y well this is an old publication as we had to change offices it's from 2002 and it highlighted Houston and Milwaukee and Cincinnati about budgeting the zero base student base uh three Innovative districts and and uh it might not be a bad to go back to some of our Roots two but true student based budget doesn't work in a district with high mobility throughout the year and that's what got us in you know we had schools that ended up at alone had borrow money from the district to finish out the

124year and so um yeah going back to student needs yep and students yes instead of class size this is great this is all cool stuff fun discussion for us great um last major topic that we had is just the just ask Jen upcoming yeah so we um excuse me yes so we uh we had to cancel January 7th because of weather White death um and um so W word so that that was going to be on how do we spend our money but that could easily be rolled into the the budgetary you know instead of looking at current year look at next year so we're good with that so the next one is scheduled for federal grants title one we can sneak in the Esser conversation into that one rest in peace we can do

125sort of a durge drum be yeah everybody we everybody we yeah okay oh um and we we can have background music Rob thank you go New Orleans sou New Orleans that's um in March we were going to talk about the treasure dashboard and our performance measures and then the the role of the internal audit function and how it's important to The District in April we wanted to invite some of our legislators in to talk about the impact that their behavior has on financial districts for the the Gen thing just as gen yes okay because I know that the uh well as vice president Weinberg is was lining up that uh legislative uh breakfast or something so let's look at that okay makes sense and that was a topic that was offered by Dr the time

126yes or it came from somewhere beyond yeah um and then the May um we actually discovered through superintendent Murphy that actually conflicted with graduation ceremony oops um and so they I've offered other dates and I don't know when finance committee members would be available we might want to wait for Mr Cross to come back before we pick that um and then the last one being the handoff that's cool we'll have to have tissues what's that I didn't hear you what was that for that um yeah I think I will need a box of tissues no you will you will you'll be a mess three more months work um last thing just done it at each of the meetings before just covering some topics we talk about next meeting one is the work plan for the

127committee we've revised work plan last year to kind of update and make sure we were kind of looking really at some of the but and also think stuff we don't do there is a version of this from last year's work plan that is on board do for folks to check out we'll also need start looking at Levy because we got to have a conversation on what the levy will be what the dollar amount we're going to look for what we want to do with it Y and um Mike and I had a great meeting with David Conley yesterday around um some opportunities surrounding the bond Levy and um strategies around the renewal Levy and so we wanted to schedule some to um to bring in Brenda David K Cashel um and have a conversation with

128the board and about all the different strategies because sometimes they're a little bit complex but um we'll do the under 200 hopefully vender contract for valuation that we've been doing um and then is that for next month or okay next and then one other thing that is just of of a conversation that we started having a little bit last year with regard to since we're doing consent agendas re-evaluating the thought process about whether or not like how we use the treasures report and so one thought process that had been offered and thought about was doing more like a comprehensive monthly one and then at the other meetings we would have whatever look you know whatever other stuff came up but thought process when the treasure was that that would also then require some needs to

129address authorizations in order to ensure that things got paid on time so we just want to have that discussion as well as to whether or not that's something the committee would recommend or think about um we didn't really di too far into it before um but otherwise are there any folks who wanted to say anything online no one request all righty uh Michelle I just had a quick comment as it relates to slide the mic down okay just a quick comment as we um talk about Esra dollars you know um I really appreciate the graph charts to show the breakdown and also the evolution of the use of the dollars and how responsible we were and just imagine if we were adequately fully funded by the federal government for public education in this country I

130mean just a perspective right that the this 325 million is really not even as much as we're really um do in terms of um public education in this country we've been short shifted um since the beginning really on federal infusion of public dollars for our children and so you know while we might make jokes about it going away um wouldn't it be nice if that was really a permanent part of our budget if we were finally fully adequately funded million um because we have shown and demonstrated that when we get federal dollars we use them responsibly and it goes where it should go so I just want to offer that observation thanks thank you to fight to even maintain what we were doing with title $1 is still on federal government so I think it

131is it is worthwhile to always say if the federal government actually invested in public education the way they say they value public education in some parts uh it would be be much more opportunities especially in districts like ours where we've shown that we can use the funds in a responsible way um with nothing else uh i i b you all Ado and call the meeting adjourned and we'll figure out it's

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.