001e e e Administration ready as last year's board president I will begin the meeting as president proem until the oath of office is given to the new president um and during the board's organizational meeting is when that will occur and that is per bylaws 0151 organizational meeting and the Ohio Revised Code 33134 annual organizational meeting see a quorum of voting members uh I call the January 8th 2025 tax budget hearing to order um we need a roll call Mr Craig here Mr Crossett here Mr Lindy here miss map here Dr Moffett here vice president weberg here president Bolton present thank you um we are uh commemorating and celebrating uh today's tax budget uh because we're approaching a number of uh lasts and today we're going to be asking uh our fearless uh Treasurer leader to
002lead us in the pledge to the flag as if this is her last tax budget yeah I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you treasure Wagner um now that we've attend we got the attendance taken care of um we are going to ask that you do another couple of roll calls I'd like a motion if we can and a second to uh uh adopt the today's uh tax budget hearing agenda do I have a motion some thank you is there a second second thank you any discussion roll call please Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes
003president Bolton yes uh Mr Weinberg as vice president would you please explain how a members of the community uh may be able to participate virtually yes I will members of the public who are online and wish to speak during our hearing of the public this evening may do so by clicking the chat button now the chat feature will be open for your request for 5 minutes if you would like a direct response to your questions please make sure to share your name affiliation to the district your school Community topic and also your contact information thank you very very much and now we'll get started uh and uh Treasurer Wagner if you'll please introduce uh presentations that we have for this required bylaw tax budget hearing yes thank you so um asking Kevin Ashley come to
004the podium our director of financial reporting and transparency um does a wonderful job developing our annual tax budget and so I will turn it over to him thank you um so as you already mentioned this is a an annual requirement there's a pretty comprehensive report in the board packet U if you want to look at more details but we we did put together a brief PowerPoint just to give you the highlights that we wanted to convey uh the first slide is the purpose of the tax budget um the tax budget is prepared in response to requirements of the or high Revis code and conforms with the modified or alternative tax budget reporting requirements provid by the Hamilton County Auditor if you recall the board requested to use the modified uh approach the county prescribes that
005and unless you're moving inside millage they typically allow the the modified approach uh school districts must prepare an annual tax budget each January to provide a basis for the Hamilton County budget commission's review of the next calendar Year's local property tax revenue rates of millage uh so we just heard that they tweaked the rates for next calendar year uh so you'll see it's a pro it's a yearslong process of of submitting the tax budget them reviewing the collections them reviewing delinquencies all of those things and they actually set the rates for the bond fund they really didn't make any change very minor tweak to the bond fund rate so that would generate the correct amount um to cover the debt the next slide is a debt summary of all the debt and it kind of
006breaks it down into categories uh the one that we are required as part of the tax budget to present is the voted uh so the bond Levy that was originally passed you know 2002 around that area the original amount was 480 million the balance as of July 1 125 which is when the bulk of this um tax budget is being presented is 173.000 the unvote energy conservation bonds um it's 28.4 million one of those will be paid off prior to um but as new issues have come along our our debt payments are kind of structured so that the annual amounts will not really change uh they're going to be consistent you know for the next number of years but just to let you know that that will be an issue that will be paid off
007uh the long uh The Limited tax tax General obligation uh series the 2018 series was for 15 different School Improvement projects the balance on that 37.4 the cops or certificates of participation done in 2018 for the mercy and can's project uh has a balance of 15.5 the cops uh series that had a 1415 and a 21 refunding um our PID out of the debt we transfer them well actually they're paid out of the debt fund but those are mostly funded by City County monies that we got as part of the stadium project and we'll continue to get that from the county uh to cover those payments and one of those that was restructured will be paid off as well um so next slide so one of the things I I did want to mention here
008too I think another key point of the tax budget is to demonstrate to the county that we have budgeted to cover our debts um and it helps them review the rates as well so specifics of the tax budget required elements of general fund revenues total estimated revenues restated and presented on a calendar year basis so we took the five-year forecast that we did in November we did include the new rates and so the portion of the rates that's related to new construction we may receive a little bit of addition money for like inside millage uh but the other levies that are Level uh the taxpayers would have an offset for those so if it's meant to generate $48 million the county tweaks the rate even though the values went up tweaks the rate so that
009it'll generate the same dollar the bond fund or the voted so in the report it has our revenues and expenditures related to that um and then we consider the unvote the supplemental information that we're reporting U those are things not tied to a tax levy um we think another important key here like I said is just an annual review of all of our debt kind of showing where we are and and getting that communicated for transparency purposes uh next slide so just looking at the voted debt we did we looked at calendar year 25 and calendar year 26 and you can see that the revenues that are projected exceed the expenditures for those activities for that fund next slide and we did the same thing for the unvote just to show that as well I
010think that's my last slide again the comprehensive report includes a little more detail if that's something you would be interested in U and we'd be glad to answer any questions ask is that report itself posted on board dos as well as the uh slides yes they both thank you any questions for Mr Ashley or for the treasurer Mr cret I yes could you explain a little bit more uh so I have a better understanding the [Music] unvote here that they'll be paid in full by July 1 2025 is that correct a portion a portion of those so for instance the bottom one the unvote paid in for the 2014 was restructured refunded into the the 21 basically okay thank you appreciate yeah other questions comments uh member Matt thank you so um can you explain
011the correlation um between uh Cal 308 and uh the report that's given like does that impact our Miller threshold in any way or is there any relationship at all I answer so um 308 is the inside midd the floor one right okay I can't keep track of them but so um so if they change the calculation on how to c do are they remove the floor or they move inside millage into it it will have an impact on our estimated tax revenues yes okay um can you explain the impact a little bit more like what could the possible impact be well if they remove the floor um I want to say 16 million of Revenue will be lost if they did it all at one time yeah if they did it all at one time
012there's some discussion of a phase in I just saw this week and initially would would be a couple million dollars if that were to happen Okay thank you and then um but yeah basically just sorry not we go from a 20 mil floor to about a 16 it would have dropped to 16 when we looked at it the last time if the floor wasn't there so that's four MS of $9 million roughly so be 36 million yeah sorry I confirmed your amount yes thank you so B the way the way it works is it says every District must have 20 Ms of tax revenue to operate and so because of our effective millage has dropped below the 20 they increased the rates to get us back up to that 20 and that represents about $36
013million of Revenue okay so if they remove that rule then we we drop down to the effective millage we won't collect as much okay that makes sense thank you um the second question is around um you talked about the unvote debt so I I don't anticipate anything being reported now but as it pertains to expenditures or um any debt acur from the growth plan would that be reported in the next uh tax budget report and would it be under that un voted classification possibly it well it depends on what path you take if you decide to go into a pi Levy or a bond Levy that would be the voted part if you decided to try to structure it through other kinds of borrowings that you don't take to the public for a vote that
014would be part of the unvote part and it would depend on when we made those transactions as to Which tax budget it would hit okay because remember tax budget taxes are typically every year and AAR so um like I said it just depends on the decision making of the board okay all right thank you you're welcome great question other questions from board members seeing none uh thank you Mr Ashley thank you Treasurer thanks uh it is now uh uh time for hearing the public do we have anyone that wishes to be heard so we can skip it we do not have anyone in person and we do not have anyone online so I'm going to turn it back over to you okay chairman uh Craig I think you have a couple of resolutions for us
015regarding the tax budget and other things yeah um so I uh submit a resolution to approve the modified tax budget for the 2025 2026 fiscal year um I submit as written in hope for a second and support for the resolution does chair hear a second second thank you member map any discussion questions of the chair or the treasurer regarding this resolution seeing and hearing none roll call please Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you all and now I believe uh Finance chair Mr Craig you have another I do um I submit a resolution for advanced payment of taxes um I submitted as written and again hope for a second and approval is there a second second thank you
016Dr Moffett uh any questions or discussion I just have one of the treasurer could you describe what this is sure for me and for the public so uh what this does is it allows us the allows us to request from the Hamilton County Auditor to once they collect property taxes to give it to us immediately so it's in our bank accounts and not their bank accounts um this I need the resolution that authorizes me to make the request and then I have to make the request on a monthly basis to the county auditor to release those funds to us any questions or comments roll call please Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you uh proa thank you and
017congratulations on one of the first of the lasts um before we move on to adjournment uh and be ready to go to our very next meeting uh treasure Wagner did you and others decide that we needed to add something to the upcoming organizational meeting yeah I'm sorry if I I was supposed to let you know no we're okay with waiting till the 22nd okay great we're talking about the resolutions that authorize the superintendent and the treasur to perform it was part of the business meeting agenda we're we okay waiting till the 22nd and waiting till the 22nd folks uh uh we will have to probably use uh part of the committee of the whole uh coming up uh on the 22nd to pass those two resolutions empowering the superintendent and uh treasur it's rather perfunctory
018and what else treasur report the uh superintendent's recommendations as well so we'll keep that in mind but hopefully those things won't take uh too much time away from what is the normal agenda for the committee of the whole having uh concluded our uh tax budget hearing uh chair will entertain a motion to adjourn this particular meeting do I have a motion so moved thank you is there second second all in favor I on that one did we have to have a roll call for that treasure I didn't think so okay well we're prepared now to move into our next meeting which is also required by law much as the tax budget is and that is the organizational meeting of the uh board um and let's see we're ready I think per board bylaw 0151 organizational
019meeting you'll hire Revis code 331 3.14 annual organizational meeting and as last year's board president I will begin the meeting as president proem until the president uh takes the office and at Point uh takes the Gabel seeing a COR voting members I call the January 8th organizational meeting to order would you please call the role Treasurer Wagner M Mr Craig here Mr Crossett here Mr Lindy here m m here Dr Moffett here vice president Weinberg here president Bolton uh present superintendent Murphy would you please introduce our uh students from uh the school that is gracing us with their uh skills and talents regarding the pledge and we'll at this time all rise while this my pleasure today we have the students from winon hills Academy leading Us in the Pledge of Allegiance their principal Mr
020Ben Falton it's time for the pledge everyone please stand up I the flag of the United States of America the Republic stand One Nation indivisible liy and justice for [Laughter] all of the two today what do they say never appear with children on stage oh thank you um Treasurer Wagner if you'll call the attendance role we'll get started I thought I already did that oh is that the Quorum did that count yeah okay good the approval of the meeting agend is next that's the next one do I have a motion and a second for the approval of the agenda for today motion soov second second roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes president Weinberg I mean vice president Weinberg sorry yes president Bolton yes and
021the uh agenda for the organizational meeting uh stands uh approved and so we will begin with the uh agenda item which is unusual ual to have but indeed the as I understand it the administration wants to update us on some de developments over the holidays thank you superintendent yes so General Council hoing and I are happy to share with you uh some information about a proposal that has been shared with cincin public schools from the Xavier University monory lab school they initially uh reached out to us asking to be a part of since public schools in one of three possible ways those are to become a charter school or to lease property from us and then to also possibly become a part of Cincinnati public schools we had a couple of meetings with them and
022then during the winter break we met with them and they said you know what um we don't want to become a charter school we do not want to lease from you we would like to become a part of CPS so I asked them if they would uh draw up what that means to them and then they did that and general Council H and I talk together about a possible draft of anou that could be considered or that we would ask you to consider so I don't know Dan if you want to give highlights of that potential mou uh that would be great uh sure just just a couple of I think the benefits for CPS uh in addition to always wanting to welcome new families to the district um it's a successful school it's uh
023High performing um it also though has a teacher education component as I understand uh for Monas teachers and so in lie of us sending out teachers to be trained on monor methods it gives us perhaps an opportunity to bring a lot of that in house so there's some advantages there I I think in in reviewing their proposal I I I think it's clear they have an interest in all kind of Landing together uh as a family and student body unit but also with their staff um and so that's something that will come with some um issues that will have to resolve uh among others uh enrollment uh if they're all going to enroll in this school uh understand not all of these students are CPS students as well that's a charter school or a excuse
024me uh non-public school uh currently and so they currently enroll students from CPS and other districts outside of CPS so again their interest is to all land together uh the board will have to have some discussions about whether that uh warrants any perhaps initial uh waiver of our enrollment policies or not uh but that's a discussion for the board uh second I they they certainly have an interest I think in bringing some of their staff members over and we do as well uh because that that will enable us I think in some ways to uh kick off uh again this monor education component uh but that's going to be some discussions with CFT as well um in terms of how those teachers and other other members would uh be brought into the CPS employment fold
025uh we we do have some precedent for this uh when uh the lighthouse School uh Clos uh we folded that school into our district and so theou that we've just started to kind of put together models that to some extent uh in that case uh uh CFT and the district agreed to kind of priority hiring for the new folks who were coming over so there's some precedent and some models that we can use but it's certainly going to require further discussion with uh the board with CFT internally financially what it means Transportation if there's any differences so um that's an introduction glad to answer any questions do any board members have uh some requests or interests or uh responses vice president then we'll go to Yes um so this definitely sounds great uh my only
026request is for that information to be shared out with the board so whatever you all are discussing with them so that we can be be uh brought up to speed and be able to have some discussion as well so thank you appreciate it so you're looking for the proposal itself to be the proposal and whatever else great uh member uh excuse me chairman Craig um so two questions and then I'll have a thought afterwards but uh first question is really like do we know the number of students that you know potentially I think we're thinking about it from them saying they would desire this but how many would actually um support or want to come to to a district school as supposed to so there are two numbers that we have received so I believe
027it falls somewhere between 160 and 190 and this is uh kindergarten through 8th grade kindergarten through e8th grade and then the kind of second thought I had is just in that well one thought I did also have was what the grades were but I think with kindergarten through 8 um we currently don't at least not to my knowledge have a fullon monory program that's K through a right so that would require either some adjustment to create a seventh eth grade at a space where there was not one or to modify to have them go into a seventh and eighth grade program um at a different School than the K through six and so I don't know if that's something you're also talking about or thinking through with them yes we have had a conversations with
028them to First be really clear of what it means to them to want to be a part of Cincinnati public schools and then our internal conversations what does that really look like sound like feel like so yeah okay and then my last little thought on this is just that I think that this is an opportunity from what uh superintendent you were talking about initially here with bringing in folks who have an expertise in the subject matter that we are trying to currently continue to build expertise up at the schools um because one of the things I have heard and one of the concerns that I've heard from a number of parents who have kids we've looked at monor education programs it's just that not everyone is as up to skill and everyone has the same
029knowledge as others who are teaching in monu right now and then that's no fault to them that's more to say that it's a lot of stuff that happens and a lot of stuff when we're bringing fils in and they just have not had the opportunities yet to gain that experience and have an in-house ability to train is something that I think is worth us truly exploring because that that both is a cost savings but also is something that's very unique to many districts I don't know that there are a whole lot of districts around the country that do their own in-house have their own in-house ability to train on this specific area I believe cincin night Public Schools would be the first uh with a model like this and the training component board member Craig
030is so critical right now because with Xavier closing out their program you're right we do have teachers currently teaching monor who do need the credentialing in order for for well for themselves as our classroom teachers but also for our accreditation purposes and so not only would we save a lot of money because we pay for teachers to become monitory credentialed there's also the opportunity of being a revenue generator because there are others in the area and Beyond who will be interested that was going to be my other little question onto that is that can we look at models also to if we bring this house in house in or bring this in house to offer that opportunity both within our area and then potentially for other uh school districts across the country because I think
031this is an opportunity for us to be a leader on I know we' did this somewhat with our community uh schools uh programming to to train other districts how to do some of the same stuff within their district and so I think this is a great opportunity to do the same with monor thank you chairman Craig Dr mofet so I'm pretty excited about this um I think when I I had mentioned when we were talking about the growth plan about having like a monory Consortium of uh parents community members um to help us frame what it would look like and again the the professional development inous was very appealing to me and that was actually a request from the staff so that's that's super perfect um just a couple of questions we are talking about
032for the next year yes they the Xavier lab school is closing at the end of this school year 2425 they are looking to land sooner as opposed to later and when we say um when we say I know this is still early how are we talking about them Landing are they are we talking about them merging with what we currently have existing or being someplace separate and starting a brand new model so we uh thought that this would be a great startup model as a lab school in particular giving it that name because that will be attractive to others outside of Cincinnati public schools um we also think that this could be helpful to us to land at Bramble because we have that space available and we have a need uh and a for a
033purpose further deeper purpose of the building and we thought that might be a good place to to land and then while you all and I think my last question while you all are inquiring about how this is looking can we get some information around costs um and because I'm sure I don't I don't know would this be like a magnet school what are we am I jumping the gun with my question on that one so they've been paying Private School uh tuition and I did I just shared literally with uh Treasurer Wagner I did ask them uh what their budget has been like for the past two years we do have that information we can share with you okay well I'm I'm excited of course growth is what I think we need right now so
034I'm super excited about that and the ability to fulfill some of the requests that are consistently asked by our staff around this and then I think would they just with with with regard to their Staffing would it just be CFT or would it possibly be at the other unions that are impacted as well yes this our entire structure would be impacted um and I I have had a brief not detailed conversation with at least the CFT president at this point point and she's willing at least um I think it's safe to say to have the conversation okay well thanks for the information and I'm looking forward to get some more thank you Mr Lindy uh thanks Miss Bolton um I think this sounds great it's a great program no no concerns for me on the
035merits whatsoever it's just a process question um um this is the first organizational meeting where we've done anything before voting for president and voting for vice president I just wanted to clarify what's what's the ask of the board from this discussion and is that something we are allowed to do if I'm allowed to ask just for your support to move forward with these conversations that would be helpful to us at this point Dan I I don't sorry good I I think we were asked if there's anything time sensitive we missed a board meeting on Monday because of weather and I think that was that was the reason for bringing it today that's great we're not breaking any rules no great thank you not that we know of that's right it's in the new world we
036live in both in Washington and Columbus it's a little dangerous as the rules change but we're allowed to do this uh if we wanted a vote I think you're absolutely right Mr Lindy we would wait until after uh the new leadership is sworn in for sure but no vote just a kind of a consensus and wanting to make sure we're all on the same page thank you very much for presenting that you uh now we'll move to what is the uh more normal part of the organizational meeting as required by law and uh members do have before them and I believe it's also on board docs the chart that has been um uh available for a few weeks and members the way this works uh we all participate and have our uh requests made after
037we've gone through through this both the um uh Treasurer and general counsel will also describe what is the voting process for both President and Vice President so there's only a few votes that pertain uh but they'll be describing that one regarding the election of president and the vice president so that we the public knows how that happens but members uh I have a as uh president protm I would like like to ask anyone if they have any uh additions as they look at this chart uh we had an opportunity to submit to board uh staff and uh I believe that what you have before you is the most complete list of requests please review uh now uh and see if this is complete and then see if you have some additions you'd like to request
038or some changes or withdrawals that you would like so we'll take a minute or two to look at the um chart as we have before us with three people uh interested in being president uh and we have uh vice presidency as well uh listed there we have Budget Finance uh in the policy committee and as you are reviewing the appointments as well as the committee requests we will be asking for a discussion as well uh that's about two years in the making and that is a discussion about health and safety as a committee and uh some options there but if you'll take a minute to make sure before we ask for any adjustments or uh withdrawals or get the determination that this is the complete list you're getting a chance to look at that uh
039before we ask for any withdrawals or adjustments or uh uh we is this the complete list as everybody understands it to be member map uh yes are you ready for any changes yes I I I'd like to wait on that till everybody sure that whatever is before them is the correct listing uh Mr Lindy I I I certainly don't think anything on here looks incorrect uh I'm I'm worried that I missed an email because there's some information on here that I didn't see the last time I looked at this which was uh before all of the snow all the snow uh and so it has a version of this come out um or when did the most recent version of this come out to the board this is the same this the same one okay
040great so then any I would just attribute any surprise on my part to me having missed an email um and so thank you great thank you before we take any withdrawals adjustments or changes can we have a brief discussion about the um issue uh before us which is the health and safety and we'll go back to uh uh there are several people on the board very very committed to health and safety and very very committed particularly to the jurisdiction and indeed when you look at our bylaws you notice that there are tremendously important topics that are handled in health and safety but again going back almost two years we can go back to uh one of the discussions over in launch Ed with uh superintendent Wright and great City Schools uh talking in terms of
041uh committee uh reducing the number of committees and what have you and indeed um at least for discussion purposes not that we have to do this tonight uh but uh one of the discussion points I'd like to raise is whether or not we should uh if we are able to find a way to deal with the jurisdictional issues in uh health health and safety if we can perhaps think about ending it as a standing committee Mr Craig so I I wanted to give one thought to this and I know this is something we talked about when we originally had to thought with the council is that I think a large part of the role of health and safety for a while there was because of things like covid and other issues that were kind of
042in front of us and so I think maybe May in a sense of not necessarily getting rid of it fully but more or less turning it into more purposeful of a um ad hoc um committee that might be something that we would specifically have things that would be subject to ad hoc review and knowledge again the example could be for this time around crossing guards and you know safety Safe Transportation points something like that might be more in alignment to what the role of a of a health and safety ad hoc committee could do and that could be something renewed each year if the Board needs it but also be something the board could say that particular year we don't need um so I would just throw that idea out on the table I I
043think that is also another way for us to um bring some of the other things that were really important things that we're coming through at coming through health and safety over the last few years acknowledging those things were great value um but I know that it's transitioned to fewer meetings and other things that have been also part of what we've done the last couple years um with uh vice president Weinberg and then also with Dr mofet at the leadership h thank you Mr Craig uh vice president then we'll go to Mr Lindy so I am going to say that I agree I could go either way with health and safety um I think it is a committee that is much needed we have various different topics that come up throughout the year but I also
044do see that it could be something as such as a ad hoc um committee or it could also be uh provided in our student achievement meeting as well some of the topics we can combine and put them there so I am flexible um I don't have a definite yes yes yes we have to keep health and safety but I just want to make sure that um if we are deciding to not have the separate committee that we are taking serious um the issues or concerns or things that may come up whether it's from some of our staff parents students and that we're really acknowledging it and making sure to have discussions and very good deep discussions on as well so thank you other questions comments Mr Lindy um as I'm now the second most tenur
045board member up here which still feels strange I will just share that historically this committee was created as a part of an old strategic plan for a former superintendent super two superintendant ago um so this is living on having long since passed its reason for creation um and so I think any of the ideas on the table sound great um I think it would be a mistake to to keep doing what we've been doing when the purpose that drove its creation is no longer there and that's no comment on the importance of student safety or student health I think there our top as a parent I will say that that's my top priority um I'm not always convinced that a new committee is the best way to make it better um but I think uh
046I wanted to just share that historical perspective thank you Mr Lindy Dr Mett having sat on that committee a few times now I think that the topics are extremely important I would like to propose that um we kind of fold them over into student achievement um and if many of you will know we we kind of broke up the student achievement or combined the student achievement and the cow and made that meeting an hour and a half I would I think a lot of the things that we're talking about in health and safety all board members need to be aware of and so I would even be willing to rather than add an additional meeting I'd love to take one away the health and safety committee and then put that information under student achievement and
047maybe have us stay like an extra have the meeting 2 hours instead of an hour and a half we are we already got that schedule going for the remaining of the year and I think that um again some of the information that is discussed in health and safety is very relevant for all of the board members to be aware of and so I think it could easily fall under student achievement or um the committee of the whole and just extend that so that would be my suggestion is rather than have it be something that we speak of intermittently have those work plans or have the work plan for health and safety be incorporated into student achievement and we always had the intention when board member Jones was on to kind of look at uh student
048achievement when we combined it and see what that is supposed to do so we could easily Just Adjust that work plan so that's my suggestion thank you member map yes so I am flexible as well and I think that um what was shared from everyone I think is really helpful so you know if it is something that we decide to do in terms of combining it with student achievement I think that's great my only thoughts surrounded is that with this particular topic um continue to bring those um important topics that we are discussing but I would hope that we are able to see more continuity and more of a comprehensive approach in these discussions Landing in policy or how it's impacting finances so that it can be just more of a circular or comprehensive scope
049thank you any other comments about health and safety Mr C it and oh sorry Mr Craig I I was just going to add I think and I'm absolutely open to either one again I'm always a fan of us having fewer meetings than more but I think if we do that I do think it would be helpful to maybe do an ad hoc committee for a month or two to work specifically on the work plan for the cow meeting and make sure that that work plan is updated or the the bylaws for that particular group is updated to match to what we are now asking to be done um because I think that's what we kind of did do but didn't do in a great way when we did the merger of cow and the student
050achievement is that we just basically said everything goes in there and everything should be included and then we realized that everything didn't need to be included in that same fence and so just as we do that to make sure we have some type of way to adjust the bylaws to reflect that combining of the Committees Mr Crossett did you have a comment yeah I just wanted to uh reiterate what board member Matt said about being comprehensive um board member map has added a lot of value in in the wellness area with our policy committee and so I just wanted to reiterate and strengthen what what she said so thank you any other members Administration uh do you have any comments and it's all right if you don't we would be happy to support health and
051safety folding into the committee of the whole that would be great okay um uh the chair is kind of hearing that there's not necessarily ground swell to keep it uh would like to know to uh Mr Lindy's uh word process uh this would require a change in the bylaws uh it would seem to me and normally that would be an assignment to policy uh can we uh agree that policy can figure out how we want to whether it's an ad hoc thing or in order to do that but let the policy take care of providing the change uh for uh health and safety but tonight we won't be appointing anybody to health and safety thank you for the discussion I think that's good uh again it's no reflection on the importance of the of the
052topics but again it's uh this might actually work better for our students and for us so thanks and now we'll move on to uh We've agreed that whatever is before us uh is the list that went out uh does anybody have any changes uh either additions or uh withdrawals or questions member map okay so I just have a slight disagreement of if this is what went out but I noticed that there are three um potential assignments for the um organizational appointments and so I wanted to I would be willing to withdraw my name from The Hamilton County addiction response uh to support the student achievement liaison if that's something that um no one else is considering I would consider that appointment great so I'm going to cross your name out of the um Hamilton County
053and we will ask you to be our student achievement liaison yes yes if no one else decides well no that's that's that does report that my understanding from uh uh Miss Davis is that everybody every board member has some sort of liaison throughout the state the committee itself is 15 and that 15 committee then has to send all the information out to the liaison Liaisons then are supposed to bring back the information to their board so that would be great if you're interested in serving on that uh Mr Craig uh so I given that we now only have two standing committees um that require board members to make selections I would uh remove my name from the policy and Equity committee um at this time okay Mr Craig removes his name from policy uh and
054uh so will I uh other additions or uh deletions changes adjustments or any uh incorrect things okay uh Dr Moffett so I was going to um withdraw my name for the southwest region um trustee and um gratefully give that to board member Crossett and then I was going to ask um I know War member map has withdrawn her name but perhaps we could I'm I currently sit on that appointment and there could there is space for two people so I was going to suggest that she didn't have to do that if she didn't want to you're happy I'm happy to have you sit on there and there can be more more um CPS voice but if you want to withdraw you know I understand but welcoming you to that one as well but it's possible
055it allow the two could attend together and yes whatever that's great well thank you for that I am going to still withdraw but if there is opportunity to maybe like attend the meetings um that's something that I will consider doing thank that's great other additions withdrawals anybody appointments correct I'd like to add if we keep to it ABC I would like to add my name to uh Mr Crossett for uh the um activities beyond the classroom if it's not already there there was some confusion as to whether or not it was there cool okay okay good I see that Miss Davis is too uh too efficient any others so now we have in um let's see we're good on finance we have four people going for finance uh we have three people uh going for
056a policy uh and the chair is selected for the members of the public it's selected by the membership uh of that committee it's not selected at the end of this whole process today uh the new uh president will make a recommendation regarding all of these okay um let's see no changes additions all right um just want to make sure on the appointments it's it's all complete on the appointments and now as we move up to the officers uh for President and Vice President uh we're going to have the treasurer and general counsel uh describe to us how this electoral process is going to occur and uh after we do that then after they explain it then we'll start doing it well hopefully we can explain it so we can get moving quickly so the process
057we planed to use is that nominations can be made for each office um when when called up um you can nominate yourself there will be a second and then um once all the nominations are made and the the nomination period is closed I'll do roll call but as I call your name please tell me who your preference is as president so for example on the president vote instead of having to go through a vote on every nomination we want to do one vote vote that seeks a preference and if we get you have to have four votes in order to win the um election um if we get four votes we can move on to the vice president if we don't get four votes then we'll have do a runoff on depending on if there's
058a 331 or a 322 vote that makes sense that only if you don't get four votes on the first round do I miss anything Dan no no election of officers in Ohio requires a majority of the full board which is four votes it it cannot just be a plurality in other words you can't have um a 322 would not would not be sufficient to an elect to elect an officer does that make sense even though they they'd received the most votes they need a majority of the votes I'm all for the most efficient process that we can possibly imagine so I think this sounds great um in the past people who are running have had a chance to say something if they would like um we usually with Robert's Rules there's a chance for discussion
059after a motion and a second before a vote am I right in thinking that those things would also be a part of this year's process uh not necessarily not required I think not not required there's not a specific process I do I think in previous years there has been opportunity for a brief clarify too like if somebody doesn't want to make remarks you know you make your own decisions I'm interested in hearing from people but if people don't want to share that's totally fine I think that the bylaws say that we follow Robert's Rules and I think in Robert's Rules when there's a motion and there's a second There's an opportunity for discussion so if anybody has some anybody else has something they'd want to say or a question they'd want to ask not that
060it needs to take forever but my my understanding is that there'd be a moment for that okay uh is a cons consensus on the board that they were like to have statements or let leave it up to the individuals okay is that uh comfortable for everybody all right uh okay good uh we're uh ready to take nominations uh we'll start with nominations for president and at this time I want to withdraw my name from the uh presidency that uh then uh we can we're open to nominees uh nominations anyone can make a nomination but we will take seconds uh as well and uh currently uh we have two uh individuals uh on the uh organizational chart the chair will entertain any nominations yes sir uh so I would like to nominate myself uh for I
061I was going to nominate yeah you can second stole my Thunderman I second Mr all right a strong second from uh Mr Lindy okay uh we have um uh now a need for uh are there any other nominations for president I'm happy to uh Mr Crossing yeah I nominate board member m okay is there a second for board member mofet I'm happy to uh second we have two uh nominations and seconds and uh this is an opportunity for a discussion before I close the nomination process Mr Craig so and I'll be really brief because uh again I also like short meetings so we have great unanimity about this fewer meetings and make it's always great 70 vote right there I would say you know again my my hope in doing this this time again is
062for two things that are really important to me and so one is I believe this past year and in the last couple years we really as a board not really had a lot of opportunities to do public engagement and so when I was here before I spoke a lot about wanting to have specifically turning a couple of the board meetings a year into opportunities to do public engagement sessions where the public can tell us what's going on what they feel are great what are things that are on their minds what are issues so there's not not just as we've had more often than not which is a full house because people are unhappy or feel like they were not in talks to um so I would certainly want to do that again this year the
063other thing I would really want to stress um if elected Bo president was to really focus on getting into more of the programmatic discussion in this setting I think we've done way too much conversation about buildings and numbers and that type of deals without talking about what is actually going in which is what will draw folks into our District if we are really truly dedicated to growth we should be as a board talking about what does it look like to make a middle school what is it what is the programmatic information necessary tools that are part of that discussion I say all that also because you know for the last uh year uh working with the treasurer and the folks on our budget and finance committee we know that we cannot operate the same way
064we did yesterday with the less dollars that we're going to gain tomorrow and I think that is an important thing that we have to be make willing to make hard decisions on and the only way we make those hard decisions is if we know what the benefits of the programs that we're doing what is really drawing in results so that we can make the hard decisions in a timy manner so again my hope if if elected would be to focus around really building in more time for us to just listen to the people and and hear what they have to say um in a public setting so that we are held more publicly accountable for that and we can rebuild some of the trust that I think we've lost and then also making sure that
065we are really getting an opportunity to hear what's working what's not working from the administration level last thing I'll say and then I will hop right off because I think it's it's about three minutes now um is that I do think we need to get back to following some of the same protocols that we had set we as a board agreed to a few years ago namely making sure that we have things on our on board dos timely making sure that we have meeting information out to board members in a timely manner I've uh I believe that that's one of the ways we restore some of the we we cure some of the ills that has been how our board has operated for the last few years and it's a good way to get us
066to being more accountable to each other is to be following the things we actually agreed to do so those are my little three thoughts um with regard to this thank you Mr Craig uh we have another uh nominee do you wish to make any comments sure I didn't uh I'll try not to be very long-winded although I can be I'll try not to I'm running for a president because I wholeheartedly love CPS and I'm really really excited to support our new Administration and our students and our staff and our families last year was very very stressful for the district and in turn it was very stressful for the community the district to me is not just our students it is our staff all of our staff all 6,000 of our staff it is also our
067families and it's the community when I ran for office I ran for office because I wanted to be the type of board member that I wanted to see so I'm very curious and I ask a lot of questions because I I've sat at home and I've been curious and I've asked those same questions and I think engagement is just one of the things that a board member should do not just when you're running for office but it is our responsibility to ensure that the the community the families the districts the students and staff un are aware of what's going on they can support us they find a place for themselves in the district and that they know they see us and so I want to support the administration on increasing our engagement to let the
068community know exactly what we have at CPS I'm all four student outcomes I support student outcomes I was a member of the Council of great City School cohort when I first got on the board so I understand the importance of student outcomes but in order to get High student outcomes to me there are supports that need to happen and they need to come from the board down just like we had a very stressful year last year our board was stressed as well and so I think that transmits downward I'm ready to unify our board I think we've got some awesome members with great diversity and diversity of thought and I think it's time that we from a leadership standpoint have some Unity have some ability to disagree but also the welcomeness and the space to
069come together I think this is a prime opportunity with a brand new Administration to do just that I want to bring us together I want to Value everyone's opinion I want us to grow I want the community to know everything that we have to offer and I think it's time for us to show that so that's why I'm running thank you Dr Moffett thank you Mr Craig uh we now have two uh nominees and the treasur and uh General Council have explained how we're going to do this vote is there any fur discussion or does any member have any question uh regarding uh either of the nominees to ask them of anything all right then we are ready for a roll call and please describe are we to then say the name and that's how
070we're going to do this that's correct during the roll call thank you Mr Craig Mr Craig Mr Crossett uh board member mofet Mr Lindy Mr Craig m m Mr Craig Dr Moffet Moffet vice president Weinberg Moffet president Bolton Dr Moffett vote is complete and the tally is four votes for Moffett three votes for Craig Dr Moffett has been elected board president congrats ulations congratulations all right and now we'll move to uh the vice presidency and currently we have Dr Moffett who now will obviously have to withdraw unless although you did sign up for both offices if you so we take care of that do you have to sign up for Weinberg yes so I am going to actually withdraw my name from vice president and I am going to take my name off the list
071so you're removing I'm removing yes I'm going to remove my name off the list and I actually want to change and make a nomination for someone else okay um all right right now we have no one running for vice president will'll open nominations for vice president heberg you said you wanted to do something am I allowed to nominate two people sure okay I would like to know I don't know I believe so can I nominate two people is that correct okay yes so I would like I'm going to nominate Bolton for vice president and cross it so we have a second for Miss Bolton second and do we have a second for Mr Crosset second do I second both of them I don't know but he doesn't he have to accept it first M no
072you don't have to AC Thank You by however we have now one uh nomination is there another nomination and a second I would like to nominate board member Craig okay second second there you go another strong second from Mr Lindy any other nominations I get that a lot all right no other nomin ntion we'll close the nominations any discussions and any requiring a statement but besides for the presidency or have a roll call yes ma'am are you saying something are you going to make a statement hadn't planned on it I mean at the request I'll be happy to kind sitting here I would like to request a statement I know that we already heard um Craig Craig would you like to make another State uh statement for vice president for the vice presidency I don't
073particularly have anything else to say uh in addition to what I said earlier I think maybe the only other thing is I I'm here to support make sure our students uh get the best education they can and so that they can do more know more and achieve more so whatever role that is necessary for me to do so I will be gladly willing to do thank you Mr Craig and at the request I'm happy to make a couple of statements uh I've been very uh pleased to be president uh this year in this very difficult big year uh and um anxious if if elected to serve as vice president and be whatever service I can be with my experience um within the district and also as a retired teacher uh as well and I think
074we Face a lot of political challenges from outside that this Board needs to uh president-elect's comment to be much more united than we have been in order to face those challenges from outside of this District uh I love CPS um multi-generational love of CPS and feel very strongly that uh growth is our greatest weapon and that Excellence is our greatest strategy and we must put our children first first our taxpayers second and we have to engage our families to uh what chairman Craig said uh in his presidential uh uh comments um we do need to engage this can't just be a labor management decision when we make decisions and then we have to somehow come to grips with the the community uh so I think having more uh open forums uh and more involvement I
075think from the community will be helpful not just when we've done something to upset them but also to have them come and help us understand I think to the commitment Mr Crossett has made to Innovation I think will help guide us and we're glad that the Administration has embraced that so I would very much I've been vice president before it's a it's a it's a good job it's a great job and I've been vice president to some very outstanding presidents so I look forward um to this coming year if I'm lucky enough to be elected so thank you uh having said that the nominations are closed the statements have been made and roll call uh Treasurer Wagner Mr Craig um Mr Craig Mr Crossett uh member Bolton Mr Lindy Mr Greg Miss map Mr Craig
076president muffin Bolton that sounds that sounded so I was like who is that vice president Weinberg Bolton and Miss Bolton Bolton thank you uh nominations are closed the election uh what is the roll call result Treasurer Wagner we have four for Bolton and three for Craig thank you very much and now uh after all of that um we have uh decided to send uh the um issue of the uh health and safety committee uh to policy we have elected a new president and a new vice president want to thank the former vice president for a job not only well done but a job uh beautifully done and uh um helping to uh create the teamwork that I think has been useful for both the administration and the board and uh thank you for your year
077of service now we're going to move as soon as we get sworn in so if you will come and deliver the oath we will then do some seat switching and then the new president will make the recommendation and we have a few more votes uh to uh take place yeah you can stand there if you want we move over here hello I hear it you're on okay so if you'll please repeat after me um and can you raise your right hand I there you go I state your name do solemnly swear I kareim Moffet do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Ohio that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Ohio and that
078I will Faithfully honestly and impartially and that I will Faithfully honestly and impartially discharge the duties of president of the Board of Education discharge the duties of president of the Board of Education of the Cincinnati City School District of the city of Cincinnati Ohio during my continuance of Office of the city of Cincinnati Ohio during my continuance in office congratulations than okay oh he wrote it big for me I appreciate to read my readers okay okay but can you raise your right hand can you switch yes I can okay so if you repeat after me I state your name do solom me swear I Eve Bolton do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of Ohio that I will support the Constitution of the
079United States and the constitution of the state of Ohio and that I will Faithfully honestly and impartially that I will Faithfully honestly and impartially discharge the duties of Vice President of the Board of Education discharge the duties of Vice President of the Board of Education of the Cincinnati City School District of the Cincinnati the city of Cincinnati of Ohio the city of Cincinnati Ohio during my continuance in office during my continuance in office very good [Applause] congratulations here you go Bab okay um let's see so just start and now the newly elected uh president will make a presidential statement I'll get better at this I'm I promise so um I am very very grateful and um I humbly stand before you today accepting the position as president of the Cincinnati public school board for the
080past three years it has been my honor to serve on this board and I am truly humbled by the trust and confidence that my colleagues have placed in me so thank you as a proud supporter of high achievement for our district I am excited to support everyone of our nearly 36,000 students our staff of 6,000 families caregivers and community members I firmly believe that every child deserves access to a quality education that empowers them to reach their full potential and we offer that at Cincinnati public schools I'm committed to working tirelessly to ensure that all of our students have the resources and opportunities they need to succeed and as decided by superintendent sh shaa Murphy we and I I'm here for kids to this end I will work closely with our new superintendent and Deputy
081superintendent shaa Murphy and Dr Alicia Smith to support their very aggressive goals and intentions for improving the educational results of our district I genuinely believe that we have the proper ingredients that is needed to ensure success and Improvement in continuing a true CPS addtion we have the right stuff to be Innovative creative change agents and improve and maintain High outcomes for our students as a board we also must hold ourselves accountable as well not only for the outcomes of the students but also to support our staff and engagement with the community I sincerely believe that if we collectively decide to work together as a board we will be the beacon needed to demonstrate the success that we desire not only of our students and our staff but of the district I believe that it is
082the diversity of each of us that not only makes us truly representative of our Cincinnati Community but our school board represents the diversity of thought that we successfully need to work for our students collectively we can be the change that that's needed for the success that we desire and I desire for us to work together disagree in thoughts and perhaps process we often do but then work together for the success of our students and this District together is how our students will succeed so I'm committing to working with each of you this day for that success together in addition I believe that our Community Partnerships are essential to the success of students within CPS and I'm committed to uh fostering strong relationships with businesses organizations individuals all of our partners who share that same vision
083likewise I'm a firm practitioner of transparency Community engagement and communication and I pledge to keep our community and families informed of the progress and the great stuff going on in our district because we need you so working together is how we will be successful and I'm ready thank [Applause] you got to get a little Direction here have so I'm going to read the organizational structure we have to vote on the trustee he is remaining the trustee both math and Craig are there but he is the trustee okay so as I read the organizational structure that we've agreed upon please correct me if there are any additions deletions or mistakes and then we will vote so we have um Dr Moffett for president Eve Bolton for vice president on the Budget Finance and growth committee we
084have uh board member Craig uh Bolton Craig and Crossett is that right on the policy and equity committee we have member Lindy map and Weinberg is that correct we are going to absolve the health and safety committee and discuss about putting that into student the sakal which is student achievement and Committee of the whole or ad hoc or ad hoc um Cincinnati Recreation Commission representative is board member Bolton vice president Bolton city city council joint meeting Lea Le Aon is Dr Moffett osba Ohio School Board Association Board of Trustees for the southwest region executive committee member is board member Crossett the diversity and Equity committee appointment is Dr Moffett legislative liaison appointed um will be Dr Moffett the urban School District advisory network is open to all board members there is no appointment osba Capital
085conference and planning committee is Vice President Bolton the student achievement liaison appointment is Bard member Matt osba Black Caucus appointment is board member Weinberg Ohio High School Athletic Association School Board leaon is board member Weinberg activities beyond the classroom representatives are board vice president Bolton and board member Crossett the business of advisory council appointee is board member Crossett the Hamilton County addiction response Coalition appointment is Dr Moffett the the Council of great City Schools official appointment is board member Craig and board member map is also going to be attending that as well the federal legislative Advisory Group for the first congressional district current appointment is Bor m Bolton vice president Bolton the Ohio Coalition for equity and adequacy of school funding legal steering committee appointment is Bo vice president Bolton and The Innovation Council appointment
086is board member Crossett do we vote Yes ma'am question yes so you had previously stated there that there could be two people so I wanted to know if I could put my name in as well to attend the Hamilton County addiction response um Coalition yes ma'am I'll add board member Weinberg and it would be board member Weinberg and Dr Mett anything else yes ma'am I would just I would also uh add I believe with both map and with Craig uh for great City Schools I think that's great I do think that uh Mr Craig remains as the trustee yes appointed by them as I understand it so the official appointment is board member Craig and then board member rap is also going to be attending right okay we vote on that yeah they move your
087statement can be the motion and we can second it and then we'll vote is there a second second I'm sorry who made the motion president did and who made the second thank you any any discussion yeah there you go right okay Mr Craig yes Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes um Miss Weinberg yes Mrs Weinberg apologize vice president Bolton yes president uh Moffett yes and now I getting my instruction I'm sorry I have a resolution and so now we have a resolution to approve the 2025 organizational meeting business items yes uh Madame President uh I am um making a motion to approve uh the organizational meeting uh business items and need a second and as Mr Craig said hope for approval is there a second second thank you any discussion okay let's
088take our vote Yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Mrs Weinberg yes vice president Bolton yes uh president bonett yes seeing that there's no more business I'll take it I'll entertain a motion to adjourn so moved do we need a second second all right we are adjourned thank you congratul the G