CorpusRecord 65355

Budget, Finance and Growth Committee Meeting December 20, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2024-12-21
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,673 words · about 121 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all righty I call to order our final of the Year our December 20 20th Budget Finance and growth committee meeting um as we have done for all of the year we'll go around and just have everybody introduce themselves and then um I believe we actually have some people watching today which is really kind of cool um the school where School folks we watching online and so oh awesome um so we will start with uh Miss Davis and just go around the room and then Rob at the end if you tell folks how they can participate if they would like to while watching online I'm phis Davis the board's Administrative Assistant good morning Jen Wagner treasur and Chief Financial Officer Kevin Ashley director of financial reporting and transparency good morning Dr Moffett board

002member Brandon Craig board member good day Shota Murphy superintendent Anna berlon Community Partnership project specialist good morning Senor badget director School Community Partners good morning Cody Hutchins contract analyst good morning David M sen count in count operations happy holidays everybody Stephanie Scott assistant general counsel Robert Wilson technician and if you'd like to speak during the speaking of the public section please click the hand icon we ask your name and School Association to the district and we'll invite you to speak at the end during the hearing of the public session thank you all righty um so we've got a wonderful packed agenda of lots of fun stuff that I'm happy that we were able to cover today um so I will get us started here with our first update which is the uh treasur search um

003this is our old business just for those who uh have not been paying attention to all the wonderful work that we've been doing on this process our Treasures uh search um the posting is now up and can be shared with folks um there should be a link out there for folks to share um the big thing I want to share with this is that we have a end of January I think it's like the 23rd is what our deadline is when we will start to do the consideration of applicants so for all those millions of people who are looking to become a Treasurer in the state of Ohio at a big school district uh there is no better option than ours and so uh please feel free to shared with folks um both who are

004uh currently licensed and then also folks who could be licensed so there's an opportunities and there was ways to become alternatively licensed under Ohio so we want to make sure folks paying attention to that but again I'll be sharing it probably for the next month or so through my networks I don't know how many people in my network are potential treasurers but uh I will still be sharing it and so we just invite others in the community as well um any other thoughts on that Jen um all right let's hop on into our monthly financials news today Financial Factor fund so I'm gonna turn it over to Kevin first to talk about the month Financial hello it's me again um okay we'll um skip to fourth slide I guess again we just put the financial

005overview in there for someone who doesn't get to hear the presentation uh they can go back and look at those um summary items in that earlier slide um so this is the general ledger uh totals uh showing cash and investment balances by category U if you compare this to last month the biggest difference is we did do a draw from Star Ohio um to cover our debt payments that were made our semiannual uh debt payments that were made at the end of November so compared to last month the star Ohio piece is a little smaller um the blue which is the operating cash uh is actually a little bit higher as some of that money is between the two uh the yellow is the debt related amounts that are held most of those are in

006syncing funds uh that will come do in future years and then our other long-term Investments so the total there is 215. n million again all funds uh not just general fund next slide shows a three-year history of just our general operating account um and you can see that it is actually a little bit higher in November um again you have to look at this in relation with the star Ohio those being liquid as well uh next slide shows a breakdown by fund type general fund having $111 million at the end of November again Debt Service uh is the next column or the next bar um internal service student dining this month um our state and federal grants which is the yellow was actually positive so we were not waiting on as much money from OD

007at this time odw at this time again the total there is 215 million um two more slides the general fund cash balance and encumbrances um our cash balance this year 11 versus last year at this point 98.3 U and then encumbrances are a little bit higher 65 versus 59 next slide is a three-year history of the cash balance for just the general fund uh again a little bit higher than last year slightly um but you can see the trend lines are pretty consistent um the bump in the green is the when we did the tax anticipation notes last year in lie of the waiting on the tax receipts um this year we're we don't feel we were need to do that um the county has indicated I believe January 14th we should be able to

008get our first tax advance property tax advance uh and at the org meeting the board will be approving the treasurer to request those advances so we should be on track to get that um bump in January next slide is threee revenues by Source uh you can see revenues the total in the third column 294 versus last year 271 the biggest increase is um property taxes um the state Foundation revenues though as we've indicated are down a little bit comparatively um next slide is revenue by month um a three-year history I just um State revenues are down for two reasons one our state share went up down because of the try to update and two um our enrollment numbers in the funding formula are lower than we budgeted for most of it is just clean up

009work so we're watching it as it creeps back up as the clean up happens um to up to where our m is but it's also lower because our mment is lower than was last year any2 do you have a percentage like how what percentage is it lower is it down 10% roughly en um not to my head was it significant no I think it's like 300 kids and and we've caught up a few hundred I think over the last couple months so we're hopeful optimistic that that will when they submit the student files to get funded if there's any data that's missing or dat the you know like theate birth date they put the parents birth date so I've done that before put my own birth date down my kids are roll B um it

010creates a fatal error so they won't fund that kid until you fix the data and it just it's a a lot of work um next slide is um Revenue by month or I guess we moved on to this one um the expenditures um again the total in the third column 257 versus 243 last year um so a little bit higher the blue indicates salary and benefits uh we were looking at some data I think we have a little bit fewer vacant positions at this point and we do have um obviously increases over last year for um Cola Etc next slide is expenditures by month again no real surprise here expenditures were down slightly um in comparison to Prior November U but not really substantial uh next slide is UN encumbered or uncommitted so about 6%

011of of the budget is either um non- encumbered um but it has been allocated has been appropriated um some things don't end up getting encumbered um until they're ready to be paid so one example of that is the tuition that's charged through the state Foundation payment we don't encumber those funds because they just deducted off of our payment um that's the um um excess cost and um juvenile placement stuff like that and we we do build in a little bit of a so we have the salary you know what we've budgeted for salary versus what's actually been paid uh and we do calculate a little bit of salary Savings in there as well and that will fluctuate as we go through the year but you know of the budget 284 million represents salaries and benefits

012to be paid for the remainder of the year uh next slide is one that Mike does this is the monthly statement of cash flows kind a broken record but netive cash flow which we'll see until we start getting those property tax that R Dred out in January um a couple things actually made it better than it would have been um one as you'll see in other financing sources this was the money that the Hampton County Auditor Office gave us back um property cash collection fees that was very nice of them um they only do that every six years yeah you can't depend on it but it's every six years they're very nice to give some money back so um and then the other one is you'll see a negative and other expenses which looks weird

013um but what this is is the final indirect cost from Esser so what you're allowed to do with state and federal is charge an indirect cost amount that's basically basically money you get back for doing business you know processing doing the backend work um and so that looks like a negative expense in the general fund and then a positive expense um against the grant so both of those things hit which are not normally numbers you would see on this report so I just wanted to point those out and I think that takes us back to Kevin and preschool yes um so the next slide um is all funding sources preschool students again this is a snapshot at the end of November Rob if you can make um great thank you um so again a snapshot

014the end of November 1,99 students um as you can see it categorizes certain kids that receive ECE Grant as well as expansion dollars um as 150 students uh and then u i did add the percentages this month to kind of show how that breaks down so so for example the first line is ECE plus expansion that means the morning is the the morning session is paid for by the ECE Grant or the childhood Grant that's a state Grant and then um the expansion dollars in the general fund pay for the other half so ver does a fabulous job of matching available seats with available funding um so just how to read the document yeah and so it may add um this is only the second month we included this so it may start adding like

015a trend but for now just want to make sure we're getting that data out there especially as the renewal Levy that includes that set aside is coming up next year uh next slide is a tuition assistance summary um the key factors on here total number of students 741 excuse me in the purple row year to date number of days is actually less again as we mentioned before this goes back to the EC Grant funded seeds have been increased he's got and the state is doing a full day um pilot wife told I need to drink more water DRS what is this it's water this is solely because we make Kevin do this every month over and over again so by the 12 month each year it's no there's a virus going around the department that

016they're sharing with each other and so I'm keeping him at Arms L thank you fellas for the and now you mik probably going get stoping me now you tell phis right on Kevin okay I think I'm good now um the next slide shows kind of a an income statement for the expansion dollars um the middle column of numbers shows the tax revenue that's been received uh year to date um compared to the expenses the United Way um payments being the biggest piece there that is then used by CPP for their their portion of this on the next slide again shows the number of students that receive some sort of tuition assistance be it full-time halftime um or other you know breakdown of that um and again noting here those the estate pilot and the additional

017seats for the EC Grant would reduce this because our agreement with the preschool expansion dollars is last dollar in when new money shows up it gets reduced from the expansion dollars I have a question is this demonstrating that the enrollment went down um from the the green line from the Blue Line we still have 1900 preschool kids is the number is the of the students benefiting from preschool expansion dollars because preschool expansion is last dollar in okay so because we got this new pilot those kids shifted funding from here to the pilots okay so it's not correlating enrollment it's just the funding for them okay I just want to make sure we're not losing kids just and well but I do think again from the if we go back a couple sides I think our

018total number is down from but I mean it's like a fluctuating total because we we typically don't Peak until like February because it's a rolling enrollment yeah um so we may be down at the moment but we continue en Roll All Year along I think the the two questions I have and I think this is one that we've been discussing for a while but I think it's more most important because we're going to be locate the levy coming up we're not really necessarily expanding the number of total Rec School seats at this point year to year and I in the same way we were doing like postco right those first couple years after Co you know after Co and we started growing the numbers back up we could say we had like 300 new students

019or 500 new preschool students we were serving and I don't know that we can say the same as we go forward I think we can say we're providing better quality of preschool education or contining to improve the quality of preschool education for those students or access to um but I want to make sure that because I think as we go into the next cycle as we talk about what we're going to do with the levy what we're really talking about right now is sustaining what we have built with the with the new with additional dollars right yes and so right now collectively our budgets are $20 million to get you know Collective but the annual funding stream is 15 yeah so we're using prior your savings to help fund that but that's going to run

020out next year and I think you know again even if we were at even if we figured out a budget on there it's still really for the number of students that we are currently at we kind of maxed out yeah grow up two or two or three, more students or something um the other question and I think this is maybe more of just seeing the patterns as we've looked at um for the tuition assistance you know I guess are we when we budget tuition assistance do we budget the idea that we would have all these dollars for the full year or do we budget based on kind of the patterns and when they would come into um come to school because I think you know it's talking about we PE more in February so CPP

021budgets based on their his history and their planning right they know what the centers and you know the economics of the day I know some private centers have closed down over the last couple years so to get new ones converted over to three four and five stars or whatever the new rating system is I forget gold um gold um is probably a long is a more a longer challenge for them for the way we budget is based on the number of classroom units that we have and what ver knows about preschool like the enrollment in our Trends and so um then she matches all the funding to it okay and I guess and I I'm thinking about this in alignment with how we're talking about our budget for next year is if we know for

022instance I guess we thinking about the total number that we would be spending on tuition assistance based on the idea that we would have somebody in those seats for most of the year if not all the year even though there maybe different people who might different times of the year be in that spot I guess it's maybe the thought or is it that we know you know basically this amount of seats will be 3 quart of the Year they'll be filled this amount of seats half of the year they would be filled no it's more of an annual basis but it's you know like historical Trend threee average of whether it's trending up or down or whatever but um we take the classroom unit which is a a teacher a Pera and a nape that

023cost and um actualize it as a percent of the share of what else is being done the funding source I agree with Jen I was just going to mention how we do projections to her point and not just as you described um chair Craig so it is we do look at um what it's been over time a period of worth of years for the complete following school year I think that's worth noting because we have you know the idea is that we have a um at any given time we'll have more students or less students but we're constantly having people come looking for preschool programming it's going to be a challenge going forward if we are kind of like and I know this from a fact for certain areas of our city we have weight

024list to get into preschool programs and it's not because there's a lack of schools it's because there's abundance of kids who need preschool um and it's just again something we would have to maybe think about as we're marketing and thinking about the levy because I think the conversation told before was let's create spaces where there's not preschool already to remove these preschool deserts and I think a couple years ago we had preschool promise come in and do the whole conversation where there's not preschool debt well in some ways we've not say necessarily fixed that or solved it but the problem now is that we got more kids and areas and so it just needs to be re re-evaluated on a regular basis because population shifts I have a question um do we this might be

025for both of you do we do because to Bor member Craig's point we do have weight lists on some areas and then we also know about SI siblings in some schools too so do we do any type of data collection around um the need in the community so like for instance if one school says hey I could fill up 20 I could I could easily fill up 20 seats with uh siblings and then we have them on a wait list do we do projections to say okay well we could increase this building to preschools or two preschool classes and that kind of justifi the need to ask for more money because look at the average and I get that but I just don't know if are we really and then we're talking about preschool so

026they're going to get in and maybe be there two years and get out but I'm wondering do we do any type of predictive I know ver ver is always in Comm in constant communication with the community and the families so there are times when she would say we need to move add a preschool unit here or there or whatever and so we use her data to kind of Drive know Miss Murphy want so director Brooks and I just met yesterday and we're just looking at right sizing uh traditionally um so where do we have space available traditionally where do we not this has not been filled for the last couple of years where can we make some adjustments we just did that yesterday do we do that like looking at um sounds crazy but like

027census data to say okay well in this community this many one-year-old or this many kids were born so we may project 5 years out that we I'm thinking about with regard to the levy and the need to ask for more money or or to sustain it because that would be a longterm um a long-term plan so do we do any of that I know I know we're we're doing a lot with a little but yeah I think that um Jeremy and his team when we do projections overall they look at that we consider where there's going to be new housing um in various neighborhoods or what type of housing uh there are some groups that come in if they're going to do a development they'll reach out to us can say do you have a

028school available what schools are available and do you have space for us or not that happens all the time okay so we are looking at the data long term as well I'm I'm really saying that in essence for the community because they need to know while we may not we have some deserts we have some highly populated areas but we are looking at the trend data on a longterm basis too so when we do the long-term student projections um dist typically look at the census and the birds and stuff like that but at a districtwide level I'm I'm sure ver looks at the community level but um in order to do the forecasting we just kind of look at the district-wide level and then we start with a school by school grade byg grade promotion

029retention rate and I have one more question I know um the governor had an initiative around science of reading and preschool is there any state funding that we additional funding that we could maybe qualify to increase preschool programming I think that's the the pilot that those kids that in the pilot okay our early childhood Grant is pretty significant from the state okay already very it's very nice yeah we increased 220 120 seats so um in times of the science of reading all they're doing is reimbursing our the stien that we pay we have to pay stien first okay once the teacher goes through the the professional development okay but for the preschool piece we already are getting extra money I think it's yeah it's a pilot so we don't know how long what the longterm

030plan is okay I was just thinking around that thinking about that around um the preschool promise money and any longevity for sustainability for that program but thank [Music] you um just the last thing to put on there for us to be thinking about this is more for board and we're probably in line with the uh superintendent um it's just I think we one of the things we talked about when we did the negotiation with preschool promise is having time to come in and discuss uh kindergarten ready and those measures um because I do think that's the other selling point for um the levy or at least that portion of the levy is the number of kids who come to especially come to PPS kindergarten ready because of the preschool education they receive so I think

031that's something we talked about doing some time to talk with them about numbers as to students who trans trans or who go from preschool promise program to CPS kindergarten ready so the January 6 board meeting the agenda item out of administration's office is preschool focused on CPS preschool classrooms and so director Brooks will share with you the student result data and how that impacts kindergarten as a part of her presentation awesome because again I think some of these things are things we could sell as part of the levy package right like this is why these things matter this is why this dollar investment has worked and I mean again thought the video that preschool promise did that when they came did their presentation couple months ago was very impactful to see you know these kids

032talk about what they learned and how they learned and how it benefited them to to do a little bit more of using our our students as a way to show dollar investment sounds great uh but we will keep ourselves moving here state and federal grants I think are next all right let's do it all right next slide Rob so miss he good is off on a well-deserved vacation so I'm doing state and federal grants this time so as you can see the monthly graph we're again ahead of schedule which is looking nice um next slide Rob so just again just working on making sure um things get spent you know we're hitting our spinning targets for both our public and non-public grants um big things for November obviously finalizing Esser and getting that final um

033expens report done and then you know doing a revision to the budget so if you hit the next slide Rob just so you guys remember this is kind of the Consolidated app of what we have today reminder of what you know we get to help the non-public manage as well they get their portion um and what you'll see starting next month will be loading in of carryover so now that we have our budget revision done if you hit the next slide Rob this is kind of our high level Grant summary this is all the title programs um spending looks pretty good across the board you can see you know we always talk about title four we've spent all of our title four for this year so when we get carryover in that'll drop back down

034which is a good thing this was planned and we did a lot of really good stuff around World languages with this money so very nice um only one there that looks a little odd is is the expanding opportunities for each child Grant um I did take a look at that budget they have a lot of expenses that are second semester expenses so some stip in some extended time some test prep services so so while it's low like it's understandably low so I expect that I expect that'll catch up you know as we get into second semester next slide Rob S Hallelujah yes I I I stole that picture from Ed genomics um but but yes we are we are done with Esser so I mean I see $2 still available is there any money no

035there's we are done there's nothing more we can claim yeah um check out the next slide but yeah it's been next slide Rob it's been it's been quite the thing um I think I think next month we'll come back with more of a summary of what we got with our Esser investment for everyone just put a little time to put that together over over a multi-year period but and I really wanted to call out and celebrate the grants team because they did this $325 million multi-level Grant without increasing staff so it was a pretty heavy lift for their Department because very compliance driven a lot of moving parts and a lot of rules that keep changing so great job grants team and I just want to note you know again this is a a large

036sum of money that we were able to both utilize on time right to get all this work done um but that it did not hamper our abilities to do other things and from across the country the biggest issues that some districts saw with with Esser is that they would get a lot of money they ain't got a lot of money so then you trying to spend a lot of money without you know getting that money back right away and we were able to do this in a in a very efficient manner to get a lot of things done for our students and to do it on time on budget use the dollars that we were given in a good uh be F good fiscal Steward of the dollars that we were given so really great

037job from all the folks in the dis thank you I think that is the end of the grants slides any any questions I'll take over from there all right so good morning again um this month on our return on investment topics we are talking about the fun topic of resource coordinators and I just want to say thank you to uh Mr badget and his team Miss Anna's here with us as well for all the collaboration they did and preparing this data and being here as well to uh answer any questions or correct any misinformation I may give on accident so all right first slide here I just want to highlight some key terms because as I was going through this and the biggest thing I'm taking away from doing these Roi projects is really learning

038in depth about the projects and what goes on because from from the financial side yeah we see all the backend Financial transactions but we don't always get to see what goes on so in working through this there were some different things that stuck out to me and I just wanted to just educate a little bit so some key terms lsdmc or the local school decision- making committee is the is a committee of 12 people that um are responsible for finding our lead agencies which then our lead agencies are the ones who employ the resource coordinator to go out and do the jobs and meet the needs that they are supposed to meet and here on the lead agency section I just want to highlight something pretty impressive here um the evaluation there is a formal

039midyear and final year eval for the lead agency that is completed and that's really just so we can keep ourselves accountable keep the lead agency accountable make sure that jobs are being done things are being done the way they're supposed to just that level of accountability is there so you don't have to click on it Rob but there is a link on that blue hyperlink that shows the evaluation through and through um if anybody would like to see that next we have our Community Partners um these are the individuals that are recruited by the resource coordinator based on the needs um that are identified by the school and found by the resource coordinator so School identifies the needs lets the resource coordinator know they go out to the community find those Partners to provide that

040service and then finally our resource coordinator so they support this the Community Learning Center they recruit our partners they they're huge in connecting our schools to the needs that they need and really um you'll hear a word that we use a lot here engage so engage the community engage the student engage the family um and really engage our staff as well just around all these topics so we can go to the next slide right and you guys have free reign to interrupt me at any time you would like so um so big slide here the tools for measuring impact so these are things that are already in place um for Mr badget and his team and how they they keep things accountable first thing would be the reform tool so this is responsible for reviewing

041the data engaging the partner focusing on the student offering support get a little reset in there and then measure the impact and so why I put this on here why I thought this was cool um Robie you can go ahead and click on that River viw East example if you'd like and we can kind of oh maybe if I didn't do the properties right I can click oh there it so this is a example that Miss Anna was able to provide for me on the use of a planning tool so what this it's really using the school as one plan to go through identify their needs identify what the resource coordinator can do for that school um and based on goals that are written in that one plan that align with the Strategic plan of

042the district as well and then on the second tab you can see that there is strategies that are aligned here so these are the different strategies that align with the different needs um it'll list a partner there as well that is going to provide that need or that service and just give give some detailed information about how that goes in and then on the final slide we have the partner log and I thought this was cool because what this does it gives a detailed description gives the type that the partner is the partner information but if you go to the right R what this also does is it there's a column that shows how and what strategic that column that's high of colors what strategic alignment or strategic goal we are aligning this this program

043with so everything kind of ties back and it just shows the importance of keeping that accountability and tracking that so if you want to go back yep so monthly impact report so me personally I love this report and what they were showing me um what this is this is data collected via Google form based on what the resource coordinator did for that month so the partner that they brought in the service being provided the estimated number of students being impacted and the estimator estimated number of donations um that that partner collected within that month and it really I think this is important because it does do a monthly reporting of tracking and donations that are recorded by the resource coordinator that we can then use and we'll talk about here in a second to um

044track and see how much money is being brought in so at this point I kind of want to hand over the floor a little bit to the to Anna and Sierra to talk about the monthly impact report in the reform to see if there's anything left off or anything else you guys would like to highlight on this thank you Cody um I think it's very very important to highlight that the monthly impact report that we get from our resource coordinators it gives us a glimpse of what's going on in the schools each month and the great thing is um we work with we work with all our lead agencies and they complete one report in the past they had multiple reports so we streamlined the process so as soon as they hit submit it goes

045straight to their lead agency and our office so we can see what's happening in the schools yeah and another reason I think this monthly impact report is important if you want to click on that example Rob I'll show why hopefully it doesn't do the same thing so this is an active example for the month of September for Riverview East so as you can see what it does is it gives the partner of the program what they the the program that they did and then the number of students there or U and or families so really what we can use this tool for going forward in the future is getting that estimated per pupil that uh that per pupil cost of what that program is that they brought in Anna and her team are able to

046take this data at exports to Excel document that they can extract that data and we can get an estimated number of students that were impacted by that program for that month so it's really really some good Tools in place that they have for tracking this data can I just say I'm super impressed with the efforts that you did in a short time towards the tracking and accountability and return on investment I'm really pleased thank you all right and we can go to the next slide rep all right so just some celebration here to calls for celebration so I had I asked Anna Anna provided this data for me and what this is is for the months of September through November the estimated donation value recorded by resource coordinators is 552 th000 um this number came

047from those monthly impact reports so the resource coordinator puts in the estimated number of students that they thought they impacted Anna takes that data takes it out manually and puts into a spreadsheet and we can get an overview um of what that looks like what we're doing is we're going to take this information obviously reconciled against the treasures report make sure that all donations are being recorded and track properly uh but yeah we just want to take calls for celebration here because that's a huge number 46 different schools impacted 45 resource coordinators used um as is rising stars ezard Charles and Vine Sheran and this also just a note here this does include about a $38,000 grant that was awarded to the Ohio Arts Council but they are deciding to disperse it at Woodford Academy

048so just some just some good things to highlight and and take here so before we go into the per pupil breakdown graphs did anybody have any questions about the process for measuring impact or anything of that nature um so just two questions and I think this kind of goes into for me the longer and bigger conversation around resource coordinators in their role is I think it's helpful to see how you guys are measuring the success in programs I guess the question also becomes of are there opportunities to merge the work being done in certain ways in certain spaces because I'm thinking about like we have some schools now we are doing where their process of growing from one school to another or going like like shorer Junior High and shorer high school may have some

049of the same needs and and resources and Investments it might be something that our our resource coordinator coordinating in that way or fashion to look at how to do more than just one building at a time I guess it's more than well Schroeder schroer is doing two buildings schroer and the prise center two different buildings same resource coordinator I guess I'm think about like just the things that they're resources they're connecting up to so some of the different partners that they're utilizing is it something that they discuss in some way or are they able to coordinate with each other so for instance if a partner says I have more than what I what you need are there other that need this particular good or service or benefits how do they connect up to each other

050I'll just add that we're streamlining the process so this new this reporting this impact the way we're doing it now is new um for us so we're definitely looking at our department is definitely looking at what resources are coming into schools and then how we can streamline it and I and I bring that up also because we talked about this before when we looked at contracts we saw schools who were doing like eight schools all were working with you know the same person and it was like well couldn't we just bring together everybody say what all do we need to that one person um so I mean I think that's something that maybe a future thought process with and how we maybe streamline some of the work resource coordinators are doing so they're not having

051to each call out to that same person by themselves so along that line um I know that the board was very clear that we don't want to get rid of resource coordinators I think um everybody got that memo however I would like to see exploration of more efficiency and the reason I say that is because I'm coming from the gear up old Bob SE era where we did share um we had the cohort model and one person had like three schools and then they followed those kids but there's validity to um to sharing Services across um buildings and so while we're looking at it from being fiscally responsible an efficiency model it's really also about benefiting the kids efficiently academically too so I know I know superintendent Murphy has heard it from me but is

052there any plan around looking at the model that currently exists and making that in in totality be more efficient so that maybe it doesn't look like this we got 46 schools with 45 resource coordinators maybe it looks differently what if any data are you finding um that could lend itself or are you working to doing more with what we have for the benefit of academic sustainability and continuity I'm I'm interested to see of those kids that were impacted with $552,000 what are their grades are we seeing an improvement with regard to wraparound services for them like you know it's it's more for to me it's more than just simply the the body and the amount and I know it is for all of our resource coordinators so I'm not ever implying that but when I

053look at the request to make it on a big spreadsheet and tie it in cost per pupil I look at resource coordination added to that as well if the resources to that building are inclusive of a resource coordinator and they're bringing in let's say Woodford $338,000 what is the impact academically and um extra for that for those students that got that Grant so we can really say that that $38,000 Grant impacted them in math and science it impacted them so I I think I'm just looking for um some continuity to connect resource coordination to return on investment um which you all are doing a great job but how can we again be more streamlined with that and I think you I think superintendent Murphy said that you all are already looking at that but I'm

054just wondering if you all have thought if you any idea on plans to kind of for me it's I call it taking it off the paper so it's not just about the numbers but it's about that number had an impact that dollar went to three kids so it really impacted them and their math scores went up or they stayed the same they didn't go down but um do you all have any idea or can you shed any light on what you're [Music] thinking I'll say we um I my team and I we just met with all the lead agency directors and we did a think tank and in that exercise we we write we wrote down what's going well and the areas that we can improve and we're also going to do the same activity

055with resource coordinators as well what are they seeing in the scope of the work that they're doing that's going well and then what can we improve um I think it's good to note that when we talk about resources at schools giving an example you see Bearcat buddies they're involved in multiple schools so that's a partner that you will probably see on the um reform tool as a partner in different like for 14 plus schools um so looking at that again streamlining if if possible I can tell you PNG they provide tutors at two or three schools so that um resource coordinators are out there hitting the ground and getting those resources but we definitely can look at streamlining I know they're doing the work so let me can I just add that the struggle with

056the academic return on investment is that when act when a test score goes up it goes up because of different influences you can't always tie it to one activity absolutely so I just be cautious to think that but um they appear to be definitely having a very positive impact on our students oh the impact is qu no there's absolutely no question so that that is not it I'm I'm really not looking for the reasons why that academic increase was there or that or that it was sustained I'm looking for the things that influenced it so it's not really an issue of this was that it was hey they had it was $14,000 a student but they had 50 different things that impacted that grade so that's what I'm I'm really just looking for and then

057do my other question my last question is are we surveying the families of the schools where those resource coordinators are to see if they are aware of the impact to the resource coordination to the building so I'm I'm looking to make it like full service cuz you all had an survey for the resource coordinators but do we ever or is there any intention to kind of ask the families hey how's your resource coordinator doing because some people don't realize that the resource coordinator is not a member of the staff they think of them as just hey that's Miss Jones but Miss Jones is actually works for the y or she works for ABC so do we do we do any of that evaluating the the the consumer about the resource coordinator lsdmc does which H

058has three um parents on there um far as far as far as the lead and the um there's a rubric piece for resource coordination under that but do we do a survey just for resource coordination no we don't okay if we we look at um a reading and MTH scores that come out right and if you look at if you group all the all the schools that went up significantly and then you backward look at what commonalities of services they have um I think that' be an interesting study that's what I'm looking for I'm not looking for this one thing did that I'm looking for a building that may have a cost of $5 million but they have they have like maybe four stars what went into that and then you know we can we

059can look at the data in multitude of ways but I'm just trying to take it off the paper to say it's not a good or bad it's just where can we shift resources to make a a bigger impact not that one school is worse than the other it's just maybe we can shift some of these resources over here to have a an impact as well so that's what I'm I'm asking about this one thing I wanted to note too is resource coordinators also um are are the point of contact on the campus is for the mental health partners and the school-based Health Center Partners too so they coordinate all those needs assessments making sure that they those they're addressing those I I think the discussion being had um is perfectly leads into the next part

060of's presentation and I'll have some questions afterwards but I want you to kind of go into that next part thank you for that perfect segue y so the next uh three graphs we're going to talk about Yep this is perfect um so yeah the next next three sides we're going to talk about are breaking out the per pup allocation or per pup cost uh at each school that has a resource coordinator and you can correct me if I'm wrong but if I understood correctly we reimburse the lead agency they they they fund the resource coordinator we re reimburse them 72 up to $772,000 per resource coordinator so of these numbers might look a little weird like ezard Charles and Vine they share one but the ezer Charles looks so much higher because of the cost

061versus the enrollment at that school so all these are going to be that cost of that resource coordinator year to date divided by the enrollment and so that would give us the preschools I broke them out individually because their enrollment is usually a little lower didn't want to skew the data too much and then the next slide would be elementary schools so you can see that all the way across all the elementary schools and then their average PPA on there as well and then the final graph is high school and same same thing here so Dr Odell's are for formerly the lighthouse obviously a lower number of enrollment so that's going to look a lot higher just to point that out but as you can see most of these schools with traditional enrollment numbers are

062right around the average or below the average cost I I think the there's a conversation Point around the the cost per people that is true to the conversation about the results right so what how much are we investing in schools where we see the best results and what are we investing in those schools um and I think that's a absolutely a great conversation to have I think one of the things that also types into that is when we think about equity and so like schools where we know that students need more resources or may need more because they're coming from places where even to get on the to say on the regular plane already in they're this additional resource this additional benefit it's helpful to see one of the things that I guess maybe going

063to the uh slide for the elementary schools um that I think it's worth noting and this is maybe where I was also kind of getting into and I think may fall inine with some of the things that Dr M was speaking about we know that there are some schools that just don't need the same level of resources of like care for like going to the doctor or care for having after school tutoring in that same sense but they may still have folks who want to give those resources to those schools and I think that's maybe a question also ask is we look at the price per pupil is it a fair assessment when for instance this school may need more like how we I guess how are we using things like the price for people

064or the the investment and that kind of look at it to say what their needs are first before we look at whether or not that investment is meeting it's return on investment guess there more question because I can see a school like Kilgore says Hey like this is what we need but this is all we need we're good but a school like gamble M or like Fredick deis was gonna need more and they may need more to get to that next step in the grade and and so like I'm trying to think of how are we measuring what that actual return should be or sometimes the investment needs to be more it's almost like if we could come up figure out a way to come up with the needs index an index to the cost

065and to the money they're bringing in donation wise absolutely yeah because because there's also programs I know that work with trying to get kids mentors and programming and that type of thing that we could utilize and certainly wouldn't cost dollar but there are other things we just need to spend the dollar and as we as a board are trying to make budgetary decisions each year I think that type of stuff is helpful for us to be a to see that maybe this needs index is higher at this school so we know that at this school yeah more students who are just not getting to their Healthcare visits right so maybe that's a resource that we're putting a lot of dollars into at this school but at another school the isue may be something vastly different

066and like how do we as a board then make the decision as to what's the proper Investments of the budget there are conversations for example um children's can tell us how many kids they see From Any Given neighborhood for example and so that might be an area where some support healthwise could go Mental Health Partners can tell us where there's density in them going to see a mental health partner child seeing a mental health partner Etc um how many people miss their pediatrician visits things like that um we we definitely can get that information and I I just feel responsible to say as the person that brought up this whole financial piece um I'm that's I think it can be unfair to just look at things from a cost per pupil U measurement so I

067don't want to imply that that's what I'm looking at that's that's like one measure out of to me probably hundreds that you could look at but I do want us to have the data to be able whatever the data is to be able to say hey if we looked at this fifth grade class across the district what services are they getting in fifth grade and then you know and that is impacting that who's doing really really really great with what they have who could be using some more support oh and then the cost per pupil so so I just I don't want you to think that I'm focusing on that but I do think that we collect the data we just don't convene the data collectively if that makes any sense and that's what Jen's

068team has been really because I've been on them for probably three years now they get it what I'm looking for but it's just an resource coordination is just another area that I think the board really really wants to support but I think we can do that a little bit more efficiently and I don't know what that looks like I have suggestions but I don't know what that look like because you guys are on the floor and on the ground doing the work how could we be more efficient and really impact the academics and the support services Mental Health social emotional for our kids and I think we can I just don't know exactly how to do that so my inquiry was more based on are you all collecting all this data so that we can

069put it on this huge spreadsheet that's probably going to be a hundred and so pages but six5 yeah but think that I think if we if we get it you know we are not just looking at our responsibility is the is the financial but it's also about how do we impact even if I see a a $100 a kid and I wanted you to go back one slide Rob because it was one about what word I wanted to ask a question about but if I see that that doesn't necessarily mean to me that they're doing something wrong it just means what are they doing so can you go back one side to 32 okay okay okay okay well there was there was another there was another one yeah that one it says like 179 for

070what what does that mean Cody oh sorry the 179 it's in a weird spot that that's the it's supposed to be pointing to the dotted line average it looked different after published um yeah so that is actually be the average PE per people cost across the the there gotcha and you know Dr M we can look across the city at um maps that exist of where there are food deserts where there are no dental clinics no medical facilities no grocery stores whatever that does exist so we could fold that into some of the decisions that we make that that's my that's you're you're going into my brain because we can inform the city on things that we need if we just kept keep that data collectively like we're paying X number for transportation to medical

071clinics you know I mean we can we can just I think you guys are on the right track I just wanted you to know what I was thinking we had the conversation that maybe um we we know that um board member Craig always has passion around the things that we have reinhertz I think this you know again I uh think the conversation we've been having for the entire year around these cost per pupil and and the the way that we have discussed about how we are allocating resources based on the needs of our students individually which we recognize that our students need more than the dollars we have as a district to function with um so it is always a not an endless pot but a limited pot of funds it is helpful to find

072those ways that we can do that that work more efficiently think treasure W brought up a great idea with regards to the needs assessments at each school might be another thing that we would talk about as a way of discussing and that really would get into how many classes do you need how many you know do you have sports programs do you have clubs do you need um is this school in a space where you might need need more security for certain reasons or may need more investment into the infrastructure for certain reasons I think that's actually part of the conversation we may have to do at some level when we finally get a facilities master plan is we've talked about school needs but maybe we need to talk about like okay what does a

073building need look like because is the roof the most important thing this building or is maybe the fact that there none of the windows Clos or the fact that you know you got it's you know it's best that's in one part or something you know whatever May thing may need to be fixed um that all goes into that what do you need in that building to invest what do we need to think about dollars so yeah um great uh keep moving all right so on to the contract review so thank you for the resource coordinator section good job as always you are welcome to leave once you're done unless you'd like to stay for the whole thing happy holidays thank you all right so due to the holidays and the the crazy schedules there are

074a few individual who are not able to be here with us so I'll just do a high overview of some of these these contract reviews but all the information of the kpi the update and the suggestion for continuance um or what not will still be in that working document that has all been updated um so first we had Career Tech about a $54 $40,000 contract value they had I think two or three contracts over the threshold they were able to achieve 100% vendor um diversity through either locally owned minority owned or combination um so their goal for the kpi was to increase graduation rates from 82.5 to 86 for the class of 2025 and this is for the Cincinnati youth collaborative I'm sorry and their update um right now everything is fully operational obviously we

075won't see graduation dates until after the year starts but they Mr Turner was positive about how things are going how the the program is running at this time and and it's good things to say so we'll do a year-end update on a lot of these because we'll have to do the year end data to see if the kpi was met or not um next section is Department of student services and I think Dr Hall was saying she was going to be online is she online Rob I don't know if she was able to find the link or [Music] not all right so Dr Hall is online with us so Rob's gonna invite Dr Hall over to uh speak on her contracts and Cody why he's doing that I'm just do a real quick question on

076the Career Tech that I think it's just something we been talking about at the board over and over again um the graduation rate is a great API but I also think who are read this some point time need to be part of that kpi um because Career Tech you're supposed to be in a career Tech program you're actually supposed to be able to do something within that career Focus so I just if that's something we can also later time with absolutely um I think Mike Turner's per person talk about it but just make sure that's another part of it as we add potentially more uh CCH to the district thank you for that input Dr Hall you can go ahead and unmute your mic if you'd like okay thanks Rob um so the first one

077is our merges healthc care system those that is the contract we have to provide one-on-one LPNs um currently we have 18 LPNs oneon-one um we need 21 students that need those services but we have been able so far to find 18 of them the hard def find position you go to the next Rob I don't want to pack the slides too much and put everybody's contract SL and then at the bottom you'll see I'll put in order everybody on so Margaret but this is Jen um good morning morning before before you move off of that first contract um you're tracking the number that are being hired versus need but what's the impact they have on the students performance how are you capturing that the students attending school the students are unable to attend if we

078don't have an LPN in place for them okay so tenants should go up right on those students yes what about acade like what about academics I can check on their academic scores right now the majority of them are preschoolers maybe kinderg Guard Readiness sure okay so thank you she can start with Western nursing right there we don't have to go line by line through all of them if we want to talk about um how the the kpis were developed the how we're impact like what the impact is at this point of the year of the kpi um and how we're tracking that in the different different Avenue news that we're going through and tracking that data so if if you have I think invoices were a lot of your your indicators so if we just

079want to talk about the kpi process and and how we're doing that student impact there we don't go line by line most of um most of the vendor contracts and student services um are for positions that we have not been able to fulfill internally like Western cross country emerges um so we track the invoices to see how many um positions are being filled um with Paras um we are struggling to actually have all the positions filled um the two vendors are working hard but not quite able to meet the needs um of the district at this point um in providing all of those Services um we have quite a few vacancies available but we do check the invoices to see where are we also double check with HR to make sure that we are looking

080at um positions as they open up and come in for new students that may require Services based on their IEP the ion um is for our students that are in their fifth year so their Workforce um and for our students who are our 11th and 12th graders in work academy so we have filled all of those positions currently those students are all on track with their irc's and graduation to graduate on time if they are 11th and 12th grader and the students that are in the fifth year program are all on track to graduate after their fifth year program um with a stronger base in employment if not being employed it's a little early for employment yet for them thank you Dr Paul I do want to make a note that as Dr Hall and

081I were working through a lot of these kpis at the beginning of the year and identifying what the impact of a lot of these Services were the first impact we want to identify Jen kind of mentioned it and we'll piggy back off of it was getting these positions filled um and looking at the ability to use these vendors to fill these positions because as you can see on some of these I think and nurses we have like multiple contracts to find different different services so it's it's using finding the vendor that can the fill those vacancies and what we wanted to talk about was the ramping up into next year about what that actual student impact is um so I did want to make a note there that Dr Hall and I will be working

082on what those like what is the impact of the kid having a nurse in the school like what is that and that kind of talks about what you were talking about earlier Dr M of the grades are going up but what are those all those impacts and what are all those factors that are going into those so I think there is great opportunity in these contracts especially to see what that student impact is anything else you would like to add for us Dr Hall I don't think so Cody unless there's any questions so I have questions um what how many positions are unfilled and because I'm looking at how many students can is are let me ask the question are the unfilled positions impacting the AC the learning of the students so I.E are those

083students not able to come to school because there is no medical professional there that's my first question and what is that number and then another question that I have is if the vendors cannot fulfill the vacancies I'm wondering why we're maybe that's maybe we need to yeah I mean I'm I'm trying to say it as nicely as I can but if there's problems filling vacancies with a vendor then perhaps we need to either look at other vendors or is it cost efficient to hire those positions in house again going back to the fact that kids some kids cannot attend classes because there's no medical professional so I'm I'm a little concerned about about that um how many positions are unfilled is my first question are those positions necessary for that student to attend school which

084impacts their learning and then what vendors are we using that are that have what's the percentage of vacancies with vendors so again I'm sorry so if you look at the LPNs currently there are three vacancies is were preschool students we have interviews for two LPNs on Monday um that hopefully we'll be able to fill those these students um are just able to attend preschool um they are now three years old or over so they can attend preschool they cannot attend until we get an LPN in place for them so we work with uh the preschool Department to make sure if a student is coming in during an evaluation that we get a heads up in the first place if the student may need nursing services so we can start ahead of time look for those

085um looking for those positions to get filled we have been fairly successful with the LPN the Paris is a different situation so at the beginning of the year we had about 80 PA pair of vacancies um we continue to always try to fill those vacancies inhouse um we also are doing some targeted PD and have done targeted PD for the pair of professionals who are working with our students with disabilities those pair of professionals are assigned based on the students IEP needs the student still comes to school um the IEP in full is not being implemented because there is no par professional with the student so in some cases we have managers that go out and assist in the classrooms um to help in certain situations um it all depends on the individual student the

086need is higher than what the agencies are able to provide so when you said that we had 80 vacancies is that 80 students that can't be serviced so there were 80 oneon-one vacancies at the beginning of the year I'd have to check it changes every other week it changes um on how many we have so for example today I know there was an IEP that went through where someone just approved um the IP team approved and and agreed for a student to have a one-on-one pair professional so those positions get um go through the process they're supposed to and then we work with HR and the um school teams to hire the student does come to school though in those situations we're just not in compliance is that how that works correct and how many

087of the agencies that we use are not able to 100% fill our needs so we only have the contracts with the two vendors Western and cross country and um those two vendors are not able to fulfill the need that we have our demand is greater than what they have they keep looking and are trying so just one more question I have a hundred questions for you but I'll ask one more so on average how many um days would you say student how many days would you say we're not in compliance with regard to being able to fulfill the medical needs of on average for let's just say first semester since we're in first semester for LPNs I can get that information for you um we do track it and see if the students are not

088in and how many days they miss so I can get that information for you from first semester okay and I'd actually love like Jen's suggestion to see the academic impact to those students um attendance as well and any other demographic um too so but thank you you're welcome and I'll just add one little thought on this and this is General issue with nursing right now is that there is a shortage of nurses it's the world of part of the problem I think this is also a reason why building relationships for like nursing programs where students many of our students who are doing the health Career Tech areas who then can go into schools to get their uh degree and then come back and work with the district maybe a great way to create pipelines as

089we think about uh the next kind of a world of building up in the district um I think the issue though and and that probably you certainly can can correct me if I'm wrong on this I think part of the issue is just that there is so much need everywhere and that every agency is also trying to meet their needs to get Staffing at places for everywhere um that that you know in the days of where you would have five or six folks who might be sitting out I I distinctly remember when we started doing or not when we started doing when I worked here when they were doing um pairs to work with I APS the issue was always that you would have like one pair who would work one day here with one

090student another day with another student and it was really hard to figure out you know like when that pair decided not to show up what you did because you already had a plan in place and now it's like the question may be do you have enough pars to even do like partial day here partial day there it just may not be the same problems that we had in the past is that right that would be accurate um so again I think I appla the words that you all are doing to putting together some of these numbers to get us better understanding I also think it's important to understand that the LPN part is actually with our younger preschool kids more so than some of our older kids but again I think this is another way

091we can think about as we look at our budget where ways that we can rethink how we do certain things or how we utilize certain roles to make sure that we can get Staffing that's necessary to support our students with disabilities um the keep us moving here well thank you Dr Hall so our next section is uh School culture and safety sorry I had to tongue twister there here I think there was only two contracts listed uh $1.1 million value both are vendors that identify as either locally owned minority owned women owned or a combination um this first one here on this one is the Yonder bags so the kpi for the Yonder bags was first one to make sure they were delivered on the first day of school but second um the during the

092contract term they want to see a decrease in cell phone usage what I would like to see here where're we're going to pry a little deeper is get that actual number to see what that cell phone usage was or if we can track that to see and make sure that these Yonder bags are performing the way they're supposed to and doing that so and just again Cody I think one think we can continuously keep working with folks to do is to add the idea that we in theory say we want yes less cell phone usage because then we would see an academic growth as a result um not just because we don't want people using cell phones um but I mean it's just reality is that the thought process is that kids will be more

093focused in class and that their academic results would grow up and I think what we argued about Hughes is that we saw some growth in academic results with the so teaching the academic side of the house on Ro key performance indicators and the impact on instruction or something has been um a longer challenge than it would be for a regular business unit who used to thinking that way so Cody's done an incredible job teaching and as they learn and get settled they get to the next level and then the next level so he keeps diving deeper well and the truth is that kpis are not the stand you don't stand at the same kpi for the rest of the time right so the first kpi might be we just need to decrease cell phone usage

094the next kpi might say now that we decrease cell phone usage how are we seeing on academic results or how are we seeing on these next steps along the way and so I think that's it's been great work um but we've gotten now everybody has the Ys now are we seeing anything coming from that you have some time I was just I was just going to add to I remember when we were talking about Hughes another indicator was a decrease in discipline as well so I don't know if that's been tracked but that's I mean that would have an impact on academics and others some type of yeah the connection up to the academic results because again I think there are things we would see in that first year of everybody having it that were

095the pitfalls right so like how do you use it how do you implement it how well are we using and how efficiently are we keeping track of when people don't follow of other things but perfect it's like fy2 was the training wheels year now the training wheels are coming off and we're gonna start doing deep Dives and actually have to provide those numbers so this should be fun going forward right H depends on what your description of fun is um so next one would be the talent um Department budgets so here we had about $9 million in contract value 83% with the vendor minority um identification and then there's some updates on there I think that information is still forth coming I'll have that information added into the working document when it gets to me

096and finally we have the Treasurers Office there was two contracts here um and I will hand it over to my friends across the table to talk about that contract so the first one is par school and that's the software license for Alo view which is our budget building software um we have 374 users so that would what's 243,000 B you do the math um but we're very pleased with the software in terms of what it provides for us it's incredibly helpful to us who have to consolidate the budget because the end users actually enter their data and they they can drill down to C like instead of just having one line of Professional Services they can do sub lines for each contract that they have or intend to spend money on and we can tag

097it to a a strategy uh or an investment bucket so that we can report out this is what we're investing on in so um but the C did you get a cost $650 per user per user so we're expanding our users um to the IL chairs and lsdmc chairs so that they can View and um upload their sign off on the budgets and stuff like that it has been really helpful with you know building out Staffing formulas and getting those things recorded somewhere and just a lot a lot of lot of nice improvements from where we were so when Jeremy does the student projections we drop those numbers in by school by grade and it spits out the Staffing formulas for us and then we just have to look at for anomalies and adjustments so

098that I think that concludes the contract section are there any additional questions at this no see none good job I feel like I say this intered it's nice to see how far this has come I think my first year on the board I was in the finance remembering the last meeting of the Year from from that year also just a lot of really good work system visibility you know sorry we're really forging new territory because I don't think I haven't seen another District that does this kind of work at least in a systemic way and so we're really forging new territory it's it's I mean again for larger districts again we're in the smaller edge of the larger District world but um in the larger districts I know this has been an issue for trying

099to figure out how you efficiently do uh some of your services and resources and how do you make sure that you're not just adding dollarss on to Dollars you're already spending coming with new ways I think that was one of the conversation points to um give treasure Wagner a little credit here one the one of the big points when we did the presentation at the council schools training and that one of things people were talking to me about afterwards was the idea of like you guys talk to people about all these things like you guys have conversations about how is this investment or Roi like you and even some of the other presentations some of the things also talked about with regards to benefits regards to other things that they're doing they've had a really

100hard time trying to communicate that to the public of why this is the thing they needed to do I think we're in a much better position because of the work we've done on on a lot of this work so I appreciate all of the efforts there and I again continue to look forward to seeing how these things evolve as we go forward thank you very much next thing we were going hit us uh before we move into another area was the community reinvestment act agreements y next slide please rob um just one for this time around so um it's fairly large one but it'll be for approval on the sixth this is actually um forth and walnut the four and walnut Tower is what this represents so but um a nice chunk of annual revenue

101for us so and then I know Lauren just said out but we uh we have the bank the banking thing next right we do yeah oh was there no the qy rep we kind of went out of order it's David we're celebrating David today because he has done an incredible job well yes while Rob pulls that up yes we are we are celebrating David Mana today across the way there um been with us for a while just a great great employee just gets a ton of stuff done and really cleaned up a lot of things so it's a little different um for the other Qi presentations usually there's kind of a formal Qi team um but one thing that we realize is Qi tools we use are embedded across a lot of other folks I

102mean we had a meeting yesterday Jen and I can tell you with you know other folks and you could just see like using those same Qi tools you know test of change and you know digging in and finding root causes and stuff um and so yeah so if you go to the next slide Rob so three things talk about today that we never talk about I don't think we've ever talked about here but they are critical to what we do um on there obviously the bank account reconciliation and then um unapplied cash is another part of that and then unclaimed funds which we do talk about annually here so but again big shout out to David Mana who does a ton of this work every day um and then also you know Ben Hecker Joseph

103Porter and Mr Ashley are also involved in different spots so share the share share the um praise there next slide please so just so you know bank reconciliation um is our process of matching what's on the financial system books to what's actually in our bank accounts um and you know it's basically like like every you know month you should balance your checkbook at home not that I don't know people still do that I we still do it I don't know that everyone does um but it's a little more complicated at our level you know I mean you have to look at our outstanding AP checks outstanding payroll checks um a transactions have a posting date that doesn't doesn't always match you know when the thing was posted in the system you know there's some there's

104some lag there I mean one thing people don't realize just high level you know for us to run pay us for you to get your paycheck on Friday we have to have that file of all the amounts to our bank by Wednesday so that's just a little thing people don't realize but your payroll is done on Wednesday to be paid on Friday so so just the number of transactions that get processed through the bank account is centrally we're we're paying ,000 paychecks pay period so 12,000 a month and then couple several hundred vendor payments but he also has to De with every single cash transaction from each school every day and that's thousands and thousands of transactions that flow through those accounts it is and if you're remember we do fund accounting we yeah we

105do fund accounting so there's 50 there's 50 funds that these transactions could be in um and we have 16 different bank accounts so it's not like we have a check going to save because we have 16 different bank accounts so get it he [Laughter] needs next slide Rob so one of the things we do is track our um variance between between our between our GL system and our bank accounts um happy to say our variance is always we have more money in the bank than we have in in our in our GL which is good right that's very good thing um and and these tracks for the last year we've been everywhere from $53 up to $670 those were kind of at those were some 67 was kind of the highest level and that was

106right when we implemented the new Focus AR system so how we bring fees in at the schools so that's I think that's went down and I think we were at $200 last month is that right and when I took over the department that variance was over $5 million and so that's the success that David's had I wasn't going to say that but okay yeah we we significantly better than my checkbook it is significantly better and so and so to give you an idea our variance is 0.000000 225% of the total count so like it's a rounding air but thank you thank you all right so but not only does he not only but but wait there's more not only all right next slide um is is is a thing that we call unapplied Cash and

107unapplied cash is and said like we get we get lots of payments from from the schools we also get lots of just checks that show up or AC that show up in our accounts um and it's not always obvious where they're from and so part of the unapplied cash process is figuring out you know what what a $100 check is for and whose account that should get applied to and so David's part of the team the AR team also works this um because we put the money in the bank to follow our policies to follow orc and then we do a journal entry to put it in the right GL account so that school or that department has the funds to spend if you hit the next slide rob you can see some significant decreases

108here you know especially since like November last year we we've we've really worked hard to knock these numbers down um and it really helps the schools you know the school gets a gets a donation for $500 you know we do this that means they can see it in their budget that means they can spend it you know for the students so it's really important that we get that we get those funds moved over and then Rob if you'll go forward um final one we've talked about for is unclaimed funds so these are checks or payments we've issued that never got never never were cashed um mostly payroll some vendors um you know and we continue to look to reach out to folks we use whatever information we can find a lot of times we just

109don't have good contact information part of the reason didn't cash the check is someone moved you know um there is on our website if you go to if you go to the CPS main website go to financial information there is a there is a link there for unclaimed funds anyone listening wants to look up to see if they have if we owe this money they can look up and there's a button they can apply um to get to get that money to fill out like a basically a claim request thank you Rob Rob is on it today I appreciate so please do that um and then obviously we reissue checks I mean most pretty standard after 90 days most checks go stale the bank won't cash them and so we'll reissue them to you so

110if you get to the next slide here you can see I put a trend line on this one you can see this number has went way down um and part part of that was a work of this committee I think a couple years ago two years ago we had a real discussion about it we created a procedure where things over a certain age could then be put back to the general fund um and we also did kind of a blitz and I think we picked up a lot of payments there so so all in all you know some great work that we don't ever talk about but I thought this would be a good opportunity to do so and praise the people who are doing this kind of behind the scenes work all right uh

111again we we will keep praising David I'm sad that you just now brought David to us to to praise any questions from Bo so David you get a raise and you get a raise for sure um that's just that's just my Oprah interpretation for sure um unclaimed funds if you don't know that you have unclaimed funds do we publish this with the county you know the county does that uh unclaimed funds things is it free for us to publish it there just to say that they have money at Cincinnati public and I'm thinking of um one of like Good Morning America or somebody does this show where they go around and they tell people hey you've got this money in this state do we do that do we advertise it outside of just us because

112if you don't know then you don't know so we don't we tried one time to give it to the state and the state said we don't want it and they give it back to us I mean I'm State database that you know a lot of like like a lot of companies afford money to and then it's on the state search and we tried not talking about giving them the money as much as I am I've done it before for myself and it directed me to the organization that I needed to go to so even if it's just to list it that this person has funds I'm not saying that we take their money out I'm saying that we keep the money let it earn interest but announce that that we have money there I'm just

113thinking what method do we have to notify the public or former employees that there are unclaimed funds if they don't know that there are unclaimed funds happy to look into that thank you and can I add something quick sure so the good news is the 45,000 that's all old money so for the last two years there have not been any new monies then FS so we have been it's more like a campaign with me and Tracy Tracy Mo and per you know just every month you know just reaching out to them you know telling them you know it's us a prison call when you call someone tell them you know I have money for you yeah so yeah but most important I want to thank Jen Mike and Joseph you know for the support and

114truly do love what I do so thank you thank you I I know the um unclaimed funds was the thing that like at least my first year on this committee we talked about in large part because the ones that were there were not like a month or two old like these were substantially old that we were having to reissue checks like second or third time on some of these things and so I think the fact to your last point there the fact that we are not seeing this in we're seeing next to none if if any that we are having to address of new that this is mostly the remaining stragglers who at some point we'll be able to say those were no longer existing as unimed funds and those are now claimed by us

115um is is important I think the one for me though and this is one that we had a discussion on and unfortunately the state changed our pathway on this but the um unassigned cash or the U unapplied cash like I think some of this yes it's steming from checks that we reive but I think also some of this stems from we have to maintain ability to accept cash and accept payments in a way that is not electronically uh efficient and so it was the thing that we talked about in a committee it was the thing that we talked about in this committee about the wanting to move to a more digital system and and digital method of of banking because paying by electronically is so much easier to track and manage and that kind of

116deal and if someone pays on Friday and it's lawed on Tuesday but the cash is in the account on Friday or a check comes in on Monday and no one tells you what the check is for until Friday it creates these little cases where yeah how do we process what are we getting funds for so I think again the fact that you all have seen that drop and kind of maintaining a a pretty fair amount is is is uh Testament to the hard work you're doing but also still maybe more Testament to the conversation that we continue to have to keep having about how we manage these things in a in a great way we talked about this in AIA times about like if you have a system in place and we can actually say

117whether or not the system's working I think unfortunately we had a system and then the state said no so gone back and revamping how that worked but it looks like it's having good results so so the AR team is working really hard at converting people from checks and cash and they that's one of their monthly kpis that they review is and all the transactions they got how many came in with in cash versus a um because the more cash you handle the more opportunity there is for Financial Risk and so um yes thank you state for making our job harder any other comments cool all right good work yes uh I see that our uh Chief audit executive is now in the building um so we will transition over to them I think the first

118thing and Lauren I'll turn it over to you to introduce it but I think the first thing we have on that is a couple of uh resolutions so good morning almost afternoon everyone um apologize for our team sted this we were running late from another meeting but I wanted to take a moment um since we did Miss introductions to introduce of course myself I'm Lauren Roberts and I'm the chief audit executive and I have my internal audit team here with me and I'll let them introduce themselves I'm sorry a little sick I'm a mu internal audit everybody leaned away from Isaac Karen internal audit supervisor wonderful so forgive me I think I have to angle myself a little with the microphone uh we were asked to come today and have this wonderful opportunity to share

119a bit of information about internal audit and the work that we do this may be a bit of a recap for those who uh saw this presentation at our September board meeting where we had the opportunity to inform the public as well as members of the board and Community about internal audit and then we also will go through our audit committee dashboard that we shared at our December audit committee meeting kind of a Consolidated version of both of those items and of course as chair Craig just mentioned uh the resolutions that are coming before the finance committee as well so perhaps so we don't forget we start with those resolutions because I can see myself moving right along uh so our first resolution that we have before you uh these are drafted with the anticipation

120of moving to the January board meeting of course uh but they are for our chair and vice chair positions for the audit committee uh so the first is Dan Hol house continuing as chair for another year and uh we are fortunate to receive a uh interest from Clarice Warner a member who has now uh been approved by the audit committee as Vice chair uh and then our second resolution is for another three-year term for member Paul kitsmiller so I submit these for your review consideration and um hopeful approval and again these were two folks who for the vice chair and the chair there um was tremendous support within the um the audit committee for them um and so wanted to make sure that it comes to us so we there's any concerns or questions from

121uh board members um otherwise I think the next step is for it to go to the full board for the approval in our January meeting um again Dan's returning um and and one I will'll say one thing Dan wanted to make sure that there was consistency as and Leadership on the uh on the audit committee because I think it was important for him to not have a full turnover of the a committee leadership team so um that that was part of the reason he he chose to accept the nomination um to remain and so and we also want to thank um and I'm blanking on names now but um Liz gridge um for her uh being the vice chair for this last year and and again she's remains on the committee but decided she wanted

122to take a little bit of a step back so any questions or concerns about the the resolutions no all right thank you and do we need to do a motion second roll call or you know an unanimous vote from a procedural standpoint I don't believe so for this I think we would do that at the um SI at the at poliy or at the board meeting yeah it'll move I think to the board meeting at the board meeting yeah yep yep perfect great well thank you so much wonderful so I will get into a brief conversation about internal audit and I'm happy to expand and of course I've got the team with me so we can dig deeper into any aspects of interest but to begin for the Public's edification and context uh start with

123what is internal audit so our job as internal Auditors is to provide independent and objective assurance and feedback to add value and improve the value through the organization as a reminder we do have an audit committee and internal audit Charter that are board policies that give us uh grant us the authority to do this work and have unfettered access to all of the resources and management team um and we work in partnership with with those throughout the organization to achieve these goals so just a briefly touch on organizational structure for those who may not be familiar I am a direct report to the Board of Education we also uh functionally report to our audit committee which is comprised of our three finance committee members and 10 members of the community who volunteer their time as

124we just mentioned uh through our appointment process uh as members and of course as chairs and vice chairs so we report to the audit committee on a bimonthly basis providing updates regarding our plan the assessment of risk in our annual risk assessment process which is what results in the plan so I'll go into that in a bit more detail in just a moment so jumping to the impact of internal audit what's our purpose we hope to increase the operational efficiency of our organization enhance the compliance and accountability throughout our organization and with our community and promote the stakeholder confidence in CPS so that is a very Consolidated version of our September 23rd um presentation if you're interested in those uh full deck of slides that is available on board docs for that September 23rd meeting

125but where we want to spend a little bit more of our time and focus today is on our audit committee dashboard so for those of you who attend our audit committee meetings you may be very familiar with this tool however for those who are not we have developed this dashboard as a communication method to our audit committee and and public stakeholders to say what kind of work is being done by internal audit and in partnership with management so the top is more um administrative of sorts it provides information for audit committee members however the rest of this uh document uh provides notable information for everyone the first you'll see is our external audit process we partner with the entire organization and request that that they send internal audit any external audits that are in in

126progress and ongoing so our management teams are aware as well as our board audit committee and finance committee are aware of what external audits are taking place so right now we are underway well underway with our fiscal 24 Financial audit uh LED and overseen by our Treasures Office and coordinated uh in the details I'm sure with uh Mr Kevin Ashley so lots of work being done there and more information to come as that concludes so to step into the internal audit plan how are audit cycle functions for those again who may not work in this daily every year we develop a full organizational risk assessment this work is typically done in the May and June time frame with the uh result then being our plan for the year so how we select things are based

127on a multitude of factors such as organizational risks reputational risks uh and think of a risk as what can go wrong also as what's an opportunity we have to uh take advantage of some improvements and and to ensure that those things don't occur so our plan every year is approved during the summer months either at our June July or August audit committee meeting and then we get to work on those projects so right now we are about at the midpoint of the year and fortunately we see we're about 40% of the way uh we explained to our audit committee that you'll see the number of tasks kind of EB and Flow as we get into our projects those numbers will go up and then they will start to move through into the completed state so

128we're making great progress through our projects this year uh to dive into just a little bit more detail there are numerous categories of projects so we perform Assurance work which are what you think of when you hear audit it's a audit report that we present at the end it's based on a set of criteria a set of data and we measure against that data against that criteria so we have numerous projects that are in progress now as you can see listed the other set of projects that we do are advisory so that is more uh Consulting in nature it does not result in a report at the end however we do sometimes provide a summary of what was accomplished but what's notable about this work is it's management Le meaning a management team or administrative

129team has a goal in mind and we partner with them to provide our feedback and um insights as an independent source so we have our projects of course listed there that we're currently working through and the next one is followup so these are projects that have historically already been audited by our team and as we get to the bottom here we'll talk about our tracking but once things uh recommendations rather are marked as complete or fully addressed and implemented by management we can come back and do a follow-up to say are we seeing the data and the results as we anticipate um and and are those is initial initial issues resolved and then finally we have some portions that are focused on our team's development around internal audit development such as implementing The Institute of

130internal auditor standards that is a an overarching multi-year goal where we are aiming to obtain a peer clean peer review that says our internal audit team functions and operates the the standards that are set by our industry so that concludes uh aspects of our our fiscal 25 plan the type of work that we perform and then the final area that I'll just briefly note are the past recommendations I touched on that just a moment ago but essentially what we have developed over the past few years is a process of accountability oversight and management reporting that lets us see what past recommendations have been completed what have met their due date and perhaps those that have uh not yet been completed by the due date establishment by management so one thing that was discussed at the

131most recent audit committee meeting were the past due recommendations and what are our next steps so fortunately since those uh since December 11th we've had further conversations with management as we are still developing this process this is a new iteration um and so we have developed a plan to to work with management to say what is our escalation process so we will bring that to our next audit committee meeting we want to ensure that it's a collaborative approach we're all learning from this new uh method of tracking uh so we never want audit to be punitive however we do wanted to show accountability and and follow through so uh one question that was specific from audit committee was to benefits so we have a meeting scheduled in early January with the benefits team um and

132speaking with uh Miss Julia indalo our goal is to embed internal audit into their processes so as they say we are nearly complete we've developed a process we anticipate the data has improved we want to come in show them how we tested it historically or how we would test it if we were to come in for a follow-up audit help them have the tools necessary to self validate and we can provide a little oversight and guidance there so when they say we are good to go for follow-up audit we can anticipate those results um being being hopefully very positive so just wanted to share those brief updates since our December 11th meeting and really appreciate management team Treasures Office and superintendent as the Dual reports to the board and everyone up below and and within

133their teams has been very supportive of this work so I think we're making great progress and I anticipate those past due items uh you know resolving themselves hopefully by the February meeting so that was hopefully my Consolidated what is internal audit what do we do in a year and so on but happy to expand or answer any questions thank you Lauren and again I think part of the reason we had this want to have this conversation is that this the entire board membership of the committee here is also on the internal audit and so we want to make sure that we're uh providing an update through here as well to just acknowledge the work that's being done this has also been a very big transition year in the way internal audit has operated in some

134ways because we've recognized have you go out and audit a million things and some of them being able to be audited and some of them things not wasn't necessarily use of the time and so Lauren and our team have really worked hard to kind of rethink and then work through how they are doing Audits and what I think the three categories right that that has been a tremendous helpful part to Administration and and some of the work also the treasures office has been doing um so appreciate it any other Dr Moffet so I just want to say to your team that's small But Mighty uh good job and congratulations because this is relatively new when I first got on the board I didn't see the dashboard um so this is a lot of work a

135lot of hard work but to the public it's actually um just 150° uh more transparency better efficient data I do want to go up a little bit Rob um if you can go up just a little bit to demonstrate that um just a little bit right above this section right there so this is with regard to incomplete recommendations um if we were to look at and I was trying to make sure that I saw you you you mentioned that hey you know what um it gets bigger and then it it gets smaller but this is a testament the number is bigger but it's a testament to how efficient you all are working with our departments and how you are again holding us accountable to running the district more efficiency efficiently so that might look like

136it's a huge number but it's demonstrating that you all are integrating more efficiently within the district and doing really really good work so kudos to you and and your small But Mighty team but you guys don't get enough um I think audit is not sexy and it could be uh a little put off offputting to some I you know some people just run away from it like oh my God math and numbers no but it's it's really really helped me as a board member and I can speak for myself to understand the numbers to tie that into being phisically responsible and efficient and I'm holding U all of department is accountable so I'm glad to hear that you all are immersing yourselves into the process so that it's not just a a punitive thing it's

137a hey we're really trying to help you get better again going back to efficiency so thank you to that and then thank you to our other teams too because it's they all tie together money academics auditing it's all a big it it really can be a little sexy so um thank you for all you do so I just wanted to say that um first the Lauren team they have to overcome the fear departments that she does they do a really good job of coming alongside the Department instead of a gotcha and then and um scaring people um but what's easy to do is once their audit is done and they have a set of recommendations we agree with them they're great recommendations but people always feel like it's above and beyond their their already day-to-day

138work and so it's easy to set it aside and then forget about it so um what we've done is one is we've started writing them into people's goals and their evaluations so that we make so they get attention two we do a monthly review of all of our kpis and we've added the uncomp incomplete measures to that monthly review um and then we also took some of those recommendations and created Qi teams around them so they're it's being addressed in different ways and having a very positive impact thank you uh so again thank you for all the hard work you all are welcome to stay if you'd like although I realized already said she feels bad um the one other little quick update that you if you didn't sit through a committee you didn't learn

139is that we have two big announcements that'll be coming throughout this next year from members of our audit team here have one of them who has this whole thing of like she decided she was gonna get married and stuff and another person said hey there's not enough of me in the world I want to bring another life into it yeah and then Isaac passed the CPA exam and then said I want so I'm pass so all kinds of big accomplishments going on in a thank you happy holidays um so bring it back to Stephanie here we will go back to now um policies policies so we we broke them up into a couple different categories of these and so first are a couple policies that we've talked about this committee the the next group is

140like a setup policies that we're thinking about and proposing to be further discussed so if we want to start uh right so the first two have been introduced and now we're just going to go into detail so we can decide whether to move them on or not and then the last three are new introductions so something to think about go ahead Mike Sure uh Rob can you go to the cash balances um slide please so this is the followup we brought this up a couple months ago the idea of having a cash balances policy it's slide 44 Rob look there you go all right so so so part of what we did the research is we looked at other um districts around the state as well as o asbo had a kind of white paper

141on cash balance policies all of them have basically the same four main parts and so we kind of tried to break it out that way in the slide so all of them have a goal all of them have a test so when do you look to see if you're meeting that goal all these policies have an action require ired and then one thing we're going to talk about is an implementation period so so we're proposing our goal would be to have 60 days of unencumbered cash um as a as a balance and we would look at the current fiscal year and the two subsequent fiscal years which nicely matches up of our fiveyear forecast um and so we would also report this at the fiveyear forecast in May and November and if you remember from

142the presentation there's a nice slide that's built into the slide deck already that shows your days on days of cash on hand going forward so would be kind of a kind of a takeoff of that um actions required are pretty similar across the board um it's generally that the treasure and superintendent create a plan on how we how we get from our cash back our current cash balance to our Target cash balance um and then obviously present that to the board for approval those are pretty standard the one thing obviously if if you looked at the look at the five-year forecast we're nowhere close to where 60 days at this point um and so one thing we'd want to talk about is an implementation period right I mean you this is not something you can

143handle in one in one year um but we talked about you know reserving a portion of each Year's Revenue to increase cash balances so have it set aside um and then also if there's significant unexpected Revenue to set some of that aside like an example I would use would be the um auditor the county auditor fees that we got back that was unanticipated 3.9 million so we could say hey before we spend and other things let's reserve some of it for cash if you go to the next slide Rob so this is just an example using current numbers so using five your forecast numbers if you remember from the presentation we had 35 days of cash available at the end of the second year um 60 days of cash would require us to have about

144$104 million um available it's about $11.74 million a day based on 365 days um and so to get to the Target balance just an example we said when want to get there five years we'd have to set aside around $12 million a year to do so and obviously you know there's a lot there's a lot of other paths to go but I think that's a good place to start the conversation Jen did you want to add anything I was just gonna say and later in a few minutes I'll show you the impact on the budget Target and how this impacts the budget Target think there's one more side on the cash balances also oh yeah the the third slide is just other districts um policy so in our research we just put them up there

145so you can kind of see what other folks are doing and how long they've been out there so so this this is a topic that we've been discussing for a few uh well not few months but basically the entire year not going back into last year um just something be paying attention to as well is because we will in theory have a larger amount of cash on hand with whatever we decide to do from a levy perspective and a couple years not this year or next year but um but it is something for us to be thinking about because again depending on when things get paid we need feedback on the 60 days whether that's acceptable to the board and is a five-year implementation plan acceptable 60 60 days $100 million off the top of

146our $624 million Revenue next year would make for a significant budget cut that we're already facing so um I is 60 60 days seems to be the common standard so is that appropriate to leave in there for thoughts um first of all great topic thank you for the chance to talk about the other um 60 days is and apologize if I missed this earlier what percent is that of our like to have 60 days um I guess I think do math right mons six yeah 18% is that right yeah it's close Okay so that seems like a minimum to me you know like with with 18% at my old job it was it was 35% right you know like you needed to have fund raise 35% extra it's 16.7% 16.7 that's was pretty close um

147uh or you're all just being very nice to me so yeah so I I I on on the so from my perspective is this is it good to have a policy about this yes um where I have some questions is this high enough you know should it be and like maybe it takes us longer to get there but like should it be higher than because I was looking at the districts and I recognize that they're close by to us so that might make them good examples but just because they're nearby doesn't mean that they're great you know they might be great I think we should Benchmark against whoever's best at this you know and my answer to who's best at this would be like who's got the strongest student outcomes and so we figure out

148like who's or maybe it's the Nexus of student outcomes and financial um uh strike you know so but you know I don't want to create extra work but but but I just I'm trying to figure out what should the bar be but then wherever we land on that I think my bigger concern is um you know I've certainly seen our board ignore board policy before it's easy to do um I think it's going to be particularly easy to do here because it's never easy to get to our there's always pressure to spend cash right yeah so but we you do have an approved resolution that you will not overspend your annual revenues over budget your annual revenues for that reason we can't go any lower in cash than we are we need to start building

149back our res I'm just I'm just saying that my worry is we will blow right through those You know despite the fact pass so one idea that you might play is what if the policy included some if the board doesn't do this here is blank what's going to happen in the budget you know and so you you create a congress once when during the Obama Administration either you pass a budget there's going to be like a 10% across the board cut you know and it it created a forcing mechanism to force people to come to an agreement that I don't think would have been there otherwise um and so um you know you'd have to make it bad um so that like whatever the board could get to would be better um but I just

150wanted to see what people thought about that so one of the uh hammers so to speak for that is the treasure can refuse to certify the budget yeah take a really strong treasure that anybody's gon want to keep their job you know I think I you have to Target the pain on the board members yes because I think I think that's that's the group that's going to want to um GNA want to spend the money rather than make the hard decision okay we get we'll look into them and if you'd like a board member to help propose that so that it's coming from a board member and not from you all right like I'm happy to play that role I just think okay we just passed um earlier this week a new evaluation policy for

151the superintend and one of the things that I really think makes it strong is it has backup rules in there like if the board doesn't do blank here's what's going to happen so like we have demonstrated at least one example of having done this and I think if this if we have to decide like is this something that really really matters seems to me like it does but if it does I think that we should we should maybe try to replicate the same idea okay well we have the policy chair Le be Ono outgoing outo they may never choose so I was thinking along the same lines I think I am slightly different than my colleague in that I think that the trigger should be because I think let me back up I think your

152department does a really good job of keeping the board informed so I don't think that that that there would be a lack of information I do think that it's very easy to take from it would be very easy to take from that just anybody would be like well let's let's take what we're saving but I do think that the triggers should be um incremental but kind of not necessarily that you don't certify the budget but that things happen uh to the to the board to the process and so I'm more comfortable rather than saying um and and forgive me just this is my thing rather than saying me as an employee of the board is not is going to do this that the board will have to realize something so don't put it on the

153on the treasurer but put it on that if if we don't make this for instance just is a very bad example but this is the only one I can think of quickly if um if the monthly payment is not made then this awareness goes up to the board and this triggers something not you doing that so what will happen is when we're filing the forecast the forecast is going to look really ugly and then we go into a series of fiscal stats States and then when you get to State aboard takeover then that's where the pain in the board comes in because you sto making this you stop being allowed to make the decisions yes somebody else does but I think that that awareness needs to be to the board in totality rather than the

154treasurer's actions not because then I can very easily see that being taken trickled down to the treasurer so I think it should be an awareness issue that the the Board needs to realize hey if this does not happen X is going to happen for you to recognize that this doesn't oh and if it happens again then it's it's an increased awareness so but I but I do want to look at I think that number is good but I also think there needs to um for the other board members there needs to be some comps there so that they recognize that this is not just you saying this this is really um comparable across the district and then maybe even go outside of Ohio to say um other urban districts that look like you and have

155faced X are are saving this number and maybe it's 15% maybe it's 30% but realistically over time what have other districts looked at that are very similar to your situation and I don't think you're going to be able to find that just within Ohio I think you're going to have to find that um comparable across other states but there are districts that look like us because I speak to some of them very regularly and they and they have faced some of the same things they don't have the state regulations but they have um some of the same demographics and they have had to decrease their reserve and are looking at this the very same thing comps simics and then the the uh the the I'm saying punitive but the awareness be to the board rather

156than to be to the treasure so we'll we'll come back in January with that information and some recommendations and then we'll add to the slides the penalties that the state does you know how you go through the stages so that'll start yeah good thank you and again I think the so what what I'm hearing also those is I think the idea of doing 60-day if not at some point maybe even escalating in future years to a higher number um is not a bad necessary U method of do it and I think also the process of doing it over a time frame is a good plan um I the one other thing I would possibly add to that thought process though is just we are looking at this as a policy for how we get there

157what happens once we're there so like maybe it is both the idea of getting there and then maintaining the 60-day may require certain things if this is not done then that y y y kind of deal as well so as we're adding language in about how do we get there make sure we're adding language in about once we're there our intended goal well and then to Mr Lindy's point at some point in time we should be rethink whether 60 days should be 70 days that way right so um maintain and then grow one other thing for me what would be very most helpful is kind of how we got here and so um again I'm into education and awareness of everybody and I think some of our board members do need that as well how

158it wasn't that we were trying to be neglectful but we got here very slowly and we're going to need to increase very slowly but just the picture of how we got here and then um the slow process and how we improve I think the next steps yeah bring it to bring it back in January and then I think what we would do from whatever the uh committee is that point will do from there is that if if what's brought back you know meets to what we're looking for the send it a policy um which is kind of the route we do um I think the other part is just uh working with general council's office just to make sure that there's no language in there that would be any kind of problematic things from us

159on the legal end U but we can do that in January before the that meeting um the next one next slide around so hopeful we can we can kind of move this one to policy if possible um this are capitalized assets policy so this is are fixed assets the big empathy for doing this is um Federal uniform guidance which is what we have to follow for any federal funds they change their capitalization threshold for a fixed asset so capitalization threshold is just how much an asset has to cost before you have to track it as a capital asset and do depreciation stuffff they changed it from 5 to 10 grand um if we want to go up to 10 grand which is good for us it's less things we have to track and depreciate we

160have to change our policy so it's it's either it's either your if your number is lower it goes by your number if you raise to their number they use their number so this just matches um Federal uniform guidance that's the big change couple other things in there has added some language around asset tagging and that kind of process what disposals and transfers look like this actually helps us kind of manage those assets better it gives people a little little more something in policy to help people go oh yeah this is part of the policy um nothing really controversial it's the same practice we've done for years it's just that um and then the final thing is there's a review of real estate um section just changing it um really changing the wording from B anual

161to B anal banal is the practice but but the words of the policy say B anual so for those of you who don't know by annual is every is twice a year and by annual is every two years that's easy one that get it's sort of like what is it bonly and semimonthly we go we deal with that all the time and like the payroll side of the world which one's which so any any feedback on those okay so we can take that one to F policy yes okay awesome okay next one um is receivables is there a Red Line version of that or you looking for us to okay mine I'll get it over to you thank you thank you Stephanie the next one to talk about is receivables and writeoffs so we don't

162actually have a receivables policy um and except for where it applies to cras and so we do bill for things other than CRA so I think it's it's good to do um we took this from highly from um another another Urban District so they have a nice um procedure manual we took some of the stuff from but high level ideas that defines what the receivable function is and you know the board you know has need to Bill people for different things um over time authorizes the treasure to charge late fees which again is in the CRA policy but isn't anywhere else um but there may be other things we want to charge late fees for from time to time and then the second part is it defines what uncollectible accounts are and we do have

163some of these um the two big things are folks who've folks who owe us money who filed bankruptcy or have other legal protections which you know we can't collect but it's going to stay on our books forever until we do something um or places where the cost of collection is greater than the amount owed you know I mean sometimes you get to a point where only thing you can do is file in small claims court sometimes the filing cost are more than what's owed and so this kind of doesn't make sense right you're not you're spending spending money spending more money than you're going to receive back um and so part of this would be to authorize a treasur to write off um uncollectible accounts under $5,000 um and then to have the board approve

164um accounts over $55,000 for writeoffs so this is a new so talking about this is the new category of stuff I think this is one that is important in in a lot of ways because we the fact we don't have one means that we don't really have a standard um to to how we would do it uh so it's definitely great the the only thing that comes to mind and my thought process that there are some accounts and we saw this with how we did contracts where you might have like one person has like six different things that might be under the amount or each of those individual things they may be in different stages of when they're due like would we be talking about those as each individual account or each individual I un

165collectible account or I would say any IND individual collectible under 5,000 versus individual collectible over 5,000 so that way you'll get the cluster as well okay um it's highly likely that there'll be a cluster because these are typically either CR cras who aren't collected we report those to the county and the city and then they help do stuff the other stuff is tuition and like employee overpayment so somebody leaves and then we we don't it hasn't entered in the system so we keep paying them getting that money back is a challenge um and so the first thing we do is we go through an escalation routine in AR and then it goes to a collection agency and we use the same one that the state auditor uses um and then at some point they declare

166bankruptcy they have a legal status and it's ridiculous for us to keep carrying that because we're never going to collect it yeah so if you want an example I didn't obviously didn't add this because it's people's names in it but um part of our employee overpayments and like their aged um we have five folks out there um and all of them have have Bank have chapter chapter 7even bankruptcy so the amounts they owe us are range from a minimum of $230 to about $4,500 so total of all five is under $10,000 but the individual accounts highest is is4 like $4,700 yeah so would it be preferable for me to when I get to a point to do the write off if I includeed in the treasures report as that schedule so I think so I

167think that would certainly be helpful um as we think about this policy one I I guess maybe the one thing I would want to make sure that we don't have is like for instance if we had a employee who also had some other reason that they were like they were were paid and they had some other debt right from something else that they should have received a payment for like inappropriate credit card charges yeah or you know something like we did we paid out for something else that like yes we may have reasons there be different in certain circumstances why we would collect so it gives you the authority to but there may be still opportunities where we would not necessarily right utilize this uh particular policy for particular reasons so we what we can

168do is write into the policy the the procedure where we bring the report and discuss it at finance committee before we do act on it because I mean I think most of these yeah they're absolutely going to be ones that we would say this is not worth our time and trouble to try and recover um but I do think there are times where we may have to follow different procedures for different uh reasons that go into whether or not we want to take other actions against a person yeah that may very different if we say we want to do this but we wrote off the debt anyway so we didn't really care but we want to the policy does have some kind of protections for that that like for example Le you're a former employee

169we write it off you come back and want to re be rehired then we have the conversation um same thing for a vendor say there's a vendor you know and they come back and want to be a vendor again well then you're going to have before we're going to let you in as a vendor you know we need to talk about this this written off debt and yeah I mean unless unless there's other thoughts from board members on this one I think it's certainly something that we should uh keep on the agenda for for January of next year then Poss move that again to policy um with a little bit of the fine tuning there yeah that you they have copies of the red line right it's yeah it's in it's linked in the slide

170so it'll give you a chance to read through them and ask questions okay they're all linked in the bottom of the slides sorry Dr M just a quick question um what do other districts do for this so this is very yeah this is a very similar the way that you all have written it like this is pretty comforable yeah we talk about our treasure huddle yeah all the urbin yeah the men is it C is it is it I don't want to say a growing problem but is is the need for this pretty significant across this the Jin and Men I don't know it's a growing problem I think we all have it but you know a lot and and like I think everyone kind of goes through their process and you just get these

171things of sat for years and so some of it's just like like how old are those there like 2021s and probably when they went to and so at some point like you either ignore it you know or you say let's get this off our books what's the adverse effect to it remaining on our books I mean obviously there is more work for David okay so I'm just I'm just thinking like is there is there a fiveyear limit where it triggers something or like what obviously you want it off the books but I'm I'm just thinking yeah I mean and we do our third party collections agency still tries to collect you know I mean but we pay them right so we're paying we pay them a percentage of what they get back right but it

172that cost is passed through the user not us okay okay so say if we they owed us $1,000 they would add their fee so that that person would have $1,000 plus their fee to pay back yeah okay thank you you I'm just going to add the auditor like an Auditor's perspective on that would be also increased accuracy of what our financials represent so that way we aren't overstating collectibles in fact that we'll never collect so I think that that was already said but I just as we look at the accuracy of the numbers that we have in our systems it's going to be more appropriate so I think that would make a lot of sense I think the thought process is really strong there thank you thanks Lauren thank you Lauren make David's life easier

173we do not want to we don't want to complicate you this is gonna be this will forever be known as the David meeting right end of the year way to kick it off thank you thank you all right so next slide thank you um this is kind of a subset of this topic but also comes in so we wanted to have a conversation with you guys about aged student fees um and so and so as you know um as you know at started this year we moved our student Information Systems um from power school to focus and as a COR are to that is we moved kind of the student fee system from a system called pay schools um into focus focus has a billing module an AR module which is nice for the parents

174because it's like a One-Stop shop right so we that's really good thing um very good the problem is we have all this data in the old pay school system that we need to get moved over to the focus AR module um and it's timely now because especially for the seniors like senior parents are starting to think through like okay I got to get I got to get all my kids stuff paid um you know you know because they're starting to think about graduation so the schools are kind of pushing us um Jen you want to say something yeah so this is um an unintended consequence of decentralizing financial transactions because up to this point the treasur office don't get other than doing the districtwide fees that we've now waved we don't participate in the collection

175the schools do that so there's a growing balance of unpaid fees and the unfair Ness of it is when they collect it as a high school the high school keeps the money where the elementary schools lose out on the deal because it follows them through their academic career um and some of them as we've been looking at the data some of the fees are how many people are in are now inactive cons I can't remember the number5 million yeah so so there's 15 and a half million dollars of and again the other thing the other well the other thing I would say is you have to realize that most of our fees get waved or reduced um I mean part of it is a paperwork thing is is that a lot of these students were

176eligible at some point for free and reduced lunch in their in their career um you know and it's basically you fill out a form and the fee gets waved but people don't do that until they get to the end and it's like oh I got to get this done you know you know so my kid can graduate so a lot of this gets waved anyway um and you can see that through the collections I see Michelle's nodding over there she she know you know she knows from a school perspective so yeah so 50 a half million seems like a huge number um some buckets so about 1.8 is just obsolete fee types these are fees that were like like in order to go back we would have to try to figure out what the initial

177intention was you know the GL codes are linked back to the Oracle system we haven't had Oracle since 20164 so you know I mean we're talking about I we're talking some really old stuff um another two and a half million are fees is assessed to inactive students so these students have left the district obviously their fees stayed um but if they're not coming back I don't see and then 11.2 million is for actual current students if you go goad or did you want to say something sorry okay and then I just had a couple quick graphs here the first one's outstanding fees by grade level you can see the vast majority of it's in the high schools um or not not the majority but the most of you know the highest per in the high

178schools um followed you know it kind of goes downhill obviously if you don't pay your fees every year and by the time you get to high school you're going to owe more money right kind of makes sense um there's a little bit of preschool tuition in there and then there's that giant inactive students um thing that we talked about and then if you go to the next slide Rob just another way to look at it um is by due date year so I got we had this kind of table of when the due date was for the fees I don't 100% trust this data but you can see there's a lot of old old stuff out there the weird thing is look at 2011 yeah that's crazy what is going on that's what I said

179recording that's I said I don't 100% trust this data but you can see um and then just the final graph there is is for active students are active currently you know you know what this outstanding fees are you can see most of them are the grade level fees which which are the fees that we we chose not to collect this year but obviously they have you know up to 11 up to 11 previous years of fees that have accumulated I think with this um and I'll get some board feedback as well or some other board MERS feedback as well but I think some of this also ties into what we ultimately decide to do as a board with regards to fees and general so I think both both a policy with regards to how we

180handle aged fees but because there still will be things that we need fees for um but then also what is our Bard policy with regards to what are things that we would have fees for uh may need to be another part of that discussion model um but I want to open up to thoughts your Dr M so I want to be real clear because I had kids back when it started this graph at 2020 or 2002 that were in school fees is not always just the $35 that we're collecting it also can include damaged items it can also include fiill trips it can also include other things and um so it's so I don't I want to make sure that we say public that it is not simply just the up to $35 fee we

181are only the district decided to only wave the $35 fee or up to $35 fee but that's not the only thing that is inclusive of student fees that needs to be clarified and then also um I want to ask a question to treasure Wagner when one of my sons was in school he went to a monory school but in high school we had to look look at the fees being paid for graduation when you say that the high school collects the money we had to go back to the monory school elementary school principal to get those fees waved so some of I don't know if there's consistency around the high school getting those fees that are collected and keeping the money that may be the end result but I've also heard of other parents who

182had to go back to the schools that where the kids were for fees other than $35 not just for school fees in order to get those waves and that particular principal wasn't even a principal he was like in the district someplace else so I don't know if we can differentiate these the these figures to be what are School District wable fees the $35 and what are other fees being charged because it's not just the $35 student fees that are represented in student fees yeah if you look at the graph um if you and we try to do that the in the graph on the right there the the huge line those are those are the $35 kind of grade level fees are we on this slide yeah on this slide okay the big bar is

183a $35 cative over the last 22 years but but yeah you also you're absolutely right there's intercession fees that aren't paid in there there's lost damage items I mean those are some significant ones so so the board did not decide to wave all fees so I just want to be really really clear because some people have been like oh I didn't know okay so we don't have a balance um you do because the the fees are not just inclusive of the $35 but I'm also wondering is there a way to notify parents prior to graduation more timely either that be quarterly is that what you all are working towards because part of the problem which I do feel for parents is when you let me know in May that my son or daughter is graduating

184and oh I've got a $700 bill for fees that may or not may not be the $35 that is cost prohibitive but if I know at the and I know it's there I'm not saying that it's not there I'm just saying that they may not be aware of it and now we've switched the focus so that's another layer of potential confusion do we let them know that well it's to this point this procedure is handled at the school site okay so the the the process and the procedures really needs Improvement and then there's to be monthly reporting and quarterly reporting or something and then yes reporting out to the school so we we really need um a team that figures out what's the right process to do um if the Treasures Office takes over that

185then we might need resources this the collection would probably pay for that so just the green is back though to what what was being offered is though is that we don't have a policy to handle once those fees have aged right so like I think there is definitely a conversation around how do we notify and all these other things with regards to new fees and fees that have currently kind of sitting there but we do have a number of fees that are also aged going back to you know now like 2002 uh that may need to be uh addressed so I think I think from our what we want to do today is just discuss whether or not we even want to have a policy about how we hand those age fees well my question

186that was getting to my question sorry I'm a little longwinded so are we talking about in the policy potentially getting rid of the historical fees that's what I was asking because the fees is not are we talking about just the fees or are we talking about what the fee entails to potentially get rid of so I'm asking the question about how you're asking requesting to structure the potential policy when there's that large number of delinquencies and it's not just what the board decided to waigh that what we're looking for is an ability to write off what is not going to ever be collected the likelihood of them like we're not going to go back to somebody from 2002 and collect money I gotta so so there's that but then we need a process moving forward

187right okay that has some teeth so that you can then hold people accountable to the act the work gotcha and that we are more successful with managing that this would go away well potentially well it would get a lot smaller okay that's what I was asking yeah people continue to not pay this is coming out of a a student information system so I don't know how accurate the information is sure it's never been reconciled to any kind of billing on our side because we don't do that right schools do it so it's just it's it's just a convoluted system needs to be fixed to keep us going here um and really quick you Laura but I just gonna say I think this is something we can certainly bring back for future conversations as to what

188that policy look like yeah I just was going to make a quick comment it related back to some of the work we did through internal audit project and I think it is one of the outstanding recommendations and I just wanted to agree it was kind of a well here we are today what do we want to do to improve this moving forward that's kind of what I think the big disc decision the board made around the student fees not charging them this year however we have all of this data that we also worked through and I concur the data is not highly reliable accurate or detailed so it's very difficult to say uh what kind of Integrity do these hold and go after people and request they pay these things do we even have the

189full set of information so I I really appreciate this coming forth because I think it will help us clean up his historical what do we do in that regard for a past recommendation and also prevent that and put better more consistent procedures in place moving forward so all right so let's keep going to the last one here quickly so we can get to we have the last little section of stuff that I wanted to on before hoping this one's a slam dunk which I probably jinxed myself for um so this yeah so so this this one corresponds to employee um reimbursements when employees travel so traditionally the district's policy is we we will reimburse you up to what's called the GSA limit which I'll talk about a minute um with receipts so so what happens

190is general service Administration is a federal government agency they set a meals and incidental rate for every location in the United States and say if and and a lot of companies most a lot of nonprofits a lot of local governments all use the GSA rates because they're kind of set by set by the federal government um but what we do we do probably the most complicated which is we go up to the GSA limit plus we need receipts and we spend a amazing amount of time looking at people's receipts for meals they spend and we spend an amazing amount of time trying to clarify rules so for example right now one of the rules is because C this CBG airport is within our kind of area we don't pay you for meal at the airport

191so then people say well if I can't get paid to eat lunch at the airport what if I get a meal on the plane okay well you're in the air you're outside a region but but but we all but we all know airpl food is awful and it's four times more expensive right um and so and so talking with our other partners again the J and the men conversation of other ones like like most other folks switch to just a per DM right so you travel you come in you get your per DM rate right and most of the times it's like it's up to most most places in America it's $68 a day it can go down from there it can go up from there actually um but we but our kind of idea

192would be can we just switch from for employee travel for meals and switch from having all the receipts and all that to just doing a per DM rate for employees um it would save us we calculated would save us over 1300 hours of Staff time a year so this is like one of those work smarter not harder kind of things this is one of those how do we change business um it would save The Travelers and their staff probably an amount of time and it just people flexibility like we have all these things like oh I just want a bottle of water we don't really pay for snacks okay so so I can go to the restaurant and get a meal I don't eat and a bottle of water and we'll pay that like so

193so I don't know I mean it just it seems like a really clean change I think the employees will really enjoy it for those who travel I know our staff will enjoy it I think it just it takes a lot of contention and a lot of a lot of detail that doesn't need to be there out of this process so again um I think what we're offering this out us is for them to come back with a policy that would reflect a a switch from reimbursements to perdum um I don't know if Bor have any issues with that um sounds like a no-brainer thank you I I would say I think the one thing that would would come with that is just making sure whatever systems we use to track and all that kind of

194stuff as part of whatever we put in the policy because I think sometimes we also have policies that reiterate things that we don't longer use or ways that we do stuff that we don't longer do it that way so um really quickly yeah two sorry I was just going to say there is a job related expenses policy which is 3440 so I don't know if instead of accting a new policy did more so adding language to that one I I actually don't know that we need to change the policy I think the policy I think 3440 says the treasurer will create procedures for reimbursing people for job related expenses so not procedure but but this is a big procedure that's why we want to bring it here right this is like this isn't just like

195oh fill out this form instead of this form this is a much I do think this is something that would come before it should go before a policy committee also and then actually some point through the full board but L your and other benefit of reduction in audit and compliance risk because with every receipt that they process is a risk that something deviates from the rules and so on and so forth so I think this would be a lot cleaner from an audit perspective too cool um well that is all of the new policy suggestions thank you for that hard work uh the last section we're going to cover before we uh depart for the holidays um and I know some folks may have to leave early so feel feel free to just out if

196you need to um just wanted to again put we're in this period of time we're in the budget cycle and um I think one of the things we can maybe do in Jen I don't know if you can do this uh quick way yeah uh but there are a couple really key points I just wanted to put in for that I thought it'd be good for Jen to put in front of us to think about as we're talking about building the budget so Jen you wanna yeah so Rob if you can bring this staff the budget timeline up I sent you or shared with you we just we had a budget steering committee meeting last night so I didn't have a chance to post it or do anything but um because of um changes in

197the growth plan we're we're having to it's Staffing doing the Staffing budgets has become a little bit more complicated so we're taking the time rather than to put something out um and Julie sellers really suggested delaying it until January so that we have time to go through what how does a staff change during a consolidation versus a combination versus a restructure pretty complicated so we're taking time to do that review it before it goes out and people start freaking out so um I can't read that so so we're taking the first part of um January to do that work um we'll send that out oh come on I can't talk and type at the same time here budget time one yeah I got it okay I can't see yours either got 100 over 60 come

198on okay so um so hopefully by the end of at the end of that first week in January we'll finish with the quality control review is what I'm calling it um and then we'll send it Staffing out to the schools by the 9th and then they have an appeal process um so that gets taken care of that feeds into the transfer rounds which will be pretty complex this year I believe um that usually starts in early February so we're just a little bit behind our normal schedule um we're going to do training on Al of VI retrain refresh training people um late in January we'll send the non-personnel stuff and load it in right when they're done being trained so it'll be fresh in their mind on how to do what to do and then

199we will'll kick off the central office and actually teach them what zerobase budgeting really is and what our budget targets um initiatives that we want funded um so we're hoping the deadline for the schools to submit their budgets back to us be February 14th they have to go through ilt and lsdmc meetings to get there then um the deadline for central office will be just a week later two weeks later um that gives us the first couple weeks in March to for the senior leadership team for us to do the consolidation go through all our checklist to make sure nobody missed anything like last year when Schedule E got submitted a day after I presented publicly um stuff like that and then um you know the gas is always greater than the target so we

200have some time to make recommendations we're hoping going to go with a first Public Presentation in April the first board meeting in April we'll use April and May to do public engagement and um seek board approval on June 23rd so I can file with the Hamilton County budget Commission on the 26th and over to the right of that I have little prayer hands I don't know if you can see my little Emoji oh it's on my screen but it's not over there okay anyway I did I added a little prayers so we're going to meet June 26 from my last year here um so if you'll switch over to the budget Target sheet this is real quick um and so this is a work in progress I don't want anybody to get any number firm

201in their head because there's a lot of moving Parts I don't have all the information yet good job Rob you're awesome so you see that over there in highlight red work in progress so our forecast November for this is where we start with the budget Target is we said our um forecast can't be higher than our revenues right so that's the 624 million that we've estimated based on current information um around student enrollment that drives State Foundation payments property tax values blah blah blah 624 million if we do the cash Reserve plan we'll take 12 million off the top so that means we only have 612 million left to spend okay so now look at the current year budget at 644 this is kind of answering Mr Lindy's question about keeping that positive cash balance

202so if we do nothing different or we have step increases that are already negotiated we've bringing on the crossing guards we said it's going to bring us an extra million dollars in budget we have to bring the Suzuki U Back to the general funds this year we used a grant that had some money sitting in it a local Grant we promis the unions who sacrific their PD money to help balance a budget this year that it would return in the following year um we have a tech there's a line in there for Cola we're getting ready to enter negotiations just to point that one% Cola cost the general fund about $4 million Mike's recalculating it now with the current staff so I can get a more firm number there um the technology return we actually

203used that tail end of the eser money um to help pay for some of the technology leases this year so that money comes back next year um the centralized enrollment is an initiative that it's not going to cost anything we're just realigning staff to create that and then the monu expansion is a relocation of preschool monu that of teachers and supplies and um we delayed the rosson renovation of 350,000 in the 24 budget um because they weren't going to be able to get it done and spend it right so that's a $15 million add to what we're already spending um and then we're offsetting with the grow savings that I'm waiting for all this revision staff stuff to happen to update that number but you remember the netet savings was 1.4 million then we come

204to the preschool expansion so I'm estimating at the end of this year we'll have about $10 million left in cash carryover um if our combined budgets go beyond beyond the 15 million okay so I have that as a placeholder so sitting today we're looking at about 45 million at least in spending reductions keep in mind that the budget supports recurring costs but it also supports one time cost that can be replaced with some of these issues and so we'll keep reporting on this as we go um I did not post this any of this stuff publicly because we just worked through it last night but um just wanted see and and it's a it's going to be a painful conversation the budget will be a painful time this year because we're trying to fund new

205initiatives strategic stuff and we have to let go of some things remember my water bottle analogy okay so um so we're going to the Zer zerob based Staffing method and we're trying to decide within the B budget steering committee how to make that happen at all of you um Mike did this beautiful document and this actually started with Mike and Derrick little last year when we're trying to identify what is our really discretionary funds spending and so you can go through that but you can right at the bottom there is a fixed and Regulatory $51 million right off the top you can't cut because it's debt payments or the auditor fees blah blah blah so um so then what does that leave you and then so they broke it we def find some of the

206categories to be more a little bit more meaningful um board discretionary the union negotiated staff why don't you to take over documents yeah so obviously board discretionary things the board controls directly um you need negotiate Staffing a staffing for all of our Collective Bing agreements you know CFT is the biggest of those but asme iua all them have as well other negotiated Staffing are basically other things in the collective agement aren't staff like the PD the PD fund is a good example that Jen mentioned um District created formulas is probably the place where we have the most leeway but those are things like your APS those are things like some of the pairs we have those things so so there's there's a lot of leeway there but they're also critical things you know counselors social

207workers um core instructional operations are just basically your Core Curriculum and the people support that we also have the same thing with with um oper business operations so that's like you know payroll team AP team you know HR staff people are people are doing that work so the the salary of the treasurer and the salary of the superintendent because you're required to have those you can't cut them um are in the district fix line but our departments are in the core operations um there's a couple others here so individualized needs which we start out call it non-formula so like what is that but this is a lot of the individual student needs so these are these are like your related service providers your El your uh OTS pts speech pathologists you know people who are

208who are who we work because they're serving individual student needs um and then supplemental operations it's kind of that next tier of things if they're not core they're supplemental um also some really important things are in there um and then enrichment obviously is your Arts um your sports and such so I think that's kind of a high level the categories um you can see I got the totals in here for this year and so as we build out I guess 26 you know start to put these numbers and where they fall so we really just wanted to introduce this quickly um so that is on our thoughts and as we go into the next year on the budget I don't think we have time today for real discussion around it um but again recognizing that

209this is going to be a difficult year and how we do our budgets because everyone's gonna have to start from you start from zero you add in the things that you have to do and then from there we're going to be looking at what can we do what can we not do right um so if there are nothing else I just want wish everyone a very happy holiday season everybody have safe travels and safe times with your family and there's nothing else

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.