001e e e good thank you seeing a quorum of voting members I call the December 18th Cincinnati school board meeting to order superintendent would you please introduce our uh students virtually that are leading Us in the pl thank you absolutely seeing a quum of voting members I call the December 18th Cincinnati school board meeting to order for all posterity I'm recorded so today we are going to introduce to you students from College Hill Academy where Brandon Kingman serves as the principal please rise students please join me in saying the Pledge of Allegiance Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God in with liberty and justice for all wonderful job treasure Wagner would you please call the attendance rle Mr Craig here
002M Crossett here Mr Lindy here miss map Dr Moffett here vice president Weinberg president Bolton pres uh vice president uh Weinberg um yeah we will be talking about how we can uh virtually participate but I'm not altogether sure today uh do we have anybody virtually participating has anyone signed up but not signing up okay and uh we'll uh I don't know that we have uh anyone in person today speaking no great uh I don't think so maybe say especially for virtual yes so I'll say it members of the public who are online and wish to speak during our hearing of the public this evening may do so by clicking the chat button now the chat feature will be open for your requests for 5 minutes if you would like a direct response to your questions
003please make sure to share your name your affiliation to the district your school Community topic and your contact information thank you the chair will now entertain a motion and a second to approve uh the uh uh revised December 18th business meeting agenda do I have a motion thank you I have a second second thank you treasure Wagner would you please call a voting rle I'm sorry I didn't catch who made the motion thank you Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett Mr Lindy yep Dr Mett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes um thank you all and the agenda as revised is approved uh Treasurer Wagner would you please uh present the topic for uh the first presentation I'd be happy to although the board member who asked for not here is she coming she is
004she's she's here okay do you want to flip it with somebody else or uh why don't we uh look at the resolution uh for the evaluation of the superintendent we'll go to Mr uh Lindy if that's all he's almost ready Miss Balton she was also part of the policy committee making that but however what I can do uh item five resolution amending board policy 34302 is straightforward happy to get that done what I'm asking I'll buy everybody some time um uh afternoon everybody um uh so item five is a resolution amending board policy 34302 uh leave for employment by a community school um this was something that we had originally um uh thought might be bundled within the consent agenda because it's part of this um policy modernization project we've been doing for the last
005several years where rather than having two separate bodies of policies one for certificated staff and one for non-certificated staff we are merging them into one set of policies that apply to all CPS employees um the the driver on the need for a policy like this as I understand it is Ohio State law uh and so we used to have two policies that said this one for one type of Staff one for another The Proposal that is on the agenda today is merging those so that we now have one section for all employees um I do not see Dan but he will speak from somewhere and tell me if I got that wrong In fairness to all the people that in and out we've just come from an hour and 15 minutes of a fact finding
006so that's part of everyone's confusion and followup to those meetings uh could I ask a question if I might about this uh sure I will do my best but I might ask um Mr Crossett or Miss map um to help me out here if we don't have Mr Hing that would be great uh I'm I'm interested in what what's the definition of a community school is that the same as a charter school I think that's the way Ohio Revised Code refers to Charter Schools yes that's correct so is it the purpose of this policy that if a CPS now maybe I'm reading this wrong CPS employee teacher or staff member I guess since it's everybody uh decides that they're taking a leave of absence from Cincinnati public to work at a a charter or Community
007School that we're giving them that leave of absence at their request so to work in competition so from my understanding um as it was presented at the policy meeting so yes um employees of the district would be um allowed to have a leave of absence I believe up to 3 years if I'm not mistaken to go and work um in a community school or a charter school and when I had a discussion with Dan around it um from my understanding he shared that it has education implications so maybe if it's uh just starting they need um Educators to go and support the development of that school um so they do have the opportunity to um work for that school for 3 years I think there may be language in there that says that that could
008be extended but I think would have to be decided upon um but yes that is something that the um Ohio Revised Code um is mandating for us to do okay so we would be required by law to allow that to happen correct I think we we are we have been required by law it's currently a policy that already exists there just two of them one for certificated one for non-certificated and all this is doing is merging that into one and and I'm I'm clear on that and I appreciate that the other thing I would ask if it's okay with the rest of the board um is there some part of this that also talks about us paying for some part of their employment with the community or Charter School I don't know if we will
009be paying for them or I think you may be right in terms of the benefits yes I haven't read this in the last week or so but it's that we um we would be paying part of their compensation at a community or Charter School through our dollars I I believe so I wish Dan was wasn't here to give more interpretation of it but I do recall reading something that discussed that we would also be responsible to support their benefits does that is that do we know we'll wait for Dan to come back on that uh yeah my my understanding is that we we we are doing nothing extra in these policies above and beyond what's required of us by Ohio law great and and if that's the case it may be that the Ohio law
010is wacky um but it's wacky we know that that's a given yeah uh I I think it's just one if this is the case in Ohio revised code again it shows the uh unlevel playing field that the state legislature has put together uh regarding US public schools districts and the public Charters so to if the if the requirement is that we have to do this by law that's an issue and we can see why it came out of policy for that reason I think merging you know the professional and the nonprofessional all that stuff I think that makes sense but I do think it's important every opportunity we have to demonstrate to the public the situation under which we are um spending their money uh perhaps against our will uh not to mention in a
011teacher shortage why on Earth we would be uh wanting or needing to help uh have our teachers go some place else Dr mofet so I I really had a couple of questions about it and and really wanted some uh clarification I'm kind of wanting to table this until Dan can uh can until Dan um Mr hn can offer some clarity because I'm wondering is this saying that we're maintaining their employment with us well because if they are if we are liable on page two of the propo of the um the policy it says uh eligibility for benefits while on leave of absence and it has a nice lengthy paragraph I don't know if the um if you can pull that up Rob that'd be great I'm looking at 5B res amending policy 34302 so that
012people can look at what we're talking about I I'd like a little bit more clarity around if they are maintaining their employment here so they'll have technically have dual employment if they're acre some sort of St strs benefit that sounds as if they are having some dual employ employment or here it comes Dan Dan man of the Dan I text Dan like we need you in here right now you know that the moment you step out of the room is the moment can you come in I said Dan we need you right now that's great what what I what I've I don't interrup you it's okay I'm on page two and I just wanted a little bit more clarification under eligibility for benefits while on leave of absence ah yes this is the this is
013this is a board policy that is determined by Statute required to have this policy by Statute sorry go ahead with your question so my question was it sounds as if we are required to somehow maintain their eligibility for employment with us while they go and work for someplace else and then they are acre benefits with regard to St strs and are are there any and and what type of financial ramifications and if you know that's my first question what so the language in the policy is verbatim from the language of the statute there is nothing we're doing here beyond what we are absolutely required to do by Statute the what we are required to do essentially is to allow employees the leave to up to three years to go work for a charter school if
014they're if they so choose we are not required to pay for any benefits but they are allowed to stay on our benefits during that time at at fully their cost uh they don't acrw I don't believe they acrew any benefits from us during the time that they're they're uh employed by a charter school so it says that they're eligible for insurance benefits corre that are provided to regularly employed staff members in the Str strs benefit it says that they are not permitted to approve personal leave can you explain provided the employee pays the entire cost associated with such benefits yes so that that would include not only the sort of Premium cost that all our employees pay but the cost that essentially the Cobra cost cost M if that makes sense so it's yeah okay
015so I'm wondering can you share since this has been on the books and it looks like it's Ohio Revised Code uh 3430 can you share if there have been any costs to the district for people that have done this over the past few years to my knowledge I'm not aware of any employee who has and I'm looking at HR I'm not aware of any employee who has um asked for this sort of leave yeah I this is this is a statute that I assume was passed by the general en assembly at a time when they were trying to get charter schools up and running in the state and Charter School operators said gosh we've got property now from the P public schools that they've been required to sell to us we just don't have have
016teachers and staff to work in our buildings and so the state said oh I've got a great idea we'll we'll allow employees of public schools to go on leave to work at these Charter Schools I I don't think that played out in terms of our are we're not losing a lot of employees to this Pro leave provision however it it is still on it's an Ohio Revised Code provision that says every school board shall have this policy okay is that helpful very much so sorry for uh it's okay sorry to have to send you text any other questions for Dan we had a good discussion out there Brandon excuse me Mr Craig I just want to note um all of this requires them to then apply to the board to give permission like it's not
017like if we had seen this happen before we would have seen it through some type of board action yeah so you know again I don't recall anyone ever doing that in my time on the board I don't know if it's happened too many times before then but I just think this is one of those things is not you know the state makes bad laws it's great they make bad laws we have to you know add to our rules and regulations and at times you have to do it almost verbatim this is just another example of that and so the only thing I'd add also the only reason it's before you today is again we've been combining classified yeah okay so chair the chair presented that I shared that part thank you thank you uh thank
018you any other questions or comments glad to be able to share this and um I think Mr Craig is right this uh would have to be approved and I would assume maybe that the superintendent and other people in HR uh have just heard some concerns expressed about this uh uh law not about the policy but about the law and I'm sure that that will inform anybody that's interested in applying for such a uh interesting opportunity to leave us and go to the competition so um are we prepared can I motion that it be passed this evening I'll I'll motion we adop it is there a second for the resolution for passage sure second thank you thank you Mr Crossett um any discussion I think we've had it uh Treasurer Wagner Mr Craig yes yes Mr
019Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton abstain if we move on let's go back to where we were if we could does that work for you uh treasur Wagner certainly everybody thanks for making adjustments so's that I know good evening everyone good evening so we're here to talk about very exciting topic not I love it so um cops are um officially known as certificates of participation next slide so this is the definition out of Investopedia I won't read it because it's very technical and very difficult to understand but a cops is a way to finance a project related to new construction or renovation um that acts like a lease but think of it as a second mortgage so instead of of getting a mortgage from
020the bank you get you're selling certificates to investors a bundle at a time and the bundle is a mix of lengths to attract better interest rates so the difference between a bond Levy and a cops financing that you could Finance the same project with two different tools the bond Levy and um creates property taxes where the homeowners pay the tax to use that money to pay the principal and interest on the the bond right so you get the money to do your construction up front you have a a annual a 30-year Revenue stream to pay the principal interest until the bonds expire on a cops um the money comes from doesn't have a revenue Source other than your general fund operating budget so you have to make room for a lease payment we pay so
021the the property that's being renovated or purchased becomes um The Leverage for the lease and um people are investing in that and then you're making annual payments out of your general operation budget so there's not a new in uh Revenue stream to help you make those payments okay next slide so the key takeaways um I probably already said this investors um have a prolease of the financing agreement um they're generally used by governmental agencies um including school districts um and how many found I think I said everything else here that some of them are tax exempt not all of them um next Slide the the also the issue with cops is that you have a three-year window to pay or you get fined by the IRS so in in thinking of our fiveyear facility repair
022plan we'd have to do two separate cops and and and size them individually the benefit of using cops for Education um systems is it doesn't become part of your debt ratio calculation um and so it's easier to to deal with um but so we're going to go through we have um I think six if I remember correctly six different issuances to deal with so in 2006 we had an issuance of $120 million the revenue stream is the what came from the city County Stadium agreement where the city uh C Cincinnati City and Hamilton County paid us annually we put that money into a fund and then we paid the annual payments of this particular issuance this was in conjunction with the facility Master pan plan that we use this money to to do create our
023local share so we use this money to do walut Hills Western Hills with thr Woodward and Hughes and then 26 other buildings for Windows and Doors and um some elementary schools to help with their the local share of the FMP it's be it's been refunded three times the word refunding is same as refinance in a mortgage World okay um so I'll go through those in a little bit but um the original balance that's left from that original 2006 issuance is 20 million so it was 120 now it's 20 um we have interest due of 3.8 throughout the life and it expires in December of 2032 the kicker on these is that once you have a um building that's encumbered through a cops so it's it's been leveraged as uh Capital you can't encumber again so
024you can't get a third mortgage on it okay next slide so then in 2012 we issued a $26 million cops um to coincide with House Bill 264 and building improvements and we used 28 different facilities to three got new roofs the rest got security systems HVAC elevators Windows back in 2012 the balance on that issuance is 11 million with um n almost $10 million in interest and the final payment will be June of 2032 next slide in 2018 we did a cops to P purchase the mercy building for gamble monu we also um use it to improve cans because we took can possession of cans back and um we did some improvements with carage and leap we are now uh we it was 22 now it's 16 million with a balance of interest in the
025schedule of 5 million and that expires in June of 2038 next slide in 2021 we refinanced some old debt part of the 2014 cops which was a refunding of 2006 um of see because you have those bundles they expire they have different lengths of time so at certain points you can take a a portion of a bundle and then refinance you can't always do the whole thing so that's why they call it partial refunding but so we we refunded in 21 $62 million um it we now owe 58 and it expires in 1232 this activity if I remember correctly saved us about a million and a half dollars in interest moving forward next slide so here's a summary so the 2006 that the part that was not refunded is we just paid it off in
026December like couple days ago so yay um in two so then in the 2016 portion that we refunded in 2015 there's $20 million um and I'm showing you the source the annual payment is 2.8 million but it comes from the county money now um and expires 2032 then the other portion that was refunded in 2021 was 58 million um that's also funded by the city county money so we have two cops that are funded by the general fund operating budget and that's represents about 4 million is in annual payment um and the 2012 was the um House Bill 264 and 2018 was the mercy building and plus so um that's the end of what I have to say so you have any questions oh yes um do board members have any questions regarding cops uh
027and what that may mean uh Remember map yes thank you um so one if I go back you said the difference between the bond is that's um creating property tax for the homeowner so that's the funding source for a bond but for the uh cops this is where um ultimately we're kind of uh we're taking out a second mortgage so there is there isn't a funding source for that particularly the funding source is your general operating funds oh okay so a bond is funded in the investors are the homeowners a cops the investors are just investors from JP Morgan Chase you know other Banks or our good friends individuals yes um so on this summary that you have up up here I guess can you break down the the difference between the city and county
028sources is that pertaining that wouldn't be pertaining to the taxpayers correct or correct so when they built the stadiums this is related to the stadiums when they built the stadiums there was a negotiation that they would pay us this money annually in Le of taxes and then we chose to use that to help pay for FMP okay okay all right and then for um okay that's all that I have right now just looking at the total balance okay for the uh for all of the payments that are still outstanding thank you member map do other board members have any questions or comments about uh the certificates Mr Craig Finance chair quick note I I would say that just as a point we while it's something we had looked at and I know we looked at
029it last year as a method of uh thinking about our facilities master plan and other things I think what we kind of determined is the number of facilities that currently are under a cops agreement also pres present some restrictions on what you can do within those buildings and so it it was more feasible to look at some of the other options like a pi Levy like a bond Levy to do some of the long-term Investments that we have to do in our buildings um because of also the debt payments that you're also required to make which means you have to clear out funds within your general fund which we don't exactly have a lot of space in the general fund to be clearing out um to cover new debt payments so was something that I
030think we have and we'll be continue to talk about it because I think that's something next year we have to do in the early part of the year um but I think we were looking more at the bond Levy and the pi Levy or or another form of payment Beyond cops because of some of the restrictions based on the number of facilities that currently already have cops um uh cops interest on them at this point Thank you Mr Craig other questions comments I I would just ask one and I I may when I stepped out may have missed it in order to fund what does it cost to fund a million dollars or10 million for cops um so the 2018 issuance was 22 million and um we were paying about two million a$2 to3 million
031a year it as you pay it off it the schedule changes um I'd have to calculate but I I was thinking like a at one time in in the budget we did a calculation it was like 50 to 60 million and I estimated a $5 million annual lease payment if I'm thank you yeah I think we about 70 as well somewhere along the line but so is it work out about that same percentage okay yeah I mean we it's is based on the market rates right and interest rate and our credit rating so as long as we keep a good credit rating we'll get better rates but um if I mean I can try to size some for you during the current market and bring it back to you but anything we wanted to do
032with cops we'd have to it would have to be part of our general fund budget which means we couldn't be doing something else exact do it but you spend a certain amount of money to get more money maybe more quickly or not as part of a giant big Bond thing that would have to necessarily pass but we also have a not a limited number of schools where we could use cops but there is a specific list that could be used if uh we could use cops for that we haven't already used for cops as long as you make room in your budget to pay it yeah that's exactly right so that's why I prefaced it by saying that first member map yeah I was just thinking about to your point if we're thinking about the
033general fund budget so while there may be some schools that could potentially um we could use cops 4 it will ideally maybe be stretching us right because again those cops payments those are fixed payments that we absolutely that that's a debt that we owe that we would absolutely have to pay so we would have to consider those other areas to potentially cut and not ACR additional debt is that's exactly right okay getting there thank you any other questions comments thanks for the the uh uh presentation appreciate it pleas we're going to now go back to Chairman Lindy for act two act two lower your expectations lower them lower the expectations um this is great uh I'm both a little surprised and delighted to be here uh to talk about this today uh I didn't think
034we're going to have a chance to do this part of the uh policy because I didn't think we were going to have another board meeting in December um we had our last policy committee meeting on Friday um and uh honestly the the number of topics we needed to cover earlier in the year and how much work went into getting the first part of the superintendent eval policy such that it really reflected everybody's feedback took so long I wasn't sure we were going to get to this part um but we did uh and I'm delighted to come back with a recommendation that has the support of all three of our policy committee members um and that is meaningfully different um from the first version that was shared with you many months ago um the a proposal
035that um is coming from the policy committee is on board docs uh it might be helpful um Rob if we could bring that up for people to see if that's not too um um uh tricky um so you you'll remember that uh in the in the policy that we recommended earlier and that passed um I think at in our last uh board meeting or two ago um there were these different sections there was a part one uh on the timing a part two on what would be in the evaluation a part three on the scoring for the evaluations and really in each of those parts we were trying to provide enough parameters for a process that would have meaning but also leave enough flexibility to Future boards and superintendents to be able to do what
036made sense in a given Year's context um this last part was designed part four with the idea of what okay well what happens if for whatever reason any of the things that are supposed to happen in the annual evaluation process don't happen so what if there's a year for example where um for whatever reason goals aren't set by the end of that first week in October for the superintendent or um what if um for whatever reason um the board never comes up with a final evaluation uh for a superintendent in a given year um I think those situations can be challenging I think both for board members and for superintendents and for uh others in the organization um because there just an absence of clarity about what is most important and an absence of clarity
037about how the superintendent is doing and so I originally wrote this section um with this infrequent scenarios title and then I really want to credit um our general counsel uh uh Mr Hing who who helped me realize that they're actually less infrequent than I thought that they were um because this goes back I think even before I was on the school board but there there have been many years as I understand it this predates me um when for these are not for bad reasons but but just because there's transition or because there are big things that happen in the district or in the city uh or there's a pandemic that um the goals wind up not getting set or that a final evaluation winds up not getting completed and so you know hearing that context
038from Dan just made me feel even more strongly that we should have something in place uh as a backup plan um but whatever that backup plan is um it shouldn't be a punishment it should be like a a set of default rules that that really create an incentive for everybody to work together come up with good goals vote on them in public um and and follow a good process every year so I think that's what we're bringing you today I would just flag um under uh infrequent scenarios section one um if the board does not vote by the end of that first week in October to approve a set of goals or performance objectives for the year um what follows here is really different from what we started with um and I just wanted to
039call that out I also wanted to credit Karen imbus for coming up I think with the idea that we took from her and the policy committee and wrote it in here um because I think the original version had said if the board doesn't pass goals last year's carryover increased by 10 percentage points um and and I think the feedback was that feels punitive and it feels um so high that they are Out Of Reach and absent meaning uh I think that's good feedback um and so what we changed it to was like it's our job as a board to come up with those goals and vote on the public but if we don't do that well the superintendent then gets to set her own if we haven't done what we need to do as a
040board uh and so there's there's a time limit on that and there's a backup to the backup um which we left at the 10% again the whole Mr Cross you spoke to this I think more articulately than I'm being at the moment but I think um there was this piece about trying to create incentives for the board to follow the process is there anything you want to add that I'm missing yeah um what I talked about also was if there wasn't um one of the defaults is for the superintendent to create their own goals and that that was uh somewhat in line with the idea that goal setting is collaborative when we do set goals so so if we're not doing anything the the superintendent has the opportunity to collaborate uh with herself themselves I
041guess something like that I have no I have no comment on that whatsoever um uh Kender or Miss map did you have anything you wanted to add from our discussion Friday no I think you both covered it all um and again just highlighting the piece of it being collaborative and also ensuring that there's accountability for the board to follow that process to establish what those goals are I think we also added in in section two um that there's still an opportunity for board members to share feedback directly with the superintendent there will have been that at the midye and will continue to be um uh I I just want to say again how grateful I am for the engagement of um Mr Crossett and Miss map and also for um Karen and the people who
042shared ideas on this I think we're bringing back a better version than we started with uh and excited to recommend it for passage today thank you members have any questions or comments about the proposed policy Mr Craig uh just a slight grammatical correction I meant to say that I'm sorry yeah the one under uh part four number one that first paragraph where it says if the superintendent does not I think maybe you should just read like the performance objectives said last year shall continue with targets that are increased by 10% yeah that's just my bad typing um this is this is nobody's fault but mine so I think if if um I will I I will now make a motion to adopt an amended version of this which if you just look at the sentence
043for and I guess maybe this is mostly for Dan or any anybody who's who's tracking with the board up here but I think it's the sentence that starts with the word if is that right Brandon It should read if the superintendent does not set her own goals comma last year's performance objectives shall continue with targets that are increased by 10% it it the meaning is there if you squint at it but it's it's a typo that's my fault other comments questions uh Dr mofet I thought I was going to say one of the same things but I have another uh question SL suggestion and I'll just the chair um was there any particular reason why you all said the first week in October versus the first board meeting in October the only reason I'm asking
044that is because what if the first week is not really a board meeting but then we don't meet until the second week but that we had an opportunity I was wondering just around timing if we could just maybe say meeting instead of week it's a great idea and I don't see a problem with it whatsoever I'm curious if anybody else see something I'm missing the idea was to have it after the final data is released from the state from the previous year which is usually the middle of September uh and early enough to give the superintendent as much runway in the current year as possible which L somewhat arbitrarily to this first week but I I I think the first board meeting in October sounds pretty reasonable to me but I'm also open if I'm
045missing something I just was wondering why you all chose the week and I thought about it like well maybe do our board meetings do we always have a board meeting the first week of the month we don't and so then it made me think for us to remain in compliance perhaps we should think meeting instead of weak but again I'm open to whatever I just want didn't want us to find ourselves in awkward situation I think that's fine AB absent any um concern uh I would probably amend my motion further to do that but also like I think if I hear you Dr mopet we should also make Parts one through three reflect that right so that's because and so that um Dan is that too complicated so we'll just make the whole thing say
046first meeting in October and then like on number two where it says the first week but if you go down there the superintendent had like the last meeting in O last week in October or something related to the first and last of October just make it uh related to the meetings yeah so wherever there's that reference to October it would be first meeting in October yeah yeah okay thank you any any other comments questions I have I have just a I think a quick question talking it's on the first page uh the paragraph that begins of in part two the full paragraph at a minimum uh it says that obviously the U overall rating it'll be 60% of the overall rating and then it goes on to say that the periodic or interim I think
047is what you call them interim checkins will account for 10 does that mean then that this this evaluation is really going to be 70% of the performance so I would like to ask Mr Crossett because the 10% was his idea and I remember liking it but I would love to hear what he the way he thought about the math if that's all right yeah uh I felt that the interim check-ins needed to have a little teeth in them and that's why I added the 10% because I think that's really going to be pred help to be predictive of the final outcome so and so we don't have any surprises during at the end that we do something midyear and not and those midyear reviews if there's a little bit related to uh that 10% and
048they'll we'll take them serious so well I I have I don't have a problem with the importance of that because the theme Here is collaboration between the board and and the superintendent I just think that uh the reality is that the evaluation is not 60% any longer it's 70% at at least 70% so I I think that the I'm I'm more comfortable if if the document actually said it's worth 70% of or you know it's 60% this and 10% that but it's not 60% it's going to be 70% or if you're going to want it to be 60% it should be 5010 I don't if I can push that a little bit like I I think that that's one way a future board could decide to use this policy I also don't know that that's
049the only way a future board could use the very same policy so for example like if we say I'm making this up but let's say for next year there are you know five different performance measures three about student learning one about finances and one about staff culture uh and that that's going to make up 60% of the overall rating and then the other 40% is going to come from things like the kind of board surveys we've done in the past or the 360 things that we've talked about fine um so then the um the 10% of the midyear might be a little bit of each of those things you know like part of what goes into that 10% is how do those five goals look part of what goes into that 10% is um uh
050what's the current um board survey look like or what's the current 360 feedback look like so I think what's nice about I think what's nice about this is because the board's going to have to vote in public on how the scoring is going to work every year um each Board gets to hammer this out in a little bit more detail um but what I really like about the 10% is that you can't skate by that you know like there's there's going to be something of of a teeth um early in the year so that there are no surprises at the end of the year but I don't know that the language in that paragraph says that the board could make adjustments based upon that and this does mean that the evaluation tool is going to
051be 70% I'm all into the idea of the collaboration I'm all into the idea that boards have to each board every year has to have some discretion but on this we're basically saying this evaluation is going to be 70% and I don't see where there's a a lot of movement as to what boards could decide to do help me out I'm just thinking about the the evaluation for the superintendent is 100% like it's going to it's going to be one one pie divided in different pieces and so um what the policy as written says is that a a 60% like almost 2third chunk of that pie is going to be based on how did the superintendent do against the goals that the board adopts in collaboration by that first meeting in October then it says
052there's going to be 10% of the 100% that will come from the midye now what what will that 10% midyear evaluation discuss what's for future Bor to decide so it could be a mix of those per so so you're going to you're going to say well that that's still 70% if you add 60 and 10 and I think that that's true I think what that does though is it leaves um you know there leaves room for future boards to decide on what else matters I'm also um in in the grand scheme of things not not a hill I'm going to die on so like if there's an alternative language uh miss bman you want to suggest I wouldn't be uh trying to suggest other language but I I do think that there needs to be
053room there and I and I think there has to be some truth in lending that that is 70% is going to be this Tool uh and I think that's very important and I think the board individual boards need a little bit more room in determin it Mr Craig so I think at least the way I'm reading this though you know a board could say this would be 8020 and that would still comply with this this policy where 80% was made up of the um performance measures and 20% was the you know interim check-ins or it could be 701 or 6010 and then 30% is decided by other factors in which we would be considering so I mean I I I don't really that it has to be hard and fast every year be 70 now
054if the point is that we wanted to make the percentage of what the performance objectives is have a lower floor I think that's a fair assessment if if that's what is kind of being asked um but I mean I guess for me the 70% is the floor of what these things would be as part of our evaluation that's all this is kind of really saying not that it has to be 70% every year because it could be 80 90 based on how we decide to do this in collaboration with the superintendent I I'm in agreement with that but I don't think the language says that it could be that I mean it says the basis of at least 60% of the reading and the basis of you know interim checking shall account for at least
05510% so I mean it and at least 60% yeah so it could be more it could not be less so it needs to be established that this is it can't be less basically saying it can't be less yeah you you couldn't have a year where the midpoint counts for less than 10% and you couldn't have a year where the whole thing less than 60% is a is a reflection of the goals that the board approves at the beginning of the year as it's currently written you can't Jim another reason why is my microphone right okay another reason why I thought the 10% was important was because it's not just an eval valtion of the superintendent but it's an evaluation of the board because we're going to set these goals collaboratively and if if we get
056to the end of the year and we have some bad results I think it's important that that the board is checking in uh and so it's it's going to it's not going to just be hey why why did this happen and the board wasn't Ming the store so that's why I felt it was important to have these interim check-ins and have some teeth in them wasn't just for Mr CR I'm not having trouble with the 10% I'm just having trouble with the 70% and then the idea that it could be less or it could be more I mean it could be more it can't be less than 70% so and then I hear all boards could decide to do something different meaning it could be 60 this or 15 I just don't know that the
057language says that within those numbers there's that movement that's all I'm looking for is that movement for board members but I mean if there's no if there's no other go ahead sure so yes so I I can add that our thinking around that at least 60% was to ensure that we were um putting a strong emphasis on um student outcomes that that was a priority for us so we do wanted we did want to call out that that was the um the minimum or the foundation and so um that's why you see that number there but then the additional 10% as um board member crit spoke about is we do want to ensure that there's still that level of account uh excuse me collaboration um with the the superintendent and also allow for that flexibility
058for future boards um moving forward so if we specifically said that it would be an evaluation of 70% um as being kind of that uh strong basis for the evaluation I think that would be limiting for other boards moving forward but at least saying that this is kind of the basis of where we stand and if people if the future boards wanted to increase that that they had the opportunity to do that but again having that 60% um Foundation was something that we did find that was really important any others uh vice president so just to make sure you said that future boards could increase it but they couldn't decrease it so what if they wanted to decrease it how could that be an option with the wording say it again change board policy yeah
059that's true too but that's true too but for currently quickly we've done this well I'm I'm actually I'm fine with how you stated at least 60% and then the at least 10% but yes you could always of course go more but you just couldn't go less it might be helpful to remember to I didn't mean to cut you not cut you off Miss wber it's okay uh H happy to seed the mic back I think the um the the initial version that I shared with the policy committee had set this there was no interim percentage at all and the goals was worth 75% um and so I I do think this this represents this is what the board approved last time I think a nice um I think just incorporation of feedback we heard from
060various sources I just would what what Miss map said too that you know um the majority of the evaluation at least from my perspective should reflect measurable results because I think that's what the public elects us to do uh and I think we're responsible for showing that we're driving meaningful measurable results um what those results are focused on year-over-year every board and every superintendent get a chied together um uh but I think that was the the the spirit behind it and and I I do recognize this this represents a compromise from where it was and uh uh because it was 70 something per and and what have you and we there wasn't like flexibility I think going forward at different board members now I I am going to also raise an issue and I I
061think we're ready to vote on this but I will raise an issue uh even in the first uh the first sentence or so of this paragraph where a minimum of these objectives will include measurements of systemwide academic and Financial performance that's great and they will include goals that focus on improving opportunities for African-American students Latin next uh students students of color and lowincome students when you say that uh my heart I think that's great but you've also now told other board members or other boards that that's what they have to be about and I think but they have we would have to change the policy that's so I think the it's that's not a remedy considering how long because we're going to live with this policy this policy will go into effect when we pass
062it correct go ahead Mr Lindy I think the policy you're referencing we already adopted um so it's already gone into effect um it doesn't mean a board couldn't change it um but I would just say that uh I did you want to speak to this I don't want you you can go first would just um I think this is worth putting on paper I think it's valuable and I think it speaks to the values we have as a district I think you see that in our Equity policy I think you see that in our anti-racism policy I think we should say that every year we want to set ambitious goals for improving historically marginalized student outcomes I think we should be proud of this and shout it from the rooftops uh it doesn't say what
063the targets need to be it doesn't say that there can't be others also um but I think there should be a point of Pride um and I I think I I have no interest in backing down from this one I I understand that I understand that but again it will include goals that focus on even if you said at least but I mean we we've got this policy but again there's another example where having a little bit more flexibility with ongoing boards I think would be helpful there but I think we're ready for any last comments before we vote so M I would just briefly add so um I was one of the ones that was really advocating for this language here um most because these are uh and it's not let me say this
064it is not um excluding any of our students but I it is important to call out the students that we serve and that and it's important to call out the students that we know um our communities are expecting us to uh prioritize because we we see that within our um our goals we see that within our guard rails and so I think that it was important to make sure that there was alignment there within the language and the policy as well thank you member map any other before we uh yes Dr Mett so I I appreciate the work that you all have done sincerely because I think that it's it's rather difficult getting seven people to agree um I I I did I do not have any problem with listing that but I do want
065to offer that it should not be only to that group I think it can say and they will not be limited to or something of that nature to identify that that is the population that we serve that is our um with intentionality we are working to improve results for these marginalized populations but I think we need to make sure that we're inclusive to show that we're also focused on other demographics as well because we could have um our LGBT plus students say well why didn't you list me and you know I think to remedy that and I appreciate that these are personal values for specific board members many of them I share as well but I also am very cognizant of the fact that we have other demographics that are to them equally important and
066are not represented here so what I'd like to offer is more inclusive language to state that it's maybe and they will include goals that focus on improving opportunities um or including opportunities for um you know I don't know how we need to say it but I do think that we need if you're going to be exclusive there you need to make sure that there is something that's saying that it's not just that because we do have policies that go to all other demographics that are not listed here as well so I I it's not a it's not something that I think um I want to fight about so please don't jump on me but I do want to say that um I think it's somewhat exclusive oh Mr Lind and I I agree with with
067with so many of the things that you have shared genuinely and I think this is a great example of like trying to strike this balance between Clarity on process and values while also leaving boards future boards flexibility My Hope Is that the like at a minimum language in that paragraph leaves some room for some of that it might not and I think it it might be that there are future policy committees that want to take another look at this um I think uh what I was going to offer as a way to move forward though um certainly uh open open to feedback was no that the the motion that I was making was really limited to part four um which is the last thing we had a chance to discuss in the policy committee um
068and that we would I was motioning that we adopt part four um would see if somebody seconds this and if we have votes for it um and that the only changes would be the um typo that I was sharing in that paragraph and I think Dr moffett's um good idea to switch first week in October to first meeting in October um and then we have a new year we will have a new policy committee if there are new folks who want to take a look at other changes to this you know I think that's how a process should work um but but my motion was going to be around part four the typo fix and then the switch to first meeting in October I I appreciate that does that uh satisfy members of the board
069to make the motion be about part four which is the new part uh we have a motion do we have a second second thank you member map uh vote Please Mr Craig yes Mr crant yes Mr Lindy yes M Mt yes Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you very much everybody appreciate it and now we'll uh go to our other presentations I think uh we'll start with the superintendence uh three I think you have I uh have one uh two retirees this year is that what I'm sharing now oh excellent announcements today great two retirees uh both Civil Service employees the first retiree we have is a PA professional from Pleasant Hill Academy Miss Alicia ringer okay and the second person uh a senior accounting Tech out of our human
070resources Talent Department Nancy Thompson Glazer congratulations to both both of those ladies thank you board members have any uh announcements or I just have a quick announcement I just wanted to thank board member um Crossett for attending the curriculum uh review today it started at 2:30 we got had an opportunity to look at some things that they're trying to utilize with our kindergarten through second grade and then they also showed us some of the curriculum that is used with our high schoolers as well so I know that we will probably be hearing about that a little bit further into the next year superintendent Murphy correct and we look forward to that so thank you thank you uh other members Dr Moffett and then we'll go to member map so wanted to say I had an
071opportunity to meet a few parents at the parent leader holiday uh um snack it was good thank you and and congrats to them on a great year so far additionally I wanted to say thank you to the winon hills girls book club because we finished our book we read Sharon Draper's book out of my mind and we saw the movie on Monday and it was awesome and so if uh anybody has any connections they would love to meet Miss Draper cuz uh they they have a couple questions for her about that book and lastly I want to say thank you to the uh principal V and Aken staff they were very very helpful um with the situation this week so I wanted to make sure that I shouted out to them thank you so much
072that's it thank you other announcements member map uh yes I just want to give a huge congratulations and kudos to um data monor's um music department specifically Miss Janine Jason um Miss Sarah ganana Ganon with the Suzuki program and Mr Brian who is uh leading our uh Orchestra students and they did an amazing job at the winter contest and all of our great musicians that performed it was just awesome um thank you to the parents that showed up um and large droves thank you to everyone that had a hand in that at data minor story and then I also just want to give a uh thank you to all of the organizations all of the churches um families that are just helping to support our uh students um during the holiday season um with food
073drives coat drives all of the above to just make sure that our students are and families are well taken care of and prepared and supported throughout this time thank you uh vice president I'm coming back thank you board member Moffet for reminding me I want to give a huge shout out to the lovely young ladies at Chase Elementary um I also took part in the book club and we read the book The Girl girl who drank the moon very interesting book um it was it was a great time for the four weeks that we were able to get together to kind of discuss this book discuss the vocabulary and really allow the girls to kind of lead the discussion and what they thought the book truly meant and what really actually happened at the end
074of the book so thank you so much for that Dr Smith yes thanks everybody uh as we moving on and now we'll go to the presentations I was trying to expedite but uh but we have no no no I was kind of passing over some of the announcements and I'm I'm glad the super caught me regarding especially the retirements and uh now presentations yes ma'am we have three brief presentations all out of the office of secondary Education First our assistant superintendent Amy Randolph is going to come and give you an overview of what's happening with secondary education including our high schools we'll follow that up with Emily is here happy to see her with our College update and then adult education brought To Us by Miss Robbie Thomas all right hello welcome thank you um
075good evening board member or board president Bolton vice president Weinberg members of the board Treasurer Wagner and superintendent Murphy I appreciate the opportunity to share some of the work happening in our office of secondary education next slide Rob um we are comprised of five departments we have Athletics adult education College Career Technical education college career community resource center and then um also we have 16 of our high schools which would also include our k12's spenc Spencer 312 and then virtual GDA um so our departments are working diligently to support District strategic plan goals and developing systems that align our work I am just going to do a highlight initially I had a few more slides but since you're going to be partnered up with a few of my team members today I'm going to shorten
076up a little so just sharing a highlight from each um our adult education program this year um they earlier won three awards from the Ohio Department of higher education so exceeding enrollment Target most performance-based Improvement and outstanding student persistence um Athletics they are working on a lot of different programs but one thing that they really want to celebrate is the um nutrition grants that they've been working on so they have over $100,000 in Grants there also Josh has been working with his team to focus on um creating a data system around GPA and student um athletic participation so in looking at just first quarter they were able to show that students involved in athletics first quarter had a higher attendance and higher GPA than students not participating probably not overly surprising to many of you
077but but um it's good to have the data to show that as well um our Career Tech team has been working to increase internship opportunities and has already exceeded the goal for this year the team also recently attended the equity lab to review data and begin the work on the Perkins plan for next school year our CTE program also um is partnering with many businesses and triy health expansion has had a positive impact they've already meet met the goal this year um because of the tri health school to work program for internships in the district our college team is celebrating uh they had an amazing college week that provided access to many of our students getting on college campuses uh the team also has worked to increase CCP participation um and has increased by over
07832% just since um last school year so very exciting um information there our College and Career community resource center hosted in November a drop the mic series uh where students had the opportunity to meet local minority business owners and learn strategy around successfully developing their own business um also in that department we are working to Pilot a CPS Edge program uh that would allow students to intern within our own internal departments for Hands-On work experiences um so you can go to the next slide Rob we have many uh opportunities to celebrate high schools in general um but I just put a few up here so you can go to the next one um so just a couple highlights that I find to be really exciting um aen they were a spotlight School in the new
079tech Network news earlier this year uh Oiler had a site visit from director dhen from odw uh we I think have celebrated Taft few times um for some of their recent you know recent accomplishments uh my personal favorite today SCPA voted uh best public high school by the Family Choice Award in magazine um we also have virtual high school they hosted a their peer leadership group hosted a career fair on their campus so that students could have opportunities for um career after school uh Woodward has been working with our social studies Department um and Dave Trower wanted to give them a shout out for uh their data reflection and their engagement strategies in their High School um Hughes is working with CED children's and um our facilities team to EXP and their children or their
080um their their medical center um with children's hospital and another celebration from Hughes last week they did um earn their stem reaccreditation last week so they are officially good to go on their stem designation so shout out to them um and something that was really exciting to me when I was at West High a few weeks ago uh they had a paper newspaper and I said I really want a copy of that newspaper and I did not realize it was there uh I did not realize they had a student newspaper and they have had one it is their they just celebrated their 95th Anniversary they have had a student newspaper since the beginning of the school so that was really awesome and they're also working with Mike to see Mike Turner around um the teacher
081is also Career Tech certified so they may be able to expand a program there um and then also our Zoo Academy is celebrating their 50th year anniversary so hopeful to do a presentation with them um in the spring and partnership with the zoo um overall High School just that many schools participated in um over the summer there was the bigger than sneakers Summer Academy where students were able to design the North Star shoe where you see a picture up there and then they sold that at the blink um Cincinnati so that was a great experience for some of our students um we had National Merit Scholars at Clark Spencer and Walnut Hills and um we had our fourth career Symposium in partnership with grad Cincinnati we had seven of our high schools represented there so
082we're also working with several other other um departments in our district I know initially I was coupled up with the elementary education uh presentation a few weeks ago so a lot of the work that we do is uh is in alignment with them we're doing the eighth grade math collab we've done the algebra 1 collab um we're doing an ela2 specific professional development instru instructional reviews School tier support meetings by-weekly with our c um curriculum instruction team and then we're doing stem coach walkthroughs uh we also have like I said with the stem coaches as a new addition and to support our teachers and students and 10 of our high schools uh we're also doing regular um emis meetings around graduation we're doing weekly High School huddles and we are focusing on on track criteria
083for graduation so I believe in Cal last month um board member Craig had talked about we're really needing to get out of the emergency room when we talk about graduation so one of our can you click that link Rob one of the things we've been working with the high school counselors on is really starting to track starting in the ninth grade um but we've created what an OnTrack um student would look like by grade level so this is this has been shared with all of our counselors and so right now we have graduation sheets for every 12th grader in the district every 11th grader and by the end of January we should be able to track you can scroll down so this would be um this is by grade level on how we would determine
084if a student is on track so that's something that we're working on there you can go back thank you um so also looking at data overall and impacts on GR graduation um our 2024 cohort shows an overall Improvement um and 2025 is on track for that as well um I know that President Bolton also asked about tracking by school which we do it's a current practice within every High School um they have senior success meetings usually weekly some bi-weekly um we're also tracking by subgroup uh we're tracking credits we're tracking the Readiness for tracking the competency um so some of the data because I know we often talk around like Algebra 1 proficiency versus competency so in order to actually meet the graduation requirement students have to earn competency versus Proficiency in Algebra 1 so
085while our proficiency rate is 36% for Algebra 1 last year our competency was 52.5 um for ELA the proficiency 41% and the competency was 58% so just want to share um the difference between C or wanted to share that data um as we talk about students needing and Al alternative pathway versus meeting competency um also a celebration for AP courses is uh last year we had 70% that scored a three or better um which is a great outcome especially when we think about post-secondary readiness um and then we also this year um Craig Hoover said we have our highest percentage of students in AP courses so that's a date of Celebration there uh one of the something I'm really excited about is we've re-engaged or beyond the tassel committee um I know there's been a
086lot of talk about my tomorrow what did that look like um and so when I was a principal we did a lot of work around that um under superintendent Murphy's leadership when she was an assistant superintendent she started beyond the tassel um so we're looking at uh we have re-engaged that committee um so that committee has a variety of stakeholders uh we have counselors we have district office we have principals um just a variety of stakeholders that are really focusing on the mission um of our district so you can go to the next slide um so the mission that we have had as a district um and that is current is that our graduates would be Sly s highly sought after by universities employees and Military and access direct Pathways to fields that offer genuine
087economic mobility and build generational wealth so when we started that committee back up this year we really looked at that we looked at the guiding principles um to ensure that we stay in alignment um with the work that the district is doing um so as we look at the components uh we have four subcommittees go to the next slide um so one of the subcommittees is working on graduation requirements specifically one is working on graduation strategies and aligning to moving out of the emergency room student engagement and postsecondary Readiness so postsecondary Readiness um is going to be on the report card this upcoming school year so it will be a component for our high schools um so it's really important that we're spending time there um so on our most recent report card although we
088did not receive a score for it um they gave us what an anticipated score would have been which was a 45.4% uh you can flip to the next slide real so the the newest language update um states that they are working on the calculation um so in reviewing data for cohort 2024 uh which is what would be on our next report card I've been working with emis and we've calculated um and we believe a projection of over 60% on this component which would be two maybe three stars they haven't released um what that would look like yet on the Stars uh so if you flip um this to the last slide um so this is based off of where where we fell as a district um based on cohort 2023 and that 45% um so
089this is where many of our schools would have fallen for post secondary Readiness for cohort 2023 so the upcoming report card will be based off of cohort 2024 and that's the one that I said is I think we were projecting close to 65% um and many of our schools were at over half of our schools were at three four or five stars for that if our projections are all on track but this is a year behind so this is based off of what was on the most recent report card um where our schools would fall so I know that was a lot of information but well appreciate any questions for me right now appreciate you doing it as quickly as you did very frankly this is as much information as I think I've seen about
090high schools and a long time I appreciate it as a person that loves high schools uh members have questions for the assistant superintendent yes sir Mr Lindy how can we be helpful how how can we be helpful I I think right now um one of the things we're really looking at is uh really especially as we move into this Middle School model um some of the data that we have shows the seventh and eighth graders specifically across the district weren't making a year of growth so I think as we think about this um how do we ensure that we have um career exploration opportunities for our seventh and eighth graders um so when we start looking at that and getting students ready for that post-secondary Readiness piece um I also think that it creating a
091model for them that will really allow our seventh and eighth graders to be successful itself is just going to be a huge help um I'm really really excited about if if all the my data calculations are right I think we're going to be like in a really great place for post-secondary Readiness at the high school level um which is going to have overall impact on Stars across the board for the district so I think right now I think just supporting the the work around postsecondary Readiness is where we are other questions comments Dr Moffett so if you go back to slide three Rob good stuff good stuff I am super excited about Aspire because I've been to their graduation for a couple years and I think they are kind of like a a little known
092secret for CPS we don't um I posted it I posted their graduation on U my my website when I went to the when I had the pictures and people were like I didn't even know we had that and it's amazing to me that people don't know that we are offering some really good stuff for adult education and just just outside the box education in our district so I really wanted to put that up there and keep that up there for a second so people really see that we have programming here and it is three stars it's really really good they're doing great stuff so I wanted to um say congrats to you and your team for that another thing I um well I have a suggestion at the end but beyond the tassel I I'm
093first time I'm hearing about it and I really like it it sounds really really good it's nice to know that that was started previously and that you're bringing that forward so thank you for that is there a possibility that we can have some Community engagement in there I know she's probably already thinking where I'm going to go but maybe we've been we've been the community has been asking for ways that they can get involved so that sounds like a natural way to maybe increase some community members in there and I was going to ask were their Community stakeholders already invited yeah absolutely so a couple of things to say around that is this work around Workforce Readiness is critically important in addition to valuing our College entrances and acceptances and so the more and more
094adults we can get community members involved in this the better it also lends itself to our business advisory Council okay so you'll hear more about that as well which is really uh community and Industry driven in terms of providing what is needed for what's next for our kids that was I was going to ask you about that one Rob that's slide 10 if you could go to slide 10 and keep that there for one second because I was going to ask you I was the um leison with the business advisory Council and they were looking for ways to get in so I was going to ask that question but I know we've got some agencies that you know like the NAACP really wants to get involved community members to get involved so maybe this is
095a way too my last question is around um Middle School preparedness for beyond for high school and Beyond so as we look at uh middle schoolers and their Readiness I know we've we've seen some of the data around their um their academic achievement some of it around their social emotional learning are you able or are you all thinking about taking some baseline data from them now and then comparing that to this time next year once we've implemented middle schools to see if that improves like are you all set putting things in place now I guess I'm I know I I feel like you probably are but I'm wondering is there going to be or is there any way that we can look and see how they're ready now for high school and Beyond and then
096measure that over time yeah and I think right now um John leads the middle school committee but what I would say is we will have three sets of data because we will have our K8 well we really will have four we'll have our k8s our Middle School model our students that are staying in a 7 through 12 model and then we will have what's the other K12 7 through 12 in middle school and just k8s so right now we know that um when we look at the k8s they tend to score a little higher um on our state assessments and I think it's probably because they don't have seven or eight Bells a day uh they spend a little more maybe four teachers five they have a little uh less of a strenuous schedule um
097so I think they're looking at like what the Bell day would look like um and how to make sure to incorporate extra time for ELA math really looking at you know where are they coming in especially since we'll have so many different entry points but I think that's always data that we keep um in the Forefront well you know I think we all CPS tends to be very Innovative so keep some data so we can make some white paper write some white papers in the future for sure but thank you for the information I appreciate it other members member m yes thank you for the presentation and sharing the um various highlights that are happening within our high schools um my questions are around I want to start with the Career and Technical education um
098slide that you presented on page four so uh the school to work program I know that this was this is in partnership with tri can you share what schools I thought it was just Riverview but can you share what schools have um access to this school to work program with tri health and what the actual uh percentage was last year to let us know how you know what that increase looked like I know it's about 10% but just what that that uh previous uh percentage was yep so what I'll say on the tri health is I do not have there are five schools I do know that it's five and I know that just because was reviewing this with Mike today um I want to say it's Hughes let me not guess I'll just email
099you the five but there are 50 students right now that participate in the tri Health Partnership um but right now we have over 260 students that are currently in an internship it might not just be triy Health they were just celebrate triy Health has triy Health has really increased the number um because they went from one to five schools this year so that has helped but so the 10% last year I believe Mike said they ended the year at 240 and right now they're already at almost 270 so we still have second semester to get in there okay perfect so with that when we when we're looking at the internships what um opportunities do our students have um and maybe I guess being hired on after like graduation what opportunities are presented to the students
100you know given the fact that they are given access to these internships I'm just looking at what other opportunities are they able to be presented with upon completion of the internship so for this triy health specific um they are they do have the option to go straight into work but I did ask Mike that same question today only because I'm going to talk about this this evening at 7:50 as well um so he shared that um you know many do especially the ones that participate in the school to work program they they end up going to college um but so he did say it's very difficult to track that because it's all self-reported so as student can say I am doing that but then when they check back in two years later they are not
101so that is an area for us as a district that we're working on Emily Mike and myself um have really been talking about how do we track that but the opportunity to have the POS or work in one of these um actual businesses is there it's just do they choose to accept that or take a different pathway okay thank you and then my other uh question is around the um graduation on track criteria I like that you all have fleshed out you know um the opportunities for us to be able to track or for families to be able to track whether their child um is on um on you know the course to fulfilling the the criteria for graduation uh as well as for the students because this is really helpful for them to be
102able to um know and have conversations with their counselors with the their teachers with you know with their parents so I think that this is great um what I am hoping for and maybe you all are already considering this is if we will be able to be presented with data from each High School of you know where the um ninth grade students are where the 10th grade students are in terms of being on track with this criteria yes um so we definitely have that um they're going to have all of the sheets updated by January 31st especially because nth grade the criteria requires first semester um data because you really wouldn't be off track quite yet based on our document um but we can definitely give an update we have that by School uh for
103each grade level um and we have it broken down by on track with credits on track with competency and on track with seals so we could break that down and give an overview okay perfect and then just lastly can you because I'm looking at just the data that you have shared um and I know that you're projecting that this year's uh cohort would would improve right right um but just looking at last year's data it's reflecting that we have some intense work right to do with our High School uh students and getting them to um where they need to be in terms of the expectations for high school but also post-secondary uh opportunities as well and so if you could just dig a little bit further share a little bit more information about just what
104the um I guess the intentionality would be or the focus would be to help support our student students um and just kind of turn uh that that data around I know it takes time obviously um but just kind of what you all's uh focus is and plan is to just really strengthen that work there yeah so I am I will say I believe Kathy Spellman did share this earlier so um it is going to take some time for sure but we should move from one star to two stars for our overall graduation for um the upcoming report card so when we think about how to continue to improve in align with the Strategic plan goal uh we really are um focusing a lot on like you said the student conversations um the counselors are meeting
105individually with students like iess we've implemented the well they've been doing some of the schools have been doing this but now it is pretty standard across the board um the senior success meetings and again going back to really how do we start looking at that earlier um because it's it's almost impossible to catch up every single year so really focusing on that um it's to go back to Dr moffett's question for a second we recently at the beyond the tasel committee meeting last week just said what members are missing so something that was brought up was parents we probably need some parents on this committee um so I think I stopped loranda in the hallway and said another task loranda so I think she's she's smiling so that's good um so we really do want
106to be intentional about educating students educating parents making sure that everyone understands what it actually means to graduate because it changes pretty frequently in the state of Ohio I think we're on the third set in the last six or seven years um I know the schools are working really intentionally around um making sure that even staff understand like some teachers really might not fully understand past the scope of their um work so really I think the first step was aligning what we need by grade level on track and really having a a data system that is succinct across all of the high schools so that we can regularly monitor have the those conversations see what supports they need um and most of their senior success teams include their resource coordinator high school counselor a teacher
107principal so really um honing in on that work and the earlier that we can prevent the better um another opportunity um is something that I've been talking about with superintendent Murphy and others is how to support our MLL students um many of them um are especially at West High and dater um they don't finish in the four four year time period or they don't finish because they choose to go to work or have to go to work I shouldn't say choose many have to um so we think about um what implications could be if we were able to create um a program not necessarily like virtual high school but where there is flexible scheduling um opportunities to some maybe morning courses if you have to work during the day maybe we have some evening courses
108so I think that we've been talking about also supporting that population and working with the board policy around um the individualized graduation plans for them um so I think we have some opportunities to grow our graduation rate in in general if we can support that population better yeah thank you for that and I'll just add I I remember when I was in the high schools um one of the things that we did do was we had quarterly um parent and student meetings and so we would have our counselors we would have our uh teachers there obviously to talk about what those graduate graduation requirements entailed um um you know how they had to um what was required for them to earn their points on the end of course exam so just providing opportunity for everyone
109to be aware but having those um meetings quarterly for each grade level 9th through 12 to still you know support the students and families and also try to ensure that they are on track definitely yep we appreciate that feedback and I will add that in especially because I think at parent conferences you have a great opportunity to do that so map other comments vice president yeah so I have a comment not really a question but just wanted to follow back up on the school to work program um I actually got the opportunity to go to their graduation last year and I'm so happy that you all are highlighting this program for years it went I wouldn't say unnoticed but it kind of did and I'm happy that we're highlighting that and sharing the opportunities that
110we're giving our students um I think it was 16 students graduated from CPS they had two additional students who weren't from CPS so a total of 18 and I know moving forward as you stated their goal is to um increase the program and really um after these students graduate and they go to college of course they want them to come back and they will immediately be hired so I think it's a great program to promote and I look forward to seeing the class for this year as well thank you any other comments Mr Craig I'll be really short because I actually have it hard out so I uh appreciate all the folks who are still going to be doing presentations um but um I just wanted to say I think the only thing that I
111want to add is just and I think you mentioned it really briefly but we really do need to be paying attention to seventh and eighth grade and specifically I'm really concerned with math specifically and that transition um because algebra one is not a easy subject and and truly some students may take it eth grade some students may take it ninth and that transition may also be affected by where you took your math classes and what opportunities did you have to grow within where you were at and be supported and I know that that was some of the worry that some students had or some principles and staff and others had expressed about kind of the timing of when students were completing that algebra work within our um 7 through 8 or through our 7 through
11212 schools because at the time that was somewhat of the challenge right is that we have some students who are on top of it ready to go at seventh grade and and their math scores reflect that we saw that in our numbers of how people passed algebra and so I just want to make sure we're also still paying attention to that as we look at the high school numbers because again in order to graduate with a degree or with a diploma state of Ohio this is one of the things you have to meet as a standard and so um I I think this important for us as we think about high school sure we think about folks who are getting pre ready um the other thing I will quickly say is that I think that
113adds into some of the stuff I've heard from folks who are looking to use some of the Career Tech and other programs is that our students aren't necessarily academically ready in some of the Career Tech um apprenticeships and stuff like that as a leave school to do it and so I think the more we're looking at that Career Tech as career ready M as opposed to just passing the state standard The More We Get students ready to then be able to go in and be employed in these different places and be able to do some of these different internship projects and I want to commend actually the superintendent because you know after our conversations uh at the last board meeting uh there was an opportunity to connect with some of the folks who who have
114been reaching out and asking to help and so she took the initiative to reach back out to them to reach out to them um with a with a couple of connections that I think are really helpful to work on that but I think that's for me one of the things I want to make sure we're looking at as we think about these newer Range High Schools is we are going to have smaller schools but that does mean that we have a a more dedicated need to make sure Career Tech is not just you pass the certification at the state level and yet you still can't do the work y thank you Mr Craig that's a part of that beyond the tassel in more ways than one uh very good thank you I think we're ready
115for the next uh presentation thank you thank you oh hi hello good evening esteemed board member superintendent Murphy Treasurer Wagner if my voice goes in and out I apologize ahead of time I'm on a tricta respiratory illness so I'm going to do my best here I am Emily I am the college manager here at Cincinnati public schools and it is my joy and honor to present about College all thingss College college is a conduit to Career I know that firsthand I'm well aware of that however I love college and so as the college manager I have a team I have what I call my College Bound my college specialist one over college credit plus one over College specialty so really working with me in the in ins and outs programmatically I'm also over District advisory
116so while that is broader to academic Excellence so social and emotional well-being and postsecondary preparedness it sits out of my Suite I also get the honor to work with two lead counselors here at the district as I get to be the District representative for our 72 INB building school counselors one thing I really want to point out is that we truly believe that ensuring every student not only sees the potential of their dreams but engages with College Bound resources people programs and tools to help them achieve their dreams and not just stop there but to thrive next SL please next slide please so when I came into this role I really said let's thematically build upon what we're trying to do within the college vein of post-secondary preparedness so as we are looking in the
117sixth grade year we're looking at choosing that seventh through 12th grade building that fits that postsecondary interest and those academic skill sets we built what are called High School program highlights and so when we're looking at K through six buildings they're using these programmatic tools to show students and families what each High School is offering when we have advisory in our classrooms in 7 through 12 we are utilizing this still in our k through eight buildings showing these highlight videos where each High School got to represent themselves what they can offer and in what vein to what academic pursuit or what career pursuit in that as well and is it a sports team does it have strong Sports maybe it's strong academically and sportswise and so we have students go I think I'm going to
118go there in grade seven we Aspire in grades eight through well actually eight and nine we connect and then expose grades 10 and 11 we're exploring and we're building upon this programmatically to grade 12 where we're enrolling our students so we're building not only upon activities built into classrooms saying what is a career or what am I really interested in and do I need college to get there do I need just CTE to get there what does this merging look like we're building these experiences to then get students out and on campuses and out and seeing themselves in maybe an HBCU environment or talking to a mentor who said you know what I originally didn't see myself going to college but here I am now and so building through that with our College programming to
119really again exposure to choice exposure to opportunity next slide please at the district level we host you may have heard about our College week we hosted the second to last week in October we're on our fourth year of doing this and it just grows and grows we talk about Athletics in college our academic pipelines the big big question on the table affordability what is college beer everyone has College beer even if they didn't go to college it's often with sports teams we cover a scholarly 60 seconds we have have online website opportunities that talks about how and when to make final decisions the differences in scholarship and AIDS analyzing an offer letter you get an offer letter what does that mean and it's just 60 seconds to really go through that and we have seen
120hits by parents students community members looking into that especially at critical timelines and time points in a students trajectory we also and I didn't add it to the slide have act boot camps that we Fund in our high schools as well as fast f ni to support our families next slide please so let's talk a little bit about our College pipeline programming next slide UC early it we currently have 134 students enrolled in our UC early it program you can see up here or on the slide in front of you our partners that are involved in this this does impact grades 9 through 12 and they're taking six it courses up to they can even take more if they would like to they have direct admission with completion of six it courses as well as
121college math English and Humanities with the c or higher directly into UC school of Information Technology let's say they don't do that they can get pref preferred review for any student that completes two of those courses with the c or higher they're getting access early on to internships the UC it Expo summer camp exponential activities and opportunity to co-op between the summer After High School graduation and their matriculation year I'm happy to report that of those students that have historically been in that pipeline that we had 49 who decided to go to University of Cincinnati as a university of that 29 went directly into the school of Information Technology and this spring we have three students that are graduating from having done that pipeline next slide please I heard you say earlier in this meeting
122we're in a teacher shortage that is no news to anyone however we are combating that as a district we are the first district in the state of Ohio with Miami University to have taken on what is called Teach Cincinnati and from that it's with Miami University this again impacts grades 9 through 12 for our students with that students are taking education courses having conversations about the critical components of education and the power of Education in our communities they're getting ACT prep assistance they're traveling to Oxford they're getting access to Miami Bridges programs which are happening throughout the school year with other school districts but what is beautiful about this Pipeline and I say it is beautiful is the guaranteed Admissions and scholarships that come with it I am happy to report that as of today
123there is not a student in this pipeline that has matriculated that is not on not a full ride so they have made it work to the students benefit they are participating in and learning Living Community is on the latter end taking their courses together what benefits our district is they get priority in student Place student teaching placement in our district and preferred hiring at the end with Cincinnati public schools we currently have 22 former CPS students in this pathway at Miami University next slide please with road to lner college credit plus pipeline excuse me this impacts grades 7 through 12 there's summer programming that actually happens more so during the school um time for students in those years sophomore to Junior and Junior to senior years they have new peer mentors in mathematics by UC
124faculty greatly needed as we know with math college credit cour college credit plus courses in business and college algebra students who complete this pathway are guaranteed admissions once again to ler College of Business we have 50 students currently in this pipeline of that we have four students who have matriculated to cincin to um lner School of Business I also was um remissed to report that we have 98 students currently in the teach program the former slide I would love my water thank you thank you so much Robie this is a newer one our our Miami farmer School business with accountancy we have yet to be able to successfully embed a CCP course in this however we are able to offer immersive and exploratory opportunities in entrepreneurship economics and accounting courses mentorships with business Affiliates as
125well as immersive campus experiences and site visits to local and Regional firms we're it is looking at accountancy however as our partner at Farmer schools businesses it it takes a unique individual who wants to be an accountant and I I know that but as we need more people in the field and we actually have seen students that are really excited about accounting as a field of expiration I look forward to sharing more about this program in the future right now we have 16 students interested in what this pathway proposes and last but not least um you all have heard word of the college Innovation pathway that was approved to start in last May Academic Year as Schroeder high school we had 27 families apply before the deadline in May of last year a summerbridge component
126since we are on an Innovative waiver if you are not familiar with what that is the state approves an Innovative waiver that waves the need for certain CCP requirements for student participation in this case it's the GPA that is because our students are signing on to participate for their ninth grade year many of them don't have a GPA with that we said we will be hosting a summer bridge that focuses on both the math and English components of preparedness to be able to take college courses with that 12 students are successfully in our first ever cohort at Schroeder high school for this it is an Associates well and high school degree so at the end of this students will be walking the stage both at the University of Cincinnati and at Schroeder High School outside
127of that Summer Bridge opportunities in years one and two the student attends courses directly at schroer high school they take college courses while what we call embedded so taught in the classroom year three they go directly to Blue as and year four UC main we are in the recruitment cycle for your cohort two of that next slide please college credit plus also underneath me so I wanted to give some scope to last year because we actually don't have full data on it until the start of this year so when looking at it we had about 2400 courses that were taken that comes out to just over 7,000 credit hours 1.8 million in financial savings for families and of those courses that students took 73 of them were taught embedded in high schools by by a
128uh High School teacher that was credentialed by the state and the university to be able to teach such in total we had 882 students enrolled 327 male identifying 555 female identifying next slide please so if we look at yearly comparisons I just wanted to highlight a couple things we had a 35% participation increase in students participating in CCP between Academic Year 2223 and 23 24 with had an 84% increase in black male identifying student participation the reason I actually bring that out is that was one of our goals it was one of our lower uh enrollment identities and we were able to increase that by 84% we saw between two years a 40% increase in tuition savings and I'm happy to report that we are at a 95% course passage rate meaning that our students
129are taking those courses with them for college credit you can see the breakdown here of our tuition savings over three years as well as our credit hours the number of courses taken in growth and are unique participants next slide please college credit plus so where are we so college credit plus falls into summer fall spring as a three term sequence as supported and sponsored by the state I will identify that on this slide I made a copy and paste error so it is not not 882 that are enrolled that was a former slide it's 83 so we're not too far off okay with that mail identifying is at 294 female identifying is at 9 um I can send an updated slide to you if you would prefer later on what I would like to point
130out is we are already at 1,700 courses taken thus far this Academic Year we've increased our embedded courses to 86 and something to really highlight is when you look when I look at the numbers of last year's fall enrollment and this year's fall enrollment just looking at those two terms we grew by 51% in CCP enrollment which I would like to toot my team's horn for so thank you um next slide please so some highlights next slide we have 310 students engaged in a college pathway or pipeline this Academic Year we have increased actually come back to that one we have 47 college or university Partners in our College Consortium we meet regularly um sometimes more often than I think they want to meet um to talk about what are our needs of Cincinnati public
131schools and what are our institutions doing not only to recruit our students but to retain them for retention is very close to my heart in an academic year we produce out of our College District team over 40 College Brown programs and events for students in addition to our 7th through 12th grade College Milestone programming and lessons in classrooms which you saw on our slide three I believe this past class of 24 took with them 10.2 million in CPS partner-based dedicated scholarships what I mean by that is only CPS students can get that scholarship and or they hold a scholarship a number of slots for since night public school students to give you some reference in that that was at 1.9 milon for the class of 2022 so we have been able to get out and
132about have really intentional and passionate I don't know if you can tell I'm really passionate passionate conversations with stakeholders to say invest in us and we will invest together in our future so we are up from that two things and one is not on the slide because I just got the data yesterday but we increased our fasta application completion by students and families by 11% this past class of it was not of any effort of me it was of the amazing efforts of team of school counselors of my team of people in the community that were coming together to support our families with mixed residency status as well as students who maybe didn't have someone who could walk through that process knowledgeably again we hosted some fast for nights here in the district but again
133I will not take all credit for 11% of that growth however I still won take credit for this one um I just got the facts and figures we stood around on a six-year average at 48% of our students matriculating to fall after graduation to college that figure doesn't surprise me even though our 3E data often indicates a 71% intent to enroll when I cross reference intent to enroll by student by their ability on GPA to enroll right out of high school we're sitting pretty healthy in our average that being said for the class of 2023 648 students from that class matriculated The Following fall to college this past year from the efforts of teams we have raised it to 959 so that is a 39% increase in colleg goinging culture for our district I would
134like to see what that looks like in retention as I'm sure you all do because enrolling doesn't mean the end point for them but what I do know is that at a twoyear um so when we look at students post into the fall and looking at a two-year we know we have some Gap your students that take a year out we're sitting at 56% average of our students in college in a program and sitting at a 74% retention rate currently for that so thank you and I will take any questions that you have thank you very much do members have questions or comments uh for this uh I would say pretty stellar report like some of the the others uh okay vice president I don't have any questions but I just want to say thank
135you so much we can hear your passion we appreciate you and thank you so much thank you I appreciate that other questions comments Mr Cross it uh same same as uh board member Weinberg keep going it's great news and as long as we can get the trajectory up let's keep going it's great thank you I'd like to offer I'm happy to meet with any of you as well I met with board member Crosset to go over this he's like okay good uh member Moffett and then we'll go to map I'm super excited because you're excited it's contagious but most importantly I think the numbers are really really good I'm going to ask my question super quick because um can you go a slide s Rob um because 78 and 10 UC see early it is
136very impressive to me um because I am a bearcat I know I built some buildings over there because I didn't paid a l in tuition but I'm very interested in the number of students that from from he CPS that go there how many of them are getting like the Cincinnati Pride Grant or utilizing that Cincinnati PR Grant so when a student matriculates over there how they look at the financial aid of that is through fasta first other scholarship and Aid and then often they put the pride Grant as kind of that Gap closure unless they need to flip the order of that so I don't know off the top of my head jack Miner would say any student who needs it and so that can be an answer in itself but I'll reach out to
137admissions and ask for our students what that average is sitting at needing the pride Grant I will say because broadly and nationally we see what G Gap closure funds are in general and how difficult they are even if it's 1,000 5,000 7,000 um The Pride Grant is really a critical piece and it is the reason why the majority of our students are choosing the University of Cincinnati as the choice school next yes and they I've met a couple students this past summer that weren't aware of it and they were pelant eligible so that was a little concerning but I know our staff is working super hard to to your point with the numbers I'm just wondering is it a is it an awareness issue or is it just you know they just don't qualify so
138that was that would be everyone qualifies every CPS gr qualifies okay that that's even better that's even better so it's awareness thing so thank you for bringing that to my attention we can even put that AB out in a newsletter so number eight slide number eight if you can go there I am actually having coffee with an aen grad is benefiting from Miami University trying to sneak that in there um he is super excited and I met the President of miam University who keeps saying Dr M I want to talk to you about your program this is what you all are offering to our to our University but he's U Mr Edward Johnson we're having coffee on and he said I would like to tell you about my experience at Miami University so I didn't
139even know we had this program but I'm super excited that we're training Educators training students to to be able to go into education so we're kind of building our own Workforce which is amazing to me so I wanted to give you a kudos for that cuz this young man spped me out and actually asked me for coffee so it's definitely working this is an a ACH and grad and so um I will make sure to connect him with you because he could definitely be a success story the last thing I wanted to say on slide number 10 um with regard to accounting I am aligned with Xavier University's women in business uh department and they are specifically looking for um CPS students to go into business majors around accounting so I'm going to give that
140information to superintendent Murphy to give to you because they would like to have women go into business I actually am now sitting on their board um but zaver University they've kind of thrown the net really wide and you have schools right here that are interested in business and they while their focus is women you you need to be connected so I'm going to send that her name is Karen uder and so um I'm going to be sending that in just a second but I want to say kudos to that because we need to make sure that the connection with the community is already there and you're doing great work so thanks again thank you I also add um I unfortunately was out but this past week our team was able on my behalf to meet
141with the dean over savior School of Business so we can even see how that merges more and Mr Johnson we use him often because he is the Superstar so we got it and if you take that energy over to that meeting we got all the money in the world I promise you so let let us know how to continue to support you and what you're doing thank you for working she were well yeah so thank you for the passion that you have I also have a lot of passion and interest around this topic um so thank you for the presentation my first question is around um our students that are in the trio programs how are we supporting and working with those uh students such as like upper bound um and and ensuring that not
142only do they go through the program but they are also matriculating into our uh colleges and universities as well absolutely so I actually get to oversee with Javon one of my Specialists our College access Partners so we have Upward Bound we have YMCA Young Achievers we have breakthrough Cincinnati as part of that and those do meet our Trio we know we don't have enough hands to do everything and so through that in our meetings we do talk about not only the access to those programs for our CPS students but additionally how those students are matriculating be it through this the year-long activities or the summer activities our school counselors are actually very in the weeds with that as well with our access Partners so um we do reports we have what are called quarterly reports
143where we look at the the student information at the granular and then we offer as a district where we can into those Trio feeds um in fact I just did a signature for Grant expansion for trio um so where we can we know that it's kind of that fine line in BL balance we host the students we have access to students and Trio is so relational right so once we can really pinpoint and piece those Partnerships and those relationship networks for our students on my end transparently it is very much that kind of data and making sure if I get a heads up I've gotten a heads up before hey we're unable to get ahead with this student we're running into blocks we're running into this and that I'm able to connect with school teams
144merge together that and see it but we have seen growth actually that's why our um Upward Bound just actually expanded at UC and we've seen that because we're able to produce the ability for students to have more opportunities in that pathway and program and them to have access with us as well thank you for that I appreciate that information and we meet it's called the access leadership team okay perfect um the other question that you touched upon is that I have is the 47 um Consortium of school or colleges and universities um I I don't know if this is um presented anywhere but I think it would be great if we were able to list and identify what those schools are that you know are within that portfolio because I think that is definitely a
145great marketing um tool to let you know people know where our students are attending um you may be able to add the scholarship right um dollars that that the students are receiving but I think that's a great way to just showcase the uh relationships and the uh the work that we are doing as a district and um creating that colleg going culture and continue to possibly add to those Partnerships absolutely so one thing I do have on hand that I can send first thing tomorrow morning is our national student Clearing House shows exactly our institutions and how many students are rolled our College Consortium takes a little bit of a Different Twist where it's more so um partnership based instead of student feeder based and so with that I actually just uploaded that sheet today
146into our strategic Plan update um so I can also send that as well perfect thank you and then just lastly um I don't know if you have any any information around this but I can imagine that you do especially with some of the schools that uh we're working with locally but I know that there's been a lot of restructuring within several of the universities pertaining to diversity and equity and inclusion departments and so I'm just curious to know from your seat and your perspective what do what do that what do the implications look like for our students and how can we support our students as they are either um currently you know in school or matriculating into right that is a great Point um and it's something that um post new elction ction results has
147been even more heightened particularly as we looked at our mixed residency students um a large part of our growth in student transition for for to fall matriculation was with getting more students that have family members that might not have us residency to be able to fill out FASA and go so I'm actually very worried um I'm worried about what the implications of that are as well as others in our district and we've been having conversations about what does that mean and how do we provide safe and also um s safe secure and informative methods and spaces for families to come and ask questions and even for families to come ask questions who've had students who have matriculated like we still remain to be a hub of of answers in that and so I don't have
148an answer I wish I did I'm kind of waiting in fact all of us are kind of waiting till January because one day you'll hear they're exing this the next day you hear in fact I will tell you that uh the National College attainment network en cam has put out a statement saying that they do not encourage for students without um residency or families without residency to file the fasta currently the Ohio Department of Education hasn't made a statement yet and the national Department of Education has not made a statement however the fasta website itself does say kind of caution without the words caution a student who fills this out may have implication and a student who has filled this out in former years there is no guarantee that's really scary for our families absolutely
149um when talking with I've talked with some University presidents actually especially when there's been some um closure of of buildings and so I will have a beautiful side conversation with you of that because I don't want to blast out there responds to me because it does actually benefit and serve our students not only in our district but in our region and our nation um but yes I have hope in how they have managed to meet State expectations of them in closures while at the same time still providing those resources to those students in ways that we can have a side conversation yeah absolutely I would definitely be interested in continuing to have discussion offline and if there are ways that as you continue to move forward through the process that if you could keep us
150informed so that we can make sure that we are advocating for our students and families I think the biggest advocating is here and now in the moments of saying we see you we hear you and we are providing this spases in which you can come and know that your information is secure and that you're not outed right we are public serving um district and in that we just even having you asked that question I'm sure someone's heart is in like in that moment and I will keep you engaged thank you thank you thank you we have lived through part of that once before and it does impact the district uh Mr Crossett yeah um as a I spent my career in accounting and studied accounting so I really appreciate you mentioning that we're special but
151but uh I I will to follow on um uh board member mfet and map I will connect you to my contacts in accounting Community here in Cincinnati I'm sure there there are not enough people going into the profession so there there'll be a lot of people interested to to help with your with your initiative absolutely also um I forgot to ask before but uh is I didn't really see any information about a pathway through Cincinnati State especially when affordability is such a big question and whether or not that could be um emphasized yeah I am more than happy to present on that at another time there be great Grant is open to um Cincinnati public school graduates they can't go to a different institution without going to Cincinnati State and following through with that however
152they have a lot of great programs and um actually I'm on an email thread looking into where we can have some of our students who have graduated but might need to stay on with some additional resources taking part in the bgre Grant and getting a college degree why still with us so I would love to with Ryan when he does that present uh Madam treasure yes I just wanted to announce that I sent um superintendent Murphy note that the second floor would welcome with through interns in accounting we do have internship program that we've been doing so having that pipeline would be awesome amazing great amazing thank you great thank you so much thank you very much we'll do the third presentation and as the third presentations get started appreciate uh board members that I
153know we've run over and uh after we get through the meeting we do have a brief uh executive session because the superintendent would like some guidance on a particular topic but most important today my favorite person ncps person no forget it you're retiring and leaving now you know that's what happens fall number [Laughter] two down because I'm short first of all I want to thank the board for this opportunity and super intendent Murphy and for the treasure I'm so sorry but I'm the favorite person now um but I also want to thank um Dr Moffett for her comments and I was certainly thrilled when I saw that you made a comment on our Facebook page about our program so it means a lot when we see board me Members comment about what we do so
154um I want to the first slide please or slide two which brings me to this slide which is about about your comment about who we are and what we do um we're not new um I really wasn't here in 1840 although my grandson would ask me really Nana were you in 1840 evening School in Cincinnati um started for workers in Cincinnati and it was an adult education program that's how far back adult education was in Cincinnati and what did they do they taught immigrants to learn to speak English and to learn about our culture and history and government the same kinds of things that we're doing now so that's how that's how long that's our history of what we're doing slide two so when we talk about our purpose or that's slide three please next
155slide it's not it it is true when adults learn communities flourish okay our purpose and our vision um what I want to say is when we worked on our purpose and our vision for adult education which is what our staff worked on the one thing we wanted to do was to make sure that it was well thought out that it was intentional and that we focus not only on the people that we serve but but the manner in which we serve them and what the impact would be on our city because what we knew was that our students often have had challenging experiences with their education either because they didn't do well in school or their P their their family wasn't supportive or for a variety of reasons so we knew that that we had
156to have empathy from where they came from and so we needed to build that into our services next slide please so with Aspire we needed to offer free services we offer day and evening classes and I heard that kind of referenced a little bit about what do you need to do when adult when the um students in high school need to complete well sometimes evening is what people do need and that um and so we're funded through the um Ohio Department of higher education now and that at one point in time you might have heard us called able and before able we were called AB so we've been around since the 1960s with Cincinnati public schools and let me just say that that's through a competitive Grant process so it's not just a given so
157about every three years Cincinnati public schools and whoever the leadership is in adult education writes for the grant in a competitive process and since the 1960s the district has been afforded the opportunity to write for that and then has been funded and so that's really um commendable that we as a district has been awarded that opportunity and have been able to serve these students so the grant um this year is 1,326 566 we receed we do not use General funds to support the program we um do get in kind um services and which we are very grateful for our funds are 72.5% federal uh through the Federal Department of Education and 27.5 through the state so rest assured when we hear conversation about what's going to happen at the national level with the Department of
158Education it does cause some discomfort and some concern in doing that we will serve 1300 students we will probably serve more than that we operate eight sites throughout the city we work with things like River City um programs such as River City Corrections we work at Tyson Foods so we work with employers at Tyson Foods um we have 85 FTE administrators we have five FTE adult Educators we have two senior support Specialists we have two PA professionals we have three part-time non-contract hourly teachers and with that limited staff we serve, 1300 students so rest assured we work very hard every day and in the evenings um Slide Five please we um so what do we offer um if you'll back up one slide please we offer hsse that's high school equivalency that's GED and highet
159most of you think of high school equivalency as GED and for many years it was GED and now the state of Ohio is Al also approved another test which is called highet and we refer students either way either for the highet exam or for the GED High set's a little less expensive for our students so sometimes we go that route for them the GED is four test versus five so that sometimes sounds like well let's go that route but highet it will break the uh the rla from the writing and from a multiple choice and so sometimes they need that because we need to be able to see is it the essay that's causing them trouble or is it the multiple choice so we're really trying to discern what is best for the student um
160so we do that then we do Workforce and we will do more Workforce if more Workforce is open to the services that we offer Tyson um is esol so many of their students are learning to speak English and so we're coordinating we're constructing our curriculum around what do the employees need to know to be more efficient at the work site and then of course Corrections so at River City we serve a lot of students there and you know those students really are ready when they come in to work towards their High School diplomas which will make them more successful once they leave um the correctional facility and hopefully not ever go back to the correctional facility so the other thing that we do with Aspire funds is we do integrated Education and Training and it's
161really important when people are going to look for um training that we're putting education and the training together so they're not separate things right so we can be working on uh well we're going to improve our educational skills maybe working towards our GED or just upgrading our skills as we're working towards learning to um be in the culinary program where we're doing doing construction and they do um Habitat for Humanity in construction we're doing patient care assistance and those students can go right into Drake hospital as employees once they um complete that program we do photomy with our students and of course you can imagine they go right into draw that blood right out of you um and that's um with um making a change Cincinnati we do medical assistant so um whenever I go
162to like today I had my physical UC and I'm asking the person who's taking my blood pressure where'd you get your training because I want to know did they go through one of our programs Hospital worker Readiness with Mercy neighborhood Ministeries and Independent Electrical Contractors those um I used to say gentlemen but that's not the case anymore fortunately we have women coming through that program too we see a lot of those people in the spring they're upgrading the skills to go into that program to be electricians and um then they're working with employers while they're uh going through the program to become electricians so we're real happy with those uh opportunities as well and those are all through the Aspire program next slide please the next thing we do which we're super excited about is
163through odw and that's a credit recovery and those are for students who are 18 and older let me talk a little bit about students who are 18 or students who come to our program we we don't work with anyone who's younger than 16 but because we're housed in the same building with virtual and digital sometimes we get students to come knocking on our door with their mom usually it's Mom sometimes Dad they want to get them into our program and the first question is have you already withdrawn from school and if the answer is no then the next question is why are you knocking on our door because you need to go back to your high school right you don't need adult education you need to go to Virtual or to digital or wherever you
164came from because we want students to stay in school that's where they belong and so we will send them back in that direction or to the customer help or wherever they need to go um if they've already withdrawn from school then that might end up being a different conversation and it might not even be a Cincinnati public school could be a different school being in the same building with virtual or digital and having a good relationship with u Mr Rosier then we can work through what's going on with the student why is adult education an opportunity for this student and to try to work through what's best what's in the best interest for the student sometimes it's a student who maybe is 19 years old and maybe only has three credits and so what is
165in the best uh opportunity for that student and we will work together to try to figure that out but with this credit recovery program sometimes we have students who are 22 23 years old and maybe they are missing some credits maybe they didn't pass the um end of course exam one or two exams and so we'll work with them and you know our goal is oftentimes they do want that high school diploma and so we want them to get that high school diploma and ccin a public has been awesome to work with um the customer help desk has helped the student get their transcripts um we will work through with that student and then of course we work with them for the end of course exam which isn't which isn't a piece of cake by
166the way that's quite a challenging exam for our students the next program that we have um next slide PES is what's called ADP it's the adult diploma program and it's the newest program that we offer and that program is for students 18 and older and what those students need to do is pass work the work keys test they have to earn a 12 it was a 14 it recently changed to a 12 and they have to earn 12 points in an industry recognized credential so we've just started that program I think we have five students who are in the um pathway for it and I think three of them are just now completing so that's an opportunity for our students and what I want to say about that is Cincinnati public is one of seven
167sites in the state of Ohio to offer all three diploma options for adults over EV 80 sites in the state of Ohio may be offering one of those diploma options but only one of seven in the state of Ohio and Cincinnati public is one of those seven and what I would tell you about the other seven most of them are Career Technical institutions or uh community colleges so for us cincin night public to be uh a public school and to have the opportunity for adults to go in three different Pathways to finish their high school education is really a phenomenal opportunity for adults and we're real proud of that uh next slide please so here we are this is who we are our goal this year is to serve, 1300 to date that says 778
168but when I recently looked we're at over 800 which is over 60% of our goal I have no doubt we will surpass our goal we have already achieved over 40 students in our program have received their hsse meaning they have passed the GED or our high set test we have five students who have earned Credit Recovery diploma we have three who have their adps our costs per student how much do we serve our how much do we are we able to serve our students for a mere $1,022 Treasurer likes that particularly so we're pretty Frugal our enrollment goal for River City this year will serve 110 students who are in correction Tyson we will help aund we will help 50 students who are employed at Tyson improve their English we will help 50 individuals who
169are with um IEC um and get involved in that program and stay in that program and we will plan to serve 200 students in our I program to um get um a credential and and one of the programs that I showed you for their Technical Training next SL next slide please so when we help transition people into postsecondary let me just tell you we don't do it on our own we couldn't do that for $1,000 we'd be miracle workers so we have all these Partners who help us thank goodness one of them is one of our new partners this year is chatville Edge and chatville Edge this year has worked with five of our students four of them are now enrolled at U at UC one of them at Cincinnati State so those are students
170who came through the pipeline got their GED or went through credit recovery and now are enrolled in college and chap pill has assisted them because many of our students are either they either um don't have parental support um their first year college students so they need assistance we have a partnered with City Link who helps they help us with our PCA program and Drake hospital we have a partnership with Mak change Cincinnati Ohio Means Jobs helps with recruitment Mercy neighborhood Ministries helps us with our Hospital Readiness program as well as sna and then our partnership with Independent Electrical Contractors so we find our our Partnerships are very valuable to us next slide please so how does this benefit the district because in about the year 2000 and yes I was involved in adult education in
1712000 in 2000 unfortunately the Department of Education decided that finishing High School through a GED no longer counted as a completion for K12 that was disappointing so you might ask yourself why is this important to the district well here are some reasons when we work with with adults who have children in the district or who attended in the district it improves the family engagement piece because we are part of the district we are Cincinnati public schools it enhances the community relationship when they know that Cincinnati public is a part of the mission that we serve the adults it has the economic benefit when we help adults improve their education start earn a higher income and then they pay higher taxes in the community they role model for their children when the parents go back to
172school and the children see the importance of Education makes a huge difference they reduce dropout rate because a parent goes back to school gets a GED finishes High School a better opportunity that the child will not drop out of school the support that we give to Immigrant families so that the parent speaks English at home begins to speak English at home while the children are learning to speak English in K12 the improved School climate and the fact that we provide we Cincinnati public schools provide multiple diploma Pathways next slide please so here we are celebrating the three certificates that Miss Randolph referenced initially that we got this year and if you ever come to our building and we welcome you to come to our building the three Honors that we received are on our wall
173and they're spaced very far apart because I told Spa the staff space them far apart because we're going to get more this year and we need space for the next ones that we get this year and before I came today we get a risk analysis every year and our risk analysis tells us and and Miss Murphy got it today too says um are we a high-risk program no we are the lowest risk that we can possibly be it's like golf you want a really low score we can never be a zero because we're always going to get Five Points because we're one of the highest funded programs in the state of Ohio so we're always going to get Five Points so when you see the Five Points that's the best we can do okay so
174we got that today and then we also got our desk review for last year and hands down we did a great job so we met that so yeah I expect that we're going to get some more certificates um for this year coming up so do you have questions thank you very much do members have questions or comments member map yes so thank you for presenting this because this really just touched my heart and just the passion that you have and just the empathy that you have it just it it really is um really appreciated thank you um my question is around the mental and emotional um challenges that um I'm sure many of the adult students um are experiencing and I know that firsthand just having to do individual counseling there's a lot of barriers
175obviously right at they did not have a good experience um academically throughout Elementary or High School overcoming um just that that mindset of failure or just believing in themselves so how do you and your team support the students that do come we know that there's um that level of um expectation that they have to go through the program and to do well but there's also that mental and emotional piece that we all know is real and there how do you support the students when they are experiencing that I'm so glad you asked that question first of all one of the trainings that we just recently went through was mental health we've done the first aid training but the next training was Mental Health Training you know what what are the things to look for what
176can we do to assist the student and I think the one thing in adult education and how I always approach students when they first come in or when I greet them the beauty of adult education is I'm an adult too we're here to learn together you know things that I don't know so we approach it from that point of view we're here to learn together it's not I'm here and you're here we're equals and so that that begins at a different point with the adult to appreciate what you bring to the table what I bring to the table so we start from that point we also don't use great so that we sto that at the very beginning we talk about what you need to know and be able to do to move to the
177next step to move to the next step that's all we do um that erases that whole you know mentality that you know I failed something no you didn't feel anything this is what you know this is what we're going to work on next they have complete ownership for their learning plan they do their own goal setting so it they have ownership for that and I I think that that alleviates some of that um sometimes our students stop out I don't call it Dropout they stop out um they have lots of responsibilities they have children they have medical issues they have work multiple shifts on jobs they have things like that so when they return after stopping out we're always happy to see them there's never any shame that where you been no hey we're happy
178to see you come on in right or we get in touch with them we text hey you know you're going to come back and see us because we sure do miss seeing you yeah things like that I think make it more comfortable for people thank you for that um in the work that you do if they have experience the stop out as you titled it do they pick back up where they left off or do they have to start over in the process what does that uh that that I guess process look like when they do retire one of the things you know of course we have guidance guidelines that we have to follow that you know the state fed's set for us but um one of the things is that their their assessments is
179good for 180 days so nothing has to change and they don't have to do anything different but walk back in the door unless 180 days have passed if 180 days have passed then we have to update things but we try to make it as pain as painless as possible hey let's get a new update on what's going on with you in math doesn't mean we have to do everything all over again so we try to work with it that way and we don't call it testing we try to just look at it as an update or you know let's see what's going on with you with math or reading or something like that try to keep it um painless okay thank you and then my last question is I know that we are anticipating or
180we have had conversation with the uh John Community High School have we had discussion with them yet okay well so there's anticipation go ahead they cancelled like it was supposed to be Monday they cancelled I can give you an update during exec if you like okay okay um so still with that line of thinking it's a possibility or anticipation around several Don students possibly um enrolling into C PS um that would either need the adult education or the credit recovery uh process do would they begin um I I'm imagining that they would begin kind of at Ground Zero with the program um depending on what pathway they select right it wouldn't be I was taking Credit Recovery here with my credits that I've earned here transfer over like can you speak to that yes I
181can first of all we've had um um quite a few Dawn students who have come to our program um who just need to make a change okay and um some of them because Don does not offer HSC we do so that is a pathway for you Don does not offer ADP we do so that might be an option for you credit recovery is a two-year program and so if they were going to Dawn and they have already gone through the two years and did not complete with Dawn for whatever reason that two years is set by the state and we can't override that but if they're in that two-year cycle we can pick up from where they were we don't have to start over we can find those credits find out what they did did
182they do an end of course typically what we're seeing is they did not do an end of course if they needed it we can pick that up and we can start from that point we can transition them right into our program and work with them from there so if they come to us then we will find a pathway for them to complete they will not be turned away we will find a pathway thank you that's all the questions that I have questions so I just um I'm a little tired so my energy is waning so forgive me not because I'm not excited um you mentioned that you are only $1,000 um per student 1200 and that is music to my ears when we look at other numbers that are like 12 and $14,000 a student
183is there um how I guess I'm wondering about how could we support you other than because I I don't think the marketing is very robust for you all could you handle more students like if if we were to get you 500 more students is that a good thing from where you all are placed or bad things cuz I'm thinking like hey that's more money that's that would be maybe more resources but would an increase in your enrollment be a good thing um I didn't mean to put you on the spot let me just say this I've been with Cincinnati public for more than a year or two for quite some time and what I've always tried to pride myself on is never to burden the district with any Financial um obligation because I know that
184the district has for K12 their own Financial challenges and so I am very grateful for things like the building that we occupy for the custodial for the plan operator for all the services that we get because we are part of this school district so I just make it work with whatever the state provides us and um be that right or wrong and if there's another administrator down the road who is wants to do that differently than I do then fine but that's just always my I love the school district and I and I love what K12 does and so I've just always been very cautious with how we spend the Grant and not to ever overstep and so we don't I don't turn people away we have a waiting list right now for E esol
185we are now at almost 5050 of our Aspire program and our ESO program because we've received a lot of students from Somalia and morania um who come to us who barely speak English so we do have a waiting list um right now till February for those students but I don't know if I really answered your question I'm not trying to avoid it I'm just trying to say we have the grant for Aspire and then for um 22 plus and our for 18 Credit Recovery it used to be 22 plus for credit recovery and for ADP we get we draw down different funds it's not a lot of money but we draw on different funds from that from odw and justor go for o no you're fine I'm such a teacher I just want to walk
186around I got you so um you answered my question fine so we're okay to superintendent Murphy do you does this have like a separate irn does this is this a separate program I'm just wondering how it's set up not not not no trick I'm just wondering so it is a separate program it's not a school okay do you know where they're located it okay she's been there yeah yes sorry sorry yeah you just said that you did say that so yes it's a program it's not a school okay yes all right I got you I have other questions but this is this is just for this I really wanted you to hear from Robbie because I just don't think people even within our own District know all of the things she provides uh the community
187and I'm I'm so proud of you thank you but thank you thank you Mr it and then we'll go to the vice president yep thank you you're uh it's impressive what you're doing it's great thank you and uh I did want to follow up on Dr moffett's question um forget about funding sources is there a need for for you to provide services to more people forget about where the money comes from but you said you had a waiting list I mean it seems like you could do a lot more there right there's always a need to provide more services for especially our esol population right now with the climate being what it is in our country I'm not sure what that will look like six months from now I don't know um right now we're
188really busy recruiting a lot of volunteers to help us I didn't talk about volunteers we're recruiting a lot of volunteers to assist us with our esol students and so that's helpful um the other thing that could be helpful um we offer scholarships to our students that want to go on to postsecondary once they graduate that's something that we do um Miss Bolton's at our graduation so she knows we do that so that's helpful great thank you Robbie I just wanted to say thank you so much for coming tonight and as I'm sitting here thinking superintendent as we have discussed just marketing and communicating we need to really get this program out there whether it's highlighting taking a month and highlighting the things the great things that CPS is doing so I just want everyone in
189this room to give you a big round of applause and thank you so much for everything that you do and that's for my staff that's for my staff and the staff everyone involved it is an amazing program and thank you so much thank you thank you very much thank you very much uh these been wonderful presentations um they're almost like tear Jer wonderful presentations yes is she about to Crow there it's her it's the vice president's touch oh wow um at any rate um we will move on but I I I I do think some one thing to add if I could this idea people don't know about Aspire or they may not know about the internships or they may not know about the apprenticeships or what have you it is the issue of the
190right vocabulary uh that uh has been mentioned to me uh yesterday uh about Workforce uh and I think the taxpayers in the in in the district need to be fully aware of of the workforce piece that we offer and uh it's another area where we don't Market it properly and and well enough and they have a long history of it and I do think that you know calling something a junior co-opt program uh with the city or packaging all of that together in a bigger bucket I think there are so many wonderful things that are fragmented that separate this and separate that and separate everything we're doing I think it's it's just like teaching you want to put things together it's not chunking it it's the opposite of chunking it you want to combine things
191together so people get the message and I I look forward to us being able to do that that some something as particular as was mentioned uh the you know having a different school day so that our young people can go to work during the school day that's a very simple thing that we could try to think about so this has been great today appreciate it uh the questions and and the conversations that have taken place um members uh we have a proposed consent agenda uh that's been distributed and posted uh and I would ask if anybody has any exceptions to the consent agenda it's a short one this time yes yes uh so I would like to abstain from the treasures report uh page nine under donations line item two as well as page 12
192general counsel line item three three so the third one thank you okay the hearing the exception uh the treasur making a note of the exception for the consent agenda does anybody else have any other extensions or exceptions to make for the consent agenda the consent agenda is uh as you can see it's acceptance of committee reports the superintendent's recommendations treasurer's report um and I will now take uh a motion to accept the thank you vice president so moved and I have a second for the acceptance second second thank you very much and uh any discussion about the consent agenda hearing none we'll go to a vote uh Mr Crossett yes Miss map yes with the noted extensions Dr Moffett yes pres vice president weberg yes president Bolton yes thank you all very much uh what
193we'll do next if we can uh do that uh we have just two things uh to make mention of uh in the um board matters and the um updates and uh inquiries want to remind the board that the organizational structure forms have been sent out I think nearly everyone has responded if you have not responded please respond to uh Miss Davis uh actually today unless uh uh we can uh uh get that yeah today would be the best uh so that we can proceed the other uh real quick one is a reminder uh that the meeting date change to January 6th uh the tax budget as well as the organizational meeting and as well as the business meeting will be held on January 6th does anyone have any assignments besides I think the one that's
194going back to policy committee about the upper top of the that policy uh not the add not what we just added but uh so we're looking at the previous um yes part of the policy that we had already voted upon will policy committee accept that assignment yes thank you uh any other assignments from board members uh hearing none uh we're going to uh take a motion to adjourn into executive session for the purpose I believe of property and um employment of public official if I recall correctly I don't have it in front of me but I believe that's correct uh we're going to do that fast it actually is going to be a short executive session believe it or not um we're pretty well meeting out and uh appreciate all the work thank you all
195very much uh treasure you need your motion on your seconder yeah who is it second thanks so mofet and Weinberg thank you and I have a question question discussion so after the exec session are you do you have to state that we're going to believe and after that we're not going coming back in here I'm going to do that this motion passes okay thank you everyone will be happy we are not returning three four meetings four meetings is enough okay uh hit it Mr crosson thank God Miss map yes Dr Moffet yes vice president Weinberg president Bolton yes we are adjourned into executive session uh we will not be returning to public session thank you very much everybody have a great holiday if we don't