CorpusRecord 65357

Policy and Equity Committee Meeting December 13, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2024-12-14
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,131 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e um maybe if we could go around the room um starting with Rob and pleas some introductions Rob technician you cross board member Ben Lindy board member Andra Matt member Dan ho general counsel Stephanie Scott general counsel CCNA Federation all right um um okay so welcome everybody um we're g to pick up in a second here with our um standing policy review um but like for um I'd like to see if we can get Rob's help displaying one attachment Rob I don't think I sent this to you recently but it's just the calendar of what we said we were going to do over the course of this year and I have it s to you um but one of the things that I am grateful for and proud of uh is I think

002we did set up um when Mr Mori sat down when Mr CR joined us and when I became policy chair um Tred to get some kind of structure in place um so that in this kind of we had a way to um we had a way to make progress against the three-year review cycle with the council's office uh we had a way to invite topics from any board member who wanted to submit one um and that we had an opportunity to work through all of those topics over the course of the year uh and then we had a chance to hear from the public at every meeting um and so I just want to share my gratitude with everybody because I think we've done that I think we've made I know we have some things

003we need to get approved by the board still but we've been chipping away at the threee review um as as Rob is kind of scrolling through these topics um for all of them as I understand and I'd like people to correct me if I'm wrong either we've done it or we asked the board member who submitted it and they said they were okay with us not discussing it anymore or we're going to talk about it today um um and so uh I just appreciate everybody um working on this setup together and and building something um who knows who's on this committee next year um I'm sure that group will come up with their own structure um but just wanted to thank everybody for um uh I think doing what we said we were going to

004do uh am I wrong on any of that am I missing anything nope okay great uh so then we're going to go to our standing policy review from council's office thank you uh we have two policies today and I'm pleased to report that I think with the these two policies we will have um completed our combining of the what was the 3000 Series that applied to um the certificated or teaching teachers and administrators uh policies and the 4,000 series that applied to classified and Civil Service staff uh which was a goal that we've been working through for probably almost three years now so uh with this these are the last two policies um with these changes we'll update sort of all the subheadings and everything else uh for the policies to say that these are

005policies that apply to our entire employee complement so two two policies today and and again from our standpoint uh simply just uh folding the 4,000 series into the 3,000 series I believe the first is policy 3440 and 4440 which relate to reimbursement for job related expenses uh we recommend resending 4440 as duplicative and uh making a few changes with with respect to 3440 just to update for example that uh the treasures office has published um a procedure or or manual related to travel expense guidelines so we point to that um there's been a slight change with respect to our Auto Insurance where we used to uh tell employees not to buy any supplemental uh insurance we now our current guidance is that they should pick up that supplemental insurance on hired Autos uh those are

006the only changes to 3440 and and with those changes we recommend uh adoption and and recision of 4440 glad to answer any questions thanks Dan uh Jim Kendra questions comments okay great um we're gonna have to have find a new activity for next uh year um yeah but that's that sounds healthy that's good uh so we'll recommend uh just do it um I think there are two ways we can do it um uh I think we can certainly make a motion uh second open discussion and then vote um sometimes if there's zero descent um we just acknowledge that and move on and I'm open to either any to sent nope okay okay uh we'll move those forward for passage on a future consent agenda I I'm assuming yep yeah these seem um singularly non-controversial I

007think so as well uh SE second policy and last one uh to update is uh 3531 uh and 4531 which relate to unauthorized work stoppages these these policies are I think in all respects um uh duplicative of each other and therefore we recommend resending 4531 and uh that's that's the only change we're recommending glad to answer any questions on that uh thanks questions on 4531 okay let me give meide yeah take your time yeah sure if you'd like to speak during the speaking of the public part of the session at the end of the meeting please click the hand icon now we'll ask your name and School Association and at the end of the meeting we'll invite you to come in to speak thank you thank you so uh I think it's very straightforward would

008this be an example to um I guess kind of like a sick in or it could be it's any kind of a workst I mean commonly called a strike right and and there are there are various forms of strikes employes have there are collective bargaining rights obviously for public employees in Ohio and there are certain times that it is lawful Collective action to strike this would relate to a time that is or a form of strike that is not lawful yeah and and uh again all of our contracts with our Union Partners have no strike Clauses during the term of those contracts when they expire there's certain steps that Serb requires that the parties take before a public employee union take its members on strike you have to go through a fact finding process you

009have to reject the FactFinder off off um recommended resolution uh you have to give 10 days notice to your employer uh if all those steps have been taken there there is a right to strike for CPS employees but all those steps have to be taken first so say anything wrong all right well that's the only question I have pertaining to it and and Dan if it comes up am I right in saying that like what we've put in this policy is what state law requires of us it's it's it's consistent with the Ohio Revised Code sections that relate to Public Employee collect collective action we're not imposing some additional set of requirements or making it more difficult or easier than what the state policy framework not at all not at all great uh okay so

010we will have um at a board meeting of council and board presidents choosing uh 4440 and 4531 to go through in a consent agenda sound good just one one F question from the last meeting we didn't actually wind up talking about this but listed separately on the agenda was one of the policies around teaching in a community school correct and I didn't think that I thought that was us applying what the state law requires us to do and we would put in the consent agenda I'm not opposed to it being pulled out I just didn't remember that we had that pulled out any insight into how that wound up there I had the same question I it it didn't come from our office okay so again we can if people want to talk about we

011can talk about it but but I just want to make sure I wasn't missing something about the process okay uh anything else on item two standing policy review cycle no okay um so on topics submitted by board members um Kender and I had a chance to email about that on 2430 and what I took away from your email tell me if I got this wrong is that we're going to hold on this but spend our time talking about mental Wellness yeah and I can give a brief summary about just my thoughts around this so for the district school and Community Partnerships I don't think that uh much needs to be changed about the um actual policy I think it's uh written well but I just thought that it would it could benefit from some additions

012um so and I'm just speaking from my experience of being um kind of a community partner so some details around uh specific contracts of a u Community partner is providing services to the district they also have individuals that they may contract and so making sure that there are specific contracts in place before services are rendered um it's just a I think something that could be uh helpful um to add to the policy um as as well as consent forms when appropriate we kind of talked about that with the extracurricular activities and then um lastly um adding language around conflict of interest I know that we'll be talking about that today but I just thought that those are three potential areas that could help possibly strengthen um this policy and I welcome any thoughts and feedback

013from any anyone I know we won't spend much time on it but any possible things to consider with those three topics specific I did um run this by Mr baggot yesterday just in anticipation of this meeting and he he felt that that we were in compliance with the current policy and he felt you know for whatever that's worth I was just kind of checking to see so um but I do think it might be kind of nice um I think we do have sometimes on the website we do have lists of Partners ships by school and uh like who our partners are so that might be a way at some point it might be worth uh a review just to be sure we are in compliance at some point but other than that but I

014think your idea is to add a you know make sure the contracts are in place prior that's a good ad and then uh what you say not the release forms but the consent forms yeah consent forms are just when appropriate because I know there are times that um as we talked about with extracurricular activities there may be activities that are happening throughout the school day but are not necessary but there may be um things that are happening after school where you know um parents fam should be good idea and what when then what you what was your third one uh and then conflict of interest looking into um identifying um just language around ensuring that there's not a conflict of interest of the Partnerships and how that relates to the district sure right great all

015good things to add thank you thank you I appreciate that um thanks Jim and uh K I like all the things you said I don't know that I have anything that I would want to add in addition I also don't have any objections to any of the ideas that you suggested um this is a more of a curiosity and something I want to advocate for but I'm just imagining that superintendent's got a lot to do in the policy currently says the superintendent must approve all of these Partnerships and I'm wondering about decisions at a school level and like are there conditions under which a superintendent could delegate the ability to enter into Partnerships to a building principal or to somebody who's closer to the the the the specific neighborhood or community that might and is

016there do is this policy this is I guess a question for Council but like is the question written in a way that that would still be okay is there anything in here that would preclude that do do we have reasons why we'd want to preclude that like I mostly just a curiosity uh no um and you know again with those three bullet points I was taking notes we can we can suggest language to bring it back on a a scale of one to 10 this is like a one in terms of my level of you know I'm just it was just interesting yeah no there's nothing precluding us from you know like from a procedure or an administrative standpoint ensuring that these like that feedback is taken back and included in the approval process for

017partners so it's it's completely up to the board whether you want these specific items like incorporated into the policy or whether it's just feedback for the administration either is fine with us yeah so I would like to start with um board approval and then if not then we can go to the directive of um if an administrative um focus but I think it would I think it's helpful to have that language um discussed policy so so um we're in an interesting moment time wise because it's our last meeting this group um and so I think we have an opportunity today to vote things out of committee to put on a January meeting agenda if it's for future committee discussion that's also cool just acknowledging it might be a different group of people um and so

018what I hear you saying is for whatever composition this committee has in January council's office would come back with some proposed language for that commit to talk about yes is that everybody on the same page and that feels okay great but um would it be helpful in January for the whoever's on the policy committee to know that we really like this one even though we I guess we don't get a chance to formally approve it until it gets written up yeah sure I I think I think it there would be a nice opportunity to discuss whatever language Council you know comes up with okay okay sounds good great um ter anything else on District school Community Partnerships okay um so next one on the agenda is um I'm just phis one of the things I'm

019noticing we we're going to put the um eval policy back on here we had emailed about is it on here yes yes it's in the packet not on my copy is it on board board do is what matters yeah it's posted great I'm looking at an old sheet of paper um so it it it appears underneath mental Wellness I guess I yeah was oh great okay so cool thank you no no it's just I I can totally pull it up online it's no problem uh in the world of things that matters this is not Rob Rob has it too great basically everybody has it but me that's great that's no problem all right cool we're going to use this one um okay great so I I think on the conflicts of interests I would like

020to move this to the end in the if we have time for a category like if we're still moving along um you know we talked about this at significant length before Mr moraski um stepped down and this is still something I believe in like our current conflict of interest policy does not address campaign contributions I think it would be a great idea for our board to formally adopt a position that a majority of the board supports on when campaign contributions if ever become some kind of conflict um I was convinced uh by the spring summer that there just weren't four votes for a version of this that I thought would make a difference um so I deprioritized it at least for myself um I'd welcome the chance now that we have a new board member

021I think to revisit that um but I I I like to make sure we get to the um mental wellness policy that I know Kendra has spent some time on and we haven't finished that last section of the superintendent eval policy so I'd like to just check with my colleagues would it be I'd like to move this to the end in the if we have time category that's fine maybe also uh if we don't get a consensus or resolution on the campaign contribution topic Dan I'm wondering is it possible you could look to see what other districts do around the state did did we do that already oh and and what okay I think Albuquerque is at the yeah so there was there's a similar policy that was put in place in Albuquerque New Mexico

022that's right Ohio we had not seen other policies outside of that yeah so you know hopefully you know Bas Kar I would love to talk about this today um but I want to make sure we get the other things we've started done first okay so with that I think next on our agenda is policy 1240 uh superintendent policy um and so I think just to start off again with some gratitude uh I do think that we got a 70er vote on the changes that this committee has worked on and I really appreciate everyone's help with that uh I think we have made taken some big steps forward um just getting the timeline to be coherent so that we can look at a full year worth of data about children in evaluating the the the chief

023um of the school district I think is is a big big win um I think having public votes on what the goals are going to be in advance having public votes on what the scoring methodology is going to be in advance um all of this is just making it much much much clearer what the expectations of the board are for the superintendent it's particularly difficult when board members have different ideas about what should matter and so forcing things to happen in public with a vote generates Clarity on what the majority of the board wants to prioritize um uh anybody who watched Monday's meeting knows that um uh like what the majority supports is can be quite different from what like every single board member thinks but that's the way democracy works you know and I

024think that it's really good and healthy that we have made the changes that we have made here and I want to say thank you to everybody um I was kind of you know thinking we might just drop this last section until our last meeting when Dan pointed out um that uh in his he's got much long tenure of the district than I have but your your comment I think Dan was that it would be silly for us to call these infrequent scenarios oh yes um silly was my word but just Ju Just that it actually happens way more than even I thought uh I'm the second longest tenear board member we have at the moment you know like and it surprised even me that there have been that many times where the goal setting with

025the superintendent just hasn't happened um and that kind of or hasn't happened on time on time okay um and that really bolstered my conviction that we should do something like I I'm coming into this meeting without a strong prior about what it should be um I have we have a draft and and Rob has a Google doc that we can look at together that's just the last place I didn't change it it's the last thing we talked about um but it it um I really worry about a scenario where um big chunks of the school year go by without creating real Clarity around what matters most to the board for the superintendent I think that is a recipe for disaster um because nobody wins uh and everybody is frustrated uh and so I I do

026think we should have something in here that says you know best case scenario board and superintendent collaborate do this on time vote in public by the end of the first week in October and everything is great um but if for some reason um that hasn't happened here's a backup plan you know um like what's the I think from my perspective it's really important that these be reasonable you know like it like I don't want these to be punishments um but but I think there should be if if the goals don't get set what would a reasonable thing to do be so that there's never a year where there isn't Clarity before the school year gets too far underway about what the superintendent is going to be evaluated for so um Rob could you bring up

027that that uh Google Document um and can you make the text a little smaller maybe like a 90 or something in that uh Zoom window okay so I this was a draft that I wrote like nine plus months ago um and so there were three scenarios that I considered when I wrote this um one was what happens if the board never approves goals that was scenario one um the other one was the second scenario was what if the board never um gets to a final evaluation like what if the board just chooses not to do an evaluation for the superintendent for the prior year um and then the third was what happens if we have a superintendent who starts in the middle of the school year um rather than like at a neat timing to

028do this really well um so I don't know I think maybe if we go go back to the top um I TR truly uh I have no skin in the game on those two sub paragraphs that like they increase by 10% or that they be improving reading and math scores for students with a even larger impact for uh disadvantaged St economically disadvantaged students students of color it was place it's a place to start um but I really would welcome ideas like what what would a reasonable thoughtful nonp punishment Backup Plan B if the board just doesn't do it what 5% 10% what are we looking at I don't think you could if you're looking at like the stars of rep card card I don't think think the chunks I think the idea would be like

029let's say that the graduate the goal was to improve the um you know passage rate on third grade reading from 50% to 60% last year this year it would be 60% to 70 % again like 10% may be too high like this there may be better ways to do this the thing I want to uh just personally advocate for is that there' be some backup plan yeah yeah I I think it's I think it's all I just don't know reasonable feels High honestly like like like I think I think it it um and maybe you want it that way because you create an incentive to do it together right because the backup is wor but but I I don't want it to I don't want it to feel like a punishment you know like I

030want I want it to create good incentives I like the idea that five that us to actually do do it instead of have this default that's that's not a bad idea it's kind of like he let's get this done otherwise we're gonna it's going to be a high high bar yeah so I like that yeah um I just Echo the sentiments um you know I I'm a strong advocate for setting those high expectations and I think that there are things obviously that could be done to help facilitate that process of Meeting those goals or or exceeding the goals and so written in the policy of the stands is that there will be interim checkins there will be different things to help scaffold right and support the uh superintendent and reaching those goals so um I

031get that it presents to be high but I I think we want to set a standard in an expectation of high you know high standards for um our superintendent because we set high expectations or we should be setting high expectations for our students if if all board members feel comfortable with 10 I'm happy to keep it at 10 if people would feel more comfortable bringing it down to five or waiting to see what the rest of the board says and potentially lowering it to five is like that there be a backup is more important to me than what the backup is creat Inc actually really have the conversation yeah and I would want to start here first and then when it goes back to the board if there's uh any F discussion around it then

032modifications could potentially be made but I would want to say at the 10% okay um so then I think the this next paragraph is probably the hardest one for me because um you know you do need to cover a scenario where there were no goals the prior year um you know everybody knows I wrote This months and months and months ago so this was not on purpose and there's no way I could have foreseen this but this is exactly where we are right now as a school district you know where we have a new superintendent that new superintendent did not have goals last year not because anybody did anything wrong but she wasn't superintendent last year you know um and so like you know we're in the process of negotiating a contract with the new

033superintendent I'm sure that will go great um hopefully nobody ever needs these things but like even just the fact that right where we are right now is this very scenario makes me glad that we're at least talking about it you know and so I I think um I I chose these because I think if nothing else what's our job you know we should be improving student learning outcomes what's the mo maybe you could swap out reading or math efficiency for graduation rate or something I don't know but like I I was trying to pick something that was like really General um and um broadly acceptable and I was trying to push on our Equity policy and our anti-racism policy by saying we should we should have a positive impact for all students and we should

034have a disproportionately strong impact for historically marginalized students um so this felt like gota start somewhere but I'm I'm I'm genuinely very open to other ideas on this so say superintendent shall receive satisfactory rating no sorry we're we're still one Higher it's okay Rob maybe you scroll up just so they can see the prompt for for number one so this is like the second sub paragraph I think it's fine problem um It's kind it creates the incentive to actually really have to come yeah like there's no reason you couldn't do something different you just got to talk about it and you have to vote on it in public you know and and there's but what's the backup plan if nobody does that you know it would be something um I meant to say sorry K

035saying um really for pretty much um the outline of the infrequent scenarios I don't have really any objection okay I I'm I'm treading lightly here because this was an area where board members who are not on this policy committee did not like this section you know and so I we didn't have a chance to to get into a ton of details about why but I one commitment I have particularly when there was some disagreement is I only want to move something out of the committee if all three of us support it um and so I really want and we did that last time I think that worked really well um uh but I'm not hearing of other alternatives for this second sub paragraph okay but you know if you think of something let me know

036okay so that takes care of one two um so this is now a scenario where we have goals but imagine that a board um for whatever reason um doesn't do the first part of the policy where they have to vote in public no we changed it where they have to have a final version and share it with the superintendent um uh uh by the I guess the end of the first week in October so it's like imagine a fall where that is not happening um uh what I want to argue is that you have to create some kind of clarity for that superintendent about whether they're doing good in their job or not good in their job you know um uh and I I defaulted to satisfactory here but you could change it you know

037you could change the default to un like again I'm not tied that it be this I just would like there to be some kind of default so that if a board is not doing what the policy requires you create Clarity we Rob can you go to the PO do you have 1240 up so can you and then can you go up or it says keep going up timeline okay so it says and then scroll down a little bit where is it I know we put it in here where where Dan where's the part about the um sharing the evaluation with the superintendant Rob is that the online version yes where's that I one bullet three proba no on uh yeah part one bullet three right the board shall discuss the superintendent's progress and performance at

038meaningful midpoints over the course of the relevant year I thought there was one more thing we did um you're talking about after the final yeah yeah thank you Stephanie for the win nice so uh if you scroll down uh Rob to part three third paragraph um by the end of the first of October the board will provide the superintendent with a written copy of the final evaluation so this this infrequent scenario is imagining a fall where for whatever reason that doesn't happen and so the super so the superintendent has some board members who are saying saying you think we think you're doing a great job the superintendent has some board members who are saying we think you're doing a terrible job and there is no written evaluation and so all board members are free to

039say any of those things and there is there is nothing that can just create Clarity for the superintendent on which of those two things is true I think we have an odd number of board members on purpose just like there are an odd number of Supreme Court Justices so even if people disagree at least you create Clarity on where things are um and I think leader deserves that um uh whether or not every board member agrees um and so I I worry about a scenario where um and I I I'll just share I have lived through years in my five years on this board where that's happened in more than one um and so I I think um what I wrote you know defaulted to satisfactory you could change it or or maybe maybe it

040could default to like a a statement that says like I don't know like I we could generate something creative yeah thinking um it can remain as satisfactory um but while at the same time um offering feedback for like areas of improvement so while because again for this particular section I think the owners would be on the board and we would have to take accountability for that right so you know we would yes evaluate the superintendent by saying that they have a satisfactory rating but this is additional feedback moving into maybe like doing the next year so if we did something like this um so the superintendent shall receive a satisfactory rating for the year though all board members um can share feedback with the superintendent is that what you're saying yeah and so what that

041would do is it would um it would create clar Clarity for the leader that um they are not going to be dismissed because of their poor evaluation um but it would also leave room for board members who had concerns to share those concerns and be taken seriously also for the superintendent to know what those areas of concerns are and the effort to have both moving into the the next yeah what's that make you think Jim to part one the third sentence says that kind of says that already the board shall discuss the superintend progress and performance um so if we say simpler just to refer to that since it's already what what language would you use just refer to part one point number three approve I don't know is that get so are you saying

042[Music] to go back you said part one where the third sentence the board shall discuss superintendent Pro progress and performance at meaningful midpoints over the course of the relevant year ideally border okay so I I just I changed this Jim to say um though all board members under part one will have shared and can continue to share feedback with super superintendent sure yeah um okay uh any descent on this one okay so if we go to three um if the superintendent starts in the middle of the Academic Year this was just trying to be like split the baby you know like if you got more than half of the year left you should have to do this policy and set goals for the year if you have less than a school year left pick it

043up the following school year cuz got enough other stuff going on but but if people want to do a different version of this you know I'm open kind of have a mid break yeah a good point yeah so for our situation now we probably would like to do something pretty quick in early January do some goal setting and yeah I think either we have to do it exactly like you said or it would be better to wait and do this in the fall when we have a Year's worth of data I would argue we it soon um and I think we can um but but yeah argum okay um Council are we are we missing anything or doing anything that is illegal or bheed I think the only um piece is that this policy will

044always work in concert with the superintendent's contract and so to be conscious of you know making sure that the the policy and the contract align I think is important does does I agree with you thank you um does that make you want to change anything that's in here not necessarily just uh something we we will be conscious of as we are you know as we put together superintendent contracts and something the board should be aware of and conscious of you know the evaluation is a required part of the superintendent employment every year uh it's it's possible the effect of the evaluation would be dealt with in the contract does that does that make sense so and that's true in in previous contracts uh superintendent performance bonuses or or increases have been dependent on the contract

045or even continued employment depended on the EV the evaluation so just making sure those two work in concert yep yeah that feels like that will become particularly important in setting goals you know like when approving those you know like the the the there would be I mean really the it's like the policy will will govern a will create a process to make sure there is clarity about whether the superintendent performed good not good somewhere in the middle what the consequences of good not good in the middle performance are comes from the contract right and not that's right I think that's right yeah and that sounds appropriate I think I do too uh the other thing I'd add I I was perhaps unnecessarily harsh on previous boards for not timely completing um tell me this now

046goals yeah and and part of that is structural I think with respect to you know the district often doesn't get its results from the previous school year until I don't know what there's a date September it's in September yeah and and by the time the board is processing that and thinking about what they would like to see in in the current year oftentimes we're we're halfway through the current year and so it makes it more difficult to that that's been a consistent challenge in my entire time at CPS yeah yeah um and you know we're g to try this but hope I hope my my my intention in shooting for that first week in October was that it would be early enough to give real runway for the school year but late enough to actually

047have that September data you know and um I also my hope to is you know we get preliminary data earlier over the summer you know and so that there can be some earlier conversations kind of setting some groundwork um so you know absent some surprises here's where we would go and if we have surprises we'll change it um okay uh we spent a lot of time on this I'm inclined to move on unless there any any can can we can we say that we're recommending out of the committee this version with um all three votes okay at what point um we'll we do have hearing of the public but we're a very small group Karen and if you would like to share something by all means thank you um I just find this I mean

048you mentioned punitive of the 10% and I feel like 10% is so unrealistic that what we're because we're talking about an increase of 10% over a three over threeyear Trend data for one year right so I mean I'm not a mathematician but that's even more than 10% you're talking about 10% more than what has happened over a three-year period so that's to me that's an enormous jump and and you know to your point that every leader deserves Clarity I guess what you're saying here is that if the board does not agree on performance objectives by October 1st then basically the board will be setting performance objectives that a superintendent cannot meet so to me and and maybe this is the intention but if the board does not is not supporting that's cannot agree on these

049objectives the superintendent is I think bound to fail and so I I don't know if that's the intention um but I I do think that these numbers cannot be hit so just I think I personally think that's very valid uh like and the intention I think is I can just speak for myself like I don't want to fail I things to get better for children uh and but I do think that it's just in my own experience I've seen us not do this you know and so I think the um we were talking about creating an incentive for the but but like if the board wants to mess with a superintendent they can just refuse to vote on something and you wind up in exactly the scenario that and I think that's also bad you

050know um and like does that make um are you recommending an alternative you know don't no I'm not I don't have an alternative I I didn't realize we were going to be discussing this today quite honestly um but I I do think it's serious exactly the way you expressed it if you want to mess with a superintendent all you have to do is not be able to have the board agree on objectives and that feels um you know I don't know what this I don't know what the superintendent's contract looks like but to me that feels unfair yeah I think you wind up recreating exactly the problem we're trying to avoid with which is which is creating a bad situation through board in action you know so like I I like I maybe it's in

051I would be open like I still think we need something because I think there has to be a backup plan um in case the board doesn't do what it's supposed to do uh and but I do think that that backup plan should be one that creates good incentives rather than bad incentives um and what that makes me want to do is lower the number a little bit um you know like what yeah um um you you none of this exists now yeah uh you rais a valid point I'm wondering if uh um part of the goal setting process is collaborative so it could be there could be a default to uh some language in here a default to the goals that the superintendent sets for themselves I mean that's we we did that would force

052the board to do something yeah yeah because it is a collaborative goal setting process so maybe we leverage that part of the goal setting to say well the superintendent made their own goals and whether they achieved them or not that's because we as a board could not agree on an alternative but that would be the default sort of yeah [Music] uh superintendent would if the superintendent doesn't set their own goals then maybe the 10% kicks in or some percentage kicks in something like that yeah yeah what do you think that's an interesting idea so so I agree with the uh goal setting uh collaborative process with the superintendent um but I also want to ensure and I'm I'm okay with working with the 10% if we need to change that but I also want it

053to be um something that will still try to move uh outcomes forward and not um allow just a place of comfort either right so I I guess there would just need to be discussion around what would be reasonable um while still stretching us as a district um with the with the board but is I I I I'm smiling because I feel like even in this conversation it's like forcing us to have conversations in public about what matters and that's the point you know like I think that is healthy I think that is good um so I'm I'm already excited whatever the number is you know but what so I'm I'm just I'm trying to reflect what I heard from colleagues um and so if we if we were to we don't have to do this

054but if we were to say if there were performance objectives sat so so where where if the board does not vote by the end of the first week of October um then we're proposing as an alternative the superintendent shall set her his own measurable goals um by the end of that month then if um hang on and you share them with the board if the superintendent does not um last year's and this 10% thing would be there I'm I'm I'm not saying we should or should not do this I'm trying to write down what I think I heard people say um and curious people think about this I think it honors both perspectives how I'm seeing it yeah what I love about it is that there's never a year where there where there is an

055absence of clarity about what the superintendent is going to be held accountable for um and like the board has control over whether that's a good thing or not a good thing but but if you want it to be a good thing you got to vote in public yeah um and that feels like forcing democracy to work I think this seems better yeah okay great um thank you for thank you for pointing that out yeah I would just add it's not in the superintendent's interest to say we're gonna drop by 5 per. also should be has some incentives yeah but but like yeah and and there's there's enough stuff around here you could choose to focus on without focusing on the hard stuff you know like this this will just force the kinds of conversations and

056the kinds of voting that I think is good okay so we we're recommending out this one with all three votes yep okay great uh moving on um next on the list is mental health I think yeah all right so uh just wanting to provide some context and rationale around just the thought uh the draft of this policy so one this is uh a area that I'm really passion about um just given my profession as a licensed professional counselor um but also because we have a a current standing guard rail which talks about honoring the uh needs and talents of the whole child and so we recognize that in our district we are doing so many great things as it pertains to Mental Health and Social and emotional Wellness however there is not um continuity around

057it or a kind of a comprehensive f focus and so I think this policy really helps to streamline that information and so um with the support of General Council so Dan uh Stephanie as well as Dr Manisha house who's the director of repositive school culture we had an opportunity to meet to just create um kind of a foundational draft of the policy um I did go in and make some um revisions but this is something that I want to um ensure that everyone has opportunity provide feedback um and and to uh let you know this is not something that has to be approved to move forward today but we want to have um you know continual opportunities to have discussion around it and so the first um goal area we pretty much drafted it very

058similar to the previous wellness policy but they're focusing around um just that Nutritional Health as well as physical health um so we identified very pertinent goals that um stood out to us that we were already really focusing on and so the first goal is to for each school to have staff uh and trained mental health and School counseling professionals and so we already know that we have those but I really like this section and I flesh this out a little bit more because a number of um just individuals within our district or families may not be fully aware of what uh each professional scope entails and so really providing that language and that definition around what a mental health therapist would do um and that falls under the counselors the school counselors because they play

059a pivotal role and I don't know if we utilize them enough and so wanted to make sure that they are um in this conversation our school psychologists our school social workers and I also want to add and you all can give me feedback around this I want to make sure that we add our intervention Specialists because they handle a lot of um you know they support a lot of our students and I know they work directly with our um positive School culture um director and team and I think that will help to have that level of continuity of services that's available so what I'm thinking around this um in terms of adding them is making sure that when we're discussing individualized education plans or we're discussing different accommodations that they are also included in the

060conversation in terms of who our um comprehensive team of mental health and school counselors support are any questions around um I think I think it's great um I've been visiting schools I think I'm up to 21 schools now but uh and and many schools that I've visited have school psychologists and the mind piece rooms uh but I haven't heard of this crisis interventionist is that I don't think they're at every school I haven't seen that but um so the the intervention specialist yeah that's what I meant special so they work with our special education students okay yeah yeah um and then what I will also no problem what I will also want to add which is not on this current draft but making sure that all of our professionals are adhering to their State Licensing

061boards um making sure that they um and I will ask I would want to ask you a question around this uh Dan as it pertains to the malpractice insurance um I know that we are expected to carry our own but I don't know how that works within kind of the district but wanting to make sure that there's that liability insurance in place and also that there's continuing education um hours that they are being compliant with while it also aligns with what our schools Mission Vision goals and guard rails are yes we carry comprehensive professional liability insurance for uh the folks who work in our schools and and especially this time of year when they're updating their lure and need to uh have proof of that we uh get that question daily almost for uh okay

062making sure that they have uh proof of their professional liability insurance okay yeah perfect so it's good to add okay right so are there any areas of concern or questions that may stand out yes uh I think it's exciting it's great these are all things I believe in a great deal I think um I know I've shared this with Kendra I don't I've shared with everybody else but both my parents are mental health therapists before they're retired I think this is really important stuff I want to do more of it um do you are there any budget implications like does this require us to spend more than we've spent in the past good question I don't think so um that has not been communicated to me uh based off of what is written here or

063things that we are currently already doing the only thing that I would um raise question about would be um when we get to uh goal three as we're talking about incorporating social emotional learning into the academic curriculum or making sure that it's moving throughout um the entire school day because you shouldn't just interface with soci emotional Wellness for 10 minutes by having a mindfulness you know practice in the morning um but it really should be comprehensive throughout the school day that helps to build up the uh resiliency of the students it helps to build up those practical um mindsets and um attitudes for the students so really trying to hone in this being more comprehensive and fluid and so to your question about budgetary concerns I do know that uh Dr Minish house and her

064team are having conversation around a curriculum right I think it would be very necessary and beneficial for us to have a uniform curriculum that's age appropriate so if we dealing with our elementary students a curriculum that's appropriate for them as well as for you know um like high school students and what that would look like so I do know that she's currently her and her team are working through that so that would be the only thing that I would uh maybe uh consider that may have some budgetary implications but everything else should be what we have been doing um as normal that's great I mean I think um I would like to support all of this the the only thing that would make me um question a little bit is given our financial situation are

065there anything things here we can't afford um but I think absent that I think it looks great to me I'll also just another thing I think is great about it um you know there are states I'm glad Ohio isn't there yet where social emotional learning uh as a term is toxic um and it is uh weaponized I think by some politicians to imply things that it does not mean uh and I love that we include it and I love that we say really specifically what we mean by it you know so I do think children should grow up with self-confidence a sense of belonging positive posivity towards learning in work teamwork responsibility self these are these are great things for everybody you know and so I'm glad it's in there uh and that's all I

066got thank you for that and also a lot of that language too is um referencing from the ASA model so that is the American School counseling Association again I just wanted to make sure that we're highlighting um the comprehensive work that's already done not trying to reinvent the wheel but really putting in perspective for everyone because we have language in our guard rails or we we constantly refer to you know how we support our students but really uh providing one standard um approach to what the district means by that right um and so just I just wanted to make sure that we carve that out um the and and also I wanted to highlight that this isn't just for students either because we wanted to make sure our educators are supported as it pertains to

067their mental health and social emotional wellness and so um when we're talking about just the services that are provided a lot of times our Educators our staff um are not aware of what supports and benefits are available so talking about that employee assistance program um ensuring that there are you know options for health AES or um uh workshops and I'm speaking from this because this is what I go out and do Reg to provide to um different companies and so making sure that they are knowledgeable about those benefits um and able to access those benefits um and um ensuring that they have the resources because we want to make sure that they are um coming to a place that feels you know um holistic and they are feeling supported so that they can properly serve

068our students to the best of their ability so that is in the first um let me see I think it's in the first goal if I'm not mistaken go one yes um and then for goal two we're talking about those common spaces so a space with designated within the classroom for students to be able to work on um if they need to regulate their emotions or they need just that uh opportunity to really U regulate their nervous system right calming their U calming themselves down and having relaxation and mindfulness um resources and techniques in place and then again also extending that to our our teachers I know that um a lot of schools that I have visited now I either have a mind piece room um not only for students but also for their staff

069and so uh just wanted to make sure that we highlighted that there as well and then are there any questions about anything that I've shared so far I think it's great all good stuff important thank you perfect thank you and then uh so go for um again we're already doing the PBIS interventions and this is the framework that really supports that tiered um process for not only behavioral supports but also academic supports right um and so leaning into that making sure that um we're offering um continual education for our Educators um on trauma informed care as well as mental health aid first care or or excuse Mental Health First Aid um resources and anything that we do provide we want to make sure that it's all evidence-based and so um that could be something that

070could be added and then lastly um for goal five as it relates to um our school partners and agencies um I I wanted to add language around making sure that we're continuing to um look for resources for federal and state grants that we can ensure this continual line of work if possible um and just continuing that um opportunity for education and awareness and I think that that's something that our partners could be doing so that might be another area that we have to look at in terms of budget um but making sure that um our partners are supporting our district which providing that information reducing the stigma um and also helping to support with that family engagement so that we are all embracing this um this perspective of Wellness so is this Jim did you

071go first um did um go this this paragraph under five is new so go five has been there but I'm just wanting to just incorporate some additional things that really stood out to me about making sure that we are continuing um to look for resources for federal state grants I don't know that needs to be there that may be an administrative thing um I was just trying to um so is is am I right I'm just several steps behind you thank you for being patient um the schools will partner with agencies that's in there currently and what's new is the paragraph below it that each School shall have that paragraph what I'm talking about now is possible additions that I'm considering adding that's not I got you but we the board already approved that each

072School shall have a collocated blah blah blah blah blah great are like beach Acres um or like um uh it's no longer children's home but those are great okay I if you want to add something that talks about reducing the stigma I think that'd be really good yeah all right so that's all that I have uh as it pertains to our into wellness policy and what I do hope to um do moving forward again I welcome any feedback not just from those that are in the room but those that are watching I do um intend to go back and work with general counsel as well as Dr minisha house um as well as um we talked about adding the school counselors anyone that's really involved in this work to have conversation with them as well

073because we wanted to make sure that it's representative of everyone's voice as much as possible that's great quick question I think it's great I I know you know there are enormous needs for mental health services in schools and we really appreciate this um I I do wonder about a couple of um whether there might be a fiscal impact I don't think it would be major but the idea the classroom should designate calming Corners um with that are equipped with furnishings and materials I just you know I want to make sure that that's not going to sort of come out of the teachers um instructional Supply budget and and I also didn't know if those are going to be happening in high schools as well as uh elementary schools I don't know if I mean I

074I respect you as a mental health professional I don't know if that's works for high school students or not but I thought that might be just something to put on your radar screen I appreciate that um so yes I will definitely take that into consideration um I do know just in my experience um I think a lot of teachers are already doing that but I don't want to say you know for certain but just in observing certain classrooms it's kind of that space that um teachers are already kind of providing but we'll definitely take that back to the team and have discussion around that and to your point in terms of high school I also think is kind of important right because again we want to create this culture where um it is it's okay

075and it's welcome to be able to attend to your self-care right and your overall Wellness in the best possible way and so leaving a classroom sometimes may not you it may not provide that level of inclusivity right but if I know that okay I just need to regulate my system for just a moment I have a designated space that I can go to Canal to be helpful for our high school students as well okay thanks yeah i' I've observed uh the spaces in Elementary classrooms and I I think uh what the teachers have put together cost almost nothing not not a big additional cost that I could perceive I wouldn't see that as a financial hurdle um maybe just a bean bag chair and a soft light yeah yeah or even just a place I've

076seen them where they're just a place for the student to stand and and it's a little bit partitioned off and there and there's a place to just to stand and be calm so I it didn't seem like it was a big expense at all great yeah thank you for that so just to recap next steps on this one so next steps um we can do what we did as it pertains to the um Community Partners we can vote to put it on the agenda for the policy committee next year great so work with everybody okay excellent all right all right um we are coming down to our last few minutes everybody so let's do um Rob do we have any speakers online for hearing the public we do not is there anybody here who would

077like to speak Karen please well I don't I mean I'm good with the policy as it is but I think if we talk about adding information about campaign contributions and that sort of stuff I don't know what you're proposing but I think there is a framework um the Ohio ethics commission has a framework and I don't think it's necessary for us to have a separate framework I think there's been a lot of work done over a long period of time at the state level um and it's um coherent and so I don't feel like it's necessary for us to do something that is in addition to that does do the Ohio I'm I'm being a little loose here just because we have extra time and you didn't speak for very long uh is there anything

078else you want and man' tell me your name would you like to speak today great okay y got me on that 10% there I'm still reing I'm trying to scenari in my head okay uh well you're welcome anybody else said just I just be curious does the ethics I'm not aware of the ethics commissions um rules that are about campaign contributions as a conflict of interests for someone who is elected that doesn't mean they're not there I just don't something can can you say more about what they are I no I didn't bone up on this last night because I didn't realize we were going to talk about it today I thought we were just I thought the proposal was just the the the policy that's in place um but I do know that it's

079a very you know that it's comprehensive and there is a Cadre of lawyers who deal with these questions and um and it's not something that is done anywhere that we're aware of except Albuquerque and New Mexico I'm sure has a different set of you know they has different state laws and guidelines around this so I don't I can't speak to what happens in Albuquerque or why they do it there but it's not um it's not commonly done or obviously needed so I think that it's you know I think when there is a whole body of law in place which I know there is um that it's not necessary to kind of try to create your own I I appreciate that um Can can I ask Dan like I um I am not aware of rules

080that impact elect elected school board members that have to do with the campaign contributions that they received but that that doesn't mean they're not there I just don't I don't know what they are I I don't think campaign contributions are generally covered under the Ohio ethics law that's not to say that a quid proquo campaign contribution can't be brought as a criminal act under go we've never seen any of that right yeah so I I I don't believe that they that campaign contributions are generally handled by the ethics law I think they're generally handled by the criminal law yeah yeah I mean so so so I and I'll just share where I am on this and and would love to hear from Kendra and from from Jim too like I I I think we may

081disagree you know I think I think I agree with you that they they're um you know there aren't a lot of school districts that have done things around campaign contributions other than Albuquerque um but just because nobody's done it before from my perspective doesn't mean it's not something that's worth doing for a first time um and I think that there are ways in which um campaign contributions can potentially have an outsized impact on the behavior of elected officials that fall short of a of an explicit criminally punishable quid po quo um and so I I I thought it could be Health stronger I think it would be healthy for us to decide as a as a whatever it's not going to be today but like whatever future policy committee looks at this um to figure

082out um how do we want to conduct ourselves here in CPS and to say we know that there's no State prohibition against some of these things or federal prohibition against some of these things but we're going to choose to hold ourselves to this standard because we think it's a healthy one um and again but like you know we're not proposing anything today um or sorry I'm not proposing anything today but Jim would love your uh just give me an example of what policy would change that happening now so the the version of this that I introduced like when Mr moraski was here this would have been in like February or something something was that if you receive contributions in excess of a certain number I think I put $5,000 which is you know the average

083Schoolboard race raises about $20,000 so $5,000 is like a quarter a big but was somewhat also somewhat arbitrary right um that if uh somebody receives um campaign contributions in excess of a certain number then that person should recuse themselves from votes on contracts with the organization or the individual who contributed to the campaign School roofs yeah yeah like that okay I got to think about it I understand the intent of that um but I got I have to think about that because I I think if you're running for office and you get supported by that like if youve if you've already said hey we need new roofs uh and then then you get supported maybe that's still okay I don't know I'm think about and and look like there's no um I I I'm gonna

084stand by what I said earlier too like I only want to really support things out of this committee that we can get through V for everybody on board and I also like and everybody can do the same uh I'm going to say what I believe you know and so I I do believe that this would be a good and healthy direction for us to go I'd welcome the chance to be a part of that with people but we're going to have to see you know um what do you think well I'll just say in short my positions through fans I recuse myself from L lots of things um and and it's because of I do not want to be in a position where it is a conflict of interest so I think it's always um

085good to have those healthy practices in place and I don't think that um it's sends a negative or I would hope that it wouldn't send a negative message to those that have decided to support I would hope that it would send a positive message about just the integrity and just upholding the ethics of you know um making decisions but not in a manner in which it is predicated on someone's contribution but what what is in the best interest of students uh uh I was appointed I didn't run for office do you do you do you have to dis I should know this do you disclose who your C who contributes to your campaign that's all public so in a way that almost sort of creates a situation where um the public would know hey maybe

086he should be recusing himself on that one or she should be right so so there there's a way for that to sort of already be um monitored a little or I don't know what I'm saying we have a scenario now where people can make their own choices uh and about what they recuse themselves from and don't recuse themselves from and the Public's totally free to look step up and decide what they think about that and whether they like that and they can come to hearing of the public and talk about it they can vote for somebody or not vote for somebody um and what I was advocating for earlier in the year um was that there be a um something a little no no like like just a like like that we would decide as

087a board our expectations for each others are about when when we want people to be recusing themselves um it it is it is when it comes to the campaign contribution piece it is completely up to the board member um what they Rec I mean I guess subject to criminal liability um uh from better State something yeah and the other thing we talked about is there there is some limit on the board's ability to stop each other from voting on things that you're duly elected to yeah and so we we talked about like the board wanted to hang a sign over each board member that said this candidate paid for by X Y and Z probably could do that but stopping that person from performing their elected Duty I forgot that that's right yeah so like

088even whatever you come up with it's going to be subject to those limits yeah also I'm I'm thinking about the roofing scenario I mean really we don't have a lot of control over that I mean the Administration has a whole purchasing process that vets can buyers and all that that's separate from what our interaction it's pretty far removed I mean I don't I don't know I'm just trying to think through different scenarios where that like a that kind of contribution wouldn't we wouldn't be able to pick the vendor just because they gave us the money we wouldn't be able to do that that's pretty far below us that's what we hope right I mean like if everything works the way it's supposed to yeah well listen I think that's a fine note to end on

089unless anybody has anything else burning um we're going to vote out of the committee Dan just kidding I just at the end of the year I think it's important to recognize the important work the committee did this year the the policy committee can be sometimes tedious and word smithing and whatever but looking back on the year there there was some really important things that the committee did um this year uh board did a lot to address things that are going on in the world we added an artificial intelligence policy a crowdsourcing policy and reversed itself on cell phone usage to allow schools to start using Yonder pouches um also addressed a lot of important Community needs as as mundane perhaps as changing the uniforms and dress and grooming policy to say that students can't be

090removed for violations of that uh added an important change to the administration of medications policy um and even uh adopted a renewable energy um resolution that was really driven by some students and staff at at our schools uh finally uh did some really firstof kind um policies uh we added a hate speech policy this year that I think was uh unique to CPS um and I would say the mental wellness policy is something that we is first of its kind and unique so wanted to congratulate the committee on another really important year and um thank you on behalf of the administration that's very nice Dan I'm not I'm not used to being thanked um so I appreciate thank you thank you um thank you for our great staff our regulars our board staff our technician

091um happy holidays everybody and we'll see you next year

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.