001e e e all right good evening and welcome to the December 11th meeting of the CI Public School audit committee um welcome this evening uh it's our last meeting of the year I'd like to just kick off um very briefly uh and recognize uh David foot for uh his 15 years of service uh to the audit committee and the school district uh David is not uh seeking reappointment to the audit committee and so we want to take a minute just to say thank you for everything you've done over these years and if uh you want to say anything feel free to do so well thank you I don't have any prepared statements but um but no the the uh audit function and the audit committee here has matured a lot since I started there was
002we had a committee and one auditor and and um uh it has progressed significantly and Lauren has done a great job expanding the department and and uh adding value to to this organization and um um I've I've really enjoyed working with this group and being on this committee and seeing it grow and I think it's just time for younger folks to step in and carry on the torch so thank you all right thanks David um we've got a fairly decent size agenda so we'll kind of get into it um I'm GNA hand everything over for the moment to board member Craig uh to handle the uh disc opening discussions around the chair appointments for 2025 yeah so um we have had the uh pledgeable year with Dan and Liz and our leadership positions and we
003want to make sure that um we recognize those and appreciate it but also give opportunities for those who might want to step into leadership roles as we come into the new year um and so again recognize we have our chair and our vice chair that we would have to um reappoint for the upcoming year so um first off are there anyone who have interest or who would like to nominate anyone into the the chair position again recognizing Dan was in this currently but uh anyone is able to express interest or nominate someone who we believe would have an interest I think they're doing a wonderful job yes can I nominate Dan I second are there any other nominations or or anyone else okay um I guess I I I'd be remissed if I didn't at
004least say that um and I'm not I don't want to put Liz on the spot but I think there was some hope that the that the vice chair would ultimately move into the the chair position and I think um Liz I you know I don't want to speak for you but I um uh I I don't think she has a desire so I was hoping that that would be the ultimate succession here uh but I'm um certainly happy to continue on and thank you for the nomination um but I I do have some interest at some point of not being the chair and I think there is I I I have some interest in get making sure there's succession and that there's leadership that is at least relatively consistent over periods of time so that
005we're not losing you know future institutional knowledge in these in these roles so um and that being said you know thank you for the the nomination and I guess do I have to formally accept uh yes okay accept the the nomination okay um and so I guess at this point we would do a uh would just certainly do a vote I I guess again I don't know that it necessarily has to be a surprise on this one but uh I think Lauren we is that correct yep so we have the essentially the motion by Paul the second with Carol and then we can do a roll call Vault if that's agreeable wonderful so we'll just start at the top uh Dan yes Liz yeah David yep H Kevin yes Paul yes Carol yes Mr Craig
006yes and that's everyone thank you um so the other position is for vice chair and um you know again I think this is an opportunity to support and bring some new voices if others would like to join into the conversation I think I I know some folks have may have expressed interest and so I again want to open up for any nominations for vice cheer I would like to nominate Clarice um she's not here tonight I think she's uh with family uh expecting a grandbaby I believe so I have traded some emails with her and she is um interested in uh uh the vice picking up the vice chair position if um the group would would have her I I would second that if she has the interest is Liz no longer interested in the
007row uh yes that is correct okay all right um again given uh we have a a motion in a second and and um at least an expressed interest in it to the uh to the chair uh I think we can call for a vote on uh Clarice wonderful Dan Hol house yes Li gridge yes H David foot yes Kevin Hoffman yes Paul kitsmiller yes Carol Mitchell Lawrence yes H Brandon Craig yes Ben Lindy because Mr Craig says it's a good idea yes it's a great idea thank you all right thank you um we are going to uh postponing to our February meeting um new member appointments um we've uh audit committee members you do have the applications of those four that applied we need a little bit more time to vet these and interview um
008so please do review these um in the coming weeks I'll be scheduling some interviews and anybody who has an interest in being a part of the interview process let me know uh not necessarily putting you on the spot here in the public meeting but um if you have interest and and want to just send me a note um I can include uh you and I'll of course include Clarice uh to to to have these interviews and we'll come come February we'll have uh uh folks to to more thoroughly discuss and and appoint or vote on to submit to the board for appointment to the audit committee for 2025 and the one final appointment matter is the reappointment of Paul kitsmiller for another three-year term um so I would uh entertain a motion to uh reappoint
009Paul to uh another three-year term a motion thank you second second all right and then Lauren can you do roll call roll call vote Dan hold house yes Liz grid yes David foot yep Kevin Hoffman yes Paul kitsmiller yes Carol Mitchell Lawrence yes Brandon Craig yes Ben Lindy yes thank you okay now we can move on to um something we haven't done in a number of years and that's talk about our Charter Eve is probably screaming at us right now but it has been a number of years since we updated the charter um and so we've got a couple items there in our packets uh there are a number of highlighted um passages in the charter uh the First on page one um there has there's a little there's a level of ambiguity with with
010some things in our Charter um and it currently is written as no more than 10 members um it's unclear as to that whether that's 10 community members or 10 Community plus the three members of the board so we would like to clarify consider clarifying that to say no more than 10 community members so there's a little bit more clarity there on on how many folks we are in fact uh needing to add um there's also a question as to whether we should uh put a specific mandate that that members actually physically reside in the the school district boundaries that was put in place a number of years ago um the fact of the matter is it is increasingly hard to find members that want to serve that live in the city um in the district
011boundaries um so those are the two highlevel topics that we would like to discuss as a group um ultimately we are uh looking for feedback discussion and then um Lauren has a couple other more administrative items that she wants to go over in terms of our responsibilities um so the objective here would be to discuss those main two items anything else that Lauren has on on her list and then um certainly take more time if we need to to to leave this meeting and digest the uh the respons roles and responsibilities a little bit more and then come back to a February meeting where we would um conclude on this as a group um vote to approve it for then ultimately be moved up to policy then moved up to the board for full approval
012we want to be thorough here because this is a lengthy process that does take up the board's time so we don't want to uh only submit one change and then six months later ask for two or three more changes uh so we want to be thorough here so uh let's first I'll first open it up to the floor to um talk about the first passage highlighted in yellow on page one of the charter around clarifying not more than 10 community members instead of just saying members um and also just I think part of the reason we want to clarify that is on the second page I think maybe this was unintentional but we me mention a minimum of eight members um which I think maybe is limiting and that we we fall below during the
013term we might run into issues there so um the intent was maybe to to to cap it at 10 community members just clarify that but then also remove that minimum so that we have more flexibility yes thanks for clearing there missed that part um so that's on the top of page two highlighted any concerns thoughts I have concerns I think they're both those are good ideas okay all right um quick Dan though sure we're adding all members must reside in the boundaries no that's the second question we'll move to that here in a second yeah so um if there's no questions about the the number of the composition of the the committee the second piece here is again the bottom of page one all members must reside within the city Cincinnati City School District boundaries
014is currently in the charter and the question is do we uh do we consider striking that do we consider loosening that to that's a preference or that's something to be considered um when we are uh vetting candidates um at the end of the day we you know you could have someone that lives five feet inside of Kentucky or 5T inside of Norwood that has maybe does have a passion for public school and they might have gone to Cincinnati public schools and they may be an active contributor in um the business community and could be a strong contributor to this committee um but under the way that the the charter is written today they would be precluded from being able to participate so um I'd like to open that up for discussion that's probably a little
015bit more of a uh I think we'll probably have more discussion here than then on the first item I I guess my first question would be what does the board think because does the board have any concerns about that because the last thing I'd want to do is us get comfortable with something present it to the board the board strike that down um the second thing I would say if we're worried about restriction of that we could also think of instead of fully striking that think of ways like you said preference or maybe opening it up saying you know there are people who live outside of the district who have kids go to school here that may be you know legally of course um that maybe that's a way of opening it up some because
016I think part of the reason that's probably in there is to show a vested interest in school district and not saying that if you lived in Norwood or Kentucky you wouldn't have a vested you wouldn't have an interest in the school district but maybe you're maybe we're trying to force more vested interest rather than just interest in it it's just my two thoughts I was gonna ask a couple questions and and forgive me if this was covered earlier um I know I was I came in a few minutes late is the um have there been particular people who have come up in the past where gosh we wish this person could join but they've been you know precluded because they lived outside CPS we have had applicants Lauren probably has more details if she she
017can dig those up I'm sure if we need to that we have had to preclude and we do have a current member who is on the committee who did move to Kentucky um uh Seth Harmon so that so this came up in light of that but then also we have had this prior applicants so um just seems like a good time to to talk about the the requirement and and are we short on people um I wouldn't say we are based on the minimum 10 or the maximum 10 um when we do ask for uh applications there there are very few that do in fact ultimately apply we do have four which is probably the most we've ever had in one um one cycle yeah like when I've shared this on LinkedIn for examp example
018I've been careful to call out share with your interested Network however they must reside within the district and I did get a few LinkedIn messages oh I'd be interested and my quick easy response is oh are you a CPS resident and if they're not that kind of ends the conversation so um I think they're out there I think we've just been clear to broadcast it so people don't take the time to apply and then find out they don't in fact qualify so um that's kind of been my [Music] experience I I will just note um with uh all all humility that if anybody watched Monday's board meeting I'm the last board member you should ask if you want to know what the rest of the board is going to do um so you can ignore
019everything that I will say um but my my perspective is that uh diversity is good getting perspectives from outside people is healthy uh I also think it's really important that people that some critical mass have skin in the game you know and you could solve that in lots of ways you could say preference you could say at least half or at least 2third um but again I would ask Every Other Board member other than me thank you yeah also to share I think there's two maybe factors that I think would be helpful in looking at it and and one is kind of looking at preference language and Andor um having some direct either living the district working within the Cincinnati public schools district area or work you know or some something that would say you
020have been connected to the area for which The District covers as part of your uh being on the on uh joining the board or joining the U the audit committee I think the other question becomes also your status is staying on the audit committee so there may be a difference between how you would treat someone who's first joining versus someone who is now that they're here and something may change what are the grounds for which they would no longer be eligible to be a Committee Member um and those two things may be slightly different for some folks I I think that's that's the one thing to think about I think the other thing that I think as a board would we would say is it more than likely at the time that it was in
021and I wasn't on the board at the time that it was created this this particular report was created there was an interest in making sure that the committee that the audit committee had a focus around at least from what I've been told um had a focus or had a invested were invested in the in the school district in some form or fashion but also had a focus on how the district operated and like at least had some type of understanding the district existed and what was connected to the district I don't know that that's so much the case that that is the same needed interest now in the same way that it was then right because when you're starting it or when you're initially putting this in and creating a committee you may be having
022a you may have a more vested interest in having folks on there who actually understand the district may actually experience the district have actually you know put some dollars into the district kind of idea versus now where you you're now looking also the role of the committee the role of the committee may be slightly different from when it first added in and so there the need to have someone who's that in in tune to what's going on in the district Beyond just being on the committee may not be as um necessary so I just think those are factors to think about but I I again I'm not sure I can sit there and tell you what the board will or will not do in that end of the deal uh either um we do have
023the policy committee chair who would say we would bring it up a discussion um at the present moment but uh I think that's I think there may be some interest from some board members that would have that concern with just what is the person's buy into the district if they're not a resident at some point or not somehow connect to but I don't know that there' be a a absolute against the idea of if we gave a preference or if we made it a some form of distinguishing for folks who have uh like so many of the board members are had to be a resident or something that or so many of the committee members had to be a resident or something to that effects so question as a board member do you need to
024be a resident in order to hold a position well so we're elected in order to run for office we do I get it but and I'll say this there are certain positions within the district where that is a requirement that they are but that is not is very few so I mean most of our teachers don't live within the district many of the staff don't live within the district it's not to say that we don't encouraged people to use us and and move in and that kind of deal but it's not a absolute mandate for many of the positions outside of our some of our really top level positions I don't think it's even required for the superintendent we just put it in the contract often that they have to live in the district yeah
025I think it's something we' we've applied to the superintendent contract for the last probably four or five superintendent if not more but I don't know that it's in some of the other senior leadership positions is it a requirement so I I think that there should be a vested interest in the person living in the community but I think we could get around some language maybe it's also working like you're paying taxes that there's some investment that you have I also think are we really building relationships with our business communities so that we have a bank of people that we can tap into as opposed to just putting you know things out there on LinkedIn um that maybe we could get maybe some more Buy in if we are starting to build those relationships with our
026corporate Community Partners um to get some one um some people some volunteers to come especially a lot of them have Auditors in the companies that would be um helpful to the committee uh and uh to the board so that's just my opinion the only thing I would add about as somebody who was a former auditor uh and who works in a business here in the city um there are some guidelines that businesses set up that that prohibit you at times from being a part of things like a government entity and I know we're probably in a hazy area as to whether this audit committee would fall under the definition of a government entity but I you know I would probably bet CPS does um and many public institutions it has to go really high up
027like when I worked at 5if third as an audit man audit audit person I had to go to the head of audit to get approval to do that if I wanted to join certain boards and things like that so it is tough to do that depending on some of those things but I as a former auditor and an audit committee person I think having more Auditors would be great but I also value somebody like you who may not have that audit background who thinks things differently than me if we have group think we're going to fail yeah and I totally agree with that I'm I've been involved on the other side of audits so I have a different perspective right I've sit in the payroll department for my whole career so I have a different
028perspective also from that perspective so I think that diversity of thought I wasn't at the meeting I was in Texas watching the bingles win Miss the meeting but Mr L I think diversity of thought is great if you are not thinking like everybody else that that's great to have that so that's just my opinion make sure you get your phone number after this meeting just add one other thought onto it is that we could also do something like proximity too so like if you had a in the district or within so many miles of the district that may keep some folks who might be you know like literally if you move to Norwood and you were like across the street from CPS I think it's a little weird for us to be like you have
029no invested interest in the district or if you're in Northern Kentucky and some ways now if you move to Florida like that's a little bit different and like there's an expectation that like folks who have moved so far past or so far out ofs side of the district that yeah even if they had a strong interest and strong love they they just not committed in the same way to the things that would be affected by it but um with so much of the city so much of the city connected to each other even when they're not in the same communities per se but they're right next to each other I like I think it's be fair you know like if you lived pretty close to or within a few miles of that may be another
030way to phrase the language out and uh to to build off of that we did have a member leave and move to Chicago uh three or four years ago out of state so they stopped serving on the committee that was obviously way significant distance away so moving to Covington I think that you know we're thinking about that and um that's where this is all coming from um I would be in favor of you know removing the sentence here and then drafting some sort of language that um describes the diversity in background profession um fill in the blank of what whatever we want to include there we do think through those things as we vet candidates we have done that whether that's prescribed the charter or not um that has been a focus of ours so
031um and then maybe we we have something with preference to living in the district however would consider someone that didn't live in the district as long as they lived within so many miles any further discussion on this specific item um I think specifying a number of miles is maybe a little bit too limiting just because I feel like you're always going to have maybe that person that's just over the line and I I think the the purpose maybe to take that out is to increase flexibility I I I agree that I think members should have an interest in the district and I in a perfect world if you had an excess of candidates I would say I would my preference would be to keep it as a requirement but but um in the absence of
032that I don't want us to you know lose that diversity of experience or someone that might have like very relevant experience so I think maybe just yeah including it as a preference and that way that gives us more judgment to say this person maybe does or does not have an interest in the district based on where they live and work um and the other thing too is I because members are required to appear in person and vote I think that would eliminate naturally because I think it was during covid when we had the member move out of state um and so we were allowed to vote virtually but now that we're always in person I think it you're naturally only going to get people that live somewhat close um but you know I I I
033still think it would be nice if they live work have kids here you know I I think we should still have that as a preference but maybe just not a a hard stop on any any individual person for that reason okay we'll Craft um we'll craft some changes to this and present it back to the committee in um February for uh either final tweaking or um voting on that Lauren can you um take over on the other items you wanted to talk about yeah just just uh as chair house said with our opportunity to make our edits and ideally making them all at once I have included along uh with the charter document a spreadsheet of sorts that's been printed off that essentially takes all of the responsibilities so the the the what become I
034guess our final two pages of this document this is how we make our work plans for each of our meetings so you the question I have and the ask that I have is for you to review not only the items listed in bullet point format within the charter itself but also glancing through and seeing how we attempt to cover them throughout the year I think we likely uh do a better job of covering certain items than others and the benefit is we can either have a more concerted effort to really talk about these things moving forward or alternatively we could edit them to maybe fit our reality and our Focus as well so just wanted to draw your attention to this is our approach of how we attempt to cover every item and also our
035opportunity to ensure we are aligning our Charter with our reality thank you all right so if everyone could do that before the February meeting we'll uh we'll have some feedback during that meeting and uh we'll be able to submit to the policy and the board uh an updated Charter at that time time hopefully um the final item very quickly is our 2025 meeting schedule um Lauren would you mind uh kind of going through your thought process on on the tweaks that you made to this absolutely so what you see before you is just a proposed schedule uh the board will set all of the committee members so the board members per committee as well as their 2025 schedule in the early months of the year ially in the January time frame however uh we are
036often asked what our preferred meeting Cadence and schedule is for audit committee and wanted to seek your feedback in advance so we're prepared for that so the thought process here is you'll see a little bit of an adjustment compared to what we have always done our historical approach is six meetings a year taking place every other month however our audit committee Charter only requires us to meet four times a year anything beyond that is at our discretion or at the audit committee and board discretion so the proposal that you see here uh actually consolidates essentially the June and August meetings so with some careful thought and consideration we find ourselves in the June time frame struggling to have all the information necessary whether it's the upcoming Year's budget or priorities uh to have that all
037set by the end of June and so by moving into a few weeks into July will be a couple weeks into the fiscal year and a little bit more solid on what our strategic IC approaches for the year and then on the other side of that rather than meeting in August again consolidating that to a July meeting often it's a first month or first couple months into our plan and typically what we say is we're working on it there isn't a lot of notable tangible things to share so that's the thought process is consolidating the June and August meetings into a single July meeting to kind of knock out the upcoming year's plan and um touch base at that time so the rest of the meetings still follow the same Cadence with being at on
038a Wednesday 4:30 to 6 towards the end of the month on an every other month cycle again aside from that what becomes no meetings in May and June and no meetings in August and September so happy to answer any questions or further explain I have a question um do you think that the I presume because you came up with this um suggestion do you feel like mid July is enough time for you to I'm I was just trying to look and see you know what we normally do at the July and August meetings um and I didn't know if for your purposes if you're like just starting the fiscal year do you have or do you need need a meeting before the end of the fiscal year to is there anything that we approve in
039terms of the plan that you need to start on July 1 yeah great question so our goal always is to complete the current fiscal years projects at by the April meeting because from our standpoint we really need to transition from that work and get into the risk assessment and planning for that upcoming year so we can be ready as close to as possible that July 1 start from a logistic standpoint or Authority standpoint I don't know that we need approval uh before ju or July 1 before the fiscal start since we have kind of our own discretion as to what our plan covers so essentially it'll just postpone or expand rather our planning and risk assessment period which we would greatly uh utilize and appreciate a couple more weeks to get that fine tuned it's
040always a Mad Dash it feels to get it by the June meeting um and it wouldn't compromise us as we move forward either I guess my yeah my only question is would it even be would it be preferable at all to skip May June July all together and keep an August meeting um just if that gives you if you're already feeling rushed maybe if that gives you more time but I also know that is typically right around when school starting so there's a lot of other things going on then too yeah that was kind of our thought processes stay in that July time frame if at all possible so if we move back a week or so that would still I think avoid um the busyness that ensu come August so I I think our
041goal would be within the second third fourth week of July would be the preference if possible and if that works better for you I completely support that yeah trying not to blabber this but just another thing to think about is that July is typically vacation time um so i' would and certainly if it happened this year and we tweak it next year but if there was the unintended consequence of half the Committees on vacation in July then maybe we we rethink it next year and if we're all kind of on the same page and the board office and board members are comfortable if it comes to it where we set this date as it approaches we see that conflict perhaps we could reschedule sometimes we'll do that with committee meeetings let's push it back a
042week or adjust the day of the week potentially yeah that's a pretty common practice for our committees as as as a norm to if we have to move it or other conflicts or something else is happening um the only thing I would like maybe raise some thought on and this is more in regards to what we use the meetings for not so much the dates and the the number of meetings is that for instance the July meeting may be something that more information is shared at than typically would have been shared at the June meeting or in the August meeting individually so like some ways we may just thinking about that of of how we allocate what get what gets shared to each of those scheduled meeting dates um just because in theory there may
043be some information or there may be more information needs to be done in April to allow for more time afterwards so just thinking about that from a planning framework that's such a good point and I think there's an opportunity to further engage the committee and board members about what goes into the risk assessment and plan so whether that's conver it's always tricky because at the April meeting we're so focused on the completion of the last year's plan that we truly haven't shifted gears yet but if there is an opportunity where of course we send out our surveys but perhaps a subgroup or a few people who maybe feel comfortable in speaking for the committee members would be willing to meet with us for a small working session in between that could give us an opportunity
044and then we could share more volume wise in the July meeting as well I I really like that thought process um the other thing that I like about that is that if we are going to eliminate a meeting then having an additional ask of ple can you come to a working session isn't so much of a big ask um and that goes not only for the risk assessment but also for some of the other things that we're going to talk about in the coming weeks months year around how the committee can help the board uh with the Strategic initiatives um uh as we go into 2025 I think too as we are reviewing the charter and our responsibilities that would be a very good time to think about what we're doing at each meeting and
045just you know kind of combine those two tasks of is this the right time of the year and is this something we need to keep doing or should we you know move it so as you are reading through that maybe also be looking at this calendar and thinking about um does all that makes sense and what would naturally shift either forwards or back um if we eliminate that sixth meeting also I think we have some Levy renewals coming up this year um and so we will be me meting on October 15th that will be the first and only meeting before we vote that you all will have access to us to have any type of planning or help in any kind of way to get the word out so it would that be a concern
046uh well we have a preview of something coming slightly later but I think we would be asking um of the committee at least the subset of the committee to be a part of the full Levy process so I think we would be updating you all prior to then along the way um Our Hope what in Theory actually we would have to have it done before we we would like to have it done before that July meeting and quite honestly we could know what we're going to ask for probably somewhere around that April meeting so that we're creating a process for the audit committee to be a part of that and be informed in that and so I think that's where um we would be asking even whether it's a subset of committee or few volunteers
047or whatever to be a part of some type of active engagement around how we message out and and full support for the levy should say the renewal of the levy and I guess as we're thinking about allowing people on the committee that don't live in the district when you have those subset committees I think that's when it really would be important that at least those people who are being selected for that has a best Ed interest in being on those type of committees as well okay any further comments or discussion all right move on to um District strategy and financial discussion may be Jen or board member Craig uh so will take the lead on this and then certainly Jen can uh add in as uh any details that I miss I think you have
048some materials and stuff that's going on I won't spend too much time on those materials um I do want to certainly call the attention to um our five-year forecast and and some of the other things that we've we've offered out but I actually want to start with the the first thing that we were going to do is just highlight some things that we think would be effective things for the committee to be supportive of the in supportive specifically um of some of the goals that we We are continuing to work through and so the first one is our wonderful treasur has decided that she no longer um can stand us uh no but that she's she's made a decision and as much as we cry about it every day um we have a search started
049it is I believe we have a um the the official uh uh form or official what is it trying to word profile profil out there that's that'll be going out if it and be shared out with the different communities we would love to have some support from some of the many members of the AUD Committee in that process and that includes at least at some level helping us interview and and talk to and uh giving us some evaluation of potential finalists for the for the position this is a very unique role in our state and or very unique role at the district because of the state of Ohio and the fun things that the state of Ohio requires and mandates on treasurers in that role and so the need for license and other things are
050important but there I think there are a lot of other skill sets that the audit committee could also be a good help in evaluating for this particular candidate so the job description is out I believe believe everyone has the job description but um we'll be certainly communicating out on a regular basis as to trying to draw interest the timetable right now is that the position will be open until about the end of Janu about the third week of January and then we would be looking to review candidates somewhere in February um the second thing and this goes into your question earlier Carol the the hope is that we would have a a subset of the committee that would be able to work with us with regards to the levy there are some important decisions that
051we're going to have to make as a board and as a district as to what are our needs of a district um and and we recognize for instance preschool promise has been substantially successful and it's wonderfully great and it's more successful than we planned so there's some thoughts we have to do around that there's some other issues with regards to how our district operates and and some of the operating needs that we may have to address through the levy and but all of that also goes into we need folks who are in the community who can kind of give us a a helpful hand or helpful knowledge as to how to both best present it and communicate it out but also provide the support uh with regard to kind of cheerleading it through some of
052those discussions or introducing opportunities for us to cheerlead it through the discussion I think this is a really important thing this year given that we're again seeing our state is not exactly you know showering us with new dollars so um we've talked about it before but we we're receiving a lower percentage share from the state than we had the previous year and that it's not likely to change anytime soon so things like these things are the the levies are really important so we would be looking to try and find either some type of subgroup or subset to to kind of work with our Levy planning folks and to really be helpful to bring some of outside voice to that conversation um and then the third one is really something uh the treasure and I talked
053about uh just about an hour ago um but is also to provide so again like another subset of a group to work with as we transition the new treasure into the role um working with the committee itself to identify or the the uh Treasures oper off the office operations to just identify areas that we can see potential opportunities to look at you know either new skill sets new ways of developing opportunities for growth um again it's really an opportunity to to put the new person in that role on the best foot as they go forward and I think it is each of you all bring unique perspectives and and and great backgrounds that may be very helpful for someone going into their role trying to assess what the needs of their team might be what
054the strengths of their team might be and you know quite honestly it's just the role of the treasure is such a uh over encompassing you know it hits so many different areas and it's very similar to what we would we think about with regards to like the superintendent's rol as well that there's so much that needs to be touched on and tapped on anyone coming to that role new uh just may be helpful to have some folks to help them help that new person transition and so those are kind of the three things that we were we discussed that we thought might be things that the audit committee could be helpful and supporting as we go forward Jen did I miss anything no covered it great you like so one idea that we've been playing
055with and I mentioned this I don't know um probably about a year ago now to Dan and Liz about um when the district went to site based management um I think they really wanted to do site based decision making and so they put transactional work out into the school buildings that they don't necessarily have the professional training to do so like the financial management transactional stuff um we we're thinking about how do we recentralize some of it so that they still have the decision-making power and choice but we maintain Financial compliance in the easier way than we're doing now so it's just something to think about kind of brainstorm about bring some people in the table to um think about doing the business differently so we appreciate um ideas we talked to the leadership team
056about it a couple weeks ago we're going to start um after the new year starts we're going to start bringing in people just to kind of think through it a bit as an idea and then to kind of Bring It full circle too through the work that we did with our school audits that was the key observation is the decentralized nature leads to I I wish I could use a better word but inconsistencies in the way things are done and so certain aspects especially regarding compliance and financials require that level of consistency and I I think uh treasure Wagner does such a good job describing siteb decision-making versus site based transactional work and I think the decision- making certainly that's the key uh but you know there could be some benefits to the centralization and
057the consistency aspect especially as we come to internal controls and process documentation so on and so forth okay well this is very exciting I think um I'm speaking for everyone else um but uh I think we are eager to help in more ways than sitting around in a room and talking and and being reported to and so I think we're um I don't think we're looking for anyone to volunteer on the spot right now for any of these initiatives but certainly if you have interest in any particular one or two or three if you're really ambitious uh you could reach out to myself or um Lauren or board member Craig and um we can start getting plugged in on on these items there just just one quick thought on that also is that I think
058this also aligns with a lot of what we heard from the aot committee when we were setting the goals this year this year round is that there was a desire to have more more of a thing that they could say we we helped do right we helped accomplish as a committee and I think this is another way of also thinking about we've revamped How We Do audits in a lot of ways because we were just recognizing that continuously doing audits of stuff that we're just GNA keep finding the same problems every year didn't make sense um so we we revamped how we think about it how we talk to folks about that that's something that kind of came out of these discussions these kind of ideas or things that you know J um Jen and
059I talked about as part of the feedback from hearing you know we need something that the aot committee can help make better and and then this also gets in a little bit to one of the things we did do this year earlier which is have the explanation to the full board at a board meeting of what the benefits of having an audit um team but also having an audit committee and the work that that's done as part of that this gets us back to those I we had a conversation a long time ago about um what are the ads the value add right like what are the things we can dis monly say this is how we added value to here some of these things are things that we if we can get better efficiency
060in processes and stuff because folks are saying look I do this and this is how it normally is done may be very helpful for us in a world where we're in the space where the folks may see it and do it in their world and only in their world and so I think that's there's a lot of value add from some of that that can be demonty expressed in a in a bigger setting okay anything else to add Jen Nope got it covered all right thank you everyone um we'll now move on to uh the audit committee uh dashboard um from Lauren and her team in May I asked the commit if everyone would like a small update on the district changes as well would uh perhaps a board member want to give that update
061if folks didn't have the opportunity to see Monday's meeting or do folks feel pretty attuned to our upcoming changes if you don't mind me asking I would love to hear that and I'd love to hear from Mr Lindy my apologies I don't mean to put anyone on the spot I just I think we had in we had intended just some additional updates to keep everyone in the loop as well great I'm no no I'm I'm happy to help uh do can you just say the question one more time Lauren we just set aside a bit of time to talk about the Strategic Direction via goal to for the audit committee and then also wanted to provide a brief and Consolidated update to our members who maybe haven't had the opportunity to hear of some of
062the changes going on in the district trying to keep everyone engaged in the strategy so I know that is I don't mean to put on the spot it's just if it's the desire of the committee to get a brief update yeah we have the superintendent here too I think would be a great great person to I I listen uh 520 on a on a Wednesday I appreciate it I really do um but I don't know if if if superintendent Brandon want to share a little bit uh I mean I think superintendent probably can share a little bit more in detail but I I'll just quickly say you know we had a uh series of of votes around our phase two of the growth plan that uh was built around the idea of of adding um
063more of a middle school uh presence to some of our schools and so I guess I will certainly turn over to superintendent to kind of give a little bit more of the detail in kind of the next stages for what what will come from those votes happy to do so good afternoon everyone so what we have proposed to the board and what was accepted Monday uh includes several things there were about nine um items and then nine bundles of how we would have school based on a course model of East Central and West schools and then thinking about programming that we offer as it relates to programming we offer on the west side for example International balarat how then can we offer it on the East Side the flip of that on the east side
064we offer an early college program how can we now offer that on the west side of town and expanding some other programs that we find to be successful and being requested from parents and students for example Junior RC also an expansion in our Career and Technical education area of uh Automotive Technologies of Entrepreneurship and of Cosmetology those seem to be the ones uh over the last several years that have been asked for by young people and their parents um in addition to that uh board member Craig mentioned um the creation of middle schools and the expansion of uh junior high school so this year we opened our first Junior High School Schroeder Junior High and so many of our traditional 9 to 12 buildings next year uh seven to 12 buildings I apologize will become
0659 to 12 buildings and so we have a flow of types of buildings in each Corridor of the district starting from Early Childhood or Pre-K our three and four year olds uh all the way up to elementary school up to Middle School Junior High and then high school so it's laid out that way in each of those corridors of the district that I mentioned in addition to that some other programming that we find to be uh in need of in our school district is the ever increasing number of our multilanguage learner students and so we have proposed that we follow the model that we have for example at Robert's uh school on the west side of town with welcome centers for our families and young people with the goal of making sure our multilanguage Learners
066have the things that they need to be prepared and come to school and be successful and feel comfortable entering into our school districts so we've requested an expansion of that and been granted that expansion and then the other uh highlevel service opportunity for young people is the growing population of our children experiencing homelessness and so what we want to do is expand uh the programming that Rebecca Beach and Project Connect provides our community uh whether it is uh clothing shoes uh supplies book bags Etc uh and we want to expand and grow that by perhaps including and creating a lrat system for our young people perhaps increasing our food pantry services for our young people and there are even greater ideas and uh government entities that we are looking to partner with who have expressed
067interest like Hamilton County Job and Family Services so uh those wraparound Services we are affectionately calling the wrap um in our in our school district for next school year so I think that's high level and very Broad in terms of what's been approved like no I mean I think I the uh I appreciate the superintendent summary I think everything is very accurate I think those are all very good things to do and is to support particularly the kids experiencing homelessness the growing elll population um and I uh I I I want us to look to the future with where we're going next I think the concerns I had were about um it would it would disrupt about up to 15,000 kids in terms of which schools they attend and that's more than two out of
068five kids in the district uh I also wasn't convinced that we had a plan to pay for it um and it it depending on what got approved or didn't get approved or how many kids go to the new school there assigned to um it could moderate it would I think most likely increase our expenses over the next couple of years um and for A disruption of that scale I thought we needed a really strong rationale um uh and I that was concerned that our rationale for the plan kept changing yep thank you for asking any other questions or comments for uh the board members or superintendent thank you now we'll turn it over to the chief thank you all very much so we'll start with some celebrations uh I'll have uh Mr Wilson if you
069don't mind jumping into the dashboard while we do this but a really big celebration for our team Isaac Kar CPA his completed CPA exam and then uh Miss Emma Mueller has an update for the committee as well around a couple other exciting uh celebrations yeah so um I'll kind of start with the dashboard first and then get into mine uh the items to review as always are linked within the email that you guys are sent so you're able to see the financial updates from the past few meetings those are linked there if you have some extra free time and are super duper interested um the other documents that you have in front of you are linked there as well if you feel like having a digital copy um the upcoming dates are there for you
070so I think we've landed on the 226 February audit committee meeting we'll update that once we have um final approval and then for our district and external audits I'm working with Kevin to update for BL plattenburg um and then I also have been sending out a weekly blurb in the newsletter that goes to everyone in central office so kind of getting what is an external audit what counts is one and how you should contact us um the other big news is over the past few months we've worked on hiring an intern so we've met a lot of really good candidates ultimately we decided on extending an offer to a student at UC um we're very excited for him to start in January to help us with our continuous auditing so super fun stuff for him
071um and he will be extending into summer a bit because I will be going on maternity leave in early May so I will not be here and then I will pass it on to Lauren for some other items yes it's B it's a big year so uh then and then I'll get married in August so we've got a big year ahead of us as a team so we're just adding letters and changing names and all sorts of things over here so I was hoping you wouldn't put two and two together no but from what works stand Point that's most important so so uh feedback I think we've gotten around our dashboard is we don't necessarily need to talk you through it every time however we have notes we can talk about any of the projects
072we just want to be respectful of everyone's time because the goal is that it's interactive you can play around you've got it in front of you and then we can dig into anything of Interest I will say big picture things are going according to plan we are on target for the windows that we projected to execute the work as well as when we plan to report on the work you will see that the majority of our projects as what typically happens each year will come through to be presented to the audit Committee in the February and April meetings that's our goal as I mentioned before to have all of the projects from the fiscal 25 plan reported on by April so of course we can start that transition and risk assessment and planning for fiscal
07326 come May um so I think I had another quick note yep so the the two reports that'll be shared with you in February are the records retention Assurance project as well as the business plus uh kind of an IT audit as well so those are the two that we are anticipating and sharing at the February meeting uh of course you can find at the very end of the dashboard the status pass recommendation um Isaac is continuing to lead that work and is prepared to answer any questions you may have as well as strong partnership and appreciation to our management teams who take the time and effort to provide those updates to us so I'll pause there and happy to answer expand uh on anything mentioned on the history of recommendations um we have five
074in the past do category um I think we've if I'm not mistaken we've changed how we've put the due dates on those so that not everything is past to it's the ones that have established a due date and then have gone past that due date um can you give any additional commentary if there's any action that we need to take as a committee to get the board to look at these closely yeah so I'll just provide a quick reminder the um the P du items um directly relate to recommendations that um management set would be done by a certain date and now the date has passed that and it's still not compl complete so I believe the recommendations were due to the internal audit team right at the end of November and so there were
075a few five items or five recommendations that had November one or um sometime in November uh dates that they had anticipated on completing them and each of the areas kind of encountered their their own setbacks and kind of put that date back now and so those are the ones that now are reflected as past due um I will say all of them for the most part are reporting as like 90% there and so they do anticipate those being complete come February when we meet again okay thank you I I think since I was looking at that too what's concerning is the Departments that are passed to or are typically the Departments that have issues like our benefits department has had issues and has not we've not seen a lot of movement with those issues and
076and then the peard is one that I would I would be concerned about at this point in time that they remain has to and those are some areas that have been areas of question over the period last several years and so for benefits not to have completed on time to me is unacceptable and so is there a way we can get them in to give us an update yeah we can certainly or coordinate um a time for them to come in an update when we initially were rolling out this P du plan um a lot of other um research that we were doing um mandated it so if it goes past due management is required to come in and kind of explain why we didn't want to push that on management this first time okay
077kind of introducing it however uh benefits did roll out um or go through open enrollment with the district in November and I think our team when we first saw the estimated dates that management was providing we were a bit we didn't want to kind of overstep and say whoa this is really ambitious of you all um because we kind of have been working with you know management and so we let them use those dates and they're kind of sticking to them um I will say from benefits uh the benefit Focus vendor and platform that they're kind of transitioning to is going Live January one so at the beginning of the calendar year and so they are hoping that that will um address some of those setbacks as well as uh the PE card work they
078also are transitioning to a business plus module that is going to house all of the um tcard statements the card statements and all of the supporting documents and so um I think that one specifically is going to kind of group a lot of the recommendations for that area okay yeah Isa think's done such a great job following up on this and the management teams have been incredibly responsive and I think our thought process is we we're in uh status of pass Rex project version two version three and maybe you know 2B I might even say sooner rather than later is what is the escalation so the escalation that was taken this time is really just to work with the folks who are giving those updates we're all learning how to do this and we're just
079really appreciative that people are keeping us informed so Isaac went ahead and did a gut check that seems reasonable we understand where we are where we are and I don't think there's a cause for an alarm however we may consider in working with management some escalation procedures to say okay after you're 30 16 90 days perhaps we need to have some further discussion so we're trying to start um a little bit softer if you will just because we're all new however um as we all get more comfortable with this process get more comfort about setting dates and what's reasonable it's it's a tricky thing to foresee sometimes as reality always is a little different than what we plan and anticipate so I would say Management's participation and focus on this is no cause of concern
080from our standpoint because it is taken very seriously so and I shouldn't just speak we of course have our treasure assistant treasure and superintendent in the room as well but um from an audit standpoint objective standpoint we are very pleased with how this is going so Lauren do you mind if I make a comment please so um one of the things that we put into practice because it's so easy to lose the recommendations in the busyness of what happens every day um we added two things one is we have a monthly review where it against the recommendations and every every body reports out their progress and then we actually had them write into their goals that they're evaluated on some of those recommendations so make it a higher priority for individual employees to work together
081um so we're actually seeing a lot more progress as well and Mike has been leading this and uh doing a great job I love that thank you and I might say her role needs to shrink for whoever is going to take her are you're not going to keep them I just wanted to followup question on that you see one of the there's two benefit audits that are on there the benefits and then followup and you said the institution of the new system going live on on gen one will correct most of what you perceive as the risk that's outstanding or correct the issues is that on both projects or on one of the projects because I would be concerned that if those ones from 2020 aren't corrected sooner rather than later I mean you're now
082going to be five years out that that's that would be well we may be having people work together five years to correct an issue um I I I would think most would say that that that's not acceptable in in most Industries yeah I'll start and and ISAC I think been involved in the OR ganization so I he may able to speak how we categorize them but I do believe this solution is uh targeted at all of the benefits recommendations and when we did the follow-up it was kind of a reup of everything if you will so um the one that might be correlated with 2020 could have been initially is I believe was initially issued then but really reissued Revisited and now this new solution addresses it at the same time is that correct Isaac
083they kind they've kind of now all we refer to it as 2020 but really realistically this solution is targeting the whole batch of them if that makes sense so Management's uh belief and take on this is that this new system will be targeted at the risk that were identified the findings that we had um and it should improve that and our goal is then to work with the team once implemented to do some testing to verify that and then it new systems introduce new risk so have you been sitting alongside determining what those new risks may be so that we have get ahead of those risks and putting some processes in place to make sure that you know there's no exposure so we were not invited to those conversations but we did request the sock
084report and I did receive that so part of um the meetings we initially had in the summer was reviewing that granted we have an old socker report so I don't know what the new socker report would look like or what those risks would be with CPS um but I know they were also working with itm and financial technology so I'm assuming some of those discussions were with them as well any other questions or comments for Lauren and her team I just have a small comment mment on the dashboard um the items for review I really really really appreciated the um board meeting um links being like timestamped to the relevant discussion because those meetings are very long and it's hard to find stuff in them um and I would love to see like even more
085of those um if there's anything that feels relevant even if it's not maybe Finance or you know audit specific if there are some like General board discussions that you think might be helpful it would be so so helpful to have a few more of those I would be happy to to watch more of those um with those time stamps I love that all right um hearing no other comments we'll move on to uh Lauren's midar evaluation yes thank you so along the same approach um I requested and hope you had the opportunity to review the memo that I drafted uh for those who maybe have not seen the memo and for the Public's uh context I provide a memo and um prompt for the audit committee twice a year for my mid-year evaluation which takes
086place now in December as well as for my annual review which we typically execute at the April meeting the memo itself provides background and context regarding the evaluation process citing the board policy in internal audit Charter that allocates the responsibility to the audit committee for my evaluation and um gives them the authority to do so you'll also find the background and um context so to speak for how the evaluation process works I am evaluated in the same manner as our cast our administrative Union we utilize their structure and the definitions for each of the terms as well as uh the ratings are all explained in detail uh and of course finally at the end I note my initial goals as well as some uh tangible tasks and actions I've taken to uh lead towards the
087progress and the rating that I have provided my self evaluation so the final page page seven of eight is the audit committee chair evaluation form and the requests for today is that you provide your feedback to chair Hol house via the executive session he will complete this form and submit it to Travis rally part of our HR Talent team uh by December 20th and that will complete the process and I uh also appreciate the time that you all take to to provide this feedback we really do our best to put it into action it gives us new fresh ideas um and helps make sure that we're progressing as expected and hopefully Beyond um and I happy to answer any questions or expand if you would like okay thank you Lauren um so the intent here
088is to recess into executive session we'll we'll go through the rules of that here in a moment but then we'll we'll exit executive session um and not come back to the public meeting so um I first need a motion to enter executive session to discuss the employment of a Public Employee or official so and I need a second second and then we need to do roll Co vote Dean h house yes Liz gutridge yes David foot yes Kevin Hoffman yes Paul kit Miller yes Carol Mitchell Lawrence yes Brandon Craig yes Ben Lindy yes thank you correct