CorpusRecord 65359

CPS Board Business Meeting December 9, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CPS Public Affairs
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Hamilton County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
47,014 words · about 262 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e me too seeing a quorum of voting members I call the December 9th Cincinnati school board meeting to order superintendent Murphy will you please introduce our virtual pledge I am so happy to introduce the young people of Woodford Academy where Caitlyn Donner serves as their principal please rise I pledge allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag to the flag of the United States of America of the United States of America and to the Republic and to the Republic for which it stands for which it stands one nation one nation under God under God indivisible indivisible with liberty with liberty and justice and justice for all for all treasur Wagner would you please call the rule Mr Craig here Mr Crossett here Mr Lindy here miss map here here Dr Moffett here vice president

002Weinberg here president Bolton pres thank you very much vice president Weinberg would you please explain uh to the audience and the hearing public uh the process that we're using to have the community join in yes members of the public who are online and wish to speak during our hearing of the public this evening may do so by clicking the chat button now the chat feature will be open for your request for 5 minutes if you would like a direct response to your questions please make sure to share your name affiliation to the district your school Community topic and also your contact information thank you vice president Weinberg um the chair will now entertain a motion and a second to approve the December 9th business uh meeting agenda do I have a motion so moved thank

003you do I have a second second second thank you treasure Wagner would you call the voting rle Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes vice president weberg yes president Bolton yes the business meeting agenda is approved as posted thank you very much uh we'll begin tonight with old business uh and the old business this evening uh is the discussion of our search for a treasure and we've asked Finance chair uh Mr Craig to update us Mr Craig so uh just it's a quick update we have completed what will be a um basically application uh pamphlet or flyer that will go out to um enti to drive in our recruitment efforts and so that should be posted by the end of this week um and then the hope

004is that we will be able to get uh number of candidates by somewhere mid to late J January for us to then be able to evaluate um we do ask all of those folks who have anyone in their professional circles um who have experience as a in finance or as a Treasurer or Chief Financial Officer to uh share within your networks and certainly please uh consider applying for the position again this is a really important role within our State and our state sets really specific guidelines but we are working hard to make sure that we can get someone early enough so that we can transition them into the role as our treasur who we have valued and uh will really be sad to see leave elects to choose retirement over continuing to drive so many

005miles to to the district each week um so again it's it's a great opportunity for someone who has a finance background and meets the criteria and should look for everyone should look for the position posted um by the end of this week thank you Mr Craig uh any particular update regarding Community um participation so part of what we're going to look at and this is really dependent upon the applications that we get but part of the role will include having some feedback from Key stakeholders so that includes feedback from um several of our key uh Union stakeholders several of our uh administrative stakeholders as well as others who um will certainly schedule time for throughout the process again we're hoping to have a robust group of folks who apply so we can have a multi-stage

006process to truly do an evaluation and determine who's the best uh person to take on such an important role thank you do members have any questions of Mr Craig or Mr Crossett who've been leading this uh effort great seeing none I appreciate the update uh do board members uh have any acknowledgements or announcements before we perhaps go to Kudos uh member Moffett do you have uh an opportunity to uh share with us what you might be willing to share regarding legislative efforts sure I didn't know if we were doing that right here I'm sorry to looks so confused so I do um I've been talking about this for quite some time regarding SB 295 and this afternoon some of my school board School family have updated us they've been really really um active with regard

007to keeping us AR breast there is a hearing tomorrow for C Bill 295 which will have a direct impact on Cincinnati public schools um the proposal it's in committee at the moment and Senator Ingram has been able to give us um some updates it has a hearing it had a hearing last Tuesday there is a hearing tomorrow and um some of the direct impact that bill what theyve what they what they typically do is they put lot of things in that impact you but it's not very clear so if you've been paying attention it used to have like one or two sentences and now it's 106 pages that talks about graduation requirements it doesn't talk about building utilization per se but it talks about conditions of which a building can close and it talks about

008potentially um needs to be the lower performing 10% bottom five 5% performance index bottom 10% for ress and in the event they have done a simulation in Senator Ingram's office and in the event that this passes two of our buildings qualify as written and they're on the screen now we have a plan our Administration has been working on a plan but this is just how things can progress very quickly we need to pay attention so write the committee you can write letters you can go online you can submit well testimony has to be submitted 24 hours beforehand but you can definitely email your um Senator Ingram you can email Senator brener and you can stay included because she is anticipating that this will pass through committee by the end of this uh month and then

009be effective for July 1st so this is just an effort that we are being hit by multiple directions this is Inc Senate Bill 295 is just one bill of many that they are working on very actively that impact our district that talk about trans there's a there's a bill and I don't know that number but there is a bill that talks about Transportation the impact impacting Transportation there is there are other bills that talk about graduation rates for our students uh this particular Bill if you choose to read the 106 Pages talks about uh college credit plus versus AP and how that would impact um students as well and they're really really tricky because they don't come out and say that they're targeting the big districts but they talk about districts with multiple high schools

010well Princeton doesn't have multiple high schools but Cincinnati does so does Cleveland so does Columbus so they're targeted towards large districts the point is there is movement at the state level that we need all hands on deck to be able to to fight against and if it's not if we can't fight against it we definitely have to stay aware and need the community support so I'm happy to talk more but I wanted to provide this update this came in at around 2:30 this afternoon and this is just a simulation a simulation of how Senate Bill 295 would impact CPS and the other districts on there as well thank you uh Dr Mett do anybody any uh members have any questions or comments for Dr Mett regard regarding that uh I will only add that I

011know for the last few years the forom uh Foundation has been really focusing on low enrollment and uh low achievement and so it's it's kind of within it's been percolating within those folks that do have U some serious concerns about uh public education and how we're doing or not doing so I appreciate you taking the lead and watching through this I also have had other people tell us that may not pass this year uh and also that it will be worked into the budget language uh as uh having some sort of control as to how much money we would be getting and and the kinds of criteria so we'll keep uh the community of breast and hope that the community will keep us uh informed as well uh superintendent Murphy do you have uh any

012uh announcements or retirements first I have two oh no she didn't have a question oh I'm sorry s yes thank you I just wanted to comment about C Bill 295 so I appreciate you both for um speaking about this issue um and actually highlighting the fact that it does not speak to underutilization because that was the narrative that was being communicated before and so I'm so glad that you just took the time to call that out and also there is language in what was proposed and again is still in committee discussion but there's also criteria defining what a poor performing school is as well as there's criteria such as close at the end of the school year in which they received the third strike replace their principal and 60% of their license staff consolidate the

013entire district with another District in the event it is a district that has triggered closure criteria or engaged with du to approve the education management organization but this is also talking about for three consecutive years so this is not something that is communicating immediate urgency as has been previously discussed so I want you all to be informed so if we're talking about looking at the information I want us to make sure that we are knowledgeable about how we are interpreting the legislation or the proposed legislation and how people are conveying that to us as well thank so I just want to clarify CU you are so right to my colleague she's definitely outlined what SB 295 States but let me be very clear SB 295 is talking about repealing Ohio the current Ohio Revised Code

0143314 D3 or 35 which is in existence right now so currently the loss talks about the building utilization that is an effect so until this passes or doesn't pass we are bound by the current Ohio Revised Code which is 331 14.35 which talks about building utilization so I want to be very very clear I'm talking about future legislation that is pending but we are bound by current legislation which speaks directly to building utilization it doesn't talk about those other things it is in effect now and that's what we have to live by this could never C Bill 295 could never pass and we are still Bound by Ohio revised code 331 14.35 so it's not a scare tactic I promise you I am not trying to scare anyone I am just trying to make everyone

015aware that we are bound by Ohio Revised Code and there is an attack against our district and other the other 610 districts in Ohio and public education they are coming at us in a multitude of ways and they're it's going to impact us but right now we are bound by the current legislation which talks about building utilization and if buildings sit closed for one year then they are forced to be closed and they are forced to be sold first to Charter Schools it's not a debate I promise you I'm not trying to misspeak I just want us to all stay informed and aware that's it another comment yes I would like to um also address that as you're speaking about the Ohio Revised Code so as it particularly states it is addressing uh building uh

016buildings that have already been closed which we don't have any buildings that are closed and we're talking about the section B for building utilization it is stating uh a 60% um utilization rate however I just specifically ask general counsel Daniel hoen to Define that and he also expressed that there's not specific language around what utilization looks like or what utilization truly entails so again I want to stress that when we're talking about interpreting these laws be mindful and be very intentional about what information is being communicated and I encourage you all just as I've done myself to do your research because you all are the ones that are able to push this work forward and again as I always say please hold us accountable to do that thank you and I hope that we can

017now move on appreciate both uh members sharing the information that they have and uh anxious to uh get back onto the agenda and vice president yes I just have two quick things I just wanted to kind of point out the sign below I mean behind me here just acknowledging crossing guards there's a call to action so if you know of anyone who's interested in becoming a crossing guard there's a phone number it tells you how much and there's also a QR to uh code to scan um I also wanted to go to the next slide which is already up I wanted to give a huge Kudos and shout out to the T football team yes wanted to give them a shout out for making history to be the first CPS program since 1992 to advance

018to the state semis in the ohsaa playoff so let's give them another huge round of applause so if you go back to that slide Mr Wilson sorry about that I just wanted to also thank um the board members who were able to attend we had a send off uh party for them and it was an great opportunity to just give some inspiring words to the whole entire team and wish them luck so I do want to acknowledge that they had a good season although they weren't able to win the game it was very very close so let's just give them one last round of applause thank you Mr Craig uh just a quick announcement um and I wanted to it's my kind of regular announcement I'm going do for till we get to January but

019um many of our schools participated last year in the first year of the the the Cincy ethics High School Bowl High School ethics Bowl um we had a CPS School came out as the Victor and so we want to return CPS to being the Victor again but we need volunteers so if you know anyone who is interested I know we have a lot of Educators in the room today and if you are interested in volunteering your services they really could use you it's we now have the largest High School ethics Regional in the country with more than 40 teams expected to be competing it's over a two-day uh process here so we need volunteers for both days um you can go to ciny ethics. org High School ethics Bowl um we can share out the

020link and I'm certainly sure we can we can post it out there for folks but it really is just a great opportunity if you scroll all the way down you can see where the volunteer in the link there um and you get to hear some of our students talking about really complicated issues in a really intelligent way that's really inspiring and they they do it in a way that I didn't even expect to be uh some of my opinions get changed by way our students think and the way our students are able to talk about these issues and again this went from being five schools participating in the first year to around 177 schools participating last year to now over 26 schools participating this year so it's a really great accomplishment and I'm really proud

021of our students and some of our schools having more than one team even competing in the competition so sitting out there we need volunteers thank you Mr Craig and again as I always say thank you for your leadership on hiding you know highlighting this and uh it's very beneficial to all of the young people and to the grown-ups that get to participate as well uh any other board members have any uh announcements or Kudos that they would like to share if not now I go to the superintendent and ask if you have any announcements or retirements no retirements today uh but I am delighted to highlight a few of our schools starting with Mount Ary Mount Ary has uh won a $100,000 Dicks Sporting Goods Foundation game on rant and the dollars are going to

022go towards their tennis courts their baseball fields and other adjacent areas and the other beautiful thing one of our strong Partners Cincinnati Recreation Commission is joining forces with them to match uh that Grant so the total project budget $250,000 then second we have done aot a lot of conversation around artificial intelligence and we have several schools that have started an artificial intelligence Club including College Hill fundamental Academy North Avendale mosur and we're adding this week Bond Hill Academy and then the last uh we will share with you back in October late October H High Park School was recognized as the newest 2024 Blue Ribbon School of Excellence in the nation uh the meeting required Criterion all nine performance areas of high performing schools congratulations to hiy park [Applause] school thank you those are great announcements

023appreciate it and I do encourage people to check out our our campuses I know Mount Ary campus is quite extensive and like many of our schools is adjacent to adjacent to our our school campus our schoolyard if you will our Recreation uh facilities and C the center is not there but the playing fields are there the tennis courts are in need this is this is very good coordinating uh between those two entities uh Madame vice president uh the chair is yours if you'll please conduct the hearing of the public yes thank you we are now at the item on our agenda for hearing of the public each speaker will have 2 minutes to speak and we'll address all comments to the presiding officer if you are online once a request to speak has been granted

024you will be invited to enter you should click on the camera icon to go interactive provide your name affiliation to the district your school Community topic and also your contact information if you would like a response to any questions that you might have please know that this is a request please know that this request excuse me is consider system with board protocol and we appreciate your help in the unusual event that someone is not willing to follow this protocol we reserve the right to end that person's time again each person will have 2 minutes to speak when the timer goes off your time is up please refrain from discussing any Personnel items after speaking if you're online you briefly see the welcome screen again as you transition back to the live stream meeting finally we

025ask that your public commentary be respectful of all listeners and I think we are going to first start with our in-person guest today and then we are going to go to our online guest so when I call your name if you can please go ahead and start walking down we have plenty of seats I think I'm going to try to call at least 10 names per section so up first we will have Shirley molum and if I do say your name incorrectly please do not hold it against me I do apologize already um if we could have Emily son come down Sessa C please come down Elizabeth I cannot see the last name but it's reg regarding ryen star on Vine if you could please come down Andrea Cruz please come down Maggie Nelson please

026come down adoria maxberry please come down Daniel Woodford please come down k Karen Kelly Zoe Harvey Ashley Davis and then Jeff Mason so if you could just come on down all the way down to the end in the order that I called your name and then you can come up to the mic once we get started but the first person will be uh Shirley molum and she's in the back back there and we'll just wait until everyone at least has a seat so we'll be able to hear her and I think everyone is down in the first round very good all right we are ready oh the mic's not on we're going to get you connected here all right my name is Charlie McCollum and I am a Affiliated I guess with just the public

027school district I don't have anybody in public school but I'm interested in what happens with the children and uh the last time I was here it was pretty much about the same thing a rush to go into something that would affect the children um tremendously you know and I'm concerned about um having to move our kids because I have I don't have internet or anything like that I I got a phone but I don't know how to use it so but I do hear the um public TV we don't get a lot of news on Public TV they skirt around and do a lot of feel-good things and when we hear something about the school board it's too late it's it's time for us to come down for a meeting so I don't get a

028lot of information and like I said I don't even want to be on uh social Med media but I'm concerned about um some of the schools that remind me of things that happened in the past uh like that Dome school now what I was hearing is that Dome school is not an accredited school but it's still going around uh with the kids in them and I'm wondering if it's not accredited why is it being able to keep the kids because those kids don't seem to be getting a lot of education and that's what makes them when they get out of school they are full of energy and sometimes it's bad energy and um because they're not being challenged somehow and I'm thinking that every child is being educated equally and that doesn't seem to be

029what's going on you know so that D name reminds me of what happened to Native Americans uh what some hundreds of years ago or whatever so thank you Miss L next up we'll start hopefully you're in order and just can come to the mic and go on down the line good evening my name is Emily Hutcherson and I'm a preschool teacher at Rising Stars Vine Academy um and so we have lots of questions but first and foremost we're so happy that we get the chance to talk to you guys and have these discussions um being a preschool only building there are 14 preschool classrooms and lots of tiny toilets and moving us out of our building would mean I would assume that we' be a cost to wherever we move to as far as just

030putting in tiny toilets not to mention all the other things that are required of preschool um whether it be a gross motor area for us that's different from the rest of the buildings um or wherever we may be put um in addition we've built such an awesome community over the next the last uh nine years we've got security we've got cafeteria workers we have um Social Work Psy uh School SES that have become such a great community and we don't know what will happen to those and so I think we have a lot of unanswered questions and we are hoping to work in collaboration to figure out where they go we know that the rap is an awesome successful group and being in the housed in the same building has been wonderful to be there

031but we want to make sure that it goes forward in the best way possible for both of us um because we have so many options and there by the way there are four disability classrooms simply preschool disability classrooms in our building having that ability to collaborate with them and create a partnership between school a the the Jed and the preschool disc gives them a chance to be around their peers and figure out what what is the correct choices what are not the correct choices and also it also creates um great uh Pathways for going to Jed or away from Jed depending on what they need um we we worry that this transition to a different building or perhaps including the wrap in our building will will stifle their ability to to grow and uh be

032academic superheroes thank you thank you so much our next [Applause] speaker and if you want after you are done speaking you can go back or you can wait towards the um hi my name is Janessa I am a school occupational therapist at rising stars at Vine um and I kind of wanted to piggyback off of what Emily was saying about our school being built for preschool it makes it so much more functional and something to consider too is we have over 50 students on IEPs because of those four disability classrooms and so with them having so many gened peers it is easy for them to do things socially with them we do groups we collaborate with them um and it also means that we have a lot of special providers ERS like we do have

033school psych a social worker myself we have a few speech therapists that come in and that's just something to consider when you are thinking about either adding school age or adding us to school age um that can take a lot of uh resources away from them um we have access to a gym that's built for us with gross motor skills um and they can we have different classes in there at the same time that can go away um and we also have a really good team of preschool disability we are all together in a hallway we're able to collaborate and make the most out of their learning in that short time that they are there because our preschool disability classrooms are only there for half a day um so that also factors in um and

034we also have an IAT team that we're able to collaborate with and because we're all preschool we're able to really focus on their needs as preschoolers and we're really focused on those developmental standards at such a young and vulnerable age thank you so much thank you next speaker just going to go straight down the line hi I'm Elizabeth zilberberg I'm the one you couldn't uh read my name thank you um and what's the last name zilberberg zilberg um I'm here as a parent of a student that attends rising stars and I just wanted to say that the school is a model for for how children should attend preschool um we were adopted into the family uh just a year ago and my son will be graduating and going on to any school of his choice

035because of the education that this school provided um the community the celebrations the parties um all of the things that built a community for these little teeny bodies that are still in many ways growing um I worried that combining this school into a larger school would disrupt that Community um so many members including um even the the security that that walks my child to school every day um are so important to the community and development of all these children um I worry that if they're combined into a larger environment what how that would feel for small people to go into that big space this creates such a small space of love and Community um um that I want for many other generations of children um to have the way that we've been able to enjoy

036it thank you so much hello everybody adoria maxf licensed art teacher at wford academy former wford graduate mother of two CPS excuse me three CPS students I've got a Kindergarten now and one Woodford graduate another that attended Woodford I'm here because we were told by our board president that you weren't convinced that the community supported Woodford and it wasn't the 1,4 or 1,421 signatures from the first time that Woodford was mentioned that convinced you it wasn't the community board presidents that came it wasn't our many community members that came it wasn't the host of teachers students and staff that came so I don't know what it truly takes to convince you that Woodford wants to keep the Legacy and the gym live that is in the Kennedy Heights Community but I don't know what it

037takes Beyond prayer and right now I want to let you know that we care we are here we have stated in so many way shapes and forms data numbers we have invited you into our buildings I'm not seeing you yet but we have invited many of you into our buildings and we have passionately stated why Woodford is a gym you have seen the magic that is in that building we have been designated as a 2020 Vision arts and culture Focus school when I was the LS DMC chair way back when and I cannot tell you how amazing it is without you not just seeing the magic that comes from that building we've had students that graduated claim what they've done with their Woodford graduation and their their illustrious careers after that I implore you to

038think about this from a PR standpoint this is a nightmare not just for Woodford but for so many of the schools that I've taught at and it optically does not look good I'm coming to you employing that you really engage the community really talk to those that don't have the capacity to get online Facebook that's what we need to see that's what our community needs and I have you all I need to see that vote be put in good faith thank you so much appreciate you our next speaker hello I'm Ashley Davis the resource coordinator over at wford acad as the resource cor at wford I stand before you with a heartfelt urge and plead to save our school closing wford converting into a middle school a decision that devastate will devastate our students families

039and entire Community meanwhile alternative options and wealthier neighborhoods remain untouched wford is more than just a school it's a Lifeline we proudly serve the largest deaf and Harden hearing population and thriving autism programs closing our doors would displace these students uprooting them from specialized support environment that they need to thrive these are children who really rely on stability resources unique community that the unique Community Ware provides these are not just numbers on Express sheet these are children whose Futures depend on the unique community that Woodford provides the night the fight is not only ours as someone who attends 80% of Kennedy Heights Community Council meetings I firsthand seen the strength and unity of the neighborhood our community stands firmly behind Woodford we have unwavering support of Partners like bin Community happens in God hands daycare

040prown Kennedy Heights Art Center the Caring Place Kennedy height Church of Christ All Saints Church Good Fellas CRC and many others these Partnerships are proof that Woodford is not just a building it's a legacy woven deeply into the fabric of this community this decision is about more than just the cost of convenience it's about the equity The Compassion the Justice it's about preserving at home for student who needs it most I urge you to stand with us to fight for fairness and choose to keep wford alive together we can ensure this vital institution continues to be the beacon and hope and community of Our Generations to come this is not about saving a school it's about saving lives preserving Legacy protecting the community this is about Equity over convenience this CH this let's choose compassion

041over cost let's keep whoer alive thank you our next speaker good evening board me good evening members of the Schoolboard facility and community members my name is Carmen I am a freshman at Clark Monas I stand before you to speak against the proposal to remove the Junior High from our Clark Monas building building the monor approach is built on fostering Independence responsibility and a strong sense of community all of which are enhanced by the way it is now and the way it has been for 30 years Clark has some very unique teaching teachers and Concepts that are taught within Clark such as our steel band class steel band is offered to both Junior High and high school our band teacher is widely known and loved throughout the school as well as our gym teacher it

042is almost like a write of Passage to have a class with Mr Ames as well as our wonderful teachers as as well as our wonderful art teachers who everyone loves the one one of the things Clark is most known for is its Grand trip to andreos it is a tradition that high schoolers come down to speak to the junior high about Andress and get them excited for their trip then again at the end of the year to get them excited for high school and give them advice for high school being within an environment with high with a high school and its atmosphere for me made the anxiety of high school less intense being in the same building with Junior High has allowed me to keep in touch with my old teachers from Junior High whom

043I love dearly being in the same building as Junior as my junior high friends allowed me to introduce my younger friends to their future High School teachers I urged the board to consider the long-term impact of this decision such as Clark's at uh accreditation with AMS let's not take away a model that focus on focuses uh n I'll take away a model that Fosters connection Independence and Community I ask you to reconsider and keep Junior High where it belongs in the heart of Clark Monas thank you thank you our next speaker hello my name is Maggie Nelson and I'm a preschool teacher at Rising Stars Academy on Vine I'm here to urge you to keep our building a preschool to be clear I wholeheartedly believe in the idea of the rap and providing as many

044resources possible to our families in fact it is my understanding that in the early days of preschool promise Cheryl Broadneck and others envisioned Vine Street to serve families as a preschool building with wraparound Community Resources for families by essentially closing our school we are effectively quitting on this amazing possibility I believe this is a major disservice to taxpayers stakeholders our children their families and our entire Community the only details we have been made aware of is that one all our current students would have a seat at TA Elementary and two that there are not enough classrooms for all of our teachers Vine has 14 preschool classrooms four our preschool disability rooms the vague propos propal has called so much stress within our community but it's also United us in our community survey 91% said that

045this would not be a positive change it was brought to my attention actually during this meeting that the most updated slides now proposed tap moving Divine creating a prek to6 building but the idea of taking away our special child focused building Remains the Same what will happen to Mr Macker security guard Miss Dyer Miss Angela and Food Service who know every child by name and if it's chili day they know who likes chili spaghetti and just or who just likes spaghetti Mr ranell Mr melus Rogers the custodians and building Engineers Miss ebony Dr Hill Miss Annie our whole interdisciplinary team and our principal Miss battle we need more engagement around this part of phase two especially considering there appears to be major change that has never been communicated to us we are supposed to be

046leaders of Early Child education and expand prek please work with us and help pre help prek continue to thrive on Vine thank you thank you our next speaker hi I'm Andrea Cruz and I'm a teacher at Rising Stars Vine as well um my colleagues have shared some really wonderful information so I'm going to uh talk about some other stuff um according to the CPS website your Equity policy or our Equity policy commits the Schoolboard to ensuring that the principles of fairness equity and inclusion are are fully integrated into the policies programs operations and practices guiding the 34,000 student Public School District the largest in Southwest Ohio it also obligates the district to eliminate any policies structures and practices that perpetuate inequities and contribute to disproportionately of access and outcomes in addition the policy calls for

047equitable distribution of financial capital and Human Resources through CPS is annual budget allocation process moving Vine to Taft would go against your own policy um you Pro I think you all received an lsdmc slideshow where I went through all of the numbers and I looked at the projected seats for this year the actual filled seats and then the projected seats for next year for each Corridor what you would be doing is making Central Corridor have less preschool seats than it does now by 38 seats and significantly less than what we were projected while also adding 140 preschool seats to the Eastern Corridor which doesn't seem very Equitable to me especially when you look at um the different income and things like that I'd also like um to point out that there are lots of small

048details and Logistics that go into preschool it's not just adding a classroom and here's recess and here's lunch you have to have a certain number hours between breakfast and lunch and lunch and snacks you have to have a nap time you have to have a certain amount of time that they can get gross motor you have to have the space to do those things please so much can I have the next speaker please my name is Daniel Whitford I'm the school psychologist out at Woodford Academy I understand that the district is in a difficult position due to legislative constraints no one wants to be be upending students academic paths and I know that there need to be shifts in the district um my concern is that this proposal is not evolved enough in response to

049the overwhelming concerns from parents teachers staff I've heard a range of complaints but also Solutions put forward that I feel are not reflected in the uh second version of The Proposal first I want to speak to the the community that the staff students and parents have created at Woodford Beyond other schools that I've been a part of the integration of the deaf and hearing impaired program into the fabric of the school is truly amazing typically hearing students and the hearing impaired peers mix seamlessly at Woodford everyone learns the sign of the week we have Stellar ASL interpreters they're Norm normalized unobtrusive in classrooms teachers wear microphones students who have felt self-conscious about their hearing aid technology have reported feeling much more comfortable at Woodford this same sort of normalization is also effective in important for

050students attending Woodford in any of our autism units students who were not counted towards woodford's utilization numbers by the way it's not only best practice for disabled students to be integrated with their peers but it's actively damaging to reduce that inclusion it feels like instead of highlighting emphasizing and encouraging the exceptional programs at Woodford the board has instead failed to incorporate parent and staff feedback into new versions of The Proposal wood Woodford could be a school that is public ized as much as our monor schools instead this proposal includes plans that will explicitly or not essentially disband Woodford you all have done a good job offering opportunities for us to speak but it feels as though you haven't taken that speech into account you have not responded to the advocacy of our teachers parents and

051students and contributed to a legitimacy crisis for our institution our next speaker please so tall okay hi I'm Zoe Harvey teacher of the de at Woodford Academy I've been up here so many times you guys know my beautiful face by now I have two things I want to talk about number one obviously I want to continue to advocate for Woodford stain as Woodford and our DEA and heart of hearing Community preferably staying there but if not there at least together um I've said before if our de and heart of hearing Community is dispersed throughout the district I personally will recommend that multiple kids of mine leave the district um they will flounder anywhere else um yeah secondly I actually wanted to directly address president Bolton back in November you had made this kind of sanded

052comment about how monor schools that it's a myth that monor schools um you know don't cater to the black community I definitely think that that monor teachers and families would definitely tell you that they want black and brown children but if you go down to OTR or into the West end I would like you I would encourage you to look at the resources available to those families to take the time and the energy to actually go through the the lottery the monory lottery to take the time out of their days when they might not even have the resources enough to do that on a on a just for regular schooling um so my question to you you know president Bolton is would you be willing to go and help get those kids signed up for

053the monor that you tote as being kind of the star of the district when the rest of us are also trying our hardest to get you the numbers and get you the scores that you would like as our next speaker comes if you can come to the podium but I'm going to have you pause for a second before you start it's okay thank you everyone I'd like to continue on with the next group of individuals so you two can go ahead and head on back if you'd like to stay you can stay um and before you begin I'm going to call the next group down Ryan Shear Brad Smith Fanny kadine Marcia futel Bishop Enis Tate R Smith Stefan prior Renee Avia banka banca gay banca gay Sandy Bennett P I don't want to mess

054up the last name Jennifer Foster and then last is Liz goat go Meer goat Meer sorry so go ahead and come on down go all the way to the end and however the order is that is where you will start so go on down to the very last seat fill it all in H it was 12 okay it doesn't matter they'll just go up to the mic and don't worry about the order just come on down have a seat and then we will just go in order so the first person the second person the third the fourth and so on all right are you ready I am if you are we'll we'll give it five 4 3 two all right my name is Jeff one yep my name slow start my name is Jeff Hitman

055Mason I am a Pleasant Ridge resident I am a proud father of a Woodford Wildcat as of this year and I'm also the Pleasant Ridge Community Council vice president so I'm I'm coming with a couple of different hats on to advocate for Woodford Academy remaining as is for the sake of our community from a Pleasant Ridge Community standpoint I want to advocate for for the Min families which I found out this week that we are the primary populator of Woodford Academy Pleasant ridges and that's because our neighborhood school is a monu and I have learned personally and I'm sure you all know that Monas does not work for everyone uh so as a primary populator it's guaranteed to be an issue for Pleasant Ridge monory which even with its recent addition is already a full

056school that if Woodford Academy was to be merged into Silverton Academy you would likely have many parents overfill overpopulating PRM in a in a town and a community that is growing with many developments to come so I want to Advocate on that I also want to advocate for the sake of our rental residents uh as somebody who hears public comment at our community council meetings it's mostly homeowners but our but I think it would be inequitable to not listen to think about uh the rental Community the people that are moving from place to place imagine if your child was was used to traditional education and having one that was within a mile and Woodford Academy would be a great thing but you would almost be cornered into sending your child to a monory type program

057that might not be a good fit for for them and so as a as a parent I want to give you my anecdotal story and that's that my son was great at Woodford Academy I mean at PRM in monu in kindergarten he was a classroom leader he helped other kids with everything and as soon as he went into the multi-age classroom setting his academics and his emotional development dive bombed and so we had to make the hard decision this year to move him to Woodford Academy after having gone to the school and seen the magic that has been mentioned thank you so much all right we'll start with our very first speaker and work our way [Applause] down good evening my name is Renee Avia I'm a taxpayer a retired public school teacher and administrator

058I follow what happens in CPS and the Board of Education I care about our schools and our students and I know there isn't a hasn't been a recent superintendent that has been strong enough to make the necessary changes to write the size of the buildings when we've had Master school plans in the past years I support your vote today to reconfigure some of the schools because according to CB Senate Bill 925 if you don't do it the state will in addition this bill is looking at low performing schools and how those schools will far out and it's been mentioned mentioned that principles could lose their jobs 60% of the staff will leave other entities like Charters and school management companies or universities are going to take over the building and the state can also shut

059down the buildings I implore you to support the superintendent plan and con so CPS can continue to control the schools and not the state legislature be leaders and support the plan thank you our next speaker good evening Board of Education my name is Brad Smith I'm a resident of taxpayer and tonight I want to speak to you from the Ohio ethics Commission on public school districts conflicts of interest involve public officials and employees taking official action or making decision and matters that definitely and directly affect themselves their family members or their business associates the basic assumption that underlies the ethics law is that Ohio deserve Public Service who Advance the public interest rather than their personal interest or those of closely related parties simply put a public official has a conflict of interest when his

060or her ability to be an objective decision maker could be impaired by his or own interests the interest of family members or business associates so let's say I'm an elected School Board member and one of my family members runs an organization that promotes charter schools and vouchers that is closely align aligned with the Cincinnati business Community if I use my position on the board to propose a plan of action to prevent public school buildings from being taken by the state and handed over to private or Char or schools that my family members organization promotes that my decision is directly affecting my family member and advances the interest of the organization which they work namely that organization gets newly renovated buildings for practically no cost my decision making is appared by the interest of family members

061by my family member according to the high commission I'd say i' have a conflict of interest so what does the high commission say I should do Ohio ethics law prohibits public officials or employees from participating in any way in actions or decisions that definitely and directly involve their own interests or those of their families or business associates that means I should recuse myself because if I don't I'm essentially benefiting directly benefiting my family member because their uh organization's interests are being served by my decision to oppose this plan if we do nothing we lose our buildings we lose our buildings we lose our jobs is that what this board wants to lose our buildings and lose jobs thank you our next speaker hello I am banca gay I serve as the lead counselor for this

062district and the proud counselor at Woodward High School and the mother of a CPS students so first I want to make sure we want to make sure all students have access that's our goal as counselors my goal is to get you to graduate but also make sure you're good after you graduate all students so in that we do have to increase our Career Tech opportunities we have to we already know that the new Ohio prepare foress evaluations they emphasize industry recognized credentials so that's also going to be a way for us to get Stars so we got to make sure we increase that for our students because as a counselor we already know that yes you can get it at Woodward certain schools you can get certain credentials but we have to expand that so

063all students have access also so we need middle schools so if you work in a high school we know that it's important that our students need to be separated to make sure that we continue to nurture them self-esteem make sure that they're prepared for high school so we need to be able to make some changes I know we're advocating for different things but we do need middle schools and I stand behind that as someone who' been working here for 10 years at woodberg high school love what I do social emotional and making sure our kids graduate on time and make sure they feel secure and loved but I think we need to be able to hone in on the middle school students and support them thank you and also just another thing our kids are

064watching they're watching how we navigate hard conversations and challenges they come and talk to us about it like you hear what's going on so let's just make sure we're doing everything out of love and no we're here for the students we're all here for the students thank you thank you our next speaker hello uh my name is Liz gmer I am with Peasley Neighborhood Center uh which was formerly a CPS elementary school until it was closed by an earlier round of downsizing Peasley is a prime example that schools are more than buildings and they are more than their curriculum schools are centers of community which is why the mothers grandmothers aunties and neighbors of students who attended Peasley fought so hard to keep it this is also why you see so many people gathered here

065tonight to speak in Passionate defense of their beloved schools Peasley still exists today as a community center because it's families knew what was in their own best interest and made a way out of no way to make it happen despite the odds stacked against them while I am happy to see that Peasley's partner School Rothenberg Preparatory Academy is no longer recommended for changes under Phase 2 I will say on behalf of all other schools that would still feel feel the impact of this growth plan School staff and parents know best what is in their own best interest if instead of rolling out such plans in a top- down fashion C PS would do community engagement first you would find that these School communities are already resourceful and good at problem solving and we'll be able

066to offer solutions that better serve CPS students and families thank you thank you our next speaker hello my name is Rik Smith I work with Allin Cincinnati I'm here with the Cincinnati Community Coalition I also sit on two Ls dmc's the president of the PTA at my son's school and am the acting vice president of winey Hills Community Council I was a part of three different meetings that actually that uh were talking about the growth plan and I actually complimented uh superintendent Murphy as well as John Chambers on their intentionality of engaging the lsdm C's and ptas in these com commun uh conversations however I realized that I was blind to my own privilege I realized that I that if I was not blessed enough to have the privilege of the time to be so

067engaged I would have no idea what was going on in this day and age not all parents have that privilege we are dependent on the schools in the board to educate us and inform us about the things that we need to be aware of and beyond that we are not experts in this space we are counting on you trusting you and electing you to keep us aware of our options and to inform us not to take away our options and our voice I'm not saying that there is not something that needs to be done I don't understand the urgency but I digress as I said I am not a a professional in this space what I am saying is that we are intelligent enough and capable of being a part of the solution if you

068would let us I'm engaged in three different elementary schools in the district for one Elementary School this plan works for one Elementary School it does not and the other school is not is not affected so I'm not even saying that everything you all have put together is not as wrong I'm just saying it's not always about what you're doing it's about how you're doing it lastly speaking specifically for my son at College Hill Elementary please let us be we have been unsecure for the last four years that we've been in the district we finally have a principal a vice principal and a resource coordinator all at the same time who are working to really encourage and improve our students and our out academic outcomes let us be if it ain't broke don't fix it thank

069you our next speaker and remember we're just going to go straight down the line so thanks all right good evening my name is Ryan Shear I'm a seventh and eighth grade teacher at awl and vice president of the CFT I'm here to speak in favor of the restructuring plan um first of all I just want to say I believe it's the responsibility of this elected board to make tough decisions when that time comes and I think it's very clear that this is one of those times where it's a tough decision not everybody is going to be satisfied with the decisions that are made um but I believe what we're seeing uh shows that we need to get something done in this District so that we can be more proactive proactive rather than reactive moving forward

070into the future um I commend those board members that are looking at the big picture and taking seriously the threat from the state legislature um I believe those that are not are failing in their Duty as an elected member of this board because the state legislature does not look at our district or our students or our students families in a favorable way and that has been very clear for a while and they have plans on plans to make it much more difficult for us in the classroom and this restructuring plan helps us alleviate some of those stresses moving forward and that's all I have thank you thank you our next speaker good evening I've been here before you before RCF youel and tonight I'm representing the Cincinnati Community Coalition which is a growing group of

071concerned citizens taxpayers organizations leaders business owners and parents so three points I'll make first of all you already know this our demands are very simple we're asking you not to proceed with this plan tonight any parts of this plan tonight until and unless you have engaged the community properly until unless you have formed a community task force of agreed upon stakeholders to be incorporated in your decision making that's very simple the second thing I would point out tonight is that we understand you have concerns and I don't think any of you are dare derck in your duties to understand the seriousness of what the state is doing so I would not lay that burden on you however we could help you we could help you you've known about Senate Bill 295 for a while now

072um we've been hearing about it that's the Lynch pinch and your plan to do all this reorg and moving around you say and it was explained to us in your board meetings that this was a underutilization issue when now it's apparent that it's not an underutilization issue but it's a academic issue and so in all of the present the presentations that you have shared with us there's been no academic data so if the situation was was uh at the state level the concern was about academic performance why do we have so many schools that are below the the number that they should be who could be at risk of closing first of all second of all as we saw tonight and I have those same presentations those same slides that board member Moffet shared but

073one of the things that was pointed out is that they cannot consider the the data thank you so much our next somebody coming behind me to finish this up I'm sure you can go ahead and get started thank [Applause] [Music] you hello my name is Fanny kadine and I am the cfop President I'm the Cincinnati Federation of office professionals and wees we represent senior support Specialists support specialist lead secretaries and all the other clerical workers in CPS from the positions that they occupy cfob members have a unique perspective on the daily operations of Cincinnati public schools we work in the school offices across the district we work with the parents we work with the students we work with the teachers we work with administrators we see things we hear things and in the very conversations

074that I've had with cop members of cincin night Public Schools people are breathing a massive sigh of relief thank to shaa Murphy's leadership in this moment and so I want to take a moment to address the growth plan that superintendent Murphy has been advocating for if the board does nothing today we know unenrolled schools will close if the board does nothing today we know students teachers and cfop members at over enrolled schools will continue to suffer as school secretaries and clerical workers we know what our school needs and if we in this room are serious about how we are going to continue to help and prepare our students for life in Cincinnati public schools it is on us to make tough decisions like these and support s superintendent shaa Murphy thank you thanks our next

075[Applause] speaker my name is Sandy Bennett Peter I'm here as a districtwide mentor as a peer teacher I feel we need to support phase two of The Proposal as an Elementary Mentor I walk into some buildings and there are numerous empty classrooms or classes of 10 to 15 students some of these schools are costing the district $116,000 per student the district cannot afford this then I go to another school where they are busting at the seams the classrooms are overloaded and Specialists are teaching from a cart where is the equity in that from the field our office sees firsthand the critical need for middle schools a great deal of our office support goes to the middle school age teachers Middle School Educators play Vital role in addressing the unique challenges of early adolescence while fostering

076a supportive learning environment middle schools would equip students with the social emotional supports skills and mindset needed to prepare prepare them for high school and Beyond I'm currently working with a team of teachers under the direction of Julia and deliso trying to rebuild our relationship with local universities they have identified a need to place pre-service teachers in buildings implementing the Middle School model without a deliberate focus on middle school education we risk losing the opportunity for developing a robust pipeline of teachers for our district no one wants to leave their small class passes but at the same time we have to be responsible to the taxpayers in line with CPS mission statement to provide high quality and Equitable opportunities for our students we need to move forward with phase two of the superintendent's proposal there

077is no way to make every person happy and we cannot afford lose schools to Charters which in turn will lead to staff losing jobs because you are reluctant to make the difficult yet responsible decisions you were elected to do thank you our next [Applause] speaker good evening I had a lot to say but I'm I'm just going to summarize my presentation tonight after hearing from those that have come before me uh I realize the difficult decision that you have to make tonight because there's so many things that are happening and so many moving Parts my concern is that we're not dealing with the real problem in the room and that is that there is division at two levels of this operation it's apparent that the administration is not working with the board and the board

078is not working with the administration which causes problems in the community and the school buildings and because of that division we have what we have tonight it would be better served time better served if we were all here applauding all the work that was going rather than having to argue about which decision is going to be better for this community and for this city so I'm cautioning all of us that we are required an expected to work together in unity A House Divided will not stand and if that be the case and I believe it is a true principle that if what more member maford has talked about and we've all heard that it's a major issue that the hammer is coming down and we're not ready and if the thief is not ready for

079the robber then the robber will take over the house and right now as I've heard tonight and what I've seen is we're not ready don't be a hypocrite help the situation by making the right decisions at the right time with the right people in the room thank you our next [Applause] speaker hello my name is Jennifer Foster as a vice president aidel Community Council a black mother grandmother auntie and Village mother for five seconds I want you to close your eyes and think about everything you lost the next time you open them that's the feeling that these children will feel when you open up your eyes you see everybody gone you have lost past the seal you have lost some of the great teachers so as you think about Aces and you think about trauma

080would you sit back and really say I'mma add one more trauma Aces to these kids and these families as they wake up every day in some of the communities that they live in according to the aces they say five or more that means you have a high tolerance of Aces we have children dealing with 25 a week now you go at 30 as your soul and your conscious heart do you want to add another trauma to the trauma that the families that they're going through this is not a ministration problem this is a withth problem we have to solve this all together not just administration because we know now academically only thing we have learned academically have had the thing that we have learned how you have added and subtracted square footage we have no

081room for no parents we have no room for Community leaders we have no room listen to the ahog committee what is we doing we grew here y'all flew here what we going to do together as our next speaker comes up Stefan um before you begin Stefan I'm going to call a list of names thank you everyone can I have David Whitehead please come down and then the other two yeah thank you Craig Rosen Rashida Pearson Casey Irwin um it's VI Manuel and then Alexis zaer mild Patterson Josh olid and Christina olid and Stefan you can just wait a second until we get everyone down okay and as you come down just come all the way down to the end of the seat I think I called nine or 10 names and then we'll just work

082our way down come on hurry up y'all coming to the altar come on now how you doing sir okay I think is that everyone that I called I think we have one more coming all right step on the mic is yours we got one more coming oh one more okay one more coming take your time I don't think so I think we have the okay they're leaving nope all yours go ahead yours she sting down all right all right ready let's go I've been doing my studying about this redistricting the schools schools will be crowded and commuted times ill fitting attendance boundaries this will make the schools very corrupted for real for real be so crowded be starting fights in classrooms and all that so superintendent Miss Murphy you they boss girl I don't know

083what you're waiting on you can call the shots I know you can I know you can you need to call the right shots for the community Miss Murphy cuz I did tell you couple months back you was going to be the next superintendent look you sitting right there right now looking at me and I'm looking at you but we got to do this right y'all miss miss eeve miss eeve B and you girl I said it last time girl you've been here so long so so long I mean you you I mean real long I know it's time for you to go I know it is when I say leave y'all say Eve leave leave leave see they they behind me it is time for you to go we need a whole new freshh can

084you just continue on please thank you I you just my yes Olympia's gold medalist I'm Sorry Miss Mary my bad on you my bad I'm sorry but miss Eve Miss Eve have a heart have a heart for people cuz one day when I was in here you said a comment to the crowd it wasn't cool so that's why I came here and said that to you no disrespect I love you nothing you can do about it but have a heart for people you know I mean I know you've been in the position for a long time and you there for a reason to help people not help that not not help the lobbyist I know the lobbyist love to get stuff get stuff done and build in the communities I know that for a fact

085but Eve do your job do it well for real you know I mean leave a legacy behind so people can remember you not what you done done and didn't do real talk Miss Eve ain't all about you here today I love you and know you can do about it okay thank you so much all right all right all right we'll just go down the line with the next speaker you're up first then we'll go with the next person vem Manuel West Residence and if you need to bring the mic down you can bring it down okay thank you V Manuel West h resident um Seven Hills neighborhood house cssj Advocate just advocate for children in general um as I look it seems like you're targeting certain areas that don't seem to have the resources but

086they are thriving I mean you know it's like do you have an old text book but we're making the old textbook work and kids are reading you know they're up they're up they're coming they want to learn cuz they have a safe environment when children are safe they Excel it it it's just that easy you know you going put a kid on the bus and send them God knows where they're not safe because they don't know where they're going they have no one they can touch feel no they don't know that but they got to deal with that environment and then wait till about 6:00 when they get home and tell Mom Mom Dad Auntie whatever oh this is what happened to me today in school it's not right it's just not right period thank

087you our next [Applause] speaker you guys are gonna get tired of seeing me I promise my name is Casey ir and you guys have seen me week after week up here I'm a parent of a seventh grade monor student like my shirt says prodct of Cincinnati public I'm a huge graduate class of 2004 I'm standing here once again because I'm believe so keep going no sorry I'm standing here again because I believe so passionately that the phase two P phase two planet is currently written is not the right choice for our for the district and its students I know each of you is trying to do what is best and want to make an informed decision as the time comes to vote approaching I ask for you to leave Clark Monas alone and prior to

088as a third monor Junior Senior High School in phase three of the plan I hope you consider the AMS accreditation process the values of the monor the importance of giving a middle school student a role model and a high school student the relationship and bonds our students have with teachers and staff and how isolating 12 and 13 year olds in their own school does not give an opportunity to to establish community and Leadership I hope you consider all the children impacted by the speed of the phase 2 plan and have taken the time to listen to the families and see how the this education has impacted the most please vote no on the phase two thank you thank you our next [Applause] speaker good evening my name is Alexis kid Zer you got it right

089this time I want to start by thanking uh board member map and also um vice president Weinberg for responding to my email that's sent to all of you all um Dr mord I know you've been busy meeting with groups I want to just thank you and acknowledge that you all have responded so I do appreciate that um I heard that we're safe but we're not sure we had parents that were going to come there like oh we were safe now we can't trust it so we're here basically making sure that whether or not phase two we're not in it thank you if you removed us and also Rothenberg because there's no reason to remove a successful school like Hayes Porter you see you showing up parents administrators the leaders residents we're here tonight last week

090we had 35 students that showed up saying that we want to stay in our school and they're very concerned talk about trauma that's what it is on our kids because hearing that their school is going to close is traumatizing so we're here to stand for those babies those families those parents who may not be able to make it tonight we're here for those parents we want to make sure that hay Porter is not in phase two phase three four five and any other unless it's adding preschool classrooms want to thank you for your time and also just also just want to encourage that continued um engagement CU although my heart is a little lifted for Hayes Porter it's still heavy for the rest of the district and all the other schools that have to carry

091a burden of potential changes thank you thank you our next [Applause] speaker good evening how you guys doing this evening um my name is Mila Patterson I am to follow up back what she said um I am a product of cincin night Public Schools I went to hey supporter and T ta so um it is very disheartening that Hayes would even be on the table as the only C night public schools in the West End for you to even consider moving them it is trauma for our kids I don't know what depth of cincin night Public Schools works with the city but maybe I need to strengthen those relationships bring more Community I heard y'all say community four times y'all have not been used in the community and bringing them forth I'm a product of

092the West End not only am I like I said I went to Hayes Porter and tab graduated from Northern Kentucky University and an educator in cin night Public Schools so I've been giving back and I refuse to let our schools close because you guys are just making a decision bring the community to the table every time we're here we're there and you guys are not using us or utilizing us as the community thank you thank you our next [Applause] speaker uh first let me apologize for my speech I recently underwent critical cervical and thoracic surgery and I'm still recovering good evening president Balton board members superintendent Murphy congrats again on removing the interim from your title and I apologize I miss Sundays with the superintendent I look forward to our district being more open and

093direct access to leadership that you have provided thank you for those who might not know my name is Craig Rosen and I'm proud to consider myself a friend of CPS for over 16 years in that role I've been involved engaged and or vocal on many district subcommittees and initiatives and I think this is part of the problem the district is finding itself in today some of these included a decade as Tri chair chair of CPS budget commission president of cincinnatians active support education a member of numerous committees including step facet LSD MC's and ilts and I think this is where the board might have made a misstep those committees the community engagement that we were so proud of for so long are limited and few in between while it's true the district has done a

094great job putting their meetings and subcommittees online for those see it is still a huge time commitment for many people to understand the will and the want of the board and the administration I strongly supported last year's Faith one changes having preached the need to re-evaluate and reinvigorate our District's gifted Services though as a Spencer Center lsdmc parent rip last year I can chair most of our school Community though appreciative was extremely caught off guard and surprised by the remediation to Riverview I personally like the phase one proposals and I also see the Merit in phase two however thank you so much thank you our next speaker the light is green before I got up here okay now we're good now David whad from the uh naac let's pull the mic up just a little

095bit David wad from the NAACP uh president-elect I want to get right to where I left off the last time and I'm still waiting on an executive summary from uh your proposal there's still no data involved and I've heard a lot of things about emotions about money about different things of the nature in regards to school but I have yet to hear anybody say anything about how it would improve the academic success of the students that's what's crucial right now we can have the the smallest rooms we can have the biggest rooms but if it's not improving success what are we doing we should be here for the children and it's about the children so when we start talking about Senate Bill 295 if you don't know I've been in the political landscape of legislation

096for a long time we stop bills in committee we go fight up in Columbus before you even see it and if we're talking about Senate Bill 295 we have to understand that it's talking about academic success and it is going from the 21 through 23 for collecting the data but 2024 and 25 is where it's going to be implemented so if you're doing what you're supposed to be doing now your school is not in jeopardy your school is not going to fall under the mix so let's not pretend that it's about the schools getting taken by the charters because what we do understand that Charters are failing there are some Charters that are closing so these Charters ain't coming to grab what is coming to grab is the gentrification of our community the fact that

097we are trying we have to stop this we got to stop playing with people we have to be clear in the information that we're are sharing and that's where my problem has been we are not showing the data points we know there are middle school students that are suffering and failing so yeah you may need to move them but share it share it with the community share that the fact that there are people not being educated and then when you go into those contracts with the the with the uh School teachers when all that tell them look it's a merit-based pay thank you so much our next speaker hi I'm Christina Orrick I'm a johnp Parker parent and PTI president um I wanted to express my concern about the boundaries let's pull the mic up

098a little bit can't really hear you go ahead is that better yes okay um I wanted to express excuse me for just a second can we please hear the speaker go ahead um I just wanted to express my concern about the boundary change that's listed for johnp Parker although it says no change changing the boundary would have a serious impact on our enrollment um and our School community and it wouldn't support the goal for the schools to be adequately enrolled we already lost a preschool class this year um because of Bramble opening and I believe we now have three completely full preschool classes um I've also been troubled by some comments that I've heard um here and online suggesting that families are not or don't want to send their children to John P Parker that

099view is really out of touch with the community I would invite you to come and speak to us um we have a really wonderful school that's high performing and it feels like we're continually being subjected to changes there's even a billboard like right around the corner from our school advertising magnet schools but there's nothing to say that we have a really fantastic school already in our neighborhood thanks thank you so much our next [Applause] speaker good evening uh superintendent or she's not here superintendent um superintendent or vice president School board since CPS School Board okay I'm here tonight my name is Rashida Pearson I'm here tonight to ask you all to um step back for a minute and not vote tonight um I need you all to stop playing Monopoly with our kids education cuz

100that's what it appears right now it appears like you guys are are looking at the school the school system this and and you're just playing Monopoly with them and that's not cool we looking at um what's going on with the violence with our kids in in school at the bus stops and then you want to take what you say some says um 70% now it's 40% I I don't care if it was 20% of the school district that you're trying to reroute it is going to devastate these youth they're already going through it right now with the economy with the city being gentrified and um Evo not understand the school board does not have anything to do with the city being gentrified but that doesn't mean we have to play a part in education to

101align with that we don't we're we're taxpayers so we don't and I just want to remind everybody here tonight we voted the school board officials in we hold the power you all supposed to listen and answer to community voice and that didn't happen just because because you you engaged you had these little meetings and you had a couple of members from the community council to engage you did not engage the community properly I know you didn't you know why cuz when I made a post there's no way my post shared 155 times because nobody was aware of what was going on with the CP School District CPS School District so I'm asking you all tonight to our next speaker please good evening uh my name is Josh olrick I'm a homeowner and resident in Madisonville

102a small business owner in Madisonville and work in Madisonville my wife works in Madisonville I'm a board member on the Madisonville Community Council and the business chamber in Madisonville also tutor math at schroer Middle School uh most importantly and the reason I'm here today is I have a kindergartener at John P Parker uh uh my friend Rashida who was the previous speaker when we came to Madisonville six seven almost seven years ago one of the first community members to welcome us into the community um so last year we were here fighting what seemed like a crusade by the previous superintendent to got the preschool at a five-star preschool at JN Parker uh the result we ended up with was better than nothing uh but we did lose a preschool class now I'm surprised to see

103that we're back here today talking about redrawing a boundary line to cut 50ish families from our school um I realized that the discussion between the two board members before we started the public comments uh put some things in doubt as to whether that hammer is going to drop as one of the previous speakers said uh but it's concerning that lowering the attendance at John P Parker by The Stroke of a pen could cause some issues with the school so uh as one of the the Woodford there is a uh uh there's a a billboard that basically casts a shadow on John P Parker with a Sans Elementary School student on it promoting magnet schools and that's great monor is fine uh for the people that want monu we want our neighborhood schools uh we're happy

104to send our child there we're excited about it we're excited to see that she gets to mix with everybody in our community at all levels so please support our local neighborhood schools thank you thank you so much I'm going to call our next group of individuals if you could please come down Angela um I think it's Angela couch I think that's correct Lisa Colbert Shana Darden Katie MC Owen Paige hater Carly Diggs Dorothy Mays and then Janet Albert captain for and then we'll just hold on one second so we get everybody down here and seated before you get started okay can you hear me okay all right I think uh we can begin all righty good evening superintendent Murphy and the board my name is Angela couch and I am a preschool teacher at Pleasant

105Hill Academy which is included in the phase two in phase two of the growth plan I am in support of phase to of the growth plan superintendent Murphy had a daunting task when she became interim superintendent from the beginning she has been collaborative and focused to correct what was wrong in the district first and foremost she has put our students first phase two is important and necessary because of the because of the many under enrolled schools she has done what is necessary to protect our buildings from being acquired by the state with Senate Bill 295 no one wants their school to be affected but the reality is somebody's school has to be affected because there has to be a physical responsibility to the taxpayers I believe that the board must vote to approve phase two

106because it is necessary to move the district forward if approved as a teacher at Pleasant Hill with so many uncertainties and different things that are being said I ask that teachers have an opportunity to continue conversations that have been started to answer questions and voice concerns such as teacher reassignments seniority and the possibility of teachers being placed into buildings and taking a look at buildings that are most beneficial for the demographics just to name a few while we are here to advocate for our for the needs of our students who will advocate for us teachers thank you for your time thank you so much did we not start from the beginning we just put inorder of our name we're just going to go from the beginning though after you we'll just go down the line

107okay go ahead esteem board members as we deliberate the future of Pleasant Hill I urge you to consider the substantial investment and strategic advantages that support its continued operation as an elementary school firstly the significant funds have already been utilized for the development of the state-of-the-art playscape specifically designed for the development needs of young children this investment coupled with the school's current configuration and Facilities provides an optimal learning environment for elementary students we have long-standing Community relationships like Cincinnati Nature Center and keep Cincinnati beautiful who help keep our Nature Scape our Peace Garden our Prairie our Outdoor Classroom our outdoor Amphitheater our vegetable garden optimal for elementary learning caring for these green spaces is a rare opportunity for young children and prepares our Primary students to be lifelong caretakers for the environment secondly Pleasant Hill

108close proximity to the public library offers a unique opportunity for Collaborative Learning and Community engagement this relationship enhances educational experiences and fosters a love of of reading and learning a large number of our families rely on the library and their after school Services every day the close the close proximity of the school and the library is a powerful part of what makes Pleasant Hill perfect for the intergenerational school community and young children finally maintaining Pleasant Hill as an elementary school eliminates the need for extensive renovation and upgrades that would be necessary to accomodate middle school students by preserving its current function we can allocate resour resources more efficiently and prioritize pressing needs within the district let us build upon the strong Foundation at Pleasant Hill Elementary and ensure the Bright Futures of our youngest Learners

109thank you so much thank you hello I'm Katie mcen math specialist at Rothenberg and I also teach stem Fridays to all grades I'm speaking for the third time in two months tonight to request the district and board members to engage with school communities as future proposals are being created I do not blame Hayes Porter for being upset just as we were suddenly shocked in October and have yet to have any further discussions they too are in shock and panic engagement is needed before any decisions are made in the future it was upsetting for us at Rothenberg listening last week as members of the board and audience gave a negative image portrayal of our school each other as we have all have many great things to offer offer however it was also evident that many members

110and City residents do not know all that we do at our school so I'm going to share some of that right now first let me say that we are in a transition of improvement we are no longer two stars we are 2.5 stars and Rising we already had major growth in our third grade OST this fall a 36% proficiency growth in two years some events and programs we are doing we had our first Annual Spelling be last year and are continuing to do it this year year we've had May the mayor and Greg L lansman come and read with our students several times this semester not too long ago we had a pack cafeteria and gym during a pancakes with parents events we are planning our first annual catian for our sixth graders I personally

111have partnered with the design lab and I'm bringing an architect to do work with our fourth graders all next semester we have a preschool waiting list every year we have several wonderful tutoring groups partnering with our school we have a successful rooftop garden parent program and summer jobs for students we have several uh student Enterprise activities we have two huge after school program Partners the man and Wesley Chapel we have a large parking lot when you come to engage with communities you will find out many other great things that we all offer we know we've got things to improve but like a phoenix but as Falcons we are rising up to Greatness thank you thank you so much our next [Music] [Applause] speaker greetings as a child I grew up in over the Ry and

112I attended rbbery school I now have the distinguished honor to serve as an accomplished educator effective leader Athletics coach mentor and so much more to the Rothenberg community at Rothenberg I help build independent critical thinkers Learners end doers of our future I know how important leg Legacy stability is in our community my siblings and I attended Rothenberg and now are adults and productive hardworking citizens who still Port into renberg and the over the Ryan Community working at renberg was a choice for me and not a last resort the level of car and concern for the students and families in our community goes beyond a report card rating we are products of renberg's long-standing reputation of caring for the whole child academics and success flowed naturally after we knew that we were cared for and that

113our needs were met the unique Community environment at Rothbury is like no other other schools have modeled our parent Center that was created specifically in the blueprint due during the renovation to allow parents and volunteers access to resources knowledge grow and be Community our after school athletics experiences and so much more have also been modeled across the district because of the success and safe spaces these attributes have provided in the community we serve each school has a unique Community where they are comfortable and don't want to be uprooted which is understandable that shows we have dedicated staff and families across our district while change is inevitable proper chains of command such as engaging the community should be best practiced as a district we need to get creative with ways to boost enrollment instead of pitting

114schools against each other we are all here for students and the disdain that has been recently spewed out of fear and hurt from these proposals is damaging relationships amongst our schools and communities while each school is unique the geographical of renberg is also what makes it a true gy in the downtown community as the boot on the ground we will continue to do what we have to do to grow our in the sake of advocacy and [Applause] support hello my name is Paige haer and I have been the school psychologist at Rosenberg Preparatory Academy for six years Rosenberg is so much more than a school it is a community with generations of families who have attended and many staff members who have a deep history with the school and the over the r Community today

115I would like to speak on behalf of a crucial part of the renberg community our specializ classrooms if we were to merge with another school our specialized classrooms could be in Jeopardy of moving renberg currently has four specialized classrooms including two autism rooms and two multiple disabilities rooms we have seen many benefits for all of our students by having these classrooms as a part of our school Community for many of the students in these classrooms Rothenberg is their neighborhood school it is unfair to ask them to attend a different School our specialized classroom students deserve the same opportunity to attend their neighborhood school as all other students within the neighborhood separate is not equal it is important to remember that the benefits of these specialized classrooms are not limited to the students with disabilities we

116have seen many advantages for students without disabilities as well a few years ago we had a student with autism who had never attended school before attend Rothenberg in place in a gened classroom students in that classroom were so accepting kind and helpful to this student that it was recognized by the district giving rberg students an opportunity to attend a school with an inclusive environment has helped them strengthen their empathy comp passion problem solving skills and appreciation of diversity these students are better prepared to navigate the real world where they will inevitably encounter people with all from all walks of life with varying backgrounds needs and abilities by keeping autism and multiple disabilities classrooms within Rothenberg we allow all students to understand that every one has value and belongs to this community regardless of challenges additionally

117the staff who work in these classrooms are experts in inclusion and differentiation and they are a core part of renberg's successful Special Education team and bring invaluable skills and strategies that benefit all renberg students please allow us to continue to give all of our students at renberg the opportunity to attend their neighborhood school and to assure that students of all abilities can continue to learn from each other thank you our next speaker you can go [Applause] ahead hello my name is Carly Diggs and I'm an intervention specialist at renberg I serve as one of the case coordinators for the building I'm a team lead and I founded and run our free clothing closet called the Rosenberg rack I have a deep passion for our students and the over the rine Community I appreciate you taking

118the time so that we can set the record straight about renberg at the board meeting on December 2nd it was mentioned that hay Porter is a fourstar school great job um as an educator I know that that's really hard to do so genuinely great job um please know that renberg is working hard to improve our status as well we of multiple tutoring programs increased proficiency on the third grade reading guarantee as well as of organized mtss model a strong PBIS program multiple Community Partners and a continued focus on data to drive our decisions one of the reasons that I care about Rothenberg is our strong special education department we have a strong team that works together to serve each one of our students despite their needs we have SP four specialized classrooms that also are

119a part of our community another reason that I care about renberg is our ability to care for the whole child not only do we educate our students we also support feed and clothe our students this winter we will provide coats new shoes socks underwear hats gloves blankets and other essential items to more than 100 of our students please consider the strengths of all schools before you make any decisions thank you thank you our next speaker hello my name is Janet alberry captain and I uh thank you for this opportunity to speak on behalf of Rothenberg Preparatory Academy so I stand here today not just for our students but for our their families and for the school community that serves as a vital anchor um in their lives Roy Burke is located in a neighborhood that

120is experiencing constant change driven by genfic for our students and their families this means navigating a shifting landscape that too often leaves them unseen and unheard families are the foundations of our school yet many are struggling to maintain a foothold in the very Community they help build supporting rberg as a stem school is not just about providing education it's about ensuring that our school remains a stable inclusive space for families who long who have long been marginalized steem education steam I'm sorry education offers our students and families a chance to rise above the challenges that they face daily it provides opportunities to dream innovate and built future um that honors their roots and their potential Este steamed designation will Empower students to become problem solvers and leaders while showing their families that their voice and

121contribu tions matter this is about this is about more than academics it's about preserving and strengthening the bond between our school and the families We Serve by supporting Rothenberg as a Este steamed School you are affirming that education is a bridge to equity opportunity and belonging for every child and their families thank you thank you our next speaker hello my name is Dorothy Mays and I'm a parent of of two boys that go to ruen bird Academy and I want to speak on the behalf of my son since they can't speak forsel but um ruthenberg has been a good school for them cuz they do learn as students and they also work with the parents like if you have any issues or any problems they they don't mind working with the parents and all Al

122They students they get to know like the whole school like you can't walk in their building and just not know the who the kid belong to and I also want to say they they are a good resource like if you have a problem or any issues it don't go beyond that school they help you or they try to help you find a resource that can fit your problem or your situation and they also help like cuz my youngest son he started preschool this year and I can see everything everything that they done did with him with him just being his first year he come home and he he learns and he he loves it and they don't do with a lot of bullying from um cuz I'm a Cincinnati public school graduate as well and

123I had to deal with a lot going to cincin night public school so I can see the the difference then and now had this um C night public schools had grew to where they is now and yes it is a work process but I like how things is going with they school now versus when I was going there years Beyond you know time but I'm I'm I'm thankful for ruberg and and it's not that far away from where they live they can get home faster so to to change that who knows what you know will cause problems in my kids life trying to transition over to something new and teachers that don't care or don't get to know their kids that's all I have to say thank you so much all right we have our

124last round of speakers can I have Emily marshman Lisha O'Neal Crystal Ingram Katie berlu Naomi lson William Beaker and then Julie sers Julie you will be last of course I'm just calling your name say it again oh yes thank you for that reminder Mr Wilson as our as our speakers are coming down how many speakers do we have online okay so we will go to them next and then we will end with um Julie sers all right our first Speaker you can come on up to the mic I think we have everyone hopefully okay you are good to go thank you hi my name is Katie berlu and I am a special education teacher at Taft Elementary and I've been there for three years let's bring the mic down a little bit more for you

125yes um Taft Elementary is more than just a school because we are a magnet school we have students from all over who are choosing to attend our school um our school has a community pool a full a health clinic full-time therapist through best point um and a food pantry through good sheeper church um and at our school we take care of the whole child um not just or we take care of them emotionally physically and academically um our school is a stem school um we have an amazing stem program and our teachers do a great job um integrating Science and Technology into all um content areas we also have amazing after school programs with a strong stem Focus that strengthen um skills that they will need Beyond just the academic classroom um my principal Miss

126Jason has worked so hard in building a really strong staff at our school and a sense of community and every day I'm seeing the growth and progress um emotionally and social emot and academically um in my students and I know that if we are given the opportunity to continue to operate as a magnet school sharing our transportation cost with Mount Auburn prep which is the school next door um we will get to continue to see all the growth and amazing progress um and see our students continue to do amazing things thank you thank you our next speaker [Applause] hello hello and you can bring the mic down a little bit to you yep so my name is l O'Neil I'm a parent of a son that goes to tff elementary I believe Taff should stay

127open because there are amazing teachers amazing staffs and a wonderful principal when my son first started my son was shy wasn't speaking now my son is in front of the class answering questions helping other inside his class he's only 10 and I believe that tab should stay open because not only does they work hard with the kids they also have us parents evolve with our kids they do these programs like we have we had a a program called math night is where parents and kids was able to do math together not only that it has an amazing Pantry there for families that can't you know get food the pantry is open to the public that's why I believe ta should stay open thank you so much our next [Applause] speaker hello my name is Crystal

128Ingram I'm a parent of a Taft Elementary graduate and have three currently attending the current proposal says that Taft Elementary will not exist as a school next year we want to be clear that we are very interested in staying open next school year with our current staff and students I love that Taft actually cares about my children the teachers and staff acts like they are their own especially the fact that they are patient with my three kids who are on IEPs by the way my children actually feel like somebody they've opened up to this school they've been there since since they were in preschool um without Taft I feel like my children will lose their confidence wanting to learn because they have to switch from a loving environment that they've been used to for years

129since they was little on up which is totally unfair to me and my children thank you so much our next speaker hi I'm Emily Marchman um at Taft Elementary and I teach um a AUM class um I'm one of the three I guess four CU we have a preschool MD unit too at the Taft Elementary um I actually taught in the preschool MD unit um before this year and I really love working at Taft because of the staff and environment and I know many of the parents that have been assigned to me in the past um often request to stay at Taft when they move on from preschool to kindergarten um and so I can have seen that I know the parents also appreciate working with us and being part of our community and um

130we've had meetings among our staff and families and we just want you to know that we have said that we will be flexible we will do what we need to do to stay open we'll try anything we'll um we've talked about monor we've talked about you know whatever we need to do we will um try to stay open and continue to be a community thanks thank you and before the next speaker I'm just going to ask for everyone in the audience whether you're staying whether you're leaving whether you agree with us whether you disagree can you please be respectful to not only the speakers but everyone in this room you can go ahead and speak hello board my name is William Becker and I am the PE teacher and the head of the mo group

131at Taft Elementary School not only am I a Taft teacher but I am a proud Taft Elementary teacher I am here today to ask to you to keep our school together the staff and Partnerships are something that you don't see at every school and is something that was not buil in a day before becoming certified in physical education I was a substitute teacher at CPS and I've seen many schools in the district all due respect we have in my opinion the best principal in CPS Dana Jason she is the reason why the school is what it is today she is the reason why we are here we work tirelessly every day because of all the work that she has put in sorry oh sorry we yeah we're TIY of the school to make sure it's

132possible it's the best possible environment for our students and that when they come to our school they stay when students leave our school they come back the reason for that is staff is special it makes the kids feel like they have a home closing our school would put us back years in relationships and Partnerships that we have built at Taff whether it be our campus food food pantry or our numerous partners that go to our classes like adop a class graders Proctor and Gamble Good Shepherd Church in Christ Hospital just to name a few just today we got our donations for our winter coats for every single student from The People's Church and Good Shepherd and what has been over a 10year relationship with those organizations this is not only a school for our students

133but is a safe place and it is a home when they come to Taft they feel safe they feel respected and they feel heard I would hate to lose that what a TA is built and would kindly ask you to consider the community and the students who will be affected in making your decision thank you thank you our next [Applause] speaker hello I'm Naomi LaRon I'm the stem teacher at Elementary for 2 years now last week studying erosion with second grade from the Amplified curriculum I took the lesson into a Hands-On realm and we were able to build landforms out of sand and see how water affects them after spraying with an open spray different water forces and then a jet spray and then finally obviously everyone's favorite a tsunami where we poured it out

134of a picture we got to see how we could transform water with the use of Science and as our students were supremely engaged in that lesson one of the children yelled out the superpower of Science and put her arm up in the air this is a child who when she came to us last year was unable to transition through classes because she would break down she was so scared to walk through the Halls because she was that shy and now she's constantly coming up and talking about our erosion lessons and how we get to do Hands-On science I would also like to say these are also the people that are going to be doing your surgeries these are also the people that are going to be building your Bridges so you might want to allow

135them to continue with their stem education we are willing to be flexible we are willing to go Monas that goes hands in hand with stem because it's about autonomy and Hands-On I am just asking that you do not throw out this whole family that is obviously fully engaged in not just our students but the community you hear from parents and our principal who went to our school and as a Westwood Elementary grad and aana Hills grad who my other graduate Ador was already up here we are coming back to this District to ser serve this District so please allow us to do things and I'm a single mom and I would like to spend time with my own children so I would like us to make some decisions but make them not in haste but

136with all of us in mind they're not numbers and if you factor them in as 15 students you better factor in their Aces because those are not classrooms of 15 they are 45 to 60 thank you very much Mr bson if you could go ahead and alert our online um speakers that they can go ahead and get started would be greatly appreciated thank you very much our first Speaker today is going to be Eric Higgins Eric you have two minutes you can go ahead unmute your camera and microphone Mr Higgins all right since Clayton Adams on we're going to start with Clayton Adams Mr Adams you can start with your please wait to unmute your camera and microphone online until you are called please mute your camera and microphone until you called Clayton Adams you

137can go ahead you have two minutes all right good evening members of the board and superintendent Murphy my name is Clayton Adams and I one of the building Representatives at Aken High School I wanted to speak tonight about the need to alleviate overcrowding at school schols like aen much of the discourse around the restructure has focused on under enrolled school buildings and very little has been said about the over enrolled school buildings for those that do not know Ain is a building that was built for a thousand students but has over 12200 students currently enrolled many schools especially on the west side of Cincinnati are experiencing similar issues of overcrowding this leads us to the question how does overcrowding impact teachers students in the building itself so one many teachers are on carts and do

138not have their own classroom space two there is a large amount of increased wear and tear on the building performing maintenance on overcrowded buildings costs the district additional money compared to under enrolled school buildings number three there are teachers who have more students on their case load than called for in the collective bargaining agreement that ultimately makes the the learning and teaching environment more challenging this also costs the district additional money due to overload pay and then number four there is an increase in stress and burnout when schools when school staff are expected to work in an overcrowded school building these are just some of the issues that will continue to persist if the overcrowding issue remains unsolved I ask that you make the right decision to help the school buildings that are suffering from

139overcrowding leaving certain schools under enrolled while other schools like Ain are over enrolled is not Equitable or fair for anyone let's refocus the conversation on helping staff and students who are currently in over enrolled buildings as a district we cannot afford to continue down this path of unsustainability we must protect our district from Ohio's Jerry Mander state legislature who can seize under enrolled buildings and give them to Charter School operators thanks for your time thank you so much thank you our next speaker is going to be Aubrey Drummond Aubrey you can unmute your camera microphone go ahead you have two minutes hi I'm abriel Drummond I am a parent but I'm here as education Advocate um I feel like we're talking about everything but the kids as Gatekeepers of academic freedom you are responsible for

140dismantling the remnants of systemic racism and education this board if in continuous support of this growth plan would abandon the guard rail set in place not to mention you will continue to per perpetuate the current strongholds that the teacher unions have over our district pushing agendas that support jobs and not Purpose By supporting poor performance and outcomes of classrooms and their staff further victimizing the people our children that we claim to serve this plan throws data and the recent claims of ACH ments in of our goals to the wind instead it reinforces pipelines to prison and poverty every neighborhood is not created equil but entrenched in systemic racism and privilege by removing School of Choice from our families we are imprisoning our children to the neighborhoods and communities they are in by circumstance but now

141becomes a condition to the quality of Education They will receive this Creator Jerry Mandarin has higher Stakes by taking place in an era in which our expectations for fairness are much higher in the scope of the whole child we need to realize that we have made so many decisions that are not centered around our greatest commodity specifically specifically in neighborhoods that are not being gentrified neighborhoods that are crimer ridden overflowing with drugs violence mental illness and pro poverty not to mention children who would lose access to health care but that's afterthought um these neighborhoods do not have strong LSD MC's or at least ones with strong parent Voice without the parent voice these children are rendered voiceless the teachers don't want to be in these neighborhoods they are not invested in the neighborhoods they often

142Escape as fast as they can these are not schools you would send your children to and you would be crazy to think that parents would stand around and watch you play Monopoly with the academic outcomes of our children thank you so much our next speaker thank you our next speaker is going to be Carrie Bellow Carrie you can unmute your camera microphone you have two minutes can you unmute yourself you need to unmute your microphone please I'm wasting my time hi everyone my name is Ki Bellow and I'm a parent of a prek uh student at Woodford I spoke back in September and briefly I just wanted to state that Woodford is a staple in the community um just a little bit of background um my son was born with heart of he was born

143with hearing loss and so this program has been um an amazing program for us uh to my knowledge it is the only program that exists in the CBS District of its kind and I'm just confused as to what the solution is um to displace students with disabilities to another location or um you know to disband the disband the program all together um I'm just confused as to how that provides a solution um to the students at wood for so I implore that you guys would really take into consideration the hearts of the parents who are speaking on behalf of Woodford telling you that we do not want this change to happen at Woodford we love our school we love our community and um I just want to say that we chose this school because it

144was in our district and outside of this we would have had to send our son to a school that was $30,000 in tuition for the same access to the programs that we have for free at Woodford so thank you Woodford principal Donner we love you and we support Woodford thank you so much our next speaker thank you our next speaker is going to be Eric Higgins Mr Higgins you have two minutes you can unmute your camera and microphone uh good evening school board and uh superintendent Murphy uh my name is Eric Higgins I am building principal at Clark monor uh been principal since 2019 um last week uh Clark Administration our lsdmc chair um was able to meet with um um Bard and superintendent Murphy uh come up with a come up with an agreement

145uh that we would take all the sixth grade students on the monstory side on the east side for um the 25 26 school year um you know that's one of the things that you know is really pressing is that all students get a seat at Clark and that's one of the things that we decided that we would do uh to to help with this situation uh you know I am truly optimistic that um you know working with the school board for the 25 26 school year that um that we'll be able to uh given that extra year that we'll be able to have a smooth transition for our students staff and families um as we work towards a a Clark Mur middle school for 20 6 27 school year you know uh assuming that this

146is all uh going to be board approved uh we want to do what's best for students um that's always first and that's every decision that to make is is students first uh so during the 2526 school year I mean if this does go through you know it will allow us to create a a small focused group uh monory experts uh working with the American monitory society um the Community School board superintendent uh on some accreditation some staffing you know researching other programs you know to keep a great program uh monitory program for our school district um in Clark and make sure that um it is done with Fidelity and in and again in the best interest of students so I just wanted you to know that um again we are optimistic that you know where

147we started from to where we are now that you know the school board and the superintendent are listening and we are grateful for that and we appreciate thank you so much our next speaker thank you our next speaker is Angela mowen Angela you can unmute your camera and microphone you have two minutes good afternoon well good evening uh superintendent Murphy and the board my name is Angela maowen and I am a re I'm a intervention specialist in the resource room at renberg Academy I will not not um repeat what was said but I want to say that we are all here for the kids um we all want the best for our children in our specific schools we serve the whole child we are educating the next president the next Senator the next councilman the

148next Doctor the next nurse so we are all passionate about our schools uh it would seem to me that if there's some schools that's overcrowd outing why can't we just send those kids to the schools that's underutilized um and I'm sure that those parents would not be as happy but wouldn't that solve a problem and stop the division that we are now experiencing again let me just say we are here for kids we are there's not a person in that building or any other building that is not here for kids so let's figure out what is the best way to go for the kids instead of what's the best way to go for the adults who've already received their education thank you thank you so much do we have any we have how many more

149speakers okay just wanted to make sure our next speaker thank you our next speaker will be bar Barb Schultz Barb you have two minutes you can unmute your camera and microphone good evening uh superintendent and board members I'm Barb Schultz a retired Cincinnati public school teacher at Clark Monas a recent lsdmc member and a lifelong supporter of Cincinnati public schools um I am here to encourage the administration and board to reconsider The Proposal that would move the seventh and eth grade communities out of the Clark building that was designed specifically for montauri Community classrooms uh on Erie Avenue um I began teaching back in 1978 and I have seen lots of changes in this District over those many years um I saw secondary schools be 78 n in one building in buildings and 10 11

15012 and another I saw the change when the ninth graders were pulled out and put in high school and then I saw the change from that went from um that took us to the current configuration of 7th and 12th 7th through 12th grade which has been Clark's um organizational structure for years um the Clark middle and high school program is attractive desirable and successful precisely because it was grown one grade level each year slowly and deliberately it came from the dreams and initial efforts of seventh and eighth graders and from the Grassroots uh research and work of parents teachers students and the support of then the then Administration and board and the late Bob Townson who is the director of magnet schools for CPS Clark monor is a success story for CPS as are many

151schools Clark has earned National recognition because of what they've accomplished over the last 30 years why mess with their success I urge you to leave the Clark Monas uh building configured as it is and our next speaker is Nicole obber Nicole you can unmute your camera and microphone and we will you have two minutes good evening my name is Nicole obber and I am a first grade teacher at Carson Elementary I'm speaking tonight imploring the board to officially move forward with the superintendent growth plan proposal this is my 13th year teaching in CPS and I have spent all 13 years at Carson our school and the community has been up and down throughout the years that we have con but we have consistently seeing growth although growth is what we strive for our building is

152so overcrowded that we cannot support the district growth we have had to use every available space for classrooms for example our stage is our ALC area with curtains for walls our library was converted into spaces for our intervention Specialists our staff Lounge was turned into a classroom our coffee rooms were turned into specialist rooms our new staff Lounge was actually a small conference room it still houses a copier however you cannot use The copier and the microwave at the same time because it will blow a fuse our Music Teacher is on a cart this year because we needed that room for a classroom to help right siiz our classes our Tech teacher was also put on a cart this year because we needed his room for the five ESL teachers we have that support our

153ESL population that is also growing our teachers no longer have spaces to plan because our specials have to be done in our classrooms during that time as I listen to other buildings speak about the things they do not want to lose I empathize with them as a building that is overflowing and needing to balance our space I'm disheartened that we are not empathized with as well we are crammed into a building and regularly have 28 to 36 students in rooms where students have to walk in window sills to get to their seats it's frustrating to see other CPS buildings with extra space to have amazing Wellness spaces for staff with massage chairs when we can't even heat up our lunch and print copies at the same time we know change is hard but with timely

154decisions we can support each other and make the necessary moves to do the best for all of the students and all of the staff in the district not just some of them thank you to the superintendent and her team for thank you our next speaker speaker is thank you Mr wison because I think that the speakers cannot hear me when I say it so if you could continue to please let them know about their time I appreciate it great thanks oie oie Davis don't start don't start letting her know now let me talk two and a half minutes good uh good evening Madam chair board members superintendent Murphy that sounds real good um let me Echo uh superint I'm sorry um member um Ali's um Kudo to T let me Echo that uh ta one

155time I want to congratulate uh superintendent Murphy on having the I removed and I want to thank uh board member m and chair Bolton for always keeping me a breast of what's going on at the district um Community engagement is broken but you didn't break it it's broke at all levels it's broken when I deal with the city it's broken from the community council perspective I would I would implore all the folk that have come out tonight to continue to be involved because that's the only way that Community engagement will get better I do think there may be an opportunity for some training of parents and community members that serve on ptas and the district's LSD MC's that they go back into the communities in which they live and get others perspectives and share information

156that is happening at the school I've seen far too many times over my 25 years single people representing an entire community and that is what is really breaking our community engagement process I want to thank you for your efforts at at community engagement in Avendale particularly with uh assistant superintendent John Chambers coming to last month's community council meeting after three questions he got a standing ovation so I don't know if we could have done any more there quickly I want you to know I had a wreck this morning on my way to tff technology high coming down Vine a staff member at uh Rising Stars was driving into left off of Vine driving into the one side parking lot I'm sorry thank you oie is your time our next speaker is Rachel B Rachel you

157have two minutes you can unmute your camera and microphone Rachel B go ahead can you hear me can you guys see me we can hear you please go ahead okay um so good evening all my name is Rachel Brown and I am the executive director of the mon Family Center and we are Community partner um to the district as Lee agency and after school provider and I stand in support of all three of our sites tonight which are Rothenberg Woodford and John P Parker I first would like to thank each of you for your commitment to being leaders of our district also thank you to the administration you all are doing great work I know the growth team has been working hard on phases one two and three to tackle some changes and challenges we're

158facing as a district and we appreciate you for doing the work to address it have many thoughts and questions on the phases but not enough time so I'll just share these four one it's now the best time to implement a plan of this magnitude without knowing the possible changes that can come as early as January from the new federal Administration two if phase two passes and once all the children are moved to their new sites will all of our buildings be at 60% utilization or more and if not we haven't really solved that issue just moved it around also from what I saw for Senate Bill 295 it mentions underperforming buildings which hasn't been addressed by the plan yet three I think the engagement was done a little backwards yes the administration did spend six

159weeks meeting with lsdmc but when they met with us plan for phase two had not been presented to anyone so it's hard to get feedback on something we don't know about four the administration stated that our buildings are being prepared for the new families coming into our communities but with enrollment being on a downward trend is there a district yde plan for recruitment in closing I think movement on phase two should be Paul to get more input from the community and I just want to reiterate that I know this is a tough decision but we're all in this together I'm rooting for you all I'm praying for you thank you so much for your time God bless you and good night thank you Rachel our next speaker will be Tracy Tracy you can unmute your

160camera and microphone that's Tracy gron you have two minutes the camera is not not let me immute is that a function on your end please continue thank you madam chair and members of the school board not only my taxpayer I'm a parent of a kindergarten at everon Academy who is autistic and nonverbal I need this board to slow down this process and not take a vote tonight or in the near future I want to speak on this plan in my communications with the board president she expressed that this board while currently negotiating with the unions is not in a position to guarantee services that my son needs if he moves from everon to Frederick Douglas my son needs a guarantee otherwise he might need to leave the district for the autistic services that he needs

161slow this process down the vice president of this board took $3,000 from the C Federation a teacher so I expect her to go with CFT and I want this board to consider a question do you work for the CFT do you work for Julie sers or do you work for the taxpayers and the people of this city there's an election coming up in November 2025 and if you all don't understand that you work for the people instead of these unions who's pushing this we will vote out half of this board and we need you all to stop this school to prison pipeline as described this WCPO this superintendent has worked for this board for over 30 years and she has done nothing to slow that pipeline down vote this plan down and yes we will

162Target everybody up for reelection in 2025 if our voices are not heard thank [Applause] you thank you our next speaker will be Victoria Victoria you can unmute your camera and microphone you have two minutes Victoria you can unmute your camera and microphone you have two minutes Victoria your microphone is still muted hi can you hear me we can okay sorry Zoom apparently does not like me talking that's fine I'm gonna talk anyway um hello my name is Victoria I uh work with the renberg rooftop garden which is a partner organization with renberg Preparatory Academy uh and this whole process has felt kind of like being the ball in a pinball machine um and while on one hand that is partially due to I would like to say rapid adaptation which could be seen as positive

163um I think that along with rapid adaptation needs to be an extra emphasis on communication that has not occurred um to that end I'm not 100% sure where Rothenberg sits right now but as someone mentioned earlier while it seems that we are safe currently I don't trust that because the communication is not communicating so I just want to give some of things that we're doing really well at Rothenberg so that whatever whatever happens you know where we're at um so at the rooftop garden which I want to give props to all of our teachers and our community members and our parents because we are just a drop in the bucket of amazingness that is going on there but here's some numbers for you so this season this season alone we have gone through 200 pounds

164of produce that we have grown with our students from seed to table those students cook those parents come into a parent program and cook our community members our volunteers our teachers our families they take that food home with them that's over 25 different types of produce we do Steam and stem activities all the time in the garden being Hands-On we provide an essential Green Space and green Bri for all of our students and our staff our last online speaker today is Ally rast Ali you can unmute your camera and microphone you have two minutes hi yes I'm coming to you not only as a parent but as an educator of 25 years I've emailed each of you several times starting back since February our daughter who is heart of hearing started at Woodford in preschool

165and when she started there she was non-verbal and we didn't know a single soul there and now she's in first grade and thriving she's speaking she's learning ASL and thanks so much to the wonderful teachers at Woodford we love you guys Woodford is not just some regular school at Woodford you have the deaf and heart of hearing units uh you have the multiple autism units and you have an elementary school centered around the Arts and I'm an teacher so I'm loving this nowhere else in the district do you have a school like this and it's more than a school it's a community that accepts each and every student and it's growing almost daily with new students coming in thanks to principal Donner if you break this up as a parent of a deaf child I

166am terrified of how she'll be treated at a school where she doesn't know a single person everyone knows Ellie at Woodford please don't take this away from her and all of her friends including the teachers she loves so much thank [Applause] you we have our last speaker Julie cellers okay good evening members of the board superintendent Murphy and Treasurer um I know that many are worried about the board's decision decisions that are going to be made this evening and it's causing many disruptions but we know what's coming down from the feds we know what's coming down from the state while we don't know exactly what actions are going to be finalized this evening here are the some of the things we do know there have already been some changes to the plan as it has

167been rolling out and that is because the board has been listening and I and you can tell from all of the speakers this evening there are many great things going on in our district that everybody in this room should be proud of but like oie said engagement has been people have been asleep at the wheel with engagement I know that um superintendent Murphy has been out to more than 75 um locations meeting with the public many of the people who are in the room haven't been given information from places where they are they belong to organizations where the board has um met with them but the board must make a decision as soon as possible based on the current processes within our district so that we can ensure proper Staffing and the budget process and

168for all of these process to work effectively the past two years or more these processes have been broken and pushed back and created chaos and dysfunction within the district you cannot stall on making a decision about these changes they're necessary we know that Transportation costs exceed $70 million a year and these costs are squeezing out educational programming and opportunities for our students and staff our high schools are overcrowded and desperately need relief nearly every High School is overc capacity there are too many teachers who do not even have a classroom and must travel and use other teachers classrooms who are on their planning Pell unless you have worked in a building with overc capacity you don't understand the chaos and dysfunction that causes high schools need more Career Tech options which is included in this

169plan parents for the last 10 years have been asking for more Career Tech options if you don't pass that when is when are we going to be able to um um have those options put in place many of the seventh and eighth graders have not transitioned successfully to the 7 to 12 school schs the high schools are too large for seventh graders More than 70% of the teachers surveyed in January of 2021 said that the 7 to2 model is not working for our students we need our seventh and eighth graders in smaller environments most all of the Westside Elementary schools are so overcrowded that learning conditions are subpar and the neighborhood districts need new boundary lines that's in this plan the wrap which superintendent Murphy has created is the strongest plan for our District's unhoused

170youth of any District in the state of Ohio and maybe of the country it will become a model if as we move forward but it has to happen now our city City doesn't have enough affordable housing and we have too many students who are homeless CPS is ALS also risking the state's forced takeover of under enrolled school buildings under the proposed legislation if you have not read the forom foundation report about under enrolled and underc capacity schools you are um not understanding where our state is going the forom foundation is directing our state if this happens CPS will lose buildings to private or Charter Schools this is reality as much as some people don't want to believe it but maybe some people don't care if we lose buildings to Charters and vouchers and private schools

171we need a healthy growing CPS which is vital for our community our families our students and our teachers if there are not changes being made in some buildings we're that's why we have a huge turnover of Staff the board must move forward with most of the decisions in this plan and they can't keep pushing the can down the road another year there have been too many years that we have not taken action to make sure things are corrected I know that a lot of things in this plan go all the way back to the year um 20 2017 and this is something that we our students need in order to be successful the students who are in the the Pilot School this year they're of middle middle school they're doing great the teachers have said

172that the students have had probably one of the most positive experiences that they have seen in the last 20 years so as we're moving forward I think we need to make sure that we're making decisions that are right for our students and I think that we need to make sure that we are looking at our students in a developmental manner so that they are not lost in all of the chaos the other thing that is happening is we need to have a board coming together so that these decisions are um can be moved on I know that some board members who are against any plan or any change haven't been around that long but I think that some of the some of them have to start thinking about the overall District as we try to

173move forward thank you I would like to thank all of our speakers both our inperson and our online speakers for coming out this evening um thank you for sharing all of your concerns and we are now at the close of hearing of the public thank you uh vice president thanks to everyone that's uh participated tonight both virtually and in person it's greatly appreciated um by the board and certainly by the administration uh we'll go on to the next part of our uh meeting which is the first presentation uh and the first presentation is from um superintendent Murphy thank you madam president my presentation will be relatively short uh Rob if you go ahead uh there's two simple slides and the first uh basically is a reminder about the board and the adoc resolution directives and

174then the second is simply a reminder about the board at hoc resolution actions that I believe that my senior leadership team and I have worked really hard uh to put together and to address everything that uh was requested of us in reviewing the plan that has been something worked on for over an 18month period of time and I understand I understand fully and appreciate everything that has been shared not only today but since uh our initial public conversation about this work in October I take it very seriously and I'm actually very humbled to be in the seat and to be able to work with everybody uh in this room today and everyone who has anything to do uh with Cincinnati public schools and outside of the fact that the federal government and the state government

175has interesting plans being discussed uh for public education I I do acknowledge the many great things that are happening in our school district that I am extremely proud of and might be one of the first second or third people to shout from the rooftop any celebration about our school district um no one can say anything to me negative about Cincinnati public schools without some type of response we do know that we have students experiencing homelessness and having worked with re Beach over a long period of time and her team and thank you to those who make coat donations to those young people today uh I do know that we talked many times about how we're grateful for cars that kids have to sleep in when that was so critically concerning a few years ago but

176now even of Greater concern are the kids who are sleeping under bridges children sleeping under bridges we have to help them we also know that we have middle school students who have needs that are different than the needs that are developed and created in K8 buildings and in 712 buildings our team is ready to put that in place for the young people we also know if you visit our schools we have an Ever growing population of multilanguage Learners we have to address our approach to our mult multi language Learners and we can't wait 30 more days we can't wait 60 more days we have to begin how we're doing business with them today it's just not fair and I'm not talking about adults in each of these cases I am talking about children I visit

177schoolhouses where classrooms have 12 children and it's great it's great and the teachers are doing a marvelous job they're doing a fantastic job I am so proud of them however financially we can't continue to do business like that and then have classrooms with 30 32 34 children we have to address it I know it's hard I'll be right there working with you on whatever might be accepted and is my wish desire goal that everything presented today is accepted we have programming that our children our families have demanded for years it took us many years to get junior rltc in aen high school for young people it took a long time just to get one teacher we're blessed to have two but we have high schools and young people who are asking for junior rooc opportunities

178in their building this plan will allow that to happen yes Clark monasa is an amazing in demand program of 7 through 12 12 grade students I have done my homework there is nothing about their accreditation process that says it's mandatory to have seventh and eighth grade I know you like it I know you appreciate your community I know you want your community to stay together but right now on the east side of town I have 90 students who would like a see that your beautiful lovely amazing school who I can't give them that but there is a way to do it there is a way and it's in this plan and it does listen to what has been shared with us over the last few months hearing your public cry now the only thing I

179will say as just a human being for those who share with us in a respectful way I appreciate it and I know you're frustrated I know you want your school and this school board I know you want to do what is absolutely best for the citizens you serve I do too that's it that's all thank you superintendent Murphy uh our second uh presentation uh tonight is from our Treasurer good evening everyone good evening I've been working on as the board is having conversations about the growth and the future of the district district and we have upcoming levies that are coming up for Renewal we have some financial needs um we've been working on a long-term financial plan to help support what the board decides to do so some of this is um repetitive in nature

180but it's important for the public in every opportunity will present it for the the public to understand so go ahead Rob thank you so what I'm about to share with you and the growth Plan cost analysis assumes that we strictly adhere to our staffing formulas um the way they are and that enrollment remains stable so that in the reorganization plan if students shift cost will change right for example our currently in our Collective Bing agreement the Staffing uh formula for K3 classrooms is a teacher for every 18 students when you get to the 19th student in a classroom you add a pair of professional to that classroom when you get to the 26 student you take the par out add a teacher divide the class into two teachers two classes so subtle shifts of kids

181from one building to another would could drive changes in some of these analysis and then um of course we we'll be negotiating some new agreements that may drive some of the changes as well so numbers that are shared today are going to change the plan is fluid um and so don't get hung up on a specific number or not keep keep going so this is a picture of and it's in millions of dollars of the longterm financing needs to support operations the first line on that is the growth plan the way it was presented recently um and that was shared on November 18th so in the first year we were anticipating a savings in operational cost it's about $5 million in cost to to to move everybody to buy lockers and and Furniture um but

182there was going to be Savings in Staffing because you're consolidating buildings you're able to staff more efficiently and that's comparing the projected students in that plan with the Staffing formuls compared to how we're staffed today so but going forward there will be recurring costs specifically um I think the 700,000 represented the expansion in the tech programs and those staff um also the board is talking about a taking on the crossing guards from the city of Cincinnati and we anticipate an increase in that budget um technology um and curriculum adoptions have five-year Cycles three to fiveyear Cycles these dollars represent things that are not currently in the budget but they're coming up and they need to be done so they were funded some of these dollars were funded by other funding sources that are no longer

183with us and namely the Sesser dollars um and so we have to decide if we're going to continue on those cycles and updating the curriculum adoptions and Technology we have to seek new money and then once again we don't know what the negotiations any cost changes that that might happen so sitting today operational we need about $12 million a year on top of what we have um that represents 1.4 million that will change based on your votes tonight moving forward the growth plan will change um and some of the negotiating Staffing formulas may change as well next slide so the long-term non-operational conversations I want to clear up a lot of confusion over the $200 million cost please do first so that was the what I just said was part one or actually phase two

184of the growth plan part two of my conversation is we have a billion dollar facility master plan that we've updated um this that our community very generously invested in those buildings are 20 years old now and they need roofs and chillers and hva system upgrades and so there's a plan A Five-Year Plan of about $170 million divided up by five years and so that we have an opportunity we cannot absorb that into our general operating budget so uh we need find to find new money for that and there's an opportunity to do a permanent Improvement Levy which which allows you to do construction Remodeling and to um support assets of 5 years or longer if they're they lifetime so if you were to do a permanent Improvement Levy to support that effort to bring in

185the revenue stream that's needed to support those um and there's a huge file on this that shows school by school project by project anyway that that would represent about four Mills of a pi Levy permanent Improvement Levy part three of the growth plan and Beyond and we have no idea when what's going to get adopted and when it will happen if you even started a building today it wouldn't get finished for two years okay so that the 200 million is new money of Seven Pro projects not just one or two but it's seven and they're listed here these are the estimates of what they would cost to support the programming the superintendent was recommending so let me just repeat myself we have an operational need we have a long-term term non-operational but it's the to

186support the facility repair plan and then we have new construction depending on where we go with grow the growth three and Beyond uh the bond Levy so it oper the bond Levy operates a little bit different than other levies so the other levies bring in an annual revenue stream a bond Levy you get the money up front and then the millage is based on the principal and interest that's needed to pay the bonds back over that life cycle excuse me um okay next slide so this is what we lovingly call the spaghetti or the slinky slide um it shows you the current fixed sum levies that we have the green line represents the $65 million Levy that's on a 10-year cycle that's coming up for in 28 the Blue Line represents the $48 million fix

187some Levy that also includes the $15 million setus guide for the um expansion of preschool that's coming up next November and we have some actions that we have to take in order to make that happen um the hardest decision is going to be what do you do with the $15 million preschool expansion because CPS and CPP the Sensei preschool promise have collectively outgrown the $15 million set aside so if we continue to fund that we'll be taking money out of the K12 operations to fund that the Ohio does not support regular red preschool financially they only support preschools with disability ities so we have a ton of Grants um and the $15 billion set aside is last dollar in so we apply all our grant state and federal grant money first tuition paying um Head

188Start early childhood there's a ton of them out there um and then we apply the general fund money after that so we have to decide what to do with that $5 million in this Levy um the orange slide represents the last Levy that was renewed at 52.5 million we we changed that to a 10-year cycle and that will be renewed in 32 I do want to point out that the current Bond Levy that supported the $480 million that supported the um facility master plan the last payment on that debt um is December 1st of 2031 I've received two different pieces of guidance one that says you can do a new Bond Levy in 30 one year in advance but tonight I heard you could you could possibly do it three years in advance so I

189need to do some more research on that um but that's an opportunity moving forward um next slide so this is the same picture but we've added um Chris Burkhart chief operations officer Burkhart and I kind of married our slides together the timeline and when a pi might come in so you have a levy on the ballot on 25 you can do a pi in either to sometime in 26 or 27 um and then we're investigating the Levy um you can't renew a bond Levy it's a new Levy but you can replace the old one with the new Levy um I'm also noting on there like U when board members are up for elction when City council's for election so you can kind of plan when you want to go onto the uh ballot again um

190next slide so board actions that are necessary and we talked about this at the Saturday uh Workshop um a couple months ago ago so we had the $48 million fix some Levy you can renew it as it is as a 5year cycle um you can renew it as a 10e cycle or you can and do either one of those and increase it you have to have your first resolution board resolution adopted on your July by your July 14th board meeting um and the resolution States the need for Levy we send that resolution to Hamilton County Auditor they certify the millage and the ballot line language they have 10 days to do that they send it back so your second resolution adopting that ballot language in the millage has to be done by August 4th um

191and we have to submit to the Hamilton County Board of Education I'm sorry Board of Elections by August 6 it's 90 days before election day so once you do that uh legal councel Dan and I will go over to and file our paperwork with the Hamilton County Board of Elections um as you're planning moving forward we need to decide what what to do to fund the growth plan and Beyond right so the mixture of operational Levy Pi Levy Bond Levy and other things we're investigating the possibility of an income tax levy um and so um we'll keep those conversations going but I want to keep this out in front so you realize your timelines the last time we did a a levy we did the first resolution in April and the second one in May

192and we were done and so we had plenty of time to do this and and have conversations about what's the best thing for the district in what order so I think that's the last slide so thank you question wner yes uh do board members have any questions for either the superintendent or the treasurer at this time uh Mr Lindy thanks Miss Bolton um I have a question for the treasure and I really appreciate the numbers so thank you um could we go back to the slide that has the um negative 1.4 and then the 7s going across the top row great um I had two questions so one I want to just make sure I'm understanding that top row with the growth plan so everything we heard from the 50 plus speakers tonight was about

193the phase two of the growth plan um and that's just this top row um so there there's nothing in that cross and guards technology curriculum adoption none none of that is the phase two of the growth and sustainability plan it's just the top row okay and then if I'm trying to figure out does the growth plan save Cincinnati public schools money I just want to check my math when I'm looking at the top row it looks like it saves money in the first year but by the time you hit the third year it's actually making our costs more expensive and I just wanted to make sure I was I wasn't I get these things wrong sometime I wanted to make sure I was following it so if you the Savings in the first first year

194will pay for several years and and actually depending on how you vote that CH that savings is going to change it's already changed based on some of the recommendations that have come through but it's so fluid um we were waiting to see what you were the board was going to settle on to go out and then redo it again um because one change of one bundle might have an impact on a different bundle so and that that's really helpful so let me interrupt you Sor that's why I said don't get married to those numbers yet but there is a savings in transportation estimated and a savings in Staffing because you're able to staff um the middle schools and the elementary schools when you're we have 30 buildings that are under the 450 kids enrolled and

195we just we can't get enough resources out there because we can't um manage the human capital well enough efficiently it's really helpful and I just want to make sure I'm I'm going to try to say back what I think I'm hearing to make sure understand it there are a lot of unknowns including what gets approved tonight or what doesn't get approved tonight there's opportunity for savings there's opportunities for increases so it it could be the fact that this proposal does save the district some money it could be that it's cost neutral it could be that it's actually more expensive and and we at this point don't know which of those three scenarios we're in that's corre correct because it's all based on human behavior and we can't always predict human behavior that's okay um and

196then the second question I wanted to ask was um if we go back a couple meetings ago where we approved our five-year forecast um it it uh doesn't look great uh and that's nobody's fault we're just at the end of a levy cycle um and so we're we're we're in a situation where we're going to see some real budget challenges I think even in this planning year that we're doing for next year correct and I was just trying to size those so if if we take if we make the assumption that just take the growth plan out of it for a second and we assume that we get renewals in the future um but we but don't assume any new money from like an increase how much would we have to take out of our

197costs in order to have a positive cash flow over our five-year forecast does that question make sense it makes perfect sense um I don't I don't want to quote a number I don't have it in front of me but I will tell you this um if we do nothing differently our operational budget goes up by $7 million simply because of by how much 7 million 7 million yeah if um and that's per year 7 million for next year but it averages it depend you it depends on retirees and new hires and stuff like that but um next year would be about $7 million just to pay for step increases so and that's without a cost of living increase it's great I think we should do cost living increases I think they're good things I think

198we should reward our employees I appreciate the fact that they work here but but I'm sorry to interrupt you but we have to stop spending on some things to pay for those things we don't have the cash reserves to continue growing the budget I agree okay 100% I think what I was just trying to make sure I understood was if we think over maybe a three-year time period we're going to see an additional need to find $7 million a year just to keep up with our current obligations and the proposal for the growth plan might save us a little it might be cost neutral or it might cost us more it depends on what you vote on but yes yeah okay thank you true Mr Craig um so again I want to thank um thank

199both of you for for bringing information to us again today um I think one of the things I wanted to make sure that we're very clear about um is there are certain assumptions that we make as part of the finance um that we put into the growth plan right and so some of the those assumptions are about the enrollment numbers uh that we would see in those enrollment patterns um and I and I I guess one of the things that is of concern that I think is just the reality of unfortunately living in the state of Ohio right now with education is that enrollment numbers can be very fickle because everything tells families that we'll get more benefits from the state if you're not in a public school district right like the the amount that

200the state will pay to the schools that are not public schools for them to educate the kids is more than what they pay to the public schools it's it's a sad reality of what our state legislature has put for um and I think that is a struggle for a district like ours though because we are as you mentioned a lot of this is so contingent upon enrollment numbers kind of following a pattern because at some schools you could have a shift of five students at a particular grade level have a significant effect and in another school you could have a shift of five students have no effect right on on the Staffing on what their needs are at that particular grade and that that idea and so um I think it's important for us to

201to recognize that as as we look at the growth plan I did want to just highlight a couple of things though that I think is important for folks to recognize and we've talked about it in budget and finance um uh Dr Moffet and and board Lindy and I talked about this um the things like the crossing guards the things like technology payments we H we you know somewhat put off or things like that we did to balance this year's budget we somewhat did on the premise that we would some point down the line still have to pay these costs right um and I I guess one thing I would worry about and what we're looking at from the numbers um on the chart there is just that we potentially have a number of figures that

202even if everything we if we passed everything we still got $12 million without looking at any of the negotiations that we sub toin in the budget and so I think that's one of those things that we also have to be just recognizing that the conversation doesn't end today about what we do from a budget standpoint the conversation still requires us to find another 12 at the least million dollars in this year coming up Year's budget to even just carry on the cost right um and so I just I I want us to keep that in mind because I do think in some ways folks think this conversation ends with how our votes end today reality is is the start of the conversation and that there's going to be other things that we're going to have

203to look at as a District on how we operate that we're going to have to change because there's no there's absolutely zero way we can pay for $12 million just operating the same way we do above what we already are spending um the last thing I will just say and I think it I did see uh council member Al be here uh earlier and I think she had to leave out but I do want us to continue the conversation with our part with our uh City Council Members because I do think some of the cost like the crossing guards while it's appreciative that we are taking on this and again I welcome anyone to come and apply and take on some these responsibilities to make sure our kids get in and out of the school

204safely the reality is that this is just a higher cost for us to take on some of these things um I look at nursing as a great example of this I think cross guards is another example but the reality is that we're taking on cost of stuff that districts and other places don't have to carry and I and I I say that really stress the fact that we talk about our partners we talk about the folks in our community and we've seen a lot of them here a lot of folks who bring in coats to to our schools who are out here tutoring who are in our schools every single day I I just I in some ways wish we had a little bit more support for the things that make our schools safe the

205things that get our kids to school safely from those folks who preach to us in board meetings that we must do more to to be safe for our kids um so I mean I it's a soap box I've been on before and I won't stay on it so but I just want to stress that and then the third thing I wanted to say about our our our to to the superintendent with regards to the plan the growth plan uh two I know we have a lot of we've had a lot of voices come in and talk about our community support we've had a lot of people on this board talk about how much we need to have community members at the table we need to have community members we need to listen to our community

206members we need to listen to those people who partner with our schools and partner with everybody and and I I don't worry necessarily that all of a sudden we do this growth plan too and everything in a district falls apart but I worry that we don't succeed in the way we could and I and I I don't use I'm not going to use hyper you know hyperbolic language with regards to that this is the end of the district kind of deal but I do think it's a reality to say that a thousand student shift is a big shift if we had that or a 500 student shift would be a big shift if we had that and I and I what I worry about is is these marginal changes to our enrollment numbers these marginal

207changes that that could happen because parents will make decisions that are outside of our control could have a significant effect on both our staffing but also on the money that the little bit of money that the state seems to be fit to give us each year um and so I just worry about that because again I think we are taking an opportunity here with something like for instance the dawn Academy there a conversation that we we had at the at last Monday that's a great opportunity for us to come in and help some students get education they were not going to get this year it may not get next year based on what that that Charter was doing and a number of Charters have had this happen throughout our time here the struggle is that

208a lot of those students are some of the students who need more than than than than other students we have and so we need to figure out ways to also think about what programming and what resources we're providing in the schools to really look at that next level so I I will throw that out there and it's just my thoughts for now thank you chairman Craig other board members have any comments or uh questions for either the superintendent or the treasurer member map yes so uh thank you Treasurer Wagner for this presentation so I'm just really trying to process all the information that you shared and so just want to ask directly in terms of uh what we have um as our cash balance presently do we have the available funds to support potentially the

209growth plan for phase two it depends on what parts you vote on what gets passed so um because the original plan projected as savings so there was some expenditures that go into supporting the plan to make it happen but we estimated around $4.5 million in savings of staff and U $1.8 million Savings of Transportation so I would say given that plan and if it's l in a whole then yes we do have the funds to support it so what I believe I'm hearing you say directly is that if what we are envisioning is um implemented then we would have the funds available however if not then we ultimately wouldn't have the funds to support this growth plan so there's a lot of unknown variables is what you're saying to us is that is that what

210I'm the unknown Vari a is what you're going to improve and what you're not going to improve as a board and so once that final when once that plan gets blessed tonight if you're going to vote on it tonight um then and you pick five out of the 10 things I'm just making numbers up but if you if you prove half the plan that'll change those estimates and we'll have to come back and share that um as an update next time okay so I guess as I'm hearing it is we don't know specifically if we have the funds available ultimately we are hoping based off of what is approved or what's not approved that this could be support it so the the way the plan is recommended from the superintendent and her team the fun

211we do we can do it but if you break it into parts that might have a lot a lot of the bundles are dependent on each other so if you start breaking it apart then my cost estimates might change okay uh the the next question that I have is around um the Staffing can you explain the Staffing formula a little bit more I know that you said it could potentially be a $4.5 million doll savings but if we so what that mean we are losing we would be losing staff because the way I see the plan being written is we are shuffling staff around so how I guess are we saving on so we'd be losing positions not necessarily people okay go into more detail about that because I'm not tracking with you and I

212want to make sure I'm tracking we have a we have a lot of vacancies so it doesn't necessarily mean that people would lose jobs but we would be reducing positions in the budget that are funded now but they're not filled or they're filled by a substitute but um so one example is when you consolidate when you take something eighth graders from several buildings and you consolid into one building then you're gaining cost efficiencies because you're able to um fill the classrooms more efficiently with the same or less teachers so it's the teachers the Paras the assistant principles counselors they're all formulaic and they're driven off of enrollment at each building so if you can fill the buildings to be more efficient then you can staff them more efficiently and gain savings that way okay all

213right thank you for that and then uh two more questions um so so with the um the levy the permanent Improvement Levy what are the implications or so one how would this positively impact I guess the growth plan and then if the levy does not pass what are those implications as it pertains to this plan so the per permanent Improvement Levy it was my recommendation to fund the facility repair plan okay means we don't if it doesn't pass we won't have money to do new roofs chillers HVAC systems and painting and carpet replayer um stuff like that okay um it supports the growth plan because you're upgrading the buildings to and there's some things that are safety precautions like you you can't have leaky roofs um um security doors security systems need to be updated

214um and so it supports the growth plan and that you have safe and updated buildings for your the students to attend okay so it's updating the facilities but that me the growth plan is also about from my understanding making sure that we have we're meeting those uh utilization requirements right so it's not in any way um speaking to how our students are our buildings are enrolled but it is speaking to the repairs yeah the facility repair plan is is strictly about making sure the buildings stay maintained and supported and safety issues are are taken care of and that that we lengthen the life of the building the growth plan is about the use of the building okay and then lastly my um other question is around the cops um process can you speak about that

215um for myself and everyone is here sure so a cops is a financial tool it stands for certificates of participation and it's a you can borrow money um and you it acts like a capital lease so you your buildings in your land is be is collateral it's like a second mortgage so you get money um from the market to F like we use the cops to buy the mercy building and renovate it and so that became gamble high school monory high school um but you had so you have pay the money back and you take the money out of your operational budget to pay that lease payment but you have there's rules around it um you have three years to spend the money from start to finish or the IRS will fine you because it's

216um the bonds that are sold on the market are tax deductible and if you don't spend it in the time that you intend to spend it then you get fined um and you can't use it on a property that's already encumbered like we would not be able to use it at gamble monory high school because it's already encumbered under the cops that we're still paying on does that make sense so we're a little bit limited on that okay so with that how many buildings do we actually have exactly that um are under the cops uh plan do you know uh off top of my head I don't know probably 12 to 14 because we used a lot of cops to help finish the facility master plan okay and so the reason I'm asking that because

217I'm interested in knowing how much money are we still expected to pay back on those particular buildings and um because that would be a yearly payment correct that we would have to uh pay yeah so at the next board meeting I'll bring a schedule of all the cops so that everybody can see it okay because I would like to know how it connects to but here's the here's the big difference we need everybody needs to understand the the payment on that cops has to come out of your operating budget so you're going to be cutting something to pay make that payment whereas a levy is a new stream of money that comes in does that make sense yes so we would have to cut something to make these cops pay P um I will be

218interested in knowing again how this aligns with the growth plan as well so if you were to use some cops to help fund the growth plan then you would have three years to do it and it can only be done on Renovations or new construction okay so not on reconfiguring bathrooms or locker rooms or whatever um so you have to be really careful about that um and you can structure the payback period with done it differently based on the market so um I will I'll do a presentation on Cops at the next meeting that will go into what our current inventory of cops are what our payments are and what the long-term um the timing okay that help thank you I appreciate that other comments other questions from uh board members before we move on

219uh Dr Mett so I have a question for you would we be needing a would you recommending a pi Levy if there was a no growth plan yes so the need for the pi Levy would be there regardless of the growth plan or not yes and if you recall we started these conversations maybe about two years ago um during a fact finding um it was right at the tail end of Co I think well we started presenting the need for reinvesting in our buildings I thought that so so and also we talked about cops significantly last year and maybe the year before would um and we kind of took that off the table a little bit or let me just say we stopped discussing it so um you had given us a presentation before about

220the buildings that were encumbered and how much we would be eligible for I think I asked the question then about being able to encumber vacant Lots because we have quite a few of those and I think we could not do that would we be looking at cops as an option or even explor in that if there were no gr growth plan or phase plan so the the facility repair plan is $170 million and it's going to continue to grow because cost construction costs keep going up inflation goes up right so 170 million over fiveyear period $170 million we couldn't do it in this in the you have to do it in Pockets because remember you have that three-year window so you can't do it over a 5year period right so you'd have to do it

221in versions and you have to cut things in order to pay for those payments um if I remember correctly there was at one point we were talking about a $70 million cops and that was going to be about a $6 million annual payment that you would have to cut of the budget to make that payment so double that gotcha um my another question around the preschool um so we need to make a decision with regard to the levy around renewal um increase or and all of that needs to begin at the beginning of the year um well I'm encouraging to have those conversations now because it's part of this larger package and so you have some opportunities to strategize on how to do that um but the $48 million Levy is coming up for in

222November yes okay and then l uh we got I think we did adjust ASG with uh Cincinnati preschool promise around um do Cincinnati preschool promise see a need to increase that or is that just what we're kind of ideating I know that they've expressed that they are using their monies efficiently but has there been any discussion around the need to increase that Levy for even them well collectively our budgets are $20 million so they would I'm I want to speak for them I haven't had that I haven't asked that dire question directly to them but if we don't then they're going to have to significantly shave back because we are their almost their only source of income okay so if that Levy does not pass that directly impacts the CI preschool promise and their ability

223to provide services for students in a disastrous way yes okay okay thank you I just can I just make one more comment about reminding the L that we're talking about the fixed sum levies they do not increase with property values um as property values went up they're fixed some and that's the definition we get $48 million whether property values go up what happens is our state revenue goes down when property values go up and because we become it's part of our wealth index we become wealthier district and so it really our state share which was 42 cents on the dollar last year dropped to 36 Cents this year because our property value went up and so um we are now down to receiving about $3,000 per student for base cost and um where the base

224cost calculator is at $88,000 per student so instead of getting 8,000 per kid for the state from the state we're getting 3,000 and um the local has to make up the difference well we did do a just ASG last week so all of those around school funding are recorded um for for people to see I just wanted to and there's an animated whiteboard that explains that the funing formula too so if you go on our website and watch any other questions or comments for either the superintendent or the treasurer thank you we're going to go to the next part of our uh meeting and it it sounds like it's going to be awful but we're going to expedite this uh by taking uh a some a little bit of privilege uh from a standpoint of

225motions there are about 20 items because the board had suggested that they would like to see if you um uh can think about this of seeing things in line item meaning people having to vote on specific things there's about 20 that are very specific they'll be by virtue of a motion and then there are the 10 uh bundles which we've all become very familiar with the the bundles and so we'll uh do that and the super the uh superintendent will be doing some of the requesting which will then make in we will make into a motion and uh be great to have a second without anybody thinking about it and then we can do the roll call but uh I think there's a total of 32 or something yes ma'am before you do that I

226think you have a resolution amending board policy first yes uh I I would really like to say that for later later got it um and U just because the people are kind of waiting but thank you um so we'll start I think um superintendent Murphy you have the first request that I will then turn into a motion and wait for a second and then they will do a vote we're going to see how we can do this yes ma'am so the administration is seeking the board's approval to allow me to enter into conversations with the city and in particular since they Recreation Commission on the possibility of any land Swap and furthermore anything around youth employment particularly a junior Co-op and a focus on the city's fire cadet police cadet internship program that's a request

227and I'll turn that as a board member into a motion do I have a second to approve that request second thank you Mr Crossett is there any discussion or question back up uh Mr Lindy I'm just tring to make sure I'm following along the motion that we're currently voting on is where is it so sum of phase two has to do with the public service Academy I just looking for which is it a slide or is it on the I think you have the wrong thing up Rob it's the other form it's the second portion attachment in board dos keep going scroll down right number one number one right there yes we're on the same page we got it do you have it yet yeah I've got it um so I I do have if

228we're we're in discussion now for a motion on a motion in a second if you have a question for the superintendent uh about these uh uh approaches you'll recall that uh the uh Public Safety um uh Academy has been part of the um growth plan go ahead thanks I um I do not support the plan that is being proposed tonight I'll be voting against I think probably all of these motions okay and I want to use my two minutes here to be really clear about why and then I probably will not say a ton left as we go through the rest of the meeting but I reserve the right to change my mind sure so um first off it's just important to get on the table how highly disruptive this proposal is it would impact

229up to 15,000 children that's 43% of the school district's enrollment or more than two out of every five children if we're going to do something on that scale we owe it to families we owe it to teachers and we owe it to taxpayers to have really really good reasons we don't why is it that we need to make these changes I've really struggled to figure this out because I keep hearing different explanations first is it was that we have to make these changes for financial reasons the argument was that we couldn't rightsize the district's finances unless we address under enrolled schools that sounds like a pretty compelling reason to me after all we can't bankrupt the district but when you check the numbers this plan does not address our financial challenges we heard this just

230a few minutes ago at a minimum we have a $7 million gap in our budget just for this year that Gap will likely be bigger if we pass any kind of cola or raise and that Gap will grow over time the plan itself over a 5year time period adds expenses to our budget this is an elective procedure we would be choosing to do something that does not address our long-term Financial challenges our reason can't be Financial because the numbers don't add up so what's our reason if it isn't financial well just about a month ago the reason for the proposed changes shifted it wasn't our financials anymore it was the risk that we'd lose buildings to Charter Schools this is not about s SP 295 which is currently working its way through the state house

231and isn't yet law I'll come back to that in a second the second proposed rationale was about an older law that's been around for over a decade and that requires districts to offer underutilized buildings to Charter Schools but again uh if you poke at this the falls apart the law says that buildings with utilization under 60% need to be offered to Charter Schools I think we have very strong arguments that we make excellent use of our buildings using almost every room in every building for instructional purposes if the state comes after us I say let us prove them wrong in court I think we can show that we safely pass the 60% threshold there is virtually no realistic threat under current state law that we lose our buildings to Charter Schools unless we independently decide

232to sell them so it's my last point if this isn't about our financials because the savings from this massive disruption barely scratch the surface of our challenges and if it isn't about being forced to sell underutilized buildings to Charter Schools what is it well there was a third idea that's come up just in the last few weeks and that's current that's the current bill making its way through the state house this s295 this bill which has not passed which may not pass and hasn't even finished being written could force some school buildings to be sold when there is chronically low academic performance I find it hard to believe that a bill that just started in the past few weeks could have been the motivating reason all along for a plan that started in a committee

233two years ago but let's take the legislation seriously for a moment let's assume it passes in its current form I have to say that I agree with the head of the NAACP tonight shouldn't our Focus be on improving the academic performance of those schools rather than shuffling the students around to avoid detection to recap there are ma these are massive changes which impact 15,000 students which constitute 43% of our district if we're going to do that we need really good reasons as I've tried to show I don't believe that we have them and in fact the reasons offered keep changing ultimately last paragraph decisions like this one are about whether we are strengthening public trust or eroding it if we want to ask for more money in a future Levy which I think we will

234will need to do sooner rather than later we need to be doing everything we can to strengthen public trust this kind of decision-making with reasons that don't hold up and that keep changing does the opposite thank you thank you Mr Lindy any other okay uh Mr Craig I just wanted a quick question with regards to the specifics that are listed in this particular motion the idea is simply to begin the talks that anything that would a come of those talks would still need to come before the board before anything was finalized um and then I would want to also um I have a lot of concerns with land swaps in that I don't necessarily know that these things will work in our benefit at the end of the day because I don't know that the

235city will fairly treat us in any of these discussions based on their past practices with us right now so um while I am inclined to support opening conversations I want us to also recognize that there are a lot of other things that we are also negotiating with the city about that I think to be quite honest we need to hold them more accountable for and so even if we're doing these land swaps I think or having these kind of discussions I would hope that we would do that in the in the premise that the city needs to invest in our school district more than they are currently doing and I have the distinct concerns with like city city council members saying things in public and on forums that seems to be opposite of what the

236city manager says in private discussions with us and I'm very concerned that that will be what we will see in some of these cases so I I again might be more inclined to support opening those talks but I would just also ask that as you're having those talks really we need to hold them to the fire for things that we no other District pays for crossing guards I mean come on like this is ridiculous that they're like oh we won't even we got to beg them to train our crossing guards so like I if they're going to be a partner I'm all four us having discussions with that but let's really hold them to the fire to make them a true partner thank you Mr Craig vice president yes I was just going to say

237that I would be in support of supporting this particular piece because it says that it's just to begin conversations whether it's sitting down with the city whether it's sitting down with the CRC but in the end it's talking about developing a Cincinnati Junior Co-op program expanding youth employment and additionally with the city police and fire cadet so I would be in support of having those conversations getting those things started I know that there is a conversation of land swaps and exploration of developing facilities but I would be in support of having those actual conversations you can't start speaking or talking about anything if you're not at the table so I think that that would be a good idea to start with that thank you very much roll call Mr Craig uh yes Mr Crossett yes

238Mr Lindy no miss m no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes and the second uh is a board motion uh the board has recognized the creation of three categories of enrollment pools Citywide East and West divisions and corridors the board would like to assign to the administration the responsibility to review the possibility of placing Parker Woods monor and Taft Elementary in the central Corridor officially and mount Ary and Chase in the west Corridor and we hope that those changes would allow us uh to uh perhaps have additional seats in the west and then more particularly uh allow us to to begin to concentrate on the development of of uh the central Corridor so that's the that's the request is there a second second thank you is there any discussion about about

239that yes Dr mofin so I really do I think that this aligns with what the original intention somewhat of what the ad hoc was about um I I hear my colleague share that this that the conversation has transcended um in his opinion but the original charge of the ad hoc was to address the boundary lines and to make our district more Equitable and so um in listening to some of the concerns around over crowding building utilization and then we didn't for the boundary lines we didn't look at academic performance I think this aligns very um very well in that we talked about Mount Ary being people that are are on Hamilton Avenue can see Pleasant Hill but they have to go to mount Ary school and so I I welcome the opportunity to align the

240boundaries more efficiently so that the kids in the district um in within each Corridor can uh see more equitable distribution thank you any other comments roll call Mr oh I'm sorry I I'm only this is the way I'm going to do this so you can catch me please I'm going to look right once I'm going to look left once but I'll I'll I'll get back to thinking do both of those twice go ahead I'm sorry thank you um so I just want to provide Clarity around my decisions today as I shared at the last meeting um while I am very new to the board I appreciate being able to serve in this capacity and during my time of running I I stressed how I was committed to disrupting and dismantling the vast inequities and the

241systemic barriers in education and so I don't believe that this current plan honors the need for Equity most importantly I have not heard where it puts the students at the Forefront but what I have experienced is how this plan has been rooted in division confusion and chaos and I would like to ensure that we have engagement and so it's not that there are things that I don't support because there are absolutely things that I support I think the um the uh safety plan is something that's good for some of the schools to have with the cadets however I am about process and if the process does not start off equitably and if the process is not honored I cannot H in good faith uh support any of these so I just wanted to make that

242known to you all today thank you member Matt roll call Mr Craig uh yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you the next one is the board commits to a deliberate marketing plan focused on our presenting instructional programs and services at our school sites as well as positively messaging the agre aggregate District outcomes so it's the thing that kept coming up all the time and it has recently again is that we don't do a good enough job selling our our our schools and our district and indeed you heard it again tonight please sell our uh our great marketing capacity of the great good things that we're doing so the motion is to support really support a marketing plan to present uh

243the good news of the district is there a second second okay any questions comments vice president yes so I would just like to add a couple of comments I know when I first got on the board three years ago um I made a positive decision to visit all of the schools along with my colleagu it was enlightening to learn about all of the great programs and I'm going to say before getting on to the board I was a teacher in the district for 10 years and did not know about all of the programs that our schools had to offer and that tells me that also as a parent I didn't know about those programs so it tells me that we have an issue an issue in terms of our communication an issue in terms of

244marketing and really showcasing the great things that are going on in the district going on in each and every one of our schools each of them are special each of them have something to offer and I really think that we have to do a better job um I really want this District to rise to the standards and I want everyone to know what we have and what our students can do so I am in full support of this because it's something that is way overdue thank you vice president Weinberg uh Mr Craig I I and I I I'm trying to understand what exactly this means though um because to me this is more of a superintendent responsibility that doesn't need to be voted on um I mean ultimately I think it's the superintendent's responsibility to

245develop any marketing plan with regard to how the district operates looks and shows so I'm I'm guess I'm trying to understand what's different about the board committing something as a marketing or or or creating a marketing plan as opposed to what the superintendent's already tasked with doing for the district well I would just answer that from the standpoint of the last several years indeed our public affairs efforts have um been reduced uh over time and redirected especially during covid and then postco to spending that messaging time and those messaging dollars to get through that particular crisis I also think that the marketing piece every time there was a ad hoc meeting it would be invariably somebody saying that we don't do enough to get the enrollment up by selling the way that we are doing

246the instruction by showing the value that we have so I think it's it's it's a I think it's a commitment from the board as a direction to the uh superintendent that this is something that's going to be funded and something that's going to be prioritized well I guess in that my my second question would be like is there a funding source of that we are going to then add to whatever it's already part of the marketing Communications budget as a part of this because again I I'm all for us doing a better job of messaging and communicating and I think that's something we have to work on I really will say that I think that means we need to build the team back up for marketing Communications first because that's how you get it done

247and work with the folks and partners we have for that um but I'm not I guess I'm just not understanding why this needs to be something the board directs the superintendent to do in any other way other than like an assignment I understand and seeing it as an assignment then you know we can vote on whether or not to make it an assignment did you have a comment vice president I was just going to say I can see it as an assignment or just a directive I think what we're basically trying to say here is that the board is asking the administration to deliberately ensure that we are marketing our schools correctly and we're doing it the right way thank you uh Dr Moffett so I did have the same question like why don't we

248just make this as an assignment however what I think this does to the community and to our schools that are watching is that we are now taking the board is directing this that we are going to commit to the community for deliberate marketing of our buildings we've asked multiple times over the course of the few years to have our Mark our schools marketed better we found that lots of people didn't know that wienberg even had a rooftop garden many of our of our community don't know about the agricultural programs that we have have at many of our schools some schools like Clark and gamble have they share a rooster they have eggs Aken has coffee many in the community don't know that and so I saw this as a way to commit to the community

249that we are going to dedicate some some some attention to the superintendent and hold her accountable to marketing our schools better so I'm all in support thank you roll call Mr Craig uh I would vote no as a at this point Mr Cross yeah Mr cron yes Mr Lindy NOP miss m Dr Moffett vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton uh yes the next one uh is that the um board recognizes the following schools and they are listed before you and posted on board docs the following schools and programs as the district's only Citywide enrollment uh schools and enrollment pools this is important on two elements is that one of the things talking about finances talking about reshaping the district one of the things that has occurred over the last few years of through the administration

250and through the ad hoc efforts and what have you has been a recognition that many of the Standalone Citywide pole pools if you will that are our magnets that were under enrolled and very very costly from Transportation many of them almost a half dozen of our magnet schools have lost their magnet status uh in part because they were under enrolled and the cost per student was so great so that's a financial piece here the other piece is saying these are the items that will be Citywide but more particularly I think it's important that so we re recognize if you look at the last comment on the right side if you will the CPS Comprehensive High Schools remain Citywide high schools this was something from ad hoc that was to be discussed in the in the

251uh by the board to figure out what we wanted to do and how we wanted to approach the idea of high schools of choice for that we have tabled very frankly in part because the major reason to do it was the great cost of Transportation but that once the district moved to have their 7th through 12th graders on Metro the transportation cost regarding high schools uh became uh less of a a critical issue regarding sustainability there are still many of us who believe in neighborhood high schools and would like to go back and frankly one of the high schools that is in this uh town in this uh District that is truly a neighborhood High School remains Taft High School but the other high schools very frankly are are somewhat uh less so than that

252but it's important that we are not disrupting the high schools of choice any other comments I have a second of that motion second thank you madam Vice President are we ready for discussion yes um on this particular one I think we're missing the Chevy at gifted school I didn't see that on here as a qualifying entrance as is there a rationale or reason because I'm not sure if it's Citywide but I'll stand corrected if whoever Chevy gifted right uh younger students is not yes it's just west side yes just wanted to make sure thank you there's a good argument to do similar thing on the E side um but we'll put that on another the list okay uh roll call Mr Craig uh no I'm sorry did you say no Mr cron yes Mr Lindy

253nope map Dr mofin yeah yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes uh the next one is the board agrees that the district's Early Learning Centers and welcome centers will be established or maintained at these centers and we start with the The Early Learning Centers a rising star at ezer Charles uh Vine and the shevy at Westwood and the fourth one listed there you'll see in bold is Bramble nature campus East but that status is to be determined so that should not be considered as part of the motion to making it necessarily A Early Learning Center but rather status to be determined the welcome centers as you see are Roberts awl uh dater and Withrow is there a second second thank you uh any discussion about the Early Learning Centers or the welcome centers uh

254some of which are new as part of the plan uh for example I think with and oh go ahead I don't need to explain it uh just so I guess maybe two questions but maybe it's just one um first is this is really stepping out of the ones that have prek within the prek through 5 or prek through6 model this is just identifying those schools that are solely uh Early Learning Preschool students and then are there any schools currently that are in existence that are just prek schools that are not on the list of these here okay roll call so wait hold on I got a question what what is entailed at a Welcome Center this is the plan for the MLL students and their families for example what they experience at Roberts when they

255come into the district having someone there to work with them to help navigate through our system so that they're comfortable and they get the proper placement and if there are any additional supports that may be needed by the student all right thank you roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes uh superintendent Murphy uh I think you have number six and seven yes so this uh number six is asking for the board support of the Middle School concept specifically at the schools listed South Avendale Pleasant Hill Harwell you'll also see for each where we plan to focus uh our instructional programming South Aven with a steam Focus Pleasant Hill with a social science social justice Focus Heartwell with stem and

256early career awareness drawing from our current high school so for example aen uh 7eventh and eighth graders will pull to Pleasant Hill for example uh Woodward seventh and eighth graders as well as Hughes will pull to to South Avendale uh SCPA will remain District y prek to 12 Taft will remain districtwide 7 through 12 as both of those schools are currently organized questions comments Madam vice president so in regards to the district middle schools that you're proposing this is just a question that was or a concern that was brought up at our last board meeting regarding Sports and um programming um how would that kind of go into thank you for that question absolutely I did uh confer with our District athletic director just for certainty and he did feel very strongly for the Middle

257School process that there could be three options um three options including uh those young people playing at the elementary level those uh young people playing up at the seventh and eighth grade level or depending on the number of students the level of Interest creating our own division for those young people so you are stating that they will have a possibility to play sports they will have the opportunity and a possibility of the three different choices based on yes ma'am okay Mr Craig uh just a question of clarifying here with regards to which school which high schools are we saying would be pulled uh would would the middle school students kind of direct to I know we have Woodward and we have Heen and Hughes listed here and I know he said Taff would stay the

258same um as it currently is is 7 through 12 yes tff would remain the 7 through 12 uh SCPA would remain prek to 12 but we would be pulling from Akin 7th and e8th grade going to Pleasant Hill uh Hughes and Woodward 7th eth grade going to South Avendale and then Hardwell would be directing students where and then Heartwell Heartwell will uh remain through the eth grade okay 5 through eight that's on a slide little later okay and then I guess the one with r was previously in discussion is this going to be a separate bullet point or uh with r should also be listed 7th and eth I think that's on a slide a little later as well when with r 7 that's junior high so this is just Middle School okay sorry questions

259comments roll call oh I'm sorry Mr Crosset uh I think did we do a motion in a second oh I'm sorry my bad thank you uh so moved so moved and we have a second second thank you appreciate it moving too fast I know I'm trying to move fast any other comments for this item all right roll call thank you Mr Craig no Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map no Dr mofet yes V president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes superintendent Murphy number seven this may require a little more explanation when you see the bundles a little later but thect want to defer this one should we defer I think that might make a little bit more sense second yes happy to do that and I think that's where the people are more familiar

260with that anyway thank you for suggesting it all right we move to number eight I believe I hope uh a the board supports agreement with the Mitchell Eric commitment to mirror the IB program in the west with the IB program in the east at awl and with returning IB once again uh to with as it was first introduced in the district is there a second second thank you vice president any questions comments about I program uh on the east side roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes next one uh a 8 B the board supports Chase in Northside becoming a pk8 school in order to add medically fragile students preferably from the West mirroring the roson condom programming

261and Staffing in the East is there a second second thank you comments questions uh Mr Craig um so couple of questions with regards to this one um opening a seventh and eighth grade in this year are we expecting them to draw seventh and eighth graders from a particular or seventh graders from a particular school to fill the eighth grade for next year are we planning to have them pull from any particular school I guess asking that's I guess it's more of the thought is that where would the students who would be in the eighth grade be coming from so I think this one in particular focus is on the medically fragile children so it's hard to say exactly where they would come from except for the designation of West okay and then I guess um

262you know my my this is where I struggle with with our enrollment estimates because I know we've been previously given that there was an estimated 35 that would come that would progress up and then 35 that would be in that eighth grade group and I guess I'm just I'm a little bit concerned with where that 35 in the e8th grade year would be coming from as as a consistent number so um the the my second question to that is then also so this is primarily focused on those seventh and eighth grade who are medically fragile yes um and are there additional services that would be offered attached to that uh to that group that would be uh unique for them no this would be just driven by their individualized education plans and what that calls

263for okay vice president so I have two questions so uh clarifying Chase currently is PK through six correct that's correct okay so in this particular motion we're stating that it's becoming a PK through eight including adding medical fragile students for seventh and eighth grade just for seventh and eighth grade yes so you have your prek through six so then you're not going to move those seventh graders you're going to well to board members Craig's um question about where would those kids draw from where I'm not really necessarily interested in pulling them from another school but we do know that we need more space for medically fragile students so in the sixth grade the medically nonfragile stud The non-medically Fragile students who are in the sixth grade are they not staying at that school to go

264to the seventh grade they could choose to go to a different seventh and eighth grade building and my last question yes did the chase Community Council community lsdm see were they able to discuss this particular option so we did not discuss this with them however we have been in practice over the years of assigning these classrooms okay thanks member m so board member Weinberg asked many of my questions but I want to understand a little bit more where do the current medically fragile graders go so there they're in many different places and I don't have the list of those classrooms today okay so I'm just wondering how that what the population of that is going to look like so are we talking about adding three more classrooms do they have the space for that what's

265their enrollment are they like significantly I no they're not but are they significantly under a role that that would take them um up a lot I'm just wondering why we're putting the medically why if this is specifically targeted targeted to medically fragile is there a need for that they do have a smaller enrollment they are one of the many schools under 400 and we do think that this could then help and assist with their enrollment numbers and at the same time provide a place for needed Services thank you Jen Wagner of course has the numbers 262 children thank you is there enrollment that's their enrollment 262 and they're currently not prek but your this proposal is to make them prek yes okay so they would be adding prek classrooms and just medically fragile seventh and

266eighth grade yes right um what you look like you want to say something okay I I just wanted to understand what the what the ask is we're moving Chase did we just vote to move Chase to the west side or was that considered a okay so then that would help some of the numbers for the West Side yes and Dr MAF they do currently have preschool okay they do currently have preschool they're currently a prek through six but we're talking about making them a prek through eight with just seven and eight being medically fragile is that right okay and I know that we got we had gotten a report last year and even during ad hoc around Children's Hospital sharing with us that we needed more autism units and they I don't know exactly what

267that number was but they talked about the need for a significant increase in autism units is that part of this or is that something separate yes so we currently have a a a blend of classrooms with young people who are uh medically fragile who are have multiple disabilities in the aut and are on the autism spectrum okay so this would address some of that yes okay thank you member map yeah so my question is around I guess if I'm understanding correctly so at Chase the seven and eth grade it would become seven and eighth grade and that would be specifically the medical fragile students so students that have like autism uh diagnosis would be at this particular School in that grade band Yes okay so some of them not all of them necessar have an

268Autism diagnosis um so I I guess what is the recommendation though or how I guess my background in this or my thinking around this I had an opportunity to go to Woodford on Friday so I thank the Woodford Community for inviting me in and allowing me to see the different units and how they were structured and it really takes a lot of intentional work um to work with our medically fragile students and so what I appreciated about the way Woodford was set up is while they are um working in their designated classrooms they have an opportunity to interface with their gen gened students and peers and so what this is proposing is that they won't have the opportunity to interface with their peers at all just those that are classified as medically fragile no no

269no that's not what I'm saying um in terms of that interfacing with peers there's a grade band an AG span that they can work with other students so it's not just limited to a two-year for example age group they can they can in terms of working with other students is that what you're asking me yeah but I'm I'm speaking specifically on like a seventh and eighth grade level uh interfacing with their peers in that way so you're saying that they would interface with uh prek through 6 but they won't have the opportunity to connect with uh students in their actual grade band other than those that are classified as medically FR that's that's correct okay thank you we call Mr Craig no Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope m m no Dr mofet I'm stuck

270on this one I'm going to abstain from this one okay vice president Weinberg no president Bolton yes next one um I think uh let's see yeah the board supports additional career acmy in entrepreneurship cosmetology and auto located at least at Woodward uh Career Technical uh dependent on budget priorities is there a second second thank you questions or comments for the superintendent Mr Craig uh just really quick I know we've talked about the adding of the additional um Career Tech but I also want to stress that we need to strengthen the the Career Tech that is currently there also um because I I I think one of the struggles that we have heard from from folks talk about is that our current Career Tech needs to be uh established so that folks could go out and

271take those into the industry and meet the industry standards for coming out of the programs and I don't know that we are at I mean I think from all that we've seen as a board we are not at that level yet um so the only thing I would maybe put a caveat into that also is that we're also still strengthening the other programming opportunities and working with some of our Community Partners a little bit better as we're developing any potential other opportunities because I can tell you right now if you look around Clifton Coryville area right now uh construction is going on in high demand and there's a lot of folks who need that and the fact that if we're producing folks who are not meeting industry standards are able to walk into some of

272these apprenticeship programs I would concern me if we're doing that poorly and then we get something else that we're also doing an addition thank you Mr Craig comment other uh comments discussion um roll roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope M map no Dr Mett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes next one the board supports a review adjustment and possible expansion of career paths credentials and funding at SCPA dependent upon budget priorities is there a second I did ask for a second second second I was just ready to say if there's no second we can move on so we have a second discussions comments I just wanted again this is another one where I'm a little bit confused because I think we also have some conversation around what is

273Career Tech at SCPA and so I feel like this might be a little bit early for us given our other discussions that we might need to be having about what does this look like to be voting on it at this point um but again if that's what the the board is the will of the board but I I just am there's a there's a lot to what is Career Tech at SCPA that will make a difference as to what what do we come through with this it's our actually our my understanding it's our largest Career Tech school when you start tallying it up which is interesting we don't usually think of that as the case uh thank you vice president I was going to ask could this have possibly be seen as an assignment I

274mean can you explain a little bit more in terms of what are we exactly asking for them to come back and do I know that it says review adjustment possible expansion but like what is it that we're looking for back on this is to why it might want to come off because of what we talked about tonight uh prior to this meeting that a meeting we're going to be having on the 18th I believe a fact finding so I I mean as a motion maker and if the seconder would be okay it would be all right with me to remove this one at this time until we have better understanding and I think that's something that the treasurer mentioned to me actually personally last week I think that makes sense so we'll uh remove that

275one from uh uh the calculation and then the next one we have is the board supports the development of additional career offerings where there is demand opportunities and funding but may not be in be initial facility capacity the board supports the development of additional career offerings where there is demand opportunities and funding but may not be or have initial facility capacity I liken this to the exact same one above my ex my my understanding is that the superintendent and her team should be doing that anyway and so I would encourage and invite them to seek out additional career offerings for our students review adjust and expand any Poss possible career path so I think that that's something that should just be tabled you know not necessarily tabled but that's just an expectation okay somebody will

276retroactively that I was say I think we need to second that but yes and then what board member we can table that one if that pleases the board yep okay all right is that I hope that's okay um superintendent you have the next one I would like the board's support of the expansion of and a wider range of purpose for our Public Safety Academy uh the Public Safety Academy becomes our CPS Public Service Academy located in at least four campuses uh including fire and E EMS at West High Law Public Law police security and 911 at Withrow the expansion of additional military options um currently at Ain but expanding a little later in the bundles at sailor park is there a second second actually wait so moved is there a second you can't make a

277motion second uh Madam vice president what is the branch the branch to be determined so we already have the Army uh junior RTC we are looking at sailor park because of our uh location to a couple of airports and the river we are reaching out to Air Force we are reaching out to Navy we are reaching out to the Marines and so far so good but we'll see where we land thank you for that other questions comments Mr Craig um I just wanted to State this is another example of an area where our partnership with the city should be better and stronger um because when they made this commitment they offered in their commitment that they were going to supply some services and and backing to these programs and then they have it's certainly been

278a part of this conversation and I knew there are folks within the public service or Public Safety um officials and the people who are work with them who have been there who say they want us to be able to build these and want to be there to help develop it um but but to be truthful the city should be investing in this in some standard some substantial way because these are the future officers the future EMT workers the future firefighters the future folks will be working at the 911 re you know um operators and all these folks that we are talking about we need and so I'm just very confused as to why we have wonderful Partners from the actual officers from the actual firefighters but not so much from the actual people who make

279the doll decisions at the city I'm I'm detecting a theme uh chairman Craig not surprisingly from the finance chair uh yes Dr Moffett so I I do think I think this should this is beyond overdue because the voters passed this Public Safety Academy probably 10 years ago I I will en encourage the administration to invite and put at the table the city because this does directly impact what they have the voters have said that their ordinance would like to enforce so I'm not exactly sure I don't think we should have to pay for much of this because I think it fulfills what their commitment is supposed to be as well I do think that um I'd like to support this with the caveat that we get some commitment or we get some discussion from the

280city as well thank you any other comments oh wait one more and if we're changing it to a public service Academy instead of a Public Safety Academy ensuring that that aligns with what the voters wanted because that was the other piece they have an ordinance that they have to abide by but are we altering that what the voters wanted in doing that in any way okay the ballot language that the voters voted on roll call Mr Craig yes Mr cron yes Mr Lindy nope Mr map no Dr Moffet yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes and here's another one uh if we wanted to delay uh to the uh uh bundle we could but I'll enter this motion the board supports additional early college program at sailor Park uh mirroring the East Side Early

281College at schroer are we will will to vote on this at this time or are we interested in waiting until we get to the bundle so moved oh yes so move second Mr Craig I so and again maybe correct me if I'm wrong on this this understanding but the early college program at Schroeder is attached to a particular University right see so like is there a university that is committed to do the program with saor park or is that part of what's being asked is that we would build another partnership so I believe there is a little interest in UC see expanding don't want to step out too far I will also say we are interested in beginning some conversations with Mount St Joe okay and I guess maybe for purposes of maybe a friendly

282amendment that would get more of my support is to the board supports initiating the conversation around addition the potential additional um because my concern is that we would say yes we're going to do this and then if the universities don't play a part of it it seems kind of a worthless gesture um I would also say I know the mount has a number of programming that also may be a benefit to other things that we do and so and more specifically um athletic trainers they have a wonderful program and a health center program that might be a better I don't want to say Early College means has to mean something specific but a focus around some of the things that they might offer might be a better partnership I think they've been trying to do

283that for a couple years now um to partner with some of the schools on the West Side to provide some resources for health Healthcare resources and so when when making the motion I was thinking that we could wait till the bundle but based upon the value of the conversation that we just had I'd like to keep this as a motion and the seconded and vote on this as is if that's all right with folks um I think I think it I think the conversation just now was quite rich I I like the language that um for member Craig offered mhm to support conversations around Early College programming and other useful programms I'm I'm happy to support it with that not just specific to early college but if it's something else that benefits that particular Community

284I think that's better so open to why I didn't make the motion so um so motion maker is uh willing to amend is the seconder willing to amend and we will vote uh on this here and now as amended uh treasure Wagner do you need the uh verbage repeated or yeah repeat the amendment please yes uh Mr Craig uh just that the uh board would support the uh additional conversations around Early College programming Andor other uh programs with the local universities for the Sailor Park School school year 2627 mirroring the thank you all right roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope M map no Dr Mett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes next one the board supports school year uh 2526 Phase 2 Odell Owen Center becomes the site

285of instructional and services Services services support site for the newly designed or redesigned I guess is a better word promise Center I think it's that merger has occurred uh but I I'm not sure that we kind of officially move both of those schools and thinking in terms of one uh superintendent we have a motion and somebody will do a second and then we'll do some discussion and ask a question of you or two do I have a second for that one second thank you Mr Crossett did you want to talk about that I think I was going to say exactly what you said uh president Bolton and that is we have really done this but circling back we've gone from there were two principles uh one running the program the other running the school now

286they have been merged okay any discussion or comment about this the state law does require us to have a particular program like uh that we have as we have called The Promise Center I think we're still requ ired to do that so by law we have to have this service provided interestingly enough the state doesn't require that of all 600 in some districts just for the most part the urban 8 so take it for what it's worth and what that communicates um uh discussion yes sir and just as a clarification is this basically us voting on something that basically already exists we're just principally voting to memorialize that providing your support okay um and then the other question I have and this is I had this question we went through this before and I and

287I really just want to stress this because while I appreciate the need to have the promise Center in a location that is more centrally accessible that is is an opportunity for folks to be able to get there and actually go I have a lot of concerns with us putting the o own students in the same building with students who may have reasons that they are not in the school of their assigned location um and it's always concerned me with that because I do again I think we keep them I think the idea is that we keep them separate but I want us to still be principally thinking about like those are two separate educational build programs house within one building and that there's not the inner communication between the two programs is that right they

288are separate okay because I mean I again I I just it's still a worry of mine but I think if we're already doing it it's just memorializing what we've already been doing uh Dr M so I was going to ask a question around the same concern how does that look um like with the building I don't know what it's called where the building has like a a number like the the irn how does that look because I think that we need to do a greater job in increasing awareness around students that are assigned to the promise Center and what that looks like for parents versus the students at the at the Odell Owen Center there that building is huge so I I think that they can very easily take up a floor each and it

289be separate so that part doesn't concern me but I am kind of concerned when we mix them what does that look like they are separated in the building and as far as your question about the irin belongs to the building and not needed for for the promise Center as a program okay that is just simply housed in the building okay yeah I got you and so and we're not talking about that many students one more one more time I'm sorry we're not talking about a large number of students are we no I don't think so okay I want to say I know the promise Center is rolling because that those are students that have been removed from the building for discipline um but the lighthouse is roughly what number they have about 75 students okay

290okay thank you okay all right roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes next one the board supports the administration reviewing and providing required athletic Student Activities resource coordination and the establishment of Community Learning Centers in the reconfigured schools and school communities uh do I have a second second thank you discussion roll call Mr Craig yes Mr cron yes Mr Lindy no uh Miss map no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president bolon thank you uh the board supports the creation was that a yes oh I'm sorry yes I was trying to do this a little faster my bad okay uh the uh administ the board supports the creation of a centralized enrollment system was that a yes

291smarty sorry second second thank you discussion question Mr Craig um so I actually support this idea of centralized enrollment I think it's actually much needed um the one concern that I have is I want to make sure though as we're doing that that we're also communicating how that enrollment process would look because I do think part of the difficulty in most parent have had with enrollment is not trying to uh navigate putting their kid in the system but is in fact trying to figure out when they reach out to the school why their kid didn't get in where their kid is in the process when will they be informed and a lot of that is for me would if it comes to Central then plays into marketing Communications which we've just said yes is under

292staff so I mean I'm just I want to make sure that we're not uh that we'll also create a plan that goes with the development of that centralized and that communication out to parents about the centralized enrollment system Agreed 100% help is on the way roll call Mr Craig yes Mr cron yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mofin yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes um the next one is the administration uh yeah the administration requests the board's support for an overall administrative review and reassessment of the practices and policies that have dictated placement of all specialized units and student services department I think we've talked about um that a number of times uh in the last uh several months particularly that's my the my motion is there a second second thank

293you madam vice president discussions as what this might mean or how uh it might impact us Mr Craig is this different from what the administration asked us at the December 2nd meeting because I feel like this is the exact same thing that we kind of agreed that should be done but I don't know that I've had a a motion with support and a vote for it for clarity Workman other uh questions comments roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mfin yes vice president weberg yes president Bolton yes and superintendent Murphy this one I'm very excited about I should have left the commentary out however uh don I shared with you I believe at the last meeting Don community school has approached us by potential partnership so has

294the Martha mcdermit monory school would like to have your permission to engage in conversation with both of these schools uh I'll make the motion is there a second to the request by the superintendent second there's a lot my does everybody want to suck at that one uh so discussion questions who has some questions about what this might mean or any guidance to offer the superintendent if this passes I will share that I had an opportunity to speak to former board members including Senator um Ingram and I shared with you what she suggested she suggested that CPS should identify which students the number changes but which students are CPS I guess eligible students and um reach out to those students anyway so I think this just gives the marching orders for this to begin to happen

295and um I definitely support it so that we can support the learning of students from Dawn and a little background can you give us a little bit of background about the Martha mcdermit monory school that's I know where that is but I want the public to know where that is yes ma'am so the they came to us under a different name uh a little while ago however they now have their own 403c they all they now have their own identity and are looking for a home and that's the Xavier University monaster is that right or maybe I wasn't supped to say that but maybe it was it was former former so this would give um you the ability to enter into discussions around and the dawn school okay thank you any questions comments just a

296comment yes sorry thank you um just a comment so I fully support um making sure that there's conversation around Don as well as the uh monory lab uh school because I think all students should have access um and and um I'm hopeful that they can have the support that they need but still I just wanted to go on record and saying because it has become a part of the growth plan I will be saying no to the vote thank you member Mt any Mr Craig I I just wanted to also say that if we can also add as part of the administration um that we also look at the budget implications of those students coming in because I do have a concern with if for instance we're taking on additional costs that either we're not

297going to get funding from the state for or that or for instance if some of the students are out of the district there's potential implications from that as well or those type of things and then I guess the second part is if they're going to remain separate entities I think we do need to figure out the financial structure to that so I would just invite maybe the the treasurer's office to be a part of that yes definition of administration did um chairman Craig did you want to make an amendment to the motion I guess maybe just a clarifying that Administration includes the treasurer's office as well as sounds instructional Administration I've already been invited uh that sounds good I do have a quick question though for the dawn students um is our our Aspire or

298our adult ed program possibly a beneficiary of this or that I'm not sure who gets to be in what schools obviously um our digital academy or other schools what so d does have a 22 plus program just like we have a 22 plus program to me that would fold ra rather easily uh there also is in addition to the adult ed with a GED 16 and above can have a high school diploma granted to them Amy's nodding I'm looking back at our assistant superintendent for secondary education so I I see that it would fold in very nicely thank you for that clarification Dr Moffett so I I would also like to invite I know uh former board member oie Davis talked about night school and um what that looks like and since we are in

299contract negotiations with our teachers and our um professionals all of our unions actually maybe we could look at exploring some creative options to accommodate during maybe a second shift or altered shift to be able to accommodate those students because I think they if if getting up at 7:30 8:00 was a challenge maybe we could offer starting school at 10: and maybe we could also use some of our buildings that um have space so Mr one last question are we talking is are the buildings are part of that conversation I wouldn't go that far for Dawn yeah I I just I don't think from what I've seen the buildings I don't know that those are things that we want to be acquiring in any form or fashion I just want to make sure it was just

300about the students and not about the buildings and structures it was about the students if it should grow to something else I will be sure to return to you now does this include the discussion around the sponsor the um being able to sponsor a charter or just the students so I believe that there there's that possibility too Dr MAF the same is true with the Martha mcder School they've approached us in a few different ways could they a become a charter could they be rent from us could they see become a part of Cincinnati public schools as well so I see similarities in both of those conversations so do we need to um in order to give you some umph behind negotiating with the state or talking to the state around CPS being a charter

301do we need to amend that here or is that is that a part of the conversation it's probably in my mind if you say a conversation around this work is acceptable I would include all of those things okay thank you I just wanted to make sure it was included thank you thank you any other last comments roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss MB no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes our last two uh are here the uh motion the board continues to support the administrative review of District properties values and future benefits of such properties in order to recommend maintaining or divesting or developing CPS properties to be studed and then there's a list is there a second second thank you any questions discussion Mr

302Craig so this is one where I I have distinct problems with because I think we are talking about doing stuff that for right now we have not earned the trust of the community to do um I think there are a lot of folks who are looking at things that we're talking about doing with current building structures and the current things that we already have that for me Phil like we're asking too much of them to trust us and how we would do those reviews and that discussion until we show that we can do it in a way that's a minable so that we don't have 700 people coming to our meetings every day asking about things and and that like um but I think the other part to it is for me there's a couple

303of facilities that I guess I'm I'm concerned with us talking about developing or uh being developed on when we are currently looking at each year a $12 million deficit that we have to to make up right so I think now is maybe not the time for us to be talking about new buildings new structures until we've figured out if the current maap that we're using the current structure we're using can be if we're really going to change programming like if we have not changed a single program in a school we have we have not changed a single uh how we allocate students or or we allocate teachers or staff to a building yet we haven't changed anything about how we do organ the actual academic structure by any of this and so if we're not

304there yet I think this is premature for us to be having a discussion about looking into the development or or restructuring or swapping of buildings um until we've done a more committed job to the actual structure I think the other part to it for me is that we are also in the course of the potential will be negotiating all of our wonderful Union contracts and so I think there's a there's an aspect of a lot of this that's going to get affected by what we can and cannot do through our negotiations with regard to our uh how we operate our schools so I'm just a little bit worried that we're doing a lot of looking into things that to be quite honest we've looked into for a couple years now on the cost and they're

305not going to substantially change or differ so I would rather use your time and your team's time to develop the programming that we currently have to make the programming more efficient and better structure than to be looking at whether or not we want to get rid of the Ed Center or whether or not we want to get rid of Iowa which again maybe very valuable things in the future for us to do do we need to make that decision now to start to look into that process any other questions or comments uh Dr Moffett so I do agree with board member Craig on this I think that um the process is very clear when building when people want to buy our properties which is also inclusive of buildings they need to come to you first

306anyway and so that's something that's your responsibility to negotiate that and to bring that to the board and tell us what the offer is um I'm actually and I've said this before really not interested in selling some of the properties that are listed here uh I think that we we have enough to worry about um just responsibly however I do think that down the line we could do some more creative things with some of our property so I think this already is in your purview um I don't I was wondering what is this is this reading to be studied for the intention of what and so because of that and I and I feel like it may have pending sale opportunities and I'm just not ready to do that at this at this moment but

307I do want to emphasize to the public that the procedure is to go through the superintendent's office anyway first when interested in buying property um so that's already on your purview he any other questions or comments roll call Mr Craig no Mr cron no I'm sorry no no Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mofin nope vice president Weinberg no president Bolton no and then the last which is somewhat different uh and that's a motion to to have let's see the board directs the administration to update the five-year repair replace and maintain plan uh fiveyear plan uh which we know we were told I guess uh last month that it probably would have to be uh re uh analyzed or what have you in some way shape or form so uh that make the motion

308to um direct the board direct the administration to update and report back if you will that fiveyear plan is there a second second thank you any questions comments and this is the plan that people have talked about before uh that's been actually given to us almost two years ago now if I recall uh and appreciate that work M are we asking them to update from what they presented most recently because the most recent update that was presented with the new numbers is an update from what was presented two years ago I think what they presented them but also whatever we're doing tonight as we finish up is that going to change anything about where we are about the buildings or what have you so I think it's an update granted that we've already kind of

309seen contemporaneously But I think we might need it additionally do your point roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map no Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes and now the moment that everybody's been waiting for uh the votes on the 10 bundles as uh presented yes Mr cret yes I I have I have uh withheld most of my comments so far this evening but as we as we get into the votes on these uh as a board member I want I think the public deserves to know what my thinking is as to why I've been very supportive so far of of phase two and um it's important to remember that organizations that survive and thrive the ones that do the best at that are the ones

310that are the best at at at adapting adaptation and this plan of phase two that I've seen and I've you know got a long careered business this is an excellent plan plan of adaptation and I'm very impressed with the work that the team has done and with what the superintendent has done and I also think that the reasons uh why I think it's a good plan is number one I think this is going to have a big impact on student outcomes positive impact especially seventh and eighth graders which is I think very critical and I also think that the elementary schools that will get a little bit Fuller will actually operate more efficiently and there might be some more opportunities for those kids as well so I think this is a and and the high

311schools get less crowded it's their the high school is less crowded those students are going to have a better chance to have academic better academic outcomes also so I think that's one of the reasons I don't think there I think there's uh many reasons I I sort of see this as a winwin win better outcomes better utilization of our buildings I think we owe it to our taxpayers I mean sure we're worried about the laws coming from Columbus but we owe it to our taxpayers who paid for these buildings to utilize them properly so I think we should be doing that anyway and taking a review of this more often um and then I think uh it doesn't look like we're saving any money necessarily doing this but I have a long background in Finance

312and Accounting and I believe it positions us it does position us to find savings much better than we would if we don't do this so those are all my win-win-win reasons why I'm very supportive of this uh it seems to me that uh We've you know we've had four superintendents in the last five years we've had a lot of um uh change in the leadership at the top and many of these things that we're talking about to me feel like they were long overdue and so I'm happy to continue to be supportive um and but I also just a reminder to the administration that as we go forward it's going to be really important to continue to have great communication with communities and marketing these things and uh getting feedback so those are my comments

313I think I owe it to the public why I support why I'm a supportive of it and not just sit here and vote Yes so thank you thank you Mr Crosset appreciate it vice president yes I will be quick before we start with the bundles because I know that's what everyone is here for um I just want to to further go into a little bit of support as I was stating in some of the previous board meetings I said that there are some things that I support and there are some things that I do not agree on I know someone stated um during hearing of the public that academic data has not been shared and I do just want to go back and kind of make a little small correction on that in terms of

314at our most recent meeting and I'm going to read this website for anyone who would like to also try to go to the website I think it was on November the 18th you can go to boards.com you can go to the district website and you can go through all of the ways to get into the information for the board meetings but they shared the administration the superintendent and the administration shared all of the data for all of the 7th through 12th and the elementary schools in regards to reading and in regards to math and what I know that I saw after I looked through all of the data was that our seventh and eighth graders really our six seventh and eighth graders were really strugg strling whether it was with their reading whether it's with

315their math scores and so after seeing that particular data I knew something had to change and I want to thank the superintendent for being creative for being Innovative sorry and coming up with a plan that would push or that will push this District forward and so my support will be for some of these items not everything but I'm thinking of the students and I'm keeping them in mind as I'm making this decision thank you vice president Weinberg any other comments questions before we start Dr Moffett I just want to share this was what a lot of the ad hoc data was surrounded around is to directly impact the student outcomes the social emotional outcomes of our sixth 7th and eighth graders because we were seeing even two years ago there was a high connectivity between

316dis and that particular grade band um we've had reports through the goals and guard rails for the past few years around improving um proficiency for African-American students and students of color in the guard wills and it just we T we've consistently talked about being what I consider is just a horrible number to board member weinberg's point to go from a 23% to a 26% and celebrate that is atrocious to me and I've actually spent time because some some teachers have shared their I ready data their disaggregated I ready data for seventh graders and I had an opportunity to go out and speak to some current seventh a current seventh grade science teacher who showed me her beginning I scores which I shared with you and it was three four grade levels behind and she said

317Dr mfet when are you getting them getting the middle the seventh graders out of the building they have so much need and so this is along with the overcrowding hearing from Social Workers say we've got grades s through 12 we they need a separate space and so um it it's this has been a consistent theme on that we've heard multitude of ways in the gold guard World reports is a collective District not necessarily with regard to that gray band but it's available because your staff has has definitely shared that so um I'm I'm really excited I'm going to ask a lot of questions about this because I want to make sure that we are doing this with as much Fidelity as we can but I also will implore to you once we make this decision

318starting in January the engagement has got to increase we can and I know you're doing it we already talked about this but we've got to we can't do this work in silos in it has to be in concert with Community with the neighborhoods councils with the lsdmc but most importantly we keep taking parents out of this equation we have to do it with them as well so that's going to be my caveat but we've heard this for so so long and I'm hoping that this my prayer is that this this is going to work for our families our kids because student outcomes is our first important piece and this is supposed to impact that thank you any other comments from board members uh superintendent Murphy would you present the first uh bundle and explain the

319first bundle entails Western Hills High School eth M Taylor Ro Hill and Leap Academy The Proposal is that Western Hills High School would become a 9 through 12 building with the seventh and eighth graders uh going to Ethel Taylor the Etho M Taylor Academy I'm calling that Western Hills junior high school because the seventh and eighth graders who would have typically selected West high would then go to that particular building converting into a Junior High School uh including the rising sixth grade students from rill rill would become a prek to sixth grade building that would not only have the current rowhill students but they would receive the eth ethot tayor students LEAP Academy a prek to 6 building would by a year at a Time advance grade levels adding grade seven and then adding grade

320eight the following year thank you any questions about this bundle any discussion Mr Craig I was say I can save it till after we do the motion if that's actually what we're I'm sorry so moved second okay um so to kind of thoughts on this uh and we've discussed this a number of times before in our in our discussions I guess the first one is the the combining the students who were at Ethel Taylor uh with the students who are at uh rooll Hill for the PRK through six and and I guess I'm just wondering like what's the expected number of students because I think right now as a personally sits that number would push to really high capacity at Ro Hill if I'm understanding correctly from the numbers that we were given before yes

321so those numbers were on a very early on like the probably the first deck or two that you had around this so thank goodness uh treasure Wagner has numbers in front of her give me a second yeah rill and Ethel Taylor um because I mean I I will say just as it was presented before it it looked as though the full capacity of the students who were at E Taylor we're not going to be coming to roll Hill and if that like if that is the case I mean that would be like I think probably still another 100 or so more students than what was in the early projections the other thing that we did if you can remember back to those early slides has stepped it out over like maybe a 3 or four

322year period of time and terms of what those numbers would look like and I just did not bring that with me today sorry it's it's again I think that's fine um I ask that in part because I do know like the west side is a unique spot in in the situation of which we have an overc capacity at a lot of our elementary schools in a way that is just unnaturally feing feeding up and so there is a a need and a capacity to do something on the West Side to address overc capacity we heard on some discussion earlier today about over capacity what I am kind of distinctly and I would still like to keep like I hate when we change names and stuff because I think it just makes it more confusing for

323folks but so if we can keep it as Ethel Taylor junior high or whatever like at least as much as we can um but the other question I have is what programmatic changes are we looking at with regards to the seventh and eth grade at Ethel Taylor that would be different than what they would be receiving at West High currently U because I think that goes into the points that several board members have said that we would have these improved outcomes and I guess the true nature of this is what academic programming are we are we offering or that we would be offering to achieve those outcomes because if all we're doing is moving students from one building to another theoretically yeah maybe they would feel comfortable in a building where there's not as many

324people but realistically for our seventh and eighth grade students excuse me we have had the conversation with uh inor assistant superintendent Randol and uh director manager Turner in Career and Technical education about providing that foundation for all of our seventh and eighth grade students which we don't currently have across the board so we would start there there are some other as I mentioned um earlier middle school programs that we're talking about with steam development or stem or Career and Technical research or uh social justice themes we've already discussed I would just say I mean again I think this is this is one area where I think there is some discussion we've had as board about the overcrowding on the West Side since I've been on the board um some of the other things I don't

325think we've really discussed since I've been on the board but I I would say this can we at least also get a commitment to come back with the academic programming that would be installed at the seventh and eth grade and I think this is in part going to also our budget questions uh because the reality is if we're offering a seventh and eighth grade and parents just say you know what I I'll send my kids somewhere else or I can look at some of the other school options because there's nothing different going to be offered we're not not going to see the numbers at the seventh and eighth grade that we're expecting on the West Side specifically though because we have so many students who are also lwi income who are also you know we

326talked about this several times we had um Becka Beach come up and talk about this several times with students who are living two houses or two people in the house at a time you know two families in the house at a time doubling up they need more to keep them on track to get them into that high school education model that then they can go into some of these Career Tech and other stuff um and so I think specifically on that side if we can just get a report back at some point as to what those academic uh programming would look like for seventh grade it would bring a lot more clarity to those folks out there who are trying to make the decisions Mr cron yes when I when I visited Ethel Taylor there's

327a very nice rec center right and that that could be a a a partnership that I think could work well with Junior High School and no disrespect to board member Craig but uh I don't when I visited leap I sort of feel like that name of that school doesn't fit anymore so maybe that school could use some rebranding um although I know I appreciate not wanting to Rebrand too much but other questions comments about this bundle roll call Mr Craig uh yes Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map no Dr mofet yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes superintendent Murphy would you introduce a bundle two bundle two at this time the administration is recommending for Hayes Porter and Rothenberg that there wouldn't be any change in their current structure [Applause] I do

328however reserve a concern for the number of students but I have heard the community saying that they're going to work with us on how to increase in enrollment any questions comments Mr Craig just and I want to one happy to hear this but two I think there is an opportunity for us in those conversations you're having with the city to really present Us in these spaces where we are having folks move in those communities um I know a comment made by a former board member about the fact that we have parents who live there who do not send their kids to cite Public Schools is somewhat true but the reality is that if we're talking about marketing if we're talking about communicating it's about having them opportunities to come in and learn what their kids

329could do in our schools that are unique and different um because I think the other struggle we're going to see uh or that we're seeing in some of the charter schools and some of other programs is that they're while they're thought they would have a lot more funding from these vouchers they have learned that quite honestly they're getting the same exact money that they were already getting because the students who were already there paying tuition are the ones who were getting vouchers now and there may be some places where those students and those parents who thought they were going to get something better may be willing to do something with a program like hay Porter especially because of its high rating and the program and things that are going on there so I think it's

330a great opportunity to sell it within the community sell it within those grandparents who live in that Community those folks like uh some of our community leaders who live in the Westend now and the development there to really push that um but the other thing that I had really quickly was that specifically with um ha Porter but but also I think it's true with rothberg the large businesses within that Community owe the district a debt of gratitude because we are the cornerstones of that Community we've been the cornerstones of that community and that the holding us there and keeping us there is what will keep that Community thriving and growing and I don't know that we have a great enough Partnership of support to communicate out the great things that are going on at the

331school we got great Partners at the school but we got some larger organizations and structures that are in that area that who really should be investing better in these younger kids getting them ready ready to go up to the higher grades so I move uh to accept this bundle is there a second second because there further discussion because there's no change can we skip this and move on no we're going to vote on this we have to vote they people want us to vote that's fine that's fine that's fine I I hear that and that makes sense I'm I'm reminded many years ago when the Taft High School folks brought uh petition and made us sign that that we were going to build Taft High School no matter what and then we did it live

332TV if I recall so we will vote on it I think it's not an unreasonable thing that you're suggesting but we're going to vote uh roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy abstain okay Miss map Dr Moffett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes superintendent Murphy would you please introduce the bundle number three absolutely at this time Administration makes the following recommendation and that is that rising star at Vine remain a preap building I'm not sure why there was any thought of closing but that would be a preap building and the recommendation for William Howard Taft Elementary is that uh at the lsdmc request that we begin the investigation for them to become a neighborhood montau school and that they would also host the RP at their building questions comments Vice

333uh we can do a motion and I'll do the motion I'll do it right this time motion to accept second second now Vice President okay and I just want to make sure that the uh slide is showing the information correctly so it's so it's saying that the building William Howard Taff Elementary then it says grades none then it says PKA to RS advine blah blah blah blah blah blah so is that correct what it's saying right there I just want to make sure well so at their request at the ls dmc's request they asked if they could be considered as the neighborhood montor school but wouldn't they have kids there wouldn't they have grades when they have grades at the school though so so it says None currently but what's their currently what do they

334have at the school Oh So currently they have prek through six so should it say prek through six it depends on if we're doing a fresh start as a neighborhood monory well it looks like right now we're saying we won't have many kids there and I know what you're saying but if I'm looking at this this uh slide unless I'm just thinking about it wrong well I'm just thinking about if if we were going to accept them as a neighborhood monory as a startup or no so you're suggesting on this particular slide that we're starting as a monor neighborhood mon neighborhood monory or or with no grades I'm just you know what I'm saying though say the existing grades are gone yes so okay I just want Clarity I'm sorry I'm sorry it's not clear

335there will be a different narrative out there and I want to make sure we are going to control the narrative and just to also State at the bottom Rising Star would stay as they are no change they would stay as they are this ISS prek six that's they would be a pre pre so we need to change that I'm so sorry so we need to change that I will change because if we are voting this in then they're going to say oh someone's going to say oh no you said it was going to be a prek through six so I wanted to just make sure that it has accurate and correct information I have I have a question and so the wrap goes to Taft Elementary MH Taft Elementary has expressed interest in having the

336wrap in their building and I think that's a fine idea and some of it is the additional facilities that they have have it so well some of the things that they pointed out is having a swimming pool access to a swimming pool that I was not aware of and so we think that that would be um very attractive to what we're trying to do with and for our students experiencing homelessness our CPS students experiencing homelessness and the school-based health center that there a school Heth get as I recall okay thank you m Mr Lindy I just I'm following up on me member weinberg's question about the grades being none is this essentially proposing that it closes Taft High School and replaces it with a new school excuse me ta Elementary and replaces it with a

337I'm just confused about what the change is no I'm not proposing a close of the school I'm not proposing a closing of the school so the students who are currently there could stay there if they're interested in becoming a monor neighborhood school yes and the teachers staff who were there could stay there if they wanted to for those teachers who would be interested in that type of programming thank you welcome president Bolton Dr mord so I would like to amend this bundle I'm a little confused I'm going to say that but it could be because it's late and I'm hungry and I've been sitting for 5 hours so it could be that too however I've taken off the prek to 6 under rising stars at Vine and just put pre prek there because that's what

338that is it is a prek building and I would like to submit that um Taft Elementary has the wp and that those students stay there and that we find out maybe next on the 18th what program you're recommending for there but there should be K through six grades there right so for the programming Dr Moffet you said find out on the 18th so just just whatever I mean I'm I'm saying that we should cross out none and say that there are K through six students there you're going to work on the programming of that right yes for the monory I want to be I want to be clear about that because there was a school that we had initially recommended and that was not desired so I just want to be really clear lsdmc said

339the principal and the lsmc said they wanted to have the monor start up what impact would that have to the current students that are there and teachers they would have to decide if that's the type of education they wanted to continue to have so if they decide to stay there's approximately 250ish students there would those students remain there or would they have to leave if they were interested in monor education is what we're saying at this point then yes they could stay well I'm I'm trying to think I'm trying to just what I let me tell you what I don't want to do and you can tell me how this happens okay I don't want to displace those 250 students if they want to stay there at all so I want to make sure that

340whatever I'm voting on it says that they can stay there regardless of the programming or we have a plan to transition those students if they want to because I know that the Taft Elementary Magnet status has been removed so that impacts their Transit their transportation I don't want to lose those 250 students if they want to stay there so I want to understand I want to vote on something that allows them to stay in that building if we can so are we going to continue to provide the transportation to the students is that what you're saying suggesting I'm I'm just saying I I want to understand what if you have a plan to keep those students there with monory programming how does that look if if if they can if they are interested in monory

341programming is my current recommendation then they are fine to stay there as far as I'm concerned okay one of the things that came up before with the monory suggestion was that school wasn't interested and the message was and I understand not all students not all families are interested in monor I understand so I just want to be clear what we're proposing would happen instructionally I got you I I don't know how this needs to to be worded other than to take this off and table this for me because I don't I'm not interested in displacing those students so for me my desire is that they stay there um and if the lsdmc of that building wants monory I'm happy to I'm I'm happy to vote on that I just want to understand how that impacts

342that population that's all so I don't know how that looks but I just want to I want to understand I'd like to ask a question too on this if I could very quickly you're we know that your recommendation is that the wp goes to uh Taft Elementary that's correct the issue is the students and that Taft Elementary is going to lose its uh magnet status as a stem school that's correct if the students want to remain at Taft uh even though the rap is also coming and we're not none of us are quite sure how big that's going to be or what it's going to involved the students that would be staying there would be students that would be part of a of the be the beginning of building up a monu yes you're changing

343your programming losing the stem status no no stem no Transportation because of the magnet status of stem those remaining if they choose to remain would be welcome to remain but it would become begin to be a monory school thank you let me go to Mr PR and then I'll go over to member Matt um so I think I have three thoughts that would maybe make me a little bit uh more in support of something like this I think first is the first right like the encouragement not necessarily just saying if they want to come but more or less encouraging those students to remain and go through because I think we have I think what's been expressed that there's a number of teachers who either have monory education or have the skill sets that would be

344required to provide monory education and so I think uh again having briefly spent like four weeks hanging out with a few of the students there I do know that there's a love of of a lot of the programs and I also don't think necessarily that stem Falls outside of monor programming I think you could do like a monory program that had a stem connection to it it does not necessarily mean stem is the magnet status to it but that the education model does not fall outside of being monory education um so for me like it would it would feel better if we were giving those students kind of that first pick of coming in to that program so they could stay and then if there were some students who needed to change or there some

345students who had other reasons that they could no longer attend that is fair I think the other part to it is we have the opportunity to have the conversation with what was the Xavier monor program or whatever to bring those students to also fill so I think there's a possibility of of certainly filling the space but I think when you like for me it feels like we need to be telling students who are in a building that we want you to stay more so than saying to them if you want to stay right like there's there's an aspect of that that feels to me a lot different when I come to you and say I want you here so if you want to be here too stay here with me because I think a lot

346of those students would be like yes um I think the other part to me with the rap and all I think this is a classic example we were talking about the discussions with CRC the relationship that's been built up in that Community around the school with the rec center with the charter school that's right up the street that's an example of how all of our schools should operate within their community and that is an that is not something that was not done by accident that was something that was a dedicated effort by the principal of that school and I think to establish a relationships where they even set up times for when people come in and out when they have activities and events they're so coordinated that this could be a great opportunity for something

347like the rap to be a part of the additional things that's provided by the school and in that rec center and again that's another partnership connection there but for me it does need to feel like it is not a if you want to stay you can but a more like we want you to be there and here's the reasons why you could succeed in a program like this monory stem I think the third and final thing is that I do think there needs to be some form of a transition um we did this with some of the other schools that we removed their Madness status fors that we grandfathered in at least a year I I think that's not a hard thing for us to do in this one but I would say it really

348depends on where some of the students are because I do know some of those students have been at like this is like their third or fourth school that they've transferred in and out of throughout the district for various reasons and I remember sitting there hearing a kid who talked about he was a sixth grader in the group that I was talking with and the thing that kind of struck me was that he was the president of their MO program group or whatever but this is his like first year at the school like this is he's embraced being a leader within that group and I think that's the thing we would lose in some ways for some of those students who have found a space it might be inviting to them but we we may need

349to figure out how we structure-wise handle the transportation issues that may be a concern where they're located and that kind of deal but I think if we're saying to them that we want you there we can have a discussion about how we get you there um but if we if we don't say it that way I don't know that parents always hear it as I wanted there remember map so yes so uh board member Craig kind of touched upon it I I was just wanting to inquire about the um the retention of our teachers if it's being offered as a monory um how would we retain um our our teachers at have um and making sure that they are also um prepared to teach the monory pedagogy so just wanted to know uh plans around

350that we definitely understand if you do support any expans of Monsur that there would have to be training provided we understand that okay so but again also how are we working to make sure that those teachers are being able being retained apart from just the training how are we making sure that the teachers are being retained so they can be a part of the training I said apart from just how are we ining that the Staffing will be there because to the point of if they want to be we want to that the teachers are still retain there so how do we go about doing that yes I do believe and I'm I I treasure Wagner mentioned this earlier that there are still additional positions in our district that are either currently being covered by

351a long-term sub or day-to-day sub or just have not been completely filled yet so I do think for our c of teachers there are plenty of assignments available okay thank you vice president I had a question as well um I have a suggestion I don't know if you all will like it but can we possibly have a 3A and a 3B for this slide so 3A could be the rising uh rising stars at Vine staying at their PK um and then for 3B we're suggesting that the r go to to William Howard tff Elementary pending there was something that you had stated about a transition and something about programming I don't know how you said it but I liked how you said it can that be add it thoughts do you remember what you said

352I I just well we've done this before with magn we've given like a transition year of invite them to remain I think the two thoughts I had was invite the students to be a part of the monory program and tell them we want them and then the other thing was the transition as regards to Transportation when we change magnet status take time to do that that's good no I think I like uh A and B uh we are missing a member and oh I I had one other question I'm sorry I'm going back to you said you talked to who did you talk with that tff regarding the mon story piece the principal and the uh lsmc chair you may have a letter in that green folder um that they submitted a while ago then

353again today and did we talk with the parents do did we talk this came from their lsdmc so you'll see that I personally did not but this came from the principal and the lsdmc the chair and they submitted these a while ago and then again today so now I'm wondering does this need to be a three-parter being the fact that you've not talked well not that you but so we know that we want to keep Rising Star the same they're going to receive the tap Elementary PK then two the rap is going to William Howard Taff and then three the possibility of it becoming the the central Corridor Monas yes okay in but we're inviting the students that are there to remain during that transition okay are you are you breaking up the vote between

3543A and 3B I don't know I think we could probably all settle on the 3B and you did the 3B capture everything that you had mentioned Mr Craig I mean again I think if we are taking the PK from whim how to Rising Stars if we are keeping rising stars is just PK and then if we're saying we're going to begin the building of a monitory model within the school although the students have the first rights to the to remain there um I I'm I can support something more in that line because I think that keeps the students at the school that they're at and gives Rel least the opportunity for them to stay for many of the students I would the only caution I I kind of throw to this and I think this

355is where I have a little bit of a worry when we talk about change to monor is that I always have this fear that we do stuff and then we like we say we can do stuff and then realistically it may take a year or two for it to actually happen and so like is if we're automatically saying we're going to go into monori as the model for next year um that has a different meaning for some of the parents who would be within the spectrum that would be able to get access to it right so like parents who would be in that mount Alburn area those type of things who may not or been in other places who may not have already been again I keep going back to the Xavier monory program students

356who maybe new students coming in I'm just worried about also capacity if we're doing um if the whole point of us is to be building the capacity within the school and we're not I want us to keep as many students that are there to help maintain capacity because I feel like if we restart we're going to be starting with a lot less students and that the potential for not growing that capacity up would worry me so what I wonder then board member Craig if it's a transition on both ends a transition with the start of Monsur which is probably best practices to do it anyway as young people are transitioning on to seventh and eth grade so we would have and I think it's small enough that we would have both go we could have

357both going at the same time does that make sense all right um that being the case we've uh uh quasi amended the uh motion by creating a brand new motion um which is not unusual for our board um and but if uh that uh is the um value of working together let's uh be ready to vote uh well we are you here or not here okay good all right uh uh so moved as amended or changed and seconded the everybody's agreed and we'll do a roll call and this is calling three all that stuff okay Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mofin yes do vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you board members uh uh superintendent would you please present uh bundle four bundle 4 begins

358with with high school transitioning to grades 9 through 12 Frederick Douglas would be the prek to6 to5 to5 to5 building that would absorb Evon prek to 5 the sixth grade students from Frederick Douglas would then move to South Avendale for the Middle School experience allowing Evanston Academy to be the seventh and eighth grade building in the neighborhood pulling in the students from with row or with row junior high school thank you uh I'd like to make a motion that that bundle four is presented by the superintendent is a motion and needs a second second thank you madam vice president discussion Dr Moffett so I'm back I had a little snack I'm better now I have a question yes uh oh it is a dangerous thought I have some concerns around Douglas sixth graders going to

359South Avendale to have to come back to Evon so for me if you're proposing Douglas To Be A prek through five I think that for that first year those students should be allowed to stay there and then they go to Evanston for their seventh grade year I just to I we've had a lot of discussion before around transition and I just feel like that is an unnecessary transition if we can prevent it and we probably could if we grandfathered those students for like one year because it just would be one class can they fit can they fit the size can they fit I'm concerned they won't be able to fit so my question was just can we grandfather like the sixth grade Douglas students to be able to stay at Douglas for that year and

360then go to Evon for their seventh grade rather than to have to go to South Avendale and then go to so Evon next year would be grade six seven and eight the EV the current Evon fifth graders would be sixth grade Evon right being six seven and eight and then that sixth grade class which is spay out and it would turn into a seventh in an effort to keep the keep them together in that cohort in that in that neighbor I just don't want them to have to leave and then go because we're phasing that part out so that's that's what I was wondering understood Vice yeah just to go a little bit um after board member um Moffett so with the transition the only thing that I want to be clear to you know

361everyone listening or who will listen is as we're talking about having these particular middle schools or um junior high schools just being transparent about the transition and how many transitions there will be I do think that if you're upfront people may not like it but at least they know versus I know here it's stating or it was recommended that we would just keep that particular grade but then for the following years you're still going to have families moving three times so can you kind of just explain that a little bit so that it's clear to everyone so it's also possible that those sixth graders not necessarily so the sixth graders who would then be leaving and going to Evon next year the following year so 27 uh can remain there will remain there at South

362Avendale for seventh grade and for eighth grade so it would not be a transition back the same would be true for the current Rising fifth graders so for next school year fiscal year 26 they wouldn't come back they would remain at South Avendale for seventh grade and for 8th grade okay thank you so are we saying okay I'm so so if it's your pleasure to keep the rising fifth graders they will be sixth graders at uh in the Evon building next year that's that's strong possibility but my only point to that is they're we're not asking them to come back where would they go they could stay at South Avendale if they wanted to I see what you're saying okay so this is these are the kids who would have selected with r for seventh

363grade they would be going to Evanston but if a student wanted to stay oops in the Middle School setting they would continue as sou I wouldn't expect them to leave South Avendale I think I understand because South Avendale would be 678 so they could stay there 678 yes okay and then Evanson would just be for those seventh graders that chose the junior high option okay Mr Craig so I think this actually makes me a little bit more concerned um and and part of it is that South avendo is not really in the same vicinity um as Evon and Douglas and I think the the folks who might be coming to South Evendale will be a different mixture of students than necessarily who would be at Douglas um as they progress up um but the other

364thing for me on this and this is where I'm I'm also trying to figure out in theory Evanson is a higher rated School than Douglas and I think we talked about this on last week and so the transition of students from Evon to Douglas potentially opens up a whole new bag of worms that we'd have to address as to whether or not they could transition from the from the higher rated school to a rated school and so it almost makes more sense too the reverse than it does to do to take students from Douglas to Evanson as that would be a more natural I don't I don't think it raises the same concerns as taking a school from a higher rated down to low rated I guess it's my question I know we talked about

365a little bit at last week but that seems to raised some concerns as to whether or not we would be required to do other things as a result of a student who's at a higher rated School being moved to a lower rated school um but my my bigger question is really with regards to the flow into wiro and this is where I think this is the weird part of how our our district is set up is that the students who normally would be going into Withrow come from so many wide parts of that like it's not a neighborhood it's like seven neighborhoods feed Withrow for some odd reason um and I think that's in part because of where we've placed our high schools over the years and the way the city's built up and those

366changes but like for instance Mount Washington would feed with row right and we made that seven or made that k through eight or or pre through eight or whatever um you know Woodford potentially could feed with row um Parker or John P Parker could feed with so like there's weird spots of how students would end up at with row and I'm I guess I'm wondering on the one end where are the students who would be going to Evon ideally coming from because I do think if they're if they're at Douglas and they're now transferring over to South Avendale and they're saying it's South Avendale then who's feeding that seventh and eighth grade number and then is that really lowering our transportation costs if we're just shipping them you know basically to the same area of

367town just a different way um so so the thought is that those students who would have selected with throw right for 7th eth grade this is where they would be going and I think to your point we are high schools of choice we have been high schools of choice so not only the mount Washingtons of the world you know the the the Woodford of the but they could have even come from Carson or wherever um in order to go to high school this Corridor model should lessen that thus helping even more with Transportation cost but that's going to take a little time to build out and that's why I guess I'm wondering who are the seventh and eighth grade students who would have been at wiro who will now be at Evon because in some

368ways I I just don't know where they come from if we're shortening who where you could go to school at and those type things we're trying to Corridor off some of the student opportunities at our high schools because like in theory we've built up other places that would have an effect on that number also and so or we have other programs so if you're a JPY Parker you might end up at shoulder middle school instead because it's closer and nearer to where you are as opposed to coming down or same deal for Woodford or that type of deal um as opposed to you picking Withrow because that's where you feels a better High School than for your child you know what I'm saying like that who's the natural feeder to Evon if it's not the

369folks at Douglas or the folks that would have been at Evon before can I Pig you back on that that that's why we mentioned some hours ago now that the idea that the uh Citywide remain s the um our Comprehensive High Schools we didn't change the high schools of choice issue so any kid that is ready or family that's ready to choose wiro would know that they start their seventh grade regardless of where they are in the city they're going to start their seventh grade at at wiro at the uh Evanson building the wiro junior high or whatever right so they could be coming from from all over the city cuz they will be except for the kids who would have been at who are now at Douglas who were at Evon before would now

370be at South Avendale going through their 628 program that's what I'm saying like I think there's well there's a smaller amount of people that I think we really are counting and I just hope we're not double counting students but remember board member Craig those students the current sixth graders will be selecting they would have selected with r or or schroer or Woodward so now it's just it'll look different instead of selecting Woodward or with r they may select Evanston they have I guess I I guess so this is where it's a little bit confusing to me because in the old days yes they would have selected the high school which would have been a 7 through 12 they're not selecting a high school anymore now they're selecting a seventh grade program which is a you

371know essentially the junior high and so unless we're requiring you to select both the junior high and the high school as a part as a package at that time where you would naturally feed up you may have a parent who says yeah normally I would have picked Withrow because withow 7 through eight cool but now I don't have to pick Withrow yet I can pick this other option that's closer to me or I can pick this other option that works better for me and then maybe when they get to ninth grade we'll make the decision about which high school they go to and that's maybe the thing I'm wondering is is that seventh and eth grade are we still filling that seventh and eth grade space um more comments and that I'm going to call

372the question pretty soon or we're going to have to come up with what is the issue for us Dr Mett and then we'll go to member map I was just going to suggest to board member Craig's question they're going to have to go somewhere so they're not going to be double counted because they have to make they're just making a choice for middle school and making a choice for high school but that going to count one time sometime what we do have is a trans a high transient population of students even in the Middle School option so some students may live on on the middle Central Corridor and choose a middle school option there and then by the time they get to high school that within that two years they may choose a different option

373but I don't think that those students are being double counted I think the number is set where they choose to go is typically based on in Cincinnati not necessarily the programming at the school but hey my my uncle went to with or I live right here so I I would I would imagine that the numbers are going to be consistent because we are seeing when Jeremy pulled these numbers before for us we were seeing based on address where kids were going was not consistent upon this the school that they chose they were living on the west side right next to Western Hills and going to Withrow so it wasn't based upon demographics that they were choosing those schools it was based on something else and so we had had some data before and I know

374Jeremy's not here but we had had some data before around the transient nature of students in the rising from the 6th to the seventh grade choosing that High School option but there's also another time period that they were also transient and it was right around N9 10th grade level too so um to your to your question around um students choosing the the Middle School options I think it would be based upon the same reasons that they choose it now because the transient nature of that demographic is consistent because of the high the socioeconomics so remember Matt uh yes so I know that everon currently um accommodates six units where would those students um be absorbed would they stay at everon or is this pertaining to I know the recommendation around students going to chase like

375where would these students go depending on their grade level so it is possible they would be going to Douglas okay okay vice president so I just want to make sure on this particular this this particular slide we're saying slide B no PK through 5 would be Frederick 6 through 8 is South Avendale 7 through e is Evanston 9 through 12th is wro that's that's what I thought okay I got it thank you roll call Mr Craig no Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr off yes vice president Weinberg can I say no and yes would say A or B I'm teasing I'm going to say no I'm going say no president Bolton yes AB bondle five so this recommendation uh evolves around Hughes Woodward South Avendale and Rockdale with Hughes stem becoming

376a 9th to 12 building with the seventh and eighth graders going to South Avendale Woodward High becoming a 912 building with seventh and eighth graders going to South Avendale South Avendale will convert to a sixth to eighth grade building with their Elementary age students going to Rockdale Rockdale becomes the prek 5 building yeah in this case so just an adjustment then they would not be receiving the TA Elementary boundary based on what we talked about a few slides ago we're on five I'm waiting to see if she's doing B president makeing a motion to make it a motion uh to support the um superintendent's presentation on bundle 5 Second thank you questions comments Mr Craig uh so just uh kind of two thoughts that one is with the removal of the tap boundary students I

377don't know how many projected students that that were um do we have any offin kind of guess as to how that will affect the numbers at at Rockdale yeah we'll still be fine with that we we will take that off based on the previous conversation okay and then the second thought I had and I this one's a little bit different one for me for Woodward as opposed to per se for Hughes because I know we have a we have a congestion issue at hu absolutely not just in the build not really just building wise but a community wise um that this might be helpful to help alleviate I think the question I have with Woodward though is I I don't know that we have a congestion problem at Woodward currently and so I guess the

378question becomes what are we looking to do to expand remember we want to add uh entrepreneurship cosmetology and Automotive at woodw I guess but I guess I'm thinking though what are the efforts we're going to do to get the numbers up because from when I remember looking at the Lings Woodward was not a school where we had an overabundance in folks from 7 through 12 currently right in in those areas uh just mentioned young people across the district have asked for those opportunities okay and so therefore an increase in numbers of students participating at Woodward I I guess I'm just uh and again maybe I'm just not I'm not following this but I I don't know that why we would take the seventh and eighth grade out of Woodward I guess is my question is

379is we also remember you um we're looking at their social emotional needs in that age band right and not giving them putting them into a high school setting when they need something much different than the high school student would need and then we also need the space for those additional Career and Technical education programs okay uh I would feel be so my my one concern and again is my growing concern with this is that the capacity level at Woodward based on what as on the chart that was presented to us would still be below 60% if we did it based on the numbers that are in that projections and so if we're at 60% at Woodward even if we're assuming that folks are going to want to come and join and that kind of deal

380we're still making up for students we're losing for seventh and eighth grade I I'm I'm if the concern is that we are underpopulated in some of the buildings I don't know that this fixes that concern at Woodward specifically Hughes is different for me Hughes I I'm look I live with the folks of Hughes walking walking around every day by hu's campus so I'm I am completely understanding of there and I think there's again I I believe Rockdale and and South Havendale are a great example of a of two schools that are literally less than a quarter of a mile from each other who quite honestly are probably serving similar population not the exact same because they have their their own issues with in the community there but the Woodward one is the one that I'm

381a little bit less convinced on but you're suggesting that like what just happened regarding uh wiro uh that Woodward also remain a a 712 I I think my my concern is just that even the numbers that we're pro ejecting in what was given to us won't get us to 80% capacity so unless we're shortening the capacity of Woodward which is a whole another conversation um I I I think we're end up in the same boat again of saying the school is underpopulated even if we're only you know especially if we're only doing 9 through 12 whereas Hughes actually has a capacity issue like aen actually has a capacity issue member Mett so I'm wondering about while I I'm sharing your same concern around the capacity of Woodward I'm wondering if done at the same time

382the increase in Career Tech opportunities that may increase the capacity at Woodward which would offset that that's what I was that's what I was envisioning is that it would increase the increase the differential programming would increase the capacity at Woodward and we pulled the seventh and eighth graders off because they didn't need to be in that building the seventh and eighth graders the social emotional learning the academics of the seventh and eighth graders across the district in alignment with the discipline is what was needing to be improved upon the academics the discipline across the district inclusive of Woodward and then when you um change the programming we may have more students that are choosing that option so that that's what I was thinking I'm hoping that that's in alignment with board member Craigs but I

383do have a question can South Avendale accommodate with row Hughes and Woodward instead of it going to Evanson I'd have to pull those numbers I'm not I'm not sure with with row Hughes and um with so I asked that question because I'm wondering I don't know if the previous one passed I don't I don't know if it did I don't think it did but is South Avendale able to accommodate all of those um middle SCH I don't know about that for six seven and eight because I'm going to say typically uh we set the classes at about 150 so 157th graders 158th graders for each of those huse to your point might be a little larger than that with r might be a little larger as well now I think about it so that's like

384almost like a th kids just roughly that humming is killing I don't know what that she said 343 at Hughes what was the number of Hughes 343 343 buildings 1286 not 7 7 339 339 7th and E at Withrow Woodward they're going to be smaller I'm just react so um8 19 so it's 195 at Woodward 195 and how many at Hugh was 33 uh 343 at Hughes and 339 at Withrow it's 87 877 sou 650 and South avend is a 650 building why are you counting with Dr MAF just asked that question but didn't we agree didn't we just vote that with would stay at 712 so so Withrow doesn't count they're going to stay no she was my question was just since that didn't pass could the South Avendale accommodate those three communities instead

385of um sending them to Evon that's why I was asking that question but the but the goal was to pull seventh and eighth graders to improve their discipline academics and support their social emotional learning in a separate environment so okay I I do think it at Woodward that indeed the additional career piece will increase the uh enrollment significantly um Rob said part of the humming is that we can't do something about the Wi-Fi and so it has to be at the particular volume so when we're not speaking uh make sure we uh muted our mics to vote on this one um I'm just curious about a a different amendment to this maybe keeping the Woodward 9912 and uh opening this up for um wiro and Hughes seven and eight I don't know if that's just

386his thought I mean would that is that even [Music] workable and we also heard from the Woodward and Woodward counselor and the district lead counselor about these seventh and e8th graders tonight as well I don't think I really don't think it's a good idea okay thank you so your uh suggestion is that indeed uh Woodward uh lose the seventh and eighth grade as okay and that's what this is part of this bundle Hughes and Woodward losing the seventh and eth grade thank you if there's no more comment then we will vote on this ready oh wait is there anything happening okay wait you another County heard from Koga County oh good Mike you can't do it it's not on this is fun so far this is the man really on charge of operations for the

387district go ahead Hallelujah no no go ahead [Music] got [Music] great thank you other comments questions I think we're ready for a roll call as it has been presented Ed has this been amended in any way shape or form is this the way it's been presented thank you Mr Craig no Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr Mett yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes and now we'll go on to six all right this recommendation is for saor Park to be expanded from a prek to 6 prek to 8 prek to 8 currently um to become a prek to 12 building stepping out adding a grade level each year and also looking at a uh junior RTC and early college programming thank you and so it is moved is there a

388second for the the uh bundle six second thank you you don't have a motion yet yes discussion question no that came from the superintendant there's no motion yet no I've made it into a motion I see thanks okay so I um yes go ahead I have a question around alignment with what we had said for the other um I think it was board member Craig I don't remember the number but we had talked about it being not just early college but but um whatever was in alignment with Mount St Joe athletic trainers or something yes board member Craig mentioned well we had mentioned um possibly you see being interested possibly looking at a partnership with M say Joe board member Craig mentioned other entities and programming that could come from uh or be supported by

389Mount St Joe so I just wanted to add that to he to align with What could potentially be that we don't know yet for the Sailor Park option yes that's all I don't know if that's amending is that amending this as written be amending the motion as presented if it's okay with the motion maker it's fine with me second or yes yes so as amended this would be Tre and you want to do the language uh was it Mr Craig that first mentioned that language way back when Amed ready Mr Craig yes Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy no M map no Dr Mett yes vice president weberg yes president Bolton yes uh now we'll do a bundle seven uh superintendent will you present and bundle seven to look at aen High School uh becoming a

3909 through 12 building with the seventh and eighth graders going to Pleasant Hill Academy Pleasant Hill would convert uh to a middle school so their pre- of five students would go to College Hill they would uh College Hill would no longer have the magnet status the sixth graders would go to Pleasant Hill for the Middle School concept the winon hills Academy pre- of five students would be in that building uh and then the mount Ary uh pre- of 5 students who live in that winon Hills Academy attendance Zone would uh go back to that neighborhood school so [Music] moved right yeah I'll second that discussion Akin High School is very full it's very full it needs it needs to have a seven and eight it's overcrowd m Mal so I just want to clarify um

391Mount Ary would be in the west boundary I mean it would be on the west Corridor I'm sorry yes not changing anything about Mount Ary it's just those students who are going to school there from the winon hills Academy attendance area would return to to their neighborhood school okay or the College Hill attend or college heill depend on the grade level right I remember that was an issue too okay okay I think I got it thank you any other questions comments Mr Craig um so I don't disagree that aen is overrun with people I mean I think that's the center of the universe it's just the reality of of the school there has again again this is where our populations move right so I guess my question would be though if we are removing the

392magnet status from um was it put College Hill and uh or just College Hill right um is there not some level of a natural transition of seventh and eighth grade within EI in in one of those one or two of those that might be less drawing of a change and I guess it's maybe the only question I would have because my my only concern is again location wise this is where I start to worry when we're moving folks from one side of an area to another side of an area and then kind of back again or that type of deal that are we really saving on Transportation costs in that in that same vein um because I think that's fair enough that they can pick whatever high school they want to kind of go to

393but yeah reality if you live in College Hill you're likely to you're highly likely to end up or you're in Mount area you're highly likely to end up in aching if it's something is convenient and near you and it's in your community and it's an easier travel but the the bouncing back and forth to me is is just another one of those things where I'm I'm wondering how much of that is naturally moving folks into spaces or if there's more maybe [Music] centrally uh I guess I'm just there there really are I mean they're close to each other but not in the in the in their communities in some ways and in their in their space so it's still a little bit of that travel for me that raises just some concerns about what happens

394in that seventh and eighth grade group and do we still keep them in the district because I think that's my other problem is that I think a lot of our problem when we lose students is that seventh and eighth grade is where we start to lose some of the students we have a lot of kids in that PK through six we keep a lot of the the model and then we start to slowly lose them in certain parts and so it just feels very disjointed to me in some ways but again that's just my perspective so Mr Craig is is that the the thing of the it's elementary and middle and the high school is that it or in this transition there's going to be transitions for this phase I I just think I i'

395I'm very much concerned that we sit here and say that this what we're looking at our seats is what we're projecting like we're not projecting people we're projecting seats and because people make decisions that are very different and so going PK to five at each one of those while it's more consistent and I will give us that that it's this is a much more consistent version of what we were doing as far as those changes I'm just also concerned that the measure of 6 through we while it may keep some folks and it may bring some folks in it may also lose some people and that's what I I guess it's more to me about we we haven't really talked about programming we haven't really talked about what's going to be offered there that would

396entice a parent to say I need to keep my kid from sixth to great here as opposed to looking at other options and so that's just part of the thing for me with all of this is that we've talked a lot more about the the seats and the spots that we have about what's being offered and so it makes it a little harder for me to Vision that people won't say no but that's just me all right any comments so I just wanted to share part of how this came this was actually how uh ad hoc came to be a little bit because I was sharing with uh former board member moraski and um Jones and Bolton about how we we were I don't think we were Equitable in a as a district because we

397would provide transportation if I chose to go to a magnet school but we didn't provide transportation if you chose a neighborhood school and that seemed unfair it also seemed unfair that students who lived on Hamilton Avenue but and could look at Pleasant Hill were not allowed to go there because they had to go depending upon where they lived on Hamilton Avenue either to mount Ary and we had to provide them Transportation or for College Hill so the boundary lines definitely need to be drawn uh re redrawn um in that area but partnered with that um we we keep hearing from Ain is screaming 7eventh and eighth graders need to be out of their building they are at capacity and they are doing a disservice to their students if that's the building that said that they

398had two social workers for the entire building and if you if you go and you visit they are really really talking about that um and wanting them to have their own space so I've heard them also magnet status and please clarify superintendent Murphy magnet status was removed prior to me getting on the board they College Hill is College Hill fundamental Academy and they have not done fundamental in a very long time so when we talk about rightsizing some of these schools that have not had magnet uh we're talking about their magnet status being removed but that was done years ago prior to the it had previously been done many many years ago however we kept treating them like they were a magnet school including providing Transportation so a lot of this with regard to College

399Hill Academy I did ask a couple of those parents that I just happened to meet around what they thought about this plan again they were excited about the seventh and eighth graders getting specific services and then aen staff was very excited I think some of them sent us emails around the getting the seventh and eighth graders out of that building I do want to also say with regard to wenton Hills Academy we've got students that live in the W terce terrrace area across the street from each other some of them were being bust to Pleasant Hill some of them were being um sent to wh Hills Academy and it it just does not make sense economically for them to do that they're neighbors and they can't go to the same school and so while I

400don't know as much about Mount aring except for that it's on the west side and it needed to be um I I really do want to to support the requests from a bunch of different directions around the middle school option for aen high school and reducing some of that pressure so I just wanted to offer that any other comments questions um before I go to you member map I do want to do that invite kind of thing too for the College Hill uh students that are there that it they it the magnet status the actual magnet program is never it's not been practicing but there are people that I think need to be invited to remain uh for the duration before they are moving to their seventh grade so I just like to uh use

401that language to keep those families cuz a number of them have spoken to me yes so yes I just wanted to state that I also strongly oppose this recommendation but will abstain in my vote on the grounds of that I'm choosing to abstain in my vote so no grounds there is grounds okay for the record there are our grounds let's do the roll call Mr Craig no Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy no m m abstain Dr mofin yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes thank you and now we'll go to bundle eight Clark Silverton and Woodford superintendent present and we'll turn it into a board motion so the proposal for fiscal year 26 is at Clark monor High School will remain 7th through 12th grade however the following year they would become 9th through

40212th grade this is following a conversation with their lsdmc and then an additional conversation with the chair and the principal for fiscal year 26 Woodford Academy would remain prek to six the following year Woodford students would trans transition to Silverton for fiscal year 26 Silverton specialized classrooms and preschool would transition to Silverton Silverton grades K prek to six uh would not have their magnet status which has been previously removed they would receive the specialized classrooms and preschool classrooms for Woodford for fiscal year questions Mr Craig oh I'm sorry motion second thank you um so and we've talked about the right sizing our buildings and we talked about um needing buildings that were not under um under uh occupied and I guess my struggle with this is that we have a building that we're sitting there

403with 32 students in it that is not a part of this discussion whatsoever and I don't I just I just don't understand that because to me the building that's the easiest to move folks out of is the building with 32 people of which we can put into other programs and other spaces and you want to build a a seventh and eighth grade you want to build a six seven eighth grade whatever you want to do in Bramble all power be it to do it and then we could certainly focus on I mean I again I know the the whiffer folks had brought in ideas like being an arts school or like doing these type of programs that might draw in attention as well as we've been talking about we think programming would draw those Inspirations

404out I'm just again I just don't understand why we have not brought Bramble into the conversation and so like for me that's why large part this would lose my support because again we have a building that's we're talking about underutilized there is no building less utilized in our district than Bramble and so I ID like to comment if I could to that regarding Bramble is your thought then that you would uh be willing to put the uh Clark uh seventh and eighth grades uh at Bramble is that your suggestion I would not so for me I don't necessarily believe that we need to take the sth e8th grade out of Clark I think what we could do is have a similar program that might Foster the conversation again around having a second or or technically

405a third Monas high school that could be built off of building a 7th 8th nth grade program at Bramble um that would give us time to think about is there a location that might be the best suited spot for a high school program um for a third monory high school and I say that because I do think there is a value to what they do with ninth with seventh through 7th and eth talking with the ninth grade 10th graders 11th graders 12th graders and especially when you go to their programming now I think though there is an abundance of people we have now created as through monor programs that at sixth grade need to figure out a place to go right and so I do think there's space to do that at Bramble to build

406it up and potentially build up either a smaller version of or a potential Landing zone until we can find a better location I think there are some potential places around the city that could be um a location that we could talk about as a board if we wanted to make that as part of our long-term plan but I I just I there's a value to seventh and eighth grade in some places because of the way they built programming that to me you start to lose when you start to pulling them out completely uh uh vice president I think I'm still awake um regarding this particular slide can we actually split it up into different parts so with Clark monory maybe that being 8A in which we're just leaving it the 7th through 12th then going

407to the Woodford Academy um can we just leave Woodford as is stating taking away the Clark Junior High piece or whatsoever and then adding an additional Bramble piece and then the Silverton so actually it's a four-part four-part slide I know that was a lot well when the superintendent comes back and says yes or no it so I was going to suggest the same um I'm not I I've said before and I I'm so thankful to Clark lsdmc and administration for working on a resolution to fix it for this year because I think that that that's true collaboration however I the all of the experts that I've talked to have suggested that what is needed is another mle is another monu and we just simply don't have the money for that I proposed at the last

408meeting and nobody really bit my proposal but I said how about we start one grade at seventh grade and maybe utilize Bramble and it just it got no traction but I'm really not interested in the whole fiscal year 27 um I asked the superintendent to give me some research did she think that Woodford would be able to increase their numbers because if it were a numbers issue perhaps they could um and so that was what I was interested in seeing for this upcoming year is Woodford working to increase their numbers I don't know if that's a preschool I've heard that they can they can get a preschool with siblings um but that was kind of what I was was envisioning is we're talking about this year we're talking about this phase Clark has been very

409generous in agreeing to work with uh accepting all of the elig monory eligible students for this upcoming year Woodford has also agreed to work to increase their numbers and um Silverton I'm not exactly sure silverton's magnet status was removed a few years ago during ad hoc actually and they came to us and shared that they were concerned that their numbers were going down um I resorted to the history that we had in Jones and Bolton and they said that we would monitor that I'm just not I don't know if this is the solution that I was looking for for them so if I'm happy to approve this if amendments are made to keep Clark as a 7 through 12 next year Woodford um stays a seven stays with are right now for next year and

410then we do form the monu Consortium that is for uh Gamble Clark and we ideate around opening up another monstory middle school again I'm going to say when we talk about under enrolled buildings Bramble does speak out very very loudly around being the poster child for under enroll buildings and so I have a problem with that as well but but if it has those amendments I'm happy to support it um but I I'm not supporting messing with Clark or Woodford at this moment any other comments or questions Mr Crossett I guess it's more of a question uh Woodford we would be if it stays the same it's basically a neighbor would be a neighborhood School primarily or an East I should say it's an East Corridor school so with our corridor uh Arrangement that we've

411agreed to does there would be students that wouldn't go to Woodford anymore because they're out of the c or right would that happen or there's about um I want I believe the number is 32 students who live in the neighborhood who go to Woodford I believe is the number yes but there you could have um I'm thinking if there's people from West High going to Woodford wouldn't that fall out of the corridor uh I mean even with this plan keeping Woodford the same with the corridor structure they're going to lose some students just by the nature of the geography correct I don't know how many but some thank you Mr Carlson I I mean I think two things of that one is that we just moved some students into Woodford from Riverview area these are

412areas of which if we are actually doing this intentional marketing of our school programs that is why you build a program at a school we've just said that Woodward would increase their Ro and be able to maintain their loss lack of loss by having programming so if we added a particular focus of programming such as something like they actually asked us about which was an arts program so that they would have a Arts Focus so they could feed some place like SCPA you might you you very well might see a growth in the numbers uh but I think the other thing to it is and this goes into a little bit of the congestion at times in that area is that and I will give credit to Dr moff for bringing this to the the

413Forefront before the confusion maybe this happens better when you have Central enrollment management uh or management of enrollment centrally uh the confusion about where you could send your kid if you lived in Pleasant Ridge and did not want to be a pleasant Rich monu has been a longstanding problem at times unresolved so and again I think we've talked about it for like two years now about the fact that every year parents have been like I'm trying gr my kid somewhere else other than Pleasant Rich mon St we have resolved that no that's what I'm saying that's was something that we have long said had problems with yeah so like when we talk about parents and like people not being in the area I do think there's an aspect of some of this is just the

414reality is of where do kids get into where did the programs they get into and what they get to pick and then what do those programs offer now I will say I know specifically and again anecdotal knowledge so I won't take it as like being fact of every parent but I know parents who have sat there and said you know I really want my kid to get in this school but if they could not I want to go to school it's right down the street for me but there're zone for uh John P Parker like literally they live two blocks away from Woodford in a zone for John P Parker so I mean I think there is some aspect of us looking at and re and relooking at how the zoning works and how we're

415able to better accomplish it but I just simply sit there and say that if we're going to sit there and say that we can't get numbers in there because there's not numbers now I don't know how we then do and turn around and say we get numbers in Woodward when we don't have numbers now now like I think that's just part of my frustration when we talk about this but at last again all of this comes back to we talked about getting a bunch of kids in the Bramble and we got 32 so like let's let's have a real conversation about that building first before we talk about buildings that are not at 4% 10% capacity well I would I would like to propose something to move us off the dime on this one um

416in part um first of all it's kind of hard to build a central Corridor monu U on the east side of town uh where we already have uh three elementaries in high school so this is kind of absurd so these people we'd be building it there but I'm I'm into maybe we could do that you build a have the uh 90 some kids that are going to be turned away from um Clark except Clark said if we go ahead we'll accept those kids and be crowded for a while but let's say we don't put those 990 some kids into uh Clark and instead we uh decide that Bramble is going to be um a developing a monor school uh and the monor school will start with those 90 kids or whatever that were going to

417go to Clark uh and uh we are building that third monor High School wherever it may be located at Bramble for these first few years years is we're already trying to build something that little Taft that's in the central Corridor so there's some sense to that so if we did that then uh Clark would remain a 712 building in 712 building in a too small a building but that might be added to some sort of a levy thing to give them the floor that we they never got so if we could adjust this and say uh add the Bramble piece here how would that look if we are using Bramble it would have preschool it would continue some of its preschool efforts it would also uh be the start of another um monor high school

418and start with those 90 kids um what does that start to look like for folks regarding this effort does that change anything about Silverton I will say though years ago it was proposed by other board members to say that there should be no neighborhood attendance boundary lines that separate uh Silverton and JP Parker and Woodford that that should have been all one attendance boundary of those three schools so that people I mean that was actually long discussed so that might be an option too but I do want to be on the record that I I it's one thing to say that there's a hope that Rothenberg and um Hayes can build their neighborhood enrollment because they've got some and it's it's a hard game for me to believe that Woodford can now do that i''

419be that'd be great but they have not been able to do it and if they don't have their magnet status and the transportation not being provided from the west side of town it's you're putting them in a difficult situation but I would I would not be unsupportive of the uh ramble piece as being the uh beginning with the seventh and eighth grade the incoming seventh grade folks I have a question I have a comment yes ma'am so what I'm supportive of cuz I I I hate for our buildings to hear that we don't bet on you well I'm not betting on that so that's just me that's just me but one of the things that is also concerning to me and we have asked we asked the previous administration for 2 years to change the

420drop- down menu for PRM to suggest Silverton and um jpp and woodf and it never happened so organically we don't know if their enrollment could have increased because we didn't do what we needed to do and I see here the asri says an overlapping boundary permit students from PRM looking for non-m monory elementary experience to opt into Silverton but it should say Silverton John P Parker and Woodford and so again this doesn't feel comfortable to me what I do want to support is Clark monu accepting all of the students great Woodford staying the AL they are and then we form this Coalition and perhaps with everybody all these coaches and coming to the table they will be able to say that we can in a month or two work on plans to expand to another

421monory but I brought that up last time and not one person was supportive of that so I don't understand how now we can be supportive of it and when I was completely ignored last week so I'm interested in and thankful that Clark can take those students um Woodford if we were to I what I would like to suggest is that we do with Integrity change the drop- down menu that even PRM has been asking about that we've been promising that we would do and never got done and see if those numbers do increase um and then leave Silverton alone they don't they're not they don't have to take any students um from Woodford right now I guess I just don't understand that why why there's the rush to do that they haven't had magnet status

422now for 2 years if not three so why do they have to have um the specialized in preschool classrooms that's a question I'm asking Administration CU it says here receive specialized and preschool classrooms from Woodford so their enrollment had been declining because they didn't have the magnet status and could not take advantage of the transportation so it's it's it's it's a bundle situation in terms of being able to have that enrollment increase and yet and still have space to be able to accept all sixth graders who want that monitory experience so that was this administration's approach of course can't speak to the past I got you can you confirm for me what the drop- down menu says for PRM students right now it is it's a neighborhood school but does it give an option other

423than PRM that is my understanding yes that it Silverton or John P Parker is my understanding okay I really like for that to be confirmed if we could even add Woodford as an option as well because it didn't have it that I that I knew of um it was I thought it was still displaying not those options but I would love to be wrong on it I just want to confirm that the drop down for PRM is enabling students to choose the other and then make sure that we're not doing anything um around the circle to inact John P Parker boundary lines and woodford's um enrollment too those are just some of the things I'm ready to vote if you want to vote on I think we heard from a parent tonight that was in

424the uh PRM uh boundary and they decided to go to Woodford and that's been such a great experience maybe I'm missing that but I thought there was a parent that that said that uh I I do want to add right before this the reason that I'm not willing right now to say um those 90 kids will go to Clark then people that on the wait list is we were willing to do that against the agreement that we have with the neighborhood and the community to go over the top so of of the folks being there and so Clark was willing to take them and we were basically doing a wink of a blink to the Hy Park Community in this agreement so I would I'm I'm more than willing for folks to think in terms

425of those 90 kids are building the the new as we do uh the next monor high school at uh uh Bramble but I would say that we will have to start with the 90 kids that wanted to sign up for Clark that aren't going to get in there that would give you 90 people at at Bramble to start the monor yes ma'am are we separating these out or will they just be one particular slide well superintendent's here and tell her how you would mention separating I think uh possibly doing an 8A for Clark Clark monor excuse me staying 7 through 12th doing a 8B where wooder stays as is doing an 8C were silverton's days as is and then adding something about Bramble and I wasn't quite sure what we stated about Bramble so no

426changes at Woodford Clark or Silverton I split them up into four different choices because as of right now it would just be the one slide saying all three things okay but those but those three schools would remain the same and what we have to do is find a way to deal with the Bramble piece and the suggestion would be at least my suggestion would then start to fill Bramble with the building the Monas high school well I think with the Clark Monas we were going to go ahead and keep it the 7th through 12th accepting the sixth graders since they already stated that well they said that but the hide Park Community hasn't said we're allowed to disagree with their with the community uh agreement and that agreement is we've been enforcing that agreement for

427a a couple of years if we'll recall and anyone else feel free to add in my a C or D okay Craig I was just gonna say I I I haven't heard from the superintendent about the idea you repos I think the struggle again is that if we what Clark agreed to do was with the premise that they would not have the students the very next year so I don't know that Clark would say that that's what they agree to is to have the additional 90 students exactly just in perpetuity kind of idea um so I think it's fair to ask us to look at the options that you propos with Bramble but I I guess I would want to ask the superintendent whether that's a viable option be given um those responsibilities with regards

428to how you would prepare Bramble as a building and I think it's the same things you would have to do for Woodford anyway um or maybe more maybe less whatever but I guess I just would like to hear superintendent's thoughts Clark sir you're right uh board member Craig did not agree with me to do this in perpetuity for sure uh I'm happy to investigate um Bramble uh as a monitory option I might be giving myself a little pause about starting two monitory options at the same time but we can come back to that Mr Crossett just to clarify so uh the kids that want to go to Clark the seventh graders that want to go to Clark I guess it's a lottery they get in and it would be the Overflow kids that would go

429to potentially Bramble is that or or if kids who selected Bramble sure so can we call a vote on I don't well the motion has been accepted and seconded so I'm just as a proceed just okay thank you for the help but what do we have we have four parts of the motion makers seconders we haven't accepted the amendment that's well that's what I'm saying that's why we can't vote I I mean I I quite honestly think we could just vote on the amended version that you proposed again possibly making it as an exploration more so than just a definitive at this point but um because I think there may be some questions that they have not necessarily priced out figured out whatever um but I think voting on each individual part we're going to

430end up putting ourselves in a bad position where one part passes but the other part doesn't then we still can't do the one part I'm wondering if the board would consider um Clark accepting all of the students next year with us uh looking into uh brambo as an option moving forward with uh a stud stud group helping us to do that leaving Woodford as is leaving Silverton as isard members can you repeat that so you're saying for Clark monor are you leaving at 7 through 12 for fiscal year 26 M Clark monory would be 7 through 12 accepting all Rising sixth graders investigating an addition School opportunity at Bramble but that would be bless you for fiscal year 27 that would give us a year leaving Woodford as it is leaving Silverton as it is

431with concern from Administration on enrollment could I ask didn't we kind of within the um Hayes and Rothenberg how to make some mention that indeed were committed to increasing the enrollment and I think if we added that to this uh that would be I don't think they should have less responsibility than Hayes and renberg have to increase their enrollment on the east side of town versus downtown we ready for a vote any other comment and based upon what the superintendent just decided the motion makers and seconders are good yes we're taking Clark 7 through 12th investigating another option but still keeping it 7 through 12th for next year for only for next year then the following year you're moving it to 9th through 12th no no no no okay um it'll still be 7th through

43212th but within the confines of the numbers that they desire for example right now it's like 135 7th graders Mr Craig go ahead yeah I think and then I think the point that the superintendent was making is that that gives us another year to look at what we ultimately will end up having to do with Clark um while and again I think some of our lovely colorful folks like to call it putting putting it our kicking the can down the line but I think the reality is we don't have the information at this point to make definitive as to say this is what's going to happen at brano or this is what's going to happen here and even to your point if we get to a point where we find another building that made more

433sense to be the central monor it almost makes sense to then be like hey now we got to sprout the folks out we get programs growing and we'd have a seventh and eighth grade potentially of folks who might want to take advantage of that so I think it's a fair uh compromise we ready for a vote so I just have a point know what we're voting on I have a point of clarification so we're going to take the are we taking out to what board member Craig just said that it is going to be at Bramble or are we just exploring that idea because what I'm hearing is and what I'm going to report is Clark currently is going to take the Overflow and then we will talk about where it goes not necessarily say

434it's going at Bramble but we're going to talk about that and then we're going to leave Woodford alone and leave Silverton alone yeah yes ma'am I agree with that uh I I would my Paws about the Bramble thing and I understand something needs to be done with Bramble on the side note I would like to focus on truly a central pathway if there's going to be a third monory but we can still we will still look into what we could do with Bramble and understanding for Clark the the agreement was it's one year of them absorbing all of the rising sixth graders okay thanks okay ready for a vote roll call Mr Craig yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy abstaining m m [Music] abstain Dr mofin yes vice president weberg yes with the specific changes

435that you stated and president Bolton no and I go to bundle 10 no nine good nine is easier bundle nine uh talks about Rising star at Carthage Hartwell school and bondil Academy The Proposal is that Hartwell school would serve students in grade five six seven and 8 and we've already agreed to one of the welcome centers being there and then Carthage school would be a preate of four uh pulling grades 2 through four from Hartwell and at Bond Hill pre 6 there would be no change Alo moved is there a second second thank you any questions comments by I just have one question in terms of adding the grades two um through four to Carthage will they have the space it's going to be tight and what is tight we may need to add maybe

436possibly oh a modular unit maybe it just depends the rationale behind this at this point board member wyberg vice president is that the number of multilanguage Learners we see coming in at preschool is increasing and so on one hand to put the Welcome Center there and understand that those services are needed might be more of a disservice to the students and families if we move some of those preschool classrooms you may remember those preschool classrooms we were suggest in would come to bondil we're pulling back on that recommendation just because of the demographics of the families and support available having that Welcome Center Brandon um just question I know when they originally opposed it again they were adding the third and fourth to Rising Stars Carthage right and then and so I just didn't know

437if it keeping the fourth grade was a significant difference at at um Hardwell so I'm thinking about the alignment around middle schools and typically starting at least fifth grade I fourth grade might be a push I just didn't know because of spacewise that's what I bit more yeah we can look at that and revisit that bring that back to the board but you know they're like 10 year old I think N9 10 yeah and only reason I said that is again because from spatial wise numbers I know it's going to be super tight at Carthage and I and I would rather not have a student in a trailer if we I agree um so I mean I I'm don't necessar have a problem with this one I would just say maybe also just considering whether

438or not four or fifth grade would be that starting point any other questions comments before we vote all right um change sorry roll call I guess Mr Craig yes Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mofin yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton yes and now we do a bundle 10 bundle 10 sorry um focuses on Carson and trying to alleviate some of the pressures around Carson in terms of the heavy enrollment and shifting of uh the attendance boundaries for Carson thank you so moved is there a second second to accept uh superintendent's proposal comments questions discussion about the boundary lines all right oh wait I have a question so does this align with what we had seen from the presentation I think at the work session from uh Jeremy around we're

439going to shift this street or this this small line and racy price would get a huge number of students and then Carson would be lower but the next year it would kind of swap is this aligned with that so it's uh shifting 75 students from Carson to REI price that are current kindergarten through fifth grade students and reesi price is what grade level they're prek at six currently and shifting 35 students from Carson to kovale current kindergarten through fifth grade students any other questions comments roll call on bundle 10 Mr CRA yes Mr Crossett yes Mr Lindy nope Miss map no Dr Moffet no vice president weberg everyone's looking at me this one is a hard one am I able to ask a quick question I know that we were done with question question ask

440start the voting so now okay would it help you make a decision yes it will um what happens if for the the students the shift the 75 and the 35 if we don't do that will the Carson still be overcrowded in terms of their numbers and there would be no other option yes ma'am this is this is um shift to the east this is a shift to the Southwest if you look at where reesi price is in relationship to Carson and where kovale is in relationship to Carson yes thank you vice president or president Bolton uh yes moving on cons vice president yes so I have a a question I wanted to ask um treasure Wagner if it was a possibility to pull back up bundle number four I know that a vote was taken

441already but I wanted to know if it could be a possible Amendment due to the fact um I do not understand that with this particular vote with r would be staying a 9 through um yes excuse me 7 through 12 uh General Council we have a I don't it's not a change for a vote but it's a re something or other um go for it meeting go for KRA sorry a board member can move to amend a prior act in a meeting if there's a second that's taken up as a motion and decided before and and if if approved then then it would amend a prior action alternatively you can move to reconsider the the vote in the first place that's taken up as a separate motion if approved there'll be a second vote okay

442so I would like to put up a motion that I say say that part again I don't know what you're asking me do the last the last one that you said to reconsider moving to reconsider you need a second bundle four second now there's a vote on whether or not we accept to to reconsider and then you would take a second vote on so we need a roll call now without discussion I hope Mr Craig no Mr Crossett yes Mr lindia nope m m no no Dr mofin yes I think we're just voting how we voted the first time right you're voting to reconsider okay yes uh vice president Weber yes president Bolton yes and now the motion would be reconsideration is Dan reconsideration has occurred so this is a motion that somebody would make

443taking the new one okay go for it so I have to say the motion all over again okay I am asking for us to Reon revote for bundle for under the understanding that Withrow High School would not be 7th through 12th it's going to the 9th through 12th everything else Frederick Douglas School PK through 5th Evanson Academy 7 through 8th so the bundle as was proposed yes is there a second second I think any discussion question Mr Crosset uh question what is the uh attendance at with her are they full or uh very full any other discussion or question r call Mr Craig nope Mr crosson yes Mr Lindy no Miss map no Dr mofin yes vice president weberg yes president Bolton yes all right bar that's completes the bundles and uh I would like

444to have a motion um I would like to have a motion to accept the consent agenda as published some move is there a second second are there any exceptions to the consent agenda and is the treasurer prepared to continue writing uh any exception and the acceptor I'm sorry I missed the who made the motion Dr and Mr Crosset you seconded vote I'm sure I have exceptions but just give me a moment you have an exception do you know which what it is I know it's been like four days since we started does the consent agenda include the it's not including the treasures report or the yes okay so yes then I would like to uh vote Yes on the treasurers Report with the um exception I think was page 10 okay on item 18 yes

445so page 10 item 18 and then I would also like to to vote Yes on the superintendent Report with the exception of recommendation 4 recommendation four four and you're abstaining from both mhm um but while I'm asking can we have discussion around that so superintendent uh Murphy could you please explain what the redesign of the digital academy is and what that this recommendation is entailing yes ma'am so we are looking at the uh Gilligan Digital Academy in terms of the cost to us in terms of uh attendance of the students in terms of um grade reporting of the students and so we've done that um audit and wanted the board needed have to have the board know that that was taking place and we'll come back with a recommendation to you to redesign our Digital

446Academy okay have we received information about what the audit entails around this recommendation you will get that with the recommendation for redesign but I thought the recommendation for redesign is stated in this report you you asked me did you get the report no I asked did we get the yes did we get the audit information about this particular I don't think you've gotten the audit uh information that comes when we give you our recommendation for how it's to be redesigned okay so this is just asking for the initial opportunity to do a redesign of this is I believe my requirement is to make sure you are aware that this is the work we're doing okay all right thank you but it still stands okay all right um and uh we've had the accept and the

447accepter we good um yeah Mr Craig yes Mr cron yes Mr Lindy yes Miss map yes Dr Moffett yes yes vice president Weinberg yes president Bolton thank you and the consent agenda is adopted and and prior to us moving for adjournment uh and assignments I would want to make sure that Miss Davis knows that for the next board meeting uh we would be talking about the resolution amending board policy 02 leave for employment by a community school and we'll carry that forward to the next meeting and uh are there any assignments seeing none we'll also entertain a motion toward your yeah just wanted to reiterate to I know the treasurer spoke about this if uh bring it back to a future board meeting the information about cops oh yes thank you the cops uh report

448so to speak all right motion to adjourn so moved second um

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.