001e e e okay noting the hour and a presence of a quorum I call the AC boxboro Regional school committee to order members of the public who wish to watch the meeting May do so online using ACT and TV's YouTube channel found at the top of our agenda as a reminder this meeting is being recorded and will be posted on actant TV's website at actant tv.org thank you act TV um in fact I would encourage if you're thinking of coming in tonight to watch the uh meeting probably better to stay at home because we're sitting on stairs and piano benches at this point in here so welcome everybody great to have such a a big audience this evening all right we're going to move into public participation um and I'll read my thing first and
002then I will ask a question to the group here so per our pool school committee policy Beed members of the public are invited to speak um typically for up to 3 minutes public participation will only take place during this time at our meeting speakers must be recognized by the chair and as a reminder the committee does not typically respond to comments made during public participation can I see by a show of hands how many people here this evening wish to speak so that we can figure out there was a a gasp and a groan all at once um all right so I'm I'm gonna allocate more than usual I'll give ourselves 30 minutes but I'm going to ask everybody to keep to two minutes in their speaking so that everyone here does have an opportunity
003to speak I don't want to cut off public participation but I do recognize a lot of you have concerns that you want to communicate to the committee I want to give everybody that time but I also need to keep the meeting moving forward so I'm going to set a 30 minute timer on my phone and then we're going to also Time Each speaker for a maximum of two minutes so when you hear me I'll probably give you about a 30- second warning please start to wrap it up so that the next folks here can speak this evening let's do this then we'll have the first person who's interested in speaking come up to the microphone and then if you want to begin a queue um behind that we can move through all of the speakers
004uh pretty quickly and if you wouldn't mind please do um give us your name and address uh uh or at least whether or not you're a resident of Acton or boxboro uh when you do come up to speak so setting a 30 minute timer go ahead all right we're we're not going to be able to readjust the microphone for each speaker cuz I only want to spend 30 minutes on this we got a lot to talk about hi meline Cruz six way acon I'm here tonight because recently life has thrown some curve walls at me that has left me um in need of help and recently I had um vouchers and when I was looking for after school care for my daughter um I was informed that acting boxboro no longer takes vouchers and I
005think that you all need to reconsider that because a lot of our family here in Acton are desperate and need to have the school accept these vouchers again without it I mean we're screwed and my daughter not only needs it because I need to move forward with my life and get my life back on track but she has disabilities and it's a recommendation from her neuros pych and I need the help and I really do wish that you would all Rec consider to start accepting these vouchers again I know that they ended during covid for whatever reason it's something that's our community needs and I'm asking you to please do your due diligence to make sure that these vouchers are accepted again thank you thank you uh my name is Amanda Monto I'm a reading
006specialist in AC and boxboro um I'm speaking tonight because you will receive a report or you have received a report dealing with a lot of things but the use of time of math and reading Specialists was part of it I can say that we were pretty shocked when we saw some of the numbers and I know they've been adjusted but you'll get a report that says we spend less than 75% much less than 75% of our time with students and our lived experience is that we seem to spend all our time with students so I've done the math for my own schedule and I know for the bare minimum work week that's 2100 minutes that's what the math was based off of that you received but the fact is that elementary students are physically in
007school for 1,800 minutes per week if you're looking at the time that students are actually in school I spend 69% of that time with them if you include my lunch and prep which I desperately need and I'm contractually o uh obliged to have then that accounts for 86% of the school day at my school there are also times in which every student in the building is in an important or community building activity so they're not actually available for intervention services so we have all school assembly morning meeting learning buddies where grade levels get together do wonderful things like kindergarteners and sixth graders bonding it's beautiful but if you account for those times I'm with students 98% of the time that they're in a building available to have intervention the 2% of time happens to be
008a 10minute gap between two of our intervention blocks so 98% of the time I'm with students when they can have intervention um so I just want to make it clear that there is not hidden easy efficiency that can be drawn out of the reading and math Specialists um the goal of us spending more time supposedly is to see more students but there isn't time to see an additional group when I am pulled out of a meeting for mtss 504 iup then I can miss groups but I wouldn't have time to see other groups like I If you don't have me go to those meetings I can have more time with the students I already have but I wouldn't actually be able to add more so I just want that to be clear um and I
009would like to with a warning about the possibility of eliminating reading assistants I know it's not on that report or on the table yet but it's been recommended before and just let you know they do half of the intervention in my school for reading so even if I pulled kids from assembly it would never make up for what they do all right thank you thank you good evening my name is Allison Sims I am the art teacher at Mariam Elementary School uh this is my seventh year teaching here at Mariam but my 14th year teaching in public schools I'm here tonight to speak on the proposed cuts to our Specialist Team and why I feel it would be detrimental to our elementary students learning and well-being if you go to our school district website the
010first thing that you will see is the following statement developing engaged well-balanced Learners through collaborative and caring relationships followed by our core values which are Wellness equity and engagement in a time when we are seeing an alarming increase in the needs of our student population why are we presenting even more cuts to staff who work directly with our students as a specialist I see every single student in our school each week for me that means 397 children and I have the pleasure of helping these students grow and develop from kindergarten through sixth grade this has allowed me to get to know and care for my students in a way that is unique to my specialist position as we are the only ones in the building that know the entire student body by the time students
011leave sixth grade it often feels as if I'm saying goodbye to family we know deep in our hearts and from all the data that exists out there that caring relationships with students matter it is in fact so important that it is written into our core values statement finally I want to add that I was deeply saddened to see that our class assistants were described as loow hanging fruit in a document created by the elementary budget task force describing Professionals in our district who love and care for our students every day as lwh hanging fruit strikes me as the opposite of our core value of equity I want to work in a place where all people are valued equally and I hope that you do as well thank you thank you good evening my name my
012name is Jill Reed and I'm the physical education specialist at the gates Elementary School I've been teaching in the ACT box Acton boxboro schools for more than 20 years I've been full-time at gates for the past 12 years before that I spent my time in two buildings a week and I have also taught in four of the six elementary schools I've had firsthand experience of what it's like to teach in two different schools during the school week you don't feel like you really belong to either Community there are different cultures in each SCH school and you aren't able to build strong relationships with students or staff as a unified Arts educator in one Elementary School one of the best parts of my job is to be able to build a seven-year relationship with students to
013me that's huge we meet these Learners as 5-year-olds and watch them grow into young adolescents as they finish sixth grade I feel that since I've been in the same building as a full-time unified Arts educator I have not I have been able to make better connections and relationships not only with with students but also with their families when the unified Arts Educators have the opportunity to work in the same building for an extended period we can collaborate more effectively with our colleagues we can share insights and build a shared vision for the development of our schools Community this Fosters an environment of innovation and consistency which is essential for creating a highquality educational experience for all students over time these relations relationships contribute to students success not only in physical education but also in the
014broader academic and social context 30 seconds consistent and stable relationships with students also enable us unified Arts Educators to better understand individual student needs strengths and challenges which Fosters a stronger sense of connection and belonging within the school Community when the unified Arts educators are present daily in the buildings we're better positioned to align our instruction with the school's values priorities and ongoing initiatives thank you for letting me speak thank you good evening my name is Brendan Ferrari I live at two marttin street with my wife Jen and my two kids Nicholas and Benjamin who attend school at Douglas I'm also the music teacher at Gates like my colleagues and others I'm speaking tonight to express my disappointment with the budget task force before teaching and act in boxboro I taught Elementary music in West
015per uh Westford Public Schools my position similar to what is being recommended here was to travel between three different grade grades 3 through five schools to cover the classes that the resident teacher at each School couldn't fit in their course load though I technically belong to three different schools I didn't feel a sense of belonging at any of them building staff were welcoming but I felt like I was borrowing teaching spaces from the resident teachers and substitute teaching their kids I can never be part of all School meetings and I often wasn't able to conduct my own performances because I was elsewhere the students were very kind but there was always a sense of I wasn't lucky to get my teacher this year who I've known since kindergarten instead I got the traveling guy and
016not only that but the traveling guy was almost never the same person over the years because this had constant turnover in this type of position curricularly it was a nightmare just like here in Acton boxboro each music room was a different size in shape and has significant differences in instruments equipment materials which forc me to create multiple and quite frankly inequitable curricula for kids of the same grades across schools 30 seconds third grade wasn't so bad because they had three years with their resident teacher at their K through2 school so I knew exactly what they had done with their resident teacher they all took one path to get to me but for higher grades they consisted of a mixture of kids that had the resident teacher and or the traveling guys in varying years are
017paths and this continues to multiply so if this were to happen in act in boxboro over 7even years from K through six a six grade class could potentially be a mixture of 64 different paths that kids could take bouncing back and forth thank you brenon thank you good evening my name is Mary O'Brien I'm the physical education teacher at the Mariam school I was shocked to learn of the proposal to reduce the elementary specialists in act and if you only look at the cost of of our FTE salaries and the numbers of students at each of our schools you miss our value as contributors to Unique welcoming and compassionate learning communities committed to multilanguage Learners children from diverse backgrounds neurodiverse Learners with unique learning needs children with trauma in their current or past lives and
018Universal Design to teach all Learners the best ways Acton has valued those caring and engaging types of learning communities and trained us or pushed us to to change the way that we teach or look at teaching and to not just teach our unique curriculums but to learn more about and advocate for our most fragile Learners to receive the best learning opportunities this is my 20th year in Acton and I remember one the for specialists at the five act in schools for the elementary model was upgraded to one FTE per specialty per building in 2012 the high school had experienced some Mental Health crisis and the district had hired a Stanford consultant to analyze the Staffing and culture at the high school to do more to help all students feel connected to a trusted teacher and
019seen at school our superintendent Steve Mills felt it was important for our elementary students to also feel seen and cared for the same message of Leslie's trauma informed schools Approach at that time the district made the decision to support student mental health in all schools including the elementaries and develop stronger student teacher connections 30 seconds under the single School model we all felt and still feel more connected to and able to see students and teachers and advocate for more of our students learning thank you thank you hello my name is Jennifer Ferrari and I live at two Martin Street my husband Brendan and I have two Elementary age children in the district at Douglas Elementary School I am also a visual art teacher in a neighboring School District I was originally going to focus my
020time on the positive impact of full-time teachers on student achievement how reduced positions negatively impact teacher morale and how part-time positions create lack of curricular continuity for students but I'll leave that to my colleagues in this room who also came to speak tonight because I trust and value their acute perspectives and expertise and that brings me to what I'd like to talk about how the school committee AB School leadership and the members of the elementary budget task force mistreated and disrespected our treasured teachers throughout this process from the task force brainstorming document on December 3rd it was clear to me that quote the goal of this brainstorm was not to fact check each response but to better understand perspectives on each potential recommendation I'm sorry but I failed to see how assuming how someone else
021will perceive something is more beneficial or direct than going to the source the teachers whose positions are in question these professionals who together have Decades of experience were blindsided eight days ago with recommendations that the Integrity of their positions is in Jeopardy when the conversation at the task force meetings became about people who were not present in the room contact should have at least been made to the program director of those affected I understand that balancing a budget is hard work but being a kind empathetic human being is not these loyal professionals have been treated just like the report from new Solutions K12 treated them as numbers that can easily be subtracted and divided new Solutions K12 called their recommendations and the findings quote opportunities who are they opportunistic for because it isn't the professionals
022referenced in the report you know I see a lot of words like transparency Trust and relationships being used on the AB School website when talking about core values and beliefs but words like this mean nothing if not followed by actions for example according to the 2021 to 2026 District strategy a belief of ab schools is to quote build relationships and trust with students families and colleagues where it is safe to make mistakes and learn from others well I can tell you one thing for certain you have irreparably damaged the relationships you have with these individuals and broken the trust they placed in you a very big mistake was made and I certainly hope that the leadership before me intends to take ownership ownership of it a public apology for the disrespect shown for our beloved
023teachers should be just the beginning thank you good evening my name is Michelle Alam and I'm the library media teacher at Conan Elementary I'm here today because I want to make sure that despite the task force and Consultants findings um key information in the areas of how we use our time when we are not teaching a class and our value frankly should be know known um aside from the obvious of grading assignments differenti differentiating instruction based on ongoing observations of student need students that we know um and of course administering a library facility there's one key component that significantly affects our students and that is the ability to collaborate when I say collaboration yes there's the collaborating on research and schoolwide enrichment but more importantly is the collaboration with regard to our shared students and
024their needs so set as everything else that we do and just focus on The Following over the past two years I've gotten to know my students really well I know what they can do and I know how and when I can push them so when I see a significant change in a students's academic and behavior development from one year to the next I become concerned and I do something about it and when that happens I meet with the classroom teacher and others to bring up concerns I have with a students present levels of performance if it doesn't match what's in their IEP we meet to share information with each other and brainstorm accommodations we come up with a plan we try out in the meantime I take all that meet all that stuff we discussed
025in our meeting and I meet with the rest of my buildings unified Arts colleagues to share what I learned in including the strategies and then we begin a plan to observe the student over the course of a few weeks so that we can provide the classroom teacher with data that better pinpoints this particular student's challenges which in the long run in the moral of the story helps to get us to get the student the support they desperately need but don't currently have just going to jump to the end then um so there's there's all this about you know importance of developing student relationships and it doesn't matter what kind of you know you could have the best learning objectives in essential questions and differentiated supports but forget the lesson if if you don't have a
026strong student teacher relationship they're just they're not going to learn um and that is what when I see my students every day day after day after day I building that relationship with them so when discussing schedules when discussing the consequences of your decisions please discuss the consequences of not being able to meet with each other and our colleagues to support our students and the consequences of not being able to build relationships with our students if we can't see them day after day after day thank you thanks yeah we have significantly different heights uh good evening my name is Heather Haynes and oh that's terrible um I wear many different hats in this community first and foremost I'm a parent of a 19-year-old who graduated last year and a 17-year-old Junior My Hope for my children
027is that they're cared for appreciated and supported to become the wonderful adults we're thinking about in our vision of a graduate work I'm also currently the elementary curriculum coordinator and for before that spent 10 years focused on math in the elementary schools thanks um our District's work of the past seven years to create a multi-tiered system of support is the work I believe makes our children feel appreciated cared for and supported to become the wonderful adult members of our community that we hope for mtss as you all know starts with tier one and this is where all students have access to grade level learning the work that classroom teachers do to support all students is hard work and is often done in isolation the Steam and literacy coaches are critical thought partners for educators to
028support this important work in tier one to help all students to access tier one instructions some students need support in tier 2 and tier three and some of that support can happen with teachers and some of that support is with the math and literacy is happening with our math and reading Specialists who have the expertise and understanding of the progression of skills students must build from kindergarten through sixth grade and Beyond in tier one instruction 2 seconds we all acknowledge including myself the critical importance of literacy and I want to all also share that numeracy is equally important longitudinal studies done in the UK have shown that weak numeracy impacts students future income health and educational outcomes throughout their lives low numeracy skills also shut students out of opportunities in college and careers and our
029math and reading Specialists act as supports and advocates for students and our critical members of our team of professionals that make this system work I don't have time list all the folks who are critical parts of this system but unified Arts Educators counselors psychologists all make the system work thank you good evening my name is Celia Knight I have taught visual arts for the last 17 years at the gate school I am also the visual arts uh Elementary liaison who oversees the elementary visual arts department uh to offer a different angle on these proposed Cuts I now want to specifically focus on the work of the Elementary Visual Arts teachers in this District because that is what I know best our Visual Arts Elementary team collaborates incredibly successfully in curriculum development and supports each other
030in teaching in a way that is not typical in other districts over my 17 years with the district I have been told multiple times by AB administrators that the Elementary art department is a model of what successful collaboration looks like this Caliber Caliber of commitment provides our students with highly effective and engaging Visual Arts interdisciplinary learning experiences throughout their Elementary career I know I'm able to bring my best self to do this incredibly important work because I've always felt very valued as an integral part of this District I bring the same level of commitment to the many steam collaborations I do at Gates if I was at multiple schools I know I would no longer have the capacity to bring such commitment to this type of C collaboration and dedication to curriculum development AB attracts
031and builds incredibly successful and Innovative Elementary Visual Arts teachers that have won multiple Massachusetts teacher and new teach Teacher of the Year Awards I've been part of many hiring committees when a visual arts position opens in our district applicants flock to apply if the school committee imposes these cuts to the unified Arts this trend will most definitely end AB will no longer attract the best no teacher wants to work in more than one school it cuts you in half your time in half your positive mindset in half your patience in half and your dedication to your craft they are all Whitted down we talk about the importance of the whole child all the time at AB why aren't we trading our teachers with the same values with experience teachers grow and improve over time by
032making these Cuts I know my students will suffer because I will not be able to be the teacher I want to be for them lastly I just want to say that um the gates unified Arts teachers teach 100 plus pre- students at the um Carol Huber Early Education Program um and I don't think this information has been talked about at all in the um the new Solutions um review and I I'm assuming that we would they would be losing their um unified Arts programing completely thanks hi my name is Laura Harrington I'm the library media specialist at MC I'm new to MC this year but this is my 20th year as a school library media teacher and I am standing before you today because I am concerned I am concerned that in their slide deck
033new Solutions K12 lists 2.0 full-time Library employees at mcti and Miriam and at Gates and Douglas the miam and Douglas libraries are staffed by dedicated hardworking Library assistance not qualified Library school media teachers they are paid accordingly if the district has allocated teacher salaries to those schools and the employees are collecting assistant wages where is the difference in funding I am concerned that new Solutions implies that anyone teaching fewer than 25 classes a week is not working full-time I teach 20 to 22 classes a week and the rest of my time is spent doing a number of tasks as are all my library media colleagues we are when we are not teaching we are gathering resources for classroom teachers we are organizing and evaluating Library materials and I'm concerned because I have been tasked with
034maintaining the library collection shared by two schools because I am the qualified School library media teacher yet my schedule provides me no additional time to perform these duties I am concerned because AB elementary students do not attend technology classes and cuts are being suggested to the library media program digital citizenship coding and Engineering are all being taught in the elementary school libraries in accordance with the mass digital literacy and computer science standards in addition to us teaching media literacy evaluation ethical use of information when my position is eliminated because of short-term cost reductions what will be the long-term consequences for elementary students who are no longer receiving this instruction how will AB students achieve academic success without these schools research shows people schools with professionally staffed School libraries have higher Reading Writing information literacy scores
035as well as higher graduation rates studies show that title one schools and English language Learners recognize even greater academic success with certified School library media teachers concerned with the shortsightedness of suggesting reducing Elementary Specialists across the district thank you thank you please folks I'm trying to get as many people to participate as possible when you take extra time you're taking time from your colleagues two minutes go ahead dear school committee my name is Marley castle and I am the music teacher at Miriam school I have been teaching for 10 years with seven of those years being at Miriam and I'd like to share the potential impact of losing members of our unified Arts team on our schools and our students I read through the presentation given from nsk2 Consulting and the proposals the elementary budget
036task force has shared I first want to share how upsetting it was to learn of these discussed Cuts via the school website and not from any administrator or Committee Member I find that to be very unprofessional especially when we're talking about direct impacts to our students and to people's livelihoods my department head was not interviewed as a stakeholder in this process he's the only Department leader our district has left after the decision was made to not rehire the PE or visual arts department leader Z years ago if anyone should have been interviewed as a stakeholder it's him I'm wondering if the school committee asked about how this trickles down to not only affect students but also the everyday functioning of our elementary schools my colleagues and I are certified teachers with master's degrees but we
037also serve other roles in our schools like drop off duty in the morning bus Duty after school and occasionally covering other classes in the building one more item not accounted for in the presentation is that the number of sections does not accurately reflect what we teach each week some of us teach adaptive PE chorus and extra rotation classes to cover those mtss data meetings and while I appreciate the budget task Force's consideration of the potential benefits and disadvantages of The Proposal it must be said that some of the potential benefits are not benefits at all I'd encourage all of you to look at for example the benefits box of proposal 4B and ask yourself whether those supposed benefits actually are it is stated that the proposed cut was an easy no-brainer solution referring to a
038proposal that is potentially so detrimental to students well-being School community and to profession as an easy no-brainer solution is inconsiderate shortsighted and insulting do I really want do we really want students to see multiple teachers throughout their Elementary years if you cut one position from every single Department there will be effectively be effectively be one Elementary School that loses their entire Specialist Team lastly I want to say that when I started teaching at AB I thought that this District might be where I retire as much as I'd like for that to happen I'm wondering if that's going to be possible at this point I simply hope I get to decide that for myself and that the loyalty to this community hasn't been for nothing hello and good evening my name is Marga Ingam I'm a
039first grade teacher at Blanchard I'm here tonight to share my thoughts regarding the recent recommendations from the task force to reduce classroom assistance as a teacher in the district for 28 years I've worked closely with many of our assistants I've seen the positive impact they have with both students and teachers the academic de demands have greatly increase a need for additional support for our students our classroom assistants play a key role in helping to support Tier 1 instruction during mtss blocks by supporting small reading and math groups during Ela and math assistance support positively increases students time on Learning Classroom assistants work directly with students supporting their academic social and emotional needs throughout the day oftentimes our assistants are our eyes and ears to help navigate the many challenges our students face whether it's tying
040a shoe zipping a coat finding a lost water bottle taking them to the nurse when they've lost their first tooth or even helping them communicate hurt feelings with a peer on the playground classroom assistants are the heart and soul of what it takes to support and encourage our most vulnerable students on a daily basis and they are passionate about their jobs in addition with the increasing ml population teachers have seen firsthand how classroom assistants play a crucial role in helping these students acclimate to the classroom and school setting by providing the necessary onetoone support classroom assistants are are our Most Valuable Personnel in the district and to reduce their pos position especially at the elementary level would greatly impact our school climate when making these Cuts please consider the direct impact on students before you
041make your decisions we should not be cutting the Personnel who work directly with our students as an educator I can't say enough how much our classroom assistants matter thank you thank you Mar thank you hi my name is Marin Gulliver I live on School Street and in the K to6 literacy coach shared between the Blanchard and conut schools I've worked in the district for the past 10 years as a classroom teacher and now in my current role I've attended the ab elementary schools since kindergarten including being a student in this very very old building my roots in the schools are deep and I very much hope that for my own two young children will have access to the incredible learning opportunities at AB in the next coming years I'd like to acknowledge and appreciate the
042leadership of Tori and Peter in leading the incredibly challenging work of the M budget task force I was grateful to participate in the final two sessions alongside devoted community members staff caregivers and students bringing many stakeholders voices to the same table to discuss structural budget changes is no small feat the challenge of recommending Personnel cuts for the fourth year in a row was truly excruciating while there are benefits to an outside perspective to get us to this point I urge you to strongly consider the voices of the professionals closest to the heart of our work when making a decision that will have significant and lasting impact as a literacy coach I work alongside Educators from blard and Conan engage in Dynamic and everchanging work of supporting students I collaborate closely with our reading Specialists math
043specialist and steam coach as a team we partner with classroom teachers to make data informed decisions about how to best support students across the tiers of instruction reading and math Specialists are absolutely essential Specialists work directly with students as much as possible in in the constraints of a school day schedule they are truly the ones providing support necessary to close gaps in student understanding all of our Specialists and coaches deeply value equable opportunities for all students while it is very true that inequities in the schools exist I urge you to think through some of the unfortunate realities of reallocating Specialists we should be clear that additional support for some schools is very necessary additional is the key word here we have advocated for years that one reading or math specials per building cannot meet the
044needs can meet our students needs the proposal to cut Staffing of non-classroom teacher roles to an equity formula would necessitate reducing math and reading specialist support for some buildings in order to provide additional support for others thank you thank [Applause] you hello everyone I'm Danielle Healey I'm the reading specialist at Miriam we crafted a letter all the reading Specialists and I'm going to read you an edited version of that now but it is in your inbox um we all feel proud and honored to be part of our District's mtss approach to our tiered instruction through our District's MTS model and approach to supporting students we firmly believe that all students are capable of success the mtss blueprint from Massachusetts States mtss is a framework designed to meet the needs of all students by ensuring that
045schools optimize data- different decisions a progress monitoring and evidence based supports and strategies with increasing intensity to sustain student growth Mt SS is not just about tiered interventions but rather how all the systems in a school or District fit together to ensure a high quality education for all students through this Dynamic structure in our schools we've been able to have databased instructional meetings where various stakeholders including teachers special Educators Administration literacy coaches and Specialists have opportunities to support tiered groups for students based on academic and social emotional needs two outcomes suggested by the elementary budget task force as Equity Focus strategies include uh increasing the amount of time reading a mass specialist spend with students to serve more students and assigning reading a math specialist districtwide based on student need as opposed to one per
046School our team has concerns about these suggested outcomes what will our Dynamic mtss structures really look like if these changes occur 30 seconds our whole school and whole team approach will not be able to sustain the structure that has been built and in turn diminishing the high quality of instruction based on Specialists traveling to different schools and sharing spaces we take a problem solving approach to much of what we do to meet the needs of our students and we' like to continue to do that what will communication about students to families and colleagues look like time at meetings won't be as actionable if this proposed structure occurs students are the heart of what we do and what we carry through each day please keep them close to your core when supporting the next steps for
047active boxboro thanks thanks can I just see quickly how many people are left in line we've we we used our 30 minutes I would really like to keep it to just five more folks so that we can six all right six thank you seven no I'm sorry we're we're not going to take the seventh person we we've got to move on with our meeting we actually need to deliberate on this topic that I had to stand that's that's why I asked I'm I'm sorry we're gonna we're going to take the seven people who are sorry six people who are waiting in line and then we're going to move on with our agenda more minutes she was just I think so too I'm sorry I need to keep the meeting moving forward we've got a lot
048of other things topics that we need to discuss tonight we've heard a lot of comments I'm happy to continue to hear the comments uh and until the the six people are in line are done please go ahead please go ahead hi my name is Leah L and I'm a kindergarten and first grade teacher at Miriam tonight I'm speaking on behalf of the K1 team at Miriam in response to some of the possible proposals from the budget task force first we'd like to State how much we value and appreciate the incredible work and support that classroom assistants provide to us and most importantly our students the reference to assistant positions being loow hanging fruit turned the stomachs of many and left people feeling hurt unappreciated and undervalued some said they had never been made to feel
049this way in their entire working career they do incredibly important work and they should never be referred to in this manner we hope an apology will soon be forthcoming that said the social and emotional needs of students are at an all-time high over the last four years or so we've seen a measurable increase in the number of students who are emotionally disregulated and exhibiting unsafe behaviors this is a time to consider what additional supports they need so they can feel positive about themselves and their time in school it is not a time to reduce Specialists and counselors who can sometimes be their person in the school the person they can turn to when things are hard it is also not a time to reduce assistants who can provide in the- moment support and be a
050trusted adult at lunch and recess because of the relationship that is built when they are working in the classroom worth noting is the fact that at Miriam our assistants are the most diverse members of our staff 20 seconds we understand that without additional state aid or an override there is a need for cuts but cutting people who work directly with kids should be the last resort assistants give you the biggest bang for your buck and losing them would mean the impact on students would be significantly detrimental again student facing positions should be the very last positions to be cut thank you hi my name is Karen brandstein I live on Sawmill Road in Acton I've worked at Mariam for 14 14 years 10 years as a classroom assistant and this is my fourth year in
051the Mariam Library as a as the Mariam library media assistant I am a Massachusetts State Certified classroom teacher and certified reading specialist I've chosen to accept lower pay and status for a position that allows me to do what I love while maintaining a work life balance as a representative of lwh hanging fruit as well as the specials team I know that I am giving substantial value for minimal pay for my first 9 years as a classroom assistant I worked 18 hours per week in one classroom I knew the students and teacher well it was a wonderful job and I had no plan to leave it then the number of assistants was reduced assistants were spread thinner and moved around working with students and teachers we didn't know it went from being a challenging but rewarding
052position to being from my point of view impossible frustrating and depressing it was I was not the only assistant to shift jobs or leave all together at that time that was when I moved into the library I appreciated that the task force noted some concerns over the recommendation to reduce the number of Specialists one concern mentioned by the task force was that specialist teachers could quote be unhappy and leave I can tell you that based on my experience as a classroom assistant as well as my work in the library this should be a significant concern I love being in a job that allows me to read and Rec books to children and working in a school library is extremely challenging when I started in this position I was the8th library teacher that the fifth graders
053had during their prior 5 years at miam the job became known as the defense against the dark arts position no one lasted more than a year students did not feel known or understood they did not trust that I would stay I vividly remember one student suggesting that I should be very careful crossing the street thank you your time is up when I came back for year two I got Applause we can make real difference in students lives when we know students thank you hi my name is Joanne Mills and I am a currently a second and third grade teacher at Miriam I'm also a parent of two children that went through the act and boxboro Community um School system um our school Miriam was founded upon the idea that building a community to support students
054teachers and all staff would provide the best environment for our students I've also felt and witnessed this philosop philosophy throughout our district as a parent and as a colleague for years we have flourished within that Community however it has changed drastically and I feel compelled to speak based upon the data shared at our recent professional development meeting 87% of public schools Nationwide report a negative impact on social emotional development of students since the pandemic 79% of public schools Nationwide report needing more support for student Andor staff mental health needs classroom disruptions have increased by over 56% in conjunction with that data the number and needs of our multilingual learners continue to rise since the start of the school year in our district based upon Gabby's recent update we began with 359 multilingual Learners we now
055have a total of 425 which is an increase of 66 students in 3 and a half months 30 seconds the mental health of staff and teachers that are working in our schools is an alltime low teachers are struggling to meet the needs of students every day often without any additional support support staff are trying to support more and more students who have the greatest of needs and do not have the bandwidth to support additional students I need to speak about the value of human resources and my last thing I'll make it quick classroom assistants are members of the community that provide Priceless social emotional and academic support to students every day they are not lwh hanging fruit thank you they are mothers fathers engineers and lawyers they have chosen to work with all of our
056students for the most minimal amount of a salary and doing so provide a big impact to our students our teachers and our staff thank you um thank you your time is up thank you very much good evening my name is Britney Martinez and I'm the art teacher at Blanchard I'm just going to remind you of all the things that my peers have already spoke about that if our unified Arts Educators roles are um being considered then we need to make sure that we're considering the things that are not mentioned in the reports the number of adapted classes that our unified Arts Pro um classes are provided for our students for our neurodiverse students there are additional classes taught by our unified arts teacher which provide the grade level teachers and coaches with time needed to
057analyze student data and plan for mtss strategies um many of our unified Arts Educators perform additional duties that allow our buildings to function outside of teaching the students many unified art Educators produce impeccable special programs events for the communities including art shows Coral concerts and before and after school opportunities if any form of the budget passes where unified Arts educators are reduced in Staffing all of these items are also at risk of reduction or elimination the alternative is to eliminating these programs would be to increase the workload of our remaining unified Arts Educators a workload that is actually comparable to the national average uh here are some facts concerning this although not impossible a significant change in the unified Arts roles and responsibilities would have to occur which would break our contractual agreement of no
058more than 24 classes per week the new Solutions K12 report mentions that a full-time unified Arts educator teaches 25 classes per week the 2010 National Center for Education statistics report shows that the average for classes taught per week by an elementary unified Arts educator is 24 classes but none of our unified Arts staff are able to see students at a full-time capacity because of our halfday Wednesdays 30 seconds the 2018 survey from the art of Education notes that the national average of number of students taught per one Arts educator is 373 and in that same service 70% of the art Educators report they're the only art teacher working in their building so whether these positions are on the docket to be cut this year or in future budgets I urge you cons to recognize and
059consider that the change in our staffing numbers would result in a significant change to the high quality unified Arts education and opportunities for our students or the workload and working conditions of our highly trained dedicated and passionate UniFi Arts staff thank you you Jason fitgerald not a teacher uh flag Hill State's acon uh we're here again facing yet another budget crisis as we prepared to go through the annual exercise of cutting teaching FTE from our payrolls we have Smart accomplished well educated people in this town some are even har educated I've been told and yet I look at this report I'm left shaking my head the argument is made that ending open enrollment could cost our district as much as 800,000 followed by the acknowledgement that our open enrollment policy contributes to segregation of our
060student body the $800,000 minus whatever savings from the bus routes would which I will get to in a moment is less than 1% of the overall budget segregation alone should be enough to end the enrollment policy the claim is made that I quote in the districts with neighboring hood schools there's no way to place students into empty seats first of all this would be easily solved by having overlap zones where new families are assigned to one or the other school 742 Evergreen terrorists can be assigned to con today while 5 years and now from now could be assigned to McCarthy town for the next family better yet merge the Dual schools McCarthy toown Miriam Gates Douglas and utilize a bigger building to get rid of this problem altogether the idea that this is static forever
061more is also ridiculous there are 18 other things in this plan that are being changed so clearly policies can be changed besides the problem with segregation there are fallacies with the idea that families actually get to choose their school one school may have three or four seats open another school May with an extra section may have 26 open seats and get the majority of the students if the process is truly random a family from North Acton may put the Blue Ribbon School as their first choice only to end up at their fourth choice in West Acton or even boxboro and spend an extra 10 minutes on a bus each way speaking of the bus routes there are efficiencies to be gained and as a taxpayer to the state and to the town I'm interested in
062the district doing the ethical and honorable things and looking for savings on all expenses including those reimbursed by the state this plan also does not acknowledge the cost savings that would come from less overlapping bus routes sending multiple buses to Codman Hill Road in boxboro canbury Hill North Acton end the end of High Street in South AF is not efficient as a parent who has four kids that go through Douglas over the last 13 years it's hard for me to hear it said that the school is allow for their own personality Douglas is not the same school that it was in 2012 with most of its character removed under the guys acity the personality of the school has been so Stripped Away it's hardly recognizable and the end it comes down to this if open
063enrollment really is a cost savings why is it not done everywhere and why we teach our kids about growth when it comes to this issue we continue to be as narrow and close-minded as possible please revisit this thank you hi my name is Don midi um I wasn't planning on speaking but I just want to paint a little bit of a picture of what the mtss um process looks like from the perspective of a math specialist so I am the math specialist at Conant I was hired in 2022 2 um just about 2 and 1/ half years ago and when I was hired one of the biggest assets that kept coming up during my interviews was that I had experience as a classroom teacher um noting the kind of lack of support that mtss is
064supposed to provide um it is a state mandate and as a classroom teacher for 20 years I had been around when it was called RTI and I've watched it progress through the years I was really excited to see that math was being given a chance in act in boxboro and I left a district that I had been teaching in for over 15 years to come here to be a math specialist um when I came here I was tasked with helping to create kind of sustainable programming or sustainable structures around mtss at Conan um at the time mtss was kind of being dabbled with a little bit at Conant but teachers weren't very comfortable with it yet and was definitely not like a consistent structure um for those of you who don't know in the 2
065and a half years that I've been at Conan I've worked under three principles and so it's really fallen on four of us um myself the math specialist the reading specialist and then the seam coach and the literacy coach who are split between Conan and Blanchard the four of us have really done a lot of work to create systems that work at Conan 20 seconds um and we're really proud of them it's Taken 2 and a half years for us to see some of the fruits of what we've done and I think one of the greatest things that we do is every 6 to8 weeks we're looking at data to identify kids who would benefit from small group supports so calling kids the kids who need math support and the kids who need reading support in
066a school kind of undermines the dynamic nature of what mtss is designed to do thank you Don thank you all right I do want to take a moment and thank everyone who participated this evening sorry some people have trouble standing for half an hour let's have one more person please I'm sorry vicam we do need to move on with the meeting we've been at feel comfortable standing for half hour I understand that we've been at this for 51 minutes I don't think you do thank you we're going to move on now considerate uh again before I was interrupted I do want to thank everyone who came this evening I recognize that not everybody had an opportunity to speak um I do encourage you to stay for the next part where the committee actually gets to
067deliberate this um this is not a done deal but there are definitely lots of topics that the committee needs to discuss as part of this uh with that we'll move on to the superintendent update [Music] Peter all right thank you Adam um you know so first for all of our staff thank you for coming and sharing this um you know we'll talk more about that I think you know from a committee standpoint I think one of the biggest takeaways is that everything we are now looking at having to cut has some kind of a significant impact um and we're not seeing anything that isn't going to have impact um and and you're hearing that I think from staff um and I think that's absolutely noteworthy and I wouldn't discount anything anyone's saying I think that
068is what's probably presenting the biggest challenge for us um in looking at you know not only this year but even the prospect of future years of of reductions ahead of us so you know I I just want to say thank you to the staff that came spoke absolutely recognize what you're saying and appreciate that that you took the time to do that um you know I do want to give a couple updates before we jump into the report I just want to start with a little gratitude for uh all of the volunteers at the act in boxb Resource Center so we're deeply grateful for um the generous donations we received uh during our AB Resource Center holiday gift Drive um thanks to the incredible support of our community we collected a wide range of gifts
069including toys clothing essential items um and we're able to ensure that 71 families and 156 children um got to experience the joy and warmth of the holiday season uh we had families coming in over the last several days to pick up those gifts um very appreciative absolutely fantastic work by the whole Army of volunteers that mobilized to get that done so thank you um also just as a little bit of data since October the resource center winter coat drive um has successfully distributed 440 coats actually this was written yesterday and I saw several coats going out the door today um so more than 440 coats um to individuals and families ensuring warmth and comfort during those colder months um once again that is all made possible through the gener donations from the community um so
070we just want to express that gratitude at this point of the year um mcast graduation requirement update this is going to be an action item coming to the committee soon um I think you know there was um a lot of Hope around the state that by ending the graduation requirement it would actually maybe remove some bureaucracy from what kids had to do um we actually just got our guidance from Desi it's going to create significant layers of bureaucracy at the district level that don't exist now that we will actually have to create in terms of managing what that competency determination looks like so just a portray it for school committee there there is our graduation requirements but the state has a competency determination that students have to pass in order to receive a diploma so
071it's actually two steps that students need to meet the law that was passed didn't change anything about graduation requirements it did affect the competency determination it didn't take away the state competency determination but it took away mcass as the measure for the state competency determination so whereas the state was actually tracking all of the students who passed mcass um in making that progress and then we knew who was doing that every District around the state now actually has to come up with separate competency determination criteria um that we will have to collect report back to the state um and and monitor in addition to having our graduation requirements so this um will hold true for the current seniors um who have not yet passed mcast so if a senior already passed mcast they're held harmless
072but we are going to have to figure that out for any remaining seniors we will also um have to look at that for all of our future years and so I think there's going to have to be layers to the thought on this um finally we will have to have a process in place that anyone who formerly did not receive a high school diploma from our district because of mcass will have an opportunity to meet our new competency determination requirement that we have in place once we determine it um and so you know we're actually talking about significantly more layers in the district that are going to have to take place now as a result of this so um that is going to be coming to the committee we're going to have to do some
073really fast work because that has to be in place before students start to graduate this spring so um that will certainly be a springtime Endeavor and I just wanted to put that on your radar that it was coming up um vision of a graduate we on the positive side we've had over 2400 uh members of our community including our students respond to that survey um so that's going well um we did have relatively low um interest in doing the in-person workshop that we had scheduled for January 8th we're actually going to postpone that at this point and try and redo that maybe a little bit later in spring when it's not uh right after a vacation so more to come on that um Elementary budget task force I'm not going to talk about that now
074you're going to hear about that momentarily um we did have our first meeting of our superintendent and school committee student advisory Council um that was great Leela was there as well as Jen Faber and Heather Stoke um and so at that we brainstormed possible topics of interest to our students um we then took that brainstorm Ser sent it back out to students who participated in the student Advisory Group um as a survey to select a couple of priorities that they'd like to work on for the year so we'll be working with them again on January 6th um we're also very excited on a separate note to to um bring in Dr Stuart ablon um who is a very well- noted speaker in the area of social emotional learning and mental health um for students um
075he's going to be doing a parent workshop for us um for families around the district called from compliance to collaboration combining Neuroscience common sense and compassion so we'll be sending out the date that is going to be January 27th um at 7:00 p.m. um and that's a virtual presentation to make it a little easier for families so um lots of things happening right now and um look forward to after the vacation thanks Peter any questions or comments for Peter all right we will then move on to our guests and presentations for this evening which is the elementary budget task force Tori I think you're leading us off this evening yes great yeah so as tor's getting ready I'll just make a couple of preliminary comments here so just for the committee to rehash kind of
076what we've already talked about um there are several processes all happening simultaneously um this year in the development of the budget I think you know one thing that the school committee talked about last spring um as we got the override and recognizing the really narrow margin in the community um that had support for the override the need to have a process that we felt establish trust with the community and a level of transparency that could help support the long-term financial support of the district within the community and so that led to the establishment of this task force we contracted with new Solutions K12 um to conduct a study um Nate levenson from NSK K12 will talk about the process as well as Tori but they you know did stakeholder group surveys um met with individuals
077looked at schedules things like that compiled them in order to make some recommendations to us I know you've previously heard from nsk2 um as part of a budget Workshop so um we'll be talking about that simultaneous to all of that work though the Administration has to develop a budget as well and the administra is kind of at the Midway point of developing our budget we present our budget to the school committee on January 30th we've certainly heard from the budget task force and we've been in the meetings with the budget task force listening taking notes listening to understand kind of different perspectives of the community around what we need to do um but we also have to work with our principes um and other staff to be able to then develop a budget that we
078present to school committee that we feel can operationalize um The District in a way that takes place the primary challenge that we have is we have a cap on the amount of money that we have to spend and we can't spend more than that and our role as an administrative team is that we have to come back to you with a BAL a budget that balances um so you know we're at a point where you're hearing from staff the cuts have been multiple years it's making things more challenging for everyone um I don't want to portray this as any proposed reductions aren't creating more work for someone um and sometimes we even create reductions you know we talked about you know for example um a teacher shared with us the other day that um it
079it's more work for her just to get paper towels now because we reduced someone in the main office and so in order to get paper towels now they actually have to fill find a form fill out the form wait for someone to look at the form and then get the paper towels delivered so all of these things have a trickle down effect on what we're doing and at some point no decision is not an option for us and so that's the conundrum that we have so I'm going to turn it over to Tori she'll introduce the work of the task force and then she'll introduce Nate um but I just wanted to preface that from a process standpoint that it's really two processes running in parallel that eventually have to talk to you in some
080form of a budget recommendation that comes before the school committee which then becomes your decision about how we move forward so um thank you Tori I'll pull up your slides and then the clicker on the table we'll power the slides for you and forgive me I've uh had a pretty good round of laryngitis this week so hence I'm going to need the uh the beverage um Google just signed me out of the account so as Peter mentioned in during budget Saturday last February we committed to engage with our community to look at opportunities for structural changes that might help our district save money and our Focus e e consultant and the main thing that I want to speak to tonight was The Cutting of classroom assistance I think it is an extremely short sided approach
081I understand that you have to make Cuts I understand that this is a very difficult task but as other people have already said but I would like to underscore they are your best bang for your pennies not your buck your pennies you are paying them Pennies on the dollar for what they do they work extremely hard they work in multiple classrooms they establish relationships and they are what is holding the elementary schools together right now you cannot get enough Subs every day to cover everything you are using bus drivers to cover recess and lunch and they are not able to do what classroom assistants have to do out there and so right now if you cut them by 25% leave alone the 50% that was suggested by some you are not going to be able
082to run your elementary schools and I'm serious when I say that you cannot cover everything they cover you don't you can't get all the subs to cover classrooms now it's the assistants that are stepping in and peac meal covering it every day and please whoever chose to include the ter techology long lwh hanging fruit to refer to valuable members of our school Community it is appalling I can't even speak coherently when I think about it so please look at what you are doing if you really care about these students keep the people who are truly helping them day in and day out with their social emotional and academic learning thank you all right Tori go ahead all right so as I was saying um we brought in Nate in new Solutions K12 to do the
083research and Analysis not just because we lack the resources to do us ourselves but also to give us an outside perspective from an experienced leader in both industry and education besides just helping us find savings Nate's job was to challenge our assumptions just because what we've done in the past is work doesn't necessarily mean we can't find ways to do it better besides eight of the usual participants school committee fincom CPAC the union a principal task force members also included community members parents Educators and students nine of which we selected using a rubric of diverse desirable backgrounds and experiences and then another eight that were randomly invited to participate among our numbers were two high school students Lucia sabatelli and guon shth both full voting members Who provided valuable input building the group this way
084was a new process and I think it was highly effective I'm going to add that I hear the feedback that some some of you felt like you were not welcome or not invited um when we put our our request together with the survey and asked for people to volunteer one of the things that went out of our way to highlight was that we were looking for specialist teachers as well um and I know that we sent some of the random uh the random invitations out as well so not for a discussion for now but if somebody has feedback later on how we better get those invitations out so people see them I would be willing to receive that tonight you're going to hear the recommendations of these 25 community members for how our district can
085be more efficient and more effective let's start with efficiency while we want to continue providing an excellent education for our students we can't afford to keep doing things the way we've done them for the past 15 to 20 years as I think You' figured out already you're not going to like any of these options but rejecting them is also not a choice we have a $2.3 million shortfall after four years all choices involve structural changes fundamental shifts in how we educate our students one of the hardest realizations in this process was that changes in transportation open enrollment aren't going to generate the savings we were looking for our transportation is actually very efficient and com comprises only .3% of our budget and open enrollment is actually saving us money that's great except now that means
086that we have to look back to staff and changing how they work to find those needed savings so in addition to those already in place the structural changes that underly tonight's recommendations include shifting from a one per School model to sharing some staff across schools measuring need and allocating critical resources where they're most needed rethinking our classroom Staffing structure and leaders prioritizing what is most important to continue as well as identifying what we will stop doing because we no longer have the resources and in order to do all of this to share our staff effectively this will require a major structural change involving moving all of our schools to a shared Elementary School schedule so if you've been following the task Force's work you've seen several iterations of the reactions assumptions concerns and facts captured
087on chart paper as we work to make sense of the proposals and develop shared understanding doing this in a Time constrained open meeting environment with 25 people a lot of us seeing this for the first time was difficult for all involved but as we've heard tonight and as I've heard before I know it was also really difficult for all of our Educators to hear their work discussed in this way and I know that it I hear you that you did not feel valued and I am sorry that is something that I will take away if we get to do this again in some sort of form that we need to clearly com talk to all of our members and understand what it is that we're doing in an open Forum because it's really hard when
088you're the ones that are being Tau talked about we wouldn't be having these conversations if we had any other choice at the same time I also want to say that I'm really grateful for everyone who participated through this really difficult open discussion and who came and provided feedback because your input really matters the quality of our work would not be the same without you and discussion would not be the same without you as Peter mentioned none of the these recommendations come without consequences and so as requested by the budget subcommittee our final round of concerns are shown in appendix B and they highlight the trade-offs and the issues raised by those who didn't support the recommendations that were brought forward the efficiency part has been really painful but I also appreciate that Nate kept a
089positive Edge on this and he pushed us to think about Effectiveness what can we do better these recommendations aren't just about saving money they're thinking about how we might do things better for students and staff if staff reductions are necessary we have to prioritize what truly enhances student outcomes and staff satisfaction more quality student facing time and looking really hard at the efficiency of everything else that we do that doesn't mean doing more with less it does mean that we need to be very deliberate in how we allocate our time we need to take things off the plate if needed and we need to focus on what matters the most other districts have a acheve this balance and I'm confident that we can too as we Implement these changes it's going to be important to
090carefully track the impact and to make adjustments as needed so here are the cost saving recommendations if you include the two members who voted for 50% without voting for 25% and so presumably would also support a 25% reduction the task force was nearly unanimous in recommending that we repurpose 25% of classroom assistant funding to Reserve other roles we heard from Educators in the room that they believe 50% would be the breaking point at which we would lack coverage for lunch recess and meetings the task force was Al nearly unanimous in recommending that we staff specials teachers according to the number of sections needed this isn't to say that our specials teachers aren't working hard all day and that they aren't valued they are providing extra classes beyond our program to students in school that have
091fewer enal education classrooms and this is beneficial for students but it also means that students who attend larger elementary schools don't have these opportunities this recommendation is saying we should continue to provide our standard specials programming but we need to look hard at everything else a majority recommended math and reading specialist time with students be top priority and then we take a hard look at the efficiency of the supporting Preparatory work let's try it hard not to get too hung up on the percentages here the the point we're trying to get at after is that we're prioritizing what is important and the number of students served and so then that brings us to equity focused recommendations many of these are centered around the idea that a student with an identified level of need should receive
092the same support regardless of the school that the student attends since our schools have different numbers of students and also different numbers of students at varying levels of need who need support this would invol sharing staff and a common means for determining student need you'll notice task force consent on several more recommendations for a reading a math Specialists again the desire to prioritize time- helping students and support as many students as possible the Nuance here is that maximizing student facing time and reducing the number of Specialists only allows us to serve the number of students that we currently serve while maximizing student facing time and retaining all our Specialists po potentially allows us to serve more students this is the sort of trade-off that we're facing and clearly the task force preferred serving more students
093to cutting back on Specialists but this requires reduction somewhere else Additionally you see majority support for assigning counselors and steam and literacy coaches where they're most needed and prioritizing student facing time for counselors all these recommendations involve sharing staff to ensure a more Equitable level of support across the district a concern related raised in this regard was workload you've heard about maintaining relationships also M also raised and that sense of school Community certainly this would require thoughtful implementation to be successful finally there is support for strengthening the unique characters of our schools within open enrollment while maintaining the quality of the curriculum there were also some concerns raised both in the task force and from the community at large about how our school's demographic rics are not necessarily reflective of the demographics of our community
094as a whole so before I turn things over to Nate I want to acknowledge that this process wouldn't have been possible without passing the override enact and and the strong funding commitments from both towns while we still have a shortfall the support has at least allowed us the time to approach these changes thoughtfully districts with less support are having to make these decisions hastily and reactively and that benefits no one vicam and I want to thank everyone who contributed from the 700 survey responses the hours of listening sessions the data Gathering and answering questions the many public comments tonight and the 25 members of the task force who work so hard to review all this information in putting the task force together we intentionally sought diverse perspectives and we're proud to say that despite our
095differences we had meaningful and respectful conversations if you haven't read the exit survey in appendix B yet I encourage you to do so in today's climate of divisive discourse these task force members truly set an example of how a community can come together to tackle tough problems with that I will invite Nate to come up and uh join the crew great good evening um what I wanted to do is spend about 20 minutes uh giving you an overview and a little bit of um background on uh what we found in our analysis uh before I get into any of the specifics just want to Echo a few things that um have already been said but really to to know even as we went into this work um there were no unimportant roles and we found
096no unimportant roles in our analysis um there were no time being poorly used people not using time in the best possible way um given all that's been asked of them and we didn't find that and having completed the analysis and completed um you know many hours of conversations including with the budget task force there really are no desirable reductions that there isn't a recommendation or an opportunity that we' said oh you should do this and you'd be crazy not to um the question and that we didn't expect to find that and we didn't find that but that wasn't really the question we were asked to help you think through um if you have the money and do not have to make any of the changes in this report that is probably a very prudent thing
097to do if you don't have the money we were asked to put forward some possibilities and the term being an opportunity it is something you should consider something you should discuss and I think the process that the district helped design of bringing together so many people getting so many voices was one of the best we have seen and we have done this in many many many places um but it did not discover the obvious thing to do it did not discover the painless thing to do um I I think and to be fair sometimes we do find that but this is not your first go around at having to trim a budget so if there were ever any of those painless decisions they were made before we got here so there really are no options
098that people are going to say this is great I I think you know I spent six years on a school board and then became a district administrator and had to go war with my prior self um these are only things that if you must do something these are things you should discuss and think about and ultimately they're about value judgments which is why I really appreciated having uh such a diverse group of um stakeholders set the values and that certainly nothing that we as Outsiders would want to tell you what you should value and just our role is helping put some facts in front of folks put some data about how other people have wrestled with this but ultimately it is your District um and your values that need to drive how you will balance
099your budget so I just want to set that as how we thought about this um the process is we did spend a fair amount of time trying to understand um where you were financially understand what had happened in the past and collected a great deal of data uh we spent uh the early fall um you trying to learn as much as we could and hear from as many people as possible as Tor shared we had about 700 folks respond to a survey we did interviews and focus groups uh with nearly a hundred people um when we collected the data and shared it back uh with the the task force there were some issues and questions we collected the data and shared it back with principles we had issues and questions the data went through two
100three sometimes four rounds of cleaning so that the task force could have have the best possible information in front of them as they were asked to make some very very difficult decisions and I when I said that nobody should enjoy making any of these decisions I can definitely say nobody on the task force enjoyed making any of these decisions um ultimately we shared the findings with the task force facilitated a number of rounds of conversations and structured thinking and ultimately um the force was asked to reflect their priorities against a range of options I will say two things about the task force one uh potentially and just to put this in perspective I've worked in about 300 school districts in 30 States um it was the most civil and thoughtful set of conversations not one
101night but over uh five nights I've ever participated in and civil thoughtful conversations on a tough topic like this are extraordinarily rare and I also uh saw something that I very seldom see is a level of nuance of people really trying to think through hey if I liked this idea for uh math Specialists do I really like it for um social emotional support and really trying to not take a blanket approach but really looking at every option um through its own lens and again something we don't always see so again it was as good a process as we have seen doesn't mean that they came up with easy answers um do you want to um excuse me pause for for a sec before we get into some opportunities but to really note uh a number
102of commendations things that you should be very proud of um and what and again this is proud of in part on a financial measure there are many more things to be proud of but one of the things we saw um which is relatively uncommon is that with as many schools as you have of many different size buildings you have your Elementary classrooms are currently staffed virtually perfectly to your existing class siize targets um that there really wasn't a single instance in a single grade in a single school where you said hey you could have had one less section and stayed within your class-size targets um in most school systems people are pretty close to their class-size targets but they're never exactly there there's almost three four five classrooms that you would you would T typically
103find we found none so there's a and we'll Circle back to that but we were very surprised at the beginning to see that surprised enough that when we saw it um we readed the analysis and wondered whether we had made a mistake because we don't see that very often uh also wanted to acknowledge that um the elementary schools have already taken steps in the past few years uh to reduce spending uh while preserving their academic programming and services so you've already made 14.3 FTE reduction since 2023 which is again uh why it is not surprising to us that there are no easy decisions left I wanted to highlight um something that we we saw and heard and that the districts worked very hard to build consistency in curriculum and academic programming which is unquestionably a
104best practice and often a critical element of districts that have tried to approach um education within Equity lens and at the same time tried to support allowing for some school autonomy and some school personality that is always a tricky balance um but we saw in many ways that balance existing we do have some recommendations for how you might go further but definitely uh saw that complicated dance happening and certainly where there has been some pressure uh to have consistency these are in the places um that really matter most from ensuring that every student no matter where they live or which school they attend is getting a high quality education um and obviously we saw throughout all of this that District's got many talented extraordinarily dedicated teachers and staff deeply invested in their student school and
105Community uh there was a sense of uh pride of being part of actin and boxboro Regional School District that that came through in many many many of our conversations so what might you consider we we had five major areas that we looked at I'm going to just walk quickly through uh each of them and then take any questions you have uh the first recommendation or opportunity and again these are not recommendations these were things we thought you should consider and the task force should should consider uh the first was to adjust Staffing of non-class stream roles from a one Pur School approach to an equity formula that matches Staffing to students needs in a more targeted way um the there are two parts to this uh recommendation one is um since resources are tight you
106want to make the most impact out of every dollar you are spending out of every person every talented person you have um and from a p uh Equity perspective ensuring that no matter what school I go to I have the same amount of support the same likelihood of getting support um this is just a four example and again much of your Staffing is done on a what we would refer to as a one person School model um but it means that if you are a student who struggles to read um you have one reading teacher to help you across that building and some of your schools have is over 200 kids who are struggling to read others about 70 quick footnote different people will use different measures to determine how many kids struggle and we
107could have used two or three different measures we've actually looked at two um the range of roughly three times as many at one school versus another seemed to hold constant regardless of the measure um this is looking at reading we saw similar in math um and what we have seen across the country if you are one of 200 or one of 70 the level and intensity of support you will get is likely different and again uh interesting with math the range moves to almost four-fold difference um you have other roles with this applies to and you can see that in the report uh the second opportunity to think about is expanding the reach and impact of interventionists counselors and coaches to serve more students this is a more nuanced possibility but again you invest in
108incredibly talented people what we heard in from principles from staff is you need more of them and if you could afford more of them we would absolutely suggest you get more of them there's no suggestion in this that you are overstaffed in any of these areas um it would be a benefit to have more that said if more are not coming how do you get the most impact out of these roles and there are really two levers that I want you to think about um the first lever is little stick here for the first lever is how much time do they spend in a day working with kids um we have done the what we call schedule sharing in I think we're up to about 990,000 Educators across about 140 districts and what we have
109found is here like everywhere um folks in these roles are asked to do a lot and which is not surprising since they're really talented people they're asked to work with kids they're asked to support teachers they're asked to do planning they're asked to sit in on student assistant meetings the mtss process there are a lot of things they're asked to do they do it and there's even more things people would like them to do all of those are really good things not one of it would we say we saw a Wasted Minute the question is if you can't do everything you want to what extent can you prioritize their time with students uh there's definitely a question we've worked with some districts that have H aspired to hitting about 75% of their time with students
110as we've looked at your contract as we've looked at um your Wednesday schedule we looked at when the kids come and when the kids go we don't believe 75% is achievable um we do think probably 65% might be achievable we think some folks are probably there or very close to there and others not yet um but I I want to be very upfront with you all the They the amount of time they can spend with kids particularly given your Wednesday schedule and when kids arrive in their workday it will it could increase a little it will not increase a lot um the flip side is how many kids do they work with at a time and as we have been revising and scrubbing these numbers and getting more updated numbers we do see more of
111an opportunity to uh thoughtfully increase the group size in which kids are being supported for small group instruction and you'll see it in the report but the group sizes run between two and a half and three kids which is nice if it was my son or daughter I'd like that except we have seen overwhelming research and experience that re the research says groups of four or five if you're grouping by similar area of need meaning five kids with the same challenge not five kids with five different challenges are highly effective and the difference there is you can help a lot more students um so we are seeing more and more school systems say if we have greater needs and more kids who need the need and an inability to increase staff we will thoughtfully manage
112group size and to the extent you have the possibility thoughtfully manage all the other things folks are being asked to do now as a as a board who thinks about budgets and I'm very glad I'm no longer on a school board um there are really two different ways you can think about those variables let's assume you said hey we're going to increase amount of time with kids and we're going to increase group size so we could help a few more kids um there are just simply two possibilities when you do that you could say hey we're going to serve the same number of kids we are today and we'll do that with less staff that saves you money or you could say hey we're going to serve more kids with the same staff we have
113that gives you more services without spending any more money one is neither better nor worse that is your value judge judement and what the financial pressures allow or not but both of those options are available through both of those levers and again to be really clear managing the group size will have a far bigger impact than whether we get 10 percentage points more of the day uh with kids or not uh the third opportunity to consider is to examine the need for general education classroom assistance at the elementary schools again if you can afford them they add a great deal of value and your schools are absolutely built if you think about lunch and recess the way your school is currently run you will need at least half the um classroom assistant is they are
114classroom assistants and they are lunch coverage and they are recess supervision so we did not see an easy or there not a there's not a path to saying eliminating all of them because then you're going to have to backfill some other way um that said and I think this is I think it was fairly surprising for some on the task force again worked in about 300 school districts I can definitely count on one hand the number of districts today that still have Elementary general education classroom assistance and I think some in the task force are very surprised by that let's say you've had them for a long time they are a Bedrock to how you do things um almost all school systems have simply said not that we don't value them we don't want them
115but almost all school systems have said we do not have a budget that could support that and as a a role that we have seen most folks have to pair back or eliminate completely um you know you've got roughly 900 hours an investment of about $650,000 in general education classroom assistants and again about half of them um pretty deeply embedded in uh coverage for lunch and recess um number four which obviously generates a lot of anxiety um consider Staffing specials teachers more closely to workload guidelines by utilizing partial shared or multiat FTE I want to explain two things about this your carrent strategy of Staffing is a one per school um I would say if we were having this conversation 25 years ago almost all the districts we worked with staffed one per school and
116for all the reasons you heard tonight there are benefits to that um benefits to culture for the staff benefits to culture for the building uh relationships built with students I would say that today we see maybe certainly less than half of the school systems we work with including districts like your own um at a one per school and we are seeing across the country a a fairly rapid movement away from one per school as budgets have gotten Tighter and Tighter this is an area in which uh a lot of school systems cross country are having to look at not because they want to but because they have to and there are really three different strategies people are using one says Hey partial positions meaning we're going to have a 6 here and a08 there and
117their PE districts have been able to hire people who want those kind of jobs uh others have said hey no we want full-time people we want the people we have who want full-time jobs and we will maintain that um we won't maintain all the positions so we'll maintain them all as fulltime by having them move across buildings and the third strategy we've seen is something that's called wearing multiple hats so I've we've seen for example where a person might be uh the librarian for 7 which was what you needed to cover and there would be A3 reading teacher but not an increase in Reading teachers but if there was um capacity or somebody left as a reading teacher they would would fill that in so you've essentially created a full-time position out of two part-time
118positions um what we saw and and you probably know that your schools are of different sizes so if you are a specials teacher in a school with 23 classrooms you teach 23 sections and if you're in a school with 18 you teach 18 that said um your staff is incredibly dedicated they're incredibly hard work not want to suggest that in places with smaller schools people are just sitting around because they got an hour and a half every day with nothing to do that's not true they have added coverage perhaps more class they have definitely found other things and other ways to help and if you were to reduce some of those other things will go away we're very clear though what will not go away in in places that staff very precisely or share you're
119not reducing one minute of art or one minute of PE that was built into your schedules so from a student perspective there's still getting access to those same courses and in the same quantity um but clearly a bigger difference uh for the staff delivering those Services um and that if precisely staffed is about a half a million dollar opportunity um also I want to point out one other thing about this is there is a good way and a bad way to share staff uh we have worked with many school systems that share staff in Fairly chaotic pretty frustrating for teachers pretty frustrating for principles um and we've also been in districts where they've share staff and it runs smoothly the jobs are doable and sustainable and it really has to do with you need unified
120schedules you need unified scheduling you cannot have six people build six schedules and then try to get people to move between them so there really does take a very high level of collaboration and organization to share staff in a Humane and effective way and not every school district we work with uh pulls that off uh the last opportunity was definitely a surprise to us uh the single most recommended I think of the 700 people who responded over 400 said oh I know how to balance your budget get rid of open enrollment Case Closed um it is without a doubt and I think amongst the task force at our first meeting where we just asked for people's thoughts they reflected that thinking as well but honest we had no reason to doubt that so there another
121analysis we did probably three times because what we found was there is not an opportunity to save any money through open enrollment um first of all your transportation is efficient as transportation is measured when when I talk about efficiency I'm not talking about that you've mastered every route so that a bus does not go past the same house or three buses don't go past the same house every morning efficiency is measured by how many drivers and buses do you need and to a large degree how many hours are you on the road uh you had a report done a few years ago that said you were very efficient we ran our own analysis and we said you were very efficient but here's the weird part even if you were not efficient but you are efficient
122it's not that important because as a Regional School System um you have a very high level of reimbursement so you are seeing your total transportation cost of about $300,000 so if you eliminated all Transportation which you cannot you would save about $300,000 which is smaller than most of the other opportunities we've put forward and you're not going I mean you the other thing that gets even more interesting remember I told you we ran the analysis multiple times since we couldn't quite figure out how every Elementary School was had exactly the right number of class classrooms but then we finally understood took us a little while that the way open enrollment works is yes you do get to pick the school you want to a limit and if you come after kindergarten you only get to
123pick a school that had a open seat that is generally considered the Holy Grail of Staffing elementary schools and there are a small number of schools typically in districts that have extraordinarily tight budgets uh where they do things like that to get that super high level of efficiency so if you look at Open Enrollment compared to just traditional neighborhood schools um we estimate that you if you had trk traditional neighborhood schools that would cost you between 400 and $700,000 more um so open enrollment is not your biggest cost driver it is actually saving your money but very few people knew that and I'm not sure how many people will believe that uh we believe it that said sorry the one other thing I want to mention um is there was also a lot of concern
124when it came to open enrollment about H one have the schools lost some of their differences and two uh the socioeconomic and particularly the racial makeup of the schools um was a concern to many and the data supports that your schools are not uh all mirroring the communities as a whole and so there's a potentially recommendation not from a financial point of view but to revisit um how do you get what you wanted out of open enrollment um and get that in a way that is uh reflects your values of equity but I didn't we did not see a financial opportunity um two things to put on the table then I'll stop is based on the not on our research but based on all of our interviews including folks inside the system that if you
125needed to look at things for future years I hope you don't have to but um a number of people said hey why aren't you looking at we think there might be an opportunity around special education services and Staffing whether it was to spend less or to spend more efficiently is a TBD but that certainly came up and again a number of folks said you know we do have a lot of initiatives in this District are they all really as successful as we hope and potentially is an opportunity to do an some investigation to say hey are we getting the results we want from other initiatives but these were two things we did not look at but promise to pass along with that happy to take any questions thanks Nate um I think what I'd like
126to do for the committee is go around and give everybody an opportunity first to ask specific questions about uh Nate's presentation and the findings and then we'll move into sort of comments and deliberation so if you can hold your comments to the second round we'll start first just question questions and clarifications on the on the report and the presentation Yin thank you Nate Tori um I have a question Nate I really loved your book but my question is that when the task force found early in the process that open enrollment actually saves money rather than you know budget as a budget cost why didn't the scope of the study expend to the other two levels which is the Junior High in high school one because it's a vastly larger and different scope and the task
127force learned of and our analysis completed in we were 90% through the study hi thank you um I do have a lot of questions but I guess I'll just start with um one uh can you sort of address the point that was brought up by numerous people during public participation that the data is off that um some time that teachers are using to cover mtss meetings and you know other things like that we're not accounted for yeah so I one the data has been reviewed by principles multiple times by every um certainly um reading Specialists and every uh math specialist submitted their data data twice it's been reviewed at least three times as well um I I think so I I think there's a difference between the data being wrong and the data being analyzed
128in different ways so I'll give you two examples um if I'm a Elementary art music PE teacher we said that given the schedules you have built and given the expectation that every classroom goes to a special one a week that's how much specialist time you need that is not to say that if they were in a school that had extra capacity that they weren't that they didn't step in to do other things that is true and if they I will say that 98% of the districts we work with art music and PE teachers are not covering mtss meetings and if you are and some are you would have to find a different way to do that so I think there's a distinction in or difference in what we were counting what we've counted is the
129way most school systems would look at it and it is certainly something that is a reasonable way if you wanted to move in that direction uh second example would be where we just a different way of looking at the numbers is so the question is how much much time could a reading teacher reading specialist work with kids and the the question would be you know the the kids um aren't available on Wednesdays part of Wednesdays so that should come out of the calculation and that's one way to look at it we have other districts that would say hey if there are no kids around Wednesday that's the time you're going to get all your paperwork done and so when the kids are in the building you're not going to do paperwork at that time and
130you've got contract time that's before the kids are there that would be when you do some meetings and collaboration now that's not the the norm currently that is a norm in some systems so I think we've tried to be very explicit about how we calculated things and different people different smart people would make different assumptions as to what's reasonable and possible hi um one thing that I had noticed is in the open enrollment section you did sort of put a figure on how much extra it would cost us do you have any figures or estimates um like I know we have percentages but do you have any estimates on what the proposed opportunities could potentially be saving or allocating back into the budget that could be used elsewhere does that make sense um so I
131didn't follow the question I'm just kind of looking for um you know a potential figure for what the opportunities could be saving or putting back into the budget if we were to make the proposed Cuts sure again I think in the report we've called out and in the uh task force as they were looking at different options that the dollar Figures were there okay perhaps I miss those and we'll have to go back thanks other questions I I I have one um and it's for for both Nate and Tori and it's kind of in response to what we heard early on I've looked through all the materials I'm just responding to this comment that has made it out that at some point faculty or staff and our are schools were referred to as low hanging
132fruit and I'm just curious where that might have come from was there anything in the reports or the conversations or any any documentation that that exists because I agree it's it's completely inappropriate um but I also when I did a quick find through all of the documents that are on our packet I don't see that phrase anywhere so I'm just curious if that was anything that ever got documented somewhere page 10 of the report I can speak to that please so what you know one of the things obviously because it's an open meeting we have to keep minutes of meetings um and during the meeting some of the meetings we did a variety of activities where some were dialogue that could be captured by people listening to the meeting and others were written activities where
133people were writing thoughts um that they may have as an individual and the goal of that was actually to allow people to get out different types of thinking um particularly people who had concerns about different reductions um I believe that that was a comment by an individual that was captured in writing on one of the activities and so you know as we developed minutes we needed to fairly capture that and I think one of the things we were sensitive to is when you have an open meeting you can't really censor what is being shared during that meeting um and kind of that under that like offensiveness standard um there's no doubt that a comment like that is going to be perceived as offensive by by people um I think the the challenge is once it's
134said or it's written as part of that formal record of the meeting it's really challenging because we can't choose what we edit out or what we keep there and I so you know I think it's important to understand the context that it's not a representation of the full group or the district position on something but it's a reflection of what was said and done during a meeting thanks for that clarification and I think I speak for the committee as a whole where we found that quite offensive and we do not support the term of of calling anybody who works in this District low hanging fruit and and I apologize for that comment on behalf of the task force and on behalf of the committee one more round of questions Becca you had one more you
135had a bunch more I do have a bunch more but I know we're going to keep discussing this also um I guess my next question would be um how have how tightly have you um sort of decided a a person's schedule should be um you know the time should be allocated so I saw obviously you know travel time between buildings proposing teachers go from one building to another obviously that needs to be taken into account I'm just trying to imagine has that actually been worked out the math of Kelly's corner has a project going on there's you know all sorts of times when different intersections get gunked up it's really easy to get you know around buildings on this campus but to go to Conan from Conant to Blanchard that's difficult um you know reliably
136so I'm just wondering you know even also like in terms of meeting coverage and such I there's there's times that teachers can't go to the bathroom so I'm just wondering how we're expecting to find efficiencies and I I guess I take issue with that word so I'll come back to two thoughts uh the first is there's always a good way and a bad way to share staff and I I said that you know good ways take into account I mean you do have some schools that are extraordinarily close to each other um a bad way is to randomly assign where folks are going to travel from and to um you know bad way is having people and I've seen all of these things where people are traveling from one school to another and back to
137that other school because that's the way they built the schedule um so any good idea or any any idea can be implemented poorly I will say the the other point is that there are roughly just give you some sanity check of and not saying you will like this but I'm saying there are about 100,000 elementary schools and about it's 65,000 elementary schools about 65,000 elementary schools in America and about 30,000 of them today had staff move between buildings this is something that people learn to do in the places that have done it for 20 years but honestly there's never been a discussion of stopping to do it there's certainly been lots of discussions of how to do it well so I we have certainly seen many many many places share staff between buildings in a
138thoughtful reasonable good for staff way and we we've seen many do it very poorly then so I have a comment and then a question so do you want me to hold off on it we're we're going to go to comments anyway so okay you're up first um I have concerns about this proposed program and the changes to Staffing in our elementary schools specifically related to the equity model for our Specialists the report highlighted that the current structure where each school has a reading and math special specialist is already insufficient to meet the needs of our students the proposed or the proposal to reallocate Specialists across schools uh risks reducing support levels already super thin at this point leaving some schools then uh with less than one full-time specialist for math or reading which could also
139limit a students access to essential support and hinder uh effective decision making my question is as we heard tonight there is there is significant concern over the implementation of this program as proposed how do we ensure that we address those needs in an equitable format to ensure that our Specialists across our schools are doing their work without compromising the effectiveness of mtss and reducing student access to these essential programs I know I'm asking the million dollar question but I I would but I have no horse in this race is not my district I had plenty of opportunity to run one and to guide one um I've known this district for a number of years I have known that you've had an incredible commitment to equity long before that was actually the thing most districts did
140um and I've always admired that I was actually just very surprised when we saw the data that you were in in a fairly Advanced state of a district committed to equity still applying a one per School Staffing model I mean I've written about it others speak about it when people talk about Equity one of the first examples usually given is a one per School Staffing is generally considered equal the exact opposite of Equitable so if you have a very unequitable system today because if I am in a school with 200 kids who struggle to read it is worse for me that I chose a school that had more kids 199 who also struggled to read had I chosen a school that had only 69 other kids struggling to read I would get more help more
141often help or help in a smaller group so I I think the your the question for you to wrestle with is which type of inequity it or how do you minimize the inequity but you have inequity today in in one of the most textbook examples of inequity um my two cents would be that if you wanted to minimize inequity the first thing you have to do is have an objective measure of how much need there is in each building and I think for reading and math that's really easy um it's interesting we've worked with systems that have put in measures around social emotional and mental health needs uh the task force had a really interesting take that for the uh the counseling support that maybe it was so important to have both the relationships and
142to have somebody there in case of a crisis that maybe there was good counterargument to why a little bit of inequity of hours of service would be something that was valuable when it came to social emotional and counseling if I'm a student who struggles to read not getting the reading support I need or a student who struggles in math not getting the math support I need seems inequitable um the best solution if you could afford it put two in every building at least it's better it's still inequitable um the which I don't believe you can afford uh the intermediate solution says hey let's have a clear measure of where the need is assigned staff based on need and to the extent that it is practical uh go to group sizes that are align to the
143research which would be five and to the ex that is practical um take some things off the plates of these folks if they're not with kids so they can spend if they can more time with kids again but I I do think that the two biggest levers or having a measure of need and managing the group size so that they can help as many kids but I mean these are hard I mean there's no obvious or simple answer but I do think an honest assessment is there some inequity already hi um I wanted to ask you know in exploring ideas that were um sort of like out of the box things that people hadn't done before um I'm interested why the idea of bigger class sizes with more assistance wasn't explored and to sort of
144jump on the back of what Ben was saying in your response to that You' said earlier that data on um larger small group sizes might actually be helpful for student learning so I'm just wondering how that pairs with uh reading specialists at not being like an equitable split and your idea that actually small groups are better for student learning so two different things so um to say save a single classroom you were going to have to add five kids to your average class size uh so what we would normally do in a study like this if there was money to be saved by larger classes something we do look at we've said hey if you added one kid to your average class this is what you could save if you added two students this is
145what you could save occasionally we will say hey if you added three students this is what you could save knowing very few communities will add three students but some will add one or two uh when we did that analysis even at four kids we weren't finding any savings so the idea the fact that it was going to get up to class sizes that are so different from what you have today it didn't seem a worthwhile recommendation and that is only possible because you have this very efficient way of filling up your classes through the the Open Enrollment process um so that that's why that option wasn't there because it didn't actually exist within reason so Becca I think what what you're suggesting we actually talked about last year during the budget process that was our
146worst case scenario budget um and I think you know there's there's two ways to approach increasing class sizes one way which I think Nate's talking about assumes that you're keeping kids in the same school that they attend um and so if you have three Elementary classrooms and you say you're going to increase the class size at that grade level you have to figure out how to divide one of those classrooms at 20 students between the two remaining classes and you have increased class sizes to such an extent that it's it's not really feasible the thing that we were approaching in a worst case budget scenario was the notion that we would actually have to transfer kids all around the district um and ultimately last year we determined that that was absolutely not in the best
147interests of students to be transferring students you know kind of randomly just in order to balance class sizes across the district and grow that I think one of the you know challenges of the Open Enrollment process it's not a challenge of open enrollment but one of the challenges is once you have kids programmed into schools it's really hard if you already start with balanced class sizes within the guidelines to gradually increase class size the only way to do that is to start with kindergarten and and really think about how you're programming your kindergarteners across the district and new students that move in and grow class size slowly over a period of years otherwise you're ending up in an incredibly disruptive you know place for students and families so I think that's the the challenge of
148of balance I think my point in connecting the two thoughts is that we seem to be a little bit all over the place in ter in terms of what's best for students in terms of class sizes and small group sizes we can't say on the one hand there's data to suggest that uh larger small group group sizes of four to six kids might be beneficial and yet it's better to have you know the lowest number of ratio of kids per reading specialist and on the other hand we're tied down to you know a class-size idea that we've you know been uh having as a policy for a while I'm just wondering like how do we decide on exactly what we're discussing here and what's best for students because I'm getting mixed information I can answer
149that so you know and Nate and I talked about this um in part of our conversation his report assumed school committee policy as the class side guidelines um and so when he talks about the balance of our class sizes within school committee guidelines it's is the administration running the district the way the school committee told us to that's agnostic to whether or not adding two or three students to a class would materially degrade the quality of education and so you know I think you know my own reading of resar SE Arch is changing class size by two or three students whether you go up or down is not going to significantly change the overall experience it doesn't make it easier for teachers I want to be clear about that it but it doesn't significantly degrade
150the outcomes that you get for kids in order to significantly improve or uh degrade outcomes for kids I think you'd have to probably increase average class sizes by like five or six students and that's where you start to really see an impact one way or another Nate I don't know if you see the same thing hold on just a sec because I I think the question that Becca is asking isn't just about class sizes it's about class sizes and then intervention sizes where we talked about some of those interventionist groups going from 2 to three to 5 to six am I right yeah so I think the the question really is how are we saying that adding two or three more kids in a general education classroom um could be significant but on the other
151hand we're saying in these intervention sessions adding two or three more kids doesn't change the outcome well so if I let me be very clear adding going from say three to five kids in a intervention group if you're grouping by similar area of need the research is clear and overwhelming that that's okay it is also true that given your relatively small class sizes if you added two or three kids to every class in this District academically that's okay what we so that's the research I know very few teachers very few principls very few parents believe that research but it is 30 years of research that um adding a few kids to uh the class sizes you have would have no impact on their outcomes your dilemma is at least from our analysis is that's actually
152not an option you would have to be adding four or five and even with that um that is not a lot of money but the we've seen virtually no community add four and five students it just it the where it's interesting last thought on class size is we work with districts say in and around Minneapolis St Paul that are demographically identical to act in boxboro um they do not have an elementary class without 24 to 26 kids they do not have a middle school class without 28 kids and many have 30 and they think that's totally normal and they're not mad they're not angry but try to add three kids to any of those classes and you will see the school committee room with 500 parents in it um what we have seen across this
153country is people get used to something and it is not because the research said you're at the right place but you you're used to something it did not seem realistic in our experience that adding four and five kids particularly since give you this trade-off because ultimately if you have to make a choice um adding increas in class size by four students or having Specialists art music PE share buildings are financially about the same we' just seen no District in our experience add that many kids to Elementary classes and so didn't seem like an option to put forward if it was one or two we absolutely would have and have in many similar situations put that option forward for the committee thank you all right time for comments you have a question okay go ahead and
154there's a followup question from Liz as well so we'll go Leela and then Liz um could could you just clarify the process for me a little bit I did read what you wrote um so I understand that you came in to gather data and then analyze it once they were findings from the data analysis um I'm curious whether the process was kind of for the task force was choosing from a range of options provided by your team or to then other option look at the data and then make meaning of that and then come to some variety of options um multiple paths so what we did is essentially three things in every focus group with both um you know the community and internal staff one of the questions question s was what are the things
155you think we should look at where do you see potential opportunities that should be analyzed so that that factored into our work we obviously brought our own experience and the very first meeting with the task force we asked again where do you think things should be looked at and interesting the there was a fair amount of overlap but we looked for opportunities from the focus groups from our own experience and from the task force and then shared with the task force a number of Weeks Later the analysis of what we found okay so for clarity purposes when we asked folks in focus groups and then in the task force um where they think Solutions might come that was without any sort of understanding of what the data had actually shown is that correct correct okay
156um and then second question I don't know if it's to you or toori um but my recollection was that in the beginning when we discussed that folks would be logging their hours it felt like integral to that process was the understanding that we then wouldn't turn around and use it as a case to eliminate positions um and so I understand that like we are in a less than finan ideal financial position um but I'm curious if that kind of guiding value shifted during the process so you heard me comment that probably one of the hardest things for me to see come back was that the things that we started out looking at Open Enrollment and transportation weren't going to save us anything yeah um so first of all nobody in the task force was in
157a place that they would be making recommendations about roles and and nor are we really um a lot of that is an operational thing that happens at the district level but yeah looking at collecting data and I can see absolutely how on this end of things it feels I would yeah I would look at that and I would be like wait you asked me for this and now you're telling me that I that I should do my job differently or my job should be less somehow yeah was that Our intention going in no not at all um Leila I think the original intention of of actually looking at all those schedules was under that Equity side of the work and really looking at how do we maximize our Specialists and different roles times with students
158um and serve the most students I think the challenge is superimposed with trying to look at that there's also you know a two something million dollar deficit to start with and so the reality of all the work we want to do of equity if we had the money we would actually increase the staff in a more Equitable way and start with kind of 1.0 for every school and then be adding to get to the student needs we want that would be the goal the challenge is when your resources are starting at -2 million that becomes unfeasible and so you also still have to look at if we're going to have to reduce staff how are we going to serve the most kids possible even if we have to reduce staff so I think you know
159the the there's just an inherent challenge with facing a deficit that you can't hide from and quite honestly you know I think what we thought about was you also can't tell the task force they're only thinking of it for an Ane Equity lens and then all of a sudden it's administration's going to have to make some choices about what what we're doing in a budget you kind of have to be clear about that intention from the start but when we started this task force process we didn't know we were looking at a $2 million deficit either so that's that's probably where the challenge's at um I understand that we have very intentionally limited our scope to Elementary and I don't know if this is a question um for you Peter one comment that gave me
160pause tonight was the um idea that reducing specials for elementary would have a negative impact on the um preschool what would be the impact on the preschool if we were to move forward with that would there be an impact or is it not going to affect them you know I think ultimately it depends um we were able to add preschool specials probably I'm going to say really when we opened the new new campus um prior to that there were no preschool specials um so you know we're required to provide those specials for elementary um but not for prek it's actually you know unusual for prek students to have access to it but it's something good that we do so you know I can't tell you what the outcome is until we actually finish a budget
161process um and look at what's going to happen but I think you know the the challenge is as we move from the first to the second to the third now to the fourth and with the prospect of a fifth and or sixth year of budget challenges we're being put in a position where we're no longer doing the things we want to do but we're more and more having to set a baseline of what are we required to do and be really selective about anything that happens beyond that so I can't tell you that we can continue them I can't tell you that we can't continue them because we're not there yet from an administrative standpoint but that is certainly something that could very well be on the table if we have to uh so [Music]
162just wasn't me okay um just to to go off back thing the the increase from three to five in in these groups you're saying the research definitely shows that this is actually not bad in fact can be productive I'm curious how how how does that occur within that that group I know it's a sort of very specific question but I'm I'm really curious because you're saying the data really does show this but I'm just showing asking how the research shows that if you group kids what what called by similar area of need so let's just take two examples I've got a group of three and I've got a group of five and you would think logically three has got to be better than five if it is a either randomly selected group or group that
163was selected because they were all in Mrs Smith's class um that could be three kids one struggling in phonics one influency and one in comprehension in the places that uh thoughtfully manage larger groups you get five kids who are struggling in phonics I will tell you in the district that I led um they the reading teachers classroom teachers were so enamored with the strategy that they actually would create five group a group of five kids struggling in dip thongs and reform the groups every seven days because they just saw so much value to having what is considered a very narrow focus and as a result you're getting as a student 30 minutes of dip thongs for the next seven days as opposed to 10 minutes of phonics and then also not that was completely not
164useful but 10 minutes of fluency and 10 minutes of comprehension so the research has said that you can do a great lesson a highly focused lesson if there are systems in place to group the kids with very similar needs and very good results have come from that essentially doubling the number of kids who are being helped almost yeah I have a comment and a question um I think a few months ago I spoke on a record when I saw the meeting schedule for the task force that on a Tuesday evening I was actually watching Mr Brandon F's children they were right there in the audience when we schedule meetings at those times I think I set the time we're eliminating people's opportunity to participate and their voices that's my comment my question is that in
165this whole entire process have the budget task force thought about or are aware of our school district's goal our District's goal number one is improve social emotional and mental and Behavioral Health outcomes for students by shifting our environments practices and supports so that students can more effectively access learning and cultivate constructive relationships speaking of Mission Vision value our vision is to develop engaged well-balanced Learners through collaborative caring relationships are we confident that with these recommendations if they were accepted and implemented we can still cultivate relationships so can I give you an army reference so for those who don't know yens and I share share some some uh some Army background um I think this is a really hard one um we've heard a lot of people talk about the importance of our school cultures and
166of relationships and of knowing our kids and what happens when you're spread out um and I guess I would offer the perspective of somebody who was put into one of those roles where I had to learn how to plug in um in the Army we have what we what we call enablers they're the the assets you have that are so expensive or so specialized you can't put them in every unit I used to be an intelligence officer and I had intelligence troops and we we didn't we weren't in every little unit so we were held at a higher level until a mission came up that we were needed for and then we would go and we would plug in and it was actually a skill that you developed to be able to go and plug
167in to be able to develop a relationship very quickly with somebody and you hoped like heck the person on the other end was ready to share that relationship with you better be a good sergeant major first sergeant who you plugged in with and was happy to see you and would take care of you and you were that units for the duration of whatever mission was that you had and then you went back to your home unit and that you You' done your thing right I think there are there are other ways to think about it I think it is hard for us to think about it right now um I think the one thing that I do have a lot of faith in though is that we have some really amazing District leadership that we
168have people who recognize this problem we have people who have surface this problem and if it's the direction that we have to go we have the time to sit down and talk about how to do it deliberately and how to figure out how to make it as good as we can am I confident no did I hear everybody in that room who is boots on the ground involved in teaching raise those concerns absolutely but again we are in the position where we're making hard decisions and I think you're right to bring it up and I think we're all right to acknowledge it's something that we have to tackle if that's the direction we have to go can I just like really quickly um I appreciate what you shared I also appreciate the military connection we
169have um I used to be a tutor at West Point but I think you had just compared like a scenario where soldiers were trained for war and these are Educators who are trained to teach so soldiers trained for a lot of things and it's not all involving fighting my first job job as a peacekeeping role so I'm going to I'm going to sort of play off G in your question as well um I I think the answer is it's it's not the the mission and the vision and the values remain the same how they look and how they get delivered are going to be different and my my rhetorical question is what choice do we have and I think that's kind of how I want to take our discussion moving forward we've been presented by
170the superintendent with a close to $25 million budget deficit again again this year and that's still with funding our school operating budget at a 3% increase over last year last year we barely made it by the skin of our teeth to get the the increase that that we got and our communities told us loud and clear you get this don't squander it and we don't have any more to give right now um and so where I struggle is how do we acknowledge what the community is able and has given us right now with the recommendations that we've been given and the reality that this sucks we have to find two and a half million dollar someone said um just don't get rid of any more student facing roles that happened a year and a half
171ago right we got rid of we had to get rid of we had to reduce student facing roles last year we reduced some non-student facing roles for this year and have realized that while they might not be student facing they are crucial to getting paper towels into Elementary classrooms those might come back but at this point every decision we make is going to have a significant impact on an adult's life their livelihood our students opportunities and it's not fun it's it's not a good decision there's no there is no win-win here um and I think where we need to go now is to provide the administration with some thoughts on where we see this going Peter as he shared he's got to present a budget to us and that's that's his responsibility he's going to
172have to use every resource available every opportunity available every intelligent person in this District available to him to help come up with a budget that meets our guidelines we voted a 3% increase um and does the least amount of damage but I I there's no good choice here and that's exactly the conversation that we had at budget sub earlier this week nobody likes this it's terrible but it's the position that we're in now and the thing that's really frightening when we look at our enroll numbers our enrollment doesn't go up for a while our costs are going to continue increase but the number of students that we get and therefore the number of the amount of additional funds that we may get based on students doesn't increase for a long time so this is a
173turn hopefully in the right direction but you know I think this may not be the last year of reductions and for all of the Educators out there I am so grateful for you coming to speak with us please go speak to the community members go speak to the finance committees go speak to the select boards find Opportunities to speak at Well Finance committees and select boards some of them are here this evening find Opportunities to speak at town meeting um you I don't think you could have a more supportive school committee here but we need support of the broader community and we need to understand that they're financially willing to support us and if not we need to find additional ways to compromise but this is it's it's a terrible position that we're in can
174I summarize please yes please so I think it's a good opportunity to summarize the process one more time so this was a report that we had a consultant do the goal of putting a task force together was to vet options that Nate brought forward and I think Nate did a good job of saying not every option I bring is going to be something that's palatable to the community right it there's transparency there the goal of the task force was to put together a broad range of individuals in our schools and in our community take a look at options and provide feedback on what they thought could be palatable options in and highlight their priorities that has to get continued to be refined you are the ultimate decision makers because you are the ones that vote
175the budget and so you may say that there are some options that we can support there are other options that we can't you'll see a budget from my office in late January January 30th is our budget presentation the budget presentation includes elementary schools but it also includes District High School and Junior High as well so we're talking about a small subset of a total budget presentation what I can tell you if if it's not one thing it will have to be something else right that's the that's the challenging position we're in um unless there's revenue and there's not right like we we have all agreed to that early that there's no Revenue unless the state comes in with something and I'm just not sure that that's going to happen um so I think we just
176need to be prepared that we're understanding that any decision we make has to have some tradeoff somewhere else within the the budget that is going to be probably equally unpalatable for some other reason right that's that's the challenge of being in year four of this um and I recognize it has a tremendous toll on everyone to go to the culture Point anything we do at this point and you know I've been talking with the principles I know what thoughts are and the challenge that they see in any options available to them I know we've had these conversations within our leadership everything we do now in the fourth year is somehow significantly changing the way something's operating within the district and that means all of our schools are getting impacted by this and it's really becoming
177more and more challenging as we we continue to do this and I think what's even more frustrating for everyone is we don't know that there's an end in sight in the short term to this educ ation funding is cyclical right and I I think back to probably the worst time I had in my career was my first year as a principal it was in January of 09 which was the last major financial crisis that schools had I took over as a principal in January on a Monday and on Friday I had to call 22 staff into my office and hand out layoff notices like it was that acute at that point and we're seeing that same general Trend in school funding now that I recall from that time time period and we also heard from
178some of the staff that in 2012 things started to change and we were starting to add things because you know there was more flexibility these things do come in Cycles we're just not in a good part of the cycle right now um so I think we just want to be cautious about making promises to people I think the one thing I want to be really clear with our staff is to know the constraints that we have and that we're going to face challenges no matter what we choose to do um I think the good thing is hearing from everybody you get a much more balanced perspective of the pros and cons of the different options I know we tried to do that within the task force even though it's a separate setting um and make
179sure people were adopting different perspectives but the perspectives you know don't add up to a Rosy picture and I think that's the challenge all right any last comments or questions from the committee L me is there anything in the T task force that we did not consider because it wasn't palatable to the community yeah we did have a couple of things that didn't come forward um actually I think I have my notes um certainly you you've heard Nate mention group size a couple of times um that didn't get very far mostly um over looking at the curriculum that we're using in the group sizes recommended in there that was some push back there and so I think that was um probably why that one didn't move another one that uh didn't go very far was
180um as we looked at our counselors and the idea that we might use equity formulas there and share them across schools the idea of not having a counselor in the building if there were a student in crisis and not having a counselor available to that building leader if there were student in crisis just that was one that didn't get very far either um check real quick here and see if there's anything else that I'm missing here here uh jump in classroom assistance you know at different levels like the committee the task force originally considered different levels of reductions to classroom assistance um and before we even voted on any recommendations we actually took any reductions to classroom assistants Beyond 50% off the table um you know in that one it was actually from an operational
181standpoint we cannot run our schools with a greater than 50% reduction yeah I was wondering if if you have to go back and if you have an opportunity to go back would you consider like classroom sizes being bigger as an better alternative than multiple years in a row of more cuts and more Cuts you know I think um so either way it's a reduction right because yeah classroom size is you you don't have the number of classrooms that you have um I think you know one thing we're seeing now that we're even looking at is when schools get below about 18 sections in a school it's hard to operate that as a functional school over time because your population of students with needs gets really concentrated between two sections um and it's hard for principles
182not to be able to move around um you know we talked about possible School closure last year and I know that's come up a couple of times at different points this year um if you're going to reduce the number of general education classrooms there's going to be some point in time where schools aren't sized right anymore to be a functional school um I think you know that presents a challenge you know doing that is more often than not not successful to try and close a school and you end up with you know a lot of irreparable harm in a community um around it but there are also places that do that um you know I think there's just we we really teetering on that edge of what's right um you know I I think knowing
183the feedback we got last year that for many in our community closing a school is not an interesting option or one that it was very very unpalatable no I'm not our goal is to figure out how do we make the rest of it work as efficiently as possible um and and that's a lot of what we're trying to do at this point is really think about increasing the efficiency um the number of classrooms you know the and I think Nate pointed to this the the problem is even if you know if you have two classrooms in a building you can't dissolve one of them at a grade level because you still are going to end up with the 25 students there or you have to be willing to transfer them to other schools uh which
184is not good um the and if you have three classrooms in a building you're essentially taking 20 students and putting 10 more in the other classrooms that's not really a feasible number either to end up with you know 31 32 33 students in a class so the numbers just don't play out well based on where we're at as a district right now so my my concern is that are we naturally going to be forced to get there whether we like it or not with years of cuts you know I I think ultimately the question is I don't have the crystal ball um I think you're hearing I don't think that we're going to have to propose trying every solution that in report this year but I do think what we're going to have to be
185thinking and I know is on my mind is that some of these recommendations might have to evolve over several years the problem is if we go more than one or two more years with these types of of budget challenges I do think we're going to be in a pretty untenable position um and and looking at a pretty significant change ahead of us so I don't know what that is today but I I certainly think that we're venturing close enough into some things that are are are challenging that if we continue to try and reduce 2 million every year it's going to be really problematic thank you all right um so I think you know this whole process sort of the important come come away that I think you started with was that um you know
186there is no big savings here and I thought it was great to point to um Community misconceptions about that but then we had an example of um somebody coming up even with this report now being out there still perpetuating that misconception and so you know I think that that's the task before us as it was last year is sort of how do we come together as a community and recognize this is just the austerity politics of previous decades we've seen this before and as Peter mentioned every time that there's a financial crisis our kids pay for it uh you know when we try to do good initiatives like make classrooms more inclusive there's no extra funding that comes from that it's the system that's broken it's the system that's flawed the funding model doesn't work
187and it's none of our faults we all need to come together and not fight amongst ourselves and not paint too Rosy a picture of things either be very clear about what's happening this is a terrible situation and we don't know when the end is coming and we're doing our best and we want to hear from people and that's very important that everybody is a part of this process so that we all are making an informed decision together um I also wanted before we sort of end this discussion to sort of speak to the suggestion that there's a segregation argument uh that we could sort of solve two problems at once by uh ending you know this uh open enrollment and have Community Schools and somehow you know that'll end this segregation problem that we have
188and I think that that you know is a gross downplaying of actual segregation in our history and also completely untrue my children go to one of the ma majority minority schools and we love it there and it's a great community and I think that that is a really Stark example of um not being helpful in this community process um Adam you're a veteran member I'm brand new and two years the past two years haven't been great for a brand new member um I think I hear a lot of fear today myself included I think that for myself speaking for myself the fear I have is that the vote that I cast today it will impact students for generations to come because we don't know when this is going to end I I just said we
189have the our Mission Vision value and we also don't have any more money um any advice as a veter member you know all I can share is that when when I joined the committee which was ironically the same year Peter became superintendent um we had a couple years where the finances were good and we were able to add services and supports and and staff and you know I believe it's cyclical we thought that that stuff would last forever and so it hasn't and I you know my my gut tells me just like Peter has said you know there's a cycle to this and it's going to be tough for a while there there are so many extenuating circumstances outside our control as a committee outside of the district's control outside of the town's control there
190are funding models that are broken there are federal funding models that are broken there are unfunded mandates and tasks that we have to do that we don't get any support for I hope that the pendulum's going to swing in the other direction and I wouldn't sleep at night if I thought that this was going to affect kids for generations and there's so much good that happens here too regardless of some of these terrible moments that we have um that you know we we have to we we got voted to this these seats to sort of balance this really difficult position of doing what's best for the students in our community and meeting the the ability of our communities the the ability of our community to fund what we need to do if I could share
191one one other thought um having watched this scene play out in a lot of places um and it's terrible everywhere but I I do see generally two different paths through this the one is to do less with less because you're ultimately and you can dislike every recommendation every opportunity every vote by the task force the only thing I know for certain is you will ultimately pass a balanced budget that is what schools have to do by law and I've I have four clients who didn't and you don't want to be there um but you will pass a balanced budget and some people do that because they're exhausted because all the choices stink um and you simply you the superintendent is going to bring you a balanced budget and people ultimately have to live with it
192or some form of it and you will do less um that's the worst outcome of also seen places where they say okay we're going to have fewer staff I mean Budget School budgets are just people there's so little else transportation is one of the big other things but you only pay 300,000 for that your utilities that's the other big thing and you're going to heat your buildings um you're going to keep the lights on so ultimately as when budgets get tight and every forecast I've seen says you're at least looking at at two or three more years of this forecast can be wrong but nobody's saying next year is all going to be better um the and the question is can you pair this reduction in staff that is going to happen with doing things
193differently because you can do the same or even more if you do things differently with less staff and the challenge is that sometimes people just get to worn out because the less staff part of the discussion is so draining you really don't want to have the conversation about should we change group size or you don't really want to have the conversation about um do we need to find a way to scale back on meetings so that staff can spend more time and to be fair you if you're the staff if some of your colleagues are going away you're not really in the mood I mean you're not in the frame of mind to have those let do things differently conversations so the world forces you to do the do less part it takes a lot
194of discipline and it takes a lot of energy to do things differently as well and we've worked with many systems where at the end of the day it is not better but there is more there is they actually there are more kids getting math help more kids getting reading help it doesn't look the way you do it today but more kids got the stuff and at least as a former board member that gave me that was the hope that that that's what got me through it was okay I'm navigating this very awful thing that they don't pay me nearly enough for I.E nothing um but at least we're doing in a way that is actually increasing the support for kids it's not did not want to oversee the doing less part but the doing it
195differently is optional the balancing the budget ultimately is not actually an option so I have great confidence you will balance the budget um it's up to you all whether you change the way you do things at the same time thanks Nate vicam just hopefully this will hopefully end things on an up note but you said there are down swings and upswings and and could you guys kind of provide a little Clarity because it seems to me that you just have your tax revenue and money coming in a number of students so it doesn't seem like there can be a great EB and flow but you're saying that there are these cycles and there are and there we were in a downswing but what then would cause an upswing and why does that forecast out to
196be two or three years and what would that look like what would cause that so I I am not an expert on like macroeconomics but when you look at like new growth in a community New Growth es and flows and so you you know new growth is going to be typically in a community is going to be about half a percent a year is what you can reliably predict which is why when we talk about sustainable budgets being at 3% it that considers the prop two and a half increase that's allowable under law plus about half a percent of New Growth that becomes new tax revenue to a community where the existing residents don't pay more but you have growth in the community that allows the tax space to increase um there are periods of
197time where New Growth exceeds that and so have new revenues coming in um there are communities in the state that are experiencing extraordinary New Growth right now um places like Ashland and Hopkinton um have such New Growth that they're building new schools they're adding classrooms they're doing all these other things but it's because more people are flooding into the communities um because they're creating that capacity for it if you have periods of time where New Growth is low or you know and that can include like vehicle excise tax all those other surpluses we don't get to deal with here impact the overall tax base of the community that's the stuff that es and flows and I think the other thing that can EB and flow is State revenues um you know the state made a
198major investment in the student Opportunity Act that doesn't impact act in boxboro because we're in that hold harmless status and we have been for quite a long time originally when we entered hold harmless status we were one of only a couple dozen communities that were in hold harmless status um because the resources relative resources of our community were high High compared to the overall State we are now one of 212 communities that are in home hold harmless status and there's a significant movement among those communities to pressure the state legislature to rethink again that school funding formula and so that's actually something that's being tossed around in the state legislature I don't know where that's going to go but I I have a sneaking suspicion that like our long-term future is going to be very
199much tied to what state funding does not to make us feel really good because I'm going to bring us down a peg but also if you start looking at national news um you're going to see that there's an increasing frustration with school increases among voter populations and so like there was an article just recently that Vermont had the single largest shift from Democrat to Republican in the entire nation when it came to State Legislature a lot of that was driven around the school funding formula in Vermont because school funding is almost solely at a state level which I learned from Nate and there was a real frustration in communities around why if our student population is declining is school funding increasing so there's also this local frustration around taxes that that's appearing and so I
200I think there's a lot of forces coming into play that you know a few of them you might have some influence but no control over but others you neither have control controller influence on which is is frustrating and you're kind of waiting out the tide to turn and then because we're in America public opinion shifts every other week and so you know that is also something that is not set in stone forever and ever and and times can change but we are certainly in a in a place of general public opinion where there's a high expectation I think that we're going to have to figure out what our resources are and then learn to work within them thank you it's quick okay um I just I want to loop back to maybe what Rebecca was
201talking about which is like yes we have a responsibility in this moment and with the resources available to do what we can this year and there's kind of a bigger systems perspective that I don't want us to lose um and I know I've talked to Adam about like what does that look like in terms of advocacy um I think what we heard from folks who work on our district is really important to share back with the people making decisions um I've already drafted an email to our T reps and our Senator and I'm happy to send that on behalf of the school committee but um Beyond just tonight I think it's important to also be having a kind of simultaneous conversation about what advocacy looks like from our district because historically we haven't been super
202loud in the space of like education advocacy um and I mean historically we've had a fair number of resources considered um compared to other districts but um I just wanted to make sure we're having this kind of simultaneous conversation about kind of the systems Statewide piece of this thanks Leela let's why don't you send me a message and we'll find some time to put that on an agenda for the committee to discuss as a whole and maybe there's action that we can take and that we can send to our legislators all right I want to send out a huge thank you to Tori and to Nate and to the entire budget task force um what you asked to do was really really difficult what you provided us was really great information nothing Earth shattering but
203also nothing that is going to be fun to go and Implement um so thank you to Nate Tori thanks to the budget task force thank you to all the Educators who came this evening to speak we have more business to move on to um we'll see how this sort of pans out as the administration presents and develops their budget for next year thank you can I a proposal are you going to propose that maybe we should let Andrew off the hook with his Personnel report he just gave it um the Personnel report's in the packet can read it but I would suggest maybe what we do brend sorry Brendan and Mark have been waiting for two and three quter hours I'd like to let them do the capital presentation they know that they're going quickly
204through it uh given especially given the late hour uh but they've been preparing for that um so have them go through the capital presentation vote the consent agenda and table any other items that might want future discussion to the next meeting which is like the finance reports audit report things like that that people may have questions on I I guess my question for um Sher is do we need to vote that investment policy tonight is there urgency around that back um this not absolute urgency but the quicker you do it the more money the scholarship account will make okay um so I'm just going to ask the room are we okay with doing the capital Plan update and then moving to consent agenda and passing over the um the other ongoing business which was mostly
205mostly Financial related great brenon how much coffee do you have left in that mug not enough perfect so we've got Mountain Dew all right do you need you need a presentation though don't you I do I it is open on the machine it just needs to be loaded yep all right go for it please okaye so good evening um I know it's late so we will go as quickly as we can through this my name is Brendan Hearn I am the capital project manager for the district I'm joined of course by Mark Hamill who's the facilities coordinator um although I've been with the district for nearly 20 years Mark and I have only been here in this facilities role for the last two this is my first time doing this presentation so bear with me
206um but we definitely welcome your questions at the end um so I'm going to start off with a little background on uh the capital Improvement program but there's a lot of detail in these slides so I'm going to jump ahead just to a quick summary so um the formal Capital Improvement program was launched in fy20 um it was one of two major recommendations from the uh 2016 District Master Plan study report CIP and and formalizing that was one the other was of course the construction of a new twin Elementary School what we know as the boardwalk campus first five years of that uh program were were funded um Prim primarily with a $7.5 million uh Bond um of course contributions also coming in from the general fund as well as the uh newly established uh
207Capital stabilization revolving fund um towards the end of that first five years facilities condition assessments were conducted on all the district buildings um to sort of help identify future priorities in terms of what systems needed to be replaced and when a firm called Bureau Veritas conducted that facilities condition assessment and provided a ton of data for us and different methods to report on it um before I get into what Bureau veritos actually looked at I just want to quickly uh talk about Boardwalk obviously that was the new building open in 2022 um it was not included in the scope because it was new at that time um it's uh our our first and only fully electric geothermal um heat Heating and cooled building um and it has what's called an expected useful life or E
208of about 50 years so that term I just want to quickly Define so e is one of a lot of different metrics we use when we're thinking about buildings and condition um it does not imply that after that time span the building is going to crumble to the ground it's just a way for us to help sort of keep an eye on when we should expect major uh systems to be uh upgraded so a roof might have a typical lifespan of 20 years whereas an exterior brick and mortar wall might be 75 to 100 but we're saying 50 some of our older buildings May in fact be closer to 30 so we'll talk through those as we uh speak about the different buildings so Engineers from Bureau veras came out again assessed all of our
209buildings provided lots of detail uh all these are of course in the packet as well as those detailed slides so you can review those at your leisure or feel free to ask questions we can go back following this um but the major items that Bureau Veritas identified at the high school were building envelope that is to say exterior facing components mortar joints flashing the roof things like that uh so envelope work mechanical electrical and plumbing system work sometimes known as M and miscellaneous interior work over at the Junior High um they're looking at more additional uh MEP and envelope work needed there McCarthy town or or rather the Parker Damon building containing McCarthy town and Marium this was new construction it was not a renovation um built in 200 uh2 um and uh we've done
210a lot of recent uh hbac system work and and more planned coming up soon um major elements Engineers noted there were site work as well as actually relatively minor envelope work interior flooring needs Blanchard School um that was a major renovation in 1995 just a reminder uh that was the town of boxboro Elementary School separate from the district up until 2014 so maintenance for that facility was handled all by the by the town of boxboro until we regionalized a lot of work went into it shortly after that including boiler upgrades and things of that nature um but uh uh J Veritas also identified further site work building envelope minor me there's a bit of a pattern here going um Conan school um this is one of our older buildings and a good um example of
211of that fact that buildings can continue to function beyond their e at 2021 you notice um that said there is understandably significant site work um additional me work envelope work as well as uh space considerations within the building I'll just pause here and say uh Conan is a candidate for msba funding either through their accelerated repair program or their core program and that's an area that we need to continue to explore um the admin building that we're here in now um is original 1959 our oldest uh uh building well past its e uh ending 50 years in 2009 um we've had some upgrades but generally speaking the building is original uh aside from interior um more cosmetic type upgrades unfortunately not a candidate for msba funding due to the fact that it's not doesn't have
212um uh sort of standard academic programming unlike a a proper School building some of our smaller buildings including the maintenance facility and the two concessions buildings were also assessed these are smaller buildings lower use also because they're physically smaller their their cost of needs aren't as high doesn't mean they don't have them they're just not as uh critical at this time um while Bureau Veritas was completing their facilities condition assessment another firm Gail Associates looked at the major athletic facilities on the uh Charter Road campus in particular they helped us understand the needs at the junior high and High School tennis courts which if you've been out there are pretty apparent with the cracking we're moving forward with um resurfacing sealing crack sealing work the there this spring um out of fy2 um the Dow
213track needs spot repair and repainting the lower Fields need a fair amount of work with with uh grading and resurfacing new carpet and ballast on top um L field luckily not in terrible shape it's still relatively new and in good condition um but it is on our our uh our sites are on it for the next 10 to 15 years being ready for replacement so overall what did we find um so no surprise a big enrollment um in increase between 95 and 2005 that the district Was preparing for resulted in a lot of school construction and renovation um and we are now just now in 2025 hitting the very beginning of that 30-year mark it doesn't mean we haven't replaced systems we've done a lot of work in our buildings especially remember some of those
214had those separate systems had euls you know less than 30 years but we're starting to see that stuff pile up now so no surprise a lot of the CIP work over the next 10 years or so will will be focused on those Building Systems um another key finding here is is the district buildings are still heavily reliant on natural gas as their primary uh fuel source for heating and then the cooling that we have is limited it's inconsistent and in some cases uh where we have window air conditioners or older H uh AC technology it's it's actually inefficient um and just a reminder June 2024 this school committee did adopt the 2050 decarbonization road map which which is going to call and guide us when we're thinking about these mechanical systems to moving towards air
215heat pumps geothermal and other systems that are are more sustainable and uh doesn't have the same kind of carbon impact um so how do we pay for this um so um fy2 um we had 700,000 allocated out of general fund and we're we're hoping to to see a million for FY 26 to accomplish what we need to do um most urgently um but we're always watching incentive programs um especially those targeted for decarbonization projects from at the state level with Mass Save through the utilities at the federal level with the inflation reduction act um EPA uh opportunities um towns of Acton and now recently boxboro have status as green communities designated green communities boxboro took a long time getting there because of some mechanisms at the how the state recognized uh that town um but
216they have that designation now that opens the door for more um uh grant opportunities msba as I mentioned either both accelerated repair targeted at at major building systems or the core program targeting um you know new building construction and renovation is an option and then finally additional borrowing is is definitely a topic it seems hard to think about taking out a loan at this stage but when you start looking at 10 years down the road the amount of inflation that's tacked onto projects uh you know five to 10 years down um May in fact be more than paying interest in getting the project done sooner so it's another piece we need to to look at pretty carefully um so how do I identify and prioritize projects so the facility condition assessment as I mentioned conducted
217by Bureau Veritas and again the athletic one by by Gail very helpful um in providing the the heavy lifting of information Key Systems their age expected lifespan and conditions um but also principles and administrators provide input our we have an excellent trade staff that's keeping our equipment running and telling us when stuff is really overdue or or due for replacement and sometimes Consultants there's over $150 Million worth of work on the CIP list currently which is looking out approximately 10 years um just keep in mind a lot of those prices are estimated so so it's it's hard to put an exact number on it when we go to prioritize projects obviously health and safety has to be uh logically Priority One and in some cases health and safety related projects have the ability to knock
218other projects off the list or or postpone them um so that's always in our mind we ask the principles and administrators to to set priorities um but we know that their their scope their lens is is building based they're generally recommending Things based on operational need or or or pedagogical needs they're not looking at it from the same districtwide lens we don't expect principles to have to know when a rooftop unit is due for replacement that's our job um but it does mean sometimes our priorities are different so that's where we come in District facilities and operation Team sets priorities again as I said through that wider lens respecting what principles have have determined to be important as as well obviously the availability of funds and incentives is a key factor in in determining what
219we can do and when and then the uh capital subcommittee of this school committee has the opportunity for discussion and approval um so what are we doing what's on the list um so fy2 which we're currently in still has a lot of work to complete this spring um so again funded uh 700,000 from the general fund the roof on this building is is well overdue for replacement um hoping to to get that that done as the weather warms over at Blanchard the play equipment upgrades although mostly community and and CPA funded as you know a big Community fundraising effort um there's still a portion of the district is is covering over there um also it Blancher the water supply for four of the boxboro uh properties known as the Hager well requires chlorination and we're
220back um so there's a portion of the district owes it's based on the amount of water used uh from that well that the that the Blanchard School used um High School tennis courts uh I mentioned um Junior High and High School tennis courts need renovation that's happening this spring and um the high school chemistry lab storage closet needs improved ventilation also happening this spring two emergent projects came up um the uh junior high h3ac controls failed on us or or started going downhill very rapidly this fall those need um immediate attention and uh Parker Damon the chiller plant which was responsible for almost all of the the uh air conditioning in the Parker Damon building went offline or failed um right after school let out so we're trying to get that back online before cooling
221season is upon us in order to have fund those two emergent projects we postponed some engineering on the high school um for some of the rooftop units there to FY 26 which brings us to FY 26 um so again um we're hoping to to see a million dollars from general fund to accomplish what we need to that engineering is now back on the top of the list roll over from fy2 so this is looking at 11 of the oldest rooftop units on the building that actually predate construction they're 1998 um converting those over to air source heat pump important to note we're not actually doing them we're just doing the engineering to figure out how to do them and and how we can price it um there's uh uh keyw work that needs to happen
222at the high school to increase security um this building here um lacks standby uh Power which is a problem when we have a crisis like we did last fall um with the Micro Burst uh Parker Damon building is in need of a new paging system over at Blanchard we're hoping to continue working with air conditioning and so we can air condition additional classrooms the as's here denoting that that there may be incentive funding available if we do this properly so if we can uh leverage air source heat pumps to air condition those spaces and I shouldn't say properly we have to keep cost in mind but um if we can leverage air source heat pumps um we may be able to get incentive funding and bring it to somewhere around the cost of of the
223window units that have traditionally been used in that building our maintenance facility or maintenance shed Des down the street here needs some new doors um over at Boardwalk um even though it's a new building we need to investigate some options for improving the way the library is used um so uh it's it's a two-floor space each floor used by one of the two um Gates and Douglas schools trying to find ways to allow improvements to the Acoustics so those two schools can can coexist in the space without distracting each other um also at Boardwalk small fencing project to um increase student safety between the play area and the active loading dock where trucks are coming and going over the course of the day Junior High um also looking to increase additional air conditioning as well
224as replace some failing and building original um ductless split systems again here um if we can leverage air source heat pumps to do this um which is uh junior high is a good candidate being one story with a flat roof um we may be able to do something incentive based there um over at Parker Damon also some fencing for student safety on the rear playground the cell tower proposal that the school committee approved earlier this fall um if the district wants to invest in um uh Public Safety and operational um Communications that that that comes back that cost comes back to us so some of that infrastructure work needs to be done at the time of tower construction to be done cost- effectively so that's built into this FY 26 plan transportation department um a
225upgrade to the wireless camera system to allow better access to their cameras um the buses have cameras now but accessing the footage from them is is challenging and extremely slow um and finally um some asphalt resurfacing work for safety limited areas and high needs areas only we're not doing massive sads um but here at the high school Conan in Blanchard needs those um so uh before I open it up to questions just a quick acknowledgement we have 40 or more than 40 men and women in the facilities Department that do an outstanding job um their efforts are what keep a lot of the projects off the CIP list um but it can't be done indefinitely in some cases though our trades people um have uh been able to to take a lot of the cost
226out of those CIP projects by either conducting them in house providing some of the services or or whatever it is so a big thank you to them and any questions very good thanks Brandon what was my time anyone clock uh I I did you don't want to know oh come on I I think uh you were you were just shy of 20 minutes no sorry vicam you did great though yeah that's right more Mountain Dews uh just a quick question uh you said uh health and safety is number one uh does Cooling in the buildings when it gets really hot consider is that considered Health I'll go with that one uh it can it can uh yes in in our opinion there's a fine line between How much cooling is needed right so if you
227give me a quantification of the temperature that's uh in the class room if we're talking exceeding 85 Degrees yes yes especially with some of the the the current students we have we do consider that the case do you have an update on the bid on the roofing here I do sure um so we had a public bid uh just last week uh we had a bid opening and we are currently in the stage of uh going through references and and decam certification uh for anyone that doesn't know in public procurement if it's over $150,000 you have to be decam certified and uh we had quite a few bids that were not unfortunately so uh between that uh we did conduct what's called a nuclear test on the building last night for moisture in the insulation
228to also get a better idea of how much square how much square footage of insulation and decking we may need to replace and the the results so far were were very positive for us uh not nearly as much as one would think with the the amount of leaks we've patched over over the past couple years so that's good news uh we're hoping just after the new year to be awarding it and scheduling it for the spring hi um it's a little frustrating to see that the brand new building has a sound issue when clearly that was an oversight with the um designing of the space I mean anybody could tell you that was not wise um I guess it's also equally frustrating to see that health and safety is a priority and yet that is
229top of the list and Conan having no air conditioning is nowhere on the list there there are some uh some current funding um sources Peter might be able to share a little bit more on that um we have some U some meetings coming up February I believe in February at the school itself some walkthroughs uh Peter can share more so Becca I think you know the the biggest piece with Conant um is the school committee needs to make make a decision about if that is going forward in the msba process we had it in the msba process and if you remember we withdrew it last year given the state of our funding uh we just weren't in a position for that we were extremely high in mba's process so if we go forward with that
230Conant obviously would be a candidate for either some type of a major renovation or replacement we don't know the future of that um however until we do that it's really challenging to put large amounts of money into a building that could undergo you know significant State funding understood and I know that came up during the discussion when we were deciding whether or not you know it made sense at the time to move forward with that um but when we're talking health and safety it gets very very hot as we saw this last year I just want to add real quick CIP isn't the only funding source for buildings right operation maintenance funds cover things and especially smaller scale items or or items that come up emergent over the course of the Year any other questions
231or comments thank you guys very much appreciate you staying late for us all right we are going to skip through on our agenda all the way to the consent agenda because it's after 10 o'clock and we know that anything that we do after 10 o'clock is usually not productive so uh items on the sent agenda do not usually require discussion and are approved with one vote unless any member would like to hold an item for discussion and a separate vote I'll read each item and if a member would like it held please say hold you don't have to be present as a member to votee on the meeting minutes item one approval of the absc meeting minutes of 125 2024 uh item two approval of the friends of Acton libraries $188,000 donation to the absd
232libraries and approval of warrants as presented in the packet of 1219 2024 uh those were the three items hearing that none were held is there a motion to approve the consent agenda so so move second so that was Leela and then vickram all those in favor I any opposed extensions that is unanimous and then our next meeting is after the new year and after the holidays on January 16th so before I entertain a motion to adjourn I just want to thank everybody for their participation engagement this evening and wish you all a very happy holidays and a wonderful break and with that is there a motion to adjourn so move that's been vicam all those in favor I any opposed extensions unanimous thank you all very much have a good evening