CorpusRecord 67143

December 19, 2024 Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Riverside Local Schools
Date
2024-12-20
Location
Lake County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
29,674 words · about 165 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Mr PLO can you call roll please Lor KY herea grassy here Jer here Scott V here here please stand for the pledge of allegion IED Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands Nation indivisible with liy and justice for all on behalf of the Board of Education I'd like to welcome all students staff parents and interested community members to tonight's Board of Education meeting I'd like to remind everyone that this is a meeting of the Board of Education held in public for the purpose of conducting a school district business and is not to be considered a public community meeting there is time for public comment during the meeting in the public participation section on the agenda make a motion to approve the November 21st 2024 board minutes

002one second thank you any discussion right Mr PLO can you call roll Scott official hi Dennis Keeny hi Lori kiny hi Linda grassy hi Denise hi Mo to agenda yeah we'd have to do it no before we get in yeah can we do that um I I would like to make a motion to table item a under header 16 until further discussion um as we have not had discussion and no consensus is in place for the process of communications from the board can I get a second on that C second thank you you second that I did is there any discussion on there can we call the RO question again I guess which which part of section 16 item a item a okay since we have not had discussion on that and we continue to

003not have discussion on the process for board communication pleas can't agree on a process well I would add that the board has agreed once the board has voted the board moves forward and the board had voted at least a couple times on that in the affirmative so the board has spoken in the past but we keep putting a resolution on the agenda to have that on our to have that so I'm just asking that we remove it there's no other further discussion Mr platco can you call the role on that Lori piski I Linda Grazy I Denise booster no Scott Bell n Dennis K nay motion declined or motion failed I would also like to propose a resolution to remove Item B under header number 16 we haven't had conversation on that either and we

004had some disagreement on that at our last meeting can I get a second I'll second it thank you is there any discussion on that here I'll just add this resolution does not really give any special power to the buildings and ground committee chair just so they can add items so um I did research to see if it goes against our school policy and it doesn't um so at this time I know that there's it doesn't really it doesn't really have any special benefit it doesn't have any benefit at least we don't think it has any benefit but it doesn't give any of our other committee heads it just doesn't seem to make sense or be consistent with our committee process there's no other discussion can we call the role Belinda grassy I Denny Brewster nay

005Scott fishell nay Dennis Keeny nay l kisy I motion failed okay I would like to remove item C under header 16 um to table conversation on item C which for the record we get there yeah item C is a building addition at Buckeye Elementary and we haven't had any conversation on that at this board table at all um we've had very brief conversation at the buildings and grounds committee meeting in which we did not agree at all on the proposal um and so I feel further further conversation is prior to making a decision on item C which is a building addition to Buckeye Elementary so I'm asking that we remove that from the agenda item until we can have further conversation second there's no other discussion on removing that agenda item Mr platco can you

006call the role Denise Brewster nay Scott bishell nay Dennis Keeny nay Lori kisy I Linda grassy I motion failed I would also like to ask that we remove item D under header number 16 which is to move interest revenue from our general fund to the permanent Improvement fund within five business days after being received um this also is not recommended by our CFO and our Treasurer um it is not recommended by myself either but I'm not on the finance committee but that hasn't brought to our attention um and our 5-year forecast did not include that um as part of the 5-year forecast I'll second is there any discussion on that item yeah I would like to add that that is additional revenue and it does no harm to the operating account and it does no

007harm to the ability of the of the district to operate and so I want to make that note and I will say that those funds were included in the 5year forecast are they not yes so so it does have a negative effect so this is the motion to remove it correct okay there's no other discussion can we call the roll on that Scott visual n Dennis Keeny nay Lori kisy I lenda grassy I Denise Brewster nay motion failed and the last item I would like to remove is item e under header 16 for the same reasons it's not recommended to be moving $1 million from our general fund and moving that over to the pi fund um our 5year forecast isn't even the ink isn't even dry on the F forecast submission um and we

008are now proposing to move a million dollars out of that um which takes away dollars from the education of our students I'll second thank you so I would add that it does not take away money from the education of our students this again is the proper tax revaluation money which will be additional Revenue uh the schools the school district has not seen that in the past um and this is a portion a smaller portion of that um to help the pi fund until the following re the revenues come in from the following next half of the year I just want to make that note I would like to be clear that that those dollars were absolutely included in the 5-year forecast that we just submitted is that not correct Mr PLO yes thank you again

009so this is a motion to remove it yes ma'am there's no other discussion can we call the role please Dennis Keeny n Lori kiski I lenda grassie I Denny Brewster nay Scott Fel nay motion failed thank you that's all I have right that brings us the special reports okay thank you I have three tonight um first up really excited to turn it over to Mr Hall and Mr Lucas and and the Riverside Academy uh Au Academy for their update Mr holl's Riverside's also Elf on the Shelf uh today so we're excited to have him here as well uh present and kind of give an update on Auburn Academy and all the great things that are going on there U joined us as well as Mr Spence so we're excited to have the 18 there you

010have oh yeah you can't borrow this sorry you're looking great well thank you I'm I'm not feeling great as you guys can hear I sound like froggy from Little Rascals so I'm not going to talk too much about this um uh and going to introduce I shouldn't say introduce but talk a little bit about where we are at with our personalized learning uh training um the slide that you see has a maybe a it's not completely in order but what we've been doing so we are in our third year right now of our personalized learning uh training and development uh we've worked through M mainly the esc's of the Western Reserve and Sumit County that's Jake Miller because Jake works out of both offices but there's been lots of folks involved in that process um

011transform was down in Columbus a year ago that was a a series of four trainings uh full day trainings that involved just several districts but the ones that I listed the four that are there Town Perry Twinsburg Mason um and there was I believe West Chester Dakota may have been there as well but I don't remember exactly if it was at school but a lot of networking a lot of sharing a lot of really good ideas happen in there and then uh closer to home uh will be East Lake Mayfield uh they do a lot of some of the things that we are doing in terms of personal what we want to do in personalized learning and also what we are doing currently flexible learning options learn and earn part of of that process and

012our Academy is going to talk a little bit more about that flexible learning option here um once I get through going through this um knowledge Works was also where we started this was prior to my time in the district uh state grant for personalizer and that's how this all began um the experiences that we've had and how we're learning from this a lot of networking from um teachers so learner inventories that come from that uh classroom setup that could be something as simple as the furniture we put in the classroom um how we organize our kids um how we make student learning visible uh presenting student voice uh interdisciplinary work that these guys are really going to talk to you about that a little bit later but bottom line is we're taking teachers and we're

013working together to create lessons that are all problem based and kids own it we are facilitators of learning um so they uh we provide the resources the guidance of those good things and they make that learning authentic as the last bullet point there at second to last uh more realistic and then finally our Auburn Academy and out of this we'll be talking about future cies as well so where we're at our staff is researching we're collaborating planning implementing and evaluating these personalized learning Journeys we are going to be doing personaliz learning uh in the campus with all of our staff um coming January February March uh those months coming we will have a lesson presented we'll be able to go in check it out see what's happening provide some feedback on that evaluate um and

014improve from that uh as I mentioned earlier our teachers of the facilitators this experience their roles are for guidance okay they are U providing serious feedback a lot of extensions and then the roles that our teach our kids work through in those groups uh again what they're going to talk about will address some of that as well Collaborative Learning activities is nothing new we've worked in quads Duos tries even Singletons who are still not single TS they work with the groups they just feel like they feel better sitting at a desk by themselves but I seen that happen as well um a real good example of that's our qualitative reasoning learning by which Mr G is one of our teachers that hybrid learning opportunities and that's just a way to learn in a place that's

015different than a classroom it's still learning and then making student learning visible uh that could be something as simple as a um XY AIS on board and they scoring how well you know whatever standard is that we're working at or the power standards that we go kids are telling you right then there so you have that feedback and it's real simple stuff but it's good stuff so um I'm going to turn this over to miss Lucas and she's going to talk you a little bit more about our personalized learning um journey in particular with auburn Academy good evening everybody I am not Mrs Lucas okay Mr Schmidt and uh I'm here uh I've been fortunate enough I serve as an instructional coach for our district and I've been able to be kind of adopted by

016the Auburn Academy team to kind of be the sixth member of their team uh and kind of support and see which ways we can go to grow the program and to help them any ways we can any ways we can sorry so last year uh in the spring when when this was coming to um fruition and the ideas were out there the the idea of well why are we doing this and and why why do we need this for our kids and there's a c there's there's many reasons the biggest of which we've highlighted here is is one that um traditionally students that would attend Auburn career center while they're getting a a very good education and in their vocation or or an area of Interest they had somewhat limited access to what they could

017do on the campus when they come back to school so um administrators teachers are thinking I think we can give these kids more give them more op options to to round out U their education here while they're still in high school um so we've also notice that the there's a wider variety of students that attend Auburn career center now uh many of which are still on a traditional career path at post high school but many now are in on a trajectory to attend a college program as well and the programs they're in at Auburn give them a head start on those programs so we have a very wide range of students uh in their interests and their backgrounds um and their needs so Mr SCH could you please explain that when the students previously came

018here why they're why they were limited on what they can do and how that got expanded what they can do now so there's a there's a slide Shing on okay did I jump yeah which is awesome it'll be yeah it'll be better basically without having to live Bell to Bell like a student and and with the teachers that are student focused it's much uh easier as you'll see to get a variety of activities for the kids to be able to do yeah and the reason I asked was we had gone over it before but I just wanted everyone to be aware of it yeah thank you for bringing that up and um our teachers then have made it a goal to adjust and adapt and meet the needs of the the learning Learners that are

019in front of them versus just content and um we continue to grow our practice and we continue to learn every day and we continue to try to mesh you know five teachers working together with a group of students and and the teachers have embraced that challenge and done a great job so I'll turn it over to Mrs Lucas I think to talk a little bit about the uh courses oops I also went the wrong way Mr h it's easy to do so um in the past the kids would come back from Auburn and they would have a 45 minute class of English one day the other day they would have study hall and then they would take in their other classes they would take their science maybe but not usually they would take a math

020and then they also had to take their social studies now that we have the financial literacy and government both offer junior year that even limited them more so if you look here you can see that right now within Auburn Academy we offer English three AP Language and Composition financial literacy for the first semester they just finished that they'll all be doing government second semester they can also take chemistry physical Universe which is also a science class and Algebra 2 and quantitative reasoning which I swear I had on there sorry that's okay so they're getting four core classes within there within Auburn Academy which is more than they've ever been able to have and the balance time between those classes is really beneficial as is the overlap between the classes where we're able to know what

021each other are teaching and then supplement that in other classes in addition we have an insane number of classes that the kids are flexing out to if you look at the other side of that slide we have kids who go to review choir symphonic band Wind Ensemble art two which was never possible before art three which was very limited possibility um and we have kids in anatomy and physiology forensics all different math classes and then a ton of AP classes AP English was not possible for Auburn students before and most of those other AP classes were very very very difficult for them to fit in and so now our kids have just really so many more options as Auburn students as to what they can take so it's it's been a really good experience for

022them for that it's a little chaotic sometimes but it's great okay and this is Mrs F she's going to go over some stats that we got we just gave them a survey this week because we do want to continue to grow so we started the year with a survey a personalized learning kind of learner profile and then just this week we gave them a mid what's working what's not what are you happy with how can we continue to grow the program because it's always important to get their input so it up math teacher thank you yeah math teacher so I teach I'm Ino I teach um Algebra 2 and quantitative reasoning which is a I like how Mr Hall calls it applied Algebra 2 it's problem based and um group based and we did ask

023them a survey we asked him 20 questions that range from the classes we were interested in review of our classes but also the whole Academy and three of the questions we asked were how would you rate your experience in Auburn Academy I mean 64% of who answered felt positive or very positive about their experience in Auburn Academy this semester and then um would you want to go back to an 80 minute that is a block schedule and 84% said no they would not want to return to that their senior year and then are they interested in Auburn Academy experience again for next year which we do not currently offer but we are researching it and 87% do want to yeah yeah they're very adamant about that um we wanted to have some students but they

024were all working so here they are back hi um I'm Tyler um I like Auburn Academy because we get one hi um I'm Tyler um I like can you go back on yeah go back one more slide now try there we go hi um I'm Tyler um I like Auburn Academy because we get oneon-one time with teachers and it's a lot easier to keep up on work and um make sure there's nothing missing get a lot better grades that's about it hi I'm Lizzy and I think what I like having shorter classes is easy to focus for just like classes in general it kind of keeps me more engaged rather than getting bored with my work and not wanting to just sit in class for a full minutes hi I'm Maddie liin I like Auburn

025Academy cuz my classes are shorter hi I'm Kylie um I go to Auburn and I'm in the Auburn Academy and the one thing I really like about this is that all of your classes together and it's hard for you not to be your class just hi I'm Derek I go to Auburn and I'm in Auburn academy uh I like it because it gives us more freedom and uh we do get to hang out with friends and we actually have time to complete work usually we don't and I don't like say for 80 [Music] minutes hi my name is Mandy and I like Auburn Academy because it's less pressure and I'm getting good grades I like the flexibility of Auburn Academy and the ability to take art three that I wouldn't have without it those are

026some of our kiddos they we asked some of them to come but they all have jobs and also they're done I mean it's really let's face it it's end of the the time before break um in addition to the what we saw as positives in the midyear survey we also saw that there is some room for improvement some of the kids identified that they wanted more teacher time for Math and Science some kids said they really wanted a silent area to work and um they wanted to make sure they were getting sat or act really like prep time and then um they need to learn some time management skills so we met today um and those are all things that we are building into as we move forward into the second semester which is great

027because we have a really good team we work really well together and we're able to adapt and change as needed because nothing's set in stone and we work for what the kids need how has this space worked for you because I know it's actually pretty good is it good yeah um and we take kids um the science teacher takes kids to her room for labs because that room is available so we do that um and then in the second semester we're going to combine government and English and work with those together with a larger group of kids is a cross-curricular experience so that'll be another way that that space I think will function even more efficiently but it's it's been good yeah we have some walls but we might need more um we I wanted

028to point out we did a cross-curricular midterm that was really fun um I'm also in student the student council adviser so I'm involved with h and Po and every year we turn the media center into a giant P plut course so this year we had the Auburn Academy students design the holes for the putput course and we did that as their midterm project in the past for the Auburn kids the Juniors they go to Auburn all morning then for exams they had to come back and take their exams during makeup time and it was always so sad because everybody else is done o I get a half day I'm done after my exams and these poor kids put in a ton of work at Auber and then came in here so we thought a Project

029based assignment would be really good so we did this it Incorporated all of their subjects so they did scale drawings for science they developed and worked within a budget for cial literacy they used math equations to determine cost Effectiveness for their math class and then for English they did um 902 elevator pitch which we talked about what an elevator pitch was and then they got up in their Pairs and gave those and then we also had course managers who applied through a resume process and they designed the entire course layout um and we had four of those so these are some of the kids giving their elevator pitches they had to have um a visual so you can see they have their whole design another group had um their description up there um and here's

030a couple more and then you can see sitting there leaning forward and looking that's a couple of our course managers who were studying these holes taking notes deciding what they wanted to choose for the project and then our course managers led the class in laying out nine three nine-hole courses we have three nine-hole courses in the media center they LED that the Auburn Academy students laid out the entire thing they decorated the media center so it was also a bit of a service project for them getting them more involved in the school community and something good for the entire district and there they are doing some of the work and then the there's just one of the holes that they designed that was based on some of the things that they did before and a

031couple of the other holes so I thought that was just a one thing that we did that's it thank you you're welcome thank you thank you all you had 27 holes of golf and yeah we have um a little kid one with plastic balls and clubs and then we have two nine-hole ones that we use real balls and real Club so what did Santa bring you what what did Santa bring what the heck is that right oh no the other day we got Shi okay there we go so it I mean from a pilot to where they've taken it it's been amazing to see what they've done personalized learning uh we are looking to expand the personalized learning program next year um obviously our seniors in Auburn Academy want it um and we have other

032students who are looking into what that looks like um and also we are looking into other U Avenues to kind of make it so it's a little bit easier for our staff to do it as well uh that helps to kind of offer these options to our students who need it uh who learn best that way and kind of where we can meet them where they are and continue to drive them so we'll keep you updated on our personalized learning Journey as we go uh but we've seen nothing but uh really strong results uh obviously it's the first time of year so there are some hiccups along the way but I'll tell you this seem that teachers have really done a nice job working through those uh we knew there were going to be challenges

033we said in the beginning it wasn't going to be perfect and change is messy and they've done a great job moving through it and all of the students you talk to who attend the academy are very appreciative not only of the opportunities they have to be in other classes but also just the opportunities they have to learn uh in a personalized manner that really does fit their needs um moving forward so it's it's been a great experience and we're really uh something to be proud of and something that we are going to um shout out as to how we do this in the district because we are meeting the kids where they are instead of forcing them into our schedule so uh my next report um I am not talking much tonight at all and

034I love it um I am turning this over to uh Ryan Smith and Roger raty from TDA and RFC construction uh to talk about a little bit about the building updates and present uh the plans so good evening thank you um I guess we have quite a bit to report since last time I was here which was about eight months ago I think or so so since then we've went through a few rfqs uh some selections and I'm going to talk in particular about the um CTE project which is the addition here and then also the uh riverv viiew project that was added um in the last couple couple months so on the CTE we've selected TDA and Ryan's steam as being the architect we selected Cleveland construction to be the CMR uh since those

035selections we uh we've had a schematic design effort put together that Ryan is going to talk about tonight and and share with you we've done some preliminary budgeting as well on um on on that project and uh we're uh hoping to get some approvals from the board so we can keep going with the with the design um on the riverv viw we also did a uh RFQ um I believe you've approved at your last board meeting uh also TDA to be the architect believe tonight uh there's there's I'm assuming you're going to be asked to approve clear construction as the construction manager atrisk on that project as well and uh there's been some very preliminary designs also done on that as far as the uh the addition where that's going to go so that's kind

036of what we've been doing in the last uh few months on these projects we're hoping to get some approval so we can keep going uh the goal is to work uh on the design uh throughout the winter and have something ready late winter early spring uh for the CMR to take it to GMP and come back to the board uh later on the second quarter of 20125 early spring to uh present the GMP for approval and uh hopefully start construction from there so if you don't have any questions regarding that process and want us just shared with you and we'll turn it over to Ryan all right yeah I'm Ryan Schmid with TDA architecture uh thanks for having us here tonight I'm going to run through kind of the work that we've been asked to

037take a look at uh thus far uh there are the three projects that are listed up there uh we do have Riverside which is uh going to be the CTE Edition uh there is the elementary school um I'm sorry the I have that mislabeled up there it should be it should say riverb elementary school classroom Edition and then there are a couple of studies that we did very extremely preliminary studies uh for Buckeye Elementary uh more will fits than anything than anything else so uh that being said does anybody mind if I stand up there and point at the screen I like to talk and point at things so and if anybody can't hear me just let me know but uh we could skip with the first slide so really what we have here um

038this is the CTE Edition uh that we're talking about this has been a process where we got uh really nice involvement uh for members of kind of the the group that was steering it and had members of administration we had principal there we had uh various entities there to kind of talk through where the elements of the project would go where the program would fit into this uh corner of the building uh for anybody that isn't familiar with it this is kind of that bar that has welding and construction your student dining is in this General location uh this is beastro kind of Commons uh this is the big parking lot to the North and then Jr is off to this side so this is kind of a site plan study um we still have

039to work through the details of this so there's going to be sidewalks associated with it there's probably a desire to look at some some potential uh patio space there access to this new CTE Edition which would be it probably be a overhead door and a little bit bit of a drive up that sort of thing so you can unload supplies and things of that nature but generally this is the area that we're talking about this is an approxim of the footprint uh of the space this isn't a fully baked plan but this is a is a really far along preliminary plan so what we did is you have the various elements that went into the project there's the construction lab uh which would be a space with tools and that's where you do activities and

040work and things of that nature there's a shared classroom which will have uh access for all the programs in the CTE Wing but also be able to help support the health care uh component of this as well and then there's Advanced manufacturing this piece here that's got a lot of your more uh kind of high-tech equipment so that's you know some of your more interesting types of robotic arms and that's some of your uh cutting uh equipment that runs off a computer and some of your uh 3D printers and things of that nature so it's kind of almost a clean room if you will of of sorts um and then there's accessory spaces so what you have here this building I'm sure everybody that's walked through this building knows there's a bunch of different level

041throughout this building um the main Corridor that's here that's that ABS Commons and student dining is up at a certain level you have to go down steps to get into Commons and student dining so the first thing the very first thing you needed to do is make some form of a connection from the main Corridor off to this space so there is a little bit of a rework uh in this area of the building kind of where beastro is uh to get a hallway and a and a ramp in that space to get people down into this area of the building and get you down on grade uh what this does do though is it makes a really nice connection to this new CTE Wing but it also does make a nice connection to student

042dining and Commons so that you have a really accessible Ada accessible ramped area that gets you from one section of the building up to the other and allows for an entrance at this location that allows users from the parking lot to get into these areas of the building it's something that is a little bit lacking in that area of the building since it is kind of the back side of the building uh over in that area what this also does is it allows us to kind of lock down this area get access to these bigger spaces and have access to a couple of restrooms that we'd be adding over in this area so you have a lot of amenities there that would work for after after school activities uh and things of that nature uh

043the left over space here this area is the beastro space so this would be reworked and reconfigured to allow this to happen and then we will pick up some additional space here uh that would provide support for the wood shop currently that space is very small uh and this would provide space for storage of tools and supplies and things of that nature um moving back up into the heart of the addition if you will um this is showing that shared classroom kind of central between these two spaces uh this is a nice feature and that the construction lab can have access to it and you have access to Advan Advanced manufacturing from the same space so you've got this relationship between these rooms uh that allows them to work very effectively and you be able

044to flow from one space to the other other um so that if you have for example instruction happening in shared classroom and then you need to break off and do activity you can break off into advanced manufacturing or if you have instruction going here and you need to break out to the construction lab you have access there so there's this really nice kind of synergy between these spaces um the other nice thing is we do still have these connection to Woodshop and Welding so this this Corridor if you will on these accessways will provide this really nice relationship between all of these these programs and then the last piece is kind of this connection that gets you back out to the parking lot that's right where you have that access drive that's currently there that

045gets you up into welding and allows uh access of supplies uh in that space as well and really what we're asking for here we did go through pretty exhaustive effort looked at a ton of plans uh to arrive at something that I think everybody felt kind of meant the intent of what we were trying to do with this space uh gets this the space that we need to um adequately provide for these various programs uh so what we're looking for is just approval to proceed with the plan and continue with the development of the elevations the sections and everything else we need to really put together uh the construction drawings so that uh the cedar can price it and Build It ultimately what about the height of the new areas in comparison so um that

046that's been a lot of conversation too what you're trying to do always is balance uh buying volume volume is expensive versus U making something that fits in with the rest of uh the buildings on campus across here you can see there are about 10 different levels that happen across here so really what we did is construction is the tallest space that we have shown here construction the idea with construction there is a band that runs around the bottom of the windows on the second floor it's also it's about 18 ft from the ground it's a really nice height to allow for that construction space and it would have a relationship with that banding we're looking at elevations now to make sure it looks really nice I feel like it does uh but this will create

047that relationship with this existing building then we'd step down so we'd have our uh shared classroom space which could step down that relates to the second floor level of the rest of this space so that's still a nice 14t height is 14 foot 8 which gets you enough space in there to run your Mechanicals get your structure in there provide adequate volume so that the space doesn't feel small it feels appropriate for the the space itself um but still starting to bring your your building down to scale and then last kind of back in this area we are bringing it down to I think it's right around 11t and a half uh 12T in this back portion here um this will bring down the scale to a more human scale since you would have access

048out here for students to go outside um you don't necessarily want three giant walls surrounding this space so this brings it down to a more human scale at that space and does save you money and doesn't buy extra volume that you don't necessarily need and is this space air conditioned yes yeah are there joining spaces air condition presently no uh we've been focusing on the active space of the project uh there are a lot of things that we have talked about but we just have not put pinned paper on uh anel spaces Dr malaker does this m meet your kind of vision of what you saw for our Career Tech education yes yes after multiple iterations we have gotten to yes where I think we are at a comfortable point to move forward and the

049staff that's involved with these um you know the instruction these spaces have had input into no no we have not we did it at at an administrative level we designed the space when we get into the nitty-gritty of what will go in the spaces that's when we'll bring okay cuz I just wonder about storage setup other accommodations I didn't know at what point we needed to involve them could could I add to to that comment this is really a process of um you know like if you bake a cake I always bring back this analogy but you get out of the ingredients first yeah you got to get the ingredients in the bowl and then you determine how you put everything together we're at the point where we're just putting the stuff together now is

050where we add the detail we're starting to get into the part where you look at this room where's the best place for your teaching wall how much cabinet tree should you have to support the various programs that are going to use utilizing that space should be doors and drawers how should all those pieces come together so there's varying levels of information that go into each of those steps and we're kind of we got our foot in the door we've got something that I think from a spatial standpoint really gets us what we need and now it's just a matter of kind of filling in details and rounding it out and obviously their buying is very important when we get into that any other questions on this particular piece if not we can move forward to

051River viw hopefully I labeled it right if I did um so uh what we're looking at here uh we were tasked with looking at where uh an eight classroom Edition could go uh we looked at all around the building you know which spaces might make the most sense we looked I mean starting at the building for anybody that isn't familiar this half of the building is pretty much your kind of um High activity spaces which is like student dining and gymnasium kind of entrance music all those sorts of things happen over in this section of the building so a connection over in that area doesn't really make much sense this is your uh academic wings of the building where you have more your core traditional type classrooms um to go to the north this direction

052there is this drive here but there is a pretty substantial drop um and you are getting um quite far away from parking lots and kind of access to Life Safety Services and things of that nature um so one other consideration and kind of notching into some of these spaces is there's an existing stair up in this location there are some existing classrooms with Windows uh and things like that across the back of this building uh there are a lot of things that could be uh adjusted to make that connection possible uh but just at a cost um there's a lot of cost that would require additional rework in some of those spaces and you might have to swap out spaces in order to uh make that work so kind of The Logical connection point there

053is a hallway that runs down along here that kind of dead ends at some doors at this location there's a stair right here this is really nice this location would allow us to build an addition with that same connection that same connective hallway that gets you down to Administration all those sorts of things maintains a stair and eress out of the building at that location and it would allow an addition to be built in that location without um significant disruption to the rest of the campus it's kind of on its own it would be able to be sectioned off during construction allow eress out of that space uh and would be really conducive to allowing the work to happen um in a way that's less impactful uh to other people in the building this does

054uh require that you would have to get this adjacent property um or some of this adjacent property to make that happen as your property line is about in this General location here uh but in addition in this spot would allow you to get uh some additional parking off in that area uh the potential for some pickup drop off space uh uh with prek potential on the first floor in that location as well so there are a lot of nice features to this um the other thing it does do is it maintains this big open space here which can be utilized for some Outdoor Classroom space uh some playground space things of that nature and things that would really kind of round out your offerings uh on that portion of the campus you do have playgrounds

055over here but if you do have the younger age children over on this side of the building it is nice to have features that are maybe brought down and scale more to U their age what are the options if we don't require the land um the option if you don't acquire the land we would have to look at something that would kind of go in this general direction or you would have to go to the north there do you have any renderings of uh what that would look like not with me I do not so there were options draw that way though um I've explored dozens of options to kind of go through and just look at probably the most cost effective method of positioning the space is it possible to send the entire board

056all the options that have been put in place yeah I mean if that's requested by the board we can more than definitely do that please and I um I know Nick you've been there too um there's a lot of activity behind the school you know with Community Soccer and different things and every everybody's trying to squeeze in that little parking lot so that would be a nice Community feature to have additional parking because there's so many people trying to park yeah I've I've come here several times for soccer we get killed every time so soccer yeah I know such a bottom back there yeah okay any other questions yeah okay and then last this is just real highle concept studies for Buckeye uh again kind of what we're asked to do here is look at

057the potential for an addition at this building um and kind of in the range of 12 to 13 classrooms some of somewhere in that that neighborhood um as the site currently sits um you have two academic bars here uh with your kind of core classroom spaces Library this is your student dining gym space this is kind of this houses all of your uh utilities that's gas water power heating all that sort of stuff is in this corner of the building and then your main Administration area is down in this area which isn't sizable but there's offices and stuff down in this area of the building main AIS right here um the challenge is if you were to do any addition to the South there's already parking and loop drives and all your utilities are kind

058of coming in this location of the building so anything to the South gets a bit challenging um the logical place the most cost effective place the easiest place is right where um the existing modular unit Set uh which are in these locations here this would allow you to there's kind of corridors that wind through here you can almost see them on this plan uh but there's a main Corridor that comes through here it would allow you to tie right into that and so you could have an addition off the north it would tie directly into the building similar in the concept of how the modellers are laid out but obviously a new building this is showing a two-story building in this location with stairs elevator classrooms on both floors uh mechanical rooms a little bit

059of administrative space and a gymnasium down in this area um we did look at an option uh that extended further north as one story it gets really really big uh it gets pushed really far back onto the site and leaves you very little room uh for fields or for for playground space this dense um kind of layout I think is nice from the standpoint of if you do have students on the second floor here they access to get back to this portion of the building is much shorter uh than if they did get pushed pushed out in this direction um the second option looks at figuring what what if the gymnasium doesn't want to be here uh where else could you put it this area like I said is really hot with a lot of

060utilities coming into this portion of the building this was the other area that uh looking at this made sense from kind of an access standpoint I do like a relationship between dining and gymnasium just because if you have kind of overflow flow or if you you have um some sort of an activity going on in the gym that has support space uh in in the dining area it's nice to have those two next to each other that is not required uh it's not you know set in stone that that's mandatory to do have that relationship but if you're able to do it you you know it's a nice feature to have this this would put a larger portion of the building up front uh but we could do something with kind of the massing of

061that to kind of help bring down scale and it is a Elementary gymnasium that you know is not the same size as whiches here at high school so it does already have a a smaller kind of footprint and height than you would have at a high school but again these are really high level these are just showing kind of from a spatial allocation standpoint uh how that might fit on the site in case you chose to go that direction so again I don't feel that all the concepts are here we have concept one concept two and then Mr official gave us option one and option three so option three is this option right so why would we have an option three is there another concept that concept two was the one where I extended it

062all on one floor again I would ask you to share it with the entire board we can do that can I ask how the you came up with these Concepts did you work with the administration on them no these are purely just looking at square footage so this is who did you work with I guess I I was just given directive to Mr official asked me to take a look at the plan so we looked at the plan we did not we didn't have any directive as to what to do was the administration aware of the work I I don't know Dr Tino Mr PLO were you guys aware of the work that was being done here I did know um I did share the initial facilities plan with Ryan and kind of asked him

063at one of our meeting I think it was at the CTE meeting as to when um would be a good time to discuss some just preliminary type ideas of adding on the Buckeye he said sooner rather than later okay um so I was aware that he was aware of it but were you engaged in the discussion on what the concepts look like in the concept discussion I was not okay thank you this just to point out too we are not hired to do this we're not getting paid to do this this was just to look at spatial allocation to be used however deem necessary at the request of one board member cor right we we're asked by our client to take a look at this um so um there's like I I've heard Dr rtin

064will talk about you know reworking the parking in the front um and then it like there would be additional parking extended along the left side of this this would consider that this is showing like how you might do that you might choose not to do any parking on that side but I think if you were to do an uh layout where you have gymnasium on the side it would make sense to extend your parking for sure um that is not a large parking lot on that campus uh the flow of the parking this is not vetted out this would not be the final solution but this is looking at saying you might want to pick up some parent parking up front uh that's accessible to the main entrance you might want to reconfigure your Loop

065so you have access out you can put buses to the north those are things that you might want to consider uh if you move forward with the projects um those would be elements that you really want to take a look at and figure out how you best do that that is something again this is a fit plan this is not saying we have a design this is something that once you get into that you yeah you'd involve the principles you'd involve facilities involve everybody so I just I just want to make sure that that we're clear as a board we haven't discussed this as a project yet yet we have our architect working on designs I'm not comfortable with that um we we haven't talked about it at this table at all so it's my

066understanding too that there was more than one board member that you were working with at times no not on this how about on the CTE or the um Riverview Mr I work I worked with CT at the same time no so they never visited your office together no okay no Mr Keeny came to the meetings we had here as well that we had again I'm just I'm just going to make it clear I'm not comfortable with that the the when you say you're working for the client the client is the Board of Education not one board member so I'm not comfortable with it so just so everyone knows in the buildings and grounds I'm the chair so gathering information to bring to the buildings and grounds and to the board in general I had asked

067for a couple renderings options that that could be done and then shared that in the buildings and grounds meeting so as a board member gathering information is what we're supposed to do and I know Miss gra you're not happy with that and in the past you probably didn't do much of that but I'm doing my job and I brought it to the buildings and grounds and we are now discussing it here furthermore uh superintendent ratino I would ask you when did you first uh when did you first write into your 5-year facilities plan template uh in addition at Buckeye I don't know the exact timeline probably about three months ago I can't tell you it was after the board um the board approved the Riverview Edition about 3 months ago sure okay so in the

068in our superintendent uh template for the 5-year facilities plan which we'll be looking at tonight uh he shared with the board the whole board so the whole board knew that the superintend had stated and I had meeted with met with the superintendent and we discussed this I agreed that the next item had to be Buckeye okay so about three months ago our superintendent suggested we needed to do an addition at Buckeye at that point in time it was eight classrooms and then uh he has up that to 12 classrooms U and and we discussed that and I certainly agreed with that so anyway uh looking for some information as to what that would look like to share it uh with the board and with the buildings and grounds which I'm the chair of the committee

069that's exactly what I did we haven't approved the plan though the plan was never approved it's not been discussed at the table for the final review of it so the plan's it's not been approved yet correct so why are we working on correct so how do we end up with a vote on it when we haven't even approved the plan so again I just I do share the same thing the administration should have been involved in the building the concepts and talking about it and about how the space is going to be used so they're not put in a position where they can't answer those questions um it's as simple as that I mean that's just they they should be involved in these discussions and as that's moving forward the board should be apprised of

070that information I would ask from now on if you do meet with one board member you share all the information with the entire board please thank you other questions thank you thank you thank you thank you okay the last one is um Michael pcel from I can't even pronounce Saina is that how say I should be able put Tong with I know uh and Associates uh share a little bit about certificates of participation which is mentioned in the facilities plan kind of the way options to finance some of this work remain seated I know you're all recommending your new plans you swivel camera that's an alternate maybe one more comfortable seating in the lecture room is definitely something I appreciate the opportunity to uh meet with everyone tonight Gary had asked some questions about some

071potential financing structure specifically focused on what are called lease Revenue uh transactions lease Revenue financing certificates of participation it's one of the few ways a school district can actually issue debt without a vote uh they have a pretty unique structure associated with them uh I don't want to go into something that maybe everyone else knows do you want me to explain a little bit you want maybe just give a quick overview of the different borrowing options available to the school districts and why we landed on proposing doing a cops borrowing and you know limitations of doing just issuing General obligation debt the limitations and then also the like tax anticipation notes and what our limitations very good so obviously you've been through the process of going to the ballot with what's called an unlimited tax

072obligation uh Capital ballot initiative that would generate revenues to pay off a bond issue to build buildings the most traditional method by any school district K through 12 here in Ohio that they use uh because you have limited borrowing options outside of that after that you do have the option uh to Levy against your incoming revenues for a permanent Improvement uh or incoming taxes what's called a tax anticipation note uh these are restricted to a smaller maturity overall so they're better for smaller transactions because the structuring uh opportunity on those is quite limited uh for the legal situation so with the larger transaction about which Gary has talked with me the certificates of participation offers essentially all the benefits and structures of an unlimited tax General obligation you can go up to 30 years of

073maturity they do carry with them a premium in cost cost as far as overall interest in the market because they are subject to appropriation risk the reason a school district can enter into this lease Revenue transaction is through the uh legal eyes of a high Revised Code you are entering into for instance if it was 30-year maturity 30 annually appropriated lease payments so every year you would have to vote as a board to appropriate funds to pay for your particular lease payment which we would call a Debt Service payment this offers maximum flexibility in terms of repayment structures it'll also carry with it a prepayment option which a tax anticipation note generally does not so that means in an opportunity like this where we may be in some higher interest rates you have a prepayment

074option you wait a certain amount of time then you'll have the ability to potentially refinance or restructure structure the issue if you wish so it's what we call it call option optional Redemption Provisions so in terms of comparing the cops to the utgo for the most part they both walk talk and Quack Like A Duck but the main difference there being is you're limited to 30 years maturity for the cops and again there will be a premium to that and that leads into the one area about your rating if you go cops district is currently rated A3 you just upgraded in 2023 June of 23 so uh cops transaction because there is appropriation risk when it trades in the market the credit rating agencies will say you are going to trade at one notch lower

075than your general obligation rating so your dou A3 unlimited tax General obligation your lease Revenue certificates of participation appropriated debt rating would be A1 so when you enter into the single a range now there's a rather large disparity on the yield curve in tax exempt municipals between a doublea entity and a single a entity upon paying the extra premium for the cops in general because of the appropriation risk coming down to a single a credit rating on the transaction will also increase your borrowing levels but what we would do is examine the use of enhancement object bond insurance that would give that particular issue a transaction action rating of double A you pay for that however what you pay Upfront for that insurance policy will be greatly outweighed by the present value cash flow benefit

076you would get from trading at a double A versus a single a so that's kind of the overall comparisons between the options that a district has there are s few other esoteric ones that really don't apply to the situation House Bill uh 2 2 64s um stuff like that but that's really not going to be an option here uh in order to borrow for this particular structure the main thing to be considered as well with a cops is that you were going to enter into a land lease and so the way the cops Works within the eyes of the Ohio revised code is you have an asset that you're going to lease and we will work with Tom Tom Wilson Tom Wilson at binmore the names change so often I can't remember the the firms

077are all merging together now and what will happen is there will be put in place within the documents the disclosure what we call the uh preliminary official statement or in this case a offering circular uh you will enter an agreement through a special purpose entity where it's basically the structure of a caps is what we call in the world a cell lease back and that's how it works so there will be a COR a shell Corp that will lease the asset back to the board and that's why you get into the Third 30 annual lease payments and so in order to do that we have to be very privy to the actual land because there will be a survey conducted and certificate holders will have through a proxy through the trustee on the transaction a

078land lease lean on that asset through the course of the overall lease can you I'm sorry can you repeat that one more time about the land certainly so when you lease back the asset the land is separated underneath when you go out certificate holders now have access to this land so whatever is on that land they get to do with if you don't pay your bills they cannot liquidate it they cannot take it down they cannot sell it but what they can do is transplant whatever you have going on in that asset building and make it very difficult you to carry on so what they are banking on is a cash flow credit this is called a mission critical asset so we're going to give them a lean on an asset that they very well

079know the district cannot forsake because legally as these are annually appropriated lease payments you have the option to not appropriate and you would be totally legal within your legal rights however the detriment that that would have on your overall credit rating you would have very difficult times ever accessing Capital markets for further financing again in the eyes of the capital markets that's a default that only applies to the building footprint correct that is correct well there's going to be uh a general property footprint associated with that land lease generally outside the just the building footprint so something to consider if you're thinking about acquiring land or for that matter if you think you are going to expand upon these pieces this is something Tom Wilson and I will get into detail with Gary when he

080designates what the legal uh parameters of the approach will be nothing will be put in stone until we know exactly what the overall Target for that property is going to be so does that mean we would have to reparel our property or they going to take a land lease on the whole parcel that we already have a school building sitting on that's correct you will not have to reparel okay only if they do a survey and they find out there's anything that's unclean in the titles and that happens rarely but the survey will give a a clean bill of health to the title and then whatever asset yeah you have on the designated land lease that will be subject to that lean per the lease documents and then what does this do to our overall

081borrowing capacity if we decide to go to bond financing for something later this will not affect that doesn't affect our limit no it does not the limit that you would have to go to the uh for a ballot initiative on an unlimited tax basis will be purely predicated one on a percentage of your assessed valuation and then if you qualify for um exceptional need which here that could very well be the case because your enrollment is growing and how many school districts ever chose not to appropriate angle de none never in a while it's one of those things it's in theory but in practice it's it's what's the number of years time frame fewest number of years and you're saying up to 30 years what's the time frame range so it all depends on the

082tolerance of The Debt Service payment the shorter the maturity for the overall borrowing the higher your debt service payment's going to be and in this particular borrowing environment you really don't want to limit yourself to the short end of the curve cuz right now that's where the most detriment is happening the curve has been inverted significantly in these inflationary times where short-term rates are much higher than long-term rates so if you start to take a let's just say you have an issue at 30 years with an overall interest rate what we call a true interest cost on it a tick of 4.75% at 30 years you could easily take that all the way down to 10 years and I bet you you'll still be at 4.6% so you can just accelerate and pay it off

083sooner that's what the prepayment option is for the optional Redemption provisions and at sub zenan Associates as Gary very well knows we will hold the underwriter to task to shorten that period which will be totally acceptable by the market and that's 5 years where most firms will push for 10 years so that adds maximum flexibility the process of getting into a lease Revenue transaction uh depending on when you part foreseeing the need for the cash um is going to be a little bit longer than normal transaction just because of the land lease documents we have to work with the trustee to get those all put in place Tom Wilson's done it before he's veteran Bond counsel he's done many of these transactions so but there's just a little added prep one of the things that

084we would have to get going immediately is a survey a title search that is going to be required to even try to qualify for insurance which we will qualify for insurance here which that will probably get a little too into the weeks for tonight's discussion if we get to that bridge will Crossing how how how common is it for districts to do these cops oh very common very very common I've done these for districts all over Northeast Ohio uh now especially it is common because uh the oscc has now allowed participating districts to fund their local portion of a cfat project with cops that never used to be the case they would always make you have to come up with a larger number that you'd have to pass so if you can do a cops

085to come up with your local portion and as well be able to go to the ball that's why they're they're a very popular instrument how much how do how do we determine what our cops limit is you know what I'm saying and like what we're allowed to borrow all comes down to affordability you have no legal limitus to much how much you can borrow that would fall on my shoulders I am your fiduciary if I was to engage with you and allow you to borrow something you couldn't afford I would be at fault and I will not love that I will at least not suggest that do we still have to do that big offer statement for that so we would have to do that all over again I did hand out um a a

086basic diagram here showing different cops options that Mr Pella provided to us uh to myself this showing what 15 20 and 25 year borrowings look like at amounts between 10 million and 17 million this so you can see on the far right hand side what that average annual debt payment would look like um just so you kind of see how those fall out um based on how much we determined to Barrow at some those numbers have been rendered somewhat obsolete with a major market movement in the last 48 hours I wasn't able to update them cuz they're plethora off scenarios there but um as I'm certain everyone's heard uh the the new market commentary coming out from the Fed was potential ease off cutting short-term rates this December as well as reducing the number they're

087going to cut in 2025 that set the market crazy the Dow took a major hit and 10year and treasury rates all skyrocketed so the numbers would be larger the probably the numbers are going to be a little bit bigger yes yeah yeah and as far as Debt Service what would you see as a source of income for that if we were do this we would be paying those debt payments out of our permanent Improvement fund permanent Improvement fund and those those revenues come from the permanent Improvement Levy right correct which is continuous it's continuous right so what's the time frame um start to finish in in U going to Market and and closing it up uh green light hit the ground running you say we're going to do it you have an amount you're probably

088talking 45 to 60 days that's from start to actual funding Gary is on the lower end of that I've worked with many many treasurers that having them to do offering circulars is like pulling teeth he is the absolute opposite of that one update in 24 hours yeah it's quite a pleasure he's an allar it is really pleasure to work with real pleasure to work with one of the things when you're when you're doing one of these type of borrowings for a capital Improvement you know once we go to market Let's us say $10 million we issue those those cops we received that $10 million in cash we deposit that into what's called a building fund we Ed the fund 04 similar to what we did with parksite and riview for those that were around that

089time once you have that cash in hand now you can invest it and start earning interest because obviously as construction goes on that takes a long period of time and you're going to make those payments throughout the construction so you can use those funds to kind of generate additional funds and usually use those for change orders or additional wants in the project as we go on because those things will come up as we go through design and you know so there's a little bit of benefit when you have that cash there's always that lag between when you actually get the cash and then when you liquidate so you're able to earn something that's on that up to yeah you can't make more no you cannot Arbitrage positive with a tax exempt issue something that hasn't

090happened until the last 20 years 15 for the most part 2008 yeah probably closer to 20 you're right honestly it's uh essentially the IRS will look at our numbers when we're done with the transaction and there's a specific calculation Bond Council will provide what's called an 8038 Arbitrage yield or a bond yield and that I RS 838 form shows overall bond yield on this meaning your overall interest cost according to that calculation which just say is 4% it's higher than that but I'm just giving you the round number so Gary can not go take those funds for which you borrow overall at 4% and go invest in something that's going to yield him 4 and a qu% or 4 and a half% that's Arbitrage and you would get nailed by the IRS then you'd have

091to go into rebate calculation and repayment proceedings and it's not fun we will monitor all that Gary do you have any pictures of or kind of say what this does to the fiveyear forecast if we were to do something like this because we' be using permanent my recommendation is we use permanent Improvement funds and I wouldn't necessarily affect the general fund 5 forecast it will affect the permanent Improvement fund forecast that we put together um one of the scenarios I we did went through in a prior meeting uh when proposing the borrow for RW was I think I put set aside somewhere in a $400,000 range for an annual debt payment um obviously this is a little bit higher than that U looking at larger amounts if doing review and and and Bucky so it's

092kind of it really depends on how how what the estimate of these building improvements will come in at and determining what we want to borrow what we want to because we do have you know about $6 million in our per premum fund as of right now so it's balancing using some of that current cash balance and in the borrowing options to to try to maximize our our funding but it would leave us with funds in RPI fund that if there was an emergency or something that we needed to do we would have access to that that would be my my recommendation is that we we don't drain our PI too low so we have enough funds for those rainy day fun rainy day activities that you know we you get a boiler or a roof

093or something unexpectedly we yeah what do we what do we collect in that fund we collect around 2 6 to 2.7 million a year from property taxes that fund we do earn interest on some of that balance obviously as that balance goes down as we do these projects we're going to obviously earn less interest but around 2.6 to 2.7 is the typical average last last one thing I wanted to know too is the with the reappraisal that fund won't increase the tax rate will be lowered so it's not you won't see an increase in revenue from the reappraisal in the permanent Improvement fund um that's separate from the 20 mil floor calculation and and you don't realize a gain on that fund from valuation increases if we take a an estimate of what we spend

094in that fund on a general basis year-to year buses um Chromebooks whatever other kinds of things that we're putting in there I can't even I can't even guess because I I don't remember off the top of my head what it is that we spend in that fund on those kinds of things and then giving us a reserve like obviously we're not going to want to go up to 1.6 right if I believe if I have to go back and look cuz I'm kind of just on the Fly anywhere between a million and a million and a half is spent annually between Chromebooks technology purchases textbooks Vehicles buses and all those other things that we purchase out of the per on an annual basis Bas right so that leaves you just over about a million to

095xspi revenue outside of your average expenses the the the column original issue excess premium is that the cost of borrowing no no so it's a good question I don't mean to get too far into the weeds but what's what's happening now is because there's such volatility in the market investors essentially uh when they run their portfolios when they buy Municipal debt they will structure cash flows and pay a premium for a higher coupon rate so that whatever they own almost like an equity shows a higher dividend in their portfolios which gives them a higher nav value and by doing such we are borrowing you are getting more from the investor than what's par on that particular Bond so for instance if you went out and wanted to borrow $20 million investors structure the cash flow

096so they are giving you 20 million plus let's say an additional 5 million in original discount or original excess original issue premium that money cannot be utilized to offset your construction fund that's Ohio Revised Code okay so no matter what my par size on a cop's issue cannot be any lower than what I am depositing into your construction fund so anything more that the transaction is generating goes into the certificate retirement fund so it goes right back to pay payments on the issue so it's paying interest on interest but this way at least now you automatically build a certain buffer into the certificate retirement fund I just wanted to ask your opinion on the agenda tonight there is the resolution to move funds general fund interest Revenue over from the general fund into the pi

097fund that I'm assuming we haven't had discussion on it yet to support the construction that's being discussed can I get your opinion on that I I I I'll give you my take on it from a credit rating standpoint okay uh that's all I would opine on as far as Moody's would be concerned anything taken out of the general fund to fund a pi is going to raise a red flag not for indiscrepancy or anything to that effect but they're going to be wondering why are you taking money out of the general fund so then we come back and say well we're going to be borrowing for a cops issue where are you going to be paying that from you're going to be paying that from permanent Improvement so when the eyes of Moody they call

098a cops issue a general fund borrowing because it doesn't when you pass if you say here tonight and you pass uh a resolution for instance that you're going to use the pi balance to pay that you are not be holding to that if the pi fund cannot make that payment you're going to have to dip into general fund so from the rating agency standpoint the general fund is the fund and if you are draining that to fund a pi which in is being used to pay debt service that's definitely going to they're going to really dig into that structure depending on you have excess Revenue coming in you're at the 20 mil floor and you've had a nice big Revel coming in 25 that's an offset to that situation you are going to be building

099revenues but in the eyes of moody right away they would never want anything to affect money continually coming out of the general fun how often did they regrade us or is it just when we asked them to re oh no the upgrade was on a surveillance so that was a biannual surveillance call uh Karen L not typical not typical at all uh but we campaigned for it and I kept the pressure on them in the off years and then when we went out in the one uh the the uh the last Bond initiative failed Moody likes that cuz it's it's so ironic you go and pay them for a rating because you're borrowing money and they'll turn around and say because you're borrowing money that hurts your credit rating it's kind of a catch 22

100but when they see a big bond issue go down they know okay you're not going to be spending or taxing people for that so they came back and said without the need immediately of going back out plus the main contributor to the upgrade was the accumulation of the carryover balances when I started working here with your predecessor the the balance sheet had dwindled it had it had its low points and uh that was one of the things I was just reading the rating upgrade report on my computer from Moody's and the one highlight in it is Gary's fiscal approach to accumulating what they call that rainy day fund which is around $22 million somewhere around there yeah right right so having a healthy balance our fiveyear forecast always helps us when when when they come

101back to we've got our ratings and the ratings always a better rating gets us the better opportunity to refinance and bring simple as that better rating means lower cost of funding um the uh the you the carryover balance is not the sole Criterium upon which they'll determine the rating they'll look at socioeconomic data throughout the district excuse me uh they'll look at growth rates in terms of property value job rates unemployment rates it's a myriad of different matrices through which they come up with this rating but without a doubt one of the heavier weighted positions of their analysis is going to be your revenues and your carryover bounds they want you to maintain in the dable a between 25 and 30% ratio and starting in 2017 you are at 15% that has grown all the

102way up to f scho 22 to 48% that's where the rating upgrade came from and they always have the ability to downgrade your rating oh absolutely oh absolutely so when they look at your finances of course they're looking for stable income right so when you look at the permanent uh continuous permanent Improvement Levy we received I was going to say this before about 2.7 is what the number showed last year I believe we have I mean this will be a couple years out into the future but we have a couple smaller developments that that are not rids or tips or anything like that so it'll probably grow to about 2.8 okay um but right now as a picture it's 2.7 and when you look at the number of years we would take a loan for

103and what the payment would be and what our normal operating expenses are year to Dear year to year as as our Treasurer said you know a million to a million and a half and and if we weren't uh disturbing those numbers or very much then then they would uh look at that as almost a guaranteed payback they'll never use the word guarantee I'll tell you that I know I know that okay but that is a stable bu that's about as strong as you can get now the main thing you Gary had made mention earlier though of the depleting of the pi balances that would def in conjunction if you were to deplete the pi balance and then pull money from the general fund to refund Pi I would tell you that will definitely they'll put

104you on negative and we're we're not looking at doing okay that is when I heard depletion of balances because I have another particular client who has accumulated a massive amount of carryover balance and now they're having a difficult time getting a renewal p a renewal because there's been some opposition and so rightly so it's a huge number however they have made it abundantly clear they're taking 30 million of that and putting it toward Capital the opposition wants them to take 50 million of it and the board just you cannot do that they would suffer dramatically from their rating standpoint uh that's the for Moody the general fund and its revenues are sacran you want you want them to be operating almost separately totally okay and I think that's pretty much how we're set up here

105right now and uh the The Continuous Pi off it's a big offers us that ability no continuing Pi is a big plus there's no doubt that's uh uh one of the things that they also commented on in the uh in the report when we when you get to the call Daye at that point is it the same process again to issue yes so it would look the same so let's say you get to the call date I show Gary a report since we had done the original issue now we're at the call they rates have come down significantly yes I would show Gary report that shows if we went out called that principle in rebored so that we could then pay it back uh at a lower rate and generates savings this would be the

106whole process over again and and that would be based on the current rating at that point it would be all based at that point in time so the rating still matters caring oh the rating is again is that's going to be the driver of affordability okay just like everyone in this room has a personal credit score uh investors rely very heavily upon what your underlying rating is uh that's what's going to determine your repayment levels we've done that a number of times already yes yeah and the call date is once you pass that date you can do it any time so like our bonds the build Parks side and riview called I think it was back in April but the market isn't isn't good enough for to refinance those things at this time but that's

107something that you know conditions change that would be looking at as well and definitely if I can uh recognize an opportunity for economies of scale with uh minimizing redundant third party expenses to go through multiple transactions we will do so if we can take a particular disclosure and make minimal modifications to do a refinancing we'll examine that if the time is right but if the market doesn't comply it just simply doesn't comply and when we do that it one saves the school district money or it'll in in our current bonds it saves our taxpayers money correct tax it's it's the depth of par review and we ref finance and it's lower that tax rate be adjusted lower accordingly okay and we've done that we've done a taxable refunding in 2019 that saved what it was

108a million or2 yeah those a significant number and what does it look like if um there is um aggressive free payment and um paid off early oh I mean moody loves that yeah well without a doubt so I just want to talk about that anytime you can take debt off the books just like any a bank or anything you you minimize your leverage you minimize your exposure the concept of doing a cops is routine I dare not say rudimentary nothing is anymore but it really again mimics the process of a normal traditional bond issue with just some slight variances that are for the most part focus on the legal side of things so I would just say that at any given time if the board does decide to move into this particular structure uh you

109want to give yourself some lead time so that we can get that survey going because if you turn around and say oh we're ready and we need that money somewhat quickly that survey could really slow things up is this we don't have solid number if we can say we can estimate and then we only borrow what we we need correct oh yeah absolutely yeah you there's no preset minimum maximum to this okay so um I would say that as the lower number gets what happens there though is costs become counterproductive so if you're down million or two which I is a lot of money please don't get me wrong but in the eyes of the market what happens there is there are minimum levels of threshold cost that are associated with the public sale of

110that it starts to look a skew so there we would probably examine doing something without a formal uh production of a disclosure what we call a private placement uh little more affordable because there are significant cost reductions specifically on the legal side um and that way that interest rate's a little higher but then it makes the cost Associated the ratio much more tolerable if if we were to use we have a number of projects that are looking at in different part of this plan if we were to use the money and take a larger sum to kind of spread out would then that land lease be on all of those projects you cat you exactly quick Lear no that's a really good question it's a really good observation because a lot of District say oh

111hey let's make the legislation nice and Broad we'll do this over here we'll do this over there that all becomes the asset as part of the lean so the only way the certificate holders can get that lean is through the land that's the way they're going to get the lean on the asset and again it's not just for the addition it's for the entire facility that so for the most part sometimes you can do these cops believe it or not if you needed a fun air conditioners HVAC and you think wow well how do you get what are investors going to do with that but it's the opposite side of that what are you going to do if investors say I'm taking over your HVAC equipment all they're going to do is come in and

112turn it off and not allow you to use it and by doing such they're not going to allow you into those buildings so it's kind of a what we call cross collateralization there but what we will have to contemplate I didn't I was trying to get around this before but if we do use Insurance during construction we may have to put a temporary land lean uh during construction on an asset but in seeing as these are expansions there Lori if I may use your first name that's where we'll bring in the rest of the asset under the land so now insurance will be happy how often is uh how often does something go bad to where there's actually an action oh I in 30 years of doing this I've never been associated with it believe

113it or not though the the main the main big news item when there was a non-appropriation on the cops and how pathetic it is that we have a daily periodical called the bond buyer is as boring as it gets but it's uh made headline news Twinsburg Township they did a cops to expand their uh administrative facilities and they walked away from it and uh that mean that sent ripples throughout the bond Community as well as the legal Community because now what's the remedy they will never be able to access normal borrowing rates ever I know you have to share all all the all sides of it but almost never no oh no oh no no very rare that I just bring that up because it it was in Ohio and that is one out of

114hundreds of thousands done nationally and that was actually the Port Authority that kind of screwed that transaction up but yeah no these are very basic uh complex behind the scenes but they're done repeatedly repeatedly they're they've become actually now especially you're going to see a lot of them with Nexus that's how districts leverage that incoming revenue and with these 20 mil floors there's going to be a good amount of additional Revenue coming into a lot of districts they can afford a general fund borrowing so one does it make sense to go private one does it make sense to go to the market mainly on size uh if we were again talking something uh where cost basement costs start to show big ratios to the size of the issue there's nothing wrong with that but to

115the to the eye it looks it it's the ratios are way off for for instance let's say we were to do a million dooll cops we did a a Public Finance on it we put a uh uh disclosure together that legal fee is going to be $100,000 whether it's a million or whether it's 30 million so when it's a million now $100,000 he's working for 10 bucks a bond so so let's say we're between 10 and 15 million oh that's definitely public offer okay no no question there no question no questions asked if you were to discuss private place I would talk you out of that that's where you have to get optimal public offering gets you the best borrowing rates and and also flexibility flexibility that is where private placement you definitely suffer there

116okay is this um The Debt Service is that um heavy on um the interest at the beginning like most yeah I have I put this together as uh level debt meaning each year your payment of interest is going to be very close to the previous and following year and then that will work like in inversely as you get further down the repayment of that issue you will start paying more principal than interest just like a home morg is okay but we can customize that debt service within legal parameters if there's a a bump you want or to minimize exposure in the early years uh remember we're probably going to have a big deposit in that certificate retirement fund through the excess original issue premium that'll take care of your probably your first two interest payments

117so again lot of options there well just to be clear you're paying interest on what you've borrowed in that particular year right yeah you're paying interest on interest you you can always adjust your payments right okay but if you go lower in the beginning you're going to have more interest payments the further down the line because you put any anything a dollar today is worth less than a dollar tomorrow so any principle you put out further gets diluted and that becomes more expensive yeah from the yield curve perspective right now though from a true interest rate perspective you have to look at it because the curve is essentially looking right now it's a straight line yeah they had gone from inverted because it used to be a roller coaster like that so it's starting to

118un invert but the last 48 hours movement shows that inflation's going to be here for a little while longer well when the government pumps money into the system it causes what it's um that's what happened and I just come at it from a truly a nonpartisan point of view but it is e time 101 you print money y it becomes cheap and prices go up any other questions thank you certainly I appreciate always a pleasure to see everyone thank you sorry if I pontificated a little bit but um I I really do enjoy this aspect of the job this is the part I really do enjoy especially because it's not snowing so Gary you're off the hook there it's about to start yeah so I'm getting the hell out of here excuse my friend do

119you need me for anything more Gary I we're good okay give me a buzz tomorrow anything you need again H happy Holidays happy New Year to everybody thank you do you need dry ey anymore good thank you thank you merry Christmas everybody nobody likes to stay for the meetings anything else Dr oh I'm sorry that concludes my reports for tonight thank you special reports yes I my own coming up thank you all right next on the agenda is discussion of old business nothing was submitted um that brings us to discussion of new business uh there was um the first thing that I just wanted to bring and I ask um Mr McIntyre to join us and just give us again another another overview of it is policy 01692 um and the reason why is I

120just had a couple of times where somebody's reached out to me and mentioned that um you know they've seen two board members working together walking through the schools together things like that and again I know that's not the majority that is a minority but again the sunshine laws in this area are a little gray so just to protect the board in the district I can you just talk through a little bit that policy yes you want a copy of it uh I have thank you very much so uh 016 9.2 is essentially a summary of a vast quantity of uh law that exists in Ohio relating specifically to the open meetings act and so as we've talked about in Prior trainings there's a definition of what a meeting is there's a definition of what open

121means there's a definition a lot of formality but let me just try to break it down into its Basics what the law is intended to do is make sure that public entities conduct their discussions out in the open that's it it's that simple we can talk about definitions we can talk about what's a meeting we can talk about what it means to be open those are all the details the primary purpose is that you as a public entity are conducting your discussions out in the open for the public to hear obviously there are exceptions to that the executive SE executive session exceptions that we've talked about many times and you're all familiar with but if it isn't covered by an executive session uh exception just always be as asking yourself always be saying to yourself

122This is a discussion we need to have in Open Session and so what does that mean so under our um um bylaw the 0169 point2 um which again is a reflection of Ohio law it says that um even a pre-arranged meeting attended by um a minority of the board could be a meeting that the sunshine laws would require to occur out in open and so what that means is that if two board members are discussing something and then a day later or a week later or even a month later one of those two board members in that original very isolated conversation has a a conversation with a third board member now in the eyes of the sunshine laws you have what's called a Serial meeting so it's an overall discussion of an item of public

123business that took place in pieces or parts first it took place between board member A and B on Wednesday and then it took place between board member B and C on Thursday and so you say to yourself what there was on only two board members there at any one time or in that text or in that email or or what have you the fact of the matter is the law looks at it as if you were all together and says you should have had that meeting and Open Session why I'll go back to how he started your discussions need to take place in Open Session yes you definitely gather information between board meetings that's crucial to what you do asard board members and I heard that earlier tonight and I agree with that a good

124board member is only good or only as good as the work that they do between board meetings and bringing themselves up to speed asking good questions collecting the information that are that will be relevant to the votes that you need to cast at an upcoming meeting just sort of learning kind of what it is you don't even know about an issue sometimes it's all new and you've got to start at the very beginning and you have to build your understanding all of that investigative all of that information gathering is 100% legal in fact the law wants you to do that and gives you the space to do that where it becomes a discussion though is the point at which it needs to take place in open session so when you stop just gathering information and

125you move into discussing deliberating weighing analyzing when you start doing those sorts of things as a group of two even um that's when the law says that needs to take place in Open Session that's what you're supposed to do out in open so that your community can hear so that your community can comment on it and criticize you or compliment you or vote the way they're going to vote at the next election that's what Ohio's Sunshine laws are all about and the reason they're called the Sunshine laws obviously is so that the Sun Shines on all of the discussions that you have because it's out in open and so um just be wary of the the conversations that take place between two board members where you're discussing board business because you as a board member

126may feel like that was an isolated conversation completely legal standing on its own but you can't control the person with whom you had that conversation and they may go on and have that same conversation with a third or fourth or fifth board member and you you as the initial participant may say well I didn't know they were going to do that well the law doesn't really care whether you knew or not it Just matters whether it happened or not and so just know that that's where the problems come into um situations that public bodies face all the time and again I I really I understand and and competely um endorse the concept of gathering information you know the idea that you say hey we're looking at a building project and I want to know AB

127BNC I want to know how it is we're going to pay for it I want to know how it is we're going to do this what's the schedule all of those are good and important things for you to gather information on but then once you have that information save the discussion part of the process for an open meeting or if it's an executive session obviously during an executive session and so you said earlier definitions are important right and so if you could if you know what the definition is uh according to the courts let's say where it says a series of pre-arranged meetings attended by a minority of the board to discuss public business without giving proper notice is a violation of the Sunshine Law so it says a series what is the definition according

128to the courts of a series so you know it's essentially more than one um and that's the I use the term serial um it's used synonymously with a series of meetings um the idea is that you know again if two board members are having a discussion and it's isolated and it's about board business there's nothing illegal about that I don't think that's preferred practice because I think the full board should be the beneficiary of that of hearing that discussion of participating in that uh discussion but standing alone that discussion is fine it's then when you add another discussion involving at least one other board member that wasn't participating in the first one that you have the series or a Serial meeting it doesn't have to be a situation where let's say I mean years and

129years ago you used to read about situations where a uh a superintendent would schedule a meeting and would meet with uh two of the board members on Wednesday and then maybe have a meeting with two other board members the next day and then maybe the fifth board Mee member uh day after that that's you don't have to go all the way through the full board to reach a problem those things used to happen they really don't anymore but as long as it becomes a majority of the board participating in a discussion even though it didn't occur at the same time even though it didn't occur using the same format so sometimes something will start on a text message or in an email thread and then carry over to an in-person or carry over into a

130phone call or something along those lines the law doesn't make any distinction about that the key is when it becomes more than two of you having had the same discussion that's when the law says it needs to have been a discussion that occurs in Open Session maybe a different a series on a definition so let's say two board members discuss the bottle of cocacola you have on the table there and they then discuss that three days later uh the same two board members how does that apply to series as long as it's the same two board members in an isolated discussion it's fine I will tell you though that there is Authority out there that says even just two more members constantly discussing this the same item of board business can be a discussion that

131the law views as having needing to occur at a board meeting for example you know the law recognizes the idea that your committees are required required to have open meetings even though there's only two of you on the committee the idea that two board members can be doing board business outside of a meeting um is um is one of those gray areas as you mentioned Lori that we all have to be careful of for me it's very much a an evidentiary analysis so I'm always looking at these situations as if I have to defend or explain something in a light that's Mo that I think is most favorable but that reflects the law um and so I want to be able to prove that discussions occurred in open S because if a resolution comes on

132to your agenda and we don't have in our minutes either at a committee meeting or at a board meeting you know the record of that having been discussed the implication is that it happened somewhere else and so now I'm dealing with this implication and I have to prove a negative I have to prove it didn't happen that way and it's very hard to do that it's just someone says you were at the BP station on Wednesday at 3:00 how do I prove that if I was just sitting in my office how do I prove I wasn't at that gas station at that time it's just it's a difficult evidentiary problem it's not impossible you know maybe I sent an email at that time but then you could send an email from your phone and you

133could have been at the BP station or or maybe I was in a meeting oh that person might not have a memory of that I don't know you know what I mean it just becomes a matter of evidence and so for me the best evidence that we have whenever there's any allegation or any concern even that the sunshine laws have been violated is that I can flip open to the minutes that Gary prepares and files and that you all approve and say look look there it is Page 17 of the meeting that happened on December 19th there's the discussion and that is a really important thing and there's one case out in in Ohio that deals with this exact issue it happened years ago but two board members had a discussion and then several months

134passed and then one of those two board members had the basically the same discussion with a third board member but in the interim what happened was they discussed it at the board table it was in the board minutes and the court looked very favorably at that situation and said look this board discussed this issue and the fact that there was this serial meeting even on its face was sort of um was was not looked at as a Sunshine Law violation because the court felt that the board discussed it it was in the M it was in the minutes and they had proof of that and so that that case for me has always been very um important in how I provide advice to public entities in particular school boards make sure that you are discussing

135these things at a public any any item of board business that's coming before this board that you're voting on that you're um you know you're considering a specific program a specific action whatever it might be having those discussions at the board table are are critical for for the district's position in any situation that involves um the sunshine laws you mentioned voting so another scenario let's say someone puts on some social media uh their how they're going to vote on a particular issue in a meeting that's going to be in a day or two and all the other board members can see that how do you view that I you know the we've I mean I've presented to this board and many boards on a public officials use of social media and it it keeps me

136up at night it makes me very nervous it's a and it's an evolving area of the law there was a very big decision recently this year and I think we talked about it in one of our prior trainings where for the first time the court actually recognize that a public official can say uh on their social media uh page or account this is you know these are my personal views this is my own page this is not reflect the um anyone else's opinion but my own personal opinion the courts finally recognized that disclaimer um as essentially a presumption that that's a personal page that said that presumption can be overcome if you're talking about official business and so it makes me very nervous about that signaling in advance how you're going to vote by one

137board member you know in and of itself isn't a problem I would say however though that if it Spurs conversation among the other board members then it could start a chain effect that could easily lead to a Sunshine Law violation because again you know like that board member who had isolated conversation who can't control where that conversation goes does it go to a third or fourth or fifth board member the same thing is true of a social media post you can't control how the rest of the board might react and that could be a problem so if it's a public page and not a personal page would that change anything um because the board really good could communicate with each other uh on social media then and not break the Sunshine Law if the court

138recognizes oh that you can speak openly on on public Pages yeah so I didn't mean to give that impression if I did I apologize so the fact that if you have that disclaimer that says these are my own personal views um the presumption now under existing law is that that's a personal page that presumption can be overcome though if you're talking about your official business and so then the court would say yeah we start with the presumption that it's a personal page but but in this particular case let's say it now becomes that presumption is overcome because the person was talking about their official business and then the court would no longer look at it as a personal page that disclaimer would not have any legal effect at that point um so again you know

139an individual board member who who you know like signals how they're going to vote on something um in and of itself isn't violating any laws but again how do the rest of you react to it if the reaction is board member B then calls board member C and they talk about it and then board member D gets involved then the the whole thing is unraveling you you are in a process of I'm not saying it's happened if it's happen or if it would happen the whole process is basically something that should be taking place at a public meeting so any other questions for Mr um I would just say that uh recently we're um uh videotaping the um or filming the um committee meetings and so there's two people as you said on a committee

140um other board members might watch that and have discussions about what happened in that meeting but they weren't there so I just want clarification on that sure so it it's the same basic principle so two board members members having one isolated conversation in almost every single case that I can imagine or that I've ever seen that's not a problem but what happens when that becomes a a third board member gets involved or two other board members maybe one that was at the committee and one that uh wasn't in the committee but that wasn't in that initial isolated conversation they start having a conversation on their own that now you have all of these discussions taking place that the law says it needs to take place in an open session that's why I started with the

141idea of the law says if you are discussing board business as a public official the the strong strong presumption is that all of those discussions need to take place at the board table at a properly noticed meeting um the law just isn't really set up to to always give the clearest answers you know it's just you have all this case law if you go to the we talked about the the Sunshine Law book it's uh uh referred to as the yellow book because it has a yellow cover on it um but it's 145 pages long and I think it's in Sixpoint font it's incredibly dense single space no paragraphs no margins I mean it goes to the edge of the page I mean it is and they update it all the time I mean I

142think there are something like there over 2,000 footnotes in this document so I'm blowing down this huge mass of decisions made over a over a hundred-year period by literally dozens and dozens of Courts at different levels all over the state of Ohio and so it's you know there there are certainly um you know some differences of opinion out there for sure among even our courts and that's why things go to the Ohio Supreme Court because they are the final word on what Ohio law means and and you know there was a lot of uh misunderstanding about email messages for a long time um a lot of courts looked at email messages and viewed them very much like a transient record like a phone slip um you know somebody calls and leaves a leaves a message

143is that a is that a record you know is it doesn't really document anything other than somebody called the superintendent let's say it's not we didn't create it I mean yes somebody made it but it's not really a record in the same way that Gary's reports are or that employment contracts are and so that was a source of a lot of debate all over the state of Ohio for many years and then the Ohio Supreme Court stepped in and said yes email our public records and so the same thing goes for the open meetings act you know I'm taking this huge quantity of information distilling it down to the basics but the law all the presumptions all of the uh the policies that underly the open meetings act are all all directly and very carefully

144aimed at having these discussions um take place at the table that you're sitting at out in front of all these people um and so that um you can have the benefit of each other's viewpoints you could try to you know talk somebody out of their point of view um the the public can hear you do that and either applaud you which some people will and boo you as some people will and all of that is the way our Democratic process is set up that it's supposed to take place all out in the open and so just I guess as you work through the where that line is again between information gathering and discussion just always air on the side of discussing the matters out and open had a meeting okay so prior to a boarding

145when I'm hearing just clarification if you're citing specific agenda items and how you're going to vote and it's on social media and other board members either see it inadvertently or someone sends it to a board member that's really kind of risky or not good boardsmy um how you operate as a board your matters of self-governance are your matters um and they may not be legal matters so I have to stick to to my Lane which is to you know provide legal advice and to give you hopefully the benefit of um good legal analysis um so so whether that should happen or not should happen on for all those other reasons that have nothing to with the laws that those are that's for you all to decide but from a legal standpoint um in and of

146itself it's not a violation as I've mentioned but could it begin a process that leads to problems that are legal in nature in terms of violating the open meetings act absolutely quick question sure if I go out and gather information what am I allowed to do with that information so I mean I think that's a great question um I think all of the board members should have the benefit of the all the information that each of you has so it's not uncommon for a board member to send an email you know to our supertenna and to our treasure and say hey I have these questions not deliberative questions not about whether we should do something um or even how we should do something but the data that you need to have those discussions I think

147that email should be sent with a copy to the rest of you again not so you can start a discussion either individually or by email or text or in person or anything like that but to know that one of you has made this really incredible request for information and then I think the response should come from our superintendent or our treasure should go to all of you now that said we if if we're going to do that we have to be very disciplined about receiving that it's human nature to say oh my gosh I really got this really key and very important piece of information and I want to talk with that a fellow board member about that that that's the Human Condition um but you can't you got to hold you just hold until

148you're at this table um and you have the chance to talk about it so what do I think ought to happen if you get good information you should share it with your fellow board members FYI um you could say you know we'll discuss this or I'd like to discuss this or uh I've asked our superintendent to put this on the agenda for a discussion that gives everybody a nice little reminder that this isn't the time when this email comes in it's later when we're at a board meeting um it's not uncommon for our superintendent or Treasurer to put together reports that might be shared with you I I don't know the ins and outs of how you guys do that necessarily every District's a little bit different but a lot of central office administrators are

149pushing information through the superintendent or through the treasur to the board members so that you have all of that and I think you all ought to have the benefit of that information so that when you're at the table you don't have that unfortunate situation of somebody saying well I didn't know that and now I'm hearing it for the first time and I have to react to it in real time and I may not be ready for it I may have my own questions that just slows down the process the the the process works most efficiently and sometimes very rapidly when you collect all the information you get it into all the board members hands you give the board members a chance to discuss it deliberate ask whatever additional questions they have and then you call

150for a vote let's let's find out how you feel about something but once that information is collected um if it just sits in one board member's hands or two board members hands it's not as good to the organization as if it were in all five board members hands sometimes when have discussions with Consultants you know you're really not coming up with any kind of conclusion but you have information that is just pieces parts of a whole that hasn't been put together by you yet so how do you handle those pieces parts so with with Consultants it's a little um I mean this is you know some of this is a matter of how you want to do business you know it's not a purely legal issue um and some of it is a legal issue

151so I I would say that um I I often look at my own situation so I technically I'm a consultant um to the district um you know sort of a you know legal consultant uh hopefully to the district and so um I always prefer that if if I have to give advice like this that I have the chance to give give it to all of you at the same time that makes me feel better knowing that you all can hear challenge question get clarification what I'm saying what I get worried about is if I say something to a board member and then maybe I wasn't as clear as I should have been maybe I thought I was 100% clear but it just didn't land the way I wanted it or maybe was just a general

152like complete disconnection on both sides of that communication and then it's we're off track yeah the benefit of that advice of going to that person like me is lost because in that process of receiving the information it didn't go as well as it should and so I think when you're dealing with Consultants by and large you invite them to a board meeting you allow them to make a presentation you um you can certainly give them a bunch of questions you expect them to be able to answer or include in their presentation um if they're going to do a report you have the right to ask for that report in advance so you have that so that you can come to the board meeting ready to go and ready to um um you know ask whatever

153questions you have or um interact with that consultant and the the fact that the other board members get to benefit from that maybe they think that's wonderful those are really good questions maybe they don't maybe they think those questions are off base and they get to ask their own questions and that's okay too that's what this process is all about it's a deliberative process you know I I I think you know the one of the best analogies for for a good board discussion is a uh you know like this the movie version of what happens in a a a jury room after they get the case and they have to go in that room and deliberate the guilt or innocence of a defendant in a case often times it starts out in one way and

154by the time that discussion ends it's going in a completely different Direction that's what your meeting should be comprised of um not necessarily changing courses like that but just robust you know vigorous uh debate about the merits of whether to do something or not do something about whether to spend money on this item or that item or no money at all um that that's what um you know that that's what um your Consultants can help you do and so doing that out in open um is going to be a I think a better process a process that's more aligned with the law and is going to allow you to function more successfully as a board um you know the strength of a board is in its unanimity that's where the power from this board table

155emanates and um and so the more times you can reach that the more effective and the more powerful your decision- making will be that's just part of also part of the human condition you know when there are you know when there is a divisiveness when there are you know three board members feeling one way and two board members feeling another way um that gives people an opportunity to pick sides but when you're all unanimous there's only one side and that's the boards and that's that's the gold standard that's what we want to always shoot for that's not always possible we we live in an environment and a democratic process um or we have a democratic process that allows for um a majority rule and that's good too um and that can be effective as long

156as you're having that discussion um you know we had lots of discussions here in the district um at a time when whether to mask or not mask was the big question and and it was very difficult and the community was very invested I mean I know that I attended one meeting there was I don't know I mean 400 people in the was it the auditorium maybe more um and as I recall the board was split on that but the board decided it and that was that and it worked but it was a very very long and difficult discussion um but it was a discussion that happened out and open and people presented their own views and tried to talk people out of their views and and ultimately they got to that answer but the key

157for that process was the idea that it was discussed people were given you know were called upon to give advice like Consultants um that was done as a part of the Open Session and and everybody on the board benefited from that and even those in the community who didn't agree with the final outcome ultimately we're able they were able to see that process taking place and and and and that that's the Hallmark that we're shooting for is this seeing that process let me ask you a question about developing a product let's say a product is being developed let's say a report and that report wherever it's going to be delivered is being developed and and you have a board member that is gathering information from the other four board members is that permitted and then

158that board member puts forth that report so um it's a there there are a lot of variables there so if the board has decided something you know they've discussed it at the table or if it's an executive session discussion and then you've decided to delegate the authority of compiling to one of you that that can be a perfectly legal process to take place outside of a board meeting um if there hasn't been a discussion already if there hasn't been an explicit delegation of authority to a single board member then it could be viewed very much as trying to subvert the sunshine laws by trying to have a bunch of oneoff meetings kind of like a hub of a wheel and spokes if you're trying to use one board member to then have these four oneoff

159conversations about board business that could very much be a problem I think that's I mean in order to give you a sort of a legal opinion on whether that's legal or not I think I'd have to know more information about it um but um the idea of gathering information from board members is a lot more challenging than getting information from your Consultants from your superintendent from your treasur um you know the law the whole structure of school boards in Ohio is set up so that your fundamental job is only to see to it that this District runs well but not to run the district and you have a superintendent and treasur that are legally and contractually obligated to do that and you just want to make sure that they're doing it according to your goals

160according to the parameters that you've established um for this District the direction that you've established for this District um and and so I I get very nervous about the idea that board members are sort of gathering information among themselves outside of a meeting other questions thank you very much um another piece of new business I did not send what we have to do um is picking a date for our um tax budget hearing in our organizational meeting and so that is in the consent agenda for buildings and grounds and operations item a and I thought we'd do it now get that in there so that way when we come to voting it's already done and it has to be done before the 15th 15th of January yes can we do it on a Thursday evening

161just like we do today um I am going to to be out of the state the 9th to the 13th okay so before the 9th Mr official did I you go out of town I'm flexible oh you're not going out I thought you go out of town I'm out on the 11 okay so we have to before the 9 in whatever time you want to choose I'll make myself available Mr Keeny any obstacles in that time frame no uh Tuesday night isn't the best for me but Monday or Wednesday is good did I say Tuesday I'm sorry um is is morning okay for everyone yeah good morning okay let me just put my work which days let me yeah I got to get my work sorry we wanted to do a morning I can I

162can try to see if I can get a morning to work depending on my um I I have Tuesday the 7th I could do I have Wednesday the 88th and Thursday the 9th if you guys anybody else can that's I fly out from oh the ninth sorry the eighth is fine eth eth is fine for me eth eight seven 7 o' no can we do 7:30 I have to drop a kid off okay 7:30 7:30 for me as well getting my kid here at 7 is a challenge yeah I I agree I barely get them out of bed some days it's Wednesday the 8th at 7:30 a.m. yep and then the so the tax budget hearing at 7:30 a.m. on the 8th organizational meeting Mr PLO usually we do 15 minutes 745 so but yeah

163it's probably 7:45 okay because we have to start exactly at those times so you'll send a meeting invite yes right so that's been filled in on the consent agenda for buildings and grounds and operations when we come to it okay um I know Mr Kenny has not been to this type of meeting so basically um last year you sent out something but I don't know how your this is going to take place this year uh I just sent out what committees you guys were interested in is the only thing I sent out so I would just come with those proposals to the table and because that's where we signed committee members committee chair and then the Committee Member so who who's doing the assignment then whoever becomes the president oh okay so the election is

164first and then okay or appointment okay all right so I got the date right thank you um yep the last thing we need to discuss um I did share with the entire board um and I should say um Mr McIntyre had shared with the entire board um the document that we received from the auditor's office um and in talking to Mr McIntyre one of the things I wanted him here for was just to make sure like what action the Board needs to take if any um I don't I'm putting on the spot again Mr M can you share like kind of the discussion that we had um and why we wanted to bring it to the table yeah so you know I I guess my thought is um you know in these situations it's important

165to think about what we need to do to um you know make sure that the district is in the best possible situation um making sure that we understand where all the um guide posts are for any kind of um you know um compliance or legal issue and so um there are a lot of resources out there available to the district to do that so um I think I'm one of those resources and I really appreciated the opportunity to talk to uh talk a little bit tonight about the open meetings act um you know these are complicated issues and um no one I I think no one was ever hurt by additional training and and um you know in service I think those are good things um but you could certainly go um Beyond me and

166you could certainly bring in somebody else that you might want to use to help you understand um you know difficult compliance issues you could certainly bring in somebody that can take a look at the whole situation sort of audit it if you will um share that information with you and discuss it and learn from it um and and again position the district and this board in the best possible way um legally and uh compliantly so I mean those are two of the ideas that I had um that I've seen other boards use and um s similar situations you know bring in some sort of uh you know consultant that can audit and advise um a Andor additional training or we do nothing at this time and allow the state to audit them audit and present

167their findings that's correct so the state's going to take a look at everything and offer their opinion we think we're not 100% sure it's a very um ambiguous situation um it's not it's not at all clear to me um where we are I did ask for some followup and I shared that with you um but even the followup was not in at least in my opinion 100% clear um but this the state audit might you know um offer some compliance observations um and it you know it ranges what that means it could be anything Gary knows it could range from anything from a simple note all the way through um a finding which is a formal um determination by the auditor's office so I wanted to bring it to the board table share that again

168the information that Mr McIntyre presented to me and then asked the ward again he presented three things additional training as mentioned is always good we had some tonight um we can decide that we want to perform our own audit and look for somebody to do that for us um or again we can do nothing and allow the state to do their audit and present their findings thoughts opinions questions I I don't know it's an interesting situation so it would be interesting to see what the auditor is going to I don't know how they're going to pursue that so thatd be a proponent of using our own attorney since I think he Mr McIntyre how many years have you been doing school board attorney work 33 so I would suggest your 33 years of experience probably

169means that he's as well qualified as anybody including an outside consultant so I think I'd be a proponent of adding another hour of whatever Mr McIntyre believes he would want to present it as far as training show the board is acting and um being diligent in in seeking uh a path that is satisfactory would that be a good way of it i' happily do that tell me when I'll be here that's that's not going to negate the auditor's response no no the is going to do what they're going to do and um but but you know um looking at situations learning from them continuing to grow our understanding of of very complicated legal issues is I don't think a a waste of anyone's time anyone against additional training all right I would suggest after we

170set our board meetings in January that we figure out that work session would that be okay Mr McIntyre of course I don't think any of us over the next two weeks are gonna be in for uh training understood um I just want to ask again the state's going to do what they are going to do is there any desire um for us as a district to do our own audit or to hire somebody to do an audit again that comes out a cost to the district so I just want to make sure that everybody considers that I would just let the state do their thing okay yeah any disagreement with that I would all right so we'll work on setting up some training and we'll wait to see what the state um presents back to

171us thank you again all right that brings us to our Board of Education Committee in liaison report um superintendent business advisory leison took a vacation um in well I didn't take a vacation but the committee took a vacation working in small groups well the small group work presented some good stuff out in the small groups and kind of had some checkups along more oh have you had some um I know that the doc loor group has I've sent my group members um some kind of guidelines along what the rubric is for the portrait side Beaver um along with an AI podcast that goes with it it's really cool about 10 10 to 11 minutes so so when we come back or the business right January next meeting will be in February February okay there'll be

172more of an update then there'll be more of a yeah we will have a robust meeting at that point kind of share with share out great thank you that brings us the curriculum and programming committee and Facilities leison okay uh we did not have a meeting this month although Dr malakar uh did attend um the uh finance and Personnel meeting and she just shared with me a request that I had made about um knowing more about the history of the third grade fall reading test and so she was able to share um scores uh not only from uh that we just received um but um we also got scores from Fall of 23 and fall of 22 and what it looked like at the end of the year so this is the uh State Testing

173uh that Ohio does at at third grade in reading and it kind of gives an idea of what where the students are right now and then the building uh principals meet in their grade level teams and they go over the data for each student which the Buzzard days or whatever our snow days kind of set that back a little bit but um they are going to have um discussions about how to proceed uh in helping students going forward they will continue to do measurements with map testing which are measures of academic progress and uh they will continue to do everything they can to bring our students um uh or get our students ready for the spring testing by the state okay and then um I know on the facilities leis on I know Dr uh

174rotino has his report tonight I may chime in with some comments um later on that but I'll let you handle that yeah there's um there's the finals been shared it's linked in the agenda and all that it's up for vote time So yeah thank you all for feedback and thank you to the committee publicly so are we having any further discussion on it there's discussion when it's up on the um on the agenda on the agenda right that's what I meant okay all right that brings us to buildings and grounds op operations committee and the Alumni Association liaison Mr offishal December is usually a pretty light month for the Alumni Association so buildings and grounds so Mr Arles shared that he wanted to emphasize the job well done by the maintenance crew for the snow

175removal uh when we had the big snow and um he also shared that um uh he wanted to thank Northshore for staying uh uh in touch with him and and getting getting everything done as needed to be done and uh if anyone is aware of snow removal sometimes you're using big equipment to move snow around just so you can maneuver into the parking lots um the maintenance guys also came in on Sunday and uh went Above and Beyond in in removing that snow the lamouth gym floor it is new but we're having a few issues and uh there's some buckling going on and so Cincinnati floors has been contacted uh by Mr aric to come out and take a look at that and that is scheduled more information to follow after that happens and and

176he said there's plenty going on over the winter break uh he said there will be inspections to the campus Buckeye melridge and lamouth and update what's called an ah report on hazardous materials in the schools and U so that'll be happening that's a state requirement um and there's a renewal every 3 years uh the Lake County Health Department will be conducting their by annual inspections of the schools uh the intrusion alarms for buck uh for the campus Buckeye melridge and louth um and the bus garage we'll be getting new motherboards installed by Southeast security this is a system upgrade and refresher for us on access control um just make everything a little bit more efficient and effective uh there was uh a Cleveland Vicon quote the louth teachers requested better safety uh after the event

177over riverv viiew for 29 doors that did not have the ability to be locked from the inside and retain the What's called the parac cord rope in the event of a lockdown uh so they're asking for approval uh Mr Arles asking for approval to proceed uh with the quote uh $4,140 and this will just uh allow them to lock everything down uh the same through the whole building and it'll be a little bit safer uh discussion by the buildings and grounds to have ccg come to the next meeting and make brief presentation to the committee on the possibility to convert Riverview in Parks side from Gardener controls to ccg ccg is a company and um there have been some issues working with gardeners so the district is looking at the possibility of making a change

178uh so that there can be a better uh and less cumbersome relationship um so Mr aresc is is is looking forward to that um the there was a quick update on the CTE building which we had tonight in the Riverview Edition which we had tonight um there was a ranking of the uh cmrs the construction companies for for the Riverview uh project and U there were two renderings by TDA is is what we're shown tonight a couple options for the Buckeye addition and that's the buildings and grounds report thank you and that brings us to policy committee and legislative Lea on Mrs Rey sure so we have on our agenda this evening the adoption of the large package of policies that we have now had on as a second read we also have a first

179reading of a new policy 2265 that has to do with protections of IND individual beliefs affiliations ideals or principles of political movements and ideology ology um I would suggest we have that on there for our first read so we'll have that on as a second read at our next meeting we also have on our agenda the Board of Education handbook revision which if I'm not mistaken Dr rotino you did not receive any I did receive um one which I made some adjustments to the grade levels of some of the buildings were incorrect so I wouldn't corrected them I believe Mel and Buckey R say prek 5 and I changed it to prek4 they accurately with there this year okay other than that um I don't have any I don't have anything else to report thank

180you brings us back around to Dr Tino and the superintendent report yeah um December is a busy month around the the district a lot of exciting things that happen uh kicking off actually going back to November the day before uh we went on Thanksgiving break with our first uh District W or second and I can say second annual Nick's not even here I took a step out second annual districtwide community kindness day uh where we had all of the schools on a prescribed day kind of go out and do different things for uh the community whether it was um uh making blankets at Parkside they made blankets for the lonus project um they did different things with um to end uh 68 hours of hunger uh they did drives they did food drives they did

181uh reached out into the general Community as well um louth students actually went to a uh Assisted Living residence and sang for the residents there it was especially personal to me cuz that's a where my dad is actually right now currently so I got to go visit dad during the day as well as see our students uh sing and they and it was great so and all the residents they really got a kick out of it so it was a nice thing to see so that was um our second annual community kindness day in a tradition that we hope to continue um Halls of Holly kind of just give a little bit brief update on that uh more than 170 campus students help coordinate h of H it's one of those things that we do

182that just makes this District special uh similar to the um Fall Fest or Boo Fest that the national our side puts on Halls of Hol put on by our student council as well as our senior leadership group um it was attended by hundreds of community members really kind of a neat special thing to get everyone in the community in the uh holiday spirit um and they had a great attendance there as as well um another thing to be proud of we are again earning the PBS uh PBIS Bronze award at the Riverside campus uh that's an award that recognizes the structures put in place for positive behavior intervention supports this is the second year that they've uh won that award I believe um the campus as well as all of our schools in the district

183develop these PBS initiatives uh to promote positive school appropriate behavior to continue to improve the safety climate and wellness of all our students across the district so it's something to be proud of and something that's out and I believe as that uh that's a committee that comes out of our district leadership team that committee continues to drive um they are we were setting up structures to earn even higher levels of that through that uh not only the Mt ass process which P asses one underneath that but through that subcommittee in there so um more great news and more to come uh winter sports season has started in fact some I think our Middle School basketball is close to ending they might have a tournament after after the break but some of them start really early

184and some haven't even kicked like the girls middle school basketball hasn't kicked off yet but uh just to bring attention both basketball boys and girls wrestling um the board of members they approved girls wrestling for the first time so they're they're own Sport and and going um going crazy swimming and Diving is is off in their thing gymnastics is finally a district approv Sport and they're they're kicking butt we're really happy for them and cheerleading are all in um some sort of form couple of pictures up there to point out our girls basketball team got and boys actually both got to play at the the quick and Loans now is that what they're calling the rocket mortgage rocket mortgage whatever the new Fieldhouse name is um they were down there on the CF FLIR uh

185floorida got to play there the rumble was I believe it was last weekend last weekend last weekend huge um well attended uh it was packed in there that the Jim got hop but really a neat um environment and then I did get some of the basketball on the new floor as well as the gymnastics team um which is actually now not a club sport but a real sport at Riverside so all excited all great stuff going on um you know for winter sports uh the craft show uh also occurred the same day as the second day of the that was last week uh NHS hosted their annual Holiday Market Craft Show featuring more than 40 local vendors a lot of people stopped by to pick up on some Christmas gifts I was one of them

186um so I got some things for the family that are excited to pass around uh really kind of a neat event that was organized went real uh went throughout the day till like 2 o'cl kids were there did a really nice job putting it on local vendors seemed really happy to be there a lot of cool specific uh Riverside spirit Spirit we and interesting things there as well and finally a official save the date we're uh Riverside is 75 years old um 75 years old from when it's open not from when the first class graduated but when the doors first open we are going to celebrate that 75e celebration on Saturday March 15th from 8 to 11: uh alumni and Community are encouraged to attend tour the building see the difference old artifacts we're going

187to have a pancake breakfast in the morning and I believe the the theater crew has decided to put a MAA show of SpongeBob on so I know there's some talk about having and a Mata that Saturday as well a SpongeBob is a spring musical but I know they're doing it at night I think they're doing a MAA one um as well kind of capture some of that crowd and get some walk up tickets so exciting times for Riverside is the building 75y old and um I think we may even have some some preliminary work on the on the expansion as well at that time so it be kind of neat to see or at least we'll have some drawings that we can put out of hey this is Riverside moving forward so and you can

188dress up in the pancake costume that we got for Mr Dr Kaya we could or I was going to flip pancakes I would prefer to do that I'm more of a behind the scenes flipper but the panc but I I think the pancake costume we can we can loan that out so that concludes my report for the evening thank you um that brings us to Treasures report and committee updates for on finance audit and Personnel committee and the booster organization liaison Mr Keeny yeah we uh had our meeting on December 12th uh typical Personnel updates um turnover and uh this is uh seasonally typically a slow period but there are still a lot of postings uh reimbursements are uh continuing to be made for the science of reading training as well as the military recruit

189award payments um discussion has been made regarding presentation of resolutions uh accepting the tax amounts and rates plus additional purchase of legal fees Beyond typical retainer Services uh which you'll see on the agenda tonight um they talked about the ESC service contracts um regarding modifications to the ESC of the Western Reserve regarding State subsidy credits and uh moving forward with the ESC of Northern Ohio regarding Services through the uh passport school program uh fiveyear forecast update forecast members were presented and an updated forecast will presented will be presented at the next board meeting uh the pi funding options um different scenarios uh utilizing different instruments maturity dates were reviewed uh these and other scenarios will continue to be investigated and discussed with the board and that's the end of my report thank you and the

190update from the treasurer Mr PLO all right um tonight we'll go through our monthly Financial reports as usual um so for November 2024 as always board the reports are available in board and on the treasurer page our total cash balance of all our funds end November was 38.3 million the general fund is at currently at 24.3 million and then the permanent Improvement fund is currently at 7.4 million of which 1.3 million is encumbered for certain projects and for outstanding purchase orders with the current unencumbered cash balance of about 6.1 million that's available for use our current appropriations of Revenue estimates were 41.6 6 7% through the fiscal year revenue is currently at 45% that's because we get the larger property tax settlement so we're still trending ahead but that will level out and then expenditures

191are trending lower currently at 39.7% but those will continue to increase uh as time goes on on the next slide here uh for general fund November Revenue was only 966 th000 for this month uh which includes 644,000 unrestricted State Foundation payments and $59,000 in uh restricted state revenue which is basically our science of reading typen reimbursements we reive this month our interest revenue for November was 73,000 our current star Ohio interest rate is 4.79 with the current rate cut that will start to decrease and then the red tree investment accounts yielding 3.83% for an overall yield of 4.36 uh expenditures for November are about $4.5 million that's pretty much all I had the report thank you that brings us to public comment anyone wishing to address the Board of Education will be recognized by the

192board president speakers are requested to speak from the podium identify themselves and their topics comments are limited to three minutes is there any public comment tonight yes sir you know it's pretty self-evident that Mr fishell wants to run a three-person board here and he wants to circumvent everyone else and impose his will on what's going on here I can tell by the questions he's asking Mr McIntyre he's trying to find a way slick way to do that without getting himself into trouble and Denise and Dennis you two are being led by a guy who doesn't have any more than a high school education and after 45 years are a tin man roofing company has managed to earing himself an F from the Better Business Bureau this man's going to lead you into a courtroom possibly

193into a prison cell the other problem that you have is that you're now flirting with the idea of encumbering the school district's real estate in a manner that you're going to lose control of the school if you're M if you're able to meet these Financial Obligations you win but I guarantee you that guy that came down and gave the presentation he understands the complexity of these Financial Obligations in a way that none of you will okay Mr plco and Miss grassy are the only two people with any Financial education here and I and I'm sure that they have trouble understanding what they're getting into okay you need to listen very carefully to what that man said he said they can turn off your HVAC and deny you access to the building okay if you default

194and and believe me these people make their living creating these obligations he can tell you it's never happened before until it happens here okay and when that day comes you will have no options they will dictate to you and they will know before they bring you the contracts to sign whether you're going to succeed or fail you aren't going to know that until later you guys are engaging in areas where you just don't have you don't you don't know what you don't know and that's very unfortunate and this man wants to control everything and if you two go along with everything that he wants to do we're going to have a disaster here and in the end of the day when you're voted off this school board it'll be the people of this district and

195the students who suffer for decades if not Generations be very careful what you do here because by going down this road and spending money that the school district doesn't have and without the approval of the voters who will never pass a school levy again probably if you do this okay you paint yourself into a corner that you can't get out of and you do that not just for this board but for every board that succeeds you going down the road thank you thank you any additional public comment all right that brings us to our consent agenda for finance and audit yeah I'd like to uh entertain a motion to approve the items listed a to G on the finance uh audit consent agena as recommended by the treasurer do I have a second I second

196any discussion I'd like to thank the following for their donations um we have $250 from the Riverside Alumni Association to decide leadership day of caring project we have $100 from an anonymous donor to the Riverside veterans memorial fund and $500 from Susan Bloss to the Henry Alam scholarship fund so I'd like to thank them for their donations any other discussion hearing none very please take the role Dennis Keeny hi Lori kisy hi Linda grassy hi Denise Brewster hi Scott Fishel hi motion carried okay we have an additional uh item here uh under donation uh this is a resolution to accept uh the following donation uh a $300 donation from Denise Brewster to the Riverside drama club uh do I have a second I'll second any discussion other than thank you very much thank you and

197I think this is a four-person vote no corre show St yeah I um I made the donation in honor my granddaughter's experience erience um in the drama program and knowing every time I go to a play I'm reminded of how much the students benefit from that experience and anyway I could help so made a donation G take the rooll Lorie pisy I Belinda grassy hi Denise Brewster abstain Scott fishell hi Dennis ke hi motion carried right that brings us to our consent agenda for personnel uh I'd like to uh make a motion to approve the items uh listed on uh items a to H listed on the Personnel con consent agenda as recommended by the superintendent have have a second no second any discussion I really don't want approve it a well to be honest

198I didn't want to recommend it um but unfortunately uh uh Mr schlick the assistant superintendent who's been here for 25 years has decided enough's enough and he's going to retire at the end of the year uh he's served in a number of different roles throughout the district including assistant principal at the campus the campus principal melridge principal and then uh in central office he's been a mentor to myself as well as countless other administrators and uh will def be missed um but there only a phone call away um so we we'll be bugging him while he's there and we wish him nothing but the best of luck in future and congratulate him um on his retirement as he's heard already this is the last whatever so this is the last assm board meeting um that

199you have to be at and so Chuck yeah we'll continue to go with that so thank you thank you Chu thank you thank you any other discussion Okay g pleas take the role grassie I Denise Brewster I Scott Fel hi Dennis Keeny hi Lorie kiss I motion carried congratulations um that brings us to the consent agenda for buildings and grounds and operations and just to note um in in the uh first item we've already set the meeting time so that has been filled in yes correct that's correct okay and so I make a motion to approve the items listed on the buildings and grounds operations consent agenda as recommended by the superintendent items a through C can I get a second a second thank you any discussion can you call the roll Denise Brewster hi

200Scott fishell hi Dennis Keeny hi Lor kisy hi Linda gr I motion carried uh there's a construction manager at risk uh firm ranking item it's a resolution ranking the three firms that responded to the Riverside local school district's request for statements of qualification for construction manager at risk firms forther review uh Riverview Elementary School expansion and Improvement project um and so formerly uh there was okay is there a second can I get a second second okay thank you uh and we need to identify the ranking correct correct okay so number one was Cleveland Construction Cleveland construction was number one um CT Taylor was number two and uh Green Space construction was number three um in board docs there was a more formal document that had that listing in there that's publicly available okay and so

201uh that is is the ranking is there any discussion on that and um so approving that ranking can you call a rooll Scot visell hi Dennis Keeny hi Lori kisy hi Belinda grassy hi Denise Brewster hi motion carried next we have a construction manager at risk contract of the Riverview expansion um and this will be the Riverside local school district Board of Education hereby approves the attached agreement between Cleveland Construction Inc and the Riverside Local School District Board of Education for Cleveland Construction Inc to serve as the construction manager at risk for the Riverview Elementary School expansion and Improvement project and also hereby authorizes the board president and Treasurer CFO to sign this agreement on behalf of the Board of Education can I get a second I'll second is there any discussion G can you

202call the rooll Dennis Keeny hi Lori kisy hi Linda grassy n Denise Brewster I Scott fishell I motion carried then we have um a Riverside facilities plan um approval and this is um the facilities plan by the superintendent is that correct it's yeah it's yes just have to read resolution yeah okay so sorry okay thank you um resolution to approve the 2025 to 2030 and Beyond Riverside local school district 5year facilities plan can I get a second second okay and I think um is there any discussion um I just want to I just notwithstanding all the work that Dr ratino put into the creation of that plan I I would like to just go on and publicly acknowledge that I realize he did a lot of work the community put a lot of work and

203effort into um that plan and we did surveys we did a lot of things I don't believe that the facility plan that is out reflects adequately what the public wanted and I believe the facility plan was then derailed um by the fact that we voted as a board 3 to2 to add on to Riverview prior to the facility plan um being able to be presented to the board of education and the public I don't think the I don't I don't think that was the appropriate way to do things I think we move decisions and board votes prior to be the facility plan being able to be produced and as a result I believe the facility plan doesn't address what was actually the outcome of the facility group so I'd like to make a comment I

204uh I was in on some of the discussion I uh met with Dr rotino regarding his uh close to final draft and and and final report um there's a lot in there um I think it gives us a good foundation for the next few years we know we have um the CTE project the Riverview project and I believe uh Buckeye project is uh very important within that and uh there's a lot of other mention uh within that on some of the other facilities I believe all of those are good talking points for further discussion um in things in that plan are not set in stone but they're available for discussion and I think as time goes on and things are always in flux uh with the buildings and things uh we'll be able to have

205the discussions uh that are necessary for improvements to the district and I would concur with you uh what you just said CU I was going to S try to say a few of the same points um no one has a crystal ball going forward um the board did um approve uh uh me as um uh part of the U facilities plan um as a board rep and it was 5e but during the course of all of our meetings we did get a lot of additional information uh that we wanted to capture and Dr ratino and I met and you know uh talked a a lot about this um so I think it's important that we you know document what was discussed what we want to take a look at going forward but we also have

206to watch what do these new housing developments due to enrollment is there going to be uh any adjustments we need to to make along the way um as far as redistricting we we don't know um but one thing I do know it's critical that we get our students our full-time students at Buckey and melid out of the modular trailers um some of them I know that they've been around except for the newest one um you know they've been around for over 15 years we're experiencing a lot of repair on some of these um things um like leaks that have happen um repaired you know by removing a wall and there's some mold there um you know it was never meant for students to be educated for 15 years in you know um this this environment

207and so I think it's very important that we you know move ahead on Buckeye and uh in particular um you know as class sizes change rooms free up and you might be able to like at melridge they have um three sections of fourth grade that's going to when they graduate there's going to be another room there that we would be able to hopefully uh manage um you know without the trailer there and as we move forward with Buckeye again finding ways that we have our students in Brick and quter buildings and not out in a trailer where they have to um you know especially you can imagine in in this kind of weather when we had all that snow having to use the key fob having to um go to um into the building from

208the trailer to go to the bathroom to go to gym to go to lunch it's just just not not something I've seen in any District that I've worked in or have been associated with in you know the 42 years I've worked so at this point um you know the other concern that I heard when we had meetings at bucka and melridge uh was the need for um better lighting but also air conditioning I heard that overwhelmingly and I talked to Dr vertino about that as well and he did put something in there about HVAC um you know a statement was made um about the advantage of that um under the lamouth um you know improvements adding air conditioning to a school can significantly improve the learning environment and overall well-being of students and staff regulating

209indoor temperatures can help maintain an optimal setting for concentration and focus while also improving air quality by filtering out dust and allergens which is particularly beneficial for those with asthma and allergies school I and I also want to say it isn't just students it's staff and so school facilities become more usable year round enabling summer programs and extracurricular activities to take take place comfortably finally installing while in this case they're in the first phase they're talking about installing a chiller at louth as a long ter investment in the school infrastructure aligning and modernization efforts and offering energy efficient solutions that contribute to a more healing and functional environment for the entire School Community while this project is convening it is also recommended to do some exterior masonry work and loading dock to be completed by

210um the boski study and although these things are needed for lamouth it's all in the order we do things and when when I look at riverv viiew at Parkside you know it's hard to think about what has happened in the last 5 years that Buckeye and melridge have not been addressed and yet these improvements for louth would be $2 million how much does it cost to have air conditioning in at Buckeye and melridge and improved lighting until we can add on and correct these issues so that that is my very strong um concern and um I I think that all students should be treated equally I think that the um you know uh staff that's in some of these older buildings um don't have equal experience as well and um I I I think that

211that should be a priority um for Buckeye know um and then um uh the other thing is um yeah I just wanted to ask um also in segment one I know that the athletic Turf replacement was mentioned and a fund was started and we've set aside some money for that um how much do we have so far I have to go back and look I I mean it's a what an $800,000 project was it or what what's the cost I think it's about 800,000 and I think we have about 200,000 so how less than that currently to do it but then you you factor inflation in it may go it'll yeah might go higher so um where is that money coming from the permanent Improvement fund so that is coming from the permanent Improvement fund

212you're designating there's designated Turf replacement fund right um there is a sponsorship currently with um University Hospitals and they they gave somebody the first time that sponsorship is up um is up so we go out to look for when we replace it for a new sponsorship um as well to help offset some of those costs um right so and then the rest of that will come from the pi fund the current the current cul fund is the revenue from the cell tower out back is De clarify and and it is it is put on to where it is because that was the prediction um our maintenance staff does a phenomenal job keeping that and getting the more life out of it if it was originally 8 to 10 years we stretching it out um to

213to 10 to 15 but at some point we within the near next 5 years we're going to have to replace it we know that okay and so just to put that placeholder on there needs to so the longer we keep it up and keep it in good shape the more Revenue we get from cell tower fund and um right the better things are okay right and also to the cell cell phone uh Revenue it's not a large amount of Revenue Gary how much would you say we average a year 30 grand yeah it's like 20 it's between 25 30 grand when we look at four years we can expect maybe another 100,000 maybe a little bit more but right around 100,000 so we have about 200 now you figure we have about 300 of the

214approximately 800 and hopefully we can get a sponsor that's that that's the next but our sponsorship is up it's it's to go out and look again I just want to make sure that we understand that that's just another item out of the pi fund that we're going to have to expend dollars on um so as we decide if we're going to find out of the pi fund that's got to be a consideration we have turf to replace and part and and to to add to that um part of the thought and idea is to possibly uh start to put a little bit of money aside whatever it might be let's just take an example of $50,000 a year and if you're four years out that's another $200,000 we could put away 75,000 we we could

215choose a number that we do uh to dedicate towards that and I think that would probably be prudent and wise to put a little bit of money away each year for that project because the project is going to come and we don't want it to be a very large number when it does come so so um I guess for me I just in regards to the facilities plan I think Dr Martino you did what you could with what you were handed so I think the pivot um from what the district or the community members wanted with putting a um an addition onto lamouth that would make it 5 through eight then also free up space that are um element schools um to do some of the same things that we're going to be doing I

216think that would have been a great plan to go forth and I think put us in a better position as an entirety for the district but I guess with the road of the Riverview um you had to Pivot away from that and I think you've done the best of what you can with what you've been handed um which is very hard for me because I think that there was a better plan out there in the first place but um I do appreciate the hard work you put into it I I I do think this plan with with a large addition of bucket provides us with three modernized large elementary schools um that are that are on the same plan and even Even in our original plan um and making at somay put turning louth into

217an elementary school we still have a modernized elementary school for that my concern with it is we have a whole high school here that is not getting touched and they do not have air conditioning and they do not have some of the amenities either so that's my big concern okay so I think that you talked about I mean we we talked tonight about the CTE Wing will be air conditioned um you are exploring options for air conditioning the cafeteria and what other space the lecture room and well this this space here actually has no working HVAC so if it gets much colder it's going to cold see your breath um but yeah this is a space that's in dire need of something the choir room was on the the choir buildings and grounds agenda to

218move forward we took that off um with the CT Grant uh to see if we can get some economy of scale in in a c in a um contract competitively Bing a contract been a little bigger um and then it would be the cafeteria the commons um and ultimately Pie in the Sky my favorite would be John our cafeteria as well so all those again equable spaces for all students they're all EA in air conditioning um and have that break during the day uh if possible but that would be again we' have we would our plan is to bid them out as alternates and see what comes back okay and see what we can afford within the the budget but we don't know until we ask yeah and the only other thing I looked into

219is um and we could only base it off the new modular that we uh trailer that we bought at um Buckeye um but the cost of the trailer was 50,000 it took um for uh basically transporting and setting it up it was 112,000 uh decking and canopy 15,000 which are maintenance uh guys do a great job on that um but then they needed some additional materials for $6,000 995 um and then electrical was 19,500 um outside uh electrical another 2,800 and electrical cost and usage um 38.92 um if you add it all up including um 4,722 for carpeting it was $225,000 for that latest trailer the others we've had for a longer time but when you look at the the total amount that we're paying an electric on electric bills for uh just Buckeye it's

22016,19 and um my concern is we don't even have comparable furniture at some of these these older elementaries and you know I know when the fifth grades from Buckeye and melbridge moved to lamu we we did buy $85,000 or so worth of furniture but again going back to we need to be more Equitable about what we're doing at Buckey and melid and so uh superintendent rotino I believe it was the beginning of November you had invited you you had put out a template of the fiveyear facilities plan and invited each of the board members to come in and talk with you and I did discuss it right so I know that I took that opportunity to come in and speak with you and treasur plco and um it was a a little more than 6

221hours of time that we we worked on the the plan together and discussed the plan and and what it looked like and I know that we had even met before that uh a month and a half or two months before that and spent a couple hours discussing it and uh I know that when we originally spoke going back a few months uh you had you had said yeah Buckeye has to be next and I agreed and of course we spent a lot lot of time talking about that and I know originally you had started out at eight classrooms and then you had moved at to 12 and um so anyway you know and I agreed with that too because I think we need that and of course that includes uh having a gym and putting

222the air conditioning through the old part of the building and updating the lighting to LED and then um my thought is uh in all of that to do the air conditioning and lighting at melridge also so but in that time we talked talked about the plan and um discussed some some changes to it and um I know that Mr plco and I spent a couple hours talking about the financing opportunities and of course you you had already set up for Mike to come in and explain a little bit better what the parameters are on that and so I think that's really good the one item that that uh is still in there that that we talked about or at least I talked about maybe you didn't say it because you still have it in there

223um the Lou uh when we were discussing it U and I think you have two phases I would look at that as a third but if it's two maybe the second half of of the second phase um and you know the idea of of putting a couple million dollars into Lou before we're doing some other things I just want to go on record that the 5-year facilities plan has taken a long time to develop and it is here before us um it is it is valuable and workable and I want just want to be on record that I would not be supportive of spending a couple million dollars at lamouth at this time before other things got done um but uh I do appreciate the the time and effort and the time that we spent

224together discussing it and um I think that it gives us a path forward and and something to work with so is there any further discussion G can you take the RO Lori kinsky I lenda grassy unfortunately May Denise Brewster hi Scott Vell hi Dennis Kean hi motion carried that brings us to an adoption of new revised board policies U Belinda I'm sorry is this Belinda we used to keep under Billings of grounds and now separ okay so uh it's moving okay Chang that recently we have um a resolution for the policy adoption uh um a resolution to approve the adoption of the new and revised board policies and bylaws listed do I have a second I second it is there any discussion on those uh just to note these were uh our assistant superintendent chuck

225schlick had handled this and these are all just uh required changes to the policies is that right yeah I mean they're all they're all legal Le right yeah legal Le changes so there's really not much to discuss here I just want everyone to know that there's a number of them and and it's just all required things that we need to approve so and by law we have to approve it by a certain date right some of them have to be on by a certain date some of them are just to be compliant with new regulations State L all of that some of them um are just cleaning up some language within and moving some things around because of other changes so that's why it's that's why it's so robust this time around almost a full

226page and everybody's had two meetings worth of opportunity to review them and read them so if there's no further discussion uh yeah I was going to uh say the artificial intelligence AI um it was interesting to read that one and I didn't know how is that then you know once we adopt this then how is that communicated out to staff because it sounded like staff had leway to use it if they wanted to they do AI is really exciting it's something we're training all of our staff on it's one of our um three major initiatives for the years we looking at how we can use AI to make uh to personalize learning actually um so we will we will share some of the ways as to how to use it our students currently um chat

227GPT is probably the number one AI site that's out there uh it does require to team as part of the disclaimer so we do not open that through our website I I also know that they have other Internet connected devices that they can get to chat gpta before so I didn't say that our kids aren't on it um but it's also kind of looking into teaching our students how to use these tools um as well uh to you know make decisions and to look with things like AI hallucinations um what that looks like kind of those sorts of things and really kind of partake in some of the the The Good the Bad and the Ugly that comes with it um and really kind of have some so we are we are continuing to work

228with training our staff work with kind shaping as we go our best practices and all that and it's exciting but it's scary all at the same time all right thank you all right well now if there's no further discussion can we call the RO please Linda grassy hi Denise Brewster hi Scott fishell hi Dennis Keeny hi Lori pisy I motion carried uh next we have our first reading of new and revised board policy uh number two 2265 protections of individual beliefs affiliations ideals or principles of political movements and ideology so that's a first read there's no vote required on that um next up we have if I can make a note this is a requirement for the timeline so it will probably be as a for the second read and action um the organizational meeting

229so we'll do second read and action okay okay were there two I thought there were two just one one one okay and it's new it is new there's nothing to reference it's new Yeah well yeah I think I think you had originally said there were two items yeah so I don't know where that no no no not not for here but in in a meeting sometime AG there there were potentially other action items on okay so so the other one is still pending okay got it uh next up we have a resolution to approve the revisions to the Riverside Local School District Board of Education handbook can I have a second second um the revisions to the board handbook had to do with the functions of the Committees um we put those out there and

230um asked for any input to be provided to the superintendent and there was there was no other changes requested correct it was the the dates were the the grade levels were the feedback that I did get um the one point of clarification in my understanding is all the appendices that we added the back and as those update we just update those or correct okay that was my yeah and so what I'd like to add is that there are so many changes in there I think it takes a a full work session to go through them item by item and so it would be my Rec recommendation that we pause and do a work session to go through them so that the full board can discuss each of the changes um and that's my recommendation at

231this time didn't we already have that on a work session yeah I me at this point we're voting on what's here in front of us so it's a um I vote a or a for stain okay so just just for the record um as we vote on this I would I would recommend that uh we not approve it and go to a work session because there's a lot of changes in there and I think we need to go through them one by one and discuss each of them as a board I would tend to agree with that because there's a couple things in there I do really have some questions on and and I did call Dr Tino and um when I started reading about the grade divisions and things that needed correction and then

232I started reading some of the rest and I thought it would be helpful to have discussion about the whole book well the only changes that we made I'm talking about the I have no problem with the um although I mean we probably should make sure the whole board is weighing in on the osba uh Edition as a resource um I'm talking about some of the redline things at the beginning so feedback was requested before this meeting so that they could be it could be addressed was feedback provided to Dr rotino I only commented about the um grade divisions I think part of the concern is as Mr McIntyre board attorney said you start getting into a round Rob and a series of conversations about things I think it's just simpler and easier uh to do

233a work session but that's that that's my opinion and again I thought we had a work session on this topic but uh we never went through all the changes and and discussed them one by one that we certainly didn't have a work session for that do have table so when when this was presented the way it was presented was that Mike had put these together they were former they were requests by board members in the past and they're just updated now and that's all that was spoken about it um we had a policy committee where we talked about the board additions to the handbook regarding the structure of the Committees that was what was the purpose of adding those things to the board handook well that's what I'm saying there was a minor discussion in

234in the policy committee but there were three other board members not present I I read through it I'm okay with the changes so um but we can just call for a vote if it fails it fails it's fine can we call the RO please Denise Brer no Scott FAL nay Dennis Keeny nay Lorie piski I Linda g i motion [Applause] failed all right next on the agenda is the Board of Education business would you want me to take that okay the Riverside Local School District Board of Education will send out by email a communication to the Riverside local school district to inform about the progress planning and direction of the Board of Education the Board of Education designates Scott fishal to meet with director of marketing and Communications on Friday December 20th 2024 to formulate

235the email communication the email will be sent on Friday December 20th 2024 can I get a second I'll second any discussion yes I'm going to continue to say that this there's I I oppose this being consistently added to our Board of Education agenda as a votable item we haven't had any conversation on how the process is going to work we continue to not have any conversation about how this process is going to work we continue to not have any review by any board members of what this communication piece is going to say we can't come to an agreement on how we're going to proceed with this we've made suggestions they've been deflected so I'm just going to say we can continue to have this board agenda added to our meeting agenda every month but I'm

236going to continue to oppose that so yeah no go ahead I again will also oppose it again it bypasses our collaborative process that um is essential for our board um to function effectively we just talked about it today as a board member we have responsibility to ensure that all decisions especially Communications to the district are made trans transparently with input from the entire board uh the communication as proposed is coming from one point of view um and does not allow for a well-rounded discussion and the lack of discussion for opportunity for inputs undermines our role in shaping accurate and truthful messaging to our district um and again for those reasons I'll be voting no also and so just a recap we have had the discussion two or three times in the past and it continues

237to be the same discussion and of course um the way that this has to practically be set up by the law is that um the anything any input you have into the email is welcomed by email and forward that and uh I have not yet received anything um uh to be put in there and so I welcome you to have input into that I to be I'd like I'd like to finish before you interrupt me thank you and U and our and our board attorney said that this is this is U how this would be set up and and the process so what we can do is we can turn this into a policy so maybe at the next next meeting we'll have a first reading to change it to policy Mr McIntyre is this

238the only way for us to go about a board communication or can we agree on a process to come up with a board communication so he is not said this is the way so let's let's put it this way the board communication typically would go out on Monday of course we're out of school next week so it has to go out tomorrow but the the suggestions in the past were let's have meetings about this no that wasn't oh yes it was a a suggestion was to let Nick write it up let Nick send it out to us and if there's any concern we raise the red flag to Nick and that is an an accurate process correct we can do that yes we just can't have discussion among usk so we could we could appoint

239our communications director to create a board email but I think the board is the one creating the board email then let's pass it around let's talk about the process so in the in the past in the past um the board had chosen to not communicate with a board email the communications which are very well done uh by Nick are are Publications and emails um but I think we need to give the people more information especially now as more is occurring and uh we're going to have three building projects going on all at once and I think I think uh regular uh emails even if they're doubled up on the the same information people hearing that receiving that I know the people that that respond to me are thankful for it they're appreciative of it and

240and I I think it's just such a simple item and the idea that that um somehow the process is not fair or anything you know I reject that idea and I appreciate that because you're writing the communication I I appreciate that you are are saying it is and so uh are you saying you would like to write the board email yes I think once in a while everybody should have an opportunity to write the email and I think at our next meeting if you put another agenda item on here I'm going to also so suggest that we put an agenda item that that says I get to write the email I mean and then what are we going to do so we can have further discuss as we go and and then uh we can

241discuss even doing around Robin to where each board member we haven't discussed that we won't we're not allowed to get the discussion okay as a matter fact you stopped the discussion the last meeting okay because it was going down the same path that the previous two discussions were with a disagreement and as we can see on on this there's a disagreement on how to do things and and so here we are in this in the same situation I think it's important to communicate with the district going and nobody has said that we don't agree that this it's not important to communicate we've just not agreed on a process and and you continue to appoint yourself as the communicator and shoot I want to be the communicator next time then I'll be honest I wasn't an

242agreement with what was put in the original communication so I that's where that whole lack of discussion or opportunity discuss it here what we want and again Nick can put it together and send it to us to say that looks good because that's Nick's the director of communications what happens if the the director gets five different opinions on changes that should be made then well that's part of what we have to figure out Mr official but the problem is you have your perspective and you just said it we don't always agree the communication should represent the entire board so there was information put out in the first communication that I was feel that was inaccurate and it was not truthful messaging or transparent to our community so and you continue to do that it's your

243opinion so again I think we need to talk about a process but you have silenced us from doing that uh we're talking right now are we not no technically we can't talk about the process because you won't allow us to and we are discussing the item right now are we not well we're discussing that we don't agree with this resolution okay we're also discussing possibilities of other ways to do it right are we going to are we going to come to a conclusion on what our process will be I think for tonight I think we have to go ahead and execute what's on the table and in the future I think that we can discuss uh other opportunity and when will we do that should we have a work session for that well it might

244not be a bad idea great okay let's set one up so we can set a work session for that and maybe we can couple it with the handbook that'd be perfect can we set that date at our organizational meeting perfect and can we can we agree that we won't do another one of these and we won't see another one of these resolutions till we have come to a conclusion on what that process is going to look like do that I I don't know if you can just stop the process okay so I think the process continues on if we want to change uh the action of the process then that's open for discussion and and I think that's a great idea so is there any further discussion Gary can you call the role Scott Pell

245hi Dennis Keeny hi Lori kisy nay lenda grassy nay de Boer I motion carried and we have next item is buildings and grounds committee the Board of Education shall require the chairperson of the buildings and grounds committee to direct the items that will be placed on the board of education agenda at each Board of Education meeting based on the discussions at the buildings and grounds committee meeting do I have a second I'll second I'm also going to go on record as saying I think this is ridiculous because we have four different committees and we don't have four different agenda items for the four different chairs of the four different committees that we have um I will also say that at our last buildings and grounds committee we had some heated conversation about what should be

246going on our agenda um and the items are on the agenda anyway so I'm not so certain that process works right now um the only thing I would say though is that the items are on the agenda but not recommended by the superintendent or the treasur so let it be again I don't think that there's any secret power here um anybody any one of us can recommend for something to be added to the agenda so it I mean it is what it is so at this point and uh just so you know you don't have to put this on every month I did confirm with Mr McIntyre that it is a a standing resolution correct yes okay so this is a standing resolution does it need to be repeated uh no I mean I would

247do it by the calendar year so each board after its organizational meeting um or excuse me at the organizational meeting could pass this as a standing resolution along with our other standing resolutions and it would last for the year sure that we include all of the Committees that would be a policy change though actually a bylaw change correct if you're doing what when you say add all the Committees do you mean to this know I mean this is just the buildings and grounds committee chair person gets to do this no other committee person is really doing that we're reviewing our our resolution items at our committee meetings that's the whole purpose of the committee meeting so this resolution essentially uh allows it captures what you all have as a right current so any one of

248you can put an item on the agenda so this resolution doesn't do anything new it just memorializes a right that you already have so is there a need to even have this on our agenda no so the one thing that it does do is it U it it keeps the process of committee so things that are being brought to committee and being put onto the agenda from the committee instead of just a board member so so that's that's the reason behind but we haven't really agreed to the to how the Committees are structured and how the Committees work because we won't approve the board policy handbook so there's that I think there's already a handbook that that describes that what you're talking about are changes that have not yet been apprach but they weren't included

249so the the board committee the structure of the board committee was not included in the board policy handbook to begin with and the definition of so so again at this we all have the right to put anything on the agenda it is what it is I mean so it's no big deal right so no it's not needed as Mr as we as we mentioned it's a right that we all have already today so Gary can you take the wall hi ly I Glenda grassy Denise Brewster I Scott Fel hi motion carried we have another item on the agenda building Edition uh Buckeye Elementary the Riverside Local School District Board of Education hereby approves moving forward with building approximately a 12 classroom addition plus a gymnasium addition onto Buckeye Elementary do I have a second second

250any discussion um I'd like to say that um this this uh approval of this we'll get the the process started which I think is very important there's a lot to be done um moving forward before we have any kind of finalized plan or anything like that but I think this is just step one in exploring what our options are and our costs and everything else because it is diely needed um to upgrade that Elementary School uh it's in a uh great location it serves a large portion of the uh Northwest side of our district um and they're uh very much cramped for space there and so new space is needed how that plays out um will be determined through a lot of meetings and discussions and everything else that goes along with it but we

251have to take that first step in order to improve uh phys facilities for the children and and the faculty and staff I think I would like to ask how much of this information is the rest of this board seeing for the first time this evening and we're going to make a decision on a building Edition that we had a brief five minute conversation or presentation by our architect team we hav't really discussed it we haven't discussed it at the board table um gosh we're going to have a work session about a piece of email that goes out but we're not going to have a work session about a building Edition that's going to cost us millions of dollars that just floes me we're worried about $800,000 for the field but we're not worried about a

252million dollar building we're worried about air conditioning at Buckeye and and again I don't I I believe buy needs updated I in agreement with that I understand where Dro is coming from from our discussions but we haven't had discussion we haven't thought about where the money's coming from we don't know where the money's coming from Riverview it's I agree the process needs to get started but that starts with discussion here at this table on how we're going to accomplish it I I I don't think we're in any way near a vote I would add that that again superintendent ratino put information out months ago about this addition it's been discussed massaged talked about changed and updated uh for months and also at the beginning of November superintendent rotino invited the board members in each board

253member in to discuss that and I would ask Miss grassy did you go in and and speak I was not invited to go and meet with him I oh you weren't we spoke on the phone we spoke on the phone yeah so uh M uh superintendent ratino did you send an email out to the board inviting each person to come in Fray yes so so everyone was invited and I know myself I I spent six hours going over this it is very very important you know we've had these kids in the trailers for 15 years and and that's a travesty uh I think Miss Brewster talked about one of them that was falling apart so badly there was mold in the wall um I know a worker that was working over there and said he

254knelt down on the carpet and his knees were soaking wet cuz the carpet was soaking wet um these trailers were not meant to uh be in service for this long kids are kids are in these trailers are having to go outside sometimes three times a day because they have to go to the bathroom they have to go to the gym they have to go to lunch it's not right you know there was one particular parent that spoke very loudly and very clearly at one of the meetings how upset she was that her son had to deal with those conditions and uh and I agree with her 100% that should not be the case and we need to fix these problems these have been problems have been going on for 15 years we need to fix

255these problems and I believe that we're on the right path in doing so we've got we've got one classroom over there that's divided into what four or five sections where where where kids that need extra help how can they're they're in an environment where there's distractions in the very room where they're trying to get help and and not not to sound don't want this to sound bad but staff is going to the bathroom in the bathroom in the kitchen there's just no space over there um I was over there last week and there's offices on the stage in the gym cafeteria area because we don't have space to put our our Administration and staff in offices um the rooms that are supposed to be used for other things the library different things I mean how

256how many how many how long are we we can't continue to go like that is what I'm saying we need to solve this problem and nobody and we need to solve the problem now we've been talk and we've been talking about this uh from our superintendent for several months now we but we haven't had any conversation at the table about the process the funding what it's going to look like going to be plenty of opportunity for all that discussion uh because uh this ball is going to be St to move forward and everyone will have input as Mr Keeny said this this is a starter but unfortunately we didn't all have input the first time I saw those drawings were at our buildings and grounds committee meeting this just this past week and at that

257time I asked did any of our other board members have an opportunity to see this information yet did our Administration our Administration was introduced at the same time I mean if that's the first time time we're seeing it that is not adequate discussion at the table in order to move forward with a multi-million dollar project again I don't disagree that we need to do something with bukeye we're saying we need to have the right conversation can I ask why is this not put on by the superintendent in the Treasure to move forward I was waiting for the approval of the facilities plan yeah thank you let me just say I'm not a fan of either one of these drawings but it is a place to start we'll have a lot of discussions going forward hopefully

258we're going to have those conversations at the table at the table at a work session because we haven't had one yet and I I know how long it takes to build an addition like that has to be customized with Buckeye it's not like Riverview where it's a pretty straight shot you know one hallway four classrooms on top four on the bottom we've done a good job of you know customizing some spaces in it but Buckeye is going to you're you're definitely dealing with an older building there's going to be more nuances plus you have trailers there that have to be removed you have relocation of people in order to get rid of those trailers so you can do construction and so at this point if you don't start you're going to lose another year and

259I feel 15 years is long enough I love how you guys look back at the history of the school there was a time we didn't have money to operate our schools where we had to cut um curriculum we had to cut busting we had to cut everything so that 15 years is not a a fair time of reference when you can't operate your schools which is where we're heading now you don't do the extras you put patches on things you make sure the roofs are not leaking you make sure we have heat that's what we could do so 15 years is not a fair reference and there was a plan yeah I want to ask whose idea was it to explore the cops Grant cuz the first time I ever heard about a cops Grant

260I thought I heard uh blinda say it and then I Gary invited the person we were talking about a cops Grant before I even knew what that was we had so we had a presentation tonight correct and it's a it's a financing it's not necess Str well but we don't know how we're financing any of this yeah we haven't had that conversation we haven't had the conversation about how we're going to fund all these things that we are going to put on the agenda and say we're going to do but we're not we don't know how to fund it yet funding it is part of the conversation that should be happening at the table in a work session about we're going to do this and this is how we think we should fund it and

261explore those options but we haven't done that we done that we really the horse um as soon as it's approved the money starts coming out of the pocket of the district and if we learned something along the way we we we don't have a plan we haven't thought this through at all or had the discussion well we don't know how much to borrow until we have a plan well that's not the point the point is once we do riview do we even have any money left are we putting ourselves in a place where we're not going to be able to operate these schools because it going back out to the community when you're putting up new buildings asking for operating money is not going to go over very well so that's the point so let

262me add that the the permanent Improvement Levy The Continuous Levy by law Mr PLO would you agree by law that has to go into a permanent Improvement fund correct right that has nothing to do with the general account the operating account okay so you know you've been on the board what five years okay I would think you would know that I do know that Mr official so since I'm talking down to me I'm not talking down yes you are what I'm saying is you're you're conflating the two you're mixing the two I'm talking about the stuff that's on this agenda we we when you when you look at the financing opportunities in our cash flow okay we have a great opportunity with our with our permanent Improvement Levy the the revenue from that to do

263a loan that is very very safe and very and and allows us to operate continue to operate just like we've been operating okay that is not going to do anything other than start to move forward taking care of the things we need to do and I've said in the past we have about $140 million of things we need to do how much money do we have we have to do one thing at a time okay we're doing Riverview right we have the money to do that we're going to do Buckeye we can borrow money to do that we just had a gentleman here tonight talking about it okay Mr PLO the treasurer has discussed at least with me uh when you look at a 10-year Revenue stream uh looking at $2.7 million a year that's

264$27 million and if we need about 12 million in a loan that's very doable we're not stretching anything there we're actually getting some done but you know how you get something done you have to start the ball rolling okay let me let me go back to the space issue why do we let me finish you know what we talked space issue yourap please don't interrupt me okay let's go back to the space issue okay this board before I got elected to the board certainly Mr Keeny wasn't here M Miss Brewster wasn't here sold the Hat in school 16 classrooms we would not have a space issue today if we had those 16 CL classrooms what did we get for those 16 classrooms in that whole that whole building there well we got $540,000 you know

265what that does for us that's one less than one week of operating money in one week that money was gone now we're looking at $18 million to replace the space look we have to solve these problems and we can't sit here and do nothing about it we have to solve the problems these problems are here okay there's nothing we can do about it it now except solve them so we're in the process of solving them why why you want to slow it down and and and allow things not to happen and if you understand construction I think Mr Keeny said it Miss Brewster may have said it this this Buckeye uh construction project needs to start to have some planning and things set in place so that so that construction uh can be broke the

266ground can be broken at the end of school uh let's say like June 1st or so in order for this project to be successful if we don't do that we lose another half a year to a year okay time is a little bit of the essence here so all I'm saying is that this is a very important project the kids are suffering over there the staff is suffering over there I was over there last week and and the staff Administration shared some things with me it is too tight too uncomfortable they need the problem fixed okay we as a board are responsible for that they can't do that on the own it's our responsibility and I think we need to take that responsibility seriously we that's what I have to say about I believe we

267need to take that responsibility seriously also but I think we also need to take responsibility for the educational mission that we have in this district and the next two agenda items absolutely do take money from the general fund to pay for some of these initiatives and so to say that that's not affecting the general fund and educational opportunities that our students have and and that that's not true because you've got two more agenda items coming up that have nothing to do with the permanent Improvement Levy okay so I think we can agree to disagree so can you take the role no I'm later whaty nay grass nay Denise Brewster I Scott bishell I Dennis ke I motion carried okay so the next item on the agenda is general fund interest Revenue the Riverside Local School

268District Board of Education hereby approves that the increase in Revenue due to the interest income is to be deposited into the permanent Improvement fund within five business days after receed this will start January 1st 202 and go through July 31st 2025 do I have a second second for discussion so we will have to have an agenda item if I'm not mistaken every single month to approve that because that's a transfer because those dollars go into the general fund I would also like to know um are we also taking the money that's in the general fund and all the subsidiary funds that are in that general fund I would like to know know there's I I don't know how many 40 funds in there right sub funds I'd like to know if we're taking the dollars

269that are allocated for those funds as well can we ask I think Mr PLO you've considered this because in my discussion asking you some questions so let's I mean I think the two two issues combined yeah yeah so I do have some comments some of it overlaps both this current agenda item and and the next agenda agenda item um you know I'm interpreting this resolution as we are referencing the general fund interest and not any other interest in any other fund because those are cannot be reallocated because they're restricted for particular purposes um as the treasur and Chief Financial Officer I'm adamantly opposed to both of these resolutions um if the board approves this resolution I will need to check with the state auditor's office to see if we can arbitrarily post the interest um

270directly to the permanent Improvement fund that's intended for the general uh for the uh general fund um we may have to actually in of this type of resolution we probably would have to actually do a an actual official funds transfer that designates the exact amount in accordance with the high rise code section 575 D14 section e each month that states that uh dollar amount I did update the 5year forecast to reflect this change and the change on the next agenda item so I will pass that out now um should the board um should the board decid to go against my recommendation and approve these two resolutions I would recommend that we file an updated forecast with the health department of education and Workforce because this is a material change to our forecast um once that

271forecast is received down there you will see that uh in fisc year 2028 our general fund unencumbered cash balance will now be projected at 8,476 um you know the fiveyear forecast shows our fund balances at June 30th if that is our fund balance at June 30th it is typically lower throughout the fiscal year so we will most definitely be borrowing to make payroll during fiscal year 2028 in especially in December January and February where our cash balances are historically um lower at that time due to the timing of property tax payments um in future years as we update our forecast if the Nega if that general fund balance in 2028 flips to negative we would have to file a written proposal to eliminate deficits but the Department of Education Workforce in accordance with biis code

2725753 N1 we had done this previously in 2016 before passing our operating Levy in 2017 we are currently deficit spending which is not an expected or a surprise as it's been 7 and A2 years since our last operating Levy uh now is not the time to divert resources away from the general fund for other purposes uh historically Riverside has kept its general fund operations separate from facility needs by utilizing the permanent Improvement fund and transfering Away interest or property tax revenue from the general fund goes against these historic PR practices um board policy 6234 which is the cash balance Reserve policy uh that states that the board believes in maintaining a general fund cash reserve of balance of 90 days true cash is necessary in the interest of sound fiscal amandement and upon receiving IND

273the indication that the general fund cash Reserve balance of 9 days may not be achieved at any point during the rolling 5year forecast the treasurer shall report that shortfall to the board which I had done last month during the 5-year forecast presentation this policy states the board shall take appropriate actions at least two fiscal years prior to the fiscal year in which the general fund balance cash balance true days cash targets cannot be met that would be the current fiscal year that we're in now so red redirecting revenue from the general fund at this time directly conflicts with this established board policy uh my actual performance evaluation that the board evaluates me on states that the as the district 5-year forecast nearest deficit spending which is where we're at currently we should we need to

274curtail spending initiatives with the ultimate goal of preserving the levy cycl for as long as possible redirecting this revenue from the general fund for other purposes is in complete opposite of this goal the Strategic plan also speaks to fiscal sensibility and states that to seek new Revenue streams for facilities plan implementation I do not believe that redirecting funds from the general fund satisfies this initiative and Expediting general fund deficit spending is simply not sound fiscal management also having such a low projected general fund balance in 2028 would make certifying multi-year contracts challenging due to a higher rised code 5754155740 during this year um that's that's the UN that covers our bus drivers cafeteria workers custodians maintenance if our general fund balance is that low in fisc year 2028 we will be unable to no negotiate

275a three-year contract as I cannot comfortably certify that contract therefore we' have to negotiate a 2-year contract which results in additional legal expenses as those don't fall under retainer it would also uh cause uncertainty for our employees um it'll also limmit our ability for signing multi-year vendor contracts we of services and would negate discounts that are typically received by signing multi-year contracts um the district will ultimately need to return to the voters they ask for additional operating Levy accelerating our deficit spending will result in that Levy needing to be a higher millage and on the ballot sooner um at the end of the day the superintendent myself work directly for the Board of Education if the majority of the board decides to redirect general fund dollars to the per Improvement fund against my recommendation and

276professional judgment I will respect the will of the board and take appropriate action as long as I am legally allowed to do so if there is any doubt I will work with legal counsel for a formal written opinion and also consult with the state auditor's office for additional guidance that's my comments on so Gary when uh when you gave the uh fiveyear with the financial forecast when were you projecting that we are going to have to go to the people for an operating Levy um based on my I'm thinking we're targeting 2026 um in November of that year um you know obviously we have to wait for the re reevaluation to go through have not gotten those values yet they should be coming out soon um you obviously we we kind of know where it's

277going but until we have it in writing we you know it's not certain um so that is kind of the time I was targeting I'm hoping that we can extend that longer um typically we've always tried to ex stretch our Levy dollars as long as possible and try to stay off the ballot um obviously with the current reappraisal and obviously be increased taxes we want to try to wait till things kind of calm down a little bit um as there will be an increase in property taxes um to the taxpayers of the district moving funds moving funds would just make our ask have to be larger correct and so if we were to move uh let's say $1.6 million all you're saying that would change the amount we have to ask in an operating lby

278yes because things will compound over time we earn interest on our cash balances so we're now lowering our cash balances in our general fund which lowers our interest Revenue going forward um if you look at the bottom of the forecast which is a it's in our forecast model I don't typically print out with the forecast but I did for this model you'll just see for fiscal year 2025 if we make these changes we will deficit spend so deficit spending is when our expenditures exceed our revenues by about $3.6 million this fiscal year um if you look at the very bottom the Mich equivalent for deficit spendings so basically what type of Levy would we have to pass assuming we' collect it today which you know is obviously a lag we would need a 3.18 no

279Levy just to cover that deficit balance deficit spending to make it a break even year so you're saying we would need a 3.19 millage Levy to cover uh to essentially break $4 million or so I mean and that's a high number cuz what would the interest be on 1.6 million we're getting about 4% right yeah I have to do the math on the calculator it's about 64 65,000 right so 64 $65,000 right of Interest right yeah and we're right now operating a budget of what $55 million it's around there yes okay and and if we were to take approximately 1 and a half% off of that you're saying that would actually change the amount of money we have to ask for an operating Levy so so you're you're saying uh a couple million dollars is

280going to change the millage that we have to ask for yes cuz you're going to drain your your cash balance you need to cover that so you need start asking for more as you know but what would the difference be on millage so if you're if you're asking for an operating Levy which you've already identified and I'm hearing you say the same thing whether this happens or not we're going to have to go to the people at the end of 2026 no matter what we do because we're in deficit spending it's still early we haven't really ran those calculations it would be a whole Mill if we're looking for three $3.6 million and we're asking for three Mills it's almost a mill MH it's almost a whole Mill just to break even right or just

281to just to fund the amount of money that we're asking to transfer out I mean also at the end of the day I mean I think there's a lot of other things in there that Gary mentioned again per the Ohio RIS code that we should be taking into consideration um I also think we have a Treasurer that does a phenomenal job and we heard um Mike talk about it and we win the audit Awards I I do trust your opinion um so so I I I agree with that and so uh what I would say Gary is that when we spoke um um you did not bring up most of these items so they're they're being brought up now okay so I find that a little disconcerting so with that of course I'm going to

282back off of this move and and uh actually vote against uh they had put on here I'm sorry I think you can you withdraw it um according to Robert's Rules so you can postpone it to a certain time you could postpone it indefinitely Or you can put it on the table okay so let's just put it on the table I move to put it on the table I think we need to wait for Denise to come back please for the record I mean you know we're missing so we had a discussion we know that um you know we know that I was not in favor of of this type of action um and basically when it came to potentially moving forward with it is when I really have to sit down and give all the

283reasons why we shouldn't do it sometimes on the spur of the moment it's hard to get all of your thoughts all I'm saying in agreement with what you're saying is if You' have just said something I would have just pulled it off the agenda okay let me ask a question okay I kind of understand what is trying to be done here to make sure we have money in the pi fund so let's say you know the pi fund is is being utilized and we have a some kind of kind of catastrophe can money from the general fund be used to take care of that catastrophe you could I mean I think the district's done that in the past I mean the general fund can be used for any purpose where we did get into a

284bind that's one of several options considered and then what something that Mr purcella said that I you know thought he says if you start taking general fund and putting it in into Pi then that is not looked on favorably by I picked up on that as well so maybe it's it's better you know I understand and this is just for a short period of time to kind of build up a a better rainy day fund in the pi and I think that's a good thing but with all things said maybe we should just kind of withdraw this for now and uh well miss Brewster while you were away yeah sorry I I moved to uh table uh this agenda yeah I I would agree with that I think said we were GNA vote on it

285and just uh we're tbling it and there will be no vote yeah so is there a second to table it second it so second by m Brewster is there any discussion on tabling it where there's no discussion on table right that's it it's table we have to vote got to vote it yeah no you got to vote it right Gary can you call the rooll what are we voting on this item this item this agenda item why we're not just voting just vote it down vote it down I'm not exactly sure why we're so there's already been motion uh to table it there's been a second so now we have to vote on that according to Robert's Rules of Order okay I want to be clear we're voting on tabling it tbling this agenda item

286okay and this is an indefinite table table table definitely okay well it could be brought up again if someone wants to but with a vote but it's on the table just to clear if so we're voting the table indefinitely I'll go ahead and call the RO um yeah table Linda grassie I think I'm voting I Denise I I Denis Keeny I Cory kisy I motion carried okay and so with that we move into the next agenda item which is you don't make a motion we don't vote on it so if we just if we're if we're good with bothe we if you don't make a motion we so since something's on the uh agenda we can bypass it and not address if nobody makes a motion or there's no second then it just goes down

287okay okay so we can ignore it so we ignore the next item all right all right so that brings us I to the Board of Education update is there any updates from the board um I just wanted to um uh bring up the loss of a very dedicated um teacher in our district that uh taught here um at Leroy Elementary for 29 years Mr Trent Norris anybody who had the pleasure of knowing him uh just a phenomenal teacher um but he was here in um you know as I said 29 years he retired in 1997 he loved teaching and his students I've run into many people since this happened um talking about it because I had the pleasure of working with him for 5 years um as principal um and um he you know students

288just loved him and he had a positive influence on his students that for many lasted into their adult years and um many continued to reach out to him over the years with gratitude and appreciation um for having been in his class so I just wanted to share that just want to wish the district a safe and happy holidays and new year um I think tomorrow is the big day everyone gets some time off so any other board updates all right next meeting announcements we have oh my gosh a tax budget hearing on january8 January January and organizational meeting on January 8th at 7:45 a.m. and then we will decide when the other meetings will be y um I'm not reading the next item not reading the other item um I'll make a motion to adjourn

289at 10:03 p.m. second and can you please call the RO Lor kisy hi lend gry hi Denise Brer hi Scott Bell hi Dennis ke hi motion carried

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.