001to order this meeting of the stowman row Falls Board of Education on Tuesday January 28th at 6: p.m. those in attendance are reminded that this is a meeting of the Board of Education conducted in view of the public any person while being heard at a Board of Education meeting may be called to order by the board president or any member of the board for a failure to be relevant to the business of the board for vulgarity or for personal attacks of persons or institutions the board shall transact business according to the agenda prepared by the superintendent and submitted to all board members in advance of the meeting the order of business may be altered and items may be added at any regular meeting by a majority vote of the members present please join us in
002the Pledge of Allegiance I had to do roll call First oh sorry sorry East Jenkins here merletti here Sheen here zonic here wind sorry about that now the Pledge of Allegiance flag of the United States of America thank you everything we do is designed to provide a future ready Student Center learning experience for every single child our strategic plan for 2021 through 2026 will help us accomplish this goal by considering every facet of a student's learning experience from curriculum to infrastructure to Wellness diversity and inclusion and everything in between as members of the Board of Education we serve as trustees therefore this is a business meeting being conducted in public not a public meeting we are grateful to serve an Engaged community and therefore encourage and respect input from citizens we expect that everyone present
003will behave in a manner consistent with the behavior we expect of our students we reserve the right to have those who do not comply removed from our meeting and before we begin our agenda I have to acknowledge our Bulldog family has been through some losses Dr G um Madam president if we could possibly have a moment of silence for all of the things that have happened um within the last week and a half in regards to our staff member and then um just recently uh as of last night um concerning two of our students and their uh families yeah moment of silence please thank you our thoughts are with everyone affected by our recent losses uh before we go on I just wanted to um Al I wanted to mention something when I was looking
004at the agenda um I noticed that there were some things missing from the agenda and I'd like to have you're out of order right now uh no there's a few things that are missing from the agenda and I'd like to see them put back on do you have a specific motion uh well was there a motion required to take them or remove them from the agenda nothing was removed from the agenda as far as I'm aware well the agenda was never there was never an adoption and I I i' just like to have those things put back on the published agenda can be modified by making a motion and then a vote of the board well but there was specific things that you moved had there was never a motion to remove them so uh
005there there doesn't need to be a motion to put them back on I I'm just kind of curious um and I don't know if our I don't know if our attorney is here are you but I do you have a motion for us to amend the agenda no there doesn't need to be a motion then you are out of order and we need to move on to our business I'm not out of order I'm I'm curious to know Pam what gives you the authority to uh veto any agenda items that I would like to have put on if you would like move for us to discuss the agenda setting process we you can move that and we can add it to our agenda you know we have the family and the kids here it would
006be really simple if you could just put that back on the agenda and and then do you have a motion uh there was never a motion to um there was never required a motion to remove them if you would like us to discuss the agenda setting process we need a motion to amend the agenda and add that to our discussion items no it's very simple it's just me as a board member wanting to add something to the agenda right you do that by motioning right now if it's not on the published agenda no there there is no need to motion because it was never removed I I again I asked the question of why and who if you don't have a motion we need to move on with our agenda there's no I I'm just
007asking to have something put back on the agenda that's missing again you can do that by making a motion and can you tell me what statute gives you the the right to um if we are going to discuss our agenda setting process we can move to add that to our discussion no it's not on the agenda very simple thing I I'm just one of five board members um this is not a board of one it's a board of five and I was asking to get something just put back on the agenda just to you do that by making a motion uh but again there's nothing to there's nothing to motion because it wasn't n it wasn't required to be taken off we need to move on um again what what determines and gives you that
008power I I want to know what statute I want do I have a motion to add a discussion of our agenda setting process to our discussion items tonight okay we need to move on it is time to welcome our board member I would like to know what you're item on our agenda I would I would like to know what you're afraid of about me um just adding having something that's missing from the agenda put back on no one's afraid of anything we are following Robert's Rules of orders regarding our agenda for our meeting uh if we did the agenda's never been adopted so we are not following Robert's Rules of Order it's time for us to move on so can we we are welcoming a new board member who decides who why do you decide
009that what gives you the power what gives you the sole power if we would like to discuss the agenda setting process you're not answering my question that's correct because this is not an item on our agenda right now our item on our agenda right now is to welcome our new board I would like to put it on the agenda as a board member then make I have equal right there is no motion necessary there is absolutely no show me in the statute show me the rule show me where you have veto authority of what goes on the agenda or what doesn't go on the agenda do I have a motion to add a discussion of our agenda setting process that doesn't answer my question I'm asking a question I'm sticking to our agenda between me
010and you I am sticking to our agenda sir yes but I'm yes and I'm just asking to have something put back on that's missing do you have a motion uh there's not required to be a mo I'm just asking to put some back something on the agenda that's missing and how one does that under Robert's Rules of orders is is by making a motion to amend the agenda but you want to show me that show me that in Robert's Rules of Order do I don't quote don't quote Robert's Rules of Order if you can't show me again this discussion is not following our agenda we to get back to our agenda disc this is not a discussion I'm asking that just put something back on the agenda as a equal equal 20% board member and
011again we have the kids here we have the activity here can can we just put that on the agenda and then we can then we can move on if you have a motion we can we can deal with that sir uh there's no need to put anything on to put this on the on the agenda a motion this it is time to our new board member to the table this is missing from the agenda you're out of line and so what you're telling me you're telling me no are you telling me no that me as a board member cannot put something on the agenda sir are you telling me no that you I am currently following our agenda if you would like us to discuss the agenda setting process during our discussion for the agenda
012to follow has to be adopted and it's not adopted and so so I'm getting are you telling me no as a board member that I cannot put something back on the agenda yes or no you are out of order right now I am I am not having a discussion that is what the criteria for me being out of order you are discussing an item that is not on the agenda and you are not moving to put it on the I'm making a just a simple statement so hey there's something missing and I'd like it put back on and we need all right so I'm asking you are you telling me no are you telling me no that me as a board member cannot cannot put something on the agenda we are moving on to our
013so you're avoiding the unless you have a motion I will take that as a no that you are denying me as a board member from from putting something on the agenda so please make record of that uh our attorneys I hope you're watching so that you can see what's happening make a motion to discuss the set our uh process for adding something to the agenda do I have a second okay so I would assume that would be under our discussion items any discussion before we vote okay roll call please east east Jenkins I merletti I Sheen no ponic I wind I we need to move on to our next item on the agenda which is um where is that on the agenda where where is that going to fit in on the agenda here at
014the end of the discussion items can I have a number it be it'll be 15f under new business it is time to move on to welcoming our new member Tina merlady and I was hoping that you could introduce yourself to everyone okay uh let me talk into the mic so everyone can hear me H good evening everyone I'll I'll keep this short because I realize we have a a lot of wonderful things on our program today uh I see all the kids here with their poster boards and various things so I look forward to hearing that uh my name is Tina merletti uh I grew up in Stow uh Liv back in Heather Hills and um I uh was a resident for many years until I went to college to the Ohio State University so
015go Bucks yay we won um and uh then when I moved back I uh actually moved uh lived in the city of akan a couple blocks from my grandmother uh where I had had the opportunity to serve seven years on akan city council uh at that time I also served as the finance chair uh over uh it was over a $500 million budget um unfortunately I uh also was there during the recession where we had to uh make some hard decisions about uh cuts and um cutting the budget so uh it was ult but definitely a good learning experience and how to work with government budget uh at that time I also was fortunate enough to serve on the city of uh serve as a city of akan member on the akan public schools facilities
016committee uh where I uh was uh privileged to review uh from beginning to end the building of 23 buildings uh looking at how to save money on utilities uh looking at future for technology and uh the things that we could do to open the buildings to the community and truly be a partner with the communities in building new facilities um I hope that my experience will be useful to uh the Stow schools as we move forward towards the future uh I uh currently reside in Monroe Falls I have uh two children in the school system a fifth grader and a seventh grader so I um am really looking forward to things that we can do to continue to grow and improve this district and I thank all of you for this opportunity thank you we're
017happy to have you aboard thank you superintendant report good evening at this time we would like to uh welcome the Woodland Elementary we're happy to be here in this building and we will have a presentation from Principal keing good evening Board of Education members thank you for being here Dr G uh Mr Gano um we have um a little presentation for you this evening some of our student council members will be coming up in a few minutes um to offer their appreciation to the school board for school board recognition month and we're just going to wait for our presentation to show up oh God for got to love technology Cody to the rescue thank you iway so I want to just quickly go over our uh mission statement and our theme for the school year
018um along with Dr G's theme our theme is building Futures together and our mission here at Woodland is through collaboration with parents in the community every student will have the opportunity to engage in relevant learning experiences in a safe and nurturing learning environment in order to uh encourage lifelong learning and our goals for this school year were chosen by our building leadership team um our first one is to consistently implement the multi-tiered systems of support process district and building wide implementing a multi-year professional development plan so the way that we're doing that at Woodland is um we are implementing some Bulldog FX time this year where we are working with our students on the the needs that they have for math and reading we're providing professional development to our staff to collaborate and plan lessons
019um providing School based intervention team meetings twice a month to look at data to help our students meet their needs and we have our monthly PBIS meetings where we look at discipline data to move our students forward with choosing positive um choices and expectations throughout the school and then our second goal is to um develop a district and building-wide PD plan for teachers and administrators looking at data and research based best practices we Implement that through ongoing staff development throughout the year we Implement that through priding the staff with updates on our new English language arts curriculum and the science of reading uh offering PD on trauma informed teaching practices is for um working with our students to promote those positive behavior interventions and supports and then obviously following up with our staff throughout the
020school year and these connect to the district strategic plan goals of mission number two continuous Improvement Mission Number Nine diversity and inclusion and Mission number seven our public relations how we uh work to bring the community to into Woodland and that's where I'm going to turn it over to miss Nikki and Miss Sarah pilot our student council representative uh teacher Representatives go over come on over kiddos all right as they're getting situated um I'll just I'm first of all I'm sorry lost my voice because I love teaching math so much I get so excited right so my name is Nikki pilin and I teach fourth grade math here at Woodland and um Miss pilot and I acquired um student council this year in the past it had been doing a really good job as far
021as like within the school doing like notes of kindness to each other and um uh way to support the students um we decided to take it a different way different approach and instead of having like all of the fourth graders being able to be in student council we narrowed it down and the students in fourth grade actually voted for who they wanted to be in student council this year and so um they these uh lovely kiddos were just missing three all gave speeches in front of their peers and were voted into student council and um we also took a little bit more serious approach to where we're like let's go outside of the community and so we um teamed together with the high school to do a can food drive which they'll talk about in
022a little bit and um I think all of them can say that they have found out that student council is a bit harder than they thought it would be all right they are really hard workers and have done an amazing job we're really proud of them and there goes my voice so I'm gonna go ahead hi I'm Sarah pilot yes it's confusing Pilon pilot on the announcements all the time um I'm one of the gifted intervention Specialists I'm usually A Gifted teacher this year I'm in third grade and I do miss working with fourth grade but I'm happy that I have the capacity to work with these students with M pilin this year and these it's just a great group of kids and honestly they've got it from here forward so the first person talking
023about our fundraiser is Miss Pon all right you got good evening my name is Payton Sean and I'm a fourth grader here at Woodland Elementary this past fall the student council hosted a pen scented pencil sale to raise money for fun activity throughout the year student council sold the pencils each morning before school and raised almost $300 the student council looks forward to planning the fun programs later this year thank you hi my name is James in December we helped the high school collect food and hygiene items for good new ambers every day the go wait every day the golden every day the golden can trophy traveled to the classroom that collected the most that day it helped keep the food drive going strong hi my name is miles since we surpassed our goal of
0241,000 canned goods the entire scroll earned a spear week and a fun assembly at the assembly students got to play a silly game on the stage against their teacher hi everybody my name is Hayes and the assembly games including picky up mows with cops covering their hand like reindeer H scooping up presentant bows with a spatula wall blind phone [Music] and helping teammates dress up a teacher like a snowman using toilet paper winter accessories and sticks hi I'm Cara we're really excited about what our next project is to help the school we are going to write scripts rehearse and record videos showcasing our PA's expectations the whole school will be able to watch these to see how we can be pause students and in case you don't know pause stands for practice kindness act responsible
025work hard and show respect hello my name is Chloe thank you for listening to us talk about the helpful and fun things we are doing and plan to do for Woodland before we go we want to thank the board of education for all you do without you none of this would be possible thank you for making all the hard decisions spending time in meetings and representing St Stow Monro Falls [Applause] schools so we have some cards for our board members come on down here we have right here here all the way to the end thank you guys for doing I mean this is a lot of meetings that you guys have I don't know but thank you for all that you do and supporting our students and oh over there sorry and yeah that was
026our student council and like I said a great group of kids and thank you for listening to us I'll give it back to Mr keing Miss pilot and Miss Pyon really put in a lot of effort and hard work during before school during lunch um to help them uh our fourth graders represent the students in our building so I appreciate their hard work they did a nice job um one more a way that we help celebrate the community is um our Veterans Day assembly um I we started that last year when I was here we invited uh Veterans of our students to come our choir director Mrs Emily angle puts on a program where the choir sings and also all of our students sing um these are some pictures from this year's event we had
027um about 50 veterans come and attend our program so I just love that it opens up our school to U maybe grandparents Aunts Uncles that didn't have a chance to come and see what their uh students and children are doing at Woodland so um we also partner with the local Dairy Queen for our pause student of the month lunches the local Dunkin Donuts helps us out with our pause uh our student of the month breakfast um and our PTA obviously is wonderful and they help us partner with many local community organizations so I wanted to highlight how we are working to improve our community relations here at Woodland um and I thank you all for your time this evening and um thank you while we worked out some technical difficulties this evening thank you so
028much does any anyone have any questions about anything I just want to say thank you for everything that you're doing as a staff to support these wonderful students and thank you to the students and families who are able to be here tonight um always love to see them any other any questions I also just want to Echo that the thank you especially to the students I I you know something like this is it's like it just really reminds everybody why we're here you know all of us everyone in the room and up here the table so thank you okay at this time we will take a brief recess to allow our families to move on with their evenings certainly you're welcome to stay if you would like uh but you can clear out if you
029so choose while we take a recess e e e we will come back to order at this time and apparently we put the recess at the wrong spot because we still have a lot of students here to support their staff which I love to see uh it is time for Dr G do you want to take the r all right good evening each month we recognize uh staff members and this month is January Bulldog Center Stage uh we will begin with our first staff member and that is Julie Alexander Julie is a District be board certified analyst Behavior an assistant behavior analyst Julie is always willing to help anyone everywhere with her behavioral knowledge a bus driver reached out to her for support and she immediately jumped at the chance to help she worked with
030students to create a behavior contract and discuss strategies with the driver congratulations Miss Alexander next we have Wayne KY Bus Driver Way Wayne helps out wherever needed and is always willing to jump right in and go the extra mile Wayne possesses a positive attitude and leads to to a Bright Start each day thank you so much next we have Kathy rich she Administrative Assistant from Echo Hills Kathy is the heart and soul of Echo Hills she is warm and caring with our students while also communicative professional with building visitors she is highly Adept at managing enrollment protocols and extremely knowledgeable about the tools of her trade that are used to manage building resources she has never forgotten her roots in our district as an aid in various special education classrooms her bond with students in
031our specialized resource rooms is absolutely remarkable [Applause] congratulations from Fish Creek Stephanie spatel our reading intervention tutor Stephanie is incredibly dedicated and devoted to her role and her students the professionalism and thoughtfulness in which she approaches her job T title is admirable she is always willing to assist classroom teachers in so many different ways Stephanie builds a positive relationships with her students congratulations next from Highland we have Tyler Buckwalter physical education teacher Mr Buckwalter is a teacher that goes above and beyond in everything he does at Highland he makes PE the best part of the day and the week for all the Highland students I walked into the gym saw him leap off the stage don't tell anybody that Mr buff and he was playing a game where the students needed to control their dribble
032with the basketball once he left off they knew he was coming to try and steal their basketball it got out of control and it was a delight and excitement [Applause] congratulations next we have Sally Stone educational from Indian Trail Sally works with students throughout the building all day long in Bulldog Flex groups and assisting at lunchtime Sally goes above and beyond her job to develop meaningful relationships with all the students and staff she interacts with she is committed to helping the school run effectively and to provide a variety of students support in areas of new congratulations [Applause] next from Riverview kitchen manager hul M MCO MCO I'm sorry about enough that's she here okay she see oh well congratulations we will make sure she gets her certificate but hope makes a massive difference for each
033of the students in the lunchroom she lets the students line up early if they have sensory needs and will chat with them and build a rapport while getting their lunch ready next we have uh intervention specialist from Woodland hly Holly climber Holly Holly is always willing to pitch in to help with student even the students are not on her case load she offers ideas for student interventions in the classroom for both academics and behaviors she is an integral member of the student-based intervention team Holly will plan out interventions for students brought to CIT and send the plan to all the members of the students educational team within 48 Hours Holly is always asking how can I help congratulations from Lake View Sue denol Administrative Assistant Sue is always a key piece of the communication procceed
034procedures and systems that make our school tick her interactions with teachers staff community members students and parents are always caring Forward Thinking and sincere this month like every month of the school year and Beyond requires that she wears many hats and meets the needs of many different stakeholders at the drop of a hat all while maintaining precise attention to her daily prescribed task and school office management congratulations next we have from Kempton Josh W intervention specialist Josh always has a great attitude with his students he makes adjustments when needed and is always finding creative ways to help them succeed many adults struggle with staying positive but not Josh he is a leader in the building for simply not for contributing to not contributing to any negativity congratulations and from our high school intervention specialist Nicole
035McCoy Nicole willingly switched grade levels and co- teers giving herself more co-teachers and more preps so that the school could provide direct instruction for atrisk Stu students Nicole is always bright happy positive with both students and fellow staff members congratulations and let's have a big round of applause for all our January winners picture e next we will have a presentation in regards to uh revised Fieldhouse fee schedule this was asked of the board to go and revisit the fee schedule uh that we had in place previously and so our director of operations Mark Tren will be sharing uh the RBI schedule and to talk about some next steps good evening all right there we go uh so thank you Dr gold and I appreciate the time in front of the board tonight uh to deliver
036an update with our our facilities um operations and and how we um you know how we choose those fees so when when the board asked for this feedback uh the big thing that I uh when I when I got into it I wanted to make sure that we uh did a lot of research um not only relevant to current pricing structures but also um what was the historical uh what what were the historical fees uh across all buildings districtwide so our first fee schedule uh was created that I can find was created in 2017 um that um that plan it emphasizes the use of our facilities uh for groups that are directly aligned or close to to uh our core Mission and so it provides the ability for the district to rent out a facility
037for PTA groups uh for booster clubs uh for our Athletics and so on and so forth and as as I have taken a look into this um the next phase was minor adjustments were made in 2020 in June of 2020 they added some things uh for donations uh when when certain groups use a facility uh for Ed advents um and so those those pieces came to the board for board approval in 2020 and then in 20124 in the spring our Fieldhouse uh was added to uh the fee schedule and so that's our background um when you look at fees in general the the most the biggest thing that I want to emphasize tonight is how do we prioritize who uses our facilities and what are the fees and so um we break each or we
038Define each group into categories there's categories one through five category one those are groups that are defined when you think of uh they use our facilities that that is a group like the varsity basketball team they get what's called Priority One scheduling so we need to lock in those uh those groups first priority category two um those groups are Community groups that are affiliated with the schools and what I mean by that that is that is our PTA group our booster groups um those those are clubs that may be adjacent to uh the mission but they closely align but they are ultimately um like a booster club okay um and so they are gr they are granted second priority and so again you you you go category one lock them in category two um after
039category one and then we have category three which is community groups uh that are nonprofits um and they can be anything from government agencies to um folks that have Civic mindedness and I think about a group like this would be some of our city Partners category four um they these this is when it gets into private groups and private groups they have the fourth priority uh we have actually as you go down and you look at our group structure we have the most amount of groups in groups one two and three in category 1 two and three we have the least amount in category four and we have the small amount in category five category five are for commercial users and we um that those would always be the last folks to that we would
040be able to entertain when it comes to fa facility usage so what one of the things that I one of the things that I I noticed when it came to the next steps was was we we introduced different ways of describing fees between the Fieldhouse adoption in 2024 and 2020 uh we had on on the Fieldhouse um schedule fee schedule we had a group called tier one well we don't know what tier one is that's actually supposed to be category one uh we also um had um a complimentary level on the Fieldhouse and again uh that again that more aligns with category one uh groups where we want to use uh those groups can use our our facilities for uh for free uh and so you can kind of see what what I've done if
041you look at the board the board artifact we have aligned all of the terminology uh so that was that was the that was a big um a big priority uh the next thing was taking the existing field uh fee structure and making sure that we are aligned between how we use our gymnasiums here at Woodland and how we use our our Fieldhouse time because at the end of the day um gym space is gym space uh we just need to provide the ability uh for our for our folks to use it and so lastly we wanted to review Market rates and make adjustments you know kind of check and adjust um what what we found out was in 2024 the rates that were provided uh they they were they were out of alignment with the
042market and the market uh when I when when we think about what is the market exactly it is really the lowest um there there's folks and spaces out there they can offer pretty low pretty low pricing and and so we wanted to uh be able to be uh to to compete with that and so when ultimately when we sat we discussed the feedback from our stakeholders um our job was to lower the price the prices get people in the door and then slowly work with them um as um as we develop long-term relationships but annually assess our fee schedule and bring it to the board on an annual basis and so it's hard to see on this screen right here but you guys I believe have it uh your in your packet um what we
043have done is we've taken the two existing fee schedules and we have taken it and we've put it into one one table and so that we are looking at Apples to Apples uh you can see that our Fieldhouse pricing uh for groups in category three um for a per basketball court per hour is $30 and I want to kind of highlight I want to highlight that so if you look at kton and Lake View they're 60 an hour well that's because there's two courts in those facilities the high school has much more than that so we kind of zeroed in on this idea of $30 an hour uh that would align us to not only the market but what our Fe existing fee structure was uh and as it goes up category three so keep
044in ter keep in mind those definitions Cate category three are uh groups that are outside of the SK the schools purview category four and category five are Pro profit commercial users or private commercial users and you can see you can see that there's an escalation there uh from the start to the end and the goal is to uh for folks that have that private or commercial experience is to off slot them in at at higher rates to take advantage of of you know if they're money-making profit Mak Venture and so this is kind of where we landed um there are some other adjustments that we we've made uh but you can kind of see that we don't offer a sliding scale in our k um our our K12 buildings or non Fieldhouse buildings and and
045that is we don't have a lot of usage uh from our private in our private Partners those are Boy Scout Troops Girl Scout Troops ptas um folks that are um involved in the Arts commission and so we want to kind of keep those uh at a minimum so that is kind of our our new fee schedule and I'll open it up for any questions prior to discussion uh do we have a motion to approve the revised Fieldhouse schedule so moved second questions I don't have a question but I just want to thank you um for this very in-depth research that you've put into this I think it's it sounds to me like it's going to be beneficial for both the community and our stakeholders and in the district it's important to keep our mind on
046being fiscally responsible but also keep in mind and you know our making sure we manage our partnership so thank you so much yeah Mark I have a couple questions for you um I I know that parks and wreck uses the school facilities correct yes and do they I guess short question why and doesn't the park and wreck uh have a schedule don't they aren't they like given here's the gym time and they schedule events and activities and sporting events and things like that correct in charge um why wouldn't that why wouldn't parks and wreck handle all of this just to keep it simple since they've been doing I mean who who handles this you know I do okay so you know I guess since Park and wreck has been in that business why wouldn't we
047just continue with that relationship and have one entity handling the rental of all of the school facilities yeah and so we don't want to like as a district we want to be in control of who uses our facilities and we we don't want to hand that off to any partner parks and wck they're not in charge of so how the parks and wreck piece works okay parks and recck Leadership reach reaches out to uh myself uh or actually down into the build building level they go into they go in and they reserve a space and so parks and wreck they're just like a like they're just like a Boy Scout Boy Scout Troop and so they are user of our facilties they just have historically used a lot of our gym time to accomplish their
048goals now has there been anything previous to this I mean this that other chart the bottom one has there been anything previous to this where the person was actively having to contact the school to rent a the a gym yeah yeah that from what I something we've been doing currently from what I understand uh we have it's a fairly new process that we're actually charging our charging folks for our facilities a lot of times it was hey I want to I want to use our facility there's a piece of paper that you filled out before an online portal that that piece of paper was approved by the building principal and they just utilized our facilities now this back to go to 2017 who where was that money going I mean who who was handling that
049rental back in 2017 going forward as far as for the schools the business office okay so are they coming to you to uh Reserve this or this is not occupying your time as far as it's yeah it is it's okay I it's a great well I I know it might be okay but I'm saying as far as getting best use of your time not being a um an activities fee an activities coordinator the there's a lot more Nuance to this discussion as I've learned a whole lot about about this there's a lot of nuance uh to it and our folks on the building level have a good idea and our responsibilities for them is to know what the fee schedule is but in terms of determining what that really is you need to have knowledge
050of how our operations work when the facilities are open is it a Federal holiday so there's a lot of nuances to the conversation that you really want to have one person you want to have a the the smallest group that you can um discussing this uh because uh it's a lot L well yeah because the biggest fear is you have two groups show up at the same time for sure for for thinking they both have it rented and that's why we have systems in place you know we have brightly in place to where we lock people in we have gym time we know that this group is go goes from you know from 5 to 6 and then this group is in at 6:30 and out by 8:30 now has a lot of this come
051about because of the Fieldhouse or is this something that was an issue or a problem prior to that uh this is just something that I'm I've been tasked with you know in my role since August August one from the way as I've interfaced with our Our Community Partners this is a a relatively new discussion now the one and the two um I'm concerned with one because the you'd mentioned the basketball team so you have an inseason Team all right my concern is for the preseason or the offseason Sports um is there're going to be something either through the athletic department or through your department that guarantees that those sport teams through the high school will have uh basically right a first refusal for use of the gym so so when it comes to the IDE
052Fieldhouse I'm I'm well the gyms or the Fieldhouse yeah and so I've already worked with Athletics and there there are State they they state required um their state dut and don'ts you know when it comes to how coaches can how they can interface with their with their kids during the offseason and I've worked with Athletics to define a window that considers a ramp up period before the season starts but those that ramp up period those activities have to meet a certain definition so that we don't get turned in eventually if yeah no I'm not looking as far as anything to oppose ohsa but I want to be very I want to be very clear that it that's what's these dates are driving that and so we've developed a window for an off like an a
053ramp up period that where we can ultimately give those sports teams the time to prepare and so they can get into our facilities so they will be given again kind of the right of first refusal as far as slots and then what's open then have ADD it yeah and so we we started to work through the idea of six we increments similar similar like the YMCA you do six you do six weeks so for example we have a sport right now that their season starts um on the 23rd of I believe February uh we have permitted that um that team to use our facilities no M no matter which one starting on February 3rd yeah because I'm I'm partial just to this season coming up Spring which is always a terrible terrible time for those
054spring Sports because of the weather yep and how important it is to have access to an door facility which now we have you know before it was it was catch as catch can going to Kent State going to NC Soccer wherever they could find an indoor facility of those Sports and then you you're looking at I mean you're potentially looking at eight teams when you look at track baseball with three teams softball with two teams girls lacrosse boys lacrosse um I don't know if I'm leaving anybody out tennis I don't know is is tennis in the spring is there a tennis I don't know if they use indoor but to give them again that priority as far as the gym availability and not being um limited because we're trying to rent it to somebody yeah
055and what what I've learned is this coincides with with how much we use our facilities for CB Scouts and Girl Scouts as well as uh YMCA after school programs as well as the city what what I've realized very quickly is if we give if we give the slot that slot away it's hard to it's hard to get back so our students we have to have a we have to have a balance our students and our teams have to have first priority the teams do yeah have first priority so you're going to show them the calendar here are the times you pick them and then they're good to go vers having to pick around yep and it potentially and it requires it requires those that are making those schedules to do they they're going to need
056to know this is what I think my season is going to look like right yeah some prior plan they got to take some ownership to say here's my calendar for the next 6 weeks or here here's what I would like to see this is what I'd like to achieve and then we have to you know it doesn't it doesn't matter no matter when it comes to our facilities we're always going to not have enough gym time for the 28 sports that we have it's we're not going to make everyone happy we don't have enough gym time as it is even with a new addition so but again I want to I want to emphasize that our Sports will have they are category one groups they have first priority okay and again within the Osa guidelines
057and as far as what's available um again keeping inside we still have the gym in the lower gym we just have the Fieldhouse as well so I guess in some respects I would think it should get easier but it sounds like it might be harder it's it's it's not going to solve everything but we're going to we're going to learn through this process we're going to make changes as we've gone from season to season we're going to be able to make adjustments and make this process from next year much much much more smoother well you've learned from your experience oh yeah um I think that's it and this is not for now but I would like to put it out there as to oh yeah I did have the question um when you had here
058Kempton Lake View gym it was $60 and then the Fieldhouse was 30 are you assuming that there's there there's two gyms in kton yep so think about like this right here okay so like the men's league are they going this way they're not going the full court the the The Parson wck I don't know you don't okay but that's why you're calling it two gyms because yeah yeah exactly like it's because you could technically if you were if you were not the men's if you had a men's league you can run two games in there side by side gotcha okay and then the last thing is um I would like to know uh not right now but a time when there can be some serious discussion on the 30% of the Fieldhouse that's sitting there
059with dirt great and why that's not that's not relevant to this discussion do I have other questions about the field Fieldhouse I don't have a question but I was gonna ask uh Mr TR if you could explain what brightly is just so yeah great sorry uh brightly is our online so it's a it's a it's a website that we contract with that helps us with facility usage so it's a one gigantic calendar that folks can folks can create accounts log in Access dates those dates then go into a workflow the workflow allows us to accept reject or make changes thanks I was just hoping that would help Mr to she and like understand that the scheduling is sort of contained within software as well as just being written down somewhere and it sounds like centralizing
060it away from Individual buildings helps us stay consistent with those categories and the priorities in scheduling correct is it's really it the implementation overall it this is building facil or building usage is a big puzzle in Lake View kton and the high school it's a little easier on our our our K to Fours uh but they the brightly imp imp implementation for them that's been a little bit more challenging because that's a little bit it's just kind of a little it's it's um it's easier down here uh but when you talk about trying to manage U parks and wreck on a on a Saturday you shoehorn gym time for another organization and then then you have set construction over in the high school it is a lot so Mr TR before I was interrupted I
061would like to finish my statement um I would like to know just when you plan relevant to the item on our agenda as I'm continuously interested I would like to know when that is done uh because and the reason for this our agenda this is a public meeting and the public sir the public asking about field that is not being used so I would like to know when this uh when that is when there is a plan call the role please East Jenkins I merletti I Sheen i ponic i Wind I next up we have more recognition I'd like to thank Mr TR for uh the hard work on the fee schedule thank you so much for that next we have recognition of board members this is National School Board recognition month so sorry I
062have one more before that sorry so I have the privilege of recognizing Megan postac this evening and I am going to share why we are recognizing Megan this evening Megan has long awaited this recognition it has been sitting in the white house for two years three years um Megan is receiving the presidential award for excellence in Mathematics and Science teaching this award was established in 1983 and is the highest award in K12 Math and Science teachers can receive from the US government award recipients are from represent all schools and organization across all 50 states Washington DC Puerto Rico the Department of Defense of Education activity and schools in the US territories nominees complete a rigorous application and I know it was rigorous processed to demonstrate a deep content knowledge and the ability to adapt to
063a broad range of Learners and teaching environments a panel decides who the winners are um and they are distinguished mathematicians scientists Educators at the state and National levels to assess the nominations before recomending awardees to the White House office and then from there um they are awarded this a distinguished honor and so we are greatly and proudly so proud of you um for this accomplishment uh she will be traveling to Washington DC um she will at some point we going to make sure you get there um and she uh we will be awarded uh at the white house uh and she will also be able to uh visit legislators as well as uh see all of the awardees from across all of the states so again we are so proud of you and congratulations I
064don't think it's saw Megan and I know she's brought some special guests with her tonight so we want to get a picture of her and them together oh that easy why push button um thank you very much but I reached out to the students that I had the year that I applied because they were a big part of this I had to do um a video lesson with them and so without their awesome math thinking and uh ability to reason with math and work and problem solve I wouldn't be up here so I want to invite the kids that were in my class the year I appli and I have a couple here that are in my class now so you guys can come up too and recognize them and I have little little number
065one student trophies for you too so there you go there you go and they have been very patient waiting for the oh thank you guys thanks for being here and CeCe Lula you can come up here because while this is very special my families that become family are the most important part of it so thank you very much [Applause] well done very well deserved you should take a trip to Disney to celebrate Megan you should you should go to Disney to celebrate oh these students have been so incredibly patient waiting for this moment we're going to give them a moment to escape out the door okay now it's that other item okay now we are at the recognition for school board members uh this is um School board recognition month and I'd like to read
066the proclamation that goes with this it says whereas it shall be the mission of the sto Monro fall School District to provide all students with the best possible education and whereas the school board sets the direction for our community's public schools by envisioning the community's education future and where is the school board sets policies and procedures to govern all aspects of School District operation and whereas the school board keeps attention focused on the progress toward the school district's goals and maintains a two-way communication loop with all segments of the community whereas serving on the school board requires an unselfish devotion of time and service to carry on the mission and business of the school district and whereas the school board must respond on behalf of the community to the educational needs of students and whereas
067the school School Board voluntarily accepts the a above mentioned responsibilities now therefore be it resolved that I Dr Felicia ghoul do hereby Proclaim January 28th as the school board recognition month in Stow Monro Fall City Schools I encourage all citizens to publicly and privately thank our school board members from all school districts serving this community for their dedicated service to our children so thank you thank you to all of you thank you and this evening we would like to present you with a gift um on behalf of myself and Patrick and we ask that you come up because we'd like to take a picture testing this evening all board members are receiving a portfolio with their names uh on the bottom of it along with the proclamation that I just read and also a copy
068of Robert Rules of Order for our President and Vice President for okay at this time in our agenda we invite citizens to share their concerns about items on today's agenda that will be voted on only comments on non-agenda items will be heard later in the meeting all comments must be directed to the entire board and and be no longer than 3 minutes we will listen to and consider your remarks but there will be no conversation aside from clarifying questions if you are seeking a direct response or further information we ask that you submit your request in writing please begin your remarks with your first and last name ah okay um hello my name is Faith grer as I've indicated before when I've spoken to you I'm a retired school psychologist I see that the Satchel
069pulse agreement is being voted on tonight I wasn't familiar with that program so I researched it and I must say I'm very impressed I wish that there had been a mental health tool this comprehensive when I was working in the schools research shows that mental health concerns in children and teens are increasing this system allows for screening lesson plans interventions and progress monitoring to address these concerns the screening piece in my opinion is particular important because it's not always the student Who's acting out who is in distress how many times have we heard about the quiet loner who is the one who later go goes in and guns down fellow school students and staff screening identifies troubled students who might otherwise go undetected I hope you will vote to adopt opt this essential tool for
070the sake of our students and the community at large thank you good evening Jason Whitaker I just have uh one I guess question for the board regarding item uh 12a the check register that you'll be voting on page one of the of the check register shows past due invoices being paid to the ESC of Northeast Ohio totaling just over $117,000 I don't know that this I'm going to get an answer tonight I'm not looking for an answer tonight but I would like to know as a taxpayer whether that includes uh any late fees why it was late and how late those payments were thank you okay see no further comments let's move on to the treasurer's consent agenda do I have a motion so moved second okay Mr G isn't there any discussion yeah I
071was going to say I wish to recommend that the Board of Education approve the minutes as or the consent agenda uh just the minutes so yeah that was it so it's just the minutes I'm want to know if I was missing something NOP just the minutes any discussion r e Jenkins hi Meri hi Shen hi suon hi wind hi we can move on to item 12 Treasures recommendations wish to recommend that the Board of Education approve the check register December 2024 as do I have a motion second questions I guess I just want to add to um gentleman that spoke here to get some clarity on um some of those items that were showed up as late fees or late um I don't know if they're going to be on this check register I'm assuming
072that's where it was seen um so yeah if we can get some clarity on that I mean at at some point not yeah I would uh go back and check into that it could be a couple reasons why it was um past du but I could go back and check for those any other questions or discussion well East Jenkins hi merletti hi Sheen hi sionic hi I wind I next item wish to recommend that the Board of Education approve the financial report December 2024 as presented do I have a motion so moved second all right so um very similar report that we have um as you can see on the top of the report it is all the bank accounts we have so the Dollar Bank checking Dollar Bank savings Huntington which will be closing
073uh shortly once this audit's done that money will be I've already transferred some of the money to Dollar Bank um red tree is our investment company so that money is not as liquid as the other banking accounts in Star Ohio which um we be pulling some of that money to bring back into Dollar Bank since the interest rates are roughly the same um so very in at the month end of December we had about 12 million um not all of that is liquid but you can see we earned an interest rate interest of 45,000 with fees of 608 and then on the bottom uh you see two graphs one is the total revenue so in the reddish color that was the previous year and in the yellow that's the current year in December uh same
074idea with expenditures so you're going to see that the previous year was much higher um that is because we had a three- pay month in December uh this year we had it in November so okay don't think we just spent we didn't really save any money compared to last year just that extra pay which is about $2 million roughly of um salary benefits the next page you kind of see kind of like um a cash flow it's getting the community familiarized with uh the 5year forecast um it's the same line items on the 5e forecast on the top bar you see what's in purple those are the actual numbers and then the further months out those are what we were spending last year I will start to play around those numbers to see how we
075are the trends to end the school year and then on the bottom on the right of that I'm sorry you'll see the forecasted amounts and how we compare the forecast and after that is our cash position report of all of our funds and what their cash balance are so some of the things that at least I try to do in our department I've been working with Mr Trina a lot is um our Verizon bill was always outrageous we had several with um some of our Mains who have District issue cell phone devices and we had a lot of hotspots that weren't being used and we had emergency phones that were just not really used as the intended purpose when they first were issued so I think um we were able to cut that bill in
076at least 50% um so we're constantly always trying to find ways where we could start saving money and things that we were able to control um and areas of like my department so when it comes to like W2s or 1099s that used to be done at neonet and they would charge us to do it but we do that all in house um we don't use a special paper because you don't have to we just use legal paper um front and back and me and my staff will fold stuff and mail um when it comes to checks um versus a know the district is direct deposit for all staff members and when it comes to vendors we are encouraging vendors to do a because a is much cheaper it's about 18 cents to send versus buying
077the paper stuffing the check then putting the post on it and then hoping they cash that check and if it gets lost you then have to put a stop payment on the bank which costs money and then reissue the check um so we're always trying to find ways to save the district money um so one of the other things is I take pride that I know how to do all all the jobs in my department so when a staff member is going to be going out which um one of the payroll employees are going to be going out for FMLA that we are just going to kind of pick not pick up the slack but we'll work as a team to make sure the payroll gets done versus Contracting with neonet or other services to
078come in and try to teach them our contracts and our ways of how to do payroll so we're always looking ways to save money especially my department so thank you questions yeah Patrick i s you over the questions I was going to ask here just to see what oh yes how we can kind of talk through those um the first one was uh uh explain the spending freeze rumor um yeah I I'm sorry I meant to get to that as well um so are given our cash balances as you could see our cash balances are pretty low $12 million for a district our size is kind of scary especially when you had a general fund so I think if you were to look at the cash position report for December for general fund it's $5
079million that's about two payrolls so with our cash being just pretty low I was just the spending free is true it's not really a rumor um but it was just making sure that only the essential needs to be spent we going to be spend if you didn't need it right away we're going to wait until our tax advances were to come in to help just bring in some more cash um to fill those buckets with more money um so we could make sure we could spend what we needed to for like payroll in so was any of that put off spending did any of that directly affect students no we made sure that if um if it was a need we were going to continue with it a lot of the secretaries were like hey
080we needed some paper so I asked like how much it was going to be how low were you do you need to buy all of the $2,000 up front could you kind of like cut it in half for the time being um so we did have some conversations and it was very um situational based I was like yeah we could cut it here but we might pay more later on due to the shipping charges so we worked together to make sure that it wasn't going to affect any student outcomes now has anything ever happened like this in the past that you know of not that I know of but um it's really just making sure that we are going to get our Central payments out and then with that have you now that may be
081on this financial report but um what our next 60 90 120 days look like as far as our financial stability yeah so typically we'll I think last year we started seeing our tax revenues coming in the middle of February um so we'll probably start seeing that come in probably by next Friday or the week after uh we definitely will have cash my thing the thing that I do not want to have to do and I'm going to try to push forward um is to not pull any money out of Investments because if it's not liquid we will probably be charged some fees on that but if we need to we will be doing that um 60 days we'll definitely have most likely have the freeze off and we'll be in a much better situation and
082are you looking at any kind of precautions or any type of preparation so that we don't have this come next December January so um always looking at ways to prevent this from happening but given how little of a cash balance we have each year um it's just hard because we don't we're not carrying over $20 million every single year where we have a cushion uh to prevent this from happening now this was my kind of conspiracy theorist um radar go up um this wasn't in any way to force uh an emergency Levy no um you kind of explained the late payments um so are bills being paid on time yes so a lot of times if you do see some late late payments um not late payments but past due sometimes the invoices never get
083to us uh and then the vendor gets upset so we just we're always we always pay our vendors but we just never know what happens in the middle and my last question is uh do the coaches have full access to their 300 accounts were they not affected by this um they were I would say they it would situational base as well if they if it was a dire need and they needed as soon as possible they were not affected I worked with Tammy sedor on making sure that they could have what they needed because in my understanding that 300 accounts through at least I know the athletic teams that's all money that they raise that's fundraising money so I don't know why that would have been tied into this yeah cuz it's all one pot
084of money when it comes in the end so all like all the uh funds make up that $12 million but so the so uh for the most part they would have it would have just been a phone call not the fact that they would have had to worry that they weren't going to get it correct now if they wanted to do a big purchase um like 20,000 or more we probably have a conversation of uh the dire need of it but if it was for something that they were going to States or something that needed the funds we would have made sure that was going to happen now what would inhibit that being that that was that's fundraising money that has nothing to do with money that we're waiting for from the state or the
085feds or yeah it's still all one pot of it's still one lumps it's all one pot of money so it all gets funneled into One bank account um so if the cash isn't there it's hard to say like well we want to make sure oh so these are all it's not it's really not in an individual account on paper it looks like but it's not yeah for accounting it's all an individual account but for banking it would probably be near impossible to try to balance all of these separate accounts if they were in separate Banks so federal state fundraising which is a donation come and that's all in one yep count yep so it gets it gets um accounted it's separate into the accounts on our software but it all goes into one at pot
086interesting thank you welcome is that is that something you've done or is that just past practice Yeah it's I mean it's pretty common now some districts they have um many bank accounts for various reasons might be interest rate reasons or they do keep some of their um money separate for certain reasons um I don't think St has done that in the past and it sounds like the the pause on spending that could be pushed out part of that is is simply the the cycle of the year and waiting for those tax revenues to come in where before they come in things dip yep and like I kind of said earlier if we did have a cash balance of you know 15 20 million we would not be in the situation it's just our cash balance
087is so low especially our general fund I hope we don't have to deal with this again but can I ask a favor um I'm hearing I I was hearing by this by phone calls and people asking me what's going on with the spending freeze and I have to sit there I don't I thought they were talking about the weather because it was at the same time that it was cold out you know so if we can get kind of a heads up that you know something's happening here you might get a phone call not that we didn't want to explain it to him but at least I got to say I don't know what you're talking about you know yeah that's very simple I could do that I mean yeah when I I was getting
088phone calls as well and it's the second I did I just picked up a phone call phone and asked Patrick what was going on it was it was uh yeah make sure to be head of the curve cuz um I apologize I wasn't thinking I'm sure you would have been getting a lot of emails I'm glad for the fisal responsibility thank you any other questions no okay East Jenkins I Reni I Shen i sionic i Wind I okay we are moving on to the superintendent's consent agenda yes I'd like to recommend the Board of Education approve consent agenda items B through F do I have a motion so moved second also at this time I would like to read the names and information of the donations listed in the consent agenda and excuse me is
089there a discussion on that because I'd like to pull something off the consent agenda yeah we okay um the satel pulse the D so we'd like to thank our our donors uh we have several Anonymous donors uh this time uh but we would like to recognize sto Community Farmers Market uh Mary and Don applebe uh Ryan cartright and estro machines and thank you to those who uh are Anonymous as well thank you so much for your donations so now the superintendent consent agenda is for a through C and F yeah Oh e e e as well enf just oh sorry East Jenkins I merletti I Sheen I zonic I wind I now we go to 13 D it's actual pulse do I have a motion all moved second second any questions discussion yes um I
090want to go into a little bit about what I found out with Satchel pulse um I found was disco not discovered but developed in 2011 by a uh Tech person namish go Hill um and the initial explanation of this was it was a homework communication device or a homework communication app that was then transformed into this uh learning platform um I was very concerned because of the uh a homework app and then they're talking about uh Behavior Uh seating welfare notes detentions managing attendance um implementing a behavior policy uh and that teachers can add web links so those are all kind of concerns of mine um I also looked at their goals overviewing goal goals and repeatedly they talk about seal and Castle as far as part of their framework which I'm very opposed to
091um I also found out that there and and this is a london-based company they do have an office in naville but I think it's for I don't know if it's just for maale but it's a london-based company um their main investors passal Capital Beach Equity jennis Ventures and local Globe um have no educational um app um homework or anything uh involved they don't do that they're not involved in any of that and it doesn't look like it would be something that um well they're not vested in anything to do with uh American Education um when I looked at the contract well the the other thing is we're looking at spending we're just talking about a spending freeze of 27,000 um and some dollars $27,800 we're looking to spend on this and we're just talking about
092money being tight um when I looked at um Team satchel. comom it was interesting that after July January 20th anything that had to do with secl Castle or any of the controversial uh learning methods were taken away taken off of their website so I I found that very uh interesting um so I look at this as this is a this is a company that's looking to make a lot of money they're based again in London England and that this uh particular gentleman was an IT specialist from 2008 to 2011 one of the things that I'm very concerned with anything that has to do with an app is data mining and when I looked through the contract um there were quite a few things that were very scary as far as the um potential dat data
093mining of our students and our parents information um unless you live in a cave uh to believe that they're not taking this data and using it not against our students but potentially to affect our students and students across America again I'm very opposed to uh because they have no liability if this gets hacked or or subject to any kind of what's happening with power school where data is getting hacked we have and then there there's they're based on their contract it's basically oops you know but then we have that information that's out there um I don't know because I'm not talked to a teacher but it looks like this is another level of activity that a teachers not going to be burdened with we already have final forms we already have uh parent was it
094parent Square as far as communicating homework um so those were concerns uh it says Satchel reserves the right to withdraw or amend services or functionality without notice so that was a concern um here it is in the event of security breach or suspected breach of security involving satel software or software delivering the service to the customer uh delivering the service the customer will inform Satchel immediately the customer acknowledges that Satchel reserves the right to investigate and confirms that such about such investigation um that might be relevant but again they mentioned data protection policy or regulations that they have to comply by but it doesn't doesn't um give me any pause as far as if something were to happen um they do mention here uh for the avoidance of Doubt Satchel has no obligation to the
095customer to Monitor and will have no liability for the contents of any Communications transmitted by virtue of the services so again disting themselves from any issues or problems uh they also talk about the customer acknowledging Satchel does not control the transfer of data over the internet and the services may be subject to limitations delays and other problems inherent in the use of such Communications um here under liability neither party shall exclude or restrict its liability in connection to this agreement to the extent permitted by law satel excludes all conditions warranties representations or other items which may apply to the platform services or any content words Express are implied I don't even know what that means but it looks like again they're going to distance themselves from any kind of liability um Satchel assumes no responsibility
096for the content of any third party advertisements so again my concern with when these kids are turned on to these apps and stuff we don't know what they're going to see we don't know what the companies doing behind the scenes I frankly don't trust them um they talk about furpa and Copa and that they're going to you know but then they put in here that they're just going to take reasonable steps to mitigate the risks I I would be lary of someone that's just we're going to try the best we can um so yeah a lot of red flags in the uh in the contract uh but my biggest concern is you're looking at uh parent data you're looking at children data um you're looking at extra task for the teachers you're looking at a
097$228,000 cost um there's there's too many things here that are very unsettling and um you very opposed to any more apps any more access to our information if there's things that we need to do to help the kids uh on a mental health issue I think there would be other ways that we can do it that it does not require an app to do it thank you for your um statements they have been doly noted in regards to this uh particular uh app this um is is going along with a grant that we are part of through the ESC and so therefore there are no dollars that will be coming out of general fund it is a grant that was awarded to us and several other uh school districts we have vetted this um platform
098through our legal council as we said we would do through Senate Bill 29 this is why it was on the agenda uh before and we pulled it off to make sure that it went through all of those uh parameters um we've um I've shared with the board in regards to the grant but I'll have uh Christy Pro to come up and talk more about what the grant is about and how satal pulse is part of that good evening sorry I think I turned it off um so the grant um it came about actually kind of coinciding with um the um introduction of satel pulse as an idea for our district um so we are going to have a a mental health and wellness coordinator so um they are going to work alongside our existing staff
099so um part of the purpose of of this program is to make sure that we are addressing the wide variety of needs um from our students um there's a specific targeting of students that may have um substance use issues or um have mental health issues that could lead to substance use issues so while we already have a full-time uh counselor on staff um through the Summit County ESC that addresses these she has a PHD level counselor um and I think we may be one of the only districts in the state if not the nation to have somebody um but one of the things that we have recognized and one of the things that has shown on um this the youth risk survey from the county and just I do all of our expulsions I spend
100a lot of time with the high school I spend a lot of time with our students um unfortunately um some of the drug use that we've seen has been very concerning and uh we uh want to keep our students alive and we want them um to have the help that they need um to um overcome addiction which is a lifelong struggle it's a it's a medical condition um and there's chemicals in the brain and all those things but how do we how do we have our students be healthy so um you mentioned a lot of the capabilities of satchel puls we are not using anything else at this moment other than the survey the survey is a brief survey it's much shorter than anything we've administered before um there are very general questions such as
101my teacher makes me feel welcome in the classroom um I have a trusted adult in the building that I can talk to um so um the only data that is transmitted or or stored on there um is it is going to be a student name there's going to be a unique identifier there's no parent information um but that's the only capability we're using so part of you know we're we're investing District dollars and Grant dollars into mental health and we need a way to measure that what we're doing is making a difference uh for our students and for all of our students so when you think about tiers of intervention tier one you have to screen everybody and see where we're at and I want to give a shout out to Faith that came up
102earlier and spoke um so also my background in school psychology and I know I worked with students um you don't know who's struggling until sometimes you administer some of these surveys and I know that we had a lot of controversy around our last one but I do want to share that we had a couple of students that we intervened with that was the only time that they ever said something about struggling and that they really needed some help um because they just didn't have the courage to do so so anytime we save one life it's good enough for me thank you um I just wanted to clarify real quick we're only using the survey correct and are we using only the student survey or are we also using parent and teacher So currently we're going
103to start with just the student survey okay so um you know as Mr Shen start you know referenced it is another task for our teachers and something we're going to introduce it is shorter so really it's time in the classroom it should be 15 20 minutes um it has all sorts of accommodation and Excel stability features built in for kids with disabilities so it automatically will read things it has language translation um so it'll be a little bit shorter for our teachers to administer um but we don't um we have a lot of things going on with new adoptions especially at the elementary level we do not want to add anything else to their plate right now um but we're going to get started with the platform and then see if there's anything else that
104we want to um want to use but we're going to start with the survey for now the language translation does that cover all of the different Native languages of I don't know that covers all of them it's a lot I have a list list I need to cross reference it because our languages have changed since I looked at it the first time right we get students in and out yes um is this solely for our internal use to track and keep you know keep track of our interventions and who needs help or is this part of any sort of State mandated um assessment so it is not part of a state mandated assessment but it is part of the grant so we'll report General results and Trends from our district not individual students results is
105a part of that why can't we do this on paper um with I can't imagine the time so you know and again being a school psychologist is a hand entering data um I we don't have the staff or the time for almost 5,000 students to to be able to do that um by hand will parents be given adequate amount of time to know that this is coming and they can opt out yes absolutely and and how could I would like to know what that looks like and at the point that you're going prior to that what that roll out looks like I i' I've heard things from parents that they will get an opt out form the day before or the day of something that they would have probably opted out on so I would
106like to know some type of timeline that when the parent gets it and then again is that going to be electronic or can that be a hard copy as well as as electronic as far as if a parent wants to opt out or guard or a yeah so all that communication will come from the building level and if parent needs a a paper copy we would be happy to send one home absolutely yeah we know that not everybody has access to print um but we will use the same um mechanisms we have previously but yes we want to give parents enough time to evaluate it and to opt out I know sometimes we have things that pop up um in the it seems last minute but this will not be one of those okay well
107again yeah I I'm right there with you as far as the concern for that one one child but again I'm opposed to any information that's going on in app we just don't know where it's going and I uh yeah so but thank you for the explanation you're welcome I just have one question when did you first start researching this so um we started with our school counselor group last year and our mental health committee um so we looked at a couple different options this is the one that we really um we liked the most I think some of the complaints we heard about our last survey were that the questions were difficult for our elementary students to understand this one has a sliding like Emoji scale um and the language is simplified and it's just
108administered once or is it routinely so we are uh we're going to administer once this year and then we are looking at twice next year thank you spread it out beginning end of the year kind of thing like a pre-post okay yeah um I was also looking into this a little bit more this afternoon um because I know we looked at all of these in the wellness committee but as far as remembering all of those details dets you even presented on this to us and again some of those details oops um just kind of disappeared there we go technical issues um so when I was looking into it um one of the things they came up was some of the questions um and that's I saw the teacher questions the parent questions uh some of
109the student questions that I saw in here um I believe students try hard to get good grades I always feel safe when I'm at school I feel bullying is a problem at my school I feel I get good career advice from my school I believe the teachers treat students fairly um there's so much on here that just feels incredibly valuable um for us to know about our students in order to kind of Target what we're doing with them um so I I really appreciate it uh taking another look at that yet again thank you all right thank you anything further roll call please East Jenkins I merti I Shen no ponic I wind I okay I would like to recommend the following Personnel recommendations do I have a motion so moved second any questions discussion
110nope East Jenkins hi merletti hi Sheen i ponic i Wind I next item next we have National Career and Technical Education Month with which is the month of February it's National Career Technical Education Month we have a proclamation that I would like to read in regards to um that should we have a motion first yeah I'm just do I have a motion so moved second okay whereas February 2025 has been designated Career and Technical Education Month by the Association for career and Technical education and whereas today's rigorous authentic and meaningful Career Technical education prepares young people for a wide range of high wage high skill and and in demand careers and whereas investing in the Career Technical education yields bit returns for State economies and business and industry Nationwide report increasing challenges related to skill
111gaps and the lack of workers in critical and growing CTE related fields and CTE programs to prepare students for this work and whereas Career Technical education provides students with career exploration opportunities early in their educational experience which enables them to make informed and purposeful decisions about their academic coursework and potential career programs whereas the 29 Career Technical education programs with the six District educational compact prepare students to be a career and College ready by offering programs that link secondary and postsecondary education lead to the attainment of Industry recognized credentials and provide student with real world experiences in classroom Labs internships and other work rated based learning opportunities now therefore Dr Felicia goul serving as superintendent of Stow memal Fall City School District do hereby Proclaim that February 2025 as National Career Technical education month and
112we urge all to become familiar with the services and benefits offered by our six District educational Compact and this community and to support participation in these programs to enhance prepare our students to be career and college ready discussion I just want to say I mean having gone to the open house with all of of the various programs it is amazing to see our teachers our students 29 programs a lot of them giving students multiple paths toward either further education through trade school or college or straight into the workforce some of our programs offer students the ability to work before they have even graduated and um those opportunities are amazing and I acknowledge that we have our student board member who is part of the six compact program yay okay East Jenkins I Merle I Shen
113ionic I wind I next item next item on the agenda is the public relations service agreement this is just to extend it for an additional two months uh it's already uh have been approved to January 31st but we'd like to extend that just for an additional three months before actually posting the position do I have a motion so moved second any questions or discussion yes uh you did answer one here so for two months um I guess my question is we're a public school why do we need need a public relations person why are we paying this person to be a PR person at 40 $ but why do we need a PR person why do we need that expense just think about the recent events that have just happened within our school district and
114how we want to convey that information to our staff and to our community that is public relations work how we tell our story to the public about how we are excelling uh in our goals and uh other areas and really painting the pictures so that the public understands that their the goals are being met that's public relations social media post that's Public Relation any media requests that's public relations telling our story before someone else tells our story is public relations I mean how did we do this before I'm not sure how you did it before but we've always had uh Laura foron she was serving in that position and she um resigned due to some Family Matters uh at the beginning of the year and so she has stayed on as a consultant to do
115the work but we actually need someone who is inhouse every day to do that position now is that why it's just been monthly yeah we will consider that that will be something to because that that was my next question as why are we subbing out this because I think someone who's in PR needs to be boots on the ground yes not in masselin and so right now I have taken that as a cut uh to save the district some money but we know moving forward that we actually have to have that person here now when she was here was that a full-time position or was this part of what she was that part of another role that she she served in two positions she served as the technology integration person as well as public relations
116all right so to get some clarity this is something that we're just extending based on her past employment uh it's just going out two more months but prior to that there will be uh it will be entertained that we will have a discussion about having someone uh within the district who's present on a daily basis to handle uh these items yes I would just like to we do have some interns for the ESC who are like kind of boots on the grounds and throughout the uh District uh taking pictures and videos and um helping out when Laura is not able to be here every single day so Madam chair I think it's absolutely essential that we have a full-time public relations person this is a public school and we are a public body and we
117need to communicate with the citizens what we we do and everything that is going on in their schools and I don't see how we could function as a public body without a public relations person I I agree I think probably a lot of the issues that we had in the past week we would have avoided had we had someone full-time that could have dispelled some of those rumors and those things that were going out on social media so I think the sooner we can get someone in full time the better thank you anything further roll call please East Jenkins hi merletti I Shen hi sionic hi wind hi next item we have a whole while he's setting up the PowerPoint presentation this is board policy update this will be the first reading for these board
118policies we had discussed before giving board policies within packets because of the number of board policies that we have so this will be considered as board policy packet B so I just want to go back over how we look at board policies they come through an organization called Neola and the Neola is an institution that helps really support uh school districts on how to uh review policies they are working with legal firms they work with state legislators so that anything coming out that we are aware of it uh immediately they serve 528 school districts out of the 611 school districts in the state of Ohio and our neoli associate is Joe seert uh he has attended uh policy meeting to share with us uh actually uh any information that we need or any clarification on
119any policies um that are uh we need to review what we've set up here in the packet is to show exactly the board policies uh for this particular packet they are set up to look at there are two new board policies that are coming out there are board policies that we will resend this evening there are board policies that have been renumbered there are board policies that have a technical correction meaning that it may be some type of definition or name or something of that and then we have board policies that have totally been revised so that is how uh we wanted to list those so that board members knew exactly what was in their packet I'm going to go through uh and give some short uh overview on some of the policies that you
120have uh and just just understanding that these will go through three readings in the first section policy 100 is in regards to definitions so it wanted to look at the definitions around what we call personal communication devices it will be referred to as PCD you will see that throughout the policies as well as uh President and Vice President changing uh the definitions for those there's a revision in that policy 0142 2.1 looks at the oath this is the oath of office in regarding to the bylaws regarding officers and it cross references several bylaws uh that are part of the policies uh as well the next one is policy 0151 which looks at organizational meeting and we just had our organizational meeting at the beginning of this month it really wants to look at the cross
121referencing again of the bylaw and the Really uh promotion of how to consolidate uh in addressing these uh organizational meetings policy 0152 looks at officers again U talking here uh in regards to um board officers making sure that we look at addressing the roles the secretary role which um Patrick serves as the secretary uh for the board as well as making sure that we um have have Robert Rules of Order uh when we want to uh look at nominating individuals uh and majority voting there are technical cor Corrections that happen with policy 0155 0163 and 0164 this is in regards to the presiding officers while we're talking about a technical correction about executive session another cross reference in regards to officers uh and then notice of meetings these all have been uh updated policy 0165
122talks about board meetings uh the definitions are which you formally found in the bylaws it wants to consolidate those uh which uh it references regular meetings and special meetings as well as emergency meetings those want to be consulted 01651 here we're talking about uh regular meetings 01 65.2 talks about special meetings and then 0166 so 0651 and two those will be resend it and then 0166 talks about agendas these are uh content addressing executive session uh making sure that's been re uh renumbered and moved to um the bylaw which it uh was referenced in before 01 67.2 this is a ruming in regards to Executive session and then uh 01 67.7 is a renumbering and a revision uh when we talk about the use of personal communication devices again like I said it will be
123referenced as PCD and this is uh really about District uh technology devices resending board off officers which also references one we've had uh earlier there just resending uh the term board offices is now found in the bylaw you'll see that um policy 41208 is a revision in regards to Personnel for co-curricular or extracurricular activist activities this is about the wraback system um that employees have to go through policy 1521 is the criminal history record check uh this is just making a clarification uh that uh employees must uh enroll and making sure that they have a new background check when needed student transfers this is a a revision to uh a policy and I just want to highlight this one because this has a lot to do with um um harassment that is happening to a
124student and what happens here is that uh the superintend May Grant a home educated student or any student enrolled in a qualifying school or different School District regardless of whether the superintendent's district is the students resident District the opportunity to participate in inter Scholastic Athletics at the school at the school in the district if the student was subject to any of the following by an official employee or volunteer or another student from the district or School in which the student is enrolled or the district in which the student is participating in inner Scholastic Athletics this is uh a revision to student transfers personal communication devices this uh falls under house bill 250 uh and where districts have to implement um information in regards to a cell phone policy uh that we've talked about before uh
125and now it is uh has to be in place and approved appr by July 1st of 2025 5200 uh there's a revision in regards to attendance to uh make sure that um it complies with House Bill 214 where uh schools are required to allow three religious expression days this is this uh bill here um policy 5500 is revised for student conduct uh this policy includes addressing academic honesty in regards to artificial intelligence um we have a committee that is also looking at administrative guidelines in regards to artificial intelligence uh there have been a lot of things that have come out uh from the uh state in regards to that in regards to student parent rights schools are required by Senate Bill 29 to provide parents and students with the opportunity to inspect a complete copy
126of each technology provider contract because these contracts are typically public records this was shared with parents uh during the time information was sent out on October 24th when Senate Bill 29 uh was uh enacted uh so parents already have the uh opportunity to review uh any of our technology provider uh contracts budget preparation 6220 is a revised and policy 6320 is is also revised here it gives um the district to have two options for addressing cash balances reserved and then the purchase and bidding has moved uh the threshold has moved to 75% uh and now it will increase 3% year yearly vendor relations um this policy incorporates um Senate Bill 29 and establishes the a number of restrictions and requirements for technology providers uh I have also linked there the technology contract so if you
127click on that you can see all of the technology contracts as well this is a new requirement uh that was adopted through the Senate uh on in Senate Bill 29 and and information will be released to uh the community every August 1 uh of the school year in regarding uh the requirements for us to adopt and uh allow for um to Share technology contracts 70 75301 version one and 75301 version two are both re revised one is the cell your cellular telephone allowance which uh reflects a definition in regards to this and the other is board own technology resources for communication again this is a clarification on definition for those items and policy 8310 is a revision uh public records this policy has been revised to note that the educational Support Services data are not
128included as public records as defined by 331 1932 uh meaning that this bill um the records request can be denied for anything that is cited in regards to like a third- party uh situation public attendance at school events is part of the legislation uh information in regards to House Bill 147 impacting the cost of admission at school affiliated events um making sure that they are discounted uh for students that are enrolled and regards to the next steps um what will happen here is the board will have the opportunity to review all of the policies that have been shared here tonight they will conduct three readings before a request from the superintendent for approval the policies will be updated and available through the website I've have actually taken a photo there so people can see how
129to access the policies from the website and where they are and then at the next board meeting because we have new legislation that has come into play and several new policies that have to be approved prior to April 9th of 2025 I'm sorry to tell the board members that you will receive packet C earlier than expected because you have to do the three readings on those and we want to make sure that we are in compliance with the law and those are approved before April 9th uh 2025 um any questions Madam chair um so this group that you used makes it so we don't need need to use our own legal people to REI look at these and make sure they're compliant with Ohio Revis code right we don't have to use our legal but
130our legal is very involved with the legislators uh at the state department and serve on uh a legislative board for osba so not only do we get information from uh Neola we also get it from our legal advisors as well and it's just a a information that they put out that's free it doesn't cost us uh any to receive that but Neola provides us with the templates that we need to make sure uh we are updating the policy as well as if we need to look at administrative guidelines they provide that service as well okay thank you you're welcome any further discussion okay obviously first reading we're not voting on that one but we can move on to our next discussion topic uh which is is deciding where we are going to hold our uh
131first regular meeting of the month that we have traditionally before this called work sessions uh Mr galano if you could give us kind of a brief rundown of what we have um considered and where we're at in terms of the options for scheduling yeah so when we were in discussing about having a consistent meeting location for the first meeting of the month that is not central office because of the space in the Maze to get to the office uh we U started looking with the help of Franco padulla uh reaching out to some of the locations in the city we reached out to both city um buildings um and we were looking at Monroe Falls but we I I think the the accessibility to the second floor might be an issue uh so we don't
132want to have anybody have to worry about not being able to get up the steps or find parking to get in uh so there are a couple locations um I believe we also reached out to the library as well we looked at Poss looking at technology usage making sure that our uh devices would work with um the Wi-Fi that was capable there as well as sound and streaming services so let me and I think the the times that were available a lot of them were at City Hall um and they do have a nice setup they do have a nice boardroom which helps and the times we have used that area uh presentations are nice they have a nice sound quality um and it's big to allow anybody to come and it's very easy to
133access and find but I I have to go double check but I think there's a couple days that didn't work mhm um so those days would have to be probably another a different location but for the most part all of them the rest of the year should be at the same cohesive spot I just wanted to add in one of the concerns about um using the library uh was that we could have a meeting room but we wouldn't have a provision for a room to have an executive session in um and the meeting rooms vary in size um so it would depend on the date kind of where in the library we would be um and obviously our library uh has a closing time which we would have to respect um and it is difficult
134at times to um predict how long a meeting will take with all of our thorough discussions uh so that was kind of why the the library move down the list of preferences um so we we are able to use uh council chambers at Stow City Hall for many of those meetings we do have a few where that room is not available and so the question is do we want to have those meetings at Central office if City Hall isn't available um or do we want to potentially try to reserve a room at the library um just wanted to hear everybody's thoughts is the media room at the high school potentially close is the media media room at the high school a possibility for those States oh yeah I had forgotten that we talked about that
135thank you I don't have a preference I just would like for whatever the otherc is to be the consistent other location so that the public doesn't have to guess is it central office is at the high school so that it's city hall and then this other PL very good point you have any Falls suggestions because I know we did have a preference for having some meetings in Monro Falls but with their City H being held I don't have any other idea kton so if we are able to schedule kton for all of those stes maybe that's the the preference because I would agree it's nice to have some of our meetings in Monroe Falls and not all of them in STO right um but then if we can't schedule in kmon all of those days
136maybe the media room at the high school um it sounds like there's consensus that it should be predictable uh and since we can't have one location we can have two but let's leave it at two and not have four okay great thank you our our next discussion item is to revisit our committee assignments uh this was discussed at our organizational meeting uh but since we knew that we would be adding a new board member we wanted to revisit this um Mr Gano do you have the list that you could share with us of where the existing assignments are yeah um the current lists are on the our website if you go to uh Department superintendent's office and then on the there's a dashboard on the left where it says superintendent's office if you hit the
137plus sign you'll see superintendent district committees so if you click on that uh you'll see all the uh committees and who's on that both staff and community members so the question is for our new member um are there particular committees uh that you feel you would be best suited for would be interested in serving on um the we have the mental and social emotional health we have policy committee Safety Committee technology committee finance committee um I am particularly interested in finance uh and then also safety uh I realize safety meets during the day but I'm willing to take vacation to to go to those meetings um since that's really my background I was hoping you would say that it feels very much like your wheelhouse uh so the question is of our two current board
138Representatives on safety um is anyone happy to give up their seat to allow that I'm happy just give up my seat okay and then with Finance you need yes she can have my seat on finance because I believe you're The Other Board member on finance correct okay that's fine okay thank you so we would be looking to change uh Safety Committee assignment to miss mer from Miss suon and find finance committee from Miss East Jenkins to miss mer uh do I have a motion could we health and wellness Nancy benel was on that and I don't know if oh we don't have health and wellness I was going to ask if I could join that one okay I do I sit on that one oh okay um oh I missed you on sorry that's okay
139but a second is always welcome I don't know why that's not listed here okay so we're adding and then it's the other thing on I saw on the agenda was the legislative representative that's currently me and correct or that's different than the person that goes to osba but the legislative liasis on I guess it's just as it's not really a committee but it's just a person updating and I would like to not do that anymore if anyone else is willing I just I've done it for two years I feel like if anyone else is willing I'll do it if no one else will but anyone else have a an interest in doing that not you Mr she I would be interested in doing that okay I don't want to well there was some conversation regards
140to the policy I would be um interested in that policy committee I definitely want to keep yeah I was hoping to stay on policy as well so I don't think we're seeing any movement on that at the moment Oh I thought there was an opening okay no that's fine okay does everyone have committees then okay everyone has a couple of committees okay right okay do I have a motion to make those changes so moved brok East Jenkins I merletti I Shen i sionic i Wind I thank you okay our oops our next topic is uh to discuss some of the details on our plan to fill the Stow Parks and Recreation position um I gave each of you some proposed questions um I would ask that if anybody has um suggestions uh for additional questions
141uh to let me know um by February 1st uh as that's our application deadline for that position um and the initial the original plan that we had talked about was to incorporate those interviews into our February 10th meeting rather than call a special meeting to conduct those interviews uh and I wanted to double check that that we're all still good with that that Mike would that be after the meeting in the middle of like I just just being respectful of our um applicants like how long they'd be expected to sit around like as if this evening has been a very thinging that's a really good question um what's everybody's preference on that I I have some thoughts on this and I I guess I should just throw out a motion this may either save us
142time or extend our time um but I want to make a motion the motion I want to make is to approve the retention of Patrick Crawford uh on the Stow Parks and Rec board position um we have somebody here who's on the board currently he's been a resident since 2017 he's an EMT he's a fireman he has two daughters in the district he's a part-time bus driver he Volunteers in many different communities he's been on the park board for three years and uh you would have to say the Parks have never looked better and he was personally recognized and praised by the city council and I think it would be a disservice to the time that he has put in uh irregardless of anyone that may want this position that we just go ahead we're
143already a month behind we're looking at potentially two months behind as far as when this was to be renewed so to reiterate my motion I'd like to make a motion to approve the retention of Patrick Crawford on the Stow parks and wck uh board position do we have a second okay I'm not seeing any any other feedback in terms of interview time I mean I think if we could do it I do think I want to be you know careful about like scheduling a bunch of interviews in the middle of a meeting either and making anyone else that's sitting here I don't know I maybe a special meeting is the best way to do it I don't know what does anyone else think I think we should do the interviews first so that we can
144just do it and like you said be uh respectful of their time so that if they want to leave after that's over we can continue with our business okay I'm fine with that do we want to leave the start time as 6 PM or do we want to bump that to 5:30 or 5 in order to account for some of that interview time I I think that we should leave it at 6 I think it's difficult for people that work to get there in time I think six o'clock is reasonable I'm seeing a lot of head knots okay okay so the plan will be to uh do interviews at the beginning of the meeting on February 10th starting at 6:00 um the applications are due on February 1st um we will each get copies of
145those applications by end a business on the 3 assuming that franka is at work that day um could be another day um but well before our February 10th meeting then um and again if anybody has any other uh suggestions or requests in terms of the proposed questions just let me know um and we can go from there any other questions concerns discussion on that I mean I think I would just like to to say to uh respond to Mr Sheen's um idea that we should just keep someone I do think that we need to respect the process and if Mr Crawford is the best person then you know I have no problem voting for him I think that it's just the you know we haven't made any um exceptions in any other um things that
146we've done so I don't see any reason to do it now thank you okay our next topic for discussion is um public participation and I uh put a copy of the policy at everybody's spot this evening um one of the things that uh has happened over time with different boards is that there are many ways to stay within our policy on public participation uh while also having certain structure uh the structure of having the two comment periods was new while I was on the board a few years back uh but now we have a different board and I was hoping to get some ideas Impressions uh from everyone on whether you feel having the two comment uh times during our second regular meeting of the month is working if we want to retain that procedure
147um and also then how we want to address public participation during our first regular meeting of the month uh and whether we would want to handle that in the same way or in a different way with dis respect for I'm not King sure that I'm not going out of order with what I'm talking about but I uh this kind of brings up about that the work session versus regular meetings come at but like past practice has been that since I've been on the board and since I've paid attention to the school board uh past practice was that the first meeting of the month was a regular meeting or was a work session which according to the law is a regular meeting but was defined as a work session which um was basically intended to be
148um for the board to have deeper discussions amongst themselves and not do things such as vote um on unless it was something you know more emergent but not do things um you know that are just not handle traditional business that it was more like to work um and I don't know if considering going back to that um would help this discussion at all instead of just sort of having two meetings all the time I I don't know if if along the way it's been lost or or what I think on yeah one of the things that happened I think when those work sessions were instituted was that was not defined in our bylaws and our policy as to what that con instituted and what what that that meeting was supposed to look like um so
149yes that is the other option for the first meeting of the month is to um just firmly Define that and set that as in policy different from our other regularly scheduled meetings I would be in favor of investigating that before we start changing practice on public participation just because then we are you know where we um kind of know exactly what our expectations are and I know that like when I first started attending board meetings they were uh the work sessions were always at at Co and it was always a little bit more quiet um there was never po public participate part easy for me to see participation and um I think you know I just want to see if we can Define some of those you know Define what that meeting is rather than
150just you know continue down the path that we are I don't know what anyone else thinks well first I would like to have these meetings maintain the same protocol I think more opportunity to let the public speak you know you don't have newspapers you got to rely on you know social media which is always um um you know it's it's not reliable um it um can allow things to get misconstrued misunder tood so the public has that opportunity to ask that question and I believe frankly for the other meeting there should be at least one opportunity there for the public to speak uh again we're talking about a 70 to 75 million business and uh you're talking to your your you're talking to your stakeholders you're talking to your uh you know your um people
151that are paying for that and they should have a voice um and we should expand that not limit it any other thoughts just if we're going to have a work session where we're not intending to take a vote then I'm okay without having comments but if we're going to take a vote I think we need to give the public the opportunity to speak and try to not have the this is an emergency we need to vote on this today but that may not just be able to happen unless we're going to allow for comments well we could if we're defining things and we could potentially add that um should there be a vote added that a public comment is added as well that's true we could we could kind of do a both and kind
152of thing we can Define work meetings and set it up that um if votes are to be taken that we include public comment time but if it's presentations and discussion among the board only that it wouldn't include include uh public participation time that would be an option well that way we're at least we're adding I mean if if today we're doing nothing it would be adding because as of today we're doing no no public comment and then sometimes voting which I know actually to be I mean past practice there has always been voting to my when I looked back at every single agenda it never really did go the way of no voting it looks like um that being said if we actually Define it that way and adopt that process we're not keeping anybody
153from speaking during a time when a votes are going to be happening ever it would potentially add that opportunity should it arise so if we're if we're thinking about adding public comment then to the that first regular meeting of the month um it sounds like it would we would want it to be at the beginning of the meeting or would we want to split it into the two sections I don't know what the purpose of the I wasn't part of it what was the purpose of dividing it instead of I mean like I when I first started you know attending meetings it was always just one and I wasn't sure what the purpose of the two is initially when it was just the one SE public participation session it was at the end of the
154meeting um so some of the discussion as far as I recall around splitting it up into two was to allow folks to express their concerns or ask their questions and for the board to hear from folks prior to taking those votes and having those discussions um and then letting the just you know other things comment section be at the end um but the the primary um reasoning behind that separating it into two sections was so that the board could hear from folks prior to discussion and voting okay that makes sense then yeah if it was going to be adding a vote it would or adding public comment then it should be right if we were consistent with that it would we would have to add public participation at the beginning or we would have to
155have the two sections again and I know for me typically those first meetings of the month are a little bit shorter um and I would rather one comment section than two for those um is that a is that a possibility to just only have it should vote be added that is that that could be something that we could look at adding into policy um because the way our policy is written it says public comment at all regular meetings so if we wanted to change that up Define what a work meeting is and lay that stuff out that would have to be a change in policy um so you know we we would have to talk with legal counsel and uh make sure that that's possible uh but I believe it would take a revision of
156policy three readings to get us there Dr gold do you have any input on how other districts manage public CIT it varies across um the districts uh some of the districts only have one meeting a month so there's always public comment some do it like we do uh current currently uh and some speak at both um meetings so it just varies I just like did a survey across our six Compact and it VAR on the was I think too we're getting cloudy here work session is just a word it's not it's not anything uh it's a meeting it's a regular meeting so we should have that opportunity because a a a person may have something else that they're concerned with they might have a question not necessarily something on the agenda so they should be
157given that opportunity to do that but to get wrapped up in work session versus regular meeting you have regular you have special you have emergency that's it work session maybe that's some we started I don't know but yeah I mean I don't know if it's we started it like but I or somebody did but you would yeah yeah it's it's not uncommon to keep it simple let the people talk you know they got something to say let them say it and as I was looking at all of this um with which you know uh started months ago um we don't have that work session phrase defined in our bylaws um I believe we could if we wanted to write that into policy we could um nail that down a little bit more but again that
158would would mean bringing a policy Revision in front of the board right well I think because it was never defined now but then that does bring back into the the discussion then if if every meeting is just a regular meeting not just legally but just as in practice as well we're moving around like for schools for our regular meeting like we would still need to have some kind of not necessarily policy but some type of procedure procedure that we follow of what goes at what meeting because right now we have the second meeting of the month is when the the pr the building reports the principles you know give their their you know speeches and we have students you know that's of best things of the meetings I think and and I don't know you
159know do we still just Define it as you know procedurally we will do you know maybe still have our staff presentations at the first and second would be like the student I feel like that's a a topic that we could add to our February 10th agenda is more discussion on how we want to use those meetings um and make sure that we're all on the same page on that okay didn't mean to like you know get off topic but it just seemed like if we're going to talk about it's definitely a related topic for sure we're going yeah if we're going to handle public participation I think to Mr Sheen's point if if they're exactly the same then the public participation public participation is exactly the same if they're different then I can't see if
160they're different then maybe they're different and until we answer that we can pause this yeah okay I mean we don't have a vote schedule on it tonight I just wanted to um discuss it and um feel every how everyone uh was feeling about that given the fact that you know those two comment sections aren't written into policy that's procedure that the board adopted and that was a lot of board members ago uh so I wanted to make sure our current board uh could weigh in on that any other thoughts on that it sounds like everybody's leaning toward the keeping the two comment periods I actually don't understand why there's two yeah um you know I think I like the idea of having people speak at the beginning if they have questions about the agenda items
161before we vote I'd like to hear people's opinion uh but I I don't understand why we have to split it up into two sections so you would lean more toward just having the one public comment period right the beginning and have them you know voice or concerns things that are on the agenda things that we're going to be discussing at the beginning of the meeting um although at this time we didn't even have anybody speak the second time so I you know I know we haven't gotten to the second time yet oh okay sorry I uh I don't know I've never seen two yeah ever so right it it could also be a possibility to just do one comment section at the beginning from from what I remember from that discussion and it's offhand I
162haven't gone back and and watched it again um the the concern was that sometimes public comments kind of ran long and when we changed the policy around public comments one of the things that happened the last revision was that we removed the 15minute time limit on public participation uh because before it was a 15minute time limit unless the board voted to extend that period of time uh so that provision was removed and I think some of the concern was well you know sometimes there's a lot of people who want to get up at the mic and that might prevent us from moving on to some of that business getting some of it done um if it's just however much time everyone wants to take up well the I just took that state training last Saturday
163and way thank you for making time for that so fast um there in that discussion they mentioned the 3 minute time period that we currently have uh they suggested a 30 minute time frame for public comments just for that reason like you said that you can then continue about the business of the board and um they felt that um 10 people uh was adequate to get U people's questions across but that was just a suggestion it wasn't uh anything that was written in stone but that was what they um had presented in the [Music] training yeah that would also be an option because again we have a we have a different board makeup and we can choose that procedure if we wanted to put a time limit on it that would be a policy change
164but it might be one we might want to consider I I would like to explore further what the state recommendations are uh because you know obviously want we want to be as open and transparent as possible but we also do have uh agenda items that we have to get to so that is a good point about if you have it in the beginning then at what point do you get to the meeting which technically could already happen now I mean if there was 30 people lined up to talk about an agenda item it could still happen today so yeah that's true so we have some further research discussion to do on the potential for policy changes um we can continue this discussion at our next meeting um in the meantime I want to make sure
165we're complying with the policy so you know in the in the meantime until we figure out any potential policy change uh I'm thinking the two sections of public comments at both of our uh regularly scheduled meetings uh while we consider this um and also that gives us a chance to give it a try Tri too and see how it goes that'll give us some time to research a little bit too yeah okay great should I make a motion to table this it's just a discussion it's just a discussion so okay okay thank you um okay our next agenda item would be our added one f um of talking about agenda setting uh so I would like to start this conversation with uh quick policy review uh policy 01651 on regular meetings which is one of
166the ones in our packet coincidentally but our current policy uh explains that uh regular meetings of the board shall be public and held at least once every two months the time of such meeting shall be fixed at the organizational meeting it shall be the responsibility of the superintendent in cooperation with the board president to prepare an agenda of the items of business to come before the board at each regular meeting the agenda of the regular monthly meeting or special meetings shall be accompanied by a report from the superintendent on information relating to the district with such recommendations as he or she shall make each agenda shall contain the following statement this meeting is a meeting of the Board of Education in public for the purpose of conducting the school's business we all heard that earlier
167then um the agenda for each regular meeting shall be mailed or delivered to each board member so as to provide proper time for the member to study the agenda um I'm going to skip a sentence there uh item D here the board shall transact business according to the agenda prepared by the superintendent and submitted to all board members in advance of the meeting the order of business may be altered and items added at any regular meeting by a majority vote of the members present there's more to that but in terms of putting items on the agenda that's what our policy speaks to um and then I was hoping you could read the procedure that we had discussed um during our August board Workshop Retreat however we want to say that um and then we've discussed
168that at several meetings since but I was hoping you could kind of refresh everyone on that piece sure um the agreed upon board meeting agenda process States the draft agenda will be available by Monday a week before the meeting um it will be reviewed and send any review it and send any changes or additions to the board president by email by 6m Wednesday before the E meeting the board president will review the board member's request to add an additional item based on it appropriateness and either add it to the agenda for the next work session or to the agenda for the next regular meeting or decline to add it it is there responsibility of the board member asking to have an item agenda item added to the agenda to provide all the necessary information including
169any attachments at the time of the request the agenda item the board president will consider the following while determining if that item should be added to the meeting agenda what is the current board policy has this already been addressed is there policy or procedure in place for this are we in compliance with board policy or do we need to make a change then what is the current District practice how are we what are we doing now and how is the current practice not effective then who is who in the district have you consulted who will be affected responsible for this has one of the superintendent commun committees reviewed this should we have this staff person present to answer any questions or provide more information and the next one is how is this a board issue
170how is it related to governance vers operations is there a proposal ready for the board to consider is this ready to be a recommendation to the board by the treasurer or superintendent then the next line goes on to an agenda review meeting is held on Thursday morning prior to the meeting between the board president board vice president superintendent and Treasurer to finalize the agenda board members have the opportunity to review the finalized agenda in draft form on board Doc before it becomes pop public at 2m on Friday while there is still opportunity to change it the agenda then becomes public at 2m Fridays no changes will be made to the agenda after it's made public unless there's an absolute necessity to do so if that happens a board member all board members will be notified
171by text and email immediately the agenda can be amended during a board meeting with a motion which must be seconded and approved by the majority vote a member can request to have items pulled from the consent agenda and considered separately at any time no motion or vote is needed and that was what um then president president Nancy Denzel had put together based on our um August board meeting and then the next couple of board meetings um which is friend you know then I think went to Legal after that and then the formalized document was pretty that and I want to also add in that um I ran this by our new legal council as well uh the process that we have just to have that extra step to double check that the process is um
172adhering to our existing policy and not in conflict with it in any way um and legal council said that uh our process is up to us and as we have established it it is currently consistent with our policy as it stands right now I wanted to offer some other information that I um from osba on agendas in general um it does say that um Can a board of education amend its agenda once it's been released to the public and then it goes on to explain the purpose of posting or sending an agenda in advance is to provide members with information so they can prepare however it is a suggested outliner structure for the meeting and generally may be amended unless it goes against the board policy board should be cautious when modifying special meeting agendas
173to ensure they fall under the purpose under Robert's Rules of Order if the board does not adopt the agenda at the beginning of the meeting only a majority vote is required to amend the agenda if the board does adopt an agenda at the beginning of the meeting a two-thirds vote is required to change the agenda um so then I mean it goes on to explain that you know I think one of the questions was that we aren't adopting agendas and it is absolutely not required um that's um you know it's over and over in parliamentary procedure and up from osba it's a suggest question you can do it you don't have to do it um and we're definitely in compliance why not okay any questions comments yeah I think you guys are just making a
174bunch of stuff up to fit your narrative um you just read this whatever they discussed in osba where is that in policy where is that in statute where is that in orc where is that in niola uh um literally read the policy and what is that policy number where where is it do I can I get a copy of that or or can you can you refer me to the polic to the policy number I gave the number when I read from it it is policy 0165 and so that policy just so it's out there is stating that a board member has no influence participation or any type of of uh involvement in the in setting the agenda or um putting a putting an item on an agenda specifically States it shall be the responsibility
175of the superintendent in cooperation with the board president to prepare an agenda of the items of business to come before the board at each regular meeting well responsibility to me means okay that person is responsible for preparing it not for controlling what is on it I mean again nothing there's nothing in any policy that gives the board President veto power on an agenda item and so so it ends up being uh then why do we need five board members if if a board member cannot bring something to the board or or have to go through so many hoops and jump through so many um hoops and go over so many um why isn't that discussed here it it's yeah you you can keep on doing what you're but we're not adopting the agenda which is
176against our policy you're not allowing a board member to um to have any input in the agenda adopting the agenda is not in our policy as far as I am aware well we're supposed to follow Robert's Rules of Order and that is in our in our policies and our and Roberts R ofis is adopted and osba said the same thing that that that she Cheryl suggested that you adopt your agenda before but she also said it's not required I hear you're playing with word again this was this I'm speaking this was entirely uh developed to try to keep me from participating and in offering anything to the agenda you can call it whatever you want but uh so you're doing your best to continue to do that because again you cannot give any state statute
177orc statute that says that the board president can an item from a board member to get on the agenda there's there's nothing that states that says the board President says that this board member has to follow these 10 steps before they can get something on the agenda there's nowhere that it says that I can tell you that an osba it says there is no legal requirement Ohio in Ohio that requires Boards of Education to even use an agenda nor is their language in the orc that discusses how they are prepared or amended so then that would go to our policy which states how our our agendas are prepared which it's very specifically States it's prepared by the superintendent with the assistance of the board president and that if we uh any board member at the
178at the meeting has the ability to make a motion to add something to the agenda that is following our policy to a te okay you want to go with that go ahead I have a suggestion for us to uh consider revisiting this topic Toc at our next board Workshop um and have further discussions about the protocol um we developed that in order to clarify our process we've now used it for several months um I feel like that would be a really good topic to dig into at our next board Workshop Retreat uh to really uh think about all of us do some research on um and put together our thoughts and talk about our options around the procedure I mean frankly being an elected official I don't see why anything that a board member want
179would want to bring to the board agenda would be something that would have to be contentious or that I'd have to fight for it's like what are you afraid of you know I'm bringing things to the board and and and maybe it doesn't cover all the cross all the do or dot all the eyes and cross all the tees but you know what I that's why I'm bringing it to the board any but I would certainly entertain that because sorry I was speaking do we have any I apologize or questions I think if we're going to have this Retreat we probably need maybe our legal team or some outside entity to speak to us about it because clearly we have different opinions on what is actually um we're supposed to do I I hear what
180he's saying about wanting to add an item to the agenda if we adopt the agenda then it requires a two-thirds vote to get it added if we don't then it's just half so it's easier to actually add things to our agenda if we don't adopt it in the beginning which is why a lot of boards don't do that so that you don't have to have four of us to agree but either way I think we need to explore it with someone that can give us a definite answer some expert advice agreed okay seeing nothing further uh let's move on to our second uh public comments period I'm going to repeat myself uh at this time we welcome any additional comments and concerns citizens wish to bring before the Board of Education all comments must be
181directed to the entire board and be no longer than 3 minutes we will listen to and consider your remarks but there will be no conversation aside from clarifying questions if you are seeking a direct response or further information we ask that you submit your request in writing please begin your remarks with your first and last name all right good evening Jason Whitaker in November after receiving Community feedback the board discussed its approved Fieldhouse F fee schedule members seemed surprised that pricing was noncompetitive but an administrator later wrote that he'd been trying to get the board to revise those fees for months tonight the agenda included the item revised Fieldhouse schedule the board voted on that without public comment this new schedule goes farther than the Fieldhouse however and makes significant changes to renting other District
182facilities these changes will impact organizations throughout the school district previously boosters booster clubs in the ptas were treated like student organizations on rental fees with no pump circumstance or even discussion this board just changed that policy by moving ptas and boosters to category two those groups are now subject to hourly fees by using the Fieldhouse fees for events and other buildings under certain conditions and donation billing by the district for instance the new feed the new fee schedule seems to permit the district to charge donation billing to the band boosters for their annual band show because it is a weekend non-school event for which they charge admission board policy 7510 actually vests administration of these fee schedules with the assistant superintendent and not the director of operations administrative guideline 7510 a States the district the
183use of District facilities for activities related to the educational program and District Operations shall be without cost to the users except that the users shall be responsible for any police fees it's also unar clear as to where many local groups fall within the new structure each organization directly supports the district in one way or another but there are no threshold or matrices to establish where they go as far as groups two three or four lastly fin uh prior fee schedules were silent on after school activities like tutoring music lessons that happen on these facilities none of those people fall under groups two three or four and so now they're going to be commercial users under five the fees of the district's going to charge them are more than they're charging the students those students benefit
184greatly from those Services if the board had intended to change facility structures anywhere but the Fieldhouse it really should have noticed that in its agenda explained that to the community and had a discussion on that instead of just doing it without any discussion whatsoever asking the board to be transparent intentional and diligent in its activities is not political nor is it unfair none of this should have happened and I do hope that this board clarifies that the PTA and the boosters are not going to be subject to these fees particularly donation billing because that would that band show since I have a few seconds left on the spending freeze the board's projections in September actually showed it worse for January and February and for months there was no discussion with the community about a 60
185or more day freeze and to tie up in any way kids fundraising money is reprehensible okay seeing no more comments I will entertain a motion to move into executive session uh for a purpose to consider the employment of a Public Employee or official under G1 so moved second any discussion roll call please e Jenkins hi merti hi Shen hi suic hi wind hi we are in at 8:59 p.m. e e e time is it we are back from executive session at 9944 okay uh I will now entertain a motion to adjourn so moved second roll call please East Jenkins I merletti I Shen i sodic i Wind I what uh we are adjourned at 9:4 be fine