CorpusRecord 67500

SMFCSD Board Meeting 2024-12-30

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Stow-Munroe Falls City School District
Date
2024-12-31
Location
Summit County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,704 words · about 27 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I call to order this meeting of the stowman row Falls City School District Board of Education Monday December 30th 2024 special board meeting uh just a quick note that I will be the presiding officer for this meeting in accordance with our bylaws which state that the president shall preside at all meetings of the board in the absence disability or disqualification of the president the vice president shall act instead um roll call please yeah it's at 5:00 pm oh I forgot to say the time you're good East Jenkins here Shen here Su adonic here wind here bsel please join us in the Pledge of Allegiance everything we do is designed to provide a future ready student- centered learning experience for every child our strategic plan for 2021 through 2026 will help usom accomplish this goal by

002considering every facet of a student's learning experience from curriculum to infrastructure to Wellness diversity and inclusion and everything in between as members of the Board of Education we serve as trustees therefore this is a business meeting being conducted in public not a public meeting we are grateful to serve an Engaged community and therefore encourage and respect input from citizens we expect that everyone present will behave in a manner consistent with the behavior we expect of our students we reserve the right to have those who do not comply removed from our meeting okay our first item of business a accept the resignation of a Board member Miss Nancy binel effective December 31st 2024 do I have a motion so moved second uh any discussion just it's December 31st I think he I think he said 21st

003but yeah December 31st yes December 3 31st at 6 at 6 p.m correct okay that is what the letter States any further discussion I just want to um extend our thanks uh from the board and as a community member uh to miss Benzel for her service on the board to the community it's been quite an interesting five years that that she was here with us that's for sure roll call please East Jenkins I Shen i zonic i Wind I okay Item B believe that's yours yep wish to recommend that the Board of Education approve the settlement agreement as presented do I have a motion I motion second yeah any questions discussion I see that it was a 350 excuse me $325 and then A500 what what of that was um paid through I guess our

004insurance company's Liberty Mutual and what was paid by the district yeah so the the [Music] 325 IS that's paid by um our insurance and then the district is liable for the $1,500 and any further discussion okay roll call please East Jenkins I Sheen i zonic i Wind I okay our next item of business is to take a look at the date of our organizational meeting uh so for reference we have our proposed dates uh for next year um and our organizational meeting as it stands uh right now is scheduled for January 13th our legal council has suggested that we bump that up earlier so that we're not trying to do the organizational meeting and potential board me member interviews um too close together and all at once uh I would say I would propose Monday

005the 6th if that would work for folks it's all right for me work for me okay Mr gano can you see if the auditorium would be available or will we have to yeah um we could do that as tenative location and then I'll check on Thursday if that's available did you want kton or High School uh our original one was scheduled for the high school yeah I'll check for that I think that first yep and then um at the meeting notice I will inform the of the location as well okay so tenant of High School auditorium Monday December Monday January 6th 2025 okay soe do I have a motion to approve that meeting date as described so moved second any discussion roll call please East Jenkins I Sheen I sud donic I wind I okay

006thank you uh our next item is to discuss our our board vacancy uh replacement process so I wanted to for all of us to discuss kind of how we would prefer that the application and interview process goes we've done it a number of different times over the past few years uh so I just wanted to open up that to discussion if anybody has any beginning thoughts I did like the um just having them all in one night um and having people sign in as a to trying to schedule everybody in just because it can be complicated depending on how many people want to apply so I would be for doing it all in one evening with the signs okay anybody is it possible to maybe look at that again based on how many because that

007last time was 19 people and it was like four hours so if we were to get 25 you know that would be a a long evening so correct and I don't know how we would split them up but just for the convenience of the people I would hate to be the last person who had to sit through 19 or 20 interviews and then um again just for our time um but maybe revisit that once we see how many have applied I think in terms of us being able to put it on the schedule and give everybody the information we have to really decide ahead of time when those interviews are going to be because that information is typically included in our announcement so that folks who apply know when to expect their interviews so uh

008could we potentially put two and like a to G and H to Z you know as far as that and then if we if we don't get that many we can always take away that second date I'm just Leary if we get a a large turnout right are we going to ask for materials ahead of time that's another piece of question I think that might shorten the the time frame if we have had time to prepare absolutely agree I think last time one of the things that you know we did spend a good five to 10 minutes with each candidate just reviewing their materials and speaking about you know some questions that we could answer ourselves just by reading through ahead of time that would help uh expedite I think the evening itself um is

009pro providing in advance we also have a number we'd also how many people then if we were requiring it to be turned into ahead of time we're working on a bit of a tight deadline [Music] when when do we want materials turned in by I mean I would agree that it would it it will save us a significant amount of time in terms of interviews if we have materials ahead um the question is how much ahead we want to ask for that so we'll have to figure that date out too I'm okay with doing two nights if that's a sticking point for you like you know that's no it's not a sticking point it we'll just see how many we get I mean I prefer to just make it one night yeah me as well

010I yeah it just would make sense if we do get right and I think what part of what we can do as a team um is take a minute before we start the interviews and and look at how many people we have signed in and make some decisions about how much time we're spending with people what are our most important questions so that we can really Focus those interviews because we are we are stuck by board policy interviewing all people who apply um so we can't sort through them um and invite some and not others but we could potentially um work to figure out what a reasonable time limit would be that evening based on how many people have shown up and how many questions is there value and even in the announcement stating what

011the process would be you fill out the application you have to turn in a resume May and that the interview process may be 10 minutes so they kind of know ahead of time that we're yeah going to have a 10-minute it it'll be a brief interview yeah yes we can we can definitely set that expectation typically with our announcements it outlines you know application materials where those are to be sent um what the due date is and then what the interview date is and and when we've done the sign in for interviews and you'll be interviewed in the in the order that you sign in that information has been included in the announcement as well so that folks know what to expect out of that process and so board policy or uh orc States it

012has to be 30 days after so we have to within 30 days within 30 days okay so do we have an idea when we would like to do the interviews I mean I was thinking between the organizational meeting and our regular meeting in January okay um like the 13th maybe or the 20th well no we can't do the 20th that's a holiday um well the 13th was already on the calendar right you want to just leave that as the interview day and maybe do the 13th and 14th like if we're going to do two maybe they back to back so that it's the same week um I mean I really lean toward just doing it one night getting it over with the only thing I would think about is if we are opening it for

013two um I don't know that we would be able to necessarily condense it because if some people sign up intend to come on the 14th and can't be here on the 13th or vice versa we might even if we only had five people still be split between two nights I don't know that right I don't know a way to word it such that it would only be one night unless we had too many so I don't maybe that's too hard to do I don't know yeah I think that's part of why I'm leaning toward just doing it one night okay oh and there was one question last time people asked if they would be able to do a zoom I think and I did want to make discussed it just a question didn't anticipate having

014to deal with it again but here we are and I do remember that being a question from the public and being that we'd already announced I don't think we could have changed the process but I do know that had been asked by at least one person before okay I don't know how anybody else feels about that it's a good point I remember it now that you mention it I don't know if we can um do interviews yeah there's we could make accommodations for that okay if you would like to do that I just I don't know if we should or not right if we're doing if we're doing sign in how would someone sign in true and I'm definitely leaning toward the signing in and doing folks in in the order they they appear because

015we've had it before where we've scheduled interviews and then we've been occupying ourselves because someone cancels it the cancels that time or can't you know changes their mind or whatever and then we're spending time just waiting for the next thing that's scheduled and then just to cover our bases I would like to reach out to legal to see if that's okay thing to do um that we're not breaking any ohar ohar VIIs codes or anything so you can just decide not to if that's the if that if we lean towards that anyway I just want to make sure that we've discussed it at least because it it was an it was asked yeah I don't know do we either of you feel strongly either way I mean if it's something that somebody needs if it's

016something that somebody needs and we can accommodate that I would be in favor of that but yeah determining when that person would would uh when we would turn on the computer to do that interview might be something that we would have to figure out whether that person might be the last person or probably not necessarily the first so yeah we could say you go after everybody else that signed in in person right I if the meeting is on um scheduled board meeting day I would be concerned that you can't be present in person like if for interviewing on a day that is a typical board meeting day I would think that you would be available on the Mondays that's a point true I mean if it comes to that too that could be part of

017what we then look at is this is this person going to have difficulty attending the meetings and so that person may not be a viable option as far as someone we would look to correct give this opportunity to so agreed okay so definitely Monday the 13th is what I'm hearing um do a signin process that day in order to determine the the order and the times of the those interviews what time on the 13th 6 honestly I just was yeah assuming 6 PM although does that I'm just ler because I don't we don't know how many because then if we did get a lot and we do them on one day then five might be better um because if you can't get here at 5 you can still come L yeah you're still coming and

018signing in right that's the other point we had we had sort of a cut off date for or time for the sign-ins last time we could make the cut off like 6:15 or something so that they add up till 6 to get here even okay yeah cuz I'm thinking if might take people some people some time and our our meetings this past year have typically been at six so giving folks until until 6 or 6:15 to sign in yeah yes that works for me okay but a five o'clock start time so then is it reasonable to ask for the resumés sometime next week right that's the that's the tight timeline we're on I'm I'm wondering if we make those resumés due by the 6th when we're all in a room together um and have those

019for everybody that night uh that only gives people a week we still have to get the word out explain the process the wording of the announcement I think um we might want to go through legal if we're thinking about whether virtual is or is not okay um that feels really fast to me especially with the holiday in there yeah um would what about Friday before the interviews giving each of us the weekend to prepare I could manage preparing between the 10th we close a business on the 10th we'd have the 11th the 12th and then I'll day the 13th I was even thinking like maybe noon on the 10th so that those could be cated and sent out to us that day yeah I would say either I would say either noon on the 10th

020or like midnight on the 9th um so that we can have them on Friday right and wouldn't a resume be in be included yeah that's I mean I'd like to have that included that's the not have them bring that with them that night yeah that's another question right what materials do we want to seek from applicants um a letter of interest and a resume I think have been typical we've also used the osba format before um and found that kind of cumbersome and not exactly addressing the things that we um wanted to look at I know where did I put that it was in the former process stuff that we did um we have before done the osba application we've done um a letter of interest and a resume or CV uh making sure that

021we collect name address phone number email why you're interested in serving and what skills you bring a list of community engagement activities both paid and unpaid um and uh we need to ensure I I believe that people attest to the fact that they are at least 18 years of age and a registered voter in our school district because those are the minimum qualif appliations legally for a seat on the board so I mean we could go back to that osba application that I sent to everybody or we can just kind of make that list like we did previously and use that for our request take a look at that again we did have like one or two of our most important questions that we have them answer in advance in writing that way it could

022help WR that process too is that's that's a good question um maybe just like three questions or something we we tended to have the same ones yeah previous interview questions were listed in that document that I wrote up that might give people a chance to to uh answer more thoroughly as opposed to trying to rush through an interview too right and that could assist us in focusing our interviews on any sort of followup that we need or clarification that we need I mean not to give everybody an essay contest but um allow folks to take the time that they need to explain why they're applying and what skills they bring to the process how their experience speaks to that that kind of thing yeah I'm trying to find the just from the last interview right

023here okay okay I mean I don't think number four is all that no but I think just asking one two three and five in advance what do you think I don't know just an idea no I like that idea allows us to focus our interview time yeah yeah it starts so you said one two one two three five I don't think four is all that I don't think four is all that relevant yes I I did like you'd given us this uh was the stowman r Fall City School District job description of a board member and there were a few things in here too that I thought it would be timely uh whether they included it on this um or just to kind of let the folks that are watching and the folks that are

024here you know we're going into a year where you know we I think we have a what emergency Levy do we have one in 2025 do you know if we do or not do we have any we have a renewal in 26 okay so so we don't we're not we don't have any of that so we won't have that issue but if we do attempt to say put the bond issue up again um I think a person who has it mentions here adopts operating in capital budgets that's enable the school district to operate effectively monitors fiscal management to help ensure the judicious use of resources so someone that might be considering this is someone that at least for myself is someone with you know business experience may be an accountant CPA type of a person

025someone with some Finance Construction um security you know a security type person is as far as what I know for myself I would be looking for as far as someone coming in with that so that we can kind of cut the learning curve down as far as that person because those I think would be attributes that would help us tremendously in some of these financial decisions and some of these things that are um you know that I don't have any personal experience in and I don't want to be kind of learning on the job and then certainly you know anyone that that we would consider would have respect for any of the elected board members because there's a difference in being appointed versus being elected you know we have that opportunity to appoint somebody um

026which is a lot different than and and and having that opportunity to appoint somebody gives us that that opport that that ability to we need the person that's going to bring those traits that we need to help the board verse an elected person doesn't necessarily have to have any traits or any abilities you know they did a good job and got elected so you know I think to to the to the folks out there that are interesting that have those types of qualities um I know that's what I would be you know looking for as far as someone that um can kind of hit the ground running and then you know it's had experience maybe an HR person or somebody who has had experience with hiring people so they can kind of understand what the

027school is involved in um I think would be key and there was a couple other things here uh that mentioned on this cultivates community relationships that promotes a strong public support for the district another one that kind of jumped out is provides leadership for the advancement of best practices and academic standards and then one here you know maintains high standards uh for appropriate conduct so which kind of goes back to the same thing of us having someone that we're bringing onto the board that respects the um the the the the the current board members so so the person can kind of incorporate that into these questions again it would be um helpful to us does anybody else have any particular qualifications or things that you wanted to mention to add to that list I mean

028I don't I personally would like to just see who you know what the what the resume State and see what the people you know can bring to us the minimum requirements are very simple being a US citizen 18 years of age and registered to vote within the district and so we could be interviewing people from you know all sects and I don't I don't have a personal preference for any specific especially because a lot of those decisions are going to be administrative decisions that the board is simply overseeing and not necessarily making decisions on our own so that's I was going to say I don't think that we I'm not looking for someone that can do the finance or because we have someone that we're supposed to be managing that's doing that but just someone

029that is um I guess a positive um influence and understands the importance of public education and I know um some of the previous discussions that we've had have also included um folks with a history of community service um a history on different types of boards and kind of understanding that process uh that has been a plus I think sometimes um but we have gotten applicants from a wide variety of backgrounds uh so I welcome anybody who is interested uh in doing the job I mean you don't have to have a specific set of qualifications in order for us to take that solid look at your materials no I definitely agree with being a a good Steward of public education probably would be a baseline okay we just kind of add some final I I guess

030the other part is is qualified you know the best qualified person because again there's a difference in being elected and being appointed um and then also looking at the kind of the Optics of um what this person can bring to the board uh um you know the elephant in the room is that there's not the board here does not have a good reputation with the community so uh this would be uh an opportunity maybe to enhance that but you know it could also go the other direction so to kind of keep those in mind as well absolutely the board members here have been elected to make the decision and that will be that yeah so deadline for application Friday before at noon or do we want to make it like Thursday at midnight I like

031Thursday at midnight Thursday at midnight we include those questions in the application ask um in addition to you know kind of their basic information uh giving us um you know could just be a quick check mark of are you 18 in a registered voter um and then you know letter of interest resume or VA um do we want to send that just here to central office um I think in the past we've had them go through legal yeah I wouldn't really want to change that process now okay so to our general councel okay and do we want to ask that those be mailed or my leaning would be to also um offer an email definitely AOW email I think okay just given the quick turnaround time I think allowing electronic applications in addition to physical

032ones um okay so with that um with that deadline we will need those applications in our general council's hand Hands by Thursday at midnight not mailed when and correct yeah because we need that time to review them okay trying to track if we settled on all of these things we've discussed we've had a great discussion and when when are we looking to post this information publicly uh yeah yeah as soon as possible I mean anything that we post we have to kind of run through the approvals um but with us looking at a week and a half time it's hopefully as quick as we can turn around with the holidays I think this the central office is closed on the 31st as well is that correct yeah we're off the 31st first so the second

033or third would be the first it would be possible but that still leaves a week yeah that still leaves a week um and as long as we you know like I said we offer that email option uh as well then that cuts down on travel time of the of the applications and the documents and you know we're we're stuck with the timelines that Ohio Revised Code gives us so yeah and then the vote would be thaty evening uh yeah I think making a decision uh fresh for me is the easiest I don't I don't how everybody else feels um but I I appreciated doing that immediately last time around um I think then I was clear on everyone that we had interviewed that evening I didn't have to refresh myself um so yeah okay good

034point what let me back up here you're saying on the day we do the interview on the 13th that evening we would vote yes that's what we did last time as well how can we do that because that would have to be a public meeting it's all a public meeting we open the meeting in public before we do interviews in executive session and then we come back to once the executive session is completed we come back to the public meeting part uh prior to adjourning anyway and that's what we did last time we came back in we came out of executive session we had that last agenda item of a vote on the vacancy and then we closed the meeting so it will be a special meeting um so we'll have to have that on

035the agenda but then we could do it that evening yeah that's the way would there be any record of that because I don't remember that I remember it being very late when we finished but I don't remember that part of it where there was an actual vote it was on video y okay no I I just don't remember that um that's why I love having our YouTube videos up because I can go back and refesh myself so again you're saying that we would have the interviews and that and we we start the meeting it's a public meeting we start the meeting then we go into executive session for the interviews and we come back out to the public meeting to vote on this to make nominations and vote correct and but our next regular meeting

036is not till the 28th correct tentative yes well I mean it's not official until we approve the calendar I mean based on here okay yeah what is the Monday now that the 28th is a Tuesday is there now we haven't approved that but what's happened is are we off school that no I wasn't available that Monday for the significance of this uh what What's the What would the 13th okay so then is there what's the next Monday after the the would that be the 20th that'd be the 20th which is Martin Luther King day so that's a holiday we can't do that correct I mean I think because of the significance of this and again not remembering um that we would take that opportunity to maybe look at that and having our first meeting that

037Tuesday whatever that date is the 21st and having the vote at that point I don't see any reason to add an additional meeting if have the cost just to about well I said we wouldn't do the 28th our our our regular meeting for that month would be the 13th or whatever that that following Tuesday is I'm confused the Tuesday Tuesday the 14th instead of instead of our tentative because again we haven't approved this the temp yes well whatever that Tuesday would be is that the 21st and then that be that me the the vote for the for the replacement um board person be on the agenda for that um I I think just giving the public an opportunity no one's no one's going to be sitting here at 10:30 at night to see this vote

038I mean we we definitely had less folks here than started the evening with us when we took that later um my goal would be to use those questions on the application to focus our interviews for folks and definitely not be here that late uh that I I know that was a very late night um and if we get to that point of the evening and there is an option to vote on the agenda we can choose not to if we don't have a solid decision at that point um but we can't add a vote to the agenda since it will be a special meeting so I know I would lean toward putting that vote on that night um on that agenda now I believe it I I don't know as far as making a motion

039but um of of having our plan a or let's see you got plan a plan B so well we we don't approve the full calendar until next year so let's just take based on this that that we would be looking at our our regular board meeting being January 21st 2025 and at that point the decision uh and vote for the replacement board member be part of that agenda so then you would have a regular process of a regular meeting people could attend um who want to attend in person uh again no one's going to be watching it on YouTube at 10:30 at night either on that 13th I just think this is a significant vote and it seems like it's it's like we're going to do all these interviews and then just whisk this through

040as far as an approval yeah I I think it would be much better optics for the public and the community if it was done part of a regular meeting I mean I I will say I spoke to our new general Council about this and they recommended that it be on a singular evening that it be decided um as soon as possible so there was that recommendation that last time and that's the same reason we voted the same night too yeah well again I don't think it's going to be good Community Optics if we do it again like that there were I'm yeah I think it would be worth it' be well worth the uh whether it's whether it's a we we do it on the 21st and that's all the meeting is or and we

041leave the 28th as a regular meeting but to do it 10:30 or 10:00 at night uh after all those interviews um having gone through it once um that's why I'm mentioning it this time I I think for for the benefit of the community for the Optics of the board um under the under the advice of our legal council I believe that we need to to follow what they've the advice that they've given us and that's just advice it's not a rule it's not a law I'm saying I you know I I whatever I do I make a motion I have to get a second if I don't get a second the thing dies on the vine I'm I'm just saying hey based on what I saw from the last time and what um what what

042good PR this could be by having it as part of a regular meeting and not in the dark of night um would be would would benefit the board and and I don't think our Council has a has a feel for uh for what what we're dealing with on a on a community basis either so necessarily know that I agree with your perception just because you have certain people that give you the feedback I have certain people that give me different feedback so I don't think that we're on the same page when and I don't think that you have the the um um uh the BL and all to determine what the community says and wants no I don't our legal council has advised us to do it this way and I don't know why we're

043having to continue to have a discussion on it I think we need to make a decision and move on and as I said we can put that vote on the special meeting agenda to start with and we can decide on that night what we're doing as well so what changes if it's not on the special meeting night what what does that do for the community what does that give them time to look at the list of applicants and apply pressure in my opinion would there be public comment at the other me like I'm just trying to see we never we've never solicited public comment on a board vacancy um even when we have had that vote at a regular meeting in the past um we haven't asked the community to weigh in during a meeting

044so we haven't use the public comment time during a regular meeting to to weigh in on a vacancy um yeah okay well I guess for the benefit of the meeting here I would you know I would like to make a motion that the voting on the replacement board member uh be held on uh Tuesday January 21st which would be be the following uh week Mr Shen yes this is a special meeting we can't add items to the agenda but aren't we deciding on something here we have so how how are we deciding on something if there isn't some type of I mean yeah we're not yeah we are we have votes we have votes on the meetings scheduled on the agenda so then how can we come the meeting we we can vote on okay

045so I make a motion that we have a a special meeting on January 21st for the purpose of voting um the replacement board member do I have a second is that outside of the January um so let me make a second so we can have some discussion because we need to we're not even we're out of order at this point so we're we need to be in a in a second we could talk about that so now that you've got your second now let's have the discussion okay as I what was the interview date we were tentatively doing we were tentatively discussing the interview date of the 13th at 5:00 pm okay is because the only thing we could really vote on is that date of the interview not the vote so if we're 10

046so the way Mr Shane worded it the interview date would be on the 21st so we' be moving the interviews is what you're saying yes okay I just want to make sure we're kind of on the same page and again within the law of our our special meeting agenda yes so right now we can only we can only vote on a the vacancy replacement interview date at that date you could decide whether or not you're going to vote that dat or cuz in the in the um notice we could say a vote may be taken does not have to be taken and then later on a special meeting could be brought up or um at the organizational meeting once the dates are approved at that January 21st meeting if that's what it is um they

047could be placed on that one all right so on that 13th that can be an agenda item as to the date for the decision of who the replacement uh board member is yes is that that yep and again I think giving ourselves the option to vote that evening would well that would be a case yeah if it was voted down no then it is what it is so so moving forward moving on I think we've discussed this kind of to death um do we have a vote on on the proposed 21st date that would be next or no can't do that we just we need a motion to set the January 13th okay um as the interview date for the board vacancy at 5:00 pm do I have a motion to schedule that as described

048so moved second any further discussion and just so that so the 13th is the interview date at 5: p.m. and then we can there can also be an added agenda item as far as the uh voting of or the um the um yeah I guess the voting for the new uh board member well I would assume the agenda for that meeting would be decided the same way our other agendas are right um so we can follow our typical agenda setting process at that point okay roll call please e Jenkins I Shen i d donic i Wind I okay that decided we do not need Executive session we do not nope motion to adour so moved second W East Jenkins hi Shen hi sionic hi wind I this meeting is adjourned at 5:45 5:45

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.