CorpusRecord 68064

December 9, 2024 - West Clermont Schools - Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Clermont School District
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Clermont County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,403 words · about 114 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e are they ready everybody ready oh she's ready good evening welcome to the December 9th 2024 West Claremont School Board Mr Rano will you please take Ro Mr Patton present Mr Rudy presid Mr Chumley pres Miss sandborne present Mrs Spencer present all present thank you will you please uh join me with the pledge of allegiance to the flag pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with libery and justice for all next up is the motion to adopt the agenda would someone like to make a motion move thank you Mr Rudy is there a second second thank you Mr Chumley is there any discussion roll call please Mr Rudy yes Mr Chumley yes Miss Sour yes Mrs

002Spencer yes Mr Patton yes five yes okay for item 4.01 we are going to kick off with a video this is the first in a series and this is with Mr pice making all the magic happen um the theme are of our video is West Claremont strong and we will be getting this out uh we'll re-release it again in January when we all get back and you'll see a a little call to action at the very end of the video that many of you children might be interested in paying attention to so so everyone just sit back and enjoy WC strong [Music] if you look behind me here here here we are here's our student body here's our community we're a diverse group of Learners a group that is resilient a group of hardworking of

003people make up our community West clma School District presents West Claremont strong stories of West Claremont in our [Music] community the one thing I would tell you about our community at West Claremont is that we have a strong and powerful community and we care for each other families support us I know when we call when we call our families and when we send home information uh about students progress that they also are going to respond and support our academic Endeavors here at the school the students here were more welcoming than any students I've ever met I mean the kids here they it really is like a family and they they let you in so easily and it's um I feel that it's a great place to be and I and I love it here I've

004been working uh working hard I want to own a Chick-fil-A one day and you work for Chick-fil-A yes uh marketing director assistant director I've been team members in 2019 and then also to uh now current as a director they had strong leadership in West Claremont High School and then also at my chick play now they prepar me with do leadership wise uh they brought me career opportunities as I worked with my sophomore my junior and my senior year they gave me multiple career opportunities really for me it is the vital aspect of the ability for the community to wrap around our schools the various stakeholders to contribute their gifts and talents and ALS o resources through nonprofits Andor our businesses that provide our students opportunities that they would not have otherwise I went to a

005group of teachers and told them we need to revamp math curriculum and there were five strong teachers and I asked them to take on this Challenge and not only did they take on the challenge but they w a national Pace header award from making schools work for their value added for the amount of growth they showed with their students and they did it through through um an Innovative approach to where students are taking ownership they're learning they're communicating they're collaborating they're working together and they're pushing the [Music] envelope I feel like I'm prepared for anything just because the education that I'm giving now we just talk about it a lot in school that's the main thing we talk about that they're like don't settle down for one thing you're going to change your mind all

006over and I feel like no matter what path I'm given I can talk to anybody and I can do anything I can really to make sure that I do thrive in that she's going to be our next person that's perseverance in the community or Athletics or anything that involves anything in your life most clont as a district we kind of want to be all all-encompassing right we want to conquer every single thing that happens in our lives west Clon strong I think this is a story that every single student at West clemont um between the students the staff the community needs to understand it's just how far the district has come it's really resilience against all obstacles that's what I think about when I hear West clemont strong we really want to hear your West

007Claremont story [Music] well you're not expected to read that fast but there's some sound missing here what they're um saying is that we are going to be sending out um an opportunity at P for you in the in uh January tell we are let moner to tell your story about West so it'll give you an opportunity if you want to write about your story or if you want to create another video and submit it there will be a mechanism to do that because um we want to make sure that every student every staff member community members family have a chance to talk about the impact that West claron has on them so um so I don't know what happened with the sound there at the end but um we will get that fixed up before

008we send it out again in January and you guys who are uh grateful enough for you to be here tonight we we are so glad that you're here you guys got the first view of it and so you can get a head start on everyone else and preparing your West claron story and I'm sure how many of you like to do videos of yourself a couple of you some of you like no way um we would love to have stories pictures videos that tell your story so um thank you very much with that I know we're going to ask um our human resource team to come up and celebrate a high performing group of our teachers oh sorry no we're supposed to do the holiday music first sorry I'm jumping ahead Mrs gold I I

009skipped right over what you're supposed to be doing after I'm sitting here talking to them so um before you guys come up I want to say are there any alumni parents in the audience tonight any parents that went to us that much all right welcome home we we are glad to see you back and with that we have our teacher our Music Teacher here from K Pike Elementary and Merwin Elementary to provide some holiday entertainment for all of us so take it away more hi everybody um yes I'm Jenny g i the music teacher at elementary school and elementary school and I absolutely love it best job um these students are a mix of both schools um they are in fourth and fifth grade we have fourth graders from CL Pikes and fifth graders from

010Merin and they have prepared a song called Jingle J which is kind of a jazzed up version of jingle for you we hope that you enjoy it [Music] through [Music] the the field [Music] weing how fun it is to ride [Music] [Applause] [Music] all [Music] [Applause] dashing through the one more open over the f tails on off tail make it Spirit what is [Music] [Applause] people [Music] [Applause] thank you so before you guys leave I want to introduce you to somebody I'm going to embarrass them a little bit but in a few short years you're going to be headed or even for next year uh you were going to be headed off to the middle school so tonight we have in the audience who your future principal is so I want you to meet Mr

011calgren Right There there in middle of the room so I be very um we have been able to increase music in West Claremont from just a few days a month to four days a week so we're not we're still not quite to five days but we've been able to make a big push and because of talented teachers um like what we have here this evening we've uh really increased the interest of Music at the at the middle school and at the high school it just keeps exploding with with both singers as well as musicians and so we would just encourage you all to keep up that passion for music and and get involved at your Elementary and then continue on as you as you go throughout the system so um I know you guys have

012a busy busy life and this is a busy season so um don't feel bad if you have to leave but thank you so much um families for taking time and bring them here to add just a little bit of specialness to our to our board meeting this evening so thank you and happy holidays Merry Christmas [Applause] [Music] well that was [Music] coming l thanks thank you thank you thank you very much okay now it's time to celebrate our teacher sorry about that thank you I know you were looking at be like not my turn not my turn thank you well uh glad to be in front of you today and uh Mr poom the principal at the high school I already sort of tipped his hat a little bit in the video about who we're

013recognizing today we have two of them in the audience and when I call your name please come up um West Claremont High School Algebra 1 team is a model for all of our teams in the district collaboration is at the heart of everything they do you'll find them either planning lessons together analyzing the results to their data collecting how And discussing how they're going to help every single student learn the content all of their team efforts have produced amazing student results on state test and achievement and growth they live by what we call the West Claremont District's belief that every student can learn and grow so the members I'm going to introduce the two that are here today and then the other ones that W unfortunately were not able to make it tonight so if

014Samantha Bessie could come up and Sarah Schwarz go ahead and say all their names too we also have Sarah Cook Abigail null Kelsey Kelly and Claire SMY and we'll do a picture and then bring them up to shake the board members hands since we have free space tonight we're not stuck down there I'm very proud of them we'll give them a big round of applause [Music] [Applause] thank you thank you appr I know right thank have any parting words or you just want to go home okay all right we just want to make sure thank you both once again thank you thank [Music] [Applause] you so next is public speaking at a board meeting I do have two um public speaking at each meeting the board president will recognize visitors who wish to be heard

015they are asked to fill out the card and to hand them to me which they did thank you visitors who wish to address the board are asked to State their name address and school or organization remarks must be addressed to the board and should be brief approximately 3 minutes and the point speakers may offer such as objective criticism or suggestions regarding the school operations or programs the board will not hear personal complaints of school Personnel or against any persons um connected with the school district unless the these complaints have first been addressed through the individuals department or administrative involved um so first it looks like I have as a Mr Mark Duff do you have a timer you do yes good evening ladies and gentlemen my name is Mark Duff and I live at 1364

016mear Lane Amilia Ohio I am also a sixth grade teacher at West Claremont Middle School I come to you tonight from the unique perspective of not only being an employee but a proud parent of two West Claremont graduates and a taxpayer within the community I'm here to express my complete and unwavering support for the construction of new buildings in West Claremont while some of our students get to attend amazing elementary schools and our high school is second to none we have buildings in the district that simply do not meet the needs of the students and staffs that work there every day for far too long our students have been on the outside looking in when visiting other schools for sports or other competitions they get to see the amazing facilities that other districts have provided

017for their students I have heard students from other districts and even referees mock our facilities at basketball and volleyball games and quite frankly it's embarrassing I understand that this decision may cause financial difficulty for some in our community I myself in 5 years from retirement and will have a change in income however I see this as an investment to our future today's students are tomorrow's workers they deserve the same opportunities as students from other districts and that includes safe clean and functional buildings in my 23 years at West Claremont as a teacher I have seen The Good the Bad and the Ugly we are truly a district On The Rise let us come together and do what is necessary to help our students reach their greatest potential thank you thank you Mr thank you Mr

018do next I have is Miss Trisha Moore good evening my name is Trisha Moore and I live at 21 Partridge Drive I'm a seventh grade teacher at West Claremont middle school and ironically I'm going to start with my with with my West Claremont story I'm a 1990 graduate of Amelia High School my husband graduated from Amelia High School in 1989 and my oldest son Curtis was the last graduating class of Emilia High School in 2017 my youngest son Ethan was the first class to attend all four years at West Claremont High School graduating in 2021 I have taught the last 26 years at ailia middle school and then at West Claremont Middle School currently over the years many things have changed but the focus has always been on what's best for the education of the

019students our building has reached a point where it does not meet the needs of what is best for the students and I was asked to share a couple of things that we have noticed temperature in classrooms can range from 54 degrees in one classroom to 88 in another it doesn't matter if it's summer or winter it doesn't it doesn't depend on the weather outside we have students and teachers feeling sick from the Heat and not being able to focus from the cold this makes it difficult for students to learn and teachers to teach for example just today both of my AC units were on on and my windows were open to make my classroom bearable temperature but other teachers on my team had to move their classrooms to the multi-purpose room because of the heat

020in their classrooms restrooms are now unusable because of structural issues and I do not know the status of if they can be fixed this means students lose class time traveling to and from bathrooms that are far their distances teachers do not have easy access to restrooms our mission is to Ed educate our students but overcrowded hallways and excessively loud cafeterias cause anxiety and increased behavior issues the multi-purpose room for example is one of the cafeterias and because of its Acoustics it can get excessively loud to the point when I pick up my kids it hurts your ears and it's because of the Acoustics lunch should be a time for students to relax and socialize but because of this crowding and Loud environments students come back to class upset and not ready to learn and work

021as I've explained I have a history a love and a connection with this district and I only want what's best for it I met my husband in high school in the current building that I'm in but the building has outlived its time we need a new facility for all the exciting possibilities West Claremont schools has to offer our community I appreciate all your work and your consideration on this matter thank you thank you thank you Mrs Moore don't believe there are any others so we will move to the consent agenda Dr F Personnel in front of you is the Personnel agenda for uh Monday December 9th 2024 on the agenda today we have the retirement of Christopher Vandergriff social studies teacher at the middle school he has been with us uh this is his 24th

022year in West clemont so we wish him well on his next Endeavor we also have the resignation of one second shift custodian this is the time of the year where we bring administrator and exempt employee contracts up for Renewal um this agenda includes the proposed contract renewals for 12 administrators and 24 exempt staff the agenda also includes the proposed hiring of four pair professional AIDS uh on this agenda we have the proposed transfer of Curtis Mason uh who is currently an assistant principal atlu Pike Elementary to interim principal at kff Pike Elementary and we also added extended days for Barb Kenny who is the dean at K Pike Elementary on the agenda we have the proposed approval for supplemental contracts for building leadership teams Lighthouse teams Club multiple clubs multiple advisers multiple coaches also on

023this agenda is multiple unpaid leaves of absences and multiple School volunteers and student teachers um you'll see on this agenda the proposed reassignment of two emis codes we had to reclassify two of our School nurses that don't have a bachelor's degree even though they have an RN license so this um this move here is to correct to make sure that they're coded the correct way in our emis program this concludes the review with a Personnel agenda submission for your consideration thank you Dr folz next uh on the agenda we have um in front of you is the EM is the memorandum of understanding that completes the leftover work for negotiations regarding micr credentialing um the administration and hope Association agreed uh on building a process to enhance skill sets for our current success and future

024career advancement of our certified and cl excuse me of our classified staff this mou Mor moralizes that work and demonstrates our continued commitment to Growing our staff to better support our students so um this concludes a review of that for you and then we have one more memorandum of understanding in front of you is the memorandum of understanding to add language to the certified contract regarding supplemental pay so typically we pay our staff their supplemental pay once they they complete their season and marching band is considered a false sport or fall activity so their season would be fall um in the contract it had them marked that they needed to be paid three separate times over the school year and past practices we've been paying them in the fall when their season ended and so

025when we recognized this we wanted to rectify that so this mou fixes our contract to match our past practice and and also match what we do with other other activities during their season thank you thank you Dr folz good evening this evening uh we have two overnight field trips for your um that we're requesting your approval for the first is for the West claron High School wrestling team to attend the Maran Harding classic in Marian Ohio that trip is scheduled um over our winter break um the team will be leaving on the 26th and returning on the 28th and pretty much rest wrestling all all day um every day except for times that they may uh have a break to eat some food the second field trip that we're seeking your approval for is for

026the HOSA um which is our like future health professionals um Organization for students to attend the state leadership conference that this year takes place in Toledo and that um conference is scheduled um April 8th through the 10th that concludes my request um for your approval of those overnight trips thank you m pres I have a question about this I don't see where there's a cost involved in this second request the there is no cost for students um it is that it that organization has run through our partnership with Great Oaks and so Great Oaks covers the entire trip the expense of the entire trip for the students okay thank you you're welcome Mr Gart good evening uh tonight we have our second reading of our policies and bylaws we've been going through these for about

027the last 30 days it seems like we've gone through the committee um and we also have had our first reading and second reading so tonight I respectively ask you to approve the second reading of those bylaws and policies that have been revised have had Corrections that are new or have been resented okay we have the uh memor excuse me memorandum of understanding with the Ohio cyber range Institute um this is for the district's ability to participate in state sponsored cyber training cyber awareness and and cyber safety mindfulness training for the entire staff uh the state of Ohio uh provisioned some money in 2023 for this and contracted with with UC to build out this training um so uh Mrs Preston and I have been talking about how to work that into our professional development days

028over the coming year but uh the IT department will start sooner there's an whole it track that will start in January but the rest of the team we will look to see about uh working into our training for next year thank you item 8.08 are the list of donations uh for the month of November um and I will briefly read those uh first John and Karen ioac donated uh $ 4225 gift cards to Withamsville Tabasco Elementary for Thanksgiving meals for families Jeff and Renee Madden donated 26 new yoga mats to mirn Elementary for fizzed classes and yoga Club poochie's Place donated $150 towards a food purchase for the Veterans Day celebration at West Claremont High School School Big B donated coffee and supplies for the V Veterans Day celebration at the high school uh the

029following donated items for West Claremont High School Mock Trial Trevon and kingi clling Smith kingan Smith LLC donated $1,500 LongHorn Steakhouse donated salad and dressing for 50 people Sam's Club Eastgate donated $50 gift card for food and drinks for particip and volunteers Target Milford donated various food items for participants and volunteers Allison Taylor State Farm donated 15 cases of water for the December 8th competition BBY coffee Amelia donated coffee cups and condiments for volunteer judges and uh in the December competition the following made donations to the West Claremont High School student council food drive the house of plastic donated goods for raffle baskets West Claremont Athletics donated a family pass Charles and Jennifer bergus donated $100 Rick and Lisa McMullen donated $25 the VF VFW Post 9630 donated $200 and canned goods linch Electronics donated

030$1,000 Julie she donated freeze uh freeze dried snacks and candy and the West Claremont Spirit Shop DEA donated 10 West Claremont shirts uh so it's a request that those donations be approved um for the month of November item 8.09 uh it's a motion to approve and authorize the superintendent and treasur to negotiate and execute contracts as presented um again these are for these are based off of either the dollar amount or the term if it's more than one year we have one and that is for um broad broadcom or net um in the amount of $27,500 is a request for approval of purpose and budget statement for this school year um we have a request from the uh High School marching band uh for a revision item 8.11 is the financial statements bills paid lists

031and Investments for the month of November and is request that uh the board approved these documents uh for the month ending November 30th 2024 um so yes I have a question about uh 8.09 the contract what is this broadcom oret what is that I'm not understanding what that is for I know that looks like Mr P is meing this so it must have to do with underground wiring or something no actually it's for our virtual server infrastructure so all of the district's file servers are run off of a program called VMware VMware was bought by broadcom last year and they've worked out uh an arrangement with the management Council of the state to provide maintenance to you know ongoing maintenance and support to school districts at a discounted rate but it's a bundled offering that

032is a mandatory 5-year program okay thank you so the request on the consent agenda is items 8.01 through 8.11 thank you Mr Romano you've heard the recommendation would someone like to make a motion thank you Mr Rudy is there a second second thank you Miss Spencer is there any other discussion okay roll call please Mr Rudy yes Mrs Spencer yes Mr Patton yes Mr chumbley yes Miss sandborn yes five yes thank you guys are moving quickly tonight that um we decided um when we were planning the agenda this week um Mr Rudy and Mr Patton and I and and Mr Rano to modify the agenda we've had a very aggressive fast-paced meeting plan with the board focus on facilities since August and we were supposed to bring forward a we got the presentation up we

033were supposed to bring forward a um resolution to proceed tonight and we just felt it was important to um take a pause take a moment and um spend more time talking about the timing of this because that's that's really what's come into question as we've progressed over these last couple meetings and for all of us to have some discussion about that and to better understand understand the the the big impact of what's the consequences of acting what's the consequences of not acting so that we go into this fully aware of the the impacts of our decision so we've modified the decision tonight and uh to bring the resolution to to proceed forward and we're going to bring it back to the board in the New Year in January that'll still allow us you know if

034it's to go through uh to be able to meet the filing deadlines with the auditors office and the Department of Taxation so we're not compromising anything I I built in some buffer time here um but we're going to pause tonight and have a robust discussion about what's on your your mind I know you've you've been um a lot of information has been presented to you but um this this will be really the night to be able to process it all and talk about it together now my team out here is going to be jumping up at the mic every now and then so I don't know if you guys want to move your seats up or what you want to do no um whatever whatever you're comfortable with but I I'll kick it off and

035what I want to just remind everybody here in the beginning is that we've been in this process of Engagement and working with our community to build the future of West Claremont since February of 21 it feels like a lifetime ago but we've uh settled on the five challenges of the district knowing that facilities is one of those key challenges in early February of last year um this board voted on what your aspirational vision is for uh the school district and we kind of memorialized that in in in your statements and continue to work very hard through our strategic planning engagement process to align the Blazing new Trail strategic plan to those Visions so that we could make sure that every step we are taking every move we are making would help realize the West Claremont

036that you guys Envision and that you want to see so we voted in May for a 2030 strategic plan and one of the things that I think has been Challen chenging over the course of the last year is that not only have we focused on a strategic plan we've been in this facility planning process at the same time so this is one of those moments where we are eating the elephant almost every single meeting we're taking it all in looking at the big picture understanding how all the parts and pieces go together and it's very very overwhelming I I've been very proud of you all for hanging with us um absorbing a lot of information attending a lot of community events and looking at data it's a lot because we're not only looking at the

037educational Direction which is the most important thing that we're doing we're looking okay well what does this do to finances how's the enrollment impacting us how's facili is going to play a role and um in the chair that we all sit in up here on this um on this area here we have to be responsible for thinking about all those things it would be so nice to be able to like just take a bite of one and just like work it through um but we we have to look at the entire thing and so that's why we've been focused on 2030 one because of the 2020 Levy we we passed a levy in 2020 it was the first that had been passed in 16 years and we know that that's up for renewal in 2030

038so we wanted to make sure that every financial and educational decision that we made in that time syncs up for the possibility of that renewal in so on the in the master facility plan what what we were really after here is having a a within this three years having a master facility plan and a transportation plan plan that addresses the start time of the middle school and and creates an opportunity to bring Merwin Elementary Holly Hill Elementary and West cat Middle School to the standard that the rest of the students in the school district um kind of live up with too and so well as I mentioned before in in these in the recent weeks the timing of this plan has really been the question and so what you're going to find and you're going

039to hear a lot of passion tonight from the team because we we've been so dedicated to to researching and uncovering and discovering like what is the very best solution what's the most cost effective what's the most long-term enduring plan that we could come up with and we we've really felt the support of the board and the community all through this process I will say um it's not that everybody agrees about everything at at the same time but usually when you're bringing a master facilities plan forward like we brought forward and people don't agree with it um usually boardrooms are lined with people when you have things like Town Halls the the the rooms are lined with people in opposition my inbox is filled to the brim my phone is ringing off the hook and that's

040really not happening uh just to give you a sense this this weekend when I was out at some events at uh cluff Pike Elementary as well as willville Elementary people were seeking me out to say you know you know this plan it's a really good plan like we we weren't expecting that to be the final plan but we really like this plan now there's always the worry about you know will it will people pass it well know will it be passed and that's always a an anxious moment for parents but um parents went out of their way to say things like to me like we know you're working really hard to bring every school up to a high level and we don't give up we know it's hard work but just you know we appreciate

041what you're doing and staying after it and that was without soliciting those kinds of comments that's what people were saying to me up and down um the events that I attended and so I I feel if the community was really really against this plan we would hear it and know about it your your your inbox would also be flooded and that's not what we're seeing so we're here in a moment where we believe that the alignment of the vision of the district that you have and the and our strategic plan and the facilities plan are all kind of syncing up in a really positive way where we would feel something very differently right now but the question here we have tonight is what about the timing so we're going to keep bringing information forward from

042all the different angles that we have to look at because these are the drivers um enrollment the drivers of aging buildings and operational costs the driver of just um the education that we want to offer and and we're going to sync all this up so some of this will well most of this will feel like a repeat but it'll be kind of a fast repeat of things that you've heard over the last couple um months and then we're going to open up um at the end of our topics here and to give you time to talk to each other to ask additional questions and just to clarify every and uncover every rock that we can so first I I want to take you back to this metaphor we've been saying the West Claremont School District

043is like a Jeep and that it's important for us and for a Jeep to be able to to function um and operate correctly tires have to be aligned and the alignment that we've been working on and the components we've been focusing on our modern modernizing our learning and our curriculum and our learning processes technology all of that modernizing our learning environments those two things go hand in hand modernizing our Workforce so that our our faculty and staff are equipped with the skills and the knowledge that they need to ensure that all kids can re receive Port of graduate outcomes and Modern Family and Community Partnerships it's been well established here that we uh can't really do anything without our parents and our community working together with us and we just need to modernize those Partnerships

044and and and support one another in in addressing all the changes and why do we have modern This Modern This Modern that it's because our entire world has changed think about how you're you watch TV think about how you get groceries at the grocery store now think about how you pay for all of the goods that you pay for think about how you you are shopping for holiday are you doing it from your couch are you actually in a store every aspect of American life has changed and schools have been slow to keep up with with those advancements we know we're not turning back this is the slowest change will ever be for the rest of our lives and so we've got to make sure that we we accelerate keep our foot on that gas

045and continue to modernize the things most essential in education and here's where our biggest problem is that everything that we need to modernize is highly affected by the modern learning environments that we do not have the Aging buildings the fact that there is inequities across our school system and that all students are not getting the same experience your address kind of determines the experience that you have have here in West Claremont and the reality is our middle school students are going to a building that is far inferior to what the high school students are are getting to do and so this is holding us back and it negatively affects all of the three um areas so I'm going to ask David to come up and just refresh our memory here on the enrollment growth and

046the pace because as as a Cabinet Team Planning we we are looking this in detail looking for every nook and cranny of this building and of of the school district to to have the space we need for our students okay the slide you see before you you saw this it was our last month's Board of presentations if you're looking at the Blue Line the Blue Line represents all of our predicted growth and so one of the things that I just wanted to P bring back to your attention was the majority of our growth comes from increased dwellings people moving into our districts and the dwellings that are being built and you'll see that larger increase in the first 5 years and that steady growth after that and when we're talking to 10 years and you're

047seeing 1300 1400 1500 1,600 new students there's a realization that we're going to run out of space so looking at this projected growth what does that do then now to the space that we have available and you saw this slide as well last month um 15% of our capacity we have to use for specialized student programming specials support staff uh spaces so we have to look at gened classrooms filling up 85% of our capacity and when we look at that you can already tell by the by the chart in front of you we're hitting red as early as next year running out of space now it isn't just red or not red as we hit red we can try things like building to building and and certain movements but as the years go on it

048gets deeper I wish we could shade it deeper and deeper and deeper and deeper red where that we're just out of space and although we can we can initially use some temporary workarounds um ultimately within two to three years we are going to be out of physical space to to house any of our kids yeah and the kind of things we do now are we we try to I don't manipulate it maybe it's the right but strategize the building to building uh transfers to create some movement we have teachers who um are on a cart so art might be not in an art classroom or music might not be in an art or in a music classroom so there's some things that we can do there other things that we've brought forward that we'll have

049to continue to think about is full day kindergarten F day kindergarten is offered for free in our district for all buildings for all students students and um the state mandate is half day kindergarten and so it is something very unique here in West Claremont and something that we have valued and have benefited from um offering to our students because just to remind you a little data point that is always a data point that keeps me up at night and that is when students come into West Claremont half of them are ready for kindergarten according to the state of Ohio and so we have an uphill battle bringing everybody up to a the the level of learning that they need be to to be successful in our school system and so that full day time really

050affords us with some opportunities that I can't imagine squeezing in to the half day but that would be something we have to look at because it would give us half of our kindergarten rooms um back and available we've also you know you know we've added modular so that's been a mitigating strategy we've also um looked at things like and and not in detail but we there was a time we started looking at a church to see if maybe we could rent some space with the church um and so doing those kinds of um big moves in this season is something that we would see a shortterm strategies and what we want to be really oh and and uh targeted redistricting that's another one that I mentioned if if we end up we have really have

051a lot of um space issues at Amelia in fact let me just tell you a quick story about that I was about I was at Amelia the other day I was working with the staff trying to get them to dream about the modern learning environments what would you imagine that you would have in a a building that has been modernized and and helps you meet the the various needs of your students and I was having one of the table share their idea and their idea was space they wanted space so here we were in this Innovative brainstorming session and space is like bread and water to me and I'm I'm thinking they're going to be talking about we need spaces for green screens where kids can create videos and podcasts and um could end up

052having Creation Station and all that's the kind of thing I'm hearing about and they're just like well we would just love to have just some space to do some things and so it just really like kind of brings me right to reality when you when you hear something like that so so I I share Amelia and the size issues they're having there because it's something maybe we could do at Amelia if they would get overflow next year we might be able to Target a redistricting out to Holly Hill at as a solution so all these examples I just gave are short-term mitigations to address the red that become the solutions without a long-term plan so and and it's it's probably and likely a combination of all those things that would have to be in place

053and even the best intentions with all of them working together would not be ideal and in any way shape reform because it it compromises the learning and the education that we can offer our students so I'm going to ask Randy to come up now and just remind you of the timeline for the the master facilities project that we proposed that includes the 5678 Middle School on the middle school campus the prek4 elementary school on a location undetermined at this time and and the additional advancements at Amelia at um the the it's a at the media center in Amelia it's a media center um refurbishing at WT but also additional classrooms at WT and additional classrooms at clu Pike Elementary and then IMM Media Center since they don't have one can I sorry I I just

054have a question I was it's really probably directed to David yeah to David more than anybody but um I'm not sure do you know how many new homes were built in this West Claremont School District in 2023 in 2023 I can get that information for you okay well actually I have it because I checked with the auditor and he said 230 brand new homes were built how much more of an in I mean how much of a attendance income increase we have from that from there to this year did they just give you Standalone homes or did they give you it was free standing homes West Claremont School District according to the Claremont County auditor there were 234 okay families so the the organization we use looks at free standing homes it looks at apartments

055and it looks at like condos and duplexes okay so I can go back so there's three different types of residential dwellings that this takes into account why don't you take a minute to like pull up the presentation that you did just last month to give some of those details while Andy talks and then you can come back and so that we can make we can make sense of it because um we want to I know you provided a lot of that information we just might need to revisit we might have to pull it back up so um if that helps because just kind of seeing it visually um I I think helps connect what I just heard is is one thing is we got to compare we got to make sure that we're comparing Apples

056to Apples and not apples to oranges if the Auditors well I was just going to see how much did our how much did our enrollment go up from 234 brand new home I mean I understand I know it's I know we're growing there's no question about that yeah just the new gleny campus with all those apartments that have went up I mean that that's a that's a monster just in and of itself yeah we we had um some and and David has covered this and again we might need to bring it back up but we talk specifically that when you look at the growth enrollment charts in West Claremont you're seeing a fabricated human created um change in enrollment growth because we did mitigating strategies inside of our system so we changed open enrollment which

057lessened the amount of enrollment in this past year we changed kindergarten enrollment and the rules around kindergarten and so we knew that was going to for a year take us down a little bit but we are expecting that boost to come back so there's a couple thing and I feel like there's a third thing David will probably have to remind me that has come into play that has on purpose slowed down growth here so that we can deal with the space issues that we are having well I I personally think some of it was the Ed Choice scholarship that also a lot of the kids chose to go to private schools which was whatever is fine you know yeah and and David shared shared all those numbers last time and if we need to pull

058them up but that's where there are several factors impacting not only the private school Ed Choice vouchers um people choosing to go to smaller environments because that's what you see is our some of our students here here in West Claremont choosing smaller clont County Schools as a as a pattern most in my 5 years here the most contact I've had with people coming to me is when we closed open enrollment I don't know how many I don't know how many people were up it was very it was very controversial and we did that proactively knowing what we were seeing in the numbers and and that's what I'll say about these enrollment numbers because we we don't use the auditor numbers feed David's numbers but we we don't directly use them we use the company that

059we contract with and that have been very predictable and measurable and and it's been very accurate over the last couple years so um there's something that you said oh the open enrollment yeah there were so many parents that came me upset that their kids could could not go to West Claremont yeah that year yeah and and we knew we could not be um looking down the road going out for an operational Levy saying hey um we need more money at West Claremont because kids from this school district and this school district and this school district are now taking up seats of our students and we're running out of space and we're running out of teachers and so okay so let's let's look back then um uh and Tammy you you can let us know if

060if this is the data that um matches with the kinds of things that you were looking at so so what happens the company that we use contacts each Township and the auditor and to find out what's being built what's in the ground what's going up what's almost done and what's on paper to be built and so they look at multif family which is Apartments attached which are Town Homes condos and duplexes and then detached which are your typical houses and so this is how many uh each year they plan on to be able to come online it's not just being thought about it's they're ready to be occupied and then they base that a logarithm on that to to to work on how many they kids they expect to be in each one of those

061and so um in 25 26 they're expecting houses to have 2011 houses ready to be occupied by the 25 26 school year another 188 by the 26 27 so Miss Spencer having that number for 202 23 that's probably accurate if you look across the board it's in the low 200s high 100s um what you're seeing there is our Apartments is really the larger of the thing and then it it almost goes Apartments you know Town Homes duplexes and then detached houses so we're expecting you know over that just 5year period 2700 new residential dwellings online and ready to be occupied as of today so if if this is actually as of October 20 or yeah October 28th so between now and then other people could have put mailed in like like U um permits to

062build houses at that time were there any other slides you want to show um and is there any other questions uh Tammy that you want to add to this or something the question really was how much did our enrollment go up up from 2020 this was last year so it would have been 2021 22 and this would have been 23 how much did it go up how much was did it from one year to the next how much did it go up 21 22 M it went up from 2122 to 2223 it went up but and then it started to go down but what Mrs Adams was saying earlier keep in mind that we manufactured that decrease if you go to Larry if you go to slide well if you I I know what you're

063saying because you changed the dates and I understand yeah we changed open enrollment we changed the dates with kindergarten and there's a third thing what's the other thing open enrollment um kindergarten and what was it home school home school ohu CH oh yeah now everybody can so but we manufactured the other changes we manufactured the um we reduced open R twice in that process so had we kept that there we our numbers would have been continuously going up because of the people who applied that we had to we had to turn down was was hundreds but in the first thing yeah and that kindergarten change this year kind of created a little blip that seems it it's just not been our normal Trend so if we look at just the reduction it's it's not completely

064accurate because of we caused that produ that that decrease when it could have been going up yeah and and I would just Echo like when we meet with Economic Development people when we' met with um different um home owners like Mi homes they're saying we are building and they are coming and so get ready is is definitely the the message and and that's something I think has been really important to our team is to not take a reactive approach to planning for the district to be very proactive and cover every base that we can so um we'll have that on the ready if we need to bounce back to it thank you guys we're very quick with that I appreciate it um let's move on then to Randy sharing the timeline for um the building

065and I think what where I got cut off there is uh there's three other things that are a part of this plan and it is an updated technology infrastructure targeted Furniture as well as Safety and Security updates across the entire school system so in our plan there is something for everybody yeah so what we have we have design build timeline and this is something that we have have worked through with our architect firm SHP Frank here tonight thank you Frank so one of the things that looking at this in 2024 is a lot different than what it was in 2017 and what I think really what caught us off guard was the time in as far as um the extended time for construction today in today's world it's taken a little bit longer uh for

066construction and so when we started to look at that there are a couple factors that when we looked at this was the time frame as well as the increased cost will continually go up year after year after year the longer that we go down down the road so I think when we looked at this time frame uh what we liked about this and obviously we want to give a lot of credit to our cat team um that helped us develop the master facility plan and we obviously make some modifications as Mrs Adams said to the cat plan for our modified C plan which I think would help with some of the things that doctor out with the increased enrollment as we move forward and we're going to see a slide um how many modules we

067would need if we do not have a construction project but when you look at this construction prog project people always ask who's it going to affect when is it going to be completed and when can we move in so what this timeline does for us typically the design is about 12 to 18 months or 18 months is a recommendation uh we've already looked at that so when you start to look at the design of what you want to see inside the building it's a teaching and learning it's a lot of people that are getting input from that our staff our teachers um Community students what do you want to see inside the buildings and that's going to be a 12mon process and so when you look at this time frame and so when you look

068at this year's kindergarten class class of 2037 which you can't believe I'm saying 2037 but that's when it would be and if we were to have a ballot issue in May um and we if we were to pass it in May then we would begin that design phase for the next 12 months however what's unique about uh the modified C plan is this is that we have some additional um space that we'll be creating at WT and at Koff that will help it can address that in 26 and 27 and so which can have a factor on how many modules we would need down the road but when we look at this if we were to pass again we pass uh in May the construction on those buildings those additions to cloth and WT would

069then um start immediately and I've got them to say in 12 months we would have that so we would have the additional space in 12 months so when we go into the fall 26 and 27 we would have the additional space that we could go and again we have other improvements that would be started immediately after the ballot issue would been passed uh and that would continue then you get into that build phase um that you would then go into the construction of those facilities and that would be again a 5 six a 78 and an elementary and during that time it's basically you're looking at a three-year process um once you start into that build and then you would start to look at moving in in 2930 and so um the thing about this

070timeline is this costs are going to go up the further down we go um construction times I don't think will be coming down in the future it's going to even increase as well and so one of the things that we have to look at when we look at this design build timeline is what are we going to do from now until 2029 what are we going to put into place what are the short-term uh Solutions or mitigations that we're going to have to put into place to accommodate the increased enrollment that Dr folz just talked about and that's the scariest part about this entire design uh build is what are we going to do until we get to this and the longer that we go and if they are we are building and they are

071coming it it scares me it really does as we move forward it is going to be um uh very very difficult for us to find spaces in these buildings and one of the reasons I think that we don't have a lot of um voice uh against these plans is because of our efforts to engage our community and and use feedback and data that was really shaped by what their interests were and What mattered to them most and that that these plans truly do solve the challenges it's it's not just some creative idea it is need-based based on the challenges that we have and and I'm going to have Dan talk a little bit about the big picture with fin finances because that's the same thing we heard early on from our community that um property

072tax alone would be a huge uphill battle and and a and a and a challenge that people were not excited about and so through listening to our community um looking at all the options we we came up with a pretty creative hybrid plan and so I'm gonna have Dan just take you to he's he shared the fiveyear forecast these are just a couple bullets that succinctly U tell you the financial picture of West clont so and and maybe before I do that I just want to Dove tail off of what the superintendent said and and so I I think also there is if un mentioned um faith that when we we really are entrusted with the Public's money and we make good use of it and if you look at the first bullet point um

073we spend in the B 177% of the state means 83% of the school districts of 600 and some school districts spend more money per pupil than we do if you look at the differences on the averages to to comparing West Claremont our in the most recent report our expense per pupil was 12810 if you looked at similar school districts it was 14,475 if you looked at the state it was 15,420 you look at those numbers and you know so it's so it's 2,000 plus or minus difference is that a big deal take it to the EXT extreme and multiply that times 8,000 students approximately you have between 11 and $20 million more a year maybe those are too big a numbers to to kind of fom but if you break it down to the classroom

074and say what does that difference in per pupo really mean it really means anywhere between $40 and $50,000 per classroom per year okay that we spend less L than other school districts one of the things you'll see in the cup report is that most school districts in the state spend the money percentage wise the same way okay it's just the dollar amount of that percentage that is different with so we don't have a spending problem in West Clara we are bringing great value for what we invest it's really it's a revenue problem right the second bullet point is on the fair school funding formula we know and we we've experienced over the last you know a half dozen years or so that we are on the guarantee we were off the guarantee one year that

075was last year then there was the valuation increase the valuation increase in our enrollment really calculates whether or not we're we're going to be on that guarantee or not we are we're deep into the guarantee so even as things move forward even as as the state if they so desire fully funds that formula the projections are we will still be on that guarantee okay so so because of that the two most critical funding sources are our local sources are State money the state basically is saying they're not going to give us any additional money so any cost increase whether it's inflation or anything else really comes locally um third Point Master facilities plan to solve District challenges requires additional funding in order to keep investing in the classroom um and to continue the positive momentum

076and what's the positive momentum it is it is moving from um three stars uh to four stars it is moving um to the momentum award it is really about the student performance in order to do that um if if we don't invest in the facilities plan then those costs that Mr Gart talked about a little bit ago and and they're they're coming up okay will be borne by the operating fund we'll be born by the general fund and so when we look at that that really means that there are going to be um increased cost because we look at that that projection out okay um and we know that two or three years up the road that we are headed towards a a deficit spend okay we'll have to make some adjustments somehow to accommodate

077that um just this evening we had a finance committee and and part of what we did was look at that Financial 5year forecast and what did those numbers really mean and how did things Shake out okay in 2020 when the emergency Levy was passed there was a commitment that we would not go back to the voters and uh earlier than 2024 we have not gone back to the voters prior to 2024 this current school year and with that projection that we did and yes there was a valuation increase and yes because of the valuation increase there was there was additional taxes that were collected that allowed us to really push that forward to 2026 six where we can if we can following the model that Mr Patton said at the organizational meeting last year we're

078going to we're going to we're not not going to spend outside um of our means we're not going to you know uh um be wasteful in what we're doing so we are there with that um so not funding that facility plan has an effect on um the 2026 what what is currently projected right now on what millage we may be asking for if we don't have uh facility money that we had proposed there are going to be as Randy talked about those mitigating circumstances that we're going to have to follow through and do and and that will increase the millage amount um that we may ask for in 2026 um then I go to the next SL or question oh was there you got the clicker oh oh you're sorry question sorry okay so I'm

079visual so I needed to get this on a a timeline here for you um we're looking at several different factors so what I'm going to do is layer in the things that Mr Gart and Dr folz and Mr Rano have talked about here so it begins with this possible Levy which is what we've been talking about really for the past 18 months um to happen this may according to the timeline that we've been on so far and just a little note reminder that because of the partnership we have with the ofcc that's the state share of the money for the for the bigger project um when you put a an issue on the ballot you have 16 months to bring the local share forward to the Ohio facilities commission if you don't produce the local

080share portion then you fall out of line your your number is and and the position that we're in right now to be able to get that state portion um is taken off the table and so we've worked very hard to position oursel to be able to have that state portion that's not something is just freely given or just you know a random gift to West Claremont it's a process that the board has put in motion um years ago now to to be able to be in this position to get State funding to help us with at least a part of the plan so there is some urgency there with that 16 months so I just want to keep that in the back of your mind we've been saying that we knew we were going to

081be able to stretch the 2020 Levy past 24 but uh the kind of the timeline now is 26 for the operating Levy and um it's always Our intention that if we can ex to expand it Beyond 26 we would push that um but kind of depending on the circumstances in the district would would will determine if if if we'll be able to do that or not so this shows you the need for a bond in 25 an operational Levy and 26 as at the earliest and then a 20 20 Levy renewal in the 2030 year so that this gives you kind of the financial look when you start layering in the enrollment projections you know that a big jump up in our enrollment is predicted here to happen in this next little window here so

082that's why we're saying no matter how no matter what passes or what what's to come with the master facilities plan we're going to need to be having District level Solutions obviously we'll want to make the the least expensive Solutions and the ones that will um make the most um meaningful learning environment for our students um but but we're gonna there's kind of a short-term game that could become a long-term game and then there's a long-term enduring plan and so which one are we going to select and then finally you can see layered in in yellow there it tells you the timeline that new spaces will come on and so you can see a direct correlation between enrollment going up and then spaces coming online so spaces in the form of additional rooms at WT additional

083rooms at CL Pike Elementary so instead of investing in a modular unit as a temporary fix this gives us a long-term solution because David's already shared with you that he believes in that the numbers that he sees now predicted for next year we can make it work by increasing class size having traveling teachers maybe doing some targeted um boundary changing uh dealing with things through the the building to building transfer to the best of its builing that we can do that without huge investments in modulars in the next year but that starts to drastically change and we'll show you that here in a minute as you move along so I just wanted you to kind of see that this is back to eating the whole elephant we have to think about what is the financial

084impact of this decision going at the r we think it is what's the impact of slowing down this financial decision if we move anything what happens to everything else and that's what we want you to be able to talk about here in a little bit okay uh Dr folz if you'll come back or I don't know which one of you are talking about this okay thanks um so as I said before looking at the enrollment as we start to look at how we're going to make plans uh for the future if we don't do a building project and so I asked Dr fol to take a look at those numbers that you saw earlier in that chart and kind of look at where am I going to need modular cuz we'll have to start planning

085for that just a reminder for modular for us to put it in we would then it would have to be basically a year ahead of time usually in November um is when we have to make that decision for the prior year so that we can go out and we bid we can get what we need to get in place for the following year and so these are just the these are raw numbers for you to look at um just to give you a overall cost of what this would be if there's no building projects um and what it would look like until we get to 2030 2031 32 how many modules we would need in respect to the increase in growth um with our enrollment and so as you will see um in 26 and

08627 WT um is pretty much at capacity now we know that we're going to have to add to WT the problem with WT is the locations the locations of put modulars at WT is it it becomes uh a little bit Troublesome because of the space behind the building for the addition that we were going to put on at WT would be uh on the building moving out toward um to the road we have space there for that not so sure we could be able to put modular out there as well so that would be something that we would have to have our Architects look at again um but we know that we have WT and all these scenarios that you see on this chart there's going to be redistricting it's going to affect kids the

087only thing we don't have to redistrict is when we look at moving maybe preschool um to other buildings that may have capacity for them as we have done we've gone from two to three this year you remember we've added at Summerside this year uh so preschool is not a large number remember that's going to be 300 or less total divided by half because it's a half a day um so that's not a lot of space but it is creating space issues currently in our buildings right now uh so that's really the only flexibility we have we start looking at putting Modell at 350 at today's cost you got to look at an increase cost year by year by year uh on what that's going to be and if I were to need to get 19

088to 20 uh modular today you're looking at $7 million um and that is uh without any complications from fire hydrant to things that we have permits and things that we've gone through in the past um those are the things that we would be looking at as far as modular go one of the things when you look at modulars when you talk to people you take surveys you say well you know we will We like this we just talk to people that are in them that's not what we're getting that's not the feedback that we've gotten through our surveys on those that are Merin right now it creates um some logistics for our principal as well for weather um I know that uh Mrs Parker has to bring kids in anytime we get uh any type

089of weather alerts um create some things with uh rain is walking in the rain you know that you've seen that um so modular are shortterm but there are districts that use it for long term and sometimes it's uh it's not the best uh for our students and so when you look at this and you look at okay when we look at the enrollment how many modular will we have and how much money do we want to put in modular do we want that um to be the face of our district that we have these at each of our buildings and that's what kind of what we're looking at right now we have spaces at some of our buildings most of our buildings to put modular in um but when you look at increased enrollments at

090KF and WT which are the two main areas we do have room atlf there is green space available to put modulars there um but the sheer number of those could be above five six seven of those and that's not what we want and I don't think that would be a good look for the district um as we move forward so those are the things when we look at modulars not only at the cost um but also the efficiency so this is one of those the vend diagram of enrollment and facilities are like overlapping uh clearly and I think if I was relabeling the title of this I think I would call it wait and see let's just wait and see and let's have modular be the solution like that's that's what this represents and so

091what what I want to make sure that is said and because it's not seen in the numbers is this idea of redistricting is not methodical it's sporadic because with the numbers that Dr folz had and the predictions that with the company that we use and and what's worked for us over the years the final number is usually very very accurate exactly where those numbers fall it might be a little bit more at Summerside this year and we were expecting it at Merwin but actually happened at Summerside or it might be a little bit cluff this year and we we were thinking it was aelia the total number is usually pretty accurate where it actually falls is quite unpredictable and it's it's just all about timing and construction and where people move and and so I

092just want to make sure that this alone could be the way to C plan it could just know that there's vulnerabilities attached with this in sporadic redistricting because we are already at capacity of these places um I'll give an example today at K Pike Elementary as we are having a very difficult day with staff and with the news that we have we are working on our plans for tomorrow and we are out of space to have a safe zone for students to go and staff to go so we've had to reent we've had to move two different activities out of rooms and like kind of twist and make something work because there is not one space that an adult could go to for a grieving period there's not one space where I could send a

093group of kids if they needed extra attention without shutting down other programs in the school so it just kind of speaks to like we're already there if something a little bit out of the ordinary happens we're not ready for it um and and that in the example I shared today and and that's what's you don't see in the numbers that I just want to make sure is very very clear okay sorry go ahead Randy I just have a question that 2425 that Amilia 31 what does that 31 mean does that mean there's 31 more students or I'm not sure what that 31 21 18 what is that it's the First Column it's the it's the very first column that says class oh there's 31 classrooms 31 classrooms yes and so then that as you go

094across it shows like the total that you would need to add to accommodate the numbers that is in the predictive model from his enrollment total classrooms okay and then yes so it says Amelia 27 28 would be two is that two modulus or just two classrooms two modular which four classrooms which is four classrooms okay okay yeah and the the hard part about when you when you do a classroom audit you have to to look into the factors of what are the needs of that particular building what are the needs of the students and so when you look at that so that's why we use that 85% because we know that we have to accommodate um those program well we were doing glad you have that clicker because it never works for me it was

095it was do really good for I is it just tired it looks like it doesn't want to see on the next one can you just do it uh yes I uh let me try you went backwards okay perfect all right so as we go into these what we did was we going to crunch some numbers for you you've given these numbers before um I think as you look at these numbers these are not numbers that I like to get up you as you know I was a principal uh for what 20 years um and I I joke about that but I always look at it through the lens of the principal and I think when I look at these numbers and when I went to the treasur he knew or she knew I didn't come

096to unless I needed something and so when I look at these numbers um it makes me a little bit nervous these numbers that you have here are the roofing numbers that we gave you prior uh in one of our facility updates that we had um had District assessments that Chuck had gone out and got these for our Roofing cost um and as you look at there I just used the three older buildings and what that possibly could be over the next 5 years and right now you're looking at just in Roofing cost and repair um through the assessments that we as a district have uh brought in uh you're looking at about 5 .2 million just say $5 million U with our current roofs um and so those are things that we look at is

097broken down I don't need to go into that but we do have cost assessments for that so roofs we try to stay ahead um but I will note this for for the roofing not only for those three aging buildings you're also going to have Roofing needs for buildings that are um are ofcc buildings that are currently ofcc buildings uh that we're going to start to have uh some issues we know we've got leaks already at WT um and so those buildings as they get older remember we have flat roofs flat roofs are going to leave over time it's just going to happen every building I've been in over my 33 years in education there have been buildings that are aging that are going to leak that you're going to have to address and so we

098are going to have to take that operational money wherever it comes from they're going to have to address um those particular buildings that as far as roofs go roofs are one of the biggest things as far as operational goes that you have to stay on stay up on uh and are big cost items for us and so those things that we constantly look at so when you look at just the three aging buildings these are kind of the numbers that you're kind of looking at for that the next one is the one that's the scary part and that's our HVAC and electrical so our hbac and electrical we do not have assessments we've not brought anybody in assessment so what we use was ofcc numbers as far as Replacements goes um that were part of

099the ofcc drafts that have many drafts that they have given us over the last 12 months just got another one today uh with updated numbers and so when you look at these numbers as far as what it would take to for these three aging buildings to replace the the uh electrical as well as the HVAC these are the numbers that start to get astronomical these are the things that when we look at it these are the things as far as replacement obviously these are worst case scenarios when you look at the ofcc how much of it can we um Salvage how much of we have to have a total replacement um I had Roger thorberg go through uh one of the one of the things that we're looking at at the middle school um is

100are those electrical boxes that are going to have to be replaced why they have to be replaced they're no longer um you can't get the parts for them um there's 20 to 21 of those electrical boxes that are going to have to be replaced uh over time uh and those are things that are going to be cost that we're going to have to take money um and pay for those over the year uh over the next few years and so I I put those numbers in there they're not in that total 35 those are just as far as additional cost uh for electrical boxes and Breakers at those three buildings um as you start to look look ahead the electrical and HVAC are another big big item uh that we're going to have to take

101in consideration as we move forward and if we're Ting money from um the general fund to pay for these there's going to be sacrifices and again going back to being a principal we know what the sacrifices are going to be and those are things that we do not want to happen as we move forward when you look at this number when you look at $ 35 million there is Dan doesn't have $35 million sitting under the desk that we're going to be able to pay for this these are things that are going to have to be spread out over time but eventually it's going to impact on what goes on in the classroom it just is and so that's that's the reality of the situation I don't like to come up here and say this

102don't want to report this but this is the current reality of where we're at operationally in these three aging buildings the next one is asphalt asphalt another big ticket item that we have um as you know Middle School the cost estimate is up there probably above even 209 now that's the pl the past assessment that's going to be a total redo Merwin we know we have issues at mwin if you can remember as far as asphalt goes there's no space at mwin there's no space for parking when they have events they have to go offsite um that's that is another um um detriment to that building uh traffic flow pattern there as well but when you just look at asphalt and you look at parking that is a problem that is a problem at marwin

103that we have to address if we do not do a building project we're going to have to look at what are we going to do to help um Aaron as far as what the uh parking lot's going to be um and then Holly Hill as well the other big one is pictures are pictures of current pictures of windows at Holly Hill if you remember going back into the modified C plan um even though we say that uh we're not we're not replacing Holly Hill part of the plan was not initially to have a demo of Holly Hill so if we do invest in Windows at Holly Hill we can repurpose that property uh down the road for other things that we might need as a district and could be there for for some reason we

104had um growth that was off the charts that we have to have space for I mean so we would obviously not uh do do a demo on that particular building and repurpose that building so would that be money thrown um at bad I don't believe so because we in our mind with with the board's approval would probably continue with Holly Hill uh and not do do a demo and that would be a future decision on what we would do with that particular property and so when you look at the windows I can see nobody would want that on their house nobody want that and we know that that's an issue for Josh um at at Holly Hill so we know that we'd have to look at that we put this in I had uh Larry

105put together um estimates for technology because in the modified cat plan remember we did uh Technology and Safety throughout the entire district and this is something that uh we know as far as technology goes that this is something that has to be addressed uh year in year out as far as upgrades as far as things that we need to add things that that Larry needs as far as um keeping us uh up to date as far as the technology goes so I had him put together for the entire District on what would that would look like over the next 5 years obviously these are approximate these are approximate we know the numbers will probably go up as we go through this but I I wanted to give the board an idea of what we would

106haveen as far as technology goes and safety uh and then safety is does that include SRO that's not we not even talking about that this is just the infrastructure on what we would do uh with Technology and Safety so when you look at the the particular buildings and the three older buildings from 1.8 to 650 to 765 and then you start to add in some of our other buildings or newer buildings with cluf and then as we go to the next slide Amelia willville are all around the same 6 50 to 700 just to maintain the current uh the networks the current infrastructure that we have in those buildings and then you get to the new high school that will be 13 years old 12 to 13 years old and you're looking at over $2

107billion to continue with that particular project there I think when you look at Technology and Safety this does not include individual Chromebooks this doesn't include um those devices that students use this is completely just the infrastructure of key continuing what we're doing uh and staying up to date and so when you look at that you're looking at about 8.7 um give or take a few million right it's it's just it's just where we're at and and those are the costs that we have and again no additional funding then these are things that are going to have to come from the general fund as I'm sitting here now I'm wondering what um Trisha or mark would say about where's your slide about the bathroom that still isn't open Where's that slide and when will that be

108fixed and how much is that going to be yeah so these are the things that that when when Chuck calls me I usually say chuck how much usually how much what are we looking at how much are we talking what is the safety where we got problems and so when Chuck called me about the bathroom about the cracks in the bathroom at the middle school um we immediately shut it down brought the architects in I think now we're to the point now where they're going to be coming in and removing cinder block and decorative block it's not it's not a lry wall it's not an exterior wall attached to an exterior wall and it houses all the pluming inside the wall so the scary thing is it's significantly crack on in the boys restroom and

109rest not along Lin but crack straight down through so so we had a structal engineer come out so there's significant pressure coming from somewhere the wall is actually not being forced down it's being forced towards the room to the right and then the left and Shing the so we shut it down so Mark Hall and our maintenance guys are going to cut out several blocks that the engineer suggested we cut out so that they can look inside at the structure and see what exactly going wall not OCC all so these are things that we deal with on a Day-Day basis from boilers to walls to to what whatever we might have in some of these aging buildings um um and I think that that's that that's the key Point here is that we are troubleshooting

110on a daily basis in these buildings and we're going to be spending money on these buildings and unfortunately that's just kind of the reality that we're at right now I don't want to be a downer but I'm just giving you the facts so to kind of get this conversation in summary form so that we can open up for your discussion with each other and to just let us know know what's on your mind um we summarize everything in a y now this is a a list of key things you know as as our team we we are always looking for the proactive solution we're looking for root causes and we're not looking for um Band-Aids we're looking for permanent Solutions are going to make the difference in kids lives and so for these reasons um

111we are saying now is the time when when you look at the big picture and all the impact of of slowing this down um what it would do so first investing in an immediate lasting solution keeps the district on track for General funds remaining dedicated to classrooms and education so this is directly to students and staff the minute any of the things that we shared on the slides today have to become the funding priority it has to take from somewhere and the only somewhere left is the student and staff experience the facility plan that we have addresses the enrollment growth the Aging buildings challenges and Equity across the district that's been well established and well supported by this board and I would say throughout the community um as well in terms of onward and upward

112and this is a a catchphrase we've used a brand that we've used over the last couple years to express the investment in the covid federal relief dollars and we give a lot of credit to those Investments where we put our money and the outcomes that we're receiving and so this targeted investment in education in curriculum programs services and people things we would have never been able to do without the additional money it sealed strong return on investment for us it's helped us increase academic achievement and overall success with our students without a long-term solution these Investments that the what we've been able to spend our money on which is in the classroom changing educational outcomes all that money all those investments will will put our current academic success at risk and I I just want

113to be very clear about that because you can't improve outcomes in subject areas if you're not using updated materials if you're not developing your staff if you're not providing the technology they need uh to stay competitive without additional funds for facilities in summary our operational costs will be diverted from classrooms and what we'll spend money on is expanding spaces just like what we talked about that the Wade and SE plan I'm calling it with modular we'll spend our money there and we will continue to maintain the Aging buildings without a long-term facilities plan um all those short-term mitigations we talked about before increas in class size consideration of moving to half day kindergarten traveling teachers targeted redistricting modular classrooms um leasing spaces uh there there are several things a combination of these would become the

114long-term solutions for the district we've talked earlier about timing mattering ofcc does provide a state share of this project that's not something that's here with us forever so there is an urgency with that and then finally as I wrap up why why now I I feel like this has been such a badge of honor of this board and the school district over the course of the year as we've worked to transform the school district and change the culture and that is that stakeholder voice really matters we've spent at least the last three years engaging our community elevating the voice of students staff and families and community so that everyone has a say in what's happening that they get to choose what kind of school district and what kind of experience they want for their kids

115we've made it very clear that um school choice is here to stay and we want to make sure that West Claremont is a is a district of choice and not only I I was this is another little small story I was at Rotary the other day and I'm um presenting to a group of people and afterwards one of the um one of the members of roie was saying you know I'm I'm working with like a lot of different kids from your school and she's like they all like they all go to the high school but they all like have really different schedules and she was just so puzzled and then she said as I started asking questions I started realizing there's just many different ways to do high school now they have lots of choice

116and she said I've so puzzled at first and then she goes that is the coolest thing ever I wish it happened for me and so it's it's one of those things that um providing that kind of choice not just the choice to come to West Claremont but choices inside of the school day um is important people want a voice and how their education goes it's it's an important value of this community and and through this whole process we've been talking about our community having a voice having a say so I believe strongly that our community expects this to be on the ballot and expects to have a voice in this and and our community deserves to have a right to say what kind of District that they want to have and what kind of community

117that they have because there's been a long longterm um connection between the schools that you have in your community and the value of your homes and the value of your community and so so this is the why now for me so I'll leave this slide deck or this slide up here just to kind of remind you of the big picture and um you know I I'd like to just turn it now over to you guys as board members to to talk to reflect and to let us know um if not now when uh when all of these things should be addressed thank you Miss Adams um if I can actually start and then I'll we'll kind of go around and have everybody kind of speak their piece so for me the question of if not

118now when is a challenging one that resonates deeply within the community and this board many individuals are grappling with the urgency of the question and seeking a clear path forward I realize that as a whole when we think about our district we think about the newly constructed West Claremont High School Summerside willowville WT and even the newly remodeled CL Pike however I want to share some facts that the community may may not realize about some of our aging facilities we've already covered some of them but I'll just reiterate Holly Hill Elementary was built in 1982 with some additions in 1996 it is nearing capacity I'm sorry yes it is nearing capacity and the roof is approaching the end of service life and may need some repair soon mwin Elementary was built in 1966 with some

119additions in 1993 it is overc capacity which we currently have mod modular on the campus to help with the overcrowding that gives us some additional room a professional roof evaluation found that all roof sections are at the end of its service life when we talk about West Claremont Middle School that was built in 1961 the school underwent some additions in 1998 2000 and 2017 the most recent updates included constructing a hallway to connect the former Amilia high school with the Amilia Middle School um renovating the main cafeteria to make it Lar knocking out some walls and painting the building our middle school students are housed in a building that was designed for high school and not Middle School a professional Roofing evaluation determined that 10 sections of the roof have reached the end of its

120service life if we as a district want to continue in the direction that we're headed in then we as a board will need to be ready to adjust the operational budget for significant costs with HVAC Roofing parking plumbing and additional modular units meaning that monies that would may be diverted away from students in classrooms which will have an impact on the academic achievement within our district if we continue on the path we are currently on progress made in our upward and onward investment will be stalled so if not now when I believe the time has come for the community to have their voices heard and to be given the opportunity to voice their opinion on ways to accomplish this I'm sorry one way of accomplishing this is by placing it on the ballot while I

121understand that our district will incur a cost by placing the bond levy on the ballot the cost of neglecting NE necessity Capital Improvements will ultimately be far greater so I ask the question if not now when thank you Miss Spencer do you have anything um well the the big question is when would be a perfect time to ask for the taxpayers to pay more for the a aging buildings I don't know that there is a perfect time I don't know when that would be I do know in the past year our constituents and everyone in Claremont County has raised our property taxes 30% everyone's was at least 30% mine personally went up 43% but as far as when is a perfect time I'm really not a business person I understand the concept of needing new

122things but as I was if I run my household my household is you don't spend more than you make and it's sometimes you have to wait it's not a no it's just let's wait to see what the future holds maybe next year everyone will feel a little bit more at ease with the new Administration coming in maybe things change maybe our uh enrollment won't jump up as high as everyone seems to think it will who it's hard to say I understand your pro your thing says it it's like 97% accurate I I don't know it's hard to Guess that and no one could have ever guessed that we would have had a pandemic right that wasn't in the five-year forecast right so things do happen and things change and I'm hoping and praying that in

123the next year people feel a little bit more comfortable and maybe they'll feel that our district has made every effort to use the resources we have to stretch our dollar a little bit more a little bit longer so maybe maybe now next year but as of right now this year I don't feel comfortable saying yes to this putting it on the ballot for in I I think it's a lot to ask for our community to do yet again so let's talk about the maybe next year because when you look at the Timeline because this is what I'm fixated on is time maybe next year means at the same time an operational Levy is is to be on so let's talk about that well whether we do the bond or not we will have an operational

124ly is that correct correct right yes so maybe we can combine it and maybe people would feel a little bit more accurate but to say that I mean the bond issue was supposed to be for Building but if we put the bond issue the way it is right now it will be also used for operational is that correct bond is building bond is bond is building everything about what we're talking about are building so if we if we won't have to have an operational Levy then in the 202 if we pass the bond Levy so no that's not correct no that's confused when we do it yeah so the way it and if if you focus on this chart okay that is the plan that for the last 18 months we've been looking at we

125actually started backwards we know that in 2030 we will be on the ballot for either a renewal of that emergency Levy or depending on the financial situation a replacement for an increase to that okay so we that's that's the choice that we have and it's really going to depend what's H what happens there as we work backwards just focusing on operational we knew okay that we would have to come back to the voters one in 2020 it's just unfortunately the way schools are funded in this state okay we have to we go back and we ask the voters to approve additional funding for us lot of it depends on what the state gives us the state looks at your community and says what's your ability to you know to fund your schools what's the what's

126you know the wealth capacity to do it they look at property values they look at income to do that we're on that guarantee so we we knew in 2020 at some point in time we'd have to come back the commitment was made to 24 current forast extends that to 26 yes that was made possible by the valuation increase there's no no question about that okay to do that but but we know based on this forecast that we will have to come back if we can push it to 27 we will do that okay in order to do that well and I just don't think we celebrate the 24 like I just want to pause that for a minute because the 2020 Levy passed and what we said to people it was a 7.99 mil Levy

127the largest operating Levy that's passed in in West Claremont and the and the the tagline was just maintain what we have it wasn't add anything and because of the Investments with upward and onward we were able to add things into the system that were basic needs like curriculum like right sizing our staff technology things that should be in schools if that's your core business you should have those things compensating staff I'm sorry compensating and compensating staff and um so so not only did it not have to we didn't have to come back in 24 we added value to the district that amount of the time been able to maintain with that help of the um the evaluation so so that that's a key thing that that was never in the cards to happen it was

128never in the cards and it was also planned that um as we as we put that plan together which which I think the key to putting that plan together was the you know we base our decisions and recommendations off the data and information that we have this District already had the data information of what they needed to do so when the Esser funding came in place the two things we we wanted to do and did was what what what's missing that everybody already told us and we identified as missing but at the same time there was there was this Global fear of because of the federal funding that there was this cliff in 24 when when he had to spend that money by and so we wanted to make sure that if we do these

129Investments we weren't putting ourselves or putting that general fund in Jeopardy of falling off the cliff quote unquote to do that and that I mean that's what this team did put that together to do it but it was really based off the date information that we had in hand had in hand at that time to do it keep working backwards we knew you know two three years ago that there were facility needs um at our schools at least the three of the schools and the three oldest ones that uh there had been a roofing plan that had been in place there were other things that were happening with boilers and with walls and different things we knew the windows to do it that's why we went and had um the evaluations with ofcc and do

130we build new do we replace it what do we do they have formulas that tell you should you replace it should you build new should you renovate to new and those different things we knew we had to do that because it it was and as Mr Gart showed in the series of slides okay okay there are costs that we will incur if we don't have a facility plan that remedies our needs whether it's enrollment or whether it's the Aging school buildings okay whether in the enrollment there's an increase in special needs that uh the the special needs you know have a class size of eight versus a class size of 25 and that makes a significant difference in where we're going especially when our special needs um in is increasing so as we work backwards

131to some point in time and I I do this in my head she visually puts it on paper and and we're there okay because you you don't want to go back as many times as you can you want to make commitments to your community that hey we're going to make good use of the funds and hey here's how long it's going to last okay this facility plan is is is going to last last a long time because we did the combination with it and because of the wording with that combination that that those funds are dedicated to Capital Capital Improvements to those new buildings there there is on the dollar amount for the bonds it's a fixed dollar amount on the bonds based on the valuation accouny auditor sets that millage if history repeats itself

132and we know valuation goes up up the amount of that millage will go down on the school district income tax side which was a specific response to what we heard the community say that that they're they're that there are um homes there are properties there are residents that um the the taxing is a problem that's why we shifted to the school district income tax tax for half of it to take it and and look at how do we do this in a more fair way to to everybody that's out there without losing taxation to commercial industrial uh utilities agricultural want to make sure that they players in the game too with us that's why the property is there but the income tax was was looking at how do we make this total more of a

133fairway so when we when we look at the bond or we look at the facilities planning and the financing of it if we don't do something now okay we will have a levy in 26 if we can push it to 27 we will do that the amount of that millage will depend upon a if we do have a facilities funded plan there'll be a certain dollar amount if we don't it will be a higher millage amount it's just because those expenses which added up to 5657 million even even if we split that up over time 10 years okay just average it out $5 million a year that's going to add a millage amount additional Mills to that operating fund because there there's nowhere else to to get the money from except out of our operating

134fund if we don't want to add to it okay that's that is direction to me to tell the person to my left tell me where tell me what you want to take out of the budget because I can't end the year in a negative number that's got to be positive if we go on too far okay and this is realistic this is real okay State comes in and says hey your projection is not as good as it should be tell us tell us your recovery plan and if you can't give us a pretty good recovery plan and you're going in that negative Direction okay then we may have to to come and take you over you may have to do that so the facility plan does impact the operating plan it's it's I mean they're

135connected together that's saying facility plan affects the operational plan correct right okay it just it won't keep it from happening no okay yeah but the thing of it is is and if you look at that time chart every decision at one point has an impact or consequence in that future position so go or no Go in 25 okay impacts what we do in 26 or if we can push it to 27 that what we do on that impacts what we do in 2030 okay because it'll it'll you know the millage amount that we go there we're going to project that can last so long and and I mean the best opportunity in 2030 is a renewal we just ask the voters you've been giving this dollar amount give us the same dollar amount if if

136we don't have some things along the way then we're going to have to ask for a replacement I mean it so the way they interact with each other if a master facility plant isn't in place money will start affecting the financial operating the operating budget and it will mean we spend money on just operating not educating correct none of these are looked in they're all looked in together and I think that's why you titled this the big picture because it they are all connected together and that's what I just going to be really clear about is like something has to stop so something else can happen and so we just have to know that those are those are the decisions we're we're sitting here making so Tammy your your suggestion is is wait a year

137and see what what the future holds with the new Administration how how the people feel a little bit more at ease without having to pay this large property tax this year 2024 this was The Big Year everybody paid it for the solid year when you say when you say next year if we ask them to pay this in May or whenever it would go on the ballot that would be even asking them to pay even more and we remember it plus that like this plus that would be what would be 26 is saying yeah yeah so next year well if we would wait it I understand the harm and waiting a year but is it going to guarantee or people going to feel a little bit better about it I mean if this doesn't come

138cheap I mean none of this stuff when you put it on the ballot it's going to cost on the on the cheap end 50,000 on the high end 125 that's coming out of our budget right out of our school budget correct right not that that's a lot but it is right so to I mean it's just I feel like a lot of people are struggling with paying this let us settle down and get our get our feel you know get it settle down a little bit and then maybe everyone I would feel personally a little bit better about it but that doesn't mean that everybody will that's just the way I feel and the people that I've talked to feel I'll uh I'll pay you back on it just a little bit I thought there

139would be more um concern in the community when we started bringing these things to the table um I was expecting to hear from a lot of people about it and I did hear from people about it and I was surprised that it's the opposite okay uh I I mean most of the young families that I'm involved with at mwin um through our church and other community um programs I mean I have not heard one against um I've heard support and I'm I'm I'm honestly flabbergasted by that um I think us as a board since I've been here we've been looking at these things kind of from from a high point and um we've seen these these um things on the horizon um the concerns we're having that we're discussing for the last year and a

140half and and over a year and a half ago we we asked you to take a dive into this and to um dig into this and and peel back the layers and to find out a solution that would would would be best um and and you did you did an incredible job um you and your staff and the community teams that that got involved um came together and and worked hard putting in time energy and resources um and brought together um the the best plane you could come up with and honestly I think it would be negligence to um not go with that or or come up with a better solution um I think as board members we're here to make tough decisions um for the students um I'm often I often think of this

141Thomas Payne line um um if tough times are to come I hope they come in my time so that um my children can have peace and uh that hits me hard a lot because that's why I'm here um to make these tough decisions for my children um and I don't want to kick the can down the road we have we have schools that are 60 60 years old how how much further can you kick that can down the road um and and and one of the big issues is we have so many schools so like we're talking about kind of refining that even and that would help tremendously in the long run so um we are at we're at a tough board um we can come together to make a tough decision because we have

142big shoulders to lay lay these things upon um and and we have a tough Community who has our back because we've we've earned their respect and we've we've gone to them and we've talked to them and and they've seen that and we've honored our promises um and and I think that I think they're going to come together with us um that that's what I've heard and that's what I see and uh I think I think it'll happen um I don't think we have to wait longer to try and try and gain more of that I think it's there um we've put a lot of time and energy into making that happen and it it has happened um it's there so if we're going to make that decision I think we need to make it sooner

143rather than later because later it's just going to be it's going to snowball and it's going to be a bigger mess um yeah I mean I don't want a bigger mess I want to I want to I want to make these tough decisions now thank you Mr CH Miss Sor I don't believe in my heart that the bond Levy will pass in May of 2025 the taxpayers deserve a break in 2025 use the time to do a survey in 2025 put the bond Levy in 2026 operating Levy in 2027 that gives the taxpayers time to recoup from the 23% tax increase and the economy in 2024 just recently in November of 2024 Bassa put out a report on the levies income tax and permanent Improvement operating levies emergency renewal 16 of the 18 passed for

14489% current expense renewal 13 of the 14 passed for 93% current expense new four of the 11 passed which is 36% Bond Levy five of 14 passed for 36% earned income tax new zero uh they had seven schools and none of them passed for new earned income tax renewal zero for two schools this is the information that was in November of 2024 um that I found on the Bassa website so I think at this time that I would like to see us wait as as much as possible to do this when the taxpayers have a more opportunity to recoup from what theyve paying right now and to give them a chance to say in 2025 that in 20 26 they'll be ready to do the bond and then operating in 2027 I really think that

145it's fair for the taxpayers and I really think that is fair for this West Claremont Community thank you so let's talk more about that uh proposal on the table here is a bond in 26 and operating in 27 and you can see from the chart we're saying it operating in 26 so what what I keep seeing in this story is the bond and the operating colliding in 26 that that's what I feel like I'm hearing tonight and so I just want to talk what what is that mean what does a bond because you can do such a thing as you bundle them together and it's one you you put them out separately there are risks in all those decisions so let's just talk about like what would that mean what would that look like so

146that everyone understands um because that's really our job tonight I mean we we are serve at the will of the board and the direction that the board gives us it's our job however to make sure that um we're looking at all the pieces and all the ripple effect because n no decision just sits on an island and just sits there so uh so the the topic on the table is Bond 2627 is that really even a topic that that would mean that would mean cutting I get like if if you're if you're going to oper do an operating Levy in 27 if if we can't do it because right now we're saying 26 we'll stretch it to 27 if we can't but let's say we can't that means cutting into the operating right now now

147so the so the question becomes what are we going without in the school district to do this and what what what is um the bond in 26 going to look like I feel like if people are struggling with potentially coming up with one if that's what I'm hearing I think they're going to struggle even more to come up with two I can come up with a dollar today and come up with $2 next year so I I don't I guess I just I'm trying to understand the if we're doing I just don't think we're going to get to if you're saying we're going to struggle now and I guess for me and I'm sorry I jumped ahead of you a bit but for me you know I understand my role as a board we are

148now a board this is when we make decisions when I'm at the grocery store that's not when I make decisions I can hear people talk I can tell you that my constituents that I've spoke with and I've been speaking to them more some of them maybe weren't as educated as they should be maybe they didn't have this information and I've had to to forward the information on um I've I have not heard anything negative now when you talk about money 100% I don't want to spend money I don't I am working on my house right well I'm not I'm paying someone to work on my house I signed over my life because I had to go get a loan I don't want to do that but the end game when I'm going to be able

149to enjoy my new house and the new individual in the area that I'm at I'm going to like that and so that's that's where I think I think what we as the board are trying to decide and anybody can correct me if I'm wrong is is we are not trying to decide that we're going to tax anybody but what we are saying is is that something's got to give and it's going to cost us money either way let the people decide give them an opportunity to hear their V let their voices be heard let them see what they want from us then that will give us guidance if it comes back and it fails miserably which I hope it doesn't the that says hey Natasha Dan you better get to work but at least let

150them have the opportunity what I'm hearing tonight is is we're saying no Community you do not get an opportunity we're going to kill it here we're not even going to give you an opportunity to tell us what you want so that's what I you know and again the public speaking that we've had we've had the most here recently all of them majority of them that have spoke has spoke about the taxes that has been their main statement is is the taxes we get it nobody wants to pay more taxes I can assure you I do not want to pay more taxes there have been people that have been speaking that have spoke for it if you look at our cat team that does not has not come and spoke publicly about it but they're on

151the cat team they're the ones that endorsed this if you look at the CAC team they've endorsed it so if you look at those amount of people then then we have that and so I guess at the end of the day and and I'll jump to you Mr Ry but at the end of the day all our vote is is to let them make the decision that's what our vote is and and we can spend the money if you said what would you say the lowest 50 there are going to be other things on the ballot I can assure you of that the townships are going to have stuff on the ballot um so there's going to be other things hopefully it'll be cheaper but still 50 it is because you share and again and

152again I want someone to correct me if I'm wrong that's not a cost we decide that is the board of election that's to to run it correct that's right so they pass on to us and so but if even if we don't do something we're going to have to do something and one of the things that I want to clarify and I continue to say this to you every time you say these things these things up here that you're saying that are that are are are going to maybe be shortterm fixes or even long-term fixes these are not threats this is reality this isn't us sitting up here and saying if you don't give us what we want this is what we're going to do to the community I hated when that happened when I

153worked in the district these are not threats this is reality yeah and that's why like that's why we work together to establish what are our problems so that we're all working toward the same problems and those are truly like real time issue or answers to the problems and it's just just a matter of what district do we want to have who do we want to be because there are consequences to every piece of this it takes away if we make the kindergarten decision that's going to take away from academics for students that might be the thing we have to do otherwise we could be redistricting a whole side of the district it could be extremely disruptive and maybe have a different impact and so that that's why I just keep saying I want people to

154picture like okay if we kick the cam and move it to next year we've now landed a levy and a bond together what does that mean what is that size what happens if it passes what happens if it fails and so like all those things really have to be thought about and talked about because it's it's it's one thing to see it on paper it's another thing to talk about it so that's why I just want you to truly like picture picture of these problems that that David and Chuck and and Randy talked about tonight continuing to be here picture kids continuing to show up here picture the bond not passing and the levy not passing a year from now because we waited for things to to to play out picture a wall falling in

155the bathroom because of the structural damage picture that picture your kids in the next classroom picture that like that's what we have and again we gave Town Hall meetings I I we've shown these buildings this isn't us sitting up here saying the sky is falling all the sky is falling you need to give this is reality this is reality and if we're talking about like pushing things further to give people a year of breathing room we're talking about coming back in 26 and then coming back in 27 and then coming back in 2030 like there's no breathing room there like or you could bundle them like she said if we're if we're afraid of of our community um rejecting this I'd be more afraid of them rejecting something much larger I was going to say

156yeah if you bundle it it's got to be much larger because you got to get it so it's and and if we're and if we're afraid of our community rejecting this I'm Not Afraid well if we're afraid of it failing um I've been in meetings where the community was opposed to something I've seen outside board meetings in other districts of communities opposed to something and they are filling these seats and they are showing up voicing their complaints uh at that Podium out the line like we're not getting that and and that um plus what I'm hearing just personally out of my own um that's that's a great sign that is a great sign for this and what if in a year from now things are are worse financially for everyone in this community what if

157two years from now things aren't better and and um and whatever like we can we can we can say that all we want and and that's again that's just kicking the can down the down the road and um well the what if is this because I will say it can't be a surprise to anybody in West clama because the what if has been lived yeah the what if is we have to operate because kids keep showing up so what do we do we put money into that side of the house we stopped putting money in education we did not update curriculum here for over a decade in multiple subject areas some almost two decades but miraculously in that statement a lot of the kids still graduated high school and are still very productive members of

158society so I understand what you're saying but we also have to give the Educators a very big hats off to what they have accomplished in those 20 years of not updating the curriculum my students my children happen to be in that mix when all that happened and every one of my children are very productive members of society and many of their friends are too and now they teach at West clont so I understand what you're saying but let's also give credit where credit is due where that was a bad dark time in West Claremont but we still had a lot of survivors that came out ahead and they look they're great members of society right now so every hat I have is tipped off to our staff staff I think they are the most incredible

159Educators I've ever worked with so that that's that's not TR but I'll will say as superintendent my responsibility is all children I believe all kids can learn and I'm the person that's responsible to make that happen I believe that I want to know every student's name their story their strengths their need and I want to respond all means all what you talked about just then was some some kids were very successful without curriculum without the resources that they needed absolutely hands down 100% accurate not all kids and so what we've tasked ourselves as a board is to look at equity and to say all kids deserve no matter what house you live in what street you're on what school you go to all kids deserve to have the opportunities and that's what we have really

160turned around here schools are performing in the school district right now that are on the lower socioeconomic side of things and they are increasing their performing performance at at amazing rates that's because we're leveling the playing field with the resources that we poured in so this is uh not a statement at all to take away anything from the past because it is absolutely incredible um incredible what has happened in the school district I'm just saying in the window of time that we've had to invest in all kids in different ways we are seeing results and the feedback that I receive on The Daily is we want to see more of that for all kids not some kids thank you Mr R I'm sorry neglected you all right Tammy I want to address something with you

161with the um the increased resources the report cards gone up and something I've noticed that kids really enjoy coming to school that a lot of them didn't like doing before and I think that's that's due a lot to these resources and the different plans of the high school um when I visited I couldn't believe everything going on and I was very skeptical about that large high school but it was pretty darn cool and I was thinking I maybe I wouldn't mind being a student again and going there because of so many different things I believe that we need to tell uh the taxpayers tell us what they think about this I think it's our duty as a board member as board members to put it on the ballot and let them decide I feel very

162strongly about that um I also am very big on equity I did not I didn't come from poverty but I came from a family of uh sufficient means uh I have three brothers we all went to college we all did very well um I have four nieces and a nephew we're all they're all college educated um and I just I think looking back in my high school it wasn't Equitable I was lucky my entire family has been lucky but when I look at some of the the areas here uh I don't know if I could be a student in Merwin not because of Mrs Parker she's absolutely wonderful but that building is depressing to me they do the best that they can um I think it's horrible with the the space issues in Holly Hill

163Merwin and the middle school and I love that Middle School building now I spent 13 very happy years there but it needs to go and be redone it's just not fair to the kids when you look at the high school versus the middle school it's sinful it's a crime what they have and it was bad when I was there um 13 years ago so I know things have gotten worse I don't want to see good money thrown at patching these things up or we could get new and not have to worry about it as much I just feel very very strongly that we need to put this on the ballot and let them tell us whether they want to support it or not and the indicators are there that we have a lot of support

164and I also think it's insulting to the cat people who are community members not to support them fully we've supported them up to this point as a board we need to continue to support by putting them the ballot and if the voters reject it we'll go from there but at least we'll know and ten you mentioned surveys I think a lot of surveying has been done and I I am one that used to do every survey I came across I'm surveyed out and I know it's not just me because every time I get an email there's something about a survey in there or every time you go to Walmart or Kroger they give you opportunity to do surveys on the receipt and I I don't think we need anymore we know what we're doing or

165what we need to do I should say the decision and Natasha you can correct me if I'm wrong is the decision at some point in the near future that the board would make is is do we put on the ballot and let the voters decide if the board decides to not even give that opportunity then the next decision that we as the board is going to make is is where are we going to make cuts and how is that going to look that will be the next decision uh those two will come to us with a proposal and they will say this is what you because again correct me if I'm wrong we don't tell her what to cut we tell her the amount of money that needs to be cut she then goes and

166comes back to us so that could be band that could be music that could be uh no more right that could be sport I mean it could just be a whole slew of things then that will be a decision that we will make the only thing that we will own today well not today we're not owning today but is if we allowed the community to make their voices heard that's what we own moving forward what we own is is getting rid of programs and getting rid of the educational the academic piece of it because we now have to take that money and move it into something else so I I mean again I just go back to me personally my constituents that have come to me uh has had uh a they have had the

167um will to listen to be educated to understand the process um I've given them information uh my constituents have said that the middle school should have been torn down when it was ailia so again I just I I think that any constituents that need to be heard need to come forward and be heard unfort un we're not under public speaking we under we missed that opportunity you can get us afterwards though okay thank you um so again I don't know if there's any other well I I just appreciate appreciate you guys taking the time to to process all this I know we've been working on we've been on a journey for quite a while it's been very intense it's been information overload and it's it's just it's my responsibility and Dan's responsibility to make sure

168that we are making it very clear all the impacts to the decisions are I don't feel like we got too far in the like it's like we can picture up to 25 but we can't quite picture beyond that I that's how I feel tonight like I don't have a good picture of if we didn't go now what really would happen and um the weight and see thing has consequences and so we would start working through if we if we go with the weit and see plan we would start working on that through the May forecast and the and the budgeting for next year and so that Pro I mean once the calendar year starts we we start planning all of that and so it's it's a um that reality will start setting in and we'll

169need to hear more and more from you about what is not a priority and what is a priority because everything that we've done up to this point has has been supported so it's it's confusing so we we'll need more Direction on what you don't want to invest in versus what you do want to invest in because if we if we really boil it down like part of the goal of the Strategic plan is to look at facilities and also to look at start time so there'd be an investment in transportation as a part of this um at this table we've talked about investing in safety in a deeper way and so the those kinds of things we've talked about updating our media centers to bring literacy to life and to change those opportunities all those

170things take a far back seat to basic needs is is what really happens and so I I just want to make sure everyone understands that that in all these things that we've been talking about when facil with those dollar amounts become the show everything else is not just a minute away it's years away and let's use this example like when I said a few minutes ago we've seen what happens this has already happened in L Claremont think how long ago it was when specials left the elementary and then know that in seven years ago when I got here there was like two day two to three days of specials a month so that was like slowly being brought back and we are still we are at four days like we still there's still basic things

171that are not full level and so so I use that as an illustration because it's it's you know with having those kids here today it just it just speaks to you of okay it's taken well over well over a decade and we're still not back to something that existed here like in the 90s and so everything that we talk about changing that outcome for middle school kids to not have to start at the very crack of dawn um to to better their education to stabilize Middle School to ensure that we have staff who want to work here and want to be with us and we don't churn and burn administrators every year or two we've got to think about this because the the more you push back the further away those kinds of things go

172and so it it may be the choice it may be what we have to do the voters may tell us in May we're not interested in this and those might be the decisions I just want everybody going in knowing full well like what what will become of West Claremont because we have lived through hard times and had to fight back we are in this middle of like getting to be very healthy and not only healthy but performing well we were this close to 4.5 Stars we were this close and all that becomes compromised and I I don't say that as a well we'll just all give up and we'll stop working I don't mean that I mean these are big decisions that start having ripple effect effects with our Workforce who choose to be here

173with the resources that we have and the time that we have to develop people to deliver this higher level of Education that we are trying to bring here so um my goal and Dan's goal over the course of the next several weeks will just be to continue to help people picture if if we're saying let's not do this now let's do it later what does later look like and what does it mean because the effort like we've spent eight 18 months talking about this so like what's it going to take how many more months would it take to talk about that next thing because you you can't take up you can't think about one topic you can't think about one year you have to think all the way out to 2030 and know your moves

174and and that's what we'll need to know we'll need to know our move so we can make decisions about Staffing decisions about space decisions about short-term mitigations so it's it's not so easy just to say well no I don't like this we have to say okay now what and we have to think through all the scenarios and so I'm just I'm saying like we'll do it you'll do it this this has to be together do you want to say anything no I well I think that you know the big thing for me is in putting a financial plan together to follow the program and the plan that you want for your District okay there is a there's a balance there's the balance between what the district needs for its students for its staff um for

175an educational program that we have there is a balance on the community side because of the valuation increases because of the taxes that they pay there is no question with that I that that is a reality okay but it is it is our our jobs our responsibility to provide the information to the board to provide the opportunity to the community to make the decision of of what they want and and you know when I keep looking at this chart I keep going through my head again as okay if we don't do this here I know we're going to have to do something else other than what you know what the numbers say right on that forecast for 25 26 that's a that's a reality it's not it's it's not a threat it is something that

176needs to be done with it and each each decision Point each perp each uh vertical line there there there's some decisions that need to be made that's that's what's going on and based on that decision it's going to imp what's up the road that that is there we we can't say maybe Tina I want to respond to the Bassa report I can't say for sure because I didn't pull any of those districts but I bet there was some sort of consequence because those didn't pass okay and I'm I'm sure the school district let the voters know that and voters decided okay they decided rather than this you know we'll accept the you know that that decision one way or the other I mean that that's okay and we respond to that the board will respond

177to that as we go through it um but I think sometimes just say here was our plan and and if we wait okay then there's further things on up the road one thing that I don't want to have to happen is we don't do this and somewhere in 25 in in 26 and there's a larger Mage amount okay than what we uh present that we you know then what could be for the operating fund if someone look back and say well why didn't you why why didn't you give us the opportunity back then because now look what we're faced with and such it's just that's there so um I've never been over 44 years I've never been part um of a decision like this that hasn't you know people struggled over making that decision it's

178not an easy one it isn't okay and I respect the fact that you you took the opportunity and congratulate Natasha for for giving the opportunity to discuss it that that's what this is a real board meeting right it's not just us presenting something and we taking a roll call and you're saying you know five yes okay it's it's about you know you meet in a public for to have Del Liberation and that's what you were really doing with this okay so pat yourself on the back for that because some some boards don't do that okay so that I mean that that's good that you're doing that these decisions are not easy okay but the decisions do have consequences I mean that's that's where it's at and we just we we need direction that's what she

179needs that's what I need that's what these people out here need you know as we put some things together is if it's not this okay then then here's some other things that we need to do okay and we'll follow through with that so again just to kind of wrap up I mean so obviously if we decide to not do a bond then we need to then make the next steps so what it looks like is that going to be a double Levy in 26 for a bond or that we just start thinking because that that will be the next step and then potentially owning whatever it is that we as a board will want to be to do away with within our district to be able to sustain falling walls and bathrooms that aren't working

180hvx that has to be replaced and so just think about that is there anything else anybody would like to State comments any other last final words everybody good Natasha is there anything else I think I do have more agenda items than my computer as far as this piece this uh no know um I I just appreciate everyone's participation tonight and I know you've been thinking about it a lot and um but we'll just continue this conversation in terms of procedurally we would need to bring this to the board in January and have it passed by the end of January to be able to get it technically on the ballot so there is like there's some timeline constraints that come into place in January and um we would need um to be able to put it

181on the ballot we would need a um a a 4-1 Vote or a 50 vote to be able to do that so so that's kind of like what January will bring to us okay can you repeat that sure um in we will bring it back in January uh the resolution of necessity or sorry to proceed as the final step um so for a vote and it has to be done inside the month of January so that uh we meet the timelines to be able to file with um the auditor's office and Department of Taxation so we're still on target to like meet that deadline and in order for um this to be able to be put on the ballot we would need a 41 Vote or a 0 vote um to put it on the

182ballot okay so um and that's that's unique in the situation um that's because typically it's it's a it's it's 32 in this situation because it's a combo Levy it h uh which means it's a combination of property taxes as well as income taxes there's a high higher level of um two a two-thirds of the board a higher standard than um than most most votes so I just want to make sure was clear about that I was so that's all I have and I'm still trying to turn on my computer and figure out where we are okay so the transportation update I'll get my computer turn back on it's tired good evening what I have for you is just information only our contract with Peter man fires in July so we have to do an RFP

183or request for a proposal so Dan um Randy and I will put together the proposal and bring it to you we hope to get it out in January and we do anticipate several other companies bidding on our transportation so if you have any questions following I mean next month let me know thanks I'll keep my comments brief I I do want to just celebrate the staff oflu and willville this summer or this weekend um they and I I know there were many events there was an event at the high school this weekend with a nutcracker um and there will probably be more this weekend so so many special family events that have been hosted and it's just very heartwarming to be in a setting where moms and dads and grandmas and grandpas and kids and

184aunts and uncles are enjoying the their time together and have such a good feeling about West Claremont and such pride and um interested in you know talking to me telling our story we we do believe everyone's story matters every voice matters and and that's that's why we're going into this 2025 with the the video series that I that we kicked off with tonight I also want to take a moment to uh thank the community for their support with um our very sad news of our very own Kevin ther principal of um K Pike Elementary um we we received such sad news this weekend about him not being able to return because of a fatal brain disease and um the staff has really rallied together um tomorrow is going to be a very hard day for

185them so I just ask for everyone's thoughts and prayers as they face their students and face their building um in a in a in a new way and um and and process and and just and learn how to Rally around each other and to do what Mr ther would expect which is for everyone to do their job get back to work learn and keep that the number one priority and so um obviously the SA amilies and our thoughts and prayers and we as a community want to respect their privacy as they are coping with this very tragic news and um you know we love Kevin with all of our heart um he is certainly a legend around West Claremont schools so um as time goes on we'll we'll provide more information but I just want

186to lift up that staff tomorrow they they were really incredible today and all the wraparound Services I will say the cabinet team we have a protocol that we follow when we have crises everybody has their role everyone played it very well it um you know was headed up by Eric duel and I just thank you so much there you are um for for all those efforts for Becky with communication um we know it's hard news for for families to hear in the last minute the school is canceled and I just didn't get any negative feedback people are very understanding and appreciative of the time and space that we gave our staff today to be the very best that can be for our students tomorrow so um I'm extremely proud of of where this District is

187and the way we come together in the hardest of times so that that's all I have and and I guess this this will be our last board meeting before the holiday season so um just Merry Christmas to everyone and we'll enjoy and all the next days leading up to the holiday and be refreshed and renewed for a very strong 2025 that's it thank you Miss Adams Mr Romano okay um item 11.1 is a request for a change order it is for the ofc see project that is still on our books this is for some work that was done on the Broner property um on a batement and demolition um the work uh has been done there was some rework that was done not this past summer but the summer before last there were some extenuating

188circumstances that that this this dragged on we're trying to close out that last segment that we've had so the request is for a change order of $1,831 126 to rain rainbow environmental um my understanding in the past not all these were brought but I've just been conditioned that if it's a change order to a Construction contract I'm going to put it in front of the board um as asked this was paid um there are funds left in the um and there were funds left um in the um the the co- segment so 70% was paid by us 30% by the state with that so um the request is to approve the authorization to execute and pay for change order to Rainbow environmental in the amount of$ 10,831 126 thank you Mr Rano you've heard the

189recommendation would someone like to make a motion please moved thank you Mr Ry is there a second thank you Mr chman is there any discussion I oh sorry sorry is this 10,000 83126 is this soil that is was contaminated with asbest or what was this or was this in the building itself this actually wasn't related to the part of the contract was when you do the removal okay it's the abatement and that so that was a much bigger part of the of the contract and job this is this was really I think restricted to the land putting putting land back restoring yeah after so so so does this cover the books are we done I mean is there anything else we need to do this part of it we're done there there's about three or

190four other little things that we just really need to trust me we've been how long has it been two there were two contractors I don't know what happened one didn't finish job foring property so thec H another contractor they finished it however the two contractors were bickering a little bit who did what so this is an attempt by the to solve that it's really already been solved this is just formality yeah okay to go through it's nothing the district did toally out of our well I started looking up like when did when was it demoed and it was like three years ago we still we still owed it yeah this this was this there was there was an issue that just kept dragging on and hanging on I know you know aside from Mr lefon

191and myself driving over there to two contractors and trying to take care of it thank you call please Mr Rudy yes Mr Chumley yes Miss sorn yes Mrs Spencer yes Mr Patton yes five yes um item 11.02 is authorization and confirmation of a settlement agreement this is a motion to approve the authorization and Confirmation settlement agreement of the West Claremont Local School District Board of Education and Mark and Angela Hodge for themselves and on behalf of their son Dustin hodj as presented um the uh settlement is paid by um our insurance company thank you you've heard the recommendation would someone like to make a motion thank you Mr Rudy is there a second second thank you Miss Sor is there any discussion roll call please Mr Rudy yes Miss Sor yes Mrs Spencer yes Mr

192Patton yes Mr chumbley yes five yes thank you and I will keep my comments real brief and I I think I I pretty much had said it earlier um this is that you know the topic we talked about this evening is not an easy topic um it's not an easy discussion certainly it's a it's it's complicated and although this is our last board meeting before you know uh the end of the end of the year before the holidays um I I wouldn't want it to be the last discussion that individually you have with a superintendent and I on this if there's more information if there's if there's more clarification that needs to be done please give one of us both of us a call we'll meet and you know we'll discuss it and give us

193as much information as we can um that we can look at you know uh addressing some things in January um with that so thank you all I have thank you looks like this is a little bit new territory for me here but it looks like the organizational meeting which will be set the first of the year it looks like we have to select a president pro term you have you have to select a president to um oversee the meeting and then there will be a process that night to select a new president do someone make a motion and then we I nominate Ryan first by second by nominations wait what are there any other nominations was there any other nominations uh Rudy for vice oh we're not doing that just do president we're just this

194is just for the January 6 meeting you don't need a uh so technically so Ryan's term Mr Rudy's Mr Patton's term and Mr Rudy's term as president and vice president and December 31st yeah so as you go into the organizational meeting at at this last December meeting you appoint um that the uh president protm to to begin the meeting okay then the first action you take at at that meeting is to elect new president so it's to really to start that meeting he breaks his hip on the way up why would you why would you say that Michael he's already done it work okay so is there any discussion so there's a nomination for Mr Pat yes do we have to second it no we we did that part so no discussion any others any

195others no okay take the vote well that we just need to call out that the meeting in here is January 6th at 7 o' that's what you're voting for here the you're you're voting to set that meeting January the president pro okay oh I didn't even see that part down there okay so yes so the board uh should establish the date uh for the meeting is January the 6th 2025 at 700 p.m. at the Union Township hall room that's probably downstairs here it's in here Civic Center oh okay I thought that was a different room so call the call the rooll there Mr Patton yes Mr Rudy yes Mr chumbley yes Miss sandor yes Mrs Spencer yes I yes thank you oh I'm sorry we're not done yet wow uh next is board comments um

196start with Mrs Spencer uh I just want to uh comment too on what Natasha said I also got to go to the um High School dance Nutcracker spin on The Nutcracker this Saturday and then afterwards they had Coco and we got to meet the dancers it was really nice I and my grandchildren went and they they loved it they thought it was really cool and they got to meet the dancers and that was they did a great job of hosting the cookies and the cocoa and the there was plenty of food for everyone and I thought it was very it was wonderful I thought it was well done as well that I hope everybody has a nice holiday break and enjoy family and loved ones thank you Miss ambor um I wasn't aware till tonight

197about the operating Levy going to be in 26 so now I'm going to have to rethink my thoughts alog together because I I didn't know that I thought it was going to really be in 2027 so that's why I said that um I will I will re re-evaluate my process and see what I come up with um so I I appreciate uh all that you have done and thank you for the facts that you have given us so far this year and um look for forward to January 2025 and Beyond really do uh Merry Christmas to everybody and happy New Year thank you Miss sord you're welcome Mr Chumley I'll jump on that H day Merry Christmas Happy New Year let's go oh there's a game tonight it's on right yeah I was waiting for

198that to come from you or Mr Gart 1710 don't spoil it Mr Rudy I just want to say happy holidays to everybody I'll keep it brief that brief uh I I too will keep it brief um I do appreciate the uh the elementary coming out today to saying that was nice to start at the beginning of our meeting again um Miss Adams Mr Romano I appreciate the time and effort that you and your team has have taken to be as transparent to the community as we can to be involved with the community as we can um and I appreciate what you guys have done I don't think I'm leaving out any so at this point we have no reason to go into executive session so would someone like to make a motion to thank you

199Mr Chumley Mr Rudy and Mr Chumley any discussion roll call please Mr Rudy yes Mr Chumley yes Miss sbor yes Mrs Spencer yes Mr Patton yes five yes January 6 January 6 yes January 6 7 P.M here at the Civic Center

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.