CorpusRecord 68182

December 16, 2024 Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Social WCS
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Franklin County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,402 words · about 25 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening thank you for attending the December 16th 2024 meeting of the Westerville City Schools Board of Education this evening's agenda will be displayed on the screens in the front of the room printed agendas are on the um table in the back or you may find the agenda on your mobile device by connecting to the district's website at www.wcsoh.org click on our district link select Board of Education and follow the board docs link to our current meeting agenda there will be two opportunities to address the board before it enters into before we um enter into a executive session there are signup sheets located located on the table in the back of the room each speaker will have five minutes to address the board a timer will be shown on the screen and with that Miss

002Marsha will you please call the role Mrs Davidson here Mrs Lan here Mrs Valentine here Mrs Alman here Mrs Meer here would you please join us in the Pledge of Allegiance Al to flag of the United States of amerce for all um we have no District highlights tonight um so next up is the superintendent's comments Miss hamur okay all right thank you I wanted to provide an update um since our ly failure on November 5th our team has been um busy working we've worked with our administrative team to eliminate 4.8 million from our budgets for this current year and then um looking ways to sustain and or increase that as we move forward into future years so I just want to share what some of those items are that we've pulled out of the budgets

003this year um we looked at some of the contracted services or repairs that typically are in our general fund we are postponing a K5 math curriculum adoption and using our current materials along with our special education math curriculum adoption we are reducing professional development opportunities um reducing purchases of other instructional materials and supplies such as textbooks magazines etc for media centers we are reducing the amount of instructional software that we have available we have some um unfilled school resource officer positions that um the police department hasn't been able to fill yet that we are going to um not fill for the remainder of this year and then um we'll want to have some dialogue about whether or not we would want to fill them moving forward as we look at Future rounds here um we're

004looking at other non-instructional materials and supplies so we have been under budget for fuel so we were able to reduce that line um we're able to defer replacement of our Access Control cards that we had planned to replace um those types of materials we have other um I mentioned some of the professional Technical Services so looking at like Design Services for projects making sure that all those are coming out of our um permanent Improvement fund versus a general fund looking at software like cronis that we use with our um routing software for our buses um moving that out the postponing replacing some of that um and some additional work that we have been doing with aligning our policies with a high viice code and looking at some of the contracted services around helping us align

005that reducing those Services um not purchasing as many of our technology devices as we had planned and then um postponing replacement of audiovisual equipment in the schools so those were some of the areas that um and again I would just say with the timing of the Year there were some things that had already been spent that as we look at moving forward those may be different um savings that we able to actualize as we go into those other school years and I'll pause there to see if you have any questions on that um I just to be to be clear so some of those are um reductions in spending that are likely to be able to be carried forward and some of them are really delaying correct right so they will have to come up

006at some point yes so for example um the math curriculum we think we can wait until 2031 the elementary math curriculum at that point um the current addition that we're using would be out of print so the subscriptions and software for that we wouldn't be able to continue to support um and I think with the caveat too as we look especially at our curricular materials that um everything we're deciding obviously is always based on the information we have at the time and we know that things change um quite frequently so for example we've talked multiple times in here about the science of reading requirements for our literacy materials so the state has required that we have certain materials that um meet the requirements on a list of approved vendors that can provide uh materials for

007science of reading instruction our K2 materials are already in compliance our 35 ones are not so we do need to move forward with that purchase um but the math as of now is is not a requirement now that could be something next year they could come in with a requirement that whatever we have in math doesn't meet some type of requirement so that is always everything we do obviously is always um you know at the mercy of legislative changes or other requirements that that we have So based on the information we have now we're still working through and looking at um you know what else can we so if if some of those things were able to put out of this fiveyear forecast and use what we have um typically we have a cycle where

008we evaluate how materials are doing and look you know if there's something that we think would be better um but unless the standards are changing we're looking at can we use those longer and kind of push those Cycles out a little bit as an example thanks that was yours too okay any other questions well just a um is it correct then that even if we are required by the general assembly to change some of our like our um curriculum we aren't given additional funding to be able to do that we have to use our own funding to be able to to change that curriculum to come in alignment with the the that's typically the case and I think I might have said that backwards so just to clarify our K2 is um what needs replaced

009our 35 is currently okay I think I might have said that backwards so just to clarify that um so we did get some money for example when the state and I think we've mentioned this before but just to to remind folks um when the state came out with the science of reading requirements we did get some money as a pass through to pay um stiens to our teachers for mandatory training that they have to do um but that was not to cover the actual materials themselves so we did see um money to help with that requirement um we are required to pay all teachers have to have that training some level of it depending on what they teach and so we did get stiens but the materials themselves we are required to pay for and

010I would anticipate if there are other like a math change would probably be similar yeah I just want to mention um you know as the state moves things around they're just continuing to decrease our funding instead of giving us additional funds pretty much every step of the way so and and I know Nicole did a nice job with the fiveyear forecast of pointing that out but there's an example where if you look um it looks like we got a little more than they initially said in our state funding but it in a restricted funding but it was actually the pass through of those stiens for the teacher so it didn't give us any additional funding we could use toward actually implementing that I just want to highlight that this is just the beginning like make

011sure people understand that this is just a start yep so that's a good segue um just to kind of of an update um so we talked at the last meeting about looking at some tier one reductions which would be things that we would recommend with most of those items um looking at being ongoing items and so we are working with our team to look at ways that we can reduce and restructure our district level positions including our Administration um we have two negotiations this year with two of our associations um wa and wessa and then we also have our admin wage and benefit guidelines so starting to work on those um already talked about the budget reductions which includes as I mentioned um subscriptions technology deferring purchases Etc um we are looking at what would

012be the impact if we would minimally in this tier one increase any type of fees that we have so those would potentially could be pay to participate course fees or general fees so getting that information together to share with the board for a discussion um we've already recommended and Nicole's already looked at doing um eliminating our turf fund train transfer so in the past um we have turfit our three high schools so we had put 65,000 a year so that could build up so looking at taking all that out of permanent Improvement funds um also looking at you know what are the other items that we're able to move to our permanent Improvement fund and take out of the general fund so we have things like bus purchases technology purchases um you know and obviously

013then as we look at our roof replacement our HVAC and those typ types of expenses um definitely reduces what we're able to do in terms of those projects in terms of what's left um looking at reducing some staff in this round including through attrition which would have some impact on core instruction student choice and student supports um Limited at that tier one level looking at potentially reducing the scope for summer Learning Academy so right now we're looking at you know what are we required to do um we have to do the preschool component because we are required to start educating our preschoolers when they turn three and so that includes that they turn three in the summer so we've been able to meet that requirement through our summer programming um also looking at some of

014our courses that have fees so that will be something that we'll we'll bring as a a topic of conversation looking at reducing some of our supplemental offerings so we have a lot of um different clubs and activities so um looking at putting together the numbers of what those different offering cost um continuing to review our transportation for efficiencies so I will tell you um right now we have uh we're already down seven to nine bus drivers from the time the day starts um just because of shortages where we can't fill positions and some people being on on leaves so when we look at routing differently it would be more um us being able to stuff everything but then also not needing as many routes if we don't need as many routes we don't need to

015replace place as many buses um buses over 150,000 a piece now the maintenance on those it's more of that type of expense that we would be able to save out of the general fund and then as we mentioned before we are examining pretty much every facet of the organization so I'm sure there are other things that don't fit into those General categories as we kind of work through so we're planning on um making a recommendation that we move the organizational meeting uh we've talked to some of you about this but just let folks know um move the organizational meeting up to January 6 have some of our regular agenda items on there which would open up then the 13th for us to be able to have a more in depth conversation um with the holidays

016in there uh just need a little extra time to pull some of that information together so that we can have some good dialogue any questions on that or anything I can any additional information at this point that would be helpful okay so again we'll be working on that and we'll plan on having some some conversation in January thank you thank you um well moving along may I have a motion to approve the minutes of the regular Board of Education meeting held on Monday November 25th of 2024 so moved second any comments questions all right would you please please take the vote Mrs Alman yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs leean yes Mrs Meer yes um next we have public comments and um the Board of Education welcomes public comment on educational issues of

017interest to our school Community the board does not discriminate based on the Identity or Viewpoint of the speaker during our public participation however the board president May limit comments that are obscene abusive or harassing in any attempt to protect the Privacy interest of our students the board ask that speakers not identify students by during by name during their comments persons having public complaints about District Personnel programming or operations will be referred to the process set forth in board policy 9130 finally the board reminds speakers that their statement should be directed to the board as a whole and not to individual board members public comments offered at this point on the agenda are reserved for comments Rel relative to agenda items 7.01 to 11.05 again each speaker will have five minutes to address the board a

018timer will be shown on the screen and Mr Doran will call time when five minutes has elapsed our first Speaker of this evening is Mr Doug krinsky welcome thank you uh first thing I want to start off with is um what I just heard I'm happy to hear I know everybody sitting up there probably isn't as excited as I might be but I do appreciate um what you're doing uh 7.01 and 7.02 I do hope you do pass um because I think it's important um for those kinds of changes for the district and I think they're both good moves um I don't see on the agenda although I saw it a couple days ago I'm not sure if it's still there or not maybe it's buried somewhere but on the public comments section that proposing

019to change so just a little bit of feedback on that right now it is 5 minutes uh going to 3 minutes I'm not sure what the purpose of that serves um so I would again go back to five minutes just leave it there um second part is must be a resident to speak I I think you miss out on opportunities of having experts come to speak on various topics state representatives state senators and various you know nonprofit folks that may want to come in and speak without having the ability to have a resident to be able to speak um I think you miss opportunities there so again I would leave it the way that it is and on the 60-minute time limit again I'm not sure why that would be in there I think as

020many people that want to speak should be given that opportunity I know you can make an adjustment or you're proposing to make an adjustment if there was that many people that signed up I just don't see why you need to limit it to begin with so I would leave the public comment policy the way that it is 5 minutes you don't have to be a resident and no time limit um and the last thing I would propose if you're looking to save time um I would limit the presentations that everybody in the district does to the board some of these presentations that I've in the last six months seen go on and on and on and on and on um if you limited what the district Personnel presented to 10 minutes or 15 minutes I

021think the meetings would move along a lot faster um as opposed to cutting short the public comments so those are two areas I just want to touch base on public comments and again on the two at 7even point I hope you pass them both happy holidays thanks you all right moving along um may I have a motion to approve resolution to resend and close the capital projects fund created on June 10th second Miss Marshall uh yes so this resolution will allow us to resend the resolution that was passed on June 10 2024 um and with that we'll be able to transfer the funds uh back to the general operating account um as we've discussed this uh ability for us to transfer this exists under Ohio law and should our plans change which it has in

022this case due to the levy failure um we're able to move those funds back thank you any questions or comments right Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs leian yes Mrs Alman yes Mrs Meyer yes and may I have a motion to amend the fiscal year 2025 annual Appropriations so moved second Miss Marshall yes thank you again um so this will amend we approved uh permanent Appropriations in September as required by law and so this is an update to those Appropriations it includes reducing the general fund Appropriations with the budget reductions that Miss Hamburg talked about and um we have other budget allocations and some uh uh some unspent non-public funds from Grants that are being returned back to the state um as were required to track all of that and then uh we're also

023adding the um eliminating the appropriation for the $30 million um in the capital projects fund that's being returned to the general fund thank you any questions or comments all right Mrs leeam yes Mrs Alman yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Meyer yes and is it okay if I take the personal consent jenman great may I have a motion to approve the personal consent agenda 8.0 1 through 8.11 so moved second welcome Mr Cooper good evening president Meyer vice president Alman members of the board Miss Marshall and Miss hurg tonight's Personnel consent agenda includes action items with regard to resignations retirements leaves of absence contract status changes one-time pays and other employment related decisions additional additionally we have oneou with our WEA and oneou with our OBC 719 Union recommended for your approval we

024have one staff member who has announced retirement on this evening's agenda Kelly Blum will be retiring at the end of the year after 33 years of service to the district we certainly wish her the best and appreciate all that she's done for our students staff and community theou at the WEA relates to replacement contracts for employees who are hired during the current school year this mou gives the board flexibility for new hires for positions that are resigned during the year or for a teacher who takes an approved leave of absence for a qualifying reason for the remainder of this school year theou with our opsy 719 provides clarification with regard to extra runs as currently defined in the negotiated agreement at this time I'm happy to take any questions you may have any questions or

025comments no questions I just on the extra runs I just want to thank everybody for I know people work really hard to cover those extra runs so really appreciate it things abolutely thank you this is lean yes Mrs is Davidson yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Alman yes Mrs Meer yes and is it okay if we take old business has one too the final readings okay okay may I have a motion to approve um old business 9.01 through 9 23 so moved second are there any questions or comments okay yeah talk through all 23 of them L speed round actually this is regarding item 24 so as as you might have noticed we pulled the public participation o policy 01691 from the agenda because we feel like we need to work on the language and Item

026B for who is permitted to speak at um our board meeting so we just wanted to make sure that we said State stated that so everybody knew where it was um I did share that with Mr krinsky before he left because I know he asked about it so that's it I just wanted to share that thank you so did we receive feedback is that why we have received some feedback we that there are some people who we want want to reconsider uh just before we just put it on uh CH you know modified the language some people who might be property taxpayers and in our district that we have not included so we just want to make sure that if you have legitimate interest in Westerville City School's business you should have an opportunity to

027speak appreciate you doing the extra work on that thank you all right Mrs leean yes Mrs Atman yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Meyer yes next we have new business um we have the first reading of 2026 2027 academic calendar and Miss Dennis welcome I'm really excited about this calendar I don't know about others good evening uh president Meyer members of the board Miss Hamburg and Miss Marshall before you tonight is the first reading of the 2026 2027 academic calendar uh this calendar was brought before um the calendar committee which is comprised of um one member of our community apparent in the district along with several representative from different um negotiated bargaining units throughout our district it received the um the best support of the options that were in front of them um

028it does meet the teacher work days along with the student count days as well um and with three professional days in there I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have I just appreciate we're not starting in like the second week of August so thank you so so much yes the first student day August 18th on that year any questions or comments okay thank you you M Marshall will you take the vote oh that's right I'm on yeah okay so next up we have the first reading of policy 20206 2265 protections of individual beliefs affiliations ideals or principles of political movements or ideology welcome Mr Dorne good evening again president Meyer vice president Alman members of the board Miss Hamburg and Miss Marshall presented here is a new policy policy 2265 protections of individual

029beliefs affiliations ideals or principles of political movements or ideology this policy is required by houseb 214 which was effective on October 24th it needs to be approved by January 22nd to meet compliance so that's why your first reading is tonight and our second reading will be early in January this act prohibits the use of statements of comments to or soliciting or requiring specified individuals to affirmatively ascribe to specific beliefs affiliations ideals or principles concerning political movements or IDE ideology summary allowed to have your own beliefs any questions comments okay thank you next up uh we have the first reading of policy 5200 attendance and then um the first reading of policy 5500 student conduct welcome Mr mline you guys are stuck with me for a couple minutes sorry good evening Miss Meyer and uh Miss

030Hamburg Miss Marshall members of the board it is my absolute pleasure to present to you revisions to board policy 5200 for attendance this policy is recommended for Lang uh language revisions due to changes within Ohio Revis code with House Bill 214 uh most of the revisions are just some general like wording pieces uh but there is a specific new requirement for three religious expression days each uh school year for students so these Provisions we'll make sure that we are now updated with this new mandate and put processes in place that will be then carried over to our handbook um if anyone has any questions I'll be more than happy to uh answer those questions at this time no awesome you guys want to do the vote on this one or you want me to do

031we don't have it's our first reading first reading oh sorry sorry sorry well let's go into 5500 then with uh student conduct um this is one where uh this policy is recommended for changes um due to changes in education and changes within technology um we started this Con conversation uh with our handbook committee last year and uh with the recommendations here from niola um these are uh pieces that we need to put in place because as technology evolves and that goes into schools we need to make sure that our policies evolve as well so um this will help us uh to guide our students on how to not only use AI in the proper way but make sure that what they are showing is what they know isn't just AI generated so um this is

032uh needed to make sure that we're up to date on current practices and how technology is impacting education yeah I really appreciate that students will get this opportunity to know how to use it properly thank you yeah any questions or comments all right thank you so much okay next moving to a standing business in May I have a motion to appoint Jen Alman as president pro tempor January 1st 2025 until the election of the next board president on January 6 2025 so moved second hope they asked you first no I'm kidding we didn't we just told her that she it was B told no I'm kidding Mrs Valentine yes Mrs leing yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Atman yes Mrs Myer yes um may I have a motion to approve the resolution for impracticality of Transportation

033so moved second welcome Mr Snider good evening president Meyer vice president Alman members of the board superintendent Hamburg and Miss Marshall before you this evening is a resolution declaring impracticality to transport identified students as Ohio law provides and allows for public schools to determine the impracticality of Transportation after consideration of several factors such as the cost of providing transportation and the number of students transported this past September 9th 2020 4 the board passed a resolution declaring 64 students in Practical for transportation and before you today is a list of 13 additional students deemed impractical to transport for the 20242 school year of note there is also one additional student identified to be approved for the 2324 school year due to a school of attendance change from the previous year of 2022 23 our department of

034P our department of purchasing and Logistics has evaluated each listed private school student per the requirements of section 27.2 of the Ohio Revised Code and declared the listed students impr practical to transport therefore the total of 14 students this evening approving this resolution would allow the district to offer the payment in Li of Transportation of which the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce DET determines the payment and L amount I'd be happy to entertain any questions you may have this evening any questions comments um it's just always good to remind people what this means right that these students do not attend Westerville City Schools but they live within our boundaries and we are required either to transport them to private schools or pay them in lie of Transportation that's what that payment in lie of

035means so um just one of those things that we have to do and the private schools are not needing to trans support their own students thanks all right Yep this is Davidson yes Mrs lean yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Alman yes Mrs Meyer yes and may I have a motion to approve the payment in Li of transportation for the five students for the 2023 2024 school year moved second Mr sler again and before you this evening is an additional resolution to approve the payment for five students for the 2023 24 school year and therefore approving this resolution this evening will allow the district to offer the payment in Le of Transportation rather to make the payment in the manner provided per the Ohio revised code at the rate set by the Department of Education and

036Workforce for the 2324 school year any questions or comments okay yep thank you thank you Mrs Alman yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs lean yes Mrs Meer yes and may I have a motion to approve the out of state overnight field trips so moved second you welcome Miss Baldwin good evening president Meer members of the board superintendent Hamburg and Mrs Marshall we have four overnight out of state field trips for your consideration this evening two our wrestling tournaments this month that include our girls wrestling team participating in a tournament at the University of Finley and our boys wrestling team competing at the Medina Invitational at Medina high school and those are both Westerville North teams and the remaining requests are for Westerville North baseball and softball teams traveling out of state during spring

037break they go for warmer weather and I'm happy to answer any questions you may have any questions comments just good luck to the wrestlers right Mrs lean yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs opman yes Mrs Meyer yes and may I have a motion to approve the early graduate candidate who has completed all local and state requirements so moved second the best part welcome good evening again we're excited to support another one of our students completing their graduation requirements prior to their cohort and this student will be eligible to complete all of their graduation requirements in January and expects to begin their post-secondary plans upon immediately making um upon completion of those requirements and I'm happy to answer any questions you may have just congratulations thank you thank you Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Alman

038yes Mrs lean yes this is Valentine yes Mrs is meer yes we Have No public comments so moving on to board comments who would like to provide some comments well I just have a few legislative updates that I would like to share earlier this week I submitted written testimony uh in opposition to a few bills that I believe are impacting Ohio students and schools um and a few of those bills include Senate Bill 295 this bill essentially aims to close or reorganize schools um and I ultimately believe there are multiple Avenues to bolster student learning I closing School simply is not the answer uh another bill to keep on your radar is House Bill 206 if passed this bill would allow suspensions up to 180 days meaning students could face year-long uh suspensions um ultimately

039creating an extreme risk for our students and families um there are various other bills uh to keep running a radar but those are a few well I also have a legislative update from Congress uh US senator Mike rounds a republican from uh South Dakota introduced uh Senate Bill 5384 titled returning education to our states act this bill abolishes the Department of Education and terminates any applicable program for which it has administrative responsibility except for those programs transferred to other federal agencies so that means all functions programs and authorities under the Department of Education under the individuals with disabilities Education Act in each impact aid program will be transferred to the Department of Health and Human Services authorities and programs within the department of education's office of Indian education will be transferred to the Department of

040interior the Department of Treasury will oversee the Federal pel grant programs family education load program um some other programs activities described um let's see well some Student Assistance the health education assistance Loan program and all programs under the education science Reform Act of 2022 and the educational tech technical assistance act it will also um it's also instructed to establish two block grant programs to provide allocations to states to support Elementary and secondary education including career technical education and support postsecondary education which I think is really important to understand that impact so if this would to happen now granted it was just introduced it will die in this session because it hasn't had any hearings but it will likely be in reintroduced in the next Congress would mean that funding would then flow just to the

041states to establish who gets to have funding and what that fun I should say what that funding um number is and so we know that we continue to be cut and so this is something that does worry me um the dep the department of Justice's civil rights division should be responsible of receiving complaints and enforcing federal civil rights laws that are applicable to these block grant programs and federal student programs so as I said it'll need to be reintroduced um because the 118th Congress ends on December 31st if you are are concerned about the state of public education in this bill please contact your US senators and your congressional representative if you're unclear who those are you can go to congress.gov members find- your- member that's all I have congratulations to The Graduate okay um

042the board will meet and and an organ uh organizational regular session on Monday January 26 2025 what I say oh sorry just wishing away days apparently gosh January 6 2025 at 6 pm at the Early Learning Center 936 East Wind Drive Westerville Ohio 43081 which is here in this building um and now uh may I have a motion to enter into executive session for the purposes of discussing the employment and compensation of public employees still moved second m m Mrs Valentine yes Mrs lean yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Alman yes Mrs Meyer yes you're welcome to stay but you don't have to it is 6:40 thank you may I have a motion to aour so moved second I need V oh sorry yes gosh Mrs Lan yes Mrs Valentine yes Mrs Davidson yes Mrs Alman

043yes Mrs Meer yes apparently 13 we

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.