001hold on ibody are we ready to go okay um welcome again uh we will begin the meeting with a roll call Bailey here V here hling here magnes here here we have a quorum okay let's begin with item 1.3 um does any board member have a change to the agenda um yes I would like to ask that we move well we don't have to move it but um that we include one of our Communications um within the litech conversation um I think it it warrants some additional um conversation the uh you know don't aot of communications um so one two and three I guess that does qualify as a change to the agenda to move a supporting item from one section to another I move that we uh move those three communications to section 3.1
002I second so so say the three communications again pada yeah there's three of them all the same um okay we have a motion in a second I Hing I'm not understanding what um I'm I'm asking that we discuss um that that particular communication a little bit more in depth I think it warrants more conversation under the light of theu so essentially moving those letters May um I'd like to make a friendly amendment that we add Matt and Julie Jones to that set seems to make sense okay can we V can we have okay so hold on it was okay U does it mean two Vote or one vote on that if gra two two votes there would be um a vote on the amendment and then you go back to vote on the original item
003Jay as a friendly amendment can it just be accepted by the original motion maker or would you rather us do it twice I I I guess if the motion was finished if I think we can do it twice so you're you're moving to include um Jones uh the Jones letter the Jones letter okay uh Magnus I I would actually like to consider them a separate item okay um so any discussion on the amendment um the Jones letter is about litech that's uh why I think it should be moved over there uh and any further disc discussion we need a second on your motion yes a second I'll second we'll have um I think I'll prer to Bailey Bailey second um all seeing no further discussion all those in favor of the amendment oh so we
004have two votes yes this is just on moving adding discuss okay go ahead adding the amendment as so that we have a group of letters all those in favor I all those opposed okay now we will open discussion we've got the three pilot letters and the Jones letter any discussion moving it to the litex section of the agenda please raise your hand if you have a discussion okay seeing none all those in favor of moving those letters over that's the three Pilato letters in the Jones letter say I I all those opposed say nay I'm sorry this didn't go the way that I expected I was hoping that we would do the letters and the um is it the Pila and the Jones separately well Amy so I amended Amy Bailey's motion so when I
005did that it became a packet of four letters okay yeah okay all those in so we all those opposed say nay nay okay okay so the motion passes any other changes to the agenda okay seeing none we will move on to the actual agenda we have right yes which is the approval of the minutes the next spot um there a motion to approve the minutes I move we approve the regular board meetings minutes from December 12 and I'll second and is there any discussion okay any any corrections none Bailey yes yes hling yes Magnus yes B yes motion pass 5 to zero okay the minutes of from our December meeting are approved um Communications uh now this is a transition uh session uh so I can give a an overview uh but I also encourage
006for this meeting uh that board members if they think I'm missing something please chime in in the future as president I will be asking different V board members to do this task in a kind of rotational basis but of course I'll give you a warning um so we have uh 48 letters here and further letters came in uh since the cut off time which I believe is 5 p.m. on Tuesday um the vast majority of letters quite a few of these letters worth were we in regards to the um litech motion litech discussion item three uh to approve revised option to buy agreement with the village of Yellow Springs uh the vast majority if not all uh saying that they would not want that stipulation uh that condition to be removed until they are there
007are assures guarantees there are different words for it that replacement land and the money to convert that land into soccer fields was indeed in place um other Communications addressed uh the end of our December 12th meeting um and particularly uh the majority of those of being uh critical of of Amy magnus's behavior um and again saddened disappointed um Etc and calling for different forms of action uh some however also uh argued that the uh situation was one uh where there was a a lot of tensions were a contribution from um many others and uh then we we have some Communications uh that were moved to the litech uh section and other Communications that are asking the board to stay on Focus for 2025 anyone have anything to add uh no just that um this is
008the most letters that this board has received I think ever in my last the duration of this term and I'm just um thanking everybody who wants to participate to this um to our the conduct of our business thank you okay moving on to a wonderful part of this meeting um hold on Dr I just want to say that I read every letter very carefully and I thank people for putting them that okay thank you um now we're moving on to a wonderful part of uh the board meeting each month and that is the district honors recognitions and introductions and I'll turn it over to Terry thank you um before I thank you before I have my principles begin I want to um have all board members look at your seat you have a recognition certificate
009from the Ohio school boards Association January is school board's recognition month so I want to thank you for the time and dedication you put to this work um it's a hard job so thank you very much [Applause] okay I am presenting the January young da student of the month for Mills Lawn and it is going to a fourth grade student Phoebe BB level [Applause] Phoebe was nominated by her teachers Mrs Bailey and Miss hemrich they are so proud to nominate Phoebe for the student of the month because she exemplifies the skills for life Leadership and a positive attitude in all she does Phoebe is a wonderful role model who treats everyone with respect and kindness creating a welcoming environment for her peers her dedication to responsibility is evident in her excellent commitment to and active
010participation in the school Community she always strives for her personal best showing consistent effort commitment to excellent and all she does Phoebe's character and contributions make her a truly deserving recipient of this honor and we are confident she will continue to inspire those around her with her leadership integrity and positive spirit [Music] family [Music] [Applause] I don't want Phoebe and her family to have this day so part of my present ation that later um talks about the four graders and how they were able to present at little art so Phoebe is prepared to do her poem and then I will connect her poem to my presentation in a little bit great um my home is called love those cats um and it goes love those cats I just love them it's just that love those
011cats as much as they love to chase a rat love to feed them every morning love to greet them morning cats [Applause] all right I've got several Awards um the first one is our Mills Park Hotel student of the month and this student is actually out an away basketball game tonight so I'm going to recognize him even though he's not here that is seventh grader William dwine William was nominated by m [Applause] Horvath William was nominated by Miss Horvath for his active participation in class and the way he is making strong academic decisions when getting to choose where it and who to work with and those types of things so congratulations to William the second person I would like to honor is our fine artst scholar of the month Molina Buster come on up [Applause]
012Melina Melena was nominated by her ceramics teacher Miss fcker who is also here um Miss fcker said Melena is a Ceramics 2 student who has shown great effort and ability in her clay work molena is very creative and open to trying new things but still make them consistent with the theme of her uh group of projects projects she has shown great perseverance when a Ceramics piece has not turned out as planned which is what mine normally do um and is willing to remake and adjust her pieces to compensate Molina is a joy and class as well happy and positive she has no problem helping Mr RX1 students When Miss vicard is is busy and is a great mentor as well as a helpful peer to her classmate congratulations [Applause] [Music] [Applause] next I would like
013to to recognize our trophy Sports scholar athlete of the mon Jackson Fletcher come on up Jackson [Applause] Jackson was nominated by his bowling coach Mr Johnson who is also here um Coach Johnson said I've had the pleasure of coaching Jackson as a member of the bowling team for the last three years and that time he has demonstrated all the attributes you want to see as a coach dedication hard work and most of all a team player who's always upbeat and focused on the success of the team I also want to recognize Jackson for his commitment to academics this year he has had a very strong uh first quarter and I'm proud of the work that he's done there um as well as just being a kind person in our school Community um so congratulations to
014[Applause] Jackson messy buns Pointon Jackson also 258 said your high this year yeah 2 [Music] [Applause] all right finally I would like to recognize our Piper Orchard Employee of the Month Rachel Madison come on up [Applause] Rachel thank you so is nominated by jod chick you said Rachel is a teacher of detail she completes her paperwork on time and is very thorough she is always on top of new requirements and wants to do the best for her students and co- teers she is an asset to all spring schools and I Echo that as well congratulations [Music] always there's [Laughter] a I would just like to announce that this is the first month that our Fine Art scholar of the month is that award is being underwritten by the Yellow Springs my Association so great thanks
015to them so congratulations to Phoebe William Molina Jackson and Rachel um well done and if you ever get a chance to go to one of those bowling tournaments please do they are a ton of fun okay we're moving to community comments and and again thank you community for coming out oh yes uh just because it seems that someone has moved the sheets out of place I just want to confirm Sierra scarver did you want to be in community comments Sierra scarver no okay H I have another individual here vat B Curley curly VA you mean yeah is it VA curly did you want to be a part of community comments no it was part of theend thank you so much I appreciate that do you want to give people no we we'll continue okay everyone
016um so I have a list here if I don't pronounce your name correctly just please correct the pronunciation when you come up uh the timekeeper is McGrath and so he will be signaling to you uh when you hit that three minute Mark we'll let you finish a sentence but please try to respect that have a lot of people here tonight I if you feel like what you wanted to say has been said uh you can just say pass but of course I wanted I want to stress you we are here to hear you uh so it is up to you to say just pass and I'll move on to the next person so if I could ask relita Chambers you'd like to comment do you want me to speak into the microphone or no I
017de yes it it certainly helps the YouTube um perfect recording so first I'd like to wish everybody a Happy New Year um I certainly don't like NE negativity in my life and it pains me to have to come up here again and make NE negative comments so if I mention your name don't think of this as a personal attack think of it as a performance about valuation of sorts um Dr Magnus I a letter of apology is required but it's not that letter I find your comments in board member meetings and board meetings rambling disorganized divisive and in the last meeting threatening and unprofessional your behavior after the meeting was inexcusable and you should be censured using profanity calling our superintendent do we have any kids in here noing and ranting raving while pointing fingers
018is also unprofessional and beneath the expectations of your office and this is not the first time Dr Magnus has acted out um I have a sense of deja vu last December earlier this year year although earlier this year um we were in a similar situation but the threats were not directed at the superintendent or a fellow board member they were directed at a teacher at that time Dr Magnus should have been censored but she wasn't because her Schoolboard president didn't think her actions warranted a censure well how about now actually I don't think it's completely Dr magnus's fault for the unprofessional Outburst after the meeting she gets to share that in the ramifications of her comment with our former School Board president miss hempling who did nothing then and has done nothing in her tenure
019to build trust amongst the school B board members and with the administrators she comes to these meetings unprepared and sews seeds of discontent in the community because she doesn't listen to any opinion that varies from her own and continues to put non-educational personal projects above her responsibilities to the school district Miss hling is not displayed the leadership necessary to effectively run this board the fact that she was selected to be vice president at the organizational meeting earlier prends another year of strife and I'm sorry that you couldn't make one simple concession that would have appeased some of the community she failed to step in after the rumble comment leaving the intervention up to the only person in the room apparently with any leadership and that was Dr Holden after that Dr Potter wisely read the
020room and all Al though it was procedurally incorrect she moved to adjourn the meeting where was Miss humling at this time sitting there observing the chaos before anyone accuses me of these being personal attacks I'd like to point out that there's a pattern to this during the 12 years Miss hempling was on Village Council guess how many Village managers and interim Village managers we went through 1 three four six six Village managers you could wrap it up that's just crazy what's even crazier is that we have a village that accepts this as okay Behavior thank you Scot five well I would my name is Scott fik I would say that we've got to stop meeting like this but to be honest I probably have no intention of stopping meeting like this um it it has
021been a while since I've spoken to you and I want to speak to you tonight about uh uh two two items in particular uh one year and a month ago uh not to the date but close to that I finished a very brief four-month interim term on the board which was my honor to do um and in making closing remarks uh um I mentioned that uh you had a tremendous task ahead of you we we had passed the the uh the ballot initiative the the building project was about to be underway um Architects were being Chosen and the the fund was just beginning uh and I want to acknowledge what what has been accomplished but I want to caution you that the fund's just starting uh the the words of the day our change order
022and those those are words that you're going to come to hate um I want to re-emphasize my request for you to stay laser focused on this building project it is the most important thing facing the community right now and I say that with full regard of the importance of affordable housing and that initiative uh this my this these comments are not about that that is a that is a worthy thing but it's not why we're all here tonight um it's imperative that the board stay laser focused on this task you're going to things are going to start coming at you fast and furious and there will be special meetings and there will be decisions that have to be made and it's going to require a lot of cooperation more than I have seen uh so
023far so I want to I want to emphasize that point again uh and I'm sorry if I'm repeating myself but that's that's just a thing um under normal circumstances I would have thought that uh a school board and a Village Council ought to be able to work together on a project like the litech um but unfortunately these are not normal circumstances and I'm not getting into the business of throwing accusations at anyone or fixing blame I'll leave that for others to do but um as the late Kenny Rogers once said you got to know when to hold them and you got to know when to fold them and I think uh we've reached a point here where for the betterment of the community and the good of this facilities project the School Board needs to
024take a long hard look at their involvement in the Life at project there are just lots of strange things going on there three minutes and that's that concludes my remarks thank you Scott if anyone would like to move and take some of these empty seats here at the front please do so Laura Skidmore I have several things to say I already wrote two letters um I'm up here today in part because the agenda and the contents changed after I wrote my letters after the deadline and so I wanted to say some more things um I guess I'll start with what I think is the most important because I might run out of time I feel like the board is putting the cart before the horse again just like you did in December when you thought
025you were going to have a donation that day the next day and here we are a month later there still is no signed donation but we're going to talk today about releasing the Restriction because we think there's going to be a donation we're confident there's going to be a donation and one thing anyone in real estate will tell you is that it's not done until closing because even at closing a party can walk away um I think removing the requirement to replace the land contingency on the Hope or belief the donation will happen and that there will be enough money is not the right thing to do there is no guarantee that either one of those things will happen in fact the only as far as I know the only written quotes that we have
026to convert land into new soccer fields into new Athletics Fields is well over the Val sorry not the value the purchase price of the Land There is no contract currently unless that has changed in the last couple days there is no contract for this donation to happen there's no signed donation there is no written bid for the work to be done within the budget and there is no contingency for cost overruns when this actually is going to be done in a year or two if we get to that point a bid today is not what it's going to cost in a year or two as far as Amy magnus's Behavior I want to say I would be fired immediately if I spoke to anyone in my workplace or behav the way that I saw in
027the security that it is truly inexcusable and it requires board censure um it does not require it does not Merit an acceptance of an apology that blames others and Fa fails to accept full responsibility for the actions last thing oh actually this was going to be the first thing but I forgot I want to say I agree with everything relita relita Chambers said everything this is the last thing I want to request that the board publish um board documents an agenda on the Monday before the meeting so that the public has a chance to review them and submit written comments before the deadline the agenda was not published until after the deadline for written comments three minutes and at that point after that the contents and the documents changed so here we are today having
028to come in person to give comments thank you thank you Julia Bergman Lee hello thank you um I know that I submitted a letter um and then after that I had a chance to watch The Village council meeting and also react to some of the other letters that were submitted so I just a few additional comments I wanted to share um so kind of similar to what was just shared I want to highly encourage this board to postpone this decision or if it needs to be made to deny the request to make the amendment to the agreement I think there are certain critical items that need to be secured one the land donation agreement and perhaps there's more technical things I'm not saying in that but we need a land donation agreement and Julie's letter
029said that's coming next week why do we need to do this today we need a sound estimate for adapting the donated land to soccer field we don't really know what this cost is and we need to involve input from local state cors we need input from whether it's School operations and Athletics or soccer leaders they need to be at the table they need to be a part of this process every step of the way and what I heard um when I know the news is reported the LI Tech application isn't actually due till February 27th and if these steps that we need to secure for this schol do not align with W project timeline that is unfortunate The Village council meeting was very difficult to ascertain why they needed the decision today yes why and
030what I was able to glean from Rel listening to the meeting is I finally heard it stated that W need VOD needs the amendment to be removed in order for them to free their own funds and resources to work on the application it's a Time intensive application and I don't fault them for that they follow good fiduciary practice IES and I encourage our school board to uphold similar standards many have been working diligently on this effort it's close but not yet there so now the school board is being asked to take a leap of faith with the Village Council a leap that involves risk to school resources and as a small community where people know each other and are friends with each other it may seem like a reasonable ask and overall I have faith
031that those managing the project really do intend to do what they want to do but they're is no confirmation that they are actually able to do it so I think proceeding without securing these items would be Reckless decision-making it would set a dangerous precedent for how the school board and other Village entities are empowered to manage taxpayer resources so therefore I urge you to delay the decision or to not approve the amendment until these critical items are secured this approach ensures responsible management of school resources and maintains the rest of our community thank youy Miller back there I'm going to need a surface here sorry I did asked for a little extra time I don't know if you got the message or not um I sent it to Judith I didn't realize I should have
032sent it to you but I am dyslexic I will be reading and I'm a little slow at reading so I ask that you put that under consideration thank you um the proposed affordable housing development has taken too much of the yellow spring School Board staff's attention the yellow Springs Council and staff's time and energy um away from their daily roles and responsibilities the financial and legal expenses due to are are due to and will escalate ultimately impacting the school board and the village uh it seems to me that the RFP should never have gone out without Clear Sight control this was a waste of time and resources why wasn't this information shared by homeate since supposedly they are the experts was this known but not shared um to put more pressure on the board to
033make a decision I understand why the school district would want our village manager Johnny Burns to review and propose uh the proposed uh appraisal or to get additional information from other contractors to get an accurate picture of the cost and the additional concerns that we might need to address this should have happened much sooner not during crunch time again the school board should have never entered into an agreement to sell land to the Village if they didn't have replacement land and several written estimates in their hands wouldn't you want more than 30,000 in hand before attempting to make this land whole there will always be additional cost in a project that's large it's not fair to expect taxpayers to pay any additional expense to make this hold I found it deeply concerning when a council
034member would even suggest this I don't believe it's our school district's responsibility to make affordable homes or be in the affordable housing business and I don't support selling school property under market value um to a profitable Corporation I found our school board is is not trustworthy and it's difficult to believe uh when from the beginning they didn't even involve Rex socer to find a solution the work of individual special group interest groups individuals and organizations attempting to undermine a fair process is alarming to me and others as well really as all the raised concerns in time and energy and frustration flaring tempers and inappropriate behavior by some in discourse is it really worth it you need to get back to putting our students first and our community recck program and how it benefits our community
035children in Athletic program I ask you not to withdraw your contingency agreement and do what's best for our children our school district and our community thank you thank you miy um Kim rifle derer I'm speaking today in regards to agenda item 3.1 approv revised option to buy agreement with the village of Yellow Springs I urge the board to conduct a thorough du due diligence point just just real quick just move a little closer to the mic because we can't hear I urge you to conduct a thorough due diligence process including a detailed one if analysis and data driven cost breakdown before casting your votes on this critical matter especially before the land donation is finalized this analysis should address several key questions what if the anticipated land donation does not materialize what if the sale
036price of the existing land falls short of covering the cost of new soccer fields particularly since the current property is not being sold at market value these are not trivial concerns and without clear evidence-based answers to these questions the risk to our students and by extension to the community are unacceptably high as a parent I find it deeply troubling that our students including my own children could bear the brunt of these potential consequences I ask those who might vote to remove the stipulation tonight are you prepared to personally fund any resulting shortfalls if these high probability risk become a reality I also want to remind the board of your stated commitment to the educational welfare of all students the resolution you are considering explicitly references a code of ethics that prioritizes this commitment Above All
037Else a vote to remove the stipulation without clear substantiated answers would contradict this resolution and compromise your duty to our students I urge the board to act with caution integrity and a focus on what is best for our students the decision you make now will have lasting impacts and I hope you approach them with the seriousness and consideration they deserve thank you thank you Kim Melissa H Melissa I'm here to address the anger of the community I feel like the anger of the community is coming because the majority of the board members here are not acting like school board members they've got other plans and agendas in mind and not the school's business I think that as we move forward it would be best if you review your code of ethics and the bylaws and
038also review the board protocols that were suggested in years previous that were called Antiquated by the last board president I think think you should find ways in which these board protocols might work for you in your best positions as elected officials the anger like I said is coming from the fact that you're not acting as school board members with the business of education and educating our students in mind thank [Music] you thank you Kate Hamilton [Laughter] hi can you hear me can you hear me closer we okay uh I wrote a letter or an email and I wrote it too late so I'm going to read it um so I'm again expressing my disappointment in the continual bullying and hyperbolic overreactions during Schoolboard meetings mainly by superintendent Holden the targeting of a neurod Divergent board
039member any board member Again by our school leaders is unacceptable this is a repeat of the past year and a half that I really thought was being remedied and worked on how many times was Dr Magnus interrupted after she had been given the floor by the school board president during a round robin discussion how many times was she interrupted by the superintendent this goes beyond a lack of knowledge of Robert's Rules of Order and straight to audacity a disregard for process and fairness targeted bullying and unnecessary melodrama describes the incident at the last meeting and I'm only speaking of what the public saw at the meeting that's what I wrote this about the divisiveness being cultivated by the superintendent has caused a lot of damage to our schools and to our community as a whole
040that was my letter and I want to say a wise person recently told me that oftentimes bullying presents as continual microaggressions such as what we see during these meetings I roll laughter angry loud size no passing Etc as well as the blatant acts such as constant interruptions correcting and tone of voice these aggressions build up and when the bullied person reacts to them the bullies in return act shocked and move right into gaslighting this wise person happens to be one of my kids we teach our kids not to bully and then they watch us do it thank you thank you Kate Amy marama um I also submitted a letter that was too late so I was going to read it for you here um it's tragic to witness the erosion of ility on the elring
041school board in reviewing the video transcripts and pages and pages of Correspondence before and after the most recent school board meeting on 12224 I was struck most acutely by the incredible strain placed on our school leadership as a leader who also reports directly to a board I can almost sense viscerally what it felt like the stress the hour spent defensive preparing for board meetings crafting responses to board emails and distracted from the mountain of ma management and goal directed work waiting for you on your desk I was de it was devastating to see that you have reached a new low with board member Magnus angry at a one-word Interruption responding with we can Rumble any time I reject the suggestion that this was a light-hearted joke my perception having watched it several times and having
042witnessed previous interactions was that it was set in frustration and anger however my perception and even yours are immaterial even if it was honestly said purely in just the if the person you directed it to felt threatened then your statement still counts as a threat and can have legal or social consequences the key factor is the perception of the recipient not your intended meeting I counted as insult to injury that blaming board member Amy Bailey and superintendent Terry Holden for not interpreting this threat against Bailey as a joke appears to have been and continues to be the response of board president Judith hempling and member Amy Magnus the silent video footage of the aftermath of the meeting is frightening even without Sound Board member am magnus's body language was threatening I can't even imagine how
043it would feel to have that kind of physical anger directed at me at work and for my staff members to witness this anger profanity and derogatory names made by a board member and directed at me as their boss I know Amy Magnus on a personal level to be a very thoughtful and caring person I do and nonetheless her behavior during and after the board meeting on 1212 was uniquely and unequivocably unacceptable this is further a recent instance in a pattern of unacceptable behavior for a school board member and by responding by blaming the victim and dismissing concerns president hempling not only failed to lead but exacerbated the issue three minutes failure to deal seriously and appropriately with this unacceptable Behavior will perpetuate a culture of mistrust on our school board and a toxic workplace for
044our district leadership okay sorry I believe a centure is required and ask that the board member Amy Magnus resign for the rest of the board to engage a mediator and that all this is done so that we might rebuild trust restore healthy communication and provide the all spring School District its students teachers staff and Community the leadership we all deserve thank thank you and and I I will be shining in when we get when we hear from Jay that it's three minutes just to keep everything on everyone the same amount of time uh dino P well Dino's making his way up and David Diamond you'll be next you can prepare the wandering out here thank you you don't pull out a resident taxpayer school school taxpayer also School Board member Potter hempling I'm asking you
045to recuse yourself from the litech project or resign there's so many ethical questions regarding the plotting potl parties that were put on by upter and by others furthermore looking at all the communications with the chat app from Home Bank Executives and board members along with Springers for more Springers and others in hopes of strategizing how to how to manipulate or influence School other school board members or more importantly our Village Council Members some of the information shared in these meetings may have been privileged and were not to be released until a Schoolboard meeting took place again it's just a question of Ethics tell me from all your meetings and discussions how didn't you know that the site that the site control aspect was going to be that important was the major important part of OFA
046you had an expert in home inc and their executive director and board of members at your meeting and you didn't know that you needed to have site control in applying for the application now it's the 11th hour we have to scramble to find out what to do this is on you this is a this is this is something has continually happened with Heming when they work with Village Council but now this is your problem this is something that you have to come up with and it's on your leadership that this we're having a problem with board member Magnus I've been in your corner I've had many discussions with you over the years however you're misstep with social media an email several months ago along with the December s recording of your verbal attacks require your
047immediate resignation if this was private sector position you'd be terminated immediately for your actions with respect to your colleague and the employee please reads the student code conduct of handbook which I have here for you guys in particular Parts 13 and three regarding threats and degrading profane or disgraceful acts towards others if students are not per permitted to act this way without repercussions how can adults who are our leaders of the school system act this way without repercussions a clear message must this is a decisive moment for the school board and a pinnacle moment for you board member Magnus for the better betterment of this board for the school system the community and most importantly the students it's imperative that you resign what kind of message are we sending to our students if actions don't
048have consequen consequences then you as adult are setting a precedent for our students condoning this type of behavior without repercussions this is a teachable moment lastly why is there a$2 to4 million shortfall on the facility building project it appears that you've been distracted with all your self created turmoil and drop the ball on the single most important job you were here to complete you a $55 million Levy and now you need more money how you going to pay for it how did this happen why did this happen this will not fall on the taxpayer it falls squarely on your shoulders and you need to come up with the solution this is not the leadership we voted for to complete this project get the project done on budget and on time thank you I'm surprised that
049anyone needs to speak up for yellow screen VI soccer I thought the wonderful coverage that is received over the years particularly from the ell spring news would keep everyone from doing anything to jeopardize this program but it's mistake to think that others know my particular perspective so I'm happy to offer that this soccer program is one of the core pieces of our family identity when we mooved to Yellow Springs in 2008 we already knew that our six-year-old son Philip loved Sports we knew we wanted to have have him try the the local program it was great uh but it was more than just a team every Saturday morning so many of us gathered at the Morgan Fields to cheer for and conso these children Philip needed cleats and ly har told us that they kept
050everyone's donated cleat in a big box for the younger kids to use Philip even got his new friend Von Hendrickson to join his team and they both later played for the Bulldogs together in high school and are still best friends we came to find out that in an age of increasing fees and professionalization all the great people like Lynn coaches referees League administrators all working hard none of them were paid I think that's a rarity among present day Rec Sports programs people like Lynn her husband Bill Bob Curley Brian Walker and many of the coaches became great role models for us as relatively young parents not trying to call guys old if you're here around the same um it was it was one of those places that just radiates Community energy and love we knew
051we belonged those fields and in Yellow Springs I still feel that energy coming off the field every Saturday morning then we moved back into 2017 I just want to say it was more the same thing with Noah I'm skip a bit could go on all night about it um when the board first decided to use the Morgan Fields for a housing project ours alarm the community had fundraised to renovate the soccer fields and I thought it would be really difficult to find another place to play in Yellow Springs with four soccer fields being used simultaneously most of the easy solutions people throw out there on social media like d Park are obviously unsuitable as it if there's one thing that's difficult to come by in this Village it's land ready to be repurposed I was
052very reassured when this board adopted a resolution to only move forward with the lit project when soccer fields had been aired the people you were working with on this project have seen uh the board resolution too and they're probably thinking what I'm thinking this is going to be really tricky that's why they have asked for your reassurance that the housing project comes first and which push comes to shove the Board of Education will leave J Springs Youth Soccer without a field rather than jeopardize the grent application please don't do this don't repeal your resolution I can see why it makes sense to the respect to the perspective real EST estate developers but I don't see why it makes sense to you as our school board don't harm something that draws families to our village and
053welcomes them don't cut off a limb we already have in hopes of maybe going a new onea um Madam president at this time we have reached 30 minutes and 5 Seconds that is the ex um end of our time for Community comments unless the board would like to extend it by I attend a motion I move that we extend the community comments I second I a seconds all those in favor say can I ask a Qui question yes um do we have a sense of how much longer yeah u 1 2 3 four five 6 7 8 nine speakers is there a amount of time or just until we're finished until the nine speakers have completed their comments is that amenable to everybody all those in favor I post thank youa it is with deep
054concern that I write to you the yell spring School Board president hempling under your leadership this past year I have watched trust erode and now reach a state of open ill will that undermines the functioning of this District it seems that the board is turning its back on its own decision to secure alternative land for the soccer fields causing further lack of credibility and contention in our community pitting affordable housing against our Public Schools is unconscionable board member magnus's recent threat to fight with another board member and the vulgar and disrespectful language used toward our district superintendent crossed a line that is UN acceptable she made it clear that she feels emboldened to speak and act without consequences even after facing censure earlier this year as you all know I served on the board yellow
055spring school board for two years with you we had difficult moments we had very tough conversations but we did not throw dirty words at each other or at District staff did not digress to thinly veiled threats to fight or brawl we came together to find compromise and voted in consensus each time in particular in the longstanding village-wide debate around our school facilities we voted in consensus and I will always be proud of that fact it is a sad State of Affairs when little can be done to repair the lack of trust or care that has been extended to our school district administrators they represent the educational Team all of the teachers and staff who bring their expertise their energy and their hearts day in and day out I am reminded at every school event that
056I attend as a parent as to their dedication their care their professionalism that our superintendent our principles and our staff provide to our children and to everyone in this community in our district I am not sure how a board member can be so out of touch as to not be humbled and grateful for their service speaking so callous and maliciously is not the least bit funny and insinuating as much as gaslighting and offensive the school board is responsible for preventing a hostile environment which could lead to further chaos and legal scrutiny I see no way to move forward without asking uh you to step down as board president uh and to ask board member Magnus to resign effective immediately accountability is the the first step toward regaining trust the board's attention must return to the
057facilities project at hand it took us years to earn the trust of this community to pay for our sorely needed facilities project I fear the current board is too distracted by its own self-inflicted chaos to be good stewards of the most important and Monumental Schools project of our lifetime please it is time to refocus and reset thank you Leah or Le Nate and after that would be Ben Miller Le please correct the pronunciation your last name it's okay it's n rhs with Dave okay I'm L na I've been a resident of Yellow Springs for about the last eight years and I have two students a senior and a junior here in the high school and I am um well I came here for a very specific reason I moved my children my whole entire family
058my whole life because I love Project based learning and what what my kids are seeing right now is a failure with regard to Project based learning because if you just Google the definition it says Project based learning claims or aims to build the creative capacity to work through difficult or ill structured problems usually in a small team and I'm a nurse I'm a critical thinker I work with a lot of other women I know how hard that can be but it's very important and it's why I came here and it it's failing and in this way that they're watching the process break down and un fortunately or fortunately I'm not sure we live in an age where our kids get to see all of this they told me about this first they saw this first
059and Amy I'm sorry you had a bad day at work that really sucks I have had plenty of bad days at work but one time my youngest son had a bad day at school and he heard another student say a a a phrase that was similar to what you said and then he repeated it imagine how much trouble I'd be in if I said that and when he got caught he got detention I immediately came and picked him up and I asked him three questions I said what did how did you represent yourself today how did you represent your family today yeah and are you how you going to fail forward because in our family we fail forward and I read your apology letter it it doesn't suggest what you're going to do to not
060do this again I don't know that you need to be fired I don't know that you need to resign I don't know that but I do know that you didn't say what you're going to do to not fail you're you're going to not do it again nothing in that letter said I won't do this again to me it felt very much like this is who I am and you have to accept it and I I understand that but you you owe that to my kids I elected you for that reason and and so I need you to tell me and everybody in this room how you're not going to feel forward again or or how you're yeah and and then I need I really believe Dr Holden and I have kind of at times budded
061heads on some of of the things that have happened but you deserve better than than the treatment that happened that day and we need to support each other and we need to support our kids and all that said I I just need to know what you're going to do and the other problem I have with the whole project is I can't follow the money I don't know where the funds are coming from I don't know who's paying for it I don't know any of that three minutes for you okay I just if if it were easier to understand if you guys could put it in a document that every other villager could just check the box and say I approve of this that's fine I don't care who paid for that part that's great but
062nobody can follow it thank you thank you Ben Miller I moved here in 1998 and since then I've been a volunteer coach referee I served on the board of yssi this is an important feature of our community and every week we can see it and we can feel it I know that a corporation has a responsibility to its shareholders but it does not have a responsibility to the stakeholders of the community if you remove this stipulation there's no guarantee of anything number two I have two kids here in school and I have a 9-year-old who has some behavioral challenges and if he behaved like Dr Magnus did there would be swift repercussions and discipline en forc I did not see any of that I have not seen that there's going to be any of that
063this is very concerning to me as a taxpaying member of this community and somebody who very deeply cares about these schools and the people who live here and attend school here we have a responsibility to every one of these kids to set a good example and to have school leadership not display those kinds of behaviors is unacceptable I I don't see how we move forward there is a lack of listening understanding communication if you really want to have a Marketplace of ideas where people can come forward with their opinions and you come out with the best one you need to display leadership that's all Dr Maran will be Liz [Music] H about 25 years years ago I worked with Judah temping uh on the community aspect to save whiteall Farm now there are probably I
064know there are people in this room who grew up here I've lived here for over 50 years there's I don't know if there's anyone else in the room who's John God also but people are coming and going from this community that 25 years ago the person who most affected saving whiteall farm from the community was Judith Pon but it wasn't only Judith of course what happened and those of you who were involved in that and I'm talking to everyone in the room those of you who were involved in that probably felt that magical sense of people working together from the County Commissioners who gave money to kids from Mills La school who had lemonade spans to raise money and that was a that was a big lift to do that to save that farm room
065we have the capacity to do Big R but we're there's probably no other community in Ohio and maybe this country that has as many smart people as we do in this community but it takes more than just being smart it takes also a heart so we have elected some people up here who I know they get paid less than counil people they are us we are them we are in a really difficult period not only in the world but in our country and I am very concerned that what we're seeing here in this Village is mirroring the distrust the divisiveness the demonizing the polarizing that we have in the country and yeah I I have a side you know I there's things that I want to see happen and they could happen if we felt
066align clearly we don't we have varying interests and there's a lack of trust to allow us to see well really I think we all want the same things um and so I'm just I don't have answers I'm just saying and it we talk about Project based learning I mean this this is Project based learning so you know if we can figure out how to uh just start trusting each other a little bit more I guess I mean that's one step I think um and I guess that's that's all I want to say it it it's very painful I'm sure it's painful for all of you guys I'm sure that it's painful and you know I almost wish we would start our meetings with prayers as much as like we don't like to do that in
067Yellow Springs really but I mean something to help bring us together so that we can speak from that point uh rather than whatever side we thank you after Liz is Christie meero Liz hle um as a community member parent PTO member and Rec Soccer organizer I've spent the last six months staying close to these issues listening carefully to both sides and I'm really trying to remain optimistic that our school board will honor its commitments to leading to a future where the village benefits from improved soccer fields affordable housing and a stronger sense of collaboration but it's becoming really increasingly difficult it's impossible to ignore the frustration and disappoint disappointment many of us feel that a majority of of people who have spoken tonight have expressed the troubling behavior exhibited during and after the December meeting
068was not only disheartening but also damaging to the trust we place in this board and the reputation of our school District these moments of division and poor leadership cast out on our ability to move forward together on top of that the potential loss of valued administrators like our superintendent due to her treatment by the board is a cost this community simply cannot afford especially considering the important facility project we're working on right now I hope the board recognizes the urgency of restoring professionalism transparency and unity I remain hopeful that with stronger more cohesive leadership one that values consensus building we can overcome these challenges but the path forward requires genuine accountability and a focus on rebuilding trust we owe that to our students our staff and our community after Christie is cind see before you
069give up our land I have a few points for you to consider where exactly is the piece of land that may be donated to the schools how far away is it from the school what is accessibility like what is the cost of replacement for like to like in terms of size accessibility and maintenance what is the strategy for funding the Gap has the village guaranteed that they can fulfill the owner's requests from what I saw there's a few major requests that only the village could say yes to why would we surrender any negotiation power at this point in this process how does this serve the school district I think you should put off this vote until the village guarantees that they will meet the donor's requests and fill in the gap for funding if you
070can't if you can't make this happen like if you don't have a plan right now I don't think you should vote for this also if one of my high school students did exactly what Amy Magnus did last December they would be suspended out of school cind CC president parent of two Bill TR gradu board me member Magnus is offering an apology for her behavior after the board the December 12th board meeting that is a necessary First Step but her behavior is not the only concerning part of that meeting and and everything that happened after it during the meeting I saw lots of scoffing and laughing when Dr Magnus was speaking lots of interruption all around all across the board after the meeting she was not the only angry person in the room the superintendent engages
071in what appears to be a very intense monologue directed at board member Potter seeming to be very agitated she walks away and then Contin comes back to continue whatever that was about and we don't know what was said because that part of the audio wasn't included in what I've seen on social media I saw no effort on the superintendent's part to deescalate the situation as the highest ranking administrative official with Decades of K12 education experience I would expect that someone in that role would be well versed and in deescalation and use those skills when needed instead what we hear is a threat to call the police that's not what I want to see in this District the only deescalation I saw on that video was from uh the board president do Dr magnus's Behavior was
072wrong and she has acknowledged that but we all know that that behavior that intense does not occur in a vacuum it's often a buildup of tensions and unresolved issues and in this case it's not just from the meeting preceding this incident but months of that same scoffing and a rolling and laughing when others are speaking and dramatic accusations if you all as a board do not board and administrators do not fully address that it will not approve I'm encouraged that Dr Magnus mentioned mediation and I hope that she and the superintendent can engage in mediation to discuss what happen happened in December in a safe and productive space but the problems extend beyond that thank you Michael Slaughter and cesal Slaughter will be after Michael um I'm speaking today as a longtime resident of Yellow
073Springs the old Yellow Springs excuse me Michael can you step closer to Michael sure um I'm speaking as a longtime resident of the village the old Yellow Springs was a community of diversity caring and looking for ways to help our community grow with respect for all I believe the new Yellow Springs has lost its way we talk to talk but can't get out of the way of some of the issues we're dealing with social media insults and threats around our village are rampant this is the school board we elected and I expect vigorous discussions to determine the best path for our schools and the community no school board members should resign we have critical projects that we're working on what I am excited about for the first time in this Village is the coordination and
074dialogue between all the village organizations Council school board ysdc and the township to explore ways to grow and expand the village in meaningful ways no decision is easy be a soccer field affordable housing or Business Development can we build better soccer fields can we finally build some affordable housing and maybe attract new businesses to help our tax base I'm pleased these tough discussions are finally happening so that we can live up to the Village values that we claim to have I say let's just move forward thank you thank you Micha CES and cesal you are our last speaker mine is pretty turn it can you turn it you could be Aston I'm here in support of those who want to move forward I'm in support of mediation if it's needed whomever needs it the professionalism
075is out the window and disrespect is being served from many directions all directions we need to move Beyond finger pointing making faces calling names rolling eyes interrupting and on and on we need to work toward Solutions there's a lot of work to be done here between soccer field and land and the school and so many other things it really does need our full attention cooperation is something that yellow spring used to have but now seems like it's adding in the past thank you so Jay that's it for the list of speakers I think I just hold on to that or pass it down um thank you all uh for your contribution uh and your your heartfelt comments we will now move on to the administrative reports if is typical that we do not as a
076board respond immediately after comments but we will be taking up the litech issue and and board member magnus's submitted apology later later today um okay so let's move on administrative reports we are going to start with Ms Juan I'm going to start with a project share um mson School recently celebrated creativity and self-expression with a project share and it featured the talents of our fourth grade students and fifth grade students you heard Phoebe earlier um share her poem um that she did in Miss hr's um language arts class so the fourth grade students showcased their original um poems and they were preparing for the inspired voices a poetry showcase and had the opport opportunity to perform at little Art Theater um in December so I want to publicly thank little art for opening up and
077allowing our students to get on stage and have that experience um they did that for free so that was a donation um of their facility and they did have the concession stand open the students loved it we did have some students that were a little apprehensive to do it but they ended up getting up there overcoming their fears and performing on stage so if you did not have an opportunity to see that um please know that it was a wonderful opportunity for those fourth grade students and during that Project Share um the teachers took small groups of fif fifth graders and fourth graders and the fifth graders had an opportunity to share their monologues with um the fourth grade student and had really good dialogue after after they um were done sharing so just a
078great experience thank you to the fourth grade teachers fifth grade teachers and to s mean who is here um for making that happen thank you can I ask who's your photographer these pictures are wonderful um Karina thank you [Applause] Karina um on to the food drive after the fall break um the m lawn student council does some type of giving drive and this year it was just a food drive and you can see that we collected over 1,600 items from millson students Mrs Bailey's fourth grade classroom had 309 items they did um win a donut party for their efforts Mrs fulker sixth grade class had 288 and Mrs Courtright sixth grade class had 163 and those were donated to the local food pantry here in Yellow [Applause] Springs and then wrapping up 2024 these are
079just pictures um some of these are I think from Karina some from um from me at some of these events the upper leftand corner that is Miss Titus um with two of her third grade students so so kudos to the Mills Lawn teachers and the middle school and high school teachers we have teachers who work hard they work long hours they care about their students and you can see it in that um picture and I will just say that Miss Titus recently got engaged and we are trying to figure out a way to incorporate her third grade students um love advice into her into her wedding and she is so excited ex about that she she had some of these students as a student teacher um so she's she's just one of those teachers that
080loves her students and you can see in that picture and then you can see um Mrs Joe Franny's um Riker's holiday winter sing along that she brings the entire School into the gym and they do um different cultural songs and activities and the students really really love um that event and then the teachers are able to kind of wrap up in their classrooms and don't have to be in there with the students so the Specialists kind of take that on and then I'm sure that the millson PTO will talk about their Winterfest in their um presentation but you can see pictures of Chandra doing face painting these are all volunteers I think that's mayor Pam down in the bottom right hand corner and then um board member bouquet they're doing an activity with some of
081the students so thank you I want to personally thank everyone who came out and volunteered for that um free event for our students and then there some upcoming events that you can see there peace week is going to begin January 27th um the family skate night that was well attended um the last the last one in the fall that's going to be January 3 30 and then we have the annual Ms lawn Talent night on February 6th um but next Friday if you would like to come out here at the msan choir they are going to sing the national anthem before the basketball game the students who are participating in the mini cheer camp uh Naomi we're up to 62 now 62 participants in the mini cheer camp um and they are going to perform
082at halftime so come on out and see the m one students in action thank you before I start uh my report I want to begin by thanking our teachers so we are at the halfway point this is the beginning of the second semester today and we are fortunate to have loving caring Educators that support our kids that show up early stay late come to events um this is much more than a job for them and and they approach it that way and I appreciate each and every one of them so I want to thank them and then secondly I want to thank our custodians and ground crew so we got dumped with a lot of snow and the amount of time and effort that they put in um extended hours to get school ready for
083us to reopen this week um I just want to make sure that we recognize that [Applause] uh um our in my reports I've recognized our fist despian so in the fall we do two shows um the most recent show was the uh Grim brother spectacular Thon and if you had an opportunity to make it out it was hilarious and um I I want to acknowledge Paul Clark and and my children and I went and my children were stomping on the floor and falling over for days because that was like one of the main parts um but it was it was so well done and and for me the most powerful piece was seeing kids who present as very quiet here at school had very important roles in that show and just see them have a
084voice um and they just did a tremendous job and then our the the second show is our Upper Grade show the O DTA um sure that we have them come in and assess and if we perform well enough we get an invitation to go perform that at the state conference and you can either get uh a short run on like a side stage a full run on a side stage or a full run on the main stage and um The Two Gentlemen of Verona um we were honored to have a full run on the main stage so [Applause] that's and then I want to recognize our bo boys bowling team so we have had um our boys bowling program is only a few years old but it has continually grown um and this year uh
085at the time I wrote this report we were seven in one the only loss was only by 37 pins to Dayton Christian um uh Jackson was here tonight but um and and he's bowling very well in all of our top five Bowlers so in Bowling your top five Bowlers their scores combined and that until your team wins or loses all of our top five Bowlers are in the top 15 in the conference so we have a solid core um our kids are doing a great job and I just want to recognize them for that and then uh finally uh right before winter break we had our semester exams and our school counselor Julie gun um did a tremendous job of rallying community support and she put together she transformed this space into a chill Lounge
086where we had lights and snowflakes and she personally baked hundreds of cookies um hot chocolate we had therapy dogs in so we had an extended lunch during exams and our students were able to come in and kind of relax um for a few minutes before they started their last exam so kudos to her and to all the volunteers who help with that [Applause] and thank you so much Jack and Megan for all you do it's obviously much more than just a job as well and if anyone would like to sit on these uh chairs in the front quite a few available okay um moving on to the mson PTO report that'll be with Liz H hello um not a lot to report um Megan actually covered a decent amount of it so thank you um
087we' had the like she mentioned the winter fest in December so thanks again to all of the community members that volunteered for that um it was a huge turnout again a ton of fun and again a a free event we we hope to continue um we have our uh monthly PTO meeting this Monday January 13th um there is child care provided it's in the Mills uh lawn conference room um I hope that'll fit all but um and we're also going to have dinner um provided at 6: pm on Monday so please come out um we're really looking to um hear new and diverse ideas for uh the upcoming school year uh this at the as Megan mentioned January 30th we have PTO skate or skate night um hosted by the PTO um which is a
088ton of fun and then uh the talent night on Thursday February 6th and more details will come out about that terms of how your uh student can sign up and that's a lot of fun so always looking for volunteers for any of these events and of course um remembers yes I just I'm curious are you still looking for a chair for the um Talent night okay we're good thank you I wasn't volunteering I was just she definitely was volunteer I wanted I want to say that the talent show is the best best event ever there is nothing more heartwarming than going and seeing kids putting themselves out there and so even if you don't have a direct family member or that is part of a school just go there you feel the love of a
089community that is just cheering those kids on we're doing a very very great thing so please come and it's on Thursday not Friday February 6 yes febrary 6 yeah and we're always looking for volunteers um to help with that as well set up and um last year we had some um awesome help um from one of the ad one of the staff here to set up the lights which was incredible and so we're hoping to do that again yeah and and just so about everybody knows the PTO does that they get no money out of it they just do it because we're volunteers and want to do awesome things for the kids in the community this is not a money-making one however the p is always welcoming donations and she'll be able to tell you
090that thank you so much Liz and so February 6 put it on your [Applause] calendar the YSA report this is the teachers union hello Naomi H I'm the president of the YCA and I'm going to read a letter that was drafted by the executive committee um for the YCA to the members of the Board of Education we write to you today as representatives of the Yellow Springs Education Association with a deep sense of urgency and disappointment during our recent fac meeting we spoke candidly about the pressing need for the board to refocus its priorities on our school and to rebuild trust with the community it is disheartening to see that these critical matters remain unaddressed we feel comp to remind you that the work of educating our young people is not just important it is
091foundational to the success of our community our children and our shared future we cannot stress enough how vital it is for all of us to work together to support our schools education must be a priority for the entire community and as elected leaders you hold the unique responsibility to Champion this cause the world is evolving at a rapid pace and our students need a school system that equips them with the knowledge skills and resilience to thrive in an uncertain future this cannot happen without deliberate and focused leadership from you the members of our Board of Education to that end we expect this board to be proactive we expect you to organize your efforts and ask hard questions collabor collaboratively identify initiatives and pedagogies that best serve our students Your Role is not merely to manage
092it is to to lead that means ensuring that the needs of our schools are at the Forefront of every decision every meeting agenda and every public statement it means showing the community and particularly our Educators that you are invested in this work and that you value their contributions we also need to feel that we are all on the same team working toward the same goals at present there is a sense of Disconnect and that is deeply troubling the challenges our schools face for from adapting new adapting to new state laws to navigating the complexities of funding and construction projects require collaboration transparency and mutual respect without these we risk failing our students and diminishing the Integrity of our educational Mission the work of this board is not easy but it is essential we urge you
093to reflect on the weight of your responsibility and approach it with the seriousness and dedication it deserves please focus on what matters most most our children their education and their future this work is too important to be overshadowed by distractions or sidelined by competing priorities our students are watching our community is watching let's show them that we are united in our commitment to build a school system that serves every child and that we all believe in the transformative power of Education let us move forward together with purpose and resolve sincerely the Yellow Springs Education Association [Applause] um I wanted to ask Naomi if you would submit that letter to the board docs I didn't maybe I missed it we did not you did not yeah because some of the things she said I would really
094like to be able to uh reflect upon and it would be helpful thank you thank thank you okay so we have scheduled in the agenda a five minute break I'll try to keep this as close to five minutes as possible so take a quick break uh and uh please thank you very much [Laughter] e e e we're going to start now um the purpose of time hopefully everyone got to stretch their legs and visit a little bit we're going to move to item three fch lhtc stands for lowincome housing tax credit become kind of the lingo uh for this uh project um village has to build affordable housing um the motion on the table is a resolution amending provision two of section 2E of the option to purchase agreement with Yellow Springs Exempted School District
095it would strike the language [Music] seller PR previously providing written confirmation to buyer that seller has secured land to replace the property and as funds available to convert the replacement land into athletic fields that would be stricken from the option contingencies provision two of section 2E additional language would be added to this particular resolution so that would be stricken once acquiring 3.6 acres to to be used as replacement soccer fields by the Yellow Springs Exempted Village School District has been confirmed and a solid estimate for preparing the land for athletic use along with assurance that the cost will not require additional School funds beyond the sale price stated in the option um in order to begin our conversation per Robert's Rules of Order we need to get a motion could you repeat the last part
096you just said sorry okay so the entire um motion is now therefore be it resolved by the board as follows the yellow spring School Board agrees to remove the contingency quote seller previously providing written confirmation to buyer that seller has secured land to replace the property and has funds available to convert the replacement land into athletic fields unquote from the auction contingency's provision two of section 2E once acquiring 3.6 acres to be used as replacement soccer fields by the Yellow Springs Exempted Village School District has been confirmed and a solid estimate for preparing the land for athletic use along with assurances that the cost will not require additional School funds beyond the sale price stated in the option so that is the motion as presented okay hold on so wait if I can first go
097to the point of information from Jud I was going to suggest we since we don't have to do this tonight we have found out oh hold on that is not a point of information me no I was I was G to ask if you I hold on please yes sorry j I know you want to do Robert's Rules the way it's done but that's G to force us to make a motion uh on this on this item yes it it it is requ order in order to discuss it yes all right um I will make that motion okay uh Treasurer McGrath you wanted to say something yeah um so the recommended action here I guess I I have a question as to what people's votes mean because um we we've had a debate about semantics
098if if if I could get a second um before we move to that I'm sorry of information of information yeah there you go point of information we were handed a document when we sat down and um it seems like we got some late coming information in right and so I'm wondering if that late-coming information impacts making this motion can we discuss that first okay so we will um we will be following Robert's Rules of Order uh and that does require for us to deliberate well I can ask for a point of information um okay so a point of information is if you have a question that you need information on yes is that does the information that we receive at the beginning of the meeting that we haven't had a chance to you know that
099we didn't get a chance to review before ises that I mean because the agenda in the item was set before we got that item I'd like to discuss I so I'd like to my question is does that document impact the uh the the item that set forth on the okay so agenda as I understand from Robert's Rules we have the following options we need to have a motion in order to deliberate um then we and or this can die for lack of motion we can uh vote to remove this item from the agenda um or we pass the motion or not pass the motion we get a second we deliberate and we take one of the many actions that we can uh have at our disposal using Robert's Rules uh that would include postponing uh
100which would be like a table uh that would include accepting it defeating it amending it um but we I I do I do want to ask the board to con you know confirm their commitment to the Parliamentary process my question answered right so if you could the question answered as followed we have the following options available to us right the proper procedure here is that we get a second if it does not get a second if the motion dies for lack of a second we move on to the next item if it gets a second we can talk about this issue if uh if you wish uh to remove the agenda item from the agenda not sure if it's too late for that but I suppose it could have it's not too late so you
101want a person could move to remove this item from the agenda um and then it's removed from the agenda and we move on point of information yes it is difficult so I'm asking if the document that we received impacts this item on the agenda so I can know whether it's appropriate to se to second or not because I don't know now any information that you receive am me can impact your decision on an item and so this was uh everyone where talking about an email that was uh sent To Us by The Village half an hour before this meeting that has information on this project um so if we deliberate we can of course talk about that uh memo so can we discuss the nature of that and how it affects the item because I
102don't again I don't know it's hard to know I because I'm not in the loop Amy I think what we need to do is to we need a second so that we can have those conversations okay so uh Judith moved is there a second okay Amy Bailey seconds it and now I want to turn it to Jay for his uh input oh well not input uh this is this is a question um there was some um discussion over semantics now uh it is typical that all items on the agenda um the typical languag is they just recommend it now um there have been points in the past where you know we followed the typical protocol of language um and that uh the superintendent myself have occasionally included the language it is recommended that the board
103approve such and such um as we were directed um and it was not our personal recommendation um so there has been a request that we change it to say is not the recommendation and we um follow Direction on that the question then is um since it's not the recommendation if you vote Yes what does that mean it would mean that the board did not follow the recommendation but if I well I I okay so so yes is still affirming the the resolution thetic issue yes yes yes so so if they yes it's still to approve the resolution even though um it's not a recommendation of the superintendent okay yes that's the that's the case and so now we're we've got things set up for hopefully an open deliberation and uh I'd like to start with
104Terry Holden to comment on her recommendation and comment on the issue okay um I was asked by vice president hempin when she was president to not put items on the agenda that I didn't approve um that the language this the standard template language recommendation to approve was confusing so for this one um I tried to be very clear that it is not my recommendation that the board approve The Village's request to remove this item number two of section of two of the option to buy for two reasons one is any protection we have goes out the door when you take that out um and two it it does not make us whole because there's too much missing information um we all know we are waiting for land donation information which we do not have I
105am very likely to change my recommendation in the future if we have that signed and sealed so not that it's coming and I know it's coming so I can talk to that but it is not signed and sealed and two um what what none of us know right now is the location and the location becomes important because there's no way we can get an accurate number about the cost to turn the land over if we don't know the actual location so this is where we are right now tonight and that was my my my recommendation was as such thank you now now I'm going to uh practice the pretty scheduled or you know regulated deliberation uh just for your information according to Robert's Rules a board member has 10 minutes to speak and can speak
106and we'll continue until our deliberation is done but I do ask that you perhaps keep your comments much shorter than that uh to below five minutes um and point of point of information I I I looked at also at the Roberts rules we have 10 minutes each and we can go twice correct now that I yes okay go twice I'll go for I I'll go with that okay and as president I find it's the best practice that I do not have the last word um hopefully I speak very little um so I'll start with whoever would like to Robert's Rules also say that the person that should start the conversation is the one that submitted the resolution so who submitted the resolution um well in this case I will defer to Judith U because I
107submitted the resolution however Judith made the motion so we'll have J to start okay so what I would like Rebecca is for you to give us an update because there's information that uh the public don't know and and I would like to hear a recap it as as well before we actually start talking about it okay and I ask um Terry to chime in and add information as she knows it so uh first of all you know that this uh process has uh been about six months from the time in May 20 um on May 21st of 2024 uh the board approved uh motion to investigate the um possibility of selling land to uh the village of Yellow Springs uh for the purpose of affordable housing and it was at that May 21st meeting that
108it was laid out that things had to happen uh the first was a subdivision of uh the existing Morgan Fields which would pair off 3.6 Acres leaving about five and a half Acres uh to the west of that so five and a half acres of Morgan Fields remains soccer fields uh and that the uh parcel is rezoned for RC zoning to all apartments and that the lean it be removed uh that lean was on the property because of of an existing encumbrance uh for um the school to get a um a loan and finally uh that replacement soccer fields were um were found and secured so that we could continue to support our recreational soccer program uh those three things uh have been the goal uh in July we reaffirmed a commitment to those three
109things and strengthened the language on requiring a replacement field and the funds to put that land into uh quality practice fields for our kids um in the fall uh the first two conditions were met first the subdivision and rezoning that was pretty straightforward there was some know you know uncertainty considerable uncertainty about getting Bine removed it was removed uh and then the big portion the big piece here was acquiring that land and having enough money to turn it into soccer fields uh we had been talking with neighboring land owners and uh one of those land owners uh her letter uh was or their letter Matt and Julie Jones agreed to gift the land uh 3.6 Acres uh they own about 80 acres directly uh to um that way to the south of us and uh
110it extends uh to the West beyond the school property and as Terry pointed out she has said we would have 3.6 Acres along you know this uh border of her property but exactly where it lands in that strip is still yet to be determined and so uh we know that the land is right there um but we don't know exactly what the bound are for those 3.6 Acres uh and the process has has taken some time uh with regards to Legal agreements uh however as Terry uh inferred uh that process is nearing completion and I I would just like to say I express my deep gratitude to Matt and Julie Jones for this gift uh it is an incredibly generous one and you can tell from her letter she has been very committed to soccer
111in this community I imagine some of you know the Joneses or know their kids uh her daughter is active in club soccer same Club my daughter played and galaxies and uh just just very connected uh she also brought uh that uh British soccer group uh to town before covid if some of your kids participated in that she's also committed to affordable housing her and her husband Matt both are um and so this gift is contingent upon the successful Award of the litech funds for affordable housing uh so the other piece of this is the date and I think that's what Amy Magnus was referring to uh at the last School uh council meeting sorry the village council meeting I think a several of Julia mentioned that we were given this really tough timeline like we've
112got to solve this tonight we got to really put our necks up I'm editorializing right now I'll stop um but fortunately we received a memo from the village manager uh this right close before this meeting that uh they won't need our decision until January 21st when the Village Council has their uh meeting and that means that we have the week of the 13th to come together with the documentation we need with questions answered hopefully um to take up this decision so we do have that extension this motion is on the agenda because we need to have a motion on an agenda in order to uh push this through and it reflects the state of things as of Monday of this week A lot has happened since Monday and so that's where where we're at does
113that answer your questions or do you have any further questions I have a point of information um do you want to read Julie Jones's letter now was that part of the LTE I don't know if it's appropriate for you to read it now before we discuss so the if people haven't read it yet I'm sorry we have to find it it's under communication yeah I got it the last it's a lot of them thank you okay um and she the second last that Julie Jones got it okay um so hi Terry please consider the statement below to be shared at your board meeting on Thursday if you have any questions or concerns please don't hesitate to reach out to me thank you to ease the concerns of the residents especially the soccer community in Yellow
114Springs we wanted to tell you why we're considering donating a portion of our land we hope you will find this personal note reassuring starting in 2015 for four years when we lived in Miami Township both our children participated in Yellow Springs Rec Soccer during this time we also hosted British soccer coaches in our home they traveled from England to teach soccer to Yellow Springs children our youngest daughter transitioned to club soccer only after she was encouraged by Bob Curley to play at a more competitive level she continues to play at an elite level and has traveled extensively across the US hoping to play at the Collegiate level soon we highly value what your soccer Community represents to the village and most importantly the children we understand the driving force behind replacing the fields is to
115create more affordable housing and we also support this initiative Matt and I have been closely involved in working with individuals who have or are benefiting from lower income housing at some point in their lives we understand the negative stigma associated with this type of development however we believe the Yellow Springs residents will radic radically accept and enhance the lives of those who reside there to complete this donation agreement we have already spent a considerable amount towards attorney fees and reviewing contingencies to protect ourselves in the school while championing championing the re soccer program's goals our effort time and personal expense reflect our desire to fulfill our offer to donate a replacement if needed unfortunately these steps take time and we've had to change legal representation to exhibit aite this process to align with the litec
116application submission and Schoolboard approval timeline we are currently in the final review stage and I expect the donation agreement to be completed next week please rest assured that we are working diligently with the parties involved the Ys school board agraria and the Village Council to ensure the continuity of the rec soccer program in Yellow Springs Matt and Julie so Judith you can start okay uh the first thing I want to do is um just read a little bit of the end of the memo we got from Johnny Burns Village manager um so um basically just his last sentence I guess it is I am optimistic that the goals of all parties Village Schools and property owner can still be satised satisfied even considering this typ timeline and I want to say again people keep saying
117this is none of the this is not the work of the of the school board and in some sense of course they're right this is Village Council uh responsibility however the school board also thinks to the Future about the school district one of our strategic plans is to have a diverse uh School uh school district and uh student body um because of the cost of housing in Yellow Springs that diversity is we're losing that diversity and the reason I was interested when this uh when the village asked us to consider this and because this is the only piece of land currently that would have enough points to be able to possibly get the app have a successful application um I felt that was very good for the school district I don't think we just think
118about the current students and I was right from the beginning very um supportive of our Rec Soccer uh League it's an excellent program and there's always been a commitment but as soon as we started talking about it people got scared you're not g to make you're not going to make sure we're you know the soccer league will be um maintained um but that commitment has been stated over and over again um I don't think we're going to go forward with this until we have everything in place and now we have a little bit more time so that's really great because I really hoped we would have a win-win s uh solution that we could come up with but it was going to take time and a lot of creative thinking and hard work to try
119to help it happen um this is not just affordable housing this is Affordable family housing this is going to bring families who are less uh lucky than us uh who have been been able to afford to be here um to be able to really enjoy all the benefits that this Comm that this community and this school district um provides for families and children and so I I believed I know some of you don't agree with me but I believed that this actually was uh something that the school district should play a role with if at all possible uh the other thing I want to respond to is is Dino's um Dino's comments um I just want to point out I mean I know we're being accused of violing Sunshine Law um that we shouldn't be
120talking to the Springers for more Springers who is an advocacy group for affordable housing that we shouldn't be talking to a village council member and that somehow how by two school board members who are allowed to talk to each other outside of meetings and work together in fact they should be working together um it it is not a violation of sunshine that we're working with uh Village Council Members that is not a violation and the other thing and that I wanted to point out is that a guaranteed um Freedom that we have in our Constitution and it's a very important one is the freedom of of assembly uh it's the freedom of Association is and it means that the individual right or ability of people to come together and collectively Express promote pursue and defend
121their Collective or shared ideas the right to freedom of Association is recognized as a human right it's not just in our constitution a political right and a civil liberty so this notion that there's something illegal unethical about us coming to together and working for for the good of the community for the good of families who are less who have less uh than we do that is not unethical and so these this constant you know idea that is unethical is not true and so I'm just trying to clarify that um and I think you know at this point I'll stop can I do another point of information sure just regarding the timeline um so Johnny Burns's statement says we can wait till the week of the 13th which is next week right to right and and
122so their meeting is on Monday the 21st THS is the 21st okay so we would hold a meeting next week would I believe T Tuesday because of the holiday oh okay oh yeah Martin Luther King day okay so we would have to hold a meeting next week to potentially approve this so that they could have it on their desk by Tuesday so my question to clarify is when we received the donation agreement from Julie Jones does it go to our attorney first I received that agreement this afternoon around noon um it is can you say that again yes I I received that from Julie Jones around noon today it is in the hands of our attorney um I have not however had opportunity to talk to him about um whether he receiv received received it
123and what his timeline is it does have some changes so it it certainly necessitates him looking at it um again I think my biggest concern is what I stated um at the outset and that is there is no property identification and I think that's feels like a big missing piece but it's in the hands with you I just want to make sure that the timeline would work in terms of when we receive it when we have to have our meeting and then when in Council make assuming we wouldn't have to make a decision tonight I just want to make sure that we have time thank again just a reminder we need to post a special meeting two days before okay um so we'll move to uh the next person to deliberate or do you want
124I'll go or you can go I'm going to need a few minutes so um okay so I um want to start with thanking Matt and Julie Jones um you know what they've offered to provide for the district is very heartfelt and I very much appreciate it um and I know it's coming and I I appreciate the honesty from our our Administration and I have trust in them I know we will be getting this that's not my concern what my concern is and I think I Echo what a lot of the comments tonight were was the cost the the Gap essentially how much is it going to cost what's the difference in price between what we're receiving and how much it's going to cost to make that land usable and accessible so I I had um
125Sarah print out some copies so everybody has I brought visuals I'm not a teacher but I brought some visuals the map yeah Sarah could you put that map up so since Matt and Julie Jones you know um [Music] oh okay so now that Matt and Julie Jones have disclosed that it's their property um I I feel it's okay to share just to so the community can have a visual this this is not for debate or questioning but um so you can see the field location the potential field location is likely going to be somewhere along that side okay we don't know exactly where it is um but I want to base my questions um off of worst case scenario okay so worst case scenario is at that farthest location where it says field location all
126right so the reason for this map is to kind of explain one of the cost factors which is accessibility so in order for people to access the field on on their property we are going the part the close there's two this is going to show the two parking lots here can you can you show where of a campus okay so the school is here okay um the new new parking lot will essentially come out to about here like right in the middle here okay so we'll have a parking lot here this parking lot is staying is so I so my estimates here are two different access points to to access the field from a parking space so from this space we're going to go out here and walk across so we're going to need accessibility
127Ada accessible past this way and then down Mary's way um to where the field will be so thanks to the Green County auditor site they will calculate how far that is so that distance one way is 31 miles so that is 62 mile walk from the parking lot okay so then the other one scroll to the other one so the other one the other option of parking to access the field location would be where the parking lot ends here so we would need an accessible path here to access Mary's way and that distance is around trip of almost a mile in terms of walking to drop your kid off to soccer practice so that's not what it's that's not what I'm necessarily here to discuss what I want to talk about is you know this
128is going to be a cost to to have the accessibility for so I have a statement I'd like to read make it yeah yeah okay um because I I know people have been asking like how where's the L how are we going to access it like this kind of just gives you can you can look at it and you can kind of think of some options okay so I'm going to read a statement and I want it to be something that this board considers tonight Village Council has requested to purchase School District land for housing project throughout this process the Village Council the school board and all entities involved have con consistently agreed that the school district must be made whole before the land can be sold being made whole is not just the land
129itself it means the district must receive replacement land for the property being sold as well as funding to cover the cost associated with making the new land usable and accessible for district purposes this requirement has been affirmed not only through verbal commitments from all parties but also through the district's unanimously passed resolution in September I included the language in our uh resolution um but the two stipulations in there the first one was language that Rebecca um changed and the first one was that we will not sell School land until we've received land to replace it for similar use and then also that the district has the financial ability to cover purchase land into usable and accessible athletic fields it is critical to understand that the school district cannot be financially responsible for replacing what it
130already owns the responsibility to ensure the district is made whole lies with the Village Council we understand that the developer W has communicated to the village that stipulations requiring the school district to be made whole cannot be included in their contract if the guarantee to make the district whole is included the application will be rejected while this is understandable the fact remains that these stipulations need to be upheld regardless where they are placed it's unfortunate that home in and St Mary's consistently indicated that a good faith agreement with the district's needs would be sufficient for the litech application these assurances were the basis for initial discussions and I specifically raised these concerns during the May 21st school board meeting when representatives from homing and St Mary's were present at that time it appears we were
131misled to make the project seem more appealing the district must remain firm in its requirement to be made whole before selling land to the Village this has been the foundational agreement throughout this process the village now faces two options either abandon the litech project or remove the stipulation requiring the schools to be made whole from the developer contract if the ulation is removed the village must still commit to ensuring the district is made whole the school district can choose to drop the necessary contingencies in 2E after entering into an agreement directly with the village to cover any financial responsibilities the district incurs as a result of this project while the exact cost may not be known it is not the school district's responsibility to account for or absorb these unknown costs any failure to ensure
132sure this would result in a financial burden on the district which contradicts the principle of being made whole the district has already taken a significant loss by agreeing to sell 3.6 acres of land for $339,000 which equates to $94,000 per acre for context a half acre of property on Dayton Street half a mile away from Morgan Fields just sold for $225,000 which would value 3.6 Acres at approximately 1, 620,000 by selling our property at this dramatically reduced price the district is already making a substantial concession proceeding further would not only fail to make the district whole but would also violate our fiduciary duty to responsibly manage District resources this situation now requires action from the village in order for the school district to consider the removal of stipulation 2E and the option to purchase agreement
133the village of Yellow Springs must formalize an agreement with the school district guaranteeing that they will cover all expenses related to the project Dorothy Boke and I expressed all of these concerns in our email to council back on November 17th these are not new we've received a very wide range of estimates to convert Farmland into soccer fields and no clear information regarding the cost of the additional items if litec Schoolboard Liaisons are confident that the project completion will be under $339,000 they should have no problem asking the village to commit to covering any amount over $339,000 if not they likely realize it will be more and the school district will be expected to cover any potential difference the village must commit to covering all costs exceeding that amount expecting the school district to solve this
134issue requires one government agency to cannibalize another all at the expense of the children in our community I remind my fellow board members of number four in our strategic plan finances yellow spring schools uses resources the yellow spring schools will use resources strategically to support the district's Mission and plans for a sustainable tomorrow time is also money and we've spent plenty of it this year on this Village housing project this process has been ongoing for nearly a year the time has come for the Village Council to make a donation to uphold their commit or make a decision to uphold their commitments our administrators have critical priorities to address including overseeing the district's $55 million facilities project unresolved commitments and funding sources only hinder the district's ability to focus on these vital initiatives not to mention
135the community has clearly spoken so what makes us whole um the five things that I've listed that make us whole which we have all discussed at some point in all of these meetings we've had so the first one is converting donated land from ffield to soccer field which is an unknown cost ADA Compliant accessibility paths to the property which is an unknown cost paved pad for portable toilets and storage sheds that's an unknowned cost we're going to be almost a mile away round well round trip half a mile away from a building any money the district is asked to provide in the donor agreement including any brush removal to access the property also any legal fees the district has already absorbed and will be charged regarding the sale of Morgan field and the land donation
136estimated legal fees the district have paid through October are around $21,000 so what I want to propose I actually I I would like to discuss this tonight and hopefully come to an agreement with this amended resolution I I I have the resolution it's the same resolution that we were presented I changed some of the language so I'd like to just to mention what that language is so first of all one of the changes is at the top resolution amending provision two of section 2 of the option to purchase agreement this is with the village of Yellow Springs it's not with ourselves so the only the whereas one of the whereases that I changed was whereas the Yellow Springs School District is committed to our strategic plan of finances and uses resources strategically to support the
137district's Miss Mission and plans for a sustainable tomorrow so everything else is the exact same up top now therefore be it resolved these are the action items so first the new section of 2e of the option to purchase agreement will read as follows which is exactly how it's presented with the strike throughs that the buyer will exercise the option will be contingent on a on an award of the um of the lwi income housing tax credit so they have to actually earn it for us to sell it so okay we can do that we will only agree to that after the school district secures the donation of the 3.6 Acres and the village of Yellow Springs agrees to fund any expenses over $339,000 on the following items collectively and they're the five items that I
138just explained um earlier this is an amendment to what was presented to us to just release all protection for the District of becoming whole so I would like to hear what other board members think of this proposal so I so so uh point of information which document is this one to replace so as I understand on agenda yeah but there's resolution on Thea right so this is Amy M Bailey has not has not yet said she would want to replace this um the the proposed motion with this or or amend the language she simply asked uh for continued deliberation with her revisions in Mind Correct uh so this would be uh you know the now therefore VI resolved U would be what would replace what was proposed in the agenda uh Amy would you like
139to share your comments now me um no actually it kind of like can we pause for like a minute so what we can because I wanted to just capture the highlights because I I this document isn't in color yeah yeah isn't in color and doesn't have the changes and I just wanna I want just real fast I wanna point of order yeah yeah well I've got one I've got one I just order we didn't have this document before the meeting correct yeah we did I it's an amendment to it it's the same right and and anyone can propose an amendment to um resolution so uh but I just hold on yeah so am if while you're doing that um actually it would be really helpful to have the soft version because then I could just
140PDF would do it beautifully yeah yeah yeah let's do that I will ask any anyone to further or you have comments I I don't have a comment yet I have a point of information and it's for J when he has a and can I can I also give mine to can I pass mine down since I've highlighted the part here she wants it email so it's just adding that so when attention I'll ask him the question okay Jay I have a question we have a motion on the table and so in this case we do an amendment to the motion we have at the table can we replace the motion that we have on the table with this one what are our options to follow it would be a a motion to amend the resolution
141for this okay and we can just we amend the existing resolution to be this one you would vote on the amendment and then you would vote on the resolution so someone needs to move to make an amendment yes and then if we have a second then we can have a discussion on the am on the amendment have amendment to an amendment okay I move that we amend the resolution that we have in a packet with this one so hopefully we can have a discussion about it great is a second okay so just to be clear if you all are following this uh so we are now going to be talking specifically about Amy's uh proposal Amy well doroth you as the maker of that amendment can start us off uh yes I was going to
142ask if Amy you could also email it to Sarah so that she can put it on the screen so that she has it so can we project it there so that people who are interested can get closer and read through it there's a little bit of yeah okay um so I made the amendment so I need now I need to discuss it okay I'm throwing away all the strategy that I had about talking with it this is going to be stream of Consciousness and I'm really sorry for that we're just going with the flow because we understand that we are even though we have more time we're on the on the timeline and I also want to start and say that I'm very thankful for Jones's um a plan donation uh I think that this
143is this removes one level of difficulty that we have here but it's not the only level of difficulty and I just appreciate them for coming here and with the best intentions that they have um I also share the same concerns that having the donated land is not the final solution but there is still an unknown Gap um and um like I think that uh Bard member B explained I struggle with Vis Gap to be um on the shoulders this financial gap to be on the shoulders of the schools at that point so my the only question that I have here is that even if you know this board comes around and say yes the village should carry that financial burden it doesn't mean that they're going to say yes to that and so my question
144is what if they say no then what happens uh I do however I think that I think that um it's fair to explore that and it's a question that I would like to answer and and that's something that I would uh push back eventually to um the intergovernmental task force uh the suggestion that I would make with that is that maybe some a way to be more productive to be productive and to be more Swift is to replace one of the two board members that we have on the intergovernmental task force with Amy Bailey so that we can have all of those preparation of documents done in between meetings so that when we come to the meeting we can have a reassurance that this has been fought through uh from all points points of view
145and from all uh areas of needs and yeah so that that's something that I would want also to discuss along with this is is it time to change the intergovernmental task force so that we can we can um have a more productive outcome next time we get together at that special meeting that will be now next week thank you uh okay um I will I will chime in here at this point uh just just a couple things I I um I in principle agree with a lot of what Amy Bailey is asking for um I wanted to just give a little bit more information about the project uh so uh just to get some some questions answered um one question I'll have in we've talked or members of the community have said we have to
146talk to to the Rec Soccer people and at this stage where we're really close that is very very true because I have the question of what uh at least in the short term uh would be done with the five and a half acres that's untouched and if Rex soccer uh could use that and if it would meet if it would be adequate or not that would mean that the girls soccer the women's soccer practice field which is now on on the west side of Morgan field would be at this uh location of where the the Jones property is uh which might address as its uh practice for our hopefully middle school but definitely High School soccer teams access may be a little bit differently um imagined uh it would be directly across although we don't
147know the exact location and I think we need to find that out or at least get a better idea because there is a range of locations here it would be just at the other side of the tree line as Where The Boys currently practice um and as you can see on the map it's closer to the school building to where we're sitting right now it'll be closer still when we build uh the new wings of the high school middle school in that direction by a little bit not much so that would be a question I'd have for this soccer folks and our in our coaches um I also will hope to postpone uh a decision on the amendment uh and original motion until we call a special meeting next week because we don't need to
148act today and uh we would be in a much better position to um make decisions I think by the end of next week I am hopeful and actually encouraged by this discussion because it helps us narrow down uh what we need to know uh especially in terms of uh what that Improvement of the land looks like and that's something that uh was communicated uh to us with regards to um you know trying to find out a cost we received a cost from a contractor a a bid guaranteed not a bid an estimate sorry an estimate guaranteed for a year that is that uh two 200 under $240,000 however it does not cover necessarily all that we need to cover and there are a lot of questions around it but it's getting us closer right it's
149it's moving Us in the right direction and uh you know that that week uh could certainly help us answer as many questions as possible and see what kind of request we might need to make of the Village right to just guarantee make sure the school is remains whole The Village has been just in their defense I I I believe they have been a very good partner in many ways uh they have paid for the legal expenses uh to remove the lean uh they have U Been uh instrumental you know in in kind of helping this go forward they did the request for proposals uh for a developer it's very competitive it was a competitive pool um I was great was great to see that uh they've put a lot of hours in this uh and
150to the point of the cost of the fields um and the selling price I just want to reiterate again that a an appraiser was hired and paid by the village because we agreed not to use school money uh to find a market value for the property uh that would be a market value if you went and sold it uh today and I I see some heads shaking uh it but that is what was articulated in the appraisal it was appraise value not right and not local value um I okay well I I I I see a council member shaking his head please look at that again that I think that the council meetings have tried to clarify that um and also U please ask what land is selling uh for across the street uh so
151I poed ground industrial yeah industrial sorry not okay well um I I I put that out there and to um encourage you to information yeah um so at a previous school board meeting meeting we we this is a question um this is a question for our Superintendent at a previous school board meeting we we we saw um mockups different Amy I'm gonna I'm going to stop you because uh a porter of information really has to be not necessarily about information you would use for your deliberation when when you are on on the floor you can ask those questions and then respond to them so I I just don't want us to go down a rabbit hole and I I'm I'm going to wrap up my question in my my comments just a a bit um
152I'm sorry I thought you were done um and okay it was I have a question for the superintendent okay hold on to that question um and so I I really feel uh that we can move forward on this um and I uh will encourage us to postpone this motion until the end of that next week and answer those questions I myself will do some research on on the point I raised it raised uh some doubts and share that information um so what we need is some more information about exactly what needs to be done to convert the fields um I am hopeful we also need to talk about where Rex soccer can play uh and I also in that sense of what we've called Apples to Apples I think I what we are thinking about
153in terms of of access and spell that out a little bit more okay um I I think that Amy Madness is Amy Magnus is the next one on well I do want to go about this but we yeah I've already spoken but I this is this is about the amendment do you want to go first because this is yours we're only talking about the amendment yeah this is only about the amendment I still haven't gone for the other one okay so could you do you wish to have the floor Amy you know I'm the school board member who you know so I'd like to hear school board members first who've been involved and then go after them does that make sense this is one of the reasons why I asked for the point of information
154is that there's information that I'd like to ask and then remate a little bit on before I have a chance to talk and to hear from other folks so can I have can I can I do my point of information now then let you take speak okay I appreciate that thank you um okay so um we we saw a mockup um previously so my question for the superintendent is um is the is that information been not necessarily shared I'm asking a little bit more than shared has it been discussed with the Joneses are they aware that that's kind of an approximation of our expectation when you when you say mockup do you mean our new facility layout I'm trying to remember the winwin mockups yeah we you presented those there was a couple of there
155were two different versions of that yes I mean they're where in the end that so they've seen that they're do what they're going to do expect that from a property but they have not communicated anything except it would be close to the boundary of the school because we do have the bike path uh in between okay Juden so I would like to table this discussion but I don't know if I can when there's a um Amendment because I because so I'd like to make a motion I would like a chance to speak before we table yeah yeah that's why I post I I just put a postponement out there but I didn't make the motion so um if you can if you can hold until we all because a motion to postpone means that a
156debate ends and we vote okay okay so Judith do you have I mean because we've got some new language here and I'm actually ready to talk about that um but I'd like to hear your thoughts first on the language that we have in front of us so Amy now is your time to speak I think we're this because I mean this this is this is new to me and I'm also the school board me you know so I'm not one of you three and so I'm this is this is I'm looking at this fresh well I no I didn't include Dorothy in that because Amy's the one BA remember Bailey's the one who's bringing the language and then you two are the representative so you three are intimately involved right and so I just wanted
157to make sure have we heard from all three of you first or we've given Judith the chance but she deferred okay so um this looks good but the it's the four you know so this is my this is my concern is that um I'm a little because there's five items so a b c d and e um and I always get nervous as you know so I've done contracts manage can contracts I'm not the contract there was never a good contract enough offer that's a big job um but I was definitely the program manager and it's you know it's it's that language that we use um there's it's usually a little more precise and so I appreciate what you put in here but things like any money that the school district is required to pay
158in the donation agreement um it just it seems a little too it's it's it's I get what you're going but it's just a little too big okay um for my comfort and I think the same is true for E all monies that the schools um district has spent or will spend in legal fees it when any things like all monies um it again is that it's those are words that we tend to avoid using in this when talking about requirements um so I just ask that that language be a little more specific um I think that you as a draft this is good I wish I was a little more intimately if I was more intimately involved I'd be able to get a little more precise but I just know that you know that's the
159sort of thing that my Contracting officer would put a red flag on so um and that's just my feedback on it otherwise you know it looks fundamentally good so um that's the only thing that I'd say on that Amendment so uh uh I but I think I but I'd really like to know specifically and if that's you because I talked about unfunded require not I talked about specific requirements so if we're going to I like this idea of saying this is the number that we're focused on that we're limit that are capping ourselves at and these are the things that we agree as a board are the things that that number has to um cover because if people start adding and that's the reason why I like any and all are kind of unspecific information
160is is that is that I want to know specifically what those items are that we're agreeing need to be Capp because things might come up and we don't have that's the thing that I'm kind of like if we can agree these are the things that need to be covered within that set of numbers that I'm more comfortable with that and I the bake information is the thing that makes me uncomfortable okay everyone um and I just also information looking at documents we've received very closely another question just to put out there is I do think we have to confirm um whether or not that $30,000 cost is still part of the agreement might not be that's that's what D meant to answer your question Amy um sorry D when it says any money the school
161district is required to pay in the donation agreement I didn't specify the amount because we don't know it yet but the draft had you know that we have to provide $330,000 so that's any any ask in the donation agreement for the school district to contribute needs to be included and that's what that meant okay I respect that again it's difficult in a legal document to not you I can appreciate the complication right so I just wanted to clarify that I I think that they will need to check if the new agreement still has that cost it may not um so at this point uh we have a a lot of uh great discussion thank you and a lot of questions uh out there but also I think a tendency to say that we would postpone
162this uh until you know until calling a special meeting uh next week uh and then ideally uh if everything is in place then the the uh issue would be do we have the assurances to remove that language we didn't have the FL twice though fine okay so um I'm gonna go to Jay just a couple of things that were said this was the only piece of land that qualified it's not accurate um there were multiple pieces of land within the the village that did qualify um why the decision was to pursue the school District's land and not those other pieces I cannot speak too it was broken oh do you want to use that um then there was the mentioned that this is Affordable family housing it is affordable housing it is family is not
163a requirement there is a certain number of single bedroom units um now undoubtedly some families would take advantage of the affordable housing um but it is not specifically towards families um we we've always talk about like for like apples for apples um and I guess I just want to point out the reality of the fact that um any other piece of land there it will not be exactly the same as you can see there is a difference on that that piece of land on to the distance that people would have to travel to get there um there's some things there there's things instead of like for like you know there's some things that are more and there's some things that are less obviously for parking and accessibility people are going to have to walk further
164to get there um from our existing parking lots or they can't park in their car and watch at this time uh more one of the requirements really to make it into soccer fields is something that that our current Fields don't don't have and that is an irrigation system um had some discussions this this week uh follow up to the uh you know the estimate that that we received um and they talked about the amount of water that would be necessary to keep the fields alive basically um until they can be established um and they had a suggestion in there to to run water from our building to the field um one the talking with our Personnel uh maintenance Personnel Village water pressure isn't enough to run an irrigation system it's only 45 and our current
165irrigation system runs on 70 um we have a well so we we do have some sort of idea of how it works but most likely it would require a well and an irrigation system which isn't something that that's at our current Fields but it as far as the distant goes and operationally and making sure that we're able to water they also said uh 250,000 gallons of water over I believe the first season was the estimate of the installer so ridiculous amount of water um best way to mitigate that is dig a well put it in but there is additional cost with that which we wouldn't have at our current Fields so I did want to point that out thank you and these would all be um I think at this point it is incumbent of
166us to get as uh thorough an estimate of potential costs as possible Judith I would move that we um table this I think we still have a couple people all right well I'm gonna going to say a couple things then I thought we could table at any time I didn't think that you had to do good well can um you of course you can but out of respect of uh you know others wanting to follow two times the reason the reason I raise that is because there's there's unknowns that we're going to have knowns within about a week and so it seems to me like we have a lot of questions and trying it's it's a preure conversation in my mind secondly the wide range of quotes were not quotes those very high numbers were
167a phone call nobody went out to the field Fields everybody looked at it and Bob mlan who many people in town know said you cannot give a quote unless you go and look at what you're talking about so I don't those numbers were kind of thrown out um but they were not actually quotes I just wanted to make that people aware that the Gap we don't know if there's a gap actually so talking about the Gap is if it's a thing that we know we have we don't actually know that Apples to Apples yeah I think that's important to keep in mind um and the plus you know we had talked about uh whole plus to me the plus is the children who will be living there and the expectation is there will be a
168lot of families with children there that is the expectation so um um and I trust the people who do affordable housing who tell us these things so um they're the experts so um the other thing I had wanted to say earlier is that but at this point hom is not involved with this uh so I hope at some point they will be be but at the moment they're not um so okay so if I can thank are are you done Judi so I'll ask U am doroth would you like to speak yeah so um if I'm on the understanding of the process I can use my time to ask a question to Terry and then um we've heard uh the feedback from our treasure here but I wanted to hear the feedback from our superintendent
169uh based on what this amendment this amended resolution is do you think that it would be a valuable path for a district to reach a win-win win uh path yes but I just think there are a lot of unknowns and and we may be able to get answers to them but um um I will I will put a fact sheet together for the board I will tell you I just got information that the $339,000 on the um assessment is fair market value I will submit that to all board members but in the land donation agreement and I don't want to speak too much about it because it it is in the hands of our attorney right now there are costs that are not unknowns they are identifiable and they are in the agreement I will
170Point those out I will total those up um they're not tremendous but they're also not ins significant that I assume would then come out of that 339 so look here's what I know about working on our own project you blink your eye and it's $100,000 and so we just need to be very careful I think there might be a Way Forward is that way forward going to come next week Bo I I it's just really tight you know even if we got the land donation agreement all buttoned up which is certainly possible that's probably the most possible but I think without an identified location it says it starts at at this point and goes to this point it's really hard for somebody to come out and give a quote on what it takes then to
171convert um that Farmland to soccer field and I think the board also has to consider we will have cost okay I mean part of part of running running a district but the number was actually 350,000 gallons of water to just to make sure that the seed sticks right and and as the treasur said we don't have that cost now because those fields have been around for a very long time so I will try to just do a simple onepage that says here are the things to think about um but I don't I I don't want to mislead anyone I think you know tonight's Thursday night to get this done for a council meeting the day after a holiday when it has to go through our attorney Etc and then we don't know a location I
172think that's that's really tight thank you for that um so I was thinking about the timeline that we had we've heard at the beginning in the re organizational meeting that the only day of the week where we can meet is Thursday so I'm assuming that if we have a special meeting about this is next Thursday so we have a week in there and for the sake of expediency what I wanted to come out of this conversation with is that is the intergovernmental task force going to take the philosophy of this amendment that the village is going to carry the extra cost beyond the 339,000 000 I want to have a clear understanding of the direction that the task force will pursue here and because we need to be expedient here I also want to know
173whether or not board member B will be included in this task force because I think that a lot of those conversations need to be happening in a working committee more than at this table right we can deliberate all we want but we won't have a estimate at the end of this session but that can happen through a task force um and I will keep it to that so those are the two points that I'm hoping that we will get here that you uh board president could could clarify by the end of this conversation thank you um so I just want to clarify that with this resolution I'm not questioning if we do or don't have a gap that that's not what I'm it's if we do have one The Village needs to be responsible for
174that Gap that's what I'm saying so finding the numbers would be important for V The Village to know not us I mean obviously yes we want to know but that's something that they would need to be responsible for because they would need to be confident that they have the budget to cover what those costs are but from this conversation it doesn't seem like we're going to be able to find those numbers by next week I do want to say I'm not available on Thursday next week for a meeting so I just want to say that now before I forget but how are we going to get those numbers by next week like that's that's one of the questions I have and then um when board member Magnus mentioned um d and e being vague um
175I mean I understand that they're vague it's because we don't know the numbers but I think we can you know it specifically says legal fees so I mean we can change that language I I I would want to know what you propos that we would change it to go ahead board member madis so I would like us to agree that um on a specific set of requirements that have to be funded within that Gap and if um and so that everybody's on the same page and there maybe some if there's numbers that you know are handwavy then I'm sorry it's not I like specific numbers so that everybody knows because we have to like give the Village Council this is what you're on the hook for you know or what we're putting we're putting our
176actually this is what we're putting ourselves on the hook for and if anything goes over this among this group among this group of charges then we're going to be looking for help if we go over that but if there's additional charges it's hard to like say oh Village counsil you're going to be on the U on the on the because I don't I don't think that it's not fair to them to like say um write us a blank check so um it so it's really I I want us to be very specific and I know that you within the constraints that we have I think that we'll I think that we'll um be able to get closer I well I think we could get a a specific list and say this is what we know
177and this is what the numbers look like and that should give us a reasonable okay we're close we're there we're almost you know that feels good I think because from the numbers that you said tonight uh and even with the $32,000 is it it sounds like we're close and with even margins so I I think that um if there's surprises that come up and one thing that we have to do is we have to come up with a contingency plan because there's a bunch of things that can happen and I think that you know that's one of the things that's that we as you know as part of this this as part of this acquisition have to think about is like if we if unexpected things happen what do we you know is it is
178we can have this disc discussion uh about what we think are appropriate paths forward as we handle those you know as Contin you know in case in case something comes up let's you know it would be good to have as part of this conversation um you know kind of like a reasonable idea of how we're going to approach those unexpected events so I really like the idea of with what we have firming up those numbers having that data sheet that I think I really want that the only thing that I'm cautioning at is that let's make sure that we're being good partners and that our language is specific so they so the Village Council knows you know what we're committed to covering and um and what we're looking to like use this $339,000 for and
179not kind of sneak things in there that also should be covered by that and you know it's it's this is just about being a good partner is let's put the numbers in there specifically that we have right now let's um if if we want you know there the and there's additional things that we can do that I'm very that I'm open to but I just don't like open-ended I really don't like open-ended I don't like thank you for think she answered my question so I just have a couple more things um so I um it's not fair for us to say to write a blank check either so that's where I'm saying that's why I'm putting it back on the village I want the village to be as dedicated to the school district as they
180are to the developer um so 100% so if I can just sum this up this these are the action items I'm hearing um and I'll just State these and then I'd like to kind of move on it's getting late just if if anyone has something they need to say say it but otherwise I will turn to Judith um so you'll get your chance uh so it sounds to me that first of all uh doroth has asked that a member uh of the current intergovernmental task force step off that would be either myself or Judith so that Amy Bailey can step on and then uh the request from Amy Bailey is to uh go I guess very quickly tomorrow uh to the task force to ask the village if they are willing The Village government is
181willing to uh you proide any any Assurance uh that uh any Gap would be covered or deliver some kind of statement that would give us more assurance that the school is not on the hook for this money now it is clear from the village Village's request that in order for this to be a successful uh project and I think we can all share people's frustration of you know why wasn't this part of the original uh proposal uh in the original RFP why wasn't caught then but it it does mean that for there to be a successful application uh we would remove this contingency but for I'm hearing from many members of this board um in order and the community in order to remove that contingency we need to have a legally binding gift which is
182in the works and we need to have a sense not only of the scope of work so we can estimate its cost and some kind of assurance from the village that if there is a gap that they are willing to um fill it and I do tend to agree with Amy Magnus at least it doesn't seem like we're looking at hundreds of thousands of dollars um but we really do need to figure that out um so uh so I I have I captured what where we're at I'm just concerned about the timeline for for next week I can't come Thursday he can't come Monday Tuesday I you know I and then Answers by okay okay so I'll I'll kind of go go around okay in terms of the action items is that did you I
183didn't hear it because you know the specific set of requirements so the first action item which I would probably do after because we have an amendment on the table so after the we vote to postpone or if that fails we vote on the amendment and vote on the uh motion uh we would resolve uh the request that Amy Bailey be on this interg governmental task force group um and we would articulate our desire to the Village to be willing to um address the Gap uh that if if there is indeed one and this point of order it sounds like we first table the amendment we we would first need to table the amendment well no it it's um it's hierarch article so when we postpone this item we are postponing the amendment and the motion
184at the same time so we don't need to table them separately no we don't we just we move to postpone and it's like a package it's like think of it as an envelope and goes on the desk until we pick it up again okay just point of order is if we're postponing it do we need the amendment um we can take that up when we take it up again um oh good point right we take it all up oh okay that's that's a very good point okay I'll I'll I'm just kind of wondering just how this works yeah yeah yeah and and hopefully we can get through this so um if everyone is okay I I will turn to Judith for a motion uh I'd like to make a motion that we table with is
185there a second and it's to postpone it technically is there a second I say gr it okay um all those in favor say I I all those opposed okay now let's address uh the intergovernmental task force question um Judith I I think it's at this stage of the process it's a very reasonable request we've not been meeting so I'm not quite sure if it's going to be playing a role here but and try it so um can I ask that you step off yes okay and Amy join should we vote um you can request a vote we you can request a vote okay it doesn't have to be by person it doesn't have to be a voice okay so everyone AG I'm cool yeah we're all agreed yeah I think okay KN down those requirements
186would be great yeah and then um a would say that the intergovernmental task force has been tasked Representatives have been tasked to address this issue with the village government are we in agreement with that okay well that's where we at thank you everybody I'm sorry we're kind of discussing this can we make just make sure you got off of the superintendent and the treasurer about that plan absolutely and I want to be able to say I'm on board big language makes me nervous right okay oh what happened to my agenda um so the next we are addressing the next item on the agenda um administrative administrative calendar um Communications we move the communications item a lot of communication down to the lch okay thank you for that um so pada letter I'll hand it over
187to you am I just want to um ask some questions to my to so Judith and Rebecca have been on the LTE task force um they've been involved with the Springers for more Springers group um we came to know about these conversations via a social media app so I just would like some clarification from Judith I emailed you on July first and asked if you were representing who was representing the board at the Springers for more Springers meetings because it was said in in Village council meeting that that we had school board members attending these meetings and you said you and Rebecca were but you're not you're not representing the school board right I have I have it right here but yeah okay so all of this information that you're discussing in this Discord is
188Schoolboard information so I'm confused and it's privileged client attorney information I'll tell you the truth I am not on Facebook so I have no idea what you're talking about this is not Facebook I know but you're talking about a document that I have not looked at so I cannot answer that um school board members any elected official is allowed to be involved working with folks who support have a common purpose and that is I do not believe I'm sharing attorney client privilege I know I've heard other board members doing that from time to time but it's discussion that's going on and you're trying to make something happen that is you are allowed to do that but I don't have the document in front of me so I could I couldn't say what you're talking about
189quite honestly and and so hold on um just do that right just a point of order I really think that Amy if you have a number of questions for Judith just just lay them all out and just give her a chance to speak um and I I can also say that I can address this issue because I'm more familiar with it so my main question was are you are you representing the district or are you there as a citizen because you told me originally you were there as a citizen but then that's where I'm confused when all this information is being as board business being spoken about um so I don't have a problem obviously you can join any group you want to advocate for whatever you would like but you cannot misrepresent the board
190or say you're not representing the board but then providing board information so that and so J I can wait until she's finished we'll follow over her I'll just refer to our code of ethics um C is to respect the confidentiality of privileged information H is to render all decisions based on available facts and independent judgment rather than succumbing to the influence of individuals or special interest groups everything in this in these discussions is a special interest group and you are trying to influence them you're you you're influencing the decisions we're making at our board meetings um avoid conflicts of interest or the appearance thereof and then refrain from using the board position for benefit of yourself family members or business associates that's all I will say about it it is I I do want to
191just say one thing you're involved with Y you know Ys soccer Inc and that you are advocating for soccer is fine well I mean your husband coaches a team that uses our Fields there is I don't think that's a problem uh being a soccer coach is great but you're allowed to if you got an interest in it in you're advocating for soccer because your kids are on the soccer team on in the soccer league um uh because your friends are in the soccer league you're allowed to advocate for that I'm allowed to talk about Schoolboard business not attorney client privilege business but Schoolboard business I do have freedom of speech even though I'm on the school board so to say it's inappropriate to discuss Schoolboard activities if I advocating if I want the school board
192to do something that I think is good for the community and good for the district I allowed to talk to community members about that that is what any elected official does and did you want to go ahead um so I I I've prepared this statement I was actually planning to deliver it in another context but it's relevant here um I have looked at the the document that Amy Bailey is referring to first I want to make it known to the Comm community that the these messages were from a private group um uh private citizens of most of them are also families with young kids uh a member who had access to those messages uh captured those messages uh without notifying the group without their permission uh their private messages um and then uh they were
193assembled uh selectively in order to kind of create this narrative that makes it seem uh that there was some sort of sharing of information uh I want to also point out that those dates on those messages uh are are being rearranged uh in ways that don't necessarily follow uh the Act exact order of those messages and they also delete or many messages in between that deal with many other issues besides you know the progress on this one a lot on the effect affordable housing has on communities and and a lot on just general zoning issues a lot of hand waving and welcoming of of new members and support for the school levy uh that was passed in November uh so those things were not included in what was presented it's also false information that this
194was going as Mr Turner pointed out this was going to be uh part of the public documents for uh the last Village counil meeting uh the village solicitor decided not to post those uh probably because to do so uh is kind of government compelled of exposure of political speech which is against the First Amendment um I want to uh State I if I can get get it up here again some some facts about uh the the text uh first and uh foremost all of the information presented in those texts are is information that was disclosed in our May 21st meeting uh with the whole breakdown of what the school board needed to do um who needed to do it the representation of you know that we needed to get the lean removed from certain financial
195institutions uh Etc and uh there's even a memo from uh Judith in the May 21st meeting packet that explains all of that information uh there are a number of of inuendos that when you know we work to get some money from a GoFundMe site to uh get bills paid uh that it was somehow elicit however that was discussed at both Village Council meetings and here at the school board I don't want to belabor this I just do want to encourage you all to to you know [Music] to move forward and and and try to you look at some of these accusations with a certain amount of critical distance um and because I will confess that this outrage on Facebook is is has has emotionally impacted me um in um in ways that I are not
196good for anybody uh so I just wanted to make you aware of that uh Amy that the documentation I looked through that documentation quite closely and in no instance did I find information disclosed is put out there that was not already part of the public record or mention at these meetings beforehand um and Springers for Bor Springers last point was formed after our May 21st meeting any implication that they a lobbying group is quite a stretch even though they had good potluck um and I they you know they are not contributing to any c any campaigns uh so let's try to support uh our our citizens um in engaging in in activism Amy Bailey and I served on the levy committee uh in November to get to get that November Levy passed was just the
197two of us uh we did not VI uh violate the uh open meetings act uh we're very well versed in uh the open meetings act we're very careful about it it's was on our own time and on our own dime and any kind of activity political activity that board members or council members or anyone elected engages in on their own time and on their own dime is essentially active Civic engagement so let's please respect it uh for that am I being recognized yes you okay I agree that the board's Affairs have been distressing I agree that they've been I I'm sure they've been impacting all of us at this table especially the last month um and and I heard I heard what you said you said that the Springers for more Springers or the content
198of this group was part of a private conversation but in tomorrow's paper there is a letter from Matt rasca that says that Springers for Springers was open to the public and welcome everybody and was a public group okay so now we have two board members and I believe a council member that was on that so I believe that constitute that any written communication between all of you is a public record and and it seems that you are in possession of it so since you pointed out that what has been submitted uh to us is incomplete and rearranged could you provide the whole record for since the beginning in the creation all the minutes all the Discord so that we can have it in the public and then we know that we can rely on on
199the real the real record I've heard you say that you that uh board information was not shared outside of the board but what what has been submitted to us suggest that there has been clients at any privilege information that was shared outside of the board before it was even shared with us with a whole board based on the date that I provided and that that was so incredibly disheartening because that means that we are not provided with all the context that we need to do to do our own job but some people outside are you know and they haven't been elected and they haven't sworn an oath to office and they haven't sworn to be following the Constitutions of Ohio and other United States and all this you know so just to put everybody at
200ease here can you provide the whole record and then we'll be done with it thank you yeah Springers fmer Springers is a Grassroots uh advocacy group for affordable housing this is very bad for our society as you can imagine you know I mean isn't this a good thing don't we want people engaged in the political discourse of our community and then I mean I'm just amazed at this and that we're wasting our time talking about this kind of stuff I don't get any benefit from affordable housing because I don't need it and neither does my family but I care about people who do and you and so I don't I don't I really don't understand the level of just mean is out there quite honestly there's nothing dishonest about this and to be asking for
201a for a you know it's an open meeting for people who agree and who are who want to support affordable housing that's who initially it was open Amy came to the meeting came to a meeting so I stepped away so we wouldn't have a we wouldn't have a suntime sunshine violation I went in the house and hung out with oh okay you know basically but um these kind of inuendos about citizens who are trying to do good work it's really bothering me a lot it's very it's it's um just yucky I think there's nothing dishonest about it um am Magnus as board members in between meetings were allowed individual choices about what other board members I mean we're having conversations with so we're limited by Sunshine laws to not Gather in groups of three so
202if somebody else like say if I wanted to go to one of these meetings right um trifly this is this has come up is that you know is that I knew that if I would be if I knew I was going to be a third person at a particular meeting then I I I either had have to actually say nothing while I'm there they have no interaction or or I don't go so that's the that's kind of the Restriction I mean because I'm trying to think of this is it one of the things that I do in the community is I help Michelle FS manage the Four Season farmers market do you want all the documentation associated with that are you representing the board there um hold on please don't interrupt and and may ask
203a question I me that's the thing is no I'm a private citizen doing good works so if I I can so I want to um again remind the board of two things and I think we've all stated one time and so I'm going to ask that we move on because first I'm sorry the I I have some feedback from some of the documents that were shared at the last meeting um that I would like to share you know some some feedback but you know again is that this is there's there's forums that we have for this um and that's not necessarily here at this meeting I it it's you know there's ways of kind of communicating amongst each other that um you know again because we have choices of who we associate with and we
204have choices about which other me we're going to associate with in a particular setting like say uh a sacame or a pyck you know um and there's there's this so this is this is plus I can't imagine managing every all the the the records I mean I decided if for records retention is that I can't imagine I mean this the information the the all that all the information that would have to flood into the stream to cover all of us and we're all signing up for this at the same time I it let's Let each individual member choose who they're going to work with on a particular topic and go to particular events with because that's their choice that's their god-given right you know and but the thing that we need to hold ourselves are
205to Sunshine laws we have to be careful about Gathering and bries and you know and you know if we inadvertently or or you know socially Gather in greater numbers like a bunch of us went last year 2023 you know we were invited over to the superintendent's house for instance that's a situation where we're you know Gathering socially and we're not discussing board business and we can do that as long as we do not mention board business because you know then it becomes a public then then it would need to be a public meeting okay thank you very much um we don't have a resolution um or a motion on the table uh Amy Bailey can bring a a complaint uh and put it on the agenda for our next meeting I was asked to answer
206two questions a public group uh that does not equate to a governmental group uh so you can have private political assembly and be welcoming to all members uh but you are then not under uh public records loss uh and I would um say that the organizers of Springers for more Springers are the people you need to address your requests to dor um and uh with regards to attorney client privilege and not violating it I just if there is a further desire uh to uh pursue a formal complaint um please uh document the the the ca the cases that you're making with the full record so we can look at them openly and fairly okay I'm going to move on uh to the next uh item which is uh adoption of the consent calendar correct I
207make a motion that I think this is the administrative administrative yeah that we open the administrative consent calendar second second okay um I can we can go ahead quick three items two you've seen before from last month second reads um the third item is uh what we do every year and that's approval of in transportation in transportation okay um are there any objections to the items on the consent calendar I am am I being recognized yeah I am a asking that we remove the new policy p165 for a separate discussion I I want to make a motion to amend it I see okay um and I should have asked for those removals early so thank you uh any other removals any objections okay we approve the consent calendar by unanimous cons no I I asked
208I made an amendment to amend I moved to make an amendment we have to treat it separately as a separate issue okay so I haven't lost sight of that we'll just consent to the things we consent to and then come back and then come back to it yeah yeah but you roll call vote okay and Ahad option for discussion if if people okay and um and we'll we'll talk about one of the um clarifications these documents is on on the consent calendar uh so roll call vote so we pulled out po I meant 0166 my bad 066 that's what I meant now 0166 it's a p p 166 166 okay all right Bailey yes okay yes HL yes Magnus yes Potter yes motion pass Five to zero okay um I make the motion that we
209amend point a in policy Z policy 166 and maybe we can pull it off it right now it says at agenda shall be the responsibility of a superintendent in cooperation with the board president I am asking that it be changed to shall be the responsibility of a superintendent in cooperation with the board president and the treasur to prepare an agenda I just want to add the treasure onto the agenda preparation I need a second I'll second okay and discussion do I give my argumentation now y I believe that there will be a more effective way uh to prepare the agenda with the whole input of our administrative team uh I'm concerned that sometimes we had a uh we were finding out during board meetings that uh our treasure add objection to some items which I
210believe could be fixed during the agenda setting and it would make those meetings more effective uh I'm opposed to that um I found it difficult working with the two administrators at the same time in agenda planning I uh asked Jay to give his input and superintendent on myself he certainly uh could reach out to me if he wanted to talk to me about it but um I found that quite difficult and so I don't want to uh insist that that be the case if that's not working for the president okay any other comments I would I would oh sorry yeah go ahead I would just like to know what is typical in other school districts okay Amy Magnus that would be a good idea so I I uh make a motion that we table until
211we find that out is there a second I'm afraid is there a second to postpone this to our next meeting is there a second okay it dies for lack of a second Terry I I can easily answer that and the standard is the superintendent and the treasurer okay good um any comment Jay is this effects treasures and it would be for a a long time until it were to be changed yeah a lot of my suggestions were simply procedural things um and they would meet and prepare the agenda and then I'd have to go back through and do some stuff and and there's just some procedural things that were missed um as they look at it because I'm looking for different things and then the two of them are um my agenda section is not
212very long but my duties to the board uh during the meetings uh requires review of the agenda and a lot of those items were simply missed when I wasn't invited to the meetings um I I can say I you know I think the um difficulty was that um Terry and I agreed on some of the suggestions on the agenda and Judith disagreed with us um don't know how to resolve that but we she didn't like that her that Terry and myself agreed on things um is the way that I felt um and I will say it's been very confusing because she would work with Terry on the agenda and then afterwards I get emails directing me to add things to the agenda so I'm understanding that you recommend that we take make this amendment um
213and so if there's no further discussion we after can we have a second time because very quickly it's getting late uh go ahead no you personally um it's it's an interesting um thing to suggest um a lot of this comes down to you know is it you're going to be the person who's um operating out of this um is it possible to try something and then bring this back after a couple of months and find out get give kind of input on you know is this working out and is this something that we want to make a permanent policy change I'm just saying is that can we can we kick can we can we kick this around a little bit before we make a policy change my understanding is we'd bring it back to amend
214it if we wanted to change the policy back to some other form um J just to say personalities were a problem in that meeting I think the president needs to have the opportunity to to uh have a meeting that she's comfortable in okay um yeah I I think I was just conscious of how long the meetings have been running last year and and I believe that this could be a way to keep the public meetings to a u a length that is more effective for everyone around the table including the audience okay okay um I I would just say I I I do wonder if why uh treasure is not included if it's standard um but uh I I suppose uh that um that and it would be nice to have a little bit of
215time but that didn't get a second and so uh let's call for a vote I think it might what's that I can make a motion I make a motion that we table no we we already did and you know I just I didn't know but um so I'll say a roll call vote because I believe this might be divided Jay you want to call the RO Bailey yes yes hling no Magness defer to the president so I'll say no uh Potter um moving forward I will vote Yes uh I think we have to work to to have as broad representation as possible okay and I'm fine with changing my vote that's okay I thought you could you can but it passed so I think we're good if you're fine with that Amy um so that's
216done now let's go to the next thought I could do that let's go to the next uh consent calendar uh Financial is there a motion to open I make a motion that we open the fin yeah we're all eager to get done with this okay is there a second okay go ahead Terry or Jay go ahead Jay okay um only real highlight on the financial forecast is after the or not Financial forecast the um Finance report um after the updates with what we received in October um if you look at our percentage of revenues Benchmark is 53.6 6 and we're at 2.6 something so within 1% there and then if we go down to expenditures um Benchmark is 49 and we're at 50 so again right around 1% on our benchmarks for revenues and expenditures
217according to our our budget at this time of the year um so um and besides that it's been updated for the um extra income tax that we received which we discussed that but the endup tax we got a nice bump but it actually just sort of catches this up for the last year so right okay um any any other questions from the board good let's take a vote Bailey yes okay yes hling yes Magnus yes poter yes okay let's open the Personnel consent calendar I so move second I'll second Terry you're this one's you uh Personnel schedules this month are very short most are required by law where we re-approve our substitutes um have to do it two times a year so go thank you to the substitutes we need you okay um any objections
218I I had just a quick question can you uh tell us whether or not we're fully staffed and where we at in general we're fully staffed and bu drivers we're fully staed okay that's that's that's a miracle than go so um let's take a vote Bailey yes UK yes hling yes Magnus yes Potter yes motion pass by to zero okay so those are all the consent calendar items we are now uh to item number s um accepting am magnus's apology uh there to approve Amy magnus's apology as presented um we need a motion in order to open discussion so is there a motion is that how it's done yes it's how it's done yeah is there a motion um and but but I do right you do need a motion to in order to start
219to deliberate a point of of point of information yes okay I move that we open uh the acceptance of am apology okay so the accept to accept Amy magnus's apology okay never mind I didn't realize was that language um you can move to not accept Amy magnus's apology or point of information yes the way that this portion is written is is confusing to me so you're saying that to discuss this we need to move to accept um Amy Magnus apology but then there's a vote at the end so the vote open the motion is not the vote on it right right you have to have a motion so we can focus our discussion I so move so we can focus our discussion okay you can do that is there a second a second okay a
220second by Amy Bailey so now we can open uh discussion and by so doing uh Dorothy you can start off our deliberation So based on my understanding of Robert's Rule is whoever posted this document should start and present the motion I think it is whoever makes the motion starts but let's let's look into that um for the next meeting the information I have is whoever makes the first whoever makes the motion has the option okay all right I want to thank board member Magnus for submitting those documents and I want to point out that I think that board me board member Magnus has the best intentions but sometime that intention is not aligned with the impact of her words so with that I would also point out that this motion is built in a way
221that board member Magnus may be the Swing Vote on accepting our own apology which would add further injury to the situation that we're trying to solve so it's a tricky motion to just navigate just how it's presented um so back to the motion on the table um I took board member Magnus is called to do uh to be trauma informed and I looked up the five elements of a good apology as outlined by the crisis and Trauma resource Center Online there are five elements one is Express regret be genuine and humble and don't blame others two is accept responsibility explain what you did wrong and take the blame three is make restitution commit to fixing the damage four is promise change reassure the other person that you'll avoid making the same mistake again again five
222is request forgiveness be sensitive to the other person's feelings unfortunately board members magnus's apology falls short in three ways her apology blames others her apology is incomplete by skipping the threat that she issued to board member Bailey and finally it is not my apology to accept in fact it's not the board's apology to take either it's it's for Dr Holden and board member Bailey to decide whether or not this is an acceptable apology so in view of this here is what I would like to S person to Bard member Magness I understand you didn't mean any of this and that you did not anticipate the impact of your behavior and uh you have one way to rise above make this painful make this painful process go away regain respect and set an example for our
223kids and fulfill your role as a board member of a public school district you can call for the board to censure you based on policy 33 62.1 and I'm going to ask Sarah if you can to pull that policy from our it's uh the board policy 336 2.01 that's uh which title is threatening behavior towards staff members you can call for the board to censor you based on that policy and it would demonstrate that you are accepting the consequences of your acts that you are prioritizing the true mission of a board and that you are restoring standards of decency it would end what I'm expecting to be an agonizing ordeal here and you have the power to do this and if that's okay I would like to read it except that I can see it
224well from here I'm going to do thank you okay uh the Board of Education believes that a staff member should be able to work in an environment free of threatening speech or actions threatening behavior consists of any words or deeds that intimidate a staff member or cause anxiety concerning his or her physical well-being is strictly forbidden any student parent visitor staff member or agent of this board who is found to have threatened a member of a staff will be subject to discipline or report to the authorities the superintendent shall Implement guidelines I don't think that this last part we app but but superintendent shall Implement guidelines whereby students and employees understand this policy and appropriate procedures are established for prompt and effective action on any reported incidents um so in this case it does identify
225agent of his board as um being subject to this policy it does identify that a threat can be any words that intimidate the staff member or cause anxiety and so and it does spell out that the board has the duty to uh either discipline or report to the authorities so that's that's my proposal here or M Bas is that you can make this go away thank you Amy um remember it'll be a process of deliberation so you might want to wait um till you hear from others but if you you're ready okay I just want to let you know um in response to member V is that member bouquet if another board member is found to have made a threat against another board member would you think that that policy would apply are we am
226we we aren't going to go back and forth so set all your you'll want to make your a statement and then when my concern is we have to be able to hold ourselves accountable all of us accountable is that um I was threatened at after the school board meeting and I don't want to go into the details but um [Music] so so I would respectfully ask that that not be asked of me [Music] here okay I I want to um this is some good information to have um it's important to realize that unlike um other staff issues where you can go into executive qu session to address uh these types of concerns uh our policy is very clear in the case with a board member it needs to be done publicly um and it needs
227to be deliberated on using parliamentary procedure and that's why we have it as an issue on the agenda and why we needed a motion to start the deliberative process um and so uh I I just say that in in the the in response to Amy's um saying you know what why here uh and this is the place that our policy dictates that we have this discussion um can I interrupt I I seriously need a moment absolutely okay uh we will take five minutes um but it will be five minutes Jeremy that e e e and just to remind us okay uh so you can continue Amy thank you I appreciate having a moment I just want to point out that the first goal that I have under mediation is that I feel safe when I
228come into this environment and I just want people to acknowledge what that means thank you uh and next uh deliberation someone anyone want to say anything Jud yeah oops sorry hello Okay um after the meeting on um uh our Treasurer said to me you know this is a result of months and months and months of an escalation of bad feelings amongst this leadership team and I agreed with them um I do want to say first that in spite of it all we have actually gotten a lot done to support our district and the community that it provides for students and families so there's been an escalation of bad feelings uh that started in February like less than a month after we receded but at the December meeting there was a lot of bad behavior from
229many of our leadership team and when I say leadership team I'm talking about Administration and the school board all of which was unacceptable uh it didn't include absolutely everybody on the team but almost everybody and I will start with the worst thing that happened which was after the meeting when Emy Magnus lost her temper and loudly used course in inappropriate language at our superintendent totally unex acceptable something not like that cannot happen again other unacceptable behaviors that es escalated things I mean if you weren't here that night the tension was through the roof the last half hour of the meeting uh during the meeting Amy was interrupted several times by our superintendent wants to correct the one sentence she got out about ysdc and it turns out she has been correct on that issue superintendent
230has interrupted her several times about it and uh Amy was right um and then after that happened Amy was talking and she and uh Amy Bailey didn't agree with her and I it's it's obvious to me that Amy Magnus has trouble keeping focused and Amy leaned in and said no I don't agree you know I.E I don't agree with what you just said and Amy said um let me finish we can Rumble any time we can argue any time that is what she meant and she immediately clarified it by saying anybody who knows me knows I'm playing now I come from a workingclass background I didn't hear that as a threat at all because it wasn't nobody from my background would have heard it that way I heard it as an effect as an effort
231to reduce that tension that was already through the roof uh by making a little basically a joke that's what I heard now the American Association of school administrators ethics is part of our school district policy it requires us to support due proc process and protect the civil and human rights of all individuals due process does not mean that the person who thought they were threatened get to decide that they were threatened we know there's many stories we've heard that people based on pre any number of kinds of prejudices or maybe just don't like the person are going to hear something that they did not intend um and so that cannot be the final word on whether a person threatens somebody or not the way de process uh works is that you have to you can't
232just say you threaten somebody you threaten that person and then insist that that's true that doesn't that's not how it works it would lead to so many unfair I mean in the criminal justice system people in jail because somebody thought they were being threatened when that person was just a big person usually a big man and awful often based on race that is not how you can decide if somebody was threatening somebody and we have our our school administrator ethics says it has you know part of that ethics is to support due process and protect the civil and human rights of all individuals so you cannot ignore what the person who said the words of said about what they meant you can't you cannot ignore that you cannot insist that you know better and people
233repeating over and over that Magnus was threatening violence does not make it true have you ever heard that story uh the Emperor who had no clothes that that story keeps coming into my mind uh uh we must defend due process to ensure fairness ignoring due process has led members of our leadership team to say things which are untrue this started these things being said are unfairly smearing magnus's reputation and I'm saying unfairly because it's untrue she is not a violent person she was not uh threatening violence and a good example is to what happened in February when when we received a censor request from our superintendent against Amy because she sent eight words in a message to a teacher uh that said um let's see if I can find it here um your anger was
234palpable it was almost misdirected she violated policies she violated policies because we're not allowed to interact with our staff it has to all be through the superintendent and she thought she was talking to this person because they do theater together in the community and there had been an issue of Comm about the theater program in the school district which which Magnus has supported wholeheartedly and she thought there was a misunderstanding unfortunately and rather thoughtlessly she sent the message at 2 in the morning and awakened the teacher or whatever time it was it was during the middle of the night so it was really a bad idea um so um shortly after that two board members um called for a censor a special meeting for a censor request and they said those eight words created a
235hostile work environment for the staff the administration and the school board I mean that is over 50 people that's 60 70 people so those eight words created a hostile work environment that is defamatory in my book if I was if someone said a fact that I I unintentionally violated a policy which she did do and that it was creating a hostile work environment for over 50 people because she sent eight words to this teacher that's obviously not true it is untrue and you don't get to just say these kind of things about people when there's when you don't know that it's true and I know that wasn't true because it's so obvious right so at the so on at the 12 Amy is being interrupted and then it's being interpreted and by our superintendent that
236she was that she was threatening violence and then there was a big dramatic I have to send my my staff home because this is so bad and then Rebecca finally had to say you know there's the tension in here is do high let's just call it into the meeting and we did and then after the meeting Dorothy is yelling at Rebecca I understand she accused her of lying superintendent comes out of this room slams the door really loud I understand it was an accident but she didn't say so and she looked Furious so there was a lot of tension in the room a lot of people weren't behaving very well and were very angry and it was after that that Amy lost her temper and behaved very inappropriately there is no excuse for it I'm
237not making I'm not making excuses for it I am just telling you a lot of people behaved very badly that night and it's been happening all year and it started in February with a request for a censor and and that became Amy creating a hostile work environment I.E she's threatening in some way so there's been this storyline you know there been you know we if we keep saying it it must be true well it's not necessarily true just because people keep saying it and it's not even uh true just because you know she was saying it to Amy Bailey and Amy Bailey thought it was true that still doesn't make it true we have to use a little bit of critical thinking here and the thing that bothers me most um is first of all
238that people are so willing to trash somebody's reputation taking taking uh what they did to some extreme negative place which is not what happened that really bothers me your reputation is so important to you right and to be have this storyline to the point that it ends up in the Dayton Daily News I mean is this good for our district where are where are the adults in the room who deescalate these situations instead of escalating them um so I mean we've got we've had a history of a real problem in this board last year one of the problems is me that I haven't been gatherling people down enough when they're interrupting each other at meetings it's not okay and it's and it just and there was a lot of me things being said I want
239to say there's a 10 minute time okay am I yeah I'm really done but I just I just want to say I take some responsibility too things have been out of control people were not inviting on asking superintendent quit interrupting she didn't stop that's a problem uh with the person with a lot of authority you know doing that sort of thing and and then everybody starts jumping in you know so I really am appreciating Rebecca um I think she's GNA you know keep us you know behaving better I hope and I hope I hope we can find some way as a an entire leadership team to uh get into a better place uh the accusations it's just I've never I've been an elected official for 14 years I've never been in in a situation like
240this with the elected bodies I've been with and it's and so we really I don't want to say it's one person's fault it's everybody's fault and we really need to try to bring it bring down the temperature um I do not want to see our school district in the day and Daily News in the same way that it has been in the last week sorry I got a little carried away there um Jay can I ask if this has a direct uh point of uh reference to the order of the meeting because I do feel it's important that can you please not um because we focus on the the acceptance of the apology um and only that uh as as a board give whole board a chance to talk um administrators are included in Robert's
241Rules of Order as as allowed to speak is my understanding so so I'm I'm asking that maybe you can hold your comments um because I do believe that we should deliberate as a board that's fine okay thank you but I would like to speak before V okay anyone um I I will then I'm not speaking last I I have right so would you like to go before me go for it okay um so I I want to make it uh very clear and I I detect this in Amy's apology um I've heard her say it uh but I want to say it that board member magnus's Behavior after the December 12 school board meeting was highly disrespectful of her superintendent and staff and as serious breach of a decorum and there's no doubting that and
242I want to keep my comments to what's on the table and that is the uh the apology that she submitted uh it is important as a board that we send a clear message that we do not tolerate that expression of anger profanity and derogatory slurs uh which is UN unequivocally not acceptable I see an apology from Dr Magnus that publicly apologizes to Dr Holden and the staff I seek an apology from Dr Magnus that publicly apologizes to Dr Holden and the staff and to the district as a whole also I seek a recognition that the impact of this kind of incident already distressing for all involved is Amplified to an astonishing degree over social media and that makes the burden on us taged with deorum even higher um and acting with respect and decorum as
243many said tonight is something we have to model so I ask that Amy Magnus continue to work with Dayton mediation to draft an apology that fully addresses the impact of her Outburst on December 12th but I recognize the people who have who have to accept that apology really are of course Dr Holden and the staff who were present at um on that [Music] night I uh ackowledge uh Amy's discussion a very personal one of her uh neuro divergency I ask that Amy join me uh now in my role as president to meet with uh someone as who has a professional expertise to help determine how such interruptions that could uh lead to uh stress and expressions of anger can best be managed in the board meeting setting But please understand I'm I'm seeking constructive steps
244forward and this is not an excuse uh for her uh her words and her actions at the end of that meeting they crossed a line and I want to make that very clear I've also is as I think mentioned in her apology I don't think any board member is denying that uh as I think Judith has said you know we had the issue of censure at the last meeting I find this ISS this particular incident very different from that one much more severe um I'm a advocate of restorative justice and I though I understand people may very much disagree with me on this we can have a censure we can vote for a censure I do not believe it will change things uh I I do believe that an honest cor conversation which i' like
245to engage in with our Administration and our our our board on figuring out what could may have some benefit if we all commit to it but first and foremost I ask that Amy show us as a board how she can assure that this won't happen again uh and that it is done in a way that is satisfactory to all involved especially our staff who I think need to know that this behavior is is just from anybody from anyone is just not appropriate no one should be yelled at um and I I also say that I absolutely have a great concern for Amy and in the sense that she has contributed to this board and her commitment to the schools and the kids is sincere um and so as reflected in what Dorothy said I think
246we all recognize the the the humanity uh that she shows in so many ways um and so I do ask uh that we approach this situation know with with a certain amount of Grace Point of information yes okay and we won't forget any yes are you saying you said that uh you would ask for board member Magnus to redraft an apology with the help of um a mediation specialist does it mean that you are tbling this motion or that you're are voting no on it until it comes back with a different improved apology what is exactly the action that well as I interpreted your comments I would vote I would not accept the apology um and tabling I guess or postponing with be another option but that's what I was thinking and I I you
247know I I think that in conversation um that offers Amy an opportunity in this apology we see a lot of processing um I was dissatisfied with it and I have conveyed that uh but I do see um I do see a potential given that she's working with dat and mediation of of moving moving towards a real assurity that we this will not happen again okay um I think it's Amy you can go there's been several things said tonight and I I feel it's important I I really pict appreciate doroth and Bay when um talking about these are the things that that's a good standard and I appre appr that and as you can tell there were several friends of mine who came who I longtime friends and it's important I'm you people are like wow
248Amy I I can imagine they're kind of like going that must be really hurtful it's like no that's a great show of Love um I didn't meet my own standards that night and I want everybody know that is how um you hold me accountable is each and every one of you hold me [Music] accountable I I welcome that because I want to live up to your expectations and I want to take the opportunity to say I am sorry not to just the people in the room but especially the people in that room and I want to take a moment to thank people every one of you in that room for what you did and I want to call you out first I want to thank the treasurer you made the right decision and you know
249I've watched that video so many times you were such a great wingman that night for the people that you care about and I saw that so many times when I went through that video okay you made the right decision okay number two I want to thank the superintendent for seeking out remember Potter um that was really good Instinct uh it you know that was very good Instinct and um you made the right choice you you went to another part of the room and that was appropriate the escalating and in a moment of great confusion for you um that showed great presence of my you people think that Terry's a professional and we don't say that aloud enough okay um just bear with me because it's pretty emotional okay um I also wanted to think there
250was four other people well actually five other people who were in that room that night okay um Sarah and Jack you had two the you had the most difficult task which was to come in here and reset the room after all that attention and you did it with great professionalism and I know I made you both uncomfortable so I apologize for that and again Your Heroes because you were I mean you just did it I mean again you can see that in the your video it's really quite [Music] beautiful and I also want to thank the other two Schoolboard members who were in the room because you were absolutely key to De escalating that situation um you can tell that these two have been in settings where deescalation has had to happen before and they
251did the right thing in fact the treasurer did the right thing there's there was another thing that happened between it's not on the video that's got the splice thing together whoever did that thank you that was really helpful okay um the other thing that I want to say in closing is that um there's a lot of things to apologize for you know truthfully the language is one of the lowest things that I need to apologize for in this okay it's but first it's really really really important that people do not use that language when describing our leadership it's really important don't do that and I I mean that's happened to me and I did that and that's so disappointing to me okay so the other thing that I need to apologize for God okay this
252is hard is um I'm sorry can I have a little time to tell a story um when I was growing up in when I was growing up in Appalachia um it's there was kind of a tradition there's kind of this awful thing in the culture where you're not allowed to be PE you're not allowed to be mad at somebody in your family you're allowed to direct that anger outside of your family at anybody okay and um it's a place of privilege that people and I I just really disappointed myself in that I did that that night you know it's an irony that these words were used before but Terry I apologize to you because my anger was misdirected and and I recognize that I do the things that I shouted that night were not that's
253you know what I try to do as part of that narrative is I try to actually represent what happened and again is that a lot of these people on this side of the room are here right around the holiday working hard for this District and it was completely appropriate and they were very appropriate about it when Sarah reached out and said you she called me on the 20th and she says will you be available on the 21st and the 22nd and I respectfully be kind and she was very gracious about it and you know the superintendent didn't come back at me and accuse me of doing anything wrong in fact she made time after the holidays to sit down with me three separate times the person is it Terry I I expressed anger towards Terry
254and that was totally off B if I held anger it was for something else en TI it it was for other things and those are the things that I kind of so my I was angry in the moment I directed it it in the wrong direction and it's that boy the irony of that is not lost on me it's not lost on me so there's a lot of work that has to be done to kind of walk back all the tensions that we've and all the hurt that has been built up over the last year and I want us to work on getting past that that because oh gosh Terry I know that you have a great vision for this District I know that you do and we don't talk about it enough I'd like
255to get to it I respect you and I apologize for disrespect you making you feel like you were disrespected in the moment it was wrong and I can say that and I can say that out loud okay thank you um Amy Bailey um haven't spoken yet um so I don't even know what to think about all this but um I mean first thing you know you might want to use your sorry I just find it interesting you know the situation happened I was involved I've never ever been asked about the situation or anything by any board member any leadership you are the president um so that is concerning to me in terms of gathering all of the accurate information um I'm very disheartened that this year is coming is taking off to the same way
256that we ended last year um when I want to know when when does a censure when do what is warranted by a censure I mean I I don't know because if it's mouth vent that's actually grounds for removal from office if it's misfeasance that's grounds for removal from Office a censure I I would like to know my fellow board members um definition of when we use a censure um Amy we cannot hold you accountable you said that we have to hold you accountable you have to do that we cannot and I would like to know you mentioned somewhere I can't remember where I don't think it's in either one of these statements but that you had you had done training after the March or one February March incident um that you did training so I'm
257just I would be curious to know what that was um and honestly I would just like us all to go home and just look up the definition of gaslighting um as homework um My Hope Is that we will have some accountability in this coming year that's all I say thank you I I'd like to ask Terry if you would like to comment and you can pass as well but want to give you that opportunity can I let Jay comment first yeah of course yeah um I have a I have a comment um prepared I know everybody's been able to speak and there are some things i' like to address jokes are funny Dorothy and Rebecca were arguing after the meeting I wouldn't call it yelling but I don't know why in Judith's telling it is
258Dorothy was yelling the two of them were here Rebecca approached her started talking to her after the meeting probably not the best idea they started arguing I asked them or told them time to leave they continued them time to leave again so why in the retelling by Judith is it Dorothy was yelling it shows the division it is through the lens that you look at life for um it's been pointed out in the paper that it's been contentious and everybody is doing what they can to make things better I will say for months and months I had asked board members to stop bringing divisive and inaccurate information in their memos I have done it privately and I have been ignored reputations are important one of these memos called me a liar essentially I said I
259said this at a meeting said it say something I mean I never said my reputation is important and when I saw the memo and I saw that it had a falsehood about me on it I asked for it to be removed and it was ignored and knowingly lied to the public about what I had said so yeah reputations are important Magnus says she wants to be heard respected and safe twice tonight she has touched me and um I've had asked in the past multiple times please don't touch me and it happened again tonight and I just want to know how many times I have to ask to not be touched that that can be followed and it is speak to feeling say please don't follow me to my car after my meetings so um I
260did want to take a moment to respond to the apology I'm not a board member I have no vote and often I have no personal opinion on matters yeah a lot of times I just sit there and have to go along no matter what my opinion is however as one of the central players in the events of 1212 and one of the top two administrators in the district I think it's important that I make a statement and set the tone at the top of this organization this apology document is too long it is also too late we have spent a month dealing with the Fallout of the events of 1212 and this response falls short of satisfactory especially since it has taken over a month to be received it does include the words I'm sorry
261however there is no recognition of the wrongs that evening directed at board member Bailey or myself the link the lengthy explanation included additional mediation goals dictated by the offender reflect that an inability to take responsibility for her own actions many of the past indiscretions alluded to in her documents are grossly inaccurate and I offer now to explain those directly to you Dr Magnus through mediation during regular business hours personally it is offensive to and shows the clear bias on the board and its thanks and praise of Judith and Rebecca I am grateful Rebecca ended the meeting however no actions of Rebecca or Jud to stop the verbal Onslaught directed at Dr holon it was only my action of recording magnus's behavior that stopped her Outburst magnus's response to quickly stop her behavior under recording shows
262that she was aware and in control of her actions when I stopped the recording thinking it was over her Menace uh her menacing approach and invasion of my space also makes clear she was aware of her actions when she felt safe that her inappro Behavior would have no accountability in the absence of a recording she also targeted me her apology to Judith and no one else the following day 1213 shows two things to me she was fully aware of her inappropriate actions and that her services to Judith not the board its administrators or staff I have dutifully fulfilled my responsibilities in this matter I I intervened when I saw my colleague being harassed see the administrator's code of conduct um policy 1200 I reported the harassment to the compliance officer on behalf of Dr Holden
263and myself see anti-harassment policy 1662 I do not wish to cause offense and I hope it is respected how difficult it is for me to risk my livelihood to address my bosses about their behavior and the expectation I have for improvement it is time to end the childish behavior and pettiness I've witnessed it is time for introspection stop pointing fingers back and forth at each other stop making excuses for your behavior Behavior because of others look back at your o of office you will faithfully and impartially discharge your duties as board members impartially I believe board member magnets violated our anti harassment policy and interactions with the superintendent following the 1212 meeting and with me her continued use of fighting language shows a remarkable lack of self-awareness we can Rumble any time come at me
264in December no one came at you and just today on social media hasht Throw Down The Gauntlet those are three public comments in a month about fighting board member Magnus I call on you to take full responsibility of your own actions that evening without explanation or past justifications of old perceived sights the remainder of the board I call on you to uphold your oath of office look at the facts of the evening yourself was your fellow board member out of line that evening did she break policy again what will you do to faithfully and impartially fulfill your duties tonight you're employees your community and most import importantly your children are watching what is the message you want to send Terry do you wish to comment I do not have prepared comments but I do want
265to say something briefly this is high uncomfortable for me I've listened to everyone um and I have to make decisions about what I say or don't say tonight because my staff are here they are watching at home I sure some students who will see this the community sees it and so I feel like um I could go go through a whole accounting um but I'm not going to do that because it's been my experience that no matter what I do I'm going to own the end result here and by that I mean if I don't accept an apology I'm just not a real woman it's like I I wonder why during this meeting the only person sitting at this table who was given the professional courtesy of being referred to as doctor was Amy Magnus
266now I'm pretty informal and that really doesn't make a difference to me but it's another and a line of things that I have to take and part of it my job and I will accept that but part of it is also about being a woman in a leadership position if I'm passionate um or excited um you know I'm aggressive I'm acting like a bully um if I raise my voice um all of these things that I don't have to tell you you all know this but this is now my reality and so I'm wondering how I accept an apology how I don't accept an apology because what message do I say to my children where we try to teach them to to rise above right take the high road but I I'm feeling like we're
267not there yet and so I read the apology that in my mind and I think maybe this is what matters because I I was personally impacted there's I'm sorry that I called you this female g this gender slur not I'm sorry that I said this to you as your boss you know I I'm reading an apology where my identity is described in a way that I don't ever describe myself that's for me to say who I am and how I describe myself but I feel like all the whole night it's it's I I you know it just this is a difficult position to put me in to be perfectly honest I I recognize that and my apologies uh Dr Holden the end I I written that in my comment I I will ask us at
268this point um it is difficult uh it is the policy that this deliberation has to happen publicly um and I appreciate everyone's patience tonight I would like to call for a vote it is very late and uh Amy has has spoken twice uh we've all spoken I think at at some length uh so and I a very very quick comment as I'm going to stain when the vote comes around so this is all up to you and I'm fine with that and I you know there's other ways of going about this and you know there's other venues to go about this and I understand that this is not enough I do um okay well so I I is that I just want you to know is that is that work in progress if people think
269that's a work in progress if they like you know is it is that there's a work in progress here it doesn't end you know it doesn't end here with this whatever you all vote okay I'm just just not thank you yes I appreciate what board member Magnus just said that this is not enough and I'm very much holding what Dr Holden shared with us here I'm concerned that not having a center tonight will normalize the tolerance of this kind of behavior I'm concerned that it will signal to the staff that really the threshold to meet to feel safe at work is very high and too high and not align with the values in this District I'm concerned that it furors the Outlook that the board majority protects their own no matter who gets hurt and
270so I will make a motion that we uphold our own policy because I know that you board president poter just you know reminded us that we needed to hold our own policy that those kind of conversations need to happen in public which I agree that's the policy then I'm asking for a motion of censure based on uh the board policy 33621 regarding threatening staff members okay so we have motion already on the table that we would have to vote on um and then we'd have a another policy and I'm with it with that I believe that has to be a um agenda item no no okay then uh let's take a vote on the the resolution to accept Amy magnus's apology um all call vote Bailey I'm sorry is there a resolution it's not not
271no okay no hling no Magnus say Potter no motion fails 4 to zero and I make the motion that we Cent board member magnet for briding our board policy 3362 .01 threatening behavior towards staff member and I I need a second is there a second I'll second um would you begin the deliberation I think um I can repeat what I just said but I know that it's very late and we've been here for almost 6 hours right uh I have given my rational that I'm concerned that not doing it in view of what is happening is normalizing a tolerance of threatening and verbal abuse and concerned that it fervers the Outlook that the board majority will protect their own no matter who gets hurt and I'm concerned about how it makes our staff teachers and
272employees and administrators feel unsafe and unrespected at work I agree with everything Dorothy just said um and I believe that I at this point this is the only course to take h i don't need to speak Magnus this wasn't introduced beforehand I just asked for due process um I I also uh want to make it very clear I hear what Dorothy is saying and it is absolutely important that we communicate to the staff that we take this issue very very seriously um however I also understand the severity of a centure and the the that due process needs to be followed in the sense that board member Magnus and the rest of the board members including myself uh and all involved needs some time to to come up with you know to deliberate on this and
273it is simply too late to give it the attention it deserves tonight and I if if people feel that that is putting it under the table again I ask your grace um because it truly is very very late um however I feel like this conversation has at least allowed this conversation you know this deliberation to take place yes okay the last time that we were in this situation back this spring um a majority of a board asked for an investigation to do due process and that's ended up costing $111,000 $1,500 to a district and then the majority of a board disregarded the finding of Investigation done to do due process we all know that this has been agonizing I was really hoping that we would not have to go down to this level tonight uh
274and I'm asking that we the board settle this promptly so that we don't have to drive this onto the next board meeting we have things that we need to do like legitimately we have to focus on the board facilities we have to focus now on the ltech we have things and this will not get any easier as we drive this on I'm just asking for resolution and actually I'm going to ask for for vote a a roll call on this vote on the motion of censure tonight I just want this to be done um you agree we have another option besides censure and that is you know again we can take a punitive approach you can take you can take a punitive approach or we can acknowledge that there's a lot of things going on
275here and that um mediation is called for so and when I went to talk to because when I went to talk to because we're all under the same policy so when I went to talk to the violations of policy that I wanted to put in a you know when I I'm working our assist to is it the first question I was asked is have you s mediation um I think we should I think there's been a lot that's been that our leadership team has you know been not behav very well about but in this instance I think uh Amy's Outburst was uh at another level and i would support a sensor and I support a vote for it I guess okay um there ahead [Music] Bailey yes okay yes impling yes Magnus Potter yes motion
276pass four to zero okay um we have more business folks uh we're going to get through it as quickly as possible uh board communication y Springs Development Corporation ysdc report uh the meeting was uh last Tuesday uh after board documents were reported uh the ysdc did submit letters to clarify uh their uh priorities and goals uh board member hempling posted those letters in other board ma matters uh so you can find them there and I will present a fuller report at the next meeting um village of Yellow Springs leaon report is there um there's I can't there's not really anything beyond though for me and I know Dorothy has something thank you maybe for clarity in future agenda can we have a different line for active Transportation just that it's clear to everybody so I
277have included here uh some presentations link and then some documents about our walk audit it really is I'm sorry it feels jarring to switch topics here so just um it really is Illuminating about how much traffic by foot on bike on Wheels and on in Motor Vehicles we have in town and if you are if you believe like me that being able to walk a 10wn read makes a community you should look it up I really uh advise that you do so I wanted to say that uh through the active Transportation I've organized a visit of a traffic Garden in Dayton Kentucky that happened in um on December 19th and um I came back with a lot of visuals here that I'm going to pass out pass around because I really would like for us
278to pursue this in our schools a traffic Garden is a painted citycape on a parking lot at a school that the students can use to practice Road Safety before they are on the road so it's ideal for the youngest of our uh students it creates skills for life it's usually great or better for elementary age so that would be for mes on ideally and then until the students feel comfortable that they can translate those skills onto the road with the supervision that they need um that project in Dayton Kentucky uh was a $225,000 project that they funded through funds that are not always available to us because it was through the Kentucky Governor Highway Association something something I'm sorry I'm losing the details of it just trust me uh what was interesting about it is
279that they made it specific to their Town Dayton Kentucky is just across the road from Cincinnati and so they Incorporated a painted railroad so that students could practice how to cross railroads that are still in practice this could be different for us we we have a US Route that is crossing Yellow Springs we have a bike bath we can adapt this model so that it fits the skills that uh our kids need in our town and also this would not be only available to our students but really to anybody because that would be an outdoor uh setup so it could be actually indoor but that is another discussion so all that to say that um I will take this further to keep nudging our superintendent who is very much on board with that okay and
280our our principle on this because I think could be a great addition and that could be the kind of preventative steps we can take so that all of the kids in the community know how to minimize the risk of being on foot and on Wheels on the road yeah I could talk more about it but we're all tired thank you okay thank you report was that's me that's it okay so it's a new year and it's a new general assembly and they've just been uh sworn into office on Monday last Monday they are going to schedule uh they are scheduled to begin introducing bills next week so right now there's not much going on at the legislature but I thought it would be a really good point to update you all about the school vouchers
281system that we have in Ohio it was passed a couple of years ago and what I mean by that is that um let me actually follow my note if you don't mind Matt Hoffman who is the new Ohio House speaker is also the architect of a universal School voucher program that has been implemented a couple of years ago this program has funneled nearly 1 billion with a B dollars to private schools while it only increased the enrollment in private schools by only 3,000 students students so in other words it has mostly benefited families whose children were already enrolled in private schools and those were wealthy families so there's $1 billion dollar of Ohio and tax dollars that have been funneled into private schools and this is important because this year the legislature is going to
282determine the budget for public education they do that every two years and so now we know that there is a billion dollar that has already been taken off the table to go to private school so we're going to have to fight with all the 612 public school districts for the rest of the money and that's not much so I ask our treasure how this voucher program has impacted our own finances and unfortunately we cannot determine that easily we would need to take a historical view on the trend of enrollment of IND District students into private schools and see how it was before the universal voucher program was implemented and how it changed after and frankly I was hesitant to divert J's time to look into this because I want to save his time and Terry's
283Time Dr Holden's time into our fa's project um lastly I want the board to be aware that uh our district is part of a lawsuit that is led by vouchers her Ohio uh that they file in 2022 and the lawsuit is suppos was supposed to start November and it's going to be starting sometime this year I think in the spring but I couldn't find a date I wanted all of you guys to know that it's not clear yet how we suffer from it we might but to determine that we need to make some change some choices or decisions among ourselves about what is a priority and but that we're still part of a lawsuit that is pushing back against the billion dollars that is being diverted into the hands of as pled right as PL
284yes thank you for specifying that and I'll will stop here for religiously but I'll take any questions you have yeah so just a comment on on some of that stuff so so when the universal vouchers happened and and as she mentioned uh you know it's not like suddenly a bunch of people started going to private schools that didn't go to private schools before only 3,000 students across the state actually changed um the real response to this was now there was money available for students already attending private school schools and and families have W and and what happened is private schools go oh we can get $3,000 for an elementary student let's raise our price $3,000 so it it didn't even really save any families money all it did is take public tax dollars and give
285them to um private educational institutions thank you I'm going to push this on because it's very late other board my items I think this is where where sorry can I be recognized yes I'm getting pretty Punchy too I think this is where we talk about preparing the next agenda would that be right yeah I want to make it very clear that this is not where we would deliberate on any item issue or propos a motion that would mean that we would put that thing on the next agenda to deliberate then so I know that you've mentioned that you wanted to make a uh you wanted to make a section of an next agend about the goals of a board and I'm adding to that can we also talk about a new protocol of uh a
286new I don't know if I'm saying this name right protocol or protocol protocol sometimes my inflection is off when I get tired um and so I'm I'm asking that for so that we get the chance to talk about come on Rules of Engagement how do we go about contacting the lawyer how do we go about asking admin's time involvement on some topics I I think that it's time for us to really set those one we might not like the last set that was being used by previous boards but how can we revise it and make it better so that we all can understand the Rules of Engagement here I'm also going to ask for something that is not an item on the agenda but I'm going to ask can we use a visual clock of
287three minutes that we can put on there during board during comments so that we can see when the 3 minutes come off and everybody can see that there know put it on there I think I got to look into getting like the shop or but their website that do that too that we can cool and it a countdown so okay okay I'm just asking that and then if we hold ourselves to 10 minutes then we might also need one for ourselves and that was it thank you yeah thanks um I to add to that I don't know how it will be set up uh but it in the MS gym but if we have tables here is there any kind of curtain apron that we can put in front of these tables so they don't
288see they don't see my fidgeting feet um that's reest the answer can be yes I'll feel a little comfortable because in this position my feet are going everywhere and that thing shows everything so okay um any other items okay uh do I have any motion to adour I move that we I second all those in favor say I iOS okay good night everybody