CorpusRecord 68745

Corvallis School Board Meeting (January 9th, 2025)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Corvallis School District
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Benton County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,630 words · about 93 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay good evening feedback on Josh knows what he's up to okay I think good Oh I thought it was a speaker back there okay okay I think we're good now yes we had some feedback sorry about that um good evening everyone um the January 9th 20 25 meeting of the corval school board is called to order at 6:30 p.m. in the interest of public health and safety for all community members especially for imuno compromised individuals and their families the corval school board will continue to offer a virtual option for board member and District Personnel participation additionally public comment is available at some meetings both in person and virtually information about providing public comment is available on the Corvalis School School District website the board packet our board agenda and packet as well

002as the link to the district YouTube channel are available on the Schoolboard page on the district website public meetings are live streamed on the district's YouTube channel and a recording is posted to the same channel typically the day after the meeting tonight we have all board members and attendance and um the first um item on the agenda is board member reports and before we did that I want to say welcome back every for winter break and it's good to see everyone and um hope it has been a smooth week for everyone um so anybody have any reports do you have Samy uh one report I have is the library invited us to that library is librarian CV invited us to join and I uh was really honored to uh shadow the library and take a

003tour at the work and understand the work that they do uh and also understand the workload and and the impact that uh libraries have on our students as a a sanctuary and place for them to learn and grow and uh find their passions and I was assigned some volunteering Duty including uh uh changing the setup from one monthly uh setup to another so they celebrate different cultural um months uh for example exle in December I believe or nove November it was the Native American and there was a setup for books then they volunteered me to take take out uh about 60 books for the one of my favorite books the pilgrim The Pilgrimage by the pilgrim the pilgrim by Paulo Quello and it was really cool to take a part of that experience and understand

004the impacts that our libraries do and really informs uh my understanding of uh the important budgetary decisions we make thanks Sammy anybody else want you to i' just like to thank the bridges program for inviting us to their holiday party and I saw um shaa and Chris there and got to see some really beautiful art and they had a excellent spread of snack so thank you so much for the invitation it was a really fun party yeah thank you for the invitation I wish I could have been there too um go ahead Chris yeah two things I know that there was a lot of comments after our last meeting with the elementary principles and their presentations um and I but I just wanted to say it again early in our meeting um today that I

005just so appreciated listening to their plans and just feel that we have such a dynamic group of Elementary principles who are very knowledgeable and dedicated to making you know it right for all kids so I just wanted to compliment that and then um also I just wanted to congratulate Dr Whitebear and her um the election for our regional osba person and just appreciate you doing all that work I feel like you're one of those people that walks the talk like you say you know things need to be done but you're in the front making it happen I just really appreciate that thanks Chris that was um that was part of my report too thank you um um for segueing into that oh do you have one too yeah okay good thank you Judah you reminded

006me of the the Bridget celebration so just wanted to also second my thanks to Bridges staff for inviting us as well as the students and the families who are there too for sharing their artwork sharing food we had a student Le Tour which was really wonderful to see how the space was being used in such a thoughtful and trauma-informed way to really meet students needs and Family's needs so appreciated being there and invited into that space okay go ah TR ER teres uh right before the break I had an opportunity to meet with um some of the math instructors uh at lonus Pauling and um it was really educational for me to see how they're approaching instruction um around um the varying levels of abilities that students have in classes and so I was just

007really encouraged that there's just a lot of thoughtfulness in the planning and um if you are curious about how our Math teachers are approaching math uh I I can't can't promise you that they're going to have time to email you back right away but I do think that they like to get questions and they like an opportunity to explain um the methods that they are using so reach out I found it really insightful and um it was I have to say it was fun to be in an algebra class again so okay um so I was able to go to Delta last night um with Bernie and um and spent some time in that with that group and really great conversations and I'm looking forward to the work that's coming out of um Delta um

008coming up with conversations with the community and uh as Chris has mentioned I was um elected as the region 10 ly Benson Lincoln representative on the Oregon School Board Association and so um I'm looking forward to serving the community in that capacity and also making connections across the counties with different um districts and the ESD board and Community College boards as well and some um pretty excited about that and um I was also elected as the um president of the um member of color caucus for osba as well and so looking forward to moving that work forward especially with the legislative um long session ahead and some of the work we're looking forward to with that um so that's it for board member um reports and the next one is the organ School Board Association

009and National School boards Association updates and Sammy thank you uh chair uh so as a reminder uh these are frequen updates that I shared uh throughout the uh last couple of years uh and uh by December 31st I concluded my service uh as the president of Oregon School Board Association uh and in the reports that I shared with you I amended also the reports I shared with the board uh reflecting on the year uh usually the osba board meets four times and I believe they met we met around 17 times or something like that uh huge huge uh movement that we have done together and I want to thank you uh especially as my colleagues and the community for their support that made this progress possible uh including uh great news that we have uh

010heard by the end of the election uh the passage of the resolution that supported uh the increase of the dues uh in a way that catches up with inflation and with the needs uh for 25 years we have not done that and I shared the schedule here in this packet as well as a reminder uh for the good work that we do uh this will definitely ensure that the service and help that I got and we got and we continue to get from osba is going to be accessible and available uh for years to come and hopefully in perpetuity with this resolution keeping after 15% increase for the next 5 years uh keeping up after that with the CPI uh definitely those uh Investments are going to help us uh um advocate for the kids

011uh in addition to the report of osba I shared with the national uh Schoolboard Association they were on break but I will take a moment here to highlight an act that has passed the house and now is going to the Senate and we may talk about it briefly maybe in the comments uh at the end of this meeting uh but I want to bring to your attention the Laken Riley act uh it was passed but unfortunately in my opinion and with bipartisan support uh from the house it will uh definitely be a concern for uh our students and Families who are undocumented uh and probably in my opinion will have an impact on Oregon Sanctuary uh status if this uh passes so more on that to come uh we're trying to assess what is the

012impact and the viability of advocating on the Senate side to bring awareness to it um on a positive uh note I want to transition to really acknowledge uh the news that was just shared uh Dr lohu Whitebear uh being elected to Oregon School Board Association and the Len Benton Lincoln representative uh brings huge value and we voted uh for her to represent us and the majority of the region agreed with that I just want to highlight how much uh lii have shared uh her values and walk the walk and uh I'm not exaggerating by saying within the last couple of months only while she decided to run the impact of that and the way that she uh communicated with bards and show showed up to boards activated our region uh districts and their Boards of

013Education to be more involved than I ever seen since I joined this board in 2017 uh so really congratulation for uh this region uh uh our our chair's election and also I want to share I talked with uh the chair that this report now will be a mutual work between me and the chair so she can share OSB updates and I'll share that as the immediate past president and also add the national updates uh so with that's happy to answer any questions but truly truly I want to say thank you for uh the progress that you have contributed to that you see in the reports here any questions for Sammy okay thanks Sammy um next on the agenda is the superintendent report so I'm going hand over to Ryan sounds good so just a couple

014things to highlight the first one is that January Schoolboard recog nition month um we will recognize you um in with more time on the agenda at our next meeting but just to make sure that folks know that this month as a whole is a month when we recognize the work of our school board who are dedicated volunteers who give hours and hours of their time to the benefits of our students and to our staff and our schools so thank you for all you do um and we'll just en hold that for our next meeting how's that all right uh next thing is Hands Across caralis so on January 30th um is our annual Hands Across caralis breakfast I'm put on by the caralis public schools foundation so um if you haven't um been able to

015if you haven't received a invitation please let me know we want to make sure that you're able to be there if you're um if it works within your schedule it's the 30th 7:30 to 8:30 in the morning and again the foundation as you are well aware does a ton to support what happens in our schools from educational access to learning enrichment and graduation rates and many things within those uh three areas um and it's a great time to come together I think at this point there's close around 300 folks that will be joining us that morning so it's a great event and I hope you're able to join us um we are close to um putting out a new version of our website that will happen at the end of January that was part of

016the communications audit that was um completed last year by Kelly um and a consultant who came to get feedback and we had feedback from staff family community about our website and how to make sure that the information there is um up to-date easy to access and provides you the information that you need so pay attention to that you don't it will still be on the same uh URL so you don't have to make any changes but just um look forward to a new website um right now just so you know we are um in the process of doing a survey with staff around the 26 27 calendar which feels like a long time away but it's really not um I promise you that um one of the reasons why we're getting that feedback is because

017of now that we um give um official recognition of juneth and we have uh Labor Day those two holidays um have really bookended our school year and traditionally in this community we've stayed away from starting before Labor day but because of where juneth Falls there are times when kids may come back to school for a day or two days and so we're trying to get some feedback from folks where we have to look at that a little bit differently so just so you know um that's something we're currently doing a survey with staff um two more things one is that um as a partnership um Cal School District was U partner in receiving the black Student Success Grant which was a a grant from the Oregon Department of Education uh Kalia kit um at Lis

018Pauling has been involved in that work along with um Jason Dorset Kelsey um Nava Cales from Al and Joanne Miller who helped to write that Grant and so it is a four-year Grant and we will have resources to continue to support um our black and African-American students um and their successes here in CSD and also supporting family community so I'll be sure to share more information about that marcianne and I are meeting with some principles next week to talk about the best way to utilize those funds here in caralis um and then finally Osborne just so you know an update on Osborne um Aqua Aquatic Center um we have received more information back from our engineers and at this point one of the goals is looking at is there a way we can open up

019the outdoor pool um as we continue to figure out what are the next steps on the interior so just have that in mind as sort of one of those next steps as we move to more access to to the water and to the pools for our students so those are my updates and I'd be happy to answer any questions any questions for Ryan from the board yeah R um I do have one question um how how are things going with fouth with the pool share um the Clemens pool is busy um they have um allowed us to use it for um our CHS swim team um as you know the CHS CV rivalry we've moved to the Lebanon pool though just because it has more space around the pool um some of the folks who've

020used our pool for parks and wreck are using the pool over there at Clemens as well so um we are making a contribution um financially so that our um Team can play um participate there and practice there but as a whole it's been a really important partnership between our two communities and Susan holiday the superintendent there initially reached out to me and said hey I know you're looking for space there's probably a way we can help to support you and so um again it's appreciation to our neighboring Community for stepping up and helping us to make that happen yeah thanks Ryan that's good here and um just want to say thank you to fouth too for yeah for letting us um practice there the students um the next item on the agenda is public comment

021and I understand there's um no comment cards have been submitted so we're going to um not have public comment at this time um the next item on the agenda is new standards the ploma requirements and upcoming adoptions update that's Amy Kim and Nikki and you have a slide presentation hello yeah I think we're working we're just going to start with introductions um because I know we have uh one new board me member that may not know all of us and so I'm Nikki McFarland I'm the high school coordinator my name is Amy Leon Elementary coordinator and I'm Kim Johnson the middle school coordinator and bridges principal all right Kim you can move to the first slide um um so what we came to talk to you about tonight you'll hear lots about curriculum instruction and

022um implementation of curriculum and we wanted to start with this slide that gives you a little bit of a picture of what's to come and um the two years that are not on there above social sciences are um health and science and I think one of the things that we want you to take away from this is this understanding that every year as we're talking about curriculum we're really talking about three different things that the state is doing revisions of standards in one content area we're doing we're working on implementation of and so it's just multia we're working on implementation of and so it's just multifaceted and we just wanted you to have that understanding um last year we came to you to talk about uh science curriculum and so that was that's not on

023there but that was a three-year cycle and then this year we're like in the district implementation we'll work on um for fall of 25 health and so we'll we'll talk about those a little bit more but this is really just kind of a a picture of how things are what's what's to come I'll just go on uh our next slide is just talking about some of the curriculums and adoptions that we're working on and so currently this year we're working on our health um adoption and looking at what is available there in the different levels um and as uh Amy was saying every year we're not just focusing on the curriculum we're adopting right we're also focusing on what is the next one that's coming down the road with the standards that are being adjusted

024and what is the one that we are in our second year of implementation in right so everything is always at a different level and we're focusing on all of those pieces uh as an example at the end of this month when middle school has their two PD days one of those days we're going to be spending a good deal of time in those content areas and having the people be able to use time to focus on their level of implementation whether like Ela is in their second year science is in their first year health is still working on an adoption and yeah there we go got to turn it on there we go so one of the things that I what that Ryan and I talked about um when we initially planned to do this

025presentation was the upcoming adoption of or not adoption but the implementation of the new integrated social science standards um it's hard to believe that when we adopted new social science material seven years ago I was in my bedroom um and we were all at home and so here it is again it feels like really recent and yet it must have been a while ago so Oregon has had new integrated social science standards but they are not required for implementation until fall and so that is the cycle that both Kim and Amy were talking about is like we get new standards so um the the standards are like there for teacher review now next year we'll get uh materials from the state that we can look at and then the following year we'll be implementing um

026the social science standards are integrated so there have been some law laws um and I'll go over those in the next slide but they integrate the Holocaust and genocide standards they integrate tribal history shared history standards they also integrate the new um at high school Civics graduation requirement and there are seal components uh related to things like identity I'll go to the next slide I think what's and that that's still me I was like maybe that's Kim I know we talked about it um so these pieces of legisl ation um really are impacting the ethnic study standards what's different about each of these is that the tribal history shared history um legislation was really about curriculum and the state providing curriculum um and th the curriculum um is for multiple subjects so you can see

027those in the slides language arts Health PE math science and social science and then in 20 21 Senate Bill 664 um for Holocaust and other genocides that was really about Concepts that teachers should be teaching these big Concepts around um the Holocaust and other genocides and then now in 2026 with um house bills 2845 and 2023 that is the actual standards and those standards bring in the the concepts and not necessarily the curriculum but the relevant standards into the social science integrated standards so I just want to that was part of what I wanted to talk about is like they're different and they're coming together but they started kind of with different intentions curriculum Concepts and then standards and so um we're going to talk about what's happening at each of our Lev levels so

028at high school right now we will be doing our adoption next year so usually the OD in October will put out a list of approved materials from the state so what what I'm doing with high school social studies teachers is I have all of the standards for high school and they have reviewed those standards and said I teach that in this course and these are the related lessons and what that allows us to do is identify the gaps what are the things that we're not we don't feel like we have great um lessons for or aren't covered in our um pathway through the social science courses because that's going to help us to have a direction and kind of some look fors in the materials that will um come to us from the state next

029year and then Amy and Kim are going to talk about what's happening at their levels at the middle school level it's really easy to say because we're doing the same thing that they're doing at the high school we have the same alignment with the standards we're looking for those gaps so that when we go to look at the materials during that adoption period we know we know what we need to fill those and at Elementary uh similar but a little bit different just because of the way elementary works we are also later this spring we'll looking at our lessons for racial Equity what we've been teaching from the tribal history lessons oural curriculum and our language arts materials to see where there's alignment where there is an alignment and then we'll look for ways and

030materials and needs after we know where kind of where we are with all of this then I'm going to talk about the next slide so in addition to new standards um legisl has High School uh being a pretty busy place for change so we also have A5 Civics course requirement for the class of 2026 and a 0. five higher education and career path skills credit ALS uh for the class of 2027 and a personal financial education credit for the class of 2027 so all of these come out of um our legislature um and we are in process of making plans for each of these so we currently have government government is our in our board policy as a requirement and so I'm working with the OD and the teachers on looking at the Civic standards

031and making sure our courses are aligned to those new standards and talking about changing the course name to Civics um so that conversation is is happening this week uh the higher education and career path skills credit is a credit that students will earn through their advisor class at both of our comprehensive high schools that is all about exploring your uh yourself identifying what your interests are your um aptitudes and then looking at different careers in and colleges and then we have the new personal financial education credit we actually have a teacher from our district Anna Zachariah that was on the standards committee and so she's already teaching she's been teaching Financial algebra and so it was nice for her to be there and see where her standards showed up um in those new standards that

032she worked on with the committee and then at CV we've been off offering a personal finance class and so so um the both the teachers in both of those courses are looking at the standards and redesigning their their courses around those standards and at CHS they'll be adding um an additional personal finance class the nice thing about that both of these credits is that they can be taught by a teacher with any credential um and they can fall into a variety of subjects so first when personal financial education came out folks thought it could only be taught by social studies teachers but it can be taught by by many teachers um it can even be taught in CTE business programs so the the I think this is the last slide or second to last slide

033yeah so this year and Beyond these are all the things that are happening so we are implementing and adopting um and getting ready for what's coming next so this year we're um implementing the new standards in the adviser classes at high school we are in the implementing the new science materials that we had as well as the new reading materials that we had and focusing on some science of reading PD and we are implementing science in the middle school and people are super excited about it the style that we have adopted has already been aligned I mean style looked ahead did their alignment with the Oregon standards as well as the ethnic studies standards and so those are already in there so as they're teaching them they're already built and then as we've shared we're

034working on the K12 Health adoption so that will be coming to you later this spring and then um we postponed the science adoption at the high school but environmental science is the area that is needed right away because that science is changing more than others it's also related to our board goals uh around sustainability so we will be bringing that adoption to you as well and then next school year we'll have a new course at CHS we'll have new health materials in place and we'll be working on the social science adoption to prepare for the implementation of the new standards we spoke about in the following school year I think there's one more slide and then we'll have questions I know we we've gone over a lot of information um one of the things is

035you know I said seven years ago I I did an adoption from my bedroom um for the social science materials uh one of the things that we're implementing districtwide as like a a common practice as rounding where we are asking folks questions about how things are going like what's going well um what are some challenges what barriers are there what can we do as Leaders to support this work so I've been rounding with teachers in uh language arts mathematics World languages I'm thinking what our most recent adoptions are and there's one more um and asking them those questions so that every year our adoption process and most importantly our implementation processes go better and so I wanted to include this slide in the slideshow because I think it shows what we are learning as Leaders

036at the district level about how to continually improve our work ultimately so that our students are experiencing the the type of learning that they should be experiencing in every classroom so um you can read it I don't feel like I need to read all of those all of those things but most importantly I think is just having that open communication is super important for staff and knowing like what are what are the things that are always actions and then what are the thing what are the where are the places where they have that that teacher freedom and the ability to use their personal interest and craft to make their classrooms really Dynamic do you have any questions I'm sure folk have questions who has questions I oh yes go ahead Ryan um Amy can you

037talk a little bit more about the science of reading and I don't I don't think you have to give us the you know the broad um version of that but just a little bit more because it's something that we hear a lot about and just and I know that there's been work that's been happening and professional development that's gone into it so just like a uh I guess an elevator pitch on that sure so I came to you last spring when was that to to get approval for all big chunk of money that we got and it was pretty fantastic and so we took that and what we have done is what I had laid out for you we purchased a new um writing program that was more up to- dat and in alignment with

038science of reading we purchased new reading materials at Lincoln and Garfield for our dual ersion schools and then we also spent some money on coaching and we have a few newer positions that are really helping teachers with the implementation of being of the curriculum and we the focus the materials are updated and have a pretty intentional way that you are to teach reading at K2 and that has not always been what we've been up to in our classrooms and so really being side by side with teachers um just yesterday all day all the second grade teachers at one of the schools were planning all morning and practicing and then the afternoon the kindergarten teachers were so with that Grant we have funds set aside that we're doing professional development around that in addition to that

039we also opened up um a course that is just about science of reading and I offered it to every K2 teacher and every principal and all the coaches and people that were relevant and it's a pretty intensive course it's like 56 hours of work and so offering we paid for it and then they get a stip in upon completion of it and then because in our district we have shaa S who's um works at the state level in this um in the area of Science of reading and is pretty passionate about it she is facilitating the cohorts of teachers that are going through that so we come together with those teachers um pretty regularly at least three or four times as they're going through that work um and I don't know I'm sure there's more

040I'll think of but I I I know that like at least that's a a gist of it we've had 45 teachers take that in the summer and right now 38 teachers are participating so it's I have that is the biggest PD that I've ever had teachers say yes to in the district and actually want to come so it's super exciting 70 70ish teachers doing over 50 hours of PD around the science of reading is pretty pretty phenomenal yeah I when shanz and I came up with the plan I was like let's just do a pilot in the summer so we can see how it goes because Eastern or is partnering with us on this and we're like yeah maybe we'll get like five teachers and I kept texting her I'm up to 20 now it's

04135 now it's 45 it's not much of a pilot but it's been great and then um in the future we will have our 21st century Grant um Pages we'll have a presentation about what's happening in our after school program and reading as well perfect okay thanks um questions okay go ahead Chris and then Sammy then I'll come back on the um all that you just presented is exactly why we need your positions at the district office because that is so much work and it's obvious that there's a lot around a lot it than you can even describe tonight so I appreciate that and then also um I Heard and I'm sure my other board members heard during the elementary night um over and over again the support that they were getting from um from district

042office that was really really helpful to their reading programs in their school so I think that's also great yeah also a comment B feel free to comment on my comment I here's the takeaways I have uh three takeaways that I can share with the community and looking at the slides hearing what we heard today our teachers are all in to make sure our students have better and more robust reading skills than we have done before and when they get to read they can do arithmetic they and connect with the world and they get to graduate and that gets me to the second takeaway that slide you added with more graduation requirements just gives me simple arithmetic which is our students today need to do more to prove that they can graduate and be functioning in

043the world so we are not dropping the bar we're raising the bar can I add to that one comment because I think we are raising it and we're giving them what they're asking for like students are saying I graduate not ready for my next steps right financially like how do I open a bank account what does it mean to take out a loan like if I go to college how much money am I actually going to pay for that if I take out loans for that the stuff that that that has been added I think is valuable and it is more absolutely and it's way more valuable than how fast you can uh fill a bubble after bubble and on a test I haven't done that for a very long time and I'm I'm okay

044but the things that you just mentioned I had to learn them as an adult and really appreciate that attention not only from the states but also from you here making sure we do it right and doing it right is the third item which I heard across the states people say when you add more requirements and curricular standards we have the Dilemma of limited resource which is time and you just showed us how you're doing this in a very mindful way you're not adding layers of courses over what we have you're mindfully looking into what are we teaching now is it matching those standards and how can we weave the new learnings that we need to to and add into what we're already doing so we're not duplicating the work for our students and that's actually

045really brilliant way that you're proactive and to your last point there uh when we have the time to do the work mindfully and we collaborate we can do it more effectively and I think that's the third one that's really uh a great aha moment for me which is when we have to add more uh requirements uh for what students need to learn really critical stuff about their culture and emotional compens and awareness and development all of these things are important for their success and when you have limited time in this classroom and in the school the only way to do it effectively is to look at our current curriculum and integrate what we are doing into it and add what we need to add and show to the state that we're already doing what we're

046already doing so these are the three takeaways feel free to comment if you agree or there's anything you want to add to it thank you um anybody on the side yet or okay sha go ahead thank you so much for the tremendous amount of work that you put into this and as Sammy was mentioning in streamlining there's so much that goes into as you said review adoption implementation and having this rolling cycle where this is continually happening on multiple fronts at all times is a tremendous amount of work to be managing juggling and to be taking on a lot lot of that work even before it comes to teachers in classrooms who then are taking on a tremendous amount of work themselves and then really thoughtfully implementing integrating into what they do bringing in what's

047what's new and helpful and expands their what they are able to do as well as makes shifts and changes and I can't help thinking about just the tremendous load this is not only on you but then on the teachers as well and so just want to express my gratitude for them for this continued work to make sure that the education that they are bringing to students is Cent is up to-date is really meaningful in so many ways and I'm getting to a question also in all of that so one of the things I was thinking about as I was just reflecting on this is that especially for subject specific Educators it sounds like they get a little bit of a chance to breathe in between some of these ruling adoptions where maybe something comes in

048language arts wise at the High School level doing a lot of that work up front in those that first year of implementation and then actually having a chance to try it out before the next wave comes when I think about and I don't want to negate how much work that is that's a tremendous amount of work thinking down to say Elementary School teachers k35 who every single year are integrating a brand new piece into what they're already doing in this very integrated way um seems like there isn't a chance to just pause and breathe and to really lean into a curriculum see how it's working and make adjustments before the next adjustments are being made what needs are you seeing there in terms of or or how are teachers being supported in that what other

049needs are coming out are there other ways that support can be offered there it is super tricky like you said and I think what I have noticed in working with the teachers so let's say this last round where reading isn't on here and yet we had to do reading because that was the state law so I think part of what's in here there's it's in small notes somewhere this can be changed at any time right like and it did and so I think the more voice that I have with teachers the more I'm in classrooms the more principles are in classrooms the more guided conversations we have and the deeper understanding of the why is super helpful for us to move into something we're also not we haven't made sometimes we're just reop the newer

050addition of what we already have and so it doesn't feel as drastically different as it could I think the other thing we've worked on in the last little bit of time is the similarities between our curriculum so it feels they it doesn't feel like such a hard shift when you go from language arts to math because it's the same tone it's the same kind of structure you have in your classroom which also helps and it is tricky I mean I think that there's just and just owning that and that we're going to do the best we can which means that sometimes we have to continually change and I think prep time for teachers is really important and it's a critical part of our of the work that we need to make sure that they have

051that time so those are just some some thoughts we're we're we're just about out of time for this item but we're also ahead and so can we add like 10 minutes just in case there's more questions and if we get done before the 10 minutes that's okay too didn't want to have to do that again if we don't need to any other questions comments okay I had some too so that's why I added more time um but I wasn't meant to make sure other people did too um I just wanted to clarify on the um with environmental science with that it's also it's not just sustainability it's also literacy so I just want to make sure like for community members that that's not getting missed too because that was a big Chang that in a

052big part too which I would think would be under environmental science but yeah it it is and um what I haven't shared yet with the board I came last year and said we're going to postpone the science adoption when the teachers reviewed the new materials they said these look the same as what we already have um except in the area of environmental science so you know that's why we we will be we spending um some funding to purchase new materials for environmental science the other thing I I do want to share since we're here it's related to to your question I think is that we um on Earth Day I think that's what we decided we're going to be surveying our students about sustainability and Eco literacy um and and because we don't have any

053Baseline data from our students um so we were talking about that goal and how do we measure how we're doing and then we thought well don't have any any data so I worked with um principles on developing a survey and then took it to students to get feedback and then back to leadership and now we have it kind of ready to go and we thought that would be a good time we're we are serving serving our kids and staff about a lot of things right Ryan mentioned the calendar um we're also asking students about school lunches right now so um they like to do Focus surveys they told us and they want them spread out okay that's um that sounds great that'd be interesting to see what we know too with the survey a separate

054one maybe as the board um because I not everybody knows the difference too between the sustainability and ecoliteracy and so um the other one was is there support from the state is there very much support from the state on a lot of there's a lot of changes that you just talked about and I'm kind of wondering where that's at because yeah or is it the the usual there's not very much support and I mean I mean at least at high school there's changes there's not funding that comes along with those changes and there's Investments required by every District right every time we purchase materials um there are those Investments the the support from the state is like providing you know really the guidance um and most of that's very technical about like this is the

055name of the course and this is the course code and this is the requirement and here's where you have leeway um but it doesn't go much beyond that okay that what the m question was around training like how you mentioned a little bit of training um but how as there what does training look like because it's a lot of changes in the shifts especially with the standards for social studies shifted so much right and all of the three of those different bills all got wrapped into they changed it like it feels like I don't know how many times to change just the standards to just collapse everything in instead of um even though as you pointed out the tribal history shared histories is in different areas um it probably could be argued that some of

056those other places could be outside of social science but I know that they're packaged within that so is your is your question does the state help to provide training or what is the training that we're providing does the training feel adequate at this point or is there like a need for additional trainings like and I know that they I know just from my involvement with American Indian and Alaska native committee that they have like right now they're having monthly or twice a month it's either once or twice a month for tribal history shared histories but I don't know if that there's anything like that on the other standards I I haven't seen anything besides that that PD that's available for tribal history shared history I haven't seen it elsewhere and that's the one that has

057like you said because that one was curriculum Focus too yeah okay all right thanks I was just curious about that and then with the science reading because we get asked a lot about well it's a big obviously a big um area that a lot of districts need Improvement on with reading um do you have I know you don't have a magic um future scene device of some kind um I don't even think AI could predict it but what is your expected like kind of when we might see some could potentially see some shifts in elementary level reading um I would say you've probably already if you're and as as we last year and into this year Rolling it out and pushing pretty hard and changing some assessment systems and monitoring data even more closely we're

058already seeing some growth more higher than expected so we'll have some of that and you probably saw some of that with the elementary when they shared a little bit of that um I think what's on the horizon that's coming next is this grant was really k23 you could use not really fourth or fth you had to minimum use like 10% or less I am anticipating seeing money coming for 4th through 8 or 4th through 12th as like an um as we continue to push this and I would say the other thing that I'm seeing on the horizon is the potential for all to get your license to teach you would have to have taken a science of reading course so those are two things that I'm seeing okay cool thank you all righty any but

059last call for questions on this one okay thanks you all for all your work you're doing and next on the agenda is the ly Benton Lincoln education Service District also known as the lbl estd um to affirm the 2527 local service plan and this is has you for that Ryan yeah I was just going to give a little bit of information um some of you are um newer board members and just a little bit about the concept of the estd and how that plays out so each district across our state is supported by an estd um and an estd is primarily there to provide resources and support that smaller districts couldn't um acquire on their own so some really good examples of that are things like physical therapy and occupational therapy um augmentative communication some

060services that if you were a district um uh I'll see as a great example because they are in our 12 districts in our ESD couldn't necessarily hire a full FTE or a position to serve and support their students and so it's a collective where um all 12 districts come together in Lyn Benton and Lincoln counties and access services to our estd um the local service plan is a 2-year plan and it is designed um in our ESD the way that it's set up is that there is um tier one services and then there are also tier 2 Services tier one services are services that we've all collectively agreed that all districts will have access to and so for a service to be a tier one service it takes um 2third vote of the 12 superintendant

061and those superintendents need to represent at least 50% of the students in our region um in order for some in a tier one service once all of the tier one services are provided and paid for everything left is considered tier two and tier two is based on the number of soones you have in your District based on the dollars that are left and that allows individual districts to spend those resources on things that the um either a the ESD can provide more of them so as an example we use some of our tier 2 services for school psychologist time because what we receive in tier one is not enough to complete the evaluations for our students so we pay for additional um tier two use tier2 dollars to pay for school psychologist there are other

062services that we also pay for um through tier two that are services that the ESD cannot provide and so in those cases we can use those dollars and um use them in different ways so an example of that is that we have health Navigators that we are paying towards and Benton County are paying towards so it's a 50/50 match but we're using tier two doll the ESD doesn't have that service so we're able to use those funds rather than our general funds that our district gets from the state these are dollars we take from the estd and we use them for those sorts of services so that's the way that the um structure of the estd is set up historically I have been um on the side of a smaller District having quite a while

063and now in caralis as the second largest in the 12 districts and what I have tended to do as I've made votes has been around services to our smaller um school districts because I feel a responsibility to make sure that the smaller districts who couldn't get those services on their own have the services they need so um just as you kind of know about me and my philosophy in these these EST meetings and making these decisions in terms of the local service plan that has been the way that I have um really supported over over my um tenure here in carala so um we the the service plan is in front of you it's a 2-year plan we're asking for you to um make a motion to approve it it um it has been something

064that we've reviewed at our ESD superintendent meetings over the last 3 months so I feel like people have had a chance to give input some of the things that used to be in tier one are not in tier one any longer because we're not utilizing them and it wasn't a good use of our funds so we've made some adjustments and as a whole I feel like it's a pretty um pretty strong plan to bring forward to you so any questions I'd be happy to answer thanks for questions questions comments go ahead Bernie then Sammy just uh uh for clarification uh the smaller school districts their uh student populations weighted heavier in terms of uh resources or or is it is that what I'm understanding or I'm Miss on the so on the tier one it's

065about scalability so they get a lower rate typically cuz we're all going in for all the students across across our region so they have some cost savings there but then when we get to tier two it's really based on number of students and so we have equal funds um based on the size of our school districts yeah so it's it's it's it's a combo yeah Ryan could you highlight for the Early Childhood special evaluation education evaluation um it's really important and critical and uh I appreciate that as here uh as tier one service I believe continues to be tier one service is it enough or do we need more need to cover the the evaluation needs so um when I get to the legislative Concepts that um kosa is bringing forward one of them is

066round funding for Early Childhood special education because that's an area that has not historically kept up with the costs associated with it and ESD are responsible for providing those Services across our state yeah so it it has not kept up thank you other folk I was going to say something similar but I'll save it because when I was going around um visiting the different boards in our region yeah during um to speak on like part of why I was running for our regional representative the special education one came up um a lot and hearing how high the numbers are in some of the districts at 1921 in our region and so I'll say the rest of the comments around that so I'm looking forward to hearing what you're saying on that but that was one

067of my comments was just that I appreciate that you're thinking about um those districts too that definitely wouldn't have support even though we still need support too it's it makes it tough when but this is a shared resource and so I would hope that the community understands like the importance of when we do have that shared resource that we're making sure that um more students are served across the whole region too yeah and you know many states have similar models California it's the county school districts that provide a similar service to what our esds do so there's different ways that different states go about it but generally it's that um Regional um collaboration and utilization of resources to really have an impact on the whole whole area and again we have 12 um dist school

068districts in our ESD it's Lyn all school districts in Lyn bent in Lincoln counties do you have another do you have another comment Sammy just W to uh do a aiel here uh for the budget Committee of the Lin Benton Lincoln it have we need to have two members from Corvalis uh right now we have one vacance and have to be a board member so uh if anybody's interested in being on the budget committee for the ESD uh bring your name forward and if there's two happy step down from that position as well but it's really important role uh to really advocate for this uh work and I believe their meetings are similar to our meetings in in May and it's like 20 minutes pretty easy I think they meet once and they meet only

069once Yes And to clarify you said it needs to be a board member right I believe so right Ryan um I don't know that that's the case cuz Sarah is able to continue um to fill fulfill her term and has decided to do so oh I do not know that yeah okay okay so that's good for the community to know then yes yes there's other community members um okay yes if anybody's interested to happy to sorry you don't have to yeah we don't have to yeah you do not have to be so if there's anybody in the community sty Sam saying that he will step down for somebody to serve yes yes and that's great experience for somebody in the ESD does some really important work so with that being said does anyone wish to

070make a motion chair good I move to approve the L Len Benton Lincoln ESD 2025 2027 local service plan second I'll second it's been moved by Sammy and seconded by Shauna um to approve the Len Benton Lincoln education server District 2025 to 20 local service plan is there any further discussion okay it has been moved by Sammy and seconded by shaa to approve the ly Benton Lincoln education Service District 2025 to 2027 local service plan um Bernie I Sammy I Chris I Shauna I theres I Judah I and iot I motion passes unanimously um and then the next um item on the agenda is the osba and Koso related legislative conversation and debrief and this is Ryan and Sammy you all have slides okay they said whoever slide is up first is who's going first

071so yeah you get to decide over there Kim all right so uh as as you recall uh we had a regional roacho and uh Vince Adams facilitated a conversation around advocacy what I want to share with you around Oregon School Board association's legislative priorities uh that we are ramping up uh to be ready in advocating for several uh priorities uh and none of them will be possible if we don't uh work with a Grassroots efforts and with compelling stories so I'm going to pause here and say if you have not filled the member advocacy survey and community members audience you're welcome to uh check this survey as well uh please feel free to uh raise your phone and scan the code uh and happy to send you the link afterwards as well where you can

072identify which priorities you care about the most and then osba will be ready to share with you how those priorities are ADV advancing in the legislative session ask you to share your perspective a local story around that so that's really important uh approach that osba is embracing and focusing on all members approach to uh Advance our priorities so that's really important perspective because uh they uh can hear from the lobbyists uh all the time but the intentionality that they gets from a member who served the constituency saying here is how Corvalis is impacted by the 11% cap on special education uh it's a different story when we share the successes of how we're investing in special education and say Here's what we're going to miss if we continue doing what we do with the funding

073that's going to be limited that's a story that will be compelling so that's the first step I want to uh share and maybe we can leave the slide for a little a little bit and take it down but what I want to move into is what are those priorities now if you ask any two different individuals uh in the education Community what are the priorities you will hear a lot but the common theme among most if not all is going to be funding is the root cause of many of the challenges we have now we have a great progress this time around where the governor uh acknowledged that we're way behind in how we estimate what's the starting point so every time we started at the legislative session January beginning of the long session five

074feet five feet behind the starting line and we have to Advocate by starting to say this is actually a reduction budgets instead of continuing to the service level budget and then when we reach to May or June and have an understanding okay here is how close we can get to keep the lights open and not have any additional Investments now it's almost in the overtime where uh we were very limited to advocate for strategic Investments so that's the good news the challenging part of the news is the assumptions of the current service level are $515 million increase to keep up doing what we do and also there's another number $600 million is to keep up with the pur rates now the pur pers rates are commitments that we have made as a state and school

075districts for our employees uh it is going to be a onetime not necessarily one time but temporary event unfortunately that temporary event is over the course of a generation which means this $600 million if we defer to the next bium that means our students for this generation are going to have reduction in the services they need now purs might be resolved in 10 or 20 or 15 years but we can't push that and say that's something we can absorb if we absorb it that means we're going to have a reduction in the service so when you see 515 million and $600 million you got to add them together and have a number and that's where the state uh the governor and also the education community and the legislative leadership is working together to understand what

076is that number that we need to make sure every child in every District get the help that they need and that number as soon as we hear about it we need to really advocate for it strongly not only by saying we need that number to pass please vote for that number that's not enough we need to really leaning on the experts from uh our superintendent and what you're here from uh Ryan around uh what kosa really lean in and aasbo the business officials who will tell us this is the actual cost of running the business and that's the number that we're getting so you're going to hear multiple numbers from different stakeholders uh osba really advocates for getting the right assessments from the experts who know what it costs actually to conduct business and that

077gets me to what does that mean special education as uh uh d uh chair Whitebear shared uh it varies from one District to another some districts have 11% some have 9% many have more than 14 15 or even 20% of the student population from special education needs and they deserve and they need an investment into the resources that's helped them to uh learn uh uh to their needs and unfortunately we are capped at at 11% you don't get more than that so raising the cap where school districts can get Investments uh that are appropriate to the number of students who are on special education uh plans is going to be really a priority and we need to make sure that the Investments are there for that cap when it increases Al also we have the

078high disability uh Investments account for students who have high costs uh needs that are high cost we need to maintain those Investments for those students uh another priority you going to hear is uh making sure that we have uh good assessments on uh the the um facilities so we have the matching grants for our uh bonds and when you pass a bond you get matching grants from the state making sure that our facilities are safe and our students are safe uh sum are learning um just as a reminder we invested in our summer learning fully thanks for our foundation and the investments from our local community we need to make sure those Investments are available for every District including ours uh from the state the state uh is invested partially in summer learning and we

079need to share that value early literacy as we saw that there is a huge impact on it now what does that all all of that mean you may want to pick one or two or three of these priorities and understand how it is impacting our district have the compelling story about how you think this will impact us share the win uh share the success that we have done and then share the impact if we don't reach that investment that's we need so that's where are we where we are right now what this will get you if you sign up in this survey is an update as soon as we're ready to go to Salem and contact our representatives and senators and the leadership uh uh in the education committees then uh you're ready to know

080what's going on and what's the hearing that's uh upcoming and also sometimes there will be specifics that we want to share for example uh there is a bill about mandatory training that you shall do all those trainings in 90 days after your election we all know we're volunteering and 90 days after our assuming the office 90 days after assuming the office is during the summer so you might be into specific uh perspectives based on what you check there and your voice is going to be important we need to be all in and our community members are invited to share with us so this is a high level of the priorities uh it's going to be investments in funding including special education needs and making sure that quality education is met by making sure we're meeting

081the uh current service level uh the second one uh that you heard a lot about is accountability and uh our executive director Nik is meeting with the governor tomorrow uh to talk about what accountability means and how can we hold districts accountable that's what the governor is asking and also we're asking how can we hold the legislature and the governor accountable and investing what we need to invest in so we can't provide outcomes without investing in those uh in those uh needs so that's really going to be an important conversation what's accountability means and how can we hold ourselves all accountable into investing into into education so I believe that's the high level and if there's any overlap uh that means that's great if there's uh some unique things that trian mentions that does not

082mean that osba is not interested in it or elevating it uh justce that's what we're hearing from the members and definitely uh osba and Coos Works handin hand uh our members and our staff work hand in hand and the legislator to make sure we're advocating for the kids so back to you Ryan so I think so what I what I would like to do is I have a few slides to share um but while we go through them if there's questions you have about any of these Concepts please ask because really what my goal is is that you have a good sense of what we're up to and that you're also able to speak to some of these priorities and so um go ahead and go to the next one um Kim so um as

083part of the uh Coalition of Oregon school administrators we have been meeting um since May um to plan for this session and identify what are those areas that we need to make sure we are paying attention to and advocating for and um and as Sammy shared we are starting in a much better place than we have in the past in the past we started because of the way that the roll up from one bayum to the next was accounted for um we were always behind here I think the easiest example to think about is that when we spend money in a bani the first year we spent 49% of the moneyy the second year we spent 51% of the money but when they thought about what we needed for the next bium they started at

08450% so we were already one percentage Point behind which doesn't seem like a lot if you think about one percentage point but when you're thinking of 11 billion that's a significant difference and so there's things like that that were built into the formula and so I think actually after the strike at in PPS there's more attention to what does that role up really mean and how do we account for that and so we're starting in a much better place than we have historically um because the governor heard that and has already made adjustments um that are really important adjustments one of the other things about that though and as I shared this information tonight to keep in mind is local context so for us local context means fewer students in our system fewer students coming

085in versus students um graduating and so all of these things are Oregon wide um but there're specific differences that will happen or impacts that will have because of the number of students we have coming in remember um when I started here we had about 6,700 students now we have closer to 5,800 students and over the next each of the next four years we'll have over 500 students graduate and about 300 students come in so we'll have 800 students less even beyond that so when we are funded by per student and sometimes based on an additional weight for disability or other factors um those things um make a difference and at the same time we're being funded at a lower rate because we have fewer students coming into the system so while that's great news that

086is not uh that is still a Cuts budget for us um no doubt about it um but again that's because we have fewer kids who are living in our community um so a great place to start we're appreciative of what the governor came up with and at the same time that's a matter of accuracy and now we have to have a conversation about adequacy and those two conversations both need to happen appreciation and recognition that there's still work to be done around adequacy um those major grants that we have SSA Student Success act student um investment account major 90h which is high school Success um the continuation of those is really important um as we think about what happens in the session what you'll see later is that there's also questions for us and advocacy

087for us around um unfunded mandates or the paperwork requirements so as you as you also know we've kind of kept track of how many reports we're sending into the states and the state in the FED we um have continued to keep track of that we're we're doing about 320 reports annually um to the Department of Ed and the FEDS there there 365 days in the in the year there's less than 320 days in a school year and that's the number of reports we're responsible for so when we think about it and talk about accountabil ility there's a lot of accountability that's happening through those reports that we're submitting and when we have conversations about the staff we need to have at a district office to um submit those reports to continue to receive the funds

088there's important work that has to happen yeah go ahead um I have a question about that number for current service level was that before the rural school um funding cut happened was it after no cuz that's a Fed rule the rules yeah and so this was so the 11.36 um came after we knew what the actual Purge rates were and after they accounted for the rollup in CSL it does not account for Rural schools okay but would that change because they no longer have that funding or is that just only state dollar that's where I'm getting a little bit confused so if this is like because it's going to cost more for those schools to operate without that Federal funding yeah is does that no that's that's does that affect that number though like is

089does that mean that's not enough anymore or it it it does mean that there's less money um another great example um and I'll try not to go too far in the weeds but title one is a as our funds that we have and we get those funds based on the number of students who are navigating poverty in our school district we anticipate having 25% less funds in title one and this is before we have a new president and a new um house and so where there's concerns about those funds there's concerns about Medicaid funds that we use for mental health therapists um there's concerns about title 2 Funds that be used for professional development all of those federal funds are not included in the the state fund that's that's um based on um property taxes

090in the state funds in Oregon I get that part and and that's more and and I yes so there's more expenses that are going to need to get paid for to even keep those services that were funded Federal I know we're not a rural school but I know that one passed already yeah that's why I use that and so it is going to impact like where those dollars get spread probably okay that I won't I won't keep on and on about it but I just wanted to make sure people knew that when there's changes to federal dollars that means though there's more strain on those dollars exactly that were expected to keep current service levels that probably won't be able to anymore right so it's already okay y so th this is the one that

091Sammy spent a little a bit of the time um talking about and that's that special education cap and the way that that works is that um as a as school districts submit in December their census which is the the number of students who qualify for special education services um back in the days of major five the average number of students with who qualified for special education was 11% that number though that percentage has gone up for many school districts our school district is is closer to 14% right now there are some school districts that are closer to 18 or 19% but that number has never changed from that 11% in terms of the the double weight meaning they get a sec are considered counted as a second student in the funding that we get and

092so one of the things we're talking to we'll be talking about in this session is that we think that cap should move to 15% because that's now the average across the state um I I think that um there has to be a limit on it I don't think it's a good um policy decision to say there's no cap but I think the average makes sense to me and so that's one of the things we're advocating for um the difference between 11% and 15% Statewide is about 400 million kept up and so there is also advocacy there to try to increase the support financial support for those um students who qualify in those ways and and early intervention early childhoods is any student between the ages of birth and five so before they come to the

093school district can we stay on this special ed for a second yep um because I mentioned earlier there are districts within our region that are at 21 and 19 and I also know that um the uh ESD is not able to even get all the students probably diagnose that need Services if they had better funding those numbers could potentially go up across all the districts that are served in our area and um I do have a little bit of I have questions I know it's based on the state average but um do you know what our regional average is by chance like that's through the that's a great question I don't know the answer that that was one of the ones I was like I wanted to ask the ESD and stuff was I'm sure

094they know but I have I'm not sure CU it would be interesting to know if it's higher or lower or the same as the state average cuz they think that matters and um yeah so that was that one but yeah yeah that's a great question and I I don't I'm not sure my my guess is it's above 15 but that's just a total guess um funding for unfunded mandates again I talked about the some of the requirements that we have that were or um unexpected that come up um throughout a session um in terms of legislation and and bills and so we also want to be able to make sure that we're addressing those those things that come up during the session um so again recognizing that um there will be changes and if those

095changes were to take place that we would need to be funded in order to in order to do those things facilities Sammy talked about that we've been really fortunate in our school district to be able to pass up Bond and build new schools and have really amazing spaces for students um and in this last round in back in November there was a school district that if they didn't pass a bond to take care of their buildings they were going to basically close and those students were going to go to the neighboring school districts because they couldn't keep their building um up to standards and have it be safe so there's this is I probably more than one legislative session this will take um these Concepts but for us to think about how do we make

096sure that communities that don't pass bonds their schools are still um up to a level where students can um be safe within them um and also finding that balance bance between districts that are passing bonds and those that aren't so it's it's a tricky conversation and a topic but it's something that we need to be aware of and paying attention to right now there is a um survey going on Statewide to look at the facilities that are School across our school districts across the state and what the facility needs are to come up with what that number would be and what that would look like we don't have that yet but that's we feel like that's the first step U moving forward to be able to have that conversation early literacy um Amy already talked

097to that one but there is um advocacy to extend or allow those funds to go beyond K3 to help um students continue to build the skill of reading um and also to continue to make sure that we're um fully funding these initiatives summer learning you've heard me talk about this one more than once probably more than twice um I feel like it's an important thing that all students have access to we're so fortunate that we have a foundation that supports our summer programming but us kids across the state should have summer programming um this um the amount of dollars over the for this last summer were not enough um and also we need to know year-over-year so that it's not a last um last minute um thing that comes our Direction and we're trying to

098organize and put it together um over the last few weeks of school it just needs to be something that's continually funded year-over-year um and mental health again thinking about some of the work we've been able to do here again it's an area that we're really fortunate to have um our um our therapists that we've been able to hire and hold on to but across the state and especially in rural parts of Oregon um those services are just not available and so there needs to be continued work there and then attendance um to continue to look at um what what works what's making a difference related to attendance um and systems of support for that and then also um transportation and access so that's another area that I think is an alignment between osba and kosa

099and then always thinking about Workforce and making sure that we're um the the folks that serve our kids reflect the students in front of them um both in culture um race and language and so there's always um continued work work to be done there so those are the priorities that we have moving into the session we know that there'll be lots of bills that come forward Beyond these areas that we will either be supportive of or try to provide additional perspective around um and so I expect to be um busily involved in that for the um next few months move forward and again this last thing I'll say is just to keep in mind that this because this is the end of the anym we will probably adopt a budget before we have a firm

100hard number approved by the state and that is normal and typical of where we are between this bayum and the next yeah thanks Ryan thanks Sammy um questions from anyone okay I did have a just for clarification Sammy the survey because I went to double check it but I couldn't look at it because I already filled it out previously but um anybody in the community can fill that out I would go on Aon say yes absolutely and I'll ask for forgiveness later on uh so definitely I think uh osba is stronger when not only board members but also the community that the board members serve are informed of what's uh going on in Salem um and I believe that will be even more powerful for uh our community to have their voice heard and to

101know what we're prioritizing Okay the reason I was asking because I was going to encourage folk because we had um previous um sessions when we had our joint um conversation with the foundation and we had the advocacy training so if folk needed to look back at that recording um you can look on the board agendas and look for the um the agenda that had the foundation on it I think it was in September wasn't it October okay so it was in October um and you can view that training if you want if you are interested because this is just followup to the commitments from the spring when we were talking to the community during the budget season about how to Advocate more and so I wanted to make sure that the community continues to hear

102these messages of how to engage Beyond just here at the board at the state level and so um if you all fill out that survey there's a that will help you know when you can provide testimony cuz I think that was something that the community was asking about as well as how do we even do that and so hopefully it's helpful for the board to be giving this information out with you all too and the community so um and one thing when you're hearing the numbers that are coming through the long session just for Community to be aware and even for the board is I know last year it was like oh that's a Hu it's the highest number invested like dollar-wise but it was like less investment percent wise of the state budget that

103went into public education so it it looks like a high number but the percent of the budget was less and again it's gone down 8% over the last few byms and so I think that's really important for community that wants to be involved and even our own board to remember to always check to see like the dollar might sound like it's a huge investment but out of this allocation of the entire budget it's not as much as what it looks like anyways okay when it's a dollar more it's a historic investment yes even if it's percents less and so just wanted to make sure make sure that folk um look Beyond headlines that say like things like that when it comes to funding for our public education because it's really important uh chair yes so

104I'm really glad that our graduation requirements now include financial literacy and I'm assuming me too it's going to include inflation uh sorry for all my friends who my anyway so uh what I want to say is uh on in that vein uh to the point that the unfunded mandates for any possible legislation we will hear lots of good ideas that's are being proposed sometimes you have legislators who propose 40 legislation pieces so an inducation you may track anywhere between 500 to double that in terms of legislative ideas and here's the tricky part the legislature is required to disclose the financial or fiscal impact of the legislation on the state so they may have a a law that requires uh the Department of Education to invest one FTE they have to capture that FTE but for

105the half a million of students uh all school districts if they need to invest uh two FTE per School District hypothetically they don't have to disclose that so here's the import in the in the disclaimer about fiscal impact so here's the important part which is if we're looking at a current service level any additional legislation that you hear from osba or kosa or WBO saying there is a fiscal impact on us now this is a good idea but the question that we will be facing in may just like how in Salem they're going to face in every budget if we want to have money into that idea where are we taking the money from and how are we going to be able to address the needs of the students so definitely we need to be

106very mindful that any legislative ideas that come without investment into implementing them not only on the state level but also on the local level uh needs extra consideration from us and we need to support our uh students by elevating that and highlighting that thank you Sammy um so I have a question for the board we've been going for an hour and a half do you need a short break or do you want to keep short break okay we're going to take 5 minute break thank you e e e okay we're back to the meeting and um the next item on the agenda is Consolidated action as a reminder the items under this portion of the agenda are for Action does anyone have a question about anything in Consolidated action sha I have a question that

107I wanted to bring up around the budget parameters okay budget parameters anybody else um I would like to pull J gab please for disc okay J gab use of restraint and seclusion anything else under Consolidated action um I also have a question on the budget parameters okay I also have a question on J gab okay so those are the two that's under action um and yeah so let's start we let's start budget parameters since um that one got asked for first okay so under budget parameters um something that I was hoping to see some mention of so I'll bring it up as a question and I also brought some suggested language in case helpful if it's appropriate at this point in time was around how do we engage Educators and staff who are directly teaching

108in or involved in coordinating specific programs or specific content areas as in helping shape some of the priorities that are decided both short-term and longterm or longterm just thinking about the um um long-term priority planning Ryan I know you said you might have a a note on that so but I'm happy to give some so so based on what we heard last time um we did make a modification and it may not be what you had envisioned so I'm glad you brought it up so under be transparent the fourth Bullet at the bottom um it had said be clear on what actions are being funded to help the district reach its student achievement goals um not just line items and Broad expenditure categories and so um what Lauren and I talked about in the modification

109that we made was to say be clear on what actions are being funded to help the district reach its board goals and the thinking behind that was that the board goals do include um those um Specialists positions so music art um and so it felt like it embedded it there um rather than a a separate bullet that just was sort of a standalone so that's what we thought about and that's why we brought that forward and at the same time that's why this is part of a discussion sure yeah can I share the the language that I had to propose for this and then maybe I would love input from you or others on the board too as to would this already capture that in terms of just referring to the board goals or would

110something like this be helpful so it may be a little bit long but we can word Smith or decide so before before you do that is there anything you wanted to add to what to our discussion okay so my suggestion was to something try again okay and this could go I could see this going in a couple of different places potentially either under um decisions should be informed by data thinking that this is a form of quality itative data or under it might make sense under taking a long-term perspective to really highlight that this is not short-term decision-making but really long-term strategic planning so my thoughts were um something like to the degree possible funding priorities should also be informed with input and guidance from staff directly involved in teaching Andor coordinating specific content areas

111and programs which might include Sciences math language arts social studies music the artarts um programs like Bridges CTE libraries related to ensuring excellent Equitable relevant and engaging student learning experiences can you read that for me one more time uhhuh and I put all the words I pulled out of the board goals in there but we don't have to include all of them so to the degree possible funding priorities should also be informed with input and guidance from staff directly involved in teaching or coordinating specific content areas and programs we could include some examples there related to ensuring excellent Equitable relevant and engaging student learning experiences so um so one of the things I'm wondering about is how to operationalize that um and so in the conversations we've had so far this year about um budget

112for next year has been how do we get um input from folks and not have it feel like we are um pitting basically one program against another one and i' and I've struggled with how to go about that um so I would I'm not opposed to the language but I would need guidance and some support in terms of how how you do that um in such a way that it doesn't feel like we are um running into that kind of situation does that make sense it does and and also not putting staff in a position of saying okay we're making budget decisions who's getting cut out of your crew yeah um but rather I think when I when I've thought about this and when Educators have mentioned this in conversations so that's what I'm pulling

113from is some conversations that have come to me in terms of wouldn't it make sense to sit down and have some strategic plans of you know to use music or libraries as a to say what are the things that we think are most important and prioritizing for what this would look like for children in or students in elementary school or middle school or high school um so more of that strategic planning phase of what is it we would prioritize I'm thinking back to the examples that we've been given several times around engaging science teachers or Math teachers in thinking through what are the need to haves the nice to haves the you know really layering in what those priorities are in that way which then helps okay we know what's most important and what they

114would prioritize if we could yeah um yeah can so that's where my thinking goes can I just add on or just not say add-on but just say something about a suggestion I think it's important to like have people feel heard and as somebody that does a lot of that kind of work in other Realms of my life it's one of the most frustrating things is where people give you all this information and you're like thanks for the input that's not what happens and so being really clear if that ends up happening or even if it's in the budget parameters that it's super clear that just because somebody says this is a priority doesn't mean that necessarily is what's going to end up happening because then it sets up the expectation from the community they're like

115why did I even say anything if you're not going to use it and that's like one of the most disappointing things I feel like that happens when you invest a lot of time advocating for something in planning and contributing in then you're like why did I do all of that you know what I mean and I don't want staff to feel like their voices don't matter yeah if that ends up like if that was the case of priorities and it didn't happen and I worry that it that might be the impact yeah and so that's kind of where my mind went to like right away was like oh man what if it doesn't happen what they say this is the most important thing and it was somebody else's important thing got prioritized over theirs and

116so I do worry about that part I just wanted to like kind of vocalize that I that's important too I was involved in conversation um just this week where we were talking about um you know the number of minutes for things like PE music and art and then the conversation quickly shifted to reading um in our K3 classrooms and we're um really tight about the number of minutes we have for specials but not as as tight about the number of minutes we have for reading and when that and if we were as tight on that it would probably have an impact on the number of specials we can provide and so um so those are so again um probably to those who you know who would be engaged as well and Lou I also hear

117you in terms of you know sometimes asking the question and saying well we're not actually we're asking but we're not actually going to take your input can be more detrimental and more harmful um when that isn't actually followed through with I think the thing that that just stands out to me in terms of reading through the budget parameters is feeling like there isn't a specific mention that staff voice does matter in this process and of course we are really centering student experience as as being absolutely critical and at the at the base of all decisions that student experience being absolutely critical and then having you know having to negotiate around what's what's possible what does the budget actually allow what are the requirements with that funding as as being prioritized because it has to be

118and just looking for some mention that St voice is included as a valuable piece of information in that decision making so I think that's that's just something that I would want to see reflected in some way or honored well and it's funny it's interesting to me that you talked about the piece around data because we talked about that too as a as a potential location for for that that as well so I'm wondering if um and and that may be like you said qualitative and quantitative data on student outcomes and student experience including staff ex staff input or guidance yeah yeah I like that too Shauna because it kind of veers away from like that idea of like okay I'm helping make a decision here when it's where it's more around like centering their needs

119and experiences and stuff like that and yeah um it would probably feel less performative yeah Bernie you had something on budget parameter were you done though sh okay yeah I it's just probably because I'm new at this and I I don't think I I was here for the first read right um so we um attended a couple of special board meetings where we talked about the importance of alignment uh all the way down which should be guiding the ways and means to uh to the outcomes and I'm just wondering uh process-wise why is that not uh why a board go not specifically mentioned not Incorporated by reference uh um yeah so yeah that that's a great point I think when when we have um developed our budget and when we share our budget near the

120front of our budget document there are um a a group of pages that are actually the pages I referenced back to most commonly and that's because there's um examples of um Investments related to to those board goals and so it shows up there in the budget document quite well I think um at least as the way I think about it but you're right it doesn't really show up here um so I guess with both your comment and your shaa I'm wondering if um you know there's multiple ways we can go about this if there's amend like amendments you want to make to still bring it move it forward or if you want us to go back and bring It Forward back bring it back to you one more time with this additional input um and

121I'm open to either either way of going about it well you're at the end of the day you get to say I was like I feel like there's too many changes to do amendments okay like that like that would be restruct like figuring out where to structure it and stuff like that um that's just personally what I think I don't know if other board members agree but it seems like this and I do have a question of like how will that impact the budget process if we do the next if we wait till our next business meeting are we early enough yeah it won't um we just need these in place before the committee meets so we can do it in February I think that would probably be more effective unless like us trying to

122scramble to figure it out just so we can pass it so the two things that I'm taking back then one is to highlight staff input um and the other is to highlight the um the way that the board goals are um through embedded throughout the um budget yep okay yeah thank you you and we're like we okay can you add like five more minutes um thanks Lord Judah I have a requested amendment to jgb before we pass it under definitions paragraph one definition of restraint to close the quotes first of all and then to if you added language you would read fully restraint means the Restriction of a student's actions or Movement by holding the student or using pressure or this is the new part limiting SL removing a Mobility assistance device or other means

123um and I felt that it was important that we clarify that limiting or removing a student's Mobility assistance device is an effective restraint on the student um and should be guided by the remainder of the restraint policy I believe there's statut statutory def def in a bill that's passed two years ago and I wonder if this definition is more if there's any consequences of including this definition that may not over that may contradict with the definition used in the legislative uh definition uh so that that would be a curiosity and probably a need for consults on on compliance with the legislation yeah because we're we would be changing a definition I would prefer to like check with osba policy to make sure that we're okay with that I mean I wouldn't object to that I

124think that this is very important I was actually originally a a part of the drafting to the changes to the seclusion statute and I had requested that change and it was just shot down um but I think it's very important that it is known and in policy that removing a student Mobility assistance device is effectively restraining them although physical pressure um might not be applied to the student they are effectively restrained I appreciate that distinction Judah and um yeah you're going to check on that one Melissa yeah if you could give me what you wrote and then thank you so we'll pull that so we're going to pull that we won't be approving it tonight if un unless I mean I'm not saying that but if if that's what you that's what I was just

125saying so we're pulling that one we're pulling it yeah that way we can check on that okay perfect thank you yeah I remember when I was like um on the when I was first looking at the PO just wondering if then under the policy where the wording says the use of the following types of restraint on a student in the district is prohibited that that could be listed as an example there well I don't necessarily want because those are blanket prohibitions under any circumstance and sorry this is also a special area of interest that what's represented is um potential use of lethal Force against a student because all the prohibited on the pro those could all result in death and this would not result in death but to to make it known that this is

126a use of seclusion or restraint and why I drafted the suggestion the way I did was to add it to the definition instead of having that fall under the blanket provision the other means because it's not clear because this is not an actual use of force upon a student um that it is still a restraint so um hopefully we can hear back from legislative Council on that is that one that um could possibly be like in um like the little footnote for example you know what I mean where it's like yeah where you can add it like that because I that's what I'm going to find out because where it says other or other means IED this is a definition of an other mean of restraint but I'm sure Judah has something I do I

127have a great many feelings on this because the removal of a Mobility assistance device is not itself a use of force on the student that that still being categorized as a means of restraint without direct physical pressure that I I believe that I believe it it's important but I will of course defer to the board majority but in particularity wanted to highlight that thanks Judah you apologized earlier I don't think you should apologize for pointing things out and um making sure we're keeping students centered in these policies just wanted to say that too okay any other go ahead so again I want to share the appreciation of the proposal and maybe to frame the question in a way that might help us capture the intent of the Amendments I might want to add a few

128questions there because I can and similarly to how Title 9 was different between the state and the federal and we end up treating having two different processes I think the proposal here is transformative policy we're saying we're holding ourselves to a higher standard on what restrain means as long as we capture that in a way where we say you have Oregon defined restraints Cal School District defined restraints and if the it is the will of the board to divide the policy into these two tiers then I can maybe want to propose framing the question should we add this definition and make sure we're delineating that's the reporting to OD is based on their definition so we're in compliance and also we're consistent uh with other districts and how they Define it if that makes sense

129good Bernie I'm I'm just wondering uh you you mentioned earlier uh that that you you don't consider this act an actual use of force type uh scenario is that is that what you're saying if that is what you're saying I'm just wondering if we should address this in a separate policy and just leave this as is so it was that this is not a direct application of physical Force as is every other type of physical restraint that restrict um and it's not a seclusion because these can be removed while the student is still in a classroom so that this is a very distinct type of restraint that does not involve direct application of physical Force to the student as we see in every other example and the OD did give us the blanket the or

130other means so if we're considering that this every single time is another means of restraint I would like to see this being brought forward to the state level to recognize that removing a students ability to move under any circumstances qualifies as the restraint that we hold our eles accountable in that in that way and report that data to OD go ahead Trace so the other means was the um part that was the reason I wanted to pull this out because I feel like I I'm well actually I'm not going to say anything more because you've already said it so much better than I can I think the other means language is problematic for consistent application of this and to sami's point if we are supposed to be applying this as a state standard there is

131absolutely no guarantee that we have any reason to think that districts are interpreting this the same way so I think the language is a problem and it should go back and we should encourage osba to fix it um I don't think corvala School District should be the only place that addresses that um but I just I see that that is so vague that any reporting we would do there is there's no guarantee that we would be able to say that the interpretation of restraint and other means is being applied consistently anyway so I don't know that's my thought you have something yeah so um in the past just kind of keep in mind in terms of policy and the way we've um worked with policy one of the things that came to mind for me

132was that every student succeed Act and the way we use the word Haw and cross rather than the word swastika based on what we heard from families about the importance of that word um to some religions and so I think that there is the ability for us to go back and ask where definitions are um there's similarities but words are different in this case it's a little bit beyond that but we have delved into this before and so I feel like it's totally appropriate for us to have the conversation get the feedback address what judah's the questions that Judah has and then come back with a recommendation for you so I think I'm glad you brought it up um because it is a spe it's another specific example of of um what could be classified

133as a restraint it just isn't in the language that they brought forward thank you Teresa was that everything for why you pulled it to okay um so um before somebody I asked for a motion as a reminder we pulled the budget parameters and policy J gab use of restraint and seclusion the rest of the items in the um packet are what we're voting on now would anybody like to make a motion Samy I move to approve consolidate action as proposed as yeah as proposed oh no I'm sorry that would you like to restate your motion I move to approve consolidate action with the exception of budget parameters budget parameters policy jcy AB J jjb jjb sorry someone makes a you're so close J J JJ JG yeah okay JG JG AB think we're need that

134again Capt you want to go for a third someone Sav me what second the motion to approve consolidate action with the exception of J gab and the budget parameters I will second that revision to the second I thought it was already second that was yeah okay the second to the second okay you all are okay um it's it has been moved by Sammy and second and by Judah to adopt the Consolidated action items with the exception of the budget parameters and policy J gab I have it in front of me so it's uh is there any further discussion okay um has been moved by Sam and second Judah to adopt the Consolidated action items with the exception of budget parameters and policy jgb use of restraint and seclusion Bernie I Sammy I Chris I shaa

135I theres I Judah I and I vote I uh motion passes unanimously and the next item on the agenda is Consolidated information as a reminder the items under this portion of the agenda are for discussion would anyone like to discuss an item and Consolidated information I think Chris had one to Chris so I apologize if I'm misreading this but in oh wait just tell me which one it is first oh yeah J sorry just j h fgb n a b d ar oh the AR okay Sammy I would like to pull out the November 2024 Financial Cal summary un audited for a question okay and also okay and also EBC uh proposed and also ebca proposed and EBC and ebca uh existing okay anybody else okay um so the first one it was um the

136policy jhf gbn ab- a reported reporting of suspected abuse of a child and I apologize if I'm re misreading this but at the very end of the first paragraph it says any District employee who has reasonable cause to believe that any person with whom the employee is in contact has abused a child should immediately report and then it should be a I'm sorry it should be a period after report should it say report oh I'm sorry it shouldn't do that it feels I cross out many things it should say I will I will adjus this for second read it should read um the employee is in contact has abused a child shall immediately report in the same manner period yeah I just felt like there was something missing there yes thank you Chris anybody else

137on that one go ahead Sammy sorry I just notice that is the language as it treats only for in contact if the employee hears in second hand of an incident uh suspected of uh child abuse I believe that qualifies for mandatory reporter but is the language here captures that because I don't I don't read it that way they're they're mandating that you have to be in contact am I right um when I read if you believe that any child with whom an employee comes into contact with has suffered abuse that to me seems like the mandatory report yeah I I it's what sounds different to you well it sounds different to me that this says if uh the employee comes in contact with the student or the child they learn about uh uh child abuse

138they have to report it yes what if an employee comes in contact with as the third party the third party discloses a child so and so was subject to abuse by a whole other person by a whole other person so a third- party report I don't think is mentioned in here no and and you're asking is that a is that a mandatory report correct I'm pretty sure party yeah I'm pretty sure if somebody discloses like that I know let's ask Judah I think it's if you know or have reason to know that a child is being abused essentially you must you must Report with the information that you have available right and that's what I see at the on top of the second paragraph any District employee who has reasonable cause so so to believe

139yeah to to believe that an a student has been subjected to abuse and and must report so if you look in the second paragraph second paragraph instead of the first right at the top any District employee who has reasonable cause to believe that any that another District employee contractor agent volunteer or student has engaged in abuse or that the student has been subjected to subject to abuse somebody else that they heard from a child I still have to report it but this is saying that um if we're hearing of any abuse made by like a volunteer so there's you know there's a there's two different kinds of policies here this policy is focusing on the actual reporting of the the child abuse and I see where you're coming from you're saying it's it's not clear

140enough about what a mandatory report is in a mandatory report is taken care of in a different policy this is focused solely on how you do the reporting and what happens following the reporting so um I can pull that other policy for you to make sure that it exists there agency or centralized hotline would it help just to put in there that this is not in place of that policy or what I can do is cross reference that policy at the Top If you would like me to add that I will that might be helpful to have that distinction since they absolutely yeah here's a problem we're going to continue to run into Chris just you know is that the statute this is based on is not that great yeah um I have a question

141real quick uh does this impose an additional duty on employees and everybody else to make a secondary report Beyond uh D the DHS report no okay I guess I I was misreading it okay it gives it gives you options you can use the centralized reporting system or law enforcement and there's always not only is that required but they also file a report that we hold on to so those are the two duties to report that we we have in the district yeah okay all right I'll add that cross reference do you have something on this one yeah yeah just came up for me so this refers to any any employee in the district what about volunteers including oh do volunteers have the responsibility yet not as put them at two categories the financial and the

142package of EBC C where is it the EBC ones ECA correct okay so would you like me to start with the financial yeah sure uh so the question for the financials in November is uh there is in the first line uh pound signs or hashtags I'm assuming this is an Excel sheet cell size yeah I just realized that so can we can replace that tomorrow right the page in the packet yeah it just the conversion from Excel to PDF apparently didn't go well sorry no worries well well that caught my eyes and I'm wondering if you have any insights why the uh tax revenue um local property tax revenue and uh other local sources uh might come is forecasted to come shorter than budgeted uh is that is there any insights about that it's like

143about $300,000 combined um if I read that correctly yeah with the the um difference on the local property tax revenue I mean when you look at it as a percentage it's not super significant um what I would say is that the the local property tax revenue across the state um this year has been coming in lower just from anecdotal information of talking with colleagues and others um and it's just the the difference in assessed value didn't grow as much as um it has the last few years so then since everything's based on that assessed value you just receive a little bit less but um again we are making an estimate based on Trends and it was just a little under the average I'm not super concerned about the 112 um that does have an impact

144on compression and so then like for local option Levy we're actually able to bring in a little bit more so if you look at the difference between those two um it's even less okay yeah thank you so much no further questions okay anybody else have questions on the financials since it was pulled okay thank you um are you pulling these all for the same reason is that why you said to lump them are two separate things there's two separate questions one specific to EBC and the second question sorry I'm I'm going to say it's a Pandora box about the change of EBC ebca policy the combined now we're the proposal is to delete that and to to add two EBC and ebca so it's a question that captures them all if that makes sense okay

145so I'll start with the first simple question on EBC uh my question or curiosity is uh there's an addition there's a requirement here for every 60 students enrolled that uh we would have uh first aid CPR ad card um and I'm wondering in the same vein for this plan if there is any value in uh riding uh access to Naran in uh school buildings in a way that we uh we ensure that it is available by policy is that something could fit here it could but we have it in other policies too and in February the nurses are bringing forward a whole pile of new health related policy that include reference to Naran that include um liability around that that that doesn't exist for our staff if we use it all of the and and

146our students all of those things so those will all be coming in February and the nursing team will bring those so it will it is mentioned in two other places wonderful thank you so second question is related to the deleted plan uh sorry deleted policy about emergency procedures and disaster plan and I remember that we passed this in 2020 um we called it a district emergency plan with minimum expectations and the minimum expectations we're listing 12 requirements the way I see it that we're moving that part into the new ebca deferring to is it ABCA or no EBC yeah because um ebcb is about drills emergency drills so ebca is safety threats safety threats so for the safety threats we have uh minimum expectations of communication which is great we have a deferral to OD

147I believe somewhere here on the requirements for a district uh disaster plan M and I'm wondering why shouldn't we retain the same list of uh requirements that we had in EBC ebca the 12 requirements for the plan um because I think like we thought about it was very thoughtful and detailed and it was appropriate for the times yes so I'm I wasn't around for that this one so did did the board create these um 12 items or was this did this just come kind of boilerplate from ospa I think it it came from osba okay I'm happy to reach out and ask about those and if those are if if the consensus of the board is that they want something like this added the the yes uh I I would propose for for uh including

148it and uh I'm I'm going to say while the policy should be really high level and say this is what we need to accomplish I believe it's really helpful to stipulates either in the ARs or in the policy uh like this is a checklist of what the plan should entail um so yeah it it does help us not to miss an element and I think those 12 elements are really uh helpful uh for a variety of types of disasters so that's my recommendation if that's the will of the board is it I'm looking around everybody's looking around at each other well I have a question then like did you used this when during Co like you had must have had to do a lot of this when you were doing all the amazing work you

149did during the pandemic and before you know as things were getting going we did all of this but most of that all of what we did was very much directed by OD and OHA yeah thing yeah I mean I didn't turn to this policy during that time I just I was giving D I was being given Direction from OD and OA so are you gonna look into yeah I can absolutely do that I will do it okay thank you all right thank you okay what's the next one is the a or the B oh sorry I mentioned them all because they were all together they're all together so uh they're deleted from one and they're referenced differently than others so that's okay so you didn't have anything else from any of those does anybody else

150I did on the um on the emergency procedures and drills the ebcb um I it I think it would be kind of nice to see in our policy that um I know it's saying what we will do but it doesn't have like that we won't do simulated active shooter okay I would appreciate seeing that knowing the harm that they've caused in other districts across the country okay huh yeah if that's okay with you all okay so we will not do simulated drills yeah can I ask a question about that so there have been simulations that the county has done um not during school time but using school facilities to practice are you saying no to that those this polic is for students just for the student yeah so I just don't think they should be

151witnessing each other pretend get shot as all totally agree yeah yeah that's why I was like I think we all but it' be nice to have it reflected in our policy yeah just uh follow up on that though uh is it the sense of the board that we don't even talk about it or do a tabletop type uh drills for for the oh no they they have drills and they talk about it but some some schools and other part parts of the country actually simulate shootings right right with the fake blood and stuff and I don't think we should so you're talking specifically about the active the that's what the simulated drills are simulated drills and not table exercises or something like that those are super important great yeah thanks yeah that I just want

152to mention to you that that 12 item list is kind of it's very specific to pandemic I know it says other catastrophes on there so um I I mean I so if that's if we want to stay specific to the pandemic issues that are listed there that's fine I'm just want to point that out thank you I would uh encourage an all Hazard approach uh for sure so I would support all Hazard approach so any Dimensions you can get from those 12 items that could be applicable for oral Hazard I would support that personally thanks thanks oh my gosh I didn't even see we're over on this topic I'm so good at that usually but we are on time though we're back on track somehow we were ahead we were super ahead now we're right

153on now we're right on the thing so um last item on the agenda is board member member comments does anybody have comments I have comments but I'll go last did you have your hand up Judah I did I'd like to thank County Commissioner Gabe sheeper for attending our meeting this evening and on this emergency response that we've just been discussing not a local resource the um Community Emergency Response Team which is a free combination of Educational Service and opportunity to volunteer in the community and um information can be found through the city of Coralis website and I think also through the county so it is free of charge they provide lots of free materials and since we're just talking about emergency response just let make it known that's in the community and it is free

154of charge Other Board member comments do you have your hand up Sammy So chair uh I have two comments the first one we discussed earlier and uh again I want usually don't acknowledge audience but I want to acknowledge uh commissioner Shephard and thank him for sticking around for a while and in that vein uh we discussed the interjurisdictional coordination Leah Zing I want I want to acknowledge that uh Ryan as our superintendent has been phenomenal in making sure that the uh working relationship with uh uh leaders across uh the community and the region is there and uh that did help a lot in many operational and strategic initiatives and at the same time I think uh leaz zening on the policy level and elected officials level would be really helpful for constituents and for us

155to have alignment in understanding what's are the goals and shared interest and how um other jurisdictions supports others uh we have seen it in a different uh uh angle but with the foundation how uh meeting together annually and then by anually have uh increased our ability to achieve our mutual goals and in similar vein I would recommend any approach for the uh leadership to consider to strengthen that uh whether annual or um every two years meeting with uh jurisdictions we interact with uh our students benefit from andu and staff benefit from uh or whatever model that could really help us on an elected officials level uh while we continue to support and advocates for the superintendent leadership that he continues to do so that's my first comment uh and I would defer to uh board

156leadership into how to drive this conversation the other comment I really referenced earlier is related to our students and families who are undocumented I want to really appreciate uh Ryan for making that statement earlier and for the resolutions that still um continue to be in place that the board passed uh in 2016 and the consequent uh reaffirmations and trainings and uh facts for our community uh that's being said I the anxiety is really high uh and and we want to ask sure our students and families we got their back and part of walking the walk around that I want to share really my genuine serious concern about the lake and Riley act it's uh basically uh the way I would describe it if uh a person is Accused uh before uh the trial happens and

157the accusation is uh considered deemed to be true or not uh that person may be detained by the homeland security officials uh if this act uh passes federally and also state attorney generals uh will have the capacity to prosecute or the homeland security if they don't detain those people uh even if the only problem is they are accused they're not necessarily have seeing their day Injustice so uh there are so many unintended consequences to that uh for folks being wrongly accused and then detained by Homeland Security I know our my understanding of the sanctuary laws that we have in Oregon pre prevent that and this act isn't contradict to that um and uh uh right now it's in the Senate side and uh having passed with bipartisan supports in the house side uh make me

158wonder what kind of advocacy we need to elevate uh because what I'm hearing from uh community members is uh really anxiety about this act and frankly uh talking about it uh not those who are impacting the mo impacted the most potentially by it uh don't have a voice and but still consider them our constituents so anything we can do to continue reassure our community that uh we're going to support them support their pracy and uh support the Supreme Court's rulings in the past around uh protecting them will be really important um but also seeing the unintended consequences of this and just holding the due process uh uh that's we hold ourselves to and not using state and local resources for federal uh uh offenses or immigration law violations is something that we've been doing for

159a while and this could really reverse all of that thank you Sammy any other board members have comments okay um everybody already thanked commissioner Shepard for being here that was on the top of my list but thank you for taking the time to um hear what's going on with the district and with the board here um appreciate that and um I was going to similarly say something about the um the act and I'm pulling up the actual name of it because I'm like the Riley Len act yes thank you um um and how it's in direct opposition of decisions that this board has made in the past to support undocumented students um it's in direct opposition of the state Sanctuary laws and also in direct opposition of the um statement that the school district has

160just reissued to our community here and so I just wanted to reiterate what Sammy said and also um Express disappointment that it was passed as well um since this board has voted on matters in the past already and continues to support um students in our district and families so the any L and Riley thank you yeah um and um with that being said I also um wanted to say again thanks for um the staff for being here all late with us and um happy back to school after winter term after I said something really sad but um I do um want to say thanks for all the work that you all do and with that the what time is it 8:57 the meeting is adjourned e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.