001e e e all right the meeting the school board meeting is now back in session thank you so much to the community for waiting those who are here live or watching streaming live we had some technology issues that we were navigating but we're ready to go forward and thanks to the technology crew in the back who are making that possible we appreciate you being here so next on our agenda is the five-year strategic communication Plan update thank you Kelly Losi for being here and turn it over to you hi good evening every everyone so this is uh an exciting moment so two years ago I was here in front of the school board talking about doing a Communications audit uh this time I'm here talking about having completed our Communications audit and having taken that
002information and now talking to you about the fiveyear Strategic Communications plan uh that I've built with the information that we gathered during that Communications audit so Kim if you could pull up slides and I'll just do a little bit of a a quick walk through um because you have the plan in your packet um and just remind some folks about uh some of the details of the audit as well we actually have three board members that weren't here and weren't board members when we did the audit so I want to make sure I give just a little bit of an overview of some of the details of that um perfect so you can go ahead so just a reminder some of the components of our Communications audits so we did this back in October of
0032022 uh we did a survey of uh staff and families and community members and that included uh some information on communication preferences perceptions ideas um the auditor also did a materials review so this included District Publications um policies websites social media um our existing strategic plan um our budget and then we also did focus groups so board members participated in focus groups um our communication staff participated in focus groups families again staff all of these comp components um and then this included kind of gathering some information on strengths improvements kind of decisions um being able to provide input on those decisions and then kind of timeliness and information needs and even though I didn't list it up here the important thing to remember is that at the same time the board was doing their strategic
004planning process and so we were able to take some of that information because it kind of involved Communications and engagement and kind of line that up next to the information from our audit and utilize that information as well to be kind of thinking about how we might put together uh strategic Communications plan for the district go ahead so this is an example of some of the kind of pieces that we put together when we talked about the strengths and challenges so um comprehensively this looked at a lot of different things so it looked at um District image it looked at communication specifically so for example um you know parents gave Communications during a crisis or serious incident uh a high rating in terms of how informed they feel which is positive um but then we
005also got some feedback that Communications were a little more kind of reactive versus proactive um and that the stories about the really great things happening in our district uh were not quite getting out so people didn't quite feel informed about the really positive things that were happening on a regular basis um which from a storytelling perspective and from kind of a public education storytelling perspective isn't great so we want to make sure that information is getting out go ahead and then we also had some information come back about our internal Communications our external Communications our website and then our social media um so you know things like delays in receiving important information um our families in particular we know we got a lot of feedback that they had uh quite a bit of communication that
006they were waiting through um that they were very confused about all the different places that they were receiving Communications from um and then not quite understanding parent Square um and that's understandable we rolled out parent Square really in the middle of covid-19 because we needed to and so we didn't have the opportunity to share as much information as we had hoped to about parent square and the purpose um and then our website being text Heavy not quite having as many photos with that storytelling being hard to navigate and then our social media again not using that as a great opportunity to share some of those stories um and then importantly you know allowing comments on our social social media but then not having an opportunity to engage with commenters on our social media and we
007know social media is a two-way communication tool so that's another missed opportunity to engage with those audiences so now I'll kind of walk through a couple of the pieces that are in the Strategic Communications plan so one of the first things that I put together was a goal for our plan and so our goal is to ensure staff families students and community members have access to and are well informed about key District information so we're really committed to delivering effective Communications that support our District's strategic communication goals and priorities that Foster transparency and promote two-way communication and engagement so that was really based on the feedback that we received that that two-way piece is really important it's important to share information out but it's also important to have that two-way communication um it was also
008really important that those strategies be aligned so that we were thinking about in particular the board goals and how are we supporting the work of the board and championing those messages um and then thinking about the objectives that we wanted to achieve over this kind of five-year period of time um and so that's really hard to narrow down to just a few things so being able to think about the highest priorities right now for us and so um to me one of the most really important pieces was um improving accessibility and transparency of our information uh being able to do better storytelling so developing engaging compelling diversity stories um and being able to do those in multimedia formats so not just one one way of telling stories but how are we doing lots of different
009ways of telling our story um and being able to do that in a way that we're showcasing the district's priorities and then being able to Foster engagement um through kind of refined communication channels so we know that we have some channels right now that are really effective we know we probably aren't using some channels that we have to the best of our ability and we also know that we want to be able to explore what it looks like to use other communication channels that we aren't already using so those three pieces felt like kind of the biggest priorities and the things that we would want to focus the most on kind of over the five years go ahead and so to me this was the first spot that we really have this high level alignment
010so looking at our key messages um and so these should look fairly familiar to you all these are pretty lined up with our board's priorities and goals so um the corval school district provides students with with challenging relevant and engaging learning experiences that help them succeed and prepare them for the future so that's our key message number one we celebrate the rich diversity of our school community and we ensure the needs and interests of all students are taken into account and we aim to ensure success by inspiring and empowering our students to thrive in a diverse and everchanging world and we believe in prioritizing social emotional mental and physical wellness to create a thriving School community through this we Foster growth and Community Care ensuring every student feels known valued and empowered to reach their
011full potential so this is the first opportunity that I've had with our Communications work to start with something and build in strategies and stories and thoughts based on something like this and that's actually been a really exciting opportunity to walk into storytelling with because in all honesty it's been really easy to start to hang things on the because this is such a core of the work that's happening in our district um and it's really great to be able to do the storytelling through this lens and be able to know that it's so easy to tie back to the core work of our district so there's some really exciting opportunities I think in having these key messages and having it aligned with the work of the board and knowing that each of our departments is also
012working on messaging and things around these key priorities um I think it's just a really exciting opportunity go ahe and so you'll notice throughout the plan there's also strategies and tactics um across all of those different objectives um there's several things across the entire kind of five years you'll also notice there's some things that have already been started um it is a 2023 2028 strategic PL so some of the work has already begun and so under each of these I tried to build things that could start now like we'll see one of the strategies right there is talking about you know creating a strategic Communications plan that's one of the first priorities um and so thinking about things that we could build over time thinking about things that were incredibly foundational um messaging in information
013is fantastic but if we don't have the right tools and the right ways and the right access to that information for people uh the actual information doesn't matter so for me it was thinking about the importance of both of those pieces um and building that out over time and also thinking about ways to leverage our staff um because they gave gave us a lot of feedback about how how much they wanted to be really really positive ambassadors for our district and just didn't feel like they had the right pieces to do that and so I think a lot of the pieces that we've included in here will give us the opportunity to give them the tools to be able to do that in a lot better way and the support and the training and all
014of the things that they have said that they want um so that they can help us be part of this messaging um and so we tried to build that out over this time frame um and also to help set us up that at some point point a while from now hopefully we'll be building out more strategic Communications plans and that these pieces will set us up to be able to do that in a positive way good um and you'll also notice another big key component in here is that we built in uh measurement evaluation and then a calendar of when we're planning to do these activities um and so equally important was uh thinking about checking off items as we go so part of the success of the plan is being able to execute the
015items that are in it but also of success is being able to measure the effectiveness of these items so the good news is because we were able to do the communications audit and a clear component of that was asking people you know how informed they felt about certain topics we already have kind of Baseline data to tell us where people were and so our plan is that partway through executing this plan we will go back and ask those questions again so we already have some builtin tools to be able to go back and assess if we've made prog ress in some of those areas and we also have the ability to see if we've been able to get some reach with some of our strategies and so you know as much as I have finalized
016the plan and it's here in its print form you know this is a living document and we will continue to evaluate and adjust and adjust timelines as needed um because the feedback that we get um as we start to do this process will be really important and we want to be responsive to what we hear from folks so if we do the things that we thought thought we heard and we get more feedback that says we have missed a mark Or that we haven't included something that is really crucial then we want to be responsive to that so um it's a living document we will continue to update it and so having these pieces in place in there will be incredibly important and I think it speaks to that accountability part that we've talked about
017tonight of being accountable to the data that we collected being accountable to the feedback that we collected um and coming back and being able to make those changes and pivots good Kim and so the next steps are to like I said measure the plan's Effectiveness and then the actual impact of those strategies um on families students community and the staff uh being able to share yearly progress with everyone so this is the first step of me being able to come to you all and share that the plan is complete that I will be coming and doing a yearly kind of update with you all on how the progress of this plan goes and what we find as we kind of do some of that early assessment work um and then I will plan to be
018doing that with the community as well um and then like I said making ongoing adjustments as needed um and being responsive to that feedback um to me the biggest commitment that comes out of this is that like commitment to this constant feedback loop of we're going to get feedback we're going to adjust we're going to be responsive to that feedback and we will continue to do so with this process because that's what we said we would do so and with that I'm happy to answer any of your questions thank you so much any questions from the board Samy first of all deep appreciation of this thorough explanation of uh the work that you engaged in and led and and the product that we have and the plan ahead uh thank you uh it's it's phenomenal
019and I'm really grateful reflecting on where we started and where we are there is so many objectives here and strategies and tactics that are clear to prioritize the work I want to acknowledge it and appreciate the work there I'm gonna pick one and anchor on one uh strategy three uh tactic two uh under develop refine and streamline communication tools and channels to keep key audience informed engaged one of the things that you're going to be focusing on or working on is creating communication plan templates for eer gencies I believe that's the only place where I can see a specific mention of you know uh crisis management communication uh and response and I think that's a really important uh point I want you to maybe expand where in the strategies or maybe somewhere else outside the
020communication plan there might be other elements where communication work informs um planning practicing training and even receiving feedback on how resilient we are how we learned after an emergency or crisis and how we're preparing for one I believe this tactic is very crucial specific but I'm wondering about other elements if you can highlight those yeah and that's a great point that there is definitely departmental work that isn't captured necessarily in the plan because we do participate in incident command system process our Communications I say Department it's me um our Communications Department is involved in that process we have communication plan strategy all kinds of things Melissa knows she's heavily involved in this as well that we do anytime that there is a crisis and so um I think based on your question too I think
021you know what are the things that we capture here what are the things that we capture in some other way and how do we assess that feedback um because you're right it's important for the community to know that we're doing that work and that there is all of this planning happening and all of this process happening kind of behind the scenes but we don't necessarily have that documented in a real thoughtful strategic way so that might just be a spot to make a quick addition a a addendum already to the plan and that's okay that's a good piece of feedback Sammy thank you thank you yeah we have a question from Lou online Lou yeah um first like Sammy said this is uh I I really appreciate all the work that went into this and
022also all the engagement um from the community and staff and everybody um I noticed when you had the um some of the feedback was given about um not seeing the learning um the commitment to learning or quality of learning um and I noticed in objective two under strategy one and um two I didn't see anything about storytelling related to student academic achievement specifically and that might help address that because there might be misconceptions in the community for not having some of those stories um out there so um with the graduation rate where it's at and even some of the success stories of students with their math and with um the AP classes um and college credits that they're getting I think those are some great opportunities to kind of incorporate some of the tactics you
023have there and so it's curious if there's a plan to focus um some of those tactics with overlaps in the academic achievement realm based on that feedback that um there is a there's some hesitancy around um if that's happening in our district so hopefully that made sense thanks for your question L absolutely it made sense and actually that's already a question I fielded today from somebody um which gave me a great opportunity to think about um I think there was just maybe not as much Clarity in some of the pieces but I was thinking already about kind of talking about that and speaking about um the strategies around the stories in the newsletter and thinking about the ways in which we're talking about kind of the learning in action and some of the things that
024are happening and those being some direct strategies to talk about kind of the academic rigor and more specifically the ways that we're showcasing um not only the things that students are learning in the classroom but the ways in which they're being asked to do problem solving and critical thinking and all of those deeper strategies um so yes I think that um it might just be helpful to use a little more descriptive language in here to kind of talk about tying that back to some of those pieces that came up but absolutely that's definitely a focus of some of the tactics and strategies in the plan because I think a lot of that work is happening and it's our job to do a really good job storytelling thank you great thank you that's awesome to hear
025and it's good for the community to hear that too absolutely thank you Chris first of all thank you um your work is always so well organized and very thorough and I appreciate reading all of this as I was reading this report I kept thinking who is this is this just Kelly that does all the communication I mean I know we lost some of your team and is it just you the Communications Department is me yes what I would say is um an important piece of some of this work and I think an important piece of thinking about how to um be more strategic is to pull pieces of this work across department and to be thinking about the roles that other people besides just me play in helping us be better communicators so will I
026be probably a primary executor of core components of this work yes will there be roles that Ryan and Melissa and Amy and Kim and other people in this room will play absolutely because I think that's how we will actually do a better job is that it doesn't just rely on me and I say my department which is me but it will rely on all of our staff and it will rely on our staff that are in our buildings who actually are already core communicators for our district and maybe wouldn't self-identify in that exact way but I certainly think of them as an extension of my department because they're all ambassadors for our district so yeah and I really do appreciate that and I um yeah I think you need to give yourself credit for all
027the work that you do and everywhere you go to and all the I mean it's not just being where things are happen happening but it takes time to write and edit and all of that and so when I was reading this report I wanted to see your name like I want Kelly to get credit for this because it's a lot of work and you do do a lot and so and I think it's important for our teachers and our staff to know how much work you do so I just put your name on this because you deserve it um and the other thing is um I wonder about Chris do you mind if I pause for a moment and ask for some more time for us given that we've gone over time can we add
028uh with the board's consent five minutes to our discussion thanks I'll be really quick um I wonder how we can Empower our students to be part of the communication too because they love to tell stories and they can also be ones that um share more about what's going on in house right in their school houses yeah I think one of the hardest things and uh Ryan knows this all too well is there are 50 things I could have put in here that Ryan would have said there's no way you can do those other 50 things and one of the strategies that I really would like to dip into and even if it's not now I'd like to build towards it is how to pull students into some of this work um a lot more strategically
029um um other districts do really cool work where students do social media takeovers and all kinds of really cool stuff and you know speaking of that Kelly are you doing all this thing I'm like why would I why would I try and grab that right now but it's such cool work and so um I love the idea of doing those pieces and I want to build towards doing some of that and my hope is that as we can strategically get some of this work happening more effectively and get staff feeling more supported in the other pieces I think it will help be in a place to be able to do kind of some more kind of planning and thought like that um and I would love to do some stuff with students a lot more
030um I love doing it thank you it takes time it does take time and I want to do it well so I don't want to just do it just to do it thank you well thank you so much for sharing this report but not just sharing the report all of the thoughtful work that has gone into developing this plan I really appreciated the alignment also with thinking about board goals as you're going through alignment that's been a theme that we've been hearing throughout which is really rewarding to hear as a board because or as an individual on the board because of the the hope that those goals came from the community and so to see that reflected back in terms of the work that's happening but thank you so much as a parent too it's
031been really just a pleasure to see some of the new Communications come out I've really enjoyed reading them in being able to see the ways that students and educators and what's happening in schools is being highlighted from a very just a celebratory stance of recognizing all of that incredible that work that's happening which with such care and storytelling so thank you for all that you're doing to expand the ways that we are connecting with families connecting with Educators connecting students and really telling the story of the district you're welcome yeah thank you everyone thank you okay moving on in the agenda we have a lot tonight and we have a lot of shifting between topics and so I think that's a mental load both for those engaging watching watching along with us and those who
032are here so if you need a moment to take a breath collect your thoughts we are moving into the Oregon school boards Association 2024 election and we have both two positions to vote on as well as um three resolutions so the board will now vote on each osba position and resolution the board secretary will submit the official vote to osba on behalf of the board tomorrow December 13th is there any discussion does anyone wish to make a motion chair oh I should probably State first that our first um vote is on the board of directors position 10 so does anyone wish to make make a motion related to that specific vote Yes I would like to uh make a motion Sammi I move to vote for Loui Whitebear for position number 10 on the Oregon
033school boards Association board of directors second okay it has been motion by Sammy and seconded by Chris to vote for Dr l Whitebear as the for position number 10 on the Oregon school boards Association board of directors all right we'll take a vote and oh discussion thank you any discussion Samy um I told uh Dr Lohi white bear I might uh speak to this motion long enough it will take 2third majority of the board to in debate but I'm not going to go that long I want to say Dr Lohi white bear is a phenomenal leader I'm excited to vote for her and this motion and for for this motion uh for her leadership not only because uh she have shown uh her leadership within this organization as our chair and colleague across the region
034that she's going to represent Lynn Benton Lincoln she showed up to districts uh she engaged with community members and she have history of uh engaging with community community members and partners across the state uh I really uh think this uh position is going to be very important for Oregon School Board Association uh traditionally uh presidents not lean in on one position or the other but I had to uh say this loud and clear to my colleagues in the region that Dr leui bear is that candidate to support to represent this region all of it not only Calis and with this words I want to share my enthusiasm for supporting her and I want to encourage my colleagues to do the same and I believe if this vote prevails uh that will uh make sure depending
035on the votes uh from other districts that she would be our next representative so every vote matters and the votes of this District absolutely matter on this one thank you any further discussion okay and then we'll I'll call for a vote uh Chris hi Bernie hi Sami I Lou I and I vote I so the motion passes all right congratulations on moving forward with the the vote from our board all right our next vote is on the legislative policy com committee position number 10 any discussion does anyone wish to make a motion I would like to make a motion okay Lou um I move to vote for saurin rounds for position number 10 on the osba legislative policy committee um yes do I hear a second I second so it has been Mo moved by
036Lou and seconded by Chris to vote for and I'm sorry I don't have the rounds saurin rounds for position number 10 on the osba legislative policy committee is there any further discussion Lou um I just wanted to share with my colleagues on the board that my um interactions with saurin um at both the conference and also at our regional meetings have um really spoken to his um commitment to representing the region and being involved with legislative action um he actually um volunteered um just as a candidate I know he was invited to but he could have said no but he volunteered to help plan the regional meeting I spoke about earlier um along with myself and our colleague from Lebanon um Clyde Roode who is also running for a position but um I think that
037says a lot if somebody is running for something and doesn't already serve in a capacity to want to help organize um legislative priorities for our region um so that is something I would share with the board in consideration of your vote thank you any further discussion okay then we'll move to vote Chris for sain for saurin Rounds I Bernie I Sami I Lou I I vote I the motion passes unanimously and now we move on to resolution number one which amends the osba du's schedule does anyone wish to make a motion I can make a motion okay Lou I move to adopt resolution number one amend the Oregon school board's Association due schedule I second it has been moved by Lou and seconded by Bernie to adopt resolution number one amend the Oregon school boards
038Association du schedule is there any further discussion Sammy just want to speak to this motion uh thank you for uh moving to adopt uh the due schedule uh this is a really important decision that has not been made for more than 25 years the last time the due schedule was altered was 1998 and uh we all know nothing cost the same since 1998 except hot dogs from uh Costco uh and the dues from osba uh the point is really to maintain the level of services and support that osba provides uh osba engaged in community engagement with all stakeholders school boards and Schoolboard members superintend to understand the priorities of services and benefits and how can we balance the budget so the help and support that I got 2017 that we get this year uh continues
039to be provided for uh School boards uh for years to come so for for that reason I believe uh that this due schedule will help us sustain the organization uh for years to come in a responsible Manner and for that I encourage AO us on it any further discussion Lou um thanks sha I was um just going to also add in that I really appreciate how much um osba staff provides for us that um our district doesn't end up having to do and especially um because everybody knows how much I like policy and um they actually help us stay in compliance with policy changes Law changes and those updates um and that would I know Melissa goes in and adds um to our policies and everything and she would have to do even more work
040without that support um on top of what she already does and I think that is such a huge benefit along with all kinds of other um things that we have um as being part of osba um so I feel like if the dues haven't been raised for that long I know it sounds like a lot of money um especially given our budgetary um situations throughout the state um but that's included among the reasons why we just need to keep advocating for appropriate funding so we're able to do things like this to continue to get the support with trainings and policies and um all the other stuff that we get for them so um that's what I would share with our my fellow colleagues in consideration of your vote thank you Lou and I'll just add
041appreciation for the work that I've seen osba do in support of boards not just our own but those around the state in terms of that professional development for school board members who are volunteers and I think our our board is very rich with board members who have a lot of educational experience and background and we know that that's we all have room to grow continually and we know that's not always the case in communities as well and not always the case on our board here either and so knowing that there is that support which also takes a capacity lift off the district to have to provide that type of support just the tremendous value that that partnership and relationship brings so it has been I'm getting better at this moved by Lou and seconded by
042Bernie to adopt resolution number one to amend the Oregon school boards Association du schedule let's move to vote Chris I Bernie I Sami I Lou I and I vote I so the motion passes unanimously two more our next resolution resolution two creates the Oregon school board members Pride caucus and designates a seat on the osba board of directors and legislative policy committee does anyone wish to make a motion Chris I moved to adop resolution number two amend the Oregon school boards association bylaws relating to composition of the board of directors do I hear a second I second it has been moved by Chris and seconded by Burnie to adopt resolution number two to amend Oregon school board's association's bylaws relating to composition of the board of directors is there any discussion Sami uh briefly I
043want to acknowledge the work that members of the advisory committee of osa's board and lgbtq 2ia plus uh 2si A+ who have helped inform the need for further support for Schoolboard members administrators Educators and students uh from The Pride community and the caucus is a path to accomplish uh the goals and the priorities that they have highlighted in order to improve students outcomes for all and with specific understanding of the unique needs of the students and um the members and Educators who support them um personally and I know uh laoi and shaana are members of the color caucus and we have found great value of it and also Bernie sorry um so we have found a great value in it and uh great resource and community in it where we can support to each other
044uh there is a rural caucus and this is the third proposal so I encourage you vote Yes and also encourage uh that we continue to engage with our communities on those priorities uh regardless of uh the outcomes of this caucus is there any further discussion it has been moved by Chris and secreted by Bernie to adopt resolution number two to amend Oregon school board's associations bylaws relating to composition of the board of directors Chris hi Bernie hi Sami I Lou I and I vote I the motion passes unanimously and our final resolution and vote tonight resolution number three which adopts the proposed amendments to the osba bylaws so I believe this follows the past resolution Samy did you have a comment or discussion uh I can or I can't make a motion does anyone wish
045to make a motion um chair I move to adopt resolution number three amend the Oregon school boards Association 2023 bylaws do I hear a second second it has been moved by Samy and seconded by Chris to adopt resolution number number three to amend the Oregon school boards Association 2023 bylaws is there any discussion yeah I will chair I would like to uh give a very general overview the bylaws include uh multiple changes including uh shall the second resolution passed by the full membership uh to formalize the seat on the governing board and the legislative policy committee uh from The Pride caucus as well there are uh several substantial changes and some minor changes to the bylaws uh within the last year with a transition osba uh reviewed the bylaws and looked into it in a
046comprehensive way and consulted with uh partners and the governance committee that uh I had the honor to chair this year and produced uh those uh uh changes that will ensure that osba bylaws uh reflect the needs of the organization today and for years to come and uh make it more robust and also address some minor uh changes that needed to be uh addressed in the past so with that uh I encourage a vote Yes and I really want to thank uh I take this opportunity to thank uh the board for allowing uh me to volunteer my time with osba these three resolution reflect hundreds of hours of service from the staff and the board members who served on osba and being of support for their work and seeing those three resolutions on the table of
047every uh school districts in Oregon is truly truly an honor so thank you for voting on those three resolutions thank you Samy and thank you for the volunteer time that you put in at the state level on the national level to be able to bring this perspective back to the board here thank you that's my honor any further discussion okay it has been moved by semi and seced by Chris to adopt resolution number three to amend the Oregon school boards Association 2023 bylaws Chris how do you vote I Bernie I Sami I Lou I and I vote I so the motion passes unanimously okay moving forward in our agenda to Consolidated action as a reminder the items under this portion of the agenda are for Action does anyone have a question about anything in Consolidated
048action I would like to pull the appointments uh budget committee appointment okay anything else anything online Chris I have a question I'm not sure exactly the process to do this but on um J C bb- AR under so that'll be under Consolidated information okay when we get to that Chris then okay hold on to that one and we'll bring that up then any others for Consolidated action okay Sammy you pulled the budget committee appointment yes thank you uh just want to highlight and Elevate the budget uh the appointment question and also uh ask uh uh to highlight about the additional vacancy so I want to uh really acknowledge that Cassandra enman will bring a great wealth of experience and expertise and also storytelling that will help us uh communicate about the priorities and ask the
049questions that will help us communicate about the priorities relating to the budget so I want to thank the rec for the recommendation and really uh supportive of the recommendation and then I want to ask about the remaining vacancy what's the timeline looks like uh to fill it or how many vacancies do we have remaining and what's the timeline and how can we be of support and recruitment so that fills the last vacancy thank you I apologize yes yes we had the four appointments um and then this was the remaining vacancy and then we had two applicants for one spot um so we actually for the first time in a while had more applicants than we did spots which is great so Lauren maybe I want to ask you sorry on the spot uh what criteria
050would Elevate recommendation of one uh the recommendation off a budget committee well that's actually a question that I had when we had more um so the reason why uh we elevated um Cassandras was was based on her interest in and um the process through appointment um on your board um and in the future I would like to have a scoring like Matrix that can be really clear um and make sure that we're also uh using our Equity lens questions and a bunch of different tools that we um have in the district for making decisions we the understanding that I have um is that we used to have a finance committee on um which was made up of District staff as well as board and they were a part of making that decision um in the
051past wonderful thank you just thought about third question when do we are when are we required of filling one position at least from the equity committee and does that fit with the timeline of the vacancies we're going to have I'm not sure on that I would have to look that that won't be till next year next year yeah so starting 2026 uh budget committee okay we have uh two Oney year vacancy or two one-year terms if I remember correctly on the current committee so we'll have two expiring actually just in June of 2025 so perfect so we're good thank you any other discussion from the board does anyone wish to make a motion related to Consolidated action chair I move to approve Consolidated action as presented do I hear a second second okay I heard
052you Lou thank you it has been moved by and seconded by L to adopt the Consolidated action items as submitted I will now entertain final discussion is there any further discussion and then we'll move to vote Chris how do you vote I Bernie I semi I Lou I and I vote I the motion passes unanimously moving on now to Consolidated information as a reminder the items under this portion of the agenda are for discussion would anyone like to discuss an item in Consolidated information Chris apologies for that oh no problem um my question under J bb- AR under safe public school choice transfers okay let's get a list of all the things folks want to have questions about and then we'll go through them any other items under Consolidated information Samy igb a is that
053information or just yeah and um the virture the charter numbers igb I don't see that one semi special education procedural safeguard sorry okay never mind we pass oh I see anything under Consolidated information Lou it sounded like your voice was coming through and we just missed you um oh it was the I might have been in oh I might have been in the wrong section it was the charter school one just kidding oh no yeah that isn't that is in Consolidated information right yes yes was there one that L just said she here just JCB okay and I'd also like to pull the budget parameters and the virtual okay Virtual contor School enrollment okay okay any others from the board Bernie anything that you'd like to pull from the section that hasn't already been named
054okay okay okay Chris Hawkins Chris I think I I hope I did this right so this is the one that talks about um student transfers and and in a case where um if a student if um student feels unsafe with a specific student that may have caused harm is this correct this is different because this is when OD says the school has been deemed persistently dangerous it's not if just an individual student was having difficulty with another individual student um I think that that's probably in um our threat uh our threat policy I would imagine okay yeah but even in the wording in this policy again just like our other threat policy it always enables the it makes the victim move not the person that's made the offense and I just can we change that
055the victim shouldn't be the one moving and I just wonder if that's something we can change I could look through the policies and see what the recommendations are from osba because it's you know the policies based on state law so it's as long as we're not violating state law that would be the case and then in some cases that that is the way it works like in terms of Title 9 UM and creating a a a safe environment for students that does look the way you're proposing it so there is variation based on different rules okay but not in every case like not in this case yeah I just giving an example of what I do appreciate that I just like it in every case with current title n rules yeah all right thank you
056thank you Chris any anyone else with J eb- AR okay we're going to move to Virtual Charter School enrollment oh I'm sorry I had a comment on that one too um please do I just really wanted to appreciate what um Chris said was all um because that actually comes up and we hear about it as a board so I appreciate you looking into that Melissa thank you thanks Chris um in the charter school um I was just wondering how the um how the numbers looked from last year is that the one um no that's the private schools in the district um for the virtual charter schools from compared to last year I don't have those in front of me so I I don't know but I can get that together and kind of do a
057kind of a long longitudinal if you want me to do that oh Ryan it's I think it's pretty similar to what it's been in the past um the the reason for this report is that um you are typically going to stay under 3% or a district can make a decision to cap um those virtual Charter School transfers um under current law and then we do know that private school number have gone down from last year that's something else that we've tracked um because we have to get numbers from them and also keep in mind that those numbers of private school students don't necessarily reside in the district they attend private schools that that are in our district boundaries so that's an important piece of to consider so as an example s m Christian has kids
058from a wide area um but that's in our account because that dist um that school is in our um District thanks Ryan I was yeah it's um I was just wondering if that was still if it was going um down because of um I know that some people stayed um in the virtual public from like covid times so that's why I was kind of wondering if it was starting to go down at all or if it was around the same but okay that was all thanks I I I quickly just pulled up January yeah I did so I pulled up January from last year Lou just to take a look and um it looks like the numbers for virtual Charter Schools was 1.99% so almost 2% um in January of 20123 and um now we're
059looking at 2.5% okay so it actually went up a a tiny just a tiny bit but like Ryan was saying the private school numbers that are listed here yeah the but we have other data so yeah that we're just looking at the virtual Charter yeah yeah that's all that's all I was yeah thank you thanks Lou anybody else on that item before moving to the next okay I ask to pull the budget parameters so what was coming up for me when I read through this I I really appreciate the emphasis on student outcomes student opportunity and student experience and I know in the last in the last or in not the last but the last budget decisions impacting this year now a lot of the emphasis when hard decisions had to be made were on
060how do we minimize impact on students experience and I really appreciate that that's highlighted in this document as well as calling out data or decisions that are informed by data decisions informed by what we know Works where where we can put the what we have to really get the best impact and outcomes for students students and something that I heard in the last round of budget decisions around process was some of the really thoughtful ways that Educators and District leaders were coming together to Think Through what's needed versus what are the things that we that are the nice to haves versus the musthaves I remember examples with especially around the science curriculum last year that's one that stands out in my mind around to having Educators who were most involved really look at what does
061it mean to have a strong Science Education for students what do we need in terms terms of curricula Now versus later what are the kinds of updates we need that we can't wait on versus what we can and that Educators voices were really just really honor seem to be honored in that process and I don't see that aspect of the process reflected in the budget parameters and so I just have a question of if it should be or if that's something to consider adding and I'm thinking about it in terms of you know some of the some of the areas where we're more likely to see that happen more systemically are around Science Education math education literacy education um some of the areas where I think there's room for growth is you know last year
062there were some really hard cuts and hard cuts to the community around libraries and Librarians and around Music Arts Theater programs and so on and I'm thinking about the ways that proactively Educators can be involved in some of this systemic thinking around what is a really strong Arts education or what does a really strong Library program look like so that those voices come into play in that strategic planning in a way that also allows for when we have to make Cuts what are the nice nice halves versus the needs to halves um so that was that was something that just stood out to me in terms of a really important part of the process in moving forward into the next wave of of budget discussions depending what what we find out is coming down from
063the state in how are Educators involved not necessar reactively later on but proactively in lining out what really strong programs look like or as well as possible given the resources that we have and and how those voices could be integrated more intentionally systemically across programs so and open to to thoughts from other board members too in terms of either that or other aspects well this will come back again because it comes back twice so we'll take that information um and and and idea from you and we'll work to try to incorporate it yeah any other comments on on budget parameters from the board I had one um SE so um thanks for pulling this one and I appreciate um your comments shared as well um on the reexamining of patterns of spending um it has
064the um District should develop and Implement a program review and sunset process to identify and discontinu programs that are not achieving their objectives are that are simply not as effective as available Alternatives um is there a process already or are you is there a plan to present us with a process that was around critically re-exam Lou I'm just restating it's a little bit hard to hear sometimes um so we want to make sure that we captured your comment effectively just around if there's a process for critically reexamining patterns of of spending that's noted in there was that what the question was yeah I was I was rereading it and um yeah sorry my voice is not um with me tonight um that's okay but yeah it was just that last sentence I was wondering if
065there is a um program review and sunset process already or is it saying that it's going to be developed and we're going to learn about it what I would say that we are currently doing um is is we this is the year I would say of this is my fourth year I think with the district and um we have been using data in every conversation and this is the first year that I have seen it to this extent um and so I would say we're doing this constantly um whether or not we've developed a formal process I don't think we're fully there um we have implemented some new strategies as far as looking at at um how many students are impacted by a decision um an investment how many students could we impact what are
066the what are the data points that we are measuring so I think we're starting to put those pieces into place so that we can do this um and I would say because we've implemented the scorecard process um we're actually making decisions a lot faster um every six eight 12 weeks versus just doing this while we're doing the the budget process um we're not I mean I think at this point we're not really interested in spending money on something for a full 12 months when it's not working um so we're doing that just as part of our our regular process um but we could work to formalize um something more for the budget process and I've been thinking about that um one of the things is we have been trying to get some more student feedback
067we've gone to a few different uh student leadership groups and talk to them um about the budget process and they have a lot of ideas as you may imagine um of things and so we can take those ideas and then sort of quantify them by how many students they would serve or how much it would cost um and kind of what the benefits and um potential pitfalls of those decisions might be and so I've already started to think through how maybe I could share some of those ideas and all of the different things that we consider um and how we kind of rate with the data um the programs that we're currently running doing that for every single dollar that we're spending our money on um next year might be a little tricky but that's
068what we're working towards um and so you'll see that show up in the next uh budget presentation okay thank you um I just came up because it says like the recommendation and the parameters is that we should develop a process for that thank you thank you Lou and thank you Lauren any other comments or questions from the board on budget parameters okay moving ahead we are on to board member comments any board member comments in evening with Chris I just want to go go back to and I apologize that I didn't say anything earlier when we were talking about Dr White Bear's um position that she was running and I appreciate that Sammy spoke up but I just also I wouldn't sleep tonight if I didn't come back and say that um I really do
069appreciate Dr Whitebear um running for this office um because I just think that as Sammy said she's such a strong advocate for our students and for our community and I I know that she does so much and I just appreciate that that she's willing to again put herself out there and and work for us and represent all of us so I just wanted to appreciate her and not go un said thank you Chris and I'll second that as well these are volunteer positions and we have board members in including Dr White Bear Sammy and everyone who serves who give tremendous amounts of time and to continually offer to give more to the community for shared learning for um that ongoing support just very very grateful to have such amazing and giving and generous colleagues Lou
070thanks um Chris and shaa for those words and for yours earlier to um Sammy I wanted to share briefly um because it would have been awkward for me to like ask to do public comment at our meeting because I'm not a member of the public but um I did go to the boards um near nearly all of the board meetings there was a couple I couldn't go to that are voting on this position for our region either virtually or in person and shared with them some of my my plans and I wanted to make sure that I told our own board about that um since it is something that um I would if I'm elected um would be able to be doing and that is to help bring our region together I really believe that
071our voices are always stronger um when they're brought together and um my thoughts are that we should be reached out to and um and ask what our needs are and no boards should be left out in our region we have such a diverse um region as far as needs and geographies and um just the whole way that the districts work across um Lynn Benton and Lincoln County and um being from one of the rural areas in our um in our region of the coastal rural side and um serving one of the the districts in the valley I um already have an interesting perspective of um how things look and I would just be really proud to represent our region and try to bring our Collective voice together to the board as decisions are made and
072um asked that the impacts on um the schools in our region are considered when those um decisions are being made at the board level and helping Advocate with legislation as as well um for things anywhere from ranging to the um to the lack of funding for special education um I learned a lot going around and knowing that the state average is 15% and some boards have or some districts have 21% 19% um ours is 15% and only being funded at 11 for special education is really a big deal in um learning about other infrastructure issues just this um last month has really made me appreciate uh the generosity of our local community I already did but it gives a deeper um appreciation for that and also a lot of empathy for districts that don't have
073the resources that we do and I come from one of those districts um when I was in k12 and um so I just wanted to take a moment and thanks for a little extra time to say that to you all because I think it's important that just because I'm from our board that that doesn't mean I shouldn't share those thoughts with you all as well um so you know what I have been talking about to other districts in our region in the ESD as well um and my my biggest idea not biggest one of my ideas was to bring the um board chairs and vice chairs together quarterly if they wanted to and were available to kind of discuss critical issues and things that we can be bringing to the osba board so I've selected
074that's one of my hopes um to be able to bring our boards a little closer together in the work as well so that was all thank you thank you Lou any other board comments so before we close I know we have one more school board meeting of this year but it's not the same as as the meeting tonight so we won't have a chance to close out and wish the community a happy holidays for those who celebrate there are many different holidays coming up in the in the coming month as well as the new year ahead but wishing everyone a a very happy holidays and knowing that this is a time of year that can be very very festive and joyful and fun and filled with care and support for some and for others it
075can be a very very challenging time and a time to sit with loss or grief as well as other challenges especially with the weather changing and knowing that many experience a little bit of all so hoping that the community takes care sending everyone with positive wishes for the holidays and hoping that staff and admin as well you give so much of yourselves all throughout the year continually this is a job that never ends thank you for those of you who are here late at night with us to the tech crew as well as staff admin and and guests from the community as well but hoping that you'll take time and actually rest and take care this work is hard and it's meaningful and it's challenging and it takes a lot it takes all of you
076and you need time to rest and restore too to come back and be strong in the new year so wishing everyone a restorative holidays whatever that means to you and very very grateful to be doing this work together so with no further business this meeting is adjourned at 9:15 p.m. thank you e for