CorpusRecord 69384

St. Helens School District Regular School Board Meeting, December 11, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SHSD Video
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Columbia County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,253 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001go ahead give me the Rosie and I if I'm what oh yes okay all right everybody we will call this meeting to order please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance FL that pledge allegiance to the the United States of America and to the rep for it stands Nation God indivisible withy andice go to 2.0 agenda approval the mve second all those in favor I I we'll go to 3.0 V to address the board this the time for public comment on non-agenda items the board will not take any immediate action but will refer concerns to the superintendent and ask him to report to the board we appreciate you keeping comments to three minutes per individual or five minutes if you are representing group of patrons this portion of the meeting will not exceed 60 Minutes I

002also have a set of prepared statements for this section public comments are allowed for any item posted on the board agenda and general comments on matters within the jurisdiction of the school district we welcome your engagement and willingness to share your board your views with board members to address the board of directors public comment cards should have been completed and submitted to Christy Ward executive assistant to the superintendent and board who seated by the podium prior to the start of the meeting you will take comments in the order the cards are received board policy bdh public comments and board meetings requires it speakers to State their names whether they are resident of the district and if speaking for an organization the name of the organization a spokesperson should be designated to represent a group with

003a common purpose the public comment session will be open for one hour before we move into our regular business meeting if there are additional speakers we will also provide an opportunity for their remarks to be heard at the end of the business meeting before we adjourn with an additional one hour to listen to public comment typically the second public comment session is limited to agenda topics listed on the published agenda we're waving that requirement for tonight each speaker will be allowed up to three minutes for comment or five minutes if it is a group please be respectful of your time so that we can hear from as many speakers as possible when you hear a sound Please wrap up your remarks in the event that there are more speakers than time allotted written comments can

004be submitted to the board at s502 SLE ns. k2. r. us please know that the board is listening but the Oregon public meeting law restricts what can be acted upon or discussed of those items properly noticed on the agenda public comment is not an interactive town hall or public forum we are aware that there are several requests to comment on the current controversy about sexual abuse allegations in our district the investigation into this terrible situation and how our district is responded we apologize for delays and initially providing timely updates and information to the public in the news media the resignation of the former board chair and placement of our superintendent and high school principal on administrative lead left a tremendous Gap in our small school district leadership team we've taken steps to fill that Gap

005and have begun regular Outreach engagement and communication to our parents staff students and Community I encourage you to visit our website at www . SLE ns. k2. r. us and click on the responding to controversy button at the top of the page to find updates FAQs and notices on this issue the district has also scheduled two listening sessions for next week on Tuesday September or excuse me December 17th for high school families and Wednesday December 18th for Middle School families the December 17th meeting will be located at the St Holland High School the December 18th meeting will be held at St Holland Middle School both meetings run from 6:00 to 7:30 p.m. the format for those sessions is to hear a 10-minute overview presentation by the Acting Superintendent on the issues then attendees will break

006into smaller study Circles of 8 to 10 people for a 60-minute round table discussion to ensure that everyone has an opportunity to share their thoughts concerns and suggestions additional lessening sessions will be scheduled after the winter break for elementary families and Spanish speaking families these sessions will be facilitated by external trained facilitators there will be recorders at each table to take notes facilitators will share with the whole audience the main points from each table for 20 minutes to close out the program lastly please note that this is a business meeting of the school district it is the expectation of the board that all persons attending act with cility and Deco please treat one another with respect during this meeting the board will not tolerate any type of disruption to the business meeting if there is

007disorderly conduct such as speaking out of turn or clapping booing or shots of approval or disagreement with someone's point of view we will provide warnings if those warnings are not heard then we will have to adjourn with a recess and we will move to another room for a virtual meeting any person who interferes with the conduct of a board meeting by willfully interrupting or disrupting the meeting is subject to be asked to leave if necessary the board may take a recess relocate to an alternative location and conduct its regular business meeting in that new location excluding the public when the time is appropriate with all of that said let's open public comment with our first speaker so far I have one public comment card is there anybody else that wishes to speak please preside to

008the public comment our first comment is from Patrick burkel the listed items on the card are costs incurred by District to address present situation questions about board meetings and decisions questions about mandatory staff training regarding mandatory reporting Mr Bur Berkeley my apologies I have been mispronouncing your name for years my apologies no every everybody I get that I am a current employee in scho District I teach third grade at elementary school but I here tonight speaking as the citizen resident taxpayer uh and someone who's had a 30e connection with school district one way or the other uh so the question I do have thank you all right uh so the yes three things one it has to do with the costs and to make sure that um the public is fully aware of all the

009costs involved I know that the uh salar is being paid to uh the administrate uh superintendent and high school principal or public and on the FAQ section section uh it says that those are the two employees that we've hired but there are additional costs the uh now deposed or the the communications director who step down uh obvious going to be obvious costs uh with the people who are involved in facilitating of these meetings all very important things but I think those costs need to be made clear what do it costing the district and also clear uh since a budget is a limited amount of money where is that money coming from is there going to be an impact budgetary impact on any other things Personnel supplies maintenance that type of thing I think needs to

010be made very clear uh the second thing is uh brought to my attention at a an article by Spotlight questions about the um process followed for the hiring of the Acting Superintendent um according to or statutes uh deliberate meetings need to be publicly uh announced and there cannot be talking amongst or decision- making amongst board members um in a like a Serial uh fashion so for instance uh from a slideshow by Shannon Fon who was is or was the Assistant Attorney General for the Oregon Department of Justice a series of private Communications uh amongst board members is it is recommended that board members not meet in private to discuss business or exchange private Communications business even if those involved um those involved constitute less than Quorum so I think it would be imperative that you

011assure the public that you follow the the proper process to make this decision I'm not questioning the who you hired but the process did you follow those laws the third thing is and I am guess speaking also as an employee uh that we were as employee certified and licensed staff are required to attend uh trainings and meetings including a a half hour video and there that's my three minutes but if you I'll finish up um and then a presentation by otus and tspc I want to be assured that also you as mandatory reporters by law that you have received and are receiving the same uh training uh the same amount that you are requiring of your employees and that same training be required of every single person who has an administrative or you know other

012role in in the district thank you thank you next we have Abigail Christner on behalf of another or is that Ashley Miss Christner Ashley of the topic is on behalf of another hi am Ashley krer I am a resident of St cins I have two students in the high school um glad to have an opportunity to speak to you tonight and while I have plenty to say myself I feel like it's more important that I share a letter on behalf of another parent who has effectively been silenced by the district um and that and what I'm not going to repeat that okay um hello thank you for hearing from you today I have a few questions how are you paying for the extra individuals brought in to assist our district how long are their contracts

013Northwest Regional Educational Service District is an agency of St Helen School District essentially employees um whom in the past provided substitutes and IAS financially the ESD is partially funded through contracts they hold with the district they have a relationship with the District that benefits them how are they able to provide non-biased services to the district why have you hired admin or former superintendant to do the investigations that are not truly third parties since they are found and employed through the Northwest Regional Educational Service District why have you not employed True Detectives who made the decision on hiring all outside individuals and why were they not brought to the community for transparency before the decision was made please explain how Mr dap was vetted whom he resigned yesterday after the community found felony embezzlement charges out

014of California are you pulling National background reports or just State please explain the process in detail placing responsibility on a secondary sourcing like the estd is not an option were you given more than one name to choose from for this position and if so who made the deciding factor if you relied on why did you not do diligence before blindly stepping in and hiring him do you see how you're hiring somebody with a history of embezzlement makes things look worse and the community loses further trust in your ability to make decisions especially when there are large discrepancies in the district's financials how will you prevent this from happening in the future in what ways are you supporting and working with detectives Otis tspc within the schools how are you protecting teachers including substitutes who come

015forward or want to come forward to O tspc the detectives and public forums like board meetings without retribution which includes bullying being let go from your job or pulling them into the principal's office with a secretary present who takes notes while they claim parents are calling in concerned about them working with their children after they spoke out against abuse at the last board meeting at the last board meeting and whose daughter received a standing ovation by many of said parents what steps are you taking to ensure that these things will not and are not going to continue to happen in detail how are you currently addressing bullies in the schools how are you supporting those bullied in bathrooms how many teachers are currently on leave or under investigation from all investigative parties who and how

016many are under investigation for financial crimes please explain in detail why a 34628 staff count sorry I'm new to this and fiscal data including her pupil count used in table from 2021 to 2022 do not line up with the 78,000 and 300,000 spent on fingerprinting we could have fingerprinted the entire Community with that amount do you charge incoming staff for their finger printing concerning the consent agenda please go into as much detail as possible with an explanation for how the board voted and why she outlines the consent agenda so again those were the uh questions posed by another parent in the community somebody who feels that her voice has been silenced uh her life has been turned upside down by the actions of the district and the board and she's been completely alienated her child

017is a victim thank you thank you our next comment is from Gina regarding Tom the laap and Steve web good evening everybody uh my name is Gina STS I'm a resident of St Helens my daughter did previously go to the high school and transferred to CCE Cena Plymouth High School um my question is uh why didn't you do a background on the lab to find this information why did it take somebody like me a really nobody who doesn't get out there and do all this stuff and protest but now I am I had to do the background check you should be doing your diligence on every student and or every teacher that comes to the school a teaches around these children that you are supposed to be protecting how do you not do your due

018diligence I mean I'm a nobody and I can do this information and find this information out on my own and I've done one on every one of you members including the CFO how can she be a CFO when she's got tax issues of her own how do we trust her with the financial issues we're not talking about people's thank you and then Mr dap how can we trust your expertise we know you have expertise we get that we want somebody with expertise but how can we trust you when you during your tenure you had issues in the Vancouver School Public Schools violating state law how can we trust you to do what right for this school district when you didn't do a right for Vancouver Betty Bundy and is it ID advisory councel Council Outreach

019until if I missed that please confirm my handwriting is atrocious so that's fine so is this then on behalf of a group yes okay thank you so my name is Betty Bundy um and I am the director for Advocate access Northwest I'm gonna let my friends introduce themselves did you say you were co-chairman of the CTE advisory committee thank you we could probably pass the microphone around do you think we can move it thank you by um uh yeah and I'm Jacob sandine and um I went to all of the the Helen schools and yeah my name's Jenny Fields um I'm a parent of kids in every school in the school district and I'm also a member of the um intellectual and developmental disabilities Council all right so we gathered here today just wanted to

020um talk to the board um representing the columia county intellectual and developmental disabilities advisory Council this Council was formed in March of 2024 and consists of indiv individuals who experience a disability family members and professionals we are a dedicated group Committed to seeing positive change in special education programs and are ready to help make that happen it's important to remember that any of us or our children could experience a disability at any moment due to illness or an accident at any point we could lose our ability to speak or complete our daily routines independently this reality underscores the importance of the robust and supportive educ ational system for all students please remember this as you consider a request right now many parents find it challenging to send their children to school due to the loss

021of trust imagine how much harder it is for those parents who have children who cannot verbally Express when something is wrong these parents live with a constant fear that their child's needs are not being met and those voices are not being heard the idg advisory council is eager to collaborate with each district in Columbia County to support teachers administrative employees and students we believe that having the opportunity in partnership with the ID program to be part of um facilitating um working sorry with um faculty and staff meetings would be a greatly benef great benefit to the students and their support systems we're asking this as this collaboration would provide teachers with the tools and knowledge they need to support students with disabilities effectively many teachers have a approach the ccel asking for training on how

022to best support students who do need accommodations these teachers want to empower their students and help them succeed in their educational goals additionally many children in special education cannot verbally communicate their needs as stated before and adding an additional layer of fear to those parents by working together we can alleviate some of these fears and create a more inclusive and supportive environment for all students our only request is to open up have an open discussion on how safe hel School District the ID advisory Council and the ID program can collaborate to benefit students with disabilities the council intends to make another attempt um to open this discussion directly with the School Employees but we would really appreciate the support of the board moving forward the council has agreed that we stand with the students of

023of St Helens and we hope the board and Community will Contin continue to commit to standing by all students thank you thank you [Music] Laura Moore protecting students safety and addressing concerns ask the board how you are protecting I'm assuming this is the statement you wish to make hi I'm Laura Moore I'm a parent to three high schoolers a middle schooler and a preschooler I come to you today as a parent I'm going to read to you what I wrote good evening I'm here today as a concerned parent to ask the board how you are protecting our children under this current circumstances first I want to address the situation involving Eric Sterns who is facing multiple charges including sexual assault and misdemeanors despite these serious allegations Sterns victims including my children are expected to continue

024attending school in the same environment where his office is located to make matters worse the school is referring to his room which includes his office as their safe room or safe space how can a safe space connected to Sterns be considered safe for victims and how does this ensure their safety and emotional well-being second I want to bring to your attentions incidents reported by my daughter on two separate occasions last Friday and this Monday why my daughters and other girls were changing in the girls locker room for wrestling male adults and students entered the girls locker room these incidents occurred while the girls were undressing despite the seriousness of these violations no calls were made to families of the students who reported these offensive how is the school addressing Suns blaton breaches of student safety

025and privacy students especially Sterns victims are protected from such invasion of their privacy are they as apparent I'm deeply troubled by the lack of proactive measures communication and accountability in these situations referring to a room tied to an individual under investigation as a safe space is unacceptable and is retraumatization for his victims furthermore allowing incidences like these in the locker room to occur without immediate action sends a message that student safety and well-being are not a priority I urge the board to take immediate action meaningful action to address these issues to ensure the physical and emotional safety of all students and to communicate transparently with families and help much concerns will be resolved moving forward thank you venturing Dorne Allison do never say her name right uh and hiring criminals and known abusers hi I

026started doing research too on individuals I started with my son's school decided to start at the top with the principal Allison debuk first thing that pops up is a lawsuit back in 2018 uh Batista versus the Beaverton School District Allison debuk was the principal or assistant principal at the time she was involved in a lawsuit because they were not protecting the students from Bowling it became severe so severe that the student and their parents filed a lawsuit for $100,000 nothing came of the lawsuit and nothing happened to anybody at that school nobody was reprimanded nothing was reported everything went on like normal and then who do we hire for McBride Elementary Allison debuk why why did she come to St Helens why did she leave a high school I I'm under the impression that people

027work their way up Elementary School is kind of like the bottom I could be wrong I don't know Robert Fink was an amazing principal absolutely loved him Allison debuk absolute joke I don't know if you guys are aware there's all kinds of bowling going down down at McBride and nothing is being done my son was being bullied I finally had to March into that office and tell them I was done that child lays one more hand on my kid that's it and then something was done but that child still continues to hit punch push and get away with whatever they want and it happens a lot it's happening rampant what I want to know is why are we becoming known as the place that hires pedophiles if a teacher has a sexual assault history in

028their past we don't seem to be aware of this do districts not talk to districts do you guys not look up disciplinary actions reperations do you not Google your employees I'm seriously confused because you're pushing out good teachers like Miss Sher Lee at the special ed program at McBride life skills classroom was absolutely amazing you have teachers and students and community members crying for her to come back because Allison debuk has completely shredded the special ed program it is a glorified daycare and they're not even getting that right children are being neglected sent home in dirty diapers and she does not care she's getting rid of the good Aid anyone who stood by Miss Sherry's side she rearranged their classrooms took away their work tubs took away their schedules they have no structure they're getting

029around the building and running without any supervision they're outside of the building running around and one was brought back by a neighbor who got loose in the neighborhood this is special needs children who cannot advocate for themselves we don't know what happens to them we rely on adults reporting to us my daughter was in Miss Sherry's Le uh Miss Sherry Lee's classroom for four years and Miss Sherry Lee changed her life and absolutely loves my daughter and my family and we love her this is unacceptable this is an elementary school Allison debuk needs to go immediately it's coming out nobody likes her nobody wants her there she's a real problem can you guys do the right thing stop employing people who are dangerous to our children people who do not report abuse Allison debuk does

030not report abuse she does not report bowling she does not report neglect get it together what you're doing doesn't work you've got to change everything there's no accountability no check and balance and we've had it we're not dumb and we're super upset about the pr situation wow we are not dumb it was really easy to find dirt on him real easy and a lot of it so much so he resigned thank you Mr you've got to get it together coms this one that's it okay we'll move to 4.0 consent agenda the board on an individual basis prior to the meeting has reviewed all material all Financial reports are available for review by the public in the business office the board considers consent agenda items routine business and will be enacted by the board in one

031motion there will be no discussion of these items at the time the board votes on the motion unless members of the board staff or public request specific items to be discussed Andor removed from the consent agenda well I understand that there was a uh comment related to that there was no specificity to that so I'll move for the consent agenda to be approved I accept the consent agenda stated second I will second okay it's been moved and seconded does anybody have any comments no all those in favor say I I I I it's been moved seconded and approved number 5.0 discussion 5.1 board vacancy appointment process so we have a open position on the board we have a policy on the open position of the boards um so it is policy BBE and vacancies will

032be filled through board appointment the board appointee must be a legally registered voter and a resident within the district for one year immediately preceding the appointment in the event of multiple vacancies the position vacated first will be filled first upon appointment by the board the newly appointed board members will be sworn and seated immediately if the offices of a majority of board members are vacant at the same time the directors of the Northwest Education Service District shall appoint persons to fill the vacancies from qualified District voters Board elections are held every odd numbered year which for the purposes of this policy are termed election years the appointee will serve in until June 30th following the next election at which time the individual elected in May of that year will fill the remaining portion of an

033unexpired term or serve a four full four-year term or serve until June 30th of a subsequent election year if the vacancy occurs after the filing date in an election year a board member so elected as a replacement will serve the remaining years of the term of office of the board member being replaced that's the policy the OS 341 335 uh on vacancy uh says that the board shall declare the office of a board member vacant if it finds any of the following the incumbent has died or resigned the incumbent has been removed or recalled from office or the election of the incumbent ther to has been declared void by the Judgment of a court the incumbent has ceased to be a resident of the district from which the incumbent was nominated or elected the incumbent

034has ceased to discharge the duties of office for two consecutive months unless prevented therefore by sickness or other unavoidable cause or unless excused by the chairperson of the board a board member who is nominated are elected by Zone and who changes permanent residence from one zone of a district to another zone or who may by a change in zone boundaries no longer reside in the zone of nomination or election is entitled to continue to serve as board member until June 30th following the next regular district election at which a successor will shall be elected by the electors to serve for the remaining of the unexpired term when a vacancy is De declared under subsection one of this section the remaining board members shall meet and appoint a person to fill the vacancy from any of

035the electors of the district if the position is filled is one filled by both nomination and election at large and otherwise from any of the electors of the Zone from which the vacancy occurs so filling a vacant board position there are uh different oper different options that we have to be able to uh follow through with this uh selecting candidates the law contains no guideline for selecting potential candidates to fill a vacant board position the statutes do do provide qualifications however applicants for vacant positions must be registered voters and residents of the district for one year immediately prior to the appointment me the college board members are exempt from the one-year residency citizens who meet these residency requirements in their District prior to its merger with another District are eligible to serve on the board

036or budget Committee of the merged District um Oregon districts commonly use the following three methods to fill vacancies the board encourages citizens who live in the district to give their names to the chief executive officer within a specified period the board then screens all of the applicants and makes selections of suitable candidates if the board interviews candidates it must do so in public meetings the board May appoint a committee to select and submit two or three names to the board for final action the board should receive a list of all candidates from which the community made its final selection if a local advisory committee already exists the board May instruct it to carry on a screening process if these methods are not satisfactory to a board it may develop its own selection process electing Replacements

037the board must make its final selection of a replacement any public meeting recording in the minutes how each member voted term of office for replacement the person who fills a vacancy serves until June 30th following the next regular district election which takes place in May of odd-numbered years that election an individual is elected to serve either the unexpired portion of the four-year term or in newon for your turn there's a selection of interview questions there on here that the board would select to be able to ask that we can use um and then we can go to the rest of that pack there yes filling a vacant board uh position requires a public discussion as directed by 92.6 60 uh the question for this may answer some our board will be interviewing three candidates to

038fill one vacant position on our board due to a resignation while all interview conversations must be completed in public it is difficult to talk about the applicants in public you have any advice for school board as it launches into this very public process so yes filling a board position requires a public discussion as directed by 92660 and yes this can be a difficult discussion well not required we recommend that the board adopt a if you can't say anything nice don't say anything agreement in order to avoid public embarrassment with this practice each current board member speaks in favor of their preferred candidates by their silence they indicate who they do not support as each board member takes a turn to comment you able to tell where things are headed additional comment rounds are made if

039necessary to narrow the field in every case the focus is on the positive points about the C inance so provide some process as far as how the board will do that so that is the process of uh noticing the vacancy and then moving forward we've had I think three of these in the last 10 years that I can recall uh we've had a fairly prescribed process that we've used over the course of time uh we have guidance from the states so at this point we have a couple different options that we can do as the board socks I'm open I'm I just think that we should move quickly to get someone on the board I I think somewhere in our notes there was a some deadlines and the timeline set out for applicants to fill

040out an application and I I think that's a reasonable process but first thing we need to do is declare a board vacancy uh and I even though there is one I I think that there's actually a motion in our notes to declare a board vacancy and once we declare it then we set up the process but I think the application process so that people that are interested or maybe folks here that are interested that then they can um fill out the application and get all their information in so that then we can make a a each view their information and then have a public discussion U whether we use a committee or how you do it that's up to you but I think that we need to move ahead and I think that our timeline

041was to have that done by what first meeting in January would be that so the proposed timeline is tonight board discussion on appointment process December 12th application posted then announced December 23rd the application window closes giving approximately two weeks put yourself up to the mic a little bit December 30th through January 6th will be the review and screening of applicants and then on January 8th applicants are invited for interviews board interview an appointment action and Open Session So the plan is to at the next regularly scheduled meeting on January 8th conduct and complete the interviews and then appoint so since they didn't really hear what was your timeline on applicants open after declaration and when is the deadline to turn in an application so tonight's the discussion December 12th application is actually posted and announced

042December 23rd the application window closes and then December 30th through January 6th would be the review and screening of the applicants uh January 8th would be when we would conduct the interview so by Janu by December 23rd then they would have to have an application in correct can they do it for I mean like online to us since that is also a holiday as far as um emailing it yeah we should be able to accommodate a hard copy and an electronic copy submission are are fingerprints required as there a school board a school volunteer background check in general do we have background checks and fingerprinting we do so that would happen after the apply that then they would do that or does that they don't have to do that before they apply but between the

04323rd and the 8th then somewhere those folks sit typically before they're sworn in yeah okay I just a matter of of process I I do advise the board entertaining a motion to declare the vacancy yes that's that was so I move we declare vacancy well let's finish this and is there actually a position number on that one it is it's position three position okay so I move we declare position three vacant I think TR wanted to carry on the discussion first well we'll finish the discussion and then we'll move to action items and and yeah we'll amend at that uh can can we get double confir confirmation on the background and the fingerprinting as it's an elected position typically those are not gone through at the time of election uh but if it's an appointment

044then does that change the process I'll get back to you thank you any other questions or comments on where we're at with the board position I think it just depends on how many applicants we get if we want to pre-screen and run them through a committee where any process so that we can bring however many you want to the board I would recommend that we create a subcommittee and that we invite at least one potential member of the community likely someone that's already in an elected position or something of that at least invite it uh so that there's a third party that's outside of us that's screening the applicants um and providing them their list of um would we say three to interview I think that's typical I it's a I think we can do

045what we like if we want to have more or less right do we have a number that we would prefer to interview on that night you believe the last time we had five that affected think a couple times I whe we get that many or not so historically we've gotone at least five I think so I think that's five have ran through the public meeting process okay any other thoughts on the process we let everybody know where they exactly would find this application online yeah we'll post it uh on the landing page of the District web page so we'll make that readily accessible and visible would would it be inappropriate to put that out also in parents were I'm sorry would it not would it not be appropriate to not only put it on the

046District web page but maybe uh at least the notice on parent Square so people we can certainly uh communicate that more broadly I mean that's our more engaged community so any further discussion before we get to the second portion of our comments I will entertain a motion to amend the agenda make a motion to amend the agenda to add a vacancy announcement for school board so first we complete the motion to amend then we amend yeah I'll move to I'll second the amendment okay motion has been moved and seconded all those in favor of amending the agenda say I I I I all right now that we've made that motion and uh completed that uh I'll entertain a motion to add action item 1.0 declare vacancy position three school board so move I'll second been

047moved and second in to add action item 1.0 on uh I think it would actually seven so we'll move seven down to eight uh all those in favor I now I move to declare vacancy position number three I second moov in second to declare position number three all those in favor I I okay that part of the business is done I have one comment card uh oh is there so we'll move to 6.0 visitors to address the boards uh as we uh stated at the beginning typically this is the time for comment comment on agenda items however we will wave that uh for today uh the board will not take any immediate action but will refer concerns to the superintendent and ask him to report to the board we appreciate you keeping comments to three

048minutes per individual or five minutes if to representing a group of patrons this portion of the meeting will not exceed 60 Minutes uh the first one of is Sarah Young uh regarding supposed new board members hi my name is Sarah Young um I live in scapoose but I have a student who transferred from the high school there to St Helen um because of bullying and after he transferred he was victimized this school year by a teacher um can you clarify please the process on how a new board member will be picked are you forming a committee amongst yourselves to pick the new board member this isn't an open Forum ma'am so we're listening to comments okay um yes we we will clarify that thank you I appreciate that um do you realize that the community

049has lost faith in your ability to do your job and the idea of you rushing to pick a new board member is highly highly concerning we have questions about numerous ethical issues um possible investigations to discuss Financial crimes and why there are huge discrepancies in in the budget and where money's gone you guys apparently that's I could go on but I'm not going to you need to resign next comment is from Stephanie croll apologies okay so I'm a mom down so I can hear you I'm a mom to a high school student and I've been fighting the school district for years for my son and been voiceless my kid was here bullied over and over I showed videos of him coming home wounds injuries nothing was ever done nobody advocated my voice nobody heard my

050voice okay as a mom I tell my son when he's done something wrong you need to apologize for it I want to know where your guys's apology is you know I want to know to the students where your apology is for allowing what is happening happened when do you guys stand up I mean you're adults you should know how to apologize and actually say to the students hey we messed up and this is what we're going to do to fix it and this is what we did wrong how are our kids going to learn from making mistakes if you aren't setting the example that's what we do at home with our kids right why AR you guys coming forward and apologizing to the community to the parents that you have literally failed by subjecting our

051kids to all this terrible stuff this bullying that I've been fighting for for years that literally just makes me so imputing because it's been going on for so long and through all of this I have yet to hear an actual sincere apology from any of you you in any way addressing the children creating an assembly to call upon the kids to say hey we are so sorry this happened to you and that you guys are scared and you don't feel safe where is the apology to the parents that we I love my child I would never put him in harm okay and when I put my kid on that school bus every morning I trusting you with my most precious things in this whole entire world having faith that you guys are going to keep

052him safe that he isn't going to come home with wounds mental wounds physical wounds screwing up my kid where's those apologies why why haven't none of you why have you apologized to the kids why haven't you addressed the kids why haven't you addressed the parents hey we're sorry it makes you all look guilty guilty guilty guilty all across the board because no nobody's owning it like literally so Scott SC Well's not here anymore Scott well guess what he's not the only one on the board so you know what you guys staying silent makes you look just as bad as him okay and without those freaking apologies basically it makes you look just as bad as him and Wagner literally it look makes it look just as bad the principal of this freaking school okay because

053I came I talked to the vice principal the principal the counselors I was on the phone every week I was in this school almost every week fighting for my kid nobody they didn't even record the reports that I put in when I saw my kids fight uh file it was empty and it wasn't until I came to the school and talked to the principal I said you know what if you're not going to protect my kid I've taught my kid his hands are for love and to do amazing things they're not to hurt but if they're not going to protect you then you're going to have to protect yourself I said another kid touches you you defend yourself and I promise you you won't be in trouble okay that very next week I came in

054here talked to the principal I told them what I gave my kid permission to do my kid ended up punching a kid for being bullied and I got called in here got to watch the video I was so proud of my kid for standing up for himself for the first time he felt Vindicated and we took that suspension and I took him out to dinner okay when I looked at that file I said where's the timeline I can fight you guys for years to do something to do something for my kid nothing was in that file up until time my kid assaulted another kid you don't get to pick and choose what you document everything should be documented and when you guys take responsibility with all these kids with mental illness drug issues suicide bringing

055guns to school when do you guys take respon any responsibility for that because it's not like they woke up just one second day and decided that they were going to do those things okay there was a whole timeline that came before that all the mental health that I put my kid through counseling everything to get my kid to where he is today that was all me you guys prepped me every way all the way down the road but I still made sure my kids see despite all of you okay and I want you guys to apologize I want you guys to stand up and do what we expect our children to do and own something own something about this because all you're doing is making yourself look just bad as the ones that aren't sitting

056up there anymore and it's not okay it's not okay and I'm I I'm so sick to my stomach over all of this finally my kid isn't in that place anymore but I'm standing coming up here right now so that the future moms and the children they get bullied and their moms are worried about their kid and where they're going to end up but they don't have to go through that you guys need to you need to document things you need to give a [ __ ] you need to care you need to take accountability and actually address these things and protect our kids these are our babies and I trusted you guys with my kid and you failed him over and over again and stop failing them stop failing we depend on you guys we pay your

057pay your wages to protect our kids this should have never happened it just shows complete Inc confidency you know STS tick toer Doug Weaver so for talking about apologies here I think each and every one of you owe a huge apology to Doug Weaver had it not been for him and his Tik toks none of us would have known about this none of us yes and especially you this will be the first warning yeah especially you I have screenshots of your gaslighting him on Facebook how shameful of you to Gaslight this man for bringing this to our attention yeah he doesn't have a mental illness you guys don't even know what a mental illness is do you cuz I'm looking at right now that concludes the public commenting section so Dr Webb as I've taken

058notes some of the things I'd like to oh okay need to out yes okay Kelly Smith parent comment thank you Kelly Joe Smith uh kumby County resident parent of many students within the district as well um over the many years that I have been a volunteer in this District I feel that I've always spoken up and advocated with a child first mindset I'd like to acknowledge that the board as the board you do provide oversite and you are not in the weeds it is your job not your job nor is it allowed for you to make the day-to-day operating decisions but as a board you can make pretty fast changes around the district's goals priorities budget and policy and as a parent I'd like to share that my family's experiences Echo the same shared messages

059with the many others here the concern for compassion and care that it is needed throughout our schools and during our strategic planning I was the parent that added compassion to our wayfinding messaging through our many experiences as a family I can share several examples that have happened just this calendar year for example I have referred to our high school as feeling like a prison or jail and I have expressed that it made me sick to my stomach to be in that environment I have stated that I felt that for the most part that the school could take care of my students physically but that they did not that I did not trust their environment emotionally whatsoever I have also countered through the correspondence that I felt like High School administration was dismissive as often I

060was frustrated and I did not feel listened to I have advocated for a structural study of the high school and I can be quoted for referring to our high school as sucky which I was a little embarrassed to express even though it was true then this week while I was at an a a state leadership conference leaders talked leaders from across state talked about sucky schools not by name of course but it gave some validation that communities across the state are experiencing the same issues within their schools we have a as a state we have been challenged with major Workforce shortages extreme student behaviors and increased liabilities regulations and requirements within our districts we must have the parent partnership that also means that we as parents must be willing to volunteer and engage so while

061this situation is heartbreaking I really do not feel upset that we are here I'm looking forward to the changes and I can agree the more changes needed it's refreshing and as I have done before I am advocating again for us to carefully consider other options for our high school we do have many caring and present teachers we have wonderful resilient students and we do have a lot of great things happening within our district but we also have this moment we have a moment where we can take a pause and consider what we want to do next I don't want to put all the pieces back together the way they were before as a parent I want us as a school Community to completely re imagine our school whatever they may be whatever it may be

062and I know your hearts and I know your intentions your dedication and I'd like to ask that the board and the community demonstrate our will together thank you okay so that will now conclude our public comments Dr Webb um there's one thing that uh through the course of both com comments and some of the experiences that I've had that I would like to have a report back so policy KL is the official pathway for complaints to the board I would like to know how we're messaging that to parents so that when they have concerns relative to decisions that are made at the building level and at the superintendent level whether they're given the correct instructions and support needed to be able to appropriately address the board to make a decision on anything related to those

063decisions there were a few other notes related to this uh that I believe we either have in our um response page uh but is there anything else out of the notes that You' feel we missed or that wouldn't be addressed through that we got a couple of parents i' like to connect with here at some point in the your ter okay yeah the other component is um typically we don't don't allow Personnel discussions inside of these meetings just for informational purposes if you have concerns about any Personnel matters please go to your buildings if you are not getting listened to there please go to the superintendent if you are not getting there please utilize policy KL which allows for us to take official action and that's now in the future and any retroactive concerns that

064you may have have so please go to the superintendent and address anything in that area yes okay we will move to 7.0 which is now action item declare vacancy for the board 1.0 position 3 declare vacancy I'll entertain a motion to declare so move I'll second it's been moved and seconded discussion all in favor say I I I and we will move to 7.0 upcoming meeting input which is the January 8th 2024 board work session I wanted to make a note on the uh public fors that we're doing where parents can talk can we post that as a public meeting as well uh so that we can all attend if we like so possible Quorum at the meetings is that okay thank you for these lisening sessions it was the plan to uh those facilitations

065be essentially with the superintendent and the facilitators and the board not present for those particular the initial plan was for the superintendent and the external facilitators to engage in those conversations with patrons with parents with students in attendance if it's the board's interest to also be in attendance we can certainly agendize that publicly and notice it or if we're clearly uh going with the mentality that it's only the high school parents that show up and only the Middle School parents show up I mean is that what you want us to do because I feel like I can attend two of them Tren can attend one they have grand we have grandparent duties over here but they could probably show up at at elementary if you want to do it that way we have two listening

066sessions scheduled for next week the 17th is for high school families the 18th is for Middle School families we're working on scheduling two additional uh school-based listening sessions after the winter break uh that will likely occur in the first week possibly the second week of January those will be Elementary level uh listening sessions we are also scheduling one Spanish speaking listening session of early in January as well the last time we did that it was very well attended it was it was very nice so I'm looking for direction here I no it it won't be noticed okay any other input I I do have a question if we were to get more than the five applications um do we do we invite everybody that night or do we need to Moet the headed time will

067we then reduce it to the tri how we go about that so there can be a subcommittee created through the superintendent to be able to invite possibly that third party and then one board member can review um so those things can be figured out for the screening purposes and then uh once the candidates are presented as meeting the qualifications all of those other things um we we have said five is our number so if there's more than five applicants then that screening committee would then engage to reduce that to five based on whatever criteria um is used as far as that goes okay so um maybe what we can do is because there's Christmas break prior there's only the two days but at least to note that um if we have the applications in more

068than that amount just said on the 7eventh um six or S is going to have to be that meeting between the different people that TR will suggested to put together have those applications right so the subcommittee can uh interview those and score them individually they don't have to communicate and then it would be a scoring Criterion based on whatever rubric is used and then they don't have to communicate they just go through the scoring then it's objective on scoring I just want to make sure we were kind of clear on the dates when even that c would um at a got it okay any other input and this meeting is adjourned thank you everybody got some

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.