CorpusRecord 7025

January 14th, 2025 Alpine School District Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School Board Livestream Service Account
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Utah County, UT
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,671 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-05-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e we're officially starting our study session superintendent thank you president King appreciate that appreciate everyone being here appreciate our transportation department we'll turn some time over to Eric Woodhouse executive director of operations that he can introduce his team okay so I was really excited to be able to um have my team present this presentation because we we really had this ready for our last session but recognized that we needed something more inse but I think what we're trying to do in the spirit of the reconfiguration is to really kind of dive in and just take a look at what this would look like for each one of our districts we recognize that there's probably still a lot of details that we need to work through but we don't really know what those details

002are unless we start exploring and so this is our um attempt at to begin exploring exactly what those numbers look like it's one thing to go from a wide lens and look at it from that perspective but as you start getting granular we're starting to find that there are a lot of different nuances to transportation that we really want to flesh out what those nuances are so that we can start to find problems for that so keep that in mind I did email you um a copy of this presentation so you've got that as viewer so you there are any questions you don't need to take pictures of the slides you have access to it and then as we start going through it if there are questions um if we can answer those questions as

003we start to go through the presentation please just feel free to ask those if it feels better that we wait till the end then we can ask them then as well if it's a question that we're not quite sure what we have the answer to yet that's great write it down and we will find the answer so with that uh just want to introduce the team Joe David and Rex um I'm not sure Joe are you presenting with David or no uh David and Rex will be presenting today and doing the bulk of the present uh presenting but just so you know um they will be going and giving you a little bit of history and context so as we start talking about reconfiguration that you have just kind of a little bit of background

004as what Transportation looks like and exactly what we do and I think that'll help you understand as we get into that you know what things may look like part of the presentation Sox you have the clicker first uh no actually havecker first clicker over to you hi welcome thanks for having us back um my name's David I'm in the East Transportation Hub and then I'm Rex's Junior companion and we also have a team of 300 bus drivers 80 bus attendants who work before the sun rises they go home after the sun sets they're led by about 25 instructors and trainers were're kept on the road by 16 mechanics uh and not only are they very safe we just had a highway patrol inspection we have about 360 buses and they found only three that were

005put out of service not only are they very safe they're also very efficient the national average per mile costs a131 to R and our number comes in a little bit lower than that at a126 and for a little bit of fun information the state reimburses us back $17 per eligible mile to review our department goals we're looking to recruit and retain drivers reduce employee absenteeism reduce accidents double runs and not eligible routes so when we're not chasing down accidents or trying to fix routes this is what we think about we also owe you guys a great deal of gratitude for the help you've helped us or sent us with our retention efforts that's the attendance incentives we provide drivers new paid train training for bus drivers and then those referral bonuses and this is a

006graph of our average drivers over the years you can see that we peaked in about 2019 2020 and then in 22 23 is where we hit our lowest point in average drivers that's also the year we started the driver incentive and you can see we're starting to climb back out not quite where we want to be but we see a positive trend over the last three years so that's a a pretty good quick overview of of our department our team uh now we're going to talk about some uh some numbers some implications for the reconfiguration talk about legislative language definitions uh state report all the information we're taking is or speaking about comes from the 23 24 school year um so the state says that we are only able to collect reimbursement from eligible routes

007but they don't do a very good job explaining what route means so we we kind of have a little bit of Liberty to in that and and and this is how we Define it so we have riders that show up at stops bus drivers pick them up at stops those stops then equate to runs and then a collection of runs means a route okay so just to make it a little bit more easy to understand you have a high school starts early in the morning the high school have a a number of stops where kids collect and we we pick them up from the high school then they're dropped off at the high schools and then they go and pick up their Junior High kids at a variety of stops and then the same thing

008for elementary schools then in the after that that makes up their morning route in the afternoon turn around and do the same thing pick up the high schoolers take them home pick up the junior highs take them home pick up the elementary kids take them home and that makes up their afternoon route okay so let's talk about eligible stops then uh what is an eligible stop so any student that lives a mile and a half or more from an elementary school is eligible and any high school or Junior High kid who lives two or more miles from the school their their secondary school they are also eligible for transportation special ed 504 it's a little bit different they qualify per IEPs or committee and that's how they're deemed as eligible writers so continue on what's

009an eligible run regular speaking we have to have at least 10 eligible regular writing students for it to be an eligible run special Le goes they have there has to be at least five regular writing students uh to make it eligible as well so we have stop One Stop two stop three maybe 11 writers or more it says up there three writers five writers three writers well we have some stops that are up around 60 students per stop it's kind of crazy to watch those cats be hurted so um there are some limited parameters from the state for eligible routes meaning what's not eligible what's a what's a non-eligible bus stop so if it's if we deem that a stop or an area is hazardous the state not to be mean they don't care it

010doesn't it's not funded right uh meaning no safe walking path or lack of sidewalks Etc uh courtesy but stops they do allow us to put those on qualifying routes we as long as it's in route to the school and there's not deviation to get to that stop all right so so that does qualify or does not the route does qualify okay the stop yes because the route qualifies as long as it's just one single that doesn't deviate from from that but you're paid by Route not by riter so a courtesy stop is not going to increase the funding that's why they're neutral on okay so proposed metrics counting ridership at El stops is more reliable than counting runs or routes so that's what we this whole presentation is is going to be done on on

011writers ship rather than routes and runs let's take a look at numbers our district has 218 bus routes made up of 1,154 runs made up of over 6,000 bus stops and we transport nearly 18,000 students every single day and as a fun note last year we did 8,000 activities that's field trips sporting events and our bus has traveled over 3 million miles so these are some big numbers we pull these numbers from our state report in the schools they do an October 1 count we do a similar thing where we ask bus drivers to count heads at stops and then we submit that to the state and then they fund US based off of those numbers per percentage divided by the pot we don't know what the percentage will be until they tell us uh

012we estimate that to be about 80% is what we expect back and then this uh these numbers that we're about to go over don't include summer school um we do about 20 in Li of which means we pay their transportation because we can't provide it Sun Crest also B drivers and then also activities so out of the 86,000 students in our district 24,000 are eligible for busing leaving 61,000 who are not eligible for busing if you cross-section that 24,000 we transport almost 15,000 eligible students and on the other side we estimate about about 3,000 not eligible students who ride our buses and the way we found that is we counted the number of students at not eligible stops in that October count that brings our total to nearly 18,000 students now if you divide that

013bite area this is what the numbers look like so if we look at reconfigured districts it would break down West would have 6,000 Riders Central eight and South almost four if we go one step lower eligible breaks like this for each area and you may look at the South and say they have a higher percentage of ineligible Riders and that's true but also what is true is that every district will need to take on uh or look at what they're going to do with ineligible Riders this is a problem for all of us so if we look at percentage counting all Riders eligible and not eligible West makes up 35% % Central 45 and 20 for South however if we look at only eligible that adjusts slightly West increases to 38% Central stays the same

014and South decreases 3% and these are the numbers we're going to use for the rest of this presentation for allocation of resources and staff and uh actually we brought a little hand out so you have all these numbers at your fingertips you don't have to remember anything if you don't mind passing excellent so division of assets we have 360 buses currently 30 of which are in the Boneyard which means they're sitting for either Surplus or repair if we take that 364 divided by the percentage of eligible Riders this is how those would break out and be divided if we look at Personnel we have drivers assuming we can perfectly place them in three new districts by percentage this is how those would break out we support two offices with 21 FTE by percentage that's how

015those would break out and then we have a mechanic shop service center and some floating mechanics out west this is how those would break out so the age-old question is can new districts conduct business as us ual with the allocated resources we can't answer that directly but here are some numbers to help you if you look at West we estimate they'll be given 77 routes in order or they'll need 77 routes in order to conduct business as usual this is not including activities this is just to school and from school they'll get 114 drivers if we're able to divide drivers perfectly and 1138 buses Central looks like this South is a little more tight it looks like this now these bus allocations include Bone Yard buses they do not include buses we're about to ask

016for for next year so if South has 61 buses given to them some of those buses will be Boneyard buses and will need significant repair before they're on the road and you want to assume um about 10% of your Fleet is in repair or being service at any given time so we're looking at just south those numbers are a little bit tight and then um one of our big concerns is one of the ways we've been able to inflate the West is we allow drivers to Park East and Drive West meaning someone lives in Pleasant Grove they don't want to commute out to West Lake so we allow them to come to the east compound pick up a bus and then drive a West Route so it's less efficient for us but we've been able

017to and we can estimate about 50 drivers we've been able to inflate the West about 50 drivers because they're able to um commute on their bus and get paid for that so that's one of our big worries going forward and splitting looking at the West is do we have enough drivers to allocate for those new districts all right so we'll talk now a little bit about our budget and how we collect revenue and some expenditures as well so we're set up as a service to schools we operate in a deficit to maximize the benefit two schools and and patrons so through the 20123 24 school year we generated a uh a revenue of 15 million and about about 15.4 million uh we added to that school fees like for field trips Athletics things like that

018at $1.4 million and uh and then on top of that we we collect test testing fees from our new drivers when they go through the new driver class we test them internally and we charge them $100 for the test and equates to about $8,000 and for a total of about $16.8 million then uh so that with that then we have our expenses of about $2.7 million which gives us a deficit of just just under $4 million uh that's because we supplement the District supplements a lot of our ineligible routes as well as activity trips and field trips then we put into that also the capital which is buses the uh the camera systems the radios the tablets that come with those new buses and for a total of about $6.2 million deficit so other large

019expense well all the large expenses in addition we have uh salaries and benefits we pay our employees fuel costs about 1.6 $6 million a year and Bus Repair and maintenance about $1.4 million a year and software maintenance and agreements at 300,000 a year uh of the salaries and benefits 67% of that is dedicated to our drivers 29% contracted 30% 37% hourly support staff mechanics office custodial at 31% and administration uh just 2% so upcoming Capital means that we are just in the process of of submitting uh our radio repeaters are on the fritz I mean that's that's how we communicate with our drivers and our drivers with us and drivers with each other uh they are on the way out so to replace those about $4,000 and once those are replaced with a new company

020that's cheaper and better it would benefit both sides of the district they'll have a repeater West they'll have a repeater East so when it comes to dividing the District there's that benefit already in place we have 29 buses like David said they're in the Boneyard that's really the cemetery uh it's where we put the buses that are very very old expensive to repair and put on the road and it's going to cost somewhere between $100 for a battery and 80,000 for a new engine okay uh but we would like to see around 50 new buses for a cost of about $10 million for next year and again those are assets that can be easily divided between the districts but it's something that we need to look at immediately if if possible West service center thorn

021in the S side I know we've been talking about this for years and years and it's kind of not happened for a variety of reasons still it's something that's very very necessary for uh for that west side of the current District as well as what will be the West District when the split actually happens you guys saw these slides last week we covered three strategies for reconfiguration the first idea was let's keep everyone together we'll call that unified Transportation another idea is a tier transition where we slowly move into it and then the third option was a clean split everyone on their own the unified transportation is where everyone works together and we have some kind ofou between the future districts however there are a lot of questions that come with that who buys buses

022who maintains who hires who fires how do we navigate that the other idea was a clean split everyone on their own immediately however when you look West they need a service center and when you look South they need everything as far as facilities so a tier transition what if West splits off immediately and then Central and South stay together until South is able to split off on their own what could that look like well West has these three they lack a service center perhaps West could contract with or have anou with Central to continue servicing buses perhaps they could lease a space and set up a temporary service center or perhaps we pull the trigger on a West service center and then that takes care of the issue for the West Side looking Central and

023South the combined uh two districts would have everything perhaps Central could act as a central managing partner perhaps Central could act as a managing partner come up with some kind of agreement for shared costs uh they would need to coordinate calendars to a certain degree where they're sharing Transportation they would need to coordinate calendars B schedules Etc we took a field trip you have some of these details from last week we found that cash had 80% and Logan 20% of an agreement that they currently operate on cash is the managing partner they hire and train they uh coordinate all the routes they maintain the office and then Logan buys the buses and then gives them to cash to manage and then at the end of the year they take all their expenses for that year

024Logan cuts a check for 18% of those costs and sends it to cash and that's their agreement they currently don't have any crossover meaning Logan buses service Logan routes if we were to look at that and if we did have crossover this is just a double down on the importance for similar calendars so what could this look like for us this is a very rough estimation these numbers um I'm looking at Jason a little bit Nar these are just current numbers divided by percentage so there's a lot that could go into this that could change every single number but if we take the current split of in out and deficit and we divide it by percentage of eligible writers the different areas would have this to look at and perhaps what you could say is

025well if West goes off on their own and that's a separate issue right now if you look at Central and South maybe what happens is at the end of the year South cuts a check for the deficit buys their own buses and transportation costs them a million dollars a year that's just kind of how you would interpret these numbers more question yes please so these split numbers are they based on the number of students in each distri district or the number of eligible Riders they're based on the eligible Riders so this is 17% this is 45% and this is 38% based on eligible writers ship and the reason we did eligible writers ship is the legislation language says State supported route and we interpret that as what does the state pay us for and that's

026this was there a followup yes please I had a question David on your upcoming need slide you had listed the 29 buses needing repair and then you had 50 new buses is it either that or is it either or or and are you saying that's going to be about over five million in costs with the 50 new buses so with the Boneyard they are there for a reason they're very expensive to to re repair and maintain so they're not really coming out they they're not however they could be at a cost that doesn't make a lot of sense so I think Julie could probably use them for books I could I could refurbish those RS do you have anything that compares this with the in ones we're currently doing um help me understand more so

027like this this is just eligible writer so how many other writers do we like that we're transporting now so what would that cost be I just need like another oh sorry Transportation budget slide 51 so you're saying like based on current information and not just eligible writers because I think that people in general don't know how many ineligible writers we have so I would just love to be able to see this is what it would be an eligible then a column look this is you're currently transporting the would not fall under this yeah we could take a look at that tricky because some of them are just being picked up as part of an eligible route I understand so yeah so it gets a little tricky with them sometimes difficult to know in a in

028a qualifying stop how many ineligible students are being dropped off walking to it's hard you know I have very packed buses yes other questions before we go on Sarah did your question get answered though as far as is it a 50 million or is it the whatever it was to do the 29 buses yeah I mean if you get the 50 million will you need to do the 29 buses wait is it wait a second is it 10 million for 50 buses because you just said 50 million in my head exp million million for 50 yeah 50 bus please don't transpose those numbers those are really nice buses if you buy today I mean with the understanding that we really appreciate the new buses because a variety of reasons it brings the maintenance and operations

029cost down the repair cost and uh the the age of the fleet remains lower and it just it doesn't make a lot of sense to repair those buses they are there for a reason they they've seen their life it's time to so if that gets through the budget process then you just dispose excess of the we Surplus Surplus and that's where I come in I'm just kidding so would that be an additional request the following year like I'm just wondering if you're saying we're replacing 50 buses potentially this year we going to talk about another 50 the following year or what what's the right number as far as replacement to get all the districts in a solid place good question um I it probably would not rise to the level of 50 again next year

030another thing we're looking at this that complicates it a little bit we we used to need drivers to put in our buses we're getting close to the point where we really need buses to put these new drivers in because we've seen the upswing that we're hiring which is wonderful we love it but I hate to get to the point and say we can't hire you I don't have anything for you to drive so no I I think there will still be a request for buses next year probably not to the level of 50 like give me a ball par like9 okay I'm just wondering is you're talking about you know 10% in repair at any time and how many we have in the Boneyard is it 50 this year and then maybe you get 35

031and then you ask for 50 again next year and maybe you get 35 and 70 would be close enough I'm just wondering like cuz I know how the budget process works you're not going to get what you asked for what sorry to break no yeah that that's probably very accurate guess and I think we could sorry Mark we could go back to that slide and say okay this is if we divided them three ways this is where we're at this is where we would be tight because you're saying probably you need additional 10 to 15% that are not being just for that flexibility so this this would cover all of your routes and then here's your Flex amount remember each district will need more buses for the simple fact we cross over and that's not

032just special ed Polaris and Summit some of our routes especially West to Central cross over between schools junior high high school elementary and so that's really a deflated number we will need more than than that shows so in the budget process it would be nice to know like hey in three years we'd like to be at this number because then I think that would help us better plan how many we really can do this year and then maybe next year so talked to some other districts that like they maintain their buses at some commercial uh you know repair facility uh how does that compare I think one of the things they mentioned is it's kind of hard because we would give it higher priority right and getting that bus fixed on the road someplace else

033they'd have to get it in line with other work they have to do have you thought about that or the cost comparison or we do yeah we do think about that a lot in conversations with our Fleet manager to Outsource not only do you not have priority it's much more expensive much much more costly if we can have a mechanics within in-house do it it's number one we know the quality work they do number two it's a higher priority and three it costs significantly less I I don't have the numbers to show it but I think I think right now you only have like two major repair hubs in the state right you've got rush and you've got Bryson that do major repairs on buses and they're I mean that's only two companies for the

034entire state where these buses are primarily going and so you're just you're another bus in that queue of all these other districts larger districts like ours has a fleet of mechanics you know Davis Jordan all the big districts do the smaller districts are the ones that tend to send or Outsource all of their buses to like a shop like that to get them repaired because it's just not cost effective for them to keep a mechanic you know or several mechanics full-time would make more sense to do that so I think the size of the three districts especially if you keep South and Central together you'd still want shops and you'd still want to do as much repair in house as you can and maybe another plug for new buses they come with warranties and that

035keeps that that maintenance and repair costs down and at least one of the shops comes to us for for a lot of the the warranty work we don't have to even take the bus to them they come to us which is very very nice and Beyond just repair we're not thinking only accidents there's continuing maintenance preventative work half of our Bays right now are preventative work we're thinking oil changes tires fluids that kind of thing so it's more than just we had an accident we have to deal with it or a road call we have to deal with it um lots of preventive maintenance goes on in as well did you say 10% is what we need like yeah you need about 10% in reserve for service repair and buses being out for those I

036think one of the things with our district that we've seen is the number of buses is certainly dependent again upon the number of drivers and we have 28 routes right now but when we had those High driver numbers at one time we had like 268 routes so we had a lot more routes because we had a lot more drivers and then we didn't have to do things like double runs we didn't have to you know have some of our buses be as crowded as they currently are that larger driver number gave us that opportunity to do more things in transportation so we've we've dropped as low as like right at 200 so our district hasn't trunk in size but we've had to become more efficient because we had you know a huge drop in drivers

037so instead of having 268 routes a few years ago we were down to like 204 routes 205 routes and we gradually began to grow that back out again as we've hired and retained more bus drivers other questions for for this slide I'm going to ask one more question so I suppose it's possible to just contract the whole transportation thing right and get a vendor that will just buy the buses um maintain them how how does that compare yeah we don't have numbers but we have a story okay that's the way I wanted the story and we can find numbers if you want uh we've used it here and there in the past it's been a few years it's just unaffordable but if you look at the Logan cash agreement that's how Logan started they transported

038through a third party and they were so displeased that they partnered up with cash and that that's how that agreement uh started but when they went with cash it was cheaper it was safer and they followed the rules there is maintenance not that I think a third part I mean there is again Ogden uses a third party vendor I think they feel very good about what's happening with that so it's not you know it's not the worst option out there that is an option for one of the districts to look and do that so yeah if you looked at the South District they've got to build all those facilities and I mean it's quite a bit of money too so the third party might not be that much and maybe even a gap solution for

039a couple of years until they get on their feet so but I don't know in my head wouldn't a third party be way more expensive than like the tiered option we believe so anyway that's what I'm asking yeah we can definitely go Jared and see what what the costs are that would be really helpful yes please when you talking about a service center um we have two areas that don't have service centers and I know there's talk about retrofitting you know back to what it was on the South but that would handicap our facilities people they'd have to give up something so with a smaller area can you like estimate how many bays is planned for the west and with the southeast same number of Bays or well with with the $50 million that Eric's

040giving us we're going to be okay we going be just fine okay so that's six no so so this is what was planned for the West service CER this is an actual drawing that Frank sent over so what would you would you estim was that a full service yeah it was full service with a a bus wash uh I I I think I remember dri that could also be service there yeah I think I think in the original plans we had a five bay and then a wash and then I think two of those were going to be in ground and the other three are portable lifts which means you could do buses in there or other vehicles so ES well Frank's not here to defend himself but let's just tell him we need 15

041million how much do we have left to build this versus what we saved what do we need to make this is that a Jason question well we were talking about that the other day there's six million right now but that six million Also may need to be used for the high school so it may be the zero but probably take another four million or so Frank was going to bring back a number I believe next time you said I mean we I think a few years ago we were looking r at about 10 million in that neighborhood so probably add maybe 12 to 13 million and again it depends on you know what type like if you do inground lifts if you do all portable lifts what other type of equipment you're going to put

042into that service center are you going to do a bus wash or you going to hold off on the bus wash for a while that seems what the plan happened or what happened to the plan was yes there's a bus wash area but we're not going to the equipment into it and save that cost for a number of years have a Jason question but so Jason when we went through the budget process we put those funds aside for the West Transportation so they can't be used for something else right yeah the board can always decide to change that it's not set that's where it's assigned right now but so there was 2 million last year two million this year and then two million a few years ago other questions for us thank you thanks for

043the opportunity pass on to Joe Joe's gonna bring it home for us um just one of the other questions that was uh asked was just a little bit of discussion about ineligibles and to come back to that subject a little bit so again what do uh you know what laws guide our decision again eligibility is based Bas on your proximity to the school and nothing else right once you get beyond that 1.5 or you get beyond that two or you live underneath that mileage then it is up to you to provide your own transportation so every time we add a stop or do anything like that that becomes an ineligible stop that is funded at some rate by the district our routers do an excellent job of making sure that we don't not that we

044do not have totally unfunded routes right but we have unfunded stops on those routes I think we only had maybe two last year that were completely unfunded routes but there are stops along that that are not funded okay so again as we look at what we do by the numbers right here um 70 completely ineligible runs but again Those runs are making up part of a route so we are getting some funding back on these routes but there are chunks of those routes that are not receiving any funding okay so again again this is from a couple of years ago but we're again we're close about 3,100 ineligible Riders about 70% of what we do is transporting ineligible Riders okay and then just to give you an idea of where those ineligible Riders are located

045we didn't bring up the information for the elementary but at the secondary level this is kind of where those ineligible Riders are distributed throughout the district okay and again they are spread kind of throughout East West Central we have ineligible Riders throughout now one of the things that we had talked about at the end of last year was moving forward and eliminating all secondary ineligible routes for this coming school year which is something that we can still move towards but as we move into this kind of Uncharted Territory with this reconfiguration I know that there had been some discussion as we try to move towards this that cities and City officials might have some impact or say as to the district having that ability to stop running routes or removing ineligible routes and I don't

046know where that currently stands or what will happen in this upcoming legislative session that might you know hinder us or present some roadblocks from us being able to move forward and eliminate these ineligible routes okay and a lot of these ineligible routes have been there for years but again they're all over the place depending upon a variety of different conditions that exist that may pose a safety issue and that's not to say that any parent couldn't argue that how they or student gets to school if they're walking might pose a safety issue so safety and safe walking routes it's very subjective right it's in the eye of the beholder what is safe and what is not safe um but just to keep going through here a little bit you know there is a lot you

047know every school is required to put together at least Elementary and and Junior High to provide their safe walking routes on their website those are gone through each year uh by school and reviewed and posted for the public to see what the recommended safe walking route is and last year you know although it's always hard when you remove busing this is a process that we've gone through year in and year out we've communicated with people and tried to let them know for again a variety of different reasons that their route will no longer be run and that we're going to eliminate that particular route or that particular stop um that Services their students currently okay it is nice when cities you know step in and provide crossing guards and things like that but that's not

048always the case so again we're looking at a chunk of students that as we begin to remove ineligible routes if that's what inevitably happens families will will be impacted when we do that okay any questions with that do you have longitudinal data for this on this it just really is one occasionally meing like looking back in the past at what's happened um it's going to be pretty consistent I think you know obviously when you take a new school like Viewpoint right we don't really know and some of the boundary changes have impacted that over the last couple of years so to say go back and say no we probably can't provide a ton we have base numbers right so we can say okay this year we had this many ineligibles the year before but it

049seems to remain fairly steady sorry I'm sorry I just met about Sundance oh about Sundance oh is it really just like one it Sundance is so interesting like were we really sending a bus to bring one I mean did this school that school it it got to that point right historically that wasn't what was happening that they had more kids there but as kids age out as kids get to the age where they can drive as families move and so as we continue to review that data we're like wow we see it trending downward you get to a point like this makes no sense at all right we need to eliminate this okay any other questions for any one of us when it comes to transportation and reconfiguration so um like in the Sundance routes

050yeah is there some way we can like give them a cash you know to drive their own kids or something like that or what's the law the law we we can provide in Li of which is a reimbursement rate where they check that you know they give them a certain amount for mileage and they look at days attended and that's what we offer usually when we are no longer going to provide service because it's ineligible so I think on the slide earlier we had like 20 20 families receiving in Lua because the bus can't get to them so that is an option oh are they all in Traverse are they all mine no no we have something out west that we just can't get to because of dirt roads or or other reasons sometimes it's

051up in the you know the Sun Crest area where the hills and things like that they don't allow because of the Grave where the buses to get into we do have a few vans that we utilize to get kids from like a house to a bus or a school where we pick them up or we just offer in L of and some families are like I'm going to drive my my student anywhere so I'll utilize that service you say a few Vans how many yeah and again they're primarily used to pick up uh special education students where we just can't get a bus into their area or neighborhood and so they pick the student up and again either take them to school or take them to an area where they can meet the bus are

052they specially equipped for stad students yes wheelchairs okay yes pleas um I know that you talked about you know getting drivers and it is looking a teeny bit better than it did back in 2021 2022 how many of our bus drivers or do we have any teachers like from FFA I mean we've had one particular that has his license how many do you have throughout the district that drive their own students or do you not maybe one we don't so when you look at teachers and things like that then you start getting into hours of service and the federal government you know says that you can have so many hours that you can drive within a week and any on duty job is those hours of service are ticking so if I teach all day

053and then start driving a bus all that time teaching is part of those hours of service yeah and and really when you think about it I and this is just my opinion but best practice right I don't want that person who's been teaching all day but then take a load of students and drive for like the next two hours I mean that's a long day for anyone and so that has hindered having like a teacher or somebody else um we've just had teachers that wouldn't be teaching at all that day they would just go with their students up to Logan at their competition and they had talked about that and it was yeah hard getting but it sounds like we've offered before and again I would push back because again it's like hey I'm going

054to get on a bus I haven't driven one for years but this day I'm going to get on on there and drive and practice makes perfect and I I personally feel much better I got my CDL when I was appointed to this position and I've only driven one bus load of students there's no way I would go out and Sub on a route right now because I just don't have I've seen you drive just on your own car this is confessional time you said that's a federal requirement to hour hours of service yes yep so you have so many hours that you can drive within a week and how many hours you can drive within a day and so those will limit teachers and others from doing that that have another job with the exception

055of farmers right somehow if you're a farmer you can do whatever you want you drive a bus another minor issue is is every month we have random drug testing and they can get called out at any time for that testing they have to leave their class their school get theirself down they have three hours to do it and I know of one teacher in the district that was called out three consecutive months and finally I think they just said I'm done you so it's there are other aspects as well if you fail a drug test it's a lifetime band so it's a big deal on that yeah some other things to consider too we don't really talk about mckenny vento students but that is another population of students that are uh provided Transportation at various

056times and so that number fluctuates based on the number of students who qualify for mcken vento so that impacts what we do we also have two 14 passenger um we'll call them activity buses which uh schools and different programs will utilize and so that is maybe an option as new districts come on board to look at doing something like that with these smaller activity buses you don't need a CDL you don't need a chauffeur's license you know you don't need those things and you can transport smaller groups of students and they come at a significant cost reduction to what it would be buy a bus Joe can you talk for a minute because when we talk about activity and activity runs it has been uh the tradition of Alpine to really subsidize some of those

057activities because we want our schools to be able to go on these field trips but it does come at a cost at the transportation level can you talk about that for a little bit about those activity runs yeah so when you look at the number that deficit number that we run in a lot of that a lot of that the majority of that is because we are still charging the same amount for an activity that we did when I came into Transportation like in 2014 right $4 a mile okay driver wages have gone up I think when I came into transportation we were paying like 1385 and what are we now 2394 yeah so wages go up the price of gas has gone up the price of repair and maintenance to our buses has gone

058up but we still continue to charge that $4 a mile for our activities now that keeps the cost down Cly for our schools our parents our athletes and things like that but it does come at a cost to the district overall right so that and that is what we do in Alpine with activity charges is I mean unique right most districts charge a per mile cost they charge an hourly driver cost set up they charge a setup fee they charge a cleaning fee B&B for buses yeah yeah so we're very generous to our schools and to our students by what we do with activities and how little we really charge to to allow those students to participate in those events and have transportation I guess to participate in those events understand that that was $4

059compared to 2394 that is that the no the 2394 is the beginning hourly wage for a bus driver yes when they first started out four hours or four do per miles that we charge for activities our best guess is that it costs us $12 and we charge four so it's 12 to four okay we estimate that we charge a third of what it costs so what do you think would happen if we charge well I don't think schools would be quite as happy maybe business goes down a little bit because it's more expensive they'd have to pull money from somewhere else and our mindset is really that of service we're not looking to make money we're looking to serve schools we're just providing that information to you to help us along so have you ever

060come to us before and said hey by the way you have yeah it has happened in the past yes but but again District wants to to help students have those experiences absolutely and and and we all know that if we up that cost who's going to pay the the difference families will it be pass on or if we did it that way in charge more could provide more it' be the same same district support whether we give it to schools and they give it to Transportation or if it's just made up in the the end yeah it's the same big pot of money as a whole we feel very supported when a bus needs to be repaired we've never been told no when we need to pay someone or fill up a bus we've never

061been told no so although we work in a deficit we feel like we're providing a good service and we're fully supported by you can we get the elementary version of ineligible writers sure love to see that and thank you for the color coding for different areas it's helpful any other questions before we sign off I guess my question is if when we start talking about if it's going to be unified or transition or clean um when do we kind of need to make that decision so that you all can plan on your end you're going to get back Eric you know I I think one thing that would be helpful for our department especially when you start looking at doing the routing for specific districts the the sooner we can understand what that starts to

062look like the more we can start looking naturally at maybe uncoupling some of those routes that are cross district and seeing how many buses it will take and I think we can get some better numbers of what those actual bus numbers would look like drivers um routes stops if we can start looking at uncoupling that and we can do that through naturally you know at the beginning of or before the beginning of the year maybe starting to look at three ways that we can do that one naturally for how we've done business as usual in Alpine but maybe number two looking at okay what would that look like if we separated West or if we coupled South and Central just starting to reimagine what those routes would look like and then we can bring that

063to the board and say this is what it could start to look like moving forward and that gives us at least two years to start working towards that that's what I'm asking so if you can start it for the next year it for the next year so that when it transitions that's what I think we would prefer okay I think one of the hardest things with doing anything like that is when it comes to sped and what sp's going to look like because then you're forecasting into the future what schools are going to host what programs where are those students going to come from to support those programs and that becomes very very tricky I mean sped is a huge project each year because even in our district currently right each year we're looking where

064do we have the space with this program and then and you know what does busing look like to support that program and it's kind of this jigsaw puzzle that is moving around constantly and to kind of forecast that out years ahead of time without knowing what that population looks like and where those um programs will be located in these different different districts makes it very tricky regular Ed a little bit easier to give you some better information on sped I would say very very difficult to provide that this one's a little more challenging than some of the other areas because it's still going to be a future District determination right so how much do you invest in that at this point to set that up for possibilities what the recommendation looks like and it probably

065needs to be more than a recommendation because or you just hold and say we're going to continue to maintain what we currently have and then new districts will decide I think one area that could help um mitigate some of that is if there's a board will to remove all ineligible prior to the new districts and then districts build that back in if they want to that would reduce some of our stress on our driver's routes and the need for buses but again that's going to come with some angst um because people are used to having transportation but what it have less I'm going to choose my words carefully would it have less of a like maybe negative clip if we were moving towards like the tiered to go then from tiered to split if new

066boards chose to do that then go from us staying all together and then three clean breaks can I ask a followup to that yes pleas are you proposing we do a tiered split starting next year or before the reconfiguration in anticipation of the reconfiguration yes so I'm saying go with what Eric's saying right we start it next year fix it the next year and so then if those new boards and two and a half years say no we want a clean break we go there but if they say no we want to stay with this tier so you're saying uncoupled routes prior to like you're basically routing three districts in our current configuration so well I guess I'm saying it two-way oh obviously I can't speak for other people but it would be my preference

067that we would continue like to help I'm not I I it's not my intention to say hey South figured out right um but if we so I guess what I'm saying is can can West be on one and then Central and South with the intention that they figure out what they're doing yeah one specific example of that that we're looking at if you look at Lehi only they have about 45 routes or 45 drivers they are currently serviced by the West service center and so we Transportation almost set up a natural two-way divide and so if we were to move those 45 from west to east that's not a good idea that would be a significant reallocation of resources that's 45 drivers buses routes and so that could tip the scale in a way that

068we could but but uh I don't know how much value that would add doing it one year early yeah I think we ought to be cautious because we still don't know what those new school boards will decide to do and if they for example decided to contract with another vendor like Ogden all that stuff we do would be of no use so and from a transportation standpoint the most efficient way for us is together right now and so it's almost like we would be doing ourselves a disservice to uncouple early before those decisions are made and they're only a year away new boards will be very here uncoupling would need more drivers and more buses because you'd essentially set up routing for each of the three new areas and say okay you figure you know

069what I mean that crossover is gone then when you do that and that and thinking of the routing team that would be such a a burden to place on men to route for three districts right now so just as a point of clarification is the official staff recommendation from transportation that we maintain the current configuration or is the are you recommending a tiered approach I I'm a little bit unsure as to if you guys are like solidly this is what we recommend and recommendations are tricky I can come back to bite you in the back I won't hold you accountable Joe I'm just I'm just C if you and if you're not comfortable answering the question please don't but I'm just wondering if you're saying hey this is like an 8020 decision 6040 or if

070it's like a 4951 like I and based on what these guys have all the work that they put into US I'd say that it makes some sense that the West is a little more set up right to be successful by itself with the service center and things like that and it would make more sense because of the size and the student population and the geography for maybe the Central and the South to stay together for at least some period of time correct me if I'm wrong absolutely that's what I assume the recommendation would be but I needed to confirm that's actually what you were saying thank you so I know Frank's not here but I don't remember Jason what we said how many years for West like I said it was first it wasn't going

071to be full then it wasn't going to be full so if we say we're going to build it how long will it take us to build it the construction of the West Transportation I don't don't depends on what I mean they wereing theare building versus a brick and mortar seems like there were some zoning issues with the city too I I think the zoning issues were solved though I think it was more of they wanted uh some more Aesthetics on the outside so in my conversation with Frank he he said if we were to start construction now on the on that facility that we showed it would take it would be done by the time the split happens so it's going to take some time there there are some of the the materials that are

07218 months out if you order right now you're not going to see them for 18 months so it's going to it's going to take time the earlier we get on it the better South is starting from zero and in those plans it's not just building a service center it's also providing like you have to kick out that wall you have I mean there's you got to push back onto that undeveloped land right there so we don't just have an existing plot we can start building we got to move some other things around to make that happen other questions thank you okay thanks for having me [Applause] uh great detail uh I think a lot of uh work went into that so appreciate uh the team and your work Eric anything to add for no I

073appreciate that super attendant they they did they put a lot of work into that good job good thinking forward and I I think that we just continue to problem solve on what that looks like the closer we can get and appreciate the value of of trying to see things in a different way so yeah Eric can I say one last thing yeah sorry super is that okay no so uh new job for me I just learned to be a bus driver I took the training I went through the class as if I was a bus driver and I have a brand new appreciation for how difficult the job is not only are you navigating and negotiating traffic and a 40 foot vehicle you're also paying attention to 60 kids behind you who may or may

074not be behaving and these are people that we train in two weeks and throw them on the road they don't have years of educational training uh student management none of that we train them on the Fly and so anytime you have a chance to thank a bus driver or appreciate them we would sure appreciate that uh we have a huge appreciation for our bus drivers and I appreciate that I think from all of you just the uh contextual empathy that you have the time that you take to understand what it is like to be a driver so that you can better support than advocate for them so thank you for for doing that and uh for that comment and uh again uh appreciate the work the it's very digestible it's straightforward I know that took

075a lot of effort appreciate you looking at other possibilities and we'll continue the uh the discussion president King anything else you need from staff at this point no I think we're good okay then we're going to break we're going to adjourn until a board meeting at six o'clock okay e e e my e our school board meeting to order um first item on our agenda is that we're going to have the Pledge of Allegiance and that's going to be led by Camy Harper next we're going to have our inspirational thought and that's going to be given to us by Rex Brimhall roll with the tides I'm sorry roll with the waves of life on on December 6 2023 during the first full day of our initial visit to Hawaii I was body surfing with my

076youngest son when I caught an impressive wave at bren's beach in the Poo area of kawaii initially it was exhilarating a sensation I've experienced countless times while body surfing however this time was different the way flipped me up feet up and propelled me toward the ocean floor causing me to land almost directly on the crown of my head fractioning my neck in five places this wasn't planned it wasn't expected it wasn't the reason we went to Hawaii but it was the reality that life presented to me at that time similarly in Alpine School District we are encountering unexpected challenges as we moveed toward dividing Alpine School District into three separate districts we Face unforeseen PL unforeseen unplanned and undesired circumstances yet like my experience in Hawaii it is a situation that we must navigate yet

077in both situations there's an important lesson life much like the ocean is unpredictable and Powerful it has the ability to surprise us challenge us and sometimes knock us off our feet or the boogie board just as waves recede allowing us to find our footing again we too have the capacity to to rise adapt and learn from these experiences in the face of unfor foreseen challenges whether personal or organizational it's essential to embrace resilience and adaptability while the path ahead might be uncertain it is also filled with opportunities for growth and transformation this division of ASD into three separate districts will certainly come with its own set of Trials but it offers a unique chance to innovate redefine and strengthen each educational Community just as I recovered from what from that unexpected wave we can navigate

078through these changes by supporting one another staying focused on our shared goals and embracing the journey with Open Hearts and Minds with determination and unity we can turn these challenges into stepping stones and plan for a bright future so let's roll with ways of life confident in our ability to overcome adapt and Thrive no matter what comes is our way I deeply appreciate the leadership in Al Alpine School District their unwavering focus on what truly matters the students is unmatched as we navigate this wave that life has sent us I hope we can all maintain this focus and continue making decisions that will best benefit the [Applause] students thank you Rex we appreciate appreciate that next up we are going to do our rise recognitions um Alpine School District is thankful for so many teachers

079and staff members who excel in making a difference for our students parents colleagues and others tonight we would like to recognize nominees who have been selected to receive the Alpine School District rise award which stands for remarkable inspiring selfless and encouraging board member Peterson our first award is going to go to Karen Hunter who's a counselor at Canyon View junior high school so we invite Karen Mel and principal Grant catrell to come forward um Karen was nominated by Mel Nelson who's an employee psychologist I'm [Applause] sorry correction Karen is the school psychologist Mel wrote Karen is the calm in the storm she is the most optimistic person I know and can literally make lemonade without any lemon thrown at her and there are lots of lemons hurled at her on the daily I am so

080grateful for her ability to be reasonable empathetic and the steady leader that our group needs even in the face of her own personal concerns she consistently shows up for us in big ways I am so grateful for her thank you Karen for being [Applause] you our next award goes to Karen oops I'm sorry I will learn to read our next award goes to Diane castiano who is a teacher at Horizon School she was nominated by Whitley white so we invite Diane Whitley and principal Dan heaps to come [Applause] forward Whitley wrote Miss Diane is the walking definition of what the rise award represents the dedication she shows to her students goes above and beyond she gives them so much love and support and then extends that to their families and that ex extends to their

081families and is felt 100% we are so lucky to have her teaching and loving our [Applause] children our next award goes to Casey Kaiser a teacher at Mount mahogany Elementary and the nomination was by Marshall osen an employee so if Casey Marshall and John EMT could come forward that'd be [Applause] great so Marshall wrote uh Casey Kaiser is an exemplary teacher her calm demeanor creates a safe space for students and co-workers alike to trust her and work with her she creates a fun educational environment for students to learn learn her dedication to students is evident in her kindness well-planned lessons and relationships that she builds Casey is an exceptional educator and deserves a shout out for all of her service and [Applause] dedication we' next like to invite Diego tapal Lugo as well as Rex

082Brimhall and principal Heather Jensen to come forward Diego is one of our bus drivers at West Transportation this is what principal Jensen said Diego is a dedicated bus driver who has made a lasting impact on the preschool children he transports each day known for his remarkable patience Diego approaches his job with a calm and steady demeanor understanding that young children often need extra time and care he never rushes them as they board the bus instead offering gentle encouragement and assistance to those who may be nervous or hesitant his patience also shines through in his interactions always ensuring that the children feel safe and comfortable during their daily [Applause] commute our next award goes to Lisa Jones and Sheri gotel who are par professionals at Harbor Point Elementary they were nominated by Jen basa and we

083invite Sher Jen and Lisa and then principal Matt Goble and assistant principal Jordan rasl up Jen wrote sharing and Lisa are par Professionals in our special autism classroom they are taking amazing initiatives and leading their in leading their class they are positive team players and always willing to take on hard things they have bravely taught the class and given the students structure and support it has been a lot of work yet they move ahead with confidence they are both they are both always where they need to be and when they need to be there they are both incredible at their jobs and we are so lucky to have them at Alpine next is Gabe donadel a custodian at Cedar Valley Elementary uh Gabe was nominated by Denise Fitzgerald and so we invite Gabe Denise and

084principal John laber to come forward Denise wrote Gabe is is an incredible professional his custodial Duties are always done with Excellence he exudes enthusiasm and appreciation for all around him he's outside with students in the morning making funny artistic posters to greet students several times a week and will stop and help anyone with anything at a moment's notice he makes a huge difference at Cedar Valley Elementary and we are the most fortunate School in the district to have Gabe and president King I think they have some examples of his work here I just so you've noticed okay I just disappeared e e for John walk away from Denise and stop trying to steal her okay next up we have our energy star certification Awards so we are grateful for our partnership with synergistic and the

085strides we are making for Energy Efficiency and protecting the environment throughout the communities that we serve we'd like to welcome senior vice president Piper aelle with synergestic for a brief presentation and recognition of schools that have received the 2024 Energy Star Award Piper thank you thank you so much it's good to be here thank you board board president superintendent and to the public that are in the room so much like an appliance in the home earns that earn energy star label buildings are also awarded certification for Energy Efficiency a building earning Energy Star Building certification meets very strict energy performance standards that are set forward by the EPA so to qualify for Energy Star Building certifications a building must score in the top 25% efficiency ratings based on the epa's national performance system so here

086in Alpine for the last four years the number of schools that have been certified for improving their efficiency rating has improved every year this year in 2024 award year 73 buildings earned the US Environmental Protection Agency energy star certification for Superior Energy performance it actually uh was kind of hard to fit them on the page this is the fourth year that the district has earned this recognition representing your sustained commitment to Active Energy Management Alpine School District has the most energy STAR certified buildings of any school district in Utah and in the surrounding states in the nation energy star admits that Alpine is ranked 15 in the nation so that's pretty remarkable concern considering the large school districts that are across the United States competing for this recognition on average energy STAR certified buildings use

08735% less energy cause 35% fewer greenhouse gas emissions and are less expensive to operate than their peers all without sacrificing performance and operations and comfort these awards are significant to your organization recogniz recognition by the EPA for excellence and Energy Efficiency acknowledging your stewardship honoring people in your organization for their hard work and commitment in sustaining this exemplary program a special thanks to Frank pulley his team Zach JJ Kevin and Scott in your operations group who work tirelessly behind the scenes to keep your buildings running efficiently also a special thanks to custodian Jared Hill at Legacy Elementary in the last three years he has helped improve the efficiency rating considerably making it one of the highest ranking efficiency schools in your District at this time on behalf of the United States Environmental Protection Agency and

088all of us at synergistic congratulations on this recognition we are proud of our partnership and your commitment to protect the environment today and for future Generations Frank could we have you and your team stand up please Jim come on guys you're all a part of the team everybody stand up so we can clap for you yeah please this uh this award here is for um the superintendent board president to put wherever you like um certainly um if there's a place to display it it's a fantastic award from the EPA but also each of the schools all 73 they'll receive their own certification Awards individually spe you at this point we have no Community comments so we will move on to the approval of minutes do we have a motion to approve the minutes I move

089we approve the minutes I'll second it okay so with a motion by Mark and a second by Sarah any discussion seeing none all in favor please say I i i i i any opposed that passes unanimously next um I'll entertain a motion for claims I move that we accept this month's claims do we have a second I'll second okay so we have a motion by Stacy and a second by Joy Lyn do we have any discussion seeing none all in favor please say I I any opposed that motion passes unanimously next up we have our routine business I will entertain a motion president yes I would like to separate one item out of the routine business uh the renewal of the business administrator contract um because um we this our standard practice is to have

090a full Board review uh which includes uh the services of usba in uh making this evaluation we have not completed that so I move that we postpone um this contract renewal uh for a later date when we will have finished that study second so removing that from the routine business okay so we have an amendment to the routine business from aah and a second by Emily any discussion seeing none all in favor please say I I any opposed okay so now I'll entertain a motion about the routine business I move that we adopt uh the routine business as outlined in board docs I'll second it okay so we have a motion by aah and a second by Sarah any discussion seeing none all in favor please say I I any opposed that passes unanimously okay

091next up our action item Dr fernworth thank you president King we do have a an offer on this CTE home in orm resolution number 2025-the resolution 202- 001 sale of CTO CTE home in Oram do we have a second okay so with a motion by a and a second by AC see any discussion I just have a clarifying question I know that we've had some code change are we within code to go ahead and sell the house at this point in time so what we're doing here is just having the board have the approval of that we can't finalize everything until the four cities give their approval which is in the process Kirk Brinkerhoff is working on that so we didn't want to have that and then have it delayed with another board meeting so

092this will just sit until we have that and then be able to find perhaps then we could amend the motion pending approval by the interlocal agreement do you want to adjust your motioning the approval of the inter local like inter or city support City approval of the four South cities okay just approval of their oh I see okay that to requires us to get approval of those entities if we are disposing of property okay I amend the resolution uh to include the pending approval of the interlocal in the South area I'll second it okay so with a motion by aah and a second by Sarah all in favor please say I I I any opposed that passes unanimously next on to our discussion action items Dr farnworth yes we invite our legal councel executive director

093of Legal Services Craig Brinkerhoff to come forward we have three policies that are for discussion if the board feels like those policies are set then we can move to an action item to approve those two of those are revisions one is a new policy we'll take them one at a time first policy is policy number 1610 maintaining constitutional freedom in public schools yes so this one is uh it was previously named separation of church and state we felt like that uh title was a little bit misleading and and didn't quite get to the point that we wanted we''ve revised this uh policy to be specific and around code 53 g1022 which is maintaining constitutional freedom in public schools um we cite directly to the code uh basically stating that uh it's as a school district

094we can neither promote nor prohibit the certain uh expression um and that it is is okay to uh research and study the the involvement of religion for example in the Arts and Music and all those things as laid out in that code um that was the main reason that we went about um updating this particular policy um we also built into this policy more about release time we previously did not uh address release time in in this policy and um so we wanted to make sure that we carved out what is release time and what it what it is appropriate for release time and not appropriate that's a quick summary we have a little president okay we can have discussion if we want to have discussion or we can someone can make a motion to

095move this to an action item so I'd like to make a comment I just really appreciate the name change that is now reflective of the same name of the piece of code that it is um then when you're searching for a rule or a code you can cross reference them very quickly when they have the same name so it wasn't just an arbitrary picking of a new name it's to match the name of the code that we're citing in this policy I also wanted to comment um we met as a policy committee this afternoon or this morning and um realized that we we didn't ever really Define what release time is and so we have some language that if it's agreeable to um the board we'd like to just add it into the policy um

096it's the legal definition of what release time is it comes directly from code release time means a period of time during the regular school day a student is excused from school at the request of the student's parent uh pursuant to the rules of the state board so AA is it are you making a motion to approve the policy with the language you just added I will make that I just wanted to apprise the board that we had discussed this and to get your feeling on that when we discussed that in policy committee the idea was that we would Define that that term the first time it's used which is in the um the statement of policy we would also site the the uh code where that link that to it in the policy is there

097any other discussion or do we have anyone will uh wanting to make a motion I move that we pass the revised version of policy 1610 maintaining constitutional freedom in public schools do we have a second second okay so we have a motion by Sarah and a second by ad aah sorry it's been a day any discussion um just a clarifying question I didn't see that there was an amendment in that motion to revised okay well it is a revised this would be a revised revised amend the amended revised version the amended revised okay um any other discussion all in favor please say I I I any opposed okay that passes unanimously um next Dr Farnsworth policy 3210 time and effort documentation this is a new policy again uh opportunity for discussion if the board fails

098comfortably they can move it to an action and approve the policy yes so we've been in the habit of uh slimming down our policies this is one that we're actually adding um the purpose for this this this information has previously been held in the business services handbook um we have been asked essentially by Utah State Board of Education to create a policy around this the time and effort documentation really is about uh grants that we apply for and how we document our time and effort that we put into those grants to um justify the receipt of those funds and so this policy is coming from the the verbiage that was previously held in the business services handbook thank you K we have a motion I move to approve policy 3210 time and effort documentation we

099have a second second okay so with a a motion by joyin and a second by AA any discussion regarding the policy seeing none all in favor please say I I any opposed okay that passes unanimously um next policy 5117 yes we recommend if the board is comfortable with the revisions made that this move from discussion to action and they approve the changes policy 5117 outof boundary School options thank you so this particular policy we we had uh discovered through various uh discussions with principles and supervisors that um there was the use of out of area contracts being done at schools um and as we looked closer at those of area contracts they were being applied erroneously um the the idea behind those out out of area contracts is to make them a provisional contract for

100students that come into a school with pre-existing and known behavioral issues so in those circumstances the code allows us to set a provisional contract with that student and say we understand that you've had behavioral issues in the past um so if you continue to have behavioral issues at our school this contract contract will allow us to move you back out and deny that out of that out of area uh agreement so that's kind of what started us on the revisions for this particular policy is clearing that up and clarifying that um as part of that we also bolstered the code language again regarding out of area uh the out of area process both um early application for that and late application what that means what those timelines are and so forth um in our discussion

101in our po committee meeting today we also uh discussed what might uh what we might need to add when it refers to military uh families so in a in a separate section of code there's a an opening of 30 days for a military family um and they have a priority so um we are going to also um suggest and I believe there'll be a motion that uh we add that one piece of code into this policy that allows for a 30-day window for outof boundary students with regards to military or boundary changes thank you I I'm so sorry I got that messed up there's two things we discussed so anytime we do a boundary change as a school district or you do a boundary change as a school board um we need to have a

10230-day window where we open up for out of boundary um applications for those students affected by that boundary change I apologize thank you for giving me that stare that I knew I was saying something something wrong he do we have anyone wanting to make a motion um I'd like to make a motion that we approve policy 5117 out of boundary School options revision with the addition of section 1.2.2 point7 parents of students enrolled in a school affected by a boundary change shall have at least 30 days after the day on which the local board votes to approve the School boundary change to make an outof area enrollment request using the outof boundary request form I'll second it okay so we have a motion by joyn and a second by Sarah any discussion um so I

103really really love 1.2 um I think Viewpoint would have loved this a couple of years ago so thank you for that but I especially wanted to comment on 1.2.1 um just a lot of appreciation for giving principles the autonomy in those situations that need to be a little quicker than maybe the others so thank you for keeping our students in mind with that I just appreciate um board member um joyn board me member Lincoln um she remembered this uh part of the code that really needed to be included in this policy which is the the special case where there's been the boundary change there does the window needs to be reopened for 30 days okay all in favor of approving policy number 5117 please say I I any opposed passes unanimously superintendent yes thank you

104Craig appreciate that and thank you board members for passing those policies last week in our board work session we discussed some items that uh could we could consider as we move forward for establishing a greater uh strength and continuity among the new districts one of those was the idea of a calendar we know the calendar committee uh there's a survey out now getting feedback on the calendar for the 26 27 school year the board discussed in that work session the possibility of having that committee develop additional calendars that future districts could adopt so that there was continuity across the three districts with respect to school calendar so we are bringing that here for discussion and possible action if the board wanted to move forward in that direction do we have any discussion okay someone want

105to make a motion I'm kind of stomach Dearing the headlights up here UMES would someone like to make a motion so you're saying there's a [Laughter] chance okay I'll do it I'm gon to well I'll just see if I can piece it together I will move that we direct the calendar committee to prepare a 25 26 Calendar oh no oh yeah 26 27 my apologies um and in addition to prepare three additional years 27 to 28 28 to 29 29 to 30 for the board to consider for recommendation for the new districts to adopt I'll second I can't repeat that again soone was going to say what I what I said previously uh I motion seconded by Stacy all in favor oh sorry any discussion all in favor please say I I any opposed that

106was easy and hard at the same time okay the next item is uh also in preparation for the reconfiguration the need to create a third data center uh in Alpine School District we would recommend that we start that process working with our partners to uh show Our intention to add an additional data center I know that is as we discussed last week that would take a period of time to be able to enact that but a motion by the board would signal to um ueen our intent and interest in securing a third location to store our data thank you superintendent do we have discussion or a motion I move move that we create a third data center in the school district joyn are you okay if I there's potentially a little bit of specificity to

107the language do you yeah just give me a sec I move go ahead do you mind if I let Emily um make a motion because I think we need to be a little and sorry my apologies take away prepared I move that we authorize the technology department to work in partnership with who was it you UE to investigate a location and begin to establish a data center within the boundaries of the Central District do we have a second thank you joyn I apologize about that okay so we have a motion by Emily and a second by join any discussion seeing none all in favor please please say I I I any opposed superintendent the last area of consideration was our print services we had a presentation um talked about the great uh services that our

108print department is offering and this motion if the board feels so inclined would direct the staff to continue to provide those Services um not work toward expanding that to three different districts but look at the recommendation of having consolidated services across the three districts until the point came that a new District wanted to create their own print services we have sufficient equipment there we would continue to upgrade that as needs be We Believe through that one Central service to provide the print services across all three districts that would be something that would allow those new districts to leverage that until they got to the point where they wanted to provide their own so that would be our recommendation thank you okay any discussion or a motion I'd like to move that as a board that

109we recommend um moving forward the discussion to continue print services to serve all three new districts okay so just to clarify AA um you're recommending that or you're motioning that we make the recommendation to the new three districts to maintain print services as it is oh okay is that or is that I just want to make sure I heard you correctly um maybe I need to I was moving forward the discussion moving forward the so you're not making the recommendation to to the new boards yeah you're not doing that okay I didn't know that we were going to go that far okay we need to include the language to not acquire additional property does that need to be in it I don't think that we we can we can have a discussion or we can

110make a specific motion disc yeah maybe we need to discuss this superintendent maybe you can reiterate yes so our our plan as we move forward towards the three new districts to look at services are provided support services are provided currently within Alpine School District and as we studied some of those some of them made sense that let's keep that as a Consolidated service across all three districts there would no need be no need at this point to prepare for three separate print services now new District could determine that they want to have their own but we would move forward as if there was to be one providing Services across all three districts we studied how they have an ordering system that would allow them to keep that separate build those districts according to those costs

111it would maintain a low cost per copy and other services a new board again could choose to go in a different direction new Administration could choose to do their own we would move forward over the next couple years with the intention that all three districts would leverage that Consolidated service the board could move to make that recommendation directing staff to move towards that end yeah I I would rather than directing or recommending to Future new boards I would say let's I would like to move that we uh recommend to staff uh and will Empower staff to move forward as uh if print services were going to to serve all three new districts I have a question so does this mean if there were because on one of my many field trips stand a print services

112I know they've had different conversations about things that they could maybe bring to different areas so that everything wasn't coming out of their Central shop so if they wanted that they've been talking about for years right so would they still be able to make those adjustments with this yes I think our movement would we would not try and buy three of every machine that we have in there to split three ways but to um expedite the delivery and the uh responsiveness of that we could make some adjustments I just want to make sure they'll be able to make those adjustments thank you any other discussion so just to clarify we're not making this recommendation to Future boards we're just saying we're going to just keep doing what print services does and then we will adjust

113if new boards make a different decision correct okay um any other discussion all in favor say I I any opposed okay that motion passes unanimously next up superintendent our membership report yes you've received your membership report I think it's this the trend continues we continue to see high growth uh in our secondary schools out west we have I believe six schools five Schools elementary schools over a thousand right now so we'll continue to to monitor that I know we're preparing FTE to send out to those schools so areas some areas just continue to see significant growth that's my report on membership thank you Dr Farnsworth okay it's now time for board member and superintendent reports and information items I will share a report we recently had a state School Board Association conference and we were

114represented by Eric Woodhouse and Joe Hayes they did a presentation for other school boards across the state on our efforts to comply with safety requirements and other measures that we're taking I appreciate them sharing the good work that they are doing here in Alpine School District with other districts across the state so that they can leverage that same expertise and and that modeling really of how it is to be done so thank you Eric and appreciate your work there um along with that we had a wonderful um conference and our own Mark Clement is now the president of the usba so congratulations on that new appointment we are happy for you um the superintendent is definitely too modest to mention that he also presented at our conference with um Scott suner and it was a

115wonderful wonderful class um there were a lot of wonderful comments about uh where El Pine is and how we are leading out and making sure that we are um I guess being intentional on building capacity for our leaders and as a board member um I find great comfort and assurances knowing that as we split we have amazing amazing uh administrators that will go to three of these districts and so it's because of uh your leadership uh Dr Farnsworth and we are so appreciative and proud of the work that you did up this weekend at usba thank you if I could just chime in on that last comment um we actually looked as usba officers at all the uh evaluations that people did and uh more people actually commented about how great that breakout session was

116than any other breakout session so that was really an exceptional job so thank you Dr ferns for your work on that so Eric I really just mentioned yours so they would mention mine but uh that's a back anyway I got called on it so sorry uh so in all my years in K12 I have never seen an excited energy that was the first day back from the winter break this year um I had the opportunity to be in several schools that day one of my teachers did a very cool um siping socks and I will tell you that when I walked into that like those kids were vibrating in it was fantastic just so excited to be back together to be back with their teacher everybody talking all at once sixth graders by the way

117so the volume on that um and then I wanted to read something from another one of my teachers uh she had sent out an email to parents ahead of time letting us know what was going to happen um with the students and asking parents to have a conversation ahead of the first day um because they were going to be making one-word resolution in class um so she had asked the parents would talk with their students ahead of time and then she said you'll pick one single word that represents what they want to focus on or improve for the year I'd love if this could reflect something at school we'll be doing a project focusing on these things and hang them in the room until the end of the year I am a big time fan

118of the new year new goals and I love that we have teachers that are it's not just an academic goal right but it's how I can improve myself how I improve my community around me and it was just very cool across multiple schools multiple classes to see just how excited everybody was to get back to their teacher and back to class um and so I'm just very appreciative of all the teachers who made that first day back um really something special and and their setting goals and things that they can work on for the rest of the year microphone um I just wanted to send a shout out to our staff we had a work session last week which um I feel really bad for Emily because we just discussed everything from calendars to OPB

119to facilities Transportation there was so much information and um I know that was a lot for staff to do so quickly after the break and I just want to express my gratitude to all of them um for committing to make sure that we have three strong districts moving forward and making sure that student needs are always put first so I just want to recognize all of our um employees who helped participate in that and prepare for that meeting and um also just so you know around the corner we have another legislative session coming so mark your calendar from January 21st to March 7th um there will be a lot of action happening on the hill and just want to extend an invitation to everyone to participate in our constitutional republic to show up have your

120voice heard and reach out to legislators about things that you oppose as well as support I just wanted to acknowledge first of all I've really enjoyed having our new board member Emily Peterson you've been awesome to work with and I'm just welcome you again to our board and I I just look forward to working with you I also have had the opportunity to visit a number of schools this week and just want to give a shout out to our teaching and learning team it's happening it's happening um great gains I am so proud of Parkside Elementary they they have just been making great strides for their their total population but especially for their MLL their multilanguage Learners they they are just doing a phenomenal job and I I just my hats off to John Shelton

121and his team I said how do you do it and he described the very very targeted teaching that they do um through their the coaches that are working so hard with the teachers they are getting this work done and I'm just so proud of them and um thank you superintendent for your leadership and and making this happen it's it's really phenomenal thank you okay um we do not have need of a closed session this evening so I will entertain a motion to adjourn the meeting I move to adjourn second the motion okay so with a um motion by joyen second by Mark we're not going to talk about it uh All In faor to adjourn the meeting please say I I any opposed thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.