CorpusRecord 7028

December 17th, 2024 Alpine School District Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School Board Livestream Service Account
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Utah County, UT
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,372 words · about 86 min
Collected
2026-05-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Al test it again hello oh there we go all right welcome let's get started we're going to begin with Pledge of Allegiance by Dr Vicky Carter please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge Al tonight we've got something very special we want to share with you for our inspirational thought or reflection we're going to show you a video um many of our schools have special service projects this time of year and we asked them to submit to us just a little information about what they did and so this video describes what has happened at one of our schools and I think I think you will find it inspirational I promise you this is a day you'll never forget it is very important for you to take care of your little Christmas

002Child all day while you're here we're going to pair you up with these little Christmas children then you will come and you'll eat breakfast provided by Costa vaita and Fat Cats this whole event would not happen without them they have funed this whole thing and they've been doing this with me for 14 years this is my second year doing the Bear Hugs program and we just love doing this uh we love helping the kids it's our way to give back to the community and I'm just really excited it's to watch the kids eyes light up when they see everything so far they're enjoying it and I'm glad to be here today and I'm excited about our Day activities when we go to Walmart each of these little kids get a $100 to spend no tax

003so you don't have to worry about that close to 100 as you can without going over today is for the little kids I'm Becky at our hugs for kids shopping um this is our 14th year doing this started way back in 2008 um when we used to do the mascot bow to raise all of our sons year our friends at caita funded the whole them so we are here providing a Christmas shopping experience for 150 little kids and we have about 300 High School students who are here to chaperone them um it is such a great thing it's my favorite thing to do all year my dream is that every single high school would be able to do this to find a sponsor to be able to give back to the little kids um the

004fun part about this is we've been doing it so long that a lot of the high school kids who are the chaperon they were once little children I came back to bear hug this year because it's so rewarding and I love being able to meet new kids and be able to take them shopping not only is it rewarding for the kids but it also is for you and it's so fun to get an experience like this and to have a great time during the holidays we are four years ago I had a student come up to me and say Mrs White when do we sign up for the jazzar shopping and the be for kids she said I was one of those little kids so I want to be the first to sign up and

005there are many many stories like of the kids who were helpers High School chaperon are now the fire chief who leads the the procession who are the cops that help us with the procession as well um people who come and work my family comes every single year to run registered and to help it's just a family tradition so we're just very grateful for all the people who donate their time their talents their resources um too many to count but we hope that this is a tradition that goes on forever are you having fun here at hug you know we've been doing this for many many years I've actually been with the bear for over 30 years but we've been here at Alpine School District doing this taking children shopping and you're one of them right

006are you having fun we do this because it's a great way to spread the Christmas spirit and help a lot of children who may not get the opportunity so thank you for all your support and help Alpine School District you bus drivers you administrators all of you schools than you very and Merry Christmas and remember I'm watching you better watch out we have found sponsors and donors and participants to be able to provide two weeks of meals for I think 160 families 522 children and they will give them a box of food to last for the two weeks over this the uh Christmas break and so that video will be released tomorrow morning so you you'll want to be sure to get onto the ASD uh YouTube website and and look at that that's also

007a very exciting well tonight we want to honor six people and uh these are our rise Awards and we love being able to give these rise is remarkable inspiring selfless and encouraging and these are awards that can be um that are given to teachers and faculty and staff but anyone can submit an application a parent a student a fellow teacher anyone for one of these people and so these are the six that we're honoring tonight and start with aah Wilson Chad bevans nominated by Jordan Blanchard if he he or she is here but Chad could you come on down Chad bevens woohoo and also principal principal Kevin Henshaw are you here thank you principal Henshaw Jordan wrote about Chad bevens Mr bevens is enthusiastic and happy students in his class and the hallways can't help

008but feel that excitement as Mr bevens brightens their day by saying hello he diligently identifies essential standards and ensures each student learns them as a wrestling coach he is always recruited and working to build the team he is a huge asset to our community it is a privilege for me to learn from and work with Chad [Applause] bevens next up we have Julie Burnside and we'd like to invite Julie she was nominated by Heidi woley if she's here please also come up and principal Gina wit [Applause] Heidi Heidi wrote my family family has been with alpine online since 2014 Julie bernside has been the teacher for three of my kids she has always been very supportive and helpful she is always readily available anytime my kids need help with questions they have with their lessons

009she encourages them to keep moving forward thank you Julie next is Rachel Lindsay who is a par educator at Foothill she was nominated by Ciana DS and so we'd like to invite Rachel colana and principal Kyle Hoops to come on [Applause] up paana wrote Rachel goes above and beyond in her role as a par educator in small group autism classroom she demonstrates problem solving skills and a positive attitude that inspires the students and colleagues around her one of the most remarkable aspects of Rachel is her willingness to help others she regularly goes out of her way to support other teachers and other students throughout the school her hard work and dedication to Foothill does not go unnoticed thank you Rachel next up we have Trina Jackson and we invite Trina Bethany and principal Park to

010come [Applause] forward Bethany wrote Mrs Jackson is so supportive she goes out of her way to communicate and ensure parents feel involved my son was injured at school and no one seemed to know what had happened when she found out that no one had told me she wrote me a detailed explanation she is fun welcoming and encourages students to reach their potential next we would like to recognize uh Jonathan horen and also invite Jill and Principal Paul to come on up with Jonathan um yay Jill wrote for years my kids couldn't wait to get to fifth grade so that they could have Mr horn for their English teacher in the DLI program he's an exceptional teacher because he listens he cares about the individual and he is consistently joyful Mr horn truly listens to the

011students and parents he has an exceptional ability to care about the needs of each individual in his class and he has a constant smile he shows up every day full of joy to be teaching [Applause] next we'd like to recognize Linda McCoy and invite her down along with principal Hannah figero who nominated her Linda principal figuro wrote Linda took on the project of our teens Center she has spent time dreaming of what would be best for students working with construction to ensure the structure could serve students designing purchasing decorating and most importantly serving students she makes hard and sometimes uncomfortable situations feel manageable and survivable she wants to ensure that the whole student is cared for if you have the chance to visit our teen center you will see she has done remarkable work which

012is inspiring and encouraging for both staff and students and I can attest that the work of Linda McCoy puts she tells those kids how valuable they are by what she does for them so thank you so much Linda next up um if we can have Brinn Losi of Westfield Elementary come up and we invite Marley and principal Stewart to come up as well if they're here tonight Marley wrote Mrs Losi is deserving of this award because she go goes above and beyond to inspire and engag students fostering a love for learning she creates a positive inclusive environment where everyone feels valued and supported my child is autistic with physical disabilities Mrs Losi loved and cared for him as her own uring he had every support he needed to succeed academically and socially congratul [Applause] ulations

013and our last nominee tonight goes to Brian Crosby and we invite him as well as Tim Randall the parent who nominated him and principal Shane Hill to come [Applause] forward Tim wrote the dedication by Brian Crosby to the musical instruction of his kids is nothing short of amazing we have had two kids in his classes over the years and he's always pushing the kids to better themselves while putting an immense amount of extra time before and after school to help his bands his work is noted by the consistent Awards of his higher level bands win every year at the state and Regional competitions we have seen the improvement in our K in our kids by having him as a music teacher he deserves a nomination for rise for his selfless dedication to his band kids

014and their Improvement [Applause] congratulations got do two lines no no it's okay know how to find our way we we just has trained us well we're good we just kind of e e now we'd like to shake the hands of all of our awardees so if you'll just come up and over e I'd like to take a moment of um Personal Privilege if I might to say thank you at this point um I spent 30 years teaching in Alpine School District and I became aware that there were so many people that helped me on that Journey every single day and I would just like to read a statement of thanks to all of our Alpine family you know the the thought came to me as I was thinking about this you're like when you have

015a problem in your classroom who you going to call and there's these are the people you call um so my heartfelt Thanks goes out to our warehouse people who order and deliver classroom supplies and materials everything from paper for the Band-Aids bus drivers who bring our students to school every day they are usually the first and last ASD employee that our students get to see our lunch workers who offer the students good to make sure the students have good nutrition so they can learn the nurses counselors and psychologists who take care of their physical and emotional needs Media Center people who provide opportunities for students to take flight into exciting new worlds secretaries who keep everything running smoothly and on time custodians who make sure the buildings are clean and safe the snow shoveled the

016grass green the playing fields groomed not to mention the days when they are called to clean up messes including those left behind by six students electricians plumbers and Carpenters who create safe and functional learning environments computer technicians to make sure the system is up and running every day Alpine has almost 10,000 employees and every one of them is important every single one of them has a part to play so I think think I can speak on behalf of the entire board to say thank you to our Alpine family and to their families and all those people who uh who rely on us and rely on them so thank you to all of our Alpine employees who make it happen every single day now yeah okay now we have one more award to give this pretty

017exciting um we're going to invite Elizabeth Robinson and Miss Lake and principal Keen to come forward um so while coming board I will say I have nous Lake for a very long time and I love the environment that she has for her students that allows them to create so it is absolutely Mak sense to me that Elizabeth was chosen so we want to congratulate Elizabeth Robinson from Lehigh jior high her design was selected for our 2024 District holiday card thank you Elizabeth for sharing your outstanding artistic talent with us and we present you with um the original artwork that has been framed along with a few copies of the greeting card tossue share with your family and friends well [Applause] done e Elizabeth Shake our hands Elizabeth come you know when you say does anybody

018else have pictures or want to take pictures we all want her picture I think it's inspiring okay it's always dangerous to hand me a micone microphone um tonight we want to do a special recognition and we're actually recognizing president hackin this is her last board meeting um after serving on the board for eight years and so we want to take the time to recognize the contribution that Sarah has um how she's made a difference in the lives of so many students and employees so Sarah has served eight years on the board um under her leadership our priorities have been student achievement teacher effectiveness and stakeholder engagement so eight years that means eight budget Cycles it means eight enrollment projections and it means eight legislative sessions um each of those carry their own weight um during

019Sarah's time on the board we have navigated a pandemic and Utah had less learning loss than any state in the country we expanded full day kindergarten to every school every Elementary School in the district if that eight years we have also built two high schools Skyridge and Cedar Valley as well as the rebuild of leeh high high we have built two middle schools lake mountain and Viewpoint and we have built nine elementary schools Springside Belmont Brook Haven Centennial Liberty Hills Silver Lake Harbor Point Trailside and desert sky in addition to that we have done rebuilds of Grove Crest Cascade Central as well as the Space Center in Greenwood Sarah's service has impacted and influenced thousands of students and thousands of of employees and we are incredibly grateful for her service thank you [Applause] Sarah it's

020it's a group effort guys it's always a group effort oh that's so beautiful thank oh thank you oh it's got little guys on it thank you wonderful do we want to do like a board photo can we a board photo maybe with us coming out is that okay that' be nice be [Applause] e [Applause] well thank you all thank you for coming and thank you for this lovely recognition I love flowers absolutely love them all right it's time for Community comments and we only have one from Tamara bar so Tamara come on up if you're here with the rise people you need to leave this is a good time to go you're you're welcome to leave we know a lot of you have families and other things going on tonight thank you very much for

021taking my comment I'm here to address the AL program that we're voting on tonight I've had five kids that participated in the AL program at Cherry Hill Foo Hill and Orum Elementary and I currently teach third grade at Cherry Hill Elementary and as a parent of all students only two of mine were able to participate in the third grade program and all of them really would have benefited from being able to participate in the third grade all program I have one student in my class right now who's reading at a sixth grade level and another one who's at a kindergarten level and that sixth grade reading level student would really benefit from being in an all program because it's hard to differentiate from Kid Garten up to sixth grade and my reading my math and

022everything like that so I just wanted to say please consider what benefits our students and how do we answer that question of how do we help the students who already know thank you Tamara all right we are moving through the agenda um the next item is the approval of the minutes do I have a motion to approve the minutes I move that we approve the minutes and a second second okay it's been moved by AA and seconded by Joy Lynn that we approve the minutes is there any discussion seeing none all in favor say I I I any oppos say nay thank you the minutes stand approved claims Dr Farnsworth yes president hackin you have received as board the claims for the month and I recommend you accept the claims thank you do I have

023a motion to accept the claims I move that we accept the claims and do I have a second I second the motion okay it's been moved by by States and seconded by Mark that we accept the claims is there any discussion see seeing none all in favor say I I I any say okay the claims stand accepted thank you routine business yes youve received the routine business for this month and I recommend you accept the routine business I move that we accept the routine business and do I have a second second okay it's been moved by Sarah and seconded by aah is there any discussion for the public routine business includes budget summary Alpine Foundation board summary Personnel hiring and releases laa specific licenses School Land Trust amendments and 2425 schoolwide positive behavior plans all

024of those were sent to the board uh several days ago and we've had a chance to read through all of those is there any discussion okay seeing none um all in favor of approving the routine business say I I any oppos say n thank you that stands approved now action items yes our first action item is the determination of the boundary for the new Middle School in Eagle Mountain we'd invite uh Eric Woodhouse director of operations for Alpine School District come forward and Brian Jolly principal of the new to be named in the future Middle School in Eagle Mountain but we need to get a boundary first so uh they have a short presentation they'll review with you this is a process has gone on over the last several months we've gotten great feedack feedback

025I appreciate the work of Eric and the team um to do due diligence and getting feedback and establishing making a recommendation to the board for a boundary so Eric we'll Tri some time over to you thank you superintendent we're really excited about this part of the process I think that there has been kind of a process and excitement of getting this boundary in place so that um principal Jolly can start uh figuring out which students are going to go to a school and start getting everything in place and naming the school and there's a lot of excitement in this boundary too because we done a lot of work trying to really figure out what would work best for this uh school and either one of these options I think will work really good that we've

026proposed um of course as a boundary committee there is one that we are leaning towards but just kind of want to review with you really quick what we've gone over and what those boundaries are so items for consideration option A what you're really looking at here is a division of the Firefly development as well as a division of the Hidden Hollow boundaries and so some things to consider transportation to and from the Firefly development Works a little bit better in this option because of sr73 going to the new Middle School large new developments are evenly split so as the Firefly development kind of builds out then that enrollment is going to be split between the new middle school and the frontier um Hidden Hollow split both Middle School makes sense for the kind of the

027traffic flow it's a little better pattern for those families however in the 50-50 split of Hidden Hollow they recommended keeping the neighborhoods together so sometimes when you split it's not necessarily keeping a neighborhood together for um the enrollment consider ation as far as balancing that enrollment out so that was some of the options for uh the positive comments on option A some of the positive comments for option b Firefly development goes all to Frontier which uh starts Frontier a little bit uh lower because as it builds out um then it'll have more room for Frontier to go because all of hidden Halla will go to the new Middle School favored by families from Hidden Hollow because it keeps that um enrollment going the same to the new middle school and we feel like that's kind

028of the best option there as far as keeping Hidden Hollow together so those are some of the considerations our team met uh with supervisors and principal Jolly um looked over option A and option b right now our leaning is towards option b we feel like uh keeping Hidden Hollow together and then starting Frontier a little bit lower and allowing that enrollment to grow into the frontier boundaries is and starting the new Middle School a little bit higher allows him to start his programs and overall we feel like option b is a better consideration for this but we understand that it's the board's recommendation and consideration so we put that to the board for your uh consideration and vote all right do have do I have a motion to um accept one of these boundary plans

029I move that we accept option b for the boundary for the new Middle School in Eagle Mountain and I'll second that okay it's been moved by Julie and seconded by join so let's start with Julie would you like to make comments on this uh appreciate all the work that the committee has done and this has been a very long process getting a lot of feedback um this one was close right like either one of them are a good solid option um it came down to two things for me first off I like the idea of keeping Hidden Hollow together we just had a reboundary of that school not too long ago um to have kids flipping back and forth is is tough I will also say um I recognize the challenge of when you go

030to Hidden Hollow you may be living very very close to Unity path CL which you can see Frontier from so that sometimes feels like wait what are they deciding um a big thing for me too is just looking forward we know the Firefly development is going to significantly increase population we know that Frontier has the ability to stretch and grow since they're around 1800 students and so we know that they can do that um but I will say even though there is a differential starting out in just a few years as happens in the west um both of those schools will be pushing you know over 1600 so um I would also say this is not the last boundary change that will happen in Eagle Mountain especially when it comes to secondary schools um because

031before you know it there will be a need for another middle school and we'll be doing the process all over again so um I'm just incredibly grateful to the committee um for all the work that they've did I I'm grateful for the amount of feedback that we received from community members their involvement in the Committees that was fantastic it their perspectives um and I'm just yeah I think this is the best option um and I think this one will serve both schools uh for longer not longterm longer um and I'm very excited and I know Brian a big piece for you is you need to figure out how many employees you need to hire and based on how many students you're going to have is how many employees you can to hire so I know

032um please don't work too hard over the holiday break because I'm a little bit worried about you're going to get these numbers and go down a rabbit hole so please take the time off okay thanks okay other board comments um I just wanted to thank the community for the amount of comments that they did send and and their involvement in the process and their willingness to to realize that this isn't a final boundary that it's going to continue to change and they're going to continue to shift as that Community continues to grow and just their patience with us as we work through boundary issues so really appreciate the community and want to thank them for their support and I'm excited to move forward with boundary B any other board comments okay sing then then oh

033a go ahead I was just going to say thank you for the data summary and all those who are uh responsible for getting that in in a concise way for us we appreciate it okay Moment of Truth all in favor of approving option b for the the new boundaries for the new Middle School say I I any oppose say nay all right there you have it okay congratulations go name that school make it happen Okay Okay the next several items we have broken out as individual items for the program studies the formal study we've done on gifted and talented and dual language immersion and the possible closure of a couple of schools we have broken those out individually so that board members could um vote on each one of those proposals individually and just for

034a reminder or maybe new information to the public these were recommendations that were made a couple of years ago by the staff to be implemented in the fall of 25 and 26 last year legislative session changed the statute requiring board approval we open back up the formal study of those this fall um PRI or prior to the vote being taken in November for the reconfiguration of Alpine School District I know that that is T being taken into consideration as board members consider these changes um we needed to start that process before the vote so that we' run the full statutory required time in order for the board to make a decision by the end of this month so the first recommendation the first uh aspect of study that was being considered was the expansion of

035third grade um Advanced learning lab programs across the district okay do I have a motion to expand the third grade Al programs across the district I move to expand the third grade alll programs to include third grade in all second the motion okay it's been moved by drena seconded by Mark uh board member comments I'm just really excited to move forward with this like Tamara commented earlier on that it's just going to be a benefit for students across the district to be able to enter that um Advanced learning Lab at an earlier age so I'm excited to move forward with this we do have that in a few schools right now this would expand it to all of the schools so other comments I agree I'm very excited about being able to offer this to

036more students if there are no other comments let's take a vote all in favor of expanding the third grade programs the Alo programs to third grade please say I I any oppos say n all right thank you I I failed to acknowledge express our appreciation to Dr Analise surce and her team for the work that they've done on Gathering feedback and sharing with the board and she would love an opportunity to come forward with her teammates to uh sit here and be available for any questions that surface in the process of this discussion thank you Dr Ruiz appreciate that okay the next item is the uh Al program study another component of that is the creation of a new program at Silver Lake Elementary okay do I have a motion to create a new Al

037program at Silver Lake Elementary I move that we create a new all program at Silver Lake Elementary second okay it's been moved by Julie and seconded by join uh board member comments just gratitude for the team for this um for looking into doing a districtwide analysis and finding out where gaps were and so thank you for the work just really excited for this program to come into a community that could benefit it there's a great need in both the Westlake and the Cedar Valley cluster for additional seats and we're glad to be able to provide those seats for students that that need them any other comments Cas seeing none let's vote all in favor of expanding or creating new program at Silver L Elementary say I I any oppos say n okay thank you next

038the next uh Alo program study recommendation was the creation of a new program at Shelley Elementary okay do I have a motion I move that we create a new Pro Al program at shelle elementary and do I have a second I'll second it okay a board member comments just excited to have Al in af um right now the programs are a little distant from so many of our AF schools so just excited to bring that opportunity more students other comments I think one thing that I've I've been weighing as I look at this is what would the new school board in that Central District area uh want it's uh possible that they would want this program in another location um I think that this kind of centers most of those programs in the north however

039uh you know I'm I'm supportive of the the board members in that area and I think that uh if they decided to move that program they could do that after the new District's created there there's two things I've been thinking about uh we had an all program in American Fork for years and years and years that was our second program we started at Cherry Hill and then uh I was sent to Barrett Elementary to open a program here and so we had a program in American Fork for 20 years at least and um there is a lot of impetus to bring it back however there are also three other programs that are in this area so I would really like to hear from the board members from this area in terms of the concern that

040if we open this program now then when the new school boards are seated will they have to juggle boundaries or close programs or um it what do you think about is this the right time to do this well well and that's a good question I mean Mark kind of alluded to that previously and that's been one of my concerns is what this will look like in a couple of years when we have a new school board we don't presume to know every you know the new school board's Vision or the superintendent's goals for that new District however I think at the moment putting it there and let's seeing What's happen what happens we may have to see some adjustments through the central area just like Mark had said and maybe moving programs around a little

041bit um I'm not sure I mean that's definitely going to be up to uh a new board but there is some hesitation you hate to start something that you don't know in the next couple of years of of what that's going to be so um I haven't had anyone contact me with concern about this right now it's just gratitude for being able to for the Shelly placement um I think I would also say overwhelmingly that that is Al is probably the thing that we hear from most parents about is wanting more programs I think we'll absolutely need to look at the ones in the Lone Peak cluster but I don't foresee that impacting um creating the program at Shell um Dr Ruiz what was the committee recommendation about this particular placement yeah the committee's recommendation

042is that many families don't want to drive as far as those programs in the north end of our district and so we were losing a lot of students because of the distance and so opening a program in the American Fork area will attract those students and we will able to provide them with the access closer to home and and I appreciate the comment that we're possibly acting premature a future board but I think it will also creating this program will allow for that possible distribution prior to that board needing to make that decision so they'll see where the will of families are to establish and it may give them some data whereby they could determine what those fi what the final location of those programs should be in that new District yeah definitely in two

043years you'll have enough data to see where the demand is where students are driving to and from and then decide which programs to keep and which ones maybe to face out over time okay other other board comments okay it was moved by Stacy and Sarah seconded by Sarah B that we uh create a new program at shelle elementary all in favor say I I any oppos say n thank you and congratulations um Shelley Elementary right he action item number five is a DLI program study item it's creation of a new Spanish DLI program at Mountain Trails Elementary need a motion I move that we create a new Spanish D program at Mountain Trails Elementary and a second I'll second okay moved by Julie and seconded by julin uh board member comments um this one I

044was really excited when the committee came forward with this recommendation um Mountain Trails is a unique school system it's Unique geographically um as to where it's located in Eagle Mountain and the students that it serves and because the other DLI program in the Cedar Valley clust cluster is essentially on the edge of Eagle Mountain and the way that it kind of hits where you've got Black Ridge Harvest Riverview kind of all in this one big really tight s um it's really limited the access that students can have with this program we've also seen a significant uptick um in the amount of multi language Learners we have in the area and so we're excited about being able to serve um some of our multilanguage Learners where this could be a support for them um so I

045I'm thrilled that this recommendation came forward incredibly grateful um and from what I've heard from the community um just very grateful that this was an opportunity that we had for their children so I'm thank you Other Board member comments yeah I just have a clarifying question for staff just make sure I'm understanding this right when we start a new DLI program the first year it's just first grade and then second grade so it's going to build momentum over time great thank you other comments all right um it was moved by Julie and seconded by Joy Lynn that we create a new Spanish DLI program at Mountain Trails Elementary all in favor say I I any oppos say nay okay congratulations Mountain Trails next item is a DLI program study item the creation of a new

046Spanish DLI program at River Rock Elementary I move that we create a new Spanish DLI program at River Rock Elementary and I second that okay moov by Stacy and seconded by Joy Lyn board member comments um so I think we're most excited about this because we thought we were getting a program six years ago and that didn't happen so there has been ample time for the community to um be excited and anticipate this um we're excited for the opportunities for our multil language learners for the roles that our native Spanish speakers will play in this program I think this is a really it's a perfect spot for a Spanish program it's going to help out the will Creek numbers and the Le high high school um program as well so just a lot of really

047excited people and I will say thank you to staff for um when we came back with the question that could we move this so that it would be a little more Central to us Lehi um thank you for moving away from 2100 I don't wish to send anyone else over there than we need to um and so so thank you for looking at that and coming up with another solution and also thank you to principal Ridge and to our River Rock teachers who have they're just excited for this program and I think man when teachers are excited and families are excited it's it's going to be a very cool thing to watch this grow and and the way that it um helps students in our community um I just want to comment I know that

048as we create new districts we're going to have to look at that West leehigh area and do some boundary adjustments but where we're just adding first grade and then second grade we're going to have time ample time for those new boards to look at and adjust and potentially build and maybe even close a school in that area and aign um but it's not going to be impacted by going ahead and getting this started and allowing that program to flourish in an area that has been I want to say underserved but really it's been a lack of service of a DLI program in the Lehigh Community um in the Lehi High School feeder system and so it's time and let's let's start moving forward and I'm sure a new board will tackle all of those boundaries

049as they come forward other comments all right let's vote on the creation of a new Spanish DLI program at River Rock Elementary all in favor say I I any opposed say nay thank you congratulations to River Rock with the build of a new Junior High School in the Eagle Mountain Area currently the Chinese DLI pathway goes from Black Ridge to Frontier Middle School with Black Ridge being in the new Junior High boundaries as that was established tonight with that boundary we recommend a change of the pathway from Frontier Middle School to the new Eagle Mountain Middle School for the Chinese dual language pathway in that area Okay do I have a motion I motion that we change the Mandarin DLI pathway from Frontier Middle to the new Eagle Mountain Middle School second I'll second okay

050moved by Julie and seconded by Jin board member comments um I'm going to recognize that this one actually has some mixed opinions from from Mandarin parents um so I want to acknowledge that first off that not every parent is going to be thrilled about this movement um I based on the proximity of the Black Ridge School to the new middle it just makes sense do I realize that there are students who travel outside of that that boundary absolutely and so I want to recognize that I know that there is also significant concern um based on the location as far as sr73 there are some challenges on that road that I know you are both very well aware of as far as speed and safety and that when mag data has come out that road in

051particular is one that we're significantly concerned about when it comes to student safety um I know that the city is working to try and get a lighted intersection to the new middle school before school opens that's one of their focuses um so we are working with the city and trying to be very intentional about making sure that student safety is you know the number one priority um but I think that this will be a long-term benefit that will lead to less movement in the future and I think anytime that we can find stability in a high growth area I take that as a huge win okay any other comments I just wanted to comment on that creation of stability um if we left it at Frontier that could also be taxing on Frontier having two

052DLI programs come through their school um this just allows both schools to have access to DLI program um it allows the community to have some choice and we really appreciate that so thank you any further comments all right let's vote on changing the Chinese DLI pathway from Frontier Middle School to the new Eagle Mountain Middle School all in favor say I I anyos say n okay that passes now before we go on to the next item I would like to just make one comment um we have had alll programs in the district since and the very first language programs were before that they were at Cherry Hill Elementary where they had Spanish Immersion so these are programs that are longstanding programs but as the district has expanded West the programs have not and so it

053is time for us to do this and I am just thrilled that we were able to do this that that the study was done that these schools are willing to to host these programs and that the board is willing to support this kind of expansion because this is a definit def itely a great direction for the district to be moving at this time so thank you everyone thank you the next item is a closure of Windsor Elementary we put that prior to item number nine the DLI program study uh the merger of the Windsor Elementary creation of a magnet program in Orchard because they're related um to that so we wanted to get the will of the board on the closure of Windsor which would influence obviously the determin mination of the whether or not

054we merge those uh programs and create a magnet program so the next item is a closure of Windsor Elementary I move that we table the closure of winds Windsor Elementary okay do I have a second I second that motion can I clarify the closure of that would mean there's a formal St study going on right now we would end the formal study with no action or are you tabling it for future action no I could could we have you rephrase that to say I move that we conclude the formal study with no action okay I move that we conclude our formal study with no action for closure of wsor Elementary okay thank you can I second that motion thank you all right board board discussion and this is really your area Sarah it is and

055some of my people are right there and we been talking about this for years and um yeah go ahead with your and I absolutely support not closing Windor at this time and everyone in my area knows that my dream is to rebuild Windsor to find the funding rebuild Windsor and then take action from there and that's something that a future board will want to do but Windsor is a strong School they've got good enrollment they have a prime location they've got great teachers so I think at this time it would be premature to close that school and let's um my inclination is let's rebuild it and let a future board take it from there when when we can so I just I I also think agree with this motion to terminate the study with while

056taking no action um I think we've discussed several things that would uh a future board could contemplate with respect to uh this uh South New South District uh one of them is uh uh moving ninth grade into the high schools uh which would boost the high school enrollment uh if that were to occur then there would be a you know a domino effect where we would probably need to close one Junior High at least and possibly move six grades into junior highs and all of those things would affect which schools would need to be Consolidated or closed closed and so I think that really this project needs to uh be taken by the future board with kind of a global um uh perspective including all of these pieces so that we get the right things

057happening at the elementary level other comments I actually am not in favor of of tbling this of putting it off um I I think we are the only area of the three uh districts that were created with the past election that has a serious um deficit and as such that we are going to have to to do some serious belt tightening in order to meet our long-term goals which is to be a viable and competitive uh school district and I I really am voting and protest on behalf of our administrators and teachers who have endured quite a bit of uncertainty right now and it is only in their interest that I am uh lodging a friendly uh no vote um but I hope that uh future boards will be aggressive in attacking um making us

058a solvent and competitive School District um and I I do count on them to um to follow through on these things we do have two Spanish programs that are right next to each other we have a very low enrolled school we have General ed students who are not being well served in this area and um these are problems that will'll need to be addressed by a future board and I recognize that that they um are I hope that there is as committed as I am to solving these problems thank you I was grateful for the opportunity to go with a AA and I went and visited uh Windsor and Lyndon and I mean there's obvious difficulties in those schools and in a regular Alpine School District year I think the decision would be obvious but

059whereas since we are splitting the landscape has completely changed when I look back on the split and this is just my feeling on it I don't think people chose to split because they didn't feel like Alpine School District was not providing a good educational experience for their kids nor do I believe that it was um anything fiscal any fiscal irresponsibility I think we've been very very fiscal which leaves uh the third prong which is the possibility of it people voting for a split because of the idea of local control which I believe we should honor that I wasn't for the split but I think we should honor the vote and that just changes um my lens on so many things I don't presume to know what a future board what their goals and Visions will

060be or their new superintendent and I know that Oram and Lyon and Pleasant Grove and Vineyard are going to have to really take a look at what this is going to mean for their area some of the push back I've gotten and I understand it is by holding off and and having a new board do this um it may be longer than a year and maybe we can't wait a year well the thing is is that January of 2026 when you have a new board in their first responsibility or task is going to be hiring a new superintendent and business administrator and looking at a budget is right behind that and they are going to have to make some real tough calls and decisions and I just feel like um it just has changed a

061complete different lens and it's it's difficult but our job I feel like as a board currently is to make sure that we are doing things that set up different District these three districts up for success and one could argue and say to me well Sarah guess what I don't think you're setting them up for Success because there are so many issues that maybe it could impact the schools and I understand that however I think the underlying principle is making sure that we're honoring the what I believe is probably the desire of local control and I support that I and I know that we've heard from teachers and people that are in those schools every day and I go back to the local control but they don't so I mean I would say the majority don't

062live in that Community or that area and so it's it's been a hard decision for me because I can see you know some of the challenges of these schools and yet um I feel like honoring the vote and moving forward and trying to do things the right way for these three new districts sued some of these issues and that they'll they'll as a community have to Grapple with all of that thank you any other board member comments okay it was I I'm sorry go ahead I used to think my talent was sleeping and I could sleep anytime anywhere um the last three months have proven that very wrong as I find myself up at 2 A.M a lot thinking about this decision I give myself a lot of pats on the back for not responding

063to emails at 2 am um because maybe I am more asleep than I think um but a lot of sleepless nights have gone into this as I look at that North quadrant of of Oram and into that there's a significant decline in students from when I had the privilege of teaching at Windsor back in the 9s um it's a great community and and I understand that um keeping it open has has costs associated with it there there is financial implications of of keeping a school open when they don't have the student enrollment to sustain all of the programs they've become accustomed to um Alpine School District only grew 30 students last year um 250 of those students were at the high school in my neighborhood so when you start thinking about that you realize that

064to grow 30 and that there there's a lot of change in where the students are located um not only is there a fiscal impact there's an an educational opportunities impact um the ability to have teachers we might have to do some split classes that's not always super ideal um but it's a possib so as I really grappled with that cost and cost isn't just a financial but how it impacts those communities and then I too go back like Sarah um to to making decisions closes to the community and and I think at this point it it's a benefit to to hold off a little we um and let that new board come in and really look at that but that new board that is elected if anybody thinks they're going to get off without closing

065a school in that area financially I'm not I'm sure that's not possible that those decisions have to be made I'm not a fan of kicking the can down the road I think that's how we got to this situation um and to continue to kick it kind of led to my sleepless nights but at the end I think we need to allow for that local proc just a note for our our Windsor parents I have been looking for a way to rebuild Windsor for several years now and we don't qualify for any state or federal money at this point uh there's nothing there's no help that way and so joyn is right there's going to be some some tough decisions but I would like to see that future board take that on because Windsor is a

066great location and it's a it's a spacious uh piece of of acreage and there's a lot of advantages but that is not a decision that this Board needs to make or can make at this time so we have a motion by I just had one more comment I I know that as we look at uh a three-way split a lot of our employees are being asked where do you want to serve where would you like to teach where would you like to to be uh a support to Educators and I would like my area to be a choice that they would make and I think and I'm just saying that that is why I'm going to vote the way I vote tonight because I want us to be a destination District that is chosen because

067their board is willing to do the hard work and make it so that as much money can get to the classrooms as possible that is what a teacher is looking at that is what a superintendent is looking at that is what a business administrator is looking at how willing is this board to do the hard work so I'm just going to say that's what my vote is going to represent tonight thank you any other comments um I think when I take when I make decisions a lot of times I feel like we have 80 20 or 60 40 votes where it feels like there's one that is definitely you know putting your finger on the scale and you know which way it's laning um this one's been a 4951 for me um and that's I

068think where a lot of us have struggled um I know the focus is on Windsor because that's the one this the school that is considering being closed but at the same time um if we choose not to close Winder also impacts Northridge it impacts Orchard it impacts Foothill um and I have struggled with this one and it was interesting to me because even today I was getting emails someone saying please close wsor and then 10 minutes later please keep wsor open and it's and it's this kind of thing of like you want to be responsive to the community and everybody thinks they represent the majority and we're getting a lot of conflicting information right and because I think it's a 4951 is why I'm willing to push this decision to a new board um but

069I also want to be very very clear that um the new board will have a heavy lift with this um my recommendation personally will be that they need to look at a boundary change over the entire South area of the district that it needs to look at you know whether and and maybe the decision made by that new board is not the closure of Windor it's a rebounder some in some other way and just at the same time we were talking about Shelly right is that the right location for an Al program the only reason I have pause and I'm saying okay maybe this is a decision for a future board is because I don't want to make a DEC DEC ision that a board might make differently based on information when they look at

070the entire South District as a whole instead of looking at one or two pieces of student population I also do want to recognize that what Ada is saying is correct that there is a deficit in the South and one of my goals has been not to disadvantage any District regardless of the configuration and um so I'm also so communicating that you know I I'm willing to have conversations throw out ideas um but as far as no action being taken prior to July 1 of 2027 I think that would be a significant disservice to the Linden Oram Vineyard and Pleasant Grove area actions do need to be taken um I am willing to assign that in a way to their area and their level of representation but I want to be very very clear that actions

071will need to be taken and they will need to be significant um I think everyone here is willing to help and roll up our sleeves and do what needs to be done while also recognizing the autonomy that the South District deserves thank you this is something we've been talking about for years couple of years and it's it's a tough one so the motion at hand made by Aiden second by Mark is to conclude the study with no action that means keeping winds are open for now all in favor say I I all oppose say nay thank you n thank you Aida given the vote that just took place to take no action with the closure of wind our staff would recommend that the board not merge The Windsor DLI program and create a magnet program

072at Orchard Elementary you need to make a motion that is a recommendation of Staff okay we need to need a motion then okay I'd like to make a motion that we conclude the DLI program study which propos the merger of windson Elementary di program with the creation of magnet program at Orchard Elementary conclude that study um that formal study by taking no action I'll second it okay it's been moved by Mark and second by Sarah uh board member comments um a lot of the the uh discussion we've had previously with regard to closing winds are also applies here however there's one additional piece and that is um if we were moving forward a whole district and trying out this new idea of a magnet uh DLI program I think that we would have the uh

073critical mass to actually make that work uh I'm concerned that in the midst of a district split trying to create a new magnet program would not be wise uh and that we should delay and let a new board contemplate that okay other comments I I think that's well spoken I think that we all agree with that that it's a matter of timing at this point and letting a future board make those decisions so all in favor of it's been moved by Mark second by Sarah all in favor of um closing the study concluding the study to merge Windsor Elementary DLI with the creation of a magnet program at Orchard Elementary that we conclude that with no action in other words we leave it as it is um all in favor say I I any oppose

074say nay okay thank you last item with respect to these formal studies was the closure of Lyndon Elementary like to make a motion I'd like to move that we conclude the formal study of the closure of Lynden Elementary by taking no action do I have a second I'll second okay mov by Mark and seconded by Stacy board member comments yeah so I've uh I think uh it's interesting to look at some of these consolidation plans again I I'm going to fall back on uh again you know as as we has been mentioned before that we really need to probably look at boundaries for all of these schools in that South district and it's un it's not easy to predict what a future board would want to do with respect to these schools um if it

075were a straight if there were room I would be tempted to go forward anyway but the current proposal would need five uh portable units to house those students and I think that would put an undue pressure on the bathrooms the lunch room all kinds of things at Rocky Mountain I think that uh as I've looked at projections for enrollments it's not like things are going to change drastically in the next two years I think that the uh the new board could make a decision on what to do with those more effectively than we could I also think that if we we have new information now that we didn't have when we looked did the initial b uh study of this uh this closure now we know that the district's going to be splitting and I

076think that uh that new information could have impacted that decision and uh probably if we look at this down down the road when the new board is seated that they will be able to to include that in their decision and make a a wiser decision one thing I was going to mention I think I can speak on behalf of all of us is that we've all received um feedback emails um comments from people members of the community and we've read all of those and I think that's important I think it it's just worth saying it's just a we're looking at things in such a different lens now that as a board I think we need to be careful just in the in the future of and we will you know be meeting next month and

077re-evaluating our goals and re-evaluating and adjusting you know our vision and for what it is and being careful care ful that we're not you know handcuffing the new board but it's a delicate balance it's something different and has never really been done in the state of Utah with the three with a three-way Rec reconfiguration but I think it's just a good reminder of our board to make sure that we are stepping where we need to step and stepping off where we need to step off so we can allow areas to flourish and making sure that we're we're not getting in the way of progress and decisions that will be made from future boards and yet at the same time time trying to set them up for Success so like I said it's going to be

078a very delicate balance but just being mindful as a board that um this process is going to be unique and delicate in the future and to be very careful of how we're making those decisions and and setting up uh new districts and hopefully it will be a successful adjustment I think not I think I know I have talked with met with more London parents than anybody in my area over the last few months um I think some of my biggest concerns here um it it's hard when I appreciate I appreciate the passion behind loud people but I also feel like sometimes we do a due service to the people who um particularly for our employees that maybe aren't comfortable coming here um the thing that is most concerning to me through this whole process is

079the employees who have said I feel like the parents don't care how this impacts us or what this is it means among our faculty and so um while I do think closing it is the right thing I also know what it is to represent an area that has decisions made by people who are not in that area and who don't know what's best for that area which is why I'm willing to support not closing it but I do hope that those who will make the decision will consider consider um as we've seen with several schools that we brought on study and then pushed it off and brought it back and pushed it off for the people that are in the building every day it's different as a parent when you go in and you're reading

080in a classroom or helping with a party or maybe doing math facts um it's a much different lens than if you're an employee in that building and if you're an employee in a building who has been up for discussion multiple times that that is a very heavy weight on them it's a heavy lift on our principles who are doing their best to keep everybody um morale High when there's constant discussions um and so I I hope that as we move forward with the people that are making the discuss the decision that they'll really um consider how this um impacts everybody and and I also think it's interesting um Lyon and Elementary was are not the only students in Lyndon so I heard from numerous parents who said we just want to stay together and there

081seems to be a little bit of of a community sentiment that somehow the Rocky Mountain students are not part of that lyen community and so I would just encourage um everyone to have open mind and consider that if you live in Lyndon and you have a student you have a lynen Elementary student um additionally I uh I've been in that building a lot of times over the years and it's only recently that I have determined that there are Florida ceiling windows in too many places um I'm concerned you know with HB 84 and the safety adjustments that have to be made um that's concerning as well um and I do worry about the future boards because I feel like it's hard to come in when a previous board has tied your hand or not let

082left enough room so I offer my apologies to the employees and the parents who were very much hoping for a different outcome tonight so that they could move forward um but at the end of the day I do think that it does need to be made um by the people who live in that area and I think with a lens on the whole South area examining um GLI at Rocky Mountain um with that not being a viable program um I think there will be some other decisions made so um and I would also say I want to caution the Future Leaders that I've heard a lot about growth in Lyndon and I I think we all have a different meaning when we say growth what is growth in Lehi is not current growth in Engle

083mountain and any growth coming to Lyon isn't even close to those other areas or as well so um I guess I would just encourage everybody to um do your due diligence look at what are the number of um homes coming and when you look at the number of homes how many students is that really going to generate so um we have actually I think over the last couple of years um got a lot of support for the idea of closing lynen as long as they stay together you know as long as the AL comes with them they're not split and sent to different places we've had letters uh signed by members of the PTA or members of The Faculty there is a lot of support for closing Lynden it is an old building it was

084built in the 50s it has got seismic issues it's it's U it takes takes a lot of upkeep and so there is a significant case for closing Lyndon the question is is now the time and with the district uh configuration I I was in favor of closing Lyndon as you were and I think all of us I think every one of us have been to Rocky Mountain and taken a tour looked at the classrooms looked at the maps looked at the playground look at the grass areas look where you could put Portables every one of us has actually walked the walk and been out to those schol schools um maybe more than once and I think a lot of us feel like lynon needs to be closed but is now the time and is this

085the way and that's that's the question that we're confronting right now so it's it's a tough one it it is kicking the can down the road but it is um a future board is going to have to really wrestle with this in a very significant way all right is there any other discussion yes go ahead I just want to say I have been to these two schools I have talked with their admin administrators and I will again be making a protest vote I I just hope that between now and when this decision comes before a board again that there's some process changes um when we started this we had to have a crystal ball as to all of the opportunities that we might consider the outcome 90 days later and as we interacted with the

086community if new ideas were generated that hadn't been thought of that had some um validity to them we couldn't explore them because we hadn't noticed them and that becomes very problematic as you enter a study with your public you want to be able to have an open study that you haven't predetermined but to notice a study you have to predetermine and I feel like it's just we're chasing our tail trying to dot our eyes and cross our tees and make sure that we come out of a program appropriately so I hope hope that we can use this experience to hopefully have some changes in the process so that we can have some really good Community engagement because the community engagement has been great over the last 90 days really exploring that um the second ask

087I have of my community especially those in the Windsor and in the North orm Community um as my as as Mark said that it would increase Portables and have drastic enrollment changes weren't foreseen my area will foresee drastic enrollment changes and those enrollment changes are going to occur prior to new boards being able to make votes so though we may Kick the Can down on this decision there are decisions like finding ways to fund this start of construction of a new high school are important that we don't kick those cans so we have to start to weigh where can we hold and make it work for students and where do we still have to take action even though we know a new board's going to take place and both of those decisions have financial and

088student growth outcome impacts and we're going to need to look at them and wrestle with them and sometimes we're going to say yeah this is a good time to pause um and to restudy or relook at and maybe we'll still have the same outcome in a couple years um or maybe we'll come up with some new cool opport OPP unities as I think opportunities lie and there are going to be votes that we need to um courageously take forward and say yes this is right because we can't ask students to stay in overcrowded positions so I just have an Ask of everybody at the table and everybody in the room to keep our minds open that sometimes we can pause this one through my restless nights I think we can pause for a minute um

089again it's a 4951 thing but there are going to be decisions that aren't 4951 that are 2080 1090 that we're going to have to take action on and so I just plead that we keep an open mind over the next years to make decisions where they're appropriate and to hold where appropriate so um one of my favorite days is when the enrollment projection book comes out it is like it's like Christmas for me personally um I will say I spent a lot of time on enrollment projections um when the information came out um I appreciate our business services team and the fact that adjustments are made every year to kind of reflect um changes and one of the things that stood out to me as as I was going through and looking at enrollment projections

090was that when we split in July 1 of 2027 there will be 14 Elementary schol schools in the South District that will be under enrolled and as we talk about um you know not wanting to disadvantage any area that concerns me and so I want to be perfectly clear that just because we're pausing on this action doesn't mean that no action has to be taken in the future um I worry about the consequences for under enrolled schools and programs um I also want to acknowledge that this is a multi-million dollar decision when we are when we are committing to keep schools open we are committing millions of dollars to make that happen um and there may be consequences to that whether that is class siiz impacts um we have significantly invested um board allocated FTE

091and that means that there are less resources in other areas so um I want to acknowledge and make sure that there's an understanding that there is uh you know joyn referenced that you know there are program you know opportunities options student student opportunities and and programs that uh can be limited because of resources being spent in other areas and so um I hope that that is something that is recognized um and that that and that that issue is understood fully um as far as the deficit if there are not changes made um by that date the allocation date of July 1 of 2027 any other comments I just have one more um I want to extend my thank you for all of the District staff who participated in these studies over the years I um

092for your flexibility um I there is part of me that just I feel badly for all the work that was done done and now we're in this massive hold so I just want to recognize that there were a lot of people who spent a lot of years trying to do um the right thing for kids so thank you to those thank you for your flexibility and thank you for the grace can I get an amen on that one all right we have a motion by Mark and a second by Stacy that we conclude the uh formal study to close lynon Elementary with no action all in favor say I I all oppose say nay nay thank you the last action item we have is the teacher merit award participation in the previous legislative session uh

093resources were allocated for a pilot program that would incentivize or provide additional compensation for teachers who reached a certain level of student achievement and other variables that are being determined and Executive Director of Human Resources Cammy Harper and myself have participated in webinars other uh sessions our recommendation at this time the the statute directs that districts need to decide if they're going to opt into the pilot program by the end of December of this year our recommendation is that while we do want to recognize the Excellence of our teachers and their achievement given the nature of the reconfiguration of teacher transfers over the next couple years as they find the district that they want to be in we believe that is not the right time for Alpine to participate in this pilot program we are

094um Rec we recognize that this may lead to some of our teachers not being eligible for that because we're choosing as a district not to do it however we believe that if the pilot program goes through and they figure out a way to do this well that there will be opportunities for those F future districts to particip ipate in that several of our neighbor districts um are not participating as well just because of timing and other things going on others are choosing to explore it a little bit further our recommendation again is that we pause at this time not participate in the pilot program due to the uh challenges going on the opportunities that we have associated with reconfiguration thank you do I have a motion to that effect I'm moved that we do not

095participate in the teacher merit award um program thank you do I have a second I'll second okay moved by a and second by Stacy board comment I think that um the legislature is well-meaning and and would like to reward our good teachers um but we need to recognize that teachers themselves are very ambiguous about this this kind of um program because they especially in the Alpine School District we have a team culture where teachers work together and to single out one of them as somehow deserving above another is very problematic for them and as well as for us um and there are other factors as well that uh I'm sure others will touch on but I'll I'll just touch on that one are you saying it creates a a culture of competition not cooperation and

096our culture is cooperation it it creates a scenario where if one teacher's test scores are being weighed against another they may not want to share their best lesson plan or their best practices because they want that bonus so I see it as being a very divisive as as it is constituted a very divisive program um other comments um I agree that it does seem to directly conflict with our culture of collaboration but also since it was announced um and we've talked about this in our student employees support committee but they're just it's gone through several can I say change of hands the ownership the ownership has changed um and so I think without being fully confident that it will be a good thing um I don't wish to wait into those Waters but I also

097have significant concerns about who would have been eligible for it anyway and um I think no matter what you teach whether it is um a core class an art uh any of these things all of our teachers um put significant ific time into what they're doing and I am not interested in trying to suggest that somebody is less deserving because of the field that they have chosen to go into so I uh met with the speaker of the house and the president of the Senate this afternoon and uh as part of that group we had uh several superintendents and board uh board members uh from several districts in the waset front and this this topic actually came up I think that my uh I was leaning towards you know following this suggestion and not being

098involved in it and uh we had a very vigorous discussion about this um and it finally we we kind of examined what is it that we really don't like about it and I think it came down to this well one one one teacher is going to feel jealous that another teacher got a merit-based award and they didn't and that it would c i I can see a potential for this causing again more disunity uh among them but then we started talking about it we said do we really think that our teachers are that petty you know what I mean I can see a teacher team getting behind and being really excited for one person that got this award and I I think uh it's also interesting I think for a while we had uh districts

099on the wasach front that were not going to be involved but I think three from the wasach front decided either today or yesterday to join in uh among those Jordan I think that have been previously not participating and as we as we talked about some of their reasons again the exact criteria that uh will be used to make these awards has not yet been decided and so um I think the superintendents that uh that voiced their opinion felt that uh there is Poss there is some possible Merit system that they would be in support of and so they felt like well I want to be involved in this so I can help shape the discussion and so I can shape it to to become something that would be better for uh uh for teachers and

100so I think I'm kind of switching my uh my support to where I think I think we should be involved in this um because uh again there's this there's this group of a fairly large group of districts that are going to be involved that are wanting to shape it into a program that would not cause that kind of division and that kind of jealousy and I think that the outcome will will be that they they they won't come up with a system that will pit one teacher against another although I don't know exactly what that program will look at look like so that's kind of my experience we discussed that uh Mark particularly uh Cammy and I and uh felt like the we trust those that are involved in the process to help shape it

101with what we are going to be dealing with over the next couple years it would put an undue burden on HR and others to try and navigate that but realize that there are going to be some adjustments and have confidence in those that are in the system that they will be able to have that interaction I just want to say that there are lots of opportunities in education kind of like Dr farnworth was saying and when is the right time to start an opportunity um and weigh that out um I think at the end of the day I think I really trust superintendents and universities to come up with with a really amazing program and I think it's something that hopefully will move the teaching profession my profession forward and and be able to honor

102and recognize the incredible teachers out there but when we look at our opportunities that we face today as Alpine district and then as three new districts um I think it's probably not the right time to sink a lot of resources into creating that they think it's time for us to to lean on our friends in other districts along the wasach front and across the state to lead out and to develop a program that's going to benefit our teachers that we can then participate in and so I just really hope that the legislators don't um they just see this as an opportunity to study it and then to have more participate as it rolls out and that's just kind of where I would like to go I personally would love to see this funding put on

103the wpu can I just one further comment uh it just just occurs to me that I really do appreciate the way our internal relations people do our Awards and that they're nominated by other people around this teacher or this student or whatever I think that's that's a wonderful way um to honor someone um and I just appreciate the the process that and the thought that they've gone through to create these rise Awards I think they they fulfilled their purpose any other comments all right let me see if I've got this right the motion before us is uh moved by a second by Stacy to not participate in the teacher merit award program at this time all right all in favor of that motion please say I I any opposed say nay okay there we go

104hey we'll invite our chief legal counsel executive director of legal service Services Craig bringer Hof to come forward we have three policies to discuss and if the board is ready to take action on first one is uh revision of policy 5181 bullying prevention okay this uh this policy has been a little bit out of out of date the bullying policy or excuse me the definition of buling and state statute has been updated this past legislative session and so we wanted to get this updated as part of that we always like to involve those departments that most most heavily deal with these issues and so in this particular um item of bullying that's our student services department so we've been working collectively with them over the last many months trying to get this policy right uh

105where we wanted it as well as updated with st current statute so we feel like we've gotten to the right place now and this policy is ready to be reviewed and discussed and and uh potentially approved by the board tonight so we would recommend this again the the major changes are the update to the definition of what bullying is um we also I've heard that legislation could change on this again so we may change that definition again this next session but but as of right now this is where it's at so we uh recommend it for your approval all right do I have a motion to approve the revision of policy 5181 I move that we approve the revised version of 5181 bulling prevention I second okay um has been uh moved by Sarah seconded

106by join and Marth so we'll say join um any comments on this well it as a policy team it's funny because we we try no we we do we word Smith I'm just going to say we do word Smith but going back up to the top I mean it's we were trying to come up with a little bit of a different name for the policy and we put prevention there what did it used to say was it just bullying just bullying yeah and it it just feels like it just empowers bullying you know to just say our bullying policy so we added the word prevention to just you know we're not going to give that much uh I guess attention try to you know calm that down the bullying part of it the other aspect

107of this and if you'll go up just a little bit I and I wanted to kind of ask you a question on this didn't we decide or maybe it was after nope our definitions are within the it's not within our rules and regs and procedures correct Craig I yes in this in this policy it's it's up above yeah and we did that purposefully because we knew and anticipated that there could be legislation future legislation that would change just like Craig said the definition of of bullying that we would be able to change that and it wouldn't have to go clear to a board you know and and await the time we could make that switch which is really helpful and I I am appreciate of the board understanding that um we are trying to get

108through policy and it is such a unique uh committee because we are trying to beat the clock it seems that every legislative session we only have such a short period of time to make sure that we have the policies put in place that we need to have put in place for that next year and being able to make these little tiny switches um without having it to have come to the full board for a approval just switching a couple of things has been helpful and we're able to expedite expedite these proc process this policy in a way that we can hopefully keep up with other policies and make sure that we are right on par with where we need to be as a district in uh concerning policy and I just wanted to point out

109the definitions in here are taken straight from State Statute so we didn't spend a lot of time wordsmithing definitions we used the state standardized definitions that are used across all of the leas in the state I had a question sorry go ahead I had a question question for Council um I know that the board received a live version of this to look at and I appreciate the opportunity to word Smith and that you responded to my um uh revisions um is this standard practice no we knew that this one had a lot of interest so that was part of the reason why we shared it okay with everybody and also because uh the changes are more significant in this one like there's a lot of changes in this one um many of our policies when

110we revise them it's a little bit here a little bit there this one was more significant and so uh the intent was to get it before your eyes before a couple of days so that you had a chance to read through it I I really do appreciate that because I really am a detailed person and I like to get the ducks in a row correctly but I also appreciate that I could see that our district professionals have weighed in on this um so they their expertise is embedded in this yes so I didn't write the number down I think it's 2.2 somewhere um yep so very much I appreciate this section um for years particularly in our Secondary School um we've had struggles between schools and and our city officers when something you know happens

111offsite and so I just very much want to say that I appreciate the attention to the off-site violations that impact what happens at school it's kind of felt like um Sometimes some of the city officers will say well that's that's a school thing well but if it happened off campus but is now coming in so I just want to say I very much appreciate bringing attention to this and I think that um I really really appreciate the way you worded it I think it's fantastic and I think this is going to help a lot of kids um moving forward so thank you shocker Craig um I'm actually G to vote no on this one um I am not I just feel like the parental notification piece is not strong enough um parental notification um when

112it talks about communication as soon as reasonably possible it just that to me is insufficient um I've been having a lot of conversations with parents about gaps in communication when it comes to bullying and hazing um I get that this isn't part of the procedures and we're voting on the policy and all the things but also I feel like when I give my stamp of approval I'm essentially saying I support everything um so rather than word Smith is here I'm not going to make you go through that I am just going to say that I will be voting no because I don't think the parental notification piece is strong enough there is a reason for that we kind of went back and forth and um Joy Lynn brought up some really good points during that

113meeting of we were trying to um cuz we really talked a lot about the pral notification that was huge for us and julan do do you want to share with them kind of the reason of why we put as soon as reasonably we put reasonably possible I believe that was your your word it's it's just tricky you always want to communicate as quickly as possible with the family and that is a priority is that parental or communication piece um but to say that it has to be within 20 minutes or 40 minutes or how long that is is is really hard to tie um I've had some personal experiences with that and and so we just left it at reasonably because we want that communication to go as quickly as possible but we want the

114incident to be handled sufficiently before and that's that sounds really bad that we're going to handle this situation and then communicate we want all students to be safe as the first priority and communication to be right there with it but we don't want communication to supersede student safety yeah and I would say it was it didn't feel like as we were working on this that it was an Andor uh you know it was there were some situations and we we didn't want to tie the hands it's that balance between tying the hands of Administrators or you know if something has to be done real quick we didn't want to handcuff them to a policy that would potentially get them in trouble and yet making sure that our parents that was the first thing that they

115were to do was to get a hold of the parents we're trying to find that balance there and that's why that was there but I just wanted to let you know as as we wrestled with this kind of what the context was Craig did you want to say anything more about that part of it no I I think that you've uh hit on it really well thank you we actually had a lot of discussion on this policy um what is bullying is it a one-time thing is it an ongoing pattern what does the state code say what is how do we bring everything into compliance so I think that we've done the best we can on the policy and and Julie if you have some concerns about language on other parts of it then bring

116that to the committee and they can do that um in committee so with that in mind any other comments all right was moved by Sarah and um seconded by joyin that we approve the revised policy 5181 all in favor say I I I all oppose say nay nay okay thank you next policy is 544 news media representative and that is a revision to existing policy so we worked uh closely with Rich on this particular policy our new communications director um he had some interest in revising this policy and making sure that uh we're doing two things well three things one informing the public of what's going on in our schools to Pro protecting our students who are in in the schools and protecting their information and and making sure that uh we're supporting the schools

117when they have media requests so uh that's kind of what drove these policy changes we again work closely with the director of Communications on some things that he would like to see in here um and uh we would recommend these changes to you do I have a motion to approve policy 544 I move that we approve policy 544 and a second a second okay uh is there any discussion Craig I'm back um I appreciate this one but also like it feels like the impetus was on student rights and that there wasn't any kind of focus on student safety um my thing is I just need a student safety piece added in there so I'll just leave that feedback and then vote no and move on with my life thank you we did talk about this

118a little bit in our Communications committee uh meeting this morning and I think uh uh that we've identified the things that that are probably kind of new since this was this policy was written and I I I support it as uh being sufficient to to be passed so I think it's 1.2.3 um I really like that this is collaborative um I think previously it was just principls let the district personel um but yep anyways I'm just very appreciative that this uh gives principles some ownership and and uh um allows them to be part of what impacts our school so thank you for the section okay I think comments I guess I want to Echo what Julie said I I really was um looking for a little bit more strong um I know as a board

119member I'm always very conscious of pictures I take things I post online like I avoid um student student uh images unless I have permission from their parents you know I go to a great deal of um uh trouble to make sure that I don't do anything that violates um privacy or parental U wishes so yeah I guess I just it was not quite as strong as I thought it was going to be so so it may be the committee can go back to 1.2.3 and add a clause in there about student safety I think they're related yeah student privacy and safety one of the things that this committee was looking in depth at is when the media contacts the district then they are um they are sent to the district uh representative so that's rich

120stole but when they go directly to a school sometimes that creates problems for principles or challenges and we wanted to give the principal some guidelines and we wanted to give them some support so that they would know how to actually how to develop a media engagement plan and what that means we'd like to get some training for our principes as they um handle the media at their school okay I think we're ready for a vote so it's been moved by Mark and second by adaa that we approve news media representative revision policy 544 all in favor say I I I any oppos say Nay Nay Nay I think it passes it was two Nays correct all right thank you last policy is 7210 it's a new policy the use of student and employee images so

121this uh is a brand new policy that's being proposed uh this also is kind of a sister policy to the one we just looked at um as we talked with the Department of communications and and worked through this their main interest um in this policy is when we do so much communication to our public sharing out events sharing out highlights about Alpine School District more often than not they're using stock photos of random people random students from who knows where and they had the feeling of why don't we use our own why don't we use our own students and this policy does lay out a process to get parent permission um when necessary um and also deferring to to parents if we're going to highlight a student in a publication or or what have you

122but the the thought was why shouldn't we be highlighting our great students instead of stock photos so that was kind of the the message that rich shared with us as we talked through this um and we would recommend this as uh something that would allow us to highlight our students in in a more personal way sharing their photos but again with Protections in place and making sure that we have permissions also highlighting employees and getting employee permission to use their photos Okay do I have a motion to approve this new policy 7210 I move that we approve policy 7210 use of student and employee images and a second second um thank you um board comment our questions can you just move right just barely right above procedures just that next paragraph right under procedures while

123sar's thinking about this so this is primarily District use of images I guess before we've tried to restrict anybody taking pictures and it felt like it could be that students could be penalized from taking pictures of each other but that's not what this is doing is that correct yeah so this is this this is used by US um for our purposes um so for example I mean we had pictures taken here earlier today right and then we allowed family members to come up we We Can't Stop family we can't stop other students especially at a performance from taking pictures and using those that's not what the intent is the intent is when when we highlight an individual or highlight an individual student or employee then that becomes the subject rather than the event itself or

124like the play performance or the whole choir if it's a picture of a whole choir it's it's not something that's going to violate furpa if there's a picture that singles in on an individual student that's when we start to run into furpa violations and so when there is a student highlighted we would make sure that we're covered under furpa and get the permissions necessary when it's just a a athletic performance or somebody takes a picture of of an entire team playing basketball on the on the basketball court there's there's not permissions needed for those types of things but we also want to or or our Communications Department would like to highlight our own students rather than again like I said just taking some random picture of of a basketball team playing basketball and instead say

125hey this is our Lone Peak High School basketball team or whatever to try and make it more personalized and give recognition where recognition is due perhaps so I'm going to vote no on this but I will give the caveat that I didn't realize until earlier that I did not communicate this to anyone so my apologies for this um my only concern with this is that this is for the purpose of District communication I understand that we can't control the public or other students um I will say with things like the Arts most of my teachers their students have a media permission because they're in that class my concern is that we've seen a growing number of employees who will take photos during the school day and then post those online and I went through the

126other 7,000 series um and there's not anything that that really addresses that and I would like for there to be some very specific um Direction in terms of what is um not allowed particularly because we do have students and I know it's not a lot but um for whom their Online safety is essential to their life safety and so um I know that people are trying to probo point with those things that they're sharing um but I just want to make sure that we are setting a clear expectation with our employees of what they're taking a picture of and the places that they are sharing those out G to ask a clarifying question um I don't have a student uh currently I won't have a student in my future either but um I so I

127don't have access to Skyward and so we are relying on Skyward as that parental permission piece what does that look like is it just a box you check or it's very simple or yes so there there's a couple things and I this policy goes a little bit beyond just the Skyward permissions but um every year when a parent goes in and registers their student or updates the student information there is a check box that says um that you agree to allow um some personal identifying information that is uh considered here at the bottom there's a list of directory information so if a parent is okay with directory information of their student being shared they'll check that box and the directory information is usually the name the email what grade they're in what schools they've attended

128um it can include their email address and their photo and more often than not that's used for things like the yearbook or uh a play bill or all all sorts of things like that where um we get in advance so that we can uh highlight those those uh students that we have include their picture um it might be on a team roster it might be on you know things like that and so parents have given their permission by checking that box so if they haven't checked that box we obviously would need to go back and check with them sometimes they might not understand and they might have checked that box but really they want their their students picture to be in part of that program of the event that they're in or the require that

129they're performing as a part of and so then we could get permission from them individually or have them go back and change that permission but that's what that is for directory information uh furpa law has a list of things that are considered directory information and then it allows the individual schools or districts to further determine if they're going to use all that as directory information or make it uh um more narrow in scope yeah Craig I don't recall a specific conversation that we had in policy kind of to Stacy's point if there was a teacher and like um let's say it was something like this Bear Hugs thing that we saw at the very beginning of our meeting and there was you know a teacher or whatever and they just took a screenshot and posted

130something on their Facebook saying we're doing this today is there anything in this policy that covers that specific speically no not this specific policy yeah see I didn't yeah this is more directed at District Communications and so would it if we're talking about that level of privacy for our students would that be in another policy itself or since this one is directly no it's a good question uh I mean we do have a fura policy our fura policy is basically protecting student information right um we could be more um more direct about how we want to approach that more direct about how we communicate that and train that to our teachers on on these types of topics um again when we're talking about what is a student record if the photo highlights an individual or

131maybe one or two individual students then it's a student record if it's a photo of a group of students it's not considered a a um a student record and so there's no fbit protection and so I guess the clarification I'm looking for because I'm I'm feeling there's a little hesitancy amongst some of the board members here wanting to pass this policy tonight if if there was something like that where was maybe a teacher taking a picture of one student two students and there's privacy issues would that particular type of protection of students of images fit within this realm of the policy but or not because this policy really is focused merely on when we're um communicating or you know advertising that type of thing would it be a different policy or is this something that

132these concerns would go into this policy and we would go back and so this this policy can cover employees it does like in 1.1.2 it talks about authorized Personnel including District employees um it it goes through kind of the steps that we would take if you were going to plan to use a photo um so if you go down further in 1.2 authorized Personnel will notify a site administrator before capturing any imagery um and then before using that image you'll check Skyward make sure that there's permissions and give a notification courtesy notification to the parent um that parent can give or roke permission at any time um so I mean it is covered it's maybe not as tight or as explicit as would be liked so so would this body here feel comfortable if the

133board went in and you know procedurally made some changes to tighten it up a little bit to make it more so I'd be thrilled if you change the title I think that's what kind of caught my eye from the beginning when we're saying um use of employee name and image it doesn't say for district communication purposes right and there's nothing in the employee code of conduct that addresses it and so for me and I understand I may be the only person who feels that way and that's just f um but I would like to see um I think and I guess I'm thinking a little more uh specifically of our secondary schools that have thousands of kids in them and sometimes things move very quickly and I understand that most of the time people are

134trying to share positive thing right um but I don't know who's on everybody's social media or online following and a variety of platforms right and so um for for me because the title is open I would like it to be tighter but if the group consensus isn't there it's fine I'll say it kind of goes back to the kind of e Stacy said I have some concerns about student safety with some of this that I'd like to have locked down a little bit stronger um I'm not sure if I need a motion or a substitute motion were this item as a discussion or an action item what is the proper way where we already have a motion on the table to just have it be the discussion and have it go back to policy tighten

135it up and then bring it back to the body we can vote no yeah just vote no and then take it back to committee with with concerns noted well again I'll say I say this all the time I'm sorry if we're just leaving the statement of policy and the PO policy is self and the rules and regs are you we want to change and tighten up on the procedures my motion is that we pass policy 7210 with the caveat to go ahead and firm up those things um for student protection and privacy I appreciate that that is your motion I am not comfortable passing it with that title and the policy which is what I'm voting on okay are we ready to vote this is going to be interesting it's by been moved by Sarah

136and seconded by Mark that we uh approve this policy as it is written all those in favor of approving the policy is written say I I I all oppose say Nay Nay n is it three to four what did you say I said I your so however with with the strong recommendation of the committee to go back and work on the title work on the concerns that have been expressed so if board members would would uh email a member of the committee with their specific concerns then they can take that to the committee next month and make those adjustments sounds great thank you Council membership report yes you've received the membership report appreciate our business services team and creating that you'll see that we still have some growth in areas declining in other areas those

137patterns continue um so we'll continue to monitor that in terms of high growth area and those that are declining FTE are going to be coming out the next couple months for our secondary and elementary schools associated with these projections and so we will be working with our supervisors and our schools regarding their ftes thank you and now we have an opportunity for uh board member our superintendent reports so superintendent let's start with you is there something you'd like to share at this time yes I would just like to express my appreciation to you publicly for uh Your Service as a teacher a distinguished teacher of the year in Alpine School District for your many years of service uh your lifetime of service to education and to the students and uh not only your service as

138a teacher but then uh continuing that service as a board member that that is commendable and we many fam students administrators have benefited from your service so thank you very much thank you it's been a good it's been a good 40 years I uh I was going to say kind of the same thing Sarah you know when um people talk about what what what do board me Members need to have to be a successful uh board member and I always say that you can learn the knowledge and the skills but the disposition can't be taught and yet I don't know if I know another board member that has the knowledge the skills and the disposition like you and you know that I love you and we've developed a great friendship over the years but I

139but we're both Sarah so there you go there you go but I just I hope you know how much you are loved and appreciated and just the absolute difference kind of like Julie what she said at the beginning just the thousands of people that you've impacted and I hope you can you know walk away tonight from your last board meeting and know that you have just made such an incredible difference in so many people's lives and we love you and wish you the very very best thank you so much I would like to share some messages to you I've reached out to a couple of former board members from our area and uh first I reached out to Debbie Taylor and she said she had been thinking of you and uh lately yesterday as a

140matter of fact and she shared this message thank you Sarah for your many years of service to this District in the classroom and on the board your love for kids and learning is palpable you had the courage to make the hard decisions when it was well hard and not at all popular I'm proud of you and your legacy of heart and conviction there is lots of good life after the board go and have some fun with lots of love and gratitude Debbie and I'd also like to share a message from jod sunberg who's my predecessor dear Sarah thank you for your great service as an excellent board member you have been an example and many and an inspiration to many thank you for choosing to always best serve the children and ensuring that our teachers

141should be respected as professional educational experts thank you for standing up for public education and being a courageous voice for good when communicating truth to power I will always be grateful for our time serving together and in my own behalf and in behalf of the children that I birthed that you influenced so deeply um thank you for your many years and for your friendship we worked way harder than we wanted to in those classes didn't we parents would know oh yes history parents yeah okay Other Board member reports so I just had a you know I feel like this has to be a tribute thing so I like you too Sarah so don't feel bad if I but I I do appreciate uh meeting you at the Orum uh Colonial uh whatever event and seeing

142the passion you have with your costume and everything and that is the passion all about the Hat Market yeah that's the passion that you bring to everything and I really appreciate that but uh also we had a usba board meeting this uh past week and um I just wanted to highlight a couple of things uh first of all we're going to have our uh district schools day on the hill on January 27th and that will be uh different this year they're going to have a a breakfast thing at 7 7:30 a patriotic celebration um the legislative committee has really been excited about this and uh we are also going to wear white uh to that event as well as to committee meetings uh during this year I I know sometimes we have the upu parents

143wear red or something so this will be kind of our Hallmark we're going to wear white and they are also setting up a signup sheets so that we can try to pack the the room for Education meetings uh with uh uh people in support of public schools so anyway um so December everybody's favorite month um nobody has more joy than me when an email comes through that we are canceling a meeting to let everybody have December Joy uh but I did want to take a minute to thank all of the humans in our schools who ju it's the most magical thing I mean I have admins dressed like elves I have teachers that are um sharing you know about different uh holidays that students observe around this time and I just think it is really

144good to be an elementary kid in Alpine um so thank you to all all of those for their efforts it it just is very cool also in the Season O performances um I do occasionally sub for our Arts teachers and um it is is a very fun thing this year I subb the first week of school and I haven't seen some of them until the the concert and I will never understand understand how the secondary Arts people can take children who have never touched an instrument or used their voice and they somehow teach them how to use them and they put on these performances that are that are actually very enjoyable to attend and so I just wanted to recognize all of their time and their hours to put those things together um I don't

145know that people realize unless you are an Arts person that it's not just the curriculum and the learning of the daily but they are putting on fullon shows um with just themselves so um thank you to all those efforts um and then I just have an ask for our community um I most days love the community that can be found online and I love when people share the good things some people have their own hashtag you can click it find all their posts lovely um and sometimes it doesn't go well and so in with respect uh to reconfiguration I had decided early on for myself whichever way this goes um I will uh react with uh class and Grace and I thought that perhaps everybody else would do the same and I don't think that

146that is what has happened and um I know we have a lot of employees who watch this and I know because they text and they say I have my popcorn I have my beverage um and so for those who might still be listening um I would just love for us all to consider that um the reconfiguration is hard for everybody but there are a lot of people who have given their entire professional careers or their students lifetime as volunteers into making this an incredible district and so I don't want anybody to feel less than um I think if you don't see it or understand it it's hard to articulate for the for so many of our employees um people aren't just co-workers these are their family these are people who choose to go hiking with

147one another after they spent the entire week together which is more than 40 hours um who are there to Champion um celebrations for students and pick things up when um they need it and so um I I think sometimes we get real Brave behind keyboards and don't consider how demoralizing that some of the comments can be to the people who give so much certainly not for the pay and so um my ask is that we all just um really consider the things that we are putting online and in the spirit of the holidays reach out to the people that you know whether it was yesterday or five years ago to the people in our schools that make a huge differ for our kids because it is those personal connections and um and things that that

148matter most any other reports or comments um I just wanted to give a shout out um to Business Services I am the worst at organizing information and I don't know how many times a week I text or email Jason and say Hey you know that document can you help me find it um I love the business dashboard it has so much information I feel like just summarized in very like succinct manner for us to be able to access very very quickly um and I just wanted wanted to send a shout out to business services for um completing the dashboard um because it is super helpful to me as a board member to have all that information right at my fingertips so thank you it's a great Innovation thank you if there are no other comments

149we do have need for a closed session tonight so I need a motion to move into Clos session I move that we move into closed session and a second second it's been moved by Julian second by a I will need a roll call vote to move into Clos session I joyn Lincoln I Mark Clement I Julie King I Sarah hacken I Sarah b i Stacy bman I okay this meeting stands adjourned we will move into Clos session and happy holidays to all of you thank you for coming and staying to the bit bitter

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.