001hey good evening everyone we're going to start a few minutes late we're waiting for our board president he did notify us he's running a few minutes behind and he does travel quite a bit uh from his job to get here uh to run the meeting so we're going to give him a few minutes to get here on time or a little bit late e e e hey good even evening everyone like to call this evening's meeting to order our regular board meeting for Tuesday December 2nd churg Area School Board uh please rise for a pledge allegiance followed by moment of silence I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with Li and justice for all thank you uh
002prior to this evening's meeting the board did meet an executive session uh regarding uh real estate matters um item 2.03 is approval to adopt tonight's uh meeting agenda motion and second please moove second motion by Mr hack second by Mr Walker um questions comments I'll I'll add one uh number 13 is new business uh that's on this week and uh thank you Chris um this was my fault last week uh I blew right over new business at Committee of the whole last week so um new business U be a discussion item only um and then uh we'll probably continue that well we'll see may continue then into the next cow and and go from there with the process so we have a motion and second for 2.03 uh to accept tonight's uh meeting agenda all
003those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed eyes have it and so moved um before we get to 3.01 just another note I mentioned at last meeting um and this will be our second meeting while we're on video uh for those in the audience when you're at the mic you can't be seen on the video so if you wanted to be seen on the video sorry and if you didn't want to be seen on on the video congratulations so with that 3.01 Student Government reports uh I'm with cashes our most Student Government president My Name Is Karly skull Teddy um so I went over the field trip last time but I'll briefly go over it again if you want to skip to the next slide um on Wednesday November 13th 25 cashes Student
004Government members traveled to the state capital building um they toured the capital they met with Representatives um and yeah I already went over this a couple times so we this the next one um Trojan care so we came up with a logo and we're currently um meeting with the boo the basketballs um the guy that makes the bask boys basketball shorts we're meeting with him in hopes that he can make shorts for us and get them out to the whole community not just students so it'll be available to you guys and we'll have a link um we are it the game is on February 5th and it's going to be a white out so for the crazies and for the whole stadium and we'd um we're also going to do 50/50 and get a game
005license so it would be really nice if you guys could um put money towards that and we're going to do a halftime game which either we haven't decided if it's going to be like a knockout or just a donation for a foul shot so that's all any questions thank you the shirts be available um well we still have to talk with him to see if he can get them out before um before after the New Year's but sometime around them I'd just like to highlight a uh event that the cashous um girls wrestlers had last week the first event having spent many evenings beside the mats for boys wrestling in my earlier years I enjoyed the opportunity to to see the first girls wrestling match and they're going to do well thank you thank Youk
006magnet 3.02 superintendence report thanks Mr Norcross um I do want to report that they the survey that went out last week to wrap up regarding the schools of Distinction and facility enhancements um was complete we had 701 participants in the survey which was pretty good um for us um 63% of the respondents strongly agreed or agreed that they had enough information we had 71% respondents are either very supportive or somewhat supportive of our preferred option four that we're going to vote on tonight with uh 45% of them being very supportive um about 56% of the respondents watched the presentations online uh 17% attended in person and that and then also 58% of the respondents have lived in Chambersburg for more than 16 years just a fun fact on that one so I do want to
007thank everybody for their participation it's been a somewhat of a long process uh to get the word out and I don't know what else we could have done so I do want to thank everybody for their time energy and effort um in the process to communicate uh certainly publicly what we were doing with all the staff presentations and forums um I do want to uh thank all of those who participated in designing um what will be more of a culminating vote tonight you know it's over a 100 staff members have participated whether it was in a survey whether it was on a committee um whether it was feedback working with the Architects to work on the feasibility study the path we've set forward really will lay the groundwork for the next 20 years um I
008think I know our schools will be on a path towards distinction and I keep using that word schools of Distinction and I also know we're on a path for a one toown one Trojan community and it's nice to be on that path uh with you as a community with you as a staff um you will hear tonight from Kurt Whitman about the state of learning in the district on performance I don't want to steal his Thunder but related to schools of Distinction uh Hamilton Heights for the second year in the row did win the US News and World Report um awardwinning School in the top 40% um and I will say to you they're approaching a school of Distinction when you do something well for multiple years in a row that's when you're going to
009get a status from the school district so as we clearly Define what school of Distinction means in a variety of ways we will start recognizing schools of Distinction formally in this room uh certainly branding and decorations bring folks in so I'm very excited for what Kurt's going to present and also Hamilton Heights and other success stories that you're going to hear about tonight um and thanks to the board of education for your steadfast support and acceptance and tolerance of all the information that comes your way that we've provided to you um and thanks for your engagement as well you've been uh very supportive of of the team my staff myself and also asking really good questions and also being an advocate for public education so I do want to thank you end of my report
010all right go Huskies all right uh president's report um last week uh in a couple minutes while I had to microphone and um mentioned a couple of of my my goals as board president I'd like to see the do uh or achieve or work towards um after the meeting I was asked about goals so I thought I'd take the time tonight to to repeat those or to reiterate what I said A week ago uh because I was asked uh what what they were or what may be the vision that I was seeing that um and these are just Ed norcross's thoughts uh but since there were three of them and one of them was to Brand our investment and Mr B has done schools of Distinction by 2030 um which happens to be item 10
01110.01 on tonight's agenda uh but it didn't as Chris said in his earlier comments here just a minute ago this didn't start just last week this started many many months ago and it's has a long ways to go so uh you know you will hear me say this often and maybe you'll get sick of me hearing it which means everyone knows what we're talking about when we say investment in schools of Distinction by 2030 that was one of my three so since Chris already took that off the list I thought I'd add another one but but uh my other one of my other ones from last meeting was uh a focus on special education um I really think uh Staffing is a is an area we can uh make some improvements on last year uh
012the administration and the board we made some great strides in our Support Services um and have really improved our our staffing and our vacancies this was a comment by the public repeatedly and uh I've heard some comments since we did this and since the results have shown um of everyone's efforts in doing that um Dr Diller schooled me uh probably a year ago on the intervention speci specialist as being a very key part of this and that was already approved but I think there's still uh I think there's still a lot of work we can do and it's not going to be easy uh and the third item was this uh and it's sort of a a sister or brother a sibling if you will uh to the investment in schools of Distinction by 2030
013and that is revisiting the resolution from 3 years ago uh with our plus plus X it has been plus one use x because we don't know what it'll be this year or future years so to be generic I'll call it plus x uh but it's worded more for capital reserve which previously that's what we were focused on now that we have you know over the next seven years $170 million of bond issues coming uh we actually uh to look at changing that resolution for for Debt Service payments so since there's only two left uh the Third one I thought I would add we'll call it 3B uh and a little bit it goes a little bit with investment uh and it's part of our projects we're going to look at our athletic facilities and a
014capital uh a capital campaign this board but the school board previous boards as well we've often talked about initiating a capital campaign uh but it's never gotten much further than just talk uh and I I think one thing that I've seen in the past year with this board is uh we get stuff done we really do uh and I think that's something that we can we can work on uh again um you know our neighboring districts have done this 20 years ago 15 years ago uh and uh I think we can we can pick up and U and help and help with that as well for us so again there are my since again they're my three two old one new uh thoughts ideas uh goals Ed Norcross goals that I'd like to see us
015work towards as a board and as a district so with that I'm going to conclude those remarks just with one final i' like to wish everybody a Merry Christmas happy holidays be safe have fun and be prosperous thank you item 4.01 by annual academic report Mr Whitman please good evening and thanks for letting me report to you this evening uh a little bit different so before I start the presentation last this is my fourth time talking about data and our and our academics and our in our schools so we're doing a little bit differently tonight um in the past it's been 45 to 57 slides is uh what I what I've seen and to quote dark uh Dr long this this week he says sometimes I felt like I was falling asleep during that presentation
016so um there you go Mr Norcross as well so uh I condense it down to 15 but for those folks that like all those color charts I did provide them still the data that supports what I'm speaking to you this evening is in some of the packet that you have in front of you and so I'll look for some feedback since this is a little bit different than what we've done in the past you know afterwards um I was asked uh beforehand is it okay if we ask questions as you go along that's fine just uh interrupt me maybe Mr bigger if you see someone's hand go up just say hey hold on here a minute all right so we're going to get started uh as you just heard uh Mr bigger and Mr Norcross
017talk about schools of Distinction that really started uh after Mr biger and it led right into uh group that I led the CD blueprint committee where we developed our six pillars and we started to talk about our goals for the district and where we needed to go um a lot of those things that uh you've seen in his presentation s on the the building reconfigurations and a lot of things we've started have come from out of those meetings so as we head to schools of Distinction by 2030 um we are looking at target areas we've already started those Dr long and myself have met with our principles um they have set goals basically our main goal is 10% Improvement across the board so that's and I'll hit that a little bit later in what that
018looks like in each division um but they have set goals for 2030 and they've also set goals for each year and finally it towards the end of the presentation uh as you seen in many of our other reports we've been comparing ourselves to 10 like school districts roughly the same size same demographics in the middle schools our our middle schools are great at growth there's always room for improvement uh you can see a little bit later in the packet uh past scores dark blue is excellent and our middle schools traditionally have been excellent our kids come in and the teachers at the middle schools really close those gaps and then lastly Keystone performance in literature Algebra 1 and biology moving on to the Reading Writing and comprehending by third grade this is the first time
019we have ever grade this is the first time we have ever assessed our kindergarteners right when they came in to see where they were and how ready they were for kindergarten we haven't done that before uh the the test is one of the the assessment that we used is I think the front page of the packet that I gave you and it it shows you what we look for and basically when it boils down to it our kindergarteners about 22% of them were ready uh reading wise and 54% were ready in math so as we look to approve the the four directors one of the biggest goals and if I go back to that CD our daycares and really let them know what we're looking for and what they can do to get our kids
020ready so our third grade data that reading and writing that I spoke about before in the year 22 23 40% of our kids hit that metric this year we did see a 6% increase of students hitting that metric um one thing I want to say our principles worked hard this summer they did rearrange some schedules um we did have uh a young lady speak at the the cow I just want to let you know that none of the recesses were actually shortened to uh and I actually checked that school so I just wanted to let you know that none of the recesses were actually shortened uh for that schedule but we have included what I need now time our teachers are calling that wind time that's extra half hour in the day where the kids
021are met where they are learning and in small groups uh our peas growth and I put third through eth grade just not third grade but really our our teachers do a phenomenal job of growing our kids and closing the gaps uh so in Reading we have excellent growth you'll see in the past scores in your packet now into the future I I already spoke a little bit about the wind time we have increased intervention tonight on the board we uh part of the agenda we are adding four more interventionists in the elementary um and including also the DEA student affairs in the small schools about 50% of their time is also going to be spent on intervention so when you look that's going to be seven to eight or even nine folks increase doing intervention
022in uh Elementary uh we're piloting walk to read um it's heavy in K to1 we're also uh starting in in second grade in three schools where we're doing it uh if any of you want to take a trip with me and see that in action it's phenomenal what what's happening in Stevens uh falling spring and fville we're going to be bringing the other schools on in the fall and we're preparing to do that right now and of course we still need more supports for our most struggling students whether it's special ed ESL or students with the biggest gaps excuse me Mr Whitman could you give uh the whole the acronyms what they mean the p p PV SS what's it stand for I mean there thank you I I should have had that written out
023Pennsylvania value added assessment uh it's it's the uh it's measures the student growth as well as each individual teacher so we can see you know how teachers even do over a three-year span with with students um of course we love to see dark blue we have some teachers that um even actually you dig down deep into it it ranks where they fall in the state when I was principal cams North I'd actually go over the past data with each teacher and we would take a look at how their students perform the year prior and how you know they're they're doing over three years so it's it's great data for our teachers to take a look at it thank you very much walk to read tell me what that is so walk uh to go back
024to your time when you were a principal it's going to be more like flooding but it's a systemic flooding uh where you would walk into the the the kids are in one classroom so at Stevens I was there in the kindergarten classroom they had four different adults at four different stations working with students and they are uh working on sounds they're breaking down words um it's uh basically flooding model but they're they're ba they're put put into groups based off of their like a Cadian scores so grouping students for MH will will there that's happening every day will there be a specific evaluation of our new open Court Reading Program or is is what we're seeing here reflective of that is what's the plan as far as data relative to that um we we've look
025at our data we look at our map scores of Cadance uh we are now starting our third year the first year we had some Growing Pains we expected to see an implementation dip um we didn't see much of an implementation dip that first year the first year we had about half our schools dipped a little bit some of our schools went up some of the schools stayed the same when you looked at all the data are it actually stayed the same that first year last year it went up a little bit so we're pretty pleased that we have a resource that is common throughout our whole District um the uh and once again going back to when our teachers selected that it was uh we had 41 folks that were part of that uh selection
026committee uh they're they're very happy with it the one um question I keep getting is there's a lot of Assessments on Friday so we keep looking at how we can make that better and and maybe less assessing times it if if we can but we still need to assess to see where the kids are so I mean I think that's the the biggest um concern I get from the teachers is the assessments on the Fridays I got a question Kurt good uh back to the walk to read uh so the people the adults who are reading are there are volunteers or that's the model the the folks it's staff members that are leading that so we have our interventionists that are in the room the teacher that's in the room and we have uh an
027aid or two that are in the room and um the teacher in the classroom the interventionist are setting what it should look like each day when they get to that point so moving on to the middle schools getting back to the uh Pennsylvania VA value added assessment system go back one you missed math oh I did I Y I must did it twice sorry so math uh fluency proficiency by fifth grade um we're pretty happy that we've seen an increase overall in our scores over the last three years um we're still using the same resource Eureka our principles have laid out uh expectations and devoted time a specific amount of time to math and also a fluency portion in each one of the classes we do believe that that has helped um overall when you
028take a look at our past growth out of the three subjects Although our growth in math is still pretty good and above the state of average it's our subject that we're probably growing our students the least right now um and in the future we we also instituted win time uh for math we'd love to see more time devoted for our math students because we're spending a lot of time on the reading which we need to do the kids need to read first uh but we're also exploring Bridges resources at Stevens right now and we're getting some good feedback from the teachers I actually have a meeting with Amber Meers uh one of our uh math coaches on Friday just to talk about uh how bridges is going down at uh Stevens right now but we
029are pleased that we're seeing the proficiency uh go up overall in math over the last three years in fifth grade could you explain the bridges what it's it's a resource similar to Eureka um it they like the fluency part the fluency piece the math facts piece um a little uh little better than the Eureka resource that we have right now so Bridges is a resource that we're exploring down at Stevens right now so it's not something that we've implemented no no it's not we uh the math k to8 math will be coming up soon on our cycle of resources so we're we're I was asked by the Math teachers down at Stevens if they could take Amber Myers has pretty much been our expert or elementary math expert that we've had and she came to
030Crystal loton slogger Lindsay uh bresin and myself and asked if they could explore it so we looked at it um and they're they're exploring it down there they're not doing it every grade um I will say that Amber did tell me that one of the most veteran teachers that normally doesn't like change actually says they like this resource better than what we were using in Eureka so moving on to our middle schools um our goals in our middle schools is that we see growth in ela math and science uh closing the gaps when the kids get in sixth grade just want to remind you in in middle school every student is tested with a pssa in math and Ela and in 8th grade they're also tested math Ela and science but uh both middle schools
031I know uh Mr bger talked a little bit about uh Awards I'm coming up with celebrations in a few moments but both middle schools uh did make that list for the US News and World reports uh for high performing schools so we're pretty proud of our Middle School's uh performance their proficiency when you take a look at that it's pretty stagnant that's why we all we want to see a 10% growth in in all subjects uh they're growing students but our proficiency as as you look at the last three years it's pretty much remained pretty close to you know a standard deviation in the future we're excited about the grade reconfiguration pulling sixth grade possibly down with fourth through sixth grade we want to look at related arts offerings what we offer our students in
032related arts we also want this is our chance to take a look at middle school and are we going to be more Project based we're going to do more handson more exploratory uh so over the next couple years as we plan for the great configur ation we have a lot to think about and a lot possibly to move forward um once again uh at the middle schools they have a little bit of intervention um but not much and one one area of struggle is of course our our uh students uh our ESL students of course are special Edge students that we want to focus on too and students with the biggest gaps Keystone performance the last three years I have Algebra 1 um one concern our growth over the past couple years is starting to
033dip a little bit at the high school um now into the future we do feel that if because of act 158 our students didn't have when the Keystone was originally put out there it was said that you needed to pass the put out there it was said that you needed to pass these in order to graduate so we feel that that will help our proficiency rates our proficiency rates and our SP scores and how the communities look at at uh comparing schools across the state uh you heard at the cal um from Dr Long Brad AER and Sean Stanger about bringing back the Freshman Academy we're excited about the opportunities that that provides as well uh for our students and the alignment of schedules for all three fcctc the uh CMS and caches will help
034with a lot of of uh supports and academic supports and of course their support for struggling students as you know that is why CMS is on school Improvement uh for special ed and ESL and basically cashes on for all their subgroups school performance profile I wanted to list the items that go into the calculation this this is how we're compared with across the state um your last pages of your packet are a list of all the schools and the 10 school districts that we are comparing ourselves to and you can see where Chambersburg Falls against those 10 school districts but the school performance profile they look at their academic achievement on pssa and Keystone that's their proficiency uh and advanced closing the achievement Gap how many kids are we actually closing that gap on learning
035they look at the Pennsylvania value added assessment the academic growth they look at our attendance rates they look at our graduation rates and we get extra credit for advanced achievement on AP exams do all of those hold the same amount weight when they're figuring into the score or that AMS there are some that hold heavier amounts like the achievement is is the biggest amount I I would have to take a look there is a uh a calculation um but it they do not all hold the same amount is there any of those just looking at that with your experience in it that we struggle with more than others that would be the first one for sure okay and we're start you know after covid we started to struggle with our habitually um Trent students or
036students with high absentee we are working hard on that that that's not just a Chambersburg thing I think that's a an every you know public school thing as well and of course attendance is then tied to graduation right everything else so if you have an attendance problem it's safe to say that some of those others are going to suffer because of that right so the next slide is a list of our schools and how they performed uh we generally within the state if you're scoring in the 70s that's pretty good if you score in the 80s I have those highlighted in blue that's really good and especially for uh middle schools or high schools to score in the 80s that that's pretty exceptional 10 of our 17 schools increased their SP School uh scores this
037year so I'll let that sit for just a second as we compare um you see the the high school is the lowest at uh8 as I looked at our 10 comparables uh that puts us at uh let me 10 out of the 10 out of the 12 12 high schools now CMS is fourth out of the 12 high schools but when you combine them it looks much better for us when you combine all of our students and I'm going to be heading into those slides right now so our proficiency comparison when you look at all 10 of the school districts you add those together all all the schools versus all of our schools we're slightly this is pretty tough for you to read I do have it in the packet so you can read a
038little easier but Chambersburg sits a little bit higher in all three areas of math Ela and science uh actually science is the the biggest uh gain over the other schools 76% to 62.5% when you look at the growth comparison when they're looking at uh how students grow grow our proficiency was a little higher so it makes sense that our our growth is a little higher as well and once again uh actually Ela is the largest uh Gainer there at 85% to 72% of our non- Chambersburg schools that are in that group of 10 10 districts and then when you combine caches and CMS our graduation rate is just slightly higher than the 10 schools back one side um the growth versus proficiency growth is a component right of that school proficiency profile yes what's the
039difference between the growth and the school performance profile what's they're they're using our past calculations if I'm correct I have to check on that but they use the peas how we are when kids come in P is looking at kids come in to a grade level right here how much are they growing throughout the grade level year-over-year and if they can close the gap it's going to equal higher growth and that's one thing our our teachers do quite well um our principles when we were meeting with them I had numerous bring up the the fact they would love to and some of them are actually going to do the the data comparison students that they have from K through fifth grade the entire time they want to track to see how they are doing we
040have a lot of movein uh last year we had um 800 families move in that were ESL students now we had a net gain of 400 and some ESL students so we had a lot of a lot of folks leave so Chambersburg is pretty transient in that we have a lot of students that are coming and going um you know Stevens Elementary being probably our most transient building that at the beginning of the year if you take a look at how many would end the year it's probably at at one point it was below 50% of the students that would start the year would end the year actually at Stevens so the school performance profile is a more comprehensive combined Benchmark where growth is a more specific component yes and these are the going back
041to this this slide again this is what's calculated into make making that score I have a slide here just to talk a little bit an update on uh AP data in 2223 we had 243 students that were enrolled in AP courses at cashes and CMS 56 of those students scored a three or higher AP exams 1 2 3 4 four or five or what you earn if you score a three or higher that's considered pretty good most colleges that accept AP courses uh for credit you have to score a three or higher to earn that credit so 243 students in 2223 went up to 270 in 23 24 and quite a few more students percent higher percentage scored a three or higher last year so 72% of the kids scored a three or higher so
042that's a really nice uh change in data for CMS and caches the IB uh data there was 217 kids enrolled in courses in the previous year 15 were in the diploma program and this year that we're in now 286 are enrolled in courses and two more students 17 are en rolled in the diploma program right now uh in the eib program I I've got a question on the um AP just in general you have a sense for prepandemic kind of data you know because I'm looking at um what happened 22 23 and then there was this big Improvement so I was wondering you know how that happened and comparing it to what happened you know years and years ago if you might have a sense for that I can get that answer for you um
043because I have the data from pre pandemic to to now uh I just chose to do the last three years um quick summary uh actually Chris has given a summary as well in his presentations uh the middle schools have recovered quite well and actually are even showing signs of improvement uh the elementary schools are still struggling but we're getting we're almost there in the elementary schools and the high schools um I would say our high school is actually probably performing still a little bit lower than where they were prior to uh Co but I I do have that specific data for year over year yeah no big and the year prior to co was an excellent data Year from as you heard me say before 10 of 17 schools SP their school performance profile number
044improved we have four buildings that are US News and World reported winners they're Guilford Hills you heard Mr bigger say Hamilton Heights for the second year in a row that's quite an achievement cams North and cams South um of course we'd love to recognize them at at a board meeting like we did with Hamilton Heights last year Scotland had the largest oneyear SP Improvement it was close to 18 points it's between 17 and 18 points so that's uh Quite a feat um Stevens so you see I talk a little bit about them under School Improvement but Stevens the last three years their SP has increased each year um as well as their their performance so we're very happy with what's going on at Stevens and they should be commended um an absolutely a celebration cams
045North South Hamilton and Guilford have been 3 years in a row with an uh over 80 SP which is really difficult to maintain that number over 80 because once again if when you were high in growth it it's tough to keep keep growing those kids and show that you have exceeded what the state has expected for one years of growth for a student moving to our schools under Improvement uh caches they're on the atsi plan uh their focus is on attendance of course subgroup growth um that's what basically put them on on atsi is all their performance and graduation rates of their subgroups um on attendance as you heard from the last presentation they're looking at making some changes at both CMS and caches and of course with our reconfigurations uh CMS is on school
046Improvement uh with the state as well their focus is on ESL and special ed growth and that's what placed them on the school Improvement uh Stevens was the only school that was not placed on by Pennsylvania but they were placed on uh by the federal government for being a what they call an underperforming school being in the lowest 10% proficiency rate um but I look for them to hopefully if the trend continues they're going to be off of that list as well and when I gave the presentation uh on schools under School improvement with Dr long a few months ago we talked about Buchanan and Buchanan is on for ESL performance and uh that data was from two years ago that placed it on it for this year and if you remember that was 79
047students that actually got them placed on that school Improvement uh over the last two years though we have seen uh increased scores with our students our ESL students at you can and so hopefully they're heading the right direction that they will be off of the uh state plan as well so bringing it back we're moving forward all in the right direction from our blueprint to our feasibility committee to the presentations that you've seen that we've talked about schools of Distinction uh to even our goals for Mr bigger myself and Dr long that we translate those goals with our principles that they are looking uh for they've set goals for 2030 in their uh performance their annual review as well as what their goals are this year to get them s incrementally there by 2030 for
048a 10% Improvement across the board we uh are investing time on changing some schedules devoting more time and resources to reading and writing and comprehending by third grade um we are looking at ways to increase our math fluency by fifth grade uh we're excited about the possibilities with uh our middle schools and schedules and what we can do with that schedule to continue to see that we are exceeding what the state expects for us for growth and with the changes that we're going to be making at the high school and also retaking of the Keystone uh exams we hope to see that we can hit that 10% Improvement as well in literature algebra and biology in March we'll look at giving another presentation that will give you a midyear performance update um what that'll look
049like we'll look at a Cadence and map and projected proficiencies and where we stand um a CA casd dashboard on our goals and where we stand predicting and where they they are set and also how do we use diagnostic data to drive our instruction so we will have that uh for you in March and I'll take any questions I know we took some along the way we'll be glad to yeah I have one final question um how do you see block scheduling supporting you know our performance metrics um just curious about that I think if we do the right professional development with our folks it can be a great benefit to our students it'll allow time to focus it'll allow time for like in biology to do more Hands-On experiments uh to um it just
050can't be teaching two lessons in one class it has to be meaningful instruction that gets the kids doing more Hands-On and uh more tactile uh learning I I think it can be a great benefit I like that it aligns to CMS it aligns to fcctc and it aligns to caches uh by going with the same schedule as well also look um some of the ancillary items that will we benefit I think that Mark said in some of his research you know discipline generally goes quite down attendance goes up lateness to class you know hopefully is wiped away and you know kids can focus on instruction for periods of time so I'm I'm in very much in support of the change thank you I I just like to say I was going through the data here
051um and the percentage of children meeting uh by grade level based on the meeting metric criteria that's listed here um still very much concerns me and I know we are we are looking at at at how we can address that but until we get that addressed I mean these numbers when I see that a half of class is going on to the next grade level and they're not reading on grade level um we continue to have issues there that and I know we we're putting forth some efforts but I I really think it it continues to it it's just a and the disparity between some of these elementary schools like I knew that it existed but to see Stevens for example 90% free and reduced 35% elll and then you have other schools that have
05244 free and reduced and 3.6% elll that's a totally different world I mean there's nothing comparable between them and so I think it even further solidifies and and the hope is I think of the board that we're moving in the right direction ction trying to consolidate and have a more comparable experience for all of these kids that are at these Elementary levels specifically um and seeing it in black and white with these data points just really drives that home so I really appreciate all the effort that you and your staff did to present that to us because I believe that we're making the right staff did to present that to us because I believe that we're making the right decision but to see it and the numbers back that up in such a distinct way
053for me personally I really appreciate uh the work that you put in to kind of go along with that so thank you very much yeah I'd also like to say too that this this is very comprehensive uh very easy to understand and um adding the aadience in there and and having a multicriteria to decide if a kid's on grade level uh because you know there's variance that goes on with that depending on the testing date or whatever I think it's very comprehensive but it also points to to where we have deficits that we've got to address and of course that you know that's a financial issue but um I I think uh K to3 we've really got to we've got to invest in getting these kids where they need to go plus we're sending a
054whole group on that are struggling so it's it's very difficult but I I appreciate you listening thank you Mr wman yeah I was just gonna say thank you I know some of these sheets are you spend hours even days just on one page so to have a whole pile of it is pretty impressive thank you thank you I appreciate only 15 or so rather than 47 gave me a [Laughter] Target appreciate you being good about it too good even board and superintendent bigger concerning agenda item 807 you will be hiring 59 people for good paying middle class jobs tonight none of you should vote no to these needed positions I really don't think any of you won't vote no after hearing all of you speak tonight in a positive manner why these people will help
055maintain Mrs Jordan's social Social Security into her aging years on this Earth that $2.6 million allocated in the $21.6 million budget will cost me 1% in next year's budget in dollar and cents based on my property assessment that is $51.7 for 59 taxpaying people to be employed here that's that's what all of us should want here taxpaying people to be employed I like nice things too I like coming into any public building being proud of it when a $170 million project is finally voted on please be assured we all can cover this cost without hesitation to do so I never left an area because I couldn't afford to live there this is to you superintendent bigger and because you're on the agenda I'm going to speak directly to you lastly superintendent bigger here's what I
056want from you if Republican state lawmakers decide to push forward with attempting to end property taxes as a source of funding our Public Schools I want you to round table with other superintendant in our state to stop this nonsense you're a taxpayer too you deserve to be paid out of property taxes not some unknown state line item which may very likely not guarantee the dollars you deserve these Republican state lawmakers may find out that they are on the losing end of this proposition too if they are remotely successful in passing such a law I know both Rob Kaufman and dougm are on the losing end of the price school private business Cyber Charter Schools to the tune of 8 million when our school budget was passed last year that 8 million should be funding our
057schools not someone else's school thank you thank you Mrs Jordan and you'll receive Dr Wagner please you receive this in email from me well good evening I'm Dr Dwight Wagner I've been a resident I think your microphone's off okay is that it got it on okay as I was saying I'm Dr Dwight Wagner been a resident of Pen National since 2008 and I spent my 33e careers ined educator with Prince George's County school system in a variety of administrative roles more relevant to you though was I spent 34 years working with the middle States accreditation Association and this uh organization as you probably know uh serves the District Columbia Maryland Pennsylvania New Jersey and New York so it covers quite a territory and a lot of schools and a lot of school systems about 1933
058I'm 33 excuse me 93 the organization acquired new leadership and they began to focus on the whole matter of developing new protocols related to strategic planning on the premise that if you fail to plan you are planning to fail and that of course is very relevant to what's happening with you folks at this time you very wisely selected Mr bigger as your superintendent I've known Mr bigger a number of years and he's very capable he understands the process he's capable providing excellent leadership in moving toward the process of strategic planning obviously that's not something that has happened in the previous two administrations and if you're standing still in my opinion you're in a process of failure what you're doing now and clearly indicated by what Mr wigman indicates in the slides is you have a
059process going forth that lays out the road work for what you can do in terms of making real progress with improving your educational system in the course of my career with uh working with middle States I visited over 60 schools in one capacity or another so I've seen just about anything you can think of one way or another I might add that uh we had the great pleasure of having Dr Long graciously serve on two of our evaluations and uh which turned out to be quite unique and interesting in their own right I'm sure he could fill you in on that if you so choose but the point is is that you really are engaged in a in a worthwhile and significant process and what we found at middle States was the under the best
060schools that we found were assist situation where you had strong leadership at the top and you had a very strong support by the board behind that leader to go forth It's a challenging process it can be difficult it takes time but it is the most important way to move ahead and Achieve educational Improvement for the students that you're serving uh within your your system so I want to congratulate you for uh what you've been doing and how you're doing I'm looking forward to seeing what's going to happen uh I find it very exciting frankly so thank you thank you thank you thank you any other members of the public wish to uh discuss on comment on any agenda items okay uh nothing in Old business moving on to uh the consent agenda the new items
061um we'll do a u motion or actually no we're going to go through these first uh we've been doing it I'll ask we ask Mr bger and any of the administration administrative team if there are any items between 7.01 to 7.07 that Mr B you or your team would like to comment on these are items that were not discussed uh last week at our Comm I think Tammy can go over real quickly 7.04 just so you understand uh where that one's coming from a little bit in short Tammy sure uh so uh 7.04 is a resolution that will allow for us to apply for the pa uh solar grants that recently came available through um the Department of Economic and Community Development uh we have the opportunity to and and we have been Matt's here
062uh and he can maybe elaborate a little bit if needed uh we have already begun to investigate looking into potential solar projects uh we're looking specifically at fville elementary and Scotland Elementary a lot of that came from the fact that the U IRS changed the uh tax credit that was available for profit organizations is now also available for municipalities and governmental entities so this will allow us just purely to apply uh we are eligible for up to $400,000 uh for each project through this grant I think just to add to that we would look at schools outside the burrow uh I had a privilege of seeing the Burrow's solar farm where 25% of the energy in the burough is coming from solar or uh waste uh gases so we would strategically Target the the schools
063outside the burrow because they're already being funded by some solar projects does it require any funding from the district there will be funding from the district depending on uh what the project basically um we would have to go through an assessment with an entity I think it's called generation 180 would come out and assess the buildings and determine what number of arrays we would need uh but through the analysis I think the one company that we looked at there could be a return on the investment in four or five years and then basically you're producing your energy at at no cost and it's it's gotten complicated we're learning pretty quickly uh there's also what they call srax which if you don't utilize all your capacity you can sell back so there would be a profit
064and loss scenario so if we're putting out 400 if they're giving out 400,000 so we get that what what would that mean for the district as far as our initial cost to we're not that far along um and this grant is due January 31st so we have a very short window and there's no guarantee that we will apply and we will even get this there's I think 25 million that was allocated through the state of Pennsylvania there are three regions that are each going to get a little over 8 million that would get debied out depending on how the projects come through I want to highlight Matt is um um been educating us he's well versed in this we're learning as a group he's well versed in understanding the infrastructures needed whether it's a rooftop
065or in a field or anything there's a lot of questions we're in study phase however this opportunity came up and we couldn't not at least try to see what we can do or not do but we're we're not sold on um selling our to solar it it has to be the right fit the right place the right location so in the study phase we're learning so if you want to learn with us we'll certainly provide you more information and documentation um about uh this approach and or other approaches as we study them as well this is this is not a commitment to to do the project this is just more or less allowing us to go ahead and submit an application to the state so that if we do decide to move forward we can
066access that funding that was it that was the only that was the only one that stood out board members any questions discussions on any specific items 7.01 through 7.07 okay hearing none then I guess I'll assume there's no item that any member would like to uh remove from the list and vote on separately okay so do I have a motion for approval of items 7.01 through 7.07 as presented on the agenda move to approve second motion by Mrs goggler second by Mrs gal all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed eyes have it and so moved our second consent agenda series uh these items were previously discussed last week at our committee of the whole uh so uh we'll provide an opportunity but 8.01 through 8.13 any new information or additional highlights
067Mr beggar not from our view board members any questions comments on any of the items 8.01 through 8.13 yeah have a question about 802 I'm just curious to know like when we think about uh should I ask the question now or no no yes go ahead yes yeah so uh as I see it when I think about the presentation that we just received and improving our metrics there do you feel like there is anything that we could do from a budgetary standpoint that would help us to um better improve the the growth that we see or do you feel like we're we're on track as is and this is a a good uh I think it's for me it's too soon to tell if we're going to get uh any State dollars right to say
068if we're going to ask the local for any additional dollars I think it's hard for us to uh receive 8.2 and then turn around continue to ask our local residents for continued more so I think there's a nice balance here and knowing more in the next couple months will be really helpful to know if we can extend some of our uh needs into some positions so I'm not ready to commit or say anything but you know it's a good topic we are really early in our budget process so I'm thankful for that we're starting this conversation really early yeah so from your end you're just keeping a pulse on what's going on in Harrisburg what you're hearing from the governor and from the legislators the other thing you have to monitor um for us and
069help us is don't overexp too much we have do have a bunch of positions we have to get them hired right trained implemented and started and that takes time energy and effort so I want to make sure we do things well and Implement them in quality and then revisit whether we have the capacity to continue to add or do something different so there is a nice uh great place we're at where we have resources and we can implement but also let's make sure we can follow through yeah I've got a comment or two um along those lines so I continue to look at Mr bigger as being the uh belly button on the organization anybody can point to and say this person is ultimately responsible for everything that goes on and I like that idea
070sure you do but I also respect that I've never run a school district he has I've never managed a budget of90 million $200 million he has and I know that probably before I can get an opportunity to there'll be a lot of other people poking him if he fails in some way and he's saying and he said this when he first came on board it's not about spending more money it's about spending what we have wisely and I like that too but I'm also aware that many many times I hear Dr Diller say we need more blocking and tackling before kids get out of third grade because we want them to succeed there I I listen to what we need in other areas and I'm wondering I'm being patient to allow those positions that we've
071already going to be proving here you know get filled and see how it's working and make any adjustments but we have the opportunity anytime we want as board members to say no Mr superintendent we want more than what you're proposing and we can do that but right now I'm saying I'm willing to be patient to let him uh guide this process thus far and if I'm mistaken I'll take I'll take the hit I'll take the punishment later on what whatever that may be but right now I'm willing to be patient with this board and with this superintendent for the next year or so see how things go I would I would like to add on um as far as the budget I know you said it's kind of up in air because you don't you're
072not sure and I know we had mentioned before about um once we set it it's set you can't go up any higher um but you can come back down uh if if that's uh just your your thought process on that would it be advantageous to set it maybe the bar a little bit higher and then come back down knowing that okay we've got money from you know the government or or whatever other sources um take on that so the vote tonight um you know item 801 and item 802 are tied together um because we've accelerated this process normally we would wouldn't necessarily have to approve a proposed preliminary budget um the cap is still 5.3 you know right now we're showing you a budget that has a slight deficit if we raise taxes to 2%
073you still have the ability to go up or down until the final vote which will be in June so if say for example um something comes up in like March or April that we say hey you know what we're going to put another million of expense into this general fund budget then I'm going to come back he'll have conversation and we may end up at 3% as our final so we still have that ability so we're not locked that was Mon it's not locked okay you're not locked in yeah okay just from a sheer number stand Point all right 802 propose preliminary two very key words currently sits at 2% 8.01 says we are are willing to go up to 5.3 so if the board no higher than 5.3 yes thank you Mrs goggler so
074as as Mrs stalford said 801 802 they are they're twins uh so we're at 2% proposed preliminary but it the cap is 5.3 so there is there is room uh up or down the reason for the initial proposal listing a deficit is because you anticipate or you hope to find that money somewhere in the next few months yeah I mean honestly I mean say this it's about yeah it's 453,000 58 I don't have my glasses on but for all in senstive purposes it's a balanced budget right now so to come in at and show you a preliminary that is at 3% or 4% you're going to see a projected def or projected Surplus there's just not a need right now with the preliminary to come in with a a higher estimate if you approve 10.01
075and we begin the architectural um contracts and we start our phasing of how we're going to move forward with facilities that'll determine too the dollar amounts we'll need and when and so you're balancing the facilities along with Staffing at the same time and we're committing to the gray configuration so we are moving down that path a little faster as we've done the essential conditions and Staffing to get us started so there is this Push Pull with both Staffing and the buildings at the same time that are both financially heavy and burdensome on our budget so I think you have to let that evolve through the spring and we'll keep bringing you data and information and you know is the four to six building first is Grand View first is the 78 school first how much
076is it what's our borrowing capacity that sets the budget and then you can come back to the Staffing if the state gives us more money so it is a little bit of a juggling act and you just have to pay attention to all the the big pieces and we'll do that for you and we will certainly let you know where we stand and I've said this before it's only a matter how fast and how much um we want to be able to do at one time schools of Distinction by 2028 you said right yeah 2030 yeah sure Mr rabber gets a bonus point because he quoted yes good investment in schools of Distinction by 2030 not a project yeah okay any other questions comments items 8.01 through 8.13 okay hearing none uh as for a
077motion and second to approve items 8.01 through 8.13 please move to approve second motion by Mr mcke second by Dr Diller all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed eyes have it and so moved so we'll go to item 10.01 Mr rabber as I said earlier got a Bonus point we're not going to give you a demerit Mr bigger we're not going to put you in detention I did spend some time in detention when I was in high school but anyway uh for we're going to you know facility feasibility study recommendation uh investment in schools of Distinction by 2030 recommendation please Mr bigger yeah I I think I've presented on this 35 times to the public I don't know I need to represent it but we are recommending scenario 4 which has the
078great configuration of K to3 4 to6 78 and 912 um with uh certain Focus areas within that targeted of our middle schools are struggling infrastructure we're uh out of space in elementary and the need for additional programming at Creer Tech and the Creer Magnet School are our three big priorities when it comes to this feasibility study recommendation okay questions or no let's have a motion and second first please 10.0 approve second motion by Mrs goggler second by Dr Diller questions discussions board members I'm excited about a lot of this um you've heard me ask this before but I think my largest conc concern my biggest concern is the size of a potential 4 through six because I think the implications of this vote is that we end up with one building would not entertain two
079or three building you know and so uh we'd have a four through six building that is larger than our high school at a much earlier age um so my question is uh as as you've talked about this with your team what what are some of the strategies that you're hoping to implement to kind of ease some of that and even for the public for teachers or for parents that are concerned about the size can you kind of put our mind at ease with uh some of the things that you've been talking about as a team that you think could really help to yeah I mean I'll look to the team to I'll get started a little bit but you know from a a person who's combined to smaller schools into a size of 900 where
080that Community was worried about the size the school opens and nobody car so I've seen it in a smaller scale I will say the Elementary schedule grades four through six runs very contained very narrow it is not hit the button and all the kids run around all 2100 of them just get to go wherever they want they go across the hall to their other teacher um I think the most challenging part of the school will be parent pick up and drop off um and certainly your buses um but as far as the school day I cannot emphasize enough that the self-contained approach of element entry schedules will be its its approach now we are entertaining ideas like um looping so you might just stay with your students you get him in fourth grade you educate
081them in fifth grade you educate him in sixth grade very relational aming um and so we were exploring that idea there are people that don't like that there are people that do like that so if we can make it feel small we will um if we can design the building which our Architects will be tasked to do that how can you make a building feel small when it's that large um and we already explored some other ideas is um you saw the one in the study if you did it was like an e really long hallways yeah how about you put the central uh areas down the middle and have it go out each way right 350 a wing versus 700 in a wing U and maybe three stories versus two stories so if we
082can start to create houses of staff and students in smaller segments and they stay in their area all day I'm not sure you're going to notice yeah um so things you will gain though from the efficiencies of a larger building are your quality spaces your anill spaces your outdoor spaces certainly your gyms your cafeterias your art rooms your music rooms things that people take for granted here that they have in some buildings and not others and when you have those I cannot tell you how excited parents will be and staff will be to see those so I think nice Auditorium yeah when you see and look at all that you go okay this is worth having the larger uh building for that um but if you know elementary teachers well they will know their kids
083by name will know their you know situations by heart that's the nature of an elementary teacher yeah great response thank you yeah I just want to comment on that I because I I've been an advocate of and I think this is a solution to that situation where we've had so many elementary schools with their own cultures their own isolations in so many ways and by the time they get together they don't know one another and this is an opportunity that when you have a four through six School school assembly they're all together even if it's only for an hour but they get to know one another they get to these aren't other people they're people they're my friends so I think that is so important because if you don't do it when kids are young
084when they're our age they don't get along and we can tell you the mascot in the for to six building will be a Trojan like that's you know it's a conversation we talk about all the time when you're one town one Community but you have a bunch of elementary schools and I'm not criticizing that they all have their own mascots that's the nature of an elementary school but there is an important point when you're one Trojan you're one town in your one community and that'll start in fourth grade so the the rallying around that idea that I am a Trojan um will start in fourth grade versus you know ninth grade right now and I think again the sixth grade moving down to the elementary will be a big plus yes I agree uh it
085has been shown time after time uh and and it's really three schools in one you know there it I de at first I had maybe concern but then looking more No it's it's going to be here and it'd be great if a teacher could stay with their kids all the time because relationships is where it's all about most of us don't remember the subjects we were taught but we remember the teacher that taught them and influenced their lives good comments good questions great answers other questions comments discussion all right um sorry Mrs yes roll call vote please this is a $170 million investment in schools of Distinction by 2030 roll call not a problem Dr Diller yes Mrs goggler yes Miss gal yes Miss Harbaugh yes Mr Hauck yes Mr mcke yes Mr Norcross yes
086Mr raber yes Mr Walker yes motion passes 9 to zero bring out the banner okay work begins now and we are off Brandy great work everyone it is exciting very exciting proud to be sitting in this seat while this is going on uh okay item 13 new business discussion only as I said in the opening uh this was my fault because I blew right through it a week ago at uh Committee of the whole so new business discussion only yes I have one item to yes sir okay so the school district has a lot of policies and uh for 90% of them it's up to Mr bigger we could just say hey that policy needs a change or take a look at it he can say Mark or Kurt go and do whatever but the
087one policy that is the board's responsibility is 0000 0 and of the 10 policies underneath that big policy the last the most recent update was uh in 2021 of the other ones were like summer as old as 2014 so I'm suggesting is our policies are really really old and obsolete if they are to reflect what we do then we should update them and so I just ask that we consider putting together a committee for a short period of time to take a look at the policies to make some recommendations to the board and to fix the problem thank you any other discussion thoughts having been on the policy committee prior to Mr bigger arriving on our change we were in the process of looking at the dates and getting the older ones updated we just
088didn't finish that process so I agree that it needs to be done but it was was a goal of that committee u a couple years ago and in all fairness we've been in flux W just saying uh Mr Hau under 000000 are you recommending that we uh that we revise and take a look at all of them or there specific ones that stood out to you as being in need of attention there are certainly some that are in need of attention uh ones that reflect I think it's section 004 uhhuh um I'm not sure who's responsible for that other than you know it does doesn't really specify but um some of those procedures are probably obsolete uh we discussed a little earlier just just in passing that most of these professional development courses are online
089we don't have to seek approval from anyone here or seek a budget request or any kind of a reimbursement for travel that's probably not going to be the case in rare circumstances where someone goes to a convention somewhere outside or inside the state um one might consider we have an election every year for board officers if you're a newly elected board member and you walk into the meeting for the first time you get sworn in that day you're going to get sworn in what do you know about any of the people that say they want to be a president or vice president or any any office you don't know anything we don't have an opportunity to State this is what our commitments were that's what I like to hear what Ed said here are my
090priorities as a president if if every candidate would have an opportunity to express to the voting members this is what I believe in this is where I want to have my priorities for the next year that would give us an opportunity to make a more intelligent vote I think think well I'm suggesting that's another area we might consider there lots of opportunities there but it is our policy we can't say to Chris fix our policy can we thank you there's one thing I don't have to do apprciate that I'll let it go with that yeah as Mrs goggler mentioned uh previously when we operated with individual committees uh versus a committee of the whole there was a policy committee um I made you comment earlier with with Mr Whitman I heard a great message on
091Sunday about living is changing uh and we are changing and we are living uh but if it's something the board would uh like to consider uh we could do Mr biger and I were just whispering to one another uh we could do an ad hoc committee if there were were u a subset of board members who wanted to to be a policy committee um I was never on the policy committee before but it was pretty much a uh a lineup I would say that would come through from pasbo uh that hey you know policy XYZ are now coming forward for review and one of the benefits of using it's a very generic process but the benefits of the generic process is we can trust it's been vetted you know uh couple years ago it was
092really heavy on changing pronouns but that's what was happening a couple years ago uh but it was vetted through you know legal and and people not just a group of community volunteers as we all are I I would suggest you do the ad hoc specifically for the local procedures of the zero section will St still take care of the remainder of them like bav and myself are focused on policy so um if if that's that would be a way I would approach it that way the zeros have an end point to them and it's not a permanent committee that just runs and forever so you take those ones that are local board procedures ad hoc on that one and if two or three of you want to help put that together that would be the
093way I think you should look at it and I'd be happy to nominate myself to volunteer to be on that committee to work with any other board members to get it done and I would nominate Mrs goggler to come work with me cuz I know we can work together to get it done you're welcome Mrs goggler mer you had a third you had a third uh self nominated person okay when would you like to meet well what we will do at this after Christmas what we will do at this point to keep the the sequence that we like to follow um this will go on the committee of the whole agenda for next meeting um if anyone wants to think of it and wants to change their mind or if anyone else wants to change
094your mind and make it four members that's good we could go to four we don't want five then we have issues with Quorum so if there were a another member who wanted to be part of the committee we could do four and there another one I don't need to I don't need to be in it I'm happy to just back off and say oh you brought it up that's how that works well and even if a policy does not need to be revised it should have a review date and so um you know looking at some of these they don't really need to be revised but they need to be reviewed so that it reflects that we have looked at them and that we put our stamp on those policies as being still applicable well
095right right for for tonight for tonight we will move this forward to Committee of the whole Mrs goggler Mr hack if you want to put together a couple talking points when we have it on our uh January committee the whole meeting we can really tune in a little closer dive in uh thoughts ideas everyone will have uh you know a couple glasses of eggnog to think about it over the next couple days and then uh we can discuss it again January cow and vote on it in January meeting yep any other new business items okay 14.01 standard District enrollment summary for information only um is available that meetings adjourn thank you