001good evening it's Thursday December 5th 2024 and this is the reorganization meeting of the cancer Rock School Board uh please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance yeah I may um may I ask fifth grader Quinn Browning to join us she is going to lead us in the pledge she's going to ask us to remain standing and then she will sing the national anthem for us so Quinn welcome Tony would you help her with oh you have a microphone to the flag of the United States of America and to the e e e [Applause] qu Quinn thank you so much thanks for braving a cold night on a school night we have little something here for you and thank your mom for dragging you out tonight so come on up here and and get this thank
002you so much [Applause] [Music] Madame secretary R call please miss pully present Mr Tate present Mr hialgo present Mr Roosevelt here Mr hickey here miss oaki here miss Khan here miss Stone here Miss Herer here all [Music] right okay uh next we have public comment public comment is an opportunity for members of the public to address the board we would ask that you limit your comments to no longer than three minutes please consider the fact that there may be young children in the audience or watching this broadcast live on crtv when speaking it is our goal to make maintain a respectful environment so that members of our community have an equal opportunity to address the board without interruption while the board welcomes your ideas and will consider them in deliberating an issue we may not
003respond to your comments or questions uh we thought we had somebody but I guess we don't right okay that was the mom of our okay excellent uh next we have the nomination on an election of the president protemp Mr amuso do you yeah uh great so do we have any uh nominations for president proem I will nominate Linda Stone Linda Stone has been nominated are there any other nominations for president proem I'll nominate Mr Rosevelt great so Mr Ros has been nominated for president proem are there any other nominations all right then we'll close the nominations I would ask the secretary to call a roll call vote obviously if you want to vot for Miss Stone say Miss Stone if you want to vote for Mr Roosevelt say Mr Roosevelt okay Mr Tate Miss Stone
004okay Mr hialgo Miss Stone Mr Roosevelt Mr hickey Mr Roosevelt okay Miss Paulie Miss Stone Miss oaki Miss Stone Miss Khan Miss Stone Miss Stone Miss Herer Mr Roosevelt okay so that's six for Miss Stone and three for Mr Roosevelt so miss Stone has been elected president proem okay do I accept hopefully all right so the the meeting is now yours okay and the next item is of course the election of the board president well then nominations are now in order for the office of president uh Yoda I would like to nominate Ed Tate for president is there a second you don't need a second don't need a second thank you um are there an any other nominations Mr Roosevelt I nominate Tracy [Music] osaki are there any other nominations okay okay um hearing no
005other nominations may we have a roll call and please name either Tracy oi or Ed Tate as um [Music] president do we get to yeah don't we get to plead our case I mean typically you just vote but look welcome to discuss I mean it's fine sure I I mean I think uh I think we did it previously my you know my recollection is did it previously so I don't know if anyone else has any comments but go ahead go ahead I'm okay thank you Mr hialgo thank you um so I'll just say but I put out there a a compromise after the last year that we had and I put an email individually to each board member uh since Mr Tade and I both have uh the most longevity on the board that I
006made an offer saying I I'm going to support Mr Tate for president and offered because I mean time I don't need to to do it but I thought if I was able to be in the leadership as vice president then we could work together and I could report back to um the four Republicans and he could report to the uh five Democrats and this way we be splitting up because last year was was kind of convol uded so I'll leave it at that we can just go back and check the tape uh so that will be my offer out here again tonight uh to everybody that supporting Mr Tate he's earned it he's been here long enough and uh and I'm putting out the olive branch for vice president thank you does anyone else have
007any comments before roll call I have some comments Mr hickey thank you I would like to start out by saying that like everyone here all my decisions are based on what I feel is in the best interest of the district the community at large and most importantly the students of Council Rock I am one in nine no more important nor less important than the other eight however over the past year I must admit that I haven't felt like an equal partner I'm hoping tonight can begin to change that my thought process is three-fold as it relates to board leadership general terms why the current leadership should not remain and why or more specifically who should be on the leadership team in general terms first let me point out I have no issues with the board
008President and Vice President being of the majority party however members of this current majority felt that this was totally unfair in the past when they were in the minority did they really mean that if so then leadership should be split among both the majority and the minority since right now we are a 54 balance not 90 or to1 otherwise those complaints were merely for show or you're being hypocritical I believe Mr Tate also served on board leadership when he was in a minority so the precedent has been set as I said I have no issues and we are supposed to be a cohesive unit and represent the entire Council Rock Community and not one particular segment only two people contacted me about board leadership Ed hat and Joe hialgo this would work out as Ed
009is in the majority party and Joe in the minority it would also be representative of our district and Community as Ed is from the Northern end of the district and Joe the southern end if there are more people who were interested in leadership and had not let me know it would only solidify one of my points as to why the current leadership is not effective which brings me to my second Point why we should not have a repeat of the same two people in board leadership two critical qu qualities of any leadership position should be transparency and communication in my opinion and in the opinion of numerous emails phone calls and meetings the current leadership was lacking in both we all read the emails you can say it was biased but the nine of us
010received those correspondences from prominent individuals within our community the educational Arena and most with no acts to grind I cannot publicly say their names but the nine of us all know who they are as far as transparency is concerned do we really need to litigate the selection of our solicitor again whether they are phenomenal or substandard is isn't the issue the four minority members were blindsided without an opportunity to vet any vendors in private some have expressed remorse in the process but publicly stand by their secrecy as far as communication goes not once in this past year was I contacted by board leadership as it concerned an issue if I had a question about a topic or have a conversation of how to see things in a different light most of you know I had
011major reservations about full day kindergarten maybe you would have thought someone would re reach out and say hey Bob what can we do to get you on board this is only one example another function of leadership is running the meetings how many hours did we waste discussing topics that never should have been made on a televised board agenda a perfect example is just last month where a policy was brought up for consent vote when it didn't even have a consensus in the policy committee meeting so instead we spent an hour discussing it only to kick it back to the committee where it belonged many of our meetings have been unprofessional as board leadership not only admonished other members but at one meeting admonished our board secretary you don't have to believe me alls I say
012is look and listen for yourselves I don't say this to be negative rather I say it to be honest in the hopes for a better year ahead for all these reasons and others I do not feel like continuing with the same is good for our district at this time so who should be our leaders as I said only two people contacted me Ed and Joe so the choice should be easy if there were more where was that communication I specifically asked Miss p and Mr Tate back on November 27th through through an email I sent if there were any other interested candidates I received no response from either I spoke to miss Herer Mr Roosevelt about their interest in leadership they were not I asked Miss soeki if she would be interested in leadership as
013I felt she may be a good fit and Mike Mr Roosevelt I thank you for nominating her she also declined citing a lack of experience my apologies to miss Khan Miss Stone I just assume the same would be true for you as well I never did bother to ask but neither of you also indicated a desire to me for me I would gladly serve if selected and I feel I have the qualifications to serve however I defer to Mr hialgo at this time and would only be interested if for some reason he was not elected well I just spent the last few minutes why I thought Mr tapate may be a poor choice choice I am willing to reach across the aisle and support him I had a conversation with him where I aired my
014concerns he told me he sees himself doing things differently this coming year he also told me that he could work with Mr hadalo in leadership I will take him for at his word Mr Tate you have my vote I am hoping that my minority colleagues will also support him and Ed I am hoping that you will reach across that same aisle and support Mr hadalo we know this to be the best path forward I am in full support of a tate hialgo leadership team they check all the boxes majority minority North and South they are the two most senior members of our group a 90 vote for both would go a long way to showing our community that we can work together I think the Council Rock Community deserves that a 54 vote for either
015president or vice president will only show that the minority here is not valued I am extending my hand I am hoping someone in the majority feels the same way and extends theirs at well we we'll know that answer soon thank you uh are there any other comments Mr Roosevelt thank you um I believe Mr hickey covered several things that I plan to talk about but one he uh he didn't talk about which I'm going to take that opportunity I think all nine of us can agree that last year didn't go as we had expected I think that despite the claims for transparency and communication and educational Excellence that were uttered um the at least in some capacity the trans the transparency and a communication were less than desirable I think Mr hickey addressed that so
016I won't continue that further regarding educational Excellence this is another issue I think that there's been several educational initiatives that have been done for future students but we have students that are looking to graduate this year we have students in the sophomore and their junior years that are trying hopefully to increase their grades because they recognize that they'd like to go to college or have something else there's no support for these we have students in the 8th grade that are looking to get into high school and and move over into that direction of their educational path um there's no help for them we've got kids in seventh grade that may have figured out what middle school how it's different than Elementary and are looking forward to high school there's not so much support for them
017as well we've got kids in sixth grade that are going into Middle School the list goes on and on down um I was hoping that we would see some support for the current kids in this District um we didn't so I don't know um not to relitigate full day kindergarten but having one thing is that excellent the other element I think that we've seen last year is regarding the way board meetings and committee meetings have been run the active one of the nine of us should not indicate the way the rest of us operate that's the way the 1949 act 14 school code effectively reads at least in my opinion um and the way in my experience it's been done additionally I think that extends to the cabinet and the cabinet clearly understands this that
018the action of one should not influence or dictate to others how how they are to operate so in fact section 427 of this I pulled out one one particular sentence this is the duties of President notice it doesn't say Powers it says duties duties shall perform or president excuse me president shall perform such other duties as the board may direct I think that's a very interesting sentence because it indicates the board is directing the president not the president directing the board section 428 duties of the VP is to serve as the president in their abs and pertaining to business of the board this is writing checks signing things doing I guess the bulk of the business here that's done um but it doesn't go on to any other quote Powers it's actually Article Five where
019it talks about the um the board sections 501 to 528 and large this refers to the board which is all nine of us we as individual Schoolboard directors do not have any individual power our power is only when we arrive together in a group and it's the board so that is something that also goes a long way to working together so I could support Mr Tate also with the understanding that this year is going to be different and I hope that it would be I hope that we can have a better opportunity to work together I hope that we would get equal And Timely information all nine of us at the same time to further communication I hope that we would be able to have deeper transparency between everybody to understand what we're here for
020is to help this Administration educate kids and I hope that we could do probably the most important thing that we're supposed to be doing up here is helping education of the community's kids that come here so I could I'm I did nominate Miss oi and I thought that um the way she's conducted herself has been very well researched um and that I think would be an interesting compliment I also could support Mr Tate as I've mentioned I agree with Mr hickey's comment regard stting experience if we're going to turn a page here and we are going to try to work more together then I think it it does despite my nomination fall upon the two most senior people on this board to Endeavor to do that I don't entirely agree with the fact that majority
021should be split or not split or north versus South I think that that is a decision upon the n of us um but in this case I'm looking at experience I Mr hickey has convinced me I think that experience um is important so I could support Mr Tate with the understanding that he would support Mr hadalo so I think that that's a question at this point that Mr hickey was trying to allude to that wasn't maybe direct Mr Tate would you support Mr Hado for vice president thank you are there any other comments Tracy um good evening I I um have really enjoyed my time on the board the last year and I've learned a lot and I will share that I'm happy to be supporting Mr Tate for board president he is the longest
02210 of anyone on the board as has been mentioned and uh he's consistently shown an interest in doing right by the students of this District I found him to have the utmost character and he's been a pleasure to work with over the last year and so I'm I'm um excited and I will be supporting him for board president therefore uh I'm going to decline but I appreciate the nomination Mr Roosevelt um I I um and thinking about what we've accomplished over the last year I have to take issue with Mr Roosevelt's comments um a number of them but I'll I'll be brief um we have opened a newly renovated soulin Stone Richboro Elementary is going to open in a in a few short weeks we have researched and planned for full day kindergarten something that
023had been desperately needed in the district for many many many many many years um and I think that was a huge win for for our families and for our students um we've done things you know we talk about the educational Excellence communication and student well-being we have researched with uh Mr W's leadership researched gone out to bid implemented a new cafeteria service provider for the district and that those things that those are things that affect our current students every day um we have approve the safe touches program for our second graders so our current students are getting educated about a good touch and a bad touch and that hadn't been done since I think 2018 uh we are on track to become a chop certified heart safe school district and that is something that means
024a lot to our current students and means a lot to me personally I've also seen our Administration and our board support our special education program tremendously um we're now talking about special education at every education committee meeting I think that's something that really needed um the extra attention um we have a new role added to the administration and that was with board support um I think across the aisle we've done a lot um including starting a CPAC with the administration that that that's affecting our current kids so um I don't know Dr Seno can I can I ask you do you think that it's accurate that we're not supporting our our current students I mean don't you think that we do everything to support our current students in addition to prepping for students that are
025to come in the future I think we do our best every day to support the 10,500 for students that we have um regardless of our role or their age or grade level from K to 22 21 right now K to 21 that certainly has been my um experience as well so that's thank you any other comments yes Nikki good evening thank you um I fully agree with u what Miss oi said this evening um I would have to imagine that being on the other side of the Das and you know most of the time sitting in the audience um as a constituent a stakeholder and a parent I've watched these meetings over the last four years and now being on this side which has been a very challenging interesting um experience and I've learned a
026whole lot and I've enjoyed my my first year here as a school board director um I just want to add on to miss oi's comment in terms of all the committee meetings you know as well as the facility with the master plan coming up that we'll be reviewing in January um I think we've gotten a lot of things done for the district for the students in um our schools over the past 11 months that I've been on the board um I fully support Mr Tate for presidency this coming year and look forward to his continued leadership um and guidance thank you any other comments y Miss P yes yes um since this is the end of my presidency and I heard some comments I would like to address some things for Mr Hidalgo and why
027I disagree with the assessment about him being in leadership so Mr hialgo I feel that you're acting as the most divisive person on this board you constantly attack and accuse other board colleagues and you have insidey chaos and distrust you repeatedly claim not to have answers to the same endless questions but in truth the answers have been given over and over again both publicly in these meetings and in private you just don't like those answers I also feel that there is ample opportunity to engage in polite discussion and ask further questions anyone may have might have been given to all board members but is often ignored you accuse colleagues of holding a Ed secret meetings that were not actually secret and not only were you invited to but were also provided information about the content
028when you are unable to attend on multiple occasions I have witness you demonstrate content sending behavior and attitudes in public meetings towards board colleagues as well as Administration Educators and other District staff members I've seen that with Mr RAB with Dr Black and very often against me in two separate meetings you berated the board secretary for 45 minutes accusing her of manipulating the minutes and unfortunately she's not here anymore you have unjustly accused fellow board members of violating Sunshine laws without cause you have publicly accused me of being unethical demanding my resignation only to turn around and apologizing private Awards afterwards once the damage was done you have you have continually stall the treasurers report to discuss solicitor bills each month even when the report does not contain any solicitor bills just wasting time with
029misinformation and runs about solicitors who are saving the district money while providing excellent service the district has requested this continued animosity towards a solicitor who was voted in and has proven their value to the district needs to stop you repeatedly have said that an investigation is needed without explaining what needs to be investigated or why you risk creating a misleading impression among our community that something improper has occurred when you know it has not and that threatens to harm our school district reputation I've written more things but I don't want to go on I just think that you have been the most divisive person on this board this last year and uh I cannot support you leadership would do you want to comment of course there's a um the one thing that you said that
030I was invited to this meeting that we didn't get a chance to when you guys met with the solicitors that's the meeting we were not invited to so I think you misspoke or I misunderstood what you said number two I stand by most everything that you you were saying there um but you there there's a lot of wrong comments uh that you made there but I'm very happy that your tenure is over thank you uh without any other comments can we call it Mr Roosevelt I just want to briefly respond to miss your long enlisted list was one of the reasons why I did nominate you I think that it's that type of detailed notes that I think is very helpful on this board and it was wonderful to hear all of the accomplishments that
031the administration and this board did together but to clarify my statement because I don't know if I misoke misspoke I meant to indicate education I was talking regarding education not support of the kids I think that that this board and this Administration most particularly um is always supportive of the kids what I was talking about is the education of those of that long and lengthy list I believe one I'll just go up to three could be educational and that's sort of my concern um I don't want to relitigate other things but additional math and reading Specialists would be good looking at at test scores and we've also been notified all nine of us that in some times over this past year the Administration has indicated that they're overloaded and when the administration is overloaded it
032makes it very difficult for them to also do what they're supposed to be doing and they're overloaded with requests or or double initiatives that this board is putting upon them and I think that they all should be commended for doing without without complaint effectively the work that they typically do additionally all the work that this board has asked them to do and I think that that that means a lot but my comments were not with respect to a slight it was more along the lines of I wanted to see more educational elements not we're not the kids support it's always there I think that's a given um but education like figure asking the administration what can we do for the current kids what can we do to help reading what can we do to help
033math what can we do to help all of these kids that are getting intervent interventions for Education throughout the day how can we get a better educational product across to our community so full day kindergarten was the answer I I agree with you as far as what we did for special education I I think this board's done a lot for that too so that's an easy to um but there wasn't much else that was there and that's what I'd like to see in this coming year is more of a focus on education of kids now how and what this Administration can do how can we support them to provide a better product and to help more kids thank [Music] you and can I make one final comment before we have a roll call um I'm
034sorry that you feel we haven't done enough and I would think that if you came or you look again at the education committee meetings you will see with uh besides special ed and kindergarten there have been many uh programs that have been looked at um looking at our test scores and how how to improve those and Nicole Crawford has given us a lot of information on on what positive steps have been taken on a constant basis so I'm sorry that you don't see all of the great things that um our Administration has done working with our education committee and because I think we have done a tremendous amount all year and that we should all be very proud of all the work that's been done and move forward to continue with that and with that
035I would like to ask the secretary to roll call on the nomination actually there's one Nom only one nomination standing if you withdraw missaki all right so so that we should right so if that's the case um without any other nominations uh Ed Tate being the only candidate nominated for office of President yeah the chair hereby declares Ed Tate I I would uh would you like do we want feel that we should have an a roll call that's fine yes that's fine you know because much like a wrin vote there might be some members here who choose not to vote for Mr Tate or may choose to still vote for Missi even though she's withdrawn her name fair enough I think make sense a roll call yes okay then secretary can you uh take a
036roll call vote thank you uh Miss Herer no you have to vote allow am I allowed to abstain from V really can't vote to abstain I mean it's come down we we could do it I mean if Miz Uki has withdrawn we could vote I or nay on Mr Tate that would probably make the most sense uh I mean the only two people have been nominated Mr Tate and M oaki so that's the only two people you can vote for what right so I think unfortunately you'll have to vote well not unfortunately but you'll have to vote for either M oi or Mr Tate oi thank you Miss Stone um Ed Tate please miss Con Ed Tate miss oaki Mr Tate Miss ply Mr Tate Mr hickey Mr Tate Mr Roosevelt no for Mr Tate
037I'm sorry no Mr hialgo Mr Tate and Mr Tate and myself thank you okay that's seven for Mr Tate and two no for Mr Tate so the secretary reports the vote in favor of Ed Tate by a vote of seven- Two And by receiving the remote re the majority votes cast Ed tape is hereby elected president of the school board congratulations was [Applause] thank you everyone I'll uh thank everyone by name in a moment but let's just proceed with the business of the meeting then um next on the agenda is the election of the vice president nominations are now in order for the office of Vice President Mr Roosevelt I nominate Joe hiago Joe hiago Mr Warner I nominate Bob hickey Bob hickey Miss oi I nominate Yoda Pali Yoda Pali are there any other
038nominations we have Mr hickey Mr doggo and Miss py Madam Secretary could we have a roll call vote please uh Mr hickey once again I feel that we should be able to State our cases for each candidate that's fine thank you floor's open I thought you wanted to speak I do but I would give anybody else the opportunity first all right Mr Roosevelt sure I'll take that I I think that my comments are largely similar to my first that this is a an effort for a new board a new Direction um and more together and to that I look at at tenure at experience on the board so that's why I nominate Mr hiago I've also known that he's been interested in this position and um I would like to see him working with Mr
039Tate I thought his email to all of us announcing his interest was was well done um Miss horer thank you so this is my first year full through this to understand how this all works and how this goes and Miss paully I believe you were the one that said if we wanted something we had to reach out so the only people that have reached out to me has been Jo Hado and to Bob for leadership or anything that they're looking to do that's why I sent in of requesting what I was hoping for facilities and Mr Tate you did come and say to me you would I would co-chair with you and I said yeah I don't care who it is and I think that would be great I did not know that you were
040going to run for leadership so the communication is lacking we have to we owe it to this board we owe it to the community to have better transparency and better communication all around I'm reaching that's why I put it out there right away as soon as I thought about what would I like to do want to continue on I will co-chair to particip requested for facilities and I would like to stay on mbit but I had no idea who else wanted to be leadership because nobody else reached out to me nobody and nobody responded by the way to my email we can't work like this we can't we owe it to make it better for one of nine for us of nine to work together and I nominated Bob because I said to him well
041what do we do for leadership and I said do we nominate people I know that Joe had said it too so what do we do so that's why I'm nominating Bob because I know that he's got experience as well also to Joe and to have some balance we need better transparency and communication through all of us miss St U yes um my first comment is is regarding the nomination for Mr hialgo um I've been very disturbed by Mr hidalgo's behavior all year long uh he's been uncooperative he's been accusatory of the administration as well as the board members i f been I personally have taken offense a couple of times when you know calling out uh our disregard for the for the Sunshine Law I mean that's those are criminal accusations and and I really
042don't see how that kind of behavior is a quality in in leadership that's just not what leadership looks like um I've seen and worked in this whole group uh regarding committees we've had some very positive interactions so I don't know why an would say we're not communicating most members have gone to the committee me meetings and we've all had productive conversations about many different topics there's no necessarily majority or minority uh issues when it comes in to education and we've gotten through a lot of um disagreements but we have come to some major uh uh conclusions and some positive actions and I think part of that is um due to miss P's leadership and working with Administration and establishing uh very positive goals and establishing um a meeting AG board agenda items that are beneficial
043and necessary for the students the community so um there is no way I can support Mr hialgo who I see him saying no but you know you insult people at the board meetings and then the meeting is over and you try to give everyone hugs and say I hope you're not mad at me and I don't understand that behavior but it's certainly not behavior of a leader uh so I'm very much in support of um Miss Pie as vice president Mr hickey well then I'll take those comments as then that you can't support me as well um however if Mr hiago is disqualified for admonishing the board secretary Miss py should be at well should be as well uh you can look at the board meeting that we had the months ago where she demanded
044that that board secretary take a vote numerous times if we're going to say that we were combative or argumentative the same holds true for Miss ply as well if you want to have Mr hadalo accused the board Secretary of manipulating Mr hickey is the floor I'm sorry sorry that's right I'm just saying um like I said if you can't if you cannot Wrap Your Arms Around Mr hango and vote for him like I said I'm throwing my support much as I did for Ed you know hey look I I have issues with that I had a conversation with that on Sunday we we you know we aired out I gave him a lot of my concerns of things that I saw and Mr Tate said he would do things differently well if he would do
045things differently why what would he I I I I meant to ask him what he would do differently and press him on on the issue but if he would do things differently it means he wasn't satisfied as well but if all we're going to do is is flip-flop our roles of President and Vice President is that really moving forward we just you know it's it's all going to be much of the same and the same will probably be true when we when we go to our committee choices like I said you you may not like Mr hiago's style but you surely know where Mr Hado stands on the issues and and on a lot of the issues Mr Hado should be commended it was through his efforts that we saved the tax you know the
046elderly with the taxpayer dollars you know he's done a lot of other good things he Mr Hado also was a full proponent of full day kindergarten he reached across that aisle you may not agree with him all the time like I said we have our disagreements but part of this is is to try to move forward together as a community and as a board as one and like I said you know Ed you my cup of tea no necessarily you know not based off of your your actions over the past year but I've worked with you in the past and like I said I think it's a way to move forward I'm willing to extend my hand I'm willing to say okay you know what I I'll support you but just supporting the same ticket
047I don't think gets us forward and like I said we're going to find out real soon how everybody feels on Mo on moving this District forward if if if this is a 54 Vote or something along the same lines we've really made no progress all we did was just flip-flop rolls and if that's the case we just should have made Miss P the president and Ed as the vice president again like I said um I'm not looking to serve uh but I'm going to keep my name in there because everybody will have their name but like I said when it comes to my vote I'm going to support Mr hadalo M D um Mr hogo thank you so a couple times tonight and that's fine I'm I'm stuck between two people that uh do what
048I do which is good so you're going to accuse me of things that you feel I've done and that's that's the beautiful thing about free speech I appreciate that we can sit here and and disagree and yeah when you leave the boardroom I'm going to say I'm going to say what we did do here is is exactly how I feel it's at my heart but at the end of the day we're all human so I am going to say things like hey you know I like this person personally but I despise the politics okay so I'm going to keep giving it the way that I feel it needs to be given um I do take uh both of you accused me of going after the administration and I've been nothing but good to this Administration
049you may have misunderstood the way that I might question Mr rap or or or bring in I don't think I even hardly touch Mr Sano and put him on the spot or Mr you know Ronnie over there there I mean I've I've I've said things and asked people questions that's what I've been doing since I've been on the board and I was reelected for it and there is a lot that I've done in the past I'm not doing this because I want Power I'm doing this because every a lot of things you say that I accuse you of is truly how I perceive the situation the transparency is disgusting the way that you brought in that that law firm we have people that I can't mention names who are very highly regarded saying this is
050not the way you do it I highly advise you not to okay and so I know I'm not in the wrong when I'm saying these things and yes I do believe that you should have resigned when I asked you to resign I think you really should have resigned as president because the board meetings have been ran terribly and I'm not reading from a script or anything like that I'm just telling you the way it is it's been terrible and it's not even like you can be Vice president I don't care what happens is when the vice president and the president and the superintendent sit down and do their meetings the the other there's members of the board have no idea what's going on and the communication has not been how it's was when I was
051uh you know in the past with other boards and I've not been Pleasant to even other presidents and vice presidents I've not changed my TB when I see something not right I'm going to I'm going to say it this is a free and open uh area for us to express ourselves and you might as you said thank you you might not like my style but you're going to get it straight you know where I'm I'm coming from and so if like someone it's mentioned but it's not firsthand um if other boards presidents had locked out people that was never me I was always a communicator I'm always I always answer their phone when some body calls me um so I again this is just an opportunity to try to you know kind of not bury
052the hatchet but get an idea into all the concerns that Miss Yota says I'm totally like off Bas it is not off based what I'm perceiving here it is not good what happened last year and so I said oh me and Ed seniority let's try to move forward um I'm hoping this election switches things back and we are going to put things back to where they are so elections have consequences and that's going to be a major focus of mine in the next year thank you Mr Doo uh Miss Horner back to the communication we're in this position because of what happened in the actions that were taken in November December January last year and no none of you will sit here and take accountability of that and we have every right to ask and
053to question what has occurred and that's what we've done all year and the lack of communication and transparency to us was zilch there wasn't and there's no accountability and then you throw it back that has to change and that's what we're trying to do right now we're trying to reach it so that we're able to make that change and it's up to you guys to decide to do that you have to decide how to do that it's on you guys now publicly you didn't you went behind our backs we have to work together and we have to make students first and that's correct but we didn't have a chance in January Ary we we're ready to go forward we're asking you all let's just go forward Miss Stone I agree that we need to move
054forward then I don't know why this topic of the solicitor comes up every meeting every month you haven't ended it and Mr hialgo and this is not a way of moving forward even at our last board meeting Mr Roosevelt said let's move forward I I think that was a quote because we know we can't keep discussing this anymore and that's and I have I would not have any qualms about Mr hickey I have nothing negative to say you and I have worked talk together and I don't have any issues but I I just feel that um Miss P can continue and will continue to do a great job and most of the work that the board does is done at the Committees let's keep those committees moving that's where all the work is and I
055think we've done a great job thank you thank you Miss Stone Miss KH thank you Mr Tate um I guess it has definitely been a challenging year um in terms of working together um I'm not sure if as Miss uh ston had mentioned bringing up solicitors month after month at a board meeting over the last 11 months is productive for anybody and it definitely isn't about putting the students first and it surely is not about moving forward if we keep going backwards for the last 11 months however you know through all of that in the last 11 months we have managed under our current and previous board leadership to get all the accomplishments that Miss SOI um cited earlier as well as to many more um our education committee meetings have been three four hours
056long due to the number of you know items on the agenda and initiatives that we are trying to get moving in forward or to um to explore for the students in our district as well as as the community members um the questions have been asked and asked over and over again have been answered over and over again um they' they've even been right to knowed and answered and presented so I think the problem here is that they just didn't like the answer or I'm I'm not sure but again that's not about moving forward it's definitely not about putting students first um and in terms of what been going on at the meetings you know all of our committee meetings including the board meeting is is on the Council Rock YouTube channel um you can fast
057forward pause any of that throughout so if there's a question for those in the community that are listening or watching at home to some of the you know the accusations that are going back and forth in the board it's it's all there permanently for history um and I would support Miss ply I think she's done a great job it's been a difficult year for everybody but she is definitely um stepped up and continued to move forward and uh for Council Rock um in the right direction thank you thank you Miss Khan Miss oi okay um I I want to start off by um I I get along with Bob we we get along and I wanted to say thank you to miss horer for nominating him I think that's you know great I I um
058I would have no qualms about supporting him um but tonight I'm going to be supporting Yoda and I want to explain that a little bit uh I think we've had a lot as I mentioned you know previously and I guess some of my comments are are repetitive I apologize uh I've I've been really pleased with the amount that we've gotten done this last year and uh the momentum that we have I think it's been wonderful for the students of this district and that's what it's all about um so so my my support is um to continue that momentum I think in a lot of our meetings um there is talk about you know oh well we're rushing this or we're rushing that you know we're rushing full day kindergarten or whatever the to pretty much
059anything that that we talk about there's concerns about like are we rushing that and and it's a it's a valid thing to say but um at the same time you know we have to trust the administration about how much they can do uh even tonight um Mr Roosevelt said you know maybe we're putting too much on the administration they seem to be stretched thin um but I think that we support the administration I think very clearly um I think we show that in our all of us in our actions and in our words to them um I hope that they all know how supported they are and how appreciated they are as well as our teachers and principes and all the staff at Council Rock um in order to keep um the momentum going for
060the students of this District I'll be supporting Yoda I have been really impressed with Yoda's uh ability to lead through these meetings and maintain her composure through difficult situations I think I probably cannot even count how many times I've called yoda after a meeting and said wow wow you did a great job tonight thank you so um I've been impressed with her she has been able to work very closely with the administration and um she's really devoted herself to the students of this district and I'm you know thr to be working with her again thank you Miss anyone um Mr just real quick um yeah I mean it is a it's a crazy broken record but it's because when we I was stonewalled and it always was stonewalled when it comes to how we we
061did the fees and it's not just how we did the the solicitor but it's going to come to an end December 31st of 2024 it's the last whatever Bill comes after that I'm not going to vote no to treasury reports anymore but what I'm going to do is apply that first engagement letter that was not disclosed to the School District apply those rates to every billable hour and I'll have a concrete dollar amount that I could say hey guess what if I knew about it I would have made you stick to that that original rate card that you did not disclose that is exactly like the engagement letter you voted on later on that's some word I'm not a legal person I still I I think you're right if you have nothing to hide let's
062do the investigation answer the questions um and so I believe that all I'm saying is come December 31st my plan is Mr rap I'm going to ask you to do the calculations for me all right uh after that I hope I'm not admonishing you or doing something weird by asking you just putting it out there that and then from there I'm going to move forward when I said I was going to be vice president obviously you guys probably aren't appreciating the way that I behave towards you but I am not happy with the way you've treated this school district and I'll say it again you can say what you want this is my my take on everything I I've if I did this in my business I wouldn't have a license anymore that's just a
063God's honest truth that would not pass mustard with anybody and I think if it was the corporate world I think there would be repercussions but we have a solicitor that says what you're doing is legal and but they're not the judge you know and so it's a it's a crappy situation to be in and was everything going to be perfect with me are we wasting our time speaking about this maybe but the point was is at least in leadership I do have somewhat of a stake in the game to make sure that this board runs a little better than it is if I'm not in leadership I can't help you guys I can just continue to see things the way that I see them and and talk off the cuff that's it thank you thank
064you Mr doggo Mr Roosevelt thank you just to sort of continue the notion of working together better and if the if that comment is made in Earnest that we as the nine of us want to move forward together make some changes have some things that go different we clearly don't all see IE to eye on several things um but if we want to try to heal that to reciprocate the reach across the aisle by Mr hickey and by Mr hadalo I think by some extent as well miss Herer and myself Mr Tate I'll ask you again if you can't support Mr hadalo as I've heard from some of your colleagues at least I'm hoping to hear from you that you would support Mr hickey and if you do I I have support for you as
065well is there anyone else comment okay if there are no other comments we have three nominees our nominees for Vice President are an alphabetical order Mr hickey Mr oo and Miss ply so um we will proceed by roll call when your name is called please State the name of your choice for vice president uh Madame secretary would you call the role Mr Roosevelt Mr hiago Miss Stone Miss pie Mr hialgo Mr hialgo Miss P Miss P Mr Tate Miss P Miss oaki Miss p Mr hickey Mr hialgo Miss KH Miss p and Miss Herer Mr hickey that's uh five for Miss P three for Mr hialgo and one for Mr hickey thank you very much so receiving a majority of the votes uh Yoda p is the Vice President congratulations Miss [Applause] P it's tough
066getting used to reading glasses um next on the agenda okay in accordance with uh board policies 005 I hereby appoint the following members as chair of the following committees the education committee the chairs are going to be Nikki Khan and Yoda P thank you both for agreeing to the important job uh for facilities committee the co-chairs are going to be Miss Herer and myself thank you Miss horer for finance committee the chairs are going to be Linda Stone and Tracy oi thank you Miss Stone MOSI uh and policy committee the chairs are going to be MOSI and Miss Stone thank you right we're going to uh approve or I'm going to ask to approve the charters of our committees um that is item 4 C can someone make that motion please to approve the Schoolboard
067committee Charters I moveed to approve the Schoolboard committee Charters education facilities finance and policy committees second please second thank you Mr Warner are there is there any discussion are there any objections Mr Doo have we ever voted on this is this new it's on the agenda so no I'm asking in previous meetings I thought the president just appoints to people or is this something we have to we what is the charter Charter Charters is a little different right separate there's is there any documentation with this in in the board what what are we voting on what does that mean the board char ERS are in policy correct Mr well then why are we voting on something that's already in policy just trying to understand what we're I've been here before so I don't know what
068Joe he Ed just did it he rever unfortunately Ed reversed the order he should have approve the charters first and then appointed the chairpersons we approve the charters every year and then after that we appoint the chairpersons to that Charter at just flip-flop CN D obviously he's having problems with his reading glasses that's true you got it [Music] okay does anybody object to approving the committee Charters hearing no objection Madam Secretary would you record that as unanimously approved okay we'll go on then I'll try to remember to put on reading glasses appointment of the Bucks County Intermediate Unit representative I'm pleased that Tracy oi has agreed to continue in that role thank you is oi we have to appoint two mbit representatives and I appreciate that Bob hickey and Ann her have agreed to do
069that important job at mbit for another year so thank you both and for the Council Rock Education Foundation I will continue to serve as Lia on if there is no objection thank you uh two formalities um appointment of Pennsylvania School Board Association legislative chairperson representative uh and that typically that is two positions correct it reads is one so that would be one and I'll ask Miss py to take that job with pleasure thank you thank you and um appointment of a psba employee relations contact that's simply a contact a formality I'll do that if there's no objection okay we've gotten through the agenda down to board comment 5A is new business is there any new business from the board okay hearing none i' i' just like to make a few brief comments and I promise
070you they'll be brief first I want to thank in alphabetical order Mr Hodo Mr hickey Miss Khan Miss oi Miss ply and Miss Stone I appreciate your support and your votes I genuinely believe despite our obviously differences that everybody around this Das is truly committed to doing what's best for Council Rock and the students and our teachers and our administrators and staff we can have our differences but I think I think everybody's motives are are the right motives and I think that's terrific and I this is an honor and a challenge I me to get started and I feel well prepared to serve as president after nine years on the board I want to give a huge thank you to Yoda Pali you did a fine job you worked extremely hard I've worked with a
071lot of board presidents and uh no one has ever worked harder we've gotten a lot done so far full day kindergartener um development of facilities master plan is underway we're taking on the high school schedule just to name a few accomplishments I think we've been quite effective um I third thing I want to say is I've spoken with every board member going into this reorganization to get their thoughts and hear what they're interested in doing Miss ply did the same as well we tried to accommodate everyone's wishes and I think we did a fairly good job in that regard of course we couldn't do everything that everybody wanted but we tried to handle this fairly and and um you know share the assignments uh as to the necessity of co-chairs a couple of people have
072questioned that um I think the approach of having co-chairs proved its value over the past year a committee co-chair doesn't just run one meeting a month there's a very important agenda prep meeting earlier in the month there's reporting out and there's some strategic discussion so uh coach chairs is very valuable to have two people looking at the work of a committee instead of just one chair um there's a lot of work ahead such as the top to bottom policy review that we're doing and um the other aforementioned projects like the master plan so we see co-chairs as another way to engage as many board members as possible I'm hoping that in the coming year uh we continue the good pace of the progress we've been operating on and I hope that we can operate in
073a colle ual fashion it's it's a two-way street Communications requires all of us to decide to reach out to fellow board members and say hey I'd like to talk to you about this or that um and it takes time I mean to be honest I I um I sometimes tell people who are I'm trying to persuade to think about running for the board that that really it's the amount of time you want to put into it but it it it's a timec consuming job because it really does require all of us to be willing to pick up the phone send an email and say hey I'd like to talk to you about this issue and it's not up to leadership every time to to do that um board members can reach out to leadership and
074say I'd like to talk about something i' I have never turned down a request to talk to anybody and um I'll be as accessible as possible um and uh I I want to extend that to the public as well I just want to mention that if if you're not familiar with it there is an email that reaches all board members just board crsd.org and on the website you'll find our individual board email addresses uh personally when somebody wants to talk directly I'm happy to schedule a phone call or even a coffee um but really the best way if you have something you want to share with the board is to use board crsd.org because that goes to all the board members at once and as I I think two of our board members said tonight
075no one board member has any power um that's something we learn in our orientation we we as individuals have zero power it's the collective power of the board and that extends to the president so if you have something you'd like to share with the board send it to the entire board um and we'll also of course share it with the superintendent just to make sure uh so in conclusion um let's have a great year I'm looking forward to what we can do in the year ahead and I want to give you all the my best wishes for the holidays and a happy New Year so thank you um old business um so thanks Ed I want to Echo that I hope that you know as many of us have expressed I hope that this year
076can be more collegial I hope that there's um more willingness to speak to one another and in a in a respectful way and um you know as Mr hickey said really really you know what can we do in and I've done this actually with Mr hickey but maybe with others as well but I an example comes to mind with Mr hickey and policy he you know I'd like to get this policy you know so that we can all agree on it how can we adjust the wording so that we're comfortable I think that's that's valuable and I'm happy to do that um I've done it in the past and I hope that we can all do that more this year um I did want to address the um the honor and privilege I've had to
077uh chair the finance committee with Mrs Stone and the policy committee with Mr Tate over the last year and I was also grateful to be the uh representative for the buck County Intermediate Unit I've learned a lot I've enjoyed all of these appointments and I've done my best to put students first in every meeting that I have attended chairing a committee offers a unique ability to work with the administration we have the pre- commmittee meetings as Ed mentioned where you have the opportunity to uh discuss our ideas bring ideas forward that other board members have shared with you and to hear the goals of the cabinet member who serves as the committee liaison during these pre-meetings I've gotten to ask questions and to learn from both Mr rap and Mr spring even though I have
078greatly enjoyed this opportunity I recognized the value of being a committee co-chair and I wanted to offer some of my colleagues that same opportunity so I had discussed with Mrs P being willing to give up my position on the finance committee um my seat was offered to Mr hickey but he declined um and it's my understanding he said he didn't um see it okay um I was also will to offer my seat at the IU um and that seat it's my understanding was re um deined by Mr Roosevelt and Mr hialgo so I'm happy to stay on the IU this year uh ultimately I'm thrilled to continue to serve the district in these areas and I'm glad that Miss Herer will be co-chairing the facilities committee I think that those committee meetings are valuable and
079I think that you know this is one step where we can work together so I'm I'm glad to be see to see that thank you thank you Miss oiki anyone else Mr roselt yeah I I didn't understand that I was being offered IU I had one conversation with Mr Tate where he asked if I would co-chair with miss her on facilities with respect to my architectural degree license and background um I didn't understand or it wasn't offered that IU was coming to me um then I had a subsequent email with uh with Miss P where she asked for the same reasoning if I would co-chair facilities with Miss Conan um in both I responded the same way which is how I responded last year I don't really think a lot of these committees or maybe
080most of them should have a co-chair um but this is last year and this year's leadership Direction so that's what apparently we're following um I think that all nine of us could step in and co-chair if the chair was absent I think that the president Andor the vice president is typically the one that does that but doesn't always happen doesn't have to happen that way and I think all nine of us as I indicated last year are supportive of the chair and the co-chair bringing value questions bringing our insight to that to that committee so um I do understand that in rare circumstances a co-chair could be a valuable thing and perhaps last year is a good example of many new board members coming in taking on lots of responsibilities doubling up might be a
081good idea so I can I can understand that and maybe it makes sense to continue it this year but for me I think a lot of this could be handled by one of us after all the bulk of the work that gets done here um is the majority of it is from Administration I think Administration deserves a hand and a and a big thank you to all of the things that have been indicated today on what this board with the administration have accomplished um so that was my comment regarding co-chair thank you thank you Mr Roosevelt anyone else um all right all right uh yeah we're going to adjourn this meeting and then open up the special meeting in just a moment so meeting adjourned thank you e