001for e e e good evening I'd like to call the January 28th 25 mathon School District Board of Directors meeting to order please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance please join war sester student willcott in leading the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible for liberty and justice for all now let's hear from Abel Toth War sester student on how much we love war sester Elementary School Abel hello my name is Abel to and I attend War sester Elementary School I love war sester Elementary because the teachers are very kind and understanding another reason is the kids because they are also really nice and friendly the teachers teach us so much that we need to know
002about our subjects and get us excited about learning new things I love all the specials and clubs that help us learning what our interests are outside of school and because everyone follows our three main rules be respectful be responsible and be safe that is because we are War sest leading the pack will you two join uh our school board president I out front for the issuance of the Junior School Board of director certificates e okay the public is here by advised of the audio and video recording of this meeting for the purposes of rebroadcasting for attendance all board members are present with the exception of Miss Purdue next is guest and scheduled speakers Dr Zerby thank you madam president this evening we have a number of guests in scheduled speakers but I'm pleased uh to
003introduce War sester principal Miss amichi to issue the spirit of methacton awards Miss amichi thank you good evening and thank you for having more sister here tonight well and Abel you did an amazing job and able thank you for telling everyone about why war sester is such a special place I'm excited to tell you about our award recipients tonight starting with Miss [Applause] [Music] Park Miss Park is an energetic third grade teacher who is always looking for new and fun ways to engage her lucky students she does an excellent job differentiating INR ction to meet the needs of all Learners and students feel included and welcome in her classroom na has a positive attitude and consistently goes above and beyond for her students and co-workers she has showed leadership within our school Community by volunteering
004for various committees over the years and is currently serving as a pilot teacher for our science resource now makes every one of her fortunate students feel valued and we are so fortunate to have her as a teacher at War sester [Applause] next we'd like to recognize nurse jod [Applause] latanzi Jody is truly the most amazing school nurse I think you could ever have she is always willing oh go she's she is always willing to help and goes the extra mile for for the students at War sester Jody has a positive attitude and approaches all situations with a sense of calm and Clarity she is a collaborative team member and works to ensure the um that the physical and emotional needs of our students are met Jody also has a great sense of humor and consistently
005makes fellow staff members smile worcestor students adore her and she makes each of them feel special we appreciate Jody's dedication and all that she has done for the families staff and students at War sister [Applause] and next we have two very special volunteers that we'd like to recognize uh Nikki Scott and Ann [Applause] Campbell both Nikki and an are remarkable volunteers at War sester both an and Nikki can often be found in the library helping to check books in and out and have become experts at shelving books both Nikki and Anne hold leadership positions on our home and school board volunteer for many school events and organize fun activities for all of War sister to enjoy for several years Ann has created uh remarkable teacher appreciation celebrations and organized our winter Workshop a much-loved fundraiser
006during the holiday season and Nikki leads our school movie Nights started our we love war sister Spirit day and never runs out of ideas to to promote Spirit within our school not to mention she's always ready to design a t-shirt we sister is lucky to have parent volunteers but we are even luckier to have uh Nikki and an as volunteers thank you for your creative ideas your time and your commitment to war sester and now we'd like to recognize Myra poar [Applause] Myra is a fourth grade student at War sester and exemplifies our school and District core values at school Myra is on our student council and serves as a member of our safety patrol she also participates in classical dance and performed in our talent show last year for the past three years Myra
007has helped our school Community by organizing and running a food drive during Dali the food collected was then donated to the methacton backpack Pro program providing meals and snacks for fellow students in our community as you can tell Myra is a very special young lady we are so happy that Myra is a war sister [Applause] wolf it's an absolute PR privilege to work and learn with all of these individuals and thank you all for your commitment [Applause] okay next next up we have Kathleen Everett who's the secretary the director of curriculum instruction and [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] assessment Kathleen is the epitome of professionalism and dedication to supporting the Thon Kathleen is very organized and is always willing to lend a hand whenever needed Kathleen started her career with the District in September of 2017
008serving as the secretary of the director of curriculum instruction and assessment Kathleen organizes student teachers updates the many curricular documents support supports student registration and works with Federal programs to name just a few of our contributions Kathleen helps to promote and build a positive Community for the staff at finina with various celebrations and festivities thank you Kathleen for all that you do to support the students teachers staff administrators and families here at mathon [Applause] I don't believe that Michelle is here okay we're first gonna honor Michelle tanova she is a Food Service employee at Arrowhead Elementary School Michelle has been working at Arrowhead Elementary School since September 28th 2011 13 years in counting she's an exceptional employee who collaborates effectively with both students and staff at the beginning of each year when students are learning
009their ID numbers Michelle takes the time to help them find strategies to memorize the pin which they use throughout the year to purchase lunch Michelle is easygoing and consistently goes the extra mile for everyone she readily fulfills any requests made of her thank you Michelle for all you [Applause] do next up we have Diane gambone [Applause] Diane a methacton Alum has been an asset to the district's transportation system since she came on board in 2014 known for her conscientiousness dependability and commitment to her community she is a favorite among staff and students when Diane suffered an injury earlier this year she was determined to work return to work quickly when she did she was greeted by a display of heartfelt cards from students lining the walls of her bus a testament to her great impact
010on her students Diane consistently goes above and beyond on her Roots calling in accidents stranded pedestrians or loose animals that she sees so they can get the proper help we are lucky to have Diane in the math Acton Community thank you for all you [Applause] do good good evening last but certainly not least is Robert Jack [Applause] peoples Jack has quickly become an invaluable member of the methacton high school custodial team in his nearly three years of service known for his reliability and dedication Jack consistently goes above and beyond his regular duties he is often called upon to serve as a head custodian other schools to cover absences and volunteers to be on call for after hour issues including during holidays and weekends Jack's willingness to step in wherever needed along with his strong teamwork
011ethic makes him a go-to person that his colleagues and supervisors can always count on his contributions reflect not only his commitment to his work but also his dedication to the success and smooth operation of the school Community thank you [Applause] picture [Music] ch [Music] [Applause] congratulations than you [Music] con [Applause] congratulations I'll send you some photos thank you so [Music] okay [Laughter] so while we're admiring the photo behind us I'd like to take this opportunity uh because uh the January is uh Schoolboard director appreciation month and I'd like to take this opportunity to reflect on the impact that our methacton School District Board of Directors has on our students staff and Community as a as a director you play a crucial role in shaping the lives of young people across Lower Providence and Wester townships
012it takes a village to create a high quality education system where all students can succeed and you are a key part of that team you are not only members of this community your neighbors co-workers parents but also public servants devoting countless hours to our time uh to the board of board business for voting meetings uh to policy discussions and comprehensive planning those efforts are a large part of what make metha a great place to learn work and Thrive thank you for your commitment to our school Community we really appreciate it and as a token of our appreciation you have at your seats some handmade gifts created by some of the very students you diligently serve these were made by members of the national Arts Honor Society at mton high school each gift is unique and
013made with love and care reflecting the level of commitment you demonstrate in your service to our district additionally we will be emailing you a video that a group from the high school created you'll recognize some familiar faces some very familiar faces who wanted to take a moment to let you know how much your work means to them on behalf of the entire meaan Community thank you for your dedication to our students and staff and the next on the the agenda for guests and scheduled speakers is the mton high school project update we have Devin Bradberry uh from uh the Shader group here with us and Josh Grace from cha members of the of the board of school directors there is a uh uh a print out of the presentation uh at your seat thank you
014thank you Dr Zerby and good evening everybody um Devon and I are here tonight to give a brief update on the schematic design phase of the high school planning project um to start out I'm just going to do a quick recap of some of the discussions and initial steps that we've had so far so as you remember uh following the concept phase where some of those initial ideas of how to kind of recreate reshape the campus and the high school were presented uh we have moved into what we call the schematic design phase so that phase started in October and it's going to take us through March and as planned with the uh board involvement and the board process each phase moving forward will go through formal board approval for us to proceed on to
015the next phase So currently the schematic design phase um which you'll be getting a final update in March uh there will be a decision at that point to uh proceed into what we call Design development and that simply uh is a phase which provides much more detail to these schematic plans um also as part of that design development time frame would be an act 34 hearing that is a public hearing where the plans the budgets and the building program are all discussed in a public forum after which point um assuming that the board again decides to move forward with the project we would move into construction documents which really is when Devin's team puts together the the final details and the final bid packages for bidding so that is is going to extend all the
016way through um January of 2026 so then there's a public bidding phase of about two months where those plans are reviewed they're evaluated and the district receives and evaluates bids any alternate bids that may be entertained at that point and we're looking for uh the approval of those bids in March of 2026 so quite a long time frame yet just for the design phase and the approval process before we can even get bids for the project for the construction phase itself we're looking at starting um uh spring summer of 2026 so really taking advantage of that initial summer time frame to start earthw work uh perhaps footings for the building and to really start to kind of recreate the shape of the terrain out there as needed so about a two and a half year
017time frame overall for construction looking to move students into to the new building over the winter break of about December 2028 obviously following that would be the demolition of the existing school and site restoration taking us into the summer time frame of 2029 so again it seems like a a long time away from this point it is over a year of design several year years of construction and obviously we can't get there um without continued updates and continued endorsement and approval from the board so thank you everybody for your time and uh consideration here with getting these updates so with the schematic design process uh we have had some key submissions uh related to local agency planning and approvals uh we did have a meeting with wor cester Township officials um was more of an
018informal sort of kickoff meeting back on November 11th just to present some initial ideas and understand where some of the challenges may come from as far as the approval process and official sketch plan submission was made on January 7th so that is a sketch plan that is now in the hands of the township for them to start providing some technical feedback for our team to understand again where some of the challenges related to zoning Land Development may be on site here uh there are ongoing testing infiltration testing which is for storm water design geotechnical testing understanding where um rock may be and and certain subsurface conditions on the site obviously that helps with constructibility and also budgeting for for site work one of the longest uh duration approvals is going to be the Conservation District
019um as you may remember from other projects on campus uh perhaps the turf project that process itself could be a 12 month time frame for approvals so that is again those those initial in infiltration testing and other geotechnical testing really is key to getting that submission made there's also a traffic impact study which will be starting in February obviously site circulation not only internally but on surrounding neighborhood roads is going to be a big Focus that traffic impact study is going to help us um answer a lot of questions related to best uh circulation through and around the site we also held a meeting with the adjacent Property ownes Owners on January 13th to hear some initial feedback concerns comments um that maybe can be incorporated assuming that we move into a design and construction
020time frame of how best to accommodate again some of the traffic some of the difficulty with circulation and some of the immediate neighbor um concerns as we look towards a construction time frame so again with wor Wester Township we do have several zoning considerations that we're keeping an eye on uh I won't read read through all of them I think we've touched on them briefly in the the past um Building height is going to be a key component we are still considering maybe an option of a three-story building which would help us to shrink the footprint of the building um there are several other items that will be uh discussed with the township and required for approval so um again this Land Development process will take the better part of 12 months certainly to do
021um challenges such as these are exactly why it it needs to take that long um everything related to zoning Planning Commission approval those are all public meetings with worest Township so again um additional opportunity for input and feedback uh at the township level uh we just also wanted to include the latest programming update and basically the programming is what is established for how the curriculum and programs within the building are to be delivered um certain quantity of spaces square footage of spaces and overall with the program including a district office space of approximately 12,000 Square fet uh the total gross square footage is 333,000 square feet for the building so that's consistent with where our earlier conceptual design numbers were if there are any opportunities um for for savings with that square footage uh we're
022continually looking at opportunities with how the the curriculum programs are delivered if we can reduce that square footage obviously that will decrease the building cost so that will be a continued focus of of our team and the District administration to see how efficient can we make this building footprint um to get that number as low as possible so um again the program and the plan site work generally are consistent with what the conceptual update um had been previously um our cost estimates therefore are pretty much the same at this point ranging from 206 million to $219 million all-in project when I say Allin that includes soft costs um again as our land development continues there may be adjustments needed for site uh related items if we can reduce that building footprint or building square footage
023obviously that will uh be an impact and as we get towards bidding assuming that we keep going that far we can certainly identify bid alternates which are going to help us um keep within the approved budgeted range uh that that the board establishes so um again that is a conceptual to schematic design phase update once we have your final update in the schematic design phase I do anticipate some adjustment perhaps to these numbers but for now um reviewing the program reviewing the Plan Building size were uh consistent with where we had been previously so moving forward I know the district has been um very proactive with making sure that all stakeholders are heard there will certainly be many other opportunities for input as we go through the process both at the Schoolboard level at the
024township level local agency level um I mentioned that Conservation District approval process um end user meetings will also be scheduled as we move through the process and that's basically sitting down with department heads or certain key instructors to really make sure that um what is planned for those spaces really fits the needs not just today but in the future for the students um as well as future student and Community input sessions I'm sure that they will be uh planned scheduled as we move forward okay with that I'll turn it over to Devin he can take you through some of the latest um updates to the plan great thank you Mr Grace thank you everyone and congrats on your lovely gifts that you received uh tonight those look pretty awesome um so that's a recap uh
025we'll just kind of show some of the updated site plans you've seen some of these slides before so this is again just to reset where we were before uh we have all of these existing constraints on the site shown and some potential access points uh as you can see we currently have four access points on creal Mill and we were again looking at the one across uh creal mill on millroad so uh again you've seen this slide before there's one compact area of development that we can utilize uh keeping in mind that all of those other areas are kind of Out Of Reach at this point so let's get into the update on the site plan um you can see the area in green is the new building proposed building um it's a a very
026faint line uh but there is a dashed line where the um existing building is and you can see we are clear of that at the moment um just focusing on the building we are pursuing a three-story academic wing for this building um so we've uh pushed the uh twostory option aside at this point and the three story really allows us to make that more compact on the site clears us from the existing building as much as possible and allows for more to happen on site so we were able to get all the uh playing fields that we originally were targeting back on the site by by making the building a little bit tighter allowing to uh have as much parking on site as possible to alleviate a lot of the concerns that we've heard from
027the township uh regarding parking traffic uh speeding those types of things um we still have the courtyard space so you can see the the space in the center of that green box that is the courtyard the space uh directly to the north on this plan is the three-story piece and you can kind of see that little separated um uh area I don't know if there's a pointer on this is there oh there we go all right so this this three-story area is is located here at the back of the site that's a three-story academic Wing everything uh to the right side of what what's here would be the main entrance is all of your public um uh spaces over here so the the administration The District administration building um all of the gym and athletic
028functions are over on the right the pool is the space that's very far on the right towards the uh Stadium and then the uh Auditorium is just to the left of that common space so all of your public functions are over on one side of the building all of your academic educational spaces are over on the other side of the building um as far as the site goes uh I mentioned the three um access points on the site so we have very separate access points and this is intentional um so we don't want buses we don't want students and we don't want parents all converging at the same point so right now our uh parent drop off is proposed at this first entrance and it would come in and have a really long q line
029to get it off of Creo Mill so all of the traffic comes now into the site and there's no more log jams along Creo Mill and hopefully not along German Town as well so they would loop around and drop off at the main entrance right here uh and then the the student uh entrance is down further on creal Mill they would come in have their own entry point and never intersect either the buses or the parents so they come in and park in the student parking this is yet to be determined what's student versus what's staff versus what's visitor but generally the student parking can be over on this side of the plan and then the bus is again completely separate so they're coming in off of Mill Road at this point and they would
030travel all the way around drop off at what would be an athletic entrance so there'd be a nice common uh entrance through here and drop off at the bus uh and entrance Point here and then loop back around so again three very separate spaces uh for a better flow of traffic on site and everything is on site again um just to note we do have uh existing varsity baseball we're proposing a new uh Varsity Softball uh both of those we are intending to put lights on those fields so that we can get better use of those fields uh throughout the year we also have multip purpose fields to replace your existing multi-purpose Fields so one is kind of over in the space that we're in right now up on this field uh there's another that
031is basically what you have now uh intersecting the JV baseball uh field down on that side of the site and then the softball field is down over here because we place the building where that goes so this is down in the opposite corner along creal and Mill um couple of other items we are showing the uh Fieldhouse still that is adjacent to the existing stadium and then all of the field events uh you know we're kind of us using some of the space where your Javelin your discus shotput those items all move up to uh kind of this Athletics complex up here um and get replaced in that area uh we are maintaining we we talked about this a few times a nice Boulevard through from the main entrance that connects down to the Athletics
032area um we have a a full loop around the building for um emergency vehicles to to access there's probably gates at either end of these uh to allow only for uh emergency access uh to utilize that that back entrance um I think the the other change that we made since the last time you've seen the site plan we are proposing to maintain the existing tennis courts so those will get resurfaced save a little bit of money keep them in the same location and resurface them rather than relocate them over where we had shown them previously um so that's kind of a quick overview I will take some questions uh after this but um this is is generally the direction that we're we're going in uh as Mr Grace mentioned we have submitted uh a plan
033to war sister Township we're hoping to receive feedback from them and then be in front of the Planning Commission at the end of February so we'll have further discussions with the township on uh what their thoughts are for what you're seeing tonight so beyond the site plan and the building uh updates we have continually discussed some of these project and scope adjustments uh things like the instructional planning centers where the district admin office will be uh shared science labs and then the pool had some uh some different alternate alternates that we had discussed before so this might be an opportunity to have some some further um discussions but uh just wanted to update the team on where we are currently with our our building plans the instructional planning centers are not included in the project
034so all of the teachers currently will have their own classroom in this uh current proposal uh there may be other spaces where teachers can collaborate inside the building but it's not taking the place of classrooms uh that would originally be cut out of the of the program uh The District administration office is back in the project so I think we had always shown that in there there was discussion of uh you know the district purchasing another building and fitting that space out it is in the project right now and it's actually on the second floor or combined second floor of of the building Administration that is an additional swing space in case enrollment increases you could easily convert that space into classrooms in the future if you need additional capacity so that's one of the
035main reasons to keep that in the program at this point uh shared science Labs excuse me is very much still uh under discussion um we are currently looking to uh some of our colleagues across the country to figure out what's happening as far as science Innovation goes uh so we're trying to uh really uh integrate some of those uh Innovative uh Concepts and equipment and Technologies into the program and then we will continue to have this discussion about whether or not there's shared Labs uh and individual class rooms or if they all have their own science spaces in the building so that's still an evolving conversation it doesn't need to be decided at this moment um so we're going to continue to evaluate that as we get more information the pool uh seems like a
036very easy thing to pull out of the project so the pool currently is a standard 25 meter pool eight Lanes so that is competition um size and then we will provide an ad alternate so that would carry through bid day so you can actually see what the cost would be and that would be to uh provide a bulkhead and increase the size of the pool so you would go from a standard 25 meter to I think a 35 meter pool and you'd have a bulkhead and that would just increase the length of the pool and that allows for a lot of flexibility with pool programs but you'll you'll be able to decide that on bid day so we can carry that through the project you don't have to make that decision today so those are
037the four topics that we've kind of gone back and forth over the the past several months um I will I guess turn it over to Dr Zerby and see if there's any questions on any of those thank you Devon and thank you Josh are there any questions from members of the board Pusa I just have a couple of questions um what what are teaching stations teaching stations yeah it was on um oh that's back on the the building program yeah so those are let me just I want to make sure I'm getting that right so those are the actual um spaces that get capacity so in a a more utilitarian word it's just a classroom that has capacity in it so those are your standard classrooms or some of your um like FCS classrooms might
038have what would typically be a Home Room back when I was in school um so those are the numbers of classrooms that account for the capacity of that makes any sense yeah yeah okay and then what would the student capacity be if you included That Swing space so the swing space for the district admin space uh I guess yeah so if we were to convert the district admin space back to classrooms right you would add eight classrooms which would be about 200 students okay thank you that's it thanks any other questions to my left Miss kro I attended the the meeting with the the neighbors and their biggest concern I think what they were voicing and I thought the civil engineer was really great with answering it but just wanted to just have the board
039be aware was water retention and with the design you know the neighbors were really saying that the water was really infiltrating their whole area there's icy roads it was going into their property erosion was happening around there you know and and to be honest with you something that I was not aware of with we had already done and the if you could just explain we currently have when it comes to water retention and that what this position could do and what we could hold and what it could do for our neighbors as far as that area of concerned sure that's an excellent point and this was one of the major topics with the neighbors uh when we spoke with them um so when you first built this building there were no storm water measures in
040place because there were no codes around it so you really had nothing on the site that required any uh storm water capture or anything like that when you did the turf field up here uh you were required to put in a retention Basin that is essentially right up in this area so that accounted for storm waterer management for just the Disturbed area uh that required for the uh the turf field now we're required with this project to account for the storm water for the entire site so what you had just for here we're now increasing that to include the entire site and the restrictions are now a lot more uh conservative uh with the uh Conservation District at the moment so not only are we trying to maintain some of this uh above ground Basin
041that we have currently in place but we're adding underground storm water basins under some of the parking areas here here under this entire multi-purpose field so you see the size of that and then under some other parking areas up in this area so it it's going to significantly improve the conditions that are currently happening on site just by the sheer volume of site disturbance and now we're having to account for that as far as the calculations go thank you and I think the only last thing to share with them too is that it was all about um traffic flow and the concern of traffic but then also the parking and I thought it was interesting with this that what they explained from the engineers that where the buses come there really are like 27 buses
042that come in through the back neighborhood and that really the access of parents and and the staff and the teacher teers and students are going to come out through Germantown and other areas so it's not a flood of the back roads that we currently see in cral Mill is that correct and yeah that's I can't speak for the civil engineering we're still um getting the traffic study uh completed so you'll have a lot more information once we do have that the results of the traffic study and the township will weigh in on all that but I believe the the point is that now a lot of the traffic is going to be actually on site rather than kind of Meandering around just that font front parking lot everything we currently have now is very front
043heavy and there's not a lot of Q space for drop off and things like that and again the buses you mentioned they're all coming in from uh basically one point at this point uh now we're spreading them out throughout the site and it should alleviate a lot of the traffic thank you any other questions from my left seeing none to my right Miss clar um let's stick with parking for a second hi um the student parking so how many spases is the current the design that you are you're working on so uh great question I asked that of our civil engineer and uh he's still going through the calculations to make sure we have enough there um I want to say it's somewhere in the 500 range but I I I don't want to State
044something that's incorrect so let me get back to you I appreciate that so how many do you know how many spots or does the administration know how many spots we currently have today we have all of those numbers but I don't know them off the top of my head yeah if you don't know it either that's I don't know it off the top of my head but we provided all of that but what I can tell you the intent was to provide student parking for all of the seniors and half of the junior class that was that was in the yeah that was the intent and half the Juniors so so let's say approximately 400 students in a senior class about the same in in a junior class so maybe 600 spots plus the teachers
045and visitors all in that one spot correct okay um great and then can I ask you a question about the square footage it's on slide um it's probably from Josh's presentation but um the the numbers the 222,000 square foot versus the 333 foot I missed what the 222,000 representing so the 222 is what's called a net square footage so that is all the programs that are required for educational purposes okay so if we say that we need classrooms at 800 square ft those are all included in those spaces the grossing there's a grossing factor of 1.5 you can see that up in this this box up here um so if you take all the net square footage multiply times 1.5 that's the grossing uh the gross square footage that accounts for all your mechanical spaces
046all your corridors all your uh toilet rooms and other the uh support spaces throughout the building okay okay and then you said that the a two-story building was off the table so and you were looking at a three-story building so is this square footage then representative of that that plan that you showed ofre and I don't I I don't know if this is a nonsensical question um but if that's not approved and the building we were looking at was a two-story building does the square footage then go up the square footage stays the same it's the footprint on the site because we'd have to take that space and then put it down on the lower level so okay the only the benefit here is you're reducing the footprint and maybe opening up some space around
047the site for things like athletic fields and parking great uh you also may see see some Savings in in in cost uh just because there's less uh footprint less roof less materials by going up by going up that makes sense okay thank you so much you're welcome any other questions uh for Miss graph yeah so um thanks so much this is a really nice update sure um a couple simple ones first do we know the public meeting dates for the zoning meetings in war sester and the planning committee meetings do we have those dates we do have those February but that's Planning Commission that's not zoning so the Planning Commission I believe is the 27th correct February Z zoning would be April okay I just think it'll be nice for us to include those in
048the board uh meeting minutes and then um my other question is if you want to flip over to the uh layout where you have the fields identified sure um so I see that we originally had four Fields two baseball two softball now I see we have an existing baseball and then two softball fields and then I sort of see an existing JB BAS baseball field back there along that back entrance is there actually going to be a field there that overlaps with that multi-purpose field that is so the intent is to provide uh one Varsity one one varsity baseball one Varsity softball and then a JV baseball and a JV softball and that does have that multi-purpose area as well as corre and that and currently we only have one multi-purpose area that we're actually
049getting two out of this right yeah and and one is you also have the practice field that's currently there right the track and field area yeah it's more intended it won't be lined you can line it if you want but it's meant to be more of a practice space in that JV baseball great um and so the where the JV softball field is in the front um that's essentially where the track and field the field events for track and field are so they're going to move to this multi-purpose field along M so if you see the I don't know if you can see this here but there are field events oh I see it scattered in here see the big javelin throw there because there won't be any building there correct got it okay that
050makes sense so then the mer there's two multi-purpose fields that are really true multi-purpose Fields replacing what we currently have as one I don't want to commit to that because the the one that's overlapping the baseball field it would be lined as a you know you you would have to do the lining yourself so it would just be open space but you could use it for a but you could see it's big enough for multi-purpose okay that's super helpful um it's a really nice layout to get them all back in there so I appreciate the effort to do that I know it was definitely a a struggle civil engineers are magicians um and then my other question was and this may be a question for Josh if we I see in here we have a
0513% escalation on our soft cost so that 3% annual escalation assumes how many years I believe at the time of that conceptual was two and a half years to the midpoint of construction that's typically how we evaluate the inflation Factor okay you know after that point once materials have pretty much been all sourced and delivered that kind of tapers off at that point so I believe in those calculations it was two and a half years from that point which would have been the midpoint of construction okay so crazy question but if we said in March we're going to stop proceeding with this project we're going to take the where we are and we're going to hold on the design development phase for one year would we assume a 3% incre escalation in cost we would
052yes okay thank you any other questions for members to my right seeing none that ends our presentations this evening Josh and Devon thank you so much for your time thank you very much we'll now move to reports the committee reports are attached from the MCI mciu this month Miss Purdue is not present so she will not be reporting on it here but you could see the attachment for your review the north MCO Tech Miss oltin and Mr mki all right thank you um I guess there's two but two meetings since our last update um in December on Monday December 16th the boards from all the sending districts um of North monot Tech were invited to attend a wonderful holiday dinner with a pig roast theme at the meeting held after dinner The Joint operating committee
053reorganized and alres of North Penn was elected as chairperson and I was honored to be reelected as Vice chair our January meeting was held on Wednesday January 22nd virtually we discussed engaging the Montgomery County Planning Commission to conduct a study of enrollment projections and trends for the school and we also heard about ongoing skills USA competitions um heard that we were recently awarded an $85,000 grant for the purchase of equipment for students in our Public Safety computer integrated Machining and construction carpentry programs and I would also like to let you know that there is an openhouse scheduled um January 30th um from 5: to 7:00 p.m. at North monotech for anyone whose students might be interested in attending the school thank you thank you very much um next will be our high school board Representatives
054Soul Martin and Marin Wells good evening everyone to start off minithon rais money for kids with cancer by selling T-shirts during lunches for the blue out basketball game that was held on January 25th the cheerleading team qualified for the PIAA competitive Spirit state championship which will take place January January 30th and 31st and they also took first pay first place in the pack Championship fccla's annual Mr MAA signups were out and they were due on January 17th this event is going to be held on May 16th the freshman sophomore and Junior classes were gathered in the auditorium for a presentation by an unusual keynote speaker the main idea that the speaker focused on was saying yes before you say no the key point of the presentation was to encourage students to be open-minded and to
055try new things he also reiterated respect and that is shown by being on time to school and following our cell phone policy he made the kids remember these ideas in an unusual way he performed juggling tricks and balanced a chair on his face methacton unified Bachi has had meets throughout January and did amazing unified alumni and best buddies came to support the team for their meet against North pen the methacton environmental Club hosted a thrift store in the library with a huge turnout they were planning to use the money raised to help adopt a zoo animal and save the rest to fun Earth Day the high school had midterms from January 21st 1 to the 24th and the second marking period ended on January 27th in a recent this week with Dr uker she shared
056a reminder to students and staff that our three words that we live by at MHS is safe respectful and responsible these are the behaviors we need to model within our community and that we all need to be the change we want to see in the world the National Art Honor Society hosted the marry Market in the cafeteria many different Club sold items and donated their money to their Desir charity the turnout was great with so many items being sold like artwork ceramic bowls pins bakes baked goods and so much more happy New Year everyone that was a nice long break that us students really enjoyed um both minithon and the senior class each had a separate contest to make either a senior class shirt or a minithon blackout shirt with a free senior banquet ticket
057for the W winner of the senior shirt and then we also had a chance to participate in picking our seniors and their superlatives for our upcoming senior banquet which was really fun and an exciting experience um the boys and girls swim team are on a winning rooll right now which is great for them this year they had an amazing win against pot grve during their senior night um the tryouts for Esports happen a week after midterms and Victoria James who is a 10th grader will be going to States for winter track which is exciting um the defense team for mock trials competed on Wednesday the 22nd and the prosecution will be competing on the fourth and lastly uh the 2025 class Congress is having a d and donate at the honey grow at the Providence
058town center this Friday the 31st uh feel free to use code give 137 to help them raise money for their Club thank you very much um that I'm going yes I'm GNA be dismissing and I wanted to say that Marin Wells you participated in the cheerleading competition this past so congratulations I'm one in the pack thank you nice all right all right please enjoy your evening and we'll see you next time thank you very much all right we'll move down to the foundation update which will be provided by next month from communication from Communications excuse me Mrs throback so the work on our new District website and school websites is well underway we're working with final site to redevelop the sites in a way that's going to make them more visually appealing and improve the
059user experience I want to thank all of the members of the website advisory committee who have helped with finalizing the homepage layout and design my team and some members of the technology department have started training with final site on the new content management system system and we're planning to launch these new sites in May with the new sites you can expect to see more photos easier navigation based on the most frequently visited Pages ADA Compliant features and a cleaner look we're excited about this new site and the school sites to improve marketing and communication with both current and prospective families we have created a yearly editorial calendar that lists holidays and days and months of recognition this is to share out on our social media and in District and school newsletters through this we aim
060to Foster inclusivity and create a sense of belonging in the school Community by celebrating cultures and heritages acknowledging important moments in history and sharing resources about important topics that impact students and staff some of those days include World Down syndrome day bus driver Appreciation Day Mental Health Awareness Month Memorial Day juneth that's just a very few of them you should have a copy of that calendar in front of you and you can see that there are many more dates listed there we're hoping this calendar will help Ensure consistent messaging and timely announcements across all of our platforms and I thank you to everyone who helped provide input on that calendar and I have an update on our community education programs for winter spring 2025 we currently have more than 360 registrations across 47 class offerings
061new this season are mindfulness meditation modern Western square dance and snip snapology there's some new sessions beginning throughout the spring so if anyone is interested in registering for student or adult classes please visit our website for that information we are also in the midst of accepting proposals for our summer programs and we're hoping to get some new programs for that and finally a quick reminder that registration is open for the methacton education foundation's annual dodgeball tournament that is March 16th we invite everyone to come out and join a team or just come out and show your support there are still spots available for teams but I've told they are filling up fast so make sure you get in there and sign up you can go to Matha INF foundation.org dogeball or head to our website
062for that and we're looking forward to seeing everyone duck dive Dodge and donate and that concludes my report thank you thank you very much yes absolutely I just want to say thank you for all of your hard work on the websites I've already been hearing a lot of positive feedback from the community yeah and let's get together and talk about dodgeball just in case anyone's interested so the finina fireballers are returning the reigning champions from last year just you be aware of that oh boy oh boy so let's move to the the superintendent's report Dr Zerby thank you Madame President um you'll see on the on the report there's uh two advisements as well as the right to know reports there's actually two with the month of November and December just a quick review of
063what that basically saying is that if you look at the December report uh year to date we have two appeals we fulfilled 4 2 requests and we had 39 requests as of July 1 we have uh expended uh approximately 36,000 or $337,000 from our right to know specialist our assistant superintendent about 13,000 legal cost about 103,000 for a total of $153,000 and write to know uh for July 1 through uh the current report um and in in addition to that I'd just like to make an update uh for the the board and the public on on the budget so as part of the regular budget process we began with principles and directors to establish a baseline of requests in doing so we received the two 2526 pupil Services budget requests that were significantly more than
064the 2324 actual given review of these requests and the fact that we have overspend in pupil Services the past few years is clear that greater review of these budget request request program operations and other Associated matters are required to determine the pupil Services budget and ultimately The District budget for the board's consideration in preparation for placing the proposed preliminary budget in front of the board in January as we typically do and in providing the most flexibility in in the budget decision process given the request the following matters have been taken first we reviewed and validated where possible the 2526 District projected revenue and related Revenue assumptions we reviewed and confirmed the 2526 District Department projected expenses and assumptions and we we began reviewing people Services uh operational spend to determine areas and means for cost
065control and um reduction we've scheduled meetings internally and with our legal team and with the IU to conduct a review of the operations and his strategize on a path forward we began reviewing all third-party people service contracts and creating framework for approval oversight modific and modifications where appropriate we placed on hold the borrowing of the $15 million approved by the board in October this allows us to borrow in the future once we so choose it is estimated that the borrowing would have committed an additional $790,000 to the annual budget if it was inserted the proposed preliminary budget includes expense reductions that will have no impact on the educational program or staff or or students and the proposed prary budget will include uh the special education exception that it shows expenses required beyond the Act One
066index of 4% this will allow leveraging the Act One exception upon final budget adoption if needed I recognize that uh this budget update and the challenges presented in pupil Services specifically are significant and impactful in in many ways furthermore I recognize that we proceeded forward with the schematic design for a new high school with the expectation of being able to keep taxes at an act one index as part of our commitment going forward we must recognize that preparation of the annual budget is a process that takes into consideration many factors some of these factors are not available to to us in great detail at the beginning of the process as an example things like Staffing and healthc Care typically are resolved in March each year based on the projected class size enrollment program and final
067healthc care report from the Consortium as part of that process it allows the administration and the board to work together to ensure that we have the appropriate resources to deliver a highquality educational program and maintain the appropriate operations of the district that process forward will include standing discussion items for finance committee along with the monthly updates uh to the full board on our progress providing targeted uh benchmarking and fiscal year-to-year reports to the full board to assist in discussion and effective and efficient operations developing and sharing with the board a comprehensive plan to ensure special education services are appropriate and consistent with the needs of our students that includes reviewing changes in program structure use of third-party providers staff training scheduling program resources and procedures uh changes to ensure compliance and oversight Capital borrowing will
068be a matter of the finance committee of the board in February seeking to Target the best time for borrowing giving our priorities and progress on our budget work while I work towards preparing a final budget we must keep in mind the educational operational needs uh at the same time consider making Investments where appropriate and reductions where we are least effective this evenings vote allows for the district to consider if needed to raise property taxes above the Act One index to cover increasing special education cost if needed the Act One index index is generally a calculation of that takes into account the cost of goods and services in the prior year a special education exception can be further explained through the use of the exception worksheet Miss Stephie our director of business service has placed the
069worksheet at each director's seat and she'll review that now uh with the the board so everyone should have in their packet um a sheet titled special education expenditures just give everybody a second to get that out and then I'm just going to run through it real quick okay so section A of the worksheet details special education costs for the 2022 23 and 23 24 school year expenditures for the 2223 school year total $22.3 million and $25.3 million for the 2324 school year an increase of almost $3 million section B details special education subsidy received from the state these Revenue figures are subtracted from the expenditure figures to give us net cost for the year in 2223 total cost minus revenues equal 19.6 million and in 2324 22.6 million section D is the calculation of the
070budget year index 4% multiplied by the 2223 net costs of $19.6 million that number $784,900 represents the cost increase if special special education costs were to increase at the Act One index rate of 4% the difference between the variance and cost year-over-year $2.94 million and the $784,000 represents the allowable exception $2.15 n million so in summary because methacton special education costs are increasing at a rate greater than the Act One index we are eligible for an exception equal to that difference thank you Miss Stephy um so in summation uh the motion on the agenda this evening does not in not conclude the budget process meaning it's not a finality in the process the motion this evening authorizes the administration to post for public inspection the proposed preliminary budget for 20 days if approved there would
071be a motion on the agenda for the February 18th special meeting to approve the preliminary budget and apply and get approval to apply for the special education exception then over the next several months we would work as outlined previously towards a proposed final budget for approval in May that ends my report thank you we'll now move to public comment on board action items the board will now take comments on board action items this is an opportunity for residents to comment on matters that are to be decided upon as outlined on the agenda the board asks that you keep your comments to three minutes or less the board of school directors may choose to respond to matters following the conclusion of the comments on board action [Music] items Jim mik War sester um item 9j your
072motion um as part of that you just talked about a worksheet any reason why you couldn't have posted that on a website the worksheet she just discussed you couldn't show it on the screen so we can look at it I mean why wouldn't you want us to see it everybody's got it up there but we don't right what's the percent increase based upon those calculations I didn't hear it is it 1% is it whatever what what is what's the number if you could give us that it' be good um you've passed these motions in the past but you've never mentioned approving the the U budget or for for um review 15 1921 approve Administration to apply for Act One peers in special Ed that's your motion I don't know what this motion is I've never
073saying anything like it it's crazy I hope Kyle you didn't do this motion because it's it's kind of ridiculous you're on the record saying that um we would not exceed the Act One index in any of the projected years and according to your presentation five months ago you projected the tax increase for TW this fiscal year coming up 1.4% without the 200 million and 2.6 with the 200 million why you why were you so far off you're talking 5% 5.5 you're telling us five months ago [Music] 1.6 can you exp 1.4 can you explain that the decision is being made without providing the public and the board with an analysis of the shortfall and all the possible options and Alternatives um I Heard the board get threatened about having the cut programs you know that
074no programs have to get cut and here's why you got some options do nothing exceed the index and go to referendum let the public decide what kind of job you guys are doing I prefer that method take money from the general fund to make up the shortfall uh take money from the general fund to make up the shortfall and replenish it with capital reserve money you got 14 million in there don't fund the capital reserve because you got 14 million in there put the new high school project on hold because there was nearly an extra $2 million use Surplus money to make up for the shortfall and perform a complete budget analysis to generate enough cuts to take care of the problem need a tabless can't I mean there's just no way I don't know
075what you're doing but somebody's got to take responsibility this place is like a boat in the ocean just floating around thanks thank you [Music] good evening John Andrews Lower Providence this evening I address two problems of communication here where your directors to fix now the first one I I I was going to speak about Amanda Kelly leaving in the middle of last year and no replacement yet no open position listed but now I see see that we do have a replacement for Amanda Miss uh scrabeck I'm not sure on the pronunciation but uh during the time the position was vacant we we had the district doing a lousy job of communicating which I think uh helped the uh idea of going with an expensive New School uh and postcards that were given out or mailed
076a lot of people consider those things as throwaways and uh a lot of the community I'm sure it's a high majority a totally unaware of your goings on relative to the new high school that's wrong and huge second as Dr mik has stated there is a cleverly worded vote item relating to the want of the special ed exception as in past years it wording should clearly be to get a vote on it and not a budget posting combined with a vote on that exception if I were voting it would be a no vote for this year's exemption uh uh proposal for the for vote with a national CPI close to 3% many in our community cannot afford everything Beyond cannot cannot afford anything beyond on the 4% that was spoken of a few months ago
077thank you thank you are there any are there any further public comment on board action items seeing none we will now move to board meeting minutes may I have a motion to approve the November 26 2024 regular board meeting and the December 2nd 2025 reorganization meeting minutes as attached M Shana may I have a second Miss Steel any comments or questions right seeing none all those in favor all those opposed motion carries 8 to zero we'll now move to fiscal items thank you Madame President there are nine fiscal items for your consideration tonight there have been no changes to items 9A through 9 I there has been one addition item 9j 2526 proposed preliminary budget advertisement optout authorize the administration to make available for public inspection the proposed preliminary budget which is required in order
078to allow the district to apply for the Act One exception with a tax increase of 6.386 that concludes my report thank you is there a anyone that would like like to take anything out separately for a motion yes Miss CLE I'd like to make a motion that we pull out both 9g and 9j okay n9g and NJ any others yes Mr Winters 9A please okay may I have a motion to approve all fiscal items with the exception of 9 a 9 G and 9j as presented all right Mrs graph can I have a second Mr mer any questions or comments on those items seeing none all those in favor all those opposed motion carries 8 to zero on those items listed may I have a motion to approve first the list of bills on 9A
079on fiscal items as presented yes Mr burki can I have a second Mr Winters comments or question questions yes you second uh let's see here in accordance with Section 1103 J of the public official employee ethics act at the public meeting today is my intention to abstain for the vote on agenda item 9A which involves the approval of an item of list of bills which includes the reimbursement to my wife due to the conflict of interest on the ethics act the nature of the interest is my wife wife is an instructional Aid at the high school and is co-sponsor to the National Honors Society thank you any other comments or questions on that right seeing none may I all those in favor all those opposed motion carries seven to zero oh with one abstain sorry
080I apologize okay can I have a motion to approve 9g as listed under the fiscal items as presented sorry all right Mrs uh Alon may I have a second Mr mki any comments or questions yes Miss Clary um I do have I have a question about that will help me um decide on on this vote is the cost um Associated the cost to the district associated with this going to come out of the current budget 2425 or will it be coming out of the 205 2526 budget given that we have to apply for the grant there's installation time like which budget is this coming out of well we one of the questions from last week was when does the grant funds have to be used and Dr soene I think we have that information yes
081Dr Zerby within three years of the award and the anticipated award is Sometime Late spring of 25 so that would take us to sometime in 2028 so the the the current budget would not be the would be the place where we would we would not fund the district portion of this so we would either uh as part of the budgeting process uh include this um or we would take it out of capital projects funds or we can uh defer the the uh the year that we do the installation to a future year that would be best suited for the district so so my concern is that it it becomes part of next year's budget am are you telling me that it won't be because that's that's my issue right my issue is we already have
082an issue so I don't want to see this added to without a lot of discussion added to that proposed budget so it would make most sense because it's a one-time expenditure that it would come out of the capital projects fund but what year not next year right it it wouldn't it it wouldn't matter I mean it would matter to me that's why I'm asking yeah I I I would think that we we would we would get notice that we would have the award we would uh I believe is this Co would this be co-stars Dr Ser or okay so the you know we'd have to schedule and work with the vendor to say when the insulation and the procurement of the products so I mean it could be within uh in the next 12 months
083it could that's the best I can I can that's as soon as it could it could happen Okay thank you Miss clear I'm sorry yeah yes Miss graph yeah um I guess my question is is it possible to amend this to require us to use Capital project funds for this and not put it as in our operating budget that may address Miss clear's concerns it also means it is it's coming out of a different account it's not part of our operating expenditures it doesn't actually impact the 2526 budget so could we amend this to require it to be one only move forward if we do in fact get the Grant and two to require it to come out of nonoperating budget expenses would that address it would [Music] so a motion like that would be
084would would we' maybe something uh to this effect uh to um approve the solar for schools Grant resolution 252 and the amount of $642 the solar for school grant program will help offset the the uh complete project cost of $2,412 for placing the solar array on the the high school Freight Farm all district cost will be taken from the capital projects fund is and so I I think this and become part of the annual operating budget yes and I think that the wording in the first part of this needs to change to approve the district to apply for the solar for schools Grant resolution right we're approving the application process is that correct well we're approving the resolutions that's that's attached right but it's it'ses to app correct and and we're applying for the grant
085in the amount of 6,412 and the project cost total is 2,412 minus the 6,400 is what we would actually be spending correct I just want to clarify for the rest of the board it's a $155,000 cost to the district okay and yeah I think the change that you've proposed to require this to come out of the capital fund would be helpful so I think you know a member of the board would need to make that propose are you making that and would you are you looking for a second a first and a second on that okay so I didn't write down what you said but here's what I think you said so I think we need so I am making a motion to change this resolution to reflect that the funding for this project would
086come out of the capital funds and it and we would only proceed with the project if we actually receive the grant funding and it will not be included in the 2526 operating budget that's my motion and I need a second anyone SE the motion that was listed above Mrs clear any comments on this Miss Ste oh yeah Mr just one question is there any objection to having the motion that's on the agenda be revised uh to be in accordance with the motion that was just made for Amendment so does anyone object to the amendment that was just made if not Madam president you can recognize uh a friendly Amendment essentially the the agenda item would now uh read as as was indicated that what is what's stated on the agenda but indicating that the costs
087uh for the project would be paid out of the district's Capital project fund uh and that the um uh project would only proceed if the grain is actually received uh and that it would not come out of the 2526 operational budget and if there's any further discussion on that you can is there any further discussion on what Mr Summers has stated for the okay seeing none all the those in favor all those opposed motion carries 8 to zero we will now move to uh may have a motion to approve item 9j as listed under fiscal items Mr Winters may have a second Mr mki any comments or questions okay I'm so sorry Miss graph um yeah I just want to I just want to reiterate for the board to make sure that we're all clear
088that and I may need a clarification from the administration to the question that was raised by the public this approval is to put the proposed budget out for public inspection which is a requirement of the process to apply for the special education exception so approving this while it does not give us the ability to move forward to apply for the special education exception it allows it's a requirement if we want to get the special education exception later in February and just also clarify that on the February agenda would be a vote to approve the district to go ahead and apply for the special education exception is that correct so I'm going to I'm going to try to so all this does is say that we can advertise in the newspaper that that we have that
089we are going to put up for vote on February 18th the vote to either ex devote to approve the proposed preliminary budget and to file for the Act One exception to this evening's vote all it does is advertise tell us you can put the ad in the newspaper and you can schedule a future meeting most likely a special meeting right before the work session on February 18th which is our our normally reg scheduled work session and at that meeting there would be two motions on the agenda the first motion would be to accept uh the proposed preliminary budget as it's proposed that could be at the existing uh cost or less uh because we will have done some work between this this time and that time and then the the second motion would be to
090authorize us to apply for the special education exception so just to clarify what you just said when is the board going to see any updated budget between now and the work session in February because if we're doing this this meeting in in prior to the work session in February there's not an opportunity for the board to see an updated budget well there there is opportunity uh for the finance committee meeting of of the uh of the board at least in February and then for us to present an update at the at the meeting on February 18th the special meeting and for you to consider whether or not uh there there are there are changes that you you would accept as part of that process so now we're going to present an updated budget the night
091you want us to V vote to decide whether or not we're going to move forward and approve the district to apply for the exemption we wouldn't commonly do that but you know between now and then things things could change and and and I would want to make those things apparent and available uh for the board's understanding but generally speaking you would if if you approve the motion this evening we would advertise as it's posted on the agenda we would then bring before the board at the at the February 18th meeting uh that presentation and and the two motions as I previously stated so I'm just going to clarify it sounds to me like the board actually won't get much opportunity to have a discussion about any revisions to the Budget prior to the next vote
092which would be to move forward with the exception number one in my opinion number two I'm going to also put out there that this allows the district you know less than 30 days days three weeks in order to evaluate all of the line items in the budget come forward with any of the significant increases that have not already been discussed in last week's meeting try to find ways to reduce them and present them in a meeting yeah I there's there's there's no there's no question that three weeks is a a small amount of time for us to make significant dent and and determination um I don't I I think the board should expect that if you approve us to advertise here this evening likely the the budget you'll be be presented on the 18th is
093going to be very similar to the budget we presented here this evening so I think what I heard you say is if we move forward and approve this tonight it's likely that in February we will also be approving the exception and a budget that has a 6.386 per increase in taxes that that that that is like yeah semantically it's preliminary budget so you said budget it's preliminary budget that allows us time to get closer to the 4% and hopefully below the 4% so it is not a commitment to that 6.3 at that particular point in time so semantically we need to be correct and I also encourage anybody that wants to come to the school board finance committee meeting they're more than welcome if they're concerned about not being in tune with what's happening while
094I also understand what you're saying about there's no there's no incentive either for the for the District administration to get below 6.3 because there's no restriction on them I would argue Miss graph that over the last uh 10 years there's been I think uh two times three times that we've taken exception I'm sure it was be pointed out to be exactly we've only actually taken the exception we taken exception once was the year after apped for the exception year after 0% tax increase because we didn't have a sustainable tax base so the premise that the committee or the administration is not encouraged to get close to 4% I disagree with them so I guess I'm just looking at past history which is these significant costs in our pupil Services existed in our budget last year
095and they weren't rectified between last year and this year and in October the board was informed that we were not going to see an increase above 4% even with the borrowing for the high school project and either no one was looking at the numbers no one was tracking the budget or somebody was being misled and I feel like I was misled in that whole process because now we're sitting here a few months later and saying it's a whole different ball game now and so I guess I I maybe I am a little suspicious maybe I am a little concerned that the district is not paying paying close enough attention to where the budget is and what we're actually running on our spend rates because How does it go from October we were on track we
096had no concerns and here we are in January and we're significantly higher I just don't understand Mr Winters I I understand the frustration I get that um to I believe in this year's budget there was an increase in special education $2 million it sounds like we may be overspending on that particular time uh moving in this this year but it's still five months away from the full close um but there was an increase of $2 million and the argument that you know we should have raised taxes more earlier seems I don't I don't understand the principle if we have been able to to keep that from a control perspective not having to take the special education exception during these times of significant increases for various reasons and we don't even know necessarily that's the point
097to have more time to know what we can do to adjust those so the argument that maybe we can do other things to offset this this year um with a you know taking the suggestions that were made by the public they are all options we don't know what those options are I don't discount any of them they're all they all or some or some piece of them maybe and maybe by the time we get to May we're down to 4% anyway but we don't know that so the the principle of this discussion is not to say I'm frustrated as heck the per purpose of this discussion is to have a point where we're making decisions based on fact and not on anger so I'd like to just step in um and then I'll give another
098person a chance I'm raising my hand to say this that you know this is definitely my going into my seventh with this budget and in in it is an a tough situation because the state requires us to say we want you you can do this millage that you have to vote for in January so the administration gets everything in November they all of a sudden then have to pass it to us in January and we have to make the decision last year as all new board members five of you came on and sat here and they were like I've got to rush and make this decision to vote for an act one index when I don't understand the budget and this is what I've got to do but this in seriousness the state has done
099this calculations to say this is what we think the a school needs in order to function in current standings right now 4% we have always year after year have had to vote for it just to allow us the opportunity to work on the budget but we always give the direction and we always work in every committee whether it's education property and particularly in finance as you go through things it goes back to finance and everyone works together the whole board and the administration work to do it we have looked every two years at special education and we have always always have met the EXP have met it which means there's a trend of going up but we as a board have said we're not going to do it even though the state has given us
100this document to say you guys need to increase so that you don't have to worry and fight about it but we ignore it and we keep it and we tighten our purses and say let's bring it back down we want to be under two under three last year was the highest that that we had and we didn't feel comfortable with it so I understand but we have work to do the preliminary budget proposed is for us to take the preliminary budget and chances are it will be the same one but we have months to work on it and work on all the program and review it so I understand but this special ed and the program that we just currently had we implemented a which I believe in a great model inclusion has definitely created
101a cost to us that was not discovered at the right time I think that we need to take a moment as you see in this that's why I asked for this you could see in each area where it was an increase that is very unpredictable unfortunately and so the student numbers have increased year after year after year and that that's so this is my my goal is my direction would be we we accept the Aquin index and the special at exemption but with the focus of that I want us to be at four and below and that is the work of the board and the administration so that's where I stand any other comments or questions yes Miss steal um hi I didn't want uh my tired brain to say anything so I did prepare
102something to say that way I make sense when I speak so um I've given this a lot of thought and I've thought a lot doing great all right so because of the discussions that we've had in the last two weeks which included budget cuts which makes everyone nervous and and includes the preliminary budget I first want to express my unwavering support for the incredible work of our teachers both in special education and general education and for our district as a whole I recognize that the current structure and needs of per pupil Services of the pupil Services Department um does need to review given the data that we are discussing right now special education is inherently complex with many moving Parts diverse needs and regulatory requirements when I look at the data we've been provided I
103do not see one specific area that is explaining the overall riseing course in overall rise and costs associated with special education but this data along with our test scores and consistent feedback I have heard and I will only speak for myself I have heard from every single area of our stakeholders and many different people over a number of years I believe that it reflects the overall needs and complexity of the program H as a board I think we must look at the program holistically as we're having these conversations and moving forward to identify where support is most needed valuable sources of insight will be our teachers educations Educators and Specialists understanding their experiences and identifying the gaps that they are facing with uh on the ground we can have a lot of conversation here but
104we're not in the classrooms with the students um given these complexities I also believe that it will be essential moving forward that does District collaborate with an outside organization that specializes in supporting and strengthening special education systems and I believe an audit from an an organization that specializes in this will be helpful and fruitful in creating a sustainable program moving forward um this will ensure that our programs meet the needs of all of our students and stakeholders rather than just focusing on a number and getting it down we need to figure out where the numbers need to come down and that takes a lot of teamwork um it will take a team effort and it must be a top priority of the district moving forward now and in the coming months due to careful thought
105and the time needed to review and plan to support a program that is sustainable and meets the needs of all of our stakeholders and I mean all of our stakeholders so that we don't burn out our teachers and our students feel supported and our families feel supported and our community has trust in our programs I do support this motion today to put the paperwork for time for conversation but I will absolutely say as a stakeholder um as a board member um needs to be hard work and I need to see the numbers and I agree with what and I I do want to see information going forward with the preliminary budget using the right terms um to make sure that we are prioritizing in the right areas um to see this number come down I
106will 6% is not really acceptable for us right now so um I've think I've spoken clearly and that's um all I have to say there thank you thank you any other comments Miss Alon thank you yeah I I mean I'm I've been looking at this from a number of ways and um I understand it's a preliminary budget I understand what the vote means tonight um I'm looking at in special ed enrollment between 2019 2024 is actually relatively flat I mean that does that that doesn't mean that there isn't more complex cases in Special Ed I I I agree that can be the case um and I want meth acting to be Del be delivering the best special programming to our students possible but I think that we have an overuse of third-party vendors I don't
107think that has been shown to be effective or Superior in our current delivery um and I don't believe that once we evaluate and Implement a more efficient and effective delivery of our special ed program that we will have a need for uh a budget of of this magnitude um and I I also know that there's other factors you know the money that were that were short I know we always have you know the Surplus at the end of the year I I don't think that voting against this puts the district at any risk of of educational programming demise or or anything like that so um I will not be voting in favor of this tonight thank you any other comments Miss Clary um I had a bunch of comments prepared but I think I'm going
108to skip them what I what I heard tonight was from some board members that they support this motion because they feel the district needs time and options and I'm really struggling with that concept because the time is the same amount of time whether you vote Yes or no the budget process is still the same so if you vote Yes you're not giving the district any more time we have the same amount of time if we vote no what the district is getting is a clear direction that we will consider a property tax increase over the Act One index and that I am absolutely not going to support um I this discussion makes this discussion is so Troublesome to me because the community is not a bank and I'm not suggesting that anyone is saying that
109but that's how that's how I'm I'm taking it in right this is a huge tax increase that you that the district wants to keep on the table and some of the board members want to keep on the table um we we well let's just talk about myself I ran for this for this position on a platform of quality education for our students doing the right thing and doing it in a fiscally responsible Manner and I said that last week and I I'll say it again I think this is so fiscally irresponsible that I will not support it I won't support if it passes I won't support it at the February 18th meeting um and um yeah I I I I I wish we could send a message to the administration that this is not acceptable
110and we need to work within the Act One index whether that is um looking at our proposed spending that we could scale back in some way or maybe there's a different delivery method that could still be and deliver the same Effectiveness um are there non-essential items in the budget that uh we could put off for a year um and look at again next year and that's not to mention as Miss Alon uh discussed that we have a surplus it seems like we have a surplus every year and we take that Surplus and we move it into our Capital reserves which I understand I view that as a savings account right it is it helps us with future borrowing it it it's good for the district but you can't do that and then in the same
111breath want to tax want more taxes to cover this stuff we need to be if we can't find reductions that make us happy as a board which is our decision um you know it's not program Cuts aren't happening unless we decide it's happening so that that what I viewed as a threat last week is I hope everyone understands that that's not accurate um I lost my train of thought but so I I think I was talking about surpluses so thank you so I was saying that it seems like we have had not seem like we have had surpluses over the last several years we've taken that money we've moved it into our Capital Reserves I think we need to take a hard look at are we over budgeting and that's creating these surpluses so is
112that an area that we need to look at it seems like we must be consistently are we consistently over budgeting in the same place that's resulting in the surpluses if it's not that then what is it and I think that's a ripe area for Budget reduction but it's the same amount of time at the end of the day whether you approve this motion or you don't approve this motion it's the same amount of time and so so I just vly eject to raising taxes over the 4% and so I'm an absolute now thank you any other comments or questions yes graph yeah um thinking about the surplus of 1.6 million that we had and I I believe the number that we're looking for in the budget overrun is 2.1 so if we use the 1.6
113that only left us with a half a million dollars and I think last week I asked the question of what was The Debt Service increase to cover the borrowing for the high school did we get that number it was $1.6 Million so $1.6 million would cover The Debt Service if we borrowed for the high school this year so if we don't borrow for the high school this year we actually have another 1.6 million in Surplus so by my calculations the money is already there it just has to be reallocated we don't need a 6.3% % tax increase we do not need to go above the Act One index we might need to make some tough choices about what's the priority for this district is it building a new High School this year or is it
114putting it off a year and getting our other programs in order and I agree like I there is no need for this approval and we do not need to move forward with this the money is in the district's coffers I mean it's sitting there in our reserves and in our Surplus at the end of the year so when we get to that point we're all going to look at each other and say we didn't need to approve that anyway why do we tax those people that much money and then just take their money and put it in a bank account I don't think that's fair I don't think it's right and I think it's I think it's wrong for the district and I think it's wrong for the taxpayers and I cannot support it any
115other comments Mr Winters can we ask Miss Stephy to explain the the surplus of $1.6 million and how how it was distributed at the end of the year so I don't unfortunately have the exact figures in front of me but about a million dollars um went into committed fund balance and that was for um that is for curriculum purchases that we have already made but have not yet paid for the unassigned fund balance increased um around $550,000 so a million dollar has already been committed to curriculum purchases that we have already made the board has already voted on those curriculum purchases and we have already bought those materials thank you and and those uh curriculum purchases were approved in last year's budget the previous year's budget correct as part of the curriculum review so uh
116the suggestion that the $500,000 that we voted on in June to say if there was any excess that that would go under the unassigned balance is that reversable from a decision perspective so to miss graph's point of the $ 1.5 million the half a million dollars in June that we all voted for I believe we all voted for to move it into the unassigned balance is that reversible from a capital um fund balance back into the general fund and then potentially as from a discussion point to cover any differences in the and so the unsigned fund balance can essentially be used for whatever you choose is that what you're asking I'm saying that we made a decision in June that if there was any surplus in the budget I think it was $22,000 we transferred
117to Capital to Capital yes but it was half a million dollars just I'm I'm trying to make sure that there's an understanding of the options that we have since somebody has made the assumption that there's $1.6 million available from last year's Surplus that we spent away which is not the case a million dollars of it is in uh a predefined that we are going to take over the next four or five years related to uh licenses for credit is that correct the half million dollars that we did make a decision to move is that reversible from and to be used in any way we want right we could move it to Capital We could decide to use it from oneoff purchases we could use it um I I want to make the point definitely an
118option but it is it has to be an option only if we know how we're going to get to the lower cost because if sustainably not smart to take your savings account to pay your for your operational expenses that you're going to have the following year the only thing I I and then I'll call on you the one thing I would definitely say is just be cautious of when you're saying the Surplus we have every year because in truth I being on finance committee I have definitely found there are different reasons behind that Surplus it wasn't like we made this big budget and so there these these statements are a little bit fightful to be honest and and I know that's not what your intention is but surpluses we it is defined where surpluses come
119every year that is a part of the committee so I have found different reasons of why that might have happened and with those we have made adjustments through each time so it's not always a consistency of there's a surplus under operational there's a surplus under this so I just would be cautious to say that we we have a surplus every year we could use this Surplus because it really does truly come from some specifics that that I've seen and reviewed through past years so miss Clary how much is in the unassigned fund balance is it $9.7 million I believe so right um and some of that money is there from surpluses from years is that not correct correct right thank you and we have to maintain a certain what is the number that we do
120have to maintain in that uh 7% so there's that that's about eight million I think we have to keep in there or 7 million I think is something that's required for us to keep our un assigned fund balance right now stands at exactly 7% okay and to be clear that's a choice that we have made that we have that in the policy to keep it at 7% not higher the recommendation come from P that we can go up to eight I believe for the size of our budget we could go down to zero if we wanted to but fiscally that's not really smart when you're trying to borrow money so I don't want it make it sound like we have to have 7% that is a choice that we've taken to be sort of in
121the middle and it is part of the uh evaluation of our Moody's writing as well miss Clary I don't want to suggest that I am advocating that we just roll over and take the money from the unallocated fund balance I that's not what I'm saying um I was just pointing out that it's an option um whether it's a dollar or it's something more because in either scenario of this motion we have to do the work to figure out if there are places that we can make reductions I'm not I'm not suggesting that we don't do that what I'm suggesting is that whether you approve this motion or not we still have the same time commitment I don't understand this the district needs more time all you're doing is saying it's okay to tax people over
1224% and and we've already heard that on February 18th it's likely that this we're going to see the same budget and we're going to be asked to approve applying for a special ed or applying for referendums to the um the aan index for special ed at 6.386 I just I just want to be clear Mr mki so what's could you explain to me the purpose of this special education form what's what what's the purpose I so the purpose of the form is to show that our special in our special ed costs are increasing at a rate significantly higher than the Act One index so the State puts it out to help you define whether or not you're you can qualify for additional taxes to support escalating special ed costs correct so it's just a guideline
123and what are we voting on tonight are we are we voting on a v final budget we are not voting on a final budget this are we voting on a final tax rate we are not voting on a final tax rate what are we voting on we're voting on authorizing Administration to put an add in the paper to to provide public notice that on February 18th there'll be a proposed preliminary budget that will uh be voted on and the second motion that evening will be to either apply or not apply for the special education so are on February 18th are we voting for a final budget no so on February 18th do we know what the budget's going to be it's the feary not what we submit what the final budget's going to be the
124final budget no when are we voting on a final budget likely in May so we have from now until May to determine what the final budget is I think the time constraints that we're under is that we have until February well we have until February 18th to decide whether we're going to submit for a tax rate above 4% correct correct or if we don't prove for that then we have to to to adhere to the aquan index before the end of this month that's correct so I think that's the time pressure it's not the decision on a final budget correct this is not about the final budget this is this is a timing mechanism within the act one uh process just one other point do we have any idea how we're going to get to
125uh under a four 4% what the budget's going to look like in the next week we only have a list of things that we need to evaluate I read through several of those but we're not going to have a final budget in a week I I'm not going to have a final budget in a week that's not what this is right it's it is not okay thank you any yes Miss Alon um I actually have a question about the worksheet specifically um but I also wanted to just make a make a point to support Miss can's point of that we really don't know um where the Surplus comes from because I think in our latest budget presentation there was like 21 different categories of of things so um I I do support that that point
126but I also know that we have had one historically year-over-year um but I actually just had a question about this worksheet um one of the categories was um 2150 Speech Pathology and Audiology services which has amounts as zero and I just I know we provide those services so I just was curious as to why those um amounts are zero and then my other question on the worksheet is what is what kinds of things fall under the category of Legal Services um so I'll definitely look into the speech facility may just be coded somewhere else I'm not sure so I'll get an answer for you on that and legal services would be any special education Legal Services related related special okay Mr Winters yeah Miss Stephy can you just uh I think you can clarify I
127believe the numbers on the worksheet are correct from the total perspective but the variances might have some corrections that need to be made oh yeah absolutely um so A1 the variance over to the right hand column is incorrect It should read 2 point um $2 million but the variance at the bottom 2.9 is correct thank you Miss graph yeah I just want to reiterate a couple of things so we're GNA vote on the budget in May so let's just play this out you get your 6.3 you come back to us in February at 6.3 you come back to us in March at 6.2 you come back to us in April at 5.9 you come back to us in May at 5.9 what is the board going to do then what what is the plan at
128that point because we're still going to be in the same situation of the some of the board members are saying this is not an acceptable increase and other board members have allowed us to get there and we're still going to have to make the hard choices do we take the money out of a capital reserve budget do we cut something in the budget do we press the the administration over the next three months to get this down yes but what happens if they don't what happens if the budget still comes back to the board at 5.5 or 6% every one of you who vote for this are going to have to look yourselves in the mirror and say well I should have said no because if I really don't want to be above four the
129answer is no now not in May because it's too late in may you have no recourse we have to approve a budget at some point between May and July 1 and if if the administration can't make any further adjustments we're still in the same decision making process of taking the money out of capital reserve halting other projects the money has to come from somewhere if you really don't want to go above 4% or four and a half percent or whatever your artificial number is because that's kind of what we're talking about here so I just need you to understand that the pressure is exactly the same regardless of whether you say yes or no it doesn't give the district any additional time all you're saying is I'm okay with being above 4% that's it that's
130the decision today the one thing I'll add though is it I understand what you're saying Miss graph but the one thing is it we are always put in this position because we always vote for the ACT one right and we've never done the act one we always go lower and lower and lower so that theory I do understand what you're saying but that theory is then we're already agreeing that we always take an act one and you know we look at it and there's many districts around our and I really wish we had that from our past one that many of the districts go to that act one and write to it um and we always vote for it but we do not do it because that is the will of the board that is
131the direction of the board so I your concept doesn't hold steadfast for even the act one because we vote for the ACT one every year so that there's an opportunity for us to work on the budget but I agree with you but I don't think I don't feel committed in any way that will be in that I think there's work for all of of us at this table and the administration to do so I don't I've never had that where we're like act one I'm at it at the top and this is it so I understand but I just kind of pause on that one any other comments miss the I I do just I just have one comment for well two things actually um it is hard for me to make decisions without more
132specific data saying that I um say saying that well there might be Cuts in something is really hard for me to understand and that's how um that that's how I process things and um what I am concerned about is not a 5% tax increase I do not see as being appropriate um but what I am concerned about is I want to see a plan to discuss the needs of our pupil Services programming and our special education program programming rather than just bringing down the cost I think if that there is already pressure in that there's already pressure on Educators within our school district especially in that area and I don't know with all the pressures I can't speak for that area um I don't know the information but I I gather that that there is
133and I want to see and hear discussion on why these costs are going up so that a sustainable plan can be worked on um so that I guess that that's what I'm looking for um it's not that I am looking at the taxpayer as um as someone who just keeps giving money I I don't know if that makes sense um and I I will be looking for the information going forward um I hope that that makes sense I I need more information that's that's where I'm at any further comments or questions okay seeing none president just one recommendation um so there is a deadline um by the end of this month um and and the generally the deadline is that the Board needs to issue um the uh advertise its its preliminary budget so that
134it can be uh available to the public in enough time before the board votes on that preliminary budget so that's the general requirement is that by the end of this month the preliminary budget um be advertised the alternative to that is a passage of the opt out resolution essentially the resolution by the board saying the board will not go beyond the Act One index and that is taken off the table as as even a possibility so essentially one or the other has to happen um BAS based upon the the discussion I think um of the board uh it's it's not clear to me necessarily what what the outcome of this uh vote that's on the agenda would be so one recommendation is for those board members who who have indicated that they are not in
135support of this um I I'd recommend a motion to amend uh the motion that is on the the agenda so that it would be amending it to reflect a um the passage of a resolution not to exceed the index um and by doing that and and and if that motion to amend passes there would then first be a vote on whether a majority of the board is in favor of not going beyond the Act One index I think that's that's an important um thing for the board to be aware of so that if that motion passes or fails if it passes then then certainly it's it's likely that there would not be a preliminary budget there would be an opt out resolution if it does not pass um then I think it would be important
136for all board members to know that there is a requirement for a preliminary budget to be advertised um so with with that I I would recommend um you know certainly if there are board members that do not wish to approve the preliminary budget that there be a motion um to amend uh the the agenda item to instead reflect approval of a resolution not to exceed the Act One index so just for clarification is there any value to doing a roll call to know where we stand um and if there is a four to four Vote or such that that if there is a vote that passes it yeah goes forward as such but if there's not sure the the recommendation to to for those board members who wish to um uh limit at the act
137one is to is to know if there is support for that before there's a final vote on this motion Miss Clary I'd like to make a motion to amend agenda item 9j to reflect a resolution that the board will not exceed the Act One index is there a second Mr Mery um have to do she asked for a second okay is there a second yes all right Miss graph okay so you do have you have a you have a motion to amend the agenda that's on the uh item that is on the agenda it has been seconded so now you're ate a point in engaging in discussion of that Amendment the Administration has prepared um a copy of a resolution that uh would achieve the impact of limiting the uh potential tax increase at the
138Act One index so um certainly um Miss clear and Miss graph uh you can take a second all board members can certainly review the resolution it's consistent with opt out resolutions that uh have been adopted previously it U would achieve the purpose of uh limiting any increase to the Act One index um so so it reads resolution 25-3 and it specifically says and I will read several of the points on there it says the board certifies that it will not increase any school district tax for the 2526 school year at a rate that exceeds the index Asal calculated by the Pennsylvania Department of Education it also reads that the board certifies that increasing any tax rate less than or equal to the index will be sufficient to balance its final budget for the 2526 school
139year it also states that the administration of the district will send a copy of the resolution to the Pennsylvania Department of Education no later than five days after the board adopts this resolution and on the back page it also says that the board understands and agrees that by passing The Resolution it is not eligible to seek referendum exceptions under Section 333 F of act one and is not eligible to request approval from the voters through the referendum to increase the tax rate by more than the index as established by the 25 526 fiscal year so at this point certainly if there's any um further discussion amongst the board about whether uh to approve this amendment and and just to to be clear procedurally if the amendment passes then the agenda item would be amended and
140then there would be a vote on the amended agenda item so the the vote now is just whether to amend what's on the agenda uh to reflect uh limiting any tax increase to the act one as opposed to moving forward with the preliminary budget process if there's any further discussion um certainly the board can have that before voting on whether to amend the agenda any comments or discussion seeing none all right so then I will be taking I will then yeah it's not a new motion it's an amendment of the motion that's on the agenda and certainly um the the opt out is mentioned and the the title of the the motion itself uh it's certainly contemplated that an alternative to passing a preliminary budget is is opting out uh of that process so at
141this point I will do a vote for then the the amended motion that was read by Dr Zerby okay um may have a may have a motion for oh no now I'm G to do a vote sorry um would you recommend doing a roll call Vote or just you can uh the president or any board member can call for a roll call vote right I'm going to do a roll call vote just so that um so for the for the motion that was read I'm going to do a roll call vote and just to be clear a a yes vote is is to amend the motion and limit any tax increase to the Act One index uh as opposed to following the preliminary budget process okay so just to clarify we're voting for the motion
142or are we voting for both the motion and the Act One index cap so the the motion that is on the board on the table at the moment is to amend the agenda so that instead of having it say to approve approve a preliminary budget it would be approve an a resolution to limit uh any increase to the Act One index so if you are in favor of limiting uh any potential increase to the Act One index and not having the option of exceeding that uh the answer to this vote would be yes to amend the item um and and if if you know if you're not in support of seeking the opt out uh resolution a no would be your vote any questions or CL clarification okay I'm going to proceed forward then so
143miss canro is no Miss Alon yes Miss Shonda yes Miss clear yes Miss graph yes Mr mki no Miss Purdue is not present Miss steel no and Mr Winters no Okay so we now have a tie vote for four Nos and four yeses in the situation right so the amendment does not pass um so you are back to the the motion that is on the agenda which is the adoption uh or not the adoption the the advertisement of the preliminary budget um and just uh from a legal compliance perspective I would uh you know recommend that the board either adopt the resolution to opt out or adopt the preliminary budget advertisement um the board is required to do one of the other so I I certainly understand uh those board members who just voted in
144favor of the opt out resolution amending it for that um but just understand that there is a requirement uh if that is not the decision that's made there is a requirement of advert moving forward with the advertisement of the preliminary budget um so at this point you can have any further discussion if you'd like any further discussions at this point Mr Winters so going back to miss graph's point I I think it's a valid point um if you do not want to vote for a tax increase of 4.1% come May then for sure if you cannot see yourself voting for 4.1 because we've gone through the exercise of determining what choices what our delivery is going to be for special education what we're going to do for you you should be voting against this but
145if you don't know know how you're going to vote on that you're locking yourself out at this point not knowing what those choices are so I I it's very clear Miss Clary I understand anything above 4% you're not going to vote for so I completely respect that's your opinion but understand what you're voting for by saying no to this at this point in time any additional comments or questions all right so seeing none um we I will do a vote for the motion that stands from the original yes Miss steel can I just ask because this is the vote for the paperwork for the for w the paperwork we're not voting for the preliminary budget yet right so what new information will we see in February before we vote in terms of where the the
146budget will be I mean I I you know we we have three weeks we'll probably see some additional information as part of the the finance committee but as Miss graph you know uh you know pointed out you know it's going to be very difficult for you to make a a a decision on the same evening that you presented the information any new information so while you might see new information the the likelihood of uh the budget being different that you vote on on February 18th is very slim can I have clarification I'm sorry with the date do we have to have it on February 18th could we not have a review in the work session and then vote on work session is February 18th no uh but can we not vote on it at the
147school board meeting the following week on thead deadline of the 19th to file it okay could we create a special board meeting we can do a special meeting in prior to the 18th or on the 18th and have the meeting to vote on on that but that's not going to necessarily get us any further ahead in terms of having new information sorry Mr winus I was just thinking sorry no I I think it's it I I think we need to understand where we just had a 44 vote on the previous if we end in a 44 understand from Kyle what our options are and what what a four vot 44 vote means at this point in time what a 44 Mo vote potentially could mean on the middle of February yeah and just um kind
148of to reiterate what I said earlier I think the the deadline is uh the end of this month so January 30th to either pass an opt out resolution saying the district will not exceed the index a motion to to have that uh item be on the agenda tonight uh did just fail um so it's either to the requirement is to either e pass that resolution or uh move forward with the preliminary budget process uh and the first step in that process would be uh advertising and preliminary budget so in terms of the impact um you know just as if there just as there is a requirement to adopt a budget by the end of every fiscal year uh and and the district complies with that uh for not wanting to be out of compliance with
149the law and any potential consequences that could follow from that the recommendation is certainly um to if if the opt out resolution is not passing to move forward with the preliminary budget uh process so as to maintain compliance any additional comments or questions I would say yeah Miss Manda so I'm extremely frustrated with this whole process first I'm frustrated that we found out information not in a timely manner and it's making this decision really difficult for me hypothetically if we come back in May and the budget or tax or whatever is coming in at I don't know 5 and a half% and we are not okay with that and a majority of the board says no in May what are our options from that point forward so the the the the passage of a preliminary
150budget um does not uh impact the flexibility of the board uh to make its decision on the final budget in May um so uh really this vote is is simply just allowing the possibility of exceeding the index to occur um the board would have every ability uh it still requires a majority vote of the board to adopt the budget and as Mr Winters indicated earlier that budget could have a zero increase highly unlikely to anything up to if the preliminary budget um is passed up to the index plus the special education exception so it's it keeps that option available moving forward but it certainly doesn't require the board uh to ultimately vote on that and actually um even the the history of the board has has generally been that the proposed final budget um which
151is typically passed in April uh you know before the the certainly before for the final budget um that final budget tends to even be lower than the proposed final budget which happens later in the spring and just to add um you know the we present during the work session and the Schoolboard meetings updates of the budget it's required we have um so it's each we're very aware as we move through each month discussions that are happening each of the Committees so if we get to that point there's a lot of work that we didn't do so we have to be comfortable when we finally get to May and everything comes in with the assessments and where we are with programming we all as a group should be comfortable because we did the work of the
152of the year so um so if we land at a higher number than we we thought I don't you know I think that's because we all agreed with the program and that's happening but I do think there should be a direction set for the administration of where we want to be so in my opinion every year we take the preliminary budget we do the Act One index and we ask and request the administration to be where we're looking so for is the direction of our board there we are like it's pretty clear and we don't have to you know we don't have to vote and accept it puts it in a situation and I think that's what Mr Summers she's asking if we don't vote for it in May what happens in terms of but
153not if if not voting to exceed the index no final budget in May you know 4.1% okay 5% no F and you know that and that's just for me but you have four people at this table right now that just said we don't we don't want to do we don't want to go over four I you know I'm I'm considering the four you know the 4.1% and allowing us to have that that little bit of wiggle room but I'm concerned that we get to May because we're seeing a pattern of less minute information and having to make PR decisions under the gun um what happens if we get to May and it's still in an uncomfortable place for at least half of the board so I think the question is if you get to that
154point and a majority of the board um doesn't support the budget then it doesn't pass um and if a majority of the board uh at that point believes you know what um we're comfortable with uh you know exceeding the index by whatever that amount may be and there are five members of the board that support that then it passes so it's it's really just a matter of where a majority of the board obviously given the absence and the attendance at tonight's meeting there's an even number of board members um but ultimately uh it takes majority vote of the membership of the board five votes to pass a budget and so that's how at least that number need to be comfortable with whatever the final budget uh that would be passed would be okay thank you
155yes Miss Clary but but Mr Summers could you sort of uh answer that question just a little bit more um if if the majority of the board does not pass the budget what happens at the school level I mean is that even AR we legally required to adopt some budget or something yes I mean there is a there is a it's a legal requirement that the district adopt a budget it's also a legal requirement that if um there is not a a vote to agree not to exceed the index that the board is obligated um to adopt a a PR a preliminary budget and advertise for that preliminary budget so um you know non-compliance with a legal requirement it certainly opens up the door um to a variety of actions I don't necessarily want to
156um speak to all of the possibilities for a school district that doesn't comply with the school code um but but certainly some sort of enforcement action um it's not a position that the district wants to be in so then there's so then there's pressure to to approve the budget that's in front of you even if it's at uh at a an uncomfortable number for some of us I mean I'm just trying to want to make sure we play it all out I want to get to the whole your whole question and and that's what I've been trying to do for the last week play out all the way through either one of these options and I feel like we you know we're under the gun now and I and I'm I'm concerned we're going to
157be under the gun again in May yeah and the only the only Point again I I would make is just a failure of the motion that's before the uh board at the moment certainly puts the district in a difficult position because there was an attempt um to limit any increase to the Act One index uh through the amendment that did not pass because of a it was a TI vote um so the the motion that is before the board to comply with the preliminary budget process um is what is required since the opt out resolution did not pass I understand uh that voting for it could indicate a desire to support uh an increase above the index but I just think the the reality of the situation is that the Board needs to do one
158of two things one of those things just failed uh and so certainly the the other option could in reality fail in a moment by another tie uh but it puts the district in a difficult position of potentially not being in compliance with the law Miss steel can we as a board asked for a deadline to review preliminary budget information and then opt to go forward before the deadline uh am I misunder like can we like there's a deadline like what was it June May I'm sorry um can we as a board have a presentation to discuss and say yeah we're good with that um or no go back get it lower does that make sense am I asking the right thing yeah so so you as I stated earlier the you know unless the board
159sees it needs to be differently you typically we would we would have standing items every finance committee we would have presentations before the full board every every meeting uh through the uh final adoption so you will know in in every month you will know the stage of the budgetary process and likely uh most of most all of this information will most getting clear by the end of March that's when all of our staffing and enrollment uh class size projections are all taken care of that's when all the the the the Staffing is is addressed that's when our health care is addressed and that that give that gives us a time to give you a more accurate representation of what we think we need to do it also gives us an opportunity to have discussion about
160the things that the administration will propose to reduce the the cost and to certainly get your feedback on those things so each month along the way you'll you'll know by the time you get the May whether or not uh you're you're you're uh comfortable accepting that or not so as the process goes before the final adoption there's What's called the proposed uh uh final adoption and that's something that that that that we vote on to say this is the one that gets advertised and then we go the final adoption uh in May so the only other comment like I understand when you say like under the gun like and I feel like we're it it it's unfortunate but we get the business administrator gets it all the budgets in October and November and presents it
161to the administrator and in December we don't have meetings and public meeting and we go right to this and we have to do it so I agree I always feel an angst of this that we're asking the community to do this it's just the worst process I think in in truth so I understand and respect it but um it's quick it's quick but then this is our point where we take it and we go and we work and we work each again I'll keep repeating it but um it does feel sudden it always does and um you know but and the the situation that we're dealing with with special ed is something that is a standard thing that the state has given us to show us this um any other comments or anything we before
162we go to vote okay with that said I'm going to do a roll call on the motion that stands in our current um state of 9j do you want me to read it out loud again or we're good right I think we're good so I'm going to do a roll call again just so we're clear so miss canro yes Miss Alon no Miss Shonda no Mr Miss clear no Miss graph no miss Mr mki yes and then Miss Purdue she's not here miss steel yes and then Mr Winters yes okay motion has not been approved it the it is four no four yes so Mr Summers what what are the next steps that we could do at this point um I mean essentially um there is a a requirement as I mentioned for in the
163absence of a optout resolution um to um in the absence of an opt out resolution the preliminary budget needs to be advertised and then subsequently voted upon so um as the the the vote resulted in a a tie uh for the advertising of the preliminary budget that also did not pass um the board can certainly um engage in further discussion if there's a desire to do that um in or in hopes of reaching an outcome uh that is in compliance with the requirement of either adopting the optout resolution or adopting a preliminary budget um so that you could entertain uh another motion for either the preliminary budget or an opt out resolution at this time which are the two items that were just voted on both failed um but I think doing so would make
164sense if if there is a potential of of board members adjusting their votes just so what what are the actual kind of tangible consequences here with an absence of a of a vote vote on either of these items so um certainly the the Department of Education could uh look at districts that are in non-compliance with the requirements of the school code and seek some sort of corrective action um there are steps that residents and taxpayers can take if a board uh is not in compliance with its statutory obligations I'm not suggesting that that would occur but there are steps that could be attempted to be taken um you know in or in in in order to ensure that board members carry out their responsibilities um those are the those are the the primary consequences okay
165um it may make sense um Madame President um for um an executive session at this time just in in terms of the board's ability to consult with the solicitor uh regarding uh potential legal ramifications of uh the the vote this evening um I think that that um may be appropriate in the circumstance in order to allow for confidential attorney client communication to occur um so uh if there's support for that I I would suggest a brief recess for the board to go into executive session uh to obtain legal advice regarding this matter okay and so I could I will ask for us to have a brief pause so we can have an executive session at this time right thank you you e e e all right we are back from Recess after receiving executive session
166for legal advice from our solicitor we are now going to resume back to under um fiscal items um at this time 9j is we had two amended and the current one that were both in ties so there is not a 9j at this time does anyone have a proposed um a proposal for 9j Miss Clary uh I would make a motion to um I I make a mo I'm not sure how to say this Mr Summers but I make a motion to um to not allow for a tax increase above the AC one index of 4% okay so your your motion is essentially to uh approve the adoption of of a resolution uh resolution 25-3 um for the 2526 fiscal year budget not to exceed the Act One index that's a motion is there a
167second okay there's a motion is there a second Sorry Miss graph any comments or questions with the motion that's at stand Mr Winters what is the difference between what we voted on prior to voting for n9j uh nothing I was just making another motion because you asked and that's what my position is okay so with that any other comments or all right or amendments or amendments uh unless there's any indication that somebody okay I there's we can go through the vote from four to four again so okay but you can make an amendment Mr Winters to any motion that's on the table Manda did you want to speak um I I will make a motion um for the sake of getting home tonight um authorized Administration to make available for public inspection the proposed preliminary
168budget which is required in order to allow the district to apply for the Act One specialit exception with an incre tax increase not to be above 5 1% is there a second Miss Miss Alon I apologize there's a second with Miss Alon any comments or questions okay so just to be clear this is a there was an a motion to um uh have the the uh limit the increase to the Act One exception then there was a a motion to amend that um and that was seconded so the vote that's currently before the board is whether to amend a motion that would have limited the board to the Act One index um to instead allow for the preliminary budget process to move forward but with a maximum tax increase of 5.1% uh and if that
169passes then the the agenda item will be have been amended and then there will be a vote on that um yeah Madam president I'd like to withdraw my motion well you you do have the underly initial motion I I would suggest moving forward with the first a vote on whether to amend your motion so if we vote to so it's going to be of all right yes I'll do a roll call so no means that we will not amend the motion and yes is we will amend the motion just for clarity okay to the right no no to what Miss clear had stated in hers as correct no so the the motion that was made was to limit to the Act One index Mr Winters then made a motion to amend that to allow for
170the preliminary budget process to move forward but only with a maximum tax increase of 5.1% that was seconded so that is what is before the board now is to amend Miss clear's initial motion uh to instead have a um have that be a a preliminary budget advertisement but with a maximum tax increase of 5.1% just on the amendment yes okay so I'm going to do a roll call based on what uh Mr suas has stated okay Miss uh Miss canro uh yes Miss Alon yes Miss Shonda yes Miss clear yes Miss graph yes Mr mki yes Miss steel yes and Mr Winters yes okay so now the motion that is before the board is authorize the administration to make available for public inspection proposed preliminary budget which is required in order to allow the district
171to apply for the ACT one special education exception but with an tax increase of 5.1% okay so we will now take roll call on the motion that Mr Summers just presented this any discussion comments or discussions I apologize thank you and I appreciate the board for supporting me in this process so I'm going to do now a roll call uh Miss canro yes Miss Alon yes Miss Shonda yes Miss clear no Miss graph no Mr mki yes Miss steel yes Mr Winters yes okay motion then does carry and is approved with one two three four five six six to two we will now move on to curriculum and programs there are no items under curriculum and programs this month oh sorry I apologize Personnel I am I really apologize may have a motion all right
172Personnel items uh Dr Serie thank you Madame President for the consideration of the board this month other the Personnel items as presented last week with the following additions one resignation classified Brenda Bowen power professional at Sky View one change of status administrative Mr Mr John Conrad from social studies instructor of the high school to assistant principal at the high school one uncompensated leave professional Nicole Brier first grade instructor at Woodland for the dates identified and the addition of Erin hilard to the classified substitute list as a support staff casual on call thank you thank you very much um may I have a motion to approve all personal items as presented Miss michana do I have a second Miss Alon any comments or questions right seeing none all those in favor all those opposed motion carries
1738 to zero as I said there are no items under curriculum and programs this month and then now we'll move over to policy there are uh no changes to the policies that were presented at the work session so for your approval this evening under second read there's policy 624 626 6.1 627 and 701 thank you may I have a motion to approve policies listed for a second read all right Miss clear may have a second Miss Alon any comments or questions okay seeing none all those in favor all those opposed motion carries 8 to zero under other under 13A gifts and donations uh we have the the same eight uh generous gifts and donations as presented at the work session under uh 13B trips there are two additional to from the work session number two
174is approve the high school tree leading squad to participate in state competition from the January 30th to the 31st in sander Arena and reading and then third one is approved mathak High School winter track and field team to participate in the state competition March 1st and 2nd at Penn State multiport indoor at State College and then under 13 C there's an agreement to approve the settlement agreement with James MLL with terms and conditions drafted by special councel in no changes under 13d for transportation okay thank you may have a motion to approve all items listed under other as presented Miss clear may I have a second Miss Alon any comments or questions Mr Winters I'd like to take item 13 C separately okay may I have a motion to approve all items listed under other
175except with the exception of 13 C Miss steel do have a second Miss Allon any comments or questions seeing none all those in favor all those opposed motion carries 8 to zero now may have a motion to approve item 13 c as listed above under other as presented Miss clear may have a second Miss steal any comments or questions seeing then um all those in favor all those opposed motion does c pass with a vote of 8 to one I'm sorry seven to one right we'll now move to dates for board members calendars the upcoming board member dates are listed on the agenda and also on the act website do we have anything for old or new business Mr Winters it was mentioned by um our student ambassadors about the Unified sports and I just
176was wondering if it's if there's any consideration for the unified soccer is the third sport uh that's something that could be considered with the athletic director for the 26 27 year thank you for bringing that to our attention uh it the that discussion hasn't gotten its way up to me yet so I'm not familiar with it Dr soini have you had any conversation but we'll we'll put it on the athletic director's uh plate for a conversation I'd love it also to be in the education committee this way they're familiar with the review of that Athletics addition to it there's a whole policy to be followed so in just as a reminder in our strategic plan it does talk about uh us getting to three sports for Unified sports so we already are at two so
177this is this is appropriate great any other old or new business okay seeing none oh sorry Miss Theo um if I wanted to just bring up just because it was on um the agenda earlier with the um Sun panels that's not what they're called thank you those things um but the solar panels um just because it was presented and I guess it would come to education committee we could talk about it there but talking about with the steel standards maybe weaving it in so that the solar panels and the high Tronics lab can be woven into maybe curriculum in the future so that more than just the 50 students in the class would utilize that since we are investing it in as a school district does that make sense so then we would that would
178just be cons I guess it would go to education committee but figured I'd bring it up now since we talked about it no that's good it's very appropriate to to say awesome any other comments or questions at this time all right good seeing none I'm going to move it to Courtesy of the floor the board of school directors will now provide an opportunity for residents to make comments on matters that are or may be before the board the board asks that you keep your comments to three minutes or less the board of school directors may choose to respond to matters following the conclusion of the comments please submit questions via email at information maa.org Jim mik War sester uh some of you board members Bravo very impressive um what happens when you give politicians more
179money what happens when you give them the authority to spend more money oh they cut back they're fiscally responsible give them more money they spend more money that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen um there's nothing in your motion about opting out it may be something in the title but the motion itself there's nothing about opting out there's nothing in the motion about a February 18th meeting where's that where's that come from it's not in the motion this motion is the craziest thing I ever saw um what I did observe is some bullying going on up here bullion and actually I I watched how Kyle conducted the vote and Kyle starts off with the amended motion rather than the motion and then blames the people with the amended motion for you know the district
180going down to tubes Kyle was that planned was that a plan the way you the way you kind of um did it didn't give him much options um miss kro you talk about um you know passing it and then working on the budget right we're gonna pass it we got months we work on the budget how much did you work on the last budget you didn't work at all zero 5.3% it's gonna be different now you're going to actually work to cut stuff you weren't saying anything last time like go let's cut it let's you know let's get it down how much how much do you pay in school taxes by the way yeah well I know because I've seen it um Mr Mery you want to build a $430 million school and you want
181to raise our taxes 6% oh 5.1 what are you paying school taxes I know I've seen it you don't pay much maybe you should start paying your fair share and then you'll be able to come up here and make a vote that means something we got two tax and Spenders over there Paul you can't be on the finance committee chair being a tax and spender can't it's it's obvious now now we got 14 million in the capital reserve we got 7 million in the general fund over the past 10 years you guys have over taxed us $23 million even taxing us below the index 10 years $23 million surplus and you need more money 14 million in the Cap Fund seven in the general 23 million over taxation over the past 10 years and you
182kept 7 million from the shannel settlement guys all should most of you should go thank you Sandy cats Lower Providence instead of blaming inclusion for Rising special education costs we should look at current practices that contribute to these expenses I appreciate those of you that are asking to see more detail factors such as increasing identification rates the rising cost of specialized Services Staffing shortages out of District placements compliance with evolving regulations and legal fees associated with disputes all play a significant role inclusion is a mindset that ensures all students have access to a meaningful education not a cost driver in fact inclusion is every child's right they shouldn't have to earn the right to be in a general education classroom it is their least restrictive environment as required by law the focus should be on
183evaluating funding structures improving efficiency and ensuring schools have the necessary resources to support all students effectively this includes investing in training and support for educators to appropriately differentiate instruction so all students regardless of ability can access and engage with the curriculum in meaningful ways I kindly thank you for all your work thank you any other people for Courtesy of the floor seeing none may I have a motion to adjourn the meeting Miss graph do have a second Miss Shonda meeting is adjourn thank you