CorpusRecord 71642

NPSD School Board Policy Committee Meeting 1-27-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / NPTV
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Montgomery County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,511 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right our webinar is live we are recording and we are Live on YouTube Mr rash the meeting is yours the policy meeting is now in session please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all can I have a motion to approve the minutes from the last policy meeting I moved uh I second any comments or discussions no seeing none all those in favor say I I items recommended for work session Action meeting uh policies 1 05 organizations policy 202 eligible of nonresident students policy 254 educational opportunities for motary children policy 308 employment contract board resolution and we're going to repeal policies 103A discrimination harassment affecting

002students and policy 104a discrimination harassment affecting staff uh please would you would you like to take over Dr wers sure good evening everyone um as Mr Rush kind of just read through the first four policies that are before you tonight just have some recommended changes from psba that's policy 005 policy 202 policy 254 and policy 308 and then policies 103A and 104a um are on and will be recommended for suspension so Mr Summers would you please highlight the policies before us yes thank you Dr Waters and hello everyone um so I'll talk about the the policy revisions uh kind of first and then um we can certainly talk about the suspensions uh as they relate to policies 103A and 104a um so in terms of of sort of standard revisions um and these are all

003based on recommended revisions that the Pennsylvania School boards Association uh has sent to all of its member districts um they've been reviewed internally by the administration uh as well as with legal council and uh being recommended for the board so the first policy 005 organization um there's a couple of changes to to that policy uh that have been psba has been making to all of their policies which is just language updates we talk about when we look at some of these revisions that there's just terminology that psba recommends adjusting over time based on um you know whether it be updated uh practices or changes in school codes so one of the changes that's made to 005 is just changing from references the board members to school directors and that's something that psba has been doing

004for a number of years um it's more uh accurate in terms of the school code language that's used um so it doesn't have really any substantive effect it's more just a terminology ensuring consistent language throughout policies so there's some changes from from board members to school directors in that policy um the really more substantive change in the policy itself is a change um to Schoolboard officers so um the policy as it currently uh reads says that officers serve simply at the pleasure of the board um and really what we're talking about is primarily presid president vice president Treasurer and Secretary of the board um the recommendation from psba is to revise our policy to say that those officers can still be removed but only after notice is given to them and an opportunity for a

005hearing before the board um the reason for this is that there has been some litigation throughout the country involving um School boards in particular and officers of those boards and the circumstances under which those officers can be removed from their positions um and there have been some cases involving um Schoolboard officers who made certain controversial statements or comments and efforts by other board members um to remove them from office and whether that deprives them of a a their civil rights um and whether there should be an entitlement to at least some level of due process before removing an officer so that's really this does is it says that before an officer would be removed from their position the board as a whole would offer them due process would give them notice of the fact that

006the board intends uh to recommend that they be removed and then a hearing uh before the board to contest whatever the reason uh why you know that that's being recommended so um it's certainly not something that uh I'm aware of ever having um happened in North pen um it's not something that would be common but um it is important you know that the policies address what to do in that circumstance so um adding that you know extra level of of fairness to our our policies I think makes good sense um the next policy is is 202 eligibility of non-resident students so this policy is really about um students who uh maybe reside in the district at one point and then move to a neighboring School District um or are in a neighboring school district and

007seek to move into the district whether they are entitled uh to an education in North pen and and how that um works so as a general rule if you live in the district you're entitled to come to school in the district um but if you live outside of the school district generally your your right to attend school is in the school where you reside um so this is a policy that that's been in place um for a number of years the revision to it are design are again from the school boards Association recommended and they're designed uh to comply with some recent legislation that was passed um at the state level which was designed to ensure that students who are attending district schools uh were enrolled at one point are not disenrolled from the district

008without again a certain level of due process and fairness um so the most significant language that's added says that students um may only be disenrolled from the district after for uh you know non-residency because they're living in another school district um only after they are afforded due process um again notice uh of the fact that the district believes that they are not actually living in the school district um an opportunity for a hearing and then a right to appeal uh that decision so that's actually a process that that the district would have provided um even previously but now it's it's more formalized by adding it specifically to the policy saying that that we will follow that process um you know for any students um with just like any district there certainly are circumstances where students

009um who maybe don't live in North pen or are you know seeking to attend North pen schools um it's not as common of a problem as it might be in in some other school districts in the county or or in the state um but it's something that that certainly District you know has deals with and has policies and procedures and this is just ensuring that they completely follow um state law um the next uh policy 254 educational opportunity for military children um is a revision to the policy uh to ensure that the definition of children of military families includes members of the National Guard or the reserve um who may be required to move in order to perform their service so um this is a policy that that the district has had in place to

010help um students of military families um be able to enroll without um too much difficulty you know students from military families oftentimes have to move and transfer schools more frequently than other students so it's designed to ensure that those students do not lose out um Miss uh time that they should be in school um you know receiving their education so it allows for certain things like um uh students of military families who maybe are in another school district either in the state or out of state and if their parent receives an order from the military that they're going to be transferred they can actually um provide us that order and we can start working on um their enrollment process so that they're able to start school right away without necessarily having to get all the

011documentation um that other students might have to uh who move into the district um so it's it's it's an expansion of that policy to ensure that it covers more um students from military families and then the last revision um is policy 308 Employment contract board resolution um again recommended updates from psba primarily um talking about resignations from employment so um the policy uh uh is proposed to have some additional language indicating that employees who no longer wish to work for the district do need to submit resignations from their positions um it calls for our professional staff and our administrators to provide 60 days notice um when they are resigning other staff um you know appropriate notice um and then maybe most significantly it authorizes the superintendent to accept resignations on behalf of the the board

012um and so the benefit of of providing that is um once then an employee provides their resignation if the superintendent accepts it it allows the district to move forward with starting to take steps um through Dr Kim's office to fill that position such as posting it certainly the the new hire would need to come back before the board um but it at least lets that process um get started a little sooner than if um needing to wait for a board meeting um for for an acceptance of a resignation uh to come before you they still will be come before you for ratification but it it allows the superintendent to um create a binding resignation by accepting on behalf of the board when an employee resigns from their role um so um before we talk about

013103A and 104a any questions or comments feedback on um those policy revisions I have none I have not heard any of any need that is necessary thank you and this is could be I I have not need thank you sure you're welcome all good okay um so we talked actually in terms of policy 103A and 104a uh and just as a reminder um those are the policies that discuss um The District's position on non-discrimination and and harassment and prohibits discrimination uh as far as policy 103 against students participating in any program or activity of the district and policy 104 prohibits discrimination uh affecting staff or other employees of the district so um this policy was mentioned at the uh voting meeting last week and we said that that it would be brought before the the

014policy committee for further discussion so the recommendation before you is to indefinitely suspend policies 103A and 104a um if uh and for that recommendation to um go before the work session at the next uh work session meeting of the board um part of the reason for recommending a suspension is that when the board suspends a policy it is no longer in effect immediately so as as we know when we repeal a policy um just like for the adoption there's a a multiple readings that take place so generally we put we give notice of the intent to repeal a policy and then at the subsequent meeting uh the policy is actually voted on for repeal here the recommendation is to suspend these two policies um so that effective immediately U they would not be implemented um

015but it's also recommended for suspension um because there's a a lot of um rapidly changing developments in this area of the law and so suspending those policies does allow the board if necessary to come back later and make adjustments to 103A and 104a uh and and reenact them by lifting the suspension without again having to go through a multile read process um certainly if um you know there there is no long it doesn't seem like there's going to be a need for those policies in the future the board could take action to repeal them um but that's a longer process and um we just uh want to see if um if there are any changes uh that may be recommended I I wouldn't be surprised if psba itself will be coming out with revisions to

016these policies that they're recommending um so I think suspension at this point um makes sense so the reason for recommended suspension of the two policies is because these two policies were adopted earlier in the fall um largely in response to new title 9 regulations so Title 9 is a federal law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex it's been a law that's been in existence since the 1970s um and it's a federal statute so it was a law that was passed by Congress um over the years there have been regulations that have been put in place by uh the US Department of Education under Title 9 that basically give details to school entities about how to carry out their responsibilities under Title 9 UM most significantly in 2020 there were regulations that were issued

017that really led the board um to adopt policies 103 and 104 um in in the form in which they currently exist and then there were new regulations issued in 2024 um and in response to that the board adopted policies 103A and 104a those regulations that were adopted in 2024 as a result of a court decision that was issued earlier this month have been vacated or essentially thrown out um so schools are no longer um expected to comply with the procedures and requirements of the 2024 regulations um we were following the 2020 regulations um at three of our schools North pen High School uh Penfield middle school and Culp Elementary um because of a court order that had essentially required us at those schools to continue implementing policies 103 and 104 as opposed to 103A and

018104a um so nothing at all changes in those uh settings that they would continue to be guided by policy 103 and 104 in their attachments um other schools that had maybe um moved recently to policies 103A and 104a would just shift back to following the 2020 regulations uh 103 and 104 um as was mentioned uh at the board meeting the other night the changes to these policies are are are largely not um revisions that would be felt by our students in terms or staff in terms of their experience um the district has applied uh policies 103 and 104 for a number of years to prohibit discrimination in all forms uh regardless of what uh you know certain regulations may have indicated um students are protected by a variety of laws Title 9 is is just

019one of those laws there's also other federal laws state laws uh Court decisions that come into play so um really the the impact of this change in policy is largely in the event that the district has a complaint received under let's say Title 9 UM there certain procedures that need to be followed and the 2020 procedures differ in some a number of ways from the 2024 uh procedures and so um things like uh who serves in certain roles to invest investigate or make a decision about whether uh sexual harassment has occurred um certain training requirements um again um things that that your average student or staff member would not experience any different um so that's that's the re but we certainly want to make sure that when we do have these Title 9 uh concerns

020that are raised that we're following the applicable law and at this time um there's no question that the applicable Reg regulations or the 2020 regulations so um for that reason it's it's recommended that at the next um meeting of the board uh which would be the work session that these two policies 103A and 104a um be suspended any oh sorry are there any questions from the board of student reps I think Dr Bower yeah thank you Mr Summers a quick question just you had said effective immediately and you don't mean immediately tonight you mean immediately at a full committee meeting at which we take action correct correct it it would be a full meeting of the board which would be um the next such meeting would be the work session um the the policy Committee

021just like any other committee can only make recommendations um formal policies of the board can only be suspended or otherwise Changed by a majority of the full board and that that would be February if anybody's interested um I I have one question uh when since we've never done a suspension before and I understand your reasons for doing a suspension do we have to make a motion for the suspension yeah so um we you're right I I don't I can't recall actually I do recall uh suspending a a policy during covid um specifically there were certain board procedures that were suspended in terms of um attendance at meeting in meetings in person so we have done it before um and yes there would be placed on the uh agenda as a a motion to suspend the

022policies um and then requiring a second discussion and then a vote just like a um any other action of the board um generally a policy that is suspended by the board is suspended until the next meeting of the board um which is why for those of you who remember during Co we actually voted to suspend policy at the start of every meeting um it is recommended that when we suspend these two policies that it be indefinitely um so that the suspension would continue on until further action of the board the board wouldn't need to to vote every meeting to suspend them thank you are there any other questions from uh from the board or from the student rep I I do have a clarification question if I may Mr rash sure yeah so what I

023understand is that suspending these two policies is in fact the most rapid way to unwind our legal obligations correct yes I agree okay excellent um and also wanted to clarify that for those that we care about which is our students their experience with regards to discrimination um will not be any different their experience with regards to us and the administration responding to to discriminations or may maybe I should say to allegations of discrimination would not be any different than we have done yesterday I would agree with that okay and that's and that's because uh this discrimination is covered by a wide range of laws and uh practices that aren't going away uh and in fact as Chris Christian Fusco said at the Action meeting this is more reporting requirement uh more than anything else is

024that a correct statement yeah I I think Dr Bower may have even said um it's more of a a paperwork uh uh procedure issue that that for those administrators Who oversee Title 9 um they will be the ones who will Who will need to make you know some adjustments in our process but the students and staff and community members who participate in the district's programs and activities um should notice no difference in terms of the district's prohibition against any form of discrimination I didn't mean to cut you off Ki no no no my my questions have been answered thank you what what is most important to me is what our students and staff experience and that has been answered so I appreciate that and I just I just wanted to reinforce what you said because

025I agree 100% with what you said thank you um I recommend the following policies for first read policies 005 policy 202 policy 254 policy 308 do I have a motion to approve policy the the following policies moved I have a second second um um one second uh do I have any questions no seeing none can I have a vote to approve the policies I I I do I have a motion to suspend policies 103A and 104a so moved do I have a second second uh any questions or comments seeing none can I have a vote to uh suspend policies 103A and 104a I are there any informational items for discussion seeing none does the student rep have anything for the committee no student report today does anyone from the community wish to speak yes we

026do have one hand up in our audience tonight individuals attending this meeting virtually and intending to speak to the committee should be aware that they are being recorded in order to meet the requirements of Pennsylvania Sunshine Law it is necessary to record the names of all citizens who speak to the committee during the meeting to assure compliance with the requirement it is essential that those planning to address the committee raise their hand electronically and state their nameing municipality as a reminder the public comment portion of the meeting is designed for residents and taxpayers of the district to provide comment and feedback on matters being discussed at tonight's meetings or matters that may come before the policy committee it is not designed for debate or discussions with members of the committee one appropriate committee members May

027choose to respond to public comments that have been made or request that a member of the administration follow up with the speaker after the meeting to allow time for all those who wish to speak to the committee the chairperson may ask an individual to yield the microphone to the next speaker thank you alrighty up first here is uh Jason laner Jason I've enabled your microphone so you're ready to begin please state your name and minp pality for the record and begin your comments please uh Jason lir Lansdale um two well two questions one is sort of procedural uh you guys just voted to suspend uh 103A 104a that didn't actually happen you're just moving it to the work session or Action meeting because you guys aren't of you're not allowed to suspend any or do

028take any action without the entire board is my understanding speaking which the board president is supposed to be on all these meetings every meeting because the board president is the one who and and the superintendent are the ones that decide what they going to be on the action and the work uh agendas uh so you might want to clarify what you guys just took a vote on second thing is um so there's going to be no change now that you've you're going to be suspending 103A and 104a so does that mean that men are not going to be allowed into girls locker rooms or they weren't before now they they aren't either or what does that mean what does that mean because if it doesn't make any difference then why'd you even pass it in

029the first place so I mean I think I think you're you're you're playing a little bit fast and loose with the uh the definitions of things uh so you only want to you clarify that whether or not that that's possible to happen uh and in on the same vein if you're suspending policies why AR you suspending 28 218 or at least revamping it and uh uh 832 two Equity so student discipline is 218 uh 832 is equity both of these things have been been uh been outlawed as well they're no longer to be Advanced and and you guys are advancing them in which case the you also need to revamp your Employment Practices where you one of the the the requisite abilities is the for is to support of uh a culture of diversity Equity

030inclusion again not allowed we're not doing we you're not to be doing non-mar hires so what do you know you got to you got to take the whole thing you can't just uh you know go with the easy one that psba uh gave you laay up on um also when this this uh also pertains to um uh professional development I I looked at the the last few contracts you had you spent a lot of money on professional development any of this involving uh or or diversity equ inclusion or any of those other things that you're not really supposed to be dealing with in school it's not it's not really educational related it's more politically related so those all need to change as well and I want to know when these other policies will get suspended

031when you'll be uh updating your hiring process and um and changing your your professional development if you could answer those I'd appreciate it thank you Dr bow wish to speak yeah I'd be happy to Mr rash um thank you for your engagement always Mr lanir and perhaps you weren't uh got distracted at some point because that question you asked about what action was this committee taking I asked that exact same question to Mr Summers which he clarified so the committee structure is one such that they make recommendations to the full board and then the full board takes action at a work session or an action meeting or any uh Quorum of the board at which it is advertised that we can take action um so I you're right I asked the exact same question and

032Mr Summers did clarify next uh Mr lanir mentioned that the board president must be president at all committee meetings that is inaccurate uh that said M MCM merry is um joining us live and in the zoom call um so she has been engaged throughout the meeting she's not a panelist but it would be as though she is in the audience um at a committee meeting at the ESC so just because Ms MCM Mery is not a panelist does not mean she can't watch these meetings as an observer and then ultimately set the agenda for our Action meeting regarding some of the other assertions I don't know if Mr Summers wants to comment but I think Mr Summers you did a great job of um explaining why a certain uh legal precedence was vacated and while

033we were taking this action I am not aware of any other legal precedents being vacated regarding some of the other issues uh that Mr lanir brought forward um but if you want to add something feel free if not no worries no I I I agree I don't think that there is any um requirement at this time for the the two other policies that were reference 218 and 832 um no uh federal court rulings or or even executive actions have been taken uh that would require any any change to the district's um policies um there's a reference to non-meritorious hires and the only thing I would say in response to that is the district does uh engage in meritorious hiring that there is no uh non-meritorious hiring uh process in place yeah Mr I would Echo

034that I've been a part of hundreds if not a thousand hires in the school district and never once uh have I seen us bring forward a candidate who is not uh the most qualified candidate um certainly you have an applicant pool and you bring folks in based upon their applications but then there's a process right and there are interviews and there are committees and panelists who make recommendations to the superintendent ultimately the superintendent makes a recommendation to the board the board votes upon that recommendation um understanding that a a piece of paper a resume or an application is part of that process right it gets you in the door and then you interview folks and then you ultimately hire um who you believe to be the best fit for the job and what you need

035Within in your school district or your organization so uh you're correct um and I appreciate your comments Mr Summers and I would say as a board member that we we know that North pen is a big school district and we have to hire the best I was told by Dr Dietrich that was the policy of the school board I know the school board itself believes that we hire the best applicant because we want the best for our students thank you uh is there any other business before the board seeing none summary items for work session we're going to suspend policies 103A and 104a and we're moving policies 254 308 and 005 uh for first read the next next meeting is February 24th can I have a motion to aurn so moved thank you have a

036good night everybody thank everyone have a good night good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.