CorpusRecord 71646

NPSD School Board Finance Committee Meeting 1-7-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / NPTV
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Montgomery County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,283 words · about 74 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good evening everyone welcome to this night um this evening's finance committee meeting we'll start by calling this meeting to order and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance IED alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all okay thank you all so much for coming and for joining this evening we'll start by um approving our minutes from the December 2nd finance committee meeting do I have a motion and a second so Move Motion by Mr Fusco second by Mr McBain all in favor any opposed motion carries okay items that will be recommended for work session or action and I'm going to turn it over to Mr scroy hey good evening everyone thank you Mrs

002romage also congratulations to you this is your first meeting as chair of the finance committee so welcome um we do have quite a lengthy agenda tonight what our plan is we're going to kind of move around the agenda a little bit we're going to cover a presentation information items we have items recommended for work session or action we are going to save the high school financing structure and the parameters of resolution to the very end those two items so we're going to try to cover everything else and hit those two items last so let's just start first with a presentation we have the 2526 extended school care program tuition rates and Camp fees and Dr aurn is going to do that presentation and we are recommending the rates for the uh 25 26 year in

003terms of tuition and the camp rates to be placed on the January 23rd Action meeting agenda so Dr oburn welcome welcome thank you for having me pleasure to be here and share with you some information regarding our extended school care program as well as our recommendation for our rates for the upcoming school year want to ADV answer for me okay so um basic some information about our extended school care program we do operate in all 13 of our elementary schools we are licensed by the Department of Human Services and the office of Child Development and early learning also known as ell and up there we have the code if anybody's interested in doing some little research and following code and reading about the code that we have to follow it is there um so we

004offer Child Care from two to five days a week for before school and after school care um we also offer families they could do both they can sign up for inservice days and they can also serve up sign up for full day inservice daycare so that's when there's no school um but we do offer Child Care at one of our elementary schools and then we also provide par parents the opportunity to sign up for additional days so something may happen um parents need to stay late for work next week or their work schedule got changed we do give them the opportunity to purchase additional um days if need be so um our child care requirements we are required by the state to follow certain ratios which as if you look right up here you'll see

005the staff to student ratio for every one staff person um there for every 12 students I'm sorry there needs to be one staff person for kids in kindergarten through through third grade when we get to the fourth through sixth grade group it jumps to 15 to1 if we add a third grader into that fourth and uh fourth through sixth grade um grouping it does drop down to the 12:1 ratio um so we have to have two staff present at any time we have children in care um they must be present at all times for opening and closing and we also cannot have any more than 50% of our staff be of Aid quality qualification so that's like the lowest qualification of any of our staff for every 45 children in our program at each location

006we need to have one group supervisor who oversees the planning for those students and if the school exceeds 45 students then there needs to be a site director who's not enrolled in the ratio um included in the ratio for the staffing so all of our staff are required to have trainings that take place every year there's fire safety um 12 hours professional development on various topics that are required by the state and then if there's a new employee they must have a 10-hour training on basic items like Child Abuse Prevention mandated reporter pediatric first aid and CPR and that all must be done within the first 90 days of their hire and then every two years after that they need to have CPR and first aid training and then the final thing that we do

007with all of our staff EV um in addition to all those trainings annually and every two years is a five-year they part-time staff in addition to that we have 14 substitutes who fill in when we are have staff who call out or are unable to work on a specific day we do continue to advertise and interview and continue to hire uh staff for our program because we want to make sure that we don't have a very large weight list for our families we want to make it reasonable for them to be able to get in um and not wait and never end up getting child care or having to go somewhere else to find that care we also are involved in the Keystone Stars program um many of our sites are on the the move

008to Star to which then will give us additional funding um and there's some benefits from being in the Stars program there's grant opportunities for various things throughout the year um they provide free professional development at times and then for our families who receive subsidy we get an add-on for those students as we move up the Stars tier so um we start off the school year with 753 students in our program as of January 1st or January 2nd we have 771 students in our program we do continue to have 53 students on our wait list and they are at at specific school so for an example at Oak Park we have a large group of Staff who are looking to get enrolled in just the morning part of the program but we haven't been able to

009hire a staff person who could only is available for that that that two-hour block each day um so we still continue to work on that um our elrc we've now accept um subsidy from four different counties for our students so students who are moving into the north pen area that may have come from Bucks County Burks County or Philadelphia they still receive their their County funding and it's sent to us through them in 2022 we had 42 students who were receiving subsidy from our schools I mean from this County um that's an area of interest of mine I want families who um need the assistance to be able to send their kids to care at an affordable cost to them and that's what this program does for them in the 23 24 school year we

010increased um our number to 68 students which was a 62% increase over the previous year and this year we now have um 85 students who are receiving subsidy from the counties um which is another 25% increase and we continue to refer families to here even if they're already in our program you can continue so we uh the market survey Trend um we did do that it's a little it's um a lot of a lot of a lot of areas don't have or schools or Child Care programs haven't established their rates yet usually the the target time is February but I was able to gain some rates um so the average cost of care for 2425 um around the area for this this current year is $555 a month Which is 7.25% higher than ours our

011our cost of care per month um they charge families anywhere from $80 to $100 registration fee and then they also charge extra fees on inservice days holidays and full day care just like we do when I looked at the surrounding Center so that's child care centers in the area the average cost of care for those child care centers that offer before and after school care for families is $79.38 um it's 53% higher than what we charge here at North North pen they do charge family registration fees of $150 to $200 and then again they also charge extra fees on early dismissal days inservice days and holidays so I also looked at again our cost of living um looking at the 20 2023 2024 cost of um living increases consumer prices went up about 2.7% from

012last November food went up 2.4% and energy continues to go down um 3 .2% but all items less than food and energy are up 3.3% and that information came from our consumer prices um and if you're interested at the presentation you can click on and get that that information on that link um the average cost of school care is $320 per week so that's that's up 133% and that's a weekly rate for those families for most of them um again you can click on that link to get the source and so um this past school year we increased our fees 5% for this school year and if you want to click on it so um when we look at our fund balance you can see there's just over $400,000 in our fund balance and then

013our profit we are on the right hand side you can see that our profit is at six uh almost $65,000 for this year um and that is after paying back the school district some of the the money that is owed to the the general fund from Co days yeah if I could just make a comment on that you might recall back in 2021 during the pandemic uh the general fund had to throw a Lifeline to the Extended Care Program Extended Care Program is an Enterprise fund it's funded by tuition it's not funded by tax dollars but in this case we were required by law to continue continuing to pay the employees yet there is no Revenue coming in for the program so the general fund contributed $1.5 million back in 2020 to the Enterprise fund

014for the Extended Care Program so six payments have been made at this point in time to pay back the general fund totaling one .1 million so there's a $400,000 balance still remaining our plan is to have another2 200,000 this fiscal year and the remaining $200,000 next fiscal year so I think the success of the program in the last couple years in particular has allowed that acceleration of the payback to the general fund so I think by the end of the 25 26 year the Extended Care Program will be squared away with the general fund that is the plan so if you want to advance to our next screen So based on that information that we have um I um have some recommendations for the extended school care program I believe that we will continue to

015apply for Grant um programs through the elrc which is the Early Learning Resource Center um that's that stars program that I had discussed earlier um and then I also recommend for us to approve the established Extended Care rate program fees there is an increase of 4.2% on those fees as well as our summer camp fees if you um look at those two items and um again this summer we're going to continue to offer parents more flexibility with summer camp we saw a a nice rise in our enrollment this past year in summer camp we offered it at two locations we offered it at Bridal path and Gwen no we had over 200 children in our program um which was up from the 45 we had the previous year um of those students we gave them

016the option right there of attending five days three days or two days it was not a flat rate they were able to come for before school care and after school if they needed or just the portion that they needed so they were able to you know look at what their family's needs were and place their students in the program during that time and then finally there's our school rates um our school age rates for next year which also reflect a 4.2% increase and I believe that's all I have for you any questions couple questions um uh first I I just want to comment on the the e RC piece I think if can you go back to that slide just so that people can see what we're referring to there um I think when people

017often ask us what do we mean by Equity or or who does that help um this is that example of something concrete that you can point to in changing something in a system or removing a barrier for families and this helps any family that can qualify or need support financially and the fact that we've increased the number of students really doubled from 42 students in 22 23 to now 85 students that are able to qualify and access that and you're able to remove that barrier for their families correct um I really I appreciate that I think for Working Families single parents um you know who are trying to make ends meet and have access to these subsidies um the fact that we are uring that we can offer them I really appreciate the effort on

018the Department's behalf to um to offer that to families um and then the other thing that I also wanted to point to was um the 45 student the increase in the um summer camp I think is huge and I mean we are a very large District I always found it odd that we only had like 40 we we could only offer like you know one site out of 13 elementary schools for child care during the summer so I hope to continue to see that program expand if we can do it with Staffing um you know I was very excited to see us go from 45 to 200 students um I I'd like to see that program continue to expand and I think offering the flexibility to families is huge because you might not be able

019to afford 5 days a week but you might be able to afford two days a week for your kids to go out and get some social interaction and see their friends and play for the day or something like that and one of things we did see this this summer was that some of the families were really excited to see that flexibility because they didn't need the child care for say Child Care purposes it was somewhere for them to get their child to be away from gaming or just sitting at home so there are families who signed their kids up just to come like two days to go on field trips or you know a social day and a field trip day so it worked really well for them so just thank you Dr oburn for

020your leadership in pushing those areas um of equity um in your department I I appreciate your leadership thank you thank you I want have a follow-up question and it's also connected to um elrc um like Dr G raised you mentioned subsidy and Grant so the subsidy is a support that individual families can apply for correct and for the sake of the community because that is such a valuable program can you talk a little bit about the application process and are there ways in which we as a board could support and promote that as a resource for our family and then could you speak a little bit to the grant sure so um for enrollment for families to enroll in the program we actually have a link to that on our website and it's also actually

021included on part of our admissions process paperwork so that families could click on that link and and get information there is um a income threshold that tells parents whether or not they would qualify based on that information and then once once they apply then of course they either get approved or denied based on additional um Avenues of Revenue the family may have whether it's child support or if it's um you know different CA different means of funding that the family has through other agencies um so once they are approved then the um County actually pays us a portion of their child care so a family may have as little as a $5 co-pay per month um students who are in foster care or um fall within the homelessness um under mcken vento those students um

022are are often eligible for free child care through Montgomery County so they they don't they pay a zero co-pay and then the county pays us the difference um when we're talking about grants grants is money that comes directly to our Child Care Program it's something we apply for so they may say um we have grants available for professional development for staff and so then there are some criteria what they might be looking for it might be stem training it might be um you know uh English language for English language Learners there's various are for Grants so when you when you have that if you meet the criteria then you can apply for those grants that's great and thank you for diversifying the funding revenues and and the sources and the and and pulling that in

023so thank you very much for that and as a former I say this every year when you give the presentation as a former par working parent that utilize those Services when our children were in elementary school um I'm forever grateful so thank you okay any other questions yeah I think I have one but I was very very very quickly trying to make sure that I'm not wasting your time um by looking at the data I have in front of me so um yes thank you for the for the presentation I think I see now that the 4.25 is reflected in the other PDF that was attached correct and so the the current fee though what's the current fee so right now so for a family let's take the before and after school program at the

024at the um very bottom right hand corner parents um who are enrolled in the before and after school program for five days a week in both before and after they currently pay um $518 a month for that care um and and what we do is actually we break that rate that 518 we we come up with a rate and that it's broken up over nine months rather than the 10 month schools in session so they they don't pay that last month it's kind of like they pay September through May so it's it's 10 months of child care over a 9month payment plan mhm okay I was trying to draw Apples to Apples to the uh 555 that you had mentioned in the so that's what other people in our neighboring so like at at at

025um other community school districts yeah that's what they're paying is so it's 518 versus 555 right yeah some of them are paying more than $555 and some of them are paying like 521 average okay yeah so I I understand that and then um is part of it's a leading question let me see if I can rephrase that um is there going to be an additional Focus therefore on ensuring that we have the appropriate resources given the increase in fee to help manage um the number of students yes so um some of the the resources that we we've requested are actually helping us to get additional Staffing in because we're required to have higher qualified staff once our numbers go up so again as we broke that 45 threshold some of those schools are requiring us

026to have additional group supervisors rather than just um an assistant group supervisor excellent and one final thing I just wanted to note so like when I gave you the rate of 555 is the average that's the average for this school year it is not next school year because they don't have their rates for next year so I just wanted to make sure that I was being a little clear on that right no that's helpful thank you thank you so Dr aurn will be back in May to do a full budget presentation tonight we're asking for placement on the January Action meeting for the tuition and Camp rates and the reason why we do this so early that allows the Extended Care Program staff to start advertising and publicizing what the rates are for the upcoming

027year because believe it or not it is time to start planning for summer so and for the next school year so thank you very much for that so do I have a motion and a second to approve the item so moved second um motion by U Mrs sto second by uh Mrs rednick all in favor I any opposed motion carries thank you and have a great rest of your meeting thank you very much all right moving on the next item being recommended for Action meeting on January 23 are the budget transfers for December there weren't too many this month actually $678,500 and these are very routine in nature to adjust for changes in spending by departments and to ensure that the proper budgetary account code is charged so again we're asking for placement on the

02823rd's Action meeting agenda please okay do I have a motion second second okay motion by Mrs McMurry second by Mr Fusco any comments or questions all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries thank you moving on to item C we have an audit and insurance broker RFP uh as you know our professional services policy calls for certain Professional Services to be put out for requests for proposals every so many years so both our auditing service we had a 5-year contract there that ended and it's also time to do an insurance broker request for proposal so per that Professional Services policy that we're very proud of we're asking for placement for these two items on the January 23rd Action meeting please okay do I have a motion so moved motion by Mrs stole

029second second second by Mr McBain any comments or questions seeing none all those in favor say I I any opposed motion carries all right thank you moving on to item d movie lot agreement uh agreement of sale amendment number two as you know the school district is under contract with P to sell the movie lots and pte has approached the district to request another extension on the due diligence period we had one that was approved back in November they're asking for another one so just to give a quick timeline the original agreement was approved with PO on September 19th and that provided for 165 day due diligence period that would have taken it to December the 18th um I'm sorry the original the original contract had a 90-day due diligence period that took it to

030December 18th there was one Amendment amendment number one that was approved by the board that extended the due diligence period by 45 days uh this agreement amendment is asking for another 30 so it would be a total of 165 day due diligence period from the initial September 19th contract and the reason p um is asking for another extension to the due diligence period they are working with the township now because they own attractive land that's adjacent to the movie lot so initially they were working with the township on one development for one half the track that they previously owned now that the movie lots are in the equation they're kind of looking at the development as an entirety not two separate developments but one development and that's required further conversation with Hatfield Township as a

031result of that they are asking for another 30-day extension to the due diligence period that would take us out to March the 3 if the board would be so inclined to improve this also want to make mention that we do have a court hearing scheduled for the sale of the movie Lots on January 27th that's at 1M in front of Judge saltz the court room 13 you're invited to attend that if you'd like um I kind of view that maybe I'm minimizing it but I kind of view it as perun in nature we simply need to establish at that point in time that the sales price is of market value or greater and the sales price for the movie Lots is well in excess of the two appraisals that we receed so I really don't

032see many problems or issues with the court proceeding but that is something that is required by code to go through as a result of selling the land uh so we would like to recommend you know we're interested in in closing this deal at some point with pte so if they need more time to discuss their development with half field Township we support that we want to have a a positive relationship and we want to make sure pte has an agreement uh with with the township through Land Development and so forth that that can be supported by the township so we're we are asking for the board to approve a second amendment to extend that due diligence period another 30 days so again due diligence will be a total of 165 days which would take it

033out to March 3rd 2025 okay do I have a motion and a second to move this item to our next meeting our Action meeting on the 23rd so moved second okay so um motion by Mrs Soul second by Mr fosco any comments or questions go ahead go ahead quick question do we do we expect them to come back for another um extension or it's hard to say at this point uh it really depends on they we're not really a party to the conversation that P has with the township regarding what they're envisioning for their land development so we're hopeful that this will be the second and last extension but potentially there could be more just depends on how the conversation goes they want to make sure that the township supportive of the concept that they

034have Dr Bower and I did have a preview and they are looking at now the two tracks as like a One Singular development it allows them having both tracks now allows them a little more flexibility so it's going to look a little different from what it looked like before that's what's just taking a little more time in conversations with the township staff and can they only request 30-day increments it could be long they could request longer but their request was for 30 days so you could view that as positive they've only asked for two extensions each being 30 days that was basically my question but is there a break point where it's just too many extensions like um I don't think we're at that point yet so I wouldn't want to speculate like do we

035envision would June be an end point would July be an end point no I don't mean that I mean like is there a point where we've extended too far like according to the law or anything where it becomes problematic no I don't think there's anything in the law that would prevent further extensions but to your point Mr Fusco like if we come back or if pte comes back and asks for a third a fourth a fifth a six 30-day extension at at what point are we going to say you know that's it we're not doing it anymore we'll look at other Alternatives if you're not able to satisfy the due diligence period we'll look elsewhere I hope we don't get to that point I think we just need to deal with this particular Amendment March

0363rd it seems to be ample time to have conversation Dr Bower and I met with the PO representative back in early December I think it was say maybe even late November something like that November yeah so they they they showed us what they're envisioning I think it's a matter now of of having that conversation with with Township staff to be able to have something that will be supported I think another key point with this is the land is already Zone residential so we're not talking about zoning hurdles or anything like that I think it's really getting the right fit of density I think that's really what the ultimate issue is here that's helpful thank you can I is it reasonable to ask at next month's meeting for an update as to where they are and

037and back to what Mr Fusco said there were other we had other options and I do think that there is a point where we may want to go in a different direction which would be the benefit for the district right so I guess you know what what are your thoughts when we get there yeah I think how many more how many more extensions and you know yeah I I it's really tough to put a magic number on it right now or even a date on it I think a lot depends on the feedback that we're hearing from the township and P but I think it's reasonable to have an update from PO for the February Finance commit committee meeting for sure I think yeah I think that would be great because they did sorry an

038update would great be great yeah and they did CH so when this first was presented there was a certain I guess um model that they had and then along the way they've changed it yes so now we are part of it willing participants happy to be a participant but there is a point where it's like okay you know we need to move so the February Finance meeting which I think is somewhere in like February 10th or 11th will be within 30 days of the expiration of amendment number two so I think it's very reasonable to hear at that point listen are you expecting another amendment or you think we're good with your due diligence period I think it's also important to note the first amendment was really driven by it was a timing issue with

039respect to the environmental analysis with the ability to get on the movie lot because was currently being farmed so Amendment one was driven by environmental timing and the farming Amendment two is because of they're kind of changing up their plan now with the township so we'll report back at the February this will be an item then at the February Finance meeting and I think it would be interesting too because they did have you know it was two separate possible projects now it's one unified project with two owners what does the difference look like and I think just for our our community and for us you know if that if those homes are developed what you know what do we expect to see so that we can have just a little bit of insight so okay

040we do have a motion and a second on the floor if that's it for questions all in favor I any opposed motion carries thank you all right thank you moving on to tax collector compensation so just to set the stage with this we've actually been talking about this for the past couple months so the school district has the ability to change tax collector compensation once every four years that deadline is coming up February I think it's February 13th or 14th of 2025 um so we've prepared a resolution dealing with the tax collector compensation and I mentioned at the last meeting that we would like to have some additional language uh to address issues like reporting or use of software or timeliness of deposits we want to add that as part of the resolution for compensation

041so in conjunction and work with Mr Summers we do have the resolution draft presented before you this evening um a couple key points first off we are not recommending any change with respect to the compensation itself so uh in looking at a countywide analysis the countywide average collection rate is $33.66 per bill that's the average in the county for school districts for school district tax collection our rate right now is $430 so we are already 17 and a half% over the county average So based on that Although our nine elected Tax Collectors do a great job I certainly can in good conscious recommend to the finance committee an increase when we're already 17.5% above the county average and quite frankly a tax bill in North pen requires the same amount of effort to collect than

042it does in Wicken or methacton or potown so it's not like there's a North pen premium because our tax bills are somehow different they're the same as any other school district so we are recommending the same for the entire four years so that's $430 per Bill per regular Bill $6.75 per interim and for a property that's not collected and is turned over for delinquent collection the tax collector would still get a fee of $2 per bill for basically not collecting the bill um and also $2 per installment so no change in the compensation and with our nine collectors we have seven in Montgomery County two in Bucks County or two in Bucks County collectively collect about 75 bills between the two of them okay so they get the same per bill amount but we also

043give them a flat fee in addition just for the startup basically to to run the bills and send out the bills uh new printon Township gets an additional $500 and Hilltown Township $250 flat fee again that is not changing so key elements that are part of this resolution that were not part of previous resolutions include a couple things number one we specifically identify that the tax collector needs to be a qualified tax collector and there's a certification process through the Department of community and economic development for that so that language is in there uh also we have information in here about tax collection software um in the event that this School District elects to go with a a common software for the tax collectors the tax collectors do need to provide access to that software

044I'm kind of envisioning that if we do go this route it would be like a webbased software that the district would have access to um a side note to that the school districts in Montgomery County are looking at the possibility of a countywide Consortium for tax collector software that way those districts that elect to participate would be on the same platform and our issue with the tax collecting software tax collection software is that it would allow us actually to be able to provide more customer service because many times Joanna gets the calls from taxpayers saying hey I lost my bill can you give me a copy of the bill well if we have a copy if we have access to the tax collection software we could provide a copy or we can say what the

045amount is at least we actually have no ability to do that now um so that would provide an enhanced level of customer service instead of saying well you need to call your elected tax collector we could actually help in that regard um it would also allow us access to information in case we have any difficulty reconciling the monthly reports we could run our own reports or unpaid Bill report if we want to reach out to unpaid property owners at the end of the of the year we could do that by running our own unpaid report as opposed to relying on a tax collector report so that's that's a significant uh addition to this particular resolution again it's in the event that the district elects to go that route we're not saying we are but we

046are that's something that is being researched at the county level right now the second item deals with the uh deposit of tax funds we are asking that the tax funds once $10,000 or more has been received by the tax collector they be deposited in the district account unless other arrangements are made um and basically what we're asking for is every tax collector has a check scanner it's called remote deposit capture it's provided by Univest free of charge thank you Univest is really been a tremendous timesaver for all of our tax collectors no longer that they need to run to the bank every day you get a check in you scan a check to the bank and then you have an image that's stored electronically in case you ever need to go back and do research

047it really expedites the whole deposit process uh we really haven't heard any concerns or complaints about remote deposit capture it Sav Tax Collectors a tremendous amount of time so we're putting that as part of the resolution um again we're asking that to money be scanned once that scanning process happens it goes directly into the school district account and we're earning with Univest right now we get the highend of the FED fund rate so we're at 4 and a half% investment income right now okay it goes in immediately so it's not deposited in another account where we have to wait then for it to be transferred to the district account goes right into the district account again unless other arrangements are made with that particular tax collector um item eight on the resolution deals with tax

048collector reports many of these items are are the same not many they're all the same as what was in an earlier resolution that was approved by the board I believe it was oh boy back in March April somewhere around that time frame of 2024 we had a separate resolution dealing with tax collector reports or or might have been in the fall it's a little fuzzy on the exact timeline but it was in 2024 um so these are some of the same reports that we can have access to if we ask the tax collector but again if we have access to web-based software it wouldn't be an issue we can run all these reports on our own so I would say those are the the critical changes uh we do have a section in there about

049payment and reimbursement of expenses to the tax collector we had a section in the previous resolution four years ago about that but this I think clearly identifies specifically the types of supplies that we would reimburse for like the sky is not the limit we're not going to reimburse for Post-it notes or paper clips or pens uh that's outside the scope this identifies specifically what we reimburse for postage uh envelopes the printing of forms things like that we're not going to reimburse for things outside of those um and that's that's basically it I know there are a number of school districts in the county that have already or will be looking to pass a similar resolution prior to February uh 13th Mr Summers has reviewed this Mr Summers cared any any comment from illegal lens on

050this resolution no I think just um that uh the the the idea with the resolution that had been passed previously by the board of requiring uh additional information um that that the district is permitted to ask for um it made sense to combine that with the compensation uh resolution So that obviously the kind of the idea with the compensation resolution and passing it this early is that individuals who are interested in running for tax collector are aware of what their compensation will be when they take that role it makes sense to say not only here's what compensation will be but here are some of the expectations that you would have in that role and and what uh you know in order to to satisfy the the district's ability request information what you'll need to do

051to satisfy that and um putting it all in a single place makes it a little bit easier rather than having different resolutions um and the only other thing is I think that in in discussion with Mr scroy we we're also um careful to make sure that the resolution recognize the roles and responsibilities that the tax collectors have as as has been assigned to them by the legislature and we were careful to ensure that the district is not taking away any responsibilities uh from our tax collectors uh and and really we're just memorializing what their responsibilities are and the ways in which uh the district can request certain information to help uh ensure funds are are adequately monitored and and that the customer uh service needs of our constitu are met um I had a question

052um um Mr scy about the online or about the um taxpayer software tax collector software do you know does it offer like online payment options and like online um getting your bill um I think a lot of people prefer to pay online these days and um pay with a check or whatever and then if I can just access my bill online yeah so that's typically a separate product from the actual software okay um I I know many of our elected Tax Collectors now offer the ability to pay by credit card or electronic funds transfer through like a checking account uh so that's pretty much right now that's tax collector specific okay so that's not necessarily ingrain with the software typically an add-on software or product or webbased system for credit card payments thank you yeah

053question for um the two if if Montgomery County goes to one system then the 150 um customer we have in Bucks County will they will just keep the system they currently have right that's what we're envisioning they they pretty much use their own product now we do have our seven elected tax collectors in Montgomery County using a common software now um and the two elected in Bucks County use their own and we just for it's a total of 75 Parcels between the two not 75 each so for that small number of parcels because I think we have over 40,000 total um we just felt that you know just let them use their own software uh to my knowledge Bucks County is not looking at a countywide software like we are here in Montgomery County so

054we felt that it would be fine for them just to continue to use what they're what they're using yeah okay my second comment is a little bit on the Frugal leaning Frugal um of the payment and reimbursement of expenses to tax collectors if we go to a digital method that eliminates forms and printing of forms and envelopes Etc I'm assuming that we won't be there for reimbursing for those Yeah we actually uh to a large degree don't do that at all now because the school district we contract with an entity we did an RFP and we have a company that basically does the build production the printing and the mailing for us there are times though when the tax collectors will mail out an interim bill it's a partial year supplemental Bill uh produce those

055on their own we don't send them out to because they're they're sporadic you know some months there might be none some there might be 10 um but they're typically not many throughout the course of the year the tax collectors will print those out on their own and they'll mail those out so they would have postage for those uh reminder notices they would have postage for and the envelopes for those but the main bulk of the bills when the 40,000 regular bills go out they have no expense for those because we're doing the printing we're doing the production we're doing the mailing on our end great thank you you're welcome so let's um I we recommend that we're going to um place this on the agenda for February 11th and so let's go ahead and move

056forward with a motion for that and then I know Mrs mcmurrey still has some questions so a motion and a second please second okay motion by Mr mcbaine second by Mr Fusco I'll make it quick go ahead I'll make it quick Mr scroy thanks um has this um document been socialized um circulated with the tax colle tax collectors for our district not yet uh our plan was to presented to the finance committee first okay and one of the reasons why I'm recommending this in February instead of the January 23rd Action meeting is to allow a little more time okay will be shared with the tax collectors and they can react to this okay and if there's any modifications that need to be made we certainly have time between now and the February meeting to do

057so and then we're still within that February 13th deadline of having a resolution pass all right thank you second question regarding number seven which requires a tax collector to deposit make a deposit on that business day should the funds tax collected be 10 at least 10,000 um is are is that being added because of historical issues where it wasn't done um and if that's the case if if um this is a harder question I guess if that continues to be problematic what would then be the plan how would you pivot to try and rectify it if it's just not compliance with this particular item yeah so your first question uh Miss MC Mery our our tax SS do a really good job I I've said that before and I'll say it again so we're we

058thank them for the work they do we I feel we have a good collaborative relationship with them uh we want to work with them I think it's in the best interest of the district that we work together um my objective with this is to try to formalize this a little bit more and standardize this is to maximize our investment income uh because the check that is unscanned sitting with the tax collector goes without interest whether it's a day or whether it's two days and as you know with interest rates even at 4 and a half% even though they're down from the 5 a half% from just a couple months ago I mean the amount of investment income that we can generate for this size School District was over $9 million last fiscal year and this

059is our largest source of cash and revenue and I don't want even if it is just $10,000 I want that invested immediately I don't want it sitting around for two or three or four days when it's batched with maybe 10 other payments I want it in right away to maximize the revenue so it's born from maximization of Revenue not born from oh we have problems with tax tax colors are holding on to payments for for weeks upon weeks thank you well I think it's also something so unique about the north pen Community is that you work with nine tax collectors and so anything to to streamline Services across nine different systems I think is is beneficial for all of us so we do have a motion and a second on the table um all those

060in favor say I I I any opposed motion carries thank you okay we're going to move now on to the informational items all of this is good news nothing requires action here so it's nice to kind of have a good news section of the agenda uh first I want to talk about the meritorious budget award we did receive news within the past month that for the 10th consecutive year North pen is a recipient of the association of school business officials International asbo as it's known of their MBA the meritorious budget award and it's because of our budget book that we've submitted for the 2425 fiscal year which is posted in board dos and as always the the first document I encourage people to read and look at if they want to learn more about North

061Penn School District finances uh so certainly I know we have our representatives from pfm here they'll probably tell Moody's when they consider our rating call hey you want to take a look at that awardwinning budget book that North pen has before you have that call with yes absolutely that's the first thing but you have to mention award-winning okay you can't leave that out 10 straight years so I actually reached out to asbo because we're really proud of 10 straight years we're the only School District in Montgomery County and there's only a couple in the state that actually received this and there's a a prescripted format that has to be follow and it really is labor intensive to be able to produce this so I thought wow there can't be a whole lot of school districts

062throughout the country this is Nationwide well actually asbo is international it's not just the United States but I did reach out to uh asbo and asked him how many other school districts in the nation Nationwide and throughout the entire world have received the MBA the meritorious budget award for 10 years or more and I I got an answer just today actually and I was amazed by the number and the number is 62 school districts have received the MBA for 10 years or more and that does include they mentioned Canada and Alaska or part of that 62 so 62 out of that geographical area that's still something to be really proud of so uh we certainly hope that uh the tradition will continue beyond 10 years and maybe we'll make it 20 years in 25 years

063but we're certainly proud of that and we're glad to have the recognition I think it gives the the school district its budget book and its finances a lot more credibility by having this designation congratulations Steve on that I think we to congratulate you and then please extend our thanks and our GR attitude to the team that supported um the creation of that so absolutely we do um next thing I want to mention is the Pacers rate has been released by The or approved I should say by the Pacers that's the pension fund for Pennsylvania Public School Employees the trustees approved back in December the 2526 retirement rate the rate for the employer share has been certified at 34% so that's up a tick from the current year which is 33.9% so it's less than what

064was originally projected so this is good news as well um the original projection was supposed to come in at 34.723061 [Music] okay but none of us will probably be around to actually see that but I remember back in the day um and some of those in in the room will remember this too pfm and Ronda you'll remember this back in uh the year 2201 the Pacer's employer rate was like 1% so we've gone from 1% to 34% in a mere 25 years I mean that's just it's mind-boggling the millions and millions of dollars that have been added to the school district's budget because of the the pension rate and a lot of this rate is basically playing catchup because the can was kicked down the road in the mid to late 2000s and now we're

065continuing to pay the price I think I have this stat in here over 80% of the pension fund contribution is really to account for the unfunded liability and the unfunded liability in layman's terms is the can was kicked down the road for many many years and now we're playing catchup so 80% of that 34% rate is playing catchup so when you have an opportunity for an increase and you have an increase lower than what it should have been from an Actuarial standpoint at some point you have to pay the piper and we've been for now for a number of years but fortunately those increases have kind of moderated and smoothed out you might recall a couple years ago when we were seeing like spikes and we were seeing three and4 million added to our budget

066in one fiscal year because of a three and four and 5% percentage Point increase in the piecers rate so now this year we have a 10 percentage Point increase in the piecers rate that is good news so in terms of impact to the budget we do get uh half of our expenditure back from the state in the form of a subsidy the increase to our budget which is over $300 million budget is a mere $78,000 that's it so that's really really small so this is definitely really good news Okay questions about that all right the last piece of good news is um the school district qualified for a 5% premium discount again based on our Safety Committee that we have here in the school district we have a certified Safety Committee uh so because we

067met all the requirements of the Safety Committee our insurance company for workers compensation as self-insured um Consortium that we're a member of called sdic School District Insurance Consortium we got that 5% discount that results in a premium discount of $452 64 I do need to publicly thank Mr Dan Linsky uh who chairs that Safety Committee and Kim liser in my office who actually submits the application for this certification so we've received this certification for years upon years so we'll continue to follow that committee U and that certification application each year questions we appreciate that those efforts okay finally before we have our student representative speak I have the item D under information is just the schedule of departmental budget presentations from February to May um so February 18th for example we have school nutrition services

068technology school and Community engagement and Communications we presenting that evening so we have a a smaller group a subset a subcommittee of the finance committee if you will uh that'll be par participating in those and those meetings are all virtual so the first one is February 18th those are special finance committee meetings so anyone is welcome to attend but I think we have three members from the finance committee that are committed to attending all those special finance committee meetings a great way to learn about individual Department budgets that's for sure okay finally we have our student Representatives welcome thanks so much for coming we appreciate it so uh this is your first finance committee meeting and usually what we like to do is ask you know to give updates you can certainly ask any questions

069from items that were on the agenda um provide your viewpoint on some of the things we talked about tonight we are getting into the midst of the budget season so that might be something really interesting because we have a large budget here at North pen 300 over $320 million that's a lot of money that funds your instruction in the classroom so Miranda and Shayla welcome thanks so much for coming tonight any comments you'd like to make or anything you'd like to ask the finance committee okay all right so maybe because this is your first meeting you don't have questions uh Shayla Miranda if you could just you know tell us a little bit about yourself what grade you're in what you're involved in at North pen High School I think that would be a good

070way to just like so you got to turn on your microphone to speak because we can hear you in the room but they can't hear you on television and YouTube so go ahead Miranda thank you um I'm currently a senior here at North pen um I am my class treasurer I've been for past 3 years um I'm currently in Key Club um a lot of extra curcular that's really fun um yeah something I'm really looking forward to this year um coming up we have our winter ball which we don't really plan this year um that was our sophomore year but it was really fun to plan so I'm excited to go without having to do all the extra planning um and also senior prom is also coming up which is so exciting um yeah I

071thought when you said something you're really looking forward to you were going to say all the finance meetings but and all of those it's just because you don't know what you're in for yet okay and Shayla hi I'm Shayla ramik or ramit and I'm a junior at North pin high school and I'm in SGA which allowed me to get here and I'm on the swimming and I was on the polo team when it was happening and then I had to swimming tonight that's it did we win our swim meet I don't know I had to leave early okay understood I'm just going to go out on a limb here and say we won so okay pleased to have you both Mr scroy she did prioritize leaving a swim meat to come here to make it

072here on time I really appreciate that I thought that you would appreciate that I do just want to acknowledge that there's the same last name and unbeknownst to me Shayla attended a Shayla is my daughter Shayla attended an SGA meeting I'm going to embarrass her um where they called for volunteers she volunteered and told me after the fact that she had done it and that she had been assigned to a meeting and I said please any but the one that I'm facilitating please anything but facilities I mean um about finance and it was Finance so um but anyway I I think some good homework also too just to um you know to make to please Mr scroy would be to review the budget book yourselves too and share with us your favorite part of it

073excuse me it is award winning award winning 10 years running award winning um and and provide us your highlight as your update at the next meeting so thank you uh hot off hot off the press uh the north pen Knights won 96 to 82 against CB West bucks so great job so I do have a question for you okay are either of you interested in a career in school business no you can say no how about how about legal career or a Public Finance career Mr scy sometimes no response is a response okay I tried I tried there is such a lack social media influencer right yeah just so you know there's such a lack of school business officials like people in my position that if you had an interest in that you could write

074your own ticket after college just saying okay but thanks again for coming tonight all right so we're g to jump back now to um other items that are being recommended for Action we're going to talk about first with the high school financing structure we're going to be talking about our first borrowing potential borrowing for the high school project and then we're going to segue then into a discussion about a parameters resolution so we have representatives from pfm here tonight as well as our bond Council so I'm going to ask Mr Willard to come to the podium I just want to give a little background before I turn it over to Mr Willard um so we are looking at basically find financing the funds needed for the high school project it's really phase one of the

075high school project we've broken the estimated high school project value is 260 million we've broken in into two phases phase one now is being bid right now the bids are out in fact we had a pre-bid meeting with contractors earlier this afternoon a great result by the way we're very pleased with the number of contractors that were there because you know when When contractors see a lot of interest they see a lot of colleagues and competition in the room this magic happens the tendency to sharpen the pencils when they know there's multiple other players like for example if you see a general contractor and there's only one other general contractor there the pre-bid meeting is kind of like wink wink you know what we can make the price a little bit higher because there's not

076much competition but to the contrary today there was a lot of interest in this project so phase one the project estimate is $29 million for phase one these bids will be opened up on January 30th and then a recommendation will be made in February for the board to issue what's called a notice to proceed and then ultimately the awarding of the bids however for 20125 we have what's called a draw schedule that's basically how much that $29 million estimate when do we expect to pay that money because you're not going to pay it all at once uh the the contracts and the estimated time of completion will will basically start in May of 2025 and run through summer of 2026 so you won't spend the entire $29 million in in the year 2025 the estimate

077per the draw schedule is we're going to spend about $20 million in 2025 so the question for tonight is how are we going to come up with that money are we going to finance that money are we going to use some of our committed fund balance that we have in reserve um how are we going to come up with that 20 million because we know we need 20 million in 2025 in 2026 2027 2028 and 2029 we plan all along to do subsequent borrowings in those future years and those potential borrowings will be much larger because at that point will be in phase two and the contract value for phase two is much much larger it's about 230 million for the rest of the project okay so fiveyear project we're only talking about phase one

078tonight so phase one what what does phase one entail well phase one entails basically a renovation to k-pod three floors of k-pod I think they're going to start on the the third floor and work their way down third floor Dr B I believe is a science rooms floor two are classrooms floor one are administrative offices so I think they're going to start at the top and work their way down also included in phase one is the nitorum uh also the pre-purchase of certain items are included in that estimate for example switch gear uh we're looking at uh um a pre-manufactured building would be the new Transportation Depot on the site uh movement of the propane tank is another example so that's all included with phase one so with that background what we want to do

079is perform an anal an analysis what is the right amount to borrow if any do we look to utilize all the reserves that we have to fund the $20 million we wouldn't utilize all the reserves but do we use reserves to fund the 20 million or is there some combination between incurring debt and using reserves or is it all debt all $220 million in debt so uh working with pfm we have a three scenario analysis that kind of outlines borrowing some money borrowing a little more money or borrowing no money and then there's a a financial implication to each of those all that is also tied into I mentioned Moody's earlier all that is also tied into our our bond rating so keep in mind our bond rating is part of this discussion too because

080there's no question that plays a role um just a reminder for the committee and for the public our bond rating right now with Moody's is dou A1 that's one notch below the highest rating the highest rating you can have with Moody's is AAA we're double A1 um we are one of only I think it's 19 school districts in the state of Pennsylvania that have a rating of double A1 or higher so that's an outstanding rating and what these Bond ratings means is the higher the rating the lower the interest rate because that means the lower the risk the lower the bond rating the higher the interest rate you're going to pay so it's really important that we um at least maintain our existing bond rating because if we would U incur a reduction a lowering

081of our bond rating to let's say a double A2 just as an example that would mean we would pay a higher interest rate on the money we borrow and that has a financial implication too so you know any kind of discussion we have tonight keep that in mind because our objective and we feel we're going to make a compelling argument when we do meet with Moody and that's anticipated to be sometime in late February we feel we're going to have a compelling argument and compelling story and compelling reserves because we've done many many years of planning for this project to get us to the financial position we're in right now and we feel we're going to be able to tell the story and and provide that argument to Moody so they can go back to

082committee and they can say yes North Penn School District should be continue to be a double A1 rating just as it is now okay so long witted preview any questions about the background kind of what led up to this presentation tonight that was basically my presentation okay Zach thank you for coming tonight um any questions about that so we're gonna we're going to dive now Mr Willard's going to talk now about the three specific scenarios and then we'll have discussion and then when we're finished Ronda Lord our bond council is going to talk about what does this mean with this parameters resolution what what is a parameters of resolution why is it set at a certain level what does a board need to do from here when ises a debt if any when does that

083actually get incurred so it's kind of it's It's part one part two tonight really of the same discussion okay Mr thank you and with me uh Garrett Moore from my office Garrett is the one who actually does all of the work that I come and present so you can thank him for all of the numbers over the past five years but as Steve said this is a discussion about the timing of the first borrowing there's no question you're going to borrow money you know we've been planning for this for years the last meeting was October 8th finance committee meeting where we showed what we thought kind of the the borrowing plan would look like over the next five or six years we know it's always going to change every year we're going to have this

084discussion right about how much do we want to borrow this year how's the project going what's the market doing what are the reserve levels so this is not the only time we're going to have this discussion but here you know we're kicking off the project so the question is you know do you need to borrow in 2025 I don't think the answer is yes you don't have to borrow in 25 but should you borrow in 25 should you start this process um that's what we're going to talk about tonight so when you look at one and 1A you can see the project as Steve mentioned is about just about $260 million as we know it today okay and as you know you don't have enough reserves to pay for that size of a project so

085that's you why we have such a you know robust borrowing plan over the next few years we're going to continue to monitor this as it says under 1A there um to make sure that this all fits into future budgets as that's you know obviously very important um under item two there the original plan and the one that we last looked at on October 8th assumed that we were going to borrow about $30 million in 2025 in the spring of 2025 you know I don't think that's the right answer anymore given the level of Capital reserves that you have um you know committed for capital projects right so what we've come up with in item C there or in number three there is three scenarios one is you borrow $15 million the second one is you

086borrow 10 and the third one is you borrow nothing okay so what we're going to do is we're going to walk through some of the assumptions that we looked at on you know does it make sense to borrow 10 15 or zero from a dollars and cents standpoint all right and then we're going to hop into the other part of this which I think is maybe the the bigger question is you know how does this affect the credit rating and how do we want to handle uh the credit rating process if you remember back you know a few meetings last year when we talked about the credit rating process we're actually planning to have the rating agencies come out to the district most likely right and that's kind of an extra step that you don't

087usually do but because this plan is so big and because the rating is so important for the plan we're going to kind of take the extra steps in the extra initiative to invite them out here drive them through the district talk about the project talk about all the planning that Steve and and the financing team have done over the past few years to get ready for this so you kind of have the the dollars and cense of borrowing now and then you have the dollars and cense of of the credit rating aspect of this so if we uh can scroll down there to the Arbitrage rebate considerations real quickly under four and five so just a real quick refresher the reason and the magic behind picking 15 million and 10 million as some of the

088borrowing options are one under four if you're 15 million or less per calendar year on a borrowing basis it it matters from an Arbitrage rebate standpoint because you'll be small issuer exempt and what that means as a refresher is if you earn more so if you borrow it 4% and you're earning 4 and a half% on that borrowed money you can keep that additional positive Arbitrage okay so I'm not going to get in all the details I know we've talked about that a number of times but that's what you get if you're 15 million or less per calendar year so that's that's option a option b which is going to be number five there where it says Bank qualified review that's where the magic number is 10 million so if you borrow 10 million or

089less per calendar year you receive special TR tax treatment you get typically a better interest rate and maybe more importantly you get a shorter call feature which means you can refinance the debt faster that you borrow so again that's kind of how we came up with 10 million as option b scenario B for the borrowing process all right I'm trying to go through this quick because I know we're 13 minutes past uh the hour so under six seven and eight we're going to go through this real quickly and I'm going to take these numbers and put them in a table so you don't have to do mental math but basically the three things that we're comparing on should you borrow now are first of all on item six the interest that you earn on the

090borrowed money as Steve said you're not going to spend all the money at once right so when you borrow the money you're going to invest that money so under scenario a where you borrow $15 million we assumed based on the current draw schedule that you would earn about $295,000 of Interest earnings through the calendar year 2025 so through December 2025 okay under note one there it shows what the interest rate assumptions are of a 450 through March um a 425 through September those are basically timed with the FED meetings and what the market expects to the FED to do so that's scenario a scenario B is if you borrow $10 million you expected to earn about $135,000 through December of 2025 and under scenario C if you borrow no money you're going to earn no

091interest on that borrowed money okay so that's the interest earned on the borrowed money item seven Debt Service on the borrowed funds those are the payments you're going to make so if you borrow money you're going to have to start to make payments on it right so under scenario a if you borrow $15 million your payments through December 2025 would be about $565,000 okay scenario B if you borrow 10 million so a little bit less your payments would be lower right you're going to pay about 302,000 through the end of the year and scenario C if you borrow no money you will have no payment obviously and then on on it item eight there interest earned on the 2024 available uh Reserve funds so that $21 million that you have available for the project all

092right because that factors into this even though that's your own cash your your your fund balance so scenario a if you borrow $15 million we're assuming you would then earn about $830,000 on your reserves because you're going to be putting less of your reserves into the project you'll be spending the borrowed money first okay scenario B you borrow a little bit less you borrow $10 million you're going to earn about $778,000 on your reserves and scen scario C where you do no borrowing because you're not borrowing any money you're just using your reserves so therefore you're going to earn the least amount which is about $560,000 through the end of the year okay so we're going to take all those numbers and put them in a chart on the next page if you could scroll

093down but first we want to hit on the second piece of this which is the credit rating considerations so Steve said you have a fantastic rating as a double A1 right we've talked a lot about this over the last few years the goal here is to maintain the credit rating you have a very large Capital project coming up $260 million um you know when you head into a credit rating process to kick off a project like this again you want to take all the steps necessary to really explain and show all the planning and put your best foot forward okay in order to maintain that rating so that's what we're planning to do as we said we're going to do a site visit um you know we would like Steve to be part of this

094process we know he's coming up on uh you know retirement unless he changes his mind but so you know we want to do this you know with Steve involved because he has all of the institutional knowledge that a new business manager wouldn't have um one of the largest and you know most important pieces of the credit rating is what type of reserves do you have um at the district right and you do have good reserves and we've we've made that a point right over the years because you know you have this project coming um so being being able to go to the rating agencies with some type of plan that shows that you you have these reserves you you are planning to spend them I think that's always been part of the plan is you're

095going to spend you know some portion of these reserves over this this financing right but whether you do that all up front or you do it throughout the plan or you do it at the end is something that we're you know kind of keeping fluid uh as we move through this but being able to start the credit rating process with the the best uh showing of your reserves will be advantageous to the district okay so in order to get through the 2025 spend the the draw schedule that Steve was referring to you know if you can borrow a little bit and still keep some of your powder dry some of your reserves available uh we think that would show best and then I think under 9C there this is the main kind of dollars and

096cents of the credit rating but we estimated based on current market conditions you know this is about 10 or 12 days ago um that if you did get a one notch downgrade so you would go from a a A1 to a a A2 that that would cost you about $4 million you know over this project based on the lower credit rating therefore a slightly higher interest rate okay so again the credit rating is you know very important when we go to borrow the money and you can see you know with a $4 million difference um you know we want to again kind of show the best the best possible scenario so in conclusion you know I think the credit rating aspect of this is is the main takeaway when when you look at scenarios a

097b and c and you kind of go through the math what we're doing is comparing scenario A and C and scenario B and C and what you wind up with in that bullet below there is based on the above analysis there there really is very minimal benefit from a dollars and cense points to borrowing Now versus not borrowing now it saves you $1,000 if you go with scenario b or it cost you about $48,000 if you go with scenario a on just the simple fact of should we borrow in 2025 or not but kind of going back to the larger question which is the credit rating considerations if you do this credit rating now you you start the borrowing process now you keep your reserves or some portion of the reserves available it could help

098us keep that double A1 rating which is um you know one of the main goals here as we kick off the the process the first rating call and the first rating interview that's the most important one um as we go through this so I tried to do that quickly I'm happy to answer questions or Steve if you want to add anything yeah the only thing I'd like to add is basically just a recap of what our reserves are in terms of fund balance fund balance again are the district's reserves so uh right now through the June 30 2024 audit we have $49 million committed for capital projects so not necessary for the high school could be for other capital projects you know we do have a 10-year Capital plan plan that totals $175 million um

099so that $49 million just committed by board resolution for capital projects we have $2.7 million assigned for our self-insurance for health care okay that's been assigned for a number of years we haven't had to tap into that at all and we also have $22.5 million in unassigned um and just a reminder on the unassigned there's an 8% limit based on our budget size so we are under that 8% limit uh so it's really when we talk about the reserves relative to this project I think we're referencing the $49 million that we have in reserves that's committed for capital projects and again we've had our eye on this project for a number of years and have intentionally over the years that at the end of the fiscal year if there were any positive variances funds were

100either transferred to the capital reserve fund or committed to capital projects um and and I've I've said publicly many many times over the years were it not for this $260 million project I would I would concur with an argument that our funds and reserves are too high but we have a $260 million project we've known about it for a long time and now with that preparation that we've done over a number of years and the long-term fiscal planning that we're going to woo Moody with um you know I don't think it's too much in fact some would argue that it's not enough when you look at the the scope of the project um but we feel we're in a good position because you don't want it too high you don't want it too low you've

101heard me say the the goldilock situation you want to just you want to just right and I think we're in a good spot right now it's not too much it's not too little it's just right certainly to maintain that doublea rating and really position us well for the future to get through the financing for this project questions can I can I ask a question yeah just before we get into questions I I think it's reasonable there not a mistake but the agenda says recommend approval for placement we're we're not actually recommending this presentation for approval the recommendation or the action moving it to the Action meeting will be the next item when we hear from Bond Council so this is just informational conversation to ensue no motion or second y if the committee would like

102to provide um commentary or Direction with the three scenarios presented you may certainly do so um when Miss Lord presents this parameters resolution you you'll probably get a sense where like no decision needs to be made on this in the near term this can happen at a at a later meeting but if you feel um that you're kind of drawn towards one of the three scenarios or if you have questions about one of the three scenarios that would also be helpful okay so I I have a question and then a comment so with the bids opening the bid opening being January 30th um and the parameter resolution would be for a maximum of 15 million correct yes does that have any bearing on where we land if we have I do have a preference does

103that have any bearing on my preference or should it yeah I don't think the bids so we have an estimate of $29 million right so let's just say bids come in at $26 million keep in mind that it's still estimated for 2025 that the draw schedule is is $20 million so I would say if anything if the bids come in over or under estimate that would impact the borrowing for 2026 it really won't have any material impact on what we're looking at right now okay right thanks so I will I have looked at it a bit um and I guess my leaning towards the option C or scenario I'm sorry scenario B Bravo I apologize the $10 million I didn't mean to take anyone's Breath Away um including mine um I on a serious note

104I do like scenario B for the host of reasons because of the credit rating also because you know we don't know what the future is it allows us the opportunity to call Sooner five years if I understand it as opposed to 15 million which is seven years so I like to 10 y okay so I like the optionality and most important and and I I don't know what other board members are going to say I think that it's a um respectful prudent balance between taxpayer dollars um utilization of our cash and then also starting the process off with Mr scroy still on board so I'm in I'm in the middle again I'll repeat scenario B Bravo thanks um I I would based on hearing that uh that opinion this board for as long as I've

105been here eight years we've focused relentlessly on being one of the 62 uh or than one of the 19 school districts with that double A1 or higher Elite rating out of 500 and obviously I mean for me it's an easy decision to not go with the the no borrowing it's just I don't think it's um it's not based in common sense with what this community has been attempting to do and investing appropriately um not by pedal to the medal for act one every single year but by looking at what each situation through the pandemic prior to the pandemic and after to manage those funds that to hit that sweet spot there is a a part of me as a single director that is coming into this seat realize the cumulative effect of not having the

106proper revenue for the scale of the growth in the needs of the district in the infrastructure and that part of me uh really my instinct is scenario a because that's a burden in hand so to speak when we don't know what is coming next however you know there there's good reason for for Bravo B uh because I I I believe it shows a confidence about the stability of the community um electing this board to represent the plan for this infrastructure improvement over the years that has been delivered is now time um f for the largest project to come forward and to to waver from that you know we've done a good enough job with the management and those variances that have been discussed and this is why I want to make sure I'm confirming Mr

107scy if for some reason there's a variance and we want with scenario B and and trying that prudent path There's an opportunity again as we've iterated each of these years um that that we've been planning for this there's an opportunity to at least make up for it it's not lost money that you're never getting again right it's we're not going to lose that opportunity to compound is that correct yeah that's correct and just on the variances like you know we talked about the variance from last year during the audit process but you know now that we're halfway through this fiscal year again just with the way interest rates are um you know when we were planning the budget for this past year it appeared that the Fed was going to be a little more aggressive

108with the rate cutting than it's been so the reason I bring that up our investment income in six months has already exceeded what our budget total is for the year so we will have a revenue positive Revenue variance again for this fiscal year so that would that also helps long term can I say just is a good opportunity to say that that that's a been large driver of the increase into our uh fund balance right is is the four years ago five years ago I mean we've been talking about this conversation for six seven years now you know we weren't necessarily anticipating the opportunity that that we've had in that investment return and I just think that's important to understand too because there's certainly going to be you know people in the community we going

109to say well you're sitting on you know this money um you know it's it's it's community's money and it is the community's money whether it came from investment or tax dollars but to be clear like there is a a healthy percentage of this that has come through because of you know your stewardship of of that money and it's and the investment that's the one question I I want to lead just to finish and thank you because it actually brings that to the to the um to the Forefront uh because I thought I heard a comment and I want to make sure I got it right and what that means for the community uh to validate based on what uh Mr Fusco had just described it means because of that stewardship we're asking for 15 or

11010 compared to was it five years ago we were projecting 30 is that years just just three years ago year year so that's even though we're talking about a lot of money and a fund balance I think it's important for the community and and for the you know the district to recognize the position that we're currently in when we're we're talking about the future direction as well yeah and and Mr Fusco to answer your question too yes it is largely driven by investment income and you know we are conservative with our budgeting we make that very very well known uh but also we use the best information we have when we're planning our budget and for the last two years you know we were expecting more rate Cuts deeper rate Cuts than what actually came

111to fruition well that's that's good news and bad news the bad news is that gives us a variance which we don't like big Varian but the good news is last fiscal year alone that drove out an additional $5 million more than what was budgeted and that allows us this greater flexibility so I guess perhaps we owe a thank you to the FED because because their lack of cutting that was expected uh last year and this year has allowed us a little more flexibility and the other part too that we can't lose sight of because the state seems to have an inability to pass a budget on time that we pass our budget based on an information we have regarding how much money we're we're going to receive from basic Ed funding and special ed funding

112so the last two years the state's budget was passed after our budget was passed and we ended up with over a million dollars each year in additional State funding so that's another piece to it that you know some people say oh you're you're you're pading the budget you're not reflecting reality we reflect reality as we know it when our budget is passed and obviously many times circumstances change after the budget is passed but the good part of that is it is allowing this flexibility that we're talking about tonight if we didn't have the flexibility we would just be talking about we're going to borrow $20 million there's no opportunity to use any reserves but now we have an opportunity to have reserves as part of the equation uh because of some of these positive events

113that have have happened and allowed us to commit additional funds into that fund balance I appreciate this and I also appreciate you bringing up that this really does take a village right so the feds rates our community investment and then great Partners like you all so I think I too am also leaning towards scenario B but with that flexibility because I think the way that we've structured this process over time is that we are pulling together teams and and great partners that are helping to advise us um on this effort um knowing that we want to be good stewards and end up with a product that are Community is proud of and is of it deserving of of the students that we serve so but I I agree in that I I appreciate how and

114I we haven't heard about the formal parameters resolution yet but that it does allow for that flexibility up so we want to be as Nimble and responsive as we can should sit situations change or need change and I'll add to Mr Willard mentioned that this is this is fluid so and Miss MC merer you mentioned about what about the bid so what's going to happen between now and 2026 we're going to have bids for phase one but we're also going to have bids for phase two the larger portion of the project so I would anticipate maybe late 2025 early 2026 now you have all the concrete bidding information now you'll know what has happened with n you'll know what kind of variances may have been in the 2425 budget and that then will lead to

115a different conversation for round two of the borrowing for 2026 it could be less than what was anticipated before for depending on what happens with this fiscal year uh it depends on how the bids come out so all those factors then will come into play when you talk about barrowing number barrowing number two and really three four and five will also depend on the situation at the time yeah we'll continue to do this you know if the market drops 2% we may decide oh let's go borrow twice as much as what we thought now because we won't have to borrow more in 2028 so we'll just continue to Monitor and be flued we always appreciate you joining our meeting so anytime yeah absolutely okay I'm going to turn over to Rhonda now thank you can

116we fix the microphone y Ronda thank you for coming Ronda is our bond counsil with the law firm of Saxon and stump so Ronda welcome thanks for coming tonight good evening I don't have to push anything I'm okay um it's nice to be here um as you know we're considering uh parameters resolution for your next board meeting I think in the past when I've come um first of all when you do a borrowing whenever a school district wants to borrow money you need to get approval from the Department of community and economic development in the past when I've come we've come on the day of a bond sale you have exact numbers you have a purchase contract um so we know exact numbers and you put those in that is one way of borrowing another

117way of borrowing is this parameters resolution where you um apply to DCd dced to get approval this approval process takes anywhere from 30 to 40 days between advertising board meetings and then they have a 20-day um window where they get to consider your filings it's a very specific filing that you we file with them um so we you file a parameters resolution in this case $15 million they authorize you to borrow up to $15 million that does not mean you have to borrow 15 million it means you could borrow five 10 you could borrow nothing um if you decide you don't need to borrow anything the only thing lost is your advertising and filing fees um the resolution itself contemplates that the school board the um Chief Financial Officer will make a decision and approve

118an addendum to the bond purchase contract so the bond purchase contract which is attached to the resolution is for the full $15 million but no borrowing will occur until there's an addendum to that Bond purchase contract approved by the board signed by either the board officers or the Chief Financial Officer so you have full flexibility to decide between when you adopt the resolution if you adopt the resolution and the filing from of a $15 million approval to borrow anywhere between 15 and nothing if you decide to borrow 10 million we would then after the borrowing make an additional filing with dced letting them know what the actual filing was for they will correct their records and then your borrowing will be set with the state and there's no time limit we have parameters resolutions that

119are sitting out there for three four years so you get this approval the approval doesn't die within a certain amount of time time it's unlimited um and it just stays out there until you either tell us you're not borrowing and we write it off with dced or you actually do a borrowing and rewrite it off with them just to um be clear for those who are watching and for me um 15 million 10 million what we're talking about is a cap at this point for borrowing not we're saying we're going to borrow 10 versus 15 at this moment just want to make sure that's the the resolution itself is maximum amount of 15 million up to 15 milon okay thanks and M Laur just want to clarify too that the parameters resolution would need to

120be approved by the board but then a subsequent board approval when the amount is actually set it it does not need actual board approval it just needs to be signed by a board officer or you or whoever is you when it is actually signed thank you so at some point there needs to be board Direction and we've heard some commentary tonight on what that amount is going to be and Mr Willard when we're preparing for Moody's is it better to know what the exact amount is going to be when we have the rating score or it's helpful I think given that we're talking about a $260 million project and here we're talking about 10 to 15 million it's not the end of the world but it would be nice to be able to tell them

121what we're doing because again knowing that we want to show them what kind of reserves we have available I think that would be important just because there's no microphones in the audience Mr Willard just said that he thinks it would be helpful to get a little bit of direction to be able to speak to that in the Moody's call Mr scroy what would be the best way for us to be able to share that with you well we've heard some commentary tonight if anyone else would like to I'll say that I'm comfortable with 15 I just feel like it gives more flexibility it doesn't mean that we're committing to 15 it's certainly it's simply just a little bit more uh leeway in terms of the ability for you to make that decision so Dr I'm

122on a okay um I would say I'm most comfortable with scenario b um I think uh my concern continues to be us being more measured in terms of our seniors and our taxpayers um and trying to borrow utilize you know 50% of what we think we may have to borrow from our fund balance and then the other half of it so I feel like that's like splitting the baby um but I also understand the flexibility and The Importance of Being Nimble so I'm comfortable with say with the the parameters being up to 15 million recognizing that I think you know you've heard several members of the board say that you know we really want to have a measured response um I do appreciate that um we have been preparing for this for years years we've

123been talking about it for years um and I I think us being able to be knowledgeable and really understand this and ask all of the hard questions over the past several years um has been really helpful while we didn't get much at all out of Co um we have gotten a lot of knowledge around this because it kind of halted Us in being able to do some things so that meant that we had time to really think about this and put some more money in our pocket um in our Piggy bank so I'm appreciative of that um I think I know way more about bonds than I thought I ever would um but I'm I'm appreciative of that um I just I'm more most comfortable with scenario B but recognize the importance of having the

124flexibility and Trust in our um our business manager our superintendent that they will also have you know a measured response as we look at whether it needs to be between 10 and 15 thank you so just for clarification here so the the recommendation is going to be to move the resolution to the Action meeting on January 23rd the Moody's call I believe you said Mr scroy is probably going to be the third week in February so between now and then the resolution says up to 15 and if it is the desire of the board for uh to give more specificity on what that number is when speaking with Moody's in February we can iron those things out between now and then but the objective tonight is to pass a resolution authorizing up to $15 million

125borrowing yeah this is good feedback though so perhaps maybe we even have an agenda item at the February Finance meeting and we kind of hone in on one of the scenarios discussion very good idea thank you very much I want to make sure that I'm clear on something since you made the point um although I said I support a I am quite comfortable with scenario B if that is the will of my colleagues perfect so the recommendation that we're putting forward is for the approval for placement on the January 23rd Amendment of the um parameters resolution do I have a motion and a second second motion by Mr McBain second by Mr Fusco all in favor say I I any opposed motion carries thank you thank you very much thank you thank you so much

126for coming thanks for coming if you guys could wait in the audience for any questions from public comment I would app I'm just kidding have a nice evening so we're still on the finance agenda okay so the work session started 41 minutes ago but we'll finish the finance agenda so the financial reports are are listed of course I have a summary I did allude to a couple things I think it's important to point out again that we're hitting it out of the park with investment income again this year so we're going to have a couple million dollar positive Varian with investment income uh I do just want to make mention I know this is Mrs sto's favorite report Mrs stole right which one right to know right so I'm I'm I think I said this

127last month I'm going to jinx the district but we've only received 44 right to no requests so far this year we had 283 last year so the fact that we're halfway through the year with only 44 wow that's great that's way down from previous years so that's great but now we'll probably get 30 tomorrow from a vexatious requestor right okay so now we're on the public comment the public comment section Mrs romen thank you um and so seeing no one in the audience um I think um we do not need to read the statement um and if do we need a summary of the items that we're moving forward or can we I can do the Su Qui so we have budget transfers that'll be on the January Action meeting we have extended uh School

128CARE program tuition rates and Camp fees for 2526 January action audit and insurance broker RFP advertisement January action movie lot agreement uh amendment number two January Action Tax Collector tax collector compensation will be at the February work session and the parameters resolution for the high school financing January works um January Action meeting January 23rd okay perfect summary um just as a reminder to the the board and the community um we have our our next uh finance committee meetings one is on February 11th at 6 p.m. and another is the special meeting um on February 18th um I just want to thank our student representatives for being here and our North pen TV students for being here we are going to allow them a moment to reset after we adjourn the meeting we'll have a little

129bit of a break um and then we'll um we'll resume our next meeting so do I have a motion to adjourn so move so move thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.