CorpusRecord 72182

Public Hearing (02-18-25)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Peters Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Washington County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,731 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001It being six o'clock, we will call this public hearing to order. We will begin with the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And at this point, I will turn the meeting over to the district administration. Thank you, Mrs. Baumann. Can I have the solicitor speak to the purpose of this meeting? Thank you. My name is Anne Marie Haar. I'm the assistant solicitor for Peters Township School District. I'm just going to give a brief introduction of our special hearing this evening. This is a special meeting of the district. The district previously held a special meeting on December 16th in order to open the public hearing regarding a charter

002school application submitted by Dogwood Charter School on November 15th, 2024. Both this meeting and the meeting on December 16th was advertised pursuant to the charter school law. The purpose of the special meeting was to allow for the presentation of the application by the applicant, and today's meeting will focus on the opportunity for the administration to present its findings and for the charter applicant to respond to those findings. The board will vote on the charter application this evening, which is in advance of the deadline of March 1st, 2025, as required by the charter school law. As an initial matter, the administration will enter the legal advertisements into the record as Exhibits 1 and 2, so I'm going to hand that over to the court reporter. Following the administration's presentation, the applicant will have 20 minutes to

003provide a response, at which point the board may ask questions. My understanding is that no one has signed up for any additional public comment on this matter. No one signed up in advance. There was one individual who did sign up. They were late, but were instructed that they could sign up or that they would be able to speak for the regular two minutes during the public hearing. Thank you. And as stated, the board will vote on the application during the voting portion of this meeting. I will now turn it over to the administration for a review of its application of this charter school application. So the administrative team did a review of the application. A lot of information was submitted, and the application was reviewed under charter school law review criteria. There were three other

004districts who were also undergoing the same review at the same time. There was the same application submitted in three other districts, so we did pull resources to review the application. Again, I will not read this verbatim, but the charter school law, the criteria that we're required to look at is there's a demonstrated sustainable support for the charter school plan, that the capacity of the charter school applicant in terms of support and planning to provide a comprehensive learning experience as a student pursuant to the adopted charter, the extent to which the application considers the information requested in section 1719A in conformance to the legislative intent outlined in section 1702A, and the extent to which the charter school may serve as a model for other public schools. So the intent of the charter school law was to

005improve pupil learning, to encourage learning opportunity and to increase learning opportunities for all pupils, to encourage the use of different and innovative teaching methods, to create new professional opportunities for teachers, to provide the opportunity to be responsible for the learning program at the school site, provide parents and pupils with expanded choices in the types of educational opportunities that are available within the school system, and hold the schools established under this act accountable for meeting measurable standards and provide the school with a method to establish accountability systems. We hear with the review team, so anybody with a large number of binders in front of them was on the review team. When we break this down into scoreable criteria, and there's the scoreable criteria, I will not read through this, the board members have this in front

006of them. I will go through it when we do the actual review. Okay, and the first one, does the charter school have current petitions and letters of support from teachers, parents, students, and the community? So the application itself appears to be the application that was submitted several years ago for the charter school located in Bethel Park. So the letters of support and electronic signatures are all outdated and were for that particular charter in Bethel. So the answer to that one was no. The second one, B, did the charter school have support from the community at the public hearing? So we did have families come to the public hearing and endorse support, so we would say that that would be a yes. Does the charter school provide the district with expanded choices in the types of

007educational opportunities currently being offered? We rated that as a yes. We do not offer a relational model of instruction as outlined in their application. I will turn this one over to the solicitor. This was a solicitor question, and it's whether or not the governance structure of the charter schools in compliance with all federal, state, and local regulations and the PA school code. Thank you, Dr. French. Upon our review, the solicitor's office found that the governance structure was unclear. There were founding members, there was a board of trustees listed, as well as principals for the school. There were some discrepancies in the application where the application listed the principals and the board of directors as facilitators and teachers of teachers, as it was referred to, but members of the board were included in the attachments but

008left off of the application. It was also unclear as to whether or not the trustees met the minimum statutory requirements. The applicant also, as Dr. French stated at the beginning of this presentation, does have a current charter in a neighboring school district and has submitted applications in multiple charter schools and multiple school districts for additional charter schools. It appears that this applicant is attempting to create a multiple charter school organization rather than a singular charter school without complying with the statutory requirements necessary to establish a multiple charter school organization, which is where there are multiple charter schools establishing under one board of directors. The applicant, as stated, has submitted simultaneous and identical applications to four different school districts, West Jefferson Hill School District, Baldwin White House School District, Peters Township School District, and Ringgold School

009District, who are acting jointly on the review of the charter application. Therefore, the application should be deemed an application for a regional charter school, and that was not properly identified at the time of the submission to the multiple school districts. The next one, does the applicant consider all of the information requested in Section 1719A and conform to the legislative intent outlined in Section 1702A? This was no, it's just the highlighted reasons was there was no location provided, no fees, there was a location provided in the application, which was for the Venetian Heritage Society, and at our last, at the hearing that we held last, that was confirmed that that was not an appropriate location or a viable location, no other viable location was indicated. And the second one under this is under the charter school

010law, an applicant is to, an applicant to establish a charter school shall have all the following information, and one of the required pieces of information are official clearance statements regarding child injury or abuse. Because the char, the employees were let go, it really is something they could not comply with, but it is, and it is not in the application because they don't have current employees, so it's kind of a chicken and egg thing, but again under the, under the requirements of the law, we had, this was required to be answered as no, and there is insufficient evidence provided that the proposed charter, the educational programs will improve pupil learning. So the next one Dr. Fisher is going to handle, he took the lead on the elementary evaluation regarding the curriculum being complete, comprehensive, and aligned

011to state standards. Thanks Dr. French. So the first thing that I took a look at was when we looked at the math curriculum, some of the concerns were they did have a curriculum or a program, and they did have it crosswalked with the standards to make sure the standards were all identified. However the one thing that we look at is making sure that there's ways that we can identify how students know, understand, and are able to perform the skills, and where we can assess them, and you know have a really good understanding, and that was missing from this, this document. And the other thing that was just one point of note, there was a sample schedule included there for an elementary classroom, and there were 60 minutes allotted to both ELA or language arts or

012reading and math, and that 60 minutes was a was listed as a combined time, and I just know building elementary schedules for the district that you know we have tons of time, and we still have a lot of difficulty ensuring we're instructing all the standards that we have. So in in the area of math that was that was our finding, and then if we go to the next slide and we take a look at ELA, the one the one real big the real big call out is the state has put a requirement in the last year for structure literacy, and structure literacy is making sure the students have those foundational or building blocks of reading which are phonics, phonemic awareness, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension, and there wasn't a timeline or a scope and sequence for

013how these would be delivered. There were literature stories, there were some resources, but again that piece that ties all of those components of reading with along with an assessment that'll you know identify who's making progress, who's not making progress, and how are we going to remediate those students who may not be making progress. For grade 612 it was similar for ELA or the curriculum in general. It was often missing essential questions, big ideas, objectives for teachers to teach to. There were standards listed but not always aligned directly to a course or to a content specific content. One of the things that also was called out is that it appeared to be that it was a little out of date or missing information because some of the most recent mandates coming through around personal finance, new

014standards, specifically the STEEL standards, and addressing technology or engineering were missing and incomplete as well. In reviewing it I had some concerns with the timelines, especially with the timelines of the evaluations and qualifying kids for special education. When a parent asks for an evaluation, whether it's oral or written, you have 10 days to do that, not give them forms, not ask for it, it has to be written, so I have a concern there. After you get the permission from the parent, you have 60 days to do the evaluation and following that you have 30 days to do the IEP. You have to follow timelines to have the meeting. Then at the meeting where you offer the IEP, which is the special education program, that is where you then have the parent accept or not accept

015the program. The timelines were a real concern as to how they have it laid out and how the evaluation and the IEP process was going to be initiated. Also in the process of the evaluation, they don't mention a school psychologist, which is a vital part of most of the evaluations that are done, especially when you talk about specific learning disabilities where it has to be a severe discrepancy between cognitive and achievement. There are specialized tests that only a school psychologist could give. That's where we identify written expression and basic reading and reading fluency and reading comprehension. There was a concern there because I didn't see that signified or how they were going to do that. That is a concern, especially since now dyslexia is such a concern and we actually do more testing for that,

016which would also be done by a school psychologist. Within their program, too, they also mention self-contained classroom. The least restrictive environment is what we all like for special education. At Peters, we have no self-contained classrooms. That's a concern if we're going to have self-contained classrooms. Then I also had a concern because there was no mention of homeless students. Thank you, Mr. Brown, regarding the budget. Criterion number seven was does the proposed charter school is the proposed charter school financially viable? The concern there, when you look at the actual budget, it's based on tuition rates of the Bethel Park School District where the original charter was applied to. Those tuition rates change. They're by school district, by spending. Our tuition rate here at Peters Township is almost $2,500 less per regular ed student and $13,000 less

017per special ed student. When you actually take those numbers into the 113 projected enrollment, that would actually cause a deficit of the proposed budget of $478,000. That's a 21% decrease to their revenue. This is just using Peters Township's tuition rate. We know that once a school would have a blended rate because you would have students from other districts, the concern would be Ringgold and Canna Mack would be the other two closer school districts. They actually have a lower tuition rate than Peters Township does, so that would actually make the reduction in revenue even worse. That is why we, based on the application, would check that as a no, as financially viable. It's particularly important that the charter did submit a follow-up information regarding all of their attempts in Bethel Park. They did earnestly try to

018find a location. They had started in 2021 with a letter of intent at 1008 Progress Court. Because of the inability to finance renovations to bring that building up to code, they had to move on from that location that was in their original charter. They moved on to the Christ United Methodist Church. The agreement there fell through because of the church's desire to defray the impact additional use would have on their ministry. From there, they moved on to the Bethany Lutheran Church, where they were able to get a lease agreement and actually open the school. They opened on September 3rd, but then on the next day, on the 4th, the Bethel Park Zoning and Code Enforcement officers showed up and cited them with numerous code and zoning violations. So there, then they had to close on

01910-14-24, and they moved on to the Bethel Park Community Center and were able to be in operation there from, it looks like, 10-17 to 10-25, when the Bethel Park authorities notified them that the community center was not an acceptable solution. And that's when they went on pause of their school and were not able to find a suitable location. So they did attempt multiple times to find a suitable location. And my point in bringing this up, finding a suitable location for children and for school, you have to worry about, do we have a facility that will be conducive to educational, our educational programming? But at the same time, are we going to be able to comply with all zoning and code enforcement? We know this from building our own building, that there are a lot of

020codes out there and it takes, and it's a lot of time. And then we have an organization who did try earnestly to move around to find a suitable place and just were unable in the location where the charter was granted. So then the next, moving on, can the charter school serve as a model for other schools in the district? We check this as no. In terms of a model, we're thinking of a model school. This is based off of a charter school that is a very low achieving charter school. And if we were looking at being aspirational and provide a model, we would want to find a model that was at least having children achieve standards at a greater rate. There was also no data supported about this, about the potential improvements and investments that

021could be brought to the Peters Township School District. It was all based on the Bethel Park School District. And again, when we look at a model school district, this is a school that attempted to open a neighboring district and unfortunately had to close within two months. So our summary checklist, and again, I will not, if anybody would like me to go through this, you, the board has it in front of you, but I, this is just a summary of the places where we did meet and we did not meet. A lot of these deficits are just a function of this being a recycled application that is, you know, about four years old. We, there have been changes in requirements and education. There are, there's a lot that we did not list, like Act 55 of

0222022 around school safety threat assessment, having a school resource officer. Those things cost money and, you know, we did not want to lump on and put all these additional things in this application. But again, there are new requirements every year that districts and charters must contemplate to keep up with in terms of their budgeting and their planning. So our final review, considering the deficiencies in this application by the review team, the Dogwood Charter School's application as presented did not include all the information required to be included under the charter school law and did not successfully meet the criteria from the review team. Our recommendation to the board is to deny the charter application. The next step would be that as advertised, there will be a voting meeting immediately following this meeting where this item will

023be placed on the agenda for the board's consideration. So I will turn this back over to the solicitor for the next part of the meeting. Sure. I would invite any members of Dogwood Charter School of the applicant. They now have 20 minutes to provide their response. If there is somebody that intends to respond, I would just ask that you step up to the podium and use the microphone for that response. Following that response time period, then the board may ask questions either of administration or the applicant. So my understanding is that nobody signed up in advance for public comment relative to the special hearing. But when we move into the voting meeting, the voting section of this meeting will begin. When we advertise, so there will be two minutes of public comment. There will be

02420 minutes of two-minute public comment in this sense. I'm sorry, I did not update the solicitor on that. Oh, I'm sorry. So their comments are included in our 20 minutes? Is that what you're saying? No, no. They're separate. You have 20 minutes and I have five minutes. Okay. I'll keep track of the minutes. Yes, it is Beth Opat, B-E-T-H-O-P-A-T. And will the 20 minutes be just so I have some idea? Is it going to be displayed anywhere or just so it helps me time myself? Dr. Fisher, can you go? I do have someone else who wants to speak, so I want to make sure I give them time. But okay. So obviously that information is new to us in terms of what you felt the deficits were. So I will try to address them to

025the best of my ability given this time and give you any additional new information that we have for you. So where to begin? So essentially when you talk a lot about there are requirements. Of course, there are the same ones that you are held to per the state in terms of state standards, in terms of clearances, in terms of all those things. It's state law. We have to uphold that. We have to do that. We have counsel as well who makes sure we do that. We report to PIMS just like you do. So all of that is not necessarily a deficit per se. We have to do that. So that is state law and we will be held to that just as you are. So that's those pieces. In terms of special education, I'm dyslexic.

026I don't always announce that. So I understand what you are saying and one of my children is and my other one is being evaluated to see if they are. And so I understand completely where you're coming from. And that is why we are working to open the school and why the curriculums were so important and passionate to us and making sure that we have the correct ones to meet the student body needs. And the really great reading program is a multi-sensory approach, which is a lot what dyslexic students use and also involves familiar awareness as well. And again, going with the new law, we have to also have our teachers trained in the scientific of literacy as well of making sure that we are compliant with that as well. Benchmark testing, which a lot is

027what I'm assuming you would do. I know Bethel Park does as well, which allows us to see where our students are so we can address our curriculum deficits just like you do according to that data. It is interesting how we, you know, always try to find holes in different things. And yes, there may be holes in different aspects, but also we are working just as you are to fill those deficits and to make that progress forward. So just as you refine your curriculum every year, we ask that you give us the same grace to do the same. And so we have a curriculum that we feel is suitable and we will continue to adjust it as needed just as you do. And like I said, we are held to standards as well. In terms of

028staff, we can't have staff until we're approved. And even after we're approved, we have to make sure everything is in alignment. We usually hire staff with the fiscal calendar, which is July 1st. So we are not able to necessarily have these people hired, but when they are, we have to follow HR protocols and have clearances for all those parties, which we did when we were open. Um, and also we did have a school psychologist on staff. We had followed all timelines and had multiple students in the, um, in the evaluation process, even within the short period of time that we were open and had to pass that off to the school districts that they then went to for a seamless transition for them to continue to be evaluated. Um, also support, that's always a tricky

029one. So we did a third of our students were from Peters Township. So we did have support in that area. We are a small school. So our support is, doesn't have to be large to still be supporting who we are. Um, and we always think of support as a larger community. Yes, a lot of our support is Bethel Park, but those students can come to our school just as yours can. So it's still support for our school, even though they may not live in your township and actually kind of works in your benefit in some ways. Um, governance structure, we do have a board of trustees, um, that started back in December. So we can be more clear with that and we can provide information, um, to fill in those gaps as well where you

030feel that is lacking. Um, we are not applying for regional charter. Um, even our own council, when we talk to them, we can have separate applications in. If we were applying for regional, we would, but then you all would have had to have talked together and because we only want to open in one district, we did not do the original approach and did just do separate applications as well. So I understand where that may have been confusing. So hoping that address a lot of your kind of questions and deficits, the location I'm going to address here in a moment. Cause I did have that prepared, but before I do, I'm just going to take a breath. I talk fast. I'm realizing some of you, I might be talking very fast. So I'm going to slow

031myself down. We do have an approved charter and we do have one in Bethel Park. And unfortunately, as you know, it's a very residential area. What buildings are there are there. And so we did try very hard. Um, and we're not stopping. Um, and so we wanted to give other options. So I believe that each, every one of you truly care about what you're doing. It's why you're here and you care about every student that walks through your building. And yes, I get the term passionate all the time for the way that I speak, but I want to remind you that that is what you're here for. And that Fred Rogers, that name I've spoke of before and that we all know if you've never seen, he went in front of the court system to

032get funding for the public broadcast system because it was in danger of not having the funding and not being able to do the work that he does. And the judge wanted nothing to hear what he had to say. And within, I think it was like two minutes, three minutes, Fred Rogers, doing what he does was able to speak to him and completely flipped. You can see it in the man's face change as he spoke directly to him, telling him what their system was going to do. And as I tell you what we are going to do for children that are not currently being served. So I ask, sorry. So we have the confidence that you have read our charter and that you would only vote to deny us if you felt that it was lacking,

033like you stated, and that if it is lacking, like you stated, that you will allow us to fix it just as other school districts have. So Provident is another charter school in Pittsburgh, and they had opened a second location in Baden, and they have a successful school, and they still denied it and gave them the deficits. They reviewed the deficits, they approached them with the school district, and then the school district did approve it the second time. So giving you an example of that. And also they opened their school with only 30 students, or actually it was less than 30 students, and already we know that we have interest in more than that. We had 73 to start our school year in the fall, and I get phone calls and emails weekly about people interested

034in our school and checking in on our progress to see if we'll be able to open in the fall because they want to enroll their students. So like I said, we have kind of doubled that amount. So tonight we are asking you to have the courage to not be divided by politics, because we all lie in different places of that, but to vote together to approve a charter school that is supported and needed and will change the lives of students in our community. Give us this five-year chance to show you this schoolworks. In a short six weeks we did that, and these families will tell you that we did that. Since our initial hearing, we have engaged in prospective family communications, scheduled in-person and virtual sessions, and adjusted our open enrollment window to align with

035our district hearing. We also curated a list of potential partnerships and nonprofits and higher education institutes that we are currently reaching out to to create those partnerships. And then also with our marketing, we still have a significant high traffic to our site, and this month alone we've had 200 unique users, and for you all that's probably not a high number, but for us when we only need 50% of that to be in our school, that is a pretty big deal. And those are families that are unique users that are coming to our site because they are specifically looking for a school choice. Our board has created additional teams to continue to delegate the tasks that we need to make sure that we are prepared and to open. These are our jobs on the line too,

036so we do take every step of this way seriously. And as I said before, we do get emails and requests. I just got another one today about inquiring about our school and hoping that it will open this fall in order to support their child. We are currently working with Alex Hardy to secure a building to our school, and I know he said he knows lots of you. So we are working with him for a building. Unfortunately, the building that we are looking at is, the occupancy has not moved down yet, so we have to a longer timeline with that, but we are working with him. I just spoke with him today, so we are asking for time in that as well. And our council said that you could keep this record open until March 1st

037in order to be able to vote once we can submit the building information to you. We have reached out to the municipality. They have emailed back with us about making that transition into the building that we are talking with Alex about, and we are working with Lighthouse Academies who is a consultant for charter schools, and so they have also reached out as well, and they have opened hundreds of schools. So we do have support and we do have people that are helping us along this way. Oh, and then also I thought I would just also put this out there. I know we had reached out to the district, so I understand that your middle school, which is right next to your formal middle school, which is right next to us. We understand that you did

038not sell it because you need to retain it in case you need it for when your community is clearly growing and need to utilize it later, but we understand that the IU is in that building and also at the Beaver County College. I understand that IU, I think, has under a hundred students in there, and I know probably in its heyday you had hundreds of students in that school building. I understand if you don't have the space, but in case you hadn't thought of it, if you do have the space in that building, that could be a win-win for both of us until we were able to move on to a different facility. And from what I have seen by driving by, our drop-off and pick-up times do not coincide with the IU's time, so

039that would potentially not be a conflict. So our families are seeking out our school. It's now up to you to help make that happen. I understand that you may not have a child that fits these scenarios, but I'm asking you to put your shoes in those parents' shoes and understand what that might feel like, because you are here to serve the children of this community, and specifically Peterstown Tip. When a parent of your district, not one of ours, comes to you with concerns, you listen. You feel these are conditions and you want to help fix them for them, and so we're asking that you do the same for us. We don't necessarily like, you know, being in this situation either. The state says that this is how this process has to work, that it has

040to be you to make the decision. So we are just as much in this situation, and I know it was concerned about taxpayer dollars last time, and yeah, we are just as concerned with that, and the longer that this goes, the more that goes up, and so we can resolve this and find a way to have a school that's already been approved in another location, because we have a more suitable location here, to be able to move forward with that is better for all of us. Okay, do you probably need five minutes? Mom, are both of you? Okay, all right, let me wrap this up there, because there's two people that also want to talk. So I address curriculum, adjust taxpayer support, yes, and in terms of giving them, it's hard to address that one,

041because yes, you're looking at one little piece of the pie that you don't feel meets your standards, but there's a whole other piece of that, many other pieces of that pie that they are succeeding with, and their student body is very different than this region, and so I am actually very curious that once we are open and be able to do those test scores, I think that's where you can really tell if this model is successful, and obviously, there are districts that are still in existence that don't have great scores, and they are working to do them, and we would do the same if it came back that we did not, but I am pretty confident, given the scores of all the students that came to us, that we would have successful scores. Heather, do

042you want to, or Luanne? Sure, come on up. Selena is a former educator, we only have seven minutes between the two of you, is a former educator in a public school system, so she wanted to speak on that. I am not a public speaker, and I'm quite nervous, but, oh, sorry, Luanne Canal, K-I-N-O-L. I taught in the public school system for 40 years, and I'm retired. I come from this from, to this presentation from several angles, one being a former teacher for 40 years and retired, and I'm also dyslexic. I was dyslexic before they even knew what it was, and I struggled really hard, but I made it, okay, and I also volunteer. I'm an educational aid volunteer at Dogwood Charter School, and I've watched these kids grow just in the two months that they

043were there. I think we all know, sorry, that everybody cannot, every child cannot succeed in a traditional classroom. I know that from 40 years of experience. These classrooms gave these children an opportunity, some that never wanted to come to school would run in the building, kids that participated in the classrooms, and that had never spoken anywhere before, and like I said, I was there for two months volunteering, and I just know, as you all know, we're here for the kids, and you have an opportunity to make this environment available to these kids, and I just hope that you give them that opportunity. Thank you. She's gonna wait till Karen come in, because she does live in Peterstown, right? Okay, thanks, Heather. Since I have five minutes, Luanne made a good point that I will just

044read briefly, but I'm trying to decide if we did what we gave to you, but I do not want to waste time, but at the same time, I'll just read a couple. So these are actual parents who, when everything was happening, we wanted letters of support to know how important this school was. So I'm just going to give you a little blips of kind of what Luanne was talking about. You know, this one parent says, all four of my students that attended Dogwood had many stories of wins in the short time that they had been in attendance, and they are so thankful for each one of them. They had said they had a daughter who lacked confidence and had been nervous to read out loud and afraid to make a mistake, and just last week,

045this is when she was writing it, for the first time, she asked to read for our family at the dinner table. This may sound like a small thing, but I give full credit to the Dogwood approach and has taken with her, building her confidence and skills as one family who had four children at our school. I urge the school board to recognize the significant benefits that Dogwood brings to a community and surrounding communities. The future of many students depend on this institution and confident that you will find a way forward to make this school an existence. Thank you for giving me the time to go through this. This one says, all children have the right to a school environment that meets their educational and emotional needs. Our family needed an alternative to a public school

046for our daughter to succeed. Dogwood Charter School provides what our daughter and our family needs as an important resource for our family and the community. This one was, it was clear that the school, her current school was not meeting her needs for emotional support. Her drive to use play and outdoors exploration as an outlet for creativity and learning, and her need for an educational environment that can meet her where she is developmentally. Every day came home drained and dispirited. That was at her other school, but since joining Dogwood, my daughter has rebounded with joy and enthusiasm and it is easy to see why. Every day she cheerfully tells me about the structured time outdoor, her play-based exploration of nature, writing, music, art, karate, math, science, languages. It's all there and more. Dogwood's teaching and administrators

047demonstrate a commitment to her emotional and academic development and personal well-being at the level I have never seen anywhere else. As an educator myself, and this is the father speaking, I firmly believe Dogwood Charter School fills a need that is often unmet with our children in our region. I certainly wish the college students I teach at Carnegie Mellon University had come from a school like Dogwood. I see future graduates of Dogwood succeeding brilliantly and their future paths in college or anywhere else that their values Dogwood Charter School is starting to instill in its students. Social emotional maturity, curiosity, confidence, community, and resilience. It is clear to me as a parent and as a professional educator that Dogwood Charter School feels a desperate need in the role of the region's educational landscape. I strongly endorse any

048means necessary to allow its operation. So I could go on and on. We have lots of these letters, but I just wanted to give you snippets. So again giving you the facts for the brain part of you and the parent letters for the heart side of both all of us. So you have all that information when you make your decision. I'll be done. If the board has any questions, I'll turn it over to you all now. Does anyone on the board have a question? Hey, thank you for your time. Appreciate you all coming out. I have two questions. How would you answer the revenue concerns and how I get your point of some of the things we the administration brought up are maybe tick tacky and from a old application you want the opportunity to

049correct those. I sit here and I'm taking it all in and I'm like how would you respond to my question of why was the application not given its I mean if my son gave me this I'd say it was C minus work based upon what I'm hearing and you would think if this was so important it would be in a level effort. So just wondering how you would respond to those two. Yeah, good point. So I'll start with the last one you said first because I did want to address that other one. So thank you. So we did not have plans to turn in new applications. So when we opened our plan with CB and Bethel and stay open and that was it. The reason it was last minute was due to the fact of

050the timing of everything because even when the building issues came up we were in the process we had hired a new lawyer to help us through that process and to still stay open. There was no intention of closing. When that became more of a possibility then we decided that our best option in addition to continuing to try to pursue that since we had been talking with the Peter Stiles and Venetia that's why it was interesting that now that wasn't viable because we had been talking with them for months prior to even thinking about applying here because we were looking there as a temporary location. So when we knew that building was kind of already there we're like well if there is a chance of us closing let's give ourselves another opportunity. So we had to

051use we had and we did go through it. It's not that we just threw you the application that we had four years ago. We went through it with the fastest that we could. We had a team of people within days that had to because when if you look at the timeline it was days before the application was due and we can't control the application deadline. So unfortunately we did the best that we absolutely could and we do feel that we have a good application because it was approved the first time. And the tuition yes I'm so glad you stated that. So I'm I'm not sure what the numbers that you looked at because we didn't do all of Bethel Park. So when our financial manager from Charter Choices did about because again it's all projections

052because we don't know who our actual student body is going to be. So it was a third Peters, third Bethel Park, and a third Pitzer Public. And yes they all have different tuition rates and so we usually go conservatively and estimate based on the lower tuition rate of that and do it based on that. Also what that's not accounting for though is we don't know what our special education numbers are going to be when we're projecting it. So we always go on the conservative end of that as well but with knowing what we opened with being close to 20 to 30 percent if you factor in that amounts that would also there would not be a deficit. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions? There are questions just to Dogwood or administration solicitor as well.

053You can ask of Dogwood or administration. Okay I have a lot of questions. All right I'm just going to go sort of through the slides as we have them here. On slide six what is the legal standard of current? So for the current petition is there a legal standard of current? I think that the issue here and certainly administration can speak to this the standard would be current support and I think that the issue that administration pointed out was that the support that was signified and the application that was received was previous support. Understood I mean it's only a few years though to Jason's similar point earlier. So there isn't a legal standard of current needs to be within the past 18 months, two years, five years, ten years. There is no definition of current

054typically it is within the year that the application is being submitted. Okay but not a standard? Not defined. Okay and then if they even being out of date were this any signatories from Peters Township or were they only Bethel Park? So I there were 154 electronic signatures of the 154 there were seven from Peters Township and they asked the question would you consider sending your child? Two of the seven said that they would and five of the seven said maybe. Okay but do or the required signatures for this application do they have to come from Peters or could they come from surrounding areas? So they can they can come from others but when you're looking at an application we're looking the question that we have to answer is there for a charter school in Peters

055Township and that question because of the timely the time pressures was not answered in this it was all the questions were supporting a charter school in Bethel Park. You'll see that I really did try here to give some because we're I think we five people show up at the public hearing so I gave that a yes even though it's five and I didn't do the math and say five out of how many people we have living in Peters Township trying to give the benefit of the doubt anywhere I could but answering this question all of the the the question that was asked is there support for Dogwood Charter School opening in Bethel? They were very specific opening in Bethel Park and again so that's what there was no there were no nothing for supporting an

056opening of Dogwood Charter School in Peters Township. Okay do you want to give I'm kind of asking the question there's three different parties here so I'm fine listening to all three. Yeah I mean again with what kind of answering his question was with the time frame of deciding that we were in Peters given the time frame I'd say yeah we you know we were able to have some support and and I can you know with our numbers of who was enrolled a third of our families were from Peters Township who were actually enrolled we had 12 students attend but again that's not big compared to you guys but for us that's a third of our you know our student well less than that but it's a majority of our student population from that district so

057Bethel Park and Peters were our two biggest numbers in terms of our students that actually attended Dogwood Charter School. All right thank you I have a bunch do you guys want me to keep going does anyone else want to rotate all right I don't want to monopolize this but I will all right um slide seven so is the governance structure and I guess really several of these I can wrap into it a question I have the next page Bethel Park's board voted to deny their application but then the state appellate board approved their charter correct yes yes okay it's a charter appeal board charter appeal board okay but and I guess because as I go through I question on you know on seven you know what are the requirements of you know the governance structure

058in several of the the curriculum items but if it did get approved already by the appellate board wouldn't these I mean maybe we don't agree with some of these standards maybe we question some of this but if this already been approved by that appellate board hasn't the state already signed off on pieces three four pretty much everything but location so you would think so but interesting at the same time uh the charter appeal board for the charter that they applied for in Chartier's Valley what I'm assuming the same application was denied and I went through it and it was denied for deficits in curriculum the ones that again we limited ours to the ones that were denied by the charter appeal board whether or not you know again I can't control the inconsistencies there so

059I don't know I did read a little bit about that Bethel Park did not really aggressively defend their denial now when cv did and there was a technicality with cvs where it actually went for a full review in front of the charter appeal board because they missed the deadline on a reapplication so when a full charter review occurred when the when the actual that's the state itself reviewed the charter because when it went from the district to the charter appeal board because of the failures at cv regarding timelines the charter appeal board reviewed the application just like we're had to do it because we can throw our hands up and say we're not going to do it like the charter appeal board do it um abdicate our responsibility in that case the charter appeal board

060denied it and again I limited our investigations to what they had cited in their denial so there's this has gone before two appellate boards one of which has approved one of which has denied it was the same board yeah it was just months apart from each other yes so it's same I know right we question that all the time yes so um right but I mean did they deny in the case of the denial was it based solely on location they had told us that it was based on lack of support in char valley a similar but in bethel park we had support because we got an extra hundred additional letters in between when we initially applied into our first hearing with bethel park okay one was a one was a review of kind of

061bethel park's denial was a denial appropriate which was different from starter's valley which was they actually the charter appeal board took on the evaluation themselves so and so yes you can maybe speak to this it is the the chart sears valley was a more that's more thorough because they had to act as if they were the chartering body and that's that's the discrepancy so um just like you would make the decision tonight to either approve or deny if uh or if you deny then the next step would be to then support your denial with written findings of fact which then the applicant could appeal and on appeal what would be reviewed would be your denial and what what your denial was based on did you appropriately review the criteria did you speak to the criteria

062in your denial whereas what happened in charters valley is they were looking more heavily at the application itself so the burden was on the charter on the charter applicant versus on the school district's denial so there's a little bit of a discrepancy in sort of the standard there okay and then shorthand might be scope of review okay that's fair and i've skipped a few of my questions in the interest of time i guess on the non-location items as we reviewed this did we reach out to dogwood and notify them of some of the concerns and give them time to address no that's that was that's a point of this hearing is to do um is to look at that so we don't work interactively with them to say hey you know update this this is

063the point of it at this point when we put this out there um if the board denies it the charter always has the opportunity i think as i mentioned before to resubmit an application so you can you can remedy your deficits by resubmitting an application okay and or you can roll the dice and say i'm going to go to go to an appeal with an appeal though is um is i think a little bit of a higher bar and because you have to get so many signatures when you can simply just redo your we're giving you your deficits now um you know you can choose to just remedy the deficits and resubmit an application okay um i do you have a response on any of that all right then sort of three last questions i

064think they're all solicitor questions if we don't vote by the deadline is it automatic denial or automatic approval or is it nothing does it continue because i know that they asked for more time to review that location so the deadline is march 1st um if you don't vote by the deadline then it goes automatically to the charter appeal board for their review so we're out of the loop at that point okay um are they allowed to apply in the different districts and not the regional charter so what i heard from the presentation this evening and i'm looking to you for confirmation is that you are applying in multiple chart or in multiple districts but you are only intending to establish in one district is that is that understanding correct i mean yes our goal is

065to be open with one school if we got multiple approvals then we have the option to decide because the the only reason i'm not saying a hard no to that is because we don't want to be large the only advantage and wouldn't make us necessarily a multi um i just lost the word for it sorry um is what would allow us then is because we're smaller to have some staff travel to different campuses we could actually help with the budget side of things um so we're not ruling that out but no the goal is to have a school if we found a locate well actually promising with the location in here so if we were able to secure that location here we would most likely again this the board's decision might i have a board

066to um represent too as well but to be open with one school is our goal so if it was just one school in one district then it wouldn't be a multi-regional charter school so they are meeting that because i know that that point was brought up of this appears as though they're trying to be a regional charter and it sounds as though they're not well well my understanding too with regional and this is just from our account so you can tell me if i'm incorrect with this is that with the regional is that you all would have met together and made a decision collectively and so what we're asking for is having separate applications at multiple districts because our attorney like i said had asked us are we trying to be regional and i said

067no we're trying to just have multiple options to open the charter school i mean that's correct i would i would argue that if you're applying as a multi-regional charter school then you apply as a multi-regional charter school and that's not what the case is here and i'm hearing the applicant say because that is not ideally what they are intending to do but they might if the circumstance presents itself again i would just say if multiple arise then you know as a school district or other school districts may consider whether or not a multi-charter a multi-regional charter school application was appropriately submitted okay and what last question before you go on can i just because it's the same thing um no no no um but if they were to have the two locations like she said

068is that then a regional charter school or not i guess my question honestly for you is like providing us multiple locations they're not considered regional they have multiple locations so i guess is what does that help clarify is there from from a default position there's already one charter therefore a second charter would be could be well it would be at least two so that that's why it's an unavoidable question okay and hopefully my final question if this board would vote to vote yes to approve this charter what would happen next would the um essentially if we if they found if they don't find a location then that's on them they can't set up if they do find a location and they're failing in this curriculum the state shuts them down right like well i guess

069what does happen next no so we would approve the charter for a period of time at the end of that period of time at the end of that five years then we would have the ability to review a charter renewal and at that time there would be a review of what has happened in the past five years but there is not really an intermediary step the state does not review an interim process of this not in the way that you are contemplating like shutting coming in and like shutting down for failure can i add so not that i wouldn't necessarily for this other but you can revoke it i mean if if you felt what we were in imminently not doing something that you could try or start the process of revoking our like you

070wouldn't have to wait till the five years if you genuinely thought that we were not following am i correct in that generally the point of revocation is is not grant i mean just candidly is not granted until at least that five-year renewal comes i mean certainly other school districts have attempted a revocation prior to the end of the five years but your first real chance to review the data to determine what happens next is at that five-year renewal i guess my response to that would be is with what we've told you you know we have surrounding us and what we've told you what we've done i guess my question would be do you think that we would do you know what i mean if things aren't working we just as you do when things don't

071work in your school you work to fix them and we have the support system just as you do to do that as well so in that five-year period there we don't have much oversight apparently we do have the ability to start a process but i'm sure that process itself is entailed and involved and probably unlikely we really i mean it's an illegal process legal process so it's going to take time there's no real the state then doesn't come in and monitor any of these standards okay but you do like she dr french would meet with us like bethel park we had already started the rubric and we would meet yearly and he had a rubric that we had to that he would score us on each year that we were held accountable that way as

072well so she would be able to do something like that as well if that is what you deemed they actually had dr walsh be in a class to learn from the philadelphia schools who have lots of charters he had been starting to attend an online course to learn how to kind of be the overseer because we understand that is a burden that we are not trying to add to your plate but we are trying to serve a need okay thank all three of you for dealing with me any other questions yeah for for the solicitor i have two if we deny and then they reapply what does that timeline look like there isn't a set timeline for a resubmission a revision and resubmission certainly i'm hearing them say they would they would hope to be

073open by the fall so i would expect the timeline to be pretty quick and then but if we deny and there is an appeal i just want to make sure i have my notes in front of me to get the dates right if they decide instead to appeal to the court they have 60 days after the vote of denial and in that 60 days they have they have to get a thousand signatures or two percent of the township of the population whichever is less and then submit that to the court of common please so there's sort of two pathways i thought with one if we were to reapply then then it sits a 45 day calendar correct for you once you reapply yes okay i wasn't sure if that's what you were asking it'd be

07425 days after our first board meeting that occurs after your application but we need we would need time to review it i just wanted to make sure if if we said denied and you all elected to not go the appeal route and you elected to go the update the application to that a standard and resub you know resubmit depending on how quickly they can turn that the window the door is not shut for this upcoming school year okay jenny do you agree with that statement or um anything possible we put people on foreign planets and on other planets but um my biggest concern here is getting a space and making up the code i know what we went through i know what we went through just for next door which was a school and the

075amount of time and effort we had to put into doing that do i think that this can be done i again you're at the i think you have the will but you are you're going to deal with municipalities and they're not you're they're not going to cut corners when it comes to children um i think that's an incredibly high hurdle i i can't unless they're moving unless the location they found is an existing school i i don't i really i would really um that would be a miracle to get it up to a space that's that's conducive for their educational programming and up to schools uh and zoning i just know having gone through ourselves i see it the same i mean i wrote down three things here that concern me with this and when

076i made the ticky tack comment that wasn't a slight it was just a reality of their compressed submission timeline and you guys have to grade them and if i'm in your shoes i grade them exactly the same way you did okay i just framed it that way so please don't take offense to how i how i said that um on the location so i guess i have a a third question now um like this just seems like the wild west welcome to the public school yeah so so let's say they show up and say oh man we got the building and we're sitting here there's 0.0 chance it meets code who makes that determination i guess it would depend on on what the concerns were i mean there are certain generally the zoning zoning hearing

077board or zoning officers are going to be the ones that decide whether or not the building itself is suitable for use of instruction for school children i mean so that's the ultimate answer from that standpoint it wouldn't be us it would be a public jurisdiction and they've any almost any structure can be a school but bringing it up to code for the purposes of being a school is is the issue so zoning is pretty much pretty much not going to be an issue i imagine it's going to be code issues there but there's an evaluator an inspector that assesses adherence to those codes yes and that would be part of this process yeah it would not be part of this process because if we vote to approve sorry it would be part of the process

078before they can allow kids enter their school or no yes just like what happened in bethel park okay all right there was not an ability to maintain that's a good example that i should have had in my head sorry thank you no problem uh my last question and this is probably a tough one to answer that's why you can pay the big bucks if you could frame in like 60 seconds you know you're asking a lawyer yeah something in 60 seconds but frame the risk of approving and frame the risk of of denying i'd be interested in hearing how you'd say how you'd couch that um i think i'm probably going to be able to i'll take a stab at it so the risk of denying i would say this evening is and i'm sure

079the applicant feels differently is fairly minimal because there is that resubmission opportunity and i know that dr french said and expressed concerns about you know the timeliness of that but there is an appeal there are two mechanisms for appeal and the one simply requires the applicant to cure the deficits that the administrator saw and reported out on i mean as you indicated were concerning um and you know that's that was their job and in reviewing that and and again as the applicant pointed out they were under a tight time frame and so there are deficiencies um so i i see that as a minimal risk because you're going back we've now pointed out those concerns and you have an opportunity to cure them based on the presentation that we've given the administrators have given tonight

080approval has just from a time frame and a legal involvement standard has a bit of a greater risk because hopefully these deficiencies are just a result of lack of time or you know other issues but we don't we don't know that because we don't have an updated application um if we approve it revoking or even non-renewal is a much higher standard for a school district to have to meet so in my opinion just when i'm looking at legal standards like the option of revising and resubmitting it's pretty simple versus what our and and you know obligation from the district would be to rehear it and revote within 45 days of that resubmission i mean that's all pretty low-level obligation from the school district whereas if we get into a space where we approve something and

081then five years down the road or sooner if you know if that comes up to revoke or seek non-renewal that then becomes a much higher standard with more a more involved court process that's a great answer you get the gold star thank you i have a couple questions just to go back to something alex had asked about um and thank you for answering all of our questions um about um the the avenue that you went in bethel so i'm guessing a pretty similar application was submitted to bethel park correct and they denied correct and so then you went before the state charter appeals board we have we reapplied to them as well and and it's a similar situation to here i mean we feel that we don't have those deficits i mean we do feel

082that those things are answered within our charter application we understand that you don't and so we will tighten that up even more um when given the opportunity to resubmit but yes we did resubmit to them again it puts you in this position right it's the state puts you in this position where you know you don't necessarily okay i'm not going there but um so yeah so they deny it again and so then we did go to the appeal board and we would have needed the thousand signatures but walsh felt that we showed support so he signed off on that so we didn't have to go through that step and we directly went to apply to the appeal board so they denied once denied second time went to the appeal board so it's my understanding the

083appeal board is the secretary of education um a member of the board of education a k-12 teacher a higher ed teacher someone who sits on school board that's what comprises the appeal yes there are certain yes and those people looked at your denied applications from bethell and that were similar to the one that we got and approved it yes and the application yes they didn't get just the denial they got our whole entire application and their denial it wasn't substantively different on curriculum and state standards or anything like that no okay remember under the scope of review issue they were only looking at evaluating bethel park's denial they were not looking at the whole application just at bethel park's denial sure but i guess i'm asking why they have they only denied based on the

084things they saw problems with which presumably another district wouldn't have seen problems with either i guess is my assumption there they were in a manner well i shouldn't speak go ahead you take that one so the denial was more of a when we're talking about standard of review the denial was more a review of whether or not bethel park got it right and what they reviewed as part of their reasons for denial not not the inverse of that which is was the application was the application correct so like so so you're saying that the bethel park missed some things that they should not have that they should have taken issue with our office represents bethel park so i'm not going to say that they missed anything um but that is what the review was that

085was looking at the the denial itself sure um and not as heavily focused on the application itself i get what you're saying but what i'm saying is the things that they didn't get denied on were probably not denied on because they weren't that contentious i mean i i just guess i'm trying to understand why that would have not have played a role not that i have it in front of me but they were similar denials is is what she presented today thank you and were they similar to the was it char valley char valley was a different situation um that one was before um yeah i would say they were similar really had a few additional ones which we kind of let slide because there were issues regarding the compliance with the application process um

086other ones but it namely it was the namely it was that kind of academic um limited scope which is is curable so when you went before the state appeals board did they require you to fix your application or the things that bethel said were deficient as part of that process no i mean it's looking i'm the way that i interpret is that they don't necessarily agree with the deficiencies in which and i know that's where i think we're disagreeing but um in those deficiencies because like i said they did they asked us questions about our charter application i mean they did review it i mean they reviewed their deficits but they also asked us questions on our charter application okay i don't always broadcast it nor do i make it a secret that in my

087day job i am a teacher so i certainly agree with miss knoll's observation that not every student can succeed in a traditional classroom and i certainly applaud what you're trying to do to help those students succeed find success nevertheless charter schools still have to meet standards and that's mainly what i wanted to ask about so pennsylvania has recently shifted science standards to these new steel standards and certainly all public schools in pennsylvania are wrestling with those changes and figuring out how to implement them and i think we're in the third of three years that the state gave schools to do that i was wondering if you could tell us how exactly dogwood charter has planned to address the steel standards and and remind you're just a k through eight school for right now right now

088okay so then then just deal with those standards well and that's the other thing too is is talking about you know obviously we apply for a six i'm sorry k through eight but depending on the the building we've also talked about possibly tampering that back a little bit just to give us more years in terms of all that but we do our board president is also a science teacher and is going through that process right now so leaning on that and leaning on our attorney just did a presentation with the charter school about how to incorporate all of that so thankfully we have people that are experts in that and will be helping us address all of that with our curriculum and also using gillingham as well who is currently in the process of that

089i understand feeling that their scores are low but their curriculum is solid and they have had 12 years to to strengthen that own racial model and so we were leaning on them a lot for to allow us to incorporate that as well okay thank you for that but i guess i was more asking specifics what specifically is it the dogwood charter intends to do to address those k through five steel standards incorporating those objectives into our curriculum okay then when you were opening i think you were open with what you said about six weeks before in bethel okay so at that point because i don't think the new steel standards go into play until july of this calendar year so it's for next school year so at that point it still would have been the

090old science technology standards and the old ecology environmental standards that would have been in place can you tell me exactly what kinds of things that you did in the past to satisfy those standards and how you assessed whether or not students had met those standards yeah so we were about to approach our end of term because we did trimesters not nine weeks so we did not have one completely completed but we do open-ended questions so specifically in science it's the same way asking them what they know i know in the middle school level they were doing geology doing rocks right beforehand so again you know the principal and we have a team of curriculum i am not necessarily that person so they are make sure that everything the teachers had to turn in their lesson

091plans a week ahead for the principal to make sure they have to standard line them put the standards next to every thing aspect that they were teaching to make sure that they were aligned and then the principal had the final review of that okay i know i'm without having the standards in front of me like i but i know i was i was in the middle school class i can give you right now because i know like with geology is one for the middle school when she was doing that she had the rocks out so i know that those things were addressed okay and i just can't give you quite the specifics right i did not bring the old ones ballpark how many or what proportion of the students did did y'all decide okay you

092have met these standards or this many not quite there yet if anybody and how did you assess that and decide where to move forward from that i mean we were i mean we hadn't gotten to that point yet being six weeks in okay all right thank you we had their journals and that's what she was using to assess anyone else one question oh go ahead hopefully quick hi thank you so much i appreciate learn all about this i have questions i know you mentioned the location that you had some i think you'll know by march 1st is that in peters yes okay and then how about the other places that you applied west jeff baudlin ringgold do you have any locations there that are so status on those yeah sure so actually oh my goodness

093right now she's doing it for west jefferson um so yes we actually are um going to that building on thursday um to um and we started the conversations with that township as well we actually have um relationships with them um prior to this so we're working with them um yes so we do have a property there um and then like i said i spoke to alex this morning and we kind of have a game plan of moving forward we're going to touch base again at the end of this week and then we'll be um continuing that plan alex is the peter yes okay so i'm sorry mr hardy i should have not said that one involved on a wrinkle um we did have one in baldwin but um it cuts out your students being able

094to be bus there so we're not approaching that one with as much um if we have good options here we'd rather stay here because pittsburgh public has lots of charters we are really here for the areas that don't have choice besides parochial schools and so the further we get closer to the city we feel like addresses the students up in there because that's a perfect segue and i've been really quiet through this in education as my background i appreciate what you're doing there i have toured provident several times and partnerships but it has a very specific charter for special needs students with dyslexia right like it is a very very specific charter it also is in what some would consider a failing school district it's part of pittsburgh public that's where their charter comes from

095and so i think it's just ingenuous to make some of those comparisons we're not a failing school district we're one of the top school districts in the state and so i i sit here and and i'm hearing all of these comparisons but it's not apples to apples it just simply is not um the the the education that students get in this school district is bar none you have a really high bar to clear just personally speaking i don't think that you cleared that tonight you didn't come with any specifics on any of the deficiencies that you address you have a long way to go in my opinion i appreciate what you're doing i know you love your kids i know that it's a passion for you but i have to tell you sitting here i'm

096i'm not satisfied with the answer i'm so sorry it's okay last call last question um at least for me maybe if the board votes to deny would you resubmit here and try to work with the administration to address the issues in the application simultaneously while working on the location i think you can probably read the room there's a few people on the fence and i struggle with no location and i would like to have some of the issues the administration brings up addressed and i mean we could make a you know continuum for a week but i feel like face it let's all acknowledge that's not enough time for you to adequately address any of these items correct so if a denial occurred would you work to resubmit on this end as opposed to going

097through the process oh yes yeah i think a reapplication would be yeah and the appeal board wants to see that you're doing that because you know what i mean they're kind of the last resort i mean the goal is to work with the district who's going to be the one who's going to be overseeing you um so reapplying right that was the question yes yes that would i mean obviously it's the boards are the dogwood's board's final decision but after the decisions are made we'll go back to them we'll say you know who are we going to reapply to because again and don't foresee us doing it for four districts that doesn't make sense um but going to the ones where it's viable and we feel is the best shot okay thank you i'm going

098to follow up with that then um i i'm going i'm assuming that you were not aware of what the district had found no not at all went on a limb and say you know blindsided yes by the district's position that that the way i i heard it this the ela and the math standards standards have not been met and i know i blindsided you on my questions about the science standards so if you are going to resubmit um i would appreciate specifics about how you can show okay peters you said we didn't meet them no you're wrong here's how we do yeah i think that that would be very very helpful thank you i appreciate that and again not making us use but being dyslexic recalling information is very hard so i'm trying to do

099the best i absolutely can't answer your questions but i will make sure we get those no that's fine and if i were in your shoes and and i had given you know me that question i wouldn't be able to do any better so um again i applaud what you're trying to do for the kids i appreciate nevertheless you need your information yep well no you we all need to meet the state standards and the fact that even if every other school in pennsylvania isn't it doesn't matter they're not the ones applying for this charter so but thank you this is the last item on the agenda when we move into the meeting can we just vote on it first so that everyone doesn't need to stay for the duration of our meeting yes we can

100move i just hate to make them sit for i really appreciate that i mean not every school does that i don't know if that's i'm all for what we're legally allowed to do we start if i need to i'll make a motion to do so to move it ahead on the agenda i just i'd hate to make them sit for an hour yeah if there's just a request to uh vote on i don't know what i'm sorry it's a it's a last item under other it's very last item on the agenda okay that's fine thank you seeing no more fingers approaching speaker buttons it's time for public comment and okay your limits up there already starting already so i thought i was going to say my name first okay um hello again i'm heather canviga

101mama's free two at tv and a preschooler i'm a licensed clinical social worker and a school social worker i'd like to take just this moment to shine a spotlight on a specific group of students that will benefit immensely from dogwood so we have the bell curve of students we know we have the 80 norm in the middle we have gifted education we have special education and we have so much individualizing and differentiating that happens teachers work so hard we know that and then there's a really special group kids who are twice exceptional or 2e they are gifted with a learning difference they are gifted with dyslexia dyspraxia adhd autism it's a unique profile super strengths and super challenges all at once makes for a very unique learning needs often their disability masks their giftedness at

102school a psychologist said this about one to a child this is not a matter of fitting a square pig in a round hole this child is a deca hexagon we need to create a deca hexagon for this child and all the teachers and educators in this room understand that because we know that when challenges in our neurological the most effective way to promote change is to make changes to the environment and provide accommodations so school teams work tirelessly so many teachers are so skilled and care so much yet even so in the best of school districts with the best of teachers sometimes a sidestep is needed a larger environment change is needed to a school where the foundational approach allows that kid to step through the door into a deca deca hexagon so good news

103there's growing body of research lots of neuroscience in the past 10 years about 2e kids the pennsylvania of association gifted education conference this past year was here in pittsburgh hopefully i wasn't the only one there in this room the keynote speaker was an expert on twice exceptionality there's growing recognition of this data literature across child psychology and gifted education about this extraordinary group of students and there's so much more to say about this but for now this is a real cohort of students with real unique learning needs who often do really need a different learning environment and these kids need dogwood to be an option anyone else nobody else signed up anybody wants to speak as two minutes because we will move it up on the agenda in our next meeting if we open it

104up public comment can happen at the beginning of that next meeting just so we can stay a little bit more on track but if we want to actually for the record now that i'm thinking about it for the record come up and speak if you want to speak for two minutes yes here again for the underdog my seven-year-old keeps asking me when he's going back my seven-year-old or your name heather mason bunker hill drive 309 to write that down my seven-year-old keeps asking when he's going back to dogwood and i don't know what to tell him um i want to be somewhat private for my kids but um and i probably said it before but uh we come with a package of neurodevelopmental conditions that i have pretty significant reservations that peters is going to

105address to my satisfaction and sitting here i can tell that there is a lot of misalignment in where we're coming from and where you guys are coming from and even though i can understand your point of view i don't think wherever as much as we can counter and answer questions i don't think we're ever going to see it eye to eye where we're coming from is a place to really address the social emotional needs that a traditional school setting cannot do for certain kids it just can't and i mean i have my own feelings on ips and 504s and metrics and things like that but um as an expert in child development it's very clear that there are certain conditions that a traditional school can just can't it can't meet those conditions for those kids

106so i'm here for my kids obviously but um there's a bunch of kids that i've met that in parents and um you you can hear it um just not from us but even from um the letters that beth may have given to you with the the family set who've been at dogwood um it's very needed and it's an option and i'm hearing about the five years and you know we're not sure after a year and it's a legal process and i can't speak to any of that but um my hail mary here is that you know if you just give us a little grace for a year just to see what happens with these kids because i need i need my seven-year-old to go back so that's it anyone else little raspy uh my name

107is rob martick i live at 316 scott um you know public speaking is kind of tough for me so i have to channel my inner gilbert from her vengeance on nerds um but um i'm neither would ever be labeled a jock nor a nerd and that's okay because i'm just a dad that's trying to best support his kids um in the ways that i never was supported um am i breathing too close i'm sorry um so uh what i mean by that is um when i first uh witnessed a presentation from dogwood um i it wasn't what i heard or what i saw it was what i felt and what i felt was is a school like this would have benefited a guy like me um you know 30 years ago as a kid um

108i am neurodivergent i am um i am high i've been highly gifted and i struggled throughout my life uh being gifted in the environments that i was in whether it was in my familial environment or especially school i i left peter's township and fifth grade and moved to ringgold um and that completely uh derailed me in regards to education um but uh over the years of pain in dealing with my neurodivergency i've created different ways to uh help support other people that do have it um and that's why i feel so strongly about this school and the way i i'd like for you guys to perceive it because on the the code level all the perceptions that are coming up here in this meeting whether it be from a code standpoint or a curriculum standpoint

109um i think it's all about integration um you know the code stuff and having a facility that would accommodate kids and their safety uh especially working with alex hardy i know him personally and professionally um their family's done a lot of great things in construction they're not going to let things not not going to let things slide um that's one thing i wanted to make sure i present to you guys to ease any of your uncertainties and fears um and when it comes down to um the structure of the school district as it stands i don't think that dogwood's trying to come in here and saying you're doing this wrong you're not treating our kids right i have two kids uh one's in bower hill one's in uh mcmurray um one of them struggles with

110reading um and they both struggle with self-confidence and i think it's because having to fit in uh i think a lot of it's they're both neurodivergent um and i think um they're a lot like me in that sense um and the reason i'm speaking here tonight is because i can see this from multiple sides of multiple coins and i would just say if you guys would consider an integration period to be able to work in conjunction with one another and i think peter's township would excel as a school district as a whole and all the children whether they're neurodivergent or not are going to benefit from that and they can be proud to say that they came from peter's township through the school district and you know through through where we live right um so

111you know that's all i have to say i probably went over two minutes or oh am i i still got a minute left oh i went over okay but i appreciate you guys not running me off um but thank you guys for your time okay um and that will put us at a point at which we adjourn the public hearing is that correct all right and we'll at least take a five minute break before proceeding

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.