CorpusRecord 72185

Board Meeting (12-16-24)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Peters Township School District
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Washington County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,692 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Okay, I'm going to try this again. Let me reassemble the gavel. All right. We'll call this public hearing to order and because we have people here who were not here before we will rise and say the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Mr. Brown, will you do a roll call, please? Mrs. Anderson. Here. Mrs. Bensey. Here. Mrs. Bowman. Here. Mr. Briegel. Here. Mr. Camilletti. Here. Mrs. Schotary. Here. Mr. O'Neill. Here. Dr. Payne. Mr. Taylor. Here. Any members present? Thank you. And I will hand the meeting off to our Solicitor. Thank you. Welcome to the special public hearing regarding a charter school application filed on behalf of Dogwood Charter School on

002November 15th, 2024. This is the last day that was permitted by law for the submission of a charter application for a charter school seeking to open at the start of next school year. Pursuant to the charter school law, the Board of School Directors is required to hold at least one public hearing within 45 days from the date of the application. Given the timing of the submission, the board was required to hold this hearing prior to December 30th, 2024. In order to meet the statutory deadline, the board is holding this initial public hearing solely for the purpose of hearing from the charter school applicant and the community. Following winter break and the completion of the administration's review of the application, we will hold the second public hearing for the administration to present its findings and for

003the charter hearing and the charter board to continue with rebuttal should it wish to do so and additional public comment. Following that, the administration will present its findings and the charter applicant may respond. The board will vote on the charter application prior to March 1st, 2025. As an initial matter, we will ask the charter applicant representatives to approach the microphone here at the podium, introduce themselves and prepare to give its presentation. The applicant and representatives will have a total of 20 minutes to present to the board. Following the applicant's presentation, we will allow for public comments regarding the charter application only. All public commenters who are residents or taxpayers were required to sign up in advance. I believe we have two registered public commenters this evening signed up. They will be permitted to have three

004minutes each to provide their comment regarding the charter application. Following that opportunity, other residents and taxpayers who have additional comments may be permitted two minutes each to provide their comments upon the application to the board. The public comment portion of the meeting will conclude the hearing for this evening. So we thank you in advance for your attendance and your participation. We will note that we have a court reporter present and so we'll ask that everyone speak one at a time and clearly to the best of your ability so that she can make a clear and accurate transcript of the proceedings this evening. And so with that, I will ask Dogwood charter representatives to approach and present as they see fit. Well, thank you for having us and my name is Beth Opat and I am

005the founder. I'm here with some families of ours and we my team is split up amongst three different districts tonight. So you have me to give all the information for you at the end. I will leave time if you have questions, but I'll go over our presentation at this time and even before beginning that I just wanted to make you aware in full kind of disclosure and and transparency that we are aware that there are have been complaints filed by a family whose children did attend our school and were previously enrolled. Throughout their time with us, we took each of their concerns seriously and followed established procedures and policies to address their complaints promptly and thoroughly. We collaborated closely with our legal counsel as well and to ensure that every step of the process is

006aligned with applicable regulations and upheld the best interest of our students and our staff. So as I said, I just wanted to state this to show our transparency and our well-being of our school community remains steadfast and we will continue to approach such matters with professionalism and care. That wasn't a part of the presentation, but I wanted to make that aware because we are also aware. So we are Dogwood charter school. This process has been a five-year process for us. So we first applied to Char Valley School District and then we also applied to Bethel Park School District. Bethel Park was our application was approved to the appeal board and we were we had delayed a year of opening until this fall as you know that we emailed stating with the building what kind of

007had happened and so in order to expand because we believe and our families will let you know as well how important and how needed this school is and just within the areas that we are it is hard finding buildings. I'm sure as you all know four that are suitable for school buildings. And so in order to allow us to be here for the families that need us we decided to apply to other districts to open up the options. So we are in the process of still the building that we originally had for Peters Township. They stated that there we have been talking with them for about six weeks prior to even submitting the application. But once we submitted the application they then did stated that we are not in alignment with what their end goals

008are for their location. And so we are in the process of securing another location and as soon as we have that we will make you aware of that as well. So you all have our charter application, but just to go over some main points of who we are. Oh, there we go. So Charlotte Mason. So you will hear a lot in the application of a relational education. And so she was a British educator. And really what it is is about her ideas and her thoughts and how relating to them. And so she believes that children are first persons. And so instead of an empty vessel to be filled but a fire to be ignited. And she uses the analogy of a banquet. And so it's really about a feast of knowledge. And we really focus

009on kind of the whole child and educating their mind body as well. And a familiar face that we are aware of is Fred Rogers. So there is a world of difference between insisting on someone's doing something and establishing an atmosphere in which that person can grow into wanting to do it. And Charlotte Mason talks about the atmosphere, the discipline. And so he did study Charlotte Mason as well among others that he also studied as well. So the best connection that I make for this area because we all know who he is. It is very similar to kind of how he approached it from a broadcasting standpoint. But what we're doing is in a school setting. So you'll hear a living curriculum. So what that means is it is all about the ideas and that they

010are narrative. So if you think of a textbook a lot of times it is the facts that are pulled from what we know about that topic and put into a textbook with a narrative or what we call a living book. It is really about the ideas. It's the person who's super passionate about that subject whether it be science or history. And then it is using their books to read to the students. And even though they might be younger they can still take on big ideas. So Charlotte Mason was very much about They will take in what they can take and what they can't they won't and then as the years progress they take in more each time on the topic. So as we all know toddler is running around talking to everybody and they are

011able to give a wealth of knowledge even at a young age. So it's really tapping into that using narrative and living books. Going into that with the narrative books as we call living books. But in addition to that so the Charlotte Mason is the main piece of our curriculum. But obviously we need to make sure we're encompassing all state standards and make sure we are addressing all of those needs. So in addition to the Charlotte Mason curriculum that we use that was curated by Gilliam, which I will show them later, is Singapore math that we have purchased and used and also the really great reading program which is a multi-sensory program. So a lot of our students are neurodiverse. And if you're not familiar dyslexia is one in five people. Myself included and so the

012really great reading using the multi-sensory approach really helps with them getting that foundation of learning. And so we found success with that for the time that we were open and we'll continue to use them. So our aim at Dogwood Charter School is to create a school that lifelong learners who are culturally literate and socially and emotionally responsible. And how we will do that is to achieve that rounded goal is to Sorry, there we go. Learning a foreign language. So at the beginning we are starting with Spanish. I would like as the years progress to also incorporate American Sign Language as well. But this is all K through 12. This is not starting in middle school like a lot of our schools do. We know at a young age children are able to take on a

013second language. And so that is K through 12. Obviously STEAM is also integrated through our living books in all of our subject areas. Exploring natural history through nature study. Again, but that is a piece of our science. It's not all of our science. It's an addition. Learning to play a musical instrument. Again creating those synapses in the brain at a young age. Research has shown is beneficial to all students. So K through second grade they learn piano in a group format. And then after second grade and third grade they can choose an instrument. We would have a selection that they could choose from that they could do starting in third grade. Read and perform Shakespeare. Even our little ones did that as well. I was in observing a classroom in third and fourth grade and

014she said get ready for Shakespeare. It's next and the whole class cheered and I just stopped in my tracks. Because I would not have cheered if you told me I was learning Shakespeare. But like I said little minds can take on big ideas and that is just proof of that. And so they would do that at each grade level as well and enjoy it. Also becoming versed in literature and the arts as well. And then exploring math like I said kind of the Singapore way. And this is for all of our students K through 12. And we did find with the Singapore math especially in kindergarten that a lot of our students were kind of past that. So we can also supplement and add in as needed as well with doing assessments and benchmark testing

015along the way. And so like we talked about a love of learning is really the goal. We all are excited to learn and for some reason as we go through school a lot of times that changes. Not for all students. Like all students don't fit the mold of education that we have. So this is just another way of educating students. It's not going to be for everyone and that's we're not here. You do that well. We are for the students that need something different. And we have found it to be successful even in the short period of time that we were open. So being nourished by great books and ideas and focusing on the whole child. Again not that you don't. We're not saying these are things you don't do. We are just doing it

016in a little bit of a different way. A lot of times these are children that have anxiety and stepping into a classroom full of 20 some children or in just in a large building can be very intimidating for them. We have lots of remarks of parents who the students that would cry every day going to school or cry when they got home because they were overstimulated overwhelmed and that didn't happen once in the short period of time that they attended our school. So it is just a dramatically different impact for these specific students and we have approved private schools in the area. We have other options for certain students but a lot of these students aren't identified. They just haven't found the way to thrive in our school districts the way that we have them

017now and this gives them that ability to thrive and become magnanimous thinkers and doers. So what sets us apart is pretty much what I just said and we do believe and has been successful in a public school way because again a lot of these schools are private schools. Charlotte Mason schools are all over our nation and in her prime in Europe there was 420 of them and so you know they still exist but we believe this can be done in a public setting. Obviously if you research her you will see that religious religion is a part of it but we've separated that being a public school it cannot be a part of it and will not be a part of it and so we've been able to remove that piece and be able to educate

018these students the way that we feel they need to be. So sorry about that there's a little different online screen. Charlotte Mason and the constructivist approach so that's kind of the best way for us to explain it and also as you know Piaget and Bogotsky also very similar as well and so her main approach is the constructivist method which again instead of just passively learning you're actively engaged and being able to take that information easier and the big piece of that too is the educator is a facilitator so instead of you know it's more of a back and forth relationship and again some people take that relational education and think that we just mean relationship between the student and the teacher. It's not what we mean we mean the relationship with the teacher but also

019the ideas and what they're doing in the classroom so as that teacher is the facilitator is kind of what brings that out. We know all of your teachers also have relationships with your students we're not saying that we are saying it's also a relationship with the ideas and what they're doing. So the benefits to you so again serving a population of students that may need this and also of being able to be a model school that is one part of being a charter school is how can we use this to educate kind of our community and even take pieces of it back into your school districts and so one of our goals is kind of researching this and seeing the impact. Like I said we got to see it for a short period of time

020but seeing long term what that impact is on all students but specifically special education students as well because it is mainly an inclusive setting for special education students obviously we do it as needed for those students so it's sometimes hard to tell you exactly what it would look like but I know for this year what it looked like is it was mainly full inclusion with pullout as needed and social groups and things like that as well. We do have a partnership with the Teen Outreach Center in Mount Lebanon who we had just received the PCCD grant to be able to have them come on board as well and offer that service to our students through counseling through social groups and also pushing into our classrooms as well. So we would like to partner with you

021in offering another opportunity for students in our community in your area and so I spoke oh yeah so our model school and consultant so I spoke briefly about Gillingham so I just want to go over if you're not familiar with them they are in Pottsville Pennsylvania and so they started doing this 13 years ago they are the first public charter school to have to be using Charlotte Mason's pedagogy and so we were the second approved they have about 250 students enrolled their population looks very different than ours in this area so it's not comparing really apples to apples which some people try to do their population their special population is up to 30 percent ours was about identified about 20 percent but we believe it was higher than that we had three students in the

022process of being evaluated even within the first month of school their disadvantaged population is much higher than generally in this area and they have met their state growth standards as well throughout the time that they have been open and they have already renewed once as well and they are in the process of their second renewal as well and just to show kind of their student population like I said is different than it is here so their test scores are sometimes reflective of that but even if their test scores are on the lower end they do show growth which is here so you can see that they meet the standard statewide growth standard in all of their categories and exceed it and two of them and that is from the future ready be ready so yeah

023that is kind of our presentation of what I have for you if you have any questions if there's information that I did not discuss tonight I can answer that for you thank you thank you so this is a time and opportunity for any board member who wishes to ask any questions of the applicant to do so now yeah so you you started in BP this year correct correct how long did you operate until October 25th and how many kids did you have at the time that you ceased operation yeah so we had 72 when we started when we ceased operation about it changed because we were we had pause people were hopeful that we were going to reopen we were hopeful that we were going to reopen so some held on for that when we

024initially had to stop we had still 60 some students at the very end 42 roughly that we still had what happened to those 42 that yeah so good question all different things so at that point some are being homeschooled I would say some went back to the home district but honestly not a ton a lot went to cyber and then so yeah kind of those three categories some went to cyber school some there's a couple that went to other charters but only a handful because there isn't there's only really one other charter in the south hills and then homeschool and then some did go back to their home district as well and what specifically was the problem the building so so whenever we initially went into the building with the that it was a continued

025use because the building was already had occupancy for educational use and so we moved into it with that understanding we had a lease with the church had gone through with our attorneys and all the processes that we believe we were to had followed the township felt that we were changing the use and needed our own separate occupancy and so at that time we were trying to work with them to stay in the building they were not willing to allow us to stay there unless we brought everything up to current educational code which we knew was not able to be a possibility so we searched for other locations we did find one in another district that was willing to allow us in the township had voted yes but the district did not feel that they were

026able to allow us to move temporarily to that district so we had families holding on and it was devastating for all of them and so obviously we don't want that to happen again and we aren't willing to stop because we saw the impact that had on these students and so that is why we decided to apply to other districts so what are you going to do to make sure you don't start and yeah cut 60 some kids right education yeah no we've already reached out to the township and peter's township and of all of our other applicants and have already started that conversation every time we find a building we check in with them as well and getting all the steps that have to be done prior to and how many different districts have you

027gone into and applied because i mean that as i recall this came in at like the 11th hour right before so how many different districts did you three others three others so four total correct because it's kind of like a hail mary right you're hoping you find something but at the same time while you're doing this you're you realize you're costing this district money and all the other districts so you're taking taxpayer money because you don't have a plan right now to be able to create a school for students that need it you don't have a plan and you're you've just spread out as far as you could and you're costing taxpayer money across many different school districts understood thank you excuse me ma'am you said correct me if i'm wrong you said you started

028with 60 students and then at the end it was down to 42 73 at the very beginning my mistake thank you 73 to 42 approximately so and about when did you start and when did things end for you september 3rd okay and then we stopped educating students on october 25th okay so rounding off two months can you tell me what happened to the students that left during that two months why they left where they went oh there were some well most didn't start leaving until october 25th we didn't officially say that we could not reopen until um november i want to say 12th okay so you had all 73 through what point ballpark 73 probably up until right at that point and then it each week it dropped from there until okay like the 40

029some of the very all right so when you say up until that point was that october 25th or yes we only had i think two families leave between opening and october 25th oh and one was that she felt that you know her statement was that she had never been homeschooled before which were not a homeschooling school but that type of environment she did not adjust well too so they had left and then another family similar situation okay so you had the most of the 73 up until october 25th and then from there until the what point i'm sorry i thought you said that you ended it october 25th that is the last day that we educated students we were hopeful that we were going to reopen in a new location oh and that's what didn't

030happen yes okay all right i think i get it thank you yes it's confusing what happened between october 25th and you said november what was that last date you had in november everybody just stayed at home didn't come in not educated at all and then they went back to their if they went back to their homeschool or whatever they lost almost three weeks of education we sent home information we still met online we weren't able to count it as days because we were not able to apply for flexible instruction days that deadline ended before we were able to apply for them and i tried applying for them even after the fact they wouldn't allow us so we still did instruction it just could not count for the calendar days for them but there was still

031instruction happening for that reason to not leave them without instruction given the period of time of instruction i'm a little confused about what this says this is gillingham's that is not ours so that is to show you what gillingham what they have at their school the growth that they have done our students never took the pssas yet this would have been the first year okay but what i see here is that um in english language arts and literature they are not even meeting the statewide average in mathematics and algebra they're not meeting the statewide average and they are exceeding slightly in the science and biology am i reading that correctly yeah you are are we celebrating that well their growth so their growth is good but if you go back i can go back so

032because their population is very different than here so a lot of their students already come very many levels behind and so that is why their growth is what it is based on um where their economically disadvantaged students are coming from okay and what are the qualifications of the people providing instruction yeah so we had um so with um charter schools obviously the goal is always 100 certified teachers but sometimes you have highly qualified teachers that are not 100 certified and so our uh we had 78 percent um that were certified in their subject area um obviously special education being 100 so that teacher was 100 certified in pennsylvania for special education so um yeah we had our certified teachers we also had a principal um that has to be certified we had a school certified

033nurse as well and out of the four teachers that we did have um and that are certified had stated that they do want to come back and teach once we open as well thank you with the the other school gilly gillingham yeah is dogwood affiliated with gilliam so no so we use them as a model because you know whenever i started this process i knew that there was a need for students to be learning in a different environment and i didn't want to create the wheel um i had looked at the kind of the fred rogers kind of idea but again he was broadcasting not 100 education so when i um from a connection in the charter world had introduced me a family friend to gillingham and so the more i learned and saw what

034their structure was it was what i wanted to do here um being out in nature having more hands-on approaches short lessons for the kind of the neurodivergent students that cannot handle long lessons all of that was integrated what gillingham did so we reached out they were willing to work with us um and then kind of give us they're more like a consultant so we are separate entities um but we do look to them for assistance when needed and we do use their curriculum for the charlotte mason piece because there is not any other and a lot of it we have to create on our own as well um because there isn't a um secular um charlotte mason curriculum there are some for homeschooling families but none for a school okay thank you what exactly is

035singapore math yeah so it's actually what the um um common core standards were kind of created from um so it is a different approach of teaching math um so it is more hands-on manipulative based instruction um and kind of developmentally appropriate starting in kindergarten and it goes all the way up we used it up until eighth grade this past year can you give me an example so using like the i mean using the manipulars using dominoes for counting and using counters and using the cubes that stack and using all those kind of ways of of kind of concrete math practices through that and they also do math games like we play blockus um sometimes to help with the spatial awareness and games and so there's different avenues that are used to create it thank you

036there's scope and sequences online as well that is aligned the biggest concern or one of the biggest concerns i had with respect to you know you said it was a five-year process for you you used you know this gillingham as a model and yet you know you have these kids in there and i mean you were honest and said it was devastating to them but it um in my opinion it's it's very poor management and if it were what experience do you have in knowing uh if the next building you're going to have the same problems because at first we were told that you were looking in a particular building in peters township which would not be zoned such that you would be able to use that and so it seemed to appear that it's

037going to be the same thing over and over and over again how are you going to in what experience do you have to make sure that the next time this isn't going to happen because that is you know the beginning of the school was hard but to go in and then to have to switch to something else especially for these children that you say have anxiety or you know aren't easily able to go into a new situation and have them go somewhere else it's very disturbing yeah no it was it was awful um so we have a team and a part of that is obviously we would not open without having a building that everything is prepared and ready ahead of time we do it is was zoned properly but you can get conditional use

038if it's not zoned and you can get variances so we now have a company called lighthouse academies that helps us as well in terms of the building like i said we have reached out to the townships already and anytime we have a building we reach out to them saying x y and z what do we have to do in order to the big thing is when it changes you so if it's a continued use then um it is grandfathered in terms of coding and things like that with a lot of these situations that's not the case and so we have to meet with the township and knowing what we have to do to bring it up to um code for in order to have students be in the building because like it like the building

039we had it already has students currently in the building um but a school is a little bit different so there are different coding things based on the amount of students in the days that they are in the building so we will use them to help us as well and we have our council um as well and we have charter choices that helps us with all the finances and business side of things that's actually the third or fourth time you've referenced council and i would be were i in your shoes i would be somewhat concerned about a council who put me in a position where these things were surprises to me um did you have that same concern um yes we have talked about it um and we did bring on other council during the building

040issue as well okay so go to pittsburgh you're making efforts to get ahead of that yes okay is there a building yet in peters um no not currently are you able to say are there options that you're are you able to say what options you're looking at i cannot yet but we are looking number of options three in peters yes do you have a building in another district and and if you find one you know we're talking about obviously the money spent hiring the court reporter everything like that um but if at what point if you find a building in another district are you just going to withdraw your application then or how is that going to work that is not a new decision um to make but if that is what you prefer we

041can definitely have that conversation i can take it back to my board um as well and there is potential for that but we would need to know that we are approved in another location and and like you said have the building yes the plan is not to open a bunch of schools it is to find the right building that is suitable for our needs and to open we don't we want to be in the south hills um because that is where our population the third was from bethel park a third was from peters township and then the rest was kind of spread throughout so a lot of people say why don't you go to the city but that's not the population that we want to serve they have charter schools they have options of the

042three other districts from meetings tonight which districts uh baldwin and west jefferson hills okay and peters or is bethel off the table or is that still being explored we are still having an approved charter there so we are still working pursuit of a building it's uh beth right yeah hey thanks for coming out here and uh giving us your pitch and fielding our questions uh it's an important important thing i've read this stuff you guys have sent us i sat through your presentation so the question i'm going to ask is probably repetitive but i'm still i still feel compelled to ask when you think of success your meaning in this world as it relates to dogwood can you can you just walk me through like what kids what families like take me on that journey

043yeah so the best way that i can describe it is not that these children aren't being served where they are but they most likely are surviving and not thriving so they are having to deal with the circumstances that are given to them and as children tend to be resilient they do it um we know suicide is an epidemic um in our society and so my goal is to allow these children to have a place where they can thrive so like i said a lot of our population was neurodivergent so a lot of students um diagnosed with adhd anxiety are the bulk of it and the reason we didn't go like the approved private school route or a school strictly for children with special education needs is because i also feel that it allows for any

044student to thrive in this environment and we didn't want to be um you know discriminatory in that way we wanted to be all-encompassing of all students but the ones that thrive the most in this situation are those types of students thank you beth one follow-on um out of the 72 or 73 or 42 wherever you want to put that number how many um could you ballpark the percentage of your student population that you would put in that category oh like not even necessarily being identified yes i would say at least 80 percent thanks what grade levels does dogwood charter target yeah realized i didn't know yeah so k-8 is what we start opening and then adding years on and honestly that will depend on the building so if we um some of the buildings are

045not large and so if that's the case we may come back and ask for an adoption to those grade levels um but we did open this year k-8 and then expanding each year after that um a lot of charter schools will only do elementary or will only do up to middle school but because it is such a drastic different way of learning um and there isn't kind of another school besides their home district or a cyber school we felt it was necessary to go all the way up to um to 12th grade okay also you had mentioned uh forgive me these are not exact quotes but i'm just referring to notes here you mentioned that you do need to address all state standards and also at one point you said you found it to be

046successful i'm assuming it was your approach to education yes so what i'm wondering is can you describe for me how you planned or how you measured that success what your plan was to measure it and how that unfolded right thank you yes so i guess when i am stating that it was successful i'm thinking more of kind of to his question of the emotional piece of it based on how the students were during the day the feedback that we received from families but in terms of academic doing benchmarks so as they came in we had started doing with the really great reading and singapore both have assessments to kind of see where the students are coming in we had actually also applied for the firefly that is currently the state is doing where you can

047do benchmark testing through that as well to getting ready for the psas and then obviously our students would do the psas as well and so that would also be another form of of measuring whether it's successful or not and also in the charter we have multiple goals i think five that we also will be tracking as well too for our progress and showing success and just like you probably do as well parent surveys and things like that of tracking that progress as well so your students took the psas then yeah okay so but then again that takes me back to my original question if they didn't take the psas and yet you just seem to refer to the psas in your answer to my question so i'm confused how how will we check it so

048no how did you you said you found past tense it to be successful i said emotionally so we have parents are raised and from the feedback from the parents is why i'm saying it was currently successful okay and then the as far as meeting the state academic standards yeah i mean we weren't even finished with our first term yet so there isn't we don't have any evidence so when you okay so it just to be i'm not picking on you just to be clear when you say you found it to be successful it was the emotional learning part not the academic part yes okay thank you thank you very much um the board appreciates your time and engagement and with that we will now shift to the registered speakers consistent with the legal advertisement for

049this hearing it's my understanding from mr ral that there are two registered speakers the first on the list at least as kept is heather matching is that i apologize okay so we had two heathers miss uh panzika please if yeah if you would um take the floor you have three minutes and if you're trying to track it will be reflected up there okay thank you yeah hi i'm heather panzika pt mom of three i have a three-year-old and i have a first grader and a third grader is everybody hearing me okay and i think it's okay um who are happily very happily attending um pleasant valley elementary school i think it's relevant to share with you an additional lens through which i'm viewing dogwood i'm a licensed clinical social worker and i'm a credentialed school

050social worker i worked for san diego unified school district as a licensed mental health clinician for eight years before coming home with my young family to the south hills so as a clinical social worker um kids social emotional well-being and mental health in the context of their learning environment is hugely important to me and i'm sure i'm not alone in that um it's my opinion that pv does a really good job of attending to the whole child in the traditional school setting i believe they do the best that can possibly be done in a traditional school setting um and this is not about but this isn't pd is a great school but this is about and peter's township has great great we know the best schools um and offering dogwood charter would only enhance this

051district i believe that with my experience i believe that with my knowledge my research and with my heart as mom um as as a clinician data and evidence-based research matters i'm also sure i'm not alone in that um dogwood 100 aligns with all of my values as a mental health clinician and as a school social worker sometimes people think alternative the word alternative takes us away from evidence-based in this case that is not true um the practices of dogwood um are very grounded in in evidence-based literature and i would be happy to be a part of providing that literature if that hasn't been done already and if that is a need um so my my intention as a parent as is probably true for most of us as parents is to just stay tuned in

052to my kids um to their well-being to their learning needs some of that is wired um and fairly fairly fixed some of that much of that is changing over time so i just want to try to stay tuned in with my kids and make the best decisions that i can for them in that moment right um and over time i would feel so grateful if dogwood charter in peters township were a part of that equation that's your time so perfect i'm done so i'm a really proud peters township parent so thank you thank you and then also registered was a heather matching nation please thank you do i have to press a button no i will do that and you'll get to see it up there um okay good to go all right let's um

053okay so i came i'm prepared um because uh i've been thinking about what i should say for a couple of weeks and it just is not going to be condensed into three minutes so if you're if you want to talk to me later uh i'm happy to speak but i think that and heather combined right here um did a really good job uh kind of summarizing from the professional experience and then a parent experience and i just want to play off of that um component that we talked about is the emotional component yeah it just feel awkward um looks like it will uh okay so that's good um so the emotional component i am a mom um to three also three boys um we've been in seven schools um by by nature we moved here

054a few years ago started at a couple schools that were outside the district and um and now i'm counting the three that they're in currently which is uh bower hill mcmurray and the middle school um they're doing well um but i'm also a mom to um neurodevelopmental differences that are across the spectrum lots of them lots of acronyms um my younger two were the ones who started at dogwood this year and i i don't want to get emotional here but um the difference in them was night and day coming off of the bus and um i have one of my kids who was to the point of um self-harm where his prior school was very resistant to um offering any sort of assistance um even though they could observe the behavior um in the classroom

055so when he started at dogwood i was very nervous um you know going in on a venture not being an educator myself um i am a general pediatrician with a niche interest in neurodevelopment um and see kids like this a lot um but so i went in uh full speed ahead um because my youngest case he knows beth um from preschool and uh his experience at preschool was the best of all the schools we've ever been in and so i trusted her and the difference in my sons getting off of that bus after the prior years that we've been here was so tremendously different that when we went down it was obviously very hard and i used it as a teaching point um to talk about resilience and so they're fine but they're not good

056and that's what she was trying to describe the difference in kids surviving in school and thriving and you have an opportunity whether you want it or not is up to you to give these kids in this district and the surrounding areas who might not be doing as well as they could be doing giving them a chance to really meet their potential to have their teachers really pull what's in them out of them and i don't imagine could you wrap up i appreciate that thank you i don't i don't know what's going to happen with my kids um but it it was not a mistake to send them there and now i feel really good that we took a chance so i hope that you do thank you and so that represents the two registered speakers

057um associated with this hearing this evening there is i understand a a last opportunity for any other district resident or taxpayer who wishes to offer comments to step forward and do so these will be two minute public comments please identify your name and your street not necessarily your full street address for for sunshine law purposes that'll that will suffice so if there's anyone else this is an opportunity and again as identified at the beginning of the hearing there will this hearing will be continued to another evening and at that one as well there will be a another opportunity for for folks to participate okay are there any speakers please come and join us all right do i have to press a button or you've got me i got you okay i'm teal larson i'm on

058bebout road um i am a former title one reading specialist and english language teacher now a software engineer completely unrelated to the educational space but i'm a mother of three students um two of which are in peter's township one of which was in peter's township all three of which were at dogwood at the beginning of the year and one thing that i think the other folks who've spoken this evening has really hit hard on is the social emotional aspect of dogwood which is incredible and also one of the things that that brought about that i did not expect was the academic engagement so my fourth grader struggled through first second third grade the special education here in peters has done wonders from him he went from like the fifth percentile to like now being able

059to read a bit amazing he was coming home from dogwood after being dragged through you know novels in third grade along with the class he was coming home and like explaining the entire um plot of these novels multiple ones that he'd already read within the first month of school um his he started writing independently the the engagement that i saw because of the relationships built in the classroom the relationships built the the setting that was being built up was incredible i can speak more on that um but another thing that i want to hit home was a comment that he made to me driving home one evening from a club the first time that i'd ever been able to get him to sign up for a club was this year like this school somehow the

060lights went on for him in a way that i have never seen or dreamed and he said to me mom i have a school where i can be myself sometimes when i was at the school i was at before i would get asked not to stim in class because it was distracting i'm paraphrasing he's not quite that articulate but essentially like he'd get asked not to stim because it can be distracting and here at dogwood he said you know i'm able to show up and be myself and that was wonderful and i'm over time thank you so much for taking the extra time this evening thank you are there any other comments please thank you my name is adam white clifton road baffle park um i have two children that attended dogwood charter school and

061oh i'm sorry sir are you a peter's township resident no i can't talk no not this evening um there are other um there are written submissions there are other ways that that the that the school can share comments from from others and i would just encourage you to reach out to miss opad and and i'm sure she could help find a way to do that for you thank you all for being here tonight no thank you can you hear me how close do i have to get i'm carissa quenlin i'm on robin hood lane um so my experience is a little bit different than the other families who have spoken because i don't have kids who had already been in school i don't know why i'm emotional tonight this is it's honestly been a really

062amazing ride and it was definitely challenging but um so when we were making our choice for school this year we live pleasant valley school district we have i have a six four and two year old so we're a young family this is our first experience in the school system um and this all started by me just exploring full-day kindergarten options i knew beth from st david's preschool which is where my oldest went to school and so we had found out about dogwood and i really fell in love with the style of schooling um we went down a road of research listening to podcasts and and my daughter hasn't not succeeded in school so this was just a what does this option look like peters township is an incredible school district i grew up in washington

063i know nothing but good things about peters um so it was never anything about peters doesn't work for us it's just about but what about this too um and so my daughter absolutely loved it there it was such a family environment she knew the older kids um we would see videos of the kids playing music together and like laughing and i remember looking at those kids being like when i was that age i feel like music wasn't fun like that like we weren't laughing we were it seemed like a like a dorky thing to like um and just the the collaboration of the whole school and the being outside for lunch every day with her classmates was something that really spoke to us she's doing great at pleasant valley she does come home with like

064a stack of papers do i think she'll thrive once it's time to have timed tests i don't um but i i do think she'll be fine i do also think that having options for students and families is really important because as as strong as peters is academically i don't know that every kid needs to fit in that box and that there are so many other ways for them to to learn and to love learning thank you anyone else all right seeing none um we thank everyone for for their time and their attention and engagement this evening um and with that we will conclude the hearing for for this evening uh any future hearing dates will be legally advertised um and uh the applicant will be provided notice directly of of that hearing thank you this

065meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.