001good evening and welcome to the special meeting of the rner Township School Board to discuss Ean Elementary School uh today is February 18th 2025 um as a standard with our board meetings we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you um I have been asked to tell people I feel like I'm being thrown under of the bus here that the power's back on at the high school so if you were hoping for another virtual day sorry um but thank you very much to all of the parents and teachers and administrators and staff who uh handled that last minute change of plans very uh
002well this morning and thank you to um Pico for flipping the power switch this evening um I'm not going to report on Executive sessions we'll do that in the regular meeting of the board next week um is there any public comment this evening public comment at a special board meeting is restricted to the topic of the board meeting okay seeing none I am going to turn this over to Mr Morris thank you good evening thank you so um as we spoke back in the January facilities committee meeting um this evening we're going to give a comp very concer comprehensive update on Ean elementary school so um I'd like to take a minute to introduce uh a few people who are going to head off that conversation and and presentation tonight we have Steve Barons from
003brein architecture uh Walt Tac from site logic our construction management and Damien Spar also was site logic so welcome gentlemen all familiar faces good to see you all right so we have five key elements of tonight's presentation that um the team is going to go over um including some upcoming board uh decision making dates um uh an update on the schedule where we are with permitting um and and breaking ground uh the construction phasing plan which some um some have seen already um and was presented to the the township Land Development last month a a project update and as well as the construction cost estimate and information about an early demolition package so um without further Ado I'm going to hand it over to the presenting team and can I just ask for clarification is
004it helpful to you if you just give the presentation and we save questions to the end I think that's usually simplest unless there's something you don't understand I think it'll keep things flowing more smoothly if we have the presentation first good evening I'm Damen Spar and I'm going to lead the presentation off uh the first couple of slides are some introductory slides for us and um Mr Morris has gone over the agenda relatively well the next slide will show you that agenda and the first thing that we're going to be talking about I believe is the upcoming board meeting decision dates importantly and most boards like to know this so we want to make sure that we explain it is as you move down the path to making these decisions about spending money on facilities
005where are our our points where we have decisions and if we don't want to proceed or we want to proceed differently where are they so what we have in front of us are in March authorizing an early demolition project we're going to outline that for you tonight that project really needs to happen regardless of when or anything about the iean site so the basically that's something that can be done early with no fear that it doesn't need to be done at all and that's not a a huge expenditure the bigger expenditures come and in fact that get get authorized is authorized for bid in March but authorized for approval in May the current schedule is for authorization to release the full project to bid in June so the March and may meetings I think are
006relatively uneventful you'll have that explained to you tonight the June board meeting if for some reason we got to June and we said we need to hold up there's a place to pause importantly in August that's when you would vote to proceed and that's when you would vote to spend a significant amount of money and that's that August board meeting is is the real last stop that stop point that you would potentially have so we made this slide so you could easily see those upcoming decision points March and may not not being um really that significant at all but the big ones being going out to bid in June and authorizing construction contracts in August I'm I'm sorry Steve do you want to as we get through these at these renderings do you want to
007just take a minute to describe what this view is happy to do so thank you while we're talking about the nuts and bolts of the project we want to we've interspersed some renderings these are updated images that have been developed as part of the the design as as it is completing and just uh a vehicle to help us to remember what what the goal is here with all of this work this is a a perspective view from the main lobby of the building looking at what will be a an open two-story space with a stair communicating stair within that and here's a a good view of of how the the building looks out to the landscape and that's been a common theme and speaking towards the biophilic nature of engaging with the landscape and um
008and natural views to the outside so you'll see a few renderings sprinkled through here as as we continue the conversation the next portion of the agenda is a schedule update and it's important to understand that as we have been working through our design schedule you know we've we've come across things that have impact it and I'm going to be the first person to say as I sit here and those of you that may have been involved in the interview process will remember I had my hand up and I said this preconstruction and design and permitting schedule seems awfully long to me well guess what it probably wasn't long enough and so some of the things that we've run into are not only our understanding of of the local municipalities permitting process which we saw for
009the high school which is is taking longer through this process and I think it's taking longer as a result of some thoughtful consideration later on you'll see that even we've been working with the township and we've actually avoided some cost because of our collaboration with the township but that was not something that the team envisioned at the start based upon our experience not only with the high school project through the brein team but but my personal experience at going through projects even at places uh locally that that take some time so we have we have this process and it's also had other impacts from the sewage planning module what was required was a study of the existing s storm sewer or sanitary or sanitary sewer thank you for inflow and infiltration this means is is
010the sanitary sewer taking in water from rain leaders and things like that or are there broken pipes and it's coming in from the earth why are we getting more sanitary flow than we should get I have this is the second project in my career I've seen this on so this showed up now we have to monitor it well we can't monitor it if it's not raining and it didn't rain for a long time and we actually had an an impact of closer to three than two months there and some of these are overlapping we we had traffic analysis in impact which happens from time to time we talked a little bit about the Land Development process and and that's reflected in the current schedule we are working through the npdes which is National pollutant discharge
011elimination system that work we kind of expect to have issues from time to time and we also are working through the sewer module and I think if if Mr Barons needs to elaborate he can we at the beginning of the job we had to make a decision whether we're going to ask for an ex ception to going through the process or going through the process and we actually I think we asked for the exception and we got rejected for it would have been quite simple if we could have gotten the exception and sometimes those are granted so you almost have to ask but doing one than the other in in that series can have an impact and it did impact us we also were put off by um some working with the shade tree commission
012by a month but we thought it was important to delineate some of the things that we've been running into really with the permitting process and offer really explanations not excuses there are things that that you're gonna we're going to talk about tonight where we're putting our hand up and saying this is unusual to us and we didn't see that and I'm the first person to say I sat in the room with everybody and I said I don't think that it's going to take this much time I Mrs Stern is smiling at me and I know that part of it is because she said to us several times this may take longer and I think that was a good point to her even though a lot of the stuff that was that was part of what
013she was referencing part of this and was absolutely right as we got into this some of this other stuff was outside of that but um Mrs Stern I did want to recognize that you did say that for sure so the next slide shows our typical update that is showing us where we are now red is some of these major time frame so we've basically finished construction documents we are looking for a release for bid in June as you saw before bidding in June and July uh contract award and issue issue in in notices to award in August and then later in August a notice to proceed that notice to proceed says go start procuring you're going to be able to work on site really starting in October and you you can see that a few
014lines down this doesn't change where we end our work um that's that's moved around a little bit and we're starting in starting in this time of the year is working just fine for the way that we have it scheduled the next slide shows um some ongoing challenges and then after this we're going to talk about uh the advantages that this schedule has with it ongoing challenges I've kind of uh alluded to we've we're waiting to work through the the the sewage module approval the good news and the bad news are both that it's with Department of Environmental Protection that can be a place where things get stuck the good news is site logic has a lot of has some former D folks and we're able to unstick things from time to time should they need
015it so I feel better than I've ever felt in my career about saying something's with d and if we really need to make some phone calls we may be able to get some good action there the Conservation District permit for that mpds is we kind of can rely on where that is and I think um we've seen letters of completeness now for our administrative submittals and that's moving the way that it should be I think that we have a good view on the Land Development process now I'm going to take a minute to talk about the way that we um see things in construction when we're doing design the further away we are from either going out to bid or starting our project the foggier it is and the closer we get the more that
016fog Burns off and the the clearer we can see we're at a place we can see very clearly and we weren't at a place where we could see that clearly even back at design development so we're we're feeling that the schedule that we have is is represented that it would be easy to say boy is this going to hold and and and I'm telling you while we don't know everything that we don't know or some other things can happen we feel pretty confident in seeing what we're seeing now because we have that Clarity the last line item here is related to work at Sprout road if we are required to do that we can bucate that from the pro the major project and have that on a separate track and won't hold us up from
017the rest of the work it would be a question of how much do we have to spend on it we have $250,000 I think in soft cost to potentially put toward that but that's a question that we have if you go to the next Slide the advantages we're we're capturing higher numbers for ACT 34 by waiting past this July to award contracts we're doing additional quality control quality assurance on the bid documents the schedule maintains the demolition of the existing building over the SE the the summer months we likeed that before we visited other options we rethought it and we're back to that and we we like we like the way that sits as it sits now we have the ability to get ahead with things like preparing color schedules we have the ability to
018present the design again to the community as we continue to work I I want to say there's more time here for us to continue to find ways to reduce costs which is not up there um we're creating the opportunity that allows for this additional or for this early demolition package which gets things out of the way and kind of clears the deck for the start of construction the the shade tree uh discussion has really reduced costs our work with them has reduced cost of the job and we're going to continue um to to work with rner Township to that end so that's what we're seeing right now with the schedule I'm afraid I'm gonna have to step out for a moment okay so the um next I guess Steve you want sure yeah so this
019is a view um looking at the the Brick volume of the library with all of its uh natural light and glass this is looking into one of the uh three um Courtyards that are between the uh classroom wings that looks back towards that main lobby that we saw a moment ago and this is also on the extreme left of the image you'll see the Outdoor Classroom that has been um designed into the project again one of the things that that that took a little bit more time but is going to provide great benefit educationally and experientially for the school and so this is this is showing a a view of the landscape looking back towards the building okay um next I just want to walk you through the um the construction phasing plan um we
020this is you know as as dam had had indicated we had been working through different options for phasing uh with the current start date this seemed like the most logical uh approach to the project uh we have already reviewed this with the township uh they're they're fine with it but uh if you want to go to the next slide there there we go okay this may be a little difficult to see but um if you look in the top of the page there's an orange bo uh rectangle there that is the uh Annex Building the plan is to demolish that uh over the summer and install a tempor build a temporary playground area since the new building will be going in the same location as the current playground so we need to find a a
021home for uh for a playground that's this area we just chose to uh to use so that'll be going on in the summer so when the students return to class in the fall they'll have the new playground in place um once we start with construction in October uh the intention is to enclose the entire construction area with a chain link fence uh we are looking at some options to uh what kind of covering we want to put on that fence uh in the areas adjacent to the school uh one option we looked at was a simple um cloth filter that will filter out dust and and you just the visual uh uh aspects we also were looking at options for maybe some sound deadening material there is as a possibility um but in any case
022we will encircle the entire construction area with the chain temporary chain link fence uh to separate construction activities from uh the public and students um the entrance to the uh building will be they will enter through the main entrance drive to the campus and right at the first bend the first 90° Bend to the right St the construction traffic will split off and uh go along the back of the new addition so all construction traffic will enter through there we'll separate them out pretty quickly we will have a uh contractor parking area immediately to the right of that driveway uh up a little bit above that is the uh area where we'll be putting in the um geothermal wellfield system um there's 200 Wells I believe it is uh that we'll be installing there um
023that'll be we'll hope to begin that in the fall uh that'll take some time there to install uh and then we'll buil there will be a as you may recall this building we're building into the Hillside and the lower level of the new building is basically one floor below the existing building so in order to maintain a safe eress for students out of the build the existing building while we're building the new building we're going to put temporary Shoring in there to uh to hold back the Earth and maintain the grade along the outside so we can maintain uh egress around the back of the building um we'll build the building that we anticipate taking until uh this uh June of 2027 in June of 2027 the building will be complete the school district will
024be able to start moving in uh furniture moving over furniture from the existing school getting everything ready there um so that come the fall students can start classes in the the new building over that summer also uh if you want to ship yeah here we go over that summer excuse me we will begin demolition of the existing Elementary School the goal is to get as much get enough done so that we can get the new Bus Loop in uh so that we have an way for students to uh get to this school either be dropped off by buses or parents and picked up uh we'll we'll use that Bus Loop for both and we believe there should be an adequate room there to stack both parent uh cars and buses um and then we will
025install a portion of the new parking lot lot that is not within the footprint of the existing building so that there will be some parking uh available for the school we also intend to use the tennis courts for additional temporary parking most likely that'll be staff parking uh in the on the tennis courts um so when students arrive in the um fall we'll have that tennis we'll have the Bus Loop ready we'll have a portion of the parking ready we'll have tennis courts uh turned into temporary parking as well um you will notice in this phase again we are encircling the entire area this time it's a blue line around the outside for temporary fence we're always going to try to maintain that a we're always going to not try we are always going to
026maintain a construction fence around any construction activities to uh keep them first of all to keep safety for the public second of all to keep the construction debris from blowing off the site um but that'll be going in at uh during that construction also during that summer we will be reconfiguring the um driveway the entrance drive into the uh campus it's primarily following the same line but a lot of it's getting rebuilt uh so we'll be repaving that and having that ready to go uh when students arrive uh then the next fa next slide shows when students return the areas in tan will be under construction there will we will still have a at the bottom of this page there is a um existing storm water detent or at at that point it'll be a
027settlement Basin uh basically an open Basin to collect sediment off the construction activities that needs to be maintained until we have all the parking lots stabilized uh so that'll be still in effect in place we will have that fenced in we will have the area of the existing school be where it has already been demolished now we're putting the parking lots in uh that'll be fenced off and then we'll also be fencing off around the play Fields up at the top uh and the uh storm water detention Basin at the top of the page there as well that'll all be fenced in uh students will be able to like I said buses will come in parents will come in drop off on that teardrop Loop um they will enter through next to the gymnasium we
028want to try to keep them away from the construction activities as much as we can so we aren't going to try we're going to try to avoid bringing them into the front entrance to the building just because we want to keep them away from construction activities to the greatest extent possible we will um public will enter though through the in the um entrance next to the what's the proposed kindergarten Wing at the far end of the building there will have to to be some sort of temporary measures put in place as far as a temporary desk or something to monitor that monitor that uh that door but we think it's probably prudent to try to keep as much tra pedestrian traffic away from the construction activities as we can um excuse me the um the
029other thing I should point out is during these activities uh we will be putting jerse barriers between the construction activities and in addition to a fence it's six foot chain length fence we also have Jersey barriers between any any paths where students will be walking and the construction activities to make provide an added level of uh security and safety for the kids um we just frankly I don't trust a chain link fence enough to stop a roller or you know a any large piece of construction equipment so we felt that Jersey barriers was a prudent measure to put in place for that this will last this phase will last until December Jan uh December 27 January 28 at what point we will complete the construction um and be out of everyone's hair uh I guess
030the last thing that will happen is I mentioned that um sediment Basin at the bottom of the page that will get converted to uh the underground storm water detention Bas permanent storm water detention Basin that we've talked about um but that'll be one of the last things we do as we're heading out the site that in tennis courts because those tennis courts have to be done after the parking's finished and restore the tennis courts that's right okay this is a view of the cafeteria so this is one of the large Gathering spaces in in the building you'll see the glass to the corridor on the right hand side the serving area which is a wide open inviting area in the center and then more windows to the exterior with with a high ceiling to uh
031to allow for an open inviting field of the space and yes and this is the art room so this is on the lower level underneath the library and this is is a uh one of one of the most exciting spaces in the building for its connection to the outdoors The Outdoor Classroom is immediately adjac to that and a view out to the to the Courtyard as well so an opportunity to take advantage of Outdoors for for art activities and um should be a very memorable space for the students okay and F uh I guess not finally but the the other the next item is reviewing the budget the estimated construction cost of the project with you um as you recall we uh site logic prepared a schematic design cost estimate in uh October of 23
032I can't believe it's been that long already um and then in may we came back with a design development cost estimate we've uh made some suggestions on how to reduce costs uh presented that in June um of last year and now we're back again with uh an updated cost so if you look at that you can see there's a column for each of those cost estimates uh we are currently running a little bit over our uh schematic or our design development cost estimate after cost reductions however on the building side I believe we have found enough additional cost reduction measures um to keep get the building back within the estimated cost site development costs are up uh about 1.1 million that's a little more challenging to find enough money without creating uh issues with our
033permitting um one of the things we have to keep in mind is we don't want to delay the the permitting process we have to be judicious in how we approach cost reduction measures there um but we are uh the and then the F the other things that have uh come up and this is I I'll be frank with you this is on me um I did not we did not anticipate or did not include in our budget uh costs for playground equipment and we did not think and at the time I think we were not anticipating using the tennis courts for parking so we hadn't included any money to Reser redo the tennis courts there's about $2 million where budgeting for that right now um so that's a big chunk of where we're over on
034our costs on the project right now uh I think we can find most of the rest of the pro the uh cost increases we've found enough to eliminate most of the rest of that um but the the playground equipment and the tennis courts probably is uh little more than we're going to be able to find we' been able to find so far anyways we were able to reduce our soft costs uh if you look the soft costs are down about $842,000 that is primarily because we had budgeted $2 million for um the financing cost cost of issuing Bond issuance I'm not sure if any of you recall but at the during the ACT 34 hearing uh that cost was projected at $1 million so we've updated our cost estimates based on that and brought our
035soft cost down so overall we're about $2.3 million over where we were at uh design development um there is a chart charts a little bit further we'll follow I'll follow that little bit before you continue I wasn't expecting Walt to say that that was his responsibility because I thought it was mine because I've been here the tennis courts and particularly playground equipment again not offering an excuse but I'm going to tell you what what happened what happened to me as I looked at this early on we had a a lump some kind of a lump number for our site yes thank you sorry early on we had a a big number for site work cost and the site wasn't developed enough for us to really bar it out any of that which was itic where
036my regret is is design development I wish I would have been able to tell you this at design development we' have had the same problem we have right now but we would have known it earlier and that's really where I I feel that we did not perform the way we should have I wish we could have identified this at design development maybe we didn't have the ability to design to identify that we didn't have the tennis courts because we hadn't planned on redoing those yet but I don't even know that my my regret and my apology is related to fact that we didn't pick that up at design development much like with the schedule as we get closer and closer to our bid period and our drawings and draw are much more refined and much
037more detailed and we have a full scope of work for for site work which we didn't hear to four the clarity that's available to us is much different so and we're comparing this project to other projects that have bid to see where are we does it make sense and we're using all the metrics that we can to say one have we seen everything that there is to see with regard to what's in the scope and having a number and two do these numbers make sense when compared to other projects and things that are going on in the industry in our area so I wanted to I wanted to put that in I was not expecting Walt to say that it was on him um because I've been here and you've seen me more than anybody
038else I think that's on me and that's what happened so the next slide is a rather difficult slide to present in a uh PowerPoint uh however what that what this slide tries to do is uh demon relay where the cost increases and cost cost went up where cost went down and how it all stacked adds up so we had our design development cost estimate um and then our construction after cost reductions then our construction document cost estimate and that variance and then if we take all the alternate bids out of the site work which was $461,000 a uh a relatively smaller amount but and then how that compares um quickly uh you know we we mov some money from our of General conditions from the building to the site work uh probably just an accounting
039thing um demolition is pretty much the same the uh well field is increased in cost and that's primarily because we've moved the well field further away from the building because of uh the uh some issues with storm water management trying to work coordinate storm water management with the the do you mean the geothermal excuse me the geothermal well yes um so that that increased that cost a couple hundred, because there was we moved it away uh five or 600 feet uh and there's numerous lines that had to be run between them um Earth workor and Grading is up mainly because we did with design development we didn't yet have a grading plan put together so we were kind of taking a a best guess what we thought how much Earth we thought we were going
040to have to move um pavings up primarily because of um some additional work at the entrance drive but also um I think we're just uh with the price of oil asphalt prices are up we hadn't fully anticipated that when we put the last estimate together um concrete site concrete is up mainly because there's more retaining walls than we site retaining walls than we had anticipated uh concrete retaining walls and um Landscaping is up because we had not fully I I had not fully appreciated the the extent of the the trees that we were going to be required to have uh by the tree commission even though they were reduced from what they could have been yes yeah it's good point yeah with probably reduced several hundred, dollar worth of landscaping um we did pick up
041some money we um we saved some uh several hundred, $270,000 on storm water Management Systems uh was a little less extensive than we had anticipated if you recall we were kind of shooting from the hip a little bit whenever we were discussing which storm water detention structures to put underground which put above ground so there was a little bit of guess work in there but that that worked out in our favor um we took a harder look at the contractor overhead profit on the site work and decided that we were a little fat on that before uh paired that back and since the design is pretty nearly complete we felt like we no longer needed to carry a significant contingency in our estimates we could pretty well dial in what was in the project we
042were able to eliminate our estimating and design contingency at this point so all in all um you know we're we're up about after cost reduction measures about $700,000 on the site work uh similarly we have a a comparison for the building costs um again you know I talked about we move some general conditions cost from the building to the site so that General conditions costs are down Footers are a little little more cubic yardage of Footers than we had anticipated at design development design wasn't fully complete at that time uh so concrete's up uh steel is down significantly and that's primarily because as we started doing more research into the market conditions for the cost of Steel structural steel the costs were actually down we're hoping that holds we're not sure there's no way that's
043going to hold no and I'm not laughing it's we we are con frankly we are concerned about that and that we'll talk about that in a little bit um the um there was a little bit more wood block or quite a bit more wood blocking than we anticipated um glass and glazing is up we had not anticipated uh the amount of laminated glass that we're in installing in the building uh basically anything within about 8 ft of the ground uh around this building is laminated glass we had not anticipated that in our estimate um that may be partly because I'm just not familiar with you know my first rodeo with with rner Township um I think that came about was decision decision during construction documents um Safety and Security flooring is let me make sure
044I'm getting the right lines here yeah flooring's down quite a bit and that's just a refinement of our costs um excuse me no that's going to be one of those things youo is still in there yeah as an alternate as an alternate so it'll go up to get to yeah that's yeah that's yeah I'm sorry yeah the 1.1 million because actually we're we're pretty close on before that there's a lot to dig into that's why I'm happy you're here yes yes you're you're right though the uh the 1.1 million was is primarily the alternates to eliminate the terazzo uh and some of the and reduce some of the other flooring um a few more marker boards we anticipated uh a little bit more casework than we had estimated um and HVAC uh if you recall
045at design development we were we're still trying to decide which type of hvac's system we wanted to use when we were uh estimating at that time so the drawings were very schematic in nature mechanically major piece of equipment were picked but we then rearranged everything because we decided to get rid of the saw to roof and go to the flat roof and put the equipment on so everything got redesigned uh and it just ended up costing more than we anticipated um electricals up a little bit primarily switch boards and panels and uh but we again paired back our overhead and profit from the general from the contractors and uh excuse me eliminated the the estimating design contingency for 1.6 million one of the things that I think is important to remember and I've said this
046before what's what is here in design maintain the program that was desired it maintains some things that have been very important over the course of time to the district whether it's a geothermal well field and and using uh you know that sustainability piece or whether it's how we're dealing with our underground versus surface storm water detention there are things here that that we have kept true including and importantly the the program The Challenge that we have is that when we decide we're going to set to a number and we want to buy as much as we can for up to that number or we want to make it as low of a cost as we can and have options up to a certain budget amount that gets that can get pretty difficult to do and
047this is an iterative process now coming in here and saying we're within $2 million on $77 million is not a lot of money when it comes to estimating and what we expect estimates to do we don't expect estimates to be perfect we know that they're going to have 3% deviation we try and estimate on the high side we have the project that we just reviewed today that was awarded in the fall and it looks like it's showing that we're estimating a little bit on the high side and it makes a lot of sense and it's one of those metrics that I noted but I think as we look at is terazzo going to be an alternate and all these other decisions that we're going to be making and the things that you'll get to decide
048when the numbers come in and we know what the Market's going to tell us things cost please don't lose sight of the fact that we have not only an amazing program that fits within the rner Township School District way of teaching children but we have an amazing building we're just kind of picking and choosing levels of finish and other things like that that we want in this so that we can Target our best and and most appropriate cost of the building and expenditure decision so it's very challenging and as I said before I think with full drawings that we now have we are we are seeing the things that we need to see but don't lose sight of the fact that we have not changed this building in any major way away from program and
049away from these things that that the district has hold near and dear the next um graphic this is actually a pretty good graphic this is kind of tells the story of how virtually every project that we uh that I've handled through preconstruction has gone you you set a budget up front schematic design maybe the cost eek up a little bit at for your design development estimate you do some cost reduction measures you bring it down you can see you know went from 72 million up to 83 million then we took we cost uh reduced the cost by about $6 million with various cost reduction options cost eek back up again a couple million dollars at construction document estimate and now we're bringing it back down to the uh 77.4 million brought it back down to
050to that $77 million range so it's that give and take that that typically happens it's you know just like any project you you look at all the stuff you want and then you look at the price and you say well maybe we won't do that maybe we'll take this but we won't do that and that's s sort of that give and take you always and you always want to have some of that it's actually a healthy process sometimes it feels a little frustrating but it's a good process because it helps you make sure you're making the right decisions well I think does that does the um total cost after DD after cost reductions I think that number was closer to 74 actually I think it was between 74 and 75 million and I think what
051you're showing there is before bit alternates before the bid altern before the bid alternate so I don't I don't know if some of you were noticing that but I was looking at that I was looking for that 74 point something number and that's where that should be yeah and we'll we will re we will relabel this and resubmit it to the district yeah I was having trouble following the numbers because our schematic that we were talking about back in May was 69 then we went to 74 with the total design development ultimately at DD we did go to 74 that's correct it designed about yeah which is what got us to the 75 number that we've been talking about I think the yeah there's a bar or two missing because we the first time we
052saw numbers it it was not 72 million that may have been before site logic got involved is my guess there were were numbers I think were at9 ASA we were also talking about okay okay that's just think in terms of I'm not sure yeah I think I I think I know what happened with the design velopment estimate that was um before the bid alternates and and maybe that you know to keep this moving forward clean this up to go using slide 19 and slide 22 so go back and if you could put if these dates could match with slide uh 2019 and then also add if there are additional ones that we should have had that would be make it a little clear thank you and then the next couple slides are um various bid
053alternates that we anticipate including in the documents the purpose of the bid alternate is giving that flexibility so you can maximize the the value you get for uh and stay within budget so there's a number of alternates the yellow ones are new ones that we've uh suggested since design development the uh white ones were all were reviewed at design development with you um these are still in works this is not a uh hard and fast list uh we will continue to refine this list and and work through it with uh leadership and try to come up with a comprehensive list but this gives you an idea of what kind of things we can we have on the table I I I don't know what the rest of the plan of the meeting is but there's
054a lot of changes here I I I'm going to want to see what a picture of acoustic tile looks like because the the slide tonight is still showing the wood no I think technically it's I I I've been marking each page trying to figure out which thing from the alternates list has been changed in the pictures yeah it it's just flat I think it used no it looks like wood on got a little bit of a grain but I think it's supposed to be switching to acoustic time yeah I I agree I think we need to see pictures of what these changes would be because I think this budget doesn't reflect what the board expected um yes the the intention would be that when we come back to you in May probably uh go go
055through the alternates in more detail would that be appropriate time probably we're going to have to talk about that because I don't think I'm going to approve any other steps on this I'm not the only person but I don't think I'm going to vote to approve moving forward any further unless I understand what this is all going to involve that's conversation yeah okay but we we we definitely want to give you as much information as we can up March conversation yeah yeah I was just say there's a March early demolition project vote so I don't know how we're going to get to that okay um but you need to feel comfortable with the decisions you're going to need to make uh so whatever information we need to provide you uh certainly want to do that
056um so rather than go through all the alternates because I think we're going to end up going through those line by line as a group can we can you explain to us the I guess the act the last couple slides so we can move I I know people are going to get ansy about questions on some of this so um as you recall at the uh act 34 hearing we set a um maximum building uh construction cost for the project uh there were two couple numbers that we set the one that's that is uh the most important is What's called the total estimated aggregate building expenditure uh which is the cost of the building construction not including any site development costs um and that would the site development cost would not only include you know
057the paving and dirt curbs and sidewalks and dir work and storm soures also the geothermal well field and the electrical incoming service and the electrical and site lighting um but it would all that would not be excluded from the construction cost T so it's the building construction cost the architect's fee for the designing of the building not including site development and then Furnishings fixtures and equipment so that's for the the the at the ACT 34 hearing we set the 49819 the 3 million 071 765 for design cost the 1.2 million or the 54 milon 090 as the uh total estimated building expenditure at that time the aggregate building expenditure St uh limit as set by the Department of Education was calculated to be 55 m772 188 so we were about $1.6 million under the that
058limit um we've just recently learned actually just last week we learned the Department of Education is going to be increasing that limit by 2.66% as of June now oh is it a retro iMed immediate oh immediate okay uh so that increases your limit to 57 m191 th000 uh we are currently like I said estimating it at um yeah okay yeah 54 million 90 um so that will put us about $3 million under the uh that act 34 limit uh then in addition to that you have all your other uh your Co soft costs your site development cost your s additional soft costs um an additional construction cost brings us to the total of$ 77.4 million for the project but we've got a one of the good things about the delay is we have been able
059to uh take advantage of that increase in uh expenditure limit uh so it gives us gives you a little bit of flexibility if you decide you want to spend more money you don't have the Department of Education breathing down your neck saying no you can't not saying you have to FIB our neighbors the it does give you flexibility within the $75 million that we said with alternates that you're you can spend on the building as opposed to not being able to do that because you need to have a cushion for some potential change orders to the building itself not a big cushion but but some cushion that's important to note because the the uh aggregate building expenditure stand that act 34 limit does not end at a w of bids it carries through construction so
060any change orders that you may have have during construction that affect the building cost have to also fit within that limit so you want to leave yourself some room for those so you aren't getting yourself into trouble when you get into construction and I think the do you want to explain the early demolition yes so and just so I can for people who this is a new kind of broken out phase that wasn't originally part of what was proposed this is part of the proposal to actually keep this moving even though we're so far behind yes exactly this is I'm sorry it wasn't included cost wise so it wasn't included broken we haven't talked about it previously wasn't a separate bid but the costs were in there yes that's the answer to my question yes
061yeah the costs were in there but just we hadn't planned on doing it quite like this um and the reason that we we're proposing this is now we're not starting construction until October we need to have this playground in place whenever students arrive um we don't want to be holding up Construction in October trying to get a playground in place uh we want to get going with construction right away so the intention is to release an early bid package to demolish the two existing houses and backfill those foundations um demolish the Annex Building and prepare that pad for a temporary playground and then install the temporary playground and then there's a few trees right around the vicinity of the uh existing school that we want that are going to need to be removed in order
062to build a new bu building we want to do that while students are not in the school um those those are large trees we do not want to be cutting those down while kids are in the school so we want to take those out also uh over the summer um So the plan with that is uh that the district would uh has authorized site logic and Ela to go ahead with start getting started this Administration has um we're working on the design frankly we're going to be designing It Anyways um we need want to submit to the township for permits in March we have been assured by the township that this should be a fairly simple permitting process should not be held up by any of the other our other permits um intention would be
063for in March for the board to approve uh authorize us to solicit proposals for this work work um we would release that for bid on uh in late March uh receive bids in mid April um come back to the board in April with the bids and then in May the board would author would approve the award of that that bid it would just be one contract um and then in June we would issue the notice to proceed and then as soon as school lets out we would start construction and complete that for the summer those dates make sense provided we answer your I think there's going to be a lot of conversation about what dates make sense um so can I just clarifying on the the temporary playground that you put that the be proposed
064to be put in during that demolition time that's something we need anyway for the project it's just that you're putting moving that up to make sure it's in place before the school year starts And to clarify Mrs Stern's question all the costs of this demolition were built into the original proposal there's not an additional cost for breaking this out and doing it separately no that was always sort of budgeted for the project so yeah Okay who wants to start I'm gonna go last because I have a page full of questions I'm hoping some of you will ask I just wanted to clarify one thing with the uh with the early um demolition you mentioned some tree work that you weren't expecting was that cost originally included or is that an additional cost the the um
065I think what you're referring to uh we I had not fully appreciated the amount of new trees that we would have to plant these are existing trees that have to be removed uh and if you're familiar with that campus there's some large trees there that we'd rather take out without anyone in the building so we had always planned on taking the trees down it's just about when we do it and we and we had always planned and estimated to take those down correct be careful how we explain this so just back to the trees do we have to take out these large trees unfortunately we do um they the primary ones are basically behind the existing Elementary School um and are right basically in the area of the main entrance to the new school so
066wouldn't it be lovely to have Heritage trees at of the exist building well that's different it would just be my request it's always my request to try to have save as many trees as you possibly can you can plant all baby trees we've seen this before 25% of them die and it doesn't look look the same as a rner campus from from the very beginning um with respect to the parking lot layout we have if if you think of the large oak trees that are near the existing Bus drop off um where there are healthy large uh Heritage trees we we've attempted to preserve those and there are several examples of locations where we were able to adjust the grading such that those existing trees could remain they'll be protected during construction as you know
067that can be a challenge but it it's it's uh incumbent on us to to document that properly so that um we can preserve those so the the the the trees that that Walt's referring to in this part of the conversation are those that are literally within the footprint or within the excavation area of the new building and they just simply can't be preserved um with regard to the playground equipment is there playground equipment that's there now that you can salvage that we don't have to we looked into that 1.5 million on new playground equipment we looked into trying to salvage some of that playground equipment and what we were being told and I've heard this numerous times before and having worked a little bit with putting these comp uh systems together it doesn't surprise me
068that it was going to cost as much to try to salvage them as it would be to buy new um if you've ever watched one of these things go together they are an absolute erector set and there's you know it takes Ikea to a whole new level as far as you know all the different parts and pieces that go together and if you start pulling them out you know you end up buying new hardware because the hardware is not in great shape or you damage it uh and by the time you end up with it you might as well bought new on unfortunately so what I'm going to say is I think about this really differently I think I'm I'm not so hung up on all these little changes I have a hard time following
069all of that what you know what we decided before I'm I'm looking at this thing globally and you know what I said from the beginning this CA we were discussing a 50 million Elementary School I'm still stuck on that and then it was like oh these things change these things change now it's up to 70 or 75 million and all along I kept thinking well surely there's a way and Miss Duffy asked this at the very beginning she said isn't there a way to get back down to 45 million and we never I felt like got satisfactory answers to that and now we're talking oh there's another two million shoved in there we're up at 77 million I think that that's an exorbitant amount for an elementary school and so I'm not hung up on
070oh you know this went up 100,000 and for me it's a fundamental question of we we asked for that in the beginning I didn't want this to be much more than a $50 million elementary school and all of a sudden it's now 77 million and and growing because we're still you know things are falling behind prices are going to go up there's going to be all these change orders so I'm uncomfortable with like why isn't there a way to get this back down to a reasonable cost for an elementary school why why why do we keep talking about what this um you know this ratio is from the state I actually don't care what their ratio is if they say we can spend 57 million that doesn't mean that we should so the process frustrates
071me because we asked a long time ago for how can we get this back down and and we were told these ratios that you can spend you can spend up to this limit we're fine because we're only a million below this limit that's meaningless to me to me it's $50 million is a lot for an elementary school 77 million I think is exorbitant and so I'm looking at this globally that's and that's so that's where I'm just stuck and so you know I understand you're going to have to go through and you have a hard job because you're going to have to answer everybody on all these yellow changes you know but to me that just reinforces that there's Savings in here so why can't this be back where it was when we started that's
072where I'm stuck Susan sorry Miss Stern that's okay yeah um thank you for bringing the information I I will say I I Echo a portion of what Miss Solomon is saying only in this regard um as one of the few votes against this particular version of the plan I expressed concern at the time that the site costs were a lot and they've grown exorbitantly it's um and you don't you don't know this I can't remember wal but I actually voted against this particular school now I respect the the vote of the board um but it's it's hard and increasingly difficult for me to swallow the site cost plans the site costs um I'll leave it at that it's increasingly difficult for me to swallow the site costs um and to see two million here and
073two million there and to be told that that was basically what it would cost for us to move children off campus and build the school um in the location that it currently sits um and yet we're just going to all of a sudden be up a few million dollars it's it's I I Echo Lydia it's hard and I don't ascribe to the notion that just because we can spend 57 million we should spend 57 million um and and the final thing I'll say about the numbers and goodness knows I love to talk about numbers is um I think we are all kind of fooling ourselves that these are the numbers because until we get back the bids these are not the numbers these are the estimates of the numbers and I remain concerned as we're
074kind of betting against ourselves right now uh we keep jacking up the price and I'm more anxious to get the cost out there and let the market tell us what the cost is and start there so that's what I'm going to say about the cost um sewer planning module yes I understand about the inflow and in infiltration I'm a little surprised that part of town you're coming into that problem only because the houses are not nearly as old as downtown Wayne so I'm a little surprised about that and normally you get your sewer planning module done in Final Phase uh final approval of Planning Commission so I guess the good news is that you found out that there was going to need to be extra work on the inflow and outflow early in the process
075um rhm has held up sewer planning modules for a long time that's the rner marle haford sewer planning module commission There's an actual commission that looks at our sewer flow we didn't get hung up at the high school I believe because we could State honestly although we were adding more bathrooms we were not planning to increase the size of the school with the number of students so we could make an a reasonable argument that we were not um increasing the outflow interestingly you know of course we are proposing if as we do a rebalancing of elementary schools here in Radner that the the outflow there would be more students at this building but I have a an interesting thought occurred to me listening to you today um you might be able to pitch that the
076overall outflow from our three elementary schools would not be increasing because we're just talking about a rebalancing so if we start to get hung up at um rhm with outflow maybe they would be willing to look at our elementary schools in total just a thought um because they could hold up the planning module even after this stage of it you guys know that I know that um the other question I had is um hold on a second uh how did the Planning Commission meeting go I didn't I didn't attend um did you get uh preliminary plan approval a couple of weeks ago unfortunately we did not okay so on the the agenda for March okay so Damien's smile was well he noticed my my grin that's true when you said long time ago that the
077you thought there was a lot of time built in I think I distinctly remember saying I thought that the planning process could take like sure did a year um I hope a year would have been okay um I so I hope you're able to continue to move forward um with the planning process I'm sorry the the presentation has gone off my screen I was I had some and I'm trying to get it back up um yeah let me just look at yours if I could look at it thank you so planning module I I was curious about the um and I don't think I ever noticed the proposed wood Lightwood uh ceiling in the lobby so I was curious about that tonight I I just didn't remember seeing that in a picture um but it
078now talk we're now talking about doing an out alternate of acoustic tile instead it looks to be on page five I just never noticed it to be that wood grain before um shade tree didn't surprise me uh the npdes is that because of the water I mean the Watershed down the bottom of the hill or the the wetlands anytime in pen uh you disturb more than one acre of land you have to go for an npdes per permit through the Conservation District um which is a arm of the Department of Environmental Protection but um yeah that's basically any project that gets over an acre of disturbance we need to get one um right so there's nothing special so why did you not you put it on the reason of why there's been impacts why is
079npdes delaying you you knew you had to do it actually npds is not the schedule driver here okay um but there was there was a change we had were originally um led to believe we would need that General permit would be fine and then we were informed that we need to do an individual permit so that was changed an individual permit I don't what does that mean um that means yeah it it it's a similar review but it's viewed a general permit is um an easier process with less paperwork an individual permit is just looked at with more screw and it has to do with the waterways that are involved that that came as a surprise and uh that was a was a recent Revelation for us okay great thank you for the sewage planning
080module is really driving the schedule right now uh and you can't get your npdes permit until you get your sewage planning module okay well I'm glad I offered a suggestion there um you made mention that our concrete cost has gone up because there's more retaining walls wal that was just something you said I I'm not seeing a change to the plan that there's more retaining walls in fact I'm seeing an ad alternate where we're going to take some concrete retaining walls and switch out block yeah the the walls basically got understand that it was just early estimates of what we thought we were going to need as far as height uh they they ended up higher than we anticip taller than we anticipated okay no CH not more in lineal foot it's more in height
081and got okay um I don't know why this question never occurred to me before and maybe I'm thinking about the bleachers at the high school I would not like to hear in a few months let me say this again I would not like to hear in a few months that we were surprised and that there's some issues with the structural Integrity of the existing building that we've uncovered when we went to start disturbing the the the the ground the grading so close to the existing building okay see what you're saying which was a surprise we encountered at the high school when we took out the bleachers and the structural Integrity of the pool wall we found out that there was a problem now it's I'm not opposed to finding out a problem I would not
082like to be surprised by an additional cost so I hope everybody has looked at I think there's some amount of ground that's I mean some amount of footing that is underneath the back part of the existing building and we're going to be going up very close to to it so yeah the exist new building is about 30 ft from the existing building I know that and yeah there there's I think the the footing for the new building goes about 8 feet beyond the footprint so it's within 22 feet uh there'll be a lot of equipment but we'll but we'll be yeah we'll have to put uh it'll probably either be we we'll make it the contractor's uh responsibility to uh to pick the system but we'll give them design PR of what it has to
083do but probably either be a um HP and lagging where they drive I don't need the details I don't want to be surprised with an additional cost that there's a problem by going so close to the existing building I think that the answer to that is I want to do a little bit more research about what is there just to make sure that um there isn't some thing that we don't know sorry I want to make sure that we don't so I think you heard my I think you heard my app Dam great and I'm going to you're going to you're going to see some action on that I appreciate that I did notice you moov the geother well uh further away I did notice that this is the first time we're seeing using the
084tennis courts for uh you know construction for sighting I I get that is there a concern with a loss of efficiency having the well the geothermal Wells that much farther away from the building will we have to size it bigger to go a further distance and not lose efficiency is that going to cost us extra money no if anything it probably should actually in um if anything it might reduce the uh amount of Wells because you think about it while it's it's running underground it's doing the same thing as it would the water is doing the same thing as it would be when it's going down in the well in the winter time it's Gathering heat out of the ground in the summer time it's expelling heat in the ground whether it's running horizontally or
085vertically matter of fact if you look if you uh know anybody that's got a residential geothermal uh heat heating system a lot of times they don't drill Wells a lot of times for the residentials they'll just run a loop of pipe underneath the ground horizontally got it principle the difference in grade because I know that where the new proposed Wells are you're going to have to go uphill you're going to lose some some grading of are we going to have to now bury those deeper I mean can I can I answer some of those questions um just to put a little light on to answer your question that was a great question um so yes if you move the geothermal well field theoretically you would need more um you would need more horsepower more energy
086or pumping power to move the water a further distance right now what we have explored um is because you know water has a density of one most of your geothermal well fields are filled with a a glycol or anti antifreeze solution which is environmentally friendly it's alcohol based um what we're exploring for this project is a specific special um thermal transfer fluid um it's it's new to the market it's it's well I shouldn't say new it's been out for about 10 years um and what it does is it actually reduces the the the density um or specific gravity of the fluid so antifreeze has a much higher specific gravity than what water is and density so what it does is it actually reduces it down to um the same as water so while theoretically you
087would need more pumping power using this transfer fluid we'll be able to um afford not increasing the horsepower of our our pumps to get it out there plus we'll gain the uh benefit of the thermal conductivity to which it um offers so okay hopefully and hopefully the fluid is also environmentally friendly and yes not horribly more expensive it is it is made for that it will actually save you money because of the thermal conductivity over its life cycle I don't know how anybody missed the playgrounds this is an elementary school I'm sorry that's frustrating and I know I mentioned the ele the playgrounds because I asked about sun shades we asked about Playgrounds yes thank you we asked about Playgrounds um the the I think probably the last big thing that I'm a little surprised
088about I mean I'm glad to see it don't oh no there's two things uh they but their page back to Bath um the staging of the phase three it's on page 15 um it seems that although there are delays in the bidding process and all of that and kind of getting the ground running to your point Damen you know we may have sucked up the extra time that you thought you know that you thought was there which is you know look it that happens it happens but you're still talking about completing the building at the end of June of 27 so this is the first time that I recall seeing that the con that the demolition of the school and the parking lot wasn't going to be done by September that's correct not only not
089done by September but all the way to January so that is unhappy news to me um I don't know why we would be hearing about that so late and there's nothing about the the delays that are the the delays we're experiencing in getting in getting the shovel in the ground let me let me put it that way it's the shovel in the ground is where we're delayed right now but you guys are still anticipating a um a completion date of June 27 so why are we only now hearing about how long the building might take to take down and I just want to ask a second question I actually posed this to Ken a week I don't know a week or two ago we were chitchatting um in our original plan we were waiting for
090for the children to leave in June to start taking down the building obviously we would finish the building in June and take down the new building and get it all going um if we experience construction delays and they are still building or finishing or whatever in the summer of 27 I would like to be clear that my preference would be we still need to start deconstruction it it's always been posed as well we're going to finish the building and then we're going to take down the old building well if we're not finished with the building still need to be taking down the old building over that summer obviously making sure that we're going to be able to open the new building don't get me wrong but I I am surprised to see that you're all
091of a sudden anticipating such a long time frame for the um for that phase three during design development one of the things that we were looking at was one of the options that we had that we looked at was moving in earlier when the schedule was finishing earlier that allowed an amount of time for us to do all that and still have a little bit of work to trickled out in the fall but not to the extent that you see in getting all the final plans together and understanding now that we're going to use tennis courts for parking which can't those those have to be done yeah after the part so as all that became clear again this is part of the clarity of the whole process as all that became clear we said okay
092this happens then this happens then this happens and instead of trying to compress it which we could I actually look at that schedule but I'm the guy that sat here and said why are why do we have this much time in design and permitting and I'm looking at that schedule going I want to see that finish in November and I'm not finished trying to do that but I had the same reaction that you did and it wasn't so much how did it move because I know that in design development we kind of slid it up into time and now we're sliding it back out to the June through some other date I still want to get that finished as early as we can if we started in April then we were finishing in August and
093and that's kind of moved and unfor unfortunately that's part of the problem that we had when we were looking at it even though we had um even though we had looked real hard at trying to squeeze it into three months I'm fairly certain that the move in earlier in 27 like maybe over spring break or whatever that original thought was that that I'm not accounting for that when I say we were planning on starting to taking down the building in June the day after the kids get out and it's going to be tight to get it all done by September but we you know but but we think we can if the weather cooperates and blah blah blah and now all of a sudden it's an extra three and a half months because you're talking
094January yeah and get a wet bad fall and we're going to be beyond that I I I don't have it in front of me but the bu the building demolition was always planned to the existing building was planned to be doing done over the summer right we always anticipated that the site work to construct the new parking lot in and that site work in the place of the existing building was was always leaking into the fall I think it was November okay now what we're saying is we're pushing that out a little bit further because there's additional work that's being anticipated for the entry drive and and some other things so it we were always my recollection is November and now we're into December January okay yeah I mean I'm seeing January so that's I
095stand correct the last comment I don't think I've seen but I may have missed it a picture of the cafeteria before and without knowing how attached you are to this particular scheme um I would just say they look to be roundtables with a lot of stools that I raised some children who would have tipped around in those like you can't even imagine and they could get hurled um lunchtime is a time that tends to be one of those less structured times I don't I'm not as concerned about them in the library I'm more concerned seeing them in the cafeteria I don't know if this is just like a vision but we're really actually going to do tables with the benches where they fold up quickly because I think we're planning on using this as some
096flexible space so it will get used a little bit differently than say the library um it is as you suspect a hypothetical vision of furniture um that has not been designed or selected not hypothetically I don't think that chairs that can be tipped in the cafeteria is a good idea but yeah they they they under no circumstances would they be freestanding stools I think the idea there is to simulate a round table with attached stools right which is typical um and the other thing is um again the round versus rectangular conversation has to do with capacity M the this is done through our through our calculations through the design development phase is the the this the room is sized such that you have the flexibility should you choose to of using the round tables which
097offer less density of seating the room is sized such that you can have less dense more comfortable seating in there that that particular and and I see what you're saying now it looks as if those are freestanding stools um that's that's probably the limitations of the furniture that's in the rendering software it's meant to simulate round tables with attached stools okay great um my last thing is just while you're on that topic I hate the round tables with the attached stools because they do not account for friend groups that have a different number of students than the table and they create huge social issues at the middle school huge it's a bad idea um I wouldn't disagree with that I'm yeah but anyway um my last thing is could we perhaps save money by utilizing
098the um the property off of Robert's Road once we take down the houses as our um one of the construction sighting um staging areas rather than the tennis courts just a thought yeah we we I we we discussed that possibility the the elevation change is is a bit challenging um to get up to the school um we're also a little concerned about entering and exit off of uh Sprout road with that being a pendot road um okay but yeah we did look at that and we the biggest expor yeah the biggest issue was the change in elevation right I I that's all I I had I sorry I did I don't Ser on facilities anymore I don't get to ask these questions so thank you I don't serve on facilities anymore either that's probably my
099problem um who else has questions Miss Lao thank you um so I think multiple people have brought this up already but the sewage permitting issue did also stand out to me as a potential bottleneck for this entire project and I unfortunately know way too much about um sewage permitting in Southeastern Pennsylvania by virtue of my stint as the former president of my homeowners association um so much so that the term sewage apocalypse actually entered the vocabulary of my nightmares um but what I learned from that experience and not to alarm anyone but this situation was so bad that the original Builder abandoned the project after waiting for three years to no avail not getting the required permits and what I discovered is that as Miss Stern pointed out um sometimes the facts are not as
100important as the characterization and relationships so because I mean the situation is like our current sewage system is already like way overburdened it's just you know it's part and parcel with the Aging infrastructure across our entire country there's nothing that we can do about it it's really just who gets the exceptions who you know it it's it's almost purely discretionary because our project our facts actually got worse but then the new Builder got the permits right away because of their relationships it seemed like um and it was all in you know how you characterized it as new build or existing or you know total Elementary School numbers that's exactly so I guess I would encourage you know us to really focus on this um because it does have the potential of holding up the entire
101project and doing what we can um you know to to help ease this along but you know it is it just has the potential to really stop everything else in its tracks and and and kind of everyone to be prepared for that possibility and then you know I just wanted to kind of amplify um Miss Solomon's concerns and I and I you know I've heard her made this make this point multiple times now in multiple meetings and yet each time we just kind of keep moving along so I I guess I would like to ask like what are our options you know if we are to lend Credence to her concerns you know are we past the point of no return is it an All or Nothing kind of decision or is it possible to
102get it back to the $50 million range you know like it just seems like you know Miss Solomon makes her points every time and we kind of just move on so I I just would like to know what are the options before the board in that regard big picture so this I to be fair I don't think it was ever 50 million all in I think it was there were there was uh it was more than 50 but the point is well taken the there was a 50 and a 45 conversation 45 all in at one point it I don't think it was all in I don't think it was soft costs and costs for the architect it didn't it wasn't it was the building it wasn't necessarily everything but your point is very well
103taken as is Miss LA and it was one of mine um and those of you who've been on the board from back when we first did the high school project will remember the term off-ramps and I think it and I think Mr Barons is aware well of aware of this term as well I think we need the board would like to understand and Mr Morris M Dr Bachelor can educate you on this but I think we do need to understand look we we have sunk costs we if we decided today we were going to walk away from the project entirely we would still owe money to the people who have done work on this I don't think it's information everybody has at their fingertips tonight so I don't and I think it you know the
104conversation about off ramps goes along with a conversation about the whole purpose of this project is we need a new we need a solution at Ean and I think the solution that the board ultimately came to was we need a new building is the question we don't need that new building you know is is the answer well we don't need it right now actually Renovations would get us there I think there were a lot of questions that came up before and we did the the due diligence and we all got to this point of no we need a new building so now is it something else related to that and I think the administration could is that an a task you could take or is that is that something that goes to site logic in
105terms of what our off-ramps are one more slide go yeah so the the as Damian um explained a little bit ago the off ramps are the decision points right the decision points to uh related to board action to move forward or not and that's that's what's identified on on this slide so and and terms I think that's the piece is the the cost associated with each offramp like each of these is a chance to say no you know what we're not going to move forward but there are costs associated with oh I see what you mean so and right so the the the the August so once bids are received right you haven't spent the construction cost to get the bids right so so August per this schedule August is when the board would authorize
106the award of contract so you accept the bids and vote essentially to move forward with signing those contracts so that's when the bulk of the pro of the money is spent between now and then yes it's sunk costs for fees and that sort of thing but as as somebody uh eloquently mentioned yester uh recently here in this conversation is we don't know what the costs are truly or what the market says this project costs from a construction standpoint until we receive those bids so um at this point I think I'd have a hard time recommending that you don't see it through to get the bids to to have done this sunk cost to have done all this effort and then not know what the actual market value is of this project I think would I'd
107have a hard time recommending that as your professional so I think the piece that threw me off because I in my head from prior projects have had it kind of this is where the off-ramps are so seeing the demolition project come in to me that's a new cost right that and that's a new sunk cost if we go out to bid we hire demolition experts they come in and begin all of that and then we go out to bid and we get our bids in August and we go we can't afford this or we don't want to do it sure now we've already got the demolition by dragging out the process now we've got that cost and we may have I don't think we're necessarily losing buildings or property we want but we have committed
108that much further funds and and project approach I don't know does that answer your question I mean I think or yeah definitely part of it and then the other part was is the $50 million range if we are to build something new is it possible to do it for it's not yeah I guess that was my question not all in with the soft costs with the and may maybe it is but not on this site so it's a new so you're going to go back to square one and say okay we're not going to build into the side of the Hill here because we don't want to pay the cost for excavation but now you're going to start all over and incur all the costs of a new design or or it would just be
109Renovations rather than new a new building or can I just add something it's relevant to this we've we've asked the question um how do we get this number down before you know that that's been brought like what could we do and what we hear is not unless you cut into existing programming what the building is going to represent what we bought into so maybe it's worth an exercise to what that would look like and and maybe it's not getting down to a number as much as we may fantasize at 50 but but what does it look like because I think and then I'll I'll table the rest of my you know I think the frustration here obviously is that you know the more it we're kind of losing sight of why we were excited about
110this building because you're getting a d double whammy here we're both delayed and costs are rising and then you know I think back when Damien said hey you know after the election we'll have a lot more certainty that's a good time to go out for bid well I I'm having a hard time thinking we have any certainty in these numbers right now in this current environment with tariffs yes I I we had the discussion for the rest of the board members oh well what about you know where is our steel coming from oh we will'll buy it from a US Source well if it's no longer available internationally you know the demand will be up the supply will be down and the cost will be greater so you know I can't say that any of
111us will be able to say we're surprised that all these numbers came in higher because we are in such uncertain times so you know and I think Dr bachor and I were we were commiserating a little bit about in our leadership meeting about you know gosh we went into the high school project with a great unknown of Co and now we're going in you know this project feeling a little great unknown so I think perhaps maybe doing that exercise to say okay what what about this building could we and I hate to say lose but is there any is there a is there a portion that we still can have a beautiful building but that we might not have everything we originally wanted and again one of I I love I love M Stern's saying
112I don't want to be surprised one of my I don't want to be surprised is that the cost of Windows and glass is so expensive because we've been saying that from the GetGo and I'm just right off the bat looking at a few t a few pictures which I thought you did a really nice job on some of the buildings in the GL go round where we decided to have a footer right and I mean I don't know if I'm header that um and there was a little less glass well if you look at those that art room below you still have Flor to sealing glass is there an opportunity there where we could have headers and have a little less glass or things like that have we still gone to that level and I
113know you really did a lot of value Engineering in the last go round but is there some opportunity that still gives us the Integrity of all the light and the windows but is there some further steps we could take so again I don't mean to hijack that but it's kind of relevant to all that CU I I don't want to make it like you know for me personally I don't think it's it's going to the extreme of of a number that I don't know was ever realistic several years ago and we've just had a market that's gone up but I do really do appreciate the comments that I've gone before that we just keep kind of ignoring it and then we're going into an unknown environment of of costs so um but then I also
114recognize that a lot of this money we've spent and we really do need to know what it's going to cost so so you know it but but perhaps there's another step we can do at least just to evaluate what we'd be giving up because we've said oh you're going to cut into programming but we've never seen what that actually looks like what does cutting into programming look like right so to so if if you're talking about going from 75 million to 50 that that's a onethird reduction so um and and as as as Damian mentioned earlier the exercises that we've done so far have not cut into program so things like reducing the size of Windows um you making making those minor tweaks to the building we we've we've we've done that now could we
115go further yes but that's not millions of dollars right that and and it does start to IMPACT program in terms of the goals of the building in terms of its its aesthetic and the way it Embraces the the the outside landscape so to cut into program um would it is is those those very difficult decisions that once you make that decision there's there's no going back right there's there's other things that are also difficult decisions that affect um sort of Board District goals for the project take the geothermal system for as an example you know that's a way to move the needle in an appreciable way but it also violates one of the goals of the project so there are things that we can explore and bring back to you and say this is this
116is we're not trimming the fat we're cutting into meat and Bone so to speak right so we can do that to change the shape of the building changes the design puts us back at the beginning of the Land Development process and means that we are delaying the project substantially more and the one thing we can guarantee from that exercise is that it will cost more because now we're we're seeing inflation we're seeing escalation so so the the process that that you're describing that in to be most effective would be something that we could do in a relatively short period of time so we don't affect the schedule dramatically that we're still getting out to bid close to where we're talking about but that that things regard um that that we can show ways to move
117the needle appreciably and put some difficult decisions in front of you to to make relative to uh to how to get the the building cost down so does that answer the question it does answer the question but I just and this is In fairness to you I want you to to to know that it will be an exercise in theoretical numbers because it will we'll be back to the place of until we put it out to bid we won't know you know I was just it's funny I was just actually looking back at our June of 2022 our feasibility study kind of back around the time when the board was heavily considering renovating versus there were a couple of different rebuild options one was rebuild you know next to our building one was rebuild in
118the existing location and to look back at what those numbers were I I long for those numbers um so you know so do we even at the time you know we made a decision it would be about 29 million to do a major major renovation and by the way I don't think that that increased the size of the school to my recollection and so we were talking about 29 million really get the school back up to snuff but we would be still faced with the the the different conversation that we've had about should we be perhaps rebalancing the size of our three elementary schools or you know mid-50s it was never under 50 was 57 55 57 for the couple of ithan options my point is that I looked at that and I thought I
119I there's no way that we would be doing a substantial renovation of Ethan Elementary again without um without uh even increasing the size of it I'm like well probably would be up the same 30% that new construction is so we're talking about 40 to 42 million I mean like it's just it's we just need to understand as as you know and you're talking to the person who did not support this particular version I do understand that the challenge we were we are we are faced with as a board as a community and as our Consultants is that we can only theorize what the numbers are and I do fully support Steve I want to say this I do fully support your notion that we need to at least go to bid yes that might ultimately
120be a sunk cost but we will not otherwise be making any kind of truly informed decision until we go to bid which is why what's going to take us to get to bid you know like that's you know so I ask a question about that going to bid though because yeah I I would assume that you know most contractors that you're going out to bid are watching our meetings and they're they're listening to the budget right so it's kind of a catch 22 you know do we do we work towards what we want to be our budget because that's what they see and that's what they know that we approved or like you said Susan do we go out to bid and and well we can't go out to bid till we have the Land
121Development approvals in good conscience well what I'm saying is you know come up with with a real budget number that we are comfortable with and then go out to bid because they know what that budget number is that we we've approved I love the way you're thinking because the way this is going is that we're putting it in other people's hands all the time we oh gosh so high you and I'm not going to repeat everything that everyone said because I do agree with exception of knowing all that you know about the sewer Pro the um permits um want the sewer so so um and I appreciate Damon's um Damian's um small comment about um you know the time does does give us an advantage that we have a higher number for the ACT 34
122but we don't want that higher number for ACT 34 let's use that time that permit process what however long it's going to be to really find more efficiencies and reductions in the cost this is a huge project and there has to be I mean as quickly as we found you know money to build the playground and rent and restore the the tennis fields let's try to find some some efficiencies in in in those um I'm not going to get into the nitt nitty and grey of the details or of the the building but there is one thing that did um that did strike me and I I think I did mention this before but it it just struck me again because as I look at the picture on by the way I really appreciate the
123pictures because I'm a visual person and um I really liked seeing those but it's the picture of the students in the gym the students in the gym and I think I mentioned before that I was concerned about the glass around the floor area what page is that on it's slide 31 very at the very end it's at okay 31 there it is yes so and again I whatever the G the glass expense is would it be and it's not going to be Millions but just you know create the wall so that it covers at least the the height of the students and staff that are going to be in there because you know what there are balls that are going to be thrown at that glass and I don't know how strong this glass is
124but these are some strong boys that go and they're not just elementary students that go in there some are middle school students and sometimes it's not just a ball that gets thrown in there so I don't know how you feel about that but I do feel strongly about that corner um that just goes from the floor to I don't know all the way up to the ceiling but if if that could be just a wall where that first um ledge ledge or that the first grade bar um maybe you could revisit that because I wouldn't want a repair cost for that glass um and then to put that gym stalled for any activity right um let me see if I have any other questions but I I reiterate every I just slightly when we started
125we we were not at 70 but we approved close to 70 and we were uncomfortable with that but now we're at 10% above what we started with a year ago um it's a lot it's a lot we're you know we're not just responsible again for our our Schools staff and students but our taxpayers so um the furniture plan Susan you mentioned that um again with with the time that that we're on waiting um for the permits let's also re you know fine-tune the furniture so that you know they're selected by you know staff and administration properly so that we can hit the ground running when we're ready and that we're not waiting for it because I I don't know how Furniture is for buildings like this but I know Furniture when we order it for
126residentials can take a long time that that was not one of the bullet points on the list but you're correct we're kind of conceiving that as lumped in with that color schedule conversation and yes that and is it's an excellent opportunity to comprehensively look at that design it wouldn't be ordered that early but we could at least have the design complete y you would have it um just to be clear we can't actually order anything until we've gone out to bid right no but you could probably get and exactly what kinds of furniture you would like stools versus chairs with backs or benches or you know just know and even the paint colors whatever whatever Interior Design Furniture is if that could you know take a look at they plan to do an inventory of
127what things make sense from the current building to move to the new building and what things don't make sense to move um from the current building to the new building so that will impact Furniture as well okay I think that's all I had cuz everyone else had it thank you thank you Miss Rosen Bloom Miss girton you're good okay just a couple Dr bson just giv the time fact that there's already been you know a couple hundred questions asked already um so I'm coming at this from a a sort of big picture perspective as well I'm trying to still sort of grasp some of the details that have the the ground has shifted and I i' I feel that it shifted I've been told that it's shifted there are numbers that suggest that it has
128but I'm still trying to understand and without delving too deeply into that particular question let me just suggest one change and maybe you could explain it and I know the you already explained it in the presentation to some degree but maybe you could just repeat so I'm just I'm I'm fixated for some reason on the difference between the site logic schematic design estimate you know I'm looking at um you know slide 19 at this that number 56 versus 70 you know on on October of 23 and then um you know seven months later something like that in May of 24 and the the the difference there that 14 13 14 Grand is just kind of hit me in the face and I just could you just walk me through that or or just you mean
129million million yes did I say thousand I'm okay with sorry yeah see um so yeah if you could just just kind of unpack that one again maybe you've already gone over this but I just I just want to what's uh important to keep keep in mind that you know from that $70 million we brought it back down to 62 million first of all through cost reduction measures so what you're really should be comparing is a 56 to the 62 but that's still a 10% I'm sorry that's not the I'm just asking the question of I I know what the ultimate number is I'm just asking how it went from that to that that's just the basic question so I was just going to say the recollection I have and one of the reasons I was
130particularly disappointed by these new numbers is it was a big hit for pite costs I feel like it was $6 million additional for site costs in that jump and so part of it went from six to 12 right that initial that was in May it was six additional million six million additional dollars and and to be clear we did get it back down to 63 million 62822 you would Round Up to 63 but we did that by losing some of the things we wanted and by cutting the size by 5,000 square ft right and I'm not saying that was wrong some of those were things we were happy to cut and we realized there maybe was a better solution maybe Florida ceiling glass wasn't ideal in certain rooms same I get that but but now
131we're hearing there's a couple million dollars more I mean I think I heard $2 million dollar more in site work yes so the original estimate for site work was six and we're up we've more than doubled that it's up to 14 yes and that's I think what was most disturbing to me and to be clear to all those contractors who may come back out and watch this I love this building I think it is beautiful I think it is a great site and I will not vote for it if it comes in above our budget if it comes in too high R rner is an affluent District I get that everybody thinks we have empty uh unlimited Pockets we do not and this is not the time with tariffs on steel and lump number tariffs
132on Imports which is where a lot of that furniture may come from for us to just plan to spend lots and lots of money at a time when a lot of people are losing their jobs I know you know this but I'm saying it for anybody who's watching this a couple months from now bidding on the project this is not a done deal if it doesn't come in at an amount that this board thinks is responsible I I I hear it from a couple other people I'm not polling I just I think that's a reality I think we need to know that people and that when it comes in the contractor who bids on it better not come in with a million change orders like we've had in the past because that does not fly
133either so it better be somebody with a lot of Integrity who wants to come in and bid on a project honestly so um you're sorry that site work was the big number sorry it's okay but no but that site work got me really angry because that is the big number change I think yeah yeah yeah no it's fine track no no no it's all good and you it again you know I'm coming at this I I work in higher ed you know I I you know education is is sort of you know this is an educational project right so I mean I'm I'm I'm just kind of setting the tone here of kind of talk to me like I'm six here you know how did it go from 56 to 70 I mean I just
134it's a kind of straightforward question I think it's just um you know it's a combination of further understanding of the scope further understanding of the needs of the of the the district and desires of the district um further refinement of the design uh and then for better understanding of market conditions is you know the uh trying to get a handle on what's going on with pricing in the in the market is uh you know we've talked about it's changing rapidly it's difficult to keep up with but I think it's more just a development of the uh the design better understanding understanding of the needs of the needs and desires of the district and okay what it's going to take to meet that that sounds fair U the other General concern I have is sort of
135and again this is fairly you know straightforward stuff here but we're looking at these uh deduction alternates um I I again this is just a simple statement here I guess I'm just concerned that I I just don't want how do I say this again fairly simple idea if we're going to pay kind of if we're going to go all in on this design we and we're not going to you know to use the metaphor cut down to the the meat and Bone if we're just trimming the fat and we're keeping the general concept I would just hope that we're not losing things that are substantive and I know that these alternates are thoughtfully conceived here I I know that there's a lot of thought that was put into that but it's just a general concern
136that I I have and the the kind of global feeling here is okay we started here you know we estimated here now it's up here and now we're kind of cutting back and in that cutting process we're like losing quality and you know it's again it's just a general sense of things so if you want to comment on that that would be great no that that's that's a very valid concern and that's you're talking about the bidding strategy um and that's why they are alternates um because again has been said a couple of different times this this is an estimate it's not meant to be the low bid right it's meant to be um you know a a conservative estimate and so our hope is that somewhere within the range of the alternates and the
137estimate that that's where the bids are going to fall and we don't want the district to lose value out of the building because something was cut and we don't have the opportunity to bring it back in so it it it it creates these safety valves for what depending on the the bidding outcome so that you have the opportunity to bring things back in or make those difficult decisions to say do we want a building with tazzo or do we want a building right and so that just to use that example since you raised it so it gives us the opportunity to make those decisions that have a life cycle cost impact on the building but don't have a can we open the building and get students in to learn impact right so so that that's
138why they're alternates right sure fine and I'll just say one more thing you know we want to build a new school in 20125 so it's going to cost a lot of money okay so that's the basic fact on the other hand as L has said and other people have said we live in this community and we have a fiduciary responsibility and we're the people that are going to have to answer the questions not only to our neighbors but our constituents of are you really you know dotting your eyes and crossing your tees when you're reviewing these documents so leave you with that thank you you're up I think I've said it I just you know I want to kind of end on a positive note I mean I I I also want to sayate I
139do believe this is a beautiful building and I think we made the decision not to renovate for a good reason um and I know Dr Bachelor and the administrative team back in I believe in May when we were first faced with you know new numbers went through that exercise right and we landed once again in this is a this is a beautiful building we have a need for this we have we believe we have a need and that it makes sense to build um yes there's a question of the site you know it's been a long standing question we also made decisions that you know you know you know I reference this a lot that Steve you said this is the best place to put this building you know and we asked that question again
140even in light of these site costs I do believe it's a little bit of a um misleading or fantasy to believe that if we just knock down the current building and and erect it we wouldn't have those costs I think our property presents challenges with slopes we would be building a bigger building I think we would end up with new challenges and particularly as we went through the exercise relocating too so I don't want to like paint that that we made a mistake in the decisions we've made so um but you know for all the reasons I think that you know we have to um you know we have to just know that we're scrutinizing every dollar here and um and that you know we might end up in a position where we have to
141make some hard decisions and you know maybe right now is not the right time to actually put it in paper because we need to see what it cost to say what the meat and Bone what what we'd be cutting into but I hope we're thinking about it because you know the reality could be that we don't like what we get and um so um that's I just but on a posit I really do I don't want to you know I just think maybe this is just what happens in the process plus we're building at a really difficult time I mean I mean on anybody who's done a renovation project at home anyone who's looking for a new home look at the escalate look at the cost today but um but you know we do like
142you said we have a responsibility to the community and we've just got to know that we're leaving no stone unturned before you know we make a very big vote so thanks yeah go ahead yeah yeah no no go ahead I have a couple questions but go ahead oh what would be the what is the expectation from the design team when bids bids will come in so if bids go out in June bids will come in by August by end of July yes so the end of July bids come in MH and then we would be looking for the board to accept or reject those in the month of August so that means we we'd have a facilities meeting and a board meeting and we're making decisions on whatever that number is whether to proceed what
143alternates to do what alternates not to do all within a one or two week time period potentially yes a month well a month yeah we could so when you say a month how does it work out to be a month we could schedule end of July to yeah the question is do we need a July meeting the board doesn't typically I'm thinking meeting wise when you say a month though meetings we have we have a a monthly facilities meeting we have a monthly board meeting so between one facilities committe meeting and then a board meeting we'd be looking at the board to make the decision on all the alternates to make a decision on um not only the alternates whether to accept the overall estimates too um and all of that oh th those are
144choices that we still have to schedule those and Define that duration whatever works for the district can I I have a quick question just because of the way you said that is there a um is there a legal time frame from the time you put out bids and accept bids back to when you must take action on them or the contractors can pull those bids correct so the bids have a lifespan right which is again defined within the bidding documents okay you know it's it's typically 45 days so a month and a half it could be defined as longer it sometimes as 60 um you know there's and and often times there's also a clause in there if there's a delay due to an authority approval that that we have the right to hold those
145bids even longer so those those are decisions that can be made as the contracts are put together and if we need a different cycle of review and approval you know th that's that's decisions that that um are yet to be set in stone okay but if we don't approve the bids in August the likelihood we're hoping to break ground in October so if they're not approved in August um we would then if we were approving in September we're now breaking ground in November correct yes yes so then the question would be can we can we move that bidding time frame forward so that it gives more time but again relative to the um to the uh you know approvals that we're waiting for we we need to be strategic about that one of the things
146I'm hearing from the board tonight is um the comments about what are the Alternatives and why can't this be lower but then also the comment on the reality of we don't really know until we go out to bid but once we go out to bid then our options once they they return once we have those bids our options are you know to accept one of the bids or to reject those and possibly not move forward and I'm hearing you know comments that you know that depending where those bids are we may not be moving forward and if we're not moving forward then we are looking at going back to what are we doing are we redesigning are we renovating what are those those options and what I'm also hearing from you is it doesn't make
147sense to discuss those options right now until we get to the time of bids till we get to those bids is when that makes sense to discuss those we we won't be able to make decisions on them but I I wouldn't say that we couldn't and and I think this has been discussed too is all those pages with the cost reduction options with the yellow highlights there's a desire to vet those a little bit more and there can be a prioritization process as part of that so we can position ourselves to be prepared with with some prioritizations so that when the bids are received it we're kind of we front-end loaded some of the discussion and so we're we're perhaps better prepared to act on those if if you follow what I'm saying in other
148words we don't have to wait to discuss the prioritization or the value that the board places on alternates until we've received bids so so the next few months coming months we could schedule uh facilities meetings where we review some of these so that we're prepared ahead of time for what these all mean um as we're right getting ready for that time period when we when we receive the bids um as to the question about what programming can we cut and I think you answered the question if it's you know if you're changing the shape of the building you're going that's redesign um we can are there other programming Cuts if we could also look at that as we prepare for these alternates and discussion of these alternates are there other things that we should be
149looking at could we does that make sense between now in August right that would be obviously uh decisions that would involve the administration and kind of making those hard decisions but absolutely that that can happen concurrently with those other conversations go ahead Miss La no that's fine so I really appreciate Dr bachelor's summary which I think is very helpful um I would just want to add and reiterate Miss Rosen Bloom's point is that you know given all of our meetings and public discussions so far have we already left a record where we really shouldn't be surprised with where the bids are going to come in given where you know we currently are I guess with our own numbers right because it's all available to biders so you know I I guess it it is that
150a fair expectation that we shouldn't really expect any bids to come in dramatically lower than the numbers that we're already showing no that that I would not say that's accurate so this is the world we live in it's the public bid Arena where everything is is is on the table anybody can watch these conversations um and no bids come in low all the time maybe not so much recently but you know our firm's been around for 60 years and um you know the the the estimate by Design is meant to be conservative and it's very common that the bids come in lower than the estimate and I'll let these gentlemen speak to that as well uh when we're putting these estimates together our our goal and we preach this again and again in our in
151our company is our goal is to be the second bidder we don't want to be the low bidder because we the low bidder that means that we were too we were too low so we want typically we like to to be within you know two or three% of the bids uh sometimes it's a little more than that but um yeah we we our goal was to be second bidder so hopefully they come in a little bit under to expect they're going to come in$ 10 million under would be very unusual uh to expect them to to to for them to come in 20 to expect them to come in $20 million under is probably is not reasonable um um but you know you you could see you know them come in under decent amount under
152these numbers potentially and and we understand the estimating is based on industry standards of square footage and and and those pieces um so could I ask the design team to think about a schedule between now and August what I don't want to see happen is is August come and then our design team look at at us and say well board you're holding us up now you're not making a decision in August so a schedule that gives us the opportunity to be as informed as possible so that we are prepared to make a decision maybe in August or also be prepared that maybe it's a decision in September and I think the other thing we haven't emphasized enough in this process is everything is estimates you know it we are estimating timeline and and as best
153as possible and it adjusts and changes we are estimating cost as best as possible we are drilling down and getting more detailed and as we get more detailed that's why it continues to adjust and change so these are all estimates as we move forward um but to build in that time because I think there's there will be significant discussion about whether or not you know we move forward you know with this project or not so I have a couple questions but I have more than a couple I'm not going to ask you to answer all of them this evening unless it's really fast and easy I know we'll connect but I want to ask them here so other people have a chance to think about them and maybe they'll come up the next facilities meeting
154we'll figure that out um a couple things came up when you were looking at the con and it's not in order it's just how I scribbled it on the page because I ran out of space um I have occasioned to be in a new building currently on a regular basis and there's a construction site right next to it and the fencing is starting to tip some days with all the wind we've got recently and we've been told you can't walk near it and some of that's because it's got fabric on it I want everyone to be really mindful I know you are but this is these are children on this site they don't follow instructions as well as adults who by the way don't follow them I walk along that fence all the time so
155please please please whatever fabric you're putting on or other like keep in mind we do get high winds it's up on a hill you need to be planning for the safety of the people who are around there I know you care about safety but just the quick answer is and watch Mr Morris smile pole driven fence yeah not not something that's I was just going to say it can't be just held down with these big cement bag or sand bags not held down so there's a cost to it but it's going to be a safe fence frankly there is very little cost difference between the two okay good to know um TR what's a jersey barrier is that like a baller the concrete barriers that you see along the highway the movable ones yes got
156it okay um the tree removal it just there's a lot of different tree lines kind of sketched in on this schedule it's not clear to me if all of those little tree lines or trees that are being removed or if they're batches somewhere and if there's a meeting I missed where it's discussed what trees come down it would be helpful to understand I think that you may not know this Walt everybody else here does rner loves its trees rner cares deeply about its trees if you have gotten shade commission approval I I do think that's meaningful but it would be still helpful I think for some of us to just have a sense of where the trees are going to be disappearing we should we should provide we should provide a slide or two that
157shows here's new trees here's a little bit of that I'm sorry did you get recommendation at shry yes for approval oh good thank you um it would be helpful next time I don't want to keep everybody here tonight but when there are changes in the renderings if we even just a little red box around it or something there was a and maybe I misunderstood it I thought in the opening conversation said something about some of the alternates were being reflected in the pictures if that wasn't the case Okay um I have no so from a scheduling standpoint would be helpful to understand especially given uh people's vacation schedules if we need a meeting in July or if we need two meetings in August to stay on schedule alternatively why are we just not going out
158to bid later when it can be on a schedule that matches our school year calendar and what we've talked about in the past and maybe the answer is because we don't want to wait any longer to go out to bid because costs just keep going up and other things will get in the way but I just the question is is is there some advantage to waiting longer to go out the bid we were supposed to go out to bid last October is there a reason we aren't just going out to bid this October because when we put the shovel the well right but we were going out to bid in October so that we could get stuff started over spring break is there reason we aren't and I'm not advocating for it I just want
159to understand it because I think it's a question will get asked and especially given kind of there were seasonal aspects to the plan that I remember understanding it made sense to do this in this season and this and that season and you know Winter's unpredictable and I I just worry about it so I just want to make sure people have thought carefully about the appropriate timing um I got that answer um I have concerns about alternates that are going to increase our long-term costs I think we had this conversation at nauseum about tazzo we don't want to be Pennywise and pound foolish so a million dollars this year may save us a lot of money over years May save us Staffing costs it may save us Machinery costs it may save us having to rip
160up and replace whole floors so the same thing with like walls right are they going to have to be re if they were supposed to be 8T and they are all now only 4 feet and children at element School are taller and taller than when I was there and they're all deciding the best game ever is to slap the wall right above where the tile is and now we have to repaint every summer instead of every couple Summers I just want everybody to be mindful about what decisions are being made that way um I didn't there was a reference to sprout Road improvements that's I think where our lower where the houses currently have a driveway that's not we I think years ago we G or seems like years ago we gave up actually having
161an access point there that references sprawl and Clyde oh okay yeah okay are there improvements that need to be made there I mean if the we're negotiations with the township on that there there were some comments that came back on the review letters with regards to some of the improvements that the township has put on their plan they've recognized uh some of the improvements that pendot has recognized uh and recommended as well um right now they are not currently part of this project or or we're not being told that we have to do those there's um so that's where the kind of the conversation behind the scenes um between the district and the township is taking place okay okay umor we and we haven't given up the existing entrance that we have no I just
162did uh at Robert's Road and and Sprout we have not we're not giving that up just okay perfect um think that was it hold on let me just make sure I didn't um I just want to say I noticed this and I'm guessing he noticed this from the back row but the big savings uh was that we the big the million dollar savings in this budget was because Mr Pauling took us out for financing and originally it was budgeted two million and it came in at a million dollar of cost so thank you Mr Pauling for the back um I know it doesn't sound like it because I'm rushing and I frustrated I do really appreciate all the work you're doing I appreciate that this is not easy um I appreciate it's not easy when
163you have a group of people who are frustrated um but I I I I don't want to repeat of the high school where we go out to bid in uncertain times and the everyone's shocked I I I can't go out to bid and have this project come in five 10% above what you think it is like I I I just can't so whatever we can do to make sure contractors understand that whatever we can do to manage our own expectations right if if you need to tell me Sarah give up on the tazzo floors unless you're willing to put it into the you know take the money from someplace else you just need to say that it's about being honest with everybody here part of what we're doing is talking to a lot of contractors
164now who are very interested in doing the job so the best thing that we can do to lower cost is get a lot of competition and again we've said it before the fact that this is a new building is going to generate competition on its own but what we're doing to talk to contractors early is I mean there are contractors that want to bid the job right now but are we making it any less I'm sorry are we making it any less appealing by breaking out the demolition piece no no it's it's insignificant yeah in the plan for coming months can we also before we go out to bid talk about and maybe we can check with our solicitor about what we can discuss in public versus it's a contract I'm not sure if it's
165anything we can talk at exact probably here but discuss what are the what are we putting into these bid specifications uh and what are the things that we are considering in putting into the bid uh specifications to not only protect the district but also to limit change orders to hold things on time what are some of those options having some of those discussions even now and that would be great to share with the board and we could talk to our solicitor about when we can what's the appropriate time for us to discuss since it's a contract um we could discuss those one of the best ways to avoid uh change orders is to make the documents as complete and accurate as possible and one of the benefits of this additional times is giving us some
166more time for our team to review the drawings and Steve team to review the drawings and refine the drawings and make sure we've got everything taken care of but that is one of the best ways to avoid changes in construction just make sure you got the absolute best set of documents possible and a big part of this project is that again we have to bring Phil onto the site at the high school and I'm sorry to have anybody relive it was please just don't different site so we expect Architects not to be perfect but to do rather well with their design of a new building which means there there could be change orders for things but those omissions and the documents are are pretty narrow and if you take emissions of 2% on $50 million
167of building that's budgeted for in in our it's more than budgeted for in in our soft cost what we also want to do is take away as much as we can of the unknowns about the site and we're going to take a lot of time to make sure that the site work drawings are improved as much as we can as well because I have a lot of confidence in what's being drawn architecturally with the building and the firms that are doing that but because the site design was behind I want to get that site design up to up to that high level as well and just for the board yeah would it be helpful in one of these upcoming meetings that if we um went back and just uh either summarize quickly the decisions that
168were made in 2022 or just reminder maybe we could just do a separate reminder to board members go back and look at some of those um you know just as what would you know came up tonight I don't want to be repetitive of it but maybe it might be helpful to see you know what were those decisions versus renovation and build and why did we choose build and and and I think it was very sound uh you know discussions and thinking at the time would that be helpful to include a quick summary of that in a future meeting I think it would be helpful to get a summary of that I'm not sure we need to have take up meeting time for it I think it is something people could read it seems like a
169lot of it should be on slides yeah I agree and I you know being the one who raised it I only meant to convey that those numbers are no longer the renov comparing what we had as an image of the renovation numbers to what we are now looking at as construction is completely unfair I I want you to know that I recog that's what I was let me be clear that's what I was trying to convey to the board we can't compare that Ren we made we made a good decision in 2022 I stand by that decision based on the information we had at the time I and I continue to believe that um I just think you we need the bid numbers that's that's what we need that's what I was trying to convey
170about that but but I think it might be helpful just kind of could send out a memo yeah we could we could do that the history y that'd be fine I think it would be really helpful to have um you mentioned Dr R so being prepared for the alternate be prepared for the bids so if we had some front loading of ways to think about all of these alternates and think about the bids and how they might come in before we actually get there so that we're not surprised the less amount of surprise the better that would be helpful it'll also give you a sense of board priorities yeah yeah I would say having been through this before the administration is very good and I expect site logic will be good and Mr Brin certainly
171sorry Mr Baron certainly is they will make recommendations for us on the alternates it I mean It ultimately Falls to us but they will say like look here's what we think you should go with and here's why and and here's you know here are your three packages and I mean they're going to be it sounds like we have enough alternates that like the numbers will fly all over the place and Lydia will really lose track well as not being on the facilities committee I have some holes in my understanding of numbers so it would be helpful to I actually do think to have a recap of where those numbers came from and then what to expect um for when we do look at bids what that might mean to the whole project no I think
172I think you're right and I and I will confess I think some of my frustration the the last project we did I sat on steering committee and I sat on facilities I chaired facilities for like two years so I was very well aware of all the little details and so I I don't have as much insight into this some days and that's and I have a little bit more that's yeah so we're getting that not I wasn't fishing for compliments um s can I just ask you another question uh we're talking about a March uh meeting to determine whether or not we move forward with early demolition how much is that because that could be a on cost that if we decide not to move forward doesn't make sense to spend we'll be preparing I
173haven't you haven't broken those cost out but I would you know you're a couple hundred thousand dollars I think that would be important information to know if we want to spend that not knowing whether or not we're going to move forward well but also it may be one of those we can go out to bid and then decide we don't like the bids and be told whether or not the bids match the estimates that were told so rather than quote a number now to the point people have had before they know what they think demolition should cost and they're going to go out to Bid And if the numbers come in and they don't recommend it they'll tell us have we fully exhausted this have we fully exhausted everyone in the room um no I
174want to thank you for having this I actually this is this meeting thank you for being here this meeting actually aligns with a a goal and a prity we stated as a board is that when we have big decisions to make we need to spend this time together as a board and this would have been very difficult to do as part of a the our full business meeting next month so yes it was a long evening yes it was a lot to take in and I'm I'm grateful for it that we took the time to do this because this will set us up to make our best decisions down the road so thank you and I you know I don't know that we said that at the beginning but just for the public that do
175watch you know this was our normally scheduled facc facilities committee meeting and in order for uh the full board to be able to participate and ask questions because we have a committee structure we created the special meeting that's what no I know just want to explain to anyone who's watching why we did that so that everyone could be here so yes I I think it is helpful the moments we do this when we have important initiatives to um turn it into a special meeting so everybody can ask questions so thank you and thank you for board members for adjusting your schedules to be here and and it sounds like there may if another one or two of these coming up so please we'll make sure we let you know but try to keep your uh
176Tuesday facility night's open um okay seeing nothing else uh the one board announcement I wanted to make um is that typically our our school our full board meeting is next Tuesday night on February 25th and typically it would take place at the township administration building but because of a scheduling conflict it will not it will be back in this room so for anyone watching we're in the rner we're in the sorry we're in the garden Suite of the administrative building for rner Township level no Garden suet so much funnier to say um and with that we are adjourned oh oh no I need a motion a motion may I get a mo well I forgot it wasn't in here may I get a motion I get a motion from Susan motion to adjourn second and
177a second from Miss Solomon all in favor thank you okay