001[Music] good evening welcome to the February work session of The Rose Tree Media School Board the school board holds monthly work sessions to carry out its responsibilities in public as dictated by the Sunshine Law at these meetings the board standing committees conduct the work of the board through discussion with the administration standing committees function as Committees of the whole with all board members serving on all standing committees with one member acting as chair we welcome the public to these meetings and depending on the length of the agenda genda may be able to entertain public comment if we're not able to address comments we encourage emails to either committee chairs or the administration as a reminder to where our conversation should focus the students are the center of the rtmsd Learning Community our mission states that
002all students will reach their intellectual emotional social and physical potential and a safe environment that celebrates diversity individual talents and effort efforts and promotes collaboration caring respect and Leadership students will be well prepared to create meaningful and productive lives in a global Society all right so we will begin with finance and operations and uh we will start with the the shrer group IC Dr Mage thank you Dr napon Williams I'm excited to welcome back our partners in our journey toward Ward The New School uh as we talked about last month we'll be having updates each month as we go through um through June and then once we get back in September start it back up again with us this evening is Mr Gus hootman Mr David Trader and Mr Phil Solomon uh the three gentlemen
003are going to go through just a brief update um I wish there was a lot more that we were getting ready to break ground but we're not and I understand why right I'm being patient David Vanessa tells me every day be patient so I'm really excited to turn it over to the gentleman um and to see the presentation this evening there we go yes okay thank you so much for having us back uh as uh as stated we have a pretty brief presentation uh it's really an update on the K1 Center's a little bit of a little bit of a delay here so uh just a handful of bullets so ordinates and what has happened since the last meeting we have a budget upload update and then timeline and then David is going to speak
004a little bit to the schematic design process what you could expect I'm sorry yes then David's gonna speak a little bit about the schematic design process which you could expect in the next steps and then just have a Q&A so with that we'll just get started uh please interrupt us if anything's unclear or you have any questions along the way thank you sir so Gus if you could just give us an update yes what well what we what we reported the last time still holds Middletown Township actually has made or has rezoned the um all of the school district uh Parcels um in Middletown Township to i1 uh what they've also done is they've made the government and school use which used to be a conditional use in the previous R1 District uh they made
005that now a bught use in the uh institutional one District um what that it doesn't doesn't need any special relief uh prior to being in the i1 when it was an R1 District you had to get a conditional use which was an extra step in part of the approval process and what Middletown Township did is they took the performance standards uh that uh that were fell under the conditional use in the R1 and simply move them into the i1 again which is now a bught use and the important development standards that would apply for this particular development would be uh maximum impervious coverage of 35% uh maximum building coverage of 15% and the setbacks that has 100 foot setback um both front and rear and side setbacks uh side yard setbacks of 50 feet um
006as I'd mentioned in the previous meeting uh based on some preliminary um numbers that the shider group crunched for the riddle site which is a 15 which is the 15 Point roughly 15.1 Acre Site uh at the uh corner of Rose Tree Road and Middletown Road is that the impervious coverage associated with the again very preliminary development uh was about 43% which is over the 35% now what that means is is that the uh riddle property cannot stand alone as a development we we'll have to merge that into the Holdings of panr High School uh but in doing so looking at the impervious coverage again the very um uh very in infancy uh numbers that Trader group has developed uh and using that the uh coverage that that we know is on the um pain
007Crest property when you combine them the maximum impervious coverage Falls well below 35% it's about 30% a little over 30% and the building coverage is roughly about 10% again much less than the 15% but we will have to reverse subdivide because the development can't stand on its own uh we did meet with Middletown Township on January 24th uh very productive meeting um Middletown Township uh had stated they are very much looking forward to working with the school district and assisting them with their Land Development um associated with the new school I think you'll find it you'll find it night and day between um what you experience at Edgemont Township and what you will experience at Middletown Township and um we will continue through the process we will continue to coordinate um with Middletown Township with
008key items for Land Development uh and we will continue to coordinate with pendot uh because they are relocating uh Rose Tree Road uh the timing of that looks like it's going to have to what'll have to happen based on the timing of when uh pendot thinks they're going to uh realign that roadway is there we may have to have a a temporary access out onto Rose Tree Road as it stands now and then build a um a full dedicated access once the uh rast Stree road is aligned uh but again we are continue to coordinate and will um you know with Middletown and pendot through the development process yeah productive is the right right term for that as well um so just to the budget uh we we did go through kind of in detail
009last time what we would consider a conservative and aggressive budget uh what we've done is we've gone back we've looked at everything we've cleaned everything up where we've where we've landed is is kind of in between the two and uh you can see that the final budget is about 81 a half million I could go through each line item if you'd like but they're kind of broken out into the building we still have you know plenty of site work to do um we do have built-in construction cost escalation that's standard so what you typically do is you escalate the project midpoint of construction uh and as of right now that's probably a good idea it's a little uncertain what's going to happen with inflation although it is flattened there are other developments happening such as
010tariffs and such which will probably push that up a little bit so we do have a good amount of contingency in the budget as well you can see it rolls up to 81 and a half that's kind of in between the 78 and 85 that we had budgeted before uh a little bit on the timeline um so what you see here I'm sorry if it's a little hard to follow but the blue blocks represent kind of the the most aggressive timeline that we could make um what we did is we we also built this as you know each segment so you you obviously transition through each one of these from schematic design to design development construction documents and then we have a line item that's permitting bidding and mobilization those are all kind of put
011together because they're sequential and we have you know a good pathway for for a very streamlined process here but some of the things are done in a series format and you can only go so fast so we have in the blue blocks kind of the aggressive and then in the orange blocks uh what could happen if some things get delayed a little bit uh we're not anticipating big delays but there are some you know regulatory things that do need to be done so if you see the the most aggressive timeline we have right now ends in December of 2027 um I know that's mid year so you know that might be tough to actually reor organiz the district there anyway uh but that could actually leak into the spring depending on some of the municipal
012approvals Etc so you could land into the March April timeline still plenty of time for the next school but that's uh that's the best timeline we have just now we will be obviously updating this as we go this is very preliminary in nature just with a handful of conversations so uh for what it's worth you know this is where we're at today we believe in yes and we will we will keep moving that about the time absolutely we will keep as we'll keep trying to be more aggressive with that if possible so the next step I was gonna have David just kind of speak to kind of the design process I know many of you were involved before but um just a refresher for some and new to others so we we plan and proceeding
013very similarly to the way that we did last time and a number of you were involved with this those of you who weren't uh we invite you to be part of this process um last time this happened people were doing this behind plexiglass screens with their masks on so it was a unique solution unique way of doing it uh this way you this time you guys can be Hands-On so at any rate what you can expect for the second row of what Phil showed you are the following steps here and so we will start off with a uh kind of a virtual tour of facilities that we see across the United States doing what you're trying to do in Early Learning Center a K1 facility and then we'll visit several um some of this team
014has already visited at least one of these there are four or five in the region that we can take you to so you can get some ideas for these kinds of facilities and I think that'll be great for you are any of them specifically like the Early Learning Centers like K12 those are the ones that we're going to tour yeah there and again there are probably four or five that are K1 in K12 so uh we're excited to take you to those the uh building program we developed a building program based on 750 students um for the study and so the information that we presented to you on January 9th had a program that did that that is what Phil was just basing his costs on that is what Gus was talking about uh in
015terms of square footage on the site so that has all been tested however you'll want to go back through and confirm with all of your Educators how you want this facility really to be so that'll be that third step and then we hold the visioning and concept design Workshop that some of you will remember um it's a pretty nice opportunity for folks to get involved and really have a a thumb print on what may be built in the community uh after that we begin making presentations to you on concept development uh back to what Phil was talking about with the pre-design estimating and finally coming to schematic design package once that's in place that's when Gus really picks up and starts working back with the township again uh so you can expect to see coming
016back to you and talking about Township meetings from that point on so that all fits right into what Phil talked about and hopefully gives you a sense of what's coming excellent thank you so much um just some immediate next steps so to to keep moving uh sorry I forget that this thing is not directional um teacher yes uh immediate next steps will be to finalize the agreements then we would have a formal kickoff uh we are we are through the feasibility study portion uh as David said you could then begin the schematic design process we would continue to work with Middletown even though we won't have any formal submissions until after schematic design always good to keep them informed as we're moving uh there are some steps that they suggested to us to keep you
017know to keep ahead of things uh I would also suggest that we uh sit for communications planning I would do that with the team and then potentially look at a new micro site uh to keep the community up to date with what's happening uh something that we would suggest as as well with that we're open for any questions what do the price per square foot now compare with when we started on the Edgmont site four years ago uh the square footage is nearly double uh the facility is quite a bit bigger um I can get you the exact number but I believe it was 65,000 at the time I'm sorry price per square foot oh how much has it increased uh quite a bit I have a stair step that I've shown but anywhere from
01830 to 40% um and cost escalation it depends on when you start you know that clock uh to where we are right now but it's it's been significant in terms of escalated cost if you'd like I can give you a whole detailed piece on that as well there's question again Community involvement um I remember the first um when we did this before for the Edgemont property a lot of those initial design um meetings were with teachers staff administrators at what point does community feedback come into play um we can certainly build in wherever you would like but usually it is going to be right around that same time when you're looking at schematic design so typically we'll do some feedback from the community uh early and then a little bit later as well uh we
019do have some new tools available for us uh to use there's a a tool called thought exchange that can really gather a lot of information across the community just to distill we use AI to distill all the the comments All comments into kind of top 10 top 20 kind of feedback uh that we could provide to the board uh that would all of this would be planned out in the communications planning it's not fully done yet but we could certainly have quite a bit it is much easier for us to get community feedback now than say five years ago yeah and and just following up on that in this case the community feedback would have to be the whole District not just the corre town right so yeah because it serves everyone right absolutely yeah
020yeah so the whole yeah the feedback would be yeah could certainly be districtwide you know it can be synchronous and asynchronous as well which is helpful um to gather as much information as we could yeah I've actually I've used thought Exchange in the past in in a previous District It's a Wonderful tool provides opportunity for voices to be heard it doesn't necessarily give extra weight to the loudest or people that type most often um it gives tremendous analytics in terms of what's being produced you can do little word clouds with it it could show what comes up most often um it really is an interesting tool to try to get a consensus understanding of what people are thinking about and it's also one of those where you can open it up for a period of
021time and Folks at their Leisure can do it as opposed to because we'll have we'll do a meeting like a traditional Town Hall type deal as well not everybody can come out to that kind of thing you know so um it'll be a wonderful tool that'll help to get perspective and help guide the discussions you know and some of the decisions that you all as a board will ask you to make called thought exchange and one of one of the best practices is you know if we do have a town hall we'll actually record and then people could watch it and then they can give uh feedback on that at any time does that sort of town hall happen when schematic designs are done what at what point in the process is it most helpful
022good either way so I mean we could certainly we could do initial like we could do before any of that done uh we could do a several pieces of that I mean it it's usually good to do early you know before everything's locked in so probably during schematic design would be the best time to get the first level of feedback and then probably a little later when things are getting more solidified yes I just ask admin then to schedule those sooner rather than later so people have a lot of time to put it on their calendar I believe Mrs Wilson was looking at dates in March was that we're looking at spendal dates so we can get up pretty soon we wanted to wait until after this meeting needing to be able to put stuff
023out but um she's been going back and forth looking to see what it's available I Yeah March April March April to do the first one because we want to be able to get one in before May gets messy right it gets really busy in May is people have little league and softball and Lacrosse and all that kind of stuff is going on Summer's tough so we GNA get the initial one in before folks are gone Joe I also had a Communications related question um uh I think you've done a great job of communicating that this is where conversations are happening right now and sending updates as they happen is there a timeline on the room to learn Room to Grow website particularly for things like FAQs I feel like people are starting to just talk
024more in the community about it which is wonderful but just so that we're sure that consistent information is shared yeah good question Kelly and thank you um we're actually going to be extinguishing the room to learn Room to Grow um and we'll put information about out about when one of the things that that Mr Solomon lists on his about the micro site development um we'll be getting together Mr Wilson is already working on a new name a different name right it it needs to be something that's fresh and different it's a new school and it's about the progress of of moving forward so we will do the creation of a of a new site um we'll talk about what the archive of room to learn Room to Grow will look like and how long will
025it be accessible um but we will start to put out the FAQs and the information so we are building that internally or Mrs Wilson is building that internally right now um as soon as we go through this next step in the process the board will be asked to act on contracts um the contracts that will allow IC and the Shader group and Gus and all to move forward um you know at the at the meeting on the 27th um so those are going through a legal review right now um and once we get those solidified we'll be able to take those next steps in sitting down um but I would expect you know sometime by the end of March at the latest um you know if we do a a community meeting that's going to
026occur in March it would probably coincide with that but I would expect the initial pieces would be up by the end of March um anybody else um for the site visits um because we've changed the scope of this to be K1 um Joe this is more question for you is can we bring some of our K1 teachers on these tours and and then the second question is um can we focus I know that one of the schools we went to and we visited the principal said said everybody's putting this into their schools and we did it too but if I had to do it again I wouldn't do it again and so um now that these schools have been lived in for like maybe two to five years I would love to hear from the
027schools themselves about what things they would double down on and what things they would say really not as helpful as we thought they would be but too so yes we will invite staff I don't know whether that will look like the same time and the same way as when we have board members go out to see it some of it depends upon the timing and the structure to be able to do it uh Mr doer and I have actually talked with a couple of Staff members you know who want to offer their perspective and their thoughts and have been involved um there definitely has to be a role for the staff to be involved right there are instructional experts there the experts you know that are working with the children at this developmental stage um
028but we will talk about that you know what will that look like and how can we set it up will it be outside of the regular working hours will it be a staff trip during the course of the day you know as we've done Mr Roth set up I know seven or eight visits back in the fall for teachers from pencrest to go to high schools that are using a block schedule right so teachers could sign up they organized it you know they had part of a professional day they went out to see them to come back and to be able to talk about what did they see what work well you know that kind of thing um we'll look to do the same thing here as well both in the design phase for the
029new building and then also as we talk about what's the shift and curriculum look like right because that's the next big discussion once the building is moving forward now start to plan what does full dayc look like for our children and again what are those opportunities are going to look like we need to have discussions about transitions transitioning into that building transitioning out of that building into four other buildings right what does that look like what does the involvement of a ptg look like what's the communication and the connection right so we start to talk about those pieces as well are there any other board questions we have a question comment the a students and this one is that is correct okay Rel sare footage how toal sare footage of this schol for 750 students
030how does that compare to other well right now the the program that's that was hatched so far and again it's going to be reviewed further uh is pretty much the same uh they're averaging around 145 to 150 square ft per student and that's what this is this is really probably the district consults is any of that 40 million that we borrowed for the original scho still available Dr Scott you want to jump in first yes so the 40 million from the 2018 bond fund there's approximately 14 million that's still available but it won't go towards this based on I believe it was 2023 where we approved the air conditioning for was it rose tree and Glennwood yes so and projects that will go towards the projects that are happening this summer so Zer Zer probably
031that will be extinguished before well we're you know interesting 17 we're actually going to have a presentation a little while about that service and about borrowing money uh this evening as well it's a blockbuster night um you know but yes we are going to have debt that's going to expire and we're going to talk about what does it look like we're going to have to borrow money for this building um we are going to have to borrow money there's additional work that's going to continue to need to be done in the district when that original those original monies were borrowed um the language that was used was to go towards the new school and other projects within the school district um there are guidelines about the expediency um with how fast that money is to
032be spent once it's borrowed so there are additional projects that have gone on within Ros tree media um one of the most most recent big ones that is ongoing is the air conditioning of Glennwood Indian Lane rose tree and media Elementary School um Glennwood and Indian Glenwood and Rose Tree will be done this summer and then um media and Indian Lane will be completed next summer summer 26 but there's been a as the money has been drawn down uh and expended we have another question than e e [Music] right so so uh a couple of things one um and I appreciate you coming back I know we had some of this discussion in January as well um if you go onto our website the presentation from January that the gentleman did um the demographic study
033is actually reflected in there that we just had redone back in the fall now we do a regression where we take the information that we received from the demographer and we've done a comparison look about what he has said we are going to be projected to have and then the actual enrollment which has continued to maintain and be relatively steady the children aren't just coming the children are here um they are here and we're going to continue to expect them uh based based on the number of units in the communities that the school district serves that have been built uh and they continue to turn over uh and are sold so that the children are absolutely here you know there are um every Community goes through Cycles um and we are in a growing and
034growth cycle listen the elected officials will tell you how excited they are that this continues to be uh a destination spot where people want to live uh and they want to be here um so we have absolutely gone through the numbers um we've sat with with the other folks that we bring in the Consultants to take a look and see what does that mean we do the regression to see who we have projected over the course of the last five years and then who has walked through the door um the children are here uh and they're going to continue to be here we absolutely are we absolutely are listen we just had the discussion again you know we have we have four modular classrooms trailers setting outside behind uh Rose Tre Elementary School we have
035four modular classrooms sitting behind Glenwood there are two modular classrooms that will be delivered there the week after school gets out because we will have six modular classrooms behind Glenwood and they are set and ready to go Mr doer and I have sat down um you know with with Mr bchi to look at the program in that building where's everybody going how are we using the space that the kids are here kids are here families are here continuing to be here absolutely all right more questions from the board we have a question from the audience it's good question thank you for asking the question and thanks for coming back uh to the meetings as well so at the legislative meeting on the 27th two weeks from now uh there will be three separate resolutions that
036the board will a be asked to act upon one of them will end extricate the district from the lawsuit um and effectively the lawsuit that's there um one will um um end the contract with uh rose tree erection um that we had with the the piece of property um that's there and then the third one um will give us the ability to put the other property up for sale the church guess the church property is what we refer to it as but the church property will go up for sale um and it'll be out on the market right we will work through a realtor realtor put it up you know we'll hope that there are folks that are interested in purchasing it we believe that there will be U but those three things will be
037acted on two weeks from tonight um and then that will effectively end that I mean we'll also have the property until you know it can be sold there are some things that we have to go through some additional legal Hoops in order to sell the property um that we will take but that will end it at on the 27th so we already own the the pen Crest property um oh so so there was initial an an initial contract from back in the fall to take a look at the property and do the initial um take the initial look to the initial presentation that comes from operational budget from the school district right right well yes effectively yes right because we'll have contracts you know that that we'll ask the board to to act on that
038evening and we'll have the three resolutions you know to end the process with the Edgemont property it does right yes I no but a good a good outcome for all of us right I mean you know we are Collective I me we we are all part of the same community so it's you know absolutely a question ma'am have a I don't have a dollar to tell you I don't know why don't I have that that's just not something that I have I don't I can I get a dollar amount it's set let's have additional conversation you can send me an email and tell me what it is that that you are what you're asking fighting the taxpayers every Stu of the way fighting the people who live in edgmon trying to get zoning changes when
039the zoning when they vot it down and continued with those legal expenses so how I cannot believe that that number is not top of mine for yeah it's not a number that I have written down it's not a number that I have in my head um if you would send me an email I certainly will uh have Dr Scott follow up uh with you and see what that is put together all right I can give you my email address uh if you don't have it um just I'll bring it over for you I'll come over to you we can I think we can move on Teresa there's one comment I wanted to make regarding um Cynthia's comments about the $40 million I know that of that 40 not all of that was earmarked for the
040school they just happened to be the same number that the school was going to cost approximately $40 million and we had a $40 million Bond but the $40 million Bond was I think partially for the new school but also substantially for all sorts of other capital projects that had to be done in the district so even though those numbers were the same it was never that particular bond fund of 40 million was going to all be spent on the new school it was never going to be that way so to somebody else's point we need topend it we can't just hold it we're paying interest on it and so it's also the cafeteria expansion was the other big project okay all right thank you thank you thanks all right so now we'll move to the
041capital projects update Dr napon Williams back with us this evening Mr Mike Nolan supervisors our facilities and Mr Dennis cinii who oversees capital projects for us gentlemen good evening let's go over the projects that are in progress now and that are going to happen this summer and as you see on the board our mechanical electrical Plumbing projects everything except the new Lighting in pentest Auditorium is um done except for that that lighting which will happen this summer window and scotlet Replacements uh the contract was awarded to a general contractor shop drawings are being done fabrication to start soon and we will be schedule for summer 2025 new windows at rose trees new Skylight at media the spr lake track uh that's in design and it's being reviewed by Upper Providence we had it scheduled for
042March that may have to push a little bit couple months due to reviews but again we're hoping for summer 2025 HVAC upgrades at Glennwood and Rose Tree bids for received and I'll be over those bid results they were good bid results construction for summer 2025 springton Lake cafeteria bids were due on February 11 11th and we got the bids construction for 2025 I'll review those bids with you they were also excellent pen Crest High School this is for the consumer science renovation science room renovation TV studio and repair replacement of Stucco at Indian Lane um that is in the design phase all the user meetings are done and gko is proceeding with design that's schedule for bidding in late March again summer 2025 hva upgrade this is for media and Indian Lane which is our
0432026 construction projects there's a proposal on tonight's agenda from gko Architects for approval and that bidding will be scheduled for the fall of 2025 are there any questions from the board regarding uh capital projects update I just have one question for the um the EI the ephis OR eifs at Indian Lane are we repairing it and replacing the eifs or we repairing replacing it with something bes besides e now we are replacing at this point with eephus again okay all right I just want to make sure sorry I want you said for two sets of bids that you received excellent quality or quantity of w bids competition was very keen excellent okay I want make sure I heard correctly there you'll see some really good comp we ran out of very surprised we ran out
044of paperwork and we ran out of P I think in board room so it was U most I've ever seen and we'll be able to have that completed by the end of summer 2025 yeah we are we are thank fortunately way ahead of time it's why we got out out the b because I know the Middle School cafeteria is bursting at the seam so yes yes that actually will start construction probably end of March outside or half I I'm just curious do you know or have an idea as to why you receive so many good bids for these timing is a big issue so that was perhaps yeah you're going out to bid this early for summer projects a lot of contractors don't have all their work yet and this these are the first things
045that come up and they bid them yeah timing is timing is everything on these it's why I always stress to get our capital projects approved as early as possible in the fall and the specs must have been really good uh one of the contractors told us because the bids were all very comparable nobody was too high nobody too low so um the way it was drawn up was really good yeah thank you that was sort of my followup is that I get a little nervous like because it because it's so good what we're offering should we be mind but it sounds like it was all within a good range very fair so okay okay next any other questions on capitals point we have a couple change orders here one is for the media Skylight roach
046tree window project um this is for LJ Pella it's to change the um the glazing in the gym to laminated glass as opposed to tempered glass I didn't realize that that many windows got broken in that gym over time but they do so we have this change so it's 6462 we have another change order for a an Lynch this is a credit change order I'm sorry cheer it's a it's a credit change order for 22150 for unused allowances that we included in the bid we also have gk's proposal for the air conditioning electrical upgrades for media and Indian Lane for air conditioning for summer 2026 but again we need to start that process now for design did we do a similar um uh work with gko for the other two schools as well okay go
047yes I just want to say thank you for for working on that I know that will make a huge difference to the staff and the students it was so wilting in the spring days so um uh anyway thank you so much it's a really important project that will think make a huge morale booster and also just quality of learning and work life um yeah it's miserable when you're that hot so thank you this you yeah mobile lease uh we're gonna you know as Dr M said earlier we're gonna have two new classrooms that Glenwood um installed this summer um I already been contact with them and that I believe I wasn't here at that time but I was already in Works before I got here cor yeah that's just a continuation all the approvals are
048done for that already we got that's all everything is just matter of prepped just doing it and there's nothing different about these two from the other four basically the same and what is this where is it being put what's it being put on top of it's at Glenwood there's two sets right now it's being right next to it so it would be one two three sets of two on what's currently grass or yes currently grass grass yep so this just emphasizes that we had four now we're getting six because of the influx of students right they're outside of the building in these six uh modular trailers and as you say Dr hson Williams you look at the initial payment is $170,000 and then between the this year we will have uh 10 modular units on
049two properties will pay a little bit more than 35,000 dollars a month probably closer to to between 36 and $ 37,000 a month is what we'll pay lease wise and while there I've heard some people say well it's okay to use modular and see how it goes with population this doesn't include the extra pressures that are on the cafeteria the gymnasiums we only have small Art Space over there art on a cart we're really bursting at the seams because it's not just extra classroom space you need it's extra everything space bathrooms everything and so putting these modulars really isn't a long-term or permanent solution that works and if I'm correct and I believe I am all of our schools are over pte recommended capacity at this point we always targeted in the past and I'm
050talking 10 15 years ago to be at 85% of pte capacity and we are over pte capacity at all of our schools so okay you want to show that bid tabulation this is the bid tabulation for the uh HVAC projects as you can see you got plenty of biders for this one the low bidder for mechanical for air conditioning was 6 million4 low bidder for electrical 6 55300 and general construction 1,538 our total project budget was a little over 9 million 9 milon2 contract award was 8,593 300 we are $637,000 under budget and that includes um HVAC controls being upgraded it also includes renovation of the faculty toilet rooms at at Rose Tree Elementary also in that Pro along with new casew work new casework Under the windows yes that's right I don't recall have
051we had experience with Spectra electrical yes okay so we have numerous project going thank you my mine was drawing a blank on them so okay great thank you okay all right anything else from the board I see a couple of hands I I assume it's from something we've we got one more bid tab here okay why don't you do that and then springton L cafeteria bid came in the other day take a look at these and you'll see the competition that we've got excellent I mean really excellent so as you can see low bid for GC bankr construction 2,109 Spectre electrical again low bid 654 uh all stat mechanical 3088 and the plumbing Integrity 224 project budget um was 2,880 this I took the budget from the 2023 facility study which was like 2 mil7
052I did 5% escalation since it's been about a year and a half and that's what the budget would be so the contract award is within $63,000 of our budget pretty good couple of days yes definitely definitely good definitely anything from the board okay we have something in the audience yesy uh I don't know that they they don't all have bathrooms in them no correct um did we consider buying them I I don't know that we looked into that to make it a permanent fixture that's there and then what to do with them after we had them and then s back do it all the time yeah yeah I I don't know whether purchase was an initial discussion the first ones were put in over at Ros tree we are not we are not renting to
053purchase so to my recollection we did have a conversation about buying them or renting them because we thought we'd only be needing them for two to three years of the time um with the other school project that was going on we decided against purchasing we have another question in the audience or it buys us electrical all electrical work required all the mechanical work required all the plumbing work and piping that's required for those two schools for air conditioning yes the air conditioning itself definitely for that that's that's the design fee that's the Architects design architect engineer design fee for the project is 600,000 correct that is a Professional Services fee correct go not have to go it didn't have to to Professional Services contract no no all right six and a half percent which is
054right within IND standards right the fee percentage was six and a half percent which is right in the middle of Industry standards for Design Services for this type of project yes all right do we have anything else are we good thank you thank you next up we'll have uh Raymond James Public Finance Dr mil thank you Dr napon Williams yes we're going to get set up here um we have from Raymond James and pfm Ally and Brad are here this evening um some of you the board I'm sure will will recognize and remember both Ally and Brad having been here in the past board members you have a copy of the presentation that's going to come up if you want to take notes on it um going to be quite a bit of information uh
055some time to think about it no decisions tonight from you lots of listening some questions for our professionals uh and we'll have additional discussion moving forward so Ali and Brad I'm going to turn it over to you too and we're good to go thank you again I'm Brad remig with pfm uh Financial advisory firm and what we wanted to do to give the board is kind of a Rob Map for how you accomplish what it is that you're talking about trying to accomplish with the K1 building because you'll need to borrow funds for those projects and we just want to give you a road map of what that might look like um over the next two or three years so Ally ran a lot of the numbers don't worry I didn't she she's she ran
056all the numbers so I want to go through those tonight good thank you everybody I'm gonna go to the first slide of the presentation uh this is just an interestate chart we always find it helpful because the first question everyone always has is what's the market like for people that want to go out and borrow money um so I know we've heard a lot about rates increasing over the last 12 to 18 months which is true um however we were coming up off of the bottom of alltime low interest rates during covid so while we are getting higher we are still below the historical average when it comes to the cost that you can borrow at what you can see here the red line is the current yield curve so that's where you can borrow
057money at today for each of those different maturity tranches across the bottom the blue line is the historic average so what you might also notice about this is that historically the yield curve is upwardly sloping and right now while it is still upwardly sloping it's kind of flat there in that beginning part of the curve and it's what we would call slightly inverted still where we're earning interest on our short-term borrowed funds or your operating funds or the things you have in the bank at a higher rate um than we have in the past and the rate that we're borrowing out long term is kind of in the same general wheelhouse because the curve is so flat as to what we're earning when we deposit it in the bank so 2 things to to keep
058in mind as we go through the rest of the presentation the next table is the existing debt profile of the district so this is the debt that you currently have on the books if you do nothing these are still the payments that you owe on these particular issuances column two is your portion of the DCCC debt um and then columns 34 and five are the actual debt incurred by the district itself so you can see there you have an A and A B series of 2017 which are set to pay off in this current fiscal year and then the only debt left after that is the 2018 bonds um and you'll see there that that is a relatively short amortization um which is going to give you a lot of flexibility and really allow you
059to finance these projects pretty efficiently because you have that type of debt profile that is highly unusual most of your peers have debt that run out 15 20 25 years um so this is an extremely short depb profile from that perspective the other thing I'll just note on this page is at the bottom of column five um you may recall you know you can refinance debt like you can refinance your home mortgage however we have lockout periods when you you bond borrowings in the public market and the last piece it comes due early next spring so we're watching that if there is any opportunity to refinance that for savings interest rate savings which you know we would do um we'll bring that to the boards of attention because of the tax cut Act of 2017
060it took away your ability might remember we used to do what we call advancer fund these bonds um which meant you could do that one time in its life anytime you wanted to that went away with that tax cut act uh now you have to be within 90 days of that call date to be able to refinance them on a tax exempt basis so that's why we're looking at the January early January next year time frame before we could do anything on that if it made sense to do it at that time all right next page is we just wanted to put this out here because we always like to kind of give you the little bit of History um and some of you may or may not remember the board here has never borrowed
061money frivolously over time and in fact has taken advantage every single time there's been any type of refinancing savings um over since 2009 you guys have refinanced continually as it made sense and saved over $6 million of interest expense just by simply ref ing debt that you had taken out previously so we just always like to put that in there remind uh everyone that you are being fiscally responsible and taking advantage of all those opportunities and then the next slide is kind of the the Crux of the the presentation here we wanted to give you hard copies because I know it's incredibly hard to see those tiny numbers on the screen um but basically knowing that you have this K1 project that you're considering doing and that you're going to have to bond Finance set
062to some level what does that look like laying it out uh what makes sense in terms of a plan to spread out the millage impact of the the funds that you're going to have to raise to service the debt um and how do you borrow it within you know the IRS spend down limits and things of that nature so what we've done here is in column two this is the outstanding debt of the district as it stands today so this ties back to that debt summary that we looked at a couple slides previous and then column three four and five layer in $81 Million worth of borrowing over three different tranches so the first trunch what we will call the seed money is a $15 million borrowing sometime this year to get you the funds
063to start to pay design cost and permitting and the other things that you need to kind of get the project going even though you're not starting construction quite yet and probably won't get to the heavy spend until next summer per you know the draw schedule we had received from Shader so that's really just the the first pot of money to get you started um you can see what we're doing here is we're actually taking advantage of the fact that your debt service falls off and essentially really goes away after 2029 um and we're layering in the principle once the existing debt pays off what that allows us to do is to keep the debt shorter which means less interest expense because the longer you go out the higher the interest rate and it also allow
064allows us to have minimal budget impact up front so it allows us to take advantage of the fact that you already have that almost 11 or 11 million doll in your run rate and that it's going away and we'll just be able to redirect that to the new debt if that makes sense so then we would come back in um sometime in 2026 we would layer in the bulk of what you're going to need because that's when your heavy spends really going to start that's when you're going to probably be out to bid you're going to kind of know more the scope the actual final sizing of the project um and we would break off the largest chunk there to give you enough money to spend through the heavy construction months on the project and
065then column five is the last piece that would fund whatever is you know the balance in this case we've assumed that it's 26 million because you've borrowed 40 million in 2026 and we like to do it that way because you're going to have things that occur as you're building this project you're going to have change orders you're going to have a roadblock or two that pop up what whatever it might be or maybe bids come in better than we think they did and we need less money so we don't want to over borrow so we kind of use that last piece as the right size so for now we've just sized it to the 81 but we could hold that out there till 2027 when we have all the knows and then you know maybe
066you have capital reserve funds that you want to put some money towards that we can downsize the borrowing to take that into account so we kind of want to lay this out where we're a not you know shoving all the debt service and having to get it on board in one year we want to phase it in over a longer period of time which phasing out the project like this allows you to do and also to you know just give you that structure where you can kind of roll with those punches and readjust and not over borrow or under borrow and then have to go out at the end and borrow $2 million because we you know didn't know what the final scope was so that's kind of the reason for that um and I'm
067so sorry for n for a second but I just I've seen some you know residents taking pictures will we have this presentation available for everyone for more easy access and download on the website yes okay I just want to make sure that it might save people versus getting up and having to do too many pictures so this will all be available for public consum yeah it'll be listed and again there'll be a link as we've had on the front page of the website um I don't know if it'll be up tomorrow with the holiday on Monday by by Tuesday afternoon for sure it will be up in and ready to go I was just going to point out a couple things um real quick so the first borrowing as Ally mentioned is just about 15
068million there's a reason for that and that is if the school district borrows 15 million or less than a calendar year the earnings and we talked about the market how the investment rates are good the earnings you're allowed to keep for three years as a small keep all the earnings the general rule is if you borrow at one rate and you earn more you have to give it back but the 15 million you can keep all the interest earnings while you have that money there's two other financings that Ally mentioned we probably can't do that because you need the money you know you're gon need more funds but for the first one we were trying to take advantage of it I think allly pointed this out as well but by not doing it all at
069once you'll notice when she gets to the right we'll able to step this in a little bit more easily to your budget basically what we've modeled here if I'm not mistaken is the least cost to the budget both from a upfront perspective and a total interest perspective that's what we've we've set up correct thank you for pointing that out um the other thing you know we want to be cognizant of is we all know we have to live under the Act One index we all know that Debt Service isn't the only budgetary pressure you're going to have there's other things that you know you need to do to keep the lights on and keep programs going and things like that so we don't want to say oh our index is 5.3% and we're going to
070use all of that for Debt Service because we can't do that right we know we have to be planners and we have to lay out in a way that's responsible and we also have to keep in mind that we've kind of as far as we can tell from all the independent budget office projections that we've kind of reached the high point uh of where the index is going to be and it's projected over the next four to five years to kind of decline over time so we're going to have less index to work with on top of having other budgetary pressures so we want to be cognizant of not trying to say okay we're going to do this all at once we're going to put it all in you know we can't really do that
071so we're going to phase this in over five years in this model we can play with that however you know the board would like to see it but for this initial pass we just assumed a fiveyear phase in so if you look to the right there in column 10 in order to phase in this millage and if we just did it on a level basis we would need roughly just shy or just more than a tenth of a mill slightly more than a tenth of a mill each year for five years running starting in the next budget year or 68% roughly of the index to go to Debt Service and be permanently dedicated to Debt Service um if you get it in ear like let's say you have a great year you got a surplus
072you want to put a little bit more in for Debt Service It just relieves the out years then or we can shorten it a year or if we have a tough B budget year and we can't get the full tenth and we get you know seven T SE or 0.07 of a mill we can push it out to the oute so it's it's flexible but I think it's just conceptually easier to understand when you just kind of say okay I need a tenth of a mill for five years running that's and in these projections we assume the value of a mill doesn't grow so to the extent you get growth in the value of a mill it just reduces again that percentage burden uh of the increase that's needed the other thing you'll notice in
073column six is that we have some cash there it's called interest earnings or School District reserves this is how we're going to accomplish actually phasing in the debt over a longer period of time we have to actually use either you know cash Reserve interest earnings that you're going to earn on the debt as you're holding it other cash of the district to kind of get over the little bit of a hump there where you have existing debt in place and you need to phase in the new debt accordingly so and that will all change as we change these numbers and change the timing and the way we want to phase that in so the quicker you get it into the budget the less cash we need so th those kind of have an inverse relationship
074and would we be able to use the proceeds from the sale of the church um property in the same way yeah I think you could do that yep so does anybody have any questions before I move on to the next page on on this because it's going to largely follow the format of this slide we're going to wait um we're gonna wait for the audience thank you okay so then the next slide um we just wanted because as we're thinking and planning um I think it's slide six that's it that was it y this one while we know that the K1 center is roughly 81 million based on the current projections we also just want to be mindful that behind that project you might have other projects you're considering so we had um ask the
075administration just for a three to five year view of what may be coming behind this just to show you the impact of adding additional debt after the K1 project is complete they told us there might be roughly $49 Million worth of other things the board's considering not that you've approved that um but we wanted to layer that on after that project was completed so you could just at least see what that impact is versus just doing the K1 center so here you'll see two additional columns in six and seven where we add those two pieces roughly half and half 25 and 24 million to get to the 49 and then you'll notice that because we're extending how many tranches we have we've also extended the phasin of that debt to be seven years so on
076the on the total you need about 0.12 Ms per year for seven years versus the tenth of a mill for five for just the the K1 project or 08 let's call it percent of the index uh for 7 years running or 87 Ms total to fund both the K1 and in add add $49 million down the road and again we're just wanted to give that to you for informational purposes so that you know we can assess millage increase what should be in the budget to fund this debt versus if we're trying to build for future projects down the line and then the the uh next page is just putting it in terms of a property tax impact analysis um if you look at the top box that's just the 81 million for the K1 Learning
077Center so if you actually look at the kind of line in the middle that's bold the median home price of or I'm sorry the median assessed value in the district of a home is 385,000 and change so the current property tax bill associated with that assessed value is just North of $6,000 if we add the 0.53 MS that we're estimating it's going to take to fund the K1 Center the new property tax bill would be roughly $6,250 or a total property tax increase to fund that project to the uh assess average assessed home value of $24 41 which divided over five years is a $488 increase annually for five years we also wanted we understand not everybody has that assessed value of their home so we gave you a plus and a minus ,000 on
078that and what what those metrics go to for plus 100 or minus 100 and then you can see there in the Bold on the bottom we give you the impact per $100,000 so if you wanted to just extrapolate it out you could do that and get to a number that made sense for whatever whoever wanted to look at this information and then the bottom box is just the same exact thing but done for the K1 and the future projects just to see that 087 and what the impact of that is if you decided to do those other things down the road do anybody have any questions to that point before I go to the next slide all right and then the last slide is just because I know um the administration indicated to us that
079the project may be coming sooner than later uh we wanted to give you kind of the quickest we could move to do that first $15 million piece of the financing if and when you're ready um so this would be closing in miday which is kind of the fastest we can get money if we needed it and then backing up from there then we would you know be looking to come and get what we call parameters resolution and bond purchase agreement done at the meeting at the end of March to be able to move fast enough to get the money in the bank by may now this is the fastest we can move that doesn't mean we have to do that you all can think about that and and plan out accordingly but that would be
080the soonest we could do we can do anything past that um that you know you want to do the the one thing I would say is I think it would behoove the board to put into place a reimbursement resolution that's a one-page minute book resolution that you could pass at any voting meeting and all it does is if you start to spend District cash on things like design fees and architect fees and things of that nature out of your own you know operating or general fund it allows you when you do do the borrowing if you want to you don't have to but if you want to to reimburse yourself out of the fund from the bond issuance at that point and it's on no harm no foul kind of resolution where if you don't
081use it it just goes away if you if you want to it's there um but per the IRS code if you don't have one you cannot do it and it looks back 60 days from when you passed it so if you passed it in February or March it would look back 60 days from whatever date you passed it in terms of the expenditures you could reimburse yourself for did I miss anything I think that was really good you don't main point any questions um I think we kind of hit a nice road map to give you an idea of what you're looking looking at um the one I want to reiterate what allly said given where you are today in terms of what's in your budget for Debt Service you're in a really nice position
082to be able to afford this um because this type of a project can be much more expensive to your budget and taxpayers if you weren't in the situation that you and the other thing I'll note to that point is if you looked at that $81 million study um even when you layer on that $81 million the debt still would pay off in fiscal year 2036 so we're not even extending the debt an additional 20 years even bringing all of that on because your debt portfolio today is so short it it's kind of an anomaly I there's not many places I've seen that um I just have one question and thank you so much I feel like that was really digestible and I appreciate the way that you walked through everything um will the administration be
083making a recommendation about the 81 versus 130 what's the next step on decision- making around that assuming that you know the step's leading up to that we will so we're gonna listen to the discussion and and hear perspective from the board you know answer questions that kind of thing as we go through probably the next month um and then ultimately we will make a recommendation as to what we think is the best path forward Ward for the school district in terms of what needs to be done in order to maintain the quality and the level of Education to provide facilities um that help to support the great works that our teachers do um and you know we've said it before our greatest resource are the humans that are here we want to make sure that
084the facilities that are around them support the work that they do every day um but we'll make a recommendation to you you know and and do it in a way that um maintains fiscal responsibility we want to be good stewards you know for all the residents and for all the folks that you know who are sending their children to our schools who will be sending their children who did send their children you know who benefit from living in such a wonderful Community to that end will we be reviewing all that list of projects because I know that30 is basically the whole gko review of all of our facilities here and what we need to do we have an opportunity to revisit that list say what have we already done like the cafeteria expansion I know
085was on the gko list and we've already started that but I think it would be helpful to go and revisit that what's still on the table what do we need to do what would we like to do but it wouldn't be wouldn't make the cut true absolutely yes we'll be putting that together I was wondering if we could look at another option here um like you've laid out sure um I'm just thinking that especially because of the fields like that seems to be a more oppressing matter and in this one even that went out to the 130 we're looking at 2029 for you know a significant piece of that and I imagine that if we move forward with the building and Fields and some par issues we're going to need more sooner so I know
086there's a reason to keep the debt short but what if we took more and had longer like what does that look like in terms of Interest Etc sure and yeah we can move the pieces around here for sure um based on that so we can run another proposal that maybe has four borrowings but more loaded into 20 six and 27 and no 29 yeah I was thinking just add 10 million to every step you know what I mean yeah or something like that y do that any other questions from the board all right we have a something audience go ahead thank you double a so very good uh double a double A Plus AAA so you are two notches below AAA do we still have no money on the 60 million that we borrowed in
0872018 for the so in in 2018 you borrowed I think it was 40 40 million uh those are the proceeds I think Dr Scott said you have about $14 million left that you're still have allocated to the HVAC projects or the air conditioning projects um but you are still paying Debt Service on them they their Debt Service is paid off in 2029 which is when we're now layering in the new debt after that pays off thank you for uh doing the millage in terms of the average house value the impact that this would have on our taxes yes 400,000 that would be something like $260 yep 20 $24 on a 385,000 assess value in over five years over five years we have something else from the audience go ahead assum about the tax index what
088type of assumptions were you making and if you can talk about real interest or real percentages and over what period so the Act One index is set by the state and it's based on an inflationary index so now that inflation is coming down the independent budget office has put out projections for where they think the index is going to go over the next several years and while in 2425 uh this District's index was 5.3% we're going to see that Trend down W over the next several years we think based on what we know today right maybe inflation goes back up maybe it goes back up but but based on what we know today and what they're projecting we expect that not to happen um and so what we're laying out here is just converting the
089required millage over those five years to on board this debt service with how much of that index we would have to use to dedicate towards Debt Service so we haven't made any assumption as to what the index is going to be other than you know we we think it's trending downward um but we just do know based on what we've laid out here which has contingency in the interest rates because we're not pricing these bonds today we don't want to assume we're getting today's rates so we've built in 50 basis points of interest rate contingency for the first two pieces and then 100 basis points on the last one um because we want to be a little conservative there we don't know and if it's better that's great if not at least we're being a
090little bit more conservative so when we we say you know we need roughly let's say it's 70% of the index let's say it's 4% two years from now we need to dedicate less than 1% of that to Debt Service um and that's based on a conservative assumption we feel today the independent budget Association is making or the group from Harrisburg that you reference so they base theirs on they get economic data from the federal government they it's based on what they call the saw index they take CPI numbers and all kinds of ferally regulated numbers to and it's kind of a black box we don't know exactly how they come to those projections but that's what they're showing so that's all we we really know IND next no no so we know that the the
091base index for next year is going to be 4% but every District in Pennsylvania is eligible be adjusted based on their own socioeconomic demographics so while the index next year Baseline might be 4% Rose trees's index might be 4.3% or 3.7% like they adjust the index per district and we don't have any idea how they're going to adjust your index next year I don't know Dr Scott if they've released that information at this point for next year yet I don't think so right no you're talking about for the 2526 budget for 2526 4% 4% 4% yes 4% for extra we have something else from the audience go ahead sir um you actually answer question actually Jack um borrowing 81 million using a projection to 3% growth of the local property tax is really not a
092heavy lift for this District that's pretty uh modest what we've been seeing we've seen uh I think it's about 4.77% since the reassessment if you do that at 81 million we never exceed our debt service level that we saw for the 2018 bonds that's great we have to necessarily get crazy with the tax rate increases but that 130 milon we do exceed that makes me personally as a taxpayer nervous but if you spread it out over 20 years you can balance it in and actually the question I wanted asked when I came in here was what is the board's plans after the school because if you do it on 10year bonds there wasn't much margin much wiggle to borrow more unless you were going to raise go above the ACT rate so you kind of
093shown that you're thinking another 40 million actually 50 million so why not spread it out on or at least some of them you want yeah I was just going to say we tried to put together was the lowest overall cost yes totally but that could be something that we be done the probably what you would see if we went longer is you'd probably see more of an impact you probably because you're you're now having you're now um selling 20year bonds and those interest rates are typically higher than 10year bonds so you'd see more of it but I hear I understand what you're saying create drop offs in the future basically what I hear you're saying you could do that but we'd have more interest up front and that that number 0.53 might go to it's
094not going to go to one but it probably go to 6 or 065 I guess I'm more interested in that service toer local property tax were pretty accurate projecting year after year that's a very accurate number we have all numbers and you can kind of project where we be at say1 you are we carrying too much debt one million no I don't think they would 13 well from what I understand the district in the past has always asked for these short debt services but there's a philosophical question about well if your building is going to be 50 years why then burden today's taxpayer with higher debt service so that's why I asked the question also I think it's something we should at least look that and talk about all right we have a to have
095a 20y year conversation to Deb you're right about the interest rate being lower on the short side but the debt service number is lower as well kind of like when you buy your first house right be house for mortgage but over the number of years as as inflation takes over you're you're paying pay more money in the long run than total interest but your debt service number is a smaller portion of your total budget I've always advocated you're going to build a building that's got a 50-year engineering life cycle and it's depreciated over 40 years on our accounting books uh it's a heavy burden to on the current taxpayers to pay for that school in 10 years from an accounting uh perspective it'll last 40 engineering perspective it'll last 30 we had something else from
096the audience yes that'se our tax a what about what's to cost to it itties all that that's going increase our also on we not talking about well I don't think that's what today's conversation is for this is just about the debt service and that'll be part of our operational budget conversation they're two different conversations so those will come okay you know we're it's gonna be we're gonna have to St right and like she said we are going to be looking at that okay operationally too I mean that's where the Act One index comes into play um The Last 5 Years we have increased taxes lower than what the state says we can and also significantly lower than inflation and so I think the district has been very good stewards of our taxpayer dollars in that
097perspective and so uh as we talk about how we're going to do the operational expenses we're still going to be constrained by act one so there's always going to be con St on what we can do [Music] I think we're getting I mean I do think we need to be mindful that these are important conversations but we're focusing right now on one area all right other questions comments I think we're doing the the bus Grant next right we are that's exciting Dr Scott are our folks from Highland we're on the line can you hear us okay good evening yes we good evening momentarily we're just gonna get so we're in a little screen share great does it so it makes sense for us to share our screen yes uh em this is chash it would
098probably be the easiest and the cleanest if you were controlling it and sharing it from from there you should have access and rights to be able to do that great can you see that all right okay great and you can see and and hear me okay we can yes perfect I'll go ahead and get started thank you so much for having us this evening um we're really excited to be presenting um my name is Emily Parish I'm a senior manager on the Fleet Solutions team Highland and my colleague Pat is also on the line he he's also on the Fleet Solutions team um we have worked closely with the district as well as Roar bus your current um School Bus dealer to apply for some Federal grant funding for uh to reduce the cost of
099purchasing electric school buses as well as some um State grant funding so that Federal award was received back in May and the state funding application was submitted and we should hear back on that funding in the next month or two and those funds can be utilized together on the same project um Highland helps districts across the country apply to Grants at no cost um but first and foremost we are an implementor of these electric School Bus projects so our goal today is to give you a bit of an overview of what a partnership with Highland could look like um to ensure a successful project um we'll try to keep things relatively brief but of course can answer questions um quick agenda we'll go over a overview of what it is we do um The Proposal
100the you know partnership economic analysis and the timeline here um Highland was created really to um solve electrification complexity and um make it simpler and easier for a school district to Electrify their transportation um the transportation team is really good at operating their Fleet getting kids to school on time um in their you know diesel internal combustion engine world when it comes to new technology like electric school buses there's a lot more involved right um and Highland was really created as a company to partner with school districts as an extension of their transportation team to take a lot of those other components off the plate of of the school district right how are we going to install charging stations how are we going to fuel these buses to ensure that they can operate every single
101day what does the maintenance look like how do we ensure we're complying with all the grant regulations um all that good stuff um little overview of where we are so we're a national company um but we have a big footprint on the east coast and we actually have the most projects um under contract in in Pennsylvania out of any other state um a few districts we're working with Bethlehem Area Unionville chadz Ford Baldwin White Hall and Eerie schools um and our buses have driven over three million miles um now so what is actually included in our offering so we are an equipment and services provider for electrification um and that involves a few different things here so we provide the buses themselves you can think of it a little bit like a lease but since
102we bundle a lot of other things with it we call it a Services contract they're built to the district specifications typically we own the vehicles for the duration of the contract because we can actually take advantage of a lot of tax tax benefits as a private company like um federal tax credits accelerated depreciation and and we pass those benefits to The District in our in our contract um we typically handle all of the construction associated with installing charging stations we um coordinate with pico your your local utility to bring in the required electrical service engineering permitting all of the installation work um we provide Fleet and charge management software which is a really important part of an electric School Bus project that helps the district monitor it's its electric school buses ensuring they're charged it
103helps the Chargers talk to the buses it helps Highland monitor the charging stations to ensure that they are working um we provide a 97% uptime guarantee on the charging stations which really means um we are ensuring they work for you know a 10 to 12 year contract period um we do the maintenance on the charging stations we typically also include the fuel to actually run these buses and that comes in the form of electricity um and our charge management software is is all programmed so that we ensure first and foremost that the buses can meet the route needs but also that we're reducing and optimizing the energy costs for the district um the last thing or there's a couple more things not on here but the last big bucket is we typically reimburse for vehicle
104maintenance um again we we partner with your with your preferred dealer with Roar um and you all continue to perform the maintenance that you perform on your vehicles um we train you in partnership with Roar to ensure that your mechanics are comfortable working on them Roar does any of the maintenance that cannot be performed by the district and what Highland does is provide essentially a bumper-to-bumper warranty for the life of the contract on the vehicle um you know this is all packaged together with ongoing training with support on all Grant compliance um so yeah it's a it's a lot of services a lot of equipment wrapped in one here some additional benefits to highlight about this type of TurnKey solution is it's a perform perance based contract so you're you're not paying us until the
105buses are delivered the Chargers have been installed and commissioned and everything's ready to go um it provides a predictable operational budget for you all so we're kind of fixing some of your operational costs over the life of the contract um and it's all kind of wrapped up into one single fee so you know exactly what you're paying to maintain and fuel these vehicles for the life of the vehicles really and you have access to our team um you know there's anywhere from seven to 10 different people on our operations team that are involved with each of our school districts on a weekly basis from our maintenance team to our grants team to our energy team um so you really have again an extension of your transport your existing Transportation team to ensure um everything's going
106well with with electrics here um just an overview of a of an idea for a site plan so typically we have to bring in some new electrical equipment to install the charging station so we've done some work to coordinate with pico on what a good path would be to get power to the site um and we always plan to um upssize the infrastructure a little bit to ensure that it is easier to expand and the fleet moving forward you know without making like an unnecessary upfront investment um so this is an idea that we talked about with the team on you know where we could we could install the charging stations to go into a little bit of the pricing um as I mentioned we provide all these Services uh bundle together for a fixed
107annual fee on a perb basis so the pricing we're looking at right now is $33,000 per bus and that is escalated annually by 3% a fixed escalator for what we've modeled a 12year contract um we typically model the contract term to the life of the vehicle um we do think these these batteries and these buses will last longer than 12 years um the real kind of uh constraint there is is some of the um wear and tear on the frame of the bus itself from you know salty and and um the roads um what else here so we've included the the grants that that we have been awarded that you all have been awarded and we anticipate being awarded through the state as part of this so that's um you know it would be more
108expensive on a perb basis if if we didn't have that grant funding and we do typically stipulate an annual mileage which should reflect what you're planning to use these buses for um and that helps us understand how much we're going to pay for electricity and the best use case for these buses right now is is AM and PM routes and and many of your routes Fall Right In The Sweet Spot for the um range and the feasibility really the buses can go a lot a lot more than 45 miles a day um so there's there's real no real concern on Range um when you're when you're looking at am am routes time for for the buses to charge in the middle of the day they need to and then going out for the afternoon routs
109um the next the next slide just show is a breakdown of the cost over 12 years and then total just so you have an understanding of like what is what does that mean to have a an escalator um and the next few slides really dive into some cost comparisons so we find it's helpful to look at this price right because because you don't typically buy buses and and buy services this way um for your you know your transportation operations so it helps to look at kind of two different analyses the first one on this page is a estimate of the Highland contract for 12 years compared to what you could be spending to purchase a diesel bus um you know pay for fuel for 12 years and pay for maintenance for 12 years so it's
110really a forward looking analysis um you know we're we're based on kind of the market data we've built up this analysis and feel you know confident that we're about cost parity with with your operations today it really just depends on how you all you know project what your cost could look like moving forward and um you know internal combustion engine diesel cost will continue to to rise over time and the emphasis is that the Highland price is fixed that's exactly what you're paying for the next the next 12 years um in a similar manner we did an analysis based on going electric with Highland versus going independent and what that means is you know you could hire a contractor to install the charging stations um manage the operations yourself maybe have a vendor that does
111charge management um and really the packaged TurnKey product provides a lot of of um benefits as as we've talked about and really um you know the way we look at this is if you all um go about doing the project on your own and if everything goes perfect for the next 12 years um it's possible you could do this for more for for cheaper um but with you know when you're when you're working with us you're you're again fixing your costs it's a performance-based contract we're guar guing it's going to be success for you and in a case where things go really wrong um you know you have to replace a bad a vehicle battery outside of warranty that could cost you a $100,000 just to replace one vehicle battery with Highland you you don't
112have to outlay that Capital it's included in our in our warranty and in our offering so um there are more specifics on the inputs that we use to build up this analysis in the appendix so you're all wel welcome to to review that um but I won't go into too much detail on that right now I think the last slide oh two more slides the last slide or the slide here is on on the timeline really from um contract s contract finalization if you were to move forward with this project with a partner like Highland it's about a year um to actually have the buses operational on the road the biggest lead time items are some of the Utility Equipment or the large electrical infrastructure like Transformer and switch gear um we have a lot
113that we pre-order to try to move up those timelines the other big lead time is just manufacturing the bus itself um which which could take nine nine to 12 months again um so there's a lot of planning involved in you know ensuring that it's implemented on time which is which is what we help with um the last thing we'll mention is you can we have a contract that was already competitively bid via sourcewell Cooperative Contracting um agency that includes this whole package um so that is one way you could go about procuring this contract and the way um the other districts in Pennsylvania procured the contract um via VIA sourcewell um again the rest the appendix just goes through some details on the cost comparisons I'll just like click through those um I'll stop there
114happy to answer any questions all right anybody from the board have a question for them I do have a question but it might oh sorry um I'm not sure if the grants were awarded maybe in the year that I wasn't on the board so if this is some you can maybe fill me in after I guess my question is just about the specifics of what they're paying for or how it is incorporated into this is that an offline discussion or yeah okay I can okay I'm happy to address it really quick if if you'd like yes Emily that would be great okay great so the you were awarded $200,000 per bus um sorry I'm just finding this per bus through the EPA clean School Bus program that's a million dollars for five buses so that
115goes to directly reduce the cost of the vehicles the electric school buses cost three times the amount of diesel buses so really those grants help bring the project to cost parity and in a similar manner this um AIG Grant which is available through the state um Can essentially stack onto those grants and further reduce The Upfront cost of the of the electric bus thank you that's exactly what I was wondering great I have two um separate and independent questions the first is will you continue as an organization to look for grants that we would be eligible for um like like the AIG Grant or is that our responsibility as a district and my second question is just to confirm that all maintenance warranty replacement items would be not a cost to the district because of
116the contract great questions um the first one on the grants yes we have part of the partnership is to um look for ongoing grant opportunities a lot of the grants again are for to to pay Down The Upfront costs so you know once you deploy these vehicles with the existing grants um additional grants that come along in the next two to three to five years those would could be utilized for additional buses um you know if you're happy with with the electrics and you want keep deploying them and you know we would support you in continuing to to get those grants um on the maintenance side so how that works is we basically agree upon a labor rate that will reimburse you at whether your mechanics are performing that work or you know the dealership
117is and we'll reimburse you at that rate based on standard repair times for whatever you're performing and will reimburse you for parts cost so it really is a full um bumper-to-bumper warranty things that aren't covered are really just um stuff that is covered by your insurance like damage damage to the vehicles you know um things like that I guess I I have one more question sorry um no problem but not sorry because you should never apologize for asking a question um agreed so you know sometimes all cars including electrical vehicles have to be in the sh for a day two days whatever for those maintenance uh items how and maybe this is not a question for you but more for Vanessa and Joe how does that affect our runs if one of these is down
118is it basically we'll have a diesel Sub in it would be we we will not have an extra or an additional setting in the lot so it would be one of the other buses in the fleet diesel or the compressed natural gas yeah I can I can add to that too go ahead oh I was just gonna say that you know um in in typical uh fleets you you have a number of spares um and we always just recommend to keep the same spare ratio because you know the the same types of issues can come up as they do with the diesel vehicles um they it's it will not be they will not work 100% of the time and that's just the case for every type of vehicle so it's really you should expect um
119to use spares in a in a very similar man manner I do you handle any of the contracts for any of the uh electric buses that are in schools in Pennsylvania right now that School Pennsylvania districts use yeah yep um so those four school districts I mentioned um I've been involved in in all of those contracts um do you guys help with route you guys help with route optimization um we have some very flat areas in our district and we have some super hilly areas in our district and so I'm cognizant that Hills are not are much more challenging for um electric veh vehicles so do you help with any of the route optimization or where you'd want to pilot the routes yeah we don't have like a formal software routing software um like you
120like you could purchase right um but we do obviously understand the right conditions to use the vehicles um so we are more than willing and and have formally consulted around yeah like what are the right routes to be to be using these electric vehicles for um we do um run modeling based on to to understand right what the right route is um and that usually looks at temperature data temper the the weather is really the biggest Factor when it comes to the efficiency of the vehicles um and you know we we can look at topography as well to make some recommendations okay you just answered my second question which was and how do you uh roll in the temperature impact as well so thank you yep and we you know we have real efficiency data
121from our operational Vehicles so it's really like a good a very good op optimal data set uh to to recommend for you all I have a lot of questions um why is how did the 45 approximate 45 miles per day um annual mileage limit gets set and what because what is the range of the vehicles yep the your transportation team shared that the type C vehicles that we would be targeting to transition that that is their approximate daily mileage we can always adjust that um the range of the vehicles is a lot more than 45 miles a day as I mentioned in kind of moderate climate conditions um most of the time of the year the buses can go 120 130 miles on a single charge um when it's really really cold out you know
122reaching 20 10 20 degrees um that's when you lose efficiency because there's just so much energy going to heat the battery itself um then you get closer to like 80 miles a day so so you're you're really not running up on the range at all if you're if you're driving the bus 50 to 60 miles a day I mean I guess I'd be curious about seeing that adjusted just to make sure that we don't ever run up against it as part of the contract if the vehicles are capable of doing more we can certainly have the conversation with Emily yep now we have we may have some questions or comments from people in our audience if you cannot hear them I will relay the question so it may be a pause okay great okay that's
123the Maybe one at a time right all right well you know what as a let me ask the question because you're it's probably too much did were you able to hear that I could not okay um where does the electricity come from and and has the grid been studied yes so um the we've submitted a a service request to Pico and they've recommended that we utilize the the campus's existing primary service um and come off of that by installing a Step Down Transformer and a switch gear um there there is definitely enough capacity to um install these charging stations um and you know it's yeah if if and when the fleet continues to expand essentially you just work we would just work with the utility to understand the the load constraints um it's really not
124not that much power compared to to what you all are utilizing on the campus um so we're confident that for for these buses even if you're electrifying you know 20 to 30 buses there there'll be no issues with with grid constraints all right thank you another question just the question though helpful okay what is it is let me you know that does let me just ask the question all right what would we what would happen if they catch on fire what's the procedure putting them out yeah um it's a really good question so we Highland works with the First Responders as part of our training process um when the buses are deployed so essentially we would help ensure in partnership with the school bus dealer that the district and the First Responders are are well
125equipped um with the right knowledge and the right materials to be able to handle handle in in a you know unlikely event that it that it happens but of course you want to be PL you want to plan and you want to be pref prepared in in case it does um I saw other people with their hands up are we good or okay we'll take one and then we'll we'll come back go ahead were you able to hear that no sorry okay all right does the annual fee include all or some of the tax credits that Highland is able to get yeah so it it does include all tax credits um that essentially helps um with better financing for when we're Bor in money to deploy the project so we have Incorporated those into the
126annual service fee um without those tax credits it would be higher thank you we have yeah go ahead how do how do because I'm trying to write down your question if you keep talk that's okay how do the the cost for your buses compared to compressed natural gas costs um the they're there electric buses are more expensive than compressed natural gas buses and you you obviously have to install the infrastructure as well um so that's you know that's really why there are grants that exist to reduce reduce the cost to be more at parody with something like a a diesel or or CG vehicle okay thank you uh even with the grants is it still more expensive um we we showed you this cost comparison so it really depends on what your what your what
127Your costs are today and what you project to be your costs in the future right um so we haven't done a deep dive with your team on exactly what the co what you spend on fuel and on maintenance and you know that's something that that would be a good next step to really hone in these numbers and understand where our contract falls in In the comparison of of where the cost that you you actually uh see specifically in your school district for this comparison we've used kind of Market rates across the state add to the list Vanessa can your group help us get Vanessa can your group help us um put together a cost comparison between our diesel buses and our CNG buses with this opportunity yes great thank you yes awesome any other questions
128we have one question he's just asking it right now oh Sor I'm sorry go ahead what if the the tax credit goes away the federal tax the federal tax credit goes away what happens then so that is that is essentially Highland's risk so we're telling you this is how much it's going to cost and we're anticipating we can get the tax credit because we feel confident that we can um so either we would do the project anyway if we can't get the tax credit or we'd come back and say I'm not sure that this is going to work um but that's all to say we're we're confident that we'll be able to obtain it um I think we have an one more question for you no problem are are there any studies on the effects
129on children there's from the batteries um we can we can definitely look off the top of my head um I don't think I can't think of any specific studies related to the the effects on on children okay thank you great I think we're good with questions great thank you so much we really appreciate the opportunity thank you thank you Patrick thank you take care we're done with finance and we're moving on to education and [Music] wellness and you know I I don't know if we have uh people from Upper Providence listening apparently uh the Lights Went Out okay so I don't know how many people are listening know the power's out so we maybe we have Middletown all right education and wellness we're going to uh start with the comprehensive planning with Dr kunr Dr
130KRA thank you for coming and thank you for your patience as we get to another exciting presentation about the comprehensive plan um Dr K's going to give you an update on where we are uh fill you in as and some reminders to the board because we've discussed this in the past about what our requirements are with the Commonwealth uh in the completion of the comprehensive plan the time frame what that means and then what next steps are for us here now I can see there we go all right good evening everybody um so as Dr L mentioned that part what this is looking at is this is looking at our comprehensive plan and where this kind of falls into the greater scope um and also within the requirements we um asked to follow by um
131by state law and regulation so overall the comprehensive plan is a way of again moving ourselves forward forward and this kind of constant for uh sense of how can we do better um where it comes out of is uh title 22 chapter 4 section 13 of PA code um basically what it is is within that code there are a series of smaller plans uh professional education induction student services special ed gifted education and the state has combine them all into one comprehensive that's where the comprehensive comes from is the pulling together of all these disparate plans um into one document um and the reason why I state that is just because of the fact that we hear comprehensive and we think oh this is all encompassing and comprehensive of what we want to be doing
132in the district and it's not this is meeting some very specified state requirements um in terms of some of the professional development that we offer in terms of uh the data we even look at um and our ways of addressing that um our plan is due to the state department um of Ed by March 31st um it will go up for a 28-day public review um and then will be voted on um before the 31st deadline um basic mission statement uh mission statement we just pulled this right directly from obviously from our website it's what's out there um as always our mission is basically to focus on our children and to focus on moving our children forward um our vision again all members of our school community of lifelong Learners um and again it's really
133about all about all members of our school district our kids um going forward yes the last slide with those three Vision are those carryovers or they those are car and so one of the things that's going to be coming up out of this in the question usually gets asked is so where does this fit with our strategic plan and so one of the plans going forward this spring is to start the process for a strategic plan which is more of a six-year thing in that time frame we'll probably also look at Mission Vision Values and that's fine because what it is with the state is we submit this as it is based off data and stuff we have if we change the mission and vision alter them anyway that's not a problem we can always
134alter them within the plan and that's that's fine so um same thing the shared values these are the ones that are carries carried over if these get adjusted in our strategic plan going forward again we can make those adjustments so our strengths um these are just some of the strengths these are just the kind of some of the top ones we looked at um math proficiency rates U meet exceed the 2033 Statewide goals and I guess you should State here all of these data that I'm I'm going to be referencing here these are all pulled from the PA Future Ready index which is the public facing um website in which the state shows how each school is doing in terms of proficiency growth um things from attendance um rigorous courses Etc but mostly um performance
135on those State assessments so the conversation excuse me that we had when I was back for you in October with all the state assessment data these where these are coming from because again in this plan that's the data they're looking for it's very specific Fields they say and the first one is is okay performance on state measures as according to the PA Future Ready index so that's where you're seeing this this coming from is is that so in math um our proficiency rate meter exceed the 2033 Statewide goals for all four elementary schools um our proficiency rate meter exceed interim Improvement goals at springton Lake and pencrest Ela efficiency rates either meter exceed or exceed um our in targets or exceed our 2033 Statewide goals and uh they exceed Statewide goals at both um springton
136Lake and Pen Crest typically we run about anywhere from 20 to 30% um above the state average for proficiency um with all of our schools so our achievement is high is what the the short answer of this is that our achievement is high for overall for our groups um the challenges challenges three of our four elementary schools um fewer than 25% of the students with disabilities in grades 3 through I earn proficient or advanced in math in 2024 still higher performing higher than the state average but we're not at the levels of proficiency that we want to be looking at on the Literature Keystone the all student group um that's the group looks at all the students did not meet the p a standard for growth okay high high achievement but it wasn't growing at
137the rate that we wanted to show the growth at um pssas for six through eight all student group did not meet PA standard for growth um subgroups this look all student subgroups there in grades three through eight did not meet the interim goals for student achievement so we had some subgroups that didn't quite meet those achievement goals but we did it for overall for everybody we had a couple subgroups um most particularly in in um students with disabilities who did not meet that the achievement Target but we're for the state now we're that's the overall it's not the there isn't an achievement Target for for example a subgroup with st with students with disabilities it's just the overall subgroup that you're comparing it too so it's kind of still an apples to oranges but yeah
138actually my question is on one of these points it might have been the second one um are we did we not meet the standard for annual growth because we're already are we are we in an area that's so I'm not trying to give you an out we in an area that's so you know High achieving that then the growth becomes you know more because it's I mean it's still um it is possible to have high achievement and high growth and we've looked at a number of our neighbor schools and have seen some of them that are achieving that as that are as high achieving as we are but they're also showing high growth what we've realized in looking at the data is the group that is showing obviously the least amount of growth is our
139students who are performing in that 80th to 100th uh percentile on achievement so it's our highest achieving students which it's students who performing in that 80th to 100th per state percentile across the state makes about a third of Any Given class of students of ours so about 100 out of 300 student students we have performing at that highest level those loans are also showing the least amount of growth what is that saying it's saying that we're spending a lot of our time which is good and our efforts on really trying to reach the students who are not at that level and trying to get them Reach more than a Year's growth in a year's time but we don't want to neglect the highest achieving students so that's really going to be the that's the idea
140here and actually we can summary is basically High rates of proficiency overall we have certain areas that we want to focus on in growing is we're doing a great job with helping our kids who are not achieving at the level we want them to of helping them grow and meet more than a Year's growth so like we mentioned with special education um a lot of those students are at the minimum meeting a Year's growth and many of them are actually exceeding a Year's growth in a year's time they're catching up they have a lot of catching up to do um but that's the nature of working with with with special needs and with a lot of kids with a lot of lots of different challenges we're doing a great job in growing them and we're
141working on that our students who are are high Achievers they're high achieving they're doing great what we're looking at now is how do we challenge them more how do we help them push more to their potential and so that's kind of the focus of this then plan certainly the challenges or the the challenges they're hard to digest like I'm I'm looking at these saying okay what are our challenges it seems like and correct me if I'm wrong so we have students with disabilities who are not meeting what the goals we would like them to meet so and that's one group and then the other group is there's goals for annual growth and we're not growing as fast fast as we can but it's mostly with high achieving students so if you're at the 99th percent
142all there's not a lot of wiggle room in where you can go I I guess this is kind of my thing of how how do you get the 99th percentile well so grow a lot so let's say you had let's just take a random hit um student scored perfect on a fourth grade pssa in in English in ela well if they score perfect the next year they'll shown it easily a growth because you're taking a harder test it's not they're not taking the same test it's not going from 100 third grade to 104th grade but the state tells taking the third grade test they're taking the fourth grade test and what it really comes down to though is how this growth measure is determined is a huge statistical engine that um the state has contracted
143with a company called evos and what they do is they will take like testing history for anyone for all the kids across the state in every school over a number of years so they can take a look at and I'm trying to condense this down quickly is they would have like say for example student a my um testing history how I've done all the pssas up to this point and they say okay now they compare it to every other student in the state over the last several years who's had a similar testing history now students with the same testing history how did they do on that next year's test and then when all the kids take the next year's test what is the comparison how does it look like and and then going forward so
144did we do on average grow the same amount as other kids so it factors out for things like okay low achieving but they're still growing they're showing a lot of growth even though they were starting way down here or okay the test was really hard when they had the when they changed the tests to accommodate for the new PA core standards the um proficiency rates as we talked about dropped dramatically across the state but the actual growth measures actually stayed fairly consistent from year to year with the different schools so the statistical measure is there that's where all this is coming from and it's really I pulled the language directly from the state's portal because that's what we have to do when we're phrasing this in the uh in the state portal it's basically pulling
145down and saying okay yes how are we doing on X Y and Z and so the phrasing has to kind of match what's in that the pa uh PA portal again which is a public portal that you can anybody can go take a look at so yeah sorry a couple questions about that one is are the tests that that are being measured for advancement do they have ceilings they have 100% all them or is there room for people to keep going so the test the these are the summative State assessments so there is a okay there's for example there's 52 points available on a state assessment in math okay and so a kid can earn and we do have have several students who earn all 52 points right but no one can but there's no
146assessment of okay so now that you have all 52 you can go and do no no they're no not adaptive okay and actually they are Criterion reference tests they are um paper pencil tests so they're gotcha well they're paper pencil tests for the last year this year then they're gonna switch to all online but there still won't be computer adaptive all right and then for the special ed kids still not clear to me are they not meeting what standards are they not meeting are they our standards are they state standards are they our standards are the state standards we do all of our curriculum are they special for special EDS or are they no no we we teach the the rule is is that even if a student has special learning needs it's grade level
147standards that they are taught now there are accommodations and modifications made to help them access those standards by their level of disability so Andy this is on the pssa is number one is on the pssas on the pssas so that's that's the tool that is reflected in that statement now it said like it says uh pssa in number three Literature Keystone in number two but in number one it's the pssas yeah and that's and how does that 25% compare to other um we're is that bad no it's not unfor I mean it's this this it's it's bad in a cultural sense but in a compared to other compared to the state and compared to others it's and again it's I had to include it because that's what the the data are showing it's the challenge
148is that the data don't show the full picture right because it only does it by a building well if you do it by a building if you're doing it by an elementary building and in a grade level you might have in a grade level you might have 10 students with IEPs so three of them have a bad day then you're you're you're facing a a significant percentage drop and it's just that's the it's a small population that's what we have to and it and I agree with you I I I don't like the way that it's done but that's this is the reality of what we we have to report on the special on the different subgroups and we have to report on each of the subgroups within the plan itself um we are always
149trying to make sure I mean we want all of our students to succeed our students who are our High Flyers as well as our students who are struggling what our data are showing us is yes yes we had that low percentage of proficiency however those students showed exceptional growth okay in most cases when we looked at the we pulled up the P data and we looked by subcategory in every case going down the student students with IEP students with disabilities were shown to be making more than a Year's growth in a year's time across the board so what that tells us is that yes the percentage of proficiency isn't where we want it to be we're working on that but our students are making progress towards that and they're making progress faster than the average
150of what students are across the state with those same disabilities getting my own way because I'm feeling like we're talking about what we need to do for development and for pssas when really this is the mandatory thing that's being required that we report to the state yes okay I you know I I don't think we'd be doing some of our students with disabilities um Airness if we expected them to be at the advanced level so okay so we're kind of in our own way we're not really talking about how to rectify this because this is a a required measurement by the State not necessarily something you guys have done the work and you've looked at each student in this small population they're doing well and we're going to keep doing that yeah it's the the
151piece of so if you take the tool for what it's worth as a diagnostic right not not the comprehensive plan which is a big picture but the individual assessment that children are taking these are all children have I APS individualized education plans right so there are individual goals that are written for the children that are being work worked on so the developmental piece is that ultimately we want them to get to a place where they will meet the standards in order they can earn their diplomas right when they hit the high school so this gives us very specific information about individual standards some of which the children may not have been working on yet and and not because of Any deficiency with what we want to offer them or what we're doing they just aren't
152there yet developmentally and academically well thank you for looking into this smaller group population because they deserve the time and attention and I appreciate that I'm just I'm I'm glad to hear that rather than kind of what's written on the paper which is unclear so and I get it it's not your fault yeah it's the the way the tool is worked it pulls and populates into the challenges from everything based off of the data that you put there and so we're pulling the data from the State website putting it into the tool and it's populating with and so while we I I mean I had to pick them pick them all and I wanted to make sure we also wanted to as a district to make sure that we are not disregarding any of the
153subgroups of students so we're not going to put into a comprehensive plan only things that deal with the all student group because we have subgroups of students and we want to make sure that even if we know that they are growing and they are meeting more than a Year's growth and they're showing that great progress we're not designing a plan that's going to forget about them as well so they're not indictments no right they are areas in order to focus on and to say we're identifying this right we're talking about it we are working on this we're holding ourselves and putting it out there so everybody knows this is what we're holding ourselves to you know it's just the reality of the practice sorry one other question um uh okay yeah the last point on
154the challenges slide all student subgroups did not so on um are all student subgroups that you looked at included here or there other subgroups that we are not seeing represented in these slides so there are it depends it varies by building so the sub student subgroups that are listed are the ones that are the ferally recognized subgroups so it's the different racial ethnic subgroups as well as uh low socioeconomic um students with disabilities and the El population but in some of our many of like in our elementary schools we don't have enough students for example in our El population to get above the end number for the statistics to measure okay we get that we get that number in the middle school because there's all the kids are in the Middle School we've got a
155bigger population so in the elementary schools we see very few subgroups that are that we get the data back on because they're they don't have that they haven't met the end count um for that number in any given grade um in any of our elementary schools um so the all this is saying all student subgroups okay so we do have some subgroups that did not meet the PA standard of growth okay we have and the I can tell you the one subgroup probably that usually doesn't is the white student population didn't meet the standard for growth it's bulk of the kids but that's also pulling the same bulk of the same kids that do the that are some of our highest Achievers just by demographic statistics there that's so that's what we're meaning with the
156with the all all student subgroups so we're by doing that there we're saying okay when we're looking at growth it's a reminder to us to say are we looking not only at all groups we're also looking at all of our subgroups to make sure that everybody is growing okay so if we have a subgroup that's not growing is there something that we are doing that's preventing this subgroup of students is that a factor or not we don't know it's correlational potentially and we need to take a look at that and it's so so you'll see as Andy continues to go through um the slides so what does that mean right so so what we've identified these things now one so the summary is of this is that we are seeing High proficiency rates overall yet
157limited growth amongst the population of the highest achieving students that's what we talked about um students even felt like some of them weren't being so much challenged in school when they did this youth Tru survey surve um our special education like I said demonstrated lower its proficiency but showed significant evidence of meeting or exceeding the expectations of growth so what this comes down to is a couple priorities that we've put forth one um design and Implement instructional model focused on effective pedagogical practices that support individual students success these are things like differentiation of instruction um and various ways to achieve that provide an environment that promotes greater opportunities to increase uh depth of understanding for all students those are the basic priorities goal these are goals just to meet those challenges so hey by the
158end of the 2728 year we want to have all of our subgroups at least meet or exceed the PA standard of growth um as defined by the Future Ready PA index okay that's a goal we want everybody to be meeting or exceeding the standard for growth um meter exceed the interim achievement targets or goals in English language arts um and again it's a goal we want to be meeting or exceeding what these goals have been set for us now how are we going to do that this is the basic strategies for the next uh three years one a new Kaa program two focus on structured literacy three um switch to the block schedule at the high school and uh four uh focus on different differentiated instruction new K ka8 Ela program we are currently piloting
159um both the middle school and at the elementary schools um the idea of board approval of a new program in the spring of this year with implementation starting next school year the new programs we're looking at um do focus on a depth in content okay um the structure literacy um we've been doing phonics um as a regular basis for decades um what we are looking at though is we've started with a new program for pheic awareness through company called hegerty um that was implemented actually is in place this year um and then a new phonics program the one we have got bought out so we hav to adopt a new phonic program which one some of the programs we're looking at for K to for ELA incorporate phonics some don't so it how we go
160forward with that we're looking at phonics um as well just to again replace what we've currently been doing um to make sure we have something that's completely supported um structured literacy is also a one of the legislated areas um under act 55 that we had to provide training for for all of our staff um who hold certain certifications Elementary ad reading Etc um and we started doing that training actually even last year prior to this plan of providing structured literacy um uh format to this to our our teachers the block schedule um now Mr Roth has been in and explained the the block schedule and the reasons for going forward with that it is in development right now um students are signing up for courses for next year uh Implement will be will happen um
161in next school year and the idea behind the block scheduling again of course is that with an 80-minute block it becomes much more able to focus and go in depth you don't have those constant interruptions of going to a classes and and switching in classes students can focus on three or four classes at a time as opposed to seven or eight classes at a time um and um so that's part of the idea of going deeper um in into the content yes just out of curiosity is there data that shows that blocks get show a trend upward in um student achievement yeah no about the instruction for a short answer right yes yeah um Quality instruction in a block schedule yes allows for those things but if there is not quality instruction and you're not
162not asking higher level questions not taking the opportunity to go in into more depth and give kids more opportunities then there won't be that impact who was much more succinct than I would have been I like his answer better um and last we differentiate instruction uh we began this a couple years ago um we've been actually looking at differentiate instruction for several years and using different methods we started with a station rotation model um beginning a couple years ago and have been increasing its use throughout um K12 um in the instruction um and then also a focus on enrichment so not only what how can we take what the whole class is learning and then how can we take it and go deeper with that for the students who need that level of challenge um
163that's it I don't oh he stole my mic um so it's great that they have these plans that you do every three years and you talk about what your goals are do they ever ask you how did you do on your goals from the last three years no okay is that something we as a board could filter into this process yeah absolutely seems stupid to have goals and not ask what then how you do yeah I mean some of the goals that we had from last time around I don't have in front of me um was to take a relook at our curriculum and we've been teachers been working um quite hard over the last couple years of redoing our curriculum using the understanding by Design format and a lot of being written we're looking
164at a possibility of a potential software program to make it a lot more of an easier access to everybody um one of the ones was um Improvement in technology we've added the um uh obviously one to one happened um we've got the ifps thank you try remember which I could not remember like with the L for yes the ifps which we've incorporated into the high school now and then to the different buildings which provide a much more interactive experience um for the teachers and students with that instruction so those are some of the goals that's a very generalization we can we can do that but yes we'll definitely provide that well and I feel pretty confident that I know the answers because like it's been I don't know how many years now I sit here
165and listen to this every month but for people who don't like it' be great to just have that on our website like available but also like in real speak yeah so that parents and the community know like how are we really doing against these goals yeah we can definitely do and Jackie I would tell tell you to when we go into the strategic planning discussions because it would be a great update um to provide to the board and to the community in the fall you know in a way that kind of succinctly shows where we are because the information will be in from the year before we'll see where we are but it would be a nice little update that could be provided and then post Ed and shared so that people can access where
166it is but I I hope that that will be part of the strategic planning discussion as well about one of the things how do we report stuff out you know what is the followup that's there it's not just about setting it but what's the reporting that's going to the board and ultimately because it's coming to the board to the community at large is there a point to having it the outcomes separate for the for our purposes for the comprehensive plan and the Strategic plan if the Strategic plan is really what it's not so much they're separate it's comprehensive plan and again that that that it's a misnomer is such a limited focus and it's limited Focus to primarily growth and achievement based off of the state assessments because that's where it's reporting from so the
167Strategic plan we can incorporate these ideas into the Strategic plan by all means but the the the comprehensive plan is limited in in scope to to basically how everything impacts growth and achievement as measured by the state assessments right it's not about the whole student at all no that was gonna be is basically to say if I read those challenges I'd be like oh my God district is doomed honestly because they look terrible but when you look at those assessments that they're using whether it's the Keystone or pssas and you compare us to all of our standard cohort of Walling fors worthmore and rner and everybody else we're right there with everybody else and so I don't you know and I want to celebrate yay we're doing as well as all of our peers and
168what we'd want to be doing this kind of focuses on okay who who's who needs a little bit of extra help to get where they're going but I don't want to lose sight of the fact that we are highly regarded district and our students do very well after they leave here yes and so how the state defines success and how the real world defines success might be slightly different than the pssa test yes and just keep in mind every District every Public School District in the state has a comprehensive plan and they're probably having similar conversations I have my mic but we done all right I think we're are we okay oh we have a couple more things nope no no questions okay we're good been two and a half hours we want to get
169through this and we want people to ask questions but you know it's nine o'clock um Human Resources so for the most part Dr naon Williams they are uh typical consent items I will point out um highlight that's on here is a letter B uh Daniel Arison as the candidate to be the new director of student services he's currently the assistant director uh at Garnet Valley so we're very excited for the board to take action um for his appointment on the 27th the other items that are on here are just traditional um consent items as we go through HR just for the Public's knowledge he is to replace Dr Francis Garner who left the district correct Dr Garner left in January she had announced in December that she was going and she left us um in
170the third week in January after about five years or so that she was in District okay any questions about human resources we're good all right we'll move down to the business of the board we include that occasionally where there are some issues we just want the the public to be aware of maybe there have been questions uh concerns and we just want to sort of make sure the information is out there um the first is the process of uniform ordering and the recycling of uniforms so Dr nson Williams um I appreciate you asking to have this these things placed on the board for board discussion uh I just want to go over a little bit with the first one process for uniform ordering and the recycling or reusing um of uniforms both the and I
171asked uh Mr Docker Bill doer is here as well to provide some commentary and some perspective um as he has spent some more time talking with folks in the buildings so we try to run a regular rotation of when uniforms are replaced uh at each of the levels it looks a little bit different at the middle school level than it does at the high school level looks a little bit different when you go from sport to sport um some sports the uniforms hold up better than others right um baseball uniforms don't typically last as long as track uniforms um there's more wear and tear in some ways that are on them um when they are ordered it's typically um could be anywhere from a three-year cycle to um we've had some that have been on
172a seven-year cycle of the replacement of uniforms um sizing of uniforms is a challenge right so the the companies from whom we purchased uniforms um each year new Styles come out there could be some variation uh in the in what the overall uniform looks like but stylistically uh there's often changes each year so we try to order uh and have extras and have appropriate sizes whether it's middle school or high school um there are challenges associated with sizing for sure um you know I was over here last week Mr doer and I were here to watch uh a basketball game middle school basketball game our cheerleaders springton Lake cheerleaders were here the springton lake cheerleaders got brand new uniforms this year and they look fantastic um you know I speak with the folks that are
173in in charge a little bit afterwards about how good they look and it just about the ordering right so they were just ordered for this academic here one of the challenges when you're looking at children that are in seventh and eth grade is you know they had a a young lady who was wearing a size zero uniform and had it pinned because it wouldn't stand up and there stay up and then you have other children that are wearing uniforms that are dramatically different sizes um trying to get that right fit um you know can can have its can have its challenges just because of the developmental range uh physically of the children you know that are playing um so Mr doy what else um as far add or say as far as uniforms go I
174think um you covered in terms of there's a cycle that we follow and um you know and we use you know typically check out different vendors but again I haven't been directly involved with that in terms of um athletic uniforms but from it's my understanding that they they follow um they follow a cycle and so then everyone you know every few years I forget I think it's five to seven years um she'll get new uniforms if that is something that um you know due to some of the questions and concerns is something that I I can certainly I can certainly um keep an eye on to see if that time period is still working if the uniforms are holding up the way that we want them to um we can certainly answer that but um
175there is a particular cycle for that yeah seven years seems like a long time to run on uh you know elastic waistbands yeah for instance I agree um yeah um and and maybe there's some imaginative ways to solve the some of these issues I mean there's more money in the budget is one way but also you know some of the teams as a baseball dad my son uh we bought his baseball pants every year uh that was how it was and we you know because we go through them and then we could match you know there was some guidance on style and we could match the fit and you know it's not that big an expense and it's not that big an expense I mean basketball shorts are pretty pretty inexpensive pieces of equipment um
176and then the logo goes on the top and that's where the number is and that's where the logo is so you can have so things like that that might might be another way to make it and then also of course I'm imagining that people are that the teams are ordering more uniforms than they have kids so that if they do have a longer replacement cycle that there's some some way to manage that and you know the different sizes of yeah things like that things like and then there's the boosters because that was the other way you know parents I have a quick question just how do we make that determination what is the parents responsibility like how much are we asking the parents to chip in and how much is the school able to yeah
177so that's something that we have to look into right is how um our booster groups operate which teams utilize those groups or have active active booster clubs and um I think that's one of the essential questions it's part of a bigger conversation about Athletics and so just to clarify some rumors that are going around do are there hand-me-downs from high school to middle school or from Team to team or is it L like a uniform for a team will always be that team's uniform until it gets recycled out it's a uniform for a team until that gets recycled out okay and and they're not handed down time to Spring separate budgets separate purchasing separate branding separate names separ SE can you double check that because I I've also been told that sometimes the varsity um
178uniforms go down to the JV teams after a certain amount of time so a uniform will go perhaps to the JV it won't go it will not go to another team or a springton lake team life cycle no not beyond the seven years now whether the seven years is too long that's something obviously but not beyond that oh I think that was what we were trying to focus on with this if there is a a desire for less than seven years I mean it really it should depend on the the the clothing right whether it's look that's about three years that's enough right so I think there needs to be some flexibility in that um so it's seven years is not just the standard it depends on what the uniforms look like because the kids
179have to wash them hopefully after every game and you know and then I'm sure they get watched again when they return so I mean there's a lot of factors that go into it the other thing I'd like to see is what's our policy on warm-ups some teams seem to get them other teams don't what's the rationale what what could or should not be consistent in terms of warm-ups and there's also a difference between boosters parents and the school because the boosters might raise money for some things but there may be something that parents are supposed to supply without without the support of the boosters and how do we make sure kids of all Financial abilities are able to participate that's a key factor because if if you have to buy a lot of stuff to
180participate I don't want to leave anyone out due to financial circumstances yeah I'm sorry Dr it's a it's a good qu you know so our goal is if children want to participate in Play We want to be able to provide that opportunity for them so as an example lacrosse is really big and really important in our community in our schools um in the boys lacrosse the the boys wear helmets and pads the majority if not all and I my understanding is especially even over the last couple of years even at the middle school all the boys come with their own helmets because they're playing Youth and playing wreck you know and working through that coming up we have a couple of helmets right should there be a child we have equipment you know for soccer
181we have shinguards um you know we have things like that most children are bringing them with them uh same thing in hockey and you know that kind of thing um so we would never um not allow a child to play because they couldn't they didn't have that stuff um again one of the other things that and you all can probably tell more stories than I can about being here but even I know a couple of examples where where there was challenge other people stepped in and purchased cleats you know or purchased basketball shoes or you know that kind of thing to make sure that everybody or the children that needed had I just want to make sure there's a good way that people can be be identified as a need without oh there is there
182is I mean because you have the the administration the coaches the boosters I mean the parents I mean it's it's not surprising it's sort of this is just the way we do it um if there is an issue it's usually I mean because we've talked about this before and yes if the kids want to play and they need something they get it so all right next Point um about how to advocate for your your athlete um what's the process who should students go to this is not about playing time this is not about making the team that's the coach okay this is just about if there is an issue like with your child uniform I mean we would hope that they would speak to their coach and then you know move the process forward but
183we'll hear about it Dr n Dr n gonna have Mr Dockery start with this he has spent quite a bit of time talking to folks and just going over uh in you know just what are the practices right now and getting from different perspective from parents who have reached out um as well as from staff um and he can give he's got a unique perspective because his time and his different roles that he's had in the district so Mr Dockery thank you so um on the pest website under the Athletics there is a student parent athletic handbook and on page 10 of that handbook it does have um a section titled um parent coach communication plan and it outlines those things and steps to follow when there are particular concerns and step number one is
184yes your child should speak to the coach and just providing a brief rationalis that we do think it's developmentally appropriate for high school kids to learn to Advocate I don't want to say you know by themselves but for themselves right like with the backing of their parents and and and teachers they they should feel like they have support around them but they should be the ones communicating um with the coach on the next and you know in order to do that they should set up an appointment with the coach and if and it outlines this again in the handbook and if they have a if they're having trouble getting in contact with the coach or setting an appointment that's when they should reach out to the athletic director or administrator to help them set up
185an appointment if for some reason you know in making that um if someone reaches out to the athletic director or or goes above this step the athletic director or administrator their response is going to be have you talked to the coach right and then the then the conversation is be well if you haven't why not how can I help facilitate that conversation but that conversation has to happen first um so it goes coach then athletic director um as assistant principal when I was there for a couple years then I was the assistant principal that if things didn't get resolved at that level then it went to to me as assistant principal then the principal then up up the organizational chart as it is um there are a couple things in there just a couple um
186kind of pieces of advice one one is to wait 24 hours after a game or event before communicating with the coach um for obvious reasons right let emotion emotions settle a bit um but also there's encouragement to and a directive to not have that conversation over email or text or on social media we really want there to be an actual conversation so those things are outlined in that handbook and um that is the protocol that um we hope people will follow all right sounds good questions so how are the athletic budgets um made and so like who approves them what's the process Jackie I mean that's that's kind of not the the F was that not part of this no okay I mean we can put it on for next time about the write it
187down for me so I can tell them but we just had the two things on there oh I thought this is like a general no I mean if we're going to talk about certain issues we have to make sure that the public knows what we're talking about instead of other things but we can do that for March part of the budget conversation yeah um I did have a a question about I mean it's great that it's in the handbook and there's some guidance out there and you just said it so it'll be on the website again which is great how do we build a culture where kids feel like they can go to the coaches the coaches are being more proactive and making sure that people are able to address concerns that kind of yeah
188so I it's it's the same as teaching right and it's about obviously forming those individual relationships but also being proactive as an adult to U make sure you're checking in with kids to know how they're feeling so then if something's kind of Brewing under the service that we're not aware of we we're not necessarily surprised by it or you know there's like this natural invitation um I think in order to build a culture like that there needs to be um training and you know overall discussion as a group like this is what we want as athletic department this is what we want our coaches to do this is how we do it and then just a constant um you know monitoring and checking in with our coaches to see if they're taking time to do
189that um we certainly ask our teachers to do that right so um we should be asking our coaches to do the same and as you know obviously by the nature of your question I mean that is it's really hard for kids right it's really hard for kids to um talk to their teacher sometimes or coach they're an authority figure about maybe how they're not feeling their best and you know and how to how to approach that and that's especially true as Mr Docker is talking about it um we have some great examples of where it's working really well then we have some examples as Dr Kat talked about where there's areas that we can grow and do better in you know I I think talking about it putting it out there um is a huge
190step in moving forward with it um just the identification of here's our expectations and this is what it's going to look like but like again we have some some beautiful examples um of where it's going really well and some examples of where it can improve right so it's got to be about Improvement this is you know what we do is is evolutionary and continues to grow children are different parents are different the experiences are different and sometimes that requires shift in the lens that we are applying to what we are looking at and then how we are talking about it's a shift in what you know Bill and I what what we need to do in terms of how do we talk with the principles the assistant principles the athletic directors you know in the
191discussion when I was over here last week and I met with the athletic directors and the principal here probably other than in passing the first real time that the four of us had sat down and had conversation with specifics about what we're doing right so there has to be a shift in what yeah and I also think this is an area where you always feel like it's almost like communication where you always feel like you can do better right because we are dealing with human beings and relationships which are complicated so no matter how well of a system you put in place there's going to be some type of incidents right so we just have to um be great at working through that yeah and I think with the coaches um most of them are
192not teachers at the school so they know the students know them even less well than they know their teachers and with this digital age of everybody texting and nobody I mean kids don't even want to make a phone call to their friends you have to text so helping our kids in general not you know certainly with the coaches but also the teachers and in general having face-to-face conversations is really important these days I completely agree it's right okay thank you we move on the policy committee thank you Dr nson Williams uh policy committee so we um at our upcoming policy meeting which will be on February 24th um we'll be looking at 249 which is bullying cyber bullying um this is something that requires uh an update and a look I believe every year every
193three years we have to go through um so we have that on here 810 Transportation which I believe we'll be finalizing and to come through for a read um we've spent God bless we spent a lot of time talking about that we have an administrative regulation motor vehicle reports um which is a10.11 we'll be having discussion uh and then some time talking about the 2526 calendar calar there's a small adjustment we had improved the calendar last year for 2526 and then a bigger discussion about 2627 um and Talking this is where we've gone through to talk about what do spring break look like what do holidays look like what's our time look like um when children are here 2627 is also a unique year because Labor Day is the 7th of September um you know
194when will we start when do we finish what does that mean um we've had some discussion I've had a lot of discussion recently especially with the weather um when it comes to calendars people have asked about uh FID days uh and snow days we have not in rad stre media have we have not had snow days and I'm using air quotes for people that are not in the room with us um snow days built into our calendar in a number of years um they they just have not been there um you know when we applied when the district applied a few years ago uh and you know received approval for the FID days um that was the direction that the district moved we have had one f one FID right Christal thank you one FID
195Day this year we've had a couple of delayed openings um and interesting feelings right about delayed openings snow days FID days um you know about what do we value right this is a is a big discussion what do we value as a community do we want spring break to be the same week every year right so that it's there's a consistency move it away from um Easter and P pass over you know in the the holidays um do we you know want to continue to have graduation the first Friday in June and have the other children finish the second Friday in June is that important to who we are as a community what does that look like there are some some bigger perspectives about what goes on I will tell you personally I like it
196when everybody's here so I like it I'm happy to have people here longer start earlier and be here longer uh I like it when there's more people around you know so um but we will kind of probably Focus most of our discussion the evening of the of the 24th um on those and then we'll look to see what does that final look like for the 2627 calendar um for the February 27th meeting well we have the data on that on absenteeism rates on that Monday before election day for that half day I believe we will that's the other thing thank you shelle um the other thing that we talked about the last meeting was about early dismissals right what do early dismissals look like um what does attendance look like we have the the days
197around election day um we have the conference days we have the there's a holiday uh that we are closed in October um this year we were open on we were closed on a Thursday we were open on Friday um did not have great attendance results all the way across the board on the Friday we have an inservice that is scheduled for next year for that day um but kind of looking at those big picture items so um yeah all right I know not because it's such a silly thing I'm gonna say there's a bill floating around right now um that suggests that we don't start school before Labor Day in Pennsylvania yeah really MH have it I did not go I did not go through all of it yet you know the legislative updates that's
198Norm that's like my weekend update I like to save that little little treat for a Saturday um we are there are a lot of it's a mix in Pennsylvania right now right with when with starting school before Labor Day um you know looking at 26 27 with Labor Day being the 7th of September it just is really really late um but it's definitely a mix of districts even in this area Chester County Delaware County Philadelphia School District you've had a number that have been moving towards the pre-labor day beginning which opens up some comfort and some opportunities you know if we look at that long term come out on the 27th out on the 24th is the next policy committee come join us at the discussion all right I think we're done um this concludes
199the work session uh our legis slative meeting will be on Thursday February 27th at 6:30 at pen Crest High School in the auditorium and on March 3r Monday we will be having our budget work session all budget all the time Monday March 3rd at 6:30 at springton Lake Middle School right here in the library all right have a good night