001for e e e good evening everyone we are going to convene into Open Session I recommend that minutes of tonight's executive session as they relate to collective bargaining and the privacy of students and their records remain sealed have a second then Diane hold on where's Angela one second one second she's got to take the notes give us a moment thank you so we have a motion and a second all in favor unanimous thank you disclosure of executive session votes Laura there were three votes that were taken in executive session they were for the purposes of reviewing and or approving matters which which relate to the privacy of students and their records the approval of the executive session minutes of January 14 2025 and the approval to reconvene to open session the votes were taken and
002it was unanimous for all three votes thank you Laura so we have recognitions on next on the agenda and we're going to do recognitions a little bit differently um tonight and moving forward typically the superintendent is very gracious in um reading aloud all of the recognitions but considering this is a school committee meeting I thought it would be a good idea to have individual school committee members um acknowledge those recognitions moving forward so um in recognitions uh 6A for Cho Regional High School Laura good evening everybody chero Regional High School we proudly announce Carter stolz adelene luser and Penelope Nicholas as school level poetry out loud contest winners on Friday January 17th 2025 10 students competed in excuse me 10 students competed in the competition presenting Works selected from an anthology of over 1,100 poems
003judges evaluated their performances on voice articulation evidence of understanding and accuracy the first place winner was Carter STL he will represent chero at the Rhode Island state poetry out loud contest at the Providence Public Library on Saturday March 8th 2025 congratulations parter the second item for chero high school congratulations on earning the college board's AP Computer Science female diversity award for expanding young women's access to AP Computer Science principles through these divers diversity Awards the AP program acknowledges 1,153 schools for their work towards improving female representation during the 2023 2024 school year chero high school is one of only a of one of only 847 schools to achieve this accomplishment for the AP [Applause] CSP okay it's official hope is now a certified therapy dog if she'd like to take a bow [Applause] [Laughter] she
004has successfully passed her certification which is an incredible achievement and a testament to her gentle nature and loving personality thank you to everyone who helped her prepare for this important Milestone as a certified therapy dog hope will continue to bring joy comfort and support to our school community Through the warm of her companionship her wagging tail that always helps make a tough day easier and her calm presence during reading sessions hope makes a difference in lives of students and staff we are so proud of her okay and the next one is spreading kindness and confidence at CH home Middle School uh confidence congratulations to Lila and Lindsay I don't know if they're here here tonight but they are two amazing students at Charo Middle School who were on the front page of the Westerly Sun
005on January 26th so if anybody missed it you might want to go back and check it out for the efforts in creating Kan campaign small colorful rocks each painted with a message are part of the students mission to promote kindness and general well-being all over the school campus program coordinator and teacher Olivia Mulla stated it's so good to to see the kids come up with these ideas all by themselves she added they did all the work they are the experts thank you Pat Polly congratulations to Charo Regional School District for earning a healthy meals incentive recognition award from the US Department of AG agriculture food and nutrition service and hold on and action for healthy kids this is an incredible achievement in elevating School nutrition and our school Food Authority as an awarde Cho will
006receive the following national and local recognition by USDA and AF HK an all expense paid invitation to the healthy meals fall 2025 Summit in Las Vegas Nevada healthy meals incentives recognition awarde toolkit with promotional resources that will help us publicize our success to local media and our school Community a banner to showcase our [Applause] accomplishments and in Charo sports girls basketball from the Westerly Sun February 4th 2025 CHS student Erin oir broke a 3838 deadlock in overtime making a three-pointer with two minutes remaining and Maddie Fano shot three of four at the foul line in the final 21 seconds the final two with 3.4 seconds left to seal things for Cho and a 4441 inter division Victory on Monday night over East Greenwich it was great to get them to get a win Cho coach
007Dan leel said all these girls have worked so hard this season and for them to get a tough road win like this tonight I couldn't be more proud of them good job coach Linda hello good evening hi I'm Linda Li um I have an honor to congratulate our very own Heidi fee um at Charlestown Elementary School who has been named a National Science Foundation awarde for the presidential award for excellence in Mathematics and Science teaching which is pist I guess it's called pamis recognizes outstanding teachers for their contributions to the teaching and learning of science technology engineering and Mathematics Heidi is she hereid sck well Heidi will receive a $10,000 award from NSF and travel to Washington DC to participate in an award ceremony at a future date we have prepared a certificate of award
008for Heidi to offer our congratulations on this outstanding achievement congrat congratulations [Applause] Heidi thank you school committee members so public forum is number seven on our agenda so there are a number of folks who have have uh signed up for public forum thank you so much I just wanted to reiterate our um public forum policy um each citizen would who would like to make a public statement has a responsibility to be accurate present facts not gossip or rumors present information based upon personal knowledge not hearsay be considerate and allow others to speak without interruption so additionally any person's wishing wishing to speak during public forum for items not on the agenda will sign in and be recognized the chair has the discretion to limit each person to two to four minutes if additional time is
009sought by the speaker it may be granted by a majority vote of the school committee um and we do have four six seven people signed up tonight for public uh Forum if you would like to when your name is called please come up to the podium speak clearly into the microphone and if you could state your name and the town in which you reside we would appreciate that so first is Dylan stracuzzi is Dylan here okay go ahead well welcome Dylan and Joselyn do you need help with the microphone oh thank you terrific we might have to give you a little bit more than two minutes if you go over your time good evening I'm Jing vanir and I'm Dylan stuzzi we are in fourth grade at Hope Valley elementary school as you know our
010school has been without a librarian and we no longer have highi here are a few examples of things we used to do during Library we used to we we would code Mrs W would read something to us then then then would then would have us answer questions about it we would research VAR various top ipcs however now we code how we now we color and sometimes code wait oh wait wait we can just not okay this is what we just did [Music] yesterday oh that's beautiful do you want to pass that around so we can all see it go ahead thank you you can continue while we review your work we just really miss the highly capable program and a normal Library class we would like to know when we have when when we'll have
011a new librarian or high SE again thank you for your time nice job I can uh we actually have two openings in a library media it's a high need area um it's been we've had small applicants we are actually looking at redesigning the job description similar to what ewg did to be able to widen our net um but yeah it's it's a hard job to fill and not many people going into that field anymore so we're looking at some opportunities uh the good news about high is that with our mtss work which is multi-tiered systems of support it would it uh it supports all of our students students from um those that have have needs or those that need enrichment so we'll be incorporating that in our work as well thank you and thank you
012to the Hope Valley Dylan and Lindsay thank you so much so next it's um Joselyn oh yeah they already did they were together oh Jo oh that oh yes Joselyn and Dylan were together sorry uh David ly from Richmond hi I'm David ly from uh Richmond Rhode Island I wanted to present a petition that I um took the initiative to make last year and circulate uh it's a petition for full transparency in Charo schools and um it's goes like this whereas in a free Society every citizen if they choose has a voice to determine the culture and the promote the well-being of that Society whereas the education of children in the free Society is critical to the life and health of that society and whereas the citizens of Charleston Richmond Hopkinton are in fact members
013of a free society and support the education of the children in the Charo School District we the undesigned citizens of Charleston Richmond hopkington Rhode Island demand full and open transparency of all books lesson plans and other education materials that are used in the Charo School District as responsible citizens we want to be able to oversee and participate in how the children learn about truth and ensure that they are taught the necessary skills to be confident contributing members of a flourishing Society we believe that the public participation in the educational process of the children of Charo is the best way for them to grow in wisdom and understanding and is the best cause to ensure well-being of our community our state and the country as a whole and um I went around my neighborhood um to
014get gather signatures and I had help in other areas of the Charo School District uh so we have a a petition has actually garnered 413 signatures last year and um I can tell you that um in my experience going around my neighborhood most people are very um very um are willing to um sign the petition they they agree with it very wholeheartedly for the most part and um when you think about it there's so much resource out there in the public various um trades and skills and crafts and people that can with life experience that can help the educational process in our schools and it's such a resource that we can um dip into to have to have that for all of our um parents teachers and students alike so I I'd like to present
015this petition and the signatures that are contained here in to uh this school committee you can hand it to miss um Brazil the district cler thank you David Kay Johnson from Richmond hello I spoke last month at the omnius about uh a vulnerable section of the public um when it comes to tax increases on property and one of the things I sort of dismissively said was that the family making $120,000 a year it's not a big deal to have a $200 hit in property taxes and then I saw a report by visual capitalist that says the livable income for a family of four in island is 123,000 so uh I thought that was interesting and I thought I'd dig into that a little bit more so I want to do the same thing I did
016last time but with a family of four yearly income 120,000 income taxes 10,000 take-home monthly is $9,200 housing for a a half million doll house $100,000 down 30 year is $3,000 a month property taxes $458 house insurance 1500 food 1,000 child care 2,000 Transportation 1,000 Healthcare 500 other expenses Utilities phone internet clothing entertainment Personal Care 700 so that totals up to um about $110,000 a month so they're actually losing almost $1,000 a month a loss of $221 a week and this is why we're seeing reports with credit card bills that are starting to slowly grow over time so I understand that any adjustments down are very painful for you guys and it affects programs that go on here at chero my intent is to try to bring balance to this conversation because adjustments up also
017create pain and the big picture that I think needs to be kept in mind is we're down over 25% in enrollment from Peak enrollment in chero so please consider that as you're going through the budget today thank you thank you Joan Kent from Richmond so Joan did you want to speak to somebody something on the agenda or just general remarks it's about this uh the budget for school okay um so I think if you have a comment about the budget we do have an agenda item about the budget so I want to make a comment about what is going on in another community and what they're up against so they aware of what's happening in other communities okay thank you can I do that now on oh is that better that's because I'm so short
018you know that feeling in Warwick they're over on their school budget with two schools they allotted an approved 350 million it came in at 387.4 they were able to cut uh 14.9 million but they are over 2 22.9 million they are also in a deficit of 9 million maybe 10 million or over in their towns starting in 20125 so they're at very very bad disadvantage I do not want to see this community or this school or any of the taxpayers going through this type of thing when you decide to look at the budgets look at it fairly concisely and know that the purse that you open isn't endless it's on the backs in the pockets of taxpayers we love our children we love our grandchildren and we do the best we can for them all
019I ask is that you consider all all the facts and I thank you for listening and I appreciate your time thank you Greg evidian from Hopkinton thank you sir Katherine juy from Hopkinton hi Katherine everybody um I just wanted to speak a minute about the tone of the committee um I think that it is important that everybody tries to be as respectful as possible when you're having these discussions but I do want to implore that when you hear someone's tone and it seems difficult to you or challenging to you that you listen to the message behind the tone and I think that you need to recognize that when someone is trying to get a point across and they are consistently ignored that can be when the tone can start to to be a little bit
020more harsh so I just ask that you all remember that try to work with one another respectfully um in this entire process thank you thank you Katherine okay we're going to go on to um the agenda item eight uh under business um so 8A is a resolution in support of amending Rhode Island general law 16-21 uh 1-15 to require nonprofit non uh non-public nonprofit schools to share in the cost of the Statewide transportation system Gina did you want to give us a little bit of background on this I know that we have um materials in our packets um but if you can give us some background on this and sort of the Genesis of this please y I'm recommending approval of this resolution it was started in uh Lincoln school committee with Mario Coro those
021that you may remember is also the Chief Executive Officer school building authority uh this is asking that we share in the cost right now the district takes on the entire cost uh and it would alleviate approximately um our cost is $800,000 that's Aid of our Educators or it's programs to students or it's you know being able to uh reduce the budget but it's it's a heavy lift and with everything rising and all cost Rising we believed it was a it's a a good um measure to be able to agree that we share in those costs so I I recommend approval uh of the resolution so move do we have a motion Linda second by Karen um discussion please Diane and then Pat hi yes so I I understand this correctly that um this is to
022cover the transportation of homeless children no what what so this is nonpublic non this is for private schools that they're tuition based nonprofit okay sh the private school subsidy to cover homeless students and requiring private schools to share the cost of the Statewide transportation system so the homeless cost is actually 24,000 yep are you so so they want us to provide that they want they want us to share in the cost to provide for the we already do that all right okay okay this is asking that they change that they modify the law that the private schools share in the cost of transporting to the private [Music] schools okay Pat could you give us some background as to why it was that we that the I mean you want to change it so that private
023schools pay but what was share the cost yeah so what was the premise when it was originally established why we didn't do that um unlike Massachusetts in Connecticut Rhode Island uh gave the ability and the law to to allow that um I was at the commission yesterday with purcel uh regarding another Transportation uh Transportation um conversation around regions but a lot of this unfortunately was self- serving many representatives in the general assembly um had you know students their own children who attended private schools and were wanted that cost to go to them uh you know we've we've made different conversations this is one of those underfunded unfunded mandates that you know was nice to have when when maybe the state could afford it but and now you know you don't go to the fire department
024and say my house is never caught on fire I would not like to pay that cost I I don't go to the senior center I don't want to pay that cost I I have never had to use the police I don't want to pay that cost but we seem to do that a lot in in the education side of the world so what we're saying is you know while costs are increasing we're asking that instead of the burden be being completely on the district where everything is going up we're asking that um overall that the state sh say that private schools have to share in that cost Donna Craig Jess just a little background um my husband and I supported parochial schools for our children in probably one of the best school districts in the
025entire country which was Fairfax County and we provided the tuition the books the transportation everything when we moved back to RH Island on retirement I was a called that the public budget has to the school districts have to support that kind of expense I think it's terrible if the choice is made to go to a private school parochial school whatever that to me is the burden of the parents that make that choice my daughter educated her three children in parochial education and I will tell you the the transport was available from her district and they never used it so again that's just a waste of taxpayers money in the school districts that need every penny we can get and i would support eliminating that at the legislative for the legislature to begin with because I
026don't think taxpayers in Rhode Island should be paying the cost for private education thank you Craig I wholeheartedly agree with everything is said but do you think uh Gina could you give us some examples uh so everybody knows what uh nonpublic nonprofit schools are and what aren't so charter schools are not um in this category they're Public Schools this would be your private schools like your lals your Bishop hendricken your monor Clarks your prouts and Charter Schools but yet I see some charter schools with their own buses well and districts do that too westle has their own buses and aragan has their own buses Cranston has their own buses okay no no I meant just Charter Schools though so right charter schools are public so that's something different so they get they get this would
027be uh the private schools thank you Jess so um Diane touched on this which is that in this resolution it is a shift of the subsidies So currently the state subsidizes our nonpublic transportation so it cost us 800,000 the state then provides what we paid the previous year which in this case this year is like 500,000 so it's a pretty substantial reimbursement that we get and so what this resolution is saying is you shift that subsidy so instead of getting it for non-public Transportation ask those parents or those families you know that those school systems the non-public school systems to share the cost of Transportation with you it's required by law um and shift that subsidy to the homeless the the transportation of students who are experiencing homelessness or unhoused which in some districts makes
028a lot of sense because that cost is a lot more for them or can be more for us that doesn't make fiscal sense for chero for us to change shift the subsidy I support the addition of six to get a state reimbursement for that transportation that we do but I I don't support this resolution I I can support the spirit of it um I can support the spirit of studying the Statewide transportation system which is how we have to provide this this um service and that was something that I brought up at the meeting I attended last night which is that there are there's a bill that was re introduced last year again this year that would help chero and districts like ours that have a transportation company quarter of a mile down the road
029to provide that service inhouse rather than use the Statewide transportation system um so I I don't support this resolution as I as I it's written currently um if I don't we want to make a if anyone would support a change to it I would support that but I think overall um I don't think it's right for us I think it it would Foster bad feelings you know I the know folks that send their kids on those buses um and I it's part of the law and the committee can make any request or changes um to just this point from July to through January we spent no July through December we spent about $24,000 with Mento students but yeah that money would then shift to support those families Karen so just quickly and I think this
030is more to Jess so I apologize so this is based on the Statewide Transportation they don't use local busing right so and you get penalized so I think what just is saying so what happens the resolution she's well the the law issue you're talking about is the one where and I agree with you um what happens is we have attempted and I think I've mentioned this to the committee before to meet with Ryden Statewide to be able to fund it ourselves at a much cheaper rate but then you don't get the reimbursements and then we get penalized for that ewg pulled out completely and lost all their estate Aid which was a huge hit for them so uh rep Carter is uh supporting and uh I think uh championing that bill which I do agree
031with uh miss pcell something that the committee should also be looking at the transportation in general is one of our largest areas of need overall that's where I would begin our Focus can you say that again I'm sorry the transportation needs uh the that's one of our largest especially because of the 128 square miles so the resolutions and the work happening right now in the transportation World um does help us alleviate a lot of the cost that continue to rise every year thank you Laura um so I'm Jess I I think what are you do you just you could just clarify for me that the you mean that this resolution is that essentially Shero wouldn't benefit too much from it is that kind of what you're no I don't think they would okay thanks so
032in the spirit of transparency I have a child that goes to a private school I pay substantial property taxes uh in Richmond um it would be a hardship for my family personally um if that Transportation was taken away I think it would be a hardship for lots of other parents who send their kids to private school I support public education I think the transportation as a whole needs to be taken a look at which Cho can't um solve overnight it's a Statewide issue so I will not be supporting this resolution the other option is to think about the transportation ones that you want to and then just pull it completely and then start with an example from uh either miss pcel or um yourself that have examples of how they want the resolution to read
033I'm happy to do that as well the bigger picture is um and we're we're not cuz that was some of the clarification it's not to remove private school transportation so no one's asking anyone to remove it it's to shareing the cost and not get penalized if you do find a cheaper way to do it but we can look at rewarding it that's another option as well Polly what's the other side what does the uh private schools think about this kind of res resolution what it what's being discussed at the table it just started so I would look at the video video yesterday because those commissions are public and available for everyone to view I don't want to speak AIT turn but obviously they would like it to remain the same Jess um I was going
034to say so it is about the in the resolution it does strike out the line that says the state subsidy so it's about replacing the state subsidy with a cost sharing agreement yet to be determined in the future so just I just wanted to clarify that point and I you know the the um the video is on Capital TV if you just search it's kind of a unwieldy first page but if you search Capital TV for study transmission you can study whatever the student transportation where commission I can send you actually was in my updates if you click on the link you'll get right to the um the page because they they've had representatives from Ripa they've had representatives from the Catholic schools superintendents of um uh Bristol Warren was there last night because part
035of the issue was the regions were established in not 50 years ago so Bristol Warren is the East Bay they send kids a lot farther and more ranging of a distance than maybe we do here or so there there's a lot being considered it's not just about non-public Transportation it's about the Statewide system in general so it's it's very informative work so is there anyone that is interested in making any adjustments or revisions to um this resolution so I was at the end of the meeting I was going to make an agenda item request to support that bill I mentioned it's 5204 I believe I have it written down but could I make a motion now that we table this and make our own resolution regarding Transportation motion on the floor there is a motion
036on the floor some if you withdrew whoever I think I second it so I have to I did it first you all right so I withdraw my second I was I first okay so no okay so we have the motion that has been withdrawn and the second was withdrawn so um Jess did you want to make a an alternate motion um I would well I don't know if it's an alternate motion or if it's a separate agenda item to um I I think what you could say is based on the resolution around transportation that that you're looking uh I don't think you need the motion okay I think you just like you said the future agenda items we can think more holistically uh and then revise it to make sure it meets the needs of
037the committee okay could could I add something to that could you run it through legal councel because my concern is I'm reading this and I'm thinking we have taxpayers paying the full amount of tax and they a property tax and it's coming to the school and they're sending their kids over and above to private school there may be some legal recourse coming from those private schools saying hey well you're getting the tax dollars we're not getting those maybe we should run that bil legal and see what concerns we might have with a resolution like this getting behind it well the we F the the resolution follows the law so there's a law in place yeah so I I would just recommend a few um the lawyer is going to say to follow the law but
038I do think um if there's something specific just dra future agenda item no I do you y I think so I think what we're going to do is we're going to discuss this at the end of the meeting for future agenda items so um is that your intention Jess um no I think well you have a future agenda item and we future agenda item will I would either table this or vote on this I don't I don't I would prefer that may we table it and and then come back at with a resolution that that meets the committee's needs so do we have a motion to table uh this agenda item thank you P Pat do we have a second second second by Diane um all in favor unanimous thank you Item B under business
039fiscal year 26 budget approval so um just so I can clarify the superintendent has put forward and her team has put forward a suggested budget for fiscal year 26 um we've had some discussions on this we had a budget Workshop um this is um something that we if we vote to uh approve this we are approving the budget as is so we're accepting the superintendent's budget but we have an opportunity to um revise amend discuss it again during the next budget workshop on February 25th we will also have the districtwide meeting coming up on March 4th where we will listen to the the uh residents and the taxpayers about again their feedback on the budget and then we also have an opportunity to make other adjustments and you know more discussions at the March 11th
040school committee meeting so if we you know vote to approve this budget we vote to to own it and um to revise it uh accordingly moving forward is that clear with everyone around the around table okay so do I have a motion to approve the fiscal year 26 budget motion to approve okay Diane do I have a second second okay Jess seconded any discussion on this Larry I I would approve this budget but lar just talk right into your microphone please I um approved the budget but i' like to send it back to Gina and see if she can come up with uh a million dollars cuts no that's our job so I actually have we have some tonight based on the request you you gave me that request last time yep so actually if
041Kathy you don't mind it you can put it up so let's take our M let's do our vote first sorry right discuss we're discuss yeah well let's discuss yes okay so then I'm GNA just flip this down the road Larry were you finished well she okay she gonna put something up on the screen so at the last meeting um just like Mr Phelps said I was asked to bring the requested from the school committee because like Miss the Lyle said those have to come from you so Mr Phelps asked me to show if hope rally closes what those cuts would look like so those were up here Miss Chapman asked about the World Language teacher which is I placed to here as well um Miss pcel had requested the uh the amount of bringing the
042fund balance to 2% and then there were two items that we added as the district which is in the third category under um the nas which is the high school accreditation has been postponed so that's a for $4,700 savings that we can do because we're postponing it and then the other thing that came up with Miss Davis's review uh and she asked and I had um no problem bringing it up to make sure pure transparency was that uh the district currently covers the BCI check uh for all volunteers for our field trips for our mentors for the work in the district that's about cost us about $55,000 a year that's something that again similar to what Miss Hopkins said about shifting you know responsibilities right now the district does it if you shifted it it
043goes back to families or those that are volunteering and that again is up to the committee with the cuts that Mr Phelps Miss Chapman Miss purcel um have asked then that brings you to 1.1 M 45,1 159 so I have I have some questions um but I'll let Jess go first um I just want to be clear so that's like a level funded budget the one it's about $25,000 off from being level funded okay but these were the requests I was asked to bring based on the last meeting I didn't know does anyone there there were two outstanding questions from the last meeting one from Mr Phelps about the uh first page overview and the amounts and then I believe there was why if you want to startop there yeah yes so if um you
044notice you were each giv her um the one pager again for section two um what Mr the fellows point out is um due to when you run numbers in Excel and you're working with 60 to 70 million um we tend to cut off at two decimal places because um that's how money works but Excel runs to eight decimal places and that $6,000 difference was actually when you run it to eight decimal places you wind up with that's where that money was so we We R We R we ran page two to eight decimal places and um then assigned that $6,000 to the three towns accordingly um in past years the district um absorbed that course in their during the year this is has been common practice over the years I guess no one has ever
045pointed it out thank you thanks Larry so I I have some questions for um Gina and um for Mr zenan so and thank you so much for putting this um spreadsheet together can everybody see that okay from the public no um how can we make that clearer so do can we turn the lights down yeah just just a second here over here there is another copy here if anybody wants it while we're doing that y can I just sure when we vote on a budget on that it we're voting on the adjustments correct the adjusted not yet we got to make a motion on not no there's already a motion on the table to just for the for the to approve the budget to approve it FY 26 great just need a motion to make
046Cuts yes we already have a motion on the table so you guys right so right now we're we're just discussing a whole host of things related to the fiscal year 26 budget so is that better for everybody in the audience that they can they see that better yes yes okay um so my questions are and I appreciate you are taking the time to put this spreadsheet together because that's very helpful um I just want to be clear that um last meeting Larry had asked about level funding the budget and you had indicated that to get closer to a level funded budget we have to have a serious conversation about Hope Valley Elementary School and you went through line item by line item a number of savings if Hope Valley were to potentially close at the
047end of this school year and my question is um in these columns and what you articulated verbally is also represented on this sheet so one of the things were when we look at staff so it says here cut uh grade one so that would be two educators so does that mean that those educators are um placed somewhere else in the district or does that mean that those educators are completely eliminated from our budget so what's the real cost savings that is the real cost savings because um we have retirements we always do and then the most senior we have some leave of absences we have some substitutes so uh for example the committee just reviewed the non-renewal list those are to cover the people that have the most seniority and experience but that is the
048cost saving we would need two less first grade Educators in the district um upon closing Hope Valley we would need one less grade two teacher um we do need our grade three and grade four based on our enrollment so that's why you don't see those grades there but this is the real cost savings however I don't know um Mr zenan I don't if you don't mind if you could share the um I gave the committee an email that Mr zenan received from Chartwells that we actually have $12,000 if it stays open you would then have to add an additional $122,000 at least to be able to run the Food Service program at Hope Valley so we are legally we are legally required to feed the students um as enrollment continues to drop in Hope Valley
049it costs us more for the food and the labor than what we're bringing in so that um is starting to happen this year and with that um we are doing an audit of um the national food Association is auditing our food services and as part of that I did ask some CH W to tell me what do you think um Hope Valley Will C us next year and um we will have a $1,000 deficit to feed the students in um grade 2nd through fourth next year so then we'd have to add that so we would have to add that we we that would come out of our pockets and then the following year it would probably be more and just for the community members um next year Hope Valley is projected to have 97 students
050is that right for second third and fourth uh they have 97 correct 97 okay um so I also had a question about the maintenance and the utilities it's referenced here 195,000 so are you looking at traditional bills over you know this year last year the year before to come up with the $195,000 figure so a 12mon rolling average was done so for example 12mth rolling average of electricity then that was deducted a 12-month rolling average of what it costs for diesel fuel to heat Hope Valley um we looked at other expenses such as garbage um expenses that are not included in that is anything that um the students would need so for example paper we did not use that as a deductible because that will shift to the other buildings so it's just it is
051hard cost of things that we would no longer be paying for because we would no longer be operating hope valy if you close it okay and I have one more question so the um the nurse so there is a nurse at Hope Valley and you said that there was a resignation I believe the last time so so right now we have um we have a resignation for the end of the school year if we keep hope rally open we would have to fund the nurse but we have an ability to then now remove that cost with nobody to be impacted okay and and it's very likely you will not hire a nurse if they no one's going to come here knowing that they're going into a school that's closed and so we'd have to go
052to contract agency which could C you even more okay that's good to know um okay and then custodian so this is I have a similar question about the custodial um so Hope Valley it says here a $60,000 um custodial cost so would that custodian then based on either seniority or tenure would that custodian get positioned in another building so if it's a custodian with seniority they would be moved to another building we currently have five openings so we would have four openings okay so again no one would be impacted okay all right does anybody else have any questions Larry now say you close it it goes back to the town can the Town come back at us and say hey this ain't the way we gave you this this ain't the way we gave you
053that I'm just um they can but um it would be very unlikely that they would have any ground to stand on especially I mean if you go back to the minutes Mr when they received that building it was and I quote Mr Dave from those minutes the worst of any building they've ever seen provided to the district just just a question that's throw it out there so I just want to comment on that um I just want to comment on that to say that I think um if we are seriously considering potentially closing Hope Valley Elementary School that before that discussion is before that decision is made um we should proactively reach out to the Town Council of hopkington and have a discussion or a walk through to talk that through um because you know
054we're basing our decision on your telling us that the school would be returned turned to the town in a manner that was in better condition than what it was turned over I just want to make sure that we are transparent we are have open lines of communication with the um elected officials of hopkington because I just I just think that that's the right thing to do um that's just my two cents so we did do the walkthrough last year um we did it with all the town councils actually because uh councelor Hurst had come up and said something similar as to what Mr phelp said and it actually it's sent you know um very upsetting to our to our custodians because they do a lot of good work uh every single day to so to
055to make sort of an assumption that the building is not uh well-kept or um it's old and and it absolutely is uh and it definitely needs um like we know that right now the roof and septic will need to be need to be taken care of um however when we did that walk through there was and I was with the the the current president the current vice president all the Town Council came we walked with our fil facilities we actually had uh it was community members that showed up and we walked the entire building we let them see every single nook and cranny and they were no one had any concerns okay Diane um yes well I I'd like to speak to that as far as the concerns are it it it did come to
056my attention that the town of hopkington Town Council has concerns over the condition of the fac facility at this time and the condition of the facility when it was turned over in The Last 5 Years and the maintenance um on everything and there is a list of uh items here that that um within the last five years should have or could have been addressed um but in returning Hope Valley School to the town of hopkington um that would place that building and the responsibilities of all the repairs and the maintenance that was not maintained on that building over the last five years in the lapse of the hopkington residents which I am not are you willing to give her a copy of that list to us sure I also think it's important to understand that
057when we're talking about what T hopkington is saying we have we have our minutes and we also have the conversations of Town Council Members coming to this committee requesting that you not invest in Hope Valley Capital which you did not for three years we took on that cost as a district in good faith when we were planning our elementary schools so the the history here is very well-kept and I'm happy to put our history against their history any day so I have a question for the administration if Hope Valley school if the school committee votes that this is potentially the last year of Hope Valley Elementary you had said the septic and the roof so would we have to as a school committee have to incur the costs to repair the septic and the roof
058as part of the the roof is still functioning and it does not currently leak and the septic system is currently working correct what we're saying is they all everything has a lifespan so the longer and if you keep Hope Valley open you're going to pay dollar for dollar because you will not get reimbursed for any dollars you put in which is why the committee agreed when when members of the Town Council asked them not to invest if they were going to plan on closing it and because they had the new plan to to revise the elementary schools with that being said I think you know it's nice what people remember but I want to say Donis scaven did an amazing job and there's a lot of town council members that come up to every single
059time for a budget asked you all to and I know Mr da sat here 5 years ago requesting that the capital budget be reduced so that you could in good Faith focus on your Elementary School planning that school is in better condition and I will I will absolutely say that and I and I when I did the walk there were no concerns so I will not take hearsay I I think that conversation needs to happen with the council president and I want and I and I'm like I'm saying everyone needs to bring the receipts well that that was my suggestion I just I think in this in the spirit of um the this is a this is a very big deal potentially closing a school and I just I I believe in open communication honest
060blunt straightforward communication so I think it's probably an everybody's best interests that before this decision is made one way or another that there is a discussion with the hopkington Town Council before before the decision is made that's just my opinion and um you know I I try to work in the spirit of cooperation whenever we can and you know we're all decision makers for either the town or the school committee so so um you know I think everybody should be around the table especially the four hopkington school committee members because it's going to impact you know you all the most so as you're um making these decisions you may want to keep in mind that the school committee has um a plan in place to close Hope Valley over the next three years correct so
061um if you continue along that plan you may also want to plan to budget some money for Capital repairs to Hope Valley to return it to hopkington right right understood thank you for that point Jess did you have your hand raised yeah so a couple comments um you know I I think as I've said time and again I think our the regional aspect of our school district is our greatest asset but it also causes issues between towns um between town councils and school committees um and part of the issue that we've had over the last 20 years as enrollment has shifted to charter schools in some ways and birth rate has gone down yes we've had decreased enrollment is that we've maintained more schools than we have students for and so while this is a
062difficult decision it does make a lot of sense but I just want to stress that it's not just hington that's impacted you know Richmond School is the school that would take on a those 100 kids and Charlestown Elementary School is the school that would take on those 93 kids that are in prek um and so it's it really is a bigger impact than just 97 children or 93 or one Town versus the other like really are all in this school district together um and that I I just want to stress that and I do think there's been a lot of communication with hopkington I was at that walkthr we all went through the building there were different um folks that have worked in there and I've been in all of these buildings and they are
063well-maintained they are well-loved they are clean but they have aging infrastructure they have Heating units that are older than me um they have HVAC that is outdated and then layers of Technology that it's come into the school layers of tiles layers of paint all they they need a lot of improvements that cost a lot of money um I can tell you personally my goal with this budget is not to level fund um I I don't I was in favor of closing H Valley when we had a long-term plan of three modern schools that were equalized in size that were that would serve our community well for the next many generations now I'm less um assured of that path knowing where these children have to go into our aging school buildings I do not want to
064level fund but I do see that you know the increase for Richmond is at 3.7% and I can't um really bear sending that to our our residents and myself included so my goal personally just to be transparent about it would be to get Richmond down a percentage point which to my understanding is about $400,000 I think that's fairly reasonable if you know but then again keeping Hope Valley open poses other problems you know you don't want these kids to feel like they don't have a full school you don't want to be spending money on a building that is slowly emptying I I think it has effects not just on the the fiscal but culture and climate of that school building as well so I have concerns either way um but level funding is not my
065main goal um but getting Richmond down a percentage point at least is um Jess may I just ask to you and to Gina when was that walk through when did that walkthrough take place June June June of 2024 correct okay thank you and so I know like it wasn't just the current Town councilors candidates were there too so miss Roy was there um the other gentleman who was elected was there the fire CH the current School Town council members were there because of the what Scott bhur had said which was very similar to what Larry said which he was worried about um how the building had been maintained okay thank you um Laura and then Craig and then Diane um sorry the can we put the lights up now um is this good for everybody
066you mind put the lights back thank you um so I just wanted to on the the issue of Hope Valley you know when those two students came up here and spoke um you know I kind of I look at that and I you know knowing that they don't have the high SE program at Hope Valley Elementary School I can't hear you you um the two students that came up and spoke earlier that when they were talking about the high sea program um that's a you know they obviously have that at all the elementary schools trials down as well and my my thought is kind of you know it at this point it it almost feels like that because of how the grades are being phased out that now it's starting to affect the students that
067are at that school is that accurate Gina I I think it impacts all your families all your teachers all your students that are attending Hope Valley absolutely I said that last time we have our buildings are not 21st century and I I completely understand what Miss prel is saying because um that was the hope right that we would be able to the 21st Century Learning facilities for our students that's what ride continues to harp on with our um our biggest concern around some of the infrastructure um because the buildings are old and they're not going to get newer when we put new kids in them they but they are what we have and that was a decision made by voters and now we have you know on on our list we're going to be discussing
068a new capital plan but we have three other schools that are excellent High performing five and fourstar elementary schools um that have excellent Educators where these Educators and these students will flourish as well the building has been well-loved um but again there's only so much we can do with old because now we have four old aging buildings Richmond has been you know and definitely one of those needs where we're going to have to reopen the basement level which is still I'm sure going to be concerned uh we've done all of our reviews of all the buildings they're needy all of them and when the school committee decided to hold on Capital Improvements across the elementary schools because of the plan there was a lot of um you know good intent but when the plan didn't
069pass we're still left with four old facilities and I guarantee when anyone walks into our schools they're old now I've heard people say they're fine that's what I went to school with so if that's what people believe but that's not what the reports is saying and we know septics go HVAC is our biggest concern you don't see them but you know when you have AC units in every Elementary School it's not efficient when you're running the AC when you have the HVAC may put in a new boiler but all of the control panels are old so there's only so much aund I mean ride will say that they consider building at life at 50 years ours have been they've lived two lives at this point and they're going on a third and we're doing our
070best to maintain and keep them clean but I agree I think I mean the the we we know the library media Richmond has an emergency certified teacher in the library media ashway has no librarian HOV valy has no librarian that un fortunately is a a hard to fill need which is why we're res shifting that that role and that position to to what we think uh somebody will absolutely flourish and be able to do but yeah putting a uh educator it's people are not going to want to come to positions that are not guaranteed or that they could while you're shifting about a school people are less likely to come in and join the team so is there you know I mean it almost seems like the it would be helpful I'm guessing because there
071seems to be a lot of you know push back with the families whose children do still go to Hope Valley right now which is understandable um you know is there is there a way to you know I guess if there's only 97 students there that is there some sort of Outreach or something to that effect that can be done to kind of you know help alleviate some of that that process of you know the the scare that comes along with that um because I mean I certainly hear it you know at different places so I mean what I'm hearing is they want to know because are you going to do this year you going to do it next year when you're phasing out because we we all know the cost is going to get larger
072this is what we know minimum but there are things that are happening like when TRS because um just in case you know people may not understand we have students who bring their lunch to school themselves they you know they're made by their families and they bring them to school so they don't need the lunch purchased so that what's happening is students who need to get their lunch at school there's not enough students that that are purchasing to be and because they bringing their lunch and as those numbers dwindle we're saying at minimum it'll be at $112,000 and that's just one area so um we're giving you minimum of what we know will will cost savings but I you know J pcel is correct our facilities are in dire need of of of updating and it's
073not because if they were just Office Buildings you know there's a difference but we're educating our students so when things when it gets cold and it's not as and and you're having heaters hanging from the ceilings and heaters hanging from um to try to get people warm again it is not conducive to educating them and learning and um all of our all of our buildings have been well- loved and they kept up the best possible that they can be kept but there's only so much paint and so many times you can fix something where you say you know do you want to if you're going to invest in HVAC I think we've sh that at Richmond alone you you were talking at about you know a huge million doll millions of dollars of of HVAC
074necessary just because of the way the whole building is laid out you know they they're not they weren't meant to live you know 100 years so is it if if the the closure was you know I'm just speaking hypothetically if it was expedited are you saying that the other three elementary schools couldn't even at this point house those kids they no they can't it's not going to be pretty and I mean people there a plan in place we've walked all the buildings we have all the rooms set up um the principles are aware they've been involved in it um you're not moving them into new buildings they're you're moving our buildings are old right they're all catching up with Hope Valley like Richmond and Hope Valley almost the same age you um and then you've
075got ton not far behind and then ashway well I think we had Craig C uh and Diane that had some comments Craig did you have your hand raised were you going to go first no you go Ahad uh I just wanted to add to what Greg was saying in reference to Hope Valley let's not forget this was handed over to us in 1986 that was 37 years ago you know and uh uh being on this committee long enough I remember we wanted to replace the the the windows at ashway school for seven straight years and and Town Council for poppington kept telling us Kick the Can down the road a little bit further you know because they and we understand we understand the Dynamics of cost Rising but there comes a point where you you
076got to invest or you got to move on so uh uh I just just wanted to add my and Jess is correct all um just about uh 96 of the 97 would head to Richmond that's correct 96 of the 97 okay thank you Diane okay and I just want to add one one thing okay I understand hope Valle you know it's not going to live forever I get it okay it's sentimental yes to a lot of people in this town okay but we have to move forward in some some way okay to achieve what we need to achieve I'm voicing my concerns at this point of we haven't gotten the independent report from veritos has we have we that you probably I talked to ride based on you know it's in there they haven't even
077gone back to us well they usually give us a preview we haven't even seen it yet we haven't even seen it yet okay cuz I mean I had understood and correct me if I'm wrong they talked about a total demolition of that building they've asked about demolition of a lot of our buildings well I'm just saying that that was raised okay so now we're looking at and the town of hackington is looking at covering the cost of that Demolition and covering the cost of repairs in that building all on our own in the town of hopkington that's Steep and I know there are going to be a lot of people that are not going to be happy to hear about that so that's why we near need to have more conversations about how the whole
078closure of this place is going to happen even with the Town Council you know I am in agreement with that I understand it has to close I get it I do I just want to do it the right way okay so uh Pat so you was you were saying with like the nursing position that you have someone retiring resigning y they resign at the end of the year so if that nurse in Hope Valley goes over to the vacant position now you have a vacancy in Hope Valley that you said most likely no one's going to put in for because they know they're going to be out of a job in a couple year so what happens when you can't fill that nursing position we have to use a contracted service at a higher cost
079okay thank you okay so we have a motion on the floor we have a second um so um are we ready to vote to um approve the fiscal year 26 budget at this point can you just reiterate the motion that's on the floor as Madam clerk I that's okay I just want to make sure I completely understand I apologize thank you so much I it's just approve the FY 26 to approve the FY 26 budget okay no changes okay so with no changes as of this point right so all in favor unanimous thank you okay um next on our agenda letter to the Rhode Island Department of Education school building Authority for emergency expenditures Mr Zen I'll ask sorry I um I this is the letter of ride for our emergency expenditures we've been doing
080it every year since I've been here because we do not have an official Capital Improvement plan and the only way that we get reimbursed is by submitting this letter to the uh Department of Education so you I uh I would like I recommend approval of the to submit this letter to ride for reimbursement of um emergency expenditures so move second we have a motion we have a second um I think Jess seconded you before Diane okay um any discussion Larry um it says exterior and interior doors District wide now is that all the schools you want it would focus mainly on the elementary schools we have our targeted list um there are there are doors like for example um with some of the boiler rooms there are doors with some of the cafeterias that we
081believe are unsafe um could be potentially more easily accessed some of the original so we would I know it's in to do doors and no no this is for the elementaries okay okay you just write it districtwide so you have flexibility in case we have an emergency in the district that we not prepared for so you said something Gina about um reimbursement so this is eligible for so how much uh reimbursement $500,000 no we we are asking for 500,000 we would be reimbursed at 61% so we'd get back about 305,000 if you look at your budget that's what we've also included for the FY 26 so if we do not do this you're going to be 300,000 to hold in housing aid for next year so remember housing gate is one year behind Okay and
082we have enough money in our capital line item to okay thank you any more discussion I just have one question didn't we replace one of these ashway boilers you did a few years ago you have there ashway boiler and one on its way great why both weren't replaced at the same time I'm not sure money but yes so SW yane way okay thank you so we have a motion in a second um are we ready to vote okay so all in favor to um send the letter to ride School building authority for emergency expenditures only express uh it's unanimous thank you okay D request to utilize the state of Rhode Island Master price agreement list for Charlestown and Ash boilers and oh we did that already no no no keep going oh okay and exterior
083and interior doors districtwide to Access housing aid reimbursement so this would allow us to go to the master price agreement list versus going out to bid um we do know that there are boilers actually in stock right now um keep in mind if we if this work is not completed by June 30th we will not be reimbursed um with the house need for the FY 26 budget also keep in mind that the master price agreement um very likely will get you better prices okay questions Craig Greg how much swing time do they need to dismantle take out put a new one in before that date so um it depends on um we would probably order all three boilers at once we would hopefully get two in um the way our um boiler rooms are set
084up at ashway and Charlestown there's an exterior door the work can be done during the school day furthermore um currently the boilers are running so you can take one offline replace it and then take the other one um we have worked very closely with um one or two of the companies that have replaced boilers in the district we're being assured that putting three boilers in in this time frame is not an issue okay thank you anyone else Laura there's no there's no issues with Lee times on actually getting the boilers in you're saying that that's what that Master agreement list is or something means that we have a call in with the master price agreement with and we know that there are two boilers currently in stock okay and the third one is the third
085one you know um um that you know it's going to get interesting because um they have to be forged um um there was a 25% tariff put on um steel and you know aluminum so um could change the prices a little bit but um My Hope Is that we could get it in before everything really starts to roll and um I I I have talked um extensively with Jason and we do believe we could have it done by the June 30th date great and then the doors would be done based on um what is our highest need and what is in stock and did the doors do those have to so those also fall under that time frame of being reimbursed is that correct okay do we have a motion to approve oh no it
086was never I recommend approval so moved okay second do we have a second okay uh Diane uh all in favor unanimous next stage one Elementary planning application to ride so you've seen this before this is the same package we have to resubmit it it's we're allowed to have hold it for one year um in queue so this gets us back in the queue with Ry to be able to Begin Again stage one for those that may not have heard this before means that you have to provide to R your facility review now the Bureau of AR house report isn't completed they know that so we packaged it with the old reports and then when the new report comes in they they recognize that's we're responsible to use that report so I have a question so
087what can you I know that this is a 1500 to 3,000 page application so can you give us a high your high level assessment of what is the the end game for the stage one Elementary planning application to ride so what are we hoping to achieve by the stage one application so you have to have a you're required by law to have a fiveyear capital Improvement plan you can't have a five-year Capital Improvement plan um which is part of stage two without a stage one review of your uh facilities they recognize that we would begin meeting with our necessity for school construction once the new report goes live however this is required to be able to show the good faith because if we're not complying then they can take our state aid allocation and tell
088us what to do with it okay okay yeah we have to make sure that it's up it expires in one year if we don't get a stage two ready and for February 15 2026 then we have to pay for another stage one okay Jess I make a motion to approve the stage one Elementary planning application to ride I will second that okay we have a motion and a second uh any more discussion all in favor okay unanimous thank you 2026 school committee meeting schedule I do recommend approval uh we did add the budget Workshop just like you had um asked for this year we added it to next year as well so that it will happen after the February vacation to give you a little bit more time so you'll also see on this page
089um uh a caveat underneath the meeting schedule which says during the 2026 school year the school committee may consider scheduling a workshop or Retreat to support the district's priorities in align with the Strategic plan well this may be scheduled at any time the committee is currently exploring options for dates in August 2026 or October 2026 I asked Gina uh the superintendent to um put that on this sheet because I feel really strongly that we have um you know our meetings which are extensive in terms of agenda items and we don't necessarily take the time that I think we should be taking to support the superintendent with her strategic plan with her um priorities for around academic excellence and I do think that those things um should take um some time and some thoughtfulness and um
090so that's why I I wanted that to be added to uh to the 2026 um calendar do I have a motion to approve the 2026 school meeting schedule so approve okay we've got Diane do I have a second Polly any other discussion okay all in favor unanimous thank you 2025 20126 school calendar Gina so this um we have the state calendar that gives a guide and then what we have to do is we have to ensure that we meet all of the law requirements regarding the school calendar so this has been uh reviewed at all of our departments and provide feedback but I'm happy to answer questions of the committee but I am approve I am recommending approval of the school calendar for the 2025 2026 school year and happy to answer any questions do
091we have a motion um I make a motion to approve the school calendar I'll second it who second to that was that Karen okay uh discussion okay uh Jess and then um Laura who can go um I was just wondering I did notice that the start time was the start were earlier and is that to is that up sorry this the um the start date for the calendar is in August so school would start on August 27th I believe is that was that so that we could because of what happened the previous year how it you know basically ended up where kids were in school until I gosh I can't remember the date but into when Camp had already started basically um was that kind of why that was done no actually it was because
092of the 171 days for the seniors they have to have 171 instructional days and we have a three-year graduation contract based on that day so we have to work backwards so uh we had to shift it although ewg had gone back to that schedule um many of our except for I think narag and South Kingstown I want there are two that that we're considering um but that's why we we we when we have it we do it early enough so people can plan oh okay thanks Jess that was the same thing I was going to point out okay so we have a motion and a second any more discussion okay um all in favor of approving the 2025 2026 school calendar okay it's un is it unanimous okay all in favor yes no okay I
093abstain okay so uh we have um so we have an abstention from Craig do we have any nose no okay great um Food Service adult meal price increase Gina did you want to speak to this or Mr zenan yes I am recommending approval go ahead Mr Zen so um as part of this um review we're doing um it it's been bur to our attention and I have um said in past memos that um our our pricing is not accurate does not accurately reflect what our meals are cost in so um we're recommending that breakf for adults move from 150 to 225 and for lunch from 375 to 425 which is still very reasonable and um if you approve this will take effect on Monday March 3rd and then um we will um in early June
094look at the price increase for students which we would do with the start of the 25 26 school year okay so do we have a motion to approve the Food Service adult meal price increase Mo uh do we have a second Donna okay any other discussion all in favor unanimous thank you Mr I didn't see I did thank you so that was behind the okay next request to go out to RFQ request for qualifications for district legal services so um do you want me to speak to you want start um I can however you want to do okay so this was an agenda item that um I wanted to put on the agenda I know that we have um able legal representation and I believe their contract is expiring on June 30th um similarly um
095was it last year or the year before the school committee decided that they were going to evaluate an auditing firm because we had been with the same Auditors for a number of years and that uh it was best practice to uh go out to um to bid for another you know potential you know auditor to um to audit the district so in that Spirit um you know knowing that the contract is going to be coming to a close on June 30th um I thought it was part of a best practice to um go out to uh an RFQ for legal services so with that being said did anybody um so so I need a mo do I motion on this so I need a motion on this then a second and then discussion right I'll
096second okay so motion to approve second is ply discussion Larry um where it says um qualification requirements isn't that being you know keeping the group of people that are so-called qualified to bid on this you know you you're saying you got to have you know three Public Schools under your belt now now the representing does that really need to be there you can take off everything the committee doesn't have to even go out to bid I'd like to remove two three four and five off the no no so your um recommendation Larry is um so we have a draft RFQ in front of us so actually before I I would say because there a couple of things just so we don't get confused okay so the first thing that you're being asked for is to
097go out to bid for Legal Services the bid is only if it gets approved so you probably should first discuss this before you talk about because the RFQ is in the consent if approved okay so the discussion is whether not we want to go out for bid and just to remind you that this is where the school committee has complete perview you you don't need to go out the only thing the committee is required to do is put it on the agenda whatever action you want to take um you don't have to go out to bid you can select somebody that doesn't bid um these requirements have come from other other districts uh that recently within the few years East Providence Foster Gloucester East grenwich and 2007 right I don't know if I use I
098don't I think it was East grenage but maybe um and the compation myself Mr zenan and Dr Cala have all reviewed uh to ensure that it mirrors and our special education department that it mirrors what we're currently doing around the needs of the district um so the two must have experience with Federal and State education law I can tell you we are in we have court cases in federal and in state so you want to be really mindful that someone has that background because if you don't then that puts us at a disadvantage so it would be my recommendation to keep in number two again my recommendation three uh three public school districts you you want to know that they are working um with other districts because Rhode Island law is different than Mass law
099which is different than Connecticut Law so you want to make sure that that but again that's my advice the committee can is at your will you can change that uh that's up to you um and then number four was Mr Fel did you say four two three four yes um four was must have significant experience in special education law got special education law bit on this you would think the person would have experience no there's not many that do so for example um would you share like Westerly as an example so um yes I I started digging around to you know um see what kind of deal we had and um Westerly um pays $9,000 to have a lawyer represent their school committee then they pay another $90,000 in um not in a fixed fee
100that's what they paid last year to have all their other legal service is done at $250 an hour um I I will um advise you that if you do decide to go out to look for a new attorney um you have now taken the budget over you're going to want to add at least $100,000 to your legal fees because what you currently budget for is not going to be anywhere near what you're going to pay Jess so I have numerous comments um thank you for sharing that you put this on the AG the agenda um in previous practice it would say who requested an agenda item um I did like that because it showed where it came from I I was surprised to see it because we just or the school committee um previously approved
101John's contract August 20th 2024 so it seemed to me like we just did this I don't understand why this is on the agenda um at that time it was approved I believe nine to two two because we were missing one member at the time um so and at that time you know it was discussed the cost was great John has a lot of historical knowledge with the district that's really valuable um to draw a distinction between the time that we changed the auditor that auditor was undergoing some The Firm was undergoing a federal some sort of Investigation criminal um it criminal investigation it wouldn't have affected us but we thought in that case and it's very different an auditor is a once-yearly an audit is a once- yearly annual um sorry it's a mathematical formula
102essentially that they plug in John works on a daily basis I don't know the percentage of work he does for the school committee versus the district but what he does for the district on a daily basis after hours on the weekends is a lot more than what he does for this committee even though we're in charge of his um agreements um so I think that that's just something to uh show him respect for the the work that he has done I think that his special education is huge the legal requirements of a public education system and one as large as ours there is just so much um I also want to you know like the the current cases he's involved in is is a concern to me um and I I just want to make
103sure that we're really being um you know honest about our goals and the finding new legal council has been rumored around this district for years and to see it pop up on the agenda like this is a surprise to me um some folks have reached out to me it was you know a I say surprise but also not because like I said the rumors have been swirling for years that this is a goal um and I can only anticipate especially based on what Larry is saying who would sit in this position that is unqualified to represent us and what kind of trouble that would get us in um so I feel very leery um I feel mistrustful to be honest um just to be transparent about it and and um I I just I'm not
104sure how this really aligns with the district strategic mission and vision and I I don't I'd like to maybe hear a little more from other folks as well yeah I I just want to um speak to that because when you say that there's rumors and there's mistrust um that's rumors and I don't pay any attention to rumors so this is something that I felt should be on the agenda because the contract is coming to a close on June 30th whether we decide as a school committee to reappoint or extend the contract is a group decision a school committee decision we have um contract negotiations coming forward if you know it would not be a great thing to make a change if the committee decided that they were going to make a change um in the
105legal firm to make a change in the middle of contract negotiations I don't think that that's beneficial to any anyone one concerned so the timing of this is the timing so I I'm a I'm a forward thinker it's a June 30th contract ends um we're heading into contract negotiations with the Nea and if if if we are being mindful of timing the timing would be now to discuss whether or not to make a change that was my goal in this it's not to say this is no disrespect to the The Firm the firm is an excellent firm my personal attorney years ago was from this from this firm there are a finite number of law firms in Rhode Island that handle education law and special education law um and I'm mindful of that um but
106you know this is um this is something that I felt um if it was if there was going to be a change potentially made that this would be the most you know appropriate time to make such a change but you know I'm one person and I'm not saying that I want to make a change I'm just saying that we should as a committee have the thoughtfulness and the mindfulness to make sure that we are um evaluating everyone that does work for the district that was my that was my thought so I'm sorry that you feel that way about the mistrust and the rumors I don't I don't care about rumors I care about what the 12 people here have to say on the subject is there anybody else that wants to talk to this Donna
107yeah thank thank you and thank you Jess for very nicely saying what I was thinking I been on this committee for about eight years um when the contract comes up for the law firm we uh Ned before you Greg did the same thing they checked around they s they checked prices for other law firms we have a bargain as long as I have been on this committee John Anderson has been available and um spoke addressed all of the issues that I have been I have been concerned with and everyone else and I would like to recommend not going out for bid I think it's an insult I think we get what what I would consider a good amount of legal advice from this law firm and I think we should just stick with it it's
108it's Greg found out it's going to cost us more money if we switch it any point and I don't think we should open that can of worms I don't believe we should go out for bid okay thank you is there anyone else someone's I'm sorry I didn't say Linda and Laura and Karen and Craig um I guess I I need to understand something before I make my decis decision on how I want to go which way I want to go on this so your ultimate goal is to save the district money I just I think my ultimate goal is to um make sure that we have the best representation possible for the district moving forward okay okay regardless of the cost you know if there is a subcommittee put forward which is on the agenda
109for a subcommittee the subcommittee would have to evaluate that um and bring that um forward to the full committee and just to clarify you made a point about the negotiations if you think the negotiations are going to be done by June or September or even next year I think you're I mean maybe you guys can get that done but I think to change uh attorneys in the middle of a negotiation would be detrimental to negotiations and that was one of the reasons why putting it on the agenda sooner rather than later because but if you make the change in June you're going to be in you're going to be in the middle of negotiations okay thank you my point Laura um Greg where did you the the 100,000 that you were speaking of could you
110please speak the 100,000 that you were speaking of Greg where did that come from was it that be like did you speak to other offices or something I was just curious I started to um I didn't have much time because I had to wait for their agenda to go public because if I started asking people about um attorneys they would immediately want to know what's happening with our current attorney and out of respect for our firm I did not do that but I did start asking around and I will tell you um the deal you have is is unheard of I I I cannot find anyone that comes close to what we are paying for the level of service well he I I don't believe he's ever lost a case for us so um but
111you know you that's that's the committee's choice you have the choice to go out but if you go out um be prepared to spend a lot more because um I I I don't know I haven't spoke to the um Mr anerson about this but if it was me I wouldn't bid it I would move on so um you may lose the best deal you have with the best amount of money so just be prepared to spend more right okay who was next was that Craig no Karen sorry so I was going to um comment as Linda had that we're going into negotiation now is probably not the best time to change our attorneys um I'd also like to state that um we're one of only two if I'm correct school districts that get a flat
112rate versus a um per call which I think saves Us in the long run people don't uh feel um the financial crunch of having call and say this is you know this this phone call is going to cost the district money so in the long run it actually saves US money and I'd like to share that um when we were doing this last year Katherine kisante actually commented that quote it's impressive that attorney Anderson hasn't lost a case and his flat rate is impressive as well so um Mr Anderson is highly regarded um amongst other attorneys amongst judges um he's taken very seriously and his knowledge of our district and knowledge of special education law is probably exceeds any other attorney in the state thank you Karen just quickly I did a very quick Budget
113Check barington currently $245,000 for legal fees thank you Pat um this might be it's like um when you you're talking about John the person not the law firm I mean John's getting older I mean he's at some time in his life he's going to retire so that's something even if it's even if it's within his own Law Firm there I mean he's right now you're saying he's like one of the best and that's that's great but we're going to be in a position at some point that we're not going to have John per se anymore so that's that's something to consider as well so don I know you already spoke on this um okay um is there are there any besides Donna is there anybody from the committee that wanted to I did have my
114hand up sorry yes I concur 100% with Jessica chair your first meeting you gave a lengthy speech and you address the fact of us working together she alluded to Something in reference to a lack of trust and this is only reinforcing the lack of trust all right now working together is just that and maybe listening to what someone has said and in taking that in internalizing that so like I said I 100% agree with with her um hopefully you've listened to some others who have different opinions than yours I'm I'm always willing to listen to different opinions but that doesn't necessarily mean that I'm always going to agree with your opinion I have sometimes I have a strong point of view on things we have noticed that and we have noticed that of you as
115well but here's a prediction is this going to be a Partyline vote I don't know Donna I just wanted to comment on what Pat said and yes we do have a lot of faith and trust in John Shan came along tonight and I was just as happy with his participation in our executive meeting as I would have been with John we're hire we're contracted with the firm and the quality of that firm is very important to me and I would not want to jeopardize that thank you so seeing no other hands raised for from the school committee yes I know I was go give me a second I was going to say I'm GNA open it up to the public is there anybody from the public that would like to speak on this Katherine um
116this feels very short cited I think Mr zenan hit the the nail on the head that you will pay significantly more for legal fees uh John may leave his firm at some point his firm is not going to bid on this contract so not only will we you will you be losing John you will be losing his firm because you're sending a clear message by going out to bid that you don't have trust in them whether you recognize it or not and I think sometimes you need to recognize that your actions are are speaking as loud if not louder than your words um I would not support this one iota I think that you have coming from a spouse who works in a different District that does not have a flat fee every time he
117needs to get legal advice he needs to get permission first uh and it costs money and um that is not a a comfortable position for an educator to be in um I don't need to talk to you about John and how he's never lost a case but that should speak to you um and I think in this case your actions are going to speak much louder than your words and I know you don't listen to rumors and I appreciate that and I want to to put my faith in all of you that you're going to do the best work for this District but this particularly right now at this point feels like um a vendetta for some school committee members not you miss Densmore but other school community members this feels like a vendetta because
118you don't like John personally um and that is a short-sighted way to govern so I hope you do not go out to bid for this um you will be losing John you will be losing his firm and uh it's it's slim pickings for educational lawyers thank you thank you yes sir please state your name sure uh Greg abidian from the town of hopkington um I would just like to ask um how long has John been uh employed by the school district I believe he was hired back in 2008 2008 so we're looking at um 17 years um I would like to Echo just a sentiments that there is a real value to uh continuity and history um and I if rumors are just rumors short of some malfeasance or malpractice on his behalf I think
119it's um it's shortsighted and uh For No Good Reason um I I I honestly can't see any value in in seeking um uh uh bids from other law firms especially we now earlier we were talking about um saving the district money cutting a million dollars from the budget um and uh the the cost of of um uh impr U returning a Hope Valley School to the town of hopkington in its original condition or in condition that it was going to use we're we're we're talking about add adding all those expenses and now you want to add potentially another $100,000 I mean to me it's it's about you got to put the kids first and and I if if if rumors are are just rumors then that there has to be something else going on here
120at least the way I see it thank you is there anyone else yes sir good evening I'm uh Joe Jen ring the principal at Travel middle school I just 14 years in the district John has saved us a ton he doesen he gives us a flat rate it's unbelievable the deal he gives us I was in a school committee in a pre in another District we had three attorneys one for special head one for school committee and one for that dealt with Grievances and and um what's what did I put down uh and negotiations and things like that and that was probably over $200,000 combined um it's a lot I know maybe John's John is is a tremendous man knows a lot saved me from from a few things he's he's well worth what you
121are spending um so I just wanted to share that thank you I saw another hand up in the back hi Donna Donna scavage um as a former employee of Cho I worked here when John Earl was our attorney and I loved John Earl and sadly he passed away so we went out to bid and John Anderson's firm was hired for the past 22 years I cannot tell you how many phone calls each day I have made to John Anderson our staff has been trained by John Anderson he comes down and does secretarial training and clerk training so our staff is aware of custodial agreements restraining orders locator Card issues he comes down yearly to train our staff for free never charged us has never charged me for a phone call I made three the other
122day on the warrant so that the warrant which we've never had one done this way we had a vote taken in November to approve a bond the bond got approved before the Char for the building committee was done so you'll notice on your warrant there's going to be a charge for the building committee their charge of how they are going to operate we've never had a warrant done like that I called John three times the other day to help Angela do the warrant so it was done legally so there would not be a problem with it because once you put it in the paper it's at least $300 for the posting in the paper so if it was incorrect it's going to cost the district more money and you wouldn't have the time to post
123it John was on the phone with me an awful lot the other day so I don't understand why I have worked with for an attorney that charged by the hour every phone call was a charge I was not allowed to call him only the superintendents were I have learned an immense amount of Knowledge from John and I didn't have to pay for law school so it saved the district a lot of money and I'm not just looking at John his whole firm because when John's not available I have worked with others so I think to lose that firm is going to be a big loss for your District thank you thank you is there anyone else okay oh sorry Laura go ahead um I just I want to say that I appreciate what everybody has
124said tonight um I think that sometimes things can be misconstrued sometimes because the committee members you know there's a lot of us up here are new we haven't been on the school committee for eight years there's a lot of things that we just don't know and you know I often look at things from a business perspective when it comes to certain things when it comes to contracts and you know all sorts of stuff so you know when I saw this on the agenda I was like oh that's that's great that makes sense to me you know that was kind of my first thought was you know I I send things out to bid constantly over threeyear periods pretty much um so it's it's very enlightening to hear the other side of things and I think
125you know people could if you're just a little bit more mindful of the fact that we are new to this whole process and there's a lot of things that you know I personally just don't necessarily understand and it's not anything nefarious or anything it's really just you know thinking that it's you know if you have the potential to save money somewhere then you know I I would always opt for something something like that but um it sounds like John does have a very long history with the district and I can also understand the implications of what that would mean if you know you there was some another firm that becomes involved in that process of how that information would get to the new firm and all that other stuff I could completely see the other
126side of how those costs could be extremely high after a very short period of time so that's all I want to say okay all right um so so we had a lengthy discussion on this so Madam clerk can you just refresh my memory we had a motion in a second to go out to RFQ yes motion and second okay so seeing no further discussion um all those in favor of going out to to uh RFQ for district Legal Services okay um that's those are the Y's the Nays okay no abstentions okay all right moving on uh motion fails thank you all for your input we appreciate it thank you um requests to open the district homework policy for review to compare the current policy to other high performing school districts and to determine if a
127policy for elementary middle and high school should be separated I believe this was an agenda item put forward by um Laura yes so Laura would you like to chat about this and I know that I think Gina may have some input on this as well sure um so I brought this forward just because I I felt like it was something that you know should be should be looked at um I do I would prefer that this goes to the subcommittee for discussion um just so that they can really get into the details of everything I know that you know when years ago when my daughter was in fifth grade I can remember that there was a policy where if a student was missing more than three assignments than an automated phone call would go out
128to the parents and I'm really big on engaging the parents because I feel like in chero and our community in general we have an amazing group of parents we all care about our kids deeply so um and I think that you know if there's a way for us to kind of get parents more involved in that whole process I don't know if that is still something that happens where those phone calls go out after three assignments um I don't think that still happens at least at the the Sip meeting I nobody seemed to couldn't really confirm whether that was still a thing um but just things like that you know the goal isn't to necessarily add more of a workload to the students and to the teachers it's mainly to look at the language within
129our our our homework policy and you know kind of compare it to how other high performing districts you know have their policy worded and if there's places where we can improve maybe we need a separate policy for middle school students and as opposed to the high school students you know that's somewhere where I feel like we we could start um but yeah that's all I really have I think Gina did you want to weigh in on this before we go to I just want to remind the committee this is just a request to go into the subcommittee which would first have to go to sit because it's teaching and learning and instruction so the request simply is you know with that you we put it under review so typically what happens when it involves teaching
130and learning you um we give we gave the heads up to the school Improvement teams that this was on the agenda to start thinking through um we've also used the quadrant of success as uh as we've been pulling policies across the state some districts like EG uh which would be in the quad after doesn't have a policy they use a handbook so there is pro homework protocol and then there's homework policy but this will allow this to get into the subcommittee's hands but it won't get into their hands until school Improvement teams have to review first per the 2019 law after they get time to review um that's why typically we we you need the sort of the charge of what you want the uh the Committees to look at and this was what uh
131Miss chap together for us so that we could share that with the Committees and then Middle High Middle High and Elementary will all get together and then those administrators um that will speak on behalf of all their sits will come to the subcommittee for conversation and review so because it's going to the school Improvement team we do not have to make a motion you do have you request that yes you want the you want us to review because it involves workload it involves an a charge okay was there any other y we got shouldn't we make the motion first yes sure and then we can discuss okay so do I have a motion to open the district homework policy for review and send it back to Poli okay so moved do we have a second
132second second okay any more discussion on behalf of the school committee Caren just a quick question are you just looking for parent notification of missing assignments or are you actually looking at the amount of homework the type of homework well various grade levels like it District to District because I kind of started looking um but are you looking more for parent notification of missing assignments it's it seems so our homework policy the way it's currently written it seems to Encompass a lot of it seems very broad to me um and you know my my feeling on that is that if we you know if if some of the Educators can kind of you know like Linda and yourself they could kind of chip chip in and say you know this is things that work things
133that don't look at the other schools and see what they have you know I know that I looked through Baron's their homework policy and theirs is very detailed and it's very you know very specific the the it's outlined so that the expectations are very clear as far as what happens if you know a student is either missing work and then they have a list of steps on things that would be completed um so there's just a lot there where I felt like when I looked at our policy it was It was kind of just Broad and it encompassed all of the schools all of the you know the grade levels I just Gina I want to be careful because there is definitely a difference between policy and protocol there are many districts barington is one
134of them that will incorporate protocol into policy which is never recommended you want your policies to be larger in overview because now when a teacher wants to make a change for a parent or for a child they cannot if you put it in policy so you try to give the flexibilities uh in your protocol but the policy is a high level overview of the expectations and the philosophy of the district homework policy so you just want to be mind like for example like East grenage doesn't have a policy because they give the freedom back to the Educators to rep with the families and the students as an individual need it's in the handbook which is what we can do so you just want to be careful because no Providence got into this so they they've
135started to sift away from it because when when you have to change protocol It Means Committee action which will can hinder the way families want us to interact with them so you just want to be C that that we thoughtful but I don't think there's any any time it hasn't been reviewed in a while I think it's a good opportunity we should always be checking our policies so I think it it's fine and and I agree with it because I always think that that this is an opportunity for us I just want to make sure that um we're mindful of the protocol versus policy because it can get unwieldy if if you do it but I I do think we have excellent School Improvement teams which often give us great feedback and I think those
136that have been on the policy subcommittee when the administrators come in they're all you know I think it's we've had good conversations and dialogue Don I was just going to say exactly what you just said Gina um there's nothing wrong with reviewing as a member of the policy committee I think it's just a good idea to review policies and I would totally support this y thank you did did someone have their hand raised here Jess yeah I was going to mention um question um if a school Committee Member wanted to go to a Sit meeting where that was on the agenda that would be okay correct anybody so schoolov team meetings are open to the public um so you know some people get people from the public others have never but like I know Mr
137Z would have his little public section on the side and so those that wanted to come in um but they're always open they're posted on the website they're posted for the for the meeting times and dates um so anyone is always welcome to attend but they're not voting members unless they've been elected by their peer group okay I just want to make sure in case anybody wants to be part of that conversation as well thank you did someone have their hand raised Helen Helen Shan Richmond so I know a family where the child moved from one town to another town in the first town that child elementary school did have homework and in the second town the child did not have any homework and the family felt as if the child's performance engagement and their
138involvement even in the child's education was hampered so I would hope that for elementary school at least that the children should be having homework we want to improve our performance we we know of the of the top 40 countries we are number 40 so we need to do something to improve it educ and homework I think is part of how Improvement will happen thank you thank you Helen okay is there any uh are there any other comments from the school committee okay so we have uh we have a motion and a second um so all those in favor to open the district homework policy for review to compare the current policy to other high performing school districts I so it's unanimous but ply is somewhere else okay all right um thank you you thanks Laura
139thanks um request to discuss Hope Valley School play funding This was um oh that me this was put on the agenda uh put forward by Diane so um Diane I know that there's a long history of this that Gina would like to give you a little bit of a heads up on and to the whole school committee as well so Gina can you give us some background on this sure that's fine um so the request came about the the actual item was request you discuss hope rally School play funding so there is um Mr Jen is here so thank you for coming every year there are three elementary schools they have an allocation for their school specialty gets called that's a $22,000 allocation so just for those that may not know Ash's uh Theme School
140specialty is STEM Science technology engineering and Mathematics hope rallies is the Arts Charlestown is Outdoor Learning and Richmond is health and wellness so they each were allocated uh I want to say it started back in like 2016 2017 with superintendent Richie looking to really um highlight different schools in different ways to see if he could get people across town lines if you will um so the one in the 2017 2018 school year a Cho high school student in the Performing Arts uh program at CTC at the high school joined the ran Youth Theater to work on Performing Arts collaboration and to provide the work experience hours for high school students enrolled in that pathway in 2019 that Pro that program in partnership with the Rhode Island theater had this student project where one of our
141students wrote the script and the music for the um a play and then proposed uh to Hope Valley's principal that they do their work their Tech work their specialty work costumes designs Etc and they utilize Hope Valley students as a way to do the performance so it was a very Innovative partnership it was driven by a shared commitment of Excellence uh in performing arts and a desire to expand opportunities for young performers it was definitely a proposal that forced a love for theater and to provide students with the platform to Showcase their talents in elementary school so it was high school students Performing Arts Pathways that was utilizing our younger Learners to be able to um practice their work experience with that population so the viam youth theater was the Cornerstone of the states is
142the state's uh Cornerstone of Arts Community they offer professional Level Training performance experiences and they funded this so uh Chelsea cook was was absolutely free she gave her time and volunteered countless hours as did our humanities High School specialist sta Hall volunteer their time countless hours to be able to support the Performing Art CTE students in this uh Endeavor and then uh what happened as my understanding is recently past spring Miss Cook um no no longer works for the theater so that that partnership um ended and there was nobody left at the theater that could put in the hours or the time to be able to maintain that level of work currently our Performing Arts um pathway students there there's e influence with you know just like if you're a culinary student or you're welding
143you don't you don't necessarily ready for year four when you're starting so there are different levels and they don't have anybody necessarily ready for that commitment however Mr scan Pio has been actively working throughout the year um there has been no reach out from Hope Val personally from any educator looking to um run the program because you need a certified adult but I know Mr sco I think as recently as yesterday was meeting with his PTA president to figure out what we could do because stage rights things like that so he's been actively working on it even previous to the request but um what the the the larger conversation is how do you do this for a fee that you know we can afford because um I remember I think Mr Jen said well it's
144the whole thing cost about $8,000 and we don't have $88,000 to give to every school for school specialty um however because that the $6,000 cost was really that was the RH Island youth theater program that's what they put to took in what Mr jelli was able to do with his school specialty dollar is really the it paid for the police and fire it paid for the logistical kinds of information and all of the work actually came from the Performing Arts um pathway program and what we call um you may see in your budget every year Arts Alliance Arts Alliance um God Rest Your Soul barara kapalo was an advocate advocate for and some of the dollars we allocate through the Arts Alliance to um to all of our schools for the Arts um but including
145Hope Valley that was one other way that we also funded it um like I said Miss Hall dedicated hours for free as did Chelsea from the rod Island Arts Theater um but overall it was not it was never funded through Hope Valley so that the the difficulty didn't come with the transition of I just want to make sure with the administration it was really because of change in the Ral New Theater but they are acely working on a solution Mr skipo believes that they will be able to do play I don't know if it'll be at the level that we've been able to do with the theater but definitely something I think that the kids would be proud of um but that just that's the history happy to answer if I can and if not
146I can get an answer if you need one thank you Diane did you have any questions um and that is really why I put it on the agenda because I wanted because I had parents asking about of course saying why aren't we having this play what's going on this is an important part of their you know their progress and their education and their excitement about it you know because these kids do get excited about doing a play they're they're they're excited and you know so my concern was that it was just kind of being like e we're not really going to worry about it so I really wanted to be make sure that there was a focus on it and that that that the community and the children are being heard I mean because obviously
147I mean the school library thing going on now and every it's just kind of like we don't want to dishearten the children that are there still we want to give them the opportunities still to be able to do the play to be able to have their library to be able to enjoy the time they still have there while they do yeah I just want to make sure people realize this had nothing to do it was never in our operating budget this was all done through uh Partnerships and grants okay and I appreciate that because I was not aware of that you know and I didn't want to say oh you know this one dropped the ball or that one dropped the ball or whatever it was but the explanation for it is really what we
148needed sure thank you you're welcome thank you Craig did you have a comment yeah and I'd like to I'm glad you gave the explanation um I would like to at least acknowledge our employees because I mean think about it if this was another District they might have just let it drop to the Wayside you know money dried up the people moved on we're just but they're trying to keep it going so I mean they they didn't have to but they did and I know um Richmond uses a um oh what's I didn't she I think there there's a member of the public that wants to talk when you're finished Craig I have so um I'm sorry just what was the name what's the name of the I'm blinking out do you remember the Scrapbook the
149scrapbook so that's who Richman used it so they they had um I Know M Keno had reached out to m Martin earlier to see if there's something that they can do I know Miss Hall has been trying to see if we can use one of the plays that we did with the middle school earlier but again it's just you've got to find then someone who can do those three weeks in a row to prepare all of the children so and and there's a lot going on but uh I do appreciate everyone willingness to try and to do the best that they can Jess did you want to say something I was just the theater scrapbook is a free program but like Gina said you have to pay volunteers to be there with the kids after
150school you have to make sure the school is available and then when the play occurs you have to pay for police and fire to be there so there's a cost but not for the program not not a hard cost for the program but saw cost after that to employee folks thank you please come up to the microphone and state your name and the town where you where you reside thank you hi um I'm Anna Lewis I live in Hopkinton if I am mistaken uh someone can let me know I'm of the belief that I'm the one keeping the conversation of the play going at Hope Valley Elementary I'm of the belief that if I wasn't so up in arms about this it would get pushed to the Wayside like the librarian like all these other
151things those children who were here asking about the librarian yes there's all these talks to have a great program in the future but the reality is they're not going to get a librarian this year the high sea program that they've been looking forward to all this time isn't happening that's the issue of the library I want to apologize a a couple months ago I came to a school council meeting which also I want to let you guys know I'm a single mom it is really hard for me to come here it's really important and it's really hard but regardless um a couple months ago when I first heard through the grape vine I've been in touch with you miss peard and with uh Mr G about how communication has gone for Hope Valley parents um
152but I heard through the Great Vine that the play wasn't happening and that's something my son's been really looking forward to that's something that's a community building experience the like you were saying I believe your name is Laura um the effects that what's going on the confusion that's having on the community at Hope Valley Elementary School it's been detrimental to my family but it's it's it's casting a PA over everything nobody knows what's happening teachers are leaving programs that kids are looking forward to all year that they didn't get to do because they were too young they're not happening nobody's saying anything so I will admit and I apologize you guys deal with so many complicated things that I could ever even understand and you keep so much Mo so many moving Parts going for
153so many people in the district um and I thank you for that and when I heard that the play wasn't happening I was upset and I came here and I think you were guys were talking about something having to do with the Arts and I mentioned months ago like oh is this thing that you is there was some Arts funding and I questioned if that was for the Hope Valley Elementary thing that was the first time that we started talking about that I started talking to Chelsea vanir I started talking to Mr G I started talking to Mr s I'm not only a caring parent I'm also uh I have an early childhood educa a masters in early childhood education a undergrad in theater and I've taught theater I taught children uh theater ages 7
154to 17 for like many many years in New York and I have offered to to I've offered to do this and I'm the one who's been asking I'm the one who's been and I'm the one who told Mr s about theater scrapbook which I will go on the record to say I don't recommend them but they are free and honestly at this later date I really doubt that they are available the reality is like this school Year's going on and if we don't know what's going on I mean we're already because I've been waiting for Mr s to get back to me and and if he doesn't want to go with me and if he wants to go with theater scrapbook that's fine but the reality is is that you need at least three months
155to rehearse so you know I I don't know what's going on but the sense is I've been asking about the play I've been asking to to meet with people I've been requesting rights I've been doing this I don't feel and yes I'm talking feelings I don't feel as a parent of Hope Valley Elementary that anyone we have big issues in this District we have the concerns of the future but there's kids there right now and I don't know who's looking out for them thank you thank you thank you thank you for your cander yes sir Joe jley again I was the principal Hope Valley um but I you know Anna Lewis and I we had a lot of conversations I just wanted to put it into context a little bit the situation with Chelsea cook
156was every year we'd have something in in in ready to go in May May or June she left for Allan theater she wased supposed to sign up and be part of the list of to work in schools she never did that so we went through the summer she we kept on asking her are you did you do it not yet but my application's in come August we were communicating again still hasn't been on it wasn't on the list so like here we are we're stuck like what what are we going to do um it was it was difficult um it was hard because I didn't want listen I I live and breathe theater with the with these kids I'm building the sets I'm doing a lot Dana Hall thank god without her none of this
157would ever happen I turned what we used to do poetry out loud to what we have with with um with the drama club um so so it was the then the transition of me going to the middle school and all that and then just seemed like there was just everything was like bad timing so I I just wanted to at least give you that as well um I I'm willing to help however I talked to Chelsea this Chelsea Vander back here um any way I can do to help I'm I'm there I mean I would never not want these kids to experience that thank you so my question is um and it says request to discuss to discuss Hope Valley School play funding so I can I can discuss this because it's on the agenda
158um are there people ready and willing to go to organize a play if the funding were available yes would you like to come forward hi I'm Chelsea band um I'm the PTO president at Hope Valley uh and the Middle School um I've been trying to help any way that I can um figure out um how Hope Valley will have a play this year as you've heard it was quite costly um and it was it's been incredible um my son was a part of it who's now in eth grade going to the high school next year had been a part of it when he was at hope valy my daughter as well um and it's been a lot of back and forth um since the beginning of the year trying to you know figure out talking
159I've been talking with Mr G I was talking with Mr G after even he moved to the um the middle school and he was has still been trying to help I've been talking to Dana Hall I've been talking to the um principal at Hope valy as well um the new principal um it seems like we are starting to um I apologize I hate public speaking so my voice is shaky it's not easy um I think that we are starting to nail things down and and a timeline um we've been talking with theater scrapbook which um has been brought up um and Richmond um is has been using them as well and they are available um and um and I had uh offered to um I had offered to um to come in it's it's twice
160a week and the the program runs for8 to 10 weeks hope Val just so you know I think it was like four weeks it's like four weeks these kids rehearsed and put on like an amazing show um but I had offered to to come in um while uh while they're there and rehearse and um and then I had also reached out to um uh Rhode Island Youth Theater about costumes and um the uh was told that they would um depending on the the the play that we were doing um that they may be able to to donate the um the costumes for us to to rent for the show because the kids hope valy is is used to having some pretty um pretty great costumes as well um but just wanted to come up and
161just update that there has been a lot of of back and forth um between uh both the principls and and Dana Hall and um Trang duub trying to get it done this year thank you for sharing that yes we appreciate do you have a a budget like a line line item itemized budget for what it would cost to put this on um I I don't personally have that I have what Mr uh s and Mr G shared with me um I know that uh I believe and maybe miss you were the parent that that Mr SK said there was a parent willing to do it for a stien um position and then uh they were looking into the theater play work so he was waiting on that figure then there was a the license for
162the play which could be between 500 and 800 the fire the police the custodians um the let's see for the costums they were looking to get them donated and then he was um looking for the PTO to see if there's any support at that at that end and let's see uh last year it cost $700 for the fire police and the custodian So based on the donations you know it could range anywhere and um depending on what the savings would be and what we could get donated it could be up to 6,000 but we're trying to whittle it down so is there is there anything that um the PTO would be willing to um dedicate to this if we can find maybe some matching funding um I I'm at at this moment I'm not I'm
163not completely sure that amount I don't think that we would be able to do our um yeah and I know Miss Hall had said they're trying they she has a lot of connections too and she's been working on this as well know and I think that's what she was concerned about that that I think there was and this is where rumors and gossip don't help and you know when people put put it's hard because there was a lot of people behind the scenes that you know feel really bad that even the high school students because they're not necessarily able to do the same level of work um and it it's like the perfect stum so you can't plan it but it has had nothing to do with hope Valley's phase out um and the librarian
164has nothing just like the librarian we we we're down three Librarians it's it's hard so I I do appreciate that when people come together and work together we can get things to accomplished money doesn't fall from the sky I've been told that a lot right so we're doing the best and I and I know that Miss Hall uh Mr s Mr G and Miss Le thank you for your uh continued cooperation to be able to do this for our kids so thank you thank you Laura and Polly um so I'm just wondering I mean what from from our side what can we do to assist so the operating budget provides the $2,000 for the logistical stuff so I I I don't have I mean unless you go to the fund balance which is typically only
165done for emergencies well already do is it within our purview too and this is just you know I have no idea if this is actually even possible but can there's tons of ways to be able to to raise money or you know see if there would be I mean I know that there's some companies that are local that would be willing to you know make a donation M Keno I think once they know like what once they' sort of nailed down which play which costoms and what they can get donated that will be closer to our figure so uh ply and then Mr G okay so what I'm hearing is we there's a lot of balls up in the air currently and maybe if we put this on the agenda for the next regular school
166committee meeting we can find out how some of those balls landed at that point and see if there's anything we could help with at that so would you be able sorry would you be able to turn around a play if we were to help you um fundraise or find the money well I the pl my understanding is according to Mrs Cano that that's the goal the the play is the goal that that they're they have their um they're still planning but they believe that they can they can pull it off I'm not sure um you want again yes you bring attention to it but just remember when when you allocate funding that you don't have from an emergency fund for emergencies then everybody will expect it for all because all your school Specialties you gave
167$2,000 across all all schools so that's where the funding comes and my understanding from Mr s is that I think you allow them to plan before we say anything specific because that's where I mean they know what's happening I would and like I say I get my information from the schools so you want to be careful because that's who's running the schools so just to clarify there is a $2,000 allocation in this fiscal year from a specialty budget for this play not for the for arts for the theme School specialty and have you expended the full $2,000 that you know of Mr G is the middle school I know you when iy by the time I left we hadn't used a penny of it but I just I just wanted to come up and just
168let you know I just got a message from um Scott Thunderland I'm just being told it has not been spent yeah Mr s has it okay but I just got a message from Scott suland from SNS Landscaping who wants to donate $2,000 toward wonderful thank you Scott sundland um and we also thank you okay so that's 4,000 we're close well you know I can say that you know our company will donate another 2,000 there we go there's 6,000 done I will make a personal donation and I will help fund raise for the rest so thank you everyone make sure Angela gets it for the shout outs going forward is there any way we can apply for Grants to cover this in the future so so we do get grants but when when you're doing something
169like this you do need one of the teachers um for the grants that we pursue has to have a certified teacher attached for the work um so yes but I explain that to uh the chair no one had the principal was working on it but again they were all of the planning that I sat down and I met with Mr G Miss Hall and Mr s like it takes time because all you lost a lot of the core people that helped with the work like you had the high school that was doing a lot of the lift around um training and going in and and actually meeting the kids there you had Chelsea cook who was putting all the hours in to get all that preparation so I do think that um we're going to
170be fine based on what I just heard from Kathy Mr s just texted me everyone's watching we'll get it done go ahead someone said Grant I did apply for a grant with Risa which would on school council of Arts um it got denied so Katie kosan and I put it together uh we sented it last spring and I got denied that was always trying the team is I mean I say if there's money out there we're going to find it sometimes they say no Anna um I am very heartened to hear that we as a community can talk about the needs of the students and come together and that people are coming up with funding for the play this is I think kind of what we're wanting to be doing here I didn't mean to
171be overly emotional and over sweep and talking about the library and this and that I'm just saying the play is just one thing nobody intended for the children at Hope Valley Elementary to get the short shrift in a bunch of things but nobody really know Mr G left and I'm sure that there are other things in all this transition and I just want to make sure that there's somebody paying attention that the kids who are still there for long they are there are getting the same quality of Education that the other students in the district are getting that their siblings who went there before got and that they've been waiting and looking forward to get that is my hope I'm so glad that we were able to come to forward to do that for the
172play I'm hoping that Joselyn and Dylan can find something with the library and I'm sure there's a thousand other things that I don't even know about thank you thank you Anna okay so um do we need a do we need a motion to no okay that was the discussion okay thank you very much for bringing that to our attention and um to the PTO president thank you so much for coming and speaking we appreciate that budget transfers SL update I recommend the budget transfers as submitted so so Mo second J was first he'll be the second you can you can always figure my white voice so um any discussion all in favor of the budget transfers it is unanimous thank you okay uh item nine consent agenda items um is there anything on the consent
173agenda items that needs to be excuse me that needs to be pulled I think we need to remove D yes D1 yep yeah so do I do I need a motion to remove it no we'll just vote against it maybe so we pull it and then we pull can I just I just want to clarify something so in your packets there was a memo from Mr zenan for um the recover payment for the Medicare claims it should be placed in the consent agenda but I think where was it found Mr Zan it was in business section so we just want to make sure that if you didn't catch it that you caught it so that when you do the consent that understand that's where it was supposed to be so um I can read medicare
174payment yes thank you so I can read it if you want okay please so um the memo says uh before my start date Cho signed into a contract with relay Hub LLC to help recover payment on Medicare claims the contract calls for Cho to pay 4.5% of all Medicare payments to relay Hub I am estimating receiving $400,000 of Medicare claims for fy2 in order to pay these fees I am requesting permission to transfer 188 ,000 from the fund balance to a fees account if the district receives more than $400,000 in claims I will need to make another request to transfer money please also note that we did not budget for these fees for FY 26 so a similar request will need to be made for next year's FY 26 budget just want to make sure
175that you didn't see that you saw it in the correct place so sorry that can't be updated in the 26 budget is that what you're saying no we have to do it for both we need it for this year yep for fy2 so that that that actions in for the consent and then when we do the budget we have to allocate money for next year as well in that for the Medicare right I guess what I was asking was is he to avoid having to submit this again wouldn't it make sense to put it in the 26 budget or make an adjustment to it yes the budget's yours now okay that's why that's included he's just giving you the heads up that your next meeting you're G to have to address it thanks okay so
176do we need to make a motion to accept that as part of the consent agenda items or it it would be listed under um it would fall under the is it permission to let's see it's in budget transfers budget no actually it should be in the budget transfer update just that's where we just approved so it's good is that one as long as it was in the right place Mr Z thought maybe it was not Madam clerk was it in the right place okay okay so I think we're good we're good try to be transparent make sure that nothing gets by okay very good okay so getting back to the consent agenda items so um was there a request to pull or remove um consent agenda item D you should pull it and then we
177vote it down okay okay so is there a request or is like what's the procedure or do we just pull it because we already voted against so that nothing happen so that that did say um right on there if if if it's approved if it's not approved then it doesn't have to be pulled it's move it's Ave Point okay great okay yeah we can still officially remove it though okay okay um Madam chair I make a motion to to pull D1 second thank you okay so we have a motion in a second any discussion on that all those in favor of pulling D1 it is unanimous okay um so do I have a motion to move the remainder of the consent agenda items now you ask anybody what do they want to pull anything okay
178does anybody else want to pull anything else from consent agenda items okay so Madam chair chair at this time I make a motion to approve the remainder but before I do I will acknowledge the donations one the Wesley Elks donate dictionaries to Richmond Hope Valley and ashway Elementary School students two Hope Valley Elementary School also received a bag of school supplies and assorted snacks from reichan three thank you to Vanessa and Patrick Freel love for their time spent creating more active spaces behind the Charleston Elementary School since the fall of 24 they have created a Gaga pit I have no clue what that is it is turf soccer field and an active play area of PVC pipes the supplies were used to part were sorry the supplies used were part of a Home Depot Grant
179secured by a Charleston PTO and number four Raymond Cormier of Hope Valley Rhode Island to donating a batting cage to the high school baseball team now I need a second second okay all those in favor unanimous okay now getting back to D1 um we pulled it to eliminate it yeah okay so so so you P it so M Madam chair I make a motion to eliminate D1 okay do I have a second second Donna seconded um all in favor unanimous thank you okay reports subcommittee reports minutes from the let okay um minutes from the chairo finance committee meeting are posted in your agenda um we had the cherot tech openhouse was aound resounding success we welcomed hundred of visitors eager to explore our Career and Technical education programs students families and community members had the
180opportunity to see firsthand the Innovative learning experiences our programs offer as we wrap up the first round of CTE applications this week we are excited to begin the selection of the next generation of students into these exceptional programs we have uh sent out to our families our survey Works um please know your voice matters it's an important opportunity for our families to share their thoughts and help shape the future of our schools this survey provides valuable feedback for our school Improvement teams as they refine their school plans we encourage All Families to participate as their voice helps Drive meaningful change if there is a question you prefer not to answer you can simply skip it the survey link is made available online in our February e update that was emailed and it's placed on our
181website and it has been shared by all our principles we have our annual District public budget hearing on March 5th as the chair already mentioned we hope that you will bring friends with you to attend as we need 25 registered voters from every town at the CMS oratorium on March 4th if whether is a concern we will hold the meeting on Wednesday March 5th at the same time in location we are preparing for artisty a lot of conversations about Arts uh our celebration of creativity and Innovation please off your calendars for Friday April 4th and Saturday April 5th we kick off Friday April 4th at the CMS Auditorium with our High School chorus and then on Saturday our draws open at 9:00 a.m. for the full artisty experience which will be celebrating our music Performing
182Arts Visual Arts and Industry arts in addition to that we hold stemfest which will showcase the excitement of science technology engineering and Mathematics with Hands-On activities and demonstrations this is a must attend event for families and community members celebrating the incredible talents and achievements of all of our students in Cho we hope to see you there and we hope you noticed our website updates enhancing our experiences Our IT team has been hard at work improving the district website to make it user friendly and accessible you may have already noticed some of those immediate changes designed to improve ease of ease of use and these updates will continue to enhance navigation ensuring that fam students and staff can quickly find the information they need thank you to our wonderful IT staff Gina can I add something
183the Apper request form in there that came out beautifully and I just ER I wrote that down on my notes because that is so user friendly and it's really well set up so thanks thank you thank you for updating the website okay um school committee requests for future agenda items or legal opinions Donna um I would like to put on and I don't know how this would end up but uh a discussion of transparency that is has been requested tonight and I also know that some Comm um some school committee candidates use that as part of their platform to encourage School transparency and quite honestly I'm puzzled by it because I think there is enough transparency I don't know specifically what is requested that is not being provided in the information either through the website
184or with a phone call or any other thing so I would like to um have a discussion or PR presentation as to what can be shared to be transparent and what really can't be shared so yes can you just give me an example of what you think can be shared and what you think can be shared sure the gentleman tonight talk about that later right excuse me well I don't think it's appropriate to go into a conversation right now that's right that's right I am requesting a discussion of transparency and afterwards I I'll be more than happy to thank you Donna suggest that yeah so as per the policy if you have an agenda item request please email it to the district clerk and copy me on it please and on the subject line put
185future agenda items so we we know what the subject is thank you so much any other agenda items Jess ply Jess I'd like to request um a discussion of a resolution to support House Bill 5204 that's the one that I mentioned it would expand School District's flexibility in selecting Transportation providers for regional transportation and I will of course send that to you to Angela and CCU thank you thanks Polly hi I had a few policies that I wanted to pull for the policy subcommittee to look at um do you do you want me to just email them to you I'll also State them the library the library media policy videography photography and audio recording policy um the automated callout system policy transportation policy Title 9 I know there's going to be some changes um so
186we'll have to uh get on board with federal and state changes to that and that will have to be pulled anyways um policy for face masks and face coverings for covid-19 and the gender non-conforming and transgender students policies okay thank you if you can put all of that to an email to um the district clerk and myself thank you so I had two um we in our materials we had some resolutions and things regarding the Cho Cowboys and cheerleading organizations use of the Cho High School football field for five home games um so I would like to put that on a future agenda item to discuss because I think when we get correspondents and things like that from the community we should discuss that and second ly um there was conversations tonight about the Hope
187Valley librarian and the high sea program and um you know there's a lot of uncertainty around you know what's going to happen with hope hope Valley Elementary School hopefully there'll be some sort of a resolution by by March 11th um I don't know what we can do about that but I I hear you and I want you to know that I'm acknowledging that I'm hearing you and um I would like to put that on a future agenda item whether could be a librarian I don't know but I do think that we should talk about it and see if we can strategize around you know coming to some sort of a forward um you know positive resolution to that thank you anything else do I have a motion to adjourn so moved do I have a
188second all those in favor unanimous thank you everyone have a great