001e for for e flag the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible and justice for please be seated good evening everyone hope you had a great day um we have our agenda tonight uh has to do with budget transfers so I will ask the superintendent to discuss that and then we will head into our budget Workshop thank you all for coming this evening so the budget transfer request tonight is to proceed with the well compliance uh it came in the State uh informed us that the amount was more uh than anticipated and in order to ensure that we have the wells cleaned prior to for the students obviously we need to be able to run the water and to have this done during February vacation we
002needed to put it in front of you tonight so I ask approval for the uh the well cleanings to be able to moove the transfer so we have the appropriate funding so move second any discussion all in favor uh Pat what does that entail so both the high school and middle school have 2,000 gallon tanks that the um the wells pump into um the tanks are required to be cleaned and the state gave us a mandate to clean them um and they want it done as soon as possible Right any other discussion all in favor unanimous thank you okay um so I item three on our agenda is the budget workshop and before we talk about um the budget I just had a few quick comments um as we head into this process so if
003you would indulge me for just a few minutes um good evening school committee members members of the administration and the general public tonight is our budget Workshop discussion and I'm looking forward to a productive and respectful exchange last Friday I had the opportunity to meet with superintendent peard assist assistant superintendent M Mr zenan the Director of Finance administration Lynn gven from the finance office and Jerry oth the director of Cho Tech the purpose of the meeting was to learn more about the realities of the fiscal year 26 budget and to put myself in a better position to be able to weigh in on our discussion tonight and to be a thoughtful partner in future budget conversations I want to thank the superintendent and her team for putting together this budget and for presenting it to
004our committee and to the community last week I realize this process takes an inordinate amount of time and we all deeply appreciate your efforts so thank you in the past I've paid a lot of attention to this process trying to digest and absorb the varying moving parts of the budget a budget today that represents about a $70 million price as school committee members we have an awesome responsibility to be the stewards of the taxpayers investment and stewards of other state and federal resources when a budget is put together we have to be mindful that this process is not just numbers on paper a budget reflects our strategic priorities our commitment to programs our commitment to Educators our commitment to staff our commitment to the district's students and parents a budget should also Drive our investment
005into academic Excellence with that being said when I met with the superintendent and her team last week I emphasized my position that this budget should reflect our Collective commitment to academic Excellence during the campaign there was a question posed to me during a forum relative to budget cuts to which I replied that we have to be mindful of what our local taxpayers could bear but I also want on to say that in the future when we're evaluating budgets we also needed a mindset shift we've been hyperfocused on Cuts but we also need to shift and be mindful of investing in academic Excellence to be the best and investing in programs that also support Revenue generation I asked the superintendent and her team are you empowered to think outside the box has the school committee empowered
006you to think about the big picture and highlevel outcomes do your budgets reflect those values we are so focused on cuts and yes while I believe there are some room for adjustments or perhaps redirection of resources in the fiscal year 26 budget there must also be room for us as a committee to have highlevel conversations to ensure that our school district is the best during our meeting I asked Mr oth the director of Charo Tech questions about his program and how we could potentially support an expansion of Charo Tech as you see in our budget materials Charo Tech brings in over $3 million of Revenue driven by outof District students we should challenge ourselves to find a creative and thoughtful way to expand our outof district enrollment to drive additional revenue for Charo Tech while
007obviously prioritizing our IND District students in addition I asked the administration about the possibility of keeping fifth graders in the elementary schools as a way to drive academic excellence and drive better outcomes in math and reading when you look at our test scores from fourth to fifth grade there is a significant drop in math and reading as a school committee we should be asking ourselves what can and should we be doing differently perhaps to support better outcomes fifth grade is the pipeline to middle school life a time that can be challenging for students both academically and development mentally in my opinion we as a committee should be working collaboratively with the administration to think outside the box to affect better outcomes for our Middle School years our middle school students our elementary schools are among
008the best in Rhode Island and we should celebrate that why not support fifth graders by retaining them in an elementary setting helping them to better Bridge toward a future in the Middle School keeping fifth graders in an El Elementary School setting would be a significant change but sometimes change is good sometimes change is even great I realize this potential change would impact our Capital Improvement planning but if we are truly committed to academic Excellence isn't this perhaps a change worthy of our consideration and with that I look forward to a productive discussion this evening thank you for listening so we have the fiscal year 26 budget in front of us we had some recommendations last week from our Omnibus meeting and thank you to the elected officials um and uh those who participated in last
009week's um budget uh Omnibus Workshop if you will and tonight is our opportunity to talk as a committee um about the fiscal year 26 budget so I will open it up at this point Jess I'm just curious um because you're speaking of the meeting that you had with this team does Gina have any response that you'd like to share I know the the fifth grade idea has been floated for a long time it was something that I brought up during the capital Improvement plan about the new schools um I was told that if you move the children back to fifth grade to the elementary schools then you have a a vacant space at the middle school um so I just want to make sure sure that some of the things you said um Gina could
010have a chance to respond if she thought that was appropriate or she thought that it was um pertinent to our conversation tonight absolutely of course so um yes Jess prel uh was definitely assum you know um even as a parent had talked to uh and many parents brought it up about the fifth grade the school building authority and the and the laws in the Rhode Island had changed in 2019 so there are different requirements when you're handling facilities uh the school committee no longer can just say I want to move this grade here and move that grade there there has to be a stage two application and a stage one application that shows how you're going to then utilize the space in the um in the Charo middle school as well as how you're going
011to address the facility needs for the elementary schools that are almost 100 years old because they can't adequately address the needs of the education even with our current uh students so and this is conversation I'm I'm more than happy if uh if there is a lack of trust of people of what I say I'm more than happy to ask ride to do a special session on a weekend or a night where they can inform you how that process would work it wouldn't entail you know more dollars into the budget regarding stage one and stage two because you have to put together an architect uh schematic in a rendering of how that would look how you would move the population so and you can only do that twice a year September M and February so I
012shared the same thing that I shared with Miss purcel a few years ago I shared that uh with Miss denmore uh while I think um just so everybody knows I also explained that over half the middle schools in the state are five to are five to eight and Dr cila actually shared data with uh and you've all seen the same data the data with uh miss tinmo that actually shows some of the different improvements I'm sure um we can probably share that again for reminders about act our Middle School overall there is no Middle School that's going to show large we have it's a different type of time of learning and our adolesence uh the brain I'm sure if you're like me a nerd about the brain and executive functioning they're uh still frontal lobe
013and they're doing things when they say to you I don't know why I did that oftentimes it's true because um they're still you know growing and maturing in that age however with that being said you know I we've heard that um well it should fifth graders be on the bus with senior most seniors don't ride the bus most Juniors don't ride the bus so we had those kinds of conversations and actually if you've been to tro Middle School you know that our kids do not matriculate with each other so the grade five stays in the grade five Hall the grade six stays in the grade six Hall the grade seven stays in the grade seven Hall the great eight stays in the great eight Hall they do not merge in between uh the lunches are
014separated so um this I I want to say the fifth grade's been it's been quite a while Mr Z would know better than I would know as the Middle School principal but but uh it's a seamless transition it's often harder sometimes for the parents to be able to have that adjustment of transition uh no different than when they go to high school it's always hard to sort of see your babies start to grow up and worry about the big fish in the Little Pond and the little fish in the big pond um but they do really well and I think if you talked and actually even if we ask some of our fifth graders to come to talk about that transition it may be helpful information for the school committee to have because they they
015sincerely do enjoy their time um but overall there's a there's a lot to discuss regarding that it's it's not a quick it definitely it couldn't happen in FY 26 but uh conversations would have to happen uh first if you wanted to do that you'd have to increase the budget so I'm not sure that's something because You' have to show different plans and if we add that we can add that to the elementary planning but it would have to now include the middle school where you'd have to then show how you plan on using using the middle school so the budget that we have currently would have to then um be modified based on the architecture so I think it's like a little over 1 million to do the renovation and or new construction our renovation
016plan will not um be able to to to meet the needs of our grade five going back into the elementary schools that that's not possible um but you could create a stage two application for the elementary including grade five but you'd have to increase the cost of the engineering and architecture because ride will require the renderings and uh they would require a a a detail analysis so um on how you were planning on doing that as well as the fact that the district has spent five years debating this and you this is the fifth time the school committee has not had an approved Capital Improvement plan because um they continued to be either one was rejected the current one and recently they've been pulled because of lack of um community support and I went through
017the president presentation and that's been going on since 1975 so there's a long history of no support in the elementary schools and our parents largest complaint is that we focus more on Main Campus than we do on the elementary schools and our elementary schools are failing so that's you know basically adjust okay thank you for that update Laura thank you so I I just want to kind of piggyback on a couple of different things um as far as what Louis has said about the you know the big picture type of view on how we address the financials because the the cost of everything is going to continue to rise I think everybody's well aware of that and when I when I look at the implications that are associated with having fifth graders in middle school
018so just little history my daughter goes to chero she's been in the elementary school I just want to caution for the OM that we can talk about the building plan stage one and stage two but we want to avoid the fact that this is a budget Workshop so we just really need to be careful because we have already four to five or complaints so just I would focus on your conversation on the budget piece that's what I'm doing okay so with that being said so my daughter she went through the middle school to the high school and I think that there's and and just again just being involved with all of the parents students things like that there's a lot of feedback that comes from the students once they get into high school and how
019they feel about things in retrospect um and I think that that would be valuable information for the committee the impact that that has on on the financials if you look longer term so chaho Middle School we have two deans currently at our school there's from from the data that's posted on ride there it appears that there's very few middle schools that have two deans on staff and that's you know that's all available on their website um and I think that when we start looking at the the costs you know the the the implied costs of having you know 10 and 11 year olds moving into the high school or I'm sorry into the middle school in fifth grade there's a there's a stage of development that happens the concrete development goes until about fifth grade
020and and you can you know you can kind of see these these hidden costs is what I would call whether you know having to do with mental health requiring more guidance counselors on staff having two deans two disciplinary Deans um you know all these different things and I don't see how with the Mental Health crisis that is going on in our country it's it's very real what our kids are going through and you know pushing them into middle school with all of the other signs that we are seeing as as a community and as a society I think that there can be long-term cost savings when it comes to the budget if we start discussing a sort of bigger picture look at okay well if we did move the fifth graders back into the elementary
021schools and there's a lot of Parental support around this a lot of community community support um you know what would that look like and what would be the long-term impact because I think that it's that from a fiscal standpoint it makes sense if we can come up with a you know a stage two application that we can address this this type of thing you know I I firmly believe if you compare our schools to other schools in Rhode Island that you would start to see a decrease in some of the other additional services that have been added on to our budget from you know over these last however many years since the kids have been in the middle schools I believe it was in the early 90s that that decision was made um so that's
022just my my take on it that's my recommendation I think as a committee we should all work together to try to get our heads wrapped around this and figure out a way that we can solve this problem because I I truly believe that you know having our fifth graders on on buses with high schoolers you know regardless of whether they're seniors Juniors sophomores it's a entirely different environment and it kind of it has implications that I think are very far-reaching so so just to clarify um that's the reason why you don't see two deans is because they use administrators um one administrator per 200 students and it's a much higher cost to hire an administrator than to utilize a Dean as your educational liaison I can tell you I would never put the safety of
023our students at risk and I can also tell you that um both Deans if you remove if you requ you should never request to cut a position honestly you should request dollars in an area because that's why you hire me to be able to make sure that I can do the Strategic plan in a time where school shootings at a time where parents are worried about harassment bullying and the things that come along with middle school I would never recommend and the removal of a d uh so I'm just going to say that because I do think you will infringe upon the safety of our students and our staff if you look at um any one teacher if one teacher and if you want academic Excellence then you have to ask yourselves what do you
024expect your principal and assistant principal doing because right now they can be focused on teaching and learning and instruction you're going to now you you want us to do more and then you're saying we moove the dean so every discipline referral that comes to the office is now handled by the administ ministration who is now no longer in a classroom monitoring instruction they're taking care of referral so again this is where when I appreciate the chair Den Moore stated about the uh collaborating with us you know myself Mr zenan Dr Cela the administrators the teachers the education work that we do you if if there's a lack of trust in us to be able to understand how to put those pieces together it's going to be problematic for the district but the number one goal
025should be students and the number one goal should be the fact that Safety and Security and teaching and learning are number one priorities and I won't infringe on either and I think the budget that I presented you is less than inflation and it is my recommendation to move the district forward but I um I I would I'm not a proponent of um infringing on children's safety I just want to say if you don't mind I don't think that there's a lack of trust I just wanted to make sure that my intention in in meeting with the team was I just want to make sure that you feel that you're empowered to think you know outside the box to bring to move Cho forward and that that was my intention in with the meeting and to
026educate myself about the budget process and you know as a oh yeah no I wasn't referring I understand but as somebody that's been on the opposite end of the of the table over the last three years I just wanted to make sure that you felt um supported you and your team felt supported in um doing what you felt that you needed to do to move the district forward and while balance ing the the realities of you know our economy and you know our taxpayers so um so I just I just wanted to make that statement okay so Aura Linda Laura and then Karen Linda thank you chair um I just I just want some clarification um from the comments that Miss Chapman made I guess I'm a little confused because um I think that I
027believe that we need to look at being fiscally responsible and I'm not against looking at moving the fifth graders I'm one of the proponents that wanted to move the fifth talk in conversation why don't we move the fifth graders back to elementary school but I'm not sure if that's something we want to get into the weeds for this budget I think it's something that maybe I'd be happy to be on some sort of you know committee that looks at that moving forward um I don't know if there'll be cost efficiencies um I but I I'm not against it I would support looking at it but I'm not sure we want to get into the weeds right now now in this particular budget so there's not much we can do about it and it will cost
028us some money so I think we have to be cognizant of that too that you know and sometimes you need to invest money to you know to get what you want out of out of uh something but at the same time I think we have to you know be fiscally you know sound and responsible thank you Linda thank you Laura and then Karen uh thank you the um I agree I think Karen should go before Laura to be honest sorry point of order um I just think Karen hasn't spoken yet and Laura has spoken so if we're trying to let people have a chance to speak sure go ahead yeah so my question is this would be an increase to the budget with a stage one and a stage two application to develop a plan
029to possibly move the fifth grade back what's the goal for that space that you're going to create at the middle school for me I would rely on the um the superintendent to give us guidance on that but I asked if there m chair point of order on me point point of order it all shuts down you got to answer this is this in this budget is moving the fifth grade back to the elementary schools part of this budget we're getting in the weeds no it's not so we should not be discussing it it should be part of a future agenda item great and I appreciate the point of order and I would just ask that our conversations be respectful and we just need to be you know cognizant of of being respectful and our tone
030okay now now you have to rule on the point of order do you are you going to P this to go forward are you going to continue with the discussion I accept the point of order and we could certainly move forward with the further discussion on the fiscal year 26 line items Ken so my question I guess is are we looking to increase the line item for Capital to create a stage one and a stage to plan well I certainly think that that's open for discussion for I you know I'm one vote of 12 people so if the full committee is willing to have that discussion and entertain that um you know I think we should talk about it this this is a budget Workshop so we should be talking about you know the what
031the future of our district looks like in a budget Workshop but if it if if we need to consider resources in fiscal year 26 this is what a budget Workshop is is about is what our fiscal year 26 budget looks like okay Donna yeah I'm going to bring this back to the budget I would like to suggest not necessarily tonight but I would like to suggest considering increasing the fund B balance in light of the fact of the news from today and the fact that we have received $3 million this budget ref refs $3 million in Grants now I don't know how much of that is federal grants but it's quite possible that we would get zero amount of money in future budgets for Grants and those that grant money funds some very important things
032mental health particularly um some of our programs so I would like to see um a consideration of increasing the fund budget balance the fund balance okay um Greg you might be able to work on that a little bit it was recommended by the Auditors that we increase it and I'd like to consider that thank you so for every um right now we have the fund balance at 2.25% if you were raise it to 2.5% um it would you would have to add an additional approximately additional $160,400 raise it to 2.75 you would have to double that number and so on and so on and I would like to recommend considering that so that we do not jeopardize some of the programs that have been established through the grant money that we've received through Katie's wonderful
033work so anyway I'd like to recommend that anyone else are we ready to get into the we weeds for fiscal year 26 I just I welcome Laura to speak I wasn't trying to cut her off from speaking I just wanted to make sure that other folks got to speak before so if she want I don't want to make sure that she knows that okay hly I'm not sure it will come up in this um but I had mentioned to you that when sh had brought up that we spent $6,000 on trophies I kind of it doesn't bother me but we have beautiful 3D printers in the Drafting and design um room which I think a student could use those if if they were so inclined to work with the drafting teacher and make some really
034cool trophies at least put a little dent in that and work with a graphic design student and they could they might be able to do a a really neat project so I explained that to M those are not for athletics so that you would have to cut National Junior Honor Society National Honor Society those are those Awards and those are two programs of academic Excellence that you will have students who want to leave the high school but if this committee would like to remove the National Honor Society and National Junior Honor Society because that comes with a specific chapter and that's not something we can't take the those not what she brought up the topic but I was on a whole different topic entirely but that's that's the that's the that that just made me
035think of the trophies and you know I understand what you're saying they're two different things but this might help in that department we utilize it whenever we can yeah and um I there's some really cool designs out there and I think some kids could have fun working with the graphic design Department back and forth maybe an independent I me our students to do things on different scales but large scales especially um if it's Athletics you're talking about the boosters often do help with that that's off offet but the line item that Sharon Davis brought up was it's the National Honor Society National Junior Honor Society those organizations you cannot steal those logos and and utilize them on your own you have to do the um you have to abide by the law Laura so um
036I have several questions directed for Greg please um the I was when I'm looking at the at so so just kind of explain this so I took the the 56-page budget that we were given at the initial budget presentation um that's available online for the public to view as well um and that was provided in Excel format and so I essentially took that spreadsheet and exported everything and sort of created my own set of books in a sense um with each each individual location with that being said um I'm trying to to figure out one of the pieces that was missing from at least from the data that I have Greg is the benefits packages can you explain how those are being allocated and how they they end up into each individual salary and which
037code that they go to because you have you have it's the the way that the Yuka codes are set up it's you know there's a a code that's listed for each indiv ual school and then there's a code that talks about the that's for the program that's being identified then there's another set of numbers so it's a massive string of numbers um but each one has an individual function if I'm understanding your question correctly when you look at an employee you have their salary then you have their health care then you have um what we pay into the pension um so and that is broken down into two different line items so you for each employee you have four five or six lines if they work in one building for every building they work in
038you have to double or triple those lines so if you have an employee that works in three buildings every single time you pay them you have to pay them what percentage they're in that building then that percentage of their benefit package gets broken up into it and then it's spread out so when you're C the codes require us to try to break it down to show how much each school is spending eventually the state says they'll be able to compare apples to apples they're not there yet actually this is something that um if you remember Santiago Guerrero he discussed and you can actually go to the financial dashboard to sort of manipulate that information um often times it helps us under if we understand the why behind the question like what what are you hoping
039to see it helps us figure out because um obviously all the salaries there's the Family Healthcare then there's the independent Healthcare there's retirement there's pension there's Fringe um uh that that went up last year so there's Social Security uh as well in the district so um but to Greg's point I understand you took it and and you created your own books but we have to present it to ride by school code and just for the fun of it and my Yuka gurus L gin they they update the uoa every year so for example just an easy one for this year the multilanguage learner uoa code is new this year because it's part of the funding formula that didn't exist last year so if you looked at last year's budget to this year's budget it looks
040like there was nothing because there wasn't because it didn't exist so now you're going to have money there just like if you looked at your computer uh line and you one a question that you know Miss Densmore had as well as miss purcel that reached out was it looked like the tech um purchases went up the tech purchases went up because we're no longer leasing because it cost too much and the lease number went down so asking us questions by line on them I think one helps understand uh so that everyone understands why those things are happening because that we can talk about it but also if we understand what is hoping to accomplish we could probably have a more productive conversation because um not everybody here's accountant so I get that and we don't
041all live in the financial world so uh it's often helpful to sort of think through like you know what this data will help us do what and then we can probably help assist okay so oh go ahead so what I'm what I'm specifically referring to is at the on the 56 page budget that we have all of the benefits which I think is around 17 million roughly for 2026 those I cannot um I was referring to the 56 page budget that we were given and section I'm not sure which SE which section it is it's so this is one of the reasons why if you go back to previous minutes for the dfm superintendent Richie never allowed the Excel document to go out I do but I did say to miss chapen and I said
042anyone who have requested it that we will not use anything that's not in the budget package so I do need you to refer to the budget package for the purpose of the public transparency and the committee that doesn't have what you created Laura if on the on this one page this personal the employee benefits is 16,1 126 maybe that's what you were thinking for 2026 what page is that no the on the it's on this page it's on the first page yeah on the first I'll find exactly which page it is and then I'll tell you to go to I'll resend in the meantime okay so I'm going to ask a question about some line items and forgive me if I'm repeating um can you tell us what section absolutely I'm in section three y
043page three line items 4816 and 4820 purchasing Services conference Workshop Elementary purchasing service conference Workshop middle school so if you look at um just for the purposes of the public if you look at fiscal year 23 to fiscal year 26 what's proposed there was an increase from roughly $ 35,700 to almost 74,000 um and so I'll take that line item first so that's the your Co Cod change with the MLL conferences now have to be included in that specific line item versus an older line item so with the MLL conferences those are now coded differently uh per Yuka and it's it should be separated out into different professional development and it also includes the science professional development required for next year so this was in another line item before and the MLL conferences yes but
044the science is uh we didn't have science PD last year this is um for this new science different grades go different years so this is an an increase in the number of grades that have to do their science PD okay and that's the same for the middle school as well that the middle school is the same thing it's their it's their science okay professional devel and superintendent Bard is that the same um reasoning for line item 4835 no 4 well 4835 is contractual uh for the computer tech and uh cyber security okay so just for purposes of the public um there it doesn't look like there was a a line item for that in fiscal year 23 and proposed for fiscal year 26 it's $7,500 yep so there are some times where the TCH uh
045the like uh our finance uh computer director uh data analysis and our uh computer administrators don't utilize it but sometimes it's contractual so they have the if they don't utilize it that they uh sometimes it's what's available they may already know it but for um but now with the cyber security concerns that have been going on it there was an increase for next year okay I have a few others unless somebody other folks I don't want to I have a number of line item questions Pat I want to stay in the same section and go to line item 596 salary development officer section three did you say I'm sorry same same section we're making it easier so we're not flipping back and forth all over the place and uh $6.99 salary overtime so I'd like
046to go over what those are specifically what was the first number you said it was 596 salary development officer salary development yeah that's what it says y oh oh um that's the that's uh Katie kakosian the director of development sustainability she was paid uh through grants at the beginning and then we weaved her into the operating budget all right she brought in $3.3 million this year alone all right and the other one is um is $699 salary over time I think I believe $66.99 is the custodial because it was in purchasing contracts and now um actually we're down we had uh nine vacancies at the beginning of the year and down to three or five five so I mean are we working on getting eliminating that overtime I mean how typically the overtime is coming
047in when we are down because of sickness or we have Recreation Department you all remember that they all came because they want to use the facilities so in order for us to stay open for basketball and wreck if somebody needs to do that we have to put in a custodian and and because we had the number of vacancies we have but with the change we're already seeing us filling those spots so that light item hopefully next year will be down because of that but it's that line is up but the purchase Services line is down in that area because we were Contracting out at a much higher rate now I do remember that we had voted on uh a pum um I know that uh Ned had I want just want to know we never
048heard how that worked out if it worked out so um we actually had a couple of uh School Employees who were parents and Educators here that took advantage of it but but we only had a couple but two is better than none thank you while we're on that can I just ask a question about that same line you just need to be recognized by the chair so Jess and then Laura thanks okay thank you um so I had noticed similar and thought you know well we did change the contract raise the rate I think it'd be great if we could get that lower um but my question was about so if you're a custodian working overtime that would so say you're like second shift so you're in the building after hours anyways you couldn't tend
049to a game or like a an event you couldn't have the same custodian be working in the school and be at an event is that true or you understand what we do we do but sometimes that person is the one that calls out sick okay but you also have to remember the custodian who's tending to the game is also trying to clean the building right that's what I'm at the same time but so that person would not be overtime you don't need that person and an overtime custodian no if we have when you're down nine custodians it's very likely the person who's doing that is working over time right corre but ideally you could have someone working that shift who could also cover a game I was just curious if there were double if you
050had to do both at the same time no there's nothing that stops us from doing it okay if it's IR regular but again it depends on the number it depends on what's Happening like a game versus practice is very different right okay thank you Laura so the this is on page 20 of the 56 page budget it starts on page 20 section four so if you look at the the grade area the Shaded area on that page it shows all of the different types of benefits the health Wellness life Dental Etc and what I'm what I was asking was how if there if the district is able to provide us or your team is able to provide us with where those go to because that's $166 million in benefits and when I'm looking at the
051salaries that are up here sometimes it's challenging to allocate because I mean I have no idea which portion of this should be can be allocated so my my understanding is that this has always been presented this way because if we start to break this up you're going to go to confidentiality issues you would actually be listing employees you would see their name and you would also know what their benefits are whether or not they're family plan or individual plan and we're not allow to do that we can give you a big picture salary yeah I wasn't asking for you don't need to do individual nams but if the if the code for benefits just as an example if you have um so for example benefits help if we break that down anymore you're starting to
052get into individual names so there's no way for the for us to have that information or to be able to know not individual that that's something we have I mean that's an even I don't see personal information because the human resources administrator uh takes that so for example even when a um one of our Personnel goes on FMLA that's not done for me because it's privacy right I guess what I'm what I'm saying is that for example the salary development officer that that yuk COA code is you know it's one0 -2500 5110 there's a second Yuka code that would be tied to the salary development officer that would be 52 would be the starting string number is that correct Lynn yes so that's what I'm referring to that is there way that's an administrative position
053you're asking up so there's the contract so if you want to go to the certified contract you can go through their benefits appendix and that'll explain the benefits that they receive if you look at the ESP contract that'll go through the benefits available to them as well you'll notice in the ESP contract their Healthcare benefits are very very expensive and the majority of their salary is benefits but the contract is way you'll get that that sort of information about what they receive or what they can access as uh contractual administra contracts are individual which is why um for example myself or we would be specific out because we're we we have separate individual contracts that are voted on in public the contracts for the ESP and certify uh those that's what's voted on the public
054and that's what we can provide publicly did you have any followup Laura um only that I would just be I would would request that information that's all is it's the contracts are online just go to um District Tab and contracts all the contracts are there thank you you're welcome Jess um all of these L items benefit well inness benefit life we can't change these through the budget process they're all contractual correct correct okay thank you so there were some other line items that I had questions about some of these actually mirror councelor Davis's sheet that she gave us last week during the Omnibus um so I just I had a couple of questions um I hope you don't mind my indulging your response to these um some of these line items um are you in
055section four I am I'm back to section three that's all right Laura gets in in the weeds because this is her speak but um okay um okay um so there are some supply lines um um line item 5931 supplies um says child Outreach it went from about $1,000 up to $3,000 you want me to go one by at a time sure so the uh child Outreach we do have an increase in uh that's fore prek ages 3 through five we're required by law to uh service any student at the age of three that need specialized Services um 3 through five is consider 3 through five before they start kindergarten is prek so that is our the child Outreach person and the need for walk-in services and that level has increased significantly over the last three
056years um I'll put it out there but please everyone just take a breath the prek tuition has been reviewed for 5 years there has been no appetite to increase the prek tuition we are the cheapest prek in the state so are you making a recommendation I am not making recommendation okay my recommendation you already have okay all right um so just going down that uh sheet line items 5962 textbooks textbook workbooks Elementary right that's the curriculum that's part of the mandated law okay for the um elementary schools okay so just for the Public's edification in fiscal year 23 that line item was just over 5,000 and for proposed for fiscal year 20 26 it's proposed 83,000 plus so I I'm GNA ask Dr Cela to explain we have um many contracts that are working so
057they're at different years so to save cost he's been able to manage that so I'm going to have him sort of review that Mike that one was the last one was the inter reading for elementary school so we yeah so what we do is um the I think the last contract we had with inter reading was maybe 22 23 which is why you don't see a significant cost there and we paid for it through Essa so the majority of it right that was a school committee at request to move it into ESS so We've Ended that contract um they typically do three-year contracts with our vendors so we're up um and that's the proposed um that's the uh proposal we got from the vendor um and and so you won't see and oh and what
058we've negotiated with you know without getting into specifics about vendors is sometimes they allow us to do a percentage one year and a percentage the next to offset cost so you don't see a bulk in one year and then you don't you know you're paying upfront so next year you'll see it significantly reduced because we've already entered into the contract okay thank you other questions Laura and Jess um okay so in section four tell every get section 4 page 14 I thought it was page 14 yeah page 14 line item 598 there is a it looks like there's a credit or some sort of allocation that gets made that is it's listed as a salary reduction and in 2025 that offset was 420,000 and in 2026 it's 190,000 which leaves is that 200 and some
059200 excuse me 190,000 is the Delta what is what is that Greg that's all schools so what happens is when you have salary step increases or decreases people change and that just captures the changes from year to year so for example we may have had a retirement TOP Step somebody may have resigned somebody you take the and the different steps come in so overall that's the shift that happens so Laura for example if you have a third step um speech pathologist resign it's very unlikely we're going to hire someone at third step for that position you're going to wind up hiring that 10th step so a third High area Mak 55,000 where TOP Step is making much more so you have to build in for that we don't know who will resign um you know
060people get married they move they they they leave teaching so that is a you have to build in for that um that fluctuation okay understood thank you Jess um so I was going to say um what I did when I looked through the budget um is I was looking for certain line items that have increased more than double since FY 23 so that's something that I have some specific line items but overall I was asking if there was a way to see all of them at once so I wouldn't have to go line by one and bother Gina and I I know you know from experience there is typically a reason why something has increased more than it seems like it should or why it has decreased um more than that amount but that that's
061something I've been looking at and the other thing I've been looking at is professional development it comes up a lot I know some of it is mandatory um but it seems like we have to pay for professionals to take it sometimes we have to pay for the conference sometimes we have to pay for the mileage to get to the PD it seems like it's layers of paying for professional development and I'm not trying to discredit that I think it's very important that our Educators and our staff stay in a learning process so that they can deal with new challenges and they can deal with changes in curriculum but that that's something I'm also interested in taking a bigger look at but overall when I'm looking at the budget um the onepage budget which we just
062receive the increases from preschool um you mind if I just explain yeah that' be great so on Friday afternoon we received correspondence from the Department of Education that the prek allocation originally in the governor and rides review of of the budget was count they were counting prek students as all full-time students which is not the case across the state that this was not just a Charo thing they did it for the entire state so um as many of you know we only have one classroom of full-time prek and then we have the remaining classrooms with part-time prek so then they informed us it hasn't been updated yet but they informed us that we would have to recalculate and they will be updating those numbers in March but that we should take that into account when
063budgeting so that the team went back to the table and then we uh rid the numbers uh yesterday and then reviewed them again today to ensure that we agreed that that would be what we stand at now and that is why um there's new pages for anybody in the audience over there but that puts the budget as an overall increase of 2.65% after state aid which is still under inflation so still proud of that but based on that new uh email that has been updated professional development all the professional development that we do is contractual and mandated we haven't been able to do anything different okay just to give you a sense but Dr Cela myself and Mr zenan along with the other superintendent of course say we're we're going to be um because the
064question of underfunded and unfunded mandates have come out so if it's okay may I pass a sec please so um the this was created by our legal council uh firm and to help assist there are not dollar amounts but we're going to be working on ways as a um cohesive group of superintendent and business offices to give this information to school committees so we're all pulling from the same Uka but this will give you a sense of unfunded underfunded mandates for the public once the school committee reviews um I'm going to be posting this on our FAQ tomorrow so you'll be able to access this via our website so Gina my question to you is is is this acceptable to pass out to the committee even though this wasn't necessarily put into our materials that
065we yes it just be once I pass something out it becomes public so people can now request it which is why it will be linked to the FAQ tomorrow for all to see thank you so just to piggyback on that question um about the new information that now affected the budget where is that change specifically reflected in this one pager so if so if you go to section two you one pager and if you go down to where you see all the way at the bottom um in percentage increase contribution to District after state aid so um the um the left of that column the one for Charlestown for example 1,500 5,440 that number changed which changed your percentage and then um I believe Richmond changed and I not POS I think hon stay the
066same yeah so hton stayed the same they didn't it did not impact their um funding yep the majority of our prease students you may remember that I explained this to you are from Richmond and Charlestown so uh the biggest impacts would be the those those two districts because it's based on enrollment of the pre- student where that pre- student resides okay so there's 56 prek students that they um budget run for okay so um I know Larry has a question I if I may just follow up on my question Larry y um so if we're looking at the fiscal year 2526 column what you just referenced um Mr zenan yes so Richmond um state aid to education received by Towns now that figure has changed and um fairly significantly and um the hopkington line item
067has changed also fairly significantly um am I am I reading that correctly yeah Richmond was at 3.10% and now it's 3.7 and Hopkinson was two 241 thank you and now it is at 3.24 okay thank you one well oh go ahead um ju um just very related to that I'm curious if you have the number like the but the money number for the the reallocation how much money did you have to add oh oh oh back or take out from state aid stand by we do have it it's we're allow we can take a breath you got a second all right I'll ask Larry uh to ask his question until um Lynn is able to get that information thank you Lynn just for GRE um in Revenue so section five no the first page page
068okay Y where you got 7605 the last update we had was the right pages so many now was 7611 and the bottom number is 61 518 it was 61513 we had a $5,000 reduction how come the number went up and not down that's a good question I I'm I'm going to have to check that because we we plugged in the new number with um Revenue into the formula that's five 5,694 difference y we definitely get that back to you we'll find thank you Larry all right you're welcome thanks any other questions Laura under um Greg can you tell me what is a claims and settlements there's a a line item that I haven't that I couldn't figure out it's actually it's not in 2026 so I'm just wondering if maybe you have more information on
069it it looks like it's an insurance item is that where are you speaking around it is on let's see it's on section 4 and it is row number 6,349 literally the end the last page 5 it is 6,000 SE section 4 6,300 49 it's like the second to last line oh RGB litigation that's right thank you but that was that's not for this year that was transferred that was FY 24 just correct want to make sure it's not in this budget it was two budgets ago and then can you also um advise the when we I believe that we started have the two deans that we had for the middle school that was originally paid for by eser funds is that correct no no so I was at the middle school 20 years ago with
070two deans okay and then um probably eight or nine years ago they cut to 1.2 Deans you have 1.2 Deans they made someone a point so it it was and then that wasn't working either and they went down to one Dean and I will tell you um it did not work um as the principal of the building I handled almost every single bullying investigation I handled probably 40% of the discipline and um so you basically paid the principal to do a Dean's job and I was not able to do my job many things slipped because you that building will not run with one Dean unless you in in my opinion unless you increase administrators yeah I I I like the idea of talking about that conversation um and I would recommend talking with the teachers
071about the difference and what that looked like I can also provide data about the number of discipline referrals and how we've actually decreased now that doesn't mean you get rid of the dean it means it's working so when we look about return on investment the number when students have access to adults who and again it's not about punishment it is about uh understanding consequences of decisions but changing Behavior to improve your behavior and when we have people focused on that work to support our teachers in their classrooms with the Deans then you're going to have better teaching and learning environments more structure and time for your administrators through teaching and learning so again um to Greg's Point there's always been two deans in the Middle School when it was removed my first year here the
072buildings were half empty because of covid so I didn't do anything about it but then when kids all came back it was very easy to see that that was a hardship and then to your point Louise my job uh you know by the school committee is the teaching and learning and there was definitely um an impass between what we could accomplish if we did not um put back that Dean I put it in the operating budget and it was moved to eser because that was the decision so I do have the numbers for um for the pre k um thank you with um thank you ly so what um what Len and I did is we took the 54 students that we know are going to be 3K next year and we just assumed all
07354 would be part-time um 8 to 10 will probably be full day but it's better to budget assuming they're all part time because that's probably where the state is going to start our funding it was um a decrease of $ 17,27 to charl toown a decrease of $4,499 to Richmond and a decrease of $130,600 to hopkington for a total decrease in state a of 2ou 242 200.2 357 242 3 five s tackle any of this okay are there any more questions from the committee at this time is sorry can I just I'm I'm trying to figure out if there's an an a more efficient way to do this um because I just I have so many questions and in in effort not to keep everybody here until you know midnight tonight um I'm just wondering
074if the administration can advise if there's an easier way to tackle this I mean honestly the best way especially about the conversations around the budget while it seems tedious the best way is to ask the questions in public so everybody has the question and everybody hear the response okay um okay so then I'll just go to the next line item then um this is on excuse me are you in section four or three I'm in section four for so I know that you had mentioned that the salary development officer is that is she's just a development officer so she's the director of development and sustainability okay so I'm just I'm just looking at the that increase though the 320% increase is that is that one person I guess that's what I what I'm having trouble
075understanding on that because in 2024 the the amount for the development officer is you know it it looks like it fluctuates between like 40 around 40,000 and then in 2026 it's 105,000 but because I explained part time of it was paid through the grant so when even still now so the more grants Kitty brings in we can we can refer some of that into in-kind services so often times we can offset that but it is what our right now it's that's what our salary costs and if we can get savings based on the grants that we bring in through the inine service then that's how we do it I guess what I'm saying is there a way to be able to see what the actual cost is because it sounds like what you're saying is
076that the reason that the numbers in 2023 2024 and 2025 are significantly lower is because there was some sort of offset to that correct correct okay it's a grant and so is there is there more positions within our school where that where that happens or is that just a one-off thing that's a oneoff okay thank you and then the next line item is also in section four the salary it looks looks like the clerks page uh it's line number it's line 427 and just looking at that increase for 2025 the adjusted amount is 39511 51 and then for fiscal year 26 it is 88,9 so I'm just vacancies okay so that's where the 193% increase comes from is corre you're filling those vacancies correct how many clerks is that does that equate to uh probably
077two 39 is one 88 is about two and B based on the the benefits package but as many of you know the the Tas and the custodians were are hardest to fill because of the of the pay rate now that we have uh changed the contract actually we're almost like I said we're down to three custodi no I'm sorry I keep saying three five custodians left but we had we started at 11 and right now I believe all our Tas are filled but we do have two out on medical leave okay yeah you'll see there's significant adjustments in like lines like clerks T and um custodians because of vacancies being filled say it again vacancies being filled correct vacancies being filled correct and so do we know how long those vacancies are how long they're
078there for I guess that's that's kind of another question that I was trying to wrap my head around was if you know if there's if the school is just at the administrative level as an example how do you if there's vacancies how long do they stay open for until they're filled until they're filled but I mean what's the time frame on a typical vacancy like for a clerk we're working on a school year and we're still down five typically for example like clerks one of the concerns that have have happened is every time we filled the position everyone's looking for people you're I pays a lot more than we do and they're 15 minutes away and we continue to lose clerks to them and so I wanted I could probably I look I could ask
079uh Kristen Merritt but I want to say as fast as we brought them in is as fast as they left okay um thank you the next line item is it is row 5,472 also in section 4 5,000 what 5,000 472 and so for this line item in particular what I was looking at was it's showing from 2024 which would be 63024 that there is a 47% increase y in the insurance error and omissions can you that's our liability insurance and we've had increased in insur a li that's your liability insurance and it went up by 47% yeah just the type of security alone is an increase and we won't have actually I think and we're estimating although that the official rate will come in in April yes and how often does the district shop out
080those policies just out of curiosity by law it's every three years you're required to and you required to have three bids minimum or we can use the NPA we're required to go out to bid were not required to have three bids we wouldn't fill multiple bids if we were required to have three sorry maybe I misspoke maybe I meant three quote three quotes from three different so when you go out to bid you you open your bids and then you you pick but sometimes it's one bidder sometimes you only get one you can't guarantee the number of bids okay you send it out so we have we work on the State Building site so in in the past um um before they created that site you would try to find three people who did that
081service and send them your bid now with the state portal which Kathy so wonderfully he manages um anybody can see it all all all the bids on the state are up all the time right so we we've the Lun had um they fixed that so that we we wouldn't have to be figuring out who to send bids to and that people are responsible to go on and search and see the bids that get posted you can subscribe and get notifications okay but that same that's the same process for if you're doing an insurance policy quote the only time we don't have to go out to bid is uh legal counsel dental and and uh physical and do your doctors this District okay and that's in the state law okay um the next line item is
082row 6,326 and this one is it says professional organizational fee organization fees for school committee and I'm just wondering what that is what island Association of school committees in your conference fees and dues that you're talking about rasas the the thing that her and I went to that you isn't that that's a conference but also you're also part of the organization to receive all the information and to be able to attend and so how much is that per person per per Committee Member no that's for the committee okay so then the additional cost that are associated with going to the conferences that's in addition to there's an addal cost to that and is that a is that a contracted thing no that's up to you guys we don't have to if you want to access
083those services and low supports and that information you've got to be part of the organization that has nothing to do with the students or um me okay I know other districts have taken it off and after one year they put it back on because they then they don't have access to the materials that's that's a new decision okay you may want to look at that organization before you make decisions for example the principal's Association gives each principal a million liability insurance so that Association May ensure you as a member of this committee they do they do I'm a member of the committee not provs thank you okay thank you anything else more for now okay any other questions from the committee before we open it up to the community okay Jess and lar um so
084these are all line items that I have already shared with Gina but since we're going through line items we're going to do that um so in the nine page oh we already did that the child child Outreach coordinator I was curious about what that was 506 um I was curious about what the academic fellow is so the academic fellow is in the teachers contract it's negotiated and it's align has to be aligned to the Strategic plan of the district currently we're in the uh it's a literacy fellow moving next year to our multi-tier systems of support which is uh the complete alignment to be able to move uh our district strategic plan forward it was literacy fellow because we had to uh increase our level of writing across the district so that's why it became
085K through2 literacy and now uh with that Focus we're moving into multi-ad systems of support and um for that position um has been very very beneficial to the district uh if those of you that been here long enough when I first started you had it as a distance learning fellow or a digital learning fellow and prior to that for seven years there was a someone in it for um the technology initiative of the onetoone initiative and that was about six to seven years I think it kept rolling for a while because it was a large initiative to phase into the district and these are current Educators who apply for an extra position correct so it's an educated that long-standing uh veteran teacher um who it's an interview position it it is um monitored by Dr
086Cella and he has an interview team that selects that individual and then um the individual's position is held for them for the contract and another individual takes their position as um what we and you'll see that in next months when we have to review um leave of absence non renewal DET germinations and so this is how many positions is this one one okay um next the cafeteria plans line item line item 474 749 you want me it's just it's $750 but it just wasn't in there now it's been in there the last couple years so I just was curious what that was um it's contractual it's for the dependent care um it it hasn't been utilized in two years however we have to uh per the um contract we have to budget for it um
087each year okay 4928 that is purchase Services you may have mentioned this actually um I did yes yep it's the ous with the increase that was the UK COA change okay um and it's uh now it's a uh middle school science math and reading curriculum course okay 58 this is the oil spill monitoring this has been happening for a very long time it has been we um actually we should be do for an update shortly we have an update every year and no they have told us we still are not ready to remove the process as long as that Barrel has anything in it um that's what happens but the department of I can um if the committee so chooses you can add it to the Future agenda uh typically somebody usually asks for every
088other year um previous ones I can send you what we have and and I can ask Mr zenan if that's something people want to see the update but we still have to address the oils Bill and this is the cost would it be less money to perform remediation is there anything we could do they go through that with us this is this is what the recommendation is not my my wheelhouse with the oil bill but um again if it helps to have that conversation again I'm more than happy to have them come back okay thank you um 5099 ground Services I was curious what that increase was so this is our mowing fertilizer irrigation snow plowing sanding um when we need additional support I can tell you uh we have received several complaints uh from
089cultes and parents regarding the concerns over the fields so uh we trying to mitigate that as fast as we can but uh we have to ensure that our athletes don't risk injury so um you know kind of CounterPoint to this some of you have seen um there has been a Cho Cowboys request to use our football field we have lacrosse field hockey soccer football and we do not have turf so that field takes a beating and we even what I'm putting in this budget I'm con I don't think is going to be enough to bring bring that field in all our Fields where they really should be but we're doing our best and if the committee wants more I told the parents would be great if they want to come to speak to you about
090their concerns and I've asked them to do that if they so choose okay but uh when I spoke to Jason Sullivan and uh the athletic director this was the budget we coordinated and Mr zenan to ensure minimum we have at least you know basic standards of safety um I feel like it comes up every year but the rental 5362 the cost of the Ryan center it's gone up again but it's still requ yeah listen uh it cost us more to do it here than it than it costs at the pry open there's a lot of space there's a lot of parking right and then and I have to say the nice thing about it is we we don't have to turn away any families where some of my superintendent colleagues who use like the vet
091they have to they get two per family three per family our families can bring in 20 50 100 people um the venue covers the security it covers the before during and after um it's well managed and like I said it's it's a venue that um actually I think the only District in this region that's not using it I believe is Wesley because they use their football field okay they do it outside in a tent you still to pay no okay right but you pay for the police probably a lot of police and it's a it's I can I can go back and share with you how much we had to do the co one and it was only four allowed per person because you can only have so many parking spaces and right AC's nice
092and June right and you don't have to cross your fingers for the rain so have you already gotten a quote from the Ryan Center for Year yes we have a threee contract okay great 5768 supplies medical that was up 69.5 eight% yep in the past we have and actually miss s will ask this question as well uh we have we enable to receive donations we are required to have our epipens and uh our tog GO bags a tog go bag is an emergency where we might have to evacuate when we are as well as the clinic and as well as two other areas typically it's the cafeteria and near the gymnasium or the auditorium to be able to ensure that we're ready for a diabetic emergency who typically donates um I have to go back
093and double check but we've been yeah usually um seniors you said CVS donated for years got it um so 60 112 this is e textbooks for the library I you believe you had said that students have access to e textbooks on their Chromebooks but they also have the E textbooks in the library but it comes with the library budget because it's accessed through multiple so if it's not specific to our department often times it's allocated through the library so across departments because ride requires us to do it by department so if it's allocated for ELA or for math so if it's in library it can be accessed across content so um 6112 you want you want to 602 oh 612 you want to know specifically what that is that's the E textbooks for the library
094it says yep um it is the um it was update for the school curriculum and it was an increase of I believe 2,257 yeah it's biannual it's not it's Al it's not every year which is why it shows the increase so it's every other year is the um you have to update it okay um 6216 there's a 327.2 six% increase for techn technology Hardware District that one yep that one um actually Miss Davis Miss sbor and you all asked about that one that's the tech Hardware purchasing we used to rent which actually would cost us money in leasing in taxes so the rental code is actually that line is down and this code is up because it's a new yoa as well oh sorry I remember you mentioned that the no problem um okay so
095now I'm going to the 56 page budget 5529 they throwing me off your list DC no that's DC uh DCF tuition yeah so this is something I I'm keep trying to understand because we pay money to dcyf so that students that are in their custody can go to school and be transported and all that which is wonderful necessary but typically when we are paying money when a student is coming somewhere we get a tuition for that student it seems like we're giving money but who's getting the tuition the residential placement so it's a a group home not a school no no school gets the money no DCF utilizes the funding to support the services of the student correct okay but no school that has the student gets that tuition like DC we the Money Follows
096the student but not to a school like that's kind of what I'm trying to where is the money that's the state law at the school so there's there's actually a funding uh formula this is the this is the area where I explained to you when I first arrived here charo's ask was about 55,000 and now it's O it's over 990,000 right but there's still not going back into a school correct find that just they they in the where the the child's going to a school but no school is getting the tuition it seems like from what I understand the DC tuition is based on the student who in spe specific placements out of yes Karen did you have a comment just so the tuition just goes back to the state like the money we no
097they utilize that c to support the group home that they're in it's not a school oh okay pay for it's a residential place resal taex for the residential police yes not for school yeah okay thanks okay that makes sense required by law but someone also must be paying the tuition somewhere it's just separate from this DCF abor it I I can talk to the department if you want to have somebody come up DC have to explain but have answer to right I know it's it's it's a formula that we've all it's what the state legislation comes up with State yeah okay um I'm just going to keep trying to understand that better so I think we just absor AB that cost right the school tuition cost we absorb it we pay for the group home
098and it's not unique to Charo this happens all around the state but the cost is different so um every District based on the legislative uh formula is provideed different cost so Providence cost actually is a much cheaper cost just because of um the way the formula works so they're paying say 55,000 where South Kingstown is paying 115,000 and we're paying 9,000 so there's different factors in your District that that are added into that formula and then the state tells you the tuition and typically I have not received it but usually in January I get some kind of a crazy update that says your new bill is increased to this I have not got that yet and I'm hoping it doesn't come they s it tet okay maybe good we Karen and then Pat sorry I'm
099I'm sorry Pat could we ask that they change the date of the increase so that it matches our budget like it yeah I mean I can also I I have uh I I we we we have gone through this but I'm happy to um we' we've explained that and I have been on calls with DCF with the superintendent Association and ride to discuss this and it's one of those issues that because it's legislated it's not a ride control it's a legislated control yeah which which brings me to my point if if we're not the only School affected by this Statewide this is a topic that may want to be addressed at the legislative level so to be honest with you this is one this is on the list the again the largest one and you'll
100see that on um I believe it's next month's agenda where the transportation resolution uh Lincoln's already put their resolution together because Mario Kino's on their school committee and he is leading up the transportation committee so uh we re their resolution today from town manager Karen pinch and then we'll look to mirror that to be able to show the state we're we're asking to uh a different way for them to fund transportation that will give us um more money back into the local to the funding thanks Pat okay a couple more on my list um we did go over so 732 is a salary stipend that's PD yeah and that was something we did talk about but that's just one of those instances where you're paying for the PD but then you're also giving stipend to
101Educators to take the PD but that's contractual we can't change that um 5134 I don't know High my back right so that uh is the increase or maintenance repairs athletic equipment so required by law we have to recondition our football helmets baseball helmets softball helmets lacrosse helmets shoulder pads for football uh and current that's currently in the general assembly and that's our mosquito spraying which has increased if you all remember we've had the um Triple E uh increased so we've got to stay on that as well but the reconditioning doesn't happen every year that's really safety correct you know it doesn't say that but that that to me is that's safy it's not you have to Ure your athletes yeah right okay correct um 5683 and to 85 I don't know School curriculum science kit
102did we talk about that's the science the new that's yep that's for next year yep science replenishing the kits you said replenishing the kits okay yep there's like a thing that comes and then my last one I have here 6214 I don't know if you did that one it's the same thing it's the it's the tech Hardware so the leasing versus the line shows reduction in leasing but it's an increase for purchasing it's still 621 yeah y so you know what the other line is uh I'll ask my friends over here to look that up while we move on the one we reduce for the thank you and thank you for answering these questions no I think it's helpful for people to hear because then you know what the money's allocated for and we all
103get the same information at at the same time I think it's good to recognize you know we're looking at this budget and like someone else said they're not just numbers and there's always a lot of context behind it a lot of layers and of course always you know I mean this this isn't uh this is an ongoing process for our team we are always looking for efficiencies we're always thinking about the best what's best for students uh and be and how to be fiscally responsible the budget you have in front of you is my proposal right it's what based on what you ask me to do a review of The District a review of the finances a review of the Strategic plan the needs of the district and where we fall in that Continuum this
104is what I'm proposing um today is the day this is uh I mean February 11th is when you'll approve that for your hands and determine you know where you want to make those changes and it becomes your budget um but this is what I believe the district needs to be able to do the work that we have uh put together on the Strategic plan and M and keep the lights on and the heat on and everything else function so so before we go to questions um from those who are joining us here in the audience and from the community we should keep in mind that it has been discussed in the past that there have been multiple budget workshops this is the only scheduled budget Workshop that we have before the February 11th meeting there
105are two of our committee members who are not here this evening due to illness um I don't know if there is an appetite for scheduling another budget Workshop before our February 11th school committee meeting we've had what up to four budget workshops in the past um and this is our only scheduled one so I just wanted to put that out there Laura um I would certainly like to make a motion to put another budget workshop on you know in the in the works because I think that you know that we're talking about a a $69 million budget and even in the amount of time that we are given to to digest all of this information many of us we all have full-time jobs so doing going through these budgetary numbers I I think it takes
106a little bit more time than just one session so I would if I can make that motion right now I'd like to we have a motion do we have a second I'll second okay discussion Jess so this is something that I was hoping for as well um but now that I'm looking at the calendar there's one week between now and the budget next meeting um I think I'd prefer to schedule it between February 11th and March 11th but then we also have the annual public hearing so maybe the week of February 25th is what I could see but I I think to have it next week seems like might be too hard right okay enough time for folks to schedule and have it in their calendar so we are going to do it I would
107prefer the week of February 25th Karen so I agree with Jess I think trying to schedule it between now and the 11th is too rushed and it's not going to be um fruitful um so I would actually propose tabling it until a and having this discussion at the next schedule school committee meeting to see if there's a appetite that point for a schedule meeting instead of trying to schedule it now because we might come to some resolutions on the 11th well it's a motion so it's not the agenda so you don't table it you uh you still have to vote on the motion as presented and you just have a motion in a second for a second budget Workshop not necessarily on a specific date so um right I I didn't mean having it scheduled
108next week I just meant before we end up I I know I mean I know many of you I know just so you know this when we have the budget workshops if you go back you're always missing members so all I ask is that um unless it's in a SI your sickness that if we're going to schedule that you're ATT 10 I mean we're always here happy to help um but if we're not attending then it becomes um not productive so I want to make sure and I think this is productive like today was very productive but nothing it was question oriented I just want to remind you that like I said the budget isn't something that um my concern is that the question so far is is a level of understanding but there are
109some questions where I'm not sure I understand how it would help with the budget so I think we have to balance how is this going to help us shift the budget to for the Strategic plan on our kids versus I'm learning the budget which is different and we can do that some sometimes differently like Miss dinsar asked for a meeting I we offer those meetings every time new members come in so there's a different level of um I think sometimes need because understanding school budget is different than your personal budget or business budget because it's it's got its its pieces so I think if people want to learn the budget more and what you did maybe some may be helpful but um specific to like here's where I I'm I'm thinking of cutting this is
110where we sort of need an an understanding of a dollar amount if you're looking to if they're not looking to great but if you are so we need to be able to plan and if we're if we're waiting and if people have ideas we need to know them so that we can plan for that so we we go ahead Polly I was just saying uh thinking maybe we should amend that motion to put it on the agenda for the 11th to discuss a date then well typically because you you do a Tuesday because that's the meeting that's what it's typically the same uh the same day that you meet or a Thursday that's what budget workshops have been held in the past so are you saying that you would there's from Karen and Jess um
111a meeting after February 11th so the suggestion was February 25th and um so would the administration be open to the 25th six o' yeah 6 to8 is budget workshops so would you would you be willing to amend your motion to make another budget Workshop to February 25th yes do I have a we have to withdraw the first Mo okay so if you can resend your first motion and then resend the first motion resend the second resend the second second okay thank you Larry thank you so motion withdrawn would you like to make another motion Laura yes I'd like to put forth a motion to have another budget Workshop scheduled for February 25th from 68 do I have a second we have a second from Larry discussion think we've discussed it already all in favor unanimous
112thank you thank you everyone thank you to the administration for being able to be available to the on February 25th thank you Larry and then we'll go to the audience um just for for SS as I'll put it I don't know what that means chips and Giggles um could you on that February 28th come back to us 2th 25th excuse me what a level fund budget would look like so I would need to know what programs you're interested in because this is what I suggested but you would need to cut you don't have to tell us tonight I'm just no the dollar amount though but I I need to know where Like Larry it's our job to cut in the area she can tell you what we need to cut but that's it's up to
113us to cut the so you've got to give me you know people programs I need to know specifics um level funding would require a 1 million 66,9 from the budget if if and know in the past you have asked me about different towns so Richmond is the highest this year so if you want to cut and bring Richmond down to level funding it's uh 58344 is that correct yes 47 so the only uh the thing that I know people have mentioned in and it's been in the school Comm Comm the updates is you have 3,000 students you have to make decisions for 2900 the hope valy uh conversation has come up to me via email um through the updates but that is about a million dollars in savings without um touching other programs and people
114so the question is are we focusing on 2900 or 100 and how do you want me to manage that Pat do we have a list I know we had we had moved a lot of programs we paid with erer funds do we have a list of what those were that are in this budget now um there's nothing left okay that's been going for over a year right I think what she means is what was funded through Esser that is now not funded through curriculum professional development and uh the dean those were the three big buckets and if you go to the if you go back to previous budget years f and there it's listed in the FAQs and it's listed in the presentations so no positions no no that was did that on purpose so
115basically I need to know are you are you do you want to you know are you looking to is it class size is it programs is it uh is it bus Steeples I like you have to give me some areas uh to review and and to how much money you want us to go in because I've given you my proposal now you've got to let me know where you want me to look Laura and Craig so I I think that what would be helpful is if we are looking at the the enrollment um that would be very helpful if we had a better understanding of the the number of students as well as the resources that are being dedicated to those students at each of the schools um I I feel like that would be
116a good place to start because if we you know just looking at the enrollment numbers that were provided has included in your packet right so looking at those numbers though it's showing a downward Trend in those numbers and I think that it's important that you know we are that we have the full picture of the resources that are going to each of those and so that we can see the trend data that's associated with that the number of teachers that are needed for you know X number of students um for example at the elementary school being able and I understand that there's some teachers that float however I think that there needs to be there there just needs to it would be helpful for the committee if we had some some finite numbers for okay
117these these first through fourth grade teachers they are at Charlestown Elementary School there's this number of students that are there there's this number of teachers that are there and then we would be able to look at the historical data that's associated with that and figure out kind of it's It's almost like backing into so so if you go to Section 8 that that that exists and it gives you back from 2021 you have every single position in every single school by school code and the number by grade and then if you go to section seven you have the you have um the enrollment of the entire District by and when you see so for example it may be help I explain so for Section 7 if you look at ashway for example if you see
118those two columns there are there two classrooms per grade and then if you go to the section8 and you look at ashway based on the code which is on the last page each school is coded so for example chyo High School is one chyo Middle School is two charlon Elementary is three Richmond Elementary is four and you look at the school code it tells you exact the number of phans per school that always exists okay so I guess what I'm trying to figure out so my one of um I know that this is this is just as an example there's language classes that are taken at the high school level World Language yes and in we have French Spanish um Italian I know that some of those classes are really small like for example my
119daughter's class there's six kids in her class French um NOP she's in Italian so but I know that there's also a French class where that's the same situation where there's you know a handful of students that are in there so what I'm trying to say is it would be helpful if we had you know a little bit better understanding of of those type of situations and and where there may be you know maybe there's there's some overs maybe there's some places where things could be combined maybe we don't necessarily need the same amount of resources that are dedicated to a specific you know program sure so you are asking me to look at the world language to see if we can cut so just to be clear I that's not a problem it's just uh
120typically the parents and the students are used to be able to select a language I we can reduce the number of languages and then maximize class size is that what you want me to do yes and and I'm saying that across the board like as far as you know looking at it from that perspective of the resources that are going to these specific places and what that actually looks like because hard to it's hard to decipher all of that information Within These budgets especially when you're looking at the detailed pieces of it sure so Craig then Karen the the district is paid for demographic studies so our latest study a few years old you could probably look at that that's going to tell you your population shifts and what to expect within the next 10
121years we have one right here so we have the world um I'm sorry you mind if I say one thing the world uh World Language this is the first year it's a graduation requirement so you're now required to take World Language where you were not before so that's why there was no changes in World Language because this is the first class the 2028 class of graduation class where that exists our freshman so now that we have that uh this year done uh we can walk back the number of languages if that's what the committee so chooses but I can put that um typically what I do for you at the next meeting I provide a list of what you've asked me to put together in a in a budget cut document so that you can
122determine if that's the will of the committee okay Karen I I wasn't finished I'm sorry I didn't I didn't realize that you weren't finished my apologies um whatever you propose okay level funding whatever just look at the long-term impacts use some use some you know common sense I mean prime example is what you just interrupted me for but you you said that was brought to our attention at the last meeting I can tell you when I cut five I received backlash so just like when we did the buses everything has a ripple effect so when parents come you know I know everyone likes to you know we are want to support the parents and support our kids but when you make a decision you have to own the decision all right so can I just
123finish of course so in the past we've had parents come right up and and complain to us all you were one of them I was can you complained now you you folks going to deal with that that now I'm done so it's more of a clarifying question I think um especially where it's a requirement now that students take two years of a language consecutive years cons well if so cutting a language to our freshman students means they would have to start all over again with a language so what I and I I agree with you Caren so what I would look to do is U maximize the class sizes and not cut but move back so for example students will have to give us their requests and they may not get it so parents may
124come to you and say well I know his request came in later than this request but he doesn't want to take FR he doesn't want to take Italian he doesn't want to take Spanish so that's what happens with the ripple effect but um what we will do is we we in full transparency I will look at the cost request for next year how many uh freshman coming in seniors uh Soph because we have to go fresh one French two French Three French four and then who needs what and based on that determine which language makes the most sense that's what you want me to do like you want me to say this is based on the C request based on the data of the student request this is the language that has the least amount
125of requests that's how I would approach it thank you okay are there any that's okay oh I'm sorry Linda I didn't see you that's okay thank you I'm good thank you is there anyone from the community that would like to come up to the microphone and give us some feedback or suggestions Goldie is this pertaining to the budget right yes okay um why can't you put the language online like my son had it at the Met where he took German online for two three years and you didn't needed teach the regular teacher would walk around make sure he was doing his homework but on that he took it totally online and he also taught himself Russian yep so students who have interests in other areas we call that uh virtual high school that's available um
126for anyone that exists however these are languages that are typically instructed and they're the most requested okay thanks Goldie anyone else okay so um with Larry's question about what does level funding look like and you gave us a number um that was 1.1 million something uh 1.1 mil 66,000 and something2 492 thank you so in evaluating that number um if we were to look at reductions but not at a full level funding so would you be willing to come back and give us an evaluation of perhaps half that number and what that would look like without in your opinion sacrificing what we would regard as academic Excellence so is that is that doable does that is that realistic the conversation of Hope rally has to take place uh I I can't move forward unless I
127know because again we're we're we're saving um and safeguarding 100 over 2900 we're nickeling Diamond too and so for for uh something that's shortlived so you we got to be really mindful of this is you know this is something that we've had an every agenda item but uh the parents are going to ask that you have 2,900 other students that are in invested in programs throughout the district and your asking parents to accept changes when you're phasing out an elementary school that doesn't meet compliance of ADA and has significant significant needs but what if we were looking at longer term not for this budget year for next for next budget year the conversation and the possibility about putting fifth graders back into an elementary school if we took Hope Valley offline would that be an
128impossibility no but you you definitely would be looking the all of your facilities are not um up to State up up to State Standards based on the facility reports so there significant needs if you invest in cap so we have $75,000 right now in Hope rally Capital Improvements every time we invest those dollars into a school that's coming offline if if the school doesn't exist 20 years on the road we have to get we have to pay dollar for dollar we're not going to get reimbursed so it's a realistic conversation and it's some something that the committee has had on the table since 2005 okay and uh Linda and then Greg I guess my question to you Gina is um if we went to um help me one and two we had to go to
129to to move the fifth graders back to Elementary I'm not sure the state would uh approve us using Hope Valley you don't even have you're not even close to a plant you're talking another two to three years out right but what I'm saying too if we if we hold out hope Valley as a opport as a option to put kids in there again it it it had to go through a major overhaul or this I can't imagine the state would right you would be looking to similar to what we just put for the bond you would be looking but ride won't allow you to do they wouldn't allow us to do uh the three schools uh the the land at Hope rally doesn't have the necessary requirements based on the current state law as we
130all know um so but there and then there has to be a conversation about the middle school but again that's a that's a large conversation that that's an it's an incredible task can be done but not quickly right um and yeah R's going to have a lot of questions and about the utilization and the planning but that's not something right now taking hope rally offline it it's it's not 8 comp we've gone through the list and it and it's it's cost us over $3 million to run thank you GRE so last year um Gina was I on the building committee so as I always conf used it too so as a resident I was I asked to be part of the building committee and was honored to be put on it I did ask um
131about putting fifth grade back into the elementary schools as a principal of a middle school I had some issues and concerns and um both slam and Colliers those were the two firms we were working with said um due to the amount of vacant space you would create at the middle school it would be very unlikely that um you would be reimbursed on any of the square footage that would be included in the plans to bring fifth grade back because the state said this is what our advisors told us the state would say you're um you're you don't need the space for fifth grade to go to elementary you have plenter space in the middle school for them you can do whatever you want but you have to pay for it and I don't think we're
132in a position to not be reimbursed 61% so that's that was kind of the Newport conversation when they were doing the high school they had planned for an a thousand uh person high school but only had 600 students so R explained to them they can do it but they're not going to be reimbursed for it so um they only reimburse you based on your current enrollment and based on the square footage in the school building authority rules thank you Jess and Larry my immediate concern with Hope Valley is preschool we can't close that school completely because preschool exists there there's nowhere preschool would go to charest toown where like in Mr Dan has already been on site to be able to allocate Miss as Mrs po again it's not pretty because you also have three
133old schools right that that are old and charlestone Richmond has been falling apart for the last five years charlestone is now crumbling as we speak we've got pipes bursting every day today the marine tech just lost its boiler um so that's an email coming to you tomorrow the the fire doors um had to be fixed yesterday at the high school so even though the main campus is 2010 these maintenance and repairs in your cap it continues to happen but your elementary schools are I mean that you've got teachers here if you can ask that between the no heat heat our maintenance and staff are there every single day and out of all the schools hope valy um is has the most concerns and Richmond and Charlestown are you know now where that school is and
134ashway is not far behind how many classrooms does preschool need four four actually well I'm sorry we already have one here have three right and they have they have classrooms that have bathrooms in charlestone yes because of the way the kindergarten M to set up correct other questions before we adjourn so do does the administration M oh Miss Davis I'm going to be in opposition to you on the uh on the fund balance never had to use it and that's not true true not true once no that's not true so Sharon just let me say that because this that is something that has been said now at the Omnibus which wasn't true and now again tonight oil spill is another great example capital projects The Hope Valley example I'm not sure why we the MLL
135funding I will I'm on the FAQ tomorrow you will see a list of where we've used that fund balance and it happens every year I had to use the fund balance every year Sharon all right well I still think you can drop it down to two I'm not I'm not going with the current legislation W with with the federal government um pausing all federal dollars that's $3.9 million of revenue for the district so the fund balance is that's an example of the special education students accommodations that we are required to ensure that they have school lunch I still school lunch is another making my recommendation you you don't have to accept I'm just going to say we have used the fund ballot all right but I think I'm happy to call you about your list
136I'm ready to do that next okay but I think um that you could live with a a 2% instead of two and a quarter that's all I'm saying that's 130,000 you said, 160,000 on the way thank you thanks councelor Davis Craig yeah for those who want to cut the fund balance if you cut it this year what are you going to go after next year to make up for that so so just my opinion leave it in you know you go down to zero that that's it it's done we we won't have $1.1 million to fix hope Valley's uh bricks again so well now it's their roof yeah and they're septic so Larry Jess Laura P Valley's brought up now what would the budget been brought up I was emailed about what would the budget
137look like if we shut it off in 20126 this is 2020 when we're done the school year whole valley does not exist anymore it's in a million dollar savings it's a million dollar sa in one year or is that over three years so the numbers that Mrs Zan pulled for me let me just go back to it I sent it to the school committee on the update I pulled just under a half million dollar without Personnel right so then we include Ed the Personnel um hold on so I I'm going to pull it from the updates I sent to the school committee and Gina would you be willing to go through those line items for typically what I would do i' put them on the budget cut form and show you how much per um
138item overall but let me just what up for you I got a second part to the question so hope rally busing 85,000 and again I can put this on a for you for next time hope rally busing 85,000 hope rally maintenance and utilities 195,000 The Hope Val Capital 95,000 hope rally two hope rally grade one teacher FTE based on current enrollment would be 200,000 HOV cut one grade two because we would need the other one that would be 100,000 um the nurse at 100,000 we actually received a resignation from a nurse so that would be no impact to the district's Personnel because that person we have a resignation for the end of the year uh the custodian at 60,000 and one teacher assistant at 40,000 so the nurse would be I'm sorry can you say
139that the nurse is 100,000 but we did receive a res a resignation so that position would be unfilled at the end of the year and no one would be impacted and um we do need we can't cut grade three or grade four because based on current enrollment we need all our teachers so we would cut two grade one teachers across the district and one grade two a custodian a nurse um um that's uh like I said current resignation and a TA and just to go back over Capital currently is at 95,000 Hope Valley Maintenance and utilities is 195,000 and Hope Valley busing is 85,000 and what was the line item cost for the custodian and the TA the custodian are 60,000 and the TA 40,000 do you have a total working on it okay thank
140you uh I think I do have it right here to hold on to me okay I have 280 it's 280,000 for services one second and then for the staffing is 500,000 and then capital is 2647 875,000 875,000 all in 8 75 now the second part to the question is yes I've read the CH act rate you if you give up that building back to the town that building that building has to be put back to the condition that you got it it is it's better it's better okay we've already done that walk through I just want to make sure that it's in much better condition than it was turned over to the district that I just want to make sure that out of that 875 we don't have to no we don't have to do
141anything to it okay so um Pat Laura and I wasn't sure if there was a hand here okay um so the staff positions would they be allocated to fill vacancies and other buildings correct if they CER if they have the appropriate certification for maintenance maintenance would fill correctly currently we have five vacancies a cutting one involves no one we have um I don't think we have a TA vacancy currently uh but I do know we have a retirement coming up so again and that that tends to shift out Laura so just to understand that correctly if that some of the Personnel that is listed there it sounds like some of them would just be migrated because they would kind of follow the student correct grade three grade four and one grade two but um it
142depend so what happens is they would have access um per their contract to positions that are open and to be able to go to the schools where there's vacancies based on there so we have it three ways to choose we have performance senor and um their experience okay and so but wouldn't is that it so isn't that the budget on the other schools would go up the same amount or is that matter it doesn't matter because you already have the whole budget so what happens is it just the codes go different so you'd lose the whole valley code and it the code it would be coded down to the school where that staff member is so we did a course analysis so for example if um Hope Valley spends um currently $16,000 in paper don't
143quote me on that but um we divided that paper among the three schools they would be going to we didn't take that as but that's why I didn't give you a supply line because those students the students exist for the curriculum the the copies that would still be made the students all the stuff that um would follow the students we didn't include we didn't include okay understood and then just another on another side point at the Omnibus meeting um all of the three different towns shared information with us about you know potential developments that they had in the pipeline Charles toown was one of them um as well as Richmond I know that there's a a Housing Development for hoofington but that's much further down the road apparently um I'm just wondering that what would
144you know how the the impact that that may have if there isn't you know because some of these developers already have preliminary plans in place um but for you know certain reasons there may be issues with the site packageing is or something to that effect how does if you closed Hope Valley Elementary School and let's just say hypothetically that Charlestown you know they Greenlight the the 60 units that they need to build then then what happens you no longer have that school so what what is what would the district do in that type of scenario is my question we're already working on that because we you're very quiet as part of our every five years we have to do but again we haven't had approved one yet but uh this is my fifth stage one
145for elementary schools since I've been here and that requires uh when we get that submitted a stage two has to have a Dem demographic study and it has to have an enrollment study it has to go a minimum of 10 years out so that you can plan thoughtfully around births permits pulls houses units things like that so part of that report is based on your enrollment so for example if we tell ride that we want to enroll you know 300 kids in in each school we want to do however two schools three schools one School whatever then we have to make those determinations that what I've explained to you is that based on the current enrollment like I heard from every almost every single member most is that we we losing kids we're losing kids
146so we're addressing that but when hope R comes to the table people are worried about people kids coming so I'm very confused about are we worried about kids coming are we worried about losing kids I our democra stud show May um so we are losing enrollment but I just want to make sure sure that if we have these housing developments come forward in three towns in the future that we have the facilities to accommodate new kids coming into the district and if we take a school offline permanently are we being shortsighted about that I actually think you're being more fiscally responsible because your facilities are not um in they're needed in di review the renov I I I will dollar to Donuts the renovation plan that comes in from the architect is going to tell
147you every one of your schools is going to cost more to renovate than it will just based on the HVAC alone than it will be for new construction My Hope Is that people will see that the new construction plan even if we have to go through a longer route to do it isn't the best interest and the most fiscally responsible I mean those of us that were just at um the houses today with the chot Tech you know there's the energy cost 0 the people that have been in the units cost $12 our our schools are killing us with just the lack of energy efficiencies because they're so old we're literally bleeding dollars out windows because the heat doesn't work then the then it's too coold I I I I can't even keep up with
148the number of maintenance requests in the last uh two weeks um and I'm not talking about just the old buildings but even the main campus so to be really fiscally responsible and be really thoughtful I I my my um recommendation as I I know my team with along with uh the I the necessity for school construction is that new build new buildings are definitely going to be cheaper and more efficient however the only way I think our community will understand that is if we put the money in which we did for the stage two to be able to show a renovation versus new construction plan and at that point we can have the conversation about the middle school and I I'm happy to talk to uh the school building authority but in the end we're
149we're bleeding money because our schools are so old and inefficient thank you for that explanation anyone Jess do you have your hand raised yeah so I wanted to go back to Sharon's comment about fund balance um but also start out with saying I'm opposed to level funding um and part of that reason is because if you look at on the onepage budget sheet and correct me if I'm wrong admin um but almost halfway down it says members town reallocation of fund balance leaving 2.25% in fund balance and if you go along it shows 2022 there was two million and then we were level funded and in the next year the fund balance was $388,000 which is because we were level we were level funded and we had a resort to using the fund balance so
150that year showed how level funding was a fiscally irresponsible choice and we had to spend down the fund balance and put that money back in um and also the importance of having the fund balance there and and that wasn't B just that wasn't based because we wanted to that was based on the requirements necessary to be able to do um just the mandates right wasn't because let's just spend the let's just spend the fund balance it wasn't like this thing right okay so I just wanted to point that out um because I kind we like twinned when it was said that we didn't didn't pay the fund balance we said that's not true we have used the fund balance um so just those two points I am not in favor of level funding and um
151we have we do use the fund balance especially in dire situations so we've had a robust discussion tonight um but we did not open it up to the community after we talked about what the potential cost savings could be if Hope Valley Elementary School came offline so is there anyone from the community that would like to talk about that or Express their thoughts about what the administration shared with us relative to a potential cost savings um if Hope Valley Elementary School is um taken offline for fiscal year 26 okay I just do one thing yes of course so anytime you take a school offline it's an impact to a community uh Hope Valley has a long history and and the spirit and soul of the school is impacted every time we have these conversations the
152the the longer it takes the um the more stress and strain on families The more stress and strain on on the students The Faculty everyone because it's not easy and trust me I I don't enjoy that part of the conversation it's a difficult it's a difficult decision it's never easy um but again I have 3,000 students that I'm charged with ensuring their educational programming so I have to balance those needs and digging into the budget and and sacrificing 2900 it's hard when I know that those 100 students are going to go to well-loved communities with excellent teachers at high performing schools ashway festar Richmond fourstar and chman fourstar so I feel proud that they'll go and while it's a loss those teachers and staff will follow them into the schools and hopefully will'll bring that
153spirit and culture to enhance those schools thank you all right I will entertain a motion to adjourn so moved do I have a second second second all in favor unanimous thank you have a great night how are you you have any news you really I'm