001e e e okay we're going to reconvene I recommend that minute pertaining to the privacy of students and their records approval of home instruction requests remain sealed so moved all those in favor unanimous uh disclosure of executive session minutes there were three votes taken in executive session first was executive session minutes 12 17 25 24 thank you um with 10 in favor and two abstained Chambers Champlain Chapman Luzon Lyle Phelps pulot pcel Reynolds and teft in favor and Hopkins and dinmore um abstain the next vote was homeschool approval with 12 in favor with Chambers Champlain Chapman Dinsmore Hopkins Luzon Lyle Phelps pulot purcel Reynolds teft in favor and the third vote was returned to open session with 12 uh in favor with Chambers Champlain Chapman Dinsmore Hopkins Luzon Lyall Phelps pulot Purcell Reynolds and teft
002in favor okay uh before we begin there was been a request uh made by the public that we all make sure we use our microphones so that they can hear us secondly good evening and thank you all for coming while I understand that many of you are here for the chair election I hope that you will stay for the remainder of the meeting which will include the introduction of the fiscal year 2026 budget and the high school program of studies I'd also like to add that tomorrow evening Cho Tech will be hosting an open house from 5:30 to 7:30 please come and view all of the great programs that are offered I understand that feelings Run Deep and that some are going to leave this evening feeling like their side lost we need to put
003those feelings aside and focus on the priorities of this committee the students the district and the taxpayers tonight will be a beginning rather than an ending we must find ways to work together which will require us to put political labels aside we must listen to one another and continually ask is this best for all students our district in our community my expectations for this meeting remain the same as every other meeting we're adults and we will conduct ourselves as the role models we need to be for our students that being said please remain from Outburst talking to or over one another we have a lot to do this evening and many of the members in the audience and on this committee need to get up early and go to work with that in mind I
004would also like to take this opportunity to share the process under Robert rules of parliamentary procedure at the last meeting I was nominated as chair and that vote failed under the rules I cannot be nominated again unless a member that voted against me makes that nomination the motion discussion and vote to table the chair vote came after the motion to nominate me at this time I will take nominations for the chair for chair of the Cho school committee poie I would like to nominate Louise Densmore I have uh something small to say should I say it now or afterwards second you need a second second second thank you and thank you for your words Louise denmore is an ideal choice to chair our school committee going forward Louise has held many leadership roles in her
005nonprofit work spanning over three decades those decades have had lasting impact on communities throughout Rhode Island we are very lucky to have her as a school Committee Member and would benefit greatly from her leadership I could list her resume the community she's touched with her professional contributions and the advocacy she's implemented to save the taxpayers of Richmond their hard-earned dollars but I'm going to tell you instead why I want to organize this school committee under her leadership she is a Fierce advocate for children she is a fierce advocate for the taxpayer and she's a fierce advocate for the community and did you know she was a Kidney donor I didn't um that is a trifecta of importance in my opinion Louise is approachable incredibly intelligent and gracious and she's a fantastic mother we should be
006so lucky as to benefit from this kind of lasting impact over the next couple of years I nominate Louise denmore for the chair of the Cho school committee anyone else Jess so I I do want to State a concern of mine that you tempor you um did touch upon at the last meeting it was voted to table this vote until Miss Den denmore could be seated um but we didn't table all the votes there was no discussion of tabling when we were discussing Karen as a nominee um it was moved forward without any discussion and I feel if it was the intent was to let Miss denor participate shouldn't she participate in all of the votes um as Karen said those of us who supported Karen could not cannot make that motion it would be
007up to someone who denied it but I would request that we retake that vote not with the intention to change the result but to be true to the word that you said which was that you wanted Miss Densmore to present she's now present I don't understand why one vote was okay and another was not thanks anybody else okay we'll vote those in favor of Louise as chair seconded it was seconded can we have discussion from the audience no okay all those in favor and all those opposed Iain Mr Lan you obain thank you okay thank you thank you before we move on because I know we have a lot of business tonight I do have a few comments um before we um move forward so first I want to thank Karen Reynolds for her outstanding
008service to the Charo school committee as our vice chair for the past 18 months I'm confident that I speak for all school committee members and the community in expressing our appreciation for your leadership and for your calm demeanor you are someone who has our respect Karen for your unparalleled dedication to this body the students staff and parents I also want to acknowledge Katherine kisan who served this committee with distinction and integrity she was always prepared for meetings asked thoughtful questions consider considered all facts before her when making decisions we owe our gratitude to Catherine for her service as well to those of you who are thinking I can't believe she's prepared remarks she must have pre-planned this vote with a quarum colleagues who know me know that I am a planner and in the event
009I was elected chair I wanted to be sure to express the right words thank you to the school committee members for electing me as your chair I truly appreciate your confidence in me for those who did not vote for me I will do my best to earn your confidence and respect for those in our community who have expressed your frustration relative to the possibility of my becoming chair because I wasn't elected by a majority of the voters of Richmond to that I will say that I ran for office giving 110% for five months of my life and came just 27 votes shy or 3% 3% short receiving 2132 votes I will tackle this role as I do with every other aspect of my professional life giving this body and our students and our community 110%
010now that I have been appointed by the Richmond Town Council and sworn in I am an equal member of this body just like Miss purcel was when she was first appointed to this committee and Miss Reynolds when she was appointed by the Richmond Town Council several years ago go the community and the school committee welcome them both to this body unconditionally and without reservation and now I ask for that same kindness that same Grace and that same inclusion today and moving forward in our meetings I will have three sticky notes before me guiding me in this role the note on the left has the word kindness kindness is one of my core values as a human being I will treat each of you with kindness and expect the same in return I will treat um
011each of you with kindness and expect the same in return sorry about that as public officials we must hold ourselves to this to the highest standard of conduct setting an example for our students and the communities we serve the second note I have here is respect also one of my core values although I have been personally been spoken ill of in newspapers and by members of the community I respect your opinion I ask for that same respect in in return just because I may disagree with your position doesn't give any of us the license to be disrespectful or mean-spirited we must do better the sticky note in the middle says students students are the center of our work here their safety well-being and academic achievement are at the Forefront of everything we do when I
012ran and for office I was s sincere in my platform a platform that highlighted academic Excellence at its centerpiece we should be the best school district in Rhode Island in academics in Career and Technical education in athletics in student safety we must strive as a community and as a committee to be our best helping each and every student realize their Highest Potential my mother always told me Louise when you think you've done done your best keep striving to do better to be better when you think you have nothing left in the tank dig deeper as a community we must strive to help our students to dig deeper to achieve their Highest Potential as we set our sights on the goal of being the best we must find a balance with affordability to our taxpayers and
013residents not trying to defund public education but by working together as Partners to look at the big picture with a fresh perspective I ask that we all collaborate as school committee members with our administrators with our staff with our parents and students to be our best we all play a unique and critical role in achieving the goals of academic excellence and affordability together we can Elevate Cho to a level of excellence in being the best it's ever been thank you okay Vice chair okay thank you all right so um I will accept nominations for vice chairperson and that Vice chair will be a member from Charlestown are there any nominations for vice chair Jessica I nominate Linda lall to be Vice chair of Charlestown second discussion Donna do you want it Linda okay was a
014perfect question well that's a question I'm just surpris um Linda has previously served as chair of the the school committee it was 2020 to 2022 is that what it was yeah I think that well positions her to be Vice chair agree any other discussion I think if you're not going to vote for Linda you should discuss it I think that was a problem we had um a bad feeling I had from the previous nomination at the last meeting I think that you're here as a member of a public body to discuss what we what's on our agenda so if you do not support Linda I'd like to hear that hear why I mean I think everybody's vote is in their personal preference so if but you're a public servant you're a member of a public
015body understood but I mean not everything has to be discussed if somebody has a personal preference then they have their personal preference Donna I would like to also suggest that if you're not going to vote for Linda then you say why you don't feel that she would be appropriate as a vice chair I think that's important to know why okay that's your opinion any other discussion okay we will bring it to a vote all in favor of Linda Lyall as the vice chair why why all opposed don't forget to vote and why so that um that motion fails um I'll entertain nominations um from the floor for vice chair ply I'd like to nominate Laura Chapman um and if I have a second I will tell you why okay is there a second second second
016so the um motion to nominate Laura Chapman from Charlestown has been seconded discussion in the short time I've had to get to know Laura Chapman I have discovered a collaborative and intelligent change agent it's apparent to all who attend our meetings that she does a lot of work researching and preparing to tle tackle topics brought to the school committee and that work pays off for us for the community and all the children who attend our schools throughout the district her questions are exact thoughtful and also thought-provoking it's refreshing to hear intelligent takes from outside ins the Box these are the attributes I look for in a leader I nominate Laura Chapman to serve as the vice chair of the Charo school committee thank you any further discussion okay seeing no further discussion um all in
017favor all opposed any abstentions okay so the motion carries Laura [Applause] congratulations okay so it looks like next on our agenda reorganization of the committee for district clerk yes appoint 43 appointment of district clerk okay so it says next to the appointment of district clerk Angela Brazil so that is Miss Angela right okay um any mo motions from the floor to uh nominate Angela Brazil for the position of district clerk so moved second okay we have a um Motion in a second any discussion yes hi Diane um when I went over um when I went over the um meeting minutes from December 17th um I was a little concerned because not everything that was presented uh in that meeting um that agenda item though it would fall under that agenda item oh it would fall
018under that agenda item all right I withdraw okay pulie did you have something um Angela yes do you want to continue I do thank you okay we're just covering our bases here there you go okay any other discussion okay all those in favor of appointing Angela Brazil as the district clerk oh yes I I I support that yes um so that's unanimous congratulations Angela you're welcome okay reorganization of committee for four appointment of the district Treasurer Lynn is it Goen gven gven um Lynn is our assistant Finance director um those of you may remember the district treasure used to be a separate position costing the district a few years ago about $144,000 um a year when the Auditors came in two years ago sahiti they um did recommend that we didn't have to completely put
019that position back into the budget we could use our assistant Finance director because we had the correct controls so to save the district money we went with Lyn gvin and uh my recommendation is to continue doing so as the auditor said it's it's fine for us to continue okay um I make a motion to appoint lingen okay second there's been a motion in a second uh any discussion Diane um well the only real concern I have is um the possibility of uh because she does work for the finance director already that there might be a conflict of interest that was reviewed by the Auditors which is they said no both times that they were they felt as though there would not be any conflict correct based on the controls that we have in the office
020okay okay Tyler yeah this was a concern going back Gina I remember when when we lost we lost somebody and Ned was going to take over this role and I remember I specifically I reached out to Ned personally and said Ned I don't think that that's Kosher for you to be the treasurer and the finance manager we should check with the Auditors and and that that that's the time that you guys did that and the separation of Duties is there it there's definitely internal control to to keep that separated thank you so okay any other discussion okay so there's been a motion and a second to appoint the district treasurer of Lynn gven um we will bring that to a votee all those in favor all those opposed it looks like that's unanimous okay great
021um nomination and votes for subcommittees um so I know that I'm allowed to make motions but am I allowed to I'm allowed to ask questions though right as the yeah right okay don't laugh at me Gina I'm new at this that's fine um right so you would request the motion that you can ask questions on the subcommitte okay I can give an overview okay so Gina can you give an overview of this because I have some notes about um that there are some vacancies and there's some new members of the committee and it doesn't look like that there are a lot of vacancies potentially for the new members of the committee to be included in some of these subcommittees and I'm wondering is there a ceiling as to how many members of this committee could
022be part of a subcommittee as long as it doesn't go to a quorum of seven so is the ceiling six for each of these committees that are not mandated by ride or mandated by the not necessarily because because we do post them the idea is if you're going to have more than six then it should be done at school committee business at the with the whole committee because then it it becomes sort of futile but overall what uh Angela and I worked on is to try to get some clarity so that people were clear about there was um some concerns or questions about where the vacancies would exist there are only there's only a handful of committees that require there to be a member per Town per The Cho act that's the finance committee so
023that's required that's why what we did was we put specifically next to subcommittees that are required by Cho act or law we put that in Red so for example the finance committee there needs to be uh member per town we have a clear vacancy in hopkington we also H um have health and wellness the law requires us to have one member from the school committee sit on that we have two so typically since since my tenure here the school committee has been very liberal about who can be on the committee there's not necessarily a ceiling but we try to avoid more than six so that you don't have to do the whole committee's business but overall um the only one that's required by chaho Act is the finance Comm however at this time members have
024typically said that they' either want to come off a committee or come on a committee if they're interested in one so it's not necessarily you know the only one we added uh to and we separated out so it was clear was the building committee is appointed by the town councils and uh the necessity for school construction subcommittee we do have three members and ride requires there be one representative so you can see there that even though there's a minimum of one that um those that were interested put their names forward so typically if there one people are very interested in they typically would uh recommend there'd be a nomination and then we do one at a time okay so my question was so for example the um sheet that I'm looking at says school committee
025subcommittees as of January 14th 2025 there was um so that's today so there was a sheet I guess from last month um December 2024 and then I had a sheet back from you know September of 2023 so at that point in 2023 Miss juy was on the committee Mr McQuade was on the committee so if I'm looking from 2023 to 2025 so for example the audit subcommittee yep I believe kathern juy was on that committee so it doesn't say you know one vacancy on the sheet that we have and this is please no disrespect to Angela or any of the notes here but so that you know I had a question about so um policy at one point there were six people on that committee I think Andrew was on that Comm committee and Catherine
026kisan was on that committee so policy doesn't say two vacancies right CU it's technically not a vacancy because you don't have to have a requirement okay so that's why it was in clear so just because somebody leaves doesn't mean it's automatically vacancy but if somebody's interested you would just ask to be add okay gotcha it was just to clear up the language okay so how do we take this do we do this Linda well I'll start I um you can withdraw my name from the finance committee and and somebody else could do it and the other one is uh the certified uh staff negotiation subcommittee I don't want to do negotiations this year okay thank you they'll be openings there did you get the angel yes I did Polly would it be quicker if we
027just went from committee to committee and reappointed everybody so everybody has a fair shot at attending the subcommittees that they would like to instead of pulling some out and trying to juggle some in so are are you implying vacating all of the Committees that aren't required by law or by The Cho Act is that your suggestion my not to vacate them but to go through them each at a time and either reappoint the people on them or add other people switch some people out we'll go committee by committee because Linda just said she would like to get off the finance committee so we'll address that and fill it in at the top um Tyler then Pat yeah I I think what Paulie is trying to say is we go committee by committee confirm people that
028are already on that committee want to still be on that committee and if anybody new wants to add we go through it one by one okay Pat is that what what you were that or go by each school committee person do you have do you want to vacate any of your positions do you want to add you okay I'll make a motion for Tyler's interpretation no you don't need you don't need a motion okay okay so we'll we start one by one so if we're looking at the sheet that says um school committee subcommittees as of January 14th 2025 for members of the audience who may not have this in front of them firsts is the audit subcommittee and Karen Reynolds from Richmond is on that subcommittee Karen would you like to continue in that
029R stay on that okay is there anyone else that would like to be a member of the audit subcommittee is it best practice Gina to have somebody from each T member town be served it doesn't have to be no okay okay um excuse me yes Laura is there any way that Gina perhaps you can provide a brief brief description of what these committee members do on these like what is their direct Point order Mr chairman I I don't I don't know that a member from the audience can can um can put forward a point of order I have the whole book right here at any point in the meeting any member of the body may rise to a point of order and it has to be addressed okay well okay thanks Bruce it's a very
030simple one I so we can't hear all of I ask you to repeat that these lovely voices have to project to the entire room so I encourage you to use the microphone there's a lot of people here we want to hear everything okay thank you Bruce I appreciate that Laura can you speak into the microphone please and all of us um out of respect for the people who are here listening thank you m question was if superintendent peard could provide a description or advise the directives of each of these subcommittees because I'm not necessarily sure what the what what's the directive of the audit subcommittee for example the audit subcommittee reviews the audit when it's reviewed um when the audit prepared it for the district before it goes to the school committee for review okay
031so then they they analyze whatever's on there and they work directly with the they directly with Mr zenan and the um the Auditors okay so once they've culminated all the report if it would be possible to do that for each of these subcommittees just because I think for newer members especially for myself I'm not necessarily sure what each of these individual subcommittees were you know how they what stemmed the formation of them and you know it just a little bit of very brief background on what they would be doing would be helpful that's all okay thank you is there anyone else that would like to be a member of the AIT subcommittee besides Karen Tyler you would like to be a member of the audit subcommittee okay anyone else okay so do do we need
032a motion to elect them as members of okay so do we have a motion to do I have to take the names one by one or can I just do it as a group no just the new just the new members I make a motion to elect Tyler to the audit subcommittee second it's too close so we have a motion and a second for Tyler Champlain all those in discussion all those in favor I okay as do I okay so um so are there there any were there any NOS no Nos and two abstentions Craig and Tyler okay thank you so that's um Karen and and Tyler okay next is the budget subcommittee so Gina can you give an overview on the budget subcommittee actually I'll pitch it to Tyler he's the chair of the
033budget subcommittee so honestly we we we formed this committee to try to revamp the budget process and and and and work towards making the budget a little more user friendly to the public and to us committee members um quite honestly it didn't go the way I hoped it would um and I'm going to ask tonight to to remove myself from the budget subcommittee okay okay so um Tyler is um it's his wish not to be a part of the budget subcommittee but we do have um Karen Reynolds who um is still um on the budget subcommittee Karen is that something that you intend to remain on okay great um then there was Jessica on the budget subcommittee Jess is that something that you would like to remain yeah I I would like to stay on
034the budget subcommittee you know I disagree that it didn't go well I think we had some good conversations collaborative discuss discussions we added some different um ways of looking at the budget some different U details I personally was wanted to get the subcommittee together again this fall and I asked Tyler to do so we tried to work on some dates Karen and I both provided dates and that never happened so I think we could have made more progress especially you know the meeting we had with legislators I thought that was a really good discussion and it's always should be ongoing because State legislation is so tied to our budget as everybody is aware of um so yeah I would like to stay on the on the subcommittee and I welcome other folks to join us
035um there's not much we can do now um as far as the budget is being presented tonight um but I think next fall or Andor late summer I think it'd be great for us to get together in a room and discuss the budget preh hand budget process not the actual budget okay so um Karen and Jess would like to remain on the budget subcommittee Tyler is um hold on one second so Tyler will are are is it your intention to come off that okay please all right um Laura um I'd like to be on the budget subcommittee please okay I make a motion to appoint Laura chat to the budget subcommittee so Tyler made a motion Diane second in the motion for Laura uh Chapman to be on the budget subcommittee um are there any
036other is there any other discussion at this time all those in favor of appointing Laura Chapman to the budget subcommittee any opposed you vote too oh I I I say yes for Laura sorry um any opposition I think I need to obain right um any you can vote for yourself I abstain okay if there's an abstention with Craig okay um so that motion carries okay thank you make a motion finance committee this one is required by The Cho Act is that right correct they meet uh prior to the budget Omnibus meeting and it's a review of the budget presentation going forward to the taxpayers it's literally one meeting one time before the omnius before the Omnibus yeah it's like 30 minutes yeah okay so right now on the finance committee um say required by The
037Cho Act One member per Town linda looks like um earlier removed herself from the finance committee so we will need somebody from charl toown um Karen is on from Richmond and it looks like we have a a vacancy from Hopkinton if I'm reading this correctly um is there anyone from from Charlestown that is interested in serving on the finance committee um Gina perhaps you can give us an overview of that that's exactly what it is it's it's the meeting prior to the Omnibus to review the budget presid presentation okay one meeting is there anyone from Charlestown who's interested okay Laura um is there a nomination for Laura for the finance subcommittee okay I'll nominate Laura for the finance subcommittee all right so we have a nomination do we have a second second okay Diane seconded
038um discussion okay all those in favor of Laura excuse me of uh Laura Chapman to the finance committee anyone opposed any extensions okay motion carries um food service contract subcommittee need hop M oh I'm sorry oh that's right we have a vacancy from Hopkinton okay is there um are there any nominations to fill the vacancy for Hopkinton okay Larry I nominate Larry Phelps second for the finance committee okay we have a motion and a second for uh Larry Phelps all those in favor any extensions Craig stain I'm sorry Jessica we read an exension or no that was a yes thank you okay all right so we have Larry okay um so food service contract subcommittee we have Craig Lucan from Charlestown is on that committee the committee hasn't really had to meet um because we've
039been going with the state MPA right now it's Chartwells which is so uh but typically what you would see as a member of the school committee uh if we were doing reviews of food service contracts you need at least one okay in the in the past it looks like there were two other um former members on this subcommittee with Craig um so I just wanted to see if there was anybody else interested besides um Mr Luzan okay and you said we only need technically one and we and we haven't used it because we've been going with the state okay okay so we don't have to renominate Craig right okay all right thank you Craig for saying on that appreciate it all right um so health and wellness subcommittee it says one member required by state
040law um Donna Chambers from Charlestown Jess pcell from Richmond so those members um are those members willing to stay on that the health and wellness subcommittee yes so Donna and Jess is there anyone else interested in health and wellness okay we've got Laura Chapman and um Miss Diane teft okay so um overview overview for health and wealth the health and wellness subcommittee um oversees the health and wellness goals regarding the policy that's put in place it has to be reviewed every three years and they meet quarterly okay so we had Diane teft and Laura Chapman that were interested in being added to that committee do I have a motion for Diane te to be appointed to that committee I'll make a motion okay hly made a motion for Diane do we have a second Pat
041second it any discussion okay all in favor of Diane teft um for the health and wellness subcommittee can vote for yourself any opposition exstension Craig okay motion carries thank you um for Laura Chapman uh is interested in the health and wellness subcommittee do we I'll entertain a motion for Laura Chapman I'll make a motion for Laura to join the health and wellness subcommittee okay we have a motion seconded by Pat um any discussion okay seeing no discussion um all in favor of appointing Laura Chapman to the Health and Wellness subcommittee any opposed any exstension Craig abstains okay so Diane and Laura are now on the health and wellness subcommittee thank you so much um next Nea certified staff negotiation subcommittee Gina can you give us an overview on this please yep these are the individuals
042that will negotiate with the teachers contract which is um up now and needs to be negotiated it is a um very uh in detailed process it means means you you should have the ability to be able to meet with the Union uh weekends nights uh weekly um it's probably one of the the most important uh subcommittees because it um basically focuses on the teacher contract and how we move forward with business okay so right thank you Gina so right now we have um Patricia pulot from Richmond and Tyler Champlin from Hopkin 10 so Pat would you like to continue on the sub committee I'm sorry if I may yes sir um I am also going to ask off of the Nea subcommittee please okay I I can't commit to the time needed it's a lot
043of time okay thank you okay so uh Pat would you like to stay on that sub committee okay is there anyone else interested in the Nea certified staff negotiation subcommittee that would be me okay so that's Diane teft is interested is there anyone else interested in the Nea certified staff negotiation subcommittee I am so I can add my name to that anybody else okay um so I'll entertain a motion for Diane teft I'll make a motion to appoint Diane teft okay I'll second that motion by Tyler seconded by ply all in favor anyone opposed any extensions Craig okay um I'll entertain a motion for Louise Dinsmore to be on the Nea certified staff negotiation subcommittee please pully seconded by Laura um all in favor anybody opposed extensions okay motion carries um Gina Nea e Nea
044ESP negotiation subcommittee y they actually um have a one new extension but we will be in negotiations again within a year so um you will need to have uh same thing as the teacher contract Can it can create a lot of time it's re revolving the um support professionals contract you should be available um on weekends nights weekly okay so right now it's Donna Chambers from Charlestown Karen Reynolds from Richmond Linda Lyall from Charlestown as the alternate um Donna would you like to stay on this subcommittee I do not okay thank you for your service Karen would you like to stay on the sub committee thank you Linda would you like to stay on the sub an alternate sure okay great okay are there uh any other members of this body interested in join the
045Nea ESP negotiation subcommittee that would be me okay um so Diane is interested um and is there anybody else interested okay is there a motion to appoint Diane teft to the Nea ESP negotiation subcommittee I make a motion to appoint Diane to the neh subcommittee is there a second second okay seconded by me ply and thirded by Pat all in favor to appoint Dian teft to that subcommittee anybody opposed extensions okay moving on policy subcommittee policy subcommittee um is fairly new it's been around maybe one or two years um maybe two and it was put in place to provide opportunities for the committee to have review of policy prior to meeting the entire committee so that they could give input and ask questions okay thank you okay so currently there is um four members of
046this policy subcommittee and and that is Donna Chambers Linda Lyall Polly Hopkins and Jessica Purcell so I'll just go one by one Donna would you like to continue on the policy subcommittee thank you so much um Linda would you like to continue thank you thank you Polly would you like to continue Jess would you like to continue yes okay approve so the ceiling on this would be if there six right so is there anyone else that is interested in um serving on the policy subcommittee or being nominated so Laura is there anyone else hat okay great um so I'll entertain a motion for Laura Chapman to be um added to the policy subcommittee I nominate Laura Chapman policy subcommittee thank you I have a motion is there a second for La for Laura Chapman second
047uh by pully so we have a motion and a second to add Laura Chapman to the policy subcommittee all those in favor anybody opposed no oppositions any extensions Craig Craig abstains okay um are there uh is there a motion to nominate Patricia pulot to the policy subcommittee please Polly I'll make a motion to nominate Patricia second seconded by Diane um any discussion okay all those in favor of Pat pulot joining the policy subcommittee please okay uh oh yes I'll vote Yes for Pat um any uh okay I guess we can bring that to a vote um all those in favor did that already sorry guys any opposed abstentions Craig is abstaining okay so welcome Laura and Pat to the policy subcommittee okay um so the necessity for school construction subcommittee Gina do um so this
048is required by ride um it's separate from the building committee because the building committee is Cho act but this uh we have to have an ongoing it used to be called if you remember like a facilities committee kind of thing but we this is the work that we do ongoing when we're get preparing every uh five years for our stage one stage two which are required by law and this is the group that meets prior to the school committee um moving forward with those applications okay thank you for that explanation um Craig Luzan from Charlestown is on this subcommittee Craig would you like to continue thank you Pat pulot would you like to continue thanks Pat Karen would you like to continue okay great um there's nobody from Hopkinton do we need somebody from Hopkinton
049on this okay um is there anyone else that would like to join this the the necessity for school construction subcommittee okay seeing no one then I can move on is that right um Gina okay Transportation subcommittee So currently it looks like there are three members of this body um on the transportation subcommittee that's um Craig Lan from Charlestown Pat pulot from Richmond and Larry Phelps from hopkington Craig would you like to continue on at this role thank you Craig Pat would you like to continue on thank you Larry would you like to continue on yes thank you um okay is there anyone that would like to join the transportation subcommittee okay seeing no one that um that wants to join that Transportation subcommittee um we can move on um right Gina sure okay the school
050safety team um that uh the the primary goal is um the involvement of the eops which um provide an emergency operation procedure I can't go into detail because those are embargoed by law um but overall they provide the support to the school safety team is run it's EOP Review Time prior for school committee uh to receive that and then um what we do is we ask that every member of our school safety team attempt to make three observations okay so um so I will just go down these names and I will ask if these folks want to continue is that correct okay um so for the school safety team for the high school Craig Lan Craig would you like to continue in that role thank you um for Cho Tech Linda Lyall Linda thank you
051so much for Kala Donna Chambers yes okay thank you Donna for Middle School Larry Phelps thank you Larry can I added to the Middle School um you can yes so is there um a motion to um can I entertain a motion to add Jessica Purcell to the middle school I make a motion to appoint Jessica to uh the middle school safety team thank you okay we have a motion in a second um any discussion okay all in favor for Jessica Purcell to be added to the middle school safety team okay looks like that's unanimous any abens um yeah that's a yes or yes um so it doesn't look like there's any NOS are there any abstentions no okay great thanks Jess Ashaway School Polly would you like to continue in that role thank you Charlestown
052Donna would you like to continue in that role thank you so much hope Valley Larry would you like to continue yes okay Richmond School um Pat pulot and Jessica purcel would you both like to continue in that role so do I take that one person at a time here yes so uh p uh Patricia pulot would you like to um continue to serve in the school safety team for Richmond so Pat isn't no um Jess would you like to continue in that role for Richmond School yes I would and I also just want to point out that the dates and times of safety drills are confidential that was a concern I brought up at the last meeting that Gina had shared with us that um someone on the safety team had shared some of this
053information is confidential for a very good reason so if you're on one of these teams you should not be sharing the dates or times or any of the information with anyone okay okay um I know that I can't make a motion but I am interested in being on the Richmond School Safety team um so I I nominate Louise denmore school safety second thank you there's a motion in a second any discussion um um all in favor any opposed any abstentions okay okay so um thank you for adding me to the Richmond School Safety team okay School Improvement team selection committee this is required by the policy subcommittee no this is required by policy for the school Improvement team policy by okay so this uh it's it's truly one meeting where the um individual who sits
054on the school Improvement team selection committee reviews the candidates that are up for election or selected by their peers prior for the school committee to see that in May okay all right so for school Improv M team selection committee um the high school so right now um we have Craig Luzan for the high school Craig are you interested in continuing on in that role thank you kala Linda yes please thank you middle school so um there's a vacancy for the middle school is there anyone interested in um serving okay so Pat and Karen are interested so can there be more than one Gina for this there can be if they're both if both are interested Ed okay um so we have Pat um and uh Karen that are interested so can I have a motion
055for um Pat pulot for the Middle School school Improvement team please I have a motion by ply do I have a second second seconded by Diane um any discussion all in favor for um Pat for the Middle School school Improvement team selection committee oh Louise yeah um so it looks like that's unanimous any AB you you okay exstension that is um Craig abstaining okay um so uh Karen is interested in the Middle School school Improvement team selection committee do I have a motion for Karen Reynolds make a motion for Karen Reynolds to report great second seconded by ply um any discussion for Karen all in favor for Karen to be appointed to the Middle School school Improvement team selection committee yes I'm a yes okay any opposed and Craig abstains okay thank you um ashway
056school um School Improvement team selection committee ply are you still interested in this role yes okay great um so um is is there anyone else that's that's interested in this position besides Polly for ashway okay so all in favor of no just just go to Charlestown okay oh okay there's a vacancy for Charlestown are there any members of our school committee from Charlestown that are interested in filling this vacancy Donna like to Great okay Donna is interested do I have a motion is there anyone else they don't have to be second because it s Char they don't have to be from Char oh okay is anybody else interested besides Donna okay so we have a we had a motion in a second okay so let's okay so let's um let's do Charles toown first so
057we have do we have a nomination for Donna Chambers yes do we have a second I did it okay great sorry um any discussion okay so we have a motion in a second for Donna Chambers for Charlestown school all in favor anybody opposed any extensions okay great for Hope Valley School there is a vacancy um any uh I'll entertain a motion for Hope Valley School Larry is interested I nominate Larry okay for that vacancy there's a nomination for Larry Phelps is there a second second okay second um all in favor for Larry to be on the school Improvement team for Hope Valley School selection I'm sorry selection right team selection committee okay ask vote again please yes all in favor for Larry anybody so does looks like that's unanimous okay great okay moving along Richmond
058School um Karen are you still interested yes okay um so do I need to vote on this not Ken not for Karen okay she's already there all right great yes Karen's all set okay school committee liaison to the special education is it La local advisory Council okay Gina can you explain this so the local advisory Council um is our special education um families that review the um the needs of we have parental workshops they provide sort of the guidance around the district around goals and initiatives to ensure that we increase that level of work um and enhance it so I know um Paulie's on it now we prior to PA it was Andrew McQuade but usually there's one representative from the school committee that that sits on that Council okay and they meet quarterly as
059well four times a year okay Polly are you interested in staying on that committee yes okay great is there anyone else else interested in joining that committee okay so I think we move on here right um okay ESP evaluation Review Committee can you explain what this is that's part of the contract that's required per the ESP contract um it it's required to have an Administration which is Christen Meritt our human resources administrator a member of the Union which is Diane mcken and then a member of the school committee which right now is down to Chambers okay so um Donna are you interested in saying on okay thank you so do I ask Kristen Merritt if she they only only okay okay because it's contractual all right um so I we at this point I don't
060have to do anything with the building committee because that's required by The Cho act correct the only other one um because it was it was been on hold um Committee Member justel Madam chair if I may um again I'm am going to ask off the building committee only because of the time commitment I I can't commit to that and the time of day that the meetings are I just I can't commit to those so uh as the Hopkin representative I am going to ask off of that committee okay with regret with regret yes okay is there anyone else from hopkington interested in being on that subcommittee so Larry is interested okay um do I have a motion for Larry to join the building Point Larry I'll second that okay so that there's a motion made
061and seconded any discussion all in favor to appoint Larry to the building committee anybody opposed any extensions Craig abstains okay Madam chair I have a question about subcommittees um there's a few that I had noticed were on earlier subcommittees and I just want to make sure that we're not missing something there was a district strategic planning subcommittee that's not listed here is that still active not yet no cuz we have we're still doing Vision 2026 so there are some that when they come up we can put them back on but they don't um they're not sitting committees uh there was also a school facility subcommittee which is now the um we right it's the necessity because we call it what it is so it doesn't confuse people and the threat assessment oversight committee that's required
062by policy school committee members AR on that so we took it off because there's no there's no requirement for school committee and it's by law so we have to have that and it has to be members of our team because it's confidential thanks I appreciate that y so there's just a note here that says member purcel has requested the consideration of a history of Cho subcommittee yep she had asked for a future agenda item at one of the meetings we waited for the subcommittee review so if if that's similar to how when uh tyer requested the budget subcommittee or when Linda requested the policy subcommittee we put in the request and then you all decide if you want to move forward and make a motion to make that subcommittee Jess did you want to speak
063to your interest in this subcommittee being formed yeah sure so so this this was an idea I had when we were going through the bond process you know a lot of um what um was important at that time was to learn the history of chero you know we're a very unique Regional School District that's formed by state legislation and um each town has a unique history and the schools that our children attend have changed over time and I just thought it would be really beneficial to have a committee subcommittee or task force that studies that timeline works together not just the school committee members but hopefully members of the administration and um members of the community like historical societies and my hope is that we could put together a timeline that would be displayed in
064one of the schools um about the history of chero school district thank you discussion I would yeah I'd love to know other folks think and if there could be a motion to yeah make a motion to create a uh chair home history subcommittee okay okay so we have a motion do we have a second I'll second then okay so we have a motion and a a second um discussion further you know it wouldn't require anything of anybody on this sub on this committee unless you wanted to join um you would just be approving the formation of a subcommittee that other people could be on or if you would like to join that would also obviously be welcome so is this like is this a committee that would have an you know a chair and Laur
065simil similar to the other subcommittees would it have the same type of formation because when you say that it's the the history of chero subcommittee I'm just wondering what that would necessarily entail would it be an ongoing thing or is it just kind of a one-time thing to develop something that would go into the schools yeah to me there the endpoint would be a timeline presentation or display that was is in one of the schools um so that would be the end point of the subcommittee I don't know how long it would take you know like obviously it's not a full-time job um so I would give it a couple years in development um okay any other discussion Pat um shouldn't this be I mean it could be something that's going to be encompassed with
066the 250th committees that each town has to celebrate uh in 2026 I don't know if you've given that any thought I hadn't but that's a good point Donna yeah it sounds to me more of a project than a subcommittee I think it's a great idea to have it but if you want to call it a subcommittee that's fine but it has a beginning and an end it's not something that would be necessarily ongoing and I think it's a great idea yeah I think the subcommittee idea is just having a group of people to be able to work on it and contribute right okay so we have a motion and a second to create the subcommittee is there any other further discussion at this point I would just say if if like Donna was saying about
067an end date if it the end date would probably be 2026 okay because then it would coincide with the 250th so there's a in a second so does that mean that we need an amendment to the motion for an to include an end a I'd rather not yeah I would leave it open-ended for now yeah we could end it when we feel the need to right okay so we have a motion in a second are we're going to bring this to a vote all those in favor of creating the subcommittee sure all in favor anybody opposed any abstentions okay all right moving on um recognitions Gina please join me in thaning and or congratulating the following our Cho chorus holiday performance the select Cho chus participants we're invited back to tf3 airport for the sixth
068year to perform for travelers this holiday excuse me okay thank you to perform for travelers' holiday season on December 20th 2024 they did an amazing job and I was I love the photos that I was sent so good job everyone [Applause] I'd also like to recognize our Cho interact club for collecting and preparing more than 60 baskets for Cho families this holiday [Applause] season I'd also like to thank the usdaa project scales Charo team led by Susie scanpo and Katie kakosian who would um who would also would like me to thank the following who have been helpful in this organization for the boy State University Black Earth all Chartwell staff including director Tony lucier tomama quag Museum Ryan Rhode Island Health Schools Coalition Farm Fresh Rhode Island roaches Fresh Foods the Rhode Island School recycling
069project Johnson and Wales univer and Johnson and Wales University we would also like to thank our eight amazing interns and the following chost staff who are supporting this work Betsy sharpener Donna Caster Heidi green Rachel Alon Don fair and Wright Kim dagel Katherine stall Melissa Richards maren ceciliano Carol Eran and Judy Torres thank you all thank you thank you so we are going to move forward on the agenda for public forum we do have a signup sheet is my microphone working yes okay we do have a signup sheet and I do um want to just read um about our parameters if you will for public forum policy the Charo Regional School District will afford the widest latitude to the citizens of the district in the exercise of the right of free speech to present to
070the committee members excuse me to present to the committee matters of public concern for any item not on the posted school committee agenda a citizen will be permitted to present his or her comments or questions to the committee during public forum it should be noted that the right or privilege of free speech is not absolute at all times and under all circumstances the exercise of a citizen's right carries with it a commensurate responsibility each citizen who makes a public statement has a responsibility to one be accurate two present facts and not gossip or rumors three present information based upon personal knowledge not hearsay four be considerate and allow others to speak without interruption additionally all people persons wishing to speak during public forum for items not on the agenda will sign in and be recognized
071the chair will will have the discretion to limit each person to 2 minutes at this time because we have a number of people that have signed up for public forum in addition if time is sought by a speaker it may be granted by a majority vote of the school committee the school committee May provide a brief response or place an item for full discussion on a future agenda so we look forward to your input at this time and there are folks who have signed up for public comment uh the first is Goldie Williams from Richmond Goldie good evening I want to know what are you going to do about the buling in the middle school and kala what are you going to do about the drugs coming into the high school and middle school the
072met in Newport is going to have a satellite Charter School in Wakefield very soon they don't make kids feel like a robot like my youngest son said they let students have a plan like a 504 or I without giving parents grief there's no drugs or bullying at the Met and no vaping allowed and I also want to know how many parents are on the special education advisory committee and how many staff thank you thank you thank you Goldie Helen Sheen from Richmond okay you'll wait until that time thank you Helen Chris Kaa from Richmond thank you Chris Conan and Richmond I want to talk about my concern about uh where school committee may be headed over the next couple years um I have these concerns because we're starting to see things that Richmond's vocal Republican
073minority already tried enrichment over the last couple years until the people in Richmond voted them out you already seen the bully of school committee members it started before the ink was dry from the election it's not going to stop whether the majority of school communes agree with them or not it's a consistent thread or may be consistent thread over the next two years they already had perfectly legal Pathways to achieve the effects they want so far in school committee but they chose to make a political show instead then once established bullying the staff was next when we saw it in Richmond they went to harass the staff and the employees to make their lives miserable the goal was to drive out the ones who didn't grant them whatever they wanted when this happened in Richmond
074in 2023 that group called it operation disruption that's why there was talk by some committee members during the campaign setting up metrics in teaching and management that's a clever way to set up a structure where impossible standards providing excuse to get rid of people who stand in the way we seen the start of this in the Westerly Sun as allies of political actors have been trying to vilify the staff I hope I'm reading this wrong but it seems like they've been working to set up the superintendent as the enemy because Miss Bard demonstrated that she plans to follow policy a strong capable superintendent is very good for chero but it's not good for the goals of this politically driven group if it goes anything like our experience in Richmond went the next will be a
075push for decisions that are good for individual agendas but objectively bad for students and constituents in Richmond we saw them appoint their own allies as a school board member uh instead of following the legal processes they appointed another political Ally as one of our inspectors and ended up being a local disaster we lost two of our most experienced Town employees and they ejected one of our most knowledgeable planning board members these actions cost the taxpayers money and it kept the town government from being able to do its job I don't want to see that happen in Shero but it's important to remember that this isn't representative of all Republicans in Richmond it was a bipartisan group that came together to correct these issues many of whom are here tonight in chero we saw in Richmond
076there's a subset of folks who are specifically interested in consolidating power to further their own end if this personal power is also used to support more responsible budget decisions then there may be some benefit from that or perhaps I'm reading this wrong but if it's used to undermine the function of public schools and hurt the students that's far more dangerous it's up to you it's up to us it's up to us in the room in the town to make the school sure that school committee members and school committee continues to act responsibly in in line with school policy and with the best interest of the students and not political games front and center I'm looking forward to seeing the budget presentation too thank you Chris thank you thank you Justin Bentley from hopkington hi Justin
077you have two minutes my friend thank you uh Justin Bentley Hoppington um I I had a speech but I know I'll be very very fast I'm just uh welcome um thank you I I just just want to ask a favor I've gone over your your the uh all a for Cho and on the surface they seem great um I'm looking forward to more sustenance more details um but I would ask kind of a favor of you being the the new chair that could a lot of those A's also apply to the committee um because in uh the past year we've had a lack of accountability committee members making publicly making disparaging remarks and there was Zero accountability um and just tonight for example we had a lack of uh transparency um and I know it's
078not directly about academics um but it it deals with academics so I would just ask that those many of those A's also apply to the current sitting committee members as well that would be appreciated uh and the other uh quick statement is that uh we obviously are all in tune to the political side of everything that's been going on and I just I I'm a chero lifer uh born and raised uh for 47 years I've uh watched I attended Cher schools throughout I watch Cher schools as many of us have uh I'm sure many of us in this room have uh watched the school develop from at the time uh was nothing but disparagingly people would refer to us as Hicks we were low achieving you you can fill in um with whatever moniker you
079choose um but I've watched it grow over 47 years into an absolutely phenomenal school district one of the best in the state and I think that's lost on some people in this room people are forgetting that we already are fantastic we already are excellent could we be better sure um but but I think we we need to remind ourselves of that uh because kids are listening we may not think that we may not hear that but kids kids aren't stupid they know what's going on with politics and the viewpoints and some of the nefarious behaviors and and I just know that as if I thought back to when I was a a child I would hate hearing and the implications which are definitely happening from members on the school committee uh that the school is
080failing the school is not up to par the school is is not what we need it to be um so I'd ask that we uh collectively as a community try to keep that in mind as well Justin thank you for your comments appreciate you Eda zasloff from hopkington Eda are you here hi Eda how are you thank you good evening good evening yes at is asof from hopkington probably with a different view than a lot of Hopkinton people tonight I'm speaking as someone who believes in the power of public education as a matter of fact I spent 34 years of my life in public education first as a teacher in West Virginia for 32 years then I did 10 years at the middle school at here at chero I'm now now I'm retired of course
081U but I'm just appalled to see this political polarization us against them going on and I I hate to see it at this school committee level there's enough of that on cable news and podcast and I urge you to enjoy it there and when you enter the school committee meeting and all subsequent ones do have but one question that guides you how does this how does whatever I'm considering serve the students of chero and the community when you were elected or appointed to this committee it wasn't for personal recognition or political gain it was to be the voice for all children who go here regardless of which town they reside you are here to advocate for them to make decisions in their best interest all kids all the time that's the team you've joined you
082are here to ensure that our schools remain a source of Pride and opport opportunity for everyone in our community just like the former speaker said politics and personal agendas have always been here but we've worked through it and put chero on a winning trajectory of academic excellence and many other areas anywhere our kids go they are winners but lately the focus has shifted we see it in political maneuverings that distract from serving students and improving our schools frankly our community deserves better and I just want to say as a longtime teacher every time there was disruption in the school committee wherever I was teaching the kids felt it so know that it is impacting them students don't care about political power plays they care about having access to Great teachers safe schools and all the
083tools they need to succeed parents don't care about who's chairing this committee they care about whether their child's school is equipped to help them Thrive teachers don't care about partisan squabbles they care about having the support they need to do their jobs effectively this isn't about politics it's about people it's about the thousands of kids who walk into cherose schools every day trusting that the adults around them will make decisions that prioritize their education and well-being we have pride in our very success sucessful schools and recognize that supporting them is vital to serving our children our most valuable asset in the community thank you Eda sure we appreciate you thank you Deb Carney from Charlestown hi Deb good how are you so Deb Carney president of the Charlestown Town Council tonight I'm speaking on behalf
084of myself and I'm very short so I'm just raising awareness this evening for those that don't know that we recently had pipes that ruptured at the Charlestown Elementary School with a hot black liquid coming out of the pipes which is not safe and we're very lucky that nobody was injured from this no kids no staff no one that happened to be in the building and I know you are all aware of what happened but I think the community needs to know because we need to take care of these health safety issues for our children I know we talk about warm safe and dry we also have a few classrooms in the Charlestown Elementary School that don't have appropriate heat and our kids need to be warm safe and dry during the school day so with
085the budget coming up for discussion I'm just bringing this up so that people are aware of the situation going on in the Charlestown elementary school thank you thank you Deb um Jill is it fontal did I did I pronounce that correctly I'm sorry if I did not from Charlestown hi Jill how are you thank you uh hi so thank you for allowing me to speak tonight I'm echoing a lot of people before me which makes me so happy um here because I care about the future of chair host school district and the students that serves I'm a mom of two I'm a taxpayer who also has hard-earned dollars that we like to talk so much about on the school committee these days um and I've also volunteered and worked in the district for many years
086so I see things from all sides and I see real life in these schools every day and I'm concerned and I just wanted to take a minute to remind the committee of the immense responsibility that you hold to make decisions that prioritize the best interests of our students Above All Else as members of this committee you were elected or appointed not to represent narrow political interests which is very concerning but to represent the entire chero community and our schools should never be used as a platform for political agendas they should be places where every single student feels supported safe inspired and prepared for the future which by the way is also our own community's future the people at chero are watching and so are our kids they want to see a school committee that respects
087the trust that they've placed in you and they want to see decisions being made with transparency and account ibility to Echo others before me they want to know that the future of our schools is in the hands of people who value education and will always put our students first and it's my sincere hope that each vote you cast and each discussion you partaken centers around the question does this serve the best interests of our students thank you thank you [Applause] um Debbie I'm sorry I can't read the last name is it melli okay so she she said she's going to pass because everything that was said so far Echoes her sentiments that thank you Debbie thank you everyone for your public comments we appreciate your input and your thoughtful comments um you speak microphone we've
088gotten longer than this okay um okay all right we're gonna okay we're going to move on all right next is um business um and we have the fiscal year 26 budget presentation um so this I'm going to turn this over to the superintendent and Mr zenan and I hope that you'll all stay because this is the first opportunity for the members of our community and the school committee to um get a snapshot about the budget uh before us so good evening everyone and thank you for coming and welcome to the FY 26 Cho budget presentation I do want to thank the entire Cho team for all of their efforts to collaborate to ensure we present a budget that serves the needs of our students and our families this budget ensures chost stays on track to
089provide a high quality and rigorous public education to all of our students as we move closer to the budget vote on Tuesday April 8th 2025 it is important to note that all numbers presented today are based on preliminary state aid projections we are here to provide a transparent overview and answer any questions you may have as we work towards promoting and encouraging strong academic performance while being fiscally responsible to our schools and the community perfect L welcome everybody I would just like to introduce myself my name is Gregory zenan and I'm the new um director of administration and finance some of you may recognize me as a former teacher resident and Middle School principal um all the budget documents that we're going to discuss will be available on the District web page under the administration
090and business office section we try to be as transparent as possible um the Director of Finance administ ative assistant Kathy is here tonight um any questions that come up she will be writing down and we will um try to do our best to post answers to them within one week in our frequently um asked question document so this slide highlights local and State per pup contributions and their impact on member towns the annual inflation rate for the fy2 24 for New England was 3.3% above the national average of 2.9% the amount each Town contributes is determined by the percentage of enroll enrolled students for FY 26 proposed budget the overall budget increase is currently 3.19% just below the New England inflation percentages the en Roman shifts across Charlestown Richmond and hopkington are reflected in these
091calculations there have been many questions regarding how much each Town pays per pupil the chart on this slide provides that information you can see why Charlestown has the least number of students that pays the highest per pup rate as Charlestown does not receive as much state aid as Richmond and hopkington um some of the budget increases some of the reasons you're see an increase in the budget this year includes salaries and benefits um an increase in health care um Health Care in New England our healthc care provider has stated that across New England healthc care will raise 15 to 20% science curriculum materials that are new um utilities are up building and grounds and maintenance are up out of District transportation dcare um tuitions and um the need for capital projects so overall um chaho
092is proud to be in what they call the quadrant of success as noted as the Rhode Island League cities and towns this means we achieve strong assessment results with a strong return on our financial investment the graph you see behind me has some shading to indicate the percentage of disadvantaged students while the size of each bubble represents student enrollment so additionally if it Fe you see the vertical dotted line denoting the average per pupil expenditure and a horizontal dotted line representing the average rcast math and Ela proficiency levels these lines divide the graph into four quadrants providing a clear visualization of District performances across the state relative to their investment only eight high schools out of 55 high schools in Rhode Island ranked in the top 10 in math Ela and Science and I'm proud
093to say CH her high school was one of them [Applause] this this reflects the dedication of our Educators and the hard work of our students this slide shows some the percentage changes of local versus State um Cho revenues from State funding sources have increased that are faster paced in local taxes the increases in state a was driven by CTE career and Tech and the regional transportation funding so as you can see in this slide our teacher compensation as many of you know makes up approximately 50% of our expenditures you will also notice as our enrollment has declined the number of FTS has declined as well so it shows that we're staying in momentum with the decline So currently we're still working with our budget with state aid based on last year the governor has the
094State of the State address tonight which hopefully will include what he's going to release to um the districts on Educational Funding and transportation funding um so we are going on the 14,361 497 which is last year's um which included full funding of transportation and our estimated um budget for tuition for career and Tech this year we believe we're bring in 3 million $4,088 and that is just an estimate at this point we base it on um students leaving graduate then students coming in based on last year's freshman into um the district from out of District into the Career Tech so grant funding remains a critical component of our Revenue strategy through initiatives like project aware the bipartisan safer communities Grant Grant and USDA project scales we've secured over $3 million in multi-year Grants this year
095alone this funding allows us to innovate and enhance our opportunities for our students and staff so the fund balance anyone who has been following along over the years with charo's budget knows um the fund balance is always a interesting topic the government financial offices Association recommends a fund balance equipment to two months of expenditures that would be between $10 and $1 million for char currently our school committee policy sets the fund balance at 2 to 4% which there appros is some risk with it being that low our Auditors have advised increasing this to 7 to 10% but um in the current environment this year's budget proposal has allocated 2.25% for the fund balance with the remaining money from the fund balance being returned to the three towns the best way to navigate this budget season
096is through a spirit of collaboration our students and our families are counting on us to work together to ensure continued success as we've said this year has been remarkable for Cho our district has excelled in many ways from earning the prestigious US Department of Education green ribbon award to achieving five-star and fourstar ratings at three of our elementary schools and our high school these accomplishments highlight the outstanding efforts taking place across all of our schools we've made significant progress in key areas including Mental Health Outdoor Learning green initiatives and farm to school opportunities as you saw we've secured over $3 million in Grants established green teams develop paid student internships through Grant funds and launch the waste Warriors program at Richmond Elementary as a rotarian I draw inspiration from what is known as the four-way
097test and I do believe it can provide us guidance as we embark on this new budget season question one is it the truth we are committed to presenting an honest and transparent budget that reflects the true needs and priorities of our district question two is it fair to all concerned we strive to balance the needs of students staff families and taxpayers to ensure fairness and resource allocation question three will it build goodwi and better friendships collaboration open communication and Community engagement are essential to building trust and strengthening relationships that support our schools and four will it be beneficial to all concerned at the heart of every decision is our unwavering focus on what benefits our students together we can meet the challenges ahead and continue to build in our district success I want to thank
098you for your time your dedication and your commitment to the future of Cho as we move forward as a United Community for the benefit of all of our students and all of our families thank [Applause] you this is just the first budget presentation it's the first time it's out there so please don't feel free if you don't know you know your question right today next week Wednesday is our Omnibus meeting that's another opportunity and then on the 28th we have budget workshops so we will continue the budget agenda item up until the March um approval of the budget going forward to the voters me um so you don't have this in front of you members of the audience but um the commit members have extens extensive line items of um all of the expenditures for
099the district um again this is sort of our first read uh as members of the committee um we are going to have a budget presentation um our Omnibus meeting is next week on January 22nd here in the library that's when all of the member towns and their elected officials will come together with the state representatives we have upcoming bud budget sessions on January 28th um a school committee meeting where um I believe we have to adopt the budget on February 11th in our annual District Finance uh meeting on March 4th um and then the um adoption of the budget comes up on March 11th and the school budget will be voted on on April 8th so at this point I'll ask if any of the committee members have any questions for the administration Laura hi
100um so I excuse me let me speak into this my question is about the formatting is it possible to provide this report first of all to committee members if we request it in Excel format would that be something that could be obliged yes we can send it out in Excel okay perfect and then my next question is does does the the current accounting system that you guys that the school uses does it allow you to separate these expenditures by School in a report format like in a summarized report format we have school codes right and I see those School codes down there but you also have codes that are not necessarily applicable to the school and look like they may be encompassing more of like an overhead I'm guessing um no but the the state
101requires us to make sure all allocations move directly to the school that they're associated with understood is it possible to provide a report that just summarizes the expenditures for each individual school campus basically I i' have to ask I don't um I'm not sure if I have the capacity to run those reports I would have to pull the each number out and see but I I don't know um okay that's not how we run that's not how I built the budget so I I wouldn't know I I have to use the codes required by the state right so those codes are within that um right like for example you have the 03 03103 is for Charlestown Elementary 03104 is for um Richmond Elementary and then it continues down the list 4102 is for the middle
102school so basically my question is would you be able to provide similar to a ledger summary of just those you know those main codes which are applicable to just those schools for each of your budgetary line I know I would have to look into that I'm not sure it would give you the information you're looking for okay cuz I'm not sure it would pull out everything from the schools okay so you would wind up with a pocket of um money for each school but it wouldn't be a complete picture I don't believe right and I can I continue with question um before you continue to does anyone need an overview of the book does everyone I mean it's pretty self-explanatory but there's some new members so I'm not sure if everyone looked at it so
103if you look at the book um it the table contents sort of spells everything out but just in case you're not sure of what's in it um so there section one is the superintendent's presentation that we just saw so it's just put out on paper for you um section two is the onepage budget that's probably the most important page you're going to see that's everything put into one page for you then um section three and four are the budget broken down into nine pages and into 56 Pages um I'm not sure how many pages the whole budget is but it's hundreds so we try to simplify it a little bit so you're not into the pieces um section five is the revenue which is an estimate of how much revenue we think we're going to
104bring into the district in FY 26 section six is our c Capital which um we're going to need to really focus on and make sure that we're addressing the needs of the district um section seven is your um October 1st verification numbers so if you're wondering where we got the numbers that are plugged in here per puple and per Town um that's all done as of October 1st those numbers are vetted and run um and the towns all get them and are in agreement with them before we start using them and then section8 is just a listing of um the staff and in their Sal and the salaries so it gives an overview of um where the money is going thank you any other questions from the committee Jess just a comment this is all
105going to be available on the website yep Kathy posted it once I presented it because it's no longer in Bar Road once we begin so it's not just the school committee that has this packet all be their documents on the website it's live as we speak right great so we'll put it up once um once the superintendent started her presentation it was an embargo so we put it online thank you um I have a question so the um and Gina I had emailed you and um Kathy and Angela this afternoon so the one page overview is that available in hard copy for people to see tonight if they want to have a copy of that at the front they were at the front Okay so if anyone would like to see a one page of
106the of the budget I think that there are some extras um when you come into the library so I have some I have some questions um so last month at the school committee meeting there was the auditor's report um and the auditor at towards the end of their presentation said that they um they had a couple of sort of findings that I wanted to highlight so my my um my highlighted uh items were the auditor said that there was a revenue surplus of 334,000 and then um on the expenditure side there were $622,000 on the expend expenditure side that wasn't spent if you will and that there was a one-time payment back to the district for um health insurance claims that weren't you know paid out if you will uh to a tune of about
107780,000 do you recall that from the auditor's report um those findings towards the end of the presentation anyone from the committee so if I look at that that was about 100 excuse me 1.75 1.73 million when you account for revenues expenditures that wouldn't weren't spent and then this one-time payment in um Health claims so that total is 1735 million what happens to that money at the end of the budget year what happens to that 1.73 five million if that if that is that excess money does that go back to the fund balance where does that money go does it go towards the following Year's budget I'm just wondering how that is accounted for in the fiscal year 26 budget so I I would have to look more closely into it but um there I would
108want to really look at the part that you're saying is for um for health benefits because that might have went right back into our um health savings account right back in our health benefits we're part of um we're self-insured so we that money um we were in a deficit the year before with Healthcare and then we we used the um fund balance for that but the remainder of the money would probably go right into the fund balance okay so whatever is left over gets recycled back into the following Year's budget um overall though um there's while some things aren expended by the end of the year there's ongoing emergencies that occur and that we have to assign right now we have lawsuits uh litigation that's coming up that we will have to put uh an
109example also was the uh multilingual learner formula was changed last budget season and it was another $10,000 that was not allocated that we had to remove and move in assigned into the um from the unassigned to the assigned so often times it depends what what happens the predictions and the um what we know we had some staff shortages and custodians we also know we we're utilizing our maintenance staff as custodians and therefore our facilities and needs around our Fields aren't getting done so there's a lot of need but overall specifically around the audit we have to make sure like but Greg said because there's there's several other accounts so to say which money I would have we'd have to just be able to review it and I appreciate that so my my point is is
110that from what the auditor said there was a surplus left over from the the prior fiscal year so I just would love to be able to have an understanding of is that 1.73 five million going towards expenses and rolled into you know the following Year's budget and I know that you can't answer that question necessarily right this second but it's just you know something that was a highlight from the auditor comments um last month um and then my other question is if you look at our packets in section um two or chapter two um and I don't know if the public has this sheet in front of them but it the one pager they do the one pager okay okay I think this is a one pager y okay so section two fiscal year 26
111yep so if you look at um in the first section where it says instructional codes Personnel Services compensation benefits if you look at the compensation line Mr zenan um the year-to date expended budget if you look at fiscal year 23 to fiscal year what's projected for fiscal year 2 six so that is over a span of what three fiscal years three or four fiscal years yes that is a um so just for the purposes of the of the public the budget for fiscal year 23 was 34 milon 500,000 and then the anticipated budget for fiscal year 26 is 38,800 th000 about a $4.3 million increase correct so when you go from that fiscal year 23 to fiscal year 26 it's a 12.36 4% increase in those three fiscal years and then when you look at
112the general fund budget um so the bottom of that those that section we're going in that section where it says Personnel compensation employee benefits purchase Property Services supplies property Debt Service and miscellaneous we go from 61 .19 million in fiscal year 23 to 69.7 65 million so that's a 14% increase over those fiscal years um that's an $8.5 million difference so I just wanted to point that out that when our elected officials our towns our schools are all putting together their budgets and their forecasting over fiscal year three fiscal years we're looking at a 14% increase just for the school for from fiscal year 23 to fiscal year 26 if this budget stands so I would just ask our elected officials on the town side and on the school side there's going to be Town
113budget increases school budget increases we just have to make sure that we're all working together in the best interest of our schools and of the taxpayers that's my point Thank You other there any other questions or observations about the budget Laura um so I think that one of the things that because I was diving very deep into this budget um just because this is what I I do so it's you know of particular interest to me um you know the onepage budget is kind of is not really what I look at I look at the 56 page budget budget in my spare time um and you know some of the stuff that I think what I think would be helpful at least for me as a new Committee Member for sure is that there's when
114I see certain increases that are taking place over the course of multiple years from 2023 to what's being projected for 2026 and you know I'll just give an example um in under the language pathologist can you just say what section you're in in the line I'm on page seven of 56 on the 56 page budget so section four so section four page seven section four and I'm on row 272 through 285 okay so there looking just looking at that increase in particular there was from in fiscal year 2023 you can pretty clearly see the increases that2 that took place um there's about $237,000 difference between that particular spread from 2023 the actuals to what's being projected for 2026 is that correct that's what it said Greg yes okay so my question is that when when
115something like that happens and you know that the the enrollment of students is going down or is being projected as going down how does the school how does the district account for any of these adjustments is this something where there's been a state mandate and if there is a state mandate that now says that okay well ride says that we need to have three language Pathologists for each elementary school or whatever the case is then how how is somebody who you know is is a novice looking at this budget in particular able to differentiate between which things are being mandated by the state that cause those increases and which things are just being increased because there's more students or less students do you understand what I'm trying to right the special uh so speech and
116language Pathologists are assigned to students for their individual education plans which are it's a federal law okay so it's beyond state law required service the middle number is 20 20 is um always associated associated with special education okay so those uh I mean there are many staff members that are assigned specifically to students based on their I AP so which is why you can't get certain budget items because students names students accommodations are listed and you can't see that because it's a violation of the law so when we put the budget together for speech pathologist this is based on Services required by law per their IEP okay so it has nothing to do with enrollment right so so again that would be something that is being required by either state law or federal law is
117what you're is what you mean majority our budget is required I would tell you um this the things that aren required we do through grants the majority of our budget that you see here is mandated through State unfunded mandates or require through federal law okay so then if there's if there's increases over a period of time then there's a way to to sort of see what those increases were based on whatever legislation mandated those is that something that the district keeps track of that you know in this particular year the state required us to have more psychologists on staff no the state doesn't require psychologists so the psychologists are based on an overall case review so the best way to get your questions answered would be to meet with uh Greg and I I mean
118that that's as your educational eaon and and your Budget Finance director it's our responsibility to ensure that you have the information and understand how it works the Yuka code is created because the state legislature wanted to be able to compare District across the state so when we had the the um ride here to review the financial digging deeper you know into the budget really we we can give you um I know Tyler you sort of did this exercise when you first started because there's assessments attached to certain things there's just very there's a very specificity around educational budgeting that's not involved in business it's very different so um I would suggest that you meet with Greg and I for specific questions like that because many of this is is related to idea federal law and
119or unfunded mandates through the state and if you're looking from um FY 23 to FY 26 um I would also recommend that you look at the um contract and look at the um appendix where you see the step increases because you're talking about teachers going from sixth to 10th step possibly so as a teacher increases um in Step their pay goes up so um there's that is built in that's all contractual and um every year the state has um you know changes what we're required as a district to pay into um retirement and into benefits they increase social security um the uh Fringe went up last year as well we supposedly got an extra $300,000 went right to the percentage increase Around The Fringe that the state required and went right at the very end
120of the legislature but overall um I think think one of the things you can see that people don't really necessarily talk about and I know when Lis mentioned the salaries is when the pension changed you you're keeping teachers who typically would have retired at a much younger age on for longer periods of time because with the new state requirements on pension they can't retire until they hit th those categories so now you're holding on to TOP Step teachers for seven to 10 addition seven to 10 years more than you would have ever done in the past so you you're so when you when you build out that work you're going to keep on increasing your top step because that's where but you also want to be very very mindful of the fact that the there's
121a teacher shortage and now is not the time to to say to teachers that um this is this is an easy to fill position there's not a line out the door I mean before you couldn't find a job now you can pretty much throw a rock and hit something that has an opening um our teachers are our largest investment because they're the ones in front of our students every day and based on our overall um needs this is how we we plan the budget so when we have our negotiations that's for that that committee and this committee to decide what happens but overall you can overall see in the state everyone is is continuing to give teacher raises based on the shortages that have recurring you also picked a very interesting subgroup um because when
122a speech pathologist for example leaves the district they are very hard to replace so if a teacher comes in with 15 years experience it's if they're good and they're a good fit for Charo we're going to hire them most likely where 10 years ago we never hired above three to fifth step tops but you you picked a group that if um someone retires relocates um to fill that position if you find a qualified person um you can't say we don't want to hire them because they're above fifth step because it also involves litigation and lawsuits so if you don't have a speech pathologist or a special educator that's assigned based on IEP you're now going into litigation right and I think that's probably something that's a little bit confusing is that there's certain things where
123you know there's a mandate that is for you know that's being directed from obviously Rhode Island Department of Education or the federal education department well the mandates come from the state legislature and then the Department of Education has to then ensure that we're moving forward with it so it's your local and state representatives at the state legislature that put forward these items for example the right to read act we were very lucky with the right to read act that we had Esra funding to be able to because that would that would have cost us over $4 million ongoing yeah yeah so so you're looking at money that we would have had to come to local taxpayers but the only reason why we were able to fund it without the local taxpayers is because we had
124eser dollars but that's an unfunded mandate now in the legislature they're doing the same with multilanguage Learners so they're going to now that I would pay attention to your legislators and and the laws coming forward because if it passes you're talking significant amount of professional development hours for teachers a significant increase to to time and significant professional development opportunities where we were utilizing um a lot of our Esser to sort of take on a lot of those unfunded mandates we didn't do anything new we were trying to take away the and um alleviate the burden right and does the district have when when these new programs are are implemented or you know come down as a directive then what is how is the how is the the success of the different programs being tracked because
125that was something that I kind of struggled with when I was looking through this budget is that found it very difficult to to see where things could be measured so if you're if if resources quadrant of success CH if resources are being put into into a specific field like let's just say mental health for example and there's we need to put in you know more resources and more resources and more resources into the into what's going on with our kids' mental health now and this is something that all schools are struggling with um but how is how does how do schools in general whether it's our district or any other um measure whether or not the the money that's being put into the programs is effective how is that being measured it depends on the
126C give me the example of a cat you said mental health is a large category so if you're looking at mental health that impacts attendance so we were looking at The Chronic absenteeism rate which is going down so that's an example right but if you're putting more resources into mental health wouldn't would it be safe to assume that there's some sort of metric on the other side of the equation that's saying that there you know that the the reports that are going into the say something that those would come down because now we put more resources into mental health is that because something is not necessarily used for that purpose or something similar so you almost want a teart with debits and credits correct and you're not going to get that in education and in
127the human resource world we live in and as a former principal I can tell if you're talking mental health if I told you how many hours I spent dealing with that mental health issues as students um so how do you build for that how much of my salary went to that how much of a nurse's salary for example goes to the mental health how much of the guidance counselor how much of your social work or your school psychologist your class teach teacher like it doesn't um it you want a a t-chart with you want it clean you want Deb I mean our DCF phone calls are tyal what they were I get it because that it would make it black and white it make the numbers really easy but I don't I don't see how
128that happens in our in educational budget I mean these are the thing is we're not creating a product right their children their students they're all different their needs are different just like we said about the our goal is to increase and improve absolutely and then we have the rcast state assessment data and we all know that we can do better but if I we all sat here and I said everyone's child is going to take a test on January 1st and at the same age and your child didn't pass the test that doesn't mean that your child is any less smarter than another child it means that at that moment in time they were able to handle something and then somebody need maybe more time some and then we have test anxiety bring in a
129whole slew of other things that can occur but we're looking to make you know you it's not when you're dealing with real people you they're not widgets I can't just say I need 25 of them this year and then we're going to grease the wheel it's it's a very complic ated um budgeting system are I'm sorry um I'll I'll we'll we'll ask questions of the um of the participants after the school committee has their questions answered um are there any other um questions from the school committee members I do have one more question before we move on if if there are people from the audience that have questions so um on page seven Mr zenan and G it says CTC tuitions um so Revenue that's coming into the district from out of District students so
130these are out of District students that are coming into Cho Tech is over 3 million how can we support as a district this Revenue generator how can we expand Charo Tech and this is a this is a comment that Pat had had right when she first came on to the school committee do we have the facility capacity to expand Charo Tech to potentially take more you know in District students and out of District students um this is a revenue generator um opportunity for our district so um knowing that we might have perhaps some um square footage that might not be being used maybe in the facilities is there a way that we can expand those programs that are not heavy into Machinery or Fabrications like graphic design coding that might not take a significant investment
131matal right but how can we expand perhaps programs that aren't going to add a lot on the expense side in terms of machinery and um you know um so there is a there's a protocol that you have to follow through a ride you can't just add programs they're they're monitoring the Career and Technical education as there's been a significant increase across the state and it's becoming more of a school choice conversation than it is a CTC conversation but overall in order to now get a new program they're looking at where the programs exist um we we've added since I've been here Performing Arts Visual Arts Theater and arts um so we we continue to do that work we have um a lot of our educational careers has been around for a long time but we
132have over we have the largest number of programs than any other Career and Technical Center um but it's also the quality of programming which we we also know the difference is it's the school choice conversation you're when you're losing kids you're losing kids sometimes to districts that are not performing as high simply because they're now allow the choice and parents utilize them as school choice versus CTC they they're going for sports versus career and Tech so when Ken Wagner opened up that door it created a very um large gate that is going to be very difficult for the state to close and it has created um transportation concerns across CTC zones they're looking at the zones now but there's a uh you we can't just go in and say we're going to increase programming because
133ride has a board that oversees all that and then they have to come through and we have to provide um it's a very lengthy process we do it when we can um but it there's always a budget impact even when you get the tuition in because now you're monitoring tuitions from other students you have to make sure their attendance is good you have to make sure that they're they're they're performing and then if they're not they have to be sent back to the district based on criteria so overall we're always looking to enhance the program but it depends on also student interest which can change right now we we're looking to enhance um we we enhanced our marine tech with some some new um assessment work but in the end it's going to be get
134on what our kids are interested in what what the um significant need would be but we're I mean I think anyone do we have the square footage no our we we don't I mean our enrollment is down but 24 students this year and they all didn't come from the high school so it's not necessarily that you have the space available and we also when we said new construction for elementary schools which you heard from Miss Carney uh I have maintenance and facility people there every single day at Charlestown and Richmond and Hope Valley and at uh ashway based on the just the needs of the the facilities so my suggestion is before we expand and and to build revenue be that it's going to be very difficult to do we we need to take over
135our capital projects because that's where we're losing more and more money every day and Louise if um you look at section five it's a one-page document that will show you um where where income is for FY 26 if you look right in the whole middle it's all the tuition yes and it gives you a pretty good sense of um how many students we are taking and I would just you know want to caution the committee um we should always take our Charo students first of course so but I do think we um if you look at that breakdown it's pretty impressive the amount of students we have coming from surrounding areas and um well our our CTC program is regarded as one of the best in the state so it's it's the Crown Jewel I
136mean all of our programs are fantastic but in just trying to be look at looking at this from a critical eye if we're taking in $3 million of Revenue um from our CTC programs to me that seems like an opportunity for more Revenue Generation Um Karen just quickly who sets the tuition rates the state giv us the number the state gives us the number however uh in other districts they have coordinated to to do less of a revenue so for example the northern part of the state now only charges $6,000 per student to be able to reduce the costs to each district but provide the students with the opportunity for CTC which is why I said this Revenue grab isn't necessarily going to be around a long time because because it is draining districts sending
137District pays the tuition right so right now you're seeing many districts um I know Newport mlon they're all coordinating to be able to do a set amount so for example you know like reuse the state tuition list based on our Zone and we get paid based on what the state says the tuition is however districts because they can they've they have a board under the superintendent and the northern collaborative is one of them not Northern collaborative but the northern part of the state is one where like I said they only charge 6,000 versus the 177,000 to $21,000 that we would charge to come to CTC see and it and it um keeps them from overburning each other but allows the the career and Tech students to be able to flow but the state is looking
138a a lot around the Cent Tech because it is while it's great opportunity and I think we all see the need for our our students to be involved it is becoming in the environment of where you know budgets are tight very difficult for us to continue with the tuitions who provides transportation and who pays for that it's based on zones that's also in a transportation subcommittee and the legislature they're relooking to redo the transportation zones um so if you're I I can't I think I want to say zone five in Cho but based on our Zone if we if our students go to um out of District then we provide transportation however legislators are looking to do the reverse make us pay for those to come into us which is why I'm saying you got
139to be really careful what you put out there because you have other people in the state who are trying to chck the rules around career and Tech okay thank you this is always a very hot topic during the legislature time Craig I just want to give a little bit of historical perspective here I was on the school committee when the state of rhod Island approached chero and said uh we'll give you this amount of money to take ownership of that building next door the state owned it Cho did not when the state owned it they didn't allow all these programs and all all the different bordering towns they they didn't allow it but once the state got out of it they opened the doors so I agree with Gina I mean yeah we could add
140more but everybody's got the same programs I mean how many uh yeah lunch program I mean food programs are you going to have in South County yeah I just want to be cautious because they're changing the way the rules are be understood the the reason why I asked was because one of my former clients was the Rhode Island Career and Technical education trust and they were um stressing that there was a shortage of um a pipeline of entrylevel um candidates for very specific jobs and very specific sectors and that they were looking for educational institutions around the state to prepare students for entry-level jobs because they didn't have enough um you know students to um that were trained in these entry l jobs so again I was just looking at this as an opportunity um
141and I appreciate that that feedback from um from Gina and Mr zenan the keran technical boards are open to the public they they meet on Fridays uh their their their board um is posted also on the ride website if anyone's interested in ever attending sometimes they do have a zoom option are there any more questions from the committee about the budget because I I just wanted to say thank you for presenting it um if there's anything of highlight you'd like to point out before the Omnibus I think a lot of these issues we talk about are collaborative like we said it's you know federally or state mandated and you know required by law so I I I look forward to that meeting and looking into the budget more um and I I think you know
142for what the questions Laura had I just wanted to State you know my the way that I've had a good experience with it in the past is that I make a list of the line items and the numbers that I have a question about and so far everyone has been answered very specifically so I appreciate that part of the process thank you thank you Jess were there um was there were there any questions from the the audience Jen did you have something that you wanted I should come if you want to come up please and state your name in the town where you reside so we can take it for the minutes thank you hi my name is Jennifer Sylvia um I think I was just trying to pay back onto like what Laura was
143saying um in regards to maybe finding a way to track the increases to we'll say your mental health uh example um to maybe justify the increase or continuing to ask for an increase um being a physical therapist for all of my patients I need to set goals and if the patients aren't reaching those goals I either have to choose to downgrade the goal or upgrade the goal if they're reaching it or just discontinue it because it's not realistic so I think what Laura was trying to ask is their way to um metrically maybe track uh the the um or Justify continuing to ask for certain increases if maybe we're not seeing any sort of gain or uh productive uh goal set of achieving by incre those increases and then I I thought that it was
144great of you to be suggesting um expanding the current Tech um maybe the the um curriculum or whatever different classes that they could be offering and being that Hope Valley is going to be closing you know is that space Maybe an opportunity to continue to maybe talk about the discussion and utilize that space to maybe expand the career and Tech curriculum okay thank you anyone else Mike and then Sharon and then Helen Mike alanti Richmond you have a very important important meeting next week with the uh state legislators the Omnibus meeting we've kind of kicked the can down the road for quite a few years about these unfunded mandates a lot of these mandates come down from ride ride is being uh lobbied by private businesses R is being lobbied by nonprofits R Allen has
145per capita more nonprofits than any other state in the country you have to realize that when people make the comment that the private sector is different than the public sector I don't buy that because the public sector derives the money from the private sector I'm tired of hearing that so when our state legislators come to this Omnibus meeting it would be nice to try and get some kind of consensus with these folks that somebody would have the strength to submit a bill in the general assembly L that any new mandates forget about the old ones just moving forward any new mandates if they're being proposed through the general assembly the general assembly has to fund them and I guarantee you you'll see probably a good 50 to 60% of these mandates will not pass because
146when it has to come out of their budget they're not going to go for it and again the private sector sector I'm tired of hearing that is different than the public sector because Charo Richmond Town Hall hopkington Town Hall Charlestown Town Hall they don't have a money tree in the back of their Town Hall will they can go pick off bills off their money tree to help pay the bills it comes off through taxation and it's either you pay your taxes or your home or your property goes up for tax sale thank you that's Mike Sharon Sharon Davis Hopkinson I just have three questions on this okay um first under um the line five hold on 590000 which is the line underneath the total for the general fund budget it said funds transferred to Capital
147and if you look at the 2025 2026 budget you see a negative 64114 I want to know what that means I can explain that M Davis um I'm glad you pointed that out I did something different this year I took from um the fund balance and um I reduced the fund balance by 1% and took that $641,000 and put it into our Capital because we have to fund our Capital next year and we don't have any funding in it currently so I allotted the money um and then I took the rest to get down to the um 2.25% if you go down a little bit further you're yeah that was my next question um it says member towns reallocation of fund balance leaving 2.2 25% in fund balance and um that the total on that
148is 2,482 666 so is that the value of the 2.25% fund balance no that's what's being given back the the value of the 2.25% fund balance is approximately 1 six I'll tell you the exct no no no I just on this paper I want to know on that final uh column 2025 2026 I want to know what that what does 2,482 666 what is that that's the fund balance being given um really allocated back to the towns being given back to the towns within the budget within the budget so when we take the money then it's it's real we're reducing the budget by that much based on your um enrollment from the the prior Year all right and then my third question is um on the state aid you said that you just made it
149the same as it was last this past year that's what we've done in the past yes he uh the governor I believe is doing his budget tonight right but do you expect that it's going to go up or do you think it's going to go down based on the 330 million deficit that the state is looking forward to hoping he keeps it the same yeah me too but that's a big hope but I we have to prepare a budget before the governor um gives us the numbers so historically in Charo you've always used the numbers you've had the year before correct and it and also that 300,000 that the state voted extra money to chero after everybody voted on the budget and then they raised their and the exact amount of money share have I
150explained that to you I know you told me but I just they take they give it and they take it away I just think I don't know I I think that should have gone back to the state back to the towns because it was money for the towns from the you know I think it should have gone back to the towns and you should have taken money out of the fund balance that you and the state would say that's not how the state funding allocation works for schools you know that Sharon well I just there's lots of things I would like to is $300,000 that we could have used thank you thank you Sharon okay Helen was fine Ellen CH and Richmond one of the concerns I have is the allocation for maintenance of the
151schools so when Laura was asking about breaking things out so you could see how much was spent for each school I believe a certain percentage of the expense for the school is supposed to be for maintenance so if you if it's all bundled together you won't really know what you actually spent on each school so I hope you can find a way to separate what the costs are associated with each I think you're saying something different you're asking about maintenance maintenance that yes we can for school we have that by code of course so I can we have a capital section six is the capital and it it gets broken down by building and anytime we have to do work ons facilities needs those have to be coded to the school that they we do
152the work at okay so I only have a onepage thing we weren't given the big piece that you have so in the one that you have the big one you have that information listed there yes okay and also you had said you could be able to put it in the Excel style if you're going to do that could you also put that online so that the no I wouldn't put the Excel online but if you have an interest you can reach out to Mr zenan because it's just it's a document that we've got to be really thoughtful about say that again if you're looking for an Excel Excel there is a purpose regarding around transparency about what we put out yeah so you have everything that you need in the budget having Excel and you
153want to do some some shifting that's a specific need which not everybody would needs to do so if that's a need that someone has they should be reaching out to Mr Zen okay so I would like all of us to be able to um understand these things more clearly so that I I do find Excel to be pretty understandable I think some people do but I in the end everyone has something different and it we can't create something separate for something for every person I thought if you were creating it already then you could share just reach out to Mr Zen okay I will do that thank you Helen Chris Chris Conor Rich Chris Kona Richmond uh Mr Z what assumptions did you make in the budget regarding Hope Valley enrollment and operations what assumptions
154did I make yes yes my assumptions I made in FY 26 it will house second through fourth grade okay thank you thank you oh okay Goldie I wanted to know if somebody Goldie Williams Richmond I wanted to know if someone has an IEP and doesn't get their speech for a month and doesn't get a s psychologist when they're supposed to what happens then that's what happened to my son at Rice he didn't never got the school psychologist in his I he didn't get the speech therapy for a month what happens with the state then go there are laws what what year is your child in now he's not he should have been till the age of 21 they he graduated 18 because he was bullied into graduating from that director I won't name because you
155won't let me so i' I've been here uh the here 2020 2021 and there are federal laws and um state laws regarding how that that's handled and they're all available online at the Department of Education and um he was never transitioned to college or work and now he's stuck in the age of 178 when he was in that Rise program what what would you do for a student like that I would do what the law requires us to do which means they have to have their services okay thanks Goldie okay seeing no other questions from the audience I appreciate the um budget presentation by Mr zenan and the superintendent thank you for um that overview thank you for putting these materials together and to the staff for putting the materials together that I'm sure that
156took a lot of work to do that so thank you so much okay um moving on uh it's the um the Cho high school program of studies presentation by Gan brat denin Brad Nini okay hi Jean how are you so I am recommending approval of the 2526 high school program of studies as uh Miss Den M say BR Miss banin is here to provide the changes as well as answer any questions that you may have so move is there a second do I do we have a second seconded by um Linda yes okay good evening good evening uh I'm happy to answer any questions there were very few changes into the program of studies one being the approved uh Advanced Art Studio class um which actually miss Densmore is part of our new pathway our
157new our Visual Arts pathway so that's one of the courses there thank you um which you know we we are always looking to expand our Pathways and our offerings to students and so this is one of our new ones um the only other um major change in there was just a shift in um the current business pathway and the offerings that we have in there and that aligns with um business standards that was through concert with um industry professionals with post-secondary um business professors and and working on that in in order to align our our business offerings and also based off of our student interest in the past couple of years so happy to answer any questions questions Linda thank you um thank you chair um I have a couple of questions uh with regards
158to the academic course requirements I see that there's changes coming uh for the class of 2028 I know that seems far off but it really isn't so World Language is now going to be a require M for graduation correct and and these changes um were put into place this is the this year's incoming freshman or this year's freshman class so you've already planned for it these I'm sorry oh um folks we can't hear um Jean in her presentation sorry thank you um so yes the there is currently now a 2-year World l which requirement for incoming students so this year's Freshman Class yeah that was going to be my question have you planned for absolutely absolutely this has been this has been um in process for a couple of years and this is more of
159a personal uh just interested I should probably the proficiency requirements in Civics financial literacy and computer science is that going to be what's the how what is um how is that going to be how are the students going to be tested to be proficient is it going to be will they have to complete something is is it an assessment is it so um the the qualifications put out by um ride um really just established that series of courses that that we've established as meeting that requirement um and we have that actually at both the Middle School level through a series of courses and then we also have it at the high school in order to make sure that we capture any students that maybe haven't had that uh series of courses in in the middle
160school thank you you're welcome other questions from the committee Jess the other the other biggest change I noticed was the change officially from the graduation portfolio to the senior project um it's a big deal you know it is a big deal it's a pretty heavy lift I'm happy to see that it starts in junior year I think that probably yeah our current Juniors this is you know we're we're we're in there actually miss um M Drake and I have have been in the 11th grade advisories we're starting that um starting with the students they're they're getting ready their first due dates are coming up and and we're happy to to have this change with our you know one of the proficiencies to from the portfolio to the project we're in quite a hybrid year though
161with our our seniors finishing up the portfolios and our juniors starting their projects but um yeah so some of the changes that you noticed in there were just our language changes as we were transitioning from the portfolio to the presentation or to the project yeah so one one of the things that was the graduation portfolio there was a lot of chances to the requirements through your classes you collecting work will there be chances for students to work on their project during class time and school time or is it uh the the project itself is an independent project so um while there's not course uh you know um assessments that are part of the project itself they are supported heavily in their advisory classes so um you know every other day students meet with their adviser
162and there's a lot guidance and support with students to be able to to help them through that process so they have advisory all four years uh in starting their here you know we're we're in there we're talking about it we're talking about topic selection and then we're we're in there um quite a bit their junior year to really get them you know started on this like I said their you know their first due dates start their their spring of their junior year um but in terms of the classes while those you'll see those components are are um struck through um in the the program of studies in terms of meeting a portfolio the actual Assessments in those assignments are still in those classes we just took out the language because there's no need to say
163that they meet a portfolio proficiency great thank you you're welcome Jean I had a question um in the mission statement that we were given for the program of studies for um 2025 to 2026 it says to prepare students with the skills needed for success in college career and life I know that we do an excellent job in preparing kids for college career life skills can you give me an example of what a class might look like in in this um document for practical life skills so um many of those uh qualifications would come with our our um School counseling program and meeting with students they have their individualized learning plans their ilps and this is something that comes down from um their you know state requirements as well and so they're built into there about
164you know the interview skills those uh email you know ETI final literacy financial literacy like balancing a checkbook balancing a checkbook all of those those are all there they've been there for for quite a while here at chero so um and and the students continue to to learn that proficiency you know personal financial planning you know and and working with local um businesses and local um Banks and institutions coming in and talking to students about some of that work um as well as with the project itself self this is where they're going out they're finding a mentor they have to have those skills of networking that's something that you know we spent a great deal talking with students about it's you know you have to you only get to know people by asking people you
165know for that help you know we can kind of everyone knows someone and that's how they're going to find a mentor that's how they're going to get that assistance in order to get out there and have that fieldwork experience and then reflect on that experience and their growth yes thank you any other questions for Jean okay so I have a motion oh sorry Donna hi Jean hi thanks for this presentation of course I've been increasingly concerned about the ability of our students to be able to in our citizens in particular um to be able to discern fact from opinion and is that and critical thinking skills and all of the things that we would hope that the students as that there those those would be what I would call life skills as well so being
166able to discern fact from opinion critical thinking if they hear something if they read something on Facebook or whatever or hear something are they are they EMP do the teachers emphasize the ability to to work on those skills to make sure not just in social studies but particularly in social studies but across the curriculum Absolut absolutely um you know part of uh you know the standards are you know um you know reading for information response to information and so looking at uh you know non-fiction and being able to respond to that using fact checking using you know appropriate valid sources and and being able to express and support their their ideas based off of that um we also have a Civics requirement you know based off of the new regulations and we've actually had that
167in place for quite a while in anticipation of these new regulations so that's something that we we also have built into our curriculum and and and that's great and I hope it continues to be emphasized with the students because that to me is a very very very important life skill absolutely and it's lacking I'd say our students are doing an incredible job okay so it looks like we have a motion and oh yes I'm sorry Pat one of the life skills being Financial Planning and financing and Banking and loan processes and mortgages is there any any introduction to any kind of cryptocurrency which is on the rise and people need to be aware of it at least educated about it to some extent I I would have to go through and actually look through our
168um you know we use everi and we use some other other resources that is a a current and everchanging curriculum and so we can you know I can go through and I can double will check that those are part of the the curricula but um yeah absolutely that's an important you know new emerging uh currency for students okay so we have a motion and a second to accept the CHS program of studies um all in favor it's unanimous thank you thank you so much Jean you okay field trip requests Gina I am recommending approval of the MA's Vineyard hockey tournament field trip request scheduled for January 17th 18th and 19th do we have a second okay we have a motion in a second any discussion that was Lind us that seconded it yes all in
169favor unanimous thank you R ask invoices per the rules of conduct any expenditure exceeding $125 will require prior approval of the school committee this year's ask January session is coming up it's $200 per member who attends I will need the committee's permission to authorize the district to make a payment for school committee members who do attend the school committee 101 session if you so choose so moved second okay so we have a motion in a second discussion so do we have to determine who's going no no just if if you do go and the bill comes in I I need your authorization to pay it can I ask question yeah yes um Karen had her hand rais first Karen um if somebody signs up to go but then doesn't go are we on the hook
170for $200 or does that we yeah they they just Will Bill US based On's registered correct so can we have something that if somebody doesn't they sign up and they don't go that they themselves have to pay that I'm just you can do whatever you need to do yep I'm I'm not sureair well just bouncing that off of Karen what if there's uh an accident or something I would hate somebody get into a car accident on the way there can't attend and then they still have to pay for it and it's like their day just got even worse so I mean there's that side to consider as well that would be conversation but I think people signing up at an expense to the district and then not attending is a waste of money the um
171the the flyer that was sent to you know to the new members um I think it was actually sent to everybody that it said on there that the the program itself that they would build the district so I assume that there must be some sort of signup sheet when you get there so that those who did end up attending will no they just will register last year they sent to me who registered oh and there was people that didn't show up correct gotcha okay so Karen did you want to make a motion I'd like to make a motion that if um if individuals sign up and don't go that they should reimburse the district okay do I have a second on that motion Donna any other discussion all in favor sorry I mean can it
172be modified to you know say what po was referring to obviously for under it extending circumstances I I agree with Karen I think that that makes sense if you sign up for something but then you don't follow through with your commitment then you you should reimburse the district for that because that's not fair to the taxpayers either Madam chair I would I would assume that it' be safe to uh to to predict that if some if I got into a car accident I couldn't make it I'm going to plead I got into a car action and I'm assuming the school committee would say Mr L on you're fine you're good but if I sign up and say you know how I'm going to the football game with the guys that's a different story sure so
173car accident Co you know fever I mean these are all what reasonable um I think we're adult have this conversation you know if that happens but I also think that if you sign up for something and you don't go at taxpayers expence yeah I agree Donna I was going to suggest that if someone signs up and then Co happens then they would find someone else on the school committee to take their place I think that that would be a responsible thing to do so anyway I I think they should be responsible if they don't go with some exception okay so I'm going to ask the clerk if she could repeat the motion I'm sorry to put you on the spot Angela Karen Reynolds made the motion that if someone signs up that does not go
174to this training that they would need to reimburse the district okay all in favor anybody opposed Polly and Diane and Larry and Larry yes any abstentions no okay motion carries thank you budget transfers I recommend approval of the budget transfers for January 14th second okay so we have a um a motion in a second did you get that Angela okay so the motion was Linda seconded by Tyler Jess has a question I just wanted to make a comment um related to something that has come up a couple times in this conversation all of these transfers were for um issues at the elementary schools with HVAC um I think that's very relevant to conversations we've had not only in this meeting but over the last couple of years as we look for ways to do Capital
175Improvements at our El elementary schools now that the bond has been rejected for new schools um so I wanted to bring that up I guess the I did have one related question though is the reason budget update is not on this agenda because we had the budget presentation okay that's it thanks any other comments okay we have a motion and a second for Budget transfers all in favor anyone opposed it's unanimous okay consent to agenda items so are there any consent agenda items that need to be pulled none okay so seeing that none no consent agenda items need to be pulled oh you wanted to vote on the whole thing at once yes okay um I would pull a the regular session minutes of the Cho school committee okay sorry about that little on my
176late arrival okay is that that's the only that's the only thing anyone else so how does that work do we take the item that is pulled first okay do I have a second second all in favor anyone opposed okay Madam chair I make a motion to appr approve A1 minutes for the regular session of the cherro school committee and includes executive session minutes not sealed second discussion Polly um they seemed a little uh quite inaccurate in places um where the Cho Act is put in in at the beginning is more of a reference and it's out of context where it could be put in where Gina had stated it um within the notes of the meeting and I believe some of the things that were attributed to my statements um were left out so if
177we could just table this I can send you my comments so just to clarify minutes are not scripts right so it's not understand it's not to get and and if that had to happen then you needed to say to the district clerk I I want this on the record and you have to make it clear so you by pulling minutes then now we're going back and forth so the minutes are to capture the the the large pieces of the agenda items and not a Verbatim yes so we can't now then take the minutes and then go back and add because you wanted certain things said as a certain way that's fine the the way that um The Cho act 102 that was put in there was put in at the beginning of the minutes out
178of the cont context of where they were used in the meeting and that just concerned me I wanted I don't need precise I just kind of wanted an accurate stage of the minutes that's the way I was looking at it so it's I'm have to go back to look at the record I remember start yep yep if we want to um so my request would be is it the I'm just is it the Cho act with um she takes out the CH act section 10 paragraph 2 yeah as a reference yes that's the that's the only concern um I had there was one other concern but that that well because it's a factual because it's a factual document factual statement so it's not it just says the charx says it was exact to what was
179read Polly what was your did you have another concern in the in the minutes besides that section of the Cho act well I was just saying that the comments that were attributed to me as I'm reading them weren't full as to what my comments were I I mean I don't need a whole recitation of what I said during the meeting I understand where the meeting minutes were um but as I was reading through them I just felt that there were some things that were missed and think that in the future you would say I want that on the record right I need this on the record I understand that because it is still out there in public these are just a rendering of overall it was I the most problem I had was where the
180Cho Act is quoted here in the meeting minutes is not representative of how the meeting went down how the minutes went through so there was a vote that went for the chair that failed and then the Cho Act was that section was read That's inaccurate I read it first read it out okay I'm sorry she did okay okay she open with that I went back and looked and and compared what I thought it's just I'm making that comment that's my opinion that's okay so we are or not making change I can't I can't put a motion on top of another motion those were my comments right we have to vote on minutes so Madam we have a motion we need a motion to approve them as written Madam chair I I make a motion to
181approve the minutes as written do we have a second um Karen um all in favor approve minutes minutes as written which we already had the motion and second on the floor did make the motion okay sorry voting all in favor uh all okay thank you all opposed to be consistent okay any abstentions no abstentions okay thank you reports okay I um I recommend approval the following actually we have subcommittee reports minutes from the special education advisory committee on November 14th 2024 from our report we beginning artisty preparation we are happy to announce that artisty is scheduled for Saturday April 5th we hope our community will save the date and come and enjoy our artist displays chorus events and many opportunities to explore our industry arts and steam activities and we also have a virtual parent
182Workshop coming this Thursday at 7 p.m. please refer to the January e update for the zoom link and I hope you will join us tomorrow for our chot Tech open house and the coming events are as noted on the agenda any other questions motion to approve the do I have a motion to approve the reports you don't have I don't have to do that okay okay school committee requests for future agenda items or legal opinions Laura um I'd like to add a future agenda item four to revisit the or not to revisit but to look over and make a change to the rules of conduct regarding the agenda setting okay um and then on at the November meeting I had made a request for a future agenda item that never got put on the agendas
183and it was to it was for a discussion about the homework policy I'm not sure why that never ended up on the the December agenda but um I'd like to read I haven't received anything from you for the homework yeah well I made the request to have it put onto the agenda so that a discussion so that it could then get put to the subcommittee because I was told during the during the subcommittee meeting that it would just get pushed I I didn't realize that I was supposed to submit additional information about the homework policy because it impacts teachers workday you have we have to bring it to school Improvement teams so then I need to understand what you were looking for for changes so that I can advise the school Improvement teams to review
184the homework policy based on your concerns okay so there are specific policies that have nothing to do with teachers workday and there are policies per their contract that they have a responsibility and then in the school Improvement team that they have to review so if I if you want to use your homework which is fine but the school committee can't take up homework policy until we know specifically what school commit wants to do so then the school Improvement teams can review and then the teachers can also review as um as part of their contract so as has been in the past I think what would be helpful is if can you put your requests in writing and if that's if that's able to um you could um just address that to the to the chair
185and just put future agenda item in the subject line so okay it doesn't get lost in my emails okay yes be specific there's a lot of generalization that people want answer and it's not fair to the superintendent or or Greg that it's specificity is helpful yes thank you um was there a comment from the from the audience Rory Hopkinson congratulations thank you all new members uh I have a comment about something that could possibly be put on the agenda at some point I believe that Hope Valley Elementary still doesn't have a play scheduled and I didn't know if that was something that was going to happen because they have a school play every year and it seems this year that was not allocated before the uh switching of principles there was money that wasn't allocated
186for a play that Hope Valley Elementary students do thank you thank you okay do we have a motion to adjourn mam chair I make a motion to adjourn second all in favor anybody opposed we are adjourn thank you so much have a great night