001e e e calling the work session to order for February 13th I'd like to thank our officers that came in Cooper and contess appreciate you um let's uh let's go to the consent agenda I need a motion in a second actually Mr chair actually Mr chair it's just a work session so we can just ask if there's any any questions about it well oh yeah that's right no motion that's we're not voting on it tonight okay my mistake okay any discussion on the consent agenda okay I think we can move right along superintendent report thank you Mr chair uh as you all know uh we made a decision to bring you all a draft budget ahead of our traditional schedule just as a a reminder we have an obligation to get our budget uh to
002the commission before April 1st and they have actually scheduled their first review Rachel if I'm not mistaken the last week in March March 24th March 24th is their first scheduled meeting but we want to get this to you in February as a rough draft so that you all have time to ask questions of us so Rachel has prepared a rough draft we've left a hard copy at each of your at each of your workstations there um my experience is it's nice having a hard copy because you can flip from page to page because there's so many inter relationships between those uh included in that packet we have a draft supplement schedule I think Rachel put it in the front in the front pocket uh Rachel's going to give you a powerpoint describing the the core
003pieces of of this draft budget mixed in her Powerpoint Vicky Hall is going to take over for a little bit to discuss uh some of the pay issues that we that we have addressed in there uh and I got got one other preface and then I'm going to turn it over to Rachel to give you all the PowerPoint and uh Mr chair um I'll invite however you guys want to handle it with questions as as as these as these slides come up versus waiting my gut tells me probably we're better off with just questions as they come uh just just based on the volume of what Rachel's going to present there's a couple places where I may say there's let's get through one slide and then we'll go back to it better than that okay
004uh so so the the other piece is is what I I know you all know which is the revenue side of the budget is is is really unknown at this point we have some Basics that Rachel's going to share with you uh we don't have a lot of detail from the state yet on on what their budget plans are but we just heard a little bit of a hint the day before yesterday at the tsba meeting uh related to uh budget the what we think of as a cost of living increas has traditionally come at the state level we have not heard directly from the state but the tsba meeting did share with us that they projected a little bit less than a 3% increase in the TSA base uh So based on what we
005heard the day before yesterday Rachel's made some adjustments there uh and again this is a work in progress so with that Rachel thank you very much uh as Mr Golden said you do have the packet in front of you and so we'll take it piece by piece uh as we go through each section I that's where I'm saying let's get through the Section and then we'll um follow up with questions along each um after each and so uh as you go through your packet we're going to talk about enrollment Personnel um our general purpose School Fund Central cafeteria fund extended school program fund and then capital projects is how we'll we'll end it see we're going to start sorry there's your these are the things we're going to touch on tonight and then um first
006thing when you go through your actual binder starting on page six you're going to see um information about projected enrollment and uh it's broken down by school it's got EC and prek is included um in the first couple of columns on that but then um K12 is listed out and so what's on the slide in front of you is just where our current enrollment is and then at the top are the numbers for projected so as you can see we are looking at projecting that we are going to go down enrollment um about 300 students total 15 within k12 and 150 between EC and prek having said that that's going to be starting the year um as children qualify they'll pick up within um EC as we go along so do you have any anything
007you want to talk about related to enrollment yes so last year I think I remember correctly that it was growth and now it's I'm just ious how you got to the negative growth I I can speak to that um uh Alison yeah Allison Nunley and her team uh got information from local developers and from the municipalities uh and projected out what we expected with growth we are actually projecting a reduction in total students this year uh and that's that um uh actually go to p six and yeah we we actually projecting a reduction in total student enroll enrollment by 4400s of a perc minus 044 that's based on those projections we believe that uh we are going to have more seniors graduate this year than kindergarteners so that's the main that's the main issue I
008just how did they figure that uh Jason um you know with all the growth we see Apartments uh subdivision after subdivision and yet we're not projecting growth what what we've seen is we have seen some some growth at the middle school level but not at the elementary level uh so if if we boiled down to each individual class we see some growth at most of those grade levels but the graduating seniors number is so much larger than the number of kindergarteners coming in I'll tell you my my interpretation the cost of buying a house is getting much more difficult for those young families uh and so they're they're used to well this tradition is still there a lot of private schools in in in the Nashville area will have a a jump in enrollment at
009the middle school level uh families might be okay in in some in some counties with their children attending elementary school but they save up for Middle School uh I think we're seeing some hint of that in the context of buying in a house uh that they're they're finding a way to move in a few years into their into their family in a way that's that's new and really if this happens this is the really the third year of this trend so um that's in so Allison does statistical analyses of of each of the neighborhoods and how many children are in each in each home our software allows us to pinpoint exactly where each child is at each particular house she can do polygons around those areas and project neighborhood numbers um so it's really a
010combination of all those but she starts with how many students are matriculating from one grade to the next so we start with who we have and then we project growth um over over and above that and it's not an exact science it's a it's an estimate okay any any more questions okay the next section um we're going to discuss is Personnel so if you'll go ahead and you can turn over to Pages starting on page eight and we talked about Staffing standards a couple of months ago uh we have to submit every year to the state what our staffing standards are and how again just a reminder that those ensure that we are providing the same services at every school uh and so we're looking at our enrollment and then what our teacher um to
011student ratios are to make sure that we're Staffing accordingly there are things that are there's a memo that goes along with that when we um send it to the state when we submit it to the state and a couple of the items on the Staffing standards everything for the most part is what we've already been doing we just went ahead and added the verbiage onto the actual Staffing standard and we're going to take it out of the memo it can be in either place but we just felt like it was cleaner for everybody to see in one spot what those what those items are and so there were adjustments those are going to be read that's what you're seeing and read or any adjustments that were made or or wording added but things like um
012assistant superintendent ratio at middle school we have one that's a very large middle school and so there was an adjustment to it Elementary School same thing for that higher number where we had just not had enrollment that high before and we felt like it was time to add an additional line um onto those standards and so those are the kinds of things you're going to see line in there about uh middle school and high school music &p that's something that's normally been in the memo we're putting it onto the Staffing standard um so if you have any questions about that about the Staffing standards themselves just feel free to ask and I I did want to add one piece one of the one of the standards we set um for for Budget was to stick
013to these Staffing standards strictly this year uh so as as we went through that we looked at each each one of of our schools um we sometimes have spots where we we notice there might we might need some specific help with a specific issue uh especially with students with disabilities we identified that um with with assistant principal work to make sure there's more people to to to perform those Services that's an example of of where the Staffing standard might have changed um uh you might notice on your document I know Rachel you haven't gotten there quite yet because you're still talking about the Staffing standard but um our position control report actually shows a net reduction in staff uh from from the current year at the bottom of page six what are strings Orchestra Orchestra
014Orchestra stringed instruments yes so just a quick question under Elementary the coaches are marked out so but then it has two total per school so what are the schools getting to decide what they need or that was just a word that had not been in there before um and so they do get make sure I'm not speaking out of but we we've provided a literacy and a math coach to each and it just didn't say total so we added total so no they don't decide they have a literacy coach and a math coach oh well the strike through is what it looks like those are struck through and I didn't know what that okay got so should it say two on page eight on Elementary where the coaches it there's a strike through coaches per
015building one math one literacy if you look right above that the wording says math litery coaches two total per School correct but I didn't know if it was a change or yeah or if the schools were going to get to decide maybe they need to literacy coaches instead of math coaches I see what you're saying we were just trying to clean up the chart and it probably probably reflects poorly but that's actually not a change I had a similar qu well a little different but um I've been in talk with some of my middle schools and um I know that and I think superintendent golden I think we've talked about this where there's a situation where you know in a middle school team say sixth grade you have three English teachers three Math teachers three
016social studies and then we have two science teachers yeah and I think that that I'd like to see us have equality you know where we have because that puts a lot on those science teachers where we have the same where some one subject area that carrying you know 33% more workload yeah and so I know there's are harder maybe to fill but I think that's really important well thank you for that and I I will invite Dr web potentially to speak to that to this so when we set up our staffing standards it's based on the pupil teacher ratio and then the principles need to set schedules based on that so it is possible that there might be for example a CTE program that's that's getting it started in middle school or to Dr jer's
017Point perhaps the strings um where a principal is is trying to structure a schedule that allows there to be more options for the students um Dr we anything else you want to add to that but you're right those those are difficult times sometimes where the where the ratio of a the the pupil teacher ratio may be different for a particular class um and I know grassland middle has had that very example I think that's the one you and I were talking about yeah it's hard on morale when they see they're getting you know more and they have labs to set up and it's a lot more work and then I have one more question um when you say the I think I wrote this down the PCR the net redu there's a net reduction in
018staff is there certain areas that there was or did just across the board we'll get there in just a minute okay sorry sorry I jumped ahead on on Rachel myself so I apologize for that so do we have any data to support the um all the instructional coaching positions that are in place like what type of impact that they're having um because it looks like we have at least two per school and in high school it might be even more if it's over it looks like one coach per for 500 I'm just wondering do we and if we do I'd like to see it so thank you for that question we do we do have data um from a scientific standpoint of course there are a lot of variables uh but U we do we
019we have some data related to the uh experience level of our teachers as well uh and I know Dr Allen and I especially have had some deep conversations about that I will say that our um our instructional leadership has actually asked for some additional supports for those coaches because we know that that enabling all teachers to grow and become better teachers especially in in in in helping students identify the standards and making adjustments based on those common formative assessments it continues to have a premium um but yeah we'll make sure we get you some data related to that um our team is convinced that um the the the schedule that we've gone through with focusing on uh uh professional learning teams common formative assessments and then having the coaches work with the teachers to make
020adjustments is a key reason that we are continuing to grow um so we'll get you some some objective data plus we can share some we we can share some qualitative information as well Dr Allen anything is there anything you like to add to that at this point I I think it's a good point we we've talked about finding better ways to quantify the impact we qualitatively see it and toally see it on a daily basis one of the things that that I would suggest from a board perspective that we could offer up is for you to do a walk along with them during the day so for example um you know our our our teacher candidate pools as Mr Gold mentioned are much more shallow than they have historically been the coaches are a vital
021part throughout the school year in helping those new teachers progress but quantifiably working to see the number of cycles that our coaches um um are working with our teachers on and what specific goals they have with the teachers and then the data will be specific to that individual teacher in that individual classroom and the outcomes of those individual students so we're looking to wrap our arms more around the quantifiable part but while we do that um I would invite you any time to to to come and do a walk along with us so you can actually see in action what it looks like um I think it might be might be good opportunity for you do just a question about the literacy coaches before we move on um do they work at all with the
022students or do they just work solely with the teachers good question thank you for that so um so we are interventionist when when we get to the part in the budget where we talk about interventionists those interventionists work with our students who are in what we call tier three the most um needed academic supports their schedule is filled from the minute that they get in the building till the minute that they leave uh in the evening working with students we run that as lean as we possibly can we actually meet annually to look specifically at the exact numbers that each building has in terms of uh tier three students and we move the interventionist to the need of the uh of the building which causes uh some some conversation in the building because we're moving
023people and it it we kind of move their cheese a little bit so those are really identified to work with the students your question about the coaches in almost every building there is an extra group or two because we run the intervention is soan where the coaches will have to provide that tier three service for the students so instead of for example when we have um uh we would run into a a net positive where an interventionist would have a a a block in their schedule by over allocating we actually intentionally under allocate the interventionist because then we'll have the coaches um uh work with the students um to make sure that we're running that as lean as possible with those with those interventions so the coaches might model lessons um in classes that do
024have an assigned teacher to grow those teachers but many of them all also would have a group um for RTI tier 3 intervention but that that varies a little bit from school to school based on those who are identified as tier three we don't have any other questions related to the Staffing standards one question sorry go ahead sorry so we said two total per school so we have one one math one literacy that's correct it just okay and that's okay gotcha gotcha thank you Mr Golden if I may that's just K8 at the high school we just have one instructional coach per I'm sorry did you did you point that out I mean it says one instructional coach for school so only the school's over 500 oh okay I was thinking it was like one
025instructional coach per 500 kids okay got it so just one coach and so so yeah Renaissance and the alc um are sharing right that help glad you asked because I didn't have writing okay one thing I should have said to start with I'm realizing I didn't we're going to go through this and you're take it home and then you're going to have a hundred questions that are going to come up and that's why we were like go ahead we'll go ahead and do this in February so you can ask ask the questions you've got plenty of time to ask what traditionally is going to happen you're going to ask a question and it's going to be something that somebody else has thought and hasn't asked yet or wondered about but didn't actually ask so when
026we when you send a question we that we that would be Jason myself VII whoever is answering the question we'll send it back to the whole board so you can see what's been asked and it just helps everybody um clarify where we are and then when we come back in March and actually present the budget to you if there are questions that came came up over and over that we need to discuss where everybody publicly can hear what those questions were and the answers we provide that then um as well so I'm saying that to you take your time do not feel panicked right now of well you just handed this to me how am I supposed to know what to ask we didn't expect you to um clearly you're going to have some questions
027as we go along but the expectation is is you are going to have questions call email and and then we'll answer those okay so just to reemphasize you're not going to think everything you want to asked to tonight so please feel free to ask over these next few weeks okay so page 11 starts the PCR um and that's the position control report we talked about principales cannot wait to get their PCR because this kind of projects for them what their Staffing uh would look like in the coming year so that they can help with hiring again I can't say it enough this whole thing I even put rough draft um on it didn't even put draft this is the bones of it um we don't have any information to hard information on revenues yet so
028it's hard to give you a budget when I don't know what that side's going to be every day we get closer to the to the end of the year we know more about what our spending looks like in our current year so just reminders of of that same thing with the PCR there's going to be changes that could happen within it because we have open enrollment so kids could go be open enrolled to another school and that school's population may go up and we may have to adjust so that school will get adjustments um and again Mr Golden said the net reduction was 35.6 positions and Miss Clemens to your question most of that is in the teacher line because we're adjusting to Staffing standards based on enrollment yes and let me say that doesn't
029mean that teachers are losing their jobs what that means is there's people retiring there's natural attrition people have moved um any number of things and so no we do not necessarily we're not saying that 35 teachers are looking to lose their job that's not the case at all through um possible shifts I think that's where we've landed it's a reflection of the 4400s of a percent reduction yes yes sir I'm looking on page 11 under Health Services other medical professionals is that where we have the mental health folks no I've been looking into the mental health of students and uh I wonder where ours are so Health Services other medical professionals if I'm not mistaken Rachel I'll let you answer it most it's nurses it still is Nurses a lot of it is the School
030nurses but then we have other um every school um has a nurse but then we have other nurses that are coming in and doing extra Services as well and if I'm not mistaken um some of the uh um services that we provide the students with disabilities are actually included in that is that right if it's medically related so we can get you some detail of those positions I'll make sure we get you some detail of those but it is not mental health professionals we um the first few pages again are a summary all the sheets behind it are related to the individual schools or indiv and then there's countywide um employees and what that means is that they don't necessarily serve one school they could serve multiple schools depending on what the role is and
031all that data is there those spreadsheets all pull into this summary sheet and so I have put out beside um anytime there was a change I kind of went ahead and told you what that change was I have a confession to make this this PCR summary looks a little bit busier because we have tried to clean some things up people are called one thing um which was named 20 years ago in the states come back and called it something else and so we're moving positions so you'll see several times within the PCR reclass to item below and we're just moving it between lines there's no change in Pay it's just reclassifying it so it actually matches what the state given us one of those items um were the coaches that is something that this year
032we're actually going to have to come back probably with you for a budget amendment to shift money because the state came out in the chart of accounts and said you have to list the coaches they can't be listed as a teacher they need to be listed separately and so part of moves that you're seeing on this chart again not new positions it's just pushing them into separate or um new new lines that's going to take y'all some time to look through I fully um understand that so you may not have a question right now again as you dig into it feel free to ask and Rachel as I'm sitting here I'm thinking that other health professionals is largely occupational therapist and physical therapist some of those some of those services that we're providing yeah okay
033thank you okay any other questions Rachel could you give us a little explanation of like page 34 is this like trying to show all positions it's just a little bit different these are ones that are districtwide and so they get again they're not necessarily assigned to one individual school they may be serving numerous places across the district so you'll have some some G countywide or districtwide um positions and here's a little hint in case when you're looking at particularly like that page and it says 71100 again if you go back to the summary summary part of the PCR it's broken down into major categories so you can tie that to 71100 and then those next numbers tie again to the PCR numbers and you can see where they show up on that sum sheet did
034that make sense okay so the one that you actually asked about that page there are numbers going across above the titles they tie back to those major categories listed on that summary sheet for the PCR so to give kind of the synopsis and the way I process it the the PCR that starts on page 11 uh and goes through page 13 is a synopsis of the detail that goes through page 35 35 that's right so Rachel for I guess help me with the the net reduction of 35 I I see some I I gu the reclass is out for the for the coaches but it says ultimately on regular specialy teachers just on page at the top that first line item on page 11 due to Staffing standards in enrollment like we we haven't haven't
035really are we change are we were we're not changing the Staffing standards it's the Staffing standard we're following the Staffing standard based on our enrollment which calls for then a reduction but I guess if we're if we're reducing by 0 4% is that I guess are we seeing something this year where we're where our our current Staffing is below the level just based on how everybody's split up among the teachers so we do not hire again we don't hire unless it's there so the positions may have been in the PCR last year but unless the enrollment was there we do not hire that position and so between the two years yes we're looking at total that we're seeing that the the enrollment is down okay I mean I know like one a couple couple more
036teach a couple more students at a at a particular school might might mean that we so it's all how the how the is spread among grade which is again why we're saying this is a draft this can this is the draft because it will change we have full confidence that there will be some things that are going to change in that if there is again with open enrollment 50 kids go to brenwood high school then their PCR is going to change related to that increase and vice versa 50 kids left to school same thing well and to and to your point the aggregate for 52 schools doesn't equal each individual school right because we have to base it on individual schools so any more questions um again I know there are questions and they'll come
037back up but are you ready to move on to the next we're going to talk just briefly about Revenue so revenu again the three big buckets sales tax property tax and Tissa for sales tax I do not anticipate getting December sales tax uh the last week of February which is a good indicator for me for the rest of the year and so right now I'm doing what I've done the last several years which is just projecting a 3% increase and so sales tax revenue would be a $6.8 million increase in Revenue property tax we've been told from the commission that they are going to have discussions in March they'll present the property reappraisal information at that point in time this is solely going to be on the commission and what they decide to do with
038the value of the allocation they give us what we generally do is 1% um when it's a non appraisal year increase by 1% so that's what I've projected as of now we'll see where we land there Tisa funding um we haven't been told what the new base is going to be we haven't um um really been given any information as of yet again last week of February we're supposed to have a first estimate for that so what I've done is made some assumptions one um have gone ahead and added 200 to the base mainly did that because the state's budget what they had budgeted for the increase in Tisa and the total number of students we had last year and kind of backed into it and just said good guess and so that's where we
039are right now it may be higher um it may be lower um we do know that the enrollment is down so average daily membership which is our enrollment plays into the T the calculation so I know that's down and I also feel very confident that fiscal capacity is going to go up which works against us as well reminder fiscal capacity means we have the ability to pay therefore we pay more um our share is higher than other County share um for the 7030 split that we have with the state so in making those assumptions um our total D draft draft draft but budgeted revenue is $500 million that's that total at the bottom so if I may mention a couple things that this doesn't include um this does not include whatever decisions County government makes
040related to the property tax rate basically and I'm oversimplifying Rachel about two-thirds of our funding comes from the sales tax and property tax and about a third from Tisa usually two to 3% from federal but that's not part of this budget and largely that Federal money we get serve students with disabilities so the the biggest variable is we don't know that a second variable on Tissa is like I mentioned earlier day before yesterday we we heard from tsba that projection of somewhere close to a 3% increase in the base amount now we don't get all that from the base the base is the state's projected share from the locals and the state uh so we have incl included that in there um but things might change at the state level also you guys may remember
041that when we had a conversation with our legislators a couple of weeks ago Senator Johnson said that he was looking to try to find a way to offset the fiscal capacity uh this projection does not include any funds from that because that that hasn't been realized yet any other big ones I should mention Rachel those are the big pots okay they really are and if you guys I didn't say that want to turn to page 37 um in the book that'll catch you up to where um we're discussing the revenues and expenses for general purpose school funding so Rachel based on based on our estimate of of how the appraisals are going to increase and what the estimates that we've already gotten um and and what happened last year with fiscal capacity at you know
042the $ three5 million hit I I mean we're any estimate of what that and will will it impact us for the for this NE upcoming school year absolutely okay so what I did um is went ahead and increased the fiscal capacity assuming it's going to increase it may increase more than what I've estimated but with this projection um I did go ahead and take that into account try to based off of the fiscal capacity increases for the past two years based on what we've heard from the county commission so far the property reassessment seems to be it's going to be a really high reassessment and so I feel like that that number the fiscal capacity number could go even higher what was what was the what what adjustment did you did you estimate a 0.1%
043increase which sounds super tiny but it's huge but what what did that make what did that do to us in terms of uh it's about a $5 million difference okay that's lower than I thought actually but that's included here that's already been included so if they don't if it doesn't go that high then that would be you know that would work in our favor we um well tdoe is obligated to let the locals know by May um what they are going to do with fiscal capacity so that's one of the reasons we had that light hit um that two and half million dollar three and a half million actually um reduction from what we had projected because that came a little bit late and I expect we're going to get it again that late and
044kind of to your point Mr galber the the $200 increase in the base um did you think well that should be able to cover it and it didn't that's why we're a negative2 million any other on that on that exciting news any other questions you want to talk about Revenue okay we will move on and if y'all want to come back just please feel free to speak up what I wanted the reason I said go ahead and turn to page 37 um what you're seeing on the screen in front of you now is a Reconciliation that gets us from where we were last year to the what's listed in your um binder is the current year revised how did we get from our original to our current revised and again this is just a reminder
045these are the things that I come back with each month and ask you all to vote on of the money listed all of it is Grants which we do not budget for because we're not guaranteed anything it's it grants or it's carryovers from the prior year of Grants and donations the only item that we actually expensed this year that's in addition to the original budget that was from the funds that we had we pulled for the bus purchase out of fund balance and that's that bottom line that 1.4 million everything else like I said is Grants but I wanted you to understand how we got from point A to point B so you could see it okay now we're going to talk about and so this is where I'm going to tell you I'm going
046to go through the slide I don't want you to ask questions just yet because we actually are going to go through and talk about each one of these lines um this is a summary of how we got from our original budget last year to the budget that's listed in this packet tonight um we are looking at operational increases of well I'm going to talk about that just a operation increases and a lot most of it as you can see is related to payroll that bottom line we'll also discuss of the reduction in the payroll lineups so let's talk about operations when we first met operational request and when I say met that's the leadership team it's the people you see sitting over um here tonight when we met the requests were 9.6 million over last
047year Department directors assistant superintendents met with each one of their groups and they went ahead and cut 3.5 million from that number then each group met with Mr Golden and he's cut another 755,000 out of it so our final operational request over last year are 5.4 million dollar more of that 6.1 is is in technology it's in Chromebooks and reminder that last year very similar this was the same number and we ended up having to cut that out of the budget because we couldn't we did not have enough funds to to fund it and we ended up funding it through capital and so we want to get this in the budget it is a recurring item that is happening every year so just idea State talking to me general purpose School fund are true operations
048you can expect it we know it's happening every year fund balance is really supposed to be able to fund those items that are extraordinary that we didn't anticipate or or a large purchase that is made not necessarily frequently and so we really would like to get the Chromebooks in a rotation it department has the plan that if it gets into the general purpose budget they have a ongoing revolving plan of how to replace so that it is a instead of huge spikes in one year you can pretty much count on this is what the technology replacement cost would be every year um in in FMA I want to give you a little bit of a of a a peek at where we're headed you may notice that Rachel included in her Powerpoint replaces second through
049fifth grade devices our plan for this coming year is still in the works but we do not intend to replace kindergarten in first um we did an analysis of U of kindergarten and first grade usage um and our our plan at this point based on that usage I'm going to give you a little quick synopsis we we've looked at a couple of weeks two separate independent weeks of time just just this fall related to usage kindergarteners on average are using those devices between 22 and 33 minutes a day largely that is during instructional time where they are at stations uh doing some uh doing some sometimes it's remediation work sometimes it's directed work towards towards particular uh towards particular skills um first grade it varies between 21 and 39 minutes uh per day uh we
050don't think that it's the appropriate thing to buy devices for them so right now our plan is not to buy those devices to take older devices and assign them at at a two to1 or 3 to1 ratio at the at the school level students will not take their devices home in kindergarten first on top of that we are put putting together a committee to evaluate screen time uh student screen time to to make some longer term decisions and evaluations related to this uh Dr Allen I know I just gave a tiny little synopsis because we're going to be working this over the over the next few months any information you want to add to that well just this this the study on screen time we you all have brought it up we've been listening it's
051been on our minds for a long period of time and so um we feel now is the time to write we right to to dig into that um we want to include some representation from the board a representative from the board to be a part of that committee um and and some community members and staff members to look at the research to get our arms around to what what's actually happening um we do see a significant difference between active what is called active and passive screen time um active screen time meaning students engaging the device for instructional purposes versus passes screen time like maybe an indoor recess where the an indoor recess where they're playing games and so maybe putting together through this committee putting together some guidelines based on the research and based on
052what what we feel is appropriate for our youth um to give to our teachers to provide them some guidance um and so we're really excited about getting that work started um we're glad Mr Golden has pushed Us in that direction to really to get a group together and take a look at it and so we're excited about what engaging with you and what we can bring back to you and what we can give to our teachers in terms of guidance and by the way Dr Allen mentioned that phrase indoor recess we're still doing that physical recess you're talking about additional time over and above o over and above the the actual physical recess um teap in elementary are they still doing paper pencil or is it computers uh paper pencil up through fifth grade and
053it's um okay we don't have any indication that that's going to change but it could because one of the things I've been hearing from lots of parents is even going up to third grade to reduce the amount of screen time cuz they're like they really are not happy with screen time and I wondered how that might affect that number if we change that from like just fourth and fifth grade instead of leaving out you know K1 yeah what we're in the process of going through that um at third grade in that window of time average daily minutes have ranged between 27 and 56 minutes so there are some times for third grade that there are doing those interventions a little bit more deeply um Dr Allen also uh the state screeners let's we talked about
054TCAP and by the way on TCAP we I get questions and I know some of your team does from time to time from the state they continuously ask us hey what about doing uh uh the TCAP for the younger grades online historically my experience is by and large the super attend and say no and and and we keep on getting the question uh you know so that tells me that they long term they continue to be thinking about it because they haven't put that question to bed if that makes sense Dr Al let's talk about the screeners uh that lead to um tiered interventions so I think you captured Mr Gold beginning in third grade our screeners which were required to which were required to uh administer three times a year are all online yeah
055um and so but then also when students uh would trigger additional supports we actually monitor those students every other week um through assessing them more frequently to monitor their progress through progress monitoring and so they they use those devices for that as well beginning in third grade so the state has two basic chunks of test uh one is a screener that identifies um which students need interventions on skills that are necessary to receive that grade level instruction those are the screeners we're talking about at third through fifth grade those are online TCAP evaluates Mastery of Standards at the end of the year those are still on paper uh at the elementary level I was curious about um because I'm I'm thankful that y'all took off kindergarten first what was the what was the screen time
056usage compared in second grade based on the data that we had the the range was between 27 and um 48 minutes because I I spent a lot of time in the second grade and third grade classrooms and I think it's fascinating to see how much they grow up in third grade yeah but I I would even say there's an argument to be made that I I don't think they need them in second grade because they're still working on the F motor skills learning how to write writing sentences you know um that's just my two cents and I think you know third grade would be an I would like at least third to be the youngest um my thoughts we'll have another discussion to revisit that Dr Al I think we kind of started in the
057same place um and I think through the conversations especially with second grade teachers we start we started to see a lot more significant use among them and we had a lot of teacher feedback um that they actually wanted to to continue to use in second grade but we I think we kind of started in the same boat thinking K through2 and we worked our way back to K through one for what it's worth um and Andy is here as well I don't know if if if Andy can add anything and and the only thing that I just wanted to add was that we do have Tennessee State computer science standards that are k12 and so there are Ted standards that are taught integrated into our Core Curriculum and so I think that's where we were
058most concerned and teachers were most concerned is that that the second graders didn't have their hands on the computer a little bit more often that you would be pushing up some of those skills to third grade and so we know how important third grade is and just some of the other impacts with the third grade law and things like that so I think that's a great point I I think I just having them Tak them home with them every day but have may maybe getting closer to a one to one ratio in the third in the second grade classroom and then maybe I don't know just I mean just my thoughts thank you for that we again we'll revisit that discussion Dr alen and Mr Gold and I just want to make sure everyone knows
059Andy Davis I think everybody does but she's our director of instructional Technologies so sorry Rachel I felt like I needed to mention that right there so Jason I guess I'd love to see the screen time that you um that you got if like even into high school I'm really I'm really interested into how much our student and and and I know y'all can't you probably don't measure the time that they're on it outside of outside of school as far as on the the Chromebook even um but it's their it's their portal into everything and I mean I can't I I'm actually scared to to look at it's funny screen time used to be this thing that the um that the pediatrician would ask um and they and it's like we don't even we don't even
060talk about it anymore um because they know that they're on their screen for five or six hours at school plus the five or six hours outside of school um and it used to be a used to be a thing that we that we talked about but since we got since we got computers in the in the classroom and at they you know taking home with them every day we it's something that we just we just ignore and I want to try to make sure that we highlight it and figure out how to how to get them um off of it as much as we can during the classroom during we'll talk to Andy um I I do have some more data I can share with you especially about K5 that Andy worked on um we
061may have to have a conversation about how long it would take to gather up some data about the oldest grades because I know it it includes some some drill down and some assistance from from tech companies if I'm not mistaken um yeah and did you want me to respond to that I can respond to that so we use class link just like you guys start when you log into your WCS issue devices you have the class link dashboard they have an analytics dashboard Unfortunately they don't have it where we can get real time grade band data it's something that they're working on they're actually developing um a new data warehouse that they're working in the background so when we ask for data on grade bands we have to reach out to them they write scripts
062in the back ground it takes them a couple weeks to get that back to us so we can pull some of that data but again because it's so much data we have to take short windows of time and then it wouldn't be something that we can monitor necessarily in real time but Jay that's actually one of the things we were talking about that's going to be relevant to the committee evaluating screen time um for sure and including weekends right for those who are taking it Taking those devices home we have another issue that we have haven't touched on I know is that that that we've had some discussions on it related to filtering has nothing to do with budget um but uh we do have um some substantial filters um that we're constantly working on
063and I know you guys have had some questions from parents some of those websites you have to be careful about what they have access to YouTube's an example that we've been working on recently Brian I know that you all have have worked on on resetting some of the some of the this filter is not the appropriate word um actually with with YouTube it's just there settings settings yeah thank you um so that's a that's a constant effort too uh in addition to the screen time and Mr Gold I would add the discussion about second grade in the one to one and taking them home uh to miss cl's question there has been discussion of leaving them one to one and possibly not having them take them home that adds an additional cost which would be
064carts which we currently don't have charging charging cards because if you're going to leave them at school there has to be a way from them to be charged so it wouldn't be the so there would be some additional cost with that if we went that route sorry Rachel a couple other things that I just don't want to uh I think I kind of said it but I want to go back to it when I say that the the operations originally we the directors cut 3.5 million that is not an easy process and so when you really think about um even technology this is what brought it back up in my mind all of our software for the most part every department has something that is driving for me um and the finance department our software
065is very expensive and most of it has a built-in annual increase of 3 to 5% and so when we sat down this year we were really looking at every line was this effective was it not could should we use it should we not could we try something different um there are things that that 9 million in requests over what we asked last year we have needs and it's just like we talked with capital we have to prioritize and think what can we what what's the bare minimum that we have to have and it's hard it is truly hard to look at people that are working that need items that they know would enhance what they're doing and would help with what they're doing and say no we can't can't afford it this year because we
066have other things that we prioritized and most of the time that's going to be our people so those were hard decisions those were hard hard conversations to have and go through and I don't want to just gloss over and say oh yeah we just cut it was hard so the fact that if we didn't have those computers in there that we were already um would have been under where we were last year operations is amazing between inflation and like I said those buil-in increases that just happen every year and so I hard work was done and I and I really want to um I don't know the pat on the back but I want to point that out that that it was done we are taking we are getting feedback we hear what you're saying
067and we're trying to be mindful of the resources um and using them to the best of our ability well and and I want to I want to speak specifically to Dr Allen and Dr Royer and Dr Webb and really those are the those are those three um assistant superintendents who who lead our mission which is to educate our children uh keep keep children safe and educate them uh and they had they've they've they brought a list of things that they had already C down we've had the discussion about one of my phrases that I often mention success is tenuous um we know we have limited supplies we know we're government we know that that the tax money is and should be very tight uh and so it those are very difficult conversations as I I
068basically put them in the position of having to grow our students without sometimes without the with without the resources that they have determined are our best way to do that uh so I think it is important for us to mention that that we have not said yes to to everything um not said yes to some things that Rachel described as needs uh be because of because of where we are and so it's it's that difficult balance knowing that ultimately right now our our draft expenses exceed our projected Revenue so I may at some point share some details of those specific positions that they've that they've asked for that that are not included in this budget because we just determined we we we just can't project out that we're going to get the funding for it
069okay we're going to go on again um that was that first operations the next several lines Vicki Hall is going to go over with you so I'm going to turn it over to her and then I'll come back at the very end for to last those payroll line reductions thank you Rachel so we started out when we were looking for um the pay charts this year looking to see what we could do we started with the goal that uh the board presented to Mr Golden which was to propose a pay increase within available funding that focuses on improving competitive pay for all positions with a focus on supplements and hard to fill positions so we kind of started trying to uh meet that goal and um and took that um and went on the next
070uh steps with that so what that led to for us was that we would propose or recommend a 2% increase on all of the pay charts um that would at least provide some measure of Improvement for all positions and you know maintain our competitiveness within the market um which I look at our Market you know with teachers primarily as other local districts that are near us that we all kind of compete for the same candidates um there's you know different wider markets when it comes to some of the classified positions but largely we do compete a lot with other leas and Vicki if I may I want to I'm sorry to interrupt I want to mention two things number one these proposals that she's talking about are proposals that that are that are number one
071based on the description we had we we have in my goal of available funds these funds are not available yet this is based on what County government has talked about potentially funding us um four four perc so that what we're talking about is using what they may give us for a proposal second big piece we have an obligation uh and frankly a joy sometimes and I'm not being sarcastic a joy of having conversations with the Williamson County Education Association the WCA through Pekka we have an obligation to propose this to them as well uh so this is a precursor to those meetings um so I felt like it was important for me to mention those two things okay so starting with teachers um on 2% on the teacher chart will offer teachers about a 4%
072increase per step because they have an automatic role so every year they um move up at least about 2% as it is so with the role and the 2% teachers would receive about a a 4% um that bottom line there where the teacher step um 21 will go up approximately 12% that is because we stop pay chart at line 21 a lot of districts go to line 25 so our theory was a few years ago let's go ahead and give the teachers that money down at line what they would be making at line 25 so that's how we arrive at that number we think it's a retention tool and potentially a recruiting tool because when we hire teachers in like from out of state that's where we start them is at that line so knowing
073that teachers are you know making choices to retire you know if you're at year 16 and you think I could go ahead and retire and do something else if you kind of offer that incentive of that big increase at year 21 we get the value of that experienced teacher staying with us they go ahead and get that increase and additionally it that helps their retirement so we're hoping that that is an incentive for them to stay with us a little bit longer um and as long as we're talking about teachers I do want to just you know there's there's a lots of positions that need attention but teachers continue to be our biggest struggle especially those special education teachers but the pool is sh is shrinking and we just have they're a limited number and
074they are very specific we've got to find licensed teachers they have to be endorsed in the appropriate area um and our local universities which you know we get we get teacher candidates from all across the United States we really do we recruit out there and we bring some in but largely still we get a lot from our local universities this year they are probably there will be well below 200 teacher candidates that graduate in the spring from combining MTSU Vanderbilt Belmont lipsum Tennessee Tech that used to be MTSU alone so we're we're still in that in that uh predicament of really you know we're all kind of scrambling for the same teachers so our market analysis it has concluded that and you're G to get some more data from from Vicki in just a little
075bit our teachers are our biggest challenge in the market because we are competing with our neighbors for teachers uh so that's that's really the core of of of this discussion they are so we um this year we've are proposing that we increase that entry level pay by 2% because um you know we can't really move it up any higher because that affects the rest of the chart which is extremely expensive so um the recommendation is to make the starting pay at 51,100 um where we'll need to spend some emphasis I think coming up in in the coming years is on in kind of the earlier to Mid years of that chart we start out very well with our I'm going to call them competitors um and primarily in my experience it's Metro and ruford County
076um sometimes Murray County it just depends but we we do start out pretty strong but then we we fade off by by year five ruford county is is outp Ping us and if you think about teachers who especially if they come from a traditional pathway they graduate they work here for a few years they're ready to buy a house they can't afford it here so they can make more in Murphysboro and by a house so we're kind of we're fighting a you know a challenging battle um of course we are a great place to work so I'm going to say that but it's but that's that's why we have to strive for that we do offer a lot of supports for our teachers and we get lots of feedback about that too that they do
077feel very supported so um just wanted to just kind of let you know that that we're still in that in that struggle to find those teachers um is is there room in the budget for any incentives like Financial incentives like U 5,000 per teacher to if they stay on board for five years or any packages like that I haven't heard anything so one thing I mention is retention bonus um that we're going to increase um proposing to increase this year what we have done is we've offered um for hardto fill positions we have offered a early signing bonus of $6,000 we don't have very many of those we have about 50 but they're theyve been an excellent tool in fact some have already gone out for next year some student teachers we had um so
078they're a really good tool we pay them that when they when they come to work for us when they sign their contract and show up to work um that helps them with like moving expenses and things like that so we have done that um our retention bonus is something I'd like to work on more but um we do we do have some and I'll I'll talk about that a little bit because I'm going to um propose to to that we um increase that a little bit so on the classified chart I'm sorry did you have a question well I was just actually getting ready to ask for clarification about those pay charts can you tell us what those four are like I know teacher but yeah it sounds like you were going the right dire
079well I I was go I was just going to go to the classified chart um so with on the classified chart uh again the uh there's an application of that 2% increase across the board the classified chart roll R differently than the teacher chart it rolls in fiveyear increments there's a starting pay and then you go to band one through five and it rolls every five years so that roll is three to n% roughly um and so those individuals would see that increase as well plus the the 2% that is going to go on the chart did that answer your question Margie or and I guess my question is is this basically all staff is getting a 2% raise even everyone at central office even everyone that makes 174,000 100 plus thousand they're all getting
080a 2% raise is that the The Proposal is for all employees to get a 2% increase the proposal is that teachers get in essence 4% double what the others get um some classified folks because of the way we've structured it will will will receive a sub a more substantial pay increase um and those uh off that chart will get a 2% so yes the proposal is for everyone to get a minimum 2% Vicki has some more details related to some other additional pay for for some others other than the other than principles and and and specialist and uh and uh leadership staff go ahead Okay so we can if Rachel if you'll move me on we can talk about supplements because I know that's been a priority um so we um after we've had a
081lot of discussions about supplements um we started a group of like a focus group of athletic uh employees and also some of our staff from Fine Arts um we enlisted Mark kenzer and Darren joins to come in and join us with that and so we've spent uh pretty much a year or more looking at supplements across our um across the districts across the state primarily our our competition and we took the feedback from the group and they gave us their recommendations we we met in person a couple of times and then they also gave us a uh feedback on a spreadsheet where we were able to kind of go through analyze it so we have taken the recommendations we also did an internal Market study and this is basically what we came up with um
082for Fine Arts we were actually paying very well in all the categories except for Middle School band director so on the on the chart hopefully y'all can see it pretty well Williamson currently is in on the left side there in dark blue and the proposal is in that purpley color that's on the right side and then Rutherford Wilson Murray and mnps are in uh the middle so we did make some improvements there and we've shared this with that group and obviously there's things some different people would like to see but I think that the group was in consensus that this was a really good Improvement here and that we are moving in the right direction another thing though I do I want to mention I forgot to tell y'all this a big concern from the
083Fine Arts staff was that we were paying them a flat rate instead of a percentage rate so we have now moved all of Fine Arts onto a percentage rate and that's that's if I may that's actually the document that's in the pocket of uh of your notebook that was passed out oh sorry about that I forgot to tell you that oh yeah that's what previously we had just given like a flat sum of like 12 $1,250 for a particular position now we have structured that so that it's a percentage of where they are on the teacher chart and you do have have those charts in your packet so Rachel um we've hit a couple of items related to pay I'm wondering about the aggregate funding for each of those is that we're GNA get there
084we're gonna get there okay okay move on to Athletics so we also reviewed Athletics and you can see that we've got the same thing going here on this chart the Athletics we actually trailed in a few positions um and we have tried to make some corrections on that um one thing we kept in mind though was trying to keep some internal Equity internal Equity between Athletics and in the Fine Arts so that nobody's you know way outperforming or way out earning somebody else um basing that on hours and um that type of thing so we do I'll give y'all time I know to look at it because youve you've had questions about it over over time and by the way we're actually going to provide this this um slide deck as well we're going to
085post this so you'll be able to find the slide deck and study it okay and while we were at it we went ahead and looked at academic supplements those the academic supplements were um there we found a lot of districts didn't offer academic supplements but um some did but we did make an adjustment of about 4% to all of these categories this is just a sample of your the whole uh chart is in your packet but just to put it up here we went on our lowest end 675 to 700 this was what Mr Golden was just asking so the cost for each making these adjustments adjustments to the academics was 243,000 fine arts is 325,000 and then Athletics is 560,000 what is listed out beside that is how many we paid last year how
086many of these supplements we paid and it says FTE that means um thank you full-time equivalency I got the fulltime I was like what's my full-time equivalency meaning I could have someone getting paid a supplement um Vicki and I could split she does the spring and I do the fall and so she gets a05 and I get a0 five so full-time 1.0 positions all added together so as you can see um academics there's tons of those um and then Athletics and then fine arts is the smaller you all I may be jumping the gun oh sorry I am jumping the gun you've already hit it sorry you read our mind okay so we were mentioning um about the additional incentive recommendations so the hardto fill positions are something we do feel like we need to
087address for those uh staff and those positions who are already with us currently they receive a $600 uh retention bonus we are proposing to increase that to 1,200 to try to address um or attempt to begin to address that issue and then also with the um non 12month classified staff um The Proposal would be to give them two additional paid holidays the plan that we have considered is paying them that during spring break because a lot of times they they do have to go that whole week without pay so um we do believe that would be an incentive for them to stay as well so if I'm May related to that if I'm not mistaken has it been three years that we increased the 10-month classified pay by five pay days was it during Christmas
088during the so so three years ago we added five Holiday full paid days we put them in the in between Christmas and New Year um so this proposal includes uh adding two paid full days at the spring break period and Rachel that it may be the next Slide the way I'm going tonight but um what's the what's the cost on on a day for the classified 10 and 11 month employees it's about 260 because it was well 430 is what the total cost 435 for the $430,000 to add those two days and the the proposed increases to the supplements we project it's going to be somewhere between 1.1 and 1.2 million just I just want to make sure I had those numbers articulated so the last line when we were looking at the total budget
089had the Personnel cost reduction and again um the PCR is going to show a net change of 35.6 41.95 reduction um related to Staffing standards and enrollment the rest um we did have some additions and you can go through and see what that are what those are uh again a lot of it related to Staffing standards uh in increased enrollment we did have some couple of schools that had an increase we the number looks huge half of that are those are those reductions that you're seeing for teachers the other half is a is cumulative over several things and that includes we looked at actual we have dug in as as far as we can go at this point in actual lines and looked at the cost versus what we estimated to fill those positions what
090that means is when we have unfilled positions or when we add positions into the PCR we generally take an average of What the pay is for whatever that job class is and so sometimes it comes in higher than the average sometimes it comes in lower so we're actually looking at who has been hired into those positions now and can reduce uh some of those lines because they are below what that average is we also looked at the tax lines which is Social Security and Medicare those um when we put them in when we're estimating we're assuming it's full uh taxes on the gross pay but we have hsas we have medical expenses that come out that can be pre-tax contributions to 401ks and so we've looked at that um and can say okay well the
091actual Social Security Medicare is lower than the full amount on the gross pay so we've reduced that um and then we've also taken the PCR shows full-time positions for classified and 100% of the professional side is shown in the PCR but there were some part-time positions that have gone unfilled that were on the classified side and so we've gone ahead and reduced those out as well so we're looking trying to figure out where all our every penny we can get we're trying to figure out where we can pull that from and so the net reduction at this point in time in Personnel cost is the 6.3 million if I may on the pay side before we we we go to the next uh uh item that Rachel's mentioning just as a reminder the governor through
092his propos proposal related to esas or vouchers uh included a $2,000 one-time bonus for for teachers I sent that send an email with some detail to you all we we still don't know the net result of that um but it the way it's designed is those teachers who were teaching who are actually doing classroom teaching more than 50% of the time for example that would not include coaches as I read it uh and so so what we are proposing has nothing to do with that with that fund from the governor um there are some variables we still don't know for example we don't know will we have a responsibility to pay the employer portion of Medicare and Social Security uh Rachel is estimated based on our number of teachers classroom teachers that's somewhere around $800,000
093so we've got to figure out from the state what their expectations are for that are they giv us the 2,000 and they and all those withholdings get taken out of the 2,000 or is the employer going to have to contribute to it right so I mean at the the meeting on Tuesday they said they were trying to cover all that yeah so yeah we need to hold them to that that's yeah that's right so yeah they're still working they're still working on that so just wanted you guys to be aware that this that what Vicki has proposed has nothing to do with that 2,000 sorry go ahead Rachel so when again when we come to the table I thought I just wanted to share this information with you too there were $2.2 Million worth of
094request to adjust pay or just pay lines where Advocate that um it could be this particular position this job class we know is getting harder to fill and it needs an adjustment there were those requests there were also 5.2 million in new requests meaning we feel like if we had this this person it would benefit our staff in this way those um again are those hard conversations if when you listen to the I won't say an argument but the presentation on each one of those they make total sense and you can understand why the need is there what we have come to you with is adding truly adding one position which is the Innovation Hub the CTE Innovation Hub because we're going to have to have someone leading that and then those two classified um
095paid days for the classified 10 and 11 that classified so that's what we've asked you for what we're asking you for as of right now but there's s Million worth of requests that didn't make it into this document yet and I say yet if we had you know this great influx of money there would be things that we would come back in at but again trying to be mindful of the bottom line and what we feel like um is a reasonable ask so this particular slide I'm putting up here to show you the trend that we have seen our revenues and expenses over the last several years and as you can see the Gap is getting bigger and bigger um and so we have been able to present budgets and balance them by using what
096is fund we call fund balance and think of it in this way fund balance is your savings account and revenues and expenses are kind of in your checking account so you've got money coming in money going out and if my revenue is not as high as my expense then I can use fund balance to come in and cover the difference the is well two things to remember is we only budget 92% of property taxes and that's a requirement um from the county for us and so we know that there's always going to be more Revenue than what's listed here this is what was budgeted but we're going to have more Revenue in property tax um and that goes into fund balance the issue is if you don't have more money going into fund balance eventually
097your savings account runs out and so the Gap is getting bigger and bigger um and I just wanted you to be able to see that that last year when we came and we asked for uh we're told a 6% raise asked for the 6% raise that was a county um directive the money was not there we knew we didn't have the money same thing when we came um last year at the same time we knew we the money the revenue was not there um we're doing it this again and but I wanted you to get a visual of what it looks like that the revenues and expenses or not and some of you who've been on the board for a number of years um we'll recall in more recent years uh the County Commission is
098in essence said pay out of your fund balance rather than the tax rate uh and so that's what we've done uh last year with a pay increase we in essence paid it out of our fund balance they forgave a million dollars on the energy Savings Program uh so there's a little bit that they gave but largely that came out of out of uh out of fund balance um another piece was uh we they um we moved some some of our purchases to Capital um but again largely it came out of our fund balance so we have tightened that up this year uh we are at a stage that based on our fund balance we have in essence paid for this year with fund balance or our savings and we can't do it again next year
099based on our current projections of revenues correct and re again I want to say we get more in Revenue than we budget at times um and we may through donations through different things that come in um Revenue will go up again property tax because of it these are budgeted expenses we don't all we're not going necessarily spend every penny with positions that are open and when I say open that doesn't mean that they're unfilled all year but there are times people retire and you have gaps of of service and so there's going to be money left over in the pot so there's money going into fund balance but it is not a consistent I can't tell you we're going to have X amount of dollars every year going into fund ballots so again just want
100to keep you this and that in mind when we go to page 37 in your uh binder so what you're looking at then is the numbers you've already seeing what we're projecting for revenue and what we are projecting at the moment for expenses over on the left side is a summary of that projected Revenue that estimated fund balance is what as of February 11th that is what our projected fund balance is for this coming year so 48 million when the year ends were projected we' have 48 million so total resources we have available to be able to to balance our budget is 549 million our expenses are at 564 million we have a requirement that we also have to keep 3% of fund balance we cannot spend every penny of it we have to keep
101a minimum of that in our quote unquote savings account so our total expenses in that 3% fund balance is 580 again our total revenue is 541 so what I'm coming to you right now with is a gap for this budget of $31 million when we presented the budget in well we kind of talked about the budget if y'all remember everybody had a hard attack in February last year it was $60 million and then we got different information um from the county different little guidance on medical insurance was the huge thing there when we presented the budget last year in March that Gap was 25 million and So currently right now as of today this number is going to change between now and March again why we hate putting this information out so early because it
102can change drastically it has changed in the last week with every little piece of information we get we posted a payroll today with posting that payroll where they're going to take that data and we'll be able to hone in even further on numbers and so while this is a sticker shock at the moment am I going to cover 31 million no way am I going to get that number down sure to some degree um so I just wanted you to understand what that really looks like and what when we're showing you this bu budget right now that would be if we presented it today this would be where we stand is with a gap of 31 million does anybody want to say anything about that I got a question sure what was our what was
103our fund balance that we actually took into this budget year into this one uh right it's 70 so when you look at the audited financial statements it's going to show 80 um so it was about well I say 70 67 if I'm remembering correctly but part of that there a $15 million grant that we got for that CTE Innovation Hub that shows up because it flowed through 141 but we don't really count it because it's tied up so without without the with taking that 15 out we had 67 so I just wanted to I just want to point out so so basically I know this isn't our final fund balance we probably showed something less than that at this time last year and you're going to you know you're going to you're going to cut
104off cut off purchas for essential stuff only and we and and we get all the um you take all the uh unfilled positions and all that kind of stuff but then we can't overpay anything and so we have to underpay all of our line items so I get all that but but at the end of the day that we're going to be taking likely less from fund less of a a lower fund balance this year than we did last year and it's because we had to fund stuff out of our fund balance that should have been funded out of out of operating were it not for the budget shortfall that's right approximately 19 million right and so we'll we'll we'll narrow we'll narrow that Gap a little bit but in addition to our 4% raise
105that we're we're just we're starting out at a in a bigger hole and off of a off of a bigger number that this year um you know our our expenses are going up and and our fund balance that's used to fund it is going down um and our 3% you know obviously is going up but it's up because it's tied to this is it's just it's the it's the cumulative impact of kicking the can down the road um in addition to all of our our Capital that doesn't go away just because we fund less than our than our requests year after year after year so that's right um a quick question on instructional support there's a little over $10.3 million increase I can ask yes that specifically is one of the things that I was
106saying that the state came out with a new line they said all coaches have to be moved down they cannot be in the teacher line anymore so they're all getting moved into that into that major category so for example special education instruction went down a little bit uh um so that your coaches got you so what I want you to do too the front page there and what you're seeing on the screen this is a summary of each of the major categories and you can see um where we ended actual numbers and then current year our current year information and what we're projecting what you then have behind that is the detail for every one of these major categories um broken down further and so what when you flip through those pages the first page
107is going to be revenue and then the rest are the major categories there's a percentage out to the right that's going to show the change in that account um and I've anything that was big to me or stood out to me I went ahead and put you a note as to why that changed and so you'll actually find that reference in there that we've moved the instructional coaches to that line and so you'll see um they make sense to me they may not make sense to you so when you read a note and you go I have no idea what she's saying ask me what I'm saying and I'll gladly um clarify but I do this just for me as well so that I understand what what we're moving the 10 million are instructional coaches
108not like a I mean it it could be a number thing okay it could be several things but that's a b and you'll have the notes in here okay got you yes and again just fair warning if you see it's 100% increase and you go she didn't write anything if it was 50 and it went up to 100 I didn't because that's insignificant amount if it went from 50,000 to 100,000 I'm going to have should have some little notation out there you're going to see a ton of reductions in that first section of teachers because Social Security Medicare penion all that when you remove those positions they all go down um so just keep that in mind as you go through but what I want you to do is yeah go through look at each
109section and then as you have those questions what's in this line or what made that up or why did you make that decision to do that that's what we're here for is is to ask those things and again that's going to take you time to go through I believe if I'm remembering correctly but general purpose School fund is on pages 39 through 54 and so you have you have several Pages there um to look through and I know you're just getting this right this second but you know if you have something that immediately you want to know um feel free to ask if not we can move on and you ask your questions um later as you've had time to look and I do want to mention in in our current Year's budget 86% is
110people some version of people health insurance salaries benefits Etc um so that's that's where the bulk of our money is spent we are in the people business are y'all okay with me going on or do you want a minute we're good I'm gonna go ahead oh you do and you have my telephone number so please seriously feel free to call me I know some people have already asked if they could you know come in and have a one-onone with me and that's great I'm glad to do that at any time um all you got to do is ask okay so the next section um the that we'll look at is Central cafeteria it starts on page 56 Central cafeteria and extended school care is just a reminder they are self self-sufficient in that they generate
111their own revenues and expenses and we do not um cover those through the tax dollars so let me put some detail on that no local tax dollars are spent on our Central cafeteria it is funded by some federal revenue and um actual users actual customers correct and so what you're seeing again there is projected revenue and projected expenses um and they've got a fund balance U listed down at the bottom they have plenty of fund balance um to be able to balance their budget again as everything else we've said as we hone in the numbers will change a little bit but um they're they are in good shape there's no um request at this time to increase fees I know some of you have asked the question you know what is will there be effect
112by the USDA and we don't we're not aware of anything um at this time if there was something that changes then we'll come back to you and let you know what that would be no questions on that one we'll move on to the extended school care program which is our before and after school care um and again revenues and expenses projected fund balances as of that one I ran on February the 5th so they do not have a gap either they are in um good shape to be able to cover their costs and are these put back in our budget or what happens no they are totally self self-funded so they stay in their own so as their year closes out it goes into their own fund balance so that they start the next year
113with that money and Rachel if I'm not mistaken we are actually prohibited from taking those funds to the general budget that is correct we cannot co- mingle the any of the separate funds and this fund is driven by uh by the the the uh the customer cost for those for the users and I will say it's limited based on demand and our ability to staff so there there are occasionally weight list at particular locations depending on our abilities I think they were able really they worked hard this year to work through that um to try to get that there took everybody off the weight list so that they could serve our staffing is better than it has been in previous years correct any questions on that one all right so the last section then um
114is our annual Capital it starts on page 65 we've talked to you I know U Mr King last month did a presentation for you on annual capital and so what you see is that first summary um don't get confused I confuse everybody the far right column is what is the current year I just put up last year's information so you have it to compare to um last year our commission did fund fully 13.1 million we're asking for the 14 that you see um listed and then behind that is the detail where you will actually see the schools where things are being requested again like everything we do um tons of tons and tons and tons of requests come in um as we go around and talk to our principles and see what um their biggest
115needs are and then priority prioritization occurs and this is what we brought talk to you um there was actually about $70 million in capital requests this year and we were asking for 14 um because we feel like that that was what the commission had the appetite to be able to approve and what we knew could keep the building safe correct uh and and in working order couple things related to this uh especially those of you who are new to the board you may notice at the very bottom of those highlighted areas we talk about General and Rural uh this is something that people really struggle getting their arms around because Franklin Special School District exists we have to differentiate our capital projects between General and Rural General is high school projects rural are K8 because
116Franklin Special is a K8 program when we do a rural Capital Improvement the county has to fund a proportionate amount of capital to Frank special so right now we are 92% well we're not somewhere around there Franklin Special is about eight% of our size can you say that one more time it's tough you got my attention with that but so so every time we do a capital project at our elementary and middle schools when the County Commission funds it they have an obligation to fund a proportionate amount directly to Franklin Special School District for their capital but Franklin the city of Franklin doesn't do that correct Franklin speci that's the that's the nature of special school districts because they still get uh County funding does it work the reverse way does do we ever get
117anything that's what I thought good question no and right but we get their students well at the high school level we get their students and so when you see a general from a County Commission perspective that's actually how much they're they're going to need to spend but when you see a rural you're basically going to have to add eight or n% to that for how much they have to spend and then Franklin Special gets that portion directly but there's so anyway this is off topic but I was just thinking how they have expanded the city limits but not their District well thank you for that and that's a state issue yeah that that is correct um um the Franklin special district the lines for all Special Districts across the the state were Frozen somewhere around
1181981 1982 and so yes the city limits expand growth occurs within those City Limits but Franklin Special is still limited to where they were again you guys are going to have questions I know you are I want you to ask them that is what my job is is to be able to help you um don't leave something on the table where you're wondering the wondering is where I just want to be able to shoot you straight and tell you what it is so again ask the questions you've got um I put in the memo in the front February 28th um is a couple of weeks from now I'm really asking y'all look at this let's talk about it between now and then we have a next work session is going to be March 6 we're
119a little off because of spring break so it's coming up it'll be here faster when we come on March on the March 6 work session um I want to have questions for I mean I want you to be able to have answered your questions if at all possible it just makes it easier y'all see how big this is and you're looking at it I don't have every answer for you we do have to do some research um you know at times and so ask those questions ahead of time it just means that you're going to get truly accurate information um that we can get back to you and so March the 6 again that work session we're going to bring the budget to you the other request I have is we've sat down tonight and
120talked through I want y'all to tell tell me what you want in that March 6th work session I don't necessarily want to do this whole thing again because you'll have had time to get your your your mind wrapped around it again we're going to make those adjustments you'll get the document ahead of the work session so that you do have time to look at the updated document before you come in to the work session and then that would be the budget we actually propos I cannot stress it enough this is the draft there's a lot of work to be done between now and then and I'm going to add I want your feedback uh you've seen the proposal we've got some time um maybe more time than we've had in the past to process through
121it uh we're going to be speaking with the WCA about pay but I want your feedback on those issues as well and you've given us some good feedback already we're going to do a little bit of work on but certainly in the next few weeks um add your feedback on on your thoughts on this did you say when the ETA was for the like the more formalized did we did you give us a I really want to get through the end of February because there's so many things that last week of February we should get a t should get the sales tax so I get so yes it'll be a few days before the work it should it should be close to a week before the work session but I really want to try to
122get those numbers in to have a better idea so on on page 66 um you know the computers 4.7 million and then you said we also took money from fund balance to pay for computers too or was this what you were talking about was used to pay for computers last year so that that's going to include that well it didn't that number the computers here I think a lot some of it is it's going to be teacher computers it's going to be the work computers it's going to be yes so annual Capital it's another one of those coding things that says computers it's it's really not computers it's technology equipment for the classroom that kind of lasts longer a lot of it's like the interactive boards and things like that it'll be printers yeah that's
123a better description yeah for some reason it's listed I'm going give you a silly I'm going to give you a silly example the state has gasoline but we buy diesel fuel right so there's lots of examples where sometimes the description is not excellent so I'll yeah feel free to ask those questions too and on the capital we do have detail uh um that the the attached document U might give you some additional detail we try to specify particular School locations as well uh in that in that Capital detail I will tell you we get more questions from County Commissioners about particular locations of schools is that a good Des is that fair description know if it's it's affecting their their they ask they ask questions about their you won't see locations for technology as much
124because that's districtwide it's just things we printers and stuff that we buy districtwide but on the maintenance side you will see specific locations I have one thing I want to ask and you're going to be like okay if you would bring your binder back binders for you to take take if you want to take it with you this time but bring it back because we're going to change out and we're going to say here's your real budget um but I didn't want you to have to keep up with two two binders so one one little one little uh uh practice tip that I learned with h with these budgets especially at this early stage when you're jotting down notes on a particular document Rachel's gonna give you a new one uh so he loves nothing
125more to come in every morning and I'm like here's your new one here's your new one it's changing every day right now so if you've got particular notes you want to jot down my my recommendation is jot them on maybe a little notepad on the side that you can transfer to the new one when she gives it to you to late Dan says that's too late Mr chair okay if I may thank you for I mean for the the updates throughout the the process you know we started early and looking at the at the process and for um the preliminary even though I know you hate giving out preliminary numbers even um even before the the budget proposal but it's really it's really helpful um for a not not that you weren't transparent before but
126I mean this is just this is really the sooner we can get it especially with 16 board members the better so it It ultimately makes your job easier I know that's why you're doing it but thank you for that um but there are so many things we we know we assume I mean you know because it's our day in day out and so you guys asking the questions I mean I may have a question question but it's not going to be the same question as you asked and so glad I'm actually it's been helpful I think for all of us to really get a big picture of of what you're coming to the table with and and the perceptions and and the views you have so thanks for that thank you thank you Rachel we
127we do know it's a moving Target every year that it is I can't I told I told Mr Gold I'm like I'm gonna say it a hundred times this is a draft this is not it it's funny Mr Cash and I had that discussion he said yeah we never find out till till it's till it's too late something to that effect so thank you thank you'all and again you're right Dr Johnson we have you have my email address and got a phone number give me a call thank you okay well thank you all right uh operations report Brian King thank you Mr chair uh some brief updates on a few of just a few of our projects we have going on in operations um the access control for all exterior doors is now 100% complete
128as of I believe about a week and a half two weeks ago phase one of the access control for our indoor uh for the classrooms and offices uh continues to go well as well as the new intercom alert system uh phase one is scheduled to be completed this summer and in the five-year Capital if you'll remember we've asked for funding for uh phase two uh construction update we got Brentwood Middle School the roof trust installation complete the brick facade installation is about 60% complete and they've started Plumbing electrical mechanical rough end work uh on the second and third floors the transportation building uh we were given the certificate of occupancy on February 11th uh once the furniture uh comes in is and installed we'll start moving uh Mr Fuller and the Transportation uh Team to
129the new building The Innovation Center the old building has been demolished uh grading activities continue the building pad they've started that it should be complete in the next couple of weeks uh and then I want to give you just a little bit of information because y'all voted on the out of Zone and that went uh that opened up on February 4th so far Alison and our team have processed 823 applications so far for out Zone request okay and the total last year was somewhere around 2400 I believe that's correct yeah so we'll we'll that that will close on April 15th yes sir Brian um if I may Mr chair uh I we we I touched briefly and you touched briefly on on some of some of our uh some of our computer filters in protections
130on the on the operation side but another operations question I know I've gotten um from U from from a couple of families related to plumbing and we've talked about this from time to time I know that that questions continue to come up about Fairview Elementary um could you share a little bit about that sure thank you thank you for the question so just a little history on the the fair viiew uh of Plumbing in 2016 2017 there was some work done on the main sewer line uh outside the building that was completed in 2017 in 2024 this past year uh we received Capital funds and uh to replace all the toilets with power assist toilets which we've completed the maintenance department have replaced all of those and um in this next year's budget annual budget
131you'll see there's oh I'm sorry also in this year was engineering to look at if there's anything else that can be done to help with the uh issues at Fairview having said that so there is money in there for next year based on what the engineer comes back and says but just to give you a little background there's Plumbing when you say Plumbing issues we have Plumbing issues at every school every day and 90% of the clogs that that that you'll hear about or more and Floyd can test to this is a foreign object or stuff going in the toilet that shouldn't be there and we clear the line um and we looked at the work orders uh for fair viiew Elementary School since August 1 and really there's not a significant difference in fairie
132elementary and most of our other elementary schools so uh not to say that we we're not going to look at what the engineer says and do some work we've already done some work uh but we'll continue to monitor thank you okay next any questions yeah Brian from when you said the 800 open Zone compared to the 2400 last year that that includes everybody who's currently up in zone who has to submit a yes sir I just want to clear for that yes I'm sorry yes that sibling WCS employees who have to fill out the form yes sir but you got to fill that you got to fill that form out every year if you're out of zone so when we look at that when we look at that out of zone out of Zone sheet
133and it shows that there's you know 4,000 people or whatever it was I think it was 10% it might have been 3,000 yes sir but we get those and everybody's got to fill that out every year back yeah so so so basically as I read it about a third of those we anticipate asking have filled out the form so far but they got I mean they got another two they've got they've got it yeah they've got two and a half months um it's it's so that's that's why that's why Brian shared that thanks J it's just worth a reminder for those folks 2400 sounded like a lot and then you think about it but it's not no that's I guess I guess the question the question would be the real question will you know next
134next time or maybe for Monday would would be you know how many how many new requests did we get last year um comp and this year I'll check with see if she can yeah well to your point separ seven or eight% of our students are attending out of Zone it's in that range and are all the um the students able to get where they want to be we don't know yet because it it we we uh we'll we'll close that out on April 15th but as of right now Brian I don't think any any particular location is closed as of right now that is correct yes sir okay and by the way when I say closed I want to encourage the public who's watching just because we get the numbers doesn't mean you should stop
135you should not apply because under the state rules there's a lottery if there is one that goes over sorry sorry Mr chair all right we ready any other questions all right the chair report the only thing I've got is uh uh we're meeting on Tuesday night for our board member our board uh meeting the 18th at 6:30 uh let's see okay new business uh got any questions on new business if I may Mr chair um uh item a the uh is the budget of course we're get I only have one item tonight and know we love these cons because it's hey we're getting money um the state last year um had a pot of money U that they could reallocate for to help offset some of the costs for special um special ed transportation and
136so there was one pot you applied for it and then they allocated out to the districts and so our allocation was $136,700 gladly take we will gladly take that that kind of money and that's the only one I've got any other questions could we have a five minute bathroom break would that be okay I'm sorry five minute bathroom break is anybody opposed to that I can sneak out of oh you need a break I need a break you need a break well take 10 five 10 what do we do you want to make it six split the difference six minutes six minutes where e e e all right okay next up we all set over there okay hey I got a cow bell in my Sunday school class but anyhow okay we got Dana is
137gonna talk about uh board policies for first readings if if I may Mr chair it'd be nice but I think we skipped about three or four items I was ready though well I asked if there was any questions on that oh okay is there well I know one Jay I'm sorry all right I'm let's let's go school fees do you want we do yeah if you want I just thought I I asked a question so Mr chair uh family tuition rate got want to give you guys a brief description of that um uh the document that Rachel prepared in the packet shows a projection of a per pupil expenditure that we include for our family tuition rate our board policy does not allow students to attend from out of County except in per in some
138very limited situations one of them may be that that a family has a non-contingent contract to purchase a home during the semester in which case they will pay the family tuition rate or can their child can move in and if they move in during that semester we reimburse it uh also the the policy does allow students in the second semester of their junior year and later if they move out of County to finish their career here they would pay the family tuition rate so those are basically the limitations so it's rare that this is used but we do have that obligation to approve that annually based on that per pupil expenditure or per pup Revenue maybe Rachel yeah okay any questions on the tuition all right let's uh let's move on to approval of school
139fees thank you Mr chair I did want to mention uh one one change that we've made really in the descriptors uh related to this and then there's a couple of uh items that um our leadership team has made a request for a change we have added some language to the voluntary fees based on that ongoing discussion uh that that we that uh that we have about the fact that the state call them fees but these aren't for for anything that any provision of services during a school day classes Etc uh all students are entitled to a free education U we are allowed to make a request for supports um and the state calls them fees and Mr galbert I'm going to speak for you just briefly that Mr Mr galbert routinely mentions this and says
140why call them fees when they're not or some version of that and he's right uh but the state does call them fees so we've added some language there that voluntar fees are requested for classroom support and are not required of any student we try to make that um a point of emphasis from a funding standpoint um we are not at the point where we feel like we can't ask for these I know there's been some discussion about well could we do something with fundraisers Etc uh and we see this as um as an additional fundraiser um we've we we pulled our our our principles that actually asked this question are there any of you who would like to foro those fees and and take a shot at at um treating this as a as a
141pure fundraiser without that at this stage we don't have any takers I will tell you as I'm evaluating alternate funding sources based on one of the goals you guys have set for me this is on my plate to continue to to do some research on uh but but I felt like it was important to share those especially since in the past we've had some detailed discussions related to it open any questions you may have Jay you got any questions um not so much a question maybe um but the um I guess we we talked we talked last year about um about making making this more of a donation um and and looking at it from a if you know I just I just don't understand why we're making um non-required fees to a school that
142can accept donations that qualify for donations and matching funds from employers while we're not while we're not doing that um so we could we could easily like I guess we asked the teachers or the we asked the principls what they would like to do but they're not paying the fees um so I'd really like to I'd really like to understand um parents if I mean I mean look at the invest in your kidss programs that everybody does instead of fundraisers and they they know what those go for um this is this is obviously different we we do everybody in everybody in our high schools and because what's what's been on my mind for the last 12 years but um has they they give to their individual into to their PTO through their their class I
143think everybody does it that way and they're and they're asked to to make a donation of you know $100 or $150 or whatever um you know we've all the elementary schools went to a went to a fee um as per Julie's um note and um and the it's it's much smaller the high school gets big because you're talking about a fee per every per every class uh but if we if we ask the parents for a voluntary donation and some of them can get matching funds I mean you're you're reducing the you're reducing the net impact of that of that fee by 30% and what you find is we're really giving like everybody will if you give them the opportunity to give more some people won't give anything and some people don't give anything now
144but the people who you're asking for donations for the people that can will give more um and I just nobody takes away Revenue Source I get it um um but we have the potential to to make it a tax deductible donation and get more money than we're getting and not make everybody feel like they're getting nickel and D which they which they are so um can we can we take donations uh yes but Rachel I will speak to that and um sure a school can take a donation the issue with the with what we're the fee is that you're getting something in return so it's not a donation you are getting your child is getting whether it's an English book they actually take that with them anything that's used as a fee the kid is
145consuming and I don't mean eating but consuming it whether it's manipul whatever they've got that they're working on so if you're dissecting you consume that item and it's no longer of use so you're taking you have something you're taking away that is not a donation I'm specifically saying for biology I pay this fee and in return that's what I get in English I'm paying this fee and I take that that novel home with me that's the difference a fee in a donation so you could say no fees but then all of those items which shouldn't go out to the kids they would be kept in schools no but they're not required now and we're they're not required that I would make the argument that you can't you can't call it a donation when it truly
146is a fee because it is covering that item a donation is here you go um and I get nothing in return but if we take away this Fe if we took away this fee schedule completely and and said we we got to we're going to ask ask for a donation of a you know $150 a kid or whatever that whatever the whatever it comes down to more if you can do it obviously you don't have to do any um if we don't have a fee schedule then if we give the kid a a English workbook then they can take it it's a philosophical difference in opinion is where I would leave well did do that I I see what you're saying it's included in the taxpayer funded free and appropriate public education then we can
147we can provide them as for they sign up for English class and they get an English workbook I mean they don't have to give it back in in the context of that goal to find alternate sources of revenue um one of the things that's on my mind and on frankly on my plate uh that I've placed on my plate is to get some specific expert tax advice on um for somebody who does income tax work to see how we could structure that I think there's still an opportunity there one of the things I'm going to explore is can we can we do alternates um and maybe potentially transition into what you're talking about uh so I'm not done with this from a timing perspective we are recommending these fees for right now but but i
148ph I I think it's more of a practical tax issue what what mechanism will work that someone's Tax Advisor can tell them you can get a this is the but I we had this is the same conversation we had last year and we said we're going to look into it last year until we didn't and now we're well it's too late I guess we'll just have to look at it in six more years when you know so I know I know exactly what you're saying because last year we had this exact conversation and we put it on your list and I said that last year would be the last time I would vote in favor of this so I'm with you J all right I got two votes all right thank you I I'm on
149his side too because I'd like to know what items um are are are we asking fees for they're on the list on the list they're on that list every single thing there for classrooms could could we do it I tread lightly using this word because but scholarships like a like if we had some type of scholarship fund that would be like a public private partnership where we could have I know there's businesses who would love to and we've talked about that as far as the goals too is to have some type of fund um where some families would say I'm happy to pay this and other families like this is a lot is there a scholarship available could we do it that way and that I mean would that kind of Remedy the problem about
150the goods well to your to to your question we don't require of we we don't require it of anyone it's an additional Revenue source and what Mr galberth is basically arguing is if we find another method to get that Revenue Source it could be actually be a win-win that's that's the essence of what you're talking about um so there are times especially in extracurricular activities uh when that that you described happens with the PTO supporting if an Athletics team needs blank amount and they haven't gotten enough for the extracurricular um the booster club or the PTO will fill in that Gap and to be clear though I'm I'm only talking about the academic fees I'm not talking about the participation fees that makes so like it's it's completely appropriate for extracurricular activities and to to
151ask for the you know 150 bucks to do drama club or whatever the chorus and all the all the extracurricular athletic fees like all that stuff completely I mean and I think we do a great job in in making that you know required enough that if basically if you're able you are are expected to to pay it and obviously you if you can't then we're not going to exclude anybody from from participating but it's the academic fees that are just you know we're it's a million bucks um it should be in our budget we should get the money um as much as we can um so that's that's I just want to make that clear thank you okay any other questions on that okay The Encore summer program fees Mr Gold thank you Mr chair
152The Encore program is a summer program run by our elementary schools um uh for what I think of as Camp items unrelated to what the state called as summer camps um so uh this is the this is the summer program for elementary schools to come and enjoy things uh um en enjoy some activities um during the summer and uh Dr oyer has included that memo for the for the cost for that summer program okay any questions okay next superintendent evaluation instrument thank you Mr chair uh included in the packet is the superintendent evaluation instrument that is exactly like last year there have been years where the where the board has discussed um potential changes to it I will tell you it's basically broken up into two sections for those of who haven't experienced this yet
153one an evaluation section for the for the goals that you set for me annually and then section two is the state required items for superintendent evaluations uh so certainly open to any questions you may have prior to the prior to the event um prior to the prior to the vote um but what I found is just to be as direct as I can your comments are a whole lot more valuable to me than your numbers uh than your scores uh because uh I I've seen the difference in in what standard you set as well what standards board members Set uh so regardless of how this structure is set up I'm going to be more interested in finding out your comments um again certainly open any questions that you may have any questions okay now we're
154ready for Dana thank you Mr Cash the um first policy for first reading is the public records request there um on the second and third page are some changes in red those are the result of our discussion at the policy meeting uh to do some rewarding of those sections uh to make it a little bit more clear and then on the next page um I think we we changed the word from I think it was some emails to Communications at the bottom of that page yes um we had a robust discussion during our policy meeting um and those are the two changes that occurred regarding this policy um and staff recommends um this policy approval for first reading Mr Cash do you want me to just keep going or do you want to yeah I
155mean we we were pretty much everyone was at the board or the policy meeting yes sir I think everybody's aware and of the yes sir discuss these at his first reading it is yes sir so the the next policy is actually I had some things I wanted to talk about on this policy okay before we go on um because I I was I brought some of this up in kind of the continuation of the robust conversation there's two points that I really want us to look at and it's on page three um line 44 and that's 2 G um so I I feel strongly that communication is just too broad um when it says uh when the personal records um of a um Williams County Board of Education member goes on to the next page
156is requested um from what case law has shown us especially in Tennessee we have a case and I think I shared it with superintendent golden um case law has indicated that communication must be in connection with the transaction of official business for school board members and I think that needs to be shown here so in I have some recommended wording um to amend this starting at line 44 instead of saying whenever start with if Communications to and or from Williamson County school board members are requested and the communications have been determined by the coordinator to be in Connection in connection with the transaction of official business the board member shall be given three days notice of the request and include the re reason that such communication is considered public record I think we need to
157put the cart put the horse in front of the cart rather and um so we need to First prove that or at least give verification that the communications that are about to be revealed in public records are um in fact a transaction of official business for the board member so I'd like to see that policy and then there's one other change so I will um thank you for this unfortunately I haven't this is the first I'm hearing about it so I haven't had an opportunity to um research it my first reaction however is the notice provision with the three days um is to allow obviously either employees or but board members to know about the request there's not going to be a guarantee within those three business days that all of those records have been
158reviewed um to be able to tell you what is or is not included um we right now are averaging at least a public records request a day um and we're obviously getting those processed as quickly as possible but I don't want to guarantee that within three days of receiving the request we would have had an opportunity to run the request and review all the documents I do think there may be something that we can do with that but I would like to um review that to make sure it's feasible so don up got a question so so this this G is more in line is is to me it's more it's more talking about the specific um response or um what whatever it calls the um the notice that we're g this is this is
159kind of the notice provision I think what you're I think what you're asking for and I don't know where I'm wondering where it is in the policy is is more along the Lin of what is what is discoverable by a records request um and so because because that that's a that's like a it fits into a whole bigger picture it's almost like uh and but where where would that be to finded data not only for not only for personnel or board members but for but for any what like basically what defines a per a public record like that's where that's it seems to be that definition is what is what we're is what she's looking for sure and and she mentioned um a case I'm gonna assume which case that is there is a case
160that talks about um more than one but a case that talks about public records and says that it's not the form of the record so it's not that it's an email it's not that it's a text message but it's really the content of the record and if the record is talking about business that would you know be before the board um then it it would would be a public record I think at the policy meeting we we talked a little bit about this I think the example that I came up with was um off the top of my head a board member who there was an email using your official WCS email uh between you and your spouse trying to determine what kind of pizza you wanted for dinner I I'd argue that's not discussing
161business I think that's an easy one um but if it's regarding um a matter that's going to be voted on if it's you know discussing a policy if it's discussing then we look at that content and that's why I said I think the purpose of this was again to provide notice but I don't want to have a guarantee that within three days um some of our requests are thousands of emails it sometimes takes us week to go through those um to react information and to look for confidential information and is it in fact responsive to the records request so yeah so I think it we might we might just and I'm and I'm fine we can talk about this in in policy I think it's it'll be a good a good discussion again but it
162might be you know a sub bullet of number two maybe um when as we're defining public records if we want to if we want to add a description on page one maybe but on page one um on page on page on page one I page one okay under definitions and and Jay I think that is appropriate let me look at that yes I think that makes sense um because I don't I mean if I don't think it's it's almost it's I I want to make sure that it that whatever we put there covers employees and and board members it doesn't need to be one or the other it could be broad enough to to show that it needs to be because either one it needs to be transa you know transacting business and not something
163of a of a personal nature or whatever but um so I think it's but I I think the important important thing is it would I think it belongs under definitions and not under the notice then we can talk about what the notice means per as dat I think as long as it's somewhere in the policy that's what I'd like to see and um we we can work that out in policy but I you know that was something that I really feel strongly about um that that should be there Donnie if you would can we make sure we get that language to Dana yeah I can I can email yeah I was working on this today so um the only other thing that I I am I jumping in front of anybody I didn't well I
164with the um back down to the the language um on page three what would be so there there in G there line for so what what is the purpose of changing it from emails to Communications so that was the feedback from board members at the policy meeting um my original language was emails that is typically what the requests are for board members um I can't recall who made who made the suggestion uh during the meeting but it was to expand it because it might not be just emails um to Communications that either that to me is not a sticking point um either way however however you want that language to be um but that is feedback from our policy meeting I think I might I don't I remember discussing it I could have I could
165have recommended it because when I saw emails like I know to Dana's previous point it's not the form of the communication it's the content of the communication and so could be vo so it could it could be it could be voicemail it could be um it could be it could be other written communication it could be email it could be text message so like it it's more communication that got you got you yeah well and I think I remembered but I couldn't remember what we were what the context of that was I think it was also to make the point that it isn't limited to just the emails that board members would have notice no matter what the communication was um if I'm remembering correctly okay and the other thing I wanted to look at
166I think is Page four um line five this I had questions about this in the policy meeting and maybe I should start with a question but um looking at the state law and then when we look at our Williamson County policy it says that bosers is our coordinator for every Department in the county with the exception of sheriff but bosers isn't our coordinator we have actually from what I see several coordinators and so I just kind of wanted to first of all ask I brought this up you're not you did is that County County government I think you're referring to won County Government government which is a different entity so it may be that they posted but I guess at the state level it didn't seem to maybe I can look back at this um
167it didn't seem to imply that Williamson County was a separate entity oh okay so so at the so at the state level then it comes down to the county level and the county level says all departments in within the entire County of willson County Brian or yeah bosers is the coordinator except for the sheriffs and so we've got to we've got some inaccuracy we are not Williams County government we are constitutionally a separate entity so when when County government speaks for All County government they're not speaking for us well we probably need to get them to change that in there well and or maybe a reference to schools or something yeah if I may the policy for the county has got several coordinators um each Department's got one what you're thinking about or what you're
168referring to is Bradley the is our archives um okay and he basically is the first point so when somebody's got one they send it to him and then he distributes it to the different public rec coordinators depending on the department so how many coordinators do we have at the county level we have oh wow um well each department so you know you're talking 15 okay you know 12 15 because you've got them for trustees uh Register of Deeds office clerk's office court clerk's office juvenile uh there's you know and the sheriff was separated because the amount that they get the amount of public records requests they get are many times more than any other department that we get them for and that's why we' kind of separated them out and their records are a little
169bit different than the regular public records there's going to be some restrictions on what you can provide them and not that are not in regular just gotcha so Bob Bobby did I describe that accurately the difference between the schools and County government you did okay thank you um have we considered having one coordinator and then underneath the coordinator custodians or do we want to have I think we have four different coordinators we have three coordinators um my office I coordinate public records um if it is not media that goes through Communications or um Personnel records that goes through HR we work and collaborate um together communicate really well um I think that was the structure when I got here and I and it works so I'd recommend we continue that structure um it could it
170could be done um but our our our experience is that it's more efficient with a media going to Carol and and anybody looking for HR records going to go to HR I guess my only concern was just that when we have several different people doing the same job um there could be differentiation in how they carry it through so but if if if we haven't seen that problem then I trust I I I see what you're saying um I just was just bringing it up we'll do it we we'll have a conversation with our leadership team and and specifically ask that question and what typically happens so you kind of understand how the sausage is made those requests initially go to me Carol or Vicky and then um they are generally then processed through my
171office um so that we we do communicate and make sure and I and I think that's a valid point that you made to make sure they are handled the same um I just think they are um especially with the media they're so used to contacting Carol bird song that I don't know that they would contact me even if they even if we ask them to but yes that's a that's a good it's a good point so Dana really I mean if if that's the way we work then then ultimately ultimately your general counsel is the is the coordinator um I mean you're like you're you're just describing where the where the initial request goes goes to um so so it does and you're right so it it on the front end goes there but then
172behind the scenes we are communicating but then if it is HR and someone has asked to see a personnel file it's then HR who is making sure they see the personnel file get copies redacted or Carol's office doing the same thing we just make sure we are all in lock step following the policy um so yeah yeah yeah but to your point Jay each one of those three have that same all the same responsibilities well except for except for Dana's responsib responsibility is to collect it and review it before it goes out yeah so I mean so I mean it really it I mean it really reads that that Dana is the is the coordinator um and for for requests from these areas here's your main point of contact but ultimately ultimately Dana's going to
173process I mean every they're Vicki's going to touch it first but Dana's going to touch it last and that's the definition of a coordinator so I'm in the middle really and truly because it's so to your point the confidential information yes my office is going to touch right but then it's going if it's media it's going back to Carol's office yeah that's fair um or it's going back to HR but that means you're coordinating it right like so I mean but by definition I don't know just I'm not sure I I I I I'm just I'm I'm kind of saying to I mean for Donna's concern was was that multiple people are doing the same job and I don't I don't think that I don't think they are I think you're everybody's doing their job
174and and everybody's got one and it it doesn't really it's not really reflected here I don't even know if it has to be I think it it's working but I I this more of a process question than maybe a wording of the policy question but I'm good with it anyone else these are all for first reading and we'll be going back over them in policy again so that's where to handle this okay um I will move to the next one which is uh policy 4301 inter Scholastic Sports um one change to this policy on [Music] um page two um and at the policy meeting I it was requested that I make certain that this provision only applies to school sponsored athletic events I I reviewed the policy again with that lens feel very comfortable that
175this is only as to uh School sponsored athletic events um not to club sports which start um those conditions and and parameters start on the next page um we do recommend approval of first reading for this policy questions okay criminal background checks okay so uh criminal background checks as we talked about at the policy meeting they um Tennessee is now a member of the wp back um which uh program which um all of our employees must go through uh the rback program um we other categories of individuals who may have close proximity to Children which for our case are contractors and volunteers they are currently uh being background checked our regular background check process our recommendation is that that continue um so the updated Parts in blue are regarding uh contractors and and volunteers but
176also regarding the update as um our employees are accepted into the wrap back program okay any questions on the wraback program just that it's spelled r a i saw it somewhere spelled w r a like Gift Rap yeah hopefully not here but yeah it just just as a reminder we mentioned the WAP is the record of arrest and prosecution okay all right and if it is okay I'm going to do the last two together um line and staff relations uh the changes that have been made to that policy are um taken from the next policy 5.83 organization charts uh the recommendation is to um approve for first reading the lines in blue and to um delete organization charge since it is um really the two policies are very similar so recommend um approval of this
177policy for first reading questions well if there's no questions you want uh r to go back to any of the pages before no never mind yeah we can go ahead and adjourn the meeting thank you good job M cash