CorpusRecord 73613

WCS Board Work Session 2025-01-16

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WCSIT
Date
2025-01-19
Location
Williamson County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,019 words · about 151 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the January 16th work session of the Williams County Board of Education we will um begin with our consent agenda um I'm not going to read through the individual items but you've had the agenda for a few days uh do you see anything you want to discuss on the consent agenda okay don't see any um any items there so we'll move ahead with that um we'll as always vote on that as a block on Tuesday night so we can move right into the superintendent report and just fair warning uh Jason already gave me the the heads up this will be potentially a lengthy discussion because of the the two subjects that are being discussed or maybe three um and and some of the presentations that we have which will be very useful and helpful but could

002take a while so let's just fair warning all right Mr thank you Mr chair and thank you board members uh it's good to see you all uh we had a little bit of a break uh during December and we had a really good first semester I want to give you just a just a couple of quick updates and then get into the meat of our discussion we actually have one separate voting item on the entire agenda that's open Zone schools and we'll get to that so I believe the bulk of our time tonight is going to be spent on some reports we're gonna have some discussion U from Maria grego who is our director of student support services and it's uh it's kind of a primer on special education and I want to tell you

003on the front end it's a lot and uh there's no way you're going to retain everything this first time but we're going to let you have that PowerPoint and and we'll have some ongoing discussions as as uh as these months and and years go by one thing that struck me when Maria Was preparing this is our special education teachers spend Years Learning all this and we're gonna try to fire hose it to you guys at at least to some extent uh second we're going to give you an update on our science textbook selection process uh if you may you may remember that Jennifer sour said something along the lines of last month well not A lot's happening right now but when it does it'll be fast or some version of that we've at we're at

004that stage and so she's going to give you an update on where we are with that but before we do that I I want to call your attention to an article that we published about a week ago last week the state released our ACT results and I can't help but brag a little bit uh we had the high highest ACT score of any District in the state and um we also have a number of our schools that were in the that were in the top 10 Statewide for for ACT score our average ACT score is 25.2 that's more than a point higher than the next closest district and so we're we're very proud of the work our our our our teachers and our students did and the support that our that that our students have

005from their parents and by the way that was this past Year's graduating class so we're getting the information about six months in aers I also want to mention that particular class 84% of them went straight to college and we've had that discussion as well really in the context of our Career Technical education programs and I mentioned that I think when when we broke ground for the Innovation Hub and one of the items that I'm proud of is how we're making sure that no matter what our students are planning to do as their next steps we are giving them the opportunities to look at business opportunities giving them giving them the opp opportunity to look at industry and one of my favorite stories to tell these last few years is it happens to be a Fairview

006story Governor Lee came to visit our megatronics program and he happened upon two students who were working together on this conveyor belt structure that was shifting based on the nature of the product that rolled down the conveyor belt and the it was it was separating product and he asked the two students what they were going to do after high school and one of them said I'm going to Georgia Tech I want to be a mechanic engineer and the other one said I'm going straight into industry I'm getting a certification in in electrical and they were working together in our schools and just stories like that abound and so the ACT is another example of those doors we're opening for our students and so again we're we're very proud of that uh in in the state

007tracks uh what they call subpopulations they have a they they track the performance of what they describe as black Hispanic and Native Amer American uh uh economically disadvantaged English Learners and students with disabilities uh and and those numbers are are are are pretty impressive as well as we concentrate on again making sure we're opening doors for all our students I'm going to give you one example our students with disabilities average ACT score exceeded the state average for all students just one quick example now the reality is you're going to learn in just a minute and I'm using this as a segue to to Maria his presentation when you look at aggregate information for students with disabilities you're looking at it the wrong way what you ought to be looking at is individual students and individual

008student performance there's a structure that's designed for that but we are emotionally committed and professionally committed to looking at it individually as well Maria is going to give you that basic structure uh so that you can start getting an idea of where we are and when and County schools with with uh how we serve our students with disabilities a large portion of this is going to be Federal a smaller portion of this will be State and then there'll be a piece of that describing how we do our work within those parameters within those guard rails that the federal and state rules give us so with that Maria I'm going to turn it over to you and she's going to share with you uh information related to that that structure and how we apply it and

009Maria if you don't mind I want to volunteer that if anyone has any question on the Fly it's okay to interrupt are you good with that okay with a caveat I may do the same thing all right good evening I guess I need to figure out the best spot to stand I don't think I can hold the clicker the microphone and my notes so um I will kind of reference my my notes back here but thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak with you all tonight as Jason said I'm Maria grigo the executive director of what we call student Support Services or SSS or Trip s uh in Williamson County schools and in Williamson County SSS includes special education and 504 so tonight we're going to delve into some of the timelines some

010of the disability categories how one becomes eligible to receive Services we're going to do a pretty highlevel overview so if anybody wants additional information about these topics I can certainly provide that to you or have a discussion with you but this is a pretty high level uh to set the stage tonight I want you to know that when we're talking about students that receive special education in 504 we're talking about a little over 25% of our total student population in WCS and I will have these figures on a a graph for you and they're in the PowerPoint but I think it's important to know that as we begin our discussion we have about 10,500 students combined with IEPs and 504s so and and and a large part of our general purpose budget um is goes

011to supporting students with disabilities uh it's about $92 million uh that supports our students with disabilities and that uh includes everything from teachers to materials to bus drivers to buses to all of the things in between that our students need in order to receive that that education that free appropriate public education um we do also get a a small percentage of federal funds um that support this work it's about about 12.1 million in federal funds compared with the 92 million that we have uh locally here uh so I'm going to keep going but I wanted you to kind of get the depth and breadth of of the uh students that we're talking about tonight so uh we're going to start off with special education discussion so all students that receive special education services qualify for

012services and we use What's called the idea or the individuals with disabilities Education Act it is a federal law and that law ensures that our children with disabilities throughout the nation gets the Ser get the services that they need in order to access education idea governs how those States and public agencies provide that early intervention so our 3 to 5-year-olds our school age students and then our students all the way up in Tennessee to age 22 um it also looks at our related services so things like occupational therapy speech therapy each state in turn is responsible for ensuring that school districts are in compliance with this federal law we have monitoring that occurs in different facets annually that we're responsible um to provide information to the state you'll also see at the bottom of some

013of the slides that are kind of wordy there's a little ASC there and it's just intended to be a little one- sentence summary of what was on that slide any questions so far all right so as far as idea goes there are four key components that I wanted to point out to you guys tonight um the first one is what we lovingly call fape we have an acronym for everything so fape lre IEP and then procedural safeguards we're going to delve a little bit more deeply into each of these um on the next slides so fape is that free appropriate public educ Ed ation and really what this this premise is in the idea is that students with disabilities are to receive an education at no cost to their families that meet their needs and

014it helps it aims the purpose is that students with disabilities have the same educational opportunities as their non-disabled peers so that's really what what that fape or free appropriate public education is looking at the four key comp components of fape is free it's that education at no cost right public education that's that's what what students receive in public school and then appropriate so appropriate in this sense means that the education is tailored to meet the individual needs of the student so I think Jason men mentioned this earlier when we're talking about special education the things that we do are individualized for that specific student so every student has their own plan their own Services their own team public is next the education is provided by the public school system and then education the services are

015designed to provide that educational benefit all right the second key principle uh under idea is what's called LR or least restrictive environment and really what this is looking at is that we are educating students with disabilities alongside their non-disabled peers to the greatest extent appropriate for that student and it looks different depending on the needs of each individual student so sometimes that means that a student might be in a general education classroom the majority of their day sometimes it might mean it's a combination of a special education setting and a general education setting so a graphic here just to kind of give you an idea of a least restricted the least restrictive environment Continuum and so you'll see over here in the green we start with our least restrictive and then we go toward the

016blue which gets more restrictive as you go so obvious obviously general education alongside their peers is the least restrictive all the way down to a homebound or Hospital placement um is the most restrictive on the right hand side um we do have students that that fall along all all along this Continuum in WCS um and and school districts are required to provide services at every part of the Continuum based on individual student need any questions on faap or L all right the Third component big component of idea is the individualized education program many of you have heard IEP IEP meeting that is the document the program that each students team designes to tailor what the student needs in order to provide them with a fape and in the least restrictive environment okay so it is

017that legal document that that lists all of the students present levels their goals their services the I process is collaborative so no one person can sit and develop an IEP okay it's intended to be parents and Educators and and administrators coming together to develop the best plan possible for students so another slide on the IEP um the IEP team which I have a little graphic to the right there showing you typical members of an IEP team um obviously other people can be invited at as as needed but these are kind of your your typical uh members the parents the general ed teacher the special ed teacher the laa representative all of those are required members and that team is responsible to develop the IEP to revise it when it's needed and at least annually they

018have to revise it and then anytime a parent or another team member a teacher administrator feels the need that something needs to be revised in that document the team is responsible for coming together and and making any revisions needed so a couple things I want to point out on this this chart with the with the required members for example if a student uh needs Occupational Therapy Services then the occupational therapist would be a member of the team if the if the student needs different services that particular um somebody in that with that expertise is a member of the team also in the interest of filling in the acronyms the Lea that's the local Education Agency uh and from from the way I process that one is that is the person who has the capacity to

019bind the school district to commit the school district to to the services that the IEP team is talking about thank you Jason yeah the Lea representative is typically um the school's assistant principal or principal um and that that's typically who who is that Lea representative at each meeting all right oh you have a question sure yeah do we ever have to Outsource treatment we don't have that specialty in central staff so we have to contract with somebody who's certified licensed or something yeah that's a great question sometimes um sometimes we we have to contract for different Services oftentimes not to provide the entire education sometimes uh but for example sometimes we've had to contract for um Vision Services something along those lines we do have our own staff um but some times if we have

020a vacancy or we have more students that that an influx of students sometimes we do uh contract those services and so also if you think back to Maria's slide with that Continuum from in a general education setting all the way to hospitalized uh we do occasionally serve students who are in a residential facility and that is that's contracted Services as well so there are sometimes that the students disabilities are such that the least restrictive environment is outside of a school and and in that case the free part applies we will we will pay for that leads to another question a chemo student do we chemotherapy a student with cancer uh do the programs stop and start depending on whether they're having a good month or a bad month given their that's a great question so

021we provide homebound services for students who are medically unable to come to school and so that is students with or without disabilities not specific to having a disability so a a child going through Cancer Treatments um we offer homebound we actually go to the hospitals we have a team that that goes to Vanderbilt different places to provide education for those students if it happens to be a student with an IEP those services or the team decides on what that looks like the frequency the duration of those Services um if the child is just too ill to participate I mean the parents certainly can let us know and and we will resume when they're medically able and often those include some pretty deep conversations with the doctors about what the student has the capacity uh to

022manage that's a great question all right so the next thing is procedural safeguards this is the last of the four big uh pillars or components if you will of idea and um these the procedural safeguards I I think the easiest way to explain them is that they are the rights that children with disabilities and their parents have so uh this is these rights are under the Ida and uh they are actually a 42-page booklet so if you've ever attended an IEP meeting it's a large document um that is provided to parents um our the legal requirement is that it be provided at least annually our practice really is to offer it at each IEP meeting to ensure that parents know what their rights are and and that they have the opportunity to ask questions that

023we can explain um if if they don't know what their rights are um and so the booklet has a lot of information it also has resources for families that the state has put together um in in the back so I want to mention something related to that 42 Page thing so we we have conversations along these lines you know our our our teachers have been working on this professionally sometimes a parent comes in for what you're going to see in a little bit related to eligibility where they're starting that process and we have had these conversations we want to make sure that it's it's tough a parent might have a 42-page rights document just plopped down in front of them and it can be overwhelming I just visualize that it's a lot uh and so

024um part of what Marie is going to walk through is the process we go through but we are H we are constantly reminding ourselves see it from the parents perspective Um this can be very difficult uh and so that that empathy is a very important component that we that we constantly emphasize U because it it truly can be overwhelming I have a question is that booklet digital is there a way for people to download it from the website yes Maria it's it's not on the website but you can actually put in Tennessee procedural safeguards and it'll pop up and we often if parents want it digitally uh we provide it that way as well it's on the State website it is but that might be something that we that we think about adding the link

025good suggestion for parents tend to have a pretty good idea if their child's going to need a 504 or IEP and so at least that's something they could access in advance of a a meeting initial meeting sure that's something we could certainly do that I was going to ask something kind of along the same lines I I would love to get I I I had a job with an IP um and I remember that and um but I would love to see that document now um there's a way we could get that that would be great yeah sure absolutely I can get it to Jason all right great questions so now we've kind of gone through okay idea is the federal law then we've got the components of idea now we're going to get a

026little bit deeper and we're going to talk about um special education eligibility or how one qualifies and then what is our responsibility to identify students with disabilities so the first bullet there is what's called child find find and that really means that our responsibility is to seek out and offer evaluations for any student that is suspected of having a disability if you have students in the system you probably have gotten the principal's email and there are blurbs at certain times through the year that that go out in in the school's emails um it's on our website it it we put brochures in doctor's offices and daycare centers and all over to ensure that people in our community know that we are here and we provide resources um same same goes for for in our schools

027right every year our our schools get a presentation on what is child find as Educators what is their responsibility if they suspect one of their students has a disability the same goes for parents if they suspect a disability we need to be responsive to that and make sure we meet and address concerns and do an evaluation if one is warranted um who is eligible and who we serve um a lot of people don't know this but uh special education actually uh serves students that are ages 3 to 22 in Tennessee so we do evaluations on students before their third birthday so that once they turn three they can start receiving special education services if they qualify and then students who have not earned a general education diploma have the ability to continue working on it

028until they're 22 or to remain in school to receive transition and related Services until their 22nd birthday so we do our numbers that you see tonight uh the numbers that I gave you do include uh students from ages three to 22 so let me give you a little bit of detail related to that so three and four year olds preschool students uh we call them early childhood we call that program our Early Childhood Program generally speaking across the state they're going to say um they're going to differentiate between voluntary prek and prek so when you hear prek or prek for students with disabilities at some other at a state meeting that's what we describe Des cribe as Early Childhood um we have a responsibility to educate those children with peers who do not have IEPs

029uh and so we have a one toone ratio 5050 and we we talk with the state regular I know Maria's team does about that about about that ratio uh and and that program from a timing perspective is generally structured with uh half a day four days a week M Tuesday Thursday Friday um so our teachers are are with a cohort in the morning the buses run in midday and another cohort comes in in the afternoon uh for those three and four year olds uh so that's kind of the basics of that early childhood is not included in Tisa funding and so you you may hear that that's been a big discussion just the last year or so related to the new the new uh Tisa funding um so so that's one side of it the

030other piece I wanted to mention related to our students who are 22 years old they can stay in the program until the end of the school year that they turn 22 uh so the moment they turn three they can come if it happens to be October 12th they can come October 12th if with if they have a disability so we're constantly addressing birthdays but they get they they we will provide services to those students students they could be theoretically 22 and a half when the school year ends so I just want you you guys to be aware of that they don't leave the program the moment they turn 22 they're able to finish the school year that's right thank you um the other thing is who is eligible and who we serve so ages 3

031to 22 and then also they they the student will need to meet eligibility criteria that our state has set forth for one of 18 different educational disabilities in Tennessee so up here this is a lot of information on this slide but I'm going to kind of Orient you to how I have it laid out on the leftand side you're going to see that idea uh uh acronym again those that is that individuals with disabilities Education Act that federal law um the the disability categories that that law sets out are on the leftand side there are 14 of those okay on the right hand side we we recognize all 14 of those and then on the right side Tennessee has added well I'm going to point out something first the purple you'll see on the Le

032hand side you see speech and language impairment is one combined disability under idea Tennessee actually separates it out into speech impairments and language impairments same way with visum impairment you'll see in the red on the leand side idea recognizes that as one disability our state has separated out into Blind and Visually Impaired then on top of that Tennessee has two State specific disability areas one of those is intellect gifted and we're one of about seven or eight don't quote me on the number states that recognize students that are intellectually gifted um as needing an IEP and then the other one is an eligibility category called functional delay and last I checked we were the only state in the nation uh that had this disability category than what do we do for the intellectually gifted yeah

033that's a great question so uh in order to qualify for having a disability you have to meet the the numbers part the criteria that the state sets forth that's one prong the second prong of qualification is that it has to negatively impact your education so the same holds true for students that are gifted so it has to impact their education so what they are getting for example in the general education classroom is not doesn't meet their needs their needs are so much greater than what they the content that they are needing they need additional opportunities sometimes that also comes with some um uh social skills needs some transition needs as they prepare for Life After High School um and and and things like that so yeah all right oh any other questions about disability categories

034I have some data at the end of the presentation that kind of shows you uh by disability category how many students we have well to that point while it's handy um you're going to see it later but 231 students in WCS have IEPs for intellectually gifted 2000 Maria are any of these State well I guess or federal um categories recent ones that have been added in the law or have all these been around for quite some time I think since I've been a psychologist so that's yeah it's been a while okay thank you yes that's a great question where does Dyslexia Fall Would it be specific learning disability or is it not I'm sorry I couldn't hear you um dyslexia dyslexia so it isn't a disability um in special education law specifically but where it

035would fall for student is under specific learning disability so typically and I have a note there out to the side it says specific academic area noted so one could have a specific learning disability in basic reading which is typically where dyslexia or reading comprehension or math calculation or written expression um there are several areas that one could have a specific learning disability in well and Maria doesn't have a plan to get into the details of of uh our our our responsibilities related to theia but that has changed in in recent years absolutely and and not related to special education necessarily yeah and it's not called dyslexia what's it called specific learning disability and basic reading okay Maria real quick do you have a do you have a breakdown um of the 10,500 students that we

036have is like how many iips five fours and then um like I'd love to see just U even the gifted versus every everything else really I mean I don't I don't think I don't want to I don't care about how many of each of these really I do have it in the presentation slide 23 it's coming um okay anything else related to eligibility categories okay uh the next thing is steps in the eligibility and IEP process um and and I I'm not going to go into depth about each of these but I wanted you to see that there are many many times that we meet and review and and support parents and students along this process um the very first thing is written consent for an evaluation before a child can ever be determined to

037be eligible for special education a parent has to give us written consent to do that evaluation that typically in our schools is done through something called a general referral meeting and I like to refer to it as a problem solving team where parents school team members come together because they've identified a weakness or a problem and they want to figure out how to solve it that doesn't always relate re result excuse me in an evaluation for special education but it might sometimes it results in intervention sometimes it results in I'm going to move so jayon can sit uh sometimes it results in uh an evaluation for for special ed or 504 or sometimes more intervention or support from another area in the school um then we go through the evaluation process then we have an

038eligibility meeting to determine whether the child is eligible after that parents have 14 days to make a decision whether they they agree with the decision that the child is eligible or whether they don't um during that time they're welcome to ask questions review our reports come in and meet with us again then we go to after the child is determined eligible let's say they were in this sense then we go to that initial IEP meeting um and at that IEP meeting is where we're making our proposal for what goals Services accommodations and so forth the student will need after we make that proposal a parent again has 14 calendar days to make their decision also each year students get quarterly progress reports I'm going to interrupt right there there and Maria is going to give

039you a little bit of drill down detail in the next few slides about some of these processes but one of the things that we've talked about is especially for a parent who's new to this it can feel like oh my goodness I've got to make a decision right now uh but the the the structure does have those time periods in there uh and and so that's that's a that's a common um concern that I've heard over time uh you know just it it has a potential to feel overwhelming um the the federal guidelines are for us are a timing perspective they're designed to give time in between all those I they they're fast in some ways because of some of the data you have to collect and some of the tests you have to do

040but then in other context they're designed to give some window of time for parents to make decisions I may be overstepping but this is just my impression after having known about these laws for the last 20 years I believe they've largely been designed to make sure that school don't drag their feet and Things fall through the cracks with all these with all these deadlines but they do build time in for parents to make decisions but again I think a point of emphasis that we've talked about is a parent might not know that because they have that 42 Pages uh you know you know that that that they've just looked at maybe for the first time so we've talked about trying to ensure that that's a point of emphasis this is important you don't have to

041make a decision today you've got time well that's a good good segue Jason and I don't necessarily have this on a slide but something that I did want to mention we know as Jason said that it is a lot of information right it's a lot of information to hear that that your child has a disability right that that maybe they're not performing in the way that you hoped they would and so we certainly want to make sure that we are understanding and that we are empathetic with families and parents and so one of the things that we've been problem solving um on my team is is how do we how do we condense we can't we can't not give the the parents the whole procedural safeguards right that's not an option we legally have to

042give it but how can we let parents know on the front end hey you don't have to make a decision today right you've got time to take this information in digest it ask questions follow up before you make a decision so we're working on a process now um kind of a a summary um that will be very specific to tell the parent who they can contact about which topics while they're in that evaluation process and then letting them know on the front end that you don't have to make decisions you've got time make that yeah so um a couple things so one thing um is it not just stated to them that they have this 14-day window we do tell them verbally but I think also when you're hearing all of this information come at

043you I don't know that they always know or understand uh what that means gotcha gotcha gotcha yep that's a good good question for the eligibility meeting that comes before obviously the initial IEP meeting I'm trying to think back we just went through this with my son back in in the summer yeah we were part of the summer crew with that and getting him take over he's on an IEP for his school um and I don't I don't remember the eligibility the eligibility meeting if I can get the word out um is this is this the standard process has been in place for a while okay okay U maybe that was something that my wife went to and I did not I'm not sure that's typically the meeting where the assessment Specialists so the School site

044the speech language pathologist the occupational therapist they're reviewing all of the assessment findings and the team is making a decision about whether that student is eligible for special education or not oh so that's not necessarily where the parent would be at they are there yep parent parent has to be a part or is invited hope I mean is there at all yeah so and then what's how does that break down then from the initial IEP meeting yeah that's a great question um do you care I'm going to run to the next slide and I'll walk through that whole time okay is that good yeah yeah yeah because I have some questions on that no those are great questions so sorry before you go to the next slide on the 14-day window so if a parent

045leaves and they they say hey I want to take some time to look over this then like walk me through the process after that do they have to come back to the school and and schedule another like another meeting do they like how does what do that window work and how's how's that work so typically what happens at the eligibility or the IEP meeting right is we present the The Proposal that's been crafted between the school the parent everybody at that meeting after that meeting happens the parent is going to get a written summary it's something and I have it on another slide but it's called a prior written notice and that prior written notice is is going to detail what the team is proposing and or refusing for the student from the time that

046a student the parent excuse me gets that prior written notice that's when your 14 days begin so typically what happens is they get the documents that they need to sign at the meeting they attend or the teacher will email them or send them that we have an electronic signing system called Panda do they'll send them that way and then the parent has that 14 days to decide how they want to you know whether they want to agree or disagree or whether they want to ask for another meeting so it depends can we have another meeting if a parent asks for it absolutely do all parents ask for another meeting no not necessarily sometimes they they go through they review it they read it they're good with it based on our explanation they sign send it

047back in once they do that we can Implement and move forward that help if they needed to make changes it has to another meeting or they could just like put the changes in the document or yeah changes would require another meeting because decisions in an IEP are team based not individual based unless it's like a typo or you know a name misspelling or something like that but if it's content changes those are team decisions um so even a teacher can't do that individually right yeah I have a quick question at which one of those steps is that procedural Safeguard uh packet given to parents so they will give get it multiple times they will get it when written consent is given at the very first step okay yeah and then they will probably get it

048again at the eligibility meeting and again at the iup meeting okay perfect good that's a great question too right anything else on this one we're going to dive a little deeper all right so special education process this is the very first thing right that initial consent I mentioned that a minute ago this is where we get parental permission to evaluate due to that suspected disability this is initiated either when the parent requests and sometimes we do have parents that request or anybody on the school team suspects the disability again that's typically done in that General referral meeting where we're coming together problem solving it doesn't have to be initiated in that way that's just the most common way so the evaluation process um is it always done from our staff or do we sometimes have

049a provider outside that assesses um no we our staff does the evaluations right we have staff that that complete all of our evaluations so like vision and yes ma'am okay yes ma'am so uh so now we've gotten initial consent right on the the previous slide once the parent gives consent for that evaluation the team then has 60 calendar days in order to complete that evaluation which sounds like a really long time right two whole months well when you take out weekends and you take out any day that the school is closed or the child is sick or the teacher is sick those days start to dwindle um really you're looking at if school is not closed at all and nobody is ill then you got about 40 days to complete the 40 working days when

050a child would be at school to complete the evaluation if I'm not mistaken that includes summer right it does yep so that's my third bullet under that first section there um the the it doesn't stop for weekends holiday summer school days schools are closed days people are sick that timeline keeps rolling um the other thing that I want to note that second bullet there um after we do that initial evaluation we're going to give you that prior at notice if you uh remember I said earlier that is that summary document that's provided to the parent um once we propose something it's provided that parent within 10 school days and it's going to detail what was proposed and or refused any questions on that section yes um so I think some of the emails that we've

051received we're talking about zeroing in on this the evaluation and then the eligibility meeting and so parents who request to get that evaluation in advance of the eligibility meeting may do so is that is that correct if it is completed in advance yes we our practice is if it's completed and they request it we provide it to them in advance yes and does the state law have a requirement for when it must be completed by no it does a deadline no no the state law doesn't have that um honestly I I think when I think of evaluations of this nature I think that I I liken it often times to getting a report from your doctor and getting that report without any explanation uh I don't know about y'all but I am in no way

052uh qualified to interpret any kind of medical test or uh something to that nature and so when my doctor reviews those with me he's usually with me he or she and explaining those things to me we treat this in in a very similar way and the parent we are reviewing it the people who are qualified to administer the assessments and interpret those result results are the ones that are reviewing that with the parent and explaining it to them then but the law just to be clear but the law does not have that in place it does not no because they have they have the right to receive it prior no no no the there is no part of Tennessee law or federal law that requires an evaluation report in advance but if we have it

053available if if it's finished our practice our practice is to give it to them is it common practice that that they wouldn't be done in advance of the meeting I I think it varies it's again it's individualized there may be a psychological report that somebody's working on the day before the meeting to finish up um some sometimes the timeline of appointments for for conversations the testing uh renders it that way Maria I don't know statistically speaking how many are are that way but I I don't think we have a data number to the way to track that but I can tell you that just anecdotal Mo we don't we don't get a ton of requests in advance most of the parents come to the meeting they they get a review of their results they ask

054questions they go home they process it if they have questions and then then then we meet again if they need it or we talk on the phone to answer their questions that's that's our typical what typically happens do you think that's maybe because they don't know that they can request it in advance I don't know I don't know I I uh I have really haven't ever experienced that how is the IEP then put together for this let's say the the evaluations and things aren't done till the day before the meeting well that this this slide describes how because there's still there's still other other timelines after that yes the IEP is not put together immediately so we've got eligibility up here now we're going to move to initial IEP so then after we have the

055eligibility meeting then there's 30 calendar days between the eligibility and the first IEP meeting it may be sooner right but we have to have it done within 30 calendar days so Tony to your question that's when we're putting it together right we're taking all the data that we've gleaned from the evaluations we've got parent input we've got observations we've got the teachers input and that's how we're making a draft of the IEP and there is um and it's on the third bullet under initial IEP there is a Tennessee law it's not in federal law um that requires that the IEP go home to the parent so that draft of the plan uh 48 hours in advance of the IEP meeting and so um that gosh I guess that maybe was put in place maybe seven

056eight years ago approximately don't quote me on the number of years ago um it's a state board R sorry um and so that's 48 hours in advance of the IEP meeting so we had the the eligibility meeting needs to happen within 60 days of the the approval for testing can and so it could be on day 58 59 57 depending on scheduling whatever then the parents have 10 days after that to say Okay I want to go through the IEP process 14 14 I'm sorry 14 uh and then that initiates that 30 days correct okay so I yeah I have a qu or just that's probably more of a statement so if I understand this the evaluation is done by the psychologists and the support staff depending depending upon how many uh Services the child

057needs and then at that that initial um evaluation uh the professionals come and explain to the parents um all this you know what they found out what the children child needs and just like you know a doctor would and stuff yes ma'am okay and so then um after that then they have that 14 days to evaluate or to to process all of that stuff and then then you're going to proceed with the IEP which is more the procedures for how to um U to help the the students you're going to serve the child yeah how how the child's going to be served right okay that's right okay yep all right um so then after we've we've had our 30 calendar days or maybe we're at 20 we've done it a little sooner um we've given

058the the invitation to the meeting which is 10 calendar days in advance for the parent they've gotten the IEP draft 48 hours in advance we meet we develop the IEP right we're we're looking at goals we're looking at Services accommodations maybe modifications um to support this student and then after that they're going to get that document again that's called a prior written notice that is that summary document that explains to the parent what we're proposing and what we're refusing so for example it might have we're proposing that um Maria have uh services in math and reading and uh occupational therapy right and it's going to tell why and then it's going to give uh anything else we considered and we didn't agree on right so maybe the team considered physical therapy and decided oh Maria

059really didn't need that service based on the data um so the parent gets that prior written notice uh within 10 school days of the initial IEP meeting and then after that um the parent has to give us consent before we can implement that initial IEP so we're wait we're waiting at that point for the parent to decide uh if they want to proceed with the proposed IEP or whether they don't uh if they want another meeting they could certainly ask for that um but that very first IEP the parent has to give that that consent for us to implement any questions on that part I I have a question about you know when there's when parents maybe don't uh agree with a an evaluation and just I'm just asking question do they have an opportunity

060to get a second opinion outside of the school system yeah that's a great question so um one of well let me say this first we want to do everything we can to help that parent feel comfortable and understand the results so that's our first go-to right if that requires another meeting for us to sit down review it does the parent think some additional assessment is needed do we need to talk through that so that's kind of our first go-to but parents do have um one of the rights under the procedural safeguards is what's called an independent education evaluation and and they can can there are certain instances in which a parent is or a child rather is eligible for that um and so if the parent doesn't agree with our results um they can ask

061for that independent education evaluation yeah yeah that's a great question so um if the parent uh asks for an an independent education evaluation again we have these acronyms we call it an ie uh and so when that is com if they're approved for that right they meet the criteria for that once uh we receive that report we schedule another either eligibility or IEP depending on why they asked for the the IE um and we will consider those results as a team that's a great question okay all right so now we're moving on to the annual IEP right we've gone through consent we've gone through eligibility we've gone through the initial IEP now annually before you say annually your your your question triggered something in my mind parents can say I don't want special education services

062that's that's their choice they can they have the power to turn that down even if a student qualifies they do not have to accept services or eligibility so are the the evaluations and these reports and things are these because I know I know idea has it written in there that they can get those documents like Student Records right 48 hours in advance of of a meeting are these not considered records so I don't think that they are official Student Records until they are presented signed and it becomes the official report I think before it is um reviewed signed agreed upon all of those pieces it is it is a draft and so that isn't a part of their official record um while it's in the preparation phases correct it's not part of their official record

063but the Tennessee public the Tennessee open public records act allows them to request those records even if they are draft so true Dana do you have anything to add to that I don't we don't have to discuss it offline we discuss it right now that's what Maria's here for I don't know that Maria can offer if if I may Dana your microphone's not on I just said I don't think Maria can offer that legal advice as to the Tennessee records act so there is is a Tennessee public records act um someone could make a request if it is in fact their child then my office would look and see whether or not it is an open record um and if it is provide that there is not the 48 hour um guideline what there is

064is what is reasonable um time time period there is also 7 days after a request if it's not reasonable to provide that request to the requester then um my office provides an estimate about when that request would be available okay if the assuming that's all the case I I have no argument with any of that I I just I don't know how we honor parents and their children by going into a meeting if these things aren't completed until the day before we drop this on them in a meeting where we're going to tell them all these different things about their their child I just went through this with my own son those meetings can be somewhat devastating for a family it's hard to hear a lot of times you have people that break down um

065it would seem to me that it is nowhere even close to a best practice to conduct it that way and I get timing and all of that but I think if we're truly and and I think we all are here we would agree that it's the student and their families that are the priority here this should be a common practice for them it's just a simple way to honor them they have the the dignity to be able to digest this process it get a cry out at least a day or two before they have to walk in and sit in front of five people that tell them all this news and we can get all legal and me mouthed about it but I think that's just a way to provide provide for ourselves a a

066way to obus skate that and I I I don't think that should be our default I think we should look for ways to make that policy in my opinion well I'll I'll tell you a little bit of my experience and it may not happen every time um when when families talk to our schools about the testing that's when that discussion first happens you know there's there's there's a suspicion or there's a possibility that your child might have some disabilities we're going to test um they go through the process of the testing and and they have those conversations and in essence say you've still you've got time and and not there there's procedures with those rules for the dates but there ought to be that conversation too this can be hard to your point you've got

067time to process this you don't have to make a decision today uh and and in those times when the work has been done we we do provide it like we talked about and I see what you're saying and and and I think this gets back to to what we were talking about earlier this is so individualized because every person's response or reaction to that information is going to be different and you're right we need to be empathetic to that and what I see and our hope is it's a human effort it may not always be perfect but what I see is I I I I see in the ones I've sat in the conversation with the parents letting them know hey you need time to process this and I see what you're saying you're what

068I think what you're saying is when the opportunity is there let them get it ahead of time so they can process it outside the presence of these of these education folks I think I think something that we should consider two things come to my mind one is that when we are doing an evaluation for special education when we are first talking with the parent about consent we're talking about what disabilities we're suspecting at that time right we're not going to sit down at the table 60 days later and Sayo your child has autism or o your child right we're talking about those things in advance when we are getting consent for the evaluation um also the the parent is a part of the evaluation which I think is super important right they're providing input whether

069that be developmental history they're providing rating skills they're providing feedback they are a piece of all of the evaluation comp all of the evaluations for eligibility and Mar could you also talk briefly about the difference between a doctor's diagnosis and what our education folks are doing yeah that's a good point there are times when a student might have a medical diagnosis of a disability something like autism or like dyslexia and that student still has to meet eligibility criteria for an educational disability which is different than a medical diagnosis and they don't always align a student could have a medical diagnosis of autism and not meet the education criteria uh the flip side is true a student may have an educational disability of autism and have never gotten a medical diagnosis so the the they are

070different Right medical diagnosis and educational eligibility but but Tony to your point about if it's something that's showing up first on the educational side that can be devastating yeah I mean it is you know we we went the route of we had an evaluation through cisin and which was a we were on the wait list for a year for cisin and Vanderbilt for an Autism evaluation I think we got cisin first within 10 months um and so we went through that process and then we we took that and we then we had you know the school evaluations and all of that um but it was I just have to say it was it was less of a hard conversation in the medical diagnosis than it was in the IEP meeting um a reason being is

071just it could have been that we had a wonderful doctor you know who was just very kind he was he was very great guy highly recommend him but also just from my experience back in August whenever July August um you know you you sit down and you've got this very clinical language detailing out these different things that are wrong with your kid and things that you didn't really even consider but they well you know we and we also did this this evaluation and we kind of found this and you have this rating scale and it falls in this and it falls in that you're this category and it's all these labels and all these different things and that is heart-wrenching it is heart-wrenching and we got the report ahead of time and it was still

072heart-wrenching um and and we had an advocate that you know helped um walk us through that and it was still heartwrenching um so it worries me that people that wouldn't have Advocate or wouldn't get it ahead of time and if our I don't want to say excuse but if our uh default is well you know we don't have to provide it ahead of time and you know then you sit and you go through this that just to me seems like a very cold a cold way to approach something like this and so I I I I just think we very seriously need to look at making that solidied because it is hard and and two with you know um I know there's like the 14 days and all of that but you know and even

073me we had we got done with our IEP meeting it was like you know and here just sign this here and we'll get started right now I I had no idea of a 14 day and I'm a school board member with a kid in there so I it's not clear so um I don't think these waiting periods and all of this that we put in there oh we're building all this time that may be but it is not clear to the parent it is not it's not made clear to them so I I think we have to work we have to work at making that a priority so let me make a comment if I if I may I'm sorry Claire do you want to go first or yeah just just a quick point please

074um I Mr Golden just think about I come I keep coming back to the meaningful participation piece in my head and um and and to me if if a parent gets that report at least even just 24 hours in advance of the meeting and they can read through it they're already able to come in and be a slightly more you know prepared and a meaningful participant in that conversation and it might even then prevent having to have secondary meetings that that you know a principal has to attend and all of these different staff members has to attend so that's kind of the angle that I'm thinking about all of this from um I've received these reports for you know one of my children and um not as a part of this school system but my

075husband and I were able to read it and then we had the meeting with the psychologist and I was able to ask questions so I don't I mean I hear what you're saying Maria um but but I don't think that it's as complicated as you know sometimes they're made out to be um in all situations so I just want us to think about that meaningful participation P thank you for that I think we have room to grow I will say um it is totally unacceptable if anyone has even implied to you that the answer is we don't have to provide it that should not be happening I I haven't seen it but but if if it has happened it shouldn't happen and we have room to grow yeah I I mean just just on that

076point I have I have heard okay well thank you I would agad sure so it feels like maybe we're talking about two different things here one is the the draft report which is I understand is a finalized copy it's you know ready to be reviewed with changes made afterwards if and when needed the other thing we're talking about here is work product which is complete evaluations things are started uh as to what you testified or testified to would you explain in some cases maybe there is even conflicting points of view from educational needs and then medical evaluations or so forth um so I I went I've gone through two of these evaluation processes and multiple IEP meetings I said when we went through there was a lot of material there a lot reports and going

077through and it was helpful to have that expert in the room to sort of explain what does that mean what is that test based upon um everything else with that and I would just we're talking about being compassionate to the parent I don't know that it's compassionate to give them incomplete work product that maybe giving a a false impression or conclusion or an incomplete one and certainly without the ability to have an expert in the room to ask questions about and have those conversations because as you said it is a team conversation now the draft one I think you stated you know it's our standard process to well must be provided 48 hours in advance so that is being provided and ahead of time the question about the the work product incomplete work product that

078being provided I I I I think that's where I'm not agreeing if that is the statement that that should be provided I think I think sometimes uh what I come back to and being in hundreds maybe more of of these meetings throughout my career thus far I think that it is overwhelming right it is a lot of information and it is hard sometimes right I I I can speak both personally and professionally right on this topic um and so I think that what I come back to is I never want a parent to get something not know how to interpret what they're looking at and be devastated for a reason that they didn't need to be devastated right because they don't they don't know what they're reading and I'm not simply implying that our parents

079aren't smart people that's not it at all I'm saying that if you you didn't have training in these types of Assessments statistical analysis standard scores percentile ranks you're I don't know that you would know exactly what is being communicated and so that is the one thing that I that I think about I do acknowledge that we we need to be compassionate we need to make sure that parents understand their rights and have the time to review all of this and provide things in advance when we're able right I do agree with that but I but I also think that we also need to be CAU cant of the fact that sometimes parents might not know exactly what those scores are telling them and what that means for their child's future and so hearing a professional

080that is trained to interpret them review that and answer questions I think is helpful and Claire maybe your suggestion is is well I'm not going to say maybe your suggestion is something we need to look at which is in those situations maybe a phone call ahead of time could be helpful well that's kind of I was going to comment on that the meaningful participation I think that's you know really important and I um I kind of I'm on the side of having the information ahead of time so they can come into the meetings and ask these questions and of course they can email and shoot a quick email saying what does this mean but I think I I still I think it should be best practice to give the parents information ahead of time and

081so they can process it and then they can really because I've been there and and they can really be more of a part of the meeting and offer Solutions and advice to what will work best for their child because they know the child best yeah I have may may I oh go ahead Dan go ahead sorry yeah Marie I have a I have a question I've had emails left and right about different uh things like the draft for instance that says it's a draft on the initial it's a it's an evaluation is this a an an evaluation draft is that the same what's what's the difference yeah that's a great question so typically not typically when we come to an initial eligibility meeting where we're sharing results of Assessments typically that document is the final

082compilation of that multidisciplinary team so that that report is not just the psychologist for example information right it's input from parents it's input from teachers uh special Educators General Educators all different kinds of people that that Psych is synthesized looked at it related to the state's eligibility criteria and and provided that in a report so that typically is a final product unless right if we're reviewing it and there's a typo or a name change or the parent says oh wait that was they learned a walk at 15 months not 12 months right we're going to go back and make changes like that if there is something that that is a a clerical error like that um but typically those are final products the draft comes in for the IEP that is the plan that has

083the students goals and services and accommodations well for an for an annual IEP what would parents ask for a draft in in advance is that what they're asking for an annual IEP they don't have to ask for anything in advance it's provided to them unless they say they don't want it so everyone's provided information about their child beforehand for an IEP yes unless the team is not doing a draft now sometimes that happens like if a parent calls a meeting and we don't necessarily know what the meeting is we don't know what they're asking for in advance we're not going to make a draft because we wouldn't know what to change right so we'll come to the table and we can make changes in real time if we need to but otherwise if it's an

084annual meeting or or an addendum that the school is calling and they're creating a draft it is provided to the parent 48 hours in advance it's actually on the invitation that the parent gets they select a box I do want a copy or I don't if they don't then obviously we wouldn't necessarily provide it but if they check yes I want a copy or let's say they don't check anything at all we don't get the invitation back we still send it um go oh go ahead sorry Dan no go ahead that's all right uh well I was just so I I guess I when it comes to um the evaluations and things and we can't give it to them in a fragile state or something that might be conflicting and all of that that's just

085where I I I have a hard time logically trying to process about how if it if the information is in that state the day before the meeting I don't know how it automatically gets there the next day for that meeting to be played if it's in such a fragile state that the parents can't even read it be and it's and everything is there might be con conflict um things that conflict with each other and all of that then I'm not really sure how we could even go into a meeting because it seems like we would be going in with fragmented information so I that just that just kind of seems absurd to me secondly I also i i people can read I mean they may not be uh you know um educated in this field

086but they're going they're they can read the reports you know and they're going to have it you know in two days they're going to be sitting down with Professionals in two days I I I agree with the meaningful participation you can't have meaningful participation in any meeting that where there's an agenda and there is all the information that five people have and the one party doesn't and they're supposed to be a meaningful participant in this six member team and they've gotten nothing while everyone else has had it and they've not been able to read it or anything you know that that it I don't know how in the world we would call that meaningful participation just it's illogical on its face so um once again I I I don't know how we can justify saying

087running right into a meeting if the if the evaluations and the data is in such a fragile state the day before so much so that we can't give it to people people and then we have the meeting the next day and somehow it all came together but just in that magical you know couple hours and two I'm not I once again I just people they can read they can read and um to have meaningful participation I think they need that because you don't even know what kind of questions to ask in the middle of that even with the professionals guiding you through it you're just trying not to cry half the time much less know what to answer and then at the end it's a hey go ahead and sign this so we can get

088this implemented maybe there's a 14-day thing mentioned maybe there's not so it's just I I you know that that's my concern I'm still I'm still hearing about meetings where they go in and there's a verbal evaluation uh about your child um and then uh of course to get answers you have to come back on Friday when the IEP documents are ready is that is that correct I'm not sure I understand the question verbal evaluation it seems to me like the emails that I'm trying to understand and I'm trying to understand uh it's it seems like there's more than one meeting uh to get to the IEP meeting there are there are multiple meetings that you have to have an eligibility meeting to to determine eligibility well they're all the initial they eligible now this is

089I'm talking about uh annual okay or annual or a third year okay re-evaluation is there is there an evaluation written for that first meeting where they say okay your child seems like he's uh really advancing in this area but really falling behind in this area is there a document that they can sit down and read and then prepare for the why does it have to be two meetings I mean it would save a whole lot of money a whole lot of time if we had an IEP meeting and I think I think that if a document is present and available to every one of them um they could read that out outside of a meeting and then they can go outside and and go to get professional advice or you know an advocate to explain

090this stuff so they're all prepared for the meeting Dan Dan's question Maria I think with annual meetings they're often just one meeting annual usually yeah unless the team doesn't finish right if if they've allotted an hour and you know people have other commitments they may have to REM meet if they didn't get through the annual IEP but I would say the vast majority of the almost 7,000 kids or one one meeting to do their annual right one other thing I just wanted to say is a lot of uh parents that I've heard from uh say one school is different from another one principal will say well I didn't know uh anything about that you know the the first uh evaluation I didn't know that you could get them or some some schools provided rather than

091you know have to be asked about it they provide it um what's I mean we need a I think Tony said it we just need a standing operating procedure on this and I'm probably sure we've got one but um that's that's what I wanted to know is the the people have that document in their hand they're preparing for the meeting it seems like the meeting would go much better and get it all done I mean gez how much time does this take it's it's very time consuming for staff and and teachers and counselors and and everyone plus the parents when they've got to have two meetings they've got to take off work some are in this County people work and um it's very difficult so I mean that's that's I think it's something pretty easy

092that we could fix if we really put our heads together for the for the parents and staff and teachers I had a couple questions um I want to um how how is the information for that child gathered um and organized and is it stored in one place electronically do or do we have do are we keeping a record of like okay they they met with a speech therapist or speech pathologist on this Tuesdays and Thursdays here's our reports are we collecting all of that and keeping it in one spot on each child who has an iip and I have one more question after that okay yeah so that's a great question we have a um it's not a cumulative file but it's it's their special education file and it's both a paper file and electronic

093file and so the state actually provides an electronic database called TN pulse psse and it is used required to be used Statewide if you've ever seen an IEP document it was generated from that system right U used to be called Ed plans some of you may be familiar with that terminology uh but TN pulse is that electronic database and that's where um we plug in the information and it generates the documents and all districts in Tennessee are are required to use that reports on there like and our reports um once we're done with them we upload them into the system so that they are housed there we also keep a paper copy as well and so each student with um special education has a paper file in addition to the electronic file 504 as well

094and and one second Donna just goes right along with that question so are you talking about like a service log like that they when they have so yeah I guess so are there like are there service logs kept for um the services that they're receiving throughout the year so that like if they supposed to go out on Tuesdays and Thursdays you know to have a speech therapy or occupational therapy or what have you are logs maintain that says yep it was done this day by this person at this time with this student type of thing yeah so we uh for all of the services in the IEP all services are intended to address goals right in the IEP that's that's the reason we provide the services to give them access and to address goals in

095the IEP so from there our staff are required whether that be a speech therapist a special ed teacher a hearing teacher whatever it happens to be to collect data on those goals so the data is logged in and now staff have um the ability to log that in any way they want before they enter it into the progress report that is given quarterly so some of them keep it on paper until they enter it into the database some of them put it right in the database the time they take it so it's not a service log per se but it is a collection of their data as they are working with that student and working on those goals and entering them into the database when what do you mean by data in that sense like

096I'm I guess I'm like a summary of what they're doing that's one thing but I'm like if they have specifically um determined that that this child per the IEP is supposed to receive these services this amount of times per week at this time surely there's a log that's kept this is done and it's done by this person at this time like correct so there's not a log that I mean right our teachers have their schedules our therapists have their schedules right they have all the students plugged into their schedules and they serve them at those times they're not writing down on a sheet of paper every time they you know a child comes into their classroom or comes into their their office right to provide services what they're doing is is when they're working with

097students they are collecting data on the goals that they are addressing with that student yeah and then that data is put into our system provided to parents more frequently if they ask but at a minimum of every quarter and that's how the parents the team is looking to say is that student making progress if the student is not making progress then we need to look to say oh why are they not making progress right would um yeah have service logs ever been a practice that was maintained for special ed teachers not since I've been in the district for related service Personnel several years back um we used them before we got the electronic database system that the state now provides we didn't have that prior wouldn't have okay have wouldn't we wouldn't it be helpful

098I would think one just so we you know parents know that it's happening one for the IP but also as kind of like a cover our rear type thing because let's say we get sued that hey I believe this has happened in the past that we've gotten sued hey my child is not receiving the services that they're entitled to based on this IEP wouldn't that log then help us to be like oh no they did and here's the log that they got it every da I mean that's service logs I don't know that seems like a would be a common practice and very practical and helpful we go to Great Links for attendance normal attendance every 15 minutes or something wouldn't the therapist or the teacher providing the service wouldn't they have a second attendance

099roster or something that I saw this student at this time it would be attendance so when when and Maria fill in or correct me when a student is pulled out for a specific Service as an example occupational therapy or or uh or physical therapy Direct hearing services we do have those records of those students being pulled out for those service we have a record that they receive that service on that day so we collect the data that we are collecting when data evidence is that they receive the service is what you're saying it's not a service log per se like I saw Maria for 15 minutes on this day or this day it's not that it's I worked on this goal and here is the data that I collected so there there are records of

100that but it's going to be related to the related to specific is connected on as well as the data points when they collect so so in that okay so maybe it's just like the card of the horse here semantics but is there a date and time linked to that data each time yeah there's not a a time like it doesn't give amount of minutes but it does have a date connected to each data point yes and that's printed on the parents get a graph um of that now I will say the system itself is had some kinks in terms of printing those graphs out of wcs's control so we've been working really diligently to try to get that in a format that is helpful to families um working with the state to try to say

101who these have to be readable um for our famili so but yes it does have a date connected to those databas is it standard practice that that is collected after each service on how the goal is written so each goal is written the team crafts each goal and so sometimes uh goals are worked on every time they see the provider sometimes data is collected on those goals um you know once a week it depends on what the goal is is and how many goals in that area a provider is working on um within their service time Maria would it be fair to compare them to I know it's non dire I'm sorry would it would a comparison to like medical records be a fair comparison I think so I mean I think uh when the

102when you get medical records and it has a test and the results I think it's kind of like that um I will say I've seen I've seen nursing charts at hospitals it's not going to be that kind of detail sure no but I'm just sort of thinking the notes that the perhaps the doctor's taking with the visitor so for is it I'm just trying to visualize it in my mind sometimes they're more formalized sometimes less so I know that's a much more regulated but it's typically however the goal is measured so sometimes that's an accuracy percentage sometimes it's a number of Trials and and and number accurate sometimes it's number of attempts it really kind of depends on what goal whether that's a a reading goal or or a social skills goal or a math

103goal it kind of depends so I have something I notic on the other thing you talked about the different um reports that are handed out so all of that information is like they have their regular um every quarter they have that I report which gives the parents that data yes every quarter at a minimum right just and then they get their classroom reports as well yes ma'am right yeah the the quarterly report on the IEP goals is in addition to what every other student gets so they're still going to get your traditional classroom progress reports and and Report cards and things like that from their teachers but the progress report is in addition to that right so that would give the the data that um Tony's is asking about whether the student is progressing on

104the goal how you know are they on the way to reaching their goal or are they not okay I I guess I'm gonna jump in with a question don't yeah um still got my second question too the um going back to this the slide that you've shown us both in the both the uh the top and the bottom section it talks it says if a draft in the third bullet of each if a draft is being developed is there a scenario in which for an IEP meeting like this there wouldn't be a draft being developed yeah that's a great question sometimes there's not um so for example if the team is coming together and they're coming together to discuss one specific purpose right let's say um the team the students oh goodness maybe needs counseling

105right and we're going to come together and talk about that the team may not develop a draft because nothing's changed yet for them to put forward to present they're going to come to the table with the current IEP they're going to talk about it make changes in real time and then provide it to the parent another scenario where that might be the case is if a parent calls a meeting and we don't necessarily know what they're asking for we really wouldn't know what to change in a draft so we would come with the current IEP and make changes in real time so in every instance in which there is a draft being developed that is is going to require discussion or a decision that draft is being given to the parents 48 hours in advance

106that is our expectation and that is the requirement yes and that's a state requirement it is okay so I think we I think we've got a you know we're diving pretty far into the weeds here which is fine because I wanted us to be able to have this discussion but I think there's still some unclear issues as to what um the real concerns actually are as far as what's not being provided vers versus what is I mean because I think I think it's going to require some f some further discussion as to whether there's procedural changes needed or policy changes needed or any of that because I think we we're kind of spinning our Wheels here a little bit because I don't know we're hearing you say that that if if a draft is developed

107for a discussion the parents are getting at 48 hours in advance they are for the IEP yes sir but that not every meeting requires a draft correct to be decided upon and Mr chair to that point the heart of what I've heard I've concentrated on the eligibility process as opposed to the IP process because it's the it's the testing um some of the psychological test for example uh that that that are after that initial uh that are that are prior to the the evaluation meeting which does not have that guarantee that it's going to be provided within 48 Hours whereas the IEPs do if there's a draft so the other question I have and this goes back to a question that was where Dana engaged a minute ago and so this this question is either

108for you Jason or Dana under any under What scenario would a would information about a student not be available to the parent of that student upon request I think that's a question for Dana with respect to the records so several different laws that deal with records gener generally with a student we're looking at educational records we've got a procedure there's federal law as well as some state law dealing with educational records um those typically and let me preface it by saying I'll tell you what the law is then I'll tell you what our practice is if it is an educational record then under federal law there we are allowed 45 days days to provide that to a parent very very rarely does it take us 45 days to do that but there is that time

109frame obviously if we have a parent who's looking for a record we can access it quickly we're going to turn it over we we want the other piece is the law requires or states that it can be viewed by the parent very rarely are we asking the parent to view educational records it's TP it's our practice often times to give them a copy so we try to be over and above when our parents ask for something and do more can you give me please finish I'm sorry oh no go ahead go can you give me an example of of something of a of a student record that would that would potentially require even though we don't do it typically um but that might require up to 45 days to find and provide I'll tell you

110I can't think of one maybe you've seen one the closest I can come up with and I still don't think it would take us 45 days would be if it is not electronic and it is a cume file from Franklin High School when it was first built they're still there we still get requests for records that old I've never since I've been in this role it's never taken us 45 minut 45 days it might take us though two or three because we can't access it quickly so to that point Mr chair for current students this happens all the time a parent calls up to school and says hey can I get a record within a day or two they got the they have the record um we don't live by the 455 day rule to

111that point we don't say well we've got 45 days to provide you that and those requests don't aren't treat aren't aren't processed through uh the the open records act they just go straight to the school and they just provide them and it's simple and it happens daily now the other piece I do want you all to hear is sometimes we have to redact records give you an example for maybe discipline investigation there could be their child's information and then personally identifiable information about another child if that's the case it might take us a little bit longer still nowhere near 45 days but that may take a couple extra days to make sure we've redacted that information but there's no to be clear there's no piece of information about a student that a parent that a

112parent of that student is not entitled to within some period of time if I could interrupt what about an ugly divorce and the custodial parent or a Judicial order that may be an example of an exception so again my office handles those we get subpoenas almost on a daily um almost daily in the scenarios that you just talked about if it's a Judicial subpoena we have seven days to produce it if it is a another subpoena I would love to have more time but we have a pretty quick turnaround um got email today requesting one for two days from now and there's an occasional situation where a court is ordered that one particular parent doesn't have access to records right so that could that that does occasionally happen um but for a parent primary custodian

113to your point Mr chair um now the the the question I'd like to follow up on related to that to to kind of cycle back to what I think is the heart of these evaluations is when something is a work in progress what how how do we respond to those requests so if we are in the middle I'm going to just use an example of discipline because that's often times parents want to see um not just the notice of suspension but they want to see the investigation they want to see the witness statements they want to see the notes of Administrators sometimes um those notes aren't aren't let you can't read them I can't get that word out um therefore they're in their own Shand or the writing is just so atrocious so they may

114have they may type them out um again we're going to communicate with the parent to say here's part of the records but we're waiting on XYZ we've got to redact it or there's confidential information I mean it's every one of those facts are a little bit different but we are still trying to get the information to the parent as quickly as we can um because there's a reason that they're asking for it so but if it is a if it is a draft then I'm going to or probably have a conversation with either the teacher or the administrator to figure out why it's in draft form and what the requester is wanting um and then make a decision based upon our you know what we need to do to provide or not provide that document

115but provide an explanation it may it may be an issue of language and terminology but I think the problem is we're saying that by definition it's a draft until it's final so whatever it is that's being produced prior to the meeting regardless of when the parent receives it is a draft by definition it's a draft so I think that's part of the challeng is is the at different stages of a at different stages of a draft is it eligible to be viewed or or not you know versus I think that's the issue of a draft is a draft until it's not a draft but well I guess my question is is the initial evaluation a draft because that's if could you go back a slide please because I think that's the heart of of what

116we're talking about it's this eligibility meeting that where there is a report and I don't think that report is a draft and some parents would like to receive that report in advance of the meeting and so and that goes to the meaningful participation piece and and then to see on the next slide that parents received drafts of the IEP document 48 hours in advance it does beg the question why couldn't we provide that same time frame for the um the eligibility meeting so it's just something to think about I think it would require a procedure change or a policy change but I think there's several board members who have expressed an interest in um honoring those requests and and and where we're at right now is and I and Maria I may be oversimplifying this

117but let me step back we're going to have that deep discussion based on this discussion that you all have had because we do want to grow and be as as empathetic and and and decent to our families as possible if I'm not mistaken Maria the your expectation for your staff is if somebody asked for it give it to them but we have not been proactively giving those prior to the eligibility meeting is that accurate if it is done I yes our expectation is that they give it to them okay right even regardless of whether they've asked for it no no okay I should have no let me say this if if the team is still working on the report it is not complete right it doesn't have conclusions it doesn't have all the information in

118there it wouldn't be it would almost be like a a radiologist giving you something that only had one part of the X-ray right like you you you you want the whole picture of all of the assessments that's been done so we're not our practice is not to give pieces and parts because in order to determine eligibility you need need all of the information to look at together so once that is completed if a parent asks we're fine to give it yeah and Tony I know you made the point if it's not completed two days in advance why not right I'm using my language yeah yeah that's that's kind of my point with it is like I'm like I don't I I don't I don't see why we wouldn't just say hey look we need to

119put this off two more days or whatever it is have this done give it to the parents and then have a meeting I don't see any reason to any legitimate reason to say hey sorry we can't get it till right before and that seems like I don't know a poor practice in sense so I guess I mean if we could Mr chair if we could I mean I I think we've all raised our concerns I'd like to hear the rest of Maria's report because I want to know what we're doing and if we have clarifications if we can clarify what we are doing right now and then we we can succinctly voice our concerns about what we're doing and maybe you know and and to tee up our our future discussions about po we're not

120changing anything right now like we just got to we just have to identify the issues but let's don't belabor them let's let let's well we've had it we've had I think I mean is any does anybody question what we I just I just think it's time we've been talking about it for an hour like I understand your concerns I think they're concerns that we can address at Future at Future meetings I don't I don't think I don't need you to tell me I can't ask questions of Miss Grio when she's here I that's what I'm here to do I'm fine with asking questions I like what you're what we're doing I know I know it might feel belabored to you but these are concerns that I have I understand that but you're but you're airing

121your concerns and not your questions for for Miss grigo like we all we all understand what the I guess the point of the the point of her presentation is to tell her to the current State of Affairs and and I think you've you've adequately addressed your question I I'll decide when I've adequately adequately addressed it I you don't get to determine that for me okay I'm I'm I'm going to Mr chair please I'm going to jump in right here because this is becoming a conversation between two people not a not a discussion of the board okay we let's let's get back to the discussion that we were here to have which is a presentation about special ed now I I can appreciate the fact that we've brought up some concerns those are duly noted we

122need to dive into those further if there are places where we need to make policy changes or procedural changes it's on record now for for those things to be pursued okay so we will um those are not going away you you've got notes on that um we need to have further discussions but let's I agree that we should out of courtesy to Maria let her finish her presentation because we are an hour and a half into our meeting um again we said at the outset this was going to be a lengthy discussion and it's fine that it was this is there's a lot here there's a lot to talk about in special not just one thing that seems to be a potential sticking point but there's many other things that are being done in special

123ed that we needed to process so let's please do that and then let's but all all agree that we're not going to walk away from these issues okay thank you Mr chair I'm making that commitment as well we're not walking away from that all right so I think we talked about annual IEP and I mentioned that that is done at least annually um your your same 10 calendar notice of a meeting your 48 hours in advance of the draft your prior written notice all of those things are the same uh each time we have an IEP meeting when it becomes the annual IEP meeting and not the initial the parent has 14 calendar days from receipt of that prior written notice to determine whether they agree or disagree before the IEP can be implemented um

124so the only difference between the top section annual IEP and addendum IEP is that the annual IEP is required once a year an addendum IEP means it can be done anytime a team member asks that's a parent that's a teacher that's a principal anybody can say hey I think we need to come together and discuss blank regarding Maria um if the parent requests the meeting we must offer that meeting within 10 school days of the request um they still have to receive that invitation if we develop a draft a a copy is still provided 48 hours in advance prior written notice again they have that 14 calendar days from receip of the prior written notice to make their decisions all right re-evaluation so we talked about initial IEP and then annual IEP and addendum IEP

125a quick question about the um annual and um addendum IEPs um how how does the team communicate beforehand and is that communication whether it's email because I know there they're coming together and the parents not there how does the team communicate you know what are we going to set for the goals what and do they share assessment you know because because teachers are constantly assessing am I effective am I doing this um is the child learning and are those assessment notes and the preparation notes how can we include the parent or or is how does the team work together before the meeting before the parent comes in and and how do they communicate that yeah so when we develop the draft there is a section of the draft called the plafs that is a terrible

126acronym it's present levels of academic and functional performance I think don't don't quote me on the exact it's essentially a present level so when the teacher assesses and they pull all that information together of the general educ tion teacher gives information the special educator any assessments that the team has done that goes in a section of the IEP so the parents going to have access to all of that in the draft in addition to a discussion of it in the meeting um so and and then when given beforehand to the parents yeah 48 Hours yep that's a great question um so re-evaluation so this happens for students with disabilities uh with IEPs every three years so every three years the IEP team is required to come together review all of the testing that has been

127done and current eligibility past eligibilities current performance and determine whether the child continues to be a child with a disability or not um sometimes that requires additional assessment sometimes the team says no based on all the data we have we believe this child continues to be eligible and and they sign forms and and explain it all to the parents and then the child continues to be eligible sometimes it requires additional assessments the law does say in the second to last bullet there under reevaluation that if the IEP team determine additional assessments are needed it says we have a quote unquote reasonable amount of time to complete those assessments I can tell you that really has def been defined in the case law as 60 calendar days which is the same as the initial so we

128get around 60 days it might be day 61 it might be day 62 but it's around that 60 calendar days um that that we're really trying to shoot for um with that reasonable amount of time the other thing timeline thing we've mentioned it a couple times but I have it down there is that progress reports are provided four times a year um just for your information it's typically when report cards go home they also get progress reports it could be within a couple weeks before or after but it's around around about that time frame that's different is that different for the EC program though correct a little bit or no is it four times a year too it is uh the EC program might be Prov providing like curriculum updates more frequently um but but

129IEP progress support at a minimum of four times a year gotcha cool great question all right so we've we've swam all through special education and lots of timelines we're going to jump on over to 504 um Section 504 is a federal civil rights law and it actually the the intent is to PR prevent against discrimination of prevents discrimination against individuals with disabilities um the the idea is that students with disabilities have equal access to education and so you see that acronym again that fape acronym it in it is to ensure that students with disabilities receive a fape in public elementary and secondary schools all right so key points eligibility looks very different for 504 we still do assessments but the eligibility criteria is much different there's a little bit more to it but this is

130the basic premise of of eligibility for 504 whereas special education has those 18 different areas this really is looking at some sort of disabling condition physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities walking seeing hearing speaking breathing learning working right so many many things uh could could make a person eligible for a Section 504 plan think of things sometimes diabetes sometimes asthma sometimes dyslexia uh just really kind of depends on the student and their individual needs um a Section 504 plan typically includes accommodations to that learning environment to help the student access their Gene curriculum so typically you're thinking of things like additional time a use of assistive technology uh maybe a uh breaks if they need them maybe you know maybe a student is diabetic and they need to

131take have snacks right or or or take extra restroom breaks things like that those can all be delineated um accommodations if a child were to need that one of the things that I people ask me what's the difference between an IEP and a 504 uh you know really generally speaking right it's it's deeper than this but really generally speaking if a child needs specialized instruction in order to receive a free appropriate public education that's more on the IEP realm if they need accommodations for Access that's typically the 504 realm that's not set in stone there is some variation there but that's the typical um it this rule has been in place since 1973 it's the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 uh historically some of these Services have been provided outside of 504 but in the more

132recent years we have seen a lot more parents access those services that might have just been informally provided through the formal 504 process is that a good that is yeah so our numbers have gone up really just because of Trends we've seen across the country not just here it is certainly ac across the across the state um is it fair to say 504 is more subjective and IEP is more objective or idea is more objective I think Ida has more strict requirements for eligibility where 504 is more open more broad is that fair but okay is there a difference in the cost to the school district between accommodating a student and having an IEP I think it varies depends on the need of the student it may be that an accommodation includes purchasing a piece

133of equipment uh so it so it it it it has a potential to have those costs but we occasionally see that with IEPs as well yeah yeah I I you know for example a student like me right I can't hide I have a physical disability right um in school I needed desks that I could get up and down from right and so for a 504 those those provided those those death to me so that I could access my education just like my peers any other questions I just real brief on 504 right I I um can I can I toss can I toss this out related 504s do the timelines that we spent time talking about in the context of IEPs also apply to 504s thank you for prompting me I have that on my

134notes that are laying over there uh so they are similar right there are less uh restrict uh less spe specificity um in 504 with regards to the timelines but what we've seen in a lot of the case law and things is that they tend to defer to idea timelines so we tend to stick to those we we our goal is to meet annually on 504s our goal is to do the reow every three years we really try to mirror those timelines there isn't the 48 hour draft piece with the 504 but but very some of them are very similar y all right so the data that I told you would be would be here I think Jay you had asked about some of this um this is just total disability served and I have the

135data all the way back to 2009 um well before I was the director here um but just longit longitudinally so you can see kind of how we've grown um in in our serving our students with disabilities we have close to 7,000 I'm sorry is that growth proportional to our student growth growth or is it disproportionate it's not been really proportionate generally speaking um uh as an example our student enrollment data the last three years has has been pretty flat and yet we're still seeing some increases so it by definition then it's it's students who were already in the system who then who didn't have an IEP or a 504 and then have one for some reason sometimes it's students qualifying sometimes it's students moving in that that have those eligibilities from other places it's both

136and I'm going to toss something out and this is a a hint of speculation with some of those bar grats where you see it flattening out and then you see that significant increase we were growing in those years where you see those those bar graphs go slightly down one variable that I saw professionally without excellent data Nationwide is um when we implemented RTI which is response to intervention uh the basic premise of that is we will give interventions to students in a general education setting not a special education setting uh to help them stay on uh stay on their grade level uh um standards um so when you hear about tier three tier 2 RTI what we have seen and I think you have a graph for this in just in just a a slide

137or two we have seen a a reduction in specific learning disabilities and I believe it's largely because of the implementation of RTI intervening in general education first and so for for what that's worth that's that's that's a portion of it uh and that was the intent of RTI to intervene in a gened setting and avoid an IEP if it if if the student didn't really need it what year did that start we may have to look that up I can't remember 177 18 around in there somewhere around in there okay prior to that they've says prior to that 11 or 12 so I I I think the implementation of it across the country might have taken a little while right okay and one quick comment is um I know of parents who've moved into the

138district just for special ed so my office gets those calls yeah regularly we've had those conversations with families yes uh it's it's as difficult as it is to to talk about those hard times we we do a good job but I want to emphasize we've got room to grow uh this is a human effort we've got room to grow but but our folks do a really good job serving our students all right so this is a large graph in terms of uh lengthwise and a lot of different disabilities here but it kind of gives you a a layout of of the disabilities again this includes students three to to 22 I think Jay this has may have been what you were kind of looking for so my question there was was was really the difference

139on your previous slide were those were those those 6981 including the gifted students okay so what was the what's the 10,500 is that that was in okay so the difference is five and four all right that's great yes I can tell you the exact numbers so the 6,981 are IEPs of those 2031 are gifted then you look at uh we have like 4,950 if you don't include gifted and then we have 504s all right all right so this is a slide that I think Jason was referencing and uh I I want to bring your attention to the light colored graph is specifically specific learning disabilities so uh you can see there Jason mentions we kind of took a dip as as RTI really got rolling and and being implemented um the dark color graph are

140disabilities that are more severe in nature so um disabilities that typically um require uh additional supports and services for students things like autism emotional disabilities multiple disabilities developmental delay things where students um typically need a lot of supports and services if you can see um on that graph those numbers have climbed pretty rapidly uh in our district uh throughout the SE the last several years and Tanya to your point earlier I I'll hear a parent say my child had blank disability and I heard this is where I needed to be right yeah um this I just thought you might find interesting uh if you do not include students who are gifted or 504s 11.9% of our student total student population is a student with an IEP if you include gifted and 54 25.3% of our

141total student population uh has a disability so Maria when you when you mention the the $92 million is that is that in addition to like all like it's so like the typical children who who aren't on one of these programs have a have a cost associated with so the 92 is is over and above that specific to special ed okay not not 504 so if if I may Rachel pulled that out of our budget and it was um the major categories for special education instruction 71200 and then special education support which is to20 um so that's an approximation the reality is our our our general education teachers serve students with disabilities as well she didn't pull out the numbers in that context right but it would be roughly it would be 25% of the of

142of every of all the other if our we got a 25% population then you would 25% of all the of all the other categories would be allocated to those students but I get your point their their cost is you know $88,500 a student more than than the general population on average based on that yeah well that is sort of a question I was going to ask is do we know roughly what it what it's costing the district per student to serve those say the ones that was on two slides earlier with that are severe disabilities I think it was 1700 some OD that were in the mild of severe category yeah 1747 um do we know roughly what what we're having to spend to serve those students on average Maria if I'm not mistaken you

143do have an approximation without without factoring in some percentage of our general education cost the uh 92 million really is divided amongst our total student count of students with disabilities and that would that would be how you would get the per pupil for students with disabilities as far as what you're asking is are students that require more support I can't think of a way that we could pull that simply because we both might be students that have autism but I have a lot more services than than this student here so it would be very difficult to to parse that out in that in that way yeah disability by disability we don't really have that data um another piece on the revenue side this is a little more than you asked the state does have separate

144funding based on those categories uh that's part of the Tissa model um and so I don't I don't know those numbers off the top of my head but but it varies based on is it nine categories or 10 it's funding based on the services not the the disability per se but how many services the student has in I okay good questions all right so 504s just a growth graph here uh you may your eyes may be drawn to 16 17 so I just want to say that prior to um the 1819 around about in there 17 18 18 19 we did not have a database to uh collect all of the 504s the state had uh we actually went out and purchased a program prior to the state providing it for everyone so I'm I

145wasn't the director in 1617 but I venture to say we did not go from 1288 to 626 back to 1075 so uh again that's that's data that was left for me but I I had venture to say that that's a data reporting error I can feel really confident in everything from the 1920 school year for we should put a big question mark over that year or something all right so this is uh pretty much the last content slide I just wanted to give you an idea of the number of Assessments I think this is this is eye opening that our psychologists we have uh we have around 50 some odd psychologists and last year alone they completed 1,44 initial evaluations 2265 re-evaluations 743 screenings and 1,674 evaluations for 504 so a a lot of evaluations

146uh and re-evaluations our speech language pathologist 729 initial avows and 536 re aows another tidbit I put on here I thought you might find interesting was we do have an assisted technology team who help our students access uh the curriculum and they completed 103 evaluations um last year granted there are lots of other disciplines Vision hearing uh occupational therapy physical therapy I didn't gather all of those for tonight but they all um complete evaluations for students and Maria at at the risk of being oversimplified I want to toss this out uh I suspect that a traditional thought when many people hear psychologists is they immediately visualize clinical psychologist our school psychologists are the testers um they're doing all they're doing the testing they're doing the evaluations and then of course they're participating in the IEP

147meetings the work that they do is not not clinical counseling it is it is the the testing that we've been spending most of our time talking about I know that's a bit of an oversimplification but want to make you it is different from a clinical psychologist although they are trained in some techniques they they do a lot um they are the experts in knowing the eligibility criteria uh and how to assess for that um and so and they they participate in response RTI um they give teacher strategies for students I mean they're they're involved in a lot of different things but they one of their primary roles is eligibility and they are very much that position is very much a hard-to-fill position and I know Vicky is not here tonight I'm trying to remember um

148we actually they they are on the teacher scale with an addition to it if I'm not mistaken we moved them to their own scale a couple years ago because we struggled to fill those positions so so they're they're their their pay is is more than a than a teacher with that experience because there's a higher demand and they do it requ an advanced degree you can't become licensed in the state unless you have your Masters and then your educational specialist degree are we at full capacity with psychologist in every school or gosh I'm to knock on wood yes right now we are we've we've a human resources really helped us by you know looking at the the pay and looking at internship possibilities and things and we've that has really worked and we are fully

149staffed right now and um I am actually looking at Angela Frederick at the moment they are they are um uh uh protected by and governed by our uh mou with uh with the WCA through Pekka Maria with with respect to the initial evaluations and the reevaluations do you have do you have any data on as far as initial valuations how many of those initial valuations are uh result in iips and 54s versus and the reevaluations like what's the renewal rate if you will I can get that for you I don't have it off the top of my head I I I I will say though that there there are times and she'll get you that data where especially as the student hits high school the the course offerings and opportunities may change the the net

150result on that for some of those interventions well I just wanted to say thank you guys so much for letting me spend time with you tonight I hope if you uh gleaned anything uh from tonight that you know that I uh I really am passionate about what I do I love kids I love families it's part of my life uh not just a job to me so I hope that came through and what I shared with you tonight and if I can help any of you in any way please don't hesitate to let me know thank you so much for the preparation and the the great presentation and Mr chair if I may I want to add something before you take a break I've got a question related to this okay ask the question and

151it's more probably for you than for Maria the conversation earlier was about how this the WCS attracts families that have special needs students or or disabilities um we all know that's true are there things that we do as a district over and above what are required of us by law is that more the reason why people come or is it just that we do such a good job at what we're required to do to to answer that question let me tell a story and I'll try to be brief when this law passed when the idea passed our special education director participated in the federal process of setting the regulations and and the rules the moment idea passed we implemented it the way it was intended um and think about well I I don't know where

152your life experience is but there are so many times when a rule comes down a law comes down and it takes years for appropriate implementation um the civil rights laws of 1964 are the most classic example to me it took it probably you know we're still going through some of that um but we initiated it originally um and and so from the beginning predecessors to us set the standard that we're going to do it right and we've been adhering to that there have been errors there you know because it's human uh there's opportunities to grow but it's because the people who came before us for whom we're stewards set that standard um Maria I I I don't know if you have anything to add to that I'm resting my feet I'm sorry I wore the

153wrong shoes um what I will say is that I don't think that I think we are individualized which is what the law requires us to do right we provide the services that each individual student needs um and so I don't think that is above and beyond I think that is um what we're supposed to do and I think we are very fortunate to have Educators that love kids and are here for the right reasons and uh I think that shows to families now with that Mr chair sometimes there are disagreements with parents um I've participated in IEP meetings in different roles here at the district before I became superintendent or sometimes because of the students individual needs um the the the employees of the district the members of the team might say we don't think

154your child needs that service we believe that's more restricted than what's best for them and a parent might say I I want that uh I want that special education teachers assistant in the classroom every minute with my child and so we do occasionally have disagreements on that um but it ought to be a healthy discussion where parents are informed I appreciate that well thanks for the good discussion and and obviously there's more to come on some of these items if I may Mr chair add my last little bit oh sure sorry um thank you guys for your participation and your good questions and and for sharing especially those very personal experiences that you guys have have had we need that um this is not this is a little bit deeper than scratching the surface of

155special ed but I want to give you one example of how much deeper it is we didn't touch on student discipline at all and many of the questions we reive from you are related to student discipline in the i in the special education implementation of that that's a discussion for another for another day but there's a lot more to it even than what we've touched on thank you unless there's a serious objection to this I'm going to let us do the uh science textbook adoption discussion and then take a break is that okay or do we want the break right now okay let's proceed then with science textbooks all right thank you Jen sour one more try is it working now okay good all right fantastic um I appreciate Mr Golden letting you guys kind

156of the reminder that the last time I met with you I said we're in this like hurry up and wait period but once it switches over it's going to be fast and furious we are in that fast and furious phase and we're going to be there for for probably the next month or so so I'm going to give you some updates that have happened really in the last 6 weeks or so and then I'll give you and here's what's going to be our next couple of steps so we start on November 22nd which was the Friday before Thanksgiving break just so you kind of have that like time frame in your mind and this is when the state actually released to all of the districts here are the Publishers that made it through the state

157vetting process access just to make it kind of easier for you to look at I arranged it this way by grade band if you click on that link at the top that'll take you straight to the uh State site so you can see where all those materials were released one thing I want you to realize is that it's it's convenient for us to look at it this way that's not the way the state vetting works so like a publisher submits materials for each individual grade level and then the vetting Comm committee vets them by grade so they say okay let's look at kindergarten yep kindergarten passed let's look at first grade yep first grade passed and so what happens is there's this potential for a oneoff to happen like so it's highlighted up there in

158yellow there's one publisher that submitted for lots of grades the only one that passed was seventh grade due to remember when we were talking a couple of months ago that idea of like one of the really important pieces that we get from an adopted curriculum is a continuity of student thought across not just one course but multiple courses we made the initial decision that there's not really a place for a resource that's only available in one grade level so we did present that to the committee they completely agreed so that one was kind of easy one to cross off the list so we had a committee meeting we met on December 4th it was a uh kind of a quickish meeting about an hour and a half after school where we went over the full

159adoption process we presented that list just like you saw we talked about is there potential to narrow the list down at all if so what procedures does the committee want to use for that and then we also read in the sign the oath that's part of the tdoe process so that full oath is here if you want to look at it um that first little part of it is probably the intent of the oath I declare that I am not now directly or indirectly financially interested in or employed by any textbook publisher or agency and it continues to say that I'm not going to become financially interested at any point in this process so here are the work of the committee at that December meeting the first question that was posed to the committee what

160are the grade bands that that we want to adopt materials in and so the decision of the committee was that we're going to divide the content in this way K to2 will adopt one resource 3 to five will make a selection six to8 will make a selection and then High School courses because they're so individual in nature chemistry biology physics each of those will make their own individual selection I want to talk about that elementary decision for a minute because that's different from what we do in ela and math in elementary school but if you remember a couple of months ago when we talked about science standards specifically in kada2 we talked about how they're compared to even three to five the focus of the standard the scope of the standard the depth and complexity

161of what we ask is really narrow in kat2 compared to even the work of 3 to five the committee felt that there was the potential that one resource might best feat the needs of K to2 and a different resource could potentially best meet the needs of three to five and so those teachers will select in those grade bands are there questions about that okay um I will also remind you that we are adopting two one-off courses so AP Psychology and math reasoning for math reasoning there's only one book that passed State vetting when we adopted math two years ago no book passed for that course since then that one book has passed it is the book that our teachers are already using so we met with that committee they said we don't need to meet

162to review anything bring us back when we vote and we'll cast the vote apsychology is also adopting a book because of those significant changes to the course made by college board they elected to meet on February 14th which is our districtwide day to review the books that we have available for that course and then cast their vote later in the month okay as far as pairing down the list is concerned I'm going to give you a little bit of historical information two years ago we did math adoption a lot of resources passed like 789 in some instances in those grade bands the committee decision then was was that's so many resources it's going to be really daunting for a teacher in a Committee Member to fully evaluate seven eight nine books to make a good

163selection and so the committee said let's narrow that list down a little bit and they decided four felt like a good number that's several different choices but it's also a manageable task for teachers and committee memb members to evaluate and make a selection so we brought that to our science committee and said given their historical experience four felt like a good number but you let's vote and decide what we want to do for science K to five said four Publishers passed let's put all four in front of teachers High School remember they're all individual courses biology had the most that passed which was five everybody else was less than that they said let's just keep those Middle School had the most it was six and the committee said six is starting to feel like a

164lot to fully dig into a resource to really think about what's going to best meet the needs of our students I think we should pair it down to four so here's the process that they used they had digital access to all of those materials when the tdoe released the rubric summaries that came from the vetting of the state level we gave those to the committee and they had a month to review all those materials they submitted their selection by electronic form so here's it's a real simple form question one which I didn't write on there is what's your name question two was here are the six resources that you were evaluating pick your top four so I put for you off to the side here are the results that we got from that selection the

165other two that aren't up there got lower than the ones that are up there and so those are the four that we put in front of teachers questions about that yes okay so remember Fast and Furious we've actually already had another meeting it was yesterday we were right here I don't know if you've uh noticed around the room we actually have our materials here from the Publishers this is our site for public review but it's also where we held our meeting yesterday which is when we had our textbook Publishers in to meet with our committee so we had the full committee teachers and parents here in this room it was a fun circus day so we had uh Publishers coming through every about 4 45 minutes they switched rooms so that every single teacher had

166the chance to hear from all the Publishers that had materials available for adoption they had the chance to ask some questions they had the chance to look at some of those paper materials that are available and then they also had some time to kind of sit and debrief with each other about what they had learned about all those individual resources they're going to take all that information that they learned back to the teachers in their building Jen did every publisher that we're considering show up there was one that came on Zoom okay but everybody else was here in person okay so what happens next for teachers they have those site based reviews remember there's five schools in each grade level around the county they're actually on the next slide if you want to see where

167teachers can go and review print materials teachers have also been emailed digital access to every single one of those materials as provided by the Publishers and teachers are going to have job embedded time on that February 14th districtwide day to review materials and the Publishers are invited back that day to be able to meet with teachers before they make their final selection again if you wanted to see those are the schools where all the materials are available that along with all the dates and times has been sent out to every single teacher so that they'll know where they can go and when they can go to review all of those materials okay what about public reviews because that's a big part of the process as well um I don't know if these slides are in

168the right order or not the right order I kind of deliberated but I wanted to tell you how do we let the public know and then what are we letting the public know if that makes sense so there's lots of opportunities for us to make sure that the public is aware of when and where they can come to review materials so we've shared information with principles for them to send home in newsletters we've published the information and INF Focus it's been sent through local media and the district's social media channels and we've published it on district and school websites those public review dates times again right here in this building in this room we just take the tablecloths off everything and they're available are listed there print materials as well as digital access is provided

169at all those public review sessions also members of our team are available in this room during those public reviews I don't know if any of you have had a chance to look at any of those digital materials that are available it's over overwhelming to try and look through a full curriculum so if anyone's asking about like hey I know we're adopting science textbooks what do you suggest should I go look at it in person or should I just look at it online coming in in person having the physical materials and having us in the room just to kind of answer questions since they have them that's really the advantage of coming to those sites however we do live in a digital world conveniently tdoe has put together a website where publicly available digital access to

170publisher materials is posted online the link is there on the screen here's the it's a little bit confusing if you go straight to the link because tdoe is listing not just the materials that pass State vetting but every single material that was submitted to State vetting so you kind of have to have two things in front of you at the same time if you're going through their website you've got okay so here's all the links I know that that's what was submitted but then I got to pull up somewhere else here's what actually passed and then their links are really just set up by publisher rather than organized and so it's hard to know which ones are for which course unless you actually go and open them so what we did is said let's make

171this a little bit more organized and convenient for members of the public to get to so that little snip there is really just a picture of a little section of the document but we grouped it by grade band so it'll say like here's K to five here are just the Publishers that pass State vetting here is how you access the materials digitally there's a link to the tdoe scoring rubric if you're interested that document is available on our website and it's published in InFocus so if anybody is interested in being able to look at all those materials digitally our hope is that that organization makes it a little easier to get right to what are the materials that we're actually reviewing for our students so Mr chair I want to emphasize this because you actually

172mentioned this to me a couple of weeks ago and said hey the state does have some can we can we do a link and I know CLA you you you've asked us the same question so what we have done is our team has taken all the materials that we've narrowed it down to eliminated the ones the state rejected and had when we have direct links that will include a link from the article that Carol team's putting together so that our families Can Read that read read the InFocus article click on our list click on the one they want and it will take them directly to the materials directly to the online materials that the state has and that's a that's a we we've not done that in previous years years no so it's kind of

173an evolving process you know math was really the first time that the state had made any of that digital access available it was a little bit more limited in the math adoption and so really like you know we learn as we go through things just like all of us learn as we go through and we said hey now that those digital links are available there's probably a way to make it a little bit easier for people to access so that it's a little more convenient and like clear here the materials and here's what aligns with each grade level if somebody goes on the State website to find the list of state approved science text right now they will find it the approved list from the previous adoption and a bunch of those links are dead

174uh so if you guys hear anything uh about this refer them to what Carol's publishing yeah Carol what when are we publishing that we already did it once yeah Carol's team did a great job okay no matter how a public member chooses to review materials they have access to the form to submit comments that'll go back to our textbook committee so if you come here in person we'll have paper copies of the comment form that QR code in the corner goes to the digital form we also have like bigger QR codes that they can just scan and get to that and then if you go to the digital access through the website there's a link to the electronic form the electronic form is exactly those same questions it's just an electronic form as someone prefers

175it that way we collect all of those public comments and that they get shared with our textbook committee prior to any voting that they do okay so then what happens next remember we left off with teachers they meet together to review materials on February 14th which is District y PD day on February 15th we'll send them in electronic form they have until the 21st so it's about a week to make their final selection they're submitting the recommendation to their textbook Committee Member the teacher recommendation data is captured it's aggregated so it's grouped by school the textbook adoption Committee Member gets the teacher recommendation data from the school that they represent if they're a parent on the committee they get districtwide data as opposed to school-based data and then the textbook committee meets on February 25th

176to make their final vote and recommendation which then goes to you all sure do you want me to go back here so when the teacher teachers send their votes yes is that done anonymously or is it so it we collect the name of the teacher but when it's provided to the textbook Committee Member it just shows like it it's almost like a PPH of how many teachers that each School select each recommendation so we do have the information of which teachers at cast which vote but that actual name doesn't get passed on to the Committee Member does that make sense okay he and this just kind of to finish up the rest of the process because then once the vote happens that's to make sure we can hit all the rest of these deadlines so

177Our intention is to come back to you at the March meeting to be able to say here is the final vote of the textbook committee once that approval happens we're able to start passing that information on to the state get that order into the Publishers as soon as we can to make sure that our teach ERS have materials ready for when students come back in August because that's when instruction with those materials start we'll set up dates over the summer to provide training to teachers so that they're ready to use those materials so this will be on your March agenda in two months for vote yeah okay any other questions all right thanks so much thank you very much I know I've gotten a few questions about this but I think I can confidently say

178I hope all of us can this process has been really transparent and and and thoughtful so thank you okay we will take a 10-minute break let's come back at call it 8:40 8:38 8:40 uh and we'll finish out thank you e e e let's resume our meeting please okay we uh we will move into our budget update um with I'm sorry skip I skipped one thing operations report first then budget update uh Mr King uh the operations report will be part of the budget so unless anybody has any questions about any projects um I'm going to use my time for the budget tonight M farmer uh I'll I'll flag that for the for the voting meeting on Monday night there are no budget items so just for the record that's fairly unusual but just so

179you guys know that's not an oversight there are no budget votes budget item votes for Monday or sorry Tuesday's meeting um okay go ahead M farmer and Mr chair if I may real briefly just as a reminder we're going to bring to you our budget recommendations next month but um Rachel and Brian are give going to give you a little bit of a precursor because we're still in that process of preparing it Rachel thank you um if y'all want to go ahead and get the PowerPoint uh pulled up for the 2526 budget update um what will happen is you all are going to receive the copy of the budget next month before the work session and so we've talked about the pieces the PCR the standard um Staffing standards enrollment we talked about Revenue last

180time I'm going to take up a lot of time next month talking to you about the expenses so tonight is just a little don't get in any of the Weeds on the numbers it's just to give you information so when you get that packet you're going to understand what you're looking at and then um the bulk of the time will be with Mr King so if we'll go ahead and go to the next slide for the 2425 budget our current year budget this is just a reminder 86% of that budget of the 5448 million is in Personnel these were the big buckets of personnel which is salaries and wages insurance which that's medical insurance dental and life retirement and then um taxes is FICA specifically so 86% of the budget which went up we've traditionally

181been right held right at 85% and so 86% was a little bit up last year due largely to the uh 6% rise operations was 14% of that and these are some of the bigger just specific Lines within operations we have 22,000 accounts um and so these are just when you consider of the operations budget 76 million half of those are just in these sections we do pretty well with the operation money um that we are given go ahead so you will receive for GP for cafeteria and for student age child care um there will be sections for each and the first page behind each section is a summary sheet and that summary sheet has on it prior year uh actual that's that First Column of numbers expenditures then our current year budget the current year

182revised budget so it'll be 24 25s and then where it says board that will be what we are asking the board to review is the potential for the 2526 budget the difference between the current year original budget and then that uh revised budget are all of those amendments and resolutions I bring to you each month uh as we go through the year and that's how it gets revised and so on the left side under expenses you're going to see numbers 7100 711 71 150 all of those are major categories and these are a summation of each one of those major categories so part of the budget process starts back from principles up is department heads meet with their people we look to determine what the needs are what we did last year did it work

183did it not work um and then what the requests are any additional cost they bring all of those each department head will bring those to an assistant superintendent assistant superintendent meets with them and they go through and say look at this did we need this they have those conversations and there could be Cuts made at that point in time for instance Mr King as an operations assistant superintendent he meets with maintenance he meets with Transportation he meets with Food Services he meets with all those different groups so cuts are made there then we take that information whatever uh requests are left and then they come forward to be presented at a separate meeting with HR Director with myself um with Mr Golden the assistant superintendent and then we have those same conversations of uh looking

184at prior years looking at the big plan of where we're headed is this appropriate can we go back and look is there anything we cut um and Mr Golden will make suggestions on cuts at that point so that is currently where we are we're still in that process once we get to that um down to the numbers that we feel good about that's what we present to you in February you will have that opportunity to review the document you'll have it for a month ask all the questions you want to ask um suggest what you want to suggest in March then we present for you um what we believe would be our best recommendation for you to vote on we have to have that document to the County Commission by April 1st so that is

185the timeline that the requirement that's why you're getting February and March so just so you know if you're looking at those major categories a lot of them are self-explanatory um and so special education for instance was where do we see I had that question tonight where can we see those expenses and so if you're looking specifically for special education instruction like that's 71200 support for special education um is 72 to20 so you can go to those different categories so go ahead and go to the next slide please this will be the beginning of the next Pages um behind that summary sheet so if you'll see at the top left you've got 71 100 which is regular instruction and then you have all the accounts underneath regular instruction again same information that account this Pages for

18671100 the totals are those sums on that very first page so what I try to do for you is we do um a percentage change so you can see from prior year if there's an increase or decrease if there's a large one I go ahead and try to give you a note out beside it to explain what it is so you're not just wondering um sometimes things to you may see a 100% increase but if the account only had $500 in it and it went to $1,000 that's really not a big deal don't don't worry so much when you're going wow 100% increase or a decrease the same amount but if it's something that I can look at and know this would cause a question for me I'm going to go ahead and give you

187a note so that you don't have to kind of wait and guess of of what that may be um if you're looking at the accounts just I wrote up across the top a little hint for you if it starts with 51 that's going to be be related to wages so any the 5116 teachers starts with a 51 that's going to be related to wages 52 is anything with Benefits which is pensions taxes um and insurance and then 53 are all other operational expenses and that's all I'm going to share with you guys tonight just so when you get the document you kind of have an idea of how to navigate it if you have questions at any time email me and call me tell me you need to talk and we'll go through it and

188now I'm going to turn it over Mr keing and if if if I may Mr chair a couple couple of comments related to what Rachel's presented just as a reminder I don't know nine or 10 days ago I sent you all an email with some information related to what county government's doing um they uh the mayor is aiming for uh a 4% pay increase and he has told the budget committee that he wants them to find a way to be able to fund that for us as well we don't project that we're going to get any Revenue based on the information enough revenue for that based on the information we have right now I've also made it clear to them that I don't anticipate we will be asking for a 4% raise across the board

189whatever funding we have we're going to apply what we are working on right now to prioritize pay increases based on that annual goal you all set for me in November uh then and you of course that's pretty recent you may remember that um our team is looking at our supplements our team is looking at some of our lower paid positions our team is looking at market right now uh uh and and we're also looking at 10-month versus 12month staff members as as we're evaluating that we will bring that proposal to you in February even without us knowing yet if we have the funding for it uh because of the because of the timeline in process um the other thing I was going to mention um was uh uh we really have uh four budgets that

190you all review uh Rachel has given you information related to the general budget uh we have food service budget which is a standalone budget and it is based on federal funding and actual Revenue it is not a tax it is not a local tax uh consumer uh the third the third one is our school age Child Care Program that is that is also not a tax consumer it is based on fees and then the final one is annual Capital request that that we make and Brian is going to give you a little bit of an insight into that fourth budget uh in his presentation right now in addition to some information on our fiveyear cap Plan before we go there Rachel not to put you on the spot but do do we have any sense

191of what the additional Tissa funding for the coming year might be any projection on that no I got a bulletin yesterday that we do not have a number yet um and so I just know based off of fiscal capacity the anticipation is we will get our first let me back up we will get that first idea in February February last week of February which will be after we've actually present the budget to you the second piece is we will get the property tax reappraisal information in March um and so at this point in time the department of education does not have any information they can give us to estimate other than they anticipate um that it obviously is not going to go down that base is not going to go down but they do not

192have an increase yet of course but we if everything's on time we should have it in time to vote on the bud we'll have an idea them all right thank you Mr chair I I do have one worry related to that the fiscal capacity indicator that we spent time talking about last year and some of you who are new to it have gotten a little bit of insight into that every year uh there's a complex formula that that projects out for lack of a better phrase the County's capacity to pay uh and Williamson's fiscal capacity compare continues to separate from most of the rest of the state if they continue to do that that unless there's some more Revenue somewhere we're looking at a reduction uh from from the state and Rachel I may have

193said too much because you know it's speculative at this point it is speculative but we do know that um we have not been given an increase in the base yet to have any idea last year that increase in base got eaten up by fiscal capacity um because the fiscal capacity once it went up we didn't really get that much of a bump and so that is the anticipation again for this year considering that our numbers are also stay in G FL but Jason the the reappraisal won't take effect in terms of physical capacity until until the following year is that right because they won't have that they won't have that done for this well right now you're right except that the fiscal capacity they're applying to us was not last year as it was the

194year before am I correct on that Rachel it's a mix and so we actually though they don't calculate the fiscal capacity until May um so they it will depend on how much information they can get in um but it is a mix between cber and tacus which one they use we don't give out draft information no I'm just kidding so no we don't I mean I ask I ask per for good reason right right and that would you know it would be helpful if we could do actually do it a full Year's in advance so that that we would have a better idea to estimate of it at this moment they're not got thanks I want that two days before yes too soon got qu question um is this um in February we is that

195when we'll have like the update just because we get we're still getting tons of emails about this uh the AR teacher supplement stuff we'll kind of get an update on we we we plan to give you our proposed pay increase plan in February with a caveat that we don't know that we have the revenue yet all right Mr King I think we're ready for you thank you Mr chair uh tonight my goal is to kind of go over the three big buckets of operation uh you will see two of them uh in February you will see the annual capital and that will be the first time you've seen that and of course we'll have our general purpose we'll be part of that and I also want to talk about the five-year Capital plan that we've

196already voted on just the plan and kind of go over uh the difference between the three budgets how we kind of come up with the numbers um and and the projects that we decide on working on so first thing we'll start with is the five-year Capital plan uh y'all have already voted on the plan you haven't voted on any money yet and um the County Commission actually voted on it this past Monday as well they approved the plan they haven't approved any money any intent to fund uh that will come I believe will'll bring it probably back to the school board in March maybe March or April I'm guessing we'll do that in April so that it can go before the Commission in May yeah so we will have to come back to you for

197a vote on the fiveyear capital for the intent to fund um and so I just kind of want to go through that because I know there were lots of questions about the fiveyear uh Capital plan when we presented it to you and and by the way at the County Commission meeting there was discussion where they were reminding themselves of the why of the fiveyear capital plan and and they mentioned that the adequate facilities tax corre requires them to do those fiveyear Capital plans correct and here's just some general notes and you'll get this PowerPoint I'm not going to read through every line but you'll get this kind of some just some uh facts about The Five-Year Plan um but I am going to go through the five cat major categories of the fiveyear capital plan

198that you voted on uh the the first uh big category is the uh new school construction land purchases um and you can see what we have and this is the fiveyear capital plan by the way that y'all have voted on uh a couple of months ago uh before we do any new construction uh and put that on the books these are kind of the steps that we go through um operationally before we even consider building a new school first thing we do is we maximize capacity and sometimes that that's not ideal but we'll do that before we uh think about uh building a new school we'll put uh art and music maybe on carts we'll convert some common areas in classrooms that's kind of our first step uh when when schools are getting close to

199capacity um we do open Zone which you'll see later on tonight that schools that do have capacity will open Zone to help alleviate some of that then we'll add Portables which we've done at Nolensville you know we have three um Portables at Nolensville Elementary uh and then we'll rezone if if we can um and then we can do uh additions if it's cost effective uh before we actually build a new school that's kind of some of the things we look at before we actually get to uh building a new school projections you you'll get that tonight uh for open Zone uh and Allison will be dealing with a lot of this tonight but how do we get those numbers we roll up grade level level we look at historical growth and uh Allison has all

200the construction numbers in different areas permits issued all that and I'm going to show you an example slide of that um of stuff that she keeps up with I did just throw this in here this is just our uh growth since 2010 as you can see we were pretty steady on uh rise until 2021 and then you can see where we've leveled off in the past three or four years this is just an example of a of sheets that Allison Nunley uh keeps and you can see the detail permits issued uh the type of uh homes being built and she has this for all municipalities this is just one example uh that I got for her for the noville area what what are those S I recognized single family th is town okay okay okay

201yes right and then MF multi family multif family yes ma'am and then she also has this she has it by Zone you can see where she actually has it mapped out where um homes are being built and some of you who have sat in on rezoning meetings you've seen you've seen some of these with a projected number of homes uh in in in those different locations any questions before we move forward this is just a timeline a general timeline of what it takes to build build a new school uh depend you know there's factors uh but this is just typical um and by the way um lyd is going to post this on the on the website so you guys will be able to access this whole thing so typically two to three years depending

202on elementary middle or high but that's typically our time range uh I put this in here about additions we have done several additions uh through the years at high schools and even elementaries we've added wings uh and I put a little example in here this is rounded numbers but just as an example we've added on at Summit Independence and Ravenwood uh roughly 500 extra seats at a cost of 23 million versus uh NOS will hide 50 million uh for 17 so you can see if it's possible if we have the land it is a cost effective way to keep from building uh new schools here's just uh some information that Eric Gardner got to me well I don't know why it jump there um just cost of uh new buildings uh how it's gone up

203over the past uh 10 or 15 years you can see the uh cost per square foot how much it's grown since we built a Long View Elementary Brion will you go back to the previous slide please sure the 23 million number that's the aggregate for the three or is that 23 per no sir that was that was what it cost if you added all the uh cost for those yes that's what I thought want to be sure yes so Brian on the on the next slide yes sir these are would you say that they're substantially the same building all all of these um as far as the the Creekside Jordan Clover they look they look pretty much the same from the outside but I mean modifying just for the s yes sir this is all

204the same architectural design now there's there's little changes in between um Eric has made it a point every time we build a new one they do they do some slight improvements there's also slight changes in the code fire code from time to time right but largely they're the same buildings and I'm not going to go through every one of these the the next big section uh that you'll see I don't know why this keeps jumping uh um is U Renovations and we have two Renovations scheduled for this year uh Hillsboro elementary middle and grassland and these are just some of the things that that we'll do for a renovation and I know some of you have asked that question before um may not do all of these May there may be some other things that

205we do a little different but these are typically things we look at when we do Renovations Hillsboro was built in 1981 and grass and middle was 86 I believe so that's the age of the schools that we're renovating for this year any questions maintenance major projects now this is where we got to get um want to do some explaining because a lot of these roofs HVAC those kind of things you're also going to see an annual capital and that conf that can be confusing it's confused some of our County Commissioners think that we're asking for stuff in two different places so I want to try to explain the difference in the fiveyear capital the major uh projects these are major projects so if we talk about a roof it's a complete roof replacement something in

206the average of 20 to 30 years before they get that it's based on inspections and the age uh Adam Christopher and maintenance they do annual inspections to all facilities every year so that's how this gets put in the fiveyear capital same thing with asphalt with the tennis repaving the tracks that's how these are evaluated and put in the 5 your Capital along with the HVAC units these are not just individual units at a school this would be an complete refresh duck work all of that would be in a five-year Capital you'll see next year we're going to ask for uh outdoor LED lights that has been a big request of schools for years and we keep we've kicked the can but we're going to ask for that next year and that's going to be for

207all high schools to replace their outdoor lighting and then of course we'll have tur fields that we already have that we'll have to replace uh there's their average uh lifespan and we'll have to start replacing those and that'll be on the fiveyear capital as well although there's none in there for this year any questions uh the next big bucket in the fiveyear capital is uh cyber security and security physical and cyber security we're in phase two of uh rep uh replacing all uh key entry with fobs that would be indoor and outdoor uh and replacing the uh paging system with digital paging and an alert system and we'll keep that in there we don't know in the next five years what future safety uh initiatives could come around uh in the next five years so

208Fletch and his team are always evaluating there's so much stuff out there and they do a really good job of kind of weeding through what would be beneficial what would help us and so um just as a fii Fletch and his team are evaluating the Panic buttons there are tons of products out there right um and there's there's arguments on both sides of that uh you know one key point would be they need to be usable even though somebody might use them only once ever right and so so he's he's going through that process we don't have anything ready for you yet but that may be something we bring to you if fledge and his team conclude that that's our next best step maybe in another year or so uh as their and that could

209be on the fiveyear capital if we find something like that that could be depending on you know infrastructure and what that would take exactly so those are the five big buckets of the fiveyear capital that you voted on and again sometime in March or April you will be asked to vote on the intent to fund and the intent of fund is just the First Column the rest of it is just a plan the only thing we'll be asking for funding for is the first column in the 5year plan and Brian and his team will be evaluating double-checking the need first right and also evaluating to the extent they can some some make sure the estimates are drilled down as tight as we can yes sir all right we're moving on to the annual capital and

210this you will see in uh February along with the uh Rachel's budget for the general purpose budget there's kind of three big buckets of our annual Capital uh you'll have some it stuff in there most of the stuff and it and the annual Capital will be instructional stuff such as U the interactive boards that you see in this room we're in a process of of getting all the projectors taken out and replaced with interactive boards this would include printers um I'm trying to think uh battery backups those kind of things things that aren't really security more instructional you'll also see maintenance projects in here which will again be like HVAC and some of those things and we'll go over those um as we get to them um so here's your maintenance annual capital and and

211you'll see the difference between this and the fiveyear capital unforeseen projects partial HVAC stuff that does have age on it but it may not be ready for a complete refresh but because of the inspections the the degreg Adam will will put that in there for an annual capital for a partial replacement same thing with maybe there may be parts of a roof that need to be replaced some Plumbing work this is where the Fairview project uh Mr bosic this was in the annual Capital to help out with some of the plumbing issues last year that he replaced the toilets and has done some work there and also had some engineering work that was in the annual Capital this is also where schools make their request they turn in a form to uh Adam Christopher of

212any kind of request for their schools uh and it could be sidewalks it uh could be upgrades to different things it could be the restrooms at Franklin High School the uh showers things like that go into requests to uh Adam Christopher he then reviews those with the assistant superintendents of uh high school and second uh Elementary then reviews it with uh Mr Golden and myself and we kind of narrow it down and I want you to see how we kind of get to that number and what that number starts out with uh starts out like go ahead just ma'am so we've got a lot of schools that are V there's a big variance in the ages of the schools like we we toured Fairview Elementary which is our oldest school um and I know each

213principal is I think it's in October that they're given like they can make a wish list and are we giving schools that are older um maybe a little bit more wiggle room in budgeting for their needs uh as opposed to brand new schools um do do they get a bigger I'm just trying to make it the disparity kind of level back out but are we given those schools that are older that might have more needs are we giving them a little more leeway in the budgeting and well it's based on needs so typically your older schools would have more needs just you know you would hope that Creekside we're not going to do an hva replacement you you know what I'm saying so just by default the older schools should get that so it's based

214on needs and I'm going to kind of go through how we get there um as we move forward but yeah keep that in mind uh so the schools do send it and it's evaluated with excuse me sorry that was the information uh kind of some of the things that technology will request in annual capital and here's the thing it's not security it's you know but these are important I mean this is instructional stuff this is not stuff that you know some bells and whistles I mean these are basic things printers and interactive P that schools need to to teach um and so sometimes it's easy to say cut that stuff out but but it's tough I mean this this is the kind of stuff that we need uh if we want to keep our instruction

215up so here's some historical data on what we've gotten in annual Capital if you go back to 2019 9 million 10 millon you can kind of see where we're at last year we were asked to keep it flat from the year before so you can see we stayed at 13 million so think about this we got 13 million last year what we have been requested by schools this year just requested by schools that was on the list that's a legitimate request not necessarily a safety issue but legitimate request is $30 million that doesn't count it and it doesn't count the uh necessarily the stuff that Adam's asking for we're at 30 million right now and you can see what we historically get we don't even get half of that for annual Capital that's just maintenance

216so if you take it of that 13 million five six seven million of it is it so that means you're left with seven eight million for maintenance annual Capital it doesn't leave a lot of extra for Stuff other than just Necessities which is hvac's and and stuff it there's just no there's just not a lot of extra to do some of the stuff that we would like to do yes sir are um are you saying that in the 23 24 they requested that 13 million and and that was what was approved and this year well so a lot and I'll be honest a lot of this is we're told beforehand what we can ask for so last year for example we were told don't ask for more than you got last year we're keeping everybody's

217Capital request flat we don't have we don't have the revenue so we knew that we could only ask for 13 million a lot of times we're kind of giving a heads up on what we can expect to get in capital in several years Through The Years we'll ask for 13 14 million and they'll say we'll give you 11 and they'll just cut a million or two U Brian can you give us an example or two of of a of of a request that that was made you know a couple a few years ago that we weren't able to fund that then resulted in increased operating expenses and then ultimately you know a a we replaced the item or we actually did the item later at a at an increased cost I just love to it's

218more than just opportunity cost and maybe it it it costs more in the beginning but some of these things are are going to cost us actually operating dollars too sure uh Adam do you can you think of anything off hand that's a great one the one that jumped to my mind was Centennial High School some uh security fencing on the top slope there next to The Drury in uh that had been requested I think the first uh budgetary estimate we got from our contractor was $112,000 to run fence security fencing across the top of that slope uh we had people coming down vandalizing the school damaging the brand new track damaging the uh the athletic turf field they'd bring their dogs down the dogs would dig and leave messes behind on the practice field that

219the kids would then end up in and and ruining their jerseys uh in the messes the dogs Left Behind Etc this it took us I think about three years to finally vet that up and be able to get the funding set aside to do that when we finally did the project it was about $199,000 uh so considerably more than the initial estimate uh and and then even since then we've done some repairs on it but I just say uh that was a security issue on that campus I was glad we were able to finally get it done uh we probably have a hundred stories like that I can't think of them all off the top of my head the uh the gas thing that um uh Mr Welch mentioned uh certainly uh there are there

220are probably a hundred of them like that that uh that we try to go for every year and to the question requested and approved um from last year the total requested before it was cut and vetted and prioritized and limited and and taken down to the Bare Bones that they said we were G to they were going to let us go for was more than it was more than $30 million uh but a lot of those we just had to really we were churning and you know going through on well is this one you know which one's G to you know are we going to prioritize out and kind of work through that what can we live without uh we go through that a lot uh and and that's how we end up with kind

221of finally what we end up uh uh getting and we do our best with the funding that we get frequently we can if we can get a good deal on a on a project we we award it we save a little bit well that lets us you know use those funds to you know get a get a couple of extra little things uh that maybe might enhance the schools as well so we really work to try to maximize the value we get from the funding that we get I hope that answers the question I have a quick question um so it looks like we kind of consistent there was a little blip in 22 to 23 when we requested 16 and got 13 million then in 23 24 we request requested and approved for 13

222million and then this year it's jumped to requests to 30 million no ma'am we're not going to request 30 minut no but I I guess what I'm saying is why did why was there a big increase I I understand we're not but suddenly we needed a lot more there was a big increase in requests there's there's actually not a big increase Brian's 30 million is at an earlier stage in the budget process okay back usually our team yes usually usually our teams will ask for substantially more than we actually take to you so typically we trim it down million that is correct and we'll say yeah that that $30 million that's typical of every year somewhere that that was my question and so we'll ask questions like tell tell us about your maintenance schedule can

223we go a little bit longer can you patch this right we'll go through we'll go through that process so the 30 million is not apples to the to the to to the others right I can tell you 27 it was 279 for maintenance last year I think was the number um before we ever came with the 8 million that was theirs that they requested so we had cut 20 almost 20 million last year right so the requested there means what was requested of the County Commission not what the team requested of us of the board and the County Commission so even last year you guys approved that 16 or in 22 23 you approved the 16.2 when it came to the commission they approved only 13 that's correct so yeah so let me yeah and

224I so that I understand your confusion that that last bullet that is the request made this year to ad them from the schools and that's typical every year year that's what that 30 million is that's not what you're going to see in February that includes proverbial wish list items that you you know you hear that phrase by the time it gets to you it's needs correct I'm GNA um jump in just quickly and should have said this to start with so when we're talking about general purpose that is the sales tax that's the Tisa funds that's taxes annual capital and 5year capital the commission approves that funding they decide how they fund it and it's either going to be through bonds if it's new construction it can be education impact fees or um they can

225use fund balance or it's they make that determination we manage the general purpose budget based off of the revenue that we that we receive but then they determine how that gets funded and they're funding um parks and wrecks and they're funding highways and they're funding us plus all of their needs so when um we make those requests we listen to them that hey we're not going to have the funds and that's why we try to keep it we would love to be able to go request everything that we feel like we actually need um but that's it we are realistic in that it's not going to be funded any more questions okay all right we're good GP I'll hit this really quick I've never gotten that from Mr Golden before that's interesting I got I

226like that appreciate that so we'll go quick through GP this is just some of the highlights you'll get the PowerPoint uh on kind of what's in operational GP won't read through all of these you can look at it on the PowerPoint uh so we'll do some uh maintenance work and from our operational uh budget but it's pretty limited as well and that's well I think that's I think we good yeah I think we're good any more any questions so as a reminder uh we will come to you with our annual Capital request it's a separate budget that that's that's that 13 or so that will that we take to the County Commission and I just got to be blunt that's the one they like to tell us no on that's right that's a good point

227I got I have to repeat that Mr Cash because your mic microphone wasn't on just just so there's a record of that pay me now or pay me later hey Jason y years ago um we had a presentation and it was sort of what the corporate recommendation was for do you know what I'm talking about you're talking and it was you know the associ of build contractors or something I forget what it was but it was a sort of a national recognized Association of what the the industry standard for facility maintenance was the percentages and then we compared it to what we were at I mean that was staggered that that might be worth revisiting thank you for that yeah I remember Mark Mark Samuels and Brian on his head too he remembers that we

228we'll we'll find that because you're right the the the um Capital maintenance recommendations for facilities managers is not anywhere near what we're getting no it's really anything else on those items two things on a board chair report one um just be reminded the statement of Interest through the ethics commission is due by January 31st so if you haven't gone on the site and filled that out you have to do that annually um that's a state requirement not a local requirement so Lydia can give you that information if you need it again I know she has sent it out before the second thing is um as a reminder tsba A's legislative and legal Institute is February 10 and 11 U being held in Cool Springs um that's where they do U the discussion of policy legislation

229they have speakers come in from the legislature um and it's a two- day one afternoon one morning but you can get if you do both days you can get all of your annual training hours in right right there so if you want to register for that um let Lydia know and Mr chair it's close it's here I mean it's here in our County so yeah I mean it's I did it last I think the last two years and it's very I mean if your schedule permits it's very easy just it's like 1 1 to 5 and then again the next morning 8 to 10 or 8 to 11 and then you're done well it's annual it's new information each year so they count it no matter what they count it two half days basically yeah

230say what yeah but you can get partial hours if you just do one half one half or the other right okay may maybe not okay so inquire with Lydia if you want to register or get more info all right we'll move on to new business we have only one item um but it's an important one and that's the uh open and closed school zones for the coming school year Mr golden thank you Mr chair and thank you board members I gave you a little bit information about this um maybe a week and a half ahead of time because this is this is one of our important annual items every year we make recommendations for open Zone schools and we've included some data for you uh Brian mentioned it in his his presentation that's one of

231the ways that we manage uh we manage our growth we actually have had this process in place long before the state law has been in place and the state law actually borrows some of the language from our policy they've made a couple of changes to it when they when they when they passed this law I don't know four or five years ago um the short version of it is that we have the discretion to determine how many seats how many available seats at each School are appropriate for us to allow students to come uh via open Zone uh and and we make that determination you make that vote we make that determination based on of course the the number of seats available at this moment we also project out the window of time that a

232student might be there because our board policy allows those students to stay uh through through the end of their career at those particular schools um the state law actually doesn't require that but we do because we think it's reasonable to once somebody commits allow allow them to stay you have that document before you uh with the open zoning it is not the only means by which students can attend to school out of Zone there's a handful of other things in board policy if somebody moves into an area and they move out they may be able to stay uh especially at the high school level some of the College and Career Technical education programs will allow a student to attend um if it's not offered at their school so there's some other examples of it but

233this is the bulk of our of our out of Zone uh schools um I want to give you a little bit of a factual correction I think in my email I told you around 2,000 students uh are attending a school out of Zone in Williamson County it's actually a little bit over 2500 this year so was a little low uh so we have had a number of students uh exercise that choice um you can see some of the some of the details certainly o open any questions that you guys may have related to that did want to mention one one specific Zone brittwood middle and brittwood high school we are recommending open zoning that for the first time in over a decade uh and it's because of us finishing the the building construction uh at

234Brentwood middle we still have some work to do on the field uh in the common area that will will be going on in the fall but all the work that Eric and Brian have done show that the traffic flow is going to be back to normal we did something similar with paig High School uh some of you may recall last year where the where the construction wasn't quite finished but it was good enough to to where there could be a decent flow and we opened Zone page last year uh so we do recommend the same thing for for this year that's really the key Point final thing I want to mention I think if I'm not mistaken we have 42 of our 50 campus schools that were recommending having some open zoning so that families

235can have Choice all right let's open it up for discussion can you speak to I've had a couple families reach out um thinking that this is related to the proposed voucher plan can you speak to that that and how that this is not related it number one it is not related uh it it by many many years precedes that it's a product of our planning to to to the extent we can give families Choice within Williamson County Schools this is not open Zone to out of County uh this is open Zone to our families who live in our County uh the um there are a very small number of students who live out of our County who who do attend it's quite limited we have a handful of families who are in the process of

236moving in who have a non-contingent contract to move in who can move in a little bit ahead of that contract closing uh we do allow full-time employees to pay a tuition rate for their children to go beyond that it's it's not it is not in any way related to Choice outside the county I'm gonna bring this up again because it it bothers me every year is when we do this and to your point say you know if you get permission to go open zoned you're you're guaranteed we we essentially create super zones for these students that are out of it and then later we we do have to fill and move things around and we have to move entire neighborhoods that are out of it while you know kids are coming in are not impacted

237thank you for that well and then we also have the implication of the grandfathering policy which creates generational so this is you know and so then when we get to the zoning and we all prpe about how hard this is and we don't want to move kids and everything else but we this is just one more example where I think we create the problem in the future so thank you for that let me put a little bit of detail in it to make sure you all grasp what Mr Welch is talking about because of our existing board policy uh once a a a student Moves In out of Zone you could reasonably argue that they have a more a greater likelihood of staying in that school than somebody who lives there because if it becomes

238overcrowded and we have to rezone somebody might get moved out of that zone when somebody who's attending out of Zone gets to stay and that's the point you're making and you're right that that's that's a part of it and I'm say it's not even You could argue greater likelihood it is a greater because you got a zero% chance of being moved that's right yeah that that's you're right about that well I guess to to that point though we do we we build in we build in some growth and I mean we're not we're not open zoning 100% of most of these um vacancies and so um and and on that on the chart in our in our packet there are um you know we've got we got people that are being zoned in and out

239of almost every every school so um I mean the net effect is much less than the 2500 students um over you know over all of our schools it's it's really it's really a much smaller number year no this is I mean this is just this is not per year I mean this is this is each year whatever I mean so but it's just the the actual number for this year but I mean the net number of you'd have to look at each school and its net out of zone so both out and in and how I mean by grade level I mean it's really it's really kind of negligible and it and it serves such a great purpose um for for parents to be able to to make make the decision to to seek to

240to I mean so many different reasons for curriculum for um you know all kinds of social reasons parenting situations like I mean there's all kinds of reasons why people use these but U my question was um was around uh the the process Jason of um if you know some of these have a relatively small numbers um and in some cases the the open spots that were filled last year is greater than the number of spots that like I was looking at Franklin High School that greater than the number of spots that are available um so um if we can explain um and and maybe it's maybe this is a a to to explain on Monday night May better better than than tonight about the process for you know hey after we approve these things what

241what are we what are we kicking off the process um in terms of the lottery system now in ter instead of the old system I that's been in the place for the last two years well thank thank you for that and yeah that so the state included a lottery system where if you if if instead of being first come first served there's a window of time where families can submit the form and request it that that window closes if I'm not mistaken on April 15th uh it can it cannot open until two weeks after you vote for open zone for whatever reason that's just the state rule uh and if if more families or or students choose uh open Zone then we have available seats we're required to do a lottery we actually did a

242lottery last year for Franklin High School based on I think there being us being two over or maybe three over our total somewhere around there there and uh enough enough families said no never mind I don't want it that we ended up not actually having to implement the the lottery work we did but that could happen um so that that's that process to answer your other question related to numbers uh Allison does her projections we look at trends for that particular school we look at offerings um through which students can get access other than open zoning Franklin is particular and peculiar in that we have our International backal art program there uh and and so students can get in there outside the open zoning so Franklin is different from the others we've also had a

243history of uh the numbers of students choosing Franklin to be very close to to our limit so so that's why it's less than it was last year um because we have had that growth um and I tell you we've had a lot of discussions about the Brentwood schools because it's been so long since they've been open Zone we're very curious to see what's going to happen um and and and to our discussion earlier we know about Nolanville Elementary School and it being um overc capacity uh Dr Johnson I'm gonna I'm G to mention a conversation you and I had uh about encouraging folks to consider uh uh the the neighboring schools there for example we uh we we we are recommending open zoning both Sunset Elementary and Jordan uh and so that that might be

244an opportunity for families there at the moment um I Tim if you could pull up the second document that's attached there uh I'd like you guys to see what I think of of of as the old 1970s road map if you remember the distance from City to City Dan you may remember you and I may be the only ones I don't know who can remember the the old road map where it shows the distance from one place to the other uh the the uh the top of this chart shows uh shows the number of students um the schools the students are Zone to attend and in the left shows the students they are attending you can see that ratio that Jay was talking about of how many how many are should be are are zoned

245to that school but are attending a different school and vice versa um at the moment Nolanville happens to be 40 to 20 uh 40 students who are zoned to Nolanville or attending elsewhere that's mitigated the overcrowding a little bit U because there's 20 out of Zone who are attending there Allison is there any detail you can add to the question Mr galbert asked about Franklin High I will just kind of give an overall explain the process it is an online application when the applications come in the parents receive an automated email that says we've received your application after my staff processes the application they'll get one that's an email that says or a text that says your application is now in the lottery queue and we'll run the lottery the week of April after April

24616th or on April 16th because we have to come in on April 16th and process the applications that came in on the 15th right so then everything sits in the queue and then we go through and um Mr King can attest to this we hit a button and it runs a random lottery so it's really pretty cool and then we go through we check we make sure everything looks okay and then it will send notific to the parents and they'll go in and accept or decline their seat so that's how if some parents have decided Well maybe they got into Centennial and Franklin High so they pick make their choice and they decline their seat and then someone else can get in off the weit list to that point we do have families submit out

247of Zone requests for multiple schools yes yes can you speak to the the philosophy behind whether the The Cho this is what the question is really in regards to the number of spaces that are being reserved for open open enrollment um well no sorry the number of spaces that are being reserved for growth resered enrollment growth spaces that column so just for example Allendale at the top of the list because it's it's at the top you're holding 200 proposing to hold 200 and in open Zone 152 but the demand last year was only 16 yeah so is the is the number more a function of the demand or is it more a function of keeping a certain percentage of the seats in the school held held for future growth it's more it it is not

248very much at all a function of demand um if if we're on the edge and we see some demand we might say maybe we can stretch it and push it a little bit but it's it's largely driven by in the examples of the elementary schools we have a six-year window to project how much how much space we'll have we factor in what we know about construction projects we factor in what we know about the history uh and and and we will make spots available to your point realistically there's no way 152 families are going to choose to go to allenvale out of Zone but we've determined that in keeping with the spirit of the state law it's appropriate to to leave those because we know that 200 seats based on what we know about allendale's

249future in the next six years is appropriate oh Allison actually just texted me and she was give me a correction we can't approve out of zones on CTE programs of study they have to go open zone now there but but I there's the IB is an exception thank you for that clarification wait a second is that say say that again so if so I I I didn't not know that that was the case I I thought the exact opposite when the state changed this law for open zoning and it says if the school has space you have to open Zone that took away the option to do CTE programs of study so somebody can't go to Franklin specifically like in in addition to IB they can't go use the aut body shop or go to

250the a systems or one of the culinary system culinary programs so they're competing because of the state law thank you for that I'd forgotten about this because of the state law they're required to compete with everybody else for those spots now we have a we have a fail safe and it's the zoning appeals committee um uh what what I have seen I'll give you a couple of examples student moves in they've got um a year of German uh and Independence has German but there's no seats available at Independence and we want to make sure that they have that opportunity to finish their area of concentration that will go to the appeals committee and there's probably some um CCT programs where there's some similar issues so that's our fail safe for good or bad that's where

251we are this is not necessarily part of this discussion but it it's related and that is just the trends over time of where we've seen the growth and where we haven't seen the growth we talk about this multiple times a year but consistently we see these a few of these Western half of the county elementary schools not growing and staying at you know significant capacity um but conversely Arrington Elementary I just I I didn't really realized that how much it had grown but that school opened two years ago and it's going to be you're projecting it to be at 85% capacity starting the next school year that's right um I mean I think that's eye opening you know and to your point about Trends 20 years ago we were exper everywhere they could run sewer

252we were we were seeing growth um and and now it's it's in spots I was I was kind of fascinated with that and I kind of did a little deep dive um talking about that because in field I looked up Fieldstone Farms because we've talked about in the meetings how Walnut Grove is there's a lot of capacity there there's a lot of capacity at um Hunter bin and grassland and so I kind of did some research and Fieldstone Farms the they were they got approval in 1987 and so interestingly enough scales was already built scales was built in 1977 and so there was this projection of all this massive development and so we built Walnut Grove in 1990 and in 1992 grassland was built and open and in 1995 so in five years we put

253three elementary schools right there all within you know a couple miles of each other your your point your point is is good and well made but grassland was a rebuilt just so you know so it was two know wait say that again grassland Elementary was a rebuild grassland Elementary was there before then but your when was the grass because I got this data from the from the district yeah it's the it's the construction date for that building there was an old there was an old building there at a different location when did grassland open grassland proper oh my I'm going to say I'm going to say yeah maybe in the 50s ATS 50s so yeah 70 80 years yeah exactly yeah but that that building open in '92 and and to your point the capacity

254is higher than than the old building right yeah yeah and so I just I saw a lot of you know well then for rut gr and Hunters B and still but your Point's well made yeah I call it the Fieldstone effect yeah that's a good point yeah and Fieldstone there's not been a lot of turnover in homes field zone is full it's just that not a lot of people are selling well we've seen we've seen that in we saw it in brenwood 40 years later right um that you have the gentrification and now um the new people coming in there aren't you know are are 30 40 50 years younger than the ones that are they're leaving or dying so I mean it it's just a matter of time it's just a what do we

255do in the what do we do in the meantime is the question well it's to the point where why do we need capital for construction when you said well that's not 100% capacity across the district yeah we're we're limited on how how far we can bust a student in the window of time we have that's our that's our challenge um and so we are in the process of reviewing options for rezoning uh but but we know that there are some practical limitations on that um before we come to you with a request for actual funding for a new building we will be doing that and we'll have that conversation with you but you know the reality is there's just a there's just a couple of trigger points though I mean the thing is you've got

256two or three elementary schools that are at capacity or will be in in short order and then a handful that'll never be I mean realistic will never even be 70% capacity capacity so it's but then it it the begs the question you know if if you got to move kids out of a certain school where can they realistically go and there's only so many places they can realistically go that's right well and to your point Nolanville and the Arrington area are are our pain points right now we anticipate Spring Hill is going to come behind that uh with the new June Lake development um yeah so that begged the question I just I did notice that Amanda H North has6 um it's proposed for to have 106 open Zone spots and um I so I

257mean you all are the experts but it just makes the question do we do we not propose as many just knowing that those communities are coming along Yeah we actually in this year's five-year Capital plan pushed back to a later date all of our buildings except the Northeast Middle School uh and so we do anticipate as we look at this annually some of those dates are going to get pushed back and I mean just using these numbers for that for that Middle School the the three middle schools in that in that area between mil Creek Sun sunset's got capacity mil Creek's over and and Woodland is is 10 from capacity 10 people 10 people right yeah so but I mean the the net is is like 25 we've got we got 25 open seats between

258those three and we're talking about building a school that's going to open in three years that's right um so and pages that capacity Page Middle right yeah the nearest middle school with any significant amount of capacity is Legacy right and but and we'll look at that but that's an easy drive I'm sure I know all my all my Nolanville Ravenwood people would love to go to Legacy I mean I mean to that point I don't want to get too far into the Weeds on this now because it's we're going to talk about it I know lots more times but those three middle schools that are at capacity or over Pig milre Woodland where's where is The Logical today before before the Jordan Middle School opens in three years if it does where's the relief valve

259at the moment the nearest geographical relief valve is Legacy it's the only really realistic existing one yes uh one idea I'd like to throw out there is Jordan Elementary has 93 could we potentially look at sending some sixth graders there you know as a short term or making it a k6 instead of a or I think they have prek don't they pre6 yes and we move the we move the prek around based on capacity from time to time um we we've had some preliminary discussions about that in different spots in different context we've even looked at some um from time to time we might ask ourselves could we take two elementary schools and make one a K3 and and another one of four six so we're we're brainstorming those we're not at a point where

260we where we recommend that but we've we've seen that kind of thing um I've seen other some of our neighboring Counties have done that from time to time um for various reasons so that that discussion will be had and while I have you um if I could get the number of students who would need to take advantage of open Zone at Nolanville Elementary so we could get rid of the Portables okay we'll work on that the challenge is classes I know right but if we have an estimate maybe we do a a drive yeah yeah okay all right we we'll we'll try to get you that but then if a significant number of them were to choose Jordan then that sort of takes away the opportunity you just mentioned about sixth grade so that's another

261Wrinkle in the plan but yeah another big issue with sixth grade is extracurricular extracurricular activities right so there there's some complexities to it so any more questions on that um so correct me if I'm wrong Jason but but the only thing on Tuesday night aside from the consent agenda that this board will be voting on is this open Zone plan that's correct so is everyone clear on that one voting item Tuesday night aside from consent and it's this plan okay so light agenda all right anything else all right we're Jour thank you thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.