001this is the uh special called meeting for the Coffee County Board of Education for February 12th 2025 um we uh we usually like to start with with a prayer if Mr Cordell could do that and then pledge and then we'll adopt the agenda and move from there so let us pray father and your son's Holy Name we thank you Lord for this day this beautiful day another day to enjoy the beauty of your creation father we thank you for the rain you sent the water of the earth we thank you Father for this team this occasion this staff our teachers our entire system I pray Lord that you would give us all wisdom and discernment as to how to make best the best decisions and may everything we say and do be to honor and
002glorify you we thank you for the legislative uh conference that we just attended we thank you for Dr Grom and what she does for our tsba for our entire State I just pray Lord that you'd bless her give her wisdom thank her for being here today and father thank you for this team that you have brought together so we could honor and glorify you this we pray in your son's precious name amen amen okay pledge I pled to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands one na God indivisible with liberty justice for all all right thank you we hopefully have a short meeting tonight which would definitely be a new thing for us so uh um get Tammy home yeah I think she's on her way to Ray
003County actually so um so the first thing we need to do is uh we got one item on the agenda tonight which is to uh approve the uh the director search brochure and the wording thereof so we need a motion to adopt the agenda for tonight do I have a motion for that I I'll move second Mr hanser Mr Cordell all in favor Mr Cordell I uh Mr answerer hi M Jones hi M uh Matthews hi Mr H and the chair will vote I that is six to zero all right the agenda is um approved so let's move on to our only agenda item so uh Dr gome yes thank you Mr chairman and members of the board I placed at each of your seats a binder we call this the uh search interim report
004as you all know on January the 27th I conducted uh faculty and Community meetings together input for the board we had 134 people in attendance for the in-person meetings there were 37 in attendance for the the noon meeting which was the County Commission mayor city council community and Business Leaders in the board the classified employees we had 23 central office supervisors and principles 37 teachers 23 and the community for Forum 14 I'm on page one of the of the binder in the center we had 233 responses to the online survey so inside of the binder you're going to get the comments for from each of the in-person meetings and then we listed the comments verbatim from the online survey in the notebook as you all know we ask three questions in the in-person meeting me
005ings and they were the same questions that were asked on the online survey the first question was what are the good things going on in Coffee County that you would like to see continued we have read all the comments and the top three responses to that question are on page two the first question was the three most common were teacher support and pay multiple respons highlight the importance of competitive teacher pay and support for teachers this includes salary increases treating teachers as professionals and reducing micromanagement shall allow teachers to focus on student learning and growth the second good thing that was going on that was mentioned Excellence program and after school programs the excellent program is frequently mentioned especially for its support of working with parents and students addition Al after school programs and tutoring
006services are seen as a key to en enhancing Student Success and providing valuable extra learning opportunities and then the third one was stem and Career Technical education programs stem and the Career Technical programs which are emphasized across elementary middle and high schools are often refer referenced for their importance in preparing students for future careers in their alignment with the community's education priorities as you when you go through the notebook there were other things that were mentioned we just took the top three for that one question the second question what are the challenges a new director of schools will face the three most common responses and we're on page two at the bottom number one lack of trust and communication between the school board and the staff many responses highlight a significant breakdown in community communication
007and trust between the school board teachers and other staff members a lot of people feel that the school board is not listening to Educators concerned and there's a general sense that the board may not prioritize the needs of the staff number two staff morale and teacher retention a common concern is the low morale among Educators and staff largely due to the actions and attitudes of the School Board number three school safety and facility concern concerns safety both physical and emotional is another recurring concern several responses point to inadequate facilities outdated buildings and a lack of safety protocols which is especially a concern in the context of student mental health for the third question we asked were what are the personal characteristics that you would like to see in a new director of schools the three
008most common was number one they would like someone with a good listen a leader who can actively listen to stakeholders including teachers sta staff parents in the community ensuring their concerns and ideas are valued number two strong Communicator someone who can clearly convey ideas expectations and policies to all stakeholders fostering transparency and trust and number three Problem Solver an individual who can analyze challenges develop Solutions and Implement effective strategies to improve the school system starting on page we're going to jump to page six page six Begins the overview of the in-person meetings and the online survey so you have all the comments that were made at each of the in-person meetings for each of the three questions and then you also have all the comments that were provided via the online survey and I do
009want to point out we provided the online comments verbatim so we did not correct grammar or uh sentence structure to those we just copied them as they were given to us on the online survey each and at each of the in-person meetings and the online survey if you will turn to page 34 in your book we ask each participant that completed the survey or were or was in attendance for the meetings there were characteristics that you'd like to see in a superintendence we uh tallied those and asked them to rank them the items that are highlighted are the top 10 so the top 10 out of those list of characteristics were listed on page 34 ability to initiate and adapt to change two ability to listen ability to generate support from community and groups ability
010to work with and generate support from the entire board competent manager of B budget and fiscal Affairs effective Communicator both oral and written exhibit strong analytical and problem skills ex exhibit strong interpersonal communication skills goal oriented committed to longrange planning and strong academic and instructional leader so from the comments from the in-person meetings and from the results of this list of rankings we have developed from that and I commend the board for asking for input this involves this process gave everyone in the community faculty and staff to tell us what they f what they'd like in a new director of schools so I commend the board for giving everyone the opportunity to participate in the side front pocket of your binder we have developed a vacancy announcement brochure and this is the item that your
011chairman said that you'll need to vote on tonight so we can post the vacancy the minimum qualifications came directly from your board policy they're at the beginning of the the vacancy brochure the selection criteria are those top 10 I just mentioned that are listed there on the first page and then we did a page that talked a little bit about your community some System facts because when someone's looking to apply they want to know a little bit about your community about the system and then the third page is the application process once we post this applicants will apply for the position via online portal that tsba provides so that is the brochure and I'll stop there Mr chairman and entertain any questions um thank you for for compiling this and I I did want to
012mention for everybody that this binder Melissa will have a copy of this it is available to the public to come in and look at too many pages to scan and put online but it will be available here in the central office if anybody wants to take the time to go through there and I know that Matthew is just uh chomping at a bit to do that right but um um do we have any questions for Dr Gom any questions on on either the survey or or the U qualifications flyer no M Mr chairman I make a motion that we uh approve this I do want to add one uh make one request or one change uh in the minimal qualifications that we take out the professional Educator's license phrase there doing some research on that
013uh and thinking it through I don't want by including that that to take out uh someone that may not have a license but may be thinking outside the box is a good communicator and experience and got man really strong in management and administrative skills and I don't know what will be involved in a professional Educator's license but I'm going to suggest we take that out and also uh check in code uh T TCA 49-2 d301 c a director cannot act as a principal or teacher so my concern is why would we have that in there and I understand that to a point but that I don't want that to potentially eliminate someone outside that may have tremendous management and administrative skills and may not have a a license or may hasn't maybe taught and I
014got to thinking this through last night and I thought well if a if a hospital has administrator administrator position open I don't know that you'd require the administrator to be have a doctor's degree just to serve as an administrator in hospital so I I had a concerned with that so I just wanted to uh on that motion suggest we uh take that one provision Out Mr chairman may I say something sure um in regards to your minimum qualifications I took that directly from the Schoolboard policy so if you want to change that that's going to require a policy change right well or we can suspend policy for for well you're going to have either way you're going to have to vote on the policy right we would have to spit suspend policy yes yeah I
015agree so I guess then the motion would be to adopt this um the um the brochure yes um with the the change that we remove professional Educators license by susp ending policy um in that regard for for the director search MH and um I guess that would that would have to be the motion then right okay some all right do we have a second on that Mr Cordell has made the motion the uh the motion is to adopt the brochure and re suspend policy which requires a professional Educator's license no second all right then we have no motion then we're going to have to take some action on this so do we have another motion I'll make a motion that we accept it as it as it's written Mr second it m Jones all right
016any discussion the motion is to accept the brochure as written any discussion I just want to make sure is Beth supposed to be is she uh Beth Y is she supposed to be part of this um no she she she's on oh she's not zoom in she doesn't qualify for zooming in although she did um contact me and say and she actually recommended um removing that provision on the professional educator no I I thought maybe she was yeah she just asked me to to mention that so so any further discussion on this all right the motion is to adopt the brochure as written um take a vote uh uh Mr hanser uh M Jones ah Miss Matthews I uh Mr I Mr Cordell nay and I will vote nay that is 4 to2 so we
017have we do not have a qu this the same situation we ended up with last meeting we do not have a quorum five people would be a positive vote so so right right now it it fails um we can have a motion to reconsider either of these amendments I guess is it still up for discussion yeah at this point yeah I think the biggest thing that I not nothing against Mr Cordell respect him but I think uh it's equivalent to any job that you you you go to if we have somebody that doesn't have a teacher license it's hard for the teachers to respect maybe uh to to see that they the teachers to think that there is a uh a common bond with the the teachers that that that's already teaching you know for
018them to have you know as a supervisor I know with me uh it would be hard for me to have as a someone as a boss uh that's never done what I've done before that don't even have a degree in it uh or a teacher's license I should say U and that's that's that's what I've gotten from the teachers that and uh that's who I'm supposed to be supporting and from other other uh constituents that has talked to me about this so that's kind of my world I'm coming from you know just to let people know where I'm coming from so Mr Bard you really should be having a motion before discussion right in at this point I do believe we would have to well I mean we've got both options that have already I
019I know I'm just that's just rer Rule of Order I'll just touch you Bas with it all right so we'd have to have a motion to reconsider I guess so so do you want to reconsider your your initial motion yes so Mr Cordell has a motion to reconsider do we um so we'd have to vote to reconsider and now if I my ADD Mr chairman I love her teachers I so respect and appreciate what they're doing they've gone through tremendous stress and time to get to where they are I respect and appreciate that but I just didn't want us by having that in there to maybe exclude someone that has tremendous management skills and could really think a little outside the box and move forward uh if I may I talk with one candidate um
020just briefly but uh he has served as the secretary the he was over the state Department of Education in one state for years and I don't know why he doesn't have a teaching certificate but he has tremendous experience working at the junior college level and whatever and he may be capable of bringing a measure to the team that maybe we haven't thought of before or some of his uh work ethic he's very experienced very knowledgeable very brilliant don't why I didn't have the the whatever but I just hate for us to exclude uh a really good candidate just because the person doesn't should have but they don't have a teaching certificate and I know that's in our policy Mr Balor you have a motion you don't have a second for discussion do we have excuse
021me oh do we have a second on the motion to reconsider okay I'll be quiet then no motion no second consider the initial motion of Mr Cordell to adopt this without the professional Educator's license suspend policy for that so what is what is the motion for to suspend policy or to adopt I'm I'm sorry I'm confused I'm I'm kind of lost too yeah okay let me repeat the motion we're we're reconsidering Mr cordell's initial motion to adopt this without Professional without the requirement for a professional Educator's license which would require suspending our policy and I don't remember I think it's 5.84 I'd have to look it up yeah sorry um to suspend policy for for the uh director search that is the motion so to adop be the brochure without the professional Educator's license requirement
022there is what's that well who seconded it before nobody nobody seconded before so so this motion includes suspending the policy that's currently in place correct right okay no second all right then I guess our next option is to reconsider to adopt this policy or or a motion to reconsider the vote to adopt the policy as written do I have a motion for that I'll make a motion to accept the uh directors as listed in the brochure second seconds it any discussion well I would like to say something um I know that when we're looking at this these uh survey uh questions and the answers that we got from various people and uh two of the things was the communication and trust between the school board teachers staff members and the board and that uh there
023was a common concern of low morale among the Educators and staff largely due to the actions and attitudes of the school board and I feel like that as as a former teacher and uh an employer or teacher of the school system I think we would be neglecting their concerns of having a leader that has been in the classroom and knows what's going on in an everyday life of a teacher and uh that to me that's very important and I know there's probably some really good candidates out there but you cannot provide the best of leadership if you haven't been in that spot at some time during your career and and that's that's the way I feel I think the point was not so much that they didn't have experience as a as a teacher or
024or in that environment but whether they have a current professional Educator's license which I believe Dr Powell does not does he have a teacher I didn't check those credentials before he was brought on I mean he have a teacher license teach license okay then I may I add that the the law only requires the superintendent to have a bachelor's degree in any subject and there's no superintendent license or certification that's law however you all by board policy have required more and that's what's listed in the brochure yes and and if I may again it you know if we just abolish the policy that gives a bad to me that's just going to give us a bad image instead of going through three readings like we always do when policies are changed and uh if we
025just immediately abolish a policy and change the the qualifications and I think we're going to really have a lot of additional you know nons support from from our employees can I say something um I agree with Miss Jones um I feel like um in order for a director to really be able to identify with the challenges that teachers are faced with every day in that classroom setting um that they in my opinion would need to have taught in the classroom uh for not just a short amount of time but you know a decent amount of time that's my opinion thank you any other discussion I have to agree with Miss Jones and Miss Matthews um I think in order to um create that bond between teachers and the director and the school board I think
026it would be um in our best interest to keep the professional Educator's license in the brochure because like Miss Matthews said you know a teacher is not going to feel like they can come to the director if they have a issue in the classroom if the director's never been in the classroom further discussion all right let's take it to a vote this is to adopt the motion is to adopt the uh brochure as written so Miss Jones Miss Matthews hi Mr uh Mr [Music] Cordell I Mr aner I and I will vote I on that that passes six to zero okay that is the item of business and I believe we are concluded we just had to do that because we're used to two-hour meeting so we had to drag it out that's we will
027post this in the morning and as indicated on the timeline the application deadline will be March 14th after which time we will review all applications screen those according to the criteria that the board adopted and we'll bring you up to three finalists that we think best meets the criteria the board will at that point once I present finalists I I I do not participate in the interview so the board will set up your interviews with those candidates and make your selection um from there all applications will be turned over to you as well that night if there's someone that you would like to interview that's up to the board we will every Friday send you a list of the people that have applied so you'll be up to dat on the applicants until I present
028the the finalist on March 31st I have a question so you're telling us that you're only going to present three people up to three for us to interview or uhuh yes but we'll see all the you're going to send us all the resumes though so yeah we'll give you all the resumés we can Shuffle the order if we want was kind of a small number because I remember prior to the P you know the what I was involved in one whenever we had named a director and it was more than three people we interviewed but I lately it it it some boards ask for five but as I said before the candidate pool is Slim just like you have a hard time finding teachers we don't get as many applicants as we used to right
029now we have five searches going on at the same time and there's 11 superintendency V superintendent vacancies across the state and it's not just our state uh everyone I just got off the phone with the Virginia folks they've got more than 11 searches going on so there're they're not a lot of applicants and we recruit as much as we can to get folks to come and um but you know you you've got to do as a board your part in attracting people to want to apply it's it works both ways you know you've got a you want good candidates but you all have to have things in place where people want to come to Coffee County because there's lots of vacancies going on across the state right now but as I said our job is
030not to select your director of schools you just ask us to do the leg work so we're going to do that for you um we will screen all the applicants we've got folks just because they list someone on their reference p page we we know folks that we can call that to find out about people that are not listed as a reference I think that's one of the benefits of using our association um we know we have some applicants that are apply for every search that we've done and I've been there 36 years and I've seen some for the last 20 apply for everything so we we know what's out there we will bring you the ones that we think best meet what your criteria is in the brochure but at the end of the
031day it is the board's decision I'll give you all the applications and you can do with what you want at that point can I ask another question um I guess I'm just being dumb but what are we what are we uh stating that the salary is because that's a big that's a big thing what we yes this is something the Board needs to decide at least give me a salary range because most people when they are applying like all of us work for a reason right um I need to know a salary range so I can tell interested applicants what the range would be we've been having a lot of committee meetings but we're going to have to have another director search committee meeting and that that is going to be a topic we got
032to work on the con the draft contract too so these are some things we got to get done and I know that we've been having a lot of meeting and I know per Holly has been like seven or eight meetings in the last week and a half so but I can't imagine anyone turning in an application I I I guess they could turn it in but that's the first one of the first things they're going to look at is what the salary is yeah but you typically it'll list what the current salary is you know the state provides the salary is yeah yeah but that's the only thing I can share with them as so the current salary is what was was well that's a good question because we never have been able to nail
033that down exactly I think it was around 140 or so but but we've been discussing you know salary plus bonus and stuff too so and we need to Hash that out so okay but but you typically in in the brochure that goes out you typically do not put a salary range in there do you okay so they can the board specifically wants it in the brochure we do not put that in the brochure so we had a little bit of time so one more meeting well thank you all very much and like I said we'll get this posted tomorrow thank you total is 15 thank you damy thank you thank you very much total in the director appreciate D sorry current compensation right now was 154 so so and but we have the survey data
034from from tsba on director salaries around the state so we're going to have to look at that so we'll get that inform back to me as as soon as we can all right meeting schedule thank you very much Dr gome um we need a motion to dismiss I'll so move second Mr answerer Mr Cordell um y be careful going home all yeah all in favor say I I okay