001for January and um um we have our our agenda here couple adjustments to the agenda um we are going to move agenda item one substitute teacher policy down to three and move the cell phone policy to number one so that um uh Mr hanser and and we have a a presenter here um who has PowerPoint presentation so he is not going to be tied up thank you also we are going to strike agenda item or actually prer agenda item four on the athletic director and athletic program to next month and uh so those are the uh agenda item changes so um this is then the call to order and so we're going to talk about cell phone policy um teacher appreciation um substitute teacher policy art programs and then uh transportation of student students so
002that's the uh work topic uh topics for tonight so um Mr hanser you can lead off cell phone policy I have uh asked Mr Chris cope uh down here today this is not a uh this is not a uh trying to to get anybody to sway this away or anything this is something that uh it even was even brought up yesterday in our meeting that our media and the school systems and so on and so forth so this is not a uh to try to sway anybody Chris is not here to sway anybody I'm not here to sway anybody just uh it's a Hot Topic because of the social media and uh I know Chris known Chris for a while he's a chairman of the the war County school board up there uh he's been
003asked to come to the estate he is the four they are the four runners four guys in in the uh Forefront of the cell phone uh that's going on in the state of Tennessee uh so without further Ado Chris cope if I can just say one thing too is the state has legislation that is that is passing through the the legislature on cell phone policy and and the FEDS do also so we're kind of trying to get out in front of that that policy talking about it here that's a very good point Thank you Mr well first of all thank you guys for having me thank you Scott for inviting me up here and again we're not trying to sway anybody we're just going to I just want to talk to you about our journey
004that we've that we've went on in Warren County the last uh actually about the last year uh and how we got started and where this came about and and what what it's looked like so far in our first half of this school year in Warren County and what what we've noticed and and stuff so how it all got started and I'll tell you it's been about it was not this past Christmas break but the Christmas break before four I had a couple of teachers reach out to me just out of the blue said hey we are being overrun by these cell phones we cannot compete with this if we're sitting right here in this meeting if everybody would have their phone out on their desk and turn their volume on I bet you before I
005get through we' have 50 notifications going off between the sing here and doesn't matter if we've got them on vibrator on not on silence if that phone goes off you're automatically going to say what does that text mean who's trying to call me do I need to get that do I need to respond so you're we're breaking our concentrations can you imagine one teacher with 20 or 25 students in the classroom and these cell phones going off constantly and they trying to teach and you turn around and your students are not paying attention because they're worried about what's going on after class or what's going on tonight my mom's takes me I got to do this I got to pick up my little brother so so we I talked to a few teachers and I
006said all right let's do an experiment we're going to do an in-house experiment and I got two or three teach teachers from the high school a middle school teacher uh and we I said here's what I want you to do I want you to when you get into class I want you to have your kids because like you guys probably most everybody we we did have an electronic device policy that says hey you know during non-instruction times you you can have it out during lunch during Halls you can have it out but we know how kids are and they're going to push this and they had them out and had them between their legs and they looking down in there we know the kids we know how it is so I said have your kids
007pull out their phones put it on their their desk turn on the volume and every time that that a notification goes off that kid needs to go to the board and write a mark on what app went off so here's what we what here's what we noticed I get this to work well there we go all right so this is a Warner County high school biology class 15 minutes into class we had 149 distractions so you can look over here how many Snapchat notifications how many text messages Facebook so out of the 149 we noticed that 53% was social media five minutes into a class here we had 151 distractions these are just students in your class so you're trying to teach for five minutes and you've got 151 distractions and you can see what
008they are Snapchat Instagram Tik Tok text messages emails biology class uh this is a little longer period of time but still 140 distractions in one class period and our teachers are having to compete with this all right here's a history class 15 minutes 85 of them 65% social media same thing we've got Tik toks look at the Snapchat look at the text messages look at Instagram it wasn't long before we realized our teachers are are being overrun here I mean you got one teacher in a class and they're having to compete with this and still trying to teach our kids so I stumbled upon and I brought the book I encourage everybody that's get a chance to to pick up a copy of this book called y Generation by a social psychologist named Jonathan height
009I actually I stumbled upon him on Joe Rogan's podcast and listened to it if you get a chance you don't have to listen to that podcast but listen to an interview with this guy he's a social psychologist has done the research for the past eight or 10 years on the influence of screen time social media and what it does to our children much less what it does to us as adults so here's what we see from the US Department this is uh from some data that we've gathered uh us emergency room depart from for self harm from ages 10 to 14 and what I want to show you right here a lot of this we kind of want to blame on Co right we want to say that's where our depression that's where all these
010things started happening for our young kids kids and then we look at teens with depression what they're battling so we we want to think that Depression started in 2020 when our we shut all of our kids out of school and everything but you look right here this starts 2012 and 2014 is when we start seeing the huge rise in depression rates girls 145% increase and in boys at 161% I have a 13-year-old daughter so this this really was hit home to me so we what we realized is what happened between the Years 2012 and 2016 where these big spikes were we can't blame that on Co now Co didn't help anything because we can see a big spike in Co but from The Years 2012 to 2014 three things happened the invention of the iPhone
011the invention of the front-facing camera which selfies was started to becoming a thing back in 2014 and in 2014 is when Facebook acquired Instagram so as older generation we love our Facebook but our kids are not on that I promise you Facebook is not a problem in our in our kids today but when when they acquired Instagram and the selfie and the picture started coming out that's when we started seeing a major rise in United States with repression these these right here you can go to other countries only in Western developed Nations do you see these Rises like this all the other countries around the world don't have these spikes like this us anxiety and prevalent so you start seeing age groups uh and each generation had its own anxiety so you had the the
012boomer generation as they say now they were World War II they were Nazis they were that was their biggest anxiety Parts uh you go up to Generation X kind of my generation we still we had we went through the Cold War so that was our biggest fear as a kid I could still remember some of the you know Fallout shelters and you get under your desk in case of a nuclear attack uh but when you get it to this gen Z when we get start talking about our kids right now that are 18 years old what is their biggest day why is anxiety amongst kids risen that much in just three generations it's because we give them the access to the world with no stipulations we say here you go if you want to watch
013something there it is if you want to if you want to have access to anything during school hours whatever time there it is anything we're not going to filter it at all so generation Alpha that's the years that we're talking about now it's born around 2010 and later so this is 14 15 year olds we're starting middle school early High School uh one in five has a mental emotional behavior disorder with ADHD an and anxiety being the most prevalent according to the CDC so if you've talked to any teachers and you've talked to any parent and you see that we know that the behavioral problems the mental issues that we're facing our kids are facing right now is an epidemic I mean you talk to the teachers I talked to and a lot of the
014research says that the reason we can't retain teachers is not because of all these testing and this stuff it is because of just discipline issues they're not going have to deal with this we have put our kids Generation Z which is somewhere between the ages of 14 and 26 which is our high school seniors and stuff is dealing with identity body image friendship issues according to their therapist in the article young Jers who are in high school worry about social hierarchies and Dynamics like who's cool kind of like the clicks we had when we were in school but with when we put this into their hands they get to see it all day long during school in school all right according to available data charts depicting generation Alpha anxiety often shows a concerning Trend indicating
015a higher prevalence anxiety compared to previous generations ADH and anxiety being the most common mental health concerns if you you were at tsba one of the things they talked about is what are we doing about mental health what are we doing with mental health with these kids we are struggling to try to keep up and we're doing we're putting millions and millions of dollars in our school systems about how we're going to keep up with mental health of these kids I mean we all know we can't sit here and deny that these kids that we are we are elected we are you know to to oversee and to do the best we can for them this minimal problem is is an issue talk to any teacher and they will tell you that and it's not
016just teen in high schools we're talking about we' had open up our alternative school to third graders I mean we're doing third starting in third grade right now at waren County with our alternative to school and we actually have kids that are younger than that that fit that protocol that need should be in there all right this is John Templeton he is a youth pastor at one of our big churches and this was one a thing he he really he's done a lot of work with our youth in Warren County and and this is something he really uh stuck to me that he said a little I don't know a few months ago but the hardest thing in our society is being a teenage girl and this is where it gets me because I got
017a 13-year-old daughter in 8th grade there's so many voices so many influences constantly telling them that they don't measure up or they have to be this or that what's the solution to that and I'll show you the picture he talks about but the number one thing is community you need it we were meant to be uh we're meant to be to walk in this life on your own and I was telling them you know we are social creatures we were created by God to be social people and even though we open up the world with our phones it has created more isolation than anything else we've ever invented in this in this world so this is the picture that he that he had posted and this is a quote I picked up from Jonathan H
018the author of this book he says people don't get depressed when they face threats collectively so if if something happened in this room right now we're all in here together we're not going to be so concerned since we've got each other but if I'm in this room by myself and there's nobody else in this building and something happens then I'm going to start getting I'm going to start having a little bit more issues with it so people don't get depressed when they face threats collectively they get depressed when they feel isolated lonely and useless so that's what social media has done to our children we thought it's going to open up the world to them but what it's done is made them feel more isolated and lonely and useless than anything as we see in
019the in the in the data that shows the anxiety and all these things so I've reached out to a place called phone- free school movement and they have all sorts of and I think I may have sent this to Scott this toolkit that they provide but there's a lot of information on here and a few of the things that I had to point out here it says 83% of the teachers support an all day phone-free school policy teenagers spend nearly five hours a day on social media apps five hours a day now 24 hours if you take a few hours of those away for sleeping if you take seven hours of those for school 50% of kids get 237 notifications per day on their phones some receive as many as 4,500 every day we're talking
020about kids here data show students not using their phones during class wrote down 62% more information during class time where the where these phone policies have been in place 62% more they also scored a full letter grade and a half higher on multiple choice test T So students that don't have their phone in their classrooms these are not just made up these are these are this is hard data here that's been and it's got all the links and all the citations to it 95% teachers say anxiety and depression is the number one problem in public schools K through 12 does anybody disagree with that it's hard it's hard when you listen to your teachers they will tell you uh one in three teens one and third of all teens reported they have been exposed to
021pornography during school day this is something that we've really picked up on in waren county and I'll talk a little bit more about it but when you when we start taking this on it it wasn't just a Schoolboard thing we would we didn't just say hey us a school board we're going to do this we got our community involved we reached out our general s chesson's judge was one of the main key players in this we went to our sheriff's department and say hey what do you think how's this we our SRO officers what what's going on here so you see the data over and over again before I go to this next slide cuz I just added it today and I talked to Scott yesterday so when you start talking about taking the phones
022out of the schools and that our students won't have that with them the number one thing and we'll talk about push backs in a minute but the number one thing is what happened in Antioch the other day and I tell everybody look I've got a daughter in school and if that happened I would be worried to death that I wouldn't be able to get a hold of her I mean that's reality and I understand that concern I truly understand that concern but here's the thing I looked at some research today and this is not a topic nobody likes to talk about but School shooters share more commonalities so they can they can look at these including a history of emotional distress mental health issues and exposure to violence they often plan their violence and may
023show signs of Crisis before the day every one of these things we've shown is what our kids are facing today so we can throw money and money after off after after all these symptoms but until we get to this core problem and this core issue of our mental health problems in in our schools and in our society none of this is going to change we can add metal detectors we can add all those things but that's not going to change what's going on exposure to violence I want to talk about that for just a second because I was talking I teach Sunday Middle School and High School uh Sunday school and I was talking to our kids uh Sunday morning when I was a kid and I can remember and I if anybody else remembers
024this but you could go to the video store and there was a I think it may been on HB it was called Faces of Death and it was a and it showed horrific car accidents and people and it was just it was unheard of I mean it was just you know today any kid can get on Tik Tok and get on Instagram and watch a hundred videos in a row of people getting killed people being assassinated and they've become numb to it when we watched those things as children I mean it was horrific these kids watch it today and they have doesn't even phas them so they're constantly exposed to just violence all the time and it's it's just numb them they have no have nothing so students on average according to who you talk
025to 192 alerts per day from their cell phones 11 notifications per hour I think these are really low because I've got a 13year old and I know how often her phone goes off uh cell phones and their applications are designed to catch the attention of students which is it is disruptive to both learning and relationship ship why do each social media app have different ringtones each app you have has a different notification sound because that way you know exactly which one it is if they all sounded the same then we would not be apt to go back through those things so I talked about our Middle School what we done was with our General Sessions Judge some of our school board members our Sheriff's Department uh Mr Dishman here I don't know if you know
026wend Dishman he is U uh or Barry Dishman sorry he was our uh juvenile advoc court Advocate served 30 years he just recently retired but we would get our every student in our uh County every school had six through eth kids so this is our war County Middle School we would have sessions with them and we would talk about subjects we would talk about vaping we would talk about the importance of attendance we would talk about all kinds of social media issues uh this is myself talking at Morrison Elementary this is Jarvis Johnson who is a captain of our Sr programs and he's actually our newest one of our newest school board members uh Deo Elementary each Elementary School we went to um so talking about phone free school movement this is a nonprofit organization
027that I reached out to uh and they started helping us with some with some of the information and stuff but one of the things uh judge Moore our General Sessions Judge started talking about because we went back to that slide talks about our kids being exposed to sexual stuff to to to nude to pornography at a young age they could be sitting in your math class and with their phone in hand go to any pornography side they want to and be watching it and no teachers are going to know and we allow that in our in our classrooms now we're going to say we don't allow that but hey we're all teenage kids at some point in time but Distortion is a thing that our judge is really hit on he just left a conference
028and talked about with things we don't really that's kind of uncomfortable to talk about but the percentage of our kids that are in Middle school that have been exposed to either some sort of extortion ring some sort of pornography if you look at the numbers of what kids that are 12 13 14 years old that have sent nudes to another student in middle school we don't like to talk about that but it's happening and I promise you it's happening in Coffee County the same it is happened in Warren County not long after we we started this we had an incident it happened at our Middle School seventh grader went to the bathroom another kid followed in there with their phone and videotaped them and sent it on the internet and it was out exposed everywhere
029and that's when we said we've got to do something here we we cannot allow this to happen to our children anymore and I know a lot of the policies hey let them have it when they're in lunchtime let them have it when they go one thing look here I'm going off right now um one thing that the kids really love to do is they text each other hey meet me out in the hallway at such and such time and we'll go do whatever all right so we done a poll to our we done a poll we put it out before we started this here like we started looking at this in March and then by June we had our policy in place in past so we put out a poll just a asked 10 questions
030we had a poll for our parents we had a poll for our teachers all right so teachers here's your 10 questions parents here's your 10 questions a lot of them were similar this is a parent survey as a parent do you feel like your student should be allowed to have cell phones white at school we have over 70% of the 150 that answered yes all right as a parent at one time would probably be right there too what does your child mostly use their cell phone for what I found alarming was almost 30% of parents think that their kids are using their phones for emergencies I said if we have that many emergencies in war County we've got a bigger issue to worry about we looked at those are non-scientific polls that we done they
031say only less than 10 or right at 10% say social media we noticed that every one of them was 50 to 60 70% of those go notifications for social media right uh texting emergencies music you know all this stuff how does having a cell phone affect your child's learning so as a parent they're saying that only about 25% the negative and very negative less than 25% believe that it affects them negatively most of them say it doesn't affect them at all right uh let's see here cell phones that can have a negative impact on learning primarily due to the distraction nature we as we as adults are the same way we get a notification you're going to look at it you're not going to pay attention to what's going on kids do not have their
032brains are not fully developed nobody in high school not till they're usually in their early 20s before our frontal cortex is fully developed and our decision- making really is in intact uh so you can see that it decreases focus and attention in classrooms potentially resulting in lower academic performance and they can also facilitate cheating provide I don't know there's a there's a app called something about math math something you can take a picture of the problem and there's the answer right there on your phone they don't have it'll just spit it right out for you so how does cell phones having a cell phone this is again this is the parent survey how does a cell phone impact your kids Mental Health you have 60% so only about 20 something percent think that it's negatively
033affects their mental health all the all the data that we've collected so far shows that it highly affects their mental health mental health are through the roof and us as parents are going to sit back and think that it doesn't have any effect on our kids at all so we just going back to this parents think that it has no effect on their anxiety or on their mental health we show that CDC all the results saying that our children's mental health are through the roof roof our emergency room visits for self harm suicide rates are through the roof especially in teenage girls so uh this is this is our teachers okay this is our teacher survey so if you allowed your students to use their cell phone in class what is the primary purpose again
034or at 60% almost of emergencies that our teachers were saying and again I say hey if we have that many emergencies in our classroom something's wrong uh social related research our teachers said that 0% said that they let their kids use it for social media how does how does having a Sone effect your students learning this is our teachers these are the people that are in our classrooms that around our kids every single day look at where what our teachers say negative very negative and I don't know only less than 20 less than 10% say that hav't your kid your student having a cell phone in classroom impacts their learning positive or very positive so here again this is what our teachers who are in our classrooms in the trenches every day are telling us
035about what cell phones do into their classroom and this is what us as parents are out here thinking that's going on in our classroom and then we blame the teachers because our kids can't learn anything but yet we're sitting here this this is so divided and you know it's a communication thing and as a parent I understand both sides of this but this is where we have to draw this connection this is where we have to bring our parents in and show them this because I promise you the the number one people that were opposed to this cell phone policy are the parents you would think that it would be the high school kids the Juniors and seniors now I promise you I got some some bad looks for some of those kids that I
036know if they didn't like it at all we have a student advisory panel and I don't know if you guys do this but we have a student advisory panel that come in and sit on our board and they give us an update of what's going on at the high school and then one of the members will sit in on our meeting uh non voting but they can come in and talk to us so this particular student uh we were talking to early discussions on and she was against it she was a senior or Junior going to be a senior and as she talked she said I I've actually I'm seeing this but I realized after looking at my screen time I'm not living in the moment I'm living through my phone I'm living through others
037people not even really living at all so this is what our kids are doing they're not having these connections with other students they're worried about posting a picture on Instagram that I took in the bathroom during first period now I'm looking every period to see how many likes I got and I'm not worried about you trying to teach me English or I'm not worried about you trying to teach me economics because I'm trying to figure out who didn't like it or who said this because you know or who made fun of about what I'm wearing so I'm sure you guys do the same do our uh we start doing our policies and we throw a lot of this stuff in our consent agenda is policy blah blah blah BL through whatever we're going to throw
038in consent agenda we're going to pass the consent agenda and that's it and there it is we're good for another year on all these policies so when it come time for our student policy I went through and I looked through all this and I was like you know what I'm pulling this one out of consent so on our I think it was our March meeting I said I'm pulling this number out and we're going to talk about this separate uh couple of things we got a six board member I had about two other members with me that was that was saying all right I kind of like this I had three members that's like our director of schools bless his heart he will tell you this to this day he said I was against this
039he said I told you when you first mentioned this there's no way you can pull this off he has two kids that are in high school and he has another one coming up one of our board members has a daughter in high school and as we discuss this and discuss this they would say we would sit down at the dinner table at night we it was pretty cold conversations going on from my daughter saying that you're going to take our phones away at school and of course mine's in e8th grade she's in middle school she didn't she was she's going into High School ex year she didn't like this at all either but as we started looking through the data we started reading we started researching this you know we're like you know what there's
040something to this we need to give this a try so the things that we realized as we as I looked at some different uh districts throughout the United States uh there wasn't much in Tennessee we went through probably 15 different policies through the state uh someone had some of them had good stuff some of them not so much but the one thing we realize we had to do if you're going to do a cell phone policy like we have is it has to be a bell-to-bell policy there can't be no Exceptions there can't be you know you can't say oh you can have them during lunch or you can have them during uh non-instructional time our principal at our high school Chris Hobbs come up to me when we first started discussing this and he
041used to be the he was the principal at Franklin County for a little bit before he came back to Warren County and he said please do me a favor as a board member please when you pass that policy put in there that there is no discretion that no teacher has a discretion no administrator has a discretion because our policy before said that hey it's up to teachers discretion how they wanted to implement their phone policy so if you had 10 minutes left in class all right kids you can feel afraid to have your ever phones out he said please take that away from me he said that way when a parent comes to me and says hey you have the discretion to make this right he says no I don't that's between you and the
042board because my teachers he said it makes it easy to discipline my teachers because my teachers don't have the discip to the discretion to say it's okay for you to use it in this particular case so for this and what we ended up doing is strict our um offense policies so we did give them a warning because we know hey the first offense you're these kids are going to try you right off the G you know you're first fence cuz our old policy I think we had six or seven I mean it went on out forever uh so you see uh the second one you're going to collect it the parents is notified the parents has to come and pick it up on your second offense it's either two days after school detention or one
043week of lunch detention uh the device is collected uh parents you know so and then the third offense is uh you have to have two days of ISS they're not allowed to bring the device back the rest of the year it's collected you know parents have to pick it up uh it goes on their behavior Contra contract we record all these things fourth offense uh K through five could could result in suspension uh short-term suspension uh device collected and it could lead to alternative school for our high schoolers we've we had this policy and when we were at uh the legislative conference in July in Gatlinburg we we were starting to get this rolled out and we had a principal's meeting and our principles come to us and said hey can you strict those policies
044a little bit more can you strien can you strict the the the punishment just a little bit more because we wanted this thing to be we want it to stick we wanted everybody to know so we went back and revised our this policy and made it a little bit more stricter than what we actually had to start with uh so by that time we started I think this was a news channel 2 Pol uh you know we've been on the news a little bit about this we did decide to go with the Yonder pouch I won't play this video but uh and we had some issues with this because as soon as we passed this bill or passed this policy and went to we decided to go to the Y pouch is when Arkansas done
045Statewide band on their cell phone so they put in a huge order so we didn't get we ordered ours in July and didn't get them till end of September so our school had already started five or six weeks so what we had decided to do is put this on a school by school basis uh most of them didn't roll it out till after they got back from from Christmas break because it was working fairly well we had bought some lock boxes for our elementary schools they could come in you know my daughter goes to k38 school she comes in she puts her phone in the office they lock it up at the end of the day they come back and get it out um we had done similar things in um in her High School
046there's different ways you can do that you can have lockers in a in a first period class and then give them 10 minut minutes at the end of the day to come back what these if you've not and I didn't bring one with me but if you're not familiar with these These are magnetic lockable pouch es uh they the kids keep their pouches that's their pouch they're responsible for them and they come in in the morning they put their phone in there they're big enough not only for our phones but we also put uh smart watches and earbuds in there you know the ear pods so there's no electronic device that they can have all that goes into their pouch they close it they can throw it in their backpack whatever they want to do
047they can't access it because the only way you can access those is through a magnet and those magnets are strategically placed on exits at the the office has one and then each exit door so at the end of the day the kids come by hit that magnet it opens their thing they can pull their stuff out and go on about their day they they take the pouch home with them they're responsible for them I think the cost on them was about $25 a piece we we fortunate enough we got we still had a little bit of extra money that we got to use for that because that was a little Kickback from some of our communi we spent $100,000 on these bags but we did use exra money so it's a little bit easier to
048explain uh so but we are rolling those out right now and they seem to be working pretty well we know kids are going to lose them kids are going to say well I didn't bring it or this or that kids are always going to try to to work around the rules but we thought this was this was a good idea in a good way and so far it's worked fairly well in the places we brought about our Communications Group got to work on because we didn't give them a lot of time as the board that one thing they wanted to wait is because we didn't pass this till June well they said well all of our uh our school are already going to have their stuff out for the year and you know we're going
049to have to add this to the policy I don't care add some pages to the policy I don't care if you've got your your book out for the rest of the year so our Communications come up with this less distraction more connection because when you get a notification on your phone it is not just a notification it is a distraction if I got a text message or an email or a phone call right now I'm going to be looking say well wonder what what she wanted I wonder if that's something I need to get to uh so the distractions less distraction action more connection so so we had we we ramped up social media this was in July going into August um so we letting everybody know here here's what's going on we we got
050the word out to all our shareholders and said like hey this is the plan I know it may not be popular but this is the way it's we're we're doing it so first day of school in our high school this cell phone policy this was from uh one of our cafeteria workers cell phone policy might be the best thing we've ever done freshman lunch with no phones was absolutely awesome uh this is from our principal our students and teachers have been more interactive one with one another students surprisingly have been happy after the initial shot they've adjusted well our teachers are happy the atmosphere is back to an educational environment I promise you you talk to any teacher that teaches at Warren County High School they will say this is the best thing that's ever
051happened our students now now has got the shock over with they love it too they they do our high school students you go see them at the ball games and you go see they're not even on their phones dur the ball games now they're running back and forth like we used to do with kids and they're back and forth and back and forth and it's it's it's amazing it's a game changer that was one of the words that was used by several teachers to me afterwards about the first month in it's a game Cher just the social interactions between our students after about a month I went to the high school and just just went in into the Hall during one of the breaks and just so much liveliness activities and and you talked to
052some of the monitors that are there and they like before it was you can almost whisper through here because the kids were they would run over each other looking down at their phones and now it's just laughter it's talking they're they're having a good time again so does this work so the I got some numbers actually this morning from Principal Hobbs um so our referrals for our discipline referral uh August let's see the green is last year the blue is this year of course August started off with a little bump because everybody's going to try to push the rules right but you see in September our referrals are started going down in October our referrals for discipline referrals are way down in November they starting to get up a little bit I just looked at
053the December numbers and they're they're staying on point right here we're we're way down in in referrals for our students this is at our high school and this is we break it down a little more so green yes sir are those referrals for related issues those are for all related issues and this breaks it down a little more so I'll I'll point this out uh so the green was last year blue is this year Defiance we're way down everything across the board T even our tardiness our skipping class um fights tobacco drug use because vaping was a big issue and I know it happens here too uh the they would hide them in the lunch in the restrooms and then text their bu hey I left it in Stall too and it's behind the commode
054so when you get done you can go over there and do that too uh so all across the board pretty much everything this Tech did go up because I got the I got the one from today uh that was up to date from Principal Hobs this morning and I asked him about uh that and he said uh uh the behavior it's starting it's getting just a little bit because they're uh trying they can't meet with their friends so some of this um text stuff they're they're going through their email and trying to do some stuff so they're getting some but we can monitor all that so that's kind of getting of that and uh some disruptions have been up just a little bit just because they've got this extra time on their hands and they
055don't know how to handle that and one of the things that they talked about in in that phone- free school movement is have something there for the kids have cards or have a game or something for them if you've got 10 minutes class let them have whatever it is and let them just use their minds you know so we have right now already and we talked to our sro's and he's you know they're saying you know it was five or six times a day it was cell phone related issues that we were dealing with almost everything that we were dealing with had something to do with cell phones whether it was vaping whether it was fights whether it was bullying and you can look at our bullying zero zero referrals for the first three months
056in school we didn't have any bullying issues now I'm not saying that that didn't happen but I'm just saying we have a drastic reduction in this so here's some benefits of this phone free policy this is uh fewer distractions of course that's that's a given you take that distraction away from our kids that's a fewer distractions less cyber bullying fewer fights and social media related drama because I promise you a 13-year-old daughter that's a cheerleader I know all about this drama stuff with these these these but females for sure increased engagement students engage more with their peers teachers uh outside of classroom I'll tell you one thing that they reported on our first month is when we had our class uh our Club Drive at high school where they would set up for extracurricular activities
057and all the clubs afterwards they had a record number turnouts for our clubs our hosta Club was a record number we had several clubs that had a record number of students join in after school clubs because their friends now are talking to them and they're saying you know hey I want to join that because you're doing that so our our after school clubs have just exploded and we're we're adding more and more just because we have so many kids that want to participate in it now uh so again uh improved attendance our attendance we've not had the issue and I know if you're you know you know attendance is an issue because if kids are not in school they're not going to learn anything um boosted efficiency more reading improved teacher morale that's huge that's
058huge the teacher retention that's something we all struggle with this is made the teacher's job so much easier they're not there's one or less thing they have to deal with they're just going to come in and teach now they don't have to fight this right here right now less mid class absenteeism because kids are not ultimately kids don't have to go to the bathroom as much in Warren County as they used to they're not leaving class to go to the bathroom less cheating because that's happened hey can you give me the what's the answer to question eight I'm texting you oh it's such and such oh okay teachers got their head here because they're trying to teach I'm not I can't keep my eye on 20 students to see if they're cheating each other less
059reported stress among students which is to me that's key that is key there's less stress that we're putting on our students but we get to push backs there's always going to be push backs this is not perfect when a parent or student asked why a policy was changed uh we've just got to stand firm on it hey this is this is what's best for our kids it may not be popular at the time but is what is best for our kids that's what we're supposed to be here for uh they when parents student State they need to have contact 247 we've got these helicopter parents and maybe you are one I don't know but I that adds so much more anxiety on kids when they're when they are with their parents 24/7 when you when
060they have that 7-h hour break away from their parents it gives them such an independence that they really need to have because once they get out of high school they're not going to have that there so the kids really like that that their parents cannot text them all day long I've talked to so many high schoolers that said said that's the best part of it I can go into that room I can go into that school and I don't have to anybody bother me for the next 7 hours safety um emergency situations this is where it's key to get Sheriff's Department your sro's all the people that are the stakeholders in this part because what it shows that students use the cell phone during Untold emergencies can distract their attention so we're already distracted enough
061so all of our teachers we put in place we've give them safety protocols if something happens God forbid something happens to our school we our teachers have been trained to what to do right if I'm on my phone trying to call my mom and you're trying to tell me what where I need to be I'm over here trying to talk to somebody and tell them what's going on I'm not being able to listen to the instructions to get where I need to be also cell phone can be in distraction because if what if it goes off and there's a shooter in here well that's going to alert the shooter that somebody's in there that's going to alert the perpetrator that hey I heard a noise going off there's somebody there and also what it does
062is it ties up our emergency lines that happened in in certain situations where the emergency Personnel could not get through because the the cell phone chatter was so much on the lines on the emergency lines they could not get through to who they needed to in emergency situations it's happened and you know you go to a ball game or something like a professional game you can't use their internet or you can't sometimes you can't use your phone because there's so much tied down on that so if you've got a thousand students trying to use the phone to call their parents at the same time and then you're going to have a thousand parents trying to get on campus at the same time it leads to emergency nightmare for the people that are trained to handle
063these situations so those are the things that is really key to get SRO is your Sheriff's Department I promise you they will be here at your meeting they came to our meetings they stood behind us our General Sessions Judge who does our juvenile court they stand behind us actually got a letter he was on my desk last night at a board meeting and he said I want to additionally thank you talked about school board appreciation he said I want to additionally thank you for the no cell phone policy it has significantly reduced the number of juvenile court petitions in the court so far this year so thanks for spearhead that effort spearheading that effort so that's from Judge Moore uh this is not just about schools this is about our whole Community this is about
064everybody and we got stakeholders all around uh so it's important to get that information out for us uh and again it's it's it's been great for us there's still people that still have a lot of parents are you know especially when something happens you know hey I need to get a hold of my kid but what we've done we we've made we've got it through our office staff hey if something goes on if our coaches has you know it's one of those what if ball practice has been canceled well it's up to us we put monitors up in in different spots in our uh School in our high school that says hey basketball PR has been canceled so our kids when they're walking through these common areas hey that board says this is we don't
065need to have a text alert or app alert come out you know they can look at that and if most of us you know all of our classrooms still have telephones in them emergency situations we can get a hold of a kid somewhere in school uh especially in our elementary schools uh there there's ways of getting hold of an emergency situation if if you know if a parent needs to really get a hold of a kid we've done it for years and years without cell phones we can still do it today I said this to our members throughout this whole process and I still believe this is true and I believe this for me as a Schoolboard member it is our job to make sure our students are provided the best environment for learning there's
066a lot of things that school board members we cannot do we can't control a lot of things we can control policy though and we can provide the best environment for learning for our kids that is our job let our teachers teach let our administrators do their job but we can we can help here we can help them we can be uh joint partners with them and we can do this and again it is worked wonders in waren County uh again you talked about uh sepii and the house bill that's coming up pretty soon he's actually reached out to me uh he called me I know a couple weeks ago and asked me if I'd be willing to come testify on at the general assembly uh on this beh on his behalf for this cell phone
067bill again when you when you start going through what happened in Antioch Covenant that kind of puts a bad lot on these things but you know I told him sure we'll come up and talk about it I've talked you know I talked at the technology conference in Chattanooga I'm going to be speaking at a uh superintendent or principal's meeting in smrna here a couple of weeks I think think about this um even if you guys were at the tsba if you're especially if you're a legislative um Lea's on it or in the legislative part and it was a Hot Topic it was debated and even tsba said they're they're not they're not for this they're not pushing for this so you know there's both sides of it I understand both sides of it I'm just
068saying what it done and how it's worked in waren county has worked very well and uh and I'm proud of it and I think we we're doing a good job is it perfect no are there going to be push backs yes but at the end of today it's what's best for our students and we're already seeing those things and if our if if our kids are more in school they're more engaged we don't have data yet that shows our test scores are improved but in other areas where they have we found a drastic rise in test scores and all of our critics in public school are saying that that's what they're going to grade us on right I talked to some guys today we were we actually passed a resolution last night about uh about
069the vvill Warren County but that's what we're hold accountable for these test School this test score so if and if we can provide some kind of reason to say hey look we're working on these things it has to improve our kids education if we to remove these distractions out of out of the classroom has to improve our teacher morale we have better teachers with better morale they're going to be better teachers and are going to teach better so that might be all I have that's all I got and I'll answer any questions if anybody has any to the best I can anyways so questions anybody I have a question yes sir what uh I know that this policy is toward the students do you have anything for the teachers as far is and I missed
070that part and I'm glad you mentioned that we did we went I pulled our staff policy out our and tightened it up too and I believe it was went [Music] by maybe in Williamson County I there was a there was a school district that we went through some of their policies and I looked at and I like that we didn't take the cell phones from our from our teachers because we felt like that was a need but they're not allowed to be on their private social media accounts during the school hours they will be reprimanded if they're caught on their social media apps during school hours unless they have unless they're on the at high school and they're part of the social media team on High School uh they are not allowed to engage with
071a student of any sort either being a friend or follow on social media unless it's a family member that was one we had in some of the younger grades that was a little bit of push back had some didn't like that and I understand you we kind of get wrapped up with our kids and their friends and and I have my daughter's friends try to add me on these things and I tell you know it's not it's not my job to be your friend you know I'm not so we we did push back on that and and made sure our administrator say hey if your teachers are caught doing these things it's up to you we're holding you accountable if we come in and see you know come in and see that our teachers are
072posting stuff on social media during school hours then hey you're going to be they're going to have to be reprimanded for that and we we stricted the policy on on on that too I think after the second offense if they get caught they automatically get uh one day suspension without pay and then it it the next one just a week without pay and then then you're then you're in trouble big time after that and I have those policies and I can send them send them out to you guys of how we done that both of these policies and how they how they read I me we our our phone policy would just completely cut it out and started all over with it but one thing I'm sorry where is hp13 in the process uh I'm
073not for sure it's gotten some you know some mix mix reviews so I think he's really trying to push it I think they've got some momentum uh I've not like said I've not talked to them in a few weeks and I'm not really I think through the special sessions they kind of pushed everything off but he did say it' probably be end of February before before they'd be really pushing on this so you know and and other states were starting to do your St you know Virginia's done it Arkansas is doing it several States doing this and this is not really as strict as ours it's just saying that every District should have some sort of policy in place and I think most of them do it just depends on how strict you want it
074and from our research and everything that we've done the bell-to-bell policy is the best because it's not going to do any good if you just say you can have it sometimes sometimes you can't kids are going to Abend the rules and they're going to you know they're going to do their thing Chris one of the things you had talked about earlier with the men you had talked about you got uh put social media to the so the parents could be communicated with when if case something was to happen right you might touch on that you talking about social media for talking about our teachers reaching out to the parents or right right during during school hours and Y you hired a a media person we hired a communications director um that kind of keeps all
075that in place so if something happens pushing that all that stuff out on social media on our accounts on our district accounts and all that as soon as we possibly can to get information out of school closings or you know school's got a gas leak or a water pipe this you know so we really amped that up as far as getting and this happened a couple two years ago I think at leadership we went into one of the break from Arlington Special School District they where they and they had a presentation at the main conference this year yeah um and that's really what got us focused on having a communications director because our our director was our communications director on top of all the other things he was doing so that kind of helped him
076out on that and and let him focus a little more so that you know we do push those out as fast as we can to our media to social media to everybody that's that needs to be contacted thank yes ma'am when you did your survey I'm really kind of surprised at the number of teachers who weren't for it did you as a oh when you did your survey I'm really surprised at the number of teachers that were opposed did you ask those teachers do you have a student in the school because that have affect well we didn't really this was kind of anonymous so we really didn't um know which ones or what uh and who did have kids and who didn't and I think it was just this was before this was just at
077the early stages of it so I think they were just didn't realize the problem was as big as it was you know and some of them some of them probably liked it because it helped them out hey we've got 15 minutes left in class I don't have to teach anymore I can just let them let them do something else and then this year we actually went back to traditional block schedule so that made our classroom times a lot longer under structural times longer uh but the retention it seems like that the kids are getting the information is seems to be and our kids are saying they feel like their classes are shorter that's one of the things the kids are saying and our classes are longer than they've ever been because we've met traditional block
078schedule and they're thinking that their classes are shorter just because they're so much more engaged in in the activities and stuff so but yeah I I think the teachers at the beginning were just you know they didn't know they they wasn't really you know there was maybe on that list of the few that come to me and said hey we've really got a problem here yes sir Chris I appreciate your your service and your concerns and you're sharing this and presenting this to us and uh we've got to listen to our teachers absolutely we've got to listen to our teachers and support them and I know there'd be some parents that would push back on this I get that they are uh I've got a granddaughter that's in a senior at waren County High School
079and this has taken over her life m this has become her God yeah and U anyway when she would come see us in the spring or on weekends whatever she'd come and she'd get get in a room or whatever and she'd be on that thing and would say to her let's talk and it's just like trying to but anyway it's become her it's it's it's really impacting her life and I cannot imagine the emotional trauma and damage this is doing to our students and think about how it will impact them now but what about their lives five and 10 and 20 years from now longterm effect the impact the long-term impact this will have on their lives and their whatever and the stress is putting on our teachers it's just not fair to our teachers
080right and I'm I'm very much in support and I'm going to suggest we may go ahead and refer this to our policy committee and start reviewing that and and amending and adopting something very similar to what Warren County or some of the other Cy said I'm very much support of that thank you for your service and again there's you know we can't do we can't take care of what things happen outside of our school hours but we can we do have a choice we do have the voice inside of what goes on inside of our schools and you know what happens at 3:00 in the afternoon when they get home hopefully what we were doing will will learn they will learn from this it's like you know I don't really need that like I said
081when you go to our basketball games you see kids now that are just running all over the place back and forth and back and forth and four or five kids strung together and they're not just sitting there on their phones and it's it's it's really a different culture out there in just a short amount of time so can you share your oh go ahead and our granddaughter we haven't seen her since March okay she's come over all the time but now she just kind of we're losing our this generation of kids we're really just losing them in general and you know I've been a small business owner for 20 something years and I know when I hire people that are out of high school and and these things it's just it's not even hardly human
082because they have no social cues whatsoever they can't interact with each other people that are around all day long they can't even interact with them without having that phone in their hand mhm we lead to listen to our teachers and I strongly support our teachers and what's I would suggest even a simple Serv grab a few teachers and do what I told them hey write all that down let let them and then show that when you show that picture when you show these pictures of what's going on in our classrooms like this is this is not something we pulled off the internet this is not get back to it this is not something we pulled off the internet this come out of Warren County High School you this come out of a history class this
083come out of a biology class this come out of a shop class this come out of I mean I didn't just take certain I mean I I went through the ones that I knew hey will you do this for me and then when you show this to people and they're like 15 minutes a class this is what we're this is what our teachers are dealing with that's what really got Mye open to it and then once you start looking at the data and when you start seeing the research that's been put into the This and like I said the mental mental aspects of this to our kids it's we owe it to them thank you can can you share your policy with us I will I'll send it to you yeah that would be good
084so we can kind of refer to our I'll send that and our staff policy that we revise to yeah although I suspect we're probably going to want to look at what how the legislation shakes out and and again I think that legislation is just going to be a broad yeah it's not going to be anything hard it's going to kind of leave it up to us to make our own you know we may want to start looking at that right away yeah so yeah you can share that I sure will yeah I'll send it out to everybody yes ma'am how important was the background stuff that you did for this to be a successful program getting with your judge getting with your SRO officers I think getting all the stakeholders in our community together is
085key because again the parents are going to be the last people on board for the most part now some parents were Overjoyed with this but there's going to be those and there's still some that push back on it but once you start seeing Community leaders that are trying to come together not just not just in this board they're not looking at all that school board just trying to you know impose their will on you know they don't understand you know we do understand again we've got kids we've got grandkids we've got people that we know that's in these school systems I mean you know four of our six board members have kids in Mor County Schools so I we have we have you know it's not only affecting you know it's affecting my family too
086so you know uh but it is important I feel like it was key to getting judge Moore out and it you know it was something key for him uh to get to get to these kids I mean when you see the you know you look at your uh Court advocate for your your kids I don't know if you've got Costa here or something but you look at some of these kids that they don't have parents at home they don't have people that's that's helping them they don't have people that's leading them and they're it's just they're in and out of trouble all the time and they're going through the court system they don't have anybody on their side and when you know when you start seeing that and you start seeing these are the things
087we're star to look at when you start seeing discipline issues when you start looking at what goes on in a School shooters mind what goes on in these kids that are why are kids going to ahead and send them to Alternative School it's not because they have parents at home that are really got you know got their back it's because they don't have anybody and it's up to us to but again like I said the SRO is your Sheriff's Department I promise you they're right on with us any other questions I just this doesn't have anything to do with this I was just interesting if you would share your resolution on vouchers did y'all did you say we pass that we we did not support this voucher bill that's going so you did it as
088a board we did it as a board thank you we sure did we're six member board and it was 60 last night and we talked about it and you know we we we discussed it in length last night at our meeting and like I said I've talked to people interviewed with radio station this morning and you know hey it's there on air if you want to look at it and see where we all stand and how we feel about it you know it's not that we're against vouchers or competition it's this bill just I think it was the way to go so and hopefully our state senator says he's against it and he's going to vote against it we'll see thank you for this presentation thank you guys thanks thanks for having me all right
089and I would say if I may Mr chairman as we're wrapping up I want to thank Mr M uh Mr West Morland and his team for what they do with about 110 people under his oversight and we'll never know some of the issues and the challenges and the concerns and the the situations that some of his team has to encounter every day with mental health issues and whatever and and this no doubt is contributing to a lot of that BR your counselors and school counselers to are huge to to give you some feedback because they are on the front lines of these a lot of these issues you know so just see as many people in the community as possible I promise you once you start getting this information out they're going to be they'll
090be in here they'll say we're behind you Jackie was involved with it too with it Jackie comes to those safety we have and we're still doing we still rotate schools we do a couple of year and just talk to the talking talking about Jackie mthi the sheriff up there he's really involved in it too so we get Chad involved and so you know questions just feel free to shoot me an email and get app Miss Matthews is going to lead the discussion on teacher appreciation program am I next you your next you're on the spotlight is you're okay all right so um I guess a lot of times uh as board members sometimes we aren't faced with things that are all that fun or more work than we thought but I feel like this is
091something that we can put a positive spin on this is one of the more more fun things that we can talk about um but when I was at the convention when we were all at the convention uh in November um there was I don't remember who the speaker was but they were talking about ways to motivate teachers staff employees and they uh brought up doing an employee Spotlight type program where we recognize our teachers for not just teachers but in my opinion it should go beyond teachers it should go classified and non non-classified um but just uh honor them and recognize them um from time to time there's a whole lot that could go into it you could make it probably as complicated or as easy as we wanted to but um I just want
092uh your ideas um I have some ideas and I would love to hear what you guys have in mind for for recognizing our teachers and showing them that we really appreciate them and um not just our teachers but like I said our uh our AIDS our transportation department our food service workers um our office Personnel our custodians people that really make the wheels turn uh don't need to be overlooked uh and so there's s you know unlimited ways it could be structured um some of the questions I have you know how you know would you want to break it up in grade level K through five 6 through 8 9 through 12 I'm open to anything okay um uh how you know what would the how would you select who was recognized based on what
093criteria um who would select what kind of input um would we want to get I even thought it might be good if we could get a parents input um I know as a parent raising my daughter through she's in eighth now um I have tried to along the way when I feel like a teacher has gone above and beyond be for her or any group of students make a point to reach out and tell them how much you appreciate it um and it means a lot it means a lot to to teacher an aid and office worker somebody checked your student in they were super kind and you know it's just if we can if we can reach our employees on a positive note I think it would be really good for entire system and
094our community as a whole so I just want y'all's ideas on how you think we could structure it um how many you know we would want to recognize at a time like I like I said I think you know if it were up to me uh it would be recognizing both a classified and a non-classified employee each uh grade grade like K through five 6 through eight 9 through 12 we can do it however you guys want to do it I'm I don't care um is it something that we would want to even reach out to local businesses to sort of sponsor like a bank you know I don't know that there needs to be any actual Prize or gift you know a lot of times that really doesn't mean a lot it's more of
095just being recognized and being feeling appreciated um um but all of those things we can we can collaborate together and figure out what is best um obviously we don't want to probably spend a lot of money or a whole lot of time but Tom I think you and I talked about maybe a quarterly luncheon for those who are recognized and letting them know that we appreciate them doesn't have to be anything fancy could just be like the lunch we did yesterday or pizza whatever just to get those employees that we're recognizing that quarter or that semester however often you want to do it together and let them know that they are appreciated that we do recognize their efforts um we got a lot of teachers who definitely do go above and beyond and this is
096more like we get a lot of complaints but I would love to see us spend that in a positive POS Direction and show appreciation and recognition so Mr Shores you had some uh some experience with that in the past I think uh Mr Henley had a program something you mention a former board member Mr Henley did that for several years he did a spotlight on uh employees and and that was once a week uh that it was actually he made a uh I don't know who I'm assuming he did it he made a um certificate sent it out by email to everybody in the everybody all all emails so everybody got to see it and it recognized the employee for the week cool I like that so how how long would you take if if
097we all kind of threw things together to maybe compile a list and and where we can then discuss it in the future work session and then basically approve it at a board meeting how long do you think that would take to do really have no idea probably just depend on how many ideas how much input we get so I'm soliciting all of you for ideas I'll help throw it together if somebody else wants to take it that's okay too I just wanted to bring it up and get the ball rolling and so that we can and you know if we don't want to you know like you said it get on a an agenda if we don't want to start it till next school year yeah you know cuz we got a lot going on
098yeah we um and we can decide you know is it weekly is it monthly is it quarterly you know who decides and how is it decided and there's a lot that could go into it like I said we don't probably need to make it more complicated than it is but some of the things that that I I took a picture of this whenever we was down there one of the things is the monthly they have the monthly employee Spotlight this is some of the ways to feel valid and supported and heard uh uh that was the guy that was the spokesperson for tsba wasn't it yeah yes and it was a spot the monthly Spotlight choose an administrative team uh supported by a local bank $100 crash cash reward publicly celebrated quarterly lunch celebrations uh
099hosted by uh funded and by the district uh ended quarterly even the superintendent birthday messages yes I one of them and the superintendent leadership Roundtable MH mixed and celebrated you know classified uh you know there just there's so many I took a picture of that because I I thought about the same thing too but there's so many things on here uh social media shoutouts stories of employees and their students drive and District newsletters just a few things yeah I remember that slide I took notes on it so yeah all those are wonderful ideas so you guys just you know let us know I agree that that's something that we should do and because and I do think that the criteria will be very important because there's a lot of employees and teachers classified or non-classified
100employees that do an excellent job day in and day out and never get recognized they don't want to be recognized and I can think of two or three teachers during my tenure up here they were excellent never got recognized they didn't want to be but when I think of of excellence in teaching I think of those people yeah and they're not the ones that's going to write up an application to be teacher of the year or what they're not going to push themselves out there they're in the classroom working with those kids and and hopefully that's the way we can recognize some of those type employees that are not you know recognizing themselves they're wonderful even if it's just a showing up one day just pick a day and show up like Publishers Clearing House
101balloons and cl make a big deal so that all the kids see and the rest of the staff see that makes you feel good is an adult and have recognition like that something simple even right it doesn't have to be that complicated really good idea H although I'd like to see teachers recognized you know and then classified employees recognized kind of separately so that yeah so that everybody gets absolutely yeah so you're not throwing them all in yeah you know so yeah our classified employees are critically critically important to this system in this County yes and we need honor them I totally agree absolutely whether you do a weekly or monthly yeah you have one fore yeah so that's yeah so so I guess but you know maybe we can all get our ideas and
102and run them through Holly and you can kind of pull them together and when you feel like you're ready then then you know we can get you back on a work session agenda and we can you know start working on putting together the program because it's certainly a worthwhile program I think so like you said maybe start next year or right because we have much on our plight exactly but but start working on the'll be effective yeah we can call this the Holly show I don't know about that Hol PR you know Freda said something that I think we have to recognize she said I worked in a system with three teachers that were excellent and never noticed I think that those within the system those who were within the classified in a certain field
103they know who those people are yeah so it could be that they pick them out themselves and then we get to to honor them it's not picked out by the director it's not picked out by the principal yeah those in the trenches with them say this is an excellent person I agree with that I think one of the things Mr Henley had done at the time was you could nominate somebody uh make a nomination to him that you want to nominate to get the spotlight of the week and that's one of the ways he looked at it but mhm that's just an idea and like I said parental and you know if there's a parent out there you know we want to pull parents in more anyway and so if there's a parent out there
104that knows that their child got you know a teacher went above and beyond uh and they're really you know impressed by something email us let us know y so we want to know all those good things we get a lot of complaints but we want to know the good too because there's a lot of good that's really a good point because I think one of the things we heard during some of these talks we had yesterday was that the parents didn't feel like they were involved enough we really want to change that we want to change that definitely for all the folks out there in YouTube land we're gonna work on it that's right so thank you very much all right is that thank you ollie any more questions or comments for Holly so all
105right then uh next up we have uh Jennifer is going to she's wants to talk about substitute teacher policy and I believe there's uh the handbook for substitute teachers in your packet so uh you're on all right so I'm pretty passionate about this particular subject and you will understand why when I'm finished so don't worry about me when I turn bright red I'm going to be okay let me climb up on this soap box here we will start okay so the first thing I want to do is I highlighted some of my favorite parts of our handy dandy substitute handbook here I'm went to go over those and then I promise I do have a point and we will get to it so one of the roles of a substitute teacher they need to be
106very flexible creative and competent something that they should do is be favorably received by pupils and they should have informal evaluations by School administration substitute teachers who performed below a level considered acceptable will be removed from the substitute list remember that substitute teachers are representatives of the entire Coffee County School System so they need to be on top of their game substitute teachers should always maintain a professional attitude towards work and resp responsibilities it is imperative that all employees of the Coffee County School System project an appropriate professional image for the students and Community each employee will show a high degree of respect for the standards of decency cleanliness and style generally accepted by the school and Community substitute teachers are employees of the director of schools and work under the direction of the school
107principal they should not get into personal conversations with the students they should follow all school and classroom rules they should be positive and pleasant they should never use sarcasm treat each child the way you would want your own child treated treat all students with respect and dignity be fair and consistent friendly and firm leave a good impression with other teachers Administration and students great substitutes view themselves as professionals they use positive reinforcement strategies they make it a priority to develop a classroom climate which encourages interaction and cooperation they are respectful to students and they are a positive role model all last semester beginning in the first week of school I have been getting emails from upset parents about substitutes many of these complaints were about one substitute in particular so much so that naming names
108I'm not naming names don't worry just much so much so that I became very familiar with this man because I heard about him so often I heard about him so often that I actually warned warned my own children if you are around this man be on your best behavior and watch out I encourage these parents to reach out to their principals to the director of schools to anybody because there's only so much I can do as a school board member a lot of these parents feared repercussions they feared that their child would be singled out and I understand that completely I'm not like that I have a big loud m my mouth so whenever my own child had an interaction with this substitute I was loud about it and I've continue to be loud about
109it and nothing has been done about it because we don't have a policy in place to easily get rid of substitutes that don't deserve to be there there are I'll pass this around I just wrote it down there are some aate law that we could adopt you want to read that into our policies our current policy is pretty simple and it's not there are not certain things listed mess up here and you're out like we need more specific rules for these substitutes um our says on an annual basis the director of schools with input from the principal shall determine which substitute teachers performed at an acceptable level substitute teachers who perform below an acceptable level shall not be reemployed all substitutes be responsible for providing correct addresses that doesn't really apply to this but that's
110it that's all it says so there's no clear line on when to get rid of someone so in October my child had an interaction that was not okay with this substitute I followed the chain of command I did what I was supposed to do I also emailed the school board you all know about this already I emailed the director of school schools and in Dr Lawson's defense he left the next day so he did not have a chance to take care of it and then Dr pal immediately was dropped in the middle of this big mess sorry about that but there's been no resolution this man who was committed so many offenses is still in the classroom but he's been reprimanded to where he can't be alone with students we have a substitute who is
111not allowed to be alone with students but he's still there in a classroom there are parents who will not allow their child to be in this man's presence and we're sending those kids to a different class instead of getting rid of this substitute and he's not the only one there are so many wonderful amazing people that should have been teachers that are employed by us as substitutes right now but there are some horrible terrible role models that are out there with our kids they're scaring them they're being aggressive they're calling them names they're breaking Chromebooks when they get mad and we're letting them stay in our classrooms I just can't express I don't have the words to express how ridiculous I think it is that we're not just letting them go when they're terrible i've
112been told that substitutes are hard to come by so we give them Grace I don't give Grace like that I don't know how y'all feel about it but I think something needs to be done one of the slides we just looked at said as school board members it is our job to make sure our students are provided the best best environment for learning as possible and we are not doing any favors to anyone by keeping people that don't deserve the privilege of being in our schools in our schools and I would I would just add that that according to TCA 49-2 d203 which defines the duties of a school board paragraph 14 does allow the board to make policy concerning substitute teachers so I think that we should do it we should really think about
113it and give some guidelines on what to do when this happens I totally agree I support that thank you for listening thank you I have a question if teachers are are employed at will wouldn't substitute teachers be employed at will they are but I believe it's up to the principal to dismiss them or just not call them back but we are still calling them back question no I'm just asking yes sub don't sign a contract with us they are not they are not employes only exactly but when we're calling them every single day even when they have committed offenses yeah I'm just ask I'm just asking will yeah exactly but the problem is right we're calling them back we're not calling it breaches we're calling them back because we so desperately I've been told need
114them that it doesn't matter who they are how they're acting we need them anyway so we're putting ourselves at risk for lawsuits yes we are I'm going to disagree on that um whenever somebody contacts myself or Dr pal or or a principal about a situation no matter if it's a substitute if it's a teacher if it's an aid classified worker it's going to be checked into uh if disciplinary actions need to be taken those are going to be taken is going to be handled uh everything that is turned into a principle or us does not and and I can tell you there's several times you're going to get a call saying they need to be fired they need to be gone and and the job that we have as administrators is to check into the
115situation to investigate it and then to make a judgment on what we need to do at that time um and and it's taken care of it's done now am I saying that every time that decision ision is made that the parents going to be happy with the decision no they w't fired uh they want them gone they want them out they want them it's automatic but that that's not always the case we have to set we we have to check into it we we do so and then we make a judgment call and what needs to be done disciplinary actions need to be taken place and so forth and uh and and that's what's What's Done Dr pal would you I mean is there anything that you would want to add with that I mean
116I'd like to add before he answers I'd like to add that I do believe that school board in session did send down a recommendation for an investigation about two different matters including one of these that no one including the parents has heard a word about no answer no discussion no investigation or checking out or whatever to my knowledge there's no information been done and I'm not so I guess was there an invest did you do what the board said in October okay I I think I remember one with that and and I remember that was when Dr Lawson was uh being dismissed and it was said during that meeting for the new director yes interim director to take that and and I don't want to speak for for Dr pal I do know that Dr
117pal has worked on that uh and but I'm not going to talk well I and I'm just saying that because you know you made it quite clear that the moment you get something like that it's fully evaded fully investigated you know if action needs to be taken actions taken and I will I will even go far enough we're four months past that exactly and in the situation that you're talking about the one that was actually brought up and the decision and what was discussed at that time like I said that was that's for Dr pal I do know that Dr pal has worked on that he's going to speak for himself on that I don't speak for Dr pal um but I I can tell you that and I'm not going to get into the
118the specifics of it but I did receive a email from uh Miss hodj and Dr loss guy at the same time and I don't care to say I as soon as I got it I went over to Dr L and said we got to check into this because it sounded bad and he said well I'm I'm gonna get started on that he started it and then y'all know what happened and I contacted Miss and I said Dr LW is no longer here I'm going to take this and and investigate it I did that I took care of it the way I felt like it needed to be handled as an administrator and handled the situation and do I think that Miss peacock H she she'll have to speak for it and apparently she is not
119approve of the way I handled it but I did handle it it was taken care of uh I've explained that to Dr pal he's aware of my my position and the way we went about it and then he's he's handled the other situation were you included on the emails uh I believe three days three or four days ago coming back in from the same complaintant no I let me just interpose here is i i before this meeting I had a a discussion with uh with Dr Powell and he is going to send out a confidential email to the because we do have a Clos loop from that resolution we had in the October meeting he is going to send out a confidential email to the board members explaining what the situation is and that because
120because it's a Personnel matter that right it it requires you know confidentiality but yeah I don't I don't necessarily need to know the specifics but we keep getting emails and keep getting notifications of issues and it's like nothing it's but hopefully there is something it's yeah we talked about it it is a loop needs to be closed and and so he's going to send out an email if we have any discussion after that then you know we can go from there but but you will be receiving something on that so we talk thank you Mr B my question I'm sorry go my question is I think the situation that I'm in particularly talking about my personal one let alone all the other ones was very serious so I guess I'm asking what are your guidelines
121into stopping the calling back of someone because if you can tell a child he's going to be your human shield if there is really a shooter and you can keep your substitute job how much worse does it have to get before you aren't called back anymore to me that is very serious and yes it was my own child but if it were any of your children I would be just as mad that's not okay and it wasn't just my kid other people said so and nothing has been done about it okay I want to respond to that once again you investigate as an administrator you check it out it doesn't make any difference if a sub substitute teacher Aid any classified worker anybody Works in our system you check into it you get one side
122of what you're hearing you know what that side is it's going to be skewed to the side of what you're hearing after you investigate it you make a decision from it you move on and that's where I went with it and and I will tell you that it was handled it was in investigated and it was handled the way it was felt like it needed to be handled and that that's that's any situation with any educator student um any employee you you you investigate and you you take care of the situation uh our our teachers deal with it on a regular basis they have to make judgment calls teachers do your your principes do we do and that's after the investigation but do you have a set line that you do not cross and we're
123not calling you back or is it just personal opinion if and this has been told to our principles they are very aware of it I have actually taken these actions as a administrator of a building and that is a uh uh substitute doing something that I felt was inappropriate that was not appropriate for our students and I I escorted them to the door said we will not be calling you back and that was the end of it uh then the the calls made to the central office uh was made to basically remove them from the list and they are no longer called so yes there are limitations on the second information that uh has come up I have investigated that uh circumstances Beyond My Control uh had to postpone it for a period of time
124it has been reinvestigated I've talked with the principal and the person that was involved in it um I have not written a report up yet I have the information from that and uh that will be written up and given to those that uh were involved in it but it has been a reinvestigation ated I I have a question about that though you said that the the uh person that we're referring to is not allowed to be around children that's what I was told by on their own how you you're the only one that can explain that I don't I only know what you've told me that he has to have Supervision in the class probably don't need to get into discussions that deep on that kind of matter here I mean I'm just quite frankly
125and that's my only aggression towards this is I'm tired of hearing it I'm tired of getting emails from a parent concerned and nothing's being done when we're all adults we could do something about it and it's not just me and that's my only issue there have been if something has been done about it fine but it apparently not everybody's been made aware of the results yeah and they will be and they will be fine I don't need to know it I don't want to I've been speaking for everyone I've gotten emails from everyone who's upset they're being ignored by their principal and I'm being ignored as a school board member who knows who to talk to so I can't imagine what it feels like just to be one of them and they don't know who
126to call it's not fair it's not right for you to worry about who's around your kid you should feel like they're safe we we can't let things get to this point yes exactly I want clearcut policy on this and once again miss P colge did come and reported it as a parent not as a school board member yes it was investigated so it was not ignored and it was handled and a contact was made back to a parent to let them know that it was investigated and it was handled and I will stand up and say when our principles hear things they're investigating it they are checking into it as well I could not imagine a principal that is ignoring a parent that is turning in a a complaint now I can't I can't say
127that definitely but I couldn't imagine any of our principles ignoring a a complaint U I just couldn't I was told that substitutes are hard to come by so we'll let him know that wasn't very nice okay and I I heard one principal say that substitutes are hard to come by I will tell you substitutes are hard to come by I will not tell you and I could not imagine one of our principles saying substitutes are hard to come by so they're going to get away with anything they want to do we're going to keep them that's two different things there substitutes are hard to come by teachers are hard to come by but we're going to make sure we have people that are good for our kids I just I make the recommendation that we've
128heard about this we heard about both cases we were notified about it the 1st of September everyone was and here we are in January right the end of January going into February the next year and that is why we will be 11 if there's any you know please please y it it is it's something that was not resolved that that we you know made a to but it's you know but hopefully this will be you know it will something get the the email from Dr Powell and and if if it's not still resolved then we will and not just remain I'm not trying to make this personal I want everybody to be heard and I want it to be in place where everyone is safe and I don't like getting ugly up here y'all forgive
129me Mr Shores you I'm not mad at anybody I'm mad at the substitute and I want to I want to say one more thing because I and I told Miss Miss HJ this and I want to make sure we we keep referring to every once in a while the YouTube land if you have a problem and you've got you got somebody that's being treated wrong because of a adult you need to report it to your administrator you need to let the teacher know you need to let the administrator know so they can take care of it to be honest the only one this is the only one I've heard of heard from was Miss hod and I told her tell them to get in touch with their principal don't be afraid of retaliation you have
130to do this and put it out there in with a lot of these parents with from coaches all the way down to teachers or everything else they do not they don't want their kids to feel the repercussions of stuff and so they come to us right oh I'm sure I'm in trouble when I get home for everything I've said right now but sometimes you got to speak up and you are protecting your child when you speak up and I believe in this particular case she felt she had followed the chain of command and she didn't get satisfaction which is why it came before the board and and you know that's that's kind of the the story there in any situation similar to this even though whoever is doing the investigating may have done the reinvestigating
131they may have made a decision but that doesn't mean that everyone is going to be acceptable to what that decision was uh and that may be the situation that that I'm dealing with what I come back out with to those that are involved in it they may not agree with it but at least we did what we felt like was best they probably didn't agree that that was the best thing to do but nonetheless I think we have to consider that and and uh take that into consideration that that you're not going to please everyone regardless of what you do good bad or indifferent I want it to be investigated it should be and I think any complaint that comes to our principls uh that comes to the central office to myself or Mr Shores
132or any of the other supervisors that are in charge of certain programs I hope those things are investigated they should be uh if they're not we need to know that but just because it's investigated doesn't necessarily mean that everybody's going to be satisfied with what the results might or might not be you hope it is but it doesn't necessarily go that way thank you Jen for bringing that up thank you can I can I Jennifer thank you thank you thank you um I feel like we definitely need to make some policy changes some updates needs the policy is extremely vague um there needs to be some specific criteria on there um that we can fall back on that will allow us to take some action I personally received two complaints on this particular substitute myself
133I encourage those two parents to email Dr pal um explaining their concerns from what I know they did um I don't think they've heard back on it as maybe the investigation was going on um but this is not a tenear teacher if if I'm not mistaken is is it a matter of just not calling the person back I mean like how we have to protect our kids and how hard is it you know if if if this person is in question multiple times by multiple parents multiple students uh why are we continuing to make that call I know substitutes are hard to come by but we have to air on the side of caution when it comes to our kids in my opinion so definitely I think the policy needs to have updates uh and
134we need to listen to our parents I agree with what all of you're saying let me F this in as far as substitutes a concern there has not been to my information that I've received and that's no excuse for what's happened please understand that we haven't had the system hasn't had substitute training uh like they used to have it's Fallen by the wayside in all honesty um we blame everything on covid but from what I understand this is where it started from uh the person that was in charge of doing this in service for the teachers or for the subtitute teachers is no longer with the system and out of default no one has picked it up I have assigned one of our direct supervisors to be in charge of substitute teachers for the coming
135year they will have inservice as they've had in the past but we have failed to do that for the last couple of years is my understanding and that's a fault that we'll we'll take but it has been rectified in terms of someone being in charge of it and taking charge of substitute teaching service I know we used to bring them in at the first part of the Year usually a couple of times a year because you have substitute teachers are coming in every three or four days in some cases uh that they want to want to come in they want to leave they want to come back etc etc and we have failed in that situation of doing a a full-time staff development uh for those substitute teachers but that will be back again in
136the coming school year uh I would assume because a director's been been uh assigned to that task and we'll go back to that and hopefully and and you folks need to come up with some set policies because there it's just you you if you looked at the handbook I know you haven't had time to look at it I know Jennifer has because I've given her and we've looked at them and there's no set policies necessarily in there as far as ABCD so those things do need to be taken care of um and that's what we we're challenged with in the next couple of three months uh before school starts next year to have those policies in place and when that inservice takes place then those will be given to the substitute teachers here's what we
137expect you would think that they should know anyway but but that's not happening necessarily uh there have been substitutes dismissed not since I've been here but from what I understand from Mr Shores um but we we've fallen down on that situation to be honest with you we being the school system for the last couple of years it just got overlooked I guess I'm not sure I can't give an explanation for it I don't think anyone intentionally didn't do anything about it but uh it hasn't been on our radar but it is now will be and I'm assuming that the new director will have some guidance to you folks and to the uh supervisor that's been in charge of them to set policies set the book handbook up again redo that so that's where we are
138right now with it if I may add go ahead first I I appreciate what you're saying because that and and I know all of you saw in the news where they were saying that the substitute teachers there at Antioch had not gone through uh a program for safety or what to do in case of a shooter or anything like that so that definitely I appreciate you putting somebody on this because that needs to be a part of it also that every substitute teacher has in service on or or training on how to handle a emergency situation M Jones that's actually law that has I know it is law but they said that they hadn't they did not have it let I was going to explain for hours yeah uh by law we have to do
139that that is being done by each school it has be done by each individual school before a substitute goes into that school to you have documentation of it we do good at each because I know an Antioch didn't each principal has to have a u a meeting with that substitute and go over those before they're able to actually go into the classroom and start for the day so uh I mean that's been told to them regularly and what you have a form or something that's signed off by both of them they actually have documentation and the each school is using their own documentation but see each each school has specific things that they do and and they could be just a little different from one school to another on emergency plans and so forth that's
140the reason why each school has to do it and such as those emergency uh trainings you can't do them at one spot because it might be just a little different this school or a little different at this school so each principal has been directed that before a substitute starts subbing in their school that they have to go through this training with them and explain it before they even start so and they are to keep doation of that information Dr P maybe they could be part of the person that's over this to have some kind of uniform so that we're not you can say look this is when that happened and this is who signed off on it what we what we hope to do or what should be done is a fact fact that there
141should be something in the entire substitute teacher staff development in service whatever you might want to call it and then there's some general things that should take place at all schools and then as Mr sh said he and I had a conversation about this just pass this last week to be honest with you um that individual schools have different methods of doing things even though it may not because of their facility and what have you but I hope we'll get put in the it'll be put in the substitute teacher folder these are General things that you would do in the case of an emergency but your individual School principal needs to tell you if there's anything specific just to their particular school because everyone has different doors to go out of they have different uh
142places to go different uh signals and things for various and under uh uh things that may take place U drills and so forth those have changed as you may or may not know uh there's some safety things that are in the schools that are not necessarily known by everyone and they will not be known by everyone uh safety issues we have a meeting this week to talk about some issues like that it's a closed meeting because everyone doesn't need to know what happens uh in certain situations but we are directing that we are working toward that and that will be something that will hopefully be put in the general substitute teacher in service and then they will talk to individual principal about specifics for their particular school and U Jen and and Holly if you
143have specific recommendations you'd like to see put in policy then go ahead and send them to me and I'll get them out to the policy committee Mr SCH I mean I think it should be more common sense but apparently these people don't have that so you know when you refer to these people are you speaking to the administrators or the general the substit are I agree with you the ones that are just out there I haven't disputed the thing you said all night but if we want to change policy then then we need some recommendations that we can pass along to the policy Mr chairman one thing I'd like to add too is not to complicate or confuse the situation but part of me would suggest that we may want to look at our pay
144that we're paying our subs and increase it a little bit because I know sometimes like the old saying go sometimes you get what you pay for but anyway I thought I just a good point I just thought I toss that I will share this I'm not saying we need to do this but I know a sub teacher in state of Nebraska you don't want me to tell you what they're making understand I believe we increased substit we did a little bit we have twice we did a little bit but we may need to do it again I'm serious on that yeah because we we we got to take care of our people and and pay them a fair wage I understand but for their service we got a budgeting process going on we did increase
145pay for Subs I think it was uh two years ago so just want to advise to be careful with what we increase it to because sometimes those subs will make more than our own staff yeah so you got to so yeah you got to be careful how it affects the whole structure so so would that be you know recommendations on policy changes I'd be more than happy to get that out to the policy committee I would like policy I would like more clear guidelines I would like for only the best of people to be around our children yeah there something clear so we can get that to the I have one more thing um I think you know being a substitute is a very difficult position to be in I wouldn't personally want to try
146it um you know no matter what what we can pay and or what we can't it's probably not enough for uh the job they're doing so it is a difficult job maybe even a thankless job from time to time but um I I believe that we like I said we have to protect our kids and if we've got parents that are requesting their children be pulled when that substitute is filling in for their child's class you know kids are having to go sit in the office instead of staying in class because of one substitute you know I I just I think we can I think we should take some some action in that regard and like I said if a policy will enable us to do that a policy change let's get on it um
147but yeah the the substitutes do have a very difficult job and we appreciate them but also you know um if you're a principal or an assistant principal and you know that you've got substitutes in your building it might be a good idea to walk down the hall check on that sub substitute um check in with them do you need anything can I support you in any way because their job is difficult and uh they that substitute you know they're they're not formally trained in this area probably some of them may be certified teachers um but they're not in the school every day day in day out they may not know the teachers next to them um and I think you know as an administrator as a principal as an assistant principal as a guidance counselor
148walk down the hall and check on your substitutes are the kids giving them a hard time because they do uh they try to get by with more with a substitute I did we all probably did um so I think you know that our Administration could probably support and I'm not saying that doesn't happen that may happen I don't know but if we could just be more cognizant of I've got substitutes in the building they may feel out of place I want to go check in on them do you need anything Miss Matthews I agree with you and I think that our principal we'll we discuss this in our next principal meeting okay uh to check in those folks I know when I was principal back many moons ago which was a whole different ball game
149than what we have now um I would try to check on substitutes I would generally have the teacher that's next door to him in the building introduce them to them and say Miss Matthew is substituting today and this is Miss hodj she's a teacher if you need anything touch base with her Miss Hodge from time to time touch base with your sub yeah I don't know whether they do that or not but it's a very good yes thing to do I agree with that thank you all right so recommendations on policy changes we'll get it to the policy committee thank you and uh go from there so um and y'all forgive me for yelling at you no you're fun that was all right so next on our agenda is uh Miss yench is g to
150talk about Arts programs art programs okay why don't why don't we take a uh at Dr Powell's request probably mine too is to take a short break I the thing you passed out e e e all right uh we're ready to start again but but before we go I really wanted to uh talk about the the meetings we had yesterday and and really thank Melissa and Holly and and uh and Beth and and Freda for for helping get that set up I think it went really well and we had uh for folks who don't know we had about 40 people here uh at the noon meeting and I guess the administrator meeting was pretty jam-packed yes it Mr par yeah so so uh so we got some good responses and I think it was all
151in all good but but really uh thanking everybody to help set up and and uh how well the meetings went so all right Dr GR mentioned to me this morning talked with about something else that they had about 20 to 25 teachers at the um 3:30 meeting and I believe she said somewhere around 10 to 15 parents for the uh 7:00 or 6 o00 5:00 meeting so there wasn't a a large turnout for either one of those probably what we had up here for our three meetings was about uh more than half of what they had on the other two meetings all right of course I was was maned story so they had to yeah that's true that's true Bo had to be there so all right so we're ready to proceed here so our
152our next item on the agenda is uh Beth Y is going to talk about art programs and and when we talk about new programs or adding programs and um Miss melson is definitely going to be an integral part of the conversation with budget so thank thank you and Mr Cordell had to leave because he he was having some back issues okay so he gave his regrets but had to leave that work yeah Robert it won't work for you no excuse for you no no no all right um thank you I was an art teacher that was what I taught so it's a subject I'm passionate about like I see Robert with Athletics um I taught in Rutherford County and I taught middle school so I learned a lot from that one thing I did learn
153that we were taught in school um if kids don't believe they can do art by Middle School very few of them will ever try it because by middle school they're expecting to be able to see it look like whatever they try to draw or try to paint and if it doesn't happen then they just say I'm no good at Art and they give it up I'm passionate about getting art into our Elementary programs and I know that means Miss melson's probably going ah but the statistics for having art in your programs are pretty good I sent you out a paper I'm not going to sit here and read through it as a matter of fact it's late enough I'm going to keep this short um and I will be sending the school board more information
154about this but I want to show you this I'm G pass it around now you guys may not think that looks like much but this is a second grader he obviously our little Ryan Ryland could [Music] not write his own note like some of the first graders in here I had who could write very well well but the kid can do art and the fact that he sees that muscles and feet and hands and all these different parts are on the human body is pretty amazing because if students don't get this by the time they get to Middle School you will see them continue to draw stick figures and you'll see adults who say oh I never could draw and if you ask them to draw a human you know a body they'll give you
155a stick figure that's because you didn't catch them Robert at what age is important for kids to learn they can do athletics Middle School sixth seventh and eighth grade is a time period in which they're either going to continue to keep playing and keep participating or they usually give it up it's the same with art that's the that is the turning point right there that you either you either stick with it or you're done and when do they decide do they decide coming up through Elementary sports that they can be pretty good at it no it's usually the sixth seventh and eighth grade okay because your your Elementary your youth they call it leagues and stuff of that nature and things that's that's more of a Pastime to hopefully trigger that you're trying to trigger
156that through Elementary and the youth in the sixth seventh and eighth grade range to find out if you've triggered it to pursue and go forward or not well that's when you lose them in art which means that even more so and I'm don't get mad at me even more so than our athletic courses in our elementary schools our art programs are important we have a lot of kids out there like this and I don't know who Ryland is I don't know if he's a special needs child but my goodness if we have a special needs child who can succeed in something like art it's not fair not to catch those children it's not fair not to catch our future um Architects and our future graphic designers and all of those little ones by not having
157art in elementary school so that they can get some concept that they can do art and I always used to tell the kids who come in I said I can teach you to draw I can teach you to paint but if they'd already turned off their mind they couldn't do it I couldn't get them any further and so I'm going to continue to be passionate about getting art into our Elementary classrooms and I'm not just saying that the teachers they they try their best to incorporate art into the classrooms but my goodness they've got to teach reading and math and they're getting tested on those we need art teachers who have been trained to show these kids how to draw I mean we wouldn't throw a um an art teacher and to teach a math
158you know and expect our scores to be high so we can't expect our kids to be passionate and good about art even if they've got a gift if nobody body ever shows Ryland that he has a gift he'll never go anywhere with it and so I am very passionate I put together a few statistics I didn't actually realize that I was up tonight or I would have gotten a PowerPoint I would really gone on and on but they do find particularly with our low economic kids it'll art in itself will cause them to stay in school it'll cause them to be more involved in school their test stores go up uh they don't uh Miss as many days if they're very involved in their art so let me just encourage you to think about Rutherford
159has some really high scores for their school system I was looking them over they have art from kindergarten each School hires its own art teacher each Elementary School each middle school has an art teacher and it's just it's very important and it's worth coming up with the money April to see that these kids who are talented in this way get an opportunity to develop that talent I I was always the one picked last for um anything athletic they were like I had her last time you take her this time that was me but I had teacher in fifth grade who caught me doodling and she said come on up to the Blackboard gave me colored chalks and said create a mural about Christmas and it came out really good and so I knew from there
160that I could do it because I had a teacher who saw it and encouraged him in me and so please take the time to look over the few simple things that I managed to get together tonight on short notice although it was talk fault he told me a month ago and I'll be sending the school board out some more information it's something that will boost our scores well all I can say is that after all these years I finally found out why I can only draw stick fingers that's right I still can't color in the lines so I guess my question is is uh you know and for whoever can answer here is what kind of art program do we have now in the schools and what is the process to to do you know
161to do kind of what Beth is is visualizing here in the schools and and how would that work into the budget process and and those types of things we can right now we have a art in our Middle School we have a teacher that it's it's through the rotations and it's a itinerate related arts class um and then in the high school we have the art class as well uh uh Mr parsley could probably speak I know he can speak a whole lot more on document uh but our elementary it actually was looked at a couple times past couple years uh and and it's is is really budgeting is budgeting numbers was one of the main things that was was uh part of it that and and there was other other I hate to say
162it this way but other needs that end up uh admin and teachers felt like was was needed more uh but I won't like I like the idea of Art in Elementary School uh and there's things that needs to be explored and looked at uh as a Elementary principal for for 16 years uh one of the things you have to also try to figure out is when you add another class such as art uh which is and I agree with everything thing you're you're saying 100% but it also takes away a little bit from from the academics that because if you're going to put something else in it takes the place of something uh and there's so much time but but there's just ways you got to look at it and and I think it's a
163great I applaud for applaud you for for bringing it up and and looking at it because it is a a good thing our kids need and deserve I think too that of course budget is is a thing you have to look at uh unfortunately there's not a lot of art teachers out there you we have a difficult time trying to find art teachers for our middle school and our high school level but they are out there if you can if you can pull them in uh and I know like Mr sha said in elementary schools uh we used to have music library and physical education on a rotating basis and I think at some point in time we added an art person in there for a short period of time those were budgeted through Federal
164program title title uh nine which was it Kelvin it would been title n title um what's what the big title project I don't know it I doubt it's Title One title one yeah that was it those were all through Title One programs but there was I think one person in and when I in my situation we had six elementary schools and uh each of those teachers had three schools that they would serve on a rotating basis once sometimes once a week depending on how they fa sometimes twice a week I think y'all had that too maybe Mr Shores I'm not sure we we had yes we had to share a teacher which we've kind of moved away from that and and been able to move away from it uh so that we do have the
165more of the music and the PE and the library and so forth but U yeah it there's a way to do it it's just it takes the the effort and the work to do it and and finding the funding to pay for it and making it work and like you said uh being at the school level for for 16 years at at the elementary teachers are doing art it's not trained art it might be a little bit more artsy craftsy type things I don't know you if you're an art teacher you know what I'm talking about uh and there's a difference in a trained art teacher compared to the other but um but they are doing those type things I I can guarantee that yeah well I have to agree with Beth these kids are
166desperate to be creative I've been lucky enough to be asked to come do some guided paintings at both Deerfield and Hickerson over the past few years and these kids welcome me with open arms they know what I'm there for they are so excited they listen we create these beautiful things that they're proud of afterwards and they treat me like I am their very best friend in the world because I'm letting them paint some of them will be like I haven't painted since last time I saw you Miss Jen and they makes me sad they need to paint all the time and they're just so happy and they're so proud once they get to do this stuff so it is more important than we realize until you see them in the moment and what it means
167to them which sounds silly if you've never played with it yourself you know if you haven't ever really played with paint or paintbrushes yourself as a child you don't know how amazing it makes them feel maybe we could look at maybe possibly in the future one for for the whole Elementary and just rot them and and have at least an art class every couple three weeks at a school because I know as a for as a former Elementary School teacher a child is talented in different ways and and some of the kids that I had may not could do math as well or read as well but they could draw and they would bring me pictures that I'm thinking oh my gosh that is talent and and it and I've read through what it shows
168a lot of lower income kids uh uh kids that aren't meeting up to their potential or whatever they're really good in art and if we can concentrate on that we're going to save some of these kids in the future if we can just pull them in through ART it's almost like you have your athletic group that that are Excel with Athletics you have your academic group that Excel with with academics and you have your art group that that can Excel with their arts and that includes music as well uh because music is definitely an art um but definitely it anything that we could catch would be great and one of the things that we were looking at U was trying to do two for the system for the elementary so it's two one for three
169schools one in one for three then it I mean you started doing one for six you're talking about trying to get through the entire system they're never going they might see art one time that year right uh but if do it to it's more but benefit specify grade you know start out with specify grade level that you're going to off that's possibility and then you might could you know might could work it in that way to begin with and just see how it works everything Mr shes said was accurate we did talk about this last during the last budget um but there were other needs that were we felt like the principles and admin thought was more important um when you're talking about people um it's not just think about their just their salaries it's
170their benefits too so you can add 40% to a salary so we talk about six people at $70,000 that's a lot of money to get we need an art program I agree but we did talk about having having two maybe two that could move around to the schools and split their time um but when you just think about that in dollars like if you um want to talk about budget is a just just depends on what year you know what year they come in on and um where they're on the pay scale of what we pay them but you can figure like if you will look at that pay scale you can figure adding about 40% to their salary and that'll be like the total between benefits and their salary so just keep that in
171mind research grants or whatever and you know sometimes there's Fine Arts grants that aren't pursued because it doesn't affect academic programs and a lot of times those are overlooked so possibility we could do that to start with but if we bring teachers in I hate to release them when our grants run out so it would be a matter of seeing what benefit they add to our program and then making a way to hang on to it well and once I found this out through experience if you get a program going that is really good then uh parents don't want you to do without it nether you know we have that in excellence yeah so and also any program like this requires a champion to move it forward so we got it yeah here we go
172well ever since ever since I came into this County and found out we did not have art teachers in elementary that's been that's been 40 years and so I've wanted to Champion that since that was one of my hopes coming onto the school board was that I could Champion art and there are a lot of art teachers out there graduating from MTS you yeah teacher program and they're all going where am I going to get a job and so there are the teachers that you can begin to advertise through those programs and they would be delighted to know they could come out with a job I know in the past we've had and I think Mr paron shaking his head back there we've have we we've had some good art teachers at the high school
173and the middle school but they're not as plentiful as they as some areas are but I'm sure they're out there if you want to try to run them down but it has been a little bit difficult getting them I know and that was also another concern that we had when we worked through budget last year like where do we find an art teacher at this point in the because they are hard to they are hard to staff they're one of those positions that are really really hard to hire do we know if Manchester City schools have art and Elementary yeah I think Elementary don't they have a dedicated art teacher for each elementary school or do they share one don't put me on the spot here now it's a test I was thinking they had
174a dedicated art teacher at each school I think they do I think we do but I I couldn't sit here and tell you for sure that we did and I mean I hate to say it but that's one area City City's beating us yeah I want to recognize one one of them was Susie puger yes I thought so in College Street right Susie Lowry go to hitting facility just look in the door yeah so you got to do you know she painted kin's mural oh yeah yeah yeah she's since retired but there's there's some retired people out there that might like to come back on a part-time basis to to fill in I mean to to have a program coming up and that is what some of the schools do is they bring in a
175part-time art teacher um because there's a lot of the art teachers especially like you say when they get older they don't want to teach full-time but they still want to continue teaching and there's not many jobs that will allow you as a teacher to go part-time well I was glad to hear what what Miss peacock hjj said was she's been invited out to to actually do some some art things with the students at those two schools even so that they're reaching out some but different once again it's a little different than having a program yeah Jennifer's been modest I mean you drive down the four lane dur in Christmas and see all of her artwork so people don't realize what she does because my mama let me paint when I was a kid that's a
176huge thing we've got two Art majors on our Bor and we just don't we need to recognize them for what they really do because Jennifer is very very good well thank you very I would say that we could hire them but you can't board members can't work with in school system I would love to continue doing this and you don't have pain we could let her do an art expo on the FR window hey I feel like I'm doing that once a week invol scissors so it's probably too late to get something in the budget for this up or I think what would have to happen is the board would have to get it on like would have to approve the positions because they are they would be a new position for elementary so that
177would have to happen before I could start working in the budget right and when would you need to have information like that um I mean I would say before March so I can go ahead and start building it in so there's still time if y'all want to start for because I'm just starting to build a budget so we still have time to get those things in the board will have to approve approve those positions right and so Beth you're going to have to do some homework and work with Miss Nelson on that so that's that's what being a champion means yeah I think this is a great thing to Champion thanks for sure I think you'll probably have plenty of help too there's there's a little Ryland out there that's counting on it everybody [Laughter]
178exactly all right so that's thank you thank you thank you all right final item on the agenda is transportation of students and Mr and we have a guest speaker also and I think Mr Gilly might chime in too so take it away Mr all right giving everybody a a copy of of um kind of what I put together um on the basically the you know we've got policies and we've got regulations on Transportation of students on school buses but when it comes to you know transporting small groups of students in smaller Vehicles we don't really have anything on the books for that um and this was talking with the Mr Alex span he's the he's the one that's over student transportation with the Tennessee Department of Education and you know that when I first talked
179to him he' give me a list of um you know recommendations and you know that I'd brought up at the the board meeting and um since then you know I've talk talked to him and I've done some um looking at some schools that already got policies uh in place because this is really and truly this is a fairly newer problem that a lot of schools have run into and um a lot of schools are have purchased many Vans for this application um you know I mean why run a bus when you're transporting four kids you know number one we have an issue we don't have enough bus drivers as it is so you know you know you run into problems with with transporting the students where they need to you know if they got a
180um a skills event to go to if they've got you know sports or whatever you know but with this I mean I'll go I'll go through it what his recommendations were um was to create a specific policy governing the transportation of pupils um in vehicles by staff other than school buses um you know as far as the the staff drivers you know um course said they a driver's license um he recommended that they have a a medical statement you know from their doctor stating that you know that they're physically able to to drive um you know being drug tested and having their MVR pulled he said he recommends that you know the mvrs be pulled same as bus drivers you know um you know if they're going to be responsible you know transporting the students
181and then he said as far as the the vehicles of course by federal law we cannot use 15 passenger vans because they do not meet the safety requirements so the um which I'll get to that in a minute but the uh you know as far as the safety equipment in the vehicles they said you need a first aid kit um a fire extinguisher um and they said he recommends a camera system they said because that's going to protect not only the students that you're transporting but also going to protect the district as a whole um and then another item um by them being in a smaller vehicle of course the vehicle's got seat belts well if that vehicle is in an accident seat belts lock up you need a seat belt cutter of some sort
182in that vehicle you know so everybody can get out um I got on here you know ultimately the the cofa County Board of Education is responsible for the safety of any pupils being transported and vehicles owned by the coffa County Board of Education as a governing body we must ensure that all vehicles are equipped with the necessary safety equipment and all drivers must have the correct qualifications on the second page u i put together some I guess some policy points you know um any vehicle owned by the school district except for buses which may be used for student transportation for extracurricular activities the vehicle requirements maximum of nine passengers total including driver working seat belts for all passengers safety equipment and vehicles including first aid kit fire extinguisher seat belt cutter Etc camera system um
183and I know here's the thing that a lot of people's had a problem with you know we've already got cameras and buses um you know the the the camera system I know you know you got a monitoring fee and everything goes along with that but um you know since we're already doing it with the buses I don't see where you know we can't have the camera systems maintained by the transportation department that way they're all on they're all the same type of cameras all running the same system you know we're not wouldn't have to purchase other other systems um maintenance log on file for each vehicle um and speaking with uh Mr Skipper on the CTE Vehicles he said that uh once a month I believe that U you know um part of the CTE
184program you know they take care of all the maintenance on the vehicle they change the oil they they clean it they you know they have a list of items that they go through that they they do on the on the vehicles um you know and you know he's got you know a maintenance log on each of the vehicles um as far as driver requirements approved personnel only of course must be 21 years of age or older um MV MVR must be on file medical statement on file um you know as far as the requirements you know pulling the MVR will tell you any major infractions that they've had you know what their driving record is well you know you can you know as a board or you know as the the policy committee you know
185if wanted to they could go on and actually determine what constitutes major offenses that would prevent somebody from you know being able to be an approved driver um operation of the vehicle no cell phone usage while operating the vehicle of course that's state law I mean it got to have hands free but U maximum speed of vehicle will be posted speed limit for roads traveling um slower during inclement weather there again maximum spe speed limit is state law on that road I mean but um students to follow same policy as bus conduct um all passengers must wear their seat belts I mean that's U you know as far as the policy I've looked at several policies and I meant to make copies of the ones that I'd found but um I know one in particular
186um you know the their policy on this is about six pages long I mean they're very in depth of course about half of that is on on the driver requirements you know what they can and can't do and um you know what they must have and and whatnot um but but that's um you know I think as a school board this something that you know you know we need to we need to put in you know maybe get a policy on to um you know protect ourselves protect our kids protect our our staff that's driving the kids because like Mr span said said all you are you're he said you know it's not if it's when said you're one he said she said problem away and said you know that's going to be a major
187that's is going to be a major um blackout on the school system and he said that'll probably wind up in a lawsuit of some type you know always does so you know it's something that he highly recommends um and like he told me he said there's a lot of school systems that are starting to implement this policy if anybody's got any questions I'll be more than happy to try to answer what's our current policy on on this on this particular here there is no policy we got a policy on on the school buses we got a policy on private Vehicles yes okay but on this here there is no policy on transporting in school owned Vehicles other than buses use of use of school Vehicles other than buses there's no policy at of course this
188is a new program for us I know Mr parsley may want to address some issues with it and I agree there needs to be policy set up on it um one that I would I guess add to the situation uh in in operation the vehicle uh if if a driver is using the vehicle is he's charged with he or she with any kind of move in violation then they we should be prohibited from driving that vehicle for whatever period of time you want it may be a year it may be 6 months whatever the case me but I think that should be put in the policy too right well that's I mean to me that's where the policy committee comes up with with what you know what punishments or you know what based on their
189you know MVR report I know one of the school systems said that if a if a driver had a major um um major incident yeah uh and it was I think you know if they were speeding and it was 15 miles hour over the speed limit you know that they could not drive for 5 years yeah you know so I mean you know I mean it's all in how strict you want to go with it right this is this is a good start I think with it very good uh very good start uh couple questions I have I guess either for you or or for trop I'm sorry I didn't get your name I'm sorry the microphone yeah sorry give the man a [Laughter] microphone SE we're not going to question too much need say
190a couple of things or ask a couple of things this is for the general use of the of the policy committee coming up okay I'm sorry what was your name it's Lieutenant Jeff Al be okay uh Lieutenant um I know the MVR is that that's a f I know our buses bus drivers have to have that and I believe twice a year April is that correct or once a year to get the MVR for the drivers on their vehicle driving record because we just I just signed a purchase order I think it's once year for I think it's $5 do per person or per driver and I'm not sure whether it's every six months or once a year could you I don't I don't know they I'm not I don't do school bus inspections so
191um but they do have to do the MBR and it is $5 yes that and I think that $5 is paid for by the school system I believe um and also the medical statement I know bus drivers have to have a medical statement every year well they have to have a do physical right do physical um I don't know whether it would require do physical or this type of by law it doesn't but it you know he would recommend that there be some type of yeah medical statement on record that you know that the doctor says hey you know yeah they're you know yeah they're good they can drive you know they're good enough Health to to drive I me to go through the uh medical that the bus drivers have to go through a
192lot of people couldn't pass that I know right got a lot of but that's good I mean I think you're fine with that uh the only thing is some time from time to time Mr parsley I may ask you uh do most of the individuals that drive these vehicles are they pretty much the same people all the time for the most part yeah you might ought to come up if you don't mind we got another one okay there you go I guess just fill us in on how the individuals are selected to drive the vehicles and that type sure so we uh with uh Mr Skipper's help and Mi Mr Skipper uh as you all know spearheaded our purchase of uh the Suburbans we have two suburbans uh at the high school now and those
193are used for extracurricular activities specifically they are for the career in technical education program the Career and Technical education program has priority for use of those Vehicles however other extracurricular programs uh are allowed we allow other programs to use them when the the CTE programs do not need them what we find is that there are a handful of CTE programs and off the top of my head probably three or four sports that tend to use those and that's just uh via the nature of their programs uh for instance our agriculture program uh they have lots of competitions in that program and you may be taking two or three kids to a competition on a school day and and as Mr said logically it's it's just not real efficient to take a school bus right uh
194and so uh a would be an example um another example might be golf a sport uh let's say you've got six or eight kids that you you know are taking to a golf match it it logically it works well to take one of those Suburbans which they are maximum nine passenger vehicles yeah that was a question I was going to ask what is the capacity of these vehicles the capacity is nine for for the Suburbans including the driver uh yes including the driver now so we have instances where a program takes one Suburban with a group we have occasionally instances where both Suburbans go with a group a little larger group um as far as criteria that we have for the drivers uh uh of those Suburbans uh we do pull the MVR report the
195staff member uh currently is required for paying for the MBR report and um based upon report uh Mr Skipper uh actually takes the lead on Discerning whether the person is eligible to drive but the criteria that we have Set uh is over a period of three years you could not have 10 MVR points um and that's what we have in place now last early spring I forget what month last spring we receed those but that's what we ultimately settled on and every year we require that the MVR report is pulled so um so you do have a policy for those use for those B some a sort ofed it would be fair to sayc procedure their procedur not as in dep but but we have those we have procedures in writing uh at at the
196school level but but not board policy you for that um regarding this discussion no one has asked me specific uh but but uh no not that I can think of I I I don't recall it for sure does anyone in the system other than the high school staff have access to these or do you have a protocol for that um other than the high school staff well uh thinking through that because they are uh the the vehicles are for primarily for use of the C uh program uh we do have some CTE teachers at the nth grade academy now those those kids are taking High School classes but it is a different school so so the the Raider Academy CTE teachers would also be able to use those or uh or if there's a sport
197at at you know and the sports you know are are high school level but there are some coaches at Raider Academy at the high school level uh but beyond that that no they are not used by any other schools not used by any outside of school system system organizations at all it would be uh Educators it would be employees of uh Coffee County high school or possibly of raider Academy we could have a non-faculty coach as well driving one which those are technically system employees if they are non-faculty coaches uh those are the only system correct excuse me just to clarify that they're still paid by the system uh yes yes yes um but but again uh over a period of 3 years uh currently we don't allow the person to have more than 10
198MV points we do run the report once a year and we're not even a full well we're we're getting close to a year having those I can't remember what month we received from last year um now we also do say that we reserve the right to tell an employee that we're not going to allow them to use them so yes the person could have less than 10 but maybe we know of a situation where we're just not comfortable with a person driving and so we would just not allow it and they still have to check them check a mile what do you mean by you got to schedule the vehicle and basic yes yes so we have we have a calendar ke the keys aren't in them right uh no no no no no no
199the keys stay in the bookkeeper office the the keys stay in our bookkeeper's office up which is up part of our main office uh that's Miss Amy Barnard and uh so so they are checked out with the bookkeeper and uh you know we've got a calendar you know for requesting use of those vehicles and again uh our CTE programs are going to have priority on those Vehicles because you know they were purchased with C te funding and that's that's why we got them but it's it's been a benefit to other extracurriculars uh that we have those um you know and and and possibly a reason why it'd be good to have them for other extracurriculars outside of CT Paul I got a question just curious because I don't know is about how many would you
200say different drivers have you had and just different people um I could gather that information I'm talking about just a guess is probably 10 to 12 I mean it could be a little more maybe it's a little less it's fine I just that's kind of curious I didn't know have you had any uh feedback which because I can pretty well tell you A lot of these a lot of the recommendations of you know safety features from the camera systems that's been the big one I don't think there's anyone opposed to to that I I'm not I we're perfectly fine with because I've been questioned about from some of the people that do use them you know about it and nobody's told me if they've had any issues have they told you if they have any
201issues with some of these you know I mean that you know they're good good things that definitely need to be put in place in the glove box or on the dash um so so um Mr Skipper and I have talked about this topic quite a bit you know since uh and I I forget it was two or 3 months ago I think at a board meeting you You' discuss this topic December Bo December um so we've talked about it quite a bit since then uh we're not at all opposed to having those cameras and I no no one has said to me that they are um the a first aid kit is logical um and we're glad to do that um a question I have uh I guess for Mr I know um in looking
202at what you were reading off as far as some of the requirements for the vehicles I noticed that some of those are things that are are law you know you you can't drive over the speed limit right um can't use your phone when when operating the vehicle right and I guess I I guess I I wonder on this um so are there actually Schoolboard policies out there that include those things or those just suggestions and I say it because they're already law well there's school boards out there that have that written in their policy just in case you know for some reason the laws ever change you know if they go back to you know the cell phones and whatnot but most of them you know they don't even allow handsfree use of the cell
203phone for the driver because okay you know I mean it's one thing I guess if you've got it for navigation purposes but you're not you know you're not looking over trying to make a call or or or whatever you know you're not truly distracted punching buttons on your phone exactly you know so I mean but you know I mean yeah if you you know a lot of them are law but you know they need to be spelled out in the policy in case laws ever change fair fair it's kind of like Schoolboard policies a lot of our policies are are set up just exactly like the laws are made so it' be the same type thing here I think putting it in there that they have to be certain requirements and so forth even though
204it's state law uh they still need to be put in the policy I think just as reminder of those that are operating these vehicles exactly and you know the thing is it's um you know I know I know here for us the only two vehicles that we have that would qualify for this or the CTE vehicles but you know in the future you know this is something that we might you know as a school system want to look at is buying minivans or other other item you know other vehicles because we would welcome that yeah because for convenience of our our groups exactly I mean you know if you've you know like you say you know your your ad classes you know we're going to a you know FFA they're going to to a you
205know a hog judging contest guess what there's three of them going you know I mean it's ridiculous to take a school bus MH for you know and the problem we running into as a school system is you know we've got buses but we don't have drivers you know and and you know the drivers are stretched thin you know there's there's lots of days that that your mechanics are having to drive your your you know staff in the transportation department they're having to you know to drive so you know you know trans portation departments basically you know there's not a spare mechanic if there's a problem you know then you know we're just don't have enough bus drivers I know right now uh excuse Matt and uh Tim are both driving fulltime this week mhm uh
206because of the lack of drivers and so forth yeah there's several I think out that's got you know that's sick and whatnot I mean it you know I mean it's just something you run into and I you know I know that uh you know as a system we've had we've had a bus out by the road with a with a hiring sign now for about two years and it's you know you know nobody there permanently nobody really to buy a sign fortunately we we not like some systems that had to cut routes and had to double routes and those type things happens occasionally but it's it's something not a but there's some school systems that are very close to us that are having to cut out bus routes of course the state Lawes you don't
207have to pick them up within two two and a half miles through and a quarter miles of the school but we've always picked them up next door in all honesty for the most part but uh I think there's we're very fortunate to have the transportation system we have and a the ability to do what we do with it right uh let me throw this out just not going to throw it out let me say something just a minute for those Vehicles as far as insurance right now is concerned okay uh we did get contact with Tennessee risk management who is our insurance carrier and it came back from them let me just read that I don't want to miss anything says in Tennessee the insurance follows the vehicle and your specific instance TNR MC which
208is Tennessee risk management uh is the insur and as such all protection we provide to the school system is in place for the vehicles and drivers uh no need for proof of insurance for from their employees so that that's relief for us we weren't sure about that and also mentioned about the F endorsement of course that may or may not be a part of the policy but um they did mention that the F endorsement is not necessary for employees to operate their personal passenger vehicle or a board operated vehicle so the F endorsement is not necessary that I think that's for taxi drivers and chauffers and well that but you know I'd taken that off because you know after that yeah after talking with Mr you know Mr span he he U you know he
209said that that was something that that they've run into and said you know from the way that they look at it technically you are for hire because you're being paid you know as a as a teacher or a coach or whatever you're being paid you know that's part of your pay right you know so you are a paid driver transporting passengers but you know he said by law you know all you have to have is a class day life it's kind of stretching it I think but I understand yeah but I mean you know you know they just look at it from right from you know yeah there because this is a new operation for the school system I think there needs to be policies set up with it other than just maybe procedures that
210they have at the high school to protect the Board of Education and protect the school system well you know I mean you know with this like I said I know right now all we have is the the two CTE Suburbans you know but you know in the future I think it's something that you know we really may want to look at um you know of course eventually you know those Suburbans will wear out you know but you know if you know as a school system if we purchase many Vans for this purpose or or whatever that are you know more Suburbans or whatever you know number one they're cheaper than buses they're cheaper than buying School Bus even even little school buses because that's what he said he said you know by not doing um
211allowing 15 passenger vans they said your only other choice is a small activity bus well you know they're just about the same price as a big bus well that that requires a a CDL no it does buses no it does not because it's under it'll still they fall under that new law that they're they're able to drive in yeah with a class day license it will match the vehicle can we requirements all these laws I'm driving that and I'm going to have to look up uh if it's a new law I didn't is is a law about actually with the 15 passenger vans which we are not allowed to use the 15 passenger van so you're able to use the small buses but it's not helping you on the price you might as well go
212ahead and buy a big big bus exactly exactly but with a big bus you have to have a licensed bus driver you know but to me this is much better than because here to for we've had to to have parents to drive some of these smaller groups somewhere and that creates a lot of problems could a lot of times uh and then buses are not necessarily they have they can't leave before certain time they got to be back before a certain time and unfortunately we don't have spare buses and spare drivers we may have spare buses we don't have spare drivers uh so I think the program is what we're looking for here but there do need some some policies on it and I agree with that so I would you know suggest that Mr
213Bor get a group together get the policy committee together and work on that probably got a quite a few take what Mr parsley already has at the high school and yes sir he's got it covered for this year I think if that's plug it plug it all together yes work on a bigger pack and I think I would like to add the private vehicle transportation too because I think it's I'm looking at the policy what we're saying here and I think it's kind of vague uh really all we require is a director of design needes approval and them show proof of insurance but I think of the passengers those kids that's in the car have their parents signed off that they understand that the school system has no liability because I think it's it's it's
214real easy to get a bunch of kids in your car and head off to a ball game with them and some of those parents may not realize that that responsibility lies on me I'm I'm caring those kids if I have an accident there some may think well the school systems responsible that was a school suction trip or whatever or transportation and I have haven't forbid that that would ever happen but I can see where something like that could occur it's not could it's just like just and that's what I was looking at is that it's it's not really detailed that like there's nothing mentioned about the passengers you know it's about the it's about the driver and the liability insurance for the driver the owner of the car but nothing about the passengers Mr parsley
215I know you've got a because I've seen it are you talking about the private vehicle well there is a private vehicle use board policy and I'm not sure if that's what you're referring to yours was more in details I I have a a screenshot on my phone and it's right here you talking about the board policy I think that's what you're referring to yeah because I think you you know you told us before that they have to have the desit knees permission from the school either director or Desi KNE which would be make sure his is more in depth let me see what board policy it is okay it's 34 uh it's 340 uh 3404 I think we need to take's not while you're looking at up April do you know the cost of a
216camera system for the buses this wouldn't be as extensive because you wouldn't have to have I think that we've got one going one way and one going another way and two back in the back and some in the side and so forth I'm not trying to answer for for April but that's actually part the bids anymore and that's been bid since we've been bidding for well past five years we've added that as part of the bid process so I don't know that we have it for individual add own the price right now so that that might be something I I don't I have to go back and look several years like because I know that we put that with the bid now i' have to go look back and I don't even know who we
217would purchase those from so i' have to do a little research each year we get new buses and we have to put cameras on buses that's what I'm saying it's part of the buses it's part of the bid so it comes with the bus already on there when we order them yeah we put them but but transportation does have the company that we use the the technology from so they they have it but I don't think April would or I would have that information I'm G find out $20.98 from Teemu well I told Mr par parsley about a system that I use um my things and it's it's I've got 14 units in my fleet that I track and have C forward facing and rear facing camera it's all GPS you can go into at
218any time and for 14 units it was it's 300 a month I agree with Chris on if you do put units doing the same things as we already Ed so that you already have everything set up and you're not coming up two different two different things might as well use the same same well if you if you need to view the video for whatever reason you know it's compatible with the hardware we that we've already got you know I mean to me that only makes sense because that way the transportation system or whomever could look there happened to be an incident or concern they could look back through the transportation system to see if and if anything did actually take place correct if I could the the board policy that that we have been that
219uh um that we've been referencing is policy 3.44 I I think that and there are several statements there ju including the type of insurance that the driver must have um that there must be um a special permit for each trip involving the students including the field trips and so on um you know there are six statements it looks like here I mean you know I possibly it could be more detailed not hard to come together yeah I mean more into that yeah you can just add something like a students uh the parent are guarding of the student being transported understands that the liability is on the driver of the car not the Coffee County School Board even though that's they I mean I think sometimes that that parents get that they do think it's the
220school board you know that's well they would need to sign a waiver of liability I remember times you did that a lot of times because at times teachers had to take kids on well you know there was no other Transportation you would take them on field trips right and they signed off a waiver right and I'm just wondering if maybe that needs to be done well I mean that probably needs to be reviewed and you know along with I know it's going to be very uh difficult with a lot at the beginning of the year you know my child's in basketball and I understand that that there at times will be transported by a parent and and I wave you know I W the responsibility of the school system I know a lot of times
221and Holly may be able to chip in on this cheerleaders are involved and where the parents do a lot of driving with the cheerleaders if they can't ride the bus or whatever the case may be and U that is where this policy we've got comes in that the parents has to show u a certain amount of Insurance liability have to sign off on some paperwork and I think I'm not sure hollly do the parents have to sign that they know that this child is riding with an individual you know from my experience at at Coffee Middle with cheer uh it's not an option for the cheerleaders to ride the bus nobody's ever explained why to me although I'm sure there's a reason um but uh it seems like um we were told that uh cheerleaders
222were not allowed to ride with coaches um I don't know why every cheerleader's parent um transports their own cheerleader to the game or if another cheerleader needs a ride I know I've married many of them I don't know if I should have or not now that we're talking about it but uh I hate to turn a kid down that needs a ride I've noticed the same thing with the buses and especially in high school take a football game for example we might not have enough to fully fill up two buses but we could have put the cheerleaders on there but we're still taking three and four buses yeah cuz we're keeping them split I I don't understand I know understand I mean I would like to know like why I mean I don't mind taking
223my maim I'm going anyway but we do have some cheerleaders that did need rides consistently throughout the season so there something we can check into I guess I guess Ju Just your comments made me think of this there are some instances um you know you could take any particular group and it would be a smaller group you couldn't do it with like a football team or something like that but there are instances where some of our Groups travel on their own and what I mean by that is that the coach or the the adviser for the the CTE group they're not offering the transportation we're simply saying you know this competition is at 6:00 p.m in t i want you to be there at 5: we'll see you there at this gate or this door
224um you know in those situations the school system would not be responsible for the students travel right um and in those situations it would not be necessary to have any kind of note signed or anything like that because students are responsible for arranging their own transportation with their parents now we realize that in many of those situations multiple students end up writing with a parent such as what you've described the coaches don't set it up they basically release the students then the parents figure out that is correct how they're going to to to get their child to is is competition I'm going to step in that doorway go ahead go ahead I'm going to step in that doorway but is that due to a lot of the cost and when I say cost a lot
225of these smaller Sports smaller organizations cheerleaders and that can afford through the athletic department or whatever to pay back for that bus the fuel that is a large that is a very big part of why we're not transporting it's a lot it's it's lots of times it's the time that the group needs to go uh it could be before school is out because of a long trip very few yeah occasionally it is that um and so it could be that it could be we know how much it will cost to go X number of miles on a bus trip and and don't have much money we can just travel on our own parents are responsible for getting their kids there um and you know I mean it's free to the school system I guess you
226might say but I mean parents are ultimately you know traveling and taking the kids so what I'm hearing is we need to update policy 3.44 right I think we hit about 19 different ones with I'm trying to simplify Robert well and then a then a policy based on your policy for for the school board to cover what uh Mr is talking about with the nine pass fans or the non-bus transportation is that kind of simplifying what what we're hearing here so that would be a policy committee situation Mr Shores Mr Mr Skipper uh and or me will be glad to send you our protocols that we have in writing so that you all can work you know use those as you create a board policy and when we do a policy down that line it
227actually includes the ones that's part of it which is the high school so so Paul and Richard would be a major part of that writing of that policy yeah and Mr Anderson also because I'm sure they there parents that transport middle school kids also okay I guess I was going back to the sub suburb sorry I thought we were talking about suburb that's what I was talking about so excuse me I got a few questions for the man with a gun in the ring and then one for whoever at the end the only want we know about you've heard all of this do you have any do you got any recommendations to add to what these gentlemen have threw in here you know as far as safety things and then you know I'd kind of
228if if you could give a I just want to clarify on the licensing kind of things and requirements and DOT requirements of physicals and things like that it never hurts to add it to and have but as far as what is required by laws sure so um when you're getting into the your medical certificate or your F endorsement um anything that that's really more for a commercial business that's what that's designed for um I think the uh when I read that the medical certificate from a doctor I think that would probably be I mean you see these truck drivers there the DOT physicals aren't that in-depth and um so so I don't know you probably be better off going to your probably better off going to your to your you know your primary care doctor
229and getting that letter of clearance to drive um which you know if we have to send out a driver's license for somebody to go retest they have to go to their doctor and get a clearance letter to be able to drive and then take it back to to the driver's license to get another license so um I think that uh you don't need de endorsement you don't need a medical certificate um like I said I think that letter would would be sufficient if you guys want to require that it's not necessary um but um the vehicle is not big enough does it have government tags on it the like County tags so it's a it's a County vehicle U it's exempt anyway it's exempt from anything y so but the LI it never hurts to
230have it well it's like us you know we even though we're exempt we still have to have everything that that a citizen would have to have because uh the liability as aspect of it somebody's going to go to court and start suing people so seat belt stuff like that mm and and know I was I was sitting there thinking if if I may uh all of our vehicles have a um I don't know what it's called but it's plugged into the um computer and it's a real time it it documents everything like your speed if somebody's wearing a seat belt how many people's in the car almost like a black box yes yeah and it's and it's real time yeah and it's real time uh that you can pull it up on a computer and
231sit there and see who how fast somebody's going um and all that stuff I'm sure I'm sure they I'm sure they get a lot of complaints on me but um anyways I tell if you w the the requirements that uh for the vehicle I think those are on par with I think you would need the fire extinguisher I would just suggest that you mount it in the vehicle don't let it be a loose loose item in there um and then uh but everything else you just have to have a d-class license you don't need anything special all right last the last one I had I've heard about no 15 passenger vans why that's national highway safety I thought it was 16 it's 16 or more including the driver but that's it is 15 passenger van
232but you that's 16 people in the van the 16th man is the driver yes but you take a seat out and there's not a seat in that vehicle it still classifi less correct for school system correct me or not I think the not allowed in the school system to be used for transportation of school kids school kids that's the reason why you can't use a 15 passenger in schools and and that's where that new law came in that private schools could get away with the vehicle we can't they could get away with the license whereas it didn't make any difference for us because vehicle wasn't going to work it's all it's all on the safety the the Vans aren't in Crash Test aren't as safe correct as anything else and that's why you know they
233recommend if you use a small bus that it's done by a one of the bus building companies because they know the safety protocols dealing with school systems you know and that's the whole reason of the 15 passenger vans don't meet the crash criteria the safety regulations right who does the uh inspections on our buses to uh Department of Safety or yeah we do it we have a special group of people that that uh do it they um Johnny Anderson or Danny V are our Troopers in in this District that that do ours and this guy's how does how does the Department of Education control was it he's he's the director of student transportation for the the Tennessee Department of Education so I didn't cuz I knew I knew the state done the inspections and right
234but he that's what maker tell a bus I thought but and I just uh in your question I apologize if fact I didn't mean to step on toes good okay uh the question or the the statement you made about the small bus is not needing the CDL uh they're saying that you do need a CDL if you have a this is 16 more passengers yeah so 16 or more passengers has to well I was going with the smaller the yeah even the short bus the W no is 15 or lower I I think you could get away without having the CDL but it has for a school system you have to use a bus manufacturer exactly but over that yes I thought you talking about I'm talking about going smaller than the what they call
235an activity bus I apologize yeah but regardless of how many seats you got in it Robert it's what it's what it's um built for like you said you laughing about and and at one time we tried that it when we when I was here before U you had if you had 15 passenger more you had to have a CDL to drive it I said well what if you take a back seat out and only have you know 10 people to get in the van yeah uh it's still rated for a 15 passenger so regardless of how many seats you got in it what it I've got by them guys a bunch though I got whole building pil full of the S SE yeah it's it's what designed to carry what it's rated for is what's
236designed to carry how built yes sir all right like GVW I think uh nine times out of 10 it don't M matter if it's over 10,000 pound gbw you're going to have to have at least a health card correct if you're in commercial yeah and Interstate in trate you don't need it so if you're just stay in the state of Tennessee be looking for yeah you know where that's going so have we beat this one to death so and then some yeah thank you very much for your contribution yes sir so we got marching orders on this we got a couple policies one we got to update and one we got to make up um that there I just got a couple just a few more things I talk real quick about the agenda items
237for next week's board meeting already and uh couple three things we want to have on there is we did not I I failed to get the director qualifications changes that the that the direct search committee made onto the uh agenda last meeting so we need to put that on this meeting um we also had a number of requests to change our videos to just go back to the board meeting only uh to on on live videos and then just do audio on the U on the on the committee meetings so take a little burden off of uh Mr damewood and so that'll be on the agenda to vote on and then the last thing is um uh policy committee is doing some changes to the policy committee to move the principles more to advisors and
238not voting members of the policy committee and so that's going to be on the agenda agenda also so um so just so so you know kind of what's coming and and Melissa so you know too so because I know we got to get the agenda out pretty quick and and uh um and I did discuss these things with Dr Powell earlier today too so with that um question question oh you go first are you sure is the new Union basketball team coming to the meeting for us to honor their achievement okay I'm excited about that yeah that is on the agenda too right yeah no we have a recognition yes we have a recognition yes we will have a recognition both participants will be here and uh coach Barlo and oh I I the new
239UN no I think they got moved to March as as we had the volle was the volleyball team who do we Jennifer we talked to you about yeah the new Union boys basketball teamk yeah I thought we had that on the uh on the agenda so don't it's both isn't it girls and boys I think it was just the boys that went without losing any games Oh I thought since both somebody requested they were Champions both and I think it I'm could be wrong but I think it was the boys that went through everything without losing a single game yeah so yeah I thought I know we talked about that because we moved the volleyball team to to March yeah so because they could make I think it was just the I think the boys
240were the champions and that's what that's what we were doing no they were double Champions they were boys and girls I believe were they I believe so they said double Champion okay well then good let's make sure we get whoever is the champion we want to honor yeah I I have it in my email I thought I forwarded it to you so my apologies so oh I hope they can come the last moment well I I told them that they were going to be on the agenda so I thought i' copied you of it so I'm sorry yeah yeah I believe they were double Champions they won their boys and girls both won the championship come on Melissa you're supposed to know this yeah you're supposed to know this glad I got to see Charlie
241blush [Music] right oh and there was one more thing that we needed to have on the agenda too is the voucher bill is coming up again so we need to uh vote on on whether we want to um have I think tsba sent a resolution against it yes sir so we have to vote on whether we want to vote against it or or not now call the the the freedom education Freedom Act same thing as the vouchers or the scholarships I think was called last year voucher bill that yeah still a voucher bill there's been some changes in it I can get the information to you folks uh I can send the bill out or Melissa can send it out to you folks to look yeah do what now okay so the bill is in
242there there's some changes in it uh one thing I would like to caution you about that we just received from toss day before yesterday the bill mention mentions the fact that a school system will not lose any funds next year based on the ACT that you keep the same funding you had the prior year but the kicker now is that that was a one-year deal only as opposed to every year uh so that's something that's that's come out of it in the last four or five days also wasn't there uh is it uh part of that and part of that change was if you were an outside Source or private school or what have you and you took that child and took that voucher just one it only takes one that school was required or
243they wouldn't get the voucher that school was required to fall in line with State rules and regul yes and no yes and no it's it's an or situation they can either take a standard test or they can take the teap test if the private schools can now at first it's still not the same as public school at first but when they come in with this last thing you're just talking about I think it was taking away the choice it no you go to state or they have to be accredited that's what I read yesterday on it well we talking about we're talking about two different things in accredited school versus accountability on testing is that no I was I was told accountability okay I know about yeah I haven't heard that Robert I'll check tomorrow
244to find out I'll check tomorrow to find out I listen to it this morning on radio about 2 o' in the morning that that will be on the agenda anyway so I don't listen to radio at 2 o'clock in the morning I have I have a sure one I don't think all of y'all know this but Mr dwood has not been he's not being paid to stay the all this time that we've been having all these meetings and I think that he should be I I mean we should not expect someone to stay these meetings and set up these microphones without some kind of pay and uh I did not realize it he didn't tell me I asked him and uh uh maybe hope you know if something passes that that we're just going to
245be recording the committee meetings then he won't have to be spending all his time up here with us we can record them but he likes us but I feel like that we we need to I don't know the board would have to pass that or whatever but I think I mean what yeah because it's been a lot of you've been spend a lot of hours up here with us and I know you enjoy hanging out with us but uh you know not that much well since you uh had the conversation toward me when you say recording you just mean recordings not broadcas just audio yeah not that just be careful that you're not committing yourself to have a live stream AUD right no live streaming yeah just you record and and it'll be open to
246the public except for full board meetings yeah we will still live stream the full board meetings that will be that will be the motion yes yeah exactly so yeah I don't know what what would we need to do in order for him to be paid for what he's done I mean that a compensation supplement you can't afford to pay him on an hourly basis yeah yeah but but we're requiring you to that's different I don't think it should be comp time I think you need to get have a history of comp all right just so your comp Ed because that's not last last word I have a question for um Mr Morin um West West Morland yeah I listened to it on the vouchers from the tsba this week and one thing that was brought
247up is that if a child comes out of our system and they have a um I thank you it's so late or 504 that that and they need services that the school system they come out of is going to be required to give those services like um occupational therapy or physical therapy we would still have to pay those for that child even though they're in a private school that that is something that's still being debated and discussed at this point as we stand right now um it looks like that we potentially as a district would be responsible for those services and it would fall under a service plan however um that that's that's still debatable at this time as far as exactly how that's going to look uh as soon as I find out and
248get any information on that I'll actually I've got a special ed call on the 4th I'll ask that question and see what kind of feedback I get from the state department on that that could get very expensive you can only imagine how expensive that could be no that $7,000 for that voucher money doesn't even scratch the surface for what those services would cost us not to mention if they're going out of out of County we'd be looking at Travel as well if if that if that had to happen and unless it's changed also the $7,000 if it is given to a private school and that private school decides that child is no longer welcome at that particular school they come back into the our system we do not get money for that child it stays
249at that private school all year long yes Tom I got one more thing what what are we going to do about these bleachers guys I keep getting asked questions about these bleachers are we done with the no uh Mr Shores we discussed that this afternoon yes we did discuss that okay the the bid actually you'll see it in the paper tomorrow's paper uh it's also going online tomorrow with the Facebook so bids are are out um starting tomorrow uh they will be requesting for the the packets and then I'm gosh I'm thinking it's February the 20th is the due date for bids to be turned in my plan is for it to be on the board agenda for March uh for decisions on the board on what you want to go with but the concern
250also is I think Mr HRI that if the board does decide to go one way or the other there's no assurance that it can be done this summer regard which way we go okay when when did he change his mind uh about a week ago when I talked to him he said that it was pretty much that he was already pretty much booked for this year CU he told us he had to March well I got in touch with them and was talking to them and and before I could actually put the bid packet together because you don't put a open ended completion date so I I had to put a completion date on it and I was talking to him and for for new bleachers the you're going to see this if if you
251when you look at it uh new bleachers won't be this summer the completion date is going to be by the end of next summer so it'll be the end of 2026 for new bleachers if it's completely changed out if the board ends up deciding to go with the modifications and renovations to the bleachers that we have I put a date on through the I guess it's the Monday after our fall break because I've got to give them time to be able to get it done and but there's more chances of them being able to work it because you could close off half the gym and and they could continue to work on the other side but then also we have to have the gym well we can't have basketball or volleyball going on during those
252times so so if it just depends on which direction the board goes Renovations by the end of the or the start of the following week of fall break because that also gives them fall break but they might be able to get it done during summer it it's just it's iffy complete change out is it's the end of 2026 summer now is that with that one company are we getting bids from more than one oh this is okay we'll see so any company could have a different timetable is that correct okay I had to come up with a time limit and and this should work for anybody that puts in a bed um and this is open to anybody we we can have one bid or we can have up to 100 bids it's whatever it
253gets turned in uh it depends on who who turns in bids I only know of three companies that actually provides bleachers for gyms uh there are other companies that can actually do the Fabrications and the work for uh the remodel and so forth so really just depends on who turns in bids if we only get one bid that's what we get if we get multiple we get multi guess what I'm saying we determining the timeline or the people I mean because we haven't we don't know who we're going to get our bids someone else might could say we can put those new bleachers in this summer absolutely and basically what I was doing is trying to make it so that anybody I I can't narrow it down we really don't have a timeline do I
254we really don't have a timeline then I had to put a completion date but our our goal is for it to be done earlier if the the company's able to get it done earlier uh but it just depends on the company and if they are booked or not so I I had to put a completion date in but that doesn't mean it can't be done it could be done earlier and so what completion date did you put again for complete you put it for complete removal of bleachers and new ones going in if that's the way the board goes it'd be the end of 2026 summer summer 2026 okay so you you couldn't have said by the end of the year I could have but you don't I might have I might have knocked out
255everybody from being able to bid on it see if you put it too if I crunch them and they can't do it then you're not going to get a bid even right I'm just thinking you know preferably you could anyway that's I'm just trying to figure out how we can not have to wait so long but now if it's Renovations once again I've got to give them a time that they can do it if I crunch them they they might be already booked up and they're going to say well there's no need to me putting in for it cuz I can't do the job I can't get it done in that amount of time so I've got to be careful I've got to give them enough time to to be able to get the job
256done so that that's what I did yeah I understand I I understand that that company's one was telling you that that's the time frame but the renovation the timeline on that was the week after fall break they had to be in had to be renovated if that's a route you go am I correct that is correct and imp possibly it could be done during the summer yeah it just depends on the company that gets it if they're free or not someone some company could any company right I [Laughter] question I believe so to me uh yeah we can let's let's adjourn the meeting and we can ask those questions