001call this meeting to order this is our annual Retreat meeting continuation you'll join me with a moment of silence and the pledge Jared good everybody Welcome in here as we all set for super bow Sunday [Music] flag United States America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all [Music] okay as we begin this morning we're going to consider public [Music] comment I'd like to make a a motion to add discussion of agenda and approval of the agenda to the to the agenda by majority vote policy [Music] 1.43 okay [Music] second that got seconds is there discussion yeah so per policy of 1.221 boardsmodern [Music] the board or neglect my share of the work um I've made the comment to several board members at the
002tsba conference uh this year that we have a very talented and diverse group of board members and U with a lot of knowledge and experience we should be able to work together to make a difference and at this point I've not been able to work with anyone uh I've been told don't talk to supervisors don't talk to other Boe members don't call the attorney it's expensive uh put your items on the agenda which I have done and I've been told we'll work on that later um so far I I have a box full of unanswered questions I have a list of items that are not being worked on at all I have an inbox full of community concerns I have a voicemail full of emotions we have meetings that have not been documented well and
003due to all this I'm scheduled to spend this morning listening to concerns from citizens who are not fully informed so that is why I would like to to discuss the agenda please do there's a motion and statement you have a second there was a second yeah um I could Echo some of those same frustrations in in the nuances of becoming a new board member trying to figure out the Cadence of of how board moves operates where where and when you communicate how to communicate um opportunities for improvement there can't disagree so this agenda has been modified in the time frame that's liable with um I guess the question that that I would have is what what was the reasoning for modifying the agenda to get to the position that we're in today after the fact
004that we do understand that um we have business to conduct today what was the reasoning for for modifying the agenda today is that the end of your statement we're going to vote unless there's other discussion other [Music] discussion so restate the motion [Music] please i' like to make a motion to add discussion of the agenda agenda and approval per approval of the agenda for majority vote okay you've heard the motion those in favor say I I those opposed say nay n n let's do a roll call Secretary here just go down the line M St yes yes no no yes yes yes no that's 4 to three I think so far that right three four five four way it goes so we're going to add discussion to the agenda go ahead with the discussion Mr
005chair I'd like to make a motion to remove agenda items 5 a and 5B from the agenda create a special committee to discuss the evaluation of the superintendent and the evaluation of the board since this isn't a voting meeting it's an annual planning meeting we can't discuss items and vote on things this is on the agenda it's not a voting item you can't vote on we're voting on what's on the agenda we didn't have advertise to the public that we're going to vote on anything today we just we just pass the motion to discuss the agenda we can discuss it we just can't vote we just did vote I'm trying to can somebody tell me and I apologize what what what are we asking to remove specifically I you said 5 a items 5 a
006and 5 b your presentation on evaluations and board self evaluation no those were not so you're just the motion to make and all I'm do is clarifying so the motion right now is just basically to remove those discussion items from the agenda and to create a special committee to evaluate the to discuss the evaluation of the superintendent and the evaluation of the board they can definitely removing them from the agenda certainly can be done because those are just discussion items so obviously it would be take a majority vote to do so so that would be a Val motion creating the committee the only reason I'm hedging right now and I'm admitting that you probably want to know what's in the mind of a lawyer it's terrible but um there's a question as to whether or
007not that is an actionable item right um it's not a policy so we're talking about creating a policy it's really procedure of a nature so it probably is more something that could be done today in terms of creating a committee the committee couldn't take action couldn't be do anything like that but in terms of creating it I think that there more procedural so I think that could be done via this motion and what I guess what's your thought process behind that Scott what are we what are we trying to achieve by doing that um are we trying to are we saying we don't need to work on it now we're waiting to work on it later or so I can I can give my discussion now if you want want me to so my discussion
008is that items 5 a and 5 b on the current agenda there are very generic guidelines that are meant to be a starting point we need to create an evaluation that is specific to our district and identifies both quantitative and qualitative accountability measures I personally have started work on a method that can accomplish that however we as a team should set aside some Focus time and come up with a template that we can all agree on U that will not be accomplished in the short time we have allotted for today it cannot should not be accomplished by executive committee alone the board is comprised of nine members all with an equal vote so per policy 1.25 board uh board director relations the board shall be responsible for specifying its requirements and expectations of the director
009of schools and then holding then holding accountable or holding the director accountable by evaluating how well those requirements and expectations have been met that's policy 1.25 uh policy 1.3 board committees the board shall operate with standing without standing any committees except the executive committee special committees may be formed at the direction of the board and as the needs of the board shall require such special committee shall be discharged when the work is finished or earlier by a majority vote of the entire board the chairman of the board shall recommend and the board shall approve appointments to committees all reports by committee shall be made directly to the board so this policy 1.3 policy was a decision that was made when the m the majority of us agreed not to have standing committees we all right
010we made that agreement at this point I myself I'm not sure that was the best decision however I think we can use the current policy to collaborate as needed and we should do just that uh committees do require a quorum and they can vote on what will be reported to the board for discussion these committees do not have to be limited to a court so all Boe members can be involved in attend committees if they so choose I think committees have to be limited to less than a qu yeah the committee meetings themselves are public so anybody could attend including board members certainly sure so as the premise of putting this on there today was so everybody'd have all the information and so they could start looking at it and with the adjustment of the
011agenda today to allow for constituent feedback which we've been asked for the time was shortened we did talk at the last work session about spending some some time submitting what folks think suggestion wise so we can formulate uh a second draft on it um five point or 5A includes a rough draft that has all three sections per tsba guidelines um for the evaluation so those have been put together in the first R rough draft to include it's not just generic it is to include specifics from our strategic plan so section c c actually has specifics from our strategic plan rolled into it as a rough first draft for everybody to look at and the intent was for everybody to if there was any questions today to ask about the format and the tsba guidelines for
012that um any questions anybody had about how we pulled it together this far and then we had talked at the work session about everybody sending via email some of their um criteria that they'd like included in it and then we could come back together at a work session with it so that's why it says on here for incorporation into the second draft and then hopefully we could have it pull together and look at it in the February session now the five um B is just the sample from tsba and it got put on there twice I'm not sure why but that is actually what the board uses now like question for questions so that's something we need to look at and determine do we want to use question for question the tsba one or or
013do we want to modify that personally I think we need to align some of our evaluation with the director evaluation as well since we're all a team working towards the same results um but again you know for everybody to look at it and submit what they want to submit and that way we can kind of work on some things without having to be you know in a meeting for everything so my thoughts that is it okay folks resp right now that that what what is on the agenda who has created that at this point that's the question so far so can I just make one little procedural thing right now we actually went into discussion that this happens it's not that big without a second typically we need a second first so is there a
014second to Mr van we's motion I'll second it okay so then so so therefore we just need to get that out of the way so discussion can continue so Mr step and I started working on this during the last board tenure um the last I'm sorry the evaluation the evaluation yeah started working on modifying it then um the prior board was not interested in changing it modifying it but we were hoping that with the new board there would the need would be seen by everybody to develop a better evaluation um for our one and only employee that we have um so he and I started working on it then Mr King has been involved in working on it as well in order to try to get just a rough draft for a place to start
015from around the Strategic plan that we have in place following the tsba guidelines but don't you think that should have been a all the board included in that well all the board was invited to be involved in that last year the board voted not to do it last year so Mr step and I started working on that during our meetings to see what we could put together in hopes that we would have something and this is a surprise I mean we've talked about this multiple times so it's not like this is a surprise to everybody that it's on here um we promis y'all that we would have a rough draft for everybody to start from um so so I can read that and I see that yeah what I'm suggesting is that get a committee
016together so that we can all have input on that cuz I have some ideas but well that was the whole purpose for everybody to submit what they wanted to have on it and then we would work on incorporate that and then we can get together and go my whole point about what I just said is that we can't do that in the allotted time that we have today right so that's why I suggest having a special Committee just just to discuss those evaluations of both the board and the director I don't know if we want to do it in committee where it would be less people there or you know what we had talked about doing is bringing it to work session with everybody's suggestions I brought it to a vote because the majority will
017decide that can't hear you I'm sorry I said that's why I brought it to a vote because the majority will decide that so unless there's other discussion can you repeat it one more time just to make sure everybody's got it now I apologize like to make a motion to remove agenda items 5 a and 5B from the agenda and create a special committee to discuss the evaluation of the superintendent and the evaluation of the board probably can we split that into two separate motions and the only reason for it is it just gets a little it's really two different actions you understand what I'm yes I got really I think the board should vote on a whether it wants to remove those agenda items and then a separate vote for B whether it wants to
018create the special Comm Mr chair I'm sorry just want to make sure we get thank you very much problem so the motion is modified to be that you want to remove the items from the agenda today 5 a and 5 a and 5 b and there's a say than that yeah there there other discussion being none we'll take a vote go down the line First District yes second yes no yes yes yes no the CH votes no so it's still 54 we'll take those off you agend and there' be a separate so now that those are off the agenda we're going to you want to Appo the committee to look at those items yes sir I seconded so is there other discussion on that being none we'll go down the line again M doll yes
019yes no no yes yes yes no care votes no 5 to four so we will appoint a special committee which I wasn't prepared to do today like to think about it will that need to be voted on again once I appoint the committee you just have to appoint the committee and maybe at the next meeting they'll have to be discussion as to whether anybody candid wants to object to that or want to make a motion to modify the appointment but it is the chair's decision to make the initial appointment before we go there who wants to be on that committee me since I've been work on got Scott raised his hand I Mr vanck him and Miss D Miss yes any others I will needed so normally we put three on a committee yeah that's
020fine so being three volunteers is there any other besides we can't hear you not a word anybody really can you hear me now no mine's on mine's on we'll work on [Music] getting technology the mic closer to you when you speak [Music] so go Mr in looking at that I'd like to consider these three volunteers for the committee and if there's no objections that will be the [Music] committee okay so moving on from that Mr step has a statement to make yes good morning I want to express my sincere gratitude for the opportunities this board has given me during my time as director of schools I particularly appreciate the outpouring of support for K County schools and me I've learned and grown significantly in this role and I value the experiences and relationships I've gained
021I respect the board's decision and I'm committed to ensuring a smooth transition to the new leadership as I complete my contract on June 30th I wish only the best for kland County and kland County schools with kind regards thank you Mr chair yes I still had one more item I wanted to discuss on this can you speak up please Mr Mr chair I still had one more item I would like to discuss on the agenda please okay go ahead item 6 A2 I'd like to make a motion to cover only Pages 110 through 112 today that's January through March okay so that's a motion to consider on item 62 A2 Pages 110 to 112 of that document is there a second I'll second that got a motion in a second is there other discussion I
022guess the intent on this again was more for FYI for y'all to look at it versus us really digging into it today it's a example from tsba not necessarily something that we'll want to do everything of but to give us an idea of um planning from a board side we have the annual can calendar that we use right now it's more of a planning from the administrative side versus the Board side and that actually has some suggestions for things the board wants to do so I figured as we were getting in charge strategic plan that was a great example for us to look at so not not a need to dig into it today but just for everybody's information to look at it um and then as we figure out today how we're going to
023break down that strategic plan then that would be some information that we could utilize to help us with some of that so it's really just for it's just for reading it's not really to get wi to today yeah yeah just you know for time sake I figured that would be something that we could dig into more when we actually start digging into the logistics on the plan the reason I made the motion is because 110 through 112 is is the focused on right now and I thought the rest of it could be discussed at at a later meeting right just for just for the time yep and that was kind of the purpose of all of it I mean again we've modified the agenda so it was just more so to have it on there
024so y'all had it could start looking at it as much information as possible before we start meeting on the Strategic plan so can I retract my motion okay so motion retracted are there other comments that we need to talk talk about on the agenda for me being none will go to public comment those that have signed up all the rules you signed up for it we've got no more than 30 minutes allowed three minutes per person I want you to maintain civility keep Personnel issues out of the dist first one signed up is Wendy Stanley just just so you know I'm the board attorney you probably figure that out I'm going just hit the timer cuz everybody has 3 minutes and right when it's at 1 minute left I'll just wave my hand thank you
025and I won't start until you start now thank you you're [Music] welcome make sure you can hear me so we don't have the same problems okay good morning my name is Wendy Stanley it's not very and I'm a resident of the fourth district want full transparency which seems to be a unique concept for some I do not have any children in the district however I am a courta appointed special Advocate who represents six Cumberland County Children I've been able to learn about the various programs offered in the schools including the CTE classes Tikka and the transition Academy through public presentations re search and personal contacts with families who have benefited from these programs I've watched with great interest the repercussions from your 54 vote to not renew the contract of Mr step our current director
026of schools after the vote some of you made vague rationalizations for your decision the one that pequ my interest was the excuse that the district needed to go in a different direction this became more confusing after attending the County Commission Education subcommittee meeting and seeing the presentation from Mr step regarding the improvements the students have made since his appointment Ela scores for fourth sorry 3rd fourth 7th and 8th grade have all improved from 2022 to 2024 fifth and sixth grade stayed at level three which is at expectation eighth grade went from level one to level four this is not the right decision Direction matth scores for fourth sorry third fifth sixth and eth all improved with three of them being at level five the highest level on the scale this is not the right direction
027third grade La teap has gone from 32% proficient Proficiency in 2122 to 38% in 2324 third grade math teap has gone from 30% in 2122 to 42% in 2324 is this not the right direction act benchmarks for college readiness went from 36.6% in 2122 to 30 8.2% in 2324 with comparable districts at 31% College ready graduates went from 34% to 53% in 2324 this is not the right direction and work-based learning from 180 students in 2122 to 75 in 2324 this is not the right direction please reconsider your vote thank you second one signed up is Miss Karen Franson remember my hand coming up is just to give you a one minute it's not to tell you to stop talking that be I understand you're good I would never do it Karen fransen 895 Parnell
028District 5 the Boe mission statement to inspire every student every day towards academic achievements and excellence and life skills so they may reach their full potential to achieve your mission what significant qualities must the directors of school possess what specific skills do you wish this leader to have one who sets policies and procedures for approximately 7,200 students and 1100 employees hundreds of us think Mr step embodies the mission statement examples given January 28th at Stone during the County Commission education committee meeting by every speaker publicly no exception evaluated Mr step's person and performance with Hardy support every remark was made by those with personal sometimes daily contact with him during this contract term these 17 presenters included SRO a bus driver students moms verse responder County Commissioners and others they're over 1,800 signers among two
029petitions supporting Mr step okay let's fact check some of the comments by board members from your January 23rd meeting Mr stpp is inacessible and doesn't listen Anonymous accusation in contrast plenny publicly said Mr step does listen is accessible he shows up on buses walks the Halls interacts with students and faculty plus support staff and parents inaccessible really he is just a good PR person is he skilled at PR as director of schools yes but he's so much more his race could instead pay for another teacher the requested raise wouldn't cover half a teacher's salary and benefits also consider he is responsible for the welfare of over 8,000 people there's no comparison that's a false comparison Mr step unilaterally moved T the funding around he did No Such Thing several County Commissioners agree he has no
030such Authority note their resolution D4 Mr steep spent $600,000 on a roof instead of something for students that was you the board it was $ 172,000 by the way for Pine View's gym because buckets caught leaks for over a year and the rooftop kept blowing off this directly benefits everyone other money spent was on the lift station at Martin Elementary functioning toilets also benefit everyone every one of those five points is false for the sake of our students and then fulfillment of your mission stop the hiring marryg go round here and now he the wishes of parents students leaders and many others find a way to extend Mr step's contract or offer a new improved one and vote Yes is Miss [Music] nuk uh candy nem 300 Old grassy Coke Road I'm here for one
031reason only and that's for my child the first first thing is Homestead School fencing which you all approved the plan was to use leftover funds from last year to erect part of the fencing yet nothing has been done I heard the reason for this is because some of the homestead citizens don't want it never mind the fact that parents teachers and and other citizens at Homestead are for it also the children need it please keep the fencing in mind when you were doing your self evaluations later uh because this was was agreed upon bids were received work was procrastinated and now it has been determined that there's no need to complete it who knows what's happened to the funds another reason why I'm here is because my daughter is struggling in sixth grade I went
032to a parent teacher meeting last week and I told the teachers my daughter doesn't bring home homework or graded work I cannot go over the questions that she's missed to help her she tells me that she does her work on computer on a computer at school and she doesn't know what she's missed she only knows her score the teacher said that the school was required to use Mastery connect on the computer and there are no papers to send home and parents cannot log on to the internet to find anything this is absolutely ridiculous my my child is not learning because she doesn't know what she's missed I heard that this is a pilot program so basically the kids are guinea pigs in an experiment please salvage some of this school year by eliminating this program
033right now and getting back to old-fashioned teaching techniques that we all know work question does anyone know how many Greek gods there are nobody just be clear I just raise my hand for the minute okay there's 12 12 and my daughter can name 10 of the down okay the one that's struggling in sixth grade during the parent teacher conference I was handing a handed a story that my daughter had just read on Mastery connect in English class so that I could go over it with her later here's an exerpt from that story you weave and SE as if the great manura the goddess of poetry wisdom and weaving herself has taught you her Arts when my daughter was in third grade and having to read these stories she said that there was a boy that
034even believed in Zeus the god god of the sky the gods are also discussed in history class and Poseidon was just covered last week teaching fiction in history does not prepare children for college fiction is fine in English however there is only one God and focusing on false gods is brainwashing children especially young third graders please remove these stories from the curriculum as soon as possible the fourth speaker signed up is Miss Stacy [Music] Cari space cargy District 9 Mr chair Madame Vice chair honorable members of the board serving on the board of education and representing our community was one of the most challenging humbling and greatest honors of my life like you I took an oath to serve with reverence and respect my motivation was to serve and to give back to the school
035system that gave my children so much I valued the education and the guidance that they received the teachers and staff were so incredible inspiring they inspired me to finish my degree and I stand before you today with my PhD to be conferred in December all that to say I love the Cumberland County School System it's perfect of course not but nothing is but our schools are filled with compassion and caring and utterly amazing teachers and support staff led by one of the most passionate ENT and approachable directors I've ever had the pleasure of knowing and working with when the board which I was a part of hired Mr step it was a risk he lacked some of the experience that other candidates had but I saw it as an asset we'd be getting a fresh
036start after Dr AA Maxwell bravely LED our system through the chaos of covid Mr step brought in a positive attitude a willingness to work with all of us in the community not just the board to make our schools and Community a better place for all at the January 23rd meeting Miss hel made the motion to reject Mr Stepp's contract stating quote the contract is not in the interest of the board the things we are looking for and it's not in the best interest of our district I humbly asked what is the board looking for Mr Matthews mentioned that he had heard from people inside the schools about issues were these issues brought up to Mr steep are they in his evaluation was he ever given an opportunity to hear and correct them literally hundreds of
037Cumberland County Citizens parents teacher staff had actually taken the time to post detailed comments praising the work of Mr steep not in how he promotes the school school but how he cares and engages with all of us especially the students we don't have a director of schools problem we have a board of education problem we had it when I was on the board a board that was not one voice as is part of the Pledge that we take but rather that has been manipulated by outside factions and I know this because they tried to manipulate me as well I was an outspoken and independent board member I voted in ways that upset people yet I owned my vote I would stand outside after a meeting as people yelled at me was it fun no but
038I an elected official we have the duty to take responsibility for our actions and not slink out the back door I had hoped that when I chose not to run again that all the infighting and polarization would end but I'm sad to say that it has gotten worse so I stand here this morning and ask each of you to go back to your oath remember why you're here it is because of the children the students and with that mindset I implore you to be brave enough to acknowledge the hundreds of voices that comments on social media and those of us who are here today as we show our support to Mr step and the job doing his dos and say I think I made a mistake because you don't need a new dos you have
039an amazing one what you need to do is put the students first and honor your oath of office act with integrity and vote to overturn the motion to reject Mr Stepp's contract and Mr stepp on behalf of all of us thank you for your service speaker is Stanford Johnson board chairman Mr SP uh thank you guys for giving us the opportunity to talk um I'm a bus driver here in County I've drove been here since 1999 the first time I drove School Bus and when I started work here Lan Mell was my boss shortly after that you guys the board that was on them voted to put Patty Rags bille they give her a big raise and give her a car to drive the whole nine yards to be able to do her job what
040did she do she run around with the mayor not for the kids what I'm trying to tell you guys right now is this man right here has worked with every school in this County when I pull up at crab orer with my load of kids and he's standing out there greeting those kids at 7:00 a.m. in the morning I don't see any of you board members [Music] none when I I get on my bus the morning at 5:30 a.m. I don't see none of you guys he's Rod my bus m multiple times he talks with my kids he starts at the back of the bus and works his way forward talking with my kids on my bus I have 68 kids on my bus one the other day just said Mr Stan said why are
041they getting rid of Mr SP let me tell you something before Mr steep got here not one of my kids knew who board the director was not none and I'll guarantee you right now not none of the kids in our school system know who you are because you don't participate so let me give you a little bit of idea of what I'm doing number one I drive a school bus for the county number two I work for a Christian Camp liouse Christian Camp out of out of smille Tennessee we take 80 under resource kids a year to camp for free it don't cost them anything I volunteer my time as a coordinator for cumland County to take care of those kids that don't have nothing not only that I'm the bus driver of the year
042for last year and I bet not one of you board members knew that [Music] I bet Mr step did because he comes to our meetings he shakes hands with the bus drivers he lets the bus drivers know that he appreciates are you board members though so I say keep Mr step get rid of the board Mr Joe Cheryl is next good morning uh Joe Cheryl crab or Tennessee and six District commissioner in C County um I did want to make a small statement this morning but um I think there's a bigger problem than any one thing part of it is the understanding of not only what the positions these people are gladly feeling and and you know wonderfully feeling need to do as well as the audience I'm not sure that he needs to be
043at the bus driver station he needs to be setting the policy of the school board so there is a balance of everybody a little bit at blank but I will say this one of the policy jobs of the County Commission as well as the Boe is to manage the funding flow and to manage the policy flow for the the people we represent now a little story that happened just recently the County Commission two commissions ago had a subcommittee that brought up a health and safety standards thing we we all all of us couldn't read we don't have fulltime in our lives for one job that's the people that we hire but the committee brought a health and safety standards up we voted on because it seemed like the right thing and then last commission what
044we do we heard from all the commiss all the constituents we heard from people and we realized oops we made a mistake so we sent it back to the subcommittee as no longer the thing because we realize and we have to realize occasionally we make mistakes it's not like we do this every day of Our Lives all day long so what I would submit to you is that a subcommittee to form a policy to discuss what the director of school should do that's an excellent thing because that's what this body does measuring the money flow from the federal government the state government and the County government that's also hard sometimes if the federal government pushes Zeus unfortunately we either give up the money or we give up the program so the point is you guys
045need to understand why something's here too but I would request and submit to you that that maybe this time you guys should go to a round two of negotiation and at least discuss a little bit better why you said no for those that did and for the ones that did yes think about it make sure you're right with that answer but uh I believe director sep has presented himself extremely well to the county to the students and all of our constituents thank you next we'll hear from Alicia Brown [Music] my name is Alicia Brown I live at 294 North Street I want to start off by saying I am pretty educated on what's going on I attended the a County Commission Education meeting and I can tell you who didn't the five there against phly
046step not one of them wow I am a 2010 graduate of Kon County Schools I have three girls in the school system they go to Martin um fourth fifth and seventh grade I'm nervous sorry breath I'm asking the five board members to Humble yourselves and listen to the outcry from your community yes the people voted you in so please listen I have contacted nearly all of you and I've not gotten any reply back only the ones that are for Billy step so where's the [Music] transparency during the voting voting session to renew Mr step I heard John Matthew say he had not heard from anyone supporting Mr belly or Mr belly said a lot of us don't have time because of work and other reasons to come to all these board me meetings but I
047know over 80% the people fully support Mr steep he is the only director that actually shows in his actions that he cares please I urge you listen to the parents even children my children many children crying out for you to keep Mr step he deserves the raise he's asking for and he more than deserves Unity from this board that's all I got to say next Miss Gloria Hutcherson good morning um my name is Gloria Hutcherson and my husband is Donald Hutcherson we live in Fairfield Glade we move we moved down here four years ago and um in the beginning uh for the first first 6 months that I've been going around and going around I was struck and I was devastated that the county has uh opioid problems or drug problems okay my husband and
048I are associated with The Gideons International our uh mission is to place and distribute Testaments to hotels schools nurses Mr step is already ning his head and [Music] um Rehabilitation uh women's shelter and ET we've been we every Saturday we have a prayer breakfast meeting with The Gideons and I'm sorry that we kind of late because we just came from the meeting and we've been praying for almost years and years that the school it should be open for this distribution of the Testaments and then finally Mr step open the opportunity the door for us to do it and we are just waiting for scheduling this year this part of this school and if you are talking about education about your kids I think the most important thing here is the fate and where does that
049come from from from God and how do we how do these kids find God from the Bible and from The Testament so I bled I beg you all of you who both it know for him we our mission is going to be devastated because we're going to start another relationship with another person in the in the Board of Education and the and the person who is in charge they my step open us to put the Testaments in the schools and because during the covid it stop and that's why we need a relationship again and if Mr step will not be there my heart and God will be devastated I thank you for this opportunity and I pray and pray again that you will change your mind to retain and and and renew the contract for
050Mr step thank you God bless you M Denise Melton thank [Music] you good morning board members and Mr sta I'm Denise Melton and I live in uh District 4 I'm the executive director of Cumberland Children's Center House of Hope and have been for the last 20 years additionally I serve as the vice president of the Cumberland County Trauma inform form Community Alliance also known as ticka at this time I would like to highlight Mr step's involvement with Tika and his work in the schools Mr step collaborates with Tika to develop strategies to address the impact of generational poverty and drug addiction on our children tick is composed of 26 organizations that support Mr step and the entities that work and we work for a common goal bringing resources to Children and Families Mr steep initiated
051implementation of trauma informed schools in Cumberland County last year to tackle the underlying issues faced by our children the initiative aims to remove barriers so children are ready to learn ultimately assisting the teachers additionally ticket is expanding trauma informed care into the community focusing on developing childhood inter prevention programs in collaboration with Mr step to bridge the gap for summer and after school activities which we desperately need together we are working toward creating a cradle to Career pathway for our children which will enhance the County's economic development in the future Mr step's leadership and partnership have been crucial in promoting the idea that solutions for children begin with supportive schools and the entire Community Mr step is highly involved with our children he knows the children and they know him because he engages on their
052level as any good educator would do and he recognizes that a community to support our teachers and principes and ultimately our children Mr steep recently presented data showing a 2% increase in student academic improvements across the board achieving even 1% Improvement is difficult and making it to two in his tenure is a notable AC accomplishment it is concerning to me that surrounding counties with fewer schools and Resources pay their directors higher wages than ours the discrepancy reflects our priorities and lack of foresight our teachers wages will only become somewhat competitive due to State mandates with four directors and 11 years it poses a challenge to attract new families businesses Industries and especially when school governance is often one of the first aspects evaluated not to mention what it does for morale and overall inconsistency in
053our school I urge you to reconsider Mr step's contract a majority of your constituents do not favor removing Mr step as evidenced by social media responses phone calls emails and attendance at the County Commission education committee meeting we are asking you to please listen and take to heart what this man means to our children and our County thank you very much got time for a couple of more next one is Amber [Music] cook hey guys um my name's Amber cook 142 days Road I'm six district and I want to thank y'all for letting us take a chance to speak to you today um I stand here and I ask for y'all to correct this mistake that's been made um what do you gain by getting rid of Mr step I mean that's the question really
054um because this this has come this is not about our kids our school our kids have signed a petition for Mr step does it matter that our kids have signed this petition and across the county our kids are trying to speak to you but they're not getting listened to so you say this is about the kids kids kids kids but are you listening because it's no we have a few select and I want to thank those the four that have stood up for Mr Steph and Mr Steph you have done a phenomenal job my kids know but I need to talk about the Personal Agenda in this because that's really what the head of all this is amen what what is the purpose who is behind how who's behind your decisions because it's not Mr
055step let's talk about what the real purpose here is there's other things among behind the scenes because that man has went above and beyond for our schools and our students so this is this is foolish this is embarrassing and you're not listening to the parents you're not listening to the community members the police the directors of this County who are you going to listen to what's it going to take because it is heartbreaking to know what y'all are doing to these kids in these schools and work with this man you not with this man yes quit fighting him he's not able to be manipulated that's awful how dare him you know these people have got up I don't even know how to follow these amazing people but let me tell you every one of these
056faces out here are amazing amazing moms and individuals of this County and you need to listen to what they're saying because we've had enough it's time to clean house and reevaluate reevaluate what is important in this County because I as a parent this is embarrassing and I'm done like this man needs to stay period Point Blank and it needs to be fixed today thank you one more we've got Miss Linda [Music] Clark my name is Linda Clark I live in in the homestead District but today I'm not speaking my opinion or my input for you um because you've already heard from me and I think I've not stuttered so I don't think I need to repeat that but there was a young lady who um spoke with Denise and gave her permission to share and
057she wasn't sure she was going to have time in her 3 minutes to share so I volunteered to share the words of this student think hang on this is from Aaliyah Norris Mr step was a huge part of me getting out of alternative school and for me to continue my schooling back at Phoenix High School when I was in ccas I personally emailed Mr step with a problem I had been getting out of the alternative school and he helped and even went through my file personally to make sure that I to go back and continue a regular school experience Mr step is one of the few people that was capitalized that cares about the children that go to Cumberland County Schools to see him get fired after all he has done for us kids is
058outright outrageous now she had a misunderstanding my assessment because he has not been fired and we all know that but I want you to listen to Aaliyah she saw someone who spoke and listened to her very much an approachable person and because of the intervention of Mr step she is going to graduate [Music] early good job please EXA we definely need to fix that St my remarks are finished I'm just trying fix the M thank you thank you we thank you for your public comments appreciate everything your participation we're going to take a 10 to 15 minute recess thank I'm doing good how are you doing so to see you like you manifested she is don't r started she gave up she gave up her [Music] went to on Thursday and that's when I learned
059that [Music] not I have to REM I've done that a million heard a lot I'm going to they B SU I brought my little every okay Am AC so C way better hand I'm tell you you e e e you be worried about do you like do you all the ones I gave you holy moly I the whole to all the states brought awesome three days there oh my go morning the rest of our neighborhood turn over to Mr mcet sir thank you Mr chair um just I've been talking a lot today but I haven't said my name again we just heard it my name's Chris mccardy I'm board counsel for the C County Board of Education um I always give a disclaimer because I can't hesitate and resist to give a disclaimer as a
060lawyer so I apologize for doing doing what I've been asked to talk about today are basically just some legal updates uh what are what are things going on in education law right now what are things that the board and the community need to know about maybe there's some stuff certainly with some of these things there's been confusion about in some of the coverage U my disclaimer is this I don't do politics and I mean that my job is that people don't hire me to come and give political opinions that's called lobbyist and I have no interest in being a lob um so when you hear me talk about these topics today some of these candidly are pretty Rial from a federal and state level um there's definitely two sides of everything I'm not here to
061talk about either side I just want to B make sure my client the Board of Education and its members and officials know where what is the status of the law as we see here today okay and any questions that that might come from that I want to answer those but there is no no political agenda with me it's just really just the facts man Joe Friday style okay so with that and you'll see one of the topics I bring up we have to give an explain um the first thing I want talk about is updates as to Title 9 um there's been some developments in Title 9 over the last few weeks certainly over the last year specifically and I want to make sure we clear that up for the board um moving forward because
062I'm sure you're getting questions from constituents school officials teachers Etc so I just want to make sure that there's no questions on that as we leave today so I'll talk about Title 9 I'm going to give a brief overview of sort of how we got here from a legal standpoint then I want to make sure answer any questions the board might have as that as we continue go through that so I'll leave time to that as well um so first of all let's just start with the basics with Title 9 Title 9 is obviously a statute that was enacted many many decades ago by the United States uh Congress that essentially says this that if you're receiving any type of funding from the federal government which would include obviously Public Schools would include public schools
063on the postsecondary level as well and some private schools on the postsecondary level because they take things like pel grants um if you're a public school system like us though title M applies and what does it say it says that we under no circumstances can discriminate against students or anybody else quote because of sex okay because of their sex this cenal concept right um now when a lot of people think of title n they certainly think of sports that's the first thing we all think of there was a great ESPN documentary series on Title 9 it was about women in sports I don't think there's any argument that title 9 has fundamentally changed how women can access Sports in this country no question about that that's not what I'm here to talk about today what
064a lot of people don't realize is with Title 9 like I was saying it's much bigger than that title 9 could come a title 9 could complaint could come up from sports like a facilities question or uniforms things like that title n could also come about because somebody says they've been sexually harassed um I'm not going to talk about specific things today I know we have some kids present there's no reason to I'm just going to talk about the basics um it could come about because somebody says that the way we do a curriculum and the way we've designed a curriculum is is disadvantageous to to one sex or the other I mean there's all kinds of ways in which a title n complaint could come about what has happened since 2020 which is sort
065of led us to where we are today legally is in 2020 there was a decision by the United States Supreme Court called boock versus Clayton County um that that case was under title seven and I'm sorry to talk about so many Roman numerals today you guys I was waiting I was waiting I knew y'all were setting me up for that you were here for the last meeting I messed up r a numeral count so I deserve that all right so I'm going get it right today so title seven is a provision of the of the Civil Rights Act which was obviously enacted in the 60s um I'm by lynon Johnson and title 7 is about the workplace so title 7 doesn't have anything to do with kids hopefully not title 7 is about in in
066American workplace private Enterprise public Enterprise what are the rules in which discrimination occurs or what happens if discrimination occurs so title 7 is much broader than Title 9 I'm getting there to the point in a second I promise title 7 prevents any type of work workplace discrimination based on sex religion national origin you name there's a lot of things under okay it's been in effect since the 60s I can assure you it's not going there what happened in 2020 was the United States Supreme Court in a decision written by Justice Neil Gorsuch um basically decided that the word sex as we applied under title 7 so work play would be read broadly to include protections for sexual orientation and gender identity right now people ask me in the workplace in America since 2020 is any
067type of discrimination based on someone's gender identity or sexual orientation illegal answer is yes so my opinion Supreme Court says so okay Justice scor wrot the opinion so what happened with that is that when the word sex under title 7 was expanded a lot of Advocates as you can imagine took the opportunity to say well hey wait a minute then it should be expanded to Title 9 as well and that's led to an amazing amount of debate amazing amount of political discourse and a whole lot of litigation I don't think there's any debate over that right so what's happened since then is under the under President Biden's Administration uh after the bowo decision came out and after he came into office in 2021 the United States Department of Education put out opinions basically saying hey
068we we agree with boar and we think that same definition of sex so as protecting gender identity and sexual orientation should also apply under title nbody still following me I know I talk a lot okay that's what so as you all can imagine and I think as we follow that caused a lot of things to happen a lot of consternation a lot of litigation a lot of political gamesmanship let's put it that way on both sides um and since then from the legal side there's been a lot of backing importantly as of basically last spring the United States Department of Education G President Biden issued its 2024 rule on Title 9 what's important about about that rule what's important about that rule is for the first time officially United States Department of Education said hey
069we are going to say Title 9 as we read it includes protection for sex plus gender identity plus sexual orientation at that point 26 States within the next few weeks sued United States Department of Education saying that they're reading that right that's the the non-technical way of putting it but that was what they were saying uh Tennessee obviously is one of those States those States uh moved for an injunction to block the implementation of the 2024 rule from from President Biden's Administration and that those cases primarily the ones involved in Tennessee were filed in the eastern district of Kentucky so the United States district court for of Kentucky in Lex what happened there what happened there was the judge in that case the federal district judge blocked entered an injunction blocking the implementation of Title
0709 in any of the states I'm sorry the new title 9 rule in any of the States including Tennessee which would have included that expansive definition of sex okay so since then there's been more and more legal rang I don't know if yall know this but there was a presidential election as well um so things have changed obviously politically and legally the court and the six C court of appeals agreed with the injunction so that rule I just want to be clear there was a lot of press about it the 2024 rule issued by the US Department of Education under President Biden has never been in effect in Tennessee it was immediately blocked and there's an injunction that went down January of this year that judge want to get too boring although I'm already flirting
071with that right but the judge in Kentucky issued a final ruling his original ruling was a preliminary injunction which means hey this I'm going to basically pause while I take a harder look at it is the best best way to understand what an injunction is while I'm pausing it nothing can happen Okay he since then has issued a final ruling agreeing with his initial ruling which is he moved to essentially eradicate or void the entire 2024 rule on Title 9 issued by the bid Administration what's happened now the reason I want to talk about it today is as of literally last week believe it was last Friday president Trump's acting head of the office of civil rights for the Department of Education issued a letter saying we now officially as the US Department of Education
072agree with the court in contu so what does all that mean that is all that means is right now Accord to the United States Department of Education and according to federal courts Title 9 is not read in Tennessee school systems or by tennessy public officials as including protection for gender identity discrimination or sexual orientation discrimination to be clear it still applies in the workplace so if you're talking about an adult employee those protections are in there boo says so that's the Supreme Court since 2020 for kids for sports for things like those issues issues that have come up a lot they do not apply one CU they have a court opinion and two because the United States Department of Education says that is now our official stance as well and they have directed schools to
073go back to what we call the 2020 rule which came out under previous Secretary of Education the boss under President Trump so that is where we are right now what does that mean that was a lot of talking to finally get to the point right what that means is Tennessee since 2020 has enacted a number of laws on gender identity issues okay to summarize those laws one would be we have a law in this state that is now we know absent from federal challenge okay we there's been a lot of talk that if those laws stayed on the book and I'll talk about there in a second that the previous administration was essentially going to take legal action to Avid those laws because they would have conflicted with Federal position now the federal position is
074the same as Tennessee's position that's the point okay so those state laws what do they say there's always a lot of talk about this so I think it's a good opportunity to clear up where the law is in Tennessee one we have a law in athletics it's been on the books for over two years now what does that law say in Tennessee that law says that if you're going to play an inter Scholastic sport School sport then you can only play a sport that matches your gender at birth that's Tennessee state law okay now again that also matches there was a federal executive order put down this week by President Trump Cally saying they expect schools to follow that same concept so federal and state now are in AI what are people's politics about that
075that's up to y'all I'm just telling you federal and state positions on the law now are in the line um so where does that come in there are some sports I just want to make sure people know though that this gets real dicey how to say it there's some sports in Tennessee that we consider what I call kind of gendered sports there's some sports that don't you don't we don't tell you it have to be a gender for example there's nothing under TW SL bylaws people know this that says you have to be a male to play football we've always considered under TF play bylaws that females want to try for football or males that's up to them if you actually look on the TSA website it doesn't say boys football what does it say
076football football football we have a lot of sports like that so for example baseball is according to t a non-gendered sport girls could try for baseball they always have been able to this is not new right we have a lot of sports in Tennessee as y'all can imagine y'all can probably name them that the T does consider to be gender Sports examples would be boys basketball girls basketball girls volleyball right those girls softball those Sports now very clearly so for example if a person born a male who has since transitioned and considers himself some female wants to try for High School girls softball the answer in Tennessee is no that's state law in fact if a school system and we are not doing that but if a school system is violated that they lose funding
077from the state they can be sued so there's no schools that I know of certainly doing that in Tennessee it's been the law now for over two years so if y'all are hearing stories about this happen and that happening I'll please make sure you're clicking on the story cuz I'll promise you it's not happening in Tennessee you're probably reading a story that's probably from the West Coast or somewhere else okay cuz the laws in those states are different the laws in those states are different as for sure okay the other laws that come into play bathrooms comes up a lot bathrooms and locker rooms we also have a state in Tennessee the accommodation bill which basically says that if a student wants an accommodation because they don't feel comfortable or safe going to the current
078restroom offered to them then state law they can ask to us to accommodate that there's two accommodations we're allowed to give one we can let them use a private bathroom facility like a coach's office or the teacher lounge or two they can only use a locker room or restroom that matches again you hear a broken record for the gender of your birth so if it's a public restroom or public loer room in Tennessee law you you can never go in there unless that matches the gender re birth okay so that's that's a law on that so I want to clear that up too you're hearing about it would be sex at Birth right not gender oh I'm sorry sex at birth that's a way to put it yeah that's that's my fault for not being
079a good science student growing up but yeah no that's a fair point sex at BIR you're right it's a good point I think about gender identity so I think it floods my own language you're right um we going back to that yeah sex at Birth whatever your sex is according to your original birth certificate so even if we were to get for example a modified birth certificate an amended birth certificate from another state we under Tennessee law can only rely upon the original birth certificate is issue got burn okay the last one I would point out is names that comes up a lot as well so how does how do names work in Tennessee so Tennessee has a law in the books that is very clear and it's actually predate some of this controversy that
080essentially says that if we have an official record if students official record so that's a lot of things that could be a grade card could be a high school diploma could be what system do we use do we use power school or Skyward or Skyward thank you there's different ones so I apologize uh Skyward um could be a progress report anything like that that we issue we can only utilize the Student Legal name that's Tennessee law so if you know I always joke that my son's name's Tate I can assure you a lot of people including meon Tater uh he's going to like to shout out here today um but Tat's not on his diploma and we it won't okay cuz Again official school records are he's going to be T um so nicknames anything
081like that really we can't use those anymore as well on official records for example my name's Chris I'm Christopher I don't like people calling me Christopher but my gosh that's suppos to be on My Grave card now Tennessee ball right makes sense um so that's sort of where we are right now with the law where Title 9 is um again I thought it was important a because we just got new guidance from the US Department of Education literally within the last week as to what the Now official completely opposite position on this is from literally 6 months ago thought it's important to talk about it and then B there's just always a lot of confus on this issue um I think everybody would probably agree that depending on which website you clicked on um that
082sounded bad I News website let me add that word um that you're going to get a different version of how this is covered and a different version of how this is gone that's just a fact in my opinion I I don't do those things I'm just telling you what the law says I've read the case law I've read the the the literally the dear colleague letter that came out this week I've read the Eastern District's opinion I'm not pulling this from a news story I'm pulling this from the official so with that and sometimes I do talk like the micro machine man I told you um any questions on this issue [Music] specific nothing nothing okay so I just want to clear it up nobody's walking out thinking oh I read a story last week
083about um a kid wearing cat ears that got a litter box given to first of all you might have read that story um that didn't happen in tenness and then two there is no such thing under federal or state law providing accommodations for C presentation I don't even know what to call that by the way um so there's a lot of things out there that I think are always out there there's a lot of things that are just not accurate and there's a whole lot more things that are just not happening at Tennessee because again we've had these laws on the books now most of the ones that it's referenced for more than two years okay thank you yes ma'am got for the clity all right so oh even claps I get that I'll tell
084you it's rare that aw I wasn't asking for more I'm just making a joke of my own experience but I appreciate no Roman Roman numeral oh you believe me I never get credit on that all right all right so now let's move into something again not not controversial at all let's talk about the special session of our recent uh Tennessee legisl okay you guys all saw that in the headlines about that there's a whole lot in a whole lot of places um I just want to clear up what just happened at the special session by the way to be very clear the special session was called by the governor the governor has the power to call special sessame when he or she should want to here it's obviously he going back to 9 there um
085but this special session was called for two primary purposes and ended up being three one was to talk about vouchers which we're going to call the educational Freedom Act and scholarships is what they're called but it's it's aboutou your concept not controversial true two was talking about immigration reform on the federal level and how we're going to cooperate with that and three was about hurricane relief funds that were for obviously a l large part of Upper East Tennessee that were affected by the devastating flooding and hurricane D last year so I'm not going to spend any time today I don't think y want me to on flood relief the bottom line is they got okay which is a good one yes um I do want to talk about sort of briefly the immigration part of
086the special session and I also want to talk about more more importantly answering any questions on the education Freedom Act and again that's the name given to the act by the sponsors um education Freedom Act what it basically does and what it did cuz it was passed if everybody was following is it set aside $45.90 um there'll be 20,000 of those that are available next school year as of right now it's still limited certainly the legis has the power and many think they will modify that in future years to expand the program but right now it's somewhat limited again it's going to be open to 20,000 students what what are those scholarships what can they be useful they're given so I I want to also clarify this because there's also questions about this there will
087be no money as I understand this bill provided directly from the state to any private school that's not how V work the money if the person applies to use an education Freedom scholarship will be granted to the household that's requested it and they will then have the ability as they see fit to utilize that for private school tuition if that's where they want to go so that that's how that works so when people ask me how does that work for example if it's a religious school well it wouldn't work if it was religious school based on case law if the money went straight from the government to the school but because it doesn't the money goes to the household of the citizen that citizen decides do I want to use a religious school non-religious school
088you name it whatever kind of school they're looking for okay another thing that came out in the bill that I will point out is one half of those scholarships so 10,000 have to be reserved for households that are under 300% of the federal level that you have to be at to obtain qualification for free and reduced lunch all right that number right now is about $36,000 so really we're talking about households that combined make I've got the number at 109 350 $9,350 so if you're going to half those scholarships have to go to households that are making less than that combined less than that combine the other half completely wide open to I don't know if it's first come first serve I don't think the state's put details out about that yet but they will
089be available for other household um there's been a lot of talk and I want to make sure we hit this too that there was a provision added to the bill um that would basically require local school systems local school board specifically to pass a resolution that would say that we agree to essentially move forward and we know what this bill says and we're moving forward understanding that's the law that has to happen if those school systems are going to receive funding from the state to provide $2,000 bonuses to their teachers to their teachers okay so every school board if you want that money that those resolutions have to be passed and submitted to the Department of Education by June of this year and they are then able to use if the school systems do that
090school board's off have to make that decision then those that money we don't know when it'll come in yet I'm assuming since it's not even due till June we're probably looking at July I don't know if y'all know this state doesn't move that fast um I'd say that if anybody was sitting here CU that's just the truth um there's going to be some interesting Logistics to that and how that's going to work cuz it's the people that are eligible would be anybody that's a K12 teacher that's the state's language again I don't want anybody coming back later and saying why did the county Reserve this only for teachers nobody on this board did that that's what the state decided to do it's k k through2 teachers that that were teachers during the 24 25 school
091years that's this year so a lot of those payments might even be issued until next school year and again I want to be clear about that cuz that's in the law and that's based on the deadline that the state has provided not anything this school system has done so if you have teachers or have questions about why is that when are we getting that when are we getting that we can't even submit it by the deadline until June we're going to try to submit it early if you guys approve it but we can't hurry up the state and issuing those payments so we don't know right now if those will happen this year or some or all happen next year that is one issue um just want to clarify that too the bill is also
092very clear it's it's teachers only that that money is being supplied by the state that would be K through 12 so even if you're a prek teacher te for some reason the state has decided that that preex teachers would not qualify under that under that governance um it's supposed to also be people that are in a classroom instructing and being evaluated so candidly under the state's provision administrators would not count a lot of our classified employees teachers assistants um bus drivers Etc would not count again they count to me I know they count to every member of this board I'm just telling you the state has not provided bonus money for those individuals it's only yes ma'am it was my understanding from watching the explanation of this amendment on the floor is the the reason
093that they're wanting this resolution is for that the districts are committing that if we receive this money it's not going to be used for anything else it's going to be used per the stipulations in section four for $2,000 for each teacher and both of the the um resolutions that have been provided one by tsba that was sent out to everybody yesterday so I'd suggest you look at that and then the one that Mr mccard sent out to us the day before yesterday um I like yours just personally to say that there's no there's a little more information in that but um the resolution is us as as a school district committing to passing that 2,000 on directly I'm glad you pointed that out that is clear so yeah the state the resolution is confirmed officially
094by the school board that that money can only be utilized for the purpose of take getting the funds so the $2,000 per teacher then returning those directly to the teacher yeah um obviously this goes about saying probably that there there have to be deductions made you got Uncle Sam's always asking for their part but but from the school syst perspective all that money will be earmarked if approved by the board to go directly to the people that qualify to reserve it to receive it does that answer that was that clarify I'm glad you asked that um any questions about the education Freedom yeah um anything yes sir what if we don't pass the resolution then then we do not receive the money from the state and the and those people would not receive that money
095unless locally you decided to find the money and give it to them direct and that and that was my question if we find the money yeah other ways to get that money there I guess is this resolution binding Us in any way to right the the education Freedom Act that that's a good question not the way that I believe it's been written um the way that I've written the resolution and I think tsba did the same is to basically acknowledge that we as a school board are acknowledging that we have to do this to receive the money that our teachers have been promised but in my opinion by no means bind you to to to say that you can never object to that movement forward that you have to be in favor of vouchers candidly
096I don't think constitutionally that could be done um there's nothing I mean there's always over there's always overlap in the board you guys have your own constitutional freedoms you have the freedoms to speak on behalf of the citizens and the community that you're elected to perform on behalf of so even if it did did say you approve it this year there is nothing that the state could do in my opinion to bind you to say you can't disagree later with something the state's done or say you change your minds or there's nothing in the resolution there's nothing in the resolution it says anything but that 2000's been passed on to the in fact the resolution specifically references just the portion about the 2000 right that was my question is because the resolution states that um
097to comply with the requirements under section 4 um of the EFA so so it was kind of like what were those strings but I mean going back and reading that I didn't see any actual strings attached to it no there's not and in fact section four is specifically only referencing the part about the $2,000 it doesn't the resolution that we put right now the one that you guys might use doesn't even refer to the scholarships or the vouchers portion of the bill and that was definitely on purpose I fig that out and that doesn't take the place of us still having to do the pay rate to get to 50 no not at all not at all and in fact again it's also going to be determine of of the school board about how other
098Rises or how other employees might be affected but the only thing the state has agreed to do if that resolution is passed is again provide those $2,000 per teacher for the 24 25 K through 12 teachers that that is that is it that's a lot but it's that's it so then this doesn't even go into any sort of our budget at all because this is directly coming from the state for a specific purpose yeah it'll be it'll have to pass through us because obviously you guys are the W2 employer the state can't just issue wages you understand where I'm going issue wages but no it's the way I look at it it'll go through our coffers certainly but it's a pastor we don't have to go ahead and put anything in the budget wise for
099the allotment for that correct and in fact for that reason I've had this question normally if you do a resolution that could affect spending that resolution has to go before the County Commission here the state has not required that the state is only asking for Resolutions from the board which again confirms what you're saying which is just a pass through it shouldn't affect the budget okay holds us accountable for passing it on to the teacher right once we get it right in in that language with the K12 language since we have so many prek teachers also the prek teachers are not they would not automatically receive that money if the if the prek if the school board wanted to consider which is up to the board other teachers qualifying for that then the school board
100would probably have to make up the difference yes sir in fact take out the word property the school board would have to make up the difference which would require a budget amendment there yeah is there any minimum number of days that they had to serve in the 23 24 year to be eligible for the $2,000 I haven't I don't believe so I don't think they they specified that I'll go back and look at that but I don't believe so I think it just said employed as a teacher during 2024 2025 and honestly what I'm hoping is going to happen is that sometimes when these things come out for example another bill that we had a few years ago y'all remember is the pral lead pay pral lead bill um there was some gaps in that
101bill and I'm not being mean when I say it just some logistical practical gaps in the bill that later tdoe put out a FAQ on and was able to give us more guidance on that but the bill does not specified no so one question I have that I think a lot of us in the board Council world have is what if somebody was on leave they qualified or the person that came in for the inim or do they both qualify for it that's another I don't I think the state's probably going to have to answer that before June but right now we don't have guidance on that so is it essentially the our HR department's responsibility to go back through and audit the employment in that year and then issue checks to all the employees
102in that time frame yes and no my I think I'm hedging on you a little bit there CU I think I'm I don't know exactly how the state's going to tell us to do it process-wise cuz it just got passed we know that the bill basically instructs that the school system once the resolution is passed by June has to submit the resolution we don't know yet the logistics on how it's going to work from a pay or when or where kind of thing does that make sense so right now what I'm hoping happen soon is the department sends out some guidance for us on who should we count as teachers like some of it's easy I want to be very clear if you're teaching a classroom this year and you're you're a tenard or non-
10310-e teacher working full-time you're going to qualify there's there's no question there the bigger question I have is what about somebody that was on leave the whole year um what about somebody that was working an interim role I mean which which which people do we submit as as requesting reimbursement board and right now I don't think we have full answers on that we're going to have to get a little more practical guidance from the state does that make sense Mr but but isn't it if if the uh if they have a teaching certificate which is you know the law in Tennessee it's it's not necessary for teaching certificate cuz you could and I don't know if we have any but if you let's say you're a licensed teacher but you're in an administrative role or
104let's say you're a licensed teacher and you're working as a TA cuz you classroom teacher just go a classroom teacher then more than likely yes you're going to get just a classroom teacher even if you just come in from college oh yeah first your first time you would get a bonus there's no question those those teachers are going to qualify the the harder ones are the you don't want me to get into all the weeds here but like one question I have is what about counselors so our counselors a lot of our counselors K8 teach classes so I can make a really good argument that's a teacher right to teach guidance but a lot of our counselors at the high school level don't so the that's going to require the state to tell us sort
105of where the boundaries there they haven't done a great job in my opinion not getting into the politics of the bill just giving us more details I think TD is going to have to fill in some of those gaps we always have more details to come it seems like after the legislative session yeah and that happens and it's very the parental believe Act is the best um compared to where I can give you cuz there were just some logistical questions with that that t T really did a good job Christy Ballard I'll give her a shout out is TD's general counsel she's done a great job for a long time and her office put out a really helpful FAQ memo I'm sorry after the pral lead bill that's that answered almost all of her question
106I expect that'll happen here too just I'm just trying to understand I guess the onuses on the district to to make sure that we make that request hold correct yeah so once we get the guidance and we have a better idea of who we should be submitting for reimbursement forward then that would be on us to submit say okay tdoe is saying these are the people that we qualify as teachers this how we read the bill here here we're going to be submitting or requested yeah correct first we have to put in resolution saying we want it yeah we you see us needing the adop or amend policy to accommodate no sir I don't think so I can't think of any policy we'd have to am in the only decision again that's going to be
107significant one before the board here is going to be a do you want to pass the resolution right do you want to do that b what would the resolution look like if you did which you get different options the one that we've sent I could always tweak that or the one tsba asent both would work under the law and then the third option obviously being if there are people that the board after we get more guidance from the state if the board feels like there should be other people that would receive a similar bonus that the state doesn't cover then the board will have to decide is that something the board wants to consider handling themselves does that makes sense Mr M I don't want you you guys to I would recommend not considering that
108yet until we get better direction from the state as to where those gaps are going to be okay does that make sense yeah yes it'd be a little premature right now because we'd be voting on something and sort of yelling into the wind a little bit that's something that we need to be looking at too though is is what's the number what's that number of how many we're going to include into that and Y how much we want have to come up 100% yeah and I think the board could pass or consider the resolution I think as early as you wanted to yeah because the resolution just basically says we're going to be open to doing this and we certainly want to help our teachers and get that money right and then the board could
109could figure out later after we get hopefully more guidance from the state what that submission is going to look like yes sir that all make sense okay any other questions no all right um the other and I won't spend as much time on this part um the other significant thing that the legisl legisl did during this last special session was pass what I call Immigration Reform um from the state level I'm going to talk about the Federal in a second we could go through that whole thing in detail but it does to me two big things one is we have a new division of the State Department of Homeland Security not federal Homeland Security but the state's Homeland Security division called the centralized immigration I'm sorry immigration enforcement division that is now coming into play
110the way to understand that is essentially this is our state of Tennessee saying there's a new initiative by the feds clearly that everybody's about for immigration enforcement it's going to be different than the last Administration and this is the state of Tennessee's legisl saying we support that and we are going to cooperate and make sure local law enforcement is cooperating as well in fact they want to cooperate so much that they're creating a separate division of home and security to make that process even easier for the feds here in Tennessee that are looking for again information sometimes raid sometimes obviously deportation so at the end of the day candidly the federal government for obvious reasons has almost complete power over immigration and you residency status and citizenship that that doesn't change anything this is really
111just more of a hey we AG this is the state say we agree the federal government we're going to cooperate and make the process stronger any questions on that that leads into the last thing I was going to talk about unless there's questions um that would be there's been a lot of obviously press of this reference tip as to president Trump's new initiative on immigration uh specifically immigration enforcement what's that going to look like how does that work there's been a lot of phone calls that I know schools have been receiving board members have been receiving probably emails I can't even imagine the number of questions guidance counsel has received and and other people in that World um what's what's sort of sparked all that is one even before the election I don't think it's
112again a surprise to say that President Trump one of his primary platforms while running was immigration reform and and making sure that people that are undocumented um especially people that President Trump or the administration considers are dangerous are found and deported I think that's been a clear directive of this Administration um what happened though well I think it's become a say blows up but why it's become a bigger point of question with schools is on January 20th the Homeland SEC so by the way Department of Homeland Security is the primary Department ice which is Immigration and custo Customs Enforcement falls under Homeland Security so just always know that's why it's not it's just part of Homeland Security Group um they issued a memo that essentially says this that there used to be under President Biden
113I think that farther back protected area status for immigration enforcement what does that mean that meant that that if you're going to conduct a raid going to look for possibly a suspect going to look for even a serve a warrant things to that effect that immigrations and Customs was supposed to stay away from churches schools and healthc Care Facilities these were protected area status not not by legislation but by previous administrations directly it was a m what's what's happened on January 20th is now under the Trump Administration they have withdrawn that protective area stats they basically withdrawn a memo and they did have the power to do that because they were just withdrawing a memo from a previous administration not not changing the law just changing a directive how they read um so obviously that
114gained a lot of headlines um people in schools I think I can understand why people started thinking are we going to start having raids at schools or people coming in and body armor things of that nature since then I think it's important to say that's been not a month but we're getting closer to it there's there's been no raid of a school in this country that I'm aware of by Ice there was a story that came out um Chicago public schools that they they thought that ice agents had showed up to ask some questions and be aggressive but even that came retracted later cuz it was Secret Service agents um ice actually immediately put out a statement saying that wasn't us they didn't say it that way but that was the point right um and
115the reason I'm highlighting that is there's another part of that when they released that memo taking away the protected area status there was another part of the statement that came with it from home security that said but we still expect our agents in enforcing these laws to use quote common sense I always think that's a good recommendation anyway but again I'm probably going to Verge into opinion here I've seen no indication from the current Administration that they're looking to raid schools um I think for so many reasons that would be very controversial don't care what politics you have um there's been no move to do that that just doesn't seem to be something that that is indicative my opinion would be schools happen to be part of that prior memo which included churches facilities so
116schools got added in withdrawal but I've just seen no indication and even the speed at which Homeland Security issued a statement saying that wasn't Us in Chicago to me is indicative that they're not really trying to come to schools and plan on raids now if you ask me is it possible certainly but I've just seen no plan even informally that that is going to occur what I think is important is we've had a lot of questions about what happens legally and what do schools do if an ice agent or anybody from come much were to come and ask questions U so I'm going to cover that real quick if I can one is there's always been a misconception in my mind of the law as to people will ask this question um why would School
117ever it's not me I'm giving the hypothetical person here why would schools ever even have to worry about that cuz don't you have to be a citizen to enroll in a public school the answer is no the answer is no that's not a state initiative that's not a board initiative that's US Supreme Court president there is a case called piler versus doe which was decided by the United States Supreme Court in 1982 which is still good precedent that says exactly that it says that public schools in this country doesn't matter if they're in Tennessee or California cannot discriminate against students based on their immigration status so student as long as you're living in this area we don't ask you if you're a citizen nor canille and that that could never change unless the Supreme Court
118changes its mind because again right now that's been the law since 1982 students cannot and do not discriminate based on students immigration status or their parents immigration status or their citizenship status nor can again that be a violation of federal law so what I think Could Happen certainly moving forward now that ice agents have more free reign to show up at schools and ask questions ice agents could certainly show up to a school and ask questions they could ask for records if they're searching for somebody or looking for ways in which to find somebody that might be a suspect um but if that happens just so y'all know and I want to be clear about it that we we've sent guidance out to schools and school officials across the state everybody knows but it's the
119same guidance that's always been on the books it's not changed which is if anybody comes to a school period I don't care if you tell us you're an ice agent or from Mars but hopefully not Mars but the first thing we're going to ask you for is what id okay we don't I mean I don't want to tell stories here I could do it all day based on the fact they represent all school systems but shockingly enough people try to get into school sometimes with false premises so we are not letting anybody no offense to ice or Homeland Security or whoever else unless you can show us an ID okay I had a school I'm not had a school system not this one pretty far from here that had an issue one time that department
120of children's services employees would just just not carry their Badges and um they would show up no not also slandering DCS I'm saying this is a very centralized small area problem but you know in that situation i' be called DCs and say I don't care who works here if you don't give us a badge show and you work for DCS you're not getting in okay and if they don't want to just throw in their car that morning that's not my problem yeah okay so we're going to do the same thing here it's not anti-law enforcement to take that position it's safety of children that's right we want to make sure if you come to our school that you show us the proper back badge Andor proper government issued ID and we're going to make sure
121that we document that but you're just not getting access period And I hope that every that's a parent or grandparent or human being would understand why we do that so one is we're going to ask for ID two what we're supposed to ask if they were to show up in a school setting supposed to ask what is the legal basis for the reason you're here real again not a confrontational question just you know why are you here uh you're showing up to the school I'm the school principal I want to know we also want teachers to know we don't want teachers to be the ones that have to answer those questions we're not asking teachers to do that if you I can't imagine this is going to happen but I'm just going to give a
122hypothetical if an agent were to show up at a school and is walking through and starts asking you questions we want you to refer that to always the building level supervisor they're probably going to call central office and they'll deal with that from an administrative standpoint we're not being uncooperative about doing that we're wan to make sure that every person that shows up gets the same answer and the only way we can do that is make sure that the people giving those answers are the same people every time mhm okay um so what would they do let's say you uh we haven't had this happen but let's say an ice agent were to show up and say that they're requesting the student records of John du they want to look at those records because they
123could be relevant to a current investigation our question then would be okay well you need to give us a warrant or a subpoena or an order and that would have to be a judicially issued warrant subpoena or order it can't be what we call administrative warrant or order and that's that's not me talking again that's the courts have been consistent on that for more than a decade why would we want that because under federal law Student Records are completely confidential we have a law called furpa family educational rights and Privacy Act which is the equivalent for Student Records what Hippa is for medical and we are never going to turn over some students records to somebody unless they give us a judicially relevant and clear reason while we have to again that's not to be
124uncooperative that is we want to protect kids that includes their records we want to make things are done right if we ever do so that's that is the basic summary of sort of where we are I hope that clears up a lot of the things that have been thrown out there just want to say again I'm just not aware and that's only been a little less than a month but I'm not aware of ice conducting threatening even showing up at a school in this country to conduct a raid um personally do not think it's going to happen it's just wood there um but if it does we will make we'll do the same process I just talked to you a second ago right who are you show us your badges show us an order that
125would indicate you have a Judicial permission to enter this school cuz otherwise that could not happen any [Music] questions thank you for that I run the Pregnancy Center in town and I have Hispanic clients who have children in school and my Hispanic volunteer gets stories they're very afraid of where they're at and what could be done and what can't be done so I'll be glad to share some of that information with her yeah that's the one thing that I did want to say for certain because there's just been and it's confusing time you know andly that's not anytime there's a change in administration we all should remember there's always confusing times I mean it's just sort of how it goes um but I think one thing that has been glossed over and based on coverages
126that Supreme Court case is still relevant and it's still pressing of the country so until or if that changes if you live in a community that is your only requirement to go to the Community Schools um so there is no immigration or citizenship requirement to attend public schools nor can we discriminate against students who who don't have that status fact we can't even ask right that's all right no room numerals were messed up there okay go ahead I'm going to keep getting a lot of I'm going to keep getting a lot of ground out of that go ahead I I don't want you in this you are bored no one reason they wanted me to do this is to clear it up for the community well I'm happy to well one perspective with respect to
127your clients and others because I've teachers in my family that are concerned about my gosh this coming after the children um is that everything I have seen about this is that they are seeking the most evil criminals first on this priority of who they seeking them first get out of here and knowing the terrorists trait of hiding behind children and women and you know in churches um you know I I wish there was a perspective of if you could view this is a branch of law enforcement that to protect and serve that they could be very well seeking someone who intends harm for those children so cooperating with them may save some lives and so and just law enforcement person interest no I think that's a really well put what I would can I add
128something to that I don't disagree with that in any way shape re form and I think pointing out to people that we're going to do things the right way in terms of asking for ID asking for orders because to your point if you're if you're doing this as part of a criminal investigation which they they fall hand in hand you're going to have that warning you're going to have that sub you're going to have that order so if everybody's doing it the way they're supposed to there are checks and balances already in place that we're going to follow and that we know Isis said publicly over and over again they're following that that it just that's there absolutely other question well thank you for your comment yes may I have a question about vouchers um
129you said that I'm supposed to say scholarships I'm just joking I'm just kidding I'm just kidding scholarships I'm playing with you you're good you're good you're good um you said that it has to go to the household and not the institution correct okay because I was speaking to refer to senator Paul Bailey and he they are trying to get that where it would go it could not go to a person a parent it can't go to home school it has to go I'm glad you said that it is not right now there was talk previously that homeschool parents would be able to use the quote scholarships but that is not part of the current bill that was passed okay this is for this is for tuition reimbursement ESS and he was also trying to get
130it to where because my biggest concern was I I believe parents have a right to to have their kids however they wish them to be taught I'm concerned about money being taken from public school and then that private school kicks that kid out and they come back and the money doesn't come back with them so one this sort of goes back to what we I was asked earlier uh and I understand that concern I'm not you'll see where I'm going um right now we we have the basic parameters of sort of who qualifies how they qualify what it can be used for again previous iterations of the bill hom school was talked about more that was not part of this current bill that passed um but one of the questions I think tdoe is going
131to have to help fill in the gaps on is how does that work so for example what I don't what I can't answer for you t that right now is let's say that like what the process looks like I assume there's going to have to be some sort of a hey I want this money because my child I want them to attend ex school but then to your point does that mean that you after that you just do it one time and then you trust the parent keeps the kid in the school or do you have to submit paperwork later to the state that shows the invoices that have been paid right now we just don't know the logistics because that direction those again those sort of details have not been published does that make
132sense yeah absolutely and I think maybe some clarification on that because I was under a different understanding than you and I don't have the bill in front of me but I did I thought that they had determined in this bill that it didn't go directly to the household that it went that it went to the school that they were showing through for enrollment in yes first I apologize guess the way look at it is but the parent is choosing it the parent the parent has to choose it the parent has to put that forward but then the money you're right the money does go directly it's not passing through the household that's going to the school that they've been accepted for enrolling in yeah and and that's my fault for saying it in the wrong
133way but the it can't be the parent initiative it can't be the school asking for the money the parent basically has to say I want this here's why please direct this money to go here and they have to show that they've been accepted in the school and um then there was some language in there regarding if the if the student comes back to public school the criteria for testing you know if they come back during the middle of the year and so forth so they did build some of that into the bill as well that's right well Senator belly did say he wanted to do it the money by semester he would like for it to be added in that the first semester and if they if they come back that at least we would
134get the second semester money back in our system so I don't know if he got that language or not but the better way to put what I was what I'm saying earlier what we're saying is there's no direct pipeline just to private schools from the state it would have to be initiated by parents as part of the household household decision then that one that makes sense yeah better way to put it other questions okay I've talked a long time no do good thank you thank you all thank you Mr mccardy thank you sir thank you we'll move to strategic plan discussion item six want to take that [Music] away want me to start okay all righty um just for as we discussed earlier the beginning of the meeting for y'all's review um we had section
135or page 102 evaluate the plan so just some guidelines for boards for evaluating the Strategic plan from our tsba um Cumberland County Board retreat ret um so those of you who have your booklets that attended the retreat last year it's in those booklets um for those of you that are new to the board you've got them attached to the agenda and then also the um the annual agenda the board annual agenda that Scott referenced earlier there's a month by month in there for you all to take a look at just as recommended things again we can do them we cannot do them I'm sure we'll come up with things that we want do on our own that keeps the board on Pace as we go through the year um for our own plan things we
136want to do like maybe School tours um media information I mean just you know touch points for us as a board throughout the year for our operations uh so just have those in there for review for us to look at and then at our work session we had talked about what's going to everybody to think about what's going to be the best way to break down the Strategic plan and for us to start looking at it with Mr step and the administration to see what if anything needs to be tweaked for going into next year's school year I guess 25 26 school year to be more specific um the 5year plan so we're what two years into this plan now we starting year three next school year are you looking for suggestions today or yeah
137that's what we thought today we could kind of come up with a a plan of attack get us all on the same page for that my suggestion is so the SWAT is analyze the SWAT and see if our strengths are still the same or if we our strengths have changed same with you know the weaknesses opportunities and threats have they changed do we need to change our Focus I think that's that's the best starting point is the spot so when I was looking at it we've got five sections of the Strategic plan plus we have our mission vision and core beliefs keys so I didn't know if we wanted to kind of Break It Out by chunks and add like a chunk to each work session and we could take that swad approach in the
138work session or if we want to break it into two half days or two evening meetings and it's figured based on everybody's schedule what's going to be the best thing including Mr step and the administration would it just be a special cult meeting just for that topic or just work session for strategic plan I mean that all kind of falls under What annual planning Retreat work session whatever we want to call it I just think the sw's the best place to start I think um you know with CTE CCT we're really strong in that area and and I know whenever we do a SWAT where where I'm at with in the private sector take those strengths and we say we're going to monitor and maintain or we're just going to monitor and then we go
139we move over to something else that we can focus on for our work plans and our strategic plan I think you know with our strategic plan right now we we have a real focus on K12 CCT and I think that should just be going to monitor that's my opinion I think we can all work on that but and then what I've seen from tsba is that they would they focus on maybe three high level topics instead of five so I think I think um academics think ath Athletics and K12 uh CTE fits in academics as enrichment or part of the academics M I don't know just just from um St back looking at it safety educational succcess and um great place to work is what I call it but you know people community great place
140to work something like that the three the three key topics and I think everything else could fit in that that's just my opinion though so so um in February's work session then um academics is a big umbrella right yes and what you're looking at is maybe rolling a couple of things under meath that academics being the priority safety as well safety security as well um so do we want to look at tackling the academics piece at the first in the February work session does that work for everybody I think I know you and I talked about you coming in showing me kind of your ideas so that imitation still there if you want to show me okay and then I can try to create a model that's of your kind of idea and send it
141out and then everybody can comment on it or whatever does that sound all right I'll do whatever I was just noting what you'd said if we take the SWAT analysis first that will guide us to where we need to go from there yes sir it may be five parts 50 Parts three parts I don't know when we look at the SWAT that will tell us so we can maybe do the SWAT and the mission values and core beliefs because that also is going to pay the way for some things I think those are the first I think they're good they do look pretty good but we can review them as a group and and if we want to tweak them a little bit U for going into next year I mean we should be and
142we will be um I think everybody's on the same page with that revisiting the Strategic plan every year because to your point things change um and along with that we'll be revisiting the director's um evaluation and the board evaluation every year because as the goalss change the evaluations will change as well so looking forward to next year for the Strategic plan next year's evaluation which we're working on this year's evaluation right now but next year's evaluation um that it's all going to be so intertwined for the Strat plan we're supposed to do it every two years minimum so every year would be okay but there's a twoyear minimum to look at make sure we're on track so we're at two year two we in right place okay anything else on there anybody so I guess
143just if everybody can look over the attachments and and the 5year Strategic plan and come prepared um so we're making HEI the sunshines in our meeting rather than rehashing things that have been out put out there for review yeah I'll Echo that and say that if if we do have independent time behind the scenes um based on your year or half year or two and a half years experience on the board review you know the Strategic plan we also have a document right we created that we can utilize to to focalize our points and say these are items that we can consider in our strategic plan for that SWAT analysis so that everybody has full visibility of what's being presented uh so you have the ability to be apprised of the discussion when when we
144arrive there you know that's going to give us uh the transparency and and the ability to actually collaborate effectively in the time frame that we have that that would be my recommendation if we have the ability to do that so tying the Strategic plan to the budget right so we are I guess a month remov from realizing we do have some more funding available in this year um that was not I guess originally understood so I would I would ask that that we we find a way that make sure we can tie our budgetary needs to our strategic planning for the evaluation if we're able to do that so if that's requesting a a report to to identify where we are by Department to say we are in in this space right so if we've
145got it we got for on Pace we're not on Pace I think we were indicated we were off Pace um we're on Pace to be over budget is what I'm getting at right so how do we how do we what do we do with that that information now that we're we're talking about strategic planning we we find out we have more money we have less money planning is a move point if we don't know what our funding sources are is what I'm getting at so how how do we make best use of that information that we have it now that way we can we can actually articulate a SWAT analysis to help create our or restructure our new uh strategic plan a lot of that's going to be coming with our budget planning yeah and
146it's we' it's going to be starting here we' we've said that we say that every meeting and so it's February we're going to be reconvene in March and it's going to be due in three months so I'm just saying let's do it yeah I think we've got you've got a schedule out there right we're going to be starting those budget meetings I don't remember the first one off hand i' have to look I can resend that out to the whole board though today before that's that was one of the reasons that I suggested the special comme is I'm ready to roll up my sleeves and start working on this but right now there's no we only have one meeting per month and one work session per month if we're going to get things accomplished we're
147going to have get together more often and the meetings are supposed to be open to the public right so yeah if we're going to have to schedule more time oh yeah and we can we're not tied to one work session and one meeting obvious viously because we've been having more but um you know we can schedule more work sessions as we deem needed and Mr step had the recommended outline for the budget he's had it out there for a couple months for us um so we can make sure we stay on track with that and get it submitted in timely manner to the commission this year our balance budget so who schedules the focus time is that Mr King the executive committee mhm and and I mean when we're in our work sessions we need
148to be talking about it right so we all agree that we need to have an additional meeting for this so let's get it on the schedule so can I make a motion for that today that we get some more time on the schedule for Budget or can we have him send the schedule out and we'll take a look at where everything falls and then we can see what dates work for everybody okay yeah so you had a a whole timeline on it m yeah we had to have it ready by January 1 by policy we had that by email correct M yeah yeah so we'll get that again and then yeah I mean we can email and figure out what dates work for folks or at our work session we can lay the dates out
149for all those meetings that way we can plan around them everybody good all right anything else we need to discuss we're right on time to jour so may a jar [Music]