CorpusRecord 73828

1-16-25 Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Elbert Farley
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Cumberland County, TN
Material
Transcript
Extent
43,186 words · about 240 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001be with Mr step running the meeting in his dead I don't think your mic's on it it's on okay there that's is that better okay I will pull it closer and lean more forward testing one two usually I don't usually I'm live enough okay um so we'll go ahead and get started with a moment in silence and Pledge of Allegiance [Music] okay I Al to flag of the United States of America and to the for stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all Mr step if you'd like to kick us off with Poe items which is first on the agenda okay the first thing on the agenda is the director of school's contract and Mr mccard is going to go through that so the board can ask any questions or uh discuss

002any parts of it sure oh I'm sorry that's all right if I could Mr mccardy before you start I just wanted to briefly do a little contract timeline for everybody okay sure because Mr step came on before all of us except for Mr King were here and or Anita was here Anita and Mr King were here when he came on and then we've had several new board members join so I just want to do like a really quick contract rundown and then um get over to you sounds good okay so Mr step's contract began July 1st of 22 um he signed the contract in May um in that contract his salary stipulate ated $107,000 which was less than the prior director prior director was her contract was for $110,000 she had a doctor's degree yes

003um the base State average at that time for our size districts was $141,900 U Mr steep accepted the contract in good faith with the understanding that it would be renegotiated or relooked at during his tenure during the 23 and 24 board con the board contracted um a company called lean frog and they did a salary study of both our certified and our non-certified um employees or positions and during both of those years the pay scales and raises were incorporated into the budget to achieve a competitive pay based on the study results uh during those two years and and those studies the Dos salary was being well below average was never addressed um in February of 24 Mr stpp approached the chair and the board with a contract re renegotiation request the timing would have allowed

004a renegotiation to occur before the 2025 2425 budget we hadn't gotten into the budget meetings at that point yet um the chair opted not to add the request to the February board agenda and the majority of the board voted not to at it at the board meeting which kicked the can down the road to the new board and there has been some discussion in Prior meetings about the new board being presented with having to deal with renewing the contract at this juncture um in March after the February meeting Mr step officially with withdrew his request for that contract renegotiation so we now have a draft of the renegotiated contract which was drafted by our elected board representative Mr King and Mr steep it's been approved by Mr step's attorney and it's been approved by Mr

005mccardy our board attorney and with that I'll go ahead and kick it over to you Mr mccardy sure absolutely well it's good to be here tonight as as indicated um just I know that I haven't been around as board counsel for a while so I just want to make sure that I'm everybody's aware my name my name is Chris mccardy I am as indicated counsil for the Board of Education um and going through through the contract what I've been asked to do tonight is go through it answer any questions that members of the board might have any concerns and just kind of go through it in detail to make sure that the public and the board is fully aware of what are these terms um as as indicated a second ago I think it's important

006to say that at at the end of the day this is still a draft so it's obviously still up to the board what it wants to do I play no role in that um I'm I think if I started playing a role in that people would think I'm going to vote over my skis which is not my job job but I can confirm I've looked at this contract I believe it falls in line with Tennessee law there's certainly nothing in this contract that is outside the norm there's nothing in this contract that I would say is legally disadvantageous or legally impermissible for a school board to agree to which is my job um I'll also answer any questions as as the board members know I represent over 20 school systems throughout Tennessee so I I

007see these a lot uh the other thing I would note there is because I see them a lot I canot only comment if asked on something that's legal which is my primary job I can also tell you if it's outside the norm of the typical terms that I see right which could include pay which could include things like a car allowance um since toss has been in existence which toss is Tennessee organization of school superintendent one thing that we've seen that they've done a good job at over really the last 10 years or more is most contracts now in the state of Tennessee that I see presented to me as board counsel by um directors of schools Andor the board representative that's negotiating with them they look pretty similar um if you were to go

008County to County I think and compare the director of school's contracts you're going to see differences in term you're going to see differences in Pay we'll talk about that that's obviously up to the board and and the director what they want to do there but in terms of what I would call the standard terms a lot of those look almost identical uh County to County system to system so I'll go through those tonight I'll certainly point out anything or answer any questions the board has but the primary point I would make is this is not an abnormal contract this is certainly something I see County to County system to system and again they look so similar across the state now that it's hard to tell them apart to be candid now so with without further

009Ado lawyers can't talk without a disclaimer so that was my disclaimer all right all right so if y'all can hear me I'm going to go through it I'll try I'm obviously not going to read this thing into the record I don't think anybody's asking for that unless people want me to read the phone book later phone book still exist but um I'm just going to go through the basics so first of all the the contract that is presented uh for board consideration includes a term of contract which will be for four years so the term right now is it reads would be from starting in January 2025 and it would expire if approved by the board in Jan through January of um that's pretty self-explanatory how that works as always the board can renew the

010board can take action during the middle of the term to increase that term that could happen here but again that's just up to the board board and the director what they want to do can I stop sure one of the things that that I've heard from parents and people that have looked over the contract and like and asked me a question about is that term okay the term of four years yes sir uh is that becoming the norm to go for four years or is it that's a mixed answer now I can give more of a a 2year most people most people feel that that two years regardless of how you feel of the director that 2 years is more than enough and then you can always renew after that you know what I mean

011so I can answer that yeah I can answer that so first of all me answer it a couple different ways CU I as a lawyer I can't ever give a completely straight answer um but no I will I'm kidding I'm kidding so one the the maximum the board can do is four right right so so I got to say that from the start that's the truth if you said to me when I first started doing this I would say 90% of the director's contracts I saw were for 4 years I say a good bit of them still are I would say that's changed though I mean there's if there's definitely been more contracts over the last four to five years that I've looked at that are within that two to four year range anywhere in

012between and every system's a little bit different candid so so I can't tell you like everybody's got four everybody's got two you never see one because honestly one's not worth the paper it's printed on most of the time time and that's my blunt answer between two and four is what I typically see I will say this though you're I think that pendulum as I've seen over the last year especially appears to be going more towards increasing the years and and canid answer is and I can't speak for Mr step it's a hard job and people want job security and I think to recruit people you're seeing more directors ask for longer terms yeah so I I definitely don't think it's abnormal to see somebody ask for for in fact if I'm in that seat that's

013what I'm asking for right um but no I mean if you're asking me do I see twoyear terms sure I see those all the time yes sir does that answer your question yeah I took the long road but and your point toss has 3.6 years is the average contract toss does and back when Mr step started with us it was 3.45 and it's got up to 3.6 so I saw that drop back but then as again just especially with the climate we're in right now that's political that's everything I think it's just more directors want that piece of mind that they have job security y um any more questions about terms all right duties the this is a pretty standard Clause that I would almost bet 99% of director's contracts have in them and honestly

014if you see there there's a reference and I'm going to say this a lot but if you see there there's a reference to Tennessee code annotated 49-2 d301 the state of Tennessee mandates what the director's Duties are and they also mandate what the board's Duties are that's at 49-2 d203 a lot of times in these contracts just to save space what I'll do is edit it to make sure that it we're just really referring to those statutes because at the end of the day whether we put in the contract or not we're still governed by those statutes it just saves a lot of time yep so that's all that says is essentially the duties are going to match what's in state law um and I'm just does any of that language uh conflict with the

015state law not at all so it's just basic basically perade them yes sir in fact what I would say is it's almost just ref referring the board and anybody else to state law yes sir and later when we get to governance you're going to see since next paragraph that's essentially what I would say there too is that it's referring the board and how it interacts with the director to state law and also local policy so I'll just go ahead and transition into there if that's okay I know sometimes I talk like the micro machine man but U nobody gets that joke anymore I'll interrupt you yes sir go ahead on the terms just for reference right sir so we going back to the term yep I'm sorry um that's fine duties not okay I apologize

016you know I think a lot of what we've done to my knowledge nobody's provided you with any notes no I don't think so right so Oh you mean board members on the no board members have gave you notes on thoughts on the contract no sir okay not specific notes I had a I've had a phone call from a board member asking me some questions uh but that was it yes sir so to to to be in the scope of comparison right as a board we've not actually compared old contract to new contract and outline the differences in the old contract in the new contract so I got my notes today are I'll just follow along as you're going and I'll just chime in with what my notes are just to point out what I've noted

017as the differences okay so in the duties the duty segment has listed that the um the difference is the old job description for the director was to be as adopted by the board and it may be amended from time to time so if we find that the job description or the duties need to change we have the ability to modify or change those during the course of the contract that's what the old job description the original contract okay was current contract is I think to your point just TCA minimum language that says you know what it says um the only thing can I pause there for a second sure the only thing I would say is everything you're said you're saying certainly is I understand it's correct but if you ever I know you have

018if you pull up that statute I've never refer to as minimum there's there's a lot I mean it if I print it out I think it's four pages long single space sure sure I just mean in the in the segment not in TCA TCA is never short worde go ahead um you know giv us the ability to amend it should or if we see that to be needed um and it is and also indicated that we we would require the director to live in the boundaries of the school district okay throughout the term of the contract M um and that the contract would be void if the director would not meet the residency requirements okay so that was one that was the one key difference in the current contract and the one that's proposed do

019you want me to address that please okay so the residency requirement is certainly something that I've seen less and less it doesn't mean that it's not legal it's absolutely still legal I definitely still have systems that require their director of schools to reside within the boundaries of the county or the municipality for that system so if you say to me which I think you are is that something you could still do legally and add it yes um I think again with the top job market there's a reason you're seeing it less and less because a lot of directors just don't want it in there uh I don't know about it here I don't that was never discussed with me yeah but that's I just it's probably why it's not in there I just don't know

020Goa no and and that that's that's just a a note really like is whether or not it's can I can I answer one more part on that the other thing I would point out you can I typically and this is just a drafting style thing more than anything else I typically if I see language in there that'll say the and I'm paraphrasing the board can always modify in negotiations with the director that's always the case so you can put that language in I consider that language kind of redundant because the board always has the power just like if I had a contract with Pepsi to you know if I had um convenience stores just to stock my convenience stores and anytime I can go to Pepsi and say Hey I want to renegotiate this there's

021no difference here I mean the board is a party with the director if the board ever wanted to renegotiate or put other duties in it has the power to do so got so that's implies what I'm saying yep yes sir so my question is to Mr step was that was that a deal breaker in the negotiation did you want that out of the contract no no it's not a deal breaker not at all so going to that actually brings up another point if at any time this is a draft so if the board I'm making that up and I don't want to I don't want to make a vote here CU again that's over my skis but if y'all talk to Mr Stephen as part of these conversations you want you all agree to put

022the resonates requirement back in I'll do it I mean it just requires board action and agreement with the director right so that's no issue whatsoever yep we wouldn't do that in a work session we have to do that in in our real okay yeah so for example let's just use that one okay that's a pretty sounds like a non non-controversial part of this right so all that would have to happen is the board would take this contract say hypothetically that would be the only amendment but I don't know the person amending to approv the contract would a motion to approve the contract with an amendment to reinsert or or add a residency requirement back to section two be that simple and I would go back in and fix that can I make a quick point

023about the residency requirements so uh in previous years and in my background Public Safety the state law allowed Public Safety departments to have have a residency requirement um within the last 5 years the state law has been reversed to allow First Responders to not live in the jurisdiction they live or uh have a certain amount of time that they have to report to their Duty station and they've done that to allow a uh better field of candidates for positions instead of the same you got to live here to work here y um so I just wanted to make that point if we're doing that for First Responders to say you know we're not doing that and I know locally nobody has any policies to contradict that you know we've got people working for our Public

024Safety departments that are going to be fighting our house fires that don't live in Cumberland County so yeah I mean just just reduces to your point that it is feasible just obviously if you're 30 minutes away and you need to be present that the fire is going to be burning for 30 minutes before you show up right no before those people show up there'll still be other people yeah yeah I'm just just not I I really do think it just comes down the job market that's that's why I've started like when I first started doing this which is I used to have brown hair to give anybody an example um I was probably in every director's contract The Residency requirement now it's not as much and I think it just comes down the job market

025I don't there's not a legal reason yeah now I have to determine if there's benefit sure what would be the benefit of putting it in there for well we are elected officials and we have to live in the um in our constituents District if we move out of it then we are no longer that's how I became a board member Cuz Mr Stone which is state law but there's not a state law saying the director has to he's hired yeah he's not I C I currently live be a part of the community need to live in theun County so why are we having this conversation I think own a house somewhere else yeah you own a house somewhere else yeah I have a house but I live in an apartment here know so I don't

026why are we even having this conversation well because it's just good with I'm good with it it's just it's just different we're just pointing out of of the contract sure so again if y'all just leave that out there that if that's something later after more discussions especially with the board chair coming back and you wanted me to re add that all it has to do is just a motion there's no problem um you want me to continue yes sir all right governance um similar here what this is is I would call this an amalgamation of two things one it's a reference to and a lot of this language is pulled directly from again what I called the the duties of a board of education statute which is at 49-2 203 that's why you see it

027referred to as the rest of this most of it comes from or honestly mirrors language that you're going to find within current board policy because you guys use the standard tsba models and when you look at the standard tsba model for example on boardmy Code of Conduct those thing it talks about the board member should bring issues or concerns directly to the director rather than addressing themselves that's where that comes from so it's a it's a mixture of board policy working that into as well as state law any questions on that is is it where did who drafted this call I do not have the answer to that I don't my my memory I don't believe I made any adjustments to it it's pretty standard though that's how I I've read paragraphs like that probably

028a thousand times but just I can tell you I know where it comes from just because I've seen that language also a th times or probably 2,000 times within that boardmodern and the director what they think what y'all think is fair on that but the obviously the language itself is pretty standard um how the person gets paid when they get paid I think that matches payroll as you do with other other employee which is what we typically see so there's there's certainly nothing complicated about this provision questions for me on that all right is it typical to see that uh I've looked at several of these the typical to see the director get the pay increase that the other County employees get as well as an annual pay increase consideration by the board each year

029I honestly see that all over the map and that's why I see that so different everywhere there are some directors that have it in there to where they only get a pay increase if it's approved by the board specifically I have other directors that have an automatic Clause that they receive the P same pay increase as other school system employees of the two that I see that's probably the more common that it's just an automatic pay increase if if one employee gets a raise everybody gets a raise especially professional employees that's what I would typically see but not always you see that versus the other sometimes so that you don't have to if you have a four-year contract and you just get that annual increase every year yeah I've seen to deal with this but

030I've seen them all yes sir yeah and in fact that that standard raise um is probably the more common this that director's pay goes up when everyone else's pay goes up yes sir and that's the way our other contract was stated okay thank you you're welcome sure other questions on that all right military leave um obviously I think we all appreciate the fact I'll speak personally on this one that Mr steep has the military background he does that he's a current serving member and serving our country as he does but I'll also say state and federal law make it very abundantly clear that we provide military leave and I'm sure nobody's have an objection about that yeah I'll just move on with that one pretty quick policy yeah it's also there's a federal law called

031usera which makes it very clear that we follow that so I don't foresee any issues there yes sir are there times that you just leave that out so say say if we have a new director in 3 years and we just want to copy this contract oh it'd be easy for me to delete it there I think it was more I mean the way I look at it is more to honor Mr step and his his service to have it in there specifically but if you're asking me does it have to be would we still be bound by that we would okay yeah that's what I yes sir we had it in the first contract yeah it's in a lot there's so many for that reason Mr step do we know how many days the

032military leave you've encountered since you've been director uh actual work days that I have to go yeah um usually it's the summer annual training and Veterans Day week so uh I can get the exact number and email that to you guys just it's usually four or five days in November and then June July probably work days I'm talking about work days CU it's still the weekends right then usually it's about maybe 8 to 10 total work days because a lot of our stuff's on the weekends annual training is over three periods of the Year for me so it's not all blocked together 15 days in the summer thank you U um professional licenser certification again this just confirms that the director shall have and maintain um evidence of a valid and appropriate license and service

033director of schools don't don't anticipate any controversy there automobile allowance the the number can change system to system but you do see this as a pretty standard term now especially over the last 10 years that I will see in these contracts just to account for the fact that directors of schools drive all over the county all over all the time just to be School everybody wants directors to do they want them visible in the schools they want in school so this is something that has certainly become much more common place I have a question about that um the auto uh the allowance don't we keep up with our mileage anyway and don't you uh send it to currently currently I'm paid by the mileage so I have to keep it every day yes sir um

034and you you turn it in I turn it like if I go to a workshop or something and I get Diane to help me fill out the forms and I turned it in for my gas y mileage and I added a line on there or the Boe will provide a road worthy vehicle for me so if y'all wanted to do that too we used to have a vehicle what what has happened with that 2003 explorers back in the back it died it's not Road worthy anymore not Road worthy to answer your question though the what you typically see like for example if this was a private sector contract because you'll see automobile allowances there the difference would the a lot of private sector employees and a lot of employers in general don't reimburse for in

035in-county uh travel right so it's only if you travel outside the county so like even leis Thomasson like if I'm where I work by the way if I'm going to a meeting in the other side of Knoxville I don't get reimbursed for that okay I think the difference here is so many directors travel all parts of the county all the time that that normal reimbursement doesn't account for how much mileage they spend within the county right that's what they mine's the same way so we mileage here in the county I was just saying typically that's why you would see the difference we do yeah you do we do thank you I think for comparison I'm sorry I wasn't trying to say you did just like just for a little bit of comparison right we um

036in our budget currently for 2425 I think we have $10,000 put in there for travel currently I think you put you're about 75% per the the document that's detached today so he's about 75% of $10,000 year to date on travel expenses that have been logged if there are more or if there's something that comes up between now and then obviously we have to modify the budget to give him room to you know take care of that but $10,000 is the amount that we gave it so we modify the budget all the time so 600 600 a month is is less than what we're currently budgeting okay the other thing you save on is just admin I mean it's a lot of admin if you're having to log all your in in County travel so I

037mean that's one reasons schools have also went to it is just there's just so much of that it's constant that it just if you just have this it's a standard amount you don't have to worry about everybody knows what's going to be paid makes it easier for but this is a question I've got about instead of the automobile allowance supplying him with a vehicle I me I believe that that's one way or the other I I feel that he needs to be compensated or taken care of for the vehicle for the travel because he does travel to all the schools and we have a large County as far as to travel around um and especially in days like we've seen the past few days it it's it's been I mean I I personally some of

038the vehicles I wouldn't want it's just been rough roads that he needs to go down to to check out you know what I mean and so um but for the $600 a month at the end of this contract regardless if he stays or goes at the end of the contract we have nothing to show for it oh where you would with a vehicle you mean where understand yes sir with a vehicle I'm throwing this out for discussion with us supplying a vehicle and I don't I don't mean a youo from 1934 but exactly you know that he could also entertain vendors or whatever take him to to schools and things like that at least at the end of the contract we have something that we get back or that we can pass on to the

039next director yeah um and to be clear Mr St pointed out that's why he wanted that last provision added because I don't think he has a preference is what it sounds like yeah one one thing I'd like to add to that also if if we were to purchase a vehicle for Mr step to use uh would during his duties if he's out checking roads and is in an accident in his personal car not only is his driver's license going to take a hit for a for a property damage accident but it's also going to affect his personal in insurance if he's in a government vehicle which is what this would be it would still show up on his DL history but it wouldn't be a ding it wouldn't be used as a consideration for increasing

040his personal insurance rate better for Mr step I always preferred that way when I was working where did we come up with the um $600 who came up with that price that I did I did I was just thinking and I know several of you asked me about mileage and how much I get a month it varies depending on if there's conf es or or if we're out of school for 10 days or whatever um so that would include like a car payment and the stuff I'm incurring that now I still got insurance and upkeep and all that stuff to take care of too I know you've seen car allowances way higher than this on contracts yeah I've seen about $1,000 a month this is pretty typical on the low end of typical from my

041experience and to your point John I I did some num numbers on that as well so we're looking at 7200 a year at the 600 a month if we were to do a car allowance which if it kind of talking about doing the government purchase with those who have done that before we could get into a sedan type of vehicle maybe around 40,000 so just kind of going with that idea or even a a mediumsized SUV you're looking about 5 and A2 years of that monthly allowance equating to the price of the car and then we would have that car still yeah Point yeah I I think it's advantageous to all of us as as a county to supply him a vehicle rather than for the $600 plus it takes a lot of the like

042he was saying a lot of the liability off of Mr step and and his and the maintenance the main maintenance would come back to the so the only thing from a drafting perspective let's say the board y'all have further discussions and at the meeting there's a motion to modify this to just basically pay pay for the car again that's up to the board then I probably would want to tweak this a little bit to say again a roadworthy reasonable vehicle and and with the board obviously handling maintenance and upkeep yeah but that's no problem that'd be an easy and I I'd actually rather this say one or the other rather than the ore so whatever you guys decide I would ask you to pick one that way we don't have the ore in there and

043it's really unclear later how that works so you drafted this for Mr stat no no I did this no I didn't draft anything was sent to did this from a uh there's every year toss does Dos contract professional developments and they give you what's the most common thing in director's contracts what follows the law all that kind of stuff so I went through that that training and then I create created from that training that was Chuck Kel did that training so I created this contract from that training uh through toss and then Mr step it so since I'm board Council I would never draft something for for Mr step thank you for that but Mr step sent it to me and I looked at it and I'm again I'm looking for two things when I

044look at a contract that somebody sent me which is this candidly whether this is the director of schools a vendor anybody uh service provider I'm looking for first legality is everything in the contract legal is there anything that would be illegal there was certainly nothing illegal something that wouldn't be um approvable let's put it that way the other thing I look at is just in my experience as a board counsel are there terms that I want added or is there language I want to tweak on the board's behalf to make sure that the language is clearer like later if we ever had to go to court which I hope everybody wants to avoid that I know the Court's going to understand it and then two just in my experience there's certain Provisions over the years

045that I have just determined I want them to be more clear I want to add things and I'll skip ahead to give you an example um and I'll go backwards but I'll give an example when I gave it to Mr mccardy after y'all hired him my comment was whatever you're going to advise the board go ahead and do it now so when I give it to them you already on their behalf done that so so an example would be at provision and I'm going to go backwards I'm not going to skip all um at provision 11 or section 11 so contract termination a lot of times there's not a death or disability clause and I've just unfortunately and I'm not trying to um before I say this when you have that happen what you really

046want is clarity as to how it works exactly what the process would be if some unfortunate Health situation happened so I'll always add more there and something for an example that's what I added so I mean there's examples like that but but I want you to know where that comes Froman 21 on oh gosh I can't read roman numerals 21 contract termination there's a reason I'm a lawyer not not a math person that's embarrassing not bad sorry that's just terrible Roman numerals on my part by the way um but that's just an example to give youall if things that I would add again based on my experience all right going backwards any other questions on automobile yes sir goad I've been trying not to interrupt anybody sorry I talked too much no that's okay um

047on the $600 vehicle stifen would that be part of the buyout if we seed the contract at any point no sir no because there would be that's a that's a great question but I understand what you're saying the answer is to why would be that's not something that's guaranteed that's based on use so obviously the director of schools would no longer be using that or using it for system reasons it would not be part of your compensation one of my first questions when I read this term was has there been any study done on what what it would save the county to buy a vehicle versus pay this stop I guess that's more of a question for Mr St and then also the other part of that is the 67 cents per mile which is

048now 70 cents per mile actually covers maintenance fuel oil and insurance that's right on standard reimbursement yes sir that's right so what we have been reimbursing him is covering the expenses that he's asking for in that $600 correct so I just wanted to make that clear because I've done some research on this but but before we make a decision I'd like to know what's the best use of taxpayer money would it be just to pay the 600 or and then the other thing is there's another term in this contract down here that says we will still reimburse him for expenses so once we once we give him the $600 vehicle stopping is he then again going to turn in mileage for that vehicle no sir the expenses would refer to and we can make that

049more clear if you want but the expenses there would refer to like say you went to the tsba conference the hotel charges or uh a dinner if you're at another conference things like that or or a meeting out of town with the state or I'm just giving examples that's where that would come from travel or professional expenses correct so I've called Miss Turner about the expenses that Mr steps turned in I still haven't received all those yet at this point um she said it was somewhere around $300 a month okay uh for mileage that's not mil person that's mile so $3,600 a year if we could I I guess in our heads decide would we be better off to pay him $3,600 a year or $7,200 a year that's pretty simple and then how long

050is a vehicle going to last if we buy a new vehicle for the county what makes more sense for us overall with taxpayer money is what I'm me at understood something to be thinking about for the board when we put this to a vote cuz we can amend this as well oh yeah everything in here is up for negotiation and vote Yes sir um insurance benefits I mean I can summarize that by just saying that Mr step has the right to the same benefits provided or available to any other employee and that's that would be no difference here that's just clarify it was brought up to me I will take that spouse part out um okay cuz that's not the same as what the employees here get so I will be removing that out of

051the draft all right what part the where it says and spouse dependent eight oh yeah I I need somebody else to point out the Roman numerals sorry make are they included for employees too I think they are what is that dental and vision are both included for employ vision is not I yes should be I guess to include insurance benefits to match what other what what we give our our certified okay that's no problem certified Personnel I made it I'm making a note I can edit that and we can come to some yeah we can discuss this and come to some agreement on things for Mr mccardy to that's what we're doing yeah to make adjustments we don't have to wait till the board meeting as you're saying you know we can amend it in

052the board meeting we can I just didn't know if we could do that yeah well have to vote do the official vote at the board meeting for the contract but we can discuss and rehash and come up with the new draft on this today which would be preferable than getting into the board meeting and doing it yeah well to just reiterate that especially things like this where you just want it to match what other employees are getting that that's a pretty simple fix just to make sure I'm tweaking that and that's that like Mr step because he's a party to this contract has the right to say hey you can take that out at any time so like he just did when he said take that out I know it's coming out so yeah Mr

053step would would you have any problem with us making that match but if you rewrite this what the other employees get yeah just equal to what other employees I'll make that tweak that's no problem but if you rewrite this at this time uh we won't have time to look over it at the next board meeting and vote for it we might have to go back and I mean it's like there I mean I could have it to you tomorrow we're all discussing it here so we're reaching some cons consensus of agreement on what we want to have in the new draft and then and then we would Bo meeting and that gives Mr mccardy the opportunity to make the changes the only thing that's going to say now just in legal ease is it's going

054to say he's going to receive the exact same benefits offered to other certified employees um any other on U I'm now I'm second guessing myself on every R numeral any other on eight sorry I'll help you with that thank you I appreciate it technology at number n um this basically just talks about if the if the director does have needs for cellular teleph telephone computer hardware like a computer an iPad things like that that certainly within reason those are provided to the director so I have a not on okay our system already provides everything in that list except for a cell phone do we not offer you a cell phone at this time I have one that I use for the Snow Day stuff and there's not any other ones that you are uh can

055receive to that's all I need is that one cell phone you get a cell phone stiping that that cell phone uh as needed you're on your phone all the time they call I think they call it the bat phone is that right guys is that I guess what I'm asking is that term necessary since we already provide all that the the whole term or you need just to cell your phone part the technology line everything in that technology line is provided except cell phone he has computer he has internet he has and he does have a cell phone he just said he has yeah no if you're asking me is does that have to be in there the answer is no it's up to Mr stepp if he wants to just confirm it that it's

056going to be made available I understand the need for the cell phone with everybody calling him all the time separate L for personal use I understand that I'm just talking about everything else that's in there doesn't have to be no sir yeah and I'm I'm okay with that just taking that out do you normally see that in other contct that one's one that it does appear a little bit redundant I don't see it every time no I would say it is more abnormal to see it in there probably for the reasons we're discussing that it's just usually provided anyway to most important assumption that it's going to be provided correct yeah yep okay so do you have oh oh go ahead districts that do a stip in for a cell phone yeah now candidly districts

057are the map on cell phone part some districts provide a cell phone some directors just straight up say they don't want one uh they just rather use their own some districts try to stop them so it's really I mean I have a stip and I get one for the Pregnancy Center because I'm constantly on my phone with clients it's just it's just I see that one that one is so different District to District that there's really no pattern that I can point to I'm good with the current setup it's good okay okay so we don't NE we don't need to have that in thereus okay all right um memberships this is a very standard term and this the exact that's the exact groups that I see reference within that which would be that Mr step

058while he's working as director of school would have the ability to participate in and have things reimbursed in relation to his participation in toss as well as the American Association of school administrators I would tell yall here I don't remember the last time I saw a director's contract that didn't have that provision in it it is it is standard term the only addition I guess in this contract is the two local Civic organization membership versus the old contract didn't have two local Civic organizations in it exactly I'm currently not into local Civics I serve on boards yeah yeah so is that is that suitable or do you you does that mean you plan on staying on the board on the ones that you're on and then joining two others and paying dues there I thought

059about joining one of the rotaries and I was going to say what I typically do see there is I see at least two or one because a lot of as you can imagine a lot of director schools don't just want to be involved in a State they want to have something local they're involved in rotary is a typical one Chamber of Commerce is another one I see I'm in the chamber also but but that is typical to also say the local stuff are you're on the board of the chamber I'm not on the board uh the school system is in the chamber so usually Dr Maddox goes to that yeah yeah I saw you at the last event um do we know what that organization's what do we expect to spend on those memberships we

060know what toss and aasa cost what does what what would would possibly be the expenses of adding those two local Civic organization membership dues I can I can find that out if there I mean if it was specific and if you wanted me to I don't know if y'all want to do this I could I could literally add rotary by name instead of the unless you're interest something else and it may change in pretty detailed there well I mean it it well I mean it's like if you're going to join a yacht club or you're going to you're going to pay dues at the tany marina those are two vastly different expenses Civic organization I I definitely would you know what you know what I mean this won't give the yach club green a yach

061club I'm kidding I'm kidding so move on yeah okay um professional liability this is also a a term that I see in all these contracts essentially the way I would summarize it is we definitely provide um different policies and pay for those policies I would also tell though here like for example directors a dno policy that also is the same policy we use to protect the board members uh so for for obvious reasons I think we want that it also protects all administrators if there's a claim individually against them and then the indentification language is in there as well to make sure it just doubles down on that same concept that if the director were to be sued or named in a in a legal proceeding by name then we just want to make sure

062that there's coverage there the same way there would be if a board member would be named individually as well so to your point there in the indemnification piece yep old contract doesn't indicate language of holding harmless in in the individual capacity right whereas in our this contract that's being proposed it does indemnify him individually but only us to certain claims and I I'm I would wholeheartedly think that's necessary that's why that's in there um and I can explain why the if you read the second if you go to that second page where it bleeds over there's a limitation to that um and I think that limitation is Cru crucial to understanding the hold Harless provision so the director would not have any identification as to any criminal proceeding any malicious act any fraudulent act or

063imposs I'm sorry improper personal gain or willful misconduct so the only thing this would really apply to is if there was an allegation that the director um was negligent or Reckless or something that was a mistake not something that wasn't anything intentional like fraud Etc so that's why it's in there it just makes it crystal clear the claims that would provide identification versus the ones that would not personally versus professionally right don't we open up an entire it's always going to be professional it's always going to be professional so would there would be no issue by striking personal from the Clause well personal okay let me explain what sorry there's two different ways we're using that that's my fault when I say personal it' be that his name would be personally on a lawsuit okay

064so for example if Cumberland County Su schools is sued and the only thing on the the line indicate what we call the caption is defendant kland County Schools Mr step might still be accused sorry Mr step within the lawsuit just like any other administrator of doing something wrong but he's not named the moment his name is on there that's a personal he's named personally even though it could be professional act it's he's personally named does that if he is personally named this that's what covers this if he was personally named in in and again feel bad talking about these things hypothetically if Mr steep got in an auto accident and rear ended somebody on a Saturday night while he's coming back from Mexican food this doesn't apply to that this would only be if he's

065named personally in relation to a professional action as an attorney would you not if you saw this Clause would you not list them knowing that this is in there as as knowing that no they always list them anyway okay yeah the last time we didn't have them listed so everybody you always list them U that's what PL attorneys do they do that to try to I mean I can give you all kinds of reasons but the main re the biggest checkbook well it's not just that they yes for sure that but they also do it to int it scares me sure uh if you see your name on there versus just your employer's name on there it Le it's leverage that the plan of attorney will use to try to encourage settlement or other reason

066right yeah so for that reason we've seen more and more that plan attorney sort of use that tactic to name you personally this just provides more peace of mind for a director that if they're named personally for their professional Services they're still covered by the board I'll be candidate with you the insurance is going to cover it anyway that's why we have it that's why we have like three or four different policies to make liability insurance bno general liability EPL we have all of them yes sir it just those those once that's done as to whether or not it's covered or not it doesn't change the fact that it will adjust our rate if we do pay out a million dollar claim our insurance compan is not going to look at us the same way

067they did the following year of living or losing the suit we're still going to I've never seen this provision the way it's written affect any rate honestly it's the insurance company's going to look at it and say what you're doing there is being extra protective and extra clear but this doesn't affect our coverage no sir I mean I I can send this to Tom Stanley with the trust to get that in writing if you want but I know what his answer is going to be thank you you're welcome um all right moving forward professional growth um this is just a again fairly standard clause it talks about just making sure that that we know and the board knows that the director of schools not only has the ability to but is encouraged to go through

068professional growth activities um sponsored by local state or not National organizations so for example attending tsba attending a toss meeting um going through different training like CLE Etc continuing ed that's just something that is part of the the duties of the director do you uh typically see any limits so on that say for instance say there's a convention in Jamaica oh are there any limits we're all going I've I've never seen limits set but honestly to be candid with you I've never seen somebody push those limits so certainly if that happened we could discuss it but I've I've never seen it inerted because I've never seen me somebody try that and we have the budget set for Mr sta so we're working within that budget restricts that's the second piece right we've got there's more

069pieces to this there's the budget that goes along with this for them and then there's the evaluation that goes along with this for them so both of those roll into those although if he asked me to go to Jamaica I might go I'm going I'm just kiding I'm just kid Prett nice uh there he's not asking me to go okay sick leave uh the director should be granted one day of sick leave for each month of contractual employment again fairly standard term just just to remind everybody certified employees as well I provided one day of sick leave for every month of employment so that matches what we typically do um sorry yes sir are there is this the same number of days in that you're currently receiving uh yeah I well the way it's set

070up there's it is 12 days and correct me if I'm wrong because you're 12 Monon contract it's a the certified teachers get 10 days plus two personals MH yeah the reason remember certified teachers I can jump in there are on a 10-month contract whereas he's on 12 yep so that would explain the difference yeah so this is an addition of eight days no sorry me same days it's just his are all considered sick versus their deser now are you talking about adding the paid vacation are you just talking about on I guess they are tied together well I'm sorry days a different line right yeah sick leave is going to basically match what certified teachers get his are just all sick Le versus teachers get 10 sick Le plus two personal so it's the same

071number of days yes sir and same thing that was on the contract the contract perfect perfect yeah good I didn't have that's why I asked I didn't have on that I had it one together um work and then the next provision is work year and vacation uh paid time off this is again something that we do see um for directors of schools the way I would explain this and and those numbers are certainly not anything I would say outside the norm I've seen a lot of directors that receive more vacation time than that um the way I would sort the way I always talk about it with people is it's exactly what we just talked about other certified employees get days during the summer they get entire months off they get um other times off

072whereas the director of schools and a lot of the central office staff as well is work those times it's it's to account for the 12-month contract typically versus the 11 versus 10 but they can take these at any time they want 20 days believe so yes sir I've never taking a non-contract vacation day kids are in session what I was going to say is what I typically see is directors end up not using a lot of these or use it during the summer cuz they're just so they're so busy so what they suggest to me I work 12 months is that I take the time off to recharge and reset and that they I'm I'm use it or lose it which most professionals are in my opinion that's what I think the contract should be

073is use it or lose it okay so instead of carrying over you mean no yeah but in this contract it says to be paid for regardless of whether he uses them or not in this contract yeah so another question I have is that part of the buyout if if he were to if we were to sever his contract so it would be yeah so if there's any unused vacation there's also state law on that too and you probably know that's where we're going so there's basically and I'm paraphrasing there's a state statute that would apply to any employee that essentially if you get if you have unused days unless there's something specifically that says it's not part of about um when there's a resignation or a termination and that is to be accounted for so

074so that would be this basically adds to the face value of that $141,000 then on a per DM rate you mean on a buy yes correct I mean the the the vehicle Clause does too it just wouldn't be counted in the B that's why it was making the difference yeah that's right so I'm not understanding this okay so if he doesn't take his vacation days we have to pay him back for the vacation day if there was a bout if there was a bout that's what we're saying suppose he just you know decides that he doesn't want to take a vacation and doesn't go on vacation do we have to pay him for the days so let me just read it that way we can go through it is that okay yeah so unused vacation

075annual leave days shall not be shall not accumulate Andor on I'm sorry and on or before June 30th of each fiscal year covered by this contract the board shall reimburse the director for unused days at the pum rate of the day of pay for the director so that's that's your answer so the answer is yes if he correct yeah if he were not to use it yes yes yeah I just want to make sure everybody was clear about so that being the case that also adds to the salary basis if he doesn't use them yes sir mhm you would prefer that that part to be out that line to be out well I mean I I think just from just from what we do at my my work is you know I think you should

076take the time off and recharge and reset and I don't think we should pay you for that I think you should take the time off I mean we're paying him either way right cuz he's getting those days within his contract so for paying one either way but I think what he's trying to what Mr is trying to encourage is for him to take some time off to recharge you know what I mean and and as an employer for that during the summer months when we're a little slower or whatever um having either use it or lose it is just encouragement to try to take those days so that you're he's not burning out or like any other employee they're not getting burned out on the job we're not trying to take anything away from him

077trying to help him encour encourage him to use those dates you know there there's a third option which the board could consider as well which I see so I just throw that out and this is up to y'all all those things are permissible by law the third option which I see in some director's contracts is some per percentage of unused days would carry over until the next contract year so if you want to split the baby there is that option as well it's never it's never all of them right so you there's always that option as well and that account what I would say there is you often see that used to account for the fact that it's a crazy job it's a hard job some years there's just less time to take time off

078than others you know I think I think about 2021 2020 there weren't a lot of people taking time off in education there's a lot of them in here right now um so to account for that you would still not penalize them if they were to have to lose those cuz they work too hard so I pulled that record with Diane he not taking hard vacation in the last two years right so that's a bad practice I'm staying out of that but but I'm just saying if y'all were considered modifying this I would also consider the carryover as a as a compromise option that's more what I'm used to you have a certain amount of days that you can carry over next year that's fairly common yeah and I I also have the military day so

079sometimes I try not to allow that to accumulate over 20 with the vacation date I try try to make sure I'm at work but what are your thoughts on what we're discussing here regarding how that be worded in the contract I mean I'm good if you want to take out that you pay me for them whatever I mean does the does the board want me to insert that some percentage then if that's being taken out would carry over it's five now you did bring up the point that you are gone a lot for military but that's you know I get that that yeah I I got to just step in there to say we have to always be and I know this is not what you're saying no but we always have to be very

080careful on that because the way those laws read is so tight that that can never be used any adverse way that's not vacation right we just have to treat it as Mr Steph be working yes right he is working somewhere else for our country right um you sounds like maybe people want me to take that part out and reinsert the five carryover is that how it was [Music] before didn't have that section in the prior one no we not it's not showing up in my compar yeah I have no problem with it that's the way it works for the County Personnel policy on December 31st if my personal time has reached a certain limit and if it's and I forget the exact number at the moment but uh it converg to sick time personal time

081conver SI time if it's over a certain level that's how that's how a lot of handbooks read now for that reason it's never the full amount that's carried over but it's usually a percentage I'm good with what the board decides so okay so the five five day carry over so he has the opportunity to use them in another year if needed and again just to be clear nothing's going to bind the board what I'm hearing tonight are tweaks that I would make then that would be the draft that would be before you to consider more in a public meeting so I will tweak that and again obviously the board wants to and Mr step later want to make a change to that that's completely before the board until this is approved in a meeting all

082right all right expenses that's what we just discussed a second ago a lot of that if we're going to make tweaks to the let me go back to sorry the automobile allowance then you would probably want me to tweak this as well this is written with the idea that it would not include those automobile expenses a reimbursement for that so I think from what I was hearing when we were having our discussion on that earlier is everybody seems to be on board with either a car allowance or providing vehicle by the district yeah but we wanted I mean I rough the numbers out again $7,200 a year at600 per month we're looking at a $40,000 $40,000 for a new vehicle through the government purchase program it's about 5 and a half years of that monthly

083allowance what would you paid for so that gives us a little bit of an idea also keep the vehicle we keep the vehicle and the way that the vehicle would be used it would probably have a longer lifespan than most government purchases I'd say at a minimum 10 years if not 15 for to save us some time here I tell you what I can do as to automobile allowance what I when I send y'all this new draft that we're talking about tonight I'm going to put two options for Section seven see I have to second um I'm going to put option one will be just the $600 concept option two will put more detail into what the purchaseing the vehicle concept look like and then when the board votes you would just have to indicate

084in the minutes which option you're picking that just makes it easier cuts that down y'all can just decide that way that way it's not an either or you have a decision it would literally be there it would be baked into it yes sir and again we could modify that like Mr mccardy has said as the time goes on with the contract but then we would need we'd have a forthcoming uh budget amendment we would need to make in order to allocate funds for the purchase of the vehicle but I'll just put that in there that way the not of y'all can just indicate which one you're which way you're choing well in his old contract it had this one which one the expenses uhuh right which is that one right yeah so that one of

085the expenses so that to be clear if y'all picked one of the other options on automobile balance the expenses would not include travel reimbursement for mileage indoor vehicle maintenance that would go away this would really just be for travel okay at section 15 also considering that mileage rate goes up every year in January so it's hard to tell going the percentage of it goes up every year because it kind of changes but if anybody's figuring we have to consider that um medical examination this is something that I've started seeing more and more in these and it's it's certainly not something an employee has to do I think directors of schools are understanding that you know it's a taxing job Mr step can speak to that more than I can it is a constant job there's

086a lot of stress with it so this just provides for the the board can require the director submit to an annual comprehensive medical examination it doesn't to I know I think you and I talked about this it doesn't open up the board to certainly see every medical record of the director that wouldn't be fair or appropriate but it does essentially if the board were to ask the director would have to submit to make sure they have a fair bill of health to move forward in the in the position that's what that's for it was not in the first contct no it's it's a provision that I've started seeing pop up over the last few years um going next to performance evaluation this is something that is required by law so I did make some tweaks

087here and I can tell you why this is something that is required of the board to do annually under 49-2 203 and if you look there in subsection I or one or whatever that is lowercase I um there are certain parts of the annual evaluation that are required by law for the board to include in that evaluation those include job performance student achievement relationships with staff and Personnel relationships with board members and relationships with the community so there's a reason I inserted those cuz I always like to make sure I've had boards in the past that I won't name forget that those are mandatory parts of the eval and all of a sudden they'll create an evaluation document leave them out so I include that in the contract just to make sure nobody glosses over

088that CU those are again the only mandatory parts of the evaluation to be clear though there's nothing in this that would preclude the board from doing more so if you wanted to put more evaluation pieces more factors that's fine you just have to have these at minimum and then the new evaluation draft that we're working on those are in there and one of the things that in this section that that caught my eye was June of I guess the evaluations that when they're due like this one the last one we had was from last year a full we're a year behind and now we're voting on this contract you you see what I'm saying and so is there any way to change the dates sure um so that we have kind of an updated before

089we have to go through another contract or whatever that we have as long as it's the only guidance that the state provides and mandates is has to be done annually so really it's up to the board and the director how they want that to look from a schedule standpoint yes sir esba recommends June this board was going to try to get on track with that so we make sure that we've got it coming in every year you know at that time so the reason that tsba recommends June you guys probably understand it is because that's the end of the fiscal year that's that's when everything else ends that's why but but no if you're asking me is it mandated no but we I don't remember us discussing that I gu I guess one thing that

090I'm asking then is could we change the date from June for the evaluations to come in to say two months prior to the next contract negotiation you know what I mean whatever the the termination date or end date of this is that those evaluations come in at least two months prior to that date to give us time to look over the new evaluations have recent evaluations then instead of having year old evaluations that we're going by think if we get on track with that if we do it in June and we get on track with that we will be okay because we will have that evaluation before we'll be coming forward to having to renegotiate M because this ends January but supposing if we're going for a full 2 year three year whatever it's going

091to be a January end which means we have had the evaluation in June but yeah but I'm saying that's a an entire other semester that we've missed out on EV so having a new evaluation from teacher staff everybody else within two months then of the next contract I the only reason I would I we we have to we couldn't do it that way I'm not saying you couldn't change the date but let me explain if you if you do anything of a mult m-e contract again that's up to the board and the director whether it's two three or four but if it's a multi-year contract then that would not be clear within the contract that the evaluation has to be done annually if I tied it to the renegotiation or the term does that make

092sense yeah and by law it has to we have to have something in there mandating an annual so what I would say there is you always want to pick a month cuz that way it's super clear in the contract that the board and the director have to submit to that annual evaluation by state law and I I guess I guess that's kind of where I'm oh I'm sorry if I'm trying to get to is and I'm not very good at at I guess getting my point across but having a fresh evaluation two months prior to a new contract because just like like right now we're we're dealing with a year old's evaluation more or less you know and a lot changes a year a lot of opinions change in a year and that's that's kind

093of what I'm trying to so thinking about the timing of that then June is the end of the school year so the evaluation that we're talking about is the board evaluation for Mr step as our employee so June's the end of the school year so we'd be evaluating him from last year on his work from that school year for him meeting the goals that were set forth for the school year uh strategic plan set forth for that year so we would have that whole year that would be encompassed in that review in June if if we were to shift and say let's do it in in August which would be a few months prior to the renewal of the contract which puts it closer like what your referencing then we're doing an evaluation at the

094start of the school year which would really still be on the prior school year because we wouldn't have any new numbers from the new school year yet it's the start so we'd be evaluating them in August on the prior School Year's his results as the leader for the prior school year so we would just kind of have a lag in time of of when we were doing that evaluation but it would still be on the same data it would still be on the prior Year's School data the school year the same would be the the case if we said it in October a couple of months prior to the to the contract renewal in January in October we don't have any student achievement data from the new school year so it's in October we're still

095going to have same Achi data I guess what I'm getting at is it's not only just student performance it is not the only evaluation that we have it's also teachers now that's different those are surveys okay so he's got a a survey that's s by his direct report to supervisors and then last year the board opted to do a climate survey of the whole District so those are surveys that's different and he's got a schedule for his supervisor survey so that's completed and done and comes to us which actually is part of the survey process for us to do his evaluation so we take that into consider consideration evaluation so nowhere in this is it do those teachers evaluations come in or surveys sorry teacher surveys do they come in am I seeing that that'll

096be that'll be that's stipulated within the evaluation so as part of the evaluation process it stipulates that actually part A of the evaluation is the supervisor survey um from his direct reports Part B is a section where we evaluate him on actually what you just outlined right the the guidelines the state requires us and then part C is the quantitative or qualitative and quantitative when we're looking at his results so all that's specified within the valuation per the form and the process that we are supposed to follow and that we're going to be following going forward as a board so we're in line with that um and then we as a board can decide how we want to do the climate surray you know if we want to do one every semester once a year

097what we along with Mr up in the administration of course I've heard um comments on those uh climate surveys that we've given out that we just have multiple choice and we don't have any room room for comments to be written and we need comments to be written handwritten or whatever or hand typed so they can cuz sometimes those multiple choice questions are not getting it yeah and I think there was a section on the last one where they could type in some additional but that's a separate you know that's a different discussion that's not something that plays into the contract well it should that is part of his evaluation we don't want to confuse what goes into the evaluation with what goes into the contract yeah what I would say as to the contract is

098nothing that this is going to give you the bones of what has to be in the evaluation but it's still up to the board in a separate vote and a separate debate what that evaluation metric and criteria look like yeah so that that's something that as long as it has these bare minimums in it that's up to the board and the director what they want to expand upon that and the valuation has a lot more in it than the Bare Bones it does yeah this just gives you it's almost like the foundation of the house not the house and we're working on revamping that and that's all something we're going to do in our Retreat so everybody will have a say and buying on that yeah okay the last thing I would say to address

099your original point if that's okay yeah it's it's similar to everything else we've talked about tonight that the only thing I would recommend is if the board's not going to keep June then just specify a month that's it it just makes the it just makes the contracts much more readable and and practically useful let's put it that way yeah and I guess the the reason I'm it's even on my mind is because coming in as a brand new board member I've had a couple of months now to try to go through and evaluate and read some of these things that's a year old to me now you know what I mean and and so and I know that in two years we're going to have to do it all over again maybe with new board

100members hopefully with the same ones you never know and in two more years we're going to be in the same boat again so is this being a 4-year contract I just I just don't want to be I don't want to put new members in that situation where they're having to make decisions on year old stuff again you know what I mean all agree we want to get on a good rotation schedule on doing the evaluation yeah for the board for the district and for Mr for our employee Mr step that's only fair right yeah so what you're saying is if we were to turn it in if we had the evaluation in January I'm or December you'd have the new you'd have half a Year's worth of academic relevant information in addition to because most

101of your board new board members would be similar to me hope coming in in November going through the the first first couple of months of evaluating and getting situated so this new information would give them I guess more information and and more of a chance to make decisions on the recent stuff that makes your point so why why why is there what is the reasoning we would like it to be in June July whatever month like we know what John's reason is what's the reason we want it to be in whatever month well as I stated it's a full and this is part of y tsba recommends that you're getting a full year scope of a review when you do an annual review you we are doing a evaluation on our employee for the entire

102school year not a portion of it but an entire the full school year start to finish based on the goals that have been laid out for Mr step okay um makes sense one one other thing sorry to throw a monkey wrench in this but um because everything y'all are saying certainly can do if if you look at paragraph 23 I got it right that time um renewal of employment contract since we talking about this influencing the renewal one thing that you also typically see that we do have in here now that you see in a lot of toss contracts is if the board does not act to um renew much prior to the actual expiration then that actually is an indication by the board that they're not going to renew the D I just want

103to point out that month actually comes way before January is what we have in here and the board might want to tweak that that March date but I just want to make sure you know it's there yeah um that's something that I've seen pop up a lot more over the last especially 10 years and I guess that was where I was trying to get to was because we we need to let Mr step know one way or the other or whoever the director is we need to let them know and give them plenty of notice at that you know before that so having this information making sure the information is coming in you know before we get to that I guess drop dead day you know what I mean we can totally control that and

104correct me if I'm wrong but we can decide after in two years let's say after the June review we're going to go ahead and ex offer an extension to Mr step for another year right or for two more years um or we could say we'd like to renegotiate the contract with Mr step so we can choose to do that at that time like the P the board could have chosen to have done that back in February when Mr steep requested it so we wouldn't be in a new board position right um we can choose to do that at that time and get it set up when now it's on a rotation of July or August instead of January yeah and that resolves the whole problem of when we board members come on would take care

105of it yeah that would I that would help a lot I think but we just need to be strategic about it really we need to do be proactive be strategic but is that something is that a date that we need to change work on now in this contract before we vote on it the the only date the reason I bring this up now as to paragraph 23 though that March date to me if again I can't speak for Mr step I don't represent Mr step but I can tell you I know why I see that March date and I want to explain why yeah if if I'm a director of schools and I'm not but if I was I would want notification by March for obvious reasons right I mean if you're not going to

106be renewed that's the hiring season for directors is end of a semester into the summer of that school year yeah so nobody no director of schools wants to not know whether they're going to go forward in January because there's no job openings or there's minimal job openings for that level in January so you would not want to change March is my point yeah right so we can change our our evaluation dates and all of our survey dates and all that thing all of that stuff to work within getting us this information before that yes sir March I just want to point that out you want to you would want to keep that March for reasons that otherwise would not be fair to anybody in the director role right right March is kind of actually on

107the very of really better to be April or I mean um sorry February yeah February yeah you would never go to go beyond March though yeah certainly you want to have some time cuz you guys know why I mean typically what happens is if a director for example is going to retire in another school system resign they'll have it effective at the end of the school year boards are looking in that spring semester more often or over the summer so that it just provides more opportunities for somebody that certainly wants is is moving right all right I will keep any other questions we've talked about that one a bit on uh performance evaluation okay loyalty uh wait I about that when it says all board members shall provide written explanation M for Ratings below satisfactory

108MH at the law no that is not the law it is it is the law that if the board the board certainly has to do it in writing and those would be public record but apart from that and apart from those minimum categories the state is fairly broad as to what the requirements are that is something that you see in a lot of directors contracts that section four there you're referring to because if you're given I mean just you probably know why but I'll explain it if you're giving somebody an average to above average rating there's really usually not need to explanation because they're pretty happy with it if you're going below average or pretty low then the employee to correct that wants guidance on what your problem is that's where that comes from H

109I don't remember when I was a teacher that I had the opportunity to ask my principal why she gave me one oh well what I would say there is that's very different because those evaluation criteria every time we do an eval and you know that we have to the administrat to sit down with the teacher go through the entire thing provide very specific details as to what the issues are the director doesn't have that luxury the only evaluation he's going to receive is going to be this one and if they're if you give somebody a I'm not saying you would but if you give somebody a one without any guidance then you're really asking the employee to fix something without telling them what to fix that's where that comes from whereas the teacher would have

110that full evaluation metric to read through right any other questions so we do not have to have that in here no man I have a problem with that okay any other questions on that section so you're asking to remove that well it says um all members uh that if you give them AOW um sat if you don't give a satisf below satisfactory then you have to have it written down instead of just talking about it I we could do an either or if Mr Steph was comfortable with that either a meeting or in writing yeah however the nice thing that is the nice thing about having in writing is yeah you're playing The Devil's Advocate and there are issues then we have the issue in writing that's that we've got documented for having been presented

111really attracts it really protects the board more as well as helping to advise Mr step if it's in writing yeah like renting a lot better than I do I think it needs to remain to hold us accountable for while we're grading our employee and just from the so I'm going to now put just the straight up employment lawyer hat on I would want it to be in writing it's again it's up to y'all you have to but for the reasons you're saying like at the end of the day again I'm going to use a director in general not Mr step but if you ever want to terminate somebody for cause you have to show reasons and grounds for that and if you're not even explaining in your evaluation criteria writing why you did that it

112makes your case a lot weaker if you ever get caught in the carpet yeah you had a lot of builtins when I was a manager if you had somebody that wasn't meeting expectations you were meeting regularly and putting and writing what they weren't doing this this gives us that Weekly where I'm at yeah it establishes the record for and it protects it protects both [Music] sides okay and what about this uh uh written self appraisal from the director that I mean none of that I don't think any of this was in the other contract that is something that we've started seeing more and more as well that you know directors just want to it it kind of follows the corporate model I bet a lot of people in here if they're working that corporate model

113now that's what typically happens I know that's what we do you do a self- evaluation and then there's evaluation by the employer just to make sure there's comparison between the two from an employment law perspective I like that because often times what you'll find and again I'm not talking about the director now what I find is they match more than you think they will so if somebody has let's say talking let's let's move beyond that let's say you have somebody that is a low performer and you want to have them do that annual self- evaluation if one of their issues that you have with them is communication a lot of times that person will even self-report that which makes your case later if you want to take action a lot stronger because you have them

114on record agreeing with so that's where that comes from it's also on our policy so the evaluation policy says that he will do that which is the tsba model policy M but it's what you but you approved it that's our poliy okay other questions on that uh loyalty is exactly what you think it is it's that you know the director at this is a full-time job and often times more so and he will direct those efforts on behalf of the school system for the compensation provided um Consultation Services again pretty standard Clause that I see now um if a director of school want gets asked to come give a speech or let's say an event happens and they put together a presentation on that and they're asked to come talk at a conference Etc this

115would not preclude the director from being able to do those things participate in Consulting situation for another school system it just allows for that as long as the Director it goes hand inand with loyalty because obviously that couldn't interfere with the director providing full-time Professional Services to the school that's why those are next to each other but when we come a top District when we become a top brist which we're going for right you want you want him to be able to talk about itly am I agree um this one is so next is 20 uh 20 is a little bit different because of y'all situation obviously Mr step does not have tenure um in this school system so therefore this provision essentially says he does not have 10e under state law there's an old

116case it's from the '90s I forget the name of the case that essentially say say if a director is serving and there's not a provision like this then those years of service can count toward their tenure so they could become eligible just by being a director so this contract makes that clear that that would not happen the Mr step would not have tenure but in exchange for him giving that up which is something that would naturally happen if it wasn't in here he is saying that the board would not have the power to transfer him to another position that that he's either going to be the director or not working here would be the way to summarize it that's what that is so that's a pretty big deal when you start talking about a fouryear

117contract and a 3/4 of a million dollar buy yes sir I understand that so if there's a reason that we don't want him to be director then it would be termination for cause right we would end the contract understand but we would still have to buy out his contract not for cause no ma' it's only without cause so without cause though say four of us are not on the board next time five there's a holy board and there's no cause they just don't want to work with Mr step anymore but if they were now we're saddled with a $600,000 Burg for our County because we've signed a four-year contract and we have no other option but to pay them pay them and watch them go and get no service that trans being taken out of

118the contract MH puts us in that situation if that were to occur sure I understand that and the the other contract right the current contract does have reassignment language in it is that contract and I don't know I apologize for not was the previous director and that cuz that comes from that PR director had 10 correct so that to me there is the difference but I know if the board is asking me everything you've said is correct um and it's really just a decision as to what the board wants to do there yeah I think that in all the different contracts we've kept that language in that if we could transfer them within this this system ever to my knowledge and I've been here for 30 something years in this system system that uh the

119Board of Education had the opportunity to transfer a superintendent if they didn't feel like they were doing the job properly so they still had a job they still and I i' correct me if I'm wrong they still made the money but they might have to go back into the classroom to teach that's what it says that's what your old provision says you just summarized it and I think that's a good cause to keep in there it has and and this is me just asking I don't I don't know of all of the directors that we've had over the last 10 15 years or whatever but has any of the other directors not already been here have they were they not already tenured before they they got the director's position you know we used to elect

120them so but I'm Andrews was not from this yeah Patty ragdale was not from this County she was not from this County yeah many years ago Donald [Music] Andre I got nothing on this it's a the contract's a partnership yeah we're determining how long we want to offer this to Mr sta later on the board would have to determine is there enough of an issue that they want to pay somebody to walk away or not do we want to put a director in a position where he's not tenured in our district where he doesn't have the option if it's not working here to go ahead and move on so another another thing that could help that is shorten the term of the contract because then you won't saddle the county with $750,000 so your reference

121was into four years right we need probably Circle back around and talk about the timing cuz we didn't really talk about that when we sure but um yes I mean we could look at that differently they definitely affect each other that's what you're asking there's no question one or the other yes sir I think that's getting on into the next section though 21 all right let me get there hold on one second okay contract termination yep um so let's just go through these mutual agreement that should be pretty obvious if the board and the director agree on termination that they can always do that um death their disability I I referenced this earlier but this is something that I typically add now um without going into details as to why I've just had multiple experiences

122as board counsel where this has become an issue unfortunately and sometimes tragically and if you don't have this in here to guide it it can be very confusing as to what the board's options are so that's why I included that um for cause what we do typically here and this is I literally I take that back I know of one contract cont that's different on this but it's the only one I've ever seen is just because teachers everybody that comes up in the state of Tennessee understands how 10e termination Works what we do is that we rely on those cause Provisions for 10e termination to guide how we would do it here it we do that for two reasons that I really like as board counsel one it gives you a a entire 100 Years

123of case law help us Define what those terms mean therefore it makes it a lot less confusing later as to whether they apply or not uh and two again even though I know Mr stepp didn't come up at here he came up in a school system most teachers in this state that have come up in education know how those terms work it's not something new it's something they're used to so that's what we typically use those five but how let me ask you how difficult is it to fire someone for cause to terminate for cause good question and and I'm going to give you an answer and I promise you if I could give yes no in this one I would uh but it really depends I mean it would be very different depending on

124the situation so for can I give you an example mhm so for some of these it honestly sometimes it's pretty darn easy so unprofessional conduct if somebody does something as you can imagine heinous you know I've used I'm not going to use directors here but I've used unprofessional conduct if somebody unfortunately strikes a student yeah we don't have to debate much about that right and again that's not directors that's anybody um if it's neglected Duty that's hard you have to show a trail you have to show a lot of evidence as to how that happened it can't just be something happens overnight it's a continuous repetitive issue it's harder right so it would really depend on which one you're asking and especially with from a board perspective because then you're having to get everyone to

125agree to that correct yeah unprofessional conduct usually is pretty clear uh in most situations and you can imagine all the things that fall under that um inefficiency neglected Duty incompetence those would be the ones that are yeah they're tough yeah even without the board they're tough for any employer and that's what it ties them into the evaluation and the surveys yeah and the supervisor surveys so that's where and again putting in writing if there's anything below satisfactory and I guess the my point to that is is with that being in there four Calla it it's virtually impossible to fire it would be very very hard for us to agree to fire him for cause without I guess the opportunity for him to come back and sue our district or I give two caveat to that

126I'm sorry any didn't could J well I mean I I'm pretty well that that's that's it I mean it would just be almost impossible for us to fire him I wouldn't agree with that for C but I'll explain and I it'd be hard I get that but let me explain why in my experience even deal with teachers and I I mean I don't want to tell you how often I draft charges of dismissal for educators it's unfortunate part of my job I would say anecdotally 80% of the time that's for unprofessional conduct I mean that's the most common thing that we see people get fired for so if you said what is the most common thing that I typically see somebody get fired for it's that so I can't say it's hard or impossible because

127that's the one we see and that one usually is pretty darn clear if you see it it's sort you know it when you see it in subordination also not as hard because if you have somebody just straight up refusing to do what they're asked to do by their supervisor that's usually pretty easy to prove um with the evaluations especially if you guys use a model where the there would be cons consistent feedback from the board as to hear the things we think you're not living up to and those are in writing it's not as hard as you think but there again you would have to have the the the boards yes sir everyone everyone would have to be on the same page more or less not everyone but certainly a majority yes sir yeah yeah

128yeah so for example and I'm just using communication so if communication was a repetitive issue that would have to be the majority of the board putting that in writing making that clear probably voting to put the director on a performance plan and then still seeing those same issues that's what you typically say yes sir and I guess I I've said all that to to drop down to the next for no cause uhhuh that really could almost tend to be our cheapest route had it not been for 3/4 of a million dollars you know what I mean I mean Oh you mean cuz you just eliminate legal yes yeah sure yeah know if you're asking me I know what you're asking me if you're asking me a lot of times just because of how much how

129many attorneys fees how much time time how trying it is on everybody from a time and a you know nobody wants to be deposed nobody likes going to court other than lawyers yeah a lot of times boards will just choose the no cause route just as a b yes sir that's right no question about it so then that brings us back to do we want to go a full four years and expose ourselves to the potential of lawsuits and everything else and a 3/4 of million dollar [Music] that's what I was going to have a question because I didn't know that we' settled up for 4 years I don't at the there's been no settling okay right that's that's that's before you guys but I want to be super clear on that that was what

130was discussed that's what you know I don't look at this to determine what the right term is I look at to see if it's legal four years could be legal it's up to the board what it wants to approve on the term so we can revisit that right with that then well I I don't I don't want to leave that without will me can I pause you for a second I I think there unless y'all ask me I don't a lot of the rest of this stuff is what I'll call boiler plate yeah um is there anything else y'all want to talk about or you could just turn to that term conversation was there any of these other Provisions you had a question about did you answer my thing about my my question about the

131board she not have the option to transfer the director are we keeping that in or we taking it out well I think that's what they were saying y'all are going to have that's going to be in conjunction with your conversation about the term okay the term is versus trans I think before we move back into the term just talking about this cause and no cause whatever my understanding is we're going into this with Mr step renegotiating his contract in the fa good faith that he has done an excellent job for this District up to this point we have surveys we have evaluations we have feedback um and if if we're talking like we're setting this up for failure and that that's what it's sounding like to me and I know where you're going because you're

132playing The Devil's Advocate and you're going but if we're that concerned about whether Mr step is going to do a good job and Lead this District forward should we be talking about doing a contract I mean is that a big enough concern because we're building this contract around having to let him go early is what I'm is what it's sounding like to me yeah and and I I think you bring up a very good point I I and I guess it goes back to from and I I have haven't yet been able to really get a good personal opinion of Mr step and and how he's doing because I've only been here a very short time so I have to take this contract at face value and if all I'm taking is at face value

133then I'm seeing there is absolutely no protections for us as a county it's but a lot of protections for Mr step as the Director because he can give us a 30 days notice and walk away not not owe a Cent and cost us everything all the progress that we've made up to this point can I explain that part real quick yeah we can never but I mean because of and I know that's not where you're going but I just want to explain it the courts never allow you to restrict some somebody that's working from not being able to quit it goes back to indenture in servitude I know that's what I just want you that's why that's in there we we're mandated I guess I'm I'm not saying that I'm not trying to keep him

134from leaving if he wants to that's that's totally up to him but at the same time what's to say another school district doesn't come and offer him $180,000 next week if that happens we have nothing to protect us for the next from them doing that that's true that's kind of the typical employer employee relationship though there's always the more there's always more protections built in there's double protection in here for a lot of the areas we talked about but the employee tends to have more protections and leeway with that than the employer does right because employer always has to show cost although I come from working in states that you can be like oh for no cost no cost States but but because of the Sue and legal system um that you always want to

135have documented CLS to protect the company um can I add one thing goad in the private sector you we if we were in the private sector there's one area in which you see employers protect themselves which is what we call restriced covenants like non-competes non-solicit things like that but those are not we're not actually allowed to use those in the public sector and that's I guess that's that's what I'm asking is yeah we can we have no protection from another another school system coming in and hiring him away more or less and then here we are stuck having to go through this whole process again with whole another person well and it's because of the no Clause language right that's in this contract versus the other one well so the question is is this contract

136worth negotiating with that language or without it are we able to negotiate it without the no Clause language or not Mr you want me to take my protection out of it are we wait can I go back to something so the without Clause language is in the old contract it is it is in it gets the full salary if terminated so it's the same it's the same across all counties it is yeah and and in most contracts right regardless yeah even if you don't put that in there it's implied should and it should be sure no but I just want to make sure it is so what the way the old contract reads is um let me see hold make sure I get the right I don't want to read the whole thing in in

137the event the board elects to terminate this contract without cause the board shall pay into the director all salary due to the director from the DAT of termination till expiration so it' be the same concept it's the same so that's the point like you it's not it's it's standard practice to pay without cost or with cost right so it's not really a it's not a chip it's not a negotiating piece per se right that you it's just it's not a posturing in a sense where it's not outside of the norm One Way Board to protect themselves for that is to reduce the number of years so so if you if you have a 2 and 1 half year cycle which I have something to show about that later but you have a 2 and 1/2

138year cycle on that then if for some reason we decided to S without cause then he would only receive about a Year's worth year and a half's worth of salary instead of three years worth of salary so I would from my experience I would Echo what you said I mean I I'm not getting involved in the debate over the term but if you're saying where you solve the issue and the concern y'all have is in the term negotiation it's not without cause that that part is pretty standard yeah you really the debate goes back to that term that's what we're all talking about and in looking if I in looking at this contract G what you mentioned about you're taking this as face value because you personally haven't had experience unfortunately you are in that

139situation so are a few of our other board members that have joined however you do have data from his tenure and that's what you're going to have to refer to and look at just because we are in this situation at this juncture and I guess that's what I'm I'm referring to as as I'm looking at at data and this that and the other I'm still seeing I'm not seeing I guess I'm not seeing the protections for us and like I guess like you said there really is no protections for us other than the for no cause the term or the no cause the no cause even if I took that out it would still be implied within the contract does that make sense if you did even if it's not in there it's clear that

140unless there was cause you would still owe the full value so that's that's why that part is really can we reass can we reassignment allows you to change to to put them put them to work and you get something that's true right reassignment gives you the ability to retain the employee now if they should choose to leave then we don't owe them any money if we give them another job opportunity and say Hey you can go be the principal of XYZ school um we'd love you to do that and he declines at that point in time we don't owe him any money so so then we that's the only way that we can get any protection is reassign is to to be able to reassign or term yeah look at the transfer I totally get

141where yall coming with the transfer and I definitely have systems that do it the only thing I would say there though is it is a really unpopular provision for from an employment standpoint from a recruiting standpoint because man that gives the board going back to protection and this is my client so I get it but that gives the board a whole lot of power to make a change real quick that this director would have no say in whatsoever and it also where we have disgruntled employee that we're putting to work that's what I was something we may not want him to do otherwise I don't think we want to go down that path but but again it puts the next can I add one thing the next director in a real tough spot too and

142i' I've had this happen guys there's another reason we don't see it as much cuz man you're asking another director to be in there there's different camps I mean it's it's tough It's it's a bad situation would it be would it be sorry I cut you off I'm sorry difficult and I'm sorry go ahead cuz you well I was just going to say if this scenario if Mr steep decided to walk out today we could appoint an interim director from house right and and I I understand that completely too and that's the best that we have capable of doing that job while we do a search and determine who the permanent one but it still brings us back to having to go through another contract in time with the attorneys and this that and the

143other you know what I mean we are incurring expense regardless if he decides to walk out yeah that's always unfortunately the risk when we're going into this it just can't be avoided that's what contracts are about it's limiting damage in that things are not amicable at the point of Separation yes and it's it's not that we're trying to say it needs to be one way or no way right just any contract that anybody's ever put their name to I would read it because it may or may not benefit you to to take that position in the event that things don't go the way you want them to and it could be worse for you in the event that you did sign it had you not even accepted the position so the current contract that were

144under has some differences one being the notification piece 30 days notification in the current propos 60 days in the old um I don't have a preference 30 days is enough I mean 60 days is a little I think excessive anyway unilateral termination um it just says hey you can go if you want to go um removal from office is not in the current but it was in the old one um and these are just conversations that we're having that we're having because it's a contract conversation it's not that where nobody's out to like hang anybody if the whatever just you got to talk until tonight yeah this is the first discussion really open discussion we've been able to have about it so well that's where we're here for sure and well let me ask you

145this on the no cause part if we want to keep it at 4 years is there a way to negotiate or talk about earning that severance pay say after the first year you get one year Severance after the second year then you have twoyear sance still a 4-year contract but now we're up to at most after yeah that you could do that I'm not saying that the problem is it really guts your term because the the value I mean I I'll be completely honest with y'all the value of a contract all these other Provisions matter but the two Provisions that really matter the most are section one which is the term now obviously the pay is in there too but I'm ignoring that for now section one which is the term in conjunction with how

146termination works yeah cuz that's that's what everything comes down to that comes down to the protection everything flows from that what I would say is it don't Tinker with the no cause if y'all are going to get in these debates it really just needs to be a debate over the term that that would be my recommendation y'all do what you want if you tell me to change that I will that's the board's discretion well I mean I I I guess I understand what what you're saying um if that's the only way to protect us as a county as a board it's the best and cleanest way I'm not saying it's the only but it's the best and cleanest way yeah because if you start getting into the tears then it the question is okay when

147does that start do I is it is it all or nothing is it PR rated you see what I'm saying like is it hey as of this date you get another year where as the term it's just clean and I guess like I said taking it as at face value if someone offered me this contract I'd sign it in heartbe and then I would do absolutely the very bare minimum for the next year hoping that you would fire me you know what I mean I would not be insubordinate I would I would live to the letter of the the minimum letter of each law hoping that because then I'll get a huge bonus once you fired me for no CS we're we're talking about and I understand I do understand that 100% I'm not I'm

148not trying to say Mr step would do that for a minute but I would say this can I the only reason I would push back practically there CU at the end of day you're talking about risk analysis which is part of what I do right so let's say it's a 4-e contract okay I'm taking Mr step out of saying let's say it's a four-year contract it's a four-year contract if somebody did the bare minimum and their evaluation show that which they would then you'd have evidence of inefficiency in incompetence all those things then if they get fired then literally what happens practically is I talk to their lawyer and we start talking about it and I start showing all the evidence that we have and I'm going to y'all and saying yeah it's going to

149cost some money to fight about this maybe but it ain't sorry I you ain't it's not it's not going to cost you $100,000 whereas 3 years more on that contract is going to be almost half a million dollars yeah so my point there is you'd be surprised like it's it's pretty rare that I've gotten into these conversations even without a director that that number doesn't decrease as part of the negotiation process yeah does that make sense yeah yeah and John if we were bringing somebody brand new in we were advertising right to to interviewing and bringing somebody new in we might want to look at some adjustments on this but we're renegotiating contract for some is a track record you know that we are going to in trust to continue to push forward and not

150do less than what he's done the last I guess that's your opinion though right his opinion is that his opinion is he just got here and he's the first thing he's got to do is figure out if he's okay with his contract the Bott the bottom line is we've got somebody who has been here and has a track record and we're we're renegotiating the contract based on that track record and I and I appreciate your your opinion on this but what I'm trying to get to is not everyone in our school system not every faculty agrees with your opinion that his track record stands for everybody that his track record is above reproach there's teachers there's other faculty people that do not agree with Mr step and so without being able to represent that without

151being able to represent that opinion how we how do we get into this contract that's the difference we're talking opinion but work against documented factual surveys so you're saying evaluations everybody's going to have an opinion but what we need to look at is the factual data that we have from his tenure and that's what we're moving forward with with this contract is factual data from his tenure everybody's going to have their own opinion some people will like them people personally I've had bosses I like I don't like things they do they don't like criteria that I've been given I do I don't like over the years that's my opinion but it's we're going based on the data that's been collected from his tenure the numbers the surveys the evaluations I mean we have a lot

152of data yeah that's just my point and everybody have their own opinion that data can be skewed as well there is numbers yeah figures figures lie and Liars figure right 77% of approval rating how many people participated out of the 100% so if we only had 55% participate and really approval ra is only 49% versus versus the 7 however that's the data though so people chose to participate or not participate when you're talking a climate survey which is what you're referring to they're choosing to participate or not participate to get their opinion we've got to go on the data that comes in and 49% and that's the I guess that's the rub is is because not everyone in our system trusts those surveys exactly they don't trust trust the anonymity of those surveys and whenever

153you have and I'm listen I'm totally new to this so I'm trying to bring this into the discussion there are teachers that have expressed their concern that they don't trust the anonymity of the surveys so then you get come back to uh what Mr vanick was say is you're only getting a portion of the people that hey I'm going to give a 100% approval across the board because I love this guy and you're you're only getting a very small portion of that data you're only getting that so if you're not in the schools and talking to the teachers and talking to the faculty then you're only relying on biased numbers well it's the it's the data that we have but that is the data that we have I understand that but what is the personal

154data that you've gathered from teachers and faculty and things like that that's the opinion part that you hear from that 77% data is the right side of the spreadsheet not including the left side of the spreadsheet that's it's Cherry kick data yeah and that's and that's where we go back to now how are we evaluating because look we're not if you're not so now now John I think we're getting to the point where we're talking about voting and we're really there yet we're still negotiating terms of the contract well I mean I guess you're right there I'm trying to get to one thing from another so yeah so I I think we're all in agreement that the survey has not been the not survey the evaluation has not been the best evaluation it hadn't been

155revamped in forever ever and the last board was not interested in the majority of the board was not interested in taking that on that is being revamped so we will have good evaluations to move forward with that will have good data in it because it will be objective subjective it'll have numbers it'll have a lot of good information we're all going to work on getting that finalized that's a portion of it then we've got the supervisor survey which is Mr step's direct report so that's a portion of it then we have what you're talking about the climate survey which is a portion of it so it's pieces and parts plus what we hear in meetings plus what people come to talk about with us about so there is a lot that we're bringing to the

156table on this but that goes back to you know we're talking about offering a contract somebody who's been here two years already with that data with that hearsay what whatever y'all are going to use on it so approaching the contract that way is what I'm saying versus it might be a little different if we had somebody that we were bringing in brand new that had no track record at all that we weren't familiar with I think the point is is that without new board members knowing and working with the director the track record is only what we hear and what we see yeah and we're not ready to sign up for four years four years four years exactly right so we're we're to the the term of the contract then can I ask one more

157question yeah was there any more I just want to make sure you guys ask me to go through the terms the rest of that's pretty clear boiler plate background check stuff that's standard governing law again that's severability that's all stuff You' see in any contract so just want to make sure I don't want to interfere with y's debate I just want to make sure I've answered your questions can we go to the next agenda item before we talk about terms well yeah I was thinking you had mentioned that you had something that you wanted to to bring to the table when we talk about the terms so I was going to ask if he wanted to go ahead and well we've already cover everything with him covering the terms that he did I don't even

158need to do that now so we can take that agenda item off okay I would like to cover the first first the next agenda can we break yeah I was going to say does anybody need a quick bathroom break 10 minutes be back4 good good evening sir how are you [Music] we can do our best we can do our best we're doing our best I'm I'm I don't know what's so hard speaking [Music] in so what's the time for [Music] that's not a I've done that it's not a [Music] I would say language [Music] they [Music] okay I'm trying to find [Music] one okay I'll be back I'm [Music] sure I'm trying to f [Music] it's me we keep yeah and I don't I don't dise so and I apprciate that app at the same

159time only good things outside Community see why are those things not being portrayed only they call you complaints I understand that but at the same time those complaints also need to be [Music] it's just not good I tried to hul up in my truck oh my gosh I'm waiting what do you mean you didn't sign up people [Music] yeah ex I'm here elected to [Music] represent I heard I tell you girl well I should not I maybe it's po back into place think [Applause] no I was to say that oh I would rather if y'all do something I say that right now having it right like you really need to get the term back where no matter what it is it's Nots June [Music] come so instead of in starting now contract ready to well

160what I would say you [Music] C it would still be for more I guess what I'm is us out V I don't like now itations are current now let you know everybody's dealing with current it's right in the middle of the time whoever EAS you would just make the basically term Contra new contct [Music] is there not a way that we can when when this contract comes into effect that we can back back up and pay that or or that oh yeah we can do anything on the pay we want not even though you're still continuing for the next couple of months you're going to get [Applause] [Music] all right we will go ahead and thank you everybody for coming back um we will go ahead and reconvene and we're going to pick back up

161with Mr Van Winkle you had some information you wanted to share regarding the term of the contract before we discuss [Music] that okay um so should we I think we were going to have a little bit more discussion about the term and how we wanted to handle that should we go ahead and complete that before we move to those I think this that ter okay well that's what I was thinking okay go ahead so I just wanted to start with this first slide is is some of the support information that we provided Mr step prior to the last work session this is some information that he collected and his staff collected about surrounding areas uh director schools pay as you can see his a circle there at 118,000 some of the questions I have about

162this information uh and I initially was what degrees and experience do all these directors have what type of insurance PES are available for they where they were so in some places they have high deductible po Insurance in our County we don't have that so is that part is that part included we don't know any details about this information and so we were asked to I guess make a decision to bring him up to a level closer to what these other directors were making based on this information it's not an app apples to apples comparison and some of the other areas Kingsport and green City are municipals that receive extra funding they receive both state and city funding County and city funding Shelby County uh Germantown is in that I think on there they receive municipality

163funding as well and recently received a 77.5 million for a new school from Shelby County Plus their normal funding and then a $5 million additional funding uh just from the Germantown City so we're not comparing Apple to Apples to Apples when we talk about salads also in this information Mr step did not include and you see on some of the areas there Mills and mileage are for conferences are included Mr step received Mills and mileage as well and he also receives local traffic mod so that wasn't included in there he does have a cell phone that was some of the information that we provided this was also provided please go to the next SL uh this is from toss provided by the committee the average experience on this uh information is 6 years the average

164uh time in the current district is 5.6 years Mr step has 2 and 1/2 years current what we're doing here now again this is not an Apples to Apples comparison we don't know the performance the terms the experience the funding sources um and I think we should focus more on what we have going on in our County and in our [Music] situation go to the next so um this is some research that I did I download this from the state of Tennessee I've added U links into my presentation to show where I'm getting the data the most recent data that they had had available was 2223 data this is showing director step when he started at 107,000 you can see the highlighted line he was rated 107th in the state at that point out of

165143 counties that's what this data and I and I have this spreadsheet and I had to combine several spreadsheets to get teachers instructional employees and all of this information together and I ranked it myself but I do have all of this fact data that I can provide the anybody that wants it uh as you can see there also education funding by the state we were at 31st in the state so that tells me that um the state funds quite a bit of of our money we don't get as much from local sources as other counties do you can see putting on there below us you see the red circle on on puton County their state funding is is a lot less than ours but their local funding is a lot higher than ours and their

166funding is quite a bit more than ours overall and I I did a comparison of uh per student pay Mr Ste had done that in his previous spreadsheet um he's at $156 per students which ranks 124th at the time there's no current data for me to be able to say where we're at at this point obviously our teachers have received some raises and so is Mr St but now at this point if we if we approve this current contract proposal is going to move him up into what I would say is probably the top 50 or 40 directors for in the state so in my experience with performance man management a fair and common pay increase in most professional settings is 3 to 5% and that's uh based on meet's expectations or slightly above expectations

167a 5 to 7% raise is common for above expectations or greatly exceeds expectations for performance ratings do not allow for raises in most professional settings it comes with an improvement plan and you work on getting better basically and you can go to the next slide so I want to do a comparison with puton county is that was one of the counties that Mr step had provided us their salary information their superintendent started in April of 2020 as an interim and he started at 125 ,000 at that time they were the 13th largest District in Tennessee almost double the students what we have come account 2021 he received a excellent review and was given a raise and an extension or a contract of 2 and A2 years salary was 130,000 which was a 4% increase which

168is consistent with what I I see in in the most professional set valuation scores were 4.14 and the highest ones were on integrity and ethics 2022 one year uh extension on that 2 and 1/2 year contract so he again has another 2 and 1/2 year contract a 4% raise and you can see his evaluation scores went up so you can see the picture of what's going on here in 2023 he actually received a 7% raise and I think uh reading and I pulled all this information from putam County Board of Education agenda and all of their meeting issues so I went into every meeting in December they voted these contracts in added another year contract so he was good for another two and a half years in 2023 he received a 7% pay increase and

169his evaluations combined with both administrators and supervisors were 4.46 again an increase improve valuation same thing in 2024 just recently happened 150,000 with 3 and half% in go next SL some of their accomplishments they met goal on tssa accountability report third grade laa at seven reward schools last year no target schools already said two times the students AC scores were level five uh that's composite over the last two years act for level five direct will be starting the sixth year in April uh evaluation scores based on 131 categories and have come up all the trends go up on the evaluations except for the first or the second year I'm sorry they were almost uh and also their school board I think another reason I chose to pick this was because they were School Board of

170a year for we all saw at the gsba [Music] okay so this is putam County's ACT scores over the last three years you can see level fives most of the way across the board deposits were all level fives of growth is positive the column next to the de colored grass or growth so this is a proposed salary of EXC what we're looking at our contract currently we typically use a laser pointer here but uh this the third column over 2324 is where we're at now with $118,000 for Mr step his uh salary with a 4% increase this year which we will have to raise teachers up this year would go to $122,700 that doesn't include the fringe benefits or the travel expenses so if you adjust for the the fringes it would be 135 380

171that includes insurance and over the last two years he's received a 10.3% Race So if you look at 2425 if we go to 141,000 and we do increase the local in at 4% that's going to move him to 52,5 year if we throw in vacation in a vehicle that's 165,000 if we throw in the 4% that's 170,000 he would be receiving in 25 26 and you can see where I'm going with this but overall 2425 if we do this contract is going to receive a 19.5% pay increase and with a district increase that would be 235% pay increase and you can see with the payout which I have a little off now because I thought we paid out for it it's going to be somewhere around $700,000 uh if we we have to pay him

172out and start him next year if he works for years after that then it reduces something similar to what pu county is doing would be better in my opinion we have a lesser term but so I put that calculator together just to give everybody a picture of where this is going if we approve this contract as is thank you so some of the accomplishments in cly County U we were below our TAA accountability for 23 24 or goal doesn't match what we actually did I think we were cl to 38% the third time we have two reward schools two target schools one is a repeat um I forgot to delete that board point I'm sorry we are not two tons of students C County half the students C County ACT scores are trending down composits

173are level one and the director will be starting year three this year T County ACT scores over the last three years you see we're trending down and as a deposit for 2024 we're level one some of the organizational items that i' that I've seen since I've been involved uh meeting planning and preparation uh strategic plan discussion and update requests have been ongoing since since September and just recently received a request for updates on that agenda items being added last minute document organization is not very good data management and acquisition email communication skills are lacking we still haven't hired a CFO and that's been ongoing since since Mr step started uh middle schools have been kicked down the road for years and we continue to do that there's no focus on it we're working on getting

174some focus on it but we haven't done it to this point already covered the target Schools Federal programs has lost over a half a million in funding in the last two years uh positions have been cut that directly support children uh positions have been added at central office with no real accountability for for data showing that they're benefiting the children okay [Music] I so some other things are opportunities for us that I think we need to work on going forward and get involved get involved in the Strategic plan third grade ELA we're reported 31% we're proficient on our TSA accountability report uh that's available in the Boe meeting minutes from November less than four out of 10 were uh able to reap proficiently this year according to the 2024 data in third grade 38% so

175less than four of our students are reading on a proficient level what are we doing about it uh our leadership doesn't know what we're doing about it because the third grade ELA um the the tools that we're using they don't know if they're working or not that's in the Boe meeting in November primarily these programs and curriculum include RTI which we've been doing for eight years tntp which we've been doing for eight years CA which we've been doing for five master connect which we just now started and if you look at Rome State's data I mean Rome County's data they're getting negative Trends and that's where that Master conect County County we're negative for grow growth across the county in most areas and that's the on Tass provide that link for you and there's our

176act information so voices I've heard from uh support staff in the community uh there's not a lot of collaboration there's a lack of transparency our time is not valued or respected we don't have a voice we are talked at in meetings facing guys don't line with the demographic at our school Some central office staff appear to have time to waste we are testing too much and students are burn out okay so that information is is what why I stand where I do on this contract at this time uh I'm not opposed to having uh creating the contract with Mr step I know he's got a a track record that everybody's happy with in some areas I just feel like that we need we need a lot of work in a lot of areas we have

177a lot of oportunity and we need to have some accountability before we sign a contract so that's all I have that was a lot of time and effort putting those numbers Scott I know you spent a lot of time on that uh just some things that I noticed from what you gathered in some of the numbers and criteria where we are with things there's not a lot to be disagreed with regarding the data that you pulled together um there's several partners that play into that right and Mr step's definitely the leader for our district um we've passed him with that responsibility but so is the board and I can honestly say from my past experience before even being on the board coming to board meetings um and then reoccurring after Mr seep started with the

178new board that I came in on that there has been a lot of board Activity Board involvement in areas that have hamstr strong the director and the administrators um so I agree with you that there does need to be a partnership on a lot of this that's the only way that we're going to succeed in it um and the new board has an opportunity to really let's focus and partner and work on a lot of these areas with Mr step and the administration but also being very mindful of the board what's in our wheelhouse and what's our responsibility and what is Mr Stepp's responsibility and then what do we have in place to hold him accountable as as his employers um so I would like to point out that I brought up the Strategic plan

179since I started since the very first work session that were I know we're supposed to do that we don't even have an agenda for the retreat so that's very concerning to me I do have some items that I presented in the last work session that about added to the Strategic plan some concerns with the Strategic plan way laid out then I received an email to ask what do you want to see change on the Strategic plan so work session minutes that we taking accomplishing what they should ACC yeah and I think that's all good stuff that we need to talk about the retreat I do I think board operations needs to be a big part of that and that incorporates you know the director the administrators and um Miss Diane as well so I think

180we need to talk about that and I also to your point with the iic plan nothing says how often we do or don't revisit that I mean that should be on radar all the time but again we're merging from what used to be done what we want to be done so that does take a little bit of time and unfortunately in the midst of that we've got the contract piece too but um yeah a lot of what I'm seeing on that because as you mentioned putham was School Board of the year so the kind of support in board operations they have in putam has is miles away from what the director and the administrators have been dealing with with this board so um yeah I think this again thank you for thank you very much

181for that cont yes consider something that we can work with there and also the pay increase needs to be considered based on what what they've done there as well yeah cuz you know from a lot of what you brought up in that you mentioned private sector which a lot of us are very familiar with and how raises work there are very different than how they work in the school system and that's something that I've had to get my head around coming in out of the private sector because there is no way in a in the private sector if you were not meeting and this is across the board I'm not just talking about this the Dos position I'm talking about across the board raises are given regardless of you know these results are from the

182top all the way down that you're talking about here from that day-to-day interaction with the students in the classroom we are all in Partnership here in this district for our students none of those things are in our strategic plan Curr well a lot of it you're pull you are pulling a lot of debt like what's required from TSA it's required by tenness State what's required by federal what's required by our strategic plan so all that does mesh togethers is not even at the top of that is changing we talked about that yes so that should be priority number one but what you're saying about the pay raises is not consistent with what Buton county is doing it's it's within those same stipulations that I deal with when I'm doing pay increases anywhere from 3 and2

183to 7% yeah but they're getting across the board like from top down in our district when one gets it everybody gets it so one teacher who's putting in 60 hours a week gets that 3% raise just like the one next to them that's just putting in their minimum to get bought the director in County does not receive the ra that they give they just go buy a raise specifically for him contract evaluation their evaluation each year the only increase so but I'm just saying if we're if we're setting the same example across the board like we've asked Mr step to align a lot of this contract with what we offer for our teachers and staff um we're asking him to align his benefits and some other things with that then we also need to look

184at the flip side if everybody across the district gets 4% Bas whether we get good results or not out of those numbers that you've shown but Mr step doesn't we only look got that criteria to give him his raise I'm talking about the 23.2% we going to give him this year I'd like to make a comment on my part so to be blunt about it we're comparing the existing contract with a new contract and my personal opinion of the existing contract is it was poorly negotiated in the beginning so while it is a large percentage for the raise I feel like that amount puts it closer to on track of what what it should have been to begin with so let's raise every teacher and every other employee in the county at the same time

185I don't think that comment is NE or that is necessarily fair either because Mr step has got his two years of experience at being director from being here two years those uh numbers that that Scott that Scott was showing from the survey or whatever across the state was for superintendents or directors of of schools that had four plus years five six years so yes yes he started out at a at a low position but we also two years ago took a chance on him and giving him the opportunity to First be a director this is his first opportunity of being a director so yeah you're not comparing apples to oranges or Apples to Apples as the case may be by saying that it was poorly negotiated to begin with so and when we talk about

186the raises are we talking about just the certified are we talking about non-certified too because there's more people than just the certified we've done both over the last two years we had the survey study for both certified and non-certified yes but when we talk about raises you know giving a across the board then I think we should include the non-certified too because because they do a lot for our children I agree everybody in the district does a lot for they're here because they want to be here I don't think anybody's saying they don't want to see non-certified get a raise I don't think that's what anybody's intentions are at all what we're talking about right now is the director's salary and is in a spot for a contract renewal it's it's fair for you to

187say right what you said um in a sense right but at the end of the day right we everyone deserves what they tolerate right so if the terms are not acceptable you don't sign right um if the expectation is to grow and exceed expectations then the data should should match that so either it does or it doesn't so the number and the term right so the price your willing to pay and how long you're willing to pay it should match the results that you got in the time frame that you paid for what you paid for so it's like you got a you got a car investment how long are you going to keep that investment as long as it's going to continue to bear fruit for you so we've had ample time in the

188mixed board in the past current board now like we're we're how many months into the the new board five months into the new board all of the stuff that Mr manck was talking about needing to be created in order for us to actively be relevant in our own evaluation process as a board we've not done it okay we we we've simply not done it we've not been able to I'm talking about since we were since we got here in in September September who's keeping you from from doing it from September that we were not able to put any of this together this is the First Progress we made in anything we've ever done as a board we have been stalemated from the beginning for 2 years now and so all of a sudden we're now

189working forward and it's still not enough it's like we're starting to put things together what Travis said is very real very real we're just now putting things together and moving forward so thinking that we've not done it and we've been deliberately not doing it we've not done it because we couldn't do it and now we're starting to do that and now it's still a delay but why should Mr sta be the one that takes the responsibility for us not being able to do our job as a board and I wouldn't even say I wouldn't even say we have it done I think those are two different subjects I hear what you're saying but I mean like I in no way or you in no way or the board in no way has changed his job

190duties and responsibilities in the way that he he he does his job right like we've not changed his job duties right like who he has to work with is his decision to hire fire retain or promote in what direction that he gives them to go out and utilize those skills tools and resources that they have been given are what they are and they're a reflection of leadership that they have now that's a little bit of a reflection on us our only ability is to say here's the policy that we've created and here is the budget that we've given you so if those two things are plain and they are they're we can look all that up at any given moment in time that that rule we not bound by any different group of rules just

191because the faces on the board have changed right how you feel or how you approach that might be different or how you interject or try to control it right I'm not saying that it was easy I'm not trying to say that that one group was easier than there not easier I'm just saying that the results are the results or they're not the results and the constraints and the the the the help or the lack of help is what that is so we're just we're just trying to get to a point I'm just trying to get to a point I think the board will be better served and Mr step's interest be better served if we understand what it is that we have accomplished what can we accomplish and can we compensate the individual for doing

192that job yeah within scope like no nobody I don't think has stood in here on record today and said I'm not willing to negotiate this contract and I think he needs to leave right like I'm not heard I'm not heard anybody say that so I'm I'm not I'm not going to take that stance today either but I think being accurate in understanding all the information that's relevant to making a good decision in alignment with what is happening consistent with success we would be silly to not follow a model that has success and a scope that's relevant to that success and try to mirror that I don't think anybody's disagreeing with that um and I think we've all talked about some of the changes we want to make and we're going to be doing those and

193and we maybe need to have more often Retreats which we've talked about or I don't even want to call it Retreat cuz it's not a retreat it's a plan definely not a retreat I don't know where Retreat came from it just a long need to Rel that thing so planning meetings more often may we need to have once a quarter so we can but I think the partnership in working with Mr step on setting expectations was not done previously there is the scope that he needs to work within right um I don't even want I don't even want to say we haven't done like you're saying September to now we haven't because we have had administrator reports right we've had Department reports we have sat down and gone through where things and we're trying to

194get our hands around okay what is it can we do as a board to help and and how do we keep our eyes on that a little bit more so that's all stuff that we need to be working on we can't forget the list of achievements and the things that have gone on over the last two years despite some of the issues that have occurred you outlined certain things but a lot of good stuff's happen too that Mr step has brought that's true and I have some questions about that too that I wasn't going to cover tonight but I I can send that to Mr St but a lot of that a lot of that is again subjective not objective so I'd like to see information and and there are things that are there that

195I think information can be added to you know how how many times have you done this how how many uh meetings have you attended can you give some bullet points on the grants that we've received I mean I I feel like there could be some detail added to that that would help it be more objective un less subjective do you feel like that that that is something that would have an effect on the dollar amount that we're talking about I I I don't know that that's why iight I just want to be careful too much of getting into the weeds and and and spending Mr step gets his time pulled away by the board a lot and and it's it's been I did have a slide about that and I think I think he should

196set time aside for that and and ignore it until that time is the year he should schedule that and I I'm not he's trying to accomodate requests of board members and I think we all when we talk operations we need to talk about what is our agreement with our employees I think that is getting into the weeds right now I think that's something that needs to go to the retreat yeah but but I I feel like his time could be better utilized helping our district rather than cering to so that's what I'm saying if you were talking about asking for more definitive on this is that something that would really help us reach where we need to the contract if not we're pulling not no I think it would help I think would help on

197evaluations in the future though okay and I would like to clarify one thing Mr van Wile I agree with you I I looked at the Strategic plan much room for improvement and I want to do my part to help I want to do my part to help our students okay I've got three reasons at home that failure ain't an option for me okay I want to see the data that Mr step can do whether it's a 2-year term 2 and 1/2 years four years with our foot off of his throat we don't have that data that's what I want to see so now now the question is what's what's the bottom dollar what what will you accept Mr step as as a adequate pay increase and would it be would it be uh something that

198we could talk about tonight can you give us a percentage that you're looking at I mean this is a negotiation between us and you I think talking in percentage raise compared to talking about where I started it's kind of two I wasn't allowed to negotiate that first contract this the first time able to sit and have discuss [Music] so think about I come up with it that's fine and then and then terms I feel like in my opinion just talking to you guys is 2 and A2 years would be the maximum that I would be and I'm not getting y v but I want to point mention if y'all notice I'm glad have that up there the first contract and I wasn't involved in that but the first contract Mr K you know what I'm

199going appears to be December 2020 if there is one thing I do hate about the current proposed contract you know I'm going is that it would end in January that would put y'all in a really bad situation if it were to expire there's nobody available to take the job so I mean I would whatever you do I would consider that extra half because it's going to then put you in L with your fiscal year and everything else is going to work a lot better moving forward you get that back in mind you can tell that's what Putman did I don't even have to go on Li to tell you that that's why they did that cuz they they did April is that they first approved in December which is probably why it's all 2 and

2001/2 2 and2 2 and2 centy well I can tell you that theirs is like clock work you can go to their their their website every December they have the evaluation scores they have the the raise and it's in the January minut you see of the year it would it would then expire in a fiscal year rather than the middle of school that is yes yeah that that if y'all could fix that you not your decision that would help you out a lot long term something else doing it is it I'm sorry why wouldn't we consider just one year cuz we've had him for three years or one and a half years I mean it still puts it in one year no one year is not even a contract on the one year we really I've

201never seen I mean I can just tell you my experience against y'all I've never seen a director accepted when you're contractors it just doesn't give there's no job security in there what this does if you do two and a half it does give him some security but it also it also lessons are burden overall so four year is going to burden us at $700,000 and it it's going to go down each year obviously but a two and a half allows him some some leway too can you is it okay if you put that slide up there that shows the um the B percentage in the full buyout is that okay to do tell me it's the one that's got 19% [Music] the okay sorry one thing else if yall also worried about that which I'm

202hearing you are with the bout concept and what you could ask me to do is and for cause sorry for no cause provision it could say that what would be due in the in the event of a buyout would be just the base salary R so that numic number not the rest of that which you'd have to calculate it would just and that is not uncommon in contract that you would just tie it to only the base salary not the benefits Etc not the pack right so that that is not uncommon at all I didn't know we were talking about that till tonight but that is an easy tweak I'm saying is that something you would accept that's kind of just common sense because the package would be earned while you're here whereas the base

203salaries what's guaranteed so I will go ahead and make that tweak cuz that is that is a typical tweak yeah yeah Mr step would a two and a half year contract be agreeable to you of course we have opportunity at any point in that after first evaluation or second evaluation to come back and revisit they do in Plum yeah like they're doing Plum every year it seems like they're adding an extra year onto that they're yeah they're just adding an extension every year so the way I'm seeing that if we were to do that in January of 25 did a 2 and a half year contract it would expire June uh excuse me January of 25 it would expire June of 27 the way our meetings fall if we did our evaluations in early June

204we would have the data for our regular work session and meeting in June of that year to consider for right but I still don't have it done before the March 1st I forg it actually still I think your March 1st actually still works there it actually works a little bit better if it were to expire in June because then that gives just more Falls in line again with that fisc so that section myself section 23 uh makes more sense if you were to do to an app it also gives the if you do end up with new board members it it falls in line with that cycle to have that's right also saying they'd have an opportunity to evaluation mm before it would renew they would have part in evaluation what we yeah we saying

205two and a half just to be clear when I twe the contract it'll say June 3 CU that's the end of your fiscal year just so yall know I'm just making it super as and this is one question kind of way off the subject too I guess or on this subject but from the performance evaluation side or somewhere in the contract I know that Scott pointed out that uh middle schools are something that we really want to focus on is there a way to write it into the contract or is it something we would even want into the contract as part of the evaluation where we're at and how close we are to getting it we've got to perform studies to see if middle schools are we have a lot of work that even happens

206from a drafting standpoint I no policy comment at all yeah from a drafting SLE that's really tough because then what I would have to figure out is how do we determine progress like what would the metrics be would have to write them in there and then if it's something I hate I'll put it this way I hate anything in a contract that if you read it and I read it we both read different things yeah and that's what I worry about with those type of metrics is progress is a really tough term to put it and and I guess the reason I'm saying that is is I want it to be that much of a focus for this board and for Mr step I want it to be that much of a focus I don't

207want it kicked on Down the Line another two years another two years progress isn't hard to measure if you know how to use calculator yeah well we can put that strategic plan where we are evaluate a data in the evaluation contort well if we are if we evaluated in the Strategic plan say we want to be all those numbers that we've looked that just a minute ago we want to be farther along than we currently are these are all of our bench marks and these categories that we value we'd like to be here yeah are we within 80% of that range that's progress if we're we haven't picked up if we're in the single- digit range and we're expecting double digit growth then we've not we're not making acceptable progress right so that is easy

208to Define an evaluation matri it's hard to define a contract totally agree with you an evaluation and the evaluation I would argue does play into the contract it plays into cause it plays into all those things but it's hard to put that in a contra cont that is in so we readable by everybody the same yeah we need we need to put it into our evaluation of his contract for the next time more so than trying to put it in the contract that would be my recommendation we need to determine how it's going to work into the Strategic plan based on the data we get back and then figure out what type of metrics we would use to measure it and put that into the the review evaluation yep all right so am I hearing

209a consensus on 2 and 1/2 years is that we're going to one thought about what you said the data we just had some data that you know he's been here what 2 and 1/2 years so we're not we're dis we're not even thinking about that data that I I think that needs to be included but I think we need to work that into the academic portion the Strategic plan okay where are we right now where do we want to be and how are we progressing to get there okay I think all that data that I just share there's some more that needs to be looked at as well I think that needs to be part of the Strategic plan and that would be a partnership between board and the director and the administrators and I

210think that's that's to allowing us to take some responsibility as a board that in two and A2 years how well have we worked together with Mr step um to get to getting those numbers on up you know what I mean instead of instead of it's it's not a fight it's not always a fight with him we're trying to help not only Mr step but our entire District so that's the way it's supposed to work when you're a leader for your employees right the tools you you set the parameters you get the tools well like Travis said take the boot off his neck yeah yeah and that's the that's the thing I think these the data that we have right now is kind of where as a new board we need to uh start our Baseline

211I mean this is this is what we're working with and when we work on the evaluations one of the recommendations you're going to see that the Dos evaluations change dramatically from what it was before and it is following the tsba recommended format with weights and quantitative data um but we need to do the same thing with our board one um so we'll want to work on that ours needs to align with Mr steps as a partnership and they're not aligned that way now any work plan need to they all need to be on the same page y just to clarify where we're at right now if I can't if that's okay please please I'm going to make certain tweaks to the proposed contract which is what it still is I mean there's nothing that's been

212decided that there's no vote no the proposed contract I will take what I'm hearing tonight from the board with ja I'm going to take to be somewhat consensus I will put that back I will resend that by tomorrow and then that will be what you guys can vote upon and even that day you could still move to amend it so I just want to make sure the Public's aware you're aware nothing's been decided I will send you that more modified contract as a draft tomorrow the only thing that I think is Li right now is what's the price right I'm going to leave that blank yeah I understood that so I'm just going to leave that for now blank until there's more negotiations and I think a little bit on that too for Mr step

213to think about when he comes back to us with his answer is are we going to do it the way we've been doing it where there's a percentage raise across the board like everybody's getting in the district and so he needs to come to us with what his bottom dollar would be operating that way or he needs to come to us with what his bottom dollar would be if we're giving him a raise separate a good question so putam County does it U as the Director separate from everybody else in the [Music] county that's something consider to they do that annually right yes they do any and they that's something we need to consider because we're going to be providing two different raises [Music] basically and then something Mr step needs to consider there's some

214years that we don't do that and they've been heavy the last couple years we're TR yeah because we're trying to get caught up Bill wants and in coming years we're not going to be seeing that so that's what I'm saying when he comes back to us he probably needs to give us kind of two two bottom dollars on this so we can my opinion is if we want to start being more like putham County we should for the way they're doing just to tell you how I would write that if you guys wanted to consider that and I'll put that in here as an option for you to consider how I write it but I just want to give you a heads up the way I typically write that and I've done this before is

215it would set a bottom amount which is what it would start out let's say this new contract you know say new contract term and then it would set it could be January whatever you would set a mandatory meeting every year in which it's discussed as to whether the director's contract would go up or stay stagnant I usually put it in there that it would not regress right right you don't ever say that in the contract so really it was set a mandatory meeting where that would at least be discussed by the yep like that yeah we do I can put that in there like that okay so is that you know what you're coming back to us with no no I mean regarding two different yeah two different so what your minimum would be if

216we're giving you the lift in this new contract and you were going to you would continue to get annual raises with the district or if you were to get annual raises separate in the district like we'll put in the [Music] model all right so I think we hash through all of this um and we' come to some consensus on some of the areas that you're going to make the changes to we'll work for that tomorrow again if you if anybody has any questions once we get that please reach out to Mr mccardy absolutely on that and then of course um we will talk a little bit about the retreat this Saturday but that does give us one more opportunity after getting the reformatted updated from Mr McCarthy before our meeting next week so we could

217always and just to be clear as we as we've documented tonight by my lack of knowledge for run neral if I in any way send something because I WR notes down wrong tonight or y'all see something maybe you thought the consensus was this please just let me know don't be shy to say hey I think you wrote 21 not a 22 I don't think I'm going to but hey I'm my point so y just let you know thank you thank you for being here tonight absolutely yeah we appreciate it um okay Scott so we took care of the two items that you had on the agenda right yes all right so we are at um 630 3 hours in we not move this to Saturday first bit um move the rest of it to Satur

218I'm thinking can how much time Mr step do you think it would take for us just to get through the executive committee portion of the agenda um so we've got that done for the meeting uh next week and then we can work on the requested items for discussion we can work on that either we can decide as a board um whether we're going to talk about those during the retreat or at the next work session what we what are you asking so what I'm what I'm proposing depending on how long Mr toep thinks it's going to take to get through the executive agenda the items we need to get through for the board meeting to handle business at the board meeting next week and get that through that tonight um in case there's any questions

219on those items and then the when we start at number six requested items for discussion we can decide as a board um what items we want to put into the retreat or what items we want to put into the work session for next month yeah I'm not willing to not talk about anything that I already asked to talk about tonight uh yeah try not not tabling some of it to Saturday or the following work session following work session absolutely not Saturday uh I don't see a reason not to I mean we could talk about we can pick I guess the real question is how much time do we have Saturday well or today you mean today today yeah I didn't I didn't I didn't set the order of the agenda so I I don't have

220I don't have a way operated on on Time parameters in our meetings but I'm trying to be respectful of everybody's time and make sure that we're approaching this information or what needs to be done in order of priority so we're not here until midnight so I'm looking to the board for feedback on this as a whole U we've got Nick opinion on the item six and Beyond uh but the board as a whole for even though this is it's okay even though this is a work session remember you guys can make procedural votes and motions so for example instead of just talk having a lot debate about this up to you somebody could just make a motion to modify the agenda and move those it table those items until Saturday and see if you have

221majority to do that then it just we could do that we could do a vote or we or whatever I don't know sorry yes can Nick do you have anything that is a priority that you want to discuss right now that has to be discussed for business reasons uh I guess it determines like what can we affect what can we what can we come out of our our Retreat that we haven't discussed in work session and still be able to vote on in our next meeting what the retreat really is a work session the goal was to be able to create as much opportunity for me to digest these subjects as possible and everybody be aware of what these things are and us having open talk to dialogue I obviously had no way of knowing

222that we were going to be 3 hours into the contract thing in reality I was under the impression that the contract and um the Strategic plan were the conversation pieces for Saturday not not today so we didn't didn't know that until we got the agenda no it was on work session because we invited him yeah it was tabled from the it was tabled from the December meeting to this work session so that was that was voted on and decided after that's fine I just I I misunderstood that apparently I thought that that was going to take place in the Satur business priority wise back to Scott's question is there anything that you asked to discuss off that list that we need to get to tonight versus Saturday versus Saturday or at the next work session

223same thing for you Scott cuz I think the two you were the ones that pretty much had put those items on for discussion well looked at what talk have you all had a chance to look at any of the items on on from six and Beyond the athletic stuff talk about a little bit Yeah anybody have any questions there not right now I think that would be you know I think some stuff might come up in discussion okay um so there's some folks in tenants today that have uh given their 3 and 1/2 hours to the first part of the meeting and are not being the opportunity to to be a part of the second half of the meeting so that that's the that's the situation that we're in we can be respectful some people's

224time or we can be respectful to everybody's time so can we do this what in particular are they here to speak on um I don't know if they're necessarily here to speak on it as much as they are to hear us speak on it can we do that now which piece is it uh 6 a through 6 l oh goodness um that's that's pretty much the the that is the whole section yeah and and and it's and it's not to say I mean I don't I don't I don't know I just know that a handful of people have reached out in regards to a couple different topics and there's there's a lot of them that are tied together and there's some of them that are not um the one area um specifically is the budget

225uh athletic facilities in need of remediate repair um there's a lot of these a lot of these bullet points that are all going to point um back into this specific topic um so we can either talk about it or or not I mean it's it's y'all's decision I just I don't I don't think everybody else is going to be able to show up on Saturday right is that something we can cover pretty quickly Mr step U cuz what I'm looking at we do have administrators here that have to do back really um have to stay this well they have to stay we haven't done their portion of it yeah agenda that's why that all be there Saturday no the administrators will be yeah but not for this yeah got it Go all right moving what

226let's do it clock's Tien all right so let's let's do a vote since we haven't come to a consensus on it so um I'm going to make a motion that we go ahead and um cover the agenda items through 5 um tonight at our work session and um that we table the six items to The Retreat on Saturday second for the sake of time all right so that it's not the discussion I thought we going to cover six and not five you guys have a motion in a second just vote on it and see what happens okay so take a vote all in favor second second I second sure second it okay Scott no sure so yes means it's going to Saturday yes six yes six goes moves to Saturday yes okay yes yes no

227no no yes okay okay moving forward with the agenda as it moving forward with the full agenda yep all right does anybody need a break before go home anybody need a break before we move on we're good to move on okay all righty uh Mr St it's to you the the next thing is we had the person that sponsors this upper child ay curriculum m p and I through it it follows to the letter of law it be using supplemental material one the modifications could be by the instructor which we're not paying for that instructor as they explain in several counties they were modify according to the age of the child something on the board pass supp material or not so we will need to somebody have to make a motion it'll be on the

228agenda so we'll have to make a motion to approve it and then I think you've mentioned in the past when we've talked about this that the material then has to be on display yes display 30 days parents can opt out if they don't want it so and by accepting this curriculum we're actually coming into compliance of the law well it goes over Mar you want to explain that it goes over um the appropriate touch in that that particular law the Olivia I think it is and it um is basic parents off in and out so if they want their child taught then they off in if they don't then they off out and it's no repercussion for the kid so there's no grades to it nothing like that it's just extra supplemental education and um

229it's been utilized in several districts around us and has been successful there I've not heard any complaints from anybody as far as yeah it's reducing it's reducing sexual abuse because kids are learning there's an awareness an awareness yep and just to remind everybody we did get a copy of the book B in our life work last work session the question I have are we not already covering what we need to perve the law it's really hard it's a consistency to have it consistent in every single School taught by the same person the same exact way I just feel like that is more appropriate like it will give us I guess a lead up yeah um that's the only you know suggestion I having the same person at every single School teaching the same lessons would

230be I think and not pulling from our resources here which is good yeah and Christy Palin is amazing she's the director of that group she's phenomenal I've known her for years I've gone to a lot of her seminars and she teaches a lot of amazing things she's an incredible person got a good staff any other questions or discussion on that okay [Music] miss you know you're asleep there bless your heart you guys are [Music] awesome okay we'll start with the financial statement well believe it or not we're halfway through the year gosh believe it or not we have our Revenue right where it needs to be at 35,6 29,6 our expenditures are a little bit less than the 50% but I will catch up at 34,848 which gives us a positive year to date of

23173463 what is our expenditure percentage percentage [Music] 44.78 here today thank [Music] you ta you did okay working to at the same time it's probably on Saturday well the good news is is we're running ahead year to dat 95,9 42 on Sal tax and that's always a good thing so without further Ado would you like to start the M of Bud yes ma'am okay the first one is allowing us to receive some funds from battalia that some of our elementary schools and high schools uh applied for get a total of $20,000 they get $5,000 each this will be used for like stem agricultural CTE that sort of thing that will be used in classroom $5,000 each the next one is basically from the same group but it was a much smaller award it's uh $750

232each to two these schools the next one okay why is that not gripping not want to grab on okay the next one will allow us to complete our transportation on to purchase all the buses that we have requested in the budget we came up $1,532 short and I am proposing that we take those funds from our fuel account which we are always over budget there because we budget the fuel dollar higher but I would like to take those funds to finish our bus purchase that would give us five new buses snow days we now for sure the next one is just basically a stiping that U Miss Marsha pson received and this would allow us to pay her her $250 let's see the next one is the recording of our gear up Grant we've talked

233a lot about this and this would be the funding the first funding that we receive on that and how it would be spent the next one is just basically an ism cleanup allow uh them to move some money around to the accounts where it's going to be needed the next next one is the recording of our outcome space funding I have just recorded the revenue and for now I have put it in the regular teacher expenditure line to offset some of the cost there the next one is just recording the recruitment retention Grant it's not actually recording it it's just moving some funding around there the next one is a grant that our maintenance department applied for through Tennessee RIS management the next one is a cleanup for instruction materials on Perkins [Music] basic the

234next one is clean up for Perkins Reserve these are both Federal and then the last two is for our cafeteria fund increasing her maintenance and Equipment no she's increasing her maintenance and equipment in kitchen and decreasing her equipment for her Machinery [Music] Parts just a big fat yay for the grants and the outcome money and then the last one is just recording her USDA funds now that we've gone through all of those does anybody have any questions in the balance in the running balance um where do we get this where do we get this running balance from okay that you take your un audited well this audited now fund balance at the end of last year and I just take the year-to date revenues subtract out the expenditures and that's your running fund balance just

235like your checkbook any questions yes yes um on on this balance right I know I had asked um in my request for this meeting for that to be one of the items that we that is on our budget or I'm sorry on our agenda today so the line items here U obviously we we're not going to be able to come up with you the reason why the $14 million is there But ultimately my goal was to understand or better understand how we have a fund balance of $14 million right okay I can explain that at the end of last year I had projected if you look at your budget that we would have about $1 million well always there's things that are positions that aren't filled and things like that when we don't spend that

236money it rolls to the fund balance most of it was from CTE which basically what I did it rolled to the fun balance and then when we started the year again I re-budget it I pulled it out and put it back in where we could spend it if we don't spend the money that year and these grants are always going to be like that you hear me talk about rollover there was $4 million from ISM that rolled over it rolled to the fund balance and I put it back in so when we finished our budget in June and we came to that number in June with our estimated fund balance does anybody recall what that number number was 3,000 no no no it you're talking about at what it would be at the end of

237this year at the end of last year I had projected cuz I look before I came in here it was 11 million something so the budget for 24 25 it was going to be four but now with this new number it would have come in basically at the end of this year probably around eight or nine when you re add where I re-budget to those ISM funds and the monies that rolled to the fund balance all your Grant Balance is if we don't use it it just goes to the fund balance and you have to pull it back out the next year put it back in the budget so that you can spend it we've had outcome monies too right that yes the outcome monies are in here but that's in your year to dat

238reserves right and I don't ever budget outcome money because I have no idea what we're going to get until it shows up right and and that's the idea here is for us to get a grasp as a board of what funds we have to plan on using within the year that that we that we have a budget to work with them right so if we're Midstream of the year and we have 14 points but you got to get through the rest of the year right so you're halfway through what you're proed this is this is where we are right now this is where we are it's not what I projected this is where we are today that where we'll be at the end of the year no no this is where we are to dat

239now right now BAS on the audited fund balance at the end of last year so are we capable of projecting in in the fiscal year what the fund balance would be based on you could just use budget I mean that's all you at this point that's all we could do is what we're going to spend the next 6 months doing it that way is if we're at 46% or whatever you ear of our expenditures it's safe to say we've got 54% left to spend correct and if that g just use budget that's going to give us you will be at the end of the year we're going to have $14 million you still got to spend the rest of the year cuz like I said this is half the year are we going to have

240$14 million at the end of the year I'm hoping we'll no no absolutely not so how do we how do we know where we're headed right how do we know what work to project we're what the year to date here is six months so you're going to have six months more of expenditures that number at the top is not going to change you're going to have 6 months more of revenues and six months more of expenditures and then that will give you the final number the 14 will change that's what I'm asking how do we know what it's going to change to I can use budget and come back to you with that number what we would spend if we stay completely on budget the last half of the year cuz I've noticed there's a

241lot of um you know I've got a list of and if we I'm not going to fast forward we can get into that later but and it probably save us time to go through all that at later date oneone or however what setting we want to sit on I got list of about 60 different items that I got questions about um you look at a couple different groups that are 14% of their budget 7% of their budget right so a lot of it's timing that's what when they make purchases that's what I'm trying to get a lot of like like our technology a lot of times when we buy like the kids Chromebooks they bought pretty much all at one time so he spins whatever's in that line boom it's gone a most of that

242that you see other than wages it's going to be a timing issue at some point it's going to be spent you see what I'm saying oh absolutely and that's what that's the tribal knowledge I'm looking to gain is to say okay what if we got if we're only if we only spent 14% of our budget halfway through the year or do we believe that we're going to spend the other you know at some 73% of that between now and and the new budget so and we' got projects that are played that we've not issued POS for yet but we know that's just like okay here's a good example I know we're going to do the roof at Brown because I've already talked to Mr Chamberlain they're put the bids out around March looking to do

243that this summer that's probably going to be about $750,000 yep I remember cuz we got the report back that said that it was still in good condition and we app we we agreed that we were going to do it anyway cuz it's 30 years old right okay that's awesome point but that's the kind of thing you're going to see that's going to make these two numbers catch up with each other yeah and and that's what I'm trying to get as how can we that's not a problem you come sit down I mean it's very simple well and that's what I'm getting at is can we get to a place where as board and in a community that we can visualize in real time pace and pace and pace and projection as opposed to like rarely

244do we sit in here and ask questions pertaining to the budget and it's a little alarming to me because it's the only two things as a board that we ever actually get to impact and that doesn't mean I'm trying to take anything away from you or your team or anybody's ability it's just I'm trying to encourage the board to be involved in what is our budget we all stopped to approve it but what do we do between the time we approve it and the next year when it comes in we don't really grasp and understand the inner workings of how the budget is being used and when and why and we don't have we don't give oursel an opportunity to to to be impactful because we're we're not spending time in it right it's like

245we just forget about it and then if something comes up we're like oh my gosh how much money do we got in the bank call Mom see if she'll bail us out and then we figure out if we can or we can't you know and there's some items that are on my agenda here at six and beyond that need to understand is to whether or not can we physically stomach committing to these regardless of time of year if it was in last year's budget or it just needs to be done and projecting is to whether or not we're going to be on Pace if we were to do that it would be super beneficial to us making decisions in that category I think a little 101 from Miss Bray as we're working on things getting

246ready for Budget season right CU we're getting ready to start that shortly a little 101 from Miss Bray would be good for a lot of the the board members and I know you've offered to do that on a one by one basis for people but in order to help with your time if everybody if we gathered and did it at one time um especially with the new board members on it but again also being mindful of crossing over into what's operational and what they're charged to do with and what we're charged to do with meaning what we're not asking her to do anything we're asking her to teach us more or less no I'm not talking about that that's part one part two being to Nick's piece regarding the um leaving it alone until budget

247season kind of thing we get these reports well a lot of this is operational we've got people that are charged with that piece of it that bring that to us on a monthly basis where we can ask questions we need to grasp enough of a knowledge for that and also for when it comes budget season but you know they're charged with the day-to-day operations of it and and what needs to be spent when based on the budget we approve so when we get a when we've got a budget and we've got dollar bills and we talk we we've outlined things that we're going to improve and effec and change how do we know when we're when we're doing it or we're not doing it yeah how do we get something on that priority list that's

248going to be working with them with the budget right and and on our schedule School rotation maintenance and and upgrades and things like that so all part of our strategic stuff we need to be working on where is that where is that list where we can add those things and have priority yeah we're just we're just trying to get get in in in a place to where it's easy to digest just and easy to see because you know it's less question you can come up your own answers if all the data is available you can sit in the comfort of your living room log into the document that has the information needed and find whatever you need to find and come to the conclusion you need to without stopping a board meeting to ask if

249we feel like we're going to be on Pace or not with fund balance because you know there's there's reasons to spend money and there's reasons not to and amend the budget or not but if we don't know if we're on pay we don't know if we're asking for something we shouldn't or not let me know figure what that like [Music] back I would ask I have one ask and I'll talk to any of you we do it class I can talk it all day long I've been doing this for almost 40 years so I'm good before we get to into what we have that we can spend I would respectfully ask this Year please let's decide what we're going to pay these people before we try to build this budget y because last year we

250did it totally opposite and 85% of this total budget is Wages taxes benefits and insurance when you say pay these people you're talking about staff staff teachers everybody cuz the majority of this budget when you take all of that out there's really very left a small amount left for everything else when you look at the majority of these Pages you got the detail you go through and you look that wage line tax line Insurance line tcrs line is the majority of what are on most of these Pages sure yeah and that and until we know what that number is going to be it's very difficult for me to tell you what's left yeah what leeway we're going to have for for other things at that point and we have a mandate from the state on

251the teachers I think that's been something I've been driving about since we started since I started was how do we get a high level overview yeah maybe a bar graph or Department level graph that shows how much money we have how much are we going to spend what do we have left right now we don't we don't see it that way see we have a spreadsheet that's got all these line items on it and I don't know what that means without see High letter you know whenever I present my expenditures to my boss I pull that spreadsheet out I build a bar graph on all the account numbers to say here's how much we spent and I have an aop an annual operating plan that I have to stay within and I show that every

252month where am I at so when we're talking about projects or things that need to be done that the board is agreed that we need to do it that the administration's agree we need to do it we know what kind of money we have to work with and how we're going to prioritize exactly what do we have left over that we can prioritize some of these issues yeah because some sometimes we budget monies based on wants versus need right so your ask is indeed that we make sure that if 80% of our budget is indeed staffed that we have the money to take care of a need versus a want totally can't I can't state that any better um sometimes things come up we budget money for the wants right the Browns right Brown's still

253in Operation Brown right I'm not saying they're not going to be if we don't put the roof on I'm just saying that there might be something more pressing pop up that we would need to reallocate funds toward and for that could be considered in the event that we have something that legitimately is going to stop progress in the near future and I'm not I'm just using that an example may not be a great example I'm just saying cuz it does leak we don't yeah right it just when when when I asked when I asked the principal about it she had no idea seriously seriously this was when when we agreed to it right well she was the one that we walked in the kitchen and showed me where they it had leave so maybe so

254I I don't I don't know I'm just saying that to say that trying to get to a place where we can all look at it from a 30,000 ft view without being a you know well if you can give me a consensus like I said you have the detail on every Department which gives you percentage line wise month to day year to day what it is that would be make it more palatable to make it and to go a little farther obviously once we have a baseline right we get to where we are right I know you work in the private sector quarter you know horizontal data and I know you're not the CFO either even though you're acting um and I don't mean that as in like pretending I just meant you're the acting

255CFO right but um trying to get to a place where we can see vertical and horizontal changes from quarter over quarter year over year you is with the system that I have to work with which is not our system we share with the County government it's not like what I had in private sector I run a quarterly statement a monthly statement six they don't do it's not like income statement in balance sheet right you get the statement of expenditures you got one choice the year and through what month right and and then realize my ask and because that constraint is going to require additional work but I I am I'm not going to let that be our be our limiting factor in my opinion I don't feel like that's worth we deserve better as a

256community than just being limited to whatever the county has put in place to be is is theilla generic is humanly possible to not give us good projecting opportunities no and that's not I'm talking about their accounting system anything that I bring to you other than what I printed I have taken and literally key in it doesn't even come out in except a PDF what you see here is what it prints and then I convert it but even like to give you this consolidation I literally print all 50 of those pages and hand key that and have my Excel if I didn't have Excel here all of my spreadsheets for payroll everything like that is done in Excel oh I would love to show it to you no one you go need to work County that

257or we would have to invest our system where she could hold the data some way and and work with it all right we good to move on okay all right next is just FYI this is the only fundraiser that's been turned in so far um next two will have to be voted on um tsba uh this came up when I was speaking with a board member on nil so tsba sent us an email Miss White I think it was to add the amateur rule to this so that's exactly what lawyers said we could put in there the next policy is tsba recommendation there's an addition in there and real quick Mr step um the 4301 M um is the same one that's under number 6h on our agenda cuz it just didn't get shifted off

258of that it was duplicated on 6h so uh we can just cross that off 6h we don't need to address that so we're addressing it here and then the tail Health Services we got some M I've got a question back back to the promotion retention piece um the new language says the information shall be submitted in writing 30 days at the end of the school year District shall send written notice to parent or Guardian whichever hang on I just pushed the wrong button whether student is eligible for retention alarm the state so my question is uh what information will be submitted and when will the district send written notice so what are we referring to as far as the information to be submitted in writing information from who and about what that's the student student

259documented academic Behavior delay reading above it the voluntary retention go through Dr Farley and the principal so the this information so the information the you want so that's a law that was passed I believe it was yeah May 2023 may4 I apologize but there was a new law that basically for kindergarten through second parents now have the ability to request that we were their child yep that's what that's about so it would only be information from the parent that's referring to so if the parent okay so we probably should clarify that right well it's in the section that only applies to voluntary attention above well well I know but the above it says the student parent or Guardian so are we talking about the parent are we talking about the guardian so that would be

260Guardian to me inter the student Guardian refer to it's definitely not the student you're a guardian of a students so the information is going to be submitted in writing from the parent to the administration within 30 days of them requesting or 30 days the end of the school year requesting volunt voluntary retention by the parent and then the district shall then send written notice later as to whether or not they retain can we Define how long like is is it when the district has to respond to that we we we put a time frame in there when the the individual has to submit their information right so we also probably need a time frame when we should expect information back from admin correct you can I mean that's a different data comes in at different

261times which is probably why you want flexibility there but if you're asking me can do that but would we want to because because then that walks us down to a timeline asking it gives it gives the parents knowing it lets the parents know whether or not they need to plan on their kid going to school in that grade or not before school starts this is all for volunteer If the parents are asking for their kid to be attained y not for not for us ret the administrators or teachers admin have to tell them whether or not they can that's what this is about no this is for the parents asking if they can retain their kids I know not the teach te asking or saying that they're going to retain them I know we have

262a procedure for that we usually do it pretty quickly doc do you want to explain what that is so we have retention meetings with uh principles and we typically have those the end of April first week of May and that's usually when parents will let the principal know by then so that decision is made and the correspondence that we give to families is when their report cars go home so they already know so you remember the instance you and I chatted about at the beginning of the school year so if that were if what you're saying is true would that situation not have been avoided that family was notified so they made a request to to hold their kid back correct and and we denied it correct so we have the ability to deny a

263request to hold a kid back even if they even if they request doesn't that law also State somewhere that the child in order for the parent to request that and it to be granted that there has to be I I documented those two things right there yeah yeah so so the parent can't just say I want them retained they have to show both those two other the two one and two factors that's why we get a chance to look at it sometimes parents do that they don't realize they have to meet both the the second they have to meet both it's not either or an it's an and student has a do that comes straight from the statute that's why it's referenc I to number five I guarantee that references that's the statutory Lang we're

264modifying it cuz that'll make it a lot easier for y'all good good okay um this is theou we have with teleah Health Services you amended it for just to add C to other side it's been very successful and um atca offered the service to the crab work at no expense to us again parents using it yeah we've had approximately 40 visits I'll tell you more Saturday right cool and about half of them returning back to class woohoo how many schools are participating um now we have three four to do it for free again that's awesome is there I vaguely remember this um is there a reason they're not all participating they I we had so many openings so to speak units that they could give us this year and we were piloting it and after

265this first six months has went so well that they were offering if they can get another unit they wanted to start with Prav so we needed anou for them to start their part me to start my paperwork all that stuff I'll make sure that they benefit before we roll it out to everything everybody all right the monthly Personnel reports and newsletters and Calenders Bui trips that have been turned in since the last meeting and then uh regular form for retired inventory enrollment any questions on any of that that you see every [Music] month all right that summarizes that's the meeting section as of right now and that summarizes the executive session piece that we need to or the executive session agenda that we need to have for the meeting next week um before we roll

266into six I'm going to go ahead and say let's take a break please um let's reconvene it 20 [Music] after so that it cuts well I can tell you the typical Reas SP discussion it will be just same that's the I can tell you the con I knew no you're [Music] asking everybody on the same [Music] agenda not just me next time get any that well that's two good points I'll buy that good I hope it does fast that's I just because I know these people sit here and they wanted they came to discuss that yeah not I don't [Music] know follow Diane don't go bathro just kidding that's not part of it it's been a long week [Music] already I'm St believe you're right [Music] is there school tomorrow no [Music] no I heing

267oh did [Music] she just wonderful no [Music] I miss she did not miss a thing you're right I went and came she sent me a text that the door was locked and she couldn't get in yeah I was so attentive I was not looking at my Tex she was so engrossed I was so engrossed didn't even look [Music] at since you all don't check your boxes there I was I need to go my box thank you is many chairs don't I can't [Music] no I'm good [Music] appreciate cheesur [Music] all the [Music] time I can't see hard to see [Music] and I and no [Music] OPP yeah that [Music] think we've got the majority of the board back here after 620 oh she isn't here okay we'll go ahead and get started again reconvene a

268couple things I just want to mention before we go into this session one of the things that we're doing for this work session that we're going to be doing going forward is we are videoing so if anybody did have to they are able to watch what they missed so just like our board sessions um so the public and our constituents can keep up and St can keep up with what's going on in the work sessions should they choose to do so um I have an ask that we do move through this section as expeditiously as possible that we all work together as board members to do that um so we can wrap the meeting work session up and um head on out okay so requested items of discussion we had action item tracking on Google

269Drive yeah so uh the creation of the document has everybody had an to take a look at the Google Drive doc that has been created yeah maybe maybe yeah I don't get any thoughts good bad ugly good burn it okay can you see yourself working with it sure anybody you think it's beneficial can be used should be used needs to be adjusted Scott spent a lot of time with it right I jumped into it it's not complicated I built everything from 6A to 6L in it that I took off a piece of paper and plugged in there and I'm not going to talk on it because he built it but I just know that I used it and I think it's a great tool that help keep everything in perspective from and and it'll help

270eliminate meetings that are going to be this long in the future so Scott I think the intent was to use it for tracking when you built it it was for tracking items that we right here all right I have agreed to you as a board and District so I did create a drop down as a proposed yeah um it's a drop down that that has proposed and so if we do that we can all in a work session say yes we want to make this an action Mr steep can decide if he wants it to be assigned to him or somebody on his team or is it a board or is it a board action yeah um and then we can track it going forward uh give a promise due date if we don't meet

271that date we we can always look at it as a as an evaluation tool as well so if we if we all decide together that this is going to be an action item and we don't meet that promise due date we have a 30-day window to get it closed to be yellow um if we close it on time it's green past 30 days it's red now we can we can evaluate ourselves on how we're accomplishing or meeting our promises so for example the Middle School piece so the action item currently is Task Force right and we've got the end of the quarter that Mr stepp is agreed to get the information to five so it would go on there with that date yes and then it would switch from proposed to open once it's closed

272it would switch from open to closed and we can move it to a tab on that spreadsheet it's all the closed items so we're only looking at the items that are either proposed or open uh during these work sessions who would be responsible so that that's that's a question a good question so what what we do in our staff meetings is we assign a staff member to take notes at each meeting so I don't know if that's something Mr step would want to do or one of us would want to be an assigned notes taker uh but the idea is to have these comments or these U statuses updated before we meeting so that everybody can preview it we all know where these action items stand before we come to the meeting and we have

273this running list of things that we are working on proactively as a team uh and we can track and that might be something that we could visit the quarterly if we decide to have quarterly uh planing meetings or whatever abolutely these things uh I also had added a drop down where they were they apply to either policy budget or strategic plan so that would be the only reason that we would want to add anything to that action it on list or Community involvement yeah I had yeah I did have Community invol fall under promotion so that's one of our three PS and as I say it would be good to have a promotion as a category in there cuz I think that's something that we all need to work on we can add to that

274drop down L I just did this as a yeah a sample yeah yep um not everybody uses Google I know that the Google Drive been able to get into it Anita NOP so not everybody has had but if the majority can well I mean has something that she wants to add we can do it during the meeting yeah if we need to print off and say here you here you go you know at the end of every meeting or or whatever that can be done the idea is that we got to open we've got work we've got list of activity and actionable items and things that we are actively working a running list of what we're working on um so as we can be prise we can we can update as needed when needed and

275it won't take an exuberant amount of time to come to terms and be caught up to speed on where we are on certain topics or projects and we can add or eliminate as needed when needed in real time so this sounds like a board operational kind of retreat sort of thing to me for us to dig into further work session I can present it at the retreat if you want I didn't prepare to present it I have it pulled up now I do just for just for time reasons we can make sure figure out how the administration can tie that all right okay um the next one the C thank you um the CFO search update so we have changed that title to finance controller still still not getting a lot of bites on that

276um we got it posted um going to start start walking around asking some of the accountants around here what would what would it need to take to get somebody in that position some research on that is the reason we're not getting these it might be um it's it's say yes well we don't have a what was the last thing we said was find the person we'll figure out we got to pay them that was the last directive I remember CU they all want a whole lot of money given attached to the position do we right like when when you look at the position does it have a range so we went from CFO to the finance controller because of the original limitations on the salary y so now we we've tried to send out and

277just get people and and we're not getting them to apply at least ones that could do the job so so we're just going to have to get right back out there and keep it posted and post in different places and really go after it you had mentioned me maybe working with some of the local colleges for that and talking to accountants around town and that kind of stuff trying so is there certification or yes Miss Bray look at her she's like hello part of the problem is this is not your normal CFO job a normal CFO and a CPA would be bored to death in this job because you have no control half of what I did the other 30 years of my life I'm not allowed to do here I have view only status

278to the accounting system basically I am a paper pusher approval making sure everybody complies with the com trol office I don't sign a check I send bills to the County finance office for someone else to approve my POS to Pro my requisitions a a regular someone that has a c like a CPA or something they would be four step at this stop so what is the difference between what this spray does and and the position that we're looking to F the finance she's doing all the finance stuff that the finance department requires so we want somebody to come in and that's that's their job is just working on the finance side with the finance director for the count can we add some responsibilities to it like data analysis data mining yeah we can find that

279person yeah what's the what's the feedback when we say we don't find the right people right we say what what do we what do we know that people are are a hard know for like what have we learned for the last two years usually not hired somebody they haven't taken it because the salary was high enough they have no experience at all they just think this sounds like something fun yeah which that's not going to work or either they're a CPA and they're going to want a lot more money and like I said a CPA would be bored with this job because you have no control you are a pencil Pusher you're working in somebody else's data if when you can get in we share the system I don't have I mean my login is

280is only as good as if the ladies in County finance are running payroll running checks so you've already turned me off from it I don't even want to apply so how do we change our messaging to the community the public and the people trying to retain we need to find somebody to do it speaking positively about it's going to help in my opinion but you got to be Hest because one lady that that left after a month yeah did not realize that the job wasn't y she left and she left yeah why not sure this is probably the longest 10 year time frame we've had in the history of K count schools without a CFO though correct yes and I I don't know the whole story of history since Inception but it's probably fair to

281say two years right so I'm just trying to say what can the board do to help I mean if it's I don't know what it is the Billboard uh do we need to independently go out do we identify this as a relevant thing for us to try to go help with while we're promoting can we go somewhere to meet people is there a work session is there a work Fair a job fair anybody on the board have an idea CFO so the job description I mean I mean I think that would be the biggest thing is to like you say not be negative but being honest what they're doing and not doing because if you get somebody that's used to this crazy Financial stuff I know how frustrated I have been when it's like not

282to get to in the week I just want to make a [Music] journal make a journal that's all I want to do I can't do that I have to write it out on a piece of paper send to somebody else see if they approve it and they physically do it things that were just routine to me that I can make and click and get my business done is just tell what work that way and so everybody whoever it is is going to have to understand you're much more of a Financial Manager and someone that manages and make sure everyone follows policy and procedures both from the controller's office to your internal School accounting manual which is this thing that sort of thing it's just it's different but you have to have some accounting skills or

283you're going to be lost reti things that we've been asking for as far as budgetary items thesa funding projections outcome projections those type of things couldn't be added to that position because they're going to understand spreadsheets they're going to understand data they're going to understand analysis they could do that but like I said a lot of that is going to be able to mine that data from the information that we have you don't really they take the time to typ it in until we figure out how to do it differently but they would have something to do that would be beneficial to Mr step and to all of our all of our system understand what we need to do to improve outcomes what we need to do to understand our TSA funding better uh actually

284present high level information to the board so we can make better decisions and project these things if if you find the right person that can manage a spreadsheet is basically all we're looking for and then will be willing to sit down and key all day long so yeah that's something that we can look at too is is how can we help improve that that system I mean it may be money do we need to add that to to a priority list so we can start understanding this better what I'm doing is poon what Nick's saying is how do we look at this and approach it as we're going to get this done instead of adding roadblocks do you think that changing the job description to add some of that would make the position a little

285more we'll do that and we'll get some positive um they notru is that what I'm getting yeah if she's been doing this 40 dang years what the damn problem to allocate a little more I mean I don't get it it's pretty D easy as long as you got somebody else monitoring it yeah that's J okay s good stuff okay um strategic plan middle school committee task force Mr St yeah we got working on the surveys now we're also going to get demographic information um facility information just all that kind of stuff so when board puts the committee together you should have a good Baseline I've already gotten all the research out to you um so you have that part the survey will go out to the whole Community people will tell us they a parent

286Community or whatever and we'll get all that information back to for the for the committee if y'all want to see the survey before it goes out and have some input I'll shoot it out to you uh tomorrow and you can let us let us know cuz we got just the beginning format right now you what middle schools or that it's pretty simple But it includes yes will it includes programming you know for um do you think it'll improve certain types of programming and that kind of stuff so some of the touch points that we've already talked about and so we're still trending on track timing wise for having that data around the end of the quarter yeah it's sometime probably the March meeting I would guess and then whenever you guys are ready to put

287that committee together I've already got some people that volunteered from the community that board members had sent me names so that's a good start you have somebody you want on there you want if you're going to be on there you know that's up to the board to develop that committee send send it send it to you and so we can have a running running list correct okay and and that's you know for us as a board right um trying to get to a place where we're content with our our approach to this right because we're not going to get another opportunity to pitch what we're trying to what we're trying to accomplish so if we collectively are interested in this project creating those timelines we got a deadline essentially in in the q1 like what

288are we going to do between now and the q1 right and what how can we help right instead of just saying hey good luck we'll have a committee ready for y'all in March but we're no Smarter on the topic than we were January the 14th like how can we get oursel positioned to be helpful for Mar March when it's time to go go go do the work well I mean obviously you're going to have input on the survey then we're going to get that out y'all probably want to take it too and uh then at that point all the data we've collected all those studies that I've already given you you know there's I don't know how many documents are in that folder there's a bunch there to to acclimate ourselves to uh the benefits

289of um middle schools is this something that um would be beneficial for us to put onto our website and say hey here's here's a topic agenda it'll be all over it'll be social media whatever make it touchable in multiple areas okay that would be that would be ideal cuz we just not game planed as a board on how we're trying to approach a community in a sense like survey is one topic I know for sure we're talking about a survey I know for sure we're talking about a committee or groups of task force or however but those are really the only two vehicles that I know of that we've identified so those are two areas now what other areas are we going to deploy to get this messaging out um and then how are we

290going to start coding or sifting through that ultimately is what discussed we've discussed a special Committee just a board member not done that yet so but I think do we do we want to do that sooner than later well what the the only thing that I think we could do at this point is what are our options is it can we do it for free can we do it for a low cost can we do it for a middle cost can we do it for two new schools how can we best as a board support if we do decide to do middle schools how are we going to do it quickly what kind of game plan do we need to put together for Mr step's team to be able to decide how we're going to

291implement it talking to Mr step the third piece of this that we had talked about was folks in your Administration coming up with data for us as well cost that's what the district task force yeah so that would be all the information that would be available to us at the end of the quarter of the Tissa numbers I've looked at totals for each School how many students there are how can we divide those students and so I've already done a lot of that leg work but I don't know if it's NE yeah everything help so anything that we can help with I guess Mr St is no and and then we need to obviously put the information out the survey is coming out take it please take the survey it's coming to you um and

292then we'll have the data by the end of the quarter and then we'd look at getting the committee rolling in order to go over that data going I just I didn't know if there's a if we wanted to delay the committee piece or can't sry think we talked about that last work session about that talk about that one put it on the agenda for the next meeting if you want the next meeting yeah do I think you know setting up a we don't want to set up a committee before we have the data yeah we're pulling people together we need to have the information that we're going to be discussing so we don't want to get ahead of ourselves with that I mean I've only to lead the committee so I could have an agenda

293for that first meeting and we can decide if we need be and of course as we have our work sessions and things we can talk about what's going on and get prepared for that so it's not like Nick said we just get to March and go okay now now what we'll be rolling we'll be doing our piece what Mr sep's doing his piece asking if we should yeah cuz right now it's all we're still talking in theory right like there's no different not being sensitive we're still right we don't have a survey to look at right now we don't have a we don't have the only thing we have that's concrete is the end of q1 is a deadline so that means everything that's happening right now is not visible or TCH we don't know

294where we are and we really don't know what to do at the end of q1 yeah what what are we going to have just the survey that's all it's do all the data y'all together yeah for the what the committee is going to need to consider um look you know what we're going to do middle school wise we're going to have to have all that um I have a [Music] question um we dissolved committees so wouldn't we have to vote on forming a committee a special one yes we a special committee we even have to vote on that if if we did a special committee but we were talking about the the Community Committee like we've done with the trauma and for what I Wasing I was talking about a special that's a separate which

295yeah we haven't really gone down that path yet that's something new you're suggest initially when I brought it up was what I was suggesting but it got simple vote though it's on the agenda create yep so I think we we can't do that work we I'm no just minut meeting it's on the meeting agenda and that's why I wanted that's why I wanted to bring it up that way we understand where we what needs to be accomplished what's what's what potentially could be accomplished and by whom is it going to be accomplished so is it going to be just the task force that's Community Based the board itself want to say hey we we find this is a valid valid enough topic to form a committee to do independent research or however you want to

296look at it to bring those things to the table to beat right in the middle of it so we can go out and and and I think if we're going to do that we need toide to your point Scott that we need to decide what we're looking for from the Community Committee right made up of board members and staff and whatever and we have to decide do we need a special committee what what would that special committee do like let's not say we're going to form the committee and then figure out what the committee is going to do let's determine there's a need for that committee and then form the committee that's really the order that we want to do it in so we can talk about that and then decide if we need to

297do it so do we have a list to your point do we have a list Force the things they're going to do right now so Mr step task force is going to you want to do a I send out a list okay you want it in list format or do you want just to roll it roll it out right now for you I'll create the list I'll create the all right we good on the Middle School how we're going to move forward on that okay all right now next uh budget athletic facilities in need of immediate repair um so here's here's uh here's an an area that has been um a topic of ours it's it's in every board meeting right how do we improve how do we repair what needs fixed what do we

298spend the money on we're always either in a maintenance mode or a rebuilding mode or some some mode that requires us to give things attention financially at different times um for different reasons um sometimes we can see it coming sometimes we can't see it coming um how well we are at that equally is going to determine how good we are with our budgets moving forward and whether or not we have to make amendments at any point in time or we don't have to make amendments um and sometimes good Lord acts we just have to take care of business and we have to take care of business um in this situation uh I'm going to I'm going to preface this this report that we've got here I don't know how many of you all read it

299um or not with saying that the bulk of repairs or maintenance that go on on our school's campuses are being taken care of by people that aren't employed by the school [Music] system so I'm going to say that I'm also going to say that this this particular situation with tennis courts the track and the field at smhs um in this report there's also the issue of the tennis courts that have been removed at CCA h s that are no longer playable um none of those none of these issues have happened overnight okay none of these issues have happened overnight um and this isn't my opinion it's just it's impossible for things like this to happen overnight unless you know I mean the sinkhole doesn't happen overnight FL you know floods are floods situation or situation

300cracks appear uh when there's a major shift of an earthquake or if things have settled or they weren't properly construed underground so saying a lot of things to say in reading this report I've got some highlighted items that indicate what is the issues this report came in on August the 12th that would appear and uh there's a timeline that leads up to this that that provides some information Nick before you go into that can you clarify for me cuz I wasn't sure I see who it's to but who who actually did this was this requested by the district was it requested by our athletic director where did this report come from Miss Bray you requested it okay so this report was requested by us already and this has come to the dist come to the

301district for information for us regarding the status of these three areas at St MH okay yep so we it's it's uh the entire football season the entire track season the entire tennis season has came and went since this report got to us um highlighted right this is a baseline construction company out of out of Knoxville is where this this gentleman came into or came here from uh indicated the tennis courts that it's 17 years old uh and there are significant subgrade movements that there most likely caused by extreme freeze Tha Cycles Amplified by the amount of water that's able to subgrade through open cracks that are there so underneath through and because of the cracks are on top of the surface recommendation of course be removed and replaced once proper subgrade testing has been completed

302proper subgrade testing has been completed uh that's that's at the tennis courts um it's unplayable you can't host District tournaments there to my knowledge that's the way that that's been being handled now they they can't play tennis there even though three three and a half years ago I think they launched the Middle School tennis program we indeed have let the tennis courts go um if we ever ever maintained the tennis courts it's not to my knowledge I don't know how or what or if it's ever been maintained repaired what how do even how to do that couldn't tell you but I do know is they've been there for 17 years and they're falling apart we can't use it I know at one point Nick um last work session work session before last week about maybe

303last week's session you're shaking your head yeah we talked about getting the athletic areas fields and such on a rotation like we were doing with Department um well like we have with the schools we've got our assessments of the schools and we were looking at what we and so we had talked about getting that on rotation so this is more on the Forefront when we're looking at doing budget yeah I think in the future that's that's 100% what needs to happen I agree we should have eyes on facilities we should have scheduling for how often we're going to look at it and by whom the evaluation process is going to be given right because if I go out there and look at it I can't tell you the condition of the subgrade terrain like a

304guy that does that for a living right so I don't know how to I can't do that for you so who's going to do that when they're going to do that we've got to be smart enough to deploy the right people to put them in place to look at our our our our facilities in a way that we can we can be mindful of how we're going to spend the money maintaining or replacing um I agree can I throw something out there yes S I know sever County recently utilized a company's name but I can find out that like did a full Athletics assessment and basically brought back a report I'm going to summarize this in very basic more complicated that was that these are high degree of need medium degree of need and that

305was that allowed the board to almost put together what you guys are talking about which I would call an athletic I mean I'm just showing there are companies that will do that like we did for our our there's compies that 100% 100% And and not to take anything away from them because it does need to be those things need to be done that's what they do for a living um but as a board like getting on page with what's what does it look like now from where we're currently sitting and what's going to have to happen in order for us to get the next season underway waiting on the timing of some us employe them be agree to the price be agree to terms and then them do the work and then it actually help

306us for next season I don't know that we have time for that that's why I put this on here as immediate need for repair because we've we've let time go by already and we're we're going to be we're going to be asking a lot of hard questions in the very near future if we don't do something about this from what I've gathered can I can I ask a question soon as as we're coming up to budget season anyway right we not employe a company such as that or go with what Baseline is saying however but determine how fast we need to like you're saying get these fields fixed up so that we can get those included into this year's budget things that we've got to get done before the season starts I mean that that's

307my intention of having this on the item today and that's precisely why I didn't agree to letting this go till the next time we could possibly move it down the line a little farther so I agree with you we could certainly look at what the cost would be and then vote but can as as trying to move this I guess forward do we need to put this on the agenda as we are requesting a company such as Chris is mentioning to come in and give us a quote do we is that something that we need to my opinion would be if the longer if we wait right if we wait on finding somebody to come in like our in finding someone to do it like how long did it take Chamberlain his team like we

308we deployed them for the same conversation it took 6 months for them to physically be able to come on site and do so by by employing them now it still pushing it Way Beyond there to do the and maybe I'm wrong maybe they can mobilize and be here in a week's time I I don't know that company but in theory what I've seen is that takes a minute yeah there's lck time there's no question and I and I I don't want to and I think that's a good point we should come back to but when we get in you know tennis is where tennis is it's unplayable it's it wasn't playable last year really um it's dangerous in my opinion it probably needs to be locked and people kept off of it we've got them

309playing somewhere else right now so that's that's been result right now not long term but right now yeah um right agreed um Stadium Field the stadium and the field and the track are are two issues that are combined in my opinion because they sit on the same footprint yeah the track physically surrounds the field itself the report here goes goes on to tell us the field exhibited wet soft displacing conditions due to slow percolation rates possibly caused by existing native soils that seem to retain water based on the visual inspection after walking the site I did feel obligated to inform those in attendance of the potential of lower extremity injuries that could occur due to the conditions it's our recommendation that the field be removed replaced with a Synthetic Turf to accommodate high volume of

310use by the middle high school teams as well as local youth teams so it's it's a very high used facility uh he says also please note the site testing May necessitate the need to soil SE the site to ensure stability so site testing that's another theme that I'm noticing here they're big on testing makees to see what needs to be and what doesn't need to be come up because it has not survived where it is because of the current soil was built on a pond so since we got I do have a question um and I guess this would be for Miss Bray Dr Maddox Mr step since we got this in August do is there a current plan in place that we haven't been involved in as a board to I know we've talked

311about tennis Sports often on but is there a current plan in place or there recommendations or suggestions that you were going to a different plan that we've been working on for the field than doing this um this assessment what was this the week of the monsoon yeah so this happened right after um that huge nons we had yeah tons of so I ran into this situation at upperman it took it was playable and safe um but Maddox has been working and we've talked to some people here in the room about our plan so um it's not it's not this plan but we want to put on the board agenda for next week um to to I would love for us to have this on the agenda for next you talk you talking about this us

312moving forward with this quote on the agenda which part all of them or just one or so it in in looking in looking at this um you've got three pieces that got to be fixed fix two out of two out of three are in the same vicinity the other one is an existing issue well they're all three existing issues um yes I feel like we need to we need to move and mobilize quickly and come to terms as to whether or not we are going to repair this based on a professional's opinion professional's opinion being people that build fields for a living and and we we identify like we've never seen any any type of proactive maintenance performed here that we like I've never I've been on the board for two years I've never approved

313a budget item that spent money on any of these facilities right so yes this this was a result of getting we got this quote back when we had an issue the issue had some repercussions right we had there was an inj leg injury that did occur during the time that this this report came out so after this report came out there was a lower leg injury kid broke a foot lost 5 weeks of football playing time okay that's one that was on our on our team um now I can't just say that it was 100% his fault it's not my place to say but I do know that that happened and I do know that the the the the track is was falling in well before the monsoon I do know that we spent to

314my knowledge hund and something plus thousand a couple years ago trying to Band-Aid the field itself or Band-Aid the track itself as it was falling in and delaminating due to its wet condition or whatever over and and it's it's not changed the situation and we've this is to my knowledge the first time we've had someone give us a professional opinion and they're telling us to go deeper right they're not telling us to stay up here at the surface and fix things on top they're saying go down below and find out why you don't have drainage being being taken care of and then let's reconstruct okay so that's that's the way I understand this and that's the way that I I've heard it explained I've heard it explained by Mr Chamberlain uh explaining that the drainage

315is inadequate hasn't never been adequate the soccer field had the similar issue where it was not adequate they fixed it to some degree it's not still 100% um so trying to get something done before we're into another situation think time is of the essence and that's the reason I'm bringing this up today in this way and looking at this there's quite a bit of expense involved in these three buckets or Stone one one school um and I appreciate your um enthusiasm and dedication to Athletics because that's an important experience for the students as they're going through their education process I would have a concern with just saying we're we can approve that much money at that school for those areas without knowing like where are the other priorities you know individually I'd have a problem

316doing that because we've talked about Middle School Fields using both the high school or middle school students students using both the high schools and how the fields are wearing and tearing and so it's like where does this fall into the overall scheme of our athletic maintenance and what's the priority first um so you know this is a big what we're looking about 2 and a half million outlay for these three items roughly based on this can I add something to that real quick and I'm sure you guys already know this but just to throw that out remember and I don't even know what the numbers say cuz I haven't seen this and I us but at at best what you could do if you put this on the next meeting you have to put it

317back out to bid based on anybody else that want to bid on it would have to put new numbers in so these as y'all know inflation there's no I guarantee the numbers don't match what's in there from August that's not shocking and then you would have to determine what are the actual numbers we get for bid because you can't just hire Baseline to do it you have to put it out for bid right so I know you know that I'm just to make sure there is even more Life Time your point exactly so to everything he just said how we um decide uh in theory is and I guess if I were going to pick the approach is just that like we've got to get we've got to agree that this is something that needs

318to be either repaired or we're we're content with putting it off knowing we've got a report out there uh and we've got another year that's going to go by in in in two sports where they can't play on it okay so track missed couldn't compete couldn't host couldn't compete on their field tennis couldn't host couldn't compete on theirs football it was they missed uh opening week they missed a couple other scenarios had to rearrange schedule move game venues almost had to totally like and and we're not any closer to any of that being fixed so from that moment in time to today the only repairs that have been made on that field were the people sitting over here and the PE the coaches and the parents and and the the the kids and the community

319that have pulled money out of their pockets to go to work and do this okay there's not been one single repair made by anybody that's employed by the school system that's fixed anything that's wrong over there have we not had you know work on that Miss bra is working on the track I mean we got we got that plugged right now you mean there the conb well they had it Miss bra what you have to do just to make it they prepared the drain and we got that and they did a lot of work over there as far as getting the earth move so and doing all of that they spent probably two days over there now competition's going to come in and actually resurface that area of the track weather perit is that an

320item we have on the budget right now correct to resurface the track itself not the whole track but just that area and what is the what is the expense on that just to do that small areas about $2,500 and that's going to put us back into the scope where we have the ability to host no absolutely not so it just means that we're going to fix the sink hole that will fix where that hole is but we have put a drain and done everything underneath the service we just need him to come in and do the service but it's still not going to put us where where we need to be it's just going to keep us sued when somebody walks out there and trips and falls and breaks the leg correct I mean the

321track is a mess yeah I mean I'll be the first person to say that right and and it's it's it's just a matter of like it us trying to come together as a board and saying look let's get ahead of these things because we know we need to right like we can't undo the past can we get on the agenda to have the athletic director and Mr step and M Bray work together to to outlay for us with the information that we have so we're not losing time to have someone come in what are the first priorities and approximate cost so that way we can if we can get that on the agenda we can start looking at what that's going to be for the budget why we maybe look at a longterm solution for

322actually getting a company to come in and evaluate everything so we you know why this is on the budget today you know why this is on the agenda today why for all the reasons that you mentioned why is it on there why is it on your to cuz you put it on there you request it be because I requested it to be on okay yeah so that's a point so if you're asking me if I want to allow people that should have been taken care of it to take care of it I'm my answer is going to be no Okay so we've got folks in positions that are tasted with doing certain responsibilities you are coming to the board saying you feel there's a need in this area so then we need to go to

323the folks that we've tasked with a request and and they need to come back to the board with that so we can determine how we're going to move forward So based on this report that we have we're asking them to provide a report to us in an unqualified manner not because of proximity when we have a report from a qualified group that tells us what we talking about this I'm talking about some of like athletic wise because we've talked about other areas in needs so we have a full scope idea of what we need to do cost-wise not just at SMH and guess what so if we could have had a list of all those things before should we have to ask for it Dr madx you're raising hand well you know when this all

324got started uh back some time ago because we walked the field back in spre time not have to back back up uh when I Liv store high school when I first got there we had a lot of work to do with the field allthough was a new school there was a lot of work that we had to do to that field and it took us quite a few years to get it back get to the shape where it needed to be in the years I've been here in in the central office it has deteriorated we've gone through three different groundskeepers uh we've had a lot of different issues with trying to maintain because there's a difference between a grounds keeper and someone that's been hired to cut grass M there's a big difference difference we

325actually had grounds keepers at the beginning the first two uh leading up to two more so in the since in in 5 and 1/2 years we've had three different people go out there uh we had the field turned into pure Bermuda at one time and we never had a problem in drainage so we have to take a look and say okay what has changed in that those 5 and 1/2 years as opposed to before now let me stop there and say I would I am in all support of of having all this done with you know that that Nick has presented I'll be very supportive of that but realistically I know where we're at as far as budget wise and when we discussed this this past uh August when this first came out we said

326it needed to be address during the budget season because there was nothing that we could do at that time when I first walked the field with Coach samber back in March of last year my question to him was what has happened to this field what's happened to it who has done this to the field because what happened the real question is who should be doing it something to the field the the field the the field was was had clumps of grass in spots and so leading into the spring the only thing that we could do at that time was we had to prepare the field for the upcoming season when you plant when you have a lot of Fescue Fescue grows in clumps and in order to fill in the spaces and the clumps where

327students wouldn't twist an ankle and turn their ankle we had to fill in those those bare spots so the best ways of filling those bare spots was to go ahead and oversee that already with the same type of grass which is Fescue Fescue is not a good Turf for sports never has been but we had to our you know go our way through the season when you have Fue to fill in those spots we had to raise the blades on the lawnmower to 4 and 1/2 in normally the tur is cut at 1 and 1/2 in when you cut grass at 4 and 1/2 in and you have a sprinkler head and the grass is growing up higher than that sprinkler head it prohibits the water going out so we had to raise the sprinker

328heads okay the other thing that was happening to us was when I was principal at Stone we had to replace one of the drains in the field we had there's four drains on that field but I had to replace one and put a riser underground and a gra on the top of it I never liked the way the design was which was by up design and whatever flaw is in that field in their drainage it was fine when up and design designed it and put it in what's the problem now because we ran Scopes through the drainage systems the only thing only problem we found was in the French drain that's that Miss bra was talking about that's draining we replaced that so now we've got a problem with you know we still have to

329fix the grass my my job as the athletic director is try to get this thing playable before football season we've got to do something for the safety of the kids now longterm Turf the field Turf it make it look beautiful that was my thought but we have to do it at both schools right my also my experience is when we take a bite of something and say we're going to do this school one year and this school the next year that next year never comes because there's a change of school board members well that's true but it's not true right we spent spent $3 million in 2019 project look at where we're at right now with with the plans going forward an email was sent out again to the uh to to Miss Smith Mr

330Brown and the coach sber yesterday morning at 6:20 after a meeting I had with Miss Bray and Miss uh uh kington after our our supervisor meeting where I outlined the next steps of what we had done in November uh I first went and met with the the gentleman at call them Parks and Recreation anymore it's the leisure activities I met with them on a separate issue and at the time I was wanting to find someone who can come out and I know two other gentlemen that are Turf experts uh that I always leaned on to to to build that field up I reached back out to them what do we need to do with this so I had a gentleman come down and take a look walk the field with myself Mr Brown and Mr

331sber what is it going to take for us to turn this Fescue back into a Turf that's made for athletic competition and to get it down shorted up if you go by cchs look at their field I did the same thing with cchs in the springtime we walked the field gave them tell them what we had to do to that field So the plan is this we first had to take a soil sample uh and send that off that has been done I've not seen the results yet Mr Brown had collected that soil well actually the the grounds keeper the grass cutter collected the soil Mr Brown got it and we sent that off we had to find out what nutrients that were needing on the surface of that field again we're trying to get

332it prepared for next season that is not saying that in the future we can't and if the board decides that they want to spend this this money on that facility I'm all about it guys I really am I I and I like to do it at both I want a showcase at both uh at both schools that the community and the kids can be proud of but let's take a look at what we need to do to get it ready for football season so after meeting and going over everything we had to do after the soil sample we and applying the nutrients that the soil is required to uh for for you know be awful growth then in in first first and second week of April we have to apply a substance called revolver revolver

333mixed in with another chemical that makes it stick to the grass along with dye when you spread it so you can make sure that you're not putting too much in that that is you know it's applied evenly all through the field it takes approximately 2 weeks for everything to die when everything dies out then you can observe and see what you have up underneath you've got to see how much Bermuda is up underneath that M now once we see what how much Bermuda is up underneath it then we can find out all right then what is our next step and the way I outlined it to them in the next step was uh I told about this will drive the next decision number one do we work with the Bermuda that we have number two

334do we spring this field and before I go further well by way do we sprig the field number three do we place in various spots with sprig or side number four do we replace the entire field with saw the quote for the entire area inside the track is $ 51,3 120 if this is the route we go the quote doesn't include installation we will need to organize one to two days of work from a lot of volunteers which shouldn't be hard number four prior to the inst installation of the sprigs or side if needed we need a minimum of around 20 to 25 tons of sand spread all over the field and then we need to drag it into the low areas of that field just like you drag an infield of a baseball or

335softball field remember the crown is okay and it is okay if you go out there and look the crown is not the problem it's the low areas on the sideline but we do have low areas that need to be built up next we have to install some rain gauges some water gauges so we'll know that we're not overwatering and uh and so we'll put those around the field but we've got a solution short term to get us through the season but we need to turn that field back into a Turf now if you spray the field it takes approximately 6 weeks for it to grow by 8 to 10 weeks you're on play uh I've I've experienced that before I've done it before uh this is not and once we do that but then we

336we have to make sure that procedures are in place and the proper people are on a schedule that they know when to top dress that field they know when to aate it first and then top dress it when you apply the pre-emergent to keep the the the bad stuff the the weeds from growing into it when the weed uh you know the watering cycle has got to be regulated we can make that field playable before the first game but this is the steps in which we need to take now do I have the $52,000 in the in the budget that's something for the school board to decide that if we have that in in this year's budget because there's no way that this should ride on the shoulders of our parents right I agree you

337know we the our if you recall back in the years ago when we had to have a 2E delay in school and do anybody recall that yep at that time that I had to come up with how much money does our parents raise in our school system so I took St M high school at that time and and we're talking you know 17 15 17 years ago our parents are second to none of what they do yeah these gentlemen right here are proof of it we raised our parents at just one school raised almost 220 ,000 in one year what $220,000 it takes a put it in perspective it takes $8,000 to run just a basketball program it is astronomical and that's before inflation yeah that's that's all valid information I we appreciate you sharing

338that with us you ma' uh there's two actually two bids turned in we had another contractor come put a bid in Baseline has put a bid in both of them agree there is a crown issue of the field which means the grades off and they both agree there is no drainage so yeah this is great I wish it would work but it's nothing more than a poorly placed landid at this point so to to go back and and look at constructional field Clinton engineering is a company task with building the drawing for so to my knowledge they have a drawing that's in place that shows what is indeed this field at construction it doesn't there's no drainage that I could see other than the the French drainage essentially that would shed water away from the

339track off of the crown off the sidelines into that void in between C where the players stand so you go back to 2019 you look at the issue that that they that the board approved to fix that field uh at that time they elected to only fix that field because it was the it was what had an issue okay spent $2.5 million on a total renovation right total renovation in a sense where it they don't have turf there okay it's still in a hole it's still below the surface of the track and they have to put tons of sand on it every year to keep grass in the position that it'll grow okay um so let me let me just ask you Nick I'm going to circle back around a little bit to what Mr

340step asked so you got it on the agenda tonight for work session so we could hash all this out y are you asking that we at the upcoming agenda put these three items on to be voted on and what are you asking for us moving forward now that we've gotten a lot of the information yeah I I just I wanted to get to have the opportunity today to explain what what history has been and how are we operating um and how or how are we not operating in order to get to arrive at this destination okay because as as a board it is Our budgetary obligation to make a decision on how to keep our facilities up to date and up to speed and check all the safety boxes that need to be checked um

341and not only that we've got an obligation to to to to do that sooner rather than later y if we're going to move forward in any capacity whatsoever with those with those three Sports we've got to we've got to come to terms with how how bad do we actually want to fix it so I'm asking that we identify that a professional in the field has gave us a recommendation another professional in the field has gave us a quote also um we have asked for asked for this information to be presented today right we finally got a hold of the information it wasn't brought to our attention Okay anybody else know that there was quotes out there and there was there was a report that said if you don't fix your field you're going to break

342a you're going to hurt your legs no that there's a lot I think there are a lot of quotes that happen out there before it gets to and then it's brought to us with the plan and the ask for money yeah yeah do you have is there any safety concerns that that you're aware of that are outstanding tennis Sports we've talked about for quite some time that's why they were relocated but we have the tennis cours that cchs we got to talk about too not just so I'm getting at that to say to answer your question I I think we need to we need to move forward and ask how to how to budget how how do we budget for this so how do we budget for this right so can can we is this

343important enough for us to take action and and fix the ire situation or just you know fill in some cracks I love Athletics I really love it now that my 15-year-old nephew that I'm raising is playing football I mean it's super important to me but what's more important to me is Homestead Elementary that has 16 cameras and 16 keys that run a school and the school keeps my sheriff sheriff up at night because he's afraid of the things that might happen there we have two SRO officers who are on the ground now so if we're going to spend $2 million I think it's for the safety of our children and when all 12 of our schools are one key and our kids are safe then we can put $2 million into a football field I

344know we need this guys I'm not trying to be rude and I'm not trying to be disrespectful I love sports our kids that coach has made such a difference in my nephew it's not even funny but here's the deal we have a school that desperately needs our help so we going to wait for a shooting or something crazy to happen before we move on that we have the plans how much money did we get quoted to build that addition to Homestead it was 2 six and eight depending on what yeah but we can't find that to fix that school that principal has 16 keys to open and close doors she got a key ring this big she's got poor little Hoopes sitting there in front of a TV screen this big watching and opening and

345clicking doors all day long hoping they don't let the wrong person in or a kid to change locks to I I think what I'm hearing is that um there is a need nobody's denying that but we've got to figure out priority wise PR we need to move forward on figuring out priorities for the Athletics and the rest of the budget I agree with the with the priorities we we've got to prioritize a lot of this stuff um but at the same time are we going to continue with our athletic department knowing and Chris maybe you can help me answer this with a letter like this that says that there is high probability of lower ankle lower leg injuries air liability then raises substantially I would I would think if we invite another school to play

346in on our Fields then it could end up costing us multi-million dollars for some of these athletes if they get hurt and can trace it trace it back to our Fields am I off on that you're not off at all in liability I mean I totally agree with that um if we are and the way you look at it from a you call it premises liability the way you look at that is if we have a known danger and we don't take steps to reasonably fix that within a reasonable time and you can have liability the only the only tweak I would make to what you said is that would still be covered by our general liability insurance Poli so it wouldn't be money coming out of fund balance it wouldn't be money that would

347come out of us it would be money that our insurance company would and then on the back end you would feel that on your underwriting right and then it cost us it cost us more money over several years it it would be more of a longterm hit shortterm that for sure and we've relocated the tennis playing because of that and I'm assuming probably we're not Fielding tra right events because of that so and I guess that's that's kind of what why it's being raised as such a concern is um do we want to continue Athletics on this field on on Stone memorials field at this point well where else would they play well I I don't know but that assessment that comment was made the day after the monsoon so that is a very accurate

348assessment for those at that time two 3 weeks I mean I that happen to be it up and I understand I understand that completely and I don't know Chris can probably answer that too how much of a determining factor that that would which part I'm sorry about when this report was was written well the I mean certainly the report that's what I was getting at earlier the report gives you guys an idea it sounds like there's multiple Cotes gives you an idea of sort of where ballpark would be no pun intended but really there's nothing we could do until you got recent quotes multiple quotes that the board can then determine a can we pay for them and then B which ones are priority which ones are not yeah so really nothing can happen until

349you guys put something on the agenda and I don't you're your decision to do that put them on the agenda separately decide do you want to throw them out for quotes get the quotes back and then determine do we have enough money a and then B is this a property to do now that's what that's what has to happen is just put it on the agenda see how the put go and to your point Mr Nichols it's not that nobody's marginalizing what you're what you mentioned and and what the sheriff has his I guess unofficial report was that it does keep him up he gave the report to the County Commission but but the Middle School conversation also has potential to alleviate some of the requirements of that school and change the Dynamics that are

350indeed of a concern so I don't want to dismiss or just pretend like you didn't say you said and if there aren't things that people know well above and beyond me that are out there I'm just I'm looking to the lenses of this came in when it came in the history has been the history and we're just trying to get to a place like what can we do with what we have in the time that we have to do something with right I $8 million plans for homey how long we had those now two years about two years this is all point of order we're trying to decide what we're going to put on the AG agenda so can we just do that yeah I mean I not sorry so procedurally can I make a

351motion to put that on the agenda as a honestly as a board member since it's so so meeting request we just add that to the agenda quot on repairing M and then the board would just vote at the meeting whether or not to throw this out these three these three items just specifically these three items second in the meantime I guess voting we got we got to keep going forward with the plans that we have in place we don't know what's going to happen this is the only choice that we actually have right now it's the only choice is to basically grow it not saw it because you don't have money to S it right no we can you know I talked to Mr steep about it it's uh and ID have to talk to

352Miss Bray again soing it would cost us about 52,000 versus a million dollars practically to to per that fi but again I would love to see it my hometown looks beautiful all that and we'd all be for that if we could find the money get that done not to make this more complicated but if you want more flexibility for what you can do that night the meeting you put the action item agenda put discussion on possible action items to remedy situation at tennis court Stadium Field so if if it were to be that you didn't want it you didn't I have no idea if you didn't have the votes to go throw it out for bid you can make a vote for example on alternative motion to get saw so it just gives you more

353opportunities to make those fixes can you repat that I knew where you're going CU we parked on the football for a minute right but we we've not you know we still can't compete on the tennis court and we still can't compete on the track so two out of the three issues whether we grow grass or don't grow grass are still not solved okay and that's not there's no quick fix for that to my knowledge and it all has a lot to do with what's underneath the the the surface so um thank you guys I thank you um just that budget lighting project update yeah the Mr mccardy and the County commission's lawyers uh finished up the paperwork recently it's on the agenda for the County commission for them to vote on it already had some

354Commissioners call me just to verify uh the details and information and the loan and the eesi and all that kind of stuff so uh we've been been filling that information out so it's at the County commission we're good to go we've been communication like Mr step said with County attorney and with all green light we should be good I believe that's on the agenda for their meeting Monday night Monday or Tuesday meting 21st [Music] okay um we had had a request to add the budget by department on this is the report that Miss Bray printed out for the board that she can do through the platform we currently have we talked about different things that the board would like to see so we're going have to move forward on that and just work on it

355do the best we can real quick M Bray can you show us where the maintenance item is for uh [Music] athletic facilities is on here n other than the seed and the grass and things like that which which line item would that be down towards the back [Music] line 420 is page 37 it's line 72620 fertilizer Fe line and C I'm trying to get there can you you said 37 page 37 okay line fizer line and line 420 that may be on a different page yeah it doesn't line up it doesn't line up with my page yet um oh okay okay so page 37 on our spreadsheet di is Page 34 of the document 37 4 420 fertilizer lime and chemicals so that budget number is $27,500 correct and we right so so so our

356our current budget for athletic maintenance and repair is 20,700 or $227,500 currently so knowing that we have potential for millions of dollars repairs do we think as a board intelligent for us to have a budget of 20,7 $27,500 no so those are the hard questions that we're talking about how to prioritize maintenance and where we put our money into what bucket has a lot to do with whether or not we're going to have a 20-year problem I think we all agreed that we need to get a plan in place so we're going to start doing out with this budget year and and put it on a rotation like uh like we're doing with the building so I don't think that's up for the booster club spent a little over $115,000 maintaining one field themselves this

357year yeah a lot so I got I got I've got 60 comments on this on this spin by Department I'm not going to bore y'all with those tonight cuz I know y'all have heard me longer than you probably care to for the rest of your lives and that's all well and good um but I I will take I will bring these up um in another setting um a lot of that I think would be helpful as we start approaching budget you know budget discussions [Music] yeah okay um so we've got our plan in place for that uh the next one on the agenda is the community involvement multi tennis facility is that something we need to address with addressing the tennis sure I brought this to Mr step's attention that the that you know maybe

358we can find I think we've all had some conversation on how to maybe find a a joint venture or a group to help us Place solve the tennis problem universally right can we build a Tennis complex a tennis location that will solve that problem for both schools cuz it's both happening in the same location there's a new group um forming or has formed rather called uh kemin cares they're going to be uh having after school day care uh Mother's Day out a lot of lot of things that are family based School based that's going to help alleviate some of the issues that are happening already they're Leasing Property at the First Baptist Church location they have a 40 acre campus there large the bulk of that campus is in grass so I shared the uh

359contact info for the the the individual there um for maybe us to start that conversation in the event that it would serve our purposes of building a comp Lex uh on some other campus that would be University located serve both purposes um just a theory just a thought but just trying to connect some dots with some two initiatives that would that help each other are you like using our funds to build a facility on somebody else's lease property I don't know I mean what's your thoughts on that you'd have to have the liability we could handle contractually I wouldn't I'm not saying that's not an issue but you can handle that contractually um it's the ownership factor of it like the way the way in which we can possess and own real property is pretty

360finite yeah so the question then becomes honestly I'm not dodging your question I just I need to look at that it's a new idea bringing it up yeah that's a new idea I'm not saying no to it just give me some time to think about that and even if even if that and that was the reason for it is knew they had space if we had a piece of property that we could utilize that would serve the purpose obviously that's job one right that would that would make the most sense yeah I just off the top of my head can't tell you where that's located there's and you and I can talk about this there's other ways to do it too that might not be qu un put us leasing it but would still serve

361the same purpose that we could make that work and one of my property gurus at work could probably help us with that is that Mak sense different ways to skin the cap it give us the same cap absolutely to me sounds like a great opportunity to maybe partner with the city's leer Services Bunch like if we were to do something like that with another government entity it' be a little more secure than it's a lot easier than the I have I have put the bug in the ear of our two Mayors but uh that's about as far as it's gotten but I think we all would love to see some kind of Community Partnership in that yeah I think if if that was possible to partner with the city or even you know the county

362but the city already has existing facilities and people to maintain them and everything but I would definitely think that would be a a better Avenue than yep Unleashed property okay all right um policy we're skipping 6h CU we already addressed it uh 6i policy Mastery connection textbook adoption this is another item I asked to be on here um right we've got you know the mastery uh Tool uh instructional material item that's been that's been piloted and deployed um in different ways across the county and then I think Mr stepp has explained to me that there's a different how about this walk us through the timeline how did we get how did we arrive at Mastery connect and where are we now with Mastery connect what was the intention what was the how did it work

363and where are me now with it yeah so just operationally last year we piloted it uh the schools that did pilot it or certain schools pilot at a certain grade level had some success so we decided to do it last semester we all tried to follow almost the exact type format gave principles because every building's different the culture in every building is different so we gave them some uh latitude and then at the end of the semester now that everybody had done it we saw gains uh in almost every area and the principles were allowed to make it work in their building so I just needed to know real time accountability and how they're going to remediate so that was principles over the the break worked on that and we're collecting their plans right now

364and I'll go building to building talking with them to see how it's working and how they feel the point is is to get that Academic Press in real time and provide remediation [Music] so so when we go when we went we decided to go forward with with with using that you know and I'll expand and you can correct me if I'm wrong to my knowledge it's it is either 80% or 100% of the grading scales the students are measured by so we got the principal together asked them what they think the percentage would work in their building they did it in different groups they just some decided on 80 20 others decided on 100% and now they got a little more latitude to figure out how they're going to do it long as I see

365real- time accountability and Remediation so if I can just see that and I see that they're using it and the kids are learning then that's the goal but every building is different every principal's different all the cultures are different so yeah so is Master connect continuing this semester in every building or yeah the principles have the latitude to how's it going to work in their building how's it work for third grade who's self-contained as opposed to eth grade who moves around just a lot of different angles to it so now the principles can decide as to whether or not that's going to be the 80 or 80 to 100% or 1% of the grade no they have to get their plans approved by me so in regular operational sense they're going to have to talk

366to me about their plan and then we'll approve it so is it fair to say that one school's grading scale will be different than another school's grading scale percentages on assignments okay so in that's been that way forever I mean each each billing has different percentages for different things and the principles they're the ones that choose the percentages were they given any parameters minimum minim minimum percentages versus maximum so were they told that they have to have between 80 and 100 or they said you can have one to 100 no they they canot not go extreme where they get rid of it we're not getting rid of it can't get rid of it so they're going to bring their plans to me yep and operationally we'll talk through that and I'll make an operation decision

367on it okay so in in in in that vein of of what's operations and what's board control um and and not maybe control or directive right um I appreciate the fact that we're trying something new right we we we and we asked you to come up of the way to do that and give us real time accountability create those mid midterm results between report cards that way we know if what we're doing needs to be changed or whatever so totally 100% appreciate that my feedback from Principal parents and students is that Mastery connect is harmful this is feedback I don't I I've never taken a Mastery connect test I couldn't log into the computer until I had to take it I can log in I can show you where to find master connect website so

368I'm not trying to be the resident expert or be the operational wizard behind Mastery connect but I think the community itself is a little detached from how you can get a zero on a on a six question test and get a 50 as a grade or get three out of six and get better than a 50 and then that be your primary source of grading your primary source of grading doesn't nothing has nothing to do with the amount of homework that you've been set on home with and you have to do has nothing to do with all the other cour work that you've completed your grade is solely dependent upon your ability to take a test and is standardized testing and its finest and not only that our policy says in 4.41 section 7 the

369responsibility to select from textbooks and instructional materials as recommended by the state commission rests with the local textbook selection committee and then subject to approval by the board use of textbooks and instructional materials not to the list approved US state textbook commission is permissible the board submits a waiver and it's approved I am just under trying to understand how do we have some oversight on that instructional material so can I jump in cuz I did look at that um cuz I knew this was on the agenda so I wanted to take a look at that policy the CU I wanted to see what the definition of that was so you're right under 4.41 which comes from State regs um you're right it says that the textbook and instructional materials essentially have to go originally through

370the commission which local commission first then by the board that's right then I wanted to see what how does it Define that and the way that's defined is textbook and instructional materials and by the way this is that red if you want me to read this whole number I can uh -5- 01-01 I love the state okay um the material shall be defined as any medium or manual of instruction which contains a systematic presentation of the principles of a subject and which constitutes a major instructional vehicle for that subject my understanding of Mastery connec and this is where I just thr this out so using that definition I thought it was just an assessment tool an assessment tool versus instructional tool is different an assessment determines what the effectiveness of the instruction so I don't

371I don't think as I understand Master connect let somebody can explain it better would fall under that definition so if if if looking at Mastery connect I may not have brought that document with me today but I to get somebody else to tell me how it works that's what I understood it it's it's kind of designed to do both like so the whole intention is to follow if I'm paraphrasing is to follow this curriculum so we can be better at taking the the TCAP test right right so it's it's it's logic is to teach principles so you can take this test better so it provides and I'm asking a question now so Master con also doesn't just provide testing your quizzes or data collection it's just it's a it's a bank of questions that are

372that are mimicked off of the state test but the point of doing it every week is not just to do it the point is did the child get it and how are we going to remediate so we don't wait 4 and 1/2 weeks and then all of a sudden half of our class Miss this standard this standard this standard this standard this how's the teacher going to catch up after 4 and A2 weeks on remediation so I my point of doing it is just to provide real time remediation and in the heart of this I've talked to a bunch of directors about this they read this as the instructional materials related to the textbook that's being adopted not as every instru not as every instructional material and and it could so very well be I

373I just my only ability was to take this and say what do we have as a board that that lists um the textbook selection distribution of the care and somewhere along the way we thought you know good of oursel to say we're going to we're going to put this back in front of the board once we once we've got that together so if everything goes away from the books and we no longer have books anymore does that mean that the board no longer has the ability to provide Direction on what our instructional material is I thought that this material from master connec and again help me if I'm understand I to the curricul it's it's it's basically helping assess whether those materials in the textbook so those approved materials are being taught correctly it is

374but you're grade for your so so if indeed you're graded on the what the test you took it is indeed instructional but we yeah instru whether or not you stay in the grade or not yeah but we don't have every teacher come in and I mean I'll give you an example I'm just going to give a personal example when I taught which is a long time ago I had here the the issue I mean I would do my own tests and I did those based upon the instruction materials that I was utilizing ing or relying upon from State Standards which is the textbooks I've approved but I created my test I didn't have to go before the board to approve that because an assessment does not follow that that's why I can create my own

375quizzes my own tests a lot of teachers do that and I don't think we want every teacher coming to y'all and having to get all their test approv right I don't think that's what you're saying I'm sort of kidding just that's what I think I'm not sure when there's philosophical shifts in the gring scale because that's that's the ultimate that's that's the outcome and that's my thing is like it's not that this was you know sabotage and somebody's like oh let's just sweep this through and hopefully the board doesn't realize it that's not what I'm saying it's that if our goal if our job as a board is to look at what instructional materials can y'all remember time when we looked at instructional materials well the science thing is being adopted right now so we're

376is science being the way that's supposed to work and I don't so we do it the way it's supposed to work is that you have textbook committees that are signed every year they provide report they don't ask you to read everything but I mean read every book or textbook but you rely upon those reports and that's that's how yeah it's just we're the Board of Education if our goal was to influence education understanding how our kids are taught and graded should probably be at the front of what we do and if we if we change our grading scale in a sense where it goes to to standardized testing when all the reports are out there says that standardized testing is not the way to go then why are we going to continue to be in

377standardized testing and it is if it was supposed to be brought to our attention I'm just asking if we do get in a position in the future when do we need to be informed of what is going to shift and when do we not right like how how involved in this process do we need to be I'm not the resident expert on education I'm not going to claim to be I just know that when we have policy that indicates that we need to be apprised of instructional materials and our gring skill changes I F I feel like we should we should be in the no on that you have a policy on I'm I'm trying to remember right now what model policy never it is you have a policy on grading skills how those work

378how those are applied across the system um I think of a grading scale is more like you go from 90 to 100 or you go from 93 to 100 right so that should be set by policy and you guys do govern that everybody relies upon that maybe that's the wrong language grading grading method grading method what I would say is and I don't it's up to you guys if you want to be more involved in it I don't play a role in that much to I just want to make sure you know that when I looked at the definition of is this something that would go through what I call the commission process if it's purely an assessment data tool I don't think it has to so what what regulates how what vehicle grading is

379to be determined really the administrators teachers principles deter so if they want to teach them all day long all Mastery connect all every textbook and that would be different if they were if they were teaching for master connect and that was actually acting as the textbook or the or the instruction material that'd be different what I understand is they're teaching from their textbooks or the approved materials and they're using Mastery connect to determine whether the state standards be that's what I thought I don't know is that right that's that's the difference I mean I you're right 100% if if Master connected was something I misunderstood and it's being used to essentially take the place of textbooks which are approved by yall that would be a very different story and we did know about master C

380connect I mean we we talked about it last year we talked about when we did our school tours we talked about that them doing the um the schools that were thinking the word testing it you know we got feedback from them during the piloting it thank you um we got feedback from them from the principls when we were there on the school tour so we we were we heard about it Mr step involved Us in that piece of it but it didn't require our approval and then obviously he's working with principles on the greatting piece on that which apparently doesn't involve our approval either but I didn't think it's supposed to be the whole G we still using the C like what we used to call Pop quizzes when we were in school right the

381pop quizzes we would get so the teacher would know did you get what we went over or do we need to go over it again yeah we call it formative assessment so we you continually do formative assessment to find out if they get it and when you know they get it great you know they didn't you provide the mediation this is just a centralized formative assessment tool that we can track but okay but to what his point is somebody's using it as a grading thing to put like child on this it is theg grade it's it's theg grade homework doesn't matter well that it is theg grade it's up to the principal to decide how they want to use that some some schools had 100% showed a lot of gains uh the principles got together

382and said the minimum would be 80 100 I didn't set that number the principal set that number and now they have the flexibility when we debreath how's it going to look in your building to know we got real-time data and you're remediating how do you feel it's going to work in your third grade as compared to your fifth grade as compared to your eighth grade so so when will we know if it's an effective tool or not uh I got all that stuff ready for for Saturday okay look at other systems they use it get you can all right so I think we got all the questions answered on that clarify the policy okay there's three more policies on here we can move through those fairly quickly um policy 24 2.44 School support organization Nick

383that was one on you requested yep so kind of back to where we were talking about budgetary items and um how we spend money um and how we don't spend money who's been taking care of what uh School support organizations uh reading the primary purpose of those organizations is to assist and support the school in recognizing promoting Student Activities principal being the responsible party for maintaining close communication with such organizations to ensure the organization's goals bylaws and Constitution accurately reflect the vision and beliefs of the school and are in compliance with board policy so anything want I paraphrase that we got an attorney here he can probably do it better than me and he had brown hair once so your hair look better yeah thank you for noticing the intention here is that the principal

384is working alongside these School support organizations to make sure whatever it is that they do or not do on behalf of that body that they represent is within compliance of our board policy right and it's saying that that one way that they found to do that is by including a representative from the School faculty a sponsor I understand that is most of the time the they will they will ask the um coach of that sport to be that school sponsor um but also I don't mean to jump in either but as school representative they're I guess our policy is a little bit off from the comp controller's policy because the comp troller actually defined what a school representative as and lists basically the people that that deal with money right it's not necessarily just someone

385that is employed by the school but the comp troller defines it as a treasure um someone that deals with money as being a school representative can you can I explain it I got here if you want um I L at this cuz I thought this might go too the there's it sort of depends and I know that's a classical answer explain if it's a school system SSO or if it's a school at large SS so so for example the SS School support Organization for X school okay then a school representative has a different um definition if it's a what I would call an extracurricular based SSO like football booster club it's a different definition too the state makes everything fun so the example would be if it's schoolwide or school systemwide School representative would be

386a school board member this comes straight by the way from 49 to 603 um School Board member director of schools a principal or to your point this is where you get that you're getting that one any individual who is primarily responsible for accounting of school system funds or the funds Adent with the school that's if it's that if it's a booster club though what I would call activity specific it's a little broader that's why I was going to point that out so for example School Board member director of school School's principal same ones here then the same one in number four the prim responsible for funds there's an there's an additional one it would be any individual who works for the school system who knew as part of the individual's employment by the school system

387is charged with directing or assisting in directing the related school club activity then there's a separate definition that says I know I'll explain it let me read it I'll explain I got to I got to decode the state then they put to make it more fun they put another definition that says it would always include coaches assistant coaches band directors or any other school sponsor of the related Club so for example if I was football booster club you know what I'm going yeah and the football coach or an assistant coach could not be a signatory could not be a Treasurer they can't hand the money for that booster club that's where that comes from yeah that makes sense really administrator or anybody that's a specific coach or sponsor so to be the sponsor and I

388mean what I typically deal with are a member a parent um somebody like that somebody that really is not working for the school system who is you usually the contoller wants us to have could it be an employee who is completely unaffiliated with a money and B Administration and C that club sure so the organization must include one representative from the School faculty as a sponsor right that's what I'm saying who should the sponsor be well that's what I'm saying anybody that would fall into those categories so if I was I'll give you an example if I was I know and by the way if I could rewrite this to make it more clear believe me I would if I if I was a teacher at ex school and um or if I was a

389teacher and I'm teaching history at at high school and I want to be the school sponsor but I'm completely unaffiliated with the club then I could do that cuz I'm not I'm not an administrator I don't handle funds cuz I'm a history teacher I hope not cuz I was one and then see I'm not an actual coach for that team unaffiliated with a club isn't like you're not going to reap any benefit from being affiliated with would be you're not the coach or the sponsor so you're not the band director so it doesn't need to be the coach correct or an assistant so do we have a list of all of our sponsors per like inter like right now do we have a list of all of our sponsors per athletic event we're in the

390middle of working on all that right now so we don't have one currently the athletic directors should have one of the of the school correct of the school yeah they they keep on file all the bylaws and the con along long they have to keep an updated record of all their officers in that club but I'm talking about who's our school sponsor as line item 21 and our policy 2404 organization include one representative from the School faculty as sponsor who's our school he said even with our ctsos in in Career Technical education the classroom teacher is a sponsor of our ctso uh coach Buck would be and in coach CS are the school sponsors of the of basketball boo that's let me explain sorry I if you look at their number three they can't serve

391as officer they can't serve as treasur or bookkeeper or sign any checks they can't have a debit card but yeah they can access the sponsor sure okay so that's all I was asking who's supposed to be the sponsor so if you look at number three there's your answer they can ask for money up and then that booster club vote on correct you got you know anybody can be anybody they can't have a debit card they can't be a signatory they can't handle the money in any way sh all right right so any plan project movement instituted or to expand modernize renovate or render maintenance to school controlled and or own properties or provide academic achievement awards and other educational recognition to student bodies will be presented to the board in official session for its consideration

392comment evaluation approval and sponsorship this must be done before any public announcement is made 11 [Music] [Applause] so if anybody spends money on my interpretation is if anybody spends money on school property other that other than the board where to be where to be where to be the approval of that I think that's in the con agenda that kind of thing isn't it what you talking about every time they throw sand on a field anytime somebody spends money on school property other than the school board we're supposed to approve it you ex sa to read that one sorry I didn't look at that one my understanding talking to other directors that is not the intent of this how they read it that that amount of BOE oversight yeah I would not consider this to be

393your daily you know like he said s on field certainly anything that would be a project that would affect or change change or add to the structure of the Improvement like even if it was I give example if booster club money wanted to put a new scoreboard which I've seen that a million times at a million high schools y'all would have to approve the acceptance of those fund so do we have to approve the acceptance of them to do to do the maintenance on the field if it was if they were changing the facility well anytime you do something other than its current state is that not change not if you're just bringing it back to what I would call working order like putting sand on grass or sand on a cough course yeah I

394don't think it's that daily operational stuff I don't believe that all has to go if we if we were putting a whole new drainage ditch in how do we how do we have any control over who's going to do what on our facilities then we can just let anybody show up well they no I'm sorry whatever no no that's what I'm saying I'm sorry you're asking me what the board has to approve certainly the the principal or the administrators can say no you can't come on our property or know hey we don't want you to do that we you you guys put them in charge of those daily operational tasks but if it's a tax that's going to change the property or change the facility that's when the board that's when it comes to the

395board so so we've spent Millions there's been thousands of dollars spent on all these field maintenance projects that has not it's been above and beyond what the board has spent okay right so the law of averages says that they spent more money than we have I have no idea on that right if we provide if that information is relevant or accurate did be violated our policy not if it was allowed by the director or the principal do we need to know when people spend money on our property I think not what I would call not a not a baseball coach or a a booster club member coming in and throwing some extra saw down or no I don't think so somebody coming in and putting a new stage in a theater sure cages even replacing

396a structural so for example I give you an example rendery it's like replacing a structure so if you had uh a light pole at a football field and there was a crack in I'm just I have no idea you can guys I don't do construction for a reason but I mean you're talking about a significant maintenance piece that is going to determine whether or not that's going to fall or stand that certainly would be something that to come for the board sure filling in a hole s even if even if that turns out to be a issue now again well that's why you have administrators in place to determine who's who they're allowed on the field who they're allowed to access it has to stop I'm not saying that the school should have no oversight

397of that I'm just saying it doesn't come to the board so what instance would would would we need to know like this if I read this any plan it doesn't say some it says any plan project or movement instituted to expand modernize renovate or render maintenance to school controlled or owned properties yeah I just don't that that's where we're any it starts out is any plan project or movement I don't think that me going over there and throwing sand on piece of grasses Falls underne of those categories does say maintenance right and it well it does say that any plan project movement instituted to expand modernize renovate or render maintenance I so for rendering maintenance if sand is considered a maintenance item on a field is m is I is that not I understand what

398you're saying I just disagree with the the expensive reading but I totally understand what you're saying and and I want to clear I'm in no way saying the board does not have oversight or should not have oversight over its property it does I just think that the daily overside of the property for what I call minor situations like sand on grass is left up to Administration to handle the not the bo somebody would to change breaker out the breaker box that to be approved by somebody correct you wouldn't want a 30 amp place that's right that's right but does the board even know to say no it wouldn't be the board it be be in the some administrative person that's charged with that that know I would argue that anything that happens on school grounds

399we have to saying it whether that goes to the board or not the question of Cl right sure should it be an administrative decision and a board decision it's really I think what you're asking I get that okay all right uh policy 26 2.61 fundraising activities Oh yeah my computer died oh fundraising fundraising let the good time so fundraising should be authorized by the board shall be for the purpose of supplementing funds for established school programs and not for replacing funds which are the responsibility of the board um goes goes on to number five the director of schools will determine whether or not the activity will benefit the school contribute to the welfare of the student body supplement not replace funds necessary to fill the board's required contributions couple questions come to mind there right

400where does the buck stop who who Who's responsible for it our policy says the school board's responsible for the primary source funding my interpretation the uh other entities other fundraising abilities School support organizations should be the supplement right so how how do we know where we stand with that I can tell you we're spending $27,500 a year to my knowledge per our line item our own budget to ensure that we're throwing some monies at um these School Pro established school programs I guess the question is is that is it do we think that's enough money do we how do we know what that dollar how do we know what that responsibility is if our if our if our if our policy tells us that we are responsible to fulfill the board's required contributions so what

401is the board's required contributions so the response I got and asking questions to other directors is the board decides on that every year in the budget season so it's you you decide what what your obligation is as a board um so that's that's up to that's y''s prog so we got to figure out whether or not we going to be in alignment with our policy are we going to be content with being the supplement or the source our policy says that we're not to be the supplement or they're not the currently math would tell me we're we're the opposite okay we we are the supplement booster clubs and Community organizations is the funding body and and act and currently that's not how we're operating so simple if we were to go out and and I'm

402probably sure we already have the data we could probably look and see what money is being raised through fundraising activities uh and those School support organizations and how they're spending it is going to come back and tell us that they're spending more money than we are on our own equipment to clarify that and you probably know this but the the way the school support organization manual now works from Tron controller's office is they do have to provide us their budget reports so that all that all that data is available well and if we're looking at that we can't just look at but thank we can't just look at Athletics because we've got Arts and Music and a lot of fundraising things that come past us in our board meetings where they are raising money to

403do the activity that they want to do at the level they want to do it where the school has to determine what are we providing that's safe secure and and reasonable that's available to everybody across the the school district and correct me if I'm wrong too but School support organizations they don't have to spend money if we if say the coach comes and asks them to pay for this or pay for that their decision it's totally up to that organization whether they want to or not they do not have to in any way shaped form or fashion pay for something that they don't feel is is going to work or they want to invest in and then on top of that we would then have to approve if we're going to allow them to do

404that yeah and whether that's an administrative level or board so for example go back to that Schoolboard example the steps there would be somebody thinks you need a new school board you go to the booster club they say hey we can pay for that we'll sponsor it we got two donors then they have to come back to the board though to determine do we want to accept those funds and move forward with that project done y That's all true so I I guess what I would ask us to do right is we're starting to head into budget season and and all of these different things have kind of came to surface knowing that we've got some language that tells us that we're we're supposed to be responsible as that primary funding source instead of the

405secondary funding source let's get some let's get some information available how do we best find oursel getting that information do we need to look it up on our own to find out how much money is being spent by these School support organizations or can we ask for somebody to get that for us we get the end of the year reports every year it's required to go in cont controller Miss bra is that I going to say you we you should have last year's because it it's required that you report that to the cont controller correct so that's that's something that look at the last years all the school all the official School organizations have to turn that in we have to turn to is that just something we can simply ask for or do we

406need to add that to an agenda and vote to ask for it Miss Bray has all that we can we can get it all compiled just SSO spend over the last 3 years okay perfect that's all I had on that one all right um last policy 4.3 extracurricular activities line one says the board shall initially approve each specific extracurricular activity so proper support and supervision may be assured I I I it it ties into kind of what we already are talking about um proper support supervision supervision is the sponsor proper support is primary funding source being the board secondary funding source being ssos or whoever just wants to graciously give their funds time or money um so knowing that we've got that in our first line item in our in that policy how you know

407we've talked we this has came up and it's been cited and some people agree some people disagree as to whether or not we are to initially approve each specific extracurricular activity our policy says we are so how are we getting how are we being proposed with those extracurricular activities and how can we continue to do that what what extracurricular activities are going on that that aren't haven't been run through the proper channels h what extracurricular activities are going on that haven't been run through the proper channels for the policy I don't know do you know no know that's what I'm asking I mean why is this an issue are there extracurricular going onun been run give you an example because initially when you set up a when you start you sp uh say if we

408wanted to start a lacrosse te uh here recently last year we start it's a soda it's a soda okay we started started a a girls flag football team last year that had to come before this board right and you guys approved of it because they were're changing the budget because we got to pay the coach we have to increase you know their pay so initially that comes before the board we don't vote on and improve it every annually because they're already established it says initially so anytime we start a new sport that has to do with football so right to his point right that those things have to be funded proper support and supervisions got to be assured if we're not looking at these things periodically we don't know if they're receiving proper supervision or

409they're receiving proper support so I'm asking the board to make sure like this is one of the reasons that I asked for the the full-time athletic director position to be the description to be made and for us to adopt that that position into our budget right is so we can do that so we can keep our we have eyes on the prize of of what is the proper support how are the activities being managed and so we can do that our policy says we're going to do it we're just not right the only caveat I would go out there just legally is and if the board wants to expand that the board has every Power to do so the only thing you're mandated to do by policy is be involved in the initial approval process

410of a new like like across like we just exampled after that it all falls back to the basic goes back to that director of schools provision we talked about earlier 49 2-31 b1a what that says is it's the duty of the board to assign the director of school to quote act for the board and seeing that the laws related to the schools and the rules of the state and the local board be executed so for example to make sure that you have good coaches in place that kids are taken care of that's a responsibility of the director to provide that and put it down to the his or her design needs M right so I mean you're doing that by hiring a director saying that but if you want to increase oversight you can y

411I just want to make sure you know you can do is we're just trying the goal is to to to not do the the minimum and do the do what we've always been doing right that's not my my goal is to find out what our policies tell us we're able to do so that we might Aid in the opportunity factor and that's really what I'm getting at is how can we be more active in ensuring that we're following our policies as Boardman right bullet point one initially improve specific activity Provide support and the supervision may be ured so I'm just saying can we create touch points or how do we do that how do y how how do you do you all think we need to do it is that what kind of what the

412director's report should be is each year whenever they come and give give their reports all of those say it's the athletic director should be reporting on all of the Athletics going on and not just main one main two right and how broad is extracurricular pretty broad very broad very broad very broad but that you got sponsor too and it says here approve each specific extracurricular so having a list of all those ex those specific extracurriculars for us to approve and ensure that they're getting the support I guess what I'm getting that is we won't find oursel in a position to where we're trying to fund every extracurricular activity that's in our school district with $27,500 could have saved you a bunch of time and just said that but without giving you all the information I

413don't know that we would have arrived there it would have meant anything but it's impossible to think that we're capable of helping everybody that has an extracurricular activity with $27,500 that's all I have and in fact we didn't we didn't add that one item to the line item or the we didn't add the director uh athletic director position to the agenda which we can do in the next [Music] meeting Madam VI chair know I want to keep half a second longer but I'm calling as fresh as I would this morning um you all chose to move the curriculum of the agenda is that correct yes and I have what um a attorney gave me what about what the final decision on the Middle School's task for that was Mr step on sorry you mentioned something

414too did you did you guys talk about changing the agenda for Saturday yeah I'm getting to that I'm so sorry that's okay that's okay after Miss Dian was that everything Miss Dian yes okay thank you all right before we go got a couple things to talk about first of all next work session February 20th at 3:30 okay so if everybody put that on their calendars and then the um Retreat I'm putting that in quotes our annual meeting our annual meeting that we had scheduled for this Saturday I sent an email to yall yesterday about making a a shift to do the department head reports in the morning on this Saturday and because of Mr King our chair's health issues ises not being able to attend that we look at the 1st or the eth which

415are both Saturdays sticking with the same Saturday or we could do it a weekday we don't need to do it a weekday um but uh the first or the eighth to go ahead and do the second portion of our treat which was board operations and and um board operations and uh Team Building yes team building strategic planning thank you I have it in front of me so do we have a preference on the Saturday date first is my birthday so we have a little perk the first or the better so it' be half days which we we talked about that maybe being a possibility when we were in Nashville maybe two days and half days instead of one long one and that way the chair which is very important can be involved in that that

416piece that board piece he can get the information from the department heads that he needs from missing that okay all right so I'm either day you're either day you're either day you're either day was the first better for you actually the first or the I think I'm actually day for you first of February you're talk [Music] yes or half a day half a day yeah that'd be fun yeah I that face it it's 61 way half dozen other I've got stuff for both days so it it doesn't matter whichever is agreeable with just be half well I'll work on the eight I'll be at the tsba orientation the 31st till they till get done and then Saturday yeah and then I'll be coming back Friday night my um well it all be fresh on your

417mind for board operations that's true yeah ready to gois um I can make either one work but I prefer the first okay all right so and the firster but it's a little closer in time okay I can make either one but which one are we going to do first first can we be sure get that out and updated and published on the website like tomorrow that way we've got she's staying here well we don't we don't have the work session out there yet right I have not been here whenever try to be diplomatic here with every I'm I have not been given when you get something from me that's published it's when I have received the information and had the time to put it out there I know from the outside world it's all coming

418from me it looks like I'm that's just when I'm doing it I think you all hopefully understand that but I'm we're in limbo with some of this stuff and I did have to ask today do I have an agenda I've been working on it all day between all the other craziness so when I get it in my hand with the directive you may publish this that's when it's out immediately when I have time so just know I'm waiting we had to make we're waiting also because we need to determine how we were shifting this um but there's been some delays because of Mr King's Health he has been working best he can with Mr Stefon so um it'll you're going to get the one for Saturday out tomorrow right you said so that'll be out

419tomorrow for this Saturday and then the following the first we deci okay all right what time what time are we talking 8 n we have nine for this next Saturday coming up we did have nine we did 9 it be 9 to about 12:30ish I don't like I mean that's what I'm getting I just want to make sure that whatever we're doing is visible with the right date and the right time because we had an issue with the last meeting that wasn't at the right date 5 hours we didn't have it we didn't have it it wasn't available today actually yeah that's fine you've got the board calendar all so I have two meetings on Saturday Okay so 9:00 this Saturday the first half and then till 12:30 so we will not be doing lunch

420in lunch is on our own afterwards when we get done and then the first will be reconvening for the second half of it when Mr King can join 9:00 at 9:00 we'll do the same thing 9 to 12:30 9 to 12:30 okay to 4:30 12:30 okay 12:30 we're go home need [Music] dinner thank you for no no no no you're fine this late

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.