001announcements this afternoon uh starting with district one good evening everyone uh my name is Robert Taylor representing district one and I just wanted to give a shout out to the students at Warner Arts Magnet School who were just inducted into the National Beta Club uh last week and so I just wanted to congratulate those students and uh thank them for being the best students they can possibly be the other announcement I have is uh to acknowledge the Whites Creek High School alumni association uh they have a new president uh and I just wanted to uh thank them for their service to White Creek High School and encourage them to continue on that is all thank you District Two thank you sir much this past week we had at Overton High School the cluster evening where
002all the schools from District H's cluster showed up and watch the basketball game girls and boys and uh learned about Overton took tours it was a really great experience um and I wanted to thank Overton publicly for hosting it it's the second year of hosting a cluster night for the district outside of that there's several different events that are happening at Overton and I will let our student board member if they choose to cover those additionally outside of that a lot of of our elementary schools are having teap meetings coming up for parents and so I encourage you to read your newsletters from your principles and of course your ptto to learn about any other things that are happening as we're starting to wind down on the school year thanks thank you District three District
003Five I don't have any announcements thank you District Six thank you Vice chair uh just a couple of quick announcements um we are excited to announce the return of the her prom closet dress giveaway it's coming back to Nashville on March 15 2025 and it will be held at the Mount Zion Baptist Church on Old Hickory Boulevard that's a 7594 old H Boulevard this is a free event but registration is required to attend and this is open to high school juniors and seniors that are looking for Prime dresses you're encouraged to register uh by texting HPC 615 to 33777 and as a reminder this is a prom dress giveaway uh for uh Juniors and seniors who are looking to uh get some really beautiful dresses I will be on site to volunteer to help uh
004these these young people get their dresses it's a really uh great opportunity for individuals to get a free prom dress with prom season coming up so again that's on March 15th at the mount Z Baptist Church on Old Hickory Boulevard also I want to give a a shout out to the Franklin Special School District Board of Education for welcoming me to their meeting last night I was uh excited to be there and got to witness the uh tenear vote for 12 teachers that are part of the uh Franklin Special School District so I appreciate them inviting me there and just wanted to share a quick updates uh I was uh as the legislative liaison for metro schools I was had the privilege of attending the tsba legislative and legal Institute conference that wrapped up today
005and we discussed among other things um what um the legal side of Education Tech and how AI policies are impacting learning in school districts um how SRO and administration work together to keep schools safe we talked about legislative updates and uh we got an overview of the special uh legislative session that wrapped up earlier and um we talked specifically about social media and how it impacts board members and school districts and First Amendment challenges related to the use of social media there are a few things that we need need to uh think through as a board of education as far as some policies Excuse Me Miss ma can we uh go deeper into that during board reports leaon yes we will but those are just some of the updates but just as a reminder if
006you're interested in getting a free dress for prom that event is happening March 15th district 7 thank you there's no there's no announcements distri District 8 District nine yes um just an announcement that James Lawson auditions for dance Ensemble are February 24th or February 28th and their theater audition signups will go live on February 21st and they will actually take place on February 28th so if you are interested in the dance Ensemble or the theater program now is your time to jump into that um tonight is a senior night for Lawson's basketball team and their volleyball team tip ball for basketball is at 7:30 um and volleyball starts at 6 and then also just a shout out to 14 talented mnps High School Visual Arts students including students from James Lawson High School who were
007selected for the Frist Art Museum's 10th banial young Tennessee artist ex exhibitions the exhibition is open through March 16th at the Prest and it has two-dimensional works of art by students enrolled in AP or advanced placement art and international baloria studio art programs so if you're by the fris I suggest you come out and see some of the great work our art students are doing throughout mmps thank you Junior board member good evening everyone um today was the closing day for the cast of the insanity of Mary Gerard at John Overton High School so congratulations to them um last Friday was cluster night and Saturday we had our coming home Dance theme Cupids Bowl um and at cluster night we beat the mavic Raiders 77 to 23 so um this Monday we have no days
008for no school for President's Day um and we also have our black history one celebration this week at Overton and happy Black History Month to everyone senior board member good evening everyone I also wanted to say happy Black History Month um I wanted to congratulate my debate coach Miss Clark for being awarded Tennessee being awarded Tennessee's 2024 to 2025 outstanding speech and debate educator um I also wanted to say that debate or city championships for debate is March 1st at NBA um and I created an Instagram for my tutoring program it's @ coherent dot toring so if you wanted to check it out feel free so thank you back to District 8 sorry I heard congratulate and I remembered that I I wanted to congratulate the teacher of the year for mmps I'm sure we'll
009do a separate congratulations as well but um her name is Natalie Williams and she is at Percy Priest Elementary in second grade um so really proud of her and also um Dr Andy Davis um who won a principal of the Year award thanks congratulations to those two wonderful people among all of the other wonderful people in District 8 and all cross mmps and then I'm District for um I just want to thank uh mnps uh their leaders Dr battle um her team uh we spent the day today with uh leadership Donaldson Hermitage um also known as Elevate which is a group of Business Leaders in The Donaldson Hermitage and Old Hickory area they were able to visit elementary middle and our high school in the area and learn learn about and see firsthand what we
010do with inside inside mnps um so I want to thank the principes at Hickman Elementary Donaldson middle and mcgavic high school for being gracious host as long as well as Dr battle and her team uh for also taking the time out um to uh meet with the Business Leaders uh and talk with them more about mnps um I also want to thank Christian bugs the CEO of pencil for also participating in that event thank you so much um if there are no other announcements we we will adjourn announcements so any see youtiful but um you know what I mean take all sh the engineers we'll call this meeting to order uh we have a quorum with nine members present and two student board members uh we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance and we're
011going to have Chief Perry yes could because your other coworker teammates stood up for [Laughter] you I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the repblic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right I will entertain a motion to approve the agenda so moved there is a motion uh by Vice chair nbal Kenny um is there a second second is there a discussion could we pull item eight from consent please yes I was gonna ask the same thing okay any other discussion um all right can we have a motion to approve the agenda with the withdraw of um action 1 B2 uh8 oh whoops excuse me 1 B8 to a motion to approve the agenda with um removing 1 B8
012system Integrations um from the consent agenda so moved all right second there's a motion a second um motion by Vice chair mckenny second by Maize uh board member ma um all in favor say I I any oppose all right we approve of the agenda now I'll hand over to Dr battles for awards and recognitions all right thank you so much CH play and good evening board members um tonight we have several outstanding teachers and award-winning school and one Hall of Fame Alum to celebrate so I'm going to jump right in so it's not easy to win the very highest teaching honor in your field but tonight we have the privilege of recognizing a teacher who has done it Natalie Boyd who has taught math at human fog academic Magnet High School for 11 years received
013word from the National Science Foundation on January 13th that the White House has selected her to receive the presidential award for excellence in Mathematics and Science teaching let's give it up for now this is the highest honor given by the US government specifically for teaching K12 science technology engineering mathematics Andor computer science and Natalie will receive $10,000 for her outstanding work Natalie has taught in mmps for 16 years overall and is known for both challenging and supporting her students as they take on higher forms of mathematical thinking and problem solving and AP statistics honors precalculus and other classes she is also part of Hume fog's instructional leadership team and a co-sponsor of the black student union Natalie congratulations and lots of congratulations um but specifically on this amazing recognition um of your teaching and thank
014you for everything you do for your students um we are so happy to have you here this evening and uh we would like to celebrate you one more time and get a quick picture with you and the little one ones congratulations so we'd like to get a picture with you Natalie and your family and anybody's here who is celebrating with you we'd love for them to join you up front and board members are you Spiderman he was shooting the webs she does not want all that's all right congratulations again um Natalie um and thank you for all the great work you can continue to lead at Hume fog he's [Laughter] independent all right so next up um we' like to recognize um John Henderson one of the greatest football players in mmps history and also
015one of the greatest in college football history we know this is true because John was recently announced as a member of the 2025 class of the College Football Hall of Fame let's give it up for John so many of you know all about John but he was a Powerhouse as a defensive tackle for the University of Tennessee BS he won the Outland trophy as the nation's top interior defensive lineman in 2000 and was a first team All-American in both 2000 and 2001 he went on to play 10 seasons in the NFL with the Jacksonville Jaguars and the Oakland Raiders earning two Pro Bowl selections but we know where he got his start and that was right here in Nashville at Pearl cone high school so John helped lead the Firebirds to the State title in
016both 1996 and 1997 under Coach Maurice Fitzgerald who is joining us he was named Mr football lineman of the year in 1997 and Tennessee Gatorade player of the year for the 1997 98 School Year John and the rest of the 2025 class will be inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame on December 9th in Las Vegas we'd like to send a loud congratulations to John on this wonderful honor um and I know that coach fitgerald and maybe some family friends are here um to represent John um in his absence today so I ask y'all to come on up uh let us celebrate um him um with you all on his behalf and we'd like to get a picture so congratulations to John Henderson [Music] all right so congratulations again to John Henderson on all
017the success he's had on and off the field so next we have principal trell Lane and her team at Isaiah T crestwell Middle School of the Arts which has been named a 2025 School of Excellence by magnet schools of America let's give it up for Dr Lane and itun presswell presswell is a proud diverse School of the school that offers Fine Arts Conservatory classes and theater Visual Arts chorus and piano band and music appreciation dance and strings but it's not just about the Arts crestwell is known for its drone Club a broadcasting club and a strong Athletics program this recognition by magnet schools of America is a great honor from a National Organization that understands Magnus schools extremely well and that will be hosting U that will be hosting when it hosts its National Conference
018here in April it's because of schools like it crestwell that's brought this National Conference to Nashville one of the judges commented Isaiah T crestwell middle school has such a rich inclusive and enriching magnet program the intentionality of your program is evident throughout the application your staff students and families should be very proud of the lifelong impact you're having on the scholars attending your program so at this time I'd like for Dr trell Lane and team to come on up allow us to express congratulations to you all and thank you for all you do for your young people congratulations sorry we got a few of these today all right so again congratulations to it chriswell Dr Lane and team uh we greatly appreciate all you all do to prioritize your students um we would also like
019to extend congratulations um to our next group of leaders we're going to recognize our next two groups of honores have won an award that not many music teachers win I'm proud to say that team Ms won two of the 23 music for all advocacy in action awards that were announced recently for the entire nation to recognize effective music education programs and initiatives first up is MCM ban have you heard of MCM ban I hope you if you've not you've heard of them now so this is a project of four Middle School band directors in the mavic cluster I'm sorry the the goal of MCM ban is to show students they can sit together with kids from other schools and make music build community and have a good time doing it while at the rehearsals the
020kids get to know each other and begin to form friendships that will continue to grow as they go into High School the band grew out of a conversation in 2023 among mavic cluster Middle School band directors who wanted their students to have more opportunities to perform last year they performed a piece that was written just for the group by Dupont Tyler band director Scott Miller and this year at their band clinic and concert on May 2nd they'll perform a piece by dala Spencer a college student majoring in music composition at Montclair State University who is an alumnist of our very own Martin Luther King Jr academic high school so let's give it up for our four Middle School band directors who started MC midle band they are Scott Miller from dupon Tyler you don't get
021to stand back there you have to come to the front we want to see you and celebrate you Amy SEL from Two [Music] Rivers Casey Sanders from dupon [Music] Hatley and although she's sick and unable to be here tonight I want to recognize Laura Shepard from middle school so as we get ready for our picture um teachers band directors thank you for your initiative and for going the extra mile for your students um we again we want to celebrate you we want to support you in every way we know Music Matters to our young people um so again thank you and keep us posted on all your events and performances that are coming up congratulations thank you for all right congratulations again so proud of the work happening in our middle schools um and so
022let's turn our attention to our other music for all advocacy and action Award winner which is Bryson finny and the mmps Visual and Performing Arts team for their work on the we are Nashville Festival an annual event that works to build community Through music Bryson a Music musician who works in mmps learning technology department first had this particular dream in 2017 and since then we are Nashville has been held annually during music in our schools month which takes place every March Bryson and his colleagues even pulled together a beautiful video featuring mmps students music teachers and some of Nashville's best classical musicians when the pandemic made it impossible to have the festival in person in 2020 and the video won a mid South Emmy Award and now Bryson and the rest of the team behind
023our every student known song are nominated for two more Midsouth emys that we'll learn real about this weekend um the we are Nashville Festival brings together students from across the city for a day of workshops rehearsals and a big joyful performance this year's Festival is set for March 24th at skimmerhorn Symphony Center and we know it is going to be a great day of Music Learning and inspiration for hundreds of our young people so please help me congratulate um Bryce and Finny and the Visual and Performing Arts team I'm on a job well done and thank you for representing Nashville Public Schools so well come on up you okay yeah than you all right so congratulations again Bryson and to the entire vapa team um so now we've got one more war winner to talk
024about tonight that we've decided to make a surprise and it is one of of our very own up and that is Christine TR our senior student board member was recently named one of eight finalists from across the country for the debater of the Year award from the national So Christine was um again recently named one of the eight finalists from across the country for the debater of the year award from the National Association for urban debate league so you didn't think I knew this did you Christine who is a senior at James Lawson High School join students from Chicago Houston New York City Silicon Valley to Tulsa and Washington DC and competing for their Ward which will be announced in just a few weeks so Christine we are proud of you and can't wait to
025see where you go after you graduate in May um we know there's so much more to come so congratulations to you that will conclude um our Awards and recognitions chair and at this time I'll turn it back over to you all right thank you for those words and recognition um it's good to have some Joy um now we'll move on to director's report um where we'll have Dr battle report on an upcoming topic all right so um this evening we have two um separate reports we'll go through the first one we'll take um Q&A and then we'll move into the second um report um this evening um so tonight I'm pleased to share first an overview of the education recovery scorecard and what it tells us about the progress our students have made in recovering
026from the academic disruptions of the pandemic this report developed through a collaboration between the center for Education policy research at Harvard and the Educational Opportunity project at Stanford provides a district level comparison of learning loss and and Recovery across the country as you will see our students and Educators have demonstrated remarkable resilience and national public schools has emerged as a national leader in academic recovery the data shows that our students gains in math and reading Place us among the top of forming large urban districts in the nation evidence that our focused investments in highquality instruction targeted supports and strategic initiatives are making a real impact while this progress is encouraging we know there's still work to be done the report also reinforces the importance of continuing our commitment to Student Success Through evidence-based Strate strategy
027strong instructional leadership and meaningful engagement with families and the community um so at this time I'm going to invite up um our very own Dr Paul tangis um who continues to work closely with our research assessment and evaluation team he and um director Tina Stinson have been working hard because this report came out at midnight last night um and the Embargo was lifted today so Dr changus I will turn it over to you to walk us through the education Rec recovery scorecard and as a reminder for board members um this is an updated report from the one we received last spring Dr changus thank you Dr battle um and given that this uh did come out around midnight I'm going to be doing a just an overview of the uh the main results but uh
028it's good to be back in front of the board to have good news to share it's good to have you back as uh Dr battle said this is a collaborative effort between Harvard and Stanford and uh they have been looking at the progress that districts have made since uh prior to the pandemic in 2019 uh and what has occurred uh since then uh they use 2022 data as their Baseline for looking at progress after the pandemic uh in part because the 2120 the 21 data across the country was somewhat uh limited from state to state uh they are comparing the results in this latest study from 43 States and over 8700 school districts uh in order to do those comparisons we need a common scale because uh States give their own uh assessments different assessments
029different scales uh and we'll talk about that in more detail in terms of how that common scale is developed uh as I said this goes back as far as 2019 it looks at the loss that occurred uh over the next three years uh and then what's happened since then and uh as we'll see in the report the uh the recovery that's occurred since those times and and both reading and math atics varies quite a bit from state to state I we'll also talk briefly about some of the patterns that we've seen with regard to economic disadvantage uh the report goes into much more detail also looks at uh uh racial and economic status but um we are going to be focusing on grades 3 through eight reading and Mathematics before I go into uh the
030actual report uh let me just do a brief overview of the recently released nape data as I said in order to make comparisons we need a common scale and the npe national assessment of educational progress is the only National assessment that's given uh the results from the nape are typically reported at the state level not at the district level uh a a representative sample of of districts of students across the state is used uh in each state to uh to to get those results it's administered in grades 48 and 12 uh every two years in Reading mathematics and science uh the science results have not been released yet uh nor have the 12th grade data but we do have National and state data in this graph uh from the 2024 assessment and these charts are
031comparing the progress that's been made over the last two years as you can see in here uh looking at on the left side at mathematics at grades four and8 uh the only progress that was made nationally in the last two years was in fourth grade mathematics uh and this is on the nape scale they used their own scale scores and and there was a TW Point increase over the last two years in mathematics uh as you can see Tennessee made a slightly greater uh Improvement a three-point Improvement in fourth grade math uh at 8th grade the national results were flat uh no significant change from 20 22 whereas Tennessee made significant progress a four-point gain uh the reading results are not as positive uh nationally we saw a two-point decline uh over the last two
032years at both fourth grade and eighth grade in Reading uh and in Tennessee results were flat uh we talk about uh reading here but just to be clear uh Tennessee like a lot of states is is assessing reading language arts more than just reading and so is the nape because the nape does measure reading comprehension using both literary and informative text uh but again the uh the results uh nationally were flat Tennessee held its own in reading so let's I'm I'm G to go into uh how the scales set without going into a lot of technical detail uh but again the nape scale is the one scale that's common across uh across the country so we have different standards in each state both for Prof proficiency levels different scale scores whereas the nape has consistent
033scale scores uh they use the proficiency data from each state and basically equate it back to what's happening uh on the nape assessment using what they in the third bullet you'll see proficiency thresholds that's basically Ally the cut score that defines the nape scale the nape has three proficiency levels basic proficient and advanced and they look at at how uh each state Compares on the nape and then what their state assessment looks like uh on their state results versus the nape results to do that equating and basically approximate not only where each state is but where each district is uh that that have enough data to be included in the sample uh and the last bullet uh they I'll just I've been in front of the board a number of times over the years I
034generally don't talk about data in terms of grade levels uh because grade levels can be defined operationally in different ways their definition is to look at the national average or 50th percentile in 2019 as being the average for that grade level in reading or in mathematics and their data is expressed in terms of grade level Improvement so we will that definition uh here so how did Tennessee do overall before we get into the district data uh Tennessee results uh and the first two bullets apply to what happened uh basically during the pandemic while the last two bullets are the recovery that's occurred since then and Tennessee results are very close to the national average we lost about a half grade level from 2019 19 to 2022 in mathematics and about a third of a grade
035level uh in Reading language arts in mathematics since that time since 2022 uh Tennessee's improved by a little over a third of a grade level 20 36% uh reading scores have not bounced back quite as much 14% of a grade level I'll also note uh is is talked about quite a bit in the study that the results show that there was a significant impact due to economic disadvantage uh students who were disadvantaged within districts the gaps widened and districts that had higher percentages of economically disadvantaged students were more greatly impacted by the pandemic and we saw that with our own data so Dr battle referred to the good news and this is first before we get into The National Data these are the districts that are part of the report for the progress that's been
036made since 2022 these are the math results and uh with different bullets representing the districts the uh vertical scale uh is again the the change that's occurred over the last two years in grade levels the horizontal axis is the percent of students uh economic disadvantage or or the free reduced price lunch that they use uh the the bluish line uh that's in here is a what we call a regression line it's basically telling us that uh despite uh economic disadvantage the progress that's been made has been pretty flat and actually slightly better for uh districts with higher disadvantage uh you can see in the upper right corner uh big bubble the bubble size is based on size of District Nashville Public Schools Nashville is up near the top Statewide over this period of time if
037we turn to the uh data for reading here we see that the regression line is actually showing that as economic disadvantage increases there tends to be lower gain on average among Tennessee districts uh we however uh still rank among the highest districts in terms of our reading gains over the last two years in summary we significantly outpaced the growth of the state we showed 67% of a grade level increase in mathematics over the last two years uh as a reminder in an earlier slide we saw that Tennessee was at 36% in comparison our reading scores went up 24% about a quarter of a grade level uh the state was up 14% during that time and now we'll talk about the national context after looking at State results and here we have uh the top 10
038performing districts out of the 100 largest urban districts in the US for mathematics over the last two years uh you can see that we ranked fourth out of 100 large urban districts across the country uh with growth that was a little over 2/3 of a grade level 69 uh at the bottom of this graph we see uh the national average which is is shown by a dashed line in Blue uh nationally the increase was only about a tenth of a grade level 0.11 Tennessee during that time 36 about a third of a grade level so again we're outpacing not only Tennessee but nation in terms of the growth that's occurred that's mathematics and if we turn to our reading language arts uh these are the top 10 of the 100 largest urban districts uh we
039rank ninth in Reading recovery uh about a quarter of a grade level increase uh you can see the national average actually declined over the last two years in terms of progress uh they lost about about 20% 19% of a grade level Tennessee had slight Improvement at 133% we were at 24% Improvement while this study used 2021 as its Baseline uh I'm sorry 2022 as its Baseline uh again because data was limited from State Assessments in 2021 uh as a reminder the last time I was in front of the board two and a half years ago slightly after my retirement uh uh my semi-retirement uh I had good news to share as we looked at our 2022 data relative to the prior Year all that's to say that our bounceback our recovery started prior to 2022
040we actually saw an over an 8% increase that year in our Proficiency in mathematics and over 7% in reading so as good as our data look since 2022 uh I think it would look even better if we had uh a 21 Baseline uh in 2022 we also saw that our growth both for 3 through eight reading uh language arts and Mathematics uh was above the state average and uh as you all are well aware uh We've continued to make value added progress each of those years that that surpass the state and as we saw earlier the state is doing a little better than the national average so again good news to share uh is before I turn this over the other comment I will make uh is that we uh and this is just a
041summary we're the we're one of five larger urban districts to be in the top 10 uh among the 100 largest districts in the country for both mathematics and reading language arts and again this report came out late last night we'll be digging in into it over time but one of the key findings again was that uh there is an impact due to economic disadvantage that uh remains persistent and the data shows that the achievement gaps have actually widened over time and that the highest income districts have about a four times more likely chance of of having recovered by this point than districts in the lowest income levels uh the federal relief dollars uh is studied in in this report show that it did mitigate some of that loss it's it's had a real impact uh
042but as we know uh going forward uh and we've made strong progress based on our use of eser and Bridge funds uh and our initiative alignment uh but we're still below the national and state averages in terms of achievement we're still bouncing back there's still work to be done but we need to continue that work and to discuss how we've accomplished that and how we're going to move forward I'm going to turn it over to Dr battle right thank you so much um Dr changus it's just always good to have um so much expertise and knowledge um around um our data and around research how we assess our students and how we evaluate ourselves up against um the information we do have so one of the most um frequent questions last year after the first
043um um uh kind kind of latest um update around the education recovery card came out um and and since this news um has been shared with us um one of the first questions was tell us more about what's happening um in and across um the district and so um as you all know years back we've been really um digging into research-based practices and really evaluating um what's helping us accelerate outcomes um for our students and so it's probably no surprise to you um that I'm going to go first to um our grounding ourselves and our core tenants I'm being really clear around our Focus outcomes what we expect to see um in progress um both in growth and achievement for our students um year after year and then our signature initiatives just reorienting ourselves um
044to how we come alongside our schools um to ensure that they have the supports that they need in order to do the great work that they lead every day um for all of our students um which leads us to our GPA experiences right we know that they are described as our guarantee personalized and applied experiences for all of our students as they move through our seamless pathway um we kicked off our metro schools reimagine work um back in 2020 as you remember started out with our fifth grade um transition but has really been grounded in our uniform strategies and our seamless cluster Pathways across um our district being really intentional about the expectations and um what we want to realize in our tiered experiences so that we can realize our Mantra our goal of every
045student being known and every graduate being a ready graduate um we've talked a lot about particularly third grade lit where there's been a hyperfocus on um third grade literacy and that not being something you can just measure and capture um in third grade really going back to birth to three which is a part of our grow together initiative and then is capped off by our internationally um known academies of Nashville um structure at our high schools as well as our University of mmps partnership so by way of that making sure that we have that seamless pathway into College and Career and then as we thought about um every ensuring every student is known some of those key levers this is not um a complete list but just some of the key levers that um we
046continue to focus in on and triple down on across the district the first is not um um letting up on high quality tier one instruction so when this board adopts budget priorities and we invest we invest in high quality instructional materials um so that our teachers can do what they do best right really educate and support um our students and then providing the necessary professional learning learning um to make sure that they have what they need and that um we're we're day one ready um for that instruction the other is principal leadership and and quite frankly this should really just say leadership because we've invested highly um in leaders across our our entire organization um to equip and Empower all leaders at every levels and so yes our principles are critical to that because our
047principles are the ones who recruit and and support all of our Educators within their respective um School communities so when you hear words like the PS um leadership framework when you hear words like the leadership Playbook it's all about really setting the expectations for leadership regardless of the seat that anyone sits in across our organization I wraparound Services um and support um very heavy in our Bridge um funding making sure that we can continue those key strategies that it were proven successful during the pandemic beyond the pandemic as well so when you think about our advocacy centers when you think about counseling mental health supports nurses in our schools our Navigators all of those are key strategies as a part of our wraparound supports our learning acceleration um opportunities uh primarily our Scholars portfolio um
048has been really critical for us as we've continued to double down and ensure that again that every student is known and that every student is making progress um as you all know we've really leveraged our partnership with Vanderbilt University our peer partnership to evaluate um all of the components around our Scholars portfolio so that we can continue to progress monitor um our students progress over the years given their reading and their math goals and then lastly our community engagement at Family University we know that family engagement matters and so we've been hard at work in creating authentic um and explicit opportunities for parents to partner um with their teachers with their principles counselors um Academy coaches so on and so forth um so that they're truly on a guaranteed path towards um success and so
049as we think about some of those High leverage high impact strategies that's just a few um but but ones that really um rise to the top when we're evaluating and researching um what's having um really um good and positive movement for our students the best strategy is to have quality leaders in our class rooms and in our schools that's something we cannot um ever skip over so it's important as we think about strategy moving forward we continue to support our Educators all across um the district so um just like last year um what came out of this report are recommendations from the researchers of course SE is made up of researchers from Harvard and Stanford University um four items here States and districts should double down on academic catch-up efforts previously funded by federal um
050relief so when you think about high doses tutoring when you think about our Scholars portfolio um those are those um catchup efforts that help um really complement what's happening in tier one instruction our Mayors employeers and other community leaders should join schools in tackling student absenteeism what you did not get chance to see tonight is there's also a complimentary graph around student um reducing chronic absenteeism of which um National Public Schools U ranks really high um in the progress we've made in reducing chronic um absenteeism you might recall um two years ago as we were um looking at our state designations we talked specifically about what was what it was going to take for us to get to that highest category right now we sit in the advancing category and it was chronic aism and
051so um we rallied um together and across the district and with um the community um that we needed help in in ensuring that our students um were um in school um and that we can then be prepared to meet them where they were um teachers must inform parents when their child is not at grade level um so when you think about our Scholars portfolio and what's happening in prompts and Scholars again high dosage tutoring the communications that are there uh but one thing that we've really committed to is our personalized student dashboard so that our families have 247 access um to the personalized student dashboard and are empowered and equipped with that data and that information and the progress that their respective child or children are making and then the last one is we must
052learn what's working and what's not in the recent reform reforms this is why our partnership our signature initiative um again with Vanderbilt University and our peer partnership and the symposiums we we host um are so important so that we can learn in real time with our rapid response research things that we can shift immediately and then also learn about the things that we need to shift um as we're moving forward but here's the bottom line um these are all forign action in in Nashville Public Schools and what I want to highlight here is we you think about the districts who shown up in the top 10 recovering districts um across the country we are the only School District that's been there multiple years in a row and so I think that's a testament to our
053prioritization our Focus um around what's translating into positive outcomes for educators and for our students um and is also realizing your priorities um for this year as as we move forward so Kudos and thank you um for that focus and that prioritization that you've already um demonstrated so this um slide is really not even needed um how the board can support we tend to in um with um a conversation around this is continue to spread the good news about our district right lots of great things are happening we know what happens sometimes the the positive doesn't seep out the way that it should but it's important for the good news to be told about what our students are accomplishing to continue advocate for measurement systems that show how we perform nationally um before this report
054we had a pretty good idea of where we were situated within the state of Tennessee now we've got some measure around how we're actually performing and recovering since the pandemic um across the country and then lastly to continue to advocate for continuity funding for our priorities um we've been extremely proud of the Investments That been made into our our district we've already moved some of those key strategies into our operational budget but when eser Sunset remember they were non-recurring fund so it's important if those key strategies are yielding results that we get them into our operating budget so again thank you and kudos to the school board mayor council um for continuing to prioritize the things that are um translating um into that return on investment uh on behalf of our students and then I'll
055close by just saying thank you to team mmps um once again um you continue to just Le away our North Star is to become the the large uh Premier District in Tennessee and Beyond and I think this data the Nate data as well as the education recovery scorecard data really demonstrates um the quality of Educators we have the talents we have in our students the family engagement and partnership that exists um and of course the leadership um from the board and the entire District so thank you again to team mmps I will pause um board chair and see if there are any questions that we can respond to thank you does anyone have any questions or comments all right uh board member Chan I mean Tren sorry um I just wanted to ask more specifically
056on the nape test itself is it something that like all students take every year because personally I don't remember taking tests like that or is it like scores from the T and ready or like map testing Can you more specific about that I'll ask Dr tangis um to respond um we actually receive um a list of schools that participate I think we had 28 schools had 28 schools in in the 24 2024 sample uh it's every two years it's administered in grades 4 8 and 12 in reading math and science uh it's only a sample from each state uh we we get that they use the demographics of students across the state to get a sample that they feel is representative of state level data uh these students take the same assessment across the country
057at each grade level and subject uh so it is the one assessments that's common across the country uh students get no feed no feedback from this either do schools or districts that participate it's only to to get the state level data the one exception is there are some some larger districts that participate uh in a in a larger sampling uh that that gets District level data with all of the testing that goes on already in Tennessee 10 ready scores are separate from the npe assessment uh I don't think anyone's demanding more testing that I'm aware of thank you School member member when um I just have one question regarding um the applied portion um about GPA experiences so a concern specifically at Overton um and at Zone schools has been towards the end of Sr
058funding and school spiraling money about where programs like Gear Up are going to go if students are going to be able to have that experience to tour colleges and what the board is doing and what Metro is doing as a whole to make sure that experience is still there for students yes so that Gear Up historically has been funded um under a grant U program so it is subject um to um non-recurring um in Investments and so over the years we've been able to maintain a pretty high level um every year there is an assessment around if grants are going to continue but this is why um this board has also prior prioritized programs like Avid right so Avid it stands for advancement via individual determination um it is um a structure um if will
059it's not a program but it's a structure that promotes um very similar um research-based practices like gear up so College visits right as an example work around your resume your transcript building um organization writing skills things of that nature and so we've um historically tried to really address that twofold not just being Reliant upon grant opportunities which will continue to advocate for because we know there's some benefits and we've seen positive outcomes but also sustainable programming like avot um this is one of the re reasons we moved away from um isolated avot programs in class in in schools and we've moved to districtwide so Avid is a district district-wide strategy to kind of um uh guarantee some of these experiences as we begin to scale up and roll it out across every school you're welcome
060uh member of heral block um I just want to I like usually comment on things like this so I feel like I kind of have to but also like it's just so exciting to be in a position where sort of as Dr battle said to see that we can see the growth in Tennessee as compared to Tennessee districts but also to know the level at which we are competing and out competing Tennessee districts and also districts nationally is not a place that mnps has been in historically um and this is not just now with the Baseline if I'm right about this Dr changus please signal if I'm wrong but with the Baseline also being 2022 that doesn't mean this is just sort of pandemic recovery this is what the last two school years have meant
061um and the kind of Investments that we've made and the focus that Dr battle and her team have had and when we look at all of the things that she just outlined I think we should expect to continue to see growth like this over time now it's hard to threp and four ped and all the things that you've said before and we certainly have had a number of challenges but um but we've got the right systems in place um for you know uh to continue to see that kind of improvement and and it is very validating to see that not just on state assessments but on the combination of state and National assessments and among districts in Tennessee and districts nationally so just to restate it it's just really cool so congratulations uh Vice chair
062Nal mckenny and to piggy back off of board member block um it is it is really exciting to see us moving the needle for kids across our district in a way that we haven't traditionally been able to do and so to you know we are at a point now where we have done a three repeat year over year over year um with our schools with within this District that is historical within itself um and to see us move the needle where we are now outpacing the state in areas um is is pretty historic for us and compared to how we are doing on a national scale says a lot about Dr battle her team teachers principles the system and and and the way in which it is moving the needle to really support kids um
063and and I just want to rehas ize this because the fact that you are looking at more than is it more than 79,000 7,900 districts did I get it right over 8,000 districts I I I got that mixed up backwards 87 something yeah um looking at more than 8,000 districts across the country and mnps is ranking in the top 10 in both math math and reading is phenomenal and to be able to do it twice in a row y'all this is game changer um we are really doing what it takes and it doesn't mean that we stop here we know where we are we know that work has to continue to happen but we are seeing that the systems that are being put in place are moving the needle and we are getting the return
064on the investment that we are asking for and that we are uh that and and and that our kids deserve and so thank you Dr battle thank you to your team to mnps and everyone who makes this difference and if you don't mind Cher If there are no other comments again I I must just send a loud thank you again to the entire team because on the brightest of days on the hardest of days our Educators show up um they show up for our children um they pour in Long beyond the hours that they are required to pour in I mean they're meeting students with so many different hats um every day and so um I stand shoulder Tosh shoulder with all of our Educators across this District it does not matter principal teacher support
065staff everyone is instrumental our drivers our transportation department nutrition services we cannot do this without everyone really leading um and and just optimizing their potential and their talents um across the district so um forgive me for having the mic again but just wanted to Echo um that and just how fortunate I am to work alongside such a great team uh board member uh Elrod thank you um first it's good to see you again Dr chenis I um I appreciate you getting up at midnight to read this information I think last year I got the text that it was out like around 2:30 so maybe that gave you some extra two and a half hours to do the work get some sleep tonight um I cannot remember and if don't have this number off the top
066of your head that's okay I can get it later from the team but can we know or do we know off the top of our heads what our average was last year so I can compare this year to last year since we are doing this for two years in a row that's okay probably have to get back to you I believe I have it so but you're talking about the average in terms of the Reading MA the grade levels sir I will have to get that back to you apprciate I mean we were we again ranked quite highly uh last year as you know but we're at a very comparable place and just in case that wasn't heard we were third and sixth last year um and then I know that you mentioned against treny
067that that there is some positive growth there and I know we've done an incredible amount of work with not only a pilot program in some of our most comprehensive high schools but then throughout all of our schools to try to work on our treny numberers and you said there was a graph is that found within the nape report or is that something we need to get from yall yes you um have them um um in the website the u National Education recovery scorecard um you can just um go to Tennessee click on um Davidson um Metro Nashville um school system and all the charts are there so they're public um documents and I'll make it easy I'll make sure you have them all by before the end of the week okay you can be in
068the Friday perfect thank you um again I echo my colleagues excitement um we were very excited last year being third and sixth um and being one of only two districts that had that growth in both um reading and math so this is incredible information I want to say that it's because of not only all of our staff like Dr battle mentioned but it's a commitment to mmps not just from our in our classrooms but also within the support Hub but also from the city and providing us with that additional funding when we've needed it because we are the least funded District in the entire state of Tennessee and so we really really require a lot of that funding body to be on the Metro Council and so we were really appreciative of that so that
069we can best utilize those funds within our teachers so that we can do this good work so we appreciate it we are proud to be good stewards of those dollars and that we have this return on investment that we can show to you so thank you so much yeah and I'll just like to close out of um this is what our accountability looks like I know people ask what are we doing um for accountability and having outside validators showing our growth and showing the success that we have and has been sustained year-over-year I think it's a really important highlight to do that we are achieving um growth and we're continue to achieve that growth and it's continue to build year-over-year um that we'll get to higher rates of proficient proficiency and increase the rate of
070proficiency um over time so um I know as we say we like to nerd out on data this is the perfect example when I say like to nerd Outland data to prove that we are doing the work and that we're holding each other accountable and like Dr battle said the staff that continues to pour in pour out um day after day hour after hour um the work um does not go unnoticed and we appreciate it all right we'll move into our second half of our director's report um the school safety report all right thank you um again chair player and board members so I wanted to take some time to go over the contract this before you tonight um for the concealed weapons detection systems as well as a general overview of our school safety
071initiatives that have been layered in over decades and in particular the last few years to protect students and staff um so I I'll go ahead and tell you that a lot of the information we're going to cover tonight is based on the questions and feedback um that I've received from from each one of you um in the past few weeks um about our efforts to address school safety and a multi-layered uh multifaceted approach so um thank you for your questions thank you for pushing on um The Clarity around where we are and um how we're planning to move forward so over the past several years um national public schools has made significant investments in security enhancements to ensure a saf environment for students and staff this slide outlines some of the key measures we have
072implemented controlled access to schools um regarding security vestibules have been added at Main entrances to provide an additional layer of security before visitors can access the building AI phones are also called AV intercom locks and Main entrances allow staff to verify and approve entry before granting access badge access as at exterior doors ensures that only authorized Personnel can enter specific areas of our building for our classroom and campus security classroom doors with locking capabilities provide teachers and students with added protection in the event of an emergency Shadow resistant film has been installed on Windows and entry points to make it more difficult to gain unauthorized access our sec security cameras and brandish weapons detection allow for real-time monitoring of Campus activity with AI assisted detection to alert staff and law enforcement if a weapon is
073visible on camera just to be clear this refers to brandished or visible weapon detection included in our security camera Network what we are proposing today will be the purchase and installation of concealed weapon detection equipment which represents another layer in our multi um layered approach here in the district other proactive safety measures um we have K9 units um capable of um weapon detection for searches that help deter and detect potential threats we have safety ambassadors for elementary schools that are assigned to support a safe environment and reinforce security protocols we have an audio enhancement with emergency alerts that assures that safety announcements and emergency notifications are clearly heard throughout campuses and our law uh law enforcement partnership um in the last few years M&D has expanded their pool of sro's providing greater cover across middle
074and high schools while expanding into elementary schools we also maintain a partnership with the mmpd for Community police officers to be stationed outside of schools which do not yet have an Sr SRO we have mmpd response teams that ensure a Swift and coordinated law enforcement response when needed these enhancements reflect our ongoing commitment to school safety while we have already taken many steps to improve security we continue to evaluate and invest in additional measures to protect our students and and staff this did not start today or yesterday we've been at hard at work at this for quite some time so by now I'm sure you some you're somewhat familiar with the new evolved systems based on their rollout um at our high school and our presentation at the board meeting as a reminder the way
075they work is for individuals to walk through the metal detectors which incorporate AI technology to not only detect metal but also the size density and shape um of objects to look for specific areas of concern that are then displayed on a monitor which is operated by a staff member if an alert goes off the student or individual going through the detector will then go for a secondary screening where a staff member will look at the area that was identified to determine if the object is dangerous or not these are two options a single Lane entry system and a dual Lane entry system which system is used will be based on the layout and flow of students or visitors into the building additionally in order to speed up the process we have tables laid out beside
076each lane where you can take out items that commonly activate an alerts such as a computer iPad binders umbrellas or glass cases to further enhance the speed of entry and arrival so while the underly technology of these weapons detection systems are from evolved the units we are procuring are from Motorola which include enhancements to the cameras and connections to our Vigilant camera control centers so alerts can be sent to those stations as well as tablet set up near the detection systems I also know there have been questions about the Federal Trade Commission and involved our understanding is that this involved some marketing materials and claims made by the company in the past regarding the systems but are not currently in use the outcome of that investigation was a settlement in which schools had the option
077to terminate their contracts early which is which to our knowledge actually did not happen to be clear we know this isn't a perfect solution excuse me to be clear we know this isn't a perfect solution to every challenge we face when it comes to keeping our schools safe it is once again meant to be a part of a multi-layered approach to safety so tonight before the board um will be a contract Amendment which we've already discussed um based upon the approval of the agenda um to our existing security contract with systems Integrations that will allow us to move forward with procuring concealed weapons detection systems for our high schools we will be leveraging an existing contract that includes the option for this equipment along with our security camera Network support and the Omni alert brandished
078weapons program the initial procurement was bid out on April 15th 2024 and the vendor was selected after a competitive procurement process with a board approved contract on January 25th 2024 the proposed amendment envisions in equipment installation and training for all of our high schools but could be later amended to include other school levels based on the expansion of this pilot to all high schools I also know there are some questions about there or have been some questions about the differences between a traditional metal detector which we have used at our athletic or School sponsored events and the weapons detection systems we're proposing for entry and arrival at our Schools traditional metal detectors work by detecting any type of metal meaning that every metallic item whether it's a belt buckle keys or a laptop laptop triggers
079an alert this results in a high secondary screening rate often over 50% requiring students and staff to remove personal belongings and have their bag searched the process is labor intensive slows down entry and requires a significant number of staff to manage concealed weapons detection systems on the other hand also detect metal but use artificial intelligence to differentiate between everyday items and those with those with a weapon signature this technology reduces unnecessary alerts keeping the secondary screening rate under 10% which means fewer interruptions and faster entry instead of requiring everyone to remove metal objects it uses targeted screening allowing most students and staff to move quickly through without delay it also requires fewer staff to operate effectively while maintaining a high level of security ultimately our goal is to implement A system that enhances school safety
080without creating unnecessary delays or disruptions to the school day by using a weapons detection system we can streamline the arrival process while ensuring a secure learning environment for all students and staff so as we look at expanding the weapons detection system pilot we need to determine the appropriate number of screening lanes for each High School to do that we're considering several key factors first we need to assess the size of the student body the efficiency of the system depends on how many students can be screened per minute ensuring that we can move students through quickly without creating a bottleneck at entry points next we must consider the space and layout of Campus entry points different different schools have unique setups and with some having designated entry point points for buses student drivers and staff we
081need to analyze how these areas function and ensure there's enough space for screening Lanes tables for laptop removal and retrieval in areas for secondary screening Staffing analysis is also critical we need to determine how many staff members are available to oversee the screening process while still maintaining coverage at other key areas of the school the goal is to balance security measures with the smooth operation of a school day and finally Transportation considerations play a role we may need to stagger bus and loading time so we don't have too many students entering at once which could overwhelm the system at the same time we want to ensure that bus schedules remain on track so that students arrive and depart efficiently by carefully evaluating these factors we can Implement a scalable and effective screening process C that
082enhances safety while minimizing disruption to the school day so as we're thinking about the implementation plan as we move forward um with the implementation plan if approved um with the amendment tonight for weapons detection systems we have structured a plan to ensure a smooth roll out across our schools first we begin with identifying the funding source requisition and purchase order processing to secure necessary equipment as that happens we will conduct a conduct School visits to finalize the unit requirements and the design flow of each campus entry points looking at the school's operations and taking lessons we've already learned from the pilot we will also hold introductory sessions for principles to familiarize them with the technology and its impact on school operations next we'll move into the deployment phase starting with the arrival of the initial
083equipment shipments the roll out will be gradual with approximately two schools per week receiving the new systems to ensure proper installation and troubleshooting before the system go goes live we will provide School specific Communications to families so they understand the process and expectations to ensure successful implementation training sessions for assistant principales Deans and campus support staff will take place about two weeks before school's deployment this will allow leadership teams to be well prepared and finally training for remaining school-based staff will ensure that all Personnel are equipped to support the transition and maintain a safe and efficient screening process We Believe by following this step-by-step approach we can effectively integrate these systems into our schools while minimizing disruptions and ensuring a safe environment for all students and staff if this expanded pilot is approved we will
084continue to evaluate the success of these systems for consideration at other tier levels meaning middle and elementary schools subject to additional funding availability as we're talking about Investments and security systems I also must look at the systems and structures we have in place to support our students in other ways while the budget is still being develop here are some aspiration ideas we've had in the past that could also um really complement this comprehensive approach in the past we've talked about College and Career viruses by investing in College and Career viruses we can free up time and space for our school counselors to focus more intently on traditional social emotional health counseling for our students we could expand mental health supports whether staff or Services ensuring any student has their mental health needs being met by
085trained professionals is Paramount to not only stop a tragedy but to keep our students on track for success in life Student Success centers we know that exclusionary discipline can be necessary for a safe and welld disciplined school we also know that out of school suspension may not serve the purpose of correcting and restoring student Behavior we've talked in the past about Student Success centers as a way of supporting students during their time out of school to keep them on track while receiving intensive supports they this Success Center also includes family component um because we know that um supporting the entire family can prove to be successful um as well um so with that I will conclude um my update around our school safety um initiatives and chair I will turn it back over to you
086um for any questions or feedback thank you for that report I will open it up for questions and comments um anybody have a question or a comment uh Schoolboard member Tran um I had two questions so first off the the um weapon detection system do we know like the accuracy percentage of the AI that be used to detect the weapon signature so let me introduce a few folks who might um let me introduce a few folks who might um address some of the conversations Chief um Sullivan who is here she's our chief um of operations we also have um eio Ken Stark um who is here and we also have Gio who is um joining us um from evolve I could answer the question but I think y'all would do a much better job in
087responding that's um I appreciate that Dr battle and what a great question it's a really in-depth question and and I appreciate it and I'm I'm going to ask our company representative just to give um the the most um appropriate answer for you sure it's great to see all of you again that's a great question again my name is jillam man I'm vice president of Education over at evolved technology um to your point it's not a perfect science right and that is one of the most important Parts about our technology is that because it's using the AI it's actually learning not from those individual systems but from our entire fleet of over 6,000 systems across the world um and that is the people who are actually using this system every day The Operators are what we
088do we call it tagging different items to actually teach the system so it's getting more and more accurate part of what the district would be getting with this contract is actually um quarterly if not more often software updates or the system is actually learning from itself and from the data I don't have a perfect number for you because there's different environments and different settings what I can tell you is that I was uh I asked Mr Stark it's okay to share that at the high school you're seeing numbers that are less than 10% typically on a daily basis of students who are getting stopped and looking for weapons I'm unsure if you've shared how many weapons have been found but if that number helps you that that means somewhere close to 90% of students are
089walking through the system without interruption and getting their butts and seats for instruction which like Dr battle said we're always trying to balance the need for the environment and the positive nurturing environment and then also the Safety and Security element so your mic sorry um can I ask a clarification question about that okay so um kind of like building on that question um because it's like a machine based learning model I think that's what it's called um are these models like different at different schools so then if like one school has more weapons detected then would that school have like a better I guess a better um like accuracy or like would it be better at to tect so what you heard me describe were the um types of equipment that's available so a single
090Lane fewer folks double lane more folks that's what you heard me um describing but generally speaking they're very similar systems our determination is just about the roll out right so how many do we need based upon the enrollment size of the school schol the design um of the layout so you'll see consistency in the equipment um how many systems that are needed which are the same would depend on the student in school population um anything else y want to add to that just no okay that's great um my second question was I think about the two per week or the two um like implementing them to to like is it would it be at just one school or is it like one at one school and one at another so it means the system at
091one school regardless how many systems we need and the systems at another school regardless of the number that we need thank you yes School member uh L um I would like to know a little bit more about how the pilot at anoch went um I know that you stated that weapons are detected or students are stopped um about 10% of the time um but if you could ask tell me more about how it went at Antioch with the large population of students um that'd be amazing yeah and I like the team um to chime me in um I have had the pleasure of observing it on a number um of days so a few things that um we were observing for um one was the ease right um of students coming through the system um
092which um from day one has actually been pretty smooth and seamless the other thing we were looking for was how long did it take um from the first student who came into the last student we came in in the normal Rush of of arrival um I think the first um day it took about 20 minutes I think they're down to 10 15 minutes um at this point because they've been able to um just kind of learn and tweak things um along the way um we've been following the number of students and visitors scan throughout the day we've been following the alert rate so I just want to be clear the alert rate just means that it required a secondary screening it does not mean that there was anything found or located we've actually not experience
093um that in the pilot um at any I could just something triggered we needed to do extra search and check the first week the first couple days it was eyeglass cases um and so we learned that right off the bat which is why I added it in my talking points today we know that's something that um we'll will pick up and so those are some of the the common things on the ground it was just more so like conversations with students and staff members um about the ease about their perceptions of the weapons detection um system which were all um pretty positive um much easier than I thought I've seen this before um this is like pretty common um for us um as well um and if I'm forgetting any other data points or information
094more or G please feel free to chime me in has we have seen um I mean I think we were even down to 7% um today or yesterday if I remember of folks being pulled up pulled aside just for a secondary search but by and large I've just watch students just walk through and um and staff members as well and let me clarify you actually we're not shooting for that number to be zero right the goal is not for that number to be zero that like we do want to know if there are things that we need to be paying attention to or looking at um as as students or staff or visitors are coming in so I I just sometimes when you do these percentages and numbers it's kind of absolutes but the goal
095is not necessarily get to zero it's to minimize it to the best of our ability um to increase um the the the the level of security we have but also not to disrupt um the school environment and then lastly I just want to add um as a comment kind of as a school Community uh especially in high schools there's a lot that we don't know about the evolved system um a lot of things that came in the conversation are yeah like the thing that is putting a lot of people at ease is that this is in the bridge Cent Arena this is in the Nissan stadium so there are things that we have seen before and then as you all have mentioned that there are ways to make this less invasive to make them look
096better to make them look a lot less scary for students um but absolutely all things could should be considered delay fin feasibility um but nothing is worth more than the safety of our students um so let's keep adding these layers of protection and keep looking looking into it um and yeah that's all I got thank you thank you we'll have board member Fe and then board member Elrod thank you so mine is more so on the expand of the mental health supports I'm sure as we Roll Out programs to support that addition we'll learn more um Can anyone speak on what we're thinking um in of those mental health Advocates yes so um you might recall uh particularly as we were responding to and coming out of the pandemic this was a priority um for
097the school board and it's reflected in the Investments that have been made over the few years so we have um abundantly increase mental health supports um across the district um what we would be focused on now is reducing kind of the ratio right um for the mental health providers um but also ensuring a consistent of supports across every school and so if you compare the mental health supports that were in place today versus pre pandemic I mean you will see a significant Improvement but we still have work that we can do so I it's just about part of our continuous Improvement know where you are uh but don't stay there um we know where we are today but we're also looking for how can we expand and reach um each more students to to provide
098what they need do we have outside resources or are they all inhouse like do we have a party service that we partner with it's our resources but um we do partner um with um key um leaders and the mental health support because we want to make sure that they're trained licensed individuals um who can actually do the the critical work um and connecting with our students and and getting them what they need so we do we definitely contract in this space um to make sure that we have the expanded availability across our schools thank you oh thank you Dr V board member Elrod and then board member Tyler I mean yeah thank you so much um so first I want to say thank you to Dr battle and her team a lot of my questions
099or concerns as I have had many um have been answered here and so I appreciate that um I want to just make sure that I understand some of it or just to confirm some information and I might have some additional questions as I go through what I have kind of prepared um I appreciate the original discussion about all the enhancements that we have is we have a multi-layered approach for security which is incredibly important as we know there's not one thing that will completely do protection for any school or any location um so I appreciate that uh historically I have not been a fan of us discussing hardening our schools by doing metal detectors um so I appreciate also this slide that discusses the differences between metal detectors and what I'm calling metal detector lights
100um which is this weapon detection system so I appreciate the differences between those two I'm grateful to know that there are less pings going off because of it and that there's a low secondary screening rate as I was concerned that it would highlight students um and possibly um highlight schools as well in a negative light um metal detectors in general a concern that I have had is that it's more punitive and that it has a changed to a school's appearance and their perception and their climate I understand that this will not have as much of that because particularly it's something that's already inside of our city um as mentioned by Hannah our Junior board member um so I'm hoping that we'll have some more Effectiveness as well additionally because it's with the Evolve I'm hoping
101that we will have some integration within our city um as I know that their programming is used and their systems are used by mmpd and um our parks department I want to take a quick second to um thank mmpd for the additional sro's I appreciate that being mentioned here this is our first year having um SRO at every middle school that has been really difficult for us as a school system um to be able to obtain because police officers are so hard to um obtain and then when they have someone that comes through the programming they need those people out on the streets um and so we usually don't get those first Cadets and so I appreciate that they've prioritized Us in my district that is a huge request is a R more so than
102this type of product um but there's always concerns about safety because our students are very important to us whether they're our children like my own children that attend MP mmps my past students from when I was a teacher or of course all of my constituents a question that I might have for us is as we continue to implement this I appreciate that it says that we're going to do it kind of in a slow process where it's no more than two schools so we can manage it when do we think all of those schools will be done I understand that there's probably going to be issues with getting the materials there's probably going to be issues with of course us taking our time are we aiming to try to get it all done by the
103end of this school year or are we hoping that it will take a calendar year what are we planning on for that roll out no so I mean it's all really to be determined based upon the procurement process well we definitely couldn't we couldn't get ahead of the amendment process um as well so um if approved tonight that's going to give us opportunity to work closely with sister integration um about how quickly um we could obtain the equipment how quickly they can be shipped in um and then really putting dates to our training um plan for for our staff so um to be determined but of course um you know if approved we will want to move um efficiently but effectively right because there's no um measure that you can Implement that is going to
104yield what you are anticipating if you do it halfhazard and so we want to make sure they really deliberate um in that process as well as there's no one security measure that will solve for every um challenge that that is out there and so we've got a at the beginning of this um presentation I listed out a ton of security measures we have in place now I'm I'm going to be transparent that there you create tension between some of those because you have to be clear about what you're trying to solve for and so we've been adding security measures over the years being responsive um and now we've got to figure out how to to work around some of those secur security measures that solve for one thing that may not solve for this thing
105and so we need to be very deliberate and intentional about that so we'll move swiftly but we also want to be um very we want to we want to move with high integrity around the implementation of the equipment which I appreciate um one of my concerns that I know I've voiced in the last board meeting was what was that roll out going to look like and making sure students didn't feel like it was being done to them or certain populations within our schools were not felt like they were being targeted by the implementation of the program um within that I I think your answer leads me to my next question which was the security vestibules my understanding of how it's currently looking as students come through those security veses vestibules pardon me and then they
106are going through the detection weapons detection system um are they able to stay within that vestibule or do we have students that are standing outside in inclement weather and if so is that something that we'll need to consider through future Capital budgets so again it go it depends on the size of the school and the layout of the school every school has a security vesu in some form or fashion um so that's part of what we've got to go and study now because we've now put Security vules in all of our schools now we've got to consider how that you then Implement a weapons detection system that allows for students to get in the building not to be out in conditions for the extra overcrowding not to happen outside the building but ultimately to keep
107everybody safe and so that's one of the key next steps for our team is to um be on the ground with our school leaders our school teams to do that assessment and come to agreement around how you create this seamless pathway um into the school y I know we prioritized funding all those vules over the past couple of years just getting them all done I think last year actually that is correct um and so it have some fun designs out there there are some we made it work guys um and so but it is a really important part of our security features and I think it will be a key part to how we have this roll out and so I want to make sure that that's being used and um sometimes we have to
108resp spend money but in under consideration um with this request of funding and um chair if this is a question that needs to be asked during the agenda portion please let me you can tell me that and I will Reas that question at that time I know that there's a course a cost amongst for this product um and we have a lot of additional cost coming up this year because our Esser Bridge um and us having to fund that I believe that this is a good fund a good use of our dollars to Hannah's Point as well my concern is of course what we will have to take away from our plate to make space for this that is not to say that we don't do it it is a say of for us as
109a board I think it's going to be important as we get closer to the budget season though I like to argue that budget season is all the time year round but as we get closer to those conversations with Council I want us as a board to be able just to say yes and we need this and I know that this is a new way of us spending our dollars it is a new request but we also have our other very important we as we just discussed through our nap results we have all the other things that we're needing to continue through our Esser Bridge particularly this year um because we do not have the ability to use our fund balance on that so I want us to be able to balance both being able to
110ask for this if it's an important thing to us as a board and we make that decision but also that we're able to balance the everyday day-to-day um classroom assessment and classroom environment and materials that we need the biggest request or concern that I've had from parents is they've wanted to know where students are going to be when they're going through this process and so I appreciate the vestibule thing and that it's going to be tailored the other biggest request has been that they get advanced notice so they can plan accordingly particularly if they have a tendency to Be Tardy of course it has brought up of course school start time conversation and I know that that will be something that we continue to discuss as it is something already currently discuss I promise and
111this will be considered I appreciate that it's down to less than 10 minutes right now I know through the testing that we saw that it was up to like 30 minutes in some schools so again I appreciate all the answers I appreciate you and your team as I know I've been asking a lot more questions than usual in response to this and so I appreciate that help and um I believe that's gotten all through all of them thank you board member t board member Tyler then board member Young okay um so when we're looking at scaling the pilot um one of the things that you talked about was the Staffing analysis so will this require us to hire more people so it could eventually um so what we need to do first um like we
112did um at Antioch um we studied the Staffing um um uh makeup of the school determining like roles and responsibilities what does it take per machine I will say day one we probably had double the number of folks um there than we needed we've now learned that we can back that off quite um quite a bit and so it will take a school by school analysis because let's remember we are a student-based budgeting District so school teams are empowered with making the Staffing decisions outside of meeting the classroom requirements um in class SI and so it will take us being very intentional um and looking at um who's on deck and where there might be some gaps that we will need to f but we're going to again individual School we're not taking a one-size
113fits-all approach this will be school by school and making these determinations and I'm kind of to piggy back off of that so what is the extra lift that we're asking of our existing staff to do this um there's the initial training um which we did with pretty good ease in the for the largest staff we have in the district um and then there is probably a 30 minute at most shift and responsibility at the start of the day um most schools are going to be able to manage the normal flow um throughout the day it's the arrival flow where everybody arrives at the same time um for the start of the school day so we've narrowed this down for it's actually less than 30 minutes um but if you include setup and and and any
114prep that's needed it's 30 minutes or less um of a focus time for um staff members um to train training outside of that to um scan everyone in okay um I just want to make sure that we're not choosing teachers who might have a planning period during that first period to run this I don't want them to lose what they need to do before the start of the school day all of this happens before the start of the school day and it's highly unlikely um so because we we're fortunate that we have some dedicated roles um that are focused around Safety and Security already in our building so for example campus support employees we have safety ambassadors in our elementary schools we have deans of students that are all about the culture and the environment
115so um you know many of our schools are already equipped with with those leaders who is kind of part of their roles and responsibilities already um and we'll look to retrain and kind of equip them and Empower them um to lead in a more Innovative way um as we look to scale the weapons detection system and forgive me if you already addressed this but I don't remember hearing it so is this going to be on all day long for visitors and students arriving late that's correct and so how will necessary staff be needed because obviously you're going to need more during the initial influx but once that backs off um what's that going to look like for our existing we got pretty perfected um system right now in one of our schools um of what's
116required again as you think about Staffing Mo models um that are in place already you already have individuals who are actually Manning these spaces right we're just now equipping them with resources in order to do it more efficieny efficiently either through the front lobby kind of vesu area or the main office um this is the kind of the routine that um those leaders were already in now they just have a more advanced technology way um to to do an extra screening and to get um individuals into the building I will tell you every day I went I walked through um the weapons detection system as well um right because it's going to require kind of all hands on deck making sure that we're all um kind of modeling and St true to the security enhancement
117that we're looking to implement okay um looking at the transportation considerations so knowing that we're going to have to maybe stagger the unloading of buses is that going to change pickup times or will buses just hold students at the school yep so what typically happens this is actually a recommendation that came from our principls so U one of the things that happens is um when students um arrive most times they're arrive and particularly in our high school tier because they're first um they typically arrive a few minutes before they can actually unload um from from the bus anyway and so all we're doing right now is studying if there is a systematic way to say well don't don't unload in this case we have 27 buses don't unload 27 buses at the same time let's
118unload the first six then those buses go then unload the next six let those buses Go I mean we've this is actually helping us enhance a lot of our normal operation flow um anyway um and so that's something that um principles recommended we kind of study and look at um it did not require a later pickup or earlier pickup it just meant we were managing from the point in time that the bus arrived at the school okay all right great um that kind of follows my next question of have we noticed that this is impacting when students get to class um it has not um again we are testing this this is a beautiful thing for us we're testing this right now in our largest um School period regardless of tier um and the first
119day we were maybe 5 minutes before we got the last student in now we are well before the bail and students have come in um and transition into the school picked up breakfast went to their locker and in class um on time that's a goal that we set um for the team and and the the other thing that we can consider here is as we think about single Lanes double Lanes how many lanes you really want to narrow the entry points within the school if we see that then we'll adjust right that might mean we need an extra Lane to um create a faster more efficient processing into the school but we've not experienced that um at um Antioch okay and um are you also thinking of Staggering maybe student drivers and buses or is
120that not been an issue and I guess that's a school by school and so this is part of the normal operations particularly in high schools anyway so we haven't noticed a need to shift this most high schools have two two arrival points right that are managed and supervised usually for buses because we got to keep bus lanes clear and then one for drivers and for car riders and so that's kind of helped us also manage um the flow in fact um in this particular Ser scenario but uh car riders and drivers were actually able to shut that lane down much sooner than we are because we have so many buses that um students ride and so that's going to vary depending on um the school but it's something that we um anticipated before the first
121day um and have continued to reduce the amount of time on that side they get students in in less than 10 minutes um so they're usually all processed and now we're only using one lane for the entry point okay okay great um I think I had a couple other questions but other people have kind of hit on them or you did a pretty good job answering them in the presentation itself so I appreciate how detailed you have been um going over the differences between the different things and also addressing the concerns people had had so if I think of anything else I'll let you know but I think you got me okay thank board member young thank you madam chair um I have a lot of questions so bear with me but let's go back
122if we could to the RFP um where I guess this was more encompassing than just a weapons detection system since this isn't something we currently have that RF P what exactly was it for because I know there were just uh two vendors that responded and I feel like there's probably several other options out there so I want to learn more about that RFP and how this particular vendor was selected with this technology yes um thank you for the question um and just to recap um the the result of the competitive bid process which was at RFP um was released back in April 15th 20124 was approved um in June we did have two vendors um who responded but I'm going to kick it to Chief sell to talk about um just because I'm not a
123part of the process which is proper and accurate I'm going to let um Chief Civ her team respond um to the details of that to that RFP yeah thank you it was an RFP for um that started um our uh vigilon Services uh that we're using it for but it also was broad it was a it was a broad um Services contract that allowed for us to expand our entire security ecosystem of products so as we were moving into the AI um based products for security we kept our request open enough that we could look at everything that might be out there in the atmosphere so to speak so that we could continue to learn about different products continue to expand our services and to refine what we are doing to provide safety in our
124in our buildings so it was a broad-based Services contract um that allowed us to pick from a suite of options and the I know there were I think U maybe Wilson County was mentioned as another school system that had this was it this same brand or is it just this technology in general if I'm not mistaken it was the same exact system we sent um a team from our school district um from the school as well to go out and observe and ask questions um and to learn they're using just a pilot program right now where they're rotating um the system throughout um um their high schools um currently um so they started kind of in a pilot as well but we went out and asked questions and and took some notes and picked their
125brains around Lessons Learned to help us it really paid off I think by day one we were pretty efficient because we had learned so much from them as well as um from um the team um on the ground the great thing about that was and just tag on to that real quick is um that some of the Antioch staff were able to join as well and they were able to see and talk to the principal and this and the um it was Mount Juliet I um the Mount Juliet staff as well so it was um it was we learned so much in just a quick um 30 minute trip so and so the cost of I think the contract document shows 1.25 million per year is this to lease the equipment every year that's correct
126okay and that's just on the equipment expense that's not factoring in any sort of additional ancillary cost whether it be Staffing or tables or chairs that's correct um thank you for that clarifying question is for equipment only it is a recurring cost and that is that amount right now is only for high schools so um if we move forward with middle and elementary in any form shape form or capacity um we would need to expand upon that but it does not include um the resources it does not include um Staffing um to date so when it comes to Staffing now that we've sort of perfected it so to speak at Antioch how many staff members are having to operate that in the morning and then what does that look like during the the day after
127the morning then day so we have it at um about four per Lane um who are are personing the uh um each lane and four to five kind of depending on how you set it up but um and then as you um as you close a lane so like if we have two lanes working as you close that lane then those staff members are able to go and do other duties as as they do and close that lane again being able to go to other duties and um as it's working at Antioch then you know they go to other duties as they would normally perform in the school before school starts and then during the day we have um we have one person who is um at that post and uh reviewing folks as they
128come through and then um but that can also as we move forward with us and we have our own equipment we'll be able to move that equipment into the security vestibule and into the office area and then it'll just be a part of your regular entrance into the school so are these are these teachers are these other class or non-certificated staff that are doing this who are they and like because I think some of the some of the concern from staff might be of the many hats they have to wear is this another one that they get to now I mean rightly so I think you know you get questions all the time about why not when this how that and what is often left out of the conversation is the demand and the responsibility
129and the Staffing and the like all the things that are required um to imp imp something like this right now um what we have learned so every school kind of already has an arrival plan and post of Duty if you will um and so um this again is just equipping those individuals in in some way with resources on their post of Duty um it is mainly um covered right now the pilot uh campus support Deans and I think there's one AP who's kind of over operations who's kind of helping support everybody and train um everyone there but that that's the extent um of the Manpower um that's needed listen I I agree I've heard this kind of sentiment um in a few comments um we we we need to protect our teachers and we need
130to protect our teachers right so um what we don't want to do is to dip into their planning time or their instructional learning time so as we're designing this the reason we're trying to be deliberate is that we don't interrupt all those important components that still need to be a part um of our instructional day but right now we've seen and again it'll take a staff by staff analysis we're seeing um um campus support we're seeing um Deans um which is a part of their responsibility as well and then if the school has an administrator who's who takes on operations like this school does then um you would have leadership in that capacity could also be safety ambassadors um it all could also be classroom Associates I mean there a number of roles that we
131could train for depending on the need and demand of the school sure um and so in the pilot at Antioch have have have we actually and I'm not saying this to be funny but have we actually taken an actual weapon through it to see how it was detected do that not that I'm for taking a weapon into SCH but we that was a part of the training part of your practice and it's actually part of the the training that is encouraged by the company and our company Representatives it's part of their training program that they take us through um and um we have done that with uh with our police officers present Etc so um we have done that and it it always hits excellent and so with this being not just a metal detecting
132system um now with the Advent of say 3D printers there are weapons that are made from things other than metal can this pick up things weapons that are not metal I want to be careful how we talk about all of your safety planning I don't want to uh poke holes in your safety plan and tell the bad guys what to do but to your point this is going to look for metal and so metal and the other uh components um and we could probably talk through that maybe at a Clos session more about security but that yes sir I thought it was important to mention that this is more encompassing than a metal detector absolutely um which I think with the Advent of 3D printers is unfortunately necessary um and so I guess suppose tonight
133we approve this contract Amendment what does that rollout timeline look like like when when first units to begin arrive tomorrow we start the process um based upon having an approved Amendment um that allows us to begin to work with system Integrations to work with evolve um on all the procurement process um I'm I'm confident that there's um um enough awareness that we're ready to start moving um on um this scale across um our our schools and so we will work as swiftly and again as deliberately as we can to start training um we've already um had conversations with our school leaders um about it and we had to hold them off a little bit don't do anything yet we can't get ahead of the amendment process um but they know to be prepared for training
134um for observation time um for us to be on the ground um pretty swiftly and immediately doing the analysis so that we can procure the equipment and get them into our school buildings so assuming this passes tonight do you have and I understand this would be possibly a a moving uh deadline but do you have a p in the sky goal of when each High School would have it in place and operational so this will take this will take weeks potentially months to get to every so we often talk about our schools as 12 high schools we actually have 24 I believe it is um and so like we're talking about every High School not just our 12 Zone schools so this is all dependent and you know sometimes the public um doesn't is not
135fully aware that you could write a check tomorrow and still not have everything in and all the training done um in weeks or months and so it will be dependent on what's available um to us um I believe there's a pretty significant availability um at at this point and so we would based upon the availability maximize um that availability and getting it into our schools so it will take weeks and months this is true with any strategy or initiative that kind of covers a entire grade level or every school across um the district our commitment is if approved um this evening that we will begin immediately um on the procurement process the Contracting process getting that all um executed training and implementing inter schools all right well I'll just end with i uh I think
136this is the right step uh if it were up to me and this pin were magic I would wave it and every middle and high school would have this in operation tomorrow but that's not the world we live in so I'm looking forward to this rolling out being perfected on a larger scale at all the high schools and then us uh putting the pencil to it to figure out that cost for Middle schools especially in the future yeah and thank you for highlighting that um so um the high level of expertise and confidence um on the team and taking things to scale this is not our first time taking things to scale if you think about um our SRO um program historically was high school we moved into the middle school space and now we've
137moved into Elementary space um you could almost name any um strategy it it's it's never been everybody all at the same time because at our scale that's hard to do but being very intentional deliberate and having a clear plan um we've been pretty um precise and U moving forward and and finding ways to celbrate the plan when possible thank you School Board member uh nbal Kimmy and then uh School Board member maziz thank you um I had the opportunity to um be at Antioch high school during the roll out of the weapons detection system and watch firsthand um how students uh flow through in and out and also had to go through the weapons detection myself and when we talk about the the accuracy of them identifying things um I even in my own case
138I went off I set off the alarm so I'm part of that whatever percentage that we talked about carrying in uh uh uh Chick-fil-A biscuits for students and staff at the um at the at anoch high school and the biscuits went off because of the shape and the size uh and the density of the containers that I held them in and so even with that felt really confident in the system um as we navigated through that system to to to to see the types of things that they were navigating um my concerns and I and I've expressed them before was about that that um hold up at the beginning as people are walking through and and there was over time a clear flow through um and ease um over the days in which we did
139so so I started out um I attended at the beginning and then couple of days later to kind of see the difference in the flow and um huge difference from day one to day three um in that process so I really appreciate the intentional work that we had and I was also able to see like we said at the beginning there was a lot of people there to help and support by the end of the week it kind of curtailed to the staff who would be working it so to see the flow between both um was um reassuring um that it it helped um my question to you is around funding Dr battle [Music] um let's talk about where we're getting the money as far as um like so where are we as around funding
140and and budget-wise what is something that we need to consider going into the new budgeting season to continue to sustain this current um system I mean you know based upon a lot of questioning um you probably hear me um alluding to this the sense of urgency right and so um part of this is um ultimately not to wait until a new budget cycle so all things are on the table right now so um we are um digging into um the the U Investments that we already have I mean it will require some repurposing as was was alluded to um we're opening to um conversations and Partnerships with our um elected officials um as well um what I will say is I think the history um of the city and this board um is that we
141are able to prioritize the needs um of the district and so we've not taken anything off the table because there's a sense of urgency um to to move um on the project and as we again not getting ahead of the amendment process right um there are some things that could shift and change I mean we're working all in estimates right now anyway and so as we begin to narrow that um down hopefully in the next few days that'll give us more Insight around uh what might be available to us but at this point there's not anything off the table thank you and then um just lost my train of thought never mind I'll pass thank you board member Maz and then board member Taylor thank you chair so um I have all the notes written
142down over here but I'll try to be succinct um so we talked about we talked about a lot of things funding is at the top of my question list and we just sort of talked about that but I want to make sure that we're very clear when we ask for things like this we need to be very clear with our constituents that asking for this doesn't mean that we have a magic pot of money sitting out back that we can go and shake the tree and fund this thing it's going to be very important to understand that to your point Dr battle we will have to look at we're going to maybe reallocate some additional funding if this thing passes so that we can make sure that the the roll out begins as quickly as
143possible but I want to make sure uh I've had a couple of constituents reach out to me to ask me if I would support this and my response was once I get all my questions answered then I'll make my decision and part of that is understanding that you can't always you know you can't always just you have to at some point if if we're outside of the budget cycle there's a possibility of having to rob Peter to pay Paul but uh understanding that the safety of our children is absolutely the number one priority we have to do what we have to do if we are going to make sure that we are protecting them by any means necessary um I have been uh like uh Dr nabal mckenny uh we've both been on the ground
144at Antioch High School witnessing how the students have um adapted to this change and I must say that uh the look on the faces of the students as they walked in the door that first day was a look of comfort uh more than than anything else there was no anxiety it was more of a reassurance to Dr NABA McKenna's Point more of a reassurance that yes we are being cared for and yes we're being protected and I must commend the staff at Antioch high school for how well they've done and as I was standing there as the students started coming in I was amazed at how quickly but efficiently they were able to get students through that vesu it was uh it was phenomenal actually um so I'm very excited for that um and I
145think something that was mentioned earlier that I want to make sure that we are very clear on there was um a comment made earlier about 10% or maybe a uh something and I didn't write it down rate yes I want to make sure that we're very clear that did not indicate that there were weapons found that's correct that just were 10% or less we were down to 7% um this week for a secondary alert but there haven't been no um thank you no threats found um as a result of that that's very important uh that we mention that because I don't want anybody walking away saying oh there was something found there were no threats so let's just just be very clear of that um and the um the ease of Entry was impressive as
146well you know even from that first day when it was a new it was a new system being implemented and the students weren't really that clear on what they needed to do by day three they they knew exactly before they even walked into the school what they needed to remove from their backpacks or not even bring into the building so well and and if I can give a shout out we have a group of student leaders um at the school that created a student video um to share with their peers about what to expect um and how it worked and so we will incorporate that as a part of our training materials um and another opportunity for student leaders across um the district because in no time I don't know that I could have done
147it that quickly in no time um they recorded they organized themselves they coordinated and the video was um in our hands and ready to to push out and so kudos to those student leaders they they have been phenomenal um in helping us um in gathering feedback and reflecting on plans and just things moving forward and I commend them as well those uh uh one young man in particular reached out directly to me and uh he was very very detailed about what he wanted to see happen and this is why I love working with the young people because they're so creative and Innovative and if you give them an opportunity and listen to them they will tell you exactly what they need to be uh protected uh but I want to again commend the entire team
148for um and I was able to witness uh what has been happening at Antioch high school and those are my babies so I'm so excited that they are doing uh amazing things that our young people have stepped up and said this is what we need we need you to protect us and we're listening to them so uh I can't thank you and your team enough for being on the ground and uh providing that extra level that extra layer of support for the uh for the administrators at Antioch High School um I think that I don't think I had any additional questions just wanted to make sure that we were very clear that this is not a situation where we can just say all right here it is we're going to do it because there is
149funding considerations that have to be thought through before this thing can happen so thank you for all of the responses to the many questions that have come up and uh getting us the answers that we needed so I do appreciate that board member Taylor and then board member uh Elrod thank you chair player um Dr battle first I just want to thank you for just all the work that you've done to get us to this point um I think the level of research that you've done even over the years around this topic and this issue and being able to inform us about the pros and cons of each uh part of this decision um I've just been very impressed with that and so I just want to thank you for the work that you're doing
150around this um and I also just want to mention that uh we've had a lot of feedback from the community uh they have definitely uh made their voices heard and uh and so I'm thankful that we have uh taken some of those uh concerns into consideration and um and your level of preparation and being able to answer the question questions tonight uh shows that you've been connected in that way and so thank you for that um so I have two questions um they kind of play off with each other but the first one is um just related to the importance of families uh our students and in their families understanding how serious this is and what happens if a weapon is found and so if you can just kind of talk about just the high
151level uh what happen Happ s when a weapon is found and how uh is that uh treated in our schools yeah I mean you know they're prohibited from um our campuses and from our schools and you know there have been a number of occasions where I personally sent out um districtwide Communications I know our principls have I know our teachers have um as well and so I mean it really is a plea um to our families um to the adults in our students lives to pay attention um it's okay the check backpacks it's okay to know what um is being posted on social media it's okay to know the friends that they're hang it's okay um and we need every adult um in this community I mean you know we can reflect I'm I'm not
152that old but um we we've talked about the village right that's necessary um parent or not um just Community leaders caring for our students caring about um the actions that they display because there are serious consequences um having a weapon um on our campus to this degree um that we're talking about tonight um could lead to right expulsion from our schools and detention um in in our juvenile detention center and so we know that that has lasting impact on our students and you know one bad decision can um really change the trajectory of um our students particularly one that is of this significance uh we have lots of layers of supports in place um we we we do searches we do threat assessments we provide supports we do all the things that um are required
153of us and we're not going to stop it's about continuous Improvement if there are other things that we can layer in we will we don't take anything off the table um but that you know having um a weapon of this nature that we've been talking about here that can cause harm to anyone does have significant um consequences that can lead up to expulsion um from school and again um and arrest okay thank you and my second question is um what efforts are being made to educate the community about these issues and additional measures that the community can take to protect the students and how can we as board members support you in that yeah um this has been an ongoing um conversation we have worked closely with mmpd in particular um we've worked here um
154at the board we've pushed locking up um we and and lock boxes and we've we've reinforced um the message we've talked about while threats are unacceptable um in our world um today um we take those matters um seriously so I think we can continue to amplify you know there there was a day and time where um the superintendent did not have to send out wholesale messages like that to the community but when you see the continued display of these behaviors you have to because it's important for every family every student to understand the message um our student parent handbook has been a significant acceleration in this work it's what has forced us to really lay out what the expectations are from year to year um because we want to be proactive and we want to
155be supportive so that we're not dealing with these types of infractions um in in our school building but it will take partnership um from the board across the entire District into the community mmpd um as well um other elected officials to help us amplify the message and ultimately we all have to continue to advocate for changes in the law that allow for these types of items to be in the hands of children we have to continue to Advocate and we cannot be distracted by what we think can't happen we have to continue to push for the change we know we need to see to protect our children and our Educators in our schools schools should be safe places for children and for educators they should be they deserve to be safe places for everyone and
156so there are a number of things that we can control there are a lot of things we can't and it will take the community it will take our leaders at every level to continue to push for the change we need to see in our community what we often are responding to are all the things from the community that show up in our schools and so without togetherness without a committed effort without a message like we're going to continue to see this exist not just here but across this country and so we are open to those Partnerships we're open to the advocacy um I know that we have advocacy chairing committee right here on the board um we've got to keep pushing for the change we want to see because we don't write the laws this
157board doesn't write the laws and so that help would be in valuable to us really making significant improvements and change in this space well I got your back I'm with you and I appreciate you and uh and know that that's something that I'm committed to working on with you and with the community as a whole thank you board member Taylor um I'm going to go to I misspoke to a member Hera block since he hasn't spoke and then we'll go to our second round of um of speakers um I'm not even sure I want to cover this now that Dr battle just did it so eloquently um but the things that Dr battle just said were the things I wanted to actually address a number of us have been repeatedly to the state legislature over
158many years asking for changes to our gun laws and specifically around safe storage and I just want to read a couple statistics statistics off from the police department's website because I want to emphasize that we need help in this we are going to do the things we need to do we're going to keep layering in what we need to layer in we're going to look at mental health we're going to do all these things and I'm grateful to you Dr battle and your team for this really extensive presentation and to my colleagues for what we're would have been great questions in the last 3 years 3,156 Firearms have been stolen in Nashville of that 2,123 of them 67% have been stolen out of Motor Vehicles those are guns that potentially end up in our schools
159but even more significantly those are guns that are being used in our community to commit acts of violence regularly and so this is an enormous problem and I appreciate everything that the school district and Dr battle and her team and our Educators and everyone is doing to try and help with a problem that we need help with we need leadership at the state level we need leadership at the national level because we cannot change those laws safe storage is a a really basic and easy thing to do and requiring people to report their firearms when they're stolen is not a difficult thing to do and it is a thing that would really help us so that's not a question it's just a bunch of statements um and I appreciate all of this information it has
160been very helpful in something that it feels very hard to want to do Dr battle said it well when she sent this to parents last week to be clear I wish we lived in a world where schools could remain open and free from the fear of gun violence we'll do our part but we all need to do our part thank you thank you board member elad thank you uh if you're interested in safe storage information it's in side of our shed handbook if you do not have a copy of that it's on our website and I appreciate us doing that a few years ago it was something I I pushed really hard for and we were the first school system in the state of Tennessee to include that information and so I'm really proud of
161us for doing that um because it helps of course with intentional but also unintentional deaths of not just students but all members of families um as a gun owner safe storage is incredibly important I come from a long line of gun owners and we all have to do safe storage so yes thank you um my question is really a clarifying uh question um I appreciate the note that we're doing it in more than our 12 Comprehensive High Schools I can't remember the number you gave but I just want to clarify that that number included like our Alternative Learning Centers and magnet schools um but it's mmps schools that's correct our district gr schools um is what we're planning for at this point got it thank you Vice chair Nal Kenny so when I lost track
162um with my questioning Robert board member Taylor and board member block had my back so um uh one of the things that we constantly talk about is what happens in society boils up into our schools um and the idea that this has caused tragedy and death within our school is is I can't even find the words to say this is a community issue and we have got to get on top of the community issue we can do all that we can to increase Safety and Security within our schools but the community has got to come together to help us with this issue students do not get guns inside of schools they're bringing them in and we have got to address that issue as a community safe storage is a first start in making sure that
163we are doing it and whatever other things that we need to do so I am imploring those who are listening those who are in the community we have got to work on this issue around access to guns from our own homes into our communities we have got to work together as a community to address this it is a crisis it is a pandemic in its own words our mnpd has talked about it until they're blew in the face and I don't know how often we have to say this but we have really really really need to work together to ensure that we are addressing this issue um and we will do all that we can but there is always no matter how much we Harden schools there's always a possibility if we're not working together
164between our schools and our community to address this together so I appla you um and invite you to work with us together to address this issue thank you anyone else um I like to close out this discussion um and saying that we this has been less than a month since this has happened um I know there was a call from the community for us to act uh more quickly and with a extreme sense of urgency and our first priority were our children we had a crisis and we dealt with that crisis after we dealt with the crisis we had to stabilize and we stabilized our community and our children and then we wanted to have this discussion um this is only the second meeting out since uh January 22nd so we can have this type
165of discussion we have had this discussion for over an hour almost an hour and 15 minutes we wanted to be a thoughtful sober intelligent um heartfelt discussion we did not want to make decisions out of emotion and we want to make sure that um Dr B and her team had the time and energy to give thoughtful information to us as a board and to the community um and I want us to be mindful of that we take our job seriously we're not just a legisl legislative body we make policy but we do not make laws we often implement the laws or restricted by the laws that we are held to um and so to the community I hope you really sit and take in this debate the questions that were asked the comments that were
166made that they were thought done with thoughtful thoughtfulness and intelligence um with cooperation and with teamwork um and with leadership and understanding that we we understand we will do our part to protect our children we will lead our children we will protect our children but as my colleague says it takes and Dr B said it takes a village what happens in the community will Bubble Up in our schools and so we need the community come out and help we need a community to take an active part and that means work for mmpd I challenge you to become a resource officer I challenge you to be a security officer I challenge you to be a support staff to not sit in the arena and just have conversations without joining us and protecting our kids it takes
167a community it takes a village we will do our part we accept this responsibility when we were elected we are not shying away from it we're taking it full Thro having a full Thro discussions with it but we also have to help with 880,000 students parents community members as I said I'm a unicorn I do not have a child but I check on the children around me every day I work from home I watch the students go on to the buses for elementary and for middle school every morning and every afternoon they know my face but I make sure that the parent that's sitting in front of my driveway who watches her kid get on the bus I watch too just to give an extra set of eyes when the kids are walking on their
168cell phones from the bus to their um to their condos I watch them until they're out my eyesight I don't do it because I they're not my child but they are part of my community and this is what we need from everyone from council members from former Schoolboard members to parents to community members get involved it takes the community to do this we understand the impact we understand the loss of innocent lives and we're trying to prevent it we've had 11 layers of security done before this incident we learned from covenant we learned from Uvaldi we learned from Park Avenue we learned from my generation of cabine this is not something that we didn't think passively by the flight of night by the back of our n ham hand this has been a constant thoughtful
169aspect when we have talked about weapons metal detectors before the conversation came up where they become osete because of the materials that can be happened and what weapons can be bring we want to make sure we were doing be a good Steward of our taxpayers dollars but also being effective and being Innovative into the future so I would like to say to the community we are having this discussion here we're doing it transparently we're having thoughtfully we are taking our time this meeting is not being rushed to make sure we are doing right more importantly by our children than by our staff who work in those schools to protect their children every day and as you'll see the investigation come out we can't do everything and everything we try but we have a limited amount
170of staff this is where we need the community to come in and when you see something say something if you notice something say something because it takes all of us to protect our 880,000 kids so I just want to be mindful to the community that we hear you we are making sure we are responding to you we take it seriously and we are going to continue to take it seriously you see the thoughtfulness the emotion of my colleagues here who are actually making this as parents as Community people and also just as guardians of our school system so I really just want to close our discussion on that thought um that we are hearing every voices I want to thank our student student student Schoolboard members this is why we have student Schoolboard members they're
171asking the questions that Implement them every single day because our two Schoolboard members are one that be affected by it every day we come in here twice a month but they go into their schools over 180 days and we want to make sure their voice is heard they're comfortable with it and that we're bring stability into it that we're not rushing into it we're not pushing something onto our children without being thoughtful in their input and making sure that we're taking care of their emotional health and their physical health is a two-fold aspect and we just can't rush in and Harden our schools and not think it has an impact we want to do it in a timely manner but I just want to sure that this is not just a one-off thing we have
172been doing it so to the community continue to watch our Schoolboard meetings continue to read the minutes continue to do not hear everything you hear on the news we sensationalizing this topic to make more clicks and more videos and they need to get and improv their ratings we have been talking about this time and time and time again this is not the first discussion has have we've had this for years and I'm in my second term and this is the several time we've had a discussion like this so I just want to thank my colleagues for this thoughtful discussion for the questions you ask um and for um bringing your intelligence and also bringing your hearts into discussion to make sure that we protecting our children and our staff so we can provide our first
173part of Education that is our primary and first goal is to be Educators and like Dr battle said every school should be open and free unfortunately times have changed and we have to tighten that Circle and that protection around our children but we will do our best to make sure our schools are safe places for our kids to learn to be creative and to be free and we will try to protect our lives their lives to the best um to our ability and understanding that we take full responsibility to make sure that happens in a thoughtful and serious way way now onto that we will go on to public participation no no we don't we'll now go to direct we're go to public participation we will wait for the list to be uh displayed all
174right we will again with Aaron Perry Aaron per Joyce Perkins I am you pull it down so you don't have to go in toes there you it's better yes okay like I am Joyce Perkins and I live in district 6 and miss Ma is our representative and I know several people on the board so I'm nervous but like I just have to hear some of the things and I appreciate what everybody has done but like I've heard some things that really caught my attention too it is the community to in terms of what is going on and um I have two children they've gone through they they came they were juniors in middle school and then high school here and my son just turned 60 and I'm still 21 and um I graduated t in
1751980 in Psychology I believe and know that everyone in this room is heartbroken with what happened at Antioch High School on January 22nd in like every single shooting in the city and state and Country I'm sure that we all really care and I am here to call for action and I heard that it's going to take time I heard what was said I listen Cath but I'm really calling for metal detectors and I'm also calling for a boot a boycott from parents and children until they are in the schools it's going to take too long to just wait for everything to be approved I get scared that things are going to come from Mexico and China and we'll never get them um I understand that this is more than just metal detectors I know it's
176mental health I know it's drug and alcohol [Music] um I know we have two schools I I wanted to say I I'm aware of okay but just uh the two minutes is really hard to just do it all but like we need we need the action thank you and you also can email your comments too to the board uh if you haven't finish your thought uh Scott Davis hello Dr Scott Davis I have a PhD in educational leadership K12 with the focus of school safety uh one Nashville organization asked me to host a community meeting to talk about school safety I made 20 copies of this for the board so that you can see the recommendations we had one will see something say something for doing some type of reward system for students or parents
177that see online uh statements and things and do screenshots and turn it in much like Crim Stoppers so they can speak immediately and encourage them to see something say something one is clear backpacks and some of the school bus drivers that showed up at our meetings said clear backpacks that can help them be able to keep that weapons out on the front end prevention before they get on the bus uh sro's trying to rotate the few Elementary SRO we have through our uh Elementary Schools sign sign them possibly six spend at least an hour every two days there checking doors being uh presence in the community with the AI technology evolved and all the research I did it said metal detection system it said weapon detection system it didn't specifically say metal detectors there a
178lot of in uh concern in the community that weapon detection system versus metal detector is different it's not a magnetometer it doesn't actually detect metal uh I do not work with evolve but there were some of the questions that came up uh in conjunction of having a comprehensive safety plan multi-layered that would be one thing that would be recommended is if the AI software does detect metals and how that is is done as opposed to metal detectors the other concerns are the speed at which it's implemented also uh attached a number of Articles uh about the uh Ai and some of the things like brought up a great question about the rate of detection okay but also was the sensitivity settings on the on the uh system and one of the recent most recent the
179uh just happened this month February 3rd of 2025 in Baton Rouge one of the systems this the uh staff have actually changed the sensitivity uh detections and a weapon got through so those are the concerns and recommendations like I said I provided 20 copies of this for you to look at thank you for your time thank you and we received the copies John and Vander Bol if only I had Vanderbilt bunny um um I'm Jonathan vandenbberg I am a voter in member Young's District which I think is district one but the numbers get mixed up right so I have a kid at Warner who's another District which is Maybe district one and another kid at head uh so I've got lots of people I love here um I want to just start out with gratitude
180uh every time I interact with the school district drop off in the morning go to a performance at Warner get a newsletter from a principal I'm really impressed and overwhelmed sometimes by the care and the expertise that goes into taking care of my kids every day and this my first board meeting but I'm feeling that same feeling um so a lot of gratitude that being said uh I am opposed to the weapons detector system um I think the costs outweigh the benefits there been a great discussion I'm not going to go through it again um I think in my case the benefit that I don't really account for is I think it significantly reduces the fear that people feel it doesn't do that for me I think the way my brain works it's not really
181reducing danger there's lots of ways that a person who's determined to do harm can get around a weapon detection system um but I asked my own kids what do you think about it and they said yeah that'd be great so um you know it's my opinion I I totally respect the leadership of the board and uh Dr battle so I can live with it I'll be at peace with it if it goes through but I would like to take the opportunity to think about those aspirational items um not to let this $5 million be the end of it like we we dealt with it we solved it um I spent a lot of time trying to figure out what to say today and um came across this concept of uh threat assessment behavioral threat assessment
182I know it was mentioned that there is a threat assessment team I have never heard of it before as a parent in the district um I know maybe it's hard to talk about because you've got individual students with privacy rights I also think it might have a bad reputation because it was requirement imposed on us by the state legislature bless their hearts but I think that is the recognized uh best practice to prevent incidents like this going forward is to develop a threat Assessment program that incorporates the whole community that see something say something but in a structure Ed way thanks so much thank you Leland Evans good afternoon everyone uh Leland Evans district 6 two weeks ago I stood before you all to Advocate on behalf of over 2,500 parents students Community leaders to
183say that we want metal detectors now weapons detection systems across all mmps last week mayor Freddy okono uh made similar statement saying quote our our immediate responsibility is to protect students and staff this investment is necessary step to address the threats we Face chairwoman player you said something very similar as well uh quote as school board we are committed to providing the tools and resources needed to protect our students against another tragic situation like we experienced at aniac high school it sounds like we're all on the same page in our words but you all have the opportunity to take action today today you'll be voting to either protect lives or point fingers you have the opportunity to vote whether you will save students or you will save money before you vote I would love to
184know how many of you have experienced firsthand gun violence because the students at ANC High School have and I have as well in 2012 my brother was shot and I know what it feels like to watch as someone you love bleed I know what it feels like to have to cover his blood wound his gunshot wound I know what it's like to see someone get rushed off in an ambulance and wonder if you'll make it to the hospital and if they will be alive when you get there we need to make the next steps to expand this pilot program to all schools I know and trust that you all will do that and to the point of anyone who's asking about the money you can ask any parent how much are they willing to spend
185to save their children's life and I guarantee you they'll tell you every penny one thing that we're not asking you all to do is come up with the money because that's not your job we're asking you to tell city council that you want want these because the people and the students and the parents are saying they want them so don't worry about that we as the community I hear you uh um chairwoman player it is the community we will show up we will back you all we will go to city council and tell them that we need we need this funding we ask that you vote in favor of expanding the pilot program thank you that's the end of public participation now we will go on and vote on the consent agenda uh may I
186have a motion to approve the consent agenda with um one B8 integration system being removed from that consent agenda motion to approve second motion and approve by chair member maziz and seconded by Vice chair nabal and Kenny all in favor of the consent agenda raise your hand it is unanimous 90 thank you very much now I'll entertain a motion to um consider the contract of system integration is there a motion been motioned by uh been moved by member young is there a second second second by board member Taylor um discussion all right I think we did our discussion during director's report so we'll move on to a vote um uh board members if you please um indulge my um privilege I will call for a role roll call vote please um Dr seir will you
187do a roll call vote Mr Taylor I Mr Taylor votes I miss Elrod hi Miss elod votes I um Mr Young I Mr Young votes I uh Vice chair nalini hi Vice chair votes I uh Miss Fain I Fame votes I uh miss Ma I miss Maz votes I uh Miss O'Hara block I ohhara block votes I and Miss Tyler I miss Tyler votes I and chair player I chair player votes I Madam chair nine I all right the um the contract for system integration passes unanimously 90 um now we'll move on to board report I will hand it over to my colleague chair M to give a brief report on uh the state legislature legislative day with the Tennessee Schoolboard Association thank you chair uh so I just uh attended the uh Tennessee school
188boards Association legislative and legal Institute conference uh that wrapped up today and I wanted to just give a quick report to my colleagues there are uh currently and and before I get into that let me just say for um chair player you mentioned that uh this is a community we need all of our community members this is where you can get on board and start helping to my community we need you as advocates on the hill as of the the deadline for filing bills we have currently over 240 bills that have been filed related to K12 education and we are going to need everyone's help to make sure that we are reviewing and attempting to defeat any negative bills that will any bills that will negatively impact our districts and our our children um there
189were a couple of bills that um well one in particular that I wanted to bring uh attention to to this board of education and let me pull that information very quickly I had it up I do apologize um it is related to um on it I had it right here so it's related to um School Board elections and that's always one that we want to make sure that we are keeping our eye on um basically what happens this is um Senate Bill 342 House Bill 416 as introduced it requires school board members to be elected at the same election beginning in 2028 so basically if this bill passes that um starting in 2028 every single School Board member would have to run for election or reelection at the same time my concern with this and
190this is a bill that tsba vehemently opposes my concern with this is that if that were to occur the possibility of a 100% turnover of a Schoolboard every four years is Absolut every two years excuse me is absolutely something that could occur and you lose knowledge of your school boards and additionally the threat of um having an Administration turnover is it goes up significantly because you don't necessarily with new Schoolboard members who don't know the system who don't understand could potentially create a situation where they are trying to turn over an Administration which could lead to uh a decline in academic success so that's a that's a big one that uh is concerning there are several bills that as I said that tsba is opposing I have a list that I will get out to
191uh all of my colleagues and we are also going to be um getting another metro schools day on the hill date in order for um our uh parent Advocates and our school board board members to join me and talking to legislators about some of these bills and hopefully we can talk them off the ledge because some of these are just ridiculous there are some that uh I think would be potentially halfway decent bills but the ones that that we are looking at right now that uh we might oppose could be detrimental to our school district and I want to make sure that we are keeping our eye on that but I will be sending out additional information to all of our school board members about these particular ular bills and uh what we need to
192do to uh make sure that this try our very best you know with the super majority being GOP the likelihood of us making a dent is small but there is always a chance so I want to make sure that we are continuing to voice our concerns and making sure that uh the folks that are making the decisions know that this is not going to work out well for any of our children and these are Statewide bills so if it impacts Nashville it's going to impact every county in the state of Tennessee so but that's just a quick update on where we are right now so thank you thank you board member oaro block uh thank you we have uh before our next board meeting we will have our semiannual um review of Dr battle's uh
193evaluation and our formative feedback that um we give so I will be sending all of you tomorrow um the report that you can use to then uh enter your feedback into system so that we can uh then summarize and I'd love to be able to have that back um by next Thursday the 20th so I'll put all of that in an email to you'all but please be looking out for it and please get it done because I'm not a fan of harassing you but I certainly will thank you very much thank you um and then one announcement uh we we will not have a board meeting on March 11th due to spring break so March 11th there will not be a board meeting due to spring break um be no further business our meetings adjourn
194this has been a service of the Metro Nashville network if you would like to see this presentation again or for more information on this and other programs visit nashville.gov he